CorpusRecord 56406

Stratham School Board Meeting 01/15/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Blue Hawk Media
Date
2025-01-16
Location
Rockingham County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,805 words · about 122 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right let's call the meeting to order at 6:03 p.m. and can we stand up and do the pledge please I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it one nation under God indivisible Liberty in justice for all great thank you so much um I want to First Take a look at our minutes from January 8th and I think we were all here so we can probably do them together um do you have a motion to approve the minutes of January 8th I'll make a motion to approve all right thanks Sophie do I have a second second thank you um any discussion or changes on those minutes uh all yes well discussion uh in the meetings someone got up and talked about how scoring is

002done uh for uh the uh state state scores and they said that if a student opts out of testing the parents opt the student out for testing that the student then receives a zero which lowers the test scores for the uh for the school I don't believe that's correct okay I think that they get no score and they are not part of the um the mathematics that result in the test scores for the school okay um did did you want to say anything more about that um I'm happy to share um some knowledge that I have on this however um I think the minutes were accurate I do want to say that so what people say is what people say um but if if this is an opportunity to maybe add some additional insight to

003that I'm happy to do that we do that add sort of a um if there's concern we could have that as an agenda item okay for for our next meeting in February okay talk about that and talk about SAS scoring and and um how that is put together so it's an actual presentation and other people could comment on that is there anything we can do in the minutes like no because as Eric said that's what their was that's the true it's and it's not changing fact check okay I'm not I'm not suggesting changing the minutes it was just discussion okay I I personally think it makes sense though to have the administration speak to that because there is I think there's always confusion about this and actually in many cases what's presented can be both

004true and untrue and so it's important to talk about the Nuance there okay I'm going to make a note about adding that thank you any other comments or additions changes on the minutes no all right all in favor I I I any opposed all right five z z um we're GNA do budget um quick after but we were thinking maybe we just do policy quick so that Jennifer do you just want to do non-public minutes too do we get do we cover we did them both together okay perfect thank you yeah because we were both at all we were all at I appreciate that I didn't catch that my apologies um do you want to jump ahead to policy is there is is it going to be a long discussion or no uh it doesn't

005have to be yeah so I think it just relates to the interest that um board members may have in the in the changes the changes all align to RSA and best practices so I think that there are good changes to make we had we suggested it could be a first read at our last meeting so this meeting if folks did have that ability to De a sort of a second review or a first review and would like to pass it I'm I'm open to that I would support passing those uh policies one thing I think that is probably I had mentioned that there there are folks who in the public who have asked how do we um ensure that a student and I'm certain faculty and staff privacy is maintained and how do we think

006about the systems and the platforms that we use um how do we think about third parties more generally speaking and there is really good there's a really good thought process around that there's a lot of discussion around that and we had a lot of input from the it function at the school and what's nice is on that policy committee there's a lot of lawyers and I come from sort of an IT background where I work with compliance so we had a really uh thoughtful conversation about it um I'm satisfied that we're moving in the right direction these policies um speak to that um but I think that there are still areas from a best practice and maturity perspective um that we can still move towards so I think it's a great opportunity to be able

007to continue speaking about this I think it's an important topic and um I guess that's all I have to say about that okay thank hopefully that's helpful did anybody have any questions or comments about those policies nope as a nursing mama I was appreciative of all the consideration no no reason to not pass it Oh you mean so yes specifically around the uh yes I thought we passed I thought we passed the one around the lactation have we not done that one yet no oh no that was this one yeah sorry I thought we spoke to that in the past so my apologies yeah unless you have any reason to not approve them I'm happy to approve them what's funny is I know I made comment about that so I don't know when I did

008make comment like two months ago which was that what I don't believe that we had to do was alter anything from workflows in the building per se that would necessarily impact our alignment to that policy um so I don't know when that happened but I think it was in December that I might have spoken about that sorry great all right do I have a motion to approve the policies motion all right thanks Paul do I have a second I'll second it Eric any more discussion all right all in favor of policies um 61 do I have to list them all out great if you did for the minutes okay um 61.1 ehb data records retention and destruction um ehab data governance and security gbj Personnel records J Student Records to withdraw eb- local records retention

009schedule GB j-r Personnel records all right all in favor please say I I any opposed all right 5 z z um I guess we skipped SMS administrative report anything didn't prepare anything we have nothing nothing okay sounds good and uh yeah I just want to compliment the presentations I know people have been asking me about them um so last week we had both a special ed um presentation and um student data presentation and um I know both of those have been fluttering around the community so thank you for taking those time last week okay um moving ahead to the superintendent report which um we're really glad to have the fact back tonight um so tonight just for everyone 's um information we're going to be hearing from the fact um there's been many questions back

010and forth on email um between Administration and Fa and between the board um and so um a lot of those questions got answered um you know so I don't think we need to repeat that here but I think the board is very interested in the facts um any concerns comments questions um that perhaps haven't been discussed before and any recommendations that the fact would like to make so I can turn it over to you guys sure yeah can I ask a question now y do you want us to start with the uh to the board chair operating budget you want to start with the um Bond the B the bond first I was told that we you want to hear our opinion on the Bond as well yeah I think both of them and it's

011up to you guys it be easier to to the bond okay and when are we doing public comment yeah yeah should we let the fact present and then open public comment whatever you guys what would you like yeah that'd be great okay um so do I have to State my name and everything or probably for the minutes yeah okay um my name is Kathleen peek I am one of the members of the fa um Heidi our chairperson is not here tonight due to illness so she asked me to present the findings of the fact um on the bond for the school improvements the $12 million Bond um all of us voted unanimously to approve that Bond um and we were encouraged by the thoughtfulness of both the um subcommittee the construction subcommittee as well as

012the school board in creating this proposal that's great yeah thank you so much add something sure you you want to add to the okay yeah uh one of our members thought that we should accelerate um the window and we had a long discussion about that as well as putting a generator in now and not later uh but I think I think as we talked it through that that it was clear that there is going to be that's the reason why we're going to be starting to set some money aside and then we'll be replacing the windows As Time Marches On as on a need basis and get that done and and I we also reiterated that how hard the committee worked on on discussing these issues and then we talked about the generator I think

013it came out that correct me if I'm wrong that I think we only lost power really well maybe I look over here once in 10 years maybe is how long my time here we probably lost it once a year once a year okay maybe that's not for significant amounts of time sometimes it's an hour right right so um but anyway because I I went to a lot of these meetings as well the the building meetings and it didn't seem like it was a high priority uh priority thing so anyway just want to let you know there was that discussion around that so yeah I did see a very thoughtful email about that all right great um and funds budget yeah oh trust funds okay yep um so I believe um the board recommended that we

014keep the special education trust fund as it stands was that the recommendation the board hasn't come out that's kind of General conversation but it hasn't come out with a an um we appr um it was an unanimous that we should continue having that amount of money in the special education fund um we agreed that $20,000 should be added to the maintenance fund again this year to continue to build up that trust fund to then work on the windows and possible generator in the future and then I believe um it was stated that it was looking that we needed to add 10,000 to the technology fund for the future changes in wiring and computer systems and we also unanimously approved uh the board's statements on those okay any questions or comments for back all right thank

015you so much thanks for your time okay and then budget budget okay um so we voted 4 to one um on the school budget as it stands with a 2.73 increase um Pat was the one denter um and we wanted to thank the school board because we thought that from our experience um I mean the budget was gone through very thoroughly and priorities were made um and so we really appreciated that and we thought that keeping the budget increase in line with inflation was appropriate for this time um Pat is going to get up here and he would like to read a statement after I'm done um and I would like to make a statement right now while I stand here as a member of the fact um so bear with me while I try

016to be very concise and uh then Pat can speak so um as a parent and a member of the fact I didn't really know what to expect coming into these budget meetings and I really appreciate um the school board's Guidance with going through the budget as well as our Administration team from both the school and the superintendent's office um at our first meeting um pat pat abrami commented that he thought it was really important that we um really look at only hiring new teachers when teachers left um our staff and I did voice my concerns at that meeting saying that I thought it was appropriate that we have multiple levels of experience within the board um and now that we have learned that five staff members are retiring and therefore um those that do get

017hired back to fill those spots will not be at the same level um of longevity as well as track um now PAB brami is stating that we should not hire back as many teachers and therefore increase the classroom sizes and personally for me it feels like um nothing is ever good enough it feels like the budget just keeps getting slashed and just constantly saying that we need to trim it down without taking into consideration uh the effect on the students is unwise to me as a member of the fact um um and I don't think it's prudent to continue to slash budgets unwisely and without reason furthermore um during yesterday's meeting when I stated this to Paul I mean to pad and told him that I was afraid um that if we continue to decrease

018our budget and not fund our school appropriately that we would not attract young families to stratum and that they would look elsewhere to towns like Rye or Northampton where schools are better funded um Pat said it didn't matter they were going to go to Rye anyways and I think because he said uh the test scores are better there and for me this is unfortunate that that's the mentality okay so thank you you're welcome yeah thank you well that was personal should have been but I'll uh I'll respond to it so you guys have a tough job we all have a tough job and I I I try to I care about the kids believe me and I was always cared about my kids what they did when they were here and they they excelled here

019and at the high school although they W up going to St Thomas for re that they wanted to go there not me they I didn't want to send them there but anyway great so it's a tough job but we have to balance things we've got a we got we've got a bond that we're going to we're going to pass it's going to pass I'm quite just from the comments we're hearing from the public I know I know it's a 60% threshold but I my my gut is it's going it's going to pass and I'll I'll be supporting it as well so the the um it's a tough job but we got I'm very concerned about the kids as well but I'm also concerned about some of the public with the bond and then what the

020recent reevaluations of property that really has hurt those who live in smaller homes that have been here a long time and their their properties just went way up and those are the people that we have to also be considerate of when we finalize this budget okay so as you no I've spent more time I think than anybody going through this budget multiple times most of the questions so I so I understand so everybody else would understand what's in that budget what isn't in that budget why is it there and and I by the way Chris thank you and your team for and and well as uh Kate as well early on answering my questions uh that that really helped because the the you need you have to look at details to really see what's what's

021there and what's not there so what I'm going to suggest is um that we amend the budget down anywhere between 102,000 to 112,000 and I think there's a pathway to get there now since I was told don't I wasn't allowed to say where it should come from but since Kathleen brought up uh classes I think well what we found out by the way that 197,000 reduction from the original budget was was really one teacher and then the other three were uh reduced salaries those three were reduced salaries that gave us the 197 okay first off so I did the math to say if if a second teacher was not to be rehired I think there'll be there's there's there's not a full opportunity for a full salary I think it's around 69,000 and about another

02233,000 in in benefits so that that gives you the 102,000 um now I did the and every time I come here I hand stuff out and no one really looks at it so I I didn't do it this time but I I went back to the 20220 boards ratios so kindergarten 13 to 17 to1 uh first second and third grade 15 to 18 to1 and fourth and fifth grade 18 to 22 to1 and then I said okay if we were to reduce those each one of those classes to four would it violate this or not and the only two that were feasible against this policy that was set up five years ago was 4th and fifth grade and the fourth grade at 81 students would be at 20.25 to1 and in the fifth grade at

02379 students would be at 19.75 to1 so you can call it 20 to1 each so if you want my opinion I think we would fall within this isn't I just didn't make it up this is something that prior boards have come up with that it's there's a pathway right there to to have four classes uh for each of those two grades and then you'd have to be nimble as board members going forward because there's a bubble I think we so I think Eric talked about a bubble last week and that's that's the current third grade or the incoming third grade uh would be at 86 so but the grade behind it is at 75 students so there may have to be some shifting of where where staff are so again so the orig now let

024let's talk cuz when we hear hear about comparisons to other Schools elementary schools we hear about all the grades together not prek you take prek out of it kindergarten the 5ifth by the way when I when I looked at all the the various elementary schools it's all over the place some towns have it you know K through three and then you know or K through two and then three to five if they have multiple schools it's all it's all over the place but but the original budget was at U with 483 students at 30 classes that's would be at 16.1 to1 the revised budget that my colleagues approved and I I this isn't like I don't approve that but I want to step back if any Amendment doesn't pass here obviously I would support it

025but 8 483 students uh for uh for the rise budget with 29 classes and not 30 that brings us to 16.6 66 66 to1 and then my proposal here again 483 students with 28 classes that brings us to 17.25 to1 so we're still as a school at 17.25 to1 which is not a bad ratio considering not too long ago we were at 19 to1 20 to1 um by the way with higher test scores so that's my recommendation thank you it was well thought out um and I I'll just stop there okay thank you all yeah thank you and thanks to each of you guys really appreciate that yeah sure I just want to make a real brief comment sure um hi I'm camer or I'm on the financial committee so one of my concerns was

026regarding the bond um I just wanted to make sure that from a PR perspective that we're able to communicate to the public the things that we aren't going to address because one of my main concerns is that if the public approves a12 million Bond and then we come back next year and say you know we're going to manage the windows or the generator or whatever it is with trust funds they're going to say well we approved a 12 million dollar Bond last year you know what I mean so that's one of my main concerns was we said we're not doing the windows as part of this I think you said it was half a million dollars or something like that and I understand it's not within the budget but I don't know if that can

