CorpusRecord 59420

Board of Education Public Meeting | Live Stream | December 19th, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / City School District Of Albany
Date
2024-12-20
Location
Albany County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
35,033 words · about 195 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening good evening my name is sh chur I'm president of the city school district of wman board of education on behalf of the board I welcome you all to our meeting today we have all our board members uh present we have uh m Mii Miss Smith Miss Wilson Miss CI Miss Savage and M Damas we have the super many of the cabinet members here with us this meeting is being live streamed and the instruction to view the meeting as well as the link to the agenda including all the documents we will discuss are available at alchool store.org SLV this is a good time for me to note that if you're here today to speak in public common you should sign up with Miss timens or board clerk here to my right

002uh with that introduction we invite those of you who choose to join us as we stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all in addition to the Pledge of Allegiance we always focus our meeting by restating the mission of the city school district of Albany which is to work in partnership with our diverse Community to engage every Learner in a robust educational program designed to provide the Knowledge and Skills necessary for Success superintendent Haw riter do you have a report for us we do and I'll turn it over to Mr leco to get us started thank you and good evening uh it is our pleasure to begin

003tonight's District highlights with some festive Sounds of the Season uh we are glad to welcome these Albany High School Coral students under the direction of Brendan Hoffman and I will turn it over to Mr Hoffman to take it from here d Merry Christmas christm timeas [Music] youing out on his it's the little it's the little [Music] little G [Music] the [Music] Christmas Merry [Music] Christmas reeee [Music] [Applause] you know Dasher dancer Ander andx and and [Music] and you the most Ree of all Rin [Music] sh Santa came to rud with your so bright you [Music] all down in his story [Music] was following me I was following me I was following me [Music] fall [Music] oh oo was the swallowed in their [Applause] with [Music] [Applause] fall in [Music] I was swollowing the P swallowing

004the cups rat to head fall [Music] and straw in [Music] [Applause] and board members if you would just come out we'll take a few pictures e e e while Mr Le go uh transitions I just want to again thank um Brendan and all of our music teachers over the last number of meetings gearing up for the holidays we share our our uh concert schedule and the public facing concert schedule that our students perform in is just maybe 20% of really um what uh some of our student groups uh where they're traveling and and performing a number of the folks you saw today the troubadors the men's group group uh performed at the aun last Friday I uh saw them perform there um representatives from both of these groups are traveling all over the cap region

005uh singing at nursing homes and and other places the jazz band plays tomorrow night on on Friday night as we wrap up the the year but um a really big thank you to our music teachers that are um providing opportunities for these kids to play um out and about and in professional venues and and learning what it's like to um be a musician I I don't know uh where Mr Caris is on our budget development next year but I'm sure we'll have a request for a tour bus or something um and tomorrow I was teasing some of the kids tomorrow is probably the first full day they'll have back in school that they're not traveling and Performing somewhere but I wanted to uh to make that known that uh uh they are certainly uh representing

006our our school district and everything that we're about uh in many many different places not just our our evening concerts and with that I'll throw it back to Mr alesco thank you and they are a very tough act to follow but we have just the people for the job it is now our pleasure to welcome outgoing shared and Preparatory Academy principal Zulo Sanchez Gale and incoming principal Tina casone to tell us about the great things happening at their school this year maybe oh there we go so I just want to um share my sincerest gratitude because I can't think of a better way to spend my last evening as the um Sheridan Preparatory Academy principal than to be here with you all um right right in the throws of the holiday shopping season and so

007um it is just Tina and I we did um allow our other um staff members the opportunity to do their last minute shopping tonight um and so I guess we can get started um do other schools read this to you the district Miss okay okay okay so let's talk a little bit about our school um our vision mission and goals have not changed um primarily because I think it they truly do meet the needs or at least still F still are true about what we want to do for our school and so sherid and prep works on being the gateway to the greatness of our students Futures we believe in being a strong foundation for our students um our mission is that we believe that all teachers students family members will expect the best and

008all we do do learn all we can and strive to achieve our fullest potential um we definitely wanted to include all of the stakeholders that make it possible for students to succeed and our goal is to have the daily expectation of student engagement with higher level learning and complex tasks in a positive and culturally responsive learning environment where students are given intentional opportunities to demonstrate success and that is actually um our um crafted staff crafted definition of rigor and so when we talk about rigor at sherid and prep it is a daily expectation for students and this is us so um it was very daunting to just to see um like my name up there in principal and I'm I I know en to here for like our final time gets me a little choked

009up um but I'm super excited about what we've done for the last eight years together and what I hope to do foring forward and so we would not be complete without Lloyd John johnon III our homeschool coordinator who works diligently in addressing barriers for our families um so that we can make sure as many of our students come to school as often as possible and our newest member is um at least for now right is Kamisha Austin she is our new community site coordinator she started in November and she's been ripping and roaring um you know making connections with the community and certainly I think living up to the to the name of um sherid and prep a community school so now you have our demographics and what I will point to about our demographics

010is that they have been consistently changing um our school has um become really a more Multicultural than it had been in the past and so at this point our black students only make up 50% % of our school population our Latino students are coming in strong and they have been increasing in in the population and so they're at 30% our Asian students are at six multi-racial students are at seven we have our white students at 7% and there is one indigenous student and that put brings us at three% and I know exactly who he is he's a cute little guy this is our School demographics right now we hold 24% of students with disabilities our English language Learners are 25% and our economically disadvantaged students are 79% so um what we did for our step

011focus and highlights where these are our goals for our um indicators or for our commitments so in ela we our goal is to increase student achievement by ensuring that all students engage in listening speaking reading and writing daily with consistent and relevant teacher feedback and so we are we have been planning or implementing and monitoring our tier one plans for small group instruction we provide opportunities for students to engage in lesson work and access and develop our students funds of knowledge and so the the more Layman way of saying some of that is essentially we want to be clear about what gaps our students have and so through the state assessments what we have noticed is that we needed to build up their ability and stamina to write and write for long periods of time

012one of the things that we are intently focused at as sherid and prep is that um or committed to I want to say we're committed to the idea that the New York state exam cannot be the hardest exam that our children see at the in in the school year right and so because of that for ELA writing became a real big focal point because our students are showing us that they can write it's just whether or not they can write and for the length of time that the New York state exam demands of them in those two days um and so uh we are really working hard to provide our children with the opportunity to show us that's when we say the funds of knowledge to show us what they know about certain topics um

013so that we're not starting um our lessons or our instruction with from a deficit model where we think our kids have nothing to contribute to what is being taught and so similarly to in math we are developing and implementing daily grade level learning opportunities to engage students in problem solving justifying thinking and persever persevering with purposeful teacher feedback and so we are focused on making sure that our students are showing their thinking because then that allows our teachers to make the adjustments on miscon from misconceptions versus um as much as um the com as long as the common core standards have been around students still um have the bad habit of just wanting to give the answer um and so then what you miss out in just getting the answer is what their thinking is

014and sometimes their thinking is sound it's just that the answer is wrong and so we want to make sure we can help them make those adjustments or recognize where those ERS are so that they can be more successful um one thing that we're always very excited at to do in sharid and prep is our teachers do conduct peer observations and what that looks like is a teacher will invite other teachers to their classroom to come in and observe a lesson um sometimes they plan the lesson together and then um the teachers all meet together with our instructional coaches both our instructional coaches um Jennifer Wilson our Ela or Humanities coach and Megan Dixon our stem coach they uh will parti they will lead this kind of work with the peer observations and then conduct reflective

015um sessions where teachers can talk about what went well what are some adjustment that need to be made and so what we find at sherid and prep is that the best teachers are our teachers um and and it's an exciting thing to see so next up a big one for us is cell um so integrating cell practices and language across content and special areas to foster a positive School culture um so some of this touches on what we do every single day soell is very important in of course the threat of all schools but like all the other district schools we do follow using resources like ruler we also implementing a summerin program which is more of a primary base because while our students can say I feel mad we also want them to understand

016what to do when you feel mad or when the feelings coming on like how can you make choices and react in a different way so teaching kids how to regulate emotions and get back to Baseline is probably just as important as teaching them the ABCs and the one 123s like having them understand what it is to move around the school community and be a good citizen is super important and so it's really important for us to start the school year and doing um like different six week cycles of having them really understand our PBIS 3bs and I'm sure if anyone's visited if you speak to any of our students they really can tell you what our expectations are um which we're super proud of they know where they want to go to school and how

017they want that environment to feel in so I think the work that we're doing in cell we just keep thinking about like what else can we do to kind of give them real life skills to understand what it feels like to move around in the world and sometimes it doesn't always feel good but so that they can really um be able to kind of interact when they're having like the negative emotions as well as positive and so that too should be coupled with like anxiety and as they get older in the grades and maybe feeling some pressure for grades or testing that too is like tied into how you're feeling and so I'm really proud of the team we have built and the structures I think the students have told us year and again when

018they do their surveys that school is a very safe place for them and they feel like they are learning skills and so I am very confident that we'll continue just to grow this in practice um and so this will always probably be one of our biggest um Step Pooles and highlights just to keep kind of forging forward okay so here are the numbers for attendance and so our threeyear daily attendance rate Trend um you can see and this is um so what I Tred to do with this particular number was just compare our school years from September to December to right now because this is the data I'm sharing with you today for um 2425 so you can see we were at 91% two years ago last year we were at 93% and this year

019we're at 92% um we are finding specific grade levels to be um a little more absent than others and so we are focusing our um our communication I want to say our communication because we use Dojo often and we do um send um weekly messages to the entire School of the grade levels that are doing really well and then we send personal messages to the grade levels that we'd like to see an improvement in so we're communicating that with families um and also um I think we and we've done a great job communicating it with our students our students get very excited about hearing their class having 100% attendance for the day currently our chronic absenteeism rate is at 26% and at the end of the year of um this past um year in 24

020we were at 37% and so if you go to the next slide I we can speak to a little bit of what we started to do um this year um so I don't know if you guys remember our presentations year to year but we have been really focused on attendance at Sheridan prep we have this um saying called The Power of attend dance and so we focused on 10 in attendance and encourage our families to not miss more than 10 days of school and so what we notice with our data year after year is that um some families are just chronic it we've put all of our efforts in and we've tried to address all of the barriers but they are always chronic and so we're still following our procedures and our protocol and providing

021them with the supports but the leg work that Mr Johnson has been doing like the primary focus of like his home visits and his communication has really lived with with our friends at the 81 and 94% um as opposed to our friends who are living below 80% and so we've been leaning more on our attendance officer to handle those families and do that work and so what Mr Johnson has been really working hard on is making sure that our families understand that they don't have to be chronic right or that they're this far from being chronic or that they have if there's if their child is sick oh okay they've been out for two days listen and this is how he talks listen Ma you only have eight more days right so we're trying to

022keep our families in the loop and I think that is um why our chronic rate has really shrunk because we're hitting that 81% to 90% and we're trying to keep them on this side of chronic um and so it feels like their attendance last year was Within Reach of not being chronic and so that's why we strategically targeted them this year I think that that says all the stuff there oh so our school highlights so we definitely will always stick behind our community school model it is completely a game changer A Difference Maker our enrichment hour it allows for common planning time this is not only just beneficial for our teaching staff but the students are getting such enriching experiences they're able to rotate in different cycles and so they have we have partners that

023come in and they're just getting something we wouldn't be able to squeeze within the school day um so it's really a TW twofold win-win in um also supporting our families we try really hard to come out with our families a very in a positive way of having really our ears listening to what their barriers are and then how can we support them and because we have so many things internally it's nice to be able to really listen to what their needs are and then make offerings that maybe they wouldn't be able to get without having a u um the community school model um we have so many social emotional resources and I do believe that our parents are starting to recognize they don't have to worry about maybe making appointments or getting their kids somewhere

024they can just come to school there's a lot of adults that are there to help them and our community agencies I have to say have been amazing with just feeling like they're part of the school so so I think families really recognize I can come to school with my child but then I can leave with so much more than just knowing they're in school getting an education so we will always be a big aate for that model because it's really helped Chev and prep and the Chev and prep community so these are our data Trends um and so what you're seeing in front of you are the pr preliminary um 2023 2024 New York State data and so I am very proud to say that for the second year in a row sherid and prep

025is an LSI school so we are a good school in good standing um however I will tell you that um as a school we are not losing our eye on what the real Target is and it's to be a level four school um and so what you see is we are in our subgroups we are solidly a level two school um the thing that is really nerve-wracking about being a level two school is that you're within the 10 10.1 and 50th percentile in the state and that can mean so many many things and so um whenever I get data I just take it and try to make some formulas so that we can figure out where we might be specifically um because what is important to me is that we we know and understand what

026our next step is and in order to know what our next step is we really need to know are we a lowlevel two School are we a high Lev two school or are we solidly in the middle and So based on the calculation um it looks like we average out as to being a solidly in the middle Sher uh level two school in the state is this is like in the state right and so um that means that there's still much work to be done um and while we are still a good a school in good standing we are still running the marathon the smaller um table shows you what our growth metrics would be and so for growth um we are a solidly level four school and so that I think is really encouraging

027because what that show shows us is that being a level three school is definitely within reach so for us our main challenges is in being a school and good standing um we did lose a lot of State funding from the school Improvement Grants and so what ended up happening for us is a lot of our well we do not have interest based after school clubs at this time because those were funded through the school Improvement Grant um and so with the Community Schools money that we had we wanted to protect our common planning time and so we're still paying our partners for being at the school but we're paying them so that we can still allow our teachers the opportunity to sit with their um coaches and with their grade level C colleagues and do

028the very important work of continuing to grow their practice while still providing our students with an opportunity to have some enrichment um but they definitely miss basketball and and soccer and um we used to have a coding Club as well so they miss those things um we are a neighborhood school and so Transportation does impact attendance especially in the winter time um our neighborhood is not typically one of the priorities of the snow cleaning in Albany and so our families may have to walk up to 1.5 miles in the actual street because the sidewalks are not clear um and so that is something that they don't have any control over um but I will tell you that those transportation is a challenge for us Mr miles is certainly a partner in the work for us

029and at every turn he is always there to try to help us find ways to to get our kids to school and and I'm just going to say he's sitting right here um I can't thank you enough because it is hard to get the babies to school especially in the winter time but you never say no to us you're always like how can we problem solve this and so you don't know what a hero you are to us for that so thank you okay successes oh here they go we love the success L um so having the uh status being LSI is a great success we are definitely celebrating our success um and it's awesome to see the level of commitment from our staff because while we're celebrating like what we just talked about our

030staff recognizes that we are at the beginning of the race too so I'm very proud of them for that the staff commitment to moving students to proficiency we've talked about this all the time we're not going to quit until we're a Blue Ribbon School um I always say I want everyone to understand that sherid and prep is the address that everybody should want to be at and we are going to be the change agent for the district and I think the staff is like rallied behind that um we are making amazing progress our in-house PDS which those are not mandated for people who don't realize ize it they are always packed our teachers do not have to go but they are there all the time and they are always asking for additional PDS or wanting

031to get together to figure out like what else we can do our attendance shift is pointing to a lower chronic rate which is so hard for people that don't know attendance and getting out of that chronic rate but we are pushing the important of attendance to the daily rate and I would say that for our families and our students too they all are feeling the sense of urgency and accountability which to me is the biggest C culture and climate change um coming out of Co I think everybody kind of struggle to get back on their feet but I think our kids like they want their school to be the best school ever and they want to be at school and they are so competitive so for all these reasons we've really seen a lot of

032success in our building and we've also feel the success and the continuation of wanting to feel that so I'm super proud of where we are and I'm super excited for where we're going to go all right so time for the student voice you are hearing from um student council members because our officers have been busy interviewing everyone and so um participating in all the interviews and so these are um four members of our student council hello everyone and we are so excited to talk about some we all love shared and prep I'm saf and I think our school is amazing because our teachers really care about us they teach us so much and they make learning fun that's right s I'm gaana and I love all the awesome fots we get to go on one

033of my favorites was visiting the museum we got to learn about mummies and ancient times and I and it felt like we were traveling back in history oh di that sounds cool I'm Maurice and one of the things I love most about sharing prep is our enrichment schedule we get to try so many new things like coding basketball and other fun activities I've learned so much and had so many new experiences I'm Rose and one thing I really enjoy is bending of scale like my musical scale shed and prep give us so many way to grow and I love getting to expel my TI and you know what our school isn't just about learning it's about creating Memories We have tra Traditions here that make every year so special like our Thanksgiving Day PR we

034get to March through the gym and celebrate together at a school family we're caring on the stairs singing holiday songs together fills our whole school with joy music and how could forget read Across America R dressing up has our favorite book character or rocking mustache on mustache Monday that's the best see our teachers and staff make shared and prep a place where we love to learn they are so care and creative and always coming up with fun ideas like that Eola activity where we turned our classroom into a restaurant it was so cool and made learning even more exciting and we can't forget to thank Mrs Lumis our student council advisor she is amazing and always help us work hard and do our best yeah with Miss Lumis guiding us student council is all about

035making Shar the prep even better we are so lucky to have teacher and leaders who cares about us so much and helped us go learn and S and succeed that's why that's why we love sh because here learning is fun and everyone is family here come Rose oh so I want to shout out Safi Giana Maurice and Rose because they really do represent our school um Safi is someone who started with us then left and then came back so we do have a lot of students that that happens um Gian and Maurice are sherid and prep born and raised they've been there since prek and Rose is a recent um she is a newcomer who has been in our country for less than a year so awesome sauce yes thank you and that concludes our

036district highlights for 2024 all right we'll transition to uh the district update here uh couple items of uh importance here for our our community and then our uh for our Board of Education community so uh we had a number of uh Community engagement opportunities uh with uh thanks to Mayor Sheen first on Monday we had a number of our uh staff first with our pupil Personnel uh Team uh and some District officials and our high school principal met with uh newly elected officials that will uh begin their work after the new year uh mayor she Sheen convene the group a number of months ago and uh we wanted to wait until the elections were settled both the um uh both uh June's election and then also uh the final election in in November uh so

037there we met with family court judges uh the new district attorney and the uh new interim police chief was there and we talked about the experience that uh our leaders were having with students and families that U needed additional support that we needed support from the city and the county uh and to determine whether or not uh some of the recent Justice reforms have had uh intended or unintended impacts on schools and students and so we were able to share some data we able to share some uh some stories and uh really highlight uh opportunities where perhaps um we could continue this work to uh identify either Alternatives or additional programs uh while some of these Justice reforms are are considered for Amendment going forward uh after the meeting our principal Miss cumerford led a

038tour of the building for a number of our newly electeds and uh I know that they were very uh impressed with the commitment that this board and Community has made yesterday and Wednesday uh the city Brook ground on the Albany West Community Center uh this is the former Boys and Girls Club on Livingston Avenue uh this is in collaboration with the West West Hill Community we learned at the groundbreaking a number of community engagement opportunities that the city undertook uh with uh common council members in that area to really understand what some of the needs of the community were so there will be opportunities for adult programs and certainly programs to support our uh school age children there in West Hill as well uh they work uh will begin in the coming weeks uh and

039um this is just one of many Investments the city has made including lean Park and Hoffman Park to improve facilities and opportunities for all of our community members but particularly our students uh St Rose is back in the news uh Albany County and the Pine Hills land Authority purchased the property uh by way of bid last week uh we have toured uh two facilities at uh St Rose both St Joseph's Hall and the LLY School of Education this took place over the summer um when St Rose uh made it known that they would be uh selling off part part of their campus and so uh we uh did a free look we were window shopping to determine uh if that centralized location uh could meet the needs of not only our district but also certainly

040our families uh right here at Harriet Gibbons is really our uh Central Hub uh for parents who are registering while we do have Academy Park downtown that houses our our district office operations right here at Harry Gibbons is Central registration special ed Transportation PPS and maintenance we also have other academic programs scattered throughout the district we have our early childhood uh leadership team at Ash we have a number of academic uh members of our Academic Teams at uh tcce and other places uh so this provided an opportunity to see if any of the uh buildings at St R could meet our needs we certainly have a lot more to learn um we have some follow-up meetings uh with the Albany County uh authority to learn what their next steps are and what their interests are

041uh as well as who else might be interested in those buildings but also other parts of the campus so uh we will certainly keep the board and the community informed um so it's important to underscore that while we are interested of course no decision has been made we have uh a number of steps that we would need to um follow before uh any sort of uh interest was formal and uh certainly that would be a decision that the Board of Education would need to make but we are a long ways away but uh as I said we're we're learning more about opportunities we may have to make um uh to have a a more centralized uh footprint of our school district right there at the former uh St Rose campus a reminder around about wintry

042weather uh our website email Facebook Messenger all of our social media accounts and certainly our friends uh in the local media will will help us communicate any decisions that are made whether it's snow day or late arrival or early release uh so we remind parents uh that if we're expecting winter weather to make sure they're they're checking those outlets and just a reminder that if uh we have significant weather where we need to close school we will use our snow days before pivoting to a virtual option and lastly uh as we heard uh tomorrow is our last day of instruction in 2024 but that does not mean that uh all of our district functions are closed but right here at Harriet Gibbons uh they will be off until January 2nd however Academy Park will be

