001all right everyone I think we're going to call ourselves to order um I want to thank you everyone so much for coming we're going to start with the Pledge of Allegiance everybody could join I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all all right it's it's really wonderful to have everyone here I'm I'm so glad you guys all came and I've been really enjoying um hearing all the chatter this week about the budget I think it's really um great that everybody's here to learn about it so um well I'm going to just start by introducing the meeting talking about what we're going to do today um and then we'll move on from there so
002um I just wanted to say before we start I just wanted to recognize sort of my fellow board members the fa who's been looking at the budget you know um all these guys up here are volunteers the fac are volunteers and you know I know that they're all not doing things so they can be here tonight and I just want to say thank you so much and you know I really appreciate the efforts um everyone has put in I also just wanted to say thank you to the administrators even though they are not volunteers um working on the budget is is a challenge and so I want to especially thank them for all the questions and answers they've been doing and um you know for their time here so thank you um so I also
003wanted to say a quick plug that um we'll be looking for a new board member um in March they'll be voting so if any of you are interested in joining us up here we would love it and um the voting will be in March for that so um just putting a little plugin for a we need a new board member okay so tonight is a public hearing which means it is really a chance for the board to hear from the town about how they feel about um the things that we'll be voting on in March so we're going to talk about the budget um and we're going to have a short presentation about the budget then we're going to talk a little bit about the building and what's going on with the bond for the
004building and um Paul will talk a little bit about that we have done Lots presentations on the building project and you can see those on our website um and so and then also we will be going out to the community for the next month and talking about that building project so we're going to talk about the budget we're going to talk about the building and then we invite all of you to um make comments and these will be three minutes long everybody who wants to talk uh can talk there's a signup sheet right here next to the Yes No Maybe book um and we invite you all to sign in and um and then we'll go through the list and let everybody comment on both the budget and the building project next week we'll be
005meeting uh again on Wednesday and that time we'll be hearing from the faac and the faac will be offering comments and questions on the budget and ultimately um endorsing or not endorsing the budget um and that will also be an opportunity for the board to vote on the budget so as of this point we are still just in fact finding information gathering mode eager to hear from you about how you feel about the budget uh as I said in the next month you'll hear us um we're going to be at various events around town both zoom and in person at school events really talking about the building and really trying to spread information answer questions about the bond that will happen in March and then finally on March 4th that is when you guys come
006to the meeting and vote on the budget and so that's a really important time for all of you to to show up make sure you get your neighbors and come join us on March 4th to ultimately vote for the budget anything I'm forgetting I don't think so just want to reiterate that um the budget's still under consideration the process is that we hear from the town we've heard a lot from the town hear from the fact hear more from the town today and then we'll finalize our recommendation as a board next week or I'm sorry yes next week on the 15th another a good opportunity to uh come and listen and then just as a uh housekeeping item we're going to try to really stick to the three minutes um in terms of public comment
007just because we have a lot of people who want to offer uh some thoughts and if you can just say state your name your address and um I'll keep a timer and just one reminder is it's not really question and answer feel free any question and answer you can direct it to the board members after the meeting via email anytime we really try to make ourselves available to answer questions um but really it's more about statements at this point so I just wanted to offer that yeah perfect thank you um okay so before we go to the presentation I wanted to just um make um if the enter if the board would entertain a motion to allow teachers um is that how I would phrase it to allow teachers to speak um so teachers from
008stratum Memorial um to speak here tonight normally as you guys probably know it is just stratum residents and that's why we asked your address on the signin sheet um but we were going to um I wanted to propose a motion to allow teachers um do I have um would anybody like to move I'll I can move okay thanks Sophie um do I have a second second thanks Paul any discussion on that hey hi all right um can we have a vote then all in favor of allowing teachers to speak tonight I I okay so that's 500 Z all right so we'll just get that business out of the way and now um I'd like to invite Kate to talk about the budget um there have been previous meetings where Kate has presented on the budget
009so just encourage you guys to go back and look at some of those meetings but I did ask her to just um talk a little bit about the process and what went into the budget that here take this one thanks um first of all good night uh good evening everybody and good night I would like to be clearly going to sleep already um but thank you guys for coming it's really nice to see everybody here to learn more about um the the proposed budget as it stands as of today and just to radiate what Jennifer said this will still be a continuing and evolving um document I will add this is my um 7th year here um and the the thoughtfulness that has gone into uh the budget um this year has been really incredible
010to see and the conversation um and dialogue we've been having has been um really rich and informative Paul and I had a conversation the other day and kind of looked at each other at the end of the conversation like our heads were like going to explode um but in a really positive way because I think we're growing and learning as we do that um so on the public hearing we um talk very briefly um really if you're thinking like a 30,000 foot view at the budget because over the past two and a half months we've been talking at a much more granular level um so the on the slide you'll see that the fy2 um approved budget after the adjust that were made at the district meeting last year was 15, 221 286 um after
011some close analysis as I mentioned as it stands today um The Proposal is 45 m637 374 um on that for your your right side you will see that's a change of $416,000 um and that's 2.73% over last year this um document is put together um by our chief financial ad adviser um and their assistant at central office and it really takes the large function codes which are sort of like the large areas within an operating budget and um puts those items that go together um into one group and so you'll see those on your left-hand column again you'll see what they were in fy2 the change and what the percentage is over the previous year or less than in some of these areas um and this all of this documentation is available online um and
012has been as we've been working through this process this is a really helpful um illustration that represents sort of the parts of the budget that the board has control over or really doesn't have control over um and when I say control they have control over the entire thing but there are many parts of the budget as you can see that are contractual or things that you really we're not going to be able to um not fuel the building where you know we have to purchase oil things of that nature so there's some things that you're they're going to support and then there's like little bit of wiggle room around some things that we can consumables and things like that and again this is also available one of the important things that we try to share
013at the public um hearing is sort of the driving factors the things that really motivated the budget um and this year I put a caveat at the top that I think is really important um because I don't want this to be lost in this process every year when the board is building a budget and the financial advisory committee partners with us um and we spend hours going through this budget um there are things that are like the underpinnings or the underlying things that we always think about um and it's not we don't um we can't just think about the following year there are implications for the year after that and the year after that and the year after that um and so we're often thinking about like what's something that we can do this year
014or can't do this year because we know what's coming in a year or two um and so I think it's really important when you think of the area in which we are um you're seeing an increase for the FY 26 we are then being incredibly financially um fiscally responsible in other lines knowing that these are the priorities this year um and it's kind of like the trade-off that you pay like what's the most important priority and then what's something that might be able to wait without impacting the educational experience of our students so um the first thing you'll see on here is special education um this is a national Trend this is not a stratum concern there are a myriad of factors that play into this and later tonight if if you do stay for
015the duration of the meeting our director of special education is actually going to talk to specifics within special education um nationally it's an increase in the number of students it's an increase in the lack of resources and so people have more control over how much they want to charge um there's a whole slew of factors that are contributing to that um then curriculum resources um this came from multiple lines throughout the um throughout the budget but it is an increase of $3,799 from fiscal year 25 um as a school we have resources that we need we have a mathematics program we have a handwriting program so there's consumables um and there curriculum materials um decodables as we learn more about the science of reading that we're purchasing books um to ensure that we can meet
016kids where they're at so that's the increase within sort of that curriculum broader curriculum professional development um I think kind of aligns perfectly with the line before as we grow and learn and as research um changes and evolves and we learn more it is imperative that we don't just bring the resources in but we train the staff to use them properly um and that we continue to grow our own understanding of best practice Child Development so that we can Implement those Resources with Fidelity um in the benefit of our students and then the last item on here is we um which is this is I actually love this line and I'm glad to see it go up um we have more students that um English is not their native language and that is enriching to
017this community on so many levels and so when I see something like that go up that feels really good to me it feels good that our students are going to be um sharing their school experience with people that have had experiences that are very different and we can learn and grow together um so for me these are sort of like celebrations of things that we're able to accomplish as a school but they are the driving factors that contributed to the FY 26 budget as it is proposed today so as I said that's a really like 30,000 foot view of the budget um you have access to the granular stuff um at any time and of course the board can answer questions if you have questions about that but we wanted to sort of give you
018the things that we were you know at the Forefront of our consideration for the FY 26 budget thanks very much um Kate I'm wondering could you just uh last last board meeting somebody had asked about the um mtss coordinator and um you know obviously we've had a presentation and we've heard so much about it again 30,000 foot view could you just talk about that new position and maybe how it's helped out since um is that putting you on the spot too much no uh um can you guys hear me okay good um no I'm happy to talk about it and if you stay for the presentation tonight we're doing our data review from last spring and the fall and we're going to go extensively into the role that that has played um one of the
019things that we um we are a very large Elementary School for New Hampshire standards right and we with the number of students we have and the Educational Systems and program that we had have been building um it is multifaceted and it was imperative to us as a system to have the ability to ensure that we had um all of that in a cohesive manner so we um we have intervention services we have enhancement services we have Universal instruction we have assessment and we have students with 504 plans we have students with IEPs um we have a child study team so we have um incredible expertise in this building um and we it was really important to streamline that have someone that could oversee that as an umbrella to ensure that each of our systems supported
020one another and only enhanced each other versus sort of like arrows going in different directions and not bringing them all together so that's a huge part of what um Mrs Martin has done this year first year the other piece I would add is that um we understood that we needed um more data at a more granular level on our students in order to um pinpoint and personalize the instruction in a way that we had been trying to do but have sort of been really struggling to find the perfect match um and that includes quality screeners that includes time to analyze that data um and meet as teams and um I think we mentioned last year it's thousands of points of data um and what Miss Martin is able to do is to collect all of
021that data analyze that data and prepare it in a cohesive way that allows us to see each of our students in a much more holistic way um and then she's able to collaborate with the various teams in our building to ensure that this all the teams are getting the same message and again all the work is then headed in the same direction so those are I would say like the two really big important parts um but later in the evening we'll get into more detail yeah thank you so much all right that's great thank you so much all right moving on to the building um Paul would you like to talk a few minutes I'll say a few words on it okay so there is no update uh in terms of actual work done uh
022on the subcommittee from the last time we met so there's there's nothing to say there but for those of you who may not be aware we had um a little over a year ago we were looking at uh a rather extensive renovation expansion of uh of the building and it was it was getting expensive it was in the 46 to 50 million range um we formed a large uh building subcommittee that consisted of uh myself and Sophie and assistant superintendent uh andris Kate and several members of the town from the construction industry and together we chose uh Kino construction out of Portsmith um to do the first phase the first phase was the scope of work in budgeting and over the course of about uh two and a half or three months we uh condensed
023what the building needs down to the basics and we have a bond um I think we're going to get a bond request or go to a vote for about $12 million so it's considerably paired down and that includes um a hefty contingency for things that we might have overlooked or didn't could didn't discover um and it also includes um you know all the prerequisite insurances and uh even a an owner's representative someone who would be uh responsible directly to the board looking out for our own best interests even though Kino construction is really that type of firm um they've been fabulous to work with access to them has been complete 100% um I can raise the uh the president of the company or our um preconstruction manager at any time of the day or night
024in fact I talked to the preconstruction manager at length just today weekends they're terrific they're terrific that way and I want to point out that the preconstruction manager is a stratum resident and had a child go through SMS so uh I think these things are all very important what it consists of is the building is about 35 years old and the uh infrastructure systems are at end of life one of the three boilers has already failed to the extent that it cannot be repaired fortunately it only takes one boiler to run the school generally um and maybe two on uh severe days and you switch back and forth so we're not in an emergency situation right now but they're 35 years old so the boilers need to be replaced the air Handling Systems and the
025uh the areas of the building that are air conditioned they are at end of life so that they need to be replaced um I discovered that the building is not completely um sprinkled to me um I think um safety is a number one priority so the entire building will be sprinkled in the event of a fire uh we're going to add four classrooms the two temporary classrooms that were supposed to be I don't know 2-year classrooms and have been in use for 8 years eight years or something there were five and they've been in use for 18 huh yeah a long time okay those so those classrooms uh they've been pumping uh pumping the chest on those classrooms for a while now those go away and the and the children that are in those classrooms
026are brought back to be inclusive in the school so we add four classrooms um the administrative offices will uh be redesigned to uh for better functionality and to improve secure for people who are accessing the building to begin with so for example today people who come in to visit visitors come in and they're already in the building by the time they're it's ascertained if who they are no longer okay all that will be done before they have access to the building so those are the main things we'll also add air conditioning to the second floor classrooms in a in a uh in a costeffective manner you know you learn as you go there's a lot of different ways to add air conditioning to a building uh this is a very costeffective way and it will
027help for the uh you know the shoulder months of September or so and uh in May and June because those rooms get very very warm at the moment we are also going to uh put on a new roof at at the time we do that we will add insulation to the roof okay and all of the things that we're doing will all be done in you know uh uh if energ with Energy Efficiency in mind all right we're going to put going to change all the incandescent lights to LED not only because it's energy efficient but because there are still rebates to be had by the state which are going away um I think in 20 27 or soon so we want to take advantage of those things so the boilers are more energy efficient
028the lights will be more energy efficient uh the roof will have more insulation on it uh the sofs outside will be revamped and they will be reinsulated because we're leaking uh energy through the sofits um that you're paying for you know when you're when you uh when you burn oil and by the way we're changing from oil to gas okay so the Energy Efficiency let's say it's a lot cleaner okay and then the other thing that I can think of off the top of my head is we are going to increase the size of the cafeteria by about 20% okay and what that'll do is it will allow the school instead of having three separate lunches go down to two I think right two lunches okay cafeteria is used for more than just uh lunches
029it's uh for other events and I think they use it on occasion for U for gym to for to as an adjunct to gym classes and so on physical education so uh those those are the big hitters um and uh yeah um it's it's going to it'll take the school into another 35 years of use thank you so much Paul Sophie anything to add um sure I would just add a little note about matriculation that's been a question um from the public and last year we did have an enrollment study and it showed that in five different scenarios um enrollment either stayed steady or increased so um in terms of enrollment that's those are the numbers that we're working with um and additionally we have seen and heard from um Educators that student needs have
030changed dramatically especially since cell phones have become you know just really really every everyone has one in their pocket and that's changed students and how they learn um and additionally students um s schools have to provide services for students that they didn't used to have to provide like 30 years ago so um Educators now and our school needs to provide more academic and learning space than we'd used to um especially if we will be having more students in the future um and additionally we will be having number of presentations six different presentations from now until the March vote I'm going to be publishing that very soon and I'll talk about it later in um the agenda but so be on a lookout for attending one of those two will be online all at different times
031of the week and days of the week so hopefully you can come to one of those and reiterating please show up March 4th at 6m to vote yeah thank you so much and thanks to both of you for all that work on that karino and um Paul and Sophie gave uh awesome um presentation at our last meeting with a whole slideshow and that's available um on the website it's also hyperlinked um in our minutes that we're going to approve later on so I definitely encourage you guys to take a look at that presentation it's pretty pretty impressive um so before we move to public comment I just wanted to talk briefly about the um maintenance trust funds just so that we kind of everything that we'll be looking at on March 4th so um Chris
032could could could you talk a little bit about those uh the trust funds not the maintenance but yep so stratum Memorial School has three trust funds that we that you've established one last year which is a technology trust fund the technology trust fund has $10,000 in it and the reason we we had um established that last year is that about every five years we need to do the switching do the cabling do any of the um the cabling you would see to help out with our with our internet and our technology structure by creating this trust fund we would not be having to take it out of the budget so we're we're saving for year after year and then that fifth year we'd have $50,000 to be able to do that that project without any
033cost to our budget the other two um trust funds that we have is our special education trust fund currently we have $ 56,7 right now that that is about an area that we are comfortable with and we would support two students out of district for about one year so when we're making recommendations that that's a healthy fund but if we had two students that moov in needed to be out of district and had significant needs that would cover the cost for two students for one in one year then you'd have to budget for it the last trust fund that we have is our building repairs and maintenance trust fund that's been building U for things that that would would occur there hasn't been as much because we've been talking about the building project for about
034eight years now um really getting to to the place where we can have but that is has a balance of $228,200 th000 with the building project the building project will will address a number of of major issues with the systems that Paul addressed and that the subcommittee looked at but there'd be other things that we didn't put into that that building project that this trust fund could could uh then um pay for from year after year so again that that's where our trust friends are that was the recommendations that we talked about last year and where they're at and these will be things that we will discuss further in our our meeting and bring up next meeting with the fact as well thank you thank can I just add on to that please you know
035one of the things that uh has been in the back of my mind is um you know this Bond it doesn't get you a new school right it it repairs and replaces things that in the old school we're going to need Windows in this school within a few years a few is TBD okay and we got pricing on them and to do the whole school at once is about a half a million dollars Okay so we've had a number of discussions on this I think Chris had a good idea let's do them a little at a time okay but you know we need to budget for windows at some point you know right now we've had a few seals fail but you know they're wooden frame windows they're good windows they're Anderson Windows but they're
036going to start rotting they are starting to rot so we need to look at that so just keep that in mind all right anything else questions or comments by the board before public comment okay and just as a reminder um we welcome everyone to speak during public comment everybody has three minutes you cannot seed your time to your neighbor um those those three minutes belong to you also it is not a question and answer period so it's for us to hear from you not necessarily for us to respond although I will be making notes and you know and and um seeking to get responses this week but it's not a on the spot sort of Q&A session um all right I'm G to grab the sign and Sheet remind people of the sign and Sheet
037who late yeah yeah so if anybody walked in um after the uh initial overview we're going to do public comment there's a sign on sheet um right where Chris is and uh and we invite you to come to the mic say your name um and your address please for our minutes so we'll just go in order if you want to skip just let me know okay um looks like we're starting with uh Elizabeth laass all right can I everyone hear me okay so Elizabeth laass 49 Union Road most people here know me better as nurse Lily the school nurse um for students we have now the students I've have had in the past and students that I will have in the future I am here to speak as a mom a staff member and a
038member of the community I am here to support a budget that allows us to put not ourselves not our staff but the students first in all the decisions that we make first I do want to talk about reducing staff and the impact that would have on the students here at SMS when we look at a budget that reduces staff we are looking at a budget that is taking away from the individual attention students are receiving this is essential for academic success especially as we are seeing more children that are requiring targeted instruction this could be for gifted education remedial support or specific social emotional learning needs with a reduction in staff there will be less availability to provide the personalized guidance necessary for each child to thrive at SMS as a parent of two kids
039that came through SMS I saw firsthand how my children were able to receive the individualized attention they needed when they attended this school in our school today students are facing more complex challenges than they did even 5 years ago we all need to help support a budget that supports the everchanging needs of the students we have here ER after year second I would like to talk about how a strong budget will help create well-prepared students which in the end will lead to a stronger Community my children and many others were able to excel because they were supported by an education system that prioritized small class sizes and a well-funded curriculum if we cut funding now and increase class sizes we risk diminishing the quality of Education which has a ripple effect on the community a
