001[Music] all [Music] e e [Music] go e I [Music] you okay [Music] call the meeting to order please rise to salute the flag this meeting is in compliance with the open public meeting law and has duly has been duly advertised in the newspaper as an official meeting roll call M gordel present Mr McCarron pres Mrs barokas pres Dr Osman present Mrs Rivera present Mrs Cass present Mr P not Mr P here actually he is present but I'm here Mr Walsh yep I need a motion for approval of the agenda motion second discussion roll call Mrs Gardella yes Mr McCarron yes Mrs barokas yes Dr Osman yes Mrs Rivera yes Mrs Cass yes Mr Walsh yes I turn the meeting over to Mrs pilly for her superintendent report thank you very much um for those of
002you who um may have just noticed on your phones you may have received a phone call or an email we have uh called for a delayed opening tomorrow for the safety of our students and staff it's very uncertain whether it's going to be ice or rain but anytime there's mention of ice during arrival time um we error on the side of caution so uh that if you haven't seen it you should see it soon on your phones or receive the phone call or email soon so thank you for Miss wiwin for pushing that out quickly for us um this evening we are here for the purpose of a public forum for a comment from our public on the srrp our strategic restructuring redistricting plan and since the announcement of the recommendations we have received questions
003comments and suggestions we have read every single communication we have received and they have also been shared with the board we also have updated our Q&A document that was shared with all of you last Friday with the um the full community and our staff and we will continue to update that as we receive questions and comments that people um would like to have answers to or if we can clarify things we will be using that um to place any of our responses there for everybody in between meetings um so I do encourage you all to please take a look at that document if you haven't already uh tonight we do have um a few additional slides that we like to share with the community and the board on just some of the major questions we
004were getting or some common questions we were getting so that we can clarify a few more things uh please also know that some things we won't be able to answer yet until we start to go through the process of bringing people together um and uniting um our staff and our students in committee work um such as like what will the middle school schedule details be or the 56 schedule details be those are the types of things that we won't be able to answer until we really get through the committee work that we will uh begin as soon as there is a a final decision so I've said this before I'm just going to repeat it again we recognize this is a difficult uh there's lots of emotions uh these are big changes that are being
005recommended um lots of empathy for that understand it uh very well-intended people making recommendations and considering those recommendations I just respectfully request tonight that when you speak you try to keep in mind that we are one Community um and we are trying to create a path forward together to unite everybody and to create wonderful opportunities for our students we can disagree of course um but let's just do it respectfully please whatever the final decision is I want the community and board to know that this school district will do everything in its power to support all of its students and staff through the transition we'll we will help with that um I'm just going to start a few slides to review so the board may want to turn around and Mr binsky and I are going
006to share some some information so again tonight the purpose of this meeting is to have a public forum and allow the public to uh speak to the board we will allow that shortly after this presentation um it was always announced that this meeting would be a public forum and that the board may vote or may not vote um and that they may push that vote to the next scheduled board meeting which is February 19th and so that is what is happening here there will be no vote this evening um but rather input that is considered and the board will consider that input and any other existing data that they request um so tonight we're just going to share a few things as reminders and then also a a few things to clarify a couple of
007things that came through from the community to us as a reminder the reason we're doing this is so that we can continue to have our strong program strong academic programs our curriculum we have that we have an updated curriculum lots of electives for our students and a variety of different ways and that we have strong um extracurricular programs and a plethora of them and that we have opportunities for supports and enrichment and if we don't do this now those opportunities will have to be gone we have reached that point where we can no longer not affect our students with this budget so doing this will help us be more F fiscally sustainable and allow us to have opportunities for our students as a reminder these were many of the factors through the process that were
008considered um and at any one time depending on the lens you're looking through on these items one thing May weigh more than the other there's a lot of factors and a lot of weighing back and forth of at what point what weighs more what doesn't to make a decision and it also depends on what lens you're looking through obviously the school district is um looking through an educational lens as a reminder these were the many models that the committee reviewed you'll see the blue arrows indicating One models that the committee themselves created and reviewed uh the other ones were presented first to them uh I just want to point out the 4B is listed as 4B because it was uh the committee made a recommendation for that one the first original four um consisted of
009two high schools not one and that is obviously the recommendation moving forward as a reminder this is the recommendation that was shared at the last meeting excuse me and I'm sure everyone's aware of it and this is the recommendation for the grade spans and the use of facilities as a reminder all of these slides are always posted on our district website following the meetings we also share the transportation model and the tiers that we're expecting to implement through this recommendation and with with all of the grade level models that I just showed you and shared in the past uh there's lots of factors well in transportation there's lots of factors as well and the committee the srrp committee was well aware of all those many factors they spent a lot of time discussing them with
010our director of Transportation this is a large operation Transportation runs here in Jackson um not only is it 100 square miles but it's a lot of transportation and it's very important that we don't overburden one tier because then it back back up into other tiers um and in fact some of you may have even seen that happen uh most recently where your children are arriving home later are being picked up later because we have a significant amount of drivers out right now we have a lot of illness going around the schools um I'm sure you have experienced that as well and what that does is if we don't have enough drivers then it obviously allows for uh or we end up with backups um and so these tiers being recommended we've tried every which way
011it's you know it's a big big chess puzzle trying to figure out what is the best way to not overburden tears so that we have enough uh buses and drivers in the event that we um we need to go from tier to tier uh so this recommendation does not overburden any tier and also provides the availability of after school sports activity buses that we have struggled with for years hence a big portion of of why we're making the recommendations we are for the tiers of Transportation so I hope that clar I a little bit we got some questions about that over the last few weeks so we also received um several suggestions or recommendations to look at a 712 model meaning that uh some recommendations that people had had suggested from our community after we
012presented was to have two 712 models right so Memorial would have 7 through 12 Liberty would have 7 through 12 um and so our committee did review those recommendations and it was eliminated for uh several reasons these are some of the reasons listed here on the slide so it was discussed extensively but it's important to know and I and it and it's sometimes um when you don't have all of the information I can see why this makes sense to people so overall we're trying to lower our operational costs in a permanent basis so that our budget is a low lower amount from year to year and when you're operating two of everything you have a greater expense by combining you do not have two of everything and you actually provide more opportunity for students to
013have the resources available because those resources are now in one building versus being split among several buildings that goes for everything not just co-curriculars it also goes for academic programs and interventions and enrichments so having two of Everything Is Not best for students right now and also not best for our budget so that was one of the reasons that this this model was taken off the plate the committee was also concerned about the developmental ages from 7 through 12 um many of the 7 through 12 models you see in different school districts are in with smaller amounts of students uh this would be a very massive amount of students and then once again you've heard me talk multiple times over the past year about the redrawing of sending areas we would need to absolutely change
014the sending areas in this model for our elementary schools feeding into these schools because again it we do not have Equitable sizes in our schools and when you don't have Equitable class sizes of students you lose programs for some students um a simple way to describe that is for example you may not be able to run a business Academy you may not be able to run um a certain uh elective for a middle school student anymore because there's not the same number of students in that facility to require it to run to be able to have it run and be fiscally responsible or to have just enough students in that class and so when you have inbalance of numbers in your schools you want to make them balanced in order to have Equitable programming so
015that was another reason why we'd have to redraw lines and we heard from our community that our community wants friends to stay together this holds true for the other suggestion that we were seeing um come in again the committee did review a 58 model in the way that we reviewed it it was for two high schools but we did speak um deeply about a 58 model some of the suggestions coming in from the community was again to do two 58s um and or to combine so when you combine a 58 you're looking at 2,000 students and that is some of our most vulnerable age group um so really not a good idea to have 2,000 students stents at some of the most vulnerable ages that we see threat assessments and bullying and those types of
016things happening um let alone the academic pieces of that and developmentally uh there is such a huge range and I'm sure um with your own children and some of the teachers you see that difference between a fifth grader and an eighth grader the committee was concerned again about um developmental ages of those students all being in the same cohort together especially on buses and again we go back back to if we do two of those schools um what that means same thing that I just said about the 7 through 12 in regards to not lowering operational costs and not being able to provide Equitable programming and services for our students so in the context of the risting recommendation that was made there are two major Financial considerations with regard to the restructuring plan um the
017first the plan provides with with an opportunity to lower our overall operating costs which can help us to establish a new lower Baseline for spending that will carry on for future years and second the potential sale or rental of one of the schools will provide the district with a revenue source that will allow us for not only to close a budget for 25 26 but it will also allow us to offset facilities and maintenance costs for future years as well uh I think we all in agreement that potentially renting a school facility uh would would with some predictable consistent uh income in the future would be ideal uh however there are several factors such as whether whether or not a rental would be enough to close the the deficit uh and also what future costs
018and risk that would be for the school district moving forward whether the decision is to sell or rent I could assure you that the the school district would absolutely seek to maximize the financial return to the school district uh just like we did with the Rosen hour property uh this would include getting an independent evaluation of the sale rental of the property and ensuring that we acquired all necessary County and state approvals before we we took any further action with regard specifically to the permanent operational savings that could potentially uh come out of the restructuring um we're looking at right now um about $8.1 million that would provide permanent reduction to the budget these savings are projected to come from $5.7 million in Personnel salary and close to 2 million in savings from health benefits
019associated with uh the position eliminations it will also include a very concern conservative estimate of operational savings related to the decommissioning of uh of a building and and these savings would include energy and maintenance costs and for the closing of the get School uh that those costs would be estimated to be about $430,000 per year um and for the midall of school it would be $280,000 per year unfortunately our school district is no stranger to making difficult Staffing Cuts uh and throughout the S2 era uh we've actually been forced to eliminate 285 different positions during those seven years um during that time period though 95% of those position eliminations were done through attrition and what that means is that when a staff member either retires or resigns uh that staff member was not replaced and
020so just last spring the district eliminated uh 70 total positions in order to to reach a balanced budget uh and all of the certified staff all of the certified staff eliminations last spring happened through attrition so while no one really wants to reduce staff uh the fact is that our Personnel related costs make up about 80% of our budget and so when it comes to closing deficits there really is no way of of doing it without impacting staff in some way I can tell you that our district will do just as we have done in the past seven years and identify the position eliminations that will enable us to protect our programs to the greatest extent possible and to provide a thorough and efficient education for all of our students uh we've been asked quite
021frequently to why do we have to do this now why can't we phase this in uh over some a couple of years and the truth is uh we don't have the luxury of time our hand has been forced by the financial situation that the state has placed Us in uh while this is not a presentation of our budget for next year we already have some very strong estimates and projections for what we believe our budget will look like I want to emphasize that these are estimates and there are still some very important relative unknowns at this point specifically state aid uh given what we know we are looking at a$ 13.8 million deficit for next year I want to emphasize that this is without redistricting uh is as there is in any budget there are
022positive impacts to the budget and negative impacts to the budget and when you look at this uh upcoming budget there are quite a few negative impacts first of all we are expecting an 85% reduction in categorical state aid for Equalization Aid which is about a 2.5 million dollar reduction from last year um we'll also we all we will not be budgeting for any sale or rental of property and this budget we budgeted for a $7 million Revenue with the sale of the r rosar property our contractual salary increases are rolling over for an additional 2.5 million and our ad of District special education tuition Aid and L employee benefits and utilities are all going to cost the district Millions more in 2526 and you can see the projections uh up on the screen uh for
023a grand total of 17.6 million do in additional budgetary costs in in relation to 2425 on the positive side uh there we will be able to increase the tax levy by 2% which is the maximum allowed by law uh which will be just over a $2 million increase and unlike this past year we anticipate being able to roll uh an additional $750,000 into Surplus into next year's budget uh to help uh to help uh add to next year's budget to reduce the impact of the increased expenses and also to utilize at least 1 million from expected capital and maintenance reserves during the next school year to help offset needs did facilities work so all considered this is where the $13.8 million deficit stands right now and as I said before we're going through the budget
024process uh and the budget first budget presentation will be in March so if we don't restructure what does this look like and you know I think that this community um at this point is sick and tired of hearing this and seeing this I know we are and unfortunately Ely um as I said before we were replaced into this position and so the prospect of not restrict reding restructuring and going after the $1 13.8 million deficit the way we've tried to do it in the past would mean some very very significant Staffing Cuts we're talking about more than a total of 200 positions including administrative certified non-certified staff most of which the majority of which would not be able to go uh be done through attrition uh eliminating some of the programs that have stood out
025in this school district for years including the Athletics theem RC um reducing advanced placement courses you know this is these are the things that that make a school district a school district and these are the things that unfortunately will undoubtedly be impacted if we have to move to a$ 13.8 million deficit closing without doing any redistricting or restructuring um so I can't help but end with this and when I say that um the board um has a difficult decision to make obviously but when you consider the alternative and this alternative path um I think that this is a decision that that absolutely has to be made thank you Mr vinski so following up on earlier what I said about our Q&A document uh I just wanted to pull out a few items just to highlight
026tonight but please go in there there's a many more uh responses to questions there but these were some that um I felt were important to say out loud so did the district consider traffic at different times of the day in their consideration of the recommendations of the facilities and so yes we did consider um and study traffic at all hours of the day remember we frequently travel to our schools um at all times of the day um to ensure that we had full understanding and I know many of the board members have done the same particular attention was paid to the times that the students would arrive and dismissed for all different different reasons um and that is one of the reasons why the recommendation for Liberty was for a tier one use because at
