CorpusRecord 59840

Board of Education Work/Public Session - January 22, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bay Shore School District
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,679 words · about 65 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e work session I have a motion please to go into work session motion second anybody all in favor I I okay we are in session no problem guys sorry wasn't paying attention we'll start off with uh bayaw Middle School School in the community M Pas M thank you Mr B nelli uh earlier I think it was right after the break Miss D University shared uh some wonderful news from the Middle School about some absolutely outstanding work that some of our students and staff did uh to help out members of our community and uh after speaking with the teachers and the administrators involved we felt it was really important that every everybody understood all of the hard work and effort to try to support Bay Shore uh and something that has been taking place

002for many years so we have members of the bore Middle School administration here along with some of our teachers who will introduce themselves and of course some of our students to share some of the wonderful work that they did so I want to invite up Dr lores and the administration along with the students and the teachers to share so you guys can all come on up to the to the podium wherever you wherever you want to go front and center good evening everyone thank you so very much as always uh for the opportunity to come before you to share what's happening at the middle school some of the things that um we do obviously is focusing on uh helping our students understand that there's a greater world than just the I and the me it's

003actually about the we and the US and the collective and in line with our District's Vision uh for this particular school year and I think it always going to be the vision and the mission of our school district to consider the community and unity aspect of community our students uh were at the Forefront of conceiving a project some time ago that Miss jarra was going to share with us about being able to give back to the community and think about other people especially when they need it most during uh the holidays Thanksgiving Christmas things of that nature for those who celebrate um so in their presentation they're going to share with you the context and the background which this this annual visit to St Patrick's Hospitality Center began is going to share the experiences of

004our students who were there and participated and what they were able to glean from that and the process and what goes into um ensuring that every single year they return to the St Patrick's um Hospitality Center and uh and are able to give back to our school community so we have uh Mrs jarro our wonderful Ela teacher who's been at the middle school for many many years and if you know her you know she always has an idea she's always going to bring it to you it's about how she's going going to involve the kids and you have to say yes now you're going to have to iron out the details but she's going to make sure you say yes at some point and then we have Mr sesky who's our science teacher um at

005the middle school there who's been there for some years as well and again you know we have a truly uh Team approach here a community Approach at the uh middle school and they're going to I'll turn it over to them and let them share with you about that so thank you Dr lores and good evening esteemed um administrators um distinguished members of our school board thank you for inviting my students my colleague and I to share with you an incredible experience that took place recently in December U meaningful learning can occur Beyond The Four Walls of a classroom and I was reminded of this several years ago when a student challenged me as a teacher to do more at the end of a reading unit that involved analyzing articles and videos and writing and discuss

006question about the plot of the homeless a student approached me at the end of the class and simply asked well what else what are we going to be doing besides talking I happen to be a patron of St Pats and there's a souit kitchen attached and I mindlessly said okay get me a phone number get me a contact and we'll see what we can do for me personally it was the end of the unit it was a Friday my lesson was over Monday morning this same student approached juring advisory with a phone number and contact and a reminder of the promise that I made with the time that I actually made the promise love so I made the call and 15 plus years later I continued to make that call to action I've been privileged

007to witness students eagerly embracing giving of themselves and being of service to others in their Community uh today they're going to share some of their personal experiences as well and they're here with us today um the week prior to this annual trip we continue to analyze articles discuss watch videos however we end each unit with the idea that we're going to do more we have evolved over the years thanks to the support of generous teachers and parents who have donated canned goods gently used clothing books and bring long and um items that we bring along with us um the day prior to the trip we collaborate in making care p packages that include gloves scarves hats um toothbrushes toothpaste um deodorant body lotion soap uh uh lots and lots of socks uh students work together

008to creates um cards designed um with words of encouragement with um warm words of cheer that you're not alone that we are in this together you're not forgotten and we see you beyond your circumstance an the day of the trip um they are eager they are excited and I often have kids saying can I come along too and I say maybe not this year but there's always next year um we even had kids who I don't even have as a student who hear about what we're doing in class saying well can't my mom just drop me off or why can't I just come and I said well you're not on our team you're not in my class I can't just bring you there's a little bit more involved with permission slips and things of that

009nature so on the day of the trip when we get there um we are divided into groups where we make um sandwiches we um make H Coco and we distribute it to the patrons um going back a little bit over the years this project has evolved to include other teachers in terms of family and consumer Sciences they bake cookies that we all Al package uh art teachers gave us a paper and the art supplies to make to design the cards um toy making Club have created toys that we bring along with us to distribute um toys to kids that we see there and uh the music teachers lend us their instruments so that we can pretend to sing and do our best to Carol um and for some strange reason we always have that smile

010and that that chair and that Applause as if we've actually sung in a concert when it's just us singing from our hearts um this year our goal was to make a 100 care packages and we were able to personally delivered them and again I'm going to allow students to speak for themselves but again the joy and the self-confidence gains through this experience is something that cannot be matched um so thank you for allowing us to share this with you today thank you for doing it so um Mr is kind of come up next so I'm going to start by echoing my principal Dr lores and said I I said yes um to to Natasha yra um this happened years ago my introduction to Natasha didn't actually involve Natasha it was um a few seventh graders

011and a Ziploc bag of chocolate and they stood at my door and asked if I wanted to go to the soup kitchen on Christmas see that's how she operates Natasha that sweet smile and contagious laugh that you hear now it's nothing more than a clever ruse I was um coerced into this and therefore hardly deserve any credit for this um Natasha is the soul of this endeavor and I'm honored to share this Podium with her as a new teacher my first thought was oh no what about the curriculum but it wasn't long before I realized uh it wasn't long before I realized that instilling the sense of community was the true essence of the job that science was merely a vehicle moving toward a much more broad definition of the word teacher I'll admit this

012vision of teaching was a bit obscured at first when I boarded the bus I was met by students dressed in sequence and practicing dance moves others were tuning instruments and singing at this point honestly I wasn't sure if I boarded a bus to St Pat kitchen or burning man um what I didn't realize was that our students took it upon themselves to not only volunteer but to entertain as they volunteered I was amazed at their enthusiasm and the general lack of fear ironically instilled in them by the adults in their life the same adults that scoffed at me days before the trip oh she dragged you to the soup kitchen I wish they could have seen this sequence clad students welcome a patron with one leg into their impromptu dance circle I would argue that

013I became a teacher when the seemingly feeble man swung from his crutches summoning the exuberance and Grace of his youth if only for a little while I became a teacher when a little girl with mismatched clothes and a glacial stare clutched her new toy with the same force that made the Stars I became a teacher when an elderly woman fought back tears while singing Amazing Grace alongside of us singing Amazing Grace alongside of us only to confess that she hasn't had a reason to sing since she was a young girl in her church choir from this shared experience I learned that beneath the harsh exteriors of some of those individuals we've been shielded from lies a teacher and yes teachers may even take the form of some of the most Bonkers seventh and eighth grade

