0012025 regular session of the Board of Education this is Joe CIO president of the Board of Education speaking thank you for attending in person or through Zoom uh before we begin this meeting tonight I would ask for a moment of silence for Miss Laura Hastings who passed away over the weekend Miss Hastings was a trustee on the board of education for almost a decade uh here in Garden City Miss Hastings is a valued member of the board and we send our heartfelt condolences to her family and friends at this time please for the Pledge of Allegiance andice do you notice of this meeting has been provided to the public and each member of the board of education is required by law Tina can you take attendance please present present president m is superintendent for human
002resources and leadership development present present at this time we have a motion to accept the agenda for January 28 2025 regular session as presented so move second all in favor I uh at this time Mrs decapia would you please provide the treasures report yes of course uh this is the treasur treasurers report for November 2024 we had a cash balance at the beginning of the month of 46 m751 134 we had receipts during the month of 47,1 51,4 we have dispersement totaling 9,629 825 leaving us with a closing balance of 84 m272 710 thank you thank you Mrs de capio at this time Dr C I'll turn the mic over to you for the superintendence report thank you Mr cilio and I have a a long report so you'll have to bear with me but
003some uh you know first I wanted to start off with some uh really good student and faculty news so I think you've seen in the in the paper around uh regarding Amy Jia she has been named a finalist in the 2025 regeneron science Talent search she's one of uh only 40 finalists from more than 800 high schools and Amy's project focus is on citrin which is a well-known within the context of his genetic disease and Amy analyzed its effects when looking at cancer cells which can rewire their metabolisms uncontrolled growth and she explored how its function can impact patient outcome be blocked affect cancer cell metabolism we're incredibly proud of Amy's work and wish her continued success as she heads off to Washington DC in March to compete with other finalists it is truly an
004incredible accomplishment and we will have Amy and her teachers Dr Gordon and Dr Foley at a future meeting to recognize them and I have to tell you Amy's research is quite impressive and if you get a chance to attend or uh go to our science research Symposium which is held in the spring it is incredible what our students uh accomplish um so we are very U I look forward to these kids doing some impressive things for our larger Community I also want to recognize Taylor lefave She's a fifth grade student at Stewart and she recently received a perfect score in the first of three meets in the 38th annual word Masters challenge the challenge is a nationwide vocabulary competition with almost 125 5,000 students Nationwide compete in and Taylor competed in the higher level blue
005Division and scored a perfect score something only um only 34 other fifth graders Nationwide achieved so we're very very proud of Taylor also want to recognize our um music department uh we had nearly 70 students who were selected to participate in this year's all count music festival they were selected in recognition of their 2024 nisma solo performances these students represented the district at Division 1 West and division 2 all County Music Festival at Long Island University very proud of our students I also want to congratulate our Latin teacher Miss Durkin who was recently awarded a professional development Grant from the classical Association of the Atlantic states and has been named a 2024 recipient of the society for classical studies award for excellence in teaching at the K12 level she was selected based on several benchmarks
006including her love for learning her passion for L and her dedication to her students growth all of which make her a leader in this field and our two Spanish teachers uh Miss Cena and Mr Berg were among the Educators recognized during the optimum for Hispanic heritage essay contest contest they received a combined gift of $1,000 to purchase materials and supplies congratulations to both of them as well and then I also wanted to mention uh we were recently notified that our high school has been selected as a nominee for this year's National Blue Ribbon award the New York State education dep department is allowed to nominate only 19 schools out of thousands to the US Department of Education for the National Blue Ribbon award and we were selected so again this is a nomination there's an
007application process that will go through but we're very very pleased and we will keep our community and the board informed of that as well um I also wanted to give an update on our we had um discussed getting an outside literacy Consultants I wanted to give an update to the community on that and we had um we have a group of uh Consultants coming in who will be reviewing our literacy program case six and again we had discussed that when we did the student achievement report on um December 10th it was and um we have partnered the capitol area school Development Association it's the Caster group casda and the University at Alban School of Education to conduct a comprehensive review of our literacy program the collaboration draws on the expertise of consultants and researchers to
008assess and enhance our practices ensuring alignment with the New York State Next Generation Ela standards science of reading and research-based strategies and best practices the review encompasses a thorough analysis of all the components of our case6 literacy program to identify strengths areas of growth and opportunities for improvement so some of the in terms of the scope of the work they'll be reviewing our materials and guiding documents they will um review Staffing what does that mean assessment of classroom and reading intervention Staffing to determine the alignment of roles and resources they will also uh conduct focus groups and surveys that's engagement with teachers administrators parents and other stakeholders through focus groups and surveys to gather perceptions and opinions about our literacy program they'll also do an analysis of both state and local data to understand Trends
