CorpusRecord 59621

Amityville BOE Mtg 2/12/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / AmityvilleUFSD
Date
2025-02-13
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,363 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening ladies and gentlemen welcome to um a budget meeting which and St dat is February 12 2025 and we are the anal Union Free School District at the meeting at this time is myself president Lisa Johnson first vice president Harold seof second vice president Meg mesman trustees Leslie cretz Chris saring Caroline Banning as well as Wendy canestro also is our superintendent Dr Gina Talbert assistant superintendent for construction Mary Stevens assistant superintendent for human resources Dr briard way assistant superintendent for finance and operation Miss Olivia batsy the time was 5:33 when I opened up the session at this point in time can I have a motion to go into exective session at 5:34 for one for advice from counsel regarding particular persons correct um persons and that's advisement counsel as well matter related to particular

002person can I have a first please first request a second all those in favor motion carries we will resume open rly thank you now at 7:45 at this point in time please note where the emergency exits are and can you kindly silence your cell phones and please join the Board of Education in the Pledge of Allegiance at this point in time I'm going to turn the meeting over to Dr talber good evening once again to our Board of Education any colleagues who are present and our Community Partners thank you for joining us as we kick off the presentation of our budget overview for the 2526 school year um now I have the clicker go to slack our goal with this fiscal plan has been clear from the start to balance the vital needs of our

003student Scholars and the community while strictly adhering to the state mandated tax levy limit this budget which is the firstr draft reflects our ongoing commitment to high quality education one that not only focuses on academic Excellence but also nurtures the overall development of our students it is designed to support a well-rounded educational experience from co-curricular activities and enriching field trips to the critical upgrade and maintenance of our district facilities this budget was developed through a conscientious and inclusive process beginning in October and November of 2024 our facilities director along with head custodians and building principles conducted detailed assessments to gather and prioritize facilities request with a special focus on items that ensure health and safety excuse me at the same time our central office team engaged directly with building principles to review staffing needs our

004assistant superintendent for finance and operations also diligently projected contractual labor cost based on our collective bargaining agreements while ensuring that all grants funded positions were accurately analyzed and segregated from the general fund budget in December and January further meetings with building principles and directors allowed us to fine-tune our departmental budgets the newly formed cbac citizens budget advisory committee met during the fall and became engaged stakeholders in the budget discussion and soon to be development process they received a copy of the first round draft budget earlier this week and will collectively offer their recommendations to the Board of Education in March looking ahead I want to share our detailed budget development calendar which will guide us through the coming months so tonight you are receiving B budget Workshop number one which is an overview and we'll

005talk a little bit about the main budget drivers in the proposed draft on Saturday March 1st we will walk through the line by line budget presentation followed by two budget workshops during the month of March focusing on the revenues and highlighting the tax levy limit calculation in April we will review with an anticipated adoption of the budget as well as the adoption of the property tax report card on May 7th our budget hearing is scheduled and May 20th we will conduct our annual budget vote and election so today marks the start of this rigorous process and I'm confident that our careful stakeholder driven approach will result in a budget that responsibly allocates resources to support our student Scholars and community so I invite you to engage actively during this session and throughout the upcoming workshops

006as your insights are valuable to refining the plan with that in mind please join me in welcoming our assistant superintendent for curriculum and instruction Miss Mary Stevens who will present the slide on instruction followed by Miss Olivia buatti assistant super for finance and operations who will present an overview of the first round budget draft thank you thank you Dr Talbert so I wanted to speak to you a little bit about some of the enhancements we're anticipating in the area of instruction if you are not familiar with them our strive programs Ser as students with autism students placement in the strive program is based on their diagnosis and psychoeducational testing but it's driven by their IEPs during the budget development process Miss Lopez shared with us her projections for the number of students who will need

007to be scheduled first strive programs in the next year she's anticipating the need for three additional strive classes during the 2526 school year and in looking at the current Staffing and anticipated shifts in the strive classes Miss Lopez anticipates that that we will need to hire staff for two additional strive classes so based on students who are moving uh in age groups or moving to different programs she thinks that she'll be able to staff one of the classes with our existing staff and we would need staff for two additional classes if we don't keep our strive Services inhouse we would then need to find a way to finance out of District placements for those students to meet their needs uh the next bullet you'll notice we are planning a new role providing oversight to the

008csse process with a particular focus on IEP development and writing which will align the elements of the district goals for ensuring fiscal stewardship while also ensuring that all students have the necessary resources to meet their needs uh the person in this role would balance student advocacy with compliance and ensure that each IEP was crafted to provide what students need to be successful in least restrictive environments the next item on our list is a speech teacher uh we are seeking to add one speech teacher to our staff this professional would provide support for the additional strive students with the need of speech services on their IEPs and their full-time status would ensure that we're no longer Outsourcing for speech services we see the value um in supporting the social and emotional needs of students and actively

009pursuing alternatives to suspension restorative practices in schools focus on building a positive School Culture by promoting accountability repairing harm and strengthening relationships among teachers students and staff these practices offer an alternative to punitive discipline approaches like suspension by focusing on restoration rather than punishment restorative practices contribute to a healthier School environment where students feel heard respected and responsible for their actions to support this initiative we've included included in the budget two social workers one for the middle school and one for the high school their roles would include building strong relationships preventing and addressing conflict and will result in improving behavioral and ultimately academic outcomes finally we've added a band teacher to the budget this addition would allow us to restore some of the music programs that were eliminated last year as a result of current

010staff sharing the ability to provide lessons has been impacted at Park Avenue the middle school and the high school additionally some music electives were eliminated the additional staff member will allow us to thoughtfully and purposefully restore our music programs and finally in the area of operations uh we are looking for an accountant to be placed in the business office thank you so what are our main budget drivers this year every year when you go through the budget process certain items certain expenditures come to light that are really stand out and you would see throughout this process that there are one or two things in this budget also that drives the whole budget the 2526 budget is currently at $14.9 million this represents 6.12 or 7.2 million increase over the 2425 budget but there are two

011items in the budget that are interf fund transfer that will be covered on the revenue side of the budget this includes the debt service for the library I'll I'll be shedding more light on that as I go along and then if you recall the district auditor recommend that we transfer $570,000 from general fund to the capital project fund to cover the shortfall in the bond project the 2016 Bond project so what are we talking about when we say top budget drivers contract transportation is one followed by the two new strive classes that we are planning to set up next year health insurance Charter School enrollment and Employee Retirement System the amital public library reconstruction is funded by a Bor secured by the school district on behalf of the library because the title to the land

012that the library was constructed constructed on belongs to the school district and therefore they cannot issue their own debt the school district has to do it on their behalf which we already did this past year and both the interest and principle are due that will go on for about 17 years in the 25 26 school year we have only the interest due so subsequently we have to pay the principal and interest as we go along and The Debt Service payment for next year will be $598,000 but the library will fully pay the district back so it will be a wash on the district box the same with the interfund transfers we have balances that remained in previous cap projects that have been completed those balances will be transferred back to the general fund as interfund

013revenues to cover the $570,000 shortfall in the 2016 Bond account the total amount of the library debt and the interfund transfer is about $1.2 million that will come in as revenue on the district box so if you net it out you are talking about it's not a 6.12% increase but it decreases it by a whole basis point and I'll get to that as I go along so what is the main budget driver that I'm talking about we have to issue an RFP for transportation services transportation services are mandated by the state and every 5 years we are required to issue a new RFP the RFP that is expiring was issued before covid and as most of you know at that time a lot of cost were much much lower than we are experiencing now so