014students and we have a lot to learn from them instead of passing judgment B your students passed out the clothes and toys they've donated instead of holding on to biases bore students hold the hands of those who are less fortunate than themselves instead of pretending to be someone somebody else B Sure students Embrace not only their true Spirit but the spirit of humanity that my generation only thinks has been eroded away from the generations that followed I'm forever thankful for that Ziploc bag of chocolate for Natasha who taught me what a teacher does for Dr lores Dr Maloney Dr pashkin Dr Outlaw Mrs cop Mrs Del University and our board of education for listening to Natasha's story most of all I'm thankful for and humbled by the students of bashore who continue to teach me

015more than I could ever possibly teach them and we'll hear from some of them now thank you [Applause] hi okay my experience at the St Patrick's soup kitchen changed my mindset on how people appreciate the little things we offer knowing that many people live on the streets the majority don't have people to love and care for them and us giving what we can it shows them we do care one lady hugged me and told me and in English that's translated to how beautiful they're doing this then I thought to myself how she appreciates the lease and take it in as more thank [Applause] you um going to the St Patrick soup kitchen and helping the people in my community was such a great experience I was able to make them hot chocolate the way they

016smiled at me with such thankful Bright Eyes made me feel so good they were all so thankful I remember specifically helping one lady and seeing how happy she was made this extra special when I saw the people taking the things I donated my heart melted it was truly an inspiring day and I can't wait to do it again someday thank you all my teachers and thank you the to the board members for giving us all this [Applause] opportunity hello my name is thius and I was at the soup kitchen with everybody else here today our wonderful teacher Miss yarboro along with our team donated toy food and clothes donations for the same Patrick's Pantry while there we met we met nice people who were grateful for our work and a kind community of Staff who

017makes us who helped us make hot chocolate and peanut butter and jellies for people who needed them it was an eye-opening experience and an awesome way to help out our community Through donations and kindness I think everyone there could agree that afterwards we felt like we had made a change no matter how big or small after helping out at the pantry I would say to anybody that if you have the time it's a great way to help out where con while connecting and engaging with your community my experience at the soup kitchen where I handed out care packages to people in need really made me think about like how can I make someone's day it could be like someone going through a very hard day and not have anybody there to take care of them

018and just me a 13-year-old boy could help them with just a care package I didn't go there because I wanted to leave school or hang up with friends but I went there because I felt good about helping someone and just wanted to make someone day hello my name is John and this is my experience at the soup kitchen when I was was there I was enjoying my time there and helping the people in need I was giving out care packages and uh and those care packages it was like socks toothbrush toothpaste a snack like chips and cards for the people that are need I also handed out other out other things like clothes and toys I really enjoyed talking to these people that were there and one old man stood out to me because I

019was talking to him a lot and watching him smile made made me happy and he was also remind me of my grandpa who I who I love and had strong connections with while I was inside I was making sandwiches and hot cocoa for the people and I was enjoying making them for the people that are in need and when I left I was happy that I was able to put smiles on the people and that was my experience at the soup kitchen and I would love to do it again thank you so very much uh it was a pleasure to hear all of your experiences thank you for showing up we really appreciate you we thank our uh teachers Mrs yo and Mr for being here as well and helping to lead the way and

020um next year they're ready for it so thank you so much for the opportunity to present thank you I can't thank you enough before you get away from us here and just to let you know that you embody and ideal that we all hold near and dear that this district is part of the fabric of this community and this community is part of the fabric of this school and we couldn't have done any better thank you very EXC you're amazing what I like to hear is you know what you realize you made a change and you change for good helping one another it's all about it really is when you reach out and you do things for other people it's so much easier than just looking the other way so congratulations I think it's fantastic

021on behalf of the board the board would like to recognize all the students that participated along with the staff but we have a certificate of recognition from the board of education for each of the students who are here this evening so we're going to present that with you and we also have all of the students that helped out who weren't able to come tonight so that could be distributed to the rest of the team so I'm going to call you up back up here and then if anyone has any additional questions for the we'd like to get a picture with we like to get a a picture of stud together so just in order of the presentations Julie stay up here okay yeah come on over here and next we have m you're welcome thank

022you and tus next you and next we have I think Randy was next yes job Randy and finally John all right so I think we're going to our Pictou [Applause] that was great great here okay ready everybody's gonna look here first and big smiles okay now don't move everybody else pictures to I got it thank [Applause] you that's a great one it's not that that yeah where's your articles now let the yeah the kid should go yeah the kid should go huh no it's low no Mine mine's all low now I got a new phone don't you make it bigger thanks thanks Tosh thing freaking give it to the kids to fix for you iPhone I oh yeah don't forget that remember how big it was look at the text thanks EV thanks again great

023presentation next we have a dual enrollment partnership with Liu post Lee P thank you Miss Benelli if you remember last time during our last meeting we had some members from our IB leadership team that came and spoke a little bit about uh the work that they're doing towards not only the diploma program but towards the career certificate program and if you recall Miss Peterson mentioned that one of the tasks is that uh in addition to IB classes students need to take classes that are accredited by organizations outside of the school so so um and Mr leech had already started doing some of some of this work with some of the other classes but uh this evening he has a few more classes that he's looking for uh opportunities for dual enrollment in Co for college

024credit for our students so I'll turn it over to him thank you Kev thank you it's a tough act to follow amaz um so as Mr cashing said we're we're here to talk about um some dual enrollment opportunities through Liu post uh and as you know in the science department we're always looking for new opportunities for our students whether it's new technologies or experiential learning activities uh and one of the things that we've done is we introduce the introduction to archite architecture and construction college credit bearing course through farming Dell State College we also introduced the Syracuse University project Advance forensics course that we're going to be offering for the first time this coming September our teachers are officially trained and we have the textbook ready to go um um and I've been in discussions

025with Liu post about two of our more popular elective classes which are anatomy and physiology and Medical Careers so these two classes are definitely classes that students show extreme interest in every year they fill the capacity and we have students that would like to take it and are always looking for an open seat and when I reached out to Liu post I spoke with Dr Adams who uh is the head of he's the dean of professional studies who oversees their High School Scholars Program he said that the courses that we offer are definitely aligned with the two classes that they would be able to offer for college credit which is um really great so um many of our students are likely going to go into the field of medicine there's a really strong interest in

026it and being able to introduce this class will allow them to see what the Collegiate level work for this type of a a career track might look like and be able to give them a leg up in their College admission process being being able to show that they've already taken some courses in this field um in speaking with Dr Adams I've learned some really great things and one of the most important things is that what we're doing fits the mold so much that we would not need to do any major overhauls to these courses they already fit into the mold of what they are looking for we would just need to include their course description and student learning outcomes and the reason for that is just it helps out with other institutions if they don't

027go to Liu post they'll be able to look at the the course subscription provided by Liu so they can be awarded credit uh wherever they end up do going um the topics align really well and um the other thing is we would not need to change the fact that these are halfe courses so our students would be able to earn four college credits for taking anatomy and physiology in a half year then if they continue on uh with Mr P gallopoulos in to the Medical Careers course they would be able to earn another three college credits for that course course um if the students wanted to sign up for college credit it would be $290 that they would pay in order to obtain those credits regardless of whether it's a four credit class or a

