001I pledge Alle to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all okay thank you for that could I get a motion to approve uh tonight's meeting agenda I make a motion any discussion all those in favor thank you very much Pearl do we have any blue cards no blue cards and so we'll skip item C and D there's no presentation so if I could get a motion for item e in its entirety motion motion second any discussion all those in favor okay could I get a motion for item F the consent agenda in its entirety I know we got a motion by Allison second and second by Christie any discussion okay just didn't specify is a disposal
002or I'd be happy to address um so those those are going to go to to bid go to auction um so we're working with Paul to place those out so hopefully we recoup some some costs on that but before we can list them for auction we'll need the board's approval to dispose of the items you're welcome any other discussion all those in favor okay on to item G reports you're up thank you um I just want to apologize if anything's a bit repetitive because I wasn't here last time but um I want to first start off by saying that the student government's trip to Lake Placid for the annual Nyssa conference was a huge success I know that members myself included walked away grateful for the experience and with more knowledge than they had prior
003to what it takes to be a true leader the guest speakers were amazing and as were the experiences student government is now in early preparations for their next educational trip to Disney World in March um I next want to congratulate our school's Deca members who have advanced to the Statewide competition in Rochester New York this upcoming March this year we had an impressive 18 individual event placers including students Nathan wichinsky Jonah Martinez Maddox Ramsey Khloe Sheen Michael Weaver Andrew Landis Andrew Card Owen Chapman Abigail tetral Sarah hbert Connor Peterson Avery Sheen Khloe Gibbs Sam fos Gage Williams Jack mavel Lillian grenell and Gabriella morizio as well as four team event placers including students Cadence Graham and Emma Lacy Zachary card and William card Ella rert and Sydney Saunders and Matthew Jackson and Anthony Fawn congratulations
004to senior Olivia Shire who was named to the NYS psaa also known as the New York state public high school athletic association's All State team in class AA for her impressive volleyball skills congratulations to senior Angelo turo who was selected to play in the big 44 All-Star game where he was awarded the MVP award as well as the US Army Warrior award for his hard work dedication Relentless effort and commitment to his football team and a congratulations to seniors Abigail Sund Grace Meyers and Olivia luki who have officially been selected as the student directors of this year's musical production of Hades Town official show dates are February 6th 7th and 8th according to to michons this year we had over 50 students audition uh which has been the most ever and then last but not
005least congratulations to senior mayah Howard who was nominated for iGo County's teen of the week if interested you can find her article online where she talks about where her love for art originated and her gratitude towards Paul V Moore's art department and staff and that's all for me okay mat it's awesome okay board member reports do we have any um thing we talk about before I make my motion up okay as we talked about last meeting I am going to make a motion that the athletic Jamie's memo for the Central Square athletic placement process be incorporated through the policy committee for item 42 7420 Sports and athletic program so they're Incorporated and they're in line with with what that policy is can I get a second just a question on that so we're not seeking
006to necessarily update the policy that we have in front of us we're just seeking to do what with it exactly well the policy and the memo are not alignment okay so i' I'd like to get whatever the decision is for it have the policy reflect what the athletic directors put out are we Mak any decision tonight I'd make a motion too so that we can it it can be yeah but I we did all that well I I think that if if I can get a second then we can discuss what we want and then put it put it to the vote then we can either amend it um as as I proposed or we can put it towards policy I don't think I'd be comfortable with moving it to policy until we actually took
007a vote on the consensus on where we stood with it before it went to policy where that's when you know we typically see what we're seeking to change and discuss it from there I think I'd like to at least gauge either through Vote or further discussion like we did last time on the board's consensus Steve I'll second so that we can now have the discussion right okay okay so if we could we'll go around and to until we get TR to what exactly doing well I think that any anytime that we're going to be asking policy be be changed on this like we discussed it last time but I said at last meeting that we would BR I would bring it you can give it some time to think about it we bring it up
008get it get a motion made and the decision one way or another as far as how we would like to go and that's really what we should be doing this can't to policy why does it keep Rising its head every couple years just put the information in there say how it is Ando doesn't align with policy so that's my concern follow it not Soo right and I just I guess I'm a little bit confused based on Allison's comment in terms of we don't typically tell the policy committee what to do the policy committee usually does it and then we do a first reading and a second reading to decide whether we you know so I I don't know I'm not really sure how you know I don't know that we need to come to consensus
