001good evening ladies gentlemen welcome to the mville board education combine for Education meeting the date is December the 11 and The Time Is Now 5:30 present at the meeting point point in time is superintendent Dr talber for president myself l Johnson first vice president Carol SE second vice president Megan mesman truste Chris naring Caroline Fanon canestro is anticipated that trusty Leslie cret will be arriving also presid at this time is assistant superintendent for curc instruction Mary Stevens assistant superintendent for human resources Dr briard W assistant superintendent for finance and operations Olivia waty legal counsil John shanon and financial cons Paul it is now 5:35 and I have a motion to enter into executive SE to discuss colle collective bargaining negotiation B the ATA um discuss matters related to the public persons and to obtain advice
002from legal accounts second Megan M first Lindy kro second all those in favor I I Mo carries 60 we will resume open roughly around 7:30 thank you for join discuss um collective bargaining negotiation involving the ATA um discuss employment history particular persons advice from legal counsel as well as to interview a candidate for the assistant director of PPS um at this point in time um please note the exits to closest to your sitting there's no smoking the school grounds please silence your cell phones and now join the bo in the Pledge of Allegiance before we get started with the agenda there's um two things that I I I want to do several things one is I would like to um make a motion to the board of education to change the order of the agenda
003and the first request is to move the superintendent of schools report after um the presentation of the annal high school course catalog some move second okay Carol seof is first Wendy canestro is second all those in favor I I motion carries 70 the second request is to move up the community input regarding nonb agenda items before old business and new business motion second so I think that was Carol first Leslie cret second all those in favor I I motion carries 70 so Community input will go after agenda item 3 F two and the last request that I have is that for old business and new business that we keep our discussion under OBS new business to roughly about 30 minutes just like we ask our community to keep the input to 30 minutes so move
004second lizie cretz is first um Carol you have a second any questions or comments on this um yeah I do um you know we appreciate that the community is coming out here and we want you to have an opportunity to ask questions but this is also a Board of Education meeting where we are obligated to do the business of the district in public um so that you could see the public deliberations you could see our thought process you could see the questions that we ask you could get the same answers that we get so limiting the time frame limits our ability to do the business so I I yeah that's it okay any other comments on this uh I would would hope that if we're we're just taking that as a suggestion as like a
005goal for us to stay within that 30 minutes but if we're having meaningful conversations that it would extend beyond that it could always be a motion to extend it beyond the 30 minutes just like with the um any like with the non-agenda items and the agenda items is always a motion that can be placed that we reached our limit do we want to extend it beyond that that time frame so the same thing would hold for for Education comments any other comments and discussion on this no all those in favor I I hold on I'm hold on one second I have to get the Eyes First So Lisa who's another I Carol yes Chris Caroline is no Megan no Wendy no Leslie yes so the motion carries um 4 Z and once again we do
006have the ability to extend the time if needed for any of these areas so going back to the agenda I am going to um just make a couple things so people are aware on the agenda item 3B one I mean 3 B2 just to make sure that it's correct on your agenda it should say assistant director of PPS and special education the background does say the assistant director a PPS so it should read assistant director PPS and special education make sure that you have that correct and also also there's a item that's going to be added to the agenda right so so for I also want to amend the agenda now to add agenda item 2 C4 which is the termination of the Honeywell contract so I want to make a motion to add the
007to the agenda agenda item 2 C4 which is the termination of the Honeywell contract have a motion for that motion I think that was Wendy canestro and sorry Megan and Caroline right so that resolution reads provide resolve the Board of Education terminates the energy performance contract with Honeywell International Inc pursuant to section 3.7 onth and authorized superintendent of schools to notify Honeywell International Inc and this is representing the representing the 22 contract 2022 contract yeah all those in favor I motion carries 70 so now we're gonna once again we've made those changes and now I'm going to turn it over to Dr talin thank you President Johnson good evening to the Board of Education once again and our colleagues and community at this time we're going to have a presentation just a brief highlight of
008the amville Memorial High School course catalog we would like to thank principal Cardone and his administrative staff for offering comprehensive and diverse courses for our students the presentation this evening will be facilitated by our assistant superintendent for curriculum and instruction Miss Mary Stevens good evening thank you Dr Talbert so the course catalog for this year is largely similar to the one that we did offer last year I just wanted to go over the framework of the catalog some new additions um and some of the course offerings that we have had historically so the first part of the course catalog offers general information on policies that are pertinent to students especially as they relate to grading and attendance it indicates what program levels we offer which are relevant to the course waiting system copies of the
009New York State graduation requirements so we do outline for students exactly which courses meet requirements um that information is in the course description and then information about the seala by literacy which we are proud to offer as something that goes on a student's uh high school diploma from the board of regions the second part offers uh or I'm sorry in the second part are the course offerings they are listed by Department uh at the beginning of each page uh each department is a page that lists the electives and the required courses there are denotations of courses that already have approval for NCAA um and there are indicators of what courses are new this year the new courses um for this year are both in technology you can find those on page 72 of the course
010guide um so they do have that indicator that they are new courses these were developed in response to student interest one is the residential wiring course and the other is the mechanical drawing and architecture course these we plan to offer to our underclassmen um so that they can start to think about their intentions for career and Tech ad programs so they would have the opportunity to explore something that they've indicated interest in and determine whether it's something they'd like to pursue uh as part of our partnership with bosis as far as our current offerings we're proud of the robust curricular opportunities that we have for students I did want to highlight uh that we have AP courses in a number of areas students do have the opportunity to choose among 21 AP courses that are
011in the catalog and then we do have opportunities for Partnerships with some of our local uh and Statewide colleges for dual enrollment courses right now we have 12 opportunities for that listed in the course catalog um for those dual en rollman opportunities uh students and their families would have to pay the tuition which is typically at a reduced rate directly to the colleges so we do indicate that in the course offerings we do have information for parents available about the deadlines for that and S students who successfully complete the class then would be able to receive a transcript from those partner colleges so that they would be able to transfer the credits as needed when they're accepted to colleges um and then finally I just wanted to speak to you about the roll out then
012um upon board approval of the course guide the high school team would start with the process for scheduling um it would begin with a virtual meeting for parents so that they could understand what the process is for course selection and then meetings with guidance counselors after those parent meetings um the high school has designed a program where there would be a day of assemblies for students so 9th through 11th grade students will participate in two different workshops one will be with their counselors where they get the overview of that scheduling process and the other would be a curriculum Fair where they would go to the different department tables to learn about both the requirements and the electives that are offered and help them with their choices the 12th grade students during that cycle would be
013meeting with counselors doing presentations on the FAFSA process and the scholarship opportunities offered and then finally after that process students would start working on what we call future me surveys it would ask them to reflect on what their goals are moving forward and how their course choices are going to help them meet those goals using those uh future me forms the guidance counselors would begin scheduling meetings with students we estimate that that would be in mid to late January hoping to have those completed in February once the course selections are in the master scheduling team begins to work on how many students are interested in particular classes um and to work with us on the budget as far as Staffing so that we can determine which courses are running start programming students in and ultimately
014have schedules for all of our students that was all I had on the course catalog thank you thank you does any borers have any questions regarding the course catalog uh hi yes I do thank you thank you for that um I looked through this this looks like a lot of really nice offerings I have several questions about it um do do we have enough core teachers and core classes as it is that we're offering this for next year like will we be fully at staff for this we definitely have enough teachers for the core classes um and then the interest in the electives I mean certainly we have to schedule students for full schedules um it's a matter of looking at what teachers we have in which areas and then determining the Staffing as we
015go through the budget process as well right I guess my concern is that we are offering these electives which look wonderful but do we have the stamping for it sorry so we do offer these to see where student interest is but then based on how many are choosing it the course may not run um so we do look at what options are available in some areas when we know there's interest in particular um courses they don't run every year so there are certain courses that pair with one another where it will run um I can give the the French as an example College French one runs one year AP French runs the next year so that students will have an opportunity if they're interested in both but it meets our staffing as well um one
016of the offerings we have is American sign language do we have a teacher for that we don't currently so the course Catal offers um what we have had approved by the curriculum advisory Council um so we don't currently have a teacher for that we're interested in engaging what the interest is but we do not currently have a sign language teacher okay I mean I'm just concerned because then we're going to have to hire new teachers right but we let go of teachers but we're going to have to hire teachers for this so so the catalog includes courses that have been previously approved it doesn't necessarily mean that students are going to CH they're going to choose from that future me form um it may be that American Sign Language isn't there based on what the
017interest is okay and then the last thing is about resources just for instance I saw jewelry there has to have material are we going to have the budget to have material for some of these electives so the principals um and the directors work with me and with Miss batti in the process um as far as supplies it's in the budget so we make sure there are supplies for any course that runs so it's already budgeted for it will be when we do our our Bud for this year okay all right thank you any other questions yeah I go ahead Caroline is it in your plan as far as um you know introducing all the content to the students for every student to have one opportunity to sit like individually with their guidance counselor to make
018sure that they understand their options and that it's being you know channeled appropriately yes okay I I also had a question about resources actually um I didn't have a chance to follow up with Dr tber I had heard that um maybe we didn't have cameras for photography and drones for drones like even this year so has that been resolved and as far as I know we definitely have drones um the cameras for the digital photography you asked about digital photography that's what you said so um for the digital photography a number of years ago they were purchasing digital cameras the technology changed so quickly that they were finding they needed to replace them frequently they realized that phone cameras um actually are almost always equally good and it was less expensive so they do have
019cameras for any students who may need them but most students are using their phones so when we do do the budgeting we look at whether a small number of Cam need to be replaced each year okay I okay I thought I had read like learning about developing and like the whole process of Photography so I'm not how does the cam photography it's more like um so I will check the description but you could it's more like the um the apps that they use to actually create photos for different purposes to modify them based on their needs okay and I also noticed ruler is mentioned and we got the preliminary results it doesn't look promising that ruler is very successful and it's in the height so how is that going to be addressed it's in the
020course it's in the back of the catalog we edit that if we need maybe just edit it out okay thank you any other questions or comments uh how are the students like introduced to Bose is that worked into this uh so there are trips to Bose I think the first one has already happened for the year so that students can actually tour the facilities and hear about the programs but then the Bose's counselors also come in and meet with students they have uh presentations and videos where other students speak about their experiences so that they can hear about the different programs that are offered bosis also offers open houses that we advertise so students can go with their families in the evenings and on weekends and does that start with 10th grade uh the introduction
021of the program or where students are scheduled the introduction of the program like when when they start to learn about it because it starts in 11th grade right right so the 10th graders who are considering their scheduling options for 11th grade would participate in those thank you I just have one more question have has the district ever explored bringing in any career ready opportunities within the district I think I read somewhere I think it was Hemstead and maybe wine danch or maybe it was Roosevelt like they had a barber something with Barber and they some of the districts have like El electrical do have we explored those opportunities inhouse I can't speak to knowing whether it's been explored in the past but not not now it hasn't we have not explored that in the last
022few months okay thank you any other questions um yes um do we have ample Spanish speaking social workers and guidance counselors to work with our students to make sure they have a full understanding of the course catalog uh as far as guidance counselors we have two Spanish-speaking guidance counselors at the high school and they do uh work mostly with Spanish speaking students thank you any other questions okay thank you thank you thank you so Dr T I'm GNA turn over to you thank you at this time I will provide my superintendent report for the December 11th Board of Education combined session meeting and we would certainly like to start by celebrating our student and staff achievements Miss Wilshire and the amville Memorial High School student council and I must applaud our student council they are
023excellent leaders and under her leadership they are doing great things they recently hosted a highly successful blood drive in the high school gymnasium this event saw 107 donors register and an impressive collection of 71 pints of blood thanks to the outstanding efforts of our student council these contributions will help more than 200 patients in local hospitals notably it is great this collection reflects an increase of more than 20 pints compared to the high school's previous drive and this is a testament to their hard work and dedication of our students and staff last night Park Avenue Elementary School music department hosted a beautiful holiday concert at the high school the performances were a wonderful Showcase of our students talents filling the season with joy and F for our community additionally members of the Board of Education
024and superintendent cabinet attended the Western suffi bosis holiday dinner it was a special evening where we had the opportunity to see our high school students shine through their fashion and architectural designs and culinary experience their work exemplifies the creativity and skill cultivat within their CTE programs in W andan I had the honor of helping to bring the barbering program which is a CTE program and we hope here in Amityville we can expand our CTE offerings in years to come we have currently administered three key surveys across the district to support our continuous Improvement efforts the ruler survey to measure our social emotional learning the culture and climate survey to assess our school climates and the district goals survey which will be released at 7 a.m. tomorrow morning we would like to thank our staff for
025working with our students and taking the time to participate and give your feedback as it will guide our decisions in moving forward and we will share our findings with the board and community upon their completion I would like to take a moment to just address some misinformation that was not released in its totality to our community regarding the debt of the amville Union Free School District the $22 million that was communicated as a debt represents the net position or the unfunded portion of our commitment to providing entire health insurance over time it's the difference between what we currently have set aside and the estimated future cost of these benefits under governmental Accounting Standards Board which is known as gasby all districts are required to report the OPB liabilities on their financial statements this has been
026implemented since the year of 2018 most districts including Amityville show a negative net position due to the scale of OPB liabilities and let me Define what that means so that I don't misrepresent OPB is it other poloy benefit other post employment benefits their liability does not represent an immediate cash obligation but rather a long-term projection of future cost I would like to acknowledge our Board of Education and administration and all who worked very hard to ensure that the 2023 24 school year ended with a fund balance of almost 700,000 coming from a deficit of over 3 million I would like to provide an update on Northeast Elementary School Northeast Elementary School a Historic Landmark in the North amville Community commun houses our youngest scholars in a high quality 3K program I would like to provide