043open on December 26th 27th and 30th uh we just ask folks folks to make sure that they call or email in advance uh if they want to uh meet or discuss a matter with a particular person but all of our departments will be open and they will be Representatives at Academy Park uh for all of our functions a reminder that on New Year's Eve and New Year's Day all district functions are Clos and schools and offices reopen on Thursday January 2nd and that concludes my update thank you superintend as is a usual practice I ask you to prioritize your questions and ask your most important question first and we if if there's time we'll uh follow up with second round let start on this side Mr alavi thank you for the update um I don't

044think I have any questions uh right now I I do think that um St Rose needs to be explored thoroughly and I think it's probably a little premature to start asking questions about it so um thank you for the update and uh thank you to the students who came in and sang s at us um and for Sheridan prep's leadership coming through and giving us an update Miss SM yes thank you no questions or comments but I do want to Echo um Mr elman's last comments to thank the students for the wonderful music and voices and uh also shared and prep uh congrats to both of you and also look forward to visiting both of you at your respective new places thank you and happy holidays yes M well I'm just going to Echo my

045colleagues um special shout out to Sheridan prep leadership um on your new positions um we just know you're going to do fantastic having the students here to start kick off our board meeting um was uh wonderful to hear them sing um and uh and thank you superintendent for giving a thorough uh update so that is all mage so I will not repeat everything I already said but I do actually have a question which is have we ever considered doing a test of the winter advisory system I notice every year the first snow day a couple of parents are like I didn't get the text I didn't get the email I didn't get I didn't get I didn't get and it's usually something is you know their email changed something got messed up have we ever

046considered doing like a you know we're GNA test this we're going to pretend it's a snow day and send everybody the text and alert them to check their text and see if they got it um it seems like something that would be helpful for people to figure out that the system is not working before that urgent matter comes to town you're referring to the school closings Network well I don't I never used that term before but in general you do things when when we're going to have no snow and I as a parent received communication that there is no snow and that there is no school there is snow therefore for no school not the school closing Network then the our internal tool School messenger Etc yes I don't know what the school closing network

047is so I cannot speak to that that's how we get us all the TVs and radio stations no no I'm talking about our direct to parent communication yeah no we've not and we could thank you scy again echoing my my colleagues uh thank you for the alets and true doors for providing us with that little musical interlude uh thank you to the folks at sharid and prep it was nice to see Shar Jerry Dan your mascot again that's the star with the face and uh thanks for the information I'm also look I'll echo my one colleague and say also looking forward to um possible uses of St Rose campus both in their benefit to the neighborhood and the benefit the district and our families for having those that convenient location with parking um to do

048some of to carry out some of our activities thanks Miss Wilson plus one thank you to the students and thank you so much shid and prep for your presentation Miss sua sent scale you've left an indelible mark on that school in our community at large and I feel so profoundly we are so profoundly blessed that someone you work very closely with is transitioning into principal Hood there and that you're still in our district is such a gift so thank you and I just had a question about our community Roundtable just the thought just the mentioning of the Synergy of all the new leadership coming and was an was an invitation extended to everyone there that we do meet periodically just to have like the brainstorming around emerging issues on a regular basis yeah we did

049commit to meet uh more regularly the judges and the da um ask for additional information and um I believe the da is going to take over convening that group so we will that will be a regular occurrence for us great news thank you and all my colleagues have already said what I needed to say uh you know uh Gail when we met a long time ago and I started on the board and where at spa and you know I know where Spa used to be and where we it's come a long way so congratulations Kudos and thank you for everything that you've done and continue to do at the district and welcome Tina for stepping him to her big shoes and and in U you know continuing that task uh and and to kids I

050mean we have so much talent in the district and and I'm you know every moment that I I I hear these voices see them in plays or other activities it's just amazing and you know what other people are noticing them too so thank you for providing the opportunity to go out in the community and these other uh uh uh invitationals where they can go and perform because when you go and talk to other people well you know what you're you the students from your District I think we were performing there and they were amazing like yeah I know so thank you any other questions this is the time we set aside to hear from members of the public uh the board always welcomes input from the community about the decisions we are making we set

051aside about 30 minutes for each meeting to hear from District residents parents students and other members of the community if there are more comments they can be accommodated in 30 minutes which we don't anticipate today uh we may choose to extend the length of the public common perod or alternately establish a second public common period leader on the evening we accept comments virtually on the same basis as those in person and we accept comments in writing and by voicemail we welcome comments in English or in any other language we'll provide translation when necessary all comments must include the commenter's name and place of a residence we do not accept Anonymous comments all the information about these many ways to share your thoughts with us are available at addressing the board uh information at alany [Music]

052schools.org we ask our commenters commentators to keep in mind that information about individual students in specific District staff cannot be shared not only is that a violation of privacy but every student and every staff member deserves to know that concerns about them will not be aired in public and we do have people signed up for public comment uh Heather Heather mat mloy sorry if I'm pronouncing it wrong and can I also have Benjamin mcrel while I recognize you please state your name and city of residence statements are restricted to a maximum of 3 minutes and M CR your board secretary will give you a one minute notice and a 10sec notice um and I'll notify you if your time is expired it's a good idea to look up occasionally to see those notices so you

053won't be surprised at the end of your 3 minutes also please notice the board's policies not to respond during the public common parent if you need a response please contact us by email phone or Postal mail our contact information is available at Al schools.org and either members will respond Y and either myself or one of my colleagues will respond on behalf of the board um so first one he good evening my name is Heather mby and I have two children in the district I live at 214 uclid Avenue I'm here tonight to raise concerns about website access on school computers over the past two years during my son's middle school experience I've noticed an increasing issue with students accessing non-academic websites during class study hall and lunch for example my son and his friends are

054able to play mindless games on Pokey watch new watch music videos or their gaming streamers on YouTube create faked social media accounts and use chat GPT for answers on school work during study hall all on school devices while I understand the importance of technology and education and the need for students to make responsible choices it's clear there are not sufficient sa safeguards in place to guide them toward appropriate use in a school setting I don't believe it should fall on teachers to constantly police what students are doing online a especially when they already have so much to manage I do think putting effective safe safeguards in place on school computers is a feasible and necessary step a step that I'm surprised the district hasn't taken responsibility for already as a parent I do my part

055by setting downtime limits on my child's uh phone during school hours however this feels counterproductive when he can simply access the same distractions on school Chromebooks or Library computers this is not a new issue and I regret not speaking up sooner many parents I've spoken with share this concern I urge the district to take a closer look at Why students are able to access unnecessary websites during school and Implement more common sense controls to make sure technology is used as a tool for learning not distraction thank you for your time thank you Mr mro good evening my name is Benjamin mcrell um a resident at 109 Manning Boulevard Albany New York and a proud dad of uh kindergar kindergartner at the Albany International Academy um I'm also a uh board member of capital streets a

056local um uh excuse me local advocacy organization uh that's focused on um creating and uh advocating for Safe Streets bicycling um Transit access for all uh Albany is uh a very fortunate City we have amazing uh bones here uh it's one of the reasons I moved away and then moved back to raise my kids here uh it is a a city in the country as Saratoga likes to claim uh we have the uh real opportunity for walkability uh bicycle we we're a Dutch city after all you got to get a couple of bikes out there um but I wanted to come here today both as a dad and a member of capital streets to say that we're going to stand in support um both at PTA level and from Capital streets of the upcoming Transit

057plan uh that has to do with um introducing the concept of walk buses it's a really exciting opportunity to create um um groups of children groups of adults group of community members who are going to potentially allow children to reach out within their own communities explore their own communities get to school have a little bit of socialization and hopefully increase those attendance rates um going forward uh and uh you know like I said I'm I'm a parent and uh a local Advocate and uh a I guess I PTA subcommittee member on Transit and uh wearing all those hats uh and and speaking for all those groups you know please uh continue to reach out to us we're looking forward to supporting this program to the extent that's needed and uh if there's any other additional

058uh Street safety concerns and I will tell you there certainly are even just this building there's no sidewalk on that side my goodness um and we've certainly reached out to the superintendent as well so I just wanted to introduce myself tell you tell you all that we're standing in support of that amazing upcoming program and uh let you know that we are available uh with uh professional staff uh located here in Al professional Advocates so we are folks here getting paid to help you all make this city better for all of our residents especially our young people thank you very much thank you we appreciate all public comments and we find hearing from community members very valuable again our contact information for both public comment and routine correspondence is at Al schools.org bu that was

059we now move to the part of meeting we call routine during this portion of the meeting we approve routine matters for the district these include items like contracts field trips Personnel matters and the like each board member reviews them each item carefully but we vote on them as a group with no discussion this allows us to use a meeting time more efficiently nonetheless each board member has the option to set aside any routine consent item in order to require a separate discussion what on their item with that introduction I now entertain a motion to adopt the routine consent agenda M Wilson Miss Smith any set acides Miss Savage I'd like to set aside number 10 the safe haven resolution Miss crey thank you I'd like to set decide number four the field trip for Aly

060high high school and the middle schools Miss Smith okay all in favor of adopting the routine consent uh agenda minus item four uh field trip to Albany high resolution and the safe haven and those the two all in favor so that those passes uh let's start with the number four field trip opening high and Middle School I was just making sure motion Savage second by Miss Wilson discussion thanks um I I want to apologize first for not being for not being able to submit my question in advance uh these are questions that I have had in general um about field trips this is the field trip to Quebec for French students in middle school and high school and this is a question I've asked about field trips before that when they are curricular field trips

061and there's a cost to the student um I do know that we always say um no students will be prohibited from attending if they're unable to avoid the trip but I've asked questions in the past um and I have the similar questions now about how are we determining if a student is unable to avoid how are we determining if a student is unable to afford the trip whom are they asking for a trip for a waiver who is making that decision especially because these are students from several different schools um when that decision's being made are people evaluating the parents finances and saying well you're not able to pay $600 but you're able to pay $100 or $200 or is it just All or Nothing um and then it does say that they'll have fundraising

062opportunities for students who would like to earn money toward their trip but does that mean that there's a requirement that a student whose family can't afford the trip has to engage in fundraising or Worse has some sort of um minimum fundraising that they have to meet uh in order to be able to participate those are those are my questions about this trip if there's someone who can answer them and if not um you know could you guys let me know thanks sure miss McKenna would you like to weigh in sure um thanks for those questions and yes I do uh recall you asking um similar questions regarding other field trips um that are based on fundraising um when I reached out to the uh organizer of the field trip uh Miss Edson um and talked

063to her about the opportunities that students would have for one participating in the field trip should they not be able to afford it or to um participating in the fundraising she did assure me that she works individually with the students and the families and they differentiate the needs based on the conversations that they were having with the individual students and they reach out to other organizations such as AF um to and other um private funders to help support those students who uh cannot afford to part to fully pay for the field trip um so they can go so there are multiple opportunities and we do differentiate um based on family need and the individualized um nature of the need of each student so would a student I did see that the field trip package includes

064like the permission slip is there something that goes out as part of the packet saying hey families if this is financially prohibitive for you please email this person or call this phone number to discuss what might be possible and then I have not seen the the field trip uh permission slip at this point um once the field trip is approved by the board of education then um we will review the permission slip um I can get that information to you and share that out but at this time I don't have the answer to that question do you know who makes the decisions is that done in the school level or is that done on just by this one trip coordinator for students from all all four schools um Jennifer Edson the coordinator of the trip

065is the one who um Works closely with the families to um support the fundraising and funds to ensure that every child who um is interested in going can attend so she works directly with the families and the other teachers in the those middle schools thank you um sorry so I think Miss Smith has a comment Miss Smith yes um and thank you Miss C for raising that Miss McKenna for your responses I think um and I the ad hoc committee on routine consent which uh also looks at you know contracts but also field trips and we're beginning that piece of work um really right after the first year but first of the year but one of the things I'm hoping is that we eliminate altto together this kind of um approach and that being that

066students uh that we will say things like we will create fund Rising fundraising opportunities for students unless it's something that is done by the entire Collective um which is certainly something that I know my my music uh and band uh in in high school we used to do was a collective thing so that we could all go to Florida and then it was up to the um uh our band leader and teachers to then figure out you know how much each earned and often we earned enough money to uh to actually uh put towards uh just having fun uh buying a little souvenirs and things like that and so I just want to encourage us to try to get away from something that feels like you know we're and I know we're not doing it

067but it it it just is on that line of sort of shaming or making someone feel bad or family feel bad and we don't we want our kids to experience everything possible and we do not want uh money or any other things to to be barriers uh on the other hand we know that things cost and we have to figure out how to support the the very things that we want our students to be exposed to but I would like to get away from that kind of language whether it's on these um you know documents but specifically on any flyers or advertisements for families so just just a suggestion um it's because it's going to get harder no doubt so I think Miss Smith expressed everything she said I more eloquent more eloquently than I

068could I am in 100% agreement with everything she just said any other discussion I have a motion to adop I wanted to make a motion to table this until we can get answers about who is who is approving these things and how and what kind of information is going out to parents for information for to let them know about about financial about financial aid opportunities for the trip so moving do I move do I move to table I'm not great at Roberts do we have the I just want to make sure that we have the the plenty of time for next board meeting for that information to I me I think I think Miss Cree has made the motion so now that now we're in discussion and so the discussion point that you're raising is

069Miss McKenna what does this du to the schedule for the trip should it be set aside until after the first of the year um I I think that is okay I'll work with um the coordinator of the field trip tomorrow um to get information um you know on the second or the third that we return and we can get that to the board of education for board approval on the January 9th board meeting okay oh I was only going to make that suggestion if there wasn't enough time if was basically if we can approve the trip but get um Ellen's questions answered but it appears that we have time to just revisit this on January 9th so goe so so do you want to call the vote on the motion to table yes second by

070I mean Ellen was first and you're second Miss Savage is second all in favor of tbling the uh field Tri okay that's unanimous except Miss man who stepped out okay so next one uh The Savage the resolution on the board board of education Safe Haven resolution do you want to do the Motions or the discussion first oh sorry motion to adopt the uh safe I'm losing all my item 10 Board of Education uh Safe Haven resolution M wison second by The Savage any discussion yes m um yes would you mind if I took the the credit since I was going to set it aside because what I really wanted to do with my set aside was to thank Miss Smith for her leadership on this motion and um for encouraging the board to put this

071resolution together and doing the omen work of putting it together and I was going to encourage if you would be willing Miss Smith to ask you to read it out loud in its entirety because it is not particularly long um and I think it's so well founded and I really appreciate you're making sure that we took this um ceremonial but important step if you hadn't said that I was going to ask you to read it Miss M please I'm happy to thank you Miss Savage the resolution reads as follows as the Albany School Board We Stand United in our unwavering commitment to fostering a safe inclusive and supportive environment for all students and families within our community Albany is one of only 34 Federal Refugee resettlement cities in the United States and was designated in

0722017 by the Albany common Council as a sanctuary City in this dual role albony holds a special responsibility to ensure that every student feels valued and secure regardless of their background or identity we affirm our dedication to protecting the rights and dignity of immigrant students and families LGBT lgbtqia a plus individuals and students with disabilities and all marginalized marginalized families and groups we recognize the unique challenges faced by these students families and communities particularly during times of social and political uncertainty it is our mission to create a nurturing educational environment where every student can Thrive without fear of discrimination bigotry hate harassment or exclusion we are actively revisiting our policies and practices to ensure that they reflect our values vales of equity inclusivity and respect our goal is to develop programs and initiatives that not

073only support our diverse student body but also Empower All Families to be engaged members of our school Community the Alban School Board believes that diversity is our strength and we celebrate the rich tapestry of cultures identities and experiences that make our community vibrant together we will work to ensure that every student and family feels welcomed resp respected and supported in our schools we encourage open dialogue and invite feedback from our community as we move forward in this important work together we stand in solidarity with all marginalized groups and remain committed to advocating for justice equity and inclusivity in our educational system and thank you again miss Savage my pleasure to work on this and to read and thank you all for your edits and contributions to that if I may Mr President I had one

074other absolutely comment to make on it um I feel that it is uh always always important to ensure that this message that heartfelt deep Feld message comes through for our students their families our staff and our community as a whole and I was wondering if it might be possible for our um Communications Department to um put somewhere very clearly even if it has to be redacted a little bit with a a link to the full statement but to put somewhere on our website where you first go on just like almost like with weather or an emergency kind of thing where the statement pops up uh or some version of that so that folks can know that this is a statement that we stand behind um and that we're committed to our youngsters I think additionally

075wanting uh to make sure that should of our families um students staff Etc anyone in our school Community feels that they are uh feels unwelcomed feels disrespected feels not supported that they have an Avenue um that's clear one to go to their school leader to their teacher or a teacher uh to some other administrator but somewhere they can go to express their concerns and have it dealt with so so it is just a suggestion um I'll have superintendent and Mr Lesco do with it what they'd like but again just to reiterate um our commitment to all of our families and in particular some of the students uh groups that are under major attack at this very moment in our um Society thank you thank you Miss SMI any other discussion mran um so I would

076also like to thank member Smith for bringing this up it is very well thought out very well written it's important that we I feel that it's important that we passed this uh for a variety of reasons one being that it um declares our commitment to inclusivity and um an environment that all students can learn without uh or regardless of um all of these issues that are happening around them regardless regardless of these issues or these um identifiers that you know whether you're an immigrant whether you're lgbtq uh plus and um it just affirms the district's commitment to protecting our students um their rights their privacy and Foster a safe and supportive learning environment that's ultimately what we are in charge of um so I'm fully in support of this and um I'm glad that this

077is something that could reassure our families and our students um in this time of insecurity essentially thank you Mr Eli motion to adopt item number 10 the resolution on Safe Haven all in favor okay the process that's unanimous thank you okay Mr super yeah we'd like to um recognize and welcome Suzanne Shen who is our new assistant principal Ash she is with us and some members of the ash team uh Suzanne is a longtime teacher and is continuing a a trend over the last number of months uh of our ability to um promote from within from uh teachers and teacher leaders to uh administrative and Leadership roles and so we're excited that uh Suzanne's just moving from the classroom down to the main office uh but she uh made it through the rigorous interview process

078as we heard uh uh earlier Zula and Tina talk about um uh the interview processes at at spa they were mirrored at Ash so welcome uh Suzanne congratulations congratulations okay the next action item on our agenda is the budget calendar sorry so uh we did update the budget calendar to include uh the 55 day period of any changes that we do with our budget process process uh this year we do have to um pick a location for our 14th Ward uh voting location so a list of places that are potential for the board to help adopt will be uh issued tomorrow um just so that on the 9th it could be a pres a presentation and on the 23rd it would be a actional item so that it meets the deadline to be sent to

079the Civil Rights Commission to approve of um just to backtrack so that's why it's uh on the budget calendar now um but there's other dates that are within the calendar that are not normally on but going forward they will be so it's important dates for board resolutions and uh just so that it's constant reminders of where we're going thank you for that information and board members as you will remember uh when we adopted routine consent we also adopted the budget ad advisory committee members uh and I wanted to thank them for volunteering for this service uh their names Elizabeth Stak George Biser and Natasha Alexander uh they'll be working with the District staff uh to bring the budget to us okay so motion to adopt the budget calendar no okay M wson second miss grae

080all in favor I had I said a couple a question is it okay sure um so first of all I want to thank you for acknowledging the need to revisit the change in location for the 14th word that happened last year and hopefully a a location for the part of the eth and the 14th next year um and I appreciate you're letting out the time frame for that so we'll look for that for agenda setting purposes you guys will make sure that's on the agenda for the 9th um and then on the 23rd um and I also wanted to thank you for the enhanced budget calendar including the dates of all of the different board actions that need to be done takeen leading up it's super helpful to have that all in one place so

081I appreciate it um one of the things that is supposed to happen today which is for us to get the three-year history um and is that going to come soonish that'll be coming through the SBO okay so that'll be this week's sbu yeah so there should be tomorrow okay perfect thank you y okay all in favor okay that's unanimous except Miss Smith who stepped on thank you Mo budget calendar passes and on to discussion on policy uh pass on the mic to miss Cree uh good evening everybody we have two we have one policy and one regulation to discuss tonight and to let you guys know there there have been many many more policies we have discussed in the past couple of policies meetings uh which have a some of which have a little bit

082of um a little bit of text cleanup little changes to verbiage here and there that we've need need to get together so in next month we will have many more policies to discuss uh the first policy on here is 5460 child abuse in a domestic setting and New York state law requires that certain school officials who work with children are required to report any suspected child abuse to the New York State Central register for child abuse and maltreatment so the policy always included those school officials who were required to report potential abuse here the only suggest the only change we suggest is to say for purposes of this policy here's how we Define School official because elsewhere School official uhu may be more or less inclusive um the next Pol the next policy that we

083discussed was 6110 budget planning while we do not recommend any changes to the actual policy uh for the regul a related to budget planning and as a reminder uh District staff are responsible for creating and uh updating regulations um under you know use using the policies that the board adopts as guidance so they have so we we have suggested or they have suggested um adding to what needs to be on the budget calendar uh the dates for Board of Education actions related to the budget vote such as appointing poll workers and selecting polling places so it ties back to what we just discussed um so at our next well that I invite any discussion and we anticipate having 5460 on the next agenda to adopt um with that do I are there any questions hearing

084no questions I would like to pass this back to you Mr President so we'll vote on these uh next week thank you to the policy committee up for discussion uh is transportation update Mr Alco thank you uh I am uh just going to stay over here in the on deex Circle and by the way we appreciate you letting us bat a little bit out of order tonight and and take the transportation presentation uh prior to the division presentation but I'm going to turn it over to durett to um hopefully knock everything out of the park for you this evening uh hello again um before I start I do just want to um quickly highlight my Transportation team um in front of the board also in front of the superintendent I think there's a perception or

