001good evening everyone and welcome to February 13th business meeting of the Board of Education um if you're able will you please stand to honor America and joining me in reciting the pled I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all all right at this time um I need a motion to adjourn to Executive session for the purpose of discussing tenure review second all in favor I I oppos extensions all right we hope to be back by 6 p.m. okay go back good evening everyone um we are reconvening from an executive session and this is our February 13th uh monthly meeting business meeting for the Board of Education um our first first order of action
002is to approve the Board of Education minutes from our regular meeting on January 16th can I have a motion please second Curiosities discussion comments all in favor oppos no is this for the minutes I just got um yes I I at 6 sorry exensions no all right our next section is uh Community questions and comments and I believe we have people that who want to uh make some comments tonight so we thank you for joining us this evening um this period will last for 30 minutes unless the board votes to extend the comment section uh those who wish to comment during this time period uh we ask that you speak at the designated microphone Mr is already there um state your name and address and any role that you may have um and we ask
003you to adhere to a 5 minute uh time period to speak you want to pardon me five minutes you have five minutes now we Al that don't have to you must have prepared glass we have 5 minutes now so we can hear your voice for 2 minutes longer you're bless and and if you want um to look at the board policy uh there's a QR code at the signin and you can take your smartphone and snap a picture the QR code and the board policy will come up on your smartphone and then um lastly the public comment period is uh technically not designed to be a discussion but rather an opportunity for the board to listen to your sentiments um about tonight's agenda or other things going on in the school district so thank you
004and Mr infity five minutes is there a mic up there oh okay thank you uh thank you my name is Bill keny I am the President of the hsees Teachers Association and uh tomorrow morning I can email this uh sa to Dr delos so we can distribute it to you guys uh good evening members of the Board of Education uh my name is Bill FY president of the hor heads Teachers Association and I stand before you tonight with my friends and colleagues Brandon Johnson the HDA Treasurer and a u the HDA secretary and we would like to address the changes in start dismissal times for next year and the potential consequences and concerns that those changes may have on our staff and students especially at the elementary level bhc met with the district earlier this
005week during our monthly Labor Management meeting and shared many of the potential concerns uh we will not shared all of the topics that were brought up at that meeting tonight as we wish to give the district time to consider some of the concerns of our devoted members next year's start times for the high school were announced this past fall the start times for the other schools were announced last month these times range from 7:20 a.m. to 3:26 p.m. across all grade levels with the potential for 5 minutes of Wiggle R here and there since the times are apparently not at out in stone the high school appears to be reverting to the original start dismissal times established by the district when we went to block scheduling nearly 30 years ago the middle school is also
006reverting to start end times that are similar to what existed before the creation of the Intermediate School we understand completely that the elementary school day had to change so that the district could meet the hours required on a yearly basis by the New York State education department however was it necessary to go so far beyond the minimum hourly requirement students in in gr students in grades kindergarten through the fourth grade will sit in classrooms for nearly 7 hours a day until almost 330 in the afternoon some of the is other issues that have been up been brought up are uh with the later start time many drop off students may become bus students has this been taken into consideration the later dismissal time will require a greater Reliance on substitute teachers at the elementary school
007as teachers will not be able to schedule health related and other appointments uh after the school day we as the district are currently facing a crisis in finding adequate self coverage now how will we increase our sub pool in the future there are also concerns that the intermediate school middle school and high school bus run will not be completed in time to pick up the elementary students this has the potential they have the students in our elementary and intermediate levels who are dependent on District provided transportation to be involved in community activities due to the time that those students uh that those events may be scheduled and the time that these students are actually getting home will the intermediate school and middle school facility be able to handle student arrival for four grades at once
008will the Food Services Department be able to handle breakfast and lunch running concurrently at the Intermediate School school and middle school has there been any discussion to incorporate a b system in the Intermediate School that works in conjunction with the existing system at the middle school has there been any consideration into how the changes and scheduling throughout the district will affect programs like instrumental music ensembles and choirs there have been classes and activities that have been offered at specific times in current in the current schedule to maximize the inclusion of all students and the altering of the schedule could detract from ideal placement of these students the changes in schedule for high school students interested in exploring career opportunity programs through the Bose CTE offerings will be negatively impacted as they will only be able
009to earn eight credits in their Junior and senior years as opposed to the 10 credits that they are currently able to earn special education students who benefit greatly under the current system that allows them to earn enough credits to graduate will be limited in the number of classes that they would be able to take and still receive their mandatory learning labs and the time crunch for high school students having approximately 10 minutes given in the currently proposed start dismissal times to get from a classroom to the transportation bus and to the B campus and in the afternoon we'll be counting on Transportation always running smoothly in order to ensure that the afternoon B students are return to the high school campus on time to make their buses to go home so that those buses can
010then return to the elementary schools to pick up the elementary students we would like to ask the District administration to all staff chats over the next month with each building so that staff members can voice their building grade level or Department level questions about upcoming changes is that me that's you so do you want to hand it off to there you go this like look at how coordin arianaa coming in so I'll pick up B I'm Brandon Johnson hga Treasurer Woodside Drive I'll start off where in the paragraph We would like to ask the District administration to hold staff chats over the next month with each building so that the staff members can voice their building grade level of Department level questions about the upcoming changes the proposed changes have caused a healthful anxiety among
011the staff all buildings a sit down and Q&A with staff might go a long way in assuaging those fears ultimately we all want the same thing what is best for our students and staff what will set them up to meet the portrait of a graduate and become lifelong Learners while we strive to explore Empower and itself lastly would the Board of Education and the district be willing to create a working Committee of stakeholder groups much like our other District committees that can meet over the next few months to talk through the issues and collaborate on possible solutions so this transition could be ath smooth as possible for the students uh on behalf of the teachers in our district I to thank you very much for your [Music] time thank you thank you do we have
012anybody else that would like to speak tonight I'm Stephie school um about St Andre drive my kids have graduated froms um I just want to say in addition to what um HDA had to say all of the educational research that has been done has said that the high school the older kids the high school kids M school kids need to start later that is what is best for them and what is best for their learning based on their their physiology they need more sleep um what else that's going on in their lives all of the research says that they should start later so I'm asking you to consider that and reconsider the start time because that is not what's us for our students right now and we really really want to do what's best for
013our kids not just what's convenient for us thank you thank you very much anybody else hi I'm Jess D um I'm a fif grade teacher at an intermediate school um I actually live out of the district so I live in coring um I had a lot of things up with a lot of the concerns that our Union Representatives stated and I appreciate that um one of the big things that just comes back to me is how these changes are affecting the parents and the families in our district I know over and over again as a teacher we're told how important it is to establish relationships with our kids and with our parents and with this new start time and the changes that were already asking of our families next year with the shift in the
014elementary schools and the changes I just can see that that relationship is going to be hindered between the district and the parents um I just know that there are a lot of issues and a lot of challenges that parents are facing right now and the start times for the elementary school are just not conducive to a working Family schedule so I just worry about the impact that it will have with the relationships that we have with families in the district and if that will cause resentment between the district and the families and I know that we you know make such an effort to um build and maintain those relationship relationships in the district and so that's just something that's been weighing heavily on my mind as an educator thank you thank you anybody else like
015to speak tonight um my name is Ashley I am a concerned parent um my child attends course of school district elementary school um and again the start time is not feasible for a working parent um both me and my husband are already going to be at work and we have nobody to put him on the bus at 8:40 in the morning to attend school at 8:40 in the morning I need it's awful um also I do have here the um teachers contract and there are a few places in it that said that these times um can't be altered to their workday um without a vote from the teachers union so I don't know if they're aware of that but it is in here um I'm also would like to address the fact that construction is
016still happen happening in schools during my child's school day um one occurrence with a fire alarm being set off 20 degree weather outside no coats for God knows how long s minutes construction workers Set It Off y um never would have happened if construction wasn't happening during the school day um can't say that a fire alarm won't go off but your chances are significantly Slimmer if construction wasn't happening um as well as odors and distractions from the noises everything going on and my child comes home and complains about almost on daily basis so I don't feel it's fair to them for their health their safety their education anything for construction be happening dur school day thank you just point one clarification as just so know in regards to the contract the HDA is right back
017there they have negotiated everything we've talked about tonight the changes everything not down to the specific times but we are in compliance with their contract otherwise we wouldn't have that contract thank you s this was asked we voted on I don't know if it was but give me a call that so they talk good evening I'm not prepared to speak so I'm just going to follow my way through it um I'm just a concerned parent my name is sahy I have a six-year-old um in elementary school and obviously the certain in times is the biggest concern um so I just want to State some facts that haven't been stated yet um I'm a parent who in the past has had to use his love for morning and afternoon care um this year I've been able
018to drop her off at 740 which has been extremely convenient um saves money and that I w't be allowed to do that if the start time was G40 next year um and I know from past experience that kid world can only allow so many children so I'm not sure we're working with I was going to say I'm not sure if anyone has looked into that um I also was using Amy Sunshine for a while but obviously everyone knows the busing you know got canceled for that so that option is out um and anybody who has children I'm sure everybody knows the younger the child the earlier they get up the older the child the later they get up it just makes sense to flip flop your play just thank you was it ter thank you
019anybody else like to speak tonight right see noakers we thank you all for coming out tonight thank you for expressing your concerns um I can just make a comment okay don't I mean again just so that you know everything from the HDA I will tell you I've received seven letters over the past month but the letters gave certain oh sorry the the letters ask questions and we're getting ready to post the question and answer responses from it because some of these things that You' mentioned we have thought about just like we understand the time the research and everything we also understand the fact that if you switch high school kids later they'll also stay up later too I mean there's no right or wrong it's trying to build the best opportunity that we can to
020meet the requirements that we have to meet uh but these questions and answers will be out there uh just so that you know we regularly it wasn't I have to say for the HDA it wasn't just the discussion last week they gave us questions and we're going to add them there may be more staff related than everybody else but sometimes they cross over just like you'd mentioned kids R we may be still having drop off that early with kids world we are looking at that just like I know every teacher wants to know when do I start when do I get out cuz I don't want to get out at 5:00 we haven't yet to have those discussions and we have already said as an Administration we're willing to try to work and create the
021best opportunities for as many people as possible one of the things so Community does know is one of the decision points in there is right now currently our high school our older kids get home way after the younger kids and that forces child care now most likely our older kids would be home to assist in that child care if they need to and they shouldn't have to but there some I look at my my cousin had the wife me when I was a child but those are all things that we tried to balance as we went through as well as looking at how down the road if something needs to change and it be changed so all these conversations just like the contract this contract didn't come about just this year it it was discussed
022freely negotiated and the raises were accepted to increase the time knowing that most likely the secondary would be at 720 2 years ago but that's the internal operations that's nothing against anybody but but we've regularly been talking about it and if you go back and watch the videos we've been say in it for over the past year year and a half now the specifics we're getting closer to those specifics that's why we're trying to get it I think maybe we might be able to draw back that 840 a little bit we just don't know until that's done so that's what we're working on and we will try to address those questions whether it's from the HDA whether it's from parents or community members that set with our question just like we did um last semester
023I just can't think of what it was for so please look for that and please if you need to we don't try to hide anything go back and watch our videos all those discussions are there it's not miss sometimes but they are there for every way but thank you for coming out we appreciate the input and if you have questions please send them in that's how we answer them all right um we will skip the report from the student representative tonight and as a result we will go to section five and there'll be a presentation on the state of the school from Dr Douglas and then um in conjunction with that there'll be a budget update get popcorn cuz this will be long try not to make it this [Music] long longer than one of
024yours I tried to good evening members of the board ladies and gentlemen members of our community back and staff uh every February we try to give you a little update about what's been going on over the uh past year it's sort of sort of recapping some of the ins and outs of the school district similar to not as great as the state's performance or their state as a state address but tonight's board meeting is to kick off part of our development for next school year there we go obviously the biggest thing we do is work with kids work with our community and trying to highlight tomorrow I believe Mr Holloway told me 100 days left the 100th day okay he said it to me wrong 80 days left the 100 day and it's Valentine's Day
025uh so there will be a lot of activity a lot of focus a lot of not so focused because everybody loves that day and trying to uh get through the day but we have a lot of great things going on from our elementaries to our athletic teams to our artistic students to our band to our kids that travel to our individuals in the classroom who are experimenting right and all of this leads to seeing a child develop and grow up and then also looking back and honoring kids through uh our St Patrick's Day Parade last year was SpongeBob our senior day one but ultimately it leads to these are top five students of last year's class that doesn't happen just because of the school that happens because of the parents it happens because of the
026community it happens because of the instructors from prek even before their mothers and fathers and their their relatives leading that student along that educational path and we all know that if we do it together as best possible and provide those opportunities students get to this point correct we have many educational opportunities first of all throughout this year the board has been seeing multi- system of supports it's really a system that we are using to get the supports to the students that they need academically socially emotionally and behaviorally you know the state has been talking we're creating a portrait of graduate well here at hor we've been doing it for the past four or five years and it isn't just like people think oh the administrator is doing this this is coming from our staff our
027community and the administration working together to develop what do we want for our graduates it's you know making sure that we have a viable curriculum we just don't go out and buy it our teachers help nurture and develop it I will tell you not every teacher does that but for those that are willing to dedicate the time and work for the betterment of kids there are these opportunities and we value everybody that participates we look forward to you know the science of reading reading is really one of the basic needs throughout every part of Education because reading comprehension understanding is really why the governor said and the state said we need to focus on that again the state is just focusing on it we've been working on it for the past few years and if
028you go back and look at our board presentation this year we have primarily been focused on all of us in addition to educational opportunities we're also talking about assessments the reason why assessments are important and coming from a person that I don't believe grading settles everything but I also know grading has to allow people to understand where they fit in where they stand and how they look and maybe sometimes value their success the reason why I have that position is I'm an industrial arts teacher and for me the success comes into performance not everybody can do that in every one of our classroom in curricular areas but assessment is a part of a Continuum that we have to look at we also want to look at Best Practices for assessment but as we go through
029assessments you you've seen State tests you've seen standardized tests you've seen end of the year region tests the whole point is each gives some point of value information that you can use to try to inform your decisions and because of that we also have to look at assessments and the results of our students and work to monitor the students progress as well as our own teaching and pedagogy that's one of the biggest things that we've been striving to get to now that we've developed certain curriculums to help enfor and guide the curriculum is that we are going to start looking at Gap analysis and we are going to start in our weaker areas that we see we need to really focus on it I can tell you that work started this past week at the
030high school and it will be starting at each of the levels over the next several months but you can only take small steps and it's not about using assessment to look at what's going on to penalize anyone it's about how do we develop the success together to overcome the areas of deficiency we may not be aware of or we may not understand how it's happening because sometimes it's test development sometimes it's a lack in our curriculum sometimes we're just not paying attention to it that happens to everybody and professionals will look at it help inform the decision overcome that and raise our assessment that's how education improves in addition we have our educational opportunities we've been switching over to one toone devices grade 7 through 12 uh for home use we are also obligated by
031law to make sure that we are ready to switch to home and time because of the past pandemic so that is something that isn't something the district can just choose not to do so we are at a position now in the district that we are able to comply with the state requirements in addition that technology and the classrooms that we are updating through construction is also becoming familiar from classroom to classroom so it isn't I'm in this class when we don't get it but I'm in this classroom I got to the fact that we are trying to standardize all of our classrooms through the instruction project and making sure the teachers instructors have what they need in this Society to help inform and lead the students in their learning process the consolidation of Elementary buildings
032this has been something that's been really being talked about since 2017 it was voted on in 2021 primarily one of the major reasons is we must have a minimum number of hours and a minimum number of days and prior to this contract we were not meeting it at the elementary level we had one of the shortest days of less than 5 hours 50 minutes for [Music] elementaries now it will be roughly 6 hours and 46 but what people don't understand just so that I make it clear certain parts are not educational during the day most people don't realize that we don't really meet the educational requirements for physical education in this new process we're putting in double the amount of physical education as well as getting up to our back to our 20 20 plus
033minutes of recess because recess doesn't count for Education even though I think it's sort of foolish because it's one of the biggest facts for little kids in socialization in addition lunches don't count but yet where would we be in education if we didn't have lunch but that's just the Dynamic but we're obligated to work around it so you can see the ant physical but one of the things that we're doing that we've been asked to for a long time by our music department now we're able to through this consolidation is that we usually have one music teacher and they have to teach all the subjects of Music General music coral and instrumental and that isn't necessarily where every instructor is and they've asked for this and now we are at a position where we will
034have a rotating fourth grade instrumental teachers for instrumental similar to like what we do with our strength program uh the physical space uses across the district will be much more consistent as well as the cultural initiative to ensure staff students and families do feel welcome that family piece is just getting ready to started that's being led by Joe Poler uh as well but we've been talking about that over the whole year and it's inclusive of trying to meet the staff's needs through our initiatives that we've been regularly doing and a lot of the information that we have or shared have come from these meetings and then the other thing people talk about Transportation our transportation currently doesn't really work the reason why I can say that honestly is right now it goes to the high
035school in the morning drops off the kids goes out picks up the elementary goes to the Intermediate School both of them are supposed to start right around 8:15 there's no way you can then on top of it some buses show up late and drop off kids late regularly or on and off but at the end of the day the same thing is true they get to the elementaries dismissed but then they got to get all the way over to the Intermediate School virtually at the same time and then they don't get back for 20 to 30 to 40 minutes at the high school and middle school and kids are constantly waiting the new Transportation direction is to minimize that kids right now trans Transportation are getting anywhere from 1 115 to 1 and 1/2 to
036some up to 2 hours of a bus ride right now our transportation from what we have been told and that we're vetting is that those runs for the student on the bus with the wheels moving should be 60 minutes or less and that's what we're targeting for and that's with the bus is arriving on time and picking up on time correct here that's Our obligation that's what the what was from the board to meet all those needs so that's some of the reasons and some of the processes behind that as far as extracurricular and Athletics because we're academics arts and Athletics this year our our band Led by Colin uh held a 40th anniversary for the district's band reing very widely attended very honorable thing it isn't going to happen every year but I think
