CorpusRecord 60866

ERCSD - Regular Board Meeting 12-10-24

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / East Ramapo CSD
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Rockland County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,739 words · about 55 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e all right good evening everyone welcome to the East rample Central School District board meeting it's now 7:17 p.m. we would like to call this meeting to order will everyone please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation God indivisible with liberty and justice for all [Music] for [Music] [Applause] at this time I'd like to make a public safety announcement fire exits are located at the front of the boardroom and at the sides of the boardroom in the event of a fire you will hear a fire alarm at that time please move in a calm and orderly fashion to the nearest exit thank you anticipated executive meeting I would like to now make

002a motion to enter executive session uh Miss kivy can you please State the reason um to receive an update on era negotiations and the possible appointment of a particular person or Corporation we do expect action following executive session thank you can I now have a second second all in favor no one opposes so carries we will now enter into executive session thank you e e e I get a chance to talk to you for for e okay good evening everyone would like to call this meeting back to order before we open the floor for public speaking we are going to make a motion to approve a new teachers contract um Kathy would you like to read the motion please ready for the motion okay uh I'd like to make the motion do I have a

003second second want to read it a motion to adopt the following resolution whereas the district and the East Ramapo Teachers Association era are parties to a valid and binding collective bargaining agreement and whereas the district and era have agreed to terms of a memo of agreement related to changes to the CBA for the 2022 23 through 2025 26 school year the mo MOA and now therefore be it resolved that the Board of Education of the East Ramapo Central School District hereby one authorizes and approves entering into such MOA and two authorizes the interm superintendent and order the board president to sign and execute the mo MOA okay so we have a motion and a second do we need to do roll call or all those in favor say I I and on oppose abstain motion

004carries just a quick statement yes I'll now give it over to our superintendent for a quick statement thank you I want to take this opportunity to com to uh comment on us working together between the school district and the teachers union as we reached an important and a milestone for our school Community as a result of tonight's ratification this contract not only reflects the hard work of our Educators and administrators but also our commitment to the East Ramapo Central School District to paror ize our students and their Futures as I promised you several months ago we would continue to dialogue with the teachers union and we worked to finally come to agreement after 2 and A2 years this contract is more than just an agreement in salaries it's a testament to the mutual respect we

005have for our teachers who dedicate their lives to educating our students and shape the leaders of tomorrow I want to thank the teachers union the executive board for their hard work and patience and professionalism I know this is not not easy and it was a long journey to get to tonight I want to thank the school board and central office a special thanks to Mr stalk M rusco Mr Gart for all their leadership and dedication through the negotiation process and reing reaching a balanced and thoughtful resolution your insights and collaboration were very very instrumental and to finally you the community we thank you for your patience and faith pen as you have confidence in the new team as we embarked on getting a contract track and made it become a reality your support and advocacy

006for our schools are deeply appreciated this is a moment of unity I hope in which we can continue as we work for many many years to come it's a reminder as we enter into the holiday season that we can accomplish many great things when we come together for the good of the community our students and our families let's carry that Spirit forward as we enter into the new year to the students teachers staff administrators parents and the school board let me say say it's been a pleasure working with you I am grateful for all your dedication collaborations and patience may the upcoming holidays be a time for recreation relaxation with families and friends so important as we prepare for the challenges and opportunities that our new year has to begin now let's take time to

007reflect on our blessings recharge and let's make the East rampo Central School District the best school district it can possibly become thank you thank you Mr the Carlo we will now I will now make a motion to open the floor for public speaking do I have a second second second by vice president Mill all of in favor say I I and oppos obain motion carries speaker number one not on is working out thank you good evening first of all I'd like to applaud these young students from Spring Valley and ramul high school for coming out to these board meetings there's starting to be a change with these young students here representing that means change is coming I'd like to thank the boards um from the students advisory for Spring Valley on Miss Herrera and for

008Ramapo Miss hunt for leading these students to understanding the importance of their appearances here today to understand that only together can we make change it is a huge accomplishment out of all the years that I've been here to see so many young energetic students to a rul student who I just found out Alexis Palencia bright student by talking to him very intellectual very forthcoming he's got a bright future ahead of him congratulations to your full scholarship to Columbia on another note as you had said only only only together as a community can we make this change happen so I'm speaking for the entire Community because I know that certain people will come up here and and speak about the budget understand that I as I speak to you I speak as an individual in community

009and we don't mind the budget increase it should not be touched we have not had a tax increase in over 10 years I understand that $30 million was found I understand the miscalculations I understand everything else but understand that we still have 200,000 worth of repairs that still need to be done okay 200 million I mean worth the repairs that need to be done repairs that are still neglected in our school see the Cause right here this is the reason why it should be repaired for these students for the teachers for the staff because that's worth it everybody wants to complain about the increase and about how un affordable it could be but there's a lot of people here that I've seen that are on welfare and own businesses and have sub businesses and sub

010business stop the Malarkey start realizing it's about the children it's about the schools it's about the community and providing what's best for the children in these schools and stop saying your pockets are empty hey I'm loow income and I'm still making ends meet and I'm going to be paying the same taxes as everybody else so it doesn't matter [Applause] one more thing is the search firms that had responded to rfps last Wednesday are they making any decisions will they share proposals with the public will they consult in time and what time thank you very [Music] much speaker number two hello hello hello uh good evening everyone uh I'm just here to mention something that has come across from the nurse's office and basically they were saying when are the renovations for the nurse's office going

011to be complete because they have a syn that is not functioning and they need it to be functioning so that in case there's a situation where there's two students who and I would hate to just like throw it out here and say something vulgar but like let's say that one is vomiting in the bathroom and then the other one has like let's say a paper cut right uh we can't handle both in the same restroom especially if there's only one restroom and if the sink is not functioning and also it is also noted that the wall is opened up and you can see within and see the pipes within the building and uh there's a lot of uh Critters that are within there so I just wanted to make that known and I mean that's

