001for work session of the Board of Education this is Joe Silo president of the Board of Education speaking thank you for attending in person or through Zoom please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance do notice of today's meeting is provided to the public and each member of the board of education is required by law Tina will you please take attendance present present present president um tonight I'm going to hand the microphone over to start um we have a presentation on the student achievement report so Dr SEL will you please take us out sure thank you um and again you know every year we dedicate one of our work sessions to our student achievement report so this evening we'll provide a thoughtful review of our ongoing efforts to support students success we continue to be one
002of the top performing school districts in New York State ranking in the top 5% in the 3 through eight assessments along with our results at the secondary level our students outcomes reflect the collective dedication of our Educators students and Families Our exiting outcomes continue to be an area that we're very proud of which uh Mr Steiner will talk about shortly while these accolades are gratifying they also serve as a reminder of our responsibility to maintain high standards and continually strive for improvement also wanted to take a moment to thank our teachers staff for their hard workor to create learning environments where students can Thrive they build and nurture deep connections and genuinely care for our students and these are qualities that cannot be measured but are deeply deeply valued in our district and of course
003our parents they are always our true Partners in this important journey and our all of our administrators that are here are um you know principles our coordinators our APS aren't here our specialed um uh administrators that are here work very very closely with um teachers to maintain a United focus on Student Success their leadership and collaboration are instrumental and fostering excellence in every classroom I I said no thank you both for being here our ass system principles um and our Board of Education of course your focus on uh you know Student Success is very much appreciated and it's seen in the decisions that we uh we collectively make here at board meetings so some of the strengths that we will be talking about this evenings this evening are high levels of proficiency and Mastery across
004state and National assessments with ap participation and performance exceeding State and Global averages regions Mastery rates that consistently Place us among the highest on Long Island and New York State and our students gaining foundational skills in literacy and numeracy and then our commitment to College and Career Readiness strong AP participation and performance robust dual enrollment programs offering college credit opportunities in multiple disciplines now we want to be sure that our literacy has strong alignment some of our areas of our Focus us with the latest evidence-based practices and remain in The Cutting Edge of instructional practices so we will be enlisting support from an outside literacy expert to review our comprehensive approach to literacy and the expert will provide feedback and recommendations to help us refine our programs and ensure they align with the latest research
005and best practices and um I believe we had talked about that uh earlier in the year and then in in terms of our addressing achievement gaps particularly for our students requiring additional supports that remains a priority for us and um as New York State transitions to the Next Generation standards which has started um those assessments we are working on on that with our uh as a focus area for us and so this evening we'll be sharing how we plan to build on our strengths and thoughtfully address areas that Merit further attention to ensure schools continue to excel and I do before I hand it over to Dr Bowman um she has done an exceptional job in putting this together this uh report for us together working closely with all the administrators so thank you for
006that and also this is your first report and so she has she has brought some additional insights for us as this is new for us so thank you Dr Bowman I'm going to hand it off to you thank you Dr Sinha and thank you to the board of education for this opportunity um I also before I get started have to thank all of the administrators who have really worked as a team to help make sure that we were prepared for tonight um and also for the work that you do every day in the service of our children um as this is my first student achievement report um it has provided me with the opportunity to immerse myself in Garden City academics from a K12 perspective um and so what did I find I found that
007student the student achievements that we celebrate and there are many are the work of an entire team administrators teachers families and of course our students um Garden City High School graduates are by and large products of 13 years of care professional expertise and deep commitment to Excellence in Garden City there is no such thing as resting on your laurels as evidenced by The increased graduation rate this year from 99% to 99.8% graduation um and Garden City students are very well prepared for higher education in their careers um as evidenced by alumni reports every single year as in any organization there's always room for growth and as you'll see across the board we have analyzed the data identified areas of strength seeking how we can replicate that success and found areas where we're focusing our attention
008all in the service of children so all the work that we do here in Garden City is grounded in the mission and V vision and so our kids we are committed to supporting our students as they strive to achieve the optimal level of academic social and personal success and achieve their personal best before we get started on the um formal presentation I think it's important to take a few minutes to talk about how we measure student learning there are multiple ways that you measure student learning based based on what's going on in the classroom every day when we have classroom assessments those sometimes take the form of teachers assessing student learning in the moment and making instructional shifts responsibly um those are mainly informal informative assessments classroom assessments also include traditional classroom assessments such as
009tests quizzes essays projects um but those are not the kinds of things that we see on a student achievement report for the Board of Education what we focus on on these kinds of um presentations are the district selected standardized assessments which here in Garden City is the nwaa um through fifth grade we use the universal screener three times a year although in this presentation you'll see that we focus on Spring to spring so that we can um compare students over time and see how they've accomplished uh grown um in six through eight we do two times a year um the reason for that is that our sixth through eth graders at the end of the year are often times sitting for regen exams and other assessments and so we want to make sure that we
010have ample time for that as well um the third bucket that you look to see that you'll see here in the student achievement report are standardized tests and that really is the summit of data that does really bear our attention um it includes AP exams regent exams our state Assessments in ela Math and Science um as I said tonight we'll focus on these last two groups the district selected standardized assessment and our standard and also the other standardized assessments um before I give the microphone over to Mr Stein grer who will start with the high school um I just want to say that change is the only constant that's true right now in education when you're looking at assessments um we are recently finishing making shifts from paper-based test to computer-based test which comes with
011some shifts in how students approach test taking and those experiences we are also in the midst of shifting from the core learning standards to the Next Generation learning standards and the associated change in exams as well when appropriate in this presentation we have year-over-year data to share however where the magnitude of the changes renders that comparison impossible we've removed prior years because we don't want it to look as though we can measure apples and oranges uh last note there are 76 slides in tonight's presentation uh in instead of going through each slide um in the interest of getting us home before Christmas I'll be leaving each slide up for a few seconds um and our principes will speak to them as a whole of course the entire presentation will be hosted to our website as
012well so Mr Stein ker you are can can I ask one question on a comment you made uh taking tests on computers um recognize it's a challenge I know I think it's particularly challenging is there anything that we do or don't do or things we can improve on to help that transition particularly for ear early Learners sure so some of the things that we do already is that we are some of we already have platforms available to students that create opportunities for them to practice the different tools like highlighting like switching between screens like um using calculators even using a stylus to write constructed responses um all of that is practice on how to use a device but it is something that is um already embedded in instruction when it is when it is related
013to what's going on in the classroom um there are also simulations we have a simulation happening in January I forget exactly what week it is um but each year the state sends out a simulation and so the students are given an opportunity and the school is given an each of the schools is given an opportunity for a dry run so that you can you can tweak any issues that might be coming up from a technology perspective but also take a look at what the kids experiences are um and provide any supports that they might need that way thank you sure I'm sorry just to piggy back um how do our current assessments and uh tasks projects kind of align to that with the utilization of um the computer so those are very specific to this
014to the assignment that's given um surely attention is paid to make sure that the tools are available to the students and that they have access to making sure that they know how to use them but the focus of daily instruction is going to be what's what's the end game of this activity what's the end game of this um event the instructional event that's happening and if it seems if if the goal includes using technology in order to get there then that's what happens but um certainly there is explicit instruction on how to make sure you know how to use the tools that answer the question okay sorry yeah it's off to you I got it he's ready thank thank you everyone uh thanks for having us uh present tonight and just to start talking about
015technology and exams moving to that uh at the high school level uh we we have been seeing that slow progression of change over two exams being on computer so sats are moving in that direction this year they will be all digital AP exams are moving in that direction um we did it over Co and then it went back to paper and now it's slowly moving on to digital regent exams are not there yet it was supposed to be done I think by 2015 but it's a very slow progression to get there uh but it's happening at that level little by little and not all at once at least so again regions are still uh paper and pencil and Pen at this point all right so uh looking at our presentation and our first slide is
016our very end so this is our graduation rates so what you see here are are two years the last two years 2023 on the left 2024 on the right and our numbers like Dr Bowman said it was 99% in 2023 and we improved on the 99% to go to 99.8% which is very good the other um bars you see for for each are what do we have New York State and Nassau County all right so you can see that our our numbers are are higher and that's fortunately and we're blessed and I'm humbled that's the trend we're going to see uh throughout the high school numbers uh the more red you see on these graphs tonight the better and you're going to see a lot of red um and that's a good thing all right
017so AP exam participation so these are the highest level exams that we offer and these are National and and even Global exams and what we see are four different uh sets of bars there and these are all big picture uh and they're showing the last three years for comparison to ourselves and what we see from the left are a total amount of AP students and last year we had 628 which is pretty similar to what we've had and that's over half of all of our students that are taking AP exams in the second uh set of bars there it is the number of exams and we are over 1,500 exams close to 1,600 and that's been pretty steady it's a lot of exams were given uh the next the the lower is the AP students
018earning a three or above on the exams and that's 565 last year which is slightly better than it was the last couple of years it's a slight Improvement which is amazing that half of our school freshmen basically aren't even taking AP exams uh some are they get to choose to be in there but as a whole freshman are not taking it sophomores is only a small amount maybe a third that are in so we're seeing a large amount of our students in the upper classes uh that are scoring three and above and sometimes that means college credit uh for our students and then finally on the right is the percentage of total AP students earning a three or above and that's where we saw a large change this year large in in the sense that
019it's over like a bit of a percent it's a 4% jump from 85 to 89 almost 90% of all of our students uh as they graduate are earning a three or above on AP exams which is amazing and again we we compare ourselves with ourselves and not the region because it's it's nothing to compare again so it's it's true and again I'm humbled to say it but I'm I'm very proud of of the work that our that our students and staff do in preparation for this every year um so for the second year in a row the the second year that the College Board has offered this new Awards program uh they called the AP School honor role it started in 2023 and for the second year in a row we earned the Platinum which
020is the highest level uh score possible and so these are our numbers from last year to this year again red is this year and we improved in each of those areas uh these are the white lines you see on there are the minimum required to meet the status of platinum so we are well above the minimum requirement to meet that and again only eight schools on Long Island earned Platinum last year all right our scholar report these are individual honors for students I'm going to start all the way on the right uh because that that shows the total amount of AP Scholars this is the most we've ever had uh ever like 310 students were AP Scholars right that means they're taking multiple exams and scoring high on these multiple exams and as we uh
021shift to the left and go down that way these are the graphs the bars that add up to the total on the right so AP Scholars with distinction is the highest honor and that means students are taking eight or more exams and scoring four uh and above as an average average uh and then AP Scholars with honor and AP Scholars total so our AP Scholars with distinction which is the highest individual honor a student can earn we had 143 which is ridiculous a lot of schools are proud to have one AP scholar with distinction and we have 143 it's really hard to comprehend when we show these numbers year after year what a big deal it is uh to score this High uh so we're very proud of our students for those all right again