014we are anticipating a higher Trend in the cost or when we issued the RFP so we have to prepare for it if you look at the budget increases this is the budget increases in all the entire budget increase next year you can see that Transportation alone has the highest Delta in this graph so we are we are anticipating based on the conversations we had with other school district that this is going to go up significantly next year what are the other budget drivers increases in the cost of student services and that is what my colleague Miss Stevens mentioned in her presentation that is the two strip classes the T onee teacher as well as the restorative practices teacher that social workers that we are planning to hire next year then we anticipate an increase in

015the cost of retirement system Employee Retirement System the Employee Retirement System is the retirement system for our support personnel which includes our custodians our clerical workers our AIDS and monitors and that is established by the controller of the state of New York and next year they anticipate the cost will be 16.5% of payroll which is more than a 1% increase from the previous year health insurance this year was a lucky year but health insurance rates come on a calendar year basis so we know what we are going to pay from July to December come December they'll give us a new rate for the 26 20126 calendar year and we don't know it yet so we have to anticipate that cost and we are projecting a 10% increase and this is based on the PRI four

016years we were looking at an average of about 12% increases in the pr in the pr four years for health insurance this year the average is is going to be the average is 2.54 so that's a really significant decrease but we don't know what it's going to be in calendar year 26 Charter School enrollment is another area that um as you know we saw it in the appropriation status report um we currently have about 64 students in the district in charter schools so we have to project and anticipate any additional cost and when we get the transportation required West around April 1 we are going to double check this number to find out whether the number ties to the projected number that we have this will cover the two the additional $200,000 will cover about

017eight additional students next year and Charter School cost goes up and down when we started this fiscal year we we were anticipating a negative ative number of about $255,000 as of last week it had gone down to about 95,000 per our accounting record general liability commercial property all those Insurance costs are going up because mainly because of the child victim act school district and all all School District are paying the cost of those um reimbursement they gave to people who file claims against school district and all of us are bearing the cost building management system is an area that we have to look at very carefully our building management system allows our system building system to work together right now um we don't have a very good system and what we are planning to do

018next year is to upgrade our building management system we hope that with that we wouldn't be Happ having some of the cold in the some of the classrooms that we have been experiencing the past year we also want to address the public address system at Northeast school when you talk from the main office sometimes you cannot hear it in some of the classroom and this is something that needs to be addressed we've postponed it a couple of times and I think this is this needs to be addressed as soon as possible then we are planning to replace the roof on the concession stand at the high school this is also long overdue so what is the budget to budget increases this was what our was referring to with Transportation if you see the budget increase

019the projected increase for transportation alone here is about $3 million so when I said that was the main budget driver this was what I was referring to other areas is special education instruction and security and building use as well as the items that I just listed a few minutes ago building management system and the PA system all are included in the $617,000 then we have The Debt Service here as well as the employee benefit of $778,000 if you deduct the debt service for for the library and Inter fund transfer from the increase of what $7.2 million you come up with a budget increase of6 million of this amount $3 million alone is towards Transportation so what are some of our budget highlights co-curricular clubs we are bringing it back to the 23 24 levels field

020trips we bringing filter back we talk about restorative practices M interventionist at the high school and then we all know about Northeast schools when it comes to the revenue side we still do not have all the numbers to project our revenues because our state revenue the initial State a projection was proposed by the governor that is simply a proposal the final state aid proposal will be released by the state legislature around April 1 at that time we will get the final State estimate and will be able to accurately project our revenues we depend on state eight as state aid is about 35 to 40% of our budget and therefore any impact any changes in state aid has a very very significant impact on the budget so the next Workshop as Dr Tabet alluded to will

021be the line by line budget and that will be on March one and we'll be going very much deep detail and it will also be tied to the budget drivers that we just talked about and thank you so much thank you Mr watsi I I I think these are a few questions by some of um the board members and I think that we all just need to keep in mind as we move forward that on Saturday March 1st that will be a long period to that will be a long morning and so please I think it's 9:00 a.m. that that we're starting and so please come you know with your questions and suggestions as we go through the the line by line so I go ahead um Miss canestro um thank you to all Central

022Administration for the presentation um I do want to acknowledge the teachers that are here that have the interpretation um devices in the back I love that um I'm wondering if Dr Talbert if there's a way to like advertise this a little bit better for our budget meetings so that we can get our English um not speaking um parents and Guardians here maybe is that something that we could push out maybe through parents Square so that they know that they'll be able to understand what's going on so thank you for being here um okay I have a a couple of uh things on this um first I noted uh about the budget development and you know everybody that held meetings about this and so forth um as you'll note the the board wasn't on here um

023you know we weren't consulted with or asked what we wanted to see in here or not certainly we could do it at these meetings it would have been more collaborative if we did this before um as far as the the citizen budget committee we only got minutes on that once is that something we can get so we we could be apprised of what's Happening yes with them okay great thank you um okay something that I had asked for multiple times was to share the anticipated tax levy cap that we'll be putting knowing that it may change if there's any adjustments with the budget I noticed that it's not on here um which is the norm for a lot of districts to share when they do their present budget presentation I'm wondering why this was not

024shared as I said because we depend on state aid for 35 to 40% the governor's budget proposal did not show any significant increase in state aid and we anticipate that our state aid projection will change and that has an impact because you take the entire budget you take out your state aid you take out all your miscellaneous revenue and that is what the tax levy typically is within the 2% cup so unless we get that number fmed up it will be given incorrect information and we are required to file it within next two weeks anyway right and doing it so here's the thing most districts do share that knowing and explaining to the to the constituents that it may change I think it speaks to transparency it does has have to be filed with the

025controller by March 1st so that is something that we should have our anticipated tax cap Levy I think more now than ever um our voters and and our residents would be interested in that because they're they're going to be hit with the equalization increase and the tax levy cap I am very interested in our tax levy cap being lower and if we're saying that there's a budget to- budget increase of 6.12% what would you be basing it on unless you know what the anticipated tax cap is so we have the figure we're just not really sh ing the figure because it may change for transparency's sake I would like that shared sure we'll work on it and share it well do you have it can you share it now no I don't have it now

026i' I've been working through the numbers because there are some variables because certain things happened last year in fact we we we called Council this afternoon to clarify one or two things so I we have to be very sure about it before we share the numbers right so you will share with us okay um I'm just going to try and move something on that topic so let just let let Miss canestro finish and then okay I I'll I'll just go quickly I am I do like when you said the social workers for restorative practices we got the survey results back I think it speaks to what people want I know that I've certainly said that we tend to be very punitive I would rather us be restorative I'm happy to see that um that was

027addressed um and as far as you know all this special education this hasn't been presented to the board before that there's such a focus on that so I was surprised to see this as far as the transportation cost and the RFP so this came up that you know we had to stick to our mileage and our our transportation per policy but when I had asked for a policy there is no policy then I asked for a certified copy of the referendum that the voters voted on to change the statute of Mand you know the statute from New York state for transportation and that wasn't provided either so here's my concern my concern is you can't change the statutory mileage without voter approval and a referendum right so if we've had this and it's been done

028I think you said for over 10 years it by what Authority The Authority is of the voters right so that's been done incorrectly which I understand is before your time but I'm just saying that so have we been giving away millions of dollars in transportation without the voter's approval of course the way to correct this is to have a referendum this year um if there's enough time I think it's 60 days before the vote to correct that the statute is more than three miles for grades 9 through 12 and the statute is more than two miles for grades k through eight right and the reason you do for vote a referendum is you want to make sure that it's equitable course the schools right one parent in one school wouldn't be in favor of it

