CorpusRecord 59972

BCSD Board of Education meting 1/22/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / BCSD Events
Date
2025-01-23
Location
Albany County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,821 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-06-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e might need to turn your microphone why would I uh if we could reconvene our meeting to open session the board has been an executive session since 6 o'clock to discuss three 10e recommendations contractual matter and a legal matter will you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for introductions D Dave Hurst Robert tan Katherine natto John Walston Jody Monroe Holly Delo you MCM Lauren Gro John MC Phillips um wouldn't think so but do we have any pig or Supa students here tonight you guys are GNA get it in right under the wire huh okay you guys have to stay until the meeting is

002over or 9:00 whichever comes first um and just don't leave without signing out up here so that you get credit for being here um and I just want to thank Glenmont for hosting us this evening always nice to uh make our way around uh first up is our approval of minutes um it is recommended by the superintendent that the Board of Education approve the minutes from the January 8th 2025 regular board meeting so moved second any discussion all in favor I any opposed any extensions that carries item three meeting reports and first is our superintendent's report sure um just one thing to recort um as everyone knows we moved uh when we uh to our food service program to a system called link where parents can pay online for their food balancers and whatnot and

003we had been using my school books prior but we also use my school books for um AP exam fees for the school store for other things things um ticket sales and things such as that we thought we were going to be able to use the link for all of those and unfortunately we've just not been able to make it work for the needs of the district so moving forward we're working on um I think we're going to revert back to using my school box for everything outside of food service we're required to use Link for Food Services because we're part of the Bose Food Service program and that's the system we need to use um however for for the other applications exams and ticket sales and fundraising and things we certainly can go back to

004my school books I think it was more user friendly for families and students so uh we'll let everyone know we do have to go back and reset up the accounts and things such as that but it just makes sense um given some of the limitations with the link system um some of the additional costs associated with them that we're just not able to um it's not our so we're under kind of what they require um so going back to my school box for now I think makes sense so we'll let everyone know when we're ready to go back to that but I just want to give the board a heads up on so we'll have there'll be the two right different programs correct one for food one for everything else correct if you previously had

005a my schoolbox account do you need to next set up a new one if we go back to it or will that old one still be there somewhere is that still okay it would still work yeah so you won have to set it back up right okay so we'll again we're still in the process of getting that up and going we'll let everyone know what it is so and that's my only report so thanks to everyone for coming out on such a cool night tonight I was surprised when I went into link just to put food money in I'd expected I think when we set it up it was supposed to be three bucks service fee and they tried to charge me 15 bucks um just to reminder people it's still free to send a

006check so I still I just sent a check into school there's no fee for that right but it was obnoxious being yeah yeah you can absolutely send a check in any other no questions okay uh next up is our board report um and I just wanted to note that we did have a policy committee meeting um since our last um meeting and there are a number of policies um that are uh on for a first read um this evening at the end um and then I just want wanted to congratulate um all of the cast and crew and parents and um staff that were involved with the production of Annie um at the middle school this last weekend I had a chance to see it it was terrific um and like everybody most importantly was

007having a lot of fun doing the show um so I just wanted to put that out there anybody have anything else okay um next are our student reports um do we have anybody here from the high school student Senate it's too cold I know it is also um midterms and Regents week so um and do we have anybody from the Middle School here this evening we want to congratulate the cast crew and directors of the Middle School Musical production of Annie a great show all around character t-shirts are due to arrive at the end of this month and will be distributed to all students and staff as soon as they arrive the end of our second quarter of our school year is this Friday January 24th report cards and honor roll will be posted shortly

008afterward at the end of the next week the Middle School equality committee ran kindness micro assemblies during home base on Tuesday January 7th the homebased meetings were led by the Bethlehem High School students who taught about recognizing differences celebrating people's strengths and being kind to all the equality committee hopes to run another round of these later in March we want to remind all of our peers that in observance of the Lunar New Year next Wednesday J January 29th there will be no school for students thank you the kids now right um yes a reminder to all of our parents that you're students will be home um next Wednesday um and do we have um some friends from Glenmont here this evening I'd like to invite up nine of our fifth graders here from Glenmont Elementary

009School to tell you the board about what's been happening here at our school members of the Board of Education miss monell doc Dr Hurst Mr MC Phillips and community members my name is Carter I would like to welcome you to glont school we're excited to share with you what has been happening here at our school this year hi I lost my voice I can't talk do you want to wait a minute okay you can do it hi my name is Tessa I can't do it it's okay we'll come back to you you hi my name is Anie this year fifth graders have an additional responsibility to be peer leaders who assist younger students at recess any fifth grader who was interested in becoming a peader had to complete an application and an interview in order

