001for e e e we're gonna call the meeting we ready call the meeting to order are we ready okay let's stand for the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you all right item 1.03 approval or revision of agenda uh be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle school district approved the agenda as presented may I have a motion is everything okay Chrissy and a second thank you an and all in favor okay all right now we're moving into reports um item 2.01 is a presentation on the K12 mathematics good evening happy holidays to everybody thank you for another opport Unity to share information with
002you and our community through our second curriculum presentation tonight we're going to highlight the work of K12 math and with me are our k6 math curriculum Specialists Mrs fuler and Mrs Simone our middle school math department leaders Mrs aluer and Dr Meyers and our high school instructional specialist Mr delans in each of our presentations this year our goal is to highlight the work that is happening in our district as well as how it connects to our district strategic plan this plan is directly connected to New York State's culturally responsive sustaining education fra framework the district first began a deep dive into staff development around welcoming and affirming environments a few years ago we have shifted our Focus to inclusive curriculum and assessment this shift has been very timely as the state has unveiled a new
003five-year Plan called New York inspires this plan which was released last month will likely be adopted in the spring by the board of region and it's based on the recommendations of the Blue Ribbon commission and that is aligned to the crse framework that you see here all four parts of the framework are interchangeable and we hope that tonight's presentation will give you a glimpse as to where all four live in FM already the title of uh tonight's presentation is creating mathematical mindsets to unleash the potential of all students FM Works to collectively Foster this every day there is no such thing as someone who is bad at math the approaches that you'll see tonight will reflect our strategic plan to expand opportunities to promote student engagement educational equity and personal ization of instruction the examples
004you'll hear are reflective of our efforts to create Collaborative Learning environments that support student inquiry and welcome students in an affirming environment that values and respects everyone so with that I will turn the presentation over to our k6 math instructional Specialists hi good evening um so we just wanted to start by briefly introducing you to the mathematical standards they're a little different than some of the other areas the other content areas and that we have two sets of standards in mathematics so from prek through 12 we have our mathematical practice standards and these are the same eight standards at every level um and this is really how math is taught so this is teaching students problem solving and thinking abstractly making models Etc and we also have the content standards which are specific to each
005grade level and so that um just thought we'd share that so I thought we'd start by talking about how we affirm students and we do this we have some fabulous resources that work in conjunction and are actually from the Publishers of our K5 math program so we're very fortunate we have um something called The Forum for equity and elementary mathematics and that comes directly from the Turk investigation authors and we'll have some specifics for you there but in particular this presents reflection tools that are given to students and or teachers and routines by which they are talking about how they interact with math class so it could be um how they what they bring in from home who teachers are calling on how often students participate and it's very reflection based and it comes directly
006from our authorship team so that's a great thing that we're really working on rolling out into as many classrooms as we possibly can and then we have storytelling math which is also by our Turk authorship team and it is a um set of picture books that they have created so that it is narrative first rather than stilted kind of silly little books that aren't truly narrative and high quality and they represent all different cultures and the culture of the author and the culture presented in the picture book match and then um finally we have number talks the number talks have been around for a while and it's a great way for students to participate to learn about mistak making revising their thinking and flexible thinking so we invite all students to participate and make mistakes
007in that way we just wanted to share a little bit more um about the storytelling math because these are just beautiful picture books that have been created and written um in conjunction with our math program k6 um Katie and I have had the opportunity to push into many of the Early Elementary classrooms and read these stories alongside with students um the the authorship team also wrote a guide that goes along with each of the books that have matching activities um whether it be discussion based something to do with the math that's happening in the book um but it's been really um really wonderful to be able to be in the classrooms and be reading these with students um they're very very engaging text texts um that are just really colorful and fun um so we
008just thought we'd bring those to share around today in addition we have some examples up on the board of some of the student reflection responses from the questionnaires for the from The Forum of equity um in MA elementary mathematics they are just fabulous the students all have a story to tell about their in interactions with math and not only there the students really excited to share an opportunity have an opportunity to share things that they don't always get to share around a typical math class the teachers are very very excited to get to know these things and so it's created these beautiful connections one classroom I was using these Reflections tools with last year resoundingly said as a group they absolutely did not like coming down to the carpet for the introduction in math class
009and the teacher was floored she was like I would no one would have ever told me that it would not have had any reason to do that and so she made a change and so that's just truly the students as Learners of math across all things about them how they can communicate their needs as Learners to the teacher and we can affirm all of them with whatever they're bringing to the classroom next we wanted to talk about high expectations so at the top you'll see our two primary resources for kindergarten through sixth grade the first is Turk investigations and Turk investigations is a program we've been using it nfm since 1999 which is really a long time ago now and um we are currently using the Third Edition of Turk investigations which is aligned with
010the common core and then within the district we have taken that and made any modifications we need to make it match the New York State Standards then for sixth grade they use the Connected Mathematics project which is also in its Third Edition Common Core and we at FM have supplemented and adopted it to match the New York State Next Generation standards and we have been with a Connected Mathematics project since 2003 below that we have some of those supplemental things that we like to bring around to the different Elementary classrooms so these are just some examples that are what is referred to as lowf floor high ceiling tasks so the low floor means that there's an entry point for everybody so everybody can find a way into the problem but with a high ceiling they
011can take it to different heights based on their understanding their engagement and that type of thing so these are just some examples we've had a lot of success in some grade levels in particular second grade at m road has taken off with this they have a game night where they invite all the families in and again what better way to have high expectations to affirm students than to get their families involved and so they learn the games with us and their teachers at school so they don't miss out even if they can't come to the game night and then they have that opportunity to come to the game night and really engage further and and bring families in if possible the next section we wanted to talk about was inclusive curriculum and assessment um so
012in k6 we have a district assessments that are given to all students um at the end of each unit these have been Fair L static Assessments in that they were for a very long time our only data point um and so we really needed to have each assessment stay the same but recently we've added in um two standardized measures am web and star math at different levels that are given to students um am web students two through four three times a year and star math is given at the middle school level three times a year and so we're hoping to kind of look back at our district assessments unit assessments to see how we can help make them even more accessible to all students moving forward additionally we just thought we'd mention some of the
013practice tools that are available to students um we have many one at each level at least um that are subscriptions that the district pays for so we have at the K2 level total Math it's a really engaging fun math app that kids really really enjoy um getting on at the elementary K2 level um we have at 3 through 5 I know it math which links to our standards um teachers can uh assign a specific or specific tasks to students based on the standards they're currently working on and then in sixth grade we have a program called math Excel that links with our um sixth grade math curriculum and lastly new this year we have a program that we've just begun to kind of roll out this fall it's called first in math and it's a
014computer-based program that the New York state is um kind of promoting and funding for all public schools um Statewide so we kind of got ourselves connected with that and are rolling that out in um the Elementary classrooms as well is a formative assessment but also gather that information to communicate with parents when things are when they're noticing different things mathematically our formative assessments are ongoing based on class needs some of them are teacher um created some of them are within the program but we have that ongoing formative assessment that um teachers are using to check in with students and then Laura mentioned our district end of unit assessments as a summi of assessment and the it's kindergarten through sixth grade have consistent District assessments and again we have always kept those the same because it
015was our primary data point for anything that we needed mathematically but as am web and star are coming in and we're transitioning to that we're really ready to roll up our sleeves and take a look at those in terms of any inclusive it that we can bring in to those assessments so that's more to come in terms of math and inclusivity within assessments because we're seeing a transition in gathering data in a summi of assessment sort of way so Andrew and I will talk a little bit about the extension of the elementary into the middle school level so as we take a look at how we affirm students in the middle school classroom um well establishing a welcoming environment is very important to us many teachers do several different activities to get to know our
016students to understand the mathematics that they're coming from and where we're going um in the classroom we have a combination of group work partner work and individual work for students so we can reach their needs at the different levels we'd like to highlight many different approaches for students stud as they're solving problems trying to encourage them to solve problems in different ways showing their work through the use of algebra through the use of drawings through through the use of other plenty of other um materials we continue the exploration of using the open-ended problems as well as the low floor high ceiling activities that Katie mentioned we are several of us are either currently or have read the book building thinking classrooms and many of the ideas there we incorporate into our classrooms with flexible grouping
