001thank thank you for joining us for um the policy committee meeting we'll open this up at at 5:30 thank you for joining us right so um so what Lyn is passing out right now are um 4532 and 45 32 are the ready okay and so what she's done she's just provided Chang that so let's um how about we go through um easy let's go through the easy policies first so we can keep you know keep this moving my list at home can we start with theu yes yes um I have just several comments on that for um the second sentence accordly the members of the board shall conduct an annual evaluation I think it's difficult to conduct an annual evaluation in July because the board members are ever changing so I suggest that we put
002mid year or before December um I had forel annual as well I my preference would be to do something like in December and another one in May right right so I the board shall conduct have a mid review and final review yes okay midye review by December and final review in May yes review I would say December okay in December and Final in May but by end of or just in May is fine in May in May um and then the only other suggestion I have there's two different evaluations in here I suggest getting rid of the first one and keeping the n one you know what um I look through I think that the second they're both from n the second one is very very very detailed very very detailed I think it's something
003that um I'm fine find the second one I'm fine okay you think we can eliminate this one is this one well the yeah the first one was one that was previously done before or something similar to this one it's like very generic very like I feel like it's more Elementary I feel like the second one is it's more in the line with the superintendent evaluation I think it keeps everything more consistent so we um have that L we we'll make those changes yeah what we're going to do is um I told Lyn we'll discuss it and then once we make our final decision then we'll say okay this is the changes we're going to make on that particular policy well because there's only very few feel like this very yeah no yeah that's what I'm
004saying so making are you going to make the changes land on the computer well this one right here I don't have a word do so otherwise I think you could just so just so you know over here only the M of the board shall conduct a mid year a midy year review by December in December well I think I would say midye self evaluation but it's not it's not um by December and then a final self evaluation in May but this is this is all the self this is all the self- evaluation here yes yeah so we're going to do one mid year we're going to review it and then we'll finalize it to see if B in growth so I'm not sure we need to say self evaluation or do we just say um
005evaluation utilizing I'm trying to find the beginning of the um oh I see what you're saying because it says self evaluation yeah you can just say evaluation and then yeah utilize the n school yeah and and when this first one the first couple of pages this one four how about how about let me just kind of talk she has so let's make sure that you you got this that the board shall conduct of midar review in December and a final and and I I think we need to use the words mid midyear evaluation so evaluation in December and in a final evaluation evaluation do and I think what we need to State on here the bo education friend seeds there was like awarding for the the I think if we just have Lyn remove that
006first one and just keep the second one in so we'll adopt it with that second one so you see this this one here so we're this one's going to go how are you hi everybody do you have it on so I think for the second part I mean sometimes I've seen where they explain do but I think we could just discuss that so um we want to do corresponds to the board from publicness um I just had a couple of suggestions because here it says public complaints and it keeps talking about public complaints I think we should expand on that and might public written complaints TR concerns or General in because it's not always complains might have a suggestion somebody might have [Music] question I agree when you say think um um so it said
007it will be directed to proper administrative Personnel but I think that that's incorrect I think the board directs it to the superintendent superintend 78 so I would say director to the superintendent who to 78 proper right Dr like we're giving it to you and 70 we're not going to be but what it says here if the matter is not s satisfied but Clinton shall then contact the principal if there's no resolution on this level super school or Des shall be contacted super final resolution I think part of the problem is that um it has public complaints about the school dist shall be directed to the proper administrative Personnel So it's talking about I look at it do two ways the first paragraph is talking about the board recognizes the right to receive information um so
008to me it's just more of if you have something if if a parent is or someone is sending us something that there a concern we would then redirect them it's a chain of maybe we can just word this where it will be directed to the superintendent who will disseminate disseminate to the proper CH and follow the command maybe we can eliminate that part because it's really just reemphasizing the CH Comm okay so just go ahead and and speak that out again and so I'll let I'll let you say this portion okay public written correspondence um to the school that this doesn't make sense how written correspondence about about the school district will be directed to the superintendent who will will umate and follow CH how do want to say that well I think disseminated to
009the proper administrative Personnel be appropriate yeah the appropriate the this is just for written it say correspondence to one maybe we could add something in here another paragra say directed to the superintendent will disseminate it to the appropriate personel that right yes to disate to the appropriate personnel and then should we put something about the chain of commands or I mean it's really that's what you're going to do you're going to follow right because you're just going to kind of kick it down to the principal going to kick it down to so do do we need to say public do we just do we need to say written correspondence about because is it is it a need to say public well the title of is correspondence to the board from the public so the public
