001e e e order please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all [Music] if you don't mind if everybody can please remain standing for a moment of silence for the following individuals who uh passed away over the holiday break we have Nel Barrett a former student of East Ramapo Central School District Curtis Pinkston Ramapo high school graduate coached intramural football 2006 and 2007 and then lastly with heavy hearts that we inform you of the passing of leer cicerone who dedicated 30 years of service to the East rapo School District as a custodian from 1987 to 2017 so I ask a moment of silence in remembrance of these individuals thank
002you thank you very much thank you good evening everyone fire exits are located at the front of the boardroom and at the sides of the boardroom in the event of a fire you will hear a fire at that at that time please move in a common orderly fashion to the nearest exit I will now make a motion to open the floor for public speaking do I have a second second second by vice president Mill all in favor say I I anyone oppos obain motion carry speaker number one first of all I'd like to say happy New Year um to everybody here and I hope that this year brings us better endeavors with the community working together in a collaboration is one instead of as much chaos as we've had in the past secondly I'm I'm
003urging you please see what's going on with the food cuz people are still complaining you know as one of the leaders in the community I represent what the community says and what individuals are saying third and lastly because I'm going to make this short but I'm going to get to the point at no time will it ever again be brought to my attention because I'm bringing to yours now and it stops here no staff no faculty member no employee from East Ramapo Central School District is ever going to deter any students from showing up to board meetings will not talk negativity to students and tell them don't show up to board meetings because the next time it's not going to going be a nice time to hear and see what's going to happen cuz there
004will be a stand up there will be a walk out students have a right to appear at these board meetings adults no matter what position they hold in the school district have no right to say to students that they should not be coming to board meetings that they should not be speaking up for themselves because that's wrong if we're going to start the new year off right let's start it off together the correct way but not take away the rights of any individual who has a right to sit up here go sign up with Kathy and speak its Injustice a lot of students are also complaining that if there is money and funding now could you possibly find a way to make sure that each school is represented correctly with the right color uniforms because
005this is not fair for students at all and you're talking about from middle school to high school let's have our students perform wear their school colors and be proud when they go out there to play sports thank you very [Applause] much thank you speaker number two good evening everyone uh my name is Tony Stevens I'm the president of the East Ramapo Teachers Association uh first I would like to uh wish everybody a Happy New Year and I hope everyone had a good break um I would also like to introduce up here with me um vice president of secondary education for the Teachers Association Trisha naab and uh the treasurer and chief negotiator for the Teachers Association uh Bill Hooper they're they're not like a new era security team or something like that but um so
006we are here tonight on behalf of the EO Teachers Association to thank the District administration and the Board of Education in working with us to approve a new [Applause] contract so this took uh this took much time but with perseverance and teamwork we were able to collectively get this done and as I tell my own students almost every day there is no task that is insurmountable and there is a solution to every problem and the important thing is we did this together I see our work together as positive steps for our district as a whole and this goes far beyond just a agreeing on a contract the Teachers Association looks forward to a productive and collaborative relationship with the district and while there are still many many challenges ahead there are capable individuals running the
007district and a more than ex exemplary teaching staff to serve the children and the community of East Ropo thank you again and have a great evening thank you thank you thank you speaker number three hello we're familiar with the current lunch condition that hasn't changed to be honest this is ridiculous don't you get tired of repeated comments the food is unappetizing as students we need nutritious food to fuel our minds and bodies but the current options often fall short that's why I'm asking for a better lunch option options we love to see more variety Health choices and food that actually tastes good it's not too uh not too much to ask for right lastly I'd like to ask about the outdoor space next to the cafeteria in Chestnut Ridge as you know the area gets
008really hot and sunny especially in the spring I think it would be amazing if we can improve the space by adding shade structures bench and even a small garden imagine being able to eat lunch outside on a night nice day enjoying the fresh andir air and some shade it it would be a great way to take a break and recharge during the school day thank you for listening to my concerns I hope you you'll consider of my requests and make sure positive changes to our school lunch options and outdoor spaces hopefully this year is better and thank you thank you speaker number five I'm sorry speaker number four I guess four and five I'm assuming hi my name is is M and MAA and I'm here to to to talk about um that I really
009want the board to put s in our playground cuz some schools has has PL swings and I don't and my school my guest doesn't have swings that's it Mom did you just Mom if you wouldn't mind so yeah so we can hear we noticed that other districts um in other districts sorry other schools that are Elementary have swings and they don't and if the others have swings they're not enough so she would like enough swings for her school which is margette thank you thank you do you want to speak as well you want yeah go ahead Happy New Year to everyone um recently I had the privilege of participating in roundo alumni day where I share my high school and college experience with current students what struck me was the eagerness of the students to
