CorpusRecord 56421

Stratham School Board FAC Meeting 12/11/24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Blue Hawk Media
Date
2024-12-12
Location
Rockingham County, NH
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,130 words · about 57 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay all right thanks so much for coming out on this rainy night we'll um start our meeting at 6:01 um I guess we can start with pledge of Alle I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all all right great okay uh I think we're going to get started tonight um by taking a look at the minutes um does do I have a motion to approve the minutes motion or we'll review do do you have a second second okay any comment or um changes to the uh minutes of November they looked good to me and I thought they look good too all right thanks so much um do uh then I guess we'll just good

002to take a vot on we yeah we'll vote to approve um and all approving I I okay that's right we only have t um anybody opposed any OBS so 4 z z Tanya not here all right so the big we'll go to the fact do public comment if you want yeah should we start that do you mind Eric I think we'll start we'll start with 15 minutes uh and then um we'll save some for for towards the end too just so um if people end up coming at the end so we'll start that as everybody knows public comment three minute increment um please come to the microphone identify yourself all right so um very important meeting tonight as we talk about the budget of SMS um I think I just wanted to do two things

003before we started that you know first of all I just wanted to say Obviously the budget of SMS very important right to this town to taxpayers um obviously we're all feeling a little bit of the hit stratum has been going through a reappraisal and that's affecting all of us differently but definitely affecting us and at the same time I just want to say a thank you to Kate and to Kate for doing this budget um I know it is not easy um uh for you know those of us that do budgets for um our jobs um it's it's a job in itself and so um I just wanted to say thank you and obviously SMS is so important to this town and so important to us and so I'm looking forward to having a great

004conversation today before we get started I just wanted the everybody to go around and just introduce themselves and I would just love to know I think just the fact if you guys could just talk a little bit just 30 seconds 30 seconds just say um you know why you're interested in being on the fact and maybe connections that you might have to SMS just so we can kind of place everybody tonight all right my name is Mike hotton um I'm a I've lived in stratum for 20 years um I am a member have been the chair of the select board stratum for the last 9 years member of the planning board for 15 years and Man member of the Heritage commission for8 years um I uh my son is a resident in town I have

005two granddaughters one is enrolled in this school the other will be here shortly um and um it's a great town it's a good school and excited to be here have you ever served on the fact before for I have not oh that's great well thank you welcome we've been through a lot of Bud yeah I was happy to have your expertise tonight thanks for coming I P bramy yeah lived in town 43 years my son was of the first second grade that came when the school opened okay and my daughter followed that two years later um was a state rep for 12 years representing stratum I was on Ways and Means Committee so I've gone through a lot of budgets at the state level um the revenue side I hope we could talk a little

006bit of revenues revenues at the end I know most of it we have cost in front of us we need to talk about revenues as well um um what else um I was involved last year uh last budget as you know um there was a lot of push back on the budget uh that was presented um I went through with a fine tooth comb last year's budget uh I was going to do the same thing and then um uh Dave Emanuel called me and said you want to do it and I said yeah I'm probably going to do this anyway so so here I am and I I look forward to working with you on this uh you know we all support the school but we all to be all have to be concerned about

007the taxpayers as well it's a rail Balancing Act uh and like like the chair has mentioned there's been a there the increases in the taxes were not evenly distributed across everybody in this town those who had a lot of land got a bigger hit than those with less land um because that went up at a higher rate than than the properties themselves so so we just have to be sensitive to that and try to be hopefully all be creative in in in ways that we can uh fine tune this budget thank thank you thanks Pat um hi I'm Kathleen PE um I have been a New Hampshire resident for most of my whole life I'm an army brat so I was not born here but um my parents moved to New Hampshire when I started

008school um originally from Hampton um and and stayed in New England for college and then um came back after 10 years of working um once my husband and I started having children we're both New Hampshire residents we wanted to come back and move back to New Hampshire I have a fifth grader and a third grader at SMS we've been here since preschool um we love the school and I come from a family of um Public School teachers and so I know how important a public school is to a community and that's why I want to be involved in this committee that's great thank you so much thanks for your um I'm Heidi Hanson I think I'm probably the veteran um fact member here I've been I think when I C calculate it I think I've

009been doing this for 10 years now if I go back to the first time that I sat and and looked at one of these School budgets um I had both my kids go through stram um Memorial School and through the middle school and I have a senior right now in extra high school and I also had my kids spent some time in the private school so we've we've s we've seen it all done it all um but y happy to be here and happy to be part of the process yeah thank you so much and I think that sense of history is so definitely appreciate your time here Jennifer uh just as a heads up so I talked to is this public comment no oh do you want to come and use the microphone recording

010uh I was sitting over here I'm Cameron or but I met I talked to Dave Emanuel earlier this week about um being part of the committee so I don't know if you need something I was talking with Heidi about it okay Dave so I don't we need a fifth member I did not get anything from David yeah got Kathleen's name on Monday but I did not get anything since that I can check in with him after this meeting okay but I did not get an official appointment from David but yeah it would be great if you wanted to stay and listen and then um we we will be meeting again next week okay and just a point of clarification on that I think Cameron had planned to be appointed but then he wasn't sure if

011he could be here tonight so he was a little concerned about that and I encouraged him to to go forward with that and I think there just may have been some cross messages with Dave so okay um we can maybe work with Dave and and get that finalized so he's an official member of the back going yeah okay that sounds great thanks yeah we can reach out to Dave okay um so I think tonight uh you know this is a very important meeting we want to look at the budget I think we want to try to keep comments um sort of concise and short and on topic of what we're talking about so I will occasionally maybe be interrupting or directing um and uh but we definitely want to hear all the voices so um

012I'm not going to put you on the spot is g to talk or is there someone who could maybe talk at a high level and my kids are in the hall I'm going to go check on them but I'll be right back um I think it can everybody hear me oh my goodness yeah is there an FM system anywhere yeah over there I'll turn the mic on we're just looking for an FM system so I'm picking out better hey Kate maybe bring the microphone really close so you don't have to strain your voice yeah I know I think that can that is that helping at all okay all right um so I think the I appreciate the cover page that mol is put together cuz I feel like it is that sort of highlevel area

