CorpusRecord 60863

ERCSD - Regular Board Meeting 02-11-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / East Ramapo CSD
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Rockland County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,597 words · about 70 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all [Music] EX [Music] the [Music] okay thank you good evening again everyone fire exit fire exits are located at the front of the borderman at the sides of the boardroom in the event of a fire you will hear a fire alarm at that time please move in Cal and orderly fashion to the nearest exit we will now open the meeting with public speaking do I have a motion to open the floor for public speaking so move move by vice president Migel I'll second all in favor say I I anyone oppose obain motion carries speaker number one good evening e Rao good evening good evening good evening this evening I am here I stand so

002proud as a past parent and also as the Director of kids net Child Care Program and we partner with the upk program something blow my mind and I have to bring it to the board meeting of the good things that are still happening at Easter Amo so on February 3rd we welcome the enrollment and registration office to our program where our students were enrolled for kindergarten can you imagine how the parents felt about this move they were eased of the burden to be here in long lines to wait to register their children for kindergarten I want to applaud the board the East Ramapo Central school district and the administration and enrollment um Department I want to say thank you so much and I do hope that it will spread right across the school district make

003it easy for our families and encourage them to keep their children in school another thing I would like to mention is The Chronic absence in our school district we're asking parents families ensure that your children are in school because when they do they will have a solid education thank you thank you speaker number two good evening board members as an adult returning back to school continuing her education get anba in 15 weeks um I've learned a lot and I've learned through collaboration there is communication through Unity there is equality through learning how to evaluate and sum it up to critical thinking you find Solutions within this District but unfortunately those things are not happening okay I'm here to say that we have to do better we must be better and change is coming and it's

004coming slowly thank you Mr Dar Carlo and by the way if none of y'all received my emails about students when without internet I I'll fill you in because I sent it to the board as well Mr darara work with me in helping students get internet because on several occasions where there was remote learning students did not have internet or one or two with issues of computer problems even though you have family University not everybody attends even though you send out recording ings not everybody attends now because there's a large community watching on YouTube this is what I have to say and I need every single board member to understand and listen to me this year when it's time to vote for an increase I do hope it stays at 5.38% people do not understand that

005for the last 10 years the voting has been neglected turned down denied because of selfishness of not wanting to pay into East rample this is the first time we actually have some money even though there was a miscalculation this is the first time we have money whoever's handling the money this time I hope they're more responsible and I hope they're keeping proper bookkeeping tracking the records and everything else as far as the individual mentioning about attendance no offense you're not undocumented no offense you haven't stepped into the shoes of the undocumented you don't face the same fears you don't face being separated from your children you don't face the nightmare that they came to this country for equality and education and Freedom the same that this country was built on by minorities the land was

006stolen from the Indians this isn't our land this isn't your land this land was stolen if we're going to teach history right we're going to teach things right let's do it the correct way let's understand why these kids are absent let's understand the fear that they hear on social media and see in New Jersey and other states of ice going into schools you know what pick up a solution if they're not doing this hello why don't we give them remote why don't we help to educate the child if they're absent why don't we come up with the effort and a solution educators are supposed to educate let's find a solution to do that when you're in educational studies you learn about morals values and you learn that what you were brought up with you bring

007into the school into the classroom to become supportive to help children become self-sufficient to help them become emotionally aware that they can verbalize themselves fully children are scared right now we need to work harder to provide a healthy safe secure environment even especially during this time thank you thank you speaker number [Applause] three hello everyone um before I start my speech I would like to congratulate the Titan wrestling team for demonstrating an amazing talent um also the basketball teams from the Middle School and High School both girls and boys um I'm Amazed by amazing talent you guys left it all on the floor and it's amazing um I would like to say that I want to talk about certain issues that affect our community first I believe that our District budget should be explained in

008a simple form in multiple languages a lot of people in our community have different degrees of education and and we need to make sure it's simple for people to know and also students as they play a big part of our district as a community we have the right to know how our tax dollars are being spent especially because of our increased as a parent myself and alumni I support that increased for multiple years as my daughter explained my little one is that we've been a balloon with water inside and every year every time the budget has been failed it's like popping the balloon and um water coming out now with the increase it's a Band-Aid over one of them on other holes so hopefully you can understand in a more visual way how my seven-year-old

009explained it how she thinks um about the budget also um in regards to the district um showing the budget also include visuals there's a lot of people that understand more VIs visually Than Words again different degrees of Education now also I would like to um discuss the importance of inspiring our students to purs uh pursue higher education as a community we need to instill hope and confidence in our young people especially those who are under representative backgrounds I propose that we invite more colleges universities to visit our high schools and Middle School is never too early to find out or explore um colleges you would like to go it is important to expose our students to various education opportunities And Trades from Young ages also including Elementary bringing someone like a doctor something that you

010know mostly kids go hey I want to be a doctor I want to be a police officer a firefighter bring those from elementary it's amazing seeing them being inspired since they're very little and I bet you those little ones love seeing firefighters and police officers as we really have programs like the Dare program that we can see them but in elementary is a little bit more different um again I want to tell the students um that I am impressed by their amazing talents and I hope to see many more um events during the year and I encourage the board completely the board to participate in going not just are like for example Sabrina or Miss McGill or Eric or the superintendent not only you guys have to go you guys have to share the responsibility

011that you have right now thank you speaker number four hello board members today I want to talk about something that affects us all lunch options we've been all been there waiting in line only to find out that our favorite food is sold out or Worse having to settle for something we don't like but this is isn't just about personal preference for those of us who participate in after school programs and activities lunch is even more important we need fuel to get us through the school day and after hours the problem is the current lunch options are just enough we need more variety more qu quantity and more flexibility what about students have dietary restrictions don't they need deserve more options too I'm not asking for a Gant meals or fancy restaurants I'm just asking for

012a little bit more thought and cons consideration when it comes to our lunch options so let's work together to make our school lunches better let's talk about administrators our cafeteria staff and our parents let's come up with some solutions that work for everyone we deserve better we we deserve lunch options that are more nutritious delicious and plentiful let's make it happen thank you thank you speaker number five Spanish ready okay for for [Applause] fore for for for [Applause] thank you speaker number eight I'm sorry speaker number [Applause] six okay um first thing IID like to speak about I have a daycare and I use I have a daycare in in the in the county here and I use Universal prek last year I had a issue with special ed needs for my children after they

013have early intervention they need special ed needs from the district so I I asked the member last year to help me find some information on getting help for my my my Universal prek child wasn't able to get that last year that's but this is a new year but what's happening is that um you um the special needs the last year that that child I lost that child because I couldn't get special needs for him at the time that was was um it wasn't in time for the the parents they got frustrated and went elsewhere to another daycare the child still I found out from the parent the child still haven't got any special needs now I have this year I have three kids this year that been on top of the parents trying to get

014them the help that they need for their children and um I've been calling the school district special needs Department I've been shuffled around two or three different people to try to get needs for them and it wasn't it wasn't it wasn't a fun thing so I just um I'm at the point where I want to go higher so because I I can't let these children that are coming through this year my prek program slip through the cracks again or else they'll probably get they went from early intervention to not getting any help in prek and they won't probably getting any Services till they get to kindergarten or halfway through kindergarten I can't have that happen on my watch because I I care for my kids and my program and and the kids that come through

015second thing I want to talk about is I don't know if you guys know of but there's a 46,000 ft facility that's going to be parked across the street from Spring Valley High School we have traffic there already traffic is the situation at that school they're trying to build a 46,000 square foot office facility across from Spring Valley High School they've been they pushed the approval through January 6 they had a meeting at this village Village for it and they're still planning it and still trying to build it not only that at Kennedy Drive I know everybody knows that the the land has been I mean the the the K the the um the complex has been brought and they're trying now to put 95 units above uh the 7-Eleven over there sir I hate