012all I have for today but thank you for listening and I appreciate every single one of you who helped with the cause of the water fountains of course because it was really important for our schools and I think recently uh I got to drink out of one and it was a surreal experience knowing that I got to drink out of a water fountain and actually not be scared to drink out of one for once so uh thank you for those who put the effort into making sure that we have our water fountains and that is all I have for today so thank you for listening to me and I'll see you next time bye thank you which school are you in sir which school do you go to which school are you in asking the

013school you're from rul got it thank you speaker number [Applause] three good evening everyone my name is glor Shirley and I attend Spring Valley High School I'm a senior and today I would like to talk to you about reinstating honors classes I firmly believe that honors classes provide students with the valuable opportunity to challenge themselves academically and reach their full potential by reinstating honors classes we are acknowledging the diverse learning needs for our student body and committing to providing Pathways for in to inspire excellence and I'd also like to take the time to amend um Mr Dar Carlo thank you for improving our school it looks really beautiful the do I love it the basketball games I know is going to be very fun with all this new stuff that are coming in the weight

014room I personally that actually warms my heart cuz I'm a track thrower in the weight room is where I like to work out so thank you for taking the time and bringing positivity to our school thank you and that is all for today thank you speaker number four [Applause] good evening um my name is Priscilla almanar I'm a junior at Ramapo high school and I want to bring up adding to the last speaker thank you add to the last speaker that many students have brought up the fact that we want more variety of electives in our school that focus on medicine or other career path that they can't access to because we don't have these type of programs in our schools and a student wants to engage and explore and explore their interest academically and

015we need more of these programs so they could afford to okay and I want to thank Mr the Carlo also for I love seeing like someone who like so strongly advocates for students and I see like we can actually make things better our schools so thank you for your time thank you thank you speaker number five good evening got a couple questions to ask uh these are questions people are actually asking have been asking but some don't really know so I'll ask the board how many schools are covered under the umbrella of East Ramapo school district are the public schools prioritized last versus the so-called private schools what is taught in these schools versus the public schools do the children of the school board members attend the public schools that they are in charge of

016no other school district in Rockland County has this type of dysfunction in this in their school district this is this has been one of the worst school district in all of Rockland County none of this foolishness is seen in New City Pearl River Clarkstown North Rockland where I attended suffering Etc why is that East R poo school district is being run like the village of Spring Valley cannot be trusted school buses from a safety point of view school buses several accidents have occurred yet there are still many buses driving at high speeds daily throughout East R Poole school district and throughout the village of Spring Valley buses are seen driving past young children at high speed who often are alone waiting for other buses to pick them up the gust of wind from the buses

017passing by at high speeds can push a child over potentially into the street into oncoming traffic which I've seen these same buses very often have children riding inside not seated very often children are not seen children are seen standing next to the drivers and are removed from SE from seats when the buses go over bumps or make uh turns at high spe speed you can see kids flying out of their seats Public Safety is at a higher risk due to the to this adct added effect and uh it's on on already uh congested roads most if not all of these buses do not have cameras either do these school bus companies or owners operators give a care about the safety of the public or the safety of the the children riding the buses I I'm

018sick and tired of hearing about accidents and it seem each time there's an accident it's just brushed away nobody hears anything about it I don't want set buses to run over other children or anybody for that matter and cause another accident it need to be really looked at really fast thanks speaker number six um good evening to the board my name is Elizabeth Bruna I am a junior that goes to Spring Valley High School um this is my first ever board meeting while I stand here I ask the qu I ask a question to myself what took me so long to find a seat at a table that is addressing my own education and future um it is time to address how we may fill in the gaps as other districts are progressing I understand

019that we are trying to catch up but we're still very set back um we understand that there's a bigger hand playing this but we fight what but what fight can we lose when we stand together this is not a fight we can just give up give up on because we understand our children education is what is at stake in about a year I I will be graduating from high school I am now understanding how much of a challenge it will be to get into my dream schools because of how how I've been set back I hope the following things I can talk about can later help me get into the colleges of my choice a lot of the seniors have brought to my attention the importance of bringing back SAT prep while other kids were

020given time to prepare for tests um def that tests that are defining their Futures we talk we walk into the same test rooms completely unprepared and blind to what may be in those tests bring me to my other point a lot of courses that have been eliminated due to the lack of teachers there are kids who sit in AP classes not able to keep up with the curriculum letting themselves fall completely behind and just simply don't have the motivation to learn cuz they can't see themselves catching up um I can give an example our AP Chemistry class there that class seats about 30 students I took the class myself and it's a very vigorous course and it simply isn't made for everybody so we need to implement more teachers who with qualifications to put back

021honors classes cuz it simply isn't fair for students to Simply pass by and just get the title of taking an AP class knowing they didn't learn [Applause] anything also there are over 39 AP classes but our school only has 11 due to the lack of teachers again how is this fair to me parents high-ups Guardians siblings just anyone a part of the East rampo Community how much of this are we willing to take there's so much to address of how corrupt things have been things have been and have become we have solo little time to speak but please hear me on some of my points I have brought up we want to carry out our hopes and dreams as students and continue on furthering our education thank you thank [Applause] you speaker number seven uh

022can I whatever yeah uh hello hello my name is Alexis Palencia I serve as the senior class president at rampo senior high school um I wanted to take a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude I know that there are challenges with Denise rampo but over the past year I've witnessed real progress and positive sorry positive change I wanted to extend my thanks to Mr Dar Carlo for the impactful town hall we had this past month where students were able to come to the auditorium and discuss our concerns with our superintendent it was heartwarming to see my peers feel heard and to gain a real hope that change will come thank you for all the challenges sorry thank you for all the progress we've had especially the gym secondly to miss Cooper our new principal at