037it's something like a 5-year anniversary or 10e anniversary but that's what our staff put forward because these are their passions and their love athletic participation continues to increase 10 years ago less than 300 kids participated now we're up to 600 400 in the two and we're heading in the spring and you're going to see some stuff later today that might help to increase some of that participation down the road with potential new options if we are able to consider it because there are options that are we are being asked but we also must balance Title 9 issues and making sure we have a balance between now athletic contest and female athletic contest and right now normally schools are impr propriately balanced to having more male based teams than female our school district is a little
038different we're balanced more female teams than male which you never hear that we actually need to before we can add anything else female add something M based or coet Bas so it counts on both sides we also have the new Intermediate School drama club that's a volunteer system that has gone out and we are also looking at how do we do that at ETD elementary school because Ridge Road has a wonderful drama program at this point academic eligibility because kids participate whether it's extracurricular or it's in the Athletics they need to make sure that education comes first and gets that done with some of this time shift parents have the difficult time of getting the kids here at 7:30 or 7:00 we believe that most likely we will probably be able to move this right
039after school so it's not a burden on the parents but it also will assist the students more on that to come in addition to F process has been reviewed and improvements have been implemented we've had virtually no issues with that I think the state is about to try to change it again too unfortunately the district has full junior varsity and varsity programs in place with modified teams to support in just about at most if not all of our competition areas and today this year we've had four stack Championship winners and five sectional winners and that's before we even get into the fall and that's going to open up next week these are the successes of our students our coaches our kids our parents our communities and our local sport programs that help feed these programs
040District point of prizes nisma honors for middle and high school B and coral students regularly we are up there at the top and our music program is an outstanding program our arts program two gold key two four silver key and 14 honorable mentions for art and writing we've had many students that have been displayed down in the capital and even had some even had a national winner for their artwork High School the one God play sort of saw a picture in that this year I think it's into the woods that's coming up in another 3 or 4 weeks right you got she's going to announce it later a wonderful program and that's where our student representative is tonight so Middle School Matilda junor play just was held this past week outstanding that's the feat program
041that's sort of like with Athletics the modified to The Varsity we have a wonderful way of moving kids through the program and still supporting just imagine what it looks like when we have elementary plays the middle school plays the high school plays if the community supports our uh positions down the road High School yearbook has finally started submitting some of the stuff for uh honors last year they actually had the 2024 National first page in honorable mention for their cover design uh it was a unique design and they've never really put their own workout this is the work of the students led by their advisor the advisor doesn't do all the work even though they probably sometimes feel like it but for the most part they facilitate and get the students to do the work
042and it's their collaboration together that brings on the high school received bner School award for Unified sports Unified sports is something I was very proud to bring when I came here from Albany area and we started in basketball we went from basketball we added bowling here and and got Partnerships with other districts and now we have bowling soccer and we also have an Esports program and we also sort of on the side work with Special Olympics because all of these students are student at the varsity level with their partner students and it's a wonderful program that is for all students here and the acceptance and understanding and support for these students is the value of the program we had four faculty members recently received the golden apple there's not many golden apples out there by
043our local news agency but they W here and it comes from parents it comes from students it comes from administrators with their nominations other District points Pride we've been a school of Distinction for the past two years what that means is every single varsity team is a scholar athlete team so it's not just about Athletics it's about that they must also be making the grades it's very rare there's only out of 700 plus school districts only about 30 to 40 schools ever reach this honor in a year not many of them do it year after year we're trying to get our third year in a row this year and that's from the hard work of the coaches making sure the students understand that the Athletics piece is one of it practice is one of it
044but the education and it's also the support of the teachers making sure students stay focused in all areas we also offer inter murals at our fourth grade students and we'll continue to plan on doing that we've implemented the my ride k for 12 busing app remember this cold day we had I had one person said what am I supposed to do wait out there they didn't know we had the app but this app gives you almost regular GPS location so you know where that bus is and there are ways that we are going to upgrade that and this is a safety feature so if it is a cold day you wait inside you know the bus is coming out you go out and try to get out there right when the bus is stopping that's
045what it's for it's also if you're running late knowing where that bus is making a call it's a two-way communication piece for the parents for safety of their students we have a new branding guide we created the image two years ago thanks to Sam trying to make sure that we have a consistent image this is a hard adjustment it's not just we can put whatever we want out about the horse at school that's our image and the board said we need to control it so Sam is taking that lead cultural redistricting team created like I had already mentioned super majority Community Support for capital projects the past two have been almost I think it was 78 and 69% for our projects uh and that's really that's $220 something million dollar and of that roughly 86
046to 87% is coming from your tax dollars that goes to New York State and everybody else is across the state to bring that money here to update and that extra 15 to 20% of the local piece comes from here we don't have to do the Capital Construction but that money is going someplace else so why wouldn't you try to enhance your own environment and that's what his resonated with people Corning is fully updated Elmyra Heights is fully updated Elmyra is fully updated they just passed another 150 million to update even further we have about 70% of the high school that's updated we still have to do more the pool is at its end of the life or else we're going to lose our pool our community's access to it as well as our swim programs
047right because the pool is 50 to 60 years old it can no longer be repair so we don't have a technology sweep we deal with Corning engineering why wouldn't we try to do something that helps our technology be connected to our biggest Employers in the area but our Community has supported this over and over through the hored 2030 initiative and we appreciate that because ultimately this isn't the reason property values go up but it does not hurt our business Community has been raising the value our school district in its Improvement is certainly enticing people to come here instead of going and choosing other places and all of that says to New York state horse heads is the place people want to move into more more so and that investment is a return of investment that's
048why we have a $60 million highspeed rails that's getting ready to be produced over in the holding point that is going to bring growth and economic prosperity to the area in addition people don't believe this but we show it every year and we'll show it again tonight that we have lowered the district tax rate from $184 on 1,000 that means if you have a $100,000 home you'd pay $1,844 in taxes in 2015 that same $100,000 home for Apples to Apples today is not1 1804 but 1594 per th000 that's what we've done by building the construction's all factored into that number it's supposed to be $3 higher than $1 1804 cuz that's what the project would have cost but we've done all of our budgets and we've done the project and we're at 1594 that's why
049people like houses here they may be higher in value but they're also increasing in value and then ultimately last year we had a budget challenge just like everybody else we have inflation we have health insurance premiums that went through the roof and we had a challenge and the community said we like what we have in the school the board said we don't want to change even though our how is we can balance the budget we don't like having to balance the budget by making reductions but one way or another the budget's going to be balanced either through a challenge either through a tax ly or through austerity our community didn't really view austerity as an option they knew that could be out there they didn't really think that if we just cut everything just to
050get down to a number that the state says we're supposed to stay under when they don't stay under it and the board opted to challenge to make sure the reductions didn't happen across the board and we thank the board but we went out to the community and the community I think it was 63 or 64% overwhelmingly supported we love our schools we don't want people who lose their positions and we want to keep hor hsees and we want to thank and notice that's a big point of Pride because there's other districts that did the same last thing and their Community said we don't we want the cups and I'm hoping that's never the case here historical district financial data this is funny because remember we were talking about last year it's kind of physically stressful
051on I know on myself on the board on everybody but the C troller came out with this report saying that horse heads doesn't have any physical stress isn't that interesting last year we were looking at Major reductions thankfully to our community but the controller says course says it's fine we know the story the reason behind that is because I was at Aly and I asked this question why are you giving us a no designation last year we had the challenge to tax cap we told you we had the challenge to tax cap we had a problem because inflation and the state has never kept up to inflation in funding the schools and they basically said said that's because forets is Rich and can fund itself and there's no designation because part of the formula is
052what is the community's wealth index and ability to pay which I didn't know they ever factor that in but I guess they do now does it mean that we're out of physical stress no we said last year it going to take one two three or four years inflation doesn't go down that quick healthc care is definitely always something that's been going up uh we think we've been seeing a little Trend but we don't know we just have to plan the best we can to try to deliver the what for the board and that's what we're going to end up asking the board over the next couple weeks what is it that you want do you want to keep hor says hes exactly what we did last year or do you want us to fit within
053what the state says we must need to fit with it but that's part of the budgeting process that's part of the decisions cuz one once we know what the goal is the Mechanicals of the budget we do we just don't know what mechanical part of the budget we have to get to and that's going to be the discussion so we thank the contoller I sort of was near his office so I stopped over and I had a friend there and I I told him I said why are you sitting there putting this thing out saying people don't have stress I can tell you the state said we're going to give HSE heads 2% it's $500,000 okay and and you'll hear some of this but they said that's what we're going to give you the rate
054of inflation just the other day is 3.3 right off the bat if the state isn't paying it the federal government we all know is in trouble right now we don't know what's going to happen to our funding those are all stressors but supposedly we don't have a stress so that's something we have to work on as we go through just so you know we talked about the tax rate I try to put up so people I'm not just saying it everybody this turn that off sorry go that everybody there's 2015 the reason why 2015 that's when I came we went from 1804 we even said that the tax rate was going to go up but after assessments after working with the town the budget was passed and it actually went down the next year again
055we thought it was going to go up because we give a conservative estimate and it went down the next year we said it was going to go up and it went up but hardly as much as we said because we said it was going to be up near a dollar and it went from 1754 up 44 or $44 for $100,000 home and then the next year went up I think it was 6 cents then it went down by 4 cents and notice this was all during Co then it started to drop what happened was is our District's value is being elevated over and over again in other words people are paying more and more to live here which means property owners are seeing wealth gains and yes they will see taxes go up a little
056if you change but the amount that your wealth is gained versus the amount that your taxes would go up even with a lower rate far outweighs what you gain in other words we did a comparison just between these three these I think it these four years and you'll see in a little bit is right here 212 through 2425 that's a $100,000 home each year what they're paying in taxes and in blue the big thing is if this and I'm going to only use Big Flats because I at least know that off the top of my head what they increased the value of houses over those years and really what happened is they've increased the value of $100,000 house 6% 6% 8% in those off years so that value of 100,000 goes up by about $2,000
057over 3 years if you calculate the $1 120,000 by the tax rate in that fourth year your taxes are up over four years about $130 or I I think it's $130 $140 so your taxes have gone up$ 140 but your wealth has gone up almost 20 it would take almost 100 plus years to make less money now people will say well I got to sell my house yeah you would have to but that's not the point the point is is somewhere down the road that money is going to be realized gains and no matter what our job is to as much as possible if we can try to build your gains while taking the rate and keeping it down we can't do that that that's not just us that's the business property that is you
058know the home values that is uh the community municipalities people having positiveness in the district so that's a little bit on the rate but if you notice in every one of those years we actually estimated that the rate would be higher than what it actually was and just so that you know here it is we estimated right there's each year and you can see this online I won't go but the last three years last year we said with the challenge budget that we estimated that the taxes would go from 6 1638 up this somewhere around 1650 to 1662 and you'll you'll see that we said the tax rate for 100,000 would go up somewhere between 12 and $24 the actual however because we only get preliminary numbers and I'm going to tell you if you
059look right here Katie bti and parizoto in our County Assessors work regularly in April to try to give us the most conservative estimate so the board understands what it's actually doing to the community so at $12 to 24 that's what we expected we got 63% approval thinking that that's how much it would go up and then if you had a 200,000 you take that number divide by two 300,000 divide Times by three but in in August this is when the tax rate is grazed that 12 to 24 Cent actually turned into 44 cents given back to the tax rate in other words that same $100,000 house went down in taxes by $44 per $100,000 now nobody sees that because they don't think about it they think just Levy you can have a levy and have
060your tax rate go down if the wealth of your district is going up and that's what's happening here if the wealth of the district was going down like similar districts around us and you're putting up a tax rate it's going to go up higher and that's what we do to try to make sure we are phisically responsible to our community as best we can just so people understand the budget we would not have a problem with the budget if our elected leaders would have just kept up with the rate of inflation this chart shows the rate of inflation over that time what we've been able to raise is in blue this is that minimum law that I was telling you about this is the high rate of US inflation that we had to deal with
061our local Revenue which is your local tax Lev we lost over that 10 years roughly 21.23% of local Revenue just because we did not keep up with the rate of inflation that equates in our tax levy to about $10.1 million you in any one of our budgets we never needed that much of money but if we were able to keep up with that rate of inflation over time our budgets wouldn't have that problem but because we have that now that we have to exist we have to slowly address that otherwise you're always behind the aall no matter what now that's just not a local thing it should be shared but if you can see the state says most of the money should come from the local remember local control that's why they're saying it well
062here's the state Foundation a the blue is what the state allocated in each of those years they allocated 2.74% 1.94 95 oh this was a big year they gave us zero that was Co wasn't it then 3.14 3.42 and last year they finally enforced the foundation a of the way they should and it jumped to 10.4 and then this year the closing 5.87 I'm hoping that will go up a little bit but it's compared to again that rate of inflation anytime we're above that blue line we're not keeping up anytime that blue line is above they're supporting us more than the rate of inflation so I don't want to count it but last year this was like 133% so now we're only about 88.2% behind the rate of inflation or from the state they should
063provide us another 2.3 million if the state did that alone this one we don't even need but that one should always keep up otherwise we can never advance so that's just understanding what's inflation doing because our budget is very simple we get federal funds we get State funds and we get local funds there is no other funds to get except maybe a grant here or there so no matter what to keep up with inflation those factors have to be taken care of and the only one locally we have the [Music] control so that's what the Eon contrer says they have the tools to be able to do it challenges the district continues to face we have ongoing inflation pressures today still it has not reced it's getting a little better but it has not receeded
064and health insurance costs are still an unknown health insurance costs are a huge driver in any School District budget we still have Staffing shortages no matter what the state isn't producing enough Educators we don't have enough teaching assistance we don't have enough food service maintenance custodial and it's not easy to find administrators cuz honestly people are shying away from the profession to become an administrator because they get attacked mercilessly because they don't know supposedly what they're doing this might 3 8th year 20 I think it's like 21 22 in education each year is trial and effort but each year there's scars and in anyone's Work World people feel that this is the biggest one Staffing shortage drives us nuts because we want to provide for the kids but I'm a Tech Teacher we've been without
065a certified tech teacher for the the past two years luckily this year we found one and we're hiring one so we're down one if anybody knows somebody please ask him to come the hores uh but family and consumer science is not easy Spanish is not easy foreign language sometimes math is not easy since that usually not bad because we got Courtland right up the street and later you'll see why we need Portland up the street in addition there is one thing we do a budget every year but there's continued Rising costs at bosies and in my roughly 10 years here I have hardly ever seen bosies reduce because you want to know how their budget is passed they put a budget give it to us and the board has to pass it and of the
06621 boards if the majority of them pass it everybody else is stuck HSE heads pays the third highest bill of mes and this isn't against bosies if you work at bosies the whole point is we have to manage our District's cost we would expect everybody else because when you see our budget one of our issues is about almost a million dollar rise in B's cost and we have no say in it in addition we all know about this New York electric busing requirements I have already told the state three times our community has been asked would they support it do they know about it each time I tell them our community knows 60% of the people that we ask in the exit pole they know that this mandates out there and I will tell you
06766% every year basically said we don't support it which means if I have to transfer every child into an electric bus within 2 years is the start of the Mandate I won't have buses so parents will be transferring their own kids because we will not be able to be allowed to buy buses after the year 2027 that are anything except EV I would ask everybody if you're listening here contact Tom OA contact Chris friend contact Phil Pomano contact everybody up at Albany and tell them fix this at least make it hyper there was some movement this past week that they said some people are in Albany are finally starting to think about that because honestly out of 88 buses we have 11 that will not complete their just single route with an electric bus charge
068so are we really you know cutting off our nose to spite our face with this where it's appropriate use it where it's cost efficient use it but just don't do it because everybody else says spend the money for us that's about $280 million because we have to build a new bus garage we have we have to put in the infrastructure and then we have to buy those buses and what people don't understand is we also have to pay about $150,000 for an extra battery for each bus because the battery will not last as long as the bus this has been all explained I've been one of the leaders in the in the legislator uh being asked to communicate this but right now it's falling on deaf ears 2% tax cap legislation you've seen some of
069that this is a hypothetical that has been thrown out there the 2% tax cap legislation isn't a requirement it just says that you can you can go out at 2% and get 50% of your voters in its pass if you go about that calculation you need 60% no other municipality no other agency has that requirement the town of Elmyra the city of almyra if they want to raise a 5% tax cap they just take a vote of their board and it's done school districts don't the only thing the board does is decide the what of what to put up and that what goes to the community and whatever happens everybody points the finger to the community and says this is what we did that's the hard part people don't understand the board doesn't make the
070budget the administration doesn't make the budget in its final form the community does we do the mechanics the board gives us the goals of that and that's what you're going to see a little bit tonight but the 2% tax cap we challenged it it wasn't 2% last year and the tax rate went down so keep that in mind because I think school districts are going to have to get used to not being afraid of that and just say what do you want from your school district and your education for your kids in the program Governor hok proposed a phone ban initiative how many people have heard of it how many how many people are for it if you're a teacher in a classroom I can certainly understand but teachers also I will tell you we've
071heard control it a lot of times but are you willing to pay $30 per student to meet the requirements because that's a $80,000 unfunded mandate that's coming if they signed it into law that's almost two teaching positions but do we have to do it exactly a certain way no we might be able to think of some creative ways too everybody knows the little the little you hang on the back of your door the shoe the shoe cany I mean I can tell you Mr mcy does it we went in there and we showed it on TV he writes the kids' names down there he goes I buy a new one each year because I'm not erasing the names our teacher shouldn't have to buy that but it works because the law says Storage off and
072Storage I also Imagine parents want their kidss to have access if there's a very critical emergency if you know what blows up is the phon right we also have to think of those things for our kids too because that will create certain levels of anxiety I can tell you from my own child he said Dear Dad take it it just distracts me anyways I mean he agrees the only problem is when I say here give it to me guess what happens nope I mean that's the hard part and so we have to navigate that thank to Governor hope this is one of the biggest challenges National political climate state federal funding uncertainty is something people need to really be aware of contact me Langworthy for our area it's not I don't care if you're Republican
073I don't care if you're Democrat the whole point is we have to have certainty for the funding of our school program because if there isn't if Federal funding is pull we have to fill that hole we don't have a tool so we must immediately reduce to programs that really can't be reduced so that's going to be one we have to keep an eye on very much and then we have to face this what does the community desire us to maintain for services for educational extracurricular excellence and horses that's the ultimate budget question question that's the ultimate what for the board to tell us do they want to do that do they want to meet a a number or do they want to go to austerity those are really the three choices real quick we've gone
