001good evening ladies and gentlemen welcome to the amville union pre School District combined board meeting today's date is January 22nd 2025 and I'm calling the meeting to order at 6 at 5:36 I apologize right um currently president at this session at this time is myself what president Johnson our superintendent Dr Jina talber our first vice president Carol seor second vice president Megan mman our trustees Leslie cretz Chris naron Caroline Fanning Winnie gestro um Dr Bridget W Human Resources Olivia wats assistant superintendent foror finances Mary Stevens assistant superintendent for CP instruction and our legal counsel John sheening as well as our new District Clark ly so at this point in time can I have a motion to go into executive session at 537 for advice from Council Council anything else beside Council particular person's employment historyman
002Council and particular person's employment history second Leslie qu was first gy off a second all those in favor I motion carries 70 we resume open roughly around 7:30 session of the monthly meeting it is January 22nd 2025 um at this point in time please note the emergency exits uh closest to you um there's no smoking on school grounds please silence your cell phone and please join the board in the Pledge of Allegiance at this point in time is there any Community input regarding border items right seeing none I will go to agenda item 2 a 1-4 can I do that all together can I do agenda items 2 a 1- four four all together yes yes have a motion for agenda items 2 A1 through 2a4 please Chris Nan is first Winnie keso is second
003any discussion on these items I'm seeing and hear none all those in favor I I motion carries 7 zero I'm just going to pause for one one quick second I just want to um acknowledge someone who's new at our table and that is Lyn lson at the end she is our new district clerk so we would like to welcome Lynn in regards to agenda item 2B the policy committee met last week on January the 15th something like that yeah there were several policies that that we did review and they're under revision with our district clerk and then they'll be provided to legal with the goal of them being on the agenda for next meeting I'm going down to agenda item 3 A1 have a motion for agenda item 3 A1 please motion Leslie cretz is
004first second and Caroline F Fanning is second any discussion on this agenda item yeah uh I had a question um just so I'm totally sure the legal requ requirement is 180 days 183 what 180 days 180 okay so the number of days here was double checked yes okay great and then if I can make a suggestion just looking at the calendar because you have three days listed as potential snow days could we switch November 26th to May 22nd um and then instead of what you have at the bottom April 2nd 6th and 7th being the snow days change that to May 22nd April 2nd April 3rd and the reason I make that suggestion is because I don't recall us ever having the day before Thanksgiving off except last year which seemed unusual so it it's
005like you squander a snow day so to switch it to Memorial Day weekend is a nice weekend and then the way you have the snow days if we do need them it breaks up Spring break so instead of having an entire week off for spring break you may have two days at the start and then two days back at school and then two more days which for people booking travel may not be great I think go ahead up the Tim thank you for the feedback and great ideas um we do collaborate with stakeholders around the establishment of the calendar and based on feedback uh if you notice this is draft four so we've gone through the various scenarios um and of course due to the additional holiday of the Lunar New Year um tough decisions
006were have we had to make around the Memorial Day Weekend around the Wednesday before November uh Thanksgiving and um this is where we landed of course you know this calendar is subject to the board's approval um but this is what we are presenting based upon much deliberation and feedback this is where we landed any other comments from the board before I see well the Lunar New Year I guess next year falls under president's week so Fe right February break so we at least save it on for that yes just speaking to M little more sorry um are you done can I add something um to Caroline's point I think families and staff would probably utilize an April break to go away if six and seven are you know in flocks depending on what happens that
007would really jam up a lot of people's plans um I would be more comfortable with the second and third being utilized as emergency days and I do agree moving the Friday the 22nd because sometimes these things whether it's if it's due to weather it's usually you know we don't take away days till the end of the year so giving the Friday before Memorial day off and having that as a day as emergency rather than the Wednesday before Thanksgiving I just think more most especially to me is that that's odd to say the six and seven are in flux so in discussion um the second was a Friday uh I mean the second was a Thursday the third was Friday and the Monday and Tuesday so this is the feedback that we received and so this
008is what we brought um we're open for discussion course so I I do have one question I'm I person the 26th of November I'm comfort with but my question is this could we do the the 9th and the 10th because I'm not too sure instead of the sixth and the seventh could could the 9th and the 10th be considered so at least there's a straight number of days Thursday Friday Monday Tuesday Wednesday but then that's right in this back in the middle of the week what days are the 9th and 10th April that's therea Friday April 9th and yeah that yeah that's not good I think the whole week having having the stability of the whole week off for families and for staff would probably be ideal I would agree for the with Caroline's proposal
009so are we proposing 8th 9th and 10th is that what I'm hearing well what I suggested take November 2 6 put it back on the calendar and in exchange we take May 22nd off the calendar and that would be one of the flex days the first day to give to snow and then the next two snow days if needed would be April 2nd and 3rd and then that way you have an entire week for spring break as most families are accustomed to but I think also on Friday the 3 That's Good Friday so some people may want to observe Good Friday so that's the reason that you probably couldn't do the second and third yeah so and over the years there has frequently been the day before Thanksgiving off and a lot of people do
010like that for traveling mic yeah I was just ask I was just asking Dr talba does we're getting feedback so my preference would be that if we um we're talking about it now we can make a decision and maybe put it back to the Cal because there's a lot of different ideas that are going back and forth they probably need to look at a couple things before we make a final decision so I think the second and third I don't I'm not in support of removing those two days if it was the second or third six to seven and eth hypothetically and then if you came back the 9th and the 10th but that's once again right right smack in the middle of of time off um so I think we need to look at
011a a couple more options why why can't we vote on it right now we we can but we need to make a decision on what it's going to be so maybe put the so the question we need to make a decision so there's two things that are out that way one is removing the 26th of November and putting it on Friday May 22nd right and then May 22nd would be that first snow day that would be removed so that's that's the first thing that's on the table right now and then based on what Caroline had said then you're looking it couldn't be the second and the third Caroline because the third is a is Good Friday so maybe the 2nd April 2nd would be the 2 day that would be an option for a snow
012day of course I'm trying to keep it as continuous as possible and we might not get three so whether it's the second and the third or to your point the nth and the 10th I I would go with whatever has traditionally worked for the district as a parent I've never encountered a spring break that wasn't a complete Monday through Friday which I think is what a lot of people are accustomed to so so if we need more feedback from more people we should we should get that so right now what Caroline is proposing is once again November 26 removing that date and moving it over to May 22nd and then May 22nd would be the first option for the snow day for snow day the second thing would be April 2nd leave that as is
013but then that would also be the second option for the snow day and now the question would be what would be the third day um I mean I see your point about Good Friday it's either a religious holiday or asking people to come back for one Friday after a week off is a c fall and then what are the odds we going to be in that position are we going to have three snow days it's a gamble what do we want to do and so they are emergency closing days um it could be other situations other than snow um where we would have to close school sure and that's why I put it last just because that would be the hardest day to give up what are the odds that we have to give up
014three days so what yeah what do other people feel I'd say if we're going to take another day from the April break that the Friday the 10th would be the best because it's not a religious day for anybody as far as I know again not ideal mhm because it's a Friday U but if it's going to be one of those days non religious day yeah understood all right so right now November 22nd put that back on the calendar and move it to May 22nd that will be the first first snow day April 2nd would remain as the second snow day and then April 10th will remain as the third snow day that's what's on the table right now anyone else have an opinion I just have a question on on um Good Friday that's a
015religious day so the kids can't be penalized if they need to take it as a religious day religious days can't didn't we say to leave that one on I was leaving that one there I know I just think if you have a full break and people do vacation whether it's staff or families you might have a problem Staffing for the 10th we may haveing for the third too I don't think so even even for the TW yeah all around I don't think it's ideal to take away from the 6th to the 10th I just think that we're going to have problem Staffing it's I think any any way around we're going have problems because even whether it's the third because there are some individuals who who recognize Good Friday and they want to take that
016particular day off um so this this maybe can we take it in two parts move the 20 take the 26 off and put the 22nd on to see if people agree with that and the second and then the third day I guess we have to figure out so right now what's on the table is what I just mentioned so the question is do we want to look do we want to vote on those three days as an option and if if the if the 10th does not make it then we will put the third on the table is everyone okay with that is everyone okay with switching the 26th of November to to the 22nd of May yes not really but you want to do a roll call Lisa yeah I'm I'm honestly I don't
017want to do the 22nd to the 26 to the 22nd but I do understand the situation that we're in all right so this is what's on the table so once again everyone everyone understands everyone has the dates so I'm I'm looking for acceptance for all three of those dates November 26 taking that back and putting May 22nd April 2nd would remain as the second snow day and April 10th would remain as the third snow day at at current so is everyone okay with the first one so you're going to do one at a time the 26 to the I'm doing one at a time is everyone okay for the 26 removing yes to the 22nd of May yes yes sure I'm I'm I'm the only one that I I don't want that but anyway um
018no for me um 61 well we're not really voting yet then April 2nd where as the second snow day I'm fine with that yes yes yes yes and then April 10th for the third snow day no unfortunately yes yes for me too I'm waiting but that that'll be the last that's the last option right so we would get I know I'm also assuming we wouldn't need it but we would if we get to three snow days that would be the third one yes okay Leslie Megan I'll come back to you Carol not comfortable with November 26 no we're going back we already did no we already did November 26 we're on April 10th as a third snow day okay Caroline I'm okay with that Megan sure yes can we just right so you'll just provide
019an updated draft Dr talet can you approve it with these can we approve you've already voted to yeah can we can we approve with these can we approve the calendar with these amended dates and change so the amended changes would be once again removal of November 26 and putting it to May 22nd April 2nd would be the second snow day and April 10th would be the third snow day so motion to approve motion make a motion we already have we already have Leslie and and um Caroline so all those in favor with these amended changes I I I I I motion carries 70 you have a motion for agenda item 3 B1 please have a motion for agenda item 3 B1 second Megan mesman is first Caroline Banning is second any discussion on this agenda
020item all those in favor I I motion carries 70 can I have a motion for agenda items 3 B2 and 3b3 please motion second Megan mesman is first Carol seof is second we just would like to all those in favor I I motion carries 7 Z are the teachers is Margaret mlin here Saia con so we just want to recognize these two individuals for getting their tenue tonight so congratulations can I have a motion for agenda item 3 B4 to 3 B6 motion Chris naron is first Leslie cretz is second any discussion on these items seen and hear none all those in favor I I motion carries 70 I have a motion for agenda item 3B 7 please motion Chris NN is first second Carol off is second I'm just going to add in the
021person's name the person's name is be resolve upon recommendation of superintendent Dr Gina talber that the Board of Education approves the appointment of the following individual as indicated Charles con part-time home instruction coordinator effective date January 23rd 2025 to June 30th 2025 certification status SB L initial and rate of compensation would be $30,000 per year grow rated and this would be District wise right any discussion on this item all those in favor all those in favor I I motion carries 70 can I do agenda items 3B 8 to 3B 17 alog together sure move it we KES is first Megan mesman is second all those in favor I I I I motion carry 70 Kev a motion for agenda item 3B 18 please motion Chris neran is first Carol seof is second um at this
022point in time I just want to acknowledge Dr Bridget wake on her retirement thank you so much for your service to our district and we wish you the best in your future endeavors all those in favor I I motion carried carries 70 have a motion for agenda items 3B 19 through 3B 33 please second that's Carol seof is first Megan mesman is second just for discussion for agenda item 3B 22 there is a change in the um start date instead of the 23rd will be January 27th and will go through June 30th um 2025 any discussion on any other agenda items on that particular one you mean or something else because I have a question on any other one um I just on number 10 and 11 are repeats is that correct or was it