027be mentioned when we you know when it's voted on so that the Public's aware you know what I'm saying can I comment yep can I comment sure oh I think I did say this last time um there is a 15% a 15% contingency in this Bond that's 1.5 million there is $250,000 in there for an owner's rep of which I think that's $150,000 heavy so I talked to the um the construct ction company today just today not 6 hours ago regarding the windows and the uh contingency and the summary of the conversation led me to believe that there is a reasonable chance that we're going to have enough money in the bond to do the windows now maybe not okay you know the Y is for things that are unforeseen right um but as Renovations

028go um this isn't a really large one okay it's a modest one it's a focused one so I don't think it's it's uh it's a stretch to say we may have the money to do the windows okay yeah and I just you know it sounded like there was some agreement from the public about using the trust funds to manage some of those things but you know the discussion we had last night was that the amount that the trust fund is being funded this year is probably lower because of the bond issue and all the other things trying to not throw this all in at once and I think that was mentioned you know that I think I was Chris somebody said you know maybe there's not an appetite for adding a ton of money to

029that but just so that when we do revisit that next year you know we don't hear well you guys we already funded the Improvement now you're I also I also want to uh emphasize the windows are not literally on their last legs we have a couple of we have a couple of Windows that have lost their seal okay and they are 35 years old and anyone who owns a home knows that by the time Windows get to be 35 years old you look to start replacing them because they're going to rot and this and that and the other things so um I know that the previous uh maintenance engineer here Tim uh he would routinely uh replace Hardware on some windows that failed and so on so they're taking more and more maintenance but it's

030not like you know they're catastroph they have catastrophically failed it's just planning for what the inevitable is okay um I do understand your point yeah what's that I do understand your point oh yeah yeah I you know again I just you know trying to be honest with the public about that um and then one other thing I want to bring up that we mentioned was um a recommendation that the board adopt an official policy on the ratio because that was mentioned um and I I don't think that that was an official policy I think it was found in the notes of a previous meeting so you can correct me if that's wrong um but a lot of the decisions you know we sit back and say hey we're not Educators we're not qualified to make

031this call on this right and I think we heard you know we're talking about balance I didn't hear an overwhelming majority you know that had the appetite for reducing the ratio so I think at the very least rather than just hey this is from 2020 and you know there should be an official policy that obviously uses you know the administration and best practices and all that so that when future budgets are done we can look at that and say you know here's an appropriate ratio that was looked at and here's all the you know because right we're just kind of winging it you know what I mean so um and uh I think that was it thank you very much okay thanks Cameron can I speak to that one just on that one point so

032yes that's absolutely true Cameron and I appreciate you advocating for that because I I think I I got a signal from the administration that they would appreciate that as well so I think that that is something that we should do regardless of whatever the budget is that passes or that we pass out of this body uh hopefully this evening um it was a surprise to me when I was told that in 2020 that they had made some recommendations those were just recommendations I think it was probably in writing it was probably in minutes it was probably somewhere else like that um it was interesting that it was during Co that okay the conversation started in the fall of 19 okay they started the conversation in September if you were to look back at the minutes

033they talked about it for and then it got passed in I think January feu not past kind of like they sort of made it their guidelines a public recommendation I think on either January or February of 2020 bu before Co so the the conversation was okay before Co I just don't I think that's important to note January 2020 so okay all right Fair all right that's fair [Music] um I kind of lost my train of thought on where I was going with that there are hard requirements from the Department of Education though just so you know so from the Department of Education I think I have them real quick I'm just gonna I'm going to share it real quick because I don't know that everybody knows or everybody in town might know I think I

034have them I know I have them handy um it's New Hampshire admin code uh 306 .7 which is it's it's equivalent to RSA when it's the admin code and what they have is they have similarly to what's been done the recommendations that were made by the board at that time align in terms of the granularity of grade so the state also says Hey by kindergarten it's this kindergarten grade two grades 3 to five it it should be this middle and senior high should be this so recognize I think the developmental challenges and some of the you know instruction for for children at different ages of development um so I would encourage folks to just look at that but know that there the state requires something and I can even I'm happy to share at least

035on grades three to five because I think that's been kind of the topic of of a lot of conversation here so in three to five they say 30 students or fewer per educator provided that each School shall strive to achieve the class size of 25 students or fewer per educator so I'm not suggesting that that's gospel or that's the best thing for stratum or whatever but I did want to make clear that there are written instructions that we have to abide to and then there are recommendations as well that are within that that three so anyway yeah that was really so and regarding that I mean I understand that's like the absolute minimum guideline right I mean it's the law the law yeah so um because one of the things we were looking at was

036benchmarking against the communities in the Sea Coast right and one of the things that was mentioned was you know a comment from the public about a school system that was significantly smaller than here right and it was like Hey this ratio based on whatever but I think we really need to you know like Cathleen gathered a lot of really good data on SE Co communities and you know there's a lot of talk about the test scores and that thing right I don't to belabor that but that's one of those ones where it makes sense I think to Benchmark against the community and not necessarily you know cherry-pick where we can see stuff throughout the state and say well this is lower whatever because of happen stance or how many people are there so I think

037you know that's a starting point right as far as the I mean not starting point you have to abide by the law but I think it would also be worthwhile to Benchmark that and of course like I mean you'd have to develop the policy to say Administration and who whoever you know you mentioned about best practices for um another policy initiative right and I'm sure there's you know Nea or whoever has best practices for those things that should be looked at also right thank you okay thank respond to that one do you sure okay so one of the things I think that's beneficial of setting the policy I think the policy should probably align not align in numbers but align to the same way that the state makes requirements so we would look at it

038by grade we do those sort of things make recommendations that way so I think it should align somehow to the way that 303 is written um but I think what it does that would be really powerful so first of all it's a policy that has to be reviewed so it's not something that could get lost in in minutes or recommendation or something like that the other piece is I think it would it would describe uh the board's stance the board that passes it stance and then folks could further boards can always amend that change it get rid of it throw it out whatever they want to do right but at least it would kind of set a standard for thinking about this and if it said hey we should review this on an annual basis

039then at least we should align to our own policy to say every year we're going to look at this right so it doesn't come it's not a surprise um that it's a topic of conversation it doesn't come out a left field and we be it creates a Cadence for for looking at that so I think that's one of the important things around creating that policy um the other thing that you mentioned about looking at other to I would say that if you look even at the state data I want to acknowledge this if you look at the state data you're going to see I think because enrollment has declined across the state and I don't think a lot of the school districts have made changes relative to that I don't I I think you're right

040I think you're going to find across the state that there are lower class averages than some of the conversations that have been proposed here and certainly proposed by me so I think I think that's an accurate assessment thank you app and does that make sense to the board what I'm saying about that yeah and why I'm saying okay yeah 30 per educator seems a lot but yeah I understand um Mike yeah thank you um first um hats off I mean this was this was a lot of work and and um you you marshaled through this to make some pretty challenging decisions to get get you to the place that you're at tonight so um hats off to you for the hard work that you put forth It's these aren't easy things um I just I

041kind of go back to the first night I was here um and and I haven't I personally haven't had children go through stratum schools I have I have grandchildren that are beginning and one thing I've grown to learn from my grandchildren is um my 5-year-old granddaughter is really really smart and when I look at my 12-year-old granddaughter who also is brilliant um she's not as she wasn't as smart at 5 years old as my 5-year-old granddaughter is today why is that cuz the world Chang changes right and things evolve and people are exposed to different things and education evolves with that um the the thing that struck me and one of the things I said the first time I was here was I I don't feel qualified to make decisions about how you teach or

042or what that ratio should be if we went to the 30 to1 or 25 to1 that Eric just cited um Pat's budget would be a slam dunk and we could go home and you know just say great job but um it's a much more complex issue than that that and you clearly all know that um and I've listened to this this conversation about um you know the the ratios between St students and teachers and test scores and it's like taste great less feeling and lots of anecdotal information and which clearly changes based on the the um demographics of a community or or the situations that everybody encounters um so kind kind of Wonder I mean I one of the things I had I I had said to all of you before is kind of a

043challenge to really robustly keep this moving into the future because because it means everything to our students and our children and I don't know I don't know if it's possible for there to be a paradigm shift that that really speaks to um the development of an academic standard that and maybe that standard is the top 10% of test scores 90% and above and because when you when you think about life and the way we're all motivated we we um you know we we whether it's our 401k or or personal Investments we we try to build winning strategies and we invest in winning strategies um athletes at their highest level get paid tons of money because people are willing to pay that for athletes at their highest level and why wouldn't we all want to pay

044for our children and students that perform at the highest level and and based on a set of standards that clearly demonstrates that the investment we're making in our schools and our teachers and our students is resulting in this High Caliber result because life is made up of results and taste great less fing doesn't get you there it it it it's there's so much anecdotal back and forth that that we we just don't seem to have come to a place where we've got a clear perspective so um hats off great job thanks for all what everybody does thanks Mike all right I'm going to open up public comment right now um and again as everybody knows I think um we'll we'll set it for 30 minutes see if people have talk what's going to happen at

045that point is then the board is going to talk about our um own feelings about the budget and and vote um on on budget Bond and warrant um but we'll open up public comment for now three minutes does anybody have any yeah please and if you would just say your name and just say it right into the mic just so they can hear I have to bring it down nice and low hi Christina Gainer I teach at stratum Memorial School but I'm also a resident of stratum a little late to the party I came to the meeting last week and I felt compelled to come and speak tonight um so all right right many years ago we had a staff meeting where we asked to think about the important aspects of our job so following

046our discussion there were anchor charts placed around the room and we were asked to um allocate 100 cents to the various anchor charts of things that we felt were important and critical about our jobs the various charts had headings such as foundational skills in Korean more I chose to put 95 cents in relationships that's right 95 cents I firmly believe that having a positive and supportive relationships with students is Paramount to student success I can think of countless students that I've taught over the years that had challenges that made their educational Journey difficult the small class sizes I have enjoyed over the years have allowed me to develop deep connections with all my students teachers want their students to succeed and become the best versions of themselves that they can possibly be I firmly believe

047this is not possible without meaningful relationships between teachers and students I'd like to share some of my experiences with you one student who school year was plagued with low self-esteem anger and the inability to access curriculum when on a vacation to Europe This student knew that I collected heart-shaped rocks this student chose to carry a very large shaped heart rock that he found on his vacation and brought it home to me another student who found School challenging due to fine motor skills created the most beautiful picture of an otter for me at the end of the year they learned to recognize that their skills their artwork was was as beautiful and as worthy of Praise as their classmates one student who felt like they were not understood by others refused to leave school on the

048last day of school until I came to see them and say goodbye imagine my surprise when three fifth grade boys came down to my classroom to hand me hand delivered handmade birthday cards these gestures made by students have had a powerful impact on me the gestures remind me that teaching teing is more than test scores and data teaching is about believing in your students and knowing they can do hard things I will admit I love to collect and look at data but not at the expense of developing relationships with my students thank you I can vouch for that thank you Miss Gater any other public comment don't be scared she said it all right thank you so much okay um we'll keep the public comment going even if it runs out if people want to

049comment after the board discusses I'm happy to open it up again so now I think it's up for the board to discuss our feelings about the budget um and then what happens on March 4th is then the public votes um so let me just open it up to the board I think let's take a look at the um Bond first since we'll we'll go in the same order the fact did so on the bond um any questions or comments about approving as is yeah I had a question why didn't we just have it a straight 12 million like what why is it what a $440,000 short like what's up with a dollar and cents preciseness I'm going to guess it's the cost of the bond right was a fee it came in at 11,960 that's

05040,000 that's what was given to us by Corino Construction for the total cost they anticipated for that project so we were not going to put more because we had what was given to us is a not to exceed that that number I see do we want to leave it at that number or do we want to call it an equal 12 if I were a member of the public that would be confusing to me but I don't have a problem making it 12 well the the current number has like contingencies built in and everything already so we'd be bumping it for what purpose I think I think Sophie is saying just for the purposes of less confusion to be accurate instead of saying to everybody it's $ 11, 960,000 just say 12 million it's semantics

051to a large extent I don't know can you just say 12 million even though it's 11960 and if it's less than that then we don't it's not like we have to spend that money it's just for the purposes of not to exceed that much what whatever's raised and appropriated is what you will bond though so you will be bonding for $12 million and you might not need that extra so Kino's given you a pretty in-depth of analysis of what feel is the guaranteed maximum rate with a 1.5 million contingency in there so I I would make the recommendation to leave it because it's been a thorough investigation by the company that we've hired and spent money to do that that I would not put an arbitrary number in there um because you will have to

052bond that and that goes back on your residents in other words it's another 40,000 at 4% gotcha okay that makes sense yeah as long as we can explain that to the public somewhat succinctly any question no I I did want to say though I I think you know I had asked and I didn't feel like I got a satisfactory answer on it but it's okay I didn't I don't need a satisfactory answer I'd ask like what kind of uh from value engineering like what kind of things do we expect back and I wanted I would have loved like dollars and cents but we we don't have that but that's okay but what I wanted to say is I I like the fact that there are things that we are doing here which would nominally improve

053energy charges over the over the years things like when we do the roof we would do some insulation that may have some dominous value but still some value we'll have the LED lights that will reduce uh some cost on electricity we do have the subsidies that they did mention when they were here and I appreciated that though I think we'll have to find out if we can take advantage of those substances if they if they if they last Etc so I I do I'm pleased going into this knowing that the the selections that were made some of them will have some return in value on the operational bu Paul I know you want to say something I can tell well I just wanted to give one example and you know we did talk about this

