001welcome to the 11 2025 special session of the Board of Education this is President Joseph cilio speaking thank you for attending in zero or through in person please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance ofday provid for the public and each member of the Board of Education pursuing the requirements of law T please take [Music] attendance present present present pres present present at this time may have a motion to accept the agenda for February 11th 2025 special session as presented don't move all in favor I um are there any questions uh from the board on the agenda items no uh at this point I just make a note um this evening on the agenda um we will be uh approving um erses all contracts related to the C engagement um all those materials um question thisis
002uh information input that's been received has been shared and posted online and all the results as a result of the committee work and as a result of the Consulting work will be shared with the literacy committee the board and the public when those results are received so I want to make note of that at the start of this meeting um there are no questions from the administration this time yeah this time is designated for Citizens questions or comments so please step forward and um if you have any questions please take your name address thank you so rich Coro me Brook Road um so the Consultants started working yesterday I understand no when do they start working they will start working when they're formally engaged so they do have access to obviously anything public on the
003websites so if I'm hearing that they were in the building that's an inaccurate statement correct not heard they're in the building they in the building to start their engagement and when is the contract start date it's going to be approved through Bose I don't know when the next Bose's meeting is approved through Bose in in what fashion can you describe that please Bose's we use Bose's for Consulting work um and they normally uh help us gain um efficiencies in terms of costs when we engage Consultants uh we did this with World Language I believe was one of them recently um some other reviews uh so we're just using that process the uh the expense savings were afforded through using bosis so um what has been the vetting process you know I've asked questions about this
004I don't feel like I've gotten satisfactory answers how was casda vetted Dr Cena do you can you explain how kazda was selected I shared this in previous meetings so kazda was selected based on their um they've been they're a consulting firm that have been that has been around for a long long time I think over 20 years and they do various types of of uh reviews so this was um and we interviewed them and we had couple of other ones as well two other ones that I had mentioned at the last meeting and we interviewed them we wa when were they interviewed I don't have the date in front of me December we interview we had said in a student achievement report it was when December that we had said we were going to engage
005in Consultants we started looking for them and it was this is February so in January how many consultant firms were interviewed we I interviewed um three bosis um another firm leam Mermelstein and then also casda and then the board interviewed casda as well okay and I I just want to have a very clear understanding when it comes to the engagement itself um I'm sure I'll have further questions but Dr Cena um you are and you can correct me if I'm wrong you are committed to removing um balanced literacy um Teachers College fontas and panel uh from the Garden City Schools correct or no what we are committed to is the review process and if in the review process it states that what we there's we we're going to be following whatever the State education department
006is asking us and what they have said very um it's very specific K to3 what they're looking for and also three to five so if the if our if our consultant say that here's something you need to look at right whether it is uh fontis and panel whether it's foundations whether it we use a variety of of uh different programs we'll be looking at that very carefully it's going to be going back to the literacy committee as well all the recommendations and everything as U Mr CIO stated it will be on the website there'll be parent engagement they'll be uh teachers but but but I'm sorry to interrupt you but you're the superintendent of schools you're not willing to commit consultant or not you're now willing to commit to that proposition if I was if
007we were doing that there would be no need for anybody from the outside coming in to do well that is a question that's on the table that is a question that's been on the table we do curriculum reviews it's a process that we use it's not just for um we've done uh reading was done prior to when I came here so these curriculum reviews as a cycle it's a good thing to do we've done our internal reviews somebody from the outside coming and telling us what we're doing well what we need to do differently that's a process so we're going to be doing that and so that that is you know we made a commitment to that and I believe since 2017 this is probably the third or fourth consultant we've had in the area
008of literacy with what results we we have um well I don't consultants in districts correct different curricular areas are very common currently we have a science uh somebody in the area of science that's my question is what what have been the results the results have been uh with with specifically around helping us to build capacity Consultants work with teachers administrators right well but in all this time we have all these Consultants coming in and we see our literacy rates decline over time and the question is one of the questions is um why are we now bringing in a consultant I've been very vocal and it's not nothing to do with our with our great people but we have a literacy consultant we have a literacy coach we have reading instructors um we have a literacy