023supposed to be something else one for the once for the high school and one's for the middle school so their assistant of both are they do they run at the same time no okay so any discussion on item 3 b19 to b33 all those in favor I I motion carries 70 so Lynn just kind of we're going to take a note on this one can I have a motion to amend the agenda to add agenda item 3B 34 which is so can have a motion to amend the agenda to add agenda item 3b3 yes and 3B 34 um is a resolution it says be resolved upon recommendation of the superintendent of schools and I'll just give this to you I'll give you have to write it down I'll give it to you okay being resolved
024that um recommendation of superintendent schools um that the board education approves the appointment of the following individual as indicated instructional position the name is Maria Palmer as a permanent substitute teacher effective date January 27th 2025 to June 30th 2025 certification status is childhood 1 through six initial and the rate of compensation is $150 per day and the location would be the middle school right all those in favor to amend the agenda to add 3 b34 I mean can I have a first motion thank you kestal Chris naron I got Wendy and Chris um any discussion on on this item to add all those in favor I now Lyn this is the second half have a motion for agenda item 3 b34 motion for agenda item 3 b34 Carol seof is first second Megan mesman is
025second all those in favor I I motion carries 70 one more have a motion to amend the agenda to add agenda item 3 b35 which is I'll read the resolution be it resolved upon on recommendation of the superintendent of schools Dr Gina talber that the board education approves the appointment of the following individual as indicated which is an FMLA special ed teacher for the Middle School effective date um September 20224 to January 23rd 2025 moov second wnie kesal is first Chris naron is second all those in favor of adding this to the agenda I I I now can I have a motion for agenda item b35 Megan M first Carol seof is second all those in favor I I motion carries 70 I'm now up to 3C can I do them all together or do
026you want me to do anything separately can I do them all together anyone went separately I'm separate okay have a motion for agenda item 3C one motion second Chris naron is first wnie canestro a second any discussion on this item see and hear none all those in favor I I motion carries 70 can I have a motion for agenda item 3 B2 please motion um Caroline Fanning first Wendy canestro is second any discussion on this agenda item yes okay sorry I'll start okay so this is uh in regards to the corrective action plan um based on the auditor's report and in the report they noted the importance of conducting periodic inventory of all assets and the report acknowledges that we have now implemented a process for tracking specific assets but we still hadn't conducted the
027complete inv ventory and Dr Talbert your corrected Dev action plan acknowledged that we have a policy of conducting the inventory every 5 years last time being in 2022 next one not up for 2026 2027 so my question is what does the auditor mean by periodic um and should our policy be updated because now this is two years in a row they're pointing this out and it sounds like we're in compliance with our policy but not necessarily following the recommendations so miss miss banii we have been in conversation with Alan Hugh around this and seeking Clarity um would you elaborate on the response yes uh we are required to do a comprehensive inventory every five years and on a yearly basis we update what we have so it's not that there's a gab every year we
028as we any time that we acquire assets we include it in the inventory but every 5 years somebody physically comes here to count everything and rets everything I noted in the in the comments he said that we didn't bring on a consultant and it would sound to me consultant equals more money so I could see the cost saving aspect of not bringing in a consultant every five years so it just if he's making this commentary two years in a row how do we get on the same page with what his advice is there was there was a breakdown in that was the um I had to go back to all the companies that did it those we have CIS that comes to do it and then there's asset system them that we work with on
029a regular basis so there was miscommunication as to exactly who perform the comprehensive inventory and we realize that CIS actually did do the comprehensive inventory in 2022 that we were not aware of because they came during Co that was just around the time they came in though so had to trace the story to make sure that indeed these people came to the district and did the comprehensive inventory so was Allan you not aware of that when he did this like latest auditor report like how did he not know yeah he wasn't aware I'm sorry did we get a report when the yes I request report no but like one once the inventory was done what happened after that the company didn't provide Prov us with a report the company provided us with a report but
030at like immediately following the inventory or whenever they prepared the report no about a couple of months later so there was a little bit of miscommunication over there that we are trying to straighten up so we didn't turn key the report to the auditor that the report that was prepared by C Biz was not t ke to alenu we should include that next year yes okay um I have another is it worth including in the no we don't need not in the response okay I'm sorry go ahead Caroline I I something to well this is a different question but still on the um corrective action plan as far far as um how we're going to deal with I'm trying to get straight this it do you want to go first and I'll pick you back
031off well is it the capital projects what were you switching it's the the overe expenditure of the 20 the 16 Bond yes and the undere expenditure of everything else and the decision of what do we have to do are we going and all the transfers that can or can't happen with or without voter approval so it sounds like a decision has to be made and what I would like to know before we enter that conversation all things being equal where you don't have a district that is struggling to bring its unassigned but balance back up what would a district normally do in an instance where it has um unexpended balances in a capital project if you have an expanded balances in the Capal project you bring it in as interfund revenues into general fund on
032a regular basis on a normal basis that's what you do you didn't spend all the money you have to tr if it is general fund appropriation but if it's born money you have to use it to reduce The Debt Service two different approaches so when I look at the page 63 in the auditor's report and I see a $3.4 million um Surplus in in the capital projects all right some of that is Bond approved and we can't bring it over but some of it is not and we can no what what he's he recommends we do is you have to go back to the project that have been closed because the 3 $3 million plus that you're talking about includes some project that are active you can't close them yet it is those ones that
033have been closed and the certificate of occupancy has been issued for that particular project that you can close so it's it's not every one of them that he's suggesting we close it's about five of them that he's talking about we have to go in look at those ones that are old because Capal projects do run a couple of years sometimes 5 years so you have to wait until everything is completed the project is completed the retainage is released to the contractor so it could go a couple of years and sometimes there's a dispute going on so you have to wait until everything is settled with each project before you can move the money into General um I just I just want to interject I'm I'm asking councel about that because I think anytime you go
034into cap move money into a capital project it needs v a proposition yes so I am because I don't think that's what the corrective action plan says for the first one it's just saying you which one on page five you talking about it's just saying you could do a transfer without a proposition the first one I think we do need a proposition are you talking about on page five um page five yeah it says general fund transfer I think we need a proposition for that but but it does say down there general fund transfer it also says vote proposition so it's saying and this is that was one thing that Megan Megan was going to bring up correct because Megan when we were in um agenda review one of the things that we had talked
035about was um would it be a voter would it go for a vote or would it be just a transfer and we understood that it would have to if that's what we want to do it would have to be a vote cost a cost overrun in a previously approved Capital project correct so you're increasing the cost of speak more mic a little bit so if you're increasing the cost of that Capital project then you need voter approval to supplement those funds so the question that go ahead Megan oh go ahead do you want to finish yeah I was going to say was that by having it listed here as voter proposition and general fund transfer right are we it's two different things so are we do we have to identify it's one versus the other
036or are we stating that is it giv us that ability to definitely address what you just stated because if it's an over spend then we know that it has to be a voter proposition correct so whether you have an independent a separate proposition or you have an authorization within the budget they both require voter approval it's just two ways of uh arriving at the same end okay right so either it's in the budget budget procure and it's a transfer general fund transfer within the budget or and that provide you with voter approval or it's a separate proposition so is the way it's written here okay or no okay yes can't may I jump in y I'm sorry thank you um the general fund transfer proposition suggests that we would consider transferring from the general fund
037to the capital projects in our 2025 2026 budget so we would build it into the budget not necessarily um a proposition yes not necessarily a prop a proposition to pay off the remainder of the pay off the deficit the 540,000 $570,000 overage correct of the 2015 2016 bonds correct um when Alan U was here I spoke about this and I had I was very interested in this voter proposition so I would almost be interested in the board deciding that the general that we would consider the voter proposition as a priority um because when you look at Alan and I understand you're saying it takes many years to close out capital projects um but there is it does appear as though there's a decent amount of surplus maybe in excess of a million dollars if all
038of the projects are closed out that the proposition be put forth to the voters to say let's move some of that Surplus and really close out the 2015 2016 bonds and then potentially even another proposition depending on what really is the Surplus and I recognize that I don't really truly know what that Surplus number is but I'm privy to um being in the health and safety policy uh committee and hearing straight from Mr Galina various issues throughout the district that need repair um so would it makes sense to put to the voters that we create another Capital this isn't even asking for additional money this is just saying we have this other money we want to set like a new capital project for whatever the priority list is from Mr Galina that the funding would
039um potentially cover so I I do note that this is uh a bond proposition so you will need bond councel to look at this issue independent from my office so when you're when you are speaking about uh Bond propositions and overages for a bond uh you do need opinion of bond Council okay yeah okay um so I just want to qualify that I you know when I when I first read it I thought it was just general Capital work but I see that is it is a a bond proposition it was the bond so we have to make sure that that there is a deadline comp if we wanted to put a prop out there what is the deadline that we're facing to find out what our options are to make a decision and to
040set it in motion if we were to go that route so there there are notice requirements uh 45 days prior to uh the election you need uh to put out your first notice uh and so if you are you are proposing a uh proposition it should be in that legal notice and that's and then there are four Publications uh prior to the election thank you I do want to just point out that we are aware these options need to be thoroughly reviewed and so the disclaimer as we're submitting the corrective action plan is that these options will be reviewed thoroughly to ensure compliance with all legal and financial requirements with the focus on maintaining transparency and accountability to the district's taxpayers so for the submission of the corrective action plan we presented the options realizing
041that it's contingent upon further discussions and clearance around some compliance issues and I wanted to just clarify something because some of these Pro it's if you look at the balances that we are talking about about it's about $632,000 versus the deficit of 7 570,000 so the Delta that we are talking about is just about $62,000 it's not a million dollars so you're saying that's actually available could be projects that could be closed the next the N the net is about 62,000 not because the some project including the generator the middle school that has not been closed which is also included in this L yes okay thank you for clarifying that and Dr tabin I know that I just figured to talk about it while we're here um okay thank you any other questions in regards
042to the and I I just wanted to point out if I could Olivia regarding the least impact on the tax levy of the two options that we it would be to do it through the subject to bond Council reviewing it will be to do it through the regular budget but we have to talk to bond councel for his review and approval before we because there's Bond money involved and capital money involved so I'm sorry you're saying that through the budget it would be less of an impact to the taxpayers I guess intuitively I would think the other one no it's I'm talking about the cost because we have to if it's a regular proposition we have to advertise it 45 days in the papers and you know get Bond counsel opinion and all that so
043to me it will be less of a burden on us if it goes through the regular budget process the 25 26 budget it will come in as interfund expenditure and interfund revenues in the 2526 budget you're saying you just propose an interfund transfer without all the extra work of the prop Bond proposition but in the voters approving the budget they would approve that transfer exactly thank you got it any other questions on on this any other questions on this all those in favor I I I motion carries 70 can I do um 3 C3 and four together do you need me separate please you have a motion for agenda item 3 C3 please move Wendy canestro is first second no actually Chris n was second any discussion on 3 C3 um yes so we are