023rampo senior high school I thank you for your leadership dedication and support as we have been trying to create new change over the past few months however and I say this with I say this kindly and with wholehearted respect these changes have been the bare minimum changes that should have already been implemented and so I ask from my community and my peers let us continue to expect excellence and not back down until we reach set Excellence while I have your attention I'd like to make request from my community there's often a shadow of negativity cast Over East bro but I believe it's time to be focused on the light the light that needs to be recognized and celebrated last week I received the incredible honor of being accepted to Columbia University with the full scholarship

024but this [Applause] achieve um but this achievement was not the result of a single moment it's the culmination of a long challenging Journey filled with many wins wins that I believe deserve to be celebrated wins that that I was able to receive not in spite of my education here at ree rampo but because of it I believe that when I got a scholarship to study at Yale over the summer or when I was flown out to em University this packed October that should have been highlighted and I don't speak only for myself I speak for all the students in East rampo who are accomplishing remarkable things take my friend Mia hernandes who just this past weekend traveled to Rochester for a state competition because of her P placement at nisma competitions the first in a

025very long time take my friend Tiffany Ortiz who just last year received a full scholarship to University or all my friends who have received acceptances to top colleges including Cornell Boston University Princeton and so on these successes are the stories that should be highlighted these are the stories that need to be shared because they represent the resilience talent and potential that Define our community let's shift The Narrative and show the world the greatness that e East rampo is capable of there is light here even if the world refuses to acknowledge it in short I ask that we continue our advocacy for a more Equitable educational landscape but to also recognize the great things that do come at of East rampo let us not forget that at the end of day we are a community that

026needs to be rooted in Unity thank you Alexis just stay there for a second just stay there for a second so a couple of things that I want to share with you first of all congratulations because you and the others that you just mentioned are really the tale of this District you started here in kindergarten okay in your journey to 12th grade so the education that you've gotten here allowed you and the hard work of you and your family please don't dismiss that allows you to achieve one of the biggest accomplishments you can my heart was warmed seeing you last week at the computer watching your face will stay in my mind forever because that says it all we are in the process you can clap we are we are in the process and I

027I'm working with my PR department we're actually going to do a superintendent's corner and highlight all of what you just talked about so I don't want you to think that we're not we are we're definitely going to do that but and I know in my heart you and the others you just mentioned here's what we need you to do you're going to be those role models who are going to go to college and and and get a great education and come back and say you know what if I can do it at East Ramapo you can do it at East Ramapo so thank you so very much we appreciate it thank you thank you congratulations um speaker number eight thank you for giving me the opportunity to address you uh first of all I'm very

028proud of the students of Easter Amo who've uh graduated and uh accepted in the top universities that's that's very very great I'm very happy to see that I am with the southeas Amo taxpayers Association e Amo has two monitors even though only District in New York state who has even though nothing illegal was ever found to be done in ISO they still had monitors they took away our Democratic vote it become taxation without representation it is a dictatorship not a democracy we had our taxes increased four 4.3 38% by false pretenses we were told that there will be a 20 million deficit and now we found that there's a thir over $31 million increase uh we have they found that in the funds which means the monitor had over $51 million mistake if he would

029have been in private practice he would have been fired long ago what I what I want to tell the board now which is very important when they for they're formulating now next year's budget they the way the budget works one one following Year's budget will be based on the previous year's budget in other words that 5.38% increase will be the base and on top of that they will make the new budget being that 4.38% was done by false pretenses it should have never been done they they said that there would be a $2 million loss whereas there was a 31 over $31 million in increase in the funding that the district had they should remember when they formulate next year's budget to take off that 5.38 increase and budgeted from the base which which it

030was supposed to be without having false pretenses thank you so [Music] much thank you speaker number nine uh uh we speak in Spanish so so person Gra [Applause] car for [Applause] we noos thank you [Applause] thank you so just to clarify I just want to correct some false information that was just stated because I'm assuming that probably you were by the meeting where we at this board even when we were facing a proposed deficit and we were proposed a list of cuts that the superintendent the then superintendent together with the state had recommended and us together as a board specifically said we will not allow any cuts to any student facing services so just to correct false information that was just stated I just want to know repeat for the record and there was enough

031people that are currently here that were at that meeting where we specifically said multiple times that we will not allow any student facing Cuts thank you speaker number 10 good evening uh just a uh we were just thinking and talking with another parents and we have a one question so we have the cameras on the okay for another concern resp I was here when we need the money we need the money for the schools that's all I can say it's not just it's not just for for the public school the money is for all the kids because the kids from the private schools they get the money for the public school something's wrong with us okay please ma'am please address the board thank you thank you very much um and that's it and I think

032we are working together we are improving many things we we have to continue working and improving improving and then we're going to see how this year is going to end but I think that things are going better and better and then we start working together so that's good news not all is bad but we need just start working together getting better thank you thank you speaker number nine I'm sorry speaker number 11 hi everyone my name is Jennifer R um I'm currently a junior attending Spring Valley High School having grown up attending schools in E Ramapo I've watched several superintendents make empty promises only to resign having done nothing to help the students I stand here today in hopes that history stops repeating in a world that's so interconnected the ability to communicate is only

033growing in importance how can we truly connect with those around us if we're unable to speak to them though it's an interesting concept to many it's the reality for about 60% of students in our very own schools it's easy to blame the increasing rates of absenteeism and poor academic performance on the students but it's time to question the opportunities they've been given first of all let's look at the facts about 60% of EAS rapo Central School District student body is composed of enl students the majority of which natively speak Spanish and creole if so much of our district is made up of non-english speakers how is it that the majority of our high school teachers are not bilingual we what are we as a district doing to ATT to attract hire and retain qualified bilingual

034teachers how do we expect to improve grades chronic absenteeism and low graduation rates when the majority of students aren't being accommodated these kids sit in class every day entirely unable to understand the instructions the teachers are giving them frustrated many of them become disengaged with school don't participate in class and eventually stop coming to school altogether the language barrier within the EAS rapo Central School District district presents a huge challenge to the academic success of non-english-speaking students by neglecting the needs of these students where we failing to provide Equitable educational opportunities in order to rectify this issue the district must prioritize bilingual education invest in qualified teachers create more courses that prioritize these students and Implement Innovative language learning Technologies by taking these steps the district can ensure that all students regardless of their language