010learn about college life however I was dishearted to hear from special education students in grades 11th and 12th that they felt unprepared for transitioning to college for those who actually had the help of looking for colleges and were fearful of the unknown furthermore I was alarmed to discover that many students in the bilingual classes had not even met their guidance counselors yet despite being halfway through the school year these students are eagered for guidance for college options scholarships and career paths and trade at I met with a 12th grade student who aspires to become a lawyer but had never received guidance of scholarships or college application process in the four years she has been in ramul high school this is unacceptable we need to do better that's what I'm calling on you the district and
011board to bring colleges with athletic music art programs to expose our students to possibilities how can a student go four years in a row without knowing how to do do anything with college we need to provide them with guidance and support that they desire additionally I would like to address the issue about the school suspension to me sending kids home without guidance for multiple days is not a punishment it's a reward we need to develop a program that provides support and guidance to these students during the suspension time rather than leaving them at their own devices and at home it is our responsibility to ensure that our students are equipped and have tools that they need to succeed we really need to work together to bring in other options that they need in order to
012succeed in life as in their adulthood also I would like to speak about um facilities specifically bathrooms for teachers and staff that is not enough in the schools and they don't have enough time to go when there's a line of multiple staff members waiting for the a bathroom that is clean also the bathroom rooms in the school including chesar Ridge that haven't been updated properly when there's still smell of feces and kids refuse to go to the bathroom I have kids with UTI problems constantly because they have to hold their bladder in order um for not to go into the school bathrooms because they don't want to have an accident and also throw up it doesn't work that way and it's not nice to be um in that position to get an infection because the
013bathrooms are not clean constantly or they don't smell appropriately like it's backed up and it's not nice because now the hallway smells like that and that's not good either thank you thank you speaker number seven I'm sorry speaker number six I apologize sorry Randy proud East round graduate happy happy New Year and welcome to 2025 I first and foremost I would like to congratulate all the leaders of 2025 I you guys have no idea how proud I am of each and every one of the class of 2025 they're making great change they're shining and leading their classmates to Greatness and success whether it may be in clubs Athletics academics I am so proud of you for those of you who don't know me cuz it's a lot of new faces I am Randy Davis I
014am the former class president for the class of 2023 I now attend Iona university and I'm serving as a senator in a student government Association I'm a product of Easter amopa and here I'm here thank you I'm here to inspire the students to continue on the path of greatness take as many people with you I say to these kids like keep bringing each other to board meetings I will take the credit I did start that I encourage so many students to come out and it's very it's very sad and to hear that you know they're being discouraged but I'm here and I'm saying keep coming keep telling the success of the district keep coming and saying all the good things that are happening because there's a lot there's a lot that goes on that goes
015unnoticed and we need to make sure that it's heard toour cabinet you guys do a lot so I just want to say thank you you know thank you to all that you do to our superintend it I've been hearing a lot of good things about you been hearing a lot of good things but it's it's nothing it's nothing new because you're a Gil and Gail shine through any circumstance you got that all right go gals okay for the new year I ask that we bring new ideas let's bring effective changes to improve our education and the experience of all our students final but not least I say let's finish off the year with a passing budget can we do that and for the um the the comment that brought up about um students not having
016the proper guidance to go into college and everything I offer up myself if you guys need I can come in and um counsel the students even have an assembly and show them um give Insight on how the college life is cuz it's needed you know a lot of there's very few of us that actually make it to college and actually are going to graduate that stay all four years it's a very hard process so I would love to come in and talk to our students you know all thank you all enjoy the great year thank you thank you Randy speaker number seven now apologies for the false start good evening and happy New Year to everyone uh one issue that that I've noticed in the village of Spring Valley mostly and I've spoken about this
017before I also spoke about it at the Village big issue is school buses and the safety of these buses most not most but quite a lot of them are seen speeding constantly every day speeding past children standing on the very edge of a sidewalk going so fast that the uh wind gust from the bus almost blew one of them right into traffic and I've seen this the buses quite a few of them are driving around with none of the kids seated if the bus happen to hit a curve you'll see the kids literally lift from the seat or if standing right to the roof and back down they're always going fast for whatever reason now I've seen a lot of them with truck style horns mounted on the left side which the drivers often use