016to cut you off can we stick to school related issues we not talking around the school I'm talking about tra we're not the town we're just list I'm going to ask you once to please stick to the thing I'm going to ask you to please stick to school related issues un issues so these two things is going to cause a traffic issue we already have issues with the school the school having traffic around that school we have a police officer that's out there trying to manage the traffic with these two buildings I'm bringing awareness because with these two buildings we don't live in the city we don't have any trains traffic is going to be out outrageous kids are going to get hurt thank you we have problems already with busing kids getting hit buses

017smashing into the people sir thank you sir sir before no I'm I'm not going into that before do not leave I have my assistant superintendent for po pupil Personnel Service she will talk to you and we'll find out what happened okay we're going to try to get what we need to get to you all right thank you thank you that concludes public speaking we will now we will now we will now move on to information and reports from the superintendent superintendent report speaker number [Applause] seven I will be in Spanish please okay so um after so super [Applause] ER [Music] summer camp so Eric think about it please thank you okay and that concludes public speaking we will now move on um I guess the superintendent is not ready yet um so um thank you

018uh president president Rose so I'm honored tonight to celebrate two of our students and you know somebody mentioned this before and you know we've begun to do that we need to do more of that it's celebrate our students right because it's always the it's always the sometimes the the negative things that get put in the paper but we need to celebrate all the positive things that go on so tonight we're going to celebrate two students both from Spring Valley High School we're celebrating a a junior Patricia Lopez and I'll tell you a little bit about Patricia in a second and we're also celebrating Owen pman NOA who's a senior at Spring Valley High School so recently both of these students participated in the Rockland County skills competition um on February 8th so I'm first going

019to bring up Owen panova if Owen would you come up please so Owen Owen is receiving a certificate that States the we certif this certificate is proudly awarded to Owen palmanova in acknowledgement of your outstanding accomplishment at the regional skills competition on February 8th 2025 as he was a gold winner for maintenance Basics [Applause] congratulations so Owen Owen is going to share with the board a little bit about um his winnings and what specifically he had to do congratulations good evening loud voice huh loud voice so we got so basically right in the competition they asked me about um like how to read a a tire and then um they asked me how to identify some tools and how to read a manual like find parts in it it was all it was um five

020minute timer each station and like I had to like Define all of them nice nice go right yeah congratulations Owen our next recipient she is a junior at Spring Valley High School and this is Patricia Lopez Patricia come on [Applause] up Patricia congratulations and let me read you the certificate um the following is is given to Patricia Lopez and recognition of your outstanding accomplishment at the regional skills USA competition on February 8th 201 25 Patricia won the silver winning award for her prepared speech congratulations good job good job and now Patricia's going to tell you a little bit about her speech Patricia good evening um my prepared speech was based on igniting potential which was the topic based on skills USA um the topic was ignite in potential ignite is something that is a fire

021that is unset but is put into motion and then potential is an untp promise within each other but it's something that you would have to figure out on your own and it's a journey good job good job so I want to share with the board and the community this is an example of what happens when you can go and be really um involved with and passionate about going to Bose's programs so both of these students are in our Bose's programs um when I spoke with Owen Owen told me he's looking to go to college and or trade school to continue his studies in mechanics and I think we all can understand how important ios's education is because I don't know about you but if I have to go get my car done if I need

022a plumber if I need an electrician if I need somebody with HVAC they do really really well so it's great and we have to and somebody mentioned this before we have to continue to promote the trades and give our students opportunities to continue with the Bose's program and Patricia this is really important for everybody understand Patricia is going for elementary Ed now here's a great case of what we have to do internally as our students from East ripo go on to college and become teachers we need to welcome them back and become teachers here because they have a passion in their heart to want to serve their community so both of you again Owen and Patricia congratulations we're so proud of you and Owen Owen your parents and Patricia your parents thank you for all

023you did in promoting who they are and what they become thank you very much Mr Dar Carlo I think we all should stand up I mean they deserve a standing vation let's go let's [Applause] go great job much success yeah than you okay thank you um and I again congratulations to both of you so um tonight you're going to see a little introduction and many of you mention about the budget so I just want to express the following um we are working hard you're going to see tonight the uh Revenue projection um with regards to the budget and where we stand um and also come on the 25th you'll hear a little bit about the expenditure side and then come March I'm going to tell you the story behind why we need to have what

024we need to have in our budget um and then we're going to link all the things that we're going to look at that we need to do and explain to you the community the why what's important in the budget and of course most importantly to the board of education so um you know it just feels like yesterday that I introduced myself to you back in July could you believe it or not it's eight months ago go and I just want to express my sincere gratitude to the wonderful support of my team that we've received from you the community and you the Board of Education we we will continue to work hard and present a budget that we think is fiscally responsible and meets the needs of the kids so at East Ramapo we believe in

025the ability of our schools to provide children with a first class education so they can reach their full potential we believe in values that hold our families together working and learning together in in a place where all students public and non-public can grow by participating in our shared values of fairness accountability and respect our vision and Mission are to provide the very best for our students in the current economic and federal climate along with New York State fiscal questions this creates challenges in US constructing a budget that is fiscally responsible for our students as well as our future programs as we move through the budget cycle I would encourage all parties to remain open to listen as we progress through the budget we wish that you can and will attend our meetings visit our district

026website and follow us on social media as the interim superintendent of East Ramapo I am confident that the best days are ahead for our wonderful faculty students and staff thank you okay so now we're going to go to our um our budget priorities um as we go through and I kind of give an overview you can kind of see the budget will include updates on enrollment the use of our Reserve funds the visions of our district moving forward increased cost of items property tax cap our instructional goals our curriculum goals our state resources that we can work with how technology is important to what we do our facilities and our contracts um because that's an important piece that goes into the goals and then I want to make sure that we understand we're going to

027encourage as we look in the budget to reallocate resources to maximize student outcomes to provide the necessary materials and professional development to our faculty in order to improve literacy in our student population you're going to hear a lot of that in March about what we have to do state mandates when it comes to the science of reading uh especially in kindergarten through third grade um we are going to include our salary projections as you know we just finished contract negotiations and we're going to talk about position control and where we're at we have to look at where we are going with our capital projects in the future and how we allocate some money for our our our a fund and then we move to look at our expenditures from the prior years and cutbacks in

028the aend from special ed funds so you'll see special aid funds you'll see that we are trying to go back to Bringing things back into our a fund budget and not having so much of this stuff that's in our uh our um title monies because as you know the federal government now is talking about title monies and possibly doing away with it so we want to make sure we stabilize it in our a fund so without further Ado I turn it over to our assistant superintendent for business Mr Stark will talk about um tonight's uh presentation on the budget and the revenue side uh Mr Spar Stark thank you sir so um I appreciate the comment about visuals um and um the next time that we talk about the revenue side of our budget I

029will um attempt to put a pie chart together that will show you some of the bigger aspects of the revenue budget there are two that are very important that make up uh the largest chunk of the revenue budget and those are our tax levy and the other part of it is the amount of Aid that we receive from New York state so there are two important pieces uh of that Revenue budget that I'm going to spend a little bit of time in detail on tonight and the first is um that since um New York state adopted the uh New York state property tax cap legislation uh 10 or 12 years ago um every District by March 1 has to um put in their uh their maximum allowable tax levy and that is done through a

030calculation that um is currently up on the screen in front of you and I'll go through that step by step so that um hopefully you have a little bit of an understanding as to how that process works um and it's it's listed up here in order so you start with the prior year's tax levy so our tax levy last year was $162,800 182 okay the first step in the calculation for the maximum allowable Levy for the 25 26 school year is to multiply that Levy by the tax-based growth factor the tax-based growth factor is a is a an amount that is set forth by the New York State Office of Real Property Services and it has to do with new construction new bricks and mortar construction within your school district and they create this number