009in student achievement and the effectiveness of our current literacy practices um they will also review our professional development plan uh with a particular focus on lit literacy related training and its alignment with instructional needs they'll conduct classroom visits and then they will uh make recommendations or actionable recommendations for program enhancements and they will provide a comprehensive report um for our board and our community member which we'll share once that's uh completed and the team will be uh there uh right now they have three people on the team um uh Meg Rooney she's an expert she has expertise in uh early childhood education literacy standards and professional development and uh Timothy bakus who's the executive director his uh his area of expertise is in uh curriculum design professional development and strategic oversight and Dr Donna scanland
010she's a renowned literacy researcher and published author of several books her focuses on Implement implementing proven methods to reduce reading difficulties and enhance teacher Effectiveness so we were very impressed with the group's expertise and background and several Nassau County districts have used this group for other program reviews and uh we're really looking forward uh to them uh conducting this review and we're looking forward to sharing that with our board and of course our community I also wanted to address some questions regarding our student performance on state assessments as shared during our student achievement report on December 10th our principls and Dr Bowman provided a comprehensive review of student performance K through 12 including key strengths areas of growth and our plans for moving forward I encourage any understanding um to listen to the student achievement
011uh report um that was uh on December 10th it is on our website it's under the Board of Education tab I also want to address uh concerns that have recently been raised on social media about student literacy and clarify how we are addressing these issues while building on our successes now I will not be reporting anything new to you this is this has was all reported on December 10th our team thoroughly reviewed our New York State Ela and math assessment data with teachers with teachers focusing on standards gaps and strengths and actionable next steps in addition they also analyze other important data from local assessments including our nwaa and classroom assessments on a regular basis um um Mr hardigan and miss hand they reported for three through five you know strong performances in determining in
012in in several in each of the grade level they identified our strengths and they also identified areas we need to do better in in grade three they um they shared that we had strong performance in determining the meaning of words and figurative language grade four strong in describing characters settings and events grade five strength in determining themes and supporting details and in grade five they talked about the growth um you know we saw a nice growth between 2022 and 2024 and they made some strategical decisions around instructional time and how that was being spent and they also talked about opportunities where we need to we we need to do better and they discussed very intense uh uh actually they spent quite a bit of time talking about constructed and extended responses that remain an area
013for improvement for us and they talked about the clear strategy which is claim evidence another piece of evidence and reasoning and to help students construct stronger written responses they also talked about that while students show strength in areas like identifying themes and character analysis there is room for more consistent performances these stand central idea summarizing and interpreting texts are critical for deeper comprehension across all grades similarly Mr Samuelson who's here um he also talked about the middle school again he talked about the strengths and areas where we can do better and um and finally they shared their action steps of what they would be doing after the analysis and I think all three of our principal spoke along with uh Dr Bowman teachers prioritizing focused standards Based on data professional development centered on analyzing student
014work and instructional strategies dedicated periods for close reading and response to to reading using curated texts purposeful rereading and the clear strategy incorporating more writing across content areas and preparing students for computer-based um testing uh with support from our of course our technology team on and again on December 10th we had talked about the outside consultant which I just shared with you just a little bit ago and uh you know I wanted to actually we also discussed this on December 10th was that the New York State uh Assessment 3 through eight is just it's one measure of literacy and they don't necessarily always capture the full picture of a student's abilities we discussed in depth during that time the importance of multiple measures so approximately 30% of our students scored at Lev one and one
015and two and of those students many are capable readers who excel in other areas and for those who face challenges we are addressing them with targeted strategies and supports while literacy is a priority our District's overall success remains strong most of our children are with us through grade 12 and our exiting outcomes are excellent our alums regularly share that they were very very well prepared for college and Beyond and we remain committed to continuous Improv ment with our internal analysis and with the help of external Consultants with a focus on meaningful evidence-based strategies we're confident in our ability to meet uh the needs of a student in our district and finally I encourage our parents to connect directly with their child's teacher to discuss any concerns as uh as they have the most in-depth understanding