044moving money from salaries to minor building repair is $85,000 and it's listed um what what is here and in reviewing the treasurers report under minor building repairs it was budgeted $273,000 and it says that there's available $161,000 if there's $161,000 available for minor building repairs why are we transferring $85,000 um the remainder of that money is what we had earmark for the removal of the mcard so that is still sitting on our box we are still reviewing it and we have to make a decision that's why there's a balance there so this this monies came from salary Lin because we there were staff changes and so we saved some money there and we thought the right way to use it is to bring it into minor repairs to do the necessary emergency repairs that we
045needed to do because of the cool spell where um I understand that the high school has the portable diesel heaters where where is the funding for those coming from is it because that's not included in these that's not included in that yet um we have to go find it I have to go through the budget and look for some savings that we have realized in the budget codes and bring it to the you know and bring it to the board as a budget transfer also okay and that was like that's a rental so that's why that's rent you know that's we got a number that it could be as high as type of thing but right right okay and it's still under discussion okay thank you I'm I'm just I just have another question if
046that's okay thank you why wouldn't we take the money from minor building repairs and then make the transfer when it's necessary when we for like the mascot like why wouldn't we do that first it is always very important that when we earmark monies in the budget we stick with what we have we said we're going to do first so in our minds we have to encumber that money for that project to make sure that that project is done because that was voter approved anything in excess of that we've got to go find the money to do I I know what you're saying but it just says minor building repairs it doesn't say mascot do no if you go through line by line it does for that for on the budget it do say that okay
047all right thank you Senate the positions that were now left open are we not filling those positions we did fill those position but they came in some were not filled till lay down during the year so the Delta between the time the person left and we got in a new one there was some savings this is what we are we short staffed because of this Okay no Okay thank you any other questions on this all those in favor I I I motion carries 70 can I have a motion for agenda item 3c4 please motion second Chris ning is first Winnie canestro is second any questions or discussion on this item yes um I just want to clarify that the only update was the door hardening policy at the at the back so there was the
048policy as we accepted it and then I guess some updates the staff like the new staff had been written in okay um during the December health and safety committee meeting um we talked about a ra the Rave app um which the ATA Heth what was that called ra R I'm not sure what it stands for but um it actually came up as a at a request from the ATA and I know you were there Dr talber but I'll just quickly I'll try my best here um but it's a districtwide it would be to add to the districtwide safety plan it's free to use and it's for uh quick emergency notifications to the county and I understand that the village can also be added um to facilitate quick response to our buildings um so I wanted
049to bring that up because I didn't get a chance to bring up the health and safety committee meeting during the December meeting and then we have the districtwide health and safety plan in front of us so is that something that would require a policy to be able to incorporate into the plan so it is currently under discussion it would require the use of personal cell phones of employees and so we are um discussing that and we'll be Consulting legal on how we can uh roll that out in full agreement okay okay so with all unions okay understood thank you um I also and I know I I think I brought this up in agenda setting but if you can remind me um we talked about the response to the you know extreme cold if the
050rooms are less than 65 or hot I guess now greater than 85 um and should there be something reflected in our districtwide plan as to how we respond to those situations so we are going to discuss it further at the next health and safety meeting um and if we can talk out the details at that meeting okay then we can come back and elaborate all right great so that's uh the February meeting yes thank you thank you um I just have one thing so this goes up to the state right so the state keeps us all of the phone numbers listed here are all district phone numbers and I understand like for privacy we might do that but if there's a true emergency if the building's on fire if somebody calls the district I don't
051think anybody's is answering the phone so are these phone numbers are is this forwarded to cell phones is the one provided to the state with real cell phone numbers how does that work so the um contact information is school related and tied to the safety contact list at the state department is a contact number for a person in the district and thank you for bringing that up we want to confirm that they do have a hotline number to contact that person so we'll follow up on that okay great thank you any other questions or discussions on this item all those in favor I I I motion Carri 70 have a motion for item 3 D1 please motion Chris is first Carol seof is second any discussion on this agenda item um I just want to
052point out the claims auditor once again noted that their P purchase orders were encumbered subsequent to the date of the invoices service while these confirming purchase orders provide evidence of expenditures the real controls ensuring that such purchases are approved before being committed by the district I feel like this is something that keeps coming up I think it's I think it might be four so any other um comments we've been trying very very hard to I mean it's this year we've been trying to M make sure that every purchase there's a purchase order before but some one or two get true the track in fact we have not been doing a lot of handwritten purchas orders anymore it's something that i' we've tried to eliminate because even if it's an an emergency somebody I'm usually there
053most of the time so I get to sign all purchase orders okay so purchase orders should not and it's a good practice to his point to encumber all funds yeah I mean we keep seeing it so it's something that hopefully next month we won't say yeah I I do have a few thank um I have a few questions sure um this is the Appropriations report through November 30th for anybody that doesn't have it in the room um on page 20 I noticed that um there was like $47,000 encumbered under District transportation noted as field trips so I was hoping you can clarify what that is I'll have to check into that what that was I have to get the detail behind it page page 20 okay I'll check uh field trips per building under District
054transportation um it's something that we uh are aware that I'm interested in implementing and then I noticed that there was 47,000 dollar encumbered so yes if you could please clarify what that is sure um on page 11 um I noticed that um supplies workbooks districtwide there's only $20,000 expensed um I just is that the boss's code for is this 211 21 yeah 2110 is that the last line in the budget that code um I don't think so rolls up to instruction admins yeah it doesn't say both it does not say both yeah it says workbooks District Y 0,000 is budgeted there's there's one code that bues always charges us in one code and at the end of the year we have to do a general entry to split it between the two is something I'll
055investigate and get back to you on that also okay I guess I guess my my question is I guess when I see something like that I think workbooks would be buy it at the beginning of the school year so if we were saying we needed x amount of money why wouldn't we have used that money because I also then hear through the grape vine through friends well teachers say they don't have the supplies that they need and so that jumped doubt it me so I'm just wondering why would we say we need all that money for workbooks districtwide and then we don't use it I understand if you don't have an answer at this moment yeah um um and then on page nine and 10 I guess it's a similar this question it's teaching supplies
056broken down subject building seems like there's money there again this was the end of November um we also have to we also have to be very cognizant because most of the purchases occur in July and August the heavy the beginning of the school year the heavy school year I mean so sometimes when it's not used by the by November you have to critically look at it and go go back to the you know the buildings and find out exactly what why they haven't used it so it's something and because of changes in staff too I have to get the purchase order and I sign it I don't I'm not the requester and the signat so it's something that we have to I have to work out with curriculum to determine why you know all these
057codes have not been used and I I guess a can I just say I guess it's a concern too because the teachers keep saying they don't have supplies or they don't have paper they need they need these things so if there's money there's money in here they should be able to do that and if there's an emergency there's always do I I sign off on all emergencies it goes to Dr Talbert to evaluate and if there's need for override we do override it but I think that teachers need like I know paper keeps coming up like that shouldn't be an emergency they should freely have that there's all this money there that shouldn't be an issue so let Megan has a few more questions that she just wants to finish up so go ahead Megan
058um it it's not a few more questions it was still on the supplies it just seem as though only a fraction of what was budgeted was tapped into uh it was the end of J November again and I'm just concerned that you know maybe the staff doesn't know the Avenues to to express their needs or somehow and they're not getting access to that that funding for their teaching supplies and hey just to I don't want to call out a specific building but there's one science um one that has over $23,000 available still and zero encumbered or expensed and that's just one of the many categories so I it just it jumped out of me so if we can just follow up I sure um I have I have one more thing I'm sorry under under
059Charter Schools we're negative almost $179,000 is there what are the plans for that yes um as of this morning it was we're down by 157,000 because you know families change their mind wait you paid off1 157,000 no we have encumbered to cover the cost for the remainder of the school year it's because of the incumbrance that you see the negative balance of 57,000 as of today but for the projection this is something that we we have to analyze and talk about during the budget process and see whether we have to budget for more POS more spots and then we have to project additional numbers last year we projected five apparently that wasn't enough so it's something that we'll talk about and adjust it better to project High than low yes but we also have to
060be cognizant of the fact that we are under the task cap so we can't go too high otherwise you know we will not be able to meet the C any any other questions any other questions on this all those in favor I motion carries 70 have a motion for agenda items 3 E1 and 3 E2 please second Chris naron is first Winnie canestro is second inlegal all the contracts have been remove reviewed correct all those in favor I motion carries 70 right we're up to old old business and then new business any I have one old business um just following up on what I brought up a few months ago maybe about the seating in the High School auditorium if that's been addressed yet yes that was addressed um the day after you brought it
061to our attention and it required a vendor to come out and give a quote and so in terms of a status update on the replacement that we probably should provide you with a closing date but it's underway it has been addressed and it's underway do you have a estimate of when like when there's we'll before the high school play and before the next round of concerts and assemblies and all that we will get back to you with the date thank you you're welcome anyone else for old bus um I have a couple of things um we still have not appointed an external auditor it's been brought up several times we need to do that okay I mean I don't should we go out for an RFP again because they probably expired I don't know have
062they can we ask them if they can refresh the quote the rfps so excuse me John so for the external orders um we were at a position when we went out for the rfps we got responses back and then with the understanding that they were going to be they were in the in the middle of working on our report and that um we would have them in place until June of so as to Wendy's question do we need to go back out for another set of rfps or can we just go back to the ones who submitted do we go back out again and say you have to review your policy okay all right but but maybe they could refresh them yeah yeah I'll take a look and provide the response okay so that's something
063I think we should do probably by the next meeting figure that out maybe Lisa get it on the calendar I'm I'm making note here um I've brought this up many times we need to do a midyear superintendent review that's our legal obligation we haven't done that if we could get that on the calendar I've been in communication with Dr talber um several times and she said that she was going to get something to me um by the end of this week to put it in in a transmittal so yes yes okay um syntax we said that we were going to review that I think we pay $94,000 a year I know with the um newsletter that's come home I've been disappointed in it there's been a lot of graphic art like clip art taking up
064big spaces that could be articles the font is very large it's just a lot of pictures there's not a lot of great content um I think that uh I know when we first appointed this there was like I don't know what you call it the Platinum level and then maybe like the silver level and the bronze level I would like the board to review this I think that we committed to reviewing this and perhaps um downgrade a little bit um on that if that's something that we could review as a board yeah I'm making I'm making not yes okay great awesome um me just see maybe in preparation of that see if there's any High School clubs that can supplement some of the services that we get from from them we can look into that
