001good evening everyone and welcome to the audit committee work session and budget work session of the East Rockway Board of Education I'd like to call this meeting to order at 6:01 pm on Tuesday February 4th 2025 can we please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Pledge of aliance to the flag of the United States of Amer stand One Nation Under godible over yeah so uh how are you guys on Rich you ready so we're gonna have uh Rich presentent from risk management he's going to give us an update on the audit committee here so J did how you doing just introduce myself partner with the firm I've been with the firm 25 years we're located in for station York years ago we are specialized in governmental Audits and County um we have about 80 School
00245 the external and 27 school districts there's four Partners involved in the uh audits of internal audits five that do uh Municipal accounting and then three that are really into the tax side of the business rich is our director he's been with us since 2006 2007 he's an expert in in this area and we we're very happy that um so tonight we're going to talk about two engagements we have two uh different engagements for you which is the risk assessment update and the detailed test day we met with the committee almost a year ago today back in February February 6 2024 to discuss the draft uh risk assessment update report and the selected area of the det testing so for this year we tested the purchasing and dispersement area and we also did an update
003to rest good evening so as mentioned right the internal order encompasses two types of engagements each year with the school districts detail testing as it says detail testing know do some sample selections dive deeper into a particular area uh the meeting last year when we met we to go to a risk assess update report Bo is when we just determin the different I guess areas where we probably find kind of the best value in terms of what area to look at from standpoint is it an area we haven't looked at yet is it an area where there been some changes might be reason to look into an area uh so the purchasing dispersements at the to was a selected area for detail review for that report here we had a chance to to look through
004with all of our reports we go through we start off with a preliminary draft report that we V that with Administration just Ure that the accuracy correctness of the different findings that we have findings uh Encompass you could be good controls references to board policies or protocols that in place related to that respective area or there maybe if there's opportunities for improvements or enhancements we have corresponding recommendation so the detailed testing report go to that one first that was the first the engagement perform first and that they're purchasing and dispersements area itself is complexities involved in terms of various components you have various different laws and regulations that can dictate how governmental entity should procure their services or Goods through the general Municipal laws that's out there as well that has certain thresholds that are
005used for when districts need to go out for bids uh and then you have uh below the bids districts should have policies that speak to how many quotes what types of quotes written um verbal quotes and have those all of documentations should be included as part of your requisition process right so another complexity is you have numerous requisitions those are people who kind of help with requestors usually department heads and support staff that will set up and create requisitions request for you know goods and services one thing the governments have too which is additional controls over expenditures you have budgets as you speaking about tonight right so that also kind of helps control in terms of the spending that takes place within the wind within the financial system itself you also have it's a robot
006system that designs and sets up district prepars and puts in place requisition or approval routing so you have the proper approvals by respective directors or managers uh overseeing those particular budget cap votes and then you have your purchasing agent districts you know you know you have only one purchasing agent the one that's lawfully allowed to actually procure and enter into and create a purchase order so that's kind of the problem and then the other key thing that we talk to and meet with people is the receiving end I you kind of have your requisition your purchasing and then on the receiving it in terms of receiving the services or Goods key controls there ensuring it in sign offs that the goods or services have been procured as as requested whether it be you know certain
007type of end results whether it be reports or actual Goods or products and then sign offs to then allow inform the accounts payable department to now move forward with the the payment kind of look at purchase purching dispersement cycle full cycle uh so the major work that is involved with the purchasing dispersement review is reviewing a number quite a few uh gu purchases you know expenditures with various vendors we categorize them as how we structure as you see in the report gion letter SC work that talks to steps and what proed follow and the other main part of this detail testing engagement was to interview requisitioners throughout the district so this is one of those types of I guess internal order engagements where we get out to uh various departments and the different schools which
008periodically I think it's a good thing uh to do that get an opportunity for us to kind of meet and obtain any information where there might be some feedback or thoughts for opportunities for enhancements or improvements from your requisitioners or your employees and bring those also to uh into in terms of the report so uh so report hasn't mentioned the format of the detailed testing report is similar to previous formats got some introduction information background information just speak about in terms of the complexi laws regulations that speak to the various components of purchasing then the scope of work that we have which should be the procedures page four and as I mentioned that's the engagement work that we put together follow our interviews and testing then the finds Rel to each of those procedures the
009corresponding findings as mentioned they vary in terms of information references to various board policies or if there opportunties or fin improvements and enhancements as a result then we had recommendations we have identified 10 recommendations in terms of enh Improvement some of their process procedures which end up being the result of of the interviews fting that perform example assigning a separate person from the vendor payment process to maintain your vendor Master files this good internal control segregation um then continue here and some of our recommendations might be efficiency based so in terms of process and procedures where you might be able to utilize electronic and place of hard copy you a lot of districts are moving in that direction from efficiencies also number two is make consider as may move to electronic vendor W9 forms hard
010copy and number three current practice you're doing and the mon monthly bues invoices requiring various administrators to review their Coast their respective piece of the B which is that itself is sizable Bill both extends a bill for the entire services that they provide for a district so the district needs to kind of kind of you know parse out those respective pieces to the respective uh department heads their and uh efficiency number four is efficiency base considering moving towards electronic AC payments for vendors lot of districts now moving in that direction uh efficiencies in terms of now rather than processing creating a check that has to be mailed and sent it's electronic and also reduces potential for any unpaid uh unpaid or unclaimed checks that you have to follow up as part of your pay and