016of their child's abilities and progress additionally our principles are always available to support you in uh in addressing any other further concerns you may have um and uh you know that's what I want to share about both the literacy consultant and the literacy the these things have been out on um social media or some folks have brought to my attention so I wanted to um um share my thoughts on that um we also had the literacy committee meeting um I think that was two weeks ago the literacy committee meeting right so I know miss papish you were there and um Dr Bowman miss hand co-chair that Comm oh not co-chair miss Han and Miss Kaufman do but uh Dr Bowman is very very much involved with uh the literacy committee so miss Papas do you
017want to share anything about the literacy committee I'll start um yes I was able to attend um the literacy committee meeting so thank you Dr Bowman Miss Kaufman and miss hand for organizing another committee meeting to familiarize our families with some of the literacy work in our classrooms um it was another well- attended um event there was um a large group of parents which continues to show how committed our district is our community is um to the literacy of our children we had the opportunity to engage in some different rotations where um they were familiarizing us with some of the literacy experiences that our children have inside of the classroom like um interactive read alouds close reading analytical writing and then also um Fishbowl discussions so um it was a great experience sorry would you
018like to add anything to that Miss Bowman or Dr Bowman uh sure um as Miss Peppa said we had four rotations which were designed to really showcase not only um individual experiences that our children have as they go through the K12 Continuum but also to weave the thread through so you could see what the growth is so if you experience an interactive read aloud that is aligned with science standards and you're also learning literacy skills in the primary grades how does that build and what does that look like when you're doing close reading in the elementary years and then how do you build on that and how does that inform the writing instruction that happens in the middle school and the culminating experience was um an example from our 11 AP our advanced placement uh
019English language and composition class where the students are asked to a few days prior given a prompt to consider and in this case it was against um some of the themes that are present in The Scarlet Letter and they engage the students engage in discourse during the course of the class where the teacher is really just a stage on the side and is not someone who's in front of everything where it's much more student run but is also very clear the through lines that go all the way back to the primary classrooms um at the end of the meeting everybody came back and and one of the things that I thought was actually wonderful is that we had scheduled for the time to end at I think we said it was going to end at
0205 o'clock um people were there very engaged in the activities until close to 5:30 very happy to to be part of what's going on and a couple of the comments that I heard from participants in my group were wow that's a lot that's a lot to be learning and and really the people that were there were able to see the through lines um and so so I think that it was a very successful meeting and our next meeting is May 29th thank you Dr Bowman did you have a no I was just gonna make a comment because something I think the board focused on in choosing the consultant you you obviously had several candidates that you wanted to interv talk to I think directive from the board and from you is to find somebody who
021would and I use the word their stamp we're not looking for somebody to tell us we're doing everything great we're trying to find we tried to find a consultant who we thought fit um the the K through five um literacy uh person who could really help Drive um a conclusion that helps us improve the district and not just tells us that what we've done is is uh is working really well because I think we all are reflecting and think there's some improvement that needs to be made so uh I think it's understood but I wanted to say that that was part of the selection process and so we're hoping you know what's the timeline again for the the report from the consultants and then the one thing we also ask for is we're going to
022we want the Consultants to look at other districts with publicly available data and see if there's things that they're doing that we're not that is maybe leading to different outcomes and um I'm sure instead of letting online people say it we'll say it we're not going to index against everybody we better than we'll index against people who are better or or scoring better than us to see if there's things that we can learn so that uh obviously this takes a step forward I know we're all anxious to do that and you're anxious to do that so yeah we're uh you know there's um you know they have a team which which is what we like we want some different perspectives to come and assist with this so they'll start um you know they'll start I
023think it's in early February and they said it's going to take a good two months for them to really um you know complete the scope of the work is pretty extensive so um so I think I mark probably around April or so and we'll and we'll give an update at every single board meeting on what they're doing that was my next question one of the things I think we're focusing on is the interdisciplinary connections I know uh trusty papis trusty Jano say it all the time you say it all the time when we're not in front of everybody but that's one of the things we're focused on you know in fact uh since you bring that up um just today I know Dr Bowman you met with the coordinators and that was the main focus