085idea that uh the transportation department is kind of a oneman show um and that is certainly not the case at all I know I get a lot of credit uh for the things that take place down there um but my team Tama pow Ronda crook Tyler Taylor as well as Eileen Leno um they all do a lot of terrific work and I don't think they get uh recognized uh nearly enough for all that they do so just want to get that out the way uh before I start here uh we are currently operating at 100 routes this year uh that's been the highest number of routes uh we've had since I've been on board and even prior to the pandemic um I've been uh on board here now four years in the past we've had

086to consolidate um a lot of our routes and um just get really creative mixing and matching um the scrambling to piece together the transportation puzzle um dayto day uh as I hope to convey during my presentation here uh that our operation has been growing um not only in ridership but also in the number of buildings we're providing transportation to um on this slide here I just want to note that we have seen an 8% increase in ridership this year and I anticipate our ridership numbers will grow as the year progresses that's that's kind of been our historical Trend um another thing I do want to highlight here here is the number of non um District routes that we provide um uh we have a lot of private private and charter schools within the city uh

087but we also provide uh transportation service to a lot of buildings outside of ALB City Limits and I just want to kind of uh highlight that here um this year despite the greater demand our vendors have been up to the challenge um this has uh by far been the best year we've had um in regards to our performance um I hear it in the responses that I get back from District staff uh constantly and I'm just really happy that U that narrative from the past couple years have certainly uh flipped around from being such a um you know negative feedback to um just hearing how positive things have been going for us this year um uh wanted to provide some uh Staffing updates here um the big biggest takeaways is that we've successfully onboarded two

088new vendors this year in Durham and Raa um they've allowed first student to focus primarily on our district students um and what we noticed is this year's workload for first student has been um much more manageable I think it was a little too much for them to take on all that we have to offer especially when they were so short on drivers like most Transportation companies are um we're a very Dynamic district and we have a lot of um just unique situations that come up that require flexibility that we just weren't able to provide last year um the addition of these vendors have allowed us to seamlessly make adjustments um and we have a much larger driver roster to pull from um so if there are things that we need to do on the fly

089or any audibles or adjustments that we need to make we now have the spear drivers in place and we can do a lot of things that we just weren't able to do last year um first student is essenti providing the same number of routes as last year um like I said just now they're focused on our IND District students um that's allowed for shorter ride times less students on board um on each on board each bus and uh much improved on time percentages uh Durham who hasn't been under contract with Albany since 2017 um has been a great addition um they've been assigned our Charter and the majority of our out of District uh sped placements um these are some of our most iCal routes just given the ridership numbers on our Charter on our

090Charter routes um and with some of the behavioral and cognitive challenge of our special needs students um their drivers and their monitor staff um you know they are really up against and they've done a really good job uh handling what we've thrown at them this year uh my biggest fear with bringing them on is they're based out of Waterford um and they handle a lot of um you know smaller Suburban type districts um you know not to say that they don't have have their own set of problems in those type of districts just um just not the same as as albony I think albony presents a unique set of challenges um and so far their drivers and their monitors have you know just been handling it really well even in those escalated situations um I'm

091just really happy with their performance uh thus far coming on um Raa um we've dealt with them um a little bit last year in emergency capacity um we've slowly expanded them uh last year um from just wheelchairs they were handling two routes and to end the year uh we were able to expand up to four total routes uh this year we thrown the whole lot of uh langin that are for disability students to them and they've remained impressive um the entire time um from their um just professionalism handling those um you know those are some of our um they're special need students that have you know it's a unique set of challenges that come along with them um the good thing about that vendor is they were already dealing with other districts um to contract

092to and from Lan um so they were kind of a plug-and playay a really simple transition for them um and given that they were already familiar with us from last year um just a really smooth um just a really smooth uh transition for us bringing them on um and giving them a little bit more routes to handle um before we move on I do want to just circle back to uh to First Student um I just want to uh note their recruiting efforts uh the past couple years they've been really struggling to recruit excuse me and retain the necessary number of drivers um but this year they've really made a leap and currently have 96 drivers dedicated to Albany um that does include their office staff um and people who aren't behind the wheel currently

093but I still think that's a significant increase from where we were at um over these past couple years um just wanted to uh highlight some historical data um just to show the growth and expansion of our operation over the past couple years um we are experiencing higher higher ridership um increased sped out of District placements uh and an unfortunate increase in our homeless population this year um I'd like to point out that though are are less students um if you look at our sped out of District placements there's less students that are being placed out of District the number of schools that were providing service to has increased and I know five schools may not seem like a uh huge ordeal on paper um but just given some of the struggles that we've had over

094the past couple years um five buses let's not take that for granted that is a that's a lot that we can do with those five buses um so I just want to point that out uh in regards to the mckin vento numbers they do not include our Charter Schools they also do not include our foster care placements I am going to work with our Charter Liaisons uh to better capture and track that mckin vento um data moving forward um I do also have to apologize I do not have year-to-date numbers to illustrate the increase and identify mckin vento numbers uh this year at this time compared to previous years um and working with board member Savage it was an eye openening um just line of questioning for both my department and their department and we've

095come up with ways to uh better track that um so moving forward we will have much better tracking for uh for you folks um one thing another thing I do want to point out real quick um in that slide is we typically do see an increase in our homeless or displaced families around the winter season that number does tend to dip as the W as the weather warms up and we enter into our summer session um so just with that said I do anticipate to see our mckin vental number significantly increase over the next couple months here um and depending on where they are placed um that may inre increase our total number of routes just depending on um how situations are handled as much as we've improved um to start this year I'll be

096the first to admit there's still a lot of room for growth um with the addition of an assistant director uh Tama pow last year and with the increas in drivers that we have for this year I've been able to take a step back from the day-to-day operations and delegate that to my team and I've been able to um you know kind of just analyze my operation as a whole and kind of see where our weaknesses are um I think my biggest challenge right now is um just getting a grip on out of District transportation um I know it's not unique to Albany uh it's something that all of my peers um you know struggle with um but it it's with our mckin vento homeless numbers as well as with our sped out of District placements

097um it does become a a heavy lift for us uh Durham has played a vital role and taking on some of that out of District weight off of First Student um but just giving some of the distances we are traveling um delays are going to be you know um unescapable unfortunately and with our sped students um a lot of those students um rely on a routine when we have a sub driver in place we have a no call a no show we have a delay of any sort it can throw them out of their routine and Trigger you know just escalated mood swings um that's something that we are aware of and um just trying to get a better grip on what we can do to um combat some of those delays um similarly with

098our mckin vento population these families are going through unimaginable circumstances in most cases so getting them to school that's going to be their most stable environment for the most part so a driver misses a stop driver is running late driver calls out whatever the case may be and we don't get that kid to school that can you know lead to severe consequences um for that student so just trying to get a better handle on um working around those out of District um transportation pieces um I think is going to be my biggest challenge and even with our mckin vento students that um attend our IND district schools um we have to double up routes we have to transfer them from one bus to another bus uh it just leads to longer wait times at schools

099especially in the afternoons it can lead to a longer Transit time getting them home you know that's going to be frustrating to Mom or family in general if you know they're expecting a 4:30 arrival but kiddo's not getting home until 5:15 520 whatever the whatever the case may be um again it's certainly on our radar um it's just trying to figure out what we can do to just shorten that ride time and just you know better equip our vendors with strategies to um just be more successful in handling their transportation in addition to our uh mckin vento and sped obac obstacles we've also seen an influx in new enrollment our enl programs this is a main source of our increased ridership this year uh my biggest challenge with this piece is um just trying to

100communicate to families and um navigating that language barrier um a lot of those programs are out of our AIA building AUB International Academy so we try to assign bilingual drivers and monitors to those routes and to that school specifically uh the good thing about first student and really ALB being so diverse um there's a lot of uh drivers and monitors that can speak multiple language languages so we um definitely want to make sure that we're utilizing those uh those drivers and monitors for our families that are in need of um you know bilingual um staff uh continued from last year we're still seeing a high number of address changes and new applicants um we're averaging about 50 changes per week um you know those small changes over the course of a couple months do lead

101up to you know a much larger a much larger change and that's where we get into a little bit of conflict with our parents where at the start of the Year their pickup time is you know one time but come around December around this time that number does change that time does change um so just being in communication with families keeping them aware of their times and what to expect from us um that's something that we do need to improve um another major challenge is uh managing student discipline um even though we've been able to lower the average number of students per route as well as provide monitors to a lot of our routes that we weren't able to last year um we're still dealing with um just daily chemistry issues um not nearly as

102much as we were last year our bus conduct reports have decreased um but still something that we keep an eye on and definitely is on our radar um and the most uh the challenge I'm most ashamed uh here to admit is our lack of tracking for Durham buses a lot of our Durham buses provide service to um special needs students and a lot of those families right now to this point have not been able to track their bus um that's something that um certainly we have fallen short of um one of the biggest obstacles with that is uh Durham's Project Lead unfortunately um is no longer with us um and it's been a hard loss uh for the company um we are working with them daily um and we're in constant communication to get a

103new uh Project Lead on that and to get uh get that implemented um but that is something that I want all of our Durham families to know that it's 100% on the top of our radar and we are doing everything we can um to get that process um sped up and expedited um I I'm a little hesitant to give a timeline as the previous timeline I have given to families have um come and went with no Real Results yielded so um just know it is something that we are hope Hing to get um much sooner than later and then uh last but not least is certainly setting uh just realistic expectations for our families uh my goal is to have our vendors be as consistent as possible uh but transportation it's not an exact science

104and there are many variables that can uh upset timing um separate from the larger from the larger communication Department I do think my department can improve on communication with families so they can be better prepared and aware of the status of their buses I try to accommodate as many families as I can without making unmanageable expectations but the reality is we cannot accommodate everyone's specific need um as we enter into the winter season we can expect uh weather to play a role in our arrival times dark rainy snowy icy days means drivers going to need to take additional precautions to ensure safe travel uh this may mean slower speeds or longer wait times for families uh um for the driver to arrive to the stop unfortunately we can't turn uh all of our Corner stops

105into door to-door pickups um and though we can do our best to ensure that our students aren't suffering through the colder winter just waiting for the buses to arrive um but I do need families to understand there are going to be some situations and some in some days um that just aren't ideal um on to a more positive note uh uh those several areas that need Improvement within the operation I do think there's much to be proud of uh I'm not sure if our families or even people work in our buildings realize all the School District offers to our students uh one of the reasons that I know about them is because we provide transportation to a lot of these programs uh I'm proud of the fact that while other districts are cancelling routes or

106not offering transportation to certain programs um we provide daily service to ours um we offer almost every sport both uh male and female from the the modifi level up through Varsity um we have after school program at all of our buildings we have tutoring programs we have special ed programs we do a ton of different things uh within the district and I'm really proud that our transportation department can be a part of that and provide service to those uh to those functions um board member Savage sent an article uh earlier this week um I'm not going to name the district but um they're not certainly not the only ones but a lot of districts are leaving parents to kind of figure it out um they're cancelling routes because they don't have the drivers um but

107we've been able to on board uh two additional vendors and I can't uh stress how important and vital that was to break up our routing scheme so that way it's not on a Sole Provider um and we just seen a major because of the additional vendors we've seen a major turnaround in that on time percentage um that's not to say that every bus is on time every single day um but our first student track tracking data along with uh School feedback clearly shows a significant Improvement uh the start of the year a lot of our second tier schools were so used to us being late they weren't prepared for us to be on time um so that threw them for a loop a little bit um and it's got to the point that we've been

108able to add so many additional buses and break up a lot of our routing that um just the school staff wasn't able to accommodate us on uh to start the year they've made that change they made the adjustment but um it was just funny going from you know all the owners being on the transportation department now being on the schools to uh to figure that piece out uh one thing I do I kind of mentioned it um before this if you can I think it's a slide before this one yeah um like I said we've here goes just some data on our on time percentages over the years we were doing uh pretty rough coming out of the pandemic when I first came on um to see it now hit that 90 number um again

109we obviously want to be close to 100% as we can um but I think to start the year this is I wouldn't have have even imagined this coming into this year so I'm just really proud of that number I'm hoping we can um improve as the year goes on and moving forward um also decreasing the number of sped stud students per route um that was a major thing for us last year and it was causing a lot of just tension on board um we're having to um deal with overcrowding almost on all of our routes to now we we have a much more manageable situation we've been able to provide vendors where um I'm sorry we were a to provide uh monitors where before it was strictly to uh sped routes now we even have

110monitors on a lot of our gened routes and some routes even have two monitors on board um again just something I wouldn't have even been able to dream of um the past the past couple years there uh we've seen a decrease in our ride times and that's allowing us to get to schools on time and clear our tiers at a much better rate um first student I can't say it enough um with their recruiting and retention efforts um them having a full-time uh location manager um him not having to split his time with another District I think has done wonders for morale and keeping drivers um happy with their station and with their place down at first student um and another thing that's um really worked out well for us is the decrease in athletic

111Transportation cost um all of last year we've essentially had to utilize Charter or coach buses um I'm not sure if you folks have ever had a travel on those but they certainly get pricey um so imagine that multiple times a day um to handle you know A 10- M trip um where now we only have uh one uh athletic Charter booked and that's going down to New York City um but we've been able to utilize first student on all of our other athletic trips which has saved us a ton of money um and to kind of add on to add to that is their performance with Athletics that's been a issue in previous years um I'm sure you folks have gotten a lot of calls from parents about uh some of the issues and I'm

112hoping that has gone away um with the uh with first student taking that over uh our favorite subject uh CDTA here um a lot of our routing schemes were carried over from last year um if you see like for example Meyers um having 423 alible Riders but having the same number of vehicles as a location like Aly High which has 2,000 eligible Riders um in light of that what we have done is we are working with CDTA um to um Talk about repurposing some of our vehicles um we've had to add yellow buses to North Albany as well as Albany International um for different reasons um ALB International doesn't have a dedicated Tripper line um there's been several um different incidents at that location when uh we've been able to add a yellow bus to

113try to mitigate some of that um with North Albany it was more of an overcrowding issue as well as some of the behaviors that we've been seeing um since we've added that yellow bus I haven't gotten a single call um in regards to behaviors um that's not to say that nothing's happened um that just means it hasn't rised to uh to my level um given the number of reports that we were getting prior to that um I like to think that that is the main cause of the improved service and the decrease in behaviors um I do also want to point out that our non-district writers ships are priv provoco and Charter Schools um we've inced increas in number of CDTA Navigator cards issued it hasn't been a major increase but we have uh increased

114roughly about 30 to 40 um cards issued to those non um district schools um but yeah I'm sure there will be questions um in regards to CDTA so I will save that for uh for later um in regards to some of the challenges that we're dealing with um discipline I think is always going to be our number one challenge um you know we've experienced student Behavior challenges uh both on our triple lines and our regular lines with less supervision um students just have more opportunities to kind of um act out if you will um and that's something that we've definitely been working on like I mentioned uh specifically out of North Albany we have provided a yellow bus to um you know just deal with some of those U behaviors and separate students so that

115way they're not all bunched up in a small area um in regards to suspending bus privileges um we recognize that that's not always the best way to handle some of that as that's going to limit the students ability to get to school in most cases um and we definitely want um every student to follow the student student code of conduct um but we are working um both internally in my department as well as with school leadership just to figure out what is the best way to handle and just manage student discipline when we are are noticing behaviors on board uh like most transportation companies uh CTA is still dealing with uh limited drivers um they're struggling to recruit and retain um their pre-pandemic numbers um and this is uh can you know is pretty visible

116in our lack of operation in AIA and our lack of ability to just throw another CDTA bus at North Albany and having to tap into our yellow bus resource and lastly is our limited flexibility with CDTA uh quick turnarounds on Route change implementation is very difficult for them um they not only serve our school district but they serve the greater Albany Community as a whole so they're not going to be able to adjust on the fly like we can with our yellow bus vendors um I know it's frustrating for certain families and um even for our district uh School members but um that is something that we are working with them to see what we can do to um expedite some of those changes that we do suggest I don't want to spend too much

117time here as this isn't my department and I definitely don't want to speak out of turn here um but I do just want to highlight um just with the increase in homelessness in our city um it's we're seeing some capacity issues with our IND District shelters and what's forcing it's forcing our families to move out of District um and then requiring a bus to travel out of District to provide service to them and that's kind of just what I want to highlighted highlight with uh with this particular slide like I said um we have a newly appointed mckin vento liaison I think she's much better equipped to get into the nuances um of our mckin vento challenges um but my point of bringing it up is just to highlight um our shelters are almost at

118capacity they've been like that since last last year um and like I said as we are increasing our number of homelessness and homeless families we are having to push them further and further outside the district um and therefore having to send buses further and further outside the district child safety zones another fun uh topic for us uh we are working with eagle to ensure we understand the law properly and make sure that we are staying in compliance with the state um as we research to expand service for under mileage students uh with our new vendors in place I'm confident we can Implement new zones um I just want to prioritize strategic implementation um I think we finally got to a point um where Transportation seems to be stable for the most part um I definitely

119want to do everything we can to serve um as many students as we can um just like I said just prioritizing um implementation and making sure that we're not uh biting off more than more than we can chew with that um I think our next steps are continue to work with legal and work with APD um and just trying to figure out what those cost projections are going to be as we work on our budget for the 25 26 school year uh stop arm cameras um the city is currently reviewing bus Patrol's Master service agreement uh for my conversation with bus Patrol they expecting to have that agreement executed um in February uh they're giving me a timeline of about 2 to 3 months once that is executed for them to start the implementation um

120I think it would be safe to say summer of uh 25 going into our summer session and going into um next school year we should have those in place um just a another quick comment on that we've already received several phone calls um from uh from parents outside of our district that are being hit with tickets and getting um kind of getting popped for passing um school buses um I anticipate that's going to be a major and absolutely we should move forward I'm 100% behind that um just want to bring it to your attention that it's certainly going to be a topic um to deal with as parents are upset about getting uh getting caught essentially um a quick note on electric school buses we did recently have a conversation um with our Grants Department

121and with uh and with first student um we are going into round four uh with the New York school bus incentive program Albany is a priority District fingers crossed hopefully we can um get some motion um with our with our grant here and get some funds from the state so that way we can start that process of building infrastructure and um getting EVS within the district and close to wrapping up here our School messenger um in my ride um parent app um I think it's vital for our families to understand that these tools are available to them um as I talked about those small changes that tend to add up after you know months and weeks of adding in students removing students from a route um these tools are going to be vital for parents

122to stay on top of what their stop times are where their what their bus numbers are any information that they need um in regard to routing is going to be right in that my ride K12 app um School mess is something that we utilize every single morning if a bus is running behind schedule we do send those blast notifications out to families um if those families are listening and you're not signed up for these tools please make sure um you do get yourself signed up I think they're going to be vital to um to your success um I believe Capital streets is here they talked about it I did have a conversation with a Mrs Jackie Gonzalez um in regards to getting a walking bus in place um still very early in the stages um

123there's a lot of legal work and liability um that we want to make sure that we have ourselves covered with but I love the idea of those parents that are not eligible um kind of partnering up and um getting kids to you know kind of walk to school together get involved with their Community get to know what kids live in their what kids live in their neighborhood and are going to the same school and um ideally that would be something that would be I think uh very beneficial um to our district moving forward um and then last but not not least I just want to highlight um first student um and their support of our students and our families in our district um this year they've donated $1,800 um to albony High's food pantry which

124provided um uh food to 200 families um they've done everything from bringing the food from um the food bank to Auburn High School and then from auy high school delivering it door too um to to those families I can't thank uh that team enough for all that they've done um and I also received a call today that they have partnered with Empire Christian Center and we'll be Dona a bus uh a bus load of toys uh to our district tomorrow um so we still have to um just figure out the plans for exactly where we are going to be bringing that but um but just want to make sure I did highlight them for all the work that they've done in uh and helping our families out that is it well that was a lot

125of material um colleagues uh if I may uh ask that we break up our questions into two sessions you know non CDTA and CDTA um start with Mr almin we do we'll do the non CDT report oh okay um non C first student um me reorient because I was going to do CDTA but um thank you for the thorough update it does it is really um relieving to see that uh first student has gotten it was like 20 more drivers or something so I know that was a big struggle yeah um thank you to First Student for the donation that they made yeah um that's really kind of them and um I will continue I'll pass until the CDTA piece Miss SMI sure um and I'm I'm hoping that I like I don't make a

126distinction between I'm not hoping but I I don't actually make a distinction between CDTA and Durham I don't think I don't I don't think that way so if you if I'm ask asking a question you think applies well it's Elementary versus secondary secondary is all C okay well I don't I don't I think mine are more General but um first I I too want to thank you for uh your thoroughness um and to specifically uh it felt like you were anticipating perhaps some questions uh that you might come from the board so uh I love when that happens um I I did want to this is more of a comment I think just to be clear I think maybe for the public maybe my colleagues for students that are uh identified as being part of

127mcken vento it it's we their home District right so even so I live in Albany but I am identified as being homeless I may have to move to scnc the responsibility for my transportation is still on my home District which would be Albany and that's what you're saying is that correct cor for the most part yes the family does have the option to choose the District of origin so if they were originally placed in or living in Albany and got displaced to's connec they can still choose Albany but they also have the choice to choose a register in connect a lot of times families um are looking for it to be a temporary placement so they don't want to you know uplift U or they don't want to remove their student from something that they're

