CorpusRecord 61609

Gates Chili BOE: Regular Business Meeting and Capital Project Public Hearing 1.28.25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Gates Chili Central School District
Date
2025-01-29
Location
Monroe County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,751 words · about 49 min
Collected
2026-06-08

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001can I have a motion to resume public session Mr rowski miss littlewood all in favor the vote is unanimous we're now back in public session please stand for the pledge iedge allei to the of the United States of America indivisible Liberty and jce oops all right I'm now going to call the hearing to order so we have a public hearing on our Capital project sorry I may have been a little excited and went out of order wonderful how are you it's red oh okay thank you red means go all right so um this evening here to um open up the public hearing on the upcoming referendum for our future ready Capital project so on the agenda we're going to do some quick introductions talk about the history what got us here um talk about our

002planning process um what's in the final scope uh financial information schedule and questions so some quick introductions uh I'm MIT bam the assistant superintendent for business uh here with us is Brian sininsky from SEI Design Group part of our architectural firm Joe palato from campus construction um who helps with construction management and Christa Carlo from BPD Municipal Finance thank you gentlemen for being here tonight so happening right now we have our 2022 Capital project this was a $ 45.5 million referendum called building brighter futures um within that we are addressing the high school and middle school technology rooms upgrading those to more modern spaces um the high school fax area um that opened earlier this week on Monday um and staff and students are now in those spaces um and they're wonderful um thank you

003to our team for the work that they've done on those and then um the district office moved into the high school our old Westside Academy which is in the southeast side of the building um and that move has happened and we are currently in operation in that space in addition to that phase two which is underway includes the music um middle school music renovation and expansion that will closely replicate the spaces that are in our high School space um that has not started yet that won't start until after April Break um but it will be commencing soon uh the Florence brasser uh main office will get an upgrade and it will become a more secure space for staff and students as well as um we are working on a new pickup and drop off area

004for students um in the morning and afternoon that allows us to pull cars off of Laredo Drive which is next to our Florence PR Elementary that's been a consistent concern of our community members that traffic backs up in that area so we're looking to move that traffic off of the road and create a safer um pickup and drop off area um two multi-purpose turf fields um will be installed off of Buffalo Road one being a baseball field and one being a softball field they'll also double as soccer fields and Lacrosse Fields as well and then another thing that we're doing through this project will be addressing building conditioned survey items at the middle school high school in Florence brasser so what's um that's not on that slide sorry uh what's uh building condition survey items

005building condition surveys are things that we is a process we go through every five years um starting in 2010 and so in 2010 New York State education department came out and said you need to be reviewing your spaces top to bottom um on an regular and ongoing basis and we look at all of the Mechanicals in the buildings from um the roofs to the HVAC units to the flooring um and we assess the condition of those spaces in conjunction with our architect um to determine how much usable life they have left and what is the value um of those items if and when they need to be replaced and so in the last building condition survey which happened in 2021 we identified about $110 Million worth of work that needs to be completed and so

006a number of those things um were included in the building brighter Futures project and will also be included in the future ready project so in terms of capital project there's really three main phases one is the planning phase that's what we're in right now and typically that takes about a year um and we work through with um staff members to look through the things that we need to do um from there we get to design design only happens if the capital project is approved through public referendum and during that process um we meet with stakeholder groups um people people who have a vested interest in spaces and we look at what the needs are um that need to be addressed within the scope that has been identified and from there um that that procedure takes

007about a year and then from there um we submit design documents um that are um developed by the architect to the New York State education department their approval takes anywhere from six to eight months and then from there um once the New York State education department approves them um because they're in a queue with about 700 other school districts it takes them some time um then we're able to bid out the work to contractors and begin that work and so that's where you get to the build phase and so all in all these processes are long um and they require a lot of involvement by various stakeholders within and outside of our outside our community um so the again the building condition survey that's a major priority for us in this project and I'll share

008a little more on that in terms of the infrastructure and things that need to be addressed um in addition to that another priority of ours was prudent and sound financial planning to ensure that we're doing work in a way that minimizes the burden on our taxpayers so again our goal is to have um no increase in taxes Associated specifically with this project so the planning process includes monthly oacm meetings what's an oacm meeting it's an owner architech construction manager meeting that's with the individuals in this in this room along with the district um building tours of all facilities with SEI Design Group and campus construction um we look at unaddressed items from the 20 21 capital projects so what are the things maybe that needed to be addressed um but we were unable to what

009are some of those things and how can we pull those forward into the next project meetings with building leadership this is a key component to sit down with building leadership as well as Department leadership to talk about what are the needs of your building what are the needs of your staff what are the programmatic um instructional needs within your spaces as we look towards the future um we evaluate Mechanicals um AC and gathering places the reason why this is highlighted here is that recently the New York State education department um put out a regulation that says we have to maintain certain temperatures in rooms we already have a a low point now we have a high point too is if spaces get too warm we have to do one of two things um one is

010we have to uh put AC in all of our buildings and so we did an assessment of that and to have AC in all of our buildings all of our classrooms would be about $170 million um which is not tenable for our district um given Financial considerations um another option is is that we um we cool spaces um that are larger Gathering spaces and then we cycle students in and out of those spaces on the um 6 to 10 days where um we go above 88 degrees um so for us uh that is um that is our cafeterias our gymnasiums and um our libraries so that's what we're looking to do within this project if approved um we generated a project scope list based on all this information and then we began evaluating the impacts

