CorpusRecord 59842

Board of Education Work/Public Session - December 18, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Bay Shore School District
Date
2024-12-19
Location
Suffolk County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,702 words · about 54 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e everybody Welcome to our work session happy holidays getting into the holiday season see you get on right into our agenda well first of all we made one inside but you're right a motion go to work session motion second all in favor I opposed so carried okay we're in session first we have uh M Rogers Miss Martinez High School AIS newcomer English language Learners right as you recall we had a great presentation last work session from Mrs Rogers going one of our Elementary programs and we wanted to bring Miss Martinez M Rogers back to just talk about our secondary AIS um at this time so thank you for being here thank you so much thank you so much for inviting us um so we'll get started on focusing on the high school students

002um so as Dr Maloney said Patricia was here on December 4th unfortunately I could not attend that evening because we had our family engagement um event um and I am happy to be here to talk to you about the high school AIS program for our newcomer L's so at the present moment um we have over a thousand students districtwide um that we are currently servicing throughout our district and the primary focus for tonight's evening is to really focus on two groups um at the high school that are in need of most support and this involves students who are um newcomers who are newly arrived to the country and to the district as well as students with disabilities so as you're aware our growing population of L's is continuing to rise and is at a steady

003rate current ly um and as the population grows we also have to um adapt and also look at our programs and provide the same equity and education to all of our students so on that note we have 262 students currently enrolled that number is closely monitored through our office to ensure that we are um able to have the most accurate information to provide to um all of the different administrators in the building as well as um all of the District district employees across um all buildings so with challenges that we have faced at the secondary level um let me first preface that we collectively work very closely with our other departments to ensure that all of our students receive the mandated services that they require um we look at proficiency levels we also look at

004coursework we also look at English proficiency projections that we have our teachers called Every Spring to ensure that we're able to provide the most accurate English proficiency Services as possible the nicet scores do not come in until late August and at that point the scheduling process is a little too late so we um meeing myself I meet with the guidance Department um and we go through every single student to ensure that we are able to provide the most um accurate and precise schedule bearing in mind all the the different um services that they also require along those lines we encounter sometimes students who um are double classified not only as enl students but we also have students with learning disabilities that require services on both ends and that poses a challenge when we're trying to

005build a schedule that meets the services for both areas so often times um with specialed students whether that is you know special uh special uh programs or services like speech uh resource room uh OT Services it becomes very difficult to embed the enl push in or enl pull out which really does not exist at the secondary level we really try to integrate the enl teacher into the classroom to provide those Services um but for areas like I just mentioned it makes it very difficult for us to be able to service those students in addition to that when we're focusing on newcomer L's um who don't speak as much English and are really performing at an entering level those students require even more support than what we're able to provide so um we are seeing all

006gamuts and ages and ranges of students that are coming into the district some of which are at 18 19 years old who for other reasons whether that be family obligations work obligations cannot attend Day School uh or um you know they would much rather attend an alternative setting because they have other obligations that they have to meet during the day so we have students currently who are mothers we have students who have multiple jobs they're providing for their family back home um some are enduring social emotional distress that is ultimately impacting their ability to come to school so um with that we are proposing and looking at a solution to how to best meet the needs of both populations of students so at this current juncture we are proposing that we run an AIS program

007specifically to cater to those needs of those students after school um to really provide that academic and linguistic support we also believe that this will help address those learning gaps that they have uh will build their skills and confidence reduce ultimately that dropout rate because of course we want to focus on graduation rate and how can we best support those students um regardless of what situations they may be enduring and of course prepare students for upcoming assessments so um we are looking to the board um to propose uh the ability for us to run an AIS program for our high school enl students um in discussion with building Administration and and of course Mr pashin um we are we are on um looking to hopefully start this program with your approval and provide those Services

008as soon as possible because we do believe that um it is something that the students would very much definitely very much uh benefit from and of course when we're looking at um providing those supports it is very important to not just focus on um how the academic uh program during the day but how can we also provide those services to them after school so how do you do it daytime and nighttime so I mean in your proposal what will it look like yeah it's not all the kids it's not all the kids so as um so as I mentioned before so we service most of our students what we're looking at specifically is about 12 to 15 students that um would require this additional AIS support and are are they all day students or are

009some of them no um sorry no some of them are exclusively PM school students um so you know we would discuss like how would that work for them too because their start time is later than when day school ends um so some of these students are doubled up because of their age and trying to fit in the supports um to ensure that they graduate on time so it's a combination of the CH of of those scenarios okay but I'm just asking the logistics maybe I'm not asking it clearly enough like like logistically how are you going to be able to pull that off given the number of hours that you need to cover so we're looking to run the AIS program three times a week um to start and it would be an hour block

010for those three sessions um and we feel that you know as we monitor the student attendance because obviously there there needs to be accountability on behalf of the students to ensure that they're attending these um sessions so right now we're proposing 3 hours per week when like in like what time 2:30 to 3:30 3 3:00 3:30 it starts so so it be right right before their PM stock it starts at 3:30 that so they could still make that correct okay so so another question would be what happens to those people that can't be here between 2:30 and 3:30 and are working during the day to support their families and whatever we're doing in our community which everybody's doing you know to support everybody what happens now to that person that can't come at 2:30 3:30

011and it comes to the later part of the day maybe 5:30 to 6:30 or something like that you have they have to do that work where we trying to get every we're trying to touch every student at this point to make them you know all catch up right so in a perfect scenar in a perfect scenario want to hear um we would like to have more enl support during our alternative program in in the evenings um so we that's an area that um I know a lot of the guidance counselors who have been working very closely with these students have suggested during SST meetings um that I've had the pleasure to attend to listen to some of the concerns that they are expressing across the board as it relates to our students and that's one

012of the areas that they would they feel the most support is required because we do have a lot of students that are going to that PM School setting that unfortunately are registered and rostered to those programs but since there isn't as there isn't enl support in that type of environment they end up being dropouts or truant so the bottom line of the whole question is is you want to add that enl into I would love to have an enl support in that's the question so that's that's where I was that's why I was asking I didn't ask it well and I don't mean I mean I appreciate the I appreciate it I don't mean to undermine it but is the Is it feasible to do it 2:30 to 3:30 let's say Tuesday and then on