010to be accepted into the program after participating in three training sessions we will soon be assigned to interact with younger students during their recess periods both by helping them find fun things to do and also by guiding them in social interactions with one another hi my name is Ben this year our school is focusing each month on a positive character trait such as love of learning or social intelligence at the end end of the month we have a school assembly during which a student in each class is recognized by the teachers for demonstrating that trait these students receive a certificate while the whole school applauds for them at the assembly a class also shows a video which they made illustrating the upcoming month's positive character trait January's character trait is perseverance hi my name is

011Emma we have been excited to part participate in the letro program at Glenmont School this year together with our parents we decide on a project we can do at home all by ourselves projects have included packing our own lunches walking to a friend's house by ourselves learning to ride a bike and picking out our own clothes in the morning by doing things independently we learn to be confident and resilient our parents also learn that they don't have to do as much for us as we grow up hi my name is fion we like to have fun together at Glenmont School whether at the Halloween ball field day or at upcoming lip sync our PTA plays a big role in funding these fun events as well as academic extras like a residency for our environmental educator

012George steel we are grateful for their support hello my name is Arie we are looking forward to another special event funded by our PTA a visit from author and illustrator Jason Chin on March 26th Mr Chin a calicott Award Medal has written and Illustrated numerous award-winning books that combine his passion for nature science and art Mr Chin has written about having having a published illustrator visiting his school when he was growing up inspired him maybe he will inspire one of us to become a famous author or illustrator someday hi my name is Logan next week is Lunar New Year which means it is now a school holiday in New York state did you know that 2025 is the year of the snake we learned that last week when we had the honor of welcoming members

013from the Chinese Community Center to our school last week for a Lunar New Year assembly it was fun to learn about this holiday and see the performers hello my name is Jada in less than a week who I'm at fourth and fifth graders will be performing in this very room for our January music concerts students in our for and fifth grade orchestras will play as well as those in our fifth grade band and all fourth and fifth grade students will sing in our choirs please join us next Tuesday evening at 6:00 p.m. for grade 4 and 700 p.m. for grade 5 thank you again to the board of education for visiting glat school tonight hi my name is Tessa as the leaders in the school we as fifth graders have special responsibilities this includes raising

014and lowering the flag each day and making the morning announcements over the loudspeaker for the whole school these are important jobs that we have looked forward to doing since we were in kindergarten Tessa just demonstrated our character stength of the month perseverance so kudos to our fifth graders thank you you guys want to come over here I have a wi for you thank you so much for coming talking to us you guys did a great job such great speakers awesome thank you nice job thankks for [Music] hang is it okay graders home so they yes definitely I was just about to say you are of course welcome to stay but you also can go home and get a good night's sleep too [Music] and our presentation this evening um is on the ELA curriculum pilot

015process um so I invite our presenters to come on up good evening my name is Dan hash I'm the K12 Ela supervisor tonight we'll provide an overview of our Ela curriculum pilot process one of the great Parts about working as the ELA supervisor is the group of Specialists that we have to help sport specific tasks and needs as they arise as a quick round of introductions let me identify and share the roles as you will hear from each of these amazing individuals as we go through our presentation Laura heon our Glenmont principal and C co- facilitator Laur and I work closely together on the management pieces of the curriculum she's our liaison to the other principles so as we work to bring in new curricula we can make sure that everyone is in the know

016and gather feedback from that group regarding implementation and training needs Jen Spa is our multi-tiered system of supports coordinator Jen has been instrumental in thinking about the measures that we use and data that we need to collect to identify both our strengths and areas of improvement Allison heer is our K2 instruction coach Ellison is our amazing boots on the ground teacher support she pulls from her years of experience with the primary grades to help think about how decisions will look and work in the classroom this presentation will be broken into two parts the first will review the three primary reasons that pushed us toward finding a new Ela program to help support our Learners the second will'll review the process itself our district goals continue to serve as a compass for our work as we

017search for a program that will support each of the domains listed this alignment is reflected in the instructional routines themselves but in ela also through the text sets that the curriculum uses to support the instruction we use eight overarching steps bless you in building a selection and pilot process which you will hear outlined in more detail as we work through this presentation these steps included reflecting on our previous adoption and pilot work creating a structure that our cabinet could follow to review the needs of our students and program options and finally pilot viting the selected program in a way that would allow us to have a number of users in different environments capture data and provide feedback for cabinet decisions let me turn things over to Allison who will walk us through the reflection process

018hi everybody it's nice to see you so I'm going to bring you back to 2022 and that's when we decided we needed to look at a new phonic program for Gres K to2 so we looked at several different options and we decided to take a look at foundations we went around to different school districts and talked to different teachers using it and of course as you know we decided to Pilot foundations um so K2 teachers across the district I was one of them we piloted it in the spring and then we took all that information back to cabinet and we made the decision to adopt foundations as our phonic program we then in this spring had at our superintendent's conference day we had some of the materials out the teachers were able to take a