027that time there is less congestion um around Liberty during the times of high school um times so it is um obviously not ignored and it is important um but the the piece that we are we planning for is to re enforce lessons on Defensive Driving expand upon our orientations for our drivers for our new students and uh continue to work with our police department and the county office on flow of traffic to an from the campus regarding comments about uh the traffic um officer that spoke um about Memorial being a better option due to traffic why did we make our recommendation before getting a full traffic data again as I said um we we're aware that there's more traffic in certain areas um and that information that they have provided for us is also helpful
028data and information and we appreciate the time that was taken to do that um it adds to other data that we have reviewed um but again we have we are aware of that traffic and we were planning for that based on all factors that are being considered and as I said before looking through different lenses um we made a recommendation based on what we felt was educationally a sound decision for our students um and we will continue to to make those kinds of recommendations what's in the best interest of our students but safety is obviously very important as well well the total Bus Time bus time has been coming up a lot um I did say this at the last meeting but wanted to point out that we have software that um helps to push
029out the routes but it doesn't stop there after the software pushes out those routes we have the availability to then put the human touch to that and work to create um routes that are 50 minutes or less obviously we strive for Less and we will continue to do that through this process what is the long range projection for the school usages again um if you look back onto the slide 22 in the presentation it goes over our projections for enrollment that we used and obviously none of us have a crystal ball but it shows the enrollment numbers warranting uh this configuration um all the way through 5 years Poss you know obviously longer now are there again with no Crystal able there's some things that may happen that decrease enrollment or increase enrollment yes of
030course um and this model does support either or now the projection moving forward should there be a massive drop in enrollment and maybe that's five years seven years from now maybe it's it's longer than that the model that was recommend uh recommended allows for fifth grade then to return to Elementary sixth grade to go to uh the Middle School model again and then to um if need be um close another facility if enrollment dropped that much so if you're looking way down the road um whomever is here at that point might be able to make those recommendations so it does allow for that in the future as well with uh not a tremendous um change to to the district but a smaller impact than what we are currently suggesting for next year so again I
031do encourage you to go in and look at more of those Q&A um so finally to conclude uh just a few of those updates um for the board and the community as we've said many times over and over again we know this is hard and difficult and as Mr binsky just so um well said we really do not have a choice to do nothing at this point um and so I'll close with the same way I I started is I think we have very um well-intended people making decisions uh making suggestions questions and then finally making a a final recommendation um and so please know assume best intentions um and we are here to provide responses and answers to your questions and we will continue to do so throughout this entire process so with that
032I am going to turn it back to the board president for board comments okay I guess we'll start you wanted to well we'll start down at that end I guess come this way everybody's this way okay is he song Hello okay sorry didn't know if you can hear me all right so I wrote some things down that I wanted to um share tonight and try to get a conversation going at the de um so you know as a board we recognize the gravity of the decision that we're making none of us are taking it LLY um I want to remind everybody that we all live in the town we have children it it's a big decision we get that um but we're I think I speak for all of us when I say we are
033committed to making the best decision that we can with the information that we have so um just to educate the public a little bit because you know we have more people in these last few meetings than we typically do at board meetings um but a school board operates under procedural um guidelines so there are rules that are in place that we have to follow follow to help ensure transparency and to make sure that we're adhering to um like the open meeting laws right and so this means that discussions among the seven of us who are on the board we don't get to just talk as a group you know out at a diner somewhere we don't get to do that the only time we really get to speak as a group is when we're sitting
034up here in front of a public or if we have executive session but executive s SS there's like rules around what you could discuss privately not in front of the public and so I mean I'll be the first to admit that before I was on the board one of my one of my gripes with boards when I would come to meetings is that they don't always talk very freely up here so you don't you know you kind of hear us vote but you don't hear the discussion right so tonight I think it's important that we have a conversation in front of and I think everybody up here believes it's important in front of the community um so I I'll I guess I'll start it off and I'll tell you some of the things that I've
035been thinking and I'll be very honest with you every day I kind of think of something else and depends on the hour of the day which way I'm I'm leaning um but I'm curious to see what my colleagues think and hopefully it will open some discussion so I do want to start with at the last meeting a parent came up to to the microphone and she kind of demanded to know where we all reside and you know I don't think that matters because I think we're all here for the right reasons and we're trying to be ethical and I I have to give props to the people who are up here I haven't once heard someone on this board say I want to do this because this is good for my kid or this is
036where I went to school that that really hasn't happened right which is great um but I'll be transparent and I live on the west side of the town I have three kids two of my kids graduated from a memorial I have a 22 and a 23 graduate and then I have a graduate this year my last one all right so this decision really does not affect my family personally right where my kids are going to go I am also a graduate of Memorial and I have great memories of Memorial but I don't think that that's enough to sway you one way or the other like we have to look at bigger picture here right this is a bigger issue so as I've been going back and forth in my head um I want to share
037some of the concerns I have so I think we all could acknowledge that there's animosity and division that we've seen throughout various ways right we've seen it in public um we've seen it on social media we're getting a ton of emails we see it in the emails and even at public comment and the fact that we can no longer hold cross town rival games between the high schools is just another example that animosity does exist here right um and we don't we're not doing those games because of Civility issues uh so to me this is deeply troubling but again it highlights that there is actually an issue here and that brings me to my biggest concern which is student safety and merging high schools um to me especially with existing tensions and it you know
038it raises some legitimate safety questions and I'm particularly concerned about the proximity of the proposed High School from the committee to the location of the police station and you know with Memorial it's closer and I do believe that this proximity and please don't get upset with me I'm going back and forth with pros and cons I'm just letting you know what my you know how I'm bouncing back and forth but I do believe that proximity could be a deterrent to issues before they actually happen um and a quick you know you can have a quicker response time and so I'm curious because I know some of the people on the board have been on different committees than I've been on and what is the perspective of law enforcement right these are our professional people what
039do they think um and you know hopefully my colleagues can respond here in one second um but how are we ensuring that the students will feel safe right because you feel sa you know in a classroom you could control a classroom environment as a teacher but then kids have to travel around a building and how do they feel um and before uh anybody responds I want to add to the public that I am aware that we house students in Liberty currently and I'm not saying that they are in danger so I'm hoping that nobody will twist my words but it is a smaller population of people and so you know we're not really comparing Apples to Apples because the popul and the S you know the size is going to change and when you have
040more kids in one area it's a real concern so I have three other things that I want to bring up as well but maybe we could start with that one and just kind of share our thoughts on what we're thinking there um Mr McCarron do you want to start with that one yeah so my my background for people that don't know me is in law enforcement I'm retired police officer um I was also a school resource officer so I Shar in the sentiment of logis ically having a high school in a closer proximity to a police department and centralized in town to me makes a little bit more sense um and that's Through My Lens um I appreciate Mrs permil uh bringing up everybody has a different lens in this uh in this audience we
041all have different backgrounds um mine happens to be in law enforcement currently in real estate so another thing that I also kind of take into consideration is uh logistically where where it's located and um where are different buildings and values of our different buildings and what's going to carry our district moving into the future with sales and balancing our budgets and doing projects that we have to do instead of continuously going out to the public to raise taxes anybody else um want to share I mean I feel like the discussion is going all over the place but I'll piggyback on what Brian's saying I I just I would like to talk about onetime use though you know in order to balance a budget right Jackson's been having to do it all wrong we start off
042the deficit right and we sell land and we're China we're like playing we're playing on credit card debt you know so we're selling land we're patching up a budget we're cutting staff we're patching a budget we're closing rows an hour We're patching a budget if you were to ask and I'll ask stand what is the the standard of accounting in a school what do you do when you come with a one-time use fund like you know you hit the lottery you're selling a piece of land what is the actual thing that we want to be able to do with it so the one thing I would say you don't want to do is to add it to recurring costs so when you're talking about adding um something that's going to be at Cost every year
043and grow after you know year to year that's something that we ran into um with the covid funding with the eser funds because we were at such a budget deficit we needed to use some of those funds to support some of the same programs and Staffing that we we just needed to do it to sustain programs and but that cost you because when that goes away you're left with an even an even bigger hole so I guess for Jackson right like listen many of us in the room maybe we have seniors we have Juniors we're talking about the people that are in Jackson right they got second graders prek right these are the people that are going to be here and they might WI that we're using onetime funds to balance a budget how many
044years are we going to do that do you feel well I mean the what I said before we're looking at reducing permanently reducing operating costs if we could do that to a point where you get that down to where your Revenue where your Revenue levels are then you're at a balanced budget and you live in that balanced budget world I will tell you it's it's extremely difficult to do it when you're an S2 School District when you are in the state in New Jersey where you have a 2% cap that that's the most you can raise your tax levy and everything else becomes more expensive it's it's a deficit model not just for us for the every school district in the state of New Jersey I mean that's we we we arrived at a place
045much sooner than other school districts did but you mathematically cannot continue to operate in that F in that fashion without just being in a deficit you know I attended the Ocean County school board meeting after the fact right because I just couldn't do it on the the night of and char Charles M was there I know that you attended and they had a a ba there right one BA didn't show up I didn't catch what town he was from but the ba was from Point Beach okay I mean this guy made it seem like it was amazing to be a ba of a school district right this is a non S2 funded District I don't know how many um students are in that District but there's a couple things that stood out to me that
046I don't even think we can even understand because we never got to do it but um you know they have um you know I appreciate what you did on the slides where you showed us what our fixed costs are you know because even though you don't know what our state aid is going to be I'm sure that you know from this educational piece they said that budget planning starts year after the budget ends you're starting again you know it's like any business you're going out you know what your increases are in health insurance utilities all that so thank thank you for that but you know he points out in be in Point Beach they're not an S2 District right they get their money they don't have to worry about anything um their Education Foundation that
047PA said that every year he can rely on 50 to 100k from his his community I mean these are things we don't even know we're we're s we're such a big community and there's been niches I'm here my whole entire life there's niches there's a neighborhood here and a neighborhood here and we we have never gotten along okay never there's always been some type of you know you live here and I live there we we've never raised that kind of funds you know that that's Athletics correct MH okay um you know I I'm going to digress I know we're talking about high schools and you know I get it but I just feel like the funding piece is a really big piece of why we're sitting here at this table today no I agree with
048you too but I want to go back to safety for a minute because I didn't really get um a clear enough answer so we got your perspective Brian and that's great um but Ally Megan Bryant you were all on these committees what did you learn from law enforcement share with me what they shared with you sure I'm going to take it over and start for a second and then you could just hit me if you want to jump in either one of you but I know that before Thanksgiving the board PRI board president reached out to um Town Council and traffic safety regarding concerns um for traffic over on the east side of town um at that time we discussed mcalli um the reason we discussed mcauliff we did do some building facility tours and
049I'll be honest I had a like a 15minute Turnin you know and it it just might have been the time and I said oh my God like are these what the parents have to deal with so obviously um we brought it up and we talked about it at that time officer candido right I believe no I'm sorry I'll go back to my actual document um it was they sent out an SRO officer and the captain said that it was a 4minute turn at both arrival and dismissal at that time and there was no traffic concerns that 4minute is not considered traffic traffic now we sat in the meetings there's an SRO right we discussed traffic and there's traffic concerns right we're bringing a large amount of students over obviously we have concerns if you've lived
050in this town long enough there's been a lot of tragic deaths of teens okay it's just what it is there was one high school and there was tragic deaths there's two high schools and there's tragic deaths right we're 100 square miles think about how many towns that is at the beach level I mean CU everybody's moving to the beach you got Mana samp point you could probably go B Mata loan all the way down that's 100 square miles right it's that many municipalities that we're dealing with in one town um from my perspective um the sro's had you know the SRO president in the committee had some concerns or big concerns regarding um Traffic Safety ability for someone to not be in traffic and to get somewhere um go ahead and his uh his kids
051go to Liberty um but with that said because I know you know listening to so many people and so many emails and doing my own research as well right um traffic is not how we make decisions on educating our students right give me a minute here her out here out we have to have this convers ation because we all aren't on all of these committees um but what we do make decisions on is the what the committee did do a great job on because most of the committee 90% of it was Educators I myself am an analytics and that's why you always hear me reciting the numbers so while so many people had so many suggestions and we welcome so many of the suggestions some of them don't necessarily work as Miss Peril and uh
052Dan had put up top right and so going back to the committee they did a great job setting up the grade banding and what made sense for this District moving forward what we did not discuss was the financial aspect that was a conversation that did not come up during the committee and so when people say why did why are you postponing the vote and why are we making decisions because for all of us we felt we need we we needed more information to figure out as we've learned from Dan just explaining right we have to balance a budget right and as a board of ed our job is to not only hire the superintendent but it is also to make sure that we have policies in place and that that budget is balanced and at
053the end of the day listen I have assumed to be senior I don't even know if she's sitting here but while I love her and I and and you know many of her friends that are will be graduating as well next year my concern is also for as Megan pointed out our children that are much younger that are going to be living here for a really long time and what does that look like moving forward and what we have in place right now is that's the St able with no income coming in so those are the things that yes while I mentioned uh Transportation now you understand why there's a lot of things we look at that are important to all of us and that is why it is taking so much time to make