035background have the chance to thrive and reach their full potential it's crucial that we recognize the importance of language access and education and work towards creating a more inclusive and equitable learning environment for all thank you so don't go anywhere so we actually did that tonight so in the second resolution what we've done is we're working with getting you teachers who are qualified to teach you because for far too long that wasn't happening let me explain this to everybody here it is something when I got here and I learned about it that I had no words okay because things don't change things don't change so what we did tonight is so outside the box to try to help you the students you need to understand that okay because we're not going to sit around and

036wait and wait and wait like we've been doing so we're actually going to be getting teachers in front of you starting in January to speak the language and help you get to where you need to get so I I that's an important piece for you and the community and for the students here to understand so thank you I appreciate it thank you and and but and now we go but I want to if you don't mind president Ro but this is where this is important and and one of the parents just mentioned working together that's because I brought this this board of education and explain the importance about it and that's why we weren't here at the beginning of the meeting because we talked about it and the board unan unanimously agreed to do that

037so that's really vitally important very much so thank you very much Dr Mr n Carlo and thank you to all the students that came out hope to see you guys here again it's good to see you guys thank you please don't leave because now I'm going to expl I'm going to talk it's now super now we're going to move on to the superintendent report go ahead Mr this is really important students you weren't here but some of the people were in this audience so about two months ago I explained to the audience and I explained to the Board of Education about Foundation Aid and that there was a report coming out that was asked to be done by the Governor from the Rockefeller Institute to talk about Foundation Aid basically in a a short kind

038of explanation Foundation Aid is monies that the the state gives um to districts okay in regards to state aid if they were to fund it the way it should have been we wouldn't have any discussion ladies and gentlemen because each Ramapo has been short changed over the last 15 years almost $400 million okay so when we talk about advocacy and we talk about things a lot of this advocacy now needs to go and turn around letters need to be written to the governor letters need to be written to the um the representatives because here's what happened the report came out and it said the following it said that the districts that are harmless another quick understanding so there's a lot of wealthy districts in Long Island and in Westchester County that have dropped their populations

039but because of political pressure they didn't have their state aid go down it stayed the same so guess what it said in the report you shouldn't continue to do that those monies should come towards the east rapos of the world okay you shouldn't be getting these monies for seats that are not there they should be going to schools that have a big L population they should be going to schools with poverty and now what does the governor do the next day well I'm not too sure about it this is what I mean about politics and how it drives what happens and how it affects East Ramapo so sometimes we get up here and we're screaming and yelling we need to start screaming and yelling at the state about funding what we should be getting in

040Foundation now I know what I'm saying is not going to go over well with some of my colleagues in the other districts but that's the reality I got to fight for you and the community of East ripo to get what we rightly [Applause] deserve so that's important and I know your principles are here your your advisers are here that's a kind of campaign that you as class presidents that you as parents really have to now say Hey listen East ripo needs its fair share okay because here we go again it's about politics and let's understand something at the end of the day politicians are politicians for a reason okay they always want to continue to get elected but you have to understand you have to see what they do you vote them in but what

041are you doing are you supporting East rapo are you not this is just not for the people that are Representatives here please don't take that and twist it I'm talking about the whole state are you doing things what are best for kids we talk about holding ourselves accountable we have to hold everybody accountable because this is an important piece to the budget because if the monies were there we wouldn't have to worry about it and will you the the the parent that just got up and spoke about we entire Community actually last week I and three of and four of our assistant superintendent met with the leaders of all the nonpublic and yeshivas I is if you were in the room with me the exact palabas that you used I used about we're hos we

042have to work together instead of pointing fingers we're here for the common good of all children and with that being said I explain that I'm we're going to be transparent in the budget because a lot of what we want to do just doesn't impact our kids it impacts the nonpublic when they want additional Services when they need additional counseling we want to know what they need so when I come before this board and you and I show you the budget and why we need more positions why we want to put APS in why we want to put CTE classes why we want to do this but you need money to do that right so that's so important and I wanted to just express that to you because as we go through this budget process this

043is really important and student voice can't just be here tonight it's got to be through the entire process it's your schools it's you it's what you do and I have to tell you everybody in the audience these young men and young women who are in front of you are the classiest most respectful students I've met with them over the last three months in our student circles their advisors are there caring about them and what we're learning and they learning is guess what we have a voice we have a say we're going to be here we're not going away we want to work with you the superintendent we want to work with you the board to do what's best for the students of East fromo so before some of you leave thank you and I just

044want to share that with you so thank you very [Applause] much and and and so you looking at the pillars of um how a budget is developed and I know the gentleman just left um and I'm sorry that he left but I want to make everybody clear we are not rolling over a budget we're not going by what happened in the past we're starting from ground zero and putting a budget together that meets the needs of our students period end of conversation that's the most important piece that everybody needs to understand we're working with our principes we're working with our assistant superintendent we're going to work with the board because we're going to hear what some of your thoughts and concerns are so we're going to present and I will present to you ultimately the

045budget that we feel um meets the needs ultimately of course it's your determination as the board as to how we proceed moving forward but within those pillars you'll see student learning curriculum as you've heard from the students there's a lot of things in that Student Life student expectations social emotional Readiness student outcomes um facilities of course and then community relations um and communication will all be a part of what you'll see in that budget so as we go through um a couple of things on this snow is coming believe it or not probably in the next couple of weeks maybe or the next months just please everybody make sure you have that plan in case we have to close or have an early dismissal um I'll make decisions by 5:30 because we know high schoolers