011financially so in terms of the final scope project and I just want to point out that um scope means these are the things that we've identified as being priorities it doesn't mean that we've done any design work around what these spaces will actually look like I'm just speaking frankly our architect is not actually fully employed until a project is approved and we enter into contract with them so right now we're in the scoping phase where we look at what is the work we want to accomplish what's the estimated cost of that using estimation and then what is um a cost that we might incur when we bid it in two years from now so we put in a little bit of escalation of cost knowing that inflation will be a factor on costing out projects

012and so was when thinking about this project there's four main categories um failing infrastructure needs Renovations Replacements and new work overall um this project is significantly infrastructure related so it's primarily in infrastructure and then Renovations then some Replacements and um only 8% of the project is in new work again much of this is focused on that building condition survey where we identified about $110 million work that needed to be done um and so much of it is in this project so at the high school I'm looking in terms of infrastructure at boilers that need replacing um rooftop units um for heating and then some Roofing Replacements as well I'm noting that we have a very large um building the high school and it's one floor so in some high schools there's multiple floors so you

013have less Roofing here we have a whole lot of roofing and so some of those roofings are failing to the point point where sometimes we on really rainy days we have some buckets that have to go on the hall unfortunately um in terms of Renovations adding a lactation room in terms of um Replacements Paving Spartan way um Spartan way is in rough condition as well as the rear parking lot and the main parking lot in terms of new work looking at um additional stadium bleachers and Stadium fencing we know that when we have um large competitions here we have uh two things going on that can be problematic one is we don't have enough seating for our our people watching games and then the other one is is that it's hard to manage all of

014the movement of people in that space because there's no fencing going around the whole um site and so we'd be looking to do those two things there are a couple things within this proposal that would be accelerated in terms of the timeline these are two of those things whereby we'd be looking to submit documents to SED pretty soon after the vote so that we can start start that work within hopefully a year of approval if the project is approved these are two of those things because they don't take a whole lot of design effort um it's it's purchasing things and so we would look to add those hopefully sooner than later uh Gat trai Middle School failing infrastructure includes boilers um rooftop units and some chillers in terms of Renovations um many of our classrooms

015have very old unit unit ventilators those are the um heating systems that sit down near the windows um many of those were working really hard to keep them running and having to um get creative and finding Parts um a lactation room and then the digital entry sign on Buffalo Road would be replaced if this project is approved no new work Florence brasser um generator HVAC unit boiler rooms um this is one of the two buildings in the district that has ashalt shingles one being the old admin building that's now the Operation Center and brasser um so we would be replacing some of that um Renovations include the cafeteria the cafeteria bathrooms at every Elementary you'll see as I go through the slides it includes the library media center as well as a new digital message

016sign um our elementaries do not have digital message signs some of them even include um plugging um the letters into the boards the old style boards um we're looking to have a sign that can be programmed from within the building to share important information with our community um re rear parking lot Paving and a kitchen expansion the Florence brasser kitchen is the smallest Kitchen in our district um by a long shot um frankly it's like a sardine can it's very tight in there and it's um it's so difficult and so tight of a space that we have to get really creative with how we schedule lunches so looking to bring that up um to more modern standards Neil Armstrong includes rooftop and ear handling units um classroom carpet replacing one of the things we had

017looked at um in designing and and scoping is to potentially eliminate open classrooms in both Neil Armstrong and Walt Disney um in order to do that um we would have to frankly um expand the footprint of the building out because the hallways wouldn't be big enough um and so we're kind of grandfathered in not we're kind of we are grandfathered in with the space that we have if we touch that space then we have to bring it up to current code which would be which would include um widening those spaces um we're unable to do that because for each of those buildings it would be anywhere from 50 to $60 million um just to bulldo those wings and build new ones and so in lie of that um we're going to replace the carpets um

018which has been a consistent issue in those buildings um and try and do some other sprucing up of those spaces uh point of information is we would look to replace those carpets with more of like a VCT Tile um something that's a hard surface instead of um carpeting those spaces Renovations include lactation room um again in all these building library media center um and additional flooring uh in the back include the back of that building um there are some Paving and drainage issues we were to address and again a digital message sign Paul Road uh some of the same things things that you would see in the other areas rooftop units lactation room library media center um one thing that's um interesting about that building is that right now there's pavement going right up to

019the front of the building where the bus loop is and there is no curb and so one thing that we'd be looking to do is put in a sidewalk and create a curb so that if a bus ever were to roll for whatever reason um that it wouldn't roll into where kids are getting in and off of buses so to create a safer situation where there would actually be a curb a stop for the bus if it was to roll um and then in addition to that the digital message sign um right now around that building the sidewalk is not fully connected so for safety reasons um and especially during drills um we would be able to get all the way around the building um and then another one for that building is that right

020now it's on a busy road Paul Road and we have a number of um students who cross from the uh neighborhood across the street from Paul Road onto the Paul Road school property and in order to do that they have to cross that road and then they have nowhere to go there's no sidewalk leading to the building so they either cut through the grass or they walk up the Bus Loop is we'd be looking to put in a sidewalk as well as a crosswalk um so that students in that neighborhood can get across the street in a safe way um and then some adaptive playground equipment um acknowledging that um there is not enough adaptive playground equipment in that building for our students with disabilities at Walt Disney you'll see much of the same things

021that you would see at Neil Armstrong and then in other buildings we have um our old administr administration building that's now called the Operation Center we have the transportation facility and then we have some other ancillary um maintenance and storage type facilities um at the current admin space we'd replace some of the roofing um we'd replace the roofing at the stadium and grounds equipment storage building we would do some flooring replacement and abatement in the current admin building add a lactation room at Transportation uh currently during large events we have um rental bathroom facilities out behind the stadium um we would be looking to put um would be looking to put a hallway into the current bathrooms that are in the current um or now current uh Operation Center be looking to put a hallway

