001watch e e e all right so item 1.03 approval or revision of agenda may I have a motion to approve the agenda thank you Chrissy and thanks Cindy any discussion okay all in favor anybody opposed or abstain okay and item 2.01 for executive session be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manlia Central School District enter executive session for the purpose of discussing the super superintendent search and time permitting a student discipline matter may I have a motion please thank you Daryl and Chrissy any discussion all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining great and we're going to go out into executive session spe for e e e e e e that spe okay okay we're waiting for Jason and Cindy oh um Miss Hefty please report to your seat please where's Mr
002catalino restroom well welcome everyone this is wonderful to see so many faces at our really exciting meeting tonight must be the later start time drew the crowds so that's exciting um thank you for coming appreciate it um we are on item 3.01 which is recognitions so we have a few recognitions e tonight whose contributions to the fville manliest school Community represent excellence in academics and wellness our first group of recognitions this evening are for some teachers who have recently earned tenure earning tenure is not only a representation of excellence in teaching but also of their professionalism and the many contributions these faculty make in our schools congratulations to Hannah Douglas and Laurel Pritchard and unfortunately they couldn't join us tonight but we will be giving them a token of our appreciation our second recognition this
003evening is for an exceptional teacher who was recently named as the New York State World Language teacher of the year congratulations to Dr Denise Ms Dr Ms was selected for this state level honor due to her teaching excellence and advocacy efforts in the areas of teacher preparation and the value of World Language programs congratulations thank you I should have said that in French probably but I didn't take your class so I'm not prepared congratulations and our third recognition of the evening will be presented by Alexis Thorp principal of the fville elementary school [Applause] thank you thank you hello good evening um I have the honor and privilege today to recognize three very important individuals that help Fel run a smoothly and as well oiled as it does every single day um last week was School
004counseling week so I thought that this was an appropriate time to bring forward my three School counseling staff members um I'm going to ask them to come and stand up here with me because I really think that they should be up here with me when I speak about them so today I have the privilege of recognizing three exceptional individuals uals who play an essential role in the success and well-being of fal's school Community our school counselor Mr Mike Quinn our family school liaison miss Emily Lorraine and our school psychologist psychologist Mrs Lauren Dera their impact reaches beyond their job titles every day they dedicate themselves to support not only our students St but our teachers staffs staff families and me they work tires tirelessly often behind the scenes to ensure that every child at fael
005feels seen supported and empowered to succeed Mr Quinn Miss Lorraine and Mrs Dara wear many hats they meet with students individually providing guidance and reassurance to help them navigate challenges they lead small groups creating safe spaces for children to build on their social skills manage emotions and develop confidence they also bring valuable lessons to entire classrooms through our second step program helping students grow in their social emotional learning and develop essential life skills like empathy problem solving and resilience but their support doesn't stop with students they are here for our teachers and staff offering Insight encouragement and strategies to help meet the diverse needs of their Learners they are here for their family amilies our families providing resources connections and listening when it's needed most their dedication and kindness extend to every corner of our
006school creating a stronger more compassionate Community fville Elementary is a better place because of their unwavering commitment and we are truly grateful for the work they do each and every day it's because of this that I am proud to recognize celebrate and thank Mr Quinn Miss lorine and Mrs Dara for the heart energy and kid they bring to our entire School [Applause] community that was wonderful thank you okay item 3.02 we have a presentation on K through six literacy Dr I believe we're available for hugs afterwards too all right thank you thank you all right thanks so much uh for for allowing us uh to come back again or me anyway um to give uh give you some information about the work that's been done um for k6 literacy um we spoke to you last
007um at the end of last year to talk about our our pilots and we're happy to give you some updates about where we are halfway through the year um and where we expect to go um very first thing that I would like to do um our curriculum Specialists jacqulyn gangloff and Amy reman Schneider uh will be presenting with me tonight and I cannot thank enough um all of the teachers um and our curriculum Specialists who have been a part of of piloting these two programs so far this year um it has been a tremendous amount of work to learn a new curriculum um and to be implementing that every day um and these are the teachers who are piloting um across our grades um and I also just want to thank although they're not all
008on this slide all of um our teachers grades three through six because many of them were part of of our piloting group um they all participated in the feedback survey that we'll be talking about a little bit um and all will be um a part of um the feedback um as we make this decision um going forward um for our community so our goal tonight really is to in in the brief time that we have um talk a little bit about what the state has um asked all districts to be doing um especially uh prek to uh to three um we're going to give you some information and some data um based on qualitative and quantitative feedback um as well as the support um that Jacqueline and Amy and others have given um for for
009teachers and then talk a little bit about where we're going um from here um we're about halfway through uh the year but there's still a lot to learn um with each of these programs so our call to action um is really part of the the P20 literacy initiative um through New York state so in 2024 uh the Department of Education released a series of literacy briefs and the goal of those briefs um really was to focus um Educators around the state around the science of reading and we spoke um last time we um met about this topic topic um about what that actually meant um the science of reading is no one thing it's a body of research that tells us what are the best practices um in literacy and that research goes back um
010multiple decades um what New York state has sought to do and what what FM has been doing for years um is to make sure that the components of Science of reading um oral language um phonological awareness phonics comprehension fluency vocabulary that all of those things are embedded in our instruction um and that continues um not just past Elementary or middle school to but to high school and Beyond um and so those literacy briefs were essentially um a precursor to uh this work right here so in in 2025 and in January so last month uh New York State released um this document um which really is um a guide book for for New York State districts um moving forward which says that um our curriculum our instruction and our assessment should be aligned um to evidence-based
011practices um that we should be regularly reviewing um our literacy curriculum and instruction um and making sure that instructionally we have best practices in all of our classrooms that is also coinciding um with education law um 818 which is evidence-based scientifically uh based reading instruction what that H is asking us to do is to make sure that all districts across New York state are providing um the best education that they can that is evidence-based in terms of literacy instruction um that we are making sure that all of the components of Science of reading are included in our instruction and assessment um that we will review that um on a yearly basis which is what this document um outlines for us um and that all districts in New York state will attest um that their curriculum