013in which you would see either um an increase or a decrease that would be um that has some importance she also organizes it by function code which I think is also really helpful um because it sort of categorizes the the items within the budget that are similar um and are attributed to the same function for auditing purposes and for building a budget within the state um I think you'll notice that and I think secondly if you turn to the second page there's a pie chart um that sort of uh I would say um um takes what you're seeing on the front page and really tries to show you the things that the school board has control over that are not already contractual um so sort of the things where they can make um decisions that

014would impact your budget in a way that isn't already contracted like oil gas prices electricity um teachers contracts things like that are contractual and they're really not um flexible or they are a little bit but not really um and then we try to work within the I think it's about 6% of things that we can actually sort of finagle um as a as a board and as a as a staff thank you so much um K anything else you wanted to add you're okay I concur all right thanks so much Molly anything you wanted to add um Kate did a good job explaining it um so all of the salaries are in here we have two collective bargaining agreements here at shadam we have a par Union and a teacher Union so this is not

015a negotiation year for either one which means they have an active CBA or collective bargaining agreement so everybody has been stepped in track per the CBA um anybody that's in a non-union position was put in at a 3% raise um and Kate did a good job with the pie chart seeing what kind of our fix versus variable cost in the budget and at the bottom we did briefly talk about about potential um removing of Furnitures and fixtures I did not embed that in the actual line by line that's why I put it in the bottom because it was a discussion point but I don't think it was actually requested to move I believe it was just a discussion point so that's why I put it in the bottom box there for you but otherwise we

016worked closely with the building Administration I start looking at the budget in August um looking at how staffing has changed from the prior year and then start meeting with principal Lucas and then eventually meet and and also the specialed team um and then we eventually open Dr andruski and have several several rounds of review so this budget has gone through numerous rounds and then we have a first blush with the board in November and take any feedback and come back in the December meeting typically which happens next week um and then we are here to gain your input tonight thank you so much um so I'd love to start with the fact is there um some questions and I got I got plenty so okay y I'd love wide range of voices but can we

017start with uh what we're anticipating as and I've got a sheet because I I was in contact with um Chris um and he sent me a a numbers about what we're what we're anticipating as the uh number of enrollments by by grade so I also want to make sure this is we're all on the same page about what the enrollments are going to be pass us around so Pat I what I did I did little cut and pasting on the uh oh I did a little I again one again one yeah it's not it's not really a microphone for application it's just for the online people right so I mean as you can see when when you get this I mean the the enrollments have declined from two the school year 9 and 10 that

018were up there were like 6 37 and I guess po Chris uh this current year that we're in we're at 498 now I work backwards uh Chris you didn't give me you didn't give me the kindergarten so I worked backwards to get to the 75 and you email to me um so um we had I had all the others uh so uh what I needed verification is that is that true is it 75 currently in kindergarten or not uh but cuz you gave me a total number of 498 right um and then and then he basically said take that number and you you said that we should shoot for 503 for the the budget year that we're working on and uh move everybody up one one grade and that's that's basically what I did um

019obviously pre I didn't know but I worked backwards from the 503 and it worked out to be 20 just like this year's so I just want to make sure that we're all on this on the same page with that and when you in the bottom then I I penciled in what that meant pupils per class assuming the same five five55 five uh for each of the grades except for two two preschools so you can see the the pup to pups to class ratios currently the first line there on the bottom um and then um that's for 2425 this year and then for 25 26 the budget we're talking about so they're R they R in the 16 to 17 per or one one would be 15 15 to1 ratio so um but I just want

020to make sure that we all agreement that's what we're we're looking at so there was a in the email that you had you had mentioned that you were missing a grade so I gave you the correct for this year and then I just use that for next year using estimates so I actually have the actual versus your your close but you had first in kindergarten inaccurate so like kindergarten right now is 81 um right and first grade is 75 so when you projected you had it inaccurately because the email wasn't accurate Pat so I have an actuals I can hand out to you guys it would be okay correct version of it good that's why I asked did you remember me I I didn't I missed that email if you email me that no I

021just gave it to you right now it's okay good good good all right so that so this this will be the number we're working from right okay uh the other thing um I'll start with and I'll speak um I'd actually went through this with a fine tooth cal um budget and I trying to make sure the numbers added up um when you when you go to page two um when you look at student body activities okay I guess it's it's a matter of um there's only only two uh two with that code 1210 am I looking at that correctly uh ped um 1410 so anything in a 1200 section is going to be special education not student oh you're talking about 14 y oh yeah specially I'm looking backwards right in the page it's uh

022right it's um got find it P if you're looking for student body activities it's on the bottom of page two it's the very last line go back keep going there's co-curricular salaries and student body activities it wasn't the right spot page two yeah so you're on page four so if you keep going um keep going one more and then down at the bottom is this what youing activities no there was one with social workers that um yeah right it's on the uh top of page oh page three top of Page Three okay so um so page three the the the second two lines are are um guidance right but when you add those numbers together it looks like um we added H do you want to let me I'll work on this I'll work on

023this we come back to you yeah yeah I have one other one though okay um let me see if I get this one right um when it comes to Computer Services and uh School District Operations um which is um it has to do with the uh District district office salaries correct is should be in should be in School District Operations but I doing the math it sounds it looks like it wound up in Computer Service computer software computer services how you may want to check it it looks like that number was picked up incorrectly the 5200 bucks if you do the math you'll see it's you mean on the summary sheet on the summary sheet okay I can double check it y all right um I had a question for you Pat um when you

024you have a son right who came through stratum yeah and a daughter do and a daughter do you know what their class sizes were when they came through the school when they were here the census here was 700 the school itself was 700 was 700 students had sixth grade here as well okay uh so you know it's funny I was going to I was actually going to call them and ask them today remember how large the classes were but yeah so how large the classroom sizes were that's what I'm getting at yeah I yeah I don't I don't I don't know have sixth grade here now so the numbers are probably going to be a little different it's only through no but the same building though um so so the assumption is that we had

025more more students per class than with 700 students plus including sixth grade I mean how do we fit a whole sixth grade in here and that included years where there was preschool as well uh which takes up some space so um but I wasn't even going to go there with that discussion but my my assumption is that the class sizes were bigger um and then if you if you um so do you think that's a good thing or a bad I'm no well this The Sweet Spot you know the question question becomes where the The Sweet Spot is in terms of of school class size um and and you know we're at 15 16 17 right now um ST which is the St aage which yeah so I I I would suggest maybe you kind