054these decisions it's not that we looked at the committee I was on that committee and I was actually part of the the one of the uh model that was Pro that was picked because at the end of the day we needed to make a decision that was fiscally responsible for this District so that is where why it is taking us time to go back and forth and back and forth and we can look at buildings all day long but like I said last time it's not the buildings that make these kids it's the people in them that make these children it is the it is the families that they that they come from right that's who's making these kids I can speak for my own child she came home the other day and she said
055you Ma I have to show you something she goes I love my English class and I'm sure that teacher's listening now so thank you for all that you do I was so happy right that makes me that tells me she's getting so much out of that class so that's why it's taking us so much time because we have to look at all of these things and it we I haven't slept in months I think most of us haven't slept in months and days and it sits in our head all night long and we think about our our families who are traveling we multitask right where's my M we're all Mom right our moms and dads right we're multitasking and that's what I thought of right sure I I did my rides I like certain schools
056I thought they were nice and then there's times when I CH go back to the other side and go but what is that going to look like for my fames traveling right and yes I'm I'm on the memorial side but for those of you in our uh who write some of the newspapers locally I was not born and raised here I was born and raised in New York I'm from Rockland County New City I'm very near a Township that some of you might have read in the paper called ripo so I'm familiar very familiar with what our townships look like um with that I was in an elementary school that I used to walk to and in the middle of my second grade we they decided to sell my elementary school that I used to
057walk to I then went to an elementary school where we were all split up and then eventually I went to a middle school where there were three Wings one One Wing got to go to one high school One Wing got to go to another high school and I had the luxury of being once again split from my friends into two different high schools and yet here I am so okay I'm going to bring this back to my original question because I still didn't really get it in so I'll answer but I appreciate everything you're saying no you make good points you make good points but I'll answer my original question was not about traffic per se because agree with you I can answer it I was I was getting prepared to answer it for you
058I can answer it okay so I just wanted toe it's not about traffic because I agree with you that our job is not to solve all of the traffic issues um but it's about animosity and I don't believe that just goes away instantly so what did did anyone talk about what is it going to be like when kids are in a school who I'm reading things online who have been like it's it's been nasty so I think your original question was did anybody in the committee um communicate the location of the police department being a factor um so I will say that there was a member of the strategic planning committee who did say that who did bring that point up um as a point of information um and that person was a police officer
059so obviously we value that input um and as you as you said Dr Osman we we currently do have students there and I respect that you acknowledge that um and so we're not you know our students are safe we know that our students are safe I just wanted to um let you know and the community know although I think I I have said this before is that the plan was to have because we were bringing so many high school students together um first of all the plan was to have a committee to talk about of students to have um plan for how do we unite um our students together in a positive fashion through activities events in fact there is something already being planned in the works for that of bringing the the high school
060students together and thank you to the High School principles for that already um and we have had several suggestions already from our wonderful staff on how to do that um these are things that are Educators do well um and then the other piece of that was for safety purpose purposes and the number of students was to have both of our sro's in the high school as well as our um armed security that we currently have um so that was one way that that issue was being addressed so I just wanted to make sure you got your question answered uh it was um brought up at the planning committee so if I'm being honest I keep going back to safety because to me I don't feel that that can happen overnight so quickly that's my concern
061just because I'm I'm reading emails I'm looking online I'm listening to comments and I don't believe it happens overnight and that very much concerns me um so just putting it out there you don't really need to respond if you don't want to but just sharing where my thoughts are but we we do have a great team up here I mean I agree with you and I I do think it starts at home I do think um some of the parents I think are I'll be honest I've read the emails um they're not coming from the students they're coming from the parents so there are certain the conversations that are happening at home that I think I think we need to change the narrative um this isn't this isn't about one High School versus another this
062isn't a rival game this isn't anything like that we're salvaging a district you all see what's happening in our community um it's changing rapidly our costs are going to keep Rising we we've all just said that so we're trying to do the best that we can um in a short amount of time time knowing that we have uh a very unique situation we have a growing or um non-public population so our transportation costs are going to keep increasing so we're going to we're going to constantly have to be plugging a budget um so we are all trying to do the best that we can so I really just feel like everyone needs to change this narrative a little bit um we're not trying to take away anyone's Legacy either one either or doesn't matter if
063you were here for 20 years doesn't matter if you were here for 60 years everyone is valued um listen 20 years is no joke I've been married 22 years listen right uh you know and 60 years is something to be proud of as well but at the end of the day we have to come together as one Community um we all do still feel like we need extra commun um information there are certain things I want to look over I do want you to know as everyone pointed out look I know that there are certain board members up here that have been driving back and forth to the schools because they want to make sure they're making the right decision I know people are pouring over records and they're looking at data and they're looking
064at traffic reports and we have our advocacy group who's fighting against our governor um so just know that no one sitting up here is just sitting Megan and I have gone to we none of us could paid to be up here although some people might think we do and Megan and I in between our jobs have been running to assembly sitting with assemblymen Senators you know really advocating for everyone we even have the um we besides our advocacy committee we were mentioning Point Point Beach right raising money and we have the Jackson Education Foundation again five of us also not paid where we we created the advocacy committee we created the um Education Foundation to raise funds you know so this way we can have money to give for grants for our teachers for scholarships
065for our students I mean we're all working really hard outside of even being on the board of ed just to give all of our all of the kids of Jackson something extra right we're trying to help everyone so we need help you know I love that everyone came out but we need help you know I feel like we talk about how did we get here you know and you hear that a lot like how did we get here you know we got here you know it's not really a surprise that we got here um you know really it's been it's been coming Miss permil has been talking about it for seven years Co kind of masked it right we were all coming talking about Mass and coming to school and then we got some eser
066funds that Mr binsky is talking about it kind of mass those budget deficits right you could use them in certain ways whether it should be onetime use or not then we talk about enrollment yeah enrollment talked um we also got to bring on an onboard a preschool program and again you know we all have different opinions but preschool has helped us in helping with some of our facilities and costs um you could argue for it and against it right but we're we're an S2 District that means every year we're getting cut based on enrollment based on your property values okay that's just a fact we didn't make it up okay that's what the state's saying um you know I think that we're here because of all of those perfectly laid out pieces of information that
067just kind of came together and I think the main thing I go back to every time I think about this is when you do anything thing with onetime use money you can't whatever decision our board comes up with like our real at least my focus is how are you not going what's the length of time to you're going to say oh we have to do this again to to balance our budget and I get it we don't have a crystal ball we're not the state Governor right we're we're all going to be electing one though you know and you can look in and advocate in that regard and I have my own opinions I'll probably share them at some point but you know we got here because we have cuts from state aid and we
068have enrollment drops you know like we have really great property value you know and everybody in our town whether we really are or we're not you know we're looked upon as being able to afford more and here we are yep one thing okay I know I'm late to the party as far as everything's concerned but I lived here my whole life I taught here I was an administrator here okay when I taught here in the a little after 2000 there was over 3,000 kids in this building okay this place was M but with that many kids with that many kids with that many kids in the building the kids will work it out they're resilient With a Little Help from security once in a while and a Little Help from the teachers and the staff
069they're going to work it out we already got our two bands working it out okay they will work it out thank you so I going off of what Megan said and and I agree with you um Mr Walsh I think in time things get worked out my concern is the short term thinking about um what Megan just said I I agree and I think it's important I'm just thinking another way Thinking Out Loud again um but that your long-term plans kind of short ter term for part of it part of it longterm because of what you're saying how are we going to sustain this state makes it really really hard to sustain right we have a state monitor who at any minute can say you have you have to meet I asked this in the
070last in the last meeting is there any way they could force us to sell a building instead of renting a building or this or that and essentially we were told yes because we have to balance the budget that's what we were told so this this is a state that's it it's very hard to get ahead of there's always something that they say you cannot do or they won't give you so you're constantly behind the ball so with that and we the one thing that we've heard over and over and over again from Clear presentations that the admin have been giving us is that we're seeing enrollment drops and they're going to continue to drop and so my question you know I keep coming back to five six seven years we're going to be right back
071where we are are we making the best choice with the is the recommendation the best choice with knowing we're going to be right back where we are and we're probably going to have to redistrict again and I understand that might not be our responsibility the next people might be up here could be a totally you know different population of people sitting at this this de but we I don't want to set students up to disrupt the town all over again when we don't have to do that and so I keep thinking to myself what are the biggest assets as far as schools in this town and it is liberty and it is mlli I would I would bet that they are worth the most of all of our properties and so if I'm thinking more
072longterm term you know are we going to eventually sell those two would it make sense to do that would that help sustain us now wait now wait now wait it's not as it's these are complicated answers because what I've learned I've learned so much from being up here because you know we're all learning like none of us have ever gone through this before this isn't a normal thing to go through even your admin hasn't gone through this before right so we're all learning but we're learning things like you can't sell multiple schools at once when you do sell a school only certain money could go certain places and there's a lot of nuances to it so it's not a very easy question but it is a question I believe we have to think about and
073then think about okay if I totally came up with a new idea and I said make a memorial the high school sell malli use the mcauliff money to fix up another Middle School um use Liberty as the middle school until you could sell Liberty and then when your numbers decrease you bring everyone back together in a middle school keep it centralized in the town you know these are all things that we're going through and as I said every day um you know you're flip-flopping every day but um I just keep thinking about that like these are our biggest assets our I I think everyone up here knows we're going to be right back to this spot like Megan was saying in years to come but I want to just say something you know if anybody's
074been around education a long time you could take a vote how hard is it Mike to come you've been around education a long time how hard in education is it to come across a good building see that like how hard is it to in education right in schools you're dealing with taxpayer money right a lot of approvals voting Etc how hard is it to find a facility and that's state-ofthe-art extremely I would say buildings turn over technology-wise about every 10 years okay so the older you get the less you're going to have as far as technology is concerned when I was a science supervisor for two years in this District I was part of the promethium project where we brought prometheum boards into the classrooms what a great tool that was for teachers teachers are
075great okay don't get me wrong okay but they're better when they have tools all right so the more tools you have the better teacher you will become but you're you can't convince me that if you sell some of your biggest assets that you wouldn't have the money to get the tools we we could rebuild things we could make things better that already exist because some of these properties are probably worth a whole lot of money does anyone else have anything that they want to relay to the public before we allow them to have their turn is there anything press say that anybody wants to share good we're good you look like you want to say something I mean I could say a million things you know I think there's pros and cons to every building
076that we have you know I think in the end it's going to be relying on the people in the buildings and the community to make those great things happen regardless of where it's at um and I think un you know undoubtedly right there's going to be disappointment and joy and that's just that's life and um I could list and probably go on right we could go on and on about pros and cons and we could argue this or we could argue that and you know um again you know you do read a lot of emails listen a lot of people out there you hit us below the belt thank you you know um we appreciate that we're tough we're up here we're volunteering for your kids and the many kids whose kids aren't even in
077the district yet right you know we can't forget that just because our Town's 100 square miles that people don't live everywhere you know just because we've knocked down and had a lot of changes throughout this whole Community you know I feel like it's it's division you know like if I could go back to when and you know Mike you were here right when you when a referendum went out and we built all these elementary schools and we decided to not have a mega High School I mean Dan you might have been here even as some type of person within a district but one thing too you got to remember how many referendums have been voted down okay along the time and Liberty High School was passed by like 12 votes it was really really tight
078when that vote came up so it's not easy to pass a referendum and it's probably harder now than it's ever been yeah just just so you know I know it always goes around that there were at some point 11,000 kids in the state district there were never when Liberty opened and you're all right mik at some point there were 3,000 kids and So eventually they voted to open Liberty Liberty opened with 9,681 kids in 2006 and then the population for the next five years stayed at around 9500 and then it started to go down way before anything changed in this Township so just keep those numbers in the back of your mind because it started to decrease in 2013 2014 2015 16 17 all the way down to where we are now so ask yourselves
079why do the population start to go down is it necessarily was it the schools was it people moving in town or maybe was there no more building going on in your Township maybe there was nothing for people to maybe so many things were were said no to that there was nothing else being built take a look around is it thriving does it look like Marboro is it a hustling bustling Township I love it here I thought I was going to have a Lowe's around the corner for me I thought I was going to have a bar because there was a because there was a Because by the shop right right it said liquor license I thought no way we're going to have right I'll bring back a bans still waiting on the bans people so
080in reality this is where we are and we're trying to do so much for the population that we have for our district and that's why we keep saying while we're in the now our decisions are not for the today they're for the three five seven years away and those are some of you have these younger children we have to make sure our schools are sustainable for those children as well my last thing that I want to say is you know we feel like we're declining like Ally said but we're still the 302 largest School District in the state of New Jersey you know like we're still have a ton of kids here you know and we're still we still have a lot of things to consider so you have to remember when you're looking at