028three credit class so that's a it's a good bargain um and in my discussions with Dr Adams there are a few other courses that would be uh that we would have the potential to uh offer as dual enrollment such as our marine biology electives um and as Mr pashkin mentioned before with the IB career related program we do need courses that are going to be um uh through accredited institutions so that our students could complete the pathways and one of the ones that Miss Peterson is looking to create is a stem pathway so these courses would fit really nicely into that and allow our students to uh not only obtain college credit but help to uh pave the way for them to be able to participate in the IB career related program um so we're

029looking to hopefully finalize our conversation with Liu post in the next couple of months the deadline to submit the paperwork is March 31st um and I appreciate your consideration and I'm happy to answer any questions you might have all I know is my my daughter is she wants to see those boards she loves all the stuff she's going through the medical field and you know what the more you do for these kids in this field the better they're going to be in life they have one pathway they can go and we could just keep helping them yeah challenge them the boards to come a presentation course to start so I didn't look down much but uh this would be a great opportunity uh Mr P is already working we've been trained on how to use

030the anatomage tables and so that class actually starts Monday and so he's very excited uh we've had about six other biology teachers who were trained in them as well so uh we're we're getting our feet wet we're learning how to use it and then there's no doubt that this technology will help our students to further their understanding of the anatomy and physiology and Medical Careers classes so they would definitely be involved as well long time stuff bring the board to us yeah we bring the board to you bring us to or do we get to do do we get a field trip out to ass we can do a field trip if you like but I think it' probably be easier to bring it here um just a so for the children that or the

031students they're not children anymore kind of um at this level the students that aren't going to do the too much credit so they're getting a college level course still that rigor of academics right and that kind of that displays on their that's not thew but um like that shows on their transcript right that they take yes so wouldn't have to sign up for the college credit um they would still be able to audit the class take the classes as if they would and they would still receive the high school credit that would count towards graduation but yes um you know depending on what we name the course it'll definitely show up on the transcript that they've taken a rigorous course awesome that's a great idea great stuff okay thank you very much next we have

032a policy update policy updates our second read uh po Mr Torres Joe good evening good evening so the last time you were we were here before you um we discussed or least we we thrilled you about the updates uh that that nisb proposes that we make to our current policy 8130 the copy you have in front of you now reflects the uh the updates that we recommended and we discussed in some some detail thank you Miss castelli and as as they're written currently we recommend they be adopted any questions so you Incorporated the things you talked about adding to it last time yes sir yeah okay this will be at the next meeting Yes actually February 26 26 good beautiful thank you for your work and then M finger on district school district records policy

033all right so this was policy 1120 um and nisba is recommending that you include something um about public officers law uh which is part of Freedom of Information requiring public agencies to develop a policy to notify employees whenever the district is responding to a request to their disciplinary records forent to foil they are saying that you could do a standalone policy but they're recommending that you put it uh Ed it here into 1120 um and the two changes that we discussed were adding a line that said we believe that if or or that consistent uh that we will even if there is nothing in an employees disciplinary records to provide the district will still notify the employee of the request after it responds uh to the person who made the foil I just felt this

034sentence should be included in there because I don't think it's really implicit in there I think you kind of have to read into that so we added that and we changed the number of days that we had to respond to 10 days rather than five and I think we're good unless anybody has any changes they'd like to make any questions no good Fair all right thank you very much H this will be uh again at the next end of February meeting now we go into our first of our budget session briefings okay fiscal year 2025 26 if you can believe that budget presentation number one we are going to start out with the budget timeline um you know we put this together this is mostly for Caitlyn who has to put some notices in the

035newspaper and then Christina and I who put together uh the our schools the six day notice uh the materials that are left in all the buildings in the local library the budget materials that we place there every year um and then preparing for the hearing that we have on Monday night the week Pro prior to the vote I think the only thing on here this year that is of note is that April 23rd date because there was some back and forth with ingr about whether that board meeting on that Wednesday should be moved to Monday or Tuesday I think uh you may be hearing more from Dr Maloney on that did we make a decision on that we're going to leave it did we leave the 23rd 23rd we're going to leave at the 23rd

036okay vote as well so okay very good I don't think that that's a problem um not the way that I read the all the timelines that came out from the state what was the question it is okay what was the question on why was there even a question because the date that you had to adopt yeah I think ingerman was recommending Monday or Tuesday to adopt so we had talked about moving the board meeting date but number of days before the vote is that what we're talking about or yes but really there is no so there is no legislative date by which you must adopt the budget there is only that you must submit the property tax report card to the state within 24 hours of adopting the budget and according to the state the

037property tax report card doesn't need to be submitted until Saturday the 26th um so we're fine with the 23rd um I just wanted you if you we had a little bit of conversation about that and what we were going to do other than that there's nothing on here remarkable [Music] um town of iel school property tax rates and I think Christina split this onto two sheets for me the first one is the Homestead the next one is the non-homestead or commercial I always like to point things out on this on this little sheet here and this year what I thought was very interesting was I give you the averages down here less um less the districts that are in more than one Township right so we take out hop hog and station because it's not

038really a good comparison so the average 3.18 as usual we come in just underneath 3.07 which is good you look at the other ielp districts can see I very high but wait till you see the commercial um and then look at East IP and West iseland and again and so we're not counting hop hog we're not counting Saum so actually when you look at us withj the town of iel districts we actually did very well especially considering we had two flat levies the two prior years saal was a little high there Dr Colony yes they were yes they were all right but now look at the non Homestead at the same district look at CI 10.25 after and and with a really high increase to their Homestead as well and now look at East I

039slip and West I slip and look what's going on with their base proportions on the commercial property the average was a negative 1.6 and again um well negative 1.14 so we're in the ballpark a little bit less but hopefully that's a sign where these proportions are going to start trending back in the right direction ction so let's look at those it's my favorite little page here all right your first two lines are assessed values so this is a fiveyear look back at assessed values these things are most interesting not from year to year but when you look at how they Trend so 2020 21 482 we were trending downward 4817 489 then in 2324 you know there's a ton of construction going on right so now our assess values are trending back upward again that

040is a good sign now if you look at the base proportions you will see what's happened to us uh why our tax rate increases have been a little bit higher than our budget increases because in 2021 we were picking up 65% of the total Levy then it went to 65.8 66.9 67 .7 68.3 so fiveyear trending the homeowners over commercial property have had to pick up addition an additional three and a half% of the total Levy which is significant right shifted from commercial property over on to homeowners don't you feel that with all that construction that's been going on in our town you think it would kind of shift the other way yes but it it runs behind it runs late but I do believe that yes I do believe that you know by the

041time the office of real property gets this data and they have time to process it and they have time to to look at it government just tends to lag behind in things like this but I believe that after a five-year Trend in One Direction you will start to see this shift can you remind me where apartment buildings are they commercial or they no I think they fall on Homestead it depends on depends on the extent to which they are like something like a trch right is actually out your assessments completely because they're pilot so and many of our larger and more recent installations of Apartments have been piloted as well so they're not even on the books at all what about like the little 20 to 30 I mean there's a ton of them that