074through these before but or say 2030 I'm happy to say because I I don't remember you said construction I was remembering so that's why uh actually most of the construction for horse heads Elementary is coming to an end probably within the next 30 days there will still be some lingering but I do believe the gymnasium is getting ready to open at Garder Road and virtually most of the thing except the outside stuff will be done because we need to get the summer I know the same is pretty much true of Big Flats they're trying to finish up is the cafeteria open yet or just about to open week after break so the cafeteria is about to open and I think the library shortly after that because we' got to set it up so all of
075it does take time and there are inconveniences and there are challenges especially when we work with other people that maybe not follow what they're supposed to follow uh but that piece is coming to an end and I'm happy to announce tonight that in another two weeks the board is going to get contracts for Ridge Road start its construction the bids came in the base bid came in about $300,000 under we still have some work to do on the alternate but because we are ending pretty much horse heads 2030 Phase 2 with the high school bid which is out on the street uh in a few days we will wrap all of that up by the end of March and construction will be in full swing again at the high school and Ridge Road starting roughly
076around March for Ridge Road is mostly outside in the parking for the high school it's mostly prep for the summer because this room from that hallway all the way down there all the way over from that side to there this whole area will be level and the new physical education spaces and classrooms will be put into this area that way the building can actually be energy efficient and close down while we're using one part of the building at night versus having to keep the whole building on that's one of the strong things we have through uh Mike cogman Dan gorum is our energy performance contract so here's Garder Road all of this work is pretty much end up at the end with some of the pictures and I'll leave this so people can go online
077but our new Wing been open uh the cafeteria has been done the gym is just getting in its final phases and the Suites for our Sports staff has been open and they've been very much appreciative because honestly they were teaming up in rooms open together and everything else these are some of the pictures that's the cafeteria that's in honor of the atrium that was there in Garder road we want to do something special for all those individuals that have been there over 50 years coming back yes that big plant is not there but we immortalized it in the floor uh that's the new front to the cafeteria which has a better entrance to it as well as the kitchen these are the classrooms and how they're uh laid out in the gardener Road and you
078can see this is modern education versus what we had before they were smaller they were about 600 to 700 ft² now we're up near 800 9900t feet they're bright they're inviting and the kids have a sense of different parts the biggest thing and I think I'm looking at Amy is storage is a problem in your room isn't it there's a lot of problems but yeah in these rooms the individuals coming back will say we've never thought we'd have this much story plus we've had to close down water features and stuff because of the age lead requirements and so forth now we're able to get back and fix those and that's through the Le ship of our facilities Department architect and construction engineer in addition this is Gardener Road gymnasium getting ready to open you can
079see it's a change from where it was Big Flats construction the back area the green has been open the gym open roughly around late September October uh they were working out the cafeteria will be open in just a couple weeks and notice that hallway the everybody would have the traits all the way around the building will finally be opening up soon and I'm sure people will be happy with that but most importantly the the support service offices as well as the library will be open and give them more of a sense of the reading science of reading as well as the reading opportunities and classroom space that they've never had in addition these are some of the new classrooms and layout everything's a little different from building to building but trying to be as consistent
080together such as presentation space Flooring Design window design as well as sensory hallways so that you know when you see elementary kids they'll play Hot Scotch all the way down that Hall but it's also meant to keep them busy so like if you look down in the hall you got a zigzag line you should see the kids especially the little ones sometimes they get the little ramb bues but that's what it's meant for to make elementaries what elementaries are for now their gymnasium at CL which is open plus it has the stage and performance area so things can be done at their Community School here's the ceria which is getting close and they have double serving line you sort of heard earlier some of those things food service is taking that into consideration remember we
081are reducing a serving line over at Center Street and that staff is being Incorporated in other places here's the rough pictures of the light Library as you can tell that's a little bit behind the others but you can see that's the entry way that's the ceiling system which will be light and bright the floor system the carpet that's down this is something that that school really didn't have they had a very small Library uh and I I've been over there for faculty meetings and I think about one one class could fit in there comfortably but they've got sometimes two classes in there sometimes three this gives them a lot more opport unities as well as more engagement with reading uh and the librar this is r Road this is what's going to start the green
082is new the blue is the old cafeteria the purple is sort of part of the old library and the cafeteria is part of the old gym right now all of that won't start until about summer but a lot of this prep work right here outside the building as well as the parking lot will and there will be a new bus loop as well that will house all of the buses remember when we're doing these bus Loops we're trying to get the bus Loops so all the buses fit in we will have the hardest time at the high school and the middle school at first the high school will alleviate itself in two years the middle school has to be revamp to the back side and the reason being is that was always built to house
083anywhere from 17 to 40 buses all at one time and that means we also build a parking lot that's able to house every staff member and still have extra spaces for parents it's just a new way of approaching it but that is the way that we are headed continuing our build this is that green area is that whole area that I'm talking about that's not one floor that's the first floor and there is a second floor we didn't put in here but that will have an upper floor running track around the open area the unique part about this is that the um graduation can now be held inside because of the seaing requirements that we'll have as well as we will have stadium seating entirely around the main competition area one area can be collapsed
084so the stage can be put in there and you can have the floor the seating area plus the upper area to house for graduation once that's built graduation will be permanently moved to a Friday night instead of our rotating Wednesday Thursday Friday we need that but we needed it because you can't do an outside graduation and have no place to go once we have that now we can do an outside or an inside the first year we try to do an inside obviously to honor the Capital Construction on the horizon this is just the continuing our build you can go in and see all of this from our presentations over the past several this is the timeline we've been operating on and we've shared this pretty much almost I think at every board meeting right
085now we're at February families are receiving outre from the new school principal that's getting ready to happen 2526 District busing routes are starting to be developed we're trying to make sure to do that in consultation with uh Tyler technology that will be something at the next board meeting we were trying to get it today we just couldn't work out the addendum for some additional work because they are the experts in our computer program we want to make sure we get it right the first time and not just us doing and then guess whether we're 100% right so you always want somebody to lead so that you learn and then basically April invited the new school events for families are we are looking at the end of May roughly to have that bus and have specific
086start times that way we can say when the buildings are going to be open I will tell you some of the things people said is I won't be able to drop off my child I will tell you we're trying to work on it so that you will still have that time even if it's at 8:40 if we have kids world or if we have to work on something to try to get something there we will try to we just don't know what that time is so we can't announce it yet at least for one year to try to help people sort of absorb into it and have more time that's always been something we've been asked by the board just like at the end of the day you know some of the parents will no
087longer need after school care because that time fits better into their schedule versus a 210 215 225 drop off depending on uh older siblings too so I hope everybody understands in the community we've have tried to have these conversations to think through as much of it as possible but there's no way we're going to make everybody happy we're trying to minimize it for as many people as we can so we do appreciate the question and we ask them to keep coming in uh as you get through initial Elementary meet and greets in June July building moves will begin that will be Mike cin right back there his busiest time because he's got to move Ridge Road to Center Street Center Street St where they're going then he's got to clear out Ridge Road and then
088we got to start all construction all in less than a month how about two weeks yeah uh and then August buildings move he's got to move them back as well and then the ele build meet and greet for the new staff and students September the district consolidates the three Elementary School Ridge Road students and staff are starting at Center Street and even we have to come down to changing that sign out front I think we're going to just make it simple Ridge Road X and Mike has a wonderful sign gu but we want to make sure we honor Ridge Road as well as Center Street Ladies and Gentlemen completing our Bild the last part the board's already had a discussion once we get through the budget season we're going to be shifting to the third
089project because the community said they wanted the first two you got to almost finish it I can't tell you to you could say no but that means 30 to 40 to 50% of the kids will not have climate control they will have older classrooms they will still have lead water pipes all of that happens and we would complete resizing of most if not all classrooms to State recommended levels Implement climate control to fulfill Heating and Cooling requirements oh by the way does everybody know that the governor signed a law that says if the classrooms get 88 we've got to do something now of course everybody thinks that's closed it's not we just have to do something this SS all of that potential voter consideration of the third project is targeted for somewhere between the fall
090and the spring and 2526 and then that would take another 5 years that would be still sum the high school but it would have to be saved probably 3 or 4 years out at the elementary to fall into the a projections ladies and gentlemen that's why state of the schools at this point I know it's long I know it's hard it's hot just briefly this is not for the community but does the board have any questions or we hear from Kate Dan says obviously I'll take some questions afterwards um I just had I had written down a question um you said the requirements for Fizz Ed are those counted in the hours or are those not because you said certain things are not counted in the hours but then you said the state mandates fzad
091so is it counted in the hours fad the class is actually counted in the hours most districts across New York State never meet the required hours for elementary fette and that's a shame in our new schedule they will get double the amount of fette than they always did so we will be much more closer and depending down the road if we can somehow get fed and recess to be sort of modeled and supervised with the teacher of theed we could count that but at this point recess does not we will be closer than most people are with our physical education for elementary get after this so what is the state mandate then for the phys education I don't know the exact minutes but we were probably 50 to 60% under okay and um the when
092you were talking about um is music and art are they counted or are those consider they class any class is counted those are also count passing not counted would be lunch passing times passing in the hallway recess recess and anything else that's not educated and dismissal arrival that's not counted either okay so like when they walked into the building what about if they walked into the building and went to a home room is that considered a class there's no education happening the state size unless um if you started it and it was a study hall if everybody started they would all the kids would have to be there huh all the kids would have to to be there at that time before it can be counted okay I'm just trying to figure out how I
093know it was different but I'm thinking about middle school I know they have like that stud how very end of the day that's 10th period that yeah the 10th period right so I'm just trying to yeah no problem if you want come on over we'll be happy to sit down but we know our hours okay any other questions oh go can take a break I make a motion to take a a recess oh where is he I couldn't I didn't know where you were I prefer to hear the budget presentation before we do that all right take five minut bre everybody set for a 5 minute break thank you get Katie a couple seconds good evening everyone um we are opening up our 2526 budget development process um we talked about it a couple meetings
094ago that the process this here look a little bit different more upside information to allow time for more in depth conversations um provide a bigger picture of we're looking at as we develop this budget um so there's a couple things I would ask if if it's okay with the board um one I would like to comment or question comments towards the end just let me get through all the information because there's a lot um I'll take a PA after Revenue um Can more detail and then let me get through the expenditure side and then we can open up discussion on the expenditures uh the second piece uh just so the board knows we're not necessarily looking for any decisions from you tonight we are presenting a lot of information um so take it absorb it
095ask your questions um think of things you'd like to hear more about in a CP CLE weeks that would help youn your decisions um but right now we're just um looking for you to absorb and think and come back in a couple weeks prepared to dive a little bit deeper and start making some decisions or providing us some guidance on how to move forward with the budget good plan good plan so the governor released her proposal for 2526 overall state aid increased by 1 $ 6 billion or 4.8% foundation made Statewide increased by uh 1.5 billion or 5.87% foret um unfortunately received half a million dollar there was a a due minimum in the budget of 2% and we received 2.02% um and I think we all can agree that based on a budget that's
096well over $100 million a half million dollar in state funding is hopefully insufficient uh there have been no proposed changes to expense geran AIDS um in the past there's been talks of consolidating them or freezing them um all things that would limit our ability to raise money based on those AIDS when I say expens A this is closely Sav Transportation need um things of that nature uh Universal School FS they are looking for um increasing funding sources for those um districts that aren't eligible to uh participate in Universal uh School meals to have the opportunity to participate right now um we do we are eligible across the board through all grade levels um once they change the formula in the threshold all of our students are currently receiving uh one free meal or one free
097breakfast um I'm Tony for the nonfinancial good evening yeah I'll just take on these U for Le and Dr already talked about a couple of them first of all youve heard about the science of reading over the course of the last um board meetings and uh even into last year and work we're doing that the Step Up from the state is according to the governor's proposal is actually briefs they're putting out that kind of have charts on there to say are you doing this are you doing this are you doing this so looking at accountability models that are coming back to districts uh so that's part of our proposal team mental health uh first aid is a non-funded mandate that she's put forward it's a great initiative actually it's one we've already started on um
098we've already had conversations and I know that working with CC and Samantha to look at U some of this work and what it means for our district we actually had a conversation just by ask admin Council what we would do in this um this Arena but the governor has put it forth uh the Tred free learning environment standard that's the cell phones the devices and all the copat that go with that um there is a small amount of money being put aside in the budget uh the governor's proposal for uh that work but by by no means will cover um I would assume it's going to be need space if anything but there is money being put aside and lastly the college in high school opportunity fund this was a pilot program last year it's
099a it's needs-based um we did not qualify it's not likely we'll qualify any under the government proposal this is for students to take advantage of higher over courses but again it's focused on needs based um uh specifically going towards um disadvantage students so not likely will be able to participate but certainly we'll keep an eye on that particular initiative uh so various advocacy groups um you know as she's building her budget L for different things that we would like to see included in the state budget um so there's always things that are hoped for that don't make it this is the list of the things that um haven't made it most of them for many many years so funding for prior year adjustment this would be a a pot of money that the state would
100allocate for any past um AG resources due to school districts so if there was an adjustment to for example building Aid calculation um instead of giving the district the money necessarily as to Du some they'll hold it back in a que and if and when they have the money they will release it to the district however they're tricky when the districts own a state they take it back the following this school year um so once again there is no funding for any prior year adjustments for us we have a couple that have been sitting in the queue um one going back to 2013 um in the amount of around [Music] $110,000 maybe we'll see it maybe we never will uh change of SE after bu implementation Dr Douglas touched on this earlier um right now
101her proposal there's no change on the timeline uh the how the when or any aspect of the Imp increase in both CCT reimbursement so right now the reimbursement we um receive for participating in the CTE program the salaries for the instructors are capped at $35,000 so we only receive Aid on a small portion of the program um there's been a push for years to um increase that threshold and it's not coming to fruition increase the capital outlay exception so um districts have the ability to do small capital projects right now with my small and saying $100,000 um is the limit so if you do a capital project in one year for $100,000 you will immediately get your building need in full the subsequent year um $100,000 doesn't go that far anymore for any any meaningful
102work um so lobbying happening to at least go up to 250,000 um just alone our breathing room to do such projects um but that has been met with um resist resistance as well and also not included is the uh section 211 TRS waiver this is what allows uh school districts to hire substitutes for vacant positions over the $35,000 that they're technically capped at upon retirement so we've been able to uh fill some of our vacant positions with reti your teachers because we have the ability to actually pay them a fair wage for their job versus capping them at $35,000 so right now that's not her proposal my understanding there's a big push um from the areas of the government government to get that in there projected state for 2025 um not not a Prett picture
103uh so as we discussed Foundation Aid um we're just above that 2% you'll see right is uh 2.15% versus the 2.02 from the prior slide there was a a nominal adjustment made to the 2425 Foundation 8 allocation um of around $34,000 um there's a process that the state runs after the budget is adopted to when the budget is enacted uh so we did receive an extra $34,000 um at that point in time uh Transportation Aid and bosies Aid those are are two of those expense trates that I mentioned earlier we know we made significant cuts across the board in all areas of the district to bance the budget this year um because we're spending less in these two particular areas the aid that we will receive next year will be less because we're aided based
104on what we spend so if we spend less based on the C we're going to get less Aid in the subsequent year uh building Aid is pretty consistent um as we anticipated small increase of $90,000 uh that is largely in part to um building condition survey a that's a one shot po of a to uh reimburse the district for the cost of the the building condition survey so that was included in 2425 no longer than 25 26 and the difference is um some old small C that we were receiving a um aged out well off the books other AG it items um include our instructional materials Aid and our excess cost Aid instructional materials Aid is um Aid we get from the state for textbooks Hardware software and Library materials those are enrollment based so
105if our enrollment goes down uh that Aid uh projection for us will also go down uh the excess cost Aid that's money that we get um for students receiving uh uh related Services there's a threshold um a cost threshold that they exed that um we ated on the amount above that threshold that number still being vetted um so right now it's about $100,000 less but that um still needs to be looked at T tax calculation um same same story as before uh limited to the 2% or the inflationary change uh whichever is less um we've been at the 2% for a while we know inflation's been through the roof the last few years so for 2526 we're kept at that 2% and the tax based growth factor is up a little um 1.68 from 1.34
106that's a figure um dictated by the New York State Department of Tax and Finance um based on a calculation that they do looking at um any new um new construction um Improvement for properties things like that so first half of the calculation um incorporates the growth factor incorporates the the 2% cap um there is an adjustment um towards the bottom to remove any amount we are anticipating for uh pilot agreements like tax sellers were collecting through a different avenue so that gets taken um off the top of the tax cap so the capital exclusion piece um is the one that we talk uh quite about each year so this is the part of the formula that allows us to love the attacks on any of our Capital debt related to our projects so the formula
107takes into account um our principal and interest payments on any of our capital projects uh there is a component for um bage Capital work shared out amongst the component districts and then those expenditures are then offset by any anticipated building Aid the Bose a any use of The Debt Service reserve the net value is what gets carried over that we can love a tax on so for this year uh the capital exclusion right now is uh just shy of $4.8 million and I just want to point out um because of calculations little um little year for comparison sake um for a couple reasons the capital exclusion figure that you see for the prior 2.3 recall that was reduced by $2 million by using the death service fund so while it looks like a big jump
108from 2.3 to 4.7 it's because we used that 2 million to bring it down 2526 does not yet incorporate any use of Deb service monies So currently the formula you know hear that piece of information um the allowable Levy change is $3.4 million or 7.12% the information referred to on the next slide references how The Debt Service um plays into uh the budget so you see in that tax items line so that includes the levy penalties and interest that we collect on unpaid taxes and our pilot items shows a increase of 3.6 million looking down below you see for 2425 we utilize 2 million in debt service nothing for 25 26 so the 2 million actually ties together with that tax items they have to be basically added together because they're they're two players in
109the calculation of the tax levy so that the net change that we're actually seeing for taxes is around $1.4 million once we take into and the adjustment for the um debt surface usage uh St we talked about um other Revenue um pretty clap um just some items of note because we are closing down um Center Street is a school and transferring Ridge Road over for a year uh we are unable to house um both seats classs that they rent for one year so there is a revenue uh L for one year um but we build outridge Road um once everything's back and everyone's back where they belong we will be able to bring those classrooms back into our district um's see so the other items appropriated reserves um fund balance we had talked about let's