027an update on our efforts to maintain and enhance the program's quality while addressing Financial challenges currently we receive funding for 85 upk students and we serve 127 utilizing seven classes rooms the state provides approximately $587,000 annually to support this program however projections indicate that it will cost over 1.5 million to operate Northeast as it currently stands for the 2526 school year to address this Gap we have been exploring additional Revenue opportunities including leasing or renting unused classroom space within the building we have met with vendors who are also uh leasing from neighboring districts and are receiving quotes as such applications for 4410 programming have been submitted those applications have been returned to us for further revision further revision around finances computations and are in the process of being resubmitted there was not necessarily A due
028date but a time frame in which these must be completed however with the 4410 the financial implications will not be clear until approvals are finalized there is estimation that perhaps if we service one child based upon that particular child's needs we may get a reimbursement of $220,000 $155,000 or $40,000 so we are calculating what those ranges would look like for us and they're simply estimates and ranges that money also from the 4410 has to pay for the operation of the 4410 program it does not appear that it will be a big Revenue but it would certainly be a way to serve more students and to cover the operation of the programs we are also exploring the possibilities and there have been some preliminary discussions of relocating kindergarten to Northeast and re-evaluating the use of portable
029classrooms at Northwest we understand the significant impact these decisions have on families and our community our Focus remains on increasing revenues and I must applaud Miss Olivia buatti and the team for increasing revenues through peeling back IEPs peeling back Medicare costs Medicaid cost and peeling back those areas where we can increase our uh claims and our reimbursement values and we have been decreasing expenses as you know one of our goals is to decrease expenses by 2% to make the cost of operating Northeast sustainable a decision is anticipated by mid April aligning with the budget adoption timeline for the 2526 school year I would like to pause for a moment and acknowledge Mr Carl Frasier our Financial Consultant Mr Frasier has been a gentle extraordinaire and an expert in the area of finances he has provided
030assistance and guidance under my Administration and I am grateful for your impartation your long hours your wise counsel your Keen Eye and guiding us through the process of navigating Financial solvency thank you for your continued support and commitment to our students and staff and together we strive to provide exceptional opportunities while maintaining fiscal responsibility we look forward to our continued collaboration your Insight and guidance as we move forward thank you Dr T with the 4410 um you just gave I'm sorry in regards to 4410 you gave a pretty good detail information about 4410 just for clarification this is Grant in the 4410 just for clarification the 4410 is money that we have to put out can you explain that real clearly so they'll understand yes um when we spend the money we seek reimbursment for
031the monies that we have spent based on a formula that is set by the state so we have to go out there and negotiate our re urement rate and our cost is reimbursed at that rate and in in terms of reimburse reimbursement rate you're referring to reimbursement for the students who attend the 44 and so this is from New York State the 4410 yes okay any excuse me other questions from any other the board members seeing none I'm going to move forward right to community import regarding board board agenda item so this is community import regarding anything that's on the board agenda at this point in time n wolf president ATA uh 100 Court North Drive just checking because I don't know whether or not this is the this was in the superintendent's report um
032so I guess that would be included as an agenda item speaking to the $22.5 million um I I think I'm just going to go through with my questions first and then comment so that I know that I'm on a timer so first and foremost you did answer my first question is that whether or not this is something that only Amityville experiences um we do know that this is if this is associated with um health insurance or payments that are happening in retirement um this must be something that every school district um has to have as it relates to because they all pay into retirement we actually pay the state minimum so there are some districts that pay 100% of insurance into retirement 80 70 whatever the case may be we do 35 and 50 so
033um the wherever it is wherever it is that this originated from um I just think that there wasn't enough information in terms of where it is that they got that um as it relates to the fact that we are obviously not operating a 22.5 million deficit I don't think that we could and be open um so I I think we should acknowledge that um the other part that I have is that how does this impact or would this impact the tax levy or a general budget at all so that's a question um it it does seem that this information uh came out publicly all of a sudden as soon as there was conversation and talk about people trying to um prevent Northeast from closing and teachers picketing um as result of not having a fair
034contract um if this was a huge concern I this information has been here for a while why yesterday I really don't know um and it didn't seem to come out all over the place it just happened to be P from Facebook and I think it was Amityville magazine if I'm correct um so I'm actually I'm actually wondering um where is that in where would that information have have come from um because um it definitely seems as though there's a there's an issue somewhere in leadership as it relates to this information in addition to before I run out really quick um as I said before that this seems to be an attempt um to create a narrative that we don't have the money to negotiate contracts for all staff or or go through the necessary processes
035to make sure that we do everything that we possibly can to see what options are available to us for Northeast because if there are not then that means that we would be going into a second year of accessing teachers and other staff it also um it also means that we're going to get rid of more teachers not be able to fill the open positions that we do have because of how it is that we unfortunately had to handle accessing the first time and then what are we doing with the building so we're going to get rid of all those people and then still have to pay to maintain the building so anytime that you have the answers to those questions um especially as a results to the general fund impact the tax levy and especially
036since this is something that's not brand new it had to have occurred for a long period of time even during those times when the tax levy was 0% or 6% or any percentage other than 2% so I just want to make sure how this would impact overall community and school so thank you uh Mr Williams for your question the OPB liabilities are reported on the statement of net position is which was reported I'm certainly going to ask the business office to assist as needed but it does not directly affect general fund or the tax levy but it does indirectly influence the district's Financial Planning and so uh it impacts our long-term borrowing cost um our credit ratings um potential increasing the financial strain on what is already a fragile budget but is the district in
037a position to negotiate in good faith with our hardworking teachers yes we are all right um the other the other uh piece to that is um how did our how did that cost get so high and that's that's really what it is I'm talking about I understand that insurance has gone up over the years um but is our cost more than other districts who are paying more into retirement for their retirees and if so how is that possible so Mr Frasier I know we were talking today about other districts and what it cost um Miss batti could you allow him to just sort of explain what's happening in some of the other districts because we began to research this ourselves yes this this amount has been at this level for many years it's as you
038had indicated it's not an operating deficit it's a calculation this opab other post employment benefits it's an actuarially developed number and all school districts are required to have this on their books and in a minute I'll give you some examples of what some school districts numbers are but it's a actuarially developed number based on a census the actuary takes of the employees who are currently in the district and those are the re retired it looks at rates the rates in our contracts it looks at many things to determine the number that's calculated and it's an estimated number if you look at last year's report it also had $70 million uh calculated number so this liability has the effect of reducing or not reducing but uh determining the net $22.5 million that you see as a
039net deficit again it's a number that is required by gby for districts to place on their balance sheet I did go through and look at a few school districts to give you sense of what other just move the mic down a little bit for me thank you sorry what other districts are experienced I'm not going to identify those school districts but I can tell you there's one District in Nassau County who has an OPB liability just move move OPB liability of1 m28 for their their their net deficit is 104 million that's one example another example I'll go the East End where this district has a little under students their liability was 22 million or a net deficit of 17 million so it's across the board there may be just a few districts that don't have
040the deficit and there that's because those districts have a high asset number on their books and they also have restricted fund balance that's very high so the the assets on that book offsets some of the cost of this post-employment benefits to give them a positive um net net benefit understood I'm I'm out of time right yeah you are okay thank you thank you thank you very much my input is regarding agenda item 401 so my question is um in a previous meeting specifically the November 20th meeting it was mentioned that in order to the the the steps that needed to be taken in order to create this committee for Northeast and if I heard correctly it was mentioned that a resolution would need to be done by legal but I don't see a resolution in
041the anywhere in the agenda so why what's the status of that the status of it is that the Board of Education needs to discuss it further and that's why under um old business has a discussion if a decision is made to create a committee then we can adopt the resolution and we can have a resolution and add it to the agenda for tonight okay because I I thought at the November 20th meeting it was decided that a committee would would be created was it was that not the case um there's more discussion that the board of education is going to be doing on that that matter okay and and regards to something that was said in the superintendent report regarding the 4410 uh also at that meeting someone I believe it was from the uh
042ATA suggested that the board reach out to some of the other districts who have the 4410 4410 and to find out to ask questions and to inquire about if in fact that would benefit Northeast so did anyone on the board reach out to neighboring districts to find out you know any more information if it would in fact benefit North East so it wouldn't be from the board it would be the superintendent so I can ask Dr Talbert thank you Miss Stevenson for your question uh prior to that discussion administration had already reached out to uh a Nassau County District who was implementing the program had had meetings gotten a cost analys from them from them and in addition there have been two additional school districts uh that we have contacted and had conferences with around
043the operations of their program so yes thank you so was it decided that you feel that the 4410 would be a benefit in regards to Northeast there are benefits to having the 4410 program we submitted the two applications in terms of bringing in the kind of Revenue it would be one stream but it would not be the premier Revenue stream to close the gap that we're looking to close okay thank you hi good after evening mateline quintine mccan um figure backing on the committee or so-called committee am I to understand that this committee is a new York state law 402a for closing Public Schools so if the procedure for closing a school building you need at least six months in advance of proposed school closing so my question is why are we trying to put
044forth a committee we don't need one because we're not trying to close this school so we do homework and we look and so that's with the New York state law 402a or a committee which one of your trustees is so pushing to push this closing of the public school and mentioning this committee so we don't need a committee we need Solutions and we need something to say that this is how we going to structure and how we going to make sure that northeast school which is a premier educational building that has been doing its level best and more than level best are excellent in teaching our young scholars as they move forward we also have one of your community members that live in the district one of your trustees and while she's not fighting for
045this is beyond my beyond my comprehension so let's get it together let's move forward let's make a plan and let's have a committee of people to get together to see how we can push forth this agenda of keeping northeast school open sound like a plan to me and let's see there was one other thing oh that 4410 um so it's it's being worked on or was worked on and was come back and it's being resubmitted again all right and I just want to make one other small comment then I'll probably come back again to the mic but if it's if it's is it connected to the agenda um in regards to to northeast school yeah just just okay because we're getting to the end of the input from okay on item so I'm G to
046probably have to ask the board to um extend the time time on agenda items because we're up to we're pass even though we haven't reached the 8 minute on the clock we're already pass the the 15 minutes so we just need to make sure that we get so I'm just just relax relax relax I'm just asking the board if we can extend comments on regarding boorder agenda items for just another 15 minutes that that's all I'm asking okay we have to just keep to the three minutes clock motion second okay so hold on Chris neron is first Wendy canestro is second so we're going to extend questions regarding agenda items for 15 minutes all those in favor I I motion carries 70 so so just can you just reset it to to 15 so that
047way okay so my little 27 seconds I got left yes I just want to make sure that we um try to even Explore why we doing this 40410 um to bring uh kindergarten back to northeast school evening superintendent good evening school board members um Sydney Martin 45 North baldon Place Mass P New York um I have a question uh referring to the article put on his Facebook page are there any members of the school board who are admins for this Facebook page I I don't know that pardon I said I don't know that not is anybody want to volunteer is anybody on this on the board an admin for this Facebook page right so the Amityville magazine that put this information out so I I don't know and I don't think any board memb is
048going to speak about at this point in time so's let's just because to me this is kind of is was this public information superintendent yes yes it was in the 2023 24 audit report okay thank you um getting back to uh School you talked about leasing are you not willing to lease to any kind of charter school is that off the table yeah it's kind of counterproductive to really to lead to a charter school because then it's taking revenue for us so I just want to make sure great and um what so your plan for the building if it's empty is to is to lease out so that that's good and it's not going to a charter school and um I just want to know that we support you keeping this school open and to
049do whatever you need to do um we're willing to do that as a community and we support our teachers thank you hello my name is Bishop Walter willly I'm the pastor of the prayer Tabernacle Church right here in amville amville is a community of people that should show a concern for everyone therefore this board that we are elected should also have the same concern for the needs of our community when one hurt we all hurt when one Rejoice we all Rejoice so therefore the north pre school that's been here over 70 years that's been a beacon life for our community is one of the oldest schools in the community yet is one of the schools that has never been remodeled in over 50 years Park West I mean Northwest Park Avenue the high school even
050the junior high school they all been renovated in the last 10 years but Northeast which is is on Prime land which have the potential to do great things has never been looked at to build up its building and yet some of the funds went to Northwest that's a shame so there we at the community understand that the board has a obligation but the concern is this are you looking at other options for what is important to our community because what we do today will affect us on tomorrow and further on down the road so I want to know is there a fiveyear strategy plan the board has in plan to talk about today the next year the next two years the next three years because a strategy CL would give us an idea what can
051be the potential of the future of our school and our community a school is part of community and which is part of the family and again we need everyone on board what's best the best interest for this community this is about people so therefore we pray that it's not a hidden agenda that somebody stone in there to make this school be a priority for someone else so therefore northeast school right of the community from Sunrise Highway to 110 to Great Nick road to ory AB that's a block of where most of the people that live in that Community if you close it down it would affect a community would cause so much pain and hurt and you don't want to do that in the community thank you hello my name is Deborah Kenny 38 years
052ago I moved into Amityville northeast school had a pre kindergarten program already implemented there was a teacher they were made maybe a few crayons maybe a few coloring books and a few puzzles that was it the children were timid and it was just a very sad sight so some of my friends and I got together shipped in our own money went and bought some toys appropriate for pre we began socializing with the children in little groups we had a meeting to explain to parents the reason for pre kindergarten was not for Academia it was for social socialization skills to be developed thank you also at that time this let's face it we all know that this was a racially divided community and anyone who says it wasn't there was certain people that would go certain
053places and others wouldn't go this brought parents together this made it a social thing for parents as well as the children I had children in there after we had uh the teacher first teacher Donna left Jane linan became the teacher she was great but there was so many children there were about 24 children in the classroom and it was in the uh cafeteria at Northeast School these children were so timid that they didn't want to leave whoever it was that dropped them off and they would sit there like little clams and not say a word we got them to become friendly with other students we would individually try to go to each one of them and take them to another student we wanted them to be sociable it wasn't learning the alphabet then it was
054to let them be sociable the program was so successful that Dr uh Mr bahensky I mean I'm sorry Jim Hicks was the principal at the time Jim Hicks gave us the biggest hugs and said it was the most progress he had seen in this town in the school district in his career he was so impressed with the program we would run Christmas drives Thanksgiving food drives clothing drives and all the parents participated every parent was there to donate something even if they didn't have five cents they bring a box of peanuts or something but it was the idea that we were coming together as a community which we need now more than ever and I would really hope that you will do everything in your power to keep my pet project the pre kindergarten together