029being less than the other I think that has to be corrected but my question to you is the RFP on what mileage is the RFP based on it's based on the current practice that's a problem yes but we are reviewing it and it hasn't been released yet so it's something that we can look at okay because um you know I think one of the the the things that I enjoy being on this board right now is really I feel like this is a course corrective year right so we're trying to course correct the district move it forward work together to try and get things back on track because they were off the rail so when I identified that issue now we have to correct the issue so I'm not sure how we could go out

030with an RFP without the voter approved referendum it would seem and I would ask that you consult Council that we would have to go on the statutory mileage and then if we change it I mean I'm not sure legal's not here I thought they were going to be here no they're not they weren't staying um so that's that um so I think that that plays into that and that's going to be a huge part of it because the transportation you're saying is 25 to 30% increase but we have the wrong mileage um and also as far as Transportation costs goes I know that we do for Northeast it's not mandatory Transportation the one question I have is about safety for three and four year olds on a bus with no booster seats or anything they're

031very little on a bus so Dr Talbert is that anything that we've reviewed or can we review so let's let's we'll take we'll take we'll take the question and then from that point um it may be something she'll have to get back to us on so therefore we'll be able to hold on a second but I'm just I'm just I'm just saying to she may be able to answer it she may not be able to answer let's give her the opportunity for three and four year olds on buses they're required to have car seats and our boosters as well as safety belts and we do comply with that all of it yes okay great excellent okay um so I'm sorry let me just go on to this um so I see that we you know

032I went through the line by line budget too so I'm not sure I'm in align with everything that's being you know presented but um you know there are some things that are being presented and my question is this like we're we're bringing in new positions but we accessed a ton of teachers our students were impacted by that it would resulted in larger classes some course offerings that we had before we don't have now and it would be beneficial to try and bring these teachers back to the benefit of our student right student achievement should really be The Driver of a lot of things what are the plans to bring back any excess teachers so be just right quick just one quick question so um Wendy with Wendy's question that's being asked with in Dr T

033when you come to answered just kind of add to that would that be part of the March 1st um line by line that we would have that discussion in terms of you know bringing teachers back not bringing to that's just my question so as you answer that question I'm just adding well I'm I just think it's a budget meeting so this is a place to ask questions no I'm not I'm not I'm not I'm not questioning that I'm just saying I'm just asking will that be also be part of the March 1st that's all I'm asking in terms of bringing teachers back it's based upon enrollment numbers as well as course offerings and as we have looked at the numbers um as we all know there was overstaffing last year due to teachers being in

034Grants um and having preco numbers at that time when the numbers decreased the staff stayed on so our class numbers on the elementary level do not warrant any additional staff uh on the elementary level in terms of our uh students with special needs we have been peeling back the layers and analyzing cost comparison as to whether we should host programs in District or Outsource and when we look at the cost on both ends adding those uh Strife classes inhouse is a savings for us as well as our program gets great reviews from parents and uh who have their students enrolled it's always great if we could educate our special education students inous if we could provide those Services yeah um something that I know that we've been brought up before is I think we need

035a director of it I didn't see that budgeted for um you know I think we need a Dean at the middle school I didn't see that budgeted for I appreciate that you want to do the social workers and the restorative justice I think it's great but I also do think that we need a dean there um let me just I'm almost done uh the charter schools I just want to talk about you allocated $200,000 and you said it was for about eight students am I remembering this incorrectly that I thought it was an increase of about 17 students this past year so aren't we under budgeting then if we had 17 why would we only budget for eight just just go back to the mic thank you it it wasn't 17 additional when I think

036it was about 10 additional so what we with the budget we brought the number to this year's level and added eight more okay you brought it to 64 and added eight more okay I'm I'm almost done sorry Northeast upgrade I think there's about $220,000 in upgrades to Northeast the the my question about Northeast is is Northeast budgeted for and covered in this budget do we have money to cover all the expenses for Northeast without an infusion from from the state without getting money from elected officials it's in the budget but do we have the money to cover it any additional funds we get will be helpful because this point we do not know how much State dat we're going to get so any bullet grant that we get will be a big help because we

037don't I don't we don't know how much state but I I don't know that that answers it does that mean that there's a hole in the budget that we don't have enough Revenue right now to cover the cost for Northeast for our whole budget because if we do have money then we don't have to ask the elected officials if we have to ask the elected officials then we need the money right so I'm just I just want to get a definitive answer because if we don't I know that we've been reaching out you know um soliciting trying to get help from elected officials my question is what is the contingency plan if we do not get money from elected officials so the first round budget that is presented tonight includes the four prek classes and

038the Staffing that was laid out for Northeast with an in increase of a 6.12% so this first round budget we've discussed Deans at the middle school necessary we've discussed director of Technology we've discussed director of security we've discussed director of curriculum there are so many gaps that we need to feel in the district in order to be operationally functional and efficient and more effective and we are making choices understood as we move forward on Saturday with the line by line I'm sure there are items we're going to infuse discuss talk about the rationale for removing it's an evolving document and so but what but what is the conting because I feel like that was an answer what is the contingency plan if we don't get money from elected officials what is our plan there is

039no contingency plan Northeast is in the budget so it's totally in the budget un covered it's in the budget that you have it is in the first round draft budget it is in the how much is the budget for this year 124 million it is in the $124 million proposed draft round one budget I I have two more questions but Megan just wants to break I think that the missing puzzle piece is that we don't know what the tax Levy increases but you have an estimate of what it is so is what you are presenting to us something that is below the tax levy cap is it below two is it below the that because that will answer the question if we can afford to do everything that's presented in this can I'm I'm GNA

040doctor I'm gonna let Miss Patti answer the question um go ahead and answer the question then then I I I want to say something as well yes the task cap has to end just like we said at the 2% mark That's the highest that we promise we will do at this point in time so we're going if there's a Delta if there's a Delta we have to wait for State a to meet that Delta and then we have to go back and cut back to make the budget work that's the plan so so if I'm understanding this correctly right now our goal is to leave it to get at the 2% correct if it's above if it's above that then as we do the line by line in in the budget presentation we have to

041look at what be eliminated what do we want to eliminate what do we want to keep whatever positions that everyone's talking about there may be positions that other people want to talk about we have to decide okay they're they're making these recommendations of these positions we may decide that you know what after hearing other options have after having discussions maybe we don't want this position we want another position that's where the line by line Bud go but let me finish so also I think also what will happen is that if we if we don't get the aid that we that we hope we're going to get then that means we have to continue to go forward and and cut more and that's so that that's how we do moving forward but I also want to

042give some other board members an opportunity to ask some questions though I'm just rounding out I just have two more things two more things just just kind of Hur because you've been while I just want to say the governor came out and said if they abolish the Department of Education that the federal funding is going to fall on the backs of state and local agencies which would mean that we would have it would fall on us so I'm worried that this may C come down at some point on us so now we have the equalization increase we may have that we're not sure what's going to happen and I would like to see the tax levy I don't want to go to the max before piercing I want the tax levy to be low I

043don't want to overburden our taxpayers and just the last thing you had carried over expenses from the charter schools from 2324 to 2425 you carried over that we owed like $225,000 or no no no no that's not it what the $225,000 you saw in the appropriation status report in the 2 425 school year is our encumbrance we are we are setting money aside this year based on the initial enrollment projection that we got from the child schools as parents with Drew their children from the charter schools that's why I'm saying it went from a negative $255,000 and when you get the appropriation status report in the next Treasures report you would see what I'm talking about okay and M M Basi the only thing that I'm going to ask for we are two months behind