040reduction in the quality of Education will affect not just students today but also the town's economic future and the overall well-being I personally have seen the long-term benefits of a strong education system in this town my children were prepared academically and socially for their next steps and that Foundation has paid off in their personal and their educational lives if we start cutting funding now we risk undermining that future for our kids and for our town lastly I want to close by urging the town of stratum to consider the long-term implications to our students of SMS on the decisions that we are making on this budget investing in our schools is not a luxury but a necessity we should be proud as a town for supporting a school that focuses on students first we should be
041proud that we have invested in quality staff that goes above and beyond to ensure that each student is being met where they are at we should be proud that staff want to be here day after day and for years to come let us all work together to support a budget that will adequately support our school so that every child in stratum has the opportunity to thrive and reach their full potential thank you thank you so much really appreciate that um Kristen [Applause] Burke I appreciate the camaraderie of the applauding that's nice but we're just just going to probably skip that and try to just move move fast although nurse lyly great job yeah okay I won't expect any um my name is Christen Burke I live at 20 Hickory Pond Lane um I would like
042to express my strong support for the proposed budget of the upcoming fiscal year and to urge the board to approve it in full as a community member and invested stakeholder in the success of our school system I firmly believe that investing in our school is not just an investment in education but also an overall prosperity of our community research consistently shows that well-funded high- performing schools have a direct and positive impact on the property values families actively seek out neighborhoods with reputable schools driving demand and increasing home prices according to the National Bureau of economic research a five% increase in test scores can translate to 2 and a half% increase in home values this relationship highlights the tangible economic benefits that stem from supporting robust commun uh educational initiatives I will say that at some
043point we're all going to sell our home homes we wanted to sell for more and and I think that's you know the point there but moreover the quality schools contribute to a safer neighborhoods lower crime rates and more engaged Community all of which are factor in the further enhance property values and attract new residents when schools Thrive and the entire Community experience growth stability and sense of Pride I would like to address those who I know are going to be opposing um the budget I will say that um you all have built a wonderful community chances are if you're opposing the budget that you likely have been in stratum for a long time you've seen property values increase along with taxes don't cut the school down now don't cut the community down now now is
044the time that we need to be continuing to build up thank you so much thank you kitty Young uh Katie young 150 Bunker Hill Avenue um hello as I said my name is Katie young I am a taxpayer living in stratum for over 10 years and full disclosure also a teacher at SMS currently in third grade I feel especially lucky to teach here as I have a child who also attends this is my 17th year of teaching not to date myself um but when I made this difficult decision to seek a new opportunity here I wanted to make sure that SMS truly aligned with my beliefs and values I want to invest my time and energy directly into my local school Community I felt that there was a supportive larger Community around SMS that valued
045and respected Educators as well as a whole child approach to help develop a curiosity and love of learning teaching at the elementary level is demanding requiring a deep expertise in many subjects as well as the ability to manage diverse learning styles adapt in the moment to individual academic and emotional needs and create a supportive engaging environment the state average is 16.8 students per classroom and SMS currently aligns with that average smaller class sizes can significantly alleviate these demands by allowing teachers to dedicate time and attention to each individual our ability to assess progress ongoingly provide personalized feedback and create meaningful connections all depend on this maintaining current class sizes encourages greater participation stronger relationships and enhances learning outcomes helping Educators address specific academic or emotional needs that will become overlooked in a larger class if
046we want to continue to personalize learning and provide students with Rich opportunities we should uphold our current class sizes student learning has become more complex over the past several years and we continue on that Trend our current class size allows for a thoughtful placement process to occur currently students are placed in classrooms that aim to honor each individual's Learning Journey including social and academic strengths and goals PE Dynamics and unique learning styles I fear increasing class sizes will hinder an already complex placement process the loss of resources and educator expertise will inevitably add more to classroom teachers overflowing plates I strong believe it will also have a negative impact on morale and the strong collaborative culture that directly benefits students staff morale is directly correlated to being adequately supported so that we can also best
047support the learning of every one of our students lastly to the best of my knowledge the latest enrollment study points to increased enrollment over the next few years as well as upcoming housing developments within town I am hoping the decisions made keep this in mind as well I share this as a parent whose child will be affected by this decision these decisions and an educator who knows how this will impact our ability to support all students and carry out the dayto DAT demands thank you for your time and for your service to our school Community thank you so much Kathleen peek Kathleen peek 13 Bittersweet Lane um I am a parent to two Elementary School teachers and I have also been volunteering for the financial advisement committee for the um SMS School Board um I
048don't have anything prepared and I've been up since 4:00 a.m. for work so forgive me if I ramble a little bit but I really want to encourage the board to not attempt to cut the budget anymore and I'm not speaking as a fact member but as a parent um after looking at numbers on the department of education's website we already have the larger classes in many of the surrounding towns we already have a bigger school um and I fear that cutting the budget and making class classes sizes bigger will be detrimental to our students um thank you thank you so much uh Pat bromy Uh P Bry 9 to Pines Drive I'm also a fact member but I'm here speaking for myself not for the what I'm going to say doesn't reflect the uh total
049opinion of the uh of the finance committee um I I I put in front of everyone um something that I've mailed out to everybody already um let me speak to and some some of my remarks what's not been said is that we've already had a program to um induce incentivized early retirement of of Professionals in this building and my understanding is that five people have taken that early retirement and that's reflected and at this point in the budget that's being proposed that you saw up on the board here two a teacher and and a u speech therapist are now out of the budget but the first thing I I know I'm not going to do this in three minutes so I'm just going to do my first page here hopefully you can read the rest
050so I know this budget better than most people in this room I've gone through it multiple multiple times and I noticed things so when we reduce the one teacher out of the budget the reduction was $193,200 without benefits so that tells me that that's more than one teacher because the average teacher salary here is about 97,000 the median teacher salary is 100 about 101,000 so that more reflects too so I just want to make the board aware and as well as Finance folks aware and I you know to me it's more more than one the second thing I want to point out and that's the red circle thing I put and then the green circled uh well before I get to that um the incentive pay it' be very helpful to the fact to know
051how much incentive paid was was gen needed to um to incentivize those five people to leave and what budget line is that incentify I I can't tell and that's one thing I've I've been asking for and hopefully m Molly can get it to us before uh Tuesday when we meet again the third thing is the estimate of the sick acrel which is the which is the second line on on this and that that went up um that went up $17,300 because my fourth point is I'm going to read it the provision for retirement sick AC cruel was increased to 237,000 531 which is an overall increase of $173,700 to14 budgeted this year 2425 not 2526 if a member were considering retirement for for next school year it is logical to to assume that all interested
052would have announced early retirement to take the incentive pay Pat if you could kindly WP okay okay one more sentence with this why was the line item increase so much I think you you've got a board members you should be asking that question and I do have some other uh comments that I hope you'll read uh before uh next week before our meeting uh on the 15th thank you all right thank you Pat Uh it looks like I have the PIR as a package deal uh Paul and Pat no my name is my name is Paul Pano I'm member of the uh uh from ten haywick drive I'm a member of the SMS building committee mechanical engineer and professional engineer for I don't know eons but I I do want to say that I support
053the $12 million fund it's the minimum that we can use you cut that down and we sacrifice this building is 38 years old we have deferred maintenance on all the main systems in this building that should have been replaced years ago okay anyone that says we can just replace the boilers is being you know just being narrow narrow-minded they don't understand the business we have to we have to resolve the situ situation and update this building okay and another thing I wrote the specification for the building to be estimated by Kino and they did not and I'm hoping that we have enough money in the continency because we do need to meet the current ventilation and energy standards that exist today okay but I I do not have first I'm not deeply enough into the
054budget but I don't mind the budget what that you've put together I think you've done the best you can with what you have so thank you can I comment briefly sure yeah uh Paul so um you know Todd Todd was saying that he he is optimistic that there are additional cost savings to find when we go to Hard rfqs For The Individual Services good so when that happens then we can take a look at I know exactly what you're talking about we've talked about this I know exactly what you're talking about so you know fingers crossed right y the thing is this we've we've gone through this is a perfect storm that this had to happen in the same year that we re that we reassessed the whole town and many of the people that
055have been in this town for many many years and have older homes and Condominiums have been penalized tremendously and it's they're the ones we got to convince you know because they've been here for a long time their kids have been in and out of school for Generations thanks Paul that was really well said thank you so much and thank you so much for your service on the subcommittee um we have a job on the school board if you would like to join us in March have some free time after March thank you thanks very much okay Abigail Dearing hi everyone I'm Abigail daring I live at 15 Patriots Road um my husband and I are the parents of two SMS students um and we are stratum homeowners and I am also a member of the
056PTO um I just wanted to speak briefly tonight um in support of the budget in support of the increased budget this year um in fact I think it could be more robust I think the I um I really appreciate everything you've you've done um I think the goals of maintaining um class sizes at where they are and not increasing class sizes is so important I think um not cutting teachers not cutting staff all of that is very important to the community um I Echo everything nurse Lily said she said it so eloquently um touched my heart and I think um as you all consider the budget um before March I really urge you to listen to the people that know this school and know the issues and the needs here the best the teachers the
057staff the administration and the staff including you know Building Maintenance Transportation um the people that should be guiding you are the people that are here every day and I know you I know you listen to their voices but um I would urge you to do that um as you you know move toward the March final um budget and I just want to finish by saying thank you for your um volunteer time here and all you do for this community and supporting the children of our community thank you yeah thank you so much uh Debbie Samberg Debbie Samberg one Barker Road um I'm going to be the negative voice in the room I'm so sorry I totally support the maintenance package I think it's incredible the school needs it but with the I haven't seen the
058enrollment studies you're talking about all I'm seeing is the reduced enrollment in the school at this point in time and with the increases that the school's taken over the last couple of years years I totally support the maintenance package but I cannot support an increase to the rest of the budget at this particular point in time stratum has an aging population um a majority of people in this town are um between 50 and up so at this particular point in time it's unaffordable for young families moving into town and the tax base is one of the reasons that it's starting to be on affordable mean price in this town uh for a house is $864,000 you add the tax base on top of that and it starts getting a little rough this school is incredible
059my daughter went through it she was all the way through sau6 graduated in 2006 last class out but I can't I can't in my heart support another increase at this particular point in time sorry being the negative negative Nanny no not at all it's okay we're open to all voices thank you Mike rry okay uh I have John Baker John Baker 25 kinlock Drive stratum I support the remodel project uh it I support the uh contractor so far that you've working with I was very impressed at the last meeting um the budget I'm sure everyone that has spoken is it's true with you know it's very important to have the U the curriculum the low class sizes and and all that but we also have to understand with this re-evaluation in this town a lot
060of people have seen their taxes go way up along with tax increases last year uh I came to this town 11 years ago from Massachusetts trying to avoid some of this and uh uh it's going to be difficult to get this to go through with a uh even though two 2.78 doesn't sound like a lot of an increase for Budget uh but with everything else going on and the remodel project that you're asking for that we need uh and uh I think it's going to be too much and uh would really like to see it uh drop down lower and uh otherwise I I think the town is probably not going to go for it uh just because it financially is getting uh just as the lady said ahead of me that it's getting very
061expensive to live here thank you thank you Cheryl McLean Smith for little tall can everyone hear me uh Cheryl McLean Smith six Alder Drive there you go thank you um I have been a resident of stratum for 20 plus years I have two children that came through the school and I have uh been a teacher in this school for 20 years this is my 32nd year teaching um there's been a lot of talk about increasing class size as a way to reduce the budget and I'd like to address that today as childhood itself has evolved over the past several decades so too have the demands on our educational system today I'd like to talk about why class size is more important than ever for meeting the changing needs of today's students to begin we need
062to recognize how much childhood has changed over the past 50 years technology is one of the most insignificant shifts it is a constant present in our lives influencing how our children learn to communicate learn themselves and socialize this digital shift means children are multitasking more than ever and it can be harder for them to focus and engage in traditional learning environments excuse me I'm very nervous in response to this personalized learning has become crucial smaller class sizes allow teachers to adapt their instruction to each child's unique needs fewer students man to manage with fewer students to manage teachers can give one-on-one attention adjust lessons based on indivual individual strengths in areas of need and ensure that each child receives the right support in larger classes this simply isn't possible and many children especially those with
063learning challenges can feel lost another major change is increasing focus on Mental Health when I was growing up mental health was rarely discussed in the context of childhood today however we see a rise in anxiety depression and other emotional struggles among students children today face different pressures including academic social and digital and these affect their emotional learning smaller class sizes are essential in helping teachers support social emotional learning in a smaller classroom a teacher can more easily identify when a student is struggling emotionally and intervene when necessary create a safe and supportive environment for all students teachers in smaller classes have the time to build meaningful relationships with their students which is key for emotional development these are things that can be difficult to achieve in larger classrooms where teachers where students may feel their
064emotional needs aren't being met in addition family structures have changed drastically today families are more diverse with more single parent households Blended families when both parents often working full-time this means that many children today come to school with different levels of support at home and may require additional attention and Care in their classroom smaller class sizes give teachers the ability to be more responsive to these varied backgrounds ensuring that all students regardless of their family situation receive the support they need to succeed in addition the demands of academic performance have increased there is more pressure on children today to excel academically with large class sizes it becomes increasingly difficult for teachers to focus on critical thinking and problem solving skills which are vital for preparing children for the future smaller class sizes allow teachers to
065create more Dynamic interactive lessons that Foster these higher level skills while offering the individualized support student needs to perform their best I would also like to talk about teacher well-being teaching today is a demanding apologies if you could kindly wrap it up yep um teachers are not responsible for delivering teachers are just not responsible for deling AC academic content they are also emotional support providers and behavior managers thank you thank you so much Emy Reynolds good evening everyone um my name is Amy Reynolds five Alderwood Drive um I'm the parent of a current kindergartener and have been a middle school educator in both regular Ed and special ed for the past 20 years um at a local public school um that school is also facing similar issues that stratum is so while I recognize both
066sides I want to attest to the fact that as students progress to Middle School a solid Elementary Foundation can be the difference in how that experience goes the students in front of us are very different than even just five or six years ago as many have mentioned the issues they're facing um affect teaching and learning every day as someone who also sits on various interview committees trying to fill positions with small candidate pools retaining highquality teachers in an environment that prioritizes teaching and learning and incentives to keep them on board such as Retirement is imperative if our enrollment numbers continue to increase we want to have the best people in front of our kids in closing I want to show support for the budget in maintaining staff and class sizes and thank you all for
067your time thank you so much Gail um varus V hi I'm Gail from 27 Dumar and Oaks um um I sent this in an email right before the holidays to you all but I added a few things and I just wanted to say it again in case I know it was a great before the holidays um is this better okay so I'm speaking um as a parent of two children at SMS um in my background I'm an occupational therapist and um I've been a Community member in stratum for almost 11 years um I'm speaking in support of the budget and a really great job on the building um plan I think you guys had a great job um what I wanted to say is I really support provid um I feel like it's important for
068the school to provide I feel like it's important for the town to support the school and students with the necessary resources and providing a nurturing and supportive learning environment when our students are given the tools attention and space that they need to thrive they will not only grow as learners but also reflect those successes in their um in their testing performances which I know is important to some and just their overall well-being strengthening the support at SMS is key to helping our students become their best and to meet their full potential so I strongly support maintaining current class sizes and the number of teaching staff at SMS the Educators and the administrators at SMS are highly skilled and they're committed to our children's successes increasing class sizes and reducing staff would put more strain on
069our teachers and would negatively imp the quality of Education that our students receive it is understood that the needs of the students today are much different than in years past if per if improving student performance is the goal cutting staff and increasing class sizes is not the solution I also support increasing the operating budget as you um showed tonight to ensure that stratum can continue to provide highquality education at SMS while I understand the financial challenges that our community faces adequate funding is necessary to maintain the excellent education and support our children need to succeed in addition it's essential that we retain stratum's outstanding teaching staff reducing their pay eliminating positions increasing class sizes or overburdening them is not only unjust but it will also impact the education our children will receive and their future
070academic successes our teachers already go above and beyond to meet their diverse needs of their students they deserve to be supported valued and fairly compensated for their dedication and their hard work stratum's excellent educators are a vital asset to this community and we must prioritize retaining them if we are to continue providing our children with the best education possible and lastly while I recognize the property tax challenges I also felt the burden when tax bill arrived and I have compassion and empathy for the residents who spoke last month at the board meeting about the implications that these ta tax rates have on their livelihood I ask that you please consider that these rates were not set by the school district and that I feel that it is unjust to place the weight of this burden
071on our children and our Educators the solution should not come at the expense of the quality of educ or the livelihood of our dedicated teaching staff Gail if you could kindly wrap it up thank you for your time and your consideration thank you so much I can't read the first name but last name Santos from willbrook it's a common Trend thank you Mark Santos 111 Willow Brook AV I have uh two daughters here at the school as well um next year I'll have two I should say one now I want to congratulate the board member for simplifying this presentation over the last couple weeks has clearly a lot of work went into making sure the message was precise consistent and easy for everyone to digest and I know this is volunteer time for all of
072you so thank you for that work and those efforts um I emphasized this last time but I think we should be really proud of our school systems I think that's one of the cornerstones that attracts a valuable community and people that are looking to send their children to the community and invest their time and their children into this space so it's really important that we take education seriously and I think everyone's saying that and supporting that which is also a really nice sentiment in the room the building uh I just want to reflect on a couple of the points I think the building budget is result of an old building um I think uh sorry Paul you emphasized it pretty well there you said um you know it's 35 years old we've had an old
073building we haven't done a lot of the maintenance these things happen no one likes it but we have to do it I think you've done a great job at making sure that the budget for the building is appropriate I would again encourage us to make sure that water is considered I know we said that there's contingency in there I guarantee you in 10 years everyone's going to look at water and go what we be thinking we should have spent money on that that's where it impacted our kids please look at the water um and just into perspective I like numbers uh when you look at the overall budget it's less than $800 per kid for this investment over the 30-year life it's pretty reasonable so hopefully that goes through and I hope the town gives
074you that support uh the school budget just reflecting on that as well uh this also seems reasonable when you think about inflation I think we we look at the numbers and we get caught up in some of the details a lot especially when you get a lot of people looking at them um but when you just practically think about every year we have inflation and I think everyone in the country knows the last four years has been pretty tough you guys are proposing I think a 2 to 4% increase in the total budget which basically covers inflation and in fact some would argue doesn't so in a way we're already you know penalizing the staff here in some regards because they don't have access to normal inflationary growth that would probably be in line with
075the country so in that regard I think you guys have been pretty aggressive with the budget I think it's reasonable but I want to reflect on you know probably some of the the hard truths that we need to realize and I think it's about branding um we have one of the best funded schools per kid in the country I think that should set in and we should be proud of that but we really do when you look at the average amount of funds we provide per child I mean we're talking California everywhere we have one of the best as a public school so we should all be like saying this is great and we should be attracting awesome people and when the school looks good kids will come here and and people that are thinking