081the scope of your life and what you have in front of you you know we you know there's seven you know I'm not saying that every one of those 7,300 kids has one parent right but there's a decent number of parents that are looking for us to look at all their kids and not just the ones that we could see dayto day or within our community you know within our our daily lives and you know I know that a lot of people don't want to hear that but it it is what we're doing up here and it's not you know it's not easy and I wish that you know it was a little bit easier than it is um and it would be easier I think if everybody supported us the same way Miss Bernett
082is um so thank you okay all right I think every everybody's anybody okay um all right I'm going to need a motion to open it up to public forum motion second disc discussion all in favor I please sign in and state your name and whether or not you are a Jackson resident each person is allowed a maximum of three minutes to speak no person may speak more than once on the topic until all others have been heard and I do um just request everyone to be respectful please of all persons thank you sorry okay um thank you all very very much for your efforts this is one parent who greatly appreciates it um I just have three points um I'm hoping decisions can be made quickly regarding structures because my conversation with the principal way
083back in my day and West AR who was involved with the consolidation of high schools said that animosity that you are very concerned about that gets dealt with when the kids are brought together and start planning it themselves the children have to be involved together making decisions not a top down it's kind of the bottom up model needs to happen with those children point two this has to do with our funding S2 it's my feeling and I don't know if it's correct but the New Jersey teachers union generally has our Governor's ear and I want to know where has the union been in supporting S2 districts this funding model has to change and the union has the numbers to kick to kick it into action we should not be like this we should not have
084long-term worries like this okay it shouldn't just be a few people going to Trenton the union should be supporting our students and then my last point my last point is for the students please keep your futures in sight please do not let animosity or anger or anything screw up your future choices because that will happen if you let that okay we're one town we're one town and no matter what the building is you kids deserve a marvelous future please don't screw it up thank you how you doing Don Lasco Jackson Township resident 44 years Police Department 21 years Traffic Safety 12 hello to the four or five of you that I met already I know I'm on a time limit so I'm going to speed read through this on Tuesday October 9th 2012 1645 hours
085a 17-year-old Memorial student was pulled over for almost running through a red traffic signal the vehicle failed to stop at the stop bar and was into the intersection blocking traffic when it finally came to a complete stop this was observed by a police Lieutenant who then conducted a motor vehicle stop on the vehicle after Lieutenant completed the motor vehicle stop the driver was sent on her way at 176 hours dispatch received a 911 call regarding a motor vehicle crash on South Hope Chapel Road upon officer's arrival the unidentified passenger of the vehicle was dead the driver was severely injured this was the same vehicle that was pulled over 31 minutes prior by the lieutenant driver was transported to jerseyshore Trauma Center where she was pronounced dead at 1938 hours when officers went to the driver's
086address to notify the parents it was learned a deceased passenger was the driver's younger sister they just lost both their daughters officers investigation revealed the driver was running late to a a school sanction event at the Liberty High School she was traving at an unsafe speed and lost control of her vehicle killing herself and her little sister case number for this is incident 2012 0486 public officials should minimize risks whenever possible and tragedy like this should never happen at the request of the Board of Education the traffic safety unit has pulled crash dated conducted traffic studies around both Memorial and Liberty high schools following data leads us to the conclusion that the area surrounding Memorial High School would minimize the driving risk for our high school students and must be taken into professional consideration in
0872024 there are 184 crashes within one mile radius of Liberty High School 10 of those occurring between the hours of 0600 0800 and 29 between 1300 and 1500 within a 1 mile radius of Memorial High School there are only 68 crashes in 2024 13 between the hours of 0600 0800 and 7 between 1300 and 1500 I also have all the traffic study D on here but you made it clear you don't give a about our numbers it is the professional opinion of the Jackson Township police Department's traffic safety unit to establish the Memorial High School as the main High School Memorial is more centralized within the township and has safer traffic statistics for new and inexperienced drivers if Liberty is chosen as the high school you'll see an increase in crash reports like the one
088I just described to you anyone who thinks Liberty should be the high school come to my office I'll show you the crash photos and the autopsy photos of the two little girls thank you hello my name is Jennifer arenson um I have a student here at Memorial who's a sophomore and I also have uh a proud graduate of the district in 2023 um I want to thank everybody on the board and everybody on the committee for all their hard work um understanding that we are in a position that we cannot move from at this point and I want to make it clear that I understand that we have a lot of uh Special Forces on us that we cannot change my one concern um and I will say I'm speaking from somebody who is going
089to be assumed to be junior in in the district is that I think what's under the iceberg of a lot of people in this room is that we have students who are in high school who are trying to move on to their future endeavors whether that be college and it's an enormous change for them and while I understand for all the information you gave us that it's possible to make this a slow transition I'm wondering if there's any way we can make it that some of our high school students can at least finish out their High School careers in their home schools and the reason I'm saying that is because I think that's why a lot of the people are here in this room um I understand that that might not be possible but one
090of the things I really thought about is that as mentioned before this school that we're in was in fact two schools at one point there's two cafeterias two uh gyms it's set up to be two schools um it's a way to potentially transition where you have students that are soon to be seniors soon to be Juniors to maybe be able to finish their careers here in this school while also having other students in other grades in the Clayton wing and it's going to allow the students that are in this room that are so concerned about not being able to finish their High School careers in their school to maybe have an Avenue to do that that um I also have a question as I know that you've gone over so many of these models but
091I it's never been really clear to me why Closing one of our other elementary schools is not an option given the fact that we are having all this lower enrollment um and we are continuing to project lower enrollment it hasn't really been clear to me on the slides why all of those options were not clearly delegated as to why that was discarded um it makes more sense to me that if we're having lower enrollment that you would not look at having one of those schools closed and giving us more transition time in these schools I understand that that's a hard thing for me to say because I do not have a younger student in the district and I have no idea how that infects enrollment but I would like the the committee to address that
092thank you good evening all uh Jeff Hena 43 uh year resident here I have two kids in the district also a police officer in Jackson uh I touched on this last meeting uh some of the projects uh around each school I had to like speedread it uh I just want to go over some of it again there's 35 projects already approved around Liberty High School um some of those some of the some of the main ones are Jackson Trails which South Hope Chapel Road 357 single family homes one house of worship um another large one is grown Estates 482 single family homes another thing that I forgot to mention is Pine Baron's Golf Course was recently sold 420 acres to the developer Morty morai Acorn who also is developing the uh development on South Hope
093Chapel Road as we speak uh Memorial High School there's only four projects approved at this moment um to note or the important ones there uh there's one on leeville road a three-story office building 57 parking spaces and on West Veterans Highway on the corner by the Wawa there's um 119 192 residences and four commercial buildings that four four schools that I keep seeing comments on Facebook about it's not approved it hasn't gone to the planning board it's not going into planning board until the end of December it'll probably take a year to decide if they're going to improve it and if they do it's 3 to five years probably before they even start construction um the area around jackmore High School is extremely limited to build to the South along Don Conor Boulevard is Prim
094L owned by the state of New Jersey and it's preserved land along Bowman Road to the West is also owned by the state of New Jersey County of ocean and Township of Jackson this area of land that stretches the route 571 West Veterans Highway is approximately 7.50 mil Square totaling 4,700 Acres that is preserved and unbuildable around Liberty uh there's only two Parcels owned by Ocean County one on South Hope Chapel Road and one on Whitesville Road with total land preserved of approximately 3,000 Acres these properties are not adjacent to either school and will be surrounded by expansive building projects that have been already approved by the township just a couple other things did any of you guys did any of the board members speak to the actual bus drivers out on the road every
095day uh not just the director of Transportation uh Dr Osman on your point before Liberty will be paid off this year I believe uh unfortunately my prediction is that in 3 to 5 years a big developer will offer the township a lot of money for the Liberty building and it will be sold and we'll back here again discussing the same stuff Miss is baracus I don't know if that's I'm pronouncing your name name right traffic safety and the safety of all students is very important when you make these decisions and my fear is in two to three years the roadways are Liberty mcalli will look like cross street looks like now and on the private school student uh comment uh with the eight I guess the Aiden I'm the private school student I was in
096a meeting with the lsta a couple weeks ago who runs the bu for the private school uh students 9500 private school kids next year 12,000 in the year6 627 so those prices those those costs are just going to continually increase thank you my name is Dr Christopher Val I'm a Jackson resident and I'm also been a special education teacher and a school principal I saw the slide that mentioned is going to be about 40 kids in a class that's no that's not cohesive to learning as opposed to laying off teachers why not do some team teaching or some parallel teaching or station teaching in the classroom because 40 kids in a class isn't ideal for learning for discovering knowledge for Gathering facts I recommend possibly combining teachers in the class for team teaching or some
097other Mo modality as young man Mr Walsh mentioned before we have resources for these students as Junior seniors to gather knowledge and go forward whether it's vocational school or academic school and college they need these resources and material to learn more and do more at the second stage in college whether it's vocational or academic thank you for your time [Applause] app good evening Scott sidel uh 26 years old for almost my entire life been a Jackson resident graduated Jackson Liberty 2016 two sisters graduated from this district one from Memorial one from Liberty just want to say I thank the board uh thank the school district I'm immensely lucky to have been here even as a Ruckers graduate uh my favorite class I've ever taken in school was APG shout out to uh Mr grub and
098Liberty uh I plan on coming here today and just reiterating some points uh I'm going to be very brief because I have some suggestions um Liberty has 400 more parking spots I know to many that's not a big deal I was a senior here too driving to school is important to many people and I know many people think that that's not a big deal when their son or daughter saves up for that car and they can't they can't drive to school I mean you're not going to be happy uh Liberty has double the amount of sports Fields a much larger gym these are obvious points a larger football stadium over double the acreage we don't know what's going to happen in 10 years if the school po uh population does rise which to be honest
099it's probably not but if it does room for expansion the schools landlocked my sister graduated Memorial when it was over 3,000 students she talked a 14-minute walk to class 14 minutes Liberty's designed circular it's designed with larger hallways it's designed for this the taxpayers paid for this Liberty is also clearly a lower cost to operate I'm asking the board to do what's fiscally responsible and people up here please we need to do what's fiscally responsible for the future of this town um I'll just pause on that for a second just I just asked that if anybody comes up here please offer suggestions as well um I'm going to offer two uh first off uh I ask that the board in any way they can if they petition a zoning and planning board to pause all
100projects on Brewers Bridge Hope Chapel East Veterans Highway and cooksbridge if possible projects that obviously have not started all traffic studies done in those areas should be considered null and void if they're if they've been done in the past couple years if we're changing the schools we know the traffic's going to increase just also like to say I live half a mile from Liberty there's no traffic at 7:00 a.m. I liveed there for 24 years at other time of the day yes at other times of the day I will agree traffic is horrific in that area at 7: a.m. when I leave for work there's nobody there i' I've lived there you can come over I'll give you a cup of coffee we'll watch the lack of cars I apologize but my second suggestion is
101I know people talk of rebranding uh I agree uh rebranding is probably important to everybody I also asked again that the board does what's fiscally responsible Liberty did go through Rebrand started when I was in school adding to Blue it took years you have 20 seconds uh just do what responsible I I my only suggestion to that is if rebranding was done that it be done to muli make everybody the Jaguar it could be almost symbolic students will be Jaguars coming up Lions to finish everybody's a Jaguar everybody's a line Community comes together thank [Applause] you that's enough if you cannot conduct yourself respectfully I'm going to ask you to leave okay hello um my name is Carolyn orio yes I'm a Jackson resident um I have a lot of interesting perspectives because I have
102a student who's in fifth grade a student who's in ninth grade I'm also um a teacher myself I grew up and T and also currently teach in Oldbridge and if you know anything about Oldbridge we've been through this um we've sold an elementary school we've combined high schools so I I've lived through it and I'm also going through it um on my teaching level also so I wrote some stuff down so I didn't lose my thought so I'm just going to read that now and I am nervous to speak so please be worth me um I'd first like to thank uh Mrs permil and the administration for being willing and open to answer all the questions during this process I hope everybody here took advantage of the email that was offered and asked actual questions
103that they were curious about instead of just complaining I had a lot of personal questions about the fifth and sixth grade building and almost all of them were answered on that frequently asked questions document and I actually is not in favor of it um because that's where my daughter's going to be at first and then after hearing the answers to my questions I do feel much better about it so I think asking actual questions is helpful in this process so thank you for that um a couple of opinions for me and I know this may be different from everybody else in the room but um I'm hoping that everyone's thinking not just about which high school is going to be used it's not the only important thing here in this plan you have it is
104important don't get me wrong but you also do have younger students who are just as important and they're going to be here in the district longer than the high schoolers the high schoolers are on their way out my daughter who's in Fifth going into six she's got a lot of years left here and I I was hopeful for what's to come for her okay um so hopefully everyone's thinking about not just the high schoolers but also for your younger students as well there's a lot of passion and energy in this room and a lot of what we're hearing is like those kids are almost going to get like the leftovers and that's probably not the message that we want to be sending to them um going along with that we have to keep in mind
105that neither High School is closing like building wise like they're both going to be used so um the way I think about it is when we're trying to decide which High School building should be used we have to keep in mind one's going to be a high school and one's going to be a middle school so we should think about which building is better suited as a high school and then which building is better suited as a middle school and in my personal opinion and it's not just because my child goes there Liberty to me just seems like the more logical choice to be a high school building it was built with that in mind it has the facilities and to use it as a middle school to me would almost be a waste okay
106I'm sorry um and I think this building could fit more as a um as a middle school um I'll skip a couple things uh not to say so much about traffic and not to say that there's no accidents or anything but Liberty but I personally had to come to this building a lot over the summer um for the theater camp and I know parents came here for the W Camp too and they were times up okay it is possible to have traffic on this side of town too and and and and I lived it when we had to come here when they were repaving the road we we have a lot of people I know I'm sorry we have to thank you you can come back at the end you may come [Applause] back am