017and um the major focus of the first part of the book is vertical um workstations where kids can record things and it's an erasable format so kids can tweak and change their work as they're working instead of committing to something on paper uh we have several different pieces of additional academic support for our students in the middle school we have um math lab at our levels and it looks a little bit different at fifth and sixth grade than it does seventh and eth but kids can come to see a math teacher for additional support we have enrichment period after school where kids can come in throughout um our teaching day we also have direct consult teaching we have other supporting teachers to help our students there after school enrichment activities vary from offering extra help
018to kids as well as we um both middle schools have Math League teams we have a first Lego League which is is a mixture of some of the stem um areas with math science and coding technology we do have a coding club and Robotics clubs as well all right and from the pictures here you can see these are some of the samples of the different activities that kids have worked as we look at developing high expectations we continue the growth mindset using examples from Joe bowler and car Carol DW as well as on the mathematical thinking classrooms we encourage kids the idea that learning from their mistakes is really important and it's a good thing to make mistakes in life that's how we learn through making mistakes once again we offer also differentiated instruction whether
019it's a class activity where we have the kids that are grouped um heterogeneously and we see that they are um we can create activities that are reaching our kids that who have several needs our average kids as well as pushing our top level kids by offering different activities where the kids don't even realize the difference of what they're seeing but in the groups they're working together on these things we do um also have a program where some of our high school tutors come down and work with our students and that's a nice opportunity for high school kids to interact with the middle school students once again our Junior High Math League our students at um Eagle Hill and Wellwood have traditionally performed very well at that so that's a spot to extend as well okay
020and we wanted to share with with you one of our low floor high ceiling tasks this was from seventh grade math it's called the acrobat task so they were it was a tug-of war between grandmothers and acrobats and a dog and they had to look at the different scenarios and decide based on the scenario in the fourth round who would win the grandmothers and the dog pulling against the four acrobats and you can see on the right hand side these are some of the strategies on the whiteboards that the students were using and there was a whole variety of strategies which which was so exciting to them be able to share and pull together with the whole class here's how this group thought about it here's how that group thought about it and what were
021the commonalities what were the differences and the kids have really enjoyed working on those vertical nonp perent surfaces and learning from one another as well and in terms of our focus on algebra the algebra strand goes K through 12 so at the middle school we focus on having concrete pictoral and then building up to the abstract representations so these are some of the models that we have used at the middle school level there's Hands-On Equations which is that tactile piece making sure that the equation staying balanced Sol me mobiles is a online tool that we use that is again application based but has that pictoral look to it as well Clos line math where they actually get to manipulate and move the different values the variables and the numbers and tape diagrams all with the
022goal of leading them to that abstract inverse operations and then how do we make curriculum and suance inclusive to all Learners we have a variety of tools that we're using some of the technology tools that we're using are the ti Rover the spos and Explore Learning gizmos which is that Discovery based in 8th grade and in some of seventh grade we start dipping into the ti Inspire graphing calculators math Excel is a continuation from elementary that goes up to sixth grade first in math is new this year so we're exploring ways of how to incorporate that in our instruction Delta math which again has that growth mindset where students can learn from their mistakes and not be penalized for making mistakes but learn and grow from them and desnos is also an online platform that
023we use as well and Mr D good evening my name is Brad delans and I'm the instructional specialist at the high school and I appreciate being here tonight uh the first area I'd like to talk about is how we affirm our students at math in the high school and um one of the ways is we help students succeed in giving them uh many pathway choices to acquire their three credits of math at the high school as you can see from this flowchart that was developed actually by one of my students this year it shows how we offer 17 unique math classes at the high school and there's over over 35 different Pathways that a student can choose in order to get their three CR minimum three credits of math at the high school we of
024course encourage them to go for four credits of math um but you can see there's many many Pathways for students to choose in order to be successful at math in the high school another way that we affirm students is our Math League we have an excellent math league program this year we have 55 students active in Math League it's an after school program where students come and they compete against other students in challenging and thought provoking problems they work together in teams to build those critical thinking skills and collaborate together in problem solving they compete against one another they compete against other schools in the county and then we do send students to the state meet each year and it's just a great program and students are excited to be part of it uh in
025the classroom we work to build community using many other tools one of those tools is our navigator system if you have a student in the high school you've probably seen our favorite calculator the T Inspire and every math classroom the high school has a navigator system and we have these hats and these hats click on the top and the hats make the calculators Wireless and what the teacher can do is you can see on my screenshot here the teacher can then project every single student's screen at the same time so we can see what they're doing so here's an example where we were asking students to graph a quadratic equation to model a ball that's been thrown through the air at a velocity of 55 ft per second from a height of 5 ft and
026we said when will the ball land as you can see student one was able to graph it properly change the window settings so they could see the path of the ball and then answer the question that the ball lands in 3.53 seconds student three we can see had a little problem with gravity their ball instead of going up and coming down went down and came back up so we could share like what's going on there another student might share hey the gravity constant has to have a negative coefficient in order to have the graph oriented in the right direction student four on the far right there was trying to answer the question numerically and instead of graphically and they were looking at the tea table trying to find the answer it's a great approach but
027unfortunately the answer was a decimal and the tea table only brings up whole numbers so they knew it landed between three and 4 seconds but not exactly when student to needed help with changing their viewing windows so they could see it was actually taking the shape of a parabola so another student could help them with that and then there's student five who's not quite on task right now and we can help nudge them in the right direction to join the rest of the class the system is wonderful and having the students share all their different approaches to solving problems the navigator system also allows us to send out quizzes and collect information back immediately so we can see who's getting it and who's not without the other students knowing and we also can put a
028student in charge of the large calculator on the screen so they can demonstrate their knowledge and share their approach to solving a problem so it's a great system that allows us to affirm students in the classroom um also important is building a welcom Community where students feel involved and engaged and and learning is enjoyable and achievable this is the some pictures from the Tuesday before Thanksgiving of my pre-calculus class where we were working on a trig identity puzzle they were given 24 triangles that each had a trig identity on one of the sides and they had to figure out a matching trig identity using their problem solving skills and then build the hexagon and it gave them a chance right before a break to engage in a fun activity but still involved complex problem solving
029and they were able to collaborate and work together on on something and achieve the goal and then we we hung them up all around the classroom developing high expectations for our students is obviously important in the math classroom at the high school and this takes many forms in many of our classes we offer problem sets which give students a chance to take a little bit longer looking at some complex problem solving they're typically assigned over the course of a week we offer honors level classes in all of our areas so algebra geometry Algebra 2 and pre calculus all have honors level classes we also offer an AP class in calculus which covers calc 1 and calc 2 and we have a super class in calculus and in statistics uh the ti technology is another way
030that we uh helps us encourage high expectations by using the Rover systems where they can do some programming using mathematical models to make a the robot move um and it doesn't really matter what class they're in we're holding them to the high standards so the example shown here is an algebra modeling example where we're teaching them how to solve a quadratic equation we teach them four different methods to solve that the quadratic formula by factoring on this slide you can see we also show them how to solve it by graphing and by completing the square it doesn't matter if they're in an honors class or if in their they're in our 2-year algebra A1 A2 class they're all going to be held to the same rigor and they're all going to learn the same methods
031of solving a quadratic equation um how do we make our curriculum and assessment inclusive to all Learners which is obviously very critical as well um one way we do this is we make sure that everybody understands why math exists I think if they understand why math exists they'll be more engaged in the learning and that math exists in order to model things in the real world and almost anything can be modeled by a mathematical model and related to a mathematical model linear models can be used to calculate the earnings of a part-time job exponential models can be used to model the growth of a city for city planners quadratic models can model the object a projectile that's been thrown in motion like a football player throwing a football a sinusoidal model can be used to
032model anything periodic like the tides of the ocean or the orbits of the planets a logarithmic model can be used to model the economy once students understand why math exists they become more engaged and we try to approach math from four angles we want students to understand that we can describe any function verbally algebraically graphically and numerically and the approach we take depends on what questions are they trying to answer and what are they trying to learn from that mathematical model all of our teachers provide guided note packets and post their finished notes every day on schoolagy this gives students who have access to copies of class notes through their IEP or students that are absent on a field trip or out sick can immediately go to the teacher schooly page and find out what
