001January 16th mon monthly board meeting Al H Central School District you please stand and join me honoring America by fled I of the United States of America and to the repu for which it stands one nation under God all right I need a motion to adjourn to Executive session for the purpose of discussing individual tener fs and a potential legal issue all in favor postens I thank you will ad to executive session and hopefully be back by 6 o' information um and want to hear from you because you don't want to hear from me so congratulations Mia on your part play right thank you very much thank you very play prce all right so now we go to the uh on the agenda uh section two which is the approval of the minut can I
002have a motion please questions disc questions inquiries all in fav minut iose substantially I Terry has indicated to me there are no uh people or individuals that have signed up uh for section three which is the community questions and comments so we will move all the way to section five because we already Hades and that will be uh report from the superintendent and I believe we're going to go right to 5.02 nope 51 okay I should be quicker I hope second thank you sir okay now well L thank you Mr members of the board that are here tonight just couple minutes we're going to get the presentation on the for buing at this point for next year that being wor time to be put into place uh there's a couple things first of all um
003we have a new craning every staff member every every Co that's to you it's the new mandatory reporter training and now every board member must also complete that TR no later than April 15 it's the mandated repor uh the new law says work number bus drive bus dri so we're going to be putting those things in place but we just wanted to give you that notice that uh you'll be seeing an email from uh pho go through the process you'll have to complete it and then we have to file it with State ad for every board member it must be completed by April 15 today anything after April 15 no longer uh in addition I'm being asked just to let you know beforehand that music program tends to go4 years to they're trying to switch
004it up a little that may ask would we be a I'm going to Disney but not Flor c um I did tell them I don't have any real concerns but it's not right now so one of the only things I told them is they must make sure and ensure that administrator must there wouldn't be that mod I would be the trip overse or something that I think that dist the item he do it for a while so we never know what's going on um but Mak sure that everybody proper so you'll probably see that the next month I told be or somebody they went I think London in yeah I think okay I think the only difference that would be F the one ulation because they do have a booster no be behind they have
005that no can't remember if next year I think two years yeah 2023 do so every child at Le once during your high school has the opportun yes I'm done okay so I think a couple years out to me you're ask this question and know nobody doing the same TY ofos but I think that um it would be something that you talk about or develop uh I don't know if you Havey on this or if you have not just for mus think it would be for trips anywhere across the board for everyone is this is what it's how it functions and how it works you know you're asking us for permission but we're not really doing it the like asking asking you you have any problems at which time they develop papery the otherwise not um
006in regards to the B trip then I'll ask them to start the paperwork and basically that will come in in form of a resolution because it's an over trip and once the board puts is basically authorizing even a couple years out so they can start fundraising because fundraising brings potential liability of I fundrais this why don't I get the money for out of it the money stay so that's what the for and allow um either the booster club or activity fund to set aside uh the board is going to enter into treat uh on the 30th for rec to have a discussion uh I need to inform board as I was looking for a facilitator and B and I been talking unfortunately the facilitators that we've gone out to have been not available for the
007date weed one day or has they sort of research it that's indicated that there're probably not for that type of discussing uh among the board so I do not have anybody I to Dan uh we talked about actually corporate but really we have some ideas we need the board to kind to talk about that during GE uh bo comment what would you like and how would you like to handle as far as that we have I think did come back we at the end of this message it's going to get a little wonky just because of the fact that the high school goes into region pleas the elementary was shutting down shutting down ending the first half of the year and then January 27 year off from 8th grade to 12th grade for a conference
008day year GI and then the elementaries were in on that day but then everybody's in on Tuesday and then everybody Bost on Wednesday because remember that then they'll be back in uh cons we are in the process of starting develop 2526 calendar that calendar will probably have coule months uh but Easter weekend is early uh which going to Regional issues and later days so that Challen to get in all of longer it was vacation so uh as far as thater we are battling below well so there couple things on your microphone on the side of each of your microphones you have value so arrows up and down you can utilize those can do that a little bit holding up close to your and this m does work extremely well in this position as you can
009see the only problem is if this mic is on it trumps all the other um and you're turn this one down too hello okay um so that's all I have right now we've got a lot of good things coming on but the end of the even Tri we do have uh still our lot of snow days left we try to use those but with the oncoming the potential heat issues uh that have been enacted by the governor they're going to be very sparingly that people should be uh aware that if we ever use all these days we're going to vote I it just please be aw in regards to next year we said we' come we tolded that basically we came to the board really speak assistance just whether high school should be early uh
010or late we ended up making that decision but that decision just helps us position where the high school is when we do with start times and bus times which is up on U board at this point okay I found the button finally um so we you remember this the continuing a build September through November won't SP much time we miss pretty much most of those uh and we're really on this one continuing the build and we're in January 2025 in January 2025 for tonight we are trying to get the approximate 2025 26 schol start times being announced and now once they're announced the actual stand boox that helps us determine which is the best Avenue to go forward will be converted into the draft to try to narrow in even more on those start Ty
011and I'll show you that in a minute so basically in February the dis District bus routings will start to be developed for next year and then by May roughly we should have the exact times for start time all I mean by the times that I'm announcing today you'll see we'll have a plus or minus maum it might be plus two minutes plus three minutes minus two minutes minus three minutes because we have to do that to fine tune the travel time pickup time between the district and the buildings that we're using so with that we remember District start time and bu and goal one was to align High School start times with both start times as best possible two correct our current late bus arrival times in the morning caused by conflicting school start and
012end time this isn't just late the bus arrivals in the morning this is also in the afternoon sometimes it takes up to 20 to 30 minutes for the buses to arrive late after the kids have already gotten out at the middle school and 20 to 40 minutes at the high school so that's one of the problem a lot of us is fated by the fact that the Elementary start times and end times school days roughly 6 hours and 5 hours 55 minutes so the other one is to minimize bus to bus transfer districtwide another we send our buses out and they're constantly transfering different points on bus and bus all over the as well as unify that we do we currently cannot dismiss the Intermediate Middle School if there's an Emer form Le cannot do
013that because they're entirely different bus Cs and buses that we use that go all over the this for the Intermediate School different than what we use the right and then limit student ride time this was the big one to one hour or less time the bus is been lotion as best possible adhering to the current Staffing is best possible for physical responsibility in the last one addressed the new extended instructional time for cage gr k36 which is contractual so these were all the goals we were trying to do we ended up going through and you can see the current District start time Middle School 7:45 10 time 305 total time 7 hours 20 minutes all of this will be placed up on the website after the freeing dat in addition High School time is 7:50
014they get out of 302 for 7 hour and 12 minute T the Intermediate School is 8:25 roughly 220 even though a lot of our schools are starting to dismiss at 210 220 225 just to try to keep your buses close so it does break up educational time but 5 hours and 50 or 5 hours 55 minutes below the minimum time needed to even address New York's re part 90 hours a year that's why contract we had to make J elementary schools at 6 hours and 5 minutes they would just barely there if you had snow day go below so the M the middle school ends up having like $1,100 hours to year the high school until we fixed the activity period only had 8 985 hours 9 the high school's all Tak care Middle School's
015all Tak care with a contractual ship where we are 6 hours 46 minutes for elementary to that will take care of all our AR so with that the current District start time we have several options we have one option I will tell you it was a pred option High School would started at 7:20 people are going to get mad when they hear this but High School would started at 720 we would have go all the way back out and pick up Intermediate Middle School around the whole District that would started about e26 and then it would have to come back drop them off and then it would have to go out and pick up just the boundary areas and because there's a delay in the shortness of the day 646 for S hours you don't
016add in that extra 15 minutes of space so the buses don't jum up that the Elementary start time if we did that perfectly tier which handle every one of our goals would have been about 9:30 Administration we aren't cool so that was one and that would has increased the amount of buses we needed and Staffing just because of the fact that our district is so large and we happy to watch to full time a lot of our districts are going to take you 12 us that that is probably the easiest the most efficient because you only go out once and pick them all up but where our schools are located and the amount of time students would have to actually ride and wait at one School wait at another school and go to the other
017school that would have roughly had the same effect as that three tier and that one has met our goal some people will say well why don't you just do what you do now that that transfer issue we could do it but we're going to even be later because we're going to have a couple schools and we still have to make that difference between the high school route and the middle middle school route because as you can see it's only 5 minutes to start need need 20 to 25 minutes usually so we looked at that we even looked at can you offet all of the way that we do it now we go to the Middle School say at 720 we go to the high school at 740 but it's not as easy as saying okay
018now we're going to go to the inter mediate or Elementary School at like 810 because their days shorter remember you got to add on that 15 with 15 minute difference so now 810 you're really looking at one of the schools at 8815 to 830 to start and then 15 to 20 minutes after so you're in the same situation but that would have cleaned it up so when we were looking at all of these goals we ended up finding one that pretty much H every single one of those gos this was sort of what I was talking about and what the problem is number we have to meet that time so new starting in 2025 26 it is the exra hour to that day right there in the box so if you were looking at it
019right now just this year we would be going from 825 to roughly about three 14 or 316 so next year we still want to changes the book at then elementary schools would have been getting out of 316 Middle School 305 High School 302 we would need almost 120 bues to do that stest but that what was so the 2425 start time we have to look at the middle school and what happens is we have to actually shape it because Middle School and High School are together actually put me 25 I was going to mention that we have to shift because the middle school and theary school is 6 hours and 50 minutes and 6 hours and 46 minutes they're less than the high school so you always have to put the left time first because
020you drop them off and then they get out first bus plac they run so what happens is the intermediate go 710 to 720 to 210 but really understand that the middle school is 6 hours and 50 minutes the intermate school is 6 hours 46 we did that perfectly because of buing that they can fit within the day and get the intermediate school out within the schedule before the middle school kids and also have some time in the morning for breakfast and they get there early and they still time so Intermediate School kids if they if they're bucked out there at 7:19 they go in they can still get right Middle School can get grab and go middle school starts at 7 point so we'll adjust this in find time again you see the yellow plus
021and minuses they're plus and minuses because of the fact that these are the rough times and this is so people can plan N9 months out we're probably plus or minus five at the moment high school would be plus or minus 7:30 remember we've got to play with that 20 minutes you can't go from the middle school and Media School to the high school in 10 minutes and pick up and drop off but if we can try to go one way or the other we do minutes Mr 2 minutes the other Y at 14 minutes so that's what the bus garage has to do when it refines IT prop they have a stun out and then the elementary schools have a 6 hour and 46 minute day because of the time that it takes to go
022out and come back Elementary will start at 8:40 plus or minus and out at 3:26 plus or minus now if you notice why is 8:40 and 720 or 730 roughly up there there that's what we started down the road if all of a sudden a future board it won't be why I'm here but a future board says hey we want to switch that because we see some different benefits the other school is aligned with bosies already that you can virtually F there would be some risting that would have to go on to do it but not as much but it's meant purposely that so when you look at it the plus or minus will be determined in the spring when specific star end times will be completed from the bus garage in their final draft
023form because we don't finalize bus routes until August because we don't do a rollover until July so we've got to get it with this year's kids first so that we know it works and then next year kids we just start all over from July the district will also implement this two-tier busing uh system switching from transporting grade 7 through 12 and K through six respectively to 5 through 12 and K through four respectively if you think about it kindergarten through six has the same grade level disparagement across the grade as 5 through 12 your kindergarten is riding with a sixth grade your fifth graders were when they're in kindergarten is with riding with that same sixth grade now will there be differences yes that's why we have a professional bus staff that's why we have
024a a process of seeding charts and we will try to look if we can with potential of uh monitors if we can do that because this whole schedule is why the administrative recognized it is because it met every single one of these it's the only schedule did and it meets the current staffing needs that we have and it still has requirement we are not doing this to reduce Staffing we could use those Staffing in other situations within the trans a if we had a need for Less bus driv but guess what there's no District that has a need for Less bus D so our administrative uh position is we select the best one that met the goals that we were given we've worked it out the best we can this is what's going into place
