001are we are we ready to get going yeah all right everyone I'd like to call the meeting to order at 6:02 p.m. uh really excited to have all of you guys here thank you so much uh can we stand up and do the pledge please I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic which it stand one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all all right so tonight's a really important meeting and we're we're glad to have all of you guys here participating I think what I would like to do first is we have a student council representative which I'm really excited to hear from and then after that we'll kind of I'm going to explain the agenda a little bit and then we'll start
002moving through the agenda just so everybody on the same page so I would love to call up our student council rep okay if we're ready oh yeah I do hear music no yeah it's good you can introduce me everybody tonight stud council is stie Herring she actually is Eric's um youngest daughter and a member of our school musicing s you want to look I think wait for I'm going to try to put behind you but I'm going to try to put it here too so you can see you know where the music is coming from what the music music it could be on the slide I don't know basketball seems very clear am I hearing no well if you are might need that tonight N I bet this past month we had a spear week
003almost everybody joined don't get me started on the on the creative art contest so many people joined it was open for grades K through 5 there were so many Thanksgiving and gratitude projects everybody did such a great job every grade had one winner we had five days of dressing up and crafts my favorite day is pajama day everybody loves Pajama Day spirit week was so fun next the whole school helped make the float for the exitor parade each class made candy out of anything grades prek through 5 participated each grade had two weeks to finish it was so much fun next we had Scott Bo the astronaut visit us he showed us photos and videos about his space trip he also told us about what it feels like to be in space he also T
004told us information and told us facts about his life everybody loved it next two of our student council members put together a podcast interviewing Scott they asked questions about what it was like in space and it was so cool to watch next we had the book fear there were so many books and there were even toys almost everybody got books it was so much fun and you could get as many books and toys as you wanted there were so many authors and parents got to come parents also volunteered at the C cash register there are notebooks pens games and books at the book fair so many people were excited grades K through 5 were able to come to the book fair there are so many good books and cool toys there were good books for
005each grade each class had different days to go it was open for a week it was a lot of fun next we had the SMS Contra Dance lot of people went miss and miss green put it together your parents could go as well you would choose a partner to dance with and Miss green got a band to play for us it was so much fun I would like to thank Miss green for putting the dance together thank you for listening any questions that was so great was really awesome that's a lot of activities since last month really wonderful thank you so much we can't do right now can't figure it out hey do you want to try to close all the tabs and see if it was left open when they were testing my computer
006earlier today oh you think it's I don't would be good caling I'm wondering if when they were testing my computer earlier if there's a tab for music to make sure sound was working like a looping music has a caling effect certainly is right first first time for everything I think the funniest thing is you doubted not everybody heard it I would well then you're like M you know been that kind of weak we all should have said we don't hear anything yes you would have done that to me PA yes I would have I know volume M I like you're at the T your volume's muted okay I don't I was just guessing Okay that was a good idea it's definitely Bluetooth planking somewhere all right so just to kind of um talk a little
007bit about what's going to happen tonight um tonight we have um a build a school um board presentation on um the building project and exactly what we're looking at doing uh with this building to kind of bring it up to speed um you know mechanically electrically um some of the things that we wanted to look at for the building um and then we're also going to take a look at the budget and we have the fa here who um is charged with reviewing the budget asking questions and and really being critical and analytical about it and so we're excited to hear from them as well there has been a significant amount of questions posed by fa and so those um will get answered and um we'll we'll do more in depth into the budget uh
008there are going to be two periods for open comment I would love to have um have us talk about the building then I would open it up for public comment if you want to speak please sign on that sheet then the board is going to go into non-public for a short amount of time come back out and then we'll talk um further about the budget so that's the plan for tonight um I also just wanted to quickly go into the schedule for how we handle um the budget and how we um talk about the budget and how there's plenty of room for public input into the budget so today is the 18th it's the second time the fa has met with the SMS board um um and the second time they've in an open public
009session talked to us about uh the budget then there's going to be a public hearing on January 88th um to again review the budget on January 15th the fact again meets with the board to finaly the budget and to take a look at the warrant articles so what are we putting on the ballot for March that we're asking Town's people to vote on um in February we just have a regular board meeting on February 12th and then on Tuesday March 4th that is when all of you guys will come um usually to the cafeteria and we'll have a vote on the budget uh there will be a short school um board presentation um with administrators board members and uh then there's a vote on that March 4th um anything I said wrong or anything to
010add I think I'd add is during that public comment or public hearing we will have a hearing on the bond if the building project goes for so it would only be the budget and the bond on the on the building project those two things so as you can tell the review of the school budget is an in-depth thing you know we bring in Outsiders we bring in the public um the board members administrators um obviously the school budget is an incredibly important part of um of what the board does and also an important part of your tax dollars and so it's important for us that that everybody um gets a say on that so that is our plan for today so first we are just going to go into um some quick uh agenda items
011and then we're going to hear about the um building project so first I would like to um uh take a look at the minutes um the public minutes of December 11th um do I have uh a motion to approve the um public minutes of December 11th so moved does anybody have any comments or questions on the minutes okay all in favor of their approval get a second Jennifer yeah okay can have a second second thanks Paul all right all in favor of approving them I I four any um abstentions I yeah because T wasn't here okay so 401 thank you uh what about the non-public minutes do I have um a motion to approve those y so moved again thanks Eric y any um questions or comments spread out all right do I have a
012second second thanks Paul um all in favor of approving those I I I yeah and I just want to say again those minutes are great um they you know uh there's a lot of public comment in them and um the administrators are doing a great job with those minutes and they they're a great resource for you guys too as you're as you're um learning more about board business okay moving into superintendent report um financials and manifests all right so in your board pack is a current year Financial so since the last month we did add some expenditures but I did note in detail what those are for you did anyone have any questions on any of those and keep in mind we do encumber things for the full year so to the best that we
013can um I had a question about technology this is Sophie um so we have a trust fund for technology but we have items that were not budgeted for that also didn't come out of the trust fund or can you explain that a little bit so it's these aren't unbudgeted items this is just a change from the prior month so what I do is I take any incumbrances or actual expenditures and just say how it changed from the prior month it doesn't mean it's an unbudgeted expense okay thanks and then the one thing I did add on here was a little bit of earnings on investment so when we keep the money in the bank we um have been seeing higher interest rates um and we always try to project conservatively because you never know which
014way the interest rate is going to go so um it's nice when we have a little bit extra there and this projected ending unassigned fund balance does that include you know this um the Corino and the Personnel matter Does it include the money that we spent on this bid so this would include anything encumbered to date so if it was already expended yep then or encumbered then that would be included in this I'm not aware of any additional expense related okay um I have another question what is earnings on investment so um when you keep the money in the bank you get interest what is the the investment I guess I have like the so when you have um money in your bank account you an interest on it I understand that I just wasn't
015aware that we had an investment do we so every month the town pays the school to support the expenditures of the school and so we have a bank account and that's how we pay all of our bills so we keep all of the money in the bank account that's at TD and we earn interest on the bank account now this isn't just one month's interest this is for the projection for the entire year all right I'll ask you more don't get too excited I would like to to go there all right uh do any board members have any other questions on that all right seeing none um it looks like next on our agenda is the construction building project so Paul I'll let you handle that can I take that please do thanks Jennifer so
016this is the fun part for me uh first uh just a little bit of background uh we've been working on this now through most of the year and U we uh have Kino construction who is now doing the work for us and notably uh part of Corino is uh Todd Todd Harrington and he is a stratum resident um and um so over the uh over the course of the summer and culminating uh about a week ago uh we've come up with what I believe we all feel is a reasonable focused and well-thought out scope to the needs of the school uh and I'm very excited about it and I hope you will be as well um IT addresses changing education needs it improves safety uh it sprinkles the entire school only a very small portion
017of the school has fire sprinklers now IT addresses urgently needed infrastructure Replacements uh most notably the boilers I think one has failed already and the air handle is an existing AC systems IT addresses uh Ada codes and by the way we're adding air conditioning to the second floor classrooms in a very costeffective manner um so we address the uh ad that's Ada is that the Americans for Disabilities Act is that what that is yeah uh it improves Energy Efficiency so obviously the new boilers are more energy efficient um LED lights throughout and one of the primary reasons for doing that is because next I think next year it ends there are uh there are rebates from the state and may be Federal on LED lights and it uh it improves and adds insulation to the
018building so what that does obviously is it lowers uh monthly operating costs it improves the flow in the administrative offices and it improves entrance security it enlarges the nurses station it enlarges the cafeteria so fewer lunch sessions are needed and for other uses for the calf the calf is used for many other things just besides uh lunches and I'm very pleased and proud to say that what was at one point recommended by the previous architect uh to be 46 to $50 million and admittedly it was a much larger scope um is now 12 million and uh um having done the math on the tax implications I think it is entirely reasonable and we're getting an exceptional value from Kino construction and with that I would turn it over to uh to Ben Carino well said
019Paul good evening everybody uh my name is Ben Carino we'll do a quick introduction of our preconstruction team who um who's been working on this SMS project for the past few months uh my role will be as a project executive I'll oversee from uh design where we currently are at estimating to the very end uh last Cod of paint I will turn it over to Todd uh Todd Harrington director of preconstruction um I'll be walking you through our our design and exploration to date and everything we considered and and where we're at I'm Stephanie gastaldi preconstruction manager will be um coordinating the construction process and everything that goes into this project prior to the start of construction so thank you all for being here tonight um it's been a very productive couple of months um
020and we're very excited to share like I said before what what we've discovered and and kind of our plan that we've put together uh um the from the outset the preconstruction effort dang so relaxed so the preconstruction effort involved existing condition review with subcontractors uh discussions with the SMS building committee Chris hrisy Kate Lucas Tim Harrington and as well as a review of the existing study that we had done um we our effort really tried to marry all of those goals and objectives uh the entire Focus from the outset we are focused on efficient budget friendly Solutions um for example classroom modules sticking with kind of a bare you know a classroom module size to allow for the operations to be flexible um uh energy upgrades was another big portion as well as infrastructure upgrades
021as Paul previously discussed based upon this analysis we came up with a list of 41 items to look at to explore to price and uh for the committee to evaluate um after reviewing these items we developed the design options and Facilities needs and the priority recommendations we will go through in the following Pages um and to B to add to Paul's point the design and priority selections made address additional educational space building an ADA Code Compliance increase student safety infrastructure repair energy upgrades in the cafeteria expansion so with that said um this is the 41 item Matrix that we worked with and we developed this Matrix with a priority one two and three the priority ones are and the other part of the task was to create create an allart inclusive budget so every project
022or every line item is is really a separate project excuse me so line item one the special services Wing um espe we'll get into the design of that shortly uh line item two the cafeteria expansion line item three this is the admin interior reconfigure and we'll get into the design of all of this uh towards the end of this um and that's basically renovating interior spaces throughout so the other line items to to go back to the code upgrades fire code upgrades um the facilities needs an assessment report looked at the fire code in the hallways and essentially there's penetrations in the walls allowing smoke through so those need to be sealed up the other part of this work is two sets of stairs need a fire rated wall and doors this was identified in
023the report as well so uh the next line items furnish and install sprinklers throughout um and again we budgeted this with in coordination with subcontractors input developing the scope in the budget so they're you know real budget numbers so furnish and install sprinklers throughout this also includes upgrading the line from across the street bringing a 6-in line in putting a new fire protection room uh Ada code stair upgrades the stair railings need to be replaced in the stairs they're not ADA Compliant uh as well as the the stair nosings they're supposed to have a uh an off color strip so you can visually impaired can see um Ada signage throughout uh that's essentially classroom signs with Braille throughout ada8 bath upgrades there's uh six bathrooms in the school that don't have are an ADA Compliant
024they're in the back kind of towards the cafeteria and so forth in the gym so we looked at that uh Ada sidewalks and flat workor this is basically the concrete up front the entryway um and then what Paul touched upon replace the boilers that's a high priority item right from the outset there was a high priority for everybody so we looked at that uh Ada Cy upgrades this is really a uh access to the playground ADA Compliant access is also identified in the report and now mechanical we looked at four different four different variations of the mechanical systems really the mechanical systems are original we need to replace them uh so option A was look at all the units and price out replacing just the units not the duct work um so they're so they're
025new and good for another 35 40 years so option A was that uh the second uh the second option uh remove and replace controls this was identified this is a upgrade from um pneumatic to Modern controls uh and lastly furnish and install splits at the second floor classrooms we looked at a few different options here um Paul touched upon it um the splits is a real budget friendly solution just to get a little bit of air conditioning upstairs for those kind of shoulder months uh replace lighting with LED lights and motion controls throughout this is an Energy Efficiency upgrade as well as a light quality upgrade and uh additional outlets in the classroom this was identified early on as a need from Kate and and so essentially we're going to add two quads in each
026classroom to give additional Outlets replace the transformers this is an energy upgrade um 19 is an envelope upgrade well most of it um basically the sopit all the way around the school the plan here and we have a detail of it but we're basically going to pull the sopit down open it up and spray foam the top of the top of the wall to seal it up and to give it a a little more insulation and then for the fascia the aluminum all the way around what we opted to do is we're going to prep and paint that just to give it a you know a fresher look so it looks newer um in Li of replacing it I think the previous plan was to replace it all and you know I think we can
027do it with just replacing and and then put that back and do a new fiber cement soft all the way around you'll see in a few pictures and if you walk around it's in pretty rough shape um and then there's miscellaneous work that was also identified in the uh needs assessment report a few a few events and so forth that need to be modified uh remove and replace roof we the roof is a 10e it's 10year roof it's at the end of its lifespan we looked at this we priced it and the other component to price pricing this was additional once again energy upgrades adding 2 in to a 4-in system giving us that much more r value and so so I Circle back it's all kind of bread and butter stuff is everything that
028we looked at just really what's going to give us a long-term bang for our buck and payback so it's really all energy upgrade kind of stuff um 24 is remove and replace ceilings and this will this will basically give the whole school a you know a fresher look we believe and the reason for this is we're going to be doing the lights we're going to be doing the sprinklers we're going to be doing all of that stuff so it only makes sense to you know really do all of that while we're pulling them all down and opening them up uh fire alarm system upgrade the panel's been upgraded uh the device is through out need to be updated for voice voice Evac um 35 miscellaneous electrical this was a fault survey that was identified so
029we carried some money for that and then lastly is uh additional storm water treatment leechfield work we don't we haven't identified the scope of work yet but we carrying an allowance we reviewed it with our civil engineer manual engineering and um with the we're doing concept ceptual design now and and getting through that process and really you know finding out what needs to be done so we feel that $12,000 was a reasonable amount to carry for some additional site work and leech field work that might need be needed um with that said subtotal 10 1019 uh contingency of 15% at this phase owners rep 250 uh gives us a grand total of 11972 uh meeting our under $12 million Target for the bond so Stephanie's going to talk a little bit about the design process
030the fun stuff thanks to so our design process for this was largely a team effort we met weekly with Kate Lucas Chris andreski and the building committee as well as Tim Harrington with the um maintenance department of the school um we work through a few different design ideas and this was kind of our final layout that we came up with when we were looking at the school and looking at the design we really wanted to respect and appreciate that this building has really great bones it has great circulation and the classroom sizes seem to work really well so these new additions here the additions are in this kind of purpley pink and the blue are the areas of renovation um so with these additions on either side we're really maintaining the existing classroom sizing and
031just continuing the hallway so we're trying to limit the amount of renovations to the existing building as much as possible as a way to be cost efficient um another thing that we looked at was um integrating special services within the building so we're our plan is to utilize some of the existing classrooms and change their use to special services that way kids with special needs don't feel isolated on the corners of the building so that was kind of an easy way to just utilize the existing space and change its use and kind of limit the amount of added square footage to the building um another thing that we looked at um was the administrative office area and kind of opening that up so we're proposing to remove an interior wall in here just to improve