018to blow you know to clear the streets quite often uh they'll cut you off they have no courtesy on the road but they're they're expecting courtesy from other motorists this shouldn't be allowed at all I don't care who the school bus company is whether it's private public doesn't matter because you now put the lives of the children in danger and you put the lives of the other people drive other motorists in danger as well I don't want to keep speaking on this subject or I don't really want to see another child dead because nobody paid attention to it I brought this to the Spring Valley Police Department to the mayor of Spring Valley and they all said they're going to look into it well hopefully that hopefully they they'll do that because like I said
019I'm tired of seeing and and hearing a school bus ran over a child or whatever the case may be and then it gets swept under the rug and nobody knows about it a lot of parents would not take that lightly some may bury their child and that's the end of it some are not going to do that so I think it's a better idea to prevent it or at least go to the bus companies and say what the hell is going on here we can't have buses flying through neighborhoods flying around corners blindly and just expecting to pull out in the road and and do whatever they want so safety school safety school bus safety is the biggest thing right now that I see on the street I can only uh imagine what it'll uh
020what will happen if another child has ran over I seen one where a kid I think this was just a pure pure mistake the child went in front of the bus the driver didn't notice and closed the door and took off luckily she made it between the rear axles and lived please see if you could speak to these people about school bus safety and speeding could save some lives thanks thank [Applause] you thank you that concludes public speaking Yeah president Rose just be as of just uh some of the questions that came up um and and some of the things um are going to be discussed in our budget when you see the budget presented the superintendent's Budget on some of the things you talked about but I want to go back to the the
021there are two comments about student voice which I have to be honest with you um in speaking with the students I have asked them and they want to be here at meetings so is everybody telling them not to be at meetings that's concerning to me because I have I have worked closely with both high schools at the meetings that we have the student circles and them wanting to have the voice they came here last month and and talked about some of the things and they are going to be back and we welcome them back because it is their school their vo are important so I just want to get that out there um as far as uniforms go we actually just today I had a conversation we had an issue with uh cheerleading uniforms and
022the like so we're on that we're looking at it to your point we want to make sure that our students are properly outfitted whether it be a team or cheerleaders or whatever so I am working with our athletic director I'm working with Mr Stark um and that's part of also what we need to do in regards to what the budget looks like safety on buses I can't agree with you more part of the problem and you're going to see that also in the budget is we are underst staffed severely in our transportation department you're right there should be more people out in the streets looking at these bus buses finding the bus companies when these things are happening taking photos of it I agree with you 100% we are second to New York City in
023the numbers of students we transport every day yet our transportation department nowhere near the amount of Staffing we need and you will see that presented in the budget so a lot of your concerns and things that you have brought up I want you to understand we are listening to we are hearing clearly and you'll see that reflective um in the budget as far as special education goes and transition and bilingual classes and students meeting with guance counselors we are well aware of that my cabinet will tell you we get it we hear it we're a new group okay we just came in this year we're listening to these things and you're going to also see in the budget what needs to be done around professional development what we how we can help our our our
024staffs how we can help our students but you mentioned it before this is all a part of what we need to be successful and to bring East Ramapo to the next level and part of that is Staffing part of that is professional development and you're going to hear about a lot of that over the next couple of weeks as far restorative practices go we have a nice team that is in in our district especially at ramma um that's working with students around restorative practices We can't agree more to continually suspend students and not have them reflect on what happened and how they can restore what some of what they've done we have to do more of a better job with and we're working with that um that group and you're going to actually see a
025presentation again during the budget process because there's an unsung hero that's out there that's been helping sponsored this group that's been in the district and you don't even know about it because it hasn't been shared with you so we'll we'll talk about that so I just wanted to Echo some of the things that you said we clearly hear you we're working with we're going to work through it with our budget um and we want to do what's best for our kids of course each and every day so thank you president and Mr Dar Carlo while you're speaking with Mr Rose don't forget about our little Allison and her sister came up and they talked about the lunch situation so forg that's no I'm I'm glad you brought to my attention thank you so here's a
026couple of things that are important we need I know you're letting us know about this but when these things are happening in the building and whether or not there's cold fooled or there's not enough options we then need to know that okay because then we can have the conversations of Mr Stark and talk with the Food Service Company cuz we're not hearing that on a day-to-day basis so we we need to get a better understanding of what those options are as far as the seating goes we can help you with that actually we are working with and and Mr Tindle can tell you a little bit about what we're doing with uh specifically the high schools but also the middle schools about looking at enhancing if you wouldn't mind Mr tendle talking about some of