046you got to get ready and operational we're going to send the notifications out via rooc calls remind district homepage social media you name it we're always going to do it but it's important that you have your Chromebooks ready with you um if we think there's going to be inclement weather and your principles will announce something because we'll be going to remote on some of these days if we use a lot of snow days um so it's an important piece for everybody to understand and this is a guide that's on our website that you can follow um also I'm sorry that was me did I hear that's my ear I'm sorry I thought somebody said something I I just want to remind everybody our Winter concert coming up tomorrow I'll be at Ramapo High School um

047the next day I'll bring at Spring Valley please come out and see all our our Fine Arts perform um and then the following week I'll be at ECC also congratulations to our thespians I was able to attend both the play at uh Ramapo High School Augusta and nobl and then this past weekend I saw too many detectives at the murder Mansion I want to thank um all those who were involved I want to thank the directors I want to thank the students the the the the students behind the scenes in front of the stage and back of the stage it was wonderful and I look very much forward to the uh presentations that are coming up in the spring now here's what it's also important to understand so as was mentioned before and and I

048think this is something that I can only speak about my time here since July 1st with the monitors I can't speak to the past but I can tell you in working with Dr jallow and in working with Mr far um this is a partnership um we work together we try to be proactive and everything that they're doing is in the best interest of our students and the community yes they have a lot of concerns you know why ladies and gentlemen they have concerns because things should have been done along the way that weren't and now we're at the point of where we're at um and and that's why we have this plan because they want to make sure we're moving along on what we need to do um as a school district um so tonight's

049just a quick little overview of some of the work that's been done over the first quarter um we have and I I apologize for tonight because we have both Dr Gonzalez and Mr Shanahan who are not feeling well so I'm going to do the first little overlay and then I'm going to turn it over to um Miss Morales but anyway as a part of the plan we put together really what should be the theory of action which supports our schools whether whether we are in schools that are in good standing whether we are schools that have work to do um what does that look like and what do we need to do and really summarizing this it really is putting together a comprehensive program when it comes to curriculum and instruction when it comes to

050assessment when it comes to um social emotional Readiness for our students when it comes to where's the money going right so when things are happening and we're looking at new programs or programs that we have before are they working how do we know they're working well we have to look at the data and the data will tell us whether we're doing a good job whether we're not doing a good job and what we need one of the other things that's really an important piece to this is collaboration working together with our building principles with our administrators with our our teachers unions because if you don't look at data things don't change if things don't change so there's a big push of accountability on all levels of what's happening in the district so when people talk

051about in the past people have done things nobody knew what was going on I have to be honest with you and it's only fair to the board the board in a lot of ways didn't know either because you don't know what you don't know if you're not told what you don't know does that make sense I know it's a play on words so what we're trying to do in this plan is to be transparent honest open um and create uh an accountability system as we move forward we have quarterly meetings this is the first quarter as we're presenting this to the Board of Education um and then we we're talking about feedback that we're getting um from our staff on what we could do um I talked about Data Tracking um we talked about um

052procedures for a budget and What needs to go into the budget and the why behind it as you'll see over the next couple of months professional development is key here's what's happened on East rapo for a long time you're right no money cut what's the first thing we cut professional development so when we're going to put professional development in we want to do it thoughtfully and over time and that's a big area of concentration that I know that Dr Gonzalez and his team is um is working on the board of education has partaken in two Retreats over the last couple of months the last one we did was on budget and before that was about governance and policy so I don't want anybody to think that the board is not updating itself and educating itself

053on what best practices are in regards to board governance now I'm going to turn it over to M Morales will tell you a little bit about as you mentioned bilingual because that's a big part of who we are as a district Miss Morales thank you Mr De Carlo so some of the other um Partnerships that we have um we have with the arburn you got it thank you which is the regional bilingual education Resource Network we are expanding our Advanced literacies which started two years ago in the the district with um teachers in grades 7 through 12 and we are bringing those down to grades K and three and also 4 and six um I just want to highlight that our first cohort some of the teachers were actually invited to present at the uh

054voices United Conference in New York City um back in October so congratulations to our teachers once again um in addition to this partnership um with the arburn we have also collaborated with Dr aslander from cuni and that is to make sure that we address the needs of our Cy students um those are our students with interrupted formal education or students with inconsistent formal um education as well um so we are working together with the building leaders and the teachers to provide the professional development that's needed to make sure that we can offer the courses to meet the needs of the students um we have some other recommendations that we will provide more updates um during quarter number two um but in addition to this we are also you can go to the next one thank

055you um we are also in conversations to start and transition our transitional bilingual education program to a dual language education program okay for the September 20125 2026 school year um in addition to that um in alignment with all the other departments so um PPS curriculum and instruction multilingual education we are working together to craft a professional development plan that will address of all the curriculum needs in the district um we are also collaborating with um qel which is quality um teaching of of El's and in partnership with them and our court which was the curriculum adopted for bilingual education to further the skills of our teachers so that we can support the students in our classrooms um thank you m Morales and then we're doing and I know some of you are on these all

056the time our family universities have gone over so very well this year um with listening to the public and and I know um we're doing uh we're listening and doing a great job in getting information out to you about a lot of different things in our schools that are happening we just did one about hiring and how we're looking to the community to hire some of these positions that we need to moving forward so um you know I want to thank our team for all the work bobin and his team um for the ongoing community support during our family universities our Bill of Rights are up on our our website um and um we've also uh begun networking with bosis to see where we can work together for commonalities and regionalization and programs that we

057can work back and forth with one another which I know the state is looking at when they're looking at uh joint services and regionalization as we move forward challenges is and you mentioned it here we go teachers shortage we're working on that I explained to you what's happening what we're doing as a district um we struggle also getting subs and permanent subs and Tas and we're looking to um address that as we move forward it's really an area of concern we understand it um we're working with civil service Mr rusco is really doing a good job on trying to work with getting people in and some of our administrative tasks both here at central office and in our buildings um and there's work to but we are working behind the scenes I don't want anybody