055and Northeast School safe because we need that we need that school thank you good evening I'm coming U my name is Heather Palmore uh 21 summerlan amville I've been a resident of Amityville for almost 55 years um I was 2 weeks old when my parents moved into Amityville unfortunately or fortunately both my parents were Educators in Nassau County in Malin and Roosevelt and it was a time when you had a choice as to where you would attend school if your parent worked at the school so I attended mour public schools and I make sure that I mention that because I'm going to loop back to why I want to mention mour for a second although I did not attend school here in Amityville I was very much aware of the advocacy and the work that
056was put in by what we would call now our ancestors um who fought very hard for busing at Northeast and besides that there is a undercurrent here where there are a lot of issues that are going on that no one wants to speak about and from the beginning of time and this country was founded on was racial oppression and I'm going to speak truth to power because it's the elephant in the room and nobody wants to talk about it but we're gonna talk about it and the reason why we're going to talk about it is because systematically by Design from the beginning of time education of black and brown students has not been a priority and the fact that we are standing here 55 years later still talking about this is a shame it is
057a shame I want to point out something to all of you you may not know this very few of you know this but many of you don't as an attorney who practiced here on Long Island about 20 years ago 15 years ago rather I was appointed by Regent Reger Roger Tillis to the school board at Roosevelt and if anybody knows the history behind Roosevelt there was a huge deficit and they closed the board they took everybody on the board and they removed them for financial impropriety because they were not managing the funds the way that they were supposed to be doing it and they brought in people from the outside people who did not live in the community to make decisions for their community and I was one of them and what started off as
058a deficit turned into a surplus and an entire new District full of innovative state-ofthe-art schools the way that that happened though and I implore the leadership the board members in conjunction with your attorneys to make sure that you are working with the community to get all Benny's attention it's all Benny who's going to eventually write that check to make sure that the funds are here that's why we elect elected officials that's why they are there to advocate for us so we're all fighting and going back and forth about what this is ultimately they're the ones who are going to be B baing you out but what sadden me more than anything I came here today to talk about Northeast what sadden me more than anything is to look at all of these teachers here that
059are working without a contract that's a problem that's a problem Bor that's a problem and your children may not be in that school district they may not be here right now but their parents in here who have to send their kids to this school every day that are depending on each and every one of these teachers to come in here and give their best effort and you have an obligation to make sure that each and every one of these teachers and administrators feel appreciated both can be true and with that I will leave you but I'm asking you to work together with your elected officials to get it done thank you thank you um I just I just want to make sure that because we only have about maybe four minutes left and the key
060is this in so so I just I just want to I just want to make sure that we get like the last three people I think the three people of the last three people that are there to ask questions regarding the agenda items only and then after the the third person I think there's three there we're going to we'll stop there thank you yep um good evening school board members Amityville residents and concerned parents my name is Samantha Francois and I'm here to read a statement on behalf of assembly woman Kimberly jeanpierre the assembly members comments are as follows over the past year I have worked diligently with the district to help address their fi fiscal issues I have closely monitored the situation engaged with board members parents Administration Western suff bosies and the State
061education department I can assure you that the next assembly member quani oero will also work closely with all stakeholders in amville school district he is well informed about the financial challenges facing the amneville school district and I will provide as much additional information as possible during the transition period during the budget process in Albany I received news of the school district's budget shortfalls and more specifically I learned of the potential closure of Northeast Elementary School this was extremely alarming and I knew immediate action was necessary I reached out to assembly leadership to ensure funding was secured to prevent the closure as a result $2 million was allocated to the amville school district with $175,000 allocated for a Financial Consultant to provide critical guidance to the district $100,000 to restore much-needed student clubs and the remaining
062funds go towards the North East Elementary School I specifically stated these intentions for the fund to the super to the district superintendent to the school board members and also incoming school board members who inquired about the purpose of the funding the state budget does not specify specific line items but I was clear that the intention for these funds was to benefit the northeast school pay for a fiscal consultant consultant and Student Activities closing Northeast Elementary would damage the foundation of our community and eliminate its Rich history disclosure would be a step backwards resulting in the loss of valuable jobs it would also eliminate the prek program which has been vital to our community research shows that children who attend pre kindergarten programs are more likely to succeed in high school and college this program also
063offers early intervention services with both save the school district money long-term and indefinitely develop care developmental concerns earlier the prek program has been invaluable to our hardworking parents in amneville and its central location makes it accessible to all residents I must also Express the concerns regarding Mr Fraser's resignation through my conversations with the State education department Mr Fraser received the highest praise and it extremely qualified for this position as a former amneville resident he welcomed the opportunity to assist the school I have been made aware of allegations of mistreatment that led to his resignation if these allegations are true it is deeply concerned learning I have the utmost confidence in Mr Frasier's ability to help write the ship in amneville it is essential that a fiscal consultant work effectively with the business official individuals such
064as Mr Fraser are highly skilled and can navigate Financial challenges I implore the board to reflect on these claims and ensure that all district Personnel are treated with fairness and the respect they deserve additionally I must note that the current Foundation aim formula is woefully inadequate this State Legislature has been taking steps toward fixing the inequities in the formula these inequities such as outdated income ratios and insufficient funding for special needs students had adversely affected the amville school district this is why I advocate for a study of the outdated formula and recommendations based on those findings have recently been released I hope these recommendations can bring meaningful changes for our district we must all work together to address the issues facing the amville school district close closing the removal the um closing the school and
065removing the official consultant are steps in the wrong direction we need to find alternative solutions to these challenges without compromising our children's education or hoarding the community I urge you to consider other cost-saving measures as these actions will likely have long- lasting negative impacts finally I would like to note that I will no longer be elected office December 31st my commitment to our community will always remain and my door will always be open if you're you have any immediate questions or concerns please reach out to my office thank you for allowing me to address the current state of the amville school district thank Youk good evening Andrew IOD 24 Ira Court Amityville New York um I wanted to address the board on a couple things obviously with the um potential closing of northeast school I'm
066a amville alumni I live my whole life I'm an amville graduate and that's a vital vital vital vital educational foundational piece I still remember my teacher from Northeast my nephew just graduated from that program so we really liveing proof and we really really really need that program and you can see it speaking volumes we here as a community so whatever it is that we got to do we got to start getting ahead of the bus if we got to start tapping in with the elected officials ahead of time if we got to start doing local fundraising if we got to whatever we got to do to bridge the gap we got to that happen um another issue I wanted to address was um I run the B Park summer league I also run the Mac
067Academy that's a student athlete incubator that's right here in um Amityville it's an acronym for making athletes career knowledgeable so it's like a One-Stop shop where student athletes could come get the athletic training but at the same time come get career advice come get civically engaged when we say civically engaged we teach him about politics not just the presidential election as you can see our local off officials is heavily involved assembly woman John Pierre kind of saved the day so we trying to get our kids heavily invested onto that but I said all of that to say I requested the gym on this um the I requested the gym on a Saturday I requested the gym last summer every Saturday just for a rain sight when we wanted to use it and I was denied
068because I understand um our school was in a financial situation we couldn't maintain the facilities on the weekend also we run an annual Halloween hoop Fest that I wanted to do I was denied that Saturday I was denied to high school and I was denied to middle school and um now I see December 14th the amville soccer club is um being being up for it on a Saturday as well so um and I offered to pay for the gym we had to go to Long Beach and I had to pay for the gym in Long Beach also had to pay for transportation to get kids out there so um if that's the the the the situation where the gym is available could you let us know the price and why is it available to them
069and it wasn't avail ailable to the Mac Academy in closing again I didn't want to finish off with it being about a use of facility thing but I want to finish off speaking about the facility and the importance of Northeast in our neighborhood again I want to speak about the you know the importance of the educational for our kids of that age they're vibrant they're young that's like I feel like is the most important thing and kind of bothers me that we even speaking about closing that school it bothers me that we even speaking about closing that so whatever it is that we got to do again let's get on the same page because we can't close that building there is there an answer on why I didn't get the building at Saturday and why
070they got it all right so um when your request was was put in at that point in time um you honored the request of the Board of Education where we had decided from last year that we were not going to use the facilities on the weekends to minimize our cost now this request has come in and now this request has been what changed what like what policy changed for them to get it on a Saturday or like was there a price or anything like that what Chang that they was able to get it on a Saturday and the Mac Academy wasn't able to get it on a Saturday or Sunday I think you you just you it was some of the trustees that came forward and asked for it to to be placed on the
071agenda and when I believe when you submitted your request you respected what the Board of Education had previously requested which was not to use the facilities and weekends because we were trying to minimize our cost there were trustees who requested for this to be placed on the agenda for this time and that's why it's here can I clarify something we have can I just clarify something I respect were we were requesting that all applicants that applied for weekends were brought forward and this was the only one that was brought forward I believe we asked for somebody to reach out to you so the other thing just just to make it clear that when last year when the budget was being done the board had decided that at that point in time that we were not
072going to utilize the school on the weekend because of the course connected to custodians and security guards and so when your request came in that's what the board had you know the press came in based on what the board had decided previously that's how the administration had responded so when this request came in and it came before um to to the to the cabinet when the request came in for the amville soccer and when it came before the cabinet the cabinet originally said no then there was questions that were brought up about whether or not why can't it be done so that's what happened you you respected the request and then it was pushed back from other organizations so can I ask the board members that you know push that request um what was the
073difference with the Amityville soccer club and the Mac Academy wa we don't when did you submit your request um I submitted my request last summer for the the use of the whole summer we usually do that summer like in June we requested for it in June but I probably submitted it like probably a few months before that then this one that we requested in October I submitted it in I want to say August but I submitted it to miss Deborah biscotti that's what I usually use and I it was I was informed that she wasn't working there no more then I submitted it to the the the right one and I was told that we wasn't using the facilities on weekend correct and just just for clarification just for clarification as and I'll let Megan
074speak as I stated before when the board did the budget last year the board had decided that we were not going to use the facilities on the weekend to minimize the cost when you submitted your application for October for use in October and even for the summer months the request was not granted because of the same reason that when it went to um Central Administration based on what the board had previously stated that the facilities were not going to be utilized and that was that's what I'm not to cut you off Miss Johnson that was that was October this is December what like what was the switch up have to say that the board did not see your requests it never made it to the board the the board did not what happens in May
075you got four new trustees that didn't agree to change the facility use Poli policy the facility use policy never changed you can use the facility on Saturdays so we never received your request Miss Miss that's false because I have emails from Miss buatti and I have emails from um the the superintendent Miss not Board of Education we it never was brought to the board of education to vote on so who was it that denied my thing if the board because I got it to where it says the board doesn't didn't approve it uh I'm going to jump in here second too so so I am a big proponent of the children of Amityville being able to use our facilities I also know that you do a lot of work if I could speak I know
076that you do a lot of good work in Amityville and this came this was brought to our attention that the soaka wanted to use it at that time we specifically asked Administration to reach out to you to resubmit for any Saturday use so that it can come before us to consider so what changes you have more trustees that want the children to use the facilities now they you know I'm a proponent of you know I I don't believe in double taxation or whatever that because we already pay taxes but there is the opportunity to have a fee if it has to be imposed if we don't have the money for instance if you're taking the children of Amityville and you're paying for them to go to Long Beach that doesn't make a lot of sense
077to me you should be able to paying for the gym and Long Beach you should in my I'm only one person this is my personal opinion I think you should be able to use the facility in Amityville having said that Sunday is double overtime so we have to be cognizant of that so it was a discussion that was going to be up tonight I was surprised that I didn't see an application from you on this because we did ask them to reach out to you to resubmit because I did the event at Long Beach I'm going to submit for February now but I I don't have anything going on at the moment no I understand but what what what Miss mesman is saying is that stopped before it came to us we didn't see it
078we didn't know about it I want to add to this it looks when you look at the agenda it looks like we're all set to approve soccer where we've already rejected basketball don't take anything we haven't gotten to that conversation yet that's later in the agenda so and I don't want you guys to reject uh soccer like I'm all for all sports I just want to know why was it that I was rejected and they wasn't well to we so we have to revisit decision that was made last spring I'm amville alumni I want long Isen Championship here too I was all long Isen I got a full scholarship to Columbia State Community College I went to Cumberland University I graduated from there with a bachelor's in health and PE Fitness and Wellness I run
079a Youth Organization I got the biggest basketball tournament in Long Allen right now so like I we we love sports we know they're important and we were looking forward to having an opportunity tonight to revisit a decision that was made last spring for all the kids we just haven't gotten to that conversation yet you brought it up and it kind of spurred us to start talking about it but all the facts are not out there yet I don't think we can cut the line in the agenda but we were expecting to discuss it for the benefit of all the kids not just the soccer club but I do want to leave with the facts that I submitted two two submission requests and for for a for this for the summer for June July August and
080I submitted one for October in in uh September as well so I just that's that's the facts and I was I was denied so I'm just gonna I'm just going to just say one go ahead listen just you did Andrew you did all the right things maybe the timing was a little bit off but we did not see the application I knew there was I didn't know if they pulled it or what and then the new board decided to try to get amville soccer in I you know we we have to discuss it we just haven't done it we we didn't do it in executive session we have to do it in open but um apply again I you want and we may even turn it down we might turn soccer down also so we
081are fiscally I appreciate you guys I definitely submit I appreciate you guys I just wanted some clarity thank you and I just wanted to add that I'm glad you came up thank you not a problem not a problem that yes the board had decided no facility use however the narrative narrative seemed to change when we had board members bring up the soccer league so that is how it initiated with the Sak leag well thank you go next next person thank you Andrew next person Madame President prti Madam superintendent I am Veron I'm Dr Veronica Henry 13 m l in amville New York I'm not a stranger here I've been in this room many times and I advocating for students providing service for students and tonight I stand there opposed to the shutting or the closing