044on these budget to actuals we really need last months so when we get the end of February we have we have a meeting we're only going to get December's we should be having a month just within a month it should not be two months because we don't have in real time what our our our expenditures are and everything so I would ask let me just let me just clarify one thing the treasurer prepares his report based on the receipt of his bank reconciliation and the bank give you those statement at the end of the month so when he gives us December the December bank reconciliation are done in January so the report that you're going to receive in December for in the next month the next uh next budget and next meeting is for December

045because we are technically one month behind before he can do his reconciliation and unless he knows his cash position he cannot prepare his treasurous report I've always gotten it I've always gotten it a month behind and and the controller agrees it should be one it should only be a month all right so I'm going to go to another trustee um Leslie do you have any questions um Wendy did a great job with so many no no no no that that's absolutely fine just want to make sure that we're budgeting enough for the charter school students that's that was a big issue last year yes that we didn't budget enough yes we are it's it's that's why we are planning as soon as the kids apply for transportation we will get an idea as to how

046many kids will be going to Charter Schools and we also have to be careful because there's a tendency for some parents to withw register late to register late or to withdraw their kids which is what we are seeing this year all right so please let let and when will we anticipate getting paid back from the library that's 600 grand um we have been talking to them as soon as because the amount is due July 1 M so immediately after that we'll be going to the library to give us back the money okay Caroline thank you Miss batti um I understand if you don't know 30% of your Revenue it's going to take a while before you can get concrete numbers but it is helpful to understand that you are presuming the 2% tax cap um

047having read the slides prior to coming here the notes that I made go back to Dr Talbert your presentation in August about your Staffing priorities who it's most important to bring back and you had mentioned back in August a third High School assistant principal which we now have and that's great a director of enl another Elementary assistant principal the director of technology and a full-time director of Fine Arts so that was established now going seven months ago I'm sure a lot has changed we know a lot more since then but I too was surprised to see the emphasis on the strive classes you say that it's actually a savings but in this presentation you also list them as a budget driver so I guess can you it seems a bit of a contradiction is it

048costing us more to put the emphasis there or are we it is what actually increases our budget but if you have to compare with placing the kids alternatively placing the kids outside in another program say boss's program it will be significantly more and you have to tag on the cost of Transportation which makes it even significantly higher so what what we are saying even though it is a driver for us if we had we have to place those kits the kits in a bosis program it's going to be even more cost and that's the comparison that we're making so what you're saying then as like a percentage of the students needing needing education they're just more of them therefore they get the priority at the expense of all the other priorities that were listed back

049just mandated August yes okay um you had oh Dr Talbert when you mentioned meeting with you know building principles to assess their staffing needs is it possible for us to see that like what each building feels like they need you know more of do you have some sort of document or report that is an evolving conversation so when uh principles come to the meetings initially they come with a wish list because they know what they need to outfit their building the best way operationally and academically for for children and throughout the course of the conversations things are scaled back because we can only include so much in the budget so those items are scaled back whether or not we have official sheets we have scratch outs arrows circles back and forth and then we end

050up with a document that says this will be included in the first round budget I I think it would be helpful even to see that which is more um detailed than what we see here just like we you know explained several meetings ago seeing a draft budget or a draft budget to actual you know we can handle the fact that things are have chicken scratched and are you know not set in stone and subject to change but trying to keep a breast of what the needs of the district are information like that imperfect as it is is better than nothing at this point um all the survey results that we got from the five schools very instructive and you know hearing things that teachers need more lead teachers it just seems that there needs to

051be more support across the building at large and I I just want to be confident that this budget as it being presented to us in its draft form is going to put more of the Staffing back where it's needed most um I'm I understand we need to staff the strive classrooms or you know fund them but so far I just want to make sure we're not losing sight of the fact that we did lose a lot of people maybe we were overstaffed in certain aspects but we need a director of enl so we do we certainly do that has that started out that started out in our initial conversation it didn't make it to the next round um we're looking to see if there are grants and we know that's sort of in a little

052flux right now but if there are grants that could absorb that position even today we spoke more about um support that is needed September 2025 we need to have science and the science of reading at a certain level per S's requirements we're on track but we need a layer between the school and an executive central office who are saying we're here to be able to support what's actually happening in the schools in terms of ela in terms of math do we want Department chairpersons back certainly one Department chairperson May set may require us to have two additional teachers in that department to support the department chairperson those are the kinds of conversations and the ask and the thought exchanges that have been taking place between the stakeholders and so then we rolled back and said

053well looks like we're going to have to go one more year with building level leaders a stien position until we can get um enough fiscal solvency to go back and slowly begin to bring back Department chairs so the process has been very transparent since October from the ground up and we're bringing to you where everything has settled at this point but we can certainly talk more about what was put on the table initially but as the executive uh management we're bringing to you um where we are now and it's a lot it's it's it's a lot and I guess I would just like more more info more detail and I I know it's asking for more work but um because I want to be encouraged that you know as progress is made that we see

054that and understand okay we can't get back exactly to where we want to be in one year maybe not even two years but at least we're headed there maybe Caroline would it be helpful maybe like at the March 1 budget line by line if that's information that's provided you know during that time frame would that you know I don't want to hug mic just want to say I I would like to see more of like a matrix as Megan said of like what our staffing was what we our wish list is and where are we in our journey from you know getting from where we were back to where we want to be I don't know about back to where we want to be but where we want to go gotcha where we want to

055go there was a time when we had nine and 10 children in the classroom we can't afford that so we don't want to go back to that I understand yeah okay Carol you um m Mrs Lopez where did she get the information to anticipate the increase in strive classes how and where did the information come from provide more information but these are all driven by cpsc decisions so it's incoming students uh in need of services I could just add the specific number for you they're anticipating 22 students via cpsc who will require strive placements um and then she did analyze which students would be moving buildings which would change the structure of the existing classes and she also analyzed who might be moving from a 611 placement to an 811 which would increase or decrease

056um so those changes helped her know what was necessary okay thank you um another question IEP facilitator we have two administrators in our PPS office we have school psychologists those are the people that have always written and facilitated the IEPs along with the special education teachers why do we need another facilitator we spoke about uh the need for oversight to make sure that the IPS were drafted uh with what the we we spoke about it a few meeting ago with what compliance is uh so making sure that we're complying with regulations but not over serving students and that what's on their IEPs aligns with what their needs are so there was a need for that additional level of oversight that was our decision but shouldn't that fall upon the two PPS administrators as well as

057the school psychologists and who's running IST meetings csse meetings I don't really see a need for an additional facilitator we did see um The Presence at the CSC meeting as the critical piece of that we thought that that would be a leadership role and that for the two administrators to do the rest of their job asking them to be at every annual review was cumbersome and that this extra level was going to support special ed in a way that they needed it okay and the last thing I know that some of our board members are concerned about class size but I do know that we are going back to pre pandemic class siiz um I have to refer back to your presentation and the dire situation with academic achievement why don't I see more remedial

058staff included in this budget to address those needs so we did look at um the reading teachers I think I spoke at our last meeting about looking how they are districtwide so that we can make sure that we're serving students appropriately looking at our mtss plan uh figuring out who needed tier three supports and we think we're okay in that area um the principls did look at their data when they were thinking about Staffing to figure out how they were going to move student achievement and so that's included in some things that didn't require um additional budgeting that we could just rearrange so that was important to us that we were looking at what we have how we're using it and where our needs are so it is included in the budget but it doesn't

059reflect an increase in Staffing because I have concerns I know that you said that we're picking up students that are one year behind in reading and we all know that the evidence points to the they're a year behind chances are the following years when the curriculum compounds they're going to f fall behind even more so I just really do see a need in additional remedial staff I know we can always benefit from additional staff but in our analysis we think that we'll be able to continue to support students and move their achievement okay thank you Chris okay um mine's oh I'm sorry sorry go ahead may I just respond to something as well thank you so much um as it pertains to our director of PPS and assistant um they are really responsible for special