110build them in now let's start talking about what the picture looks like now if we use all the tools available to us uh right now I'm recommending the uh same levels as last year so the 700,000 represents 500,000 from the ERS Reserve that helps offset the cost of the employer contribution um to the erf system also recommending uh the million doll again um is support from fund balance so right now um our budgeted revenues um are up 1.4 million again that's primarily from the the change in the tax um 1.38% any questions on [Music] Revenue it's not I any questions okay so expense side few areas to cover first slide is a reminder of what we did during budget development last year to balance ourselves out for 2425 recall we made um many reductions as
111you see in the list in Personnel items please remember that these were vacant positions these did not impact livelihoods we were mindful last year of trying to find those areas that we could have budget savings but maintain people employed with us so these were the lists of positions that were able to reduce or Shi somewhere else um in order to find some savings but protect the livelihood of um our employees other areas we look that we reduction in um or the shift of um costs from general fund to Grants uh technology uh we delayed our laptop replacement cycles and our carts um food service we have temporarily move the cost of our monitors over to the school lunch fund we made a variety of reductions to our bosies coers transportation we had elected at the
112time to uh remove the engineering study which would be our next step in our transition to Electric busing um con attendance and their job fair facilities was reduced um by a variety equipment um all buildings and departments shipped in for supplied equipment conference money contractual monies any any dollar they were willing to to give up to help balance this budget um we also looked at canceling the the nisba and the rules schools memberships that the board had participated in and our Ed support center uh significantly reduced its curriculum monies so I would just like to remind the board um as we talked many times during the budget development last year that these changes are things that we can do to balance the budget for 2425 many are not sustainable some are able to be sustained
113longer than others um but others need to be looked at um sooner for the operations of our district so after the budget was adopted there were some adjustments to the budget um both additions and reductions uh that is not necessarily an uncommon practice you you prove an adopted budget based on let you know at the time but there um are items that come up after the adoption of the budget um that we have worked in um so one of the items we added back in was the high school Social Work social worker um at the time based on um our estimates of needs at the times we thought we would be okay without it um but we did restore to make sure we have sufficient coverage for student needs uh same set for the RTI
114teaching assistant um added back as a as a means to support our students puddle camera system um this is something utilized by our athletic programs to uh stream our athletic events uh we have explored adding those cameras to our baseball and softball fields so to expand those streaming opportunities we have shifted our golf team from will Creek to storing Eagles it does come with a small cost but this allows for regular practice and home matches um on the sectional course that the students would participate in the sectional so they get to practice where they would compete in wrestling modified wrestling that was something we talked about fairly recently at a board meeting um is a necessary ad for increased participation so reductions made after the budget adoption you recall that um part of the tax
115C challenge was to try to preserve any positions that um we may have lost without the challenge um however the high school vice principal uh did end up leaving uh for another opportunity so uh would thatb vacancy we have not filled it and it has been removed from the 25 26 budget those duties have now been shifted to the other um administrators at the high school same goes for uh the C share for grades 5 through 12 included in the budget for 2425 that position has now been vacated uh CIO um the person that currently has the the CIO CSD position um those roles were eliminated and that person was transferred over to be the Cs chair for 512 so we're still able to service those students uh the CIO duties were absor AB by
116the director of instruction and the assistant superintendent and the director of student services absorbed the uh CSS for our Boi students high school English teacher um is a vacancy is uh result of the movement we had a a middle school position that was vacated High School teacher transferred to that role and based on enrollment it was determined that that high school English position did not need to be filed so all of these have been removed in the 24 or 25 26 budget so we talked about providing more of the normal course of business things that we have to add um things that really aren't negotiable um things that we have to do to maintain the functionality of our district uh they're listed here um in numerical order based on their cost um you can you
117know skim through the list yourselves I I won't read them all to you um but you know bothies that serve as Healthcare obviously are some of our big players um but I did want to point out at the end um a couple opportunities for some savings uh we have a significant number of folks retiring this year that have been with us for a long time so we do a calculation based on their current salary and what we would estimate for um a new higher salary which creates the savings um in the amount of that breakage figure that St salary at this point doesn't incorporate um you know benefits that nature so the consolidation is the other thing we need to talk about um looking at what um we need to have in place for the
118consolidation to function and what can um what positions can be reduced because we're down in a building uh so on the addition side we do need two physical education teachers at each of the three elementary schools this would be put in place in order to meet those state standards that um Dr Douglas was speaking to [Music] earlier uh We've added some funds for a districtwide equipment and supplying needs um there's going to be a lot going on once we convert to these three buildings and we just want to make sure we have some funds available for those things that may come up that we realize that we need we also need to create some sort of signage at on a street so it says something to eff a r road at Center Street or welcome
119Ridge Road to Center Street um to give recognition that Ridge Road is um being housed at Center Street for a year on the reduction side um because of the consolidation we are able to reduce those positions listed um these do not impa livelihood either uh because of all the various movements um from the transfer of Center Street and you know various other you know just Staffing changes these reductions can be made without impacting likelihood so no one has lost the job uh with the list that you see in those reductions we will be able to uh reduce our school resource officer contract we'll be done on Elementary so we can reduce one officer as I mentioned before the both these room rental will go go down just for that one year until we can bring
120them back into um one of our three elementary schools so items to discuss are there at the bottom um we haven't put them on either side yet this will be part of um you know the ongoing discussion so assistant principles of the three Elementary buildings is something we'll have to discuss um as a functionality need for the building uh just to give the board some context on um enrollment numbers based on what the consolidation will look like currently our elementary an average our average Elementary enrollment for the four buildings right now is around 360 once we go to three buildings and those students are redistributed the projected average enrollment for the three elementaries goes up to 480 so on average 120 students more per Elementary building for comparison the intermediate school has 520 students the
121middle school has students currently the elementaries have one principal the intermediate school has a principal an assistant principal and one counselor the middle school has a principal assistant principal and two counselors to support their population elementary schools support five grade levels where the other support to um with a much younger clientele that come with their own unique set of needs um we also need to think about the roles and responsibilities that a building principal does um on a daily basis um as far as student management uh staff management um evaluations um as well as just the daily operations to to keep the trains on the track that you're building so that is something up for uh discussion with the board um as we work through this process um as far as how we feel about
122those positions um another area um we specifically noted one um fourth gr play at all three elementaries this is currently done at Ridge Road there is a siphon attached to this work and we'd like to expand it to the other two Elementary so they have the same opportunities um as part of the cultural team they are looking at you know all activities events things like that because as Joe has said during his presentations we want to make sure everyone has the same opportunities and is um having the same experiences as best as we can we need to R student supervision due to the changes in the St and end times we already have processes in place for student supervision um so I'm not NE necessarily saying we need more um but it is something we
123have to look at once those times are honed in a little bit more as far as um you know athletic supervision while you're for the bues or um additional Supervision in the morning or you know the place to be before the the buses arriv uh kitchen staff needs um there's something else to look at we will be moving all elementaries from one serving L to two so just making sure they're properly staffed um school lunch fund has continued to be healthy and be a resource for us to kind of shift those costs over to them if deem that we need more staing school lunch could probably pick it up again for a year but that will be something coming up in fut year about budget conversations that we need to start elating school lunch and
124shifting some back to the general fund K I will taking a little bit back and forth on some of these items um as part of our um process as starting in November he and I visit all departments and all great uh in principles and have multiple discussions uh considerations and things that of need um so what you see on here um are some of the conversations and lot of good portion of them are ones to which we reduced in address and sustainability so the S Learning Academy has been a grand funded program through Esser ARP and cersa over the last three Summers it is a program that you know looking talking about assessments conversation that Tom top mentioned earlier our ntss work you know we use that data set with our principles and their teams
125within the buildings to identify students that are of high need and we can certainly not have to request of our program but still certainly see the benefit in producing summer slide to some of our most meeting Learners so there's a a consideration to consider that program or continue that program as I mentioned earlier um in similar to S learning academy uh the ARP and the source of Mone carried a lot of our um work in the curriculum we did have internal lines that were pretty much reduced to nothing um because we were able to until this last summer to carry in that gr stimulus package so to continue at the robust level or at least at some level of curriculum work to have teachers doing the work that Dr was talked about we would need
126to look at funds um of some sort to um put back into that system to which we took for last year's budget or EX for current years we been as a system since for several years been very proud of the atas we've been being been able to add and especially you the bank your buck at the primary level and you get students you know engaged in the teacher the assistance of the teacher um and a teaching assistant um so all Hands-On gck at our lowest levels for the needs of kids you know that when students can are at Great level at the youngest the benefits are just tfold as they go up through the grade level so it's very much a strong consideration that's a um something that we've talked about the board supported in
127that growth of T we did reduce last year and this is of course looking for conversation about the app we also did reduce the bus monitors uh last year two floating monitors that were able to assist the behavioral needs that we could see on buses um again it was not done through um livelihood uh was maintain it was just a reduction in the budget that we made during the process um certainly could uh look back to that it was conv ation that we've had again like the T for the last couple years in importance of having that flexibility to put a monitor on a bu that might be having some situations that require and some behaviors that require some interventions by someone besides the driver the instructional Tech and FY support we have three individuals
128that are assigned to our district as part of the um reductions for this current school year we took away um it's not the previous Slide the both se but IAL amount of time away from their day they're able to maintain and work but with our canvas and some work that we're doing the educational software their their roles and their work with teachers and with guys support you know it's something we should consider it's got to be on the radar considered budget it last year we reduced and I'm working with the music department a group that you know as far as you know managing that budget and what it looks like we did take a reduction of $10,000 from that um it's a replacement cycle I have to be very wary of replacement cycles and what
129that means and what that looks like so certainly we have to um think about adding um some monies back into that so they can maintain the level of instruments they currently have with students um laptop parts is one we saw the a previous slide showed um already built into the budget was the need to continue at a very low level our laptop replacement cycle what wasn't there was the carts um we will have to look at what carts look like Bill johy and team on what that might entail um we could maintain perhaps for another year but it's certainly going to catch up to us with as things age and you do have to replace or there just you're not going to have it and there's issues that come with not having these cars available
130uh they primarily of course our charging station first and foremost lot of the classrooms throughout the district is the place where students put the computers and charge also to move around the district when serviced and worked on so we have a a small Fleet of those that need to be kept up the last one was one that came through conversations I think it's been talked about during board sessions Le the first item and then there's also as a talking hockey team and I think Tom addressed some of that earlier with some of our athletic opportunities um so what I'm not sure that we'll want um too much feedback on but I want you know we want to let you know this is what we're thinking about as a dist we're thinking about every year we
131review our special education needs this is not new we did it last year if we look at what the students needs are based on Cs and IPS and we it's still in process those I APS and those those committees will continue to meet for the next several months so it's not anytime but we're always looking that and continue to have a conversation on our end and let you know we're going to need this or we don't need this any longer so with our uh student intervention services I think previous meetings I was asked what does that look like do we need that I about the current capacity we have and what opportunities do we have um we have an amazing group of of interventionists that provide very specific interventions and can look at diagnostic tests
132and know that Contin assessment the work they do with kids and we want to make sure we're looking that at um across the district as an opportunity to um a needs based system so that where is a conversation ongoing in the background you saw earlier grants review SL um slide how we did ship a lot of money over to FTE uh and did have to reduce some items um we do have a Time Stacy and team here are going to meet to go over our grants where they stand what does next year look like are preliminary numbers that's ongoing conversation we had an initiative of uh as Tom talked about earlier uh with the bus app and what that looks like the next stage of that was to get our he cards the students to
133be able to swipe as they the buses that would be the there's cost that goes with continuing that mission so we want to that what that looks like and what what we might do with that particular initiative um we're at a good point right now app has a lot of benefits already compared to what it previously had is this one and like I said having that conversation internally about what that looks like to add those cards and the training and the systems and put them online it comes with the cost um time to talk about the the busing and uh we have to do um again this is internal betting but I want to make sure the board's aware that we're talking about these things these are items of uh that the administrative team have
134to think about in next year's budget how are we going to appropriately strike parking lots um is there opportunities in capital project monies or is there something that we have to take on internally work does have to be done to a certain extent and uh but we just want to make sure you knew what we were talking about that and we'll come back to the table and read that it further tennis court repairs um our current tennis court had been patched a couple times um they do need some attention I'll let KY speak to some details that so A couple Avenues depending on you know what attention and level of repair you want to give the tennis courts um if it's you know I don't want to say simple work to be done in house
135but if it's work that could be done in house um as far as patching it would be a general fund expenditure um if wanted to think bigger on how we repair these tennis courts um and when I said bigger I'm not talking millions of dollars um a few probably hundreds of thousands it could be done as a capital project it would be done budgeted and a general fund the transfer of capital um and then we'd be able to uh commit those costs and get Aid on the repair of the tennis courts over the next 15 years because the tennis courts is considered sight work outside attached to a building in order to get Aid on the tennis court we' have to do at least $10,000 worth of work within the high school building um which
136um you can easily find some options to to meet that threshold um um Mike is getting quotes we're we're looking at our options um to come up with what might be the best way to that t um of course not to address that you know similar to what we had with cool you we have to find another site for that particular event to happen for our students to maintain that program so that mean that's the other side of that P for several years and we've been proudly using um some of our science kits with bosis and the development and unified approach to our F uh system um we are now because of the curriculum work that we've been um able to do looking at redoing some of those F kits and making them internal creating
137our own not one that's been created by someone else and meet the needs and that our teachers are we have to have these and what does that mean currently we pay them through bosies if we brought them in house it is a expens we paid on that of course but the cost up front can be offset so it's conversations that Tiff and I are having about what that looks like moving forward and that would that be part of this particular budget or would be uh be one year out but it's it's exciting work that our science teachers are engaging in looking at these kits and how how we can make them wor skits um we in talking with technology in Bill we know that our ISM ass sign and our high school front electronic signs
138are certain age and show their age and luckily we've been able to reboot them and do some things on the internal function um again we're betting this we're looking at this where that lands sooner or later and what those signs look like um been talked about I believe during Open Session this website um we currently have one that's B reports um we did there discussion about it and we had not put it in the budget it's certainly still out there as something we would uh consider um but need more and what does that look like moving forward and lastly the distract free learning supplies as uh the budget you know the governor did put forth you know some money to go out the school districts but by no means we that's cover what we would
139need to implement that again it's the government proposal we'll see where at lands when they how they play in know so before I uh reviewed the overall budget with you I just want to go back um and just say a couple reminders here so this slide all these numbers are currently incorporated into the budget the items under additions and reductions currently incorporated into the budget items of discussion are not these are considerations not included in the budget at this point the items that we're betting not Incorporated in the budget at this point so with that a budget overview our salaries are up um just over a million dollar 2.51% this includes all contractual obligations as far as salary increases as well as uh cost of uh substitutes over time Healthcare byouts um offset by that
140breakage number that you saw for the retirements um that reduction is also in there uh benefits of $623,000 much smaller number than what was last year uh 2.38% as a reminder the benefits line includes um the distri district contributions for ERS TRS Social Security workers comp unemployment Dental claims and and fees and of course our health claims this budget currently includes as you saw on the previous slide an increase of $500,000 for our Healthcare line um I think we all know from our um difficulties last year that uh Health Claims can kind of turn on a DI with us um inflation is still continuing to be after um making the market rather unstable which we all know trickles into the healthcare industry cost of medical service cost of prescription drugs um we now will have
141um new members added to our plan uh people will get married people will have babies um our membership will continue to grow when we have a retiree guess we save money on salary but we carry that person and their family on retire plans while we're bringing on when you hire with their with their family so it's almost a twofer when you when you have a retirement um so while this year currently is looking good we're trending okay so far um that's not to say that we don't want to continue to plan for the future make sure we're prudently thinking ahead and in building this line so we're not caught like we were last year um again given the very unstable Market that we're seeing in the moment uh The Debt Service lines um this includes
142our short-term borrowing for referendum 2 uh it includes our uh dasne bond for referendum one and the borrowing for our buses um again given the current economics um and some of the uncertainties that we're seeing we're working closely with fiscal advisers looking at interest rates um right now for our band renewal or short-term oute um we're conservatively estimated right now based on um notes that have been sold on the market um so we have a we have a pretty safe number in there right now we're going to continue to work with them right up to the very end to make sure we we budgeted sufficiently for what the interest would look like at the time we uh go up to the open market one other thing that we're looking at with our debt service is
143that we are getting ready to go up sell our bu 1.6 million for our buff B approved by the last proposition we typically go out um mid-march to sell um a little wrinkles this year is um the situation with the tariffs that has been announced by the government that are currently on hold 30-day pause could be lifted right around the beginning of March if they're lifted the the Market's going to be a little bit in in some chaos as it adjust to to what that means which will impact interest rates if it's paused um you know things will stay relatively calm so we're kind of watching the timing of when we want to actually borrowing um to allow time for the market to react and calm back down um if the tariffs are implemented um
144or if they're caused that will influence our decision as well so we're being very mindful of the the current economic status and its impact on our borrowings um one I note um two I want to add that I will bring to this board next time um regarding the debt service different questions um this year and over the course of budget development last year about how our building Aid and our debt service and how those two inter plan what they meet together uh so Ann and I are working on braking that up for you let's break down what we get building aid for what project what debt is off is supported by that building Aid so you can see a clearer picture here's referendum one all the components thatt and a related to referendum one all
145the components related to referendum and we also have some cash projectss that we we used to do a a million dollar um annual project as a transfer to the capital of us while we pay cash we still get building a over 15 years so there's no debt associated with those but we do get the aid so we'll provide that breakdown uh for the board on the 27 uh just for a deeper understanding of our building Aid and our Deb Service uh both SE we actually just got our budget a couple days ago um so this number is based on what we had received at that time uh increase of almost $900,000 6% uh still being reviewed still reviewing um the cost and the services um within the initial run and decisions to be had on