013Wednesday do it at a different hour so that you can catch different groups of kids is that something that's feasible this is honestly a work in progress right so we need to do something for kids so the easiest way to do it and the cleanest way for scheduling is to propose the same time slot however if we find that the students are unable to do that we're malleable we will change it and we'll um you know we'll adapt and pivot and do whatever yeah I'm just looking for good results right it's it's it's we have to start slow as we do with all of our programs that we imp we implement we don't want to take off too much of a chunk because you have to find out and do A needs assessment because that's

014the proper way to do it figure out whether or not the students are going to a attend B if they're really going to buy into you know our evening program and then develop the needs as we go along so yes of course to your point we'd have to see what what the kids need mostly and it doesn't fit in PM school at all well the problem is that they have credits that they need to also meet in order to meet their graduation requirements so it and that's the that's the piece with all enl at the secondary level and that's the reason why the state wants an integrated model which we have right so we have integrated enl in ela and math and science and social science because those students are making those minutes in their

015content classes and they're not like olated by getting enl support in a standalone piece right so in order to do that at the at the U PM school we would need unfortunately money and we're not asking for that we're just seeing if right now we can start small you know with AIS supports with saying money three times a week who's doing that I don't need a name is it one teacher doing it three times a week is there additional like stip in for that what what are you you're looking for I mean somebody's not doing it for nothing oh no no that's that's the piece it's like we we're actually asking for monies that are already allocated to AIS for us to be able to use those funds for this program we're not asking for

016I'm sure there grants that we can write too right well so I did actually based on based on last month I did ask actually I did put my feelers out about Grant uh because somehow I knew that question was coming back to me um and um we we we do know that um any Essa funding and uh for sa and both SA and federal there's nothing available beyond what we currently have offered to us for specifically for enl students um everything for RTI as well as AIS has already been dissolved based on our uh the former you know covid monies and whatnot so that's all dried up um unless the state and I do suspect that the state is going to re uh I don't know re set themselves in terms of how much money

017they're going to give for title 3 I'm hoping that within the next couple of years they're going to bolster that because I do think that they know that there is a need for us and they're required pieces so anything that we would have to seek in terms of um grants would have to be privately offered pieces okay so it would require a lot of more I mean anything we could do like on a Schoolboard level and stuff like that because we go to a lot of stuff where we can go ahead and you know go ahead and try to sell all the stuff to get the state to help out it' be a great time problem y it is a problem so there you know especially on Long Island so you definitely could get people

018together to of champion to push the state in the right it is way thankfully and I will say this thankfully um because of your support we really do have people that are in place that are able to provide both the minutes and the content for our students and honestly there are very many districts that don't have what we have and so really Kudos and thank you for all of your support and uh and understanding the need that we need like this is a growing population that does have greater needs and unfortunately what we're starting to see is the trend of more students that are both um students with disabilities as well as students that are in now classified so it's it's a challenge for both of our departments we're working closely with them to to

019make some resolutions thank thank you both thank you thank you very much sorry for no no I I appreciate the the question and the clarification thank you so much and happy holidays Christmas happy New Year thanks okay next we have uh Dr Outlaw Stella University she's not here no she's here she's here she here and if you're helping out and giving out money let's uh see if we can get a little bit from us too she's looking at you no but we may as well if she's being so gracious well sorry I am the biggest guy sorry don't be laughing in the background Mrs D University and I are grateful for the opportunity to share an update with you on the literacy programs and um the initiatives that we have been working uh on and

020toward there's been a lot of collaborative work that has been done both with the administrators classroom teachers the support staff uh Mrs Dell University Mr pashkin and I I have really spent a significant amount of time just taking a look at the state's literacy um initiatives and work that we've engaged in so that we are able to ensure that our literacy practices incorporate a lot of the um explicit and systematic um approaches that the state has indicated that we need to consider okay thank you everyone for having us uh this evening at happy holidays and as Dr atler mentioned and as we all know literacy is not only a Cornerstone of academic achievement but it's really a fundamental tool for success in lifelong and so we're excited this evening to share with you some of

021the progress we've made in our ongoing efforts to align with the New York state literacy initiative um as well as to it most importantly to ensure that our students are growing as readers and as writers and so just for brief overview tonight we'll be discussing some of the highlights from and the updates to the New York state literacy initiative along with some of the action steps and the foundational work that was put into place in the district last school year um some of the assessments and program practices that have been implemented this school year to help to enhance our literacy instruction and ultimately implications and next steps moving forward as we grow our literacy program and ensure that we are aligned with evidence-based practices and measures so there have been two governing agencies that we've

022heard a lot from um the governor herself has stepped in and offered $10 million toward the look and investigation about the science of reading practices we also had the State education department who in April when we first talked about these updates um shared literacy briefs that they want wanted school districts to go back to their organizations and look closely at their curricular programs in order to see where the science of reading practices existed and if there were adjustments that were needed so that school districts were able to meet the needs of all of the students that they were servicing um and so in response to the state's called to districts to incorporate these science of reading practices into their instruction there were a number of steps that were put into place last school year which

023are outlined here um these action steps helped us to further our understanding of the research and also to begin to incorporate these uh principles into our literacy based efforts so uh the first of which we had a collaborative book study the text Shifting the balance was selected courtesy of Dr Outlaw as a recommendation um it was a key resource that we used to actually help our admin ministrative team as we began to educate ourselves on the science of reading and we were very fortunate to have collaboration from a variety of Administrators across buildings and grade levels which allowed for a lot of collaboration as we started to explore these principles and really to start this work together um and ultimately we did gain a deeper understanding of how to shift instructional practices to better support