022in so that when we have events um community members visitors can use that space for bathrooms as well as increasing the size of the gates trie food pantry and then finally um we would look to put a concession stand in that building as well as some additional paving at the transportation facility so in terms of financial considerations our building Aid ratio um it's typically between 80 and 81% right now um and what does that mean is that if we're doing work that's aidable um then we get 81 sents back on the dollar and so when we think about planning these capital projects it's really important that we're considering when um work is aidable and the way that that's calculated is every five years the state assigns a certain amount of money to each of our

023buildings that um we're able to get Aid back on and it's a rolling fiveyear window and so that's the maximum cost allowance Aid ability component is we want to make sure that as we plan these projects and that um rolling window of Aid becomes a available that we're utilizing it to the best of its ability again because when we get 81 cents back on the dollar it means that it doesn't require um Community um burden in terms of Taxation based on the plan that we put in place um utilizing existing Debt Service and looking at when um our mortgage payments essentially for prior work our interest and principal payments drop off and making sure that we're keeping our debt service level and then our credit rating as well as again having no impact on taxes

024so in terms of this project we started planning um in January 2024 again it's a year-long process to get to where we are today um the design phase would take us until spring of 26 and later uh and in terms of construction we would be looking to do construction currently over four phases um with that last phase going into 2032 so it's a long process referendum itself looking at a proposal that includes $88 million Allin the propositions on the ballot would be the approval to undertake the project and then also a second proposition includes our ability to use $4 million in capital reserve funds for security infrastructure this was a reserve that was created a few years ago by the public through referendum and we now have the money in that Reserve that would allow

025us to increase security features here at the high school and also at the middle school including electronic door locks um and also electronic clocks and so right now we have um analog clocks and we have an analog PA system at the middle school and the clocks in the high school have failed and the PA system does not work well at the middle school and so looking to upgrade those to a digital system that also ties into um our tap app security feature um so that if we were to go into lockdown it would announce it through that system it would also um put it out in words lockdown lockdown across that system it would be an integrated system um across those buildings so the vote is on Wednesday February 5th from 6:30 to 8:30 6:30

026a.m. to 8:30 p.m. at the Spartan Fieldhouse at the Gat try high school at one Spartan way please come out and vote are there any questions all right thank you so much for being here tonight thank you so much it is now time that we can close the hearing since there's no public comment so now can I ask for a motion to resume the regular business meeting Miss littlewood Miss kais any discussion all in favor the vote is unanimous we're now back in public session move us on to the GC Pride Awards um I'm honored uh every year to be able to present the gay shy Pride award uh this year is no different uh being able to honor it to Michelle Mandola uh she's one of our bus drivers that has been with us

027for almost 20 years I looked today it was very close I can't say 20 but we're we're right there um she's someone that just goes above and beyond every year uh she was always a a sub when I first started she did everything and she could now she has her own run and she still tries uh everyone knows we're short we'll call on the radio and say this kid got missed or whatever and somehow Michelle is always on the radio saying I think I can fit it in if I go here first I do this and I can do this and a lot of times I actually have to say it's okay we'll figure it out because it's not possible right like but it's just who she is um I know you know a lot

028of times we're trying to get drivers to learn kids and Michelle's someone that knows probably more kids than on every run even today when I get in she's like I think I know his kids and I remember over there like she knows parents she just knows our community so well so it's a very uh nice honor to award this to Michelle for uh G Charlie Pride award for this year thank you so much thank you thank you thank you now you got to talk oh no no but I appreciate it thank you thank you for all your work uh do we have any agenda changes sir we had agenda changes to Personnel thanks all right that moves us forward to board president comments um first I just want to take a moment mostly to remind

029ourselves but to make sure that we're just kind of sharing some of the work we do as a board to make sure we're continuing to grow and to learn to do our jobs better um we're doing a book study right now and it's actually a really easy read um the way it's formatted it's uh how to it's something how to be a good board member how not to be a sorry I'm bad at the title remembering we've got it it's okay it's really it's a it is but thank you how not to be a terrible School Board member um which is kind of written in like a very light-hearted way but to address kind of the serious work that we do really always being grounded in representing our students and our mission and vision and

030values as a district um and we'll be kind of discussing it talking about our takeaways things we we learn in upcoming March time together just as a reminder for all of us it looks like some of us have it with us which is awesome um and as I was thinking about that and the fact that we're at midyear Time regions just happened there's a lot going on each day in our world in our community and just taking a minute to kind of reground ourselves into not only the work we've done so far and the work we have to do but kind of reminding ourselves of that mission and vision and goals we have for ourselves as a board for the district and to be able to support our kids so I'm not going to necessarily

031go back and read word for word our mission and vision and goals but kind of just touching on some of those pieces that really Center us and we need sometimes to like pause for a minute and really focus in it because life gets hard and busy but really here engage CH a big part of what we're doing and focusing on is providing that sound education for all of our students working to inspire excellence in each of our Learners establishing healthy and caring relationships for not only our students but our staff and being able to refocus in that and for our families and the rest of our community we have that Spartan way which especially if you go in our elementary schools they all know those kind of words and that little statement because it's kind

032of focusing in on as few words as possible to get to those core values of respect responsibility hard work and compassion and just kind of revisiting as well apparently I'm saying a lot of kind of tonight sorry um those goals we have for ourselves that fostering belonging through Equitable access to culturally responsive and restorative practices supporting the wellness of all the people in our Learning Community focusing on increasing our academic achievement by access to rigorous instructional practices using data to monitor that all the work that keeps coming and being reported out on each meeting and that work that we have for ourselves as a board of really working on our communication and pulling in families in the community as well so just wanted to take that moment to make sure that we all can pause