012and instruction is aligned to the science of reading and that attestation needs to be signed by the superintendent um by September 1st um at the beginning of each year so I'm really proud when I came to to FM that this work has been has been done in in a lot of ways um that's through the benefit of all of the work um that's happening in in different classrooms and it's through the benefit of H of having curriculum Specialists like um Jacqueline and Amy um it means that that work um provided a great Foundation um for for making some choices um about our curriculum and instruction so last fall um we talked a little bit about um a literacy review so that was a comprehensive review um that was done um with an outside um agency
013ocm bosis um and their literacy team who came into all of our um elementary and middle buildings and did comprehensive interviews with of our k6 teachers um as well as um administrators um to talk about what's going really really well in the district as well as what we needed to be working on um from there um we took those findings um which showed that there were a lot there was a lot of great work happening in the science of literacy um but it was happening in pieces right and that what what teachers were asking us for was a um one comprehensive curriculum that didn't um didn't require that teachers had to be peac mealing anywhere that we had vertical articulation and Alignment k6 um and that the the skills that students were learning would spiral
014across the grade levels right that it would continue to build upon itself from there in the winter we um put forth A literacy pilot um program appraisal team so that was a cross-section of teachers K through six as well as our administrators um to come together and take a look at some of the the most uh well-regarded um curricular uh curriculum that are out there we looked at six programs um and over the course of that year we went from six to three to the two that we are now piloting from there last spring of 2024 and uh in the summer our piloted our piloting teams were chosen so we have a cross-section of teachers um across K six we have um four teachers across both of those programs and all of those grades um
015who worked to plan um did a lot of professional development um with the two uh curriculum companies um and then launched in the fall um from here I'm going to um turn it over to our curriculum Specialists to talk about the support that has occurred over the course of this year and then we'll dig into some of the data good evening so I'll start with sharing a bit about the support we've been giving teachers and then um transition to Amy who will speak a bit about the data collection that we've been doing throughout the pilot so as we continue to grow our understanding of the science of reading we've continued to align with the evidence-based literacy instruction but we before we Divi dive into those specifics around the pilot there's three aspects of this work
016that we'd like to highlight for you tonight the first is the ongoing support for teachers and students who are not in the pilot program so we continue to support those classrooms this year the work actually started years ago though over multiple Summers we've worked with teachers on curriculum projects where we've created instructional guidance documents so these guidance documents frame instruction for each unit and ensure the skills in teaching align with evidence-based literacy instructional practices for grades K2 K2 these documents have been revised to align with research on how students learn to read with specific focus on foundational skills and a framework for explicit instruction in phonological Awareness was also developed for K2 for grades 3 five these documents were developed to enhance writing word study and grammar instruction so in grades three through five our
017gram grammar standards fall within a band Banning across the three grades so we've created a document that delineates at which grade level those um standards would be introduced practiced and then mastered and then we created a framework specific to grades three and four that aligns their grammar and word study instruction across the school year to further expand on that we also um revised some initial writing units to incorporate sentence construction so as you can see we've continued to work with non- piloting classrooms to align with evidence-based literacy practice with practices through our current program the other work we wanted to highlight with you tonight were things um that involve all of our K4 teachers so not our piloting classrooms along with our non- piloting classrooms so this year we've made some updates to our suite
018of assessment tools available to teachers with the goal of making our assessments more reflective of the reading research for example we now have a standardized approach for administration of a phonic survey which provides valuable formative data um for teachers in the realm of students phonics growth and in first grade we've added a screener in the area of nonsense word fluency to track student progress in the application of their phonics knowledge the last um example I'll highlight for you tonight is one that we're probably most excited about with our um K4 teachers that is the introduction of youly so um we this year were able to supply classroom teachers with youly manuals and initial training with Dr dorine Maisy from uh Sunni asigo was offered to teachers this was in an effort to help small group
019uh support small group instruction and differentiation for those students who would benefit from supplemental phonic support in the classroom so uly is an explicit and systematic program that teaches students the foundational skills necessary for proficient reading it follows a carefully developed scope and sequence designed to ensure that students systematically acquire each skill needed and learn to apply each of those skills with automaticity and confidence due to the nature of the skills being taught through that program it is primarily utilized in grades K through 2 but it's a resource grades three and four teachers might utilize to help support students with varying needs so as you can see we've continued to build our commitment to academic Excellence through continuous Improvement around our evidence-based literacy instruction in our classrooms now I'll switch over to um transition to
020what's been happening for our pilot classrooms and the additional support that we've been providing for teachers there um every week Amy and I facilitate Google meets with the piloting teachers at each grade level so these meetings are specific to each piloting program and during the meetings teachers are offer offer teachers offer feedback on the previous Ela lessons sharing both what went well and what presented challenges along the way in addition they make suggestions for improvements if the district were to adopt this particular program and during those meetings Amy and I are usually planning ahead in uplifting parts of the upcoming week's lessons that may require additional discussion or planning and provide suggestions for pacing as teachers are moving forward approximately monthly we've been able to bring teachers together for a half day of release time
021where they have the opportunity to collaboratively plan um in person with their grade level partner who is also piloting the same program as well as receive ongoing training with program Consultants so depending on the program that included has included video calls inperson training observations of lessons in personalized Virtual Office hours that they can do during that time so these collaborative opportunities have played a pivotal part um as an implementation of this program the new programs that it's as it's been an enormous undertaking um for the teachers who have um been on board with us so now I'll turn it over to Amy who will speak to the additional work we're doing with the pilot classrooms and data collection so excuse me we are currently in the midst of the data collection process process for the
022two pilot programs following the completion of our January Universal screening for kindergarten through sixth grade students were in the preliminary stages of analyzing the student growth from fall to winter within the piloting classrooms but our data collection strategy extends Beyond standardized screening soon the piloting teachers will convene to examine their experiences with the pilot they will utilize a rubric that synthesizes the reading League's curriculum evaluation guide the newly released New York State K through3 literacy curriculum review guide that Dr doton spoke of earlier along with the FM needs assessment to structure their collaborative Reflection by integrating these comprehensive resources we aim to create a multi-dimensional understanding of the pilot program's initial implementation and potential impact to enrich our comprehensive data collection efforts we will readminister the November surveys that we gave to students in grades
