CorpusRecord 59336

02-18-25 Manalapan-Englishtown Board Of Education Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Manalapan-Englishtown Schools
Date
2025-02-20
Location
Monmouth County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,019 words · about 56 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Mr. Ferber, here. Mr. Green, here. Mr. Ferber, here. Mr. Ng, here. Mr. Lucas, here. Mr. Feretti, here. Dr. Wallace, Joe Chalkley, Dr. Luxley, good evening. From the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. We are going to have some session, if anyone has any questions related to the HIV summaries. If not, we're going to skip. I don't believe anyone does. The street that you live on. I was filming in a bus zone on Bridge Drive. In November, my teacher went out on an unexpected leave of absence and a substitute teacher was provided for the students. However, it was not a special education teacher and my son has a and in his IP, it states that he should be educated

002by a special teacher. So I reached out to the child study team. I reached out to the supervisor of special education to ask about compensatory services since my son was just given worksheets. I excel at puzzles. There's 75 minutes a day, five days a week for nobody giving an official time when his teacher was out. So I'm going to assume it was a month and a half. Possibly, right, because of the holidays. So I reached out as a concerned parent, I'm a special educator myself, asking CST to at least try to find out what kind of topics they would be covering so that I know what's going on with my son. But I was told to just check Google Classroom and be complete by itself. So I wasn't satisfied with that response. I continued on

003and I asked additional information. Nobody was able to provide me any information. I got pretty much just a Band-Aid over the issue and then I was told that he's not entitled to compensatory services because of the data, which I respected. However, they are not able to provide me with any data. What kind of data? Give me somewhere improved. Give me some tests. You could be doing worksheets every day. So as far as I'm concerned, there is no data. If the district can provide you with data, proving that he's not entitled to these services, then I will be comfortable with that. But I'm just curious, as a ward, as a district, what are we doing for these children? Are we hoping that they're not going home and telling their parents that they don't have a special

004education teacher? What are we doing for them? Because these are children that need services. They're children that cannot be. And I was told to take and join ESY in the summer. So I'm going to leave you with this. If somehow payroll totally took an unexpected leave of absence from your job, then you were not able to be paid for one month. And then they said to you, I'm so sorry. You can come back in June, and we'll give you your payback. Would you be satisfied with that? Because I'm not. My son shouldn't have to wait five months to be compensated for services that he's entitled to. So this district is not providing a pretty appropriate education. I believe that the teacher is special education certified. That was in the classroom. I was told they were

005not. Okay. We will double-check on that when we get back to you, but I'm pretty sure. And as far as the data, I think you asked for about an hour and a half ago. No, actually, I've been asking about it since November. I just CC'd you on the email last week because the team is not getting back to you with the data. Okay, so I will follow up on that as well. Yes, please, because they're not following up on that. That's why I started CC'ing you on the email. I know you're busy. You have a whole district to run. And this is just one minor issue. This is minor. But I know in the special education teacher process, if I'm trying to reach out and giving them the respect, right, if I went straight to

006you, that would be perceived as me going over the head, and I don't want to do that. So I'm giving them the respect, but just telling me because I said so, right, because the data proves it, because of the measures, that's fine. But you need to put that in writing. What data are we talking about? There is no data. Okay, we'll follow up on that. Thank you. We have a couple of teachers out in the lead, so I just need to verify who her child is. You don't need to tell me over the mic. Oh, the one teacher, if it is who I am thinking, that teacher is certified as a special educator. Right. And my son is still doing word sheets every day without instruction. Matter of fact, in one occasion, we were told

007to please sit down because he was having those conversations about credit cards. Okay, we'll follow up. Thank you. Okay. Is there anyone else that would like to come to my phone? Three minutes if you'd like to speak. Mr. Graham. Brian Graham. I'm from New Jersey. So I saw on the agenda tonight that you folks are abolishing policy number 5756, and I wanted to come tonight and support you and thank you for staying the course with the state, with your attorneys, and making sure that, you know, what this board and the previous board over the last few years tried to get done. So certainly, like seeing this here on the agenda, I'm glad that you're going to abolish it, because parents do deserve the right to be informed of many of these types of decisions. I'm

008not sure I would agree on it if it was a, if it were a high school district, but certainly dealing with younger kids better, kindergarten, first, second, third, fourth, fifth grade, faculty, parents should be involved. And I think there are other items that hopefully this board will address in the future regarding parental involvement that I will not bring up tonight, but I will certainly reach out to the president, on my thoughts on another topic that I think parents need to be more involved in where they're not. I'll say that one for another day, and I wish you all a very good evening. So thank you. Thank you. We appreciate the support. Anyone else? Last call, going on twice. Okay. Public comments. There's now changes in revisions. Do we have any self-deb? No, Felicia has sent

009you guys an email maybe around 2-33 o'clock about some policies. There was nothing after that. Item E, can I get a motion and a second on items E-123? Any questions on items E-123? So the district regulations updates are for the board's information, but then in item F, we're already done with them? In item E, it's the right division, yes. It's in both places. Will the regulations be in both places? Yes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. In item E, it's the right division, yes. It's in both places. Will the regulations be in the policy? Yes. Thank you, Felicia. Any regrets? Well, should they arise, it's going to be at the discretion of the administrators. There is no... It's dealing with every situation that they arise and treating it individually. We're comfortable and confident that

010this policy is not needed, and if anything, creates more confusion and potentially adds problems that do not exist. This endeavor... As a district, we will resolve handbinding. For getting us here, I also want to say, without consulting, and again, I... Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. I enact business. There's G-1 through G-7. Yes. Yes. In particular, the foundation would like to... Yes. Just to start off, basically, it was put in place really to the administrative team knew what to do or not to do so that you didn't misstep. And it was to keep the confidence of your community for giving these seats that pay you lots and lots of money. So, the School Ethics Act, these are the minimum ethical standards that you're expected to abide by. That does not mean that you can't be more

011ethical. That's always greatly appreciated. I promise I won't spill the water. So, when you look at the School Ethics Act, there's four different areas. The two on the right, the prohibited acts and disclosure statements, are actually applicable to all board members, as well as the administrators that are in the district that hold the superintendent cert or a business administrator cert or a principal certification, which is your principal's assistant principal. And the two on the left are the code of ethics and mandatory training. They're only applicable to all board members. So, as board members, you actually have four areas that you're responsible for, whereas your administrative team only has six. It does not mean that your administrative team is not being ethical and following the code of ethics, because they are. But they're not required to

012do the mandatory training. So, who enforces the act? It's the School Ethics Commission, which is supposed to be made up of nine people. For many years now, after two years, two and a half years, it's only been made up of six. They have not filled all the seats. The two school board members' seats, both seats, are currently vacant, and the one school administrator's seat is currently vacant. That becomes important when you're talking about six, because in order for an advisory opinion to be made public, they need to have a vote of six people of the nine that are voting to say, yes, this has a part which you need to have. So, as we all know, we have meetings. Not everybody shows up. So, when they have their meetings, they don't have all six sometimes.