042have popped up over the last right those I those I think all come under another time coming this year there's a whole bunch coming right now too and there's a time span on the pilot all the pilots have their own time span they're all negotiated separately so they all have different dollar amounts different time spans do we know what Trinity I know we know what Trinity was weren't they five years or something like that Trac was was long 10 or 15 years it was the longest one we've seen was it was really long we've never seen one like that and now they're going to sell but right now our P when I started here our Pilots were $200,000 a year and right now we're up to about a million5 and the tax break stays with

043it that that shouldn't be the that's not legal you you you signed for tax break and then you're going to sell the property who do they sell it to they sell it to somebody it's an investment per person and then they move on yeah they're really not property managers we said that from the beginning they're that that should be something that when you borrow from the taxpayers and you get all that money and you get those breaks that's where that's where they should say we're going to be stuck in that town with that town for 20 years no they sell it and move on yeah my my concern is and and that tax break stays with whoever buys it that's wrong too yeah like I mean the pilots are obviously a problem but my concern

044is you know like you're saying it should swing back because it's cyclical but if you throw all these apartments and they live in Homestead they keep pulling out they're out youring our Homestead which hurts our homeowners right like that's yep it's more and more assessed value that gets pulled out I mean fortunately the assessed value right now the last two years is trending in the right direction so let's hope that continues uh and let's hope base proportion starts to swing back the other way um and where do um where do nonprofits fall in that because you know because the other big construction is the hospital they're not even assessed so they're so that doesn't affect commercial at all no no tax exempt um but you can see when we just looked at East IP and

045West I and they had such large reductions to their commercial uh rates you can see that they're they're seeing the same Trend right um and then on this one I also wanted to point out one more time you have under your revenues just remember what's happened the last couple years so we were at about 50 million we had about a55 million do uh state aid increase we had another large State increase state aid increase another large State a increase right this was as they finally made good on Foundation Aid because we were about $20 million a year behind receiving about $20 million a year less than what our formula than the Adar formula would have driven to us so now we're finally made whole um but if you look at our tax levy 113 115

046115 115 and then 117 so we have only increased the tax levy by $45 million in the last five fiscal years which is pretty good pretty good we have done well we pretty much gave all of that state aid back to the taxpayers a bore okay time anatomy of a budget code we'll do this one really I know you guys love this one every year we'll we'll do this really quickly school districts in New York state required to use a standard system for classifying and coding accounting transactions why because it allows for comparisons to be made whether it's We compare ourselves to ourselves over different Financial periods or whether we compare our school district to another school district we all use the same alpha numeric system of account codes the alpha part is your fund

047the general fund is the a fund that is the only one that you really need to worry about even though we have eight eight funds nine funds U the general fund is your big fund and that's what gets put out to vote every year so that is the a fund then you move on to the numeric portion of the budget code the same account code number is used across all funds it doesn't matter if it's the a fund the P fund the S fund that doesn't matter the the account codes are the same across all of the alpha funds you start with function this is your function chart this is how generally speaking uh public education is is broken up General support really is your uh central office instruction is everything instruction Transportation Community Services

048we don't use that's if you have a a PM School uh employee benefits Debt Service interfund transfers these are your large categories however the state came up with this many many many years ago and this is what we all use and what we have been using for so many years they have left it but decided that they don't like the the way that this distributes the budget they want the taxpayers to be able to see the budget a little bit differently that's why they came up with some of the uh reporting mechanisms that we use including right now they're they want to see it in a three-part budget which we'll talk about a little bit later uh so all of the numbers have to be disaggregated and reaggregated because they can't really move away from

049this which they set up such a very long time ago so these are your broad categories then you can begin to drill down those were your function codes then you move to your object code so in the the example that we used I think we used a 1325 uh which is an accounting code and then 4100 the 4100 would be the object code here you have the ones personal services it's payroll right uh whether it's certificated staff or non-certificated staff they're both ones if you look at the chart down below you'll see that we can drill further we can go uh 0.10 0.11 0.12 this is how you divide salaries whether it's between prek kindergarten k6 712 you just keep drilling down on the number to make yourself additional codes but the one is the

050ones are all payroll the twos are all equipment purchases fours are all contractual uh and we use five for supplies even though the state does not the state uses four five we use five all right so that's how you can drill down on those those are your object codes and then you can drill down again to location codes and each one of our locations each one of our buildings and uh some of our larger departments each have their own location code that we can drill down to so if you were looking at an a 2110 is instruction 4100 is contractual 14 that would be Gardener Manor right and then you could go once more if you wanted to and you could put in what's called a program code which we use only in the special

051projects or the grants budget we do uh we do drill down all the way to project codes because their fiscal year does not match with our fiscal year many of them run from September 1 to August 31st so we have to carry them over multiple fiscal years so we actually drill down to a project code level year by year morning is there any is there any consistency with other districts because obviously they don't have the same buildings that we have Etc they're all the same it's it's every we're all on the same uniform but with the object codes it's not though right yeah the object codes are all the same so so I'm going to say um health and fizet will be 30 in another District as well or is that unique to Bay sure

052no no the location codes are unique to B okay right so they would their own their buildings would be would be unique to them but your function codes and your object codes are all the same and and in terms of the location codes do other districts also have location codes or is that just something that we they we have to now now because of the the federal fiscal transparency that we file at the end of the right y it's it's building by building okay yeah so now the location codes are actually quite important uh we're splitting up expenditures that we never used to split up before and it's it's gets more complicated every year okay state aid uh when we sent you home the budget presentation on Friday uh the state aid page was essentially

053blank so Caitlyn handed out the new update updated page this is the new updated page um so what we want to focus on tonight and I say this every year but because the state has done so much to build predictability into the state aid formulas this is becoming less and less of a thing but when the state releases their state aid runs they compare the governor's proposal with the current law budget so basically what happens is after we file our financial statements from the previous year we don't just file the previous year's financial statements we also file our budget for the year that we're in so the state readjusts our state aid based upon our budget they will then readjust it again once the fiscal year finishes and we file our financial statements it'll get

054adjusted yet again but when the governor puts out proposal she compares her proposal to what we call current law typically there's a a big difference between your what you estimated the estimated are the numbers that we used when we built the budget last year those are the numbers that I'm interested in right I need to compare what we're going to get to what we budgeted last year not to what the current law says we're going to get now there are years when there could easily be a million dollar difference but what it does is it inflates her numbers when she puts them out it makes them look like they're much larger than they actually are but this is becoming less and less of a thing I mean you can see now there's only there's a

055$100,000 difference between $125,000 difference between the estimate and current law because they really have done a good job of making the state a formulas more predictable um so that we don't have these large discrepancies so our two big changes this year are found a where we are actually getting a $2.5 million increase if you looked at Governor's proposal versus current law which as I'm telling you don't look at that right we are we want to see the governor's proposal versus the estimated because that's what we budgeted last year so you can see right there that the increase is just a little bit lower than what the state is reporting the state's reporting a 2 point almost a $2.6 million increase but in effect if we compare it to last year's budgeted number it's about .3