054once before but I did want to give one example that comes to mind when you talk about value engineering and that is there are several ways to air condition the second floor okay one way can cost $2.5 million and the other way can cost 350,000 they both both ways make the rooms cool okay one way is how what we consider value engineering we use Min splits rather than putting in full duct systems and adding steel girds to the roof of the school inside the roof to handle three ton the three ton weight of the air conditioning systems so they both they both ACH achieve the same thing but one does it with a lot more value uh in mind there were some other things that were discussed and agreed upon in the last three months

055that did value engineering we didn't really break them out during discussions because it becomes laborious those that information is available if you wanted to see it we can we can talk about it but the real value engineering gets done when the design work gets done design work hasn't hasn't been done so that's when they really that's why Kino is optimistic that there are further I'm not speaking out of turn here I'm trying to I'm trying to quote they said that they are optimistic that there are further savings to be realized once the design is accomplished okay well thank you for setting me straight on that that reminds me I was set straight on something else can I speak to that for just were talking about the building so I I had characterized um I think

056it was not the last meeting but in December I had characterized the prior decision around the roofing that was done um describing it as something that needed to be replaced too soon as a mistake of that board and um somebody on the fact objected to that characterization I think it's a fair criticism so I'm open to that and they gave me some more information which was at the time uh we had one of these building assessments that was done similar to the one that we had made a lot of our decisions based on and that uh report had suggested I think that the building that the roof would need to be replaced it would be $600 something thousand and they were able to negotiate and find a suitable provider to be able to do that

057and save $200,000 so I thought that was remarkable and worth and worth noting um it didn't just I don't think we got to the point what my intention was to was to talk about warranties where their better products and were those determined I think I feel confident that our committee by having the committee that we did and the work that we did that we've thought through a lot of that this time but the other point is there's always trade-offs there's always things that are going on in the town and that was that was mentioned by the person who brought this to my attention and I think that that's just an important thing to say going forward is we're going to make decisions well this board will make decisions I'm sure in one year not 11

058years somebody will come along and Monday morning Monday Morning Quarterback like I did and say that it was a poor decision so um I I just wanted to share that cuz I thought that that was uh I promised that I would do that and and I thought that was a fair critique yeah yeah I mean I want to say I support this Bond I mean I've been very impressed with Paul and Sophie and the work that they've been doing I it's a little bit hard for me because um I was on you know all of you guys come up and say how you're so glad it's not 40 million I was on the $40 million train for a long time and it's because we started thinking about this school as a community center right as

059a place that people gather um and it it was really exciting to think about it with a stage and with a a gymnasium that adults could play basketball in and even last weekend I had a conversation with somebody about how stratum does not have a community center and so you know um I was definitely on that on that train for a long time this school is so important to me and um I've spent so much time here and um you know it's I was on the 40 m and do train but what I would say now is that I do appreciate obviously um being a taxpayer listening to taxpayers I understand how the $15 million $12 million train is um is the better one right now um um but um so I I will support

060this but I do claim um responsibility for the larger train uh I'll go on record saying that I do support this I do have a question just really quickly I was kind of noticing in here that there's um The Kino number the 11961 and then there's the um additional 29944 is that in is that included in that 11 million or is that an addition that's an addition to would it be bonded together so what will happen is you'll put the bond in for the 11 milon 961 745 but then what's happening is here if you see at the bottom one of the last sentences in article one it says and further raise and appropriate the 29944 so you're going to have to they're going to have to vote that's going to be part of it

061this is your first years's portion of interest that you will have to pay next year so you have to raise that and include it in your other budget items that you're passing okay understood okay very good I missed that Michelle could I ask a question very real is that is that almost like the concept of like an amortization schedule where the folks who are running the bond want to make sure that they're getting or am I thinking about that wrong can you characterize what the purpose of of doing it that way is so it's typically when we pay a bond we pay in August in May or April and what they do is one piece of it is the interest and one piece of it is the principal so what they did is they actually

062provided us with the schedule the payout schedule and irregardless of the length of time that ends up being chosen that first payment is just the interest in the first fiscal year that we're working with fiscal 26 so it's the same amount in every year and just interest so it is kind of what I'm thinking about when you look at your anization sched and work okay thanks and then are and talking about the budget tonight as well are we um are we also looking at the different Bond links and determining which one we want to go with if yeah I mean you could give that to us tonight or that could be for our February meeting so that we know it can happen after the vote too um but we gave you a couple of different

063schedules where it's at but the board would want to give us uh an which direction they'd want to go all right my my opinion is Go year Paul can you speak to what the implication of that on the sort of that median household concept that we've been talking about in a lot of other contexts what that might represent uh yeah I can so in year one it adds I just happen to have that one in my head it adds 37 cents per thousand um to the tax rate and I'm going to turn I can give the exact numbers if you give me a second to start this St it's also in the one pager that I passed around just an average cost yeah Jennifer has it you can read it can you read it aloud

064just for the record if you want um if pass the bond will be not to exceed 12 million which includes a 15% contingency for unseen unforeseen issues the impact her tax bill for an average home valued at $834,000 will be roughly $315 a year this assumes at2 year bond at 4% and that's obviously rough numbers but yeah that right I think it I was just kind of wondering what is it at a shorter I'm just because I think it's Paul go ahead Paul yeah go I've got this up what is it that you would like me to if it was 20 versus 30 versus 25 oh well I'd have to change the bond schedule so um uh that I'd have to change the bond schedule I can't give you that number right now okay is

065so is is the suggestion that we do make some kind of recommendation coming out of this okay and might be how did you come up with the 25 year it's it's between 20 and 30 actually what I what I do is I I look at the uh I just look at the dollar impact on the taxes okay um Molly gave us a 20 25 and 30-y year schedule if you look at the 20year schedule the impact um is like 68 or 69 cents per thousand it it so you I can look I could just in my head look at that that that 312 is going to go to probably like 600 and then if you run this across all the way we talked about this another time and you add the municipal the state the

066co-op up um and all the other aspects of taxes you end up with yeah right you end up with uh you're going to end up instead of with a $729 impact you're already over $1,000 so let me say it another way if you go to 20 years yeah thanks and it goes up to 69 cents a th000 what is now 729 with all of the components of our tax rate in it the the 8 $334,000 average uh assessment goes from $729 to about $1,000 right and there there's some in the methodology there's some assumptions that are made but they're based on historical context and then I would say the other component is that is a for the median sort of that median home y it's the median house is uh is is valued at is

067assessed at 88 $834,000 and the the assumptions made in this are very realistic I talked to the town about about them okay one of them is an assumption on what the co-op is going to come in and I use the very conservative number based on history thanks I'm fine with 25 I think that makes sense I'm good with it is there an average what is what is the normal yeah anywhere between 20 and 30 you you typically for a a bing project you're going up is 20 um but 25 would be appropriate so yeah and the I'm sure if we do it pay pay it off quicker you probably get a little bit better interest rate with a municipal Bond Bank you can't pay it off quicker that's the one but I mean the 20

068versus the 25 or 20 versus a 30 yeah different L you you'll see the total interest that's in cost if you look at these sheets right here yeah you look to the left it's the tax impact by year but you also look at the U amount of interest that you'd have to pay between 25 and 30 so if you did a yeah so the total project got a 30-year would be close to 19 million and in 25 years you're you're about 17 million excuse me 20 years at 17 million you're at 18 million for 25 years so saving about a million dollars just buy five years sooner right and then do you want to state that a little bit later yeah sorry I'm just looking at the bonds right now like the different um but

069the the net interest C the rate is 4% across no matter what time frame is chosen so obviously you pay something off faster you're going to pay less interest over time similar to a credit card um but it's 4% there's no break in you know if we went with 10 it'd be less in the interest uh percentage so 4% what are the what are the chances that we can get better than 4% again this is just where they're at now as interest rates come down it could come down lower and that's what we're starting to see with the municipal Bond Bank so that we'll know that that's the sale will be July correct so that's what we we'd be looking at as in July that's that's another very important point that I keep thinking about

070and keep meaning to mention and forget to men mention is that well the implication on the town's taxes is very real it doesn't really hit its full impact until the year 2026 correct okay so everybody thinks oh we're going to vote on this Bond tonight and we are and all of a sudden next week they're going to get hit with this big tax increase no they're going to get hit with a tax increase but they're not going to feel it till 2026 we don't we don't actually buy the bond until July be July right yeah we'll start working out in April so once the vote happens in March we then can reach out to the Bond Bank starting in April we do all the back work for you and then we'll know what the bond

071Sal is in July to give you your full number and how how much you'll be be charged each year you know I said that word big tax increase and then I bit my tongue I want to say this again and it's already been stated once uh this $12 million Bond results in an increase in the home assessed at 83 $4,000 which is the average assessment in the town is $312 annually so you get two tax bills a year it's $156 on each of two each of your tax bills associated with the bond I hope I said that right associated with on top of everything else yeah just go ahead I said it wrong is that right no no no no Mike hon um so just just pieces of information I and you know you them

072for your benefit or not um but Public Safety bonds Police Department fire department in stratum were 20 years um we just paid off the police department the fire department would be um another year or two um and I'm not sure I'm not sure the process but but I I don't know when you have to commit to the time frame it may not be tonight correct so um and and so there may be you know maybe interest rate changes off into the future so good dialogue but but as but as a point of reference the town's used to 20-year Bond so you wouldn't be doing something that's out of character for the town um and and um so just something something to consider the other the other part is to consider is it it would be

073useful to think about not waiting 35 years to do the next some of things that might need to be done and they may need to be done before you know right around 20 years and I think folks would appreciate not having two Bonds on the school so just just things to yeah factor it's helpful yeah Kate what would you like to say Paul I had this we had this conversation in a building Paul and I and Sophia were there chrisy were there uh at one of our building committee meetings um the bond is proposing a solution to several problems no question there are other problems remaining that we know are going to have to be solved because the building is 35 years old and I express some similar reservations or concerns about a 25-year Bond

074because as a taxpayer myself when a school or a police department of the Town wants you to have two bonds for something that is the same like the school or um a police station saying oh we actually need to go bigger now we need you even though you still have seven years on the first bond that you passed 10 years ago or 15 years ago is really hard um and I do wonder about the difference between a 20 and a 25 year in a particularly when you're talking about a 35-year-old building and you're remedying some and the most important no question but we also know there are remaining things Windows would be an example and I know you don't want to bond those but there are other things that could potentially come up in a

07525 year bond puts us at a very risky place I think to have to go back to the town with another potential need for another Bond I will have retired but I just thought that was important to mention I might still she could be I think best she's a decade than I I'll be dead how much just yeah I think that's a really good point just so I I'm clear what what do we have to do tonight you just have to approve the number that's going there the the terms we can bring back we can even wait until after your the March vote and talk about that at our April meeting so you do not have to do in length we just we gave it to you so you could start thinking about it and

076look at Dollar figures as it goes out what what is the experience and maybe I hate to ask Mike again but or anybody but what's the experience of going to the town saying you want $12 million but we haven't picked a time frame yet is that well you've already you already know what's going to happen in your first year budget you know it would be in the length of that time so they're okay with that well you that's the what your bond is going to uh that's what the Project's going to cost you it's the interest that you'd have to build into your budget year after year right you know what my question is there Mike I mean you're not you're not necessarily required to do that I mean you're asking for 1212 million and

077that's what they're voting on right if I if I was a taxpayer I would just I I'd want to know but I I I appreciate that also I don't is it tied to is the B is the rate tied to other uh competitive municipal bonds that are out there is that the bond the municipal Bond Marketplace that those rates are set based on yes so so when they give us a projection they're giving us what they believe is the the highest amount kind of like what they used to do with Health Trust in their health and gmr so what they're trying to tell you is that they expect the highest to be the four % but they're going to go out to bid when they gather all the groups that are needing a bond for

078this time period that they go out to bid and then they're finding out who's who's who's buying all these and who's going to give us the best interest rate and that's when we'll find out what the actual final is got it and are they tied at all to other bond yields that are out there that I don't know okay we see those Rising all right so maybe we defer the schedule for another time and just vote on the amount what uh yeah do weate do we are we doing a motion for each one you should as a board what's your Rec Commendation for the bond all right does anybody have any other comments or questions okay um do I have any motions on the bond you do it uh I like to make a motion

079uh to vote to uh accept and approve um a bond for 11 million 960,000 is that the number 61 and 61 any change 745 745,000 I will second thanks guys all right any discussion on that motion all right see none all in favor I hi hi any oppose all right so five zero no extensions zero I almost wanted to make a joke and say nay all right great um okay moving ahead to the um trust funds uh Chris will you just review for us quick the current Trust fund or um Michelle y got it you want the two that were yeah um so the two that were recommended by faac would be um the maintenance capital reserve fund and the wording on the warrant could show shall the stratum School District vote to raise an

080appropriate the sum of $20,000 to be added to the maintenance capital reserve fund previously established in 2009 this sum to come from June 30 fund balance available for transfer on July 1 no additional amount to be raised from taxation okay how much is in there currently question okay for that maintenance maintenance maintenance you have $228,200 th000 as a minimum so we talked about possibly funding this at $20,000 that would put us at $248,200 as construction occurs we'll know more and more about what unforeseen items arise or don't arise and it as we can start to get a good flavor about it's looking more like we can begin the process of the windows or maybe not but no yeah I sorry I understand that just I wasn't sure if we had already discussed like let's try

