CorpusRecord 59419

Board of Education Public Meeting | Live Stream | January 9th, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City School District Of Albany
Date
2025-01-10
Location
Albany County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,448 words · about 70 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e name is shur I'm president of the city school district of w Board of Education on behalf of the board I welcome you to our meeting uh today we have um Miss Micky Smith DAV Wilson um CI and Savage and damous man uh with us um member El minav is uh not attending today because of an illness U and we have members of cabinet as well with us uh so everybody Welcome this meeting is being a live streamed and the instruction to view the me meeting as well as a link to the agenda including all the documents we will discuss are available at Alys schools.org for/ booe this is a good time for me to note that if you're here today for to speak in public common you should sign up with Miss

002timens here to my right and with that introduction we invite those of you who choose to join us as we stand for the Pledge of Allegiance fled States in addition to the Pledge of Allegiance we always focus our meeting by restating the mission of the city school district of Aly which is to work in partnership with our diverse Community to engage every Learner in a robust educational program designed to provide the Knowledge and Skills necessary for sucus superintendent Haw riter uh do you have a report for us we do and I'll turn it over to Mr Lesco to get us started thank you and good evening it is our pleasure to begin tonight's District highlights with a celebration of Excellence among our teachers three teachers in STEM related fields at the secondary level have been

003accepted into New York State's prestigious Master teacher program Kevin Allen is a technology teacher at Albany High School Emily Lawler is a science teacher at Albany High and Carrie welcom is a seventh grade science teacher at William S Hackett Middle School Kevin and Carrie also are siblings so it's a bit of a family affair for us this evening as well I would like to introduce Amanda Powers our instructional supervisor for secondary science and stem initiatives to tell us more thank you and thank you to the board and the superintendent for having us here tonight the New York State Master teacher program is an amazing initiative it's designed to recognize and support the state's most effective and Innovative stem teachers it acknowledges Educators who demonstrate exceptional teaching practices leadership skills and a commitment to advancing their

004professional development the rigorous application process requires that teachers demonstrate both their knowledge of and desire to grow in stem content pedagogy and knowledge of our students families and Community the program encourages collaboration among teachers and provides opportunities for them to enhance their skills learn from one another and share strategies for improving student achievement teachers who are selected to be part of the master teacher program have access to a variety of resources including professional development workshops leadership training and collaborative networks with other accomplished teachers across New York State they receive stiens and recognition for their role shaping the future of education but they also commit to Growing their practice in areas that will benefit their instruction their students and their school Community the city school district of Albany currently has five teachers and one school counselor

005who are active Master Teachers as well as uh as well as 12 Master teacher ameriti a few months ago these three teachers from our district were also accepted into this distinguished program a significant achievement for both the Educators and our community this recognition highlights not only their individual dedication and achievements but also the continued growth and Innovation within our district by participating in the New York State Master teacher program these teachers will have the opportunity to expand their impact on their students and the broader educational Community the selection of Carrie welcome Kevin Allen and Emily Lawler for the master teacher program is an exciting development that reflects their ongoing commitment to high quality education in Albany these teachers join a fantastic group of Highly skilled professionals who are committed to fostering a culture of Excellence

006within their classrooms and Beyond congratulations to these three teachers I will now introduce each of them and then give them a chance to get a word in edgewise Carrie welcome is a dedicated Middle School teacher at hackit known for her student centered teaching approach she tailor her lessons to meet the diverse needs of her students through Hands-On experiments group work and inquiry based activities that Foster critical thinking and curiosity Carrie is committed to equity and education ensuring that all students have access to high quality science regardless of their academic track she has led the Joseph Joseph Henry science fair allowing students to design and analyze their own scientific experiments which enhances their ownership of their learning Carrie is passionate about her professional growth continually seeking development in stem content and collaborating with colleagues beyond the

007classroom she Mentor mentors fellow Educators serves as an apster rep advocates for inclusive curriculum and organizes stem align field trips her commitment to her students her profession and equity and education makes her an invaluable asset to her students our department our building at hacket and our community she will both contribute to and grow along her extensive skills in the New York State Master teacher program Carrie thank you thank you Amanda and thank you for having us here tonight I am thrilled and honored to begin my journey as part of New York State's prestigious network of Stem Master Teachers it is truly humbling to be selected among such an accomplished group of Educators and I cannot wait to immerse myself in the opportunities this program offers one of the aspects I'm most excited about is a

008chance to collaborate with colleagues from across the state I believe this collaboration will not only broaden my understanding of different teaching strategies but also deepen my knowledge of both my subject and best educational practices as a teacher I am always seeking ways to improve and ensure that my students enjoy and connect with science as much as I do I am confident that my participation in this program will help me grow professionally while also engaging in stimulating professional development that will inspire and challenge me I look forward to learning sharing and growing alongside my fellow Educators and I'm eager to bring what I gain from this experience back to my students and my community I will next introduce Kevin Allen who is a technology teacher at Hony high school he consistently employs a student- centered project-based

009instructional approach Kevin encourages students to drive their learning by using robotics coding and digital design to Foster critical thinking and problem solving Kevin is an advocate for equity and stem ensuring that all of his students and those in the other tech classes especially underrepresented groups have access to Tech education at Albany High School he is an integral part of his Department's efforts to recruit into our introductory tech courses and also retain diverse enrollment within our pre-engineering pathway Kevin's dedication to continuous professional development includes UD specialized training in Project Lead the Way courses which keep him on The Cutting Edge of Technology education outside the classrom he also advises our nationally ranked robotics team and contributes to districtwide Tech initiatives Kevin's commitment to Student Success professional growth and stem Equity make him a standout educator and

010a strong addition to the New York State Master teacher program good evening and uh thank you Amanda I'm honored to be part of the New York State Master teacher program some may say being selected as a master teacher is an affirmation of our dedication to Preparing students for the future however I see it as another step in being a lifelong learner it connects us with a community of skilled Educators helping us collaborate innovate and stay passionate about our work for the first 13 years of my career I was the only technology teacher in various middle schools that I worked at while I enjoyed the work there was always something missing colleagues in the same field to collaborate with I didn't have anyone to share best practices with or discuss the unique challenges we face in

011a technology classroom that all changed six years ago when I transferred to Albany High and F finally found what I had been missing throughout my entire career at Albany High working alongside Mr Katy and Mr lamman has been a game changer now I have peers to exchange ideas with learn from and collaborate with to create more consistent and cohesive lessons honestly as an educator I would not be where I am today without the support and expertise of others in my department through the New York State Masters teacher program I look forward to even more opportunities to collaborate and Elevate the field of Technology education as a whole I look forward to bring back all that I learned to my classroom and Department thank you and finally last but not least we have Emily Lawler who

012is is one of our Innovative science teachers at Albany High School and I'd love to recognize her for her engaging student centered approach to science instruction Emily creates and facilitates dynamic learning experiences through Hands-On labs gamification and inquiry based activities that encourage students to explore scientific Concepts Emily is passionate about promoting equity and stem particularly for women and minorities she has played a key role in district-wide initiatives like Hydroponics and the freight fire bringing real world science to her students committed to professional growth Emily regularly participates in PD and is at the Forefront of developing curriculum aligned to our new science standards outside the classroom she teaches night school and is an Adjunct professor at Mildred Ellie Emily's leadership in stem education continues to have a lasting impact her combination of strong pedagogy content knowledge

013and advocacy for Equity will benefit Emily as she participates in the New York statement Master teacher program thank you um I didn't prepare anything like everybody else did but I am I am um I'm really excited to be able to take part in a lot of the excellent PD that I heard um that is available to us through the master teacher program and be able to collaborate with teachers you know from around the state and bring everything back to our students so thank you all right thank you now we just ask uh board members and the superintendent to come out we'll take a few pictures for than Albany High School celebrated the academic achievements of 109 seniors on Monday with its annual National Honor Society induction ceremony to be eligible for National Honor Society Society