024our students in their development of literacy skills we also had the continuation of Orton Gillingham training last school year this program was brought into the district originally by Dr andies many years ago exactly 25 years ago we learned um for use with our support staff and it did continue last school year it expanded um through grant funding as well as really through the efforts of Dr ry's to incorporate classroom teachers enl teachers reading teachers and special education teachers across grade levels and being that the focus of the training is on pheic awareness and phonics it does align directly IR ly with the science of reading and we are proud to share that there were an additional 50 bore teachers who were trained by The Institute for multi-sensory education in the Orton Gillingham approach last school

025year so I think that's a great Testament and just investment in our staff um additionally in all of our schools our building leaders dedicated time during grade level and faculty meetings to share and introduce the New York state literacy briefs um so this gave teachers the opportunity to start to familiarize these themselves with these Concepts and also um to discuss some of the common misconceptions sometimes associated with the terms and to just begin to consider what it might be for their own literacy practices and finally there were a number of professional development opportunities that were also offered around the science of reading and effective literacy instruction uh one of which was a very comprehensive micro credential offered by Sunni nuls and these trainings and S sessions and offerings um allowed teachers who were interested the

026opportunity to enhance their understanding of literacy instruction and to stay informed on current research and best practices in the field and what Mrs Dell University didn't share was that she herself participated in the new poll's micro credential uh which was very comprehensive um and uh and so previously we mentioned the different organizations that were contributing to the discussion so um there is um a curriculum guide that the state sent out to districts or made available to districts in June of 2024 in order to guide their work part of this uh work included the creation of a dyslexia and disg graphia task force now this task force is being asked to take a look at the processes that school districts as well as other stakeholders are involved in around dyslexia and disg graphia they are being

027asked to provide a report at the end of this month of their findings I anticipate that it is going to require schools to take a look at dyslexia screenings and disg graphia screenings in order to um identify students who are in need of more explicit support at a recent uh Regent board uh Board of Regents meeting which was held a few weeks back there was an emergency order that was put forth by the state education department and this order asked for school districts to take a look at um at their programs and I anticipate that at the end of this in September starting in September of 2025 school districts are going going to be asked to attest to the fact that their curriculum programs have explicit and systematic instruction in um participating in that delivery

028during the classroom um by the classroom teachers and so this is what I anticipate um is going to be something that we are going to have to check a box that indicates that we feel that our program meets those needs and you're going to here in the upcoming slides we're confident that we will be able to check that box that's me and so one of the ways that we are able to check this um box or indicate that we are meeting those needs is through the introduction of an assessment called aadience aadience is a phonic awareness and phonics um assessment that allows for Universal screening and progress monitoring now this is made up of a number of different assessments that allow a drill down of the foundational reading skills that children need in order to

029be prepared for further reading instruction um just some of the key points to note about aadience it is used for Universal screening purposes it's administered to students three times per year so this allows teachers and Educators to really identify the who need more support as often and as early as possible and to provide targeted supports and interventions um as Dr atlo mentioned those foundational reading skills you you'll often hear those referred to as the five pillars of the science of reading and those are phic awareness phonics vocabulary fluency and comprehension so this assessment tool measures all of them and is able to give comprehensive information about students progress in each um the data yielded by this assessment is reliable standardized it's actionable and it is aligned with the science of reading and the state's literacy

030initiative in that it's evidence and research based and we are currently using um the Acadian K2 across the board and also in our 35 elementary schools with specific student populations and next we have the hegerty uh which is a program that we have utilized um at our K2 buildings um in and our upk building in different capacities and this program is also a research-based program that allows for a multi-sensory approach similar to Orton with the development of early reading skills and so it's a very um efficient application of the practices that can be used whole class which then allows for it to be a tier one intervention that every student has the opportunity to develop their skills students then can be um further supported by Orton or another program if they are not responding to

031the practices that are being utilized in hegr and just some uh key details to note about the heger femic awareness curriculum and as dram mentioned these terms you hear them a lot in association with the science of reading this is systematic expl expit direct instruction in pheic Awareness um it targets eight phological awareness skills and three early literacy skills um and builds the Foundation students need to decode which eventually leads to comprehension um the program is inclusive it's available in English and in Spanish um it also incorporates a lot of Hands-On learning interactive activities to keep students engaged and appeal to a variety of different Learners and learning styles and the lessons are approximately are just under 10 minutes a day which as Dr La mentioned makes it very efficient and like aadience the program

032is aligned with science of reading research so now let's talk about um our next steps and what are we doing with the information that we acquire and um how are we making this actionable in the classrooms so we are priar prioritizing the literacy programs um and practices and professional development so as you can see there have been shifts to ensure that our programs and professional development opportunities support the explicit and systematic instruction um you'll also see that there is a commitment to ensuring that the students gain the fundamental skills that they need and that's what you've heard us sharing throughout this presentation we are incorporating a Cadance for the universal screening and progress monitoring what I believe is most important is that we are using the data in order to incorporate explicit teaching practices that

033build upon the student weaknesses that were found when that assessment was completed we're also increasing the use of hegr uh explicit and systematic phonemic awareness program so that students become more proficient in their early years prior to moving into the element intermediate school buildings um this year we also continue our partnership with Orton Gillingham and so this year there were an additional 25 teachers in November who were just trained by The Institute for multi-sensory education so really building on that work that Dr Andy's started so long ago um and actually that brings our total number of teachers districtwide to approximately 175 Orton trained teachers who are able to provide the service so it really is it's a wonderful investment in our staff and their professional growth and development and our educators are putting that training

034to Great use because we can also proudly share that at both all three of our primary schools our two inter media buildings and at our Middle School we're now running Orton based groups to provide this type of instruction for students who struggle and small group support um this school year also saw the formation of a district level 3 to five literacy team so this is comprised of teachers from both of our our intermediate buildings working together to review and evaluate their current programs practices and resources for literacy and Dr Outlaw and I had the opportunity to meet with these teachers for the first time recently and we have just a wonderful group assembled we're very much looking forward to working with them on this uh on this endeavor and I encourage you to ask any