081and replace five each year and have a rotating schedule and that's already no we haven't come up with that yet okay that's just mechanics it's that's an that's really an easy decision to make great all right well I'm good with that for the maintenance trust fund okay and um the one thing I was just looking for in the packet but I don't see it is what is the anticipated fund allance at the end right now I got it y um we're looking at uh last Wednesday Y and again that's projected for as of last Wednesday yeah yeah but there are certain items already earmarked for that 182 um it would be whatever you pass in your warrants what what that would go in there for your unreserved um but I'm thinking about retirements K paying

082karino things like that are those do to come out of that your Kino is coming out of your general budget so that would come under your facility so we take that out of our general budget yeah it's already been encumbered we've accounted for for everything whatever is left is things that we have not new bills that have come in that we have not encumbered for the year yeah okay so we're looking at 182 yeah I mean I actually think it should be a little higher um that's what I would argue for I think um I I think we need to make that fund more robust which one are we talking about maintenance trust do you have a recommended number you're thinking um I mean I I would let me say 30 okay um I just

083think you know we always hear from people and and I can't even imagine what what if the bond doesn't pass I I don't know um I'd just like to make that more robust seems like we're switching hats I originally wanted a 100 yeah right right and and this is a rais in appropriate number or this is a we would transfer okay yeah right this be the end we move 20 excellent this is not a raise in appropriate right so yeah I I I kind of think that that's I agree with that I don't know what anybody else think if you're on the building from the building do I hear 50 no yes do you Paul do you have the number for we've talked about in the building Bond like for um the boiler right like

084the boiler is like the big thing that you know is going or needs to be replace like what's the number on that 1.5 million okay cafeteria expension is 750,000 offices area is 1.5 million roof is 655,000 what else you want to know well I think what I'm thinking about as a parent is what is going to close this school down right so boilers boilers um boilers the roof you know what what can I I mean even the roof isn't going to close the school down boilers will close the school down there's no question about it no water will close the school down right okay but we're we're going to be redoing the water system all the way back to the pumping station so right so yeah we're not going to buy a new boiler no

085definitely not that week yeah no we're not and I just I'm just thinking too I'm kind of looking at the last meeting's um financials um for numbers and looking at the um ending fund balance for like previous years and obviously we're like we're already below some of that and so I'm like you know hesitate to move a ton to the trust fund but I also don't because I I want to cover what needs to be done if it needs to be done obviously even 50 is not going to do that for like a boiler um so nope um I'm in I'm in favor of this as it stands I'm also meable to a little bit more but I I don't know that it's gonna I guess just to talk against myself you know we do

086talk about keeping it consistent what we turn out of that fun balance from year to year so like Tanya is saying we are lower this year um just can you tell us a little bit about the impact of that you know dips and Y [Music] so in previous years we've given back anywhere from 547 th000 to 237 553 765 and 401 so those kind of the different years that you're weaving back and forth so obviously in the years that you give more back than that has a positive impact on the tax rate as it gets set and that obviously the less you give back then that has a detrimental effect to the tax rate yeah but you said there's something about fluctuation or um I guess where I'm going with this is the taxpayer will

087feel that like next year almost looks like an increase because well um this year it looks like a tax increase because we're not giving as much back correct yeah okay yeah so maybe maybe to that point we we keep it at the 20 just to kind of keep that fund balance as much as possible that's yeah I guess I just think 10,000 that's not a huge difference to the taxpayer but it is a difference in the trust fund should something happen yeah um I would say special ed should stay as is I do agree with that um and then we're thinking 10,000 for the tech fund can you just talk a little bit about that I know it's sort of to buy computers over time yep so we were trying to look uh future and

088look at what are major cost impacts and in every five to six years you're looking at doing your wiring your switching anything that's going with your cabling so all of your internet your infrastructure to be able to provide uh technology throughout the building it's a significant increase every five years you're seeing a 60,000 and technolog is only going up so by putting this money away you're not having to take this out of your budget you're you're planning for the future A Five-Year Plan and that was why we made that recomend Commendation so if we put $10,000 away every 5 years you'd have that fund you use it and pay for your wiring but then you would not have any tax impact and none of that is covered in the renovation Tech isn't no no okay

089what about the Chromebooks like what about the things that AR on a fiveyear yep we put those in our budget so those are in the budget yeah this is specifically for your switching which are like the time every five year fees that we knew we' have there because Chromebooks are year to year we put it in we do have replacement cycle so that we can try to keep that as consistent as possible in your current budget sense to you yeah but is it a full Fleet Refresh on the Chromebooks or is it like no it's a grade level okay all right that's much better so we looked at starting first grade and then carrying those up and then replacing at first grade that makes sense I just didn't want to see a big endpoint nope

090price tag that we weren't thinking about because we weren't nope yeah number of years ago we did it was after Co we had replaced like basically the fleet that's remember and since then we are now on a one year grade level recycling plan so a kid will get their get it administered they'll take it through their experience here yeah those was one of the things we tried to clean up because all of our schools there was eight replaced at this grade level 30 at this grade level so if we do it by one grade level we know the number of students and then then we can follow them up yeah I think that and that was a significant factor in that budget if I recall correctly huge it was so can we make a motion

091to approve all right and what for what amount um for maintenance 20,000 and then as recommended I guess I forget the exact uh special ed would um stay as is which is zero right which is just not to have we're not going to add so in the in the in the board packet that I got today it said 10,000 yep that was just a a review from last year so if we did not fund this this would not be on your warrants so this would not be listed LED for people to talk about we just remove it we just showed you what we put in there last year as an indicator and a discussion point and then technology 10,000 okay so just maintenance 20 and Technology 10 okay just to just to discuss it for

092one second more so you're are you what are you saying now that we don't need the maintenance tress fund increased by that amount do you feel comfortable with that no what I said was I I am it is reasonable to assume that the next big um repair or renovation to the school is the windows is it's reasonable to assume it can be covered by the bond reasonable not 100% yeah okay I was prior to that I was uh insistent that we increase the maintenance TR trust fund considerably uh or faster than we have been so that we would be prepared for that $400 to $500,000 window bill that we're going to have to look at in several years several being three or four or something like that then Chris uh made the argument which is

093reasonable you don't actually have to do all the windows in one year you can do them say a wing at a time so you feel comfortable with the 20,000 I would say when all is said and done we've got a bond to pass we've got a budget to pass you know that the town had almost almost a 12% tax increase last year 25% of the town is looking at a 125% increase this year already with the $132 rate and it has nothing to do with the things we're talking about the bond the budget the and all that stuff so yeah yeah I absolutely feel that way okay okay I just I was going to Second it just because there wasn't SS um all right any further discussion then all right so is everybody clear what

094we're voting on uh 20,000 for maintenance Capital trust fund 10,000 for the um technology capital reserve fund all right all in favor I I I all right five anybody opposed five Z zero all right moving on to the budget um the warrant as it is right now um $1,961 745 um and what percentage increase is that 2.74 right 2.73 2 point okay that's that version I just wasn't clear which version well you just talked about you just mentioned a bond number 11 million n that's the bond oh sorry sorry I'm sorry this the budget is 15,6 37374 thank you all right any um conversation questions on that I wanted to ask a question first because I don't think it's part of a discussion for the vote per se um and Chris I had asked about

095this do we have what the what the operating budget percentage increases have been over the past I think three years so not this one but the one 20234 two no I'm I'm starting in the wrong spot but so last year would be 2425 right and that one was at what that was at 3% okay and then for 2324 2324 was 10.59% 10.59 Michelle that was the health insurance in the 2223 was 3.77% got it okay thank you cop um personally I feel comfortable passing um the budget as proposed I think um we've heard a lot of discussion we've done a lot of work to reduce it um to what feels comfortable to admin um I think we should yeah I think I feel comfortable respecting that respecting the recommend the recommendation of the fact and

096approving that budget myself um I also just want to mention it's really confusing as a board member to pass a budget without really understanding the implications of those numbers and what it will have in the school and on a day-to-day basis and for admin so I understand it's really not our job to micromanage like how that money is then spent um and just appreciate like all that goes into that and um I often wish it was more of a conversation and kind of a Roundtable discussion you know of like okay what if we do this number what would that mean okay this number what would that mean and it's really hard to have that conversation in this format and you know with the amount of work that it would have to take to come up

097with those numbers so um yeah I guess that's just my personal reflection I feel comfortable with it and um that's it for me thanks so can I just speak to one thing about that process cuz I think that I think that's a good thing to think about is um what we're going to submit and correct me where I'm wrong I'm going to look to you Chris specifically for this so we would we will recommend a number that's passed out of this body it will not it it does not dictate certain line items within that within that budget we take that and we then present that to the town on in March early March they have the opportunity ultimately to decide what that number should be right and then whatever the decision that's made in March

098is again on a number that number will then come back depending on what it is the administration will make recommendations um and then some of those items do require approval by the board is that a fair assessment not sure what items you would be referring to so for example last year we had um an mtss coordinator position the board at that time was in the majority supporting that position we heard from folks in the town some folks in the town that tended to vote no on the on the proposed budget saying they didn't want that position so we we were we were left with a certain amount of money that the that the town gave to us I recall voting on that mtss coordinator position it was a difficult vote to make but we made

099a vote on that so what I'm saying is there are some items that when we get a number back mhm the administration is going to present to us um in more of an allocation or an appropriation perspective but some of those items have to be approved by the board that's constituted at that time so the mtss was a new position that's why it was put brought to the board because that was the implication in that budget with this budget being reduced in the number of Staff how that's managed by the building Administration they'll give you a presentation of how it's going to be staffed but that would not be need board approval board can definitely give recommendations and insight to how we would staff it and how we'd manage it but it doesn't need approval

100that way but a strong recommendation from our board would definitely have guidance of how how we'd want to staff the building thank you that's really important what we would vote on so if existing teacher positions or regular instruction positions if that's that's been a large part of some of the discussion around this number and these numbers and how because fundamentally these numbers if we were we've already reduced them to to this extent if we were to reduce them further they're going to have implications some of the implications I think I don't want to quote you put words in your mouth but you said they would absolutely have an effect on regular instruction I would think correct like likely right because it's significant enough the only way that I think you're saying obviously the board would

101be able to make a suggestion about that a strong potentially a strong suggestion but you're saying that the administration would make that choice they have the authority to make that choice regardless so we're going to come back to you with a staffing number and here's how we're going to staff the building based on the number of full-time halftime whatever you uh employees that we have that are certified that are required so that's why we use the administration to make their recommendations of here is how we're going to staff it and why board can then ask questions and talk about concerns or questions and give recommendations and then that would be the discussion that we would have but for approval not specifically approval the board could be very disappointed in the presentation we would hear that

102and that would be feedback that you give to me since I am your you know your resource for the board and then I'd bring that back to the the building Administration got it why is it that the board doesn't have to approve that uh I would review the policy and roles and responsibilities of the board yeah you know you're you're approving the overall budget yeah how they manage the the the budget that that is under the opice of the the building Administration I think that's important and then the um we do vote on the on the Slate of regular instruction teachers to be approved or not approved at the end of the year as presented by the administration so we will make a recommendation of who's who's going to be continuing on their contracts and

103who would not right yeah so we bring that to you to be approved because you do you do approve any new certified staff that come into your building right I want wanted to go through that process just so everybody here was clear and so that it was kind of on the record how that process works because I think sometimes people think one thing happens and something else fundamentally can happen can I ask a point of clarity what you when you see the nominations for staff for the following year that is not budgetary that's more of I just want to make sure that that wasn't said I agree I'm just saying when does the board get to weigh in on regular instruction and who proposing new staff right yeah new positions right I I have a

104question on that too one of the first things I had to do was sign off on the staff what is what is that that's presented to the board at that point what are we do what are we signing off on um your it is the staff that is currently working at the school and is proposed to be working here the following yearing on their contract you're approving their contract for the next year they're certified staff that is one that is one authority of the board the staff's coming back what what what option I'm I don't know I right I've never done it before what options do the does the board have except approving it you we definitely could have your's concerns about staff members we could have a non-public meeting and talk about those concerns

105and that would be a discussion of of why we'd make a recommendation one way or the other okay all right so it would be concerns of Staff members could be yeah Y what other what what other reasons would there be uh I have not dealt with any in in that aspect okay I could I couldn't give it to you just curious I I don't know all right thank you ask a question um as a question yeah uh okay are we still in public comment so public comment has expired I don't know if you want to treat this as a fact question or a public statement so really how you want to do just just keep it brief minutes no it's so when I'm looking at the 25 budget I don't know it's been long so

106when does that get by line item talk to miss the detail here when does that get solidified does that so when I'm looking at the 25 budget it's by all these lines I mean hundreds of Lin so when does that get finalized so that's now they're voting on the total M and we recommended the toal so that's what we give of how we've allocated the different the overall cost of this budget and by different line items and and function codes so that's the accounting piece to it right however remember that when you do a budget it's a zerob based budget so if we know that technology went up or special education Transportation came up we can't go over that $15 million so we may have to borrow it against oil which is down right now