128you know comfortable with with teachers with friends so they want to keep that student St uh in a stable environment here in Albany so that's why most of the times parents or families will remain to stay um enrolled in our district and I don't so that was really kind of a comment that I was getting confirmation but I do have another but just one more I then I'll come back around um in terms of the uh see traffic violations uh that that are likely to increase um does is the responsibility for handling the calls as a result of those violations on the district like how how is it that we would be getting involved and does that mean some staff or to handle this perhaps onslaught of calls I would imagine it would be on

129the county I think from the driver's perspective it's a school bus so it's you know their first reaction is to call the school bus company or the transportation department of that company um so that's where we've been getting those calls is parents or families just being confused at of where to call how to re rectify the situation and their first call is usually going to be um to our department we've experienced so far even though we don't even have the program up and running just yet so is there a way that we're trying to I don't know I we do we want to be able to inform our parents obviously but if if that becomes really such a volume I I just wonder if you all are thinking about the option leave that to uh

130to Mr leco to uh communicate out to families what the steps are what the necessary steps are to resolve their their tickets and it'll be a lot like the speed uh Zone cameras that the city implemented this year although the city did a very good job from its perspective from my perspective communicating about it but we we certainly communicated with our families uh consistently over a period of about 6 weeks as well and we continue to as new uh new speed zones come online it will'll certainly do a lot of that we the partner to me at the moment isn't exactly clear on which municip municipality it is going to be that we'll be partnering with on that communication but hopefully it will be a joint effort County City certainly the school district and we

131will be rolling out plenty of communication in advanced to let as many people know as we can but I you know I think the Dre's Point people are going to be angry just like to work with the speed cameras and they're going to be looking to yell at somebody and so because it's a school bus they might call us first so there you know there will be a curve in the beginning and as people um learn that oh I really can't drive past that school bus when the arm is out and it's going to cost me and uh I think just like we've seen with with the speed zone cameras it will hopefully uh in the interest of student safety and and and pedestrian safety uh change Behavior fairly quickly Miss man I really appreciated

132the um very thorough presentation um when when I uh oversaw a foster care program for like 20 years um when children were separated from their parents for whatever the issue was um one of the top five challenges was transportation and getting kids because we would we try to place children in in homes in their community and when those aren't available you could have a child being placed I'm not even talking connty you could have a child being placed in Washington County yeah um and so I appreciate your thoughtfulness about stepping back and trying to figure out how to make that work and I want to also share that's a heavy load not just on your shoulders but also I know the county they were um they were wonderful to collaborate with um and uh many

133of the local nonprofits um that work with children and and families um because even the process of getting a bus to a house I mean it's just very complicated and and people in other districts don't know it so um so I just wanted to share I I appreciate your thoughtfulness and um that's that's what I wanted to share thank you thank you Miss Savage so I want to thank you not only for the thoroughness of the presentation and your um additional data that you added um some my request and some on your own initiative I really appreciate that um but more importantly I want to thank you for the outcomes um you you did a great job of you know being recognizing the challenges that you're facing but I don't know that you uh you

134uh celebrated quite enough the extraordinary results that demonstrated in this report we went from 63% to 90% of kids being to school on time each kids's Route 12 minutes shorter on average 10 fewer children on every bus more drivers giving us more flexibilities more routes giving us more flexibility that is an incredible level of outcome that makes a huge difference in every child's life every single day so I just wanted to take a minute and say it's not about the report the report is also great but it's about the change that's happening for our students and how much we appreciate the fundamental systemic change that your team created by um integrating these multiple different contractors that caus that to happen doesn't just happen as evidenced by the fact that it's not happening in every District

135so thank you very much for these exceptional outcomes we really appreciate it thank you um yes let's do another round of applause um I wanted to and I'll do one quick just tag on about the stop arm cameras I'm going to send you guys which I shared with the board earlier there's a recent report out from the vision zero Network about equity in automated enforcement it's primarily around speed camera um but it also may have some applicability to stop arm cameras so I think you'll find an interesting read it's not very long it's only about 12 or 15 pages so I'm going to send that as well to the superintendent in case it needs to end up in the um hands of the city or the county or whoever is doing that work um I

136think it you may find it interesting um and then my question comment I wanted to thank you for acknowledging the possibility of walking school buses um I don't even know if my board colleagues know this but this was actually something I tried to cause to happen my very first it was like I was super green School Board member and I'm sorry that Miss Sanchez Gail is not here because she was my liaison School my very first board member when I was a brand new board member she was my my first year and she said one of our biggest challenges is getting kids to school especially the youngest ones because they can't walk on their own so if Mom doesn't want to go or dad or Auntie or whoever it is can't go because there's a

137sick infant or Grandma's sick or whatever kid doesn't go to school and I was like well we can we can work on this we can do walking buses this is a thing that happens around the country and it I could never kind of like get it to go so to have it reflected back from the administration rather than me sort of being like come on let's make this happen is fantastic and having Capitol streets who of course I know because of my um cycling and um pedestrian advocacy work um really leading on that is fantastic and I look forward to seeing you guys do the research it will take because it does need to be well thought out and one of the questions that I'm sure you'll ask but that I'll be asking as you

138come forward on this is whether um like our paid monitors on buses whether paid staff supporting walking school buses is transportation reimbursable um I don't see why it wouldn't be it's still Transportation just because they're not on a bus so this is a question I would like to make sure we know the answer to um because it seems every dollar we spend on attendance is a very well spent dollar and if it's a dollar that is 80% reimbursed by the state it's a very very well spent dollar so um I'd like to to ask that question um through the state um channels to find out if that's reimbursable money um so that's my question which I don't expect you to answer I'm just getting it out into the ether you wanted to add something M

139Smith yeah I thank you and I don't know whether this is the time and I pardon me Mrs Cree for buding in but it's on the Walking bus piece I I'm definitely very interested in um what that might mean and look like for uh in communities of color U uh communities where there is heavy crime you know so I I have access the website but I know having lived uh you know in a particular area for 30 years uh I could not get I could not get such a situation of families willing to walk um so I did a lot of driving couldn't even get my my own kid on the bus she was just like oh no not dealing with that so I'm very interested in how how this will actually work and manifest

140itself in communities that are very challenged um by a number of factors so um just wanted to add that on thank you thank you I wanted to Echo what my colleague said both about the Excellence of the report in terms of you provided a lot of data on the report and the Excellence of the work of your department in that the data on the report is so much good news and I appreciate also the analysis you provided to kind of explain what what some of our challenges are and what some potential Solutions are one thing that stood out to me is I was said oh my gosh I can't believe that we are having to transport students all the way out of state into Massachusetts every day and it got me thinking because we're driving

141you know here we are driving through skodak East Greenbush AAL Park uh New Lebanon I know the state educational Department's recent regionalization initiative is really pushing districts to work together more closely and it made me wonder are there new will there be new opportunities for us to coordinate you know if we've got a school in Pittsfield that we can coordinate with those districts to drive through and pick up those kids who live along the way in other districts potentially so um we've partnered with other school districts uh in the past um what I've experienced is that um just some of the challenges that are um that are students present to some of those smaller districts um are are just a little bit harder for them to handle what may what we've kind of become numb

142to um is just an everyday type of thing that our drivers and monitors you know just deal with um doesn't necessarily land the same way with some of our other um neighboring Partners where they've um you know aren't necessarily eager to take on some of our some some of our students that's not to say every district has been like that we've certainly have partnered with other districts in the past and we will continue to reach out when um when we can um but not everyone uh is as um willing I will say to um to to to take us on understand it's it's disappointing to hear that but I I appreciate your cander on that thank you Miss Wilson thank you for your presentation um one thing having you know um met you and since

143you've joined us we definitely appreciate the growth in your presentation it's very much um the same presentation but going deeper like the analysis is going deeper and and as many indicated we definitely see the pro progress so thank you um it's clear you're very thoughtful as Demis indicated and also as um and pointed to you're very solution oriented and I think just Transportation just still living and thinking of the earlier presentation we received from sherid and prep about attendance and this intersection with um transportation it's not so much a question but just some commentary that um attendance or the lack thereof is not so much obviously an indication of your commitment to school or your parents commitment to getting you to school or even an indicator of your health it's very much a fe a

144feature um it's not an indicator of your health because many times sick people still go to work and some sometimes sick children even come to school because indeed um the way our society is set up we are another branch of child care sometimes um and it's not so much an indicator of that but it's definitely a feature of poverty which you know we have a high concentration of that in Albany and even when theica sanche Gale mentioned shovel passable streets and back to your point about walking um I think historically line communities where a lot of our schools are situated or highb burden communities do have an inequitable burden of Hazards um they're not prioritized for improvements a lot of times whether it be shoveling or just the way the built environment is underdeveloped whether

145it be through um vacant homes you know other features other consequences of poverty people loitering outside various hours there's a shelter that lets out at the similar time some of our cool students get out so um understanding that you know one of the features again of poverty is not so much the lack of income but the crunch on time energy and capacity that people have routines or or afterthought and and whatever the opposite of a routine is what people live in in crisis mode um I think of like the game of the nice where one thing goes wrong and the whole thing collapses so um you know just in that in terms of the social determinance of Health uh I feel that you know we won't get that increase in attendance and we won't see

146this decrease in crime until we figure out how to mitigate the economic challenges in our community I am hopeful because of course our community school model and much of the developments that we have from our Equity um AG you know Equity policy is um supporting people and of course the upside of being nonprofit heavy I think is that we do have people who thoroughly understand the you know context of what people are going through locally and we have a lot of orders but I do think it's a Beyond it's beyond just attendance and I think attendance has always been a point of contention whenever I hear about it I think we can't address attendance unless we address root causes which um those are some of the issues that our students and families face so just

147understanding that thoroughly is where I was coming from and I appreciate your presentation and just beyond Transportation it's just you know those other features thank you once again I go what my colleagues and and and a wonderful presentation it's good to see the historic perspective from where we started and and where we are now and and I'll actually go back even further to before you started when you know I before I got on the board I remember being at a board meeting at at the uh new SC elementary school and he had you had Durham employees protesting against Durham so to be here having you you know tell you congratulate Duram about their good service it's a good it's it's you know know it's good for people to turn around realize their mistakes and fix

148them um I my question was going to be more in terms of our most vulnerable population that we have the bean winter students and the sped population uh you mentioned that uh the Durham buses don't have the GPS yet um so I mean and that's where our sped kids go on uh as a parent I'd be wor I would want to know that how so how do we make that possible in the interim uh before dham actually implements this in February or or the next school year so is it possible to have a you know because you can track anybody with their phones could we provide the you know a bus a phone that now you can track at least you would know where that bus is so I do have access to Durham's GPS

149units um we have made progress with that so if a family were to call um I can certainly provide them with the status of the bus or location of the bus um really good thing that I like about Durham is their responsiveness and their ability to take on our family's uh phone calls where first student just because of the number of uh families that they're dealing with they can be overwhelmed with calls um I'm hoping this year uh we've noticed it in within our office the number of calls are significantly down compared to previous years it's like a call center um in my office and mornings and our afternoon rush hours where now it's a lot more manageable um but during has been really good at picking up their phones they've been able to um

150have conversations with families and they've been able to directly interact with families um but I do have access to their GPS um units on their vehicle so I can uh track each of their buses just unfortunately we haven't been able to um Grant um I haven't been able to get access that I need so that way I can provide it and implement it into our parent app the same way that we can with our first student buses okay Mr Al so um I'm going to kind of mix it up here with uh my questions or comments so first uh I guess question on the Walking bus um proposal or know program first of all I'm I'm super excited about about the idea and I also think it could reduce a lot of the issues that

151we're seeing in front of schools during pickup and drop off and also you know enhance community and um and many other positive e you know positive externalities um do you have next steps um or I would encourage you to start creating next steps on that front because it seems like we've got a a pretty good um motivation behind it right now um especially with the different groups including Capital streets um that are very much willing to help us with it so I think it's kind of a strike when the iron is hot U moment on that um so that's it's not even really a question it's more of a comment but then um I want to kind of switch focus and I'll look at this more you know broad instead of just CDTA but M

152um so the question of monitors yeah first I understand that we added uh the yellow bus specifically to North Albany which has done wonders in terms of reducing the amount of you know people packed into the buses um but I'm seeing that our first student Durham you know and raia groups they have almost a monitor to every driver is that like is that a legal requirement for the elementary school transportation or is that just it come with it it's not a legal requirement for our general ed students they are they it's not mandated that a monitor be on board obviously we would like to have as much supervision as we can to mitigate any whether it be um student behavioral problems chemistry issues whatever the case may be that is not mandated um given that

153we now have a larger monitor pool and Driver pool let's you let's utilize it let's put them on buses that we haven't been able to before and if even if we double up some of our heavier routes let's get as many monitors as we can on our buses to help provide that supervision I would I would agree on that and I'm just trying to understand so I don't think CDTA has monitors though our CDTA side doesn't have monitors correct and looking at it from an equity perspective if you know half of our buses get monitors or three4 of our buses get monitors when it's through these vendors and we're not getting the monitors with the CDTA um buses I would I would say that's a hole that we need to fill specifically because that is

154the group of students that are probably the most rambunctious and need it the most not to say that I haven't been in an elementary school bus it's been crazy but um Mr would you mind if I ask just a factual question because I'm just trying to make sure I understand the situation I know in North Albany we added staff to buses that's on the CDTA buses as well right not just to the yellow bus a CDT bus the CDT Red Line in particular five or six employees who are rotating as monitors on that particular trip or bus so it's it is something that we have an understanding with CDTA that if we have the staff and the Capac capacity we can put and I don't want to misuse the term monitor versus staff I'm not

155sure if we're using those in two different ways um but we can put adults that are in our employee on CDTA buses if we have the capacity yes um and as per the s spu that is also a reimbursable expense um so it is um reimbursed by the state 80% next year so it's a good effective use of our of our money so it sounds like we have one staff member monitor on on the red line for um North Albany there are five or six North Albany employees teachers and staff who have volun not they're been being paid for their time but uh they have stepped forward to serve as monitors two or three at a time on the red line and so they're not all doing it every day but there are two or

156three of them on uh the red line Tripper Bus every day right but what about the other ones what about the other buses we hear you yeah we hear you yeah um I think I think I'm good uh I'll pass sure um and again I maybe uh the uh walkable bus piece needs needs a presentation of its own now I want to agree in part with Mr alawi about hey strike W the iron's Hut however I don't think that means necessarily getting kids to walk right now given the weather but I do think it means planning and really really working out the details and all of that which I'm sure uh Capitol streets right and and others are are working on um but I I think there are some pros and cons uh to both

157and it's really those cons that I really am very very concerned about we all have had situations again where safety in certain areas of the city you know one of the problem what we're trying to do is break up the the Gatherings and the gangs and the groupings and so now we're this potentially has them back together again and I know it means with some adults but getting the have having consistent adults and you know those things just scare me a little bit I'm just I'm not against the the program at all I'm just wanting us to really if we're connected to it to really work through the details make sure that the things that are uh because I have about six or seven cons in my head and I I shouldn't use the word

158cons but things that are concerning um uh that would have to be addressed I think in in that regard but I also want to see that to say this one of and it relates a similar concept uh but it relates to like sort of the support that's needed on our buses and so forth and so my thought is hey if there's a crew of adults or you know uh responsible adults could we somehow get a s similar kind of crew that would like again I don't care if we have to charge landlords or whatever but would clear the pathways for walking right that would um on a regular basis serve as you know the guard rails to ensure that there's Safety and Security um that these same individuals there might be some who would be

159willing to serve as bus monitors you know I I mean I'm just trying to figure out how do we engage and that's going to be true whether we're talking about walkable the walking bus or monitors or whatever we have to figure out how to engage the community in the safety and security of our youngsters getting to and from school and we're just not there and so I'm I keep imagining some sort of crew of people that are dedicated consistent coverage throughout the school year reliable um you know that no kid is going to be left out of their group sort of somehow get depart separated from their their Walkin group or you know or left out in the rain or what have you so you know so whatever it is I'm just whether monitors of

160some sort adults of some sort I'm just trying to figure out how we get that engagement and commitment from community and I know it's we have this on almost every single question of it possible um but I wanted to also follow up on Dr chatur's um question about the tracking systems and so where you left off made me want to just push you a little bit um because I still want to understand what's needed for you to be able to get access so in order for our um parent app to um track uh Durham's GPS units um we need to have a higher level of access than I think that they are um at least originally um wanting um to give um and then they had the recent passing of the their Project Lead um

161whose spouse was also involved um so just a um just a terrible loss for them I certainly hope I'm not rehashing any or reopening any uh wounds for uh for for those um over at the Durham um at my vendor but um that's the that's our last hiccup U first it was getting me access in general um we've crossed that uh threshold and now it's just um getting a new project lead involved and um giving me additional access that needed so that way the their software as well as our parent app can um communicate with each other and you're saying that there's like I mean again this sounds like a lot of conversations that still need to happen but there's there is no way of having them enter facing with our system without have giving

162you that access is that correct well giving me the access is essentially giving um our parents our techn technology yes giving giving them the access that they need um um so it's I think we're right on the cusp but I can't imagine there's much more that needs to be done um like I said just unfortunately losing two members um in the way that they lost them um you know I I would like to be just um just careful how I you know press them for um expeditor process in that and um I wanted to just uh the CDTA we still have do they still have that ambassadors okay that's gone that is gone okay and that's kind of connected to my previous comments about a crew of people dedicated you know so that that's unfortunate

163um okay and um okay I think and then I guess just one follow last one um so the bus the transportation companies are still uh recruiting correct yes okay so I have heard maybe of one or two individuals who have uh submitted uh uh applications to um first student and they haven't had a response and I'm not talking about like hey I did it last week and nobody's responded I'm talking about repeated um uh attempts to to communicate with them hey I've put this application in but I'm not hearing anything is there something some advice that you might have how do we um if you have uh maybe um uh or no offline if you have the name of that individual or individuals please feel free to share them with me and I will get

164them to the people that need to um the need to address it down there okay we'll do that okay thank you and just a quick comment on the Walking bus um situation we are in very very early stages of conversations um I certainly don't want to give the impression that we are further along uh than we actually are um I just recently had an introduction um with uh Mrs Jackie Gonzalez uh over at Capital at Capital streets um there's a lot of legal work and um just liability issues that we need to address before we can move forward um it's a great idea it's a very fun idea and I think it would be very beneficial but I definitely don't want to leave this group uh with the impression that we are further along than

165we really are so for example not uh the PTA are actually I think sir I'm sorry you mentioned the PTA your connection but that is not to say that there's been conversations at that level you're talking it hasn't even correct it has that those once we get a little bit more guidance from Lego about what um you know where are uh just need to be mindful of and what you know what our landmines are I think that that at that point we can uh move forward with PTA conversations and involving um District leadership Miss men Miss Sage um so I have couple three quick ones to follow up on and then one topic I want to um raise that we haven't really talked about uh finish just finishing up walking school buses 100% understood very

166early stages there are walking school buses all over the state they already exist in New York state so and they do happen in high crime areas and non-h high crime areas they're they're all over the place there's they're all over the country so um I think it would be wonderful for you guys to do that research and the first Next Step sounds like the one you have planned is to do the research and then come back with a presentation um and it seems like hopefully that could be on track to do any budget allocation that needed to be done for this year's budget right because the budget um you know will be putting the budget to bed in towards the end of April so if we can move quickly enough to determine whether there's any

167budget implications um and hit that time frame that would be wonderful um but we are not inventing a wheel here we're just putting a wheel out that that exists other places secondly we um Miss Smith raised a question of snow removal um which is also a question that has and I think um Miss Wilson did as well a question that comes up perennially and I really um this is one of those questions where um I'm always caught up in the um the title of your department which is transportation it's not busing right and so Transportation doesn't um in the word your your job may be busing but the word means all the ways kids get to school and I would hope that we're having um we're moving towards a place where we're uh talking with

168the city about where are high need snow removal areas are because there are also cities in this state that do snow removal on sidewalks um in Rochester they they remove the snow they have a snow sidewalk plow and they remove the snow it's not up to every single resident unlike in Albany where every single resident is responsible for their own sidewalk which obviously creates problems in the communities where we have the most um chaotic home lives uh those are sidewalks that tend not to get shoveled because they've got a few other things going on in their lives besides getting out on time to shovel the sidewalk um right or the landlord ofina BNB there right right a whole combination of things result in there being too much snow on those sidewalks so us figuring out

169where the problem is and then working with the city to prioritize and I know that wable Albany who is a sort of a connected with Capitol streets organization they've gone out and just shoveled sidewalks they just go out and shovel the path because and that's a real Community effort but if we can identify okay these are the areas we know that the snow is just an ongoing problem and it's preventing our kids from getting to school or getting to school safely because they're out as Miss sanes Gail said walking in the street because they either can't walk on the sidewalk because it's too icy or frequently the plow Plows in the corner so you can't get to the sidewalk so when we can help identify what the issues are and see if we can get