027the work that you've begun to do and what we're looking at doing in some of these areas so we had a company come in and kind of design all our um cafeteria spaces um right now most of the students eat on foldout tables and folding chairs um so one of the things we wanted to look at is actually making the space a better space overall um one of the things we actually did with Chestnut Ridge recently was we upgraded the window systems um and the the doorways around that cafeteria space already that work already finished um probably within the last month or so so we are making the spaces nicer um including the cafeteria space with a little more school pride have the tables uh show a little more school pride um and not look
028like just columns and rows and boring seating so that'll be right now we have um designs for the high schools and the middle schools um hopefully we are able to continue to reinvest in our cafeteria spaces thank you I appreciate it um and Randy to you listen at the end of the meeting if you can come up and meet with me and we can talk about how we can get you to do that that would be awesome because that's really what it's about that role modeling so thank you for offering of your services and we need to do more of that so I appreciate you wanting to volunteer to do that so that leads me into um my superintendent report um just a quick little update um I know that there was an article in
029the news about this so um just to you aware the state controller's office has reached out to us and the Board of Education the division of local government and school accountability of the office of the state controller has selected the East ripo Central School District for an examination of our budget the examination will focus on an evaluation of the district's adopted budget for 25 2425 including historical budget estimates and prior operating results we will contact you soon to schedule a date I can let you know that they have contacted us they're coming in this Thursday to meet with myself and Mr star to go over what their procedures will be and what their needs are going to be in regards to information that we can provide them upon completion of their report that'll be uh
030then sent to myself and the board and we will share that with the community I want to let the community be aware of that process starting um and and then we get to um an overview I just talk to you a little bit about the budget a couple of things as a superintendent of schools you know and starting July of 24 over the past several months I've engaged in many conversations both with my cabinet building principles parents students to analyze what is happening in going on here in the East Ramapo Central School District we've looked at data we've looked at performances and now it's time to come up with a budget for the 25 26 school year what's really important is that we look at our strengths we look at our weaknesses and then we
031put together a superintendence budget that's reflective on what the needs are for our students for our staff in regards to academics safety Health well-being professional development um Quality staff and fiscal responsibility so I I share this as an overview because over the next number of months we're going to be talking about budget so the budget establishes the goals for the East Ramapo Central School District and it's really important because it fulfills our mission in educating our students not only for the 25 26 school year but for years beyond that and what do I mean by that this is really important when you're looking at a budget and you're looking at professional development and you're looking at materials and supplies and you're looking at programs you want to be able to sustain programs from one year
032to the next and we have to make a commitment to what that looks like moving forward because at the end of the day we don't want to start something and then have to stop it and then start something and have to stop it we want things to be able to continue from year to year that we feel are important for students academic growth social emotional growth and other boats so it's an important piece my responsibility and the board of education's responsibility is to reflect the values of the community and establish the necessary poliy policies I'm sorry to achieve these goals and to communicate to you the community the goals and progress that we're making our values and core values should be centered around success is measurable by student growth and achievement so we have to
033present to you data so you can see where our students are at and that what we are looking to do to plan to increase that student uh growth graduation rates performance and on state assessments College acceptances which are really important as we move forward our students are worthy of intellectual social and emotional respect that needs to be reflective in what we do in the budget effective teaching is essential and it was just mentioned by the union how we have to work together to professionally develop the needs that they need to be able to make sure that we're on The Cutting Edge of technology so that our students are prepared to meet the new challenges that are out there understand something the state is actively involved in saying guess what we have to look at things
034differently we we have to look at different Pathways to graduation not the traditional regions that everybody's got to pass but looking at the trades looking at different types of things cyber security other things uh that are important for kids to be able to develop a pathway into what needs to be done the state has also said the following and you're going to see this very much highlighted in the budget the state is saying we can no longer wait for kids to be able to read at the of grade grade level three they are saying to all districts and we have to sign off on it okay that between prek and third grade kids need to be able to to read at the third grade level upon the completion of their third third year of of