107or plowing since we haven't had plow this year so that is how we have to look at our budget so we do it by function code so you know where we're spending and you're going to see overages where we spend and you're going to see underes as long as we don't go over that total allocation that's what we're looking for right right I okay so what you're saying is that they vote a number then you can you you eventually come up with right now because I'm looking at the budget here and has individual lines which we didn't modify many of those lines um they wouldn't just carry over you between now and whenever you come back to the board with the final allocation of all these of the dollars that get approved um are there

108changes or or what not typically okay so as it's allocated by function code that's what we're presenting is what we need is our our need based budget for the following year okay however that could change if and then as the year come as the year comes Goes On by um I I understand you move you can move you move items around but does the B does the board approve that those changes they've approved the overall allocation of the budget okay so P every month we get um what changes there are to the budget lines and that's why we were just talking about the fund balance because at the end of the year there is a positive fund balance depending on yeah I I understand that I understand it I so okay I I would say

109and correct me if I'm wrong it's fungible to some extent however there are some things that are contracted correct right so for contract fact that things there's not much you can do there are some discretionary items and then there are some items that do come to us for an approval because they're based on contractual items right so it's it's it's it's kind of a composite answer to that question I mean I'm not averse to moving the mone's around as you as you see the needs you may not spend let's say there's less snow this year so you have extra in the snow budget and you see a need in another place you you'd move that Dollars around right but that's that's all by the administration no approval often times we we talk about budget I

110we talk about budgets every board meeting and if there's changes we we'll be you keep aware that's what you're saying that's it okay that's all I need to know thank you yeah I think for me um you know I I do support this budget I think it is pretty slim actually I worry sometimes that it is too slim when we're under inflation we're actually you know um cutting our budget at the same time you know I think we to Kate and Kate every month and you know obviously I defer to them and how they run it and how lean they are um we know that the state is funding less and less and I think that's something we're going to be fighting you know every year from now on especially with these Special Special Education

111costs um so I do support the budget I actually worry that it's too lean but um I'll be voting for it I'm I'm happy to speak on it so I I kind of spoke on it uh I mean I shared some thoughts last meeting I don't think that my position has changed on it too much I would not be supporting the budget I would support it at a lesser amount and here's the reason I I do agree on the inflation piece the thing that I'm I'm actually more concerned about with inflation is the contracted the biggest piece to me is the FTE the biggest piece is regular instruction and those positions I and I don't know Michelle if you can if you can speak to it because I I know I think I kind of

112have a sense of what the collective bargaining agreement was on that but what do you know what those increases have been over the past and in the length of that time and I can keep talking while unless you know what I believe so but let me just pull it up the yes I I'll keep talking until you until you get that I I've mentioned this before and I'm trying to just look over the hill and say that we are going to have to renegotiate I don't want to say have to we get the wonderful opportunity to renegotiate the collective bargaining agreement with with our with our teachers our wonderful teachers and um and they have experienced a and I we'll get that number pretty soon but we they really haven't we haven't our budgets have

113not been as affected by the inflation component on those FTE yeah did you want to share so it was a one and a half% for each of the four years in the agreement okay one and a half for each of the four years in the agreement right I mean does anybody recall what the cost of living has done I'm not trying to put this out into the universe and and make any anything harder here but I don't think it's I think it's I think it's pretty obvious that there's been a lot of changes that's to me where the biggest part of the inflation component comes and where the biggest demands will be there are going to be conversations with the town next next year when that gets renegotiated and there are going to be there's

114going to be a request of the town I don't know if that's going to be 1.5 or if it's going to be zero or if it's going to be whatever it's going to be I I'm I'm going to stop talking because I I don't want to I don't this is not the opportunity to be able to negotiate something that's going to happen in the future I just think it's something that's important for us to think about one thing that uh when Cameron mentioned that some of the other and I said rightly so um that there are other towns who do not uh who are have not adjusted to higher class sizes um one one thing they may not have done is what we did which was we we offered a retirement incentive and we I

115didn't I don't think any of us knew what we were going to get we knew that we had certain a certain quantity within that uh cohort that may have been interested in that um and I was I guess pleased I don't know that we had a fairly significant uh response to that that response gives me to to me it's the opportunity to do something that we could not do going forward potentially because it was a good number of people that were in that criteria I'm doubtful possible you never know next year you may even have you could do something like that again I don't think so that's just me and I'm going to make my own value judgments in in my vote based on what I think is going to Happ I don't think think

116that's going to happen again I think we have an I think we have a unique opportunity right now to right siiz the classes and I when I say right siiz I know people will probably challenge that that's the correct wording for that um but I think it's a unique opportunity now let me let me just say what I mean by right siiz when I talk about right sizing I'm talking about going back to what we had in 2018 2019 years prior a very similar number so prior to 2018 it was actually higher 2021 in the two grades that we have talked about being affected potentially um and that might have even been I don't know when Mrs ganner made her comments I don't know that might have been some of the times that she was

117reflecting on over time where there were larger numbers of students in the in the classrooms we certainly have less than that now here's what troubles me the most so we heard I and I think I would never have I had the sense but I didn't really get it until we went through this process when we went through this process we got a lot of feedback on this particular concept because we' never really positioned this concept before even though the recommendations that I would make around fourth and fifth still comport to the 2020 guidelines again pre-co um the feedback that we got was from teachers was from parents former teachers uh former staff members in the building in my own home friends of mine was that and I I don't uh how do how do I

118want to describe this I don't want to be I don't want to use hyperbole but a a near distress with the concept of adding three children per classroom in grades four and five and what I heard and you can look at all the stuff that's different what was the difference between 201819 and now and a lot of folks who are older are probably going to say it can't be anything that's justifiable but what we've heard is that behavior is wildly different behavior is poor there is apathy there is rudess there are class disruptions there are work refusal by children children have become very challenging in the upper grades and we've heard some reasons about why that might be what I would love to hear and I haven't heard yet even though everybody's heard this conversation

119so far what are we doing about to me that is a for alarm fire type of feedback and to me it's extremely important I do not want to disregard that feedback I think it is the most important feedback and I think there is some feelings of capitulation ation to that um that things are just different now these are just the behavioral things that we're going to have to deal with I think it should be our top priority and our top focus and I think it's less about having three more students in the in the classroom than it is about getting our hands and the school wrapped around improving that component if I'm wrong I'd love to see what our plan is what our policy is what our metrics are are we measuring it how are

120we going to measure against it and we might not be doing maybe this is new feedback to everybody but this is not I've heard this for a couple of years sort of anecdotally and I'm starting to hear it more from people that I've never heard it from before I think that's the biggest issue that's facing the school um as it relates to increased class sizes and I it would be my challenge to and this is not just a challenge to the administration please it's a challenge to the parents in the Community uh it's a challenge to when when we hear that kids are not coming to school uh ready to learn uh kids are uh perhaps not they're being very disregulated when they're here it's a challenge for the entire Community but I'm not willing

121to just throw my hands up and say well we just have to live that's the way kids are today that's the way parenting is today um I would love to come up with strategies where we can support the board can support the ad Administration the administration can support parents and we can get uh we can get back to the uh the way that kids probably should comport and I understand I'm sorry for being on soap boox I I understand that there are significant differences I've read the anxious generation I would suggest everybody read the anxious generation if you can't buy it on Amazon Barnes & Noble wherever books are sold it's at the library you can rent it you can download it you can listen on audiobook it's on Spotify it's on Audible uh everan

122it's extremely important and if you're in the older group it's extremely important to know what your kids are dealing with in raising their children it's extremely important for your grandchildren for your nieces and nephews and to understand what's going on and what uh what has been changing over the past five years my challenge is that we should get on top of it and not paper it over and is that a budget conversation that you want to have tonight like it's it's it don't want I don't want to try to propose any and my Solutions might not be the right Solutions what I'm saying is I support a budget I'm sorry let me let me make it very super clear I support a budget that that puts class sizes in the frame of the January 2020

123Schoolboard recommendations for fourth and 5th that recognized a minimum and a maximum we would still be within those it would be 20 I don't even think 21 kids per class in the 14 or 15 based on expected enrollment for 25 um and it would uh afford us all the other things that I described which is not having to hire people back not having to worry about riffing somebody if our if our enrollment continues to decline and I think I mentioned last meeting when I spoke uh Sophie had mentioned this about are the enrollment ports right are they not I think that's still debatable I feel very confident that we're not going to see a huge uptick but if we did my opinion is that we should in a we we should in a more agile

124way address those we're going to have a third grade group that's going to be coming up in a couple of years that might not that might exceed those recommendations and I I think this is an opportunity for us to hire um and to fulfill that so anyway that I'm suggesting that we take that I think an additional 111 or 109 or 102 or whatever that number was that I I'd heard earlier in the night and the budget by that um because we're already suggesting potentially to do that for the fifth grade I'm suggesting to do that for the fourth grade the number was 111 um I want to follow on to what um Eric said a moment ago and I had mentioned this when we learned about the results of the first um um offer

125for early incentive for early retirement that maybe we'll have another round of that so we know that um stratum was the in aggregate the salaries were on way up at the top end for the state okay and Kaden said much we have a lot of teachers that have been here for a lot of years you know they they've had long careers here understandable so five took it this year that's great I don't know what the longevity of the remaining teachers is are is here maybe next year there will be a couple more or three more that either go in into the category of what we did this year maybe we could change the category if we decided it and we may and we bring the age and Longevity down for the early retirement you know

126change change the criteria and maybe um a few more teachers that are at the very top end of the pay scale decide to accept um the in the incentive of motivation for early retirement and then again we bring other teachers in at uh a uh you know at a lower pay scale younger younger teachers and so on businesses do this all the time okay it is a regular thing okay we read about it we hear about it on TV you get a lot a lot of people that are in their late 50s and early 60s they're at the top of their pay scale and the companies just say okay you did a great job thank you for your service here's a nice little uh motivation to take early retirement people say you know what this

127a good good time to to take to retire a few years earli and out they go um and and so it is a strategy for uh for managing um salaries it's nothing wrong with it it's not it's not being disingenuous or anything like that so I just want to follow on that on that on that uh and I mentioned that the last time we talked about this subject I guess to me um Eric I I hear what you're saying I think there's a lot of Truth in a lot of pieces but to me it doesn't they don't really add up I feel like you're saying two different things one is that kids are disregulated and we need to address that right and that the other is that you feel comfortable with the larger class sizes

128and to me that those two things don't go together you know like if if teachers and parents are saying look this is a lot we need help don't reduce our you know don't increase our class sizes now I think if we do that that doesn't feel good to me as a board member of not listening to that wisdom and that experience and saying okay we hear things are a lot harder now than they were pre-co when those recommendations were set but we're still going to reduce them before we address those things you know what I mean like if teachers were coming to us and saying hey hey actually like things are coming down you know the covid wave of disregulation is quieting down now things are a little bit more pre-co times maybe that would

129be a good time to increase class sizes but given the feedback that we've had overwhelmingly on email and in person I personally don't feel comfortable um and nor is it appropriate in my opinion to say to admin um to make that recommendation about class sizes question does every every uh class have an aid um there are students um that have access to par professionals but the only place that that exists like a classroom Aid is kindergarten um and then in most cases it's attached to a student or students but not every room has a pair of professionals so third and fourth and fifth grade classes don't have um I gave those numbers you don't have them in front of you I gave them out Pat had asked for them I could look them up for

130in one second if I get my computer out I believe in fifth grade if you thought about um pair of professionals across fifth grade it was2 would be the average in the class because we have one that's assigned to fifth grade right and that's a student yeah so um it is not we have prior to the increase in the number of students have complex profiles the model here had been to have classroom partnership Paris and we've talked about that a few years at the board level to support the environment however as we've also talked about the need of our students in the complex of their profiles has shifted that because we didn't want to increase the budget we instead shifted the model from the classroom partnership to more of a shared model for the specific

131students with which they were assigned okay all right thank you um I'm sorry did you want to say more please do uh just want to go back a little bit to Eric I appreciate you putting words to your concern because I think that's the first time I've heard you put it like with such an in-depth rationale of like what your thinking is about the your concerns for our students um I want to make I think this piggybacks on what you said the be the what we are seeing in our students is is it is unacceptable for to us to put that on our students it is an adult problem this is not a kid problem so you use words that I know were sent to you about the misbehaviors the disrespect the insubordination that kind

132of THU that that kind of stuff that is an adult problem that those are learned behaviors created by adults and so for us to be thinking about students and talking about students like that is a real challenge for me I know you're not I know that no no no I know that you were given a letter that had that language I know that and I know it's been said at meetings about their behaviors it is their behavior I understand that they're the one with the action or the words those are learned behaviors that is um uh a lack of skills that have not been developed in the way that they should have been because of a variety of circumstances that is a drastic change in our world that the biology and the Brain development of

133an eight-year-old has not possibly kept up with like our body doesn't evolve that way our brain doesn't evolve way that's not how Evolution works and yet the world is changing at a rapid pace and so we are taking four-year olds 5-year olds 8-year-olds and putting them in a world that their brains simply cannot process and so we are seeing an escalation and disre disregulation um behaviors as we'd like to summarize that or capture that um we are also seeing an increase in students that are exper significant trauma and so their behaviors are different that was not happening 40 and 50 years ago 30 years ago at the rate at which it's happening now we can talk about Aces the factors that influence that like there's a whole body of research and I'm so glad that