170the city resources to brought to bear because we are responsible for our sidewalks we the school district responsible for our sidewalks and we can work with them to try and improve matters around the city city so snow removal is a bigger question but I think the city wants to do the right thing they're trying to be a good partner so let's try and work with them and see if we can make that happen um CDTA I really would love to see that actual ridership data because I think those eligible numbers are just misleading in terms of the number of buses and number of students obviously we do not have the same number of buses coming at Albany High where there's 2400 or whatever the number was eligible students we're not putting that many buses students

171on those buses so I really think that's something we should be getting on the regular do you know what the holdup is because it seems to come and go we used to and neither of us are sure why we don't anymore so we will okay yeah and I I remember like we didn't used to and then we did and then we don't again probably is one of those things that happened went away in the pandemic and never came back and and but but we'll follow up okay cool and then finally I just wanted to thank you for your work on child safety zones um and just ask you to put in bold letters on every time you put that slide up that this District fought for that regul that legislation that legislation exists because of

172the work we did as a team this board and Mr leco and other leaders of the district fought for the law change that makes it possible for us to Define certain areas of our City's child safety zones and provide transportation and we should always celebrate that we got that law changeed because getting a law changed in New York state is no small feet um and so I I'm thrilled to see you actually being in a position to thoughtfully um consider when we'll be ready to implement that and I'm sure you've already talked through the time frame on that which is similar in terms of we would need to have the board would have to take action some 45 days before the may vote etc etc um and we would love to do at least one

173child safety zone if you think that the system can sustain it m and I I just want to speak to that very quickly um and sort of in conjunction with what you said a moment ago about The Walking bus matter um to my knowledge no one in the state of New York yet has implemented child safety zones with a new regulations so that is a whole new thing and we're committed to that and that you know unless we get a direct if we get direct guidance from the board that should not be our priority for uh budget priorities for next year getting more of our children on buses through the Child Safety zones is going to be our top priority for a new budgeting it looking at next year walking buses is extremely important but

174as as he said we're in the very very early stages with that and I don't want that to get in front of this child safety zone uh issue that to your point we've been fighting for for years and it's brand new so there's there's a lot there that we're going to have to unpack and unwrap to be able to do that including the budget uh ramification which we think we have our head around to the extent that you can at this point but that is that is a a very important priority for us at least in the conversations we've had thus far about 25 26 Mr CR uh thank you you know it's interesting what some of my colleagues has have said about wanting to get more adults on the buses um it kind of

175ties into what I was thinking I'd read an article a couple weeks ago about Price Chopper giving every employee the CDTA pass and then reading CDTA has universal access Arrangements where employers can provide uh universal access to their employees and it got me wondering if that's something that could be potentially beneficial not just to our employees as a potential Fringe benefit but also because it would get more of our District staff um sort of organically on the buses riding to school along with our kids which even though they wouldn't be on the clock I think seeing your teacher or seeing a staff member you know and trust on the bus is going to put some level of control on your behavior you're not going to act ridiculous you know knowing knowing that there's somebody who

176works at your school um on the bus now you did mention however that a lot of the buses are overcrowded so that I could see that as a potential con to that but I wondered what we thought about potentially uh working working in that direction what we might be able to do it just for some bargaining groups we might be able to do it for all bargaining groups as we work on the contracts but do we do you think that would be helpful to have staff riding the bus back and forth to work along with their kids I certainly don't want to speak out of turn um I know that we've been pushing for staff to ride our buses since CDTA proposed the ambassador program and one of the reasons um that we do not

177have the ambassador program um anymore is because we were unable to identify staff members uh to ride um I'm all for whatever suggestions I'm willing to consider anything I think um CDTA is open and they've been really good with um being flexible with us in regards to allowing uh non CDTA staff on board they've encouraged our staff um to be on board um but I would be more than happy to engage in conversations um that would incentivize and M and motivate staff to to ride CDTA and I don't know how much CDTA is charging um its Partners to have each employee ride the bus but I know the price that the state is charging their employees for a bus pass is much lower than the retail cost of the bus pass so someone's subsidizing it

178it might be affordable um did we want to go around or can I comment on uh the walking buses now or should I okay so just on the Walking buses I agree agree that they're positive I agree that there are some challenges but for things like you know for things like the weather right now because we have the 1.5 mile Transportation limit you know we have already making kids who live a mile away to go on foot to school so I don't know that saying we've got to wait till the weather's a little better to try to organize groups of students to walk would necessarily be something we'd need to do because I think right now especially with the bad weather you know parents with health or safety issues May you know or or just

179the young very young infants may may find it harder to make that walk um but I also Echo what my colleagues have said about really needing to work with the city um in areas where like I park and Sheridan Hollow and the city should be ashamed of how it takes care of some of the sidewalks there I mean not to criticize my fellow elected officials or fellow uh municipalities but some of those sidewalks are shameful and it's not it's you know I walk in the street because I have to so it's not so we want we want to be able to make our streets and our sidewalks you know safe for our kids and families to get to school and and I know you know we've seen a lot in the news lately about the

180C click fix you know going down temporarily but it would be great if we could make that connection with the city to figure out who we can who we can get stuff on their radar that poses a health and safety threat to our kids get need to school thanks M WIS thank you again for your presentation and why I was droning on about poverty before is because um your report mentioned homelessness and the plight of our M fento families and while I know it's no easy feet that yes are shelters at capacity there are ways and solutions that can be put forth um Alternatives that can be had for our families that would not cause the trickle down effect of course on our transportation and I do look forward to the future synergies that we're

181going to have with the incoming um elected officials in the assembly and our da as well as our um family court because all of this is connected indeed thank you so much so um starting with The Walking bus uh I mean it's not a magic one that will solve everything but I mean in support of it because it will bring communities together uh and and in this day and age I think we need more people to act more in a community environment we're sort of getting away from that uh so it may not work for everybody but at least even if it relieves some of the problems great it's a step in the right direction certainly understand that it's a concept right now at least in Albany and there's some research that needs to be

182done before we implement it great um but I want to come back to the uh mckin vento students uh again in our most vulnerable population again um they don't have a choice where they're going to be homed uh and so they could be in a different County different District what have you that doesn't mean that they are any different from our other non-m eventor students right so and the reason why I'm bringing this up is I mean we have students who are accelerated we have students who are in sports activities and we bring them sometimes from the Middle School to the high school and we leave them there right for whatever activity and then it's it's on the student to either take a CDTA bus to get back home or a parent to pick them

183up from uh the high school mhm what happens to the mck mentor students are we having some sort of mechanism where now this student who was qualified to be a great athlete or a you know after school club or whatever that situation might be that opportunity that we offer to other students has a way to get back to we are uh obligated to provide transportation um regardless of their placement um for all but we have the Tripper buses and stuff to bring them to school for normal hours but then there's these other things that happen so uh like after school programs um even like some of our later programs release at 6:30 um we are still obligated to bring those students um to their residents um same thing with sports um if a student wants

184to participate in sport and they are identified as mckin vento um as um challenging as the service may be we are still obligated to provide that service and I know we you know we've ordered the vs we don't have them yet right correct um from my understanding when they were ordered um I think our timeline was February or March so as we approach I will continue to work with uh Mr Caris there and um check on their status great yeah and transportation always been a big deal in in our district and other districts but not so much because they own their buses and staff um but the things that that you know we as a district have looked at all those obstacles and you know kept chugging on it's like the little train that could

185and where we have come it's commendable uh including the Child Safety Zone Changing the law was not a small feed and the fact that now we are in a position to okay where do we apply this law that's that's a privileged situation in my opinion um so thank you for everything you do and and great presentation uh looking forward to any any anything that you need from us that we can support you with and helping move forward so thank you I want to add one thing that illustrates a lot of the points that we've talked about tonight and durett was very diplomatic about it earlier and I'm not going to throw another school district under the bus however it it really bothers me and it illustrates a lot of the points that we're talking about

186here tonight one of the mckin Veno challenges that he's encountered recently is a is a family that has been relocated to an out outlying school district and the students already in an outof District placement a kindergarten student 5-year-old boy is in an out is in an out of District placement uh the school district that they're residing in currently uh already transports to that same outof district placement and they've refused to transport this 5-year-old boy in addition to their students so the rat's responsible for making sure that that young man gets to school but they refused to transport that kid from Albany and that's illustrates a lot of the challenges that we're talking about here tonight that that our families face now is this something where the board can actually talk to the board and the

187other district and and try to facilitate some of these things what can we do I think there are potential Solutions prior to that okay but thank you thank you thank [Music] you up next is the capital project update good evening everyone today tonight our extended project team has three presentations um Mr pekham and Mr malison will be presenting first of on the um cooling challenges that we have at New Scotland Elementary uh next up our friends at Turner Mr Collins Mr deetto and Mr Hunt will present on the Albany High School project project and finally Mr day from day automation will present the EPC close out thanks Don um for anybody that hasn't met uh Zach malison he's a CS Arch's director of Engineering Services he's joining us to talk about the New Scotland cooling

188situation so we wanted to uh give the board an update on the overall history of the system at New Scotland to make sure everybody's on the board and then talk about some of the aspects of the feasibility study we've done about how to address the ongoing issues that have been been experienced there so just going all the way back to 2006 is when the design of the overall existing system was completed for the hbac for the renovated school there it was typical at that time um due to it being a school in limited summer use the um total capacity of the cooling system was most likely designed to an ashray 2% parameters which essentially to say that um which has a an outdoor temperature of 83.4 and an interior temperature of 75 degrees and ashray

189is the National Organization that kind of governs or provides guidance in HVAC design um so essentially that 2% guideline is saying that 2% of the days would exceed that 83.4 degree exterior temperature and in designing schools it's normally uh thought that most of those days are going to going to occur in July and August when students are most likely not in the school so based on these parameters the design capacity um based on the calculation we just redid of the um of the energy usage of the building would have required a cooling capacity of 11 2.6 tons and the actual design capacity between the the system which is the chiller and in this case as we've mentioned is the ice storage for this system has a combined capacity of approximately 120 tons so just looking

190at those the was pretty close to the design um what we figured the design was at that point in time completed by a different um engineering firm and then also the um what the design the capacity is so just looking at this and we showed this chart in a previous presentation to the facilities committee um but the current um data largely supports that this is data from an 87 degree day so 3.6 degrees higher than that design day um and as you can see from this chart the for the majority of the day at least units two and three were maintaining the building and around that 75 degree um parameter and unit one which we that's the one we're going to do some more investigations on next week as far as why we're getting variable

191performance out of that unit wasn't that far off considering the fact that the temperature was higher than those design parameters so um we'll get into a little more about but some of the issues we're dealing with as is that we all know that the um outside temp temperatures are seem to be trending hotter than what than 83 de quite often a lot more than we would anticipate and happening in May and June instead of in July and August so [Music] um during the use of the originally designed system during a period of time the chiller would shut down on high return water temperature so in 20 9 to address this and part of that is the the geothermal field that was rejecting the heat heated up over time and couldn't take on more heat so

192in 2019 with new technology available the chiller was replaced with one that the return temperature wouldn't impact as as much and would also be able to used in heating mode to take heat out of the ground instead of just putting heat into the ground which happens when you use air conditioning in the summer so that equipment was installed and then in 2020 as they were bringing that equipment online it was determined that the existing building wide temperature controls were not working properly anymore in particular with the new Chiller and that meant that the cooling was not available in all the classrooms at that point in time and this was in the middle of the covid period and there weren't a lot of of students in the building to begin with 2021 mes was the first

193building that was converted over the new day automation temperature control system which was completed in 2021 and first operational in January of 2022 so during that 2021 and 2022 Winters we tried to run the chiller hopefully take some of that heat out of the ground to make it work more efficiently so really it was 2022 was really the first cooling season where we had the new Chiller the new controls and everything everything um to the point where we said okay it should be working at this point in time so and it was determined then near the end of that summer that that it really wasn't maintain the cooling so in 2023 more detailed investigations were taken to determine why we were not able to to maintain it so there was some some variations in how

194the chiller water flow was was running that was all investigated the rooftop coils were cleaned to make sure we were getting maximum flow the chilled water flows between the chiller and the ice storage were modified um sometimes we were the flows were happening um too prematurely and we were prematurely melting the ice so we were losing capacity in the afternoons and then late in 2023 basically the end of the um cooling season it was found there was a bypass valve that wasn't shown on any of the original drawings and nobody to this date knows when and why it was put in but it wasn't set in the right position and therefore a lot of the cooling capacity wasn't going to the units on the roof it was just kind of recirculating in the in the

195mechanical room so once that was fixed at the end of 2023 we really had to wait till the summer 24 to determine whe How much of an impact that had on the cooling situation so in 2024 there was some improved cooling achieved during days in the in the low 80s that's really that chart that I showed kind of demonstrated that that the low 80s things were pretty reasonable but it was determined that even after with all those adjustments to maintain the temperature across the building at the at the typical summer temperatures that we're seeing now it was still having problems you know at that using that 2% parameter although it was common at the time we're 18 years later I think everybody feels that climatic conditions are changing and have changed so that we're dealing

196with hotter temperatures during the school year that we need to address and the district standard set point of 74 is a little bit less than what the original design parameters were so we did load calc calculations to determine what the increased capacity would need to be or what the capacity of the cooling for the whole building would need to be to kind of meet an outdoor air temperature of 90 degrees and hit the the district standard of 74 degrees inside and that would as the calculation from our load calculation software puts that in 158.3 tons or as you can see about 46 tons greater than what the existing um the ash rate 2% and 38 tons more than the 120 that we have So based on that um you know it's about a 46 ton

197increase an additional cooling capacity may need to be between 50 and 80 tons depending on what type of system is implemented and um and what the final design calculations are so now just as far as the current situation most rooms will require either additional equipment or different equipment to meet the district's parameters that 74 degrees indoor and 90 degrees outdoor and the final design could explore the impacts of increasing the Target outdoor temperature if we wanted to go higher than 90 degrees as a Target outdoor temperature you know depending on the type of system it may have a marginal increase or it may have a significant can increase but that would have to be calculated so and and this will require both additional Central cooling capacity and additional capacity in the rooms so as an

198interim option we could provide individual units in each space um that require additional Cooling and when we wrote this we said it would require new electric panels and circuits when we get to the we have some new information as of today we went out there with an electrical contractor and one of our electrical engineers took the covers off the panels measured the current um electrical usage on the panels and then checked how much space was available in them for um additional Breakers if we needed that and based on the on what we found out in those reviews this morning we feel that we can provide some level of additional um Ro room based air conditioning without any electrical upgrades to the building um whether that's going to be enough to hit all the points but

199we would definitely be able to do something that will will um mitigate at least partially the current concerns so a couple long-term options um we can do a what's called a blower coil or fan coil system which basically replace the VAV boxes that are in the rooms now with a with a blower coil which is essentially the system that was put in at the high school where there's an individual unit in each room that will combine ventilation air and then recirculate room air to either heat or cool um some of the benefits of this type of system is that it replaces all those existing VAV boxes that'll be close to 20 years old when this work would be done and it only has the new Chiller and some pumps as additional equipment number of pieces

200of equipment to maintain because you're basically swapping out a piece of equipment in the classroom the other option is a a vrf system um some of you may hear of as mini split systems it's a little more sophisticated than just a a onetoone condenser and and unit in the room where you can put um an indoor wall or ceiling matter unit on on the um in the room and then condensing units for multiple rooms on the roof um refrigerant piping that has to connect those one thing I didn't mention on the blower coil system we we um did some preliminary calculations and we can do that with the existing piping that's already going to the VR to the um VAV system we would just need to either reinsulate that piping um for chilled water usage

201or wrap it with a vapor barrier depending on what we do determined based on more investigations um with the vrf system all of the um existing equipment stays in place and this is basically an add-on system to that to provide cooling so a little more modular than the blower coil option but there are some concerns there's questions about some some federal changes in refrigerant requirements to get refrigerant that's less um um greenhouse gas or or climate friendly more climate friendly and then there's more moving Parts um Zach do you just want to give a brief description of what the what the refrigerant concerns are um sure so yeah we're kind of in the middle of the phase out so um for this particular system the variable refrigerant flow of the VF um it it was

202delayed from its original phase out period but um which is at the end of next year um So based on the timing of this project um it'd be hard to get the existing equipment spec purchased um and then the new equipment isn't necessarily designed yet so there's some unknowns there um and you know and then again once they design it how fast can they manufacture it so it's just a timing thing and then there are like I said a couple unknowns um as to the functionality so as you can see here um the interim option of room air conditioners this was based on um the thought that we would be using a 2ton window air conditioner for each room and therefore need to run 220 volt power to them um and that would require all

203new circuits to be able to do that because all the available circuits in the building right now would be 120 volt and that could be to do the whole building would be between 500 and $650,000 approximately a third of that cost is the air conditioners themselves and then 2third of it the actual electric work but based on what um we we've learned in another line of thinking is that although a 2ton unit is what the design calculations have said we would need an iterative step that we could do would be to to get some portable onton units which can plug into existing circuits and they just can sit on the floor and just need either need a vent out of a window or into the space above the ceiling to be the hot air sucked

204out and for that um we feel we could do the whole building for um top number $175,000 and that's even if we need to run some additional Electric Services I mentioned that would be if we ended up having to put two of these portable one ton units in each space the thinking is that particularly some of the ones using um running off of um Air Handlers two and three which were keeping better better cooling we might get away with only one we can see what the um how how it runs and and um do it do it um iterative and be able to uh to provide the cooling we need at uh at the best uh Financial aspects for the district the other thing too with going with 120 volt circuits instead of 220 when

205you go to a permanent system for the whole building you haven't thrown away any circuiting that you're not going to be used for anything else um and we don't have to modify it even if we do have to run another 120 volt circuit it can still be used for something in the classrooms um as you can see here the blower coil units would be between 1.9 2.2 million and the vrf system would be 2.2 to 2.6 million um some of you may be asking you know well why can't we just do what we did at Arbor Hill last year and C hook up a different Chiller this is a different system it that in that case you were just hooking up equipment to to take existing equipment out of place out of out of service

206and you were just using the same same capacity and this there's additional capacity needing in the existing piping couldn't handle the additional capacity if you just hooked up a bigger Chiller um so here's here's our recommendations you know in Implement an interim option as soon as practical I've kind of already described what that would be it can literally be um go to Home Depot by a by a portable uh portable air conditioner plug it in make the connections and see how it works you know Don and I were talking and say well how are we going to test it this time of year one way is well let's just heat up the room to 80 or something and see how quickly the air conditioner can cool it down or some some manner or that to

207see how effective the the um the air conditioning would work and then plan to include we feel option one is the better option to include that in the the next fiveyear plan pending further design refinement and uh and working through that plan process with the district I think that's that's the end I didn't put a question slide in so did I miss anything Zach no many you questions I'm certainly not the expert but I'm just curious about the testing um that you threw out there and I I know it's probably preliminary but if you turn up the heat to 80 and then you plug in the AC's isn't the Heat going to constantly fight to turn well I would say we heat up the room to 80 turn the heat off and see how quickly

208that that air conditioning unit would bring the temperature back down again I it's it's it's it's not an exact sign that way it was it was just a way to get a sense of how well one unit in each classroom will work and not wait until it doesn't cool enough in June 15 and somebody's wondering how are we gon to get the next unit in there just want to D on to what uh to to that thought wouldn't you wouldn't the ex the exhaust from the AC be dissipated out well we're look we're looking at at at two different ways because because the the windows in New Scotland are sliding windows it's not as easy to vent out those as it is if you have a double hung window where you can just vent out

209a raise it up 6 Ines put in a panel and vent it out because they're relatively tall sliding windows so you just have a vent at the bottom then you got to put a big tall panel in next to it so so the space above the ceiling that's where all the exhaust air from the classroom goes anyway the return air from the um from the unit goes there so it's returning that air back to the rooftop units and out already Okay the reason was I again I'm not I'm not an engineer but I was thinking in terms of the it's cold right now and it's hot air going cold it's going to be dissipated faster than in summer when the outside just sort of like the geothermal system yeah I mean as I said the

210testing is not an exact science if we did it that way because there's a lot of parameters you can't duplicate so um just again to follow up on this so I mean is it right now we believe it sounds that you're fairly confident this is the best option so it might be one unit in the place or two units but but this is these individual units are what are the shortterm solution so is it that important to test that now wouldn't it make sense to test that as we are getting closer to some you know some more you know uh some expected weather because and I didn't know whether the testing needed to happen now for ordering purposes but I just wanted to yeah I mean I think not get too caught up in that

211the the testing is more and as I said it's it was more just to get a sense of whether we're going to have to run any additional circuits we can get a unit in every room in the one unit in every room in the building we're pretty confident without running any new electric sorry and um if I might so um I was very I'm very pleased to hear we are likely not and again I'm basing this on what I'm hearing is your confidence these we don't have to do any new electrical panels or circuits um um but the we will have the existing system will still operate in in the school um but we are going to maybe I'm just playing this out if I remember our conversation in the meeting there might be areas

212where we're not we what some areas are turned off from the bigger system because the units are better all all of the all of the main rooftop units will still run because they're bringing in the ventilation air and they're bringing in the level the level of cooling that that can cool it to so the individual room unit doesn't doesn't have to do all the cooling okay you're still and there's some days you know in you know it may be you know 78° out and you're perfectly fine with the central unit and the and the in in room units don't even have to be turned on okay so that that's what I wanted to make sure of um that I understood correctly thank you they go ahead yeah just to add one thing um right now

