001e e e good evening my name is sh chur and I'm the president of the city school district of baly board of education on behalf of the board I welcome you to our meeting today we have all our board members Mr El minav Miss Smith Miss Wilson miss grai m Savage and M damus man uh joining us along with super Haw riter and uh members of the cabinet this meeting is being live streamed and the instructions to view the meeting as well as a link to to the agenda including all the documents we'll discuss are available at Alban schools.org booe this is a good time for me to know that if you're here tonight for to speak in public comment you should sign up with Miss Timmons here to my right I don't see anybody
002in the audience today so we other than one comment that came To Us by mail I don't expect any new ones uh with that introduction we invite those of you who choose to join us as we pledge we stand for the Pledge of Allegiance United States indivisible and Justice in addition to the Pledge of Allegiance we always focus a meeting by restating the mission of the city school district of Albany which is to work in partnership with our diverse Comm Community to engage every Learner in a robust educational program designed to provide the Knowledge and Skills necessary for Success super HW rer do you have a report for us uh we do not tonight we will save for the 27th so like as I mentioned this is a time we set aside to hear from
003members of the public while there's no iners public comments here uh we do invite members of the public to share thoughts on the decisions we are facing we we accept public comment in person by voicemail and through a webbased form and information about public comment and contact information and contact information is on the district website at Alban schools.org booe and today we have uh one public comment that came to us by mail um this letter is from Miriam tell she says as a Jewish parent I'm sadden to hear that Jewish students are experienced bullying in our schools education about the dangerous stereotypes out there about Jews would be useful however I stand une unequally against conflating criticism of Israel and anti-Semitism that they are two entirely different things and to say otherwise is offensive to
004the deeply Jewish principles of Justice introspection and open debate it also leaves Jewish students with criticisms of Israel of whom there are many victimize again from another Direction please do not try to correct a wrong by generating another one and carefully vet any training material you accept to make sure that it does not do so thank you once again we appreciate all public comments we find hearing from public com uh public uh community members very valuable our contact information for both public comment and routine corresponden is Alban schools.org we now move to the part of our meeting we call routine consent during this portion of the meeting we approve routine matters for the district these include items like contracts field trips Personnel matters and the like each board member reviews each item carefully but we
005vote on them as group with no discussion this allows us to use our meeting time more efficiently nonetheless each board member has the option to set aside any routine consent item in order to require a separate discussion and board vote on that item with that introduction I now entertain a motion to adopt the routine consent agenda motion by Miss Smith second by Miss Wilson any set asides M Cree yes I'd like to set aside a different outcome different that's number 11 different outcome uh all in favor of adopting routine consent agenda except um item 11 different outcome yes ma'am okay Miss gra sure I had concerns no I mean everything except okay that's Anonymous okay let's move on to number 11 different outcome motion motion uh Miss CR Miss Savage second discussion so I had
006some concerns about this program last time and while I did receive um actually the board received a memo from Miss Brown on the program I had some addition follow-up questions uh that I directed to District Council I have not heard back on last Thursday when I got the memo from Miss Brown I have not heard back so I would like to table this until we hear back from Council thank you Paul do you have anything to add well only that at this point I haven't received or had the opportunity to view the uh memorandum that was provided by assistant superintendent Brown and I believe that the legal guidance would go hand inand with what's provided in that memo um obviously there are um there's a there's a requirement that we provide um equal opportunities for
007all of our students in the district with respect to our programming there are some well settled exceptions with respect to that based upon a demonstration of need um and the requirement that that need be uh addressed in an even-handed MA manner however without you know knowing about what's in the memo I can't really address the legalities of that even inh handedness of the approach um I've never uh received or heard of concerns in the district other than those uh shared by uh board member CR at this point with respect to these types of programs or whether or not that those uh programs are being done uh even-handedly however I've got to say that it's not my role as legal counsel to be evaluating those programs uh the breadth of them what we're doing across the