146um what we're keeping what we may need to increase what we feel maybe need to decrease um so more betting to be done on both these equipment contractual um that's of $653,000 um few things in there um being mindful of increase in energy costs um one thing that goes up every year Mike hin and Dan delam check that trending very closely um and they've given our recommendation um that was on our prior side of $160,000 increase to support an increase in energy cost uh we have a increase built in for the cost of fuel we have um equipment needs that were seen on what the prior side of things that were built in for transportation and Facilities um as well as those um instructional supplies and equipment money that we added um to support um
147what we may need over the course of the consolidation uh the in fund transfer um that is um in part of the general funds responsibility for our um special summer summer programs and our preschool programs and also trans money transfers money to the school lunch fund for their share of um po a and the refund so right now we have a proposed budget of $106 million 3.8 million increase over the prior Year back to our normal range of an increase of 3.68% um which is good news however the revenue side is not keeping pae oh sorry ask the bottom one item of note not included in this yet is any increase to the employee healthare contributions uh Caitlyn and I are working with our consultant um as they finalize what the premium equivalents will be
148um for um employees to contribute their share it's um anticipated the increase is not going to be as large as What was seen going into this year because things are kind of calming down um so once we have those numbers that'll that'll get built in that'll be a reduction to the budget figure also just a reminder um because reserves always play a part in how we uh balance our budget so these are all of our reserves and the balances as of today we did appropriate this year 500,000 from the ERS Reserve that amount has already been taken out of the reserve so that 1.7 million is our true balance right now we've already already utilized the 00,000 we have our taxt Reserve um our crude benefit employee benefit crude liability Reserve we had appropriated 200,000
149out of this Reserve that transaction that pull from this Reserve won't happen until June so that 768 198 will become $200,000 L as we Clos our hooks uh TRS we used it as a one time shut of around $200,000 in a prior Year's budget unemployment has 24,000 our capital reserve has 3.2 million and our debt service fund currently has a balance of 4.8 million but similar to eelr we appropriated $2 million to come out of The Debt Service fund that transaction won't happen until we close the books at the end of the fiscal year so that will come down to 2.8 so right now our Gap with everything inclusive below is uh 2.36 million our resources available is um hopeful when the state finalizes their budget that we receive additional state aid and that we
150receive that information timely they approve their budget on time so we we can use it if if it's there we can look at additional reses we can talk about additional fund balance use you know we'll have a similar conversation that we had last year regarding any additional usage as far as sustainability and is truly solving the problem of of bright sizing the budget we can look at challenging the tax levy as we did in Prior year or not more but and we will continue to look through other budget reductions do what we did last year go through everything with the F come um across all areas and see what savings we can come up with can I ask a question pleas thank you the hard part is when you look at this slide you have
151to remember from the earlier discussions things that were items for discussions or vetting that aren't in the budget if any of that's selected to go into the budget that number goes up that's what you've got to sort of balance and that's really the next one uh before we get there that's what we want Bo to think about over the next couple of weeks because you you see the immensity of the budget you understand it uh you understand that we're not keeping up with inflation and no matter what if you don't keep up with inflation it's a year-over-year issue um we have made major reductions last year we've tried to keep it away from people we have shown mostly all the tools I am hearing that we should get some additional Foundation a uh that I
152heard as late as yesterday afternoon where they think the governor's hurt right now and she needs to make people happy in addition it was just revealed yesterday she spent $7 billion in the past year on immigration issues $7 billion that was not allocated in the budget so that came out of our reserves which are at $30 billion so and there's other things such as a$2 billion give to lower people's cost for groceries inflation she so these are some of the things that are going to be working over the next several weeks as they deal the budget we have to look at the reserves we have to look at the fund balance we have to look at healthare we have to look at whether or not overall the rate that we have like last year which
153helped make the decision for the board is going to be favorable that although you see what the percentage might be the rate may be virtually nothing depending on grow the question comes down to is the Board needs to look what do you want out of the budget that will be a lot of our driving questions on the 27 because that last one is budget reduction we're going to try to trim this up but we already know there's not enough to overcome that Gap so we either have to consider some of those if it will close the gap but if it's not you get that last one and I don't think the community wanted those reductions last year I don't think the board wanted them but no matter what unless we get Revenue we have to
154balance that so that's what we want you to think of because for us we need to know that what and if you're willing to entertain those things cuz the earlier we know the easier it is to not raise everybody's anxiety level to give them the opportunity because ultimately we all know the board doesn't make the budget the board recommends the budget the community makes the decision on the budget and that's going to be really our focus of discussion at the next one because really by February 27th you got to start having that discussion by the first week in March I think we were talking we want to have that direction because we have then only about 4 weeks I believe plus we have a break so that's what we wanted to instead I didn't I
155didn't want to cut you off this is the board's presentation we do not open at this point but if you get to me I I'll answer I actually figured it out so thank you so any questions at this point on I okay so you mentioned um you gave us a breakdown of the elementary schools and the IM and the MS as far as students to um principal assistant principal and do you have that for the high school at all I don't School en uh High School enrollment compared to like breakout of principal princip High School two assistant principes how many counselors no five they have five fin answer any 1100 students is that what you said thank you we have specific the next meeting that's fine um so you gave us a breakout of what
156the BOS cost is um this year you said that there's more to come on that you just kind of got it and you're looking into it um with some of the rising costes if we were to and I'm just going to use the example that Tony gave of the science KS for example if we were to bring those in house is that a reduction in our V's expense or yeah so we pay for the kids to be put put together everything that's in them is all part of that cost them for them to be delivered and to be stored so we don't have 12 of them in our classrooms right they're delivered when we need them and we return them what we have to balance that out is is probably be cheaper for us to
157create our own based on our own units of study but now where do we store them when they're not being used and who refills them and the ongoing cost of refilling absolutely so yes that's the betting we're doing is what does that set Cost Plus Revenue loss following year for not for not using the we not using okay right so that's the you know I think we're going to move that way sooner later but often we brought back from bosis we look for a zero you know net neutral like we brought back a attack it's because the cost was beneficial bring that position in house for what the you know we worked out the side of so and like the C Bose C reimbursement that was on as well that's the Bose C reimbursement is
158actually a government proposal like my group the superintendent's group have been asking them to reimburse CTE not at the 30,000 but double at the 60,000 but that's all that means the state's got to pay us more money so it has nothing to do with the budget but it would have impacts if the governor put it in so that has nothing nothing to do with our budget thank you yeah I think so so first uh thank you for the presentation I think viewing it this way with the tools already included was effective um and I appreciate the work going into that and I recognize this is you know the first look right so I think for me I just have some general comments as opposed to very specific kind of questions but certainly as with last
159year I think my Approach going in would be to try to maintain our program and maintain people right as we look at the budget recognizing you know we have to deal with what we have but those would be my overriding kind of principles that I want to try to approach I think it'd be helpful to see a couple of things as we work through the the budget each successive meeting and again I know this was just preliminary but the considerations that were included if the administration as you continue to think about those work toward a prioritization that you think from a you know a program and perspective are most important I think that's helpful for the board as well as obviously assigning U costs to those as as you are able to develop them so
160that's one I think it would be was great to see the current reserves and I recognize those may change those will change some of the year one of the things I always like to try to know is what the recommended kind of level is for the reserves because I know we're getting close on some so maybe when we look at reserves if there's a way to also annotate it's recommended that that should be x% of you know so we see are we above or we below or where we need to be um I think frankly I think it's too early to decide or or have a strong point of view on whether or not we need to challenge the tax cap you know I'm very mindful of the burden the community has to bear I'm
161certainly not ruling it out right because we always have the beneficial impact from a levy perspective but so I kind of would keep that in the back pocket at this point as we continue to work through the other pieces including and recognize you know a lot of work went into reducing last year and we have to worry about sustainability but as there are potential reductions that you identify also seeing those and um you know to the extent you those are things you want the board to consider the point of view as to what you think is most feasible without with the limited impact I it could be helpful to see so you know we have a long road ahead of us uh but I think this gets us started and thinking about those factors and
162as that other information comes in I think it'll help us but um otherwise you know thank you for this first presentation so I agree I thought um the presentation was great I I really really like seeing it this way and kind of see starting at the end and now and now kind of going into theil I think help early do that thank you very much that um do we have any so so one of the things that does concern me is I is I feel like we we've been you you've been really using reserves year after year after year is in my opinion are getting a little too low for my level right um particularly since you know we're it's going to be even you know $2.2 million less you know than what we even
163saw tonight um do we have any sort of projection as to are we going to be you know how much positive to the budget we're going to be at the end of this school year that you know so we have a a better feel for what is that what is that excess right I know I already started driving I thinks already that because it does give us some of those and I think they're scheduled to do another we did one back in early de it gets more and I think we've said the earlier you do it in the year the less reliable it is at the end of the year the closer we get to March it starts getting into the higher so I think starting to look at that and being able to have
164have that view I think would be a little bit helpful as we start to make decisions about where we take Mone and that is exactly what we do um the fund balance projection is done for each code um so that gives an the opportunity to sit down and comeb through it what why options we have um and then I I agree with and um you know looking at those considerations and and looking at it in a prioritized manner um based on what what the districts disc but but overall you know thank you for this view very very very helpful thank you for breaking it out also um I am really glad to hear that you're going to break out those pieces of the budget and give us line by line information more detailed information I
165think it's just helpful to understand uh the origin of things so thank you for that um I'm I'm nervous about the state of our government right I'm trying to say it in that way but to see how we're going to be affected with the possible withdrawal of some federal funding right and how that's going to impact us as well as what's going to happen at the state level with the governor so I think a lot of that we have to educate the public as much as possible as soon as we know what's happening so that we can factor that into what we need to do to balance our budget yeah um there's a lot of uncertainty um a lot of ideas being thrown out there as far as and things being Sol and bled and
166things of that nature that it really is very challenging to know how to plan for some of those things what is the worst case scenario it could be something we haven't heard right yeah um so yes we are watching closely um right yes and how that's going to impact our building projects as well there's tariffs on things and building suppes and whatnot so um on the flip side of things a completely different question is do we have any numbers on what um paying to see students in athletic events admissions ad yeah so I actually looked at that just the other day we had budgeted 60,000 uh right now we have 30,000 received okay we about halfway years that's all my questions and comments thanks um can you please refresh which slide did you say was
167it number 50 that that is in the budget right now with The Gap already there so this one is everything we see here uh additions and reductions is in um everything you see in the chart is in okay so these are all the things that are in and I want to just go back and say this course of business one um this is not an exhaustive all-inclusive list there are many other many other adjustments that were made but trying to limit it to the big ticket items and not make you a list of things that were $5,000 we really just wanted to sck to the high point so these are in there as well as some other adjustments that are made and you don't and you don't want to reduce these anymore is what you're
168saying or is this an option for us to look at these things and take them out those you can't do right these are um I mean you can look at things like laptops y um however we've already delayed our replacement playl delaying it further would result in technology and our stud hands that could be faulty um and not up to date functioning properly um but most of it um it is what it is and there things we need to do in order to um keep the district moving ahead bis I will say has some potential wiggle room like we talked about earlier um but yes this is all pretty much a down okay and then the items to discuss when you're talking about the addition of the assistant principles all that that is not there
169okay but that is something that in the future necessity we're going to ask you for the discussion just like I think what Mr Christmas said I already know that's about $450,000 and yeah that's that's the hard part we've got to do that still for each of the other yeah that's administrative position those are more expensive than teacher assistance when you you know they all have um okay so um the one slide that talked about the Huddle and um the Sor Eagles all those types of things are we I slid out of it are we going to be able to get prices for what those costs were can we get about 15 to $20,000 Soaring Eagles is about four wrestling is about six yes okay um could you could you maybe get that like written down
170so I can we remember so we have the numbers there that would be nice um and then I I don't know if this is included in the budget but are we increasing the cost of our busing with these times so if you're having people drive from um start time 20 so let's say if it's an hour start time 6:20 in the morning and then they're dropping off at 8:40 is it still just only going to be 2 hours in the morning and 2 hours in the afternoon or are we going to be increasing that expenditure to 3 hours for some runs or a 6-hour day for drivers as opposed to a 4H hour day for drivers so is that going to increase all depends on length of the run as the former driver some are
171two some are 2 hours and 20 minutes some are 1 hour that is all in there the big thing is we have roughly what 66 bues that are on the road at any time I think we said 71 70 that's that's 56 Roots we have 56 Roots right now estimated we're looking at 37 plus 14 so there could be less rooms we have to go through the whole position the good good part about it is even if there was some increased cost it is a one-ear increase because the next year you would get Aid to return on it you always have to pay for it up front but if there's a decrease then we'll get aid for one year and the next year our transportation Aid will go down because we decrease the cost roughly
172we think it's probably going to play out very much neutral okay I'm just curious about that and I um like to see things on paper so we could get break to unfortunately we aren't going to have that we won't even be able to finalize those final runs it's going to take a couple months that's why we have to have the addendum to have them work through the final run that we've said that yeah I'm just worried about you know in the future all of a sudden it's you know the next year we get a thing and um because of what we've done with our start times and the configurations and where things are and pickups and drop offs and all the different logistical things that maybe C up because of these shifts if we're going
173to see an increase in our budget next year and the following years from that so that's what I'm trying to be proactive about right now in this moment can I just add one thing to that that topic um so yes we are mindful of our bus our bus RS are changing and we're still finalizing what that's going to look like the other piece of that puzzle is um as far as understanding the cost is because roots are all changing they're going to be three bit so we don't know what driver is taking what route yet um through that process so hourly rates are different depending on the driver so to assign the cost to a run we have to do some sort of estimate on whether and and if we can add because the board
174said we'd like them an hour or less that shortens our run times and it shortens our R times thanks to the right I know that like those start times but I don't know if because we shortened it if one bus driver is going to go out and pick up all three parts or if they're still only going to be doing two parts because you had talked back and forth about three tier compared to two-tier I was still thinking that we were going to be under the three tier now we're back to the two-tier so just thinking about you know how people pick up drop off that's that's what my concern is length length of even though the run is short that doesn't mean that the driver isn't driving longer you know like or picking up
175slack or doing something different so that's that's what I'm um that's what I was wondering to get more clarity on it is are we going to try to use the driver as efficiently as possible and not over working which is true um remember one of the big changes we go out and around the entire District twice right now yeah we will only be doing it once next year every kid 5 through 12 will be picked up on one run not two that right there is an automatic potential savings yeah so what I would like to see if we can is the comparison of numbers I know you have to try to work through that stuff and get that information to try to Fig figure out this is the cost this is like the next year
176hypothetical I mean we're paying the Tyler technology company to kind of do this for us aren't [Music] we okay and and just so that you know we're in contract negotiations with bus drivers right now so we cannot have that discussion out here any contracts will have to be any contract discussion about cost will have to be an executive and that will be only for some board members okay and then my final thing is are we able last year we um we did the print out of all the codes that we voted on the April 18th meeting I printed them off because I thought it was helpful because I was looking at codes like what you were saying comparing the Cod lines and I do have a couple questions on that when we get to the
177regular budget presentation but I went through like the first first page and I did a comparison to what we see with what we have on our 10 pages of the budget report that we get each month um The Gentle lady's time has expired you've spoken for five minutes as per the rule would anybody else like to speak I was just wondering with the both these classrooms when they go to a different site will they automatically come back to us do they have the choice to stay where they're transferred yeah both Kelly and I have been talking with our counterparts overies about and they have reassured us let show this sorry that I did get an email this week as one year they have found a spot we were concerned because of course it Services course
178of students right so we wanted to make sure that they landed but the exercise we've done with you know amarie and paty about building usage and how syry can be used with the rig Footprints you know did require us to move out our pre and those uh closest classrooms as was anticipated in our early um you know tabletop discussions so yes they will be coming back to us we want to come back because obviously service a good amount offor students thank you in addition um as we go through this we have at the superintendent level we've already had some discussion about once we transition back to the three elementary schools and I believe it's 26 27 uh we may have some more rooms because they are hurting for locations at this point so we have
179already told them we may have that opportunity not only returning our own but we may have some space for at least one or two years depending on any other future projects so I'd like to ask um I'm sure at some point in the future there's going to be discussions about using the capital fund and we talked about that last year so um I'm sure that's going to come back up I'd like to see no I don't know cost benefit analysis opportunity cost of if we take that money from that what are we giving up because we put that money aside for a purpose and if we spend it to as Dan said save programs and people which is um certainly an applaudable objective what are we giving up to achieve that goal so yeah so
180a couple comments on that I can speak to now okay um yes we did talk about last year year of liquidating the capital reserve it would have to be approved by the voters to do so um once liquidated it would move um we have du ability to move it into certain other reserves that would not be an opportunity that we would have for usage in the development of this budget because we don't know if the voters are going to approve it so we could if approved and allocated to different reserves you know do amendments through Al budget process to increase the usage of certain reserves um but again let's keep in mind usage of reserves is kind of a stop Gap not necessary a solve to a budget problem um cost benefit analysis if we
181gave up the capital fund um we went out for this third referendum that um we're starting to plan that's less money that the district has to put towards it which then shifts that over to the taxpayer okay that's if I can just rephrase that because the only reason I want to rephrase it is because it would be less money that the district would have at its availability on behalf of the taxpayers it's not our money it's their money sitting there if we put it out other places it also doesn't mean that the board couldn't say although we have the use of it in reserves and we don't want to if we're in a better position you could say we want to dedicate some of that in the reserve towards the C Capital you you have
182much more flexibility that way the reason why you have the capital reserves is because you are trying to plan for that down the road I will tell you as well as the board if this District can get past that third project no matter what and keep our tax rates going down you'll probably never have to worry about a capital reserve after because the money coming back every five years should take care of you for about the next 50 to 70 years of projects believed it would come up in the future cuz it came up last year when we were told it was too late to use so I just wanted to know in advance what it was and if I can just add because one of the things we have not put up here is
183it came up last year to Sal at H Grove right now we're about to close down the entire South LNG we have already doubled up several spaces at the high school and we are doubling up and moving people into the elementary there are no other spaces we plan on doing whatever the board wants to with hither road but you really need it for another year until Center Street becomes available for the vast majority otherwise we are going to have to rent different space we cannot pack the kids in even more that was the precipitous of what happened I think it was almost 7 years ago at this point because we want construction is going to overhaul and force kids to automatically do it now they're not but in the high school they're about to Shi