076about moving to stratum will say yeah this is a place I want to go and this upgrade will help with all that which by the way I believe that will alleviate the tax burdens in the future as well um you know we have a lot of people worrying about this new assessment and the tax impact that's had well if we don't attract the right people and high value individuals that's only going to get worse it's not going to get better we need to bring people to the town that say this is a great school the school delivers results and ultimately this is a place where I want to raise my family and and I do and that's why we're here so we like it here um again I just want to appreciate everyone's time and
077effort into this um and I would encourage everyone in the town and the community to support the budget um thank you all thank you yeah thank you so much Glenn was evening Glen was 6 Gord Farm Road last meeting I spoke of the plight of our low-income households being able to pay their property taxes because of the significant impact of new property tax assessments Monday select board meeting identified 44 households that qualified in 2024 for the elderly lowincome exemptions many were in attendance we have no idea the number of how many low-income households that are struggling who receive no exemptions because they are below the age of 65 the largest impact to the tax rate impacting those households are School costs one gentleman at the last school board meeting remarked in his comments supporting school
078cost that he had vote for any warrant article to help and was willing to pay more taxes unfortunately those are Hollow words is there are no mechanisms to help many below the age of 65 without exemptions and are Force to sell and leave our town if you want to pledge to your pledge to be more than Hollow words you need to put time and effort into a fundraising mechanism and program to be able to provide Aid to our struggling low-income households tonight I want to focus more on what taxpayers are getting for our school costs that exceed the state average by 15% the SMS website claims award-winning Strat Memorial School earned SE Coast Regional Elementary School of Excellence award by New Hampshire excellence and education awards for past 21 years we have been selected as
079a blue ribbon school by the New Hampshire Partners in education question one what year did SS receive the seast regional Entry School of Award of Excellence because the website shows the winners back to 1994 and SMS is not listed question two there isn't even a web page that talks about the New Hampshire Partners in education but the organization's focus seems to be on promoting Volunteers in schools what's the criteria for this award that we've won the past 21 years besides membership it seems to me that our website has false advertising while comparatively the Swansea Central School actually won the SE Coast Regional Elementary School of Excellence award in 2023 and they don't even place it on their web page it appears that SMS is becoming like the sebr and sau21 and unlike cabber it has
080nothing to do with resources it has to do everything with how those resources are utilized and how curriculum is taught question three Kate what are you doing to collaborate with other schools such as Swansea to share best practices to improve ours and not try to reinvent the wheel but to improve on it Chris what is the superintendent office doing to facilitate ensure best practices are shared within our sa and outside of our SAU especially when data shows we are struggling question five what is the true problem are teachers being handcuffed by acceptable teaching practices because they don't I don't doubt that they are capable of teaching if allowed proper flexibility again best practices State data shows that SMS perform better across all testing with larger class sizes of 18 to 19 from the years 2014
081to 2019 and we haven't come close to those test scores with smaller class sizes of 16 to 17 from the years 20121 to 2024 and again we saw another decrease in testing in the year 2324 this test scores this isn't the same across all similar communities like Bedford Amherst Hanover even B to name a few have improved test scores to include better test scores their first year out of covid than they were before covid and have consistently improved while maintaining an average class size of 19 Glen if you could kindly wrap it up this is it there's no justification to not decrease our operating budget by eliminating a teaching position from each grade level and returning to a class size of 19 to 20 we have paid staff beyond the classroom teachers to work with
082students who are identified as deficient we need a zero operating cross increase in this year's budget thank you thank you Glenn okay thank you so much Kelsey Quinn hi uh Kelsey Quinn to lamington place um I've had the privilege to attend stratum Elementary only N9 years ago seems like a long time for me but it's probably not in comparison to other speakers today um I've also had the privilege of having a mother who works here um that means I've been able to come back through the years and watch the school grow um through this generous budget the school has grown positively I can say that firsthand maybe not reflected in Awards or test scores but reflected in the attitudes of the schools and the students um I am now in my third year at a
083university where less than 5 % of the student body comes from a public education background and I can say without a doubt the building blocks I learned at SMS are part of that achievement um I have received intervention for my fine motor skills uh than a literary interventionists which part of this budget cut would cut um I have received help from esps who have helped me with one-on-one teaching um when I struggled in math um in conclusion to cut the school's budget would be to cut a lot of kids like me's future um who might need a little extra help or a lot of help because stratum does Aid to a lot of um special needs children um you can't really put a monetary value on Intervention and children's Futures and stratum So yeah thank
084you thank you awesome to hear from you thank you all right Miss Quinn hi Kristen Quinn to lingon place that was my daughter great job I guess that's all I have to say um I don't have anything written or planned but I just wanted to say I support the budget um the talk of cutting teachers and cutting and increasing class sides um concerns me um looking at just test scores and ratings concerns me I have lived in this town for 21 years I have two children that went through this school I have worked in this building for 15 years I have worn I'm going to say most of the hats that have to be worn in this building um not only that but um I feel like when you're part of this place um in
085the level that I know that most of my colleagues are uh that I am it's not just a school it is it is cross country it is getting a million hugs at Market Basket it is the feeling of this place that needs to continue the small classroom connections that we make matter it matters not in tests perhaps I don't know um but it matters it matters in well-being it matters in community and cutting this budget would cut a lot of that connection and I feel like that's an incredibly important piece so um that being said please keep the budget actually raise the budget I think everyone here deserves a race no but I mean at least keep the budget um it's important this class I mean I that was my daughter I'm just gonna end
086it at that thank you thank you very much uh Brandon um wiut Road M hi uh Brandon misho 55 wiut Road uh I've been a teacher for 20 years I work in a neighboring District uh we've been in town for 10 or 12 years we have two children one child who comes here now and one's on our way next year uh been really positive things happening out of this school the class sizes I think are appropriate uh the small class sizes have helped my son not go unnoticed when he needed some extra help where I think he would have faded in the background with larger class sizes I think those things are important I think a $415,000 increase on the budget is super uh fiscally responsible for having worked in a high school that does
087these budgets every year and has to go to town votes all the time um I looked at our uh annual report that was given to the state and with the 33 million that this town needs to generate for revenues that's a 1% increase I did some quick math and it's probably wrong I don't know why you're wish your financial person was here but um I can't remember what you had said that the building was going to cost at the tax rate last meeting in terms of dollars and cents but it looks like this 415 on a really rough on my phone calculation is anywhere in the neighborhood of 16 to 20 cents per thousand so when you do that on $800,000 house we're talking about $160 a year divide that by 12 and we're talking
088about $13 to fund all these teachers and keep this program going the way it is with the budget that you've created I don't feel like that's irresponsible I feel like that's doable I think every town I work in se21 and every town is hurting from reassessments every town is going through the same amount of stuff and I do empathize with people but I also see building developments going down by my road and they're not putting in houses for uh one bedroom houses and small developments these are huge houses that are going in that are going to have families and going to have children so I think this enrollment issue is is something that we need to look at and I think that it's and it's going to stay just seeing the different developments that have
089gone just through wiut Road uh or been proposed I think that this is something that's uh we're going to need the teachers that we have so again I mean for for 20 cents per thousand I feel like this is fiscally responsible and something that I can support I wish I had the number from you so I could add it on to figure out the total for the bond and that but I couldn't find it online so but thank you thank you yeah thanks so much and uh Michelle is here and she's our finance person in SAU so I should have have had everybody introduce themselves but thank you so much Brandon um Greg Richardson sorry I was in the back uh so Greg Richardson six-pointer Rock Terrace um like a bunch of people who spoke
090I have a son who's a second grader here and my daughter who will be in kindergarten next year uh which probably makes a lot of people say well you're bias but I I'll put the bias aside uh and I am I work in corporate strategy and finance so I can look at things pretty objectively um every meeting I've come to people talk about numbers so I'm just kind of reflecting on a few data points right we're talking about a 2.7% increase in the budget for the school as he just mentioned it's it's Pennies on the dollar when you really think about it the average uh pay increase across all Industries in this country this year is almost 5% and the average spend increase for most uh companies organizations is 4% so to what Mark said
091you're already basically operating under the medium that you would see for this country the other thing is there's a tendency here and what I've observed is to conflate test scores with spending and it's my opinion it's it's relatively punitive um I looked at seven surrounding towns and the truth is we do have the lowest composite test scores that's that is not a joke but when you look at some of the other data points that we're talking about we also spend out of those seven the sixth least on per student and that's compared to Ry Northampton exitor Hampton Greenland Portsmouth and we have the biggest class size and even with this budget if this was to increase we would still be the fifth least spend even if the other schools spent nothing so we're not spending
092ahead in my opinion of performance we are conflating it and we're not thinking about the right way we need to think about performance and what we need to do there strategically and really take a look at that take a step back and say what's causing that um the second thing is when you look at the the the schools that are you know in the high 80s or in the 80s or high 70s like Ryan Northampton they're spending about 31 and $31,500 per student that's almost 30% more than we're spending here so there could be a correlation but you can't correlate backwards because you're going to end up with where we are today um and you the gentleman mentioned Bedford so I will tell a personal story so my son has received Services here he is
093an awesome kid but he's like me and he's you know he needs services so um my sister-in-law is is an OT in the Bedford Elementary School and when we got his assessment back we're lucky it's not as you know severe as it could be she was floored she's like I work in Bedford everyone talks about Bedford this is like this is amazing compared to what we do and when you talk about Bedford the average house there is you know it's about 750 800,000 so not so different from here this year we're spending $940 per thousand on school they spend uh almost a dollar more than that per school so we if we're going to talk about numbers we really need to peel it back but just to kind of bring the story together like the
094school in my opinion is the legacy of the town and if you think about any town if we have a the Small Town Hero goes and becomes a runner in the Olympics there's going to be Flags in I think we literally have Flags in the town for someone who is Olympian everyone here regardless of your if you grew up here or not like we are part of a town and the legacy of stratum and the Legacy that we live in the world is our students so for us to just think about budgets and just and not think about in the context of everything especially the other parts of the town I said it before and I'll say it again it's punitive we're punishing students for something that we're not happy about but we're not actually
095talking about what we're not happy about so I think at the end for me the last question is I understand a lot of people talk about the cost and fixed incomes fixed incomes might imply that you have time I would spend time in this school whether it's volunteering bring some of that uh if you can't if money is not the thing bring your time in but also learn what's actually happening here because you know I went I was a public school kid I grew up in the 90s it's a lot different than it is now it's it's actually shockingly different and I didn't know that I remember the first meeting I had I couldn't believe it so like personal experience aside plus plus work I think fully supportive of the Budget Building budget is great
096too I don't know why we wouldn't do the windows now but I won't uh Crush that uh part of the conversation but thanks for your time thank you so much uh Jan Ted two country farm God you're already on the last person okay very efficient everyone exactly so thank you to all of you first of all I I just have a bunch of notes here so please don't beat me up I don't have a prepared speech so I want to say in looking at the bond will put together for the building I love that I love that it's started at a high dollar amount I love the scrutiny I love the time I love everything that went into it I want to thank everyone for that so thank you forgetting it where it is at
09712 million I think most people can support that if not you know really appreciate it the operating budget um I heard everything everyone said here I love The Passion of the teachers the principal the other people that you know the town that have kids here I do think it's a little biased if you have kids here I'll be honest I don't anymore but I do think what worries me is we had a big increase a couple years actually it was last year and I think that was the teacher salaries or inflationary increases or something that didn't take place during Co I'm not sure about that but there was a big bump in our taxes and that was due to the school that's the biggest part of our taxes but you know then what happened was
098now we've had reevaluation now that's not any fault of anyone here but I just think we have to be really careful with the operating budget because what I worry about is as follows so we're teachers are retiring but are they going to be now replaced next year we're saving money this year but are we pushing money to next year is it more like a shell game I'm not trying to be I'm not trying to be sarcastic here the reserving I was listening about the trust we have three things in trust right should we have more things in trust so it's more overtime and it's not we're being whacked every year for 5% 6% 10% I said it last time when I was here we have to operate this budget the school should be operated we
099care about the kids we care about the curriculum we need a budget like a business I work in a business where they say it has to be this no increases make it work so I say to myself are there other line items that aren't class siiz maybe not teachers maybe we have too many administrators maybe there's other areas of the budget and I and I do appreciate that you guys have all looked at this and scrutinized it but I just say to myself we can't just keep increasing and you know I think we did that we did that again I don't know if it was the salaries or something but we can't have 5% the next year it's another 10% 5% so while I applaud everyone whether it's class sizes we go to or we
100look at other line items or we look at the amount of Administrators we have or we look at that off you know that pie chart which how many teachers and the things that are I know stuck in contractual things when those come up do we take a look at those I just think we really have to and maybe you guys are already doing all this and I'm just speaking and not really knowing what I'm talking about here but I just really think we have to do to the operating budget each year what you guys did to the building you have to tear it apart get a lot of outside views take it really seriously because we're losing a lot of people in the town and I think you want the people to support it as
101the gentleman said you want The Branding you want everything but we have to really look at it hard thank you thank you is there another sheet up there we're not did everybody get a chance to sign up yeah just one of the three administ yeah if anybody didn't get a time to sign up please do hi uh Mis Misa pitaro 23 dumart Oaks I wanted to thank the amazing teachers at SMS I have two girls one in fourth and one in seventh at CMS who is thriving thanks to the solid foundation she has received at SMS we have had nothing but a positive experience here and I'm so grateful as a former first grade teacher who taught for 10 years um but have out been out of the classroom for almost 13 years I am
102often reminded when I run into former colleagues how hard teaching is now and they tell me how easy it was back then and I chuckle because it was far from easy and I just say that because we can um think about our past experiences if we were in the classroom years ago if our kids were in the classroom and what that was like but the only people that truly know what it's like to teach now in 2025 at SMS are the teachers and the administration that is here today so um I just ask that you listen to all the stories that they've um shared and I think it's important to remember the world that we knew when we were in school and how different the world is today our teachers are all already wearing so
103many hats that I can't imagine adding more to their already full plate by increasing class sizes I am in full support of the proposed budget and helping to keep class sizes as is thank you thank you thank you so much and thank you for help spreading information to about tonight appreciate that Cameron's up on okay Cameron hi Cameron or 6on drive um I wasn't going to speak originally because I wasn't sure about that but I do want to speak as a parent and as a resident um I am on the financial committee but I just want to mention that I've heard in multiple meetings people talk about running the school like a business right and you know whether that analogy is appropriate or not people are not going to work at a place in the
104Private Industry with the year-over-year increases that the teachers get at this school right so I heard someone you know I think it was Greg mention about what you know what people are getting out in the country right uh I work in the Private Industry I'm sure a lot of people do here you know people are demanding five six seven 8 10% raises and they're getting them because there's you know a a shortage of skilled workers and people who do the work here are obviously specialized and have skills and you know I'm just saying that what I hear at a meeting last week that the contractual increase is 1 and a half% and then I hear someone say well yeah but the teachers getting a cost of living increase well they're not because I I I
105bet if we go back and look we're going to find that if we match the school budget increases um over the last four or five years they're not going to match the rate of inflation so the school isn't immune to inflation and I understand that hurts everyone but at the same time the cost of you know consumables and software and all this other stuff is going up for here so it's really just math we have to say if we're not funding the school at least at the level of inflation then we're cutting things and I can say you know the budget there's not a lot of wiggle room there's you know that's the the main thing it's not like this is a wasteful spending thing right we've gone through this and you folks have gone
106through it the Administration has gone through it there's there was a lot of thought put into it and it's still ongoing but you know we we're looking at things that I think people in Private Industry would say well that's great he like oh $2,000 for chairs right like I look at the money that's wasted where I work and I go wow wish I could give that to the school because we're wasting it here and we're fighting about $2,000 for chairs right so I just hope everybody's aware that this isn't some wasteful spending and there's no thought there's dozens of people that are here there's people that are employed here and are volunteering and they're putting their time into looking at the budget and it's very thorough and there's no waste there's there's not much left
107cut in that budget um and I did want to say also uh to Paul and Sophie that I really appreciated the building presentation last week and that was uh that was really great and you know I think the town really reacted and appreciated the fact that there was a lot of problems last year with discussing the building improvements and uh it sounds like you guys found a good partner um to improve the school and I really appreciate the work there so thank you very much thank you hi my name is Diana linkler um 18 GI front R I didn't have anything prepared and I will be as quick as quick um I just without numbers without anything with you know I want everyone to know when I moved here 12 years ago I did a
108lot of research on the schools and the first bit of research was who passed the budget and those are the towns we went to and those are the towns we looked at to serve for our children my daughter was in second grade my son was in fourth grade and we chose stratom even though we toured Oyster River we toured exitor we toured Portsmith we toured oh my gosh we toured a lot and um they were all impressive but the ones who passed the budget time and time and time again is the ones we we looked at and that's where we landed because we knew that the community valued education and that goes for now we don't have kids in the school anymore and my house is worth what it is worth because of the schools
109so I just want to put that out there when you look at data and you see school districts not passing budgets people don't want to move here it's an interesting way to house hunt I like that um uh Lester Lester cuff uh 50 stratum Heights Road I just want to say hi and I want to thank the uh the committee the capital looking at the uh the building uh I think over several years we've kind of lost uh a process on keeping our eye on the building and I really appreciate what what the committee has done this year and I think we've kind of learned a lesson from that hopefully I have over the last 5 years and what a difference of 5 years makes with look at this I mean historically it's been one
110two three people and this is just mind-blowing so I I think we've accomplished something maybe not the right way of doing it but we did it and uh I want to thank the the committee and offline I'll give you my little personal feedback thank you though I would like to just say that um everybody looks at me when they say the thanks it was a team effort right okay it absolutely was a team effort um couldn't have done it you know I I would have failed miserably but we had some great people and you know I spent 50 years in the electronics Industry I have to say it was rare I don't think I ever saw uh strangers come together that didn't well a couple of people knew each other okay but for the most
111part different you know didn't know each other they came together pulled together and uh and acted together and cooperated and agreed together it was terrific well I think it's great to keep tradition because you know we came to New Hampshire back in the 80s and New Hampshire is a uh it's run by volunteers stratum is run by volunteers and everything we do is volunteers and and I think just through the years if we didn't have the volunteers and dedicated people we wouldn't be where we're at everyone talks how great it is moving in here uh and it was great like this cuz there was senior citizens my age now back then who supported my kids that were little and all their kids were grown up and gone and we put in like we built like
112two three schools the fire department this and that so uh over the years when someone talked about the history of stratum there is a big history on volunteers coming forward and and people coming forward and doing it we kind of lost the when we talk about wow this this school is 35 years old well we've kind of lost looking at this school over several years and uh we' We've refocused now so that's good so thanks everyone yeah for anyone that doesn't know Lester is a longtime member of the financial advisory committee uh very big proponent of the maintenance trust I don't know if that was good or bad how's your how's how's your metrics gone yeah thank you thank you yeah thank you for your service all right it looks like I have um Eugene
113C sorry iong I'm sorry you chumak 23 quest to terce I'll be quick as well I came completely unprepared uh so I'll be quick I moved here about five years ago from Florida um I have two kids one's going through SMS right now and particularly moved to Straton because of the school system and uh uh well it was said before me but you know uh funding school it's about funding human potential it's a long-term investment it's not going to come right away but F fundamentally this is about future of uh of the community and of the state of the country basically uh I firmly believe that uh you know with the inflation what it is right now where you have a 2.75% uh budget increase that's probably under investment and actually under you know you're
114putting lower than you probably should bottom line I definitely understand people that are um looking at the fiscal side of things and um feeling the hurts of the increased assessment um but like I said again fundamentally this is about the future thank you thank you thank you so much and Caroline Donaldson hello my name is Caroline Donaldson I live at seven chis Farm Drive um I'm really nervous to be up here I didn't prepare anything um and I will say this is my first board meeting um and I am here um because of the support and um the education that so many of the community members have uh shared over the last couple months um I won't try to speak to numbers that's just not me uh I was a former teacher we moved here