065and see we yeah I'm making it we can look and see so if we have some of that data while we're trying to figure out what level we continue with we can um uh I really do want to talk about kids I feel like we have to talk about kids in the academics I know we had a presentation where a lot of the kids were two to three grades behind and we were reviewing it we had the graphs and everything I'd like to know if we've had any updates with that Benchmark and what is it what what is being implemented to catch these kids up to speed I think that there was a gap um I think it was uh was it third grade right go third grade was a big year where there was
066a big um lull I'd like an update on academics really so we just recently administered the I ready assessment I think most schools are wrapping that up if not last week finishing makeups this week and and um Mary Stevens has been in touch with the administrators and their leadership teams around academic goals academic monitoring um progress monitoring as well are there any additional updates that you'd like to provide to the board at this time that covers the general scope of the work that we've been doing um we have been meeting regularly with reading interview interventionists and math interventionists to look at the supports that we're providing we are looking ahead next year looking at the tiers of support that we provide so that we're very clear on what AIS supports we're providing we're using our
067mtss plan to guide the work that we're doing um making sure that there's a clear understanding of what interventions happen in the classroom what interventions happen during AIS and what interventions happen with the Specialists um but I I know you're saying you're looking ahead to next year but we still have we still have a whole half a school year here as Dr tabbert mentioned we've been working with the principes on their goals uh we target professional development we have um Specialists come in and work with our teachers during faculty meetings to ensure that our goals are being met and that we're aligning it with the progress we're going to be examining the results of the I ready that was given this month to make sure that we've made the progress that we expected and if
068we didn't we're going to Target our goals so that or Target our intervention so that we're meeting our goals for this can you share that with the board those results being that we saw the results a couple of months ago so we could see if there's been progress or not so the board could monitor that thank you absolutely that's all just question um Mary um do we have enough remedial staff to support the needs of our remedial students because I know that you know we're picking up at a very low number so how large are the groups how many specialists what size of their groups so our groups uh when I meet with the reading teachers we speak regularly about the importance like I said of identifying what the interventionist rules are um we are
069looking ahead at making sure that everyone understands that for next year so right now there are larger groups in our secondary buildings we are examining whether we need to we're working with Miss boti in the Staffing and um and budgeting process to make sure that we have what we need it may mean shifting staff um but we are going to make sure that we are providing appropriate services and what um Mark are we picking up at it especially Northwest is six months below is it a year below where for the interventionists they're picking up for a year below just thank you in in addition if I may uh with the I ready program there is a a targeted intervention plan that is available on each student who completes the Benchmark and so the Educators do
070have a individual plan that is utilize to guide that instruction and to tear it differentiate it and also spiral it based upon the gaps the academic gaps that are discovered once the Benchmark is complete in addition we're doing a deep dive on our student intervention teams um with our special ed Department as well as with each individual school we are looking at the processes that we're using to bring struggling students who are struggling academically uh to the committee and that committee is providing strategies where educators are going back and for four to six weeks are a set duration of time implementing those strategies and then they're coming back and so what we're doing is looking at data more intently intentionally to ensure that we are putting programming in place to address those direct needs that
071are showing up in the various data sources that the different schools are using have a coup thank you um I guess in that realm a few meetings back we spoke about ruler and there was a survey to gain feedback um so is that also what's the status of that I yes ruler has been complete um we are analyzing the data we'll be sharing that of course with the board um just as a general rule of thumb it looks like um facets of ruler is working in some degrees on the lower levels and that we are looking at it more intently on the secondary level but we will be bringing that data um to have those conversations with our administrators uh staff as well as the board thank you um I guess uh shifting gears a
072little bit um there was mention of being prepared for upcoming budget um again a few meetings back we spoke about the cell phone policy so I guess I have a question for the policy committee if that's a policy that's been attempted yet um since it's a very huge issue to get ahead of what what do we think that we want to to implement so that we are budgeting uh for the implementation so um that is not a policy that we have looked at yet but that's the policy that we will be looking at so so yes we'll be able to look at it in enough time to if there's anything that we need to be part of the budgeting process we'll make sure that'll be done in in a timely fashion but I also think
073it also depends what's going to happen from from hok because if hok makes a certain ruling on the um self phone you know cell phone restrictions in the school is a number so we can put a policy in place to answer your question we can say that we're going to get I'm not saying that we're doing it but we can say that we're going to get pouches hypothetically but if there's a different ruing that comes down then we may have to look at something differently so yes it is a policy and you can correct me Dr T it is something that we do plan to take a look at go ahead yes at the last policy meeting we did have some preliminary discussions around it because it is a Hot Topic it is something that
074we know that our staff is dealing with and it's it's difficult to get control over it and so we were exploring uh different options um and it's going to require more discussion um I know we were looking at some pricing of some products just to kind of see what the market value is for certain items so that when we come back to the policy committee we'll have some exploratory thoughts we can at least present for further discussion and if I recall correctly and then Chris and Wendy can correct me there was also the discussion on the fact that if it's something that we're going to do it wouldn't be into the fall because it did require communication that would have to occur you know throughout the district and you know there's so there was a
075lot of discussion we did mention that the middle school was actually we're going to do the cell phone um and that we option and then the board that point in time i' said you know to pull back on it so um so we you said you were going to no so no the Middle School in please I think they had a they had funding for it yeah go ahead yeah um we we did purchase it and we had to return it and they give us back the money yeah this year we had so years it was like two years here um I think John's waiting to say something over there right uh yeah so there governor has uh unveiled the plan to restrict smartphone use in schools and um it is a part of the
076it's going to be part it's proposed as part of the budget proposal yes it's SP budet million yes so G give School District money yeah that's I was gonna say are they giving us any money for that I don't know what she's doing $ 13 million with that yeah so the budget allocates 13.5 million for pouches Cubbies and other storage devices great well so the the the big question is are we going to how much of that money we're going to get I that's not in the article I think it's going to be part of her budget and I think her plan is to come to pass this down so that schools could be prepared for September but she also had said oh she's going to come up with a plan but you know each
077individual school could figure out you know each district so she's putting pushing a little bit back on us too here you have to do this but now you figure out how to do it it's an unfunded M there are mandates attached yes go ahead Megan is it Megan I just want to jump in and sorry if this doesn't seem official enough but I heard that all St Anthony's does they hang a shoe rack over the door with like the clear plastic each kid puts their phone in the shoe rack that's how the teacher takes attendance if they don't see your phone in your assigned shoe rack slot you are not officially in class because we know if your phone's in your lap you're not in class doesn't seem very expensive um I I I read
078the same article that governor hok's coming out and this might be a project months in the making I don't see what's stopping us from trying simple things now especially while we know that kids are not learning now because there's no policy I would say the likelihood that somebody walks in with one cell phone and walks out with two cell phones even if they're not planning on keeping it just to mess with with somebody else right and I so we did talk about that in the policy committee and that was one of the concerns that that we we did talk about that yeah there the security sorry I wasn't there it just seems simple and it it is in effect in another school it wasn't just an idea that an adult had who doesn't have any
079connection like they're actually doing it so yeah we talked about it that's all yeah we did we did talk about it and um because it was something that I know you had brought up so we did speak about it and I think our biggest concern which you know Chris just brought out was the security of the phones in the pouches and that means it now would go to the teachers and now the teachers will have to be responsible for making sure that the right kid took the right cell phone so and so and even even if we tried to implement it this year then it was just also the communication to the parents the roll out so we didn't want to so we did talk about it so we we it's part of our discussion
080with the policy commit yeah we recognize we it we're just trying to figure out how to get there and make sure that all the stakeholders that are involved in the possible implementation also have a um a say in this do anything else John you want to answer that no okay so go ahead Megan um okay I there's um in our Friday memo there was reference to Locker repairs again at the middle school and I say again because I think at the beginning of the year there was a number number of locker repairs in the Middle School um but then at the same time I understand the kids were told they can't carry bags so I just wanted to clarify if their lockers are broken are they still being told not to carry bags or what's
081the approach what's happening over there so at the middle school at the beginning of the year they did Implement um a policy a procedure where you could not travel with your book bag or your jacket or head gear um the policy the procedure was not enforced equitably across the school in all spaces and places and they needed to reign in the procedure and so they held an assembly uh with the student body prior to the um December break to reiterate the expectations so in terms of um certain paraphernalia that can be carried in bags certain items that can be carried in bags and in jackets the school wanted to address that and so the lockers each student is assigned a locker um with a Locker number and those lockers that are not working uh students
082have been assigned or could be reassigned the locker if there's been a gap in it somewhere now in terms of recalibrating the lockers and repairing the lockers our building and grounds has um looked at those and is securing uh a quote to see what that would look like okay thank you thank no I think you got all of it okay um the draft budget uh when can the Board of Education expect to see the draft budget are we up to new business or oh that's new business I I have another old business if before we move on oh sorry that's okay I'm sorry you call that new business um the building and grounds i u we discussed um adding a tab on the website to be able to facilitate the communication of the buildings and
083grounds updates so a tab has been added oh okay the tab is there there's a description of the under departments okay um you go to building and grounds you can access the facility's use form as well as some other information so it's it's under construction okay more information will be added okay but the tab has been there for I'm sorry quite a little time right now okay with the information on the do project and the middle school project make it there no that information has not to my knowledge yeah he just he just included that in his board update that um someone from the Department of Transportation will be at the next health and safety committee meeting to talk about the cvit project right okay I guess I just figured might be helpful for the
084community to be able to learn something about the project I understand you can't put everything there about school plans you can't but he does have intentions okay it's on his list to add more information about that the Middle School Capital project um and he's working with our technology department and with syntax to get it up all right thank you very much I'm sorry the regionalization plan I I did read the strengths and weaknesses tool um what was that tool submitted was there a date that it needed to be submitted yes it had to be submitted by January 13th 15th January 15 so and with submitting that are we def like we're definitely part of the regionalization plan or there was an option to opt out can you clarify that thank you har you want to
085elaborate on the latest regarding the regionalization there was an uh a date which was January 15th if we wanted to opt out of participating in the tools in the assessment tool that was there um and now it goes to to bosis for the next stage for them to provide feedback for us about the services and the ways that we can work together so there's no obligation to participate in anything that's recommended as a result of any of the stages do you have a timeline of when boses anticipates I'm not sure about that date but I know they are just receiving those reports now so they have to go through them and then work on the next stage can check and see if they have a d okay so I guess like as far so the
086district has to budget as though there's not going to be any sort of benefit from the regionalization or we just have to assume we're not going to participate when we're looking at our budget for next year unknown because it's unknown we don't know what the recommendations would be and we don't know if we would accept them okay can I can I ask something on the regionalization if I may in in reviewing it like the vision and everything I noticed a lot of it was focused on operations and finances and I didn't see a lot of focus on the academics is there a reason for that so the domains were broken into four parts and so we were required to answer certain parts based upon uh that area and so there was an area for academics