032the circulation of the space there's a lot of action going on back there so just opening that up and removing the window and adding a door so essentially visitors will have to go into a secure space before allowing access to the entire building so that's a way to improve security um and then also the cafeteria expansion that Paul talked a little bit about um that'll ease scheduling day-to-day scheduling will allow for two lunches versus three and also allow indoor Gym classes and just a larger space for community events it's pretty tight in there currently um and yeah really the main driver of this design was uh to meet the the budget constraints of $12 million so we thought that limiting limiting renovations to the existing space keeping and maintaining the existing massing and the existing
033layout of the school was a way to um to be really cost effective in this design so in in conclusion we're real excited about the work that we've we've completed in today and um couple of months and um really excited about presenting to all of you and and uh wanted to get your input so thank you very much thanks so much um I want to open up to a public comment um but before that does the board have any questions or comments I want to add one thing please uh one thing that doesn't fit on a u on a balance sheet is uh the type of company Kino is um they they maintain a True open door policy I can't tell you how many times I called them after I was 9:00 p.m. weekends Sunday
034morning Sunday nights and they pick up the phone every single time getting a hold of them and communicating with them is easy okay and that allowed this thing to move forward what do they say in Star Trek at warp speed we could never have done this otherwise never have done this and gotten it ready for where we are today they absolutely are a pleasure to work with and they should be commended for that thank you couple for there's a lot of ADA stuff that's in there um obviously we want to do those things but if we were to not do the entire project my understanding is that we would not be doing those Ada components what is the break point for when you have to get in and start doing work to where you have
035to upgrade to these codes um so essentially it boils down to if you're touching the areas and I think there are areas in except itions like for example the bathrooms in the back I think technically we don't have to do them but the with the cafeteria Edition that kind of touches that area so I think it you know depending on how you dig into that code and interpret that maybe maybe do a couple of them you know and find some middle ground it also depends on the building inspector which we have an intern one at this point and so once we get get through Bond and start working on that kind of stuff we'll really be able to develop the design and the code but for these reasons is one of the reasons why we
036carried a 15% contingency because there's a lot of unknowns at this at this early stage so we thought it was responsible to carry pretty healthy contingency for all that kind of stuff um I thought it might also be interesting for the public to know a rough timeline if you have that available so the go goal would be then I'll let you talk sure upon approval in March we will then enter into our design development phase certain parts of this project will take could you just give the microphone sure just people are watching why not give it back thank you go ahead um so after the March approval our next step is to enter in design development um process where we start finessing the budget start going through exploratory work Deep dive into design right now
037this whole project is based off of um past Knowledge from previous Architects budgeting we have major subcontractors and vendors that we've walked through the past few months we have our in-house estimating so all that's based off of floor plans and Concepts and our due diligence to what we do know so moving into design development we start really crunching those numbers getting into design um we have a budget update at 25% a design development again at 50% design development so we are never moving forward with design without knowing costs we will not design a $20 million project and then say hey this is now a $20 million project so we actually check prices right through design development so at 50% we can make different changes start value engineering the budget and we work this process the
038whole entire time I see us breaking this project down into four or five phases meaning that we're once we start we'd prefer not to remobilize each time but first plan of attack boilers you know the lead time on boilers we order those in March we have most of the information we already need we hope to install those in the summer so lead times do dictate lots of projects design obviously for the additions will fall behind some of the renovations but yes this will be kind of pieced out and phased out as one simultaneous project but the schedule this project could last year and a half from March 18 months um plus or minus all depends on lead times and availability and and design review sometimes design review we can be moving Concepts around for for
039weeks at a time we have a great um relationship with the building committee we've moved incredibly fast the past few months the team is absolutely right so I do think we can we can push on it uh on design and get underway as fast as we can to protect inflation escalation things like that um the the the other uh component to the schedule will be the school schedule you know if if we're limited to just summer work for example microphone oh thank you yeah that's a great Point Todd so I said you might not get the microphone back once I get it um so we accommodate clients and owners so we'll work directly with the school uh we don't want to be changing ceiling tiles when the classroom is open the very next day um
040everything's accomodating stratum the school system schedule-wise lead times and then we just blend it all together produce an overall schedule we riew with the team update it on a weekly and monthly basis and that's generally how our projects move forward I'd like to add something as well the building subcommittee uh was comprised of uh about 12 people total and it included uh superintendent and dry uh Kate Lucas myself Sophie and uh members of the local community who are actually from the construction industry in all areas you know HVAC and building and uh real estate and so on so uh these these gentlemen make their living in the industry so that's one of the reasons why this moved forward quickly without a lot of around and round but one of the things I learned coming from
041the electronics Industry is it is beneficial for an entity like the school to have what's called an owner's rep now many of you may know what that is but I didn't know what it is so that's a firm or an individual or an individual who has a firm who um is compensated by uh the SAU um to I don't mean it the way it sounds look out for our best interest because I got to tell you I think the I think these guys are terrific I think they are looking out for our best interests but nevertheless they report to us they're paid by us and they oversee the project over the next couple years so kinao wasn't coming to someone like me saying hey we ran into this problem here we can do this or
042we can do that what do you want to do okay and this individual takes that on and reports to the board it summarizes these things and reports to the board and the board makes decisions on a more on a higher level basis that's all in the budget that's all in the bond it's all been accounted for so for the public you should feel doubly confident and comfortable with the way this is proceeding thanks yeah it came as a surprise to me that the roof needed to be replaced after 10 years I don't know who the best person to speak to that I know I I got the answer but I didn't know if that was surprising to anybody else who might be in the audience um why does a roof need to be replaced after
04310 years and how can we ensure that that doesn't happen again and similarly with other work that we're considering so good question it's a it's a 10-year roof and right now my my review with Tim was it leaks once in a while and when he when it leaks he calls you know Brad he comes and fixes it and so we looked at that and it's a 10year roof right at the end that being said um the other part of that driver was to get 2 in of ins ins ation in there and we bid it out or priced it out with ANM and it was a competitive price with 2 in of insulation and a 20-year warranty um so that was why the decision was made to move forward with that particular item so when
044we say 10year roof what that means is All Roofing Systems when you get into rubber roof style systems have warranties from the manufacturer so the roof installed it's a 10-year warrantied Roof System which means the manufacturer's warranty so if you do have leaks um they won't honor anymore at that point generally at this point um with this type of climate we're at we generally install 20 year to 30-year warranties which means the manufacturers rep comes in at the end actually throughout construction of the roof in a project like this blesses our install our means and methods and at the end hands us a nice letter that we then turned over to town stratum saying your roof is warranteed for 20 years and any any leaks you know beyond natural disasters things like that you know
045um roofs do leak at some points you can be 100% perfect and water can go anywhere so um the manufacturer will then step in for what we suggest next 20 years to repair any leaks things like that and and to add to that is is we're you know looking at it from the Viewpoint of we're spending this money on making the school you know updated and to not do the roof and we just rolled the insulation in but there's like for example the Skylight right here we looked at this and it's not leaking I think it needs some cleaning so we decided to take that out of the scope and just look at cleaning it and seeing if pressure washing will get it to look a little shinier I was just going to add that
046it was a choice that was made by the board 10 years ago to go with a lesser durable roof so that was one of the points and we're trying not to do make those mistakes again um we talked about sort of the value engineering component where there's sort of an Roi on some of these enhancements that are being made do we have any anything that we could speak to rough order magnitude on what savings we can expect over time and if there's not an answer tonight that's fine but would love to see if we could get that that's a that's a great question that's that's certainly on our radar kind of the next steps um you know beyond you know we'll probably we will'll continue to work on it um but really into post bond
047work design work but yeah I'm certainly very interested in that myself um but but the idea the general concept of everything is is really I'm a Believer in lights insulation are just two bread and butter ways to you know get your building tight and save energy um those two things in motion controls and things like that I'd like to add to that if I may one comes to mind that I mean I correct me if I'm wrong we sort of did some value engineering as we were going through some of the different ways to do things and one of the big ones that came up was how do we air condition the second floor and we had I think three different technologies that we could go with and designs and one was GE I don't
048know four or5 million okay um and we chose Mini Splits which are a fraction of the cost and given the fact that those rooms only need to be air conditioned as as Todd said on the shoulder months you don't have to have an air conditioning system that would keep Madison Square Garden cool with 25,000 people in it right so it it just brought it down to a very very small fraction of the cost and we achieve the goal I call that value engineering am I wrong no absolutely value engineering is changing means and methods product substitutions finding ways to do the same thing at a lesser cost um once you get into I think another part of that question probably had something to do with Energy rebates and seeking those so with our process we
049are design build contractors so we work with utility companies state in federal um there's also grants out there um so once our plans are developed more our Engineers develop the mechanical systems the building envelope uh including the roof insulation the spray foam Todd mentioned around the building sawet that's we incorporate that into our full plan set we have a full scope of work and then we start working with the utility companies they have independent contractors that also will review our plans they come back provide all the grants that we can possibly get all the rebates and then we turn that over at the end of the project they will do a review we do this in all of our projects that we design and build if the rebates are there they will certainly hand them
050over to the town of stratum that happens towards the end of the project but after design we will know what the ROI is on some of these products that are selected a little bit too early for that all right thank you so much and Sophie before um before we go into public comment I was wondering if you or Paul could just talk in Broad Strokes kind of what the the next few months look like for the board in terms of Outreach um getting Town up to speed yeah so we have six presentations scheduled um Chris has do you want to pass around the timeline I oneop okay um so timeline of key dates we are going to have the first presentation on January 29th at um well this is all per board approval but um
051so the first one would be at Town Hall January 29th um 6:00 p.m. and then Monday February 3rd 6: p.m. there would be another one online um Saturday February 15th there would be one here at SMS at 9:00 a.m. um then Wednesday February 19th we would have another one focused on the 55 plus community in town hall um then we would have another one 700 p.m. at the fire department and then 10:00 a.m. on February 26th online um so our hope is that we with that schedule can access a lot of members of the community if you can't make it you know in nights we have some morning options if you can't make it in person there are some online options so really trying to make this as accessible as possible um and so we
052want to make sure communication is going both ways and we get feedback and um then we have the vote on March 4th so that is um the tentative schedule and each one of those six presentations would also have one to two members of the subcommittee presid to really like help um just introduce it and take ownership of the communication so next steps for that if we if I get board approval I'd like to make a flyer with all of those um dates on them and um I've already made sure that all of the dates um are available I've already booked the rooms with Town Hall double checked the communities and um everything looks good double check the schedule Kate and Chris um so with board approval my next step would be to create a flyer
053with all of that and then start circulating the dates that sounds great and I know that's on our agenda later on but I just thought maybe it could be a question here just is there question and answer at that Sophie because yes yep so it probably be about 30 minutes or so roughly the presentation we just saw um and then question and answer after that's great thank you for doing that okay unless the board has anything else I'll open it to um public comment the way public comment works is it's three minutes for each person and you know obviously there's a lot of people in this room we want to hear from you um and we just want to make sure everybody signs in so I'm going to go through I think for right now
054I would love to have the discussion beond things other than the budget because we're going to be talking about that later so anything having to do with the project or if you have other concerns um I'd be happy to hear from that but in terms of the budget we'll talk about that in a little bit are you going to open up for public comment for again for the budget yes I am okay that's my intention um so I'll go down through the list um so Steve Patton um can I talk about the budget um we're GNA talk about that later you want me to come back to you yes okay uh Paul I was going to talk about the budget okay but if I wouldn't mind making I just want wanted to uh say one
055thing about please do if you would come to the mic just say your name and your address [Music] yep um Todd the uh the Mini Splits those are vrf units right a variable refrigerant flow units that are going to be they're going to be supplementing the heating system the h&v overall correct I mean you're not going to take out not going to be pulling out the H and V for heat right that correct well they're Standalone there's separate systems but they'll compliment so they'll comp that's right they'll be complimenting each other I just wanted to make sure because I I wasn't involved in that conversation but I understood what you were talking about I just wanted to make sure that um one other thing I wanted to bring up was um energy recovery um that
056that's something that we really it we didn't bring it up but I'm looking doing my engineering thing I'm looking at makeup air ventilation air for the entire facility to meet the latest codes and we're going to be bringing in a large amount of makeup here and to and I just want to make sure that we look at energy recovery using either um heat pipes or heat recovery wheels so that means you're going to need return I mean I'm now getting into details but you're going to have to get that return air and exhaust air back to the heat pipes to preheat the outside air so that you're not heating it from whatever it is 0° up to 72 degrees because that's a lot of heat that you're going to be asking the boilers to be
057providing and this is a good way to B maybe downsize the load on the boilers and save us a lot of money quickly it may be a very quick payback like three or four years something like that well well my hope first is is the upgrades with the in insulation you know after we once we get p post bond and we get you know some Engineers signed up and you know some other Architects and so forth My Hope Is that um we we'll be looking at all that but the insulation will contribute significantly to your point the loading requirements of the mechanical systems thanks all right I have Mike thank you and from the presentation I'm I'm also quite impressed with Corino I think it's a great project and you're definitely going in the right
058direction coming down from 40 or 50 million down to 12 why it started at that point I have no idea but I question I have a number of questions why we're needing more educational space for fewer students I mean that that makes no sense to me uh the idea of uh putting in these additions and some things obviously need to be done uh all at once things like the fire uh fire sprinklers and the roof obviously but a lot of these uh smaller projects seem to be able to be pulled off into separate projects they don't have to be included in the bond uh things like like better lighting like adding insulation adding electrical outlets uh come on I mean that stuff that's ordinary maintenance kinds of things and then I also have the question
059of how are we assuring that we're not going to have a future bond issue come up because in the business world there's usually funds set aside as you go along for future enhancements things that have to be done like a sinking fund for new roofs or painting or things that I consider ordinary maintenance types of items thank you uh thank you I can I can speak to a little bit about the classrooms um we looked at several different options uh as you can see the the final option really entails four classrooms with a connecting Corridor simple simple simple and two of those classrooms are getting rid of the temporary classrooms that we have now so essentially we're really only adding two classrooms but that's that's the part that I could speak about we looked at
060we looked at other Ro more robust schemes uh the maintenance items there are several items that are that we did pull out that are actually planned to be maintenance they're uh upgrade like for example Windows these windows are going to need to be replaced at some point in time that we but we we didn't include that in this Bond we decided that we were going to set aside funds and do it as a maintenance project down the road the other items um I guess Paul head of the building committee can speak to as to why things were pushed and pulled but we looked at the 41 item list and I think we have 18 or 19 in so there's several items that we did pull up that's definitely move in the right direction correct but
061let go a little fur well I I think the goal was to find The Sweet Spot you know hi Mike I'm I'm gonna ask Kate to speak about the what drives the need for the extra rooms be but before she does I just want to mention one thing small like on the outlets we're going to have electricians here okay the rooms need extra Outlets that was made clear to us it costs more to bring the electricians back and open up the ceilings and everything to run the wires for the electrical later than to do it now so it just becomes more costeffective to do these things um so your your questions are good ones they're valid ones but I can assure you they were deliberated on and the only other thing that I would put
062in perspective or ask you to put in perspective and you already have really but so we've got 41 items I think we brought it down from like 241 okay so you know there could we go further maybe we've come a hell of a long way but good questions Kate would you would you speak to the need for the one second just um so just as a point of um information for these public comments this is really a chance for us to hear statements that you guys make it's not necessarily a conversation back and forth it's really for us to take a note and then potentially next month we answer your questions so I'm going to ask Kate if she wants to be responsive and then if not um we can come back to you in