013So, sometimes when there's only five or less, even if something that comes before them as an advisory opinion has a far-reaching impact, or they believe it does, they cannot make that advisory opinion public, because they did not have enough people. So, as part of this, you do have the financial disclosure statements. These go, if you're a brand new board member, you have 30 days from the date that you're sworn in. Not the date that you're elected. It's the date that you're actually sworn in. And for all other people, it's actually April 30th of every year. Every district does this differently. Some will do it in, like, December, January. Others will wait until, like, you know, February, March, April to remind you. These are generally done through an email. You get the notification. You fill it

014out. It's not asking you how much money you made. It's just asking where your funds have come from. So, as a board member, you have to do mandatory training. There's four years' worth of it for the terms. So, as we all know, board members are generally on a three-year term. So, your very first time you've been elected as a board member, you have 90 days to complete governance one. And that is basically giving you the foundational knowledge that you need to do the ground running as a board member. For year two, any time during your second year as a board member, you are going to complete governance two, which is finance and policy. That's what it's going to focus on, giving you all that information that you need because board members generally do a lot

015of policy work. And as we all know, finance is so important in order for a district to run. By the end of year three, now you're starting to get into student achievement, because that's what we're here for, the students, and also labor or negotiations. Because at some point during your time as being on the board, your board is going to be involved in negotiations, whether it be with your education association or your principal supervisor association or some other group that you might have within the district. Every time you're re-elected, then you have to take governance four, and that's your legal updates. At any point, you can take governance four, but you will have to do it again every time you're re-elected. So some people will do governance one, and they'll also do governance four, because

016they want to hear all the legal information. I'm one of those nerds. I like all the legal bases, so I actually enjoy listening to all of that. All of these trainings are offered both in-person, by virtual, and also pre-recorded. You can kind of do your own self-case, do it at your own pace at your own time. So advisory opinions, as I said before, and the SEC can receive something, a request from a school official requesting to know whether something that they're thinking of doing before they do it, it would be an error, if they would be doing something wrong. They can ask for that advisory opinion from the SEC, and then they will let them know what the outcome of it is. If they feel that it has a far-reaching impact, and that would be

017something that people across the state would be interested in, they make those advisory opinions public. But once again, you need to have at least six people that vote to say yes to it. So we had somebody that asked, well, if it's an advisory opinion, do I really need to abide by what is being told in that advisory opinion? You kind of do, even though it's called an opinion. It's basically, if you think about it, we say it's like a police officer. The police officer pulls you over, and you're speeding, and they say, you know what, this is a 25-mile-per-hour zone, and you were doing 40. I let you go, but if I catch you again, I'm going to stick you. That's his opinion, right? He's giving you the advice. You go and you speed again,

018they pull you over again. What do you think is going to happen? You're going to get a ticket, or worse. So yes, you really should abide by those advisory opinions, because if you've requested one, and they've given you what their ruling is on it, and then you go and do something against what they told you not to do, then if somebody files an ethics complaint against you, you will probably lose, and you will probably have some serious consequences as a result. So I'm not going to go through all the cases, but once again, I do find them interesting, and these are sort of little blurbs for those cases, but if you read the actual cases, because lawyers do like to write a lot, these cases tend to be multiple pages, anywhere from, say, three to,

019like, 20. But they give you a lot more information, and so you kind of understand why they made the decision that they made in most cases. Sometimes you're so abstract in your head and saying why they decided to do that. But I'm just going to point out two of them. The first one is A1424. So when you see A, that means advisory. When you see a different, and I'll show you that, too, the C, that means it was an ethics complaint. So, and A is advisory. So the first one is to review the resume of their candidates before voting on the superintendent's recommendation. So basically, in that case, the board member wanted to review all the applicants that the superintendent had received before they could actually cast their vote. That's not your role as a

020board. As a board member, your job is to look at the candidate that the superintendent's recommending and saying, is this a viable candidate? Not a whole board. The second one, A1324, I'm pointing out, because in another slide, that case is going to come up. But in that case, what happened was somebody, a board member in the district, had a family member relative that was not, that was in a position, but it was not in the union position. So in other words, it was called a non-aligned, meaning that they weren't operating under a contract. So they wanted to know, could they still participate in negotiations, and the answer was no. And the reason for that is because if you look at any contract, chances are there's a direct correlation between even the non-aligned and the aligned.

021If the aligned get a 3% base, chances are the non-aligned are also going to get about a 3% base. So unless you can tell, or the person can demonstrate there is no correlation between the two, there is no direct connection, you cannot be involved in negotiations. And I'll show you when we get to the chart in a little bit. So looking at this one, if you go down to the second one, and this is on another slide as well, so A0524, that was, somebody had received an endorsement from the local union. They wanted to know, is that going to create problems for them? The answer is no, an endorsement in and of itself does not create a problem. However, if you do receive financial contributions, that could impact you, and it could cause you not

022to be able to be involved in certain things. If you do get a financial contribution, you should contact your court attorney, explain the situation to him or her, and let them give you the guidance on what you should or shouldn't do. And then the two down from that, that one, AO224, that was an employee, and you're seeing this more and more in the school districts where somebody was working in the school, and they got terminated for whatever reason, then they won't run for the board, and they say, hey, I'm going to run for the board, I'm going to fix that superintendent, because they got rid of him. So they wanted to be then involved in the evaluation of the superintendent's contract. They're considered conflicted, so therefore they were not allowed to be part of that.