031for every school district in the state and every school district in the state has its own number so what this is saying here is that they have shown a growth of approximately 34 of 1% in the actual brick bricks and mortar um real property in the East Ramapo Central School District so the first thing that we do is we take that um tax uh based growth factor and we multiply it um and then we have before we um come up with that number we have to reduce it by the prior years's pilots pilots are uh that is short for payments in lie of taxes so towns have the ability to make deals with developers and so on and so forth to keep all or portion of their taxes off of the books in exchange for

032an agreed upon um amount um which is uh the pilot and the school district receives that money in place of taxes um so we reduce it by that we also reduce it by the exemptions that are allowed within the the calculation from the prior year what we will do as we move through this is we will then finish the calculation and then add the New Year's um pilots and exemptions back so when we do that we come up with an with an adjusted prior Levy of $161 m1999 32 then we um multiply that by the inflation rate however the inflation rate is capped at 2% so in a year where the inflation rate would be lower than 2% you would only multiply it by that amount anytime that the inflation rate is above 2% um

033you multiply it by 2% so here we add in another 2% and that brings us to m423 930 we add back in the pilots we add um back in the exclusions which have to do with u Capital spending interest on um bonds and notes that the district has to pay during the year and when we put all of that back together we come up with our maximum allow Levy um and that is$ m638 67 which would be an increase over the prior Year's Levy of a little more than $4.8 million um and that percentage increase would be 2.97% anybody any of the board members have any questions about that I know it's a lot I can also give tutorials during the week if you'd like to come in to be clear this is the maximum

034allowed to that we would be allowed to raise before we needed the super majority is that correct that's correct okay that's a great Point that's not the propos you're just explaining what numbers you have to work with right what what what I'm what I'm going over this evening are drafts of everything this is this is a draft as well so one thing that I want to point out to you is we have to file this with the state by March 1st um in some of the work that I've been doing with our assessors um it has become known to me that we have not used the proper numbers for our Pilots um in our calculations for several years at this point and I've been working with um the State Controllers Office as to how to

035properly address that in our current year so we will make them correct um we're working on those numbers with the assessors right now we will correct them um so this is again a draft as are all the other things that I'll be showing you this this evening and as we continue to meet I will give you updates as to how those have uh shaken out I should be um I should actually be able to to have this completed by the end of this week um so at at our work session I'll I'll give you an updated version of this as well as the other things that I'm be showing you tonight okay so that's the first step and that has to do with the tax levy which again is um when you see the overall

036Revenue budget uh a large chunk um of the budget it's close to 50% as is our state aid the next piece um as I said the other big piece of our Revenue budget comes from state aid that is provided by the state of New York excuse me um every year in January we receive a an aid run that is set forth by the executive Department's uh the governor's office um which then has to go through um the legislature and then as we move through this budget process we will receive a final Aid run that is approved by the legislature but the starting point every year is the executive run so when we begin to have conversations about our budget we look at the executive proposal um in order to uh make an estimate as to

037what we will have in terms of Aid in our Revenue budget what you have in front of you now is um the executive proposals from January of 24 and the executive proposal from January of 25 so you will see here that um the district was uh treated very well in terms of um Foundation Aid uh we are showing an increase of 95.8 million to 109 .2 million a 13.4 million um dollar increase which um on a percentage basis is a 14% increase to a so this is why if you remember two months ago I spoke to everybody about the importance of foundation Aid and lobbying And discussing it so finally the state up until this year they were basing poverty rates for East Ramapo on the 2,000 census right so one of the reason reasons

038why you see this number as high as it is is because they actually updated it to a couple of years ago which was more reflective of actually what our community is is so that's why when I said two two months ago how important foundation Aid now you'll see that that the governor went back and said okay we got to get this updated and we we benefited tremendously for it but remember what I told you it's 25 years after the fact but listen half a loaf is better than no loaf so it's a really good start so I just wanted to let the community know that that's where that money is finally we're getting the monies we should be getting so thank you for letting me clarify that Mr Stark absolutely is the 9 is the

03995 what we got or this was in the her proposal because her original proposal was opposed by the legislator so this is what the executive branch releases and it's what you're what you're saying is a good point because when they put out their um year-to-year comparison they don't necessarily compare it to what the executive proposal was last year they compare it to the legislative proposal so it's really a combination of of items but this is what they this this will match if you look up our our Aid run on the State website this is what you'll see so we did get 95 last year from State a that was that was what the proposal was you actually get paid your Aid based on your actual student count each year so we we'll be able to

040provide you with that information I don't have it with me tonight but I'll be a I know that she proposed last year she also she last year she also proposed to change increase to take away money from decreasing school districts and putting into increasing school districts but she didn't get it the legislative voted it down so I'm not so that's called the save the hold harmless excuse me or safe harmless and um yes there has been uh um some arguing amongst the different um legislators throughout the state about whether or not that should happen obviously legislators legislators that are from districts that um receive Aid based upon older numbers don't want their districts to be hurt by having it taken away um and then obviously legislators from districts like ours are pushing to have that

041money go to the to the right place so that's really the political hot button um and I leave that to the public politicians so I was seeing the but we have a very very good um Aid proposal uh in front of us for the current year so far as you move down um a foundation Aid um there are there are actually two different types of Aid that we receive Foundation Aid is called a formula based Aid and that means that there are formulas that are created in order to uh determine how much each School District gets it looks at the population it looks at population uh student population growth it looks at poverty it looks at um lots of different economic aspects of a school district um and those go into those those um formula

042based AIDS as we move down this page you see that the the rest of the AIDS are for the most part called expense driven AIDS so we receive dollars back based on expenditures that we have made in various different C categories so for example in bosis our Bose Aid has gone down by almost $300,000 but that's because we spent less money in the prior year with bosis so if you're spending Less on expense driven AIDS they will go down similarly high cost Aid um we have a much higher number because we've had uh more high cost um special education students that we have stacked and uh requested the refunds on so when you see those numbers going up that means that you have um reported more expenses uh for those different categories when you file

043the st3 which is the way that we file our information with the state um so moving on down the page when you look at all of it uh together we are looking at an increase of almost $17 million in Aid which uh is an 11.9 uh% increase 11.09% increase excuse me um just a quick question for for bosis um my question is just for clarification purposes so that doesn't affect the amount of students that can um go to Bose's correct no no it does not affect the number of students that can go to B bosis so the the proposal for aid for the 2526 school year is based upon what we have reported for the 23 324 school year so there's a 2-year lag in that in in the way that the eight is is

044um paid so every year after the um audit report comes out we file our financial statements with the state for the end of the prior school year so that would have been the 2324 school year and then the state uses all of those numbers to calculate the aid not for the current year because that was calculated last year this is for the 25 26 school year so there's a two-year lag but it it's based on our actual expenses two years ago so if we spend more in the current year we'll see that number go back up if we spend less on bosis this year then then that number will go down again if I understand correct that's bosis is what we get back for what we used that doesn't really affect the budget it's only

045one it only one thing that we won't the way the government works is if you didn't use money that you that you had you have to give it back and you cannot ask next year for more so this is what it shouldn't be affecting much on our budget what we're going to get or not get well it's it's going it it is going to affect it based on your usage because it's based on the expenses but it's not going to have an effect on how we budget our expenditures I that's that's what I'm trying to bring out it's not something that's going to be an line item on the budget how much we the reason why we didn't get more because we didn't use it probably we weren't able to provide stuff that they were

046offering so this is why we weren't able to use it or we didn't need it right it it so the the number of students that we have going to different programs at Bose's can change from year to year we could have a a large number of special ed education students that are in their programs that maybe are going to a private placement in the following year or maybe they graduated and aged out and are and our younger students coming in we didn't have as many filling those spots or in um the with the uh general education population with um the um occupational education um it it all depends on how many students we have in each of those programs on On Any Given year sometimes we have more sometimes we have less so um our