011number five determin functionality exist looking at wind cap in that data to see might be able to import of the data between those created uh to create from the data to do that and then number six improve process during efforts to create POS and consider confirming claim order reports that's basically where goods or services have ordered um and will receive before a purchase controls is always Ure that you have the purchase in place unless there's true emergency kind exception scenarios where it's an emergency lot of times it comes with like Plumbing or heating or those types of scenarios that dis May count number seven contining with uring vended payments timely and in some instances it might be a vendor reason for delay maybe they wa get the invoice to the district or maybe it's waiting
012on certain other items to be delivered or just you make notations it's kind then looking at aligning practice and procedure so we'll do some policies and procedures in place related to the are weevie we look practices are and if there's any disconnect between those lines either looking at and up the policy or the district's practice to be align then uh number nine is similar again it's the Po's in advance on the payment side this is related to we also did some testing reimbursements travel expenses and then attend approvals to attend conf properly documented documentation so a couple of findings we had found district end clearing by providing some documentation subi which is questions on that puring dispersements report no no and then uh second Eng that was perform is the annual risk assessment update similar
013format to our prev reports just some introduction speaks about the internal AIT processing the procedures uh in terms of internal controls control risks I just want to highlight on page three for this risk assessment update we're looking at open recommendations from previous risk assessment report February open is bring in and look at recommendations from a a detailed testing that we uh with addition test kind to work on so in this case it would be the resources uh review and detail testing that would be included in in this report and then the status of whether recommendations have open or have been closed is is part of that process during our risk assessment during interviews administrators and staff related to page four and five it's kind of the table business process areas that's where cover some conversations
014discussions talk about key changes in addition to if there are any open recommendations to follow up on what have impacts might have been in terms of any of those changes new laws regulations workpl violence something that was new here as well at District sex put some things in place including training doing risk assessment as well as the board policy so we would do is follow up in terms of compliance on anything that might be dos legislative then we also highlight on here where when we perform some detail testing in the prior area as not as well what we'll do is we'll kind of you know rever back to this they we have to go through the report we talk about and discuss you know areas for proposed testing for next year and as part of
015our interviews we identifi I mentioned any key changes uh and anything that we find brought into the report as well as I mentioned uh there's a number of changes both the board level and uh and in wise as noted you kind of talk about that you know meet with people and talk about the Transitions and stuff that have taken place there new new policies as mention Place violence any financial information well statement or other documents see and also following up as human resources it areas distri addressing some of those recommendations in those areas as well so new uh so key changes go through page and obervations or recommendations couple board policy Left Right signatures recommend considering vising to align with the authorized approvals that are part of your annual reor first one second one is
016is um looking at and recommending to establish procedures to document and track outstanding any outstanding checks those the unclaimed funds as part as the compliance uh State 21 ref to you know track and monitor and period of six years that you have an obligation and then Bank rex u just looking at clearing out and reconciling and any open recommendations District um still needs to or has started addressing page eight through Page 11 and then we get into close recommend closed items various reports but there's a few a number of Human Resources uh recommend that have been Dred and closed out and that was and good work there on the district in terms of that stuff this the first time followed up on those particular recommendations that report and then there's further uh closing out of
017items in information technology which was an area that had a few years of turnover there with the directors now you have someone now kind of established there and started addressing and working on those recommendations once they came on board some close SIDS last year and further further work there and I expect the couple recommendations CL out risk assessment update disc coming here question I just on this I'm Waring on on the table that has low medium and high risk the med mediums are just always mediums or can they be moved to low but they're just you know they're just always going to be medium because of the nature of what they are good question so what we generally do is U they medium if we do if we're not performing any testing on that particular
018area so you'll see where we've got it dat of detail Tes we've um part of that testing where we're ensuring that what we understand the controls and processes in place are in fact in place and kind of working as design in terms of mitigating risk from good oversight reviews uh and also ensuring compliance with any laws of District protocols and then we have any suggestions or recommendations a district has closed out address uh the majority of those recommendations those reports from Moder to okay so if there's no date you've you've not done your company has not done a detailed testing of that area so then maybe you do that next year kind of a discussion of know looking at what area you know talk about have conversations with Administration for tonight's meeting as well to
019you know my thoughts as well as the thoughts of Mike and administrators terms of what we think is probably best the kind of the best value of of an area to look at and given you know we see that there's still you know a number of areas that have not been I Look To Go those areas generally look for an area that has quite a bit of dollar amount budget wise activity or just just in general just the activity itself within within those process procedures so the suggestion and consideration is financial operations relation anen area that has again as I mentioned uh did usually sies will cter the budget many districts are experiencing increasing cost to their service both not only From perspective but even just the services standpoint as well terms of students meeting
020Services additional services so then in terms of and we we look at Finance operations meaning that we'll look at you know the budgets but how they managing the services that are required for the I check and look at that ensuring that that's necessary there's also some Aid that that's attached special education for high Aid that you District um at those scenarios we don't get into whether or not the services seem appropriate for students that's say I put on the financial thought B to see what they doing to track and monitor you have the three main budget lines bosies have related Services providers that are included within the budget so procedes and kind of enery knows and placements right student placement so uh it's another one of those areas too you like to see good coordination