023So if you're someone who knows somebody, or you're one of those people who got on the board for that reason, realize that you're managing to be tied for a lot of things. So an ethics complaint, when somebody feels, and it can be anybody, it can be anybody in your community, it can be somebody outside of your community, where they feel that you as a board member have broken one of the tenets, the code of ethics, they can actually file an ethics complaint against you, and they have 180 days to do that. So anything that happened prior to 180 days, they cannot file an ethics complaint against you, but they have to provide evidence. And so when we go through each one of them, I'll break down with it so you can see what they have

024to do. It's not just them filling out a form and saying, I think Joe Smith had an ethics violation, and I think you should go and investigate. They actually have to give a lot more details to it, as well as the evidence to prove their point. The person that it's filed against, you are notified that so-and-so filed an ethics complaint against you, what the claim is that you violated and you're given the actual evidence that the person submitted, you then have a time period to respond to that, provide your own evidence in response to it, and then the ethics commission has heard both sides of it, they will make the determination whether there was a violation or not. So if the ethics commission finds out that you did have a violation, they make that determination,

025then there's four different penalties that can happen. The first one is a reprimand, which if you think about it, it's like a slap on the wrist. They're telling you, you did something wrong, don't do it again. The second one is a censure, which means that as a board, you actually have to pass a resolution that identifies the person and the tenant or tenants that the person violated. And then the board has to approve that resolution, so it's very public. The third one is a suspension, where the SEC will say, you as a board member cannot be on board for this amount of time. It could be 30 days, 60 days, it could be a year. That's whatever they determine based upon what the problem is. And then the fourth one is a removal, where they'll

026say you can no longer be a board member and you're immediately removed from the board. These are the tenants, and the paper that was handed out actually has a nice copy of it there for you. There's also a sign-off sheet. Some districts will use it, some don't. Your VA can tell you whether she needs it or not. Some districts will reflect that to if this date comes in, and they say, hey, did you do ethics training? Besides showing the minutes or the agendas, they can actually then show all the sign-off sheets. So you do that. So the first one is basically that you have to uphold and enforce all the laws, rules, and regulations. As I always say, you might not like the law, rule, or regulation, but you still have to follow it. So

027that's your first one. Now when you look at the top part, that comes from a statute that's called 18A. That's the tenant that you're expected to abide by. The bottom part where you see standards, that comes from 6A, which is code. So that's the factual evidence that if somebody feels that you violated that tenant, they have to provide that factual evidence to prove it when they file the ethics complaint. So when you take your time and you read through these, you can kind of see there's a lot of information there, and they actually have to produce something if they're going to file a complaint against you. The next one is that basically you're here for the students, and every decision that you make has to be in the best interest of all the students within

028your district. Not just ones you like, maybe those ones you might not like as much, but it's for all students that are in your district. The next one is that you are confined to basically three main areas, which is policy-making, planning, and appraisal. Appraisal being the superintendent, planning being your district goals, you could be your strategic plan, and policy art as you're all aware are the things that you create that helps the district to understand when a situation is presented what they have to do. Your job as a board member is not to run the schools. You hire the superintendent and the superintendent has a team, that's their job to run the schools. And I would say if you ask the question and you say, if it's a what question, then your chances are you're

029doing well as a board, that means you're doing what you're supposed to do. That's not running the school. Once you start to say how, that means you've stepped over the line and you're actually running the schools. So, for example, if you said, you know, we want, we would like more enrichment opportunities for students within extracurricular activities. Great. That's pretty broad, it's not specific. It's a superintendent's job, that's a what, it's a superintendent's job to turn around and say, okay, well I want, in order to do that, what you want, I'm going to create X, Y, and Z and they'll identify the programs that they're going to create, so on and so forth. If you step over and you say, well I want you to have this, that means you've now stepped over. Okay, so that's

030one area where people do, as board members do step over the line, you see a lot of ethics complaints in this area. A big one is you cannot make personal promises nor take any private action. In other words, if somebody from the community comes up to you and says, hey, I have this concern, it's not your job as a board member to turn to them and say, don't worry, I'll take care of that. Once you say you're doing that, you're basically running the schools. So you can go back to the previous tenant, but you're also violating this one as well. So you can never make any promises. Remember, you are, your team is the only one that comes together to actually take action on anything. You as an individual board member cannot do that. You

031also cannot make any promises or do anything for special interest groups or any political groups. Remember, as a school board, we are a political, meaning we're not involved in politics. We are only focused on the one thing, which is our students. And to me, this is probably the most important tenant, which is confidentiality. You are, as board members, you are privy to a lot of information that the public is not. That's one of the reasons why you have executive session, because those are things that you cannot discuss in public. You have to do an executive session. That information has to be kept confidential. So you have to abide by that. Same thing as with any kind of private communication from the superintendents. All of you, some based upon what's in there, that will be private

032as well. You're also, your job is to appoint the best qualified personnel, which means the superintendent is going to make a recommendation to you. Your decision to vote yes or no should not be arbitrary or capricious. You have to look at the tenant that's being put before you and vote hoping that you're going to put in the best person in the position. And then your job is also to support the tech school personnel and the proper performance of their duties. As I always say, never say anything nasty about any of your staff members. Even if they haven't done something right, let's say they were even arrested for something. Do not make any comments, because that means that you're not supporting them. And you also don't have to come out and say, yeah, they got arrested

033and we're going to support them. Don't say that either. In other words, be silent. It's not your job to raise any staff members either. The only person that's doing that is your superintendent. So that's your job is to simply support the personnel so that they can do the best they can for your students. And then you're going to refer all complaints to the chief school administrator or your superintendent. It's not your job to fix. When somebody comes to you with a complaint, refer them back to the chain of command, say, hey, this is who you want to go see, and then let the superintendent know that so-and-so came to you with this concern, and then that's it. Your job as a board member is done on that. Let the superintendent handle it. Let the superintendent

034figure out the resolution. So as I said, I'm not going to go through all cases, but this, once again, again, I sent this to your superintendent. If she hasn't already, she'll email it out to you. It's a PDF. Each one of these is hyperlinked, so if you click on it, it'll bring up those cases. So when you look at this first one, these are the code of ethics. As a board member, the staff member felt, the board member felt that the staff member was personally attacking them at board meetings, and they basically called the principal and told them, get your staff member under control. They should be coming out of the board meeting to blast me out of the board table. Keep in mind, as a board, you will be blasted out of the community.