009before we send it to them because I feel like policy is the one that then develops the policy and makes the Amendments granted if we want the seventh grade provision of the memo to be incorporated in the policy you know I mean that could be advised because then if it comes back and it's not theoretically we're just going to send it back to them after the first reading but I don't know that the process is that we make the policy give it to them to put into print and then we approve it that's not really I do think that I think it's a good idea that we do we do come to some type of clarity because when you look at the policy as Steve just mentioned 7420 and it does talk about the AP
010uh protocols set forth uh by the section which we do comply with because eighth graders still need to take the AP to be able to try out for junior varsity varsity which we still do we still have uh seventh graders on um certain sports that do not have a freshman or mod ified such as rifle or golf things like that they they still have to do the AP process the only part that was a little bit kind of ambiguous is where it says in the policy the superintendent will Implement procedures for the app and will direct the athletic director to maintain the records of the students who have successfully completed AP so that's a little bit ambiguous U people could look at that and wonder what does that really mean does that mean that the
011superintendent has the right to be able to say like what took place in 2023 when it was brought to my attention that we were not going to have seventh graders trying out or younger so I for consistency and Clarity I do think that we should definitely talk about this and then if the if the current Board of Education feels that that should be a policy then this memo this practice I will say because that's what we did for last year will actually be written in so anybody that looks at bore policy 7420 would know exact there'd be no ambiguity they would know exactly what it means is that what you were thinking yes exactly so it leads this way then the everybody now 10 years from now they could look at board policy 7420 and
012they would say okay for teams that do not have a modified um or a freshman team they would be able to take the AP and be able to play because that's how we're currently doing it um but when they do have a modified um or a freshman team then seventh graders or younger would not be able to try out for those teams however way we do it it will just be written in there that way so there'd be no confusion moving forward okay any more discussion on it and I'll I'll just I'll just talk just a couple minutes about procedures and and policy so what what I'm striving to do here is to make sure that whatever the Administration has is based off of policy and if policy's out of alignment come to the board
013right because that's our main responsibility is policy and if it's not and and so that if there's questions from board members about policy or if there's questions and procedures from Administration that that know that we can come bring it up talk about it and then keep it in alignment so we have a process to go because Lori to your point you're very senior on the board you've been here a very very long time along with Randy and Christie and I are the second most senior so we have a new board here so I'd like to have as a group we'd be able to if there's issues and things that get brought up come in we talk about them if there's something that we need to to actually make a motion going vote on that we
014have a procedure and everybody's comfortable with that is really what I'm trying trying to get accomplished as a secondary part of this exercise uh I guess the only other point of discussion which I somewhat raised in the last one um you know Tom the the language that you reference that the superintendent will Implement procedures for the AP I don't I mean is that what you're saying that's where the the edits will be made in terms of no I don't really know what I I didn't create that I don't know what the intent of that means so that's why I think this doesn't sound like a procedure this sounds like a policy you know what I mean so oh I'm sorry I thought I was referencing no no no I am and I am and I'm
015saying superintendent will Implement procedures that sounds like process that doesn't sound like you know so we'd be CH effectively changing the policy to reflect the decision that were behind this correct okay and so again my only hesitation in doing that is I feel like we have an AP process that can fully accomplish this without having it as a a policy a policy within a policy so it just seems like AP will apply except in these situations I just have a feeling it's going to the policy is going to become you know this the policy probably will have to be entirely Rewritten um and if that's what we're because you know we talk most of the policy talks about following the AP process and so I guess legally you know exempting out seventh graders but not
