CorpusRecord 61887

Highland CSD Board of Education Meeting 2-11-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Highland CSD (HCSD)
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Ulster County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,058 words · about 67 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone we'll open the meeting please rise for the pledge plge Al to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all okay I'll open the meeting up to public comment uh front end public comment is for agenda items only so if anyone has any comments regarding the agenda please stand state your name and you can ask a question um just coming up tonight let the board know um it's been obviously a lot of conversation in the state of New York regarding cell phones and I know that's an agenda item tonight um just this past week myself Corey and Dr squirrel were going to head down to Terry tone town as nice is unveiling their cell phone

002policy and their cell phone plan or initiative obviously it got cancelled due to Thursday's weather and postponed until March so I don't know what their stance is going to be at this point but I do believe it's going to align something very close to what the governor as they're lobbying the governor to post a what seems to be a bell-to-bell ban of cell phones across the state of New York um many of my constituents and districts surrounding me that have already gone into cell phone policies have remarked back that they're positive and the cafeteria is louder and there is obviously um more engagement in classrooms is what I'm hearing um however at this point in time I'm asking the board I don't know if you have intentions on voting tonight is it possible to delay

003that further back a possible another month to see what the governor is going to put out give our administrator Mr Opitz and this new assistant principal time to settle in because this is going to be an unveiling and it's going to be a process um that I don't know if we're ready for to start tomorrow um so just food for thought at this point if it is at all possible to delay that process so we can provide the support that we need for our principal in unveiling this plan um that would be my only request at this point we'll have that conversation during uh the second reading of the proposed policy okay anybody else for a public comment right we have our special presentations this evening we'll start off with leaders of the pack and

004the elementary school welcome ladies and gentlemen evening um tonight's leader of the pack is Stella Bird come on El [Applause] Stella so Mr White your classroom teacher said Stella has had a great year academic academically Stella shows excellent effort and she is highly motivated to learn new things Stella is reading above grade Stella also loves to write she writes with enthusiasm and has been adding more detail to her assignments Stella has a wonderful and heing personality she shows empathy for her PE and she tries to make others feel better when they are upset Stella is kind and thoughtful and almost always has a smile throughout the day she always offers to help in the classroom Stella enjoys humor and often likes to share jokes with her classmates Stella has all the potential to be a

005leader in the future and she should be very proud of her efforts to become the best she can be as a student and as a person miss bavo your art teacher said Stella is such a polite person she each time that she sees me in the hall she always goes out of her way to greet me Miss Hughes your steam teacher said I have had the pleasure of watching Stella grow from a kindergarten student to a responsible and respectful Fifth Fifth Grader in my time here at Highland Stella has always put her best effort into every project and has met every challenge headon her being a chosen leader of the pack is a well-deserved honor Mrs mcaffrey your music teacher said Stella always comes to music eager to learn she's always participating and always has

006some great insights into what we are discussing discussing she also has is a pleasure to have in chorus as she's consistently making great choices and singing her best great job so Sor there a few more Mrs petrack your Li library teacher said Stella has such an enthusiasm for Learning and is such a bright and inquisitive student I truly enjoy having her in my class Mr Helmer your PE teacher she's said he said Stella is a pleasure to have in physical education class she is always prepared for activity displays a positive attitude and is willing to help her classmates and Mr Smith said you stand out for not just what she does but for who she is okay [Applause] congratulations all right we'll do the first one I got you yeah now we got got the

007paparazzi here tonight [Applause] hey our Middle School good evening everybody I am really excited to um present kayen gainor our seventh grade leader of the pack for the middle school now we had many many amazing things to say about Kaden um Mr donum your English teacher says that Kaden Works diligently inside and outside of the classroom he advocates for himself and is genuinely kind and caring towards others Mrs Deo said Kaden is responsible he has a relaxed easygoing personality he is thoughtful and kind to his peers Mr Pard shared that Kaden is a student who thinks deeply about every question gives his all to every assignment and shows kindness and consideration to every person Mrs near shared that Kaden is a kind funny and hardworking student who has made a lot of academic and social

008growth Kaden puts effort into all academic task and is well liked by teachers and peers Miss Bernette said that Kaden is a kind thoughtful student who is always respectful in class he's a hard worker and always willing to lend a hand he is a worthy recipient of the leader of the pack designation miss besco your math teacher says that Kaden is a fantastic student who always takes takes charge of his learning he never hesitates to ask questions or seek help when needed he is incredibly responsible gets his work done without reminders and treats everyone with kindness and respect his positive attitude and his work ethic make him enjoy to have in class Miss yanki said that Kaden is an awesome student who shows so much excitement in music he brings an interesting information and personal

009experiences to class that make the experience better for every one he's also such a hardworking student making sure that he gets all of his work done Kaden is a pleasure to have in music Miss Ivan shared that Kaden is a very hardworking student he always participates in class asks lots of questions and is a great friend to other students it's been a pleasure having Kaden in class and seeing him flourish as a student Mr well shared that he is an extremely hardworking kind to others and has shown lots of growth in French between quarters one and two and finally I had some things to say about Kaden because I'm lucky to say that I've known Kaden since he was in third grade he was in one of my very first classes when I started at

010Highland we learned how to zoom remote teach together um I had the uni unique opportunity to see kayen transform just from the student to the great brother son and human fous and I'm really proud of you and glad to get to be in your daily life [Applause] that's nice when they smile don't get that from middle school a [Applause] lot good evening everyone uh congratulations Stella and Kaden I'm Your Leader of the pack very proud and look forward to having you guys open in the high school eventually uh this evening would like to present Angelie Cabrera Hill who is a senior here at Highland High School super proud going to share a few blurbs from some of the faculty and staff here at the high school um and wish her the best first off we

011have Miss labach uh her school counselor it has been a joy getting to know angelise over the years she is a very kind and considerate person not to mention focused and determined when it comes to her future goals she is going into nursing and I think she will be an incredible fit for this occupation as she knows how to show empathy and care she is a student I will miss next year because she always has a smile and is always such a positive influence on the building Mr Tatum for English I've loved having angelise in the class this year in public speaking she worked incredibly hard to overcome the nervousness and anxiety that comes with presenting in front of a large group much like we're doing right now her speeches were always heartfelt and genuine

012and she made incredible progress over the semester she is a kind and selfless young woman who will make an amazing nurse she embodies the empathy and compassion that the world so desperately needs right now congratulations Mr Miller who is here in the room tonight uh for social studies I've had the privilege of being angelis's teacher for economics now participation in government she's an incredible and well-rounded young adult Angeles is intelligent hardworking open-minded and overall great student to work with she is an asset to our class both personally and academically she possesses a multitude of strengths that will serve her well as she enters the next chapter of her life and then lastly coach earwood for flag football angelise is a dedicated Natural Born leader she identifies that flag is a growing sport in the community

013and continues to overcome any challenges and obstacles that may come her way she is a team player dedicated to building up her fellow teammates although she although she may be a quiet Observer it doesn't stop her from vocalizing her love for the sport and her teammates on and off the field she is known by myself and her teammates as the mom of the team has a heart of a giant so with that being said I want to congratulate [Applause] angre I asked a pictures okay and she does have some peer support with her that's great [Applause] on behalf of the entire Board of Education of leaders of pack job well done [Applause] congratulations know you have a lot to do tonight as far as homework and getting ready tomorrow there's not going to be a

