CorpusRecord 60864

ERCSD - Regular Board Meeting 01-21-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / East Ramapo CSD
Date
2025-01-22
Location
Rockland County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,843 words · about 44 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e yeah yeah want to please stand for the pledge and then national anthem thank you pled aliance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all [Music] a [Music] I'll make a motion to open public speaking second by Mr Young can you read the uh fire notice the red sheet first fire exits are located at the front of the boardroom and at the sides of the boardroom and the end of a fire you will hear a fire alarm at that time please move in a calm orderly fashion to the exit thank you speaker number one we do need a motion for public speaking you made a motion you did you did I didn't

002hear it hello isan English yes okay uh I am here very concerned about what's happening with our community about uh new legislation is going to be about Donald Trump and how it's going to affect our community if the immigration can come to our district to get uh kids or get a parents who is in there so in this point uh we have to understand our community have lot immigrant parents who doesn't have any kind of documents so we I would like to know what the steps the district is going to take for protect our kids in our schools that's one thing and and we are very concerned about our neighbors too and we are very sad we are suffering we having very uh hard days uh about this and another point I was just concern

003how the district is working to improve the grades of the schools if how we're going to know in one point is going to be Implement to improve in this point because our district is very very bad and we have the report uh so that's my concern thank you today is very sad day for most yes so if you don't mind chairman grber just to speak to it only because it was brought up so um I sent out a memo today to all the buildings okay everything goes through me the superintendent so if anybody would show up P HMO ice or anybody else they ought to direct them to my office okay so we are not going to have any questions about what happens Who's involved who's saying it it sits in my office so anybody

004comes into any of our buildings looking for or having any issues or questions with any of our students they'll to be directed to office at which point in time actually myself and our attorney um you know Mr Gard are been working together so nobody will be able to come into our buildings and remove any student whatsoever it's really it's important for you to understand that okay there's a lot of speculation there's a lot of things that are out there being said that can and will happen um it can't happen in our schools nobody has a right to come in and remove any of our kids now on the outside of school that's a another question with regards to your local authorities right your town supervisors you know your town um County Executive what is the

005county and what are the towns doing if this were to happen when somebody comes to your home and says something because you're right that's problematic right what we don't want to see happen is you not being advised as to what the next step should be with regards if somebody should come to your home but from a students point of view we're going to protect our students here yes because I I don't think so I think is um that teachers have to be training how to um try to explain to the kids because many kids are talking about it in the school and I think that is like a mess it up you know with a her with the kids's mind about the that problem so maybe the kids need some kind of orientation too about

006the migration things is happening now that's great yeah we will miss then um our assistant superintendent for curriculum instruction is is here with us tonight and it is something I know we have been working with and are sharing with our students to put them at ease because I think one of the biggest fears is that somebody's going to come in to the building and take them um and that's not going to happen thank you very you're welcome thank you thank you speaker number two um good evening hello I'm a school um hello School hello school board members and Community I'm a freshman at rampo high school I'm speaking today about a few issues that affect me and my peers first I believe our district should publicly recognize student athletes achievements more not just football and

007basketball but all sports this will boost our moral and pride in representing our school and and District I suggest showcasing our achievements on the school district website and social media Pages second our soccer field needs renovation it's uneven Rocky and difficult to play on proper lighting will also be a huge Improvement this will not only benefit our school but also Inspire young Generations personally personally I've been fortunate enough to participate in an international soccer tournament in November I was recruited to play in to play in Guatemala and in April I'll be traveling to Spain to comp compete in a prestigious um soccer tournament in Madrid and Barcelona my team tsf academy and I will be competing against teams like Real Madrid Barcelona Manchester United Liverpool espanol and Atletico Madrid and many other more I'm grateful

008to my father and stepmom for supporting me in these opportunities and I hope my peers will have similar experience in the future furthermore the cafeteria food has been the same since kindergarten and it's horrible many students including me often Go the whole school day without eating because of it lastly I would like to request that the district invite more colleges to talk to us starting from n9th grade especially those with athletic programs this will help us make in this will help us make informed decisions about our future about our future I'm not just speaking for myself I'm speaking for the students in our district we deserve better thank you so thank you very much you can stay right there I don't know if you heard but um I did announce this in January but I'll

009announce it again we actually have now um a PR person just to deal with Athletics okay her name is Emily Neri and she has begun to go around doing exactly what you're saying taking photos doing profiles what I will make sure after you were just told me a little bit about what you're doing and what's happening outside of school I'm sure she would love to do something with you but yes clearly um that's something that I spoke about with Mr Russo with Mr Stark we're only the second district to do that so North Rockland put a PR person in for athletics a couple of years ago we put it in this year for two days a week of course we want to do more um but yes we should be showcasing our athletes um as