025for next year questions real quick and anything that didn't a letter just so you know letter will be going home to parents tomorrow and stff tomorrow indicating everything sorry is my mic enough or do you want me to use that other mic okay um so you're G to bust kids five five through 12 are going to be all together on one bus when you go out and you do the run now and then what they're going to drop off like we Intermediate Middle and then drop off the high schoolers on the bus is that the idea behind it going P can somebody get that back up there for me thank you um I think if I remember your question say it's like we said by2 according to what we just showed the kids will all
026get picked up but when the bus comes into the district it's going to end first at the Intermediate Middle School drop them off they end up having the shortest ride of everybody we don't count when the bus is stopped that is right when the bus goes from there over to the high school with the high school kids then they will get off we have been told pretty much almost every single run is 15 minutes your life okay and then pick up would be the same thing they go to the middle school Intermediate School pick up go to the high school pick up go drop off then come back do El than just so that people know when they look at this we'll get the we'll make it edit to it so it doesn't add that
02724 25 St time but see how it at 720 720 those kids are the 5 through uh 8 and then High School 7:30 it might be 78 32 it just depends what we can see and then Elementary go right in the order of the drop and that would be the order of the drop coming back not about the bu I did look up we do you have a policy oh sorry um I just look it up we do have a field trips and Excursion h 531 um and I just have one question about the high school my on yeah I can hear all right just um the high school the drop off I get it plus orus 7:30 what time do the buses in the high school if you're a b student what time they
028leave the campus to go to bis they have to be up at bis roughly at 9:00 preferably they could be up there 9:02 9:03 right but what time do they leave our they would leave roughly right around 8:45 8:50 so where do they hang out for plus or minus they don't hang out anymore they go to a class this is the best that's first thing I didn't put on now all the students there are no book end classes anymore they have a class either on that end or the other oh um I made a mistake 840 is apprciate up because I forgot to put that on there so make that that I'm all good mind the high school kids will have a class before they go yep now they will they have a a class
029with like a half a class called the book end but what that does is physically our teach teaches half but then the other half they don't have any time so they get a little more extra time and they don't take it as off but they have more time that will virtually go away we will maximize the our instru sorry about that no problem remind me I'm glad we we missed it well thank you again we'll communicate that out and the bus garage will start working we'll be back with the final times right around there ladies and gentlemen I'd like to at this point turn it over for our MTS this is going to be a little heavy LIF so please be aware it will take a little time because they're getting into the data down
030on a student level without getting into it I turn this over to Tony and his team with with no more than a minute for slide tell you keep we give a second to transition here so as usually myself and my team will be presenting some information um on our initiative our district goal around ntss all system Sports and our movement as a district I'm steing C sorry you recall the December uh presentation we discussed the type of Assessments the variety of Assessments that we use on a regular basis some annual some a couple t a year and then of course the ones that are more formative are the teacher every day right we don't wait to a major assessment to make change in the work that we do with students our next step if you
031recall was to talk about go deeper into student and staff learning excuse me to to use our January conference days as we just went through ex January staff meetings to go through um some learning with our uh staff and talk about this process and read where we're headed um so um there's one thing I do want to address and it's an image that has come up a couple times in the work that we've done and it's the one on the the left one I hope you're familiar with at this point that's our portrait of a graduate work that's the one that we have created throughout the years and have now formalized in the work that we do with students and creating our um our assessments and our Capstone and our performance task and what that
032looks like in our curriculum work we do have a task of making sure that alliance with what New York State decides to do and but uh at the state level with the graduation blue Riven commission Etc the one other right we haven't talked about just want to give a brief um overview what that is um it the tiers themselves are fairly familiar that anybody um that has looked at the response to intervention in our TI model tier one tier two tier three um the the change that of course we look at is the holistic of the system and the academic behavioral and you'll see the social emotional as you come outside that Circle and then you have the equal access and what we call Universal Design for Learning the one thing that's small print that
033I that more just a brief conversation are the drivers the competency driver the implementation and the leadership what these are referring to is in order to make all that happen here are the the things that you need to do now these drivers were developed by the Novac group U the KY Novak is the one that created these Massachusetts um state of Massachusetts and other states um M TSS um road map and we have worked with her before and this is a model that we she came in and and Aon I think we you mentioned you know bringing someone like this back in again for our work at some point she did an audit of how what systems we have in place according to these things and and these drivers and how we can get better
034so we use those administratively to look back at to see where we need to move forward and what we need to tackle next in the capacity of a s Dum we're very much in that implementation driver which is strong curriculum tier one build our curriculum make sure there's equal access to it um ensure that all students are um in the in develop our social emotional uh beyond the academic as where as well as our behavioral approach in a universal way so I just want to make mention to those we at some point I hope to go uh deeper into those with the board and explain what some of those things are but one thing at a time um but just to know that is the backbone of the the work that we do out of
035my office when we talk about mtss we look at those items and it defines our learning that we're going to do so really the format we're going to go through is um overview Kell's going to do a like a you know if you're old school teacher the anticipatory set right she's going to give you the B I'm sorry Maran she you're lucky you didn't mention me um it's the model to which we do a learning session that you you spark the interest to remind the people what we're doing what we're talking about Kelly's going to do a couple slides of reminders talk about what we uh some the January presentation we did with our staff and learning with our principles um Joe's going to present on some data sets and some of the data we
036look at and this is based on the assessments we looked at last board meeting and and then pay a picture of a child uh one at the younger level one at the older level and what that looks like and what information do we have and Tiffany for both those scenarios are going to say what is it that we're driving to both current model and aspirationally to approach students in this holistic model and then I'll come back to Mike and we'll finish things up so that's how we're going to go about it today now I give you that information because it's very typical for um in the past Sean and I to dump a whole bunch of data on you say here's our grade three chart here's our grade four we go through all sorts of
037assessment data but in the end takeaway and the importance of the data is lost it's more importantly that we share for you for once what we do with this information rather than just a regurgitation of what you can find from the state web website so again if you want to see all those charts and graphs and Trend data on the work that we do as a whole system it's it's available matter of fact New York state is up their game there and it's available for anybody to see um how we perform what's more important in this work is the student centered model and how we use that information granular down to the student that's something we've never discussed it's a process with the board and it's public and it's the work we do every day
038in our system so with that I'm going to off the C and she'll get us started sta so this is the vision you know our why of what we set in front of our staff and ask them to take a look at this vision and ask and think about number one how many students do you think you're going to touch over the next five years you know we often get this mindset of I'm in this school year I've got to teach these plenty or 25 kids in front of me you know and and teachers have a lot to do but when you start to think about your impact on not just one child not on 25 child children but over the course of five years how many students you would impact whether it be 100
039students at the elementary level upwards of our semester scheduling for high school students of 1,250 kids and some of them are repeat and I get that because you might have them for more than one4 but 1,250 kids that you touch over five years is a lot of kids so then multiply that by a 30-year career this is big impactful work that we want to make sure that our students are always brought in Center for so we asked our staff when you look at our Liv what words stand out to you you know what's important to you so that they can begin to establish their own lie and reflect on the purpose for you know why we're doing what we're doing to work with our students so really are thinking about a system approach um for
040our children when we're looking at our wise but also again back down to the root of f student a black of students a thousand students um once we establish what our our vision is the next piece for us us is the mission the the how how are we going to get there how are we going to ensure that when we think about the system of mtss that we are ensuring that we've got that Focus for all of our students and that main focus for us is be shift forward into the system collaboration so that when we take a look at our students we're addressing them as a whole TI that we're looking at their behavior their academic and their social emotional well-being and we're meeting all of those needs and it is on a Continuum
041of services so that every student is getting they need to be successful whether it's they need intervention or extension it's the whole Continuum no longer is it when we think about how we're intervening just the kids that are falling behind this is meant to be an individualized approach to identify early and intervene or atttend all students in those three areas so that is also the other Shi um New York state has in the past had RTI response to intervention sitting in the special education world and the big shift for New York state is to pull it out of special education into general education so we are thinking about every single student having their own individualized learning so we can do the best we can for each student so again a system approach you know we
042as a system have been working on in our curriculum work the central questions that are um within the ulum that our St our staff are writing um but this is the essential question that we posed to our staff in that staff training and then supported through a share of reading with the staff how do we create a system that ensures all students get the support they need when they need them to learn at high levels academically socially behaviorally and emotionally so we've talked about that question before with our staff and then we came back to it again and Revisited it once we had uh a little bit more learning and you will get the reading that we post to the staff like you did at the last um presentation we'll hand that out to you
043at the end of this presentation and then our guiding questions that uh we are asking and that we'll take you through tonight for the purposes of this presentation as well we are presuming when we think about students that every student is competent so when we think about presumed comp confidence how can we use student data throughout the school year to make better decision and support each student's success and again with that basic understanding that we're presuming all kids are capable of learning so I'm going to turn it over to Joe to start talking about our data and what we're going to look at okay so when we were together last month we shared this Continuum discuss there's a there's a role that everything you see up here plays in that bigger picture of how we
044support our students and continue to improve our systems instruction like called players we own in a little bit more last month on the end of year assessment new yor state Regents you know and how those really you know they're a year end assessment that helps us have information on what are we doing well instru what standards are we teaching well that could inform revisions to our curriculum uh professional learning for our teachers but the piece that misses is that throughout the year that was in that guiding question so all the other pieces that you see stars next to tonight the common assessments the benchmarks and screeners the Diagnostics and just the ongoing work that teachers do on a day-to-day basis that's the information that's helping us make good decisions for kids while we still have
045them during the year to do everything Kelly just talked about so what we like to again do tonight then is actually just give you a couple case studies of what would it look like now to use these tools for a real case study of a child the profile that they present because every child is unique and as we said last month every child has strength so we need to find find them build upon them but also you know help them in the areas where they have room to grow so we're going to walk through just against some example students not real students but to just show you a little bit about what this looks like in practice so you see this you know Lucy we talk here here a grade one student but here's how
046a student that gets in front of a good perent they're all unique but Lucy for example she's a student that has strong math skills including her number stent it's just just her General understanding of relationship between numbers ability to recognize them count them compare them and with onstep problem solving challenges we see with Lucy is her ability to read independently and some concerns we noce in observing her on a day-to-day basis she often puts her head down and refuses to engage in Independent Learning tasks so there's some social emotional observation we see on a day-to-day basis as well so we talked about these we're going to talk through the benchmarks and screeners first we shared what these were I won't I won't go into into detail again this month but these are again where those
047three time a year usually fall winter spring where there the they're a brief efficient measure that all students receive um and it's kind of it serves to be that quick diff stick not necessarily on grade level standards but with foundational skills a chance for us to get a quick read on every child is there are there potentially any areas that are being flagged that there might be some foundational gaps for that child that indicates beyond our current grade level where they may have some missing foundations for prior years so we to take a deeper dive in so one of the tools that we use academically our in we talk about which sits on on for our first graders their early literacy skills and then early numeracy we don't share this you know to go too
048far into the week but here's an example of a little bit of the data our our teachers would get from this assessment the students taking the early literacy realm you notice there's this overall composite at the top and you see that that orange bar that has a one and a two that's indicating this is a student that overall in early literacy with this being a normous assessment stored in the first or in the winter the second percentile among all first graders who took this so there's a big picture flag but what's important to note also there all those boxes underneath with abbreviations that you see those are all specific measures that make up that overall composite that relate to very specific literacy skills that are within kind of how this is administered to our students