014seniors must have made an overall academic average of 89.5 or higher throughout High School this year's class of inductees represented an increase of 17 students over last year and a dramatic increase from the first induction ceremony for Albany High's Arista chapter when 15 students were inducted in 19 57 a heartfelt congratulation to all of this year's inductees on their exceptional academic achievements the second Albany High Community blood drive of the school year is coming up at the end of the month the drive will be held January 31st in the library from 8: in the morning until 2:45 p.m. students employees and community members are invited to donate online registration is required in Advent in advance we strongly recommend that donors drink plenty of water and eat green leafy vegetables in the days leading up to

015the uh to donating you can find registration links and more information in the Albany High section at Albany schools.org Albany High Senior aara Gates is nearing a milestone this evening as our girls basketball team is taking on holy names aara entered tonight's game just 32 points away from reaching the 1,000 point mark for her varsity career knowing aara she could get there tonight but more likely she will have a chance to pass that Milestone at home on Saturday afternoon when the Falcons welcome White Plains tip off for Saturday's game is 1: p.m. aara has been the Falcon starting point guard since her ninth grade season and it's hard to believe she's already a senior we look forward to celebrating her achievements at an upcoming meeting and we wish her and her team teammates well as

016the season moves on the Falcons entered tonight's game six- two and ranked among the top 25 teams uh class 3A teams in the state Kudos also are in order for members of Al High's indoor track and field team the Falcons won their most recent team meet Sunday at Union College easily out distancing a field that included nine other schools four members of the team also excelled over the holiday break at an event in New York City Samir Gardner won the long jump and tied a 14-year-old School record at the jambar coaches Hall of Fame invite at the Nike track and field Center at the New York City Armory that was a lot Gardner also was a member of the Falcons 4x200 relay team that took second place at the competition also on the relay team

017were Darren harell nasif Smith and Rohan Edwards Grant Edwards Grant and Gardner also finished 23 in the 55 meters as well congratulations to all of our student athletes we look forward to continuing to celebrate their achievements as the winter season continues and that concludes tonight's District highlights thank you Mr leco we'll move on to the district update and as our tradition is we uh share our vision mission and goals a number of topics uh tonight some that are um pretty difficult to get through uh earlier today we had a uh safety matter at Albany High School uh that involved two students um that began as a verbal confirmation one student displayed a knife uh and following uh the incident our staff uh found that the second student also had a knife uh in his position

018possession our security staff uh and Albany Police Department school resource officer responded uh immediately I want to let the board and the community know um that uh a number of uh different camera angles uh were viewed footage throughout the building so I know that the investment um this board and previous boards have made in in security technology played a a very significant role in in today's deliberations um during the um confrontation uh as the students uh were attempting to be separated our school resource officer did withdraw his weapon uh he did ask the student a number of times uh to put the Knife Down uh at one point uh the student in the school resource officer were were within two feet of one another eventually the student did comply uh and that student was taken

019into custody it's important to underscore that there were no uh injuries during the fight uh the uh student student was charged by Albany Police and they have a a separate set of protocols they go through and we will go through our student discipline protocols as outlined in the student code of conduct uh the school was on lockdown approximately from 9:40 a.m. to 11:00 so the investigation could be thorough and complete uh various uh Communications went out uh both to uh to families and our and our community at large uh earlier this evening around 4 or 5:00 uh we communicated to our entire School Community about what happened uh as did the Albany Police Department uh it's also important to underscore that um the students did go through uh our our front door or or um

020uh were exposed to our routine Security checks what we don't yet know uh and I want to underscore this is we don't know if uh the weapons were brought in through those channels or uh if they were um if there were other uh folks that assisted in making uh the weapons available in the high school but that is a ongoing investigation uh not only internally with our staff but also with uh Albany Police Department and as a result uh we will have increased security measures at the high school tomorrow additional counselors and social workers are available for our students over the course of the last uh number of weeks um we have heard from uh families community members and students uh about uh upcoming uh the impact of upcoming leadership changes at the federal level

021it's important to underscore and this is not the first time uh our school Community as a sanctuary city has has gone through leadership change that's proposing some policies that very well could uh in Impact our students and families uh we have shared legal legal guidance uh with our administrators we're awaiting additional guidance I'll talk about that in a minute uh but with regards to um ice the immigration Customs Enforcement and really any other uh law enforcement agency their access to schools uh for purposes of seeking information about our students and their families um while law enforcement uh officers and agencies are permitted uh to question students on District property it's really only under the following three circumstances one they have a warrant uh which is Court authorized uh to access students uh and interview them

022two with consent from a parent or guardian or three if the student is accused of committing a crime on school property and school or District Personnel ask law enforcement to investigate if one of these criteria are met uh the district will comply however uh I want to reinforce that if these criteria are not met Law Enforcement Officers including ice are not permitted to speak to our students on school property we have instructed as such to our School administrators on the appropriate steps to follow if this does become uh the case uh I mentioned earlier that we have received uh legal guidance and have shared that internally uh with our leaders we're also awaiting guidance from the state education department as well as the Attorney General's office uh once we receive that guidance we will share

023that uh immediately with not only our staff and leaders but also our family and our school community at large and it's uh very important and I hope it uh doesn't and it needs to be said but it's uh important to underscore that our school district is committed to protecting all the rights and the Dignity of all members of our school community at all times and we understand that uh while this is a a very stressful and unsettling time for students and families um that we are going to do everything we can to protect their rights and dignity next week uh the State of the State uh take place takes place on Tuesday at the egg uh we have been in constant communication with the governor's office on a number of opportunities for our students and

024staff uh to participate and be recognized so on Monday uh across the river at Hudson Valley the governor uh is meeting with uh one or 200 students and have invited 20 Albany High School students to be part of a fireside chat uh they'll be uh provided the opportunity to uh ask the governor a question or two and engage in a Q&A uh around some what we believe to be up upcoming policy uh considerations the governor is um uh is considering that we anticipate she will unveil on Tuesday at the State of the State at the egg the Albany marching Falcons have been invited to perform uh at the event so that's just one more uh opportunity for our students to um to perform but but uh a very nice honor for them to be included

025indeed and we have a number of our food service staff will be recognized uh we um we won't share what the policies are we don't know all of them but uh we anticipate the governor unveiling some policies around school lunch and making meals more available and affordable for students uh and we're honored that uh a handful of our food service staff have been invited to be recognized as she outlines uh the vision of her policy so uh we're thankful to the governor and and her office for including our staff and students in this very important unveil of uh the governor's next 365 days of priorities some upcoming uh reminders uh we have a middle school early dismissal uh next week on the 15th um the three middle schools and Tony Clement will dismiss at 1230

026this is an opportunity for uh some committed and uninterrupted time for staff development uh for our teachers on Monday the 20th we will honor Dr Martin Luther King Jr all of our schools and offices will be closed when we come back uh high school students uh will have an opportunity to take regent exams so uh if you are a high school student you will attend by exam only if you are taking a regent exam the 21st to the 24th we will be celebrating Lunar New Year on Wednesday January 29th again offices and schools are closed and we have winter parent teacher conferences on the 6th and 7th of February uh in the E early evening on the 6th and afternoon conferences on the 7th uh as our teachers districtwide will participate in some staff development

027that morning and that concludes my update for tonight thank you super as is a usual practice I ask you to prioritize your questions and ask your most important question first we'll start with one question for each board member so that everybody has an opportunity to be heard um let's start with that and today with uh this man so my my comment is really um about uh the event that occurred today in um at the high school and I'm very interested to hear the outcome of the investigation that uh occurred regarding the um students and the uh and the webon thank you Miss SM apologies I thought you were coming down the line but um okay uh so good evening everyone I think uh again I I share um uh Miss man's concern and I'm wanting