184again remember the whole South Wing is gone and if you think about it it's that whole hallway up and down the rooms because construction is in that hallway we can't utilize them right now so we have to actually relocate those students and those classrooms I think what was it Tony 16 High School yeah 16 16 classroom are going to have to be doubled up and that has to fit within the schedule that is 80 minute classes so those are some of the challenges but it's not that we haven't looked at it we also know that real sales right now especially on business property it's not very at the top of the list so um those are some of the things but we just wanted people to be aware it's not that we're forgetting about it
185so does anybody have any first round questions real quick can I have one more time [Music] to back to the cost benefit of The Debt Service fund or the capital monies so when we allocate money to a project with capital funds we use that cash up front first so it delays our borrowing and it's less we have to borrow and it Sav us my on expense okay any other first round comments second any second round comments I Katrina I assume you have are you sure okay I just have a question um Tom you mention um the third project and closing down this Wing isn't that what we were talking about in the October meeting and we were having your team look into and investigate the additional costs and you going to bring it back to
186the board we at that meeting what we're saying is is it okay for us to start trying to organize and plan that yes that's what we are doing we're not currently doing that we won't even start that until after we get through budget but at that point then our Focus would shift to trying to bring that third project forward for consideration and Direction but that third project is the shutting down of essentially the w we in no that is all part of the second project in other words coret 2030 had three conceptual phases of building our future now which is all all completed we're in continuing our build which the high school and Bridge Road are the last two remaining projects that we think we have enough funding for there was a third which was
187the middle school hbac but we don't have enough money to do that or we wouldn't be able to do the higho You' have to pick one the least amount of project was that middle school and because it's an hbac project we can be ready if the voters ever approve the third project that would be our very first project to K off and go because we have no wait time on so that's all part of the next potential phase with the last phase of course 2030 okay so the redoing this wi and having that gym and all that entrance has already been that's already been approved and ready to we we are hoping that we will be bringing contracts to you within next 40 days yep um yes but just uh clarification it wasn't the Middle
188School it was the Intermediate School right that was no it was both middle school and for both yes because I remember that was the cooling system right for the intermediate H how would you say h but it's like cooling but it's not cooling it's climate control envirment is what I have to right Mike so but back to the thing um um are we able to get a print out of all of the codes like needed for that budget thing the 17 Pages because I think it would be helpful some of the numbers and the quotes that we don't have that I'm noticing on our spreadsheets um the repetition are the taxable benefits I wrote in like the difference between them just so I could see like so from the proposed budget um I'll give you
189an example d146 d169 so that was like an original allocation of $1,100 but it's up to $37.97 so I did that for the first page of them and I got to like $36,000 but most of those codes were ones that we don't see on the regular on the print out um so I think it would be helpful and beneficial to be able to get all of the codes on our report like this is it's like five pages different I think it's one of is to see like where we are within both of them with within the ones that we used and the ones that we haven't and then be able to ask questions about those lines specifically and get more breakouts of it when we have to make like those types of determinations does that
190make sense cuz this is what we end up approving in the end so that report um you don't present until the end because everything's a moving Target it's not a complete budg at this point and it's not accurate the reports that you see each month within uh the finance documents the budget status report that is that same information a little different format but it break it out by function so your 2110 to 2250s and then when you're referencing the 169 object post the three numbers at the end so you'll see you know 2110 and then below you'll see 69 so same information different format live and up to date yes but so like I was saying some of the ones are missing though and the ones that I noticed were the ones that were missing
191tend to be under the category of taxable benit or vacation days so you don't see every specific but it's all there just consolidated I can show you what I did I wrote it down if you'd like to look so it's helpful I don't know I just found that to be helpful in the way that I think of things the way that I see them yeah I understand the the requests you're talking about state report that we we upload that's printed on that last day for your approval um so whatever it's worth the the breakdown to see what a Gardner Road second grade teachers are purchasing out of their supply codes because the object codes Need is a detailed report that these are always Consolidated together to show a larger group of individuals or expenditures into
192one say you're 400 Cod or 450 Cod Etc so you you have all the the numbers are there the totals are the same you're not missing a total it's just they're combined into larger groups because the finite detail is well quite finite so you're seeing all the object codes put together but the numbers the dollar values when combin are the same as the one sitting on finance oh yes but when I take this the more detailed one and then I go and I start looking at the unencumbered compared to the encumbrances you can see like oh this fund was unencumbered so we haven't really spent it and it's money that we can do so maybe we can reduce that code because right just because it's not encumbered now doesn't mean it's not going to be
193encumbered between now and June that's just an accounting principle that we have to use and we have to explain so the board does it's Financial oversight not management of the budget each month that's why you see encumber and unencumbered and balances at the end of the year if you perfectly do your budget everything's spent but that's why you also have transfers and that's why you have Surplus and that's why you also have sometimes deficits that's how the budget works the why for this process I don't know if the but if the pter really wants to do that we can but that's not how we have to do business I thought it would be helpful because I found it to be helpful that's all so that's that's up any other questions so we will take some
194of the guidance from tonight to try to put together the 27th please think about those things about you know some of the options cuz that's where we'll really have to start having discussions we really it's hard to make all the final discussions because I I like to really drive pting us because then I got to say okay what are the potential assess I know what are the potential assessments have you talk to the assessor what about the growth factor and she'll say they haven't called me back yet but that was very helpful at the end but if we have that direction we know where that most likely will be that's what we're hoping to be able to accomplish with the discussion on7th to give us Direction by the 10th or 11th I think it is
195and then that way we're trying to hopefully wrap it up without building anxiety for everybody with close to a final Direction hopefully a budget by April 1st that might change some of the numbers too so that we bring you a plan and say are you okay with this is this what the community wants is that anything else um if I make a request um don't tell me um too late um I was wondering if the board and Dr would be okay that over the course of the next couple weeks have questions or there other information that you would like to see if you could email it to Dr Doug prior so I have time to prepare presentation or prepare the answer just in the interest of keeping the conversation moving along as quickly as we
196can and what I will do is because no one board member can tell us what to do I'm not trying to bring it back we'll try to make it as easy as possible but I will consult with the officers and we'll try to do the best we can hopefully this is sort of what we talked about so thank you thank you everyone and I did say no all right moving on to uh Finance uh items reaction we have an audit committee report first before the finance committee um action okay so the audit committee we met last Monday um no this last Monday actually days ago um and we had Tom zuer was there he did a review of the external audit report which was the single audit um and that audit was on the federal
197program specifically special education and school lunch program and no findings were identified so that's why you see in the documents for the C action plan for that that there is no ctive action plan because there was no Finance so um great job um with that uh he also took a look at um the extra uh the extra classro activity funds um recommendation really there is just to continue to implement a plan for more student involvement in the preparation of pnl statements um and also additional controls for establishing change fund and then also continued recommendation status of the N clubs um he did also note that all prior recommendations have been implemented for the corrected action plan so we did um K did then did review the corrective action plan um for uh for that extra
198audit um and again all those plans are in place to implement those audit recommendations then we had Julie Kart there who went through the internal audit risk assessment update report um there were just a few minor findings related to building access badges for facilities and minor issues related to the extra classroom activities um she also noted that there has been continued positive progress and all the areas that are audited so she continues to see that year after year and all prior findings have been corrected um so we also had a discussion at the end to talk about what would her next detailed audit be and the recommendation from the audit committee was have the focus on health benefits and that was the thank you um so I need a motion on 6.03 room 6.18 please
199second Curiosities discussion comments I had a question I don't [Music] know so I noticed um I didn't really know who the jeweling person was but she had given us a from TSC B but I don't see that it was given to the rest of the board I see the report given to the rest of the board and Tom guy but I didn't see it given to the rest of the board for that and then she had suggested a different topic um and I wondered if the whole board should discuss what we thought um this person did I didn't understand completely that night okay so Julie she is our internal auditor does she work for us oh sorry sorry um she is a contracted service through TST bosies uh so she comes in and um audits
200um her initial audit that's um on for tonight she has a you know White net has a variety of areas to find where we might have some internal weaknesses and that's what she'll put in her report um that's what you'll find in the corrective action plan um for the risk assessment audit Wait no that's that's what we're not on yet so yes so we just received that report um corrective action plan is still in the work so that will actually go to the June audit committee meeting with the corrective action plan to presented to the board in June part of the process of the internal audit is to look any findings that she may have had if there's a specific area within her audit that we want her to take a deeper dive on if
201there was you know some weak thisis and processes that we should really um look into a little bit more um but it is the role of the audit committee to review that audit and make its recommendation to the audit give her that direction of what we want her to focus on so the report she gave us the rest of the board won't see that until June correct okay so um I can just speak to it briefly findings um there was one um I think one of 19 badges tested in facilities Department um that wasn't turned off upon separation of employee um and that was just a a paper trail issue uh facilities has made um a lot of progress that was actually a focus audit of Julie several years ago looking at badging and processes
202of issuing and uh turning off badges there were a few extra classroom findings and the third one sorry oh yes the training um on workplace violence that we're working on um the appropriate roll out for that so the audit was very good right there wasn't a lot of findings um so that's that's what the board um isn't at this point is what was in that report but it was those four items um typically like I said you know wherever there was maybe the most findings is what we would focus her her next audit on we've seen so much improvement in extra class we've done audits on extra class um that it's not really worth the time for her to do another audit on extra class which is why we had the discussion of what else
203could we do that maybe we haven't done in benefits um with one of those areas um and I think the time weed given some of the challenges that we question I just have a question 6.13 um in the July meeting we authorized specific uh users for credit card use and I did not see that the family consumer science program or those teachers were on that list that we authorized live so is can we approve an increase for someone that we didn't authorize so the resolution was done to authorize this credit card I think sometime in the fall okay um Bo passed a resolution to authorize that um this is asking for an increase to that prior authorization um due to increased section numbers in the fact program but to your point yes in July it
204will be on that document of uh the various credit cards issued by the district and who was authorized to use them thank you can I I it was the August 15 20 2024 meeting where we did that um yes so first I'd like to just make a motion because I did make this suggestion at one point in time and then nothing happened I make a motion to allow all board members to join the audit committee um effective immediately for the rest of the school year that way we are all given the opportunity to come and ask as many questions as we want to and not make board meetings see longer so may I have a second you can still make motions with motions okay I'll do it later coms then okay well can I please
205have my time restarted then um okay so quick question uh the drum pedal was $290 so I was asking about um that foot pedal is it for something other than a regular Pi Dr it's not that that's not the cost so there's a total po that total well over that amount and to cover it they took out of a supply money from the music department and then they covered it over in um an equipment line they pulled unnecessary money to cover the full po one of the items on there happened to be a foot p $160 double tap really nice one toble spring Chromebase um but that's going to um that's just have to be the last item on there there were several other items I don't remember them all up top the have in
206that PO but they had to grab that money from the equipment code and a transfer to their supply to be able to purchase all that items okay and then I think you touched on a little bit about the initial appropriation because that's where I was confused on one of the um computer hardware lines that was an increase of $20,000 from what the line was at the April 18th that we did but then it up by 20,000 and you said that that's just something that normally happens with our lines so it was two budget codes combined so there were two codes there there was the 16899 30 219 and the 168 99339 both of those added together equals the 156 700 that you reference okay so there was a separate there's a separate for added together
207yes okay thank you for that clarification um and then um I did want to I'll I'm I'm not going to ask any of my other questions at some point hopefully you'll be able to get back to those questions and answer them when you can I did email them over um so but I did email some that I think it is important and um the com controller says that we should never allow anyone to review and approve their own purchases I kind of feel like by giving them a credit card it's like they're reviewing and purchasing and it's not that I have anything against fact teachers or science teachers or being able to get supplies readily available but I'm wondering about like why wouldn't we go through Cisco or um Palmer Foods or whatever it is
208like just credit cards were supposed to really Safeguard and make sure that we're monitoring and everything that I read about and that I see it's supposed to be like that's why we signed that form at the beginning of the year we're very limited with who gets to use it why they get to use it and I think it's important that we safeguard that you know well if I um the only the individuals that can they aren't just subject to purchasing what they want they have to turn in their receipt at the end and it has to be verified cross checked and secure so whether you're purchasing through P or Cisco a lot of times they don't take individual orders that is usually a restaurant supply store yeah food they don't necessarily work with school teachers
209right and that's more bulk purchasing too so the purpose of this credit card is if the F program or the science program is doing a lesson need X they need X um they need to um they need to write the St by a that they doing they need to buy 2x that's not something a Fisco or something like that would do um so before they would they would go TOS tabs is expensive um so by using the credit card it gives them the opportunity to go to Walmart it gives them the opportunity to go to Sam's Club more cost effective ways of buying the things that they need and it's just for perishable items only so if they need some kitchen utensils or items of that nature that still goes through a normal purchase order
210process through a a bid or vendor um but as far as the credit card there are definitely save cards I feel very strongly about credit cards and the safeguards that are in place um but it still runs through the purchase order process uh receipts are turned in they are reconciled um and paid by the business office so they well they are allowed to purchase they know the parameters they are reviewed as long as they're in line they're good to go each time they get to use the card so they get $1,000 when they go out to make an expense like so to me if we're increasing that to $2500 within four purchases if any four people within departments if however many people have access to it that could be a potential of $10,000 no um
211not for the things that they're using um this card for um the increas is due with $1,000 has wored $1,000 has not been a problem until second semester when there's been an increase in sections so that should tell you how much utilization is these $1,000 has been sufficient until we've seen an increase in sectioning the teachers very responsible with its usage there has been no abuse of the card because believe me that would be addressed if it happened um so no there's there's zero concern in my mind of um exceeding a credit limit or excess purchase unauthorized purchases um it is all very well maintained just like any other distri credit card that we have if you can add if there's a $2500000 sorry if there's like a $2500 limit until the cards rectified it
212doesn't get to go above 2500 so that's another safe card that we have it's like the board has a credit card and say we went to a conference and all of a sudden say the rooms for the board cost $5,010 you're going to get the card handed back and say you don't have money because it will not let you go over that until it's either rectified or the bill is paid so that's something that a lot of schools have now because of conss so how many um people utilize this credit card is it just one card or do lots of people get a card it's one card to be used by Middle School and High School fs and science programs so high school and middle school is locked up leave at the high school um
213and there's a process in place for the sharing not that so how many people you know how many people are two the middle school three four four p teachers two maybe two two or three science teaches at high school that's right you used to yeah we well and facts so we teach a unit on whatever we go out that night have a competition that Friday have the kids cook so the kids give you the menu you go out that Friday by the that that Thursday buy what they need and they cook it on Friday so it's it's kind of like a as you go basis and it's not again it's not to say anything about teachers or anything like that I just everything that I read from controllers from audit from New York State it's
214like credit cards you're supposed to be so that's why I'm doing I am saying what I'm saying think it's important I don't disagree if if I can help to if I can help to assure your concerns of this that's why our business department is the business department that we have it's also why our audits are the way that they are these things get have been regularly checked and we have an Exemplar reading I mean well we have little things here and there but I I'm absolutely enamored in the fact that I don't have to worry about my business department or my Audits and in other districts we do in the board I would hope feels very good about that as well from the numerous audits I think we get two or three audits every year
215for the past 10 years and since our first year everything's been very much complimentary to the work everybody even our staff does and when there's a problem we correct it can can I say something Katrina I just want to share that you know in this process the teachers have to apply to get the credit card they have to pick it up they have to put their receipt back within what is it 3 days a three-day time limit to return in receipts is it 3 days uh receipts should be turned into the secretary when they return from the purchase okay and then those the receipt is compared to the purchase signed off that yes those items were purchase on this receipt and they right so I I understand what your concern is but I also see
216the Merit in trusting our teachers and trusting the process that's been put in place for them I don't I definitely trust our teachers as professionals to utilize a credit card to get the supplies that they need for their classroom I understand your concern but I don't think it's like they're handing the credit card to a friend or a spouse and say you know go make this purchase for me they're doing it as part of of their job and I think we need to give them the respect and the professional courtesy to know that they're doing the right thing um and if they're not then that's something that the business office will will pick up and address immediately and you know we we've seen corrective actions for those kinds of things and in my mind those
217corrective actions would be credit card is removed individual can't do ize this card anymore training is going to be put in place those are all the things that happen when somebody is utilizing a credit card um and being on the receiving end of that being somebody that has held a district credit card I'll tell you I have wrapped that thing up I have hidden it in my wallet I mean I I treat that thing better than any any other card that I have in my possession because you know we take it seriously so I I just wanted to share the that comment and sentiment thank you Erin I appreciate that I understanding more detailed about the process of how it all works again it's nothing against not trusting people or anything like that I think
218it's my job to save this piece of it for the taxpayers and everybody else you know it's the US holding accountability and and I don't disagree with that too either but I think it's part of the Ed process for you to understand that there are processes in place to make sure that um missuse of funds isn't happening um so and I and I feel strongly that our business office and our teachers have that in ch call question all in favor oppose exensions can you get ready for the next can I just give a couple things real quick and get them out of the B while you're thinking of moving on real quick because I did not have my own report in there but just so that you know uh we already covered a couple but
219the board tours are March 14th 8:30 to 11: I know we did not have that time on there uh the board retreat just so that you know we are still waiting on confirmation dates because of four superintendent searches that are going on I have reached out to him again to see if he can get us a rem Mark uh and then I mentioned at the last board meeting you had to do the child abuse training that they surprised upon us oh you don't have to get the links now because they interpreted it wrong you remember that stuff you did at the beginning of the year with backer you're all set so you don't have to do it so I just want to make sure you got that and then the last thing I believe we
220going to you're about to get to an HR recommendation and I know at our Middle School uh I wanted to say this earlier there's a retirement of a person in New York state that needs to be recognized and I know the person will probably smack me on the head and say sit down in the back row but miss olar Teo has entered into retirement uh through her own personal reasons and we are obligated to make sure she is comfortable after 55 plus years of Public Service to the so ladies and gentlemen you'll see that on your note I know some people are upset uh in the community because it came as a shock but you have to give a person we do that if they feel it's in their best interest we wish her well
221in retirement and I know she doesn't like Po in circumstance but thank you o for everything that you done HR I have a motion for [Music] 7.02 inquiries discussion comments um I would like to thank Mar and bl for her 43 years in accounting um she was with the district PR the board so thank you and then for her 56 years in the sociates department in middle school she had some of our our children between these two ladies they had 99 years of service in our dist that is just amazing and thank you so much call a question all in favor I oppos extensions so before I move on I have two things number one I also would like to uh congratulate uh Olga and Maryanne um for their years of service to the district