035experience and what does that look like that's going to have implications for professional development that's going to have implications on Staffing that's going to have in implications on interventionist and guess what the state has said this is what you have to do state not just East ripo but even more so here because a lot of our students are L Learners okay so I it's the work that we need to do and get people in front of them and programs in front of them so that they can be successful and then again we learn from each other it's a partnership between you parents and Guardians in the community and all students deserve the opportunity to achieve at their Highest Potential so these are the things that are important and then you're going to see if you
036can just do the next slide these are going to be the areas that we're going to talk about the themed areas student learning objectives promote social emotional creative and intellectual growth for all our students encouraging them to take challenging and self-directed classes as a part of the new New York State graduation Pathways and Inspire our students to do their best through their K12 experience here in East ripo and that their education should be equ and should not matter what elementary school they go to what middle school they go to and what high school they go to whatever those requirements are should be systematic across grade levels K12 continue to work with um and hire high quality staff recruit hire cultivate evaluate and support all faculty and staff to consistently lead all students to learning styles
037and learning at or above grade level benchmarks community and and um engagement and Outreach to communicate collaborate effectively partner with parents students and our business community and local colleges and universities and then last importantly is Resource Management manage management of fiscal Capital Technologies and resources that efficiently align with our mission and vision that's the overview of what you're going to be hearing and seeing over the next several months so um president um Rose I thank you for the time being able to present this to you and I look forward to many healthy discussions over the next couple of months when we lay out our budget thank you thank you Mr Z Carlo looking forward to as well um any questions or comments okay so hearing none we're going to do things a bit differently today
038before we move on to consent and agenda items you do have a question Mr guber I wanted to add about the bses that as far as I'm aware most bus companies almost all of them already by now have installed cameras inside and outside of the buses for safety so we could have an idea to see if the kids of all these allegations are true and if yes we could see which driver and which company it is thank you great Point as I was saying thank you Mr grber and it's a good idea if the the buses that have the cameras we should Mr G you said all of them B at this point most of them have most of them have the cam so and I believe what about uh we're talking about a a
039safety some more safety officers yeah Eric do you want to speak a little bit I mean I I kind of gave an overview about it but and and I know that you work closely with Rochelle and and Miss Gibbons is putting together what some of those needs are as we move forward in the next budget cycle yeah so that there's actually quite a few things um and as you know we also had a report that came um a safety report from the state so there are a lot of things that are um in process of being uh worked on um cameras on buses are an important piece there's also the cameras that are on the uh stop arms that are connected to the to the police force um so there's a number of different items
040that are out there we're working on them um we're actually having a transportation committee meeting tomorrow where we will be giving an update on on that report um so um it's been taken very seriously there have been meetings with uh the uh all of the contractors for both public and non-public students uh already during the year and um we've also set up a number of meetings uh with the uh directors of the non-public schools to go over uh a lot of the procedures and processes that we have here in terms of registration um to to uh make that process better as we move forward as well so there's a lot of work going on um kudos to relle who has come on board um in the summer and has gotten quite a bit done but
041um as as you all know Rome wasn't built in a day um and there's still a lot more to be done um but we we've we've uh I think taken a good chunk uh of what uh was in that report and and worked on it so far thank so just I'm sorry just for clarification purposes to my understanding from um what was mentioned earlier during public comment and also at the last board meeting um I understand that we have cameras on the bus but the issue is the way the bus drivers are driving the cameras on the bus are only uh they only detect from my understanding drivers that are passing the buses or V doing no they're constantly recording all the activities inside and around the bus from all if you look at the
042bus there are cameras on all four back back from side and inside their two cameras but what I'm saying first of all you didn't let me finish um you know I didn't interrupt you so what I was trying to say is that when the buses are driving erratically on the street the cameras are not detecting that and if unless there's a way that it is supposed to and it's not then we're not aware of it but um clearly if that was the case we would be able to identify the buses and the drivers that are causing you know all the issues on the street so I believe what the concern is coming from our community members is you know making sure that our drivers are trained and also warned that you know safety of our
043students safety of um others that are on the street is very important and that they need to you know basically you know have a concern and be worried about the way they're driving I mean it's it's it's clear um we're not trying to say say that there AR aren't cameras we just want to make sure that our students are safe that we um do not have any more incidences where students are being ran over by buses or you know hit by buses and um I think that's something that we just need to make sure that we mentioned to the different bus companies that we're contracted with so that um you know it doesn't happen Okay the caminas are recording constantly they only send tickets for what when somebody passes but if you complain on a