014snow day tomorrow so not tomorrow or you can leave if you like appreciate coming I know it's private got a little worri I don't like next presentation is going to be our budget development budget season now so we're going to start off with an overview of where we're going with our budget so our business official will G to keep the excitement going Mr Baron is that what I hear keep the smile going here we go going hard act to follow it really is was it's hard it's hard to beat the leaders of the pack we'll give you a leader of the pack award if have to hear the budget SW um so ladies and gentlemen I'll start off by saying before I do the presentation it has been a challenging and rewarding seven months that's

015yes a whole seven months since I've been here at Highland I want to thank you all for your patience and assistance and would like to thank my staff are not here but I'd like to thank them if they're watching this for helping me with the slides otherwise it would been just Exel spret we thank them as well you will you will um I do not know a lot of the students so it took a little while let's start off by saying tonight's presentation will cover the tax levy limit calculation we'll go over the state aid executive Revenue budget we'll talk about the estimated 2526 Revenue we'll talk about the proposed bus referendum and we'll round it out with the budget fining calendar so the tax calculation is now in its 14th year of implementation it

016ensures that the school districts properly tax their residents it is reviewed by the office of state controller to ensure that school districts do not exceed the tax cap and finally it presents a transparent calculation of the tax levy providing the public and school boards with the knowledge they need to make informed decisions there are some key points to know about the tax calculation formula and you can see them on the board I'll go over them one by one number one the tax-based growth factor that is determined by the New York State Department of Taxation that actually increases your tax base calculation this year as you can see it is 1.63 last year when the other school business official was here Lindsay it was 1.015 I'm not saying I brought doom and but that's just what

017happened uh number two pilots pilots are designed to entice business businesses to the area by providing a tax levy discount the next item is the allowable growth factor which is right there on the screen 0.02 that is your actual tax cap that is calculated by the office of State Controller they determine that number and that's what's locked in item number four to highlight in yellow is the capital tax levy for the current year it it's also down at the bottom for the proposed Levy for the current year for the next your net of reserves simply put folks that is your building Aid your buses and your bus's Debt Service that we have to pay excluding our state aid so something that you should know once again that number is excluding our state aid to the

018state aid that we get this is the five-year historical Trend um as you can see in yellow if anybody has ever looked at the budget book or care to look at the financials that yellow number is this year's tax levy base and know it's a little hard to see maybe on the far side of the room 33 m397 254 so let's review the formula let's take a deep breath start at the top it starts with the number that is our tax based Levy 33,39 254 we multiply that by the estimated of the tax based growth factor which I said increases your tax base as you can see that raises it to 30 3 24741 we add back in 2425 pilot payments which is 52,6 59 increasing your base again we exclude the 2425 Debt Service

019otherwise what I said before the building the buses and boses Debt Service that we have to pay excluding U state aid to come up with your new taxable Levy base we multiply that by the office of State control is 2% and we end up with our new base of 32 m179 476 we deduct from there this is just what I do on a daily basis we deduct from there 68,69 which represents 2526 pilot payments that will be occurring coming up you'll notice that it increased from the 52 to the 68 that's that means basically we're going to have more pilot payments as they go out in years finally we add back back in that whopping 1, 7931 194 which is a 2526 Debt Service payment excluding building a that's what we say once you put

020all those numbers together that gives us our new number of 33 milon 903 986 a 2.62 increase from last year or a whopping 864 732 now I just want to point out previously when I me mentioned that the multiply that growth based Factor multiply was 1.63 at the Top If we had used last year's number if everything had stayed flat we probably would have received another $141,000 once again this is those numbers that changed these are the numbers that we do not have control over that impacts our tax levy calculation um last but not least these numbers have been vetted by Bernard Donan we've gone over them one by one I've double checked them crossed under my eyes and cross my tees and that is our tax levy calculation that has to be sent to

021the office of State Controller by March 1st so this will be our number if there are any questions I will move on U you say Capital local debt and Lease expenditures that lease is that that's the uh Bose's lease Bose's lease is included there that's included this year that's start of that lease I park 80 do we know if we are occupying I park 87 this September I don't think that was in the plan I don't so we're paying the first we're paying I think we actually paying the first year lease on that now even though we're not occupying in September we're not occupying in 25 266 well be I think we should be occupying in 2526 okay they've been under construction all year right but this is for this for this year yes and

022do we have a we have the terms of that lease did they get in a a fixed rate increase or did we not know that the details of that off the top of my head I I'll get it for you but I oh it's getting to him no I mean he's got the information that he needs to to come up with our number but all of the details about that lease I don't have so move on to our state aid um the foundation Aid is increasing due to several factors including the consumer price index index CPI your student needs the regional cost index and the Census Data it should be noted that the Census Data originally what the state was using was the Census Data from 2000 and that was hurting a lot of districts

023and now they've brought it up to a reasonable number that's closer to this year some expense based Aid categories are experiencing reductions due to various factors such as changes in and this is a hard word to say out loud AR uh which is your resident weighted average daily attendance you can say that three times and the evaluations by the office of State Controller uh the definitions and explanations for the state aid can be found at his website if you want to go there feel free to if you can't sleep at night that will definitely help you sleep um we'll talk about the executive state aid and we'll start off with Foundation Aid Foundation Aid increased 36900 , 584 it should be noted that the foundation Aid now if we still are held it home harmless

024old harmless that will be our new starting base 15 million bothies increased 129,000 hardware and Technology increased 20,000 software and library books increase 24,000 as I mentioned before there are some expense based AIDs that decline as you can see high cost SL excess cost private excess cost and the biggest one there is the transportation cost went down by 152,000 I have been and my staff have been helping me looking at what are the factors that are contributing to this loss for example on the transportation side that Infamous word our water um decreased that's your resident resident weighted average daily attendance and the office of State evaluation increased so simply put you've got less students sitting in the seats and the state decided that you have more evaluation here in Highland and other school districts so

025they're not going to fund you as much and these are the calculations inside the formula so it's not always about expenses it's about how the state adds things into the formula that will throw your numbers off but isn't ourada is a composite of all the Cy's kids at Bose's It's a combination of things yes but for our in Highland our water sign went down by itself so give you our water for everybody because of our enrollment going yeah each one of us has our own individual our our yeah okay so we went down individually because we did have a decline in enrollment and that does hurt us do we have an idea of Bose Bose enrollment is increasing or decreasing I would imagine it's increasing because they're trying to open up these new facilities specialized

026fa ours has uh remained pretty pretty consistent and we're actually I think increasing slightly the number of students we send I got you thank you so um in regards to bu Aid the building aid number will increase um once we have made some of the submissions for the sa 139 final crost reports and the certificates of substantial completion I could say that for phase one oh I know that the superintendent has signed off on some of those items those will change that number and we'll get increase in building aid for the things that we've been the projects we've been working on so that number will change going forward um the high cost stays the same and in high cost and excess cost we're looking to see if it's stacking or if it has to be

027an increase in the local share so that's been my project this week to try and find out what are the re what are the items that are kind of drivers that are making those increases we then move on to we take those numbers from our the state and we add them to our Revenue that we have we've kept our federal Medicaid Revenue flat I don't see that increasing payments in Le of taxes for 25 26 will go up slightly by 16,000 our other Revenue sources are made up of 250 ,000 in interest $400,000 in Bose seed Surplus $50,000 in Prior year and a new Revenue source that we've tried to start 20,000 which we call fuel fuel oil reimbursement um once we have that we've kept the interfund transfers flat for now I know there