019look at them and that's the best part teachers want to see the posters and all the good stuff so they took a look at all of that um and again we made the decision to adopt and then this was great which the teachers really loved in June we were able to have all of the materials delivered to the school district and we were able to have trainers from foundations basically do an unboxing and open up the kit and walk all the teachers through all of the materials um so that if they chose they could look at it over the summer and get prepared for September and then in September after they were in full swing we had the foundation Trainers for a full day through Zoom going through what typical lessons look like and to

020answer questions that some of the teachers still had about the program um so you're going to hear a little bit tonight about Ela cabinet so I thought it would be important for you to understand what the cabinet is um I have been a member of the cabinet for a very long time um obviously as a classroom teacher I was a member but I'm also now part of it as the K2 instructional coach so the cabinet is made up of several members you have teachers from every building we have a representative of our primary from K2 as well as intermediate 35 um we also sometimes have reading teachers on cabinet may have a really nice perspective to provide um we also have Laura and and Jen also goes I attend and the El Ela cabinet is

021basically the decisionmaking team for the district um they take all of the information that they hear from teachers in their buildings bring it back to Cabinet um and we make the decision on whether to adopt a new program and so when you hear about pilot process we're doing this evening you'll see that cabinet is the one who will make the final stamp as to whether we will will adopt a new program and I'm going to give it now over to Jen who's going to talk to you about why we're now on the journey for a new Ela program hi everyone okay so just a quick refresher about what the science of reading is and the points toward the need of systematic and direct instruction for the big six competencies which have been a major focus

022of the New York State education literacy briefs um which also encompasses edlaw 818 which requires each School District to ensure that their curriculum in grades uh prek to three aligns with the elements of instructional best practices okay so here they are the big six so oral language that refers to spoken language skills that form the foundation for reading and writing it's the ability to understand we call that receptive language and to use spoken words effectively that's expressive language the next one is phonological awareness and that's the ability to recognize and manipulate sounds in the spoken language phonics is the relationship between the sounds of spoken language phones and the letters or groups of letters that they represent graphes um used to represent the Sounds in written language comprehension of course is the process of understanding

023and making meaning of text and this is the ultimate goal of reading so all the things that we need to do to inform the process to really get to where students understand have a deep understanding of what they're reading uh fluency is the ability to read um text accurately quickly and um with procity and expression that's appropriate to Aid in comprehension and of course vocabulary is the collection of words that a person knows and understands the bigger the vocabulary and the deeper understanding the better you're going to able to comprehend what you read so where where does all that leave us and how did this inform our process so we reviewed our current program that were in place and we we saw a lot of strengths and some areas that were gaps and there were

024inconsistencies so that sort of informed our work in selecting a new program and what we decided we wanted to Pilot um and we want to explore other programs that more comprehensively integrate all of these different six competencies um I wanted to talk briefly about a knowledge based curricula okay and this is in line with the science of reing reading and essentially what that is is it's a framework assigned to build background knowledge so all students have a deeper understanding kind of before they dig in to the nuts and bolts and processes of reading and writing they've got that foundational knowledge of what they're going to be learning about which makes everything easier to comprehend um it typically brings in uh knowledge across subject areas particularly social studies and science not replacing those of course but

025building um that knowledge framework for them to be able to make meaning of what they're reading um let's see so the student learning is really rooted in inquiring information um and using that information to demonstrate their understanding when they're speaking or writing um to make it kind of Simply a knowledge-based curricula is you're learning about things and kids love to learn about things so you know when you come home with the dinner table kids might you're like what do you learn today oh well you know we don't want to hear things like I'm learning about how to write an essay I mean yeah of course that's one but we really want to learn the content Rich environments that they're getting through the curricula so that's knowledge B turn it over to so the actual process

026of the pilot so first we needed to explore the language arts curricular products available on the market so Dan reached out to other local districts to talk to their Ela supervisors we scoured Professional Publications and websites talked to other contacts that we have and eventually selected a list of Publishers and their products that we felt were worthy of bringing to the cabinet to learn more about before the Publishers came to present to us however we did ask the cabinet to First Define what criteria we should consider such as for example of course alignment to the New York State Standards um high quality instructional design a product that offers differentiation and one that includes texts that reflect the growing diversity of our students and the world that we live in those were all priorities as well

027as some other some other elements the cabinet then spent a full day hearing from different Publishers and reviewing their materials that they brought to share with us or you know they had sent to us because some of them were via Zoom the cabinet members had a rubric that they used to keep track of the different curricula to help narrow down the list in a thoughtful Manner and then after we had go to the next slide please Britney after we had eliminated a few choices based on that initial um review we wanted then to gather as much information as possible about the remaining options so we invited a small handful of teachers to conduct a couple mini Pilots for Whitten and wisdom and CK and by mini pilot I mean that maybe two teachers taught a