0233 through six as well as to all K through six families and teachers in the upcoming weeks these surveys provide valuable qualitative insights into the pilot programs initial implementation and perceived Effectiveness our ongoing weekly meeting with teachers complement the survey data by capturing the nuanced realtime feedback that the teachers give us as Jacqueline stated earlier these collaborative sessions allow teachers to share anecdotal observations emerging challenges and preliminary Impressions about the program's Effectiveness and performance at this point the preliminary data both quantitative and qualitative does not definitively discount either program in fact both programs demonstrate meaningful potential especially in the elementary years at this time we'd like to share some initial Impressions from families teachers and students in the piloting classrooms and we'll turn it back over to Dr Don okay so this is a good
024problem to have when both programs are are telling us that there's growth um and both are relatively even um in terms of quantitative and qualitative data um so I I say it's a good problem to have because there's nothing that's discounting one program um over the other and I think that speaks a lot to the teachers that were a part of um the recommendations and and the Really comprehensive rev uh review that was done by those groups so um again as Jacqueline and Amy shared we have surveyed once are our families um of our k6 students um our students grades three through six as well as all of our piloting teachers um what we tried to do in that feedback um since we can't show you the whole list um in in the time that
025we have was to try to find Trends in some of the the quantitative feedback or the qualitative feedback I should say and and and share some of those Trends to you um what we're seeing in terms of the family feedback the questions that we asked really were um three one was just what can you tell us about the experience um so far so what are you seeing um and again this is December so um are you are you seeing your your kiddo come home and talk about um things do they seem excited about the work that they're doing um would you recommend um this program to the district and then left an open-ended question of is there anything else that you'd like us to know um and this is a sample of what some of
026that um feedback was um generally speaking both of the programs were were very very positive in terms of um engagement um and in terms of interest um K4 we can't say that right now for five and six so there was um there was not universally positive um feedback at grades five and six and so we'll ask again um about that um the trends for the the family data um are this now I do want to qualify this by saying um that we had only an average about 15% in terms of return rates there are a lot of reasons for for why that could be um it was December um it's a busy time of year for um a lot of families and it's possible that you know um um that it was just um too
027busy um for for everybody to complete at this time it's also possible right that this is very early days in a pilot program um and you might want we might get more feedack back a little bit later in the year right um certainly again overwhelmingly positive um but there were also families that said yeah I think it's positive but you know I'm I'm not you know I'm not sure yet um which is why we'll be surveying again generally speaking though um of the the families that um surveyed um and and answered the survey for us um they said number one they're really happy that FM is investing um in a new literacy program that is lined to the science of reading into the research that's out there so overwhelmingly positive that hey this is the
028the right track um and that was before um the state released you know um its findings we were very happy to see that both of the programs earn very very high marks um with families so you could see in some of that feed feedback right that um families are seeing um students engaging in content that they seem um to be interested um that they're sharing new vocabulary um and they're they're happy to see that growth there was nothing that discounted one program over the other um the other big piece was again that that families were seeing um their you know their kids coming home and talking about it and sharing what they learned um sharing new vocab um sharing their learning and so that um is certainly validating um right now for both programs again
029um with a 15% uh return rate we want to make sure that we are asking those questions again um we might ask different questions right and continue to to give families the opportunity um to share their feedback with us and any questions that they have uh in terms of our teachers you'll see some longer um some longer pieces of feedback here and that speaks to um the expertise um that they have um in their classrooms um and again the the teacher feedback um is asking for um a couple of different questions um we're asking essentially um what do they consider the strongest Parts um of the program that they they are piloting right now um what are the areas that they feel there needs to be Improvement um how satisfied they are with the program
030that they're using right now um and how are the skills being developed um for for students in their classrooms and so overwhelmingly you know what teachers were telling us in that um survey that we did with with ocm bosis last year is they do desire um curriculum that is very much aligned to the science of reading and what the research is telling us um as well as making sure um that we're consistent right that we are looking for um really guaranteed viable curriculum knowing that um no matter what classroom you're in what building you're in you are receiving um the same um the same quality of Education based on um the materials that you you see here and so we also want to make sure and this was something that um teachers were asking for
031in that that first survey um is that teachers were were peac mealing a lot um right that they had to go outside um of the current uh curriculum that we're using to try to supplement and so we're happy that the teacher feedback right now is telling us it's all in one place and that's true for for both programs that they um that they don't have to to search out um to supplement um especially in terms of you know um differentiation um within their lessons teachers are also seeing and appreciate the fact that this is uh that both of these programs build upon skills and that's what we what we call the the spiral right that students um continue to um practice new skills and then those skills come back at Le later units and later
032years so that means that um there's no um there doesn't have to be judgment on a student that hasn't mastered a skill in November because that skill is going to come back in January that skill is going to come back in March and it's going to give students a lot of lots of opportunities um for Mastery our students I'm I'm happy to say we decided um five five through six in terms of of levels um andow allowed our littlest Learners um to have conversations at home uh to share some some feedback what were we what we were asking students um about is engagement are are the materials interesting um are the materials um are they aligned to where you're at so we asked uh students you know is this text just right is it a
033little too hard is a is it a little too easy um we asked students um what did you really really like um about what you're learning so far and what are the things that um you think need to be improved students gave um really fantastic feedback um we had um 456 students K through six um supplied feedback um in December and again we'll be asking again because of the spiraling nature of both curricular uh curriculum um will want to see where they're at in the spring as well as the early winter um generally speaking um students felt that um the interest in their materials um was high so we had um about 72% of students feeling like the text level was just right for them um and we had for the interest rates um anywhere
034from we'd say 50% that said really high level but when you add always high to um you know sometimes interested um we got to about 90 90% um I do want to say again um of the places where students felt less than um that it tended to be five and six um five and six grades in five and six um were interested in you know they want wanted to know where their novel um studies were that's a big strong part of the FM curriculum um and um and because of that passion for the nval studies there were questions about well I I I like this text so much but I think get to read all of it um the nature of of some of this work right is you're you're reading excerpts um and so
035student interest was high and said well I want to read all of it but then we're we're moving on right and so those those are questions that we want to ask again um so that we can find out more especially at that 56 um level so where do we go from here um again we're going to gather additional data right so where we are in December is not going to be where we are in February which is not going to be where we are in March right both of these programs build on each other so we want to know do families um do they have a better understanding of of what's Happening um in their in their students classroom are they starting to see um skills build um are their students coming home are their