016all seventh graders only seventh graders where there's not a modified sport it just gets you know it just gets messy and so you know if if that's what we're doing I feel like it's more than just the language that you're quoting because the language that you're quoting I don't I don't think this would qualify under a procedure you know what I'm saying I do and so um and so if if we're rewriting the policy then I feel like it's got to go to the policy committee and then it's got to be a first reading and a second reading and and it's got to say that that the seventh graders can play modified if they're eligible and I I I really in my heart do not feel that they should play up they they have modified
017if they want to or they can you know a lot of times the kids who are very good do travel ball and travel soccer and whatever so I think it should be more clear on who can play and who was part of this poliy so there are several school districts that over the years have have made changes I don't know if they actually changed their board policy or if they just implemented a practice but there were many school districts that have said we're not having seventh graders um being on JV varsity because of the social emotional aspect and I think that like the whole pandemic exacerbated that when we saw kids that really going through a lot of things um at the end of the day like I Steve hit the nail on the head
018this is what the board does the board does policy so if the board were to say well you know we disagree we see what your point you're me and and Jamie Grimshaw um one of the other things though that's it's really important understand is so I coach three Varsity Sports and there's a lot of pressure on coaches and so to have to make um an objective decision without people thinking that it's subjective when it comes down to maturity you're always going to have people say garbage you said yes to that seventh grader because you go to the restaurant with that father or that mother like people are always going to say those things and when you weigh the two next to it I just personally don't see that we're doing a massive of disservice to
019a kid that can still play JV varsity at the eighth grade level again I go back and then I'll in conclusion I'll just say I respect the fact that the board does policy and so if the board says we hear what you're saying Tom but we're not in agreement with that I respect that 100% because the board does policy and again I don't necessarily disagree with the assertions with respect to seventh graders I mean I my own kids I you know discouraged my seventh grader currently from playing a sport that doesn't have a modified level um because of maturity and as a parent I I think that that I'd probably be the one that's best to know whether my student is mature or can handle the pressure and so on and so forth but I
020guess again my concern with this is the AP process provides for everything that you're talking about because the um athletic director who is has you I think last meeting you said that he was this was his idea because of his feelings about it he has to sign off on all of those and so if it's his provision that seventh graders that have a modified sport available should play the modified sport then on his page of the AP thing he would say declined modified sport available I feel like that's a more appropriate for the student and so I guess that's where I and it's probably just the legal training in me having rules within rules just ends up getting messy and so when there's a rule that covers it it can accomplish the same ending it
021just seems redundant to have another rule inside of that rule but um you know again I tend to agree with the premise it's just the process process that's happening I just feel like it's a bit redundant I think what's more that people just don't want to say no they don't want to be the ones that say declined on the AP application I mean it every seventh grader that applied for any of the sports that have modified level could say declined on the page that is required for supp right so but that's but I think we've already discussed this so like at length this portion of it with all due respect like last meeting we spent in a huge amount of time just discussing this topic and whether Jamie is literally going to go through and
022every time a modified student applies for a contact sport you know that wants to play Varsity he has to go through and decline every single one based on the premise that you know they're not ready and then every single parent that disagrees is going to call him and it's going to turn into this giant thing that it doesn't need to be I mean I don't know where it stands I'll just make it here unnown irregardless of whatever is brought up tonight I am absolutely not for um in any circumstances a seventh grader playing any Varsity Sport where it can otherwise be prevented with a modified sport in play I'm just not for it regardless of anything and I wouldn't support any policy relinquishing that back to the a process C or whatever that might be
023I'm just not for it I I don't think that seventh graders have any place playing JB or Varsity Sports when they have a modified sport to play yeah and I I think the question is too is is where's the back stop so if the policy if you have the athletic director and superintendent not wanting to deal with the decision then the back stop is the board and saying that that seventh graders will not play if there's and if there's a modified team they're going to play on the modified team and that and that ends that so then it's on it's almost like a shield to the athletic J and the superintendent that this is a board policy if you got a problem with it go to the board and I think that's to to me