022red is good and we're going to we're going to see by subject area each of these following slides so we saw art and then we see English uh we have language and literature our numbers improve in almost every exam over the past three years uh then we see math uh then we see science uh Environmental Science Biology there's another science slide there uh chemistry was at 100% for the second year in a row uh physics is always very high and these are high performing top students that we have in the school world history US History um these are you know over half of the grades taking these AP exams and these courses macroeconomics we see the numbers improving year over-year uh US government and politics we see big improvements year-over-year we also see increase in
023uh the number of students that are taking the these exams so those are all senior classes there um another social studies slide European history psychology Human Geography these exams are interesting because they're not your typical top students they're not Elite students that are taking these courses these are elective courses they're open to anyone to take and I mentioned earlier there's not many freshmen that take AP exams human geography is one of those exams that that freshmen are taking AP psychology is is Juniors and some seniors in there these are not your typical AP students these are not the students that are um you know at the the top with their average of the class but their scores on the AP Psychology exam over 150 of these students are scoring at the you know the highly
024proficient levels with fours and fives in computer science we have two computer science courses uh our numbers of students in these courses are low we're trying to build them back up and trying to uh rebuild what we have there principles is the newer course that's like the friendlier type of course um the AP Computer Science a is computer programming and that has fewer students in it overall the analysis of our advanced placement exams there's a number called the quality index we're not presenting that number because it's very difficult to even understand what it means and not a lot of schools look at their quality index to explain it but basically it tells us that we have very high participation rates like I said it's not just Elite students it's over half of our students taking
025AP exams which is one piece of the index and then the other piece is our excellent achievement so we're scoring high so we have students that are not your typical AP students scoring very high on exams which gives us a high quality index and we see our Quality Index Rising each year even as more and more students are participating and this year I'll tell you our 2025 numbers we're going to have even more students and more exams than we had this year and the year before and the year before and our overall population of the school is lower than it has been over the past 10 years so we're moving in a direction where it's normal to take AP exams in our school and it's normal to achieve at the highest level now our Quality
026Index the third point there overall is double the schools in our area and in some of our courses our biggest courses that we have statistics macroeconomics AP Literature senior course apbc calculist a senior course and psychology so we have 100 150 students taking these and scoring very high and our quality indexes triple what the typical schools in our area are again that's not a score that is ever publicized but I'm saying it tonight because it's a big deal to us all right our dual enrollment courses these are courses that students can take and earn college credit in our high school at the same time they're taking High School courses so they sit in class here and our teachers are able to act as professors for these colleges so we work with ad IFI we work
027with Rochester Institute of Technology and we work with St John's University St John is the world language courses our business courses are through adelfi and our project lead the way are through RIT so we have AP and college level they all weighted very high and over 700 student 750 uh enrollment uh are taken by students not 750 individual students some students take more than one college level course but that means there's that many opportunities for students to earn college credit this goes on the transcript as college credit and it's very beneficial for many of our students the Regents exams so we're going to start by saying the exams are constantly changing they've always been changing since the 80s I know the the exams have changed every few years right sequential math right a and then
028one two and now it's algebra and geometry and Algebra 2 uh it's the same thing in every area uh with the Sciences they'll be changing over the next few years the maths are in the the process of changing Ela just changed and that'll be changing again in a few years so as we constantly see these changes our teachers are adjusting their curriculum they're adjusting their syllabus which is a challenge in that sense it's not like people are are like just figuring out how to teach to these tests every year they're constantly learning constantly evolving uh and training our students and as we're going to see as we go through the next set of of graphs we're doing well that's because I believe we compare ourselves to ourselves again yeah so this is all us it's
029uh years 2022 23 and 24 and all the different subject areas it was English right at 100% it was it's the maths geometry Algebra 2 the dark red that you're seeing is the Mastery level that's 85% or higher of how many students are scoring that so you can see consistently as we go through all of these our students are scoring at the Mastery level what most schools are scoring at the passing level so we're in the 80s and 90s of Mastery and and that's a passing rate for a typical high school uh in our languages it's the flax exams not the regions exams and we see similar uh scores there 100% the last two years in German Italian 100% the last three years 100% in Spanish in in in the past few years so we're
030seeing very high results in every area and those regions exams are 9th 10th 11th graders so typically your AP students that are taking multiple exams or your upper classmen and the regions exams of the lower class so we're seeing every grade level at the high school students are scoring very high and overall overall analysis of the region exams again across the board we're at or close to 100% passing so it's difficult to show growth year in and year out it's tough to show that Improvement but like we started with our graduation rate at 99% how do you improve just a little bit so we do that with the region exams as well how do you improve um very targeted uh with Precision you do that you look at the data we look at the exams
031um and the results very specifically and Target what are the areas and what are the skills skills that our teachers need to work with our students on to do better the next year again our Mastery rates are high and that's where we can show a greater Improvement and we continue to do that every year uh another statistic that is not publicized much but it's the overall average of all exams from all of our students on the regions and we have the highest average on Long Island at 88.4% this year and that's not a one-off that's every year since since 2016 there's no school district that's had higher region results than us that's true proud of that and again overall analysis so the ELA the English Regents exam which is taken in 11th grade is the
032final overall indicator that every student is required to take before they graduate after that exam uh there are choices students don't have to take region exams they don't have to take uh AP exams that were all by choice at that point but this is the final requirement and we're at 100% year in and year out that is a culmination that success of our students is not just about the high school staff that is about every teacher and every administrator in our district at every grade level starting in the primary schools the elementary the middle school it's the building blocks of everything we do in every subject area and that's why we use and have used the ELA regions right for our APR score for everyone in the district because it's a culmination to show the
033success of everybody um and we're proud to to do that and we're proud to show that every single year every student specialed special needs top students they're all scoring and passing on the Region's exam and we know that as students leave Garden City High School and go on to the college level they're prepared there not to not just because of the dual enrollment classes and the AP courses but with literacy and the reading and writing that they come out of Garden City High School and they tell us every year they come back that we are so much better off than students that are in their courses in their other colleges and they don't know how to write and they the other students don't and our students do and they tell us that and they're and
034they're proud to present it and we're proud to report that thank you thank you Kevin um all right before we move to the high to the middle school I'm sorry Mr samuelson's going to be reporting on regions exams in nwaa and uh State assessments but for the algebra 1 and Earth Science regions I just want to point out um since the majority of our students do sit for those region exams Mr Samuelson is reporting on those too however there are students at the high school who take the algebra 1 and Earth Science regions and their data is combined um in one data set um again we've organized the slides by discipline after the Regents so you'll see the literacy slides with the ELA State assessment scores followed by the nwea for each grade and then
035you'll see the the same process go through with math on the nwea slides you'll see reference to a RIT score and just so that everyone here has an understanding of what the RIT score is um it is where each student is ready for instruction today so that's where the RIT comes from um it's a measure of student growth and achievement it's nationally normed the most recent Norm was done in 2020 um and just to understand a little bit about the percentages the if a student is on grade level they are averaging getting about 50% of the questions that they're presented with correct um and that would be highlighted under the average so there you'll see that there are low low average average high average High um three the the three top ones are the ones
036where uh you see that the kids are on grade level um as Dr Sin has said earlier we plan to work with a consultant to conduct a k6 literacy curriculum review um we are also taking intermediary steps to ensure that students learning experiences allow them the opportunities to reach their potential um finally what you're going to see is that our for each administration of the New York State Ela and assessment uh you'll see Garden City data and region data listed just to Define what region is that is Nassau County and that's not to suggest that our goal is to um reach the same levels as Nassau County but rather to kind of give some context on Trends over time um you'll see the trends that are in the region parallel some of the trends here
037some do not but it does add context to the um each of the slides uh Mr Samuelson if you I'm sorry just one quick question for uh Mr St grer um just out of curiosity you seem to obviously know the data very well what's your biggest surprise and biggest concern good question uh biggest concern is maintaining um it's difficult to stay uh at this high level um and we can't let off the gas that's a challenge it's not easy to do that um and like I said with with changing exams and changing curriculums year after year um you're not starting from scratch but you have to be up to date and there's a lot of training that gets in it uh the biggest surprise is that um positively we saw General Improvement across the board
038in every subject area uh the the master Mastery level improve approved which I didn't expect that I thought maybe that would stay flat along with the the high passing rates in general uh so it was a it was a surprise to me that we continue to slowly increase it can't sustain itself I said that last year too I said just be prepared we cannot sustain that level and then we still did it a little bit so I was surprised that we were so next year again you know if we you know usually it's up and down a little bit this this wasn't this this was a surprise that it it didn't drop at all um I'll tell you this year we'll we'll look at um our classes with um you know cotor classes are large
039we we see a lot with the nth grade group and I think we're going to see an a steady amount that way so we're going to look at supporting those students at the higher levels it's you know business as usual I think with the the younger students coming up we might need more support there uh thank you Mr CH grer and thank you to the board of education and District leadership for having us this evening I know that speak for all of my colleagues and I sure we're very proud to uh provide the community with uh these insights into our students outstanding achievements and to share some information about how we look to move forward uh evenings like this I always put an important focus on not only where we've been successful but also where
040our next steps are uh so that said I'd highlight that the broad goals of the Middle School include providing access to a wide spectrum of activities that give them a taste of a lot of different curricula uh our students are learning how to be Learners and we're learning about ourselves how we can self- Advocate self- Monitor and attend to our goals uh so uh before we get into the numbers I'll open with a great deal of pride in our school's results this year certainly there's always room for improvement and we're taking a very close look at our outcomes in all of our areas but we're also deeply proud of our students achievements and even though this year's success comes through that careful planning and thoughtful analysis of student cohort performance data and self-reflection we know
041the work never f stops and that the reflection needs to continue and we can need to continue to make adjustments to make sure our students have the best experience that they can have um and I'll just say briefly because I'm supposed to be brief uh brevity is with uh Mr hardan uh in all we know that our successes couldn't take place without the expertise of our teachers and coordinators and the incredible diligence of our students and families without this the leadership of this team um and with uh the coordinators and our partners in PPS who do an incredible job of supporting us our students uh by providing us great insights into the curriculum and and and a strong uh ability to analyze data uh so I'll begin by talking about uh our flax and Regents
042exams the first slide you'll see are the results of our re our flax exams uh we continue to be very very proud of the results of our flax a this year nearly all of our students scored 85 or above in all three of our world language courses uh and as we look to continue our work in World Language and push our students to achieve proficiency through Act full techniques and philosophies and a drive to create learning environments they're engaging interpersonal rigorous safe we see that our students AR rise ring to the challenge uh our language courses are taught nearly entirely in target language and our students have demonstrated both an interest and ability in using that same language to communicate their ideas and understandings and also a deep interest in the culture of the communities
043that speak those languages uh the flax exam is the local regions that assesses the two years of world language students undertake at the middle level uh we know that students are required to earn at least one credit of roal language and to pass these exams by scoring higher than 65 in order to graduate from high school in a few years and so this is a critically important moment for our learners for many of our middle school learners this is the only exam that travels with them um and the obvious distinction between this one and the uh algebra and Earth Science regions that we'll talk about in a moment is that the flax exams are taken by nearly all students uh except for those who are otherwise removed uh by other needs uh and an important