010is just anybody at Great of hars right so just say it again public WR correspondence public written correspondence about the school district will be directed to the superintendent disseminated to the appropiate personel I think this other tus need we can taken out because I think that we if we want to put something in here that you know the chain of command will be followed you know where it's like teacher principal there's another policy that talks about the chain yeah we have I think we can take this and then and then we can add this part too that way on the superintendent shall refer the issue to the board for final resolution if necessary I think we should need that so if it's an an issue that's heightened to that level the superintendent will come back
011to us for consideration or whatever it is I think that last sentence should remain um and then the other sentence that I just wanted to kind of clean up was full corespondent received from the public while be acknowledged in a timely manner I think it would be approprate to put a time frame on that are we going to respond within a day are we respond within 48 hours we expect our teachers to respond within a day won't you be responding whatever the acknowledgement is you know thank you your email will be it super I think I 24 to 48 hours I would say 24 to 48 hours think um I think also what's what's important there should be it doesn't have to place in it but there should be a generic response typically what I've
012done in the past I say that thank you so much I correspond so I think what people understand that when we acknowledge we just acknowledge it doesn't mean that it's resol okay so do you want to so okay so let's go to let's go to the next all correspondents we'll keep that second sentence all correspondents received them from the public will be acknowledged within 24 to 48 hours where you this is the second sentence of the second paragraph So written public written correspond will be to superintendent will to the and now you're saying all correspondents received from the public will be acknowledged within 24 to 48 hours from board president what do you want to things they just say 48 hours just say within okay within 48 Hours okay within Hours um I I think
013we have to over complicate it because I think people just need to understand when it says acknowledge that all just that we have received it all correspondence for the public will we acknowledged as received yeah I rather do that acknowledg as received okay acknowledged as received within 48 hours I would take out the rest May the superintendent shall refer the issue to the board final resolution if necessary okay um shall be writing direct to the board as a individual board member shall be and then I had here I wanted to add add in shared with all board members within the 48 Hours like we can stick to that for consistency and refer to the superintendent for investigation report investigation okay so all man refer to superintendent and on the shall beern where to the board
014as a whole or to an individual board shall be shared with the board with within 40 I would say within with the en board within be shared with the board okay with the board okay I'll be um shared with the board hours and refer to the superintendent investigation all right so we're now up to everyone's okay with this Shar 4 hours yes refer to the superintendent investigation ref as soon as we super investigation resolution so are we taking out well I don't think we should do as reason as possible I thought we said 4 hours we G respondin 48 hours to the superintendent I think it should probably be sooner than that if we're going to get it and acknowledge it within 48 hours we're sorry shouldn't we just automatically one within 24 hours what
015I think I mean that's that's up to the board but I think we should give yourselves some leverage time so we don't get and I think only we have to be very careful of is that that that means have to make sure that every single day day that we're looking at emails make sure that something comes in and what do we say shall shall be shared with I think all CL will be acknowled as we see within 48 Hours doing business hours well I think as a school board you're kind of always on if there's a pressing matter and it's an emergency like I feel like it's our responsibil be responsive and check our emails one of our respons right so let's say for example I do the Christmas break no nothing much is happening
016like I didn't look at my email like every every day Ian so I didn't so exist we're going to put this in place that means that we have to make sure that we look at our emails I think it's reasonable because I I think you have to think of it from a parents perspective or Community if they just really pressing stuff sometimes it might just be in or suggestion but what if there something like really pressing like something not good we don't want to say hey we need check our email yeah we should be checking our email day is there a way to set up one email account put on this and then that anything sent to that email address gets forwarded to the board members well they do have that in another District they
017have like a generic one like if might say amille Bo amever that's why I saying you got it automatically forwarded to all the board members we own person but that way the complaints go this and then instead of making sure that you you might you probably get more more resum and you got two days where you're tied up you can't check your emails Miss 4 hours to everybody then well I do think sometimes they might send it to one person just the board presid or a different person the only thing is like we have to remember our due diligence is to like be checking our emails and be monitoring so like it's on us to our job and what what about circumstances where there's someone that is maybe sharing something with a board member just
018say I'm Shar with you but I just share with you I don't not resolution in that it's just like soyi right exactly so that in that situation then is it responsibility of woman Shar because what happens person I don't want it Shar with I want to make you aware of it I'm not trying to make an issue on it I mean I think that we're only here we're a governing body we're really not individuals we we're an operating governing body so nobody's really here in this position just as one person body so as a body I mean that's just for me I think for me personally if someone if someone shares something with me and it's only happen once they say I just want to make you aware not looking for it to be a