026of look at um the average classroom size around New Hampshire and that's probably how the teachers make the class assignments um I think tonight I'm just going to interrupt just let's focus on really budget questions we have about the budget um you know obviously there are policy issues and things like that um which are maybe more board issues but I would love to to hear some other questions you guys have about the board about the budget so can someone explain how the uh uh teacher salaries work I understand you know there's contractual increases every year um but they're also steps I used to call them steps in the old age y it's still is so so contract only does it basically moves moves the it moves the range up correct y right so and then

027and how many steps are there 13 13 13 steps yeah and then there's additional like a stien for additional um certification like ational national board certified teacher would get a stien we don't have a CAG stien but um longevity is also included in there but you can get up to like a master's plus 30 at Step 13 so you be Step 13 Bachelor or you could be Step 13 Masters plus 30 or anywhere in between so Step 13 is different depending on your education right and all the collective bargaining Agreements are published on the SAU website and at the end of every CBA there is salary schedules that show all of that information well I ask Molly for the salaries of everybody um and the way they're the way they're listed is they're they're listed

028as as the it looks like the base salary and then something called Longevity yep so is longevity the steps no longevity is been after 10 years of being here so the so after a certain time period of um being an employee here you can earn what's called Longevity so it's in the collective bargain agreement as to what the longevity stepen is so teachers or um staff that have been here for an is it 12 12 years earn was called Longevity on top of the base salary right and so that report that I provided you is by account code so it's you'll see the account code first and then everybody's name and the salary and possibly Longevity if they have it underneath each account code that's how that report's organized so what you gave is is

029the salary projected for them for next year correct uh which includes the uh the step that they're in so follow as the increase in the range for that year correct correct it would be that anybody that's stepping in tracking per the salary grid okay MH all right and Pat just to be clear so I ran that based off of a 501 account so in your in your pack you're going to see there's a long stram of numbers numbers that begin with 11 that is your general fund 14 I think it is is your food service fund um and then the second code is a four-digit code and that's your function so that would designate regular Ed special ed Transportation facilities maintenance and then after that is a five-digit code that always starts with a 5

030Z 5 signifies expense and where you see 501 that signifies salary so a 502 3 4 5 that is a non-salary item so the report I ran you Pat was based off of everything that was a designated 501 account meaning a salary account line right thank you uh Molly is there a key what you just described is there a a key that tells us or reminds us oh this is what this means well there's a state handbook um but I could also do a download out of the system yeah I mean I the numbers don't the numbers don't mean anything to me I'd just like to have a little cheat cheet that says what you just said that's all if that's possible I don't have it readily available but I could no no not not

031now yeah that's all yeah that' be helpful thank you so Molly when you do the when you do this uh when you added up all the let's just regular teacher regular teacher salaries for instance uh you took all the the base plus the increases and then the longevity is in that number as well correct they're all in that number so everything on your report so that would be the longevity projected for next year was on the report that you have but but when I look at the when I look at the page one first first line item it says regular instructor teachers salaries and I see budgeted uh 3,798 th000 in change that's all inclusive of everything longevity and everything in there okay that is everything on that line item yeah thank you all right

032what are the questions yeah I have a question about the I don't know if people can hear me but um Miss attempt to talk into the microphone here I know last year um there was a line item for a police detail and I think that's on page five under contracted services and last year in an effort to remove some things from the budget you guys really went through and just like slashed slashed a bunch of things from the budget and one of the things was that you went from a I think um a 4our detail three times a week which would have been 43,000 and you you reduce that to 4H hour detail two times a week and it looks like that's what you're asking for this year as well um I wonder if can

033you speak to maybe what kind of services are being provided for that dollar amount during that police detail I can I can speak to that a little bit um we actually just I met with Chief King I don't know maybe six weeks ago now and just had a followup um the police department had been short on staff they're filling positions currently um and so it had been a bit harder to sort of line that up because we wanted to be really clear about um what we were hoping that person would do when they were here um part of that I think is wanting to ensure um that it's uh that really what we're asking for is them to just be on school grounds not even in the building right now because of the consistency with

034kids and the interface with kids we would want to ensure that that person was trained to do that and right now um the person that they have trained is spending a good deal of the time at CMS and they're waiting for other people to finish some training um so right now it will be and we're just getting it lined up um because they're just feeling that they have the staff um it'll be one time a week for 4-Hour detail randomly throughout like just so that it feels um like someone would not know when someone was going to be here so they would plan that there would always be someone here okay so right now I think what I heard you say one time a week is because of the short the shortage with Staffing but

035next year you're hoping to get two times a week I think it's I would say that we're going to see how it goes with a hope of it making working out more especially as they get more staff okay mam chair I have a global question yeah so if we look at the whole let me just let Mike go just hear oh I didn't I'm sorry sorry y so I I don't I don't necessarily have a line item um speech to make here but I I would just start by just making some observations first first compliments to the staff for the amazing job you did with putting all this information together it's a lot of data and um I appreciate your efforts in doing that and you know like like many of us um we all

036have hard jobs you have a really hard job um there there as I look at this and reflect on your budget I mean 80% of it is people right 80% of it is people oh yes yes right so and then the other 20% is all the other stuff so when you look you know when you look at the environment that we're in being sympathetic to that and that environment I mean my my sort of observation would be that we're above the level that we should we should be at and should be targeting something less than that and and um you're much more abundantly qualified to find those areas than those those of us like me that don't understand your environment um but I would I would look at it from the vantage point that love

037to see $400,000 come out of here um to get to a level that I think is more um you know more sympathetic and with the community and and um provides needs with our our students and you know and I'm not sure what's happened in years past with respect to the relationship between um student enrollment and staff size and how many children are in a class I heard that conversation come up um I'm not the one that's qualified to say whether it's this that or the other thing but it but the student enrollment is going down and and it would it would appear to me that there might be some room in class sizes to rethink how we do the things that we do um and and maybe um maybe discover uh a method to move

038forward that um alleviates some of the cost that's associated with the operation of the school on a day-to-day basis with with 20% uh of the stuff taken up by 80% of the line items on the budget um there's not any one line item outside of people that you can cut enough to to make an impact that um I feel you really all would want to make um in terms of in terms of um the challenge that um lays before our community in terms of the things that they're dealing with so um that's where I would start if um you asked me to come to to the next meeting with the identification of a bunch of line items I can do that um but but um I thought I'd offer some observations to start with let