044observation about these exams is that they not only push our students to show what they know but flax exam is truly a performance assessment it shows the degree to which students can use the language to speak and to understand um the target language which is deeply challenging uh particularly at this at this level but as you can see in our data our students continue to be very very successful um and then moving on to algebra and Earth Science um just pointing out that algebra and Earth Science are typically High School classes that students at the middle level take when they demonstrate the ability and interest to accelerate uh in 23 24 we had over 50% of our students taking algebra and Earth Science and again these are high school level classes and our students performed
045extraordinarily well uh and by the way this year those numbers have climbed and we're closer to 2ir in algebra and earth science uh 139 students took algebra last year and 137 took her ass science uh and our students did very very well with 94% and 96% achieving Mastery on these two assessments respectively and that just means 85 are better than has nothing to do with passing all of our students were successful of course we're very proud of these results we view them in the proper context the grades that students earn in these courses on these exams we card of their High School transcript and we want them to understand and appreciate the gravity of that we also want them to enjoy their middle school years so we know that the students are diligent in making
046balanced choices um so they can be successful in the long term uh and then on these next two slides we'll provide updates on two very different brands of Assessments uh the 3 through eight Ela and math assessments are intended to give students and teachers information regarding student level of preparedness for the upcoming year of learning High School curriculum graduation criteria it's also important to note that parents are permitted to opt their students out of one or both of these assessments and so our data only reflects those who choose to participate this year uh last year pardon we moved to full participation in the CBT the computer-based uh teaching testing model uh for the 3 through eight exams uh the previous year we had piloted the model in only one grade H and we know that
047the shift created challenges for our students that related more to the technology than it did the content uh but due to the diligence and planning of our coordinators and teachers uh and to speak to your question before Mr cilio uh we had plenty of opportunities to practice the the module to become accustomed to the tools um and we found that the students were very successful there this year was also the first year that we took the new science New York State Science assessment for eighth grade students uh the makeup of that exam both in style and content is brand new for all New York State students and the feedback from our Learners was that it was very difficult and in fact if you speak to leaders across New York State they'll share the same that
048this new assessment was much more challenging than we've seen in the past uh our own review of the assessment showed the test required a much deeper understanding of both the concepts and the reading and data skills data interpretation skills that we've seen in the past so in the next slide uh we have our science data um and you'll see in the results the the new assessment that our schools our scores significantly outperform the region uh there's certainly room for improvement but it's important to note that we don't really have anything to compare this to because it's a new assessment and all of our um all of our results are really compared to themselves but as you know we did much better than the region in the next slide you'll look at um our literacy or
049Ela 3 through eight assessments and you're also Al going to see the nwaa assessment results and it's important to note that there's very big difference between a 3 through eight assessment and the nwaa assessment so again the 3 through eight assessments are New York State achievement tests they focus on how high the student can reach whereas the NWA is a nationally normed assessment that measures student growth it's a significant difference and the NWA test is reactive to student performance too and that students climb as they successfully answer questions until they hit their upper maximum uh we also know that students approach the nwaa as a no Stakes assessment which is something to consider in the middle level an important consideration truly so I'll show some closer thinking and some data analysis in a few moments
050but first just the broader data as you can see here uh 70% of our sixth grade students 71% of our seventh grade students and 78% of our eighth graders achieved a three or four on this year's Ela exam in all cases showing a positive comparison to results in our region you'll also see Improvement in our NWA in our nwaa results in sixth and seventh grade and a consistent level of performance our eighth grade of course we also need to maintain a focus on where we need to show our efforts and our pointed our pointed approach to standards and uh as we've done every year we've identified the following areas as priority focal points and for us uh it is standards 2 three and four of the New York State Ela standards uh key information and
051and authors craft uh and and that's where our work is with our Learners that's where our teachers are focusing their energy so that we can uh see improved results with respect to uh mathematics you can see that 88% of our sixth graders achieved a three or four in the exam and astounding 94% of our seventh graders scored in that range and 86% of our eighth graders scored in that area and I'll highlight that with respect to the eighth graders um only students who do not take algebra take the the 8th grade algebra ex um math exam so uh that result removes the students who are predisposed to mathematical success who also did very well in the regions uh and you'll also note that our math NWA scores show similar growth that we saw in ela
052as we did in ela we again dedicate ourselves to identifying priority standards and areas of Need for growth based on our student performance this year we'll continue to highlight areas of priority interest and F our energies there to ensure the same level of Excellence uh we also know that uh students who be coming to us in the elementary school having experienced more of innovative math and that we are using a lot of our time with our Math teachers to help make sure there are no gaps um this year uh areas for targeted growth would be algebraic reasoning proportions uh geometry and constructed response so in general as we do every year we think about our cohort results and we're we're we're proud to share the high performing results of our classified cohort with more than
05360% showing Proficiency in mathematics uh our proficiency rate in ela is lower but as we indicated last year it's important to keep in mind that for our classified students the vast majority of them have identified needs in reading and in speech and language areas that would manifest themselves more frequently on a read on a on a reading exam than they would on a on a math assessment uh and then again these are just summaries of the uh 6 through eight uh assessments and you'll see uh growth in math you'll see some uh some slight decline in ela um and a pretty standard uh consistency in uh eighth grade mathematics again um as I was indicating before the important factor of our work going forward is reviewing where our students are successful maintaining that strength and
054attacking those areas where we identify opportunities for growth so in ela those areas are standards two three and four and of course writing we see a lot of writing across the curriculum in fact the partnership between our ELA teachers and social teachers with using common language and common strategies for developing thoughtful evidence-based responses is very very strong continues to grow and a mathematics this year focusing on those content areas uh algebraic reasoning proportions geometry and applications of percents and linear functions and of course constructive responses which in many ways use the same strategies that we want to see in English it's positing a position and defending it with evidence and logic uh and again making sure that all of our students at all levels are comfortable and ready to be successful using the computer-based testing
055format thank you Mr Samuelson thank you questions um how can we integrate um again actually I'm sorry how can we involve more children uh do you believe into the Region's curriculum for 8th grade well as I shared earlier we have um seing an increase this year so we have we're up to two-thirds of our students who are taking the Region's level classes um which is certainly the highest it's been since I've been here um and I think we want to be thoughtful about making sure that we're putting students in position to be successful um and making sure that we are giving students a chance also to take responsible risks and push themselves so our our motive our Mo our methodology has been that we have a a benchmark success rate that we want to see
056in sixth grade before we Grant students access to it but we also allow for a meaningful conversation with families when they feel like uh that grade doesn't necessarily reflect their students level and we've been able to be uh flexible and thoughtful making sure we put our students where they want to be to achieve their goals so again two-thirds a pretty high number uh and I think we want to make sure that we're putting students in there who are safe and comfortable and ready to be successful but also not putting unnecessary barriers before them taking responsible risks uh you mentioned concerns with uh standard 2 three and four um just looking at the standards right now how is it that we're utilizing uh the other contents specifically um science and social studies probably well not probably
057the best areas to gain uh access to non-fiction how are we utilizing science and social studies to uh Shore up Ela that was a great question so I mean this is one of the benefits of working in a in a team system our teachers collaborate all the time and in fact uh both in the sixth and seventh grade we see a high frequency of interdisciplinary work just last week I watched as our seventh graders performed and demonstrated their understanding of the Salem Rich trials which is history content but they were using it to uh socialize content which they were using to um in English class to demonstrate their understanding of the non-fiction text they're reading and to be creative in how they demonstrated that understanding they made projects as well as doing some some writing
058uh and certainly in eighth grade we see that as well with the with the Holocaust unit where they do the the cage uh aligning with the w World War II curriculum and as as I said before with respect to the math we certainly see our students looking to be scientific writers and develop thoughtful theories based on evidence and communicating those things in a way that the average reader can understand um I apologize if this is uh I guess out of your purview but I'm just looking at that I have some concern with the nwaa uh V versus the uh Ela state exam um I'm just curious how we compensate for that because if you're looking at the results from 2022 to 2024 there's actually a 26p point swing between at if in 2022 where 13
059points higher um just so you could know my rationale I took the high high average and average and I basically said that that was a three and a four so I compared that versus the threes and fours that we received in ela so just some fast math you're looking at 89 to 76 so that's 13 points higher in on the ELA state exam and then when we move into 2024 it's actually we're at um 70% threes and fours um on the state exam and we're at 83% on nwaa so I'm just curious how we deal with those inconsistencies it's a good question and I I guess I want to think about that a little bit but one of the things that the New York state exam assesses that the NWA doesn't is constructive response and
060that's an area where weaknesses can show up uh and then the other thing I think is that as students get older non no Stakes assessments tend to become more challenging to use as as benchmarks the the nwaa uh assessment doesn't hold weight for our students and while we try to push them to do their best and motivate them to put their best foot forward we also understand that in the scope of the great number of academic challenges they have uh they may not approach that with the same level of uh care do other things I'm sorry enthusiasm enthusiasm so nwaa does not have writing I'm sorry the NWA assessment is not assess writing if I could just add the nwaa is adaptive meaning that it's individualized by student based on prior answers so if you
061get one answer correct then it's going to level up the difficulty so sitting next to me might be it's not going to be the same exam that person next to me is going to be deing with so that may have an impact as well everybody gets the same assessment I mean of course there are um field tested questions that might not be the same on everyone but the vast majority of the assessments for New York state they're the same thank you certainly thank you I just had one more quick question the slide um that references the proficiency rate for um students with disabilities um in the area of ela that 30% proficiency do you have any um suggestions for any um additional supports that need to be in place so that we can do a
062better job closing that achievement gap for our students with disabilities especially in that area of ela I appreciate that question I I don't know that we need more support I think that we need to continue to improve our practice and to look carefully at our students a small population so we're talking about individuals here and about making sure that we understand their needs very carefully and that we're able to provide them bespoke experiences that speak to those needs I think that's where the growth is for us for our special education work I don't know that's a question of supports but I appreciate that question okay uh thank you Mr Samuelson uh as we move to the elementary portion of tonight's uh presentation I just want to point out and add context to a few things
063uh regarding what you're going to see the gains that were reported last year in math have been maintained um I point that out because we've had a high level focus on in the elementary buildings to implement illustrative math as a primary resource over the last few years um that involved a substantial amount of professional development and planning and while that was happening at the elementary schools there was a focus on um the foundations of literacy in our primary buildings where we have our K1 students and as the student achievement report really speaks to the achievement of our students in grades three through eight what you won't see on the screen is uh the growth of our students in the primary buildings in K in one that will come to pass once those little kiddos get
064into the third grade and get uh the opportunity to sit for the New York State assessments um but for now those that Focus that area of focus has really been um up until now in the primary buildings and so Mrs hand and Mr hardigan are you ready yes thank you to the board of education and thank you to my fellow colleagues who helped put this presentation together and uh again Mr Samson thank you for just some additional information about the NWA as it relates to New York State assessment we see some of the similar trends at the elementary level with both of those the first assessment uh that you'll see pictured here is our grade five science exam as Mr Samson explained this was a very lengthy test and talking with several of our students