024of your meeting with them do you want to just speak speak briefly about that yeah sure actually um we have been working on getting some diagnostic data so that we are able to address some targeted needs of our students and that has just completed its cycle um and we used linkit to perform those assessments and the results that we have are tied to the standards and when I met with the coordinators today it wasn't just the literacy coordinator it wasn't just miss Kaufman it was all of the coordinators and we discussed making sure that the standards where we our students need some extra supports are focused on in all of the discipline areas so looking at how are we going to make some small adjustments in how certain assessments maybe are presented or how instruction
025is presented in the science classroom that would help support the standards and make sure that the students skills are really being focused and targeted to you know to close any gaps that we have but we also had today and yesterday kindergarten PD happening where our kindergarten teachers were um learning more about interactive read alouds and the text that they were using was on forces and so when I think about Force I first of all I'm thinking that we're in physics um and I also as the AP Physics teacher today so I hope he's happy to hear that our kindergarteners are learning AP Physics um at the right bu age of five but really what was happening was that there was a crossover between the literacy instruction that was happening in the in the kindergarten classroom
026with also the science units that are being taught concurrently which really is very much in alignment with what is best practice um and so that's another thing that was just happening today as well just just as a refresher for everybody link it is the system that the board and the administration worked on purchasing over the last year and a half that tracks student data um track unit tracks units of study and is is able to be used over the course of the Continuum of the students life with us so when they go to se from second grade to third grade to fourth grade those teachers can see the data and the and the performance of those students in those course units over time so that we have a significant Data Tracking System so we're no
027longer kind of you know my word stone age uh in terms of tracking with paper and Pen relying on teachers to have conversations with each with each other correct all right just some other updates there was all uh there was also uh um questions regarding our class size in the middle school and that's something that we had discussed um early on on this school year so that's something that um you know we are we said we made a commitment to the smaller class sizes particularly for our seventh graders going into eighth grade so uh Mr Samuelson has been working hard uh along with Dr Bowman and uh Mr Samuel's team to ensure that for our eighth grade and we also have a larger class size coming in sixth grade so we have been working on
028uh our budget so I would ask everybody to continue to come to our board meetings especially through our budget discussions and we'll be talking about enrollment and class size for K through 8 yeah and I I think you know I know some people asked about the question I forget when that discussion was whether it was September or October uh obviously we couldn't make Universal changes in classroom size and hire new teachers if that was the direction so that's being handled in the budget process those discussions have started Mrs de capio was hard at work with the admin ministration working out how to pay for all of this um I would be remiss in saying that you know anytime you ask for more resources it it's got to come from somewhere so it might lead to
029increases in taxes or cut in other services but um it's something we've committed to doing so I just wanted to flag that for everybody so they're not surprised when we go through the budget process and then just some items that are on the agenda that I wanted to mention uh we have two retirements on the agenda one is our coordinator of social studies Miss Janette balante who'll be retiring at the end of June 30th um and we're very very sad to be saying um for uh looking seeing miss balantic retirement she has been an integral part of the success of our social studies um Department throughout the district and she's been here uh for 18 years and she has also believe it or not in the last couple of years when our coordinators became K12
030uh the work she has done with our K5 um you know know uh classrooms and looking at social studies in in those classrooms particularly she has brought in a lot of project-based learning um and assist assisted us with that so we will be um celebrating and honoring all of our retirees uh later on in the school year uh but we do want to thank her for her dedication to Garden City schools and we also have on the agenda and that's in April of this year Miss Hilton Valerie Hilton the head secretary at Locus school will be retiring and that'll be after 27 years uh she's been with the district and uh Loca school is going to be very different with that Miss Miss Hilton because she's been there for a long long time and we
031thank her for her dedication uh to Garden City Schools we also have on the agenda uh an appointment for uh Miss uh Michelle vavona as our next director of P Personnel Services we're very um happy to share that uh you know that we she'll be taking on this this role and again it won't be effective till uh July 1st but this affords us the opportunity um to look for an assistant director um for Miss favona but I want to mention that in a very short amount of time um you know Miss favona started here July 1 she has built relationship relationships and has learned about our um about Garden Garden City our district our special education program and um she has strengthened The Homeschool partnership that was something that we wanted uh we it's a
032work in progress but um she's already strengthened that partnership to ensure that every student receiv receives the support they need to thrive academically socially and emotionally and um we're really pleased um to be um recommending her for appointment this evening and um Miss mclin will start the search you know once she's a appointed for the assistant director and at our next meeting she'll share a timeline with uh with the board and the community other items on the agenda our continuing education program for spring uh 2025 is on the agenda we have two donations on the agenda so we want to thank our PTA for Their donation uh for the purchase of nine mini drones with remotes for our middle school I know our children and Mr Samuelson is clapping uh teachers are very pleased with