039me just ask you about that 400,000 is that is that a percentage that you're kind of shooting for that you think's palatable I I think that's yes and so what would the P well I mean I think you I think if you were somewhere in the 2% range is is probably is probably where um where I would be looking at things and and um you know I guess you know for my involvement in the town for my involvement in I I own and operate a business I look at the economic environment the realities that people are confronting in front of them and and the stressors that that creates um just being sympathetic to that and and um trying to look at um ways in which we can balance that for the community and the school

040in in a constructive way um as I said at the outset you you have huge challenges because 80% of your cost is people and you know we all feel very much you know engaged and and connected to our people so so you know that that calls for perhaps a level of more radical change than um is typically felt in operating environments yeah so Molly from what I understand this pie chart all other that is the Disposable so the way I put it together was um contractual can mean a lot of different things to because salary is salary but you also have flexibility on the number of people you employ so what I did is I broke it down into different sections so there's a salary and then there's Health dental disability life insurances F and

041retirement so anybody that um works over a certain threshold has to be in New Hampshire retirement so we have to pay what's called nhrs which is New Hampshire retirement system and then the FICA is just your federal tax uh Transportation um we have a contract with first student um and we also have special education and you legally have to transport children to school you have the sa assessment which is the portion that stratum would pay towards the central office which is decided by The Joint board and that has already been decided for next year um and the maintenance you have to keep the lights on you have to keep the heat on in the building and so this is everything that's in the maintenance section and then food service and I noted it was non-salary

042because the food service salary portion is up in the salary section y you legally have to serve kids a meal for it to count as a school day and so these are items that that have to happen um now the level of salary is is flexible but but you have to pay people per the step and track on the salary schedule and so everything else in the budget is in the all others so your pens and your papers and your um computers your Chromebooks that's in the all other outside of those items that I mentioned y okay I have a question please on uh on page one the very first line I is regular instructor teacher salaries and then the second to last line on that same page is teacher salaries what's the difference [Music]

043um yeah so the 1100 is regular Ed what starts with the 1200 it's usually 1210 yeah is special ed okay thank you so mam chair Molly would you say that um when you add the salaries and the benefits including FICA and um retirement is that around 50% of salary is Fon retirement 50% of salary no no you take all of your insurance he health insurance cental disability life FICA and en and uh retirement add them together is that 50% of Sal it was last time 50% of salaries P I just did the napkin math it's like 48% so very close now that might be different on a graduated basis depending on who we're talking about but if you just take the salary number and you combine the other two it's 48% so your all in

044is like 48% overhead so you know and that's typical for as I I researched this last time that's typical for um public environment I don't know I don't know do you know what what the town towns that off your head so um for benefits over over salaries so it it's probably it's probably close to that yeah okay so um but I I think the I think the um so it's fine to look at salaries but you can't do anything about it now but you provide them benefits too so so it's really people costs and what are the people costs and the people costs are about 8 % of your budget so so that's you know that's undeniable that's that's where your costs are and and you know and then 80% of the line items are

045probably the other 20% understand if you go through all the all the line items on the budget so you know so well here's my here's my only comment on on that I I I think I mentioned it here before years ago I would come to these meetings um and I noticed something that when you when someone leaves and you replace you replace the person you bring in someone not at the lower end of the scale you bring them in somewhere closer to the midpoint see so when I when I look at these salaries I'm not going to see a normal distribution of salaries when if if I compare it to the range I'm sure it's going to be skewed to the higher side so the the only way that we can start tackling and reducing

046these salaries is to start Chang in that that strategy um I remember bringing that up the year that a lot of the a lot of the teachers that taught my kids were retiring and I said you know something those teachers were young pups when when they were they were here they they were out of school okay young eager um energetic um so I don't know it's just an observation there's nothing we can do about it for this budget understand that I mean that's something for the board to consider going forward if we if we if if going because this is not going to get any easier going year to year um and um I I think I think we got to look at that that's one way that's one area when it comes to salaries

047that we might be able to to start getting a more normal curve in terms of the salaries you know with lower lower salary people here High here and then and then they have you have all these step functions right you have all these steps I mean that the teachers you know they're going to they're going to gain every year each she' be keeping happy with the steps um but um unless you come back and say to me well and I I know what the salaries I did go and I did get the salaries of all every school and average salaries from two years ago that's the the latest one I had I have it hand out I'm not even going to bother handing it out but I will if you want me to but the

048stratum for elementary schools this was two years ago was the highest average salary of any of the schools and where did the data come from the data came from the Department of Education now whether people filled out the surveys that they sent properly I don't know was my data um you know was the top one was was as was the co-op that was the top 80 86,000 was the average then uh and then and I have a I have a graph I could show you the graph of of what it is so I I just want to make sure I'm on the same page as you are you saying that the school should not try to hire experienced teachers now I'm I'm in healthcare so I I don't work in a school I don't understand

049it in the same way um but I know in healthcare it's probably similar that you want a good mix of people newer to the profession people kind of in the middle and experienced people so I don't think I would S I don't know if I would suggest that we should not hire people with experience and just new graduates because um that seems a that would seem a little bit hard um hard well it depends on it depends on the grade it depends on the the level of experience you have in place right now you have all experienced people well no we have some we have some new people my my third my son's thirdd grade teacher only has a couple years of experience and she is right next to an experienced a very experienced teacher

050Mr salus and I'm assuming that was done for mentorship to help her as she transitioned um and again this is I'm not talking about the same school district but my sister-in-law is a public school teacher in Washington DC and she is the most experienced teacher and all she has are new gradu in that school and it's it's very difficult for the school the most experienced teacher doesn't mean that they're the best teacher let's let's say that yeah I I hear you I just want to focus on sort of the budget yeah but this is the budget okay I mean and by the way I I didn't make this up I heard this said here over the years that it's great that they're hiring some younger teachers that that's I think that's good it brings new