065uh we had a 100 uh over a 100 students still testing after 200 minutes uh this is the first time this assessment was administered and you know it came out um as 62% proficient across both both buildings in grade five compared to the region at 48% we attribute this to strong curriculum articulation the assistance of Joanna rogosich who has helped us out with some staff development in these areas and also our fifth grade team who has just consistently prepared our students for this exam we do hope that the you know of course the state will make some changes and some adjustments to this assessment in talking to our elementary colleagues uh you know there were students that demonstrated some you know emotional distress because of this exam but we overall uh of course higher than
066the region as Dr Bowman explained before that is not the barometer but it is nice to know that uh you know we were uh significantly higher than the region in our science exam which was also a reading exam I think and I'm sorry to interrupt you one of the things that's important is I said earlier when there isn't another assessment to compare to there will only be one assessment up um and while that's not only true for for fifth grade science it's true for fifth grade science because there wasn't a fifth grade state test in science prior to last year's Administration and once the administration took place there was outcry across the state regarding the experiences of students being tested over the course of a number of hours it was it was there was a
067similar experience in eth grade but predominantly in fifth grade because the kids hadn't really had an experience like that before and as Chris said it was a very reading heavy assessment with um the balance of content not being as much as we had expected across the state so it at times it asked students to compare um and contrast two very dense uh you know pieces of science uh literature and then respond based on creating models over the computer so it was a very intense uh type of test for our kids and I just want to reiterate that again over 150 students still testing after 200 minutes at 10 years old is um you know it that's tough that's tough for our kids so I do have to give a you know a shout out to
068their fifth grade teachers for preparing that and again to Mrs rogosich for just helping us out with that staff development in the area of science as we move across you'll see the same graph we'll pause here for a minute and then we'll go through the numbers um and I want to make sure we get to the summary slide as well but the what you'll see here is the numbers across is the proficiency levels up at the top so New York state grade 3 Ela the top bar there is 85% proficient from 2022 then we in 2024 67% proficient um of course we that was an area of focus for us and we're going to discuss plans to make sure that we are addressing the needs of those students the NWA grade three we we what
069we spoke about you're already on there thank you Dr Bowman um so we again when this the NWA is the most Norm reference assessment that we have available in the country it's sampled over a million times so relatively speaking from a general perspective you do see the bands that are pretty evenly distributed with this um as Mr Jano asked a great question just about some inconsistencies between nwaa and the state assessment if we use all three red areas as like a you know a 3 four we're stilling we're seeing some of those inconsistencies and we've got a plan to address some of those which we'll talk about towards the end of our our segment the grade four assessment you're looking at uh Ela up at the top I'll draw your attention to the 77% proficiency
070levels in 2022 and again uh you know in the 2024 68th percentile and also analysis of the grade 4 NWA here as well um just to draw your attention to the grade 4 nwaa National Norm which is just under the title there the national Norm RIT is the 204 and we have been at the 212 210 and 209 numbers uh keep in mind two RIT points is uh minimal difference as a standard deviation is usually around um 15 so you know we looking at minimal change in the NWA across several years it's been a consistent barometer for us and it is always helpful because while we indicate the na the Garden City RIT there it's when we use this for Diagnostic purposes we're comparing um students to themselves in this and this helps us develop
071a individual plan for these students and it helps again just make sure that our supports are calibrated through the mtss process hey Chris just a quick question I'm sure you've told me this before and I forget but are comparative districts using the NWA as well or is there another some are and some waren it is um I'd have to say though it is one of the two that are widely used across Long Island okay thank you here uh we've got grade 5 Ela we are at at the 2022 school year we were at the 58th percentile and we have been on a steady increase in grade five for proficiency levels starting at the 58 up to the 68th and then to the 73rd um this kind of calibrates and jives with the grade five Science
072assessment and the grade five math as well very proud of our all of our students and of course the consistent growth that our fifth grade students have demonstrated the model that we have used and the blueprint we have used for this fifth grade increase I'm going to get to in just a little bit um but we're hopeful that we will be able to use this model in some of the other areas in which we did not see the uh the anticipated growth that we had hoped for okay all righty and just quickly going through the math slides before we get to our summary page we start with the state assessment for the third grade in mathematics it's important to note that third grade this last year was the first year that they took the computer-based
073assessment the year prior both fourth and fifth grade did so fourth and fifth grade have taken computer based twice third grade last year was the first grade first year they took the state assessments on the computer um we have our 2022 score of a 86% uh proficiency and then in 2024 we have 87% proficiency there when we look at the NWA again as Chris said you'll see those even bars kind of going across for the nwaa there the national Norm is at a 2011 and our um most recent Garden City average rate was a 208 when we look at fourth grade in two in 2022 our proficiency rate was 83% and in 2024 our proficiency rate is 90% NWA math again you'll see those consistent bars going across the national average for the RIT is
074a 2 210 and in Garden City in 2024 our national our average RIT was a 217 and fifth grade math assessment data in 2022 we are at 59% proficiency and in 2024 we are at 82% proficiency so as Chris explained we've seen nice steady growth growth across the board for fifth grade and we plan to model some of our other grade level experiences in the same way that we've been working with our fifth grade teams is there just when looking at the NWA for math is there similar maybe gaps in that um program versus kind of ela and some of the things that Mr samelson mentioned so I think anytime we're using the NWA all of the things that Mr samelson said are very true our students you know when they sit for the stateus
075assessment it's a little bit of a different feeling for them they go in with this sense of I need to you know do everything I can to make sure that I'm put meeting expectations on this so NWA sometimes you get inconsistencies in that place it's important that's why we use multiple measures whenever we're looking at student data so NWA is going to be one piece of it whether we're talking about Ela or math and then there's a lot of different other assessments that we'll use to try to triangulate and make sense of that data a little bit make sure that that data is telling us a true picture when we look at NWA data very often we'll also look at the time it took us student to take the assessment because it gives us that
076down to the minute how long it took it um we'll also look at rapid guessing because it will tell us the percentage of Rapid guessing that a student maybe just click click clicked through a couple of questions because that can be very telling for us and when we if we see indicators in the timing or the rapid guessing that kind of make us wonder about the assessment data then there's some follow-up assessments that maybe we would do or we would look at different um classroom assessments to kind of confirm what we're seeing so maybe in short you think the NBAA is probably a little bit better in some ways than on the math than it is in in ela on the math it's definitely more comprehensive because on in the ELA we're missing that whole
077writing component thank you okay so again we have our slide here similar to the middle school for our proficiency rates for special education and again it's going to be the same story as Mr Samuelson said we do recognize that we have 31% of our students who are classified who are receiving a level one those 30 31% of students have identified reading needs on their IEP that are being addressed through resource room for reading or resource room programs or even the ICT or the 12 1212 programs okay all right so while we get the analysis I think it's important to take a look at the summary slide for all of the assessments across the board from grades three four and five both in ela and math those are on display for you here while we've gone
078through this it's important that we just highlight some of the strengths because if we we've recognized that if you you know if you work hard at the things that they already do well at it'll have a ripple effect on some other areas so when we reviewed the New York State Ela assessment with Mrs calman and our teachers a common strength across all grades was in standard 8 standard 8 focuses heavily on evaluating evidence um it's a Nuance standard because it asks these students to um have a to develop their own strong understanding of why authors are using reasoning not to create their own reasoning but why the author is doing and saying these particular things across all grade levels our teachers have shared with us through their individual teacher reports that they our students students
079are becoming really critical thinkers the uh the standards within each grade that are some strengths and I'll go through these in standard three there were strengths in determining the meaning of words phrases and figurative language which was standard four uh 83% of our students received full credit for questions that act students related to this question in grade four there were in grade four there were strengths in describing character settings events and drawing specific details standard three that was 70% of our students received full credit for questions that asked uh that asked students related to this standard keep in mind that is of the released questions that is not all of them and in grade five there were strengths uh pretty much everywhere um but in in determining the theme and how is how is it
080is how excuse me how it is supported by key details about 85% of our students received full credit for questions that ask students questions related to this standard we did this analysis through Mrs calman and our teacher teams to professional development the grade five from a general perspective we've demonstrated an increase overall proficiency from 2022 to 2024 we started at the 58th percentile and we went to the 73rd per proficiency while there is always still more room to grow in those areas we attribute the consistent growth with the following four actions a significant increase in student expectations we have gone through an analysis of extracurricular events and made some really strategic changes without compromising what we value um and making sure we're increasing the instructional time we focus test preparation by incorporating practice assessments embedded
081into the units we've also done an analysis of Exemplar student work samples through professional development sessions and of course our fifth graders have the increased exposure to online testing because they have been doing it from you know for a few years at this point and also have manipulating the NWA for quite some time even as our fifth graders and our youngest Learners are doing that so those are some of the strengths of the ELA we're going to go into the strengths of the math and then and then come back to some areas that we want to grow in and the plan for those okay when we reviewed the New York state math assessment data with our teachers a common strength in measurement and data was identified in all grade levels grade three in particular with
082time grade four in angles both measuring and drawing and grade grade four angles and grade five was in volume in all of those areas students scored within 90% or above on those questions other straints were identified on each grade level in grade three there were straints in multiplication and division word problems as well as identifying addition and multiplication patterns grade four strengths included decomposing angle measurements and solving equations to find the missing parts as well as multiplication grade five students showed a strength in using multiple strategy IES such as place value drawing models math properties and the relationship between different operations to add subtract multiply and divide decimals all of the strengths that we have identified in mathematics can be attributed to strong professional development and data analysis that our teachers participated in last school
083year Mrs Cardella and her team of math coaches LED ped that was grounded in student data each session had teachers reviewing data on linkit and using that data to identify student strengths and areas for additional instruction teachers worked with coaches to identify strategies and create resources that would support the most challenging topics within each unit fluency and classroom assessments were consistently analyzed during grade level collaboration time to make plans for small group instruction work this and I'm sorry the the standards that you're mentioning which were very strong is that something that you've SE um in math is that something that you've seen over the years or is this something new or so some are consistent some are new measurement in data has not always been a consistent across the board strength measurement in data sometimes
084shows one of our opportunities for growth in there um because of some of the really challenging areas that can be found in there with area and perimeter um volume was actually one area that was a big opportunity for growth for us in fifth grade and we identified that and kind of made shifts in the scope and sequence to be be able to address it sooner and then be able to reinforce it throughout the school year um which really was helpful for our students thank okay so now on to opportunities for growth when we analyze assessment data with our teachers we always look to identify opportunities for growth Chris and I are going to share some of these areas with you now both Ela and math and then we'll go deeper into the plans that we're
085going to use to support this work so when we looked at our Ela data we have determined that an opportunity for growth for all grade levels continues to be in the area of constructed and extended responses response to reading is a very specific genre of writing that needs to be explicitly taught to our students our goal this year will be providing students with skills and strategies that can be utilized to ensure that they are answering questions complet complely using claims and appropriate evidence in grades four and five we will focus our efforts on how to expand our work with the clear strategy that's really how we get students to focus on writing a claim having evidence another piece of evidence and reasoning into their extended writing responses in addition we will focus on the core
086standards as Matthew shared before standards two three and four because data currently shows inconsistent performance in these areas a deeper understanding of these standards will which include finding central idea theme summarizing character analysis and interpreting words and phrases in texts will enable our students to think critically about texts both literary and informational that they are presented with maybe just on on the ELA uh areas for improvement is this coming off of classroom data is it coming off of State exams a combination of both so this is primarily from our state assessment data but that being said anytime we see something in the state assessment data we look at our classroom assessment data to see if we're finding consistencies or inconsistencies and where we can kind of fill in those pieces so we never just use