028single unit to get a general feel for the curriculum originally we had thought about doing the same with a third product Arc but we decided at the last minute to remove them because they really did not meet our criteria and we felt like we were reaching at that point we also um Dan set up two Zoom meetings with other districts which had recently adopted each of the two remaining curricula that we were exploring to hear how it was going for them they were both both a year or two into implementation um what they liked what they didn't like any advice they could provide us and these um Zoom meetings were each an hour before school with the full cabinet in attendance so everyone could hear all of this information firsthand I'll turn it over to

029Dan to continue with the process so while those manyi Pilots were being conducted the knowledge matters campaign updated their site with additional curricula that fit their standards bookworms was that new addition in an effort to do our due diligence along with this program receiving support from local Educational Consultants it was recommended that we take a look at this program we scheduled a presentation with representatives in the same fashion that we conducted with the other products and after evaluating materials using the same rubric we found that aligned with a number of our wants and needs in particular what stood out to our cabinet members was the use of authentic texts and the interdisciplinary knowledge based opportunity after its unanimous voting as our Top Choice combined with the concerns raised about the other products during our many

030Pilots the decision was made to move forward with a pilot in only this one product to create an equitable pilot we decide to have one teacher from each grade in each building take part in this process we started with asking our cabinet members to take part after those slots were filled we moved to the social studies and science cabinets as we want to get their unique perspectives both on the product as a whole as well as on the interdisciplinary units once those groups were exhausted we then reached out to other teachers who may have been interested in taking part and this additional work once we had our group of 30 teachers sixth grades across five buildings we then started working on professional development opportunities to get our teachers to a place where they would feel

031comfortable starting this new program in the fall pilot members were provided with two separate trainings both virtual and both completed prior to started school year as teachers were taking part in the PD we worked on The Ordering of materials which included manuals for teachers workbooks for students and a large number of new texts at each at key points along this journey we want to evaluate both the product as well as teachers feelings about the products to help gather this information we had our pilot members use the rubric they int they were introduced to the previous year that was provided by Ned called the materials alignment Quick Check rubric this rubric allows schools to review key elements of appr program to help decide whether is both instructionally sound and a good fit for our district rubric

032focuses on seven key areas as well as as an eighth fit to your District component we also provided pilot teachers with a Google form that asked for Teacher comfort in a number of areas including the use of materials and the instructional routines teachers were also asked whether they felt it was a good fit for our district additionally Jen and Allison went into classrooms to use different curriculum based measures to review growth that students may already be showing one Focus was on fluency which was a focal point of a number of our discussions these results will be shared with cabinet at our adoption meeting next week to help provide them with an array of evidence to help make an informed decision it was important for us to get the pilot group and cabinet together regularly as

033we knew this was leading to a very important decision that would potentially shift the way we teach Ela for the firstable future we started with a halfday meeting for pilot members to Workshop any issues that they may have been experiencing as well as sharing their initial thoughts this was followed by a cabinet meeting where the information was shared it is important for us to have this early checkpoint in case the program was already generating red flags so that we would have time to Pivot thankfully the feedback was positive and we were able to continue with our work during the months between that half day and our adoption date later in January we provided a monthly time for teachers to collaborate these morning meetings started with a very brief update on the process and then teachers

034were virtually shifted into grade level meeting rooms to discuss and continue working together we did also ask the teachers discuss any areas of concern that were brought up at the cabinet meeting to see if they resolve themselves if they would turn into a major red flag or if they would be something that we could work to g f we're on the precipice of our final stage in this process after providing roughly half the year to Pilot the program we will bring our group back together next Thursday with the ultimate goal of voting on the adoption of the program if adopted we'll start to discuss next steps including using the spring to start the professional development work ahead of next year if it is not adopted we will once again review the options that we have

035and start the process a new we understand the amount of time and resources that go into this work but we also know how important the decision is so we are working to make a choice that lives up to the high standards that we all have here at BC we really appreciate your time this evening and a special thank you to superintendent Monroe and Deputy super superintendent Dr Hurst for their support throughout this process a c so turn your mic back on thanks sorry I've got a couple so feel free to pause me if needed um so I think my first question was we adopted foundations and and I'm just wondering um for kids who are who are who are not receiving fundations now but will be in 35 presumably when this is rolled out no

036we don't have any of those so just to clarify it's okay no there's a lot of moving parts and that's one of the things with the ELA that's you know as a 7th through 12 certified person yeah uh and teaching mainly in middle school and high school getting this job and and previously being a principal opens up a whole new world of Education that I never got and what we're also realizing is that some of our teachers even in the elementary years did not get this Foundation of information so part of the professional development that we talk about has to do with the program or the product that we purchase it also is Gap filling knowledge that some of our teachers just did not get so we're trying to balance these two things with our