115N9 years ago um we now have four kids two are here at stratum Memorial School to will be coming um but try to make this quick um when we moved here my oldest son we knew need um Services uh we were living in Boston at the time and uh we're told that you know he probably something happened with him traumatic at Birth that he probably wouldn't read he would probably have a hard time with sports with academics he would probably have to repeat a year all these things and so when we looked our main focus was yes we love New Hampshire born and raised here but um it was for the school and we toured schools like one of the other um moms here said we didn't look at budgets um we looked for the
116feel and we looked for what people had to say about what their families got from the community and without a doubt Kate knows I email her too many times um this school has changed the course of my children's lives but most importantly my oldest son's life where um I can guarantee you I was a former educator in Lexington Mass where I don't know if they even have a budget down there because it's so vast um without a doubt if my son was not here at strata memorial school with Kate and many of the people who are probably here tonight the course of his life would be different than it is today and that's not just um you know 504 IEP reading all of that it's something that to be quite honest I didn't quite hear
117anyone that's opposed to the budget talk about and that's the interpersonal part of being in a place like this so yes I I don't agree with a school's business um sorry if that doesn't sound right but school is about raising little people and humans and you know 16 kids in a class for one teacher U my son doesn't even have a a in his class this year um one te dashing one teacher to be responsible for those little lives for what they're coming in with whether it's academics or home or social emotional um that's a big ask that's a really big ask and these teachers I I bet if you asked into a survey of the school um the parents here it wouldn't be what a test score said or what's po on our website
118it would be the feel and what their kids get when they come home what they have to share and what they come and what they get from the teachers and Educators here and I think the only way to really acknowledge that and thank the people that do this day in and day out with our kids is to support that they have time and resources to give our kids what they deserve and like so many said that's the future of this town that's what you like to say when you're born and raised somewhere when you you know have grandkids you know all these things like I think Greg said that's what life is about so um sorry for my rambling my emotional part here but thank you all for all that you do and this is
119my first meeting but it definitely won't be my last thanks thank you that's great thank you so much um thanks to everyone that spoke opposing and pro um we've definitely listened to all the voices and um appreciate them is there anybody that did not get a chance to speak okay so um I heard a lot of people talking about the building project I would encourage you to talk to your neighbors um and your friends who you go out to lunch with who you see at the library just to let them know you know we're going to do our best to reach out but um having the help of everyone in this room would be great too and there's a lot more information on the website um we are going to move on close public hearing
120yeah we're going to close the public hearing and move on um you know I think like I feel like my heart is very full seeing all you out here so thank you um we are going to go into our regular meeting now and we're going to do some great presentations on um looking at student assessment data and also looking at special education costs and um what's happening in our special education programming so would' love you to stick around um but also uh we'll close the public hearing okay do we have to move um no but I'm just wonder if we just take like a five minute five minute break we're gonna take a five minute break yeah so reconvene at 7:42 great 7:42 perfect thank you so it does make me think though like about
121I want talking points for the session [Music] and so this is a one okay thank you sir how are you see you um no feedback no oh oh oh uh the town let me know I'm going to be sitting here this will be available okay hi Lester how's everything going with you okay you did okay I'm Sorry's I you look great okay yeah when I came okay that well and it was more important to me okay how's your wife now oh was she here I didn't even see her okay is that like we haven't yet but um we'll probably put it on the SMS website gotcha okay um and we'll be having so um presentations six present fun fun well thanks for coming tonight appreciate it I would have liked come to one of those
122karino karino will be there and you can drill them all right um so we're going to call the meeting to order at 7:48 p.m. um moving first into approval of the minutes um we have both public and non-public minutes um I think we were all here for both of those right so we can take them as a whole any edits on either the public or non-public minutes nope anybody um again I know I just want to compliment the minutes I think they're so good I also just want to point out that um within the minutes it's hyperlink um the various reports that we've been talking about here tonight so the karino presentation um and and uh there's another H Berling come forting right now but anyway great job and I would definitely encourage you guys
123to take a look at those all right um do I have a motion to approve the minutes thanks Paul do I have a second second thank you Tanya uh all in favor I anybody opposed all right 5 z z for both public and non-public minutes all right looking at superintendent report manifest Financial okay um I put the manest there if you could please sign those um we included the financials in your board pack can you speak in the mic a little bit Moree sorry so we included the financials in your board pack this month we spent an additional $ 37,6 and does anyone have any questions yeah um so in the when we did this report I asked Molly because we were concerned about where you were looking at your end of the year fund
124balance yeah it's very low right in this report so Molly did a great job scrubbing it with Erica and Michelle also they've set got a meeting set up with Kate and Raymond what we we noticed is that we had a double encumbrance for special education Raymond did an encumbrance and so didn't we do it at the SAU so there actually is an additional $13,693 229 so we were really we were out about to freeze the budget and say no more spending unless it is crucial but we not in that point right now we are still lower than we are but we do we do have realization of why that has happened so just wanted to draw that to your attention that it is not as low as that 58539 I know that was pretty terrifying
125okay uh any questions for Michelle I just have one question um I just noticed the uh encumberance change for the transportation um it's noted homeless incomer change um last month it was around like 3,000 and this month is um 76 I'm just curious do you have like a line item that that's or or like can explain like the difference that happened there from month to month so um that's a mckin vinto it's a federal law and that fluctuates depending on the number of families and students that are homeless and so um and how far they reside from school or so and there a variety of times that that is just fluid okay so we probably added added yeah def Point got can also add to that too I've put in question um the billing that
126we have gotten um it looks like we were getting double build for a family so I've got that question with the transportation coordinator at SLC um because it looks like the they're trying to do per student vers coration so I've have not gotten an answer I asked that before break and I asked it again uh last Thursday when I was in the office so hopefully that will be cleaned up as well so again we were trying to do our due diligence looking at every number and why and getting the correct number I do not believe that is accurate but that's what we have now so that's how they encumbered it okay thank you you're welcome all right um next up on the agenda is the budget so um I think we want to um um
127I'm just this um so I think I'm going to open up um public comment for but just before we move on to talk about the budget um I think there was maybe someone who wanted to talk so I'm just going to open up public comment for 10 minutes in case anybody um wanted to talk and then we'll um allow that public comment and then we'll run um into the next agenda item does that sound okay can make yeah can um can I have a move for a public comment for the next 10 minutes so moved okay do I have to do I have to do a motion for that no I I just want to clarify this this was the time that you're going to allow teachers to talk because they couldn't talk during the
128public um public hearing because they weren't residents only residents can speak during a public hearing but during a board meeting is when your teachers could do that per youry so I just wanted to clarify that does our earlier motion apply now you I I would just redo that motion I thought you were doing it for for overall um but I would just clarify that and if that was me not giving great guidance I I take okay all right awesome um okay so um there are um teachers that perhaps would like to speak at this part of so before we go on for too much longer into our agenda I wanted to just open up public comment allow that to happen for a short time and then retain public comment for after um the presentations just
129because there might be some questions for that um so can I entertain a mo does anybody have a motion to allow um out of district teachers to talk during public comment in our regular board meeting yeah so move okay thanks s um do I have a second I'll second Sophie okay uh all in favor I I five so 5 z z so we can allow out of district teachers um to talk so we'll open up public comment for 10 minutes is there anybody that would like to talk thank you Miss Forbes yes Sor take away hi I'm Whitney Forbes I teach third grade here at SMS I've been here for about 5 years and I've been in education for 17 um I apologize for the confusion thank you for answering my questions all of you
130about that we weren't sure exactly when we were supposed to comment and who would be hearing our comments um when I thought about what to say tonight I um had a lot of thinking about how I think some of the um almost tension between what appears to be people who have children here um or people who work here or our staff um and those who don't is really um a misunderstanding or a lack of experience both ways like I don't know what it feels like to be in that position and obviously uh many of those people don't have the same experiences that we do um so I do want to preface my comments with that um I spend a lot of time in hockey ranks like an insane amount of time both of my boys
131play it's a yearlong sport there are many families from stratom who live that life too it's actually quite fun I'm really enthusiastic um last year in the summer I was standing next to a father who still has students here and he said so um what do you do all summer is it is it rinse and repeat every year and um I said well I I actually teach at UNH in the summer a grad course and I teach at the writers Academy so I do that work um and I I also uh don't know how to tell this without sounding flippant but no it has never been rined repeat that would make my life really easy but it is not that way um in fact every year you have between 16 and 20 very um Unique
132Individuals in your classroom and you are responsible for tailoring your day-to-day to those needs and it's fun it's Dynamic and it's amazing and it's hard um and I know that we have an opportunity to to recognize that people have differing opinions about what we should do with the budget and of course the building project although that seems less controversial um and I I also know to this to be true I know that everybody wants to create a place where their kids are valued and where they have an incredible community and I've heard a lot of people say that we should focus more on Reading Writing and arithmetic which always makes me laugh because we don't actually use the word arithmetic here but I also want to highlight that this year in particular of my five
133years here and 17 in education we have spent so much time and energy thinking about and researching and understanding um how we can build those foundational skills that we are well aware our students need while also creating experiences for them that are more authentic in Real World um we we want to combine those content area skills with um I think someone called them soft skills earlier or interpersonal skills um and those skills require instruction too um we also need kids to be able to persevere through challenges and we know that because of things happening in society including this feedback loop that they get from technology and their ability to just turn it off when it's not going their way or shut it off um or or change it or start again there our kids ability
134to persevere has been negatively impacted by that um and I I've also heard people talk about enrollment reports in our in our numbers and as as one person mentioned I think it was Sophie earlier um there were I I believe like four or five um different models that the report which was from 2023 so so not that long ago um so the projected numbers increase on on all of these models but fluctuate um slightly they did a composite where they compared um you know or an average of those um numbers and the average enrollment projections increased from 540 for the next school year to 582 in 2627 63 in 2728 um 600 I'm sorry 629 um and then in 2930 664 and so on um so I I think it's important that we're we're considering
135accurate information um when we're talking about these things because they they highly impact our day-to-day lives but more importantly our kids day-to-day lives um I think that someone else mentioned leaving a legacy and and that Legacy um should be prioritizing education um I also want to quickly mention test scores this is really hard as a third grade teacher because it's the first year that students take standardized tests and I have have a lot of bias toward standardized tests for many reasons one of them is that they're biased the other reason is that we know a lot more now about the way students demonstrate their understanding for example many many test scores in order to be normed have to be have have to have multiple choice questions and they're standardized in that way and we now
136know that those tests cannot cannot accurately determine students reading comp Rion because those are word recognition tests that's one just one example they're actually endless I'd be happy to have lots of conversations about this I really I really enjoy talking about it and thinking about it another thing that I'm not sure that the public is aware of is that not all standardized tests are appropriate for our population or any population of students and in fact you can opt out of them and when you do that your student receives a score of zero which can then negatively impact our test scores I'm not sure if the public knows that I don't know why you would unless you were in education I actually am not even sure how many Educators know that because our job is not
137to prioritize test scores our job is to prioritize children and we do that every day my students regularly amaze me in fact um right now we're learning about the foundations of our government and civil rights which is really important to me I was a polyi major in undergrad and two of my students are researching Abraham Lincoln now we know him as a great president president he was also relatively controversial um and I was asking them why do you think it's important to continue to learn about him and share this with an audience at our showcase last night and they're like well he's a great leader and I'm like why do you think that is and they were talking about the fact that our country was incredibly divided then can you imagine a country that's incredibly
138divided like that what do you do as a leader when your constituents have incredibly dichotomous View views of the path forward as people elected to positions I'm sure you can consider how hard that must be and Abraham Lincoln said this it often requires more courage to dare to do right than to fear to do wrong and I hope that we can take a little scrap of my students understanding of Abraham Lincoln and why we should continue to learn about him and carry that forward in this process thank you thank you thank you so much were there any other out of District teachers that wanted to talk yeah so we still have 2 minutes and 45 seconds left on this okay thanks run run because Whitney justed a lot so I'm Ashley Healey I have been
139at SMS for 10 years first in the classroom and now I am in the learning Commons um and Whitney just capitalized everything I was thinking to say about how brilliant the people that work here are I come to work in inspired every day by my Administration by my co-workers now in my new position I can reach like every aspect of this school so I see and have the privilege of working with people I've never worked with before and they don't do what they do for like accolades or praise like we have nationally board certified teachers we have teachers invited to speak at national conferences writing professionally taking courses to better themselves for their students and I just hope everyone recognizes that thank you missy all right thank you so much and we will open a
140publicly comment again after our um presentations all right so looking at the proposed budget draft and warrant sorry what questions um what thoughts do you guys have about um the budget that um we can talk about any thoughts or did you say just waiting is this open for him for whom yeah for the board for the board yeah I I wanted to make a few comments and I'll I'll probably restate it to some extent when we meet next week because that's our vote on it I I've heard a few things yeah both through public comment and and correspondence that we've received um one of the comments was we don't want to cut teachers um we don't want to reduce teacher pay and we don't want to eliminate programs these are a couple of items that
141I I wanted to make sure that were clarified so in my mind where I currently stand on where my vote will be after considering public comment today public comment over the past several months um data that that we've all been presented with and the work of the fact I very much appreciate that and then all the other considerations that we have we got considerations in town we got considerations with the with the building all sorts of stuff um we had my purpose in my individual vote so I'm only speaking as an individual board member of course um for the incentivization of early retirement was twofold one in early retirement theoretically if somebody was laded up at a higher p rate and they were replaced with someone who was perhaps newer to the teaching profession even
142though that we may or may not be doing it that way um we may realize some savings so there could be some savings there but my real driver was to be able to align what I consider to be a non-transient enrollment uh phenomenon that we've seen not only here in stratum but across the state and that has been a reduction in enrollments and and a reduction in ADM um um in looking at that I went back and I'm looking at what were we able to do with class sizes that were both aligned to what the board had recommended during Co what the state requirements are there's a 303 requirement actually for for class sizes and what my position is is that we should which I think has been I think has been proposed in this
143budget I'm not sure um because I really want to understand exactly what those moving pieces on the staff are is a reduction of one class size in fifth grade and I'm convinced also a reduction in one class size in fourth grade um that's based on the fact that I think it would increase classes class sizes by about four students uh per class that would still be somewhere in that range that uh that Miss Forbes just described sort of in the 20 student range I'm I'm more open to be persuaded on the third grade that that should not happen in third grade after doing more research after having some more conversations realizing that that would also I think based on current enrollment would kick third grade up or our fall fall enrollment to over 20 be
14421 still open to hearing hearing more about that um we have an opportunity in my opinion where we have um teachers who have opted to retire if enrollment continues to decline I don't know what what is the number if we do a you know a reductio at absurdum and we say maybe we just we keep reducing classes to what 12 10 11 at some point we need to align uh teaching resources to to this in my opinion nontransient enrollment decline so I would say the time to do that is now because what I don't want to do is cut teachers we have one mechanism to do that on the board and that is a riff and that's a very indiscriminate way of reducing teaching sizes I don't like that um it's a last in first
145out based on the current negotiated contract and there's certainly very talented teachers that have been uh that have been hired in recent years um so my my suggestion is that we are not my my goal is not to cut teachers in fact my goal would be to treat this in a more agile way where if enrollment in this in these in these models that have been proposed increase certainly we should increase the teaching staff to to meet those those class sizes so I don't see this as something that's just a onetime uh one-time thought process when I hear about eliminating programs I don't think anybody on the board has had any concept of of eliminating any programs um and I'd love to know more about what if if there are people who who have heard
146more about that what that would be we certainly can't reduce pay that's not something that we want to do and it's something that we can't do Contra contractually um what I will tell you if you want to look over the horizon at our current Staffing levels the teachers are going to renegotiate their their contract I think it's next year am I right about that next year what many people may or may not know is yes our teacher signed a contract prior to very large increases uh through inflation and I'm I'm sorry for f bustering but if you guys can give me just like five more minutes here on the board that is not lost on those teachers they've been having very incremental raises over this past contract and I think we're going to see uh
147requests where that information was not lost on them when we going to renegotiate that excuse me I'm not sure I follow what you just said say it again we have uh we will be renegotiating teacher contracts in a year over the past several years that that contract covered does not encapsulate the major cost of living increases that we've seen through inflation yeah sure yeah so I think that's something that we should just think about about as a board um obviously nothing is determined there but it's something to really think about I was really compelled by uh Miss dilo's uh public comment the other day I went back to to YouTube and transcribed it thought about it really like Paul taking the initiative to ask her to come back up and offer what was the one
148thing that she thought was the big change in in kids um there we have more disregulated kids that was her I think her description people who are not as come to school as ready to learn um and a lot more behavioral issues I don't want to take it out of context and put any words in her mouth feel free to go back to that YouTube clip and keep me honest there um and when she was offered what was the one thing that made it very very difficult um if she had to choose one thing it's technology um and social media specifically and we had some comments about um anxiety and impression and some of these other things that are that are the product of that what what I think we have to understand is that
149many people who come from an older generation perhaps even my generation the social contract has changed where we sent kids to school for the Reading Writing arithmetic math but now the social contract has changed where we're sending them to be I don't mean to be flippant either but to be parented to be disciplined to be regulated that's tough and we all need to have our eyes wide open that that's what's being asked of of our of our teachers and so my challenge is not so much in saying let's keep papering over that by adding more adult bodies into these classrooms and I don't want to put the teachers in a bad position but I would challenge the administration to think about how we can better address that and I'm not going to offer any any
150suggestions here um I'm happy to offer suggestions on on a personal basis of things that I would think uh might be might be helpful um those those were really my only other comments what I would say is that the class sizes that we're talking about do go back about five years um the ones that I proposed for fourth and fifth that would be the if I understand correctly the elimination of one more or the not rehiring of one more teacher uh position um and I think just from an overall when we look at the spend um where we uh for the cost per student this is from State data um stratum was at about let's see I mean if we go back for like the five years prior to 201819 we were somewhere in the
1518 n 10 11% overstate averages for per student spending uh we're up to 23 15 15 now uh or not now because we don't have the we don't have some data that takes a while for the state to generate on 23 24 um but we we spend we over overspend but we're still spending we're still providing a lot of funding as a board uh to the school uh on a per student basis um so anyway I'll leave it at that that's my recommendations uh and and where I'm currently persuaded to in my rationale for it um and happy to provide any other feedback to the board members and again thank you for indulging that very very long rant sorry it's always it's always good for me to listen to you um I like what you're
152saying I think overall are you saying you support the budget with the idea um that perhaps fourth and fifth grade I'm confused a little bit on on what we've been talking about so we had to kind of rush through a meeting because we wanted to be responsive to the public we have a a fairly good understanding that I believe if we didn't re hire one teacher and one speech pathologist if I'm correct that that would result in a correct right can you remind us yeah about the buyouts and how yeah so I'll have Michelle talk about the buyouts because she put all that together um but we did talk about uh there was two positions that's how you got that Savings of not hire rehiring two positions I don't think we formalized what those positions