087one piece of data is the state asking enough questions on a specific State no and it's different every year so one it's hard to even compare how we do on standard two from one year to the next year because one year there may be three questions and the next year there's eight questions so it's it's challenging do you I'm sorry go ahead no you first um do you rather than I mean specifically with Ela um I know that the standards are a little gray at times um do we break down the standards to really look at what skills are being asked like main idea drawing conclusions academic language like that absolutely we never just stop at the standard level because there's so much to unpack in one standard especially as the grade levels increase once
088you get to fifth grade those standards can contain a lot in one so we really break apart question stems and what's involved in each individual question to really see where the breakdown in the specific standard it lies and and maybe just one last question what's the I guess from a percentage basis how much is constructive is constructive and extended responses on these State exams is it a big portion a small portion how do you how do you guys think about that so it's definitely a smaller portion than the multiple choice there's about four or five questions on the entire assessment that are constructed responses and in fourth and fifth grade one extended response question thank you can we share this this slide basically this this is where the is yeah the parents overall I mean
089obviously things come home we want resp sometimes aent sometimes we don't we get the homework and it's like okay CLE we send these gr I know individually probably so the parents can see yeah we we definitely try to we have parent uh we have teachers write about these ideas in their weekly newsletters that go out we share um like clear last year we did PTA presentations about it and we sent our parents home with clear kind of resources and anchor charts that they could keep at home to help their kiddos we also use the family math and literacy nights to be able to share a lot of this information with parents as well but a lot of it directly comes from the classroom teachers specifically in their newsletters and then before I go into the
090opportunities for growth but Mr adanu um after the student achievement report is finished we try to direct our PTA to direct parents to this as well and we put it out in our our monthly we're going to be doing that uh in our next monthly to to reference this because there's like you said there's some important data points on this and there's some good planning here so we want to make sure it reaches everybody the um the opportunities for growth for math so just to kind of calibrate a second before we get into that what you're still what you're still looking at is the New York state from a slides perspective a New York state grade three through five assessment analysis we've touched on these we're going to get to to more of that in
091just a moment um after we talk about the opportunities for growth for math with the opportunities for growth in math you saw the you know High 80th the mid 80th to high 80th percentile proficient uh excuse me percent proficient so these areas for opportunities for growth for math are are very granular um so keep that in mind this is we came under the um the analysis of the same passion with Mrs Cardella and our teacher teams through staff developments and in grade three we want to continue our work in comparing fractions I think that as always regardless of where this the proficiency levels point in comparing fractions for third grade it's such a critical comp um part of the uh you know the instruction in third so we want to make sure we always spend
092you know a fair amount of time and making sure our students have a good understanding of comparing fractions this way they when they get to to Matt and to Kevin you know they know how to do all um you know the math that they need to get the Platinum award um you know that starts with us just another just letting you know that again um it starts with actually our primaries across the way there but um in grade four and then actually really our parents I should start with but um so in in grade four um our goal is to strengthen finding whole number quotients and remainders with four-digit dividends so that's our our long division right in our division in grade four we'll always want to have a focus in on that even if
093our proficient levels are high on that we're we're not going to never lose sight because we recognize that that is a such a strong foundational and prerequisite skill for future success in there um parents if you're listening this is a plug for math facts and in grade five we're also drawing our attention to solving real world problems involving multiplication fractions and mixed numbers all right so now to take you through the plan for this so the first bullet that you hear is the close reading and response to reading plans so this slide in general indicates some takeaways from the data and some immediate next steps for us as Carrie shared with you earlier we recognize that we have demonstrated some inconsistencies within Ela standards 2 three and four sometimes for a grade there a strength
094and sometimes they're a need for a different grade these standards grouped together make up about 60% of the exam okay it has been cleared to us through the data that our students need a heavy focus on response to literature writing we did not get the writing results from the constructed response that we had hoped but we have a plan to address those um we have been in discussions with the board about our using our new data management system link it in ways in which we can level up our expectations for students and that means um you know assigning some some sample tests and sample test questions through that management system we've been able to take some of the data through link it and compare it with local Assessments in a very visual appealing fashion both
095um simple to digest for our teachers to make some actionable next steps so for ELA we plan to administer a practice assessment through linkit to compare it with those other data points teachers at this point have identified the key standards that they want to focus in on on their classes our Elementary Administration team along with Dr Bowman and Mrs calman have met to discuss the implementation of a Clos reading and response to reading instructional period periods this will include curation of complex texts similar to the state exam purposeful rereading text dependent questions annotation and finally what Carri talked about written response to reading at times it may also include some higher expectations for homework for our students Carrie previously explains that our work within the uh within the district and the the districtwide acronym for
096clear as response to literature we're going to talk we're going to continue to talk about that as we hone that skill for our for our students this blueprint that I just shared with you to increase these expectations for our students has been successful already in fifth and we look to continue to expand it in grades three and four recognizing that this work has to go hand inand no pun in tender there Mrs hand with preparing students to successfully nav Navigate computer-based testing so that plan um it it it doesn't it won't work unless we make sure that our kids are adequately prepared for computer-based testing so that was part one and then part two will be shared with Carrie on that okay I'm going to kind of share the next parts of the ELA plan
097all integrated together because they all support the opportunity that we have identified to strengthen our students writing responses to both constructed and extended response questions we'll continue to focus on the clear response strategy with our students when students engage in this strategy they reminded that they need a claim two pieces of evidence and reasoning in order to completely answer a question we have noticed significant Improvement in students written responses when they use the clear strategy on paper and pencil tasks on paper you often see evidence of students checking their work they may be highlighting in different colors or making their own check boxes to make sure they've done each part of clear students at this point are not using the strategy as consistently or completely as we'd like to see them use it when they're
098tasked with answering a question on the computer the act of typing can be laborious in and of itself for our students which at times has our students finding ways to condense their responses to limit the amount of typing that needs to be done this often leads to pieces of the answer being omitted and the students only receiving partial credit our classroom teachers and Technology teacher will be engaging in specific computer-based clear strategy practice with our students to enhance their responses for example when we practice the clear response on pen and paper we often color code our responses teachers will model this strategy on anchor charts in their classroom and students can be found using this strategy to check their work when they finish their writing this year we will ensure that teachers model responses on
099the computer using tools to highlight different parts and different colors to show a transfer of the strategy to the students students will be encouraged to mark up their responses in a similar way when practicing while this cannot be completely replicated on the day of the state assessment there's only one highlight color um it will reinforce the usage of the clear strategy when typing your responses in addition now that our teachers and students are familiar with the CBT platform Basics will Explore More of the tools that are accessible to students that can help them when they're constructing their responses for example they can be copying and pasting evidence from the text so they don't feel the need to shorten their answers when they're typing we'll continue to utilize the clear strategy across all content areas to
100provide additional practice in various genres okay when we move into math you'll see constructed responses comes up first so it kind of goes hand inand with what we were just saying we've also identified constructed responses in math as an opportunity for growth the work that we'll do in this area is consistent with clear strategy work we'll be engaging in but a large component of this work when it comes to math is how to transfer your mathematical thinking onto the computer utilizing link it practice questions is as well as the CBT platform we will provide our students with opportunities to show their work on the computer to ensure that they are transferring all of the important pieces solved on paper to the screen last year we really focused on becoming familiar with the platform itself for
101example how to use writing tools how to access the measurement tools that are provided to answer some of the questions this year we'll focus more on how to ensure the students are capturing the essential components of their thinking when showing their work and explaining their answers look I have a question just when looking at the data and I know we've talked about this in other meetings you know with the increase or I don't know the exact numbers of students with special needs and identification has been been an issue the community's brought up and we've spent a fair time talking about yeah you probably don't have an answer to this but how does this play into the numbers and the impact you know you want to look at apples and oranges when you look at numbers
102I know we talked about our special needs students and some of the proficiency numbers' be great to kind of see if there's a way to to maybe dive deeper into these numbers and segregate them a little bit more and talk about them you know in the future with the administration the board about if we're seeing any patterns there maybe we're not identifying people or maybe there's certain subset of students who are you know fall into those categories that need you know extra support and that's why we're seeing maybe underperformance in some of the numbers that we haven't seen in the past yeah that's definitely something that we continuously do we look at our data especially when the benchmarking times come up we look at each individual students data um I think it's also important to
103note that one of the main things that we're looking at with our students our classified students is how are we transferring the skills that they're working on in resource room for reading let's say into the general Edge classroom when they're working on some of this work because it is completely different at that point for them so how are we getting them to use the strategies when they're in the general education classroom and we do a lot of that now we have our resource room teachers um push into the classroom at times so that they can be supporting the student and reminding the student sometimes hey remember how we do this in our in my class but also then providing support for the classroom teacher and can give some kind of tools and resources right on
104the spot of hey when I'm doing this in my class this is what we use and kind of model how that looks like in their classroom because that transfer piece is where it becomes challenging maybe just one fall onto that I know we look at the numbers by year but obviously we don't look at the previous years and some of this some of this data is there are things we should think about uh at the primary level that maybe we can do to I don't know if it's identification it's different systems um and it's probably not for this conversation but I think that's something we should look into because we started grade three and we're looking at data but obviously there's a there's three years of build up to that I think uh I think
105Chris or Carrie were saying that at the primary level they have been focusing a lot on the writing especially last year this year and uh that came from our data so um and that's a goal in terms of you know what we see in third grade that we share that with our um primary colleagues I know that we're um comparing it's not even comparing apples to oranges it's like comparing apples to automobiles but over the span of 22 to 24 in third grade the dro 19 points in proficiency l so I I I think that really looking U um I'm sorry in ela so really looking to the primaries to see what they could do to kind of help us Shore that up I think is a pretty strong approach um a side question about
106math they're still against scrap paper in the CB uh CBT right they can use scrap paper but the scrap paper is never going to be looked at and so like we said we wish that the students could take a picture with their Chromebook of their scrap paper and upload it and it's something every time the state gives us what would you suggest for next year how can we we suggest it every time because there's a lot of times students have step by step every bit of their thinking on there and then it's just too hard to get it all on the computer it's tough when it comes to math the technology is there photo photomath that app you can take a picture of your examples that you hand write and it will work it out
107for you there's so many apps and programs that we use that let them do that it would be such an advantage to our children if that was an option for them and Chris I know you mentioned link it I know that was something that the board and the administration was spok on getting a a data system that was you know something that we could use over the course of time so we you know we wouldn't have to worry about the transfer of a student from one to the other you could see kind of strengths and weaknesses and work on that can you just give uh a 30- second overview of you know what you've done with that system whether the administration not the administration but the teachers are embracing it what you think can really