037professional development and we're trying to do that systematically with with the principles thinking about during our great CI days during our department meetings ways to layer in some of this education as well so foundations is something that we have for kindergarten through second grade yes that's balanced with hegr so we're hitting um if you remember some of those the six areas that Jen talked about we're hitting the phic awareness and the phonics components uh bookworms is filling in those other four areas so we're thinking about fluency and reading comprehension all these other areas we're working on handwriting we're working on word work so that is going to carry us kindergarten through fifth grade oh thank you yeah so it's it's a juggling act and you know one of the big things that we talk about

038with teachers is the time that goes into it because look I would love the day to be Ela but I also understand that math science and social studies need their time as well so one of the benefits of this and when we're thinking about the time component is the knowledge-based curriculum so science and social studies uh topics are covered in this they do not replace science and social studies so that instruction still has to happen but the way we structured um our pilot process allows members of the social studies and science cabinet to be part so they can look at the books that we're using and say hey this really matches a social studies or science stand ER we can use this book to talk about the topic and then we can use that as

039a point to layer in that social studies and science lesson so everything is Flowing really smoothly together um so it doesn't feel like a another another another kind of to help teachers balance their time a little bit so so bookworms a supplemental curriculum to what we're doing in 35 now it supplemental is one way to talk about it it hits the other six of those big six key standards that we want to get for students so we're not entirely I guess what I'm driving at um or what I'm trying to drive at but not clearly with any Clarity um are we replacing entirely what we're doing in ela 35 now with book words corre or is it that is okay again and I just pause for that just for one second because we haven't gone

040through the adoption process yet if it is if it does pass if cabinet does feel that this it then it would uh replace the units of study that we currently have in place for three f for k K yeah but Foundation stays K2 it will be in addition to so so what we've noticed coming out the past few years is that there's been a deficit of phonics and pic awareness work and we noticed that when we had the units study they did come out and they uh created a different whole different phonic set I think they kind of realized it too um so that was our first step and that's why we reflected a few years ago we knew that that was the first big step that we needed to take we really need to

041shave K through 2 so so that we built in that phonics and phic awareness learning so that students could progress what we realized after is that when we were thinking about the other units of study that we still had in place those reading and writing units of study uh they were not fulfilling what we needed for our students they were a bit Antiquated um they were not a knowledge-based curriculum in the way that we're seeing these new products got it thank you yeah so just one so just one more on this to make sure I get this one piece um so then do we have any either going into so assuming this is adopted it seems as though what I'm hearing from you it seems as though it's got a lot of support we're hopeful

042so so should it be adopted um and begin to be implemented next year do we have any kids next year who are going to have not who who have who will have had the units of study but no foundations and if so what are we going to be doing we've identified gaps right there so are we going to how what what's just the thinking so they will be so because it's K through 2 um and we'll be going into our third year okay um there will be one cohort that did not have the full three years of fundations but they will have had exposure to okay um you know even before we had foundations and hegerty to support that a good chunk of our students were successful um we just wanted to make sure that

043that everybody was successful and we knew that we could do better so they won't necessarily be at a deficit from the foundation standpoint whenever you adopt a program and drop it in K5 as opposed to slowly rolling up there's going to be terminology that will benefit those kids who've had it a few years ago there's things like super sentences as part of this books program if you learn about super sentences in kindergarten first grade by the time you're in fourth or fifth grade you have their routine down some students who get a for the first time when they're already in fourth or fifth grade there's going to be an extra little level of learning that they're going to get it's just the problem that happens with dropping a program in and and starting it um

044no that makes sense yeah thank you so much and let somebody else but I'd love to come back um you and I think you question yeah I appreciate the emphasis on text reflecting diversity of our community and place we live someone mentioned authentic texts I was curious what an authentic text is so the difference is some companies create text themselves um to their need um you know which makes sense right they have a curriculum to teach uh they kind of create their own product that goes along with their system um this program what we really liked is they use some text that you might be familiar with um some of the Ramona novels are in there walk to moons some some really popular titles that a lot of our teachers are already familiar with that

045had already been bringing into their into their classroom so genuinely real books not fake Books Okay exactly yes y Bob yeah this might have just sort of be dub tailing on what was already decid talked about but you talked about a a shift in the you know the way that that Ela was going to be taught and also mention the fact that some of the professional development was going to have to be overl you know can you just talk about the you know what the differences that is going to be you know from from from A to B and and apples to oranges now so one of the big uh areas of emphasis um is fluency vocabulary and background knowledge um so fluency is a major component of a lot of the different curriculum that

046are out there really having opportunities for students to read out loud alongside their teacher um the other two areas vocabulary and background knowledge you know we did a PD right uh before we started this search um we had a couple local uh Educational Consultants come in uh background knowledge and vocabulary are uh a great equalizer you when you think of students who have a variety of different experiences in their life their family gets to take them to museums and uh all sorts of different places they are building this wealth of knowledge so when they interact with a text they're already going in with a knowledge about that topic when they come across different words when they come across different ideas they have this inherent knowledge to help them understand that text a little bit better