033this and I know our kids are going to love this so we thank our PT a and we also have a donation uh from Box Tops for education for Stratford school to purchase uh recess supplies and some important dates uh our High School open house for 8th grade eth graders is on January 30th at the high school beginning at 4 p.m. we are also finishing up a kindergarten registration this week so so parents who still need to register their um their children to contact the home school um and uh next week we we are also looking forward to the Stratford fifth grade musical that's on Wednesday and Thursday and uh we'll be having our first budget discussion on February 25th so we've moved it to the next meeting it's um and we'll update our calendar
034for that as well and then finally as a reminder schools are closed tomorrow in observance of Lunar New Year and we wish those families celebrating a very happy Lunar New Year filled with health happiness and prosperity thank you thanks T I may just one follow one on the on the Middle School class sizing just to put a number around it it's preliminary and Mrs T Capia will yell at me at some point for saying this but School in pods you're talking probably about roughly $500,000 or somewhere thereabouts in terms of teachers that need to be hired for a pod is that oh if you're hiring a full team of teachers um yes um but but Mr Samuelson is give me a head no okay so we can we can flush that out but I just
035want people to to just yeah yeah don't yeah don't don't be upset um but our but I do want to reiterate that is but um the plans that have been um you know that that have been developed is that we will have um smaller class sizes for sure and that we made a commitment early on that we would and um so the the you know looking at scheduling and looking at um assignments that's that's that's our focus and then one last thing um I know there was some school outages this week uh we don't need to belabor it but some of the boilers in the high school and middle school are both older than most people in this room um they're out of date they need to be updated there's been a plan in place
036to replace at least one of them um another one is going to be replaced in short order due to some of the challenges that we experienced in the past few weeks um so I know there's some talk about that it's it's being budgeted for but the the facilities old and just need some general maintenance and I don't think there's much more to say unless people have questions on that any other questions or comments from the board Administration oh oh oh you know what yes one more item um is the universal prek we wanted to just give a quick update on that uh Dr Bowman will give an update sure um So currently the Google form for families to register for the lottery is open it opened on Monday at 8 a uh sorry 9 9:00
037am um and by 8:59 we had five respondents so that was great currently we have 166 respondents to the Google form um we have 174 seats across four locations we are increasing the number of locations where we're offering uh upk next year we will be continuing to offer two classrooms at Homestead we'll have four classrooms at our um Harbor Roslin site we will be also opening two classrooms at the minola site for Harbor as well as a classroom at our Precious Angels um included in the Google form that was sent out as the indication of preferences for where a family would prefer to have their child seated should they be successful in the lottery to get one of the 74 seats those preference are just that they're preferences they're not guarantees because we need to
038make sure that we follow the lottery rules which are posted on the upk website um the Google form will close this Friday January 31st at 3M and we will be holding the lottery the following Friday on February 7th um we have held one day of professional development January 22nd where the teachers from both of the currently existing sites came together to learn about the new creative curriculum through teaching strategies that we're implementing um and we just booked a second date March 12th uh for a second full day of uh professional development for those teachers in anticipation of having full implementation in the fall okay thank you thank you I think uh trust trusty papis um had the pleasure of doing a walk through the schools this past week and she would like to give an
039update or give her overview of what she experienced thank you um I was um fortunate on Friday to have the opportunity to visit many different classrooms at various grade levels at Stewart Hemlock and um at straford and I really want to thank the teachers for welcoming me in to observe the great work that's happening I know even after 20 years um as a teacher it can still be nerve-wracking having um people come in and observe you doing um your work in the classroom so I do really appreciate them um I'm going to do my best to capture some of the highlights from my learning walk I observed in all of my classrooms both whole class and small group instruction in phonics literacy and Mathematics I saw students working on an activity where they were decoding
040multisyllabic words I saw sound drills and the start of making words using tile boards I saw students sharing texts reading out loud together talking around a focus objective WR writing down their thoughts and ideas using graphic organizers I observe teachers pushing the thinking of their students with discussions in a read aloud and also in group discussions around texts I also observed some whole class and small group instruction in mathematics where students learning was supported by manipulatives like base 10 blocks at the primary level I observed small group work around building pheic awareness students were mapping sounds and using manipulatives to represent the sounds they heard I saw encoding work as students were segmenting sounds and writing words I observed Center activities where some students were engaged in activities to build fluency and practice decoding skills