010you know back in the fall we actually celebrated um the JV program at Ramapo soccer right for their accomplishment so please do not think that we don't care that we're not interested we want to promote we want to make sure the community and outside the community knows about what our student athletes are doing very much so and as far as the food goes myself and Mr stalk are looking at that we're looking at what the quality of food that we have and we may be looking to do some things down the road um regards to some um some changes so um I just wanted to share with you a little bit about what your concerns are we hear them and we are like I said we did something about it with Athletics um and we're

011looking to uh enhance it even more in the future so thank you for sharing thank you so much sir you're welcome thank you speaker number three hello good evening I come here today as a student I'm asking you for to use your power to protect us for far too long our communities have been treated unfairly as a student of color I've seen how racism and discrimination hurt people our country is taking away important protections for Education public schools and students like me it's not fair that Stu that kids like me are being targeted just because of our color of our skin our status or the family of our our family I'm asking to please use your power to help us we need a safe place to learn and grow we need to talk openly about

012the problems we face and the fears we have please don't let us down protect our families our futures and our education we all deserve to be treated with the respect and kindness I also urge the superintendent to create a group from kids from all the district to help us with the food options we deserve human foods like other districts thank you have a good day thank you thank you speaker number four good evening everyone so thank you for addressing what um the First mom was speaking because that's also a topic that I wanted to touch tonight but I would like for you guys to do a public announcement on the stance that our district takes please um until now the district has protected the rights of the students without sharing immigration status which I am

013very fortunate that you guys are doing that that is great um another thing to continue um maintaining information of family and students confidential and refrain from sharing to other authorities um again to refuse to coordinate with immigration and custom enforcement um only share Student Records in in rare cases and only with the full understanding and consent of a the parents um also to not let this ice Agents from accessing school grounds school buildings and also to make sure when if they're here in this building that the community that's in here during the daytime feels safe um because at the moment that they see that vest that says i c they go into an a frantic mode I'm a child to both undocumented parents and I remember the fear that I faced and still have the

014PTSD over it so I can't imagine what the kids are going through if there can be the psychologists psychiatrist that are on site in the schools if they can speak or have teachers flag those students that look off because my little one said that recess kids are literally discussing I hope my parents are home when I get there and the next morning when they get there yeah Mommy and Daddy were home so I don't want them to continue crossing fingers and toes hopefully hoping that their parents are home and It's upsetting because I went through that um we need to be a safeguard for our kids and then I want to address the students that are watching because I know students that watch this the message to you students every single one of you are

015so smart and Powerful no one can defy you no one can defy who you will be you are worth everything there's a quote from a TV series that has been stuck in my brain since I saw this it says where is the future it's right here in the students of East rampo and who life is this it's yours and what are you going to do with it live it by any means necessary you are the strength don't give up and like the kids say prove every hater wrong you will be a success story and show everyone that you have the brain and the strength that goes beyond these walls and whoever tries to detain you and your greatness show them wrong thank you thank you speaker number [Applause] five good evening everybody thank you for

016giving me the opportunity to address you excuse me I'm here today to speak about the budget you should be you probably are formulating uh the budget for the coming year so you should take into account that the monitor last year went way and above what the voters voted for the voters voted for a 1% increase in the budget and the monitor added on a 4.38% increase that's above and beyond what the voters voted for so he took away our right to vote and came up with his own figures he the reason that he gave was he projected a $20 million deficit for the district so we have to make that up so we felt even though the voters only approved 1% he's adding on another 4.38% after a while the district called in other organizations

017to uh verify that number and they came up Not only was there not a 20% decrease there was a projected increase or there was an increase of $31 million that's more than some total school budget for the year with a $31 million increase then we would that what he said was said under false pretenses he wanted the people to pay more so he came up with a false figure uh that's it's a $50 million difference $50 million is no small money instead of a 20 million loss there's a $31 million increase so number one what I'm asking is is this uh 4.38 increase will be once it's in the budget it stays there every single year so we did not only pay 4.38 we were paying that to Infinity what I request of the board

018is they should number one for this coming budget which they're presently formulating they should take off the 4.38 and even the 1% which the voters voted for under false pretenses should be taken off because there was no 20% decrease no 20 M the $20 million decrease there was a $31 million increase so I'm asking the school board to make sure the next budget decreases the by 5.38% so we shouldn't have been lied to and deceived uh there is enough money to carry on all the programs and everything else that the board would like like without fooling the voters and making sure that they do get the decrease their money back for what they paid under false pretenses thank you thank you this concludes public speaking we'll now go to the superintendent report thank you truste

019guber um couple of things which are important as you are well aware a week ago this past Saturday um there was an incident that took place at um RC Ketchum high school I'm sorry come you need no what did I say I said to him oh I'm sorry he's the same last name as you I'm sorry I said trusty grber no you didn't call you I'm sorry yes finished thank you I apologize if I said something wrong um so as you aware last Saturday um at our Varsity BAS ball game up at Spring Valley High School um there was an incident with taunting while one of our players was at the um the foul line I just want to share with the public that um and if you read the report um actually section one