008spectrum of all of our programming for all of our students Miss Wilson just something I've seen I've observed other places I'm curious if it could be a solution here um some things that were traditionally targeting to women like for example like a financial thing for women have now shifted to saying women plus so I'm just curious if that's something that could address this instance and others potentially if I know naturally would have to be reviewed if it's something that's unprecedented but I'm just curious if that could help or things of that nature nature so with respect to specific programming it very well could um assuming of course it's a voluntary program uh however it doesn't necessarily need to have that type of language in order to be appropriate and to pass muster under the law
009if equal opportunities are being provided across genders and across different diverse groups um across the course of your entire programming so just because there is a specific program that might address the needs of uh 10 uh boys uh with respect to a particular thing uh it doesn't necessarily mean that it's unlawful to approve such an agreement because it only addresses boys if somewhere else within the district there's another program that provides a similar type of opportunity to T females for example Miss grae and then miss Savage so I did forward the attachments to you a second time but uh in the text of the email one of the things I had asked is uh whether we we doing those semiannual compliance reviews of our Single Sex programs to ensure that they are being done in
010accordance with all our requirements um I did also ask about equivalent programs because my understanding is they have to be substantially equivalent programs and available to the same kids not like a different program for girls at a different Elementary School and part of the memo from Miss Brown said well we have a summer program for stem for girls but this is a program that involves weekly tutoring in multiple fields field trips to the boys so I have concerns I'm not comfortable part of the email to Mr aloy did also ask about my concerns that does this align with state division of Human Rights policies so barring barring more uh barring more certain uh affirmation that this is in accordance with Federal and especially State policies I wouldn't be comfortable V voting on this and would
011like to table it thank you Miss Savage um so I feel uncomfortable about having a discussion at this level of detail without a memo from Council um I am disappointed that we don't have that I do remember that the um attachments did get forwarded so I would have loved to have had that tonight but since we don't have it our next board meeting feels like it's far in the distance because it's not till the 27th but in between there there's this thing we call February break so that's really only like seven school days from now so I'm wondering U Mr aloy what the time framing as you would need to review the materials provided have the conversation you need to have with Miss Brown and provide us with the information we need in order to
012understand the legal ramifications of this decision and whether that could be done timely for us to vote on this on the 27th which I realize is not the preference I would rather have it uh voted on today but but I really don't think it's appropriate to be doing this verbally without proper um Memo from Council so I don't believe I ever received the memo that you're referencing with respect to what was provided from a background standpoint from assistant superintendent Brown what I recall receiving was a copy of the contract which I had already reviewed a copy of some OCR Guidance with respect to that and a copy of uh I believe it was the New York state division of Human Rights um or the education law or division of human rights law with respect to
013what laws might apply um ultimately once I do see that memo I will be able to Aline with respect to this particular contract fairly quickly so I Believe by the next board wonderful we'll make sure you have that before for the um end of the next 5 minutes so that you've got it in your email and I apologize if it didn't get to you through some administrative error um but now that you have it it sounds like that we can table this till the 27th um and we would be able to have your opinions by then that that feels confident and Miss Brown is there is that okay in terms of the pedagogy for this contract that's fine and I'll touch Bas with Mr Alo if there's any additional information that's needed Miss thank you
014just wondered Miss Brown if you could just um uh in the meantime are can we be is it clear that students whether it's these 10 or or others are getting the tutoring mentoring that they need in some other uh through some other means um and were there any plans for them to these students to have any support during the break um so I just wanted to make sure there was nothing that was going to be a barrier so I don't have that specific information um from Miss Gaines or her team but I believe we are waiting on the contract before program begins for these identified young men can I ask a followup question because I think Miss Smith's question is an excellent one we have lots of tour of tutoring and AIS and other kinds