041While others were spelling or encoding I saw teachers working collaboratively each delivering small group instruction I observed some skilled behavior management when a movement break quickly transitioned into small group learning and I can appreciate that that doesn't happen easily with children at the primary level unless you've created a community of clear expectations I was also able to visit the renovated steuart Library which was a beautiful job integrating the old with the new they made really great use of the Space by creating a separate portion of the room that a class can utilize even when students are work um when another class is working with the librarian during their special time but overall I saw our kids engaged um and hard at work and I also saw our teachers leading learning experiences in which students were
042active in their learning so I'm looking forward to carving out some more time to visit some of the other primary schools as well as our middle and high school and my suggestion too is that I'd love for us to find a way for more of our families and also our community members to see some of those new learning spaces that we have created um this I mean I the Stuart library was beautiful um and I may not have seen it if I hadn't been on that learning walk so um I think it would be wonderful if there was a way that we can invite more families and community members to see some of those spaces in some way and I'd just like to done but thank you for taking it I know you took a
043day off from work to go through through the school so I think that's appreciated by me it should be appreciated by the community members people dedicate a lot of time and um so thank you for doing that and providing the report any other questions this time uh the mic is open for Citizens questions I think you as most of you faces are familiar so if you have any questions you know the drill hi my name is Sarah Hogan um I live on Kenwood Road and I have a fifth grader and a seventh grader um I have been bringing the large class size to the administrator's attention since September and I do recognize that changes do not happen overnight um I'm still disappointed that my daughter is sitting in classes of 33 students and and um
044I feel like this would be a great time to make a change because they just finished their midterm benchmarks and um maybe they could be split up into smaller groups um I'm here to advocate for class size because class size is linked to student performance um I do really appreciate the fact that you addressed this and it does seem like there is hope that next year um class size will be imp approved and I appreciate that you have heard um what the community has been saying and are looking to change that for next year um I I feel like I heard a commitment for next year I wish that something could be done for the remainder of this year thank you just to be clear that that's a commitment from the board so we we'll
045we'll figure it out for next year this year I don't think there's I don't know if there's anything else we can do that we already done so hi dinor Del camro one sunet lean I have a couple questions about the Consultants I'm very familiar with Dr Donna scandin and she is not structured literacy trained she's not credited in it and she's actually vly opposed to it I have been in Albany with her I've been on a committee with her and she is the complete opposite of Science of reading based instruction so I'm just confused as to how you went about the selection process what criteria and qualifications you looked at and the other point is being part of a university they're they kind of created the problem they are not teaching teachers are preparing them
046the way that New York State wants them prepared that's why New York state now has the path forward because they see there's an issue with the universities so the fact that she's affiliated with Albany they're creating a problem because they're letting teachers graduate that do not have that skill set to really teach reading with phonics that's why we have to do so much professional development why you have to train in foundations in integrities and have speech brought in because they're not being well prepared they're still holding on some colleges some are changing now but there's something called New York State path forward you could look it up if you're not familiar with it but it literally states that New York is going to be implementing these changes at the University level so teachers will be
047prepared when they graduate unlike they are now so this just seems completely counterintuitive to me and it seems like we're going to be going in the opposite direction and yes Mr s like you said you're not looking to rubber stamp but you're hiring people that that's exactly what they're going to do because that's inclination they're not for science of reading they're not for moving in this direction they're actually opposed to it just real quick Dr did you say that she's affiliated with Albany yes who's going to make these changes no she's not they don't she doesn't make any changes she actually no but you said the university is going to she the New York state has something called The Path forward SC has I understand all that I'm just ask you said University of Al
048is changing standards so teachers come out with this they are supposed to be it's going to take some years to do it but scandin has programs that she sells herself that are balanced literacy so she has a money thing uh I I understand I just was confused when you said she's affiliated with Aly and they Liv kind of KN University of Al okay she lives there and she shows up whenever there's any kind of legislation going on or groups or advocacy so she's not affiliated with she's not affiliated with well she was with Albany she does I think she's retired she's like an emirus Professor like she doesn't teach there anymore or anything but I think it's she um has that um you know I guess that title just because she was there for a