047overall usage went down two years ago again that number does tend to to fluctuate and have uh some waves in it based upon uh what's going on and uh you know this in this particular year it went down because we spent less any other questions on that okay so moving on um the next piece will be the first draft of a revenue budget and in it I've used the the the larger numbers that we have given to us these are not uh I'm not presenting to you a budget that we're asking anybody to adopt um it's the revenue side we're not even talking about expenditures but since the tax cap came into play um the revenue budget actually drives the expenditure budget which was not the case before the tax cap legislation uh was put

048in place before that in fact the the public voted on the expenditure budget and most Boards of Education wouldn't even um calculate their tax levy and look at their revenue budget until the summer um but now because your expenditure budget can't exceed a certain amount based on your tax levy we have to look at the revenue budget first and it C it becomes the first step in putting your expenditure budget together because you have to know what the limits are and where you cannot exceed so um first draft of our Revenue budget um it shows um various different categories um other things that have been happening as we have been going through um prior years um budget and uh reports and then looking at the budgets the actual we've uh noticed that there have been

049certain parts of the revenue budget as well as the expenditure budget which you'll see in in the coming weeks where um the budgeting wasn't done um in in quite the way that I would have liked it to have been done but now you'll see it the way that I like to be done which which I hope is accurate um it's not always going to be perfectly accurate but I think that what you will find hopefully is that when uh you receive the budgets uh both revenue and expenditure from me that they will uh be uh based on numbers that will be close to what we will actually achieve okay so with the property tax again in this calculation I have used the maximum allowable tax levy that's not to say that that is what is

050going to be eventually um proposed to the board by the superintendent but that's uh for the purposes of showing showing how this would work um that's what it is uh after that you have the pilots which are the second piece of the taxes um and again as I mentioned earlier there's the asterisk there that $252,600 that has been used um in each of the past three or four budget cycles that number is a higher number um and I am working on exactly what that number will be I believe I will have it for you all by the next meeting so that number will go up a little bit um New York state aid the number that you see there the 167 million uh matches uh what was on the the prior slide um and then

051we have all of the the smaller pieces so uh again the next time that we meet I will make a pie chart of this for for those that do like to look at things uh in a more visual way what you'll notice is that you will have two really big pieces of pie and then a bunch of other little slivers um and um these other amounts all uh when you add them all up they don't come close to be being um the value of either the tax levy or the state aid uh component of our budget but the one thing that it is important to point out when you look at this um if you look at last year's budget the T the state aid was about $11 million less than our tax levy but

052because of the increase that we received Aid um currently we're looking at 167 million and change in both taxes and in state aid so we have uh we are definitely benefiting from a nice increase in state aid uh from the state's um initial projection uh moving forward um interest income there was no interest income actually put into the revenue budget last year um I'm adding in 3.25 million Dollar in interest income uh which is earned uh on the on the money that we have in the bank throughout the year um tuitions are uh it's Revenue that we bring in for selling additional seats that may be available in some of our classes that is something that may have um existed in a in a in a large manner uh in the past there was 1.9

053million um budgeted for that we actually will not earn uh anywhere near that this year so I'm not sure where that number came from or how how long it's been rolled over for but um we will only be budgeting $100,000 for that rental income um we're moving that from 180,000 up to 250,000 um we have worked on the facilities use policy in policy committee and it's been adopted by the board so we have increased the fees now to cover the costs uh that we have uh for our custodial and maintenance uh staff when we are uh rting out property and um you see a slight increase there again these are all just very small parts uh reimbursements um has been done fairly well we you um we see it was about 250 prior it's at

054225 now um refunds are um refunds that we get from various entities that we do business with one of the bigger ones each year is at the end of uh each uh fiscal year we receive um a refund from bosis based on um their budget because they collect everything based on estimates so at the end of their year they they're actually required to give all of their component school districts back um a portion of the of what they have collected they can't keep they don't keep a fund balance like we do so they have to give it back to all the school districts so we get we get a nice piece there each year that amounts to $1.3 million um we get Medicaid reimbursements um the amount that is closer to what we are actually

055achieving currently is about $400,000 so I've reduced that um by that amount um other income um was also in at 1.5 million um I'm trying to put things into proper categories as opposed to just lumping things into other income so I'm only going to have $200,000 there and interfund transfers are transfers that we receive dollars from some of our other um funds such as the special Aid fund cafeteria fund um uh right now what we've been using is um there is something called The Debt Service fund and Debt Service fund has in it money that was earned by interest when you were doing a capital project and you then are allowed to put that in a reserve and then use it to pay off the bonds that you uh have to pay off so we

056have budgeted the same amount you generally try and do that in equal portions over a number of years so that it doesn't create a big hole um after uh you've you've used all of it up so there's that same $ 53,55 there um and last year there was an appropriation of our fund balance of $19 million which um was at the time more than half of the fund balance which is very um not not a very prudent way to use your fund balance in this initial draft and I wanted everyone to see that that with the increases that we have in the other areas um without taking anything out of our fund balance um we would still see an increase of approximately $3 million overall in the budget so again this is just a draft

057this is not a proposal on any particular item um but it's the first draft um and it shows you that um we definitely uh are benefiting from a very nice run on state aid from uh from the governor's office so Mr Stark just real quick um I saw the other income how it it was a decrease right of like 86% for which one the other income yes can you give an example of what type of you know what would fall under that category in terms of what type of income so it um things that would fall into other income uh would be categories that aren't on here generally have smaller amounts and I'm I'm not looking to talk about what other people did in the past I'm just trying to move forward but um the

058$1.5 million I I don't think you should ever see a number that high in other income you should be trying to put it into the proper categories but something that's not on here for example would be donations okay so uh donations that are being made either by PTO ptas um individuals so on and so forth that would be something that would fall into other income and again on unless we know that you know Mr Gates is strolling into town with a million dollar check for us then we might we might uh put that in actually if that were going to happen we'd probably make we'd probably make it a category of its own so um but that that's an example I was reading in the I just got the man of the school board the

059association paper they were talking about that the governor announced that there's going to be a five 6% increase in state aid like how's that is that going to affect us Foundation a from from that govern H yeah I mean I hadn't seen that just based on the more than what was proposed in the governor's proposal I'll be honest I didn't read through the whole article it was I saw the headline so I'm just wondering if if you was that I just saw it today uh okay that the governor announc I don't know if it's send me the link I'll read it I I got a actually a paper copy but hey if we get more from the legislature um that'd be great AB one question one comment question on the Medicaid is it because we

060are not providing service that many case pays to us or we are lacking in Billing properly so we um thank you it's a good question I'm I'm not sure of where the 800,000 number came from what I know is what we have actually collected over the past three years that is an average of what we've collected we do use a third-party group to help us file for the Medicaid dollar so um is it possible that we're missing out on some I guess it is but we are using a firm that that provides a service that knows exactly we look did we look into it to see if that's an issue yeah certainly will okay now again um as if I understood right about the foundation it is it's not that we are getting more money

061we just counted more kids in our district is that correct it's It's a combination of of uh of population but our population growth from year toe if we if we go back you see the foundation a increase by 14% we have not increased our population by 14% so part of it's the formula as our superintendent mentioned there have been changes to the some of the the calculations in terms of poverty that have changed in terms of of our District's population so it's a combination of things that have happened and do you have could you and and also just another factor is that the district has been coding our L students the wrong way for example they had had us down for 5,000 students when it was over 7200 we correct that and that also has