009committee now we're bringing in yet another consultant within let's say a fiveyear time frame so part of the question is why the other part of the question is were these people properly vetted you're you're looking over there I'm asking so were these people properly vetted um and you know do why do we even need the consultancy you're not even willing to commit to removing what has been proven as a debunked non-scientific approach to reading so those are all questions my my last question uh probably is will you commit to the implementation of a scientific research backed structured literacy program in Garden City if if that's where we need to go of course but we are going to be following what we are required to do and what the state education department they have a the
010literacy briefs that came out they're actually very very good they're excellent and we'll be following that but you're not sure if that's what you're required to do at this point in time we I believe in our in what we're doing currently but we could always do better we could always do better and if that's the case and they give us make recommendations again it's going to be vetted through our people as well which is the literacy committee not going to go back and forth I think I've been very clear with that and Consultants having in District is not atypical it's actually quite typical but it's not clear what qualifies this group of people to perform this function and we as a community some of us have had to reach out to kazda and try and
011find out the information ourselves and ask the question for instance what's your track record and the response was well we don't C we don't keep that information so it does beg the question what level of vetting was per formed here what level of oversight I'm I'm not seeing it I'm not hearing it and I'd be curious to know what was discussed between you and the board on this topic what was discussed in terms of the various interviews that were performed in the relative Merit of the consultancies I've heard none of this debated publicly that's a pro this is all a problem and you know what I personally I'm going to make it my mission to make sure everybody understands these issues and that we do have a top tier number one structured literary program in
012Garden City that will be my mission so thank you good evening Dr General delam one Sunset Lane Garden City New York the most fundamental responsibility of schools is teaching students what okay let me fix this mic yeah the most fundamental responsibility of schools is teaching students to read indeed the future success of all students hinges upon their ability to become proficient readers Dr Sing Hof proudly admits that Garden City is a partner with Teachers College reading writing program that Garden City uses a chapaqua school district's literacy program as a model and she hired and used Lynn McKay the former superintendent of the chapaqua school district as a literacy consultant Dr singho used to be an assistant superintendent at the School District it really boggles my mind to think as to why Dr singho would not
013follow it in the footsteps of the chabaa school district and hired the literacy Consultants who were credentialed in science of reading structured literacy as did chapaqua the chopa Consultants completed their report and it was available for viewing on the school district's website as of June 2024 the literacy Consultants report was very critical of chapaqua for using TC balanced literacy chapaqua is rated up much higher than Garden City because they had to supplement all parts of it that's part of what their 72 page report said that all of it was being supplemented and there was no reason to continue using TC Mr CIO last time I was up here speaking you made a comment and you said that you would consider High performing school districts but no other we're number 51 the peer districts that you
014think are a peer districts are no longer a peer districts do you know East Meadow is 35 do you know Belmore Merrick do you know Lim Brook do you know levitown they're all above Garden City do you realize that the Casta Consultants have less than 50% reading proficiency rates at the districts they worked in where they were overseeing the literacy programs so can you please explain to me how this is going to help us and why if chapaqua was so great for you to model our program after and they have this 72-page document that fully details it could mirror every problem we've been discussing about literacy here in Garden City and it goes into extreme detail with recommendations and critiques and they're willing to learn from this consultant because they're embracing science of reading and
015they want to be aligned with New York State the people you picked are not they're not structured literacy trained science of reading credential they're the opposite you have Tim bakus who has 42% rate of literacy in his in his uh School District South Colony so please explain how he's going to help our literacy program improve and please explain why chapaqua was okay for you to emulate when they had TC but now you don't like what they're using so you picked a whole different route you picked a whole different set of Consultants that are actually against science of reading that are not into structured literacy and have never even taught in a school system bringing structured literacy into fruition use instructed literacy is the meth methodology behind a scientific reading research and how reading is taught
016in case you were not familiar with that but if you actually unpacked the literacy briefs and understood them and synthesized them and spent the time that chapaqua spent doing it then you would humble yourself and realize that maybe you made a mistake and instead of doubling tripling quadrupling down you would be able to learn from that and bring our numbers up and St further decreasing them South Colony is rated 214 Mr cilio please explain how you're able to pay for these Consultants who are way beneath where we are as far as proficiency levels and student achievement and you're okay with that but you won't consider anything else so is is this a plan of failure like what what were you thinking Miss delamara I know Dela Dr Del camera Carri D online for those who