033and ground ourselves because it's the middle of the year and sometimes we need to reset for a moment um that moves us forward now to points of interest does anybody have anything to share Dr Richards that's okay I'll use my educator voice um just V went to the junior Spartans game this past weekend and I know um particular interest in the fourth grade grest team but watching them play on an our Fieldhouse where we are able to host a number of games at one time it was exciting to see family and friends out to support them and I know with the fourth grade team they won again twice in a row so just to say that it's good to be able to house our students in an additional athletic way and making sure that our

034our community knows that it's it's we're proud we're Gates shly proud and it was good a good thing to see them play thank you any additional points of interest Miss kais this is upcoming but on um February 7th next Friday evening uh Java Jazz will be here in the pack um always a big fundraiser option for our band and um music kids um for their upcoming trip to Orlando but um they have great musicians come in kids get to play on stage with them they work with them during the day um I look forward to seeing everybody there thank you so much any other points of interest okay thank you that moves on to reports of meetings have there been any meetings Mr msato I had the opportunity to attend the M County School Board

035associations information exchange um committee meeting the topic was the New York State Department of Labor's teacher ambassador program the focus of the program was to help schools develop um Career and Technical education programs and to enhance the opportunities for students to take these looking at the um job market basically point being that we're going to have 500,000 skilled labor people retire and we only have maybe 200,000 at the moment in the pipeline so the idea was to enhance that and to say it's not an issue of college uh excuse me college or trade it's college and and try to have the kids be aware there's a lot of opportunities and college is not the only one so it was well worth it thank you thank you any other meetings okay Dr Richards hold on I

036had the opportunity to attend the N uh nsba Equity Council membership meeting what it was good to to hear from districts um around the area just kind of on a report on where things stand and just to you know have a a voice with other colleagues and kind of to be able to let someone let their hair down and release some of the frustration that we have going on in that education today but I think it was very good to be able to um sit on that call with when we were districts across the state um from upstate to down state but it was good to be able to to see some new colleagues and meet colleagues that you hadn't talked to in a while thank you do we have any visitor comments no okay

037that moves us forward to our reports we have our transportation report good evening again everyone um tonight uh uh it'll be nice to be able to show you a little bit what our Department's doing the main focus of tonight's report will be based around our electric uh school buses uh we are one of if not the leader in the state so it's definitely wanted to give you some information where we're at and and where we're going with that uh but before we get there just a little a couple quick slides this is our team uh we have 80 driver positions 11 openings uh four people are training two of those are our attendants which is nice uh so we are fully sta in attendance but hopefully after tomorrow we aren't uh because one of them's

038taking their road test tomorrow uh and so is someone that's not an attendance so hopefully in the next week or two we get four more drivers on our mechanic staff is fully uh staffed at six and then there's five office staff members including myself we do uh 391 uh trips a day um that includes everything uh one of the nice things about Gage chai I just had someone come in today that is looking to come to Gates to be a driver and one of the things I always tell them every year is it's so nice that we do every student in house we don't contract out anybody it's great so when a driver needs support if we can't give it our people's service department helps us and it's just really nice that we can give

039the drivers everything that they need to be able to transport the students I wanted to blow up the map a little bit bigger uh something I get all the time so I don't know if you do is but why is gay CH over on this side of the city why is gay ch's bus over here every purple building is somewhere we go every day so we have seven buildings in house and out of our 391 trips we go all over uh being 15 miles uh near almost every charter school if a parent wants to go there we transport to them our special ed Department those are all the buildings that we go to um they might fluctuate daily a little bit if a program changes but those are the buildings that we transport to and

040when you look at it like that it sometimes it's like oh is they're all over uh so to do that we have I would say the best Fleet in the state um we have our current Fleet is 87 buses uh after we get our delivery that we our finish our delivery from last year we'll have 15 electric buses those are the ones that a little hard to see but they're highlighted in green um and then looking into next year we're looking to purchase 14 new buses those will be diesel uh We've pretty much maxed out right now at this point our grants and we are looking to downsize our by two buses we do track data every year monitor our trips monitor our students monitor our Fleet and we have uh come to the conclusion

041that we can downsize our Fleet which will help save uh an overall maintenance cost um oh nice thing too is we will be auctioning those so like a lot of times you'll see uh when we purchase new buses we say those are trade prices unless we can get a better price this will give us really good information on what's a good value out there for our trades coming in next year so it will definitely help us uh hopefully get a better price uh being the leader in electric school buses after we get our 15 uh total buses we have five on the road right now we took delivery of two of the for um two of the 10 that we bought last year already uh and once we get our chargers we'll have the rest

042uh delivered we'll have 177% of our Fleet electric school buses so it's definitely a huge undertaking it's our mechanics our drivers our maintenance staff our admin our board everyone to be able to do that that's a huge accomplishment I don't know another District that will have that many electric buses already uh taking advantage of everything that we've been able to do uh with that we were just awarded uh from the Greater Rochester Clean Cities uh the leadership award you wanted me to bring the prop it's a little better the show had to bring the prop um it is a nice award up uh we were sitting there wondering what it was going to be like but it's very nice award um uh and we were recognized for our transition to Electric school buses in the

043community uh we're able to take advantage of some more funding we were just awarded in December uh the other half of the grant uh we finished our we didn't finish our plan yet but because we're so far ahead the state gave us the infrastructure Grant uh to be able to purchase those Chargers to get our buses on the road faster uh we're also looking to have extra money in there to set us up for the future so there's no extra cost on uh infrastructure bringing in power be uh being a leader comes with challenges um so one of the things I want to say is something we found out is you hear it you still see it on commercials now is that off peak charging everyone you know everyone you can charge it lat at