036kids coming home and talking to them um about what's going on in the class um and we want to make sure um that students have a voice in terms of where where they were at when this was relatively new um to where they've had a few more months of experience um and we want to ask our teachers right how are you seeing that sort of spiraling um continue has the level of professional learning and the support from um each of these curriculum than supporting your work and so as Jacqueline and Amy mentioned will be bringing back piloting teachers again um later this month um the whole group um across both programs um to really take a deep dive and in a half day and of really talking about what's working um and what we'd like
037to see because ultimately we're not looking for a cookie cutter right we're work we're looking for the best curriculum that we can have that is aligned with the research that will be most successful for our students um and something that we can make sure vertically aligns um allows students um to continue the growth that we've we've already seen over many years at FM um but also something um that that teachers feel aligned across um all grades from there um we'll after we do more data collection and those conversations um with teachers and administrators then we'll be looking um to purchase um and I'm happy to report back um on that um with the when we make that decision um and then we're we're going to get digging into training right away so um we'll look
038that at the June um professional learning day as a day when all of our elementary um and potentially Middle School teachers would be digging into um the new program and take a full day for that and then um uh a lot um a lot of curriculum hours over the summer for any of our teachers who are willing to do that and by next year um what we have talked to to teachers about and and we want to make sure our community understands is that the support that you heard earlier from Jacqueline and Amy in terms of regular Google meets half days those types of supports will be in place for all of our teachers and not just those who pilot um we know that um you know the the adoption of any new curriculum um
039you know really takes years right and and and the results and the data that we're going to be looking at is not just going to be this winter this spring or even uh two or three years really what you're looking for is you're looking to see growth um over five years um and and Mastery um of that at all levels um within five years and so what I hope um that our community under you know sees um and and that the board sees um first is the tremendous lift um that our educators um brought forth um through both of these piloted piloting programs and that there is a lot of validation for the two programs that were chosen um through a year of of study um because right now I said it's it it's going
040to be a big decision um but there's nothing that neither of those pro programs um has given us any reason to say it's not this one um and I think the fact that we can can feel very very comfortable and confident um with either um is a is a really really gratifying and a great validation to the work that was done but every by everyone that was a part of the pilot um so from there we're happy to answer any questions that you have certainly we'll ask to come back for a few minutes um later in the year um to talk about where we're going from here but we want to thank you um the board Community our principes our teachers um and our students um for all the work that they've put in for
041making the pilot um as successful as it's been so far how do you see either of these programs working with are students are the most struggling readers and what are the reading teachers seeing as a result of this piloting which program do they like or are they seeing an improvement is it easier for our kids who struggle yeah so I think again they they tend to be relatively even in terms of their strengths um as well as the the wants from from everybody um generally speaking I don't see um I don't see any glaring weak is and either in terms of um supporting all levels of learning I think that's one of the pieces where teachers were working so incredibly hard um trying to to supplement for our students that needed to move forward our
042students that were um right where they needed to be and our students who were struggling and there was a lot of supplementation and with that comes a lot of differentiation and sometimes it's you know not not the differentiation that you want right and so I think overwhelmingly the feedback from teachers um so far has been it's all there and that I have everything that I need in front of me to differentiate learning for students who need a little extra time and I think that's the be the beauty of a of a curriculum that spirals it says that you don't have to master it in November because we're revisiting it again in four weeks and another few weeks after that it gives student students lots of opportunity um to master um within that curriculum and because
043it is something that is so well aligned across grade levels um that that opportunity to practice and learn um will continue and I think that that alignment is is really a beautiful thing and that's really the feedback that we've seen um so far does anybody else have any other questions guess I'll try thank you Katherine Amy and Jackie um I guess I have a bit of an issue with not with any of you but with the whole idea of the science of reading um I learned very well to read with phonics at faithville Elementary in the 50s I think Dan did as well in the 70s right it's calling out years M Road fa right m road thanks forting yeah had to do some quick math um and we used phonics and as a reading
044specialist I and an English teacher I certainly used all the phonemic awareness and the things that are necessary that we're all calling the science of reading today so I also noticed you're very careful not to it's not a basil you're calling it a program is there a book is there a what what is it that teachers are sorry are using there are a variety of materials and not you want to do you want to talk to each because each is a little different um so I can speak to that a little bit so um both programs don't have like your traditional textbook by any means that's definitely not a thing um the students do have um books that they utilize so in one program they're more um in Benchmark they're More Magazine type for a
045unit that has excerpts that uh the students read the um inter reading has what's called a my book so it is a bit of a thicker book um that the students have that is given to the students and it provides opportunity for them to annotate and whatnot as they're reading so it's actually more traditional of like a workbook with the excerpts in them where the students can actually um as I said annotate they can respond to questions and um do all of that work within the book itself yeah no problem yeah I think um you know I do want to stress so first of all I appreciate the commentary about the the science of reading right it it is um it is you know meant to be representative of the body of research um which
046is not new to FM and I appreciate the fact you know what we talked um last spring um we talked about the fact that you know FM continues to be a district that um leads the state in terms of achievement for literacy um and that the strength of the district is to not be happy um just leading But continuing to to grow um and I think the while so much um goes well what our teachers were asking us was you know for consistency so that they weren't constantly peac mealing right how do we create um really a Core Curriculum that allows them to grow um and supplement is needed so I mentioned that neither is perfect right um one of the pieces of data that has come out to us um you know strongly through
047teachers is that our reading program is second to none um you know and and is so strong um in in so many ways and is stronger um in a lot of ways than either curriculum right either program um that doesn't mean we're going to throw out what works it means that we're going to incorporate what works um but we're going to do that and and make sure that we have consistency across grades and ac across classrooms um and that we have that vertical alignment um so that students will continue to build and that's really um that was the really big ass that came out of that literacy review last year was um teachers were really craving that consistency for the betterment of students and I think that's what either you know either of these programs