017are unaware and that's because I'm a veterinarian in the community and I just post for literacy so yes that is my name online thank you for reading my post I'm glad maybe you read something because you don't read the emails and you don't read at the pictures interact State mandates for literacy you said that was not your concern do you want to hear my answer or do you want to talk you can answer the point of this review was to engage in a consultant to provide us a third-party point of view that would not provide us with just Teachers College which you've advocated thank you for recording again I know it's you know one of your favorite things to do teachers college and structured literacy so we would like to the board would like to
018hear both sides of the story from what I've from the research that I've done the research other people have done here I've talked to other teachers I talked to the administration I don't think it's settled science I know you feel I know you feel more strongly about that I've asked I have data everything else can you we Dr uh Mr CIO patiently listened to you and complet yeah but he's saying things and's not I understand everyone deserves the respect of being able to finish what they were saying everyone afforded you the respect please let's just be able to listen until someone's finished thanks so the goal was to do a thoughtful review that here is all all constituencies yourself included I know you met with Dr son I know you've met and given your your
019notes and your comments and those are taken seriously those are being shared with a consultant to be reviewed thoughtfully because the goal of this is to do better I have two kids in those two grades you talk about I know it I live it every day so it's not some sort of not passion project for me personally I'm not happy with the numbers nobody here is happy with the numbers I think in standard business practice what you do when you have people with competing ideas or a program that's not working is you use outside resources is to help you evaluate whether what you're doing is working whether things need to change whether there's a new program in town that is better and the goal is to go through that process and see what it yields
020see what it whether it delivers maybe it delivers structured literacy I don't know but I to go through the to not go through the process is not the way the school district can operate we need to operate in a consistent and professional manner we do take what you say seriously um and that's why we Engage The consult because it's hard for somebody who has a belief to Teachers College to give that other side of the story and we believe our Consultants will do that we've put the full Engagement online so community members can see it they'll be provided the report you can give additional comments if you'd like we're happy to share that with them but that's a process that will be completed the results will be shared with everybody that will go back to
021the literacy committee which I believe you're a part of you're a part of the literacy committee so you can there be there to Advocate as as well which is which is great and we'll see what results come out of that and what what better changes we can make as a result of of the work that's being done well I think my question also is I'm not people that are involved in businesses right and that they're looking to move their businesses up to higher rankings or to have increas increased performance in their businesses right and they're looking for consultants and they're looking to better themselves would you pick a consultant that was functioning at less than half proficiency or less than half if you were rated if they're not able to move their product or to
022get x amount done and they were actually performing lower than you what value would that consultant bring to your business I'm just not following the train of thought maybe you can help explain that but it just doesn't make sense if you're looking at data and you're looking at trying to better something why have guidance from people that haven't even gotten to where you're at I I think in terms of I think you're referring to Mr Mr bis I know I mean and I we also did look at the the consultant that was chosen chapaa different background very unique kind of unique shop they haven't been around very very long casda has been around a little bit longer but they come from diverse School settings they don't come from settings like Garden City so in in
023some fairness to them I wouldn't necessarily expect them to have the same literacy results that we have um and so that's part of the challenge I think you know we we lean on the administration to to pick a couple of different candidates and to review those candidates and we thought that that was the best option for the district as part of this process the chopa Consultants had a whole school system that they ran and they implemented with evidence-based high quality instruction I don't see anything like that for Casta at all and Casta any work that they did it was a very misleading statement that was made last time where it was imply that Casta had worked in literacy with districts on Long Island when in fact that's not true um there was an email uh
024response to a question from a Community member that stated that Casta only worked in four school districts with special education they had nothing to do with Gen Ed and nothing to do with literacy so the information you gave us was actually incorrect you made it seem that last time when we had this discussion here at the board of ed meeting that they were you know reputable and they worked in this area they didn't they didn't work in this area for jened and they did not work in this area for literacy and we have an email confirming that so I did I did say that they did reviews on Long Island which they have done and uh and that was a statement that I had made Joe thought to Del camera first of all I just