153would be right at this point but we gave you scenarios and we took two positions in their salaries based on where we thought one being a classroom teacher one being a specialist um and it wasn't a specific grade level obviously if we had our choice it would be a higher grade level that we wouldn't start lower um but that that was the conversation that we had but the buyout I'll I'll give to Michelle so she can talk about what that was thank you so the incentive that was offered was $115,000 um the there was an age restriction and a year of service restriction that went along with that um and for the five that were that the board accepted the incentive offers for um we then priced out what it would be to replace three
154of them okay at an M6 and then to not replace the other two okay and I guess I think then what I'm suggesting is not rehiring one additional yeah is that a decision that we're trying to make like here tonight I guess I'm wondering do we have enough information you know I would definitely want to understand the implications of that a lot more than I feel like I have been I don't feel like we've been briefed enough on what that would do for classroom teachers you know kind of the behind the scenes of what what the implications of that would be I don't feel prepared like I have that information I'm not requesting I I think what I'm thinking is I wanted to go ahead and introduce this now so we had a little bit
155of time because next week we do have to vote okay on passing this budget at least out of the board and so we have to make that decision before by next week on many teachers we rehiring uh are no how do you how do you want to characterize it that is a component but it's really we're passing a budget out of the board right yeah you're passing the budget and then and then we've got to figure out how to staff that based on what that budget is it is going to be a staff member I mean when you're you're if you're going to reduce it let's use the number if you want to get to 2% you're talking about $111,000 more out of this budget which could be a position so what Eric said if
156we reduced one more position or did not rehire back one more position that's what you're talking about is about $111,000 give or take and so we can give you specifics to that that's where you're at and so we can talk about what grade level that would look like or what that position would be uh but we can we can be ready for that for for next next week if if that would if I could just correct one thing Chris I just don't want to imply I'm not trying to get to a particular percentage number what I see is enrollment statistics and Trends and I'm just trying to align to that sure if it turns out to be 2% turns out to be 2.1 turns out to be 1.9 yeah I I was just using a
157a ball for the staffing that it would bring us one staff member is about 100ish and it would bring us closer to that 2% so we'd give you a percentage by the reduction of that one more teacher so that's why I use that percentage I'm not looking I just didn't want to set a goal post for I appreciate the clarification so I got a question um occupational therapists and speech therapists uh in the classification of teachers is that right they're in the CBA yes yes I just wanted to make a comment um Eric you're talking about next year obviously you know collective bargaining is going to happen um with the teachers um but we also last meeting we talked about you know um special education funding not going to be like as robust as it
158has been so I think that's also going to affect you know next year we have to kind of think ahead about that impact um also so I think being responsible this year and thinking about our budget going into next year um is is going to be responsible for us yeah I think the adran thing is a really interesting s thing that we have to like figure out because the study shows that it's increasing right in all five scenarios that's what it showed and yet we have seen in recent years a decrease so those seem to be at odds right and so that leads me to ask why are they at odds what's behind that what's going on are we going to continue to see a decrease in which case is the enrollment study flawed why
159is it flawed um what admin thinks about that and then I guess so that's part one um and then part two is yeah how how do we handle that as a board you know if we think that enrollment is going to stay static or as Eric brought up you know if it is going to be static or decreasing to not then hire more staff that we would then have to cut you know I I really appreciate that kind of point that we're at now so that we don't have to to cut teachers in the future because I agree I don't want to do that either um I don't know if we can have any comments from admin about enrollment and if you think the enrollment study is accurate and that you think like the recent
160dip is you know what what is attributed to that and if that will continue or if you think that the enrollment study was quite accurate and I I can just say you know a lot of schools when they're doing building projects or they're looking at enrollment they do enement studies and they're pretty pretty close to to Accurate that's why they give you six different types of scenarios of what could happen but they give you that range it's pretty accurate in that range in my previous experiences when we've done other building projects you you build a building you will see more influx of people coming into your your community I experienced that in my previous District when we added on to both the elementary school and the high school there significant increase that following year when
161you seeing new buildings being built or or new programs being able to be established in in your in your program so um I I would say that's why you hire someone to do that that's their expertise but in in my experience of the last 28 years when I've worked with other districts they're pretty pretty close to being accurate in their in their studies wait just a minute um are you saying if you build it they will come I'm not I'm not saying that what I'm saying is I've seen increases and that that's why when you're thinking about building projects that does go into the studies conversation and looking at uh sizes and and Building Development so they take all of that into consideration when they're when they're putting putting their their numbers together so then
162I I guess I might maybe a clarifying question to that is the enrollment study that we're talking about was done in 23 with the information at that time which is a large building renovation happening here we're no longer trending that way obviously so is that enrollment study then kind of flawed based on what we're actually proposing to do with the building like do you know what I mean it's going be like I I wouldn't say it's flawed but I also wouldn't say that there's a direct science to it you know I think you're still going to do a building project you're going to do upgrades it's going to be very attractive for families to move here because you have a newer building and you're not going to your budget is going to be set over
163years so when I read the um the um the enrollment study um it's not an exact science okay there's a lot of caveats in it so then I said to myself okay let's look at the town and I went out and talk to the builders I talk to four Builders who have built in this town and I talk to the planning board I talked to the select board and you know what I found is there's not a lot of geographical land available to build in town and the the land that is available is very expensive it's very expensive it requires the builders to put expensive homes on them to get to get a return on the investment so then you start to think about you know uh what are the probabilities that those uh big
164expensive homes are going to get sold to people with small children and I conclude clude that um I'm not convinced that we're going to see an enrollment increase I'm not saying we won't okay but I'm just uh I just don't think it's going to be the type of uh enrollment that some of the scenarios in that u in that enrollment studies say could happen can I just offer one more thing too because I think this gets to the heart of it I think when you're doing a building you're building something that's going to that's it's a physical structure so you really have to plan for how many kids are going to be here right I you have to think about it years in advance what I'm describing as something more of an an agile adaptable
165approach which is and I think we should probably create a policy I think we talked about that before that if we were going to set some goals we had goals that I didn't even know existed when I came on I didn't know that in 20120 that we even had that the board had made recommendations about it because it wasn't a policy I would suggest we actually do a policy we say these are what we would like to as a board have as acceptable class sizes in various classes I I used the AI to generate one in two seconds today actually so it's it's very easy to do I think we can come up with something in the policy committee what I'm saying is just that we look at it every year when you're doing the
166building you got to you got to really invest for the future but when we're talking about on a year-over-year basis at looking at actual enrollment not what we think is going to be three years from now not what it has been what is it next year what is it the year after that we can make those changes over time um what I what I think is the real challenge is when you when you have when you hire teachers and then you have to unfortunately remove someone because the enrollment goes down and that is not the situation that we're in the situation that we're in is that we can hire more teachers if the enrollment changes if enrollment goes up and this 15% decrease that we've seen over the past decade it reverses we can certainly
167hire we're talking about next year's enrollment numbers for our for our for this budget right that we're talking about right so that's the only other thing that I just wanted to mention Sophie it's it's to me it's about being adaptable and looking at the current data and then making adjustments and then being very upfront open with the town and I think a policy should say that in fact that that's that would be our approach to it so that it's not a surprise about how we make these decisions yeah I guess this is where I always get lost on the budget because you know our role as a board is to approve a number right and then it is up to Administration to choose how that money is spent I know for a fact they're always
168evaluating like what classrooms need what teachers and how big they should be and how many there should be so you know I think what we have to do is agree on a percentage that seems reasonable and then it is up to you know the people that we hired and Trust um to then decide what to do with that um I think one of the things I thought about tonight when um you know somebody said it is like are we under valuing under budgeting um and you know just to prepare for the future right so we're we're trying to cut the budget increase to 2% or whatever seems palatable next year they have to cut it you know um I'm just worried at a certain point we're cutting we're not growing with inflation costs we're just
169cutting um when you're under inflation right you're you're effectively cutting your budget um and that's something you know I'm worried about chasing this this 2% or whatever um is palatable I don't know how you guys feel about that I just want to say I don't I don't want to chase a percentage and that's why I was specifically wanting to say that to Chris what I do think is that we and that's the other comment that I made about let's see how that those inflation pressures influence the collective Barber process and I don't obviously don't want to get into that but I think it's a factor and it's just something that has to be considered as well so I I don't think that next year um I think it's a different set of Dynamics and it's
170a different conversation to have next year with with the town can I offer one Insight just from inside the building one of my can you put your mic up so we canot I'll hold it one of my favorite things is this is my eth year here so I know all the siblings and um family so when when I go into K And1 I'm like oh you look familiar do you know someone named Logan because I'm pretty sure you're probably right that's that's one of my favorite things a lot of our oldest siblings right now are in K1 which is a shift because our my my first year eight eight years ago it was the the youngest were in 3 four five and they were like oh you don't know my other sibling and now as
171I get to know these families K1 has a lot of new last names a lot of new families coming in and they're like do you know my sister June I'm like oh I don't she's five months old you know like an Orient um they don't know why um but that's just something I noticed and when we had orientation last year that was one of our first and that's just like an inside piece that like otherwise you wouldn't know when we look at the spreadsheet I'm like there's a lot of new names here so as we continue to chase siblings which I like to do because then I can link and remember their names um that's just a piece to consider like and I'm not an expert in enrollment but what I would say is is
172that is something that I noticed last year and again this year I mean it's so hard because we're trying to make a decision about a number that adma is going to use but without understanding the implications of that number like I don't feel comfortable making a recommendation so it's like yeah yeah um so I'm listening uh to all this and uh I've been studying the numbers pretty closely and a lot for the last week or so and one thing and we're talking about a school budget I know and when I uh when I ran for this position I can't believe I did but when I ran for this position I said I would bring another perspective to it okay because I'm a generation or several older than some of the board members and certainly the
173teachers here and uh and by the way for the uh third grade teacher who said uh that the older folks in town they don't they don't have your experience believe me we had it long before you were born no we went we went we went through it okay we went through it we we went through it with our we went through it as as you know Town res with the teachers and our kids as well so the same struggles same struggles From aent perspective to a teacher perspective is to be sure to be sure um but at any rate so I'm looking at the numbers and uh I I won't go through them in detail but uh coming very shortly are increases um to the taxes for uh the the co-op for the municipal increases
174um then we've got the bond and uh we've got the budget and we've got the reduction in uh state aid for special education um then there's the state number which is going up a little bit a small amount but it's going up so when I do the spreadsheet and I've been working with the town on this and then I then I look at the fact that uh about 50% of the taxpayers in town so there's about 3,300 taxpayers in town uh not that's excluding the commercial okay um about half of them more than half of them actually um experienced a significant to extremely significant tax increase already at the tax rate that you all know you have right now the $132 I got a call today from someone whose tax taxes when up 30% and
175his neighbors doubled okay now those are extreme to be sure but when I take everything combined okay and I look at um what's coming people are looking at tax increases if you include the last big one that they got of tax rate increases in the 20 to close to 30% range over a couple of years over a couple of years that's that's a lot so yeah we're looking at a budget here okay we're looking at a budget I understand that but I think I think I think we're actually looking at a major shift in the demographics of the Town people going to have to move they're going to be forced to move so I'll go back to what I said I'm a you know Generations older so I'm thinking about those people who are on
176fixed incomes and they they're living on Social Security okay they've lived in the town for decades okay we at least owe it to ourselves and to them to consider them to consider them absolutely Jennifer can I just offer one more thing for the board to think about so out of the eight budgets we've done in the SAU and I take the SAU budget out because that really helps Drive the tax rate for the seven School budgets stratum is the second lowest it's the biggest Elementary School with the lowest budget our budget range from anywhere this year from 1% increase to 6% increase and so I just want to give you a perspective that I I believe the administration in this board has listened to the public has really tried to get to get it to
177a point that that's manageable with the bond going on there um and I think every every budget we've had this conversation I know Michelle and MAV and the administrators so we didn't want to go any further but I just I want to give you that information that 2.73 is the second lowest budget in the SAU with the largest Elementary School by population thank you welcome okay I am very aware of the time it is 8:30 is there anything else the board would like to raise in this public session if not I I would encourage the board to you know um address questions to Chris um or to bring bring them up here we can do it for a couple more minutes any anything else that we should address in public okay um and we can
178always come back to this too but I would love to get going on some of these um oh do we need to talk about warrants right quickly U we'll just bring to you you can vote on it but what I would suggest is that you got a copy of last year's warrants what we will do is We'll add the building Bond as warrant as article number one it has to be there by law so you put your building anytime you do a building Bond or or Bond that's number one your budget will be two and then I would recommend that we we fund the three um again uh knowing special education costs what number you put in there we'll leave we can put what you had next year but that would should be a healthy
179discussion of what you want to put as a number and again that comes from our trust funds so it's even though it's not separate it is raised in appropriate from that year and there'll be um the fund balance at the end of the year that would populate those and just a reminder the order that you put your trust funds that's the order that they get uh funded based on what you have in your end of the year balance so if you are going to fund $50,000 over the 3 202010 and you only have 30,000 it goes 20,000 to the first one 10,000 the second and the third one does not get funded okay but it seems to me based on what we had recommended the only ones that really need to be funded is the
180maintenance trust fund for roughly 10 I forget what that was yeah you're getting close to that to that number yeah and then the tech fund for maybe 5,000 10,000 10,000 for the tech fund you're you're right at the number we were looking at for special education but again that that cover two students for one year so just you know if you don't want to because this isn't the year to do it that's okay but I just want make you aware then you have a recommendation to make I just ask what was our goal on the technology 50,000 50 yeah okay that was another thing because that was mentioned tonight um in one of the big increases that we had was when we made that change where we had to buy a whole new Fleet correct
181we reduced an FTE we we kind of repurposed a role um and that's something that we wouldn't have to do going forward because of this but it requires that funding yeah I thought it was interesting what the woman said about alternative trust funds do other districts have trust funds that we don't have the only one is uh Safety and Security but we are getting more and more federal dollars for that so we're not spending as much in those other funds actually making recommendations to draw those funds down as we've been getting uh competitive grants and having a grant writer helps that um a couple others are just worded differently um but they're for the same purpose so again it's the purpose of what you're doing with that trust yeah okay uh Chris and I yeah
182that's right Chris and I had a conversation about the U the maintenance trust fund and as much as I'm for saving money I wanted to increase what we put in that substantially to cover the windows so and Chris had made a recommendation well maybe we can do the windows a little at a time yeah that makes good sense so I don't know what what we were have been putting in the maintenance trust fund but we need to consider that we have a large expense of in Windows coming in a few years I don't know how many years but we need to consider that so you would recommend over the 50 or whatever it would okay so you know we have yeah we're struggling here trying to contain everything I wanted to put $100,000 in it
183okay I you know I'll acqu on that one 25,000 okay you know something like that okay um we got to get there yeah no that's helpful we got we only get 200 now and we're gonna we're going to dip into that for something so yeah do we do we have a stated goal on that or have you worked on that Paul in terms of what the that fund should look like um I haven't worked on it but I know what it should look like but at the same time as I said I mean it you know yeah if you want it to be where it needs to be we need to put at least 50 to $75,000 in in each of the next three years we don't if we don't do it if we don't
184do it this year we just push everything out another year and the windows don't get any cheaper either right right right and if the building doesn't pass that's what I think about too yes right okay all right so that's uh something else to the budget and the warrants next week anything else on those uh I just have a question about the the special education trust I just want to make sure I understand oh sorry um you had mentioned it's for like two um out of District students and that's like on hold for us because obviously we're we budget for special education and transportation that's just like unknown what might happen okay got it thank you yeah if nobody moved in right yep okay sounds great all right um I would love to move ahead with
185our presentations well that's another we just sent this to you guys did release yeah got to a couple of the slides but you can look at that more specifically oh yeah um Cindy Christa Brian Missy if you want to come up here Kate um I'm G to I don't know if the phrases shoot from the head but I think that's actually what I want to start with um I wasn't prepared to to start with this but I think it's important because I'm feeling this intense weight um and responsibility before we share the data um as a building administrator I recognize that the um our students achievement and performance is incredibly important and it and it drives our work um and when I came here seven years ago for me coming in I felt like the
186work that needed to happen was to build a sense of community to build connectedness to build a group of um Educators that uh trusted each other to be really vulnerable around the work that we need to do for children today and in the future um and I as the building principal prioritized that work um and in doing that I feel like I put us in a position where we're being um examined in a way that I feel like is not representative of who we are and so I apologize I'm being emotional but I'm really so proud of the people in this room and the experience the kids have and I don't want that to be lost in the data that we're about to present because this is not the whole picture of what happens for
187our kids every day and I'm incredibly proud of the way that we responded to the data from last spring uh the standardized data I want to be really clear about that so the standardized data that we um received last spring came as a surprise to me um the year before we had seen significant increases in our students Improvement and I think we felt like we were doing the things that we're going to continue to see that increase in student performance and it didn't um our Mass scores did not they actually went down which was really I actually called Chris like oh my gosh this was really surprising to me I wasn't anticipating that the learning that I was seeing in the classrooms was not indicative of what the students then performed on a computer-based one-time
188assessment um that being said it was a great opportunity for us to then um really be deeply reflective about what we wanted to do and not because it was about improving the test scores solely but because we want to make sure that everything we do is a critical examine is critically examined in the interest of our students and our staff um and so when we're talking about the data that we're going to present from the spring and then our response plan and then our fall data I think that that's a really important piece that I want us grounded in so tonight we are going to talk about really briefly the purpose of assessment the board members have this slide deck so you have this information so we won't go through every single slide um so
189the purpose of assessment the results from the spring the results from this fall and then our plans so yes it is incredibly important that we track our students progress it is incredibly important that we assess where our students at or any given moment so that we know that we can personalize the educational experiences that they're going to have um and more than all of that it's important because it gives us an opportunity to really look closely at the things we value and the systems we want to put in place to support our students um and so that's a huge part of why we assess our students the final piece on here I think is really important because I do think it gets lost in this conversation a lot is that the federal government um has
190every student succeed act which is their commitment um to ensuring that there is equity of educational experiences for all students in our country um and there's you can click on this and get more details about that for anybody that wants that um and stratum performs really well by their criteria so by the federal criteria we're in good standing we do the things that they're looking for and further on in here these are the things that they're looking for um you know we're looking at Equity High academic standards um local initiatives accountability to Improvement um and we are in good standing we are doing all of those things do I think there's continued growth um absolutely I think we're doing it right now but I think that that's an important piece that we kind of get
191stuck in some of the smaller um assessment pieces but when we think about our system at large um we are doing well um here are the long-term goals that New Hampshire has set up and aligned with um the every student succeeds act um and so if you look at these These are the goals for 2027 at any point you can look this up and it'll give you sort of the benchmarks that have been in place um leading up to this and we've been meeting those benchmarks so again good standing the other piece we wanted to talk about really quickly is the considerations when we're analyzing data and these are sort of three overarching ideas that we consider um and that's the data quality um um and we've made the reason this is on here is