021between the business office and that department go of all these various activities that take place and it's challenging to B your monitor this constant changes as well lot of moving Parts there so that's kind of suggestion of an area we haven't done detail testing yet in that area so last cycle the the the the discussion was around do we focus on purchasing this for this detailed testing cycle or on the special education side the decis was made in collaboration the recommendation was made in collaboration with internal audit to choose purchasing because it's districtwide and I was brand new in my role the business office had seen a lot of retirements so it felt like a good opportunity to take a fresh look um with that being said special education and grants is equally as important
022um it's an area we should certainly consider for the future for having a detailed testing gonna ask you about that um it's purchasing is more special where we really get our our value from internal audit for doing a full review of our special ed Financial operations is what type of opportunities do we have to be getting more stackable Aid um excess cost Aid private access Aid Etc um there may be some improvements we can make in our processes there that we can organically without doing anything else bring more Revenue back into the district from State perspective and like by doing that it's just something that we go back in look at the what we have and then trying to see how we can work it to benefit our students uh they would so I mean
023I don't want to speak for um for rich in internal audit but they would design a detailed testing plan which I would imagine would be focused heavily on some of our procedures to identify and Report special special education services in accordance with um the uh the ve it's very complicated special there's a lot of different opportunities and different rules related to different Services um and placements to determine whether you're aable or not so I I would imagine a large portion of that detail testing would be focused on that making sure that we're doing maximizing that that would be it the maximizing yes you know all the potentials and everything that we could get it'll touch upon policies procedures as well making sure our policies and procedures in special education are up to date so like
024my daughter you're welcome so my daughter does medical billing and she does a procedure and they can bill it like eight different ways so she builds it and gets the maximum insurance payout from the insurance company is that something similar you're talking about we do something for the special ed child and you could you could look at it five different ways and get reimbursed from the state make maximize it's not quite the same yeah all right I don't want to go off on a tent but just like high level yeah depending upon what the service is some could be 100% aable some could be only that's what you're just checking only a portion over kind of like a deductible a district deductible is able okay little more defined districts in terms of how they track
025St accountability children we look at to maximize it okay High CL St students right and then what procedures are you have IND District programs you know just more involved in terms of trying to calculate and determine SCH students versus oces or placements more defined in terms of what is your basically what does it cost for that student to you know to attend that b program or that other you know uh approved facility so Serv pieces will have an impact on financial I just have another question as far as uh grants with special Aid and everything else um they change from year to year obviously uh depending like they try to keep them for a certain amount of time but is it something that's constantly changing so it's something that we have to constantly look at
026on the grant side too in a lot of districts there there's uh you have also part of you have a single ORD required for school districts that threshold has is changed October 1st 2024 it changed from 750 million to 750,000 to 1 million um typical grants that you'll see for the schools is like Title One um 11619 um title three there's a series that that pretty much a lot of districts will get the allocation to those grants will fluctuate they're pretty solid that you're get those every year Al I know that's a big conversation out there right now about funding Federal FAL Federal funding ASO came out and they backed off of that um but the grant money that's kind of gone away is all that Co pay money that pretty much has ended at
027this point so it would just be whether or not you something else happens in the future um you know if you remember back in well back in 2008 with with that uh the crash and all of that um they came out with ARA funds right so that was another funding back you know a while back around 2009 I think that came out to help support schools and make sure that they have the funding that they need um but that was only like a short term so so some grants pretty much there all the time and then there's some that will pop upate kind issues where we we're small so none of our grants really as have gotten to that level where they're over the thresholds that trigger an automatic but we still do a sing
028audit over um we're still required to have a single audit be performed just the scope of it is not usually as big as if we were a bigger District okay um that's good if you come from a bigger District most of your grants are going to be over that threshold and just included in that threshold would be your so get some federal dollars from that whether noted but now it's going up to a million we're doing okay okay 450 okay thank you for explaining it's so what just now now they kind of you know used up and had the money coming in Co monies threshold going up right now back to more districts now falling underneath the radar and requirement to have a single yeah know most districts needed it was Co money push them
029over that was 750 yeah so Chang thank you anyone else I'm good all right right Rich Jen thank you so much for coming hopefully hopefully it doesn't take you too long to get home thanks so much you all right see you guys soon you need me to all right uh moving on we have y um okay so it's it's old business but we'll just do the uh yeah we don't have any old business we'll just move right to the budget development presentation all right so now we're gonna Mr van W's going to do the uh budget presentation so work session number one I can't believe to back here um today I'm going to cover just some overview of our budget development process uh I'll talk a little bit about the Rockefeller Institute report recommendations that
030came out for changes to Foundation I won't spend too much time on that because most of the recommendations in that report not make its way into the governor's we'll talk about the actual Governor's executive budget proposal for fiscal year 26 talk about some of our Revenue sources and opportunities for the budget for the upcoming year um I'll give a little bit of information based upon all the work we've done on the budget today on some positives and some head wins that we're facing in the future and then I'll just I'll end the uh the work session today with the tax levy cap forecast based upon all the information that we have today which we're still missing some uh but we have a pretty good idea of what the tax levy cap will be for 25.6
031so when we when we build the school budget um we have a couple of objectives we want to make sure our budget is educationally sound transparent phisically responsible uh we're always striving to maintain our existing programs and when opportunities arrive provide enhancement to meet the emerging needs of our students um our budget supports the health and safety learning environment of our for our staff and our students and our budget is always aligned with our five-year strategic plan and the four pillars of opportunity achievement connection and Innovation before I get into the 2526 um budget cycle just want to highlight some of the uh things that we did with 2425 budget so we made some significant building and Technology Capital Improvements to our district uh we had our tech building ceiling installation and tile project wrapped