033we did in class that day get the copy of the class notes and find out any other pertinent information that'll be posted there uh we also offer a 1511 class in algebra A1 and algebra A2 at the high school which is exciting and wonderful that we do that and all of the Math teachers are busy ninth period and also in the learning support center during the day helping students be successful and master the content that they're learning we encourage students to stay after with their math teacher or if their math teacher is not available with any math teacher that's avail after school we look forward to evolving as New York State graduation standards change and adding new and exciting math courses to our offerings in the future thank you the last piece that we just
034wanted to quickly mention because we know we're over time um is the ongoing professional learning which is just so numerous there are so many things going on across the district um at the elementary level K through six um we provide District monthly curriculum meetings um where the curriculum Specialists are meeting monthly with all teachers um these are a great way for teachers at different buildings and grade levels to get together um and collaborate on different ideas at the middle school we have department meetings um that that are function in a similar way um we have such wonderful opportunities to get to different conferences as uh Math teachers the only thing better than working with students is geeking out with other mathematicians so we have opportunities to go to bosis for um math leadership groups and
035specific math collaboration groups every year we send some teachers to the association association of mathematics teachers of New York state conference and as a treat every once in a while we get some people to the National councils of teachers of mathematics National Conference um all of those are really invigorating and bring back huge and wonderful ideas in addition to that one thing that is really fantastic at FM is our inservice um system and you'll see from the pictures up here things that you have been hearing about from all of us throughout the night so these are three of the ins services that Laura and I are running districtwide we are supporting the teachers in the direct consult um teaching model and supporting students and differentiating for their students we are doing a course a series
036of courses actually on building thinking classrooms which Don and Andra mentioned just a little while ago and then we finished a first in math inservice where we had I believe over 30 teachers who took the course in order to get familiar with first in math and launch it the best thing about these inservice classes is we work very hard to select um topics that are open k12 and we have had side by side or in um communication and school G courses kindergarten and AP Calculus teachers d dialoging about things so we try to keep our initiatives very clear um as you've heard through the presentation get lots of ongoing professional development for those things um available to teachers and then I apologize for jumping around I know Dr doton has a couple other bullets in
037here she's gonna question okay wrap it up from there thanks everybody um thinking about where we want to go in the future right so there are a lot of big changes on um on the horizon for for New York State and the thing that I appreciate the most about being in FM is just that we have a growth mindset um and that's really what we're trying to instill uh through K12 math right we don't want any kid to to walk away and say I'm not good um at math um if if that happens then then we need to continue um to do this work um to that end um we are really focusing and digging deep into um parts of the Strategic plan around um around Dei um we have at this time all of
038our K12 teachers um in a program with Dr Meredith Matt and a 10-hour um asynchronous learning program um with her called Dei matters which really lays the foundation um for all of the work to come everything from the history of crsc to microaggressions to how do we um plan curriculum and create assessments that are inclusive to all students um we also will have a group um of K uh K12 teachers across uh six different um groups that will be working with Dr Madden um for theer of this year digging deep into a framework by which uh we can develop uh curriculum instruction and assessment that is fully aligned to the crsc framework and is inclusive to all students that work will also be a part of some of the uh changes to our Curriculum maps
039which I'm happy to talk about in the future um and in addition to that we have teachers participating in action research this year that is specifically focused on personalized learning and our district curriculum councils which is a a K12 leadership group that um works with all of their departments individually um began work last year um around the portrait of a graduate so taking a look at the skills that are part of that portrait which will be adopted um in the spring and digging deep into their current curriculums right now to think about how do we structure um our Curriculum maps and our curriculum to ensure that all of those skills are met um throughout the course of their K12 uh K12 education um we are piloting more High School courses for college credit um we
040are working to engage in Cross uh curricular uh work that will create some new interdisciplinary courses um at the high school and above all we are working to um Elevate student voice um across across all of our buildings um with all of that so these are a few of the examples um of what we call or what Dr Ty is called uh the little bets right we know that these are really really big changes um but they will happen in small incremental shifts that we are have um that are happening all over um our our district um so to that ends thank you very much for the time and we're happy to answer any questions that you have Dr Doon I was just wondering so we made reference in the case six and back on
041slide 11 we talk a little bit about the assessments that we have so I was just wondering do we have that data captured and is that something that can be shared with the board sure thank you and yes I just wanted to say that I was really glad to see the flowchart it it looks like there's only like three classes that all students no matter where they start in the Middle School um will be all students no matter what they started in middle school it's math 8 or the algebra regions they'll still all be able to get those high level classes there's a path for them I think there's only like three that they couldn't do they started with math eight and I think that's really impressive yeah I'm so appreciative of that flowchart and
042I love that a student created that and that will be um part of the the handbook for course selection going forward and it it again is a piece of you know uh sort of a misinformation right I think students assume that depending on what you're doing in eth grade like there is one one track here and One Track there and it's great to um to have a a student create some graphics to dispel some of those mths yeah I agree and I I think I've noticed there's been a concerted effort to try to kind of reinforce that messaging that there is no one siiz fits-all and lots of different paths um the other comment is I think it's great I've personally witnessed at the elementary level just how so many different opportunities for kids to
043show their creativity and how they approach math which I think is so different than what it was years ago so I'm guess I'm just curious at the higher levels are we seeing sort of the fruits of that labor payoff as kids go through FM to kind of embrace math in a more um positive way and looking at multiple ways to embrace the different learning styles yeah I don't want to speak for all of our teachers but certainly all the classrooms that I'm in we're we're starting to see those through lines again it's just it's not this idea of here's exactly where I need to get to to get to this college like I think these are Big conversations that we're also having in our big read we've had some great conversations across our community um
044about what is important and what is important is that again it's it's a low full or high stealing like so where are the places that every kid can enter um into their math classroom and where and and we want to make sure and and our curriculum special and teachers say say this a lot um we want to make sure not only do do kids believe that they they can succeed um in math but there is no such but going faster in math is should should not be the goal going deeper into math should be the goal and that's really a lot of the professional learning that has come out of Joe bowler's work is that doing well in math is not about going fast it's about going deeper and deeper and that's really where the
045differ differentiation comes in right that we can always push to um to do a little bit more um based on where a student is so it's it's a joyful place I hope that that's something that that you um really get a sense of is that there is a lot of joy in in K12 math that's for sure as I went through the program over the weekend I was tickled to see as a student and a teacher of the humanities I got excited about math um I think there's a math problem in that isn't there Brad that flowchart how if so and so right um I I love the little guy or woman girl I don't know whose great great grandfather worked with Einstein I mean you would not know that if you hadn't pose the
046question so I just am so happy and I love that so many things that I've written down but um that Carol DW's work is going not just Elementary where I knew it was but through middle school and I'm Pres resuming high school as well right so that's terrific and uh I'm just we have a really deep bench I'm not saying you're old but we have a lot of experience in this team truly truly right a yes a lot of experience thank you a compliment it is a compliment for sure no I appreciate all that you you're doing and have done yeah our teachers work incredibly hard and and again I um you know we we want to make sure that again the work never stops right so it's we what what can we do um
047to to make sure that every student um succeeds um and is able to do what they want to do moving on from FM I would love to hear especially at the high school level what's being seen and what's being taught with regard to integrating AI into this how much is it being used how much is it being encouraged to be used how much is it being discouraged to be used I i' I'd love to hear a little bit more on that absolutely I mean I'm we're we were we certainly benefited from having a full uh professional uh Development Day last November um again I think that put us far ahead of the conversation in most of the districts and my experience um in my time at Bose um because most of the early discussion around
048AI was around fear um and um and how it's going to harm and so usually when you approach Ro things with a you know with a fear model then you think about um immediately like well we got to we got to get rid of it um I think that day was one of those days where we talked about um all of the opportunities that our Educators um Can can do with AI to um to help in their classrooms to help it easier um to plan um as well as to instruct um but I think part of that too was we know that this is happening um regardless of whether or not we say we don't do it in FM they will this will be a part of their life um in College and Career and
049Beyond so it's really about um knowing it at a deep level at the at the educator and administrative level so that we can make good decisions in terms of instruction um I don't think there is any one approach in any classroom but I do know that um in the feedback that I've gotten from teachers over the last year and a half there is far more Comfort um in terms of being able to use uh materials and then that that has lent itself to instruction around how do we use this well um especially in terms of modeling for students about why AI is not always the answer that's particularly true in writing right um and in research um and the more that we can model that the more that we can teachs kids how to use