025want to listen I appreciate you've made me a better board member I am not an educator um I've listened to you for two years and I've I've researched many of what much of what you've given me I've had to if I had come to you if we had come to you and I'm just off the cuff with theory and practice as our consult consult would you have been all in I think that they mirror what New York state is asking us to do and asking School District to do if you unpack the briefs and actually understand what they said right and and I I look at all this when you and I look they actually work at a school in New Jersey I'm I'm just saying that right at a $40,000 year school with a
026one to five teacher ratio right both of them were educated at Teachers College if I would have put that in front of you and I mean it sincerely I I you Great Value to what i' I've researched but I I I worry that we're worried about little you knows and this they were both educated teach that's okay teachers they did a great job on I read the report no but Teachers College doesn't just have the Lucy Caulkins method they have two routes of Education you can take and one is structured and one is not so you can't just write write it off as they went to Teachers College so what I I understand and lots of teachers thought with balance but I just think if we put it out there it would have been Facebook
027so okay appreciate that I appreciate your honesty but in the matter of fact is they both work at a small school right in they in New Jersey $40,000 a year one to five student teacher you know I like the report there listen we have we're in the same church not in the same Pew um well I think they did I think they did a nice job but if we had come to you with that I don't know if that would have made it out they're only business a year right again I'm not criticizing that they did a nice job but I'm just saying I'm trying to look at it without without a I'm an investigator so I'm trying to look at it unemotional I try to look at it I've lived through the Common Core
028right unfortunately I'm a lot older than people here my kids suffered through the comic cor and that came down from the state yeah was highly approved by Educators so I I'm not I just don't think there's a silver bullet I I think there's things you talk about that we need to do or we need to look at to do but I just don't think there's a silver bullet and I don't want to get into another Common Core scenario well I don't want to get into another I am scenario either and Donna scanland has a program to sell called Isa for literacy and at the East Green Bush School District where Casta was Consulting they brought that in and if you look up Isa on cast's website it pops right up and that's what they use
029for literacy so did we sign any is the contract um that you have with Casta does that involve anything with Isa and Donna scan's program the contract only involves the scope of the work that is detailed on the website I think what's really important to focus on to is that um the assessment that kazda is going to do about our curriculum we're asking them to use New York State EDS K through three curriculum guide and we're also asking them to use the high impact instructional practices as detailed from the literacy briefs so when we're asking for their feedback and their evaluation we're looking to see where we fall as far as our work according to those high impact instructional practices that we are all going to be expected to follow um in you know in
030our curriculum work with our children and I just I just really want to assure the assure the community that when we're engaging in this um work with the Consultants that your the teachers the administrators and all of this board we're looking for an objective report so that's why we're looking for somebody that's like outside of the of the talent that we already have within the district but we're also looking for constructive feedback um with actionable next steps and if some of those next steps involve us um looking at different curriculum materials looking at different curriculum um programs that this board and your the administrators and the teachers are all open and willing to discuss those um those possibilities well I have a question about that that's you know very important statement that you made and
031that they're going to be looking at everything through that lens but Tim Bas was a social studies teacher he was not a literacy teacher he doesn't have any experience in science of reading or teaching reading and then you have Donna scanland who's a university professor professor retired Emer professor in Albany who is not a classroom teacher who has not taught in a classroom teaching reading or teaching anything related to structured literacy her program was actually debunked because it uses guessing and queuing and a lot of things that were found to be anti- um how children learn to orthographically map words and become fluent readers so those are two people right now that obviously are not going to be able to provide what you ask them to provide because of their scope of their work um
032does not coincide with that and then you have the other consultant who I can't find any information that she ever worked in school at all so she might have a teaching license but where did she work in a school district teaching and I can't find that because she just works for New York State and now does Consulting on the side based on what experience it's unknown to me so these are who you hired then for consultancy work to do something that they have no experience doing so how is that going to translate to helping us I I think we've already um talked about what we're looking for as the scope of their work so I think just no further comment right but like for instance I'm a veterinarian and and I do surgery but I
033don't do orthopedic surgery so how would it benefit somebody who has needs major orthopedic surgery to come to me for a consult for something I don't do yeah I learned about it I assisted in surgeries but I would never take in a case like that because it's not something I do all the time or even scrub in to help all the time so I wouldn't want to waste somebody's time with my opinion on something that I truly don't have an expertise in but I'm licensed Ed I can give an opinion on it no one can tell me I can't do it but it's not the right thing to do because it's unethical and also Donna scanland lobbied against the literacy bills and the structured literacy bills and there's actually a newsletter from New York state