032up over the course of this past year we just completed the high school surveillance camera and door lockdown project this week so we have state-of-the-art cameras across our high school and Junior High School um we did a number of Technology projects districtwide this past year we upgrated all of our network access points um so our students and our staff now have state-of-the-art Broadband access and all of our locations in the building we updated all of our classroom PCS districtwide with up to- dat computers and we are in the process of wrapping up our phone system upgrade project districtwide as well um from a staffing perspective we added quite a few PP staff this past year to meet some of the emerging needs of our students we brought an in-house occupational therapist on board um we've
033added an additional full-time speech teacher and this past year we were proud to announce the introduction of a new 612 special education class for r Avenue Elementary School just a couple other highlights this past year we were really proud of it we were able to fill all of our prek seats allocated To Us by the state um we've continued our districtwide technology and classroom enhancements including purchasing state-of-the-art technology for our students our one-1 chome initiative upgrading classroom smartboards and investments in flexible furnitures in all of our buildings um and last but not least some of the technology other technology improv is we've rolled out the parents Square communication tool to our community as well as looking to roll out a magic school a artificial intelligence instructional tool over the course of the next couple months
034which more to come on there oh and I would be remissed not to mention that we also had the energy performance contract um enement starting this summer of 2025 which we're so happy that the community supported that initiative just to give you a perspective on what the budget development cycle looks like we actually start working for the 2526 budget in November December so if you think about it we're really projecting expenses that could occur 18 months in the future um the budget process starts with the distribution of our guid lines from my office to our building our budget Builders who work on their individual budgets which get submitted back to my office in the December time frame while that's going on I'm working on salary projections um retirement system contribution projections uh projecting out other
035costs for the district centrally and then January time frame we usually meet with all of our budget Builders to refine their budgets um and review our staffing needs so that's kind of where we are today um what we have going on the rest of this month is we're going to be reviewing our staffing needs for next year um considering any enhancements for the budget for next year uh considering whether we want to propose any additional capital or technology projects using some of our Capital reserves or other funding streams and then finalizing the budget initial draft of the budget for submission to superintendent of schools March we have to file our tax levy limit calculation on the 1 the budget gets submitted final budget draft gets submitted to the board of education for their review and
036consideration our next budget session will be a March 4th have more robust detailed line item review of all budget across all of our budget codes um and we'll make final decisions on any voter propositions that would be need to be added to the ballot for next for this upcoming day budget hearing will be occurring um in the uh I'm sorry excuse me on April 23rd and sorry March 13th and then the budget vote this year is scheduled for May 20th 2025 so this just gives you a perspective of what actually goes into a school budget as you would imagine our product is our staff teachers in our classrooms our support St um from our custodial through our teacher aids through our monitors through our administrative team 75% of our school budget is for the employee
037salaries and benefits I'm just give you a perspective on what that is so we have a $45.2 million budget for this year 24.3 million of that is is um is salaries that doesn't take into consideration insurance cost um pension system cost the district other insurance that we pay on behalf of our our staff um based upon the current uh the current projections of our stepping from today factoring in collec bargain agreements that we have settled this past year and and anticipate to settle over the course of the next couple months our projected salaries for 2526 are going to be $25.2 million so that assumes no changes from status quo there's no retirements there no additions to our staff projected increase of about $900,000 um the other portion of our budget for for that that makes
038up our budget is our contractual expenses which covers things like the cost of Transportation Services security Insurance utilities tuition um our final Auditors who were here earlier today they want to be paid also um and then any goods or services paid through aose contract and then we have a couple other items that we pay for also Material supplies and textbooks equipment at service inter fund transits Etc but the majority of what we spend is salaries benefits and those contractual expenses so this is what our budget looked like last year 4 5.28 million across the administrative program and capital portion of our budget this is how we paid for it last year state aid made up about 20% of our budget $9.0 million what we budgeted last year Pilots is a payment in Le of taxes
039so uh if there's a local business that negotiates with the uh with the nassa county ibaa they may get a tax break up front and come up with a separate arrangement for how they're going to pay the school district for the cost of their real estate that's what pilot is majority of our pilot gets paid for Lia who have Power Authority local sources that's uh tuition we may charge for out of District students um charges we may uh Levy for the use of our facilities interest that we generate off of our cash Holdings last year we budgeted about $664,000 of local sources course the general operating budget appropriated fund balance and restricted reserves you can view those as being our savings accounts so this is funding that was generated from having a budget that was
040that came in from previous years coming in under budget so that money if you're coming in under budget that money needs to be put somewhere it can be put into a restricted Reserve or can be appropriated to the next school years budget to reduce the burden on the taxpayer um and then finally and most importantly the property tax levy funds approximately 73.7% of our budget in um state aid is made up of two different components you have Foundation Aid which is a purely formula based amount of Aid that comes from the state and then there's another portion of state aid that we receive which is usually referred to as expense based Aid so it's generated based upon what you did in a previous year or previous years for example Transportation costs we get a certain
041percentage of those costs back in the following year it's very much event driven so if we don't have a bus transporting on a particular year we would not expect to get transportation to Aid in the next year um special education services is another area where we receive state aid back based upon uh you know students that that meet a certain metric for uh excess costs for for private placements or for public placements um Bose's is another area where the state incentivizes from state aid uh you use Bose's and and they give you Aid in future years based upon your expenditures that are avable this gives you a perspective on what found a looks like over the past couple years so 21 22 22 23 and 23 24 those were three years where districts across the