082of Northeast West Northeast School uh Elementary School we need to educate our the future and our students or the Future Okay early childhood education should be a must to all all students it is so important in their developmental stage skills of their social skills their emotional skills and their cognitive skills secondly it benefits the family earning power Right facts children with pre educa precare education are more likely to graduate to complete high school graduate enter college graduate from college and earn higher wages in during their career path I could go on and on on I'm a retired educator and College admin ministrator and I know that it's very important to educate our our children pre if we close Northeast now considering what's happening and maybe forcasting for the Department of Education the next thing will
083be closing the other schools we can't let that happen we have to be the voice of our young kids our children our youth they remember I've been in Northeast um Elementary School many times you know as a role model for the district and I know you know about um these events that the school district hosts and couple of years ago I was with um in the school in the in the school and I gave a little talk about the heart and everything because you know science is my is my thing and so couple of years after I met the students that was in the store and this young kid said he was about at that time though when I met him after preschool pre pre kindergarten he probably was about going into middle school and
084he saw me I he said I know you and I'm saying where did I know him from and he said you came to our school and you taught us how to jump up and the how the heart beats and race and then I said to him what size is the heart and he said you're like your thumb so they remember so it's for their their formative years we need to pres preserve that for kids and so I I urge you I urge the board I urge the uh budget people to go back to your uh committee your budget um committee and rework your budget because this will not work education is really at a very pivotal point we need to protect you that we can start um closing schools thank you so much thank you
085moving on to agenda item can I do agenda item 2 A1 to 2 A7 Al together yes right have a motion for agenda items 2 A1 to 287 please motion second Chris naron is first Wy kestal second any question regarding any of these items I don't have a question uh the comments that I sent were uh updated in the AG in the minutes um I just with the new district clerk I'd love that we would um indicate a time in the video so it's easy to go back to like we kind of know like see the video for discussion but it would be good to I know we talked about this months ago but to time stamp going forward all right thank you any other comments on on this item these items see hear none
086all those in favor I my motion carries 70 can I um do agenda items let me do them some of them together well 3 B1 um Lisa can I just make a comment I think we might be able to do first and Final on number five yeah that's what I'm trying to yeah yeah all right so I would like to do for agenda item 3 2B one 2 3 4 five 6 7 8 and even number 10 um can we do them as um Second and final reading either third and final reading all right so if everyone's is everyone's okay doing item 3 2b1 to 2 B10 as final reading final for all final for all second Leslie qu is first Winnie canestro is second so these are final readings for all these um policies
087all those in favor I I motion carries 70 um can I have a is it a motion to table agenda item 2c1 legal John John yes yeah Kev motion to table agenda item 2c1 please move it Wendy canes first Carol C off second um all those in favor I I motion carries 70 I have a motion for agenda item 2c2 please motion Chris naron is first second Carol fan Caroline fan a second I just want to say um once again with Carl is it's been a pleasure working with you you've been with us and you've been an asset for us this is something just how I feel um you came with a a lot of um accolades and you have been very beneficial to US during this time frame and and I'm very sorry to
088see you go I feel the same way and I really wish e e e Janine Okana as assistant director of PPS and special education effective date January 13 2025 on or about certification status of sdl with a rate of compensation of $143,000 so that's not that can't be an on or about date that has to be a date on on on on yes sorry on January 13th on January 13th okay all those in favor I I motion carries 70 can I do 3b3 all the way down to no can we do 3 3 to six separately okay can I have a motion for G item three B3 to 3 B5 no six sorry six second right um Les request is first Caroline Bannon is second any questions regarding these agenda items yes uh just looking
089for clarity Dr Talbert you explained in your email that this is this position of the family or parent liaison it's a change from a title three program which is for enl students to Title One so to clarify the position was in place last year and it was funded through title 3 uh with an emphasis on reaching out to bilingual families we want to expand that to reach out to all families to align with the district goal number four to increase our parental and Community engagement and so these parental liaz on will be funded through our Title One funding source okay so the source has changed but the budget item or the expens is the same yes okay and do all the liaison speak Spanish no and they do not need to why it it seems
090like you took a program that was expansive you you changed it to make it more inclusive but then made it less so by not having a requirement that they could communicate with the parents so we do have a program called language line that our staff are familiar with and it translates when we communicate with the parents so even if you're not Spanish speaking or Haitian Creole speaking you can communicate with the families through language line so it's like a mechanical thing that changes what you're saying and makes a translation no it's through the telephone you would you like to elaborate it's just a phone number that we call and we get an interpreter on the line so anyone could communicate with parents who speak other languages we also we have a number of ways that
091um non-speakers of languages can communicate with one another so we do have human interpreters who are able to work um we do have uh through parent Square people can communicate and other languages as well when this program was title 3 and it had four Liaisons did they speak Spanish you can elaborate on that may um there were two leaon last year and one was a Spanish speaker and one was not so are we paying for an interpreter then like each time one of these liaison reaches out so there are a number of different resources some have costs and some don't so if we had a human interpreter there would be um a cost incurred for that but if we have a subscription then it's not a aloc cart cost it's just a subscribed cost such
092as language line right language line does have a cost per minute per minute per minute correct so then so then it's going to cost more than potentially the stien right because now we're paying also for an interpreter yes but so communication with families sometimes will have costs attached to it whether it's the liaison doing it or someone else who's doing it yes okay any other questions or comments on these I just feel like how hard would it have been to find Spanish speaking apparently aison all right so I'm sorry but Community can I just you can minimize the the comments from the audience I appreciate it thank you so any other what was your question Caroline I find it unfortunate that for this position of parent Liaisons with 60% of our families being Hispanic we
093don't make it a priority that the liaison speak Spanish but we we don't always have we may not have enough Personnel in the district that that speaks Spanish for the position so I believe so generally when we when we hire you know it is something that's at the Forefront of our minds you know you know what is the role and is speaking Spanish necessary and does the applicant have you know that capacity so I don't think that the second language is always as important as I am sure our administrators looked at the best effective candidates and then if need be interpret interpret comes second but we're looking at the effectiveness of the program and thus that's why certain candidates are selected so can I ask um how was the program measured last year and how
094effective was it and how are we going to measure this program this year and determine how to move forward so last year the liaison ran workshops um for parents some of them were virtual workshops some were inperson um we had moderate attendance at those but the function was a little different it wasn't necessarily drawing people into existing uh parent events but it was creating events for them so it was measured based on attendance it was moderately successful as far as attendance was rated um the goal of this program program is to ensure that families are welcomed have the resources that they need um that contacts are made they know what events are coming up in the community that they know how to access uh parents Square how to access the parent portal um and that
095they see a welcoming face when they enter the building who can help them acclimate for the different events um with all due respect it's December 11th and we've been talking about parent square and we've had Parents Square this is the second year with parent Square so we're talking about needing a stip in position to continue to affiliate our parents with parents square and when I thought we already knew that we had like 98% usage on that app so parents square is one aspect and role that the parent Lea Zone will carry out but the position is much larger than parents Square it is engaging with parents reaching out to parents ensuring that parents can successfully navigate the school system ensuring that they have access to Opportunities working along with our existing social workers guidance counselors
096and other Personnel in the school to ensure that our parents um are properly acclimated and that they can advocate for their students needs and to ensure that our schools are warm open and friendly as they all are but there's a contact person that will help them to navigate that and that would be uh the four persons who are listed here on the agenda this evening lie you want to say something with all due respect just bring to my Clos I'm hoping that this um has nothing to do with the Personnel one of the Personnel that was hired tonight for apparently is on um that has been questioned many times before so that's what I'm hoping so we move forward and yeah can we just move forward on any other comments I agree with you I
097find it very interesting why all of a sudden this question is one a certain person so C can we move forward to vote on this any other the comments can we just move forward because everyone has said something on it already anything new that wants to be added to it right all those in favor I I I anyone opposed I'm sorry I voted for it I just had questions wheny I didn't hear you yeah motion carries 70 can I do agenda item 3 B7 all the way down to you go can you go down to 42 K have a motion for agenda item 3 B7 to 3B 42 motion second second so Winnie canestro is first Chris Nan is second any discussion on this item these items no all those in favor I I motion
098carries 70 can I do agenda items 3B 43 to 106 to 106 alog together yes yes 3B 43 23b 106 Kevin motion for second Carol seaw first Wendy canestro second any questions or comments in regarding these items um yes I have a question I know that we're going into the second term of Leaders of Tomorrow and the um some of the criteria the grant was that surveys had to be sent out to parents and students to um get their feedback has that before we approved this has that happened for the first semester Dr impagliazzo has a survey it's set to go out to both parents and students um starting this Friday and into Monday to Wednesday of next week and when does the next session begin in January okay and that will be shared with
099the board absolutely and as far and also part of the grant is based on attendance so do you have any feedback about attendance because I think we have to meet a criteria for attendance on this um so we track back attendance regularly we do meet with our stately aison so we're okay with attendance but we do use that to inform what we're going to do for the second session so there were a number of um activities that students indicated they were interested in and we ran them but then attendance after the first week fell those are not uh programs that we intend to run again because we do want to maintain the High attendance and we do keep in mind that the goal really is to increase attendance during the school day by developing connections
100with students after school so we know why it's important that they're well attended okay right I just want to make sure that we're in align with the Grant and then lastly for the classes being offered the second semester for the parents for child care will classes be offered the same days the same days as the keep the schedule yeah to keep a schedule for the parents is it going to be offered on the same days that we did the first semester so if parents made arrangements for child care or something are they going to be offered States Monday Wednesday Friday are we going to be consistent with that for the second half of the year so I can't guarantee that in the scheduling because the same classes may not be offered okay right so a
101student may have an interest in a course that's run on a different day you're saying it depends on the on the class so if they choose a different class it might be different correct okay correct okay thank you any other questions or comment all those in favor I hi motion carries 70 can I do 3B 107 to18 Al together um I'd like to discuss 109 so I can do it all together yes K have a motion for agenda item 3B 107 to 3B 118 is this something that needs to be in executive session um no I just want to discuss an exit form I know that uh we requested it from Mrs Wade we didn't have time to discuss it during executive so I'm just requesting that she send it to the board via email
102tomorrow so we can review it thank you okay um just for 3B 109 um for the backup the resignation date uh is affective today which is December the 10th so September 11th I'm sorry so for agenda item 3B 109 the resignation is is effective today which is December the 11 any other questions or comments regarding these items all those in favor I I motion carries 70 um can I do agenda items 3c1 through 3C 4 alog together wait what no what did you say no say that again we need to take them separately yeah all right can I have a motion for Gen item 3c1 please oh okay motion Mo second Caroline Fannon Chris ning any questions or comments regarding this item no all those in favor I I motion carries 70 Kev a motion
103for agenda item 3c2 please motion second wi kestal is first Caroline Fannon is second any questions or comments regarding this item yes yeah oh um go ahead so uh one thing I need to clarify is that I am on the board of amville soccer and my so that is part of the reason that it has gotten pushed onto the agenda but my motivation has not been to solely have this impact amville soccer it was to get the ball rolling so other organizations could hopefully utilize the buildings as well um so that was my motivation for pushing this onto the agenda so we could discuss it and try to figure out a way that if it's not part of the budget and the cost is too much for the district that we figure out some way
104to minimize the cost and try to recover the cost that just needed to clarify that okay I for for me I just I just want to state that um once again last year when we did the the budget one of the things that we and looking at being fiscally responsible one of the things that we said that could help minimize the C minimize expenses in the district was to minimize the use of the facilities on on the weekend I don't have a problem with the facilities being used used on the weekend but I think it needs to be done in a different way I my feeling is that if we're going to open up the facilities on the weekend to organizations then we need to be able to Clearly say to everyone that the board
105of education has now decided to open up the facilities to organizations with the understanding that if for example it doesn't cost more than whatever number so the question that I give to the board that we may not be able to answer right now is so if someone comes to ask use the facilities on a Saturday and a Sunday for example or on a Saturday whatever it may be for a couple of Saturdays and it cost the district $4,000 or $5,000 hypothetically are we going to allow that organization to use the facilities so my it's just my I'm not looking for an answer but I'm just saying that if this is what we're going to do that it need people who apply to use the facilities on the weekend need to have an understanding up to
106what amount is the district is the board education willing to pay for having the facilities open on the weekend I'm all for kids I'm all for the Youth in our district I'm I'm completely for that I'm I'm for a fair process that everyone know knows what are the guidelines to use the facilities on the weekend and what would be the cost to use the facilities on the weekend if it's limited to a number of Saturdays so therefore the if you can use it for seven Saturdays and the course is going to be $3,000 then people who are asking to use the facilities on a weekend know what to ask for so that's my only concern with with doing this at this point in time there's no guidelines that's available for anyone that's going to be
107utilizing in facilities and we're going to open ourselves up in my opinion if we turn someone else down that may be more than 2500 what will happen from there so just my comment here's what I would like to see happen um I have a son who plays soccer on the club I'm not on the board but I have an interest in kids playing soccer I totally think that it we should do what other districts do which is charge for facility use that goes above and beyond what's happening already so I do support charging for use to um the clubs for uh whether it's security heat electric um custodial whatever it takes and yes there needs to be some sort of policy or framework to refer back to to keep it fair in the interest of
108just like making up for lost time now I'm in favor of the soccer club paying the $2,500 so they can play on several weekends and letting everyone know if you're willing to pay send in your application can can I just make one comment this is my comment when the Board of Education last year in a policy committee meeting started to have a discussion about the use of facilities we got such a backlash in terms of charging for the use of facilities We got slammed in a policy committee meeting about the use of facilities and paying for it so I have no problem asking for organizations to pay but it's just very interesting that now we're willing to possibly consider having organizations to pay and I'm telling you I got slammed in changed no but I
109I got it but there I got slammed in that policy meeting and fun I feel you but right but there are people here on this board that that I got slammed by all right for for asking about paying for us we were just having a discussion on it so on social media so my my thing is this is that I have no problem this is a Cy I have no problem times changes boards changes I've got that but it has to be a fair process for every person who puts in an application every person has to know okay you can use it for X number of days and I'm all about change I have no problem not changing but we have to be fair on how we're going to do it that that's all I'm
110saying we oh can um I if I could just weigh in here um as I had said I am a big proponent of the children of Amity being able to use our of the amville school district because it also includes East mapa being able to use our facilities most other districts have if it's 51% um of the roster is of Amityville students we may change that to say 75% or 80% it is 75% 75% okay so if 75% of of the roster is Amityville what I'm saying is we already pay taxes for these facilities the facilities are owned by the taxpayers so then to say to charge them again I think is double taxation right so I'm not saying to charge them um I do think that children benefit when they're playing sports as to