049so in this case you see a lot of that orange that indicates all below but for some students it's just very specific skills that get flaged that gives us an initial read that that may be an area we need to dig deeper when we talk about this student and also you know look at other sources of data that we have that's just quick example on the literacy side this is also administered for math ear numeracy so here's an example of a student that while they're showing some areas that probably wen't a deeper dive that might need some some bigger needs on the literacy side were in much better shape on the map side per screeners so this quick check shows that Lucy's you know really so far it's within that Ong grade level or approaching
050above range in most of her matth skills which tends to line up with that profile and what you just see on a day-to-day basis what he goes back is kind of the wheel SP on what does that potentially mean for Lucy as Kelly mentioned our approach to mtff is not just from the remediating skill that are missing standpoints also if we have students that already have these skills in place and are ready to be extended that's a read there too so we have certainly have students that present like this where they're strong in one and may have challenges in the other so a kind of typical way a student could present we also shared oh sorry before I share that the other benefit we get from an as web is that we also have the
051ability look at prior Year's data so they're they're using this tool each year and they then in some cases the measures are the same year to year and then eventually they shift just in the L the skills they progress but it does also give us that lens that we're not starting every year as if there's a brand new student in front of us whether it's our data from last year our assessments throughout the year but nams we we can also look back historically if that and add another ler to seen trends for students that might indicate a pet so we just share that a as awareness for the board that it does give with that ability as well the we we had shared in that word exploratory I want to stress again as we talk
052about the social emotional piece and the role of a screener we do not currently have a screener in our system this quickly screens for social emotional and behavioral skills with a tool like this we had mentioned it was in the very early stages and Kelly I believe it's just the school or the school sites that are starting to look at this with a long term in mind knowing that some of this is aspirational but sharing that example of this screen that they're starting to look at could give us the ability um to start to look get a skill like self-awareness which is a skill that's that's developed and taught um the example here shows that this is a student that is presenting with a limited ability to identify her own emotions um to know you
053know how to potentially respond when I'm feeling certain things which might relate to that observation earlier that here's a kid who tends to put her head down when work feels challenging and maybe there's a self-awareness piece that a potential of indicator who teach as we dig deep so again the role of a screener to give that quick snapshot in some areas that give a grade on every child where might we dig a little bit deeper and with that information in hand comes the role of the collaboration of the team what do we do with this information I'll turn over tiany to talk through that okay so Miss Lucy we we've heard her profile we've looked at some of the the initial screeners now we're looking we're going to dive a little bit deeper so our
054team comes together and it's a group of a lot of people on the team it could be related services our PT speech it could be our special education teachers our general education teachers our psychologists our principls it's a whole group that comes together to really talk about what our next steps for Lucy what does she need so when we look at our screeners we're looking at those any red Flats we want to talk about those because sometimes a student may just have had an off day in the classroom taking the assessment so it's really important to also think about teacher observation their anecdota data those common assessments those are also pieces of the puzzle when we think the whole child we know kids can show up differently each day so they might not do well
055testing and that's okay that is why our experts are in the room talking about kids so if you know they do get a red flag they can say yep I agree with this I'm seeing the same thing in the classroom but then there are times where they could challenge it and show the data from the work that they've done in the classroom so with Lucy she's at risk for early literacy so we want to really talk about that really she scored low on the PS which means the phoning segmentation so in our world it's really working with some oral sounds of letters so we're going to be thinking about what does this mean for her and what does she mean she was definitely at low risk for our numeracy as Joe indicated she's doing quite
056well in math so this might be an area where we're looking for extensions for Lucy and then we're we're really thinking she's that risk for social emotional and really focusing on why what's going on in her little world that she needs help with so with all of that we're we're looking at those teacher observations we're looking at some common assessments and then looking at those red lik to make some bigger decisions for luy a part of this meeting is then to really determine what are her next steps what do we need to do now for Lucy we can't wait till the end of the school year we need to really Implement a plan right now um for math we said she's performing well we we need to dig deeper we really don't know the root
057cause that screener give that dipstick we need to dive deeper and that's where our experts really they have certain tools to really help that deeper and figure out where do we need to pinpoint those extra support for Lucy so we're going to focus on those phone name SE segmentations oral reading fluency which is a sub test that you thought was called work and then that social emotional learning we're going to focus on the self-awareness and and use our Diagnostic and last month we talked about the diagnostic this is really that a choire where we said you open up the brains and you dump in that information important important for students to really get to that level we need to dig deeper and see what aren't they retaining what are they what are those gaps where
058are those coming from so for Lucy I can't see it from here but you can see that it's highlighted and there's because she showed some red flags I think she showed red flags on the ORF and the PF that tells us we need to go into word recogition so we're going to actually give her administer her the letters phonics and words and reading screener and then we're also going to give her a pass which is a phic awareness screening test that's where our experts will come in and do this assessment it's a little longer than that screener because we really want to spend time understanding what's going on with the from there we determine what intervention tool she needs or what grp we could put her in we've also and this again is exploratory or
059exploratory we're going to be diving into this but there will be that you know a diagnostic that will align to this which is will be the self- awareness that we focus on this is the learning when we talk about your definitions that our staff really just drove into so this is is the work in progress um when we think about tiers we wanted to share this with you as well because when we think of a plan for Lucy this is we're going to refer to these tiers and what we need to do within these tiers so for tier one is access to essential grade level standards for all students this is prevention all students should get have access to that tier one tier two is the additional time and support to learn essential grade level
060behavior and academic standards this could be the intervention or extension so students AR let's say that they need that intervention maybe they didn't get the lesson or the unit of study and they're they're just missing a couple things teachers can work with those students within their classrooms to try to you know work a little bit more explicitly on a certain standard that maybe they've struggled with or just the opposite like with Lucy we know she's doing quite well in math what can we do to make her go beyond the standards so providing her with some activities to do that during tier two and then the tier three is that intensive reinforcement the the universal skills so this is really important so they are really R we you know showed the red flags we do Seer
061and she's really strugling a specific area we can actually give her an intervention on that specific area in the tier three Lucy's plan of action for her tier one she will get access to all grade level standards which is through our forets developed curriculum she will have the ELA units of study she will have the math units of study she'll also receive social motional learning um often times we see this in our Elementary classrooms and morning meetings um also she'll receive a monthly full class lesson top by the social worker where the social worker is going to come in and teach with the whole all students in the classroom for tier two some additional time and support she will receive Ela she'll get small group instruction this could possibly look like a slower piece um
062Integrity lesson or Integrity is a program that we use for phic awareness so our teachers are going to maybe slow those lessons down in a smaller group so we can try to get Lucy what she needs as well as then she'll get in her math she'll do small group extensions this will be a group of students that are going beyond the standards and activities there and then our social emotional learning she be reinforced of specific class the whole class lessons that would that were taught by the social worker so the teachers have access to the character strong they can pull lessons from there in a small group or maybe the social worker is working in a small group there again these are some of these things are explored we're still working through that but that
063is our end goal of where we want to be and then our tier three she's going to receive some intensive intervention on heric awareness and phonics intervention probably with our intervention team using our 95% or if that's not working they will be looking at different tools to use with youc and then she will also receive some small group pull outs focusing on self- awareness skills with the social workers it could be oneon-one or it could be a small group in a different set one big key aspect to this is that regular collaboration we need to meet with meet about students frequently and and not just one student I know we're focusing on Lucy but it's all students so our team needs to come together and talk about kids talk about their data what's working what's
064not working we mean and it's not just teachers it's everyone that supported that team that I talked about earlier they need to come together and talk about the students they're going to review the progress um and adjust interventions as needed I know there was a question with St before what if this intervention doesn't work well then we're looking at other things to use with students to make sure that we we are um really focusing in on the needs that the students we're going to evaluate need for change or in an instruction or intervention and then ensure academic growth while addressing those social emotion me so that was going through lot and just just the Highlight we put it an example also of an eighth grade student to to kind of highight the same process just
065to show the intention behind the system aspect of what we working very hard to do that that kind of that same pathway while the data progresses up in complexity as kids you know grow older that same process that was just highlighted we want to continue throughout our whole system so that again kids are getting the supports they need when they need them so as we talked through Johnny is an eighth grade student we'll do this we know a little more of a rapid face because it's a very similar progression but may present again as a strong student math skills he St that's respectful he participates well in all his classes challenges that he struggles reading independently another concern that his gra it's kind of just getting by in every subject other other than math is
066what's reported so Sim an additional data point I that we share here that you know we're talking about an eighth grader now so another layer that gets added to this we do have to go back to that Continuum um Johnny's New York State assessment data from the third grade this this is just a realistic snapshot you see the the years of the pandemic this is what we would legitimately look back and see right now if we had student at this age level so we wanted to be you know kind of as realistic as we could so you can see know we get those numbers you look at an Ela you see a two a one and a two F you see a three a four and a three in general that lines up with what
067we're seeing that here's a student that you know the struggles are a little more on the reading side and tends to do well in math well when we think about so what would we do to support this child he's a three man don't tell us whole heck of a lot he's he was a in the LA okay there might be some struggle but that's not giving us information on any of the specifics that would help support this child so while it gives us another one of those big picture data points the data that the benchmarks that start to the screeners start to dig into is really giving us the information that helps us know what are the specific strengths this child has right now what are the areas of next steps but it's another reference
068point in the bigger picture on that continum at the individual student LEL so again very similar we have our am plus screener up into the e8th grade as well some of the measures change a bit based on being in eighth grade um but same concept we can look and see the composite overall score on the reading side and some of the specific submeasures underneath to see are their areas and you can see in the winter the vocabulary is a bigger area of need than the reading comprehension although the reading comprehension is an area that needs work as well so just it potentially informs where we dig deeper with those Diagnostics that di will talk about in a moment we jump to the math things we have data and you actually see blue here blue means
069this is a child that is well above average in these areas so this is potentially a student that is probably a good bet that there's going to be extension for this child this child might be ready to go beyond grade level standards and that's something we continue to talk about that we're committed to you know as we invest resources to help our students what we don't want to happen is that our students that are already meeting are the ones that kind of are the Forgotten ones they have a piece in this puzzle too and they should continue to be accelerated as well so work we're committed to but again you see a composite that's well above sub areas underneath to help us know where we might dig deeper look to extend further and again you
070see it you know an eighth grader a historical piece again you can go back and see PS reading or math has there been consistent struggles in certain areas consistent areas of strength so really working to have a deep understanding of every child to give best works that we possibly can and then on the social emotional side here's a child that when we looked at that same indicator of self-awareness appears to be you know in a good spot with that skill so that's not necessarily an area that this child will need intensive support but we'll still continue to work to grow those skills part of the overall education so another quick snapshot of data this time on an eighth grade student and so what would it look like for a team to come together to support