028has been some questions in the past about using some of the fund balance and using some of our reserves but as we look at our expenses we may have to come back and look at that number we added in the fund balance that was approved plus the tax levy to come to our new estimated first round of Revenue of 55 mil to questions comments just curious going back to Bose that was roughly what an 8% increase we're looking in the fiscal year is that typical or is it just because of the new property that's typical an 8% year-over year I I think that it it's not as I think it's it's it's higher than it has been okay it's a concern the superintendent have brought I'm just yeah because I'm looking at you know the

029the amount we're receiving from the state is significantly the percentage is much smaller than an 8% increase we're going year-over-year with Bosey so just curious to how that's tracking one thing that we have to be careful with is and I think in my first few years we started to look at some of the things we were purchasing through bosis and one of the downsides of that is if you don't purchase then you're not getting reimbursement so right expense driven Aid you need to you need to make sure that if you can buy it through bosis buy it through Bose's because you're going to get you're going to get a return in the following year but when we were going through that that struggle um we were we were chopping things out of that so that

030we could make that bottom number make sense for that year so um we haven't added anything back in but we need to start looking at getting back into that into that reimbursement cycle have we broke I mean everything's a different percentage so you know if it was uh the cost of the school tool management system that might have gone up I'm going to make these numbers up because I don't have them in front of me that you know that might have gone up 3% something else might have gone down 2% something else might have gone up 16% so it's hard to say it just depends on what the category is curious what the offset of the reimbursement does to that that number yeah we have been I have looked at line by line in terms

031of both these categories to look at what's the plus and minus is in terms of what the superintendent said what's going up what's going down and they fluctuate depending upon the services provided I can when I finish the analysis I can gladly share that with you if you like so you can just see overall what the increases are and they just range all over the place is that Transportation Aid expense driven as well yes so a loss in that category might make sense if you're buying propane buses I mean aren't they supposed to have a lower uh maintenance point they break down less you're not maintaining them so there is some potential there that efficiency increases expenses might decrease no you do have some that is true you do have expenses that transfer is one

032of the expense driven AIDS in the situation that when I looked into it we have higher expenditures we do have more mileage for the year that we supported it I see however when you have those other variables impacting your calculation like I said in tax levy if you have a smaller tax levy ratio that you're multiplying it by that's going to give you so even though we had higher expenses the other factors that are coming in from the state and the other factors in terms of the our water drove your reimbursement down and this is not normal to any of the school districts that I've seen it's just that it hit High land a little heavier than I thought so once again we're looking into what we can do to make sure that does not

033happen for going for start with giving our local politicians an earful we'll talk about that that's a whole another story um Des yeah on the previous Slide the um executive state aid I know you had said the one uh building Aid may change are we confident in the rest of the numbers or is there potential for them to change as well there the potential for the other numbers to change I'm very confident in the building Aid I've been working with Berard Donan we're looking at when the submissions of the phase one items are being sent in will that drive another million dollars perhaps to that line and that's possible but it also then has the opposite side effect we have to have look at The Debt Service that we're going to pay for those projects

034so it it could balance itself out in terms of the excess cost and high cost I think those are areas that we can look into that can have a change in those numbers but transportation is one that's just a little bit um difficult right now to kind of move to need lot okay and the foundation a is expected to be there that's approved approv that Foundation 8 is not going to change okay you'll wake up tomorrow will be the 13 million4 0799 some of the high cost too is if we bring back students from out of District placements or or if they graduated or if they went to a bosis rather than a private so that can affect some of those and those are all fluctuating items and we're looking into that what posing thank

035you you're welcome so um we'll move on we'll get to the end of the presentation the proposed bus referendum we have Sho 654 buses that we are looking to purchase and a Ford F-150 pickup truck with a plow Pete Miller tells me that's for me to do extra work but I'll work on that and then finally we have our calendar which as you can see January 21st the governor release her executive budget February's meeting is today March 1st is the required due date that we have to send the tax levy calculation to the office of State Controller as I said before it has been reviewed by Bernard Donan it's I'm very that number and then March 18th we'll have our another next board meeting where we'll go over the adjusted revenue and we'll start to

036look at the expense side and finally our next meeting is actually the fourth fourth that's the second that's the second one I apologize there my one correction um and then there is y it's March 4th on there so I took the budget Workshop below that this is our calendar that's on our website that has all of our dates which was approved by the board in terms of what we're planning on doing so if you want me to send this to you again we can I'll make that adjustment for the fourth and if there are no questions I will now go back quietly Desmond on the bus proposition um I know we have to approve that prior to approving our budget because that has to be in one year we we missed that date yes we

037lost it but with the governor's proposal for districts to not be able to buy f fossil fuel buses after 2027 and have to be all electric by 2035 I believe those are the dates wouldn't it be beneficial to us I mean if it falls follows through this and one more year is going to be the last year we're going to be able to buy fossil fuel buses I think this and I think next the next year we' have to really evaluate do we need that extra those extra buses we'd have to look at what I'm getting we're looking at the inventory that we have how old the older buses are and how long they can stay on the road and what type of Maintenance we need on them but you really have to look at

038that that's number one number two do we really believe that this is going to come to foru um no there's a new probably not Administration who may or may not and I'm going to leave it at that we're not going to go there um who may change that idea so I think school districts are right now holding the line with the bud that they're purchasing and then determining where do we go from there so I think Highland has to do the same thing we'll go with these two purchases and once again if we can get that reimbursement for fuel oil back as an additional cost in there then more money talk to Arlington talk to Whoppers if they're not buying EB buses why should little old Highland that's my it's not just buying the buses

039it's also the infrastructure that you have everything around it and we have our own electrical grid we don't want to be the first ones to do it we' rather to see what everybody else does and how it works out what do we Mr Miller Cathy what do we currently have as Reserve buses do we have Reserve buses if if some break down we do have reserved buses yes but they're aged buses no not necessarily our fet is we got a few few buses that are uh hitting into the 10 plus years okay not too many a couple of them are diesels all right um the buses that we're putting in for this year are basically replacements for them for long trip buses um they'll be gasoline they will not be diesel they will not be

040propane um so that we can take longer trips without having to worry about being able to get fuel um so we're looking at it that way um we were advised to continue to buy fossil fuel buses we've also ramped it up a little bit so we have extra buses so if buses do pass away that we have enough buses to continue to move forward so um that's been our goal that's where we are we don't have the power grid we don't have the infrastructure well you're confident right now that possibility that we only have two years left of buying the fossil fuel buses that what we're proposing only two right now is 65 passengers no handicap no smaller subb we're we're going to be okay I think next year we're going to have to look

041at that seriously as the last year in the window what we're going to do and where it's going to go from that point but I gu we my concern if we're going to burden the taxpayers next year with seven buses and only maybe not get an approval for it and not get approval for it do you want us to now take a step back and look to see where we are with our buses and determine if we should add other buses to this proposal I think it's I think it's based like where you're going it's based on dollars spent in this budget year that's where you're going correct well the proposition the referendum the proposition is a is a taxpayer approved so I mean what is the percentage just like Heather said if we have

042to hit them with throw a number out there you know seven buses 1.2 million what if they defeat that then we're well I thought we had a schedule we were following the schedule there's X number of units we bu we are but but with I know you're saying it's not going to happen but if it does happen actually let's back up there's um you know I don't know what the transportation conversations are out and I don't know if anybody in this room does but maybe it's time to talk with a consultant and see what they would advise on what what's going on in New York and make a recommendation I don't want to put it all on Pete I don't want to put it all on me I can tell you from the last Ox