019big issue make you aware and to me it's someone is made me aware to me it's the same thing as walk up to me and said you know what I just make you aware that I think but they're making you aware because you're on the board of education you're part of the governing body so the whole board should be aware right once again it's what I can make the whole board aware but I what happens the person says I don't want someone to know my name so I can tell the whole board that I re SCH board 101 is you don't respond to Anonymous oh I never no no no I'm not I'm not talking about Anonymous at all not not but if someone if someone walks up to me and says Hi my name
020is is Bobby jokes I'm a parent such and such school and I just want to make aware ex but I don't want my name to be given now to the entire but the Board of Education operates with confidentiality so I think again we are a part of a body we're not individuals and then you can you can relay that to the board want any use I think that you have give it and say they want this is they want to remain anonymous they don't want it to get out this is I'm sharing it with you but it's confidential but you have to trust your board members enough that we are Gover body and we operate the Char just relate to that person as my in my position I have to Rel this message to the
021board might be necessary for whatever the case is that your name well maybe maybe up front you say that you yes on on the gifts for the public I only had one thing and I'm not sure if it should go here or not teachers may not accept gifts exceeding $75 wor value but I think that this is for board so I'm not sure where that would go so that particular one was brought to our attention by call fras there some whole layout um that probably is One D all conditions or restrictions that may well you correct because there is one after V to the board as well so this came to our attention when um bar Stevens and Paul Frasier were meeting with Anum who wanted to make a donation a scholarship donation to The
022District and so when we went to look for a scholarship policy there was not a direct scholarship policy and so then we begin to gather the policies that may be applicable and we pull some from uh another District to reference so back to um the original policy 1800 gifs in the public yeah this anigo policy he recommended you be updated with additional information for gifts and donations through crowd funding as reflected in the attached policy um 18800 so let's see we have the amville one and then marry the one from cop is it also 1800 it's like 5800 the one I just pass out cover on so okay so just bring that to your attention then it went on to say 5800 enity Bill does not have this policy but they're suggesting that we add
023policy based on the attached 5800 and then there are two other districts that have a 5800 um that is also being compared and their language was the same did you see that and then there's a cross reference of 5500 for perp missing something I just have I have the one from the next one that says student awards and schar the one you're referencing and then I have another one that says student GI solicitations yeah those correct those are the only ones we have a Tex but I'm I'm just reading from this cover sheet saying that there are others I guess that are not with us here I don't see the student yeah student GI solicit okay so we do not have a student gifts and solic solicitations policy uh we don't have a student award
024and scholarship policy we have a gifts from the public um so I am not um I I personally do not want crowd funding it's kind of like a GoFundMe whatever because you have no oversight to that you really don't know how much it's going to be used how much they rate they just zero oversight I would not be in favor of that um for gifts from the public the way I'm reading this particular policy I think is to the board to earmark and people gift us money or or things like that I um I didn't have a lot of input on that I did have input on the scholarships though I I don't I for me personally I think I didn't have anything for for for the gift from the public I missed the Apple
025instead of a fly but I think I I looked at it that that if someone says that we want to make a donation to The we want to make a donation that in terms of they want to make the Don say what is the purpose of that GI I want to give $1,000 to buy yeah PRS right that's the that's I'm going to give donation to the high school right the purpose of it is um to buy $1,000 beneficiary condition that may apply so I I look at it that we're just saying them give us this but once again the give must not benefit to benefit a particular or well you know I I've had this in my know we had like wealth people that would donate money to the district and they would say
026I'm gifting you by the way sometimes it was like crazy money but I'm just gonna say like what and say was ,000 I'm giving this to the principal to use how you see for the students or whatever that's what we would do we would get checks and they might suggest something but that doesn't mean that the board has to do that it's at the discretion so I think that this might say that it say disc rejected on the board so so I'm well can we add maybe that the gift the um dissemination of the gift or how apply will be will be the 7 will be um final decision will be by the Board of Education right because if somebody says I only want to give this money for this classroom or whatever like you
027can't do that right equal so un have full discretion I think we just should look at it from a larger lens yeah and um yes I think this was something that F reach out to um Al you and the reason why he did that was because in this particular case the family or the person who was going to give the wanted to get names of kids and S make a selection can't do that yes because of 2D and that was Alan's point that when it gets to that point they can't go too far so that piece about at the discretion of the Board of Education becomes very important now the board decides not so so Chris is suggesting five right um dissemination of funds we have the dist of the board we that so can