028to wait for the report um I uh just generally I think we all continue to try to understand uh why we are not able to perhaps engage every single student in the excitement uh of learning and the excitement of the opportunities that we have available to them and uh you know it's uh and so it's a big challenge but I want to just commend our staff for continuing to do that very very hard work of trying to reach and touch every single student uh to ensure that they are uh engaged and learning and have uh access to all of the opportunities that we are uh desperately wanting them to have and desperately trying to fund and desperately trying to ensure under the new Administration they continue to have access to uh and I do not

029mean Mr Haw ridder's Administration I mean the federal Administration so to be clear um so anyway that's always going to be uh something that we're concerned about um I uh do want to commend again our staff for uh for uh working to ensure that uh incidents uh don't uh result in further harm or damage to any staff or personel or student for that matter um and so uh just thank you and um um I think I I'm also just wanting to acknowledge the uh superintendent's uh message um that aligns certainly with uh our overall board's vision and and cabinets around the protections uh that we would like to um offer and ensure uh are available to our immigrant and Refugee students um I'm looking forward to some of the guidance that may be coming out

030from State Ed um and there are other resources as well um and I I think uh one of the questions I will continue to also ask is um in what ways are we continuing to demonstrate to our students and families our commitment and in what ways do we need also to ensure that our staff are able to uh adhere and and commit to those same um commitments so there are number of things I know that we might do and consider doing uh some things are unknown as of yet um and it wouldn't worry me as much uh I mean we've this district has been through some of this uh in the 201 uh 17 18 and so forth um but something is very different it feels um going forward and so I think it raises

031different questions around uh what we are willing to do to ensure that our youngsters uh and their families are um are safe and feel safe um and uh so again I want to thank the board for uh supporting a policy that to reaffirm our commitment and again I don't think it's just going to be limited to our uh immigrant and Refugee students I think they are kind of obviously first on the list um and there is some indication that things like raids and other kinds of events are are occurring even in Albany but even around the country and I think we just have to keep a an eye on that and and again uh work to figure out what we do as a as a school district within this Sanctuary City to keep our youngsters

032safe um and again I also just want to say like while I'm don't want to get into panic and gloom and doom I am just always always excited to to hear uh Mr Lesco and and uh and from others the exciting things that continue to go on within within our district those are so so important and often don't get the kind of focus um that we'd like because certainly the good stuff I think in the end always outweighs the bad stuff but um I just I don't want to lose sight of of what incredible work staff and and are doing and students are doing uh to be great citizens and to be great peers and and family members so thank you thank you very much Miss Smith you said things in such a beautiful way

033today that I don't don't have it in me to say again in any different way since you did such a beautiful job I do have two questions specifically around those same two topics that Miss Smith was speaking to one regarding our interaction with law enforcement uh in particular federal law enforcement have we had conversations with our transportation vendors at this point about their role um since our students are our students I believe from the moment we accept them onto our school buses and I'm wondering if those conversations have had been had um so that drivers as well as School administration is prepared we have not and that's a great suggestion thank you we will make sure we do that okay um I think those particular drivers are in a very um unenviable position should they

034ever be faced with this because they are alone on the road with students um and so anything we can do to prepare them for this possibility which may never come to pass but we know there have been rumors of such so let's let's make sure that they are prepared um and know that their job is to keep the door closed and call the lawyer um and then my second question is regarding the um very unfortunate events at Albany High I'm assuming that once the investigation is complete there will be some additional reporting about um improvements that are going to be made to our um security protocols whether that be truly the the entry protocols or whatever else is happening in the building and I know and I will stress for members of the community that

035will most likely not be shared in public because one of the things that you learn is you don't tell everyone all the improvements you're making to your security protocols because that tells people people where to look for the problems so um but I hope that we'll be able to do some public sharing of the fact that a report was complete and some improvements were made at least so that people know that it wasn't just um you know not dealt with we'll make sure that's provided Mr R uh thank thank you for your update I appreciate you providing the information um about what happened today at Al High school and I share um I share the concern with my colleagues and en encourage us you know we kind of want these we'd like to have these

036situations be prevented before they get to this point um whether it's through our staff or through some of the improvements that we were promised with a new building that we'd have more security a less ways for people to get in ETC so I'd love to see uh more more situations where knives are caught at the door and removed um you know I'm glad to have our school resource officers there but also encourage us to continue working toward having a signed memorandum of understanding with the Albany Police just to make it very clear uh what their role is and where their where their job starts what what their job entails and what it does not entail thank you M Wilson thank you for the update so many of my colleagues have um especially board memb Smith

037have so eloquently put basically a synopsis on the events of the past couple of days um it is wonderful to hear about our students and staff that will shine at the State of the State and all the other updates we received in the superintendence report including the um AER Gates approaching 1,000 points and ultimately I feel that it is indeed all connected that you know something resonated with me about students being sort of inspired and motivated and I think we all collectively want to support every student reach fulfill their potential and we are just going to remain committed to supporting them so that we no longer are experiencing these issues or as someone indicated they're greatly reduced or don't evolve to that point and most of my colleagues have already said what I would like

038to say uh but one thing I do want to point out is I want our students and families to realize that we stand by them and we are there are resources available for them and it'd be great if those resources were available in other languages so that uh you know the message gets to them in their comfortable language uh in the language that they're comfortable in um you know it's our students are great uh even if nobody else wants to uh shout out from the rooftops we will and we know they will do great uh and that goes for all of them and things happen uh unfortunately the incidents that have happened since Monday um are a little disconcerting but you know we'll get to the root cause of why things happen and once we

039have that investigation done we'll know the house and the wise and then know what to do about it and U so not that concerned about it I'm glad it wasn't uh it was handled in the most appropriate way and and things were taken care of um so this two Shall Pass um we will get through this thank you this is the time we set aside to hear from members of the public are there any uh public comments today okay may I have Rebecca schw Schwartz okay I I couldn't read the handwriting and Freda uh come up to the table um and while you do that uh see the board always welcomes input from the community about the decisions we are making we dis we set aside about 30 minutes of each meeting to hear from

040District residents parents students and other members of our community if there are more comments that can be accommodated in 30 minutes which we don't have anticipate today we may choose to have a separate uh public common perod um we'll also accept comments virtually on the same basis as those in person and we accept comments in writing and by voicemail we welcome comments in English and any other language we'll provide translation where there is necessary all comments must include the commentary's name and place of residence we do not accept Anonymous comments all the information about these in many ways to share your thoughts with us are available addressing addressing the board information on Albany schools.org slpa we ask all our commenters to uh keep in mind that the information about individual students and specific District staff

041cannot be shared not only is that a viol of privacy but every student and every staff member deserves to know that the concerns about them will not be aired in public having said that um invite Rebecca start and and make sure that you pay attention to miss CI because she'll be giving timing your three minutes and putting up the one minute and 10 seconds okay uh thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak tonight and thank you for your update about the situation today at school my name is Rebecca schwarzer I'm an Albany resident and my daughter is a sophomore at Albany High this morning I received a frantic text from my daughter asking her to be picked up because she did not feel safe she heard that there was an earlier lockdown due

042to a knife fight where both students had knives and the police officer drew his weapon this is the second incident involving knives at Albany High this week even one is one is unacceptable two incidents call to question the ability of this the the students teachers and staff to all be safe each day students go through the metal detectors while their bags are hand checked according to both my children the bag check is genuinely a cursory exam of items at the top of the bag and the whole monitor feels around inside students can easily hide things at the bottom or In Pockets if the metal detector goes off the whole monitor scans the student with a wand but that does not always find everything students hide items in their undergarment and are not caught if we

043know that two students got knives through security today how many knives don't we know about how many will go through next week or the rest of the year and if students can get knives in how how do we know they're not getting in guns we don't want incidents in what happens in other school districts the school board to the school board I recommend that we Implement immediate significant and permanent changes to security procedure students need to be checked thoroughly and any student with an unidentified metal object needs to be pulled aside until St staff can identify the item all incoming bags should be scanned with x-ray scanners I know that there's a huge cost to that and it would take time but it's worth it to be able to keep our students safe many school