042state they basically funded this formula um that generated Foundation Aid uh those three years and you saw a significant amount of increase in Foundation Aid 2425 was the first year after the full the foundation Aid formula was fully funded um and then 2526 this is the up to dat number that we had from the state aid runs that came out about a couple weeks ago for what we expect our foundation Aid to be this year so we're looking at a 3.95% increase in state aid for foundation Aid worth $234,000 if the governor's proposal is approved by the legislature as submitted um just talk about what the Rockefeller Institute report said so it just to get some perspective last year with the budget passing there was a lot of consternation about the foundation Aid formula and
043the governor had made some proposals to change uh a number of items that were in it one of the things she wanted to eliminate was this hold harmless provision which basically said if your foundation Aid um generated based on the formula decreases year-over-year you can never get less money than what you got the previous year so Foundation Aid is is generated mostly by the needs of the students so if you have a higher percentage of special ed or or English language Learners in your District you expect to receive a higher percentage Foundation Aid if your enrollment is increasing You' expect to see a higher percentage Foundation Aid enrollments decreasing the foundation Aid formula works that you should expect to see less but the whole harmal provision prevented districts from reducing their Foundation a year- overy
044year the governor last year proposed to eliminate that provision there was a lot of push back on it she also uh proposed changing the way that inflation is factored into the into that uh calculation for foundation Aid the legislature when they when they passed the budget that hold harmless provision stayed intact they made some minor tweaks to the CPI calc calculation uh but the the concession that was made was that the governor agreed to fund a a a review by the Rockefeller Institute of the foundation Aid formula and make recommendations on changes with the goal of making state aid more equitably distributed across the state uh and providing funding to schools to support um the Learners of the 21st century so just a couple things that was came out of the rockfeller Institute report they
045focused on a lot of the um they focused on U modernizing some of the cost calculations increasing the funding adequacy uh of the foundation Aid formula they basically benchmarked New York State against a lot of other states and how they fund their education their public education they made some suggestions to some of the metrics that feed into the formula that were outdated um for example they everyone cites this but there was a sensus number that was used from the year 2000 in the foundation 8 form one of the recommendations say me was you should update that to 2025 um I won't spend too much more time on this just because some most of the recommendations that were in their report did not actually make it into the governor's proposal for this year it's possible that
046they may be added into future years some of the some of the recommendations that they had that we were very excited about some changes to the combined wealth ratio as an example um that would have really benefited the district financially they did not make it into the government's proposal there were a couple that did make it in that did have an impact on our foundation a for 25 26 based projections a positive way I'll just talk about those right now so the governor's executive proposal came out in January 21st um for next year so you should propose an eight increase of $ 1.7 billion 4.8% Statewide uh the two recommendations um from the from the Rockefeller Institute that made it into the uh into her proposal were to change that census 2000 poverty data and
047update it with current data as well as replacing a free and reduced indicator with economically disadvantaged data so those two things right there actually benefited the Rockway uh and gave us a higher percentage of foundation need for this upcoming year she also recommended a minimum increase of 2% for all districts based upon so if you fell below if you were hold harmless district and your your the formula generates that you get less Aid this year than in last year you're still getting a 2% increase based on her proposal that one did not help us um because our Aid based on the formula was going to be higher than 2% anyway and last she the Rockefeller Institute did recommend changing something called the state sharing ratio tier two that one did not benefit us we don't
048use this the SSR tier two to generate in the formula to generate our state aid so uh it was a nice recommendation it will benefit some districts but does not benefit us um there were no changes made in her proposal to the expense uh Aid categories driven Aid categories so that good news um and some other positive news that came out of her proposal was that she's recommending putting some additional funding to Universal School meals across the state so any districts that are currently um have a percentage of students that are paying for their lunch this subsidy that she's recommending in theory should cover that cost so if this devils in the details we haven't seen the full the full way this will roll out but we're optimistic that if this passes we may be
049able to offer free breakfast and lunch to all of our students next year move away from the free ruc lach application process great and last but not least creek creek kindergarten the grant allocation we're receiving this year in her budget proposal is consistent with what we received last year so no funding cut there which is great so just to give you a perspective of what our foundation Aid looks like for our Aid categories look like for next year 2425 our final Aid allocation was 6.2 million for next year our foundation Aid based upon the recommendations that the governor has made should go up to 6.4 9 million so it's about $234,000 change a 3.75% increase again these are the governor's proposals the legislature still has to mve these over if they approve them as is
050this is what the impact would be to The District in the expense driven he categories um no changes there but because of the spending we had last year for things like foses transportation that were increased costs last year we're getting additional funding from state aid back um for those events so that's a 4.75% increase total imp impact from state aid perspective supporting District's budget if the legislature was to adopt the governor's proposal would be a 3.95% increase for approximately 400,000 um I just made this note on here but the universal prek Grant allocation is included in all the state aid runs but you can't use that money for anything else other than Universal prek it's really a grant a couple highlights for next week as we look ahead so there are some positive news um
051we did see some health insurance premium relief this past year if you look at this chart here you see what the health insurance premium increases have looked like over the past couple years so in the pandemic year dropped but then it shot up so 2021 increased by 2.71 2022 12.7% increase in premiums and 3 15% 24 9% um it's a big nut to crack on a $4 million budget line item if it continues increased at a 10% rate which it has been over the past couple years when we budgeted for 2425 for our active employees we budgeted with it for a 10% premium increase we were very happy to see that that did not come to fruition this past year um November the night ship premium rates come out for the following year family plans
052had less than a 1% premium increase and individual plans had a approximately 3% increase so great news for 2425 it does give us some Financial relief there that can offset costs in other areas of our budget but it's even good news for next year's budget as well because we budgeted that number at a 10% higher didn't come in so like budget to budget you shouldn't see as big of a swing um even if I budget for next year at a 10% uh lift on top of what this year's actual look like because that money is already in that budget line item I have to go look at just our um our staffing mix right now and who is actively participating in night ship either from an individ individual or family plan perspective they make that