015of supports I assume that these students were not were not withholding our normal level support from these students they are receiving those additional supports just not through this particular program am I understanding we would absolutely be providing them um if they needed that academic support through other avenues and that's what I that's what I was asking and wanted to make sure of what it be okay to ask a follow-up question from Miss Brown about something in her Memo that's not a legal question but it's a question about the program so one of one of the things in your memo was about specifically us students in special education is this program targeted towards students in special education or Pro or students on tier 2 or three PBIS so I can't speak specifically if they are tiered
016students but um when it comes to some of the seal um needs of the particular identified students there's a number of different factors that the team has looked at to identify the young men who are um going to benefit from this program what about special education are these are these special educ are some of them in special education some of of them may be I don't have the specifics around okay what students might be Sol oh I just wanted to note that I that I stand corrected that I did receive a copy of the memo thank you for saving me the forwarding aspect that I was trying to do at the same time so I believe there was a motion on the floor to the table is it a second okay all in favor okay
017motion passes oh um no motion pass oh okay sorry sorry yeah um any anyone against and extensions okay so motion passes it'll be tabled to 27th and hoping that doesn't prevent uh students from getting the help they need and hopefully we can have the information for the next time any board committee reports okay sure you want me go ahead sure okay sure um so just wanted to uh let folks know that the ad hoc committee on designation of student students board representative it's a long title uh that we will be meeting with um students during uh the very the four lunch periods at the high school to sort of get some feedback and information from them and uh the week before uh this was it last week or two weeks ago we also had a
018a meeting with the sgaa which was very productive and got a lot of feedback from students there and uh so anyway we're we're moving along on that and uh continuing to to get information out and I I have heard from a couple of you that you had school visits and you had been in in a conversation with the School principles around uh this particular uh activity goal uh to have a student board rep and uh so I I haven't heard yet how those have gone but I'm delighted that that that's happening and uh some next things will evolve uh after this week yeah in fact today had a meeting at montesi and and explained what we were doing and what our goal was and how we want to make sure that the student voice includes
019Elementary and Middle School rising up through that High School representative to the board and so I I I forwarded the the NBA article to them and uh asked them to keep their eyes open for the survey that should be coming to them and get that import so great thank you um and I I'll just before um uh the facilities committee meets tomorrow uh here at h G at um 5:45 and uh so we have a pretty uh heavy agenda but uh it's all around uh the completion of various uh uh projects capital projects that we have going on um so um and we're coming to the end of of most of those so um anyway tomorrow night thank you thank you m grei I just want to say the policy committee is meeting this Wednesday
020here at 5:30 and I did want to say we're already getting positive student feedback about the communication that went out to students encouraging them to participate in that so thank you was that some was that something that was done in conjunction with student government the uh the power lunches yeah um so uh it was they know about it because we were prepared but it was something that we talked about with principal kford and uh the uh SGA advisor faculty advisor uh Miss D roza and uh and we said to those students at during the SGA meeting that we this this is what we wanted to to do and then it was through the uh Communications Department um Miss um Miss Ashley I'm not going to get our last name correct um our new person there
021at the high school Communications person uh did uh craft took the information that I provided and crafted a flyer so that was posted up uh now throughout the building and we'll see um how many students uh come and uh we're going to each take some role in sharing with students uh what it about you know what a board School Board does um and also uh more importantly uh the importance of their voice um in shaping uh educational policies and decisions so that's really ex that's really exciting and it's it's nice to see this playing out thanks government relations so government relations the next major Topic in the government relations agenda is the uh Council Big Five schools Lobby day which is coming uh Lobby multiple days Lobby days uh comes up Tuesday the 25th and
02226th of February so uh thank you president chour for uh running Herd on trying to get everybody signed up and rsbp for that I appreciate you're taking that on um so we will have more to report uh once we've um sat with them their priorities almost always align almost perfectly with ours because the demographic need and fiscal challenges of the big five and our um plus three districts are similar despite the Fairly substantial difference in the way the the school districts are structured and I will also move on just to talk about school visits of our 18 School visits close enough to updated we have um two complete already four scheduled and the remainder are kind of split between we're waiting to hear back from the principal and we're waiting to hear back from a