034reading Association Upstate where she proudly lobbied against it and stated made statements on it and I have a copy of that too I'm happy to forward to you but she was said that as soon as she heard about these literacy bills they put her at risk and other people at risk that obviously have programs to sell money to make and I mean that's not what she said exactly in those words but you can understand where that takes you same thing with Lucy is having a hard time selling her program and FNP I mean these things affect the bottom line of these people that make these programs that they're making money off of them so you have people looking at something through the lens that New York State wants but they don't have experience in it
035so how is that objective thank you for sharing your concerns we've already but you didn't answer my question you guys are spending a lot of money on a consult on Consultants that have no experience doing what you're asking them to do so can you please explain that Dr Dela um you know we we we also know in terms of what they're what we're looking for there have been in the past we've had Consultants that we may not if if if we're not getting the work that we need we do believe that we will and if that if there's a case where we're dissatisfied we won't go that route right so but I very if I could finish please I I am very confident that the engagement process for these Consultants are going to work for
036the district and make us better and and again you'll be involved in it I I shared with you you you you know you've given me a lot of information said I'd be sharing all of that with the with the Consultants which I will be doing and any other comments that we have receiv received from parents parents are going to be very much involved and it'll be a process where there you know everything will be up on our website it is already there the information that we have so far and we'll continue to do that and keep folks informed and I think we're going back and forth and it's it's a and I know you feel very differently and you feel very very very differently around with the work that we're doing you're engaged so we're
037we're you know I'm glad that you're engaged and your feedback is going to be important what is the bottom line of the price tag here what are you Char what are they charging you it's going to be $247 for the total total and thank you hello feie Campbell Oxford Boulevard um I don't have a school age child um my oldest uh attended uh kindergarten the first year that it was full day in Garden City and that was in 2005 and to read with ease and um that was great but I know that's not the case for everyone it surely wasn't for my second child and I understand the frustration that the parents in the district are feeling and um and I think you do as well I mean I thank you for listening to them
038and uh trying to work with everybody but it is a serious issue um I although I have no longer have children um in the district I still continue to pay a very big school tax bill and I'm concerned about how the money is being spent and um I'm not happy that a consultant is being hired that has um he he came from a district that probably was very different from ours it's in Albany um but the success rate was uh under 50% I I the data I found said 47 someone today corrected me um said it was 43 Dr Del Cam said it was 42 so that really that's pretty bad so um and then someone from the community reached out to casda and you've heard this before and they had no data on their
039successes and that also is not good so I questioned how we ended up with CDA um but I also want to know why when we have a superintendent of of curriculum and a director of literacy why do we need a consulting firm and I know $24,000 in the scheme of things is is not really a ton of money but it's still our money that's being spent and I'm trying to understand what the superintendent of curriculum is doing in terms of literacy what the director of literacy because that job didn't even exist um that long ago am I correct how long have we had a director of literacy in the district two and a half years we had a curriculum coordinator 6 through 12 and then we changed all of our coordinators they're now K12 so
040that's been for the past I would say three little over three years so what's the role of the director of literacy the she she's very much all of our all of our coordinators that are K12 or directors they are they they bring a lot of professional learning in The Bu in our schools they do they do quite extensive work but I'll tell you if you speak to any School District Consultants when they come in I just said before we we actually had our science consultant come in yesterday they bring another perspective they help us get better um so that's not that's like in any organization you do get people to come in to help you to see things uh you know with whatever area we need support in so this consultant that's coming it's really
041coming in to give us here's x amount of work we've done what can we do differently and better so that's what it what uh CA would be doing one question that you asked that I do want to address any consultant that comes in for whatever reason the success rate is what the districts will do with with whatever there's lots and lots of variables it could be a cons you know I don't know but if if there are Consultants that make recommendations um you need more Staffing you need multiple changes those things happen over time I think and not every you know uh getting a review is a process and I think that is something that's important for our community to understand with um you know when you do any of these curriculum reviews and it's