044districts have implemented that also the school doors open only 30 minutes before the start of the day with over 2 200 students Hall monitors have to completely check third 85 students per minute to ensure students can get to Home Room on time I suggest do should open an hour before Home Room to allow enough time for adequate Security checks to be performed furthermore the hall monitors are being asked to do jobs that in other cities are being done by the police they need to be given additional security training and additional staff should be hired all Hall managers should be paid at a rate that accurately reflects these responsibilities there should also be a police officer overseeing the security process to keep keep everyone safe to provide back up to the hall monitors my daughter will

045be in school tomorrow the email this evening said there would be increased security at school tomorrow but I want her to be safe not just tomorrow but everyday following education is important but parents should not have to wonder if they rather have their child child ignorant and alive or educated and dead please ensure that my daughter will be educated and Alive thank you thank you Miss Freda hi Freda parot Albany New York um I have two things whenever I say that I forget one of them so but there are two the first is tomorrow Tomorrow there's going to be a teen night here and I I congratulate everyone for opening the school and having those activities for students I don't know why it hasn't happened before it happens in any school districts um it even

046happened in the old days when I went to school some so this is a wonderful thing I hope it'll be ongoing that it's not just tomorrow um but I'm anxious to hear more about that the other is from last time we met you all met I'm very very upset that the school the buildings that were done the construction we were supposed to have trained a trained Workforce from this people from the community students and their families these are rare opportunities in this political City and it was supposed to happen and it started happening and I'm not going to dissected after that except to say now we have cost overruns and we still have problems with the construction that's upsetting that the cost overruns can be supported but the students and their pet families could not

047I just want to be on record as saying I any opportunities there are for educating our students in any way and in this case I'm talking about the trades this is something that would change their lives their family's lives this is not just attending a a only one minute attending a course and then walking away these are quality of life issues that we can't ignore and I have been pretty quiet about this considering five was it five six years ago when this was all planned um because I really believed it was going to happen we don't know about the culture of the trades in this city only certain people do and for those whose families mostly white were part of those trades they've been kept quiet they've been kept closed we had an opportunity to

048do something something important here and we're all poorer for the fact that it didn't happen thank you we appreciate all public comments and be fine hearing from community members very valuable um I do want to St U not to let you know that the board's policy is not respond during the public common parent if you need a response please contact us by email phone or postmail our contact information is available at omnis schools.org booe and the board will respond on behalf request said that we move on to the next part of our meeting we call routine consent and during this portion of the meeting we approve routine matters for the district these include items like contracts field trips Personnel matters and like each board member reviews them uh each item carefully but we vote on

049them as a group with no discussion this allows us to use a meeting time more efficiently nonetheless each board member has the option to set aside any routine consent item in order to require a separate discussion and vote on that item with that introduction I now entertain a motion to adopt the routine consent agenda Miss Smith second B Miss man um are there any set asides m c I'd like to set aside item number four the field trip to CC okay any other set asides okay hearing none all in favor of adopting routine consent agenda less item four field trip to Quebec that's unanimous okay may have a motion to adopt number four field trip Miss Savage seconded by Miss wison discussion thank you um I appreciate that more information's been provided about how financial

050support is provided to students who are not able to par participate um in field trips that require Financial contributions and I appreciate that there have been some changes made to the communications that go out to parents um on this but I did have some follow-up questions um just regarding more St if we have some number first uh historically it says the the memo that we received says in the past um guardians of students who Miss payments are contacted to discuss potential hardships and then collaboration with principles has been used to assess students financial aid status where hardship is suspected um and then assistant if a student or Guardian communicates financial hardship assistance is provided if hardship suspected Outreach is initiated with the guardian I would be curious to know how much and how many students

051benefit have benefited from this financial assistance in the past um not I'm not necessarily asking for every single field trip it it maybe just be helpful to know just for these cack trips also I know that we do maintain statistics on how on which of our students are economically disadvantaged so I would love to see statistics on for example what percentage of our French students are economically disadvantaged versus what percentage of those student what percentage of students who go on these field trips are economically disadvantaged to know if they're if they are indeed having that opportunity to participate we do we are we should be able to know that um additionally um the memo says that uh we will be Additionally the memo says it's going to be clear on all the communications that financial

052aid is available but some of the communications aren't really super clear on that um for example the permission slip mentions a cost of $615 but on the permission slip there is no information about financial aid and some of the brochures say things like well reach out to your French teacher with any payment concerns that's not really the same as what we say in our field trip policy which is no student may be excluded from a trip because of inability to pay provided they Avail themselves of all fundraising opportunities I think saying or the email to family says if you have any you know a deposit is required if you have any difficulty paying the deposit please reach out to the teacher that kind of makes it clear makes it sound more like well you might

053have extra time to pay or something it's not really very clear in that memo um and the permission slip also doesn't oh no I said the permission slip doesn't mention it but I'd really like to see what's promised in the memo The prominent placement of messaging and all Communications to ensure families understand that no student should be discouraged from attending due to financial hardship and I would like to see past information about that um it won't stop me from voting for the field trip because I know it's coming up but just want to say thank you for providing the information but I would like to see these types of communications to parents very very clear about do not let this stop you from going and I don't I did not see that in these communications

054thanks any other discussion all in favor adopting that's unanimous thank you motion passes next thing on our agenda is the policy and I pass it on back to miss CR M Mr President if I may um I'd like to uh recognize Mr Alex Santana who is with us as the board approved its consent agenda tonight they also appointed Mr Santana as assistant principal at Sheridan [Applause] prep he's been with us in a in a number of capacities since 2018 and uh made it through the vaunted uh application and interview process that included uh staff and families and students and District leaders and it's really nice and heartwarming to see our um most most recent leadership team at spa and now the current and uh future leadership team so uh we welcome you Alex and look

055forward to working with you thank you Miss grae back to you thank you we have a short but sweet policy action agenda for this meeting um I am here to encourage a action on policy number 5460 which is child abuse maltreatment or neglect in a domestic setting as you may recall from our last meeting we suggested a a small revision to the policy to specify that its definition of a school official which includes teachers school counselors and psychologists nurses social workers full or part-time athletic coaches building principles and any other school Personnel required to hold a teaching or administrative license or certificate uh that this definition only applies with regard to the requirements for reporting suspected child abuse or neglect uh which is the scope of this policy um then the other policy that we

056reviewed is 6110 budget planning and while we the board does not recommend any changes to the policy itself we did discuss and recommend uh changes to the accompanying regulation which as you'll recall uh regulations are put into place by the administration and the the committee recommended a CH a small change to this regulation to specify that the annual budget calendar will include dates for Board of Education actions related to the budget vote such as appointment of Po workers and selection of polling places and I welcome any questions thank you and just a procedural one since 6110 is just about the regulation we don't really need to vote on it right so we'll only be voting on 54 60 yes yes that's correct 6110r is just going going with it but we wouldn't be voting on

057that just just on okay may have a motion to adopt 5460 Miss Wilson Miss scy all in favor okay it passes thank you as is our normal practice we have arranged our agenda to have all the action items at the beginning unless something unexpected happens we do not anticipate the board will take any further action uh today uh the balance of the meeting will be items of for discussion some of which may lead to an action either at the next board meeting or a so that brings us to the next topic for discussion which is the grants update good evening everyone uh Miss Timmons is going to help me drive this car tonight so I appreciate her help with this uh we're going to go right to slide three if that's okay um so good

058evening I'm Dr Engelhart I am the I have the pleasure of being the director of Grants and program development I I said this last year it really does feel good to be home so I'm in month 19 back and uh appreciate uh again this opportunity to speak to you um so before you get to really look at the guiding principles I'm going to go to the next slide if that's okay because I took all of those words and made a a word cloud because it allows us to see some of those Salient words that kind of jump off the page at us and of course we see Grant we see program development and I've been thinking a lot about resource acquisition is really the heart of the work um it takes purposeful Focus um around