063January but I think you bring up a great point that what you're hearing right now is a presentation about the building itself we've been talking in previous meetings about the needs and why why it is important we do a project like this and that was missing from tonight's presentation just because of the nature of the speakers in the future you know that will be um by definition part of our presentation so Kate do you feel comfortable talking a little bit or um we can also defer it um I don't I I feel like there's a lot of reasons I mean this is a six- year on the making conversation about what that space is for um something I just really quickly would draw attention to is that we are losing the cottage which is two
064of our instructional spaces so when you think about four what we're losing two so you're actually gaining two so we're not I think that's like an important distinction we are not gaining four classrooms we are getting two classrooms I think that's an important distinction I think in terms of educational rationale tonight is would be a very long conversation if we got into that okay but that's a great point and something we will include in the future okay um I have John Beaker did just have a building question great do you mind talking at the microphone yeah be able to speak lat sounds great okay uh I may have missed this John Baker 25 kinlock Drive I may have missed this in your presentation but in light of what we've seen happen this year with the
065uh school shootings I know we've got a uh safety space provided in the front secure space what about everything else that would involve safety for the students I mean we're doing it this is a great project I I like what's being done here but I'm just wondering do we have the necessary safety things that uh um that that's a great question um essentially we are the existing security system we're relying the security cameras and so forth around but one of the one of the ideas that came up we haven't really talked about it but maybe there's an opportunity came up as as doing the design and going going through the different iterations but maybe maybe there is an opportunity to have kind of a a satellite police office so that you know they could the
066officer on duty could come get a cup of coffee do a little computer work and there'd be a cruiser park now front and it's kind of a win-win situation for a little 10x10 office so we haven't really talked about it but it's just a thought that came up because I I agree with you I think enhanced security is is certainly a concern um the gym addition we are adding a you know the thought was to add a a kind of a secondary entry as well so you have two sets of doors but really um the existing security system is is what we're looking at we could we could look at you know TW as a design develops you know adding different features know once we get into reviewing it that and and this isn't the
067only opportunity where we do that so we make security enh en Ms upgrades anytime that we're made aware of it over the past year or two we've made enhancements and upgrades to the communication system to the visibility systems physical security um and we've also approved uh in the budget the ability to have U police officer detail uh here more frequently so we take it very very seriously obviously in light of recent events and um we're not waiting for this project to be able to make sure that the kids are safe all right how's our timing got okay uh Glenn I'll speak later on budget okay thank you um Debbie on Thank you Lisa the great um scam and James James scamman 96 Portsmouth have I just want to say A+ on this presentation um and
068awesome job committee um I'm I'm definitely supporting this and I I hope everybody else will take an interest so that they'll know what they're voting on come March 4th thank you so much um I have Jeffrey Baker Bunker Hill I'll wait okay uh Mr okay um um Gail okay um Sally hi Sally sty I'm at 59 stratum green I just moved here about eight months ago um I'm curious because um I've had a lot of Schoolboard interests over the years so I looked up the stats on enrollment and um enrollment appears to be down about 130 students over the last 10 years and I see four new class classrooms or whatever you want to call them um it doesn't make sense to me as a new taxpayer to pay for more classrooms um when we
069have a lot less students and the trend is further down um I wonder if you have any of the stats on the population of stratum and how many of us are seniors and already got hit by a very big tax but uh uh bill this past month and are we we going to get hit by another one with this I I know I can't afford it but some of the design is very good but I don't think increasing size is warranted okay thanks yeah thank you I think enrollment is another issue we've talked about quite a bit and we'll we'll continue to talk about are we prepared to talk about any numbers tonight or not yet not right now yeah not right now um but that is will definitely be something we continue to talking
070about okay the final person I have is Jan and then I'm going to just put this at the end here and if anybody else would like to sign I feel funny talking like I don't know which way put on this yeah that'd be great thank you so much I'll talk sorry my backs to you um I came to the first meeting after our last tax bill got really big so thank you for listening the board thank you for the building committee whoever's been on it and thank you for these new folks coming forward because when I was hearing $50 million I want to move out of town I'll be honest with you so thank you for getting it to where it is so my questions really are around so we have it to $12 million
071bond is that sort of set or is that quas Set uh 12 12 M million would cover the scope of work presented and discussed and then you have a 15% contingency what would be would there be a a situation where you'd have to come back um 15% contingency would be things like unknowns design changes modifications developments for example say we're crossing the road and we hit ledge you know where does that money come say there's a price escalation in something would that be enough I gu yeah Todd to can I can I jump in here sure um if you if you would if if you uh remember Todd's spreadsheet the work was 10 in change right and then 15% on top of that and then an owner's rep on top of that and the grand
072total was 119 right okay so that 15% which is like about 1.5 million what is the what is the 15% yeah5 1.5 million that money is there for the oh my God we forgot this or the unknown you know we hit ledge so it could come in lower but it won't go high it could it could but you know I I you know I've only been to one Bond vote in stratum and I think the Bond goes something like not to exceed right right you know so it's not to exceed now you know for those of you who have a little bit of angst um I went through some effort to find out exactly exactly to the penny what the implications of this is for you okay so right now your your tax rate is
0731312 right $132 a $12 million Bond one would bring your tax rate to $13.49 you can do the math when you get home y 13 okay and last but not least so I got we got the bond we got the contingency oh God I think I forgot my question now see Paul you mess me up um let me think it was something along oh I know so what confidence do we have around once we make these changes that this will be good for 10 years or 20 years like if we started out with 41 we got down to the top 19 great but what stops us from coming back 5 years from now and getting we need another 10 million or we need this we need that I'm going to hit that head on okay
074because I would hit it head on at the bond vote this does not get you a new school okay it gets you a refurbished 35 year old school and as Todd said in a few years this school is going to need Windows and we've already looked at that a couple of different ways and that's about a half a million bucks okay and so one of the things that I am going to get pretty militant on this and other people have made the recommendation from who are in the financial side is to put together like a capital schedule okay and we need to get like we've got a couple hundred, in the maintenance fund right now you're going to hear me say I want $100,000 in it every year okay I mean there's just no two
075ways around it you either pay the piper now or you pay it later in a very big way that's why I'm bringing it up when I was living in do we were around the condo complex and we had our monthly fees for people but we also had a reserve right right so whether it's in the reserve it's just I worry about not only for myself but all the taxpayer is here cuz you know we're all we're all worried about that Jan we're all worried about it this one that's one of the reasons why I'm here okay not not that the others on that's one of the reasons why I you're all great and I want to thank you for going from 50 to 12 that's a huge huge win but just everybody understand this does
076not get you a new school this school is going to need work in the future it's going to need maintenance and it's going that's why I think we need to talk about Reserve or we get there or and also all the things that everyone else is going to bring up like enrollment and all of that because yeah it's not going to be a new school but is it enough education isn't always built on the best buildings give you the best education right I mean so yeah you want to have a good solid building you want to get your best education for your kids but as taxpayers and we're not getting bigger let's be honest we have no more land right so it's how do we just not keep coming back to the well thank you
077thank you yeah thank you so much everyone for the really thoughtful and um wonderful questions we appreciate you being here and um yeah this is all things we're going to keep talking about as Sophie said over the next few months so at this point we're done with public comment we're going to move on to the budget and then we'll have public comment again um but I know there are people here for the budget so I want to I want to make sure we move on can I just add one thing that was one of the reasons just because public comment is generally like you said statements to the board that was one of the reasons I asked Sophie about the Q&A sessions and so as as these get publish I think you're going to publish
078it probably on the town the the select board will send it out um we'll have it probably maybe a Facebook post or something like that right all those things please take those down it's a great opportunity to ask these questions we'll take these questions that we heard tonight and be prepared to answer some of those in advance in those meetings but that's a great interactive opportunity uh to be able to dig into this a little bit more especially around like the academics and how we would what the uh the impact on academics would be around some of these changes yeah thank you okay well thank you so much thank you we'll be talking to you a bunch in the next few months thank you sir want to do Kara back up right okay um so
079we're just gonna reorg for a little bit so we can invite um fa up here you want to yeah okay um yes all right I'm going to Quick um as I said at the start of this meeting I know you guys are here for the budget we're very cognizant of that if you trust me to let you know that we are trying to do things to speed this up we are going to go into nonpublic for a short amount of time and then we will be back um so I'd love to entertain a motion to go into non-public under a letter A okay um do I have a motion so moved okay thanks Eric do you have a second second all right we're gonna do roll call I I I I I I all right
0805 Z so we will head back into this room and do a non-public and we please invite you guys to stay we will be back all right I'd like to call the meeting back into session um um where's my water no it's fine no I'm I'm just the assistant it's fine I thought it was your voice got one more it's hard to get water without getting locked out so if anybody needs water let us know hook you up okay we are going to come back into public session do I need a roll call vote to do that okay um motion yeah can I have a motion thanks a second to come back into public um so moved thanks and we'll do roll call i i i i i 500 all right we are now back
081in public session thank you so much um is there a motion on the table yes I'd like to make a motion a motion to accept all five applicants for the early retirement incentive thank you do I have a second second all right any discussion all right can we have a vote all in favor I anybody opposed five z0 thanks so much so um Eric is just going to offer a brief statement to just talk about what we um just voted on so we've been very uh aware of um both increasing budgets over the years and also what has um become clear is not a transitory uh decline in enrollment seems to be a trend and taking those factors into consideration um and also uh with a desire to maintain uh the teaching staff as much
082as possible uh we made a offer uh to all uh teachers who um would qualify and so that means a certain amount of tenure and certain age if I'm if I'm thinking about those parameters correctly and we offered uh the ability through attrition uh to be able to remove some of those um some of those roles and we thought that that was the uh most effective um both in terms of um morale and uh and the academic success of the students uh to be able to offer that as an incentive for attrition did receive uh in we can talk about how we did that but it was in a sort of a timed fashion where people had to be able to submit those responses and it was a first come first served type of basis
083uh depending on whether or not you uh met that criteria and we did get respondents uh who were interested in that there is an incentive um for that early retirement um and in so doing it still will have a uh certainly a a net positive effect to the operating budget so what you can imagine is that as some of our older teachers who are laded up higher in terms of um the pay scale because that's how it works here uh due to tenure um as those folks retire early uh then we have typically um I would say less laded because I don't want to say younger teachers or teachers who have less tenure um but usually those are going to be the people uh who are retained on staff so there's sort of a net
084positive effect on the operating budget hopefully that makes sense um and then what we can say today we did not want to keep folks waiting because we know that there's a lot of public comment out there and interest in the budget um so we will certainly have more deliberations on the Staffing plan but as currently proposed by the administration we expect a minimum um net offset to the operating budget of and I'll if Chris if you can give me that number I think it was 200 272,000 $50 okay so that would be a a minimum uh Improvement in the operating budget and this the board still would like to have more deliberations about that uh Staffing plan and what that might look like um and that will uh that will commence over over the coming
085uh board meetings anything else to add or anything that I got wrong folks no I think just the board was going to ask uh or just add you know one of our Bo board goals is really to recognize the staff of SMS and we do and we value so much and I think we're really happy that we can sort of offer this um incentive uh as a way you know of managing the budget and recognizing long tenure um of some of these really core teachers um and just you know thanking them for their service so um now what I would like to do is um I think the best way to do this you know we have um answered quite a few questions and when I say we I mean um the SMS administrators uh
086Mr andruski um and and so there's quite a few answers in writing hopefully tonight you know we don't necessarily need to rehash um some of the answers that are already provided um but I would love to hear if the fact has overall comments or questions um based on maybe what we said and also on some of the responses you got does that sound like a good way Heidi or um sure yeah this it it it changes maybe um a little bit of our approach here tonight can I just ask one clarifying question are the five retirements all regular classroom teachers no they're not how how many of them are you able to share that we had three classroom teachers so so will the other two be replaced that would be part of the plan that
087Eric talked about that we can't share at this time okay mhm thank you thank you for that information yeah um I think I'm going to start with just a general concern about the process um we felt like this was a little bit rushed I think all of us agreed that it felt like we were given um a quick brief overview of the budget I think last two weeks ago last week last week and we hadn't seen anything prior to that unless we had checked our email because Chris had sent us the information um a little bit in advance so we we had a little bit of time before last week but but not much and I started I I got a little bit concerned I thought I don't remember that the public budget hearing is
088in January I'm like why is that sticking like why does that just not ring ring with me and I realize that it is earlier than we've usually done it I think last year the public hearing was in January but every year prior to that as far back as I looked which I went back to like 2018 and 2019 and it's always been in February so this process seems very shortened and it doesn't I I think all of the members of the finance advisory committee would agree that it doesn't give us enough time to review this with with um as much of a comprehensive um eye as we would like to so I wonder if if somebody could because I don't know who maybe is responsible for setting those dates but I wonder if someone could
089speak to those dates and so we can understand why there's been a change um in the way our budget process runs in the way that the public P budget hearing um plays out so I I can just address the timeline so I've had quite a lengthy couple conversations with Mr Emanuel the the Town School moderator and the timeline got set very late of who was being appointed to to the fact uh and when meetings could happen so uh Dave and I talked that we would be starting early September next year doing an informational session talking about roles and responsibilities talking about in a chair for the fact and then also getting questions ahead of time but also being able to share the budget with you much sooner um when we set the bud when we
090set our timelines back it is based on um the Dr setting up based on when your annual meeting was on so our ual meeting was on is going to be on uh March 4th so we have to use timelines to back that up based on the recommendation timelines especially when you're doing a bond hearing so the bond hearing on the on the building you have to have that and there is a dedicated Post-it time of when that can happen so we March back all the dates based on when we could have the bond hearing the public bond hearing over $100,000 for the for the building so that's how the timelines got set so it's from that it's also when we also have our our um vacation in February that U ties into some of how
091the decisions have made of when we can meet and actually hold other meetings so that that is how it got set so okay in the future we do realize the how Rush this does feel and I've heard that many times so David and I will meet earlier starting in in September to be able to get this committee earlier so you can ask questions so we're not here having you know probably about 55 I think 55 to 70 questions were asked in about a three-day span and we were we were really trying to get you all those answers before tonight's meeting and we really appreciate that effort thank you so much I know it takes a lot of time to review the questions and to find the information um so we are not really in the
092position tonight to make any specific recommendations we would like to have a little bit more time and I'm not sure how that's going to play out in terms of there not being another Schoolboard meeting prior to the public hearing um it could be that we just end up maybe making some recommendations after the public hearing since obviously at the hearing you might hear things that also cause you to maybe make some adjustments to the budget um but tonight we do have a few additional um issues that we would like to uh discuss um and I'm trying to think maybe how the best way um to proceed here um maybe I I think I'm just going to go down the list of what we talked about earlier we had a meeting with um the five of
093us we in the past as a financial advisory committee had requested that all of the software line items sort of be compiled together into one line item and it seems like for a while that happened but they've now kind of started to be scattered again throughout the budget and it's hard to tell always sort of what all of those S software programs are are there any that maybe are now defunct are we continuing to pay for things or are we continuing maybe to budget for things that we're not actually spending dollars on um so one of the questions that came up from the committee was um is there any opportunity that we could look at scaling back some of the software programs that they have um for the school and that would not include of
094course any special ed programs that are required um I'll move on unless there's any any comments towards that um also we were unclear if the furniture and fixtures item was going to be taken out was the decision to now take that out out or is that going to be left in or have we not decided that yet that's the 55,000 number that we were given yeah um I think we are looking at taking it out in the draft numbers that we're looking at okay and just so the public knows um because the building project when we originally costed it out at that $46 million um that included Furniture right tables for the cafeteria things like that that are also 35 years old and so um the idea was maybe we added to the budgets annually