107I all to speak um dear members of the board of administration my name is Jaden Stokes I'm a friend at Jackson Memorial High School and I'm here to express my deep concern for the well-being of my fellow classmates friends and teachers the area of Liberty is located in has obvious traffic and safety issues I beg you guys to retain the name memorial for our esteemed School the name Memorial holds profound significance for our for our community symbolizing not only a place of learning but also a tribute to the values and history that we hold dear thank you hi my name is Jennifer kosek I'm a Jackson resident and I also work in the district um speaking to what you were saying about worrying about safety and the police uh you know Department being closer to
108Memorial the safety should always be a concern and there's been animosity for I'm in this town for over 20 years um there's always been animosity unfortunately on either side of the town so that should have always been something to be on our high list of of our children attending school each and every day and being and feeling safe um at any given Mo moment I can get a letter from the district and ask me to move to the a different school on the other side of town never ever would I dream to treat a child on let's say the other side of town as it's been spoken of in so many so many times like that differently because of their address the animosity that we saw just a little a while ago is it's mindboggling
109to me these are people that my children play sports they have kids on their sports teams that are on both sides of town they walk off that field and they're fine they're fine let's give them some credit this is all coming from home these are the parents who are doing this it's not the children I think this audience should be the children and let the parents stay home and let these kids make the decision it's their future it's very hurtful to see that we have clapping going on and eyes coming this way it's it's we're all the same Community we're all neighbors that's right it's insane it's crazy to me and I'm so sad to see this happening hi I'm Debbie Holman I have two daughters in elementary school we moved to Jackson about eight
110years ago and I will be honest I came here because of the academic achievement um I know what this academic institution offers and I think if we are thinking long-term sustainability how we can protect the education of future Jackson kids we need to consider as Dr Osman shared before our biggest assets we need to strongly consider leasing instead of selling I heard there was also talk at some point about selling um gets to Jackson Township I think we all know that the township is changing and so I don't think that that's a good idea either um but in terms of protecting our futures for our children um um looking at the safety um the developments that are happening on that side of on the Liberty side of town I think it makes most sense if
111we're going to Lisa building to really consider Jackson Liberty thank you hi uh my name is elain Koger and I was asked to speak um I'm a Jackson resident um once again we're here and once again the decision is still pending it's disturbing that a lot of people have heard that the board members have been openly going around town saying they are not letting Memorial go so uh my question is um are you more concerned with saving a building than investing in our children's future and have those board members even bothered to look at the data one of the emails you received was from a liberty mom she stated that she works in the court system and unfortunately cannot work with certain people because it's considered a conflict of interest so that brings the question
112of how parents of children that are also on the board can vote and it's not going to be a con conflict of interest clearly it is and it's obviously shown at the last board meeting this is like a real life episode of Married With Children where Al Bundy is living in the past as his greatest football player that ever walked the hallways and is still trying to fit into his jersey well guess what this is not pul high school this is Jackson parents and respectfully born members you have lived your high school years now it's time to be responsible adults and do what's best for our children your children and our school system's future voting with emotion turns into voting with incompetence voting based on factual data is the responsible thing to do doing some
113minimal research of schools that have merged in the in the recent past not only in New Jersey but in surrounding states out of 17 guess what they found out that 17 experienced very similar problems to ours and not one picked an older school do you realize what laughing stocks our town and our board would be and look like Liberty has everything even a full recording studio for musical artists you would be taking away quality tools for a better education to stay with school and for traditional purposes I thank you uh thank you for allowing me three minutes to speak this evening my name is Steve wuki and I have three children our district tonight I'm not here to weigh one high school against the other but to discuss the impacts of the plan that you
114put forward and ask some questions that haven't been asked before final decisions have been made when the board votes to approve this plan 2400 students or 35% of our population will be reassigned to a new school and there is an imbalance as the majority of the 2400 students that will be moving are on the gets a memorial academic track but the changes don't just impact students as more than 300 staff members will be required to relocate this number doesn't include those who will shift within their current building to accommodate new grade level structures or programs and this leads me to several questions one what are the financial costs associated with moving 300 staff members and how will they be covered can the district manage this internally or will they need to hire a third-party moving
115company and if that's so what cost given the district's 2% budget cap does not account for the rising health care costs how will this transition be funded what cost does rebranding have at three schools rebranding just isn't new uniforms and logos it involves reflooring gymnasiums updating signage repainting buildings and installing new scoreboards can all this really be completed within three summer months will academic continuity be maintained ESP especially for our Rising seniors School culture takes years to develop but our seniors don't have years to wait they only have a few short months to Showcase their academic and extracurricular activities before applying to college will their academic experience remain strong or will The Growing Pains negatively impact their final year the plan also references an expected $8 million savings from the closing of gets will the
116district need these funds simply to make payroll or will they be reinvested in the schools for structure infrastructure Staffing and academic programming if GS is sold or repurposed as a private or Charter School are there additional hidden costs related to the transportation or shared services as required by the Department of Education and finally all of these decisions are being made before February 28th when the state releases an official funding allocations we are planning these massive changes with an anticipated 4.5 million reduction in state aid but that number could be higher or hopefully lower Additionally the has the district developed a financial Porta for the years Beyond 25 26 or will we be in the same situation in the future because we are running out of schools to sell beyond the logistics and finances we must
117consider the human impact the potential for staff layoffs teacher turnover and administrative reductions could significantly impact not only the success of this plan but also the district morale Jackson schools have a deeply rooted sense of community and we must ensure when the dust settles we still have the same support in our town thank you good evening my name is Elena Nelson and I am a student at Jackson Liberty High School as we all know today we Face a decision that will shape the future choosing one of our equally amazing schools to serve as our new high school but this is more than just selecting a name in a mascot it's about choosing Excellence opportunity in a place where Success is Not Just encouraged but also expected St statistically speaking our school has bigger parking space
118for both students and staff a best ramp three points of entry and more much more uh and much more and Liberty is much newer uh on the topic of traffic yes the school is father and having your kids drive for a longer time it's SC is scary and I know because I as well am a new driver but traffic is everywhere and not just in our area and if anything there's always the option to use the busing also an addition also in addition no matter what school we choose one school is losing their original school but this does not mean we will lose the memories of our school and I can say this confidently because I was one of the students from the now closed El Elementary School of Rosen hour thank you for your
119time and have a good night hi guys Vin Mista Jackson resident um first of all I want to thank you guys for taking the the time to really you know let this decision sink in and try to get all the information um I know the township appreciates it it's a big decision so we do thank all the work that you guys are doing I do want to address the animosity concerns um I'm in a unique position here where I came up to the school about 25 years ago I graduated from gets Middle School there's a whole new crop of kids that graduated from a call Middle School we both came together in the spring of in the fall of 2003 and believe it or not there was not gang fights fist fights you know any
120sort of nonsense in the hallways everybody got along and it was the norm so to say that there's always been animosity here between both sides of town and and where people live I think that's a little ridiculous and it's assuming a lot it is the responsibility when we come together it's the responsibility of the teachers coaches advisers administrators to set the tone and set the culture from the beginning no matter what school we are at it is their and our responsibility to do that as a professional and as someone who takes pride in the town whether you grew up here or you just work here that is what's going to build a strong school system and a strong education so that's first and foremost the problem problem that I'm seeing is the longer that we
121wait the more this divide happens the more you get clapping here clapping here booing here booing here so my question is you know there are some some really good questions being addressed by the board and next in two weeks if you guys decide to vote no on the plan that was presented does that mean that the whole thing we start from square one or can you at that point go back into an executive meeting or something come out with a new plan or a restructured plan and revote because honestly at this point like you guys said the board is come uh the band is coming together and figure things out Mr Walsh said kids are resilient they can't be resilient if we don't give them the opportunity to be resilient we have to bring the
122kids together the staffs together the buildings together all right I have pride in this building I graduate from this building I believe this is the right one but really my my vote and opinion doesn't matter in that situation what I really believe is we have to get everybody together on the same page as soon as possible so we start moving forward thank you hello Veronica Bernett teacher Jackson resident um I have ties to both sides of town I have mentioned this before and I have um so much love and pride in my entire Community um it makes me really sad today to feel so strongly the divisiveness that is you know one side of the room and the other side of the room and and it's hurtful I'm sure that there are kids that I
123coached over on that side and and there are kids that I taught and and instruct over on this side Miss Larsson and I who is the drama club adviser here at uh libert at Memorial she and I have already spoken about getting our groups together and and letting them Bond and get to know each other because the merge is happening whether we like it or not the two high schools are coming together somebody's going to be unhappy but what we need to do is is get the kids together so we can start to heal we want to become one great Jackson and right now I feel like there are so many closed minds that you're not willing to let that happen and we have to fix that the kids will do it um we keep
124using the word traffic as like a scapegoat with no one wait and and um you know I I had a kid who went here who drove to Liberty it we are all concerned about the traffic but what is also not happening is the traffic is not going to change it's going to get worse and um I actually called the zoning board today and there are four or five schools approved on this side of town I don't know when they're going to be built but traffic is going to get worse so why can't we be coming up with a plan to fix the traffic why can't we make the traffic better because we want everybody to be safe wherever you are in Jackson we want you to be safe and the board you have this awesome
125weighty decision to make so much responsibility in making this decision and I can't imagine how difficult that must be to put your own allegiances and your own Traditions aside to make the decision that is best for all the students in Jackson but they have to make the decision for all the students not half the students and we have to make sure that whatever decision gets made we are going to make the best of it and it has to come from you guys it can't be us against them Hatfields and The McCoys we have to be one Jackson good day good good day everyone uh Isaac ellner Jackson resident for a length of time uh before I get to my main point I do want to add on to the two other points starting with the
126principal's very valid point of smaller class sizes as someone who who the district paid to go to private school mainly ker high school he is so right about smaller class sizes I can't emphasize that enough especially with what is likely going to happen the two high schools merging you're adding a lot of students from who knows where into whatever you decide to and it's pretty likely that the class sizes are likely going up depending on how you handle the teacher Staffing and I know the guy on the left over this there said that Memorial at one point had 3K students but now days with the research we've had with various school stuff in America it's just shown that smaller class sizes are better and I can attest to that it's very important and the second
127point before I go on to my main point is the Rebrand which I'm a bit conflicted on this because on the one hand yes it definitely would cost money to well you know change the entire identity and that hasn't worked for some actual sports teams Chicago Fire of the MLS but on the other hand the booze from the section kind of just shows that not everyone would likely be willing to join the Jackson what other you guys decide because you know the football rivalry has been going on for a reasonable amount of years now I mean I think Liberty's technically younger by Me by by year but it's going to be whatever you guys decide you guys make a new mascot or something you guys got to unite together but my main point I want
128to discuss tonight is the future Beyond this because I've been thinking thinking about the middle schools in particular and particularly mainly because of S2 which my concern is does this plan last a year before we have to make more Cuts because I do want to mention Sylvia Rosen hour was only closed last year and it kind of does feel bit quickly how we're in February and we're already discussing the future and cutting a high school which keep in mind is a very big deal CU two high schools is better than one as someone probably said before but yeah I'm just hoping you guys basically I'm just trying to say is you got to figure out the future CU you can't keep selling schools forever and we don't know what's going to happen after this state
129or governor election because even if we relx a new guy he's not he doesn't it doesn't mean we're going to change the formula immediately there's so many other stuff that's going chaotic in New Jersey right now and we don't know if S2 is going to change you have 20 seconds yeah that's that's pretty much it thanks [Applause] good evening I'm a a Jackson resident for about 33 years um I live on the North side of town north of 195 I'm on the Freehold border so we're like the Forgotten side of town we're a small pocket that is districted to Crawford muli and Liberty I had a 21 2021 graduate of Liberty and I have a junior in Liberty we are so far removed from all of the town that um if anyone should complain about
130traffic it's us because we're basically north of 195 but I drive my daughter to school in the morning and I can make it in less than 15 minutes there's really not traffic and I have multiple ways that I can arrive in at Liberty at any time of the day um yes my daughter is going to be driver in September so I'm a little nervous but I'm glad that you're putting in the resources for the students and the parents to be make them more aware of of driver safety and anything that we can enjoy all the parents and students together to arrive at that um make them more aware of these safety issues is appreciated um as far as the fiscal part of it I am a CPA for 30 years so I really appreciate all
131of the work that you've put into this it is not easy to come up with these numbers um and as far as Unity I find it kind of strange because my son attended uh Liberty for four years he also was in the RC program here for three years he had attended with a great group of kids from Liberty and Memorial and you know where they all got along and that's tone at the top because that came from major you know that these kids were both part of this town my my son also was a a Boy Scout from first grade until high school and attained his Eagle Scout and he did that with both Memorial and Liberty high schoolers I was a girl scout leader for six years I had kids in both sides of
132town in my troop it is possible but it comes from tone at the top from the parents the teachers the Educators and the leaders we have to show our children that we are united too and is really really important so you know let's keep our kids safe and let's find ways that we all can unify together whe whether it be like ptsn you know the parent teachers or even parent committees with the children so we can bring this town together and keep our kids safe that's it hi my name is Jim Osman I um have a few points to make I first want to uh thank everyone for getting involved I wish there was always this many people who came out to Board of Education meetings and got involved um there's always important things happening
133in your school district and um getting involved in many ways are valuable tools and ways to get inside knowledge of what's happening in the schools and being informed um I can tell you as someone who um you know wants to believe that I am well informed um the people who are sitting up here are taking taking this amazingly seriously for those of you who think that they're not I assure you that they are I happen to be married to one of them and I can assure you that they are not sleeping they are not doing many of the things that they would much prefer to be doing they are doing everything they can in the best interest of all of the children in this school district and for anyone who thinks otherwise I assure you