050it um ethically um so I'm happy to gather more information across all of our teachers K2 yeah to to Dan's Point um I know one of the conferences we were at um they talked about the use of AI even as a support for tutoring as an equity tool for helping kids who maybe didn't have access to private tutors or whatever who might be struggling and how they could maybe use AI to help them figure out how to solve problems and look at that so I was curious if that's something that's being used or at least talked about from I don't know specifically how to that one is but yes absolutely I think there are different places again we're in different places where some people are less comfortable some people are more comfortable but I'm happy
051to um to say that I think we're we're definitely not in a place where we're just saying well we'll just not do it because I don't think that's teaching our kids what what they need to do um um as adults so we're going to keep moving forward on that and I'll gather some more information on that any other questions all right thanks so much for time so much for [Applause] coming those are beautiful books all right we are transitioning to item 2.02 presentation about diligent community and is it Sandy solo all right I do have some backup good evening Board of Education members thank you for the opportunity to present to you this evening Sandy and I are excited to introduce you to an updated governance tool offered by diligent the parent company of board
052dos I am sorry that I couldn't be with you in person to present today but I hope this video will suffice Sandy and Dr Ty can answer your questions at the end of this presentation or you are welcome to email or call me after the board meeting to give you a little bit of history about FM's use of e governance products in 2010 FM adopted board dos at a conference in September of 2019 I learned about diligence new governance product called Community during that conference I noticed that our version of board do looked different than other users and discovered that bardock's product updates were not reaching a number of districts in our area due to firewall issues I coordinated with ocm bosis to make adjustments to the service hosting then with diligent to update our
053product now we hit pause until this September well let me back up a bit back in July I came across a demo video for community and I was impressed this September we were informed that board do users are being asked to transition to community due to boardd sunsetting within 5 years in November of 2024 I spoke with a representative from nisba who reported that they support the migration from bardocks to community so what is community it is a next generation e-governance solution that is transparent and inclusive secure and efficient Community is Ada and wcag 2.1 compatible and open meetings law compatible the product allows members of the community to subscribe to agenda notifications and request to speak during public comment it is secure through Google sign on integration with your existing log on credentials that
054you use for your email it is efficient through its new feature of being available on mobile devices as well as on standard computerss and its ability to download full meeting packets including attachments also Community search feature has been improved from the board doc search now I'm going to turn it over to Sandy to show you an example of community from another Board of Education thank you Sarah here we have an example of how a diligent community site looks and works if you click on the picture a link will pop up and you can go directly to the live site to review at your convenience from the landing page you are able to view the upcoming meetings recent meetings join the live stream for a current meeting review policies and anyone including but not limited to
055staff residents and community members can subscribe to receive email notifications about upcoming meetings as you can see it is extremely user friendly and easy to nav navigate if we SE select the welcome tab this is an example of what comes up you are able to access the calendar tab which gives you a view of the upcoming meetings and can include committee meetings there is also a tab for meetings which gives you the option of choosing previous board meetings or previous committee meetings there is also a search tab to find topics of Interest in upcoming Andor previous meetings if we open a recent meeting we have access to the agenda at this point there are several choices of presentation we can print the agenda Andor the agenda packet we can choose to view the split screen
056or watch with video as you see the live stream video is embedded and appears in the right hand corner of the screen this function makes it easy to follow along with the meeting and viewers can click on the corresponding PDF reports that the board is discussing now Sarah's going to explain what's new before I get into what's new I just wanted to make sure the board knows that although PDFs will be available there still will be public content and executive content like you're accustomed to on board docs the default level of accessibility is public content um and only those with specific credentials such as yourselves will be able to see the executive content within the system so now moving on to what's new some of the new features I told you about in the beginning
057of the presentation the mobile capability the Google sign on managed by our technology department the integration of requesting to speak during public comment which by the way is currently a separate step uh for our community members and the much improved visual appeal layout an embedded live stream that Sandy showed you but as they say in game shows but wait there's more you as members of the board will automatically receive a text message and email when an agenda is released this is currently a separate step of the board meeting process community members will also be able to subscribe to the notification service another feature that Dr Tyson I think you'll enjoy is the ability to privately annotate on agenda items within the system please know that if you opt to use this service you and only
058you will be able to see the notes that you make a new feature that I'm excited about is the committee management feature that Sandy showed you earlier the committee management tool will give each board committee a dedicated space within community that looks and operates similar to how board meetings work within the system you're welcome to review the Glen Brook site at your convenience clicking on meetings will show you how their committees are set up Sandy can you review the next steps with the board yes our next steps we will need to know when the board would like to transition to the new diligent community and please let us know if you need any additional information to help establish the transition timeline Bose Services requests are due in December of 2024 in April of 2025 for
059implementation in the 2526 school year year diligent will migrate everything over from board dos one thing Sarah and I would like to review prior to the migration is our board doc Library we want to know what library information the board finds valuable and what information the board would like us to Archive our goal is to make the new site as clean valuable and efficient as possible and now back to Sarah for the most important part of the presentation the financial before I begin I want to note that Sandy indicated that Bose's services are uh requests are due in December and April and board dos and Community are both considered a Bose service the figures I'm going to review with you today are all annual costs all of which are Bose's aable as you can see
060on this Slide the annual cost of board do is just over $1,000 and the cost of board dos hasn't changed since 2008 to maintain our current level of service in the new community product will cost $939 per year this includes meeting agendas policies and a document Library if the board wishes to add the committee manager enhancement the cost is an additional $3,188 the embedded live stream add-on is $3,060 bringing the full cost of implementation of all of community's features being 15,600 $50 per year now I will turn it over to those of you at Eagle Hill Sandy and Dr tyus would be happy to answer any questions you have wow what a presentation you guys voiceover actors um any midnight uh what questions does everyone have uh it's five years we don't have a specific
061date that I know of the reason I pointed at Mr cyberg is he sent us something earlier regarding one of the items on the agenda this will allow you to put your notes in nobody else will be able to see them unless you choose to share but at least everything you have you don't have to Fumble for papers everything would be in there for you in terms of your not notations yes y um so the committee option there that the 3,000 something what can you explain a little bit more about what that particular feature is yes so the committee documents everything will be in there like the board duck so for community Relations Committee you can click on that committee you'll see all the previous meetings you'll see any upcoming meetings if they're in there
062so it really as opposed to going to board docs going to library scrolling down to committees to finding it's just going to streamline everything can you subscribe to the calendar because that would be a beautiful thing if we instead of having to enter every single either through the Google Calendar if there was a way to subscribe to this calendar and populate your own personal calendar do you know if that functionalities available I don't could we find out I mean it wouldn't be a deal breaker but I would love to know um and then the second piece for me is just in terms of the timing I think if you're hoping to might sort of start with a new the new system with a clean library then I think we need the requisite time to make
063those decisions um so I would think maybe it's realistic to say we'd start in the next school year like July 1 so that we have some time to make those decisions because I think we will have some healthy debates about what to Archive what to keep sounds good do you think that the live stream feature would save like our av folks any time because it's would be all inter connected in there Sarah is looking into that there are two systems and I think one is like a box type the other's something different but she was looking in to see if it's easier or be if the two systems will work together or if we have to switch to a different system so on the public comment part um which we said was integrated will this
064allow people to do public comment remotely no but they can fill out what like if they want to come speak they can fill the form out right so they can do that within the system but that it's not like I couldn't ask to speak for public comment and do it from home with uh a monitor on my screen right correct you'd have to any other questions good for you to put it together was it fun yes good just wasn't clear on one thing on there so it said for implementation for the 25 26 school year that it was either January or April April so what what's the difference between we let you know by January versus let you know by ini requests are due now but we can certainly always add so for example we
065can it's it's tough to go the other way it's tough to say yes with the initial requests in December and then back off it in April but we could add in April if we so choose it's just the initial requests right now so bosies can plan their budget but who who's counting yeah in five years we're going to have to do it anyhow so the question is I think Miss Cen is just to be able to plant it so we don't face plant in terms of what we want to carry over and what we want to can we put our budget request in now and still do it in July and so we have the request in and then we can do all the other uh decision making in fact oops our district clerk isn't