044night that really doesn't exist until you hit certain they call them tariffs I know it's kind of a weird word but it's a fee uh and the way it works is if you use a certain amount of power within 30 minutes that's how they determine what rate you go to it's not how much power you use in the month they base it off 30 minutes uh and then what they all do is put you in it and I've learned a lot about Electric in the last year and pretty much we're right in the middle right now we're past the the 100 kilowatts an hour and we're under the 300 so there's only one more rate that we can go above and that wouldn't be until we had a lot of buses on the road and

045they everyone involved is working on it so our current infrastructure and that rate structure does not allow a really good plan for school districts and that's really what we've been working on with everybody uh they're hoping to have a school specific tariff they call it by the end of this year um so to put a little timeline in that we had our buses on the road in 2022 it took until May 23 for RG to determine how to even bill us right so that was our first wow this is how this works right it took that long that started working with we started working with Nera right away showing them what's happening how things are working and we had our new Chargers installed in 24 of January those Chargers gave us a lot more capability

046they were going to allow us to charge this bus at this time this bused this time and really try to spread out the power with that in April ourg determined we still hit that next rate structure so that's when we started advocating right away we were able to get a 50% rebate on our demand charges to offset that no one wants to penalize you for being first so they're trying to work with us on that um so that's why I kind of wanted to there's so many rumors that are flying out there I kind of wanted to throw out how that um rate structure works and where we've been on the timeline with all of that the nice thing is these are all the people we've been working with um so being first and being

047the leader it's really nice I don't think many directors of Transportation have the head of Public Service Commission cell phone right so like they were calling me I'm calling them part of that grant that we were awarded was based off of numbers that we gave the state and a lot of people will benefit from what we've done here um RG bus manufacturers uh assembly member Sarah Clark came out uh she's someone that's been working with the state on this quite a bit she came and met with Chris Mitch and I um so everyone's working together to uh get to where we need to be um going to that lunch for the leadership award they were beautiful building they had the new uh geothermal it was a little cold in some areas right so being the

048leader just because you have it doesn't mean there's not bugs and stuff so you know we're working on all of that so some key takeaways we started this before there was any mandate out there uh we Mitch and I uh met with our bus manufacturers and we started this before there was ever any talk when we got our first two buses the state only had enough money to buy 10 so that's where we started to where we are now so being the early adopter I mentioned all the great benefits having those connections and having people trying to work with us and and really care to make sure this takes off is a is a nice thing uh that we have uh and then just willing to work through all these in a a fiscal way

049so we got the rebate uh we've been working with um like I said this year the Public Service Commission hopes to have that new rate and really they're basing it all off of our numbers and how we're doing any questions great job thank you so much all right next we have our student ex officio update good evening um today I'm actually going to start off with the Middle School um in the past few months the middle school has hosted a very successful fundraiser for the winter and they raised over $1,700 with their jingle jars fundraiser and the student council is also collaborating with the school nutrition team to host a food show on February 5th where students will be sampling possible additions to their school menu and at the high school it's been a great

050addition to see the new fax rooms and in addition there's been a bunch of new murals across the high school painted by the peer leadership team and for the district as a whole I'm actually going to be representing the gate shal Central je school district and the Monro County Schoolboard association's legislative breakfast this Saturday I'll be presenting about gate shilai security and safety with the goal of promoting increased funding streams for districts to use for their security infrastructure thank you thanks Lucas I'll see you on Saturday uh next we have our Capital project update can you present by yourself what was that I know he didn't wear a suit today all right good evening everyone uh it's been six weeks since our last update so a lot has happened and we've been very busy with

051the capital project as Dr ball had already mentioned uh We've turned over a couple more spaces so we'll see a couple photo of those tonight and talk about them our general contractor we completed the district office move we have we are ongoing punch list in this space so punch list is when the architect and the engineer walk through the space they create a list of deficiencies that is then distributed to the contractor and they need to correct all of these items prior to their final payment so the general contractor for phase one is completing those items in the district office as well as in the fact space since our last meeting before we turned over the space they did complete the casework in that space so the cabinets as well as the countertops uh we'll

052see some photos of those they came out very nice uh shortly uh the High School Technology space the steel is up and the roof metal is in uh we're waiting for a little bit warmer weather to put the roof material down to air uh to dry that space in and the Middle School Technology uh drywall finishing is complete as well as uh some of the ceiling paint in the classrooms and then we've started the wall tiling for that space and we'll see a couple photos of that as well Plumbing wise the sinks are all in the fact space again that space has turned over kids moved in on Monday There's a small mishap uh with a waterline busting and soaking a brand new classroom but that was cleaned up and taken care of uh High

053School Technology the roof drains are in for the roof that was just installed and then the high school or the Middle School Technology the domestic water lines for those classrooms are all finished overhead mechanically uh punch list in district office and fax as well uh continued High School Technology duckor Ruffin so in the two classrooms that already uh existing they've continued to run duct work for that space uh in preparation of being painted the Middle School Technology continued rough in as well the new uh unit heater cabinet units have been uh installed in those classrooms that feed the duct work for each classroom uh those rooms rooms don't have a large unit on the roof they all are served by a small unit in the space and then the Middle School Technology for the wood