020um was very compliment in the manner in which we handled it um I I do and I'm clearly aware the year before there was an issue between um Us East Ramapo and Scarsdale and there were a lot of um ill feelings about the way that was handled and what was done just so that you understand literally within 2 hours all the powers that be in section one the superintendent of schools up at wers myself this board of education were notified of the issue a subsequent investigation continued on the next day on Monday when everybody got back to school uh up in wers they ascertained the individual that did it um they are to the full extent of their code of conduct and Dasa um will be doing what needs to be done with this individual

021when it comes to discipline please understand we will never know what that discipline is we're not allowed or they're not allowed to share what happened but I can tell you that in my conversation with the superintendent um Mr bunk up at Wappingers that he will be following through on his policy and what needs to be done I want to thank our student athletes our our Varsity Boys Basketball team from Spring Valley High School for the way that they handled it in such a classy manner that Monday afternoon um I was there we spoke about it um with the coach and they're they're moving on um it's terrible it's hateful it's disrespectful it's something that should not happen um we address this all the time with our student athletes with our students but this is something

022that we're learning from I know that wenes is learning about it um and if we can you know we're looking to create um maybe a community circle with their student athletes and our athletes um and we're hoping that they're amenable to it but I I just wanted to share that with the district I wanted to thank Mr carton for his work on doing the investigation um as well as Mr Russo uh and all those who were involved so I thank you for the manner in which that was handled second and I really want to stress about the chain of command a lot of times the public comes up to the the uh the speaker or or to the mic and talks about issues that are going on in the building please if there's an issue

023that is happening or going on in your building go through if it's an issue in a classroom speak to the teacher if there's an issue in the building speak with the principal if you are not getting satisfaction from that if it's an issue with facilities you can call up Mr Tindle or you can call up our assistant and super superintendent um Mr Stark and if you're not getting you feel any gratification from that ultimately you can call me up things happen in buildings every single day and we I Mr Dar Carlo meaning I I don't sit at my computer from the time I get in to the time I'm out I'm busy I'm doing work I'm around buildings I'm trying to put a budget together we have to follow that chain of command and what's

024happening is people are snapping pictures be uh uh of something that may be happening in the building and we have to have the time to ascertain what the issue is if it's an issue with the pipe or it's an issue with heating Mr Tindle works with that building custodian and he will send out let's just say pemp for example the plumber the plumber will report back to Mr Tindle yes I can fix it we may have to shut this you know bathroom down I can do it within an hour or two if for some reason that the plum or any person there says I can't do this uh you know without shutting down the building or whatever then we would have to look at doing an early dismissal drill nobody no superintendent wants to do

025an early dismissal drill because guess what nobody's home kids are on their own that's when tragedies happen and you have to understand something for us to do an early dismissal it takes MOS about 3 hours by the time we call the bus company up the bus drivers come back the buses get here so if we have to do it we'll do it we work with the Board of Health we work with OSHA calling up the commissioner of Education over an issue that we should take care of is not appropriate it is not and I understand prior to myself getting here there was a lot of anger there was a lot of upset sment things weren't addressed I get that I'm here now you need to respect me in my role as a superintendent of schools

026you have to allow me to handle things yes I do understand at the beginning of the year we learned right there was an issue with the heat in one of the buildings and we had to move the students we should have done a better job notifying you to let you know but on other things that these things happen it's a part of what happens in schools all the time so please respect the chain of command and things when they go on it would be greatly greatly appreciated I thank you very very much now we're going to go on to our um update on our budget um Mr stalk our assistant superintendent for business we'll give you a little bit of an overview I know today the governor actually spelled out what she would like to

027see in the budget as you are clearly aware now the legislators the Senators and the assembly um assembly people get to look at it they get to make their thoughts and then there's a negotiation back and forth so Mr Stark will'll give you an update of where we are right now and then um I'll make a recommendation from there and then we'll turn it over to our special education assistant superintendent Mr Stark okay thank you very much so I'm going to be doing two different things I'm going to be first giving a quick update on where we are in terms of the budget um creation process for the 25 26 school year and then um I am going to give some reports on where we stand in the current year budget okay so is that

028better just wasn't close enough okay it was on um so in terms of the uh creation of the budget um we have now received enough of the factors that are a part of making up the maximum allowable tax levy um which is a calculation that's set forth by um the New York State Controllers Office in terms of the New York state property tax cap that was put in place many years ago um when we put those uh factors in the first draft that we still have to verify pilots and some other things with um our tax assessors but the first draft um shows a maximum allowable tax levy for the the next school year at 167 mil 23534 that would represent an increase of 4,428 732 uh or a 2.72% increase okay um the uh

029well I I wrote this before this afternoon so the New York State uh executive department state aid projections are released they were released this afternoon we have we will be reviewing those tomorrow uh and we'll be able to provide the board with an update as to uh what the aid projections for the East Ramapo school district are for the uh coming school year um those are the two major factors uh when we look at the revenue budget so um now that we have those we're going to be able to put together the total revenue budget in the past before the tax cap uh existed um school districts basically um did did their uh expenditure budgets and that drove the revenue budgets but now with the tax cap um law in place it's the actually the