053projection and then come up with what I anticipate will be next year's premium increase based upon the history that we have here um but overall you shouldn't see us as significant of an increase in that budget line item which has been a very very challenging budget line item for schools over the past couple of years here's an area where there's some mix news so pension contributions on the teacher retirement system we just heard last week from the state that the contribution retirement will be decreasing from 2425 amount of 10.11% to 99.59% next year now it's an estimated amount generally speaking when the final amount comes out it's pretty consistent with what they're recommending here um that's a 52 basis point drop that translates to about $100,000 to the district um and reduced cost if our
054staffing salary costs remain consistent um with where they are right now on the flip side the Employee Retirement System you're seeing the exact opposite um so the Employee Retirement System contribution rate on average is going up from 15.2% to 16.5% next year um that's the highest amount it's been in over five years what does that translate to into actual dollars it's about $55,000 on our current salaries um in our budget for 2425 so overall net good but we were hopeful that ERS rate would sto climbing as it's been over the past couple years hasn't yet the they do give you in the ERS system a long-term expected um contribution rate which is significantly lower than what the actual rate is this year so we're optimistic in the future that will come back down but tier
055six sorry tier four is actually very expensive right now it's like 19% we contributing um for tier six BRS employees and then here's a couple of areas that we know are going to be fcal challenges for the upcoming year um as I spoke earlier the projected salaries for District employees in 5.6 is going to be higher this year and the reason why is we settled a lot of contracts we settled contracts with our teacher aids with our uh with our administrative team uh with our um our clerical our custodial we're in negotiations right now with our teachers which is our biggest unit bargain unit the salaries alone in the in the teachers um markeing unit is over $15 million that that's taking it's not even taken to consider longevities any additional benefits Etc so um
056when that contract any time of contract is up and you're negotiating a new one you should expect there's going to be a little bit of an impact uh in the short term in the next budget to cover those costs so we know this year is going to be challenging when it comes to salaries and the increase that we're expecting to see um but it's something we're working on managing I'm working with the bargaining unit to figure out how we can structure this in a way that that keeps us on a a strong fiscal standing uh in special edits another area that we're seeing a significant increase cost so I mentioned in my intro some of the additional special education Ser uh Personnel that we added this past year to meet some of the state mandates
057for special education services we brought some of those services in house which do have cost offsets we're paying consultants in the past but not all of it is offset um there was a court case that happened a couple year a ruling that came out a couple years ago which basically extended the time that um special education students are entitled to um Services through public schools from age 21 to age 22 districts across the state are are see are feeling a financial impact from that um and then rising out of out of District tuition cost we we we've had we've seen a lot of emerging needs from our students we've had to send um quite a few students out to private placements um for specialized services that we cannot provide in District um those all have
058cost and dollar values associated with them um so those are another area that we're working to manage with the budget for this year and then and last but not not least Transportation costs last year I talked about it for just our internal routes our non-public routes that we were we were expecting an increase there we were able to manage that and optimize some of our routes to reduce the cost but we were informed this past year that bosis will be increasing the transportation cost for next year by approximately 30% so it's an area that we're going to work on managing where you are considering maybe we take some of those routes in District we have buses for we just need drivers um to to manage that because if you basically translate 30% against dollar cost
059from this year that you're looking at about $100,000 increase in cost in total okay property tax ly cap so for 2526 this is our best estimate right now so last year's tax levy increase was 1.98% which translates to about $648,000 we're estimating right now that the levy cap will be 2.45 U for this upcoming budget which translate to about $818,000 I say that this is estimated right now because there are some inputs into the calculation that we don't have the data on yet specifically Bose's Capital costs that's that's that keeps into the into an exclusion in the calculations once we have that information we will be able to get a final um app number we H the file state by March 1st give the board and the community that's watching perspective on um where we've
060been and where we're going this just I like this slide because it just gives perspective on what inflation has looked like over the course of the past seven eight years as well as what of our property tax L increases have looked like so you can see from 2016 2021-22 inflation fluctuated between uh z uh 31% to a little bit over 2% our our property tax legely fluctuated along with that pretty consistently and then boom 22 23 happened 2 where we saw 4.7% inrease increas in inflation 8% the next year 4.12% and 2.95% quite honestly the market still sorting out all these cost increases um even with those increases we've been able to maintain relatively fiscally responsible recommendations for for property tax levy increases we didn't go over 2% in any of those years part of
061the reason why we weren't we didn't have to do that is because the foundation Aid formula was fully funded so there was additional cost uh different additional Revenue coming in from the state to offset some of the additional cost for inflation um but something we are looking at and managing moving forward for 2526 we haven't yet to come to a final number in terms of recommendation for property tax levy as we finalize the budget over the course of the next couple weeks we will have that in future budget presentations okay and that's that's kind of for the budget overview for the first work session as I mentioned we have another work session on March 4th we're going to do the detailed expenditure review there um April 8th we have our third budget work session uh
062we're plenty on covering the V proposition there our final Revenue our final three par budget those work sessions are going to be held here in Center Avenue 6m same thing April 23rd our budget adoption meeting will occur and then our budget hearing will be here also on May 13th and then the budget school budget vote and Trust the election will be on May 20th um 2025 our polls are in the high school are open from 700 a.m. to 9:00 p.m. that's it does the board have any questions I have questions I also have a question you can go first I know you have more than me um before when we were talking about the grants that were're trying to accumulate um would some of those grants help us for the special education students that our