035one of the teachers who have participated in either the hegerty or the Orton Gillingham training to ask them if they felt that it was of value and if they've seen a difference in both the practices as well as the training and you will hear hands down that they believe and have already seen the difference that it is making um the last two uh one being the book study we're expanding our work and the way in which we're exp expanding it includes the secondary and content area directors so Mr pashkin is working closely with those um administrators with regard to vocabulary and the role that vocabulary instruction plays at the secondary level so I believe that this is not just a k6 or K5 um area of concern this is a k12 and you see that

036all of the administrators and classroom teachers and support staff are committed to helping our children be better at their reading development um for their future and the other is professional development there are so many additional opportunities that continue to be offered to them and um there's the Otis has now made an micr credential available through their program so teachers have the opportunity to explore um yeah to explore that micr credential and as Miss Del University just mentioned that's free to us because we have a partnership with Otis already and in January in the next few weeks net is holding a a regional meeting to provide updates on the New York state literacy initiative they're going to present a p through3 literacy instructional best practices document and earlier I mentioned that districts are going to have

037to attest to the fact that they have explicit and systematic instructional practices embedded into their uh literacy instruction this guide is what is going to help districts identify if they are meeting that Criterion and so once that document is out Mrs Dell University and I will be sharing that widely and so as you can see everyone involved in this work um has recognized the value in enhancing the literacy programs with the incorporation of those research-based and explicit and systematic instructional practice practices so collectively we will continue to focus on programs and practices that align to the science of reading we're excited to see the positive impact that these adjustments will have and have already had on our students and our school community and so thank you for your support because really without you we would

038not be able to continue the work and ensuring that the students of bayur get the best educational experience possible so thank you thank you very much thank you I have a couple questions sure um so the acadians we're just starting that now yes are we going K to six for it or are we limited in certain areas well that's actually going to depend on the training and the data and information that we receed and so in order to do entire uh grade levels we would need a larger team of people who would be able to administer uh the assessment it's a quick assessment and it doesn't take long but the way in which it is um um completed it would require a group in order to move through quickly yeah so we don't have anybody

039trained on it yet we haven't implemented it yet we have with the people who have conducted the aadience assessment already we would need to train more if we wanted more students to be a part of that assessment at the 35 or even Middle School level does that take the place of we do um the I ready testing already does this replace it so are we then re double testing so we're testing an I ready and reading and then we're going to test in cadians would one replace the other would we take the already literacy piece away and just stick with the math I'll let Mrs D univers answer that because I hear her on my side like ready to say something um but it assesses completely different skills so I'll let Mrs D univers tou

040we use the I ready at KATU only for math so we don't use it for reading as a trainer so this is for K2 for reading we don't use the we only start the I ready for reading in third grade okay and the Acadian drills down to specific pH phonemic awareness um skills that we then are able to Target that are not that explicitly um identified in the I ready assessment because those kind of things like that that could take time to individually test each student so if we're doing that in multiple areas with multiple me methods it might I don't know if it would overlap or get messy it actually is so quick that very very short that the entire um the entire assessment um really is done uh within minutes that it then

041moves different than the I ready completely different than the I so the last question is where does our current programs fit in like literacy collaborative where does that fit in because I've heard some mixed reviews on that lately and you know that requires sometimes to teachers in a classroom are we staying with that is that something we're going to move away from are we just putting stuff on top of that um because we keep training people in it so I just want to make sure where does that fit in so right now because there's value in both um practices that we have meaning with the uh literacy collaborative teachers have an opportunity to hear students reading uh individually which provides a lot of uh information to the classroom teacher the assessments right now and the

042science of reading practices we are infusing in the areas where we see that we need to bolster that explicit and systematic instruction and so right now we are approaching both because we see that there are value in both if down the line the teachers um and in our assessments we feel that there is the ability to move away because we are still getting that same information from the one assessments or a few other assessments then we absolutely will explore that realm but right now we see that there is value in um all of the approaches that are being utilized and they're meshed together I don't want to say seamlessly because they're all different programs different pieces um it's the testing piece too to keep doing different Assessments in different areas yes are we really tapping

043into what we need to yes right now as we learn and as we grow um I believe that what we are doing meets the needs of all of our students one of the uh conversations that we have had is that teachers are interested and appreciate having as many Tools in their toolbox as they possibly can so when a student does not respond to one approach they have a number of others that they're able to utilize that I think with some of the approaches though like a literacy collaborative there's something to be said about or they expect you to do it with Fidelity and if we're not doing it with Fidelity and running the program the way it's supposed to be run and we're now peac mealing other things into it so I'm just curious and

044like would like some information as we work through it absolutely of how they're working because each one of those pieces is going to expect you to do it with Fidelity and if that's not the case if it's like well we're going to do this part of it but not this part of it and this part of it but not this part of it and pce me it together it could get could get sloppy yes and so we'll continue to evaluate for the effectiveness of any of the approaches that we use because we want to make sure that our students get what they need but that we aren't spending time in areas where it's not necessary curious to just keep Heering about it oh absolutely happy to talk about it we are it sounds like it

045yes any other questions anything else well thank you very much great thank you thank you guys very much thank you right next on the agenda regionalization Dr Maloney P talk about to take the podium we'll go do right for just a discussion like the last board meeting um November 19th we had a discussion with the board regarding regionalization in terms of what was being proposed by the state again it's an initiative that was adopted in September they had a timeline in terms of things that needed to be completed by districts in order to be compliant with the legislation um now on December 18th we live in a different world than we did a month ago because things have changed with regionalization and right now um after that meeting that it came out that it is

046you do not need to um submit the needs and assessment tool which we have completed um we did not I want to thank Rob laqua and all our directors of principles for for doing that because it was uh a lot of work but we did not submit it yet there's a lot of districts in New York state that have not submitted it as as of yet um districts were also have the option now of writing a letter to the state and opting out of regionalization um I can tell you in the town of isop right now that it is um mixed um some districts have submitted some districts have passed a resolution not to participate and others are waiting um until January to see if more information comes out because right now um people are