095in a in a in a way to um slowly build um those Replacements in but um we've elected to take it out for this year um on the student AC activities budget um we had sort of a a discussion around the fact that parents have to pay for a lot of those out uh after school programs and so the question was why is there still um a light item for Student Activities I think it's like $3,000 um is that oh here this one is available the remaining money that's in that line is for our cross country program okay what what are those costs like bus No Buses you have a cost for all the coaches for um EMTs timing all that sort of stuff um t-shirts bibs just the cost of the program minimal really
096another question we had was um we know that students who are part of that inclusion model who come to SMS for the preschool program pay for pay tuition to be um enrolled in that program has the school ever done any kind of U market analysis to determine if we're charging what other preschools in the area are also charging Miss BL would you feel comfortable answering that well the charges for students that are what you would consider um typical role model peers so there's the price for three-year-olds who attend for about three hours four-year-old to attend for about five if there are students through the child fine law that by law access our preschool because they live in our community and they're three years of age they come free of um so it's just that component
097um as far as a market analysis I don't know the last time that that was looked at Kate do you know I know it's increased every year I can tell you um it's incredibly difficult to compare public um preschool with any of the preschools in the area for a variety of reasons um f first because our program is very different this is our first year that we've offered a 5-day program so previously it was a 4-day program um and if you were 3 years old it was about 2 and a half hours if you were 4 years old it was about 3 and a qu now like Kate said it's much longer for both both our three and four-year-olds um but also part of the expectation through the state and part of the program that
098SMS in is that you um are really looking to have as many peer models as you are of students that receive IEP Based Services and so you have to be consciously offering a program that is Affordable to those families as well to draw them in because that is the expectation of the state you know that you're trying to have a balance of special education um IEP Based Services and then your role peer role models and so to do a cost analysis or a comparative is nearly impossible when you're talking about a public preschool that's based on that model yeah I would add you have I we do have a wait list but I would add that the hours are different so for families that would usually pursue like a typical child care for their preschool
099like we can't we're we're done at 1:30 so most families can't make that work um so I do think that impacts enrollment as well but we I believe we have a wait list for both we're just at capacity as far as what we can hold in each classroom for student to teacher ratio and it's relatively balanced at this time the goal is to have I think 5050 yeah thank you that's really helpful to understand thank you Kate um we noticed that the legal budget went from $10 to $30,000 and the what we heard last week was that part of that was um potentially having some cost as a result of the building Bond and we would suggest um if that's the case if the increase is for the building Bond then it should appear as
100part of the building Bond and not part of the regular operating budget that would be a recommendation that we would make a large percentage of that Heidi was actually from right to no requests that we needed to get legal um Council to be able to work through the requests that were asked of us so yes there is other cost in there but the majority of that cost is based on right to no requests but not necessarily right to know regarding the building just other issues correct I so you're saying the full increase was not necessarily for that anticipated correct okay the legal for the bonds though is that in the is that in the number or is that already picked up no it was the increase that we made from the significant charges that we'd
101had based on right to no request and other legal obligations that we had had but the but the cost of legal is in in the bond itself to have people review and to uh we thought we thought the number was because of the bond but I guess it sounds like it isn't there's also NE negotiations are coming up there's a variety of factors that play into that total number okay thank you Heidi can I take one while you're typing go ahead yeah so it's our understanding that uh our facilities director is is leaving at the end of the month he's done a great job he's been here a long time devastating Pat huh it's devastating yes yes so he his uh budgeted salary and it's public information so I can like can say it's it's
10291,5 but also Tim's been here a long long time so he has a longevity in the budget of 46,000 and change so my way of thinking that we have an opportunity to try to replace Tim with maybe somebody 85,000 or something we can maybe pick up $10,000 here in savings between you know there won't be a longevity that that that $4,600 would go away and which is in the budget that that's been presented and then if we can bring the replacement in I don't know how where you are in the search for that and I'm not quite sure what what these fellas go for these days but you know there's an opportunity here to to try to save maybe another 5,000 6,000 plus the 4, maybe 10,000 total uh with the longevity because the longevity
103is based of years the longevity is based on the years of service here at the facility starting after 10 years correct so the new person wouldn't get any longevity uh pay so that's that's something we we hope the board considers could I just ask is there any do we have any comment on that on what Pat brought up I'm sorry can you is there any comment on what Pat brought up um so you're correct Pat there wouldn't be the longevity so when this budget is built it was before we even had the retirement so it wouldn't have been reflected in that um and then the negotiations for the contract will be when the finalist is brought forward to HR and then negotiate those things do you have a salary range though that's been posted for
104it I don't believe we posted with the salary range because it really depends on the given the market right now for people in facilities in custodial you're really it's very unclear what you're going to bring in for qualified candidates as you know we were couldn't even fill custodians Sor another question that came up um is related to the salaries of regular instructor A's it went from um 649 to 885 Molly I'm not sure which line that is but do you know what I'm talking about yeah I can speak to that um we had a number of positions that were either in special ed AIDS or in tutors that were misaligned um we uh as we have rolled out our mtss model so our multi-tiered system of supports a number of those um positions are not
105serving um special education students they're serving all of our students that's how an MTS system is built and so they're just reapo reappropriated to the right lines so they would have come out of a different line and just put there correct it's not they were in a variety of other lines they were there were some in tutoring lines which I think was asked about one of the questions um which was also under special education so it needed to come out of special education that's why you saw a reduction in a few of those lines that were then brought into the regular Edline okay um there was a question I think it was around sick payout and that's based on projected retirements is that correct um so every year we take a look at people who
106might express interest in retirement um we don't fully budget for every person eligible to retire because we know that's not going to happen um and in the document there we have two unions and each Union has a collective bargaining agreement or what we refer as a CBA and each CBA it has the provision for retirement on how much they get paid so I did put a screenshot in the document that was shared for me for you from each of those uh cbas to determine um how much they get paid okay great can I ask a question around that though so mhm we said but these teacher retirements or early retirements that we made net 272 part of that 272 did that include the the uh the sick time payouts correct as on as an expense
107against what we can gain or is it coming out of that budget line item which is pretty much doubled uh because you never recruited for that before I know years a couple years ago you hadn't acred for it you you recr like top of my head 64 I think it's almost doubled uh in this budget the the acral for sick uh buyouts when people leave just normally leave uh is a way of paying out there there's a whole policy on this right about sick payouts um but when you when you when you mentioned the 272 in our deliberations it be helpful to know if that was already factored into the 272 or did you go to that some of that stuff that was budgeted elsewhere and are we using some of that to offset so
108because obviously these folks are going to be paid off for their uh extra um sick time or their unused sick time I guess what I'm saying is that impact that line at all in the budget it does impact that line so we did the whole calculation but we did keep a certain amount because we might have other retirements that would come along next year not teacher retirements but other retirements as well as one other known retirement that we've already spoke about tonight right but would that figure cover all of these retirements that is part that calculation that we had done on the Excel project is all inclusive of the cost okay so if we said let's reduce that number it's already been accounted for it's already been accounted for and the next time we rep
109the budget make the changes of the personel you'll further see that that's the answer thank you U so so just to be clear so it's not well maybe this isn't maybe I shouldn't assume this how How likely is it that you're still waiting to hear if someone else is going to retire I mean they have till February or January 15th have have those requests now been made known because it would be so just keep in mind that's just the teachers oh that was just a teacher incentive okay it was and so um in this CBA for our esps um it is there's not a set date there's a time frame of if you want to be collecting retirement how much time you have to give but it is not a set date such as the
110teachers which is January 15th and then you do have a series of um what we can call non- unior employees that might retire as well that don't have a set date I see at least it's well it depends on the position actually okay so the bottom line is you need to make sure you have a little bit a little bit of padding in there to make sure that someone's who you didn't expect was going to retire does retire padding is not a good word just to have make sure we're not taking away from other programming in order to fill that yeah and the incentives were only offered to people with certain criteria so if there were people outside that criteria I see they could retire and you can't share what those criteria are I don't
111know we can we identified anybody that was of age 55 or higher and had been here for 10 consecutive years 15 consecutive years excuse me thank you Michelle at SMS how many 15 years or more 15 consecutive 15 consecutive years thank you I appreciate that um related Services um Molly that's 1210 50331 can you that went up 22,000 can you um explain a little bit more about what that's for what line are you talking about special ed related Services Heidi um it's a 1201 is that 1210 sorry 1210 is that fed that is special education y so um and it actually if you look at related Services which is the 12 50331 um projected for 26 is actually um less than we projected for this year oh it's a reduction that's right yeah I should
112have known that I saw the parenthesis and I didn't didn't register in my head and and what was the why why did that change so that we try to make that as close to actuals as we possibly can based on the current students and their level of services and so that fluctuates based on our student population at any given time okay can I just ask Kate could you characterize what related Services includes um it can it can include a variety of different Services an example I could give you is um we might have students that need um a registered Behavior technician with a board certified behavior analyst as their support that's a required law that there's oversight by a bcba for that position um um and those are for students with par sometimes really complex
113profiles um that require a lot of onetoone um services and direct explicit instruction that has a highly specialized training that is not typical full-time employment within a school um and then the esol contracted Services is that one that went up I think sorry I I was collecting everyone's questions um yeah it did it went up from 15,000 to 30,000 so so you obviously have more students this year and you know you're going to need the services for next year I assume we do um that is that's based on actuals and that's another example of a contracted service um there are plenty of schools um that actually have full-time esol teachers on their staff um up until today um Strat Memorial School had never had enough students with that level of need which is based on
114an actual exam that they are required to take that measures their level of service it's a national normed exam um we've never had as many students with the level of service that would require us to have a full-time person and as of today we do so that's an increasing number as we evolve I got a real basic question this es o l can you just Define those letters for me please yep English Second Language learn second language okay so we have more second language students here now got it okay um a question on Grounds Maintenance uh was $43,000 and someone wanted to know what falls under that so that's everything from like Pest Control to our irrigation um I can pull out all the details for that but um so it would be Pest Control
115irrigation um mowing um we have a variety of like curbs that have to be done sometimes there's all sorts of things that fall under that every year it really depends on what projects we have planned for it like smaller things like repair but no major projects because those will be pulled apart Okay so I think I'm going to kind of open it up to the um rest of the committee if if they have other questions because I think I covered what we talked about um and I one of the things that I um noticed it was one of the questions that I had sent and it was regarding um student teacher ratios and without going into all the details I'll just say it looks to me like fourth and fifth grade based on the guidelines
116that you guys set around how many students should be in a class in fourth and fifth grade that there could POS there could possibly be higher um student numbers in those classes however for me personally I want to understand what the impact would be about if if we had if we went forward and had had higher um students numbers in those classes and I want to sort of pref like add a little bit of context to my question um when my son was in fifth grade he um needed some accelerated math um instruction and he had tested out of the the curriculum and um you know I talked with the teacher and administration and we finally settled on the fact that he would take kicad kic Cadabby math during the time when his classroom was
117taking math and I didn't love that solution it seemed to me like it was almost punitive but I presented it to my son as like wow you get to do this and during math and then that way you won't be bored and it was you know and it worked out it worked out fine for him I've learned recently that there's now actually a cohort of students that get pulled out to have that accelerated math program and what that does is it gets those students ready to take pre-algebra in sixth grade then they take algebra in seventh and and geometry in eth and it's it's an accelerated track and it helps these kids who are ready to move at a faster Pace do that and I would be very concerned um if having classrooms with more
118students would impact that kind of program in a negative way because I see those kinds of um investments in programming here to be so important I think when you look at individual students and are they are they making gains year after year you don't want to just look at the students maybe who are behind are they catching up you want to look at students who are maybe learning quicker and maybe are ready to dive deeper if they're also being challenged and G being given the opportunity to um have access to um a more robust care culum so I wonder if if you could speak to that I guess the other piece of that I'm I'm also concerned that we're looking at in fifth grade students who in 2020 were in kindergarten right are we supporting
119the social emotional needs of these students who went through sort of a very traumatic time and not just them also the students who have come up behind them we know that um the pandemic put into very clear Focus these social emotional learning issues at our students have and I sometimes like to compare it to this um idea that kids when they come to school and they're hungry they can't learn right and so we had breakfast programs and school lunch programs to make sure every kid is eating and I think I I feel like this is very similar to that you can't have a child who is acting out in class or doesn't have emotional control you they're not going to learn anything in the class if we're not addressing those issues if if um those
120kids aren't making strides in Social emotional learning as well as other kinds of learning so I wonder if you could speak a little bit to that and how that how increasing or decreasing class sizes and I'm looking more at those fourth and fifth grade classes because it looks like for K through third grade you guys are probably right right on target with what your guidelines are so I'll leave it at that I'm assuming you want me to take that yes please um I want to be as concise as possible um so yes to both your points Heidi um It Feels So part of the mtss model that we have rolled out this year we talked about this I think it was the last board meeting um was our ability to provide some of that personalized
121instruction for people for our students that were ready for extension um and that has been something we've been um has been a goal and we've been striving for and had been unable to figure out um with our with the way our schedule is built the way our Staffing was built um and this year we've been able to do some of that and that feels really really good I was um in the The Cottages um last week doing some observations um and they had a group of third graders for extension math out there and the whole building was like rocking like it was like a buzz with like energy because they were doing some pretty complex they had whiteboards and things I mean everywhere right um so yeah I don't want to lose that that's really
122important that we continue to build on that we're just finally getting some really good traction on that in a way that isn't having a kid isolated to do their learning because they're ready but really we know that learning is really a collaborative thing and should should be involved with the adults as much as the kids right so that there's opportunity to really stretch and pull um the the other side of that for me when I think about a group of a 16 or 17 children in a room um is the demands that we now put on our classroom teachers is dramatically different than it was 15 20 years ago in what we asked them to do in personalizing the education that they provide for our children um and the diversity of children that they have
123in their room um is um I would say it's a broader scope of what students both both their challenges but also their strengths right so I think that that's also a beautiful thing and I don't want to lose sight of that um and you're right that there are impacts on our kids from covid um we've been looking at our Dynamics in our second grade and our third grade and thinking about them in fourth grade and fifth grade with four classroom teachers and not five and having significant reservations because of their current profiles the complexity of those the level of Service delivery that they're requiring the level of time that we spend working on um occupational therapy as a whole class um for because of the skills that are finally now coming now that they're finally
124ready for because they weren't ready for them two or three years ago because they were missing this experiences from when they were three or four years old um so there are significant imp PS I believe on a classroom when you reduce um sorry when you increase the number of children in that room um I think that's hard because when I look at studies that have been done about that they're 20 and 25 years old and so we look and we're like oh well they say class sizes can be 25 and that's what the research shows and if you make it a little bit bigger it's no big deal um that was 20 and 25 years ago that is not the world we are facing today um I think our I think our community ask more
125of teachers than it did 25 and I'm glad they do that's not a criticism I want to partner with our community but the expectations of what we provide for children is very very different um and so for me that matters a lot when we think about reducing the number of teachers in a grade level but the uh can I chime in and then I'll CH in after you I didn't realize huh did you had your hand first you go okay so I guess the board not this board but prior boards have recommended ranges and for the fourth and fifth graders they said a a minimum of 18 and a maximum of 22 so this budget called with five classrooms with 81 students in 8th grade and and budgeted in uh 79 and in fifth grade
126so we got 16.2 to1 and 15.8 to1 uh students per class if we made those four it goes up to 20.25 to1 and 19.75 to1 so 20ish okay uh with with the actions that the board just took it would seem this is the opportunity to seriously look at reducing at the very least that those those two grades uh and it it falls right in line right at the midpoint of where the prior boards have suggested uh we'd be at so uh given that given that most of the expense here 3/4 of it anyway is in in salaries uh this is an opportunity I think that we should seriously look at at that um and my sense is that maybe the board has already done that but um but it falls we have to say that