134you brought it up and kind of articulated that way because I feel like that's our job to present that information to you in a presentation at the board level all the things that we are doing as a school to address those things systemwide classroom wide family wide the number of things that we do on a daily basis to support our students at understanding how um how they function in our classrooms has an incredible impact on them and their peers is substantial and I don't want that to be lost and I understand that we probably haven't had that presentation as a board that hasn't been presented to you but there's a systemic approach every single day that we do here for our kids um and so I struggle with this idea that this is a student

135issue this is an adult issue and I agree that as a we need to um be really clear as an admin team about the things that we do address it I want to be able to share that information with you because I think you deserve to understand the implications of what we're talking about the other piece that I want to add um when we talk about reducing teachers at a grade level and I prepared This and i' like to pass it out because I think it's important because it's a it's it's concrete and it's numbers I think a lot of what you've heard from our community has been um really powerful really accurate but also it feels a little feels for me anecdotal right like personal experience it hasn't been wrapped around numbers and so

136I think it's really important to look at some of these numbers when we're thinking about the childhood the child experience but also the implications of the work we are putting on already taxed staff so the chart where it says five classes this is our current fourth grade class would be our fifth grade class in the 25 26 school year 15.8 right so I average 16 kids per class if you reduced it to four classes next year it's 19 75 I think someone actually mentioned that number earlier would be 20 I want you to think about the number of meetings a teacher attends on a weekly basis and I took this is an average I calculated the number of 6.8 or seven students based on those students in a classroom that either have IEP Based Services

137a 504 plan or in our child study team that means for those students which is roughly seven kids per class teachers have to attend meetings on those students averaging 30 minutes a week per kid some of those meetings are two hours some are three hours and some they don't have one week because it's bi-weekly but that's your average if you were to go over to the next column and you just went to four classes I want you to see that that's an extra hour week they're out of the room not providing direct instruction that is substantial at the end of the year that's 36 hours the 20 children in that fifth grade class did not have their classroom teacher providing direct instruction differential right the differential progress report writing 16 I I want to be

138clear I was a real conservative on this number for those of you that have children here the narratives are really meaningful they're long they're comprehensive I estimate an hour per progress report per student L I'm being conservative again you add four more kids you're talking about substantial amounts of hours that you're putting on the teacher which directly impacts the students talk about family communication roughly I did this based on a order of your classroom is the teacher communicating with each week I think that's also a gross underestimate but I'm trying to give us like some numbers I gave 10 minutes per communication I would argue that some phone calls are 35 to 40 minutes an email is 5 to six minutes so I kind of right again you look at the time we're talking about

139putting on teachers and Educators that directly impacts their ability to engage with their students and better prepare for their students and be responsive and come in feeling like they have some sort of balance in their lives to be sound brilliant Educators that they are personalized planning and prep I said two hours a night for planning that's basically what I said was 30 minutes for reading 30 minutes for math 30 minutes for inquiry and 30 minutes for science or social studies that's bare minimum for any teacher that would sit has sit here I mean it's hours and hours every night of planning when you think about a literacy block and you think about planning we think about personalizing you estimate that you have students in roughly three groups there's sometimes an outlier but when you're planning

140your let's give wordworth for an example you can assume about a third of your kids are working on this this part of phonex a third on this and a third on that when you add four more kids you can assume you just got larger groups because you're going to try to personalize in a better way because you have a larger scale of where the students are at so that's an increase in hours that they're prepping to personalize their instruction for the students of strata Memorial School the course of the year the differential is 120 hours it's a lot of time then you think about all the assessments that we ask our teachers to give and then they have to grade all of those assessments and then they have to provide feedback to all of those

141assessments again a amount of time the differential there is 144 hours over the course of the year so did the mathe that's the differential between having five classro teachers and four classroom teachers with this year's current fourth grade which would be fifth grade next year would be 314 hours additional hours just by going down by one teacher that's not even talking about what we've been bringing up about the experience in the room right so we're I mean that's 8.7 hours a week so we're just adding another day of work to our teachers loads is that what we're thinking we're going to do just want to be clear if that's what we're thinking I just want to make sure we know what we're talking about the bottom part of this talks about student contact time within

142a day so our day starts at 825 it goes to 303 that's and I subtracted the lunch and recess time and I subtracted the related arts time which gives the classroom contact teacher 303 minutes in a day if we want to think about that at a one: one that's 18.9 minutes a day I'm guaranteeing not every kid gets 18.9 minutes a day right that's just not happening small group I did the math if you look over at the end you guys can follow along I need to read this to you less contact time with your teacher and that's not even talking the minutes at the top right I'm just talking about if you have more students in your class each student is getting 11.7 hours less time over the course of the year if you're

143doing one to one and 45.2 less hours of contact time if you're doing small group these are significant amounts these are significant hard numbers when we think about it it's not just my class became more complicated it is my load is exponentially harder which makes it harder for me to be my best self in the classroom and I just think it's really important because we hadn't had these numbers when we were talking it's really been anecdotal about the complexity of profiles um and how challenging that is but so is this this adds an enormous complexity to what we would be asking our teachers to do in fourth and fifth grade if we reduced from five classroom teachers to four classroom teachers and I put this together B based on last week's meeting I was incredibly

144moved by the response of our community but also thought like if we could have some numbers to look at it would be helpful in our conversation um and that's the only reason I prepared it for you guys yeah so I I have a question and thank you for that Kate I appreciate I have a couple points that I wrote down what what's different then about the way that we're the way that we operate today in the classroom versus the way that we did when we had higher higher student counts I'm so glad you asked that so I had a recent experience where um a couple I'm I'll get more specifically but I want to talk about like a realization that I've had recently um when I was a classroom teacher and as an administrator in

145terms of like coaching into classroom culture classroom management classroom that stuff has always been what I would consider like a Cornerstone of my practice and something that I felt really confident in and had always been really successful at and this year when I'm working with teachers and to tell you the level of partnership between Administration and classroom teachers right now around what's happening in our classrooms is I mean it's all day every day in a way that I have never experienced before because it's so complex and we are trying things that I have never had to try on this level of magnitude certainly the things I've tried with one or two students a year right but I'm talking about a higher percentage of students and I thought to myself I don't know that I'm the

146right person because I haven't been in a classroom by myself in so long for the first time since I've been out the classroom which is over 20 years like because it's so different um the what I would say the difference is um I can give you an example I'm in a classroom today actually in a classroom today trying to help um 16 kids um there are four of us each with a group of four I look over there are two kids crawling under tables because their sensory needs are so significant that they're trying to seek input they're not trying to be disrespectful they're not loud they're not doing they are literally trying to seek sensory input because they're so disregulated and overwhelmed it's the afternoon they've just come out of lunch in recess it's freezing

147um and they experience outside of school a significant um their sensory needs aren't being met outside of school either and they come here and we're not going to be frustrated with them or angry with them or talk unkindly to them because they're eight actually nine in this case um and their body is on fire inside part of that is that we understand that gross motor and fine motor isn't developing like it should with our younger kids because they're not having their shoes off and playing in the grasp when they're little literally ot's have been telling this for 20 years so that would be one piece I am looking over at another student who um is trying their best to be incredibly patient and support their classmates and is literally being so good in coaching um

148and supporting and yet she's competing with the group over there that's talking really loud the group over here the two kids over there um and there's four adults in there so I'm thinking she's like hearing the four adults too and she's working her tail off but there's all these other distractions I am thinking about where kids come in um coming in and I didn't have I didn't sleep I played video games till 2 o'clock in the morning that was one of the kids I played video games till 2 o'clock in the morning I'm exhausted I didn't have breakfast and I now I refuse to eat lunch because I'm so disregulated and so upset and so over tired that I'm like pleading with kids to eat these are not things I was dealing with 10 years

149ago um I mean those are just like a snapshot of one day today like right like these things are I in my day right now I have students that I take every day for 15 minute walks in the woods because it's the only time with fresh air that regulates them to come in and then sustain active learning if I try to walk them in the building they're not getting what they need they literally need fresh air and they need to be moving and jumping like I feel like I'm like um Teenage not like a ninja warrior out there in the woods with them because they're literally seeking that level of physical movement and then I'm coming in and we can get 45 minutes of sustained attention and focused learning but if I don't do that

150and we try to walk around the building for like 5 minutes I'm getting a 15minute return they're not trying to be difficult they're literally their bodies need that in order to then focus and sit down part of that is Diet I think that's a huge part of our issue Eric is when kids come and they get jacked up on their sugar and then it fades at 9:30 in the morning we're seeing crashes like there's so many factors that we weren't facing 10 years ago um and then I think about the neurodiversity which I want to be clear I consider this a a privilege and important part a bonus of our job is that we are seeing increase in neurodiversity I think that is so important in our classrooms but it also requires a different level

151of personalization and differentiation in our classrooms that we were not facing 15 years ago because before they were going to the Learning Center for two-thirds of their day I don't want that I want them in our classroom that benefits everybody but it requires a level of expertise and responsiveness and differentiation that when I was in the classroom I didn't have to do so I think there are a myriad of factors for that Eric and and we can even talk more about that um but it is for me it is so Paramount that as adults we solve the problems and continue to support our kids through this and build the skills with them um because that is what's going to benefit all the generations moving forward and that's an adult change that is not a kid

152change and I agree with you on that Kate I I think it is an adult change and I hope it I again I I know you corrected it but I was never describing this as a student issue it's not the kids what it is is it's adults but it's not just the adults in this building it's the adults outside of this building and that's the contention that I've made the contention that I've made is and I think you're making I I don't want to say you're making my point for me but when a kid's been up all night playing video games and then they don't have a meal and then they come to school and they act out in a way that frankly parents who don't let their kids play video games until 5: in

153the morning and give them a healthy breakfast when they go out the door we we have it will only stop when we make it stop and that's what I'm asking is what is the administration doing to help make it stop otherwise the answer is let's throw this budget out and let's add $4 million and let's get it down to five kids per class so that we can keep helping and enabling some of the things that we're seeing that are going on outside of the class and I don't I'm Pro some of these comments will probably hopefully not be taken out of context I mean this in the in the in the most sincere way we do a lot for kids on IEPs 50 we're doing a lot we're doing a lot in the building there

154are things that we have to do and we have to turn our Focus sometimes outside in my opinion as an individual board member speaking but as a parent of kids who are young kids who went through covid kids who I have a challenge telling who who get the dopamine hits by sitting who would sit here and do this all day long looking at a video doing dance videos I mean we if they were parents in the audience they would go their heads would be bobing yes some kids like with any addiction some kids are going to be more addicted to those things than other kids what I'm saying is I the difference between three kids in that situation four kids being added that situ I understand I get it not good but we've got to

155fix the problem and I and and yeah this is the first time I probably articulated this way it's the first time I got this level of feedback throughout the process and not just from one or two people that maybe we all have been on certain strings about lots of other people and um I think it's important and I think we have got to start like we got to get ahead of it we got to like think about it differently come up with different strategies I would personally support anything uh related to what that might look like I'd like to offer that that's we think and Chris if that's okay with you like that should be our presentation in February because we have we are I mean it's extensive the work that we're doing around that

156and I um what well yeah um but I also yeah Eric I like what you brought up about the dopam could you get a as Kate was talking I was thinking about that and I taught a fifth grade class today was the highlight of my uh month and it was I wore TOA because it was the Roman numerals and so we made it the Roman Empire um because why not but my point being I watched the level of sustained attention be the lowest I've ever seen and I'm important in here so usually I can get people's attention and hold it I had to move pretty quick we got there but I was really surprised because I thought I cannot keep up with the fact that you skip every commercial that you can hit dopamine like

157that and get get a positive experience when you flick to the next real I can't be a real that fast while I'm trying to teach you these Roman numerals that were then it was an escape room it was very cool we got there but my point being I was blown away in that moment of like oh my gosh I've got minutes I've got two minutes for something that I really need eight for so I'm going to have them read a little bit of it we're going to break off and I'm going to go around oneon-one and provide support I didn't do that nine years ago as a classroom teacher I could keep them for 15 minutes and so that is a huge component of this the language they're exposed to would blow your mind the

158things that that kids hear on technology and then come back is a huge component of that and then I would say further student children's confidence is highly impacted by what they're observing on the internet when I was in high school that's a tough time for everybody but I just compared myself against the school and the kids that I saw there not the entire world that I could access on my phone and say how come I'm not like her and so it is a major hit when confidence is low you're battling so much more and it just continues to compound so the the solutions We are continuing to evolve what we do to keep up with this world that I mean I know Tik tok's being banned but the rest of it like I I can't

159shut all that down fast enough and so we do have to continue to evolve our practice but bigger class sizes isn't the way to do that I I don't see us accomplishing that with bigger class sizes I see us combating it harder burning people out and then really struggling with even a bigger problem than we have now but I do in February want to present to you our Student Success Council and the work that we do our daily supports that we' have in place for the whole class not just students who are identified like I feel like we could paint that picture for you in a way that would answer a bunch of the questions you have and we haven't presented about that before um but I think it would be helpful because there's a