071John I'll turn that over to T so again just looking at those screener Johnny was low risk for maaps um strength and Concepts and application that's what the ca stood for he is at risk for reading comprehension and just a little side note often times in Middle School what we're finding the research of supporting it present to at the reading comprehension but when we dig a little bit deeper it actually ends up being for cing and I think I actually wrote down um the percentage it equals 30 to 40% oftentimes students in our Middle School level needs more to coding and that's something we typically see in elementary so it's it's really um interesting as we start to dig deeper that it it does it could present as a comprehension but it really truly is
072more dcoding dcoding it's really just um breaking apart work being able to to sound out the words making sure that they can read the words um and then also he presented himself as low risk for social social emotional learning however he is struggling in classes so he's just getting by so there could be something right there that we need to look in a little bit deeper we're looking at the teacher observation and common assessments um but we don't want to lose sight that he's just getting by why is he just getting by that's what we need to dig a little deeper and figure out we look at the screeners then we go to the diagnostic level we are recognizing that we need to do a little bit deeper with that comprehension to rule it out
073we're going to give him some grade level texts and ask some questions about those texts and then we're going to see what does Johnny really need after we di deeper so Johnny's plan is tier one he's going to receive all content areas units of study he's going to also have access to that social emotional learning in tier two additional time and support he's going to read grade level texts at a slower Pace with support so he'll get his in class and then he might get some extra supports where the text might be a little bit the same type of text but he could have more time to read it with some support and then he'll get extension for all skills in each content area he's doing well but we we want to make sure he's
074not just getting by and then our tier three he's going to get intensive language comprehensive comprehension intervention with our intervention team this would serve as our reading skill class um it could look in many different ways so right now that is going to be his plan of action again I'm going to highlight this because it's so important that collaboration the regular ongoing progress monitoring collaboration of our all of our students so that if Johnny isn't doing well with the interventions we can make some adjustments it's not a life sentence we want to make sure that we can adjust as he needs it and if he catches up he needs to be we need to push those extensions okay so coming back post start go to our guiding question what we hope to accomplish tonight as
075we walked through Lucy and through Johnny was just to show when we go back to that Continuum what it looks like and how this impacts an individual child a level that we are working to get to with these tools to really truly understand the strengths and the areas to work on for every child that we work with so back to that guiding question that keyword again being keyword iation being throughout the year though how we use these tools to inform while we still have the students in front of us to give them the best education that we can that they deserve so because we the past couple meetings we've taken you through this Contin and we just stress again that everything up there plays a role you know again those New York State assessments that's
076that end of year summative type information for us by standard to know what are we teaching well are there areas that it looks like you know we need to revisit our curriculum to to to beef that area up for that standard or potentially grow our understanding of what that standard means but then all those other tools you see up there um that's the work that informs what we do all throughout the year for our students but there's a purpose for everything up there and it creates that total package for us so key takeaways that we walk away from with these these presentations that we hope we help to highlight to do this and to really you know hone in it's easy to stand up here and say we're going to meet the academic social emotional
077behavioral needs of every child that's a big task it's a big task in it system work and we know it's work that's going to be multiple years ahead of us but that we're invested in but as Jeff said the importance of collaboration to make that possible for every child is so critical and it's where we know we we kind of go back to one of our first points that you know our kids present with such a wide Continuum of strengths and needs in all of those areas to think that one person is going to have the skill set to to be what every single kid needs it's just not realistic so we need the strengths of all of our team members and really viewing every hsee head student as our Collective responsibility and something that
078we embrace you know and also again that Focus you know being on the whole child as we share last time that best intervention is prevention it really does start full circle with that curriculum work that's happening for that initial instruction for all students if that's as effective as it can be hopefully we're going to need to less and less intervene because our initial instruction is as effective as it can be so some key takeaways to Shar and I'll turn it over to Tony to wrap it up thank you all so you remember we started our conversation in November with the graphic like this these quote randoma of improvement that we've been working on as a district for some time but the mtss work and the work on social emotional dates back to the origins of
079our 2030 work and our work as a system um in 201617 so well looks like that and feels like that sometimes behind the scenes our our work is aligning that's what's important here and it helps us identify our capacities and where we put our leverage points what's going to work what has high effect and has change um factors in our work um and moving things some of our things in there are aspirational they're piloted they're they're worked on through the system there's constant feedback loops with stakeholders in the classroom where our social workers uh as was mentioned earlier at the faculty meetings this past month month uh the one prior we're asking for feedback from the staff we're engaging making sure that they're coming along with us in this journey to align our work and
080to make everybody see this picture that we're trying to uh aspirationally create you recall this would have been a Damian's slide he's a big proponent of this he he still he's not be able to join us tonight but you know that this is our what that portion of a graduate you know how we're going to achieve that you know is through our NTS work and then you know the saying you know all means all you know our Raider Nation is our is our why why we're doing this the importance of why we do this um and for the all means all you know some some highlights of what we talked about tonight Kelly referred to earlier the number of students that we having contact right we have contact with on a regular basis and those
081are just classroom members that doesn't mention their extracurriculars those those points of impact we have the children in the hallway saying good morning to a child our bus drivers we talked about that often you know our Tas our monitors this is goes beyond the classroom this is a system that which all means all including our staff our employees um and what it means for us to engage in kids in a positive way and and to support them in this journey of this work to be in lookout for those um be a part of the conversation of what they might be seeing in the in the um non assessment in the way you we traditionally think but the observational part the anecdotal part of the work also worth um mentioning in some of our social emotional
082work is exploratory uh as well as our behavioral we do have some things in action but one thing we've always used the system as a screener in that in that area would be our at risk reports your absente data the number of times the students is getting a referral their tardies the number of classes they're bailing these are constant reports that our administrators are looking at especially if they the higher levels to help identify students that might need additional assistance in in those areas so it's not like our social emotional behavioral does not exist I want to be clear a lot of what we presented is we would went ahead with some exploratory work and what those steps in a more formal way would look like but we certainly have data STS when it comes
083to students in that world uh also and I think tip mentioned it you notice visting these this idea that you're going to have an intervention and you're going to get the help you need and we want to Target it there was the whole alphabet City up there that our professionals every day know those ins and outs and you know we're proud of that we're proud of the work they we do with students and what it means to be a you know do an intervention with a classroom teacher on comprehension sounds very simple nebulous to us but the detail that goes into that work is just amazing to see that they do with those kids so there's a lot of nerdiness going on I love with our with our students um I think that the the
084most powerful thing we know in education and learning in general this goes for kids and adults is that you set a goal you measure yourself against that goal and you celebrate when you achieve that goal every researcher and educational philosophy looks at those three factors and revolve around those three things and when we do that with an individual student you know or any one of us you're going to see success and that's that's what this is all about it's not just the academic in that's that's the power of our mtss part so um with that said I believe that was next steps we're going to continue with our capacity in-house and the staff learning to unpack the district wi definitions of those three tiers you saw some of the preliminary work and the feedback loop
085we have from staff we're going to continue to explore and build that capacity here and you see the three areas that we're focusing on these are not just made up this comes from our looking at those drivers and what has high yield for the work that we do and that's to um review the schedule changes that are coming and how um those work event mtss looking at tier one instruction um and the exposure and uring all students have that and receive it and examine current resources and detering areas of need and so important is our continued commitment to the curricular work and the delivery of the instruction um the collaboration our staff have and the work of our support office to move that work forward and to share the expertise so we do not have
086pockets of Excellence um to share everybody has a strength in our education system and our employees to be able to share that with each other and to provide that that that place to which they can do that work um and so so critical to uh this is that curriculum work and the inter excuse me um and the the work that we do with our special ed and our interventionists and how they all come together and not Islands upon himself so it's much to be proud of and work we've been doing for the last s years so that's it I hope at a future date that will'll come back after budget season maybe in um April May June somewhere in there to share some more where we are at that point in our goals and our
087work but that's all I ton and you to my team one two three I'll start this way go right in that order um thank you so much for the presentation it was very inative if you have a question for your team when you were talking about Lucy and County the team for them involved many people do we currently have enough people to fill all the teams for those students um we do have teams that get together to talk about student data sets our principles lead those and with the help of those in their building um and Tiffany alluded to the fact that there it's not like it's a often it's about a singular student and sometimes it's about variety of students or they meet throughout the course of the day to work with students and
088interventions and once needed as far as the what's needed for the capacity to do the interventions um I think we're building a system right now and our vision is with the current capacity but know that the more we Leverage The the approach to our curriculum work and the the instructional practice and the high tier high yield um instructional practice of a tier one and ensuring our staff are working together to provide those Essentials to those kids those grade level standards and those priority indicators that have been determined by our staff um and then share it amongst the teachers of that grade level the more we see that work solidifying as we implement Ela and math and then moving to all grades all subject areas with capacity over time I think that's where our biggest bank
089for buck is is working with our classroom teachers and there's the ones that have them the most and work with these students on a regular basis I'm not saying no to those other supports obviously but as far as a high yield result that 5 Hour 6 hour a day with that one particular person a lot of impact we all know that that they have with that child so focusing our energies there and supporting our curriculum instructional work feel maran's word Bravo a great presentation I really enjoyed it um especially highlighting the specifics of how an individual child so thank you um I might be getting into the weeds here a little bit and I don't need to but I can do that it truly is an interest right so you have all of this information
090coming you have state scores you have local scores you have the anecdotal information that is coming from teachers you have your team meetings do you have a common repository where you plan to house all of this information in one place that will follow a student from year to year I know there's School tools right but I don't know if that's really going to be able to fit the needs of of what you want so I'm curious to hear what your thoughts are with that and and what you may need so that a comprehensive picture of the child can flow with them their whole career here we're always exploring for something that we do well with that we have systems in place currently and they look they're different at different levels um we we at our
091elementary we have our Sim team they have data that they're bringing together our principles run those meetings um where they have some of those we've also looked at thinking about student portfolios so there's some futuristic things that we're thinking about as well where you know when a student comes from fourth grade to fifth grade although they have their card in their folders is there a simplistic way where a teacher can give this information and say oh my God I got the picture and not have to sort through all the papers so still looking through that but we do currently keep that that data it just may be whether it's the hard copies or some summaries um but there are systems in place I wonder if that's a question that could be bounced off of christen
092Novak really to see if there's other districts or other regions that have a a data repository like that if it's a if it's a program I mean we all know papers get lost and this is the way that people could share any person that touches the kit you know um they could put in their information and whatnot so I'm curious to see what her feedback would be I I really appreciate that seduction and um we also we come write that down we're always looking and then we also have a school to aspect that we've been kind of dabbling in a little bit where they can go in and put some some information in but yeah we should definitely ask that question thank you for that um just it's very impressive um you know I'm I'm
093a scientific numbers type of person want to look at the data and you know to be able to see how you've you know looked at the science of all of this and the data and have developed plans associated with where the needs are it is it is really impressive um I wish more people you know I hope there's a lot of people watching tonight I I wish more people in the community would really see the Deep dive and and the work that is happening in the district around the needs of our children and all the curriculum you know it's it's I I feel like the district gets a lot of attention when it comes to anything related to Athletics or anything related to the capital project or you know like the consolidation and then the