043meeting uh electric buses was one of the items that I brought up to the the uh legislators that were there and I got a pretty strong sense from I think his name is um assemblyman mayor or Mahar that there were going to be changes coming down about that that that schedule um nobody will nobody will give you um a definitive yet but it sure sounded like it and even uh assemblyman Jacobson was uh was was not necessarily in agreement with it but understanding of what districts were saying so one of the points that I brought up was in the Hy Park Central School District in the fall they had a grant for I don't know the exact number but it was in the teens number of buses that uh they could get approved um it

044was a grant for electric buses but they needed voter approval because they needed other things to go with them and that got voted down and so my question to the assemblyman and the senators or the senator that was there uh what happens if the community votes down our buses how do we transport if this mandate stays in place and so I think they listened I think they're taking it back to the state where that's going to land I think we're going to hear more about it during this budget season I think the problem is Z's right if if the deadline doesn't get moved we are two budget Seasons away we're in one of them I hear what you're saying I think just take that back and review it maybe there's a possibility you want add

045another additional bus or something just you don't know where it's going to land we can take it back we can take a look to see where we stand in we it's early on in disc it's early enough to say yes I mean we got hit with a bubble once before and that was difficult and that's why we talked about developing the schedule to smooth these purchases out so you're Bo yeah which they're following do we have do we have a schedule because I know I had asked I believe it was last year before I it was Financial schedule that was created by B Bernie Donan that was based on debt and debt falling off and what what was going to create what our bus purchases was going to be we kind of ran off the

046end of that so we're kind of in limbo a little bit as to where we're going because everybody's up against the 2027 ruling and everybody's being a little bit cautious except that nobody's got enough power nobody's got enough money for infrastructure and the taxpayers don't have enough money for electric buses so um we kind of like I think I kind of where we are right now in this conversation is kind of where I thought we were going to be while we were putting this together so I guess my concern is if we do have that schedule like Mike had alluded to we did at one point have a bubble where is that bubble going to hit us right or have we smoothed it out enough because if that bubble's going to hit us next year

047and then we're also looking at what this potentially could mean I think we got to consider that this year to make sure that we're not putting ourselves excuse me I was just going to say it was like two or three years ago whatever the budget presentation was the schedule was right on and we just got to carry it forward with new purchases shouldn't be difficult I think what Heather's saying is it shouldn't be difficult to update right and I I know when I asked last year the year before I was told that the schedule had ran out and they were looking to refresh it and I don't I haven't seen anything and I don't need to see anything as long as I have confidence that that schedule is there and it exists and you're comfortable

048with if there is a bubble that we're good with Where We Are the discussions were on guidance to get it to to that point that we were doing the right thing at that point in time not that there's anything I think at this point that is factual to that it's one bus two buses three buses whatever I think it's got to be uh analyzed as to where we want to go and how far we want to get into uh because the other the other end of the 2027 issue is 2037 when you can't run them correct okay so we got to look at that yeah yep so I guess when does this this bus referendum have to be it's on the slide 45 days before days 45 days before the ref so I guess I

049would just encourage just take one more look to make sure that we probably got into the meeting first meeting in April to have that approved so what we can do is kind of there's a couple things I'm hearing one um go back and look at that schedule that actually existed it showed the trajectory of when we're going to have the buses kind of meet that bubble and not get to that point number two look at what we want to do going forward um look at the maintenance of our current buses where do we stand and if we do want to create a new list or a new schedule here's what we will do and keep that in mind that we know eventually it will fall off when we have to do the electric buses so

050we can pull this we can pull back and kind of make some more suggestions in the next meeting for February I mean March you know 4th which we could do that or get it to the board ahead of time but that's what I hear is a goal that we want to do and if you agree that' be great if you disagreed please let me know Desmond in regards to the uh ebes What uh how much is in that Reserve fund we have established I don't recall establishing a overall no I thought there was a no we got Capital reserves we've got uh other reserves that we have but I do not see that was one approved by the board for electric buses State support with purchases of the buses what percentage do we get I'm

051not sure about that probably theying something Transportation I mean it doesn't this goes up as a separate referendum so we don't have to worry about I'm anticipating the prices will most likely increase if these steel tariffs we'll look at it from that perspective any other questions or comments good thank you thank you very [Applause] much okay uh we have our uh consent items uh fa1 to c.6 with uh an addendum that's added on it's going under Personnel uh appointments five probationary that'll be added so like you normally do if you have uh any consent item that you want to pull have separate discussion a separate vote you can do that you need anything clarified to shout it out I make a motion to accept the consent agenda second motion by m by Heather everybody okay

052good the way it sits all right have motion on the floor to accept our consent agenda with uh the addendum under Personnel absolutely motion by Mike second by Heather all those in favor opposed any exensions so carried okayy so so this evening uh we do have a couple of our newly appointed uh employees in the room that I'd like to recognize we have Alissa dwit uh in the back there she will be our steam teacher starting at the high school to replace Mr anone uh we also have Julia safone sitting there in the back she'll be teaching at the middle school as a leave replacement replacing uh Mr savelson and our new high school assistant principal Miss Colleen Mullen so congratulations and [Applause] welcome congratulations for okay moving on to our principal report so we'll

053start off with the elementary school um just a few quick additions to my principal's report uh that didn't quite make it because submit things uh Friday the interact Club from the high school came down we had a tremendous amount of interact kids that came down um and made Valentine's cards for our veterans part of Pat Ryan's um program so this is the third year we're participating in that um we had well over 200 uh cards made the other day so um and they got sent over to office um and you know I just want to give a huge shout out to uh Amelia dorno she did a phenomenal job organizing getting everyone scheduled um it it flowed really well so hats off there she did job and the only other thing was is this big

054news also this really awesome is that we have currently 50 packets out for kindergarten so is good number at this time in the year that's that's good enough any questions for thank you very much Andy all right uh just two quick additions the first one um was last Friday of the 7th we did a wear red for um heart uh heart health awareness yes thank you heart health heart health awareness month so one of our teachers actually miss Ivans helped organize that um for the staff and students so although we had a snow day the day before which is usually when we push that out um we still had really a lot of people who participated in war red second time during the month where we wore red which was cool um so that was

055that was great so thank thank you for Miss Ivans for really pushing that and the students have participated um the other one was um Dr Harris who last year was on a sabatical sorts uh in South America uh presented to our staff during the three uh staff launch periods in our conference room kind of some different things that she did uh during her year in Ecuador so that was really cool we all got to she made food for for us um she had a slideshow that kept running of all the pictures and things that she did and she was there to kind of answer questions and talk to staff about um the the the work that she did when she was there um so she's done that with students in different ways to her students

056but it was really cool for us to staff to see kind of what she did during her year um Dr Harris so um so yeah that that was my addition to my my any questions thank you Andy you're very well good evening everybody I do have three brief additions uh the first one I'll share with you um last week we had FBI uh Intel analyst uh working with our new health and visette teacher Noel Randol um her name was Odessa Sims uh she came in to speak about Internet safety digital footprint um digital literacy and things of that nature she is currently um you know still active with the FBI uh so we are happy to have that partnership uh students across the A and B days were able to um you know meet with

057her ask questions and learn a little bit more about um you know digital uh awareness and safety uh additionally today we had Deputy Tui here with the Ula County Sheriff's Office uh who brought in K9 Cody who Mr frier had the chance to meet today uh Cody is a therapy dog and today we kind of collect collaborated with our Taste of success program and our student Capone projects with Miss sailor's class uh so our senior Lauren uh Santiago um set up the connection and we brought um you know her in to present to our students and it was a good uh it was a good day and um you know Lauren is going to be talking more about it at the Civic showcase uh in April and then lastly just before I came into the