051blood into the the organization that's that's um so I I'm just I'm saying for the future because there's really not much we can do because teachers have you know they they have they have a Union contract corrective bargaining contract I should say and U and there's nothing we can do until the next next cycle so so it is what it is the salaries are going to be what it is the only thing is if if there's if we're projecting I think three people may leave next year I don't know if they're going to be teachers or not um what's the strategy to hire the new ones there's there's an opportunity to to save some you know budget dollars by carefully you know looking at what we got for a distribution of salaries and experience to

052say maybe we should bring a few more younger ones I'm trying to be creative here I'm not trying to uh you know every organization has new people right out of school okay I'm not saying we shouldn't hire new teachers I'm I'm just trying to make sure I'm on the same page as you right um but as a as a parent um that was one of the reasons why we moved to stratum was because of the reputation having a very guess experienced guess what 43 years ago that's why we moved to stratum too yeah so and when I when I talk to people out there and I talk to a lot of people I went for office so many times that's the reason they moved here too so I understand that um but we'll get into

053another conversation about something else later on but um I'm just saying I now I have the salaries of all the teachers I'll do a little graph for the next meeting to show where we're at and maybe I'll maybe I'll dis proove my own self again I was just reciting what I thought I heard here because I didn't have the data in front of me I didn't have the actual salaries now I do for each teacher and we can say okay what's that distribution of salaries look like compared to the uh compared to the the ranges that we have again there's nothing we can do with it now but it's for discussion for the board for the future uh to see if we want to change a strategy to try to help out in future budgets

054um because right now if if we're if we're replacing somebody with a lot of experience with somebody with a lot of experience we're we're we're going to be marching backwards in terms of trying to it's going to be harder and harder to to balance a budget harder and harder to keep keep tax rates down um that's all I'm trying to say okay all right um Jen I guess the only comment that I would make um we we could individ ually just throw out our opinions here and it would be no different than if we were just sitting in the audience sort of offering up our opinions about the budget um process wise what we've done in the past and just I I don't want to dictate how we do this because there are no really

055rules around how the fact should should be here making um recommendations but I would say I think if we want to come up with a collective recommendation to the board let's do that um or we can just throw out individual recommendations and and if I'm going to do that tonight here I would say I would be concerned about just making an arbitrary cut of say $400,000 without without understanding what that might do to the teacher student ratios um so yeah I I would just like to be careful about I agree approaching that um in a way that might not be in the best interest of of student learning in the classroom yeah I appreciate that comment I think in your past two haven't you guys kind of gone off and separate exactly yeah into a

056separate thing okay which allows us to sort of we don't always agree on everything to come up with sort of a compromised recommendation about how can we maybe reduce this just a little bit okay from what's being proposed questions and then we can kind of get right yeah exactly how does everybody at the fact feel about that if you guys were to excuse yourself what everyone to do okay I'm new here yeah so but let's do this though but I have a little bullets next to some of these line items so I understand we all have to understand why something went up for instance we're on page one um uh Professional Services for curriculum development uh it it used to be zero now it it was 11,000 this year now it's going to 21,000 can

057we have again I just have to understand why yeah that's a great question Pat I think thank you for bringing that up yeah please um there's been a ton of research that supports I'm sure you're familiar with the science of reading like a major uh body of research that's been um having a significant impact on how we teach reading within our schools um and in order to ensure that our teachers are getting access to professional development and new curriculums that support the new research we have to bring in Consultants or we have to um we have trainers that come with programs that we use and that money supports that level of curriculum development within our school as we adopt programs and new testing materials and the state came out with new laws with regarding dyslexia

058and things like that we have to provide Professional Services for our staff in order to keep um up to current trends okay that one that one up 10,000 11,000 um 15 have I'm just trying to find the big item on big ones oh the other thing is I meant to ask earlier um in this whole budget whether it's bre you know regular education special education and all the other sub accounts that have FTE in it people in it are there any new people any new positions added in this budget and any taken out so there's nobody new and nobody's been taken out okay just want to understand that so when we see salaries going up or going down that's that's existing people or Replacements are thereof let me just the time um maybe a followup

059to that are you aware of any retirements that might be coming from teachers good question so the uh in the CBA for the teachers January 15th is the expected date to tell us if they're going to retire okay so unfortunately it's an unknown at this point okay we do know we have a this current year we've had two esps retire one's last day is actually Friday and another is in February but that's the only known retirements at this time and I'm sorry what were those PHS esps professionals sorry those will be replaced for us yeah okay so okay so um before moving forward I'm just gonna we already did 15 minutes of public comment I'm going to start our timer for 15 more minutes of public comment if anybody does anybody have anything yeah so

060uh hi I'm Cameron or I live in Shannon Drive and I have uh two kids attend here and my son um just moved to CMS this year um and I attended quite a few of these board meetings I think you guys met me before I was looking to get appointed to the board and something I keep hearing tonight and I've heard at all the meetings I attend is the primary focus seems to be on this tax issue which I completely understand but I hear a lot of sympathy to the taxpayers and the people in the town and I totally understand that I live in the town I pay taxes in the town I understand but I also moved here from a town that had a failing school system so that town did not attract any

061people I moved out specifically because I didn't want my children attending there so I'm concerned I was trying to look on the The Board website and I don't know what the Mandate of the school board is and I understand there's a responsibility to the taxpayers but I would assume that there's also a mandate there responsibility to the Excellence of Education in our town right and to the point that you know I keep hearing we're going to save money by you know hiring less experienced teachers or whatever so I I work at the nuclear plan right and we have this uh Excellence model right where we just we develop policies for excellence and what we can do to have excellent performance so I think trying to determine the lowest common denomination in a school system which

062is highly ranked and people move here which I mean everyone who lives here knows the price like average house prices in here are 6 78 $900,000 there was a new development buil behind me full of houses $800,000 those people are paying the property taxes to the town they moved here so that their children can attend the school here that's why I moved here so you know I I heard we want to have Creative Solutions and I would rather you're I I don't think Creative Solutions are eliminating teachers or hiring less experienced teachers and I don't think there's a problem with having a balance of new teachers and you know getting people up to speed but I looked through the budget numbers and I saw $85,000 for fuel oil and gas right so we had the

063New Hampshire Department of Environmental Services here earlier this year about the well right and I don't know if any of them are involved maybe we could ask them about Energy Efficiency things right like I know the school is going through the process of evaluating the building right so I'd really like to see Creative Solutions that don't involve reducing the staff and also the teachers are subject to inflation so I keep hearing like yeah the TA like my taxes went up a significant amount the people that work here are some of them are people that live in our town and they have the same concerns so I think we need to have a little bit of B balance on the side of yes the taxpayers need to have some savings but the people here are also