062a big factor in state is that is that something that we did wrong or that the state we did not you you are we did that was us the information that was put put in was not coded um properly and and Katherine Morales is not here but her and Bin and Bin's team has worked on it so that it is indicative of what truly the amount of our L Learners are is it possible to get somewhat I understand this is a big number there's a few factors is it possible to get more direct which factor and how much the amount of money just I'm curious to know because as the superintendent mentioned that part of what we are getting is because we were getting money for for 2000 for 2000 not for 2025 so I'm

063just curious what amount of money alany held back from us because of that back form if could if we could divide it somewhere we can I mean Eric and I can look at it it probably be very hard to to determine that um the the calculations if you were ever to look at them and I would tell you not to do that unless you wanted a migraine um they are really really complex and I'll dare say convoluted um so I would tell you that I would not be able to actually get granular with you on that we'd probably have to ask somebody from state aid to come down and do that um but that would certainly put you all to sleep it's a substantial amount of money it's a substantial amount of money because it's

064it's been 20 years years that was one of the points that we were always saying that we're being short changed from Aly any other questions thank you you're welcome um next just a quick reminder about kindergarten registration has begun on the 21st as you heard you know we are going out and and helping parents into the community to register just remember all upk students must register for kindergarten and it gives you some information it's on our websites online so just uh remember we have started that process next up so this is really important and and you've mentioned this and it's sometimes a struggle regardless of what happens with the budget we are running summer programs okay we're not going to wait till May or June and decide we have to get out there we got

065to get teachers to come and be a part of you know teaching the program we got to get administrators to oversee it and we want to let you parents know that we're running it so you will start to see probably um middle part of March you're going to be getting Flyers home we're going to be offering High School Credit Recovery credit attainment um in our high schools and in our middle schools and elementaries we're going to be offering a variety of different thematic um days and and programs whether it's Sports um whether it's uh computer science robotics Fine Arts and Performing Arts so not only will it be you know we'll be teaching and and and work working on our work with literacy and math but we'll also be providing students with some of these

066areas that they may like in our creative Inn so I just wanted to share that with the district no matter what we're going to be running our programs this summer I know last year the last second they were uh you know we thought we were going to run them and we couldn't but this year we are I just want to let the public know that next now we go to um Dr Carlo I don't think it was a money issue last year either was a building issue more than a money issue wasn't something that we didn't provide because we didn't have because construction right I'm sorry I meant to say we didn't realize it till later on though that we couldn't run it thank you for clarifying that next we go to our elementary education

067um department and Miss Ellen andriello our executive director of of uh I think this is wrong it should be primary education but that's why I do read she's going to give you a little bit of an overview of some of the work that we are are doing in the area of Elementary Ed so uh Miss andriel over to you thank you good evening president Rose vice president Mill and trustees Mr Dar Carlo fellow executive cabinet members ercsd community members my name is Ellen andriello and I am the proud executive director of Elementary education here in the curriculum and instruction department at the district offices this is my 10th year here at East Ramapo Central School District I started out as an Ela coach then I was a proud principal of Elwood Elementary for six years

068um shout out to Elmwood and Elmwood uh in that role we took Elmwood from a school in need of improvement to good standing so before I begin this presentation before I begin this presentation um if you indulge me there's a quick video here I wanted you to take a look at um I want you to know that before we get into the details of the presentation it's um we have some fantastic administrators and teachers across the district they are very committed to educating the whole child to help them feel safe supported engaged and Challenge and challenged we are all committed to becoming proficient and above in all that we do you got it I learned we all need a pep talk [Music] I think we all need pet talk I think we all need pet

069talk you we need you now I'm not trying to sound needy but I'm just saying we need you we need every voice Little Voices shaky voices any voice looking to spread love we need the young we need the people who might have forgotten what it's like to be young we need the hopeful we need the Hopeless the usual and the unusual because we can't handle any more business as usual we post a video on the internet grab WR a pep talk well because you need a pep talk and I know what it's like to need a pep talk so I delivered it we put it online and realized lots of other people need a pep talk teachers parents kids Beyonce people who aren't Beyonce more people that I even knew existed there are people all

070around you who need reminding to laugh to dance we can remind each other of all the reasons there are to dance and there's lots of reasons to Dance I mean if you're looking for them so look for them because your dad's moves they're needed even if they're awkward especially if they're awkward your joy it's needed we are little reminders to each other to stay unusual whether you're Michael Jordan and you were in Space Jam or if you're just somebody who's watched Space Jam a lot guilty you are needed there are people around you who need reminding and you you can let them know we can help each other roll on when we can't do things on our own if this journey is toss anything it's toss that the little words C out big love that

071can go a long way so here's the love here's the throw in parades for each other parties that cheer each other on wise friends to light the way we need reminders that amazing things can happen because they do all the time and one of them is you we can brighten up every room we enter every place we go the entire world but only if we take care of each other together we're Unstoppable so we got to stop stopping each other from being Unstoppable that made sense right what I'm trying to say is that we got too much goodness to be spread pep talks are nice but they're not a one time thing we all need them again from time to time cuz people grow days pass times change challenges come and we all need little

072reminders that we're here reminders why we're here the most amazing thing is the fact that we're here together right now one chapter may be ending but there's a whole big story that we're telling together so we'll keep pep talking and we hope you will too sometimes it'll be seen sometimes it won't but it always matters believe me I know because Love Love Changes Everything so let's fill the world with it thank you for that so again it is very important just to know that we take care of the students social emotional as well as the standards in the curriculum so New York State Standards what is my child learning for ELA and math the standards focus on in these focus on in these subjects are based on the Next Generation learning standards for science we

073follow the New York State P through2 science learning standards which align to the Next Generation science standards also for social studies we follow the New York State social studies framework with an inquiry based approach which is focused focuses on historical understanding geography economics and Civics and also there's also phys physical education we focus on skill development physical fit fitness health and wellness and social emotional learning through physical activity also for the Arts most important focus on developing developing students creative technical skills and appreciation for the Arts across the disciplines in visual art and also in music here at East Ramapo down at the bottom is a link to New York state has a standards and instructional website and I wanted to just show the community that if they were to on this website for New

074York State education department it's filled with a wealth of knowledge of what is my child learning on in each grade for ELA for science for social studies for the Arts for physical education and I have some handouts here that I'll leave at the table as you know you go and it's at a glance so you can see if your child is in third grade what are they learning for ELA what are they learning for math and it's a real userfriendly manual for you so I thought that was helpful as well so New York state literacy initiative as Mr Dar Carlo was speaking this is a big effort put by New York state it aims to enhance reading proficiency among students from prek through grade three which is the primary grades which is the foundation for

075their success in the elementary years and and so on H by they Implement evidence-based instructional practices and the key components of these are instructional best practices is curriculum alignment professional development and the superintendent uh this coming September first of 25 has to make an attestation which where superintendant are required to sign an attestation confirming that their District's reading curriculum and instructional practices for prek through three they align with New York State education department instructional best practices so all of these measures measures are designed to ensure that early literacy instruction in New York state is grounded in scientifically scientifically validated methods thereby improving reading outcomes for Young Learners very important standards versus curriculum the New York State learning standards are not really a curriculum it guides the curriculum so New York State education department does not

076require recommend or endorse or advise a certain curriculum they leave that up to the local levels with teachers students parents we all come together the districts and schools choose Andor develop curricula the materials the instruction to meet the individual needs of all of the students and to support students in gaining the skills and knowledge articulated in the New York State learning standards but there's a lot of guidance on the websites so curriculum is the scope and sequence of learning experiences Tau in a course or grade level to provide students with opportunities to achieve Knowledge and Skills as defined by applicable learning standards usually it's divided into units or lessons curriculum includes an outline of the scope of the content the concepts and the skills to be taught the sequence in which they are to be