059the school and District priorities and goals and making sure that we really coordinate and facilitate to match those grant opportunities to our goals and priorities um I mentioned resource acquisition because um what I'm going to present today is a lot of financial um or fiscal data but it doesn't necessarily hit the resources that we receive that aren't monetary so for example we work with st peters's Health Partners um we have for for many years and they often give us resources around Wellness um they provide us stensils for re uh recess um type activities but we don't necessarily see that uh so a lot of what we do is behind the scenes with those that resource um acquisition and I'm as I was getting ready for uh this presentation tonight I was think if there's a

060way that we can codify that a little bit better so we can um give that information to the board and to the public um next next slide please so this is us this is the Grant's office um I'm knocking on wood uh because this is now year two of a stable staff um so uh we were able to uh add an assistant project coordinator for one of our after school programming grants um the district contracts thank you to the board and to the public contracts with um various grant writing services one being bosis the other one being Laura whan um who's an independent grant writer um and they really focus on those competitive grants that come across our desk and they do a lot of that narrative work for us um there are some project

061coordinators that aren't in this picture so I just wanted to publicly thank them many of them are staff that also work in our district but we we really are responsible responsible for program design program monitoring collection of data data analysis the monitoring of funds making sure we pinch every penny um we provide technical assistance to our buildings and our departments um and then also our Community Partners as well next slide please miss Timmons thank you so here's a list of 2425 new Grant Awards um I know Miss Powers had to scoot out but she received a chemical safety Grant um through a local organization that's providing additional funds for IC storage and safety some training around that as well we received uh the archive Grant some of you may be familiar with this we received

062this in 2223 as well so the PPS department is going to be utilizing those funds to digitize Student Records that are a bit archaic that they're dusting off so we're we're excited about that um I know we're going to talk a little bit more at our next board meeting about the resource allocation review um because the board is has received some information regarding regarding that but just for the Public's sake um this grant has allowed District administration to look at systems of equity um in our district and how we can more equit equitably disperse resources um to our students who who need those um so more to come around that there was additional School Improvement funds for gfin um I think at this time last year we just got word of the center for supportive

063schools Grant we did uh get awarded that um there's a program called the peer group connection which really focuses on student leadership and peer mentoring at the high school um so I that is starting to get underway and I'm sure miss comford will will talk about that the next time she's up presenting to the board um this one this last one this last bullet is interesting in that um the leaps program for those of you who remember the Empire State after school Grant we had from like 2017 um the office of child Family Services changed that to leaps and leaps is awarded directly to the community partner so we worked closely with the boys and girls club in the YMCA they were awarded that we provided technical support letters of commitment based on their history

064um we are still providing programmatic oversight for that we have um our teachers and staff still tutoring and getting paid through that funding store so I say that to say that when we get to some of the financial piece that's not part of it because we're we don't own that that fiscal piece so I just wanted to let you know but we are still having to monitor that okay Miss Tim's the next one if you don't mind so we talked about this last year a little bit recurring competitive grants are those that are funded annually um typically over multiple years they do require annual uh reapplication so some this slide kind of uh depicts those recurring competitive grants we have for this school year uh I Tred to think I think it's the educator in

065in may try to organize and categorize them so the first two bullets really are those Refugee service grants um so rip and the S2s the next two are some teacher pipeline initiative grants so the teacher Residency program and teachers of tomorrow and those last Six Bullets um I guess I would characterize them as intervention and enrichment grants or maybe even Cradle to career grants so thinking about all from our upk expansion program Grant to Smart Scholars which is that preol post high school work that students get credit for um and then all of those intervention types of Grants the office of mental health we partner with Parsons um it can event a homeless grant for those displaced families and students so it's really thinking holistically for the child support and again that Cradle to Career

066type of support for them next slide if you don't mind thank you um as a reminder and I think I went to a little bit more depth or maybe a question spurred a little bit more in-depth conversation last year we talked a lot about title but title funds is um what's considered a reoccurring allocational Grant and that is something that we anticipate receiving every year there's a little bit of fluctu fluctuation in what that um overall cost might be um but for the most part we we're guaranteed that for the most part I don't want to jinx myself some to knock on some wood again um but title funds are um are special education funding through idea uh School Improvement Grants and then um not only our upk that we get every year but also

067our Perkins Grant which funds our Career and Technical education um again I went into the title a little bit more because just want to again reiterate that we have to consult and collaborate with over 50 non-public schools um I think this year we had to reach out to Brooklyn Waldorf School they didn't respond but we we tried um so they're all over the place we have boarding schools we have to reach out to and then of course those that are within our catchment as well our summers are busy around that all right our next one and this is something this is newer information um that I did not include in our presentation last year but I wanted to at least bring U bring it to the attention of the board we are very proud of

068our community school model um and we didn't really talk about the funding around that last year so Community School Aid is actually considered a set aside from general fund um it's required by state Ed the district has treated this funding source as a grant um since its Inception um so it is under the purview of the department so we treat it like a grant uh the set aside is approximately $4.4 million um and has stayed at that threshold um as far back as I could as I could check so I just wanted to give you that information the other thing is I want wanted to publicly uh acknowledge the Tui Foundation um they are as many of you know a blessing to our community they fund uh regularly initiatives Around My Brother's Keeper to supplement

069that state program this year because they had some additional funds the high school started at my sister's keeper which is great and then Arbor Hill Elementary School has a regular allocation from the Tue Foundation as well and then uh lastly on this one I I did want the board to be aware that um and you'll see in some of the slides coming up that we still are liquidating American Rescue plan funds the the the obligation period ended at the end of September but for things that because of vendors and because of contractual services that they allowed us to have an extension around the liquidation of that which we're very thankful for so we're still a lot of our technology has come in but some of our contractual services are still working on all right and

070we'll start with the grant metrics so the next one I know that's I'm I apologize that that's so small um but I'll just have you take a look at that so those are our main categories again if you look at purchase Services you'll see how the blue is further out than the orange as we liquidate those American Rescue plan funds we anticipate that that that orange the expense line will grow around that as well and then the next one um so with covid fund sunsetting we are returning to some of our pre-co levels um just just to make everyone aware so our budget in 23 24 with some of that ARP was over 46 million in 2425 at this point um we have a budget about 31.5 million and so it's January last year I

071presented in February there's a possibility that some of the um this doesn't uh include the grants that are in the hopper right now so we had I lit I had a submit button today so positive energy um that might grow a little bit as well and and as um if when those things come out I'll do an sbu to the board so that you're aware of those things as well all right continuing our priorities um on going even my my my predecessor really um hammered these priorities and I think the maximizing of funds and ensuring internal controls was something that was really important it's really important to our department the last bullet was something I wanted to highlight this year um because as I I'm still fairly new into in this position I'm realizing how

072much of a resource we are the department is to the community so thinking about the partnering with like AF and some of our nonprofit organizations we do provide some technical support for them um knowing that it takes a village and we want to be able to help um network with them and give them the support um to better our children and our community and then our last slide so I liked what Miss Smith said about not going to uh focus on the Doom and Gloom um but we also I I I keep saying we're going to hope for the best plan for the worst and so with the upcoming Federal Administration we want to be cognizant of some of the federal funds that may not be coming our way like they may have been in

073the past and so we're going to just um do all the metaphor shake the tree keep our ear to the ground all the things um to make sure that we get the funding we need um to help our kids and sustain the things that we have um I met with Lauren um Laura whan this week regarding okay what if we don't get the full service Community School what can we do we started to brainstorm really looking at some local foundations some other really competitive types of grants that we may not have looked at before just to think creatively around how we can do that so I will say and for those who are are listening in if you have thoughts around funding sources we we will dig um so so I know some of you