058meeting I have one late edition um Mr Tatum mentioned to me that he just received word that cam adoma uh just got a piece of writing from his last year's College comp one class uh it just got published in new pulses new voices New Visions student work Anthology awesome so we're happy to hear that and additionally uh cam will be taking part in our staff PD development um where he'll be presenting a workshop alongside some other teachers uh this Friday for professional development does the board have any questions thank you thank you thank you okay we have our directors here this evening again I'm going to ask the question anybody have any questions for our directors for the fifth month in a row they're doing an excellent job they are thank you I did tell

059Mr fiser great website I really like the new look and feel of the new website and know there's a lot of work behind that so uh that look good and so does the completed um stand outside just came together nice Mr fer showed us some pictures of the Husky that was put on there from front facing because we see the side from the parking lot but it's really coming along back there so yeah looks good good thank you okay uh our student rep okay so the elementary school sorry can you pass this down has inre participation in the be a friend project which is a letter writing campaign to support kids being bullied um the be a friend project builds empathy in communities and offers peer support to students across the country which stops bullying

060before it starts um this month participation has increased to 12 classrooms one related service provider and a Highland Girl Scout Troop there are nearly 200 letters pictures and cards of support for this month ver of kaani K tayia I'm sorry I mispronounced your name um in the middle school spirit week is taking place this week highlighting all the things that are Love by students in staff themes include school spirit being cozy Sports scams friendship and the colors red and pink for Valentine's Day everyone is excited to represent their favorite things school days um sixth grader Chief Wang was selected by the olster prevention Council as a winner of the 2024 youth media contest in the foreign language category the youth media contest is an art competition students created their own original pieces that highlighted the

061negative effects of vaping marijuana and or alcohol on the teenage brain or provided examples of healthy alternatives to substance abuse Chief was chosen out of many other entries andly the users of talent at the middle school um the Highland Middle School Snowball Dance will take place on Friday February 21st at 6m the dance will be hosted by the middle school PTA and the students are very excited to show up and show out for this little dance the Last Dance was success and to continue this at the high school two weeks ago on Saturday February 1st the Science Olympiad Club went to a tournament at John J High School stem teachers Mr Moore and Mr Ayan Zone helped the club medal winning eighth place out of 36 teams that attended the students in the categories air

062trajectory one 16 helicopter 15th and ecology one second um this Friday the high school's Bandon chorus are putting on a Black History Month concert the theme is Summer of Soul Harlem in 1969 guest singer Ronda Den is coming up from the city to perform with the music department the Jazz and percussion Ensemble will be performing and the choir will be singing the song Stand Up from L Harriet also on Friday after the concert is the vi Cultura celebration run by students Emily Alan and Kelly Flores for the CIA project it will be a pep rally with Latin them games and prizes the cafeteria will be serving a special breakfast including Orange churos cornbread hot chocolate and Meo yogurt it'll be a big celebration of Latino culture um Mrs Otis the Spanish teacher did Valentine's for

063veterans after school on January 27th which was already mentioned um oh no sorry not this one wasn't already mentioned with the sophomores including afine AER Gavin Decker nickol neelson Susan slovich and P bllo these students designed and created cards for veterans in hon Valley and last Friday continuing the trend Mrs Pia's interact Club visited the elementary school more cards with the kids the kind messages and drawings from the students will help right in the day for the heroes in our community that's all any questions I don't have a question I just want to punctuate the comment about the be a friend project I've had the pleasure of being personally involved and I just wanted to say out loud and go on record what a beautiful project it is and I've been so happy to been

064able to help with it as well so I'm glad it was brought up um it's a really wonderful project so I just wanted to punctuate that note anyone else okay moving on um assistant sup for curriculum instructions not here this evening and human resources and pupil Personnel Dr Boyd hi everybody um so each year um before our annual review meetings I meet with all the teachers and review their recommendations and talk about our programs uh which also helps us plan for uh for next year uh so on Friday I met with all of our Middle School teachers today I met with all of our elementary and on Thursday I'll be meeting with all of our high school teachers which will cover us across the district as we plan for next year um we have an

065education stabilization fund monitoring report that we have to do uh so we did one last year uh and this year we have to go back and look at all of our grant spending that we did um during the 2324 school year uh and it's a lot of information uh working with Desmond's office uh to CCT that and put that into different categories on how we spent some of that money uh so we'll be working on that uh and we'll be submitting that by the end of the month um I think I mentioned earlier in the fall oler County set up a traumatic event team um so across all the component districts uh we have individuals um that are part of the team that if there ever is a tragedy at a school district um these

066are team members that we might send uh if needed or will support so uh we we've been meeting monthly on Zoom I just want to highlight um Lisa and Emily Bacher uh from our district who came forward to volunteer uh to be part of that team so we have another meeting this Thursday and again we just find ways uh to help um in a productive way um when these situations come up uh we hope we never have to utilize this team obviously uh but we want to make sure that um we're there to support each other um if it does come about uh and lastly uh we there is a Hudson Valley Educators Consortium uh last Saturday I participated in that there was a workshop held at Maris College they invite all Maris University Maris

067University Excuse me yes you better get that right I know uh held in their new building which is absolutely beautiful um but it's all um all new uh are soon to be teachers uh teachers in training from um Maris Bard news Mount St Mary's Alan everybody across the board uh comes to this um so I was on two different panels one was for uh some new teachers of their first few years and another one was actually for um aspiring administrators uh so it was a great experience to get to meet some of those new folks coming up um and share some stories with them and get to know them as well just give shout out to um the folks who run that um really helping support those new teachers uh with that endeavor any questions

068for Dr Boyd okay superintendent okay so this coming Friday uh we have a halfday professional development we have students in the morning and we have uh professional development scheduled in all three of our buildings in the afternoon um no school this coming Monday for President's Day and believe it or not we are already up to Winter parent teacher conferences so I know those messages are going out to families now to get them to sign up for conferences but on February 27th the high school will host from 5: to 8 on March 3rd the Middle School from 5: to 8 and on uh March 6 the elementary school and then on March 7th we will have the day conferences in the morning and no students will be in session so I wanted to just also put

069on your radar that uh we are gearing up already for music in our schools month which starts uh the beginning of March and our music teachers have been very uh busy getting our students ready for the two scholarship concerts that always turn out to be such great evenings so please put them on your calendar for March 5th our instrumental concert that's the one in the uh the one in the round in the gym uh and then on Wednesday March 12th would be the coral uh concert at the last board meeting I mentioned that I'd be attending uh The Mid Hudson Catskill Council school superintendent in Goan that following Thursday so I went there in the morning and then I went to the oler county school boards associ in the afternoon and the combined between the

070two there was quite a bit of information uh one about Foundation Aid and things of that nature but I think the Highlight for me that day was I mentioned a little bit ago about a meeting with the legislators uh with the school boards Association and topics ranged from uh from all different superintendents but I will say that if anyone I think Mike's uh District might have told him that I spoke a lot because I feel like this is our only opportunity to get those folks that are going back to Albany to take back our concerns so uh increased aid for prek uh we want them to evaluate uh the Civil Service uh requirements because it civil service often um stunts Us in getting people hired because those tests are not offered very often we talked