077taught the amount of time allocated for the content and the materials and assessments to be used throughout the instruction in New York state curriculum is developed and adopted locally and must be aligned with the applicable State learning standards so curriculum materials are the educational resources that we use to support the instruction in the classroom they include but are not limited to they're textbooks multimedia content online resources workbooks teacher manuals and lesson plans there's a lot of curriculum guidance from New York state which provides information to assist teachers schools and District to develop refine and enhance local standards based curriculum instruction and learning experiences these can include tools used with local curriculum to evaluate its Effectiveness suggested activities or instructional practices that enhance the teaching and learning and Curriculum maps or guides for curriculum development or

078selection so just to reiterate um our curriculum assistant superintendent Dr Gonzalez had this in his presentation back in October we have to remember that curriculum is not just a program it's not simply a program because while a program might Encompass a broader set of educational offerings a curriculum refers to the specific planned content learning objectives and instructional methods used within a program detailing exactly what students will learn and how they will be taught going Beyond just the overall structure of a course or program currently for English language arts our core programs for K through3 are wonders through mcra Hill and elel education which is grades 4 through eight and we have intervention programs to help fill the gaps to bring students up to grade level it's Lexia Core 5 K through 5 power up 6

079through 12 and Lexia English K through 12 and the students have a onetoone device where they can go on to the platform and they can work with these with these programs for mathematics for kindergarten we have go maath through hmh which is hooton Mifflin hardcourt and Eureka math squared for grades 1 through eight and the intervention we use is First in Math students go on that in their academic intervention periods and for science and social studies we have a um a program that we use through hooton Mifflin hardcourt which is into science K through 8 and we have a partnership with pnw bosies for social studies which is a social studies Ela curriculum it's a cross-curriculum K through 8 and we can't forget the specials the Arts we use Spotlight in music for our K

080through 8 General music and Davis art for K through 8 for visual art physical education K through ART and that goes through the high schools to they use a curriculum called spark and all of the teachers adapt that to our students that they have in front of them for technology we have K through6 learning.com and in grades five and six they start to use a program called code where they bring it into the middle schools and they start to acquire credits for their technology uh requirements so what does the data say this data chart was also shown back in October from 20 3 to 24 what our New York State scores were and yes we have some work to do but if you look across but then if you look at a cohort from 23

081to 24 if you look at our Ela grade three in 23 they were at 12% proficiency but as fourth graders in 2024 they went up to 17.20 yes we have a lot of room for improvement but we are seeing a lot of um growth with the cohorts going from grade to grade and in math we saw a big uptick well an uptick from 23 to 24 from 1633 to 18.54% proficiency we have again some work to do but we see in the data that we're looking at some really highlights that are coming through for us uh this is just to point out the second report card is in its way to be uh being developed uh the end of the marking period for elementary K through six was last Friday February 7th teachers have already

082started putting in grades and all of that those report card materials will be available and ready to go out to parents and families for the March 7th parent teacher conference so we are halfway through we have one more progress report and the last report card in June so we are progressing pretty quickly through this year again just to remind us on our instructional Focus here for East Ramapo the East Ramapo Central School District believes in learning that is personalized driven by inquiry focuses on reading for understanding and writing with Clarity instruction across all grades kindergarten through 12th we will include it will include engagement strategy scaffolding questions discourse meaning conversations and progress monitoring monitoring how the students are doing through all of the curriculum based measures our instruction focus and smart goals align with the

083district's theory of action by enhancing instructional delivery and addressing opportunity gaps ultimately improving outcomes for all students and fostering a culture of success again I wanted to remind everybody that we have a great uh teaching and learning uh website that we put together it's called curriculum connect we have three episodes so far we go into the school buildings we take a look at the teaching and the learning that is going on we talk with teachers we talk with students and these curriculum connect Corners we call them uh are great for the community and the board to see all the work the great work that's going on in the school buildings upcoming important dates we have our New York State Ela and Math and Science c um it's computer-based testing we are computer-based 3 through 8

084uh we have the dates April is a very busy month for these dates uh we split it up by grades 378 456 uh there's two days for the ELA two days for the math one day for science also Nic slat speaking there's a window that the schools administer the test and then also NCIS lad has three days in a row in May to do the the Reading Writing and listening we have a large we have a great amount of um students that are enls and we give this test to in all of the buildings K through 12 so thank you very much I hope that answers a lot of your questions if there's any questions please and I will put the handouts over by the table so when you leave you can take that thank

085you alen oh the handouts oh yeah thank you next up yeah I think Kathy right are we're going to go to let's let's first do the consent and agenda and action items and then we'll do that is that okay okay moving on to consent and agenda items do I have a motion for consent and agenda items one through motion mve by Mr Weiss man have a second say second by Mr Young mer all those any discussion here no further discussion all those in favor say I I andone oppos obstain motion carries moving on to action items 1 through 14 do I have action items one through 14 do I have a motion motion by Miguel motion move by vice president Miguel do I have a second second by Mr C we'll open it up for

086discussion hearing no further discussion all those in favor say I I anyone oppose obstain motion carries we will now move on to information and reports from the board Kathy before we move on to the board member updates Kathy and our attorney have some goe all right so the first oh okay let me adjust s aable over here yeah we had a lot of talk about the budget recent meetings and that's a a leadup to the budget vote itself which is in May on uh May 20th and voter registration forms are at the table handout table every board meeting so if you need to register and need a form you can get it there or you can download it from the County Board of Elections site on our uh website um there's a link for running

087for Board of Education as a trustee what that means what the requirements are and what the responsibilities are and as of today our website uh We've upload uploaded the candidate petitions and the statement of expenditure forms that candidates have to fill out this year as most years there are three wards that will be up for a vote this is a ward two which is uh uh Miss char Charles Pierre Ward six Mr guber and ward nine Mr Weis mandal so um those are the three that are in rotation up for voting on this year and uh the website we have um you can see on the screen what they call a friendly URL so if you go to ercsd.org budget vote2 we can get links to all the different pieces of information that you need

088okay okay um let's talk about sorry just quick quick question um for the voter registration forms um I know when I was in high school we had days where um if you were going to be of age to to vote uh we had forms available for students to um fill out I know we've been told in the past that it is being done I'm not sure how accurate that is in the two high in our both of our high schools but um can we look into that to make sure that it is being done where our students are um able to uh fill out the forms for voter registration so what that's a great question I actually asked that question and I am told and we'll codify it that the county does come in to

089both high schools to register students um County Board of Elections County Board of Elections does yeah but we we will get to you what those dates are so that we and they know we have an understanding that they are actually going to come in to do that it's a great point they normally make those arrangements directly with each high school but we can certainly reach out to them yeah and I don't know if it's possible maybe just to get an idea of what that number looks like um you know how many students will be of age to and how many actually fills out the form thank you thank you okay and let's talk about the as we heard before our dedicated colleague and board member Mr Young merer submitted to us his um resignation letter

090um we're just can Douglas or Kathy perhaps Douglas can fill us in on our next steps how to how we're going to be proceeding sure So based on the timing of the letter um the board is well back up one step the board is required to take some action to fill that vacancy within 90 days that 90 days would be um the day of the actual annual vote so the probably the most democratic and most prudent course of action would be for the board to announce that vacancy allow people to submit their interest to run and then just run and get voted in for and and get voted in on the day of the annual vote whomever is voted in then serves the remainder of Eric's term so that's probably the the most efficient and

091effective way to do it as opposed you know as opposed to like appointing someone who would only serve until May so we would have in addition at Mr Young's Ward there would be another there be another candidate to fill out the remained two years I think it is two more years right yeah I so we okay right so we would just we would have a a a vote for trustee in Ward one in addition to the three trust come through through through the rotation and it's more um Douglas talked about more efficient from the process but also more efficient from a cost perspective doesn't increase our cost to and from the voter's perspective it's more democratic than having someone be appointed for a short period of time so right okay so I guess that's what