056million increase it brings it down about a half a percent she looks more generous than she is uh and we have a bigger difference to make up right the rest of these not so you know these are normal fluctuations year to year nothing really uh remarkable and then we look at building Aid as we've been discussing for the last year or so um our 2002 Bond referendum uh the payments are starting to fall off the books and so as those payments fall off the books the building Aid that comes back to support those payments also falls off the books right so we have a $2.2 million decrease so $2.2 million increase $2.2 million decrease right washes each other out we end up down here $3,622 so basically our state aid is flat this year so

057we're moving into a budget knowing that we're not expecting any additional state aid and then I just I kind of highlighted this because this sort of made my point here so here's the governor's proposal this is our upk Aid right which doesn't even go into the general fund that's why it's on a line below all by itself it doesn't flow through the general fund it flows through the Special Projects fund but this 3345 is our number that's what we get every single year unless we wrote a new Grant current law is showing what we're actually spending and because we are not maxed out and we have some seats available what we are going to receive is less than what's budgeted for us so but it looks like if you were to look at the governor's

058proposal versus current law it looks like we're getting an increase of $236,000 but we're not that number this is our allocation this is our actual use but when she Compares them it looks like there was an increase there is no increase see and this is how that's why I say these numbers are they don't necessarily always need tell the right story um and state has a story that they want to tell and I'm going to tell you what the actual story is because that's not it saying show me the money yeah I put that for me and Dr Maloney I am I am done I done um this is just one last page this is tax cap um this is a draft I do not have to file I filed this on March 1st but

059even what we file on March 1st is not set in stone I still have the opportunity right up until the time that you adopt the budget to to change this so I am still carefully looking at the exclusions you can see that I raised the estimate on Pilots because as we just said pilot payments continue to rise as town of iscp offers that to more and more Builders they're pulling that they're pulling out that assessed value and uh asking for these payments in lie of uh an actual tax payment that's what pilot is payments in lie of taxes right so this is from the time that I started here this was probably a $200,000 Revenue category now it's it's going to hit 1.5 probably next year uh but the exclusions are really what's interesting here

060and this is going to change some depending on what we do with the the capital project Debt Service that is falling off the books the building Aid that we we are losing um and some of the plans some of the things that we have been discussing uh as far as bonding so we will definitely look at this this is a very uh dirty draft I really need to spend some time with this and kind of project this out over a few years so don't Focus too much attention on this this is definitely going to change all right and that's it may have any questions I'm good for now anybody else take it all in all right that ends our agenda for work session does she have anything else Steve no we're good work session motion

061second all in favor I I we need a break we go right into public let's go uh motion to go into public session motion second all in favor opposed all right if you stand please for the pledge Andy you want to take this out Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all all right gu okay I don't know if I left my public session do you have the public session now what I inside I don't have the one with the uh we go I need to get his paper excuse me all right there any uh questions or comments from the audience on agenda items before we get going just on the agenda items I'll

062read this opening comments on the uh on the items not on the agenda will be heard after adjournment of the public meeting please limit your comments to 3 minutes the board board May recognize a speaker not more than twice on the same topic please feel free to give the board any additional comments in writing when you are recognized state your name for the district clerk neither the Board of Education nor the superintendent of schools will entertain in public comments relating to a personal matter or individual students uh Personnel matter Please be aware that both staff and student privacy are protected under the law if you have a Personnel qu a concern or an issue regarding a staff member or students you can call the superintendent at the uh phone number listed on the agenda uh

063we have presentation before we get yes we're can actually call up Mr Rell director of culture arts to recognize one of our middle school students and again every year we have a holiday card and this year um actually you know we get a lot of submissions this one overwhelmingly by far was really unique so we want to recognize that student this evening and I'm going to turn it over to Mr Rella thank you Dr Maloney is Savannah in here come on up Savannah I'm G to miss miss Turan unfortunately couldn't be here with us tonight Savannah I think she talk to you today but she she had nothing but the highest praise for Savannah and this is what she wrote Savannah is an art student in the e8th grade Advanced studio art program she learned

064how to use prismacolor pencils by studying the Light Shadows and colors of a red and white candy can remember that Savannah observed the way colors reflected off one another and how shadows and highlights affected the colors and created form she learned how to use complimentary colors to create the observed shadow and then expertly applied them to her drawing Savannah worked diligently to create a colorful ACC accurate and brilliant piece of work and I if you you I'm sure you've all seen it by this point she did an amazing job creating that beautiful candy cane that was put on the front cover of our card and I want to congratulate her personally congratulations Savannah is a true Testament to the art program that we have here in the bayaw school system thank you Savannah should have

065something to show this to everybody this is a beautiful job that is unbelievable congratulations [Applause] get one more sure San can we get one more with with you please your parents want to come down too watch that Court r [Applause] okay start with the agenda page A1 motion to approve Board of Education meetings of the executive work and public sessions of December 22 2024 and the executive work and public sessions of January 88 2025 motion second any questions all in favor I I I opposed so carried page B1 Mr pasin on page B1 the board will find a motion to approve the professional staff requests for leave as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried B2 on page B2 the board will find a motion to

066approve the professional staff appointments as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried B3 on page B3 the board will find a motion to approve the professional staff salary changes as presented we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor give me give me a second the gun all in favor I opposed so carry uh B4 B4 a on page B4 to b4a the board will find a motion to approve the Civil Service resignations and retirements as l listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page B5 b5a on page B5 to b5a the board will find a motion to approve the civil service request for leave as listed we recommend its approval motion second any

067questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page B6 b6a on page B6 to b6a the board will find a motion to approve the Civil Service appointments as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page B7 b7a on page B7 to b7a the board will find a motion to approve the list of substitutes substitute appointments we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page B8 on page B8 the board will find a motion to approve the Civil Service reinstatements as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page B9 b9a on page B9 to b9a the board will find a motion to approve the civil service changes in

068assignment as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page B10 b10a on page B10 to b10a the board will find a motion to approve the Civil Service salary changes as listed we recommend it approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page b11 on page b11 the board will find a motion to approve the volunteer and volunteer athletic coach es for the 2425 school year as presented we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page B12 B12 a through b on page B12 and b12 a through b the board will find a motion to approve the coaches ex schedule and salaries for the Department of Health physical education Athletics for the 2425

069school year as presented we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so Carri p uh page B13 on page B13 the board will find a motion to approve the professional staff resignations and retirements as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I oppos so carried Miss finger page C1 on page C1 on page C1 the board will find a motion to approve the budget revision presented we recommend its approval motion second uh any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page C2 C2 a through L on pages C2 and C2 a through L the board app a motion to accept and place on file the internal audit report and the associated corrective action plan for the 2023 24 school year as

070presented we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page C3 on page C3 the board will find a motion to adopt a resolution designating the Bayshore Board of Education as lead agency uh in the projects uh listed which are considered unlisted type two actions for purposes of secra uh and this includes the boiler replacement at Mary G Clarkson uh boiler replacement of Gardner Manor and boiler replacement at the Bayshore Middle School we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I I opposed so carried C4 on page C4 the bo the board will find a motion to approve the new exemption allowing volunteer firefighter and ambulance workers with as little as two years of of active volunteerism a 10% real property tax exemption prior to