066here she's actually at a conference on parent Square learning the additional features right now uh but uh I believe and I was kidding about the sun before midnight tonight the sooner we act we get in at the lower rate if we wait then obviously that's part of their marketing but as you see they've kept things pretty consistent since 2008 I'm sorry that's okay um so the only other thing to keep in mind and I believe believe Sarah mentioned that maybe we would have like um I don't know create like a little subcommittee or something to review the current board docks to figure out what we want to keep and what we want to let go of um so just with knowing that we're going to have additional meetings and obligations over this next year with
067superintendent search and all that I just I guess I'm not clear on how much time we're going to need to ask for board members to also review the documents if that's going to be a another big ask I don't know how much of an effort it really will be well we're not going to review like individual documents so it would be like looking at like the Thursday letters and saying you know keep these amount archive this and looking at committee meetings and things like that and looking at how much we have to keep um by law Etc so I think it shouldn't be that meetings because it's just big chunks of data as long as nobody I I think it's a no-brainer but I would I guess just um I think it would be a
068shame to lose anything old but maybe I'm crazy be archived right and still access be archived someplace else or we'd have it yeah okay we wouldn't lose it okay I think July seems every did everyone get that on the record we've still found we've still found way we've still found a way so I'd say we budget 90 minutes so what are the next steps can I ask one question if we're in are we in for all of the modules Al together is there a circumstance under which we would not go in for one of those two in the middle no I didn't I'm just asking yeah so do we do we need a official nothing okay we all are nodding our heads so you're good perfect thank you guys so much for putting in that
069work and being proactive to try to get ahead of the the game there so appreciate it and it was an excellent presentation thank you okay uh item 2.03 president's report um so later on we're going to have an an exempt session where we're going to be reviewing um the responses we got to our RFP proposal um request um for identifying search firms that we would like to interview to consider coming on board Bo for the superintendent search and that's the main update I have on there um item 2.04 superintendence report thank you President Fitzgerald uh superintendence report is in uh board docs um as your backup information item one Capital project update the high school Capital project as moving forward as contractors are readying the new photography studio that it becomes operational prior to the
070holiday break the furniture is scheduled to arrive this week in addition the auxiliary gymnasium is nearing completion but still needs the matted flooring to be installed so that it is ready for occupancy as the calendar flips to January 2025 item next students uh School climate and culture survey with the student version of the school climate culture survey in the rearview mirror and we've already received the draft results we're prepared to release a similar version for the faculty and staff in the days ahead administered by research and marketing strategies out of Baldwinsville RMS the confidential Anonymous survey is similar to the instrument that was administered over the past couple of years so that we'll be able to analyze the trend data longitudinally over time for everyone students faculty and staff and families and parents is a
071reminder the family parent version of the survey will be administered in the early spring and our community relations committee I'm ad living here added some questions on cell phones for the faculty and staff to augment the fmta survey that was done earlier but this will open it up to all the other bargaining units as well so I encourage staff members to do it will be released before the holiday break and it will close after the holiday break uh stool school start time committee uh has been meeting regularly since the beginning of the year administr ERS have worked with representatives from our transportation department to explore bus routing and schedules and an attempt to see what's possible in the winter months ahead we are going to add faculty and staff to the discourse before engaging students
072and their families in the spring so while the goal is to have a recommendation ready for the summer coming up of 2025 for a new schedule in September of 2026 the committee is determining whether or not there are any bus routing strategies that they'll be able to pile it in the year ahead so that we don't waste any time item next Community Relations Committee I mentioned them earlier uh they met this past week to uh discuss the redesign of the school district website among a number of other important topics they had a chance to review some of the responses from the recent Community stakeholder survey which was embedded in our annual report in addition to uh discussing Governor hok's efforts to develop a bell to Bell cell phone prohibition so that social media does not
073interfere with the teaching learning process as you know a few of us attended the disconnected convening hosted by net this past autumn in Albany and I believe net is meeting on the capital as I look out into the audience coming up soon to discuss that uh with the media and finally item last the nid regionalization study which is on our agenda a little bit later I will ask the Board of Ed to opt out of the nid regionalization study as you may be aware the regionalization initiative is a way to for districts to be able to collaborate and share resources as enrollments decline throughout the state of New York at present the regionalization study will be helpful for Rural districts more rural districts in the North country and Southern Tier who struggle not only to
074provide meaningful electives but also the core subject areas nice c as made it crystal clear that they're not trying to encourage mergers or cons consolidations but rather their aim is to publicize ways that school districts are able to work together to ensure that students throughout the state of New York have equal opportunities they are not defined by ZIP code if we elect to opt out this board must act by January 15 2025 that ends my report uh Dr T for the opting out of the study can you give a little more information about why we would opt out and what the benefits for opting out would be certainly basically I've already started uh completing the form uh on the state ed portal there's three parts to it uh the first part is taking a look
075at our data and I find it ironic that we just went over the data at the last meeting and you may be raising an eyebrow that why are we entering the data into the portal when I took the data from the portal the state doesn't have a way to harvest that data so they are uh asking all school districts to do that so not just this superintendent but other superintendant are busy taking their data and entering it back into their system that they'll be able to use in a meaningful way so that's item one item two that was the easy part item two is looking at what different and unique opportunities that we're proud of that we're offering here and item three is what areas would we like to collaborate and share with other districts
076so the question on re that a lot of districts are opting out right now until the state is able to better Define it is we just are not sure when we complete this uh part one seems seems fairly innocuous and harmless part two sounds interesting of the things because I think State Ed is interested on what's working in the field but everybody is just a little Leary of part three that if we make this promise is it binding are we going to be expected to suddenly uh merge with the neighboring District I mean I'm kidding but partner and share resources so I think people are just pumping the brakes now I think it makes sense as I said for the rural districts that are forget about electives are just having trouble offering the core classes
077or things like physics every other year every four years so I get where this is of urgency but I think for our district um we pride ourselves on having that local control we're able to provide and so I think uh just being protective of what we have so far is the way to go until things get clarified does that make sense and very I mean it it may be coming to a theater near us eventually and we'll have to fill it out but I just don't know if it's right now in a sense we did our sorry Mer go ahead no but in a sense we did our regionalization in 1951 right fville and manliest parts of pompy um I mean we border closely to chit angle and East Syracuse so I'm not I'm a
078very know I was just going to say at the last Boose meeting Dr Cook talked about this there are a lot of districts particularly in the Long Island area who've been really leading the charge against this regionalization discussion um because they were worried about consolidation and the state not being very clear as to what their intention is he said their intention is exactly what you said to just look at ways for districts to work together but their presentation unfortunately hasn't been done in a good way and I think at the same time and I believe I shared it in the Thursday letter the Rockefeller Institute study from Sunni just came out so I think people are feeling that the devil's going to be in the details and they'd like to see where the chips fall
079there I mean you have to remember sharing and collaborating I've been talking about that since my arrival uh but what is the devil in the details is that as you begin to share and I know another District asked us if we wanted to merge earlier a few months ago you give up some of the local control there you have to remember that these Partnerships are a good idea and certainly we want to be a good neighbor but there are strings attached there's tethers so I mean we may get to a point where we're ready to partner and collaborate but keep in mind that will come with loss of local control you know as other districts will have a say so I think right now not to just air on the side of protectionism but I
080think we're in a strong position right now and it may be something that we consider down the road but with the Rockefeller Institute study just coming out and not knowing who the winners are and who the losers are in the state aid formula it is my humble opinion and recommendation is just to pump the brakes and wait is there any danger of this going the other way so New York State loves to mandate whether funded mandates or unfunded mandates um if we opt out of participating in the studying and planning of it I'm just I'm just wondering what happens in the hypothetical if New York then decides what we're going to mandate implementation of regionalization and then we haven't been involved in the planning process and we end up just being the recipient of the
081man mate is there is there any do you have any concern about that pathway certainly we've had mandates we've had unfunded mandates um I think not knowing what the winners and losers will be in terms of the Rockefeller study uh you have to remember the governor sets the executive budget and certainly the board of regions champions for additional funding for districts so I'm not worried about that part it's it's a parallel track but in terms of being foed upon mergers it's exactly that and Marissa brought it up about Long Island I mean there could very well be a Revolt with the districts that are down there so I mean you're at least considering pros and cons of both Long Island they've already made up their mind a lot of districts and they're not filling it
082out because you know they want to keep what they have and let the state you know fund the Have Nots so does that help answer your question anything could be a mandate down the road but I think right now we're in a position of strength and it may very well change as time goes along yeah I guess I'm just trying to to fully understand the you know participating in obviously there's a time commitment there's a time and resources commitment and that's the biggest piece of it as I understand it but you know there's always a difference between participating in studying and planning without that necessarily meaning you've committed to acting on it and and I'm not I'm not sure that that brid I'm not I'm not sure if that bridge is there or isn't there