071about the electric bus mandate uh I made a plug to uh have them talk to uh the retirement system and we hear uh fix tier six well there's a reason why folks aren't going into the profession one of them is the the the amount of time that they have to work they have to get to 62 and the contributions that they make so take a hard look at that was one of the things that we mentioned um school lunch funding so we right now we're under the the the program to have uh free meals for all so I think the governor is on board with that but hopefully uh that doesn't come at the expense of other aspects of our budget so we asked them to take a look at that um we've heard a

072lot about the Rockefeller Institute and their study of the foundation Aid formulas and many districts uh saw slight increases or at least got the safe harmless funds to be in there but believe it or not there are 24 districts across the state one of them being Ronda that saw a major decrease Kingston also saw a decrease so um I actually spoke up on behalf of Ronda out because I don't know that they wanted to be uh um faking that statement but it's it's not right I mean I I of course I want as much money for Highland as possible but olster County kids these are all our kids so one District shouldn't get penalized because another District got a little bit more funding so taking that information back to the state and then just uh

073other other unfunded mandates that are coming down the pike from the state education department through the legislature um as something as simple as every student has to fill out a fasta form that sounds great but that's capital that's time from our guidance counselors taking away from other things that they need to do um so on the surface all those things sound wonderful and this uh assemblyman Jacobson and I have had this conversation for a few years now every time they put another mandate on the school district without providing um some additional funding or additional Staffing it takes away from some of the other things that we're doing and we all know how much we valued mental health here in our district so taking guidance counselors out of the mix so that they can follow up

074with students to make sure that they get that uh fast performant again truly important work but it comes at the expense of other things and then um we also ask them to if the governor is going to do her cell phone policy please get it out get it out quickly so that districts have information that um we can actually work with and not drag you know we heard all last year she was going to come out with something by September and that didn't happen and I think that held us up in making some decisions here locally uh they all said that that is definitely one of their priorities to bring that back um and then just finally off of all of my politicking in the last two weeks uh one of the things that we

075just finished today was the annual or the every other year we have to submit a a huge uh it's a huge report it's the first time I've ever seen it it's the office of civil rights out of Washington DC that we have to submit that data that was a pretty arduous process it started in the fall it's due March 7th our data was cleaned as of today and I submitted it so we are good to go with that I don't know that that data does anything for us um you know I don't know that it gets us any more funding but um we took a hard look at all of those uh those categories and and and tried to give as accurate number as we possibly could and that's all that I have any questions

076thank you Joel thank you okay moving on Board of Education new business uh first reading of our student Officer school board policy uh anyone want to move that to a second reading you have an opportunity to go through it we're ready to move it I read it it seemed pretty straightforward all right Highland Central School dist Board of Education policy number 2370 student officer of Highland Central School District Board of Education be resolve the Board of Education upon a recommendation of the superintendent approve the attached highand Central School District Board of Education policy number 2370 student officer of the Highland Central School District Board of Education as presented to the board at this meeting can I have a motion please motion by Ed second by Janine discussion all those in favor opposed any extensions so

077carried okay both's annual meeting roer has her own policy now is that she does that amounts standing you know I thought we had a policy but we've just had a standing practice for all these years we we talk about this once before but I don't think we we were ahead of we were ahead of the curve on and then when they came out that uh the governor approved it last year the we needed to have a policy in place by July 1st so thank you for doing that so that we're ahead of the game on getting that done okay both these annual meeting and bothies vote both annual meeting scheduled for Thursday August 10th uh August April 10th 6 to do what I do those are some warm thoughts April's not bad though uh the

078B countywide vote is scheduled for Tuesday April 22nd and nominations from component districts for vacancy are du to bothies board clerk by March 21st 2025 and both's board sheet bacon sheet Lisa can you fill us in on that a little bit we got there is our district is not up right so if you want to make any nominations for new puls found out Valley we can do that let vote will be on our March 21st meeting what do you mean like we can I guess we can nominate to somebody want we take those seats if they don't get filled sometimes I mean District usually in the past any two at large seats yes like in the past Highland in which we nominated sumore right we can nominate for the at large seat anybody interested here

079so we should do that on the March 4th meeting March 4th yes Tom put up there I will say that they okay uh old Business review of Board of Education mission statement and District goals I know we've been talking about this um and I know Jennifer put out something at our last meeting I had passed around you know my thoughts that we talked about the last two meetings uh I sent revisions too after the last four meetings and I mean it's probably something we want to finalize and then be able to put it out over the summer on our website for you know the 25 26 school year so sure give it some more thought uh if you want I could send that back out what I sent around the last meeting some things that

080I put together and I kind of read them two meetings ago but let's develop a revised mission statement and our board uh board goals and our district goals all right and then we'll kind of develop that and finalize it and adopt it right away over sum for 25 26 school year okay okay um the last item under old business is our second reading for the student use of personal technology um you know we had a little glitch at the last meeting totally my fault we don't we don't I I take full credit for making that mistake so for the for the for the folks that are watching when I save the draft I unfortunately did not save over top of the other draft and sent the board unfortunately the wrong thing at the last meeting

081so I take complete blame for that so the new policy as yeah it's the new policy but it's one that was out there a month ago it looks great right I have copies if anyone needs copies right now I know there was you know initial public comment uh earlier on regarding um us to put a little pause on developing this policy but I think this is my opinion uh we've been working on this for well over a year um and I I think ARS doesn't have it's not the teeth that if the governor follows through where she's talking about Bell to Bell ours is strictly in the classroom electronic devices their personal electronic devices can be used during study hall during lunch period in the hallway blah blah blah blah uh I I think it

082would be Good's graduated right so Elementary is a little is the strictest Middle School still strict and then the high school that we're allow Middle School pretty much status with them they haven't we haven't changed it in middle school it's been like that for a while uh I think it's it's good to implement it now it'll give our high school administrative team you know some time to move it through uh if the governor does come back and say hey hey it's belto Bell at least the students have couple three four months of this under their belt yeah let me clarify that belto Bell because it is restrictive however I believe the terminology on the governor's proposal says unsanctioned use there's no unsanctioned use in between those periods but I believe a local school board is

083a sanctioning body and I expect that our policy will hold even up to the governor's so I there's some key terminology there that I think because I don't think it around the table we ever talked about no use belt the belt so very restrictive and so I think there's some leeway by adopting this now they will have sanction used during the day well even there's no if we adopt this now there's nothing to say we can't come back and revisit it absolutely and if we want to fall if there is a more strict uh policy that comes about we can we can discuss that and but I think you're right this is a great transitionary moment and I'd love to hear what n has to say as well um but that can come back to

084us with that but just because if we have off this today there's nothing to keep us from changing it down the line we just have to discuss it and meet again so there was something that we talked about helping Administration operationalized this a little bit and it was a penalty schedule that we had talked about now that would be in an admin regulation so we don't need it this evening but I still stand unless you feel differently Tom but I still still stand that part of the difficulty at the high school was the enforcement whatever the rules were right is the enforcement and therefore having a a penalty table attached to this as an adid rag or you know whatever it is helps us Focus so this way admin knows what is very clear the

085public knows what's clear if these if students violate the policy yeah I mean this talk is out there I mean wherever you turned uh you see them talking about you know the the time lost during the educational oh it's overwhelming it's you know I know you had said 10 minutes but I saw an article not too long ago was like 19 minutes lost during the course of a of an instruction period oh trust me I was being conservative the kids Kai knows how much time is lost in class the kids know they so we have our second reading we can uh approve that this evening uh why don't we just you would want to implement this March 1st or whatever that Monday is first Monday in March would be the 3D I believe u what's