058to think we have job postings all over the place we're struggling and a lot of districts are struggling also with getting people but we're working on it and now the business office um and and Eric I know you're going to go over this quickly um but I think it's important for the community to just better understand about the 6.7 million opposed to the 30 million okay thank you so I we we had a presentation um at our last meeting regarding the audited financial statements which showed that there was a $30 million surplus in the budget from the prior year um and there are a lot of reasons uh that went into that including um a very important piece was that $15 million um in salaries were moved from the general fund budget into the SARP

059Grant in June um in in an action that was taken by this board um so that Surplus had that not been done would have only been 15 million what we have been hearing a lot of are um conversations where people are Mis representing that the issues that happened with the Surplus from last year's budget are related to the 6.7 million that was added to the budget uh by the Commissioners raising the tax levy they're two they're two mutually exclusive items that really shouldn't be tied together there are a number of reasons that the Surplus existed um and that includes again the 15 million that I just explained there's also there were there was uh additional monies earned in interest due to higher interest um rates available for the money that's invested during the year by

060the school district and then we also as as um our superintendent was just describing we have significant uh amounts of unfilled positions and those positions are budgeted for in the budget um in two ways the salaries and then also the benefits for those positions so had all of those positions been filled again that Surplus would have shrunk even more um and then uh a few other pieces there were there was some um conservative budgeting in the transportation area um where those dollars weren't spent and then we also had monies in the in the budget for um the anticipated settling of a contract which we did settle tonight so those monies also were accounted for in the budget um and Warren spent and will be spending them in the current year so um just wanted to

061be able to make people understand that the two issues are are separate and different and the dollars that um were added to the budget by The increased tax levy have all been earmarked to uh specifically address the students in our Public Schools uh based on what we were uh told by the commissioner of Education uh into areas that would directly affect them and that they would see during this school year okay so 30 million was last year 6.7 is this year and those dollars have been added into places in the budget uh that will affect our students directly before we get to the end of this school year we don't forget thank you and just quickly um Mr tendle just the um liquidation of the the um arpa Esser funds so we're uh winding down

062the close out of our our three threeyear arpa project uh currently right now we've paid out uh 68 million almost 69 million as of November 20th on this uh resolution tonight there'll be more change orders that it's already worked on uh as we move closer to that $90 million work the bulk of our work really uh left is we have a handicap lift at Spring Valley and we have window that'll be wrapping up at Summit Park and starting at Hemstead uh this December um outside of that all the remaining work is about um punch list items if you don't know what a punch list item is it's all right uh contractors did work we came back in and said this isn't done exactly the way we wanted it please fix it they come back they

063fix it um so that that piece of work does take time um weeks uh months if they have to to order more materials so that's really the remaining work but outside of that we accomplished a lot of work over a lot of time um and as our Architects come up here and told before this is the largest arpa construction project anywhere in the state that we pulled off so and Matt thank you and all the work that you and the team um did um as the students mentioned they can they can see it in a lot of areas it's a beginning it's a good beginning so I I thank you and your team and I just want to turn one second I have a question um Matt just really quick I know one of the

064students came up talking about the nurses office um how it needed renovation and the pipes was showing in the walls are we perhaps going to do something about that or address that problem yeah um I've already re uh the administration already reached out to me about that what I'm trying to do is get the timelines um I don't like to do a half response so I want to give the exact information I'll work with uh Miss Rog Cooper about that great so that's situation is being addressed yep awesome thank you so um before we move on just a recommendation from what I've witness um thank you for all the work that you're doing with facilities uh you know it's really making a difference in all our buildings um what I did notice is that with

065the work that's being done currently at Spring Valley High School um it's being done right after school while students are still in the building um I know there was an incident last week where during the scage while we had nyak at um Spring Valley High School the fire alarm went off and they had to evacuate the school you know for precautions of course um but maybe if that can be communicated with the principles and also whoever is going to be um at the buildings after school so they know where the work is being done so that students are not um either in the building or in that hallway Wing um that would be it's it's kind of a a two-fold thing if I did that I'd never get the work done because high schools stay

066open till 6 7:00 at night so so that the issue becomes they already did a lot of that work moving around certain programs and now it's kind of like listen we got to get some of that work done I already talked to the principal at Spring Valley uh we already put a plan in place to make sure the uh alarm situation doesn't happen again um so that's being addressed um but yeah we're kind of in the final ask for the work to be y of work correct just for there to be a plan in place so that everyone is aware of what's going on when it's going on that's yeah that's all yep question are we taking the fire alarm offline when we work so some of the work involves Bondo and grinding of the

067metal um and the paint is actually being applied through a sprayer so we have to do take we have to take the alarm off what happened was when it um got taken off during the uh at the start they set for an hour's time frame and it just happened to come back on um so we're just making sure we take it off for the the period of the work for the contractors they usually give a four and an8 hour period on the when they take it offline uh yeah so so T sometimes we we had that happen where the work extended longer than what they originally said so sometimes the contractors don't always um accurately State their work for the night and do we have a fire watch who takes fir watch uh that would

068be uh our custodial staff our custodial staff at night is the largest custodial staff because all the cleaning's done at night so then our custodial staff act as the firew watch and another question I saw on the chart before about the ARA funds we used up about 70 million what's with the other 20 are we losing it is it being used up what's the story with that I don't know who to address that question though so we filed a Amendment um with the state to use what we saw at has uh leftover monies um we included on that um additional monies for our athletic fields um and we included Paving and we also in that's what we're doing the additional water fountains with so what we did was we saw that we were going to

069have a savings and money that wasn't earmarked we pivoted right in September Mr Stark I believe right around September um we filed that with the state we got approve for that to swing that money towards those areas so we're also doing the the weight room renovation with that the new dance studio at Spring Valley fix that floor um actually make a baseball stadium at Ramapo High School actually make a softball stadium at um uh Spring Valley High School rebuild the batting cages things that have been neglected over a decade we're trying to make right with uh remainder shift of these funds I'm very happy to have because we were all at the understanding that whatever we haven't used in September was lost so in terms of that the the federal government offered to the states