049while but it's not something that is based on science of reading it's not something that structured literacy she's actually opposed to structured literacy and science of reading honestly I'll have we'll discuss that and that's not going to be the marching orders but listen We're not gonna have anybody perfect you know we we Ved these people well that that's your opinion and I respect that are you an educator no but I've been involved in all of this and worked with New York State as well so we will bring that up after the meeting because I'm concerned with yeah there's I there's two competing schools of thought here you you have a very strong opinion on one opinion it's fact Mr cilio and it's fact that based by New York state if you look at New York
050State Department of that everything it does every District use what you're saying no but they're gonna have to so it's not it's not it's not Universal then right no it's a mandate 202 in sep top District use what you're saying as far as as far as we know I don't think that's that's a fact well Long Island is just don't declare don't use generalizations is fact we're we're aligned have you read the Mandate have you read in the issue I mean reading the Mandate is not of my concern we have people who are looking into it what I'm saying is there's two schools of thought there's not there's one school of thought and your opinion show me the research that backs your opinion that's what New York State not evidence yeah they are and they
051have to change that's what New York state is saying I mean New York says a lot New York state says a lot of things so right they're finally getting this little piece right so you should read it I hope you're right questions comments Maria Alber 29 Locust Street I just had a question I wasn't at the last like one or two meetings so I didn't know where we stood with the law suit and I just wanted an update that's allation yes yes is a lawsuit um the board will spent a fair amount of time um based on the most recent uh releases from the state and state Ed uh we have made the determination that by op out which we already have done there's really no further challenges for us at this time um other
052districts want to sue to have a full removal and Mr Spencer can correct me if I'm using general uh legal parlance full removal um things might change uh um we're not uh we we're not unaware of the fact the state has fiscal challenges and you know some of us suspect that part of this was to solve for some of those issues so uh I don't think it's done personally but as of right now I don't think there's any actions for us to take Mr Spencer feel free to jump in right just to confirm you Mr cilio that's that is absolutely correct at this point there is nothing more for the district to do you've opted out of your participation in that program um based upon that we don't believe that entering into the suit is
053something that would serve your best interest at this time they they I I will say I'm aware that they are they are commencing um it will affect everybody there's always a chance to to join if something changes or a data point changes or some sort of fact changes but as of right now we submitted our paperwork there was very specific language that originally required that you could opt out of the process but you couldn't opt out of regionalization it was kind of cute legal ease in my opinion it they subsequently changed that language over the course of I think it was four or six weeks in November December uh and so that's where the board's at at this point in time okay was there any like specific reason why we opted out like just not
054in the best interest of this District or is we don't think it's we don't think we need to at this point in time um it's also a financial consideration but I don't know if Dr zind you had another yeah if I we opted out of the regionalization and we did send a letter to State education department that was recognized we received a reply back from them that you know that we won't we don't we don't need to participate in the regionalization process at all from what I understand and um I've just glanced over documents that there it really isn't an option it's going to happen like that's from my my understanding um they actually clarified that and we do I think we did actually I don't know if Tina you can confirm we put it
055on our website or what we received from State Ed recognizing that we're not going to be participating okay thank you so much there are any other questions at this time to make efficient efficient use of the meeting the board has authorized the use of a consent agenda consent agenda allows for one motion to approve multiple items and such items as identified on the agenda president of the board will ask for a motion to approve the consent agenda and we'll ask if the board members was to have a discussion or clarification on any specific items contained within that consent agenda following discussion the board will then vote on the consent agenda Motion in addition of request to have one item removed and discussed individually and voted separately at this time may have a motion to approve
056the consent agenda which includes business of the board items G1 through G5 Personnel matters items H1 through H5 business office matters i1 through I13 special education matters items J1 through J2 and continue education matter scale through K2 so mov all in favor I you know after the appr I'd like to congratulate Miss F on her appointment thank you for your hard work wish she continued success in the role um is there any new business from the board Administration future board of education meetings they'll be uh Tuesday February 11 2025 it's a board of education public and public work and special session 8:15 and then as Dr Sina said the I think it's the first uh budget meeting will be Tuesday February 25th it's a board of education regular session at 8:15 um at this time
057we have a motion that there's no further business to come before the board that the meeting is adjourned second all in favor I