086your feeling as far as implementation of the policy is that doable for the beginning of March is there the table in terms of the progression consequences is that in the current policy no there's no consequences in the current policy I like to set up form I think initiate the policy and then give you the opportunity when we develop the uh code of conduct what what the penalties are going to be yeah I think it'll just make it very clearcut what it is this is the step by step and it'll streamline you know any of the hiccups that we may encounter um and it'll just make it for an even smoother transition any violation will fall into the term of insubordination we already if we well yeah that that would yeah if student told several times

087it's in subordination we don't have to wait for the summer if you want to put that table into the current code of conduct bring it back to the board we'll approve this has got to have teeth it's got to be very clear but I also think the students need a transitional period to be able to get acclimated as well as the staff and the administration and the school to be able to support this yeah but I think we're given that that opportunity I mean what Mike is saying is it's going to take the administrative team maybe a month or two to develop what those repercussions are going to be a Prof and then by the time we implement it you're going to be May or June so I think there is this this transition period

088right now if we implement this policy March 3D and then you then the opportunity to develop the repercussions our job is to pass or not the policy polic as it embeds into the institution does it take two weeks two months do they come back and say you know we need more stuff that's the ongoing discussion but policy's policy you know to answer you know your question you know can we make this happen yes we could definitely make it you know happen there's going to be some hiccups you know it's a transitional period for myself uh and Colleen who's jumping on board but you know we're ready to to jump in um the timing isn't the best but we will make it uh happen for sure I yes I I I will say that should this

089policy be passed tonight there's a reasonable time frame that we all will need to I mean for all I know the community doesn't like it and we're in the cafeteria in two weeks and let's see how it goes but I don't think that's going to happen you know there's concerns and objections but I'll tell you what if the governor's policy comes down it's more restrictive than what you have in front of you so I guess that's how I look at crawl walk run right let's start moving I mean this is what we've talked about this is what we've agreed on if what the governor says is coming down is truly what's coming down it's only going to make it more restrictive right so it gives us time to take take steps um everybody wants those

09020 minutes of instruction back every day in every class just a quick observation uh Colleen is probably not going to come on board until about midm March possibly sooner so you're on your own no I wouldn't be nervous about because as J mentioned it's a transitionary period and it's enforcement does fall to you ultimately right so the you can use your empathy and situational awareness to to judge but at least the policy will be uh will disseminate the policy and the terms will be set forth and then you as the the administrator meading the high school will be able to to help help guide the students in that transition and there's a certain amount of bway in which lot of judgment calls but and that's you know the feedback that I've got from other administrator

091specifically Beacon that you know whose policy we're mirroring um you know pretty closely is that they have that table there and it's just it's easy this is it this is your second time this is your third time that's what it is every time and it you know from what I've heard that you know that's made it easy and obviously when Colleen gets on board that's something that we'll look at together I'll throw this out here and it's up up to the board um March 17th be roughly a month from now uh to implement it and hopefully Colleen's on board at that point in time you want to take a look because we meet once before that right on March 4th want to look at perhaps adding on a policy of you know the what being

092talking of conduct conduct policy have some discussion I don't know if we'll implement it on that day but yeah right I mean we yeah we can start discussing and share it at that meeting all right we're good sounds March 17th we'll have hopefully have Colleen on board by then wait who's not coming for St P so so Brandon doesn't have to take the whack by himself we're still meeting on St Patrick's I think he's all right all right um just one one piece of feedback on the wording in the policy and I am my personal device because I forgot to print it out so iify that um so for the middle school for the high school we say that we will permit use uh during non-instructional periods such as study H thank you my place

093here yes such as study hall and lunch and then in the middle school we say we will not allow it during instructional which includes it sounds like it's contradictory I would just suggest for the Middle School saying it's not allowed dur during instructional or non-instructional time because I think that's our intent currently that's your pretty much your your rule down there yeah we're not changing anything the element or the Middle School you just want to change the wording in the high school we say non-instructional time such as study hall but then in the middle school we say instructional time which includes lunch and study hall so one we're saying lunch and study hall is instructional and one we're saying it's non-instructional so I think just for the Middle School to say that we do not

094allow it for instructional or non-instructional know people get a little very nitpicky about wording once there's an issue I like it it's it's all in the details when it comes to this stuff good I can make that change okay our second reading student use of personal technology be resolve the Board of Education upon a recommendation to superintendent proves the attached Highland Central School District Board of Education policy number 7316 student use of personal technology has presented to the board at this meeting we also want to incorporate that uh the policy will take effect on March outstanding can I have a motion please motion by Tom second by Mike any further discussion all those in favor I oppos any extensions so carried thank you anything for the good and Welfare of the district I'll open the

095meeting up to public comment for the uh General item so if anybody want to stand up shout your name out and go ahead I have a question I wanted to follow up on the uh has it been any discussion by the board uh if uh the Department of Education is close on the federal level and possible fiscal implications of that if that does happen which they've been saying they're going to do I think at that point in time from what I've are hearing is it's going to be pushed down to the state level and they're going to make all the call so I don't think it's going to affect us locally at this point in time on on a financial basis I I don't know that we can actually say one way or the other

096I didn't know if there's been any discussion or are Chang things are changing by the day I don't think we can you have to presume legal challenges as well so I don't think within this fiscal year I don't think we're going to see anything thanks anyone else again I just uh I actually have two things and um first thing is I want to thank you for pushing that back to the 17th because I believe our meeting with NI is going to be way before that and I want to make it clear I'm not against the cell phone policy I get my marching orders from nent nice it comes in and says it's a bell to Bell ban I'm going to be coming back on the 17th saying this is what this is what nice it

097is asking this is what you know I'm going to ask you guys to do at that point um so thank you for doing that and also thank you for giving Brandon the time to have his assistant principle there that's going to make a big difference in the school um when it comes to implementing this policy one one person doing that would have been a tough ask and thank you all for seeing that um on a change of note at this point um a culmination of of events happened over the past few weeks to maybe about a month where multiple groups have uh have come up and approached me um our sports groups a lot of our community groups um and also our teachers um and they've they've approached me about the usage of the building

098and the insurance issues that are going on with the building um I told many of them that I would come and speak at the board meeting um and and ask not in a confrontational way that the board look into the insurance issues that are going on with allowing people usage of the building allowing events to occur at the building um allowing teachers to host events in the building that are educational allowing our Sports programs that we've worked hard to build up at this point we have a very strong youth football program youth baseball program youth soccer program is growing youth lacrosse program is doing great and having their access to the building um and even town events that can happen on school property um and it seems like it's being hindered by our current insurance

099company um asking for more and I see it at the sports level what ends up happening is if our sports team will take football Pop Warner for example we'll use a round number it cost $100 to sign a child up for football and to utilize our F the district is going to charge them additional Monies to have insurance that the district needs them to have that gets passed on to the parent that's paying for that I'm not complaining because I think I can afford that but I'm looking to grow the program and I have families that may not be able to afford that that that deters them as they raise that price um so just something to think about as a board um potentially create a subcommittee to look into that to look into risk

100assessments I've been working with uh Desmond on these issues and he's been wonderful with it explaining thees of uh of Insurance to me um and I understand you're between a rock and a hard spot but you know our school is our focal point to our community that's that's Highland's identity and all of our groups need access to this to this facilities to these facilities um and we got to make it as easy as possible for them to utilize it so I I hope that so let me let me understand this correctly inside and outside groups are being denied access be based upon their insur their insurance certificate is not reaching a level that our insurance is required for seems to be correct in in general terms yes uh we've had superintendent and myself had some