048would offer and Katherine is there any great cost differential they're probably pretty comparable in price relatively comparable yeah and I'm I'm working with bosis to see if um we can get some Bose Aid on a few of those as well but as I mentioned you know again I've I've worked really hard um with Jacqueline with Amy with principles with Brad um costs will not determine the the the best move for for students right we're um but yes we're always going to work towards you know being as fiscally responsible and um yeah and you know [Laughter] and like I said we're gonna need hugs after this meeting yeah yeah um yeah and so yes I think they're um they're very comparable to one another um and um and any time that I didn't see something that
049I felt was right I said well like the shipping cost I'm like nope so and they they worked with us um so I think um we're in a good place um to go as far as we can I just have one question on it I think without you know seeing the the actual underlying data what are you seeing in that data for especially for our youngest Learners as far as how both how these are working with you know our our more advanced readers are less Advanced reader is this is is this are you finding these to be as effective across the full spectrum of our student body or more effective in segments generally speaking so looking at just the the question from students about um uh the level of text about 75% of our students
050felt that the level was just right um and then an even mix between those other you know the other 25% um between it's a little too hard or it's a it's it's going a little too um or it's a little too easy um and again that would be just the core right so we have opportunities um and we have the knowhow and we have the materials and resources already to differentiate and so there are ways that each program within itself allows teachers to do that um as well as all of the knowledge that we that we have as a district um to be able to do that but what I think it does do um and what we're seeing from the feedback from teachers is you know getting 75% of kids just where they need
051to to be to continue to grow is a really really good thing um and being able to do that with one curriculum that has multiple different resources is better than we've been able to do um currently of what we're using and I guess my only question or comment is um appreciate that you're asking families about their feed back but I also think depending on how you're asking it can be a really hard question if they don't have anything to compare to and so I'm I'm particularly interested to hear about the teachers feedback and see the the actual results themselves because I think the the teachers will see you know they see the same types of kids year after year and can see how it helps them work with the kids in a much more effective
052way or not or how that all flows through um so I think that's that will be a really interesting piece of feedback to get agreed uh you know I again I I think there are a lot of um great lessons that we've learned just through the the course of of a pilot in terms of you know from the the first survey with all of our teachers to the continued um asks from families teachers and students and elevating all of each of those groups voices um is is should be standard practice and so I I want to make clear that this doesn't go away with a pilot right we will continue to gather feedback from all of our stakeholders um just as good practice moving forward does anybody else have any questions okay thank you guys
053for all of your work no thank you so much um for your support and just to our curriculum Specialists and to our teachers for all of the work that they're doing thank you and so we think spring couple months is that what you're thinking time frame yes so we'll have uh the meeting with all of our pilot teachers at the end of February and then we'll be serving again in March um and go from there okay great thank you thank you all right um um item 3.03 president's report um so I just wanted to update you all um as we kind of kicked off with a recognition for counseling week I know there had been um some conversations floated around and then this week in CRC there was um a discussion about using the week
054of May 6th to be sort of all staff recognition but have the board be able to um visit the different locations to be able to um recognize buildings and grounds and transportation and all all the different uh staff members that we have working as opposed to trying to keep track of which group is recognized which week throughout the course of the year because there were multitude of calendars on that front so unless anybody feels strongly a different way um that's kind of our plan going forward so we will will'll be talking more about that as May gets a little closer um and then just an update obviously you all know um we were meeting with Dr Cook before this meeting um to begin to work on developing the superintendent's job ad so more information will
055be coming out shortly on that front but definitely appreciate everybody's time and commitment to working on that so thank you item 3.04 superintendent report report thank you thank you President Fitzgerald uh the backup information is in your board packet as I fight a cold here item one Capital project update I'm pleased to report that the expanded cafeteria Edition which is part of the high school Capital Improvement project has been en closed which will allow contractors to begin to work on the inside of the new facility and in order to help it become operational for the upcoming school year item two Scholastic art Awards congratulations to all of our gold key and silver key winners who were recognized at the recent Scholastic art Awards held at the SRC Arena on the anaga community college campus I
056had the pleasure of attending and many of our middle school and high school students were honored with gold key awards for their portfolios and individual works of art item three school starttime committee our school starttime committee continues to meet in order to recommend a new alignment with the proposed Senate and assembly bills that would uh choreograph the elementary schools beginning no earlier than 8:00 a.m and the secondary schools from starting before 8:30 a.m. the committee is not only looking at adjusting start times but also exploring revisions to the existing Bell schedules in order to take full advantage of new facilities such as the expanded High School cafeteria item four the big read unfortunately the big read special event panel session which was originally scheduled for January 28th was cancelled due to inclement weather and now
057will be held later the spring we're anticipating it to be on a Monday in early May emergency closing days speaking of inclement weather we used the third of our four appropriated emergency closing days which were scheduled for this year in the event that a fourth day will be used in the future the district will then pivot to remote learning days for both faculty and staff and students will be required to transport their electronic devices either Chromebooks or iPad back and forth between the home and the school so that we will be able to switch on a moment's notice because of the impromptu nature of inclement weather closures such rem remote learning days will resemble more of a w Wednesday a synchronous instructional Day from the old hybrid learning model which was employed during the covid-19
058pandemic while some teachers may elect to use Virtual meets for synchronous instruction most educators will post their lesson materials and assignments on our learning management system entitled schooo item next legislative lobbying Mr Corbin and yours truly met with assemblyman El stury and a number of other local school district officials to discuss the legislative priorities for the budget season ahead assemblyman stury was receptive to the input and we took time to thank him excuse me for the Sam's Grant which you know as a board has been earmarked for the purchase and installation of four excuse me electronic signs on our campus furthermore darl wheeler and I represented the school district at this Saturday's Central New York school boards Association legislative forum Forum where assemblyman stury and New York Senator Ryan state senator Ryan were in attendance
059among others to learn more about the governor's budget from Rick Dr Rick Tims from the schoolwide state Statewide School Finance Consortium the meeting this weekend ended with commentary from the elected officials and a moderated question and answer session item next new school climate and culture survey to be offered to families with the student and faculty staff surveys in the rearview mirror our attention now turns to the version that will be administered to our families in working with research and marketing strategies out of Baldwinsville New York our third-party vendor helps to ensure that all responses are Anonymous and confidential we've been comparing the results longitudinally for all subgroups including students faculty staff and families and item last new presidential orders and deployment of ice as you are aware governor hokel New York State Attorney General James