087so there was an equitable response but we had to respond based upon the parameters so one was social and emotional one was academic what were the others capacity was the third one which was mostly the the operations okay thank you thank you new business I don't know if this is are you old business I don't know if it's New or Old goad um the warrior logo removal that's old it's old right right oh okay that's what I thought um has there been any re-evaluation of the cost or what is going to be replaced or removed or like redressed like I know the logo that's on the bleachers at the high school is just painted on I don't know if that could get sand blasted off or and then things that we know we're going to
088have to get rid of can any of that like be donated to the community I don't know if that's a legal thing since the logo is not okay like I know there like just say on the side of the bleachers when they roll out there's a big canvas banner I don't know if somebody would want that at in their garage or something like an alumni or things like that yeah well I don't that might be risky um we may be may be required to auction it first I think legal is sitting here scratching his his he's trying to so you have disposal of obsolete properties policy right uh my opinion this would likely fall into that category and that policy would dictate how you dispose of that property and determination of whether it has any
089market value at all and even if it doesn't even if we can't auction it off and profit from it we would I would think at least save disposal fees we we'll check it like like that giant boulder that's at the high school track well they're not going to get rid of that or just flip it over no it's yeah yeah yeah so we have to flip it over so that's on the bottom of it but you know just I don't want to see a report that we're spending however many hundreds of dollars to get rid yeah $8,000 to get rid of a rock that we could just roll over or that somebody wants in their front of their house I no any other comments for old business new business then well guess so the question
090is that we have to follow up did we re-evaluate any of that or is there any plans to like get a actual cost on how that much this is going to be no um we've been I've been discussing it with Al Galina and hence the money in the code we have to look re look at it and see what we can do what we can do s blast it whatever we can do he's looking added critically to come up with new plans and we'll talk about it CU I think that number would was decided before he was on board correct correct and he does have some preliminary Rec recommendations in terms of some of his observations and walk through yes um so we need to collate that compile it and take a closer look at
091it I'm waiting for new business yeah new business anyone Leslie new business Caroline new business yeah um three things I think they're quick uh one minor I Tech uh didn't text I emailed you uh Dr Talbert and Lisa and Lynn yesterday about this the text notifications that go out for meeting notices um a parent had texted me wondering is there a public session because it wasn't clear to her based on the text that there wasn't but you did post on the district website the letter that explains it with total Clarity so is it possible to have that linked to the text notifications because everyone checks their texts it that added info would be helpful to a lot of people I know what an extra step we all ask AP is it possible no I wouldn't
092put you on the spot no really they're GNA look into I didn't expect you to answer I didn't put you on the spot but we'll follow up on your concern okay I tried sorry um the other one we were talking about this uh briefly but I just want to put on the record as far as the need to create um a policy for all of our different social media accounts because we have the two official accounts but anyone going through Instagram or whatever wouldn't know what's official and what's not so um for the sake of allowing Free Speech but covering the district's interest in case someone speaks too freely under what seems to be a district site or account that would be something I would hope the policy committee up we started speaking about that
093yeah and and actually I was really surprised to learn when I asked how many social official social media sites are Dr Talbert said too I mean I was surprised there's a lot out there so we are reviewing that discussing how to implement that and I believe communication is already out there as part of the Brad rization policy but because I know there's um like clubs or teams that might communicate with the students through the social media so that we they should start weaning that off before it becomes an actual policy yeah it was dis it was discussed yes okay thank you and then my last question um you know we got our transmitt and we got the packet and obviously there's a lot of um repairs that need happening around the district emergency repairs transfers
094that have to happen because of that so I was concerned when I heard about the rooftop unit that broke down on December 3rd were they able to order the part immediately or did they have to wait to order because now we're paying a lot of money potentially for backup heating so we were first notified of that on December the 3 and I believe uh Olivia they came out two days thereafter um it was moving really quickly and then when they realized it was on back order for two weeks that took us through the Break um those items are actually under discussion yes because the um financial obligation is uh quite expensive for the parts or for the emergency heat for them by the emergency heat by the emergency heat that's why I'm seeking reassurance that
095we ordered the part as soon as we knew we needed it oh yes yes oh of course there were no delays delay that like because we needed to make a budget transfer we had to wait several weeks to order aart meanwhile no okay actually I asked whether you know to play The Devil's Advocate I asked the same question I said did the Contra to speak more to the mic did the contractor reach out to other contractor to see whether he can get the part and they did all that they how expensive would it be to drive where this part exists if it's already been manufactured it's you know some of these parts come from you know yeah far away so it's it's it's very difficult to lay hands on it and most of most of
096these contractor do not carry those parts on their shelves and actually the contractor contacted a lot of local businesses and they actually drove to several places trying to expedite because they understood the frigid weather and our intent to get this done quickly so they really kind of went beyond the Call of Duty um Mr galin worked really closely with them but the part just could not found okay thank you CH question yes go ahead is the so do we have heat at the high school gym right now or we don't because of the so the the signal you know our our our building management systems are old and the they are not sending accurate signals all the time to the blowers that you need to blow the Heat and so because we've not had necessarily
097a great maintenance plan due to financial challenges we're dealing with some equipment that is aged and so while there is heat blowing it's not sufficient enough to raise the temperature to a degree where we would want the student scholars in the gym what about athletic events or public use that's currently going on right so this week we did not have that issue because of the regions we made sure that no students would be utilizing the gym and they weren't so our issue is next week and so we've been in discussion with Mr Galina and um Mr Cardone and Mr farus farcus about next week and I don't know exactly where we are with that there's no like basketball games or volleyball or anything that was scheduled not this week based on yeah regions but the
098like after school sports I mean based upon our discussions no and what about gym for the children for to meet the FED requirements there's no gym week because next week but we're next week is our is our is our issue do we have a plan for that it's not defined yeah we're hoping that by then we'll get the part in to fix it but if we don't have it because we brought in when we requested for the temporary heat because of the cost we have to reduce it from 3 to one just to keep the pipes from fre being from freezing so um we have to re-evaluate it on an ongoing basis and I'm going to tou base we're going to touch base with Mr Galina to press on the contractor to see whether they
099got the part and if they got get the part they have to fix that immediately can Mr Galina be here for the next meeting so like we have so many questions about this it would be helpful if he was here to answer a lot of these questions I I did speak with him they could not be here tonight and so yes uh February the 12th and I know Miss Stevens has been working with some programming as well I just wanted to give you an update on the instruction plan so Mr farcus and I have been speaking speak a little B more time sorry Mr and I have been speaking about um what instruction would look like if the gym were not available so we've been looking at alternate spaces that we can use lessons on
100health and wellness that can supplement and ways that we can get movement in in smaller spaces so there there is a a plan B for instruction if the gym is not available next we all right if you guys could just keep us updated um I think Chris was trying to I think Chris is trying to keep going yes I believe there's a public use of facilities for this Saturday at the high school gym have they been notified and asked to relocate to maybe the middle school I'm not sure if they have but I know that we did discuss facility use so I'm sure it's on the uh discussion agenda to for next steps okay because I yeah then they'll have to notify all the participants so just so hold on a second do any anything
101else from you Chris that you have uh I don't think so okay so I'm just going this way um Carol anything NOP I'm good Wendy anything um yeah I just have a couple of things um a a math building level leader for the high school we we don't have one are we getting one what what is the status of that Dr wait that posting did go out today and we have an applicant okay great um I was going to ask about the heating you address that um the only other thing that I wanted to bring up is this Equalization letter that everybody got from the tan of Babylon I had asked if there's anything because our Amityville um those that reside in Amityville and the Amityville School District are going to be hit with an
102increase and obviously all of us I think I could speak for all of us that were really concerned um and I don't think anybody's happy about that um but we were told there's not anything that we could do to Advocate it's out of our hands I don't know John did you want to speak so I think I think Dr Talbert in her superintendent report address that yeah so in her so in your report you can address okay so I'll just I'll just finish the the only thing that I would say is you know um having empathy with the community like we have to really do our best to sharpen our pencils um not to overburden our taxpayers um and I oh and just about the budget when when will we receiving the draft budget we
103you know I know that I want to be able to ask meaningful and thoughtful questions and be prepared our first budget meeting is February 12th I would hope that we could get it uh minimum TW two weeks before is that going to happen well yes we are currently uh reviewing draft one um okay so I just want no I think February 12th it says on the calendar I think the I think the 1 is the Saturday yeah the Saturday we could do you know when we went we had to go to New School Board training when you're a new school board member um and other districts had spoken about they had seen draft budgets in October so I just want to make sure that we are fully prepared as a board of education that we're
104not just getting it on the spot because I think that um some trustees had said that last last year that they were seeing at the same time I don't want to be in a position where I'm seeing it at the same time I want to be able to listen ask the questions I think all of us to be prepared so um can we have assurances that that we'll get that in advance can I can I just ask a question just for clarification so the first budget presentation I know was on February 12th yes so the question that I have sometimes that first presentation is just sort of general information is maybe if you can just kind of let the board education know maybe what will be the the sequence of the Pres presentations because if
105the first presentation does not contain any really budget items if that makes any that's what that's hear what you're saying well I think that we we do see the the presentations before they go out right with Dr No what I'm saying is that is the first well the first presentation have questions be like sort of like general information about how the budget is going to go like what are the steps and will the second one actually have numbers and I think that's my question March 1 you mean is the next one after but I still think that we need it in I I I we should be having it actually at this point so I would like to make sure that happens no I I do agree I'm not disagreeing but my question is that
106what will that first will that first presentation have numbers for us then I think that's my question because I if I recall correctly in the past that first Pres presentation didn't have sort of like general information about the budget process that that's my question just kind of put the yeah go go go close to the mic yeah um the first presentation will have highlights which includes of course the Highlight would include some numbers so like um Miss Stevens talked about you know we're still trying to F tune some numbers we are working on it we going to meet as a group to talk about no I understand it's it's a work in progress It's fluid and and I think having a draft budget is just that we understand it may change and we might be
107able to save some dollars here and there and the last thing when it comes to the budget presentation I had asked that we share what the proposed tax levy is knowing that it may change which it is Ever Changing as we saw last year too is that that we're just transparent and we you know keep the community AB breast every step of the way hopefully it goes down along the way and and obviously to reinforce it's it's draft and I know you're going to do that I'm sorry anyone else new business or old business new new business okay I I have a question I don't know if this is just um it's one of the executive orders that was just signed by the president referring to citizenship and how that could greatly impact a school