047questioning really like what is regionalization because there's still this concept up there about student outcomes sharing of services these are you know sharing of services something we've always done all district I've done so trying to figure out exactly what it means um but in order to figure out what it means to be in um the know in terms of future discussions you would have to opt in um so right now that's kind of our is that right that's to if you you need to Comm commit the assessment tool then you would be part of knowing what it is without knowing what it is and I would say probably most of the Nassau County school districts have opted out it right now now from what I'm hearing in suffk it is little mixed a little bit

048of both um some districts are waiting for January to see if anything happens between now schools are closed and January 15th um in terms of anything Chang because the big question is um are there any consequences for not participating and we really don't know the answer to that um so that's kind of our update and resolation I'll let Rob jump in as well if he has anything additional that you know he share uh just Dr M shared you know the majority of where at and I think the last time we met we went through our process and again thank you to all the administrators who helped put that together very quickly along with alen herck from District uh according to a article in uh on board uh school board's um their their paper that they

049put out uh the other day they mentioned that it was reported that that approximately 70% of the school districts in the state had submitted the tool um I I I you know we're still getting some more information I believe there may be a possibility where we could participate with submitting the tool but still opt out of the plan that that's another option you know we've discussed this we we don't really have a strong necessarily opinion either way but um that would be maybe also a way to show some cooperation and some with the with the process but not necessarily agree to any kind of plan that comes out of it so there's another there I think we have a couple of different options there but uh it has been suggested that we wait you know

050a little bit longer to try to see uh what other information comes to light is there a benefit here that I that's what we're struggling with right now to say if there's a benefit one way there's a benefit is there like a a vision somewhere out there that you could point to that might the only other directed towards the benefit well that was that's the thing because I think the districts that opted out early get there was a lawsuit against the the state Ed regarding this are also districts that are looking at the foundation Aid um formula that's going to be revised right now they they believe the two are linked together that you a district may lose uh funding going forward with the New Foundation a formula and the answer from the state will

051be well you can participate in regionalization and share service and District right now you know we share Services all the time busing athletic teams um out east I know many of the districts are in favor of this because of the size of the districts in terms of programs we share contracts Upstate New York again um due to the geographic nature of how school districts are are set up um there is probably a need and an interest in doing that Long Island's probably a little different because we um all different sized districts um we have a lot of of different services that we provide our students again in bore again we have you know AP IB all of different different offerings for students other schools may not um so they may want to um you know

052obviously look at B say could we you know share a service and again we can we do that now with different things uh I don't necessarily know that we needed a formal plan from the state to say you can do that um but I do see in Upstate New York out east why they would interested more so in the plan but it's not just that because if it was just that it wouldn't be this 100 page document and it also the concerns that I think I shared last time what you had looked at was what it says that the authority it gives to the Bosey superintendant they've changed some of that language I don't know if you saw that so it's just it's it's just too unknown I think that's again there talk about local

053control I know the governor came out and said you know this is not about seating local control the local control should go back to the school district um I don't know if that was the intent of this but I know that was something that people started to discuss and we kind of said it in you know when we were meeting with the administrators administrators say I don't think the Bose superintendent right now wants wants my my job I'm GNA be honest with you no um so I don't think that's actually uh you know something that would would be would happen um but I know that was a concern for many there a lot of language and it doesn't that's not clear well I I think that's and and to to make districts to go through

054all the work that you guys did and then say oh well we only wanted if you're going to be participating and not give you that option first of all is shortsighted because wouldn't they want as much information as possible because if you're only going to take even if it's 70% if you're missing 30% of the state you're not going to get an accurate picture so that boggles my mind but um my question to you guys like did that exercise even though it was forced did it did it bring anything to light that like we could you know proactively do some stuff on our own that without waiting for the state to tell us what to do it's yeah was I I don't remember if I mentioned it last time but the majority of the information

055I think all the information there was a little bit of coll of putting some additional uh things that we have um in our district together but the M large majority of especially the all the work that Ellen did uh was from information that's already publicly available it's nothing you know really new or something that is not already well known there was a little bit of information that was asked about course offerings um that is also available in our course catalog that is publicly available so I think that tool was maybe more to you know to to compile that for the whole state would be probably very challenging so maybe asking the districts to do it but there's really no information in there that is not already publicly available which would be again you know maybe

056a reason to um submit but it's again I understand all the aspects of this and and why there's some questions about it for sure It's Tricky yes because we really don't know what it is that's we're prepared to submit if we if they if they hold us you know if they hold us hostage we can submit of you know the of the a ready to go we're ready to go so ready to push the button whenever we're ready but it's yeah it's totally that's all we're good the frustrating part is the Lost productivity I mean just yeah it took a lot of time and energy yes that that is frust very good any other questions all right get to okay all right next uh M fer on firefighter extension so uh this currently exists but

057the state has changed the real property tax law just a little bit uh they made a little tweak the town of iip opted into it and now the districts must decide if they will opt into it as well so a little bit of history in February 2004 the board adopted chapter 450 volunteer firefighters volunteer ambulance workers real property tax exemption whereby the district CH chose to Grant a real property tax exemption to Residents enrolled as a member of the local volunteer fire department or volunteer Ambulance Service the property uh that they're enrolling must be a primary res residents it must be within the school district there was the exemption was very small in uh 2004 and I think in 2005 they changed it a little bit so that what was then offered was 10% of

058the dollar amount of the real property tax bill so there was a little shift there right within the first year uh the Board of Education considers this to be a gesture of recognition to these critically important volunteers who serve the Bay Shore community on Tuesday September 18th 2024 the town of IOP Town board opted into the new exemption under real property tax law section 466a Statewide volunteer firefighter and ambulance worker exemption was specifically designed to encourage Recruitment and Retention of volunteers predominantly the major change is the opportunity to provide a 10% real property tax exemption to a qualified volunteer who has as little as two years of active volunteerism instead of the current five years that is the change so volunteers with two to five years of volunteer service again they must own their primary

059residence it must be their primary residence they must own the property and according to an danziger who is the assessor uh for the town of iip this is expected to have an insignificant impact on everyone else's tax rates they're not anticipating it a lot of people signing up in a big ship sh uh so we are recommending at this time that sometime in January or February the board opt into this new exemption uh the town of iscet business officials have been emailing back and forth um and there does appear to be consensus on this issue it's it's being recommended in all the districts right now um that you allow residents to come in with this two to five years of volunteer Service uh for this exemption at the 10% I can you know being in