192because these are sort of the things that drove some of the decisions we made in response to our spring data um and we'll talk a lot about that as we get further down but we have learned a lot um not just stratum but nationally about um kind of um Whitney sort of touched on like the bias of some assessments the inaccurate of some some assessments um and we have been able to um use current research and science of assessment um and really made some changes around that which feel really good the other part would be contextual understanding I think a lot of our families spoke to that um something I think stratum does incredibly well I don't think it does it I know it does it really well is to know every single one of
193our students really really well inside and out um and to personalize their experience and to care deeply about their whole being and their whole growth um not just their academic growth but all parts of them and certainly their academic growth is at the heart of that um but part of when we think about contextual understanding is understanding the environment and the Dynamics um and when um there are significant transitions within a school so teachers are out for long periods of time um movein move outs things like that those have can have significant impacts on um children and so there have been a significant number of transitions adult transitions um at stratum that have had implications for our students um and then the last one is that it's super super important for us to be looking
194at Trends over time over environments over assessments to really be thinking about how we can triangulate multiple points of data in order to really get at the heart of what we're learning about our students and the and our craft so we're going to look at Spring 2024 really quickly um what we were able to compile for everybody and I'm going to just do kindergarten as an example because you have it in front of you um here is our proficiency for kindergarten for example so there are 81 students in the spring of 24 um the first major um row uh is several but it's literacy and you see on the right where our students scored in terms of proficiency um and then at the bottom is math and then the social emotional piece and this was
195our kindergarten scores at the end of 2024 we have um the same for first grade same idea so literacy math and social emotional second grade third grade fourth grade and fifth grade um the thing I want to talk about is that um those assessments you'll notice um there was various assessments for each different um content area and then we have kindergarten through fifth grade New Hampshire SAS I think Whitney mentioned it as well doesn't start until third grade and so that's why this data is kept separate from the school at a glance because this is only done for third through fifth grade I'm just trying to understand that um f andp because it like it jumps F and panel Benchmark assessment system um it's a assessment we can give students that really we can standardize
196it we can give it multiple times across the year to look at gains um in aligns with grade levels just helps us to understand what text students can access and then what skills they need to access Beyond um I'm Kate blanger one of the three administrators um we are not overstaffed by any stretch of the imagination but I invite anybody to where roller skates and join me for a day um so I'm going to briefly review um some whole school data from our sass testing the double screens are distracting for me I'll do my best um so you know overall um and we do break these down by grade level but you can see um our Ela proficiency I me people can do simple math but just to explain this um levels three and four
197are considered proficient um levels one and two are considered below proficient and so you can see the breakdown here for ELA math and our fifth graders take the science test um and we broke it down by grade level here just so you can get a picture of what Ela math looked like for third grade fourth grade and then our fifth grade here I'm Christa staler I'm the math coach here at SMS I joined this school year so this data is not something that I was part of the administration for but I can speak to it this is the universal screening tool that we use we give it three times a year this is called I ready this data is showing the beginning of year compared to the end of year so The Faded bars are
198the beginning of your data and the brighter bars are end of your data and what we're hoping to see is that the greens get bigger and the Reds get smaller which they do so this is the entire school at a glance and um if you can see the the coating here is the the performance levels that I already has is um identifying if students are at grade level one grade level below two or more and when a student enters let's say third grade they will often score in the one grade level below category because they were one grade level below just before entering third grade so we would expect a lot of students to be in that yellow bar that's why that's so wide and by the end of the year they've learned that third
199grade content and now they're in the ONG grade level bar so that is what we would expect to see and this also demonstrates the growth the slides following this show the breakdown for each grade level so kindergarten first second third fourth and Fifth and I ready is given how many times three we're currently in the winter testing S window so if your kids are sorry um we're like we just need a little bit of information but it's a long day for them um so we have some celebration and action items based on um the data that we just reviewed um some celebrations uh like Kate had mentioned we continue to remain in good standing um with the doe and federal government um the I ready data that just reviewed um Trends are in the right
200direction as intended um and that helps us to measure our instruction um and then schoolwide you know it is worth celebrating the 32% of students who are above proficient in ela the 23% of students who were above proficient in math um and then we talk about action items like where do we go from here um one of our next steps or steps that we're in the middle of um analyzing the I ready and SAS data to identify the trends and areas of focus um and in the next slide I'm going to talk a little bit about what we have here um there are a significant number of students who scored partially proficient um and they were really cusping on the edge of being proficient right between that two and three category so that's data for
201us to look at and say how do we target that area um to move students two to two to five points in order to be proficient um because the windows are the window is not a matter of one point or two you know they're they're wider so um looking at who was close and how can we provide intervention and support and Target our instruction um and then also identifying relative strength and challenges through a more programmatic lens um what resources are we using what curricular materials are we using and um what benefits do they provide our students so more specifically um we went through and kind of looked at the number of students in each grade level that was right on that cusp of proficient and what that would mean for our percentages um because
202this helps us to project and set goals for what we're hoping for this year um so in third grade math if you take a look at the chart here there were nine students who were C being on that proficient if those nine students were able to move to proficient and be at a level three instead of a level two for their math scores um it would have moved from 57% proficient up to 68% proficient just to give a picture um for um Ela in third grade that's 10 students moving our proficiency from 64 to 76% and then if you take a look at fourth grade we had a large number of students 17 students who are right on that cusp of proficient um had those 177% been proficient um that would have moved the current
20353% to 77% can see the ELA here there were six students who were cusping um and this just kind of paints a picture of like what we are hoping for um and allows us to think about how we centralize our efforts um to move those students right on the cusp this is you one of the other reasons we wanted to um share that with you is because I think I'm Miss sit down so I can do the slides properly um in that when you think about that partially proficient and it's a wide range when someone says well the student scored a two and this student scored a two the reason each student scored a two can be vastly different and so just knowing that a student was partially proficient does not serve us as Educators
204and our ability to then address with that student what areas they might need um additional instruction in and so one of the things that you'll see when we get into our response plan is the ways in which we are looking um at data very differently this year and the frequency at which we're looking at data to be um responsive in a way that has been is very new for us because it is much more timely and in the moment um so our response plan um is a huge much of what you're seeing here and you will continue to see is um our efforts through our mtss and really bringing things aligned and together um so in the end of um the 23 24 school year um based on the data and some other research and
205things that we were doing we realized that we needed to um add additional screeners which are assessments that we had administer to the kids three times a year um they're very brief quick assessments that give us really important information to make sure um they're really what they do is identify student that might be at risk for not making a Year's growth or for not meeting um the academic standards for a grade level um and so we um added the I ready literacy we had been doing I ready math I ready literacy is new to us this year um the universal screener for number sense in its entirety K through five and aadience um K through 5 we had been doing it K through three for the dyslexia law um but we're finding it's giving us
206some really helpful more um granular data to be able to identify um areas that we can um can Target so that's the first part um the next is the curriculum progression reviews um So based on um the information because one of the things that we were able to find in our Deep dive um was that a particular unit in mathematics for our third graders was done after the assessment and so had it been done before the assessment it would have improved and changed our student scores and their performance but it was done it was some of the fractions it was done after the assessment and so by doing our progression reviews and our and our sequencing um it was it allowed us to better align things so an example of that would be here um
207in literacy so this document something very similar to this um has been done and this does this has our competencies it has the graduation standards it has has the I can or the performance indicators that are SAU aligned and then it has the Common Core State Standards so we're aligning across both federal and state and obviously SAU um 16 expectations so that's an example um from literacy and then in math um something very similar um same idea you can see the strand of mathematics um you can see the competencies you can see the performance indicators um and again um in this particular document you'll notice that some of it is yellow and some of it is green So within any grade level there are considered like core academic areas and then they're like subsets or
208the important but not as important and so these are highlighted so that we ensure that when we're going through our progressions um and we're um thinking about pacing and the areas in which we spend a lot of time and focus we're focused that our alignment is focused in that way as well um oh well that was quick I'll go there anyway so so um as everybody is well aware and we've talked about for a couple of years science of reading has really um helped us better understand literacy acquisition in our youngest students um and even if it's not all of that research there is lots of longitudinal research that talks about routine and structure when it comes to phic awareness and phonics in early literacy acquisition and so um our staff um after participating in
209lots of learning and workshops and courses um whether that's letters or Orton Gillingham with our two literacy Specialists um created not created um finalized a structure and a routine that we use K through five to really um ground ourselves in those early literacy skills um and then we revised all of our pacing guides so again an example so this is unit 2 um I think this is I might have pulled it from fourth or fifth grade um and then it's like literally the dates of you're doing it how many days you can expect these lessons to take um if you were to click on any one of the blue things it's going to bring you to the Common Core State Standards to give you more detail um so it's a really the in all of
210these documents um and these processes and this learning and this commitment to the vertical and horizontal alignment is then talked about uh weekly or bi-weekly so I'm going to just jump ahead really here it is it's right here just to the professional learning communities so so all the work that I just talked about um and all the conversations and all the student analysis uh student work analysis and the data analysis happens at our professional learning communities um and here's the schedule of that so you'll notice um second grade uh meets on Mondays from 8:45 to 9:45 for literacy on week one so that's the entire second grade team um meeting with Cindy Fitzgerald our literacy specialist where they're analyzing student data um they're reviewing the pacing charts they're picking the assessment M that might be
211coming up to ensure that we are um really keeping close watch on how our students are performing what instruction is um really supporting our students in which they're flourishing and where are there areas for us to collaborate around some of the pieces that seem a little bit that aren't making sense or that we need to talk about some more so that structure this PLC structure really supports the collaboration and the professional development that is um collectively growing us um so that's really important another piece that we built uh based on some of that uh data from the spring is that the um daily schedule for every student K through fifth grade every classroom there is a gredient support block um for students in which they can receive everything from Intervention special education services to enhancement
212enrichment opportunities so that's for every student um it happens twice a day once for literacy and once for math so um those are some of the pieces I was um mentioning in terms of the schedule the next thing that really comes out of our response plan is our Universal progress monitoring and data collection and when we first started talking about data tonight um and I mentioned sort of what the staff is doing this year and like this amazing feeling I have to be part of the staff that's doing this this is sort of I can't even imagine I I do imagine the weight and the burden that I've asked of our staff but this is an example so we wanted to be able to look at student data far more frequently and at a more
213granular level to figure out why some of our students weren't performing on standardized tests the way that we were seeing them learn every single day and show us they're learning every day something was not translating from what we were able to see in the classroom to what we were seeing on a computer computerized onetime exam picture student names down left yeah so I'll get so this is an example an actual example from a fifth grade classroom students names are on the left side and this is lesson one here are the three Common Core State Standards that are associated with lesson one and the teacher asked to go in and put for each student was during this lesson for this standard was the student able to show evidence of this were they developing or were they
214proficient within this and so as I said when I talked about thousands and thousands of data points this is what I'm referring to so every single one of our teachers has this for all of their students so um when we talk about the importance of our mtss coordinator when we talk about the importance of um being able to analyze our data this is sort of an example of what we were referring to so this gives us incredible um really close examination of what we're doing um and what it also allows us to do is to have that communicated across the entire staff that works with certain students so special teachers that um partner with this classroom can look at this um the Specialists whether it's literacy math or Briana as the mtss coordinator Administration um
215when we are at a child study team and we're talking about students when we're at the classroom study team team and we're talking about what's happening to our entire class we have access to this data in real time in a way that can inform us to be really really responsive to our students um this interestingly some of this sta that you're looking at right now I mentioned that we have a fifth grade cohort right now that's deeply into some extension we actually in math when you be able to take this so this is just one class but you're able to look at fifth graders as a whole and all of a sudden you're seeing all these erors where they're just excelling you're able to really then take that group and utilize that gradient support time
216to offer some enhancement and enrichment for those students and then of course um and if you click on the multi-tiered system of supports it's the presentation from um Miss Martin in October uh November close um but that's been an absolutely essential part of our response plan in um order to um ensure our students are succeeding and flourishing and thriving so fall 2024 hi I'm Banna Martin I am the uh multi-tiered systems of support coordinator um and we're going to take a look at the fall 2024 data which is kind of what we used part of our start of this year thinking what do we want to make sure we hit for students um what is this telling us about student needs that then we can then continuously gather data progress Monitor and make sure we're
217meeting students where they're at and moving them forward so looking at the whole schooled glance we'll start again with with kindergarten um I just want to point out with kindergarten two assessments that were not on the end of year um data sheet because they're only done at the start of the year there's the Bame which is a speech screener and the VMI um which is visual motor integration which is for an occupational therapy component and really um one of the things that I have felt so lucky about being in the school because I'm knew within mtss but had been a special educ here for a number of years um and having had that position in other schools the ability that we have with a fully staffed um speech and OT Department within special education to
218take a look at kiddos right from the time that they enter and see is there anything that's going to need a little boost here um it's amazing sometimes what a six to8 week intervention can do for a student who just needs a little bit more explicit construction whereas in other districts where I've worked where we haven't been able to provide that response to intervention or that um nonsp specialed support because all of our speech and OT resources have been tied up in special ed um we have not been able we often we see an increased number of referrals which usually leads to increased cost for the district so I love that we get to get to kiddos early and often provide a much less restrictive um response that gets them where they they need to
219be moving right along with their peers um in terms of what our expectations are for kindergarten students at the start of the Year we're looking at typically any other grade level you're thinking well did they Master everything from what came before understanding with kindergarteners that what came before kindergarten isn't a hugely varying experience for our student population you'll often see numbers that start out looking very strong like these numbers are looking but also letting us know like here's where we might want to step in and just make sure they have the foundational pieces that they need for moving forward um here's our grade one data again we can see we're looking at phonics we're looking at their placement in The Benchmark assessment um we introduced the I ready reading and then we're continuing to look
220at those developmental SK spelling skills we had added in the Universal screener for number sense and I think especially as we get into some of the higher grades we see a discrepancy there between um I ready math and Universal screener that lets us know oh this is some really good additional data to have so that we can look more deeply um we weren't necessarily getting this information before by just administering the I ready math um and we continue to administer the social emotional screener as well so here's our grade two and you can see here a little little split between the universal screener for number sents and I ready math but pretty much on track um but as we got into higher grades there notic a larger difference there um and particularly you can see
221within our fourth graders that performance on The Universal screener for number sense really let us know when I see a number like a 51% I'm not thinking I'm going to intervene with a whole bunch of students right I'm thinking okay this is great information about what we want to work on with our grade levels and we'll talk more about the response plans to that that came from that as we move forward similarly in grade five we see that difference between the IR already math and what it's saying about our student levels and the universals creator for number sense they're just looking at slightly different um in terms more at strategy use more at um performance within an interview that gives us some really good information about that correlates I think more strongly to what we
222see from students in the classroom than on the computer sized assessment months and then we added in IR really literacy so our literacy specialist will tell us about it hi I'm Cindy Fitzgerald I'm one of the reading Specialists here literacy specialist this year um we as you can see adopted I ready Literacy for our K to 5 we did not use it last year so unlike math we we can't we weren't able to compare beginning to end but this year we will be able to do that because our students are currently taking it midyear and then they will take it again at the end so we are looking at this slide and we are seeing what we would expect to see which is that yellow which the first time this the first time I've used
223already in literacy I saw that and and my first thought was like whoa wait yellow yellow's not good but going back to um what Christa was saying I won't repeat all of it because it was spot on it's just like math we are looking at so if you take a second grade child you are in the fall assessing them against um the standards and the expectations for the end of that year so yellow is one year behind which is where we would want them to be they're ready for their grade level um and then in math if you remember if you looked below that there was um the end of the year that yellow we want to shrink as well as the red and the green to grow so that would be what we'll be
224able to look at our students are taking it right now and then again in June um we also I won't go through each one because you have the these slides but here's our first grade already and this is again fall data second third fourth and fifth celebrations I get to do the celebrations um so some of the celebrations from um the the most recent data we shared um the additional screeners we added Briana was pointing out to you the the new information we gathered from that Universal screener for number sense that was really highlighting some areas that we need to dig into further so a celebration would be the new additional screeners that we administr administered are providing really helpful data and information for us that we perhaps were missing before um this helps to
225organize our gradient supports and our extension opportunities for students in areas that the I ready assessment data that we were using was potentially missing so that's exciting for us to have new information intervene in new ways and then watch how that pays off um we now have screeners that are highlighting the areas of needs before and um we also were able to conduct um Administration was able to meet one-on-one with every single staff member in this building uh we sat and talked for 10 minutes and we were able to really determine some patterns challenges and successes across the building to streamline our efforts everything from professional development to just overall support um to make decisions that would be best for everyone um and that was one of our best favorite weeks and things to do
226um we have a quote there from a teacher who um to Kate's point they're collecting a lot of data it's a lot of time and energy to go and and Mark every single student where they're at with every single standard sometimes over and over again um and so a quote from a couple of teachers is like forcing me to record and share the data has actually helped me to know my students better than I ever have um because to work intimately with their data and not just say yeah I think they got it um but to really know what do they understand and I I imagine that will improve um experiences at student lead conferences and Reporting um for families action items for US based on this data um how does a more consistent and
227comprehensive structured administration of Assessments impact student performance um what environments are we providing for students when we are giving that assessment what does proctoring look like what does practice look like um a lot of school districts will spend a lot of time practicing the assessments there's lots of extra test questions on there how can we provide students because some some of the challenge in estate test just navigate the system right there's a highlighter tool I could play with that for 10 minutes like so you know how do we how do we remove some of that um and and explore different ways to support students so they can be more effective and really demonstrate what they know um and then explore how the current screening tools uh can be expanded upon even further to provide longitudal
228longitudinal data across the building back to you Kate for a response plan so as I mentioned actually earlier when and I said I would talk about it later um we had been using aadience K through3 as our dyslexia screener um and one of the interesting things that also came out of that was the staff response to saying like this actually also helps me in the work that I do um and there was a um piece of it as well that was it's giving us data and it's not taking as much time which gives me more time with the kids and so that was a response as a collective of things we feel like would be really helpful um the other part of that that people appreciate is that it's nationally normed um which for them
229feels really good and because um we are going to be able to have it electronically we can be entering all of our data it can do a lot of the data analysis and synthesis for us um in a way that's been really hard in terms of longitudinally um additionally we have had um we and continue to have professional learning and training opportunities um as I mentioned um the staff is incredibly committed to uh growing their understanding of best practices especially with all the new research that's coming out so the of staff that have gone to Orton Gillingham training or have invested in letters um it is just uh we just had a person come back from a writing um the science of writing workshop and so it's just the commitment to um continuing to go