071this it they were required to have 5 years of active volunteerism we're low lowering that threshold to two years we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so Carri page C5 on page C5 the board will find a motion to authorize the Personnel listed to receive a mile mileage allowance for travel within the district uh at a rate of7 cents or a15 per mile upon submission of properly certified bills and tabulations effective January 1 2025 consistent with the IRS rate we recommend its approval motion second that was my question if it was consistent with the IRA IRS rate uh any questions others all in favor I oppos so carried page C6 on page C6 the board will find a motion to award the bid for security guard uniforms to

072the lowest bidder Hill specialty Inc uh in an amount not to exceed $1,558 180 we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page C7 on page C7 the board will find a motion to declare as obsolete the items listed uh which which were from the bore High School cultural arts department we recommend its approval so these items might be disposed of accordingly motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page C8 on pages C8 and C8 a through D the board will find a motion uh again to declare as obsolete the technology equipment as listed so that it can be disposed of accordingly we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I I opposed so carried go on to uh

073D1 D1 Dr Outlaw on page D1 the board will find a motion to endorse actions taken by the bore committee on special education pertaining to students being considered for services as noted in the CSC minutes listed and referrals for December of 2024 and January of 2025 we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I oppos page D2 on page D2 the board will find a motion to endorse actions taken by the Bay Shore committee on preschool special education for students being considered for preschool Services as noted in the minutes listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried D3 on page D3 the board to find a motion to approve the undue burden independent evaluator hardship waiver resolution we recommend its approval motion

074second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page D4 and on page D4 the board will find a motion to adopt the individual home instruction plans on behalf of the students listed for the 2425 school year we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried Dr Maloney page E1 E1 a through G on page E1 E1 a through G the board fired a motion to approve and hereby authorize the board president pres to execute the contract with the State University of New York at postan for the purose of student observation in the field workor we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page E2 E2 a through C on page E2 E2 a through C the board find

075a motion to approve a stipulation agreement dated January 15 2025 is presented we recommend its approval motion second all in favor any questions sorry any questions all in favor I I opposed so carry that brings us to the end of this evening's agenda enough comments uh Mr Borland John Borland yes good evening I'm John Borland and uh I'm here again once once again unfortunately on behalf of a community that's been pleading with the board over a year to do what's right um I say unfortunately because I'm a longtime resident of this district and there's so many things to be proud of unfortunately I I don't think this is one of them the crimes of Mr Bern GOI and the um the district's response are not something I'm proud of um I know that a town

076hall was promised at one point or it was discussed a chance to have honest dialogue about a path forward uh that never materialized instead it seems to me that what we're experiencing is a result of negotiations that with with lawyers behind closed doors costing what I can only imagine is millions in legal fees and dragging survivors through courtrooms instead of stepping up to settle cases that a self County jury has already declared that we're liable for I believe that every day that we delay Justice we open and keep the wounds festering of these survivors um I don't believe that anything is going to really correct the wrongs perpetrated against these victims but I know for certain that hiring a PR firm is not going to fix this I believe like working with Community leaders to

077explore real solutions like maybe um raising funds through Bond sales to settle these cases fairly might begin to do some healing and this isn't just about money you know this is this is a moral issue um it's about integrity it's about honesty these are words that I want my district to be associated with survivors need you to do the right thing residents have implored you to bring transparency and accountability to this process unfortunately I don't think these have materialized yet on personal friends with more than one victim of Bern Go's crimes and they you know most of the time when I speak to them they express concerns for current students uh and and future students that you know they're worried that you know due to their the the district's reaction and the current handling of

078it they're worried about the future of these children Bayer is a strong Community I know this um but I think something like this is testing testing its resiliency um the victims of these crimes deserve resolution and they deserve healing and closure and I think our taxpayers also deserve honesty and responsible leadership and our children deserve to be protected and we need to send a message that they will be um I think enough is enough I think the time has come to resolve these cases um Bayo needs this to happen so thank [Applause] you next Betsy Flanigan hello again so we've been a lot we've been through a lot as a community and what I hope to get out of this aside from all of these cases to be settled is strong policies in place so

079that all of our current and future students will be safe I want my children to go to a school where the culture and climate makes them feel safe enough to go to a trusted staff member if needed I want a culture and climate and policy where staff members know exactly what to do and how to report any claims or allegations I want there to be follow through clear investigative policies and practice most importantly I want our community to be educated about this more than just vague words like things are different now we have practices in place there has been a major loss in trust and those vague empty words aren't good enough anymore I want details of how things are different I want education for us parents and community members I know you've said you

080can't discuss policies during ongoing liation but I also noticed a new policy that was added in 2024 that referenced this litigation and investigations so I got a little confused if this is what's best for our students and keeping them safe there is no reason why we can't add policies on this as per your policies it is the job of the superintendent to bring these new policies to the table Mr Maloney I ask you to do just that we need it and we're asking for it as I stated we want all of the cases settled I think many of us have made that clear over previous board meetings two things can exist at the same time we can support the cases being settled for these men and for closure to do the right thing I can

081also want to know and be educated about how the payments of these settlements might look I know that there are things that can't be shared maybe we don't know everything but there is information that's public knowledge and there's still some things that are being worked out but what can be shared what should be shared educate us educate us about the bonds how are they paid what does that look like with regard to the payment structure who repays that what is that going to look like in our taxes I know we didn't have to vote on the bond but as taxpayers we deserve to be educated about the details how does it work what what might it look like we want to be prepared we support it but we also want to know so we can

082be prepared what we've always asked for is information education John mentioned that town hall we just want to know what's going on we don't want the vague words educate us help us tell us what's going on please thank you [Applause] Mary retali good evening everyone I'm going to begin my comments by just setting the stage for who I am and why I'm here and then I'd like to speak to the issues that are in front of all of us my name's Mary Ralia I live with my husband Pete and Brightwaters we've been residents of the bashore community for the past 46 years our adult children children Kate and Pete both live in the community with their spouses and children they're graduates of the Bayshore schools we have three grandchildren ages 92 and four months old

083our granddaughter attends school in Bayshore we chose to stay in Bayshore send our kids to school here and we were always so proud of the education they received now I'm not so sure about the district or do I feel proud of what I'm witnessing I am a life long educator having proudly served 5 years as a teacher here in Bayshore School District at Fifth Avenue school then as an assistant principal here for two years at fifth in Brook Avenue School I began and supervised the universal pre kindergarten program here I'm proud of this District I continued my career in the Half Hollow Hills School District as an Elementary kindergarten through sixth grade school principal a middle school principal and ultimately an assistant superintendent of Elementary education I've developed curriculum with colleagues supervising faculty and staff

084for seven schools and most importantly caring for over 5,000 students at the height of our enrollment I have experience interacting with legal council in school Personnel matters I know full well the limitations of what can be discussed in public and in the legal advice provided by Council to administrators and Boards as to what can be discussed in public what I also know is that strong leadership can demonstrate empathy and care for victims at the very least without compromising your legal limitations empathy that reaches out to the community with a commitment to do better in ensuring something this horrendous never happens again given my experience as a school district administrator it is unimaginable to me that this issue was never properly handled at the first hint of sexual abuse in the classroom by a teacher my