127it does fall within the guidelines that was established by prior boards uh as being reasonable in response to your question I just would Echo what Kate said and add that student successfully is dependent on the teacher um before building or anything else that is your number one indicator of success is is the teacher for students um there are years in teachers experience where you have 16 students and it feels like 25 based on the Dynamics and other years where you have 25 and it feels like 12 and so those Dynamics are ever changing and I think the world children are living in today and the things they are navigating has made each one of their profile so much more complex that pulling it just to ratio is is really simplifying something that is unique and
128complicated I think when you add four students to a classroom your there's it's really simple math to say that you don't have more time to offer those four students so when I planned my family and decided I was going to have children of my own a fourth I'm not going to have more time for them I'm just splitting my time 25% right so you you don't have more time to offer the individual support that is needed to have high levels of success and that's something we're all committed to and so if we're committed to Improvement whether it's test scores learning whatever you're looking at increasing class size probably is no way to accomplish that you're looking at more meetings for teachers more time for student conferences like every piece of it every student you add
129you're pulling that teacher thinner and thinner um and so I like Kate had said I'm concerned about continuing to add teachers plates um Without Really Ever taking much off and so that's just an important piece I think to consider um sometimes more students in a class can offer some social benefits you know you get a little more groups to mix up and things like that or can make your social dynamics more challenging and so that's negligible I would say you know uh so I had a question uh about the amount of time for a classroom teacher that has to set aside for like 504 IEP implementation because we're looking at the ratio and I'm thinking you know there's savings that people are talking about but also that's time that you have to cover that class
130so you know I just from my observation I seen it's quite a bit of time so I'm assuming that adding or increasing the ratio we're going to have to consider how many teachers we have to cover for those folks right I mean I I don't know how many like the average of students there is that have IEPs in particular class but obviously by adding 25% you're going to add 25% to that workload too right uh there are a couple things I can say about that I think the time out of classroom for meetings is a constant conversation here about how we can um minimize that because that is lost in time with their with their teacher um and uh so I think you made a great Point cam it's not just students that might have
131IEP Based Services but we're talking about students that have 504s as well um I think when we did our mtss presentation in October I think there were was it 64 students with 504s right so you're talking about those um then we have child study teams which is the meetings that take place before your you might have a 504 plan or before you might have a student receives um IEP Based Services those are all meetings out of the time out of the classroom um there are I had one teacher today in third grade that was out of the classroom today for three hours for three different meetings um and that's not abnormal um the other piece I would add about there is a cost to that so we are incredibly fortunate to have the wildly talented
132um esps that we have but they are also then compensated when they're asked to cover a class for a day um as they should be just like if we were to hire a substitute for the day so that is an expense when we're pulling teachers out of the room because the esps thank goodness are willing to cover uh those classes and teach so there are those expenses as well Cam and the so the mtss I do what ask a quick question about that too this is probably like a really complicated analysis but is there some sort of like industry Benchmark about mitigated cost from early intervention because I think while we're looking at savings I don't think we're taking into account that hey if we did this early intervention based on this data then we're
133actually saving money down the road so I just I you see it's very it would be really complicated but I'm curious if there's some sort of like industry analysis on that um at this time there really isn't because that you you'd be looking for sort of a longitudinal study and it just hasn't been um around long enough across the whole country to really be able to do that but that is one of the intended benefits is to really provide the early intervention at the level um of like a six to 8we to 12we intervention um to fill in some of the areas where students might need some really more explicit instruction so they might not need further um and long-term support so that is the goal of it right so that we can do that
134when they're younger and their brain is more um plastic um but it's really I don't think that we have that sort of study yet okay and and the data that's gather gathered with the that process I know there's been a lot of discussion about performance and metrics and that sort of thing versus you know the ratio and the cost and all that so I just don't know if that type of data I know it's really in-depth based on that presentation there was like I don't know 200 points or something there was like a lot of points was like um will that data do you think be valuable for determining you know like year-over-year performance that sort of thing there are so many things so I used to be like if you would ask me 10
135years ago about student on data on students I had a real like uh visceral reaction because I was seeing data as a measurement of student and what we have really been able to do over the last three years is we have been spending diving into building our mtss system and then this year implementing it was seeing a data seeing data not as how the student is performing but all the things that we can do in response to provide a better education for kids and that's not to say we're not providing an awesome education but some of the things we' have learned like our curriculum materials it's alignment it's uh it is not the quality of the teacher it's the way that we support our teachers to best support our kids and that data has been
136incredibly valuable to us um what we're going to be talking about in January when we do our data presentation um one of the things that we've been implementing um this year and beginning last year was screening three times a year and more Universal progress monitoring data so that's going to be giving us both big picture grade level and then granular student data that we will be able to track over time to then be able to say like where can we be more efficient and more effective with our systems and get a higher um more personalized experience for our kids okay thanks yeah because the um what you know again we have that metric discussion and my concern is that you know I don't know that the metric that people are looking at is directly applicable
137you know what I mean it's like well that metric is up or down or versus what we're spending um so you know we're just trying I think you kind of captured some of it with you know there's certain groups and there's certain things and you know Heidi was talking about the progression overall so we're just looking at like what data could we you know try to bring to the public to say Hey you know here's some of the things that are going on this is what you know your money is getting right because I feel like just saying boiling it down to well this ratio and this performance you know what I mean so I think that's just something we're look saying like what metrics can we use to sell it as you know like
138it's not just this number you're looking at you know y um so just to I'm very aware of the time very aware no thank you very much for your thoughts um I'm just very aware of the time and that I would love to open public comment what would be helpful to you right now is this Q&A helpful should I open public comment uh I think great right to yeah just yes I mean not to belay the dialogue but um I mean I I would I would offer that as I said at our first meeting I mean if you if you look at what you're doing here 80% of what we're looking at as people and and so I think to really cut to the Chase and get to what's on a lot of members of
139the community's mind is is to understand the Dynamics of that better and and um and to a certain degreed in order to do that it's a little bit of a mind shift from from how we talk about it today um because because most people will walk around looking at student teacher ratios the decline in population low test scorers and scratch their head saying what are we doing it doesn't compute um but if you listen to the dialogue U from a lot of the professionals around the table um there's a great storyline here about things that they're working on to improve the quality of education and the results it just doesn't resonate with the community so I would challenge the school board to figure that out and get in front of the community and tell a
140story that supports what you're asking for because the story today doesn't support what you're asking for so that would be my challenge to you guys uhu really quick Mike specifically when you say what we're asking for what could you elaborate on that you're you're asking you're asking for a $15 million budget at a 5% increase and 80% of the costs are people and and um you know I think the community is pushing back saying that's too much right thank you the board has not approved this budget just by the way either yeah I'm just you asked for input yeah so okay do we have the signin sheet y I'll get it for you so I guess just as a point of clarification you know we've kind of we had that vote um for the incentives
141earlier we will be rerunning a budget and then presenting it in at our next meeting in January yeah so um I guess I just want everyone to be cognizant when they're talking about the budget that you know because of the incentives we're actually looking at a much smaller increase um so anyway just just wanted that to be clear um I'm gonna Jen can you clarify when when would you be offering a before the public hearing or at a different time in January well I guess what I'm saying is so this budget that you got where we see the 4.78 increase that's going to a new draft would reflect the early incentives you will reflect that in the $55,000 in Furniture which would be a 2.78% increase over last year does that make sense that and
142that that will most likely go to the public that's what we'll go cuz that's where we're at right now so that's what we'll talk about the public hearing and then that'll be opportunity to talk about it more and see if it gets reduced or changed in any capacity at that time so just to be totally clear right now you're sitting at about 2.78% increase Furniture that's okay thank you we get that ahead of time yeah given that we're working on it we we we will be working on it the holiday season is coming up and there will be people so but we will definitely work through that to get it to everybody ahead of time for sure [Music] all right thanks so much so um Steve just your name and your address for the notes
143good evening Steve Patton to Shirley Lane um I really am grateful to the board for the reduction in the bond request uh I'm also grateful to the board for this update on the incentives for retirement I think that uh that's a great help as well um but I do understand there's still a a uh pending request for an increase in operating costs and I think after the outpouring of taxpayer concern last year that feels kind of unreasonable um the State education department show that uh stratum costs more than 15% above the state average for elementary per student expenses further uh ranking sites like us news and World Report and Niche uh show Strat Memorial as kind of a mediocre School in the rankings seven of the top 10 ranked New Hampshire elementary schools cost less
144than stratum five of the top 10 ranked schools actually cost below the state average um top R uh ranked Mason in Mason New Hampshire is 42% below the stratum State reported per student cost and that is also 23% below the state average for per student costs it's clear that a superior education outcome is achievable at reduced cost from ours the board should consider significantly reducing the operating costs of strata Memorial this year and I suggest that they consider reducing it enough to pay for the increased Bond and the near-term repairs that have hav been budgeted yet um these repairs are basically deferred maintenance from previous boards um and the town of stratum itself has gone to Great Lengths to keep the tax flat for Town operating expenses and I think there are a number of
145residents who feel that it's time for the school to attempt to do that as well thank you thank you I have copy of my statement and rankings for anyone who's interested okay thank you Paul Paul parano 10 haywick Drive stratum um I just want to further uh support what what Steve has had to say I I am against raising the SMS operating budget for the 2526 fiscal year um and I I point to the fact that enrollment is declining it declined 6% this year from 530 to 499 and that seems to be the the the uh the statistic that we can expect in the future it's a national statistic it's a state statistic and I don't know how we can continue to increase at $750,000 budget increase when added to the new Bond for the
146$12 million $12 million school is going to kill this the uh the the seniors in this in this uh Town seniors Unfortunately they and they and they've lived here and built their houses and and have been stratum citizens their whole life and uh basically they're the ones that can least afford a 63% increase in assessment which is what they're hitting because they're living in a house that averages that actually Peaks at 512,000 it maybe two years 5 years ago maybe it was at 250 but it went up 63% and now their $500,000 house is being assessed at $ 830,000 and um they're being asked to fund a huge burden that they didn't anticipate um asking for this 5% operating budget is really adding to their burden we need to consider there that they're in a
147difficult position I hate to see I mean there was a woman here who just talked about she moved in here and now she's wondering why she did you know that's just part of the situation I think it's it's typical um those people aren't making the big bucks they can't go out and buy a 8 10 room house we're at the million two or something like that and guess what those people's taxes didn't go up or if they would went up they went up slightly I'm very disappointed in the in the assessing uh people that that that that reassessed our community I don't think they did a very good job and also they reduced the commercial property I mean they created a mess is what they really did um we need to finance a bond for
148this town just about 30 you got a choice you got a choice you don't if you don't well if you don't you don't Finance the bond to its you can you can reduce the cost of the bond and and and keep in mind that the bond has the majority of the of the work is to keep the building running because like Steve said it's deferred maintenance it's been we should have replaced this equipment 20 years ago or 15 years ago so we got to you have a difficult position right now we we have a building that that needs to be renovated and we have a school that needs to be run and um but I'm telling you I've talked to the seniors I know what they how they're feeling and i' I've got to go
149in front of that those seniors and convince them to spend $12 million in a couple of months give us a chance because if this if the school budget goes if the if the tax rate goes up over $14 it ain't happening thank you Paul thanks all right Mike anything to add all right John John Baker 25 kinlock Drive stratum I agree with everything that's been said I'm not going to go over uh repeat everything uh I can just say that uh my tax rate just went up 21 my tax dollars went up 21% and they went up over $1,000 last year too and now they go up another 21% the school yes the presentation for the remodel was great and it's to be brought down from where it was is fantastic and it's necessary we
150need to do it but we can't take everything at once can't take this uh increase in the budget 700,000 we just can't you know it's it's going to be asking too much of the taxpayers and it won't fly and then the budget uh the bond won't fly so I agree with everything that's been said here thank you thank you uh Glenn evening Glen LC for the farm Ro bottom line up front the school administrators need to sharpen their pencils and ensure a 0% operating budget increase over last year's budget and school board members should only vote for a budget that meets those goals you'll be coming to the taxpayers in a couple of months requesting us to pass a $12 million bond for the building changes this Bond should be the sole focus of your
151board for increased spending is there is a limit on what the taxpayers are willing to pay I understand our school administrators can ask for any budget they see fit to achieve the educational outcomes for our Town's children I also know it is your job as a school board members to paint the lines they need to stay within and to serve is the taxpayers representatives to ensure fiscal constraint and that funds are not used frivolously or wasted if not expect the taxpayers to act and reject any operating budget increases during the town vote I want an excellent education opportunity for our Town's children at SMS my son received very good public education in sau6 graduating college sumacum Ludi this last spring which all started here at SMS in his time here at SMS we had 100
152plus more students enrolled our students test scores were in the top 5% this entire time at this school in New Hampshire and our teachers were in the top three in regards to compensation it was that academic education focusing on what some would call Reading Writing and arithmetic that laid the foundation for my son so what happened because the only thing that remains are the high teacher salaries as enrollment is down we're losing students to private schools charter schools and homeschooling while our students test scores have plummeted as well as their ranking in the state we seem to think that throwing more money at the issue will be the answer but that hasn't moved the needle with 21 administrator educator positions per our last Town report earning over $100,000 with Educators only required to work 184
153days with no more than 7h hour 10-minute work days I feel cheated as a taxpayer and we are overpaying ultimately is our Town's children being cheated both SMS and the corporate corporative school budget have the greatest impact on our residents taxes I wonder if you're aware of the impact of the property reassessments have had on our residents especially the most disadvantaged we are quickly becoming a town that does not allow diversity and I am referring to income diversity pricing residents out of our town that can't afford to live here I didn't see any of you at the select board meeting two weeks ago where many of our low-income senior citizens showed up asking how they were going to pay the ,600 to $2,100 tax increase that was due today many Express concern they couldn't afford
154to stay in their home if there weren't meaningful changes one gentleman said his increase was due was more than he takes in in a month and couldn't even get a loan from the credit union to cover his entire tax bill most of you probably think you got hit hard with your new tax bill but if you had a residential property your assessment went up an average of 59.4% our lower income res residents typically in condos saw a 69.6% increase and manufactured homes increased a whopping 100 and 1% in their assessments when you leave tonight I encourage you to take a right on level Road and you will see very modest manufactured homes that saw their taxes Skyrocket we have no exemptions in this town for low income until you reach the age of 65 to
155make matters worse Our Town didn't have the foresight to increase the lowincome elderly exemption with a warrant article last March so there's no relief the town can provide these disadvantaged residents for this tax bill future relief is dependent on residents voting in March to approve exemption increases on a warrant article being crafted I hope I can count on all of you to vote Yes on any warrant article regarding elderly low exemptions blind or death exemptions for those unaware these exemptions provide a property value reduction so for many the value of those reductions just got cut in half with the assessment increases but what about the young struggling family I'm almost done but what about the young struggling family who receives no exemptions do we keep increasing our taxes with school spending so none of these
156income dis disadvantaged children will be able to experience our schools we can't do anything about the teacher contract which has program increases through 2026 but we can control our school operating budget it's time to sharpen those pencils and slash spending thank you thank you yeah I I definitely hear the theme of Assessments this is something you know it's a very complicated issue obviously nothing the school board has control over um but I I do understand the bigger Point um Debbie it's Debbie Samberg one Barker Road um the president presentation done for the renovations excellent coming down from a proposed 50 million to just under 12 exceptional however I cannot support any increases to the operating budget to the school thank you thank you Lisa hi Lisa Hanselman 62 High Street um I appreciate all your