060and New York State education commissioner Rosa issued guidance on safeguarding the rights of immigrant students to that end I had the opportunity to meet with representatives from local law enforcement uh in addition to double-checking with our school district legal councel with respect to the presidential executive orders regarding ice as such fedal Manley a Central School District will abide by the law which stipulates that all students regardless of their immigration status have the right to a free appropriate public education in the event that a government official shows up at a school building to either speak with or remove a student School District staff have been instructed to immediately contact the superintendent's office the superintendent of schools or my design will contact School District legal councel and the student should not be released or information shared with
061those government offic officials until school Personnel have heard back from legal counsel in the interim school officials will reinforce furpa the family educational records Privacy Act and keep personally identifi Stu identifiable student information confidential I will be participating in a ncus webinar this week to learn more about our obligations under the recent presidential executive orders that ends my superintendent report for tonight thank you do everybody have any questions for Dr Ty nothing um so Dr Ty you mentioned that you're going to attend the webinar later this week about the other executive orders I know we've gotten some questions um can you know to try to understand what the any changes at the federal level might mean to FM is that what the webinar is looking at or is there anything that you can speak to
062on that well as you know I mean the executive orders have been churning out daily the webinar this week is on ice again in immigration status but I'm sure they will be hosting others regarding the dismantling of the Federal Department of Education and so forth but is it safe to say that at this point in time the the amount of federal funding that FM receives is relatively low comparatively to other districts that may be potentially more impacted most definitely it's important to us especially title one and I know our business official Mr Brad Corbin is keeping the puls on that but every little bit matters during difficult times so uh certainly we'll keep an eye on it I know you're right the vast majority comes in through property taxes and state aid from New York
063State uh but we certainly pay attention to our F federal grants as well Dr Ty isn't it my understanding that title one preceded the development of the Department of Education so with any luck that will be sustained one would think you're right I mean uh the Federal Department of Education began in 1979 under then President Jimmy Carter and then continued forward so you're right there were items that existed prior to so I think as the government looks at its efficiency study uh it'll be interesting to see what is maintained in terms of communication with our our staff and our community I think um it's very important that we are reassuring people um I mean some of the things that are being said in regards to Educators and um groups minority groups in this country are
064very concerning to a lot of people and I just hope that as this process goes on we will make sure we're reaching out and letting people know that we support them I mean everything from ten years being attacked to you know people's right to exist you know um people not being able to be referred to by their um gender um so I just hope that we are making sure that we are reinforcing that how our standards are in this community um for for our values um regarding our staff and our community and I know local law enforcement was indicating that a group of local law enforcement in the central New York area we're going to meet with ice officials so they will keep us posted on that as well in terms of what their progress
065is Dr tyon I'm just curious on the the legislative form that you attended there's some several bills that are have been proposed in depending on the ebos Mandate dates was there any discussion about that yes well certainly I mean at the presidential level they've talked about rolling back obviously some of the dates and what was discussed at The Forum and as wheer can jump in here as well uh I mean just to be able to switch over to electric buses or zero emission buses is going to be problematic uh for districts not only the financial implications to end up delivering what we current deliver deliver now with diesel buses but also the infrastructure improvements as well we've done a study involving uh the grid and the supply for electric but uh they even talked as
066you know about uh facilities planning who you know we deal with with our construction projects all of a sudden having 700 plus districts entering in for new bus garages with all the infrastructure improvements so this is a huge number that we're talking about and I know you know that as part of the facilities committee I think everybody their heart tells them one thing and we want zero footprint and green and and and everything that we do but at the same time uh it's a number that would impact our operating budget so in order to buy buses and to replace diesels could mean and probably will mean cutting back on other parts of the budget that's my question is not not on the federal level just on the state level whether there whether there's any sense
067of the deadline current deadlines moving or not moving it was pretty clear from the room how how the superintendents and the board members felt and certainly the legislators get the get the message El stpy had it right along because he was promoting the hydrogen right hydrogen fuel cell or even propane buses which we've tried I mean I think uh as you know and you'll hear more at facilities committee so spoiler alert for those of you that belong to it I mean we've been using an electric bus on campus during some of the cold days here and uh surprising it doesn't get the mileage that it's advertised to get and it finally warms up just when you're pulling it back into the bus garage to to plug it in again so our students and the bus
068driver be sure to dress in layers warmly uh because the heat is not optimal let's just say it was pretty clear that the manufacturers couldn't possibly provide the buses that every District would need to meet this deadline so that right there any other questions or comments for Dr tce okay thank you item 3.05 so reports darl is there anything from the legislative well I think I would only add I I'm pretty sure I told you all that I wrote to all the representatives and state senator um Chris Ryan um I did have a very nice response from him and then I was able to meet him personally on Saturday I would just like to say to all of you I I think I well we didn't have a forum during the one year of the
069pandemic but I think I've been to most all the others and most boards send two or three or sometimes four people as along along with a superintendent and a business official and um I hope some of you will will pick that up next year it's it's very valuable I bet most of you if not all of you had Dr Tims in your training he usually does the right and uh I don't know anybody else do you Craig in The District in this in the state who could explain the ins and outs of the budget and the money it's I wish I could do it justice for you but I'm I just hope that one of you or two of you will will look forward to that it's really valuable thank you for participating darl appreciate
070it uh Mara bosis oh we're meeting this Thursday um we were supposed to have our um CTE regional meeting but that was cancelled due to weather so a report next time isan hello uh coming from the student board member me uh We've recently had our dance Marathon kickoff it was very successful and I thank all our MC's and choreograph choreographers add and Hayden and our videographer Sydney who worked very hard on both the movie and the performance and theun raer for Camp good days is in progress and will continue up until the dance marathon mid-march and we just had our uh cineman the FM model un Club was thankful for for the board members who came to cinnamon and in the early January raised over 9,000 and Syracuse Maxwell scholarship with 35 schools and 800