060education PPS registration and attendance and it's a heavy lift all four of those areas need dire attention and as we are pulling back the layers we're looking to see how we can provide layers of support so that we can appropriately address some of those runaway areas or areas that need more accountability so I just wanted to um respond about the IEP facilitator and why we are looking at that so that the director and assistant director can appropriately handle the umbrella that is before them with those four areas I understand that but in the past that has been part of their job performance iup facilitation and it is yes and um we are where we are today thank you Chris thank you um going to bring up again something that I had requested in the past

061and was brought up by other board members this evening on having a staffing Matrix for the district so we know how many teachers are in each building for each subject if the position is filling a vacancy or if it's a new position um um and then on top of that um if we're adding positions if you could build a business case for it um you can mention the educational impact um the total cost of it if there's possible savings from the investment as you stated with the shrive teachers for bringing those students within the district um if it's a position that we had two years ago before positions were accessed um what else did I have um go gois can I go through um if it's a new position what the student teacher ratio would

062be following that um what the trickle down impact would be as you were just speaking about in the PPS office you're saying that this new position would make these changes with with these other positions um what else did I have and if you could provide a comparable salary for that new position either with a similar position in the district or what you've seen posted in other districts that would be comparable to it and um if any of this could be provided or all of it could be provided by the March 1st meeting that's all ahead thank you thank you Chris Megan but do we get an acknowledgement on the March 1 or I just jump in just just go ahead jump in and I'll I'll let it come back okay so um clearly there's a

063lot of questions on this academic programs and operations I I don't feel as though we were involved and I think that all the other trustees have expressed that very well um I am a little bit unclear are we assuming that we're bringing back students that have added District placements just to clarify that there was mention of 22 strive students some of those students have not been placed we are now assessing it and evaluating it and saying it is better to have that program in District because if it's going to cost and I'm looking at it just from the finance pieces 150 per student to send them outside excluding Transportation if we have eight students in the class it is when you do the cost benefit analysis it will be better for us to have them

064IND District than to send I I understand I'm just wondering are we assuming in the numbers that we're convincing students and families to come back is my question no okay this is um cpsc preschool educ education 22 students with IEPs that must be placed by the amville school district either we will place them in the district or we will place them out of the district and we're required to place the upk students prek students prek students yes but okay but prek is not like a required when you come to a cpsc the student is maybe four years old so they'll be placed in in a kindergarten a fiveyear they'll be placed in a Kindergarten class but they're going through the cpsc prior to next year starting so these are students we are required to educate

065we can't say no and we have to figure out the best way to say yes based on meeting their needs okay thank you for cl um expanding on that um I too um wondering about the prioritization I don't want to repeat what others have said um very interested to understand and how decisions were made to present these as the roles that were going to be carried forth into the upcoming year so that we can better understand and and weigh in on that decision process um how does how I also don't understand if this is actually accounting for the survey results so the the feedback of the survey results how that was incorporated into your budget process we wish we could have Incorporated so much more um you did see the social workers for the restorative

066practices uh one of our goals is to improve culture and climate to decrease disruptive incidents and to provide mindfulness and restorative practices so one of our initiatives is districtwide to have our staff trained in restorative practices we've had bits and pieces of it throughout the years and in pockets and then to have these um social workers being able to TurnKey that and leave those initiatives in our secondary buildings with our staff as well as students okay is there okay is there considerations of why we're not doing that at Park Avenue in Northwest too hoping that it's trickling down budgetary wise um um for as far as the $570,000 inter fund transfer from General funds at Capital project fund um I thought that we had the opport um option to present a voter proposition that we

067reallocate Capital project funds in projects that were closed out and funding that was available to offset that deficit that were carrying in our capital projects pot of money so this budget is carrying money instead of the voter proposition yes we we run it by Council and they said we we can do either of two options it's an accounting it's an accounting thing and we can do either of those two option either bring it as a separate proposition and if it's brought as a separate proposition we have to go through the 45 day timeline so if we put it if we put it through the budget we don't need to do that as a followup is oh hold on let let Megan finish please well it's a followup to that but I don't want to interrupt

068If You're Gonna Keep Going Megan yeah just let it keep going please all right thank you um I don't I don't mind I I mean I I would it's more of a conversation but um I guess I need to ask the Board of Education to that we can consider on the 26th voting to proceed with the voter proposition to it's a board decision to reallocate or to present this voter proposition to reallocate Capital money that's sitting there to clear that deficit in the Capital Money rather than carrying additional money that's on the backs of our taxpayers to then move over to the capital no it would not be be at the back of the taxpayers because the is the balances that remain in the cap project will come in as revenues interfund revenues one interfund

069Revenue one interfund expense and they wash out so either case it will be zero that that was my question it seemed like it there's going to be two transfers two trans like the revenues and then the expend cancel each other out they cancel each other out thank you so on on page on page 15 when you talk about the subtract the library debt in the into fund transfer that's that 1.1 and that brings it down so we are we are utilizing that money to bring down okay thank you for clarifying okay um um as far as the transport you said that we're required to put an RFP out every five years yes would it behoove us to put R fees out every two years every three years so that we don't get hit with a

07030% increase at the end of five years and it can just more gradually increase with because that's just what happens with things it's gradually going up all the time yeah the reason why most school distri do the five year is CPI is attached to it so within that 5 years when we went out in 2020 to do the RFP there was a clause in it which said the the transportation company cannot increase the amount they Char the district higher than the CPI for transportation so it capped how much you can do and you can plan ahead for five years if you go decide to go back for an RF every two years you give them the chance to increase the cost so it is always better to tie it in within a 5year span than

071to do a twoyear okay um we already Wendy already spoke to the distances in the RFP and I guess in your your number that you're carrying here what about Northeast are we so we're providing transportation to Northeast even though we don't have have to for prek students yeah we have to review that with Council one more time we have to review it with Council to confirm whether or not we don't have to provide transportation of I thought it was not is it not mandated it's not Monday that's so okay so the $3 million projection increase projection in assumes prek Transportation corre it assumes pre prek Transportation with the half mile yes okay thank you um the health insurance cost increase was 2 and a half% last year I know you spoke to an average of

07212% over four years I know we spoke about this and ATA negotiations um now we're going to carry a 10% increase that seems like a little bit conservative considering last year was 2 and a half per. I thought it was the other way around but that's for the next from January of 2026 to June of 2026 because we don't know what the rate is going to be right and it just it just take another flu Outburst or FL flu outbreak or Co for the insurance companies as you know to increase the cost and that is the second most expensive cost in our budget okay I guess I still I mean it was 2 and a half% last year and now we're going to carry 10% which is almost $700,000 in the you never know it's

073very difficult saying it out loud I guess the board members can think about it um Charter School enrollment I agree Leslie um you know we're only carrying an increase of eight I don't know if that's enough last year was 17 did you say but you know whatever projections we make we always have to think about the cup because if I decide to go 20 it means that I have to cut back on something else understand yes um okay um is there a priority list that can be shared from buildings and grounds um because I know I mean you you point out a few I'm assuming there's other building and grounds um but you point out just a few the BMS and the and the PA system mhm so there's been like a lot of heating

074problems uh you know major boiler repairs in this building that we're sitting in um I guess I'm a little bit surprised that there wouldn't have been I guess bigger issues brought up from building is ground yeah um we list all that but because again we have to think about other departments instructional programs we have to prioritize it and say is this something that we can defer one more year um this is exactly what happened last year with the PA system we had to defer it one more year so it's something that we look at we we make a list and then we go through it one two three times to make sure that these things can make it into the budget or not or whether based on the priority list which is based on the