047um so the great part about all of these programs that we've been looking at it's how they're really focusing on uh building this background knowledge for all of our students so for those those students who don't have those same opportunities that aren't getting out there and maybe don't have a text-rich home environment this is a way that we can build that up for all of our students and is that related to bringing in the other subject matters into it is yeah yep um because we also know that students are really excited about those things I mean when we sit in our kindergarten all of our Elementary classrooms animals every kid wants to talk about animals and has this wealth of knowledge about these things we're finding that same thing to be true about topics that

048we might see as dry we sat in classes that are talking about the American Revolution and kids are so excited to raise their hand and talk about these things volcanoes planets they're just so excited to share this information and the great part about uh some of these products that we're looking at is it incentivizes that it gives them an opportunity to share all the facts and hands are hands are flying up and then lastly it looked like um bookworms was a late entry to the process and how did it come to your attention I think you mentioned it but yeah so our uh the the people that we worked with our Ed Consultants uh brought us to this website which is called the knowledge matters campaign and that was really what we used as the

049springboard to look at all of the different curricula that we used um as that site developed more and more they begin to add new new products to it um so we would reflect on that and the products that we initially piloted and those mini Pilots while they were good while they had some of those uh positive traits they were still con concerns raised by the teachers um issues like the length of the units we're talking about 10 15 week units um when we're thinking about the text that they were using they weren't always using authentic texts there were some issues that we had when we talked to these other districts and they shared while they did like the products in their districts they listed off the issues that they were having with professional development the

050issues that they were having the timing fitting all of this curriculum within their school day so we we had a hunch that something was off about these two um when we did come across this one we wanted to make sure that we worked slowly through it to give it the same time and everything that we saw uh kind of answered those concerns that we have out and that was just because it popped up on that knowledge matters website it did and one of our Educational Consultants also um when we saw it said hey I've heard about this it's pretty good you should give it the same fair chance that you gave the others and then actually lastly um what what's the I mean what's the percentage or the differential and price for these different programs

051are they wildly Divergent wildly um so the the one great thing um about this product that we're looking at and again I I I really just stress cabinet has not made a final decision so as I talk about this I do not want to we might find that next week there are concerns and and we don't adopt it um compared to the other products the the biggest expense for this program is the books we have to buy tons of books which is such a great problem to have I mean lots and lots of books that are getting into the teachers hands to do read allows to the students that are getting into the students hands to do research to do pair reading to do coral reading we are getting so many books and that's been

052that that's the big price of this um because you can access their curriculum for free it's a open- source product um what we buy from them we buy workbooks from them student workbooks which are really nice we buy a hard copy of a teacher guide but the biggest expense with this is going to be the text themselves that we populate the teacher libraries with thank you yeah um would this aect how we or are you looking to change how we're teaching writing um particularly to our third through fifth graders it it does and one of the interesting pieces of this is it fits nicely with a another program that we had done some professional development with um the writing Revolution was something that we uh played around with um it was this book that came

053out uh a few years back and was really catching steam it was kind of a new way to look at writing and really kind of focusing on building small chunks of the writing before getting into the longer pieces um they have this program has pulled in a lot of those same key features things like super sentences really focusing on making sure a student has a really solid sentence and paragraph before we we get into that essay writing and that's something that we've had conversations about because it is a difference for our teachers in the units of study some of our teachers were uh expecting to do longer writing at younger ages um this one's a little bit different this one's really pushing us to say can every kid write a great solid paragraph before they

054get into those multi- paragraph pieces um so we're we're excited about that uh we're interested to see what happens the great thing about working on the cabinet is and uh working with these folks is that we get to take our time look at things if something is not working for us doesn't fit our needs what's the data that's pointing to that and how can we Gap fill uh those areas um you mentioned um that this uses authentic texts and um an example of the Ramona books do will kids still be reading an entire book or will they just be reading a portion a chapter of whole books okay yeah and in two different ways one is through um uh higher level texts uh text that are a little bit above their grade that is read

055by the teacher to the class that they get to enjoy and there's a whole another section to this program um that is devoted to students reading those texts with each other um with the teacher um so they're getting exposure to text in two different ways great and then um I know we we brought in foundations a couple of years ago um and now bookworms some of those same teachers are are bringing this in to their classroom as well do we have any concerns that this is too much change for the these teachers that they're being asked to do too much for sure and we've asked that question to Cabinet multiple times we really want to make sure that we weren't going too quickly because I get that hey I just got this going and now

056you're giving me something new and something new and something new so that was one of the first things that we talked about with cabinet was is this too soon do we need to take a little bit longer because there was talk about adopting it at the end of last year and having this year be our first year but we knew that was too soon we knew that there's lots of other departments out there that are working through their needs and we can't steal all the time as much as we want to um so we're trying to do this in a slower measured way we're hopeful that whatever the decision is by cabinet we can slowly layer in professional development through the second half of the Year even if it's not about the product itself hey