108district like ours and if there's anything that the district is looking into to see how this could interrupt students learning and impact them in different ways yes the state released a document for all schools to follow centered around safe schooling for immigrant students and that document has been disseminated from my office to our director of pupil Personnel who has disseminated it to our building Administration and we'll be following up because there are some specific rights that students have and we want to make sure that all of the staff are aware to um support follow and just um assist our students in feeling as secure as possible right and I I don't think we because I don't we don't ask their citizenship so it's not we don't really have a way to know which ones we
109have to focus on to help right it's just right am I right that like we don't know who's right there's certain information they do not have to disclose and um we do not pry but any student who is you know seeking any assistance we make ourselves available yeah is there is there any way to publicize that to kind of help them the students feel comfortable without without trying to like you know call them out in any way so the building administrators have the tool and we have a forthcoming meeting where we're going to talk through it and take a deeper dive through the document but they're all reviewing it and uh Miss Lopez is in communication with them around some strategies as well okay thank you anything under anything else under the new business Dr
110talber anything superintendent of schools okay so our superintendent's report um good evening everyone once again and AP is going to assist us because we wanted to just kind of put a few things on the big screen to um kind of paint a picture to some of the wonderful things that falcony staff and students are doing throughout the district so just a few January highlights so uh the Board of Education um really prompted this community Forum through a discussion that took place here in the boardroom and so we hosted it on January 14th had a great attendance from the community a very respectful environment great Solutions were shared um based on the feedback we received there was a special emphasis to keep the school open um to relocate kindergarten to Northeast and to avoid posing any
111hardships on families who are in need of Early Childhood Services uh there was a consistent pattern of recognition of the historical significance and commitment to Quality education that has been presented it through the doors of Northeast and yesterday thank you letters and picture collages were sent to all of the attendees who completed the feedback sheet and we had their email addresses so we're building an email Network for um open communication moving forward here are a few of the pictures Senator Martinez sent the young man in the middle out to represent um her office uh Board of Education we've received an init ation For an upcoming meeting with our new assembly member to talk about um Northeast and where we stand as a district and so these are residents who are working in small group um
112sessions to provide feedback our Board of Education was present and they too were working at a table so thank you for participating in the Forum as you know just recently we did a mascot survey and we wanted to provide you with an update so Trends and patterns that were observed from the survey responses we're going to share those with you on a graph momentarily but our next step is that we're going to vote on the top responses by the school and Community we have an upcoming Forum already scheduled on February 2nd where we meet with the community at 11:00 a.m. and again at 6:00 p.m. for any topic that you like to talk about and we're going to focus that particular meeting and Forum on providing the community with an update on the top responses
113so from the survey okay so this is the flyer that shows our next meeting it says February 3rd so I stand corrected February 3rd it's a Monday is the third of Monday yes okay thank you now this may not be the e easiest to read um but this is what we were able to provide for you quickly this evening and we're going to work on a more legible graph but what are your top three suggestions for the new District name which is the survey question that was posed and if you start on the left side it says tide and there were 51 responses um who responded that they like the name tied the most the next name does that say Warriors at 32 people Crimson Tide was 31 Eagles was 18 sharks and lions were
11414 Red Hawks nine I can't see that one okay so I wanted to take you to the the four of them had seven votes and that would sort of be considered our top 10 that we would be looking to share at The Forum and have more discussion around this feedback okay and so then we also asked what are your top three suggestions for the new mascot so name mascot mascot Eagle 39 people lion 32 wave 26 shark 24 tide 17 wolf 16 tiger 16 Knight 12 11 Falcon and seagull 10 is that say seagull okay yeah seagull and so uh that's where we are with our mascot update so please join us on February 3rd which is a Monday 11:00 a.m. and 6: p.m. and we normally meet at Park north and if we have
115to change our location we'll be more than willing to do that um also we want to touch base with you regarding the tax Equalization rate which has been brought up of course by our concerned board members around the increase of $3 million for our Amityville residents we had a meeting with our town supervisor Rich schaer other governmental officials and also parties from the Farmingdale school district and we reiterated and expressed Our concern that our Babylon re residents are now going to be footing a heavier tax bill than those living in Nassau County so the Farmingdale and amville school districts are split between suffk and Nassau counties meaning that our tax levies are divided based on the respective share of the total fair market value in each School District so this year when Nassau County's Equalization
116rate was left Frozen while babylon's rate was reduced which artificially we say in inflated Babylon share of the fair market value so the Town of Babylon um has actually uh reached out to us for additional information they've had a consultation with our legal and they are pursuing this through litigation uh there have been times in the past when the uh Olivia the uh tax alization rate in Nassau County was frozen for a very long time and the impact of that yes it's been frozen for a while now because um once the assessment is frozen it impacts the fair market value of all the properties in the Nassau County section of the district and hence the equalization rate stays stable whil Babylon like Dr taba said goes down it goes down it then they have to
117shoulder a heavier B burden of the taxes and that's what is happening now because nasau county has frozen their assessment for some time now so amid properties in Nassau County have seen their tax burden decrease and it's placing an unfair share on Town of Babylon homeowners um I didn't know if John wanted to weigh in on any of this um any preliminary conversations that you want to no this that's only by between councils so okay I leave that the town of Balon but that that slide is accurate my understanding is they're contemplating legal action yes with respect to uh the school districts do not have standing to bring legal action yes with regard to Equalization rates absolutely so um yes we do not but we are certainly cooperating with whatever the town would need from
118us if they are pursuing the litigation which is their desire so all of our schools have been working very hard on improving culture and climate which is one of our districtwide goals and we wanted to just take a moment to um just give an extra Applause to amville Memorial High School and Rec ognition of their Data Tracking and H how it has resulted in some significant improvements so the administrative team the teachers the staff they have been brainstorming and coming up with Creative Solutions to engage Learners and when you talk with the students they're enthused they're looking forward to what's going to happen next um they're happy at school and we've seen a marked reduction in incidents in the building so kudos to our student Scholars and our staff for their dedication and effort and
119that's not to say that our other schools are not making Improvement it's just that the high school has really stood out and their reduced incidents are visible um and they've been really getting the word out about um engaging the students in a lively Rich learning experience so thank you to all of our Administration and staff who are working so hard and thank you to our high school for moving the needle in a remarkable way it's always a pleasure to visit the classrooms that we've been observing some excellent instructional lessons across the district uh we just want to take a moment to celebrate our great staff their creativity dedication and the innovation of staff and our student Scholars every classro that we visited we saw Bright Eyes we saw engaged students we saw enthusiastic teachers and
120we just wanted to take a moment to display what's a little snapshot of what we were able to capture in some of our walkthroughs and our reading in Spanish classes the teacher third picture is Dr mcglenn Who was awarded tenure tonight and we enjoyed our observation in her class the students are really utilizing their digital technology in the classrooms and our Spanish teacher was uh I learned a little something during my visit kudos to Mr Abate and the Jazz Band for their outstanding performance at the Dr Martin Luther King Jr day service at bethl am Church they have been performing for years and last year the Miss Bianca Pate came and brought the orchestra and so um they received a generous donation to The Music Department he wanted uh them to take the students out
121and get them something good to eat so special thanks to Pastor Keith Hayward and the congregation uh we are pleased to announc that Samir Shaw one of our 10th grade students is a chist was selected to represent amville in one of the Long Island stream Festival secondary honor orchestras very proud of Samir and so here are a few pictures of our jazz band that's Mr Bate receiving the donation to the music department and as you see our students I mean uh Pastor Hayward said that's the best he's ever heard the jazz band he would just kept applauding how well they were and kudos to our building and grounds Department because they were able to get our mu musical instruments out the buses were able to come in the sidewalks and the parking lots were paved
122um another school district was invited and they weren't able to make it but Amityville was able to make it because of our great building and grounds and outstanding staff and the parents who shook the kids and said get up you've got something to do so thank you the budget development process we want to say that our financial Outlook has improved significantly compared to last year we are not where we want to be but we are making progress in the right direction governor hokel and we know this is the governor's budget proposal and it will change when it becomes the legislative proposal perhaps but it shows a total change in our state aid at 1.5% what does that mean right now that we will be getting approximately $595,000 more for the 2526 school year that's not
123enough by any means but we're grateful for the increase we were hoping that we would have seen more than that um our budget presentations will begin in February and we'll be providing more detailed updates um as we move forward and we are working diligently to get the draft budget uh to the Board of Education we're analyzing more programming Based on data that we're getting from various benchmarks and we just want to make sure that we are plugging those holes uh particularly in the early grades and that our class sizes will be uh as best as we can make them so thank you to all of you and to our board of education for your continued support and collaboration we strive to provide the best for our students and our community and so that concludes the
124superintendent report thank you thank you Dr talber um okay any Community input regarding non-board agenda items just come to the mic just state your name good evening good evening my name is Jessica Adams I live um 3438 WR in Amityville Jessica Adams yes okay I'm just repeating the name for the district okay jessam hold on one second for me because he just needs to do the time hold on one second Miss Adams I think her picture was up there it was thank you for joining thank you okay go ahead so again Jessica Adams I live at 3438 great NE Road in Amityville I have two young sons who graduated who are a product of Amityville I have my high school student who again is going to be a product of Amityville I also have two
125young twins at Northeast Elementary School which is where my dilemma is um I am aware that you do do not transport out of the district however there is an exception that the board can make um my children go to Northeast their daycare is on 45th in Copeg it's a mile away from the school and there's no Transportation I have to have them get dropped off in the morning and I have to leave work at 2:00 in the afternoon to pick them up from the school to take them four minutes away to their daycare so I'm asking if there's a solution that we can come up with any help any advice anything from the board to help me in this situation I also have a two-year-old who will be also coming into the northeast school that
126is also going to need Transportation so is there anything that can be done regarding this so thank you so much for your question what I'm going to have to do is the information that Dr talit has taking the the the notes and that she will get back to you on this particular matter and can I have a time frame of that um Dr T will you'll be able to give a time frame so thank you Miss Adams we are aware of your request um she has spoken to a number of people in the district to try to get a solution um so we are going to uh Circle back through all of that as well as the regulations so if you can give us until uh Monday at the latest okay give us until Monday
127to be able to get you a confirmed response per all right thank you very much thank you for your time any other community input on non-agenda items hello my name is Monique Cox um I have a student at parav here at the middle school and also at the high school um my reasoning for being here today is actually regarding the high school um my daughter is a varsity cheerleader and as most of you know they have the opportunity to participate in Nationals um February 5th in Disney World um it is disheartening to me to know that some of these girls or some of these Scholars have been cheering since middle school and to know that they have worked so hard to place and be able to go and participate in Nationals and not have the
128backing of the district um these Scholars have worked hard they have worked tiously to perfect their crafts and to not have the backing of Amityville is disheartening to know as a parent and it's disheartening to know to the athletes that they don't have that support um from their District so I wanted to know if that's something that could be reconsidered because they have worked extremely hard to get to where they're going um thank you so much for your your comment and it's something that if the board is able to this evening to reconsider look at it we we can possibly do that but I'm not too sure we'll be able to you know support the the team as we would like but we will I we can talk about it afterwards thank you hi uh