160lot of initiatives and support going on um to find the success we do find today I just want to say I I I do have questions I I have more at this point I have more opinions than I have questions just to be honest with you I I've done a lot of research into this I've lived it I what I want to see is instead of us thinking about this in a silo that the only things that we can control are within are within the building whether it's a review of our policies around Behavior whatever it might be there's neurodiversity I get it we have more increase of autism we have more increase of people that are on we get we've gotten those presentations that's a factor 100% yeah massive uptick that massive uptick wasn't

161though in 2018 or 19 or it went actually that massive uptick started a lot a lot decade before that what I think is it's more about these things that we were just talking about the things around the dopamine the things around the way the children are being parented today and and that's and we've heard that we've heard testimony public testimony about that so what I would love to hear is how we're going to review those things how we're systematically going to approach that here how we're going to measure it and how we're going to improve prove it and have teachers come to school happy to come to school having far more regulated kids I I just don't believe that if we throw our hands up and don't approach that other aspect the caregiver outside of

162our walls aspect it's it's not going to change I don't know if you're taking I want to clarify that no one's throwing their hands up I and I don't that's important the partnership we have with our families are really strong around most of our kids so like to think like the conversations that I have with families their vulnerability their willingness to sit at the table and talk about like how we can partner to support their kid they'll the number of times they're like I don't even know what else to do can you help me or I'll call and be like I have tried everything in my Arsenal can we partner together can you come in we'll meet with your kid together like there's no one throwing hands up it's what we do all day tirelessly

163we at we've had the child study team in place for seven years the first year I was here um this year we actually went it is also the class study team because the Dynamics and classrooms are so complex that it used to be would' be like oh these are the two or three kids we're going to Target in this classroom but now because like you kind of mentioned like all the kids feel it when things are going on we now have a classroom study team in which we literally sit down and talk about all of the kids in there how can we do this what what can we add what we what what times a day we need be be dividing the room and having so we're in different spaces because we know that they're

164Fe like there's the concerted efforts that are made daily in and out are intentional and I also I also want to add um that I would argue that our teachers are happy to come here this is a joyful place and they're here the people the reason people stay here it is joyful and I shared our admin check-ins with You Chris like we met with 136 individuals every single one of them and resoundingly feeling supported connected feeling proud of the work they're doing and also acknowledging at the same point I am exhausted and I am working harder than I've ever worked but it is worth it so I don't want that message to be lost when we talk about how complicated our job is it is a privilege to serve the children it is also an

165exhausting thing yeah and let me if I can I I don't I let me retract some of that characterization because I I know I'm not saying people are throwing their hands up and not doing anything I know A lot's being done in fact this this these number of hours that are different now a lot of that is because of that it's because of all these meetings um it's it's because of these interventions so I'm I I don't mean to say that and I also don't mean to say that teachers aren't happy being here what I think would be great is if teachers said if I had three more kids in my class big deal I'm not worried about that being a huge disregulation and behavioral problem that's what I mean yes I I do think

166that the teachers are happy I'm going to stop talking because if I if I characterize things wrong it's probably just going to keep going I'm going to have to keep correcting my own statements here but it's the way I feel about it I don't think that anything fundamentally has changed there I think that we have to think outside the box on that in terms of my vote my opinion on it um so that's it and we I know that your hand for a public comment I'm perfectly happy to I want to weigh in that I want wa in please I'm listening very carefully to every what everybody's saying here just a few brief comments I don't think the children in stratum are in this school are any different than the children in any other town

167in the state I've done a little bit of uh research myself you know the interesting thing is as the months go by I'm getting phone calls now too I've gotten I'm and they're coming with increasing frequently frequency the people that call me are typically young mothers with children either at SMS or were at SMS got a call from a from a a teacher at CMS not too long ago I get Anonymous letters there was a post on stratum talks back a week or so ago and all of those and I I didn't plan on talking about these things okay I didn't plan on talking about them um they all paint a picture I don't want to get into this in too much deta detail they all paint a picture for me that tells me and

168one thing I agree with you Kate wholeheartedly like you said like I said I don't think the children are any different in this town I don't think your task your your challenges are any higher harder in this town than they are in any other grammar school in any other Town it is an adult problem 100% yes I'm old school I'm generation older than most of the than many of you here not more than some so I am I take a very traditional view of things if the kids this is my opinion if the kids are coming to school not ready to learn then you need to sit the parents down like their children and say your child is showing up not ready to learn and until he does we don't want him in the school

169don't tell me about the law okay but you need to get that across you need to get that across your child is a problem but you're not getting it across okay because from what I hear the parent teacher conferences on private enough the kids in it too much for the for the uh teachers to really have that conversation with the parents and it's a difficult conversation I'm certain it's a difficult conversation I could go on I could go on my research peer schools peer schools are not necessarily Sea Coast Schools doesn't matter where they are okay I looked at peer schools these are schools that are approximately the same size as SMS I've got it all grafted out I I didn't bring it with me today because I didn't think we' be talking about it

170okay peer schools are approximately the same size the same number of kids same grades in the school it's not perfect nothing's perfect same demographics okay in the town similar demographics not wealthy towns not poor towns and guess what their test scores are Stellar the ones I chose okay I chose them because they were peer schools their test scores are Stellar right through Co they didn't miss a beat they didn't miss a beat so uh it doesn't hold water for me that it's co co co it doesn't hold water for me that our that the students here are any different than any other schools so I ask myself how is it these other schools oh and by the way their class sizes are up in the 19 and 20 range what are they doing what are

171they doing where their their test scores are way up here their class sizes are way up here okay now I don't know if they're spending $30 million on their school I don't know I don't think so because if they've got 500 400 400 500 600 kids they're probably not okay but someone last week said why aren't you looking at schools that have that kind of performance SMS on a recent website is now listed as a mediocre School a b it's a b school all these parents coming up talking about what a great school SMS is I don't see it it was it was okay but I don't see it today okay I want to see the test scores up I would go to those other schools and say what are you doing well your test

172scores are so high and you got 18 or 19 kids in your classes but you can't seem them to do it here don't get me wrong when I look at you Kate I see dedication if I look up the word dedication I see a picture of your face okay and you are putting in a 100 hours a week okay we're probably going to be looking at down looking down at you in your bar Gray Bar in your casket I always say that I say that to my friends who's going to be looking at home right okay you're extremely dedicated but for some reason it's not translating into the test scores okay I'm frustrated I can sense okay about test scores okay all right I just want to make sure that our conversation is budget yeah

173I know it but there but we were but we went on and we started talking about this and I wasn't I wasn't going to talk talk about this why am I talking about test scores because when you want to talk about you want to talk about uh your home values when someone's thinking about moving into town the very first thing they do is look at the school's test scores okay they don't go they don't go doing PE uh peer School analysis like we and the board do okay they don't do the touchy feely thing okay they look at the test scores come for a tour okay yeah maybe they come for a tour and there's a reason test there's a reason we test there's a reason we test there's a reason test scores exist they

174all my my my uh numbers came right off the New Hampshire Department of Education website okay be so people who are not education professionals the lay person can look at a an objective measure of the school and recognize that test scores on everything but they're a huge deal if you want to keep your your home values up and the graph of SMS for the last 10 years looks like a slide it looks like just it's going just off the deep end are you tomorrow night to the Showcase I'm serious no I'm not you can I'm babysitting tomorrow night my wife would have my head friendly yeah right okay Paul how does how does what you're saying translate to your budget vote today I'll tell you how it translates to my budget vote because thank you

175for thank you for pulling me back on okay okay it's not the number of kids in the class we're all talking about whether it's 16 17 18 or 19 or 17 18 19 or 20 that's not the governing factor and I've read the studies too okay the studies say if there are less than 15 kids in a class it has a significant impact on on test scores and if it's more than 22 but overriding the size of the class it is uh the teacher skill um the um ethnicity of the of the uh of the makeup of the kids um it uh it is the U um whether the whether the uh schools are disadvantaged economically or otherwise in economic years lots of factors lots of factors in these in these uh studies affect test

176scores more than the size of the class and the and the end of the study say and it's all kind of squishy anyways all right it's it's nothing's perfect about the way they they do their their take their measurements it's kind of a little bit of a wave of the hand okay that's all I'm saying is I don't think that the primary reason is the test scores honestly I think you've got a lot of kids in in the school oh by the way the other thing I hear is the kids don't get enough homework and they don't get enough tests okay I don't think and I I think again I'm old school right I came from we uh schools where you got homework you got an hour of homework every night your parents were on

177your case if your parents are there okay so you you you need to parent the parents if there are parents PA you're making a huge assumption no okay I'm I'm gonna go back to I'm gonna go back to what I said a few minutes ago how do the other schools do it that's all okay so I'm done thank you very much okay sorry okay I recognize that we have public comment I'm just trying to sort of sum up where the board is at this moment um and then I would love to hear public comment yeah do you want me to did you have something to say sure you know because everybody's kind of gone at this point so I'll try to make this succinct I think um for me like I'm I hear all the

178conversation going on out the public comment and I'm trying to be objective and think about this operating budget um as it stands to for me looking at numbers um and in in conjunction with the the building renovation Bond um I I'm trying to keep in mind that the operating budget is you know it doesn't live in a a bubble um obviously we have the the co-op M Municipal like all of that adds up to the the final tax rate for our taxpayers um and for me this year we we've emphasized the need for this bond for building renovation and that is even at at 12 which has been taken out from a large amount it's a it's still comparable to like our operating budget request and so I feel like with both of those combined

179looking forward Over the Horizon at possible expenses next fisical year like um we talked about the CBA um potential rise in special education cost things that we're we're we're going to be obligated to think about in our budget um I am currently not comfortable with where we're at for a budget this year um and being that we have this is what we have control over in terms of like the final tax rate right now I am a no vote okay um okay I'll I'll um open it up to public comment we can do 10 minutes do I I know somebody in the back has been waiting for a long time is it still three minute per yeah we do three minutes I will be really quick um my name is lindsy says in I'm 16

180Country Farm do we still do that I don't know yeah um I'm very nervous I hate speaking in front of people but when you brought up the issue of neurod divergency and hearing Kate speak about um all the things that she spoke about and then talking about how parents are kind of to blame um I would like to tell you that I have two n Divergent children who these people support every day I have one of them I'm going to talk about just because he is that little boy he is that little boy who has all the Wiggles um but I am a parent who shows up for him every day um things that we have done outside of school we pay every week for him to go to an outdoor school so that he

181can get some of that every year I write to his teacher at the beginning of the year I tell them all of the things that he struggles with I try to communicate I try to do those things he does not watch screens he does not play video games he is not that child who is up at night I feed him a well-balanced breakfast I will not even let him eat the things that come from the school cafeteria most of the time because it's not good for him he does not eat red dye because that increases his activity levels um we have a sensory diet for him at home he has a trampoline we paid for outside OT um these individuals support him every day and he is probably still when she said somebody's going on

182underneath that table that's probably Jack and I know that um but to say that there are parents that are not showing up I know a lot of the parents in the school um I'm sure every school every school district has parents who aren't holding their kids accountable who are not doing things but that is not not always the case um I am probably the most strict on my children so to your point um I have some old school values I do think that they should be polite I hope that they are here most of the time that is feedback that I get um I make sure that when they have homework they do that homework but if you have not experienced having a child like that you don't know what it looks like to sit

183for an hour with them to try to do one sheet of homework that they get one time you just described my grandson Dom okay yeah I'm sure he's I'm sure I'm sure his parents are working very hard and and my wife and I take care of him and the two of us have a difficult and he's four he's uh four years old so you have a two onone ratio to a child so then you're asking them to have less people so that's the exception that we're in our 70s okay but but there are some teachers here who in there 60s it's but it's you're point is I understand it's not a light switch it's not all one way and it's not all the other way but all I'm saying is that there are people who

184are showing up for their children and there's just children who need a little more and I think Kate made a great point about the fact that you know these these children have other things that are happening and whether that is trauma whether that is there's a lot going on in the world my son needs to be barefoot foot nature that's not the environment that we create for our children here they're looking at a screen I wasn't looking at that when I was young but that's how they learn now so there are other things that come out of that there's pros and cons to every piece of the puzzle um but I just think when you're I I mean Sophie I I wanted to raise my hand the first time and Sophie said exactly what I

185was thinking which is the equation isn't adding up when you're saying let's make sure that these kids are less rude that we are doing all these things that parents should be doing and then you're taking support out by Li by making their class sizes bigger it the equation doesn't add up so um I'm a little emotional I'm sorry um but I just to sit here and listen and just know what these people do for my kids every day the teachers in the classroom um the parent professionals are so important my son came home today and he said you know what I made a power for the Showcase he's never been able to do that Mrs F sat with me she helped me he yeah it's huge so I know some people don't have kids in

186the school but um and it's maybe you know you talked about your kids scrolling I I would I would wonder if you have neurodiverse children okay so thank you so much um is there anybody else for probably commented okay all right so um I think what I would say okay I excuse me excuse me you're so I I want our conversation to be very budget related you know one of the things I really stress is is Kate comes in every month and does a presentation I hear us talking in anecdotes I could contribute my own anecdotes I want us to really think in terms of um budget in terms of the role of the board in sort of managing and really keep our conversation there um you know we we were here until after 10:30

187last last Wednesday and I'm happy for us to do that but I want us to be really very centered in our and focused in our conversation and also we're going to keep it to three minutes there's no responding to each other's comments we we are interested in hearing your public comment but we're not necessarily going to respond um and I would like the board and and audience to really keep up um budget based all right so who um if you've signed up please come up to the front microphone yeah and just please state your name and address like oh sorry hi I'm Tori Bell um I'm at 15 Brin farm and I just had one brief comment because I've heard some back and forth about um the early early retirement offering for teachers um and