074have already done that with hey have you looked at um feel free to send those things our way um so you'll see here that we are um part of we're going into resource allocation review part two again we'll talk a little bit more about that at our next board meeting um we are uh we're waiting for finalization for the teacher Residency program round two and just a quick um note about that we had one resident our first year we have five this year our resident for year one is a teacher in our district so the program is working so that's a great thing and we already have someone who's signing up for a attorney to leave so um we appreciate that those funds we are submitting this is the one I hit submit today was

075the farm to school Grant to support the toast stem program and their outdoor Gardens um someone connected me again people who who are connected connected me with Seymour Fox and so we're working with them to do some one school one book um plans folks um are sending in little types of Grants uh or requests for steuart's Holiday match so we're working that as well we have our ear to the ground around apprenticeship expansion grants and then those last two bullets are really from the federal from federal funding so we're going to keep our fingers crossed around those and um if that comes on the radar we're going to we potentially look at those as well and I think that's it I didn't keep it to 10 minutes I apologize I I tried any questions for

076me thank you start on that again miss man any questions I'm looking at the first of all wonderful presentation thank you I'm looking at the picture of um the number of staff that you have and then looking at all the things that you're doing and just how organized you are and and your your team and the output that it's providing to us so um it's pretty impressive and so thank you thank you Smith okay sir I have no uh comments really just pure praise for for you and your staff for the work you're doing um and I uh I did come across a couple of grants that I will forward your way I don't you know I'm always trying to be hopeful that they they might work for us um and some of them to

077do with really supporting uh School leaders of color uh in particular and that might help with some of our Equity U pieces so um hey it's worth a shot I say right so I will pass that along Kudos thank you very much so the same kudos for as as my colleagues we always appreciate hearing from you and all the good that you bring for our students um beyond what we can provide without the grant funding so it's very much appreciated I also appreciate it um and I remember feeling this way about Eileen as well um I think everybody has their mic on so anybody who's not talking if you could turn your mic off that will probably reduce the um Screech thank you um so is the the focus and the intentionality around Grant selection

078and not um spending resources writing grants that are not likely to be delivered I think that's really a critical aspect because it increases what we can do when we don't throw um Staffing Resources at Grants we're not likely to get which of course brings me to Safe roots to school which I know you know is a a question for me um and this is actually in part and I'm just flagging it the superintendent picks up his ears because I'm going to broaden it Beyond you um safe to school as you rightly pointed out is often given to municipalities rather than to school districts um and it is a grant-funded source for providing what it sounds like safe roots to school usually the safety is transportation related and I was wondering whether in your research in

079determining that it that it's a better Municipal Grant whether we'd had any um connections as you've described about interacting with our Community Partners of which the city of course is one to put together a save roots to school grant that is pretty common I I think because the schools and and the municipalities work together and did we do that Outreach to the city or would we be willing to do that Outreach to the city to look for an opportunity and then I'm going to broaden it just a little bit more to say we invest a lot of money in getting our students who live one and a half miles from school or more to school and we invest very very little in helping our students who live 1.5 and less in getting to school in

080part that's because of course it's not Transportation reimbursement and we're all well aware of that but I do wonder if it's a place where we could expend some additional resources whether they're Grant resources we bring in from the outside or whether they are general fund resources in that U 1.5 Transportation because we know that when kids are in our schools they do better um and getting kids to school is is a priority so it's really a two-part question one is sort of like would we look to the city to partner for a safe roots to school Grant and then secondly like can we start thinking bigger about what we can do for our our 1.5 and unders about providing snow removal safe by you know safety or organized things um and convenience I I was

081I I will say that we um we we did dive deep into this quickly not only because um Albin High's PTA reached out um and had some concerns but also within that same time there was some an incident that happened at at nams um so very quickly reaching out to those folks and working with them um they felt confident that and then simultaneously I think the mayor at that point was meeting with Mr hug Rider and M Mr leco um specifically around speed limits and so when that speed limit um came out it felt like we had partnered with them in that aspect to your point is there more we can do uh absolutely so what I'll do is I'll reach back out to my connections and just see what else they need from us

082um I did I had mentioned St Peter's Health Partners earlier in my presentation I also reached out to them um really around some of the biking um and the biking aspects they they did not know and again just with some informal conversations with our principles having bike rcks at school um and things of of that nature would be really helpful um so we started talk kind of going down that um Road pun intended I guess um around that to make sure that you know we were promoting that as well but it to your point we can you know we can reach back out to them to see at one point we I had submitted names for them to be on a for people to be on a committee and I don't know if they ever

083were called into partnership with that yeah there's been enough momentum through the city's uh coordination of vision Vision zero um long range planning walkable Albany Bicycle Coalition I I wrote down and Mr leco had to run into another commitment but um perhaps bringing these groups together under the um umbrella of our monthly Community Round Table to see who else we already regularly network with that we're not thinking of that can be a part of this and and have a think tank and a and a Planning Group for this purpose um I know the mayor uh through her work with the speed zone cameras and reducing speed there is already a there's sort of a working group over there that either we could join or they could can come on our side of the aisle but

084we'll certainly investigate that that would be great and I know that um there's certainly a feeling in the community that there's a there's some budgetary benefit to the city of school's own speed cameras um and it would be nice if that increased dollars were specifically uh refocused around schools and now the city has a difficult budget right their budget is not an easy one I don't envy them their budgetary situation so it's not like they're they've got you know cash to hand out but some combination of us and them and federal safe roots to school money might be a way that we could address some of our longstanding um pedestrian safety issues um and yes bike Rex would be lovely speaking as a person who would use them M graie uh thanks for your presentation

085I don't have any specific questions but I appreciate I I appreciate your efforts both to uh coordinate and coordinate the spending really work harder on that um internal control audit uh functionality of it I appreciate that that's getting a little bit cleaner because I know it's a lot of paperwork and regulations to get all your eyes dotted and your tees crossed for some of those things uh while also focusing on bringing in new money from new Grant sources so I was also excited to see some of those new sources that we haven't previously reached out to thank you M Wilson thank you for your presentation many of my colleagues such said things that have been would have been my question thank you again thank you for everything that you do uh in terms of Grant

086so stem grants know whenever I see them the American Chemical Society has some out there for schools and stuff I usually send it over I'll send it to you uh uh there are also small foundations that might be out there they may not be big parts of money but they might be parts of money that we could creatively use for helping our teachers in the schools do stuff that they normally wouldn't have you know um fund sitting around to do and now they can think creatively out of the box and offer that programming because of this extra funding that they can get for that small project I mean our kids at hack it if you know saw fourth year in a row they're sending experiments to space we can certainly help them do experiments on

087earth right the one other question I had was uh you know well a couple things one with the Department of Education don't know what the status is going to be but whatever it is if things get difficult I'm guessing that by the funds would still be there because some some of those Federal monies won't go away but getting access to them might be a little bit more difficult instead of going to One Source you to go four different ways for four different pieces of that same pie um so if you if your department needs help because you know we need those money right so anything we can do to help just let us know um also uh when it comes to contracts this is this is something that we mentioned the past two and the

088ad hoc routine committee uh the routine consent committee is looking at this too it's important for us to know what the return on investment is right so when when when whether it's a grandf funded thing or a a general fund expense uh knowing what that U contract is bringing in what happened last year you know are we is it worth renewing it what is it uh that didn't work having that information is good because then we can make sure we fix things and and grow our programs so just just a request thank you right moving on to another money matter budget update good evening um it's kind of crazy it's beginning the new calendar year and we're already starting to talk about the upcoming fiscal year and how our budget and how we're going to

089plan for and um to meet the needs of our students so this is the first presentation of many of the next upcoming five months um so this one's a little bit the shortest one because there's a lot of details and information that is not currently available yet but we're Gathering data from our individual School District or buildings sorry um and the needs for our school our children to make sure that they're successful so uh as always we keep our district vision mission and goal in mind as we present and our work on our budget uh our budget calendar which is this just a the next two months snapshot um but there's also the link on the bottom of the page for anybody that would like to see our full budget calendar they can see it