035That's just the reality. And as part of that community, sometimes that is staff members. They will come out and they will blast you, especially during negotiations. If it's a contentious negotiation, you will have staff members that will come here and they comment. Your job is not to try to control them coming here and speaking. They have a right to do that. You have to grin and bear it and take it. But listen, so in this case, the board member was censured. So when you see the word censure or the point below that recommended, and it's not saying recommended, it just says what it was, what the penalty was. That means that it's gone through both levels. Every time there's an ethics complaint, the first level is always the school ethics commission. They will make a

036recommendation. So they could say recommended censure. That means that they've decided based upon the information that they've received, this is their recommendation for penalty. It then goes to the commissioner of education. The commissioner of education reviews everything. They make the final decision. So when you don't see recommended, that means that it's been through both levels. So in these two cases that you see here, it's been through the SEC and it's been through the commissioner of education. The case below that, the board member, and like I said, sometimes you read these cases and you say, what were the people thinking? Where does common sense come in? So you had a board member that was really going to the other board member to try to get them to reverse an HIV decision that was for their child.

037So you as a board member, as you know, sometimes you're not aware of who the person is that's being brought up on the HIV charge. Sometimes it's just student numbers in some districts they will use. So when that happens, you might not know that it's your child that is being discussed. Once you realize it, get out of the board. Get out of that executive session. Let the board handle it. If your child is involved in an HIV case, do not talk to the other board members about it, because that's what happened in this case. So this is where I say common sense. This next case, the teacher was to be discussed in the executive session, so it was a personnel matter. A board member ended up sending a text message to the teacher, that's not

038your job. There's mechanisms in place to notify staff members when they're being discussed in the executive session, price notices, so on and so forth. So don't overstep that line like this person did here. And in this case, a board member took inappropriate action that was beyond the role of the board member. And like I said, there's going to be a lot of cases where when you read them, it will be people overstepping and doing the wrong things. So in this case, a board member took it upon himself to go to the employee's home, pick up a letter, present it on behalf of the employee, to direct it to the VA, not to give a letter to the superintendent. Right there, they're circumventing the superintendent. So it gives you an idea that, you know, just do

039what you're supposed to do, nothing more than that. In this case, the board member recorded an endorsement video for a state of three school board candidates that referenced the board, and the members positioned on it while wearing a school identification badge. You as a board member have to make sure that if you're speaking, we'll talk about that in a second, but if you're speaking as a community member, that there's no reference to you as a board member. In any way, shape, or form, and anything you're talking about has nothing to do with board business. You're welcome to endorse candidates that are running for the board, but you should not be doing it as a board member. So we will talk about how you should be using the slangers and all of that, because if somebody

040sees that, they're going to think that endorsement is on behalf of your speaking for the board and everybody in the board does the same way. Not necessarily the case. So that would be what that case is about. So you have refusal and abstention. You abstain on agenda items when you do not have enough information. So let's say, for example, you're recruiting the minutes from the previous coordinating, and you were not present for that. That's a perfect time to abstain. You do not abstain because it's a hot button issue, and you just don't want to be known as what you voted, so you say abstain. Don't do that. You're not doing your job as a board member. So you should either be voting when you have enough information, regardless of which way you're voting, or you

041abstain when you don't have enough information. Recusal means, even if you wanted to vote, you can't, because you're complaining. So it could be maybe you're voting on contracts, because we're going to talk about contracts in a minute, but let's say you're voting on a teacher's contract. You may be found to be conflicted, so therefore you cannot vote on it. So instead of saying abstention, then the public thinks you don't have enough information on your contract. You say, I'm accused from this, because then that tells them that you did have enough information, or as much information as you're supposed to have, but you're not legally allowed to vote on it. These aren't just a list of prohibited acts, so you can read through them at your leisure. These are all the things that you, if any

042of these are opposed to you, you should be recusing yourself. Benefit is not just what you believe is a benefit, it's also a belief of the perception of the community. So even though you say, I'm not benefiting from whatever the agenda item is or the action, if you think, or anyone thinks that the community might believe you are benefiting from it, that's a great time for not being involved in that one and recusing yourself. Like I said, I'm not going to go through all the cases, but these are two more conflict cases, where there's a conflict of interest, and so in both of these, you can read them. They're interesting. Relationship definitions, in the three papers that you were given, there's a nice sheet there that lists all possible relationships and how it could impact

043you as a board member, especially with negotiations and other things that you could be involved in. But this is not from New Jersey school boards, this is actually from an advisory opinion that was requested, so it's AO 623, and so that's where that chart came from. So just realize your relatives, as much as you might like them or not like them, they can create conflicts for you in your role as a board member. So you may, as a board member, you may already have family members or relatives that are working in the district, that's okay, but once you become a board member, you cannot hire anyone from your family who you don't know. There is a rare case where that does happen, and let's say, for example, it's really, really difficult to fill a position,

044and only one person applied and it happened to be your relative or relative of the superintendent. In that case, the superintendent can reach out to the executive county superintendent and make a request for a waiver, a one-time waiver to consider hiring this person. The executive county superintendent will provide your superintendent the directions on what they expect the process to be moving forward, they might ask you to advertise it again, and so on and so forth, but they're the ones who can actually grant that waiver. So it doesn't happen often, so that's why it says limited exceptions, but for the most part assume that once you're a board member, you cannot hire anyone else in your family or any relative. So collective bargaining agreements. So this is the one where I had said about the relative

045that is working in a non-aligned position, meaning a non-union position. So when you look at the first two on this chart, if you look at it in both cases, immediate family member or relative. Yes, they work in the district. In the top one, in that case, they're not aligned. In the second one, they are in a union position. You look over to the right and it says for that top one, participate in negotiations, yes, but there's an asterisk there. And the reason why it's yes is because if the individual can prove, the board member can prove, that there's no connection between the existing contracts and the contract that their family member or relative has received, then they actually can participate in negotiations. But that's not your decision to make. That's where you will share that

046with your board attorney, and the board attorney will make that determination. Otherwise, everyone falls into the second one, which means if you have a family member that's working in the district, you cannot participate in negotiations and you cannot vote to ratify the contract. When you look at the next set of boxes, it's yourself, the relationship to the board member, yourself, or immediate family member, you do not work in the district, however, you do work in another district. So you're seeing, once again, a lot more of this where you will see administrators or teachers that work in another district, but they're sitting on the board here. In that case, you cannot be, since you're part of the union, you cannot be involved in negotiations. And if you say, well, why is that? It doesn't really impact

047them. It does. Because what happens is, during negotiations, the NJEA will look at settlements in other districts, and they will use those as part of those negotiations. The same thing happens with principal supervisor association. PSA will do the exact same thing. They will look at settlement agreements, and they will use that as leverage. If you're on this board, and you really want, because you know that's going to happen, if you can get a good contract here, don't kid yourself. NJA or PSA are going to use the settlements here for your district back home where you're actually working, and they're going to say, hey, look at the settlements here. That's why you can't be involved in negotiations. But you can kind of see that in that case you can actually vote to ratify the contract. Why?