222and then I received a request from uh Mrs Corbett maryan Corbett to read a letter out loud to uh Miss artimo um and the PO I think I might have failed acting class but here we go Dear Mrs Aro I am sorry that I cannot be there tonight to personally congratulate you on your retirement thank you for your many years of dedicated teaching for the students of the hhcs district my two boys were fortunate to have you as their teacher in middle school I texted them with the news responses Sean I remember her map assignments I love those Matt wow what a run I think your daily modeling of excellent teaching strategies and the benefits they reap for both the students and teacher had an influence on Sean he chose teaching as his career very
223best wishes for retirement years abundant in joy good health and great times I often think of christen M's Challenger astronaut uh Christ mlli model I touch the future I teach you miss Aro have touched so many I will end my note uh by asking Mr con to read a poem so here's the poem I will not if it will not matter what kind of car I drive what kind of house I lived in how much money I had in my bank account nor what my clothes look like but the world may be a little better because I was important in the life of a Child author unknown sincerely Maryann hollerin Corin okay moving along we're at Section 8 miscellaneous items for Action 8.02 8.03 can I have a motion please second Curiosities discussion comments I
224need to abstain from 8.03 for personal call a question all in favor oppos exensions um there was no policy committee meeting this month and happened on the day we had school cancellation one St so um there's nothing to report and we decided to leave the first and second readings to next next month so we'll move on to uh my report and under my report is the discussion on athletic coaching and extracurricular leadership I chose to put it here as good of any place on the agenda my intent is to allow every board member to have the comment and discussion involved in it this is just a place to park for the disc I I do have a couple of introductory comments um there may have been some question as to why this didn't go to
225a committee to be discussed I felt in reviewing the video and then the minutes that most board members said they wanted to discuss it and I felt to send it to a committee without some direction from the board what the board's feeling was would have been a waste of time quite frankly because the committee did what the board didn't want then we were wasting time so that was uh the purpose in doing this and as I see it um we have a couple of questions to consider uh tonight um I kind of sense from the email received there might have been an acknowledgement that those currently uh coaching and might have a child in the program it might be too late to change that but the email clearly stated that going forward the district should
226say that you cannot be a coach uh and um have your child on the team so the one question I think for the board is going forward should a coach a play director a band director VI a cloud and Leadership program if if their child is part of the program and I think what we assume last time was we always took the um idea that it would be a vars City coach and then their child would hit there at the 11th grade so it might be a 2year um period of time that they couldn't coach I think it's more than that I mean if we say there's a varsity coach and they have an athletic child and they enter the seventh grade and want to participate and modified and now the other portion of the
227email says our Our concern has to be the appearance of favoritism or bias why wouldn't we say that they have to stop once their child enters the program and therefore that could be a six-year band and maybe if it's a play director their child starts in the play it's a three-year manand so I think there's a lot of ramifications for employment here if this is the path the board chooses to go down the other part of the question was for um volunteer coaches and should they be allowed to uh coach their child I just want the board to know cuz I went and looked this up and it's dramatically changed since I was a coach within the district these are the requirements for a volunteer coach right now they have to have first aid CPR
228and AED certification they have to have a save Workshop certificate um with a $25 fee and all costs that I'm going to site here are borne by the volunteer coach the district does not um incur any of these costs they have to have a child abuse reporting certificate they have to take a concussion management class they have to have a daa workshop certificate $70 cost they have to make an application to New York State Higher Education for a coaching certificate and to apply is a $50 cost and then they have to be fingerprinted and the cost is $925 so my thought is if they're willing to do all that time and take and do all that coursework and then out of pocket incur the financial burden I don't see why we want to turn anybody
229down but those are my opinions and I want to say one last thing and then I'll open it up um the the emphasis was on to uh prioritize fairness and to prevent the perception of bias and that would come through if a Coach was um leading their child within the program I personally do not want to open the scan of worms I don't think this is a road we should walk down because if we're going to go into what people think and perceptions of what is fair every coach may or may not have a brother or sister and if they do that means nieces or nephews now what if the niece or nephew tries out for the program can the coach no longer coach can they have special guidelines um if the coach I'm sure
230they're going to have neighbors I'm sure they're going to have friends similar situation do we now prohibit them because if the perception is fairness then the public can say well that's the neighbor he they automatically get on that coach's team so I think we open a can of Wars we don't want and if really were looking at perception then my question is what about board members that have children in the uh District do we have guidelines for them or prohibitions for them what about administrators in the district that have children in a building that they leave what about them our last two superintendant have had children in the district so what do we do about them so I think this I'll repeat myself I think this is can of worms I don't want to open
231and I'll end with this Carl Bross Doug Chamberlain Tom Skidmore um Jim Keenan and Tommy Jansen all coaches in the district all iconic Co coaches in the district all in the horse heads Hall athletic Hall of Fame all coach their children and when they coached their children the Board of Education trusted them to be professional and trusted that they did the right thing and at least for me I trust the men and women in those positions now and I think they do do the right thing we have heard uh stories of the lengths they've gone to to protect themselves and I think we let them um continue in that fashion sometimes it's just best to do nothing and let it it stay so if there is a motion made to send this to commit I
232I will vote no on that motion all right I open it to anybody else that wants to I was I was glad to see that this made it the agenda and I'm glad that you broke it out because I didn't want to be able to have time to speak and um I have to five minutes on both so I wanted to share a sample policy just to be able to play I understand Warren's point and I listen what everybody said before in the slippery slope I also don't think that that doesn't mean that we can't create standards and say okay if these standards are in place then we can write it down and make it more formable so I was able to find a sample policy from another school district and I thought that it
233was kind of good so I wanted to share it with the board and I can email it over to you guys because I don't think it's a bad idea and I don't think it's a bad idea for the committee to look at it and to come up with ideas and then to also include like the current people because I mean we saw what happened times have changed not to say anything about it but we saw what happened with like the small Frank football in almyra and the coaching and not to say that it wouldn't happen here but maybe this helped Safeguard it so here it is this is the purpose the board of the school directors of the Owen J Roberts School District recognizes the importance of Athletics and wants to ensure that all student
234athletes are treated in an equitable manner consequently except as noted below the board will not permit a parent of a student athlete to serve as a varsity head coach or advisor for a sport in which his her child participates at the same level and it says advisors and then I said guidelines in order to prevent preferential treatment or even the appearance thereof as a general rule parents will not be permitted to coach or advise their own children at the secondary level however the board may allow parents to serve as coaches or advisers at the secondary Level under one or more the following circumstances when an individual is recommended by the building principal and or the athletic director here are those instances that they have written down one the parent is a professional employee of the
235School District Two the parent has distinguished him or herself with years of service as a school district college or professional coach advisor in his or her respective sport prior to the quing or advising of his or her child at the secondary level three the parent has coach advise at secondary level for at least 4 years prior to the time that his or her child is eligible to participate in the sport four the parent is the only qualified applicant for the position in question and the District athletic director and or the building principal determines that the parent would be the best candidate under all circumstances five parents May participate as a volunteer coach or advisor at the discretion of the head coach advisor and the approval of the athletic director any questions or concerned regarding this
236policy or the Athletics in general should be referred to the athletic director so I kind of thought that that wasn't a bad thing I think that that kind of says okay we're not saying that this isn't a thing that is allow like it's not allowed but I think it also helps to have like an extra layer of Safeguard if that level of Safeguard needs to happen because if you I'm not saying that it is going to happen or not going to happen and I don't want to ever um make it difficult for parents or people to be able to participate I think it's really important to be able to have that um but I think right there it spells out kind of all of the issues that waren was talking about too with these could
237be the obstacles but right in in this policy it says that the board can make the decision the athletic director can make the decision the building principal can make the decision anybody who's a professional in the area it just kind of I don't know I I didn't think it was that so that's why I wanted to just bring that for perspective was it ow D young ow J Roberts where's the school I have no idea I just in a Google search for sample policies and guidelines that's not in new YK I don't know where it is but I just thought I was like it's not that it's not really that bad or like if you came up with something that just you know League says they have certain standards you say okay well this is
238our standard just to say this is what we believe in and that's how we feel so I I'm not opposed to having the committee talk about it and to bring something back if um it makes people feel more comfortable you know I don't think that it's going to hurt anything this what is what I think my on what you read is first of all people are quick on Google I can't do that but it's Pennsylvania so that's one of the problems with it uh and then if I heard it correctly they had all these exceptions which virtually gave the administrator and the ad the ability to appoint anybody they want anyway it sounds like somebody there wrote the policy to potentially appease the issue but then open the cave because they I think the first
239thing he said is no parent of a child but then they said but if you're a professional employee you can sometimes writing the policy which even if we wrote something like that that's going to our lawyer and as as a superintendent I'm not giving the authority to anybody else except me or my Des need to hire the reason being is I'm ultimately going to be held responsible for that hire now they may still be part of it policies and regulations and I think Pennsylvania should probably that into more of a regulation that they're trying to follow uh I do understand Warren Point and I just want to emphasize because we had a senior night and I don't mean to call this coach out but I know he he would not have a problem I'm pretty
240sure his name is coach Andy Scott and his youngest daughter is graduating and and he point blank read a letter to her and in that letter he goes I know I was probably hard on you I'm going to miss you and stuff and it's hard being a coach's kid because most likely you get the brunt of it he was I mean Le was doing great not to cry but he Andy wears his heart on the sleeve even though you don't think it and I think that's the emphasis of what you were trying to say about those other coaches it's sort of like with me with my own son being the superintendent here all of those things sort of go into it there's different stressors the big thing is that you know you try to be
241professional about it and there's rules or at least guide posts that we understand that we've got to be mindful of when those situations arise just so the board knows that's all I talked to the A&E committee about and said we need more direction from the board and I will tell you overwhelmingly the coaches said if you do it we can provide good advice for people but don't put something in that says people can't coach that's I think was you both were there well they said they want to be involved they want to be involved to make sure other people don't fall into the Trap that can be there for people that have their kids so I just want to make sure you're hearing all we discussed about it as well so um I 100% agree
242with everything that you said Warren and I I also feel like you know most if not all of our Sports have rubrics that they follow for try outs and things like that so they have the data you know to back the decisions that they're making um I also feel like you know really trying to understand what is the problem we're trying to solve right so is it then the perception of one person five people or is this a recurring issue that we're constantly showing favoritism because I feel like you know there people are always going to have those perceptions because there's always jealousy there's always you know everybody thinks that their kid is the best right um but I think if there's really an issue that issue needs to go to our to our athletic
243director right and then our athletic director needs to manage that with the coaches and you know I think you know we need we need to again you know hold our coaches at a high standard which I feel like we do um you know and I said this at the last board meeting I mean my kids have always had coaches who have had children on the team and I me those coaches have always been role models on how they should coach when their own kids are on a team um my husband was a volunteer coach for several years right when when my kid was on the team and I think that I don't think that I I have not seen enough data that shows that this is actually a problem that we need to be trying
244to solve right now if Damian was getting a lot of complaints and he came to you Tom and said you know hey we're here in this I think this is an issue that we need to try to address and I think that's a different story but um I you know I don't think this is something that we need to make a change to what we're currently doing now um and and you know I think we need to respect the coaches that we have and I think they all do a fantastic job coaches and yeah let's make sure it's not yeah and and that's that's pretty much what I was going to say too I mean when we get into um the extracurriculars you're looking at a really finite group of people that that can do
245these skills you know and we they happen to have children here in the district and you know it is it is what it is you know I mean I feel like there there can be regulations or protocols put into place that can give those recommendations to folks because they may be questioning themselves they might say well how do I handle this situation when I have my own child on uh in this club or on this team and that's a conversation with the athletic director um and also an accountability conversation with your team right and and if you trust your team and your team has this conversation and says you know hey bub I feel like you're doing giving uh you know impartial treat to your kid well let's have a conversation about that let's be
246professionals about it maybe I recuse myself from this audition or maybe I remove myself from the conversation that involves placement of my child on a team these are all things that can be brought to the attention and part of an initial onboarding for our coaches and extracurricular committees I don't think we need to put a policy around it because I think we have to be careful about that will alienate a really large population of our employees and of our parents in the community we we are constantly asking parents to come out we say please please come out help we need the help we need you on the field we need you in the classroom we need you um to sew this behind the scene you know whatever it is um and I think we want
247to continue to encourage those people to come out be supportive of our students be supportive of the staff supportive of our programming and um that's all I have to say I would vote no on anything that would um try to put something into place that would remove um parents from working with their students children damn just briefly it's been a long long night I agree wholeheartedly with with Warren Christine with Aron I mean frankly as I listen to Warren I feel like we we had a solution looking for a problem you know and uh there are in my view there are already other controls in place that address this for example rubrics in the trial process or requirements in the contract as to the fact that um you know District employees have a preference over
248somebody from the outside coming in and just wanting to coach their kid for example right and if if you know then the the process of pulling somebody up the apps process we have we have requirements around that so someone can just unfetter do what they want and then lastly I do think if it were a problem I have full faith and confidence in the athletic director that he would handle it uh if you know we have oversight um through him through the superintendent and ultimately we had a problematic coach the board could choose not to um reappoint that person the following years I mean there are these existing controls that are in place and and I don't think there's any sort of a pervasive issue that warrants um a formal policy or any interaction at
249this point um I will be honest I do give my daughter preferential treatment of thing uh she is the voice I hear when the kids are talking I can hear her immediately and she becomes my the what I want everyone else to do I call her out more than I would call anyone else out because I know her I know what I can expect out of her and absolutely look at her to be my leader however that preferential treatment only goes that far because I know as a parent that my daughter should be the one that is the leader in the room and showing every other student how they should be acting if she's disrespectful then everyone else is going to be disrespectful to me it so I keep my daughter in check so when
250we say preferential that's what I mean I will say as a parent who is a volunteer if this does go any further than this we'll have to add um intermediate drama club to the roster for the budget because I couldn't do it and it would have to be a Sten position um I think as a parent who has coached as a parent who is volunteering my time I agree with Warren we absolutely should trust in our coaches and our leadership that they can do this and they've been doing it and I would also vote now Julie I'm just do speak I mean the vote will already not pass but that's okay so um so again I was the one that drafted the email but after a discussion last meeting we I understood that there couldn't
251be a policy put in place and the intention of the email was not to never have coaches with kids in the program not coach that's not feasible in this District I understand that but rather to establish guidelines that protect both our student athletes coaches and anyone who does participate in extracurricular activities that does have a family member or a coach or parent guiding that program there istismar of retaliation but it does and I think we're burying our heads in the sand to think that it doesn't now I'm not saying that any means that our coaches aren't fantastic because I agree with all of you that our our coaches and extracurricular activity directors are absolutely fantastic and I've heard a lot of they're already doing this they recuse themselves from selections they are very careful they
252ask other people to do things and that's fantastic but if they are already doing that stuff then why not put guidelines in place that actually protect them and also their student who might be seeing that behavior or feeling that people are looking at them because of their relationship with someone so all I was asking for essentially is guidelines to be put in place that prevent preferential treatment we're I've heard multiple times that we use a rubri selection and it's blind and that I've heard that we recuse some of the coaches refuse themselves from the team selection so these are all things that are already happening then what is the issue with putting a guideline not a policy in place that actually States hey if you aren't doing this this is the best practice and we
253recommend that you do because it's going to protect everyone involved we got to remember that both coaches and extracurricular people most of the time except for volunteers are stien position therefore they're actually being paid by the tax taxpayers right so we need to protect them from that netism and biased behavior and that perception that's out there so if we have these best practices and guidelines in place we can say when we hear that [Music] eptisa we're protecting them we're protecting the student who is going through it might be hearing it from their peers or their peers might be in aess bullying without us even knowing this is happening I can't imagine that it's easy to coach your own child it's got to be extremely difficult but like Li said you mentioned your own children and
254and working with them in the drama club it's human nature for us to also hear our own child's voice first it's human nature in regardless of how we respond to that that's human nature so I'm not by any means saying that we should put a policy in place that prevents people and although that might have done what my original email was our previous discussions led me to think no we can't ever do that but I would like to us to heavily consider working with the athletic committee to put guidelines in place that are become best practices for all of our extracurricular and our coaches to have so that they can actually protect themselves protect that nepotism and bias behavior and stereotype that does occur and it shows that we're not actually just turning our heads
255to it and pretend you know everyone's doing these best practices because some of these coaches and Warren you mentioned a lot of really great amazing coaches and I played for some of them and I've been part of the program and I've been part of the school and I didn't necessarily see it happen I don't see it happening to my own children but I do think it does happen at times and I think that maybe we just have these in place to prevent that from happening in the future and as a guideline to help those that maybe aren't as comfortable or aren't as familiar with how to handle it and that's what I was asking for to consider those guidelines thank you um I said this the last meeting I still feel that way I don't
256think it's a can of worms meeting to open I think that there will always be a perception whether you're a volunteer or whether you're coach or whether you're you know when war coach you know I'm sure people said well that's the favorite she's going to be there she's going to pitch every game there's always that perception and by making guidelines you're not going to change those perceptions those perceptions will still stay there and even though you can refer people back to the guidelines they're going to say they don't needan anything because they're still doing it and I don't think as a board we should make a policy for that and we're not it's not really our job to make guidelines and I don't think the athletic department needs to unless black Department was hearing a
257lot but there's several coaches that Warren didn't even name that have coached their children and it definitely would not be fair for a coach who would coached 10 years and then their child suddenly came on their team that they couldn't coach anymore I mean I don't we and I don't I know jul that's not what you wanted I I I understand it I hear what you're saying you wanted guidelines but I don't see the need to do that to people because hor that's you know I've been in the district 40 some years and there's always gra artism someplace it's people's perception and you're not going to change that I don't think we should you know discourage if we write the guidelines I think we'll discourage volunteers and I think you'll you'll have people thinking twice