134you are wrong they are with they and night they are doing what they can to make the best most informed decisions in the best interest of the children of this community with that said I'm so glad that I'm starting to hear more people talk about Unity because the divisiveness is atrocious everyone's got an opinion no matter what no matter who you are no matter where you're from you've got an opinion your opinion is your opinion it's self-serving it's it's admittedly self- serving we all have a own opinions trust me I've got plenty of them but my opinions don't matter I've got to think about what's in the best interest of the community as a whole and at the end of the day I've got to trust these people up here to make that decision now
135changing my conversation to this direction the biggest thing that I'd like to say before I walk away is and I heard someone say it a little while ago we've got to get to a decision because all of this is not going to stop until a decision is made and so I would hope that it would but clearly it's not going to until a decision is made and when a decision is made now we can pick up the pieces and we can pull back together and our people our staff members can pull together as was just said we can get together our students can start to reunite the kids that were on all the same sports teams growing up can come back together again and stop this ridiculous banter of back and forth Liberty Memorial blah
136blah blah we're all one town you all grew up in the same town you're all together stop with the this side that side stuff we're all one town come together be together be one Jackson and be proud to be from Jackson that's all I have thank you hi my name is Tara I'm a Jackson resident coming up now on 10 years I have a graduate of Jackson Liberty last year and I have a current freshman I just want to start off I am from New York I know you guys are talking about traffic this is nothing I understand it might be Jackson traffic but you do what you got to do and I think it's ridicul I I shouldn't say it's ridiculous because it is a concern and I totally get it and I don't
137want to disregard anybody's but like I live across the street from Liberty I still can get in and out of my driveway sometimes I might have to wait a minute but I do get out I am representing some of my other parents it's a a group of different types of parents so I want to also thank the board and I understand the difficult decisions you have and I appreciate you listening to everybody's concerns and I just hope we make the correct decision on the students account um if you reject the proposal created by the committee that's been consisted of Jackson School District's best these are the members that are consisted of principles Vice principles Central Administration board members supervisors as well as teachers and parents we should appreciate the hours and months of the time
138that they have spent coming up with the best solution for our current and future students of the district we surveyed the community went out you did results you took a email you got all your information that you need I know that their decisions and discussions on committee put the best interest of the districts and the students first not letting emotions or ties to certain places get in the way the facts that some of the community feels that Memorial would be better High School versus Liberty the facts are right now currently for an academic Jackson Liberty High School is the best choice for a high school academically and all the amenities and the newer school a lot of concerned parents obviously again on the traffic surrounding Liberty Liberty's been open for almost 20 years and they've
139never been a discussion until now about traffic concerns what just happened in the past months is now being concerned is around Liberty I know that also part of this is going to go into a 5 seven-year plan I hate to say it but what everybody's concerned about that's happening on the Liberty side it's going to come to this side too you're going to have to deal with it again later at some point they drive to work there's children that drive from the memorial side to go to work to the Liberty side three four times a week we let our kids drive to the Freehold Mall they go to Great Adventure they go to the beaches in the summer you just let them go there's no concerns for that during the start and the end time
140of the school there's not a lot of extra traffic it's normal volume can go in you have 20 seconds please consider that the recommendation as presented so our students can continue to have the best experience that Jackson has to offer thank you very much my name is Kim Nelson um I'm a Jackson resident for most of my life I have two kids in the district one graduated while I do have a high school student my main concern is my fourth grader because we're going to be here and she's going to be coming up through the district now she came into the school system during covid so those children have that already going for them now you're saying that we're probably going to be doing this in another 5 to six years possibly I heard that
141during the commenting here there's a possibility of another redistricting how long is this going to hold us over this is this a Band-Aid or do you have is this going to be a permanent solution do we have any numbers as to how long this is going to hold this or these kids going to get reshuffled around again and Ne this year they're going to be going over to Mcall if is their I hear all this stuff for the high school students what we're doing for them what is going on for these students that have the fourth graders are not adjusted for this the fifth graders were getting adjusted to going into another school these kids are just being surprised you're moving over is there any plans for that grade level like we're doing for all
142the other students that we're talking about tonight thank you hi everyone my name is Joselyn Salas um before we start I wanted to tell everyone that uh first and foremost the Jackson School District is not a construction company nor are we landlords so we you know thinking about Liberty as being the best facility is because we don't have to put as much money into it in regards to some of the other buildings in town nor should we be putting money into it while the kids are there either and them suffering through construction process with that being said I prepared something um as we navigate the financial landscape of our school district it's essential to address the current situation regarding our preschool Annex for the community to hear while funds from the state have aided getting
143the annex ready for the preschoolers it is important to recognize that these resources could have also been allocated elsewhere the consideration of relocating and retrofitting another building for our preschool Annex so that the high school could remain at remoral raises concerns such a move could incur significant expenditures that our district cannot afford especially as we project a deficit for the upcoming year it's vital for us to prioritize our funding and make decisions that support our children's education without unnecessary and frivolous Financial strain particularly if the reluctance stems from a preference for a different High School moreover with the seventh and eighth graders being proposed to be situated at Memorial we have an opportunity to reconfigure our space effectively this can include relocating some offices to enhance our operational efficiency especially given the findings of the
144architectural assessment highlighting the urgent need for renovations at the Transportation Hub due to its poor air quality traffic flow around Memorial remains a challenge as I have observed first hand myself many cars find themselves caught at the light while trying to merge onto Don Connor which further complicates our daily operations so the traffic argument is not one-sided we need to take a realistic practical approach that not only addresses our financial priorities but also considers the Practical aspects of our facilities layout and Community traffic patterns thanks hello my name is Drew Gibson and I'm a teacher here at Jackson Memorial High School um I've been here for probably got since 2002 so um I want to thank all of you guys the Board of Education members for my job but also for this all the work
145you put into this and everything like that and um you know obviously I'm not from this town but like Mr Walsh said earlier you know I was here before it all started I was here during it all you know what I mean and the kids were good and we're talking about uniting as a town and you know I don't think that's going to be a problem I really don't you know the kids were great back then the kids the kids it's going to stink for is the Juniors this year because they're going to have to go to a new high school and it's going to be very tough for them you know I'm a year or two away from retirement and that's my biggest thing is I'm going have to change my last year so
146it's going to be tough for them the younger kids they're going to adapt sophomores it's going to be a little bit tougher freshman's going to be a little bit easier eighth graders seventh graders they're going to come up together and they're going to be fine they're going to be fine they're all going to come together as a town and there won't be the problems that everybody thinks that we're going to have you know and I sit here and watch and you know kind of not cracks me up but I look at the Divide you know and I look at all the red shirts over there and I hear us talk about we need to unite we need to unite but you know that's everybody's together for Jackson for Liberty whatever it may be I wear
147my red but we do need tonight we do need to unite and we will and the kids will be fine the kids will be fine they will adapt to it they will be great so I think you know for you guys you have to look long term five six years what what is going to happen then you know you can't base I know we we all care about the the kids we all care about what's going to happen to them and the kids are going to be fine and next year's kids is going to be tough on but in six seven years where are we going to be that's where the decision has to be made what is the best decision long term and like somebody said before you know my decision what I think
148doesn't matter obviously I love Jackson Memorial I've been here forever I have great memories I've worked with great people you know I mean I've worked with great students and I'm sure everybody that worked at Liberty can say the exact same thing you know so we will come together but what is the best thing for our town in 5 6 years from now and what's the best decision to made for the the people that live in this town the kids and everyone you know so I want to thank you for your time I know we will come together as a town I know it will be great and it'll be the next 25 years will be wonderful in Jackson thank you hi my name is Shannon Pinko I am a resident of Jackson I would just
149really like to extend my sincere appreciation to the superintendent to the entire Administration to the srrp committee for their dedication and hard work your commitment to the success and wellbeing of our students and staff is truly commendable I would like to express my deep gratitude to the board of education for their ongoing support vision and efforts in ensuring that our educational system thrives I understand this is a highly emotional decision for everyone involved whether you are a parent a teacher a coach a district employee a student and a family member I would like to point out that where the police station is located does not matter we currently operate two high schools two middle schools five elementary schools the police Do not sit in the headquarters all day because they're out on patrol lastly I
150just hope you can use the facts the data and the research that have been provided by the expert to make a unified vote on the superintendent's recommendations and be objective and not emotional thank you so much for your time and all that you do it's truly appreciated good evening board my name is Chris adolfson I have six children who have gone through the school system or still in the school system um I was born and raised in Lakewood I went through the entire Lakewood school system all the way through graduation I have seen what's happened in the Lakewood schools with their with everything that's gone over there I've schools have closed the funding over there has dropped and the education level for the students themselves has disappeared um I want to make sure that whatever
151decision you guys make is not just a Band-Aid solution that this my children who are still going through the school system will not face what's happened over there so my question to you is have you reached out to the lake equid board and learned from their mistakes learned what they've tried to do and where it hasn't worked um the other thing I wanted to talk about is what happens if this vote takes place and it fails how long are you guys going to take to come up with another plan have another vote and will that be done in time to enact those changes prior to the budget expiring uh the last thing I want to talk about is you've you've considered this and I hope you have what happens if you have a program where
152there's too many children wanting to do that program when you consolid the schools how are you going to address that thank you uh my name is Stacy richardi I am a resident of Jackson um I want to thank the board I especially want to thank Mr McCarron and Miss Cass you guys responded to my email so that's appreciative thank you um I'm just going to speak more on perspective of unity um I like Carolyn was part of theberge high school merger in the 9s I was a freshman I got booted out of my school to another school and I have to tell you we didn't have our parents involved right there's no social media we staged a walk out we didn't want it and guess what we came together and there was no issue I
153actually met my husband he was from the other side of town and and I have some great friends from it so I think I think a lot of the issues with with unity will come together once our kids are together um and I think us as parents um needs to step back and I also just want to say that um the addressing the safety issue with the school and the police station um I have to say you aren't making us Liberty parents feel like all warm and fuzzy um based on your recommendation um about how safer it is here than it is where our children go now and I just want to say like are you saying that my seventh grader because I will have a seventh grader um who could potentially be at Liberty
154is not as safe as my senior who could potentially be at Memorial thank you good evening uh my name is Diane leapold I'm a teacher in The District 27 years um one thing I want to comment on is as you're talking about the technology that we have advancements we have our promethium boards which are now outdated we have Chromebooks which are now outdated uh we have screens that come down that we use our computers in order to give our kids videos and access to games and access to online tools there are times when the technology doesn't work it doesn't matter which building you're in your technology doesn't work so what do you do you pick up a marker you go to the white board and you teach your kids or if you still have a
155green board you're picking up a piece of chalk and you're still teaching your kids the building and the technology that's not what makes educ ucation it's the teachers who make education so we're going to do whatever needs to be done we're going to adapt however it needs to be adapted we're going to change whatever needs to be changed we're going to roll out whatever needs to be rolled out because that's what we do we put our kids first and what needs to be heard is not just what I'm saying here but parents need to understand you need to stop just clapping for your person you might like what one person said says about one side of town but you really need to hear what everybody is saying it's not about one building or two buildings
156it's about this and if you think that technology is what teaches your kids ask them what they learn when they're on social media on their phones thanks and thank you have a good night hello I am Ace cober I have been in the Jackson School District my whole life I am on the Jackson girl bowling team is say just Jackson because this year the Liberty girls and Memorial girls have merged we talk about the fighting that comes between Liberty and Memorial I don't see that as big of an issue as we see it is because when I heard that we were merging I was terrified that there was going to be a line that there would just be between the liberty and Memorial girls because we were from different schools we've never spoken to to
157each other before and it never happened I was going to quit because I was scared of being with the other girls because I heard about the fighting about the other things the Prejudice that comes between them but it never happened those girls are my best friends I've never met Kinder girls in my life and I will I don't regret my decision with s staying because we talk about the fighting within kids who have never met each other before and I feel like we should more see this as an issue when it becomes closer because we have never had the chance to meet these other kids our schools don't do anything where we have had the chance to be able to get to know them we just hear the fighting and I feel like most of
158the fighting comes from the fact that we don't know these kids we see these kids and we heard about the fighting we hear that they said this about us we hear that they did this to us but we don't actually know them we don't know what they have said they could have have said great things about us but we wouldn't know because we had never had the chance to speak to each other we talk about the fighting but it's not going to be as big of an issue if we actually had the chance to meet together before any of this happened I was nervous about the schools teams merging at first and I thought that it shouldn't have happened I thought that it was unfair that the schools were going to merge because I like
159just having the Liberty team but I think that our team's merging was the best decision that could been made thank you can I go again or do I have to wait sorry everyone has to since you already spoke everyone else has to speak first and you have to go last okay the rules thank you hi um Andrea frangela parent of uh two girls in the district I also work in one of the elementary schools I just have a few things to say um through all of this the one thing I never worried about was the value of Education that these kids are going to get from the teachers in the building so that is never an issue in my mind from being in the schools and having two kids sixth grade and nth grade never