048Because all the terms of the agreement are already ironed out. And so therefore, if you were just voting that, yeah, I'm going to vote for this because I know what it is now. And then the last one is basically, all those board members who do not work in the district, they are obviously not part of a department agreement, and so therefore they're the ones that can participate in negotiations. I was in one district where they had nine board members, five of them all worked in another district, and so none of them, five of the nine could not participate in negotiations. So it was locked up to the four new ones who were all brand new, never negotiated, and they were all hopefully that doesn't happen in your district but realize it is happening. This once

049again refers back to that other case which is campaigns and collective bargaining. If you receive financial contributions from an endorsement, that can actually knock you out of negotiations for that first year. I'll go through this, but these are the top cases in Monmouth County case, but it just goes to show you that as a board member, if you have a relative working in the district, it can actually impact you on your committee assignments. Whether you're a one of the on it committee, whether you're on a chair committee, or even if you're a board resident and you're the one who gets to select who's on what committee. It can impact all of those. This one is the advice of council defense. So a lot of times a board member when a case is brought forward will

050say, yeah, but I followed the board attorney's advice. And that very well may be true, but it has to hit all four of those there. And if you look at that, it has to be the approval or the advice that was received prior to the action. So in other words, you as a board member can't do something wrong and then turn to your board attorney and say, ooh, I might have misstepped. What do you think? And they say, you're good, okay, but you already did. So it's after the fact. So it has to be something that you're requesting before you actually do something wrong. The individual will offer the advice of approval, rely upon possessed authority or responsibility. In other words, that's the board attorney who's approved and you're allowed to actually ask the board

051attorney that, not just any attorney. So some people, some board members will turn and say, yeah, but I asked, you know, because Joe is an attorney and he's an education attorney and he told me this. No, it has to be your board attorney. All pertinent facts and circumstances are fully disclosed. In other words, you can't give the full story. You can't give just the details that you want to give. You have to give everything. And then the individual actually has to comply with the advice that received. So your board attorney may have told you what you should do and you may not have followed it. So you have to be able to approve all four of those before you can use the advice of counsel defense if you're brought up on a case. Volunteering in

052school as a board member, you can absolutely volunteer in school. You just want to really watch how often and how involved you are with that volunteering. And also in that volunteering position if you have the impression that you have authority over anyone, you have to give any directions to anyone or direct, it looks like you're bossing or managing staff members because that's not your role. It's also a great opportunity to never handle money. So think about you can be in the PTA, you just can't let go of the money. You can't be the treasurer of it. It's not a good idea because somebody can have the belief that you're pocketing some of that money. Not that you are, but it's that impression. Everything is about impression. So these are just, once again, case about it

053with volunteering in school. And then social media. So when you're posting on social media, it's always going to come down to whether it's an ethics violation based upon content, substance, and contents. So every case is going to look at those three areas. And so you have to make sure that what you're posting does not have to do with poor business. And that when you're posting it, are you even approved to actually speak on behalf of the poor? Because you are a poor member, everyone in your community knows you're a poor member. And if you're posting on poor business, they're going to think that what's being said or posted is what is the belief that everyone on the poor. Social media, and it happens to be about poor business or you think it could possibly be

054related to poor business, then you should use the disclaimer. Now that disclaimer is over on the left-hand side. It's just a simple statement that you write. It does not have to be verbatim, but this is the one that's suggested by the SEC. So if you change it, make sure you have not changed it where you lost the essence of what it's saying. Don't just use part of it, you have to use the whole thing. So this is just a Q&A on when you're looking at social media. Basically, if you use the disclaimer, does that automatically get you out of trouble? No, because it's going to come down to the content of what you actually posted. The context and the substance. If you don't use the disclaimer, are you going to get in trouble? No, because

055it's still going to come down to the context and substance. So you get the idea that this is a Q&A for that. And for social media, if you're a brand new board member or you ran and you re-elected and you used a social media account or webpage or whatever might be a social media page where that was your platform that you had posted on, once you become a board member, you should not be posting on that campaign page anymore. Because anything that you ran under, we all know that people run whatever their platform is and they say, for this purpose, people can read that page even though it's a prior post and then think, once again, that impression that what you posted is what the whole board believes. So you should stop using that page.

056And I had a board member tell me, yeah, it took me a lot of work to get all those followers. I understand that. But this is not me saying it. If you look, that was an ethics complaint. So that was a finding from an ethics claim saying you should not be using those pages. So it just gives an idea that this is very serious for you. Once again, when you're posting, make sure the account itself doesn't say that you're a board member. You want to make sure it's you as a personal individual, not as a board member. And also, if you're an administrator, we have some board members who actually are administrators of those social media pages, you want to make sure that you're no longer the administrator. Because anything that goes on that page,

057you can then be held viable for it. We always like to say thank you for all you do as board members. I know you don't get paid to do this. The community might not realize that. But you put in a lot of time and effort, and you're doing it all for the students of the district. Any questions? I really do look at the PDF that was sent on the links. The cases are really interesting. Hopefully you'll enjoy it. Thank you again, Dr. Tien. I appreciate it. Thank you for the presentation, and thank you to Melissa again. I did go up two, so I'm good for this year. So, it was very informative and having this right after it. So, thank you. Do you want to make sure that we recognize and take care of them?

058What we're currently offering right now was brought to us as a possibility through the State Department of Child Nutrition. We work through an application process, it's called non-common feeding arrangement. Typically, we have to feed them in a group setting. They made an exception for this. If something were to come along from the State Department of Culture or Child Nutrition that provided for an opportunity for any other faith or religion to do the same, of course, we could jump right on that. So, is this a state-paid program? All it's doing is allowing the children to take lunch home at the end of the day instead of eating it in school during the day. And these children normally have free or reduced lunch? If they're paid free, whatever their income status is, I mean, if a student

059is a paid student, their lunch account will be charged for it. It's not free. It's just offering them to have a meal to take home instead of eating it in school. Thank you. Appreciate the clarification. Thank you. Just quickly, I've been trying to follow the bill that's school funding formula and it says that there's a 2% reduction would be compared to your last year's budget. Do we know anything more about it? We're requiring a review. It's very unclear to me if anyone is missing. I wanted to talk about that, but we did get an update about... numbers are coming from two days after the governor's budget address which is the fourth Tuesday in February, so that Thursday we're going to have a state-aid number. That will be the first time we actually see actual numbers.