129good evening Dell cron in 32 more place just a quick question in reference to the equalization rate when does the district receive that do you what's the process do you receive the equalization rate and when do you get that so can you just do me a favor that little lamp thing you just thank you Miss bti yes we receive it around August and we use it um we get it from the office of rear property taxes in ALB so the district has had that information in reference to the town of babylon's the situation with the Town of Babylon we've had that we've know you the district has known the equalization rate since August yes and we don't have any control over no I understand that I was just wondering when that information received and also
130I have a second request Dr chel butt I had emailed you on DEC December 11th in reference to an appeal and I have not heard back from you yet I was just wondering if my email was received I don't recall seeing your email I know I I received an email from you prior to that right and I had email after um a meeting um with the district and I emailed it on December 11th and I haven't heard back from you would you please check your emails I sure will I'll take my spam thank you okay and congratulations and please enjoy your retirement I'm sorry any other community input on non agend items um question to the board does do we want to go back in huh oh go ahead good evening so I am Reverend
131saber chunzi and I'm the president of the central Long Island NAACP and I want to just acknowledge first of all that I was at the The Forum uh that Dr talit referenced and I know as she said also that uh many of the school board members were there so I just want to emphasize and reiterate what I hope you saw which is that the community is really really really in favor of saving the northeast school so whatever has to be done and we know there's a lot to be done whatever has to be done we are just hoping and knowing that the district will do whatever that is that's my first point to preserve that school my my other point has to do with the mentoring program that was uh presented by the uh 100
132black women organization and from what I understand it was sent to there was insurance issue and it was sent to the uh the attorneys of the district District so i' just like to get an update in terms of what is the status of that mentoring program that's my question uh good evening Reverend Saban and thank you for attending the Forum and for your question this evening the um 100 black women there was a concern regarding insurance around sexual abuse and molestation and so the memorandum of agreement was crafted to require that insurance and um the organization went back to their insurance carrier and discovered that that insurance was expensive around $5,000 and they've been working with Miss buatti um in terms of submitting quotes um before they buy the insurance to see if any of
133that would filter through an approval and so can you update us where you are with that yes um we they sent us the policy we've been working with them to because when we receive the insurance policy we have to send it to our insurance company to validate that a compli with the terms of the memorandum of agreement and what they discovered was that um they require us to have what is called an AM best insurance product to support the Pol to support the program what they said was that the policy was a second tier policy and therefore our insurance company could not approve it that's that's where we left it so what what's needed to be done at this point to move it along they have to go and get an AM best policy which
134will be very very expensive so my question is does every other outside organization that deals with District children have to have that same exact policy that you're referencing to the best of my knowledge yes and the cost of that policy Dr talber you mentioned $5,000 is that the amount or is it more than that well I did not see the quotation that they receive but my understanding was that it's very expensive to price out that policy and our insurance company was insisting on getting something which is that quality okay but you didn't answer my question yeah my question was and if you have other organizations that deal with District children on various different programs and they have the same exact policy that you say that this organization needs then you should have an idea as
135to approximately how much that would be is it $55,000 is it $10,000 I ,000 the doesn't that the reason I said $5,000 was because when we initially started hearing from their insurance companies that was the quote that they first presented to us so I don't know if that fluctuated or went down or where they landed when they were working with the business office to see what the approvals would be are there other organizations in our district who have to adhere to that prior to that particular MOA not to my knowledge but since that information has been Incorporated in our standard Mo MOA provided by our legal moving forward I don't so we don't procure that insurance so we don't have we don't receive the quotes for that insurance it's up to the contractor to go
136and receive quotes for that insurance uh our risk uh our risk management uh company arm of our insurance carrier they provide the recommendations with respect to required insurance that that becomes part of the contract and the expectation is that the vendor procures that insurance before they begin their service so we don't we don't quote that we don't receive quotes for that I understand so so now my question though and and I'm even though I asked it already but it's not clear are other organization outside organizations that deal with students in this school district are they required to have the same exact level of insurance that was referenced right or is this something new so I think that's I think there's a question that you posed to Dr talber and maybe she can get back to
137you on on that particular answer but also the your your time ran out and I let you go a little bit longer so I think it's a question that that she has received and if she's able to provide that information for you then she'll get that information back to you okay okay and and just finally we want to be clear that this organization is being treated the same as previous organization as opposed to oh by the way now we just found out that you guys need such and such an uh Insurance level of insurance whereas previously other organizations have not been required to have this level of insurance I just want to put that out there that's the issue that's part of the issue that's part of the question and Dr talber I will be
138in contact with you so you can um fill me in and update me on my questions and concerns thank you thank you any other comments on non-agent items right so um Mr Sheen just for the question came up about the the cheer leader right and so um the conversation just for clarification if we need to do it in public or we need to do it in in executive session so the question is that there was um the possibility for money to potentially be utilized for them to go on to be to go towards the trip but the board was did not have a meeting to have a discussion on that particular item so the discussion does that need to occur in in in a public session or can we start the discussion and then so
139whether you're you're going to be funding whether or not we're going to provide any funding activity yes that that is a public discussion by the board right so we're going to have that discussion now in terms of and Dr Tabet please just kind of clarify for me because if I understand correctly there there was a question of the possibility of having funding that there was money that was available in the athletic department that could provide some funding towards this particular um for the cheerleading competition and that we as a board just needed to have that discussion I just want to make sure that and what was that amount just to clarify everyone's mind on the amount and where that money would be coming from so sure so in our discussion with the atic director around
140the cheerleaders um qualifying for Nationals and congratulations they have been working very hard uh there was a request for $115,000 to offset the cost uh the cheerleaders have raised Mary Stevens a little over $9,000 or I don't know if that amount has increased since we last met but it was a little over $99,000 and there was money set aside on a budget line for travel Athletics in the athletic budget and the request was to help offset the cost of going to invitationals the Invitational Nationals in Florida uh by contributing $115,000 so the Board of Education would have to decide if understanding correctly if we will be willing to utilize that $115,000 um for the cheerleading competition correct that that was the request to utilize the money from that line item but I think also to
141if I understand correctly it I don't think is a decision it's something that the superintendent could could do but on the same token she was making us aware of the fact that it would need to come from that account so I just we need clarification well so your your your policy with respect to uh field trips and activities uh provides for travel for the district to um it provides for the superintendent's authority to authorize travel expenditures uh for athletic competitions so this is not a u competition uh with in the section uh athletic section but it is authorized by it so if it was just travel uh that would be something within the superintendent's authority to authorize the travel however the expenditures associated with this event are not limited to travel they are travel accommodations
142meals Park tickets so the overall expenditures for this event ceed the superintendent's authority to authorize travel with respect to this event if if it is covered within uh the scope of your Athletics budget in my opinion that the entire amount would be covered by your Athletics budget so the idea of the district donating $15,000 uh you can't donate to something that is uh a club activity if it's within the scope of your budget then it's a district charge uh you can always accept donations by Third parties to offset the over the overall cost uh you could require uh students to uh expend money for the non-educational portion of that trip so for example if there are Park tickets right that's something that's outside the scope of the athletic event the that could be a charge
143for the students or they could they could U fund raise to offset that charge uh but that is based upon the amount of money uh that cost of this chip uh that the park tickets were only a small portion of it so so we in terms of um like transportation to get there the money could be utilized for the transportation and to get there to that particular event it could be utilized for um registration for for the event as well and yeah so the the transportation could be funded by the district the registration for the event is our district charge uh the issue is uh the accommodations which I understand are a large portion of uh that overall charge may may I add something um not yet because I just have another question do we
144know um the approximate cost of of once again REM the cost of the the transportation the approximate cost yes Miss Steven Stevens can give us some additional details around the itemized budget so the flights uh were a total of 7,300 and then there is um some ground transportation that's approximately 7 $150 um to get to and from the hotel the ground transportation to the airport um so at at this morning meeting Mr park has indicated families were getting students to the airport here in New York and the registration course is was uh registration is not broken down just by registration um so it's a total of I believe approximately $24,000 28,000 24 um but it does include components um that are not just registrations so 24,000 so registration includes lodging and some other right expenditures
145so you can't just pay the registration fee it encompasses a package and that that amount is roughly about $224,000 that that whole package I believe I have that correct okay um I would like to add something so hold on one second because I'm not I'm not so well I think it's important to this conversation I know but I'm just trying toig finalize my my numbers first and then I'll I'll let you you know come in so right now so the flights and ground together right now that amount would be like $8,000 $250 32,50 no what I'm saying right now the flights and ground is 8,50 cor right and then the registration large and everything else is extra but that's something that the district cannot really contribute to because it's all embedded we it's like we
146can't pull out and just pay for the registration that's what I'm just trying to clarify because it's all embedded together correct but can we clarify that the park tickets are are not part of that I think the park tickets were separate uh the package the registration package includes lodging Park fees meal vouchers and Grand ground transportation from the hotel to the okay um Evan estimated the expense of Park tickets to be 7,2 $62 okay so now now I can take other questions so go ahead um first congratulations to the team I think everybody's very proud of the children and there's no doubt that you worked very hard um as school districts you know we have to really monitor the money and we are in a very um fiscal fragile state right now especially with the
147equalization um this um had had come up and so I had looked into this as some may know or may not know I've served in other districts and um I have spoken to the president of Section 8 for High School athletics that's he's in charge of all the school districts in nasso county for Section 8 um nasau County doesn't have any school districts that pay for this what they we're section 11 I'm going to get to that one second so nasso County doesn't have any school districts that pay for what they do pay for is the registration which he said is about $1,500 and some pay for the transportation to the hotel from in Florida some do some don't almost all the districts do pay for the registration um suff County was pulled in section
14811 um and he said at that time about half had responded that the same exact thing they don't pay for anything other than the registration and some perhaps pay for ground transportation um it he also explained to me that the the VAR City Nationals is a little bit different because when when teams go up to the states or they have to travel you know whether it's soccer or basketball or baseball there's three to four divisions in each sport So Long Island might have three to four teams go up to the States and it's sanctioned so these are sanctioned by the section it's sanctioned by the state it the ntional cheerleading is not sanctioned and the president of Section 8 told me and it is not approved or um recognized by any sections that it just