030revenue budget that drives the expenditure budget so now that we have those factors in place we'll be able to look at uh where we will need to keep our expenditure budget using various um variables in terms of uh where we uh think that we would be uh asking for the tax levy to be at um in terms of filling in all the uh expenditures in the expenditure budget we are in the midst of finalizing and reviewing uh salary projections for all of our employees uh for the 25 26 school year um that is obviously a very important piece of our budget as uh it makes up uh a very large percentage of the budget we basically are a service provider so we are paying for salaries and benefits um so that is the the largest

031piece in terms of um getting our budget filled out and we are working as a team with uh both the central administrative team that is here and the superintendent as well as our building administrators um the principles and assistant principles at all of our schools um a presentation uh of the draft revenue and expenditure budgets uh will be given um at our next meeting or the following meeting um which is something that we'll be discussing in a moment um so yeah I I think that's a great opportunity so this is to the board um and it's just a thought but I highly recommend it as you are seeing um in the presentation and subsequent slide um we truly are going to need an extra meeting in February because there's a lot of of budget stuff

032that we have to look at so um I would be asking and and maybe Kathy can pull the board to look at the possibility of um another meeting on February 25th that's a Tuesday night that's the week after our break um there's just so much to do and other information to glean and get um I know we have one board meeting schedule but I think it would behoove us to do an additional meeting on the 25th just strictly budget right um all the stuff that I would normally do I would do it the 11th but if possible the 25th and we're not looking for an answer right now but I I want you to expect you know that Kathy would may send something out to see if that's viable and if not the 25th but

033maybe another time that week but you know we have to and the monitors are here we have to give a uh a draft this state a part of the plan by March 1st so it's really important that we try to to the best of our ability have a conversation with you around it so I just put it out there yeah another thing that we could do and um just a another possibility if you didn't want to do a full regular board meeting we could just have a work session on the budget where you didn't have to do the if there if there wasn't going toine as to as long as it's open to the public yes that's fine yeah as long as it's open to the public that's fine so we have some we have

034some you know we have some options and we will explore that with Kathy and she can send it out to the board thank you board back to you Eric right so now um coming back to um the current year budget um we have here a breakdown of our expenditures for the 2425 school year that we are currently in the midst of um and along with that I've given a 2-year um look back on all of these expenditures and they fall into um a number of categories that are in the order of the uh School accounting that's set forth by New York state so you have uh Board of Education section Central Administration uh the finance group central office staff Central Services um special items which include um insurance and some other things um building administrators

035teaching which is the as you can see is the largest part of our budget um instructional media pupil Services which is um in is the area that has special education school psychology social workers so on and so forth um guidance um and then moving on we have transportation services garage building Transportation uh other transportation services which are uh inter Scholastics and um field trips and things like that Community Services um another large one is employee benefits which uh is is what correlates to um our salaries and then Debt Service and interfund transfers so I'm not going to go through all the numbers but I I have some comments that I want to make about them you can go you can look back and forth and and and um review this and feel free to send

036me any questions if you have them or ask feel free to ask them now um the expenditure report Eric about the tax levy last year I think it was 1 150 something million why is 167 only 4 million more um it wasn't because of the increase with the increase it ended up I think at 159 no no with the the with the increase it's um I I'm not sure that I have that right here without opening something else up but oh we can get it in uh board dos hold on give me one second please that was August August 14th for um yeah so the the adjusted tax levy after the um additional 4.38% was added was 162 milon okay so if if you if you want to see that it's the it's the attachment

037um on um the August 14th 24 meeting um and if you go into the set School tax rate which was item f for that meeting attachment D would show that to you in detail and if you click on that and open it up and scroll down to the second page it gives you the uh net amount to be raised by the tax levy okay you're welcome I the glasses off again okay so um going back to the expenditure report for this year um currently the expenditure report includes all amounts in the general fund that have been expensed or encumbered and that what that means is they have been they've had purchase orders or accounts payables set up for them in our financial system there are a number of items right now that have not been

038done in terms of that so when you look at the current numbers on there it may seem well they actually show as as as the projected shows as being lower we will be working to correct all of those for the January hopefully the January but perhaps the um February um update to these reports because I'll be giving you these monthly so uh certainly by the end of February you will have um a projection that should be um as accurate as we can give it to you in terms of what our full year expenditures will be so included in the December report are the Retro payments that were made as a result of the teachers contract extension but what is not yet in there is the increases to their salaries in the current year okay we

039are currently working on those and getting them set for um they're going to be receiving the the back pay to the beginning of this school year um in if everything goes to plan in the first payroll of February um so once we have that done we can get those numbers into the uh system and project them properly which right now those are not in the projections um another issue or another item that is not in the projections right now is our remaining Debt Service payments of $3.8 million we will be encumbering those for the January report and then we also um have a number of employee benefits that um need to also be um encumbered for the year um and those will be included in the January report so again uh hopefully by the end