108be driven from that tool to help us in this process yes of course the teachers have taken to link it because of uh a very strategic roll out from the entire Administration team um it's been really important that we show the benefits of the program rather than just say this is how we're going to collect data uh so in our oneto ones with teachers whether it's uh you know through the observation process or staff development we have taking a look at data profiles that they have never seen before so what you mean you can create a dashboard for a particular grade level and you can upload their previous two State assessments their nwe ba and they are running records and local assessments and you can see it visually color coded in every domain and then
109within that you can click into a subgroup of students and it will show you number one discrepant data like for an example if a student is in the high average range for the NWA but scored a level two in the state assessment it allows you to dig a Little Deeper to figure out what might be you know the cause of that um and while we've always been a you know we're building this culture of data this has been at our fingertips to make it so simple for our administrative team to create these dashboards and then when you create the entire Master grade list you can share it with the teachers and they only have access to their students and then we have developed fluency plans for math facts through linkit we have developed um and
110we were just talking about this recently about pushing out some State assessment practice questions through link it as well which will be data that um is supportive and maybe perhaps indicative of how they'll do on state assessment so um long story short with data you know with link it it's been a really intuitive way for a district and for our teachers to be able to do it and I'll share a quick story quit um but a teacher's uh roster was down and um she couldn't access her her report cards and she was coming to me she was like you know I was like all right I'll get I'll get it up and running and she's like no I I need link it for the for the um for the report cards and it was I
111I didn't I didn't imagine we would be in year two and a teacher being so dependent on the dashboard to create the report cards so it just goes to show me that I think we're in The Sweet Spot for it because of the very strategic roll out from everybody at the table here making sure that it wasn't just another thing for teachers but it was a really valuable tool that they could see it in a way visually they have never seen it before and I know I asked this question um when we we spoke in the past but our teachers able to look at it and you can look across your cohort of teachers and see some teachers do certain things better than others and vice versa and how you uh use that tool to
112assess maybe professional development or uh teacher learning amongst themselves to figure out how to kind of address certain topics that maybe their students aren't doing as well as that other other teachers are doing better at yeah you can certainly do that and with the help of the coordinators they've been able to take a look at some of that data and then um you know best practice is the teacher next door sometimes and making sure that you not just visit them because you think that they're good but you visit them for a particular reason because the data shows that and when you've got three years a trend of demonstrating some Proficiency in a standard based on linkit it teachers are happy to share what they're doing in those particular standards some a teacher staff development um
113component it's working really well I do want to share with you though um I think we can continue to do more on the teacher staff development front but um also recognizing we're in the second year of this and you know as duton had shared uh in previous meetings we are far ahead of where I thought we would be with the help of Lauren Maguire um and our team making sure that you know link it has been successful for for our teachers I'm I'm going to just round out unless there's another questions for IT yeah um I just want to round out and we're like at that last bullet on math and I just want to make sure I get there um so just to close out here uh for the elementaries um in collaboration with
114Mrs Cardella and our math team we've been monitoring the math fluency data and teachers just recently had an opportunity to meet with their building level specialist for individualized fluency plans they are um through link it uh and it's been wildly helpful if there's anyone listening and if there are any parents listening please practice your math facts um you know and the last component to the to did I say practice your math facts I did okay I just want to make sure I got that in there um additionally we were always making ways to adjust the pacing and incorporating significant review I think what we saw the increase in math uh proficiency levels was because uh Mrs Cardella and the math specialist teams have strategically put in Spiral Review both not into the instruction but also
115the assessment and that has been U very helpful to see how those kids are doing and the Spiral Review isn't just the unit prior the Spiral Review is connected to the major clusters on the state assessment um so that's been big and we'll continue to do that as we move forward with the help of Mrs Cardell and the rest of our Math teachers and that is it for now for the math uh excuse me for the elementaries I just have one question yeah um I just had a question it sounds like we're being very um thoughtful and strategic about creating some more close reading experiences um but how do we do that in a way um that doesn't become test prep like are there ways in which we can provide those experiences but embed them
116inside our curriculum units to provide those experiences for the children looking closely at different types of test TT giving them opportunities to write about those different texts but not where you're doing it for the purpose of you know what I mean where it becomes test prep because sometimes you can lose like engagement and motivation from children when it's like you know to prepare for a test yes that's a great point that you raised you don't want to over rotate on just close response uh engagement because then it may you know uh it may turn kids off to their chapter books that they really enjoy uh and if you do it um let's say close reading is not just a test taking strategy you you read you you close read three times right for a first
117read a second read and a third read and you can select a variety of texts to do that and I think it's up to our teachers who have done an excellent job of making sure they select those texts that are interesting to kids um so if they're interested in a topic there are so many resources that could populate text now and there's so many available resources in our new libraries that if you really know your students inside and out you can do a close reading strategy with a text and create those text dependent questions without having it to feel to test pry I also do think that when you go through close reading and um response to literature practices you're teaching kids to be really critical of the work that's in front of them and
118I think that's the idea is that you want to turn kids into critical thinkers of the work they want to make their judgments on what they're reading that's really really really important so it's a balance it's not going to be an everyday experience that's not what we hope for but it will be a balance embedded into the units both on the front end and the back end and then of course leading up to the assessment like you know and then communicate with us if there's more resources or support that you need so that you can provide those texts for the children in the classrooms um we would love to be able to support that work as well that's great and one another area so it doesn't feel so test passage text um kind of prep
119we can use the text sets that the coordinators have helped us curate for science and social studies for especially our fourth and fifth grade classes so they're very aligned to our science and social studies curriculum but then we can create the close reading experiences to go along with those text sets so you're reading science and social studies based on your curriculum work but doing some of that additional close reading experience in there and that's embedded in some of the mystery science right inside of the units they have text connections and and I know I posed the question to you Chris but I have all the primary teachers here U principles I'm sorry here is there anything you're seeing amongst your student populations that um is something that either the you know the board or the
120administration is unaware of or any patterns that you're seeing positive or negative that you think kind of impact scores as the as the children get older yes we analyze our data and work you know at data meetings together and are very grateful for our work with our coordinators as well so you mentioned the writing before um last year we did a great deal of work with our teachers and writing we're thankful to our literacy director we worked on the writing mini lessons and we really increased our volume of writing and this year we're looking at reading and writing as reciprocal processes we build we're building the foundation with phonics using heg foundations foric awareness so as the children are decoding in their reading they're encoding in their writing the teachers are adding sentence sentence sentence
121dictations daily um even more so and then with that volume of writing as we continue to work together the goal is for the writing to increase we looked at writing in teams of teachers we looked at the writing progressions so that that the um gauge of a writer can be consistent across the place and I think um just to add on to that I know you were talking about the primary levels and Mr sein grber said it starts with us and although we don't have the state assessments at our level we do work very closely with the elementary I mean they do a great job with their data analysis and the state assessments so we work with them knowing so what we can do to help you know close those gaps as well with the
122elementary are you are you seeing any kind of themes and changes in our students I know some of you have been with us for a long time so you have uh good purview um not as long but um in terms of what the students what the students you know the preparation uh the student subset the mix you know where they stand when they come into us are there more challenges or it's consistent over the years anything that you can share with folks that is of note I think want talk post pandemic so um we have seen a trend change for our kids post pandemic and now we're feeling like we're back to a normal group of cohort of children that have had school experiences and life experiences um so we've seen that I think the
123other thing I just want to comment the board about supporting us with a coach and so we saw huge uh impact of our math coaches uh in both Elementary and primary and now we have one literacy coach uh which we hope will be another added asset and benefit to both the Q5 level so I mean in terms of seeing it's it's hard to say you see Trends in K And1 because they're always evolving there they're babies they're sponges so we I all I can say is I see them learning and growing every day so is not a day I don't see a Child Learning something uh so it's hard to say like if we've got a gap there necessarily per se are there places to grow always right because education is always evolving and we're
124always learning and recognizing where we could do better in first grade as a result of our second grade Feb back from our elementary principal so one area that you can speak to is uh particularly with the support of with the speech and language because that's been a big support for I think the primary with Ruby all [Laughter] right so it hasn't been that long but we are very we are very fortunate that we had we've had H we did we did um we have a speech teachers to support our primary teachers in hegr and specifically she pushes into the kindergarten classrooms as a tier one support with heger to help those students gain that phonemic awareness and she works in centers with the um kindergarten teachers and um recently she is working in conjunction with
125our math coach in building that Center time with the classroom teachers so that children can get what they need at a specific time of day whether it's working with the speech teacher or Integrity the math coach and then the classroom teacher will also have censored time so that children are all gaining access to whatever they need during that specific time but she really hones in on those and she really has built capacity with our teachers and staff as well in building phic awareness um instruction any other questions from the board no so we'll open it up to Citizens questions uh comments on the presentation you could just been here plenty of times so you know the drill uh my name is Aon DB 90 Huntington Road first of all thank you for the very thorough
126presentation it is very much appreciated I have two questions uh one and I'll just ask him and go sit down uh one was just in regard to achievement data for special education students at the School level was there a breakdown of students with I APS and their achievements um and then secondly looking further into special education students and looking at the collective uh achievement data and that was presented as standardized data um assessments but is there anything about alternative assessments students is that that's achievement also um but with both of these analysis and the data what does it show us about special education students strength and weaknesses if we're analyzing all of our students and all of our Learners kind of to Echo what Mr cilio said can we dig deeper into the special education
127students in our district and what does it tell us about the strengths and weaknesses of our instruction to special education students so those are my questions all right the high school numbers did not break down or separate the special ed students they were included in there but we do have that information specifically for special ed we can provide that for you also get the alternate assessment um just as a side note uh uh Kristen and I were actually discussing what we thought was going on basically with special education as compared because obviously Ela is lower than math um personally I think it's it has something to do with the fact of um I am a math person I I just find sometimes it's more appealing you're not going to get that same level of academic
128frustration that you're not having that that you have with Ela as the as the uh uh uh as the text gets hotter so I I think to that point I think that that's something that we should really look to embrace um our uh the data that was presented for the middle school and and the elementary the special ed data was included within that also you separated but I just that was part of that as well Angela muta 117 Kingsbury Road um I look around the room and I think I may be one of the oldest people in the room and because of that I'm not oh okay we're in competition where you see that then I hope I have support on my quick history lesson um I want to remind people that may not have
129been in this field in the field of education at the time of No Child Left Behind this was a political uh push that led to the common core standards which I thought was a fabulous idea of coming up with who should learn what when there's absolutely nothing wrong with that concept I think that's brilliant and we absolutely needed that the problem came shortly thereafter when New York State and the entire nation was was forced to um create standardized testing that was very challenging to students the entire nation failed the test that's okay that's what happened when the entire nation failed the test publishing companies took over and Pearson Publishers got the contract for New York State and students did horrifically on the Pearson's first test so Pearson said we got a great idea we're going