111the gentleman said you have them in a positive environment you're working with them they're mentoring them I think there are so many positives to that and not to mention these students often come to the school district and Excel in the sports once they're here um what I would find problematic is Sundays Sundays is double time that would cost us a tremendous amount of money as for the high school I had asked High School is open for Varsity Sports on Saturdays we already have a custodian we already have a security guard on staff the fees would would not you I I would find it also problematic if we're going to pass on those fees to uh a we or somebody using it if we already have it there right if you're using the other schools and
112they it isn't open because there's no Varsity Sports there that's that's a different different story as for advertising it as for things changing I have to tell you the policy has never changed the policy is the same it's not written anywhere anywhere that you can't use it on Saturdays and Sundays so while that may have been conveyed to the gentleman um I haven't seen it in writing it's not on the policy um in my view you should have been able to apply it should have came before the board for us to decide um the board has changed and when there's a um board members are ever changing right this board won't be here probably in five or 10 years maybe it will but it's always changing so the priorities the perspectives the vision of a
113board also changes my vision of the board is to have the kids of Amityville use our facilities so any other comments on on this item these items because there's two items one is is 2A and 2B and we're talking about um to so I I have a question on this like resolution right here the way it's presented is it that this cost be passed on to the district or the soccer club incur the $2,500 the the district the information that I received is that the soccer club with like to go with the eight Saturdays and so we cost we provided a projected cost to cover the custodian and security Personnel we did not include a cost for heating wear and tear of gym floor or anything of that nature but the projected cost is what
114it would cost the district to have Personnel on site on The Saturdays requested and who's any other any other comments on this um I'm not crazy about them using the high school middle school right the middle school that it is open on every Saturday from 9ine to 3 or 9: to two or is that what your no that was the high school for Varsity Sports no that was later right that was later that was later so just kind of speak a little bit more the soccer is requesting to use the Middle School from 9 to two from 9 to two and what grade level are those children are they the young one you know younger ones because don't they have practices and whatnot or they have training stuff during the week outside they don't have
115the they don't the age is not there so I'm not too sure what what AG is Megan do you know by any chance I'm just well the roster that's listed is just it's not participants specific for that day that's that's just people registered with the leag okay all right any other questions on agend item yeah I I still don't when we vote on it I don't know what I'm voting for are we voting for The District to incur the cost give it away for free or are we voting for the soccer club to pay for it no right now the district is paying for it correct maybe you I'm sorry I'm I'm providing the board with the cost the minimal cost that it would take to approve it the board can approve it uh with
116the cost to the organization or the board can invoke their right to wave the cost it would be the decision of the board is it necessary to have a custodian and a security guard like what's the security guard's role we have to secure the facility so I I want to point out something that I observed I think it was last week I went to pick up my son who was doing interal soccer at the high school and there was a door wide open on the side of the building I've freely walked in there was no sec in sight the coaches didn't know it was there so if there's going to be security there then there should be securing the site where the activity is happening um there was an event that was held by amid
117socer few weeks ago again they were allowed access to the gym at the high school they didn't even know if there was a security guard there so if they're there to secure the site then they should be again securing it where the activity is happening so either there shouldn't be security or they need to do a better job of securing it okay so I think the question that that's really being on the table here is that the resolution is is stating at the cost is roughly um $2500 does it do we want to incur the cost or do we want the dist does do we want the district to pay for it or are we saying that we want the soccer league to pay for can can I make one more comment um you know
118as somebody scrutinizes the expenditures I mean I do go through these a lot I don't really have a problem spending money on children I mean I think that's money well spent when it's for our children okay so once again do what do we do we when we when we go to make a vote on this are we stating that we want for gend item 2B do we want the district to pay for it or is the Sak Le going to pay for it so John I may I may need a little bit of guidance here for three 3 C2 2B maybe there me to be two different motions yes so what what I'm going what I'm going to have to do is this ladies and gentlemen I'm going to have to re resend theemotion for
119the motion for agenda item 3c2 so I'm going have to do it separately because there's there's a um there's a 3 a and 3B okay so there's 3 c 2 a and 2 B so I'm going to have to separate out so I need to resend the motion for agenda item something for J item 3 c 2 a and 2B I need to resend that motion please okay second Carol seof is first Megan mesman is second because I have to separate them out because we vote on them individually Lisa I think you can take the vote with the district accepting the fee and then we wave the Fe with a second so let me just yeah all those in favor of resending it so we I I should just just we have we have to
120separate them out Leslie Chris I I okay now I'm going to do this again have a motion for agenda item 3C 2 a please second Chris Nan who was the second Megan all right Megan now so for agenda item 3C 2A use of facilities that is that's the town of Bon so can we vote on that one first sure all right all those in favor for 3 C2 a i i motion carries 70 now I'm going to do Kevin motion for agenda item 3 c2b motion second Winnie canestro Caroline Fannon so this motion currently as stated that this projected cost of 2500 so John I'm going to do a little guidance here are we what's on the table what's happening right now is I may have to change my motion that we're looking to either
121the district is going to incur the cost can can we leave it at at that no right now that that is how the motion is stated that the district will in it is and this is a recommendation by the superintendent of schools in my understanding the the superintendent of schools is recommending as per the this resolution that the the approximate cost of $2,500 and4 $254 will be a charge to The District No a charge to the club okay to the organization all right I so that's how it's stated in the currently stated in the resolution okay so the question that I have with the motion on the table for this item if it was voted on and it people vote Yes hypothetically that means the organization would be char chared correct if if we vote
122no then that means the organization would not be charged can we no that means that the facility use does not pass if if subsequently there's a motion to amend this motion and remove the charge and that motion as amended would then be permitting the use without the charge right so now I have to resend this motion too don't I well it this right now this is how the superintendent has recommended it if you wish to if you wish to amend it you can amend it mid you've moved it you can amend you can move to amend it okay in the middle of your motion okay so that's where we're at I I have one more question some districts they have a ro you know with the custodial staff I'm just throwing this out there they
123sometimes have one person on a Saturday rotation so to to take rather than during the week they one of their work work days would be a Saturday so I'm just saying maybe it's Tuesday to Saturday to cover the cost if if facilities need to be used Monday through Friday no I understand but what I'm saying is some districts do do it that they floated on a Saturday that opens up that has to be negotiated that opens up a contractual issue I understand okay thank you right John I need a little guidance here so there's a motion in second for this resolution M as stated that's what's on the floor correct if a board member wishes to amend the motion that's on the floor they make a mo may make a motion to amend this this
124resolution that's on the floor to remove the projected cost of $254 from the current resolution and then that would be voted on if you do not amend it then it's going to be put to the vote as stated which is this projected cost would be the charge to the organization everyone understand so has the organization said they'd pay this do we even know that before we vote on this one of the board members of the organization contacted me and um said to indicate what the cost would be and that the board could invoke their right if they wanted to wave it so he is aware of what the cost would be so I'm just going to chime in here um $2500 is 00% of our budget um and I'm aware that the amville soccer club
125is a 51 organization and they provide significant financial aid to many of their players so if we do decide to charge $2500 to them that's $2,500 that they would not be providing financial aid to their players um I would was that explained to Dr talber I'm not sure John you look like you have a question no oh I'm just wondering if there's a motion yeah that's I'm Wai for too so the motion to wave the fee you can move to amend okay the motion that's currently on the floor and then we can try to vote without the fee way to remove the fee yes okay sure I'll make a motion to remove the fee from the soccer club so it's a motion to amend the resolution I'll second it to move to [Music] remove the
126fee of $2,500 and for 254 can I all right so let me just that that's the that's that's the motion so I need to I think I heard of who's who's the first I need a first Megan Megan Megan Wendy second Wendy second okay okay so now we're opening it up to anyone that has the application so we will pay every you know for every organization to use our facilities on Saturdays and Sundays this is the opening of something we have not negotiated an ATA contract yet and there will be there's programs out there that want to use our facilities now that we're opening them up that's something that I really feel uncomfortable with at this point all right so the motion it's it's on the it's on the table so go ahead I I
127also understand that the facility use policy is one that's been discussed in the policy committees as one that needs to be updating in in the next meeting if I'm correct I'm not on the facility I'm not on the policy committee but it's next on so I I will also say as I stated before that back in the fall of 2023 when we first discussed the use of facilities policy and the policy committee meeting about about maybe charging a fee or not charging a fee we were just having a discussion on the matter it became a whole issue within this community so now that we're at a point where we're having this discussion it's the motion's on the table and I think everyone has talked about it enough and we just need to vote on it
128so the motion to amend the resolution to remove the fee of 2504 was by Megan first wend conal second so what is the vote to remove the fee all those in favor I I so that's Megan mesman Yes W canestro any other yeses all those opposed i i i Chris Leslie Caroline and Carol so the motion fails so now so that Returns the motion back to the former motion that's on the table and the motion that's before the board is as stated in the resolution with with the fee to the organization so returns motion as stated for 3 c2b that the fee the charge will be to the organization can I have a do I need another person all those in favor I I I all right I gotta get the yeses who who's yes
129everybody I think everybody motion carries 70 and I and I would ask that you start submitting all right so can I have a motion for agenda item three can I do 3 C3 and four together no no have a motion for agenda item three C3 please motion motion Chris nering Winnie kestal any discussion on this item no c a motion for agenda item 3 C4 please motion second Chris Narin second Carol seof discussion what are we uh hiring this Law Firm for so the engagement contract uh with this Law Firm is through our insurance company for the data breach that took place on November 19th so since it's through the insurance company is it covered by Insurance uh there is the possibility to incur fees that will be paid by the insurance company Miss buatti
130do you need to clarify anything on that there is a possibility of a fee because of the deductible what what is the retention 10,000 25,000 25,000 is this do we have cyber insurance is this for cyber insurance this is true cyber what do you know what our limit is off hand 1 million for this particular one and then we have the other one for 250 okay thank you why do we think we need this because when the data breach was reported to our insurance company um there are actions that they have to take with the persons impacted as well as investigate the matter are we being sued because of this no no we're not being Su because of this the district took an action where exposure of information and so now we had to report
131that and INF fraction to the insurance company and now the insurance company has to take certain steps because of that and they have secured this Law Firm to carry out those investigative steps so is this a requirement by the insurance company and it is not anything that our current Law Firm it's it's through the insurance company which is a different set of legal uh Council so do we not have a choice in this matter is that if you don't want to forgo the insurance right so this is a this is a function of the the insurance this is typical this is typical so the insurance the insurance carrier has uh has this uh Law Firm that provides the notices and does the investigation as part of its part of its insurance for uh cyber security
132so we only just discovered this this afternoon because it wasn't on the agenda we received on Friday so I was hoping we could table it and learn more because it seems like a big thing to say yes to but it sounds like it's something we have to do no matter what anyway it's part of the insurance you've already procured right this this is this is typical as somebody inance it's typical of any any data breach when you get notification you've already procured the insurance so real really the board has already agreed to this when it B the insurance right okay all right any other questions or comments all those in favor I I I motion carries 70 have a motion for AG item 3d1 please motion Megan mesman is first second thank you Winnie canestro
133is second second any discussion on on this item I just I just have a quick um question uh we discussed at the last monthly meeting that the appropriation the Appropriations report would become available on the website for the public is that because I was looking for it I didn't see it is it up on the website it yes it was yeah I just I looked for it I where was it under the business but I I'll double check because we send it to yeah I think it's under the with within the public documents on the um agenda item was one of the links that are the oh you're saying it's It's associated with the agenda it's not okay it's not um I have a couple of questions about the appropriation um status report on page
13411 of 21 payments to charter school it's a deficit of almost $179,000 but we had the expenditure of $225,000 for Charter School carry over to this budget is that in addition to this is separate and apart separate this is for this year 2425 okay so we're in the negative for almost 179,000 and then plus we're in the negative for 225,000 from last school year is that correct last year it's closed it's closed can you just bring the mic a little bit closer last year's books are closed it's closed okay understood um I just had a couple other things um on page 15 of 21 it says salary summer program administrator High School it was budgeted for 13,000 but we actually spent almost 122,000 so now we're negative almost 109,000 how could that be such a
135big disparity we had want to pick it up oh this is this has to do with um summer regions exams we we went over this and this was required we knew we were going to exceed the budget just bring the mic Clos we knew we're going to exceed the budget this is something that we went over several times during the summer months when this program was going on because we're monitoring it very carefully but it was required so we had to is this something we do every year is it the same thing we do every year this program because if we do it every year why wouldn't we have forecasted better may I just further add for clarity sure this Pro this um summer Regents review was originally Grant funded it was budgeted in a
136grant and then it did not meet the eligibility criteria correct and it had to be funneled back into general fund correct so we offered it without knowing we had the grant or we offered it anyway we had to go ahead it's a requirement or it's not it had been submitted in the Grant and evidently it had not been approved as an expenditure and there was a miscommunication and so as a result we could not absorb that cost in the Grant and it was absorbed in the general fund okay on page four on page 14 of 21 it says teachers K12 temporary they're zero budgeted but we spent almost 24 $1,000 so now we're in the negative of $240,000 what is that um when we are rolling over teachers in July sometimes when they are coming
137from a grant we don't know where to place them at that point but all those people have been reallocated and it has been cleaned so by December you will see that code go to zero okay and and just so the audience understands these reports only go to October 31st yes um I have one more question just so I could get the page number um sorry I'm sorry I had written it down because we were doing it electronically I think I'll just go off with my notes there was um several items on um I should probably find it hold on hold on one sec I'm going to jump in then I have a few uh just simple questions on the revenue report at the bottom it says total revenue 115.7 million but the approved budget is
138$17.7 million so it's a $2 million difference which I would have attributed to to the 2 million we got from the state except in the other state aid line it's showing 2 million so why does the total revenue Show 2 million less $2 million was supposed to come from reserves that's not included as part of Revenue okay so there's like a transfer that would okay corre that thank you um does the revenue report like where do we go to see grant funding and the reason I asked this question when you mentioned Dr Talbert the title three Title One grants like if we get a grant midseason mid mid year where do we see that reflected uh the appr uh revenue report for the grant should also be included in this report in the uh Treasures
139report yes I'm so could you because grant funding you allowed to spend up to 20% because it takes them a while to approve the grant so sometimes we don't get the revenues until later so we don't have any revenues coming in for the grants but we are allowed to spend up to 20% because they know that you know payroll has to be met especially the title grants and the grants that come every year okay but when I look at all the columns and the revenue report I don't see anything that looks like it would be a grant and when I look here on the table of contents I don't see anything either so where where in this packet might I see it when the money finally comes in I'll double check it and make sure