092we're going to do unless we have any opposition Mr Young was a pleasure having you over here keep on being an activist um okay moving on to board member updates or do we have any Kathy am I missing something sorry I I'm not sure if any board members have a committee report to give oh okay think the vice president Mill has yeah um unfortunately I wasn't able to um give this report at the last board meeting um in regards to the athletic and U Wellness committee which was um presid was uh Mr Dar Carlo our state monitor far myself uh Mr feder as well as Mr Russo and I'm just going to touch on um information that was talked about we discussed um partnership with Rockland both for sports information and increase student athlete um

093Expo exposure uh we discuss uniforms maintaining inventory and making sure that we have you know all sizes for all students so that they all look the same and they all feel a part of the the team we discussed the budgeting what should be under title money and grant money and what should be operational um I know there was a long dis discussion um that there was a deficit for extended period of time with Athletics as well as extracurricular activities in general as per uh Mr far not enough resources to catch up in one year general fund dollars you need to put to this not title money title money more instructional base we need a plan to build it back and we want to be able to have a a new like they mentioned like the

094weit room and the dance room for our um athletes so that was some of the stuff that we discussed in terms of the budget budgeting um number four was assigning an East rampo Central School District security officer to accompany student teams a away to a away games you know we we've had issues incidents um for example at the Spring Valley boys basketball game as well as last year with an incident with the girls basketball team so uh we felt like and and Mr feder even mentioned that as well that it's imperative to have at least if we could have at least two security guards to escort teams when they're going for their um going to their away games so that too um was mentioned as well I'm trying to talk as fast as I can

095um in terms of winter Athletics we we talked about uh Mr Russo talked about how there's been struggles and successes um which is great we talked about how um as per Russo the numbers at the modified level was down we're struggling with numbers with the JV both sides um I also so I remember this about us talking about the girls not having a varsity team and how they were disappointed um we even talked about the importance and and which I mentioned to them I know Mr Russo mentioned about um reinforcing like we're having students fill out progress reports and I like I told him it's a matter of coaches as well as you know making sure the players are doing their weekly progress reports in regards to um making sure that they're keeping up with

096their grades because not only is sports important but their academics is important as well and then we discussed um the community basketball day was going to be February 8th at ripo however um I know that I did get the pleasure of being there um for for a short period of time but that the games took place at Spring Valley High School um we then discussed about the section one realignment for next year um and the fact that we are a big school and that there's going to be a different um League um realignment when it comes to the boys and girls basketball and soccer team um all big schools grouped together it's going to be us out of you know our two high schools North Rockland suffron John J east east uh Fishkill Arlington and

097Ketchum all in in our league um because of beds you know the beds number so we did discuss okay this might bring some problems in terms of right Mr Dar Carlo Transportation right because of the timing I don't know if you're aware sometimes when you go to those track meets which I am a track official down at the Armory you're there for hours so we talked about that being a huge concern for for our student athletes and I know we'll we'll re we'll come back to that again and talk about it again and then um something else that was mentioned was the end of season Board of Education report and I think that's imperative that you know our AD should at the end of each season at least share a report of how things went

098you know and so on and so forth so all of those things we discussed during the Athletics and wellness uh committee meeting which I am so glad that I was able to take part in and um one last thing and I think this is important I mentioned this during the meeting that you know us as board members you know it's hard for us to get to every you know um but I think it's imperative and I mentioned it that we all we need to get that information whether it be academic sports but we were talking more about sports because it was Athletics but I think um that all board members should be given that information the schedule when it comes to various sport programs whether it's at Pomona Chestnut Ridge um Ramapo Spring Valley and

099I do want to say this after having this meeting um I did get the information I believe you shared it with the board from um oh my God yeah um what's her name no I knowel angelene she did make sure that there's a weekly athletic schedule that's sent to the board members so that at least we're aware so that we can have the opportunity to support them all right I think that was that very but thank you no you're welcome and just another note because this was also discussed um as we move forward and we're looking at vars City coaches we are going to be establishing a committee made up of students parents and athletes it just happens to be that this season in um uh for the spring season everybody's coming back so but

100in the future when we have those openings um we're going to make sure that we go through that process which I think is important moving forward so thank you very much yes thank you Mr Dar Carlo you know what just one last thing that Community basketball day I want to give you know remember that um Mr Russo stated how um it promotes um like you know um teamwork or whatever but I do think that it's necessary for us to say and mention that you know we need to thank John boyin remember the Ramapo head coach he mentioned that for putting the Community Day basketball together thank so I do want to mention that thank you and uh just a quick um overview of our Dei committee uh meeting that we had um it was myself

101Mr Dar Carlo Mr Young Mercer Miss Beverly Jones and Miss Anna Rosco who was present um and this is a committee that we've been trying to get off the ground for I want to say almost 3 four years now where we would start um to try to build a structure of foundation but due to change of leadership uh we've never seen it through so I would like to thank Mr Carlo for you know putting a team together uh having a committee where we can actually start having the conversation ation to what this committee is going to um be uh so we spoke about creating a structure where we will ensure diverse representation um establishing clear objectives for fostering inclusivity and regular regularly assessing progress towards the EI goals um we will be looking at nisba

102and the other districts um our local districts to see what policies they have in place so that we could bring that to our policy committee and to our board so it can be implemented um we also discuss having more job fairs and promoting different Pathways where we can partner with colleges and uh today's students tomorrow as teachers to fill our teaching position so it's a it's a work in progress um we're still you know trying to outline what this committee is going to look like and um you know we look forward to just hopefully having a successful committee where we can actually seear through this year yeah thank you and you will see in the budget when we talk at restorative practices in our buildings our secondaries you'll see some of that as a part

103of what we need to do moving forward so I thank I thank you and the the group that got together because it's important work as we move forward all right and um Mrs uh kivy this is also information from the board this is that part because I see it was moved from the um normally it said like towards the end are you am I correct the superintendent search no I'm talking about where we are because right now we're we're um dealing with um we're at the part where it's board member updates right we went back to the beginning because I S over the board the board reports so we need to finish those so the unless any other board members have a report we need to then go to an update on the superintendent search

104okay that's fine okay let's go there y anybody else yeah uh uh Dr Karen deino is here for uh uh mcferson and Jacobson the cons search Consultants that the board hired and she'll make a presentation to you and also to the community because we want the community to know um the timeline and what's planned okay is that the clicker thank you okay thank you so much for having me um like Kathy indicated my name is Dr dinino I am one of the search consultants for mcferson and Jacobson um we have been retained by um your District to work with you in finding the next superintendent of schools um so I am here to assist the East Ramapo Central School District I'm going to keep my remarks brief um and do just a few slides to

105try to give you a brief overview of the process that we will engage in probably the most important thing what I'll be talking the most about um you'll see five phases of the mcferson and Jacobson search um probably on the monitors in front of you but the things that I want to call out that I think are the most important not only for the board members um but also for the community um is that we rely very heavily on stakeholder input as well as board members input right it's very important that the board members and the members of the community find the right fit for the next superintendent of schools here in East ripo um one of the things that I think mcferson and Jacobson does well and I think it's probably one of the

106reasons we were selected to work with your District is that we do um a lot of work with your community stakeholders we work with the board to identify Community stakeholders so for example you may be choosing members of your cabinet you may be choosing members of the community you may be choosing leaders of different religious organizations in your community in the surrounding areas you may be choosing business owners parent Association members that's really up to you to determine who the stakeholders are our job is to meet with those stakeholders ERS and ask really important questions the same ones that we're going to ask you which are things like what are the characteristics that you'd like to see in your next superintendent um what are the needs of the district what are the issues that the