213your existing system is taxed I mean it's it's running flat out all the time so you know there is a possibility and I think we talked where if we put some of these units in it might you know bring it down off of Full Tilt right and then that could help certain areas of the building function better and that's what I remember hearing that we there's some level of maybe controlling certain areas to bring it down you know to keep that system down so that it could pump more over here okay okay that's Miss buff did you want to say something good evening everyone um I hope it's appropriate for me to ask a question because maybe I could provide some institutional knowledge of of the building and our air conditioning um the units that

214you're the portable units that you're talking about are those the portable units that I already have some in the building they they plug into you know just a regular outlet is that correct are those the portable units that you're proposing uh yes um and so we had summer school at New Scotland Elementary School I believe three years ago um and this is when our air conditioning was we were really struggling it was a really hot summer um those portable units did not cool the rooms um at all and they were also quite loud so I guess that would just be my only other concern is if you're talking about potentially putting in two of those portable units to cool a room um it does become very difficult to to teach over those units um but

215they did not work um when we had summer school and again I hope it's appropriate for me to to share that but just to give some context thank you for asking that question because that was going to be my question later I mean some of them i' I've been looking at some of these units and some of them just like dishwashers some of them are really loud and some of them there's other ones that are that are quieter and I would think that three years ago correct me if I'm wrong that the central system wasn't really working proper ly at that point in time so that was another um complication there that you were probably trying to do all the cooling with just the just the portable units and not having the benefit of the

216cooling from the central system M thank you I am really not an hbac expert but this was an interesting presentation and I had a number of questions um the first was kind of like a minor factual question your slide on your slide on three with the current data is that based on actual conditions you measured or is that based on load calculations because I was trying to figure out why you do it based on an outside temperature of 87 degrees rather than 90 that was information that we got data from the day automation temperature control system that they Trend all of the um temperatures every 15 minutes throughout the day um for each room so that's that's was reading from the temperature sensors in each room and I'm guessing 87° was the hottest day they

217had data on hand for maybe no we had other days where it was 95 out and that was a that shows that it can't keep up at 95 This was meant to show that based on what we thought the original design parameters were we were meeting the the needs at those parameters and it's the increased temperatures that are causing a lot of our issues CU I would be really curious to know what this data shows at the highest degree outside degree that's been measured because um you guys probably all know being being in this field that the governor just signed a law saying that if classrooms exceed 88 degrees you literally have to stop teaching in that classroom so we would really want to know um you know we don't want to have to disrupt

218our students by I'm going by memory but I don't think even on the 95 degree day I don't think that the maximum temperatures exceeded 88 they were like 885 86 but they they weren't 88 that is good to know I had a couple other questions should I wait my turn to go around check does anybody else have questions okay um the next question I had about the potential Solutions was one are the costs that you showed just the costs of installation and not the costs of running those systems because I could kind of picture with the window I in each classroom then then each teacher has the opportunity to turn it down to 67 if that's the way they like things those do not include uh electrical consumption charges and then I wondered if you

219have if you're running and this is again this is where I'm not an expert but if you're running your big units and then you're running window units in some of the classrooms is that going to throw out throw off the temperature control system such that the rooms without window AC are going to get a because like the thermometer systems are messed up that's I guess it's I could answer that but I'm going to defer to our our engineer to that one so I think I think the goal is to put one of these units in every room right a portable unit well if we need to right so um I guess um the installation of the temporary solution will not impact the rest of the building um to put it yeah if does that answer

220your question I just want to make yeah that so it's not going to throw off the rest of the classrooms and my final my final question was in comparing the three potential Solutions do they differ at all uh not just in the cooling effect but in the effect that they would have on the quality of the air the air quality or the ventilation in the in the classrooms um no we we looked at that we were going to you know put up some pros and cons of each system and really what you saw there is the pros and cons um really the experience is essentially identical with both options thanks very much appreciate it m Sage um I'm happy to yield to the experts on this but I do think that the question that Miss

221buff raised about the volume of the of the mechanism is a very important one if there's a way to position the thing in the hallway and feed the air in or somehow make sure that the actual condenser or whatever it is it's making the noise is not in the classroom that would obviously be substantially preferable I mean that may be one reason just to get one and before you buy 60 of them get one and make sure that it's not going to cause an issue well based on what Miss buff said we already have them so we can just try them now without even buying however different we we we can we can look at what they have so and I think that's my question is like what what is the system that they were

222talking about and are there systems as you I think you're pointing out that may have be both improved m in terms of sound um and all of that and and maybe that means we're spending a little more money for some of those units just to mitigate the sound elements so that's all information I think we'd want to know is okay and and it sounds like um we we really I I wish to goodness there was some other option right now but this this interm option really is the only thing that you believe we can do I think it's the it's going to be the most expeditious at the least cost at the least cost okay I mean I mean I know the other two things are that that isn't even possible um just given design

223and you know all of these things but putting those individual units in it sounds like the only option that we really have for this immediate um spring and summer yeah I mean whether you do do I mean originally we were thinking we were going to need to use true window air conditioners which again the sliding windows make complicate that and um uh we were thinking that we'd go with a two-ton unit which you can you can only get in window units unless you go to very expensive portable on to get two ton two ton portable one you're several thousand dollar versus several hundred dollar for a one ton portable one and yeah I mean the the the the biggest I think uh reason we're proposing this is because we don't have to run new circuits

224right we've said two-thirds of the cost is in the electrical to support those two ton window units so okay so that's the issue that was kind of the you know the deciding factor to push it to so hang so hang on a second so uh again I let me just I I think I follow you um so right now and I'm assuming it's something close to the existing kinds of systems or is it would it be like the btu and stuff is around the same so we wouldn't have to do we would not have new panels or circuits uh and that should come in around roughly 175,000 for one ton is that is that right 175,000 would if we needed to have two units in every classroom that would cover it if we needed two

225units uh why wouldn't we go to the two ton because you're still needing additional um a lot additional circuits for for doing foring the putting the two ton units in but let me sorry I'm just pushing one more time if um if but we right now the the the amount of money we're budgeting for is for the panels like I'm all about saving money but we've sort of included the cost of these panels and circuits right if we have a better learning environment because the 2ton is quieter achieves the level of coolness that we need I'm just suggesting why wouldn't we go that route yeah so what what is the comparison um we we don't want the school to be we want everyone to be more comfortable in terms of the temperature obviously but we

226don't want to still impact that learning environment such that the noise level is just not conducive to learning we will explore the noise impacts I'm not necessarily sure that a two-ton window unit is going to be quieter than a a one ton portable unit fa that's fair enough but I want to know it's just not clear to us you know like initially the what I'm hearing is like and I'm all like I said all about it is being able to have a to have a less expensive solution is generally my goal but I think if it doesn't give us uh the kind of overall satisfaction for that learning environment you know it be the way we want it then then I think something else is Neary am I interpreting this correctly that the two one

227ton units can be plugged into two two outlets in the same room but the two ton single unit would need 220 volt power so you need more electrical which increases the cost that's right an and they're factoring not only the cost but also the time so they feel like this cheaper solution is also the time time expedient solution to but can I ask a follow-up question on this so um we know what we know that there's some sort of units going to go in okay the but we would not actually get the option two or three into the schedule until first of all it's got to be put into the plan so that's already we've already lost a year right there and when when do you think if we got that approved within the 5-year

228plan would it be 26 or 27 before we actually have a workable new system the preliminary discussions that I've had with Don is that probably May of 26 is the earliest that you'll be voting on the fiveyear plan for the public so then you've got design work after that so 27 at the earliest and more likely 28 is when you would put in the put in the permanent system so I'm I'm really going to just urge us to look at the best systems given the amount of time I mean if this would again I'm not trying to suggest that oh if it people can deal with a period of time where it's just a a little maybe a lot of noise little discomfort for a short period of time I'm not suggesting that either because

229I don't we don't want to have any environment that's not conducive to good learning uh good instruction and good learning uh but this now this we're not talking about a short period of time we're going to have to deal with these particular units for some time so and we have no idea what weather patterns conditions are going to be like from this summer coming to the fall to the next summer after that so I'm just wanting us to make sure that we are looking at the best quality systems that we can and bring it to us and we'll have to figure out hey do we really have the money or do we want to take that approach to spending more or not but I just want to have all those options presented to us um

230so that we can do what is best for student learning can I miss miss buff did you did you go ahead Miss buff looked like she wanted to say something then she just turn the camera I I apologize again because I really don't want to interrupt and if I apologize if it's not appropriate for me to ask these questions this for your kids so go ahead I just have a a few um first I want to say that I believe I have five of those portable units located in my building um I believe at the time when we needed them we um the high we got them from the high school so the high school may have more units that I'm not sure if they use anymore since their building is um completely remodeled um

231so the district May own more portable units than we think we might have and that that might be a cost um if those units are appropriate to use um and then I just have a few questions when we talk about plugging in two units um if we do that in every classroom from a standpoint like is that safe in terms of like am I like is that a lot of electrical energy I know that's not appropriate term being pulled um from the building if we have you know all of these classrooms with all of these units and then you add all the technology that we're using is that going to be a concern um are these un need to be unplugged at the end of the day day are these things that the teachers are

232going to have to remember remember to do um and then I have a question about the units that would possibly go into the windows um I do have spaces that have only one window um and that's the rescue window so how does that portable unit do those spaces not get a portable or a window unit um if that's the case or how does that affect the the rescue window and I promise my last those are my last questions I'll take the last question first and because if it if if the air conditioner would have struck a rescue window we can't put it in we would have to go to one of the portable Flor M units there and ventilate it to the um to the plenum above the ceiling because we couldn't even vended out

233the window because that would R render the rescue window um unusable um so that was that question as far as the electrical capacity one of the things that we did test today when we were were there was how much power the existing panels are drawing and their 100 amp panels the most that we had pulling from anyone was 35 amps and most of them were in the range of 20 amps so that's where our Engineers felt there was plenty of power so with these units you probably just have to make sure that they're plugged into separate circuits so that's why if we ended up rooms if we end up with rooms that need two we might have to run a new circuit for one of them in those rooms and one could plug in to

234the existing circuits because every room has an existing circuit dedicated just for that room for receptacles and that is an addition to circuits that are for the computers so I know there was some kind of model run in terms of energy consumption currently versus energy needs in the future and I would just encourage you guys to look at potentially other models adjust the variables a little bit to make it you know maybe the most extreme situations and and see really what comes out and like maybe have you know the lowend medium end and highend and um we can make our judgment or we can make our decision based on um how much we have how much we need is this going to be suitable to miss Buff's Point um to what we have currently is

235this going to be you know supplementary and is it going to be good enough for May till May 2026 so um I don't know if you guys want to speak to the model you used or you know comment in any way about other kind of heat load calculations um or energy like simulations or models that we can potentially use the the energy modeling that we do is relatively easy to plug in different parameters you plug in the interior temperature you want you plug in the outside temperature because we've essentially built an energy model for the building and then the computer just tells us what that total cooling load for the building will be um and that's what I referenced when we said we were you going for 90 but we'd evaluate with some of these

236other systems whether you could what the cost would be for the installation of a system that maybe can provide 95 you know because you know who knows how hot it's ultimately going to get Miss Savage um I I had a question about the um the timing and the money is there a reason this has to be done as part of The Five-Year Plan it seems like no matter what we feel that this is a high priority to address this because it's creating a teaching uh a real barrier to teaching so is there any reason that we can't put it up this may I'm turning turning this this side of the table for that question is there a reason that we couldn't put this project Standalone not as part of The Five-Year Plan up in May

237it's it's an aable project I assume right a ability is not an issue um so that we could then be a year ahead of the schedule that you just laid out it could go for a public vote it's just going to save us maybe a year we'll have to still do something for temporary basis for sure no I understand there shouldn't be a temporary basis but it seems and we don't know yet what the temporary what the downsides of the temporary thing are going to be um did you have a a followup question Miss no I'm sorry I I I remember us talking about that and there was I thought there was some uh Mr oerman is nodding um so would I don't know I remember this question coming up and I'm sorry there's cons

238and we want to come back and discuss it again after you've had a chance to talk at facilities committee because maybe there's something that needs to be further discussed I don't no if you if Mr Carris is saying not I'm but I'm just looking at Don because I remember this and I remember feeling like there was some reason why we weren't doing it sooner rather than later Mr opman did you did you have something to add to the conversation no he does not want to something okay so I'd like to I'd like to keep that as part of the planning possibilities and then the other question which is much more microscopic and is really an engineering question and a teaching question rather than a board level question is um I I must have misunderstood because

239I thought we were talking about venting most of them not through the window but then it sounded like there was a concern about maybe venting some of them through the window and I am a little concerned about light I mean one of the things about that building that's really terrific is those great big windows and if we're going to have window units and the sliding I I pulled it up on street view because I'm like what are the windows there's something special about those windows I was like oh yeah they're sliding windows and then you guys said sliding windows so that means the windows have to be half open and some sort of panel put in I suppose it could be a plexiglass panel rather than a plywood panel but it still seems like it's

240going to be sort of a um not particularly great um situation for that whole period well and that's that's one of the disadvantages of the window air conditioners obviously is that and I agree that we would probably look at something that's going to let natural light in in that in that panel um because it would cut down a lot of a lot of that light coming in there if we put something solid in okay thanks so much so the um if you go to uh middle the middle east or Asia and and you see these apartment complexes and everybody's got these room units they have their ductless units which you have the you know Heating and Cooling happens but there's no duck duct are those the vrf units you're talking about very similar I think

241probably a lot of what you see there's one condensing unit for each unit you see in inside um is pretty much the same thing except there'd be six or eight larger condensing units for the whole building so up on the roof so they'd be serving you know five or six rooms each as far as as far as that goes because those are really quiet I actually have this system or something like it in my house so the condenser is outside and then there's a blower something something I don't understand what I've got exactly in the attic and then there's four vents in the bedrooms upstairs so I have cool air in the upstairs and not in the downstairs so and it works great and it's very quiet and nobody it's like it doesn't the condenser

242is on the outside of my kitchen wall and I never ever hear it Miss graie I'm just sharing anecdote about on vacation this summer somewhere with like 98 99 degree weather staying in places with those uh window mini split units and Whisper quiet and cool things WR down all right be okay well thank you I guess there's some more research to be done for thank you I just wanted to once this is done I just want to ask a question for the first part of the presentation okay thank you Mr be thank you okay so for president um I wanted to make a motion um to adjust the agenda um I know we have a I don't have it up here we have an item J um that talks about uh Communications and operations and

243I'd like to um move that agenda item to our next meeting we have a motion on the table is there a second okay we have a second all in favor okay I suppose I'm in favor any opposed okay two oppos who's who's the second one just one oppos okay well I guess that motion passes we'll table it to the next meeting just Les schol gets to go home quicker okay so Mr uh Turner well thank you um before the guys get started just letting you know that um we also have Bethy Batista our vice president operations manager on the phone as well as uh Bob Grande who's also a senior project manager who joined our team recently some of you may have met him at a recent uh facilities meeting but uh if you hear

244some voices is coming from the TV it's uh it's part of the team so we'll let the guys uh get started all right so we'll start off our update with a high Lev schedule overview um as many of you know we're on phase four which is uh the academic building Renovations as well as the kitchen and cafeteria which were turned over in Fall of uh 24 so a big uh win for the team is uh the special education classrooms which we are turning over six months ahead of schedule uh they are being completed now punch list is being completed teachers are starting to move in uh so these rooms will be up and running on January 2nd um which is a a huge win for the team so we're excited about that uh remaining building

245Renovations and the connector Edition um the remaining work in those spaces that is slated to be completed for June 25 so a quick update in the building uh first slide here is the connector Edition so you can see a a view underneath the canopy um the ceiling was installed in the canopy as well as the masonry veneer along the uh uh exterior of the new Corridor and uh the lighting was completed in the in the canopy ceiling so now we got some photos of the special education classrooms uh so as you can see things are are nearly complete in these rooms uh if you're wondering what the funny red tape is hanging from the ceiling that's actually so the uh testing and balancing company can go through later and know which ceiling tiles that they

246need to pop so they can adjust the air flow going into each room at the end of the project um sort of a just a handy little way to prevent them from digging around in the ceiling too long uh but mill work was completed BCT flooring the electrical finishes and uh the rooms were cleaned and waxed so like I said teachers are moving in and we'll scroll through the next few slides to see a couple more photos and then up on the second floor uh The Culinary Art Space is being fitted out uh culinary arts equipment started coming in the contractors are are making their uh me connection now and then the ceiling grid and and tile install is is progressing along the maker space room has been painted out uh light fixtures were installed

247as well as uh ceiling tracks uh the divider curtain um we have that on hand and we're we're getting ready to uh the contractor is getting ready to install that uh and then the last item on here is uh originally this this room was going to get a sealed concrete floor uh that's on hold right now as uh the the district has asked to review some options for epoxy flooring so we're getting some quotes from different vendors um so that we can uh compare those with with the facilities team and and make a decision uh also on the second floor uh ceramic tile uh and the the walls and floors of the bathrooms is is progressing along and then up on the third flooor uh which is the farthest along other than uh the first

248floor obviously which which is being turned over but uh ceiling tiles electrical devices painting um and floor grinding are pretty much finished up on these floors um so we'll scroll through and uh and lockers actually you can see in uh in these photos are are about a week and a half old but the lockers were just installed um so some of those empty Pockets you'll see in the corridors uh that's where the lockers went this past week yeah so in that photo on the right hand side those those Pockets if you're wondering why those are there they're filled in with lockers right now so we'll get some photos of those for the next presentation and then a couple miscellaneous items uh Tower two um there was a request to install an overhead door here in

249place of the the original man door uh so that was completed this past month and then also a uh a heater was added to the concession building uh main uh utility room that was also completed a high level snapshot of the eeo and mwbe uh participation on the project uh eeo has been tracking at about 7% on average including uh the month of October which was uh also 7% and mwbe has been tracking at 2% uh potential change orders a lot of these are uh repeats from the the uh past few presentations so I'll uh focus on the right hand side the placeholder for the new storage area under the m music and arts Wing uh this isn't a placeholder anymore this work is progressing so this is more of a final update on cost

250that have come in uh track modifications uh we have an initial proposal for $82,000 which involved a lot of asphalt changes a lot of extra asphalt needed to make sure that the track was uh properly sloped and built correctly uh to address some existing conditions so uh we're vetting that we're working with the site contractor to get that proposal uh submitted so we can get that one uh paid and behind us uh and then we're also holding uh $150,000 for the fiber cement panel remediation for phases one and two in the PCO log and then to sum all that up a very high level uh overview of remaining contingency we're at $488,000 remaining uh which is 20% of what we started with and uh tracking to about 5.2% of uh work left to put in

251place all right and then I think Bob Grande is gonna talk about our quality control plan yeah good evening everyone I know I did meet some of you on the facilities committee I apologize I was looking forward to meeting the rest of you in person today I had some family had to take care of um but like Mike said uh another senior project manager with Turner I've been here for uh going on almost 15 years with the vast majority of that in the K12 uh Capital Region managing K12 work um and just really joining the team to help uh do some of the day-to-day help we really finish this last phase of this project on a strong note um and really give Mike some more time to focus on some of the deficiencies that we're

252going to run through at the end of this presentation to make sure that he has ample time to get those closed out and bring those to resolution while the job still progresses and we get phase four like I said finish on a strong note uh before we dive into some of those deficiency items I just wanted to quickly run through what our standard action plan is to control quality on the job site um and some of the commitments we're making on uh phase four as well to again make sure that we're rending on a strong note here um so these are all the things we do to ensure that as you can imagine the multi who the things that happen on a job site every day and a job that size that we get in

253front of we catch so they don't ever make it to this log and become a deficiency that we have to track after the job is over um so the key uh ones here are submitt review uh so again we we make sure that every submitt that comes through we are fully vetted and reviewed uh once CSR does the review process we make sure we have the full update on any changes that were made in there um any corrections that needed to be made so that the contractor is aware of those and then we use those when any material gets delivered to site we do first material install to make sure that what we're getting on site and what the district is getting is what was approved and what they paid for that could be color

254of tile that could be Locker material that could be any sort of items that come on site we make sure we do that first delivery and reject anything that's not what was approved or what is owed to the district another big piece we do is mockup so we like to mock up anything and everything we can we do you know simple things like column covers um some of the VCT um and more complex things like you see in this photo um which we've done for each phase is the exterior wall system so we do a small piece of it we do every part and component um and make sure that there's no misses nothing that we really needed to to hone in on any questions comments or concerns and we leave this up for the

255majority of the progress that they do on the exterior wall that people can refer back um to what the exterior system should look like we also do pre-install meetings for uh any new activity that we start we make sure we have the appropriate parties involved make sure have the Architects Engineers us that some those same submitt those shop drawings the material um and we run through every aspect of how that material is going to be installed what's going to happen what the process is and we've really found is honing in and getting the actual people that are doing the install involved in these pre-install meetings so it's just not the higher up Foreman that's going back to tell his guys it's the guys actually installing the work um that are the ones there listening to

256it and knowing what needs to be done to install things properly some of the stuff we've just done recently is the metal Locker install like Nick said we ran through last week we got all those lockers installed we did a full pre-install prior to that uh level one VCT again like Nick said that's getting turned over all that VCT layout the colors anything that had to be reviewed with the install it was reviewed to make sure that we're not coming back to redo work um just a couple quick ones that we coming up you know we're doing the residence floor it's a Specialty Flooring in the culinary arts we'll make sure that we get that subcontractor area make sure we get the material uh some middle in hand we make sure we get the color