054shop space the dust collector doct work is being installed electrically again punch list in district office and fax Middle School Technology the lighting in the classrooms has been installed and then the High School Technology they're continuing to pull wire and uh install conduit for that space we've started phase two the last meeting we had we awarding those contracts uh it's minor item so far but the site workk cont contractor has started the preparation of the temporary conditions at Florence brasser as well as the Middle School Fields if you came in today uh off Buffalo Road you may have noticed the chain link fence fence that's up and the large number of equipment that is over there uh we're starting that a little bit ahead of schedule uh that they want to be pretty aggressive with

055these fields um so our goal is to turn those over by October um General trades similar to the en forence Florence brasser temporary walls have been installed in the uh to block off where the main office will be going and then the minor abatement of those two rooms and then the mechanical electrical and plumbing contractors they have done some minor uh demolition work in the new main office space so a schedule for February 20125 High School Technology this has been on the list a couple times but poor the concrete slab we've been fighting weather for a long time now that the roof is up uh when the weather turns will be able to pour that slab as I mentioned previously Roofing of the uh new new three rooms and then mechanical electrical and plumbing installations

056will be ongoing and then finally we' like to start getting some doors and windows into that space Middle School Technology art and health finishing all of the drywall and all of the painting continued me installation so we're talking about final finishes once uh the overheads have been painted and then hallway wall tiling and painting and then finally flooring throughout the space the tech rooms get an epoxy resin flooring and then the couple other rooms have uh VCT Tile for phase two Florence brasser uh large scale demolition of where the new main office will be going in uh what it used to be off of door 11 will still be door 11 and then abatement of the new otpt area that is in the back of the building where the current gym storage is and then

057the middle school as I mentioned before preparation for the large uh undertaking of the fields budget uh phase one 20 million this uh value has not changed uh since putting this presentation together we have processed a couple more payment applic we're now at 63% build by contractors for phase one uh phase two contracts did increase uh in this value uh we have a proposal in front of you all for an award for the musco lighting later on today's meeting and then our contingency dollars is 2 Milli 65257 and we're holding to 570,000 in allowances between the two phases some photos uh the last meeting the district office was nearing completion this is the uh fully carpeted new front lobby this is a photo of the fax kitchen space with all the appliances the you'll notice

058a TV over the middle teaching Island that is a downfacing camera so that the teacher can display to all the students what is happening another shot you can see the TV on in that uh this is the new wood delivery space for the High School Technology this is a shot of the inside of one of the what will be one of the wood shop rooms for the High School Technology and then in between the two wood shop rooms there's uh what's called a finishing room for where they will do all the stains and painting of the wood so there'll be speal special ventilation for this space uh this is a curved hallway in the middle school this is in the technology space uh everything that you see in white will end up being uh tiled

059uh this will be a display case when the space is complete in the middle school this will be for the art room and then a planter box outside of the a what will be the AIS room and finally a general photo of the Florence BL Florence brasser room emptied any questions thank you so much thank you all right now we have our 2025 26 budget update good evening superintendent daily president coffee vice president Richards and the Board of Education thank you for having me I'm here to present an update to the board on the planning of the 2025 budget so our agenda includes um this evening specifically Revenue estimates um what vote propositions we anticipate will be on the ballot um Board of Education Election information positions available um and then next steps so in

060terms of Revenue estimates um in our current year the majority of our Revenue comes from Taxation and state aid and that's the same and consistent for nearly all 700 districts across New York State um and then there's some smaller items we get sales tax from Monroe County we use fund balance and reserves to help balance our budget that's kind of that our our little relief valve at the end of the budgeting process and then other revenues that are much smaller in turn in including interest earnings which we've done a very fantastic job of over the last two years um we have the highest um investment score in the state um for individuals that use the Investment Group that we use um payments in Le of taxes Medicaid fees and tuition um so in terms of

061the current state aid um our adopted budget is $55 million a little above that and we're on track and in good shape so I want to talk a little bit about Foundation Aid um there's a big change that could potentially be coming to the way that schools are funded in New York state um and it's specific to one of the metrics within the formula that the state uses to Aid schools so one of the things that um occurred last year was the governor governor hok indicated that as part of the approved budget she wanted to see a provision in there that would include a full study of the foundation Aid formula there are many groups um that have asked for a better method of calculating this Foundation Aid what is foundation Aid Foundation Aid is

062our major um formula driven Aid there's different types of Aid one is um expense driven Aid so things like transport ation we get um funds back in the following year on Transportation costs um things done at bosis we get Aid back in the following year at things done in bosis um building you you heard a little bit about that with capital projects tonight we get building Aid on Capital work that we do um the other type of Aid is that formula driven Aid our largest formula in New York state for Aid to schools is called the foundation Aid formula and so the Rockefeller study looked at this Foundation Aid formula and provided um a whole bunch of recommendations and how did they get there they collected feedback from stakeholder groups um they did surveys they

063met with uh education Finance leaders and advocacy organizations and I know that many of the people in this room have been a part of that including myself and Mr Dy um in terms of advocating for changes to this formula because there were some components of it that frankly were inequitable and they were certainly not helping Gage child ey Central School District so through that process and that study it was a year-long process on in December um they released a report that um gave about 30 recommendations for adjustments to the foundation Aid formula um right now um in the current funding model the way Foundation Aid works right now is that there's really two measures of poverty that they use in order to calculate Foundation Aid they look at a lot of things they look at

064our number of students they look at even the density of our population they look at the wealth of our population they look at uh students with disabilities and give us a greater um amount of money for those kids English language Learners so they look at a whole bunch of demographics and things that are specific to our district in atus one of the big factors that they use is census poverty currently um census poverty is an issue um for us because they're using data from the year 2000 and so they literally have not updated uh the poverty indicator for the calculation of Aid to The District in a quarter Century that's a long time ago and we know that our population here in Gage Chilai has changed dramatically over the last 24 25 years and so