071students in attendance the annual conference at Syracuse University was a success and we just recently had our black Hy month uh assembly was very successful student body was engaged was an educational and exper educational and enriching experience and mid-march we were going to have our prom the musical uh the musical is in production and rehearsed there has been some complications but that's why we have the students here to discuss about it Isam will you be participating in dance Marathon no I was going to say don't fail to you could ask us for support well I was going to say how could I would be curious if there are ways that the board could support dance Marathon um other than fundrasing wise if there are I'm not studing up or anything just curious if there is
072some something that we could show our support of the students in that way yeah maybe next year if you guys comes maybe next year next year darl Daryl and Dan offered to chaperone all 24 hours just for the record that was when they were learning [Laughter] phonics okay is that all Isa thank you very much okay so now we have item 4.01 public comment so I believe we have two individuals for public comment um Matthew would you like to go first and we and both individuals are students correct Matthew and Caroline so welcome thank you for daring to do this we appreciate it hello my name is Matthew skring I'm a senior at FM high school and I am Trent Oliver in our production of the prom I'm here today to bring up the lyric
073changes in one of our songs Love Thy Neighbor a song I spearhead the production crew has decided to remove any mention of Jesus Christ or Christian themes from the song while I understand their sentiment I have come here today to State my case defend the song and share the sentiment that my castmates and I share firstly I want to clarify that nothing in the song is in any way offensive I myself am a Greek Orthodox Christian who has done a lot of research and a lot of digging and a lot of thinking with this number and I can say with 100% sincerity that there is nothing in this number that is in any way anti-christian anti-bible or anti- Jesus this number simply uses jesus' message of love acceptance appreciation and forgiveness which is so absent
074from the characters that Trent is lecturing this number is very important to the plot of the show uh the message of Jesus's love that Trent conveys resonates deeply with his students who previously displayed hatred towards the main character character Emma simply for being homosexual additionally Love Thy Neighbor is very important to the message of the show acceptance and unity is what the show is all about Trent cleverly uses the Bible and Jesus to highlight the intolerance of the students and it works by the end of the show the students support and love Emma and without such a personal message being delivered to them it's not likely this outcome would have occurred changing these lyrics to be more more secular not only subtracts from the message it also subtracts from the plot this message of unity
075the message of loving your neighbor like Jesus commands the message of acceptance no matter your beliefs religion or identity is inherent to this show and I really want and my cast as well wants to get that point across uh it is also um crucial to mention the legality of changing these lyrics As far as I know our our um license company theater wrs worldwide TRW for short does not did not give the production team any um permission nor did we uh ask for permission to change these lyrics um so that's just something to add on on top of that um I hope that my points have been made clearly I hope that we can strive to accept one another and by uncensoring this song we can get the message across through our show my castmates
076and I understood this show going in we understood its cont its controversy we understood its themes we understood everything about it and we want to deliver as it was written above all I'm here for my cast and I'm here for the show thank you thank you very much we really appreciate that feedback um and and I I think we're we'll need to talk about this a little bit perhaps Dr tce I don't know if there's any comments that you want to make at this point or not no okay didn't you want can we ask a question or two then like how many complaints did were received that led to the change in the lyrics we received a few complaints probably half dozen a half dozen complaints and now the young man was very astute and
077had that wonderful point about the legality of it kudos to you for coming up with that one um so have we looked into that we can look into it we sure should he sounds like he's already done the research he could probably share that with us bet has it good idea do we believe that we are um bound to whatever decisions have been made at this point or is there do we think there is flexibility with making additional changes I can answer any questions now that I am sorry just want toy do you have that research that time nothing nothing that I have with me but um I do know that you do have to ask permission from uh the licensing company in order to um change the lyrics and as again as far as
078I know I've spoken to the production team there has been no request of permission it see it's some it seemed very spontaneous just based on the reaction of the production team to these complaints Matthew I was curious so you obviously are representing the cast and delivered um a great comment that and passionate comment I was wondering have you spoken to your director about these concerns yes um I've spoken to our assistant director Mary Nixon as well as our director Mr Hebert um and he shares the same sentiment that I do um so I'm just this is just um he just feels trapped I guess in the um just due to um you know comments uh so this is just uh just so I can get my voice heard so um because he requested this thank
079you for the record on that the school edition is different from the Broadway musical and the movie so there were edits from the Broadway musical and the movie so vernacular terrible words were removed already so I guess I'm confused a little if the cast and the director are not supportive of making the change I'm just who is who did make the decision half doz people other what did you say I'm sorry well they didn't make the change we I think the board's heading down a slippery slope I think be careful so Sor I think we have one more person for public comment can we hear that comment yes thanks sorry thank you Matthew Caroline hello my name is Caroline Zoya James I'm a junior at FM high school and I'm Kaylee in our school's production
080of the prom I'm here today to speak on the line and lyric changes in the show as Matthew had previously mentioned the song Love Thy Neighbor is a crucial part of the plot of our show and the changing of particular lyrics and lines that mention religion takes away from the message of love and acceptance that the song is trying to send a key ideology in Christianity is the idea of loving and accepting everyone as they are as Jesus did hence the phrase Love Thy Neighbor this show simply takes lines from scripture and presents it in the form of song explaining to the homophobic students in the show that they shouldn't judge others while they also do things wrong in accordance to the Bible the vast majority of the cast agrees that the song is necessary
081to the show and its goal is not to offend any member of the community but to uplift positive and inclusive values within it a survey was conducted today with the cast and over 97% of students agreed that the line and lyric changes were hurting the message rather than helping it and there have been some suggestions for how we can convey that message of acceptance to the community having a disclaimer to preface the show mentioning the fact that the show touches on some controversial topics and is a form of social commentary could be helpful in the shows in showing the cast's perspective on the positive aspects of our show's message whether that disclaimer is written out in the play bill or spoken at the beginning of the show it could help the community see that in
082no way does the FM music program intend on attacking any group of people but rather lifting everyone up and showing how welcoming our community can be thank you thank you very much for your feedback so we have heard the feedback and I know that for public comment we don't have to respond um so but is there anything that anybody has an opportunity we certainly can so Sarah can you um take a takeaway and talk to legal counsel and just figure out where we are legally with this so do we have to present the so exactly as it's written are we allowed to make changes is so I don't want us to get in trouble over this right I'd rather not get sued by a copyright company so if we could talk to Legal yeah we