060As far as looking at the funding formula, I do believe that there needs to be a little more transparency. What we got today is something we've never gotten, ever, and it said basically school districts can anticipate that total K-12 state aid will not decrease by any amount greater than 3%. So even though that doesn't sound like a lot, because we still don't know if it's flagged more or less, at least we have a bottom figure, and we've never had that before. So for our district, we receive a little over $9 million in state aid, but we're $9 million, so 3% is not that much. Our state aid should not increase more than $272,600. So at least, I think last week, insurance, we expect a social deficit. We haven't shared with you yet, but right now,

061it is normal for everything. And I just want to say at the Mount County meeting a couple of weeks ago, Senator Vinico Powell was a guest speaker and he is really pushing for transparency on that formula that school districts should know exactly what the formula is and how it's going to impact the districts specifically. So he's really pushing for that transparency. So hopefully you'll have the exact formula at some point moving forward. So which I did, and you know, we look at we're building a budget now that doesn't go into effect for another almost, there's a whole 12 months after that. We don't know how many special ed students might move in during that, how many special ed students the health benefit increases are because it's a major increase. A lot of unknowns, even if

062we were to know stadium numbers, there's still a lot of, and we try to budget conservatively. I do have a few things. As a district, we regularly re-evaluate our programs to see if we can make any improvements. Most recently, we determined that it may be of interest to redistrict the section of town from Taylor Mills to Lafayette Mills. We are going to be discussing this at a board meeting on March 18th, at our March 18th board meeting. I don't know if this may affect ahead of time. Welcome to attend this meeting and to hear what we're proposing on the board and what we're considering, and that whoever it would affect would be absolutely invited to that meeting to share their thoughts. The primary reason for this is that's equity, safety, and operational. The referendum committee

063is meeting this week to go over something we're really going to be discussing with them and looking at, where and how we can offer them. That's something that we're going to be going. We've actually started the big product, a little bit more to where we're at. Matt, Ronnie, do you want to share where we're at? Yeah. We started last week. We had a meeting. Specifically, what we do is we have a meeting that's interested in specifications as a chance for them to come. The attorney general of the architectural leads it. New roads construction is there as well, answering questions. We started out last week with paving. Yesterday we had roofing, and today we had an HF project. Some of them are multiple phases, phase one, phase two, package one, package two, throughout this particular phase.

064The work hopefully will be done this summer. I know there's going to be a lot of coordination of contractors because there will be, and some sites will have all three things going on at once, roofing, paving, and HF, which is wonderful. Actually, you mentioned that we may try to adjust some of the programs that we do offer this summer to have the least amount of impact on students that are involved in those programs. We'll have bid openings the first week and second week in March with hopeful that's the goal. We want to try and get them done so they can get their orders in place, that they can, you know, there's a long wait time that is going to dictate whether or not we can fully complete the projects during the summer, mostly on the

065HF. Also, that could filter down and have an impact on costs. We won't know until the bids are open, but we'll hope for the projections that the architects have developed. They did have some built-in contingencies and we have to do with that. When we obtain the bids, we'll be construction specialists and review them. Sure. The board had mentioned that they wanted to talk about preschool. Do you want to have that conversation? Yeah, why not? So, right now our preschool cutoff date is 9-1. It talks about moving it to 10-1. Administration is considering the date primarily for two-year-olds. We don't get state funding at this time to make sure we provide inclusive population. So, down to two, it changes that time. I know that it says always a month. The two-year-old, the month of the two-year-old

066is a big difference. As I shared with people, our ELC has population currently being special needs or ESF, multi-language learners, and two-year-olds. So, if we're able to, then we'd have to change the cutoff dates to 10-1, and then we would also get state funds to three weeks of grace. That's when the law requires us to provide services. So, if we open up the general ed program to two-year-olds, we would obviously have to do that for special ed, and the two options would be to not provide them with the services they need at two, or provide them with the services at our expense, because the state doesn't mandate us to provide the services until their grade. So, at this time, we would like to hold off. We have reached out to the parent that spoke at

067the board meeting, and we offer a compromise. Anyone that's born in September can still apply to the program. Once they apply, they will be put on a wait list based on where they felt in the general lottery. So, we take the lottery, if they're the first name on the lottery, then they'll be the first person we call to see if their child is discussing changing it further on. Was that an accommodation that you can put in place, right? Yes. Well, not just for that one parent? No, we did it for everyone. So, now we're going to hold that. So, essentially, it does kind of slide the dates of time one with the contingency that if they make it into the lottery, they still can't start until they actually turn three years old. And see those

068dates. September 18th, 15th, whatever. And I see that's open up for sure. Okay. The gentleman that spoke brought up a very good point about only that one being the one that doesn't fit in. But if we had a universal free average, we don't every other child would be able to go for two years and they would only be able to pay another surrounding rose. We are looking to do that. In order to redo that, in a community where we would basically other things, and we could lose their hiring practices. We would just be paying bills. We would be responsible for their safety and well-being without actually being in charge of hiring. And Jesse, we've sat on all the grant workshops. So, those are valid points. And also, they give you a very small window of

069time. You may not find out until August, mid to end August, that your approved end program has to go into effect for October. You know, I understand that. I'm just on a September birthday, right? Like, they graduated. I know it's apples and oranges. I mean, and I'm sure that like we broke down that it's 48 families with every district, right? Like, how many people entering the lottery fall on that one to September 30th birthday? As a day for preschool, I know that it's mind-boggling to me that four kids, that they've got to find child care and they've got this argument that they only get one year of pre-K instead of two years of pre-K. Like, it just seems like maybe my number is a safety thing. And even if that, we're still on things with

070families. I mean, I don't know how we're going to solve this debate, right? Like, I don't know if it's something that goes to emotion in the morning. It's just, I don't, I don't know. Jesse, Jesse, just to we receive 45 applications for the preschool program and 17 for the four-year-old program. If we stick with the three-year-old program, we receive 45 applications. We have 16 kids on a waiver. If you have 45 kids, right, we're going to decide this. Like, are we going to go to a vote? I firmly believe that this data administration says this, and we're not supposed to interfere with that, but we set policy. And like, I think it's something that we need to consider and have a larger discussion on and workshop something. And I just, I don't, things being heard,