060the fire and all that stuff with uh with the volunteerism it has been hard getting some people to volunteer and uh the programs that they have to go through are very very intense and the people that do stay uh they work very hard and you know what like you said it's hard to be a homeowner here and doing all that volunteer and what they require for them to be a volunteer firefighter has been it's hard significant it's very sign ific it's it's almost like going to college and stuff like that so we we're very lucky here in Bay and we have a great community and they and they buy in so you know what I I I'm I'm I'm a benefit of it so I can't really I don't want to vote on it myself

061but I I think it's a good program for what we're doing guy for the training who does does the individual have to pay for that training or does the fire department all fire department comes out of our budget in the fire department they send them out to fire school they have to do the work they have to do all the work at the fire School between Nassau and IC they go to both fire schools and all that stuff and there's Hands-On training and there's all it's a pretty it takes a year for them to get all the training done and it's all under the you know what they're doing so transportation to and from they provide they they their time everything is there yeah I have no problem supporting this more I'm totally in favor

062of it but I do have a question so is the major change then just reducing it from 5 years to two yep and that's why it's going to have a minimal impact on the cor correct okay correct anyone who does the training at why not why shouldn't they get the benefit immediately right so you know it's not like they just can walk in and say oh now I'm a member make somebody stays they don't get approved won you know if they have they have to do this get out probationary member yes so they have to do all TR this is a good thing they should get the benefit immediately yeah no problem okay good thank you for that what wrong way wrong way sorry going to pick a motion to go out of work session

063we're going to take a break so we'll just have a motion second all in favor I okay we're going to go out of session here just for a couple minute break e e e uh Mo motion to go into public session motion second second any uh any questions no all in favor I oppos so carried let's start off with the pledge Andy take us out all righty the pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all just a couple of notes to go through real quickly uh comments from the audience on agenda items will be heard after the Pledge of Allegiance comments not on the agenda will be heard after adjournment of the public

064meeting please limit your comments to three minutes as you all know anybody who's come to these meetings we don't really hold you to three minutes but try not to go on too long the board May recognize a speaker not more than twice on the same topic please feel free to give the board any additional comments in writing and in fact if you brought any comments that you have later on in writing we'd like to have a copy of them when you are recognized state your name uh and your address for the district clerk neither the Board of Education nor the superintendent of schools will entertain in public comments relating to personal matter or individual students Please be aware that both staff and student privacy are protected under the law if you have a personal concern

065or an issue regarding a staff member or students please call the superintendent schools and the numbers listed here on the agenda anyway it's 968 11115 in addition we'd like to uh have a brief statement read uh like to provide the community with another update on child victims act as we shared with our school Community back on December 4th we have settled 12 claims before trial tonight the Board of Education will vote to approve 35 Mill ion Dollar in settlement agreements for those 12 claims at a meeting in 2025 the board will approve a judgment bond to fund these settlements so far the district has settled 17 uninsured claims and our insurance carrier has resolved three more claims all decisions related to the child victims act will continue to be guided by fairness and compassion for

066those affected fiscal responsibility to our bore right Waters community and to ensure that our district continues to thrive and we will continue with these upgrades uh updates as much as we can all right we have some presentations before we get going now Mr AO be first Mr agustino thank you everybody for having us here tonight and really great opportunity to recognize three of amazing athletes from basher in the fall season um what we did was we brought the athletes here and their coaches are here as well and we're going to have their coaches um say a few words about their their student athlete as well so again I want to thank you this is not about Chris agino this is about these student athletes and we're going to bring them up right now so first

067up I'm going to bring up coach Drago and haly nansi com on I I failed to introduce your assistant oh I did too I apologize Mr Ted Nat gas is with us as well just be standing there and yes we can have [Applause] it are you ready don't read it okay go over there okay so before don't read it you're cheating before I speak about Haley presently I want to go back 5 years ago when she was in seventh grade she played Middle School field hockey and was already showing signs of greatness at a seating meeting for suff County for the upcoming upcoming season her eighth grade year coaches were discussing where their team should be placed for The Following Season based on what was coming up the pipeline one coach said she really didn't

068know how she could do this since she didn't really know the players at the middle school level in her school district this frustrated me that's part of your job as a varsity coach I stood up and said to the entire room I want you to listen carefully to the name I am about to say because you will remember the day you heard her name for the very first time and you will spend the next 5 years getting to see what she is capable of and trying to figure out how to stop her that name was Haley naslonski she is the next great player at bashore to this day people remind me of that moment and just how true of a statement it was and how dominant dominant a player she has grown into Haley is

069one of the most dynamic players I have ever coached or seen play the game of field hockey her sheer athleticism makes her a threat she's explosive fast and plays with 100% effort at all times she has been an integral part of B's team for the last four years playing Center Midfield or Center forward even on an off day she stands out amongst her peers her skill and speed is exceptional she has no fear and she has played through countless injuries in her career most which would sideline a player but she continues to push through she is a four-year starter and a three-year starting center midfielder she was named top 50 players on Long Island in 23 and 24 and is now a two-time Allstate player only 18 players from section 11 earned this honor she

070has been named to the National watch list a two-time nfhca academic All-American and a four-year New York state New York State scholar athlete this year she had 14 goals and 11 assists with Superior players and athletes sometimes it's hard for them to deal with a variety of skill levels on their teams Haley has always worked hard to challenge their her teammates to raised the bar and helped to improve the skill level and intensity of our entire program it's hard to imagine a Basher field hockey team without Haley at the center of it all but the beauty of what she has accomplished that she has inspired countless younger girls including my own and her Legacy will be their future success as a person Haley is a phenomenal teammate friend and leader a two-year Captain she's always