130to sell you test prep material and they SE sold test sprep material for one year students got workbooks that they could write in and then they would be tossed out and the reason this happened was because the following year they were changing the test and every every year thereafter they continued to change the test since then none of the students in my family not my own children and not my grandchildren have taken the test I opt out of the test all the time because they are not fair no disrespect whatsoever to Mr Stein grber but the reason that the high schools do so well and the other schools K I mean 3 through eight do not do as well is because they're taking regions tests a regions test has a regions curriculum with a region
131test that teaches exactly what's going to be on the test and then the students that listen and prepare and Do Do Well whereas with the New York state test there's always a surprise and and I think we spend time days two hours tonight and lots of aggravation trying to figure out what they're going to do next to make more money and keep themselves in business and unless somebody actually says this happy to say it and I'll repeat it we absolutely need to focus on inhouse looking at student work I keep repeating it I've been coming to these meetings for eight years and I keep saying let's use teacher created data teacher created test because the teachers are teaching the students are learning we're sending our best students into these schools we have a very very
132very supportive parent community and everyone's doing a lot of things right and this looks horrible and the reason it looks horrible is because it's keeping somebody in business it's an a multi-million dollar business I just had to do that thank you any other questions or comments everybody it's uh Rich Coro me Brook Road um two items first hopefully quickly um Dr Cen I believe the last time that I addressed the board um there was the issue of creating a contractual bargaining unit for OT PT staff um I believe at that time you had said around December so I just was hoping for any followup on that item we'll be reporting on that at the next regular session at the regular meeting this is a work session we'll be address is that that's um next week
133next week correct okay thank you the other the other thing um sort of in a somewhat different direction but I heard a lot uh tonight about you know three through five we didn't talk so much about K through to um a lot of talk about data testing but in in my view I believe the the child find system the system designed to find the students that H are having issues of those critical early years K through two I think it's broken I'm happy to be told I'm wrong I'm happy to have that conversation with any one of you um been difficult to have that conversation with any one of you but I think it's broken I'm happy to be proven wrong trust me um I have to respectfully disagree with Mr Samson when we look
134at the numbers and differential between math and reading performance at the middle school level the question was posed well do you think it's a matter of support um I have to disagree I think it is a matter of of added support at the right time in the right way and tailored to the student we we get lost in these numbers we're not you know necessarily focusing on particular students I get that this this Board of Ed meeting um but it is in my view at least um a matter of the right kind of support for that student and you know a lot of times what does happen uh and this dovet tales with one of the concerns that I've had a lot of the times what happen is you know parents will hear that type
135of response for their particular student and one of the Avenues as you know that they have as parents under the law is to ask for an independent assessment of the situation and you know I'm looking at an email from Mr ODU from March of 2023 the district had implemented a policy and procedure whereby parents asking for an independent assessment were being directed to a multiple multi-is AR team of Educators to discuss the request in my view this is illegal this is an illegal policy it's it's my view I'm happy to be told I'm wrong I'm happy to have that conversation my question to you is and it's quite clearly expressed in detail in this email and there's a chart is this policy still in place what's that I comment it's an email from Mr O
136Mr I know you're a lawyer I can't comment on legality in a public session without my counsel I'm not asking about legality I'm asking is this is this policy in this email which I'm happy to hand out to you I I would love to take a copy but I can't I don't know the policies off the top of my head we can look into it policies by memorization but if you if you have concerns about legality you should put it in an email and send it and we'll have Council review that well I I've sent emails to the board and I've been ignored um this is a new IE process implemented 202 I'm Not Gon let you make statements like that that's not true it's you're not ignored all all emails sent to the board
137will be responded to by the administration the board does directly respond to your emails sir I reached out directly about this IE issue and I was ignored by yourself by the board by Dr senha now I'm here and I want an answer is this policy still in place um I no one has interest having something so like President SL said please email that us that it's would be disturbing to all of us if there is something that is illegal so this is the thank you I appreciate yeah you're you're not on the email yet I don't believe okay yeah so you didn't email the so which is fine well it's it's it's this is this is Janine valz Joseph cilio Tom panu Mr gneo um William oonu custom CA it's March 2023 it talks in
138quite explicit detail about this policy there's charts a year-over-year chart in comparison so yeah you know there are people that that it's fair to say did not receive it and again we have no interest in having things that are illegal out there I think we can all agree that so just send send it again and then we'll review it I certainly will thank you Frank Napoli U 32 Adam Street Gordon City you just pull this past week Frank Napoli 32 Adam Street this past week I have been posting critical making critical posts on local Facebook pages about specifically the ELA programming grades 3 to eight all right I have a concern about that I think we're headed in the wrong direction we're in the wrong trajectory I'm not looking at just this year I'm looking
139at this preco postco okay I'm comparing it not only just taking Garden City in a vacuum I'm looking at I'm looking at the ELA assessment uh the proficiency rates on what I consider our competitive school districts like heris Jericho uh Great Neck Northshore see who who did I leave out herck um East Willis okay just look into at those that I consider all competitors and we're at the bottom of the list significantly so and it's been that way since 2018 I've also taken we don't have a math problem we have an Ela I posted this and I'm going to give this to the board I don't know if you had a chance to look at social media assuming you don't I think this is data driven what I'd like to see the board do is
140review this digest it and please forward it to the administration and open a dialogue and ask the question why okay because my because I'm looking at the data and I am absolutely amazed and I see now the last two years I'm looking at the year before last 2223 I was absolutely shocked to see uh new High Park Garden City Park score better than us in laa okay grades three day shocked I saw a plane view all Beth Page right on PA with Garden City same thing this year I'm kind of perplexed about how that happens and I'm really seeing us what I consider our competitor school districts I'm seeing us really at the bottom of that rung I want you fellas to look at wom men and women look at the charts look at the
141graphs and and ask the administ ation why because what I see is the elephant in this room that nobody is speaking about is well we have an Ela program all I have heard and I don't know much about this is we talk about structured literacy which New York state is saying there they want all the school districts to implement that we've had balanced literacy under the under the teachers college now it's morphed into comprehensive literacy I don't know if the if the program is wrong I don't know if the PDS the teachers using are not effective okay what I'd like to do is make a suggestion if that's the elephant in the room if that's the reason why our Ela scores it down maybe we should ask I ask the board consider this as a
142suggestion I an independent consultant okay an independent consultant whose credential instructed literacy all right then have that independent not not somebody that doctor Sr Miss Bowman or Miss calman recommends you guys figure this out you men and women on the board figure it out you bring somebody in to look at this and what I'd say is number one identify the program that we have okay identify the uh the assessment tools we use identify the PDS that we're using identify them secondly evaluate them all right third look at these look at the programs and say what options if you're going to look at structured literacy if the state is saying we need to implement this and de Implement balance literacy or comprehensive literacy what exactly what literacy programs with this structural literacy recommend what PDS they
143recommend and what assessment tools and give us a cost analysis find out how much do it cost us and the and a timeline that's all I think that's just you know if we have a problem let's look at it turn the corner address it and move on we need to do something and this is the future of Garden City these kids we're not talking about these kids are in high school that are knocking it out of the park we're talking about these young kids you know like look this year I mean I want to just throw a figure out to you 29% almost 30% of the kidss from 3 to eight are not reading at grade level do you know that third grade 34% aren't in the fourth grade 32% I mean this isn't a
144oneoff this isn't just this year I want you to look at the data look at the stuff open up a dialogue with the with the with the administration and ask why and and please consider using looking at a structured a consultant that's a convential instructed literacy you no uh Frank I'm Sorry Miss na one of the things that um Mr cilio and I were looking at we kind of looked at how the kids progress so in other words you know over the past three years you looked at the third grade in 22 the fourth grade in 23 the fifth grade in 24 it's the same group of kids right so you're looking at apples and apples as opposed to apples and oranges um and I mean one of the things that we noticed was I
145I mean there were decreases is in uh three of the uh because obviously there's four there in three of the four so this is something that we are concerned about and I think you astutely pointed out that uh I mean just considering with the math but I mean this is a definite concern we don't have a math problem Pro and what I'd like to say is we just re we received today uh with the with the uh student achievement report we finally got some NWA data I have not had a chance to post this on social media but I made a table for you folks and what I did was I wanted to show the importance of it's not just Ela Ela the nwaa correlates to the uh nwaa correlates to the ELA state state
146assessments and you can look at it it's not just the decline in the state assessments you can look and see this decline in NWA nwaa RI scores as well so it's in here there's a lot of data I have nothing to hide I would just like you to take a hard look at it and and talk about it open up the dialogue and just answer the question why I would just say Mr napy we are we are looking at the data we we appreciate um you know some of your comments we do uh dive in we have we have been diving in with members of the administration the team over here um to your point on a consultant we are planning on interviewing consultants in short short form um to interview with the board and
147the administration to find somebody to look at this with a fresh set of eyes so that was maybe maybe you missed it earlier cuz I know it was you know two and a half hours ago or whatever it was but we did we did mention that and that is part of the plan because it's always good to get a fresh set of eyes and see if there's things we can do better because I think everybody up here wants what you want we want to do better and so I think we're all pushing in the same direction I know we all have different views but it'd be great to get a consultant to give us another view and look at the data also have you know a disc it's on a PowerPoint it's on the disc
148a stick Drive in case you guys want to use it and one of the things I just want to mention looking around it's not like people don't care right because I can tell you I monitor the post some of my posts that have been up there we've had over a postre of over 6,000 and some another postre of over 5,000 views on that so people in the village are looking at this so it's something that you know I think is kind of important thank you I mean one of the other things that we were looking at too Mr Napoli is how many questions kids are off out of the three I mean of course there's a secret formula that all has that they're not going to share with us but you can take a guess
149hi Deborah dangler 142 killer Road I'm here to talk about the ELA and specifically the class of 2031 um I have older children they were in the class of 21 class of 23 I have one in the class of 2 7 and my youngest is now in the class of 2031 and I'm very proud of all the data Mrs D grer showed with the aps the college courses everything my kids excelled in the high school and they did well in the high school they've done well in college because of what they learned in Homestead in statford and in the middle school you can't do well in one if you're not doing well in the other it's a progression um so when I look at my son in in sixth grade at his English curriculum that
150having this year I see drastic differences to the English curriculum that my older three children had when they were um in sixth grade and I wanted to illustrate it so you could understand what I see in the changes with the curriculum and maybe that will help explain why we're seeing the decline in the ELA grades so I charted it if you'd like to live that um as you can see Mr R was the teacher in sixth grade for the class of 21 and I compared what they learned in the first quarter in sixth grade for the class of 2021 the class of 2023 and the class of 2027 and you'll see a list of their assessments for each quarter so they had spelling and vocabulary tests chapter one chapter two chapter three they WR a
151book called Where the Red Fern Grows they had a test on it um the books were split into two or three free tests um they would read a chapter as a whole class they would discuss it they would learn vocabulary words for each chapter then they would have questions based on the chapter that they had to write about so they were learning everything at the same time they were learning spelling vocabulary Reading Writing everything and grammar they had a noun test and what I was surprised when I looked they had different teachers but they pretty much all stayed on track and even my child who was in sixth grade when we were on remote which was every other day amazingly the teachers stayed on track and they learned pretty much the same thing the three
152quarters but then when my fourth child in the class of 2031 entered sixth grade everything was different so we went from two periods of English to one period of English and I was a little I was concerned about that and I did speak to Mr Samuelson about my concerns and we've gone from two periods to one period because I saw the decline in English for the class of 2031 and I really thought they would benefit from two periods of English um so anyway the quarter started and I reached out to his teachers I did speak to Mr Samson and I was concerned because they weren't having vocabulary tests they weren't having spelling tests they weren't reading a book together as a class um instead the teacher reads the book out loud and they have to