257right all those things we'll get before the work even starts um there's some other kitchen equipment coming in there's the ano system in the kitchen so some of those specialty things we really want to hone into and make sure we have the appropriate parties around the table before anyone actually starts the work uh so the other things we do uh CSR has been great about coming to site at the minimum weekly uh we do an observation walk with them throughout the building they we look at progress we answer questions we bring up concerns um and we view them and drive those to resolution and then us as a team we have multip people on site full time and then some me and Mike and some of the parttime that we're constantly doing walkthroughs constantly taking

258photos and we're not just taking photos and telling the contract to do it and letting it get lost they are uploaded to procore which is our project management software um and they are brought up immediately to the contra contractor they get pinged on that system and it never goes away until we go back and close it out um so those items are reviewed at a weekly progress meetings with the contractors we ensure that they received them they reviewed them they don't have any questions or if we do need to go further down the path we get the architect involved and make sure that they understand what they need to do to resolve those observations and then the final one on this slide is just the detailed punch list so the architect has always come they

259do a detailed punch list I know uh Frank was CSR spent three or four nights last week doing one for the early turnover space in the special letter are make sure we get that punch list and now we're actively working on closing all those punch list items out hey Bob this is uh Beth and I just I just want to say is um those items that Bob said are standard industry practice it's what what we do and it I just want to point out when we go through these deficiency it was done on on those items as Bob said as that picture showed we did do a mockup we did do those items as part of what we're going to talk about a def icy um it is not a a perfect we're going to

260catch up but it is a process that is done to um as a best practice to to catch these items are we there on top of every single um worker we can't be right at our Peak we're like 120 125 workers out there so we just wanted to point out that those items were done and then Bob's going to get into some of these additional commitments of things we're doing uh above and beyond what's required per and and doing with the contractor above and beyond what's required in their contract yep thank you Beth yeah so some of the things just based on the lessons learned from some of the deficiencies we're going through that we're going to committing to for phase four to like I said make sure we're ending this on a strong note

261and not having some of these deficiencies down the road uh we did exterior window testing so like I said we did that mockup for the system we had the windows installed we had a thirdparty contract to come up and actually test those windows to ensure that there were no leaks we did find a couple areas um that did have some we corrected those resolved them then had the third party come back and retest to make sure that what we did the fixes we made were the right fixes um when that retest happened we found that we did cracked um the leaking areas um big thing we've done recently is engaging the manufacturers for installation review so definitely some of the specialty items um and you'll notice again down in some of the deficiencies is the

262thermod duct was a big one so the thermod duct is all the exterior duct work we were having some moisture issues uh with that duck work um that we were able to get the thermod duck rep out here not only review previous phases but give us a full detail review of the current phase that's in progress to make sure we have an understanding um and a full observation log to make sure that this doesn't happen in phase four um and they will come back out again at the end when contractor tell us they complete we'll make sure that we do our observation punch this with the engineers and Architects but we have that specific thermod duct rep come out and review the site um turn is providing additional resources so that is me you're looking

263at them you're listening to them that's me getting out there like I said the focus more on the the day-to- day and focus really on that quality for this phase four which again will give might some opportunity to close out some of those other deficiencies that we riew um and then csar is also committed to getting you know their site guy out a little more often throughout the end of this project to make sure that we do have more eyes on site and are really honing in on some of the specialty areas and speaking of some of the specialty areas when CSX does come out to do their detailed design it's getting those specific specialty consultants and contractors in sight to review them so as we finish the thermod duck like I said we'll have

264not only theru riew the duck work we can have the mechanical contractors or mechanical Consultants come out and review the mechanical system as a whole we're going to get started to turn that on in the early uh New Year here all the new equipment will be turned on come online let's get the proper Consultants on board to look at that review the system well before we're ever talking about turning those spaces over um similar with any other specialty items that we have we'll make sure we get the right people involved do a comprehensive review prior to ever turning the space over well thanks Bob um so some of the deficiencies that we've been tracking um that we'll update you on current status is the uh phase one window leaks update um the uh you this

265is an area this is a phase one building two an area that was finished in 2020 we've had some uh uh some leaks that were reported um you know back in you know earlier in the year in May um we've gotten we put in the phase one contractor on notice of the leaks that's Jers construction um they've uh there was also some interior finishes that were damaged um they they where we where we are now um you know we we understand the urgency to finish these and get get these areas wrapped up so we we've written him another correspondence earlier about a week ago expressing a concern and urgency to finish this by the end of the year um right now the exterior window uh you know uh weeps have been drilled out that that's

266been done they're concentrating on the interior finishes um as of latest update they are uh finishing the interior finishes uh this week with uh some claing to come in on Monday they're having their specialty qua uh contractor come in um and address the quock issues on the interior um what we're doing is you know we're we're not waiting till they're done to to review we're we're walking the uh the rooms and the finishes that uh as they get done we're we're we're actually before we actually even bring uh CSR and and the district we're walking it with with their Foreman um to ensure that the quality as we see it is a quality that they would uh want to turn over um what what we've also done with the exterior this exterior has been done

267uh Turner and CSR have both uh been on the lift together and we've gone through and looked at the windows that have been uh adjusted with regards to uh new ca or drilled out weeps uh We've documented that with uh with photos and a timeline um so we've we Turner csrs have gone through and and reviewed the completed work for the exterior um repairs for these phase one window leaks um so in our last correspondence we did ask uh the comp the prime contractor to uh as you know as well as document what they've done to finish and and repair also to to bring in a third party to provide the testing so that we can ensure that what has been done is is uh um is watertight so mik I just add that um

268you can see there that the substantial completion was 2021 so that meant their warranty was out in 20 or sorry the substanti comption was 2020 the warranty was out in 2021 um but uh we understand that this is not been fun for the district and an impediment to the district to deal with um but we are glad that jurors in their subcontract are standing by the workmanship and they are addressing these issues that are really three almost four years out of their warranty period um so we are happy with that um that this is being addressed and we we are here committed to the district through all of these I just want to stay up front um to make sure all of these items that we go through tonight address whether we're still on site

269or not you know we're pressing for urgency on these um but but we're here to ensure that uh the primes um correct any deficiencies thanks Beth um the curtain phase one curtain wall leaks it's the same uh same general contractor jerson um these are the uh the west facing curtain wall um again it finished in um a warranty out in 2021 the uh the currently the again we Express in urgency with them to finish this work um they have finished uh as of this week they finished the last piece of exterior work that they needed to do uh we're looking to try to get on a lift on Monday uh while there's no school to just go verify and make sure that that was done uh and is completed correctly uh the interior finishes are

270all but complete I think there was a little bit of uh painting around the column that it's not satisfactory that we're working with them to finish up uh while they're finishing the rest of the interior uh the finishes at the interior um um and again same thing here as with the windows we requested in that recent correspondence that they get a third party into test the windows to make sure that what's been done is is uh um is watertight phase two uh window deficiencies so this is um uh an area of the building uh this is Phase 2 building four um again completed in December of um this is a different contractor this is Santa Rubin Contracting uh from the you know the deficiencies that we've seen on on phase one we we went and

271looked at what was going on at phase two um can say that the phase two uh leaks weren't weren't as prominent we found one interior window that leaked that had some interior damage uh we notified uh Jers or excuse me ASO on the end of October um they came out in the 27th the day before Thanksgiving they came out uh they they reviewed the exterior um in the areas that we noted had issues um their their plan is to come out on uh the 30th and 31st to address the interior finishes uh they've also committed to come out on the 26th the day after Christmas uh and work while the the school is is on session to address the rest of the items that they need to for the uh exterior um we've asked them

272to again in a report identify what was done uh get back to us we've also requested from them that they hire a third party to also um you know provide the the testing for water tightness so uh again we'll continue to express the urgency with both contractors on on getting these items you know completed and behind us um the the other deficiency here that that uh Nick mentioned in the PCO log is the phase one phase two fiber cement panels again it is this impacts and includes both jerson and Santa Rubin um the uh the uh you know we we've issued the deficiency we've issued uh you know two correspondences one about the overall deficiency be due to the uh U manufacturers review of the install installation of the panels they came out go to

273report um found the the panels were weren't installed correctly uh put the contractors on notice with regards to uh improper installation to come out and fix it because we have the the warping and in some of the cracks um we've uh We've also followed up with them asking for some additional uh you know making sure that they they you know to provide the installers qualifications as as what was required for the spec as well as some uh some calculations for some of the uh furring uh that the panels are attached to to the building that that that we didn't see that we had um Turner uh you know another thing that we've done is we've engaged our own in-house Engineering Group we turn has its in-house Engineering Group so we we consulted with them on

274on on how to approach this and and what the next steps may be um their recommendations were to uh you know reach out to a third-party um you know exterior wall consultant who who mainly focuses on exterior walls and and this type of uh uh you know rain screen application with the cement panel so we've done that we've uh reached out to uh three vendors one uh um uh three three per three Consultants we have those proposals in uh they've followed up with some additional information uh Turner the district csarch were we giving that a final review tomorrow uh with the intent of having U at least an outline of what that consultant services will be you know and one of the main focuses a few of the focuses that we're we're looking at from

275that survey from that consultant is just validating the rest of the panels that are on the building are installed for the for the manufacturer um as well as to look at um the uh the attachment method on how it's attached to the building and the importance of making sure that it's designed properly um so and and as well as the other thing too that are we can't ignore uh or or we're also asking the Consultants to test that cement panel is that cement panel what what should be there is what was it what was submitted is it per the spec so we're also looking at the the panel too because the the panel is under some stresses and and it has cracks and is warping so we're asking them to look at look at it

276all so that's the that's the next step um that we're you know that we're that we're moving forward to um the you we've asked the primes to get back to us on their positions some of them have gotten back some of them have told us they're turning over to their insurance companies so we we're waiting to see what reaching out to them to see understand what that is so um the next step is to you know let's understand what the rest of the building impact is due to these deficiencies so just to give a little more information to is this exterior wall was a delegated design to the prime contractor so there was a a cross-section in what they bid but the the design for loading and attachment was delegated from the backup wall and

277then the the furring that holds these panels um so when we when we brought in the Turner Engineers that sit in our New York City office um and we were kind of focusing on just the panel itself uh they really had us look at and geared us to ensure that we're looking at the whole system so that's part of the review we're look we're waiting for the calculations that from the contractors um and jersen has said that they would be submitting theirs um and just to note is we do have letter from the manufacturer that's pointing at the installation but we did receive responses from the prime contractors who are then saying that they are um looking at the product because they feel that it could be a product um that is failing under the

278Heat and and weather conditions that's there so we don't know truly who is correct it's part of this investigation and part of what that third party will do when they're testing the panel so us along with CSR looking at as well as the panel that spec and what we were able to take uh measurements last year in those panels were reading 100 over 120 degrees I believe John um so it is part of trying to really figure out what it is um that is failing and until we get some of that testing we won't know if it truly is insallation or everyone's kind of pointing their fingers and we're trying to manage that process to come up with what is the root cause and then what is the solution and path forward and like I

279want to just reiterate what I said before is that we are not leaving we are going to push this through we we're we have a timeline right of when if the if they don't comply with us that we would uh be able to perform the work and then go after the money from the prime craft director if it is a default in um installation if it's a default in manufacturing you know the manufacturer uh the product would be responsible for that so we're trying to track that down and work with the district within that timeline so that you um don't have continued issues with these panels thanks Beth uh we could happily say we haven't heard any issues on the phase three panels uh metal panels or the windows um but we are going to

280conduct a secondary review uh with the design team so get up and list look at the windows just to make sure everything is in compliance get a second look at everything um and then potentially uh if it's desired by the district uh we could could consult with a third party uh window testing agency to to test those windows if if that's desired uh phase four we've uh consulted with third-party window testing during the window installation uh for a pretty rigorous review of uh a good uh representative sample of each facing uh exterior elevation uh along with supplementary testing with our own team on virtually every window um and working closely with the window installer to ensure that they were also conducting their own window testing uh to correct efficiencies that were found by the third

281party uh window testing consultant uh in addition to uh the contract specifications we've also asked the contractor for the metal uh for the metal panel installed to have their the manufacturer of that product come to the site and actually install or review the installation uh which they have found to have no issues uh onto the tennis court cracking issue um the current update now is that you know I'm sorry excuse me Mr President just just a kind Interruption I don't know whether we want to stop here before moving on to the tennis courts I apologize for interrupting but I just wanted to check in with my colleagues yeah why why why don't we take a break and uh ask questions on this part first and okay what ia okay s John thank you Melle I

282yield to my colleagues M Smith yes thank you um so thank you gentlemen um and uh and and uh Beth and I apologize because I've just forgotten your last name um I don't usually call people by their first name deti okay there we go um so thank you all for uh for the presentation tonight and um I'm I just want to say right off the bat I appreciate what what I'm hearing from you all um particularly around um really honing in on or really reminding us of uh your quality controls and also what now you're expecting uh uh of your um subcontractors contractors based on the deficiencies that we're finding and your also re in-house uh review as well as requesting thirdparty reviews so all of this is a very important aspect um and it

283I will be honest with you and it makes me feel so much better personally professionally uh that uh our Urban system isn't being taken for granted um I just wanted to I wanted to say that because it's just I'm not saying that that's what where people are coming from but so often being in urban districts we are definitely I think treated mistreated differently than other uh districts outside of urban areas and so I appreciate very much um you um taking on the responsibility of ensuring these deficiencies are uh addressed and not just address say this panel or that panel that is deficient but really testing the system the panel system all the way around to ensure that we're not going to or that at least we will know whether or not there are other um

284deficiencies um there and so very much appreciate that and and uh and so that that was that was what I wanted to say so my colleagues ma'am I guess I I wanted to ask this the sort of question that Miss Smith was leading up to there which is um I appreciate the recognition of these deficiencies and the um obviously full attempt to address them right and not just address them in a um peac me way but to take a systems look um but it's pretty disconcerting um you know these are fairly significant aspects of the project right almost the entire exterior is is impacted by the windows and the clotting on the outside of the building right so so if I'm looking at the building from the outside um almost every part that I can

285see has had some sort of a problem at least in these early phases to my understanding um and that's very disconcerting um I know that there's been some fairly serious conversations within the facilities committee um and so I I don't want to re um have those but I guess my question is ought we to spot check work that water would not have been creating problems in inside the building from phase one and phase two water is a wonderful tool it finds lots of problems all the time but the inside of the building where we have had water right I know I have seen videos of water on the inside of the building as well but wouldn't necessarily show us other deficiencies um during this time frame so I am disconcerted about the lack of workmanship

286um the lack of apparently following the manufacturer's instructions around how to install these windows and wonder if we ought to be doing spot checks um and I'm also just a little confused and I'm not someone who does construction management at the $200 million level on The Daily so I'm really wondering what level of expectation I should have of the construction management folks for doing those spot checks all the way through to have identified these things before the water was in the building so that's that's really what I'm trying to understand is what else do we need to look at and whose job is it to look at that so I I'll take that one so the the our our as a CM agent the the liability Falls onto the prime contractor I think it was

287mentioned it was our contractor it's not our contractor it's the the low bidder low successful bidder in a Wix law um the the subcontracts that the primes brought on to do this work are are respected in the industry Robinson Hall and um gson uh phase one being Robinson where we've had the issues phase two um where we we didn't have issues till we went out and seek so I can tell you that there was we went through all of those things that that Bob brought up mockups reviews um we were not in a lift inspecting every single window um that is not in our in our it's not a typical thing we do it's not um part of quality control right so we have though done that since then so every single window on that

288building has been inspected phase one and phase two in a lift with both CS Arch and Turner so um with the work done we are also requiring that the contractor the prime contractor who had this issue um do water testing um so that we can ensure that even though we don't see an issue right now that when we're putting the water the water pressure on it that you're not going to have a leak in the future and they do that when they do that water touch they also have a um we remove material from the inside so we can see if there is any water intrusion into the interior of the building the interior of the building um the contractors have common address so specifically around the windows where we're have the windows is where

289we in curtain wall where we're having the water intrusion and all of those have been checked we're asking the contractor to verify um that they have checked them as well and to provide that testing so the the fiber cement panels are different there's not water getting in from those um it's the cracking and the pulling that we're seeing on the outside and in that case I will just remind it didn't happen until you know 3 years past the warranty date and it wasn't something we can see that a screw if a screw what the manufacturer is saying is a screw had to be centered to the utmost centimeter millimeter detail and we are still working through that to see is it truly that or is it truly the whole system that is delegated to a

290wixa sub or is it also could it be something with the fibers panel is the fibers panel the right product to be used on the side of the building with the heat all of those factors we are we are going through what I would call an investigation to get to that root cause um I'm just going to continue for a minute because while I understood everything you just said you I don't think you fully understood my question which was things that have not yet become apparent so for example perhaps there is something going on with the tile and the mastic was not quite right and in a year the tiles are going to start falling off I am not suggesting that that's happening or that I believe that to be happening I'm just trying to

291give you an example of another kind of thing that happened in phase one that we I'm wondering if someone ought to be spot checking since it seems clear that that the level of attention to detail um at least in this window installation piece was was not at this uh of the caliber that one would think and I and I hear what you're saying about the fiberglass I'm sorry is the wrong word but the panels on the outside of the building I understand those are still under investigation my understanding is that the wind window has been determined that there was an installation error that they were not installed to to the manufacturer's recommended me mechanism so I'm wondering how do we um so I'm going to ask you the question about going backward I would like

292to know what we what we ought to do to protect the district about things going on in the in um you know that we don't are not yet aware of but then I would also like to know and this um is a looking forward question ought we to put in our standard RFP more than a year of a um of a look back period because a year is obviously not enough because these windows were installed incorrectly right and we did not figure that out for two years or three years so maybe a year is simply not enough and while I understand that's the industry standard maybe we need to look for more in our future rfps um and I know that that will add some cost I was as a contractor would add a percentage

293on that but um you know we can't have Windows that don't keep the water on the outside of the building and just to agree so deficient work that we we can go after contractors for deficient deficient work outside of a warranty which is which is why you see also that they are not I mean they could fight it and say um you know send file a lawsuit or you know you you have some contractors that won't stand by their work and and will fight um we're fortunate here that they they're not and they're doing the right thing which is correcting a deficiency um there are things that we have over one-year warranties on like Roofing um so we are we are working right now on Roofing items we have gone back and checked um we've

294gone backed and um have checked and we're working with CSR to ensure that lightning protection is done correctly um we audited the roof we've audited um the mechanical units which um Bob is going to talk about and um we can work with CSR to do walk through the district on any other area that um all of the areas if if you know we can definitely arrange that I think I think that's great to hear I'm sorryi go ahead and then just to say too is that um Bob was saying like the the things that we're doing and that I think in future specs is to make sure that we have the requirement of the manufacturer to be out there and um sometimes that is inspects you know to have a manufacturer rep at the mockup

295review have a manufacturer rep at you know coming periodically we do it with it's a requirement of roofing to get their warranty um so that is what we're doing right now we're engaging on phase four manufacturers reps to come out and look and and as Bob had said and John had said is they've come out and said yes we have no issue um with with these the installation and that's particular to the exterior wall but I think Bobby had a few other examples of that but we could definitely schedule a walk through um we are scheduling already the 11 month walk through for phase three so that we can see if there are any issues and we can address them prior to a warranty for items that are truly warranty and not deficiency work there

296is a there is a difference there's there is a difference in that thank you that's very helpful very Mr alwi were you still yeah um just uh quick question on something that was just mentioned um Can the fail committee get a report on these audits that you've performed and uh potentially um what I would put as a list of auditable projects and which ones have been audited um and which ones have not and Mr Ami could I add to that the warranties I think I was not clear that there might be uh some things that we might might still be covered under a warranty and I'm just looking at Mr Caris because maybe he has that information but it would be helpful I mean I think on the warranties a lot of them are two

297different warranties there's product warranties that are often longer than a year so if the if the window itself fails or something then that's that's uh that but most times the workmanship warranties are only one one year sometimes we'll have twoyear workmanship warranties but what Beth was referring to and and uh Chris Honeywell and Jeff Honeywell brought this up that there's a a period of time for defective work that's not warranty that you can go back six years I think it is um for the statute of limitations on defective work yeah and I think uh at least some of we're beginning to I think understand that but I think um you know as we talk about these deficiencies really being able to sort of say okay what could potentially be covered under what warranty or whether

298it's product or workmanship and what can't be just just so that we have that so I I I totally hear what you're saying I I think I I just want to just in general say that um and and I really really uh do very very much appreciate what we've heard tonight um and I think that back to app Point Miss Savage made because of the sort of scale of this I mean we're not talking about oh you know they miss a job painting the trim around the door kind of thing uh or you know uh you know a door knob that wasn't functioning properly or something U which usually you would catch those in a punch list anyway but we're talking about some substantial significant um things uh costly things and you know not just

299one you know but a few of them and it just kind of sets my hair on fire right it just it just feels really unsettling I think and concerning as Miss Savage said and so I think we just want to be assured that we are being responsible uh uh for our taxpayer dollars and expenditures and so forth and we're giving folks what we said they would have in this high school and that is pretty much a state-ofthe-art high quality learning environment and we want to make sure that does not sort of another year from now or something kind of remind us of the old Albany that felt like it was pieced together with 10 and Band-Aids and rubber bands right so you I mean I think you understand where we're coming from um too much