028I just make a recommendation funds Bas recommendation consultation super D we're adding a dation of the F expression yeah because I don't want to make it that the superintendent has the final word theard has the final but I do think it's important that the superintendent says so that's consultation consultation consultation now may I ask um Miss Stevens are there any concerns that this policy does not address that was a part of your conversation be a m who wanted to make their donation was everything all cleared and this policy should be good to the dist um the only thing that I I wanted to ask can we like tether this to the student I think student awards and scholarship just because goes in maybe do that see we don't have a student award scholarship policy we
029do Nots yeah that's not out it's the s make sure so the only thing that we changes on this one for 1800 is under one D um it's apply instead of apple and then for 5D is dissemination the funds is at of the board with consultation so that one is um question do we have a policy 1801 we make the student awards scholarships like 1801 they kind of go in hands or well I know that um there are three other districts that have that same one and they call it 5800 oh so should we just do oh wait um this just want also has plus reference yeah so at the bottom there reference would be 5800 7 not to exceed $75 gift for teachers do we have a policy for that or is this something
030we should add to this even though this is a gift to the Board of Education I feel like we have to that somewhere so if you look in the same attachment at policy 2160 uh 2160 someone with good eyes number one it says gifts there's a contradiction do you see it there an officer or this is our policy an officer or employee shall not directly or indirectly solicit any gift or accept or receive any gift we just have to fix that having a value of $100 or more but that should say 75 if that's the okay so ly do you have that no under one should be yes thank you um so 2160 the only thing we making change be55 now since we're talking about solicitation policy 5660 talks about student gifts and solicit can
031we do this one first that one I just wanted to add one thing to this 5800 married I don't need to volunte you she was good at this okay for the student awards of scholarship the only thing that I wanted to add to because this was an issue last year I know of a student who received a scholarship and it had monetary value and I don't think it was necessarily from the school district I think it was through the um the student had no idea that they was criteria that they had to submit information so when they received the scholarship like months later they're like yes I never got money and the ATA was like well you never submitted the criteria he student like you gave us the criteria so I I was just gonna
032say and any criteria for such scholarship shall be shared with the student SL parent of guardian that so just say it again any criteria this is this is before the gifts this is I was gonna say like the last this is for 5800 this is the this is the new right know I you might know this Chris had a good question the criteria is it at the time that they're notified of a scholarship like how it get notified I don't think it would have to be twice it should be in the application itself right which we don't necessarily govern any application maybe we have any before you guys go so what Lynn did ly did she she wrote it up and you guys have it in your passage and so we can maybe just make
033not to you guys so what she did for we student GI solation so what she did she attached the old one but what she did she typed it up okay just for go ahead um how about we put any scholarship application shall include all criteria but isn't that the case now no I just told you what happened somebody got a scholarship and they would never notifi the criteria so this is my question and just when we talk about say criteria I'm thinking in my mind this is the criteria to apply for the scholarship so I think we need to clarify um to receive a monetary award how about that any scholarship application which involves um monetary award shall list all paring criteria to receive receive the money to receive scholarship um and then to Mary's
034point maybe a second sentence the criteria shall be [Music] disseminated what do you say the second time at when you're handing it out Mary saying to do a on the application and you hand it out Cy in writing I think we should say in so like so they should have it in packet like I used to do the award ceremony and we used to get like used to write something up we would get the scholarship and we would have an envelope and we would give it like that's yeah maybe should say a gift gift monetary or otherwise to receive the award the award could be monetary or any scholarship application shall include all criteria to receive the award right so let's read it back through again one person I have is one little thing any
035scholarship application shall pereria to receive warant and then add a second sentence written criteria shall upon presentation of award presentation written criteria shall be shall be included yes upon presentation of award written Criterion shall be included um can I just ask a question be included in order to receive the award or no just show they have to so to make sure that it start appc sh criter should sentence written criteria presentation of I think other way upon presentation so let's read one more time any scholarship app and the next part will be presentation of your War written criteria shall be yes everyone everyone I think should we list this one H 216 so that we know that we just covered that we just made that one change yes yes the main yes could we also
036before we move on look at 5660 so 5660 explicitly talks about student gifts and solicitation and as of now uh I guess what perhaps we should have brought with the fractalization policy 566 and I have you gave us that um one yes I don't know what I did with my lary the only question are we sticking to these numbers or we have to check these numbers we'll check the numb so I know we had a Friz policy is this something we want to add to the fraiz policy or just have a simple separate policy I a simple separate policy I think it's really nice how it's written as so you have yes I mean it's very simple so at student gifts and solicitation should we change fund drives to fundraisers are we accepting outside organiz