149is there's no affiliation to the Section 8 and section 11 so there's no affiliation so having said that it's not to diminish the hard work that's happened but um it's a little bit different than the section and state sanctioned Sports having said that um so when there's in the budget for hotel or accommodations or anything that's um I think that we've had a great record of sending um our our kids winning I think it was in soccer and perhaps basketball if I'm not mistaken to go to the states it's sanctioned so they have to go to the states so so they they pick up the tab for that um so even the wealthiest school districts don't don't you know fund this right it's the the parents and the families understand that it has to be
150pure fundraising from the beginning the district will throw in the registration and perhaps transportation in addition to that we have the equalization like I said that the residents are going to be really hit hard on our district should come as close to a zero zero tax levy increase as possible which may be near imp possible being all our financial woses over the past two years um and none of our students have field trips so being that our students don't have field trips which their peers in other districts have I would have a hard time approving $15,000 or whatever it is for a handful of students to go to Disney when we can't get our own children to the Cradle Aviation Garden City or we can't get them to the fish fish hatchery in Oyster Bay
151so it's not to diminish the hard work or the effort but I think that information is really important to have thank you does anyone have anything to say because does the I know this could kind of cause kind of a conflict but does the school district have any ability to encourage the fundraising because I know the team themselves are doing their part to try to raise money for it but are we able to uh like promote fundraising for this specific event I I I think go ahead goad School up itself I mean I in terms of promoting fundraising like if we use our social media we send letter out to the district or Rec no the the they have to that mean that's a student organization does the fundraising we don't have authority to do
152fundraising all right that's what I figured any any other comments on this may I just add clarification um the assistant director of the Statewide Athletic Association did provide an email confirming that they do sanction the event so I just want to make sure that we were clear and and so I I think one of the things for for me is that um and and I heard and I listened to everything that um truste um kesto had just said and I I feel as if that this is just my own personal opinion I feel as if that this is something that has not occurred for our cheerleaders and if this could be an opportunity that we could make a donation not donation but if we can give money towards their trip for this year with the
153understanding as we move forward if this is something that they want to do they're going to have to continue to work on raising more money um um in reference to wealthier districts you hit something right on the head with wealthier districts there's more money there's more opportunity for people to donate for that particular event so I don't have a problem with um maybe not the 15,000 but maybe like 8,000 or something like that that would cover the flights in in the ground transportation to give towards um the trip so that's just mine and I I understand I I understand all about section 11 and everything that sanctioned not sanctioned I'm completely aware of that but this is just me I am okay with the district if there's money in that account from Athletics if there's
154like $8,500 or are we just providing guidance I think you you would need to take a to take a vote the policy does not provide the superintendent with authority to all to encour this cause well I'm just I'm just want to hear people's feedback I just I just want to understand what what comes at the end of this and um I am a cheer parent my daughter is on the cheer team um I'm also very proud of them so when it comes to a vote I will recuse myself because for obvious reasons um so I guess can I just speak as a parent or a you can speak as a board M you're Bo member I can't I my opinion is um Wendy I hear all your points and I share many of them my
155feeling is that what will be the best way to do right by all the hard work that this team has put into it since last January because this has been a work over a year in making I would like them to see to see them get similar treatment as any team that is going to another Equitable event does any team get $15,000 I don't think so I don't I would not agree to $115,000 but an amount similar to what the soccer team or the track team would get to travel um I I can make peace with that I understand we need to cut costs wherever we can but we still need to do the basics of Education including Athletics so I I don't want the cheer team to get unfair treatment um but I don't
156I don't think what I'm asking for is unfair okay listen my question just piggybacks what she was just saying sorry um do we know like what the average cost is like if the soccer team went to States or basketball team went to States like what the normal cost that would be because I don't it it probably wouldn't be as much because it's in New York State no I know it wouldn't be as much but I'm just trying to get pay for the accommodation that's not my question though I'm just asking like what the average cost is I I think in the past to speak more to the Mich L the school districts have our school district more into the mic the school school district has given uh paid for meals so if we did like
157something like that like $5,000 or $7,000 or something like that you know taking something specifically or I think Carol you mentioned it take $7,000 and let them do what they need to do with it you know 15,000 is a lot but I think they should get something but I think John John had stated that we have to make it towards flights we have to put it towards it should be more okay um if I I just want to mention something leis I know you said about wealthy districts to to just to be clear the districts are all different from all different economic you know socio economical backgrounds just to be clear and um the other thing is I think you know we have to watch our money I know we all know that but first
158of all if you do this once you can't just say we're going to do this once and we're not going to do it again board members change you are opening up the door to do this the second thing is this decision while I would support paying $1,500 for registration or the transportation I think this is a classic case of how we ended up where we were like how we overspent money if there's extra money in athletics we're already down money we already have a hole for like Northeast like we shouldn't be spending every money just because it's there I think this is a clear example of how we get oursel in this mess not me because I wasn't part of it but that's how that it happened there extra was there money put aside for
159athletics to go to States go ahead go go ahead right wasn't just it's just it's just it's just a general budget that that he has and so um he has money in his budget that he said that could be utilized um you know for for for the cheerleaders so I've I've heard from everyone I just so Chris I want you to finish your your questions Leslie Caroline because you may know just kind of speak close still going to do more fundraising are they looking for sponsors like soccer okay yes okay so they will continue so they're putting their hearts into this done they've done a lot already um one thing that's been really successful and they would like to do more if they can get approval for it is clinics um because I I know
160this this is a difficult trip to make a case for so um instances where they provide a service in exchange for a fee such as teaching kids cheer that's wildly successful they did several of them and it would be great to see them to do more so um they will they will continue working if allowed and I know that little a little by little um Amityville organizations are donating money Kanan has just do donated $250 and I know other organizations are playing on donating as well is is there has there been any issue with approval for the clinics that I I I'm asking if there's been H have you asked permission for the clinics I is that something you've already asked and you're waiting for an answer for or something that you're going to do
161in the future Caroline I'm asking Ashley you so the have the clins been done on on school gr or are you waiting for an answer for approval I know they did one in the Middle School in the spring and another one I believe it was at the middle school in the fall and I I hear that they want to do more and I don't know where it stands um Dr Talbert are there any pending requests you know no I've not received any requests have we at this point so not for that specifically so um I think any other board members have a qu a comment this scle that ATA just wants to make a a quick comment on this correct is it that which yeah okay go allow you to come to the mic on
162this matter Mick wolf ATA president 100 Avalon Court um there is a clear understanding of the financial situation that it is that we find ourselves in um and there it isn't an a regular occurrence when speak there isn't a regular occurrence when it is that we um have situations where it is that our student athletes are able to um partake in these experiences um even though I do understand where it is that trustee canestro is coming from in terms of um making sure that we are are um fiduciary responsible with our um with our spending um I do think that it's important and especially in a year where we don't have field trips that when you reach a certain Accolade or when you reach a certain status that you're be able that you're able to
163take advantage of those things um you know I can remember being fortunate enough to go to field trips that were away um and I've been in the district for over 20 plus years and you know those those times are the they're not normal occurrences where it is that it happens so if the board decides that they're going to move forward with allowing something like this to happen um the ATA would like to work with you to make a donation um moving forward to make sure that those students have that opportunity thank you thank you thank Youk you so thank you any other comments on on this before we I I call for a number go ahead I do have one question so John you explained that um for our policy we have authorization to pay
164for the travel expenses correct then um there would be an understanding that going forward I guess this is now more for Dr Talbert there would be an understanding that going forward this would have to specifically be in the Athletics budget and it wouldn't be like an un like an assumption that this would happen every year right yes I think we certainly need to plan for the future and have some procedures in place if what if we had five teams who will go in the Nationals this year be wonderful but we'd be in a pickle we wouldn't be able to pay for far so yes certainly moving forward we need some internal procedures that would govern I guess they're lucky that they are the one team that wants that money but who knows if there was
165another team that held back from pursuing a competition because they didn't think they would have the funding so that's you know that's hard they decided to pursue this and I believe I actually was a cheerleader cheerleader High School College college cheering coach I get it I love the sport love it I love watching you on Instagram I love it um so I just want to be fair and I I really feel strongly that the students of our school district deserve a field trip as well so I'm having a really hard time with this um but I I know that you're saying that it's in the Athletics budget um but I do want the board to be willing to go back and consider the one field trip and I know had to ask Miss batti uh
166just to clarify why there was money allocated under transportation for field trips so we'll follow up on that I just thank you for the all right so um at this at this point in time um I I'm going to do I'm I'm going to do two things I'll I'll do the the first um how many board members are willing to support I I looked at the flights which was 7,300 and the ground transportation of 750 all right that would be $850 so I'll start off with that amount and then I I can go from there so probably Dam so how many board members are support of $850 that will cover the flights the flights so we've heard 8,50 that will cover flights in grounds so we can just arbitrarily say we can make just a
167donation we can move money from the athletic department of $5,000 hypothetically do we have no so that's my that's my question that's I just need clarification so you your policy you you have the authorization for to spend the money for travel right which you be of flights and grounds not a portion of travel okay so that's what's on the table $850 that will be for transportation which will cover the flights and the ground transportation so how many board members are in support of coming from the athletic department $850 that would support the flights and ground transportation in Florida I support that amount that's me I going to say no and I just want to add this the Board of Education answers to the taxpayers I think it would be very difficult to say to taxpayers
168that you're going to expend this money again when there's no field trips and I'm not opposed to the registration or the transportation but I think it would be very difficult also for the Board of Education to say what happens with the senior trip what happens with the junior class what happens with these other things how are you going to explain that you only a handful of kids you're sending to Disney and and now you know we're not doing that it's not Equitable really uh for everybody so that's just my opinion and and I'm just asking you to consider that but no I'm not amount that's very exorbitant thank you so I think we already had our discussion on it so right now I'm just taking the vote so um in terms of $850 that will
169cover flights and grounds um Caroline you're excusing yourself accusing yourself all right um Carol yes Megan Chris yes Leslie Megan oh God Megan what what do you want to do V Megan yes and no well I I want the board to talk about field trips Megan make what's on the table right now now is is is the cheerleading vote so that that's what's on the table right now all right so either yes or no right now what the vote that's on the table is regarding the cheerleading so you have to do your vote for the cheerleading making a donation not I mean not not donation but coming from the athletic budget of $850 that's the vote that's on the table right now okay yes so right now it's five yes one no and then I'll
170and then one recuse obain abstain and the abstain is Caroline right at this point at the point in time I'm going to make a motion to adjourn the meeting at 10:20 please so moved second second so it is car see off is first Chris n is second all those in favor I I I motion carry 70