070and then the state offered it to the school districts in uh the state of New York uh to fill out something called a late liquidation request we um filed that along with the amendment to allow us to do the work that Matt was describing um we have been approved for the late liquidation request um that currently sits with the federal government um they have to give the final approval but we've been approved by the state we're awaiting that approval from the federal government and that will extend that period through December 31st of 2025 and we should have no problem um spending the rest of what was uh granted to East actually okay I'm sorry just curious you mentioned that uh East Ram was this arpa funds was one of the biggest um Construction in the

071in the state how was that that East ramp was was so fortunate with the biggest I think part of it was the relationship the architect had with s some of the Consultants that were brought in um Mr Carl turnow for one who used to run the office of facilities planning for over 20 years and it was I believe those relationships um that that were brought in um and the straightforward and the plan that they presented is why I was talking about the dollar amount is the dollar amount yes so that plan involv involve the dollar amount so that all that construction they already had those numbers figured out when you submit a project to S you submit a worksheet and all that worksheet has estimated values broken out to it so originally the submission was

072almost I believe 1220 million in construction the state was like really three years and so a little haggling back and forth of can you realistically do this cuz it it included I would say included windows for every every building uh HVAC for every building and when they pulled it back they were like you that's a little over ambitious so they cut it back down and basically were able to get it done so if there we'd probably still with those added projects probably have another two years of construction if we were to if that stayed on that we wouldn't know we would have funding for okay thank you Mr Tindall thank you Mr Dar Carlo I believe we're done um and thank you I'm sorry one second thank you Mr for the great job you've been

073doing with the buildings and thanks to this board for supporting the students and supporting the facilities and making sure that all these projects get done so good job um I'm sorry vice president Migel yeah just real quick uh Mr De Carlo the um December 18th I know you're doing a virtual town hall with the students at Spring Valley is that going to be in person like Grand yeah that's a great question so what's going to happen is this students are going to we're going to be in an area um where they're going to ask me questions but in conversations with um Mr Carlson what we're going to do is actually stream it into every single classroom so everybody will get to see it because it's hard we don't have enough space to get everybody in

074one big area so we're going to stream it into the classrooms so it's virtual it's virtual um but there'll be an there'll be a section where there'll be the students asking me questions um but it'll be going into the classrooms did I get that correct yeah I thought so just wanted to make sure I'm looking at you but thank you I have a question that concludes I have a question for Mr Dalo and Mr Stark um schools have been trying to contact the administration for transportation matters and they're not getting either responses by email or by return phone calls what which route should really be taken that they should get responses uh it's been my understanding that uh the the inquiries have been responded to again uh I've mentioned this in the past if there

075are any uh uh schools that have concerns regarding that they should contact me directly if they're not having emails um going back September October beginning of November still not answered uh again if if they have not been answered by transportation department um then they should have them sent directly to me and I'll make sure well I believe um you were you were CCD on all of those that's question number one question number two on November 8 19 we had a transportation committee meeting uh I don't think anything materialized from that committee meeting several emails were sent and no responses uh my understanding from our director uh well the uh the business director who is uh working directly with Transportation was that um she had given a response but I'll have to double check on that

076and uh if that was not the case I'll I'll make sure that a response is is sent have you seen any responses you were you were CC together in the emails I I do not recall uh on that particular email I have it's wasn't one particular large email quite a few was there another question I think what Mr feder was saying about for tonight was that respond about responding to to the emails and to the transportation inquiries because there are some frustrations that some things are not getting answered some emails I'll again I'll meet with uh relle tomorrow to to review all of those and make sure that uh they're address and then we'll have a response for you president Rose will'll send you the response okay um well should the response should go to

077the schools I don't need to response I don't need to be involved just that we're following up as you as a board president as a courtesy so you know what we're doing based on what trusty feder said which we're clearly will follow up with right thank you okay great um okay moving on to consent and agenda items do I have a motion for consent and agenda items 1 through 10 oh Mr w m moves the motion do I have a second second I'm sorry who it was Mr kth I think second man Mr kth will open up for discussion VI president yes I I would like I know this is a personel item um Roman numeral 8 about appointments Athletics 2024 to 202 5 um so I I have questions about it and I know

078I can't do it out here because it is p a Personnel item so I would like to be able to discuss it maybe in um executive session if you may give me that opportunity thank you vice president just out of just uh we did do the exec before can we find out if this specific item is time sensitive perhaps we can pull that one until next meeting you can have like this we can address it just out of the interest of time um that's fine with me that work um can anybody look into what vice president Migel was saying and which item is it number three and item what what was it R numeral eight R numeral eight so perhaps we can pull that was it a point was that section Section 8 of certificated

079you're talking about removing yeah number three and it's um eight appointments the entire entire Section 8 let me just pull it up again this one if we can't wait I guess we can we can go into exec again I mean if if the board agrees I'm okay with that uh or we can just or theity sake are we speaking about one specific individual that's on that so I I have better understanding is it the a specific individual I'm not mentioning the name with regards to discussion around that individual right okay if I can a point of information as um Mr Gart had pointed out at the previous meeting that you can still put it to vote and if five or more people vote to accept it it's passed and those who um are unhappy with

080a certain section can say they vote nay to that section which is what we did last meeting I understand what we did last meeting but if a you know trustee I have a concern I just have a question um I really can't say much because again it's personal item that I would like to ask our superintendent in regards to the situation and I think it's important that we should be able to be given that in that um opportunity that's all so I would just add to that your options are so no I think I I I guess what I'm incing is not it's a specific individual that's in question so I guess the question to the attorney is can everything else be accepted with the with the question of one individual to then be discussed

081in executive session possibly at a next executive session yes if you want to remove three Roman numeral 8 which is what we're talking about right the appointments Athletics 2425 if you want to remove that as a set aside you can still vote on the remaining consent agenda and then that that item would be removed and either discussed at your exec session next meeting or go back into exec at this meeting May I just for clarity is um is the suggestion to remove the resignation uh but not the appointment because there's two action items here one is a resignation and one is an appointment I think the question on the table is about the resignation I don't think it's about the appointment correct the appointment correct thank you okay okay so can we remove the reg