023board member so if you have not checked your District mail recently could you please check your District mail and make sure to get back to principles um about possible dates and I will nude people individually so that you don't feel like I'm the teacher saying everybody in the class stop talking when really it's only one person talking um but I I do have that list and I will share that with you guys so we're making progress and I fully expect every school will have had the opportunity to show off all the wonderful things that they're doing to at least one board member between now and the end of March so one quick question uh is there any generalized format in which you expect a report back no Miss Smith and I were working on that
024some time ago and we did drop that ball so we probably should pick that ball back up again and look because we would like to get some report out but we want to make sure that we're doing it in the spirit in which these um visits are intended so that would be helpful thank you very much sure um and thank you Miss Savage for that I think I'm happy to I know follow up work with you on that still if uh that's desired um I back on the um student board rep uh policy um I just wanted to make sure I don't know um while we're still waiting on some data I think we do have some information right now that could be forwarded to the policy committee so I'm just wanting a n uh
025nud nod uh to indicate that that's okay to try to put some of that together for you all that's one question go ahead oh yes please not for this Wednesday but for March yes absolutely absolutely that we we would be really excited to see it thanks okay you got it um and um oh my gosh I had one more related to that uh Miss man wants to say something while I try to remember what I was thinking I was just going to say that the um audit committee is not going to meet again until April the 21 go going once going twice that's quite all right it'll come article um no I don't think it was the nisba article uh but I do think it's important uh for people I think I did shift it
026around there's the U nisba guidance came out so we have the the policy their policy uh suggestion so that's what I wanted to make sure miss Cree has um the other thing is within teams there is a lot of information there I've you know um and I'll just I'll give you links to everything but you know uh including conversations that have uh or videos that have been done with other um student reps including the student rep in skincity um so that's probably the district most most uh um you know like hours um the other one is Buffalo that's much bigger and they are able to do some things and the reason that their policies that they've already got a persons because they've already had a policy in place prior to this uh legal requirement um
027um so they could proceed um but we're uh I think the the law is pretty clear uh even though we've been pushing uh Council a little bit uh uh not you Paul but uh Shannon and um and so uh but I think that there's really sufficient information where the uh committee uh policy committee could get started so I want to make sure that that's out um but there are some for everybody you do have access in teams to a few things and I would invite you to to take a peek at some of those things uh be it be it the law um or the nisba policy as well as some of the interviews uh from other districts um where you can hear what students you know have what role what they describe as their
028role and how they're uh functioning um so anyway um and I I'm just babbling on because I cannot remember this one thing I had wanted to say but that's okay all right always time okay thank you any other business items if not we have I just wanted to mention which I assume the district H either has or will send out to the general public that the uh Capital District Vision zero initiative is doing a meeting at the Pine Hills branch on February 26 from 4 to 7 it I don't know the full format but it looks a little bit like an open house format where you'll be able to sort of come in and out um to talk about the um their planning effort around the Albany High Traffic Safety situation um so that would
029be wonderful to have lots of people be there to talk about their lived experience um one thing I would like to raise with my board colleagues is whether we want to have a formal statement um on behalf of the board I don't I don't plan to speak as myself because I don't think that's appropriate even though as you guys know I have fairly strong individual opinions about this I think that we should speak as a board on this um and I would like to suggest that we um work with Mr leco and the superintendent to write a formal um letter um into the process and then if people also want to do individuals they certainly could do that but I think it's always I always use caution for myself as an elected official to make
030sure that it's clear when I'm speaking as an and when I'm speaking representing the board so I'm I'm wondering are people willing to do some kind of letter like that is that you know subject obviously to it being fine-tuned sounds like a good plan all right hearing no objection I will work with superintendent and Mr lco on on some sort of letter thanks all right all right may have a motion to adjourn and return to a retreat uh Miss Smith Miss Wilson all in favor that's unanimous thank you everybody good night for