083that's what I'm trying to understand is is there this bridge from agreeing to participate in the process to committing us to participating in the outcome and that's what's unclear right now I mean there are a number of districts in central New York that are considering this opt out for that very reason nobody is offended by part one and re-entering the data they're I think some are angry that they have to do it but they're doing it part two you know shouting from the rooftop all the wonderful things that we're doing people are not opposed to that it's the part three what would if we were neighboring districts what would we be willing to share you know we're willing to partner and and making this up not just because it's a favorite of yours but swimming
084which we do already and partner with other districts but we're not going to partner with Science Olympiad you know what I mean so the the part three of the form the survey that's what's a little disconcerting is if we put down all the wonderful things we're doing is it's suddenly not only swimming but Science Olympiad where we seem to you know have enough interested students to suddenly be able to share it with other districts does that so I I'm I'm much more until I know the details I'm much more in a protectionist mode so I guess my last question on that is do you have a clear sense the districts that we would if there was ever a mandate that we we would be regionalizing with would be those that are surrounding us do you
085have a clear sense of which of those are opting out because if we're all in this region opting out then there isn't a regional plan to be foisted upon us so do you have a sense of those who are around us that are opting out I get a sense and I you know I mean that's for them to disclose in the in the weeks ahead or whatever but just you know not trying to avoid you but think about Mike and think of the districts that kind of cut to the beginning of the line I mean if anything Dr Cook as Marissa knows as a representative on the ocm Bose's board has been trying to include all the other districts this isn't a first come first serve this is all of Central New York will be
086impacted by the arrival of Micron so to answer your question I think they we're trying to get away from some of that competition first come first serve and we got to first settle out how things like Micron impact all districts together so that's why I think some were just pumping the brakes right now does that help I just have a question on a different part of your report but I just I'll holding we're done with this part just on the school start time committee who's I have two questions on one is who's on that committee what what is what is the composition of that committee now and the second and this may just be a wording thing in your your report I just want to be clear on where you said the goal is to
087have a recommendation by summer of 25 for a new schedule we're not presupposing a new schedule the schedule could be remain the same or a variety of news correct we just if you recall when Dr Leen was out here we one of the things again people said the data makes sense we like the data they couldn't if you recall all the different surveys focus groups they couldn't decide on a particular solution whether it was the flip or the slide or the flipp and slide and all that but at that time if you remember we promised to give a Year's notice so Fairport recently did that Webster had done that before in the Rochester area so it is doesn't it doesn't mean we're going to change everything it means we want to give if there's a
088a risk of people having to look for child care we wanted to be able to announce it a year in advance so forgive me that's yes the goal hasn't changed right now to answer your other part of the question is just administrators in terms of looking at what is possible so we're not trying to limit but it's a more convergent approach that it can't just be Pie in the Sky we have to be able to pull it off with our bus fleet so we've been working with the transportation department believe it or not there's a creative idea that's out there that I won't not ready to share just yet but it's more uh convergent than Divergent so we're trying to identify the areas where we can make some changes and then certainly adding faculty and
089staff and then family and parents to get their feedback is the plan for this year so right now it's administrators and transportation department that's the Lynch pin obviously we've always said lynchpin is transportation are they looking at this through the lens of our current Transportation or to get back to this concept of mandates of how we're supposed to flip this bus fleet to buses that have much shorter ranges that they can run on before being recharged for hours what l L what lens are they looking at this through actually believe it or not both because not only right now is you know we're triple tripping so for a lot of this to be pulled off especially you know we want students to get home in time for dinner and sleep uh you know we're going
090to have to be able to yeah I think they would I think we're going to have to look at double tripping and so whether it's diesel fuel or those other things that you didn't name um I think we're going to have to be creative think of double tripping but it also May mean as some board members in this room have heard of different committees looking at building utilization a little bit differently too not because we want to just because we have to in terms of the new Fleet so I think there's a lot of Creative Solutions out there and I want to give credit to the administrators involved certainly uh the distri district office team as well uh and our transportation department uh M Susan Sterns has done a great job along with Becky finnery
091in terms of taking a look at a lot of data to pull it all together so kudos to them anything else on superintendent report okay thank you uh item 2.05 uh reports representative updates darl do you have anything I really don't have any news um but I would encourage people to read the nisa's summary of the Rockefeller Institute uh report and I did sign up for the webinar and unfortunately was unable to attend but I do get access to it so as soon as I hear I'll report that to you as well great thank you thank you Mara excuse me darl are we got to reach out to um Senator Le um Ryan to invite him to the district I see North Syracuse has already done that so um before he gets too busy just
092to have him come and maybe yes our new our new state senator different Brian no not Ry MC Chris Ryan Chris Ryan yes yes okay but uh as you saw in the Thursday letter uh we've received a Sam's Grant from assembly Derpy but also outgoing state Senator John Manion has provided us with some support for Safety and Security which I know as near and dear to the facilities committee art as well yes keep that generosity coming from Albany uh Mara F's update um I was going to talk about regionalization but we kind of covered that um we have a meeting on Thursday so I will ask around the table if other districts are opting out and let the board know keep you apprised of what Dr Cook reports back on that and our district clerk
093reports no remote public comment to answer Mr catalino's question in person just signing up for moment thank you Isa have anything to report nothing okay thank you so my understanding 3.01 public comments nobody is signed up must be because I can't do it [Laughter] online uh okay new business item 4.01 approval of minutes uh be it resolved that the Board of Education of fville Manley School District approve the minutes of the regular meeting held on November 18th 2024 as presented may I have a motion Jason and darl thank you all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining yeah three you got those great thank you all right item 4.02 be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle Central School District hereby moves the fraternization or non feniz policy um second reading I
094thought we were first reading okay into second reading for the next regular board meeting May I have a motion thank you Cindy and an okay any discussion so we don't really need to do this all and take the time I I shared comments and thoughts that I had with all of you and I I guess I would just ask that policy Committee just take a look at those and if we can get some feedback ahead of the next meeting that would be great great and Dan if you had any particular suggestions I saw we saw your comments but if there are if you have some proposed um options for how we would suggest maybe we reword pieces of it I'm sure the policy committee would appreciate that I'll add those into there Sarah you did
095discuss it once more during policy correct oh yes we have discussed it several times and has it not also been discussed with the administration Dr Ty the non Friz and they all approved it and they did uh as you know this revised policy is really the eie one policy and we took what we had crafted before and are transforming that into the administrative regulation which if you remember was a compilation of all different sources So This truly is the eie one which a number of districts use already and yes was approved by the administration in terms of process the policy committee has forwarded this to the board in first reading to move into second so if there are changes that board members would like to see shouldn't that be part of discussion now because it
096sounds like it's being referred back to policy it was tabled last time to get additional discussion or whatever information but I'm curious as to why it's going back to policy now if it's in first reading about to go to Second shouldn't we have discussion right now and then hear what people would like to do with this we could certainly do that but you want to do that we do that so start at the bottom I I'll work my way bottom to top so bottom of this policy so the last full paragraph says that any students School Employees or third parties that have knowledge of or witness any possible occurrence of inappropriate staff student relations must report the incident to any staff member Etc so I don't think that we can I I I don't think
097that we should be mandating students as reporters if they're merely a witness to something or may have knowledge of something that's their choice to come forward or not I don't think we have the authority cart blanch to mandate that third parties report and we have have a policy policy 9645 on reporting that that's directly inconsistent with which says that staff members are encouraged to report but not mandated to do so so that is a policy Prov proposed policy provision that's directly in conflict with an existing policy we go to let's talk about that one sure go for it so isn't I I understand your point about mandating students but for staff and employees wouldn't I fall under mandated reporting if you are aware of you have of a inappropriate relationship as a mandated reporter you
098have to make a report on that I'm not sure how the student piece could be changed so that we're not saying students have to maybe students are encouraged to but employees wouldn't they Dr Ty fall under mandate reporting I believe so yes I mean I'm not legal counsel nor have I stayed in a holiday and express but since you're sit there in aut and tie I was just going to refer to you as Council this was vetted by legal counsel I mean it's one that Erie W bosis puts out which is put together by a number of attorneys that work in West senica paragraph above is just a sentence so that's I don't have anything in that one the paragraph above that so this is third to last um this is a policy about staff