064taxpayers and they're also the teachers of our children right um so yeah I you know I heard that the hackles kind of come up on this $400,000 off the top that's alarming because you know I I think there's appreciate what you're saying probably minute or so yes yes okay no problem but so I also looked at the police detail because I had that question last year and I guess I don't know you know I know this isn't a question and answer but this is more like maybe a follow-up if the town pays for the police department why does the school district which is taxed separately also have to pay for the police detail I don't understand that because to me if we're looking at Cuts I would much rather eliminate things like that than teacher

065salaries or hiring less expensive teachers what so I I'll wrap it up but I just want to say that I think the tax savings folks so far are over represented at these meetings because it's difficult for parents to attend and I know you guys several of you I know are parents actually I think most except for well I don't know I I I've seen you guys around um but I think that we need to take into account that you know the savings that we're looking for we need to be creative in a way that doesn't impact the school so I'll I'll be done thank you Jen Jen could I make a comment because he's on the nuclear he's he works in nuclear sure because of of what you do um and I'm on the uh

066building uh subcommittee I chair the subcomittee um the new boilers are more energy efficient that we're looking at we're going to gas versus Oil we're looking at a new roof to double the insulation the lights will all be led from incandescent um the there'll be insulation installed in the sofits there are a number of things that we're doing in the renovation of the school to improve Energy Efficiency and you're that's your line of work so and I appreciate that I just think we should also have the folks understand the projected savings on that when we're talking about right I know this back forth but I do appreciate you yeah I think also I just want to address two of the things you said too you know the role of the board that's actually a great

067question really what our position is is approving a budget and so um we really were not in the minutia of the school you know how they um who they hire and you know the actual running of the school that is we defer to Kate um and she does an excellent job in that and so we are really just budget and then um she works within that budget so that's a great question and then I think just to answer your question about the police detail the police do come here you know you probably seen them in the parking lot and all of that these are kind of extra details that that some of the parents had indicated they were looking for so it's really extra where sometimes we pull maybe we might pull a police officer

068from another town it's something that they're doing extra okay thank you yeah so I have two questions on the budget that'd be great um great yeah um Molly on page two uh I think I know what the answer to this is but I'm not sure it says tuition uh private in Hampshire what is that please so okay I don't know if you want to explain it's out it's students that go out of District I I thought I thought that's what it was okay and then the other thing is does does um aside from the steps uh because of longevity and and uh I think there are steps if uh uh a a teacher ACH achieves a a higher education level themselves right yeah those are those are tracks that yeah tracks okay aside from that

069does the collective bargaining give um the the teachers an annual increase for inflation or there's a cola sorry there's a there's a cola cost of living yep so um if you look at the collective bargaining agreement that are all published online you'll see there's a different salary grid for every year so if it's a three-year contract you're going to see three salary grids and each one is adjusted for the cost of living or Cola okay that is agreed upon theost of when when's the next Collective bar yeah well and I and it when I say the cola it's the cola agreed upon at negoti is not the cola that's like published it's it's one percentage for everybody oh I'd have to check but 1.5% I think Dr andisi said it's 1.5 and when I say

070Cola I mean that Cola agreed upon in negotiations not the cola published by the Department of Labor when's the next collective bargaining bargain we'll start bargaining next year this current contract for the teachers ends in 2026 ends like the 1st to 26 2025 2026 so it will run through June 30th 2026 and then we'll have another contract negotiated for the start of the July 1 when does when does that negotiation next year I no I'm sorry I next what when when next it all determines when we start working with the Union sometimes we start as early as August we might try because of the number we have about 13 different contracts that we we deal with throughout all of the SAU so miss Murray our director of human resources does all of those negotiations but

071it's mid year it's not January it's not it could be as as early as next this spring coming up so we're going we'll meet with the Union start to talk with them we'll set up a timeline but typically it would be uh August is the beginning and then September October so that we can get it ready for your budget so you know the the tax impact because it has to go as a warrant that helps a lot thank you welcome all right so before we let you guys go anything else you would want to oh there plenty of stuff to talk about I mean um okay so that so the T so the uh tuition private is the the uh special needs uh I guess we special it's special education special education y I guess

072Pat it does seem like these are amplifying can you just bring it a little closer yeah yeah so so does that tied to the when you go to Transportation do that also tied to the increase in the uh significant increase in the transportation of SE Transportation yes the 150,000 yeah yes so how come it goes up that much can someone explain that to me depending on a student goes right try to well help me out help me out where where how far can they do they how far away can they go um it can be 20 minutes away it can be an hour away it depends there are very few add of District placements that have openings right now and so the the distance or the radius that we sometimes have to travel from here

073is significant to find a place for a student to receive the services that they're entitled to right right okay so you you you have your projection of how many special currently based on actuals based on actuals okay um okay let me go back to the uh page the first page um we were talking about retirements on U provision for for retirement SI sickels M um last year we budgeted 64,000 this year we're budgeting 110,000 I could have sworn last year we said we had three people retiring too we had a $64,000 budget and I know you don't know how many people are retiring or either retiring or just leaving um I mean how do we get to the 110 Pat we always look at who is nearing retirement and who has talked about it but

074we never have any guarantees and that's not just for teachers that's retirement for a variety of different positions and so it's not and and the amount each person get varies by their position by how long they've been here and so it's really hard for us it to say it is a best estimate from what we know but is not a guarantee for obvious reasons right so is this just for the teachers this line no that's everybody right yes yeah okay that's what I thought okay um so the reason I'm going to ask a few more questions is that if we're gonna if we're going to get together and and discuss this we're gonna have a million questions as we look at it maybe it's better that we me I have some right now I just

075want to try to find the big ones um one can I yeah please one of the things that we have done in the past is the fact has had a series of questions and they've given them to Heidi and then Heidi has communicated to me and then I respond and get you the information because sometimes you leave and you're like oh I wish I had asked or something like that it does provide a nice line of communication so that all of you get the same information in the same way we have done that in the past I don't know if the board would want to do something like that but that is a a practice we've done in my time here yeah right I kind of thought we were gonna do that tonight but I