157hard work and know you're working really hard to get all these budgets down the presentation was excellent I agree with everything Debbie just said but I feel that enrollments down and families just can't afford to move into stratum um and I feel that um the increase needs to be zero we cannot afford it thank you James do you have anything to add thank you I have a question and then I have James scamman 96 Portsmouth have the first thing is the question uh we reduced the budget by 260,000 at the last school district meeting which was the value of one salary and I was told that the principal wanted that person and therefore they would be hired and the reductions would come out of support staff and I just want to know what happened this
158year did that person get hired and did the reduction come from support staff um want we' need some time to look through how those played out yeah and also I I would just you know as I'm sure that you know right the board does not micromanage how the administrators spend their money I I'm your school district treasurer I know you are that's I know you signed the warrants just so as to I right so um really what you're doing is approving an amount of funding to go to spend the to go to run the school and then the administrators make those decisions that's what I'm asking yeah did the administrator to make the decision to hire that person and I think we'll get back to you with an answer in January okay but I'll be
159in Jamaica I'll catch you in February um thank you all right now when I went to SMS class size was 23 now I'm hearing 18 I believe an increase to 20 is not a big deal and I understand you can think of at least 150,000 excuses why I'm wrong because I heard them all tonight and the fact of the matter is there's only one thing to look at if you want to reduce the budget you got to reduce salaries that's where the money goes Jeffrey uh Jeffrey Jason 46 buer Hill Avenue I'm up here to um talk about the uh the operating budget and I was here at the last meeting and I believe it was about 750,000 they're looking to go over from the previous year which and we have fewer students in the
160system right now I think it should be at the best know level budgeted from the year years before I know when when people present a budget they don't present exactly what they want or what they need they go what they want and that that gets reduced by other people in the system I want to talk about education too um I've heard a lot of uh uh alphabet salad anagrams being thrown around a whole bunch of different things um that stuff really didn't exist when I was in school quite a while ago but like stealing from the other guy line reading WR writing arithmetic kids are pretty much the same obviously I think the system where we have Internet computers and all that I you know they they they they gravitate toward that but back in
161the school when I was there you had to figure out the problems and if you couldn't do on your own you have your teacher help you and that's how you learn um the um like I said kids doesn't change I'm a school bus driver and I see the kids on the bus and I remember when I was a kid on the bus their their age they're the same people kids haven't changed but it seems like more programs are being introduced better ways to educate I don't know what was wrong the way I got educated back in you know the 70s but it seems like they got all sorts of different programs here uh you know for kids I know special needs obviously need their their things but it seems like there's a lot more stuff
162going on and the teachers back then you know were in the classrooms all the time taught their lessons and they went home or or they had their meetings about that and um I think it's being over complicated my my opinion only but it's um as uh big thing we get back to basics and and work from there maybe you know cut some of those programs out I don't know I don't know what they mean and I know there's a lot of them are mandated by the state and the government and I understand that but um I think the budget should be uh as close to uh last year's budget as we can get and we've already seen some I was very happy to hear that some of that already been reduced with the teachers retiring
163all that type of thing thank you thank you Mr Leo hi there I'm Shannon andalo I live at 8 Mason Drive um I've been in education since 1998 um and I moved to stratum in 2006 and I had a son who was one at that time I now have a daughter as well I moved to stratum for the schools and then I was lucky enough to get a job so I work in stratum I've been in stratum since 2013 I did two years as curriculum then I realized I was realized I was a little tired of working with adults and I'd rather be back with kids so I went back into the classroom and I have to say that from really truly when I started in the classroom 2015 to current kids have changed at
164warp speed um teachers we are at the um front lines every day um when I first started in 2015 I had 24 students I may be worried about three maybe um kids came ready to learn mostly they came ready for academics they came ready for their social emotional growth they came ready with very few behaviors what I'm seeing today is markedly different um I worry about a lot um kids need to come ready to learn they need to come fed they need to come emotionally ready they need to come academically ready as a classroom teacher there's so much more to my job than there was just just in 2015 My Two children came to school here one graduated in 2017 one graduated from here I say graduated from here in 2019 um my son is
165now a freshman in college my daughter's a junior at the high school kids have changed since my own children were here kids have changed um My Hope Is that as you're going to look at the budget and I really don't envy what all of you guys do and and I'm I really appreciate what you do you will look at class size I know that a previous meeting you talked about class size um was I think it was 2019 that you kind of gave the you know class sizes in fourth and fifth grade can be up to forget if it was 23 I will tell you I have 17 kids this year I work from the second those kids arrive in my classroom at 825 until 303 I am teaching them all throughout the day not
166only academics how to be great individuals how to work through issues how to deal with anger that's what teachers do every single day adding more students to our plate is not going to solve any problems it will literally create more so my whole reason why I'm up here is I'm really asking you when you look to the budget you do not make class size any bigger than it is it really will add more chaos and it will not be best for students and if I'm anyone wants to volunteer I'm looking for volunteers in my classroom thanks so much don't go don't go don't go Shannon shanon Shannon S sorry Mr L not we're not whistling at you I had her kids I just want to ask you a question please sure if you could if
167you could choose one thing oh God don't put me there yeah I'm gonna if you could choose one thing that you feel contributes the most to the change in students today from your one thing now I I assume it's not I heard not for the better I can yeah I one thing just one one thing yeah I think honestly technology yeah I do little has anyone here read the anxious generation be a little more a little more specific I just think I I taught fifth grade for very many years I just actually moved down to fourth grade because I just felt like I needed a little more innocence and I noticed that a lot of my students have had cell phones and you know social media and I think that's a really difficult thing um
168and I get it it's hard but I think social media yep thank you thank you be yeah it's thank you very much for that Insight Gail hi I'm Gail at 27 dumbar and Oaks and I wasn't planning on speaking and public speaking isn't my favorite I don't have anything prepared I just feel from my heart that I wanted to speak in support of the school budget um I believe that um I have two children at SMS I have a second grader and a fifth grader and they have both from the day that we showed up at their um their assessment I've only we've only had such a positive experience here um my children have been embraced they have been learning they've been um all through covid especially my oldest who was in kindergarten when um
169everything and his whole world turned upside down this school has been nothing but supportive to him and and my and my other child and giving him give meeting them exactly where they are and I just every teacher in this and administrator and support staff every person in this building that we have come across is here because they want to be here because they love to be here um they are here for the children and I don't know how we can't support people that are here for that reason um and I don't know how we I just in full support of our children and of the Educators here and I just and I also want to really compliment the um the accelerated math program both of my children are enrolled in it and they are loving
170it they have learned so much they're so excited about learning and I'm really with my fifth grader heading into CMS next year I'm excited for him I feel like he's going to be more a confident learner um and I just um I just really wanted to to share my experience so thank you you're welcome thank you um Sally no Sally Jen quick promise I feel like I keep coming up here all right I heard everything you guys all had great questions I think everyone wants a great school for the kids here I mean let's face it and everyone does a great job you guys have a hard job can I just ask who puts together the budget is it the principal and the I'm sorry I don't I'm the associate superintendent of schools okay so
171is it you two that put together the budget it's it's a it's a process okay it starts with every team starting in August and then we have a process every month where we bring and then it gets to this okay I mean with what we saw for what we need for the school and everyone's taxes going up even last year for the teacher salaries and all that stuff I just can't support anymore and so I I agree with everyone I'd hate to see everything go down the drain like the building and all of this and we all vote everything down because of the operating budget if you know what I mean I think people want to be reasonable and support whatever we can but I'd really like to see people sharp if it's like a
172business now it is a business we can't just keep raising costs I work for a big company they look at the product and they balance oop too many people heads go down this goes up our enrollments down we have to I mean whatever whoever the gentleman was that presented some of the top schools that don't fund as high as we do however our teacher salaries got that high or whatever that's fine but we have to either cut administrators cut teaching positions consider higher class sizes even if it's a couple we have to do something or the whole town will vote everything down and we will not move forward and we'll sort of be in a catch 22 that's my feeling I don't know if anyone else agrees disagrees I'm not trying to be difficult but
173I think we really have to start thinking about this like a business so thank you thank you we're not going to do clapping or public displays we're we're just listening to comments uh Miss Masten hi thank you for letting me speak I'm Melissa Masten um kindergarten teacher stratum resident um I've been teaching for 32 years um so I've been teaching for a very long time when class eyes as were I had 25 kindergarteners in the morning and 25 kindergarteners in the afternoon and things have changed um again I'm not much of a public speaker I can speak all day in front of 5-year-olds um and like Shannon said anyone who wants to have a wonderful time you're more than welcome to come to my class it's full of amazing people um but I appreciate the
174opportunity to speak with you today as a classroom teacher and a tax prayer in the community I come before you not only as a teacher deeply invested in the success of our students but also as a representative the entire staff who dedicate their hearts and Minds to nurturing guiding and educating the children of our community my colleagues and I spend countless of hours above and beyond our contracted hours we spend nights and weekends speaking to parents attending function birthday parties games for our students in preparing lessons and entering data so that we can be the best Educators each and every day teaching is an increasingly complex and demanding profession the expectations placed on Educators continue to grow from uring academic excellence and fostering social emotional development to addressing diverse learning needs integrating ever evolving technology
175into our classrooms we are asked to be teachers mentors counselors and sometimes am on the last line of support for students facing unimaginable challenges and we do it because we believe in the boundless potential of each child who walks through our doors when Staffing is reduced class sizes inevitably increase larger class sizes mean less indiv individualize attention for each student fewer opportunities for teachers to identify and address specific learning needs and diminish the capacity to support students who may be struggling academically socially or emotionally it's not just a matter of numbers it's about real human connections that are at the very heart of effective teaching and learning our students deserve more than just a seat in the classroom they deserve Educators who have the time and resources to provide meaningful personal Iz instruction they deserve
176environments where every child feels seen heard and valued they deserve teachers who are not stretched so thin that their ability to innovate and Inspire is compromised investing in education is not just about meeting today's needs it is about shaping the future while I understand the difficult financial decisions that must be made I urge you to consider the longterm impacts of those cuts I hope you can explore alternative solutions that do not compromise the quality that students receive and the well-being of our educat Educators who serve them thank you for your time and consideration thank you Marie uh Greg Mark was Mark um oh sorry Mark apologies hi Mark Santos 111 Willow Brook AV just have a couple points I want to make so the capital project I think you guys did a great job home
177run um I'm probably coming from a different side of the perspective on the capital project I think water is a very important uh element of the capital project um we will find in another 10 to 15 years how detrimental the water is in the town of stratum knows how important water is and what impact it has from being near a local Air Force Base so in that regard I just would advise the town and everyone that's looking over the budget and the final approval to consider water make sure that water is part of that plan I wouldn't propose any changes to the overall budget other than that I also want to point out the budget itself I think inflation is a reality that everyone understands very clearly over the last several years your budget is
178about 4% increase from last year inflation has been much higher as is with no change you're proposing a salary decrease to the Educators in this community so I don't see that as a problem I do think that were in a tough situation there are not less students there are less people coming into the town and the less people we have the less taxpayers we have which by the way will cause the tax rates to go up so we have to get people excited about the education system we have in stratum again so the way I see it is that we have kind of a bit of a branding issue I think your budget is fine I think you have to make sure accountability to the standards of Education are the highest in stratum we see
179the salaries very high here that's fine we should be proud of that but it should produce results and we need to figure out how to make sure that the community here knows that that's what we're chasing I mean I grew up at a school where um Neil Armstrong went okay so we look to that in New Hampshire we had Neil Armstrong go to our school we should be excited about what our schools can offer and we should be proud of this the teachers and the students that are going to the school and we should be excited about the results they deliver so in that regard I would just say that we really shouldn't be trying to slash and burn and punish the teachers of this Community we should be up figuring out how to we
180make them excited about the future and what we can deliver thank you thank you Greg Greg Richardson six pointer rocks Terrace um I've spoken at these events before as many of you know first of all I want to Echo what Mark said it's funny I went to school with where Adam Sandler went it's not the same but I do I do agree that you know I went to I grew up in the School District we were barely accredited I got out I did fine um but I I I think though like part of the philosophy I think as a town and I've said this in public forums before is that like the number one Legacy that we can leave as a community are the people we put out into the world Mark's excited because he
181went to school with Neil Armstrong like think about the impact that's how you do it and that's where education is really important and you know frankly I think the budget conversation I'm extremely empathetic you have my complete vote for Equitable um warrants to to reduce taxes I'm all four that I'm willing to pay more for people if they have to but it's punitive like it's like the results aren't there so we don't pay I think that's an assumption that we're overpaying you know that that cost is the reason for that and I don't agree that a school should be run like a business but I think you can apply strategic planning principles similar to what Mark is saying in the sense that we need to take a look at where we are as a school
182relative to where we want to be and I think that we need to use benchmarks that are reasonable the Mason New Hampshire example I understand it Mason New Hampshire the average cost of living is 50% lower than here and they have 79 kids in the entire school it's not Apples to Apples their average class size is 10 I mean we should take a hard look at ourselves strategically and say where do we want to go as a school what do we want to produce and how does that compare to other schools and other towns that are like stratum I think if we started there we could have a more informed conversation and the budget piece becomes noise again empathetic I mean the the stratum budget is about 71% of the whole town budget is school
183it hasn't moved that much in the last six years it's a the inflation is a real thing and I hope this same rigors put into the other parts of the town that are put into the school or else it just seems like a punitive piece thank you so much Cameron I have you down but I think you're all set uh well I have a question that's not part of this so it was from the building presentation so I also just want to I'm thank those two guys for saying everything I was going to say anyway but um my question for the building committee was at Future presentations I would like to see some transparency on the process C of the selection because it sounds like the vendor is doing the design and build and you
184know normally that sort of thing would go out to bid or something so it's not like you can take their design and go have another person Benchmark it I think you mentioned and I know this isn't back and forth but this is just for a future presentation I think you mentioned there's like a public Advocate or something for to monitor that is that right right um so first of all we have just completed well first of all the the board has not uh vot voted to move forward yet right we have to vote then it goes to the town we've only completed phase one then there is a separate process whereby we go to a um a public RFP for the build phase okay okay so yeah it's it's uh and and it has to
185the The Architects need to design uh what needs to be built and so on it's it's all public okay yeah I just didn't know if there was like it's not it's not I you know personally I think Kino did a great job and we check their references they are very um a lot of their past um jobs have been schools specifically colleges they're doing a big project in uh in Portsmouth right now it's not a college okay uh but they're doing a big project we so we called their past customers I did personally and I got Stellar just absolutely Stellar uh recommendations on them so we did due diligence with them but everything everything's public okay no and I'm just you know an ipating that being something especially when the bond goes to the public
186they're going to wonder you know how that was selected so thank and also Paul the phase that phase was also went out to RFP and we had how many respondents yeah the the original we had uh uh we had I think we we had four respondents to the original RFP which was to develop a scope you saw the scope here today and we interviewed all four okay okay all four were absolutely capable we chose uh you know based on several criteria not the least of which was was uh that they are right-sized for the project and the key the key individual that will be managing our project is a stratum resident okay and his children uh he's got a child in uh sms okay so I mean these things all matter yeah I agree with
187you thank you yeah and thank you so much for the insightful comments I mean I think one of the things I do just want to say is um all the information that we're talking about in this budget is cumulative right every month we um as a board take on a different topic so it can be the food in the cafeteria it can be um special ed cost it can be um what's the data coming out of the mtss coordinator um and so all of these things are building a story of what's happening at SMS right now you guys are looking at a very dry document um but we've really been telling the story month by month and so I would just encourage you to to take a look at some of the old you know