094bus times but you know the stuff that you're doing this this is the most important stuff that we do in right and it it impacts every single student we have and I just I don't think enough of our community members really understand or really really see it right and you know and it's it's just great work um you know I it's going to be exciting to see how this continues to progress and you know how the data changes over time based on all of this um but you know thank you it's excellent work there we go well good things are worth repeating so Bravo why I wanted to be on the school board because me this is why we're here education our students um I really like your emphasis on the total child I think
095it's wonderful um I started to do a little Rea here of approximately 25 students time so many years uh how many students and I I feel through what I do in Courtland I'm still continuing uh to work with students I it's exciting but when I look at numbers is kind of scary too um one of the things you mentioned was you use the term extension and I really like that because VI's day of intens spr that was intervention for those students who needed extra help there were programs at that era that were called gifted and talented and so a small number of students were selected to go into special programs for extension but there were so many of those students who were really good at something but they didn't get the opportunity to go to
096gift and talented they didn't have scores or whatever so you're looking at all these reading M all these things that oh you know you're really good at that but we're going to extend that to you I think that's wonderful and the last thing um and I share this with my student teachers uh looking at the audience probably too young for this but back in the day it was the Challenger justas where the elementary school teacher was board the um B shuttle I don't think it was the shuttle of B she was on the Challenger and that was the one that exploded and so and her name was Kristen Mull and um I recently read her biography which was wonderful but her motto was I touched the future dot dot dot I teach and I love
097that model and when you're talking about excuse me the number of people the number of students that you reach not just your particular class board music the art all the interaction think about yeah you are touching the future because we teach and I feel very very grateful that I am heard of that ready on this side well why don't we oh keep going this way I Echo the think but I do have a question for you Tiffy um you mentioned collaboration at what point should we bring in the families of the students to let them know like here's the plan I know in special ed there's obviously very B different gools but if we're doing this individualized plan for each student when doing M caretaker in you know those are things we're so discussing and
098trying to figure out to be honest with you but I definitely think if you know we have some systems currently in place that we could look at to to help I know that our you know current models we send home letters to RTI those kind of things but you know to really talk about it I know our our teachers are talking to parents all the time so maybe embracing some of our systems and adding some of these pieces in or you know some of our teachers are doing this already so I want to I do want to highlight that we a lot of our teachers are making those calls talking about students saying here's where we're struggling this is the supports we're going to provide and try so but definitely system wise is a conversation
099we need back thank you okay thank you um it's really a big test try to I appreciate you doing this test but um I think today with the teachers andone has a big to try to like office to and how you like she just asked how you bring the parents or the staff that might not be completely sold on it or um I mean how how are we going to because like in special ad they are have those they have to go by certain things but just one child who Family behind getting read just get read I really you're right and these are the questions we're asking you so we are in that when we talked about three to five years we are starting to build that system and really talk about how because it
100can't just be one teacher right it takes all of them so I would I would be lying to you I through up here so we have all those answers yet I mean those are conversations we're having that is why we're doing a slow roll up of just even the definitions of the tear at this point and what does this mean for us in talking about what are we doing well and what are some areas that we need to F in line so that is one example of things we need to talk about we're not ready to flip the switch and say oh we got implement this tomorrow so I appreciate you sharing that we don't have all those answers yet we're still and um trying to figure out those those pieces and and really some
101people are doing this very naturally so talking to them how how's it working talk to us about that you know do we build upon those systems that are currently in place as well so one hello okay now I can hear um one of the things I I think mski was also asking is how are the parents going to be involved I mean currently we can't wait 3 four five years okay parents if they are seeing something should be having conversation with their teachers their teach teachers even now would be having conversations with parents and trying to zero in for those emergency needs right now as well um I think that's one of the questions I mean how are you addressing these need not just through the program but the need of student in these situations
102that aren't going to have two uh so then to that point couple of thoughts like Kelly said about our our students we we too must assume and presume confidence that our staff have a love for kids and are in the system to do what they do our principles the people standing in front of you we we have a passion for this work and we care and while we might um have opinions on how we achieve that with the learning that we do and a a time roll out of appropriate conversations because you're talking about hundreds of people talk moving a system forward and all being you know not just letting your explorers go ahead and ruin it for everybody else I say that with quite honesty an implementation plan to which 5% of the population
103gets out ahead of it the other 95 say what the heck's going on stop in initiative fails so we we are conscious of these things as much as we want to do everything we can tomorrow and we have some of those people like let's do this tomorrow like time out still done because you're going to be alone you're not leader anymore you're a guy taking a walk by yourself so we're very conscious of these ideas of these drivers and that work um but I go back to this idea that in this business because we we care about these things and we're going to move these people for these students forward and we will do everything in our capacity our job at my level and people behind me is to build that capacity right to make
104look at the research look at the whole picture to engage with parents is something that's already done those pockets of excellence in the work that we do and to encourage you know um again to Tom's point if there's issues going on with your child that we're not aware of you can bet a parents usually letting us know we have those conversations on Rec basis we are working to get those students what they need when they that goes from the parent telling telling us as well as our teachers on a daily basis identifying i k just struggle with that maybe it's just the day find out what happens next next the progression of time and how their expertise and what learning and what this the child is is going through so yes it was up to
105us we do be doing this tomorrow but we also know we're moving a system of just alone 300 teachers plus 100 Tas 70 bus drivers you know 20 administrators you know there there's a lot of moving pieces and a lot of opinions on how this work looks but it be centralized on best practices and I think you're hearing that you're on support of that you get it and we want everybody else to get it then everything we do is with good intention right we moving forward a system with the best intention for each child and that's what we're going to continue to do and we'll welcome the conversations with the parent and to address the needs of the students they are getting a high level of support right now and now we're just trying to
106universalize that support and then determine you know um well get more nerdy about what we do and be approach this work more identified and targeted so when a child goes into a system into an intervention where saying okay good job celebrate it success and moving forward we need to do that a little bit better so great question Sue and that's that's the stress we have as a as an administrative team is you know the the outliers and how to handle them both those that don't want to make the change and those that are too far ahead of it our job is to maintain the implementation cycle and like I said that is the nerdiness of those drivers the implementation leadership and the competency drivers that we look at as we think okay what's next what's
107going to get the best yield to move this forward but do not want this down that we do great work already how do we do better and how do we universalize it and be more efficient effective in the work Yep music M yeah I'll just say thank you very much for the presentation it was particularly interesting to see the the illustrative examples and what you presented last week translated into this thank you for the time and effort that went into doing it uh and for the work that you're doing District thank you again uh there's one thing that wasn't starred we realized that the Capstone those corstone assessments are not yet number those are the things we have in progress that's that's the work New York state has said those you got to do them
108well we're already talking about how we're going to get those and what those are going to look like and answer your point those might be the large essential question by type assessments that will move on from year to year that measure large pictures including our portrait at graduate work you know what does that look like in our assessments so yeah maybe back off of a couple of different things that people have said um when looking so when you're looking at the data of the individual student I know we focus a lot on the students as an individual so if we collect all of the data from the class having it in one location to say okay so here's this class and it seems like everybody on their a is struggling with the reading or the
109math or maybe it's like an a higher level up in it's a particular course the one teacher is teaching at the high school or whatever and now the kids are faing that course whatever English whatever what what steps do we have in place to say okay how are we going to help those kids who is Teachers is is is the issue with the teacher is the issue with what we have created for the curriculum to be how do we change that how do we fix it and not in like a slow motion but in a fast enough motion so that Prive action can actually be taken and delivered for that student for the always be yeah now you're getting to the accountability piece and when I was asked earlier about capacity that's why I said
110our our number one goal was that um that tier one the classroom teacher as you're stating meeting with with those students especially the lower levels for all subject areas and ensuring that person is delivering what their colleagues and themselves have been part of to to say this is what's important and this is what's going to matter as the student moves forward in our vertical alignment of our work so um we're at a point now especially with Ela where it's like you should be doing it your colleagues have created this and now we're looking at accountability measures of you should be doing this work because it's been universalized it's been supported by the board the ccul work we've been doing and up so there is an accountability um I often use an expression out of my
111office 90% of the work we do with you know humans is to coach them to coach them to get them to move them to get the learning to push them but then in our model then it becomes accountability time you're you're you're you're Dragon you're not there yet now we our principles are are well aware of those things and working with those teachers seeking out the assistance of us at Cal office to support those teachers that aren't moving some but could be willfully yes we're talking about um in that that bell curve those outliers we have many more than on the other side of that but we do come to a point of accountability you're right that that we we are a profession they are professionals and we do have an expectation we highlight those
112ones specifically but certainly we provide all the professional learning we can to assist those to get to the level of of others and to mature that this implementation is happening one more thing to add aside from mtss that's what our teachers do on a day-to-day basis so they're looking that's what those informal assessments are for so if our students aren't getting it it's telling us oh do I need to retach this do I need to go back that's why up on the continu of Assessments we have those informal assessments those exit tickets those let me check for understanding that's the purpose so that we don't get too far you know that we're adjusting in that moment it happens all the time I think great teaching happens they'll they'll do it the lesson fails the kids
113just didn't connect with it or maybe maybe it was just way above their level the next day they're coming in they're trying it again they're readjusting so that is always what our teachers are are working towards to do so that is a piece of the puzzle as well I don't want to do thank you and I'll share that we're asking with some staff in this curriculum work and we shared St of us in the past of how they are um they're like new teachers again we're asking them put a performance task in this is not has been what they've done before and they come back to the table with Tiffany and her team like that's lck and they feel horrible right they they they're reflective thinkers and professionals and they're going to do it better
114and they want to figure out okay now I got to go back in because there's still an essential standard that has to be met what do I need to do differently so they're the ones that are coming to us in a reflective practice to say that didn't go as well as I thought in that implementation of that what what do we need to do different with this current cohort this current group of kids not like they're saying ah let's just wle unit 2 next year and we'll figure it out no they're concerned and then come to the table saying we need to redo this one for this year to make sure these kids have this essential standard um so we do have that reflected practice in that feedback loop with the curriculum work which is
115why our emphasis is there um so but to your point there are outliers there always outliers in the system as large as we are that we do need to address in accountability not thank you and then I'm just going to try to ask a couple of my questions then um then you can answer so to going back for the whole when you were talking about like the assessments 2 three fours and having that information easily and readily accessible and available do we keep the whole year like this is our fourth grade year this is how as a whole they've done not just like New York State they have their test but do we have our own individual assessments I know we have the as web that we collect that data we keep that data and
116we can reference it as a whole to see how each grade level is moving up and then another question um that I wrote down collecting like so you're just developing this emotional social piece but collecting data on students for that social emotional piece are they in music do they participate in sports have they never participated in anything what are their interest you know what services are they you know like the introver how do we collect how do we collect that type of data and then to go also to talking about or asking about um getting the parents involved and collecting feedback from the parents say you know you guys are giving giving my kid all of the intervention means and it's still not working or the parent home is saying you know this is my
117my student's doing great he's above and beyond this is way too simple we my child needs to have have way more advanced information how how do we get that information from this from the parents to get feedback in this whole process as well and I think yeah I yeah that so the first one was about the collection of summative informative Assessments in our uniform which is something that does exist yeah yes that that that that not all curricular areas you know some example there's lots of variables just understand it's such a dynamic system but for example um our elementary they have blue folders I'm sure Amar could shake her head and those where we collect there's some formal writing genres that we do that is a standard so they have to collect they capture that