065we have been advocating for a change in that in the way that that's calculated in addition to that they use free and reduced lunch percentages um in many cases um that's problematic um for cultural reasons um language barriers to people filling out applications um there's all kinds of reasons why having people have to fill out an application in order for it to be calculated for our Aid is a problem in addition to that um we are currently C what C that's that free School meals program um under the current methodology they look at this data and they say you know how many of people do you have filled out these applications well people aren't going to fill those applications out if their kids are getting free meals there's no incentive to fill them out because

066you're going to get the free meal anyway and so in some ways we're being disincentivized um to be in the free meals program and I can tell you that there's some other districts in Monroe County specifically and across the state who didn't enter the free meals program specifically because they know that they see a drop in Foundation Aid when they enter into that program and that's been demonstrated over and over again it didn't stop us but it did stop some other um districts in the state and so that's also not a good indicator for how you fund education especially when you have equity in mind which is what the governor is helping to support and so in the new model under the Rockefeller study um they're using something called sape Data until December I hadn't

067heard of sap um so this was new to me too is um sape is the small area income and poverty estimate and so again this is a recommendation from the Rockefeller study that they use this instead it's calculated by the US Census Bureau every single year and it provides estimate of income and poverty um they use data like tax returns and they use a whole bunch of data to say based on your population of five to seveny olds how many of those students are in poverty and then they assign you a percentage and so again um it's a different way to calculate poverty in a community and um that's what is in the rockfeller study the good news is is that the governor um Wanted responsible improvements to the foundation Aid formula and this was

068absolutely one of the things that she included in um the calculation of foundation aid for her executive proposal that I'll share in a minute the three main initiatives um via the governor right now are free meals for all kids um so to offset whatever um Federal reimbursements come in for school districts regardless of the community's capacities to support um free meals or not free meals saying that all kids should eat free meals in New York state um a ban on cell phones um we don't have a lot of data on what that looks like there's still a lot to understand about what that could potentially mean and then to remedy this Foundation Aid formula that was a big push of the governor's um with an increase to school aid a total of $37 billion not

069that's not the increased amount that the total funding amount to education in New York so what does this mean for Gat shilai a record increase in Foundation Aid 16 plus percent which is incredible when you think about it and it's also um further evidence to us and a justification and you know we feel good to see this information through the governor's proposal because we've been saying this all along we've been saying that it's not a good way to calculate this that it's not reflective of our community need and so this is good news for the district it would mean if this goes through over $5 million increase in Foundation Aid which would certainly help us do some of the important work that we know that we need to do to provide an equitable education for

070our students and we're absolutely um having conversations about what are the things that we could support if we did get this increase of money acknowledging that you'll see in a minute that we are um utilizing fund balance and reserves what are the ways that we can target areas that we know um we could be doing better in and so um in addition to that um just wanted to share that we're going to be running two concurrent budgets one where we get the money and one where we don't so we have to develop two budgets one where we get the full 16 plus perc and one where we get the typical 2% increase in Aid so in the governor's proposal specific ly um you can see that there's that increase of $5.2 million in Foundation Aid

071in addition to that the bosis aid we've been working very hard to push expenses to bosis because we know when we purchase things through bosis we get about 70 cents back on every dollar we spend there um building Aid is not a drop I'll share another slide in a moment excess cost Aid those are um cost for students with disabilities and then Transportation Aid is up as well because again we're trying to push things um through the transportation Aid category when they're spent on Transportation so that we can get Aid back in those areas one of those drivers is um certainly um energy costs have gone up so in terms of that debt service number although we would see an increase in building Aid of about $1.3 million we do have additional payments so this

072is when we talk about balancing those mortgage payments on Capital work like we talked about a little earlier with the aid that's coming in although we'd see um $1.3 million in additional Aid we're also going to have about 1.2 plus million dollars in additional cost in terms of principle and interest and the way that we're we're balancing that in our budget in a responsible way is that we're getting in more Aid than we're going to be paying for those Debt Service principal and interest payments for construction work so although the AIDS up um quite a bit um there's a portion of that's being used specifically um to pay those Debt Service principal and interest payments so final thoughts are sap is is a huge win for Gates shy Central School District if it goes through

073and again this is a Governor's proposal um the foundation Aid increase puts us um I was able to connect with the president of the association of school business officials down in Albany and um was able to get some data sets and do some side-by-side comparison and after looking at our increase it's the seventh largest increase percentage wise in the state um so very good news for the district and also again indicative of the reality that for years when thinking about an equity based formula we've been underfunded and so now this is an acknowledgement of that and an opportunity for us to continue doing some of the great work we've been doing um as a district building Aid is increasing um and transportate increas is good as well as um cost shifting devotes in terms of

074the tax levy limit it's um capped at 2% as a base and last year the CPI the Consumer Price Index on average was 2.9% and so we start at 2% that's the that's the starting Mark if it was CP was less than 2% we would be capped at that lower number uh our tax based growth FL factor for last for this sorry for last year is flat um the tax levy limits due March 1st but there's still a number of factors that we don't have enough information in order to calculate it yet um do anticipate in an upcoming board meeting that we would have that prior to that March 1st deadline other revenues we have Monroe County sales tax um facilities use continuing education and fees is a smaller portion um we we get reimbursement

075for Medicaid um right now if you've been paying attention to the news this was a late ad to the slide uh federal funds are uncertain because of things happening in Washington and so we're hoping to be able to unpack that stuff soon with more releases from various organizations to see if there will be any impact on our budgeting process for next year all other areas of Revenue would remain stable so I mentioned this earlier we are um Reliant to some degree on our fund balance and Reserve use most districts across New York state are leveraging fund balance and res reserves to help balance their budgets um right now we're using 5.9 million um we would look to reduce our Reliance on that if funds do come our way so a portion of those funds we