083certainly could take that action I think the only thing to be mindful of there this is not a typical board level decision this is an administrative decision that does not rise into our decision making Authority I just want to be very clear about that it's as much as we may want it to be it is not y so the only thing I I understand and so the only thing that I want to just remind of and I know people are aware of Dr Ty is you have this discussion internally with the administrative team is that the musical is March 7th and 8th today is February 10th um it is approaching very quickly so if there are any changes to be made or things to be restored that needs to be answered and determined expeditiously so
084that the cast has the opportunity properly to actually learn what it is that they're going to be on stage performing and I'll just add to that comment I mean nobody at this table made any edits for the record and you're right it's an administrative decision that as you can see from our reading program I delegate to an assistant superintendent for instruction for an example who works with the faculty and staff I mean there's a two-way channel of communication that occurs so again nobody at this table made any edits and I think that's important to reference that being said I agree with our speakers in the sense I want the show's message to be out there we have talented students we have wonderful message of inclusive uh inclusivity I got a cold inclusion of about that
085but at the same time I don't want anything to detract from it as well and having lived through last year you know our Communications Department struggling with the anti-semitic remarks on an article that really wasn't anti-semitic people were reading into it having dealt with the covid mask versus no mask I mean we often have political ends of the spectrum so I'm delighted that they came tonight because you're right to miss mim's uh comment you don't want a few people on one hand but at the same time I think the answer is somewhere in the middle that to pick one side or the other is a slippery slope to get on and that's where I was headed I mean you own that decision and now all of a sudden it's like you don't talk religion or
086politics and we're kind of doing that here I think it's important to look for bipartisan opportunities to keep this moving forward to send that message of inclusion but not to take anything away from our talented students through protests fights in the parking lot because people are you know wetted to a certain philosophical or idiot you know logical I I understand that and I appreciate that and I also think that as a district when we go through the process of selecting our musical whatever it might be that I I presume that there is a process and there's an evaluation and determining what's the best choice to engage in and we spend funds on that um so if I just I think there we're always times to evaluate that throughout the process because we don't make those
087decisions now right we make them summer long time ago so I just from a understanding from the process perspective that there are opportunities to understand what we're saying yes to and got to commit and be supportive of the decision as made okay thank you thank you for coming thank you for sharing your feedback next new business item 5.01 um be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manliest school district approved the minutes of the regular meeting held on January 13 2025 as presented may I have a motion please thank you Daryl and Chrissy any discussion I have a question on in the minutes where under executive session there's a a vote in there but I was looking at the letter that we received where it said the vote should be or the
088resolution should be an open session so it's shows that it was an executive session as opposed to open session in the minutes so shouldn't that be open session and then it shows darl and I made the Motions but it doesn't and then show a five three vote but doesn't show who voted in which direction so shouldn't that be reflected in the minutes and shouldn't that not be under executive session that vote based on the letter that we received um that's how it was done that night we've gotten guidance since of how we should be doing it going forward but the minutes reflect how it was done on that date okay well the minutes do reflect how it was done on that dat but it was not done correctly um can we at least amend it
089amend it to include votes in favor and votes oos I don't know why that's not in there yeah okay adj that Sarah thank you thank you okay so with that adjustment all in favor I anybody opposed ear abstaining Jes thank you item 5.02 be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle school district approve the minutes of the workshop held on January 27th 2025 as presented may I have a motion Jason thank you and Cindy any comments okay all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining Mera item 5.03 be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle Central School District hereby adopts the 4,000 series policy in second reading and defers enactment until the completion of the policy transition may I have a motion and thank you second Cindy any
090comments discussion all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining okay item 5.04 be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manlia Central School District hereby moves the nisba 8000 series policies into second reading for the next regular board meeting May I have a motion Marissa and Ann thank you any comments discussion all in sir I've got one so if we move it into second that that's fine but I just would like somebody to take a look at um policy 855 the last three lines of that policy so what the line what the policy states is is that basically if a student has money left on their prepaid meal fund at the end of the year it reverts to a sibling and if there's not a sibling after a certain amount of time the
091school district keeps it the problem is that kind of conflicts with New York state of she statment law um that money normally would get remanded to the state and not kept at the district so can we just double check our policy to make sure it's on alignment absolutely thank you okay um all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining thank you all right item 6.01 um board development I don't have anything on that front unless anyone else does um item 6.02 so we have our potential considerations for future meetings um I think so the school start time um Dr Ty that you mentioned that you had the one meeting and then you're inviting staff to the next meeting and expanding out faculty and staff we've reached out uh to start with the teachers first and then
092adding okay as we go along great and do and I know sometime in the spring we were going to have um Trisha report out on restorative justice correct we don't have a I believe we're working in for the June meeting right is that what we said today I'm looking at Amy yep June okay June did you have a preference on the AI time frame I attend the national AI conference in early April so I would think sometime in May all right and we've been talking the cell phone use depending on how um Governor hok's budget comes through we have to have the policy by August 1st as you know so we'll be working on that post tase yep okay um I does anybody have any other discussion items on that okay item 7.01 future meeting
093agendas so moving into budget season will'll be working on all of those aspects um 7.02 dates to remember um so we have de committee this week pink out basketball games coming up um some concerts all sorts of things okay anything else okay and moving into consent agenda may I have a motion to approve the consent agenda please thank you Cindy and second thanks Daryl all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining thank you okay and we have an additional executive session um be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville Manley Central School District enter executive session for the purpose of discussing one two two one appeal I'm sorry Oneal one student disciplinary matter and the employment history of particular persons may have a motion thanks there and Chrissy and all in favor anybody
094opposed or abstaining great okay so we are going to go into ex sorry yes we're going to go to Executive session and then we will come back to vote and then adjourn so thank you for e for e for e e for you e e e okay we're we're back oh no we're waiting for Jason so it's like I'm out we've got enough can we we're not allowed to lose a member well people have left early before can you just okay be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle Central School District enter no no ah be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle Central school district has reviewed the record of a 3214 hearing per a parent Guardian request for appeal and hereby uh app upholds the
095discipline as previously levied may I have a motion thank you darl and a second Dan any no discussion may all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining great and then 11.01 adjournment may I have a motion to adjourn thank you all in favor thank you couple thank you