042not atypical by the way it's actually pretty typical to do curriculum review that's what's what we're engaged in at this time right but as Dr delam said and I didn't know this Tim bis his his um background is not in literacy it's in social studies that so that's concerning and he was a um Deputy um superintendent um in last year he just this his job is very new for him so we're really um we're really rolling the dice here with him and his company he's brand new at the job um his the there's no um success rate that you know they can speak of and um from what I hear from my friends and neighbors the kids in our District are not in a good place reading I mean you know those those of us
043who have kids that learn with these yay but what about everyone else and um that's concerning that we're starting with a consultant with really no track record and our kids are not in a good place we had shared C Casta is a um it's not a new organizations they've been around for many many years so um you know their the director may be different but that consulting firm Casta has been around for a long time but they have no data on their successes do do like does everyone realize that they have that they said that they have no data on their successes how does a company like that not keep data I just explained that earlier I think there's a lot of variables it's on whatever any review you do in a in a school
044system any program review it's a about the implementation and what the districts are taking the recommendation and what they're implementing so I think that's what that means for my perspective but you can still have data on that you can say Garden City did X and this is what right I can't I can't speak to I I just gave you I didn't speak to them about that I I couldn't give you that information I mean I would love I would love to know where where they've had successes it just would be because it's not just the money it's the time that's going to be spent on this and what's going to be accomplished in that time so thank you thank you everyone I appreciate what you do we always appreciate new people showing up so thank
045you Angela muta 117 kingsbery Road uh I have a couple of statements to say first of all I know that every single person that's in this room is really on the same page we all want the students of this District to do better so that being said I have to say that as a lifelong educator I have been through many programs some of them horrible some of them great some of them mediocre some of them in between I taught them I did professional development with them and even the worst left us with something good that we learned so that has to always be considered as a stepping stone toward professional development even when you make a mistake you actually have a Learning lesson that goes along with that I really wish and I know nothing
046about casda I don't care about kazda I'm indifferent doesn't matter to me one way or the other I love the fact that there is going to be another set of eyes coming in to look at everything hopefully with without being jaded I don't know can't speak to it haven't researched casda don't care about casda only care that every now and then we have another set of eyes coming in to say let me look at what you're doing let me give my professional opinion a social studies teacher has a professional opinion just because they didn't teach literacy doesn't mean that they don't have master's degree in education doesn't mean that they can't do it but I don't know I don't know this person I have no skin in the game I could care less but we
047definitely frequently need another set of eyes so if that's the argument Casta I don't care people do your research figure it out doesn't matter but having another set of eyes should be respected and done frequently what I really wish people would research is the validity of the data and the test that we're giving and the attention and the time that we spend on tests that are invalid we need better data I think all of the work that's been done in the last eight years that I've been following this and been coming to these meetings have led to us getting better data not from the New York State ELA test not from the New York state math test not from the nwaa the data that is timely that is accurate that is is on the students
048desk most recently is the best data something that happened when a test is given in May and the results are given the following September when the child is in the next grade to me is invalid anyone that disagrees with me I'm happy to have this conversation with but please research the data and then we can discuss where it is as far as the data of the Consultants again I'm not an expert about that but in my humble opinion I've been working in many different schools throughout my life and you can compare one school to another you can't compare one District to another and you really can compare what the results are because the results in the South Bronx are not going to be like Garden City even if it's the same consultant so that's my
049piece any other questions seeing none thank you um to make more efficient use of the meeting time uh the board of education education authorizes the use of a consent agenda as part of the meeting agenda consent agenda allows for one motion to approve multiple items and such items are identified on the agenda the president of the board will ask for a motion to approve the consent agenda and we'll ask if board members wish to have a discussion or clarification on specific items contained within the agenda following the discussion the board will then vote on the consent agenda Motion in addition the board May request to have an item removed from the consent agenda in order to vote on the motion separately at this time may have a motion to approve the consent agenda which includes
050business of boards matter F1 Personnel matters G1 through G3 and business office matters H1 through H3 so moved second all in favor I future Board of Education meeting announcements the next one will be Tuesday February 25th 2025 it's a regular session of 8:15 in the Garden City High School um is there any other business from the administration board none at this time at this time a motion that no further businesses to come before the board and the meeting is adjourned so second favor I