044bus with a number they could request from the company they have data it's recorded and it's stored they could access and see anything that's done around the bus on the outside and on the bus itself they could see how the driver drives what he was doing when he was driving what the kids were doing and the speed he was going this is the system that they have on all the buses and if you call in with the bus number and a complaint they could go back and see and I have clips of buses what's going ontime so you're saying so you're saying with the cameras on the bus with the camera on the bus you could see how the driver drove what he was doing if he was on the phone if he was concentrated
045if he was looking what it's doing on the sidewalk there cameras on the surround it's not only the two cameras that you see on the left that record when you pass the red lights there's a camera on the rear of the bus there are two cameras on the right side there's a camera on the front they see everything around the bus on do we have but do we have that system in place for all our buses 90% of the buses have it by now they all the whatever you see having the big camera on the side they have the bus Patrol have everything bus Patrol stores it and you could go back and ask whe Whoever has authority to ask and I believe that the district has that as well to see what's what if
046they get a complaint on a specific bus a number in a time they'll be able to send you the recording of a whole period of time what was going on on the bus outside the bus everything um Mr St I don't know if you could answer this question but I know originally when um executive Ed day came up with the idea of having the cameras outside of the bus um we I believe this word only opt in for cameras outside do you know if all of our buses have cameras on the bus as well in in terms of answering your questions specifically right now I can't give you that answer but I will bring it to the next meeting okay thank you okay I know for a fact that whoever got bus Patrol which is
047the company that the county contracted to do give the servises they have the entire system on the bus and the other thing that I can tell you is that we can work with the transportation committee on um guidelines and if we do that and get those set we can put those guidelines into our bid document ments for next year and make things required so that if you if you have a bus fleet and you want to bid on the work for the school district you will be required to have that and not having it would make it a uh make you an unsuccessful bidder so those are things that we can work towards um I'm I'm not sure how the the process took place in previous years but hearing all of this and with the
048fact that we're we're having a number of Transportation committee meetings now to get uh the processes set properly for next year it's a great point and we'll certainly uh begin talking about that tomorrow thank you qu question to followup on that um with the is there a number of confirmed infractions that a bus driver has to have before he's removed from a route is there um what is the process by which um bus drivers are removed held accountable and I guess assessed if they're found to not be following the rules of the road so um I I will tell you that I do not believe that we have board policy on that um I do know that we have had um certain instances where there have been issues with a bus driver either um in
049terms of uh certain driving or in terms of interactions with students um and if we make the request of the contractor to have that bus driver stop driving immediately they have to do that so and we um I can tell you that we have done that on at least one occasion this year year so far oh okay I think um just a recommendation it might be um beneficial to us to have a guidelines of what the good and or bad driving looks like so that bus drivers can have we can hold them accountable because I'd imagine if you're getting that's actually set forth by the state okay and it's part of the required training that every school bus driver in the state of New York has to have on an annual basis it's not just
050once and then so then my followup to that would be then we should probably have in writing what if you're first infraction leads to ex suspension section infraction leads to this and then you're terminated or removed based off I think it should be a little bit more um in in writing rather than left up to interpretation guess be hard for us to do that and enforce that because the bus drivers in this District are not our employees but what we can do is we can put language in our bid documents and in our um contracts that require certain treatments based on certain actions okay great thank you thank you okay thank you Mr star and thank you Mr Z Carlo um okay so as I said we're going to do a little we're going to
051do board reports before we get to the agenda namely to hear reports of the policy committee meeting today by Mr attended by Mr Young Mercer and then we will get to other board members who have some any other reports to share Mr y thank you Mr President um happy New Year everybody um today's policy committee meeting for myself was a very enlightening one um as a new member this entire process is a learning p a learning um experience for me especially in this first year so I just want to say thank you for all of the members and staff that have been patient and explaining things to me and how to go about it um especially U Mr Carlo and the team that he's built I know they're doing a lot of hard work um
052and that's just want to know that that's acknowledged and um appreciated um but one of my biggest takeaways from today's meeting um besides how alarmingly outdated some of our policies are is the responsibility we as board members have an understanding the magnitude behind its understanding approval and updating of the policy um I know there's been past rhetoric from board members that these are things they weren't aware of however um as a community member I grew up in Spring Valley went to Spring Valley High School you know that shouldn't be an an acceptable or reasonable EXP ation to our um current community members simply saying that you were unaware um shouldn't suffice um one of if not the most important part of our job is policy this has been made clear to me on day one