071she's also a member of an of athlet subing athletes an honoral student with a 93 plus GPA and a 3 sport athlete she was all County in Lacrosse and a national qualifier in winter track I'm so proud and lucky to have had the opportunity to coach this young woman there are so many memories that will stay with me and how many laughs we've had and one last thing Haley I need [Laughter] more shot afterwards what's that okay thank you coach Drago congratulations again um next I'm going to bring up coach frm to speak about evangelene come on up coach where are you coach first I have to say it was disappointed to lose Haley as a soccer play because she was a very good soccer player too but I'm happy to hear her success as

072a a field hockey player but that was four years ago um just wanted to start by thanking the board and the administrators for providing us this opportunity to acknowledge our student athletes here tonight um Evangeline has been a 4-year Varsity soccer player two of those years she was our captain uh before I do speak about her achievements I want to talk a little bit about her character because that's really what stands out most about Evangeline um even as an elite player Evangeline has such a wonderful perspective on what it means to be a student athlete she truly values her time with her teammates she appreciates the time on the field and most of all she cherishes being a Bish maraud um about her achievements so there's quite a few of them evangelene has been named

073All County player for Four Seasons um she's been selected to the Long Island um top 100 soccer players by news day this year she was was the feature story she had an interview her face all over news day so that was nice to see um she also was named by news day uh to the all Long Island team this year she's been an all state player for three seasons um this year she was uh sub County's offensive player of the year she's LED uh all of Long Island and goals scored she's been top 10 all four of her seasons in fact this year she broke the Baya Mara record with 70 goals um so quite a few yeah uh in addition uh evangelene has received National recognition as well she's been named all regional player

074uh which is an elite uh acknowledgement um by the national soccer coaches association um which is nice to see I'm going to miss evangelene um not just for what she provides on the field but her personality her character are wonderful so Evangeline thank you and um finally tonight um again I want to bring up coach Lynch to talk about Joseph and his wonderful accomplishments [Applause] Jo I just want to thank the Board of Ed and administration for giving me the honor and privilege to talk about one of my favorite athletes Joseph Belford um he's also adoringly known by his friends and family as Jeb and that's how I'm going to refer to him tonight because that's what I call him um Jeb is one of those rare athletes where he sets a goal and you're

075like all right that's a lofty goal we can shoot for it but wherever you land it's going to be really good but he that doesn't really work for Jeb any goal he sets he goes for and he actually achieves it um a week and a half out from the state qualifier meet Jeb finished 16th and I'm looking I'm like that's I know that's not his goal so I had a talk with JB and I'm like he's like I I did really good I think I did good and for him he he's he's right he did very well and it was a beautiful perfect day out but I know his goal he wants to go to the state meet I'm like oh Jeb I don't think that's going to work like he needs to do better

076meanwhile he does really well anyway fast forward to the state qualifier meet unlike a week and a half back it is now really hot out and for distance running that's rough cuz your body just overheats so as the race goes on Jeb's up in the front of the pack he ends up finishing sixth overall and making it to the state meet now that race every Runner um doesn't matter division boy or girl ran slower CU it was hot out except for one one ran 3 seconds faster than he did the the week and a half before that was Joseph cuz he wasn't going to stop he was going to make it no matter what 45 minutes after we left the medical tent he had to get ready for the state meet so that's the type

077of athlete in person Joseph is he's not just that um he's a role model for his teammates like many of the athletes that we have at Basher and it's a beautiful thing he shows them that that hard work pays off he shows them that they can be studious and succeeded at sports he's currently ranked number three in his class which for an athlete that does a sport every season I I don't know how he does it um and he's committed to Colgate to run division one track in cross country I just found out out this week um so I just want to you know thank you guys and um thank you Jeb for giving me the privilege of coaching you for the last four years it's it's been on mine so I'm very proud of

078you so finally last thing I just want to say again thank you for everybody being here we have our assistant coaches here as well coach juo for soccer coach hary for uh field hockey without these coaches these kids are great right and and again thank you for everything thank you for the board of education for letting us do this and happy holidays to everybody thank you we take a little picture get the p you take a step forward [Applause] and also Mary Dro got her two WI [Music] [Applause] Rob's do next he the student okay the former student this is for did anybody put their pictures up no she but I we have another presentation just I know all right moving on we have uh we would like to recognize Matthew modula for a donation

079uh Mr pasin you're gonna do the honors thank you m Benelli and it is truly an honor one of the best things I think about being administrator Educators seeing the students that have gone through our schools and are coming back to uh try to support the schools and the students in the district and in particular when you have a student who not only was from the district but is a student that was in your class that's particularly uh a great moment so um we are very pleased and and uh I have the honor of of introducing Matthew who uh despite uh his seventh grade science teacher is the founder and sound engineer at talking R Productions very successful uh full service sound company based here on Long Island uh with a lot of experience in

080sound recording and Studio work uh in New York City on location for various television shoots I believe Matthew may have to correct me but I believe he worked on the uh documentary the captain Derek Jeter yes uh along with the many many others uh and does a a lot of additional work um locally so we are very very pleased that he is willing to um come back to us I I remember Matthew was a phenomenal student uh in in science class but also always was very interested in music and I'm I'm going to try to remember here was it percussion oh I got it right okay uh and did a a great job with that I always spoke very highly of our music program so it's great to see him finding his place in a

081career in music and in sound and uh Matthew is generously donating uh approximately $2,800 to the cultural arts program uh for the purchase of sound equipment at Fifth Avenue school so we thank Matthew for uh for being here and for doing that and Matthew if there's anything else you'd like to share about the equipment uh but we we really appreciate you doing so in supporting our students and we're going to call him up yes we have certificate for you out you make a mention I want to mention any um Donna perone uh one of Dan and the bayaw briw Chamber of Commerce has made a donation of $33,000 to the bayaw High School drama club Miss perone couldn't be here tonight but I'd like to recognize her anyway so uh thank you very much she's