090there as Miss grae said our new calendar has more information on it especially with information that we need to do as a a district and a board as who to appoint locations one of the biggest things coming up is our and an upcoming slide is about the oh I moved too fast there a couple sides down where we have to we're looking for a new location for 14th W polling location I've reached out to many uh Community areas or members and we're just waiting for another uh response for them if we can utilize their space for the 14th word poll where last year was Myers Middle School but that goes with the January 30th date where we have to um ask the Civil Rights I just want to make sure I get it right um

091we have to submit to the Office of the Attorney General's civil rights Bureau for the New York State Voting Rights Act so that's the upcoming biggest hurdle for us as a as a district as I go back um 2425 budgetary notes there's some uncertainty for the state Foundation Aid due to the Rockefeller Institute recommendations that were released this past December there are many variables within their recommendations and how it to adjust this Foundation aid for each and every District um as of right now if the current Foundation Aid formula was used Statewide there would be an increase of Aid of $1.4 billion but the initial estimate is only $950 million so you can see that there's a short fall right right off the Gap right off the start for the state budget we'll know more

092more next week with the State of the State and then as the state adopts their budget uh we'll get more information there as well um as for our budgetary notes we would like to continue our existing programs and services to help our students succeed um we have our contractual obligations our operations we have 19 school buildings um a lot of infrastructure a lot of Staff a lot of students so we want to make sure that we continue with all that um and we also continue to monitor our overtime and related work that's one of our biggest line items within our budget as well uh the Staffing ratios this is one slide that we will continually see as we go through our budget uh season uh one of the nicest things about what we did in

093this current year is we did the position control which makes this report a lot easier and thank you for Kate that's I appreciate that that was a good push and it helped us out a lot uh as you can see one of the things is our enrollment number it did go up by by about 500 students 450 to 500 students which is great for us which also change our ratio at the bottom as we get more numbers they'll get into the table and as we work on our staffing for next year there'll be an additional column for estimate for next year I am Frozen oh there we go never mind um as far as there's a lot of work that we do behind the scenes for our legislative priorities and budgetary impacts so the priorities

094um there's also the document on the bottom there's a link for that so if anybody would like to see it I think it was adopted in early December as a board uh again it's the equal prek funding the 2.2 to $2.7 million that would help fund us as a whole as a district to help make our prek program um very successful not that it isn't but it will just help us out without using the general funds within um that area support for our teacher pipeline grow our own initiative we're asking for $300,000 uh the charter school over saturation and the support for enl and Refugee students of $3 million uh again the variables right now the state aid the state of the state is next week um the final state aid will be released in

095March or April health insurance increases the tax cap which will be finalized in late February the tax levy that will be set in early April and impact of retirements again the 14th board polling locations uh we've I've reached out to many locations uh we should have a discussion and action on the next agenda to uh approve a location within the 14th Ward um again it's the timeline is so that we can meet the regulation of the New York State Voting Rights Act to make sure that that location is approved by the Civil Rights Bureau our next steps we are reviewing the bilding request finalize the district priorities and make the recommendations to our Board of Education we will always incorporate new information as it becomes available we are continuing to review projects budget estimates and

096assumptions uh respond to board questions incorporate feedback from board community and staff continue legislative advocacy efforts as well so again this is one of the shortest budget presentations as we just start the the season any questions man I do not I know this is ongoing we're going to have them at each meeting the updates um as we get closer and closer um and so I appreciate this very helpful I will say one of the best things is positioning control um definitely a lot more easy for me to interpret right so thank you thank you for that Miss Smith Miss Smith uh I'll pass this go around if you come back thank you savage no questions just a thank you to you for all of the work to date and in particular on your uh attention

097to the issue of the 14th board polling place um and an encouragement when you do submit it to the Civil Rights Bureau to clarify that Myers was a one-year um you know stop Gap because of some changes that happened with our prior polling place rather than a longstanding one um so that it's this is not actually a change so much as a reversion to normal um for for our our folks who live live in the 14th and part of the eth ward as well and it is part of the four eth right I think it's not just the 14th it's maybe four election districts of the eth as well so M grey uh no questions right now thank you miss wison m m SMI thank you um and probably a little too early for this

098but I I was thinking a couple of things um our technology our one toone computer uh things um I'm I assume we are building into the budget the cost of replacement or repair and all of those things I think I just want to kind of I'm keeping that on my mind I want to kind of get a sense of the the cost of that increasingly um because we're definitely not going back we're you know we're only going to keep moving with that um and then um relatedly in a way I was and again probably premature before we hear from the state of the state but um is anybody hearing anything on the cell phone issue in terms of what the governor might do and whether that's a cost that we will bear any cost that

099we will bear or that the budget state budget will include yeah I I can weigh in a little bit we had some pretty good sources that thought um there would be a a plan uh unveiled or a position of the governor unveiled last last month in December um when we were invited to uh send students to the round table on Monday that I talked about earlier um I don't know if I can say this round isn't here so I will um the ADV the advance uh the governor's Advance Team came to Albany High School to see if the High School auditorium would be a viable um setting and um it was they just wanted to have you know bigger venue I I guess uh and and we were a little concerned that she was going

100to unveil a cell phone ban in front of an auditorium full of high schools or high schoolers but um we believe that there will be a policy um statement on Tuesday um our Advocate many of our advocacy groups whether it's the superintendent Council or the Big Five have pushed that if there is to be um a demand or an expectation that there is a ban that um this is not an unfunded mandate so that's where sort of the the the deliberations have left off and then not only an unfunded mandate but there are very few companies that do this work so now are we creating a a monopoly and a lot of other things now maybe that has been the delay in laying out the um the policy statement over the last six weeks I

101don't know but I do anticipate something being said on Tuesday and the groups who are representing us are saying that this cannot be one more unfunded mandate but be beyond that chatter I don't know anything else okay it's too early to ask questions um but you know when when you talked about the um um digital devices uh that just reminded me we have the smart school funds that we also apply for and that usually we use it for you know making sure our equipment gets renewed on a regular basis and today I saw somewhere that the you know the night said where they put up the demographics and all of those information they also have a new tab there for digital equity in your District or School uh so that is something that we should

102be I I didn't get a chance to fully explore it but uh look at that and and and see uh that you know we are as close to 100 as possible um because I saw that like my first glance was we were not 100 we were 90 something but you know but identifying who are the ones who because I I assume that are postco we were onet to one with the devices U but it could just be that the reporting was more in terms of some kids are using their own computers and not District computers so I I haven't quite analyzed the data um but you know all of these things are good things for us to be keeping in mind especially when we go with our begging ball in the next few months to

103see what we can get in scr up uh because every dollar that we can get for our kids is more opportunities we can provide for them so more questions to come thank you that is all the topics we have for discussion board committee reports sure we'll start on this side okay uh let's see so the first one is the um uh facilities committee uh we met just the other night Tuesday um and uh we uh will be preparing uh along with our partners uh for a presentation I believe on the 20 on the 23rd I'm not sure if that's on your agenda yet superintendent but I believe we're giving a a capital project update at that time um we will be meeting uh again on uh the 14th and um we will uh uh get

104that information um up for uh public notification um but we you know we're coming towards the end of our um uh High School rebuild and and some of our uh Capital uh fiveyear Capital plan projects and so uh we want to make sure that everyone knows what that work has has been about and that it is uh or will be substantially substantially complete um and we do have some things that will continue at the high school just through the summer like the tennis courts and some other um other tweaks and so forth um so anyway we're just excited to keep seeing uh that building uh take take the final shape and form um being U fairly state to state-of-the-art for our youngsters um and so that's going on um the second um committee that I