040of January we'll have uh a more accurate number uh it will be very accurate and um should be a good should give us a good idea as to where we will end the year um by the time we have that February report any questions about that I keep moving away from the mic nope okay Revenue once again um what you have here is uh two years of excuse me history um so you can see um we have really three major categories when we talk about Revenue we have our taxes we have the state aid that's provided by the state of New York and then we have our other revenues which include a number of items one of largest that winds up being in the revenue budget each year is um interest that's earned on our

041money that is is in the bank so um you see here um the different um pieces of the revenue we've gone from 275 million in 2223 up to 299 million in 23 24 and we are looking at um for the current year uh number uh of approximately 323 uh5 million the revenue report includes actual Revenue earned to date as well as projected revenues for the remainder of the year in the following areas uh real property taxes as we've already mentioned as well as um the state aid we do not get paid either the real estate taxes or uh our state Aid all at once so that's paid through the year but we have projections um as to um what we will collect on all of those and then uh We've projected out the interest income

042um for the year as well there are a number of other areas that are smaller in there such as tuitions um and a few other minor items so we will also work to um get projections for those items through the end of the year and update those uh in January as well any questions about the revenue side okay so finally we have our cash flow analysis uh this too um you've got a lot of numbers here you probably will not be able to see them if you're in the audience um if you have it up on your computer you can zoom in and out if you uh so desire this is in two different pieces so cash flow is looking at cash in and cash out the first page that I have up on the

043screen right now is the cash in that's the total receipts um and the actuals are um in this cash flow through December so everything that you see from July through December in this area or or on this spreadsheet are actuals and then January through June are the projected estimates for what we will bring in and receipts in all of these different areas so it's property taxes state aid health insurance contributions so on and so forth down the down the page the next half of this we had to split it up because the numbers on the numbers on the bottom do they present funds that we have away because it seems it's much more than the budget at the end I'm sorry say that the number on the bottom it's see the 495 or 562 the

044total that's a lot more than the budget is that Reserve or something so that that is so that is a projection for where we will be based on all of our total receipts added to what cash we had to start the year when we go to the next page which has our dispersements it's going to pull from there right so it will show you that um if I if back up it's showing you that when we add all of our receipts into the beginning balance for the year we'd be at 562 million currently we are showing 455 million going out which would leave a balance of 107 million of course that as I just started to describe is not the full picture yet um because we are constantly modifying this and I have some notes

045here about um how that uh is is currently there and how it will change okay so could you maybe explain if the budget was 300 and something million how are we do we need to disperse 455 where's the other 150 million great question so the cash flow analysis is not just the general fund the cash flow analysis is also all of the federal funds that we receive all the grants and we we receive a substantial amount um and in fact some of those grants are are going um are being dispersed out to the to the non-public schools as well so it's all of the funds that come into the district all of the funds that go out to all of the various sources so um so this is not only budget money this is everything

046that goes through the entire District yes correct so the out all the construction all of this is included in these numbers that's correct so if you if if we go back to um the earlier slide if if you look down at the on the on the um receipts the last two items are arpa capital and ARA other so those are those are funds that we received from the federal government and there are other you know you have um school school lunch fund has several items in there so this is all of the different um funds that we have in the school district not just the general fund okay so this project that in the end of the year we will have on hand Even after spending everything we'll still have 100 million over $100 million

047again that's what it's showing right now but there are still things that are not part of the projection that also as I talked about with the with the dispersements I'm sorry with the expenditure report and the revenue report we're modifying everything this is the first blush as we are presenting it to you and it will be find as we move through the months um and know and have a better idea as to what's coming in and what's going out the federal revenue was not included in the revenue report I'm sorry say that again the federal revenue is not included in the revenue report of. million the first two areas that I discussed the the expenditures and the revenue those were just the a fund those were just the general fund okay the cash flow analysis

048brings into consideration all of the different funds in the district that make sense so total of 562 million is com is the total expenditure of the the revenue of the receipts of the of the year so the it's the number before that if you go back 495 it's the four it's the 495 right the four 562 is taking into consideration the opening balance the opening cash balance okay so um again the this cash flow analysis that you've been presented today is as of December 31st 2024 which means that the actual receipts and dispersements through December 31st 2024 are there um the remainder of the year at this point are estimates that we continue to refine as we move forward okay um it includes the Retro payments that were made to the teacher staff and just

049as I explained when I was talking about just the expenditure uh budget in terms of the a fund um it does not yet include the um salary increases and Associated employee benefits from the changes to the salaries that we are putting into the system and and uh paying out in February so as we see this in January and February will you will see a more refined um look at uh what our cash position will be moving forward okay um the current dispersement projections include salaries and employee benefits from all current employees annualized but it also does not include um budgeted amounts for vacancies so we do have a number of positions that are a part of our budget um and we we have not put into the uh projection that those will be filled and