075health and safety issue we can defer it one more year and that's how we do it because whatever buildings and grounds takes somebody else will have to be put on the next level okay but similarly to I guess the academic um prioritization can we can the Board of Education please see the list of requests from buildings and grounds sure thank you um um I I understand Northeast is in uh the budget is there are we assuming no there was options for revenue streams discussed at the Northeast presentation Community presentation yeah yes I think you are talking about the 4410 at this point yeah um we're still receiving information from the state and that has not been finalized yet so it's it's very not included nothing is included right okay um okay thank you g go

076next um so I just just a couple clarifications not clarifications but um questions so on March 1st when we when we go to meet I know there's been some requests to to get the the list um whether it's for um Builders and grounds whether it's for academics I I know in the years ago this is prior to um the administration that was here there was a time where we had um building administrators and different departments that just came to the mic and they just shared their their wish list you know with with the entire board so I mean that has been you know done in the past that once again that was prior to the administration that that's here now um I'm wondering if and I know that we cannot ask the administrators to come

077on March 1st but I know I think there was one year where we did it that there were some individuals that were actually here and so when we had questions where it was connected to building and grounds for example then um they were able to kind of speak on their reasons as to why they wanted this versus they they wanted that so I'm just kind of sharing that information with you and maybe that's something that can be considered to be done um because we can get the list of what they've been requesting but sometimes knowing why they wanted something over something else is also very helpful so that's just that's just I would love to hear that at the February 26th meeting you know just several days before if that's not to last minute just

078like a presentation where we can take notes because that would be more than what we have now yeah whatever whatever it may be I'm I'm open to it but it it was I know one time when we did it for the um line by line it was nice when they were actually here because let's say for example if I said no I don't want to do I don't think we should do this thing I don't think we should have um this teacher or that do something for building grounds when they were here they were able to say well I hear what you're saying um but I if I could actually have this but maybe a little bit of that that would be beneficial yeah but you're saying that they're not going to be around on

079Saturday no I'm just I'm just saying if you're correct if they were if they cannot come on Saturday maybe it's something that can be done on the 26th that's like the next best thing not ideal but better than nothing right and it's and once again I mean they could share it with us but doesn't give they can share with us I'm just saying that at the line by line it allowed more of that dialogue that to take place but but at the at a meeting you really it's difficult to have the dialogue you're just getting the information and that's it so I'm just making a suggestion as we move so we can either get the list and then we can look at the list if we have questions then we can take the we can

080bring the questions back to Dr talber and then maybe those individuals could attend or they can answer the question so we can do it either way if we can get the list and if questions um we can submit the questions in and then that way they can maybe attend to at one of the meetings so go ahead Li I think I remember that we got a list we had a presentation and um a quick presentation but a list of everything that principles or directors wanted of each department or whatever and then we went through it and decided do you remember that we decided what what was accepted what was it was difficult but at least we had feedback you know so it was it was yeah it was a long list of things that they

081wanted and some of them would prioritize if I really really really could get it I I would I would like I prefer that but so I thinky said something is that some thought I thought I heard Wendy I was just gonna say um yeah I would you you had just touched on it Lisa if they're going to come and present I think that was a couple years ago I think I was at that meeting I remember is just to prioritize what they want what is critical what they need because to Dr Talbert's po point you know when you're asking somebody what they want they're saying everything I mean I would do the same thing I want it all so just to prioritize that um I just want to um confirm that you'll be giving the

082tax levy cap the the anticipated tax levy cap at the March 1 meeting is that correct okay and then you're going to try and get this Staffing information to us by March 1 right yes we we'll work on it and then buildings and grounds okay great and um the other thing is with the three million increase I was just listening to Megan you know if we're in a quandry right now because right we have to go to the statute because we don't have a voter referendum to change the mileage but there is no mandate for prek for busing so if there's no mandate for prek for busing that saves $3 million okay so we just did that um right but does it does it save to three million or it doesn't save three million how

083much insignificant actually how much is it it's it's not going to it's not going to be very significant because can you can you get us that figure I think I think at the at the line by line that maybe that would be something that could be brought yeah that would be great if we could have that the other thing is because if if yeah okay we'll get you that information great and then the other thing that I just noticed going line by line just in anticipation of March 1 I noticed that there wasn't a Breakout by building of like the gas electric phone and then there was another category I think it was like garbage and carding or whatever can we get a Breakout by building of that like it was just districtwide can we

084just get a break out of building we build it districtwide why don't you they say bid oh you build you bid it bid it okay just white and then something it's 93,000 right it it was high yeah okay the last thing that I just want to touch on when we were talking about educating our own students for special ed we kept talking about it's more cost effective to educate our own children do we have the resources that we need to provide a quality education to them in District I understand it's cost effective but can we provide these children every single thing they need for special education if we're going to do it in-house I I don't want it to be cost effective driven I want to make sure we're giving them the education and then

085if it's cost- effective great like that should be the priority we are particularly proud of the strive program that we've developed um other districts come they look at it they are always interested in following our model so I'm confident in telling you that they are receiving a high quality education when we keep them and that we do look at the programs we have and we determine whether they would be better served somewhere else okay thank you so much and thank you again for the presentation I think we Meg I think it's Megan and then Chris and then I just have one I just have one thing um I agree I would like to see the administrators here on the 26 to talk about their priorities and their buildings their requests is that something that we

086have to um consense on or like take a board consensus um yes I mean if if the board wants the administrators to do a quick quick two a quick two minutes go two- minute um just little list of of what their priorities are then that that would definitely be helpful um but also let's keep in mind are they are we going to give them are they going to do the presentation and then we're going to you know question them through and through so you know we just we we just got to keep that in mind so yes if does the board want the administrators just to do um a two-minute I'm just looking for something a two-minute presentation on their desires yes yes I do yes yes right thank you Dr tal but if we

087can get that from the building administrators Chris thank you uh I just want to reiterate because I feel like this would reduce a lot of the back and forth and questions that we keep asking about these positions And just hoping that we get what I was talking about having a business case for new positions and the impact that it'll have on everything stating why we would be why we should have it and the cost and all that cuz like a lot of these questions are would be covered on something like that and if you need me to read off the list again after the meeting I can yeah okay Carol I just want to request when you present the instructional staff you do break it down with special ed teachers speech teachers but could you

088also break down the remedial staff reading math and I just want to say to my fellow board members I understand that class size is important um however speaking from experience as a longtime educator if you really want to support a teacher and a student provide the intervention lists in the classroom that are specifically meeting the instructional needs of the students deficits that's how we are going to increase our achievement thank you any other question from the board thank you so um before I do um Community input we just have to amend the agenda to add um two items and and both are resolutions so that okay I thought was someone's I'm sorry I was thought it was jewelry so we have um two resolutions that we we do need to add to the agenda and

089and both are so so one is agenda one is a we need to amend the agenda to add agenda item item 2 A1 um which is a resolution that states whereas the board received a complaint alleged the violation of District policies um by by complaintant submitted by the individual identified in confidential schedule a and initiated um and another complaint initiated independent investigated by the complaintant and now therefore be it resolved that after due consideration the Board of Education determines the complaint is not um substantiated and be further um resolve the Board of Education to authorize the district clerk to advise complaintant of the outcome of the complaint so so the motion is to amend the agenda to add agenda item 2 A1 motion I think I think I heard um Carol sea first oh sorry