099student relations there's one inclusion in the end of that paragraph about this extending to the students parents I don't think that was the intent of the I've never understood this to be the intent of the policy I didn't never understood that we were um concerned about um faculty or staff calling or having a telephone conversation with parents um but this would seem to preclude that from happening so I don't I think to me it's just the removal of the phrase or the students parents I'll pause on that one what's the process right now like teachers going to call parents coaches going to call parents what's the process yeah teachers uh would call parents administrators would call parents uh in fact during one of the budget meetings today we talked about a new software that has
100the option of one-way communication directly with the student athlete uh the parents so I think so when parents when teachers or staff communicate with parents do they document that somewhere like in school tool like when we communicate with parents and Syracuse we have to like put it into school tool tool like under Outreach or something and we say what happen is that what we do here fil we use email quite a bit I don't know no like you have to document it like if I call a parent and I say I'm calling about I don't know Johnny did something in class today I write it in school tool under Outreach like do people teachers and staff have to document when they talking I mean it depends if it's disciplinary I don't know if every doc
101you know every interaction is documented but certainly un the discipline tab the discipline cont they don't have to seek permission then to Dan's point they do not have to seek permission like if a teacher wanted to reach out to a or a coach wanted to reach out to a parent to communicate about the student they do not have to seek permission correct do they have to advise someone of make of making such a call or text or whatever if they don't then to his point we could we should remove that if they don't have to seek permission unless you want it documented somewhere um for some well even then maybe it doesn't belong in this policy it's yeah and I thought we removed that paragraph I thought we did remove that whole paragraph um but
102we'll have to yeah that went back to legal counsel and the if you recall policy asked why was it removed by legal councel in the first Place legal councel removed it because they felt it was redundant but it could be in there so we put it back in the attorney we we no just clerk we put it back in the question by policy committee was why was it removed we had a question so we contacted legal counsel legal councel said that they took it out because they thought it was redundant it wasn't that it was wrong it was redundant so just to give a little bit of background from the policy conversation um we had a discussion about the fact that we were maybe overstepping the purpose of this particular policy with getting too much
103into the communication tools and protocol because this isn't a communication policy it's a non-fraternization policy and so we intended to just spell out what's okay what's not okay honestly about any staff student relationship and communication instead of specifying exactly the means of how they would communicate so it sounds like we don't we can remove that sentence because it's not what people do now it's not not what you need want them to do so that last sentence there doesn't seem like it's in line with our policy or our process and procedures right now so I have no objection to removing that what are people's thoughts on that to me frankly that whole paragraph the whole paragraph the whole paragraph is is is is is what would ordinarily be in an administrative regulation not the policy I
104certainly think that the student parents reference needs to be removed if the paragraph from Ms but fundamentally what tool to use how to communicate that that's an administrative regulation that's that's not a policy why don't just take it out and put that in a rig then we could but I believe the discussion that was remanded back to policy was to try to get them to use School sponsored media I believe the objection was that they couldn't use their own cell phone and I think this was written with the help of legal counsel to permit them to use their own device which I believe was the first objection but if they did it would have to be with school sponsored media a reg that's making them use their own that's doing the same thing right well
105well let if if you make it a rig and say people have to follow you certain devices is that how is that different than having it in the policy so the conversation that we had was that we didn't want it in the PO we we agreed that we thought it could go into a reg but we were uncomfortable with putting it in a reg right now unless we had the particular tools available to any District staff for example coaches to make it easy for them to be able to use other means of communication to be able to reach students and right now we don't have those tools available so we didn't want to put it in an administrative regag at this point but we that was where tools available Dr T like what's the time
106frame to have all those tools in place I mean we have some tools we're looking as you could tell from my discussion earlier at better tools that not only document the communication thread but at this point right now do we have tools in place that would allow our staff to communicate through District communication apps with our students so why couldn't we have the r now I mean obviously you're looking for better but we're always looking for better why couldn't not be putting a rag now the rag doesn't need to name the tools per se it just has to provide the the the you know the definition of what that that is we do have tools there are sports you there's tools that are used by coaches now and then obviously all the um school schooly
107and other resources that are used parent Square for broader messages so I mean I guess the question question is does this belong as a reg for I mean does it belong in the policy or does it belong as a reg as a companion to this policy or is it a reg that's sort of its own thing which is about Communications um to students and parents it sounds like right we're trying to have really clean Communications with our our community that are not um texting back and forth on a staff member's personal device I don't want to speak from Mr seberg I was under the impression that the objection was that we were not allowing folks to use their own personal device so I believe policy committee made a concerted effort to allow people to use
108their own device but they had to use School sponsored software that's the line now I worry taking it all out means I can use my personal device and do Instagram or Snapchat and so so the idea was you could use your huh well I I was gonna say Ann correct me if I'm wrong but I believe we tried to take it out because we discussed that this policy was really about sort of setting the framework to say you can't have inappropriate conversations and relationships with students it was more about the content than the tool versus the how which would go into a reg in some form or fashion but that's up to the administrative group to be able to figure out where that fits if it's in a communication overarching reg or wherever but for
109the purpose of the policy was more setting the guidepost to say listen you don't socialize with students at a personal level that's could be inappropriate see now with that last sentence there if an employee needs believe they needs to use other means of communication so other than District communication tools um that's not the same as that they can't communicate with with parents I that's I'm sorry I read that a little wrong I misunderstood when I think policy committee and again I don't want to speak for all the policy committee I think they were trying to honor Mr seberg's initial objection of not using prohib the prohibition of using their personal device they were tethering it to a school sponsored media that would be able to track it and know that big brother was watching so
110I think policy was trying to honor the request and tether it but what is the majority I think hold on and and I think and I think and I appreciate that and I think they got that mostly right other than this reference to the students parents part which I don't believe belongs in here but the mostly right part is there's still a fundamental just core issue is this proper for policy or is this proper for an administrative right that's that's just my question and obviously there's greater there's going to be learnings through this where it's going to be well what about because I have scenario X or what about I have scenario why and there's much greater flexibility in an admin ministrative reg than there ever Israel will be on a policy so that's why
111just in in in my view I it's I appreciate what it was addressing but I still think it might live better in a w than the policy but as they look to as they look to policy even though we said we moved all that other to rag I believe we deleted this right there was a separate sentence that referenced an annual review of the reg we took it out and embedded this all in see I'm trying to with help you with the notes so it's just we deleted the the reference to the reg and that's why this appeared back in because there was the bull bulleted list right and then in the other one there was this paragraph we deleted the reference ref to the r if memory serves and that's why this got embedded
112again and so we did I give credit to our district clerk asked legal counsel why it was removed which I think was brought up at policy and it was because there was a feeling of redundancy now I don't know if it was redundancy to the old one that we created which was kind of a hodgepodge but there was no you know legal council wasn't offended if it reappeared here Council has reviewed this and you said it went to our staff who would be using who would be under this policy following this policy administrators administrators um did you take it to the teachers and see what they thought coaches Mr sugar Dr sugar Dr sugar now right Dr suar sugar now did we ask them if they thought this would impede any of their Communications we
113can this is hot off the press we hav't between now and I have I think that might be a good idea I don't think it's going to but I also am worried about trying to word Smith to individual board members because I would like to hear the majority of the board members think about this right now I have about three problems I thought I had two but I maybe have three first of all these notes didn't come to us till late this afternoon I did read them my second problem is my technology is not working tonight so I can't even access it um but I said in the very beginning we tabled this we asked the policy committee to look at it again they looked at it again it went through legal the administrators approved
114it I'm in full com I'm very happy with the way it is we cannot be too careful that's all I want to say we you know have been very lucky so far but I can remember things in my own youth at FM that if I'd known about a policy thatd have been right in there so that's all Chrissy Jason do you guys have any so if I understand it correctly there's more flexibility with the r right as opposed to then it as opposed to it having to come back to policy right so I would think that you would take it out and put it in the rag so that way it wouldn't have to continually come back to the board if you change it right I'm just reading that and kind of after hearing what
115I've heard tonight it just seems like that would be a better way to to do it so I'm fine to take it out I think that kind of makes more sense and then to pieces that I've heard I just want to make sure I have Clarity so Craig we do or do not and this is a yes or no question we do or do not have a way for coaches uh sports teams directors of Afterschool groups to communicate with students through an FM sponsored software yes yes okay thank you so that so there is no ambiguity right so if we change an administrative brag or this policy there's no ambiguity amongst those groups right we can clearly communicate to students and or administrators and or whomever else is leading after school groups or sports teams