050expensed at this time as we move through the year and hire people that will change there are no other questions I believe that's it for me thank you Mr Stark just before I turn it over to our assant superintendent for PPS Services Miss Marone I I just want to acknowledge the uh assistant superintendent Mr Gandhi Mr Shanahan Miss Morales Miss Marcone um Dr Gonzalez Mr rusco and Mr Stark they have spent many many hours cleaning up data that was not reported correctly to the state and by cleaning up the data we are hoping to see some of that reflective in some of the monies we get from the state um and I I want to thank them for their hard work over the last number of weeks a number of months doing that um been

051a lot of information and stuff sent up that was not complete um that sometimes was an error and it has impacts on how the state gives us money here at East Ramapo so I want to thank all of you for your hard work and dedication so M Marone I will turn it over to you for our [Applause] PPS thank you can you hear me no better okay thank you superintendent Dar Carlo and good evening Board of Education so just a little up dat on the Office of Pupil Personnel Services I oh thank you good F out louder have to project your voice we're in a big room it's hard for me that's much better must mayle that's much better I'm going to stay right here so I just want to uh take a moment to

052acknowledge our leadership team who's here with us this evening we have Tamara Truax who's our executive director of special education we have Tina Marie Woods who's our CSC cpsc coord coordinator we also have Ashley Coffey who's our CSC cpsc coordinator new to the team congratulations we have Dr Jennifer coio who's our director of special education nonpublic beatric Munoz who's our assistant director of special education and Stephanie Ayala who's our assistant director of special education so just want to acknowledge similarly all the hard work that they've put into for this school year as well yes yes yes yes um just a little bit about our department and who the providers are in which we supervise so we have special education teachers School psychologists speech and language providers occupational therapists physical therapists Vision teacher teacher of the

053deaf and hearing impaired board certified Behavior analysts social workers clerical and office staff that help us keep everything running teaching assistance and teaching AIDS and assist technology Specialists also just a little bit about what is special education it refers to a range of services that can be provided in different ways and in different settings there is no one-size fits-all approach to special education it's really tailored to meet the individual needs of students special education is not a place it is a service and the districts are obligated to provide a free and appropriate public education to students with disabilities a student with a disability must have a disability that prevents them from benefiting from their education in order to be eligible for special education services those services are described and tailored in an individualized education program

054otherwise known as an IEP that is designed to meet the needs of the students individual needs so students who need support do not belong to special education all students belong to all of us and within the regulatory framework that we work we have part 100 in which we're required um expectations for all students to meet part 200 regulations help us to support students with disabilities with programs and services in order to access and participate in the general education curriculum and similarly part 154 supports our English language Learners and multilingual Learners as well our Continuum of services here at East Ramapo consists of a variety of related services along with resource room integrated co- teing and special class for students with disabilities it is always the obligation of the committee on special education to recommend the

055least restrictive environment for students with disabilities so for the 4 25 school year we have been hard at work and the department is currently in progress of updating our committee on special education for preschool and school age procedures we are working to develop and distribute clear accessible procedures in alignment with the regulations for all stakeholders including staff families and community members around the preschool and the school age initial referral process as well as the non-public public school age referral process the new entrant intake process and the re-evaluation process the department is also going to engage in a consultation process with the non-public schools to discuss child find provision of special education services the use of federal funds Health and Welfare Services and special Transportation parent requests for special education services must be received in writing

056by June 1 for the preceding school year that the requests for services are being made the only exception to that rule is if a student is newly classified or newly enters the district and then the written requests must be submitted within 30 days of that date the department has also provided a lot of professional development for this school year including special education law for school administrators IEP csse cpsc meeting protocols and best practices functional Behavior assessments and behavior intervention plans progress monitoring risk and threat assessment New York State Next Generation standards and dynamic learning Maps alignment for students who take the New York State alternate assessment adverse childhood experiences testing accommodations and the department is working to establish a multi-tier system of support integrated District leadership team currently the district has a partnership with the

057multi-tiered system of support integrated Center out of Sunni Albany just a little bit about what mcsi is and what it is not it provides a structure for districts to prioritize the needs of the whole child including social emotional behavioral and academic growth while ensuring culturally responsive sustaining environments for students it is not just a curriculum or a program or just a process for struggling students nor is it synonymous with academic intervention services or merely implemented by just creating some forms or set of steps for procedures what districts generally strive in a multi-tiered system of support is to have 80% of their students at or above grade level responding to core instru instruction and tier one supports 10 to 15% of students that would need targeted tier 2 interventions and about 5% of students that would