037to distribute F do that we take that out any outside organization yeah stud conne drives you know shoe drives and the student councils or cloves made is there a way just pleas that wording fers fun I think so because I approve every flyer that's disseminated so are we making any changes to this to students so good so we're going to reference reference it to guess from well that's for students I would be good to cross reference into the Friz B whatever number yes Ian if we St with from that yeah1 all right reference 9150 good that good I saw that just want to this Eddie signed on so that's the Eddie leave it so use of service animals 3 this is that legal gave us on 11824 I'm not sure if Lynn had that version
038or not I I don't okay oh they added yes but then the memo that's attached back here there that uh it says we know that review policy includes a reference to miniature horses in the last paragraph the board may want to include the following paragraph since Min are not mentioned anywhere else in the policy in this memo is January 8 so this memo came after the policy was approved right so the very end of the package is this Memo from and this right here is what they're suggesting you may want to consider to add they think that well they're saying since it's in there they're saying that we would allow the use and it would only be permitted when it's been individually trained to do the work but that means you know we're we'll have
039to come back and re approve this because we approved it with that in there okay so we'll just take out that last paragraph you mean that last that superintend or we'll just take out the word use of service animals and scratch you said service animals on school grounds yes service animals yeah we'll take out those three words why is there like different words in show changes oh so that's so wait I had I had a suggestion okay on something that I read um I think it was from different District I so it was from the college was in here as a reference but something that they did in here was they added they added two things one is the dog required person disability two what worker has the dog drink those are the only two
040questions yeah I think we should include those it's in the State College one you can't ask like they're not requ certification we have to figure out where we want that okay so there was a regulation that I attached you all have the regulation oh you do we want to put that we put that Parra ahead of it where it Additionally the district not ask about the nature person dis ability determ whether person animal qualifies as gerous animal however when it is not readily apparent that a dog is aous animal um should we say the superintendent may make two inquiry to determine whether the dog qualifies as a service animal which are one is a dog required the disability two what workers has we take a moment look at the regulation that might answer some of
041our so that was the assignment tonight to develop a regulation for the policy that we had adopted but being that we got the memo January 8 well I think it might be helpful so particularly around the where where but I don't have it okay I just passed around yes yeah regulation for the use of service animals G okay and should have draft but it doesn't so it's you see soly where it says general requirements um who's eligible the task that we just talking about must be under the control of the Handler at all times must be in good health vaccinated license should be well behaved not POS a threats and then procedures individuals seeking to bring a service animal on school property must submit a written request to the building principal or there desn't need
042at least 10 school days in advance when possible documentation proof of the animal's health information on the task the animal is train to inform a statement of the individual's disability if not already on file IEP 54 and then how do we evaluate the process the building principle in consultation with rence re an staff will review the request if the request meets policy and regulation requirements the principal will issue written approval denial request may be denied if the animal is not a service animal poses a threat is not house broken can I just can I just ask one more request when it comes to approval Parts regulation that I think it should also um the principal should will notify the superintendent that they have approved mean because I I I this is just my perspective if
043the building principles has done all this and then approv yeah but I'm just saying it's not do so I think I think we need to add that one step that under we have review hold on a second also do you feel that should H there be a step for HR that HR files this with the employees file they to definitely be um involved in the process can I just ask a question what happens if it has to be an employee that brings in the service animal what happens if what happens if I have a service animal and I say I like to go my service anal and if it's a student then see a statement of the individual's disability is not already on file for students with the IEP are section 504 that's applicable let's
044just add okay but we also need to go back up to Roman numeral two because this was written when the other item was included out yes so just which is trained which is animal as a dog which is so we take out everything else for inic circumstances we taking that out yeah we're just G leave a service which is trained to perform task to work directly which is train and then um procedures Lisa you want to add number three to that where you want where did you want to and number five the evaluation approval process so I feel like number two says request policy regulation principal will issue approval condition for the service the superintendent in HR not same well do we want to go back to review the building principle or designate in consultation
045with HR will review the request and supporting documentation so H Human Resources the request supporting documentation um but I think that we should say and the superintendent should should be supplyed a copy as well I we should put that in there so the building principal designate in consultation with human resources and relevant staff I mean no because why is it relevant sta you're having the administrator review it you having right so B will designate in consultation with HR because the relevant St that STS consultation with relevant staff I think we should leave relevant staff there Rel staff and and human resources do thank human resour should be involved should be in their file yeah HR specify this policy is for students and staff because we can't really expect ex a parent to have to go
046through this entire approval process just to go to one night of parent teach conference the only thing is thank you for join us