140that the treasur includes the revenues for the grants in his report would be called a grant Revenue so that's forthcoming yeah um all right I also had a question about the charter school line because it a month ago it was showing the deficit that you had already warned us about for um 225,000 but this year it's less correct did we get kids back no what happened there were a couple of kids that decided not to go to char schools we got back so yeah they came back to the district okay so the number became less so I'm hoping that you know the number will go even further down that happened during the school year it does they started and then they dropped out and came back okay some does happen and then sometimes it goes
141the other way correct sometimes it go the other way sometimes it comes the opposite direction okay got that um and then last thing is just a commentary um last month's meeting I had just gone through quickly to C up all the deficits in both the um general fund and the federal fund line and you explained the federal fund's too complicated stay away from that so I did this time around however with the general fund um a month ago the total of all the line item deficits was 574 th000 now it's up to 69,000 um and that's after accounting for the money we recouped from the Charter Schools changing so I just throw it out there as an indication the deficit line by line is creeping up from last month so that's that we'll continue looking
142at it but I I I I'm sure it will be going down when we do all onc brances um I have I I found my question it's on page four or five um it says there's two salaries here and it list the position then it says healthcare workers bonus and they each got $1,500 $1,500 they were given a bonus general fund this is this is yes yeah yes okay what what are these bonuses because now we're negative $33,000 yes um during Co the governor gave healthcare workers up to $3,000 each okay this included I think social workers Nur and some group of employees they did not give you have to work a certain period of time to get that money and we gave the first allocation they approve it they sent it to us and
143we have to give the monies so it goes through the school district it didn't go directly to the employee and that's it goes to the employee though it goes to the employ but it has to go it has to work through the district and that's New York state regulations I guess okay that's all my questions thank you any other questions no all those in favor I I'm sorry I do want to just say one other thing I'm sorry the the claims udit are noted um that there were two purchase orders that were encumbered after the invoice a service so it said that we they should be you know they should be created before before you know we have appr we have to get approval before they're incum yeah this is the second time that it
144came up to Leslie's point we are trying very hard to make sure there there are no hrum purchase orders okay CU right this will this will clean it up and we are getting better I know because this only goes till October so I hope I don't see it in no the November report okay but sometimes it's an emergency and we have to do it sometimes they have to call it in because it's an emergency sometimes it's unavoidable okay thank you but emergency POS must go through a oh wait I'm sorry Carl what just just give give him the mic can you just give Carl the mic oh I think he said there training and reminders to employees constant training and reminders to employee make sure they tow the line with this okay okay so this
145matter was just addressed uh this week yeah as a matter of fact we addressed it this week say that you would not comp it will completely go away because in some emergencies you have to order the item okay if they if they need it something happens in a school and they need it immediately yes yes I try we try very much if they need something call us we'll set the purchase order up but sometimes it's unavoidable yes but it it must be very rare it must be rare correct and um we are putting controls in place to avoid that and all pertinent parties have been properly communicated with as it pertains to the submission of confirming POS okay thank you have a motion for item 31 please Carol seof who second it second Megan Megan
146M any discussion on this item I have a question um it looks like a special ed contract with West ISP but it's for two um private schools including a parochial school so which I didn't thought think offered special education services am I miss they do they do absolutely provide special John have you reviewed this contract yeah my office has yes okay so if the students are parentally placed in a private school in a particular Public School District then the um public school will bill us for the services whether it's a private parentally placed special school then they will build us for the services because they have to um extend the services through their Public School District to the private schools or the special needs schools it was just the names of the schools it's a
147me I never would have thought that St John the Baptist offered special education services but if I'm wrong I'm wrong okay all those in favor I I motion carry 70 can I do again items 3f1 and two together yes k a motion for agenda items 3F one and 3f2 so moved second Carol seof Chris neran any discussion on these items no seeing none all those in favor I I motion carry 70 so we have moved up the community input regarding non- agenda board items at this time so at this time we will take Community input regarding non board agenda items only good evening everyone it is so good to see many of you I want to openly give feedback first by thanking Dr Gina Talbert for giving such Clarity with the financial breakdown to really
148explain to the community um and to counteract the misinformation that was posted on social media and I think you deserve a thunderous Applause for that eloquently clearing up our concerns with that being said at that age I just find it interesting that we were ready to abandon charging um people to pay for weaken use of our facilities when we are crying the deficit that's an opportunity to have income and to not have teachers have a contract but to be so moved to be so concerned about these items it just seems like this is not the priorities are not managed properly to see such sensitivity to Athletics which I support Athletics but we have teachers that don't have a contract that is disconcerting very disconcerting and I would just urge the board to consider reprioritizing your
149agenda and where you show empathy um as a person that has studied in my um final dissertation secondary trauma to have to constantly fight about in some cases minute issues that frankly often seem to be racially motivated they really do it's oppressive and it's becoming tiresome but we have to continue to fight we made such um we pinpointed a particular staff member and we really stretched the comments concerning whether people speak Spanish or not which I understand because approximately 60% of the student population are Spanish speaking so we want that reflected but our board doesn't even reflect this community and so it is disturbing to show such concern with up one aspect but yet there seems to be a determination to keep people oppressed and this has to change and I'm not talking just skin
150color I'm talking about ideologies that come that are eurocentric and do not really take into consideration the trauma of having teachers who care to come and to have to constantly fight for things that they should have and they don't have a contract and then they are expected to still serve that's just it's disgusting we are not stupid people we appreciate our teachers our PPS staff we appreciate our administrators we are grateful to have a superintendent that understands our needs but we need a board to support that and there are some of you who do because we have relationships long time relationship ships from um ongoing positive and negative interactions but there are some of you that do not fit that profile and we need answers and we need these nonsensical questions that all of a
151sudden come up to be used as a strategy to try to subvert or to divert the community to end and we need to have a real conversation about Harmony because if you're going to serve then you're going to serve our needs not your own personal agendas and is enough there are certain things with all due respect that were asked that you should know as a board member special education is a federal item and all schools that are open off for special education services so so what I am summing up to sayk is this thank you um to yeah your time is up sum it up please I will sum up thank you thank you Lisa um we were given $2 million by um Miss Pierre that yes John Pierre correct okay that was to sustain
152sustain the school until this June yes por portion of it was a portion we have $587,000 given to us in state aid okay the projected cost to maintain is 1.5 million after the 587 is applied a little over so that leaves us with approximately $2.6 million right right because that's the 587,589 raising $500,000 to S sustain the school we can do that if we work together with putting the priorities in order we cannot close northeast school thank you I'm as as everyone comes up and I I I just request that you try to keep your comments two to three minutes because if I extend one person's time then I feel obligated to extend everyone's time so please be mindful of the of the timer and in it 3 minutes if I kind of bring the
153mic towards myself that's when I'm going to ask you to sum it up thank you no problem good evening my name is Daphne rizari I am the founder and president of the Long Island Latino Teachers Association if you want yeah sure better known as Lila we are an out for-profit organization of approximately 150 volun tier members we don't receive salaries um and our mission is to increase graduation rates higher education enrollment retention and completion thus I'm here on behalf of lilta board advocating to keep the Northeast Elementary School open for preschoolers we all know that early educa early education is crucial and beneficial for all students some researchers go as far as say that preschool year is the most important year because it teaches our Young Learners to be Learners this is more importantly for
154our vulnerable populations such as English language Learners which you have 22% of your population uh special ed which you have 177% of your population and economically disadvantaged students which is 73% of your population Ila is here to support and collaborate with the school district in providing and meeting the needs of all students and their families so we hope that you keep the school open thank you thank you again kind of piggybacking off of what um Dr Martin said uh regarding the uh northeast school um I was that was brought to my attention when um Kimberly John Pier's assistant came up here spoke about that so why are we even talking about closing the school like we understand that we understand the money but she just came and spoke about the money and the money was
155there allocated why are we talking about closing the school now but just one year it ends in June and it was money left over if I'm not mistaken correctly no no the money will be um will be ending in June of 2025 so so what was it that we had the fund raise was it $500,000 or what was it it's going to be more than that yeah because it's it's $500,000 for the um that we roughly 500 $500,000 for the from the grant but there's another like 1.5 1.6 to keep it going go ahead Dr Talman go ahead do so the school is actually closer to 1.6 million to keep it open she's raising her eyebrows and saying go up a little more and in state funds we get 587,589 apply toward the expenditures of
156keeping the school open okay um another question is so why aren't we talking about those steps publicly why isn't it like a camaraderie talking about those steps why are we talking about closing the school down or is that just like policy procedure where we got to speak about that earlier we did talk about some of the steps that we're taking right um to maintain the school we're talk we've been meeting with others about leasing out space that's not used by our prek program we are talk we've talked about the 4410 applications that will allow us to serve additional students and that cost would help us to operate those programs within Northeast we talked about the possibility of relocating um our kindergarteners back to Northeast um to complete you know the the the uh outfitting the
157school um we have talked about those options to um transition in terms of keeping the school open and um just a little bit more clarity of you guys didn't mind uh the special education aspect I'm hearing that kids are being denied special education at Amityville that's that's not true uh no and if a parent has spoken with you please connect them with us okay so that we can properly service the needs of the youngest Scholars we don't want anyone turned away and not understand what the steps are to move towards it or intervention steps that maybe they don't need the full special education services okay please connect them with us thank you thank you good evening Matt Grace 85 Craig Road High slip terce now we all know that we've been operating on an expired
158contract cont but the existing language in the contract Still Remains in effect this includes the grievance procedure process designed to Foster communication to resolve disputes quickly cheaply and at the lowest possible level unfortunately this has been a frustrating process as there's been very difficult to get the district to adhere to the timelines of procedures within the contract ignoring the language only makes resolving disputes more difficult and leaves our members harmed and in limbo for Unnecessary amount of time with that being said said however I'm glad to report that after months of being ignored we've finally been granted a hearing in front of the school board on January 22nd to present grievances related to involuntary transfers long-term substitute pay and compensation for a six class I'm disappointed it took this long but I'm hopeful this will
159set us on a path towards a resolution speaking of additional classes and it's been brought up here about special education I'm not sure where we're falling short or whose shoulders This falls on but I have some concerns concerns it's been a vacancy in the middle school for special education teachers since the end of September this has impacted several ICT code talk classes and a resource room we've made multiple sorry we have made multiple requests to allow the special education teachers in the Middle School who were both very willing and highly qualified to be assigned an additional class to cover this vacancy these requests have fallen on deaf ears I want to make this clear that what I'm saying has nothing to do with trying to get additional compensation for teachers this has everything to do
160with protecting our students to date no one has been hired to fill this position and Middle School teachers have only been asked to serve as substitutes let me explain what this means since they are not the teacher of record they have no access to the grade book they are not responsible for parent contact and most importantly they don't receive access to student IEPs in 504s as a result one of our most vulnerable student populations have not been able to receive their ferally mandated Services despite our please to allow these dedicated teachers to be moved out of a substitute role and approved as a sixth class so that they can become the teacher of record two years ago it took the district getting embarrassed on News 12 before finally filling several vacancies in the high school
161it appears the lesson wasn't learned whether mandated or unmated I can't understand why we would not want to give our students what they need to be successful and the Line quote we are working on it it's just not good enough anymore I'm fearful that either the district can't figure out these solutions to these problems or they just don't care as long as it saves a few dollars my only hope is that a third option may still exist one in which the district makes a decision to do what's in the best interest for these children who attend our schools the choice is yours jacqu and Stevenson I just have a bunch of follow-up questions from previous meetings uh the first one is from the October 23rd meeting there was an organization called the National Coalition of
162100 black women that gave a presentation on a mentoring program for high school students and I just wanted to know what the status was of that because it was slated to start November 14th Dr Talbert thank you sure the 100 black women uh presented their mentoring module to us and we still anticipate their active participation with their high school students um that night it was uh presented that there was an insurance component that was required and they are working on securing that and we hopefully we'll be joining us soon okay um what is the status of the superintendent evaluation and the board evaluation has that been done or is there a date for it um we just recently looked at the policy regarding board evaluation and typically what happened with that is that there's a
163new process for the board evaluation and we're still looking at the superintendent evaluation so super evaluation was done for 2324 yes was yes MH okay so does that information get related to the public or is that just for the superintendent um if everything is agreed upon and signed then yes it gets released to the public so that hasn't happened yet it's not happened yet okay so will you be attempting to do her evaluation at her annual date in August coming this this coming August because there's certain guance in her contract that will termine when her um evaluations are done I just remember off the top of my head okay do you have an update on the re regionalization plan yes the regionalization uh deadline has been extended to January 15 as of now uh amville
164is still participating in the regionalization unless the board directs otherwise okay um what is the status of the $43,000 that we're supposed to be getting from the uh covert project I don't think it's go go ahead Dr table $43,000 just you got to speak into the mic thanks thank you the $443,000 from the co they claimed that were we still haven't received the check yet but I'm looking out for it okay what is the status someone had mentioned in the November 20th meeting about new policies for social media cell phone and AI what is the status of that the policy committee is still working on different policies we haven't gotten to the those policies as of yet and and also the cell phone the governor might be imposing a cell phone policy Statewide that might
165be coming down I think in July thank you um question regarding the EPC why was Northeast removed from it um Dr Talbert or you want to pass it over to uh olivan Carl why why was North East removed from the EPC miss bti it has to do with the questions that we a lot of residents have been raising about the northeast school so we had to remove it from the scope of the project but as you can see today the board passed a resolution to even terminate the whole agreement okay so I'm assuming you're going to be going into more detail about the committee for Northeast okay um and the reason why I asked that is because at the last meeting someone up there I don't want to say board member I don't remember who
166but someone said having a committee doesn't necessarily mean Northeast would be closing the committee would review POS other possibilities so that's why I asked that question but I'm assuming you're going to go into more detail when you talk about it correct uh yes um just for quick clarification John if in regards to the education law 402a and the closing of school in establishing a advisory committee if a committee is established does that mean the school is definitely closing that question no it is a utilization committee so under the under the statute uh it has a specific charge to look at specific factors with respect to utilization of the school including utilizing that school for other purposes and not closing it okay that's thank you for that Clarity uh it was also mentioned in the last