076would hope to be to use to reduce that dependency so overall takeaway is it's very promising but we don't want to count the chickens till they're hatched so um you know we are cautiously optimistic and hoping that everything turns out the way it should um frankly in terms of equity for our district in terms of the vote propositions uh we would have the budget approval um a bus purchase proposition and one that we're um starting to discuss is a potential capital reserve for future work acknowledging that as you heard earlier there's a whole lot of work that still needs to be done in the district and right now we're at a point where we're trying to um bring our buildings up to standards just from an infrastructure perspective noting that our buildings of our similar

077many of our buildings are are similar vintage and so we're starting to have some of the same problems in those buildings we know that programmatically um we're going to have spaces that need to be updated as well um so we would be looking to start saving up some money for future investment in um programmatic and instructional areas uh three board seats are available each with a three-year term I'm going out to June 30th 2028 inspir expiring seats include those held by Frank Moscato Dr Christine Brown Richards and Tanya sanowski petitions will be available on March 1st 2025 with the district clerk next steps um we're going to continue collecting information for the tax cap calculation we're going to await final state aid allocations acknowledging that hopefully there's an ontime budget that would come on April

0781st and then we would get some numbers soon thereafter um so again we're going to be doing a lot of planning um districtwide to refine our expenditure budget we have budget ambassadors coming up in March um so there's a lot of things um moving right now in terms of the budget process this is the budget calendar and timeline I did mention a few of those things that are coming up with the vote being on May 20th in the Spartan field house if there's any questions please email Communications gat ch.org any questions from the board any question job thank thank you have a great evening you as well all right that moves us on to the consensus item agenda can I have a motion to approve the consensus agenda what thank you though I appreciate it

079can I have a motion to approve the consensus this agenda Dr Richards Miss Davis any discussion all in favor okay the vote is unanimous let's move us on to our motion to approve consensus items C through H can I have a motion Miss K miss littlewood any discussion all in favor vot is unanimous this moves us on to action items can I have a motion to approve the gates chai High School HBCU visits Washington DC in Maryland March 10th through 12 2025 can I have a motion Dr Richards Miss Jennings any discussion all in favor the vote is unanimous be it resolved that the board approves the following 10-year appointments at the January 28th 2025 meeting meeting as recommended by the superintendent of schools Christine smen in the tenure area of special education and canala

080Rollins the tenure area of assistant principal may I have a motion to approve Miss littlewood second Mr manowski any discussion all in favor vote is unanimous I can I have a motion to approve the contract number 208 Athletic Field lighting bid to musco lighting can I have a motion Dr Richards uh miss littlewood any discussion all in favor vote is unanimous can I have a motion to approve the addendum to the 20 2008 2013 agreement with Richard Stein can I have a motion Miss littlewood second uh Miss Davis any discussion all in favor the vote is unanimous that moves us forward to their superintendent comments an important calendar reminder we are closed to honor the Lunar New Year uh tomorrow thought to have originated in ancient China around 3,500 years ago is one of the

081most important holidays in Chinese culture marking the end of winter and the beginning of the new year 2025 marks the year of the snake and in Chinese culture the snake is a creature of wisdom mystery and transformation as shared earlier in our presentations our fa students started the new semester in their beautiful new spaces this week as you heard during the capital project update tonight our fa spaces are complete and ready for use and a reminder to our community we're about one week week away from the vote on our proposed Capital project Future Ready the vote will take place on Wednesday February 5th from 6:30 a.m. to 8:30 p.m. at our Spartan Fieldhouse at Gates Char high school as you heard tonight during the public hearing the project will address critical infrastructure and mechanical needs

082across our district these improvements will ensure schools remain safe and envir and efficient environments for our students and staff and it's important to stress that this project will have no additional tax impact on our community and for those who don't know Bing is your Neo our community has two opportunities to help raise funds and have fun while playing b n goo this week on Thursday Neil Armstrong we host their bingo night in the Armstrong cafeteria beginning at 5:30 then on Friday night I will be one of the celebrity callers at Walt Disney's Bingo night from 5:30 both events benefit the respective pto's yes I am the least celebrity person there uh and perhap perhaps you have seen these events advertised on none other than parents Square we continue to see growth among our amongst our

083parents and Guardians and students this month we saw an increase in student use of parent Square student component student Square students can activate and access their student Square accounts through class link to stay connected with their athletic coaches and Club advisers and then we had an exciting bit of news this week that relates to our facilities our Spartan Fieldhouse is now equipped with a huge video screen the screen was installed last week and the final result is phenomenal this screen will be a game changer for IND District events like conference St and of course our high school graduation and finally we held our second meeting of the district Equity team this week we had solid attends from our staff students and parents Guardians during the meeting we introduced Mrs Carter as our new director and

084had a zoom session with Dr Malik muhammd sharing the progress we are making and the work being done we're excited to welcome him back in person at our next conference St this March and again this Saturday Lucas will be representing us and presenting to the whole group at the Monro County School Board association's legislative breakfast um I've seen the presentation Lucas has done a great job putting together and we're excited for him to share great things going on here in our district and have a chance to uh work with our legislators to advocate for Gates trii that is my report ma'am thank you sir can I have a motion to adjin the meeting Miss Jennings Dr Richards any discussion sorry Mr long I'll have you third the motion all right all in favor the vote

085is unanimous the meeting is adjourned thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.