057here's some of the skills here's what a knowledge based curriculum is here's what here's how to use fluency in your classroom here are little things that you can learn so no matter what product we end up with they'll have some of that background information thank you um I definitely appreciate the um sort of going through how the the process works because I think sometimes it's a mystery to the community about how we um bring new curriculums in um and you know maybe for this is a question for Dave maybe but um just in general is the process the same in other cont 10 areas depending on what we're looking at yes so for I mean I'll speak I guess K12 but so for K5 all curricular decisions are made by cabinets um so there's a

058an Ela a math a science and a social studies cabinet that um each one of those bodies has a K2 rep and a 35 rep from each of the buildings um the subject area supervisor and principal liaison um to the point about Ela sometimes like so um Allison takes part in both the math and Ela cabinets as an instructional coach because that role kind of fits sometimes we bring reading teachers say into the um Ela cabinet um but that's the body that essentially makes all sort of curricular decisions um and then 6 through 12 it's more departmentalized because now you have um subject area experts in each of those departments teaching the courses so the curriculum decisions are made through those departments and then as we had this presentation last year um the cabinet or

059the curriculum council at the high school is sort of the overall deciding body once departments kind of come to agreement on what things they want to add or remove from the curriculum guide that goes to the full curriculum Council who then votes on that yeah but in terms of I'm thinking like say at the high school with the English curriculum if you're looking to add books change what is being read in different classes like you might still do like a pilot of different for sure and that's done more the departmental or even typically the high school it's for that type of situ sitation be done at the course level um and then you know the typically all the teachers in course might try a new text say and then um decide whether that's something they

060want to move forward with um one more thing I want to add about this is even though the timeline might seem a little bit accelerated um we sort of have no choice this is sort of a state you know as we we started this conversation three or four years ago now um the the science of reading has really taken off and this actually beginning in September we have to to fill an attestation to the state basically saying that we are providing um instruction and curriculum that hits those six points that we talked about um and that we're following the science of reading so you know we delayed I guess we moved as quick as we needed to but also as slow as you need to at the same time right if that makes sense sure

061John uh it's very exciting to hear about all the texts and workbooks that are going to be involved what's is there like a suggested um breakdown of the amount of time on a screen versus amount of time using the workbooks and reading the text yeah there's not really a screen component to this uh there's a physical workbook for students there's a teacher manual and as we mentioned before a whole lot of books that's great thank you yeah thank you um so can you speak to spelling for a little bit and how that'll be covered is that are we shifting that's tau is that built into well SP so spelling obviously we are K2 is foundations so obviously that's how they cover the spelling um in K2 and then when you move to 35 there is

062a spelling component there's a word study component um I'm going to speak to borms but as Dan said we haven't formally adopted it yet but yes so when they move to third grade um they focus on um for example closed syllables open syllables things like that and how using that knowled to break down words and sound words out so there is a very big word study component to it it's pretty neat actually they also do a lot of morphology work um in bookworms um so yeah there's this very very strong it's not your traditional I get a list on Monday and you study study study and you take your test on Friday and then on Monday you forget because you're head start all over right um so it's it's a little bit different than that

063it's really looking at words a little bit differently so yeah but there is a very bit work so it to three through five oh that's fantastic thank you and then um we've spent rightfully so a lot of focus on Ela at the elementary level which is is great and very much oh just a quick question you were talking about units of study I'm that's that the L Lucy ckins right like okay I just want to make sure I'm I'm picking up on the U all of that correctly okay anyway so we're looking at um K5 are we also plenty any shifts middle or high school for EA not currently you know uh to the question that was mentioned before about tech selection process that's something that we constantly go through at the high school we

064spent time last um last summer you know kind of looking at who our authors were um when those books were written um and doing some piloting for new books as well um at the middle school there is a component of bookworms that goes through 6 through 8 it's not something that we have decided to move forward with um but there are opportunities um to kind of bridge that five six Gap um you know we constantly are looking at our data um I ready in particular as well as our classroom scores to make those decisions are students successful um where what are those specific areas or specific donate Mains that we have to really focus on um last year we found that vocabulary was an area that we want to put an increased emphasis on um

065so we worked at the end of last year to create systematic vocabulary instruction 6 through eight um we're working through that again this year um um it's not really a pilot we are going Full Throttle but in the same way that Pilot's happen we stop and reflect and see what's working and not working so it's really a little bit of a different beast in 6 through 12 where we look at kind of as opposed to a product that we can put in we look at the different domains and say what are those skills that we want to beef up and we want to focus on could a product come in and help us with those domains possibly um but there's a lot of work that those professionals can do as well thank you and then