076guess probably better that we get together and and you can do both yeah you can do both I wasn't trying to limit tonight I was just offering that as a possible Next Step um can um by the way can um I'm jumping around here now on the front we had the $55,000 reduction of of furniture and fixtures um ma Marly can you maybe offline tell us which line items you got that from so that that was a variety line items and it was actually um identified by a board member who's not here yes at the last meeting um and so I would have to go back through yeah please not now the line items yep okay I'll I'll do that um oh oh you're going to do it now no there's a variety of line

077items um P we would we could that could be a question and we could identify for you yeah can't do now that's a great suggestion that Kate made is if there's questions it would be a lot easier for us to get all the questions be able to provide you uh ample time to get those answers back so that the whole fact has the same questions and gets the same information cuz did email us on Monday afternoon to get some questions for's meeting which was very helpful um so I would make that that recommendation that we can provide it to you in one document so you see all the questions to help make your your recommendations okay thank you I guess the other big number is the uh health insurance and I know everybody's hit with

078this um but again to me it's a longer term issue and I know I know during contract negotiation this comes up uh in terms of you know at some point you know you know you get you got to look at the plan and all that but right now this is the wrong time to ask that question I understand that uh but it just went up 10% again um and you know it'd be interesting to see what kind of plans we're talking about that they have um but uh I'll just leave it at that but that that's a big that's a big number again one of those can't touch and just so you know about the health insurance so we use Health Trust and it's a it's a pooled program and so every year we used

079to get what was called the gmr guaranteed maximum rate this year they did away with that now they give us the rate and so it did vary per plan so if you look back a few years our health insurance increases were actually zero during covid and so what happens is they base their annual increases based off of usage and so what they were finding in the past few years is that postco a lot of people are going to the doctor and when they're going they're going with the stage four cancer because they didn't get to go when Co was active and so we're seeing those higher increases now because people are going to the doctors and people are using the plans and so it's great when people go but at the same time when people

080go and the usage goes up so does the percentage increase the following years so if you look back at the covid days you're going to see the increases I believe it was zero one year and now it's catching up postco so that is part of the reason why you're seeing those increases our but that's also part of your collective bargaining right so it is part of the collective bargaining on the percentage contribution to the health insurance now and and the Plans offered offered correct so it would have to go through the negotiation when we want to change the plans and also the contribution rates towards the plans understood and then health insurance provides us the annual uh cost every year [Music] the other thing we haven't talked about tonight is is revenues and there there

081our revenues um I know Molly I'd asked you sure and I just want to remind everyone as we're talking about budgets and the appropriation of the budgets that's done in the March vote that is only the expense side of the house that you're voting on that night so what happens is we vote on the budget in the spring and then in the fall the revenues are set and so revenues are such things as um Food Service sales and there's three parts it's what parents pay what the state parts and what what state pays and the federal government pays um then we have other sources of revenue like special education Aid which has been steadily decreasing um and also different types of um Aid that we might receive or things when we rent out the building

082we get local revenue from renting out the gym stuff like that any difference between the expenses voted in the spring and the small amount of Revenue that we received and the small amount of Ade adequacy we receive per student that has to be raised in your tax rate so what happens is we vote on the budget in the spring and then the revenues are set in the fall based of our projections and that Delta is what is raised in your November tax rate and so when we're talking about the budget in the March meeting there's that is not part the revenue is not part of that at that point in time yes the revenue will impact eventually how much has to be raised in taxation M but what goes on the warrant is only the

083expense side and so you have to appropriate all expenses that you believe you're going to spend whether you have Revenue to offset it or not so for example special education Aid you get Aid if you have a certain amount of students that qualify for it you still have to spend the money to to to educate and provide the services for the children and then you would get the revenue to offset it um the following year so I just want to make sure everyone understood that so when we start talking about revenue revenue is not an opportunity to decrease the budget it's an opportunity to decrease your tax rate I know that's why I ask it because I know that's why I want everyone to know we we can't think about taxes unless we know the

084both pieces correct correct and U you know for instance we're not here to the tax uh but in my mind that's what people people the question people out there want to know is what's the impact on the tax rate um but you know the I I see one one red flag flying already and I don't know again I I reached out to toale she sent me uh this summary that says because the big the big money we get from the state is the uh um grants um and it looks like it's two 2,296 th54 are you talking about the adequacy yeah you sent me the the summary this says for for stratum uh but last year was We the on in the ms26 there was a line less amount for State education TR tax and

085Grant that was 2,345 Million so the ms26 is just a projection it is not used for any tax rate setting purposes but that eventually turns into this line right no so what happens is on the ms26 that is just mainly for budgetary purposes to publish your budget and what we typically do is take the revenues that were planned from the prior year cuz at that time we don't know how they're going to change so we just usually carry them forward but the purpose of the ms26 is to post your budget so people attending your annual meeting know what the budget is going in there is no that that revenues on the ms26 has zero impact the the revenues are set on the ms24 which I sent you earlier today and so the ms24 are is

086approved by the Department of Revenue and that is what your official tax rate is set on your tax rate is not set on the ms26 so you sent me the uh towns in uh Town splits on cooperatives uh report so is isn't the 2.2 the concern is that it looks like what we're going to get from uh state aid is drops about 49,000 so I believe I also sent you the projected aid for 2020 uh to uh 20 yeah 26 yeah that's why I got y so yeah it's probably decreasing that would be a decrease in all right that's something we gotta I mean I think everybody's got to be aware of that that we yep and that's a and I would highly suggest everyone express that to their state representatives we're very aware of

087that I used to be able to tell myself but I more so um adequacy um so one other question and then I I'll stop um so for 23 24 we had a surplus correct are you talking about unexpended appropriation yes yeah and and I think it was the amount of around because I've been coming to these meetings around 700,000 if I recall but then the board approved spending some of that money on certain things like the new door door handles and things like that if I recall is is there anything how does how does the Surplus handled if there's one at the end of a year so fact so I sent that all to you in an email earlier today but I'll recap it for the board again I got that like an hour before

088I came so sure so what happens is you have your annual budget so in the 23 24 year we had a budget and then you have your actuals on how you spend against it and so the expenditures less than plan was $384,500 then we got revenues more than planned which was $163,400 so your expenditures less than plan and your Revenue more than plan add those together to get your unassigned fund balance which was $547,500 went to the trust funds so on the ms24 which is the official document that sets your tax rate that I sent you earlier today you're going to see the offsetting to the tax rate of 500 7654 and that what happens is to support the current year budget you then have to raise that amount Less in taxation so there's never