188some comment to the benefit of of retiring out people with higher salaries and bringing on less experienced teachers with at a lower salary point I can speak anecdotally about my experience as a parent I can also speak to my experience as an employer for over 20 years as someone who has worked in the private sector and what I can say is that experience does in fact make a very big difference so you're not seeing a onetoone replacement you retire a heavier salary some organizations do have to make those very difficult decisions and there's been plenty of studies I've done so in my professional life to look at the longtail effect on an organization when they let go their tene unexperienced professionals and replace them with people with very little experience at a law firm you

189wouldn't put a first year associate on your most high profile client likewise here at SMS so I ask the board to please consider when you're looking at the differentials of rolling off experienced teachers it is not an equal replacement when you're replacing with a less experienced educator that's thank you very much um Glenn evening Glenn was 6 Farm Road um I don't have my prepared two page notes tonight or whatever um just a couple of comments and I do want to try to keep this uh budget oriented um Kate appreciate the information you gave um however I kind of question that it's getting dropped tonight as opposed to you just thought that you were preparing that tonight and nobody actually gets through go through the figures uh on the eve of a vote so I

190don't quite appreciate that um but I question some of them without being able to study it that when you add three or four students to a classroom I would think three of those students are average or above and maybe one is troubled and so for one student per classroom to add 300 however many hours you say to a year or an 8 hour day to a um a student's attention doesn't seem to quite make sense Chris I welcome the invitation to have coffee with you and talk about some things budget oriented last week you talked about um how our percentage is the second lowest and our class size is the largest or whatever um it seemed a little bit biased to me because I think if you looked at probably the number dollar amount maybe

191we would a largest are close to the top but we also know there things such as economies of scale it's not a linear approach that the more students you have that the cost goes up linearly so it would have been nice to have a little bit more conversation that yes percentage wise the 2.73 requ was second lowest in the SIU but we the largest size there also things as economy to scale it seemed like you were trying to just toss that out there and not toss out all the facts the other thing that was talked about two not quite with the budget but in regards to the test scores which I didn't appreciate the Whitney that got up the teacher 17 years and spoke talking about the zero test scores I think our principal our

192vice principal even you Chris probably knew that that was not a correct statement that scores do not go into zero I'd appreciate when the expertise is here that you correct some of those things on the spot as opposed to the audience which was large that night thinking something is true when it's not true because our test scores when a teach a student is it out that enter zero is not entered into the state database at all and that is the truth thank you yeah just that's federally okay just two points um we we have actually I think this is our fourth meeting talking about the budget so we've been talking about it extensively for for a few months and then secondly I think just before you came in we were reviewing the minutes and we

193were talking about how we're going to have that at a future meeting to talk about the participation in test scores affecting final results so appreciate you bringing that up but in the meantime when the expertise is here and people are watching it on YouTube that can come here a large audience here that walks away that say like oh that's why our test sour is so low because parents are opting students out and zeros go in that is untrue and she didn't even if it were true she didn't even say how many of our students are opting out or where do we lie in regards to the average of the rest of the state yeah thank you thank you I appreciate you saying that um this is not a back and forth this is really us

194hearing public comment um but it gives us ideas for future meetings and clarifications uh Chris uh Chris Rema e aome way um I'll keep this pretty short um I fully support this budget as is I agree it feels to be honest pretty light just given the cost of everything going up um I think the two things I'll say is one we moved here we'll call it six years ago I think now for the schools um didn't look at test scores I still don't know how to look those up um we did it by reputation of the school I still think it has a wonderful reputation uh we had one child who is in middle school now had a great experience even through covid and everything and her youngest is now first grade and having a

195wonderful experience um and the second thing I'll say is I know there's all comment about how do we improve test scores concerns and all these you know I'll call them problems I don't know if they really are I'll defer to the experts on that I don't think cutting costs is the way to solve those if there are problems so like just to consider that thank you thank you all right thank you very much all right I'd love to hear from the board um if there's a motion if there's some more conversation how do you want to move this FL could I just I just I feel like I have to just address one thing because I just don't want what I said to be taken out of context because it like sometimes I'll let things

196go but I want to say this when I when I'm speaking about somebody who's disregulated I recognize that there are differences between people who are neur neurod Divergent people who qualify for additional assessments and assistance under IEPs and 504s that's that's not the category of of student that I was talking about and I know that parents have a lot to deal with when it comes to that um that is far beyond what parents who do not have those circumstances have to deal with and uh so my comment should be taken in context the category of students that do not qualify for IEPs 5 4S and I thought I made that clear but if I didn't I want to I want to make that abundantly emphasized thank you yeah I'd like to make a motion to

197accept the budget as is as proposed all right do I have a second we can have discussion there is a second I'll second it um and then discussion is there any discussion on it I think I just make one comment relative to a lack of funding so why I ask what we've been doing for the past three years on those um I think that those numbers hopefully were reflected on the record and they speak for themselves that in fact over the past three years we've had some uh I think fairly healthy budgets uh that have been provided and um we also are still I believe 15% as of the latest State scores or state not numbers were about 15% higher than the New Hampshire average on a per student basis so I just want to

198make that that single point I guess to me cutting the budget at this point it feels almost like a punishment like we're punishing um for test scores or for some of the behavior we hear from our kids when they come home at the end of the day and I think that having that conversation at this time feels unfair to me and I you know I mean Eric and I have talked anecdotally about you know about things we hear from our kids in our classrooms I'm 100% on board with what you're saying it also very much frustrates me um but I don't think this budget conversation is when we when we have it when we lump all of the stuff on when I made that point about these monthly sessions I think what they do is

199convince me that Administration is thinking through these issues and planning for them um even if as parents I don't always see the results I want I I I defer and I respect what's happening administratively um and and to cut the budget so much right now I mean my my kids are going to be out of SMS very soon right I think about you and you and you guys were cutting the budget you're not going to replace that money next year or the year after when your kids are here right and and I worry that this trend of just cutting cutting it's going to result in in some unfair results that will not affect my kids but will affect yours that excuse me that's not that's not necessarily true um I just want to defer to

200the administration and and to what we're hearing I'm talking about no I'm just talking about if you cut it you you're not going to put it back next year that's not true at all if enrollment goes up sure as heck would put it back we can make that decision any time that's all I mean to say do you think yeah if enrollment goes up and it's Justified you hire a teacher back back you hire a teacher if I if I could just respond to that too because we've been at this for a little while I I don't uh first of all I do not intend this as a punishment this is not any kind of vindictiveness the way the way this started for me was I asked for a staffing plan relative to what I

201saw as a nontransient I keep saying this I'm going to keep saying it a non-transient decline in enrollment could be wrong could change it's been going down what I want to do is I wanted to be able to rightsize it to and I say rightsize it again I'm sure those those world will get picked apart to something that we've seen actually work in the past and so what I when that was proposed the reason that test scores and behaviors and all these other things have been brought up and so much feedback which is great feedback is because the implications of doing that necessitated that conversation so I didn't go after it saying we got behavior problems we got low test scores let's punish these people what I'm saying is I think we have a non-transient

202enrollment issue and I think we should align the class sizes to that why should we do that now because we we incentivized retirement we have a great opportunity to do that and not have to if the enrollment declines face pressure from our own decision-making or others from the town who say why haven't you looked at that why have you why have you not taken advantage of the time to do that and why will you now potentially have to use the only blunt force instrument that we would have which would be a riff which would be getting rid of teachers who were last in first out based on at least this collective bargaining agreement I don't like that I don't want to do it I don't want to get rid of teachers right now we have

203the opportunity to do that without that even being a a question and I think maybe to Paul's point I'd like to say yes we could change that as well at any time if enrollment changes so not trying to com in fact you never heard test scores come out of my mouth tonight I don't think not trying to complate test scores not trying to complate Performance not trying to conflate any of those things not Behavior none of it this all started with simply trying to align to the enrollment um that we're seeing that's it but yeah I guess what we're hearing is that the maybe sorry trying to getting tired um that students are different now so to say like oh we can just go back to what it was working in the past the the

204conditions are different now than they were in the past so to me that's that's not a that's not a fair statement if students are different then you can't say oh it worked then so it should work now when we're hearing that clearly it's not the same so why would like that does because I'm addressing what Jen said specifically which is why are we I I feel like this is that she wants to make sure that this is not coming from a place of punishment because of other issues it's not it's not a punishment for other issues and it's not a conflict of other issues with what my I'm just speaking individually as my vote was and the way that I was looking at this these other issues have been brought up and I think they

205are extremely important and they still need to be addressed I do too I just don't think that making the budget smaller is going to address those issues whatsoever I think they're going to exacerbate them and if we're trying to support the school to get to a place where maybe we can right siiz classrooms let's do that but let's not also in my my opinion say you should reduce classes CL reduce the number of classes increase class sizes at the same time also by the way we don't even have the position to do that like us on the board that's not our role we can't tell them what to do with how like how to do that so I don't think that that's our role either but if us as a board we're saying like hey

206you know disregulation is important to us scores are important to us being fiscally responsible is important to us I think we do all of those things by passing this budget and then working on those things that we need to work on not by reducing the budget and saying oh by the way you're not performing in the way that we like like that that doesn't sit right with me at all does anyone have any other proposal I have made a proposal for accepting the budget as is any other proposals I think it's a vote all right are we ready to vote all right so voting on the motion of accepting the budget as is all in favor I all opposed no all right um so the budget fails as proposed yeah I mean I can make

207a motion for a revised budget and that number being um I think we had talked about it being 111 based on some of the conversations that we had around where a perceived cut would come from so I would propose a budget of I believe it's 15, 52637 ises that math sound right can I ask a question clarifying question Eric when you're proposing that number is that because you're hoping that that will result in the class sizes that you want or is it because you're trying to be fiscally responsible like what is the I guess what is the motivation for that reduction because we don't have control over there's a motion on the table why don't we discuss that okay I just want to make sure that my numbers are the that's correct thank you 374

208right 15 15 526 374 yeah 15 526 375 374 374 did you make a motion I made a motion second all right discussion all right Sophie you would like for me to yeah can you expand on what yeah what's the motivation behind that number so my intention around this budget though I have no control over how it will be administered clearly we discussed that was to change the class sizes for fourth and fifth grade to be within the bounds that I've described when I had heard previously that to do that the budget would necessarily need to change by a certain amount that was projected if we were not to rehire one of those teachers as I had stated previously Chris I think told me that it would necessarily if we went to a number that

209was lower it would necessarily affect the the probably the class instruction now you guys might find numbers other other places I don't know but that was the intention so the intention is yes to change the class sizes for fourth and fifth grade but but why I mean if you say you car about disregulation and you care about test scores how will increasing the number of students per class get you those things right I Sophie I feel like I've I've I've I've said my piece on it um I am happy to you know continue this conversation um but for and I don't know how I can do it any more concisely than I have or restate the points that I feel are the most important so I I without rehashing and saying the same things that

210I've said before I I don't know how to how to satisfy that that that question I apologize and I get a sense the budget is so tight really that's the only place it could come from yeah so the comment I made is if we made further reductions it would it would result in programming and prog would would be a teacher instruction or staff right that was the comment that I made yeah can we offer a comment the finance portion I think I think at this point we're just gonna have a vote so there is a motion there's a second is there any more discussion is anybody doing that bring us percentage sorry percentage wise in terms of an increase what is it 2.0 it's 2.0 flat all right any more discussion yeah I want to

211make a comment uh my primary goal was to get uh the budget to 2% uh my primary goal is to see the bond pass um I keep my ear to the ground uh a lot of people I talk to a lot of people a lot of people talk to me and uh I think we needed to be there I've I said this before I thought it needed to be a zero increase okay it it's not but I want the bond to pass and there's a there is a percentage of the people in town that are going to be very very concerned about the budget and the bond so that was my primary goal was 2% or less um yeah I'll just speak and say that um aligns more with where I was thinking again based

212on the bond and everything um making certain taxpayers in this town more comfortable uh approving both um I think we heard from a lot of folks who wanted a zero they didn't want any kind of increase on the operating budget um which I I don't um agree with um but I think this brings me closer to the Comfort level that I want so I would approve I would vote Yes on that I mean I I guess I just thought I saw a packed room last week right of people supporting the budget not every proposed it was not all teates there's plenty of people speaking I'm sorry but that's not true not true so I'm frustrated that we can't have public comment about all right um so at this point uh I think there's motion on

213the table um so all in favor of reducing the budget Michelle can you just give us that number again so with a motion to reduce the budget by $111,000 even that would bring your your proposed budget to 15 million 526 374 is that I think that's the motion on the table is to pass a budget of 15, 526 yeah all right all in favor say I all opposed I all right so the reduced budget passes 32 z uh anything else on the agenda don't think so all right do I have a motion to adjourn uh move I want to before we adjourn I I would like to make a comment I want to address the fact please okay yeah Mike uh you have been a selectman in town for nine years okay weed the meeting

214stop we made a motion to oh we didn't vote on it though we didn't vot have to vote on motion on the table we add something to the agenda for next time perhaps you share will the fact be here next next time I will be here I'm the school district

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.