118moment in time for students and they collect those we're looking at the performance Tas that the performance test gives us that data goes in their folder so there's certain assessments or collecting through out to make sure students are progressing those actually go from grade level to grade level until the end of their fourth grade year where it goes home so there are systems we also like I'm kind of mixing up some of your questions but I know like when you think how do we report out to parents so again i'mgoing communication is currently happening all the time with our parents with our teachers to our parents you know the report card is a great indicator those are aligned to their standard so anything that they're collecting you know evidence throughout that full marking period and
119Reporting out our down to our kindergarten level where they have a tool called esdi where they're constantly doing assessments daily and it's it's drafting reports that can go home to parents so we have so many different tools to share off this information with parents um along the way it looks slightly different at different levels of what we have available to for and then the oh great point about the curriculars and their engagement we know that there's a study after study said the more the child's engaged in certain activities the more likely they are Sly successful in school because they're building positive relationships with adults and their peers and not you know more not a structured a format in the classroom right and that that those experiences so part of the work that we're doing with
120our character strong and some of the screeners we've looked at um for the social emotional discuss that and there are conversations that even come up when we look at at RIS reports and individual conversations just the higher level because we have more opportunities at that point um that so it's more of informal conversation but there are in our exploratory actually questions and frequency questions about that um every other year every third year we also um do a countywide data set about um at risk students and part of that ask questions to our eth 10th and 12th graders um about their um involvement in such things as an indicator so we get some raw data sets on that but I I I can't stress to you enough this point though we data rich we have a
121lot of information I think sometimes it comes to us trying to figure out what's the important stuff and how do we use it with validity and the the drip back right data Rich information for we have a lot of information on kids in our system but making the meaning of it and using it correctly is that's the effec of efficient art that we're looking at because yeah we can collect all sorts of things but what do with it and how how is the appropriate way to do use that information so yes we're looking those quantities those frequencies those every two years some of the work we're doing with the strong uh and those social emotional aspirational assessments we want to look into but I don't want to just give an assessment to give an assessment
122right we want to make sure that we're going to make use of that work and that data that we collect thank you all well the one um I just want to say thank you because I know you guys are really working hard on all this and I I on the one assessment we had done before was the Wellness committee last year so we did that yeah and I do appreciate it and I do like to just you know be able to ask questions and then one final thought do we ever ask the students like okay you're at the end of your freshman year what what classes did what do you wish you would have been able to be taught at that you know what I mean to get their feedback and to try to help
123get that information while you're building and growing all still I will actually of sh Chris if you don't mind Chris just brought down a great example today of a teacher at the high school who um she gave this assessment and then brought the student back and they had to map it to their standards and and think about okay where what did you not get here let's talk about it so I don't like to steal the story because it was wonderful it came from the high school but there are great examples of what our teachers are doing to really ask those questions students we have other teachers that we give an assessment and then do well in it so they give it back and they have to work through that grit you know figuring out what
124did I do wrong and having those conversations so I just want to give you some examples of that yeah feedb back on the performance Tas as well it's really powerful when you have a rubric in place because that does require dialogue you have to talk about with a student you sort of make sure the students understand what their pain that because even down at the kindergarten level that's important they need even if it's at the kindergarten level they need to understand again sets the goal measure yourself against the goal celebrate have success story when do give the gold star thank you all right thank you I all my questions were answered we'll move along thank you very much very informed moving on Section six um the audit committee did not meet so we do not
125have a report so I need an action vote uh or I need a motion on 6.03 through 6.10 can I Mo please okay Curiosities discussion comments question all in favor I oppose extensions moving to section 7 um we have 7.02 are HR recommendations can I have a motion please Curiosities discussion comments I'll go Julie and then S I just have a question on 7.21 those are contractual mentoring retirements some the new teacher we pay for okay thank you no problem that's find where the cube was so that button on okay I just want to recognize the two bus drivers who are retiring 27 each in our district Mond days thank you for your service thank you for delivering our children safely um that's a big big tast being the bus dver so thank you very
126much I also would like to recogniz Karen um I worked with her for years when I had my preschool program and and she's a hard worker a wonderful person did a wonderful job when I have a I work with her and she will definitely be just TR recognize those people and congratulations all right call a question all in favor I oppos extensions get okay thank you all right and I would like to reiterate Sue com comments uh Linda Shellhammer has been 27 years with the district as a bus driver and a school monitor David schwart out has been 27 years with the district as a bus driver and bus washer um and we thank them for their years of service and uh delivering our children around the district and Karen mlan was 17 years with
127the district um also so we thank them for their service and I also would like to congratulate eron Hogan uh we approved her tenure appointment tonight and we wish her a long and happy and prosperous and successful career all right we move to section eight um I need a motion on 8.02 second inquiries discussion comments all question all in favor I I oppose extensions moving on to section nine uh dealing with the policy committee and we have a policy committee report Dany committee met on January 9th continued our review of his policies in the 6000 series financial management there are three policies on the agenda for which we uh are doing a first reading very if you can see the minor changes made um in those documents and then two additional policies for the second
128reading these were reviewed in the last board meeting and we didn't make any additional changes to what uh they looked like during the first reading and then lastly we had policy 405 Student Wellness on the agenda as it's been tabled while the wellness committee is doing its work we we received an update on that work and decided we would take it off the agenda and then when the committee's ready to come back uh and Report out on the work we would put the ball back on the agenda that was um the that was it no good to the order thank you so in section nine we have uh two policies 9.03 and 9.04 uh for approval may I have a motion please curiosi discussion comments um I I did email over last month some of
129um my suggestions on public in the annual budget and um taking those out to both B graphs I am going to vote no on the changes for the second reading and I just wanted to give the explanation as to why and that was my why I think that we I think the more specific is very important and I think that we need to really um hold ourselves um accountable with as much detail as possible and I I didn't I like the I like the way that it was of so that's it all in favor I I POS exstension all right section 10 we have uh first readings only so does anybody have any inquiries or discussion or comments they'd like to make being none um I really only have one thing per se to report
130and it's more of congratulations uh this year we've had uh three teachers uh received the golden apple uh from Gard road we've had uh Christine wace and Tyler McQuade and from the high school Lane so we congratulate all of them for their fine work and for their recognition by the students so that's a nice thing for them board member comments oh I'm sorry I thank you so where there's something yeah all right all right so we also have to vote on the board uh the resolution you've all had an opportunity to read it anybody have any questions on the resolution yeah so when I'm reading the resolution to me it is saying for a new um self- evaluation instrument um for Ed during the 24 25 school year so does that mean that it's not
131going to continue moving forward and if the plan is to change it and it's going to be the new tool I think that the resolution should specify that and not just say that it's for the 2425 school year and uh want to paragraph down and where is the final draft of the new horse head Central School District Board of Education self- evaluation document upon its completion will be submitted to the full board of education for review by April 23rd 25 and any action thereafter is that what you reference no the one great about that the one that says that the District Board of Education self evaluation document to form a new Boe self evaluation instrument for use during the 2425 school year so it will be used during the 2425 school year but I'm guessing
132that this would also still continue further that this is going to be the new tool moving forward for evaluation so I'm thinking that the resolution should clarify that as well that's what I'm saying if if I can Aid in this it's part of the legal resolution the paragraph that you're talking about which is I think the second is talking about that the instrument would be used at the end for the 2425 but the next paragraph Warren said is that this document because it won't be used unless the board votes it in after it's developed so I think it's a little premature for what you're saying that when it comes you're saying once it comes back I believe later on um by the deadline date but then the board's going to have to take action for
133what they're going to do with it and that's therea so in other words whatever document the committee brings back if it's accepted the board you have to approve it for use for the year and going for so there would be another resolution but the Au Okay resolution to say that moving forward that's what I yeah the committee can't just say here's the thing they have to bring it and then the board has to receive it and then you have to vote to put it in the place going forward otherwise you use the old document say committee St committee brings that forward and the board said no we're keeping the open so I think it's just premature at point right idea we have to do that all right and I am told I have to read
134this into the record um and this violates every good teaching principle where you read a docum but here we go it is recommended that the horsee head Central School District Board of Education approve the creation of a Board of Education ad hoc committee whereas the horad Central School District Board of Education desires to revise the Board of Education self- evaluation document for board members where as an ad hoc Committee of the board will utilize the current horsee head Central School District Board of Education self- evaluation document to form a new Boe evaluation instrument for use during the 2425 or 2024 2025 school year to be active whereas the final draft of the new horseed Central School District Board of Education self-evaluation document upon its completion will be submitted to the full board of education for
135review by April 2025 and any action there here after whereas the membership of this board of education ad hoc committee is Christine Dale lizo Del Wheeling Aaron Chone Susan unari and Dr Thomas Thomas J Douglas as well as the ad hoc committee may include other District administrators as appropriate whereas the committee will determine the meeting schedule and frequency needed to meet the expected delivery date of the draft to the board and this ad hoc committee will be chaired by Christine Dale whereas the board ad hoc committee will be dissolved by June 177 2025 or earlier upon the submitt of the new HED Central School District Board of Education self evaluation. doent to the board president therefore being resolved the hored Central School District Board of Education president Warren Conlin motions to hereby establish an ad
136hoc Committee of the board for this purpose and timeline the Motions are more discussion oh all right one motion second all I know question thank you to the volunteers yes so um so basically are you just um going over what our evaluation was last year and changing how we're doing our evaluation at the end that the idea the survey that we all filled out but just for our board survey all right call the question all in favor I I oppos all right section 11.02 board member comment and I see they have a thing that they're doing with their buses that are allowing students to stay inside if they can see the bus coming down the road and the would wait for the students to get out to the bus a c do we have any
137cold mother um cautions in place I like to hi my down we have something like that in place I just they most most of the buses have their protocol those drive up and often times if it's cold the parents are there and then they come out at that point uh a lot of times kids are out there different like Community stocks have like sheds at some of the other places but if it gets to a certain point we also have a pickup in route procedure that we do if needed if somebody's in distress as well so uh they do handle that very well coaches um I think it great you know we have a lot of volunteer and um paid coaches that are have students athletes that play for them and I do feel that
138it creates an inherent conflict of interest um it creates favoritism ored or actual and I'm concerned that it can undermine the team cohesion and integrity um I know that we have a lot of these coaches and Physicians and I certainly don't want to I understand we can't change policy get rid of that and we can't gr other people in but I'm asking us to take time to have discussion about it and you know look at but clear and clear guidelines essentially that we essentially even put into writing maybe it's not a policy but clear guidelines and directions that in those in these positions can follow I have more can I go ahead and thing too okay um I had asked about if you so interested in Rat and as a new board member I am
139interested in a retreat of some type even to focus on our communication and working together cohesively um as well as maybe the four duties that are proceed compared to what they actually are um I think we could all benefit from that or at least I know I could um I want to congratulate I think we had some uh school records in the Trap program recently which is pretty exciting and um I know we have some players on the state recognized from our football team recognized on the State team that's pretty impressive the other thing that I'm asking us to talk about is do we currently offer a buyout for spouses who both work within the district for healthcare does anyone know that like if you if if if me and my spous are both teachers
140can we offer a buyout so that they only have one plan or if both of them work for us corre no okay they only get one plan no matter what so we would be paying money for something what happens when they retire and they're using like sick days and then one of them like retiree they stagger the retirement so one of them takes retirement and takes an individual plan that we're not paying for right and then that is something that's contractual and has been worked on with bhda because we have those situations there is a procedure and we follow the contract yeah but we don't pay anything extra if they work here the buyout is the one individual works here and one individual Works someplace else doesn't matter and they choose to take the outside