024you know I I'm not on one side of the fencer or the other when it when it comes to seventh graders playing the sport but it's what the athletic director and the superintendent want so I'm that will sway me to support them in what they do but this has got to get cleaned up so it makes sense abely so so that so it makes sense and I don't think it can really be down to a couple sentences and then it's not up because what what ultimately happens is memos get lost emails get lost TS get lost where if it's going to be that important let's get it in writing let's get it in a policy let's go through the channels and then then we'll go through so to David's point I I'm not an attorney
025we have attorneys on our board but I I'm not an attorney I don't know could a just stop so if it wasn't the coach that said no but if it's the athletic director that can say no what's the next level that a parent can say well I'm going to challenge that I'm going toing assume they'd have to be an appeal proc I'm going to bring this into court and so to Allison's point where does that stop and so now are we going to expend District Resources with with appeals but again as I said from the beginning I wholeheartedly believe the bo board makes policy and I respect that process so whatever the outcome is I will respect that okay any further discussion do you want me to re re reiterate what we're what what the
026uh motion was thank you I'll try and do my best no no no slipping so my motion is to have the memo that Jamie khaw has written go back to the policy committee to be in inated into 7420 Sports and athletic program so that it talks about the things that that they would like to get accomplished in the memo be put into policy go through the policy committee first and second reading and then come back before the board that's my motion and it's already been seconded it's already been seconded so could I get all those in favor I need it to be Al those opposed motion perous okay thank you very much you're up Tom well I can I can thank Mato because he literally took three quarters I I heard a lot of scratching
027going on over three quarters of all the DECA all the sports excellent very thorough Mato I appreciate that um ju the the one thing that I do want to be able to just kind of give an update is um I did give uh City bosis a tour of CSI um as a a possibility to uh potentially Le space they are having a meeting coming up and they will be discussing um there is a need for space with our many many programs at bosis um the other thing that we were looking at over at CSI and we still are um Aaron Phillips has done a really good job we're in the process right now of taking all the information they got for what full day upk could look like um and we started to get you
028know the a lot of the surveys back so we kind of know about the parent interest in that ironically enough there are still a lot of parents that still just want their kid to be in half day upk I'm surprised I was surprised I thought parents would really jump on having full day but I totally understand um the parents point with that but what we're thinking is is if we're able to accomplish what we want on an entire Wing could that then the cost be then completely offset by the leasing for Elementary uh special programming that could be housed down there so that's exciting we're in the process that I gave the tour um to uh Roseanne at City bosis over the break I also want to give a huge shout out um we had
029a very unfortunate situation at Millard hawk in the art room um where there was a little small fire uh before break a lot of smoke and uh Paul brassette did an amazing job right on the spot putting it out before it really got worse and his crew did a phenomenal job over the break um you don't smell anything the cabinets were replaced we had extra cabinets the everything was painted I went in there over the break and I just went in there again today and uh art classes are resuming and it looks like a a brand new classroom so kudos to our maintenance and our custodial Crews they did really did a wonderful job and really kudos to um Elizabeth um Smith who is here today who um is our interum principal over at M
030what they did and it was amazing because we brought all of the students into the um the um what do you call it there the auditorium and they were showing um Christmas movies and whatnot for the kids we even had um some of our carolers and our performers playing for them the kids didn't want to leave like they were having the time of their life in there which was great I had probably I don't know probably over 15 parents call and just say thank you that was great um we never want a situation like that but the way that you guys handled it so really hats off to Elizabeth Smith that entire staff at Millard Hawk Elementary that we watched make the kids feel really comfortable um in a really unfortunate situation um so really
031hats off to them um again the DECA that was already said and uh yeah that that pretty much mat thank you that wraps up my superintendent report that's A+ Mato on that thank you Tom okay can I get a motion for item H in its entirety I'll second any discussion all those in favor who's who's the first one that made the motion oh christe oh Lori made it and I seconded doesn't yeah yeah and could I get a motion for item I adjournment I'll second or whatever all those in favor