160a question I was never worried about that and I hope that shouldn't be an issue for anybody in this room or watching at home um Sports should be competitive High School sports should be competitive I know it stinks if your kids's a senior and they've played a sport all through high school I get it but they should be competitive so not everybody's going to get on the team and I think that's okay um advancement in technology 100% enhances education it's not all about education but technology enhances your education and and to think that that's not uh a step up to me is is is not doesn't make sense to me um no one is doubting that we can't fit everybody in this building that's that's not I don't think anyone's doubting that um but that's
161like choosing a 60-year-old car over a 20-year-old car that you're choosing to drive your family around in it just to me it doesn't make sense um Mr binsky week after week discusses S2 funding and if you don't understand that it's not uh something he could tell you about for next year by this point it's like beating a dead horse we don't know next year until next year so let's give him a break to to stop explaining what S2 funding is it's been going on for seven eight years now um and the last thing I have to say is prolonging a vote by the next meeting is doing a huge disservice to the administration you have seven months till the first day of school it's doing a disservice to the administration to the parents to the
162teachers to the kids we have to start February 19th so I really hope you guys can come together with a decision by then thank you hi I'm Ava I'm a senior Jackson Liberty and I just wanted to say I remember when I was entering middle school there were three elementary schools I think it was three elementary schools I don't really remember because we all came together and nothing really mattered after that but um there were I believe three elementary schools that funneled into my middle school I was thrilled like like yay new friends new people to get to know we were all so excited for our schools to come together I met some of my best friends who I'm still so close with and that wouldn't have happened if our schools didn't come together it
163was so much fun what's changed from then to now why were we so excited to combine back then but so hesitant to combine and hostile towards each other now this hate hasn't always been in US it hasn't always been in us against them divide I don't know what's changed as we've grown but this really is all about perspective and I'm graduating but I have so many friends from Memorial that I would have loved to go to school with so it just really is something something to think about and all about perspective Tom Smith I've been in Jackson for 36 years had two students graduate one's currently a freshman and uh this is really a message I want to give the students because where I went to high school in Berkeley we had grades 7 through
16412 packed into one building with split sessions for the entire time I was there and for years before I went there and it took about 20 years to get a new school built and my senior class was the last in the packed school and the class after mine that had to get split all our sports teams got split those kids didn't want to go to the brand new school in their own in their Town set off from Berkeley so the only thing i' want to say to the students is yeah it's it's painful it's a consolidation event and it it's I mean you're all better together um it's the opposite of what I saw in high school and I think I would look at it as a better opportunity because you're bringing all the best
165from two schools into one and I think that's just the way the student should look at it U everything's going to improve as far as what they're drawing from so just for the [Applause] students uh hello everyone uh my name is uh Darren trout wine uh I think I was on the minutes earlier today I'm a unpaid uh coach at Jackson memorial for the last three years both in the fall and the spring so I start my work day about three or four hours earlier than everyone else so I can come over to the school and Coach these students uh the other thing I have a a club and I have 60 kids right now that are practicing volleyball in both of the gyms in this High School those kids come from the memorial side
166of town they come from the Liberty side of town and I challenge any of the adults in this room to go over there and if it's not your kid to show me which one's the Liberty Kid and which one's the memorial kid based on how they interact with each other the other thing that I see uh and I've been on the sidelines or on the on the court coaching and countless times I've had both uh both girls volleyball teams as well as uh the boys volleyball teams being the loudest cheerleaders for their brother or sister team that was in Jackson so my take on it is I think that uh from being around these students all the time all day I was coaching at uh soccer in the town before that we had Liberty Kids
167we had Memorial kids we have kids from out of town I personally feel that the division and the animosity is adult driven and not parent driven I actually just saw two liberty kids get up and walk from that side and go over to this side and shake a couple of the guys hands who I know from Li from Memorial um so I I I think that the divisiveness is honestly a product of what the parents are putting on social media the fabrication that they're putting on social media the lies that they're putting on social media the exaggerations they're putting on social media if you want to speak in here or you want to let people know what's going on use data find resources site references because that's the information that'll hold up in here and
168nothing else will the other thing that I just wanted to mention is about the technology I have a a a senior in in Memorial now and I have a freshman in uh Memorial now as well right um the technology thing uh schools that have greater technology have better education is fake it's false and it's proven that's false so in my day job I uh work for a rather large company and I sit in seite meetings and I advise them on how to make decisions and all we use in those meetings are sticky notes and Sharpies and we make decisions that affect millions and millions of lives on this planet so the technology thing whether you have a computer or a whiteboard or whatever it's not true it's not proven it's not factual right so the
169technology doesn't matter it's a matter the the the idea of bringing these kids together the parents not getting involved in it and letting these kids come together as they already do as they are doing in the gym right down there the gym right over there walking over here some of the players over here I'm sorry sir thank you I got thank you hi everyone uh my name is Alison Malone I'm a resident of Jackson for quite a few years I have a son who's a senior and a daughter who's a sophomore at Memorial first off thank you very much to the administration the Board of Ed I know you know some of you and I know the countless hours that are uh spent on this and is very much appreciated if it's not always represented
170that way um just in the spirit of what he was just saying about the parents and you know I agree with that so I I think um in the spirit of that you know even as we're sitting in this meeting tonight people are posting pictures on social media you know the switch plate that's behind uh Miss Cass uh Jack Memorial is in great shape so so that's what we don't need you know like pictures of that on Facebook and it's not a kid because it's on Facebook so it's a parent so let's just not do those things and let's not do that and Jackson memorial is a great school but you know what at the end of the day my daughter just wants to know where she's going to be in September like whether it's
171here she will be thrilled if it's at Liberty she will also make her way through and by the third day she'll know where her classrooms are and she'll know all that stuff so I'm sorry I'm getting emotional but um you know I just hope for the kids sake that if it does wind up at Liberty that there's orientations that these kids are shown around so as not to you know make it feel like Outsiders you know when they show up there in their first day of school um and I think that's about it and you know hopefully you know everything is going to turn out good in the end so hi dorlene demerest um Jackson resident over 20 years it's very upsetting to me as someone that sat on the previous redistricting committee um I
172thought this was going to be a good thing because my kids were the product of the schools being divided we're coming together it's going to be be a Powerhouse again it's going to be one town again it's going to be a good thing and coming together and not knowing like you're in Jackson it's one town the kids all grew up baseball Hull Brook wrestling they all come up for the most part they know each other but miss Cass and I we went to Regional High School where you had three totally different towns come together and I hate to say how many years later but we're still a very close-knit group your memories are your memories no matter what the busing the school yes there's traffic but I dare anybody to try to make a left
173out of either building at prime time it's tough the animosity's got to go the animosity comes from the parents I know that from the first time when we divided If the parents don't want the kids driving this the proven safest way to get to school is on a school bus and if you do want your kids driving and everybody wants their seniors to drive apparently there's more spots on Liberty so you have your choice be like a city take a bus or allow your kids to drive and go where there's more spaces and because of the animosity I would bring it to the board to look into getting some resource officers to be in whichever building you choose to to make sure they're safe not just one in a building especially if you're all coming
174together you need more and you're probably going to need someone to direct traffic no matter Memorial or Liberty because getting in and out it doesn't matter good luck hey again I'm not going to talk about traffic um for a change um with that being said I just want to piggyback off coach mrea coach and Coach Gibson I referred to him as coaches I respect them we do need to unite these kids as soon as possible uh with that being said why aren't the decisions on who will be coaching these sports teams for the 25 26 school year decided yet so they can meet with these teams and hire proper staff we don't want current coaches and student athletes leaving this District because they don't know who'll be coaching these teams also the head coaching jobs
175of all these teams should go to the best person for the job the best candidate the most productive not who has been in the district the longest we have we have great student athletes here we always have um and it's been going on forever and we don't want that to disappear and that goes for next school year I don't understand why these decisions can't be made tomorrow when the merger the merging of the schools shouldn't matter on on when you announce who's going to coach the teams we know the schools are merging it has no effect on when the coaches should be announced and the last uh thing I have on Sports is I remember Miss Peril said this last meeting why can't the sixth graders play Middle School sports some sixth graders in the
176school district should be playing for the middle school team I believe last year five or six sixth graders made the gets Middle School baseball team so why should that not be allow why should they not be allowed to play Middle School sports um and that's all I have thank you this this will be the last person to speak we're going to close public forum after this okay thank you uh just just wanted to ask some questions uh I know I made statements before just wanted to you know obviously I don't expect these to be answered um but just three questions I wanted to leave the board with uh just to reiterate a lot of people said this what's the decision process if you vote no on February 19th I mean there like people said there's
177seven months to school district uh to the school next year um I don't really know what you guys would do uh I also I work in data analytics I personally uh enjoyed when the fixed cost was showed uh to us I think that's very important what's the cost per student what's the cost per student in five years you know there's inflation uh you can estimate the inflation what's the cost per student in 10 years whichever school is chosen I think I speak you know I'm not trying to speak for everybody I think I think we can recognize that choosing the newer school is cheaper in general just by default but what's the actual difference is it a large difference is it a small difference and uh I know I made a statement before about the
178zoning and planning board I don't know if you guys can actually do anything I don't know if you can use your bully pulpit and Advocate to pause projects that haven't started um I would hope that you can if not obviously maybe we need to petition those boards as uh taxpayers and voters um and I know that those boards are appointed by the council so I understand that we may need to go that route as well but just those questions and I appreciate your time thank you I need a motion to close public forum motion second all in favor just want to thank everyone for coming up and speaking as well we are certainly taking all your comments to heart I just want you to all know that thank you I need a motion to move
179to move the official meeting schedule motion you want to ask oh wait respond oh yeah um yes let's uh have Miss permil respond to some of those questions I thought we were going to do it at the very end I apologize oh no worries um and again and as I have said in our past meeting I may not answer everyone's questions um if not tonight then we will certainly address them in the Q&A or um individually ask you to reach out to us um for example I know there was a lot of questions from one gentlemen that we have heard from before and we do plan on answering many of those questions um throughout our Q&A um and also individually so um continue to send them to us I know you've had some fiscal questions
180um and please be patient this was a lot of information and I want to be able to go through it um from start to finish so there was a couple of comments in regards to um making sure that this decision happens I do know that the board is I just want to make sure everybody can hear me um I know that the board is working hard to be able to make a decision as soon as possible um it is a very weighted decision and they are doing all of their homework and working hard to make an informed decision and so I just want to reiterate that and that they do want to make a decision soon so that we can begin moving forward in planning and we really are waiting to a for a final
181decision because nothing is official until it is finalized by a board vote um and should something change we don't want to start work and then have to undo work because it is a short timeline um but please know we do have draft timelines in place ready to go as soon as we have a vote we're not just sitting here doing nothing we have timelines in place that we're going to begin to roll out as soon as possible and form committees as soon as possible the student committees as many people spoke about all of that is in the works we do have plans for that um so we we are thinking um I do want to thank the police department for the information that they have shared um it is important information to review and consider
182and we do appreciate appreciate that there's been some comment we've had some actual questions also an email and also tonight about slowing the process down and being able to um let some high school seniors finish out in their current schools and our hearts go out for them of course and we're going to try and make everything as smooth as possible for students and help them in that transition but unfortunately uh when you break up grade levels like that you won't have the same opportunities and a abilities of things um by splitting programs across schools it isn't going to work for the district in regards to being able to offer Equitable programs for all students that's the bottom line for us here we're here for students that's our purpose and offering Equitable programming and opportunities for
183all must be the first thing considered here and that doesn't allow us to do that unfortunately um and again you heard from Mr binsky myself several times why we have to act now otherwise these things are at Great risk we have been Banda peac mealing being creative for seven years and been advocating for seven years last year was the the moment in time and some of you may remember when we had to make that very tough decision to sell Rosen hour we didn't want to do that but we were forced to have a balanced budget we had no choice um and unfortunately if we continue down this path we will continue to take things away from students and for all of those who asked questions about what about the future that's what this is about
184sustaining programs and keeping this excellent School District in place together um and we need to unite and come together and I want to thank everybody who spoke about that tonight we are an incredible staff here I say it all the time it's not just lip service so many staff members some who came out tonight to speak about bringing kids together this is what they do they're wonderful at it and we will make sure students are okay we will offer opportunities for orientations we will offer opportunities for students to see things and for our staff too our staff is going through great change we'll offer opportunities for them to see their new spaces all of that is important in these transitions elementary schools um and I I appreciate that this question was asked and that there
185was some comments about our elementary students a lot of dialogue coming up to the mic is about our high school students um and some of our fifth and sixth grade our early Learners were absolutely considered in strategic planning uh lots of conversation about it um in our elementary schools currently we have a lack of space honestly we have added a significant preschool program that serves this community free preschool for three three-year-olds and four-year-olds is an incredible opportunity for this community I wish I would have had that how much money I spent on Child Care um so it's an incredible opportunity not only for parents to have that for their children but for the children themselves to begin their learning process with us earlier is going to make significant impact on their education long long term
186so it's incredible program not only for students and for parents but also also fiscally you've heard me say it before the the state funds that well that is state aid that comes to us um and it really does help offset a lot of expenses for us so our our elementary schools have a lot of preschool classrooms currently many of our elementary schools have their unified arts on carts there's no separate classroom so our students and this was something our Elementary staff spoke about in strategic planning that some of our students never really get to leave their classroom all day especially in the winter months that's difficult so that was taken into consideration by removing our fifth grade from the elementary schools that provides some additional space to have those unified arts for our teachers and