090Caroline Fanning first Chris naron second right all those in favor of agenda item A1 I I I sorry so that's I recuse yeah I know hold on one second so yes is Caroline Fannon Carol coff Lisa Johnson Chris neron and Leslie cretz right and recuse themselves is Megan mman and Wendy canestro so the motion carries five z c a motion to amend the agenda to add agenda item are we voting I think we just voted to amend that to the agenda I don't think we actually voted on the actual item you are so right can I have a motion for agenda item 2 A1 thank you motion second so that I think was Caroline again yes and Chris okay thank you now we're actually going to have a vote for that item that that's what

091I thought yeah we vote Yes to amend the agenda I vote Yes I don't know what you do Megan I vote Yes okay now we're gonna have a motion for the actual item 2 A1 so is Chris faon I mean Caroline Fanning Chris naring so now all those in favor of AG of agenda item 2 A1 I I so now it's Caroline Fanning Carol seor leis Johnson Chris naron and Leslie cretz and then Megan and Wendy recuse themselves recuse yeah recuse so the motion carries 5 Z now I'll try this again have a motion for agenda item to amend the agenda to I to add agenda item A2 which is a resolution denying Transportation appeal um in regards to confidential a whereas the education received and consider a transportation appeal from the parent of the

092students listed in confidential schedule a b resolved the board education hereby denies the transportation appeal and authorizes the district clerk to issue a decision letter to the parent on behalf of the board education can I have a motion to amend the agenda to add this resolution sove second that's Carol seof and Wendy canestro that they all those in favor of amending the agenda to add this resolution I I motion carries 70 can I actually have a motion for the vote on this resolution 282 motion Chris nering second Caroline Fanning the motion is to support the denial is that correct I don't have the motion in front of yes so once again it says where is the Board of Education received and considered a transportation appeal from the parent of the students listed in confidential a

093b resolve the education hereby denies the transportation appeal and authorizes the district clerk to issue a decision letter to the parent on behalf of the Board of Education you're welcome so all those in favor of this I I I I motion carries 70 thank you for your patience on that now is there any committee input at all regarding the budget that was presented I would say the initial budget hi good evening denel Cronin Amityville uh just a quick question in reference to because it was indicated that transportation is such a budget driver if New York State according to their law indicates that students are busted within a certain mileage from K to 8 and then 9 through 12 do we follow that guideline or do we make up our own guidelines go ahead Dr T

094good evening and thank you for your question uh past practice has been for many many years in Amityville to have a mileage limitation eligibility which was less than the states threshold I don't know those numbers off hand but I do believe it's prek through two is a half mile and then 3 through 5 and 6 through 8 and 9 through 12 have different mileages I understand that that's a written policy P practice we're talking about people that have to include an equalization rate we're talking about a huge driver we're talking about transporting prease students which are not required by law why are we not following New York State guidelines why are we making up our own rules it's it's mandated and it was Prior I mean I think um I think Dr Tabo was gonna

095answer the question go ahead so we've had several conversations about this and some of our own inquiries to the transportation companies have been around the cost for prek and we're still trying to just double down confirm so the way that the contract is designed is that you are Contracting drivers on a um per hour basis for example 4our slots 5H hour slots 7 hour slots those are examples so if your prek students or within or being picked up and dropped off during that 4H hour slot there's no additional charge to the district so if the high school students are saying being picked up at 6:00 a. and if the prease students are dropped off by 10: a.m. then you fall into that window of no extra cost now in terms of the mileage eligibility we

096are looking through the records we have been talking to long-term employees who have been employed for many years to determine how this decision was made about our Li our mileage limitations we have been looking for voter referendums we have consulted legal other legal firms who were in the district prior to the legal we have now and um we are still in the research phase of that so my understanding is there should be a legal referendum indicating these you're not going to tell me that a law firm who has represented this District does not have that information I'm I just would be very hard pressed to believe that a law firm does not have that so we are still researching that we are still in the process of trying to confirm where that document or information

097is housed who has it um and so that's that's where we are okay so if my understanding is now I've lived in this community many years there has never been and if the New York State guidelines is two miles there has never been a time where we've come to a school district and say Yes I want that to to be the rule so if New York state is saying two miles why are we not following that we follow every other New York State mandate why is this one different we've been following what has been in print or Amityville what has been in print but that's not the law but it's not been in it has not been confirmed to be policy or we have not located a referendum that supports it and how long do

098how much how much longer are we going to research that we only have a short window of time correct I mean there is a I want the best for the kids in this school district but the taxpayer is absorbing a lot and the whole Equalization rate has only added to this and if the window of time for the pre students are outside of that window I know there are many districts on Long Island that do not do not provide transportation for prek liability purposes and because frankly they can't afford it so I think that's something that would be very important to look at to make sure that children are safe in their buses and the fact that the taxpayer would be represented appropriately L thank you thankk you hi Margaret cha a quick question on

099the again the transportation so maybe I didn't hear clearly enough but the RF EXC me excuse me can you just repeat your name because we have a new District cler yeah Shuff thank you surely so my question is the RFP went out and is this figure based on a hypothetical or this is I say the notation where neighboring schools are getting double digit increases what have you and you're using that as a guidance but double digit to me is like 11% 12% and then I see 31% so my question is where are you getting this 31% and where is this new figure coming from is it hypothetical or is the RFP come back like I'm I missed that conversation the RFP hasn't gone out yet but we we met with the current Transportation speak more

100to we met with the current vendor and that's the indication that they gave us in addition to that we call School District that have issued an RFP the last couple of years and that's the indication that we got because our RFB as I said came out before Co and that was five years ago so so how many vendors are there like so you how many rfps do you put out it's one RFP and we send it to it's one RFP which is sent to various vendors that provide transportation there are various vendors on the island they about five or six big vendors on on the island yes so they all come back with the figure we haven't issued it yet it's when you do it how many how many numbers do you get back from

101different vendors I can't predict that I'm sorry yes it could be one two three because it has to be cost effective for the vendor too they have to have a yard which is close by because it will be very difficult from for somebody from South hington to come here so they also have to and they have their you know I just was wondering how many choices you get you don't know that until it comes back so not everyone even is even going to bid on it because it wouldn't be feasible correct exactly got it and my other question was what constitutes Boe District Clerk and district meeting what is that what does that cost like what what does that constitute 13 which says the first line the first line which says the hold on 1345

102it's probably the the the salary of the district clerk the full-time district clerk along with any board education expenses that's that's what I'm assuming but will we go to do the line by line no I'm just asking but I'm I'm just saying I'm assuming but that's a lot that's a lot yeah I'm just assuming it could be the um 134 500 it's a combination of the Board of Education expenses as well as the district CL and the Monies to the election how you know the election workers and you know the voting machines and all that election these meetings security correct corre but the increase of 144 what does that constitute oh it's because we are we are and that's what is going to come when we do the line by line I will be there

103the line by line okay it was it was the iPod for the voting to to last year we had $6,000 budgeted for iPods for uh the budget vote and now we are bringing it back it's something that the board is has to look at where we to go through the line by line that's really part of it so 14 Grand in in iPods for one day no no no it's only 6,000 say it again it's $6,000 oh and that's and plus the increases in whatever thank you any other comments input okay um also I'm I'm as for the budget presentation on March 1 um let's really make sure sure that we advertise really well and blast out that way that there'll be a March 1 budget presentation line by line mean I mean to get

104it to get it out that way to the community so therefore the community knows that this is taking place because it's something that's really very informative and it allows for the Board of Education to have these discussions and to be able to go back and forth so it's something that's very informative it sometimes does not always allow for the community to provide input but it does allow for a lot of dialogue between the board education and and all the trustees as well as the cabinet your microne is dying right um I have one so and also to advertise for um you know interpreters as well um quick question didn't we have a a a budget committee is that still intact yes we do yeah and okay so they don't they're not are they here so