066will adopting a new program have any impact or differences in how we supporting students who are not reading at grade level yeah it it could and I I'll lean on Jen for this a little bit there are components of many of these programs that are really focused on that additional support um at this time in regards to this program that we've been piloting we are looking at the primary uh two areas and not the differentiated instruction block at this point um but that is a product that they have that we could layer in as well if we find that there's there's a need for that you know we have a a great mtss process um that that Jen's kind of working on the spearheading you know so we kind of lean on our Professionals in

067that area to help us make one of the best parts of this program is the um students have access to a grade level and above grade level text and it's all presented with the teacher scaffolding and modeling so unfortunately what can happen which we're trying really hard point is students who struggle with reading often you read decodable more simple texts this yes you get that to be able to practice the skills that you have but you also will always need access to grade level material and this really um nicely fits that in so although kids may not be able to read it themselves depending on their level of you know proficiency they still have access to hear the content that the whole class is learning and to be able to participate so that's a really

068important aspect that allows access for all kids regardless of their proficiency level with reading so that isn't really and if we're seeing gaps is this is this another would it be another you know pilot of process to like is would we follow the same steps to assess if we wanted to use the other block you were referring to it's it's really important for us to continue to follow this process um with our cabinet you know when when we have our cabinet making these decision ision they are the ones that can go to their fellow teachers and say this is why we need to do this it is a really quick way to kind of build that support behind whatever the decision is that's being made so yeah it everything goes slowly in education and we

069know that and we're trying to embrace it as a positive thing we don't want to race into something we want to make sure we're taking those measured steps before we make that decision and and as we talked about funding before these things cost a lot of money so we want to really make sure that we're making the right decision and then my actual last question you um You referred to professional development rolling this out what type of support will we have for our teachers this is going to be rolled out in PD over the summer is this going to be how are we approaching that we're working through those details um the two they offer virtual professional development and on-site support um when we talked to one of our neighboring districts who did uh already

070adopt this program they said that the on-side support was very helpful um to them it's kind of a regular coaching process that they have where they come in you know this really comes down to what the needs of our teachers are and we really want to make sure that the first year is a success um so we'll we'll be working with cabinet through those decisions as well wonderful thanks thank you very much you thank you very much thank you thanks appreciate it uh next is our recognition of public comment on an agenda item if we have any visitors who would like to address the board on agenda item now would be the time to come up to the microphone uh item six action items a professional Personnel action items it is recommended by the superintendent

071that the Board of Education approve the following professional Personnel action items one through [Music] 13 uh any discussion all in favor I any opposed any extensions that carries and uh B support Personnel action items it is recommended by the superintendent that the Board of Education approve the following support staff action items 1 through six any discussion all in favor I any opposed any extensions that carries item C other action items it is recommended by the superintendent that the Board of Education approve the following action items 1 through four any discussion tobacco use of vaping and such um I know it it's not completely clear that vaping of things other than tobacco is also forbidden and maybe we can look at the wording on that slightly more that was all it was there a particular just

072you had a particular sentence in there I can I can send you a comment if you want if that be EAS okay Sobe we can do is we can pull that one from the first read if youan has a comment and then you can just yeah if you couldn't sure add that and send it to the policy commit easiest way to do it um so with that exception um all in favor I I any opposed any extensions that carries uh item seven recognition of public comment on a non-agenda item if we have any visitors who would like to address the board on a non-agenda item now would be the time to come to the microphone yes if you could just um state your name for us please hi everybody my name is Danielle Hamid um

073good evening superintendent Monroe president delba and other members of the board first off I would like to thank you for your commitment and dedication to the students of the Bethlehem Central School District as the public school teacher myself I truly understand the importance of a school board while also realizing I ing the challenges this position often encounters um as I mentioned my name is Danielle and I'm a resident of the Bethlehem Central School District I've lived in Glenmont since returning to this area in 2012 after teaching overseas in Dubai currently I'm a special ed teacher at Tech valy High School where I've taught for the past nine years as of right now Bethlehem does not participate in sending students to Tech valy High School iosis program that being said Bethlehem does send students to other

074Bose programs I am hopeful that you might reconsider this decision before making your decision I would love to provide you all with a tour of our wonderful school um and provide you with any additional information you might need in regards to our school I believe that once you visit Tech Valley you will be excited about the work we do with our students um I really appreciate your time and your consideration on this deeply personal matter I look forward to help us facilitating this additional option for Bethlehem students thank you thank you thank you anybody else um item eight of future meetings and events our next regularly scheduled board meeting is on Wednesday February 5th at the high school anticipating executive session at 6 and reconvening to open session at 7 um and then our meeting

075after that um is on February 26th a longer break because of the U winter break um again anticipating uh executive session at 6 and reconvening to open session at 7 seeing no need to go back into executive session could I have a motion to adjourn the meeting so moved second all in favor I I meeting adjourned um and our e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.