187our students and it also by keeping the preschool Annex here allows for us to have overflow for any preschool classrooms that we may need to add in the future so lots of things were discussed lots of variables like I said before that not everybody May understand so it is important that we keep and we do remove the fifth grade because we do experience um overcrowd and happening right now um on many levels in our elementary schools now in the long term as I said earlier we'll see what happens with enrollment and again we plan for a flat enrollment based on what our incoming numbers have been over the last few years but unfortunately we're in a situation where we really can't predict exactly what that's going to look like in enrollment to talk about futuristic
188plans we have done the best we can with the information we have currently knowing that those variables especially here in Jackson can change quickly not only on enrollment but state aid here we are February we have to present a tenative budget in March do we have state aid numbers how do you plan future I istically when you don't know from year to year what you're dealing with for Revenue one of your only main you have a few but one of your biggest Revenue sources so it becomes very difficult to make those projections but we have done that out five years um and we strongly feel that this plan should be able to carry us well into the future preserving programs and extracurriculars 40 students in a class that comment came up that was if we
189don't restructure um may even be higher in some areas remembering the purpose of restructuring is to lower permanent operational costs by lowering permanently operational costs from year to year that carries you versus one-year fixes like many of the board members talked about earlier does not benefit the district so this is a more permanent reduction to our overall budget the cost to rebranding and financial costs to move we we recognize there are some expenses to that um the rebranding process we're looking at for middle school high school together with Committees of students and teachers will have to be a long um year process it's not going to be a quick few months process need to lay out a plan we well aware of this when we work with that committee it'll be what can we do
190in the short term what's the recommendation for rebranding and how do we make that plan come to life over a year or so so that we can make sure that we are able to do it and do it well um and I know that we also have excuse me some volunteers who have also um stepped up and said they would be willing to help us and help with assistance and I will be honest I'm also going to talk to ptns and also to um the Jackson Education Foundation about how they can help support that um working together is the way to make this happen successfully for our students there were some questions around um selling schools we'll run out of schools to sell eventually and absolutely agree with you 100% um and actually said that
191to the Department of Ed assistant Commissioners when I went and presented at a hearing recently about the funding formula um and and urged them yet again to differentiate that formula based on unique circumstances like Jackson um overall the money that comes from selling a building will be put into back into our buildings and our facilities um and offset the budget expenses there to then help again Lower operational costs um we believe that selling another building will take us through several years of not having to be in a budget deficit and obviously we hope many factors have change will change at that point I would assume some enrollment will drop we'll continue to make some reductions based on enrollment and that's how we see looking into the future um our projections and we will we'll also
192outline that a little bit more in our Q&A for everybody um so that you can see it in some writing as well there were some questions about what happens if the board votes no to the recommendation to the whole thing or to partials of it um my understanding is whatever the board decides and votes on they'll also make a recommendation um to me to what they would like to see either happen or ask me to do something um but they are very much informed about how important it is and the process that we all have to take as administrators and staff in this District to roll this plan out so I'm sure that they will make a good recommendation of what they see should happen next um and that I assume um Mr zmer that's
193pretty much what would happen normally if a a vote is overturned correct yeah that's correct and as I understand this board fully intends to come to a final decision at our next meeting I think everybody understands the timeline that we're operating Under And the fact that we we need to to vote on this so I don't want to speak for anybody but I think Miss Cass that's pretty much an accurate yes account of how the plan the board plans to operate at the next meeting okay again I want to thank those people who spoke tonight I know the board is thankful for their input to consider um and I really do appreciate the message of unity uh we're here for for kids and work let's work together and think of the power behind this for
194our students if all of us are moving in the same direction to support them just want to see if I have anything else Staffing decisions we have a timeline for that that we're ready to launch as soon as there's a decision as well the same uh for any staff who are listening the same for the timeline for packing we have that and getting ready to launch that as well as soon as there is a decision right I think that's that's where I'm going to stop tonight but I will revisit my notes tomorrow and update any Q&A um and or reach out to anybody else who I think um had some more questions that maybe I didn't get to so thank you thank you I need a motion no I need a motion to approve the
195official meeting schedule motion second discussion roll roll call M cordella yes M gella yes Mr McCarron yes M barokas yes Dr Osman yes M Rivera yes Mrs Cass Mr Walsh yes excuse me one second everyone we're still conducting some business up here so if you can please take um your parties out to the hallway and continue your conversation so as not to be disruptive to us we would greatly appreciate it thank you very much real quick before you all leave and be we're GNA we're going to do board comments I don't know if anyone wants to listen to us um before we get to all that um just for something a little fun um I do wear a second hat I am the President of the Jackson Education Foundation as well we're having a comedy
196night on February 27th so if you want to come out and support the district we do scholarships for the kids and teacher grants throughout the district so just want to give a shout out to that um you know we want to help the district out as much as we can thank you and we'll start board comments that way um well we're sitting here doing little uh announcements okay seniors scholarships close February 13th make sure you get your applications in online okay another thing I'd like to give a shout out to the girls wrestling team who won the shore conference over the weekend I know this is difficult but we have to remember what our objectives are as a board objective number one is to make sure that our students have the best education possible our
197teachers are going nowhere they may move their classroom listen I T for 25 years in 25 different classrooms it happens you move around okay they're not going anywhere though the best thing that we have are our staff and they're very good I know some people I said about technology before it's a tool it helps okay but it doesn't help if you don't know how to use it and our teachers know how to use it thank you just wanted to thank everybody for coming out tonight and participating in this meeting uh all the emails everybody getting up and speaking we are listening um obviously we're going to come to a decision next meeting thank you hi thanks for hanging around and listening to our closing remarks I just wrote a couple of things down um so
198I just want to point out again you know a a couple of people came up who have younger kids and said you know don't forget about the younger kids and I 100% agree with you with that they are going to be with us longer than our older kids and I I think you have to give some props to the committee who really did think about the younger kids because if you look at that fifth and sixth seventh eighth grade model that's a really really smart model when you only have two grades in a school and the reality is you know my kids were older when covid hit and so um they already had their foundation so they were able to move along pretty well right but you know I have friends who had kids in
199kindergarten first grade second grade and they lost their foundation and so that model of five six in one building 78 and another will really help those learning gaps I really really believe that you know by the time you have to revisit this due to numbers it's a new cohort of kids coming up who didn't have covid in those you know fundamental years so um please don't think that we're not thinking of about the younger kids because that model is really good for that um I also want to comment on you know somebody came up and they said how could we vote how could we have the power to vote if we have kids in the district and I just want to remind people that you voted Us in and gave us this responsibility and the
200reality is if everybody up here didn't vote who has a child or a grandchild in the district you wouldn't have enough people to vote and that's just going to slow your this process even more um so as I said before you know just because we're debating the pros and cons over and over and over again that should be seen as a good thing you wouldn't want us just to sit up here and be like oh this is what we were told so let's just do this right like this is something you really have to think about so yes you know one minute I'm thinking this school the next minute I'm thinking that school but that is a good thing because you're trying to find the gaps and what did you miss and what is the
201best decision for everybody right I'm staying up super late I know all of the people up here are up super late and you know analyzing things and you know as I said at the beginning I my kids are out of the district so we're volunteering our time to make sure it's good for all the people coming up and I think you need to remember that um and then I also want to talk about one other thing um somebody came up and they said you know and I agree with this let's have a plan to fix traffic but I need you to remember that this is not the board who could do that right we're not a traffic board we're here for education and so of course you have to look at you know can you
202get kids to school how long they going to be on the bus and things that have to do with the educational part of it but we agree with you we this town does need to fix traffic we do need the police to to work on that but that's not us so we only could do what we can do and we're all trying to do our best here um but please don't think that because we're questioning things and analyzing things that that's a bad thing also I really don't want people to twist my words I have a legitimate concern about safety safety should always be number one in a school okay I'm I'm I'm in education right I understand that when I go to work it should be number one for students for teachers for administrators
203everyone in that building and so that is not saying that any kid who's currently in a school is not safe but this is going to be a new population of people a larger population of people and so you can't you know a a board and a district can't be naive to the fact that when schools get larger and there's more people there could potentially be more problems and so yes that should be in the conversation as well and that shouldn't insult people right because we should be debating all of the pros and cons before we come and make a decision that at the end of the day when I see my neighbors in shoppr right I could feel like I did the right thing right regardless of which school we chose so that's what we're
204trying to do up here so thank you all for coming and you know supporting us I want to thank everyone for coming viewing us live stream your inputs and comments we all live in one ZIP code there is unnecessary fears of the unknown we need to come together and unification as one Jackson we have a lot of considerations dialog fact findings including state aid actual numbers we also look at the buildings that are you know that are in considerations you know I travel a lot on Hope Chapel Road around Liberty during tier one and I don't see too many traffic concerns during that time my concerns are that gets um building according to the engineers analysis is a tear down and in excess to do the upgrades their multi-million dollars are needed and then the
205transportation Depot that's housed on Liberty campus is newer and also the transportation on department on Don Conor Boulevard needs a complete renovation we are doing the best we can during this critical time and everyone have a wonderful and safe night so someone asked if we you know did we consider the elementary schools and some of the other things believe me none of us wanted to do this we we've asked about closing elementary schools we've asked about combining prek like they didn't how we've asked about can we extend it a whole year right push it out everything that you have thought about we if if besides being up hours and we cry all the time my husband will tell you I up all hours I see I check the emails I'm always looking up information it
206is a it is definitely taking a toll while on all of you is taking a toll on our families um listen I understand graduation is a really big deal like I said I have a daughter he'll be a senior next year of course you want to graduate from the school that you're in anyone have a kid that graduated during Co 8th grade high school they never they never went back to their school they weren't in their school their whole year and they didn't walk across the stage we have a tape at home anyone have family that live in California guess what some of them don't have high school right now to even go to they're happy to be anywhere to be educated so when you email us and when you talk about your own kid
207and while I understand I I have I have empathy for you I do I I get it stop and think about what's going on around you and that other kids are not able to graduate from the schools that they're in it's happened they'll survive and they're going to do really well anyway thanks for coming out it was nice to see everyone and like Tina mentioned I'm the vice president of the Jackson Education Foundation and I'd like to fit fill 120 seats so please sign up and join us on February 27th thank you and have a good night oh sorry did I say J sorry it's been a long night you know I uh mimic a lot of the same sentiment as the board members that have spoken you know the committee did great work they
208came up with an education ational model that really takes into consideration the development of students at every grade level and you know a lot of us are affected in many ways you don't necessarily you might have elected Us in but doesn't mean you necessarily know of our ins and outs and you know it is as the young lady said it's scary when you don't when you're thinking of the unknown and what you don't know um you know we have to shake our head because like Allison said the committee did look at so many different models you know even we might have thrown out things that you're throwing out tonight right to say can we do this and can we do that and what would be the best for the town you know in the end
209consolidation has to happen because we're facing a you know a fiscal issue that none of us can control right things that are out of our control are always out of our control we can we can only do then what's in our control and that's what we're trying to do and we understand that facility matters to a lot of people and you know I get that um in the end I said it before and I'll say it again you know someone along the line is going to be disappointed and someone's going to be happy and that's just what's going to happen in life right some days we're happy and some days we're disappointed and you know there are concerns you know it it's tough cuz we have looked at every single piece of data you know
210and there's really respectable people coming up to tell us a lot of data and then they throw us a sucker punch like we haven't looked you know I've read a traffic support report 700 times I'm not going to sit here here and tell you what I feel on the report because I feel like in the end you know we have to drive in a town and Jackson's not the same town it was 25 years ago you know I drove over there at 3:45 and it's like Bricktown you know and it's not really what everybody's used to um does that mean it's right or wrong no I just feel like in the end right everybody in this town from I feel in the meetings that I was in you know I think that the police are
211feeling the same typee of pressures that we feel you know they're dealing with their own constraints you know and again here we are you know feeling the pressure of their own constraints that's my personal opinion and you know I just want all of our kids to have great experiences and I think parents write the narrative and adults write the narrative and you know the narrative was a lot better tonight so thank you um you know because it did give us some things to think about and I appreciate it I wrote down some questions to ask and thank you for your participation tonight um I just want to thank everyone for coming to speak as well and um I I did the same thing I think I wrote some things down there were a few things
212that are running through my head from things um that some of you had said out there a few things that maybe I didn't think of or that I just was like oh I I need to ask that question kind of a thing um again we are all taking this very seriously um we're all looking at Unity um when I look at my decisions I mean I'm I'm looking at the fiscal responsibility I'm looking at the sustainability I'm looking at the longevity and I'm also looking at the facilities so um we will have a vote on the 19th we all know that we have to we um we talked about how that works if if there is something that we need to change or we don't agree with so we we have a process for that
213so um there's seven of us so even let's just say it's not agreed there's it's four and three that's why they're seven so there will be a vote on the 19th um so and the the last thing that I have to say um is just the word Unity is in community so pay attention to that okay and everyone have a good night thank you can I have a motion to close motion by by acclamation oh I need a second by acclamation