085comments this evening reflect deep concern and sadness for the victims of Decades of child sexual abuse perpetuated in the Bayshore schools by a former teacher this deep concern and sadness is further compounded by silence Silence from the board and administration in expressing empathy for the victims and outlining policy and procedure improvements as they relate to the child victims act I believe we can agree the unthinkable sexual abuse that these young victims EXP experienced who were not protected or believed by trusted adults is forever life altering we can never know how hard it was for these victims to come forward even after they were denied the support from trusted adults maybe this did not happen under your watch even more reason to be outraged and steadfast in working to ensure that this will never happen again

086as a result of a miscalculation in the pursuit of a jury trial the district was found liable and negligent and Reckless disregard for failing to investigate a third grade teacher and keeping him employed despite multiple allegations he sexually abused students the jury found the district 100% responsible for the alleged abuse of the plaintiff in the case of the former teacher resulting in a $25 million award to the victim still cases remain unresolved and victims hang in the balance I recognize that some cases have been settled out of the court but there still has been no public statement by the board recognizing our community's heart-felt sorrow and apology to the victims and their families the bayaw community and our school district finds itself at a Crossroads now one defined by the weight of past failures and

087the promise of future accountability the choices made now will determine whether bashore becomes a symbol of enduring denial or a beacon of meaningful reform there is no way around this the only path forward is through the opportunity if the board and administration will own it is to not only atone for the P but to make Bay sure the gold standard for how you deal with these situations going forward that is the only way to recover from this the only way to not be seen forever as the place that allowed this to happen the board and administration face a choice maintain the perception of the bash show School District as the district that allowed a Serial sexual predator to roam the halls for three decades abusing students and then Tred to avoid responsibility for it or

088lead it toward becoming the district that owned its past made every effort to make good on it and now has the strongest commitment to student safety in New York state becoming the Benchmark example of policies practices and commitments that prevent abuse of all kinds and guarantee to the community that this will never happen again my greatest disappointment is that the school board has shown little or no public concern or effort directed at the healing of the survivors our neighbors our children our grandchildren nor have we heard anything about strengthening policies for the future I thank you for your time this evening [Applause] Mr Bano I'm rich Bano it's my wife noren we both have a few comments to make we've been in Bayshore uh Brightwaters for 52 years our kids went to the Bayshore schools

089uh throughout their uh education and knew many uh of the students who were involved in this abuse from Mr Bern GOI we're close to many of the families and we suffer along with them and watch the fam suffer for a number of years but I won't go over the history uh Mary did a wonderful job in covering that one of our concerns is the community's concern how it's going to impact the school district financially and them they the taxpayers financially we have heard we're not certain that this is true but we have reliable sources that the rest of the victims over 20 uh who have not been settled are covered by insurance insurance can expeditiously resolve these cases is much quicker without a fight without further litigation without uh relying on uh a variety of

090other Tech techniques that lawyers sometimes use to extend cases if this is true I think the community needs to know that the insurance companies have uh made available uh coverage for the rest of the students which would certainly mitigate the volume and the cost of this to the district so if this is true we hope uh that the board can acknowledge this to the community and let people know uh that there is future for settling uh these cases noren has just a couple of comments thank you I too have been here before and I you may hear some reiteration from my standing other school districts on Long Island that were in this predicament sold bonds and had their insurance carriers reimburse them so they could expedite the process for the sake of the victims after

091speaking to you in October I left the board meeting with hope because you expressed some empathy for the victims at least one of you I believe that I had an inaccurate understanding about your caring for the victims because that you then proceeded to appeal a jury's decision that the school district was responsible on every count liable for all actions you are question questioning a jury's finding and I am questioning your empathy I and others are beginning to question your understanding of how to best use our money I and others are beginning to question many of the statements you have made these are not money grubbing men we know they are not and that's very very important for the community to know these cases could have been settled early on saving the district lots of money

092I no longer ask you to to listen with your hearts now I ask you to listen with your heads and before much money is spent on the district's lawyers and a PR firm with a three-digit number I ask you to settled quickly a blue ribbon commission would have saved the district a lot of money if you don't know what that is that you know you can people of of uh good standing in the community who could have done some investigating rather than the pr firm that's costing so much money uh you Cho you chose otherwise now it is time to choose correctly you have the tools I no longer attempt to appeal to your moral obligation that has been appealed to by me and many others to no avail now I appeal to the reputation

093and practicality of the those making the decisions and holding the purse strings you the board and Dr Maloney I love Bayshore my children loved Bayshore School District please please fulfill your obligation and settle quickly before you cost this District so much money thank you [Applause] I'm GNA say geres is it Mr geres or Mr uh Jack did you just sign in would you like to get up to say I didn't know I speaking as neighbor of three gentlemen were part of unfortunate Ur who I I had no idea until two months ago uh and I've known these three guys these three men uh all their lives and my heart goes out to every single one of them um it's my Earnest hope that I know how legal things become in this world um but I

094think In fairness to everyone uh Expediting a settlement would be welcomed by the taxpayers and by the individuals involved thank [Applause] you uh there's anybody else who did not sign in who would like to get up and speak you're welcome hello my name is ajaya Hill and I'm here to speak about the injustices and targeting I endured as a special education par professional in this district from teachers other staff members and administration from March to September of 2024 I've been silenced targeted because of my race this is you repeat again what you wanted to speak to us about this is a Personnel matter yes now you're going to have to take that up privately which which we welcome you to do you can come into district office I've tried already that's why I'm here you've

095tried and been refused to speak with who yes I've spoken to many people I'm sure my case has gone across the board to so many people so I'm not allowed to say what I'm about to say uh not not in not at a public session that's this isn't the forum for it I'm sorry but you're allowed to say what you want to say and I'm not sure who you've spoken to at district office have you spoken I think it's have hand office okay anything else that's not a Personnel issue all right thank you very much for your comments uh rules and this is a part of my frustration just a second I read the rules before we went out here the rules are listed in the front of the agenda I don't make them up

096they're just there they're not just there but they exist and there they're something we go by we're not talking about Personnel issues here this is not the for to uh engage in negotiations or representations as a union or Personnel representative this is not the Forum I'm sorry uh I don't know what else to say about it okay great so how who can I follow up with to talk to about this matter because I've tried many times my office you can call Dr malo's office and you can speak to him directly okay if you have trouble getting to Dr Maloney I'm easy to find and you can give me a call and I'll make sure you get through but that won't be necessary I know you're all here looking for answers and and uh there were

097a couple comments in the is I'm not going to address all the comments that were made uh we're not going to do that in this form the answers that you're seeking to certain questions regarding our insurance regarding how we're going to pay for this how it's going to affect taxpayers are all going to be answered this is a work that's in progress It's a very frustrating thing for me to be involved in uh Mr ralat said that uh this may not have happened on our watch well no it's not a question of May it did not happen on our watch this happened decades ago nobody involved in this school district had anything to do with what's going on right now this has been dumped in our lap and we're doing the best we can to