058require intensive supports at tier three we want to just take a moment to acknowledge the impact that covid has had on schools locally nationally and internationally for both academics and social emotional well-being for students Dr Gonzalez came to us in the fall with a sense of urgency and purpose to improve our literacy scores across the district and so the work of the mcss district leadership team will be how to respond to an upside down triangle given that we have 80% of our students that are functioning below grade level our work on the mtsi team will also be grounded in the theory of action that Dr Gonzalez was shared in the fall that if the district provides targeted support to schools direct professional development focusing on community and family engagement then each school's capacity for improving

059instructional delivery would close opportunity and learning gaps and we would expect to see students and staff engaged in their own learning leading to improved outcomes for students it would also focus on the districtwide instructional Focus for reading for understanding and writing with Clarity and so as we close out this evening just a look ahead for the Department we will continue to team and plan with the curriculum and instruction and multilingual education department to prepare for supporting literacy needs we'll continue collaboration with District administrators and staff to best support the literacy Continuum to articulate our core instruction and tier one supports provide professional devel velopment and support the mtss initiative we'll also continue to refine our preschool and school age procedures as well as review and evaluate our Continuum of learning for special education thank you

060very much thank you Mr Marone great job thank you and to you to you and your staff all the work that you are doing ask a question sure um you said that um special education Transportation has a Cod of date of June 1st April one is transport transportation is special education trans special the June 1st date June the date that you gave for June 1st June 1st is for requesting iesp services so that is for a student who has an IEP I think in the education law there's no deadline for requesting transportation for IEPs the deadline for transportation is April 1 for for everything not for for IEPs is's no deadline that's number one number two most IPS are not done till somewhere in September I know historically that that has happened here but the

061department is making an effort to have all of the non-public IEPs done prior to the April 1 deadline so that families have ample time to request transportation and IES Services okay I think we should clarify that um the transportation does not have a cut the Cod of date for special for IEPs it's in the education law I don't yeah so I don't have that same information I have the April 1 deadline but we are going to be engaging in a consultation Pro process with the non-public schools to talk about Transportation thank you so going back to what I was what what I was saying I'm sorry if there's any other comments I'm sorry anybody has any comments so what I talked about last time we talked about the instructional core and what this District needs

062to do and some PE some of the parents came up tonight and said what are we doing about the scores and what are we doing about what's happening with our students um it's um very important for you to understand um we are uncovering a lot of stuff this year right I'm sad to say I agree with you about the scores and what's happened and what's gone on and there's a lot of different things that go into that um and I can't take back the past the past is the past but we can only move on the future what we are looking to really do is and you'll see this in the budget process is to be able to go with a core instructional Focus for this district and it's about literacy especially K to3 getting

063students to be able to read and write at grade level by the time they end third grade and then what do we need to do to make that happen right from a professional development point of view from materials um from a supplemental staff to help out and then of course how we can get more kids to be able to graduate what that looks like um and that's really an important piece of what you'll see in the budget and the why we need certain Monies to do the kind of work that we need to do on another note we are already working on summer school programs so we are going to have Summer Schools this year right and what we're going to try to do is get the information out to you as soon as possible

064so you can register we're not going to do what happened in the past we don't know what's happening with the budget we don't know whether we're going to have programs or not we have to wait till May if the budget passes fine if it doesn't then we have to make for June families have to make plans on what they're doing teachers have to know what they're doing so we are working hard to put something out hopefully masus by the beginning of March so that you can apply see what the programs are but we are going to run summer school prr programs I know last year we didn't but we want to do that second thing we're looking to do to help success in our students be becoming a part of the school community in kindergarten

065is the possibility of offering a k jumpstar program so kids over the summer can come in and really get ready for that kindergarten experience which we think and we know will'll have them be ready to do better and the better they start to do in entering into kindergarten the the more successful hopefully they're going to be and we're going to start to see over time some of these scores get better so I want to thank again Special Education team but all of our members for the work they're doing um with regards to the budget truste grber back over to you in information reports from the board anybody of the Committees from atletic Wellness Medicaid has something to share about meetings anybody at the meetings that we had committee meetings committee meetings anybody wants to share

066something about it we had an Athletics meeting um last week and I believe that um superintendent Carlo already addressed most of the issues that uh we spoke about we spoke about the incident that happened in WAP Falls and uh the quick action that was taken by the superintendent to rectify it and came up with some solutions for further uh this shouldn't happen again and then we also spoke about believe he mentioned about the uh issues in the buildings and he's the superintendent really clarified very strongly that uh any issues should be brought to the proper authorities in a timely manner and that was the uh atletics meeting then we had a um we had another meeting yeah we had health and safety okay so both of them were addressed thank you also as a board

067member I would like to thank the superintendent for the quick action something we weren't used to when we had incidents with other when we had in the past incidents with the sports that it wasn't this time it was handled professional and first we really appreciate thank you we'll move on to consent and agenda items anybody wants to move who's first if he's first and Mr feather is second consent in agenda items 1 through 12 anybody has any comments all in favor say I motion passed 5 to one we'll make a motion anybody wants to make a motion to move the agenda item 20 to vote following the exact second I'll move it anybody second second second by Mr C I'll make a motion for Action items 1 to 19 I have a question on 19