230our practice has been um really evident this year um and then we are using our plcs that I mentioned um earlier to um analyze student work to ensure that we have inter reliability when we're looking at proficiency so if there's a team of five teachers um in first grade and they're looking at first grade writing that they're all looking for very much the same thing and assessing it the same way which is especially in writing really subjective and can be really challenging so they've done a lot of that work as well um I can't see behind Raymond's hand thank you um we are we've been really being thoughtful um about maximizing our student access to our specialized staff so part of what our gradient support blocks has allowed us to do is really think about
231flexibility with our students um we still have we're still looking forward to even further ways to do that but has really offered um recently we had our literacy Specialists um supporting um and collaborating with our special ed teachers in second grade around literacy so we could maximize um the number of students really getting some explicit um specialized instruction um so there's a lot of amazing um pieces that the the Educators in this building are doing um even in response to the fall data that came in so spring 25 and Beyond um we have uh last year we formed um we've had the framework committee for a number of years um but last year out of that work came a need for a specific committee focused on math at our school and a specific committee focused
232on literacy um and so those committees meet once a month um and are really doing deep dives into research and programming and curriculum and best practices um and then being really um intent about communicating back to the rest of the staff so that everybody is on board and understanding um the direction we're going and having opportunities to participate and contribute and then we wanted to open up to questions to any member of the team up here I I can go if you don't mind I don't um I don't know that I do have some questions in here I too was deeply disappointed uh since September when I saw these um being the eternal optimist that I honestly am I really found a couple of pieces interesting which was the partially proficient and proficient partially proficient
233and proficient slide I my hunch is based on the quality of the teaching the kids there's nothing wrong with our kids when you look at our kids relative to other kids in other elementary schools that score better I I I've always thought that it was the kids on the bubble the cusp as you describe I really believe that if we can move the kids on the cusp and your numbers show it you'll get the results that I would like to see I believe that I think the stuff that you're saying is all right like I I I like the direction that you're going it sounds like a lot of stuff it sounded like a lot just cuz we were being presented with a ton of information my only fear is some of it might get
234lost in the weeds just a little bit because making big changes like this in terms of a lot of daily operations I don't know how well that's working you can describe how it is um but I think this is really important to do um I would love to take this issue off the table that's what i' love to do I'd love to take State assessment and our Port performance on it off the table when we go and ask for things as a board it makes everything easier it makes everything easier for all of the things that that this Administration ask for when we when we when we get that done and I don't mean it as a checkbox activity I think what's really great is the stuff that I'm seeing the alerting mechanisms the curriculum
235review the sequencing of curriculum I love that I like the I like the the going in and finding more data and and going into each class for each teacher trying to determine that and working with our our mtss coordinator we haven't seen the the results of what that really is going to be until next September right so I I appreciate that I again am uh very hopeful and optimistic about it um but I think you know the proof in the pudding is going to be in the eating when we see it next uh next September um just to be honest with you um anyway those are my thoughts the only other two I guess this is questions not just statements I do have a question on the pacing guides I had a question about the
236pacing guide I didn't quite understand how that was relevant to I I know it's relevant but I didn't I couldn't draw those connect the dots myself on that so yeah so um yeah so the one of the things um I think Eric that every teacher faces is when you have a class of 17 kids and our job is the balance between taking them exactly where they at where they're at but then also ensuring that you expose them to the entire curriculum of the grade that they're in and so it can be really hard as a classroom teacher when say 12 of your 17 kids are just not showing you yet that they're that they're proficient in the content so you stay a little longer than you should so you say three days instead of the
237two days and so the next thing you know you're not covering the content you need to cover within the grade or so you don't and I coverage is the worst thing because it's like God that's actually about learning it's not about covering um but it is our legal obligation is exposure to the grade level curriculum right and so that said when you want to personalize it sometimes kids aren't ready for it and so that is a constant battle and so it's very very easy for good teachers great teachers to say I'm just going to stay cuz I'm we're so close to getting it we're just on that cusp but you have to keep going you H and so this allows us to be really thoughtful about like you know what I know you're going to
238want to stay here but we really need to stay within one or two days otherwise you're going to get to the end of the year and you've missed a whole unit you won't even expose the kids to a whole unit and so we really tightened up that and and we're able to review it all the time so when they meet at their weekly PLC like how are we doing are we close are we off by a day or two because they know you might have an assembly one day or you might have a teacher was out for 3 days so there's like constantly going back to this and having it documented really keeps all of us accountable to like ensuring that we're maintaining some proximity to that it is not like everybody on page seven
239day S I don't want to be I don't want to mislead you but it really is a piece that really gives us perspective of where we should be and the time it should take and there's lots of research that says this lesson should take about three days because of what you're doing or this one's only going to take a day um so I it really guides us in a way that we hadn't had done before okay so this is new oh yeah okay Concepts that had come up and um the teachers were like you know it's really hard to teach time over the course of just four days like how am I going to teach that I read a clock in just four days um and that opened up a conversation about how something like
240telling time should be embedded throughout your day every single day for 180 days so how do we adjust our analog clocks how do we add that into morning meeting how do we say hey is it time for recess prove it right like how do you build that into your day so that it's not just isolated to that math time to say these are our four days to learn math so those are best practices when you can interweave those that instruction throughout your day and year and it just opened up a really great conversation about how can teachers possibly fit everything in you can weave it through your day so just the pacing conversation is what got us there it was like how do you do time in four days and then it landed in a
241place of like here's how you can build it in all year and that's what we want for our kids so these these open up great conversation at plc's one thing I would add to that is I think pretty universally you know we know we're at our in our best place when we're finding balance and that these this conversation having these data sheets and being able to meet talk to together it keeps it helps us maintain that balance between the amount of curriculum that needs to be covered and what students are needing um in order to be ready to move [Music] on yeah no it makes total sense um on the professional development piece we we're do okay on the literacy side and kind of always like I'm I've never been as worried on the literacy
242side as the math side you guys are doing some stuff on the professional development getting groups together what's come out of that has anything actionable come out of those professional development brainstorming sessions yet about regards to math in particular so I mean do you want to talk about some of the stuff that you've been doing so I I wanted to say there's actually I just had an awesome conversation with the special ed Department today about math so as you know the shift in math is much newer than literacy there has been a concentration in literacy in public education for a very long time like 50 years 40 years like a real Focus math has been more like 15 years where it's been a real shift in like making sure that there's complex conceptual understanding um
243what is missing is opportunities for really good professional development regards to like I go to like that kind of thing where like it's you can find literacy Left Right everywhere math is just finally getting more accessible to people number one it is very inaccessible to special education they do not have the resources in special education for mathematics instruction like they do for literacy I just had this huge conversation because they're like it's so hard to keep current in all of math if you're a special educ because you're like I'm actually going to get speal you know my my professional learning is focused on special education or neurodiversity so that is a major Gap that we've been working really hard on and figuring how we're going to fill that so I just wanted to address that
244because that is a piece of like that PE that puzzle of like intervention before a student is identified is a piece we really have to focus on that said a number of our teachers have gone to some great things um the National Council for teachers of mathematics they went to DC last year it has brought new daily practices that we do every day in the classroom um we worked with Caroline Worcester um and broke apart like the the need for you know the the beginning or the the concrete understanding to the more of the representational to the abstract so we have done a lot of those things that are now daily practices that align with best practices in our classroom that we've learned through professional development opportunities they're just more scarce than literacy I would
245agree with all of that and uh part of my role I see as bringing as much professional learning through the plc's as possible that's where those unpacking conversations around pacing I'm constantly talking about the high leverage standards as Kate Lucas was talking about earlier that there are there's a lot of research to show that there are major areas of focus and so we Center our conversations around that I have just started some conversations around deeply understanding learning progressions and various resources that exist for educators that are that are um really solid reliable sources of information and um as you can see on this slide there are a couple things that we're moving towards so there's this really silly acronym oap that's up there that I am a gigantic fan of it stands for the ongoing
246assessment project it offers phenomenal math training for educators in four strands it is intensive and I have just started conversations with teams some people have a little bit of experience some people have never heard of it and uh we were talking today like how do we get them here um there's also some opportunities often in the summer for free trainings for New Hampshire Educators so that's on my radar and it's a priority uh because I would agree in terms of um the the quality and um amount of training in literacy versus math it's a little leaner in the math department and then lastly um another thing that we are going to be working on is trying to pool and streamline all of the resources around math uh across the building and across grade levels there's
247a lot of awesome things in this building that are just sort of Lost in the the hustle and bustle of the day and trying to have a bank that's really organized um is is the next step for me as well and you must I'm sure as you're working with different students from different teachers some of this must be targeted I'm sure there's some teachers who are just based on their training are more competent in this area and lesser so probably even self- admittedly so in all things yeah right right absolutely okay um two more sorry student wellbeing how much of how much disregulation we talked about disregulation from a behavioral standpoint and I'm not talking about the kids who are disregulated I'm talking about the impact of disregulated kids on other kids how much of
248that affects their ability to keep on this pacing how would you quantify that I think that's very difficult to quantify um one thing I meant to wanted to add on to the professional development conversation that we were just having was around that regulation component and understanding that we have to have that regulation before expectation right you had mentioned it earlier that Miss Dello had referenced it as an obstacle um or something that we're really working on skill building with students and one thing that we are doing universally is some work um within the whole school in the grounding ourselves in the under in the underpinnings of educational neuroscience and that helps us to have a much more effective um brain-based response to disregulation that helps to minimize it over time as well as in an
249inance instance of disregulation whether it be a student who's quietly shutting down due to anxiety or having um an expression of their disregulation that is more likely to impact others we're able to respond more effectively and I think having weaving in the support from our um Behavior interventionists has been a huge piece in kind of being able to respond more quickly and um help students get to where they need to be for learning much more rapidly and consistently um Brian mentioned sort of the Neuroscience piece of this I think it's really important one of things that we've been learning as a staff that we sort of call disregulation disregulation it is so much more complex than that and it's so much harder to tease out so there's like physical disregulation right your vestibular system and
250then there's emotional disregulation and they often can present the same or similarly and they are uh the response to each of those is vastly different right and so ensuring that we all continue to to have the professional development about be able to identify that and then knowing the response is very different um occupational therapist has an incredible expertise um and they and their the work they do with kids is very different than potentially what maybe our one of our school guidance counselors is doing even though at first glance the student may have been presenting with you wouldn't be able to tell so that's a piece of the work that we're constantly doing so dis regulation is this like huge umbrella and manifest itself in very different ways and so that's a piece that um I
251think all educators are really trying to work through because the responses are very different I'm not an OT so I could can I do two more I promise I'll make it quick test prep this might be an easy question do we are we focused on that just I mean prior to I know there's probably I'm sure there's some I'm sure that you're doing it but I mean is there any area for marginal Improvement that gets those cuspers across the edge so one of the so one of the things that Kate and I and well I'll give it to you in Chris just a second is that um some teachers take it very seriously right and do like the interm assessments they do like really get on there and explore it other teachers spend a little
252bit less time and that's not a criticism I think Eric going back to a lot of what we're talking about like that balance of trying to figure out because all the time you spend on test press you're taking away from instructional practice and you're taking away from learning and so I think that's a cont continual battle but I do think we've all acknowledged that there are some foundational things that we could have in place in every classroom no matter what that would absolutely help a student feel more comfortable navigating the interfaces for sure and feeling like they're familiar with the the genre of test taking in a way that would help them navigate that better and potentially perform better just this week I've been helping the three through five grade level teams with some really
253actionable next steps of how to not cram for the test I'm not um my I in a former life was a curriculum director so I have some pretty strong opinions about this and about test prep and how to do it really authentically so that students enter with um the least amount of anxiety and the most amount of feeling prepared um knowing that it is but one one single data point in many to get a whole picture of what our students know and are able to do and so uh something I'm very passionate about is helping students and teachers feel really prepared for the New Hampshire State assessment system by um incorporating uh a problem of the day situation where we teach to the level of rigor of the test the item type of the test
254and the user interface of the test and that could be done really intentionally and thoughtfully for just five minutes of a lesson and have it aligned to what's being taught in the classroom so that it feels very seamless um and then that way we're not teaching to the test I don't believe in that that's not what we're here to do but we are preparing them authentically and so um that's the work that I've been starting and it is January and if you do that a few times a month you're much better off when May comes around and we sit for the test yeah thank you for that last one is a pral this could be a short one or or a long one I have opinions about this but how are we doing anything you
255can look at a lot of different metadata out there parental involvement is is a factor how much emphasis how much of a success criteria do you place on Parental involvement and I know not every parent is going to want to become involved I'm not suggesting that we make mandatory parental involvement there are parents who do want to be more involved how do we do that do you think that that's something that it's impactful I think that one thing that we that the research is very clear on is that for students who have for example trauma stress umon issue any difficulties with learning a strength based approach is what's going to be most effective and approach that also builds off of the strengths of their family and community support system so from my angle one thing
256that I really look forward to doing I think you know being relatively new in this position and right now I'm in a place of a lot of system building but one thing that I really look forward to expanding as we get those systems into place and there are pieces that I can remove my hands from a little bit is our community connections and um continuing to create welcoming spaces for families and also getting to know them really well so that we can access those strength to support students great I'd love to hear more about that once you've got it um you know they'll read the newsletter and say what else can I do so I do see a good amount like as far as being working in several different communities over the course of my
257career the support from families here is phenomenal um so I think that the more we can harness that and access that the better um but and I do think our students benefit from that regularly but the best point of communication for any families listening is to connect with their classroom teacher and figure out you know what what you can do to best support your child I agree I would say if they're asking yes that that should be that should be a signal yep that we could go the other direction too so don't they don't need to ask like here's here's some ideas yep one of the things that um I'm really proud about in our department in special education is the way that we approach um meetings for example in a very disarming way a
258lot of uh parents and Guardians who come to meetings are coming with some emotional baggage of their own maybe they've not had positive experiences in school uh or their worry for their child uh is manifesting in some um you know um some feelings about their parenting um and in special education we throw around a lot of ACR and I think it can be really intimidating and I'm really proud when I see that our approach to engaging families in the special education process is successful in a way that you can tell that some of the guard has has come down and um that families are feeling more comfortable asking uh questions that they might not have felt comfortable asking uh otherwise so I think so some of it is just the relationships that we have the
259opportunity to build with families too and I think uh that's an important consideration in your question yeah um I just have two comments I think um you know kind of going opposite Eric you know my my kid was supposed to start kindergarten fall of 21 obviously did not she has a very different experience at school than her older siblings and you know she get so much anxiety from these tests like she came home today and she was like I'm 1% done with I ready Matt you know um Mom and you know I know I'm going to get percentages and so I hear what you're saying about prep but I think you know there are kids that this is so stressful they're very aware um that they're being evaluated and um yeah so yeah I just
260want to just bring that obviously you know it I but I just want to you know kind of speak for parents that it's a hard time right now these kids know no and and something new Jennifer that we've done this year and your daughter may have come home and told you a little bit about it but we we really tried to sit down and talk with students about why this test is being given how it's designed how it's actually designed in fact for you to get 50% of it wrong because that moving meter is trying to figure out where you are so when you get one wrong know that you probably got the last one right they're trying to find your sweet spot that background and understanding for so many students this year we're like
261oh okay that feels a little bit better cuz I was feeling like I was getting a lot wrong so while it doesn't take care of everything that's an additional piece we've done where there was a streamlined PowerPoint presentation for all students to get the same message on how these tests operate so there wasn't that frustration yeah and then I guess secondarily you know um you guys do after school enrichment and um we've we've done it every term but like there's no um I would love to see like a math or spelling or you know a a book club who knows um have you have you considered you know doing math after school in these arren classes so I know this would be years ago they Mike oh yeah sorry this would be years ago that
262there were several of those offered and nobody kind of this was pre-co was like my first year and maybe into that fall and it just wasn't being filled up and when they don't take seats they don't you know we did have u a math club my first year of fifth graders that did it during recess um and then but I think what we're trying to do is sort of use that gradient support block to do that enrichment within because what we are also finding is like kids are over booked overstressed doing so many things and for families another thing outside of school hours is really complicated that said I'm happy to talk to the staff about like this I mean we do have newspaper this year which is new um Kristen actually put out debate
263debate was one of the ones that was put out um so we are we are always open to if there was interest in things we would want to offer it so we could certainly try and you know add that to the spring yeah yeah I would I would love to see yeah I would love to see some math b or something uh definitely math is our strugg all right any other questions or comments okay thank you guys so much thank you it is so late I really appreciate it special ed you want to it up the slide deck just this slide deck just now if you would like yeah yeah I just but you knowbody and that's again it's not the be yeah I just want her that's what I think SMS should be because
264they were remote of course start checking in oh checking with the babysitter good you still still good are you still awake you still good kids are asleep so I'm mindful of the hour um and U my own stamina so um this is sort of a continuation of a presentation that I gave this time last year to answer questions for the board about um the progression of uh special education in enrollment or eligibility rather and um some of the costs associated with it so uh Dr Andi is sending that slide deck to the board so that they can be looking at it and can jump in uh with questions rather than me going through uh every item um extensively uh and risking not hitting on something that people are more interested in learning about full disclosure
265I'm colorblind and so I don't know if what you're going to see is going to um mess with your eyes be because it looked right on my screen but it might not look it's wildly offensive the color scheme it's very right it's pretty it's pretty bad yeah um yeah I I hit up a lot of unsuspecting fellow Shoppers when I'm picking out clothes um okay so this is just sort of the progression it just hits on um in enrollment uh overall enrollment and the number of students in special education with a percentage and then some other statistics like the number of referrals that we had received um uh U by the way I'm ramond pills Ram the director of Special Ed this is my second year in this role uh my 23rd year in education
266I've had a lot of work done um so the um so some of these things predate me so it's it it's information that I pulled from other sources um so what you'll see is that the uh the percentage of students within the student population who are uh receiving special education it fluctuates a little bit but it stays uh pretty standard some of the things that I find uh the most interesting are the number of new referrals um that tells us quite a bit about what's going on for our students um uh so the uh bottom right hand corner uh is so far this year as of the end of December and already this year we've had 21 new referrals uh and of those 21 uh we have performed 14 uh special education eligibility evaluations and
267for those of you who don't know how involved and comprehensive the evaluation process is it's very arduous for students to be going through it's very arduous for our staff to be administering it takes countless hours to administer the evaluations and then to do the documentation afterward so uh the uh column so the uh column on the left is just a repeat of that bottom corner the uh column on the right is just the array of different disability categories that special education serves um that number doesn't total the uh total number of students who are receiving special education because it's plausible that some students have more than one of these disability categories it's just interesting the array and percentages there uh some of the available Services you can see those um we have a large percentage