071I guess, is what I'm trying to say because I think that we 100% should encapsulate these four kids somehow, these four families. Can I ask a question which sort of piggybacks off what you're both saying? I know that you said we can put them in now, right, and that if they get called in number one on the list, they go on a wait list. Is there a happy medium if we, like, like they get the spot but they can't start till their third birthday? I know that's something we discussed or it came up at the last meeting. So that they don't have to be on a wait list but they just still can't start till they're three but at least their spot is held if their name gets pulled in those first 16 seats. I

072think one of the reasons we didn't want to do that is because there's going to be 30 other children also on a wait list, so do we tell them that we have a seat available but no one's sitting in it for three weeks? So if we put them in the lottery, right, just, I'm sorry, you're pleased you didn't finish it at all? I want to just add one point. So we're saying that it's three weeks but your birthday might be September 4th, so it might only really be three days. So it's really, it arbitrarily depends on if your birthday's September 30th versus September 2nd. So I think that that, I mean, that's just, I'm just throwing it out there as like maybe a happy medium instead of going on the wait list because, listen, we

073all know those coveted spots. If you're number two on the spot but your kid isn't there and they lose their seat because they have to go on a wait list and really, it's kind of, we're still not taking them to their three spots held, it's just something to think about. I'm just throwing it. The lottery's already been drawn. Next year, we gave, we changed like as this was approaching, we changed the way we re-handled our applications. We don't know if we opened it up to, everybody could say, your child can be three and you can apply now and we're going to hold a seat for you or we're going to, it could increase the number more than what we have now. We don't know what the impact might be and all that's going to do

074is dilute everyone's chance of being selected. Right, but if we go into the agreement like that, Dad said, that if they get selected and they get us and they pay the fool to win, we're not losing money, but it's not right if you win a lottery, right? See, Kelly wins the lottery and they say, oh, well Kelly, you gotta wait 21 days, but we're going to pick a different lottery for you and you go to the waiting list and if that guy doesn't claim it, then you can come back and get what you got pulled toward. If we say, if your birthday, if you get selected, you get a seat but you have to pay for it to seem fair to a 30-day window of their birthday. Like, it just, it blows my mind. You

075know, you're saving it right now and I think you've got some valid points. Jamie's and everyone else, everyone else, you know, I hope you don't get hurt because make that statement and we're going to be five dead families and Dad's going to come and say, hey, my kid's birthday is September 6th and yeah, he might miss two days of school, you know, but it's just one of those things. It's the right thing to do and especially, especially if they're going to, these kids are going to go to a town that we don't want to use if I'm interpreting that the right way and then they're going to get in with these kids that come to school and maybe miss five, six days. Consideration, I think you perhaps have some really valid points talked about as

076well which is why it was important to come to that conclusion when that father did speak to make that compromise at least for this year. I think I want to make sure we understand the purpose of this principle, the universal principle. The universal principle would be for anybody, right? That would be the intent. Obviously, if we don't have enough spots, so you also know we can start small with that down the line. We can initially start with three, four classes, maybe five, six, depending on space to expand. The guideline they give us is you have to be able to accommodate 90% eventually. But this preschool program that we have with tuition is because of the inclusive program. So what we, my only point for you to think about is if we're holding seats where children

077aren't there and it could be 3D, is there an adverse consequence that we're not thinking of for those students with special needs with whom the program is for those students? Do the special needs students go in the lottery? Exactly, so we're not costing them anything. They get their seat. They cannot go in that too. So what we're doing is actually equitable professional ed and the gen ed. We're required by state statute to provide a program for the special ed. The gen ed students are there at the site to create an inclusive event. They're there to be general education students modeling. If we're holding seats, then we may not be, and I think that's what you're trying to get at, we may not be fulfilling our obligation to the special education students. All of the kids

078that fit that category this year, all four, you're holding four 16 seats, you're holding less than a third of the seats. And if you never know, they're not under the last half policy on this. It is the, no. It is under, if we were going to add it to policy, I would add it to the entrance age policy. Our entrance age policy does not suggest that we move forward, but right now with the lottery being complete. Yeah, it sounds like this year the ship has sailed. There may have been parents that didn't bother to apply because they know their child didn't turn, turn, you know, in that month of September. They knew that they missed out on, maybe they would have applied. So I think to be fair to those people that maybe would have

079had an opportunity had they known, we changed the rules, the application period was closed. Yeah, no, we can't go back on it closed I'm not asking who, what the, if the board wants to do, keep it the same at 9-1, or if the board wants to change it to 10-1. How are we going to do that? Why don't we work? We have to do it after October 1st, because then it would change it for this year. Then that's what I said I want to eat. So then that means we wait until October 1st. Then our age, the next rotation. The years almost already doesn't start until January. The administration does not recommend changing it. They do not think it's safe. Before, just to clarify, with that, you know, I didn't have a child, they were

080not in a 3-year-old program, but they were in a 4-year-old integrative, and they did have one of the special ed seats. And to your point, the IEPs often say they have to be in within a certain percentage of their population of inclusion, right? So you need those kids. So yes, this year it's only 4, but next year it could be 10 of the 16, and now you go to school and they only have 6 kids as their inclusive role models for maybe up to 30 years. So I do see the other side, and I think it's important we do think about that. I'm not saying I don't, I still might push for September 1st, but I think it is something we do need to think about because we want to make sure that the kids

081that need the modeling also get what they need, because it's legally required, and we need to make sure we do that. So I think it's a greater conversation, and I think all the things we're looking for tonight are really good, and I think we need to really, it's not a decision, it's a question. Exactly. I'm not trying to rush it either. I just want to, like most people, and they say, hey, XYZ there's this, there's that, what are we doing this? What are we doing? How about transparency and how do we spend money? Transparency, how do we do this? Like, the lady here in misery, usually the only cat is Dr. Siri, but like, you know, it's not just we set up conversations, we say, hey, we're going to do it by X, we're going

082to do it by Y, like, we're going to have this, you know, there's just, it's just Jesse, just to finish up, the parent that left was happy with our compromise, and as long as we had the program, 10 years, anything has to do with artisanal. They're not consequential, they're not, hey, oh, that's the first, you know, we've got things that come up on a daily basis that are the first time it's happened in this many years or that many years, and I think that we need to take a pulse and understand what is important to some, might not be important to others, what Kelly thinks is important, less than what Kelly thinks, Christine might have something important that I think is irrelevant, but it's still important to her, so we have to do the due