258that do music or do extra curricular if your child is involved and I don't think I personally don't think we need to do that I just want to say something briefly sue you kind of cover it but I mean as a formal matter the board only sets policy right so we either would enact a policy on this or or if the ath the Athletics and extra committees is a superintendence committee which so of their own valtion if they thought this was a problem they could talk about it and create guidelines but as a formal matter the board is you know we could only create policy or do nothing so I mean I'm not necessarily like like obviously we already have some controls there in place you could call those you could imagine there being guidelines
259but frankly I think it's not our jurisdiction I'd say it's within the province of that committee and the a record superintendent to see if that's necessary yeah and what I would add is when we talk to the A&E and I think I don't think the coaches were against trying to say hey here's best practices for their handbook keep this in mind because people out there I I don't I don't think that will discourage people because the handbook is really a guide for the coach to know hey I mean that is why I brought in the r procedure because probably 8 n years back there was some concern even though it was very superficial here or there but the coaches were very good about saying saying hey here's some rubrics here's some things that help make
260it as more objective based than subjective but there's always going to be some subjectivity I do believe that's happened in like our theatrical casting because I've been in there when they're casting and sometimes there's some kids that are too close to people and people have said hey I'm just back in away you tell me what best will work that's the professionalism and I think if the and e or if we want to do something we will only focus anything on trying to make sure our coaches or our athletic advisors have something to help give them the ability to say hey watch out for these but they weren't averse to talking about it at all because they all said we've seen different things so I think you're right Dan I mean officially outside of the policy
261I can do that just didn't want to go down the road before sorry turn that um go ahead Noe um I mean I just want to say that I know that maybe right now we don't have those issues you know my kids are younger and I have had issues in the sporting World recently that have come up with coaches and I'm assuming that these coaches will be coming eventually the coaches of the district as they so chose um and I've already I've seen a lot of it already what has happened with different issues and I'm not I I take it more specifically to sports because that's very competitive and it's it's different than the than other not to say that plays and casting rules is not competitive it it is but um I've seen it
262and the and the younger coaches we those other coaches were older people had a different standard of how they practice things and I from I can't like throw out personal examples but like I could but I'm not going to do that yet but I I don't I don't think it's a bad I don't think it's a bad idea I don't I don't think that what Julie is trying to do is by any means try to discourage anybody I think that it's trying to um have preventive measures in place and I don't think that the people in the district are that unintelligent to put in something that would be not good if that makes sense and I I I hear what everybody else is saying like oh it's can of worms we don't have to spend
263our time on on it but I um I can see that having a standard is I the rubrics all those things so if we have those different things like then I would just maybe you can show them to us and we can see them or maybe they're online but I I he you Julie just I I think that um to Dan's point it's it's not really a Board responsibility so I think that's up to to Damian and how he wants to run his athletic department right so you know I mean if he sees the need to have these formal guidelines which you know knowing Damian I'm sure he already is doing that informally and not already formally with his coaches um then you know I think it's I think that falls in his level of
264responsibility not not the board at okay um just is a they didn't include our character CU we're talking primarily about coaches but no I was I didn't want current employees I knew there were current employees Andy Scott yeah I did I was doing the historical all right anyway um board member comments is does anybody have a board member comment Christine um I have two uh first one um the ad hoc committee for the board evaluation that we um approved a resolution for the last meeting we did have our first meeting um a few weeks ago we made um some really good early progress on on looking at the board evaluation but so I just want to everybody know that we did meet um and we're meeting again in February so we everybody updated um and
265we send out minutes so you saw those and then the last thing I just want to say is I just want to recognize um Alicia tus and two of our students they recently represented um New York Special Olympics in Washington DC where they had the opportunity to meet with government officials and to really advocate for the funding of un right Sports um and you know this program has um started uh in horse heads in 2017 2018 well with the unified and Yak um started in the in 2017 in 2018 and I think you know all three of my kids were involved and and the really neat thing and and I really credit um Alicia for this really is be because she has continued to stay in contact with them to get their feedback and and
266and ideas from them but they've all carried that outside of high school they've carried it with them in college they've carried it with them in the community service that they are doing on their own um and how they have been influencing others and I just think you know having having three people from our district be able to recogn you know to represent for heads at that level um is just really commendable so just wanted to give a shout out for for anybody who didn't know that that happened um thank you I wanted to second that I actually wanted to acknowledge Alicia as well and those students that was absolutely fantastic um I wanted to wish any of the students going into sectionals or States um the best of luck as well those um participate in
267the upcoming flight and um the only other question I have is can you remind me if we as a district participated in the regionalization needs assessment that Bose had that they put out and if we I just didn't remember if we did or not uh we participated but we also discussed it and we are opting out of formally being part of it even though like I said we're still going to attend they're just not going to force the cost upon us so like I know we talked just the other day they're setting up U an introductory one um another meeting I think within two weeks of coming back and I've already got it on my schedule to go one of the things I talked to him about you want a good regionalization that hockey would
268just because they're looking for something simple easy to do quick that they can see see successful was there a reason that we chose not to participate was it a cost absolutely we bear the cost and people get the benefit from work okay thank you I have two things to share um first just recently within the past couple of weeks um students from our horse heads choirs went down and attended the S strong uh competition down on Long Island there were two groups that participated uh they are student Le Acappella groups which means the students come together on their own without guidance from really anybody else they practice in their homes sometimes they practice in the schools um but they have uh a whole little student organization of groups of kids they come together they pick
269their music they choreograph they um do all of the work themselves and then they go down to this competition and they sing their little hearts out and they did an absolutely amazing job so um Round of Applause for tonee and for pitch please who worked so hard in this competition they were great um so that is my first comment my second comment is uh horse heads Green Room players will be featuring into the woods in the horse heads High School auditorium March 13th and 14th at 700 p.m. and March 15th at 2: p.m. and 700 p.m. so two shows on that Saturday tickets are $12 a piece for students and senior citizens and $15 for adults you can purchase tickets online or you can purchase tickets at the door and this is a tough musical
270into the woods it's by St sonheim his music is up so I think the last time this was performed in horse heads it was something like 1992 and there's a reason for that it's hard the music is hard so come and see these kids perform um at one two or three or four performances thanks good can add to erand uh like we do every year if the board members wish us T night for you and the significant other please just let Terry know the night the time of the show and we will get do passes for those nights as a thank you for helping the support let's I turn off two quick things I just wanted wanted to congratulate the cast at the middle school of Matilda Jr it was a wonderful show and to
271see what those kids could pull together in such a short amount of time it was really cool um and also this week I had the pleasure of being in the audience for the all district Orchestra where we got to hear um fourth grade through uh seniors Orchestra play you it was very neat the way that Matthews said it you could hear how um they progressively got better and better uh it was really cool and they all played one song at the end I just wanted to give a shout out to that program it was really neat to see them all come together and be on stage um I just wanted to say that um I have a concern of the time and how late the elementary students will be starting um parents who you know
272have to be to work by8 that think that's a tough time and I know when we approved the high school time um there was some of us who felt that that was too early for high school and I'm just I'm just adding my comment again that I'm very concerned about the way the times are going to be and maybe we should go to one busing system and have them all somewhere that's just my thought can I ask what you need that like K and 12 like in the old days know I understand that I was in that front seat for a long time uh you well because the kids are all from the same neighborhood it's um it just um going to school that late little kids are up early I mean you know parents
273will say these guys are up at 6 o' by the time you get them into school they're ready for their morning nap you know especially the little ones and um so I just have a real concern about that um because even them out and call them someplace to have care and then get them to school that's that's two or three hours of their day before they get to where they have to sit the seat and start learning and um so I really have a big concern about the CH still I also have a big concern about the times the um way um that we didn't have any understanding about when those elementary students were going to have when when they were going to come um kids world I believe mom Sue told me my mom
274that um state law says that they're only allowed to have one daycare thing in the school I think this is something that we have a discussion about I try to have a discussion about this and have this on the agenda a very long time ago um um because I think that the elephant in the room is the busing and this is why we have to have our time so spread apart and this issue is not going to go away a long time ago there wasn't funding for busing that's why they had East schools and West schools that's why you had neighborhood schools if you want to get creative on the budget for a long-term fix we have to get creative in that way we have to get creative in okay maybe we have east and
275west maybe we have K through 6 maybe we have K through 8 maybe we have have to high like we people are going to have to walk to school we cannot continue to sustain this we have to start having out of the box conversation but the one thing that I did want to talk about a long time ago that was denied to be on the presentation but Warren when we got to say his piece I'm going to read the statement and this comes from the long range planning for the educational facilities and in this spot and in this part it says thoughtful planning on the part of the Board of Education working in conjunction with the administrative staff and teachers as well as with the architect and the engineer this comes from the state it
276doesn't say the administration gets to have a workshop and pick out which model they think is best we wouldn't lose all of our funding we could change the model and still get it you can reconfigure it any way you want to right now not only have we displaced a school full of elementary school teachers they told you tonight the union came and said the anxiety is palpable what's going to happen when these teachers go and teach how is that going to affect our kids and then people show up and we don't even acknowledge them and we go through a whole meeting without saying anything about it and pretend like we've discussed it because we haven't you can't say that you have because the only time that you guys have said that you've had this discussion
277was in a retreat when there were no minutes taken the PE these are our community people so let's have a workshop and a discussion and hash it out let's get them up here and hear their concerns because guess what the state guidelines say the Board of Education and here's another thing from it as a final word of caution the Board of Education May delegate the various activities and the commensurate authority needed to carry out those activities for a successful Capital project to anyone they choose however the responsibility to assure proper procedures are followed through the entire Capital project ultimately remain with the Board of Education this is my school district I was I came up through horid and I don't even recognize it I see the teachers that I went to school with and they
278are crushed they are crushed right now and what are we doing about it to help them I am going to make a motion right now that we create a survey for our teachers to see how we are doing as a board of education I want to hear directly from the staff give me a rating 1 through 10 that could be the only question but I want to survey I want to create it I want to know how we're doing because I think that we should hear the feedback from the people because there are so many people and they come and I was one of them too I had so many questions at a March meeting that's why I ran for the board I had so many questions and we all just sat here everybody sat
279here and stared at me and I'm like this isn't hores this isn't what I where I came from I my heart is broken right now for what this District currently is and it's not to say anything against the administration everybody has a hard job and they're doing their job and making the best decisions they can based on what they think the board wants because the board doesn't have enough conversations all we do is approve the agenda we don't get to put things on the agenda today Julie did for the first time we don't get to openly say this is what we want on the agenda let's have a work session let's have discussion none of that stuff is happening it needs to happen because the people in our community deserve it we all get to
280have a seat at the table we all to have a discussion about it you know it's not like you meet with a demographer one time and oh somebody else has it it doesn't it doesn't work that way I'm not blaming anybody it's nobody's fault I'm not saying this but like Kae said our budget these problems aren't going away electric busing isn't going away lady's time is expired okay well that's I have my motion on the table do I have a second I'll second what's the motion I want a survey created to hear from our staff on how they think the board is doing we get to vote okay discussion discussion Katrina you're you're obviously passionate and I and I admire that but I think there were so many inaccuracies in what you just said it's
281almost hard to respond to the board has been incredibly involved in the oversight of capital projects the last nine years of my life I've spent hundreds of hours here being involved in the oversight of capital projects to insinuate otherwise is frankly insulting and the vote on how the board is doing occurs when you run for election there's no special survey to see how the board is doing I just um again you know your passion is is admirable but quite frankly and I say this with all due respect you're wasting our time asking about drum pedals you want to know what kind of a drum pedal the district plot that is so outside of the province of a board of education member you want to know which teachers got the laptops that we bought the hell
282does that matter to the board of Education that's why we pay the administration to run the district okay I think you should focus on what the board should be focused on and what our role is and you know maybe when we function a little more efficiently and effectively that's all just want to add one thing you know the comment you made about you know people comly speak you know to the board and you know we just sit there and stare and when you came and you had all these questions the open public comment is not a back and forth it's part of our policy our policy is that anybody can come and they can say or they can ask a question or they can make a comment but it is not a two-way dialogue it's
283not an open Forum this is our Board of Education business meetings so you know it's a privilege to be able to offer that for people to be able to come and be able to share with them but we're not going to I mean unless we were to change our policy but we're not going to sit here and continue have back and forth because that is not the purpose of this meeting and we take that we listen to that and then we all have that in our heads most of the time either our president or our superintendent will have some level of response or it'll be discussed later on in the board meeting um but so I just I just wanted to correct that that that's that is not the intent of the public comment I
284also want to say as Christine had shared this is our public board meeting there are many other times during the course of a day of a week of a month that I'm having conversation with Tom that I'm bringing things to him it that we may have a conversation about things um it's not that these things are falling on death ears by by any stretch of the imagination I think sometimes a lot of the when when community members come up to the podium I think it's best to take a moment to reflect on what they're saying to respond immediately may not be in our best interest either individually or as a group right so sometimes there's moments where you need to take that reflection to think about things to research things to ask the questions that
285that need to be asked and then people don't see those conversations that that we have you know Tom Pro Tom probably talks to all of us a multiple times a week I I feel bad you I'm sorry we're always calling you or texting you right or asking asking questions and I don't think the community sees that you know and we and I do applaud your uh as as Dan said you are passionate because you care right you really care and that comes across but just as many people and I think I've said this before that come and talk to you are also coming and talking to each one of us individually and and I'm hearing things that are Maybe different than what folks are sharing to you I'm I'm hearing a lot of positive things
286I'm hearing a lot of thank yous I'm hearing a lot of these these different things I'm hearing about people you know being nervous about the changes that are coming about but not not hating them either understanding the the purpose of why why they're happening so I want that understanding to be known that maybe there's there's a certain feeder group that are coming to you but there's certain people that are coming to us as well and saying things that maybe aren't as negative okay and and that we are having conversations and and taking things that are being said into into account but maybe we're having those conversations directly with Tom I agree with Dan your passion is amazing krina honestly like it is amazing but change is hard it's scary it's hard and from these seats
287we need to show confidence in our district leadership confidence in the decisions that are being made I know we don't know all the answers yet because we simply don't know the answers yet um things take time and I know that is the worst to sit on the edge waiting when you hear okay it's coming it's coming and you want to know when when will I know this will be over um I get it the anxiety is through the roof however I do agree that when it's time for the public to share their feedback there is also the um board email to send comments share those with us we if you have things to say we want to know um but as far as I understand that's not being utilized as well I received seven emails
288and those were to me but that's sorry G apologize for your tail um that's the foundation what we ask for for our question and answers and we will have those up we've already started them Sam has I think some scheduled to go up tomorrow and then uh you know let me comment you heard from the teachers unit tonight that's part of their issue because they have internal issues where they negotiated absolutely most of this two years ago and they have been part of our discussions every time we get together for 2 years they knew and we've said here most likely secondary at 720 because we need to align to bosis or 840 we're not exactly sure but that's pretty much going back to where we were for the elementary our Elementary start 8:15 to 8:25
289there's a 10 minute Shi do we have to try to work on the other things that we heard from like Mrs and others yes and we're making that commitment we've got to go through it but because they come and we don't answer doesn't mean we're not listening I agree thank you Aaron I anybody that calls me anybody that sends me an email usually gets a response if I get 40 questions a day before a board meeting I try to get back I may not have all the answers and that was brought up tonight the reason why we don't have all the answers is because everybody in this room was working to get where we were for tonight but you know what tomorrow those unanswered things will probably take a little more of a stage but
290that whether it's a board member that does it whether they have sticky notes or something here or there we try to address it if you reach out our offices have been open to any board member any time and I've said this over the past two full years and some have never come in so it's easy to say that passion's one thing actions also have to have follow through we follow through with everybody whether it's a good conversation we know or whether it's a bad conversation we're probably dreading because we know what's going to be on the other end of the phone whether it was Sue whether it's Sam whether it's Terry I don't believe anybody will say I've never called them back or out and back to or the district has it because that's our
291responsibility even when it's difficult and we will continue to do that we make our s available but we listen to everything just like we listen to the teachers everything they said some of it was new but some of it they've negotiated but their membership's mad at them but they didn't mind taking the raises that they approved for those same elementary teachers and we're two years past that and they knew this day was coming so we can't go back and the decisions are made okay but we have a motion on the floor I a question I okay um I just want to reiterate what Dan said I've been here since the start of the construction project for 3 weeks every other day from 4: to 8 I was in a meeting with president presentations from all
292of the um companies that wanted this bid we ultimately selected hunt and Weller but the board was there for the whole time just cuz you weren't there doesn't mean nine other people weren't there elected by the community to make those decisions and when hunt and Welliver finally were given the bid they came in and gave their thoughts and board members had input to them the fact that you wen't there doesn't mean a board wasn't doing things so like Mr Christmas I resent the fact that you are saying the board wasn't doing anything the fact that you weren't there doesn't mean other people W call a [Music] question I just had another question but I don't sorry I just had a question but I think it doesn't I was just going to ask do we do
293morale studies all with staff at all have we ever done yes we did PLC did it at a cost of about $90,000 a year uh when I don't know when that was 2015 2016 and we the board it just I'm sorry I don't have my thing on uh that sort of came to the end because one of the things weren did not mention that was the hiring piece but there was another piece of about a Community Committee of about 50 constituents that developed the educational components of horse heads 2030 where we had Parents we had teachers we had administrators and board members that sort of put out the framework for everything that we're doing right now even the consolidation as well as before that the district had the consolidation study and the merger study all
294of that was around 2010 to 2012 then 2012 to 2015 and this latter part that committee for horse heads 2030 where we did follow everything with the state all took place and this is sort of the precipitous of everything so but that's when we did I'm sorry so you're saying that was on the old strategic plan and that's when the the last morale study essentially was done for sta but it's not a morale study what Katrina is asking is a study of how they feel about survey survey yeah survey about how they feel about the board I understand I was just didn't know if we did morale studies or not studies exing morale surveys with SE at all or if we ever we've done them not necessarily the morale because of the fact that morale
295is very subjective culture or things to look on or highlights yes thank you okay I get my last rebuttle um also I'm going to submit these for the record so that they have them where I highlighted it because tonight we heard from the you had your opportunity to speak it's time to call no this is a different section than the noral time talk no you've had your time to speak now it's time to call the question all in favor I am absolutely in favor of hearing directly oos any extenstions okay so three four and five against I move to adjourn second CL a question on favor oppos extensions us