153sit there and listen and they don't have copy of the book so he's not even seeing the spelling he's not seeing the grammar it's just it's a very different experience he's not having spelling vocabulary tests um I don't see the grammar I don't see the spelling I don't see the vocabulary I don't see him learning that and that's my concern because I know the rigor of high school I know what's on the SAT I know what he's going to face and I know what his classmates are going to face and those are my concerns and I was wondering if you've looked into the difference in the curriculum because it switched after the class of 2027 a new English curriculum was introduced and then I noticed the decline in the ELA scores so if you look
154on the fourth column these are the tests that my the class of 2031 had they only had two tests the rest of the assessments are homeworks and classworks and you see a drastic difference between the testing through the four years so I didn't know if we could discuss if you guys have looked into the impact of not giving the kids vocabulary books and teaching vocabulary the spelling the grammar he did get a grammar packet sent home um it wasn't the same grammar that my other three children had they had a grade six book these were grade four and grade five grammar sheets that my sixth grader was getting so I'm concerned about him receiving grade level materials as a sixth grader and all of them because there's only three English teachers now in sixth grade
155cluster a has one English teacher cluster B has one English teacher and cluster C has one English teacher and they're all doing the same stuff so it's not like it's just one class it's across the board the whole grade so those are my concerns I didn't know if anybody had looked into the impact of removing the vocabulary the spelling the change in ela I mean Matthew I don't know if you want to address it or we can you know have it have it addressed kind of offline if there's a longer conversation to be had yeah i' be more than happy to speak to you on this topic Miss dangler this is certainly something we've thought about carefully and we have uh felt very strongly with some time that vocabulary instruction should be something that happens
156in situ which which is to say uh through the context of a text as opposed to uh a workbook we uh are very satisfied with that with the outcomes we have our vocabulary instruction as well as our grammar instruction but I'd be very happy to have a conversation with you on this topic if You' like thank you um it's just that the vocabulary if you look at the SAT you look at the PSAT you know the reading section split into four sections and vocabulary makes up 25% now my other three kids did learn vocabulary while they read the books and in the content and other other classes but they also had that Sader vocabulary book in grades four five six seven and eight and that seems to have been removed so all those antonyms synonyms
157that they learn the definitions the class of 2031 wasn't getting there and they're not getting that in sixth grade so that's my concern because that impacts reading comprehension and I do see if you look at the second sheet I look at the class of 2027 they were 89% per proficient that's the curriculum that you saw now I look at the class of 2030 they're 70% proficient so we went from 28 students not proficient to now 106 students not proficient and I'm looking at the impact of not teaching the vocabulary the spelling the grammar and I just think it's something that should be looked at we can we can look into that and we we'll we'll share the sheets with the administration we we'll have them reach out to answer your question or have a further
158Dialogue on that thank you because my goal is for the class of 2031 to be like the class of 2023 I want to see them Excel and I want Mr steinen grer in a few years to be standing here proud of the data of the class of 2031 so thank you thank you hi Tor Delo one Sunset Lane I've been here numerous times advocating about literacy I do not have a vested interest or any financial gain for advocating about literacy I do this because I care my son was diagnosed with dyslexia in first grade and because of that I became very passionate about literacy I do not have a financial gain or any kind of um benefit i' drive from it except that I just hope other kids can learn to read and write at
159grade level too despite challenges because it is possible I've seen it with my own son who started at a reading rate of zero in first grade when I was told that he would never be at grade LEL reader he accomplished that he got to grade level reading there's always bumps in the road because he requires more repetition than other kids but I'm not here about him I'm he about in general the overview of the literacy instruction here um could be so much better Barden city is a wonderful Community wonderful place to live I can't say enough great things about the teachers the supportive um staff and everybody that tries to help the children that are really here because they care and that's why I'm here because I care too um and going back to the
160data that we were just talking about you guys have a ton of data and are able to analyze a lot of data and make decisions that are data driven um when the charts were presented before I'm just a little confused with the nwaa and how it correlates to the ELA and I'm hoping that you can clarify because when I was looking at the NWA correlation chart it shows that if you are at or below the 60th percentile you're not proficient at that point for that Benchmark so in the charts that were just shown it looked like the red or the orange or whatever shades of them at the 50th perc were being considered proficient but according to the NWA correlation chart it's not anything below 60th percentile is considered at risk for not making the
161grade level benchmarks um for that year and then looking at the mtss plan that we have we don't offer supports until students are beneath the 35th percentile which would put them at at least six months behind their typical peers or six months behind that what they should have learned for the year and that's even very hard to catch up from when I called other school districts in the area that are considered um I guess more about our peer districts I guess like your Jericho your Manhasset you know those types of school districts they start giving their mcss supports once their students uh start to decrease past the 60th percentile they don't wait till the 35th percentile they're offering their mtss supports at that moment when they're at risk so I'm just curious as far as
162when you look at the data with whatever computer system or whatever program you have how do you use that data to drive instructional changes or instructional supports so you get children before they fail because I feel like once you wait for them to be six months behind it's very hard to catch up from that especially when you don't necessarily legally you don't have to notify a parent until you put them in AIS and they have or mtss and they have to go to the extra help from what I understand you know please correct correct me if I'm mistaken so then the parents may not be aware because you want to believe your kids are learning they're getting good grades lots of times my son would get 90s and 80s you know in high 80s but
163he still couldn't necessarily do everything independently on his own to a level of Mastery that would be expected for that grade you know um so if the parent isn't made aware until they're six months behind how can the parent get a tutor or help their child at home too because this is a community that likes to help their kids we're not going to sit back and just watch our kids struggle you know but if we're not aware of it or you know people are waiting and watching and just being hopeful and giving them more time that's time that that child doesn't have can't get back and more social emotional issues happen then too they start feeling bad about themselves you know reading is a first job a child has and if they can't master reading
164they start to feel bad about themselves they feel like a failure so it does contribute a lot to social emotional well-being and just a sense of belonging amongst their peers when they're they feel that they're not catching it as quick and then it also affects all other content areas so I guess the main question is how does Data Drive instruction are we looking at the 60th percentile and the fact that they're at risk when they fall beneath that and do your graphs correspond with that information because it was just confusing the way the the colors were okay uh can I start by asking a couple questions sure okay you had mentioned that you reached out to some of our comparative districts to discuss their mtss plans can you give me a little more no just
165to ask where the cut scores were and there might a little bit more I can't it was a while ago but I know that it was at the 60th present I could find it and I can email it to you I think it's on their website that would be great sure um you also address parent communication I think it's important to note that our teachers do a great job of no they do I'm not saying that I'm saying that you don't have to say it you don't necessarily put on alert that your child needs extra support until they enter that the mtss the tier two you know you're not saying like the child needs extra help or extra support or mandated support however it's worded in the letter but I know that a letter goes
166out to inform parents that their child now is in getting the tier 2 level of support but in our district it takes almost six months you have to fall beneath the 35th percentile and that's you know but once you're beneath the 60th you're at risk of not making grade level so maybe there's a way to communicate that sorry teachers for our kids to be failing to communicate to parents or add intervenes in the classroom educator doesn't do that so you may not be getting a formal letter there's strategies that teachers are using they do that on right I'm not talking about in school I'm sure they are I'm saying what if a parent if a parent knows about you know a communication between parent parent right but sometimes there could be a disconnect in the
167parent may not be aware they could be helping them more at home that's all I'm saying but they may not know teachers communicate processes for our teachers to communicate with our parents and they do do that okay I teach but I I think what I'm trying to say is parents looking at your graph which is came out great and this presentation was very well put together and very professional it's a little bit misleading because you're thinking that if your child is in the 50th percenti they're okay they're not there at risk of not being proficient so I don't know if parents understand that if you're beneath the 60th percenti these are benchmarks obviously benchmarks aren't 100% cor cor they're not going to correlate 100% but they're pretty close you know and so yeah a couple
168of things the the um the Norms referenced on the nwea are by percentiles but the average high average and high ranges that you're referencing those are on grade level um so I'm talking about the cut score once you get to the cut score like for instance in Cut score are you talking about the state assessments now no I'm talking about the cut score for RIT if you look at the NWA carlet table to elas there's a cut score so if you're below that cut score like for instance 221 do you mean the yeah the NWA Norm table that correlates it's not National it's specific to New York it's in New York ela's correlate table to the NWA so for instance 220 one is a cut score for 8th grade I think I think it's for
169eth grade um for um your fall RIT so RS is so this is spring data just so you know the data on these slides is spring data oh it's I thought you did spring or you to fall spring spring to spring because if we're using spring data if if the state assessments are administered in a season closer to the spring it made more sense for us to use spring n WEA data well because I checked it with the table and it looked like it was fall unless you know what it could be spring because you know what the numbers the numbers didn't really move they stayed the same it's spring like 220 well the current ninth grade class over the past two years has not had a growth in RIT they've been at 220 221
170222 and 22 on the whole time which is not indicative of much growth in ela at all I Dr Dela we'd have to look into your specific questions and I think we're just going to keep going back and forth so Dr Bowman will look into that and go back to you thank you sure watch your step are there any other questions or comments want to share one more thing I forgot to mention before there was a science research it was called handwriting May boost brain connections more than typing does I don't know if anybody is familiar with that I noticed it's a different it's another variable that's different from the class of 2021 2023 with Ela compared to now is the impact that the Chromebook has had on English um there was a new feature
171that the district added and every Sunday I can see what period um and how much time my child spends on the Chromebook throughout the day it's a great feature I can even see every um page he's gone to what he's doing and one thing I noticed tracking his data is he spends the most time on his Chromebook in English class I don't know if anybody was aware of that um and last year in fifth grade the spelling program was all on the Chromebook so instead of my child writing out all his spelling words um like my other children did you write it two three times and that's an easy way to remember it he was clicking and dragging on the on the Chromebook so that method didn't work well for him and I noticed that
172in the beginning of the school year for the first two weeks the kids didn't have Chromebooks they were all handwriting and then the third week he was he wasn't in school for a week and each teacher had a different way of teach teaching a different style some it was he had to write everything some was on the Chromebook and I noticed that everything he wrote he remembered but then when I asked him about information that he had done on the Chromebook he didn't remember it so I noticed that change with him and if it's affecting my child I think it could be affecting other children I think maybe more handwriting in school could help them in English class with remembering writing it at out especially with spelling that could really help the lower grades I
173don't know if anybody looked into that with the spelling program we we can look into that I mean I've personally had concerns about computer testing I'm sure everybody here has heard me say that before it's different Learners have different ways but if you know that specifically about your child you should definitely have a conversation with the teacher or somebody in the school to see if there's last year I did discuss it then with all the high school teachers and they notice the difference and they go no all the kids are writing with on packets you know that's how they remember and I said' oh that's interesting because in Stratford it was heavily on the Chromebook and now in middle school with all different teachers you see all the different styles and you see what works
174and what doesn't work but for the majority of kids maybe in English it would be better to spend more time on paper and pencil than on the Chromebook it was just a thought thank you I appreciate that there are no other questions and comments announcements future Board of Education meeting is Tuesday December 17th next week uh 20124 regular session 8:15 here at the Garden City High School the meeting will be moved to the auditorium also make a note of that may have a motion that there's no further business to come before the board and that the meeting be adjourned so moved all in favor I please just got to sit with the Gabel one time very excited about the gap