083diligence with that, you know, that's what I'm saying, we can't minimize, just because it happened once in a decade doesn't mean it's not going to happen again twice next year, like, we can't, like, Robbie said, unless at this table it was old you know, like, we have to take these things as they come and be flexible and understanding and try to do those. I'm just trying to hold us to say, hey, this is an issue, we need to do X, we need to do Y, we need to do these things, and we need to set timelines that are achievable and understandable, and people get that until they don't think that, oh, well, Mr. Tulsi, Mr. Ferber, Mr. Kane, they're just saying, well, we want to hear, they're not doing nothing, you know, and mushrooms in

084the sun. I just meant you had said that at each time, but on which issue? I think you brought up some very valid points as well as everyone else has said. That's, to your point, the conversation needs to continue and it's not something that is going to be forgotten about or swept under the rug, and I believe everybody needs to give more thought to, based on some of the information that we receive tonight, and maybe maybe something else could be provided to us with a little more detailed information, or at least something you know, on paper that you kind of outline for us, a population that, you know, currently maybe what we anticipate, and our plan for universal placement to all this, because that is a plan that the administration has been thinking about for

085quite some time. I can talk about that now, about transparency. Right now we have a lot of new developments being built. Pre-K, we want to work with the new communities. We had a committee here tonight, unfortunately, she had to leave, but that's in our population, it really helps our district, you know, plan and prepare for what we need to do. Once we know that we have the room, which I anticipate that we'll have the room, and what the goal does not require a peaceful change of scene, once the work is done, we'd have to look at that. If we say no, we want to send a deadline in order to work a contract with contractors, which I guess we have to, but that's an expense that we have to look at. There's also, and Joanne

086is there, kindergarten has to, Pre-K has to have a bad certain size, so we would then have to say, okay, well, we know we're not fit at PEOC. Last time they said, based on the math I did, they estimated that each school year about 200,000. I was going to pursue universal preschool, talk about big picture, felt we should move towards universal preschool, and that's certainly a big picture. Would we have to go for the PEA grant? Unless we get another referendum. Well, so in other words, I'm going to say that the PEA grant is the preschool expansion aid grant through the state. Paper staffing, instructional assistance, so without that, we would have to get really creative or... Different ideas, so what Nicole was saying before, class size is really what will have the most impact.

087The guidelines for a preschool classroom cannot exceed 15 students. So we can fit, as you know, COVID and whatnot, six feet apart, 24 students in a room. We cannot do that in a preschool. So essentially, we kind of cut our classrooms in half as well, plus we have to then configure three-year-olds and then four-year-olds. So if you anticipate having, let's say, hypothetically, I think the number we looked into was about 250. If you have 250 three-year-olds, you then have to be able to plan for 250 probably more, because by that time, word has spread, more people apply. So say 250 to 300 for four-year-olds, plus all those children will move up to kindergarten. So it's not as simple as expanding and opening up with funding as well as the space limitations. We also keep in

088mind, too, because we do this in the district where I work. In my district, we actually mix three and four. Now, there's probably a whole discussion as to whether or not that's best practice, is that educationally appropriate, but some teachers have pushed back on that, because you'll have students who are older four heading towards kindergarten with a kid who just turned three. So there are a lot of logistical sort of things to think about. I believe you have five years with the grant to get 90% universal free head, is my understanding from the last meeting. We have a potential three-year plan, which we toy with different ideas. I know Nicole just explained some of it, but a lot of that will be impacted by the Taylor redistricting and what could potentially happen with enrollment thereafter.

089Once we have a better plan with enrollment, when we have the new developments moving and actually students starting, we can then go on to phase two, and then hopefully phase three down the line. So we've actually all spent a lot of time thinking about this and planning this. We are not ready to share out yet, because we don't know if we can do it. We have to see what enrollment is. It's something that when we have a conversation with the architect, we have a conversation. Two months, it has not gone well, where they've redistricted their entire district once and then twice. We don't want to be in that position for our parents. We want to go into this, and we want to be able to transition. So I think it will be rocky, probably. That's

090what happens with this. But we'd like it to run more smoothly than it could. And we want to plan for that. Jesse, with a two-year-old, I would love to have this in two years ago. You had commented on something about private school. I have no issue with private school. My daughter goes to private preschool. I have no interest in that. In my interest, I have no issue with private preschool. I think that's fine. What I have an issue with is if I'm responsible for a child, I can't monitor... I understand that. I understand that. But the main argument is we don't control anything. We're making it seem like the private... I know employees in private preschools too. The guy that runs one of the private pre... You know, it's the same argument people... I'm not

091making that argument at all. What I'm saying... I didn't say you do it with other people. There's somebody who, Ronnie's saying, that means we don't control this, we don't control that. That could make a person think, similar to where I am, that preschool is a bad thing. And it's not. All my kids are at the private... I think I can clarify. So we were talking about having, if we don't have the space, we have to put it out to a consortium or a pre-school, which is where we send our kids to a private school. We're legally responsible for them, but the staff at a private daycare facility is the one who's doing their schooling. A lot of school districts, the district that I worked at years ago, have that. Sometimes the district will send their

092staff to the schools that they need to, but more often than not, it's by the private school employees. So we are legally responsible for these children, but we don't have control over who's being hired. We're not, it's not our contracted teachers that are there teaching them. And yes, you have to put a lot of trust into these private facilities, and it's not saying that we don't trust the facilities here in Monalton. My kids went to private preschool here too. It's just that we're taking on the liability, and we don't have the control, and it's a big risk. So I think that's what was trying to go back and forth. I would say that private schools, that we would really have, that I would have no control over saying yes or no to. Basically, if it

093was the bill, we would lose a certain level of control. I think the main point is that none of this is something that we should clearly make quick decisions on, or rash decisions, and not really allow the time to think it through and plan appropriately. And I think that's from this conversation that there's a lot more to be thought out and figured out and planned to get to where I think we all want to get to. Do it right. Let's do it right, and hopefully do it right one time, and make mistakes and rush into anything that we may regret. Again, there's more conversation to be had. This is not the end of this topic. Anybody else? Do executive session? Motion and second? Council Executive? For my read, I'm going to say that. We are

094officially back at open session, and we have one item, which I'm going to ask for in motion. I'm going to read it in first, and then I'll ask for motion in second. It is recommended one from the following provisionary period determination effective, as noted, employee number 1917, effective 21925. Yes? Mr. Kane? Yes. This is Lucas? Yes. This is Gracie? Yes. Mr. Chastain? Yes. That's a great item. I motion to adjourn. Jesse? And the purpose.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.