167meeting that you were going to look into having one class trip per grade because right now certain grades do not have class stps so what is the status of that Dr T so um Miss Stevens has been in communication with the building principles uh regarding that request and you want to give an update as to where we are now with it the elementary principles have identified one trip per grade level that they wanted um the secondary principles did it by core content area instead of by grade level so that it would be curricular related and we're currently working with Transportation um and the business office just to cost those out so we have a reasonable expectation uh what is the status of the damaged or missing seats at the high school auditorium one of the
168board members mentioned that at the last meeting so following the report out of the damaged seats at the high school auditorium we communicated with our building and grounds director who went on site and conducted an inspection and he contacted a vendor because it's going to require a Specialized Service and they are scheduled to do their walkthrough tomorrow uh in regarding the financial consulting was he wasn't he in charge of a committee yes so what's going to happen with that committee if he doesn't change his mind and stay so the committee received the charge that it would be co-chaired by the assistant superintendent for business and operations and one of the members and one of the members has agreed to co-chair um he was never necessarily the chair he was the facilitator and launcher to get
169us off the ground and so the committee will be co-chaired by Miss batti and Mr Misha okay uh and with the policy final readings that happened today what what is the next step so the next step step from here excuse me is that now the policies will be updated and then eventually in the timely frame they will be placed up on on the website I believe legal has reviewed them already or will review one more probably will will review them one more time and then from that point there's a notation that's placed on the bottom that that policy was adopted on such such date and then it's uploaded to the to the website okay 36 seconds uh just the the the last two are not questions just comments I wanted to make a comment once
170again about the superintendent meetings that she's been having I unfortunately missed last one that was my mistake um but I have I definitely have um benefited from them and I'm looking forward to the next one in February I just wish more parents and community members would attend those superintendent meetings they're very informative and my last comment is I listen if I'm not here I listen to the recordings and it's a lot of times when the ATA presidents or members of the ATA come up they have long speeches they read but then there's no response from you from you guys so if you could just reconsider responding to them and because they're they're obviously taking the time to type out their what they have to say and what they have to say is extremely important so
171it would I think benefit everyone here if they would get some sort of response some sort of answer some sort of timeline because I feel like like I said it's very important thank you um legal just for double I think typically under circumstance like that we really are not I'm not allowed to speak or respond to a comment no those we have constant Communications between myself and Mr Glenn who is the Labor Relations Specialist much of U my conversations with Glenn Mr Glenn has already preempted much as what has been said at the floor good evening everybody my name is Katrina I live 92 Maple Drive I'm a community organizer and a community leader I need to reiterate the fact that no Northeast should not close at all and you should do everything in your
172power to keep it open I've sat here I've listened to everything that you did have to say and you are definitely 100% taking 25,000 steps backwards if you close the school it is deplorable it is Despicable despicable for the teachers to have to work without a contract why don't they have a contract does anybody know it's being worked on you're working on the contract that's wonderful okay and also as I was listening to some of your your plans to keep Northeast open one of the plans was to rent out space in the facility who owns that building the district owns the building the district owns it so you allowable to rent out the space for the students you also mentioned as a resolution that you going to have portable classes in Northwest Elementary School I
173didn't understand what that was about so I I'll let Dr T will finish it but some of the things that she was just stating that these are things that can be looked at so we're not definitely doing it at this point in time just things that possibly could be looked at so the ideas of portable um is something actually that do we have some that exist in Northwest right now that have also become permanent so it's just another way of having I don't think I think that's a horrible I'm just saying because I live there I live on Maple Drive Northwest is right down the block of on county line that school is overcrowded you don't need to stuff nobody else in there and from what my knowledge is I'm telling you you don't need
174to stuff anybody else there's people who don't even live in the district that drive to the school to bring their kids to the school that don't even live in the district whatsoever they're also doing another development on Maple driving count and 110 a 14 unit development Housing Development which is also going to be overcrowded so therefore you would have to do a traffic study before you decide to put anybody else in Northwest Elementary School because it's already overcrowded we've been to too many board meetings about that and I don't know if it's your knowledgeable but I'm letting you know right now that that's a terrible idea as you can't do it you just can't do it all right then the last thing I wanted to talk about may I just clarify sure I'm sorry so
175when we talked about the possibility of moving kindergarden from Northwest to Northeast it would free up the Portable Buildings in Northwest so we would be moving children to a permanent structure a building that houses a permanent structure and then looking at what are some of the possibilities that we could do with the Portables that are located at Northwest just wanted to make sure I appreciate that because that's why I needed Clarity with the portable classes like no more enough is enough is enough you also and this I need to know the 4410 you said you resubmitted the program and you should get an answer by April 2025 to find out if it's going to be granted can you clarify that for me yes we submitted the applications previously they have returned the to us one
176for the special class one for the integrated class we submitted two because we had to reanalyze some of the numbers that they were requiring the financial pieces and so there were lengthy meetings going on to get that done and we will be resubmitting them okay and you will have an answer supposedly tentatively in April we're looking to make a final decision prior to adopting the budget in April understood is there any way we can have communication like the community can have better transparent communication with the board so we're not in limbo until we get to the next meeting like is there somebody you can reach out to maybe like a pastor or assembly person or maybe meline or so we the community the people who actually live here do I'm sorry question any board members
177we all live in the district Community we have you have to live in an school you have to live in the district in order to serve on a school board everyone has to live in a district okay UND understood thank you kindly all right so that was it so that just believe that we should have more transparency okay and a better line of communication thank you thank you good evening Nikia wolf at president uh 100 Court North Drive Melville um I've spoken exhaustively regarding our contract situation and the lack of transparency um recently it it turns out that we could have potentially come to a conclusion a long time ago if there was transparency as it relates to what was actually budgeted for teachers our members have had to wait while we have engaged in
178exhaustive negotiations due to the reluctance to share information once we found out what the actual numbers were it was the union who pivoted you really need to understand that transparency would have helped to move this um negotiations process along a Lot quickly because at no point in time were we ever going to come to an agreement without having accurate information when it became parent that negotiations were stalling um I found it interesting that the district's negotiations team brought up field trips I don't know what place field trips had in our negotiations talk but my team found it insulting the board of educ put forth a budget that did not include field trips one that everybody voted for or that we had um a majority of the community vote for although the board proposed budgets that
179would have allowed them a current trustee who was not a board member at the time expressed that they didn't feel as though any of those budgets were feasible especially one that pierced the cap that's why I was also surprised that a board of education members spoke about field trips at the Board of Education meeting in November when you have Board of Education members on the team who spoke about who spoke out against the budget that ultimately passed you actually wonder how committed they are to genuinely working to move Amityville forward this week we have engaged in pickets and we will continue to do so until the district shows works with us to value our teachers every report High highlighting the achievements of students are a byproduct of their efforts that of their teachers administrators and
180other Frontline employees yet those individuals continuously fight for less than a fair deal continuously being surpassed by other school districts it is time that you prioritize those who are the backbone of this District those of you who are committed to moving Amityville forward I encourage you to do what is right and stand up for your school district thank you good evening Francis O'Brien 684 Bohemia Parkway saal New York seek first to understand then be understood it's one of the things I teach in my classroom in other words listen first before speaking take the time to understand the other person beliefs and thinking before stating your own this cannot happen without face-to-face communication we are supposed to be a data driven District financially speaking the data is constantly changing hence there's no trust in the district
181statements or budgets since a request to see the data has been denied by the district negotiations team men spoken about passports and how it's a disgrace the teachers contract has been settled yet here we are two years without a contract simultaneously the administration Union is three years without a contract and the Castor unit is two years without a contract we hear board members speak about m in one District I say prove it acur speak louder than words and silence speaks volumes this current approach is unnecessary unproductive and has failed to produce meaningful results at November's board meeting I was amazed that a board member asked the district to find money for field trips yet failed to realize the simple truth that is the teachers who make field trips happen the paperwork transportation ensure that every
182student has lunch and most of all organized with the venue to make the trip an educational success while on the trip the teachers are supervising students from the moment they come to school till the moment they leave and yes this includes students who are waiting to be picked up quite often field trips go beyond the contractual day you want to find money for field trips but can't seem to find the money to pay the teachers to go above and beyond what is expected them besid field trips we hold additional extra help days provide snacks and drinks for students as well as purchase holiday gifts for those in need all out of our own pocket the board you recently had the opportunity for face-to-face conversations with the ATA in effort to exite these contract negotiations again
183seek first to understand then be understood the ATO is more than willing to do this in fact we requested you to come down one flight of stairs and meet us to make progress in our contract negotiations that didn't happen even though we were in the same building it didn't matter we're actually miles apart with no effort by the board or the district to close this Gap to negotiate a contract shouldn't take two years nor should this process be upon Pawn in someone's Personal Agenda to further his own Ambitions we keep hearing decisions are based on what is best for students but again I can speak louder than words the Middle School swapping teachers a couple classes instead of signing them a sixth class does not support students teachers cannot teach nor can students learn if
184there's not consistency for both I my evidence right here of what I'm talking about so let's have the transparency transparency necessary to move this District forward let's start by telling the truth to teachers who interview in am in amville that truth is amville is in the lower the bottom 6% in terms of salary for districts on Long Island furthermore if you retire from amville then you will pay 50% for the cost of your insurance on individual plan and 65% on the family plan that is the state minimum that is what you are worth to this District the action here are simple and speak for themselves past two days our members were on the street in front of Northeast Northwest Park Avenue Middle School and the high school all raising their voices seeking to be heard
185and understood listen to our voices thank you and my final note I'm Dr peon Martin I just wanted to offer as a suggested resolution for the transl issue um there are now Bluetooth translation real realtime translation ear earbuds that can be purchased um they are on Amazon the cost range from $26 to about 10 and some cases $160 $170 so for your parently aison um or for any support staff member if the concern is being able to communicate effectively it is a viable concern that could quickly swiftly and efficiently be rectified by simply investing a nominal fee into the this particular piece of technology so if you research it um one is called realtime language translator earbuds um another one is called language translation earphone and it's the threein one translator earbud and there's another
186one that's a 5in one I would urge you to consider purchasing it so that we can eliminate having to now Define what type of person or that person must have that language we can now change our human resource structures and really open it up to the most qualified candidate because if the person doesn't speak the language whether it be Spanish whether it be Haitian Creo or eru we can now utilize this with human interaction and also to continue the use of language line um as uh an additional um support device thank you thank you Dr Pepper actually our Teachers Association has recommended amended those and with what the board approved tonight the money available for supplies will go toward those actual devices thank you so thank you Dr good evening Patricia Hobson amville Rainbow Lane
187good evening and I've stood here many times and you know I I would hope I'm going to pretty much say a lot of what you've already heard in that you've heard the voice of the community in regards to the school in our community and that hopefully the board will make a decision to remove that option of closing our school down for our children I found it interesting in listening to some of the what I would call tag teaming of good cop bad cop but you're speaking the same language that we don't understand that one person speaks one way and then whatever you're saying behind closed doors is going to be something different it's not good a board member this evening made a comment about not having a problem spending money for children what are salaries
188you pay teachers that's spending money for children so hopefully you'll reach a point that you'll prioritize what's important for our community North amville is a community where a large population of the diversity in this district is when you teach elementary children about Community they talk about their schools the police the fire departments it takes a village that school being in our Community is important to us which should also be important to you thank you all right any other community input on non-agenda items right now we're going to go to Old business what open it's whatever anyone wants to talk to talk about this point in time so I'll okay I don't mind starting off about Northeast it's a lot to follow up on after three hours of conversation um I'm going to start with the
189question I understand miss baty that there's a draft budget that's already been created as part of the budget committee is that true for next year there has not been at all you just got to speak into the mic okay we are in the process of building it it's the process you're okay so then I was mistaken about that um all right so then I'm going to go back in time to last spring when it was this Administration that said to the community we're going to have to close Northeast and everybody was upset no one liked to hear that and it was only because because of the $2 million bailout that we got from assemblywoman jier that it was able to stay open for one more year since then we have heard little to nothing about
190it unless we ask repeatedly at board meetings what is the plan for Northeast what is the plan for Northeast we had a one-time bail out but we have to figure out what comes next and information was not forthcoming so at the and it started to sound scary because budget season is upon us and you have to have a plan at the last meeting November 20th we agreed let's have a committee and I think many of us were thinking about Committee in the general sense of a lot of community members getting together to figure out the plan it wasn't until later that we received a memo that explained no actually if you want to if you're considering closing a school this is the sort of committee you have to form and it has you know be
191formed six months prior so there were very specific steps attached to the committee that we did not understand a month ago when we were just saying we'd like a to committee to discuss it because we want to know what the options are none of us want to close Northeast but we know we have to figure something out as long as we can't settle teachers contracts and we can't offer competitive salaries and we can't can't bring excess staff back and we can't offer field trips and facility use and all these other things it is imperative that the administration continued looking to cost-saving measures and last Spring closing Northeast was one of them so like the board is counting on the administration to come to us with all those options what are they we had the most
192we'd heard in the fall was we're going to look into the 4410 what we heard tonight was the most information we've got about those efforts to look into the 4410 and as I understand it it won't generate Revenue it won't put more money back into the budget it will just cover the costs of servicing the children Dr Talbert you mentioned reaching out to other vendors the board has not heard anything about who you've reached out to and how those conversations went the other day I was curious um about marks of Excellence which is an early Child Care Learning Center at the intersection of Albany and Great Neck just several houses down from Northeast they operate Copeg upk program in the building alongside multiple programs um I live several houses down and I was curious so
193I just dropped in I walked down the street I wanted to see if anyone would talk to me and I got a tour of the whole building it was wonderful I saw the babies I saw the little kids and I spoke with the owner who explained she's very adept at operating multiple programs through different uh government agencies so the natural thought I had was could you or someone like you do this in Northeast for amville as a upk program it's a possibility but that's not the job the board of the it's not the job of the board to figure that out we are counting on the administration to do the leg work do the research find out what are all the options out there and bring them to us so we can talk about them