068okay go ahead we we need a second or before we discuss second by Eric are you 1 we're on action items Mr feather go my question is what happens to the other schools there's only three schools that are mentioned question for you 20 we not question on the table is number that's okay 19 amendments to Transportation contracts 2425 truste feder has a question yes the transportation contracts right why only these three schools um are on the uh amendments where are the other schools that students were put in let me let on the uh contract amendments on number 19 and the action items there's only three schools mentioned avakov Central UTA and viset and I believe there's more schools that should be amended thect um the ones that are on here are the ones that have

069been that were completed in time for this meeting I know that we were asked to get the larger ones that had the uh biggest changes to the contracts done as quickly as possible if there are additional ones we will uh look to have them on the next meeting so if if you are um aware of any particular school that believes that they at least 10 to have one there at least 10 schools missing I'm sorry there at least 10 schools missing there are 10 schools missing okay well I'll I'll I'll get those uh names from you and then I can work with transportation department to ensure that uh those have been done and we'll we'll get them on the on the next on the next meeting okay we'll have to amend the action items as

070per the recommendation of the monitor we are pulling 13 14 15 16 and 17 so we're going to vote on 1 to 12 and then 18 and 19 and then after EXA will vote on 20 yes douglas douglas is that how we do it are are we tbling yes so you've so we're never tbling we're never table not taing okay yes so you're motion is amended to be a motion to approve action items one through 12 and then and 18 number 18 and 19 and items 13 to 17 are taken off at this pointed for they are not tabled I'm sorry removed and put them on this for for later consideration by the board yes so I think that's what the would you like me to explain or Dr Jal would you like to explain

071I can't okay you can because you probably got more insight than me because you got the call actually we've been discussing this for the last couple of days there's a concern about um the reimbursement that you would be getting as a district is in question uh so we want to validate that you will actually be getting a reimbursement for arpa funds for 13 14 15 16 and 17 we don't think it'll be a problem but we're not sure we want to make sure that you in fact get the reimbursement from the federal government so uh give us another couple of days to check and so we'll bring it back if possible on the 11th yeah just for clarification sake this is nothing we did what we needed to do on our part I don't want

072the public to think that you know something you know we were behind the able not doing it we did but that's the way government works at times so we just have to make sure we get the okay from the federal government so but you need to understand that thank you I don't know much about these change orders I'm just concerned because a couple of them indicate Ada which indicates to me compliance with federal law so just sharing that it might be in inappropriate to remove a i up from an agenda if there's ADA compliance issues with it even though there isn't reimbursement is that I I mean yeah so the school district would pay even if they didn't get reimbursed I mean if there's I I don't know anything about this it just I guess

073that's disadvantage of having something come up this late so right now the question is about reimbursement through the arpag grant um by moving this to if if we were to bring it back to the board for reconsideration uh or for consideration at our next meeting it would the that the timing of the two-e delay would not really affect no the work anything that's in here is already done it's just a matter of amending the contracts so yeah these are I mean these are very very modest amendments these are number 14 you're talking about $20,000 so the total is 100,000 yeah so that's an incidental amount of money even if the district didn't get reimbursed by the federal government do we need to remove the motion or we could just amend what we moved before I'm

074just making the observation that to to remove remove I'm asking the process the process that that the motion is amended as I understand it to only include action items 1 through 12 18 and 19 at this time and 13 14 15 16 17 will come back perhaps at the next meeting I'm asking if we need to move it again or did it so why don't we make another motion with those items removed second it and then you can vote on that anybody wants to move to am your motion we are we are amending the motion to only include items 1- 12 and taking out 13 14 15 16 17 and we do include 18 and 19 20 we will vote after the exact session I myself okay so who was first so did you move

075that Mr guber yeah F he was first F he moved and Mr C is second okay thank you all in favor I Mo moved future meeting dates is February 11 beginning at 7:30 over here at the plcc room in administration building written Communications since the last board meeting board did not receive any written communication make a motion to go to enter exact session to discuss matters regarding the possible appointment or of particular persons or Corporation need a seconder do we have a second second by Eric Mr Young all in favor say I motion removed e e e we'll call the meeting back to order anyone want to make a motion for item action item 20 okay uh motion that upon the recommendation of the interm superintendent of schools the Board of Education approves and authorizes

076the board president or in his absence the vice president and the interm superintendent of schools are designate to sign the agreement with Tom carton to provide head of security services consultant services for the 2425 school year anybody all in favor say I motion carries I'm going to because I'm just getting here and just like you said I was absent vice president was absent so I'll just um I guess I'll say no for the time being you know because of the fact I'm just [Music] arriving so we have five yes and one no right make a motion to adjourn this meeting so the next till February 11 yes everybody in favor say I I also we want to wish wish mazov to Simon C he's Maring go a son today conratulations congratulations Simon congrat I missed

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.