116how they're going to communicate right and we can do that through our in fact a lot of Staff prefer to use School telephones School sponsored but I'm just thinking of right like so for example the musicals coming up right and there are all those different groups within the musicals right and they need to communicate and there's a change in this weekend's set build time or whatever so whatever we have a software whether it's School tool or parents square or whatever it is but we have a tool that the district pays for that we can communicate out to everybody to say this is how supposed to do it going forward yeah at minimum it could be email stents have a account that that's fine I just want to make sure that that Tools in place that's
117all thank you I would uh agree with Daryl and what she said that's how I feel um I did want to make one change or just one comment we had talked about that that last paragraph about students must report did we clear that up that that was taken out I thought I heard it was taken out and then it wasn't taken out that's the only part that I'm confused about that it was already part of another policy and then you said you thought we took that out okay that's my only part because I don't I don't know that regulation if we can tell students they must report they things like that right yeah okay outside of that I think that it is gone through the proper channels I agree as well and I think having
118had legal look at this is important and during the day staff can use the phones at school and not use their own personal devices um to call parents and I do think it's important that there is a platform that you can go through outside of school hours that would be Ed to protect everyone quite honestly to eliminate a lot of questions I mean I'm to me I'm hearing everyone's points about this paragraph regarding the tools I just think it it's a helpful how too because you said the goal of this was to Define what can't be done but it's also helpful to know what can be done um so I don't think this hems Us in in any way just to say District managed Communications I don't think it requires us to keep going back
119and I think it's a little bit of a gray area whether it's an administrative reg versus a policy I think there's probably blurry lines all across our policies and regs about what is fits in what bucket so I support it I think we need to figure out maybe just the parent piece and then the reporting piece um but other than that I would support just moving forward okay so let me just finish working upward so we still have to figure out out come to agreement on the parent piece and the the reporting pieces we identified those I still have I'm still not clear on what happens through this policy when you have an employee and you have student or students who are interacting on non District matters so a teacher who's doing private tutoring a
120teacher who is doing uh outof District personal music lessons a teacher or employee who is doing offseason conditioning or or Sports practices where they are allowed to communicate with students or or not allowed to communicate with students on their own tools and their own devices because it's this talks about employees and students they're still employees they're still students but it's non-district matters and I'm not I'm not I just genuinely from this policy I'm not clear where that falls does that need to be a different policy the relationship's different yeah because this policy is about staff to student relationship ship not people who have a private their that's a separate thing which we can't I mean we can say you can't like solicit um clients or whatever during you know using School devices or in school
121but you can't say that if you know one child has a coach through another program that they can't communicate as through that relationship because that's not something we can monitor I don't know why we would even consider that it's not our business no but we're talking about an FM if it was an FM employee MH that was giving let's say private music lessons to an FM student but it is non it's not through the school it's private right so are we saying is that included or not included our business they're not doing it as our employee they're doing it as their okay but that's right but it's an FM employee communting with communicating with an FM student right so do you understand where the gray area is there is no gray area because if they
122are an FM employee and they they send something to their whole music class right through our channels and say hey I'm going to have lessons on Saturday whatever that's wrong if they are an F music teacher and they post something at the library and say hi um I'm I'm going to offer tutoring or whatever and people communicate with them through that thing that they've posted in the library it's none of our business so if that's the case we would I would hope agree that that scenario just you just laid out is a scenario that is that is unrelated to coursework or official School matters my my point is you said those are things that are none of our business and don't apply to this policy at all we can't regulate at all those things that
123you just described are things that are unrelated to coursework or official School matters not related to their job as the employee in our district this is related to their job as an employee of our district interacting with our students what people do in their off time we can't cannot control that and and I get that but the policy is specifically as worded right now says you cannot have frequent Communications with a student unrelated to coursework or official School matters those things tutoring private school private music lessons theater lessons Sports things are unrelated to coursework or official School matters says policy 9150 staff student relations so this is regarding staff and students people in their official capacity capacity with students this is not about people that that's your interpretation that's the title of it it says
124staff student relations right there in the title yeah and then the and the paragraph also starts inappropriate employee Behavior so it's it's right there it's not just my opinion they're still employees and they're still students and they're engaging on things that are unrelated to cour work or official School matters so there is but not within their job description if you don't see a grade area on there that's great I see a gray area on there I have a concern on that gray area so this is where we've gone round and round and we the intention was really I believe from everyone was to basically just highlight that it's inappropriate behavior and inappropriate um personal relationships that we are trying to make it clear is not okay and we are not going to tolerate so I
125think the policy committee's heard everybody's comments and um and then now now I just have one last one last question I don't know what undo familiarity means I think you would if you saw it is it I don't know what it means I have no idea what undue familiarity means can the policy committee um apply a definition of undue familiarity from legal counsil to the policy before you know we approve it in second reading ask Council what undue familiarity is from a legal perspective and insert it in there I have no problem with that sure is there any other that's for for for language so you have a paragraph in here that says inappropriate employee Behavior includes and that has all these examples and that's including one that we just talked about if the paragraph
126before just talks about that staff members are prohibited to engage in inappropriate employee Behavior as defined in here then you eliminate any issue regarding an undefined undue familiarity just the examples to the prohibited language I think you should be on policy Comm well I just I just I mean look it I I I I appreciate the look version one was much longer it was it covered a lot I I I genuinely appreciate the work that's been done on it it doesn't mean that I don't have concerns about it as it exists today and we appreciate all that I think everybody's had an opportunity to give their concerns but at some point Madam president president you have to call the question so we we've moved it so we are going I forget what we moved it's
127a second reading okay all in favor to move it to Second reading move it to Second reading okay anybody abstaining no everybody voted okay moving along 4.03 be it resolved that the Board of Education of the Ville manle Central School District makes the following appointment as presented may I have a motion thank you Cindy second anyone darl all right all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining okay 4.04 be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle Central School District hereby agrees with the administrative recommendation to voluntarily withdraw from the New York State education department regionalization study may I have a motion Marissa thank you second Daryl again and all in favor anybody oppos or abstaining no okay thank you okay board development uh nothing we are developed 5.02 potential considerations for future
128meetings Okay um so as you can see we are updating our chart as we move along with some items um anybody have any questions or comments on there nope okay item 5.03 RFP award be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle Central School District hereby continues the agreement for mental health services with CNY mental health Counseling in accordance with their 2022 proposal for the 2024 25 school year year three of five the Board of Education notes that any extension of the contract in for a fourth or fifth year shall be subject to annual administrative review and approval by the Board of Education may I have a motion thank you Jason and Dan all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining isn't this something that should be teed up for July so that
129we're not doing it mid school year Well we talked about that I mean that's one of the reasons we missed it last year the Ser RFP as you saw in my backup information was originally issued for five years and what was unclear clear was when the board adopted it midy year because that's when the RFP was uh you know initiated was the boards and that's what we couldn't decide on was it five separate options or was it a five year plus four options for a total of nine years so we're treating it as it was five separate oneyear options so it does mean we missed last year we did it this year but in the future and this may come to fruition because you saw my point I said it may be moot they're talking
130about reissuing the RFP because of different services and so that may occur this spring and then if that's the case then we can definitely park it on the reorg that's a longer answer than you wanted but I think getting out of the midyear cycle will help us not forget it we vote all in favor for that did we already vote did we okay sorry item 6.01 future meeting agendas so we meet again after the new year happy New Year all of you I'm sure we'll see each other somehow uh item 6.02 dates to remember um lots of concerts coming up so you can attend um item 7.01 so we have a proposed executive session um be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville manle Central School District enter into executive session for
131the purpose of discussing the employment history of an administrator may I have a motion thank you Chrissy and Jason and all in favor okay by all right so we are going go into executive session and then we will return to vote on consent agenda oh all right it's fine if you guys would like to depart or if you're on the edge of your seat for the consent agenda you're welcome to say oh Lisa Melissa for e e e okay we're back um all right item eight consent agenda may I have a motion to approve okay thank youa second from Daryl all in favor anybody opposed or abstaining okay and item nine no we're skipping it 10.01 U proposed exempt session um be it resolved that the Board of Education of the fville Manley Central School
132District enter into exempt session [Music] for purpose of oh there it is of the um superintendent search may I have a motion please Chrissy and Jason thank you all in favor is anybody opposed or abstaining no great and then we will adjourn so the rest of you Hangers On thank you have a great evening e