300a lot of money a lot of hopes a lot of um sort of trying to remedy barriers that were impacting learning and instruction and the culture and we want to feel like we're on our way to dealing with some of those aspects so that we can get to having a more successful student body so um anyway enough said thank you though Miss gra thank you you know I'm really not an expert on any of this and I've never you know managed even you know any kind of construction project worth like one 1,000th of of what this project is but yeah it's disconcerting and even disappointing to to see these things come to light about this project that we were so excited I mean I remember 10 years ago being saying why is a 40-year-old building

301falling apart this is sad this is not something we want to see so I guess my question for you guys because you guys are industry leaders you work on projects around the country for all other kinds of large organizations and and government entities and school districts and whatnot is is this level of of air and problems typical for a project like this and if it isn't uh what are other organizations doing differently uh to avoid having this level of of error that we could maybe adopt so we do there are deficiencies in um in this type of and I think probably more re re revent in this type of procurement um low bed um which is why you hire construction managers in first place right to to coordinate all the trades that we're required to

302break this apart uh delegated design on a on a Wix law job I wouldn't recommend myself um you know because that's putting engineering into low bidder hands so I don't know if that played into this at all we don't know yet if that played into it at all but um that is a suggestion as well as um in this specification having the manufacturer requirement specified requirement as part of the mockup and part of uh um ongoing review is uh another item that I said and that we are doing and implying in in phase four even though it is not a spec requirement and we brought them into review phase three as well even though it is not um so we did it uh really reactively in the first two phases um and proactively and the

303others um you I'm sorry to go back but I as I said I am not I am really very ignorant lay person here so can you tell me more about delegated design on a Wix law project I know Wix law says something about what is it having Divi to divide things up at the multiple contractors or maybe only having one big contractor what is what does delegated design on a Wix law project mean and what would that how would that contribute to this so I I don't know that it did but the exterior wall was um so on the design documents it is shown as um spacing of the studs the metal studs that back up and the and the furring strips that attached the fiber this is specifically in the fiber I'm not sure

304if the the curtain wall was delegated as well um Rich could answer that but it requires th those those contractors to hire an engineer that stamps those systems and Designs those systems after it is Bid instead of the engineer record um having a system that is is designed fully um so we see it a lot we do see it a lot in the industry but mostly um more in and at risk but again there aren't a ton of schools building um brand new buildings or or really um having the renovation of major renovation where you're tearing down a whole entire uh wall to this level so um I can just say that we are also frustrated with this we are not um happy that this happened we we are not we did not in any

305way see this and not say something right um we went through those procedures and and um did we get up on lift and inspect everything no um the curtain wall testing and leak testing that is is typically done by the owner through a third party um we did not do on the first phases and we have done on phase four and so that would be another thing in the future to to do that right away um so that those can be caught during construction so those are those would be the recommendations the manufacturer coming out and all of these things that I'm saying for recommendations besides the delegated is really we are implementing them on the on the last phase thank you so this is you you're saying what's happening to us is a little

306outside the margin of that you normally see in big projects um I I'm not saying that for the anything besides the exterior wall I'm just this is this this is a large amount right it's it's on multiple phases um and both of those phases we're not we did not do the third party testing so we weren't following that along um I could let Rich answer um we there are EX wall issues on other jobs um it is it is um it is a complex system with lots of different materials coming together and looking at thermal bridging and gaps and cocking and um so we don't typically see in a whx law a lot of like large exterior wall systems thank you for helping explain that I appreciate it Miss wison and Rich I don't know

307if you you obviously could add um or anyone else thank you I know there's more to the presentation that we have to get through and many of my colleagues have stated my similar sentiments I just want to offer the perspective that it you know unfortunate as it may be um we would rather there not be leaks in these deficiencies it's probably for the best that it occurred because we were able to identify and now remedy them I'm just curious as to you know the extent of it and how did it come to be that there's you know you know we're it's obviously being investigated and you know had there not been water I'm just curious if there would that would have just been a like in terms of like the airtightness a leaky window thus

308causing other deficiencies for us like inefficiency as far as that so it's just thoughts that I have you know and we'll just investigate and keep moving forward through the presentation okay and I just want to say one more time and I know I've said few times but we are not leaving the district we are a you know a a a client in a relationship for life so when this last phase is done and you if there is an issue that we don't know of that comes up a year from now when we're not on site we will be there to address it with the prime contractor responsible for it we we are not walking away from this from any of the work that is done in any of the phases my colleagues and the facilities

309committees have have talked about most of the issues um in an interest of time I'll just say that for me a $200 million project is not something we come up with every other day right and so we and we we hired the best people to do the best job for our students so these things are a breach of trust for me and and so what I expect is whatever you do is making up to that you know building back that trust up and so the the stuff that you've talked about in terms of coming back in the year and and doing absolutely I expect that so I'm hoping that you know we will be even more cautious going forward but we also take a look back as M Miss Savage mentioned and and do some

310spot checks and make sure that everybody is back to a comfortable level with the performance on the project because yes mistakes happens errors happens but at this level is a little disconcerting so I'll leave it at that and we'll move on to the next part quick update on the the tennis court cracking is um the design team has finished their their RFP package and will'll be ready to issue it out to uh we found two prominent tennis court installers in this area um and would be looking for a Cooperative purchase agreement with them which is essentially saying a single Prime so we'll reach out to the tennis court installers receive bids from them and it would be a single Prime where they would carry a site contractor under them to do um the additional site

311work as in in addition to the tennis Square repairs uh the work planned uh would be for the beginning of the summer I'm not sure to what level everybody's reviewed this um this is just an overview of the tennis court um in the planned outline crack repair and then this is just a a section cut through through the crack and how it would be um repaired speaking on this um so one of the most more recent deficiencies or not or issues that have have sprung up has been the leaks and the thermod duct uh this is pretty much triggered by some of the duct detector issues that have been repetitive that we've been trying to get to the bottom of the root cause essentially of why they keep going off uh from investigating uh dust

312um to humidity temperature concerns to to installation um and then essentially it was through one of the more recent duct detectors that triggered uh that we found uh there were some manufacturer defects in in the seams on this duct um that we reached out to thermaduct who is the manufacturer uh they did a full study of all the systems installed to date including the current one being installed now uh I know we talked about this a little bit earlier but um so they've developed a report that issues um they called out some of installation uh deficiencies in addition to Manu factur defects which um just they just it was the duct seams that had failed uh so in that they've they've offered um to to honor the warranty and and repair some of those um

313and we're also working with the installing contractors uh to correct these issues uh and so far we have all of them on board uh to resolve the majority of these uh deficiencies by the end of the year so with this I just want to um so just to give a little bit more on this one so the the this effects three phases um the the duct was going the detectors were going off again this was outside of the warranty period of those phases it had not been an issue when thermod duct came so we we first were tracking down as it dust as it dust and then that process took a while to get eliminated we did find some things we did find some deficiency with the unit um we then went brought in additional

314resources from our team um experts in the me and kind of really geared us towards moisture and had us bring and recommended we bring in thermod duct because in the industry there has been multiple issues with thermaduct thermaduct themselves the manufacturer um has gone from a four-page installation guideline on Phase One to a six-page installation guideline on phase two to a 30 page installation guideline on fa on phase three so this is a product issue that they're learning that that is changing in the industry um what they found where the leaks are occurring and the reason why it's happened in 2023 and not at the end of 2023 and not prior um so even if we had done the 11mon walk we wouldn't have seen it is because the spacing requirement on that thermaduct have

315changed they you know they they now say you have to be within two feet um they didn't say that back then they now say when you go from thermod duct to a flex duck which is shown on the drawings that they're saying now you need because it's but it's it's been happening in the industry is now they're saying you need to have a rubber membrane roofing membrane over that to protect it those things were not required of the contractors but each of the contractors from phase one phase two phase three are standing behind their product and saying we're going to come there they've already been on the roof they already got the plant together they're Gathering the materials and they're going to address it in the meantime it's been temporary Provisions have been put in

316place so we have it protected um so that we were that was good news in this in this bad situation again um it was good news because I feel that they could have pushed back on those items because it is not like they they did not install something that was deficient at the time of the installation so we are we are happy with that and we are we are following through and ensuring that that gets done I just wanted to explain that a little more John John sounds a little tired so I just wanted to make sure I gave that detail all right and then the last couple slides here uh quick update on the Upper West Field uh so the change order to reduce scope of the upper Westfield uh was processed and uh

317so there was some scope that was value engineered out of the project uh so we're lining up the site contractor to perform this work over uh the spring of 25 and really the big uh issue with starting work here is getting the East field turned over uh which I'll talk about on the next slide here so on the East field um this field is uh grass is still was still being established over the summer uh we're we're very optimistic that this field is going to be uh ready to go in the spring there's only uh there's one issue uh the city's got to come in and do a little bit work with some of the vent piping that uh connects to their their storm system that runs under the field couple months prior you might

318you might remember us talking about a manhole cover that blew off in the middle of the field so the city is uh getting around to addressing that and uh until we know the extents of the work and what they have to do to tear up the field to get to that line if at all um we're we're not sure um what impact that'll have on the schedule for this field and and the West Field would just note too we are trying to work with the city and their Contra their contractor who is Keller who is the site contractor on the project um to try and mitigate the damage to to seek alternate ways they can repair the the pipe without having to tear up the whole field as a first is this manhole coming off

319like an actual physical danger to students on the field like you said the manhole blew off and that that seems like it could be actively dangerous for human beings there are these huge underground storm water storage tanks underneath that field that these um mans are on um so in theory they're only going to come off if you're having an incredibly torrential rain and hopefully nobody's going to be out there while that rain event's going on you know one of these several inches an hour rain falls that's when they come off man so how responsive is the city being right now to because that's the kind of thing that we would want to hear how responsible are they to responding to coming out and addressing every time we talk to them there's higher priorities because it's

320the water it's the water department that deals with this so I I'd been in contact with them or trying to contact them and the guy finally got back to me late on a Friday afternoon saying sorry we've been out working on a 30-in water main break this week and then the latest is we've got to get all our repairs work done and get the roads patched before the asphalt plants close so the last corresponds we had and I don't know if they've had any direct corresponds with Turner um last week they were saying well maybe this week and I haven't heard from them this week I need to follow up it probably won't be next week now so that's where we're at and we we're telling them you know they have the propensity to say

321well we're going to come dig and find out where the break is we don't know that there's a break to begin with we tell them dig at the end and run a camera so you can see whether there's a problem with the line before you just go start digging to uh to find it so this last slide is uh sort of redundant we talked about the special ed uh classrooms at the beginning um but uh the the summary to this slide was just uh we're bringing the the kids in a little bit early um there's going to be some construction going on around around the space and uh you know we just wanted to make you know the teachers and and the staff aware that there there's going to be a little bit of uh

322cohabiting uh in inside the building during during this time but I think the one change to this slide most of those spaces that you see in yellow that were going to be potentially not occupied I think all of them except for the vestibules on the left hand side of that screen are going to be occupied or ailable at least to the school um next week any questions on this part Mr many um I was up away from my chair for a moment so we we covered the tennis courts and the fields essentially it's just outdoor outdoor matters um um did we make a decision about the tennis courts in terms of like the the final repair that is going to be made okay all right no questions I I think that yeah I'm just going

323to just to answer your question I think that um John didn't go I think you made a reference you said you we are probably familiar or maybe that was your assumption because we've been we've talked about the tennis court pieces so so much um um so he didn't actually cover here and that might have been the point also when you had gotten up so but but if you needed to know something I think now time it I mean the the whole repair was essentially going to be we're going to dig out these cracked areas um fill them back appropriately you know layer by layer and then we're covering the entire court again that's correct the gist okay thank you m uh no I'm very good and thank you all very much and miss uh dep

324I'm gonna mess it up Beth thank you Batista thank Miss Man Savage I just wondered if you could talk a little bit about the um the special education students returning and the balance of decision- making between getting them over sooner while the construction is still going on I I'm I'm sure that there was some conversations about what was the right thing to do in that case and I'm also interested to know what's been conveyed to the parents um and the families about the fact that they'll be construction closer to the students than they've experienced um in other parts of the construction project yeah I can't speak to what's been conveyed to the parents um but as far as um as far as to the the construction and and we are there's not going to be

325contractors in this occupied space so we've worked through plans logistically to have the alternate egress and Ingress into the building that separates contractors from the students as much as we can um and as far as any dis disruptions on the over on the second floors above um we've been scheduling the work uh to try and expedite that now or address that on the next break the more noise inhibited work would be grinding floors and that's 80% done so just a little bit more on that uh question so this was a request made to the project team by Miss cumerford based on complaints received from parents about the current situation out of brooken we laid out all of the things that could be potential detractors and even with all of the those items reviewed with the

326teachers and the leader of the special ed uh team they decided that it would be for the best as to your question about what's been communicated to the parents I do not know all of the communications uh were handled by Miss comerford's team M GRE thanks for the background on the move back into the level one special education plat classrooms I think it was really helpful before when we talked about New Scotland to have the building leader be part of the conversation so it's good to hear that the building leader was part of that this conversation I think that's really critical to making the right right call here yeah so again all the questions have been already asked the only thing I would um suggest is is when you move the specialist students into that

327space with the noise if there's a way to insulate them a little bit better at even if it's a temporary fix the constructions happening uh it might not be a bad idea as Mr Hunt pointed out every effort's being made to do the noisier operations and tasks either before the school day starts or after it ends um and uh as he pointed out some of the noisiest work has already been completed or the majority of it has been completed but every effort will be made to limit that impact so it sounds like you guys have done a tremendous amount of work in a very short period of time to make that happen I really appreciate that and I appreciate the fact that the teachers and the administrators were really driving that I do think it's

328important and it's not a u job but it's um probably superintendent question he stepped out to ensure that the proper communication has gone to the parents because the number of parents who are listening to this meeting right now is probably like zero so for them to understand why they might have that experience I think would be valuable and the superintend in his back uh the question on the floor is whether the special education families have been um had the opportunity to get a communication to explain that they're moving in earlier which is wonderful and exciting and great for them but that they may experience a little more um awareness of the construction project than they had previously or whatever else we feel like they need to be communicated whether they know this so it won't

329become as a surprise we had been just speaking about this with myself and uh Mr Caris and Lori McKenna I don't know Lori if you're with us the extent that um Elaine and the special ed team have been communicating with families about the uh transition or we'll report back to you oh Ron can so I uh there was a letter that went home to the families that are coming back from brooken to to that space uh week before last I believe I I edited that letter and I might be remembering not remembering correctly but I don't remember anything in that letter about construction continuing to be going on in that space when the students were coming back so I don't know that that information has been communicated to the families the fact that they're moving

330back early and the positive signs around that were included in the letter uh again I don't recall anything about it continuing to be a construction area while the students are back in there being part of that communication I think just to be clear there within their space there will be no construction going on so it's just around and above them so thank you thank you moving on to the day automation for or EPC Contra hi good evening everyone it's nice to see you um I'll uh my name is Jeff day it's nice to uh be with each of you and um we wanted to give you just a quick update on the uh EPC project I'll be uh I'll be quite brief um uh the next slide please uh you don't want to go till

331midnight where we're close well I'll I'll try to make that uh uh not quite that how about that uh so very quickly to give you the uh overview uh the good news here is that the energy performance contract uh project uh the construction has uh wrapped up uh and we're kind of in the final uh final stages with documentation and such um so just to give you a quick uh reminder of the scope of work that we completed uh from a mechanic systems perspective which really uh mechanical systems replacement was one of the big driving factors for this project um at Arbor Hill uh we did a chiller replacement and um a boiler replacement um at the uh Ash building we uh did uh two boilers and a domestic hot water system in that hacket

332we had done a pool air handling unit system and a domestic hot water system updates um in terms of lighting uh up stes and retrofits uh that took place at Arbor Hill at Ash hacket and Myers and then at each of those same four buildings we also performed a building envelope improvements to try to make sure that we didn't um have uh um air escaping the building or infiltrating the building next slide please so to give you a sense of uh kind of what has been accomplished with this project um the annual savings uh that were uh expecting to see here are about 35% uh reduction in energy consumption uh and what that really meant uh in terms of some statistics were uh we we were able to um positively affect and upgrade almost 7,000

333uh lights um we uh touched 150 different doors with weather stripping um uh we touched 14 different air handling units with duct ceiling uh four new boilers a chiller and um a pool unit and we'll get into some of that in a minute the chiller obviously had tremendous Logistics with I was very proud of the team about what they were able to accomplish uh we wanted to give you a sense of kind of what that meant uh in terms of some equivalencies um so that really amounted to about ,400 tons of CO2 saved or if you wanted to put it in terms of things like cars taken off the road it was about 297 cars taken off the road a year or the equivalent uh uh consumption of about 192 homes of power or um

334if you would like it in gallons of gasoline that was a good one too the equivalent of about 143,000 gallons of gasoline so really um uh wonderful uh impact not only for the comfort for the students uh for the resiliency of the building but also uh a very very positive effect for the environment next slide please so we'll just show you just a couple pictures of some of the projects that happened so here at Arbor Hill uh this is the hot water boiler that went in um and we'll just kind of go through these uh quickly the next slide please um here's the uh we had one existing boiler that was remaining in Arbor Hill uh but we did some uh controls work there so that's complete we also uh at Arbor Hill again um

335replac The Chiller uh um and this was really probably the the largest uh effort uh for the project uh quite honestly um again it was in concert with the capital project and the Electrical uh change outs that were happening at the building uh so again much much better unit works properly with the new um Power and Transformers um again off also in Arbor Hill uh we as I mentioned we touched the lighting so uh that was pretty much throughout the building uh here's an beautiful shot of the hallways over at Arbor Hill again we're able to preserve the um uh unique Lighting in each of the buildings uh again another beautiful shot of the cafeteria as well more lighting work there over at school of humanities we had um again uh we had two boilers

336there so this is the new boiler work that was completed um again classroom lighting retrofits uh took place here [Music] too um here's some hallway again some uh beautiful fixtures that were're able to we maintain the artist or the um uh original um lighting fixtures which just changed out the all the lighting to LED and then at hackit we'll take a quick look over there um again we were able to swap out one of the boilers there in the uh mechanical room and uh we also put in uh new domestic hot water tanks and heat exchangers to to get the hot water system working better and uh also just recently kind of the final piece of the puzzle this was new update since last we were together uh the pool unit has been set and

337uh is complete as well um again classroom lighting throughout the building as well and hallways and and uh and the remainder of the building and then last but not least over at Myers we'll take a look there um so again uh this one we focused on uh lighting Replacements in the building and then uh in each of the buildings again we'll just take a quick look at uh the building envelope effort so again this was a cocking uh ceiling door sweeps um and also duct air duct ceiling to make sure we weren't losing any air flow out of the duct work that's all complete now too uh in addition uh we have uh put in some new sequences of operations that are energy efficient with this equipment um uh uh doing things such as uh

338CO2 monitoring so um in some of the larger spaces we're able to tell if we um have already achieved proper ventilation in some of the larger spaces so we can kind of back some of that down if necessary but updated all those sequences to be energy efficient on the energy management side um lessons learned so we did have one uh really kind of notable issue occur it was actually on the you got all the way to the end of the project uh with the pool unit uh there was some piping work that was done uh for the unit and um we had put in place some temperature sensors some wells if you will in the uh piping and we had an issue where uh at one of those Wells we had a leak and it

339um uh uh damaged some of the wall in the maintenance office which was below that area and uh uh Danforth is resolving that at no uh cost to the district so we'll make that that um repair but again on this project um no change orders and like this was really the probably the most uh notable issue everything else seemed to go pretty smooth and uh thank you very much I think really where we enter at this point is um we'll be um uh uh working to collect uh energy and utility bills going forward over the next three years uh to confirm that we're making our Energy savings and uh annually uh you'll be seeing uh some nice reporting that comes out that really uh shows all of the certified calculations uh to make sure that

340the project is meeting its energy goals so uh again I I can't thank enough the project team that was involved uh but uh really um the school district has just been phenomenal and their staff who uh helped us with this has just have just been great so we thank all of you so much for a successful project and I guess with that I'll open it up to some questions thank you so much for your presentation I'll start with to my left with my board colleague dmer thank you and board member Savage no questions thank you board member Cree no questions thank you wonderful thank you so much and board member Elman yawi no no questions fabulous thank you so much board member Smith oh okay thought you about to skip over me um and Mr

341day I just wanted to say thank you and uh it's been a pleasure and and um I really do appreciate the information metrics the results that you the reporting I guess I should say uh that you're providing us um and so very very helpful and I do look forward to the the future information on the actual savings uh that that we uh that will result that will be a result of this work so thank you very much and your team really appreciate it oh you're you're quite welcome thank you very much and we thank you so much for your presentation that was fabulous great well thank you everyone it was uh wonderful wonderful seeing all of you if we don't get a chance to speak with you hope you all have a marvelous marvelous holiday

342and uh thank you again I appreciate you uh taking us so late in the evening it was very kind of you thank you have a happy holiday and a happy everything yeah you too so I'd like to make a motion to um amend the agenda to eliminate board committee reports and other business and move straight to adjournment I second that motion you're also chairing this meeting so would you like would you care to call for a vote Yes at this time I'd like to entertain a vote to amend the meeting agenda to conclude at this time all in favor good unanimous thank you all have a Happy Everything e e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.