107district faces so that we can get a really large um Gathering of data and put that together so that we can present that then back to the board so you'll hear from myself and some other co uh Consultants giving you information from the stakeholders we also speak to to students if that's your desire we think that that's very very important um at mcferson Jacobson as well as teachers any constituents that you identify as important stakeholders you want to hear their voice we will speak to all of those groups gather the information and bring that back um in a report to you uh one of the other things um that is really important I think for us to share and I think I probably have it on the next slide but like I said I want

108to keep this brief is that we do surveys as well uh The Sur surveys um would be distributed in English Spanish Yiddish and Haitian Creole if there are other requests for other languages we will accommodate that as well we recognize the diversity of your district and want to make sure that we don't leave anyone out we believe in transparency in the search and trying to help you find uh the best fit for your um for the leader in your District we also um conduct um some pretty significant um reference checks and background checks as part of the process uh in that you know whenever anybody has gone for a job interview they always give the reference of somebody who's going to say something wonderful about them right I mean that's why we list a reference

109so um not only do we speak to those references and ask questions but we ask the references to give additional references and ask further questions one of the primary concerns for mcferson and Jacobson as we report to the board is that we don't ever want um any candidate that we bring forward to you or that we ask you to consider to have any kind of bias or controversial historical problems in their work history or their personal history we know that when you hire a superintendent of schools that reflects on you as trustee members and on the community right so as a consultant firm it's really important to us that we do a very deep dive in trying to find out the background of the people that that we are hoping to bring to you as

110um potential people that you would be interviewing um and just a couple of other key points um obviously we we go through Gathering data and doing some research and providing things for you um but then of course we meet with the board uh we'll be meeting uh later on this evening to work on a few things and really devising uh what our um what our advertisement looks like and the qualifications um as well as the timeline um but once we um gather the um applic s they're reviewed and they are provided for you to review as well so you have the opportunity to review all of the applicants um we go through the process we also utilize um a video approach as well so if you get to a point where you want to have

111a second look at certain candidates we ask them to um provide a video you create the questions they do some Q&A you get to view those videos and then you get to bring in your finalists and the board of course gets the opportunity to interview any candidates that they wish to see as candidates for superintendent of schools here in East Ramapo um and I know in New York uh we have the commissioner of course has to approve I think as well of the final decision and uh your monitors are part of this process too so it's quite a lot of people to be involved in the search but it's the most important thing that you do I think as trustee members and for your community um you have wonderful children and families who look to

112you for leadership and we really hope to be your partners in that regard and we um we look forward to working with you on uh getting this process started um Dr Ralph Ferry is one of the other Consultants um and um Dr Barbara pinac so you'll see one of the three of us with you through the whole process one of the other things we'll talk about I think later on is um establishing stakeholder days when I would probably come here and spend a couple of days in East Ramapo um with the stakeholders group groups that you name for me and I will be sitting and conducting interviews with another consultant who will take notes and that will begin that stakeholder process um so and I will um like I said I wanted to keep things

113brief for you you know it's really important to look at a diverse stakeholder groups I think you want to get the most transparent look at the needs of your community um we will utilize live sessions as well as some Zoom sessions to move some time forward uh for example um Dr Ferry my colleague will probably work with trustee members in doing individual Zoom sessions to gather feedback from you so that you all have say and characteristics and things that you feel are important in your next superintendent of schools um like I said we'll be providing uh surveys in multiple languages to make sure that we solicit feedback from all of community stakeholders and at times you'll notice that the process kind of overlaps each other because the goal is to have a superintendent not only

114selected by you but also approved and ready to go for July 1st of 2025 and we feel that we can do that uh We've started the process and of course being with you here this evening we'll talk a little bit more about that in um executive session um but at this time um if I can answer any public questions or um maybe general questions I'm more than happy to try to do so and if you'd like me to put up the the five-phase slide back to get a closer look at it I can be a little bit more specific but I know that you've all been sitting for some time listening to some really important stuff Happening Here in the district anybody any questions okay hearing none thank you so much thank you vice president

115yes and I'll just Madame vice president just make a comment that um by Thursday morning we'll have a friendly URL web page set up for for uh information on the superintendent search and that will be uh uh ercsd.org superintendent search 25 so by Thursday morning at the latest we'll have that information up thank you m uh trusty guber if we could explain the public that it's not that we want a new superintendent we are very happy with the current one it's just regulations of waivers or something Douglas would you Vice to explain that I'm sorry I didn't hear the question it's not a question it's more of a comment to address the public the reason why we are looking for a new superintendent that it's not that we are not happy with the current superintendent

116just why we're doing a search is that the comment um well you speak this is this is in an awkward situation but I I will be honest with the public and with you the board so um I'm able to serve in this capacity currently because of the state waiver right I'm not ashamed to tell you I'm under the age of 65 and the state of New York if you retire between 55 and 65 normally you can only make a certain amount of money it's $35,000 but as a result of covid the state came to learn that many districts were struggling with getting administrators so the last number of years they've done the waiver but but the problem is they haven't blanketed it meaning it's going to go on you know x four five years they

117do it from year to year and the problem is they don't come to a decision until May so that's not fair to the district um that you know well you know are they going to have the waiver can Mr to Carlo stay can he stay so you you have to go out and look for a superintendent it's not anything other than the fact that this is the rules of the game that the state of New York has to work with and deal with I have to tell you I've been very humbled tonight by the conversations and the thoughts of the public it is very humbling um um I am humbled by the opinions and things that have been said by the public and and the board but it's just the reality of of what is

118happening right now with regards to my situation and where I'm at um and the Board needs to be able to move forward and look for that position you can't go by or what if or what not cuz then you could be back in the same situation and that's just not fair to the community and not it's not fair to the to the board of education but I can assure you that you know I think you've come to learn who I am I'm going to work as hard just as I did July 1st as I will on on June 30th um and I and I think the community will speak to what their thoughts and needs are with the firm in the superintendent I'm sure you as a board will also do that same thing and

119as it was mentioned this is one of the most important roles that you take on is is looking for somebody um who's going to make a commitment here over time because that's really important of the stability so um you ask the question and that's the honest answer that the public is getting and everybody else is getting so that's uh that's part and parcel of the what's happening thank you Mr Dar Carlo you're welcome all right we're going to continue so I'm sorry I just want to just one make one recommendation um as we as we um as a board speak with the search firm about you know who we would like to who we would like the search firm to interview and uh talk with I think it would be important to if we have

120um our current interim Superintendent at the table uh just to so he can share his uh you know views ideas and so that we can um you know make sure we have someone that is aware and that we know that this is a critical position and we can't just have anyone so to to hear from the current interm superintendent I think would be very important as well okay yeah right we wouldn't we wouldn't do the we wouldn't conduct the search without consulting with him uh it's C and thank you for asking the question and pointing it out we want to do everything we can to work with East Ramapo to make sure that you have the best possible leader and his insight and experience in The District in the last you know know eight or

121nine months is really crucial so we would definitely include that input for sure great thank you so much okay future meeting dates a regular meeting is scheduled for Tuesday March 4th 2025 beginning at 7:30 p.m. in the plcc room in the administration building at 105 South Madison Avenue Spring Valley New York written uh Communications since the last board meeting the board received a revised resignation letter from trustee Eric Young Mercer with the resignation date of February 23rd 2025 anticipated executive meeting uh Miss kie I'll just uh step back for a moment we are having a budget work session meeting on Tuesday February 25th so it's not a regular meeting there's no regular business no public speaking but it is a pretty important work session It's the final on the budget before it goes to the

122monitors I believe and then um changing topics back to Executive session uh to discuss matters regarding the possible appointment of particular persons and to receive advice from Council on a part possible litigation but we do not expect action following we might oh never mind is there a motion to enter into executive session motion by Mr cof is there a second second by Effie all in favor any oppos so carries e e e adour this meeting motion made by trustee wise mandal second by truste cof all in favor any opposed have a good night everyone e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.