141health care we have a buyout option for that person but when they when the retirement takes place we do end up with two plans essentally no when they retire they they're if they're on the buy out they don't have access to we're protected either way are you complaining two things here I'm going to up for a second are you asking a married couple in the district and they're both retiring from the district or you asking to marry couple of his districts One retires from our district One retires from somewhere else so let me declare I'm sorry so we have both of them work for our district both of them are employed by our district so we do not so they're only eligible for one Healthcare program correct okay so now let's bu okay no buy
142and now let's follow that through so now both retire or one or one reti so one retir the other retires they get one Healthcare and retire and then they survive the language and plot contract that's what we want okay thank you does that help yeah yeah yeah now bearing that the other side one person here one person outside the district they take the buyout inside District because say this SP get to stay at Chun uh they're getting paid each year when they retire they're on that healthare they don't okay they have to notify us beforehand and op to him but if both employees are employees of our district and they stagger their retirement they can both go at the same time if they don't so one's still teaching One retires they could technically end up
143put two plant one to go on a single plant and one to still family okay okay thank you all right so no I want to um ask the board how we want to proceed because one of Julie's comments was about do we want to explore some sort of policy or guidelines around parents who coach their children in the district so I think we have to um go back to that and see what the sentiment is of the you be exploring does the board wish to create a policy you do not set gu you set a policy and I come or are we exploring as the board want to correct talk about it yes right so we want to talk we're not at policy stage no be sent to policy committee then and I don't even
144know if it should be sent to uh the athletic committee well that that's one of the things if you were ever going down that road I would tell you you might want to utilize that first because it's going to have a major I mean really I think what you're saying is not just about parents and coaching any coach oh I'm sorry I forget I think what you're saying is any coach there should be something that is very cautious about coaches having their own children on their teams whether they're volunteer whether they're teacher uh and so forth some of that is contractual but that's what the discussion and it actually I know it will go beyond coaching there's other things we do outside of coaching in the district that has that same type of potential conflict
145so you want to have that discussion first and out of that discussion if you come to saying we want a policy once you set the policy then we'll use athletic committee and myself for regulation hopefully that's not up all right does board have any okay that's basically what I was going to say is uh I have some same concerns get Jing again about gu coaching I think our coaches do a wonderful job obviously we' got great Seasons lots of awards and um student ANL going on to play at the college level but the coaches I I think their job is trem help but I just I I really question parents uh volunteering to coach a team where their child is playing on their team so I would be very open to further discussion and including
146the athletic department and I wouldn't know if I'm ready to write a poliy but certainly I would like tother disc question so how do we handle um teachers who then have their student in their class I mean that is kind of a similar thing right I mean you know we have I mean in lots of cases I know we try to avoid that but we also have there's some classes at the high school where there might only be one teacher for a particular class so do we have a a process for that no we expect a profession to be profession right so I guess um I you know I've had kids go through the athletic program and I've had kids on teams with coaches but have also had their kids on the team and I
147mean in in my my experience those coaches have all they're all experts in their field right they're all um you know it's I can't even imagine another coach in those positions um and I do feel like from my experience that those coaches are very professional and in in many cases utilize their assistant coaches to make some of the decisions right like related to lineup related to and the season awards um and you know and then that that coach takes themselves completely out of the equation when they're kid upon the team and maybe that's just because those coaches have put that own process in place for them you know maybe that's something to explore that you know that the athletic committee could explore like different processes or guidelines or procedures when that happens um you know
148I would be really concerned that the um that we would lose a lot of really really great coaches because we we have excellent coaches in the district and many of which either currently have kids on their team or have had kids on their team um and and many of them are coaches that coach long before their kids came on the team and will continue to coach long after their kids have left right um so it's you know it's it's it's difficult I mean I understand you know the the perceived favoritism that happens and you know I that's that happens you know and I think that happens whether it's a parent who's coaching or it could be a close friend that's coaching um you know it's it it is it is difficult um but I just
149I think we need to be consistent so if we are allowing it to happen in an academic environment then you know how do we say no to one environment but yes to another Environ Baron I'm certainly open to having the conversation more at length than what we're discussing now however I am opposed to creating a policy to that effect um we are a big District in some people's eyes but we are a small district and some of the finite skills that are staff may have in order to uh coach or to do other extracurriculars I mean and I'll share this from a personal perspective if we were looking at academics neither one of my children would have been able to participate in ch my husband was their teacher it just is what it is we
150live in districts and that is a course that they chose um we have to do what's best for kids and we want to have the best coaches we want to have the best curricular folks that they're in now in saying that does that mean that there can't be guidelines Associated to minimize mitigate the risk of perceived or actual favoritism absolutely so that's what I would be open to having conversation about yeah I would just say procedurally um I certainly think it's is worthy of discussion on the agenda at a future board meeting not necessarily you know that we're going to TI this evening um and I think the idea it would be helpful to in that discussion to know a little bit more about exactly what our procedures are for hiring coaches uh what the
151contract says about you know hiring coaches just I think having more information and then talking about it and then potentially referring it to a committee for uh consideration of some guidelines would be a good idea so I supportive of talking about that future meeting on um I'm in favor of also discussing it but I want us to be aware of the trickle down effect because if that were the case uh there would not have been a drum Club at the intered school this year there would not be a garden cled school year because I'm doing it for my child um so just keeping that in mind I will say I took Mr shon's advice and when it came to Casting our show I did take myself out of it and had not prob actually cast
152it so that it was fair um so there are some procedures that we've already put into place um that maybe have to talk but just I want to be aware of that trickle down effect with I'm doing it for my kids right I I just want to clarify something uh I am not in any way opposed to you know coaches with their children on their team um I didn't mean maybe I get wrong impressed with that my concern is Eren who volunteer to coach and I don't know the ones who are currently parents who are coaching personally but I think at times when they volunteer to do that it's because and I guess it's judgmental um they want to have an in on what's going on and my concern is not only for the team
153the individual student athlete probably takes you know en Ching from other members on the so I think it would be a good idea for us to just the down talk about it share our ideas and make sure that we're making the best positions for our student and other I don't think we otherwise discourage having parent volunteers for anything um when our kids were in school I care with anything and it is the fine line when you you know like their music program volunteer volunteer to coaches or or to volunteer and help with the team but I think most parents who do that I would would be profession you know first B first space whatever or play more because it's because I'm volunteer with buiness I don't think I would hope that would not be the
154case it but I don't think I should I don't want to say you don't want to have parent volunteers because I think they're really important I think we need and I don't think we can control they with our district and coaching um I'm sure there's already got that we have in place but our work and people will always think that because you're helping you know your child's the fa but that's not our supp I don't believe you could be wrong all right other than are you gonna are we GNA vote are we voting to have this is this like resolution that we're voting on right now I com yes I looking inone didn't there was one other item to retreat oh that Julie mentioned I GA information get all of our opinions and I appreciate
155everybody's viewpoints what they shared tonight everybody has very valid ones and I think the discussion was really great to listen to um I am in favor of still having a retreat I think it's a good idea for all of us to sit down and have these types of discussions to figure out more of our functionality and I think that is a good idea so I am in favor of the retreat and then my last comment is we have a lot of issues with our microphones in the hearing and the sound and I have been voting now on the minutes regularly because we still do not have it's written out when Tom says something it's written out when Warren says something but when a board member makes a comment or asks a question it is still
156back to the a board member commented and what those comments are and I believe it is very very important that our names are associated again with the comments that we make because it is not always easy to hear at home when you go to replay it our minutes should be very reflective of the things we say and I think it's important and so I guess I'm asking my board members for the next meeting if this is not something that is reflected because it's your voices to it's what you make a comment about and you should want to have people be able to see your name we did it in the board member comments what we say but for the presentation tonight there were a lot of really great comments made and the minute they're only
157going to say a robust conversation and a board member commented and I think that the thoughts that Erin shabon had and Julie and my mom and every single person should be reflective of what they say so that's that's my comment and uh Happy New Year January 2025 I think it's looking good wait are you going to talk about the no I just got no we got to stay with the coach we got I haven't I haven't talked yet then i' talk about you can come back to the coaching all right you can come back at any time CU there all right go ahead um I someone am also um open for a retreat if we can find a facilitator that can support that um and then my board member comment I just wanted to make
158sure I say it one more time mlda Jr hosted by the Middle School drama club will be February 7th and 8th um the 7th at the 7 p.m and the 8 is Go performance at 2: pm. tickets are $5 at the door and it is set for shut so if you aren't doing anything that weekend sorry one more plug we still have tickets available for the Harlem wiard thank posters at the back of the room General Admissions meeting is open at $15 per ticket uh there will be merchandise to Du buy within the next week There's also opportunities for some free things coming up so check it out have a question coming students you have in the that's an amazing question I don't know um I for the Intermediate School we did carel for the
159middle okay do you know for the Middle School don't midle school I mean the Middle School play I the P middle school plays have tended to have like 25 to 4 so I'd like to comment on the coaching um I disagree with the majority of the board I think this is a policy or guideline this uh discussion and search of a problem I've been with the district either employed or as a board member for 47 years I've watched coaches cut their children I've watched coaches agonize over do I bring my child up from JVS to Varity as a sophomore because of the perception even though their child was clearly better than anybody on the team and the one thing I know about coaches they want to win and they're going to put the best athletes
160on the court on the field whatever playing environment we're talking about and if their child happens to be that good and I have a real concern how this would work where we currently have coaches that started before they were married have great credentials in coaching were blle with children and then had children that were athletic and now we're saying because going forward we're going to say okay your career now as a coach ends because we as a board are going to say you can't coach I find that disruptive to be with and I don't even know if we're going to be able to hire people for two years you can only coach for two years then this person's coming back I again I think it's a a policy inserch of problem I think You' all
161outlined that any coach that has been in this environment has done things to avoid conf icts of uh or appearances of conflict there's always going to be perceptions that the the coach's child or somebody's favorite Kurt manwaring the baseball coach put Kurt man wearing at catcher when he was the sophomore took the job away from a senior and the baseball coach had to go in and get lectured by the parents about how wrong that was and we all know Kurt maning went and had a 12year major league baseball career the best athlete went in the position and I agree with Sue we shouldn't be discouraging parent volunteers Who come out I even if the reason is their child is involved right now they're bringing their expertise they're bringing their hours and they're bringing their time
162to the children of our community so I'm not for a discussion about it I'm not for a committee meeting about it I'm not for any part of this because I think we're just going to create more problems than we are going to solve problems I want to clarify one more time M I have nothing against coaches having their own children on their teeth that was not my comment and I hope not oh no I all right so I guess I need procedural guidelines here first on we'll stick with the coaching issue how we want to proceed there's no motion no mo she I think the board should talk about okay so now in a future meeting all right so you could request uh it come on the agenda there's no motion no action and then
163it would be up it goes through the operating all right then no we're not next we're almost done um we have the retreat issue so I have Katrina spoken to the retreat Julie spoken to The Retreat and Liz has spoken to The Retreat so that's covered Aaron yeah Christine yes as long as we have a defined plan as to what we want to accomplish and we have a plan not for retre Dan is going to have to leave the only thing I was going to say beforehand is we don't have a facilitator the question that I posed the I think we tried to talk is if we don't have facilitated lawyers the lawyer can either do it but I don't know if people want that um but oh sorry um the issue is is how