053it is curious why that has um that may have been lost on some members um cor correct um we do rely on staff to share information with us um but we should be asking the right questions if we notice things aren't being done we have annual meeting that teach us these things so if we don't know we should use those we if we don't know we should use th those times to ask um we should take this more seriously as a board specifically in implementing work sessions as an idea for next year's schedule to better our understanding so that these things do not happen again um that seems to be like a fair and reasonable expectation we should have of ourselves and of each other um I think as board members it's easy to place
054blame on systems and um persons that are no longer here or that have not best served us but we have to look forward um to what could be not what has been done and I think um the rhetoric should change on where that responsibility um of holding our district and ourselves accountable that's what I have to say and that was that came from this meeting so again thank you to everybody that was a part of that thank you president Migel would you like to sorry yes um I just jotted down a couple things that I wanted to mention um at Rockland Community College uh there was a uh track meet over the holiday break in which I had the pleasure seeing our student athletes from both ripo and Spring Valley High School compete in um
055various track and field events against Rockland and Westchester as well as Upstate schools um so I hats off to them and at n high school over the break I also had the pleasure of supporting the boys varsity basketball team who participated in a for team tournament which they were the overall winners so besides besides congratulating our student athletes I say this to say it reminds me how important it is for our students to be able to participate in extracurricular activities such as sports for many that is their way of obtaining a scholarship or financial support to attend a college of their choice so I just wanted to mention that um because I know that at the present time we are working on the budget so please consider and think about how some of our student
056athletes here in East Ramapo attend college and how they um attain obtain scholarships to to attend a college of their choice thank you thank you president go ahead no I think we're just doing it now so uh just to add um I want to say congratulations to our ramp of varsity team um before a board meeting tonight I intended their um game against Port Chester they won 57 to 36 uh so congratulations to them um also prior to before the break um you know there there was a lot of activities that uh occurred in our district I want to give a special thanks to Mr dallo uh where he had a town hall with our Spring Valley students um which was a success our super superintendent student circle from rampo and smooth Valley also enjoyed
057a nice lunch together here at the administration building before the break um which is something that we started back in 2016 uh something that he did which was interesting was the ice breaker where he had the students Place himself in birthday order without talking so giving them a way to you know commun without using their words which I found interesting and I think they only got one wrong um also a special shout out to our world famous marching band um they had their annual holiday performance at every building and ended it here at the administration building they were also treated to lunch and went around the room and talked about their most meor memorable moments during their visits um at the buildings and then last but not least thank you to our family resource coordinator
058for putting together another great holiday feast uh this is an annual um Fe holiday feast that they've put together every year since I believe 2015 2016 um I also want to thank um bin I'm sorry Mr azim and the Islamic Center for always donating their time to cook and provide gifts and boxes of groceries to our families feeding over 3,000 families so thank you [Applause] thank you just Charles Pierre and following up about the marching band I actually saw them yesterday by the inauguration of new assembly weer and they sounded great so always a pleasure to see them okay moving on to consent and agenda items do I have a motion for consent and and agenda items 1 through nine move by Mr C do have a second second by Mr guber any discussion on
059the matter hearing none all those in favor say I I anyone oppose abstain motion carries moving on to action items do I have a motion for Action items one through 20 so move move I vice president Miguel second by Mr coth we will open up for discussion any questions any concerns hearing no discussion all those in favor say say I I anyone oppose abstain motion carries moving on to Advanced planning future meeting dates a regular meeting is scheduled for January 21st 2025 beginning at 7:30 p.m. in the plcc room in the administration building 105 South Madison Avenue Spring Valley New York written communication since the last board meeting the board received written Communications from monitor far regarding the mooding mood mood rating issue to the district where moody moody removed the negative outlook for the
060district and affirmed the rating of baa3 moving on I will now make a motion to enter executive session Kathy what are we discussing um to discuss the possible appointment or termination of particular persons or corporations and we do expect action following do I have a second second by just Charles Pier all those in favor say I I anyone oppose obain motion Carri thank you have a good night everybody e e e W for I'm just waiting for the motion honestly I'll come get it again okay good evening i' would like to call this meeting back to order um I would make a motion to accept a letter letter of resignation from Christian Alfieri effective 11262 24 do I have a second second by Mr Young merer all those in favor say I andone oppos obain
061motion carries I not make a motion to join this meeting to have a second second by the board all those in favor say I anyone oppos St motion car thank you very much good night everyone