268of those that are provided by School staff and then um we contract for highly specialized um services such as behavior management Audiology Vision feeding spelling things that we don't have the Staffing for inhouse uh or the population of students to justify hiring somebody uh as to provide that in-house so uh it's customary for special education departments to contract with Specialists uh one thing that I will say is that those contracts are becoming increasingly expensive for schools um and uh some of that is because to find those Specialists is really challenging because of Staffing shortages and so the charge that we incur uh for those contracts tends to keep going up and up and up U because they're harder to come by um in our um pool of resources um this is just the uh Staffing
269for the most part in in our department and our Affiliated departments like the uh nursing uh Department department and the school counseling department things have stayed relatively uh flat uh over the years the um asterisk on the rehab Assistance or esps that's our par professionals um uh I put that there to remind myself that that is not the total number of par professionals that are employed by our school it's a rough idea of how many are funded through special edit uh exclusively and this year because of uh shortages in being able to hire par Educators we've had to contract with some outside agencies to fill those positions these are just the numbers uh one of the things that I'll say about trying to budget for special ed is that it's a really big guessing game
270and uh there are lots of surprises in this work and um when we are trying to estimate how much um things are going to cost what we can't account for is those situations where IEP teams uh make decisions about what a student needs um that we hadn't um anticipated or that we didn't want to sort of prejudge ahead of time and be wrong about that so sometimes uh we guess High sometimes we guess low uh and it can be a little challenging to get those numbers exact and then we do try to when we're projecting for the following year take a look at what our actuals which are the ones in green to to make decisions for the coming year um but there are always new students moving in uh there are always uh students
271whose situations dramatically change and require more services um and uh so budgeting for special education can be really tricky it's just uh uh what I wanted to break down here that I didn't do on the previous slide was that uh tuition and contracted Services I lump together because it's kind of of the pool of funds that get drawn from to support the students in our school who have the most intensive needs so some of those needs are met through outof District placements which is tuition some of those needs are met through contracted services with those uh Specialists that I was talking about so um I lump those two lines together because uh sometimes uh tuition is uh lower because we don't have so many students in out of District placements um and sometimes they're higher
272so um there's a little bit of interplay between those two all right just a word about um uh just contracted Services placements and transportation so contracted Services it's really uh those are those services for students who have much more intensive needs that exceed our staff capacity um so some of those things are like bcba behavioral supports uh instructions for students with hearing and vision impairments and so forth um by providing those Services um we are able to help prevent the need for outof district placements because we're able to meet those needs within the public school um and otherwise um we wouldn't be able to uh keep so many students in our school we would have to rely more on out of District placements which are significantly more expensive autod District placements that's when the IEP
273determines that uh a student's needs cannot be met within the public school and um there's there's quite a process that goes into making that decision um not the least of which is really making sure that we have attempted with good faith all of the different uh interventions at our disposal including contracted services in order to support a student with staying within their public school um if a if after all of um those efforts a student ends up um requiring an out of District placement um we generally we'll see a reduction in the contracted Services line because we no longer need to provide those services to that student the needs are being melt met uh out of District transportation um that's sort of the bane of my existence if I'm being honest uh we're at the
274mercy of what the uh Transportation companies charge us um and when a student goes into an out of District placement which involves a greater distance um that's particularly expensive so um that's one of those Larks this is something that I wanted to really emphasize so um we make every single decision about special education with the Mandate that we're under to be the least restrictive possible meaning that under uh federal and state law every student with a disability uh is entitled to a right to receive their education in the public school with typical non-disabled peers to the maximum extent possible so um we don't make will uh nilly willy-nilly decisions about that a great deal of thought goes into it oftentimes a great deal of uh Services uh preventative Services go into that um but if
275we make a decision uh for a student that is more restrictive such as those contracted Services uh or an out of District placement we are on the hook with the state of New Hampshire to justify that very extensively in our documentation um to make the case for that was truly what that student needed so it's not a financial decision when we're making those decisions it is based on what the students rights are and what they truly need need um so um placement that placement decision that is everything from uh receiving special education uh Services uh within a classroom in a pullout setting uh all the way to an autod District placement each of those decisions is Guided by that least restricted mandate uh it's important to note that the decision- making is shared among a
276students IEP team so no one person on a child's team makes the decisions that's done by uh consensus among the members of the team and that uh the services that we provide kids is not one siiz fitall uh so our placement decisions for example uh we don't offer the same placement to a category of students who have a particular U set of disabilities uh or uh based on the severity of their disability we truly are on we have an obligation to make sure that we individualize it based on what the students actual needs are uh these are the things that are beyond our control in terms of um what uh drives up our uh expenses in special education um certainly Staffing that's part of it um the tuition and contracted services tuitions are on their
277way up uh contracted Service rates are on their way up uh it's harder and harder to get out of District placements and to secure those contracts therefore they're a lot more expensive Transportation I already went into that consumables such as book supplies and equipment also includes the evaluations that were required to administer to determine if a child is eligible for special education and those are subscriptions they're very costly those costs go up every year uh and extended school year in the summertime that's based on eligibility and we see it you know year after year an increase in student need and sometimes to meet those needs we have to contract for some extra Serv Services um this comes from Dr Bennett's uh memo that uh the board U was looking at last month um some of
278the cost drivers and this is not limited to uh SMS um the there's a dramatic increase uh in students requiring special education the needs of students is becoming increasingly complex um such as the increasing prevalence of mental health needs um uh the increase of what we call co-occurring disorders meaning a student having more than one significant disabling condition um critical shortage in critical shortages in community care so if our students are unable to access Counseling in the community for example um the schools end up having to pick up a lot of that um uh now slack I hate to say it's laack but you know what I mean um uh increased needs uh for out of District placements in order to respond to the complexities and so forth um contracted Services costs private tuition costs
279or drivers Transportation costs um all of the required evaluations assessments and subscriptions that we maintain um uh become increasingly expensive uh it's important to note that the increased Demand on staff time is a contributor to the um the expense of special education so uh every month the state sends me a lovely uh memo that I then have to decide how I'm going to break to my uh special Educators um uh asking them to do more and more and more um with the same within the same amount of time um the increase in referrals and eligibility determination evaluations is very costly in terms of time which takes away um from student support time unfunded mandates that's sort of uh what we're up against all the time and um we do receive uh um Federal grant funds
280which help offset some of our costs and those keep going down and down every year and then uh a big issue that we were talking about last month is that special education aid from the state of New Hampshire to local districts um is uh anticipated to go down by almost 31% from uh 2023 um it's important to note that special occation is dictated by both federal and state laws so we don't wing it uh it's it's all driven by at every stage it's driven by uh federal and state guidelines um it's important that uh you understand that special education is all about supporting students um to experience equity and inclusion uh in the public school setting that's a requirement by federal law um we're striving to remove barriers to learning and um we are not
281only helping students to find success in school but to also set a stage for their uh for their future um opportunities and meaningful contributions and uh it's not merely a legal requirement it's a moral and ethical Duty that we have for our kids lastly uh it's important to note that um if we are not following the law if we are um not funded adequately so that we can adhere to the laws that tends to be much more costly to school districts uh lawsuits and and so forth um and in particular it's costly to students with disabilities um being unable to realize their full potential that's it Raymond could I just ask a quick one of course very rarely does my mic have a red light so it's getting late um when you go from a
282contracted service to an out of District placement are the contracted Services contracted such that you're going to have to pay that for the whole year okay no all right thanks no it's driven by a child's um individual education plan or IEP but the contracted service doesn't have to be contracted for like the whole school year no just hours they in the building interesting all right well that's good yeah also just a question you said special ed had stayed relatively stable like 18% but then you talk about as a driver increased referrals I was just confused yep so thank you because what I wanted to clarify is that thanks to um the robust gradient supports that we offer students at this stage the students who are coming through and qualifying for special education are truly the
283neediest of our students because um their needs exceed the gradient supports through mtss and so forth so I mentioned that because the intensity of need of the students within the percentage of students that we're supporting uh at this moment uh is I contend significantly more intensive than it would have been even just two years ago uh across the state the trend is that um eligibility for special education is increasing by 12% okay since last year but not at SMS it's a little different here because uh we have such robust gradient supports um so not all districts have that we do have an obligation to meet that least restricted requirement but because we have the gradient supports the students who are found eligible for special education are truly eligible for special education and require that service
284it just tends to be more intensive at the point because you know the St the the situations that are maybe less intense the students needs are able to be met through regular education did that make sense yeah yes any other questions all right thank you so much and I know this will be posted um on the website and so I know there's G to be a lot of parents interested appreciate that good job everybody good job thank you Raymond thank you did you ever think you would be presenting at 9:57 p.m PM yeah p.m p.m all right let's move ahead to building uh to board reports um building committee adding updates from Sophie and yes um I have some materials that I would like the board to give final sign off for um this is
285a one pager Chris you've seen it but I've added a couple more sentences and here three more copies for do you I think Jennifer needs one y oh and then these are the dates um so with y'all's approval of these two items I can make them public and um move forward with all of the presentations I'm really excited for the six presentations two are on zoom four are in person and all of them um feature one subcommittee member um so the folks who are on the building subcommittee are going to be there give their pitch on why they um think this project should move forward um Corino a representative from karino will also be there for detailed questions Paul toini is going to be there um so we will yeah hopefully be able to address
286questions and take Q&A from the public and then drive turnout for the vote on March 4th was kind of cool um I would like to it's so late I'm not really going to spend more time on this but if you guys could give this a quick look um maybe tomorrow and get back to me if you have any edits to the one pager by tomorrow so that I can start Distributing it um that would be awesome and um unless barring any edits to the dates then I'm going to make those public also okay sorry um um yeah I do love this I mean so many numbers got thrown out today you know different people commenting um I I do like this 35 hold on before you say a number Paul needs to give me an
287updated number on that on what the first part you said you needed to give me an updated number on the I I went from deposition to here I haven't had a chance to do no I'm not yeah okay so just don't say a number out loud because it's not the correct number Paul's going to give me an update number yeah um yeah I think if there's any other numbers I don't know I don't even know what I'm looking for but you know any other numbers we could kind of talk about in these meetings I know you have per family for a certain number home you know people today were like how how much per kid how much you know I don't know just trying to think of what some what are some numbers I provided
288you with the municipal Bond Bank and you saw the 15 to the 30 years once you really pin down what you would want to project as a board for a number you'll actually have a much more targeted number to be able to give that we'll have mly here next Wednesday where you will actually I think that would be really helpful for this flyer to to give a better number with with Paul's assistance okay so should I wait then to I know he had a very long conversation with Molly today so he might be able to give that to youe of time but I want to put him on the spot you know again you you use approximate numbers I mean I looked at I looked at the three schedules and you know a 20 year
289is pretty hefty okay so 20 I'll wait for call then then we can just maybe use those numbers yeah okay okay great well and our first thing isn't until January 29th so yeah yeah yeah I wanted to buy us a little bit of time after this that sounds great this is amazing thank you um I think are we also talking about putting stuff like sending stuff home with kids oh yeah I met with the I came to the PTO meeting yesterday and talked with PTO um they're really excited to Fire and going to rev their engines as well which is amazing um I am also going to make a flyer to hand out for students um to put in their backpacks leading up to the vote um and yeah hopefully a lot of parents will
290come to the SMS meeting um February 15th it's a Saturday at 9:00 A.M okay we be doing and I I just really wow nice yeah so in terms of um Kate you're going to give links and for the zoom and put those on the website okay yeah I don't I I'll work with Chris and Sharon about the website to make sure we have all all the information there because I think that's where folks are going to go so I want to make sure we have the dates the one pager the blueprint you know details from kinao like do you want me to send you the link so you can add them to that no because this is going to be I think um a flyer more and I can and I can put the links
291in a description I was going to just take a screenshot of it and attach it to parents Square just like as soon as you approved it just because that's quick and easy to get out to people but I just want you to know that once you guys say that that was what my plan was it seems to be the easiest way to communicate with families right now because it's one thing at a time and they actually read it I think yeah I read it I love that yeah great um any questions about the Outreach or yeah anything love it okay great all right that's it for me yeah very impressive thank you um superintendent evaluation committee we're actually meeting um 8:00 a.m. to um work with superintendent asbell on her evaluation so I'll have an
292update next week um Safety and Security task force I do not have any updates at this time okay uh communication engagement that's it yeah um chair update I just wanted to note I got so many emails um this week um supporting SMS and the budget and SMS teachers and um yeah very very strong Community Support so thank you for those emails um strategic planning committee um no report the um survey is going out this month okay I saw that and policy we met but um I would not do that to anybody I like all of you so um I would suggest that we do it as a first read I don't want to give it short shrift because some of this stuff is this is largely yeah I can just peek on here it is
293um it's really around the data governance data records we met with our it yeah and I know we have members in the audience who have asked about uh that specifically there a really good policies there so I'd like to provide a much more wholesome uh wholesome rather wholesome fome update on that okay unless you have unless you're opposed for some reason from no I think with the amount of time I think it's worth the discussion we can move that to the next Wednesday as when we're done meeting with the fact and just move into that there's a lot of interesting things here just about um compliance personally identifiable information what our processes are I think there's some things that could be very helpful in uh in making the public feel comfortable with what we do
294in our process but then also uh areas of opportunity for us to look at going forward uh to make sure that we're adopting best practices okay thank you all right um do we have to do anything with that first read no it's no no motion okay um old business yep so just want to give you two quick updates uh a member from the public talked about the water and I want to give a quick update on the water so we do have a timeline we are working with CMA Engineers which was the engineer we brought on to do the grant project so the timeline that you are aware of a bid advertisement is going to go out on January 21st um there were three vendors that we had identified through the state um that would
295be qualified to do that work so they'll be put out there we'll have a pre-bid meeting on January 28th at 10:00 I believe Sophie you're coming to that meeting to represent the board with Kate myself and Arthur our new director of facilities um and CMA they'll go through the three vendors talk about the water treatment plant where it's at look at the the the plan so that they can put a bid in and then on February 14th Paul will join Kate myself and CMA Engineers will open up the bids because it is a federally required Grant we have to go with the lowest bid uh but it's still covered in that $90,000 grant that we were awarded so we're on page so after that February 14th meeting we can start work on that that water
296treatment plant so that is really positive and excellent news okay that's pretty great and they know we have 990,000 they do yep they've been they've been along through the whole process so they've been with the the department yep yep yep yep okay yeah that sounds great I know people always email me about the water so that's great additional bus rades yeah so uh yesterday Tuesday what day are we is it yesterday Tuesday uh we had we opened up we had two additional bus rots that that came online so hard work by first student to get people hired um the other thing that we talked about uh they've giving updated list to Kate so we can work on the timing but one thing they shifted today is also they put the uh exitor high school bus
297routes first for stratum coming back so because they have the furthest distance to get out of the high school so that will alleviate in speed up time on our kids getting home so they'll get here for sooner be able to get our kids home sooner um so that has been a lot of hard work work and one of the things that we're already commenting on there's far few stewards on every bus which is a huge thing for kids at the end of the day when they're packed with three kids in a seat is a very different experience than maybe one other kid in your seat and we were already like all the energy is even walking the kids out it felt different because usually you've got 60 kids behind you and they're just it felt
298different within the first day the first student's bus broke down at the end of the day today for the last run and I thought they have the worst luck of any Bus 30 any organization like they've been I mean it's already been it's been a day and a half and been like yeah and then literally I was like my yeah I felt so bad so like Bus 30 I'm still getting those emails it's just left school 352 today so where when am when am I going to see the difference hope hopefully in the next couple weeks all the buses have been quicker except for because of the breakdown today we the two buses that we had we weren't even sure if they were to be first run or second run they came by like 312
299and then 38 or 17 so like it's our I mean it's minutes right now because they're also just figuring out the runs with new driver right like the new and we're going to email all week and we had so kids get on the wrong buses no but now I have documentation of how late it is well and then they had kids that got on the wrong buses so that they had to get brck back here and then we had to bring kids home I mean know but we would really expect like the beginning of every school year this a cool field trip like hey okay back to the one other thing I want to add about buses we've heard about special education costs so we are actually in preliminary conversations is be news to Raymond
300with first student to be able to do specialized Transportation as we enter into a contract with them for all bus services they are looking to bring on more specialized transportation services which hopefully could give us a competitive cost and bring down our bus cost is where we're doing a long-term uh agreement with them um and so that is something that's in the works and hopefully that can provide more more updates when we get to a a contract uh and look at that pricing so just want to let you know we are looking at all Alternatives specialized Transportation if no one is is in their own business that's where I would tell you to go because the costs are are crazy special uh a special Transportation vehicle has special equipment uh it can if if you
301have a wheelchair or or if you need harness but it isn't it's on an as needed basis right you don't have to you don't have to um if you're going to offer that service you don't automatically have to have a specialized vehicle right it depends what with the IP and the safety of the of the child and what their uh requirements are getting on off that bus safely it's that same least restrictive principle so even providing alternative Transportation through special ed has to be justified and documented as being linked to a specific disability reason uh I do want to say for the record that our um relationship with our current special education Transportation provider is very very positive they're incredibly flexible and accommodating and um the the the more challenging aspect is when we have
302to go outside of that relationship in order to secure transportation in in unique situations um such as out of District placements that are outside of our customary arrangement with the current provider so it's important to mention that they're wonderful to work with they're very accommodating they help us out at the last minute all the time so um I don't mean to imply that they're difficult to work with um it's those unique outlier sort of situations that tend to be very expensive all are we allowed to know what grade that out of District person is in we wouldn't if it's a sole identifier uh okay I'm just thinking about financial planning okay um all right do we have a non-public do have nonpublic I just want to update you really quickly the police details started um
303and chief King has been in Tony's been incredible he's like you have to call me Tony so Tony has been incredible to work with I just want like he's been so cooperative and like flexible and helpful and like so he even dropped the cruiser fee and the administration fee so it's down I think it's $68 an hour versus a 90 something it was going to be an hour so there's a reduction in that as well so um and I think when I spoke with the assistant um Michael I think we're eight weeks out consecutive weeks before where there's a potential Breakin week so they've been great to work with and it's started okay is that something that can be added to the newsletter when it when you have another newsletter just to notify just to
304make the community aware yeah I can see yep absolutely I can is it once a week yes yes I'm I'll just put it right in the um like I'll put it on parents Square um any other update from you guys then the reports so many things okay all right yeah yeah okay um all right so non under letter A under letter A do I have motion moved okay thanks we um do you have a second so moved okay can we do roll call I I I I I all right we'll head into nonpublic at 1011 all right um we oh we just made it came out of nonpublic at uh 10:29 p.m. um do I have any motions on the table yeah I can make a motion um a motion to deny the Personnel request
305all right thank you do I have a second second thanks Tanya uh any discussion all right so let's um vote uh all in favor I I anybody oppose no uh 5 Z Z all right I believe there's a second motion does anybody want to make I can do that one uh to accept the resignation the retirement yep isation isation resignation okay thank you thanks Eric um do I have a second second okay thanks Paul uh all in favor I I anyone oppos 5 Z Z all right do I have a motion to adjourn motion thanks Paul um I'll we'll do a roll call t i i i i i all right thanks we're adjourned 10:30