194but up to now the only thing we've heard is either we close it or we don't but you know we we want to know what the options are just as much as anyone so so I'm just gonna and then I'll I know I saw Dr tal pick up I hear Megan on the other side of me there there's a couple of things if hypothetically we utilized you know some place like Marx exent to come into Northeast to do a prek prr program it would mean that we would have to um Let Go a number of teachers right because there would be different type of teachers that would be utilized for that for that program would it save the district money yes it would but it mean that it would mean that we would um lose
195teachers um Dr talber has spoken about the 4410 she has mentioned before in other meetings and please correct me if I'm wrong Dr Talbert in regards to um looking at other options options are being looked at but nothing has panned out yet and that's where we're at right now it's not like we have our head in the sand we're not addressing it so go ahead Dr talber and then we'll go from there sure thank you so it doesn't necessarily have to be Northeast open or Northeast closed there are several options that we're analyzing across the district and even last year there were options s presented to the board and the community about relocating uh North uh prek to Northeast um there were options presented other than just open or close the building but let me
196walk back just a little uh further Mr Frasier reported out to the board his meetings with other districts regarding 4 410 he has met with principal Collins um Miss Bazi and I have visited marks of Excellence we also had a tour we have invited her over to Northeast she runs the complete upk program for Copa and we would have to turn over our upk money for her to run our program we would like to keep our teachers running our program in addition if she was if she uh wanted to rent space out from from us it would be at her expense and there would have to be a charge incurred um for parents to send their children that was also discussed with Miss Marx who has an excellent reputation in early childhood Ood as it
197pertains to plans being presented to the board we have said repeatedly that 4410 is not a revenue driven program we have said that we met with a district and they opted out of the program because it was not a revenue generated program we have met with um two additional vendors and spoke about leasing out the building and that information was shared with the board what the approximate cost would be to lease out certain space in Northeast but what we are working on is to compile all of this information in black and white so the board can see it explicitly and further discuss is Northeast the topic to be closed or not or are there other options throughout the district that we can consider as well thank you can I jump in because I think that
198you just answered my questions Dr Talbert and to Caroline I thought you spoke very well um I had similar thoughts that we have heard and thank you Dr tber you have spoken to it when we have asked you in public session during old business what is the status of this so we get a little little tidbits um but it would be very helpful and I was going to ask today during this part of the meeting that you put together a report of the steps that have been taken um where they have led and so that we can look at the pros and cons and really understand to be able to move towards a recommendation for next school year so so and you know to Caroline's point I mean we were I thought that we had
199to establish that committee six months in advance of even thinking about a change in the use of that building our legal counsil has told us that no you don't actually have to do that so I don't think that we need to establish a committee I think we just we do need what you've just stated a summary of everything that's been done to date all of the Avenues that have been explored so that the board can then you know review that information and be in a better position to understand the path forward I I excuse me um I kind of feel that we also it sometimes it's not just us who's sitting at the table that can provide input or ideas in regards to um the situation that exist in with with Northeast what are the
200options that we have Dr Talbert the cabinet the board sometimes has more insight than individuals that are in the community so for me if if there was a committee that was started but the purpose of the committee was the focus was not to close the building but they'll come together to talk about options to keep the building open and brainstormed then that's to me I support something like that I don't support establishing the committee to look at closing the building but maybe establish a committee provide input from the community about how could we keep the the building open so that's I know we're part of this old business but then I'll pass it back to Dr talber so thank you for the clarity because the consensus was given for the uh 402a to be formed
201um and then of course we were advised that that did not have to be followed so if there are options that we're exploring and the board would like to hear ways to keep the school open then we can develop uh presentations to that end and I think also whether it's I think it's not just presentations but I think the presentations are great but I think whether it's yeah contain the information whether it's different Community forms that are not connected to a school board meeting so it allows an opportunity for discussion to take place whether it's done in small groups or whatever it may be to have to have the discussion and it has to be something that that continues to happen it can't happen today and not happen again to January 22nd so whatever we
202decide to do as a board like I said I support a committee that focuses in on keeping the school open not focusing in on closing the school if we don't do a committee then if we do several different forums so sometimes when you have a committee and people are are together they can bring ideas back and go from there so that's just my perspective on it and in regards to that matter um okay I'm going to jump in you know I don't think anybody wants to close a school especially a school for pre pre uh prek um in fact more districts are getting more grants for prek not less um I do have a question though um from what I understand Northeast prek at one point um because it it looks like we had funding
203for 85 kids but we have 126 kids so now we had a fund an additional 42 kids with drove up with which drove up the cost it's my understanding that in years past to accommodate this they had a morning session and an afternoon session I mean is that an option that makes it very difficult for parents working parents um I understand went to full time but is it an option but I'm asking if it's an option because other other districts do it I think what we're trying to do is keep a program keep the children here help the parents but also be realistic of of um what we can do right I don't really know every District usually districts have lotteries that's why they have lotteries because they only fund a certain amount so if
204a morning and afternoon can accommodate all the children so we're able to do it and you know still keep the school and keep the program I'm asking Dr Talbert to perhaps look into that but I I think it's and that's where and I'll let Dr talba answer but I think that's where it goes in terms of whether once again it's Community form or a committee so there's ideas that that are put down just like you're suggesting again then it goes to Dr talber she can in her cabinet they can look at all the options and come back with clear information so instead of giving one thing at a time if there's several things options that are being looked at it could be looked at and fully flushed out and then go from the so go
205go ahead well I just want to say like as a Schoolboard member that's sitting up here at a Schoolboard meeting I'm I'm asking if that's something for for you to explore um when you're looking at the different Avenues um I think that I am also nervous it's Wendy I'm going to interrup because it's not and it right you're asking as one School Board member but if it takes time to look at all that information then we as a school board collectively should be on agreement that these are the things that we want Dr talber to look at okay I mean didn't know that it was going to be such resistance just having an idea but not that seems like something that requires a lot of feedback from the community as it was pointed out that
206drastic changes that would need to happen just an idea as the question yeah I could answer it right now it's not an option okay that's all I'm looking for so it's not an option in terms of what we've been approved for okay and the formula provided to us okay that was easy enough um also when I I do have another question as far as when you say that you're looking to cut 2% expenditures in the budget is that cutting the 2% expenditures in hopes of making up the money to keep the Northeast when you're saying it's 1.6 million is that what your goal is for that the overall goal is to just employ good fiscal practices and not spend every you know dime in the budget to increase our fund balance but as we are
207working very diligently to increase revenues and decrease expenses then that would allow us to have more money to put toward Northeast put toward fund balance put toward closing gaps okay understood so with the budget season upon us I think when it was brought up in April last year that we potentially might have to close it I think everybody was really shocked by it I hope that um as it has been stated tonight by many people that during the budget season I think um begins mid-February about mid-February or the end of February that these discussions will happen throughout the budget SE season and not just at the end you know that last meeting that but that we can continue the conversations of what it will look like right so we've had a lot of questions of
208what is what is it going to look like so um I agree with what have said been said before that you know I'm looking forward to get the recommendations and the information and having it before us so we could have thoughtful discussion but it is for administrators to bring it to the Board of Education thank you any other comments on this item any other old and new business um I would like us to have a was it I don't think it was committee but it was group of um yeah the Forum of the community for Northeast because we do need to reach out and utilize the resources within the community to find ways to keep the school open and fund it and there's a good network of people in this community that are very passionate
209about keeping it open and we've seen a portion of that today so the question I have for the Board of Education are we looking to do community forums or are we looking to I'll do that do we want to do community forums yes yes legal net something that we can do correct sure I'm just double checking okay but would we so then for the January meeting we would have the presentation is that agreeable Dr Talbert you mentioned the presentation of everything that's been investigated with the form take place before that meeting I I I think that was my next question I was going to ask I think that we should try to do a community Forum before the January 22nd so maybe at that Forum that's where that presentation could take place and therefore there'll
210be ample time for people to ask questions and questions to be answered because that would be the only focus that will be occurring at that time so that that's just my suggestion wait when are you saying to do at Le I'm just saying that before before January 22nd I agree just to do that pres that should be the only focus for that for that night or whatever would be whether it's a pres do a presentation have a discussion have questions and then can we should we now be specific about what the presentation should include because right off the bat I just feel like the the community should know if you've already done a lot of research and understand why some options are possible and others aren't um to not reinvent the wheel that's what I
211feel like you ought to present to the public so we can understand oh right that's a dead end but this is promising but to to your point Caroline I think that would be a good thing that would occur at a community form so whatever information she has gathered the the information that would be would be put out that way that um come hear the presentation from um Dr Talbert in the in the school board in regards to what has been looked at already yeah I think we agree yeah exactly so I wasn't too sure I wasn't too sure if you were saying to do it ahead of time no I just want to be specific about what's in the presentation we want to know what kind of work has already happened and what are the
212results of that because we have not heard much in the way of detail okay all right so then so the board of education is in agreement well is the Board of Education in agreement to do a community form in sometime in early January before the the next school board meeting which is January 22nd um I would ask Dr Talbert how how much time would you need before the board meeting then when when would that be would it would you need to do it a week before two weeks before what would work lastly a week before um and I just need us to be mindful and the part of this has been the gray matter and the variables is that dollars are not fixed in many of these options 4410 is not fixed you're not going
213to know that until your applications are approved and your program is in motion so we can present information but it won't be fixed and it really will still be a a variable in the budget right like the potential pros and cons of this draft and the leas okay and the leasing you know is not going to be profitable enough to close the gap based on the ranges that we have received thus far we will prepare that information and continue the other um Avenues and I'll continue this effort with the absence of Mr Fraser who has been a real Vanguard in helping us to move the needle with Northeast and um we will continue to uh you can think change your mind call yeah oh one more thing Dr Talbert I just want to mention we've
214discussed before Northeast the bathrooms are made for little child tods and children so when we talk about leasing or renting you have to be mindful that we might not meet those standards of what's needed you know for older children or adults or something so that comes into play too that's something we have to consider that actually was brought up during executive session and I just want to clarify because there just seems to be a tone with a few people on the board that information has not been presented to the board however that is not true Mr Frasier Dr talber has presented much information along the way at practically every executive session so I just want to make that perfectly clear and I'm sure that there are other people on this board right now that would
215agree with that any other new old business that needs to be addressed um I just have one other thing Dr Talbert I know that you're doing your monthly Community meetings in the morning in the afternoon and um one of the parents mentioned you know that she goes and some sometimes I'm wondering if it might be beneficial to maybe allow Zoom so if parents are they could zoom in from work maybe put earphones in or maybe type a question um maybe just to expand the audience any engagement yes and that is our Initiative for the February meeting uh we did talk about zoom and so that will be our first opportunity to connect virtually at our February meeting um in in the morning and in the and at the evening morning and the okay I have
216one other item that wasn't already mentioned by community members um the middle school project um Can the bid form please be shared with the Board of Education as well as the cost estimate for the CM so that we can be better informed um as to what that might look like when we're making decisions about the middle school is that is that okay yeah okay that will have to come from the AR okay yeah yes yes okay great thank you any other new old business there was one outstanding item that took place at last night's cbac meeting was that last night yes um Mr Frasier wanted to put it on the table as he received some feedback from community members yeah so we had a very good meeting last night of the committee and and uh
217there was one concern raised by the committee which we said we'll bring back to the board for decision and that concern was about extending or having access by the community to listen in to the meeting by the committee most of the committee members felt that this meeting this B this committee was elected by the board to provide to gather information and at some point next year provide a report to the board they were not comfortable having a zoom in their session where the community can listen into so my question to the board is and in the charge of the committee it does say that the um Community can listen in but they cannot speak the committee feels that that should not be in terms of having uh the community members uh be part of the
218discussion because they're collectively discussing and then collectively they'll give an advisory opinion to the board right yes the the committee would collectively give um advisory information to the board for example we had our first um minutes completed and Dr Talbert will be submitting that to the board the minutes from the November meeting but specifically about future meetings having community members zoom in as we discuss issues and the budget preparation and discussion so there so the committee as a whole is asking not to have that for them to speak holistically and you know freely without scrutiny okay yeah I don't I'm not in support I think this should we the board education um greeted the the the committee and we gave them guidelines I feel the committee should have that ability to speak freely and discuss
219to agree to disagree without any interference from anyone within the community so I'm not in support of zooming it in or anything like that John you give me a look do we need consensus John so I I'll just have to look at at your policies um and the charge of the committee and I'll provide further guidance to the board okay thank you and just I just want to make pull up my computer I just want to make one thing bring to the attention of the the board in the community that um one of the committee members that's on the citizens budget advisory committee had sent an email to me just stating that um they were upset at um they were incessed at in discussion that took place at the meeting on the first night when
220the question was asked about um where people lived which part of amvel that they lived in and they felt that the question was to make sure that every segment of the district was represented and as you well know there's um tax differences between town of ban and OA Bay and part of the discussion was was imperative that every person in the committee understood that understood it and could communicate their differences so and that was the only reason that it was done not for any other reason so the person wanted me to to make it make it aware but didn't want their name mentioned oh go ahead uh just a further comment I neglected to inform the board that tomorrow we will have a site visit at Northeast from one of the from the um squa
221from squa regarding the 4410 application that we put in they will be coming out for a site visit to observe the rooms and the size of the rooms and the layout utilization of the building thank you thank you thank and just last one last thing before I call for a motion to adjourn just as a reminder and maybe you did in report and I and I missed it was that we have the winter concerts that are coming up next week so I think it's it's like Monday Tuesday Wednesday and Thursday summer summer doing the day and some are in the evening so if you're able to attend some of the concerts in the evening um that'll be great High School is Wednesday the middle school is when Middle School then Monday I think it's Monday
222and I think Northwest is like Tuesday Wednesday Thursday during the day and I think Northeast is Friday during two times during 84 9:45 and 1:45 I think and Park Avenue spelling be on Thursday yes can I have a motion to adjourn at 11 11 p.m. so moved it's 1110 Carol seof is first and I think I heard Caroline vanan in second all those in favor I motion carries 70 thank you for coming out