082been a good friend the chamber's been a good friend to the school system for a long time yes so thank we're going to give them a present some kind of note a note or something a nice presentation May in Cham of Commerce yes I think it's already I have it Friday we can do it right yeah absolutely okay okay we're going to start with the agenda a motion to approve the Board of Education minutes of the executive sessions of November 18 2024 November 19 2024 the executive work and public sessions of November 20 2024 and the executive and work sessions of December 2024 motion second any questions all in favor I opposed motion carries okay Mr pashin with uh B1 on page B1 the board will find a motion to approve the professional staff resignations

083and retirements as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried ex I need to step up B2 on B2 right on page B2 the board will find a motion to approve the professional staff requests for leave as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I oppos sorry so Carri B3 on page B3 the board will find a motion to approve the professional staff appointments as listed we recommend as approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried B4 on page B4 the board will find a motion to approve the professional staff salary changes as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried B5 b5a on page B5 and b5a the

084board find a motion to approve the Civil Service resignations and retirements as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I oppos so carried page B6 b6a on page B6 to b6a the board will find a motion to approve the civil service request for leave as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page B7 b7a on page B7 to b7a the board of finer motion to approve the Civil Service appointments as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page B8 b8a on page B8 to b8a the board of find a motion to approve the list of substitute appointments we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so

085carried page B9 b9a on page B9 to B9 a the board of hun a motion to approve the civil service changes in assignment as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so Carri page B10 on page B10 the board will find a motion to approve the Civil Service salary changes as listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page B1 on page B1 the board will find a motion to approve the extracurricular activity in athletic volunteers for the 2425 school year we recommend its approval mo mo second all in favor I I I didn't ask for questions any questions all in favor opposed so carried thanks okay Miss finger page B uh excuse me page C C1 a through

086r on PES C1 and C1 a through R the board upon a motion to accept and place on file the financial and claims Auditors report for August September and October of 2024 we recommend it approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page C2 C2 a through K on pages C2 and C2 a through K the board app a motion to approve the athletic Training Services agreement with Orland and Cohen Specialist Group uh we recommend it approval motion second any questions all in favor I oppos so Carri page C3 on page C3 the board will find a motion to approve a one-year extension of the bid for uh General Building Maintenance involving new construction reconstruction and demolition services to renew Contracting and restoration Inc we recommend it SP motion second any

087questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page C4 on page C4 the board apped a motion to award the contract for dishwashing supplies and service for the period 71 2024 through 620 2025 to the lowest responsible vendor listed um based upon the recommendation of the Long Island School nutrition's director Association Cooperative bid committee we recommend this approv motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so car page C5 on page C5 the board will find a motion to approve the donation of $2,860 to the bore school's cultural arts program sorry thank you from Mr Matthew modula uh talking moves production LC we recommend it approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried and thank you once again thanks and page C6 on page C6 the board will

088find a motion to approve the donation of $3,000 from the Chamber of Commerce to the bashore High School drama club uh for the nesa uh conference registration fees to cover that expense we recommend the school motion second all any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried and once again to Donna pericone and the uh Chamber of Commerce thank you very much for your donation uh Dr Outlaw on page D1 the board will find a motion to endorse actions taken by the bayro committee on special education pertaining to students being considered for services as noted in the csse minutes on the dates listed and the annual review for the 2425 school year and referrals for October November and December of 2024 we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed

089so carried page D2 on page D2 the board find a motion to endorse actions taken by the bore committee on preschool special education pertaining to students being considered for preschool Services as noted in the minutes listed we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I oppos thank you very much Dr outw and Dr Maloney on page E1 E1 a3g the board find a motion to approve and authorize the board president or vice president to execute a contract with Toro University for the purpose of student observation and fieldwork we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page E2 E2 a through G on page E2 E2 a through G the board find a motion to approve and authorize the board president and vice president to

090execute a contract with suff Community College for the purpose of student observation field workor we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried page E3 E3 a throughh on page E3 E3 a through H the board of find a motion to approve and are authorize the board president or vice president to execute a contract with Sunni Old Westbury for the purpose of student observation and field workor we recommend it's approval motion second any questions all in favor I I opposed so carried page E4 on page E4 the board finded a motion to approve a me excuse me memorandum of agreement between the bay share Union Free School District and the Bay Shore Food Service workers unit we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I I

091I opposed so carried and finally page E5 on page E5 the board of find a motion to approve and hereby authorize the board president or vice president to execute settlement agreements and releases as presented we recommend its approval motion second any questions all in favor I opposed so carried that takes us to the end of our agenda items at this time we'll welcome any comments on any other items of Interest from anybody in the audience I'm going to kill this signature I'm sorry fandu fandu or fanda is it Mr fanda am I saying that right okay I just want to make sure I'm saying it right good evening hi Hi how are you little nervous standing up here in front of people I know most of you I'm Donal fanda uh I live at 438

092Boulevard I was told to say this and uh I went to basaw high school from third grade to 1967 my whole family went there we're very proud of be basaw High School alumni and most times if I'm coming home from Home Depot or something like that I'll go by the high school and I always got such a good feeling that it's such a good school because I really have a lot of faith in this school and the job you people do I could never do it's one of the most important jobs in the world but with all of this everything going on I'm a little daunted about the schools but I saw on the newspaper I had a whole three pages prepared to say but I'm not going to say it because it would be

093wrong I saw in the news this a this evening that uh you're voting to to approve settlements and uh I see progresses being made and I think that's a very good thing and I was going to talk about my grandson whose special needs and he wasn't being in my opinion accommodated very well by the bore School District but that is changing now and I appreciate everything you've all done I really do and and I guess that's about all I want to say I appreciate what you do and everything and Dr Outlaw you remember when I was Santa Claus at your school yeah that was one of the happiest things I ever did thank you everybody thank you very much for your comments anybody else well with that uh like to wish everybody here and out

094out there there wherever you are uh Merry Christmas happy Hanukkah happy holidays and uh we're looking forward to a great 2025 everybody have a nice New Year and we'll look look to see you all back on the other side next year enjoy New Year enjoy yep happy enjoy your vacation with that a motion to go out of uh public session motion second okay all in favor I I nobody's opposed I know I'll speak for that one second okay happy holidays everybody happy holiday thought was in a motorcycle accident

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.