063Costa going up with we do use this so there so um Ida Ida um IND Comm individuals of disabilities Education Act okay uh it's a federal law that provides funding under Section 611 and 619 okay um that funding goes directly into supporting from salary perspective as well as for um equipment TR and supplies our special education students about we have this past year 450,000 been around that somewhere around there so it it does pay for the bulk of it pays for salaries for special education staff some of it pays for services for students who are parentally placed okay um in private schools and then some of it pays for um you know in District services so with that does it increase with the number if we if we have more students each year are we
064able to increase the amount that we get or is it capped at a certain amount well it it's given to us based on our population okay that's what I want it's a question if our if our population is increasing you expect the funding to increase okay as well along those same lines so we have we budget for those students services that we're going to provide that we know that we're getting corre and then is that in the the aid category that we get reimbursed no so how is how do we considered the revenue from that Grant in the budget that we're budgeting for those children so so how do we consider so when we build that Grant um the majority of the grant pays for the school psychologist a portion of each school psychologist salary
065um so in in that sense we we have a set amount per you know we we get our fixed amount we get it in the spring and so we allocate that among the psychologists and then part of it will go toward services that we have to contract out for so PT or um Behavior Services if we need to contract out for those and then the pass they're called flow through funds that go to the um parentally placed students who receive special ed services in private schools we have a general idea of what we're going to get every year and and when we when I build the budget for 25 26 I take out of the budget the salaries that we know we're going to pay for through the grant okay so they're not in our
06645.2 million no it's like another 400,000 that the grant pays forre but we don't see it in the budget correct okay and same thing title grants too okay that's good that's good question ready go ahead okay so you guys know I've been tearing apart the audit for years and there's one page and I I I've sent it to you guys but there's one page that kind of says it all and it has the general fund highlights and it'll have every year for the past 10 years I reviewed it it says actual revenues were more than what you budgeted and every year it is and every year it also has actual expenditures are less than what we anticipated and this is to the tune of you know millions of dollars um so with that being said
067I want you know I'm going to be annoying for the whole budget process and you know and I'll try to explain why but so now I want to go back to your handout and you did the looking ahead to the 2526 budget and you have the aid for this current year and the estimated aid for next year and then if you go back well and and I'm not surprised and I know why so you have the state aid that we created our budget on at 9 million $449,000 right that's inclus Foundation at that time when the budget was adopted on April 16th right the so a couple things so last year on April 16 that's when the legislature actually budget so we didn't have anything else to go off except for the ex and I
068understand and every year we get in the high six figures we get last for 24 24 23 24 school year we got $891,000 more than we anticipate and it's it's rained from you know 500,000 usually what happens the governor puts out a proposal and the legislature yes groups more right so I just want to say that when you're comparing last year's budget formation to this year's budget formation and you have a plus $391,000 difference it is not plus it is it is more so budg to budget it's more budget is not let me do my numers so last year in our budget that I took this from the newsletter it was 9,49 th000 and then this year's proposed legislation Aid is 10.3 million of which you have to take out prek correct so now we
069want up with $9.9 million so our net ad for Budget formation purposes is I wrote it down somewhere but it's it's 9566 minus no it's hold on sorry it's 958 I now I'm under pressure so it's minus 9049 it's $900,000 more not $300 91 correct so I just wanted to kind of put that out there we talked about this before the the the reason why the number came in so much higher than what was in the governor's proposal was because we had a reporting every free reduced lunch that we worked on we couldn't Bank on that on that money coming in and I understand that so we use restricted reserves into last year's budget in the tune of about a half a million dollars in the event that we didn't get that money back from
070the state and get that error resolve and and I get it and I I'm just saying consistently for 10 years we get high six figures more in Revenue than we think and then we have two high of of an excess and that's in Morin's opinion can I ask question so go ahead wouldn't and I'm asking because I'm I'm trying to figure it out like when I look at stuff I always rather have an excess yes for the Emergency agree so are you saying that we have too much because the way I look at it isn't it better to have too much for like when we have that situation like a Sandy or something like that that we have that money in that Reserve to use we have it we we have in in my opinion
071of having gone through this for the past several years and going back we have a good size of reserves in the past six years we've added 12 million doll to our reserves we've spent a lot on the hbac we've spent like nine or whatever it is but we have how much million in reserves right now around that I don't know the exact number I'm gonna say we have 11 12 million in res it's about that and then we also every year have the unrestricted Reserve which right now is just under 2 million every year so so we have money we we're not in danger of like if the boiler breaks or if if you know God forbid rain got flooded and we had to go rent another school in Oceanside yeah but at that point
072that's a catastrophe right and at that point that money is what we need to keep us afloat and not become one of those districts that go into the red right yes we have I'm always comfortable with having an excess amount and I know that sounds silly because interrupt real quick sure it's about yes F prudent fiscal planning if I'm not generating some level of excess then I probably was not effective in my budget correct I was either not conservative enough or something just something drastically went wrong the course of the year that was and and which happens um it's about are we generating is is the excess at a level that is way too high what do you think it should be if if if this was just you what would you do I was
073just going to ask the propos the question to Mike and it and we want to be adding to the reserves every year corre so I think it a for a 5% excess the the office of State Controller came in here to do a financial condition audit of the district they would consider being within four to five% of your of your budget fiscal fiscally responsible budgeting so is four to 5% on of $45 million budget it's million and a half two million something like that y million and a half Y is what I have in my 1.8 million year over year because things will happen that are just non recurring in nature we have a sinkhole like we had here right like that's and and that's kind of where I was going with it we have
074older buildings um and I'm always comfortable having that I hate to use the word cushion but that cushion there for when we do have that and we don't have to run to the public and say okay now we don't have to right but that's that's what I'm saying like that makes me comfortable knowing that we don't have to run to say and I understand what you're saying that it's a little bit more than where we would like want to have it but at the same time I feel like that makes us better because of the fact that we have it just to be on the safe side and I want to I want to spend it I want to spend it on our kids that's the way I look at it and and I agree