089a carryover from year to year you just raise that much less the next year so essentially we have that in the bank so we don't need the additional that's where I'm getting at so you're say it's important to know sure you said we have 500 what was the number again five so it's 57,6 54 however 163 of that was revenue unanticipated revenue you cannot spend unanticipated Revenue you cannot overexp your appropriation unless you have a public hearing to accept the unanticipated revenue and some unanticipated Revenue you cannot have a public hearing to accept an expend so the more important number would be the expenses less than plan which would be your 384,000 which is only 2.6% of the budget which I would say was a very good number yeah but but that that helps doesn't

090it helps it helps reduce the tax rate it does help reduce the tax that's what I'm trying to get at that so that's why ultimately it's important to see what the ins and the outs of the tax rate looks like we lose about let's call it 50,000 from less state aid but we have this 300,000 number out there that will be coming in to offset what we need to raise in taxes that's the way I like to say it so it it did in November already it did in November that was all part of your November tax rate oh it did correct okay so how are we looking for this year in terms of we going to leave we going to end with a surplus if I had a crystal ball I would love that

091um but at this point in time I mean we're still early in the year we still have over half the school year to go um and students need needs change throughout the year now in every school meeting we do encumber for the full year to the best of our ability but every every month students need to change every month we have a different level of substitutes that we need we have we have changing needs within the building yeah every month we look at things like for example right now I have snow plowing incumbered right now I don't know if it's going to snow or not if I knew I would play the Futures Market um and so at this point in time I can't give you a solid figure that's from our November meeting that's

092the number so in the November meeting what we were projecting is 800 uh 183,000 um66 966 as an unassigned fund balance now a small part of it I think is revenue unless I don't have there might not be any Revenue but at this point in time that number would not be a promise right okay I got I do have another question I hate to do this to you guys so we have three funds out there we have the uh um special education fund we have the building repair maintenance fund and the new technology fund and and it looks like the special education fund has 56,000 in it correct so given that given that we basically doubled looks like we're going to double next year what we budgeted for could that some of that be used

093to offset that is that for a true emergency in terms of like four more families moving in with that would I would have I mean I can let the board answer but I would anticipate that as for unexpended or unanticipated expenditures because that would not even cover two students that move into District potentially yeah I'm sorry could you say that again I didn't hear you so trust funds we would like to try for unanticipated expenditures so if you had didn't yeah I just didn't hear the last statement you made that wouldn't even what cover two students so if two students moved in with significant needs that trust fund would not be sufficient because it includes Transportation you should yeah and that would need that would need to cover all the needs of the student right

094okay all right thank you and then it's up to the board to determine how much because this is all part there's the operating budget but then there's monies that we put into these three funds every year if you so choose to if they so choose to so that's board still hasn't decided what they want to do with that correct and that could either be from from balance or raise an appropriate okay but if they do put it in that that's going to impact the tax rate because that that affect his expense correct correct depending on how it's raised correct so if it's if it's if it's from fund balance it still impacts the tax rate because it would go to the trust fund rather than being returned in the tax rate if it's a rais

095in appropriate then it is raised in appropriate in the tax rate okay thank you all right I'm good okay thank you yeah thank you guys so much um so do you Heidi does it make sense for you guys to maybe head into the tend and take 20 minutes or um what makes sense it's a little early in the process I think for us because I think we're still jelling around what questions we might have individually um but if I look at this schedule I would say maybe the the second to last meeting would be when we would meet and then come out with any final recommendations um and I think that's January right mid January and then there would be one final meeting that you guys have okay so we would meet before that I

096would yeah I'm just thinking about timing right if it so Heidi what are you saying he would have to work Heidi quickly do you want to get all four of us together at some point is that what you're saying um well Jennifer was just asking if we wanted to split off now to talk well I don't know if everybody's had a chance to really stud that's that's what I said yeah so um we can certainly meet offline if if the group wanted to do that or just maybe meet before the next meeting if people wanted to come in for that we could also do now we supposed to be here on the 18th next week as well to discuss this I think so that's correct y we will see you on we have you scheduled

097for the 18th and also January 15th would be your last meeting to finalize any recommendations to this board do you want to meet before I'm sorry I missed that yep so the way we had it scheduled out is that and this was off of last year and last year we called one special meeting because of recommendations but uh the schedule we have is today would be the first meeting next Wednesday would be the second meeting that is also a school board meeting so we'll conduct all full School Board business at that meeting but we'll hear other recommendations or questions you may have um next Wednesday and then January 15th is our final uh isation with the fact about the budget so that would be where we would give us final recommendations of what you're asking

098that happened last year and we called the meeting uh directly after that um to go through what you had recommended okay so can I ask a question about so are recommendations or advisory only correct it is correct right right it's the really it's really the board that does the final decision on that is correct okay but I think what you say carries weight and we're definitely interested in hearing it did last year you made recommendations went back what happens on the E January 8th is a public hearing so that's where we'll do a public hearing with the public about any warrants uh our budget and also the bond that we will be putting out there so on that day is a large all all three um areas will be put out so so how do

099you do we want to get together next Wednesday ahead of the meeting so Kathleen just said she couldn't make it to that meeting so maybe we meet um I think um the does have another piece of business do you guys want to just maybe talk separately oh yeah you guys did you all right we're going no all right so at this point um public comment is finished but really thank you guys so much for coming um we'll be talking about it again next Wednesday ceron um at this point does the board have anything else or I think we have a motion we we'll need a motion for non a motion to go into non public letter A under letter a uh do I have a second second thanks Eric can we do roll call hi

100hi I all right everyone we're out of nonpublic um do I have any motions on the floor like to make a motion i' like to make a motion to approve the employee compensation to be paid out no later than the first payroll in July of 2025 mm all right all in favor I I for z z thank you any other motions on the floor I'd like to make a motion to continue the employee compensation review review okay with the with the SAU sorry continue employee compensation with the SAU sounds great any um all in favor I I four Z 0 looks like all approved any other business all right thank you so much you have a motion to adjourn I will make a motion to adjourn thanks

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.