101conversation uh several weeks ago about we're bringing it to the board at a future board meeting uh hopefully in the month of March starting the discussion how we're going to allow our our community group groups our in-house groups to utilize all our facilities which now is going to be our turf field our concession stand so we're going to have that conversation in house and and start that kind of develop some type of policy or or rules and regulations with with also with our business official involved in that and we'll see where where lands with insurance I mean we're governed by what the insurance company tells us so our insurance company has increased our premium based upon what the limits required by the outside groups right but I sorry I would think that this is a

102standard policy or procedure compared to other school districts I mean we're not the only School District that has Community member sports teams extracurricular activities who want to come in and use either their buildings or their grounds so why it sounds like from the community members that I've also heard this from that it's tougher for some reason to use Highland than it is to use other school districts so then why is that because I would think it would be a standard policy of what needs to happen for that to take place well something we had expressed before that we wanted the schools to become a hub of the community and so this seems to fly in the face of it uh as far as insurance goes is there any instrument that they can provide like a

103a waivers that people uh I mean if they there has to be some kind of an ins look that this is a big topic it sounded like this was going to be brought to the board um we we'll bring that forward to the board to uh have that discussion and have feedback coming from our business official as far as what the insurance companies are asking and if there is any waivers that could be I I will tell you this is not unheard of a district to our South that I'm familiar with actually created a facility use policy and there's some ratings of inside outside groups a schedule was applied because once you have these wonderful facilities people want to use them all the time and I understand which rightfully so they PID for them it's

104probably a good time to look at facilities use when that is brought to the board what I would just ask for is um I know obviously we're going to be forward looking but I would also just like to understand what has changed right do we have a different insurance company did they change their requirements is it something state is is advocating for like what change cuz I know there has been a significant change the quick answer to that is I believe all School insurance companies are becoming more um strict and they're requiring larger coverage we found this last year when we were trying to get the the town alloyd fireworks on our property State education department has added additional layers of um red tape that we had to go through that the town had to

105get a a much larger uh insurance policy for them to for their July 4th celebration to allow us to do their July 4th fireworks here if they if we didn't I mean you can do them but then the district has taken the liability if God forbid something happens so we have not changed insurance companies but might be time to look at that so when I was at nisus this was one of the questions that I brought because it wasn't just this year it was last year we were facing some of this as well and um the other the other major carrier out there is doing some of the same thing I you jump in on this for a second so we have um cerated the other school districts and I would say a third and

106a third and a third there are a third who are having the same difficulty we are having or another third and I will not mention their names who just H they work through it and they say well we'll let that go and there are a third who just don't care there are groups who have individuals and we looked at their websites we've looked at their the background and said they're not following through on some of those violations number two the insurance limits that we that nyser is asking for some of the entities that are asking to rent the space cannot meet that limit niser is saying does the school district want to absorb that liability for example uh somebody may want to come on premise and do something and they need umbrella Insurance of a

107million that's what Nisa will ask for that particular organization has only $500,000 they can go out and get the increase in um umbrella policy but it's going to cost them well that cost could be Monumental to them for that one event why should they do that and therefore we get into this tug of war of well can you kind of limit what you're looking for n is saying we need a million because we have the deeper Pockets if something should occur and now we get down to smaller issues umbrella we have Auto we have all these different requirements that niser is asking us to meet and those individuals are not meeting all of them and so we go through this tug of war back in the finance office and with those entities saying well you

108don't meet this insurance what we've tried to do to try and make sure the finance division is not the culprit is to send the um entities and their insurance broker to talk to nicer and let them hash it out they're speaking Insurance they're talking liabilities Insurance they're talking the language they should talk and if they don't agree then it was on the insurance level and then both organizations know well we going to take it or not but now it's coming back to the district and ncer is saying what do you Highland want to do what is your requirement we're saying you don't have enough insurance for this organization do you want them to still be on your property to perform or use your space that becomes something that the board decision if you put that

109in the finance office it can get subjective well I said yes to this no to that why did you say yes no to this there's got to be very clear-cut rules as to what we're willing to accept um and we're going to run into some serious problems because I know that Highland is very into the students and making sure that we participate in all the sports and I've talken to Mr Rizzo we've gone through conversations for different events that have occurred here and came down to the wire literally down to days if not hours to make certain events come through so more and more staff or more and more organizations are trying to rent the space and even today I have one organization we say you do not meet that requirement and they're going to

110push back on you there's going to be phone calls to you to the board to say I really want this to happen and it's not fair so we really should address this um it's it's going to get worse kind of increase as we start to use the Pavilion outside what are our goals but right now there's a lot of organizations that we are either saying no or waiting to the very last moment to see what other insurance they can get and that's costly and it takes away from some of these organizations well a rider a rider a riter certificate for the day in that event is going to be an increased cost but that is the methodology that one needs to go through to but then in that sentence we asked them to get the

111rider to get that additional cost Mr rizo's Point well then that's a burden on that organization to fund for that event they're not making enough money to put in their coffers to head for the students so where do you want to go what do we want to do do we get a standardized limit of liability in these issues but we do ner is saying this is the standard that we want to have for your organization so once again it's a million dollars and but I'm saying I'm saying to have participants sign a waiver saying this is this is acknowledge limit of liability and we you know basically a writer to the policy saying that they're not going to should anything occur any damages would be limited to this amount something to that degree would probably

112have to be vetted by our legal council if they will allow us to have each participant sign a a a release it might be an Avenue to take but that's something we all have to have that discussion with our with our carrier that could be a possibility but let's give us the opportunity to uh The Desmond to go through and do some research I know he's working on budget at this point in time but if we can get the insurance carrier to come back and say yeah if you get releases from every one of the participants that District's not liable and we're not liable but not everybody's going to sign those releases so we have that battle too so let's vet this whole thing and then come back and have discussion at board level well

113yeah but I you know listen this thing get very tense as we head into budget season absolutely right conversations that might upset the public belonging discussed in this office among other offices so I look forward to having more dialogue about this well when you're having your dialogue also looking into field trips as well and the events that are occurring inside our building with our own students with our own clubs as well um to see if we can go back to pre-o where students had more access to outside of the classroom opportunities that's all I have thank you first name a a I want to go back briefly to the cell phone policy um I think that um what I heard and correct me from wrong can you answer if the proposal from the governor passes

114which is effectively a bell-to-bell ban and I think that she mentioned that the policies would have to be in place by August are you saying that there's possibility that the board would not uh implement the guidance from the governor no I'm saying that the governor's uh policy allows for sanctioned and unsanctioned use during the it out it it doesn't want unsanctioned use but it can there can be periods of the day where there is sanctioned use and I believe that our policy will fall under that sanctioned use plan is to keep this policy versus changing well no if if the governor comes up with a policy that seems to be if if ours doesn't seem to be in sync with the governor policy we'll definitely we've got a legal team that'll look at as as

115soon as something legal happens our attorneys will share a briefing with us and we'll take a look but I believe the way it appears right now there there can be some sanctioned use during the day and her policy allows for that does she have an established policy ultimately what it comes down to we have to wait for anything I will email you what I've read she gave a propal it's there on the website and it's effectively there's budget from the state as well to help mitigate essentially all cell phones will have to be put away for the whole school day that's a lot of logistics look for those sanctioned and unsanctioned words they're in there at least the version I wrot okay anybody else motion to adjourn motion by Jen second by Ed all in

116favor I I should have did it earlier so I could

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.