082resignation from is that you yeah okay we don't accept if we don't accept the resignation they can't resign what's the what's the purpose of voting on it m Mr guber I I don't even think I can discuss it out here I'm just asking wise no he he's just asking what happens procedure wise what happens if someone resigns and we don't accept the resignation is that what you're saying we shouldn't accept it until next meeting yeah so in general if you have someone who resigns and then you don't you don't have to act on it prior to their resignation necessarily so failing to act on that doesn't prevent the person from resigning you would just act on it at the next meeting I don't know the resignation letter I don't know what dates we're talking about

083but the date they say is 11:26 we do not have a meeting the qu I think the question being asked is about the actual action itself to further get a clarification as to the why behind it I think that to your point the resignation can the person has a right to but I think the question for an executive session and I don't want to speak for for vice president Miguel but I think that's what she's asking is the why behind it and that would be appropriate executive session topic and I would Reserve that corre I would set this aside for your next meeting correct there you go okay so let's do we have any opposition to tabling the item that vice president McGill requested until the next meeting so we don't have to go back

084and take Zach just that an interest of time because I I have to be home already so I've marked down Section 8 just the resignation is tabled till next meeting agreed okay yeah okay if if the board votes we need to vote I think we all okay well we'll amend the motion for items 1 through 10 minus three Roman numeral 8 resignation only correct resignation only Fe do you amend the motion and Mr coth I will second because Mr cth left already okay any further discussion on the items 1 through 10 hearing none all those in favor say I anyone opposed OB same motion carries moving on to action items I will now make a motion for Action items is one through 30 do I have a second second M Mr grber will open up

085for discussion yes um action item number two um I just hope for I just wish that um I had well we all had the opportunity to see exactly what was changed um in each um part of the policy because there was different ones um one was use of school district facilities so on and so forth so just to be able to see what was changed or what was amended would be very helpful when voting on changing something in the policy is there a particular policy you referring to or to all of them um yes um miss kiby it was 1500r use of school district facilities um there was a couple of word the wording and some of it I wasn't clear on and I and also after looking at it wasn't sure exactly what was

086amended you might recall when you were on the committee last year and the committee spent a lot of time on these policies and regulations that the last time the uh um let me get the right number here the 1500 R and the E the E is the fees last time they were updated I believe was 2006 so they're totally different totally different the world is different today the district is different our financial position is different so I think Mr tindel if we had done tracking changes on those particular things with facility fees everything would have been read and then everything that you see now would have been added honestly um it is so different from what it was yeah it was it's a it it was completely gutted uh we had it was a very

087um cumbersome process to figure out billing um we kind of simplified part of it there was separate billing for heating and cooling well we're at New York State School District we heat 10 months out of the year so why do we have a separate fee schedule for any of that so we went with the lower fee schedule which is the heating um and we just made it one fee schedule we also added additional things because as our state M got upgraded and things like that those lights cost a lot of money to put on so if groups want to come in at night to use those facilities and have us put those lights on those are things that every other school district in this County charges outside organizations for Mr Matthew I'm clear I've just

088you know would like to have seen the what was amended I I I just would like to see okay this is what it was compared to what it has been amended to and I think that's fair it's a request I agree I I because you can't tell yeah we can I I could I could ultimately just show what the original one was because that's um I mean the red line like uh Miss Ki said the little the it would just all be read we can certainly do that it would come back for uh next meeting at second reading and um I can work with Mr Tindell we can get that we'll put that up there but I'm I honestly telling you almost everything in that old policy basically was deleted and then started to bring

089it up to date but we can do that and um we can probably make sure that it's up in board dos for more than a week before the J January 7th meeting so that would give you lots of time to look at it before January 7th meeting this I won't give you an exact date because you know there's a small matters of Christmas and Hanukkah that coming but pretty sure we could do it with at least up there one week in advance of the meeting for you and for all board members thank you so when I send an email out go to board docks and you can see it thank you that'll be good all right okay okay okay hearing no further discussion all those in favor say I I anyone oppos obain motion carries

090information and reports from the board Mr President um yes I just uh wanted to say um I don't know if you all know but um I would like to you know give honor where honors do and congratulate the um there's you know the Ramapo Spring Valley Football League um which is in my opinion a feto program for East rampo Central School District that has been around for well over 50 years um they had um basically they had three team that were Metro North Champions and two of those teams have advanced to the American Youth football national championship games in Florida and they're there as I speak and I just want to you know say to them you know congratulations because again they're serving our our children here in this District thank you what age levels

091if you don't like oh gosh um 8 you 12 you and 14 you so you're talking about kids that yes keeping them off the streets right and keeping them occupied so it's a good thing and the last thing that I do want to mention um and the one of the young ladies was here this evening it was great to be able to attend the um annual Rockland Bose annual service guide dinner um where some of our students attended um and I think it's great to have that opportunity to learn various trades like culinary um nursing they also have you know like um if you want to become a beautician so I think it's great a great opportunity for our students here in East Ramapo there was a few of us this year hopefully next year

092there'll be more um but you know I thought it was I thought it was a great event thank you thank you president Rose thank you vice president Miguel and congratulations to the football team yeah I appreciate that and the good luck in Florida okay moving on to written Communications since last voting board meeting the board has not received written Communications I will now make a motion to adjourn this meeting to have a second second by the board all all those in favor say oh I'm sorry I did miss the future meeting thank you trustee grber much appreciated a regular meeting is scheduled for January 7th 2025 beginning at 7:30 p.m. in the plcc room in Administrative Building at 105 South Madison Avy Spring Valley New York before we adjourn this meeting I i' like to

093wish all the staff students parents a very happy holidays and a Happy New Year we will now adjourn this meeting all those in favor say I anyone oppos abstain motion carries thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.