105there there's going to be a report I think Dr Tabet spoke about it in her budget presentation it was the the CBC um citizens budg budget um committee so they're going to be presenting to the board in I believe it's in March yes some of the members are here tonight okay so how many how many meetings have they had since it in its institution I think three go three meetings and we had one yesterday and how many members are there about 18 and you meet once a month right or once every other month has it I forget what it's about once every month yes once a month yes and okay and did they have input into this so far or not yet at all like I don't understand how that what what second comprised that

106we have been discussing it just what's here yes excuse me and are they required to come to the budget meetings no there's no requirement but some of them do come here every budget every board meeting I've been seeing some of them and in fact some of them are here right now okay well great thank you but I think it's as a resident and a taxpayer I think it's absolutely appalling at the attendance of this meeting I am shocked shrined I am appalled that people do not give a crap about the P taxes that we paying it's it's it's sad beyond words thank you yeah just just go and go to mic just just give just give your name eglinger from amville I just want to clarify one thing is going back to the transportation if

107we find this referenda this um memo or whatever from garci Garo about voting on changing the mileage is it in the board's wishes to put a memorandum out to change it back to what the state says we should have to save us money because like we said said time is of the essence so I'd like to hear tonight how the board feels about correcting that situation in order to decrease the transportation cost um so why can't we discuss it right now I mean it shouldn't be a big discussion it would be going back to what is legitimate and it would save us a lot of money so I I don't see where the big discussion should be and it should be decided tonight because you do have a Time Factor where you have to decide

108make the me memoranda the it's a referendum referendum put it in the newspaper do all that jazz well if there isn't a voter referendum if there wasn't a certified one if they don't find it and there isn't one we are automatically at the statute of two miles for K through 8 and three miles 9 through 12 if there's no voter certified voter referendum that's where at we wouldn't have to do anything if we wanted to change the mileage you know to to make it tighter then that would be have to be a referendum so we really need an answer if we find this or not so can I just ask the question that I have for example what what is the mileage let's just say from and I'll go both directions let what is the

109mileage from let's say Jefferson Avenue in North Anville to to the high school right and then we can we can go the other direction what would be the mileage from Ocean Avenue right to to Northwest like what what is that mileage so my my question is this and we have we have to find out because my my question is this if we're talking about two miles right that someone has to be more than two miles to get busing so that means for someone who lives on Ocean Avenue that goes to Northwest I don't think that's too miles so that means that parents or Guardians are going to have to get their kids to school every single day that will also mean it will impact individuals who have to work and everything so I'm just I'm

110just I'm just putting out that way I think it's something that we have to really really think about that what what is you know I don't think there's any and I may be wrong and I'm not I don't want to speak out of term but my question is what is the mileage we got to find that out and and I think what is mile from both directions so because if that's the case then then that means they really probably wouldn't need to be any busing and if it's three miles to the high school if it's three miles to the high school I don't think there's really anyone in Anvil District that's going to need a bus and that's one of our largest expenses right so Jefferson Avenue on Google to Aville High School is 2.7

111miles there you go and that that's not so that's three miles they need three miles so that means everyone that's you know up that in that direction won't so I'm just I'm just saying we we have I have grandchildren in the district right now they're bust and if my daughter-in-law knew I was up here saying this she'd probably take a gun to my head but in the world that we live in and the expenses that we are andreed we have to do something to get that budget down so if the transportation can be adjusted to a quite a bit amount the board is obligated I think to do that did you share responsib yes and I because I mean I understand everybody has problems everybody you know if you want to get your kid to

112school somehow you're going to get your kid to school everybody has issues both my daughter and son both work so he and grandma would probably be bringing the kids to school so I'm really up here putting a gun to my head but in reality these are the things you have to do in today's world and I really think I think it's 60 days isn't it 60 days that it has to be done before or it could be 90 was six we we'll confirm itely I know it's close in order to get something on the ballot I think mid-march we have to do it so I really think a decision has to be made we can't just sit back and say well times is of the essence yeah we'll look into it if gerso and gerso

113doesn't have that paperwork they should have everything well the district should have it really a voter referendum a certified voter referendum should be you know you can't you have to keep District records for 55 years we should have it and the problem is right now right now the problem it can't be found so for me personally I I cannot say right now tonight that yes I want to go back to three miles and two miles I just a little bit more information about what would really be the impact like how many how how wide does this go and that's that's just I just want to find and we can't just look at the emotional impact we have to look at the financial impact right and I'm that's I want to I want to know the

114mileage before I make a decision before March 1 Lea we the next time that we're we have the 26 we have a meeting we have a little bit more meeting we'll have hopefully more information then but then by March first we need to make a decision right can I ask something does this does that um ation impact our ability to put out the [Music] RFB that's something that we yes you're right we have to talk to and what do we what sort of timeline do we put on the RFP for the response is it a month the last one was done June of that year so we are a little bit early but it's always better to go out early okay I'm sorry I um oh you're saying we're not going to put the RFP

115out during budget season so that we know that we have to yeah with coun what's the timeline of the response I guess is my question we always give about six weeks six weeks yes so we'll know before I so we need but how do you what's I haven't read the RFP how is it written but you know can can we wait to make the decision on the mileage or is that going to impact your ability to put out the RFP of Transportation it will it to impact our ability so we have to make the decision on the 26th yeah okay thank you last Community input count let's can I and when you're doing the referendum and you're figuring out the mileage and doing all that it would affect how many hours you need the buses

116two hours four hours seven hours do we need two hours in the morning two hours in the afternoon that would all affect how much money you're spending so one falls upon on the other and it has to be done in a timely fashion like within the next couple of weeks thank you theia wolf 100 Avalon Court Melville good evening um very um important conversations as it involves as it um involving Transportation um it is something that the district should be looking at very carefully to make sure that we are transporting those individuals who um who qualify for that uh I think one of the things that people should and um is important to realize is number one what the practice has been the other piece is is that um I believe we just had um

117I think it was uh truste uh Caroline who said something about the distance or someone said it was about 2.7 miles someone on oh sorry Megan trusty Megan said it was about 2.7 miles so if the if the if the mandates or the regulations are three miles um then who's getting on the bus how do that's going to impact our funding because we if kids don't have access to transportation to get to school everybody doesn't have the same resources and I understand that we live in a day and age where people have to try to find a way to make things work but if we don't have kids in schools then we not getting any state funding so that's going to have a have a significant impact on that talking about it from a budgetary

118standpoint um the other thing is that since we are looking at this I think that it's probably time that the district should consider your own Fleet we a small school district having your own Fleet of buses would be sign would significantly decrease Transportation costs you can set your own mileage based off of you know whatever kids that we have that you know may need to go to Charter Schools or um the kids that are here in the school district um that would be a significant cost savings yes there you're going to have to find areas you're going to have to get a bus depot and all the rest of those things but over the course of time the district would realize savings as it relates to Transportation um but it cannot be um overstated that

119if we were to change the change the mileage and I guess you probably would have to find a sweet spot to make it um more palatable for the for all of the residents who are responsible for um paying taxes um we have to do realize that part of that fin final piece is our state funding which means kids have to be in the classroom and if they can't get here then we don't get that money just one last final Point as before we adjourn just as a reminder everyone that um if this if we go back to the state mandate for the transportation guidelines for the mileage that this impacts both public as well as um parochial school which is St Martin so it impacts both School schs which means that um the kids who

120attend St Martin's would still would adhere to the same guidelines as the with the kids who attend the public school right and I have a motion to adjourn the meeting at 9:37 moov second hold on W canestro is first Carol see over second all those in favor I I motion carries 70 f

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.