188minutes and some of the old meetings and you'll really see um what is happening here at the school and you know I'm obviously so aware everybody is so busy and we've been here three hours and I applaud you guys for sticking around we can't every meeting kind of rehash everything we've talked about monthly for the last year but um I would just encourage you to take a look at the website and and um you know we really have been trying to share what's happening at SMS and um and and some of the issues that that I see on social media that I see here you know we really we talk about them here too so anyway just wanted to to say that yeah so if you go to the SMS School site and you check
189out School Board you'll see our old minutes you'll see all of the information about the building committee um the building committee has been reporting out for years at this point um as we as we work through this process so this is not this budget is not a story born tonight right it it has been built um month by month can I also add that um every time we have a board meeting I publish a summary in the town newsletter the PTO newsletter and the SMS newsletter um so look for look to those places if you want a little summary after each of our monthly board meetings okay so let me go back to the fact anything um to finish I got a question or so let's say the budget doesn't get voted up it gets
190voted down my understanding there's such a thing as a default budget um I think it's important that we especially the fact understand it's not just that we freeze it at this year's budget level there are carve outs that have to be included is my understanding will you be producing a default budget so we know what the default budget is no that is incorrect Pat um a default budget is only in what's called an sb2 town so the Cooperative has a default budget but the in sau6 some towns are or some districts I should say are what they call sb2 and some are the old meeting style stratom does not stratum Elementary does not have a default budget you go into the room and you vote that night and you come out with a budget that
191night there is no default there has never been a default for shatam elementary school the only part of the stratum budget that has ever had a default is the Cooperative section right okay that's very helpful to know that thank you but can I sorry sorry can I just add to that and say while we don't have a default budget we do have certain contractual requirements and so if we were to take on let's say a $500,000 cut to a budget we would we would have to look at cutting things that we actually can cut like I mean we can't cut Transportation because we have a b a bus contract correct and we have a certain number of students that we know we have to to bus is that correct Molly I mean we do have
192a bus contract and you legally have to bus students to school correct and so you really would be looking at things like slashing teachers slashing programs so it's not a it's it's not something to be taken lightly if you're considering um something Draconian like making these sort of like a zero um a flat budget it um it means that we have to slash teachers because the teachers that we keep do have to get an increase because we already voted as a as a school district we are all members of the school district legislative body we already voted to approve those contract increases for teachers so the only way to get around meeting that contractual requirement would be to eliminate some teachers um so I just I wanted to clarify because that's a little bit of
193a nuanced thing with us since we don't have a def default budget I want to ask quick followup so where there's no default budget and last year the budget was voted down does it just stay at the previous year how does how was it determined if the budget is voted down um it it was voted to what the budget was voted the budget wasn't voted down a different number was voted okay I thought it was like a yes or no okay no thanks appreciate it all right any other things from the fact okay so thank you very much hope you have a great holiday appreciate you um working here with us and we'll be moving on with the [Music] agenda I have to go soon soon thank you to stick around yeah feel free to
194stick around everyone we're just getting started I'm doing a board committee report um all right State special oh no no that's no no no that's totally fun I could I was reading through the minutes I'm hang do that I just wanted to provide in your packet should we just take a two minute till everyone out Jennifer so we can hear instrument no we're trying to continue the meeting minutes less sleep can we can we reconvene come back tomorrow higher than us I know right yeah yeah that's the normal R oh okay green yeah yeah and so can it justar it is that how it knows or is he he has a little a little wrap like monitor on his foot yeah yeah I was clear I know when it goes below like then they thank
195did you have gosh no we had the cameras that was all we have yeah so Jennifer can we call this back so we can get going if I know I know it's getting late but people in the public can we finish with our public meeting please I'm going to ask all right excuse me everybody we're going to continue with our agenda so if you could please take any conversations in the hallway unless you want to stay and listen thought that was pretty loud this is be so thank you all right moving ahead State special education reimbursement yep so I just wanted to make you aware uh from the commissioner of Education the letter that he sent out on December on November 12th discussing how reimbursement for spa uh for special education cost is going to
196be reduced even further to 66% moving forward um so Dr Bennett and other special headed directors across the state uh have been talking about this because obviously it's a significant um um budgetary comment to think about not for how we develop a budget but how we get funds reimbursed so you see in the memo the respon response again we budget for what we know and the needs in our school but that reimbursement of any student the uh cost is about 72,000 and any cost over three and a half times that for students who are out place is what you would be eligible for reimbursement so a couple years ago we used to get 100% of that reimbursement and then two years ago was reduced to 85% and now it's being reduced uh in the upcoming
197years to 66% that's the formula so I I got a question about that is it actually getting reduced or is it the same amount that is just now spread amongst a larger group of special education no it's being reduced there is larger students there's more students qualifying and in the memo that you see that there was a change in the number of or the age of what students could qualify for special education up to age of 22 right so and typically those students that are are still receiving services are your higher cost students um so there is a reduction to what is being reimbursed back to our districts thank you at what point are these just unfunded mandates right I mean it's so hard to see how Public Schools survive with these um Draconian cuts
198and you know it's yeah yeah so that that's I just wanted to make you aware there are other things that we will make you aware of a board that will have impacts um at a meeting today we discussed that there are are about 285 lsrs which are um legislation that's being discussed at through legislation that will could have impact either through policy uh budgeting or uh other impacts on on um students uh that are being discussed and will be voted on so that that's a significant amount 285 we had about 184 last year the year before that was about 140 so you can see that there's a lot of talk to our state legislation and a lot of it is on funding uh and is on uh um policies that have to be put in
199place that ultimately uh dictate um funding for a lot of our schools so we hear you we're in that same boat and so we're trying to understand it so that we can navigate the boards the correct way so would we feel that in the 2627 budget or yeah it's a year behind so it would be yeah so we do know what we'd be eligible for I'll bring that to the next meeting in January of what what has been established so I can bring that to the next meeting how do you how do you derive that Chris how do I dve what derive that number that you're going to bring to us um because there is a list of what uh students who are eligible and what we'll get reimbursed back so we have gotten a
200list from the state of what but it's based on real people with real y criteria correct and matching that to funds Y and that's going to change year to 26 27 correct okay yeah I can tell you what we' be eligible for this upcoming year so you can have that uh uh are you going to talk about uh some of the work that you've been been doing uh in the SAU relative to uh special education developing special education programs for the SAU uh I could invite Dr Bennett to do that since that is what she drives and oversees I'm not specifically sure what your your question it was a conversation that you and I had uh in your office back a week or so ago I'm working on little sleep from from this week so
201you'd have to remind me but if there are certain questions i' I'd be glad to bring it here um so you have to remind me I apologize Paul okay about bringing special education uh into uh CMS I think yeah I I think there's a grand there's a grand plan um can I don't think I would elaborate it right now until I have more specifics about that it it but that could mitigate the effects of a reduced state aid is that that is that is not correct that is not correct okay can I just make a couple comments on this before we move on so I I know that we do the very best that we possibly can to keep kids in the school we've uh supported that as a board philosophically aligned on all that
202but we still have some kids who are going out correct and if we're providing all of the and I know the answer to this but I I think it's important and all the people who were here probably really need to understand what this letter means and and what What's Happening Here why are K why do we still have kids though we've we're doing everything possible we've got all these different resources why are kids still going out of District sure I'll let Raymond take that one and yeah I'm happy to so um we only have one student who is placed out of District uh in our entire uh population of students who receive special education services um and uh one of the things that I consider very carefully as I um Shepherd our special education teams
203our IEP teams through uh the legal process not me make decisions myself but Shepherd our teams through the decision-making process to be in compliance with uh state and federal law is there are certain criteria that we are legally obligated to fulfill uh in the least restrictive manner possible meaning uh in the local school district setting uh to the maximum extent possible so uh placing a student in an outof District uh setting uh comes from being able to demonstrate with hard data the uh reality that all of the things available to us in in within the local school setting have been attempted with Fidelity and we have hard data to support the fact that the needs of that student exceeded the capacity of our uh School environment to be able to fulfill so a student uh
204receiving outof District special education services has uh a level of intensity in need that we just aren't able to fulfill um here in the local school setting and we take into consideration uh have we tapped into all of the available resources and creativity and expertise that we have at our disposal uh in order for a child to remain in their local school uh with their Community um of peers um so uh not just with the decisions that are made to find kids eligible for special education in the first place um but with uh the level of intensity of services that children need uh so much thought and careful consideration and legal navigating goes into every single one of them so I can confidently say because I am responsible for shepherding us through that um that
205each of the students that are receiving special education were referred to special education for a reason were evaluated for LG eligibility determination for a reason and were found eligible uh or ineligible for special education services for a very specific reason that was datadriven uh and very thoughtfully considered within the bounds of special ed law I'm really proud of that fact I'm really proud of the expertise uh that we have uh on our IEP teams and our collaboration with parents and Guardians to arrive at those really life-changing decisions so as a school to have only one student in an out of District placement is really remarkable and I've been around the block for a while so thank you for that Raymond I just want to say because I think it's important I'm I'm I'm convinced based
206on the way that you described that that's what we're doing so I think what is important for people to know we're not taking kids who have behavioral problems and saying we're going to get we're going to send you on a bus and pay transportation fees and tuition fees because we can't figure it out what I what I also would say is that like I was reading about idea right past I think 75 and then in 1990 the individual's disability Education Act what people need to understand though is is a diagnosis could be anxiety it could be depression right it could be these it could be these things that fundamentally many of the speakers who were talking who are speaking today and reminiscing about about life 10 15 20 30 40 years ago in their school
207setting these were not these were not the same diagnoses so if if people want to have the the and I'm going to be out of my depth to some extent but I'm going to just say it as a parent if you're if you're going to perform your Psychological Services and your well-being services within the school setting that's what we've decided as a as a society we passed it in federal law we're passing it in state law then we have to expect that this is where people are going to come for childhood Psychological Services they're now coming to the schools you're not going to find as much outside of the school system probably because the resources are being funneled into the school systems to be able to provide those services and I just think that that's
208important for people to understand that that is in my opinion A change that has occurred over many decades and that now we have different requirements than we had and then when people were speaking about the introduction of phones and other things which you can absolutely see raising anxiety raising depression all of these sorts of things that are diagnoses these are criteria that are within law and if we don't follow those law that law we're subject to lawsuits we'll pay not only our legal fees their legal fees and then we still have to we still have to put the kids through the process that they would have been entitled to have I gotten much of that wrong you're pretty spoton okay yeah can I add a piece to that really quick Eric because I think what
209you're saying is so valuable and actually came up a number of years ago when we were talking about having a social worker as an employee of strad Memorial School and one of the questions was like what is the impact for a classroom when a when a student or two has significant anxiety like is it 10% of our population I was like in a classroom it affects 100% of the students in the room and so kind of going to what you're saying is like we're providing the Direct Services to maybe the student that has anxiety right or maybe has depression but the implications are that it impacts all the students right just like any student that comes in with any sort of any part of their profile and so it's important that we're teaching the coping
210skills to all of the students certainly the one-on-one services with our social workers is not for 100% of our students but the idea of then being in classrooms to provide that tier 2 level where you're talking or Universal level where you're giving some skills around that to prevent that from um happening to more kids because life is complicated um but also to like how do we as students learn to better engage with other students who might be presting very differently than us so there's a complexity Beyond just those that then are potentially identified as other health impaired through special ed there implications for 504 there's implications for beyond that that are financial implications as well right because that's we're talking about budget it is a much it's really complex when you think about what now
211happens within a school that did not happen within a school 20 years ago which is also more Equitable I mean being able to access Services right if I can't pay to have those done privately my child is struggling to learn that's impacting to Kate's Point all the all the students it's impacting the teachers time it's impacting the time lost on learning and if that family can't go at the support outside and we can provide it inside there are so many opportunities that come with that and so much success aside from if you can pay for the support you get it like that that's a huge Equity issue um that we've been able in the past 10 to 4 years to your point been able to understand better and then be able to provide those better
212resources like we know more so we can do better right and and I just want to say whether that is to be debated whether it should be done in the school or not the fact is it's being done in the school we're mandated to do it right there are implications for not doing it we just got a letter that says they're going to pay us less we're seeing trends that we're going to see more cases and I'm directionally in agreement that it's Reading Writing and arithmetic but when you tell the public schools that then they also have to provide all these Psychological Services and they're responsible for behavioral disorders of children it's no longer just reading writing and arithmetic so you the local board can do some things but these are conversations with your state
213representatives and with your federal representatives and if you want to have that debate it needs to be changed there in terms of the legal aspect of it well and I think an important clarification is that we're not a treatment facility right we are well at least I'll speak for myself I am acutely aware of the fact that the availability of for instance Mental Health Care at the community level is increasingly limited um so while we're not a treatment facility our legal and I would say moral and ethical obligation to Children is that we have to provide um services that allow them to be able to access Reading Writing and arithmetic so if they can't access that because of a condition um uh whether it falls within you know the uh federal law Ida or not
214we have a moral obligation uh to be able to support kids to the maximum extent that we can within the scope of an educational facility to support them to access their right to Reading Writing and arithmetic instruction so you know it's sort of a double bind that we're in that with you know against the lack of those kinds of services keeping Pace with the needs uh in our communities yes a lot of that um is falling uh to the schools in terms of the number of services that they have to provide to sort of compensate for that in order to help children be able to learn uh the things that we would like them to be able to learn so I'm not can I'm sorry yeah no I was just going to say thank you
215just an observation you know I I read that letter I clearly didn't understand that letter and I've had conversations with Frank edelblut myself okay if I get overall I get the trend um the um the the frequency of children who qualify for special education um special education is rising yet the state is cutting back on um its uh funding for it do I do I does that pretty much sum it up reimbursement reimbursement yeah does that sum it up that is correct well that makes a lot of sense yeah I think the way to look at it Paul is that the law the federal law in terms of what we are legally obligated to provide to children has not changed the needs have exponentially increased and we we don't just anecdotally say well then more
216kids should just get special education we still have to follow the exact same legal processes in order to determine if a child should even be evaluated for special education let alone found eligible so that criteria is exactly the same right the need is exponentially higher and the cost to meet that need is exponentially higher so when we excuse me the need is higher because there's more children that qualify with that level of need so the qualification bar hasn't changed the number of students who meet that eligibility bar has exponentially increased and the criteria hasn't changed right I don't want to call it eligibility it's the criteria there's a Criterion to to meet eligibility so we're seeing like we're just saying we're we haven't changed how we Define what these behaviors are what we're saying is
217that we're seeing a higher volume of these Behavior we haven't changed what constitutes legitimate need we have seen more need correct really like I'm since when I'm just trying to remember when I was a student I have no idea were anxiety and depression included then as well or are those new added like are the changed since when I guess well so there are a set of conditions that are sort of qualifiers in and of themselves to even be considered uh for eligibility discussions under the federal law so when idea was sort of Reed uh it broadened the categories of uh diagnoses and such that schools would need to consider still though regardless of a disability per se it is the inability to access education that is is the criteria because of a condition be it
218learning be it um psychological or what have you thank you there's so much cell phones are the root of all evil yeah I don't know how we're going to deal with that as a school board I mean given public comment that's yeah we're between Ro in a hard place okay I mean I think we we talk about it you know Cades talks about the contractual the legal responsibilities it's just it's hard to present it every single meeting um you know when Mike says have a story it's like okay every meeting we have a story It's Tricky um I would love I've actually reached out to our state reps right because I would love for them to come to these meetings um they should understand what we're going through here um right all that can happen