098make sure that this District comes out whole uh I did not know any of the uh victims I knew them many of them but I did not know them as friends I knew their parents as friends as everybody here did we're all part of this community and to uh come here and be upset and be mad and be frustrated uh I welcome it cuz it's all the same stuff that I'm feeling I don't know what else to tell you except we're doing the best we can with this this is a long process uh the negotiations you're talking about to come to settlement Agreements are two-way streets they're not so easy as you may might believe and uh short of giving out any details uh on what's ongoing I can tell you that it's a it's

099a frustrating and very time consuming Pursuit that's about it anybody have anything to add I I just want to say um I sat through every minute of that trial I feel for the victims that are both in this room as well as that victim um anyone who came up here and talked to tonight talked about how long they've lived in bashore I think uh other than anyone who said so I got you all topped I'm here my entire 65 years I live in breathe pure I'm here because I volunteer my time when I sat through the trial I volunteered all that time I have not been paid I happen to be an attorney some people like attorneys some people hate attorneys it's okay I did it because I care uh when people say that we

100don't have empathy that really does strike to my core because I really do give a damn um I wish I could answer a lot more things I will tell you that there were mistakes made during the trial by the judge by the jury and so we did have an obligation to do various things all right I I just please give please please give me some respect that's all I ask okay um I I will tell you that um there are many people who are not here tonight who who say to us the same thing how are we going to pay for this this is not easy we're trying to be fair to the victims we're trying to be fair to the community and just please understand we really do give a damn we all do

101but I'll speak for myself I I I've I have volunteered more of my time in the last year than I care to mention with regard to this because I care because I want to be fair and I want to be Equitable but that fairness is a two-way street there's lawyers there's Community there's the victims and it's just very very difficult to balance it all I want so bad to speak more the lawyers keep yelling at us telling us we can't But please understand that one thing is for certain we really do give a damn that's all I can say tonight folks if there's not anybody else I'm GNA ask for a uh yes ma'am I want yeah thanks good evening I don't I actually prepared something but I'm going to kind of go off the

102cuff you know who I am I'm Tanya Weiss I live in bore uh not 65 years but um I've been here for a long time uh and I don't need to go over how personally I'm related to the child victim act cases in our town but I I more want to speak to you all about how we're moving forward uh and I think that's some of the frustration that's going on and we understand that you're frustrated and I know you recommended I could have went to the trial also honestly couldn't um for a lot of reasons one my son's home right now two uh I don't think I could sit through that um but uh I know everybody's making their individ individual choices when it comes to that I I mostly wanted to talk to

103you about this meeting setup um I come here often I know a lot of you personally I've sat in rooms with you I've had meetings with you I've had drinks with you Etc um it's really nerve-wracking to come up here and to try to express something I come here often and speak uh I know the rules I watch from home when I'm not here and I still shake a little right and I still prepare what I want to say and so I kind of implore the board and the panel to figure out a way that might be less intimidating if you really do want to hear from the community because um I know there are protocols I know there are legal things I know there are things that people can't speak about uh but there's

104a 30-day Span in which the public can come before you and then in between we're left to email Communications or phone calls and so not administration because Administration always gets back to me but if I reach out to the board of ed because I hit a wall with Administration or they hit a wall that they can't help me anymore who who read s the Board of Ed emails and because I've sent emails in that and and I came in in November and I was quickly helped with Jackson um with my son but prior to that there had been multiple emails to the board of ed that I then got a response that said the appropriate administrator would reach back out to me and I was sent to this Vortex that's kind of been resolved temporarily

105and and there's a little bit of a long-term plan with Administration but to the board of ed members who reads your emails and how do we know they're being read by the public elected officials Caitlyn will say but they're all being forwarded to us we get them all okay so I send a really long email about Jackson and it takes me coming here to get a result because I set like several over the last 10 months and I didn't hear from any Board of Ed member not you Dr Maloney I heard from you I heard from Mr pashin I spoke to a lot Administration I'm talking about the community elects Board of Ed members and we say hey we hit a wall I'm upset as evidenced by someone that just tried to speak then we

106come here we're not allowed to speak about something personal so we go home and we send an email we spend another 30 days preparing what we could bring to you sweating shaking and then we're told you can't talk about it so how do we have those conversations with the people that are making the decisions because ultimately you know our Administration is is they have their hands tied in certain ways too right like they they have a job so when we're going to you and we're saying this is an open public forum and and there's a way for us to discuss like how does that occur I guess the answer I best answer I could give it's like we don't run the district right so if you write to us we hear your concerns um as

107a school board member I would expect and I don't have to demand it but I would expect that the administration would do their job that's exactly what happens so if you write to us um some Caitlyn will say to us this has been referred to Dr Maloney or to Mr pashin or to Dr Outlaw Etc so we know that there somebody is addressing it so I think that's is that yeah that ansers my question so then so then to that point my so I have an issue with my son in September of 2024 uh 23 I reach out to the teacher the teacher doesn't get back to me I reach out to the assistant principal who says You must misunderstand Mrs wife she probably meant to call you and then I said well no and

108then we end up having a phone conversation and then I have to wait 20 days to have a meeting and then I call PPS and I say this meeting is not resolving it and then I meet with an assistant PPS director and it goes on and on and on and on until all of a sudden finally 18 months later I'm in the superintendent's office but that's kind of why we're in this position right because people make complaints and then everybody expects their jobs to be done and then they're not and then you have to keep rising up the ranks and you get tired I'm tired I'm a tired mom of a very disabled child and I am not giving up but like that's why we're in this situation with these young men because that's the

109culture here is you send an email it gets distributed out somebody else is supposed to take care of it and then you have to follow up as a parent like that's one of the things that was bought up in the case right the mom didn't follow up but that's that's what we're asking you to do so I'm asking like what's the policy and procedure when I hit a wall and I say I don't want to have to go all the way up to Dr Maloney's office I want to know that the people in my buildings and in my classroom are doing their job and my situation is being handled Now by Administration but maybe we need policy in place and we need a forum where the community can come to the board and say hey

110I have an inclination or an anonymous Reporting System that's just monitored by the board and the administration where you know there's another situation that is personal to me that I'm not allow to talk to anybody about because it's not my child but my friend doesn't want to report it because she's afraid of ramifications right so we don't have things in place that protect our kids right now in that realm or that put Jackson out of a building for 18 months so that's what I'm kind of saying too like this needs to be a little bit of a better system so that people that are scared can speak or people that aren't articulate can speak and there needs to be a way for reporting to be brought to board of other than just forward it out

111to another administrator and just trust that it gets taken care [Applause] of all right thank you for your comments but the issue initial issue you were talking about is being taken care of how do you mean you just said finally was taken care of we're in the process now yes my son is being taken care of but as Rob and St will tell you I am a global thinker it's not about just my son I'm loud I will come here I have the privilege to be here I have the privilege to keep him home it's not okay it's just not all right well thank you for your comments is there anybody else all right with that I ask for a motion to uh go out a public session motion second all in favor I I

112thank you all for your comments tonight

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.