075I want to spend it on academics yes um and so the one the 1.5 1.8 million we were talking about we agree last year which was a year which has been a lot less than what we've had left over in the past was 2.2 million so that's 400,000 more than I think the projections are that it should be a lot lower than that okay so let's use some of that money and put it towards our kids and in education I think we agree on that totally and the other thing we have to consider too as administrative team on a board of education is there are significant long-term capital inir we have to make to our buildings to maintain a health and safety Health a healthy and safe environment for our students and staff there's probably
076about 10 to 15 million dollars of work and that's ongoing and that's that's a continuous process so there's a couple ways you fund that you fund that through a bond which you gotta borrow money in a in a tough interest environment right now where you budget fiscally and hope you have leftover money D move it into a capital reserve um generate interest on your own money and use that to right fund Capital Improvements which and that's a direction that I would recommend to the board we have some reserves that are um High higher than than than I think is necessary and I talked about in the last budget cycle last year the ERS Reserve is enough money in that Reserve to fund 10 years of contributions to me that's the type of um Reserve that
077we can look to spend down and then reallocate funding to a capital reserve to pay for roofs in our high school or Windows across all of our buildings and I agree with that I'm big on maintenance and I'm big on preventive M maintenance so it's not you're not reacting um so I agree with that and then I just had something else to say uh and we'll talk about it when we start talking about reserves um but you know we appropriate a lot of money every year and we just really just kind of recycle it which falsely inflates our budget but that's something we'll talk about at and my recommendation to that would be start reducing our our Reliance on appropriated fund balance because that also is dangerous in the future if we start having less
078money left over yeah because it's a fake I wouldn't recommend doing that all in one shot because if you do that all in one shot it goes into a restrictive reserve and then you have right a lot of restrictions on what you can use that money for but you should do it over time and if the off again if the office of State Controller came in here to a of us that would be a recommendation that they would have and then um so the good news bad news you had with the TRS and the ERS contribution rates are is good because the TRS is the big one correct and that's dropping in the ERS is small and I was going to say but you already kind of hit on it with the health insurance is
079Long Beach was going to close a grammar school yep so they jumped on their budget early and they have no increase in their employee benefits at all because uh I guess of those reasons so that was good news that was surprise to see so um it fluctuates year over year though because you never know who's going who's going to um change your plan from an individual to a family um they have a life event we're small where you have a couple of individuals who who decide want go off my my wife or my husband's Insurance to go on to the district Insurance it could have a significant impact right and and our and the interest rates which will be our local source is going to be big this year too so I would like to
080take advantage of that with the academic enhancing our academic performance uh category and then so the pre is that number of students so if we have seats we have right so if family of 10 moves in with 10 quadruplet do we get more money no so we're locked in i s it becomes a lottery that's it yes so you get depending on how many kids you get that number been locked for several years East Rockaway and we've talked to our um legislators and said like this this doesn't work for us but what happens is we have that set amount of $351,000 um which is how they calculate it's really $5,400 per child to a maximum of 65 children um if we have more than 65 families interested in a upk seat we have to do
081Lottery because fund I saw another District get another 500,000 for the how do we increase that do we have to just you know speak to the it's written in the statute I don't think get more funding for it or to increase our number this is the way it works this formula that allocates the number of seats in the in the statute and there's a formula that allocates the the amount of dollars per seat that they allocate to a district they wrote it in a way that basically creates a floor in what amount you get for SE based upon a foundation aid number from like 10 years ago wow if your foundation aid number per pupil was higher than $800 might be for this little about $800 um and then that's your amount if you're a
082less wealthy District if you're a a wine danage or brenwood um you might be getting a significant higher amount for students 10 years ago life is so much different for everybody so I think you know that's just I mean we're Miss because ofage PL too so I keep her so what I would say was we met with um all of our leaders uh Mr Griffin uh we have Arie Brown coming in and we just met with Patricia fatrick CER and we talk about unfunded mandates and grants and how to support our kids and one of the things we did talk about was upk that it's important for us to be able to fund the mall and unfortunately it comes down to uh you have to disappoint some families in a lottery system where they can't
083get it so it's uh we're working on it we're working on the back end what I'm hearing from these conversations is hey we have to be fiscally responsible and we've been in good footing for a number of years for a lot of good reasons and what I'm hearing now is is um not that we get away from that but we you you want to change the balance line to a little bit more spending uh some of the monies that we can you know put it towards different programs or academics which you know we can certainly do but we don't want to have that um we won't have any programs if we're not in good footing we'll be losing programs and cutting people so we got you know you know Mike has been working on finding
084that fine line and we'll work with you and the community to find that fine line where we are responsible and at the same time you know spending the money where we need to spend it we don't want to throw money at something that we don't need but GNA put it in the areas where we need support so it's a big process I you know Mike I thank you for putting that all together um you know in in terms I think which the community can really understand um but I think the big message is that we've been fiscally responsible and now uh you know we have some uh monies that we can spend yes so we're going to take a look at that we're in a good position compared to you know some other districts yeah
085yes this from a financial perspective district has been more managed yeah okay thank you you're welcome thank you thanks thanks all right uh you guys any questions anyone um actually before I end um are there any questions regarding the minutes of the January 14th regular meeting and the special meeting on the 24th anyone no okay and how about questions on the next monthly meeting on next week on February 11th any questions on that all right anyone else any questions no all right at this time can I have a motion to adjourn the meeting and enter into executive session to discuss contract negotiations motion motion by Mrs Lan second second second Mr lores all in favor opposed abstain motion approved good night everyone good night thank you alen thank you