219is the Law changes these kids aren't helped in the same way because otherwise public schools are going to collapse I think that's you nailed the head is that we are trying to meet with our state reps as well because how we're funding education and it's being held up in the court of law right now to adequately fund and not get reimbursed at a full rate for the services we have to provide impacts our budget which impacts the population and people that we're talking today so if those were funded properly we would not be having this conversation right 100 so that is our job and it's the job of our residents to get in front of our state reps to continue to advocate for that to be funded properly and I think just to have a
220national conversation and state conversation local conversations about disregulated kids I I mean we've got to figure out why and we got to fix it it's not just a dollars and and legislation problem to me I mean fundamentally we need to get to the bottom of it and it's not our job but it's just my editorializing I do feel like that conversation has started you know like as someone with a seventh grader and a fourth grader you know I do I do hear more and more moms talking and I don't even this whole social media thing it's the phone period yeah people always talk about social media it is really complex because there's a body of research that started with occupational therapist literally like almost 20 years ago now talking about prior to even going to
221school the lack of experience their bodies are having in terms of like no shoes in the grass like literally occupational therapist started this like ma like major like we need some longitudinal studies because that is leading to um underdeveloped vestibular systems which leads to major disregulation as older children and so like this is I mean yes social media yes technology but this has been a major problem longer than that when you have two working parents when you have them you're putting them in too many structured activities like there's a body of research that supports why we're seeing what we're seeing like it's not like we don't know we know we just aren't doing anything about it I let's not pretend like we don't know we do know words societally we're not doing anything about it
222not you or me keep the kids away from the TV and the cell phones and get them out playing in the Ard yeah there's a ton of research with other kids with other kids yeah I've been listening to the anxious generation on tape and it's great yeah really lays it out for you if you don't know why've known known it just finally someone's saying it yeah well thank you for your time on that I just want to share one other thing under the superintendent's report which is good news Kate and I will be meeting with first student on December 30th and we're going to talk about adding two new runs on January 6th which will reduce Game Changer feel free to dance C I know we been talking about it but January 6 we will
223have two more buses running for stratum before and after school we'll actually have the routs uh laid out on December 30th with first student we'll put that out in a newsletter so they that parents know and on January 6th we will be back to nine bus routes which will be the max that we'll have won't be here till 4:00 hopefully we leave that with with some positive news from tonight we can be here till 4:00 kid should be here I was going to say um yeah because I wrote a letter to myself this month because um yeah four times I get an email saying 357 the bus is just leaving um she doesn't get home till 4:20 that's more than an hour it's we hear you and we've been working on it so now first
224student was has got it rooted out and we're anticipating that on the 30th I can't say enough about and Dawn too though like they've been incredibly when I call I'm like I have 16 issues they're like mhm I they're great okay um I also had told a parent um that we would report on the water every month can you just give us a update on the um filtration and sure so everything's been approved we've been working through the the environmental Department of Environmental Services um I know Tim's been working behind the scenes to get everything up and running um Kate I don't know if he's given you any updates I have not Ted talked to Tim in probably a week and a half so I that's the latest that we had from the last time
225but once that project goes up it will filtrate our water for all the pfoas so that again anything inside this building is fine it's that water outside that's coming into the building that that filtration will take care of so it's in the process it's just uh once it actually happens will be a quick process for it to turn around we just need to have uh the Architects uh MRA or taking care of that and then and then we're good to go or CMA I think is yeah CMA I think CMA all right no further timeline than you know okay no because part of it is um because it's Grant funded there's a lot of like certain people that make certain decisions based on certain qualifications so it's really kind of in their hands until we
226hear back okay sounds great um retirement letter SMS yeah so we we've already the cats out of the bag but that is the letter just to approve that Tim Harrington will be moving on at the end of this month he's been here for 23 years I think he's been such a valued employee um he will be missed uh he's other than just being a fantastic employee just a great person so I know I will miss my conversations with him he makes me smile every time I come in here so K you want to share something else as well we celebrated him today it was awesome so surprise it was it was a surprise he had no idea um and so we were in here and everybody sort of submitted a slide about their favorite Tim
227memories with pictures and memories and then everybody read them to him and he was like beside himself but like he sent me I think I have like 15 texts from him literally saying things it was there was food and celebration and cards and gifts and it was just really special and he spoke about just like how hard it is but this was such an opportunity for advancement but he I mean he was like overwhelmed with how special it was which was great yeah well I'll just speaking on behalf of the board you know um I've definitely seen him in all different kinds of context working with students working with committees um you will definitely be missed yeah best of luck uh anything else in the SMS administrative report no based on that we were doing
228budget budgeting and the reti incentive and all that stuff it didn't make sense to and we had just seen you have nothing left yeah we're empty yeah so I did get an email today about um food and allergies is food in the classroom a thing again okay so the we had um been trying to balance a safe foods list for a very long time um and one of the things that we were encountering was that we would do it basically like three times a year like update it based on the uh package well even in those that time span those were changing and it became this like wildly full-time job to manage um and so last year we put like a break on it while we could kind of like get our bearings and pause
229and and figure out how to move forward um the feedback was mixed some people really appreciated that some people were very frustrated by that um so a committee was formed here by staff was all staff L um to really collect feedback make a balanced decision make uh and to take control of that um and they really decided that it would be on a classroom level so each classroom adult will have all the information about all the students in their room and so when they decide and to be clear like it will be a very rare minimum like they're like maybe one celebration a year or two celebrations um it came down to like we didn't even do popsicles actually we did nothing last year yeah um so they really felt like they wanted to be
230able to do that on a classroom level so the the classroom teacher will be responsible for all of those things and communicating with their families when there might be a food celebration okay is the week that there's a bunch of those food restrictions oh it's thrilling news in my household it's um movies and popcorn it was really I mean it was great to see it the the staff came together decided that was really important them and yeah decided to do that and um consulted with admin consulted with the health office and really felt like they came up with what they felt was okay moving forward exciting anything from you guys okay moving ahead board reports um Paul and Sophie board um sorry building anything more to add I don't have anything more to add I
231think tonight uh was well received I think so the only other thing um I wanted to add so I look I mentioned the dates I didn't have official approval from the board to move forward with that yeah or any comment on it um the only other specific question I had is that we said that it would be kind of a presentation and um I don't know how I'm going to handle the the academic needs portion of that there are going to be questions about the academic needs of the buildings um am i g to speak to those are we gonna ask admin to be there for that portion are we going to have a statement prepared by admin to address those questions how are we going to address those questions about academic needs in those
232six presentations don't you wait until every all the dust is settled and everything that we need to decide and everything is done what do you mean in terms of uh you know the teachers and everything that we voted on tonight well I think he's she's talking about like the four classrooms getting rid of the trailer and the four class yeah there are still two classroom spaces added in our model well and also what came up here tonight to is security concerns and enrollment right so right you know those are going to be some big issues that are going to come up um like as Mike says the story of the building right it's not just the building itself um I guess can you send me those dates so I can see them and then what
233do you think about who we can ask to be at some of these um I mean the best are the administration but I the six dates to be out is a lot yeah um suggestion what first of all why why don't we put our heads together and come up with a list of the things that we think are going to get asked on which we need support and we come back and I'm happy to prepare like a written response if you have like what you expect is like frequently asked questions or something like that like I'm happy to do that I don't know that I can give six meetings in that short time frame and the function at work um but I'm happy to like sit with the two of you even and like let's
234think about frequently asked questions let's put a blurb together for like the space and the academic piece that way you have that material to answer questions and if there's something you can't answer you could always say I'll bring it up at the next monthly board meeting and we can answer it then talk about that what if we used our time on the 6th we have that 9:00 time we've been using for building if Sophie and Paul you came in the four of us can meet and put those academic questions in place so that we'd have them ready for there I mean we're just going to be basically writing down what we've been talking about for six years so January 6 9:00 a.m. yeah we had that scheduled out for building talk anyways if we to
235spent that hour to go through those questions and put it together in a template and we EXC I'm sorry we have one already planned we kept it in the books through this building project and when is it is that Monday Monday January 6 9 a.m.: you and me we we'll send you a calendar invite thank you you got it um and I guess why six you know is that so you're going to do six We have basically six weeks so it's four in person and to online just really trying to get a spread of different communities in the town and then online for the folks who can't be there in person um also just like a 600 p.m. online and a 10:00 a.m. online yeah it's a lot but it's also like how we can
236get to the community yep um I guess also I'm thinking about things like um PTO meetings what about them like could we C could we go to the next PTO meeting I already am okay I'm going to okay yes the PTO they're on the subcommittee two members of PTO and they are going to present so I assigned each subcommittee member one one or two subcommittee members will be at each of the presentations okay so that's another way to engage them in their the folks that they know in town so they're going to talk about why they're on the subcommittee why they approve this yeah I've already gotten um yeses from the majority of members of the subcommittee to their particular dates that's great I'm thinking it is great I'm just thinking like we're asking them
237to come to us are there events that we could go to them like you know like Winterfest and um you know like that Halloween how like are so for the PTO to get more engaged you mean or I just yeah are there events between now and March yeah we have the Showcase in January that's what I'm thinking about the Showcase January 16th it's uh Thursday like the yeah you totally could what about something like that there's half hour break in between so right there's 5 to uh yeah so there's uh 6 to 6:30 is like a break in between because the we can't have all the families in here at once it just does not work um so there's a little bit of break we understand some families have kids in younger that's there's a
238little bitak there be if we to that minutes I mean maybe we just hand out a one pager or your you know what I mean obviously we can't do a presentation yeah we could do that I was also wondering if I could um create a pamphlet for um students to bring home reminding them of the date for SMS in particular and the other dates and then also to show up and vote in March is that advocacy or something is that no you can do it important dates you can put it those you just can't say vote one way or the other important not for to have your voice heard because I'm not telling you what your voice should be I'm okay this is this is what you'll be voting for this is this is one
239of the options on the ball we cannot push towards a vote one way or the other you can say here's important dates and we can list the annual meeting to to votee why why they're important yep okay and we could say why we're so you guys set up a table right here get a ton of traffic and I would encourage a table because it'll give you time for conversation versus just handing out at the doorway this gets congested set up come over this way and you'll get a lot of people um and get conversations Kate will cheerlead pom poms the whole night I'm running the student council table and we're going to have snacks and um bracelets for that's a good idea little candy okay so January 16th we table who should I follow up
240with okay about that thank you um yeah th oh it's a Thursday usually my husband has meetings on Thursday nights so I don't know if I can do it I think I'm available okay I guess that's what I'm thinking is can you send me the dates just so and then CU board members we should be able to join yeah let's think about it's too much for any one person so you should have all the dates in your packet I think I included that right so it says timeline of key dates they're bold all of the key dates are bolded okay thank you so much the Thursday night that's I got a babysit that night but you should bring your grandson cuz it's an awesome night and then you'd have an idea of what school was
241like on a regular basis Paul snacks what do you mean no they're snacks you know you know what uh that nice teacher was talking about with the kids in her classroom they're all they're all amateurs compared to my grandson well we I'd love to meet him cuz I promise you he would love being here he's the one I was telling you about I know bring him on where where are the dates in the board pack okay I see him here uh they are on page um it's on a table yeah it's on the table y I don't have a page number right now oh is it 28 28 28 can't wa okay I think could you also just talk to PTO about any other events they might be doing um I had an agenda one
242time from a meeting and I guess if you guys can think of any other events we should table at or you know come is there bingo night when is bingo it's usually so does it make sense for January or is it all the way in March timel is there any way that we could get some visuals of the presentation from tonight like to have at that at the table yeah get the whole P PowerPoint is that what you want no cuz I don't I mean I don't want to like have that I would I'm just thinking like like a small I like some of their bullets yeah you know really good yeah well was only was only half a dozen slides the the other thing you could do is we could give you one of
243those yeah you could have it up and so people could look through it if they wanted to while they were right like I think you just want visuals draw people in much more than text they'll look at the text once the visual is there but if we could put set that up for you and you could have that running and then people could look through it and you could explain what you know and don't know you could make a little model most Architects do that I'm shocked they haven't I run month by month because of my husband's schedule yeah so um I'm happy to like help but like kind of Peace mail when that might be yeah okay I know I'm like could I do my church on Christmas Eve like stacked full of people
244all right um okay so do I have approval from the board to move forward with those six dates and create a poster publicizing those dates and start publicizing yeah them definitely great and then I'll come up with um yeah maybe NE on the 9th what the actual agenda for each meeting will be I have a rough one in my head okay of um the subcommittee person or I would open it introduce the subcommittee person the subcommittee person would talk about why it's important to them why they think they should do it for five minutes then they would hand it over to Kino Kino is going to talk give the presentation for 20 minutes then Paul toini will give his best sales pitch about the financials and then we'll wrap it up and ask the board
245the subcommittee member will ask people to vote on March 4th that's what I was thinking for agenda and then there's questions yeah I think the only thing missing from that is you know what people were actually talking about tonight too is why are we doing this right why what like the boiler's gone the you know Eda that kind of thing I could talk about I can talk about all that stuff when you guys why and why now yeah when you guys do your Q&A your brainstorming you want to circulate it and we can just add if we think of anything that's you know what I mean that work yeah to build a frequently Asked question and we can just get the FAQ and then now we that's very smart everybody will be prepared I think
246that's very smart so how are we going to do that though cuz we're going to meet do you want to send them to Chris then ahead of time you guys are going to meet in person right brainstorm send it to you to ask start yeah okay and we'll try to turn it around super quick like if there was just something we heard that we didn't see captured that way we can get answers for them quickly okay great and I would just also ask the board members to take a look at the I understanding everybody's time commitments but just take a look at when you could be at some of these meetings Sophie does not have to do every single one oh I was planning on it but great were you really you have me at
247everyone right I'm planning on it cuz you're sales guy want to buy a watch okay we got a watch all right uh we got to let people go home here um all right anything else for building committee no okay superintendent evaluation committee we're meeting at the beginning of January um Safety and Security task force uh we don't have any updates we haven't met again last time um Community engagement I think survey will go out in January no other updates yeah yeah I mean I we don't have to talk about this but you know just like social media this week you know people are like why don't we talk about the food in the cafeteria and it's like ah you know I know I was resisting responding I know I know you are I know and
248I was trying to as well um yeah I just think it's always such a struggle right um yeah nuts okay chair update nothing really uh strategic planning committee that is not me I'm not Sophie was the one who actually sat in on that so I my name keeps going I'll change that yeah um and I don't know when strategic planning meets so oh I guess that's what I thought I was just giving an update on the surveys going out in January there we go it is 9:30 whatever okay um policy committee Eric y we did meet um the policies are in the packets in here it was it was not as significant in my mind for a discussion perspective as our last ones were so I don't have as many comments there um there was
249some discussion yet in my mind you could either do a first read because it's very late or you could pass them I don't want to give them short shrift but I do feel that they I my vote would be to pass them when I'm asked for my vote on it um I don't believe that there's things in here around like lactation spaces and all this other stuff my understanding is that there's no need to reconfigure anything um for SMS to be able to provide for the policies so I don't think there are any considerations Beyond implementing those policies um as they have been edited so they there was a draft we edited on them and now they're here for for presentation so I didn't have I really didn't have any major concerns but I don't
250want to force anybody to take a vote on anything obviously did anybody else have any concerns on policies all right is there a motion on the floor then I would move to to uh accept the policies second I have a second all right any discussion sure all right all in favor I and then we are meeting tomorrow for next month's thank you Eric for doing that 500 z uh any old business any new business all right um do I have a motion to adjourn 948 motion Paul all second all right Sophie will second call I I I I all right thank guys