105have is the uh student ad hoc committee on uh board student representative to the board I don't know if that's actually the right T title but you know what I mean and um that work is just starting off and that again has to do with a a law I think it's education law 25 two section 10 applies to us which uh requires our school district along with others but specifically this this particular section applies to small City schools and so we are working uh number one to uh determine a or to determine a process that we would recommend for selecting uh a high school student or two two because it has to be at least one uh for um representing the student body uh on the uh board and uh so we had one really

106great high school meeting uh in December uh I should say meeting with the High School uh GSA faculty MBK faculty msk faculty um that was great and we had another meeting uh this morning um excuse me this afternoon uh with uh principal comford uh where we began to lay out the next steps of uh the work that we want to do want to make sure we have uh spoken with as many of our school uh stakeholders I should excuse me let me say our diverse Community um at every school uh to get their input into that selection process um and uh so that's going well and you're going to start to hear from the committee about ways in which we will'll roll out um some steps to um to solicit that feedback uh it will

107involve a series of meetings uh one just uh earlier this week was with cabinet to get their feedback and uh and we had a couple of cabinet members that will that volunteer to take on a couple of pieces uh to explore I won't even get into what they're exploring right now but to to help us uh provide some incentives that would um encourage our students to partake um in or at least express interest in applying perhaps for um a SE a seat on the board um so really want to increase that student voice get them excited about this because it won't be just this year or you know it'll be every year uh for for the for the whatever um and we want to make sure that our students are engaged so so um we

108believe I would like to say that we would be coming to the policy committee on some levels we have some I think uh sufficient information to to take some things to the policy committee now um uh and I'm I can speak to uh Miss C about how she feels about that um but at least that would get you all started um there are also some so those are things that would have to do with policy some research that we've done Etc but then there also have to be are some things about the actual uh implementation of the process and so uh we're working with the school high school to get that going but uh couple other series of meetings we want to make sure that every um School building leader administrator and staff have information

109about this requirement and I sorry I hate calling it requirement because it's so compliancy I think it's really an opportunity um and that's trying that's how we're trying to also sell this um so that would mean that our staff would also be invested in ensuring that student voice um is is uh is um available uh to us here at the board level and we want to make sure that voice uh is captured uh all at every level from elementary to high school so we're trying to bless you we're trying to work on what that process looks like so anyway not not to go too on and on but um I really um it's been exciting to talk about this initiative with um staff and uh as well we're getting to do that uh shortly with

110the GSA and other student group groups um and so um we're working it um and I appreciate uh the assistance of uh certainly Mr Eli and Miss Wilson uh in this process Miss Wilson anything you want to add on any of this that all no okay sorry I went on too long did you say no just kidding um at any rate uh thank you all and we'll we'll keep you posted on sort of our steps and uh and I will speak with Miss C about um how to maybe get the committee's work maybe started a little bit sooner just because I think we've captured quite a few things that that can get them started okay um and and that because the reason for doing that is because that deadline is going to hit us before

111we know it uh we we all have to satisfy the requirement by the end of the school year and um so we don't want to we want to stay ahead but we don't want to get um get don't want to get behind in the process so thank you thank you for all your efforts okay policy thank you policy committee meeting next Wednesday at 5:30 uh We've switched our meetings for January and I believe either February or March to be not the same week as the board meeting um just works better for everyone's schedules and to allow us to prepare and looking forward to anything from the student ad hoc committee because I'm also really excited about that work and and you know I can't wait to have student Voice once again represented as someone on

112our board participating in our conversations especially with what's going on there there it would be great to have that firsthand perspective um that somebody can understand a little better the situation on the ground thanks conratulations dam is all ready to go uh government relations will be government relating next Friday uh we will be meeting with our local delegation um as referenced by U Mr Caris we all adopted last time our legislative priorities and we thank the district and in particular the Communications Department for the excellent um Improvement to the look and feel of that document it really has the district branding and the district um the high quality of District um graphic design that we've grown accustomed to in other efforts and I think that that will um be received very well by our local

113delegation and then I will also slide in um School visitation committee you look for an email from me yesterday but I didn't get to it so maybe tomorrow um asking you all for your availability because we will go back um it I have also invite your comment um my inclination is to try to not have people visit the same schools they visited last year so that people will get a better opportunity to see more variety of schools if you feel differently about that you can say so now and this is public or you can say it in an email to me whatever um but that is my thought is that I'm going to try and um move people around a bit so that everybody gets a chance to see different kinds of schools uh Miss

114Smith yes so miss saage just one um question on that so one of the approaches that we're trying to do uh with the student committee is we will be trying to meet with every student Equity Group so I think I feel like that's different than a school visit right okay but nonetheless I do love to get credit for being in the building and having those conversations with with youngsters but that'll come out another way but I just wanted to make sure that yeah I that doesn't sound like a school visit it sounds like committee work I mean we we have a formal process for these School visits and we'll consist with that but it's fabulous that you have the capacity and are able to do that that is amazing tempting to do that yes good

115job well done I I have a question regarding the student visitation uh sorry the school visitation is and it is does the school visitation committee at any uh with or without board input want to develop parameters for what a school visit should be you know should there be a minimum amount of time a principal expects to spend in we have done that and if you haven't reviewed it I'd be happy to resend it to you but yes that was all worked out through a um collaborative process between the um board and the superintendent and cabinet and it's um all clearly spelled out and hopefully I will I will send it to you again so you can excellent I remember the part about not taking notes but that's the only part I explicitly there's a fair

116amount more and I will be happy to resend it to you I just want to ask another aspect of um this discussion is ask another dimension what about the um I think it's only in recent years that we've truly tried to wait to be invited per se versus you know maybe stalking social media to figure out what an event is happening and seeing you know so um often the event we see it on social media for example but we would I just want to know if we're going to break down that protocol so yeah I want to clarify that I'm only talking about the formal School visits when there is a public event in a school that is open to the public you everyone should just go um yes we can I do sometimes but

117I think there's also another dimension of us being board members that was brought up over the years and we reduced doing that so I would love to see so I'll let the superintendent speak to that but the documentation that we worked through is my understanding is that for public events board members are encouraged to attend whenever they can to make sure you introduce yourself to the principal as you come in so that they know you're there um and to participate as any Community member would this I personally have only taken responsibility on the school visitation committee for these formal School visits where we come during the school day meet with the principal take a tour visit some classes that's the piece that I feel like is my responsibility beyond that I leave at the discretion

118superintendent and the officers to to address so I don't know if you wanted to add anything yeah yeah just I think um correct on on both accounts the school visitation was really around um celebrating the school's work it's sort of a little bit of either a followup or a Prelude to the school presentations we hear about highlights um the board had a desire to basically see it in action and so as Miss Savage said we created some protocols we worked with our um principles about where the time is best spent in terms of uh public facing school events you are all more than welcome if you want to give anyone a courtesy heads up you can do that too but but not required and we hope that you can participate in events that uh fit

119your schedule yeah the whole point of these visits is so that we you know we hear more about what what's happening in those buildings over and above what we have here at the the public uh board meetings but also for a chance for those building leaders to um present some challenges right to us and say you know things that they've been trying to get through system hasn't they feel like they haven't been hurt well here's your opportunity so this is sort of like a one-on-one with those leaders uh and and to to see both the to celebrate everything that's happening in the building but also to hear about concerns that we could bring back to through our board process uh U you know to whatever needs to be done so um it's all good so

120I'm glad that we are doing it I mean we were doing it but not in a formal way but in the last year we've been doing it in more formal way um so thank you audit thank you the audit committee will meet on Monday the 13th at 5:30 5 5:45 here okay at Harry gons thank you thank you and uh again this is U lobbying advocacy government relating uh days so I I I hope you guys notice uh that NBA's lobbying day will be on the 7th and the 14th of February so I don't know if you have plans to attend the virtual Lobby session as well as the uh you know going and meeting our our assembly and Senate leaders um to explain so you know the more opportunities we get to tell them

121what our priorities are I think is um we might be better heard so okay any other items uh for the great or good if not um motion to adjourn okay Miss Wilson miss gry all in favor

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.