164do we as a board want to approach this and what do we want to do because I'm not setting the agenda for the board's discussion not that I'm not it's just that you guys have to help me and Dan because we're open a facilitator was going to come in and talk with board members and develop the best way to help bring the board together which I have to commend you you know the past three meetings have improved and I appreciate that I think everybody does length of time we're working on it hey it's only 8:30 uh but it's just making sure we have a plan together and right now Dan and I we were trying to pull it together but we don't have a plan so what would the board like to see I think
165the big I just want to make one comment because I'm assuming everybody wants um to retreat yes all right so here's what I see fact everybody says they want to retreat for the time we sent out availability and dates and things like that we had date sent out one board member available 8% of the time one board member available 15% of the time one board member available 50% of the time 65% of the time uh 89% of the time 90 93% of the time and 100% of the time so I guess my point is you can all want it but the facts are once the dates are set out sent out nobody's available so maybe the issue is and we the June 30th date January 30th or only because you yep it's h that's only
166because you changed I thought we're going for a totally new day if we can't get right now we don't have a facilitator for the 30 get together and talk each you we had nine members available if you had they have already then we would have not had a meeting they were here last year in last J so Dr dou I've heard you say a couple of times you made mention of of a corporate something or other what is your what's your plan do you have a a way to De with let let me help clarify thank you I was going through my educational contact I don't have the corporate contact okay I was working with Dan as much as I could but um Dan and I have talked sometimes the corporate contacts don't have the
167same understanding of board Dynamics and we don't know if that would be the best situation because let's face it business and board work differently depending on the we and I don't know if I wanted I Know Dan wanted to leave but I don't want to Pigeon hold him because we're all trying to do the best for the board one board member I have no I not I don't have a degree in Retreats I don't have any I have the point of view that the a corporate facilitator wouldn't be effective in dealing with a school board and the issues that are inherent in Schoolboard governance and the things that we deal with that's my point of view I'm also interested in retreat but I think we need to have a clearly defined you know agenda I
168think it might be helpful to hear from James we continue to have issues around open meeting law and minutes requirements things like that maybe we have James helps us understand the rules so we can all level set on what those are we can talk about Schoolboard governance and what the duties and powers of the Schoolboard are so that we have a common understanding about our role and administration's role I mean there are some things we could do but um you know I don't uh I don't have any secret thoughts here that and and I also mean we found a DAT and you know we asked facilitators they weren't either available or interested so we you know we still we have and we do have the Loy so did you did you happen to look at
169getting dates from the facilitators at the facilitators if they if there is one that would be willing to take this home if they have dates I had five facilitators I gave them the two dates then it narrowed down to one uh two of them had to be out because they're already working with others I'm saying kind of the other way get the dates from the facilitators that they're available push them out to us and see if if we can jive with them instead of them jelling with us yeah I can tell you we've tried that before it doesn't we've got to go to the facilitator what for you I know that that's the hard part and we've done this many years in a row uh that's why we put out the do the little calendar
170and I think that's why Warren was saying if we're not available Narrows down who can do it we did have one or two but once they went and looked at what was going on because I did not tell them what we needed I'm asking them go out and look tell me what you think we need to act effectively as a board some says I will tell you one came back Point Blank and said listen I'm going to charge you a lot of money and you're going to be in the same place even after I worked with this isn't a one time thing another one said I see what's going on I just retired I can fit it in I don't know but they chose their vacation over coming out but that's from them doing their
171initial research because I didn't give them anything and I told them if they chose to then I was going to turn them over to the officers me and Dan and let them talk to each board member to try to develop the best type of retreat they could but I'm I don't have anybody in the school industry that will do that even different dat we have come start all over I mean I I have one person that he goes I just can't help you because I'm he's one of the busiest people that works right if you want a new date I I can go out and ask that that's not how we've had to do it in the past that at least gives us some leeway right I mean I know that if somebody came back
172and said I can only do these three days I would be flexible if I could to finish something off to to figure it out because I care about the board right so I think you have to give us the opportunity to be able to see what we can come back with best intention I I don't have a problem with it's very hard nine I can be there very easily but nine members and and everything with one person it was the DAT right so if he was on vacation now he's back entally or she and we get from them no she is she's got I'm going on vacation and I not show work uh but the one that was the original one who I think would be problem best first just not on that day he's
173with L he gets done with them at 5 there's no way he can get here that so let's reverse it and do it the other way what do he have I can ask I like what you're saying too that helps out a lot when you do that and if you are going to ask at this point where we are we're January so when you're asking the facilitator first scheduling me it's easier if work I need like six weeks so cuz we we we picked the January date like three four weeks ago so I'm saying now where we are like can you look towards like after February break if we're going to bring on a facilitator but I'm still in favor of still doing a retreat where we all get together and I think that it
174could be just as simple as reintroducing ourselves talking to each other saying hi my name is Katrina and this is why I ran to the board these are the things that are important to me and getting to know each other as individuals a little bit and then maybe having the lawyer there you know and and being able I I think that we would be able to sit and have discussions with each other I think it would be okay and I think it would be necessary if you know for whatever reason but I'm just saying from my scheduling standpoint I know that at this point it's very hard for me to be able to get something onto my book before like the second week of Fe so um I'm definitely you know I'm in favor of
175a retreat however we've had retreats in within the past 12 months and we have had the Lo there and we have done the this is why I'm on the board and I still feel like even after those we still have had a lot of issues and the whole reason why this came up was because of issues because we were not getting along we weren't being effective we weren't being productive and and we felt like we needed a retreat and we needed somebody with an external perspective that does not have bias that does not have emotions involved with it to facilitate person um L and and I think you know having that perspective is extremely important um because you know we spend a lot of time here right we spend a lot of time in committee
176meetings we spend a lot of time at D meetings so if we're going to go into a 4H hour Retreat which again I'm in favor of I and we we typically have done Retreats every six months I mean our in over the course of history we would have every r every August and Retreat every January um I just want to make sure that if you're set up for Success because I don't feel like the last two Retreats we had we were set up for Success because we didn't have either full participation or we didn't have the right type or we didn't have any facilitation for it that that was able to get us over the hurdles that we have um and I so I just want to make sure that our time is being used
177wisely and that we have a plan versus let's just all go in the room together and have have this discussion right um because I I think it's important the work we do is important and we need to be able to understand how we can work more effectively as a so I think you just to a vote who's in favor of sticking with the January 30th our original date retreat and then if it passes that we are still going to do that on that date or if it doesn't then we move to the plan B of asking the facilitator when they're available I think we just have to make a decision on that I need to clarify at this point in time we do not have any facilitator for January 30 the only one we have
178that would be available in present is James gr is confirmed and set aside okay so then who's in favor are still having to retreat with those circumstances for the 30th I I am in favor of that correct sorry try I just you know we're clear you're saying James Gregory would do something for 4 hours for 2 hours he set aside he set aside for whatever need that night right now at this point I told them you're more there for any type of legal guidance you're not doing the retreat but if he's going to end up facilitating The Retreat even for two hours of that I just need to tell him tomorrow have chance with what you're going to do all right so I guess we'll put the motion uh for January 30th retreat with James
179Gregory and have motion pleas or motion first whatever that's too late for me to think yeah we want a motion for January 30th with James bir I need a first and a second yeah I I support that we still keep that but there's a first yeah is there a second can talk all right now Curiosities discussion comments so with the attorney be in there would the attorney be able to speak on um Dynam like the proper dynamics of the board as far as like um RS and responsibilities or you can you can speak roles and responsibilities with no question um Dynamics he will probably stay away from it by know commun he probably would stay away from like the way that we communicate with each other he would probably weigh in on you didn't want
180to be professional you want to be respectful um I'm taking notes so I can tell you too I think if we had a clear agenda of what we were looking to achieve during that time period Then I would be in favor of it without a clear agenda you're looking to achieve and if we looked at that agenda and says this we not we're not going to get resolutions to what we need during that time period Then I would defer and suggest that we go back to the other lator so discussion about it so maybe what we can do is say okay we're going to keep this date we have a firm date and then the time between now and then if we can figure out something better with facilitator that you can find for later
181like February then we can bump it to that February one because that would be the better option but if we can't get a date with everybody together with a facilitator for February in the future I'm still saying I think it's important that we have some sort of meeting you know what I mean I don't want to cancel January and then still not be able to have a date for February that's what I'm saying one right so I think that we I think that we should all keep the 30th date and then in the meantime I can change my resolution that in the meantime if we are unable to find a facilitator at a future date in February then we still keep the retreat date with James Gregory in January so that we at least have
182a day that we can meet and and and talk so we have one date where we're all together everybody agree with that well there's a motion on the table for January 30th and that's what we're discussing at this time anybody else have she amended well we got to get the first change too then right I'm gonna say the quiet part out loud um I have seen in the past that not all of our board members love our attorney so I'm concerned that if James is T that he may run into some really blocks with personality conflicts with trust conflicts and I just want to make sure that we're all aware again saying quiet part out loud that not everybody is not every St so just saying that because I'm all for having a meeting with
183an agenda with a clear plan but we all have to I think we already had a meeting with Mr it didn't go well and I don't see that environment changing and um I I would be opposed to to this um saying the quiet part out loud I think he'll be challenged on everything as he was the last time and um I don't want to repeat I know I know I suggested it right just for discussion purposes but frankly I think it it would probably be um you know not an Effective Government to you just describe but we don't want to do that for four hours and I feel I don't really want to commit myself to a 4 hour meeting we have no idea what exactly the agenda I think what has been said is
184we need to have a clear agenda I think at this point I'd be in favor of um trying to go the route of you know the a facilitator that we think would be effective and meeting their dat me I think that's going to be be more successful if we can do it if I can add just because with said one of the things with the facil I one of the things with the facilitators is when I'm talking to them and I will tell you I'm trying to make sure that is I have no connections with because I'm part of this whole discussion and the hard part is when I'm talking to them they said are you just doing one and done or do you want us to come in and try to help move the
185board forward that might be something you want to think about if we're able to pull it off is that once we have it you'll have to tell me whether you want because it's not one and done it takes a little bit eff but it is a cost to so but I I agree with what you said Dan is I can go out and find it but it's hard to do both that to S I'm sorry I end so I I agree with j i um we've had we've had James here before and I I think James does a good job it's just that I don't think that's what and um we've just in you know like a year ago we we did this and and I know we have new board members on now that
186we had a year ago but it's it's just going to be a in my opinion a repeat of what we've already done and I think our needs are greater than what James could provide for us so um I am opposed to continue January 30th we don't have other toet our need we don't for membership but why can't we use this I know they're going to cost us money but board of education is important thing if we can have some people come and help us why can't we do that we did that as well so we had we had M come in was January so n came in in January James did it the previous August um and and again it it it we just spun our Wheels um and it just um it it really
187wasn't effective because it was more around how a board operates versus the Dynamics of a board and how we communicate with each other and how we we work together to to make progress um which is why I mean I feel like we need to have a facilitator and you know and I'm the one who had suggested originally to corporate conator um I think our I think our issues are more around um how do we how do we get past conflict um conflict resolution how do we how do we communicate effectively um and I and I think whether you're a corporate facilitator or an education facilitator it's it's all around personal and Team Dynamics right um and I think you know we need somebody that has that level of expertise um having knowledge of how board
188operates I I I agree I think it's helpful but I think it's it's more around Team Dynamics and I don't think it is facilitator or James was able to really help us with that my my opinion based on the past Retreats that we've had with with with that type of support I agree with what Dan and Christine said I don't great guy but I don't think heble to give us what we need I don't think we need to have them come again um I would be against January 30th that going to be kind of a repeat of what we've done before all right call the questions all in favor of January 30th meeting I yes because this is if we can't get somebody for February because we still have the date that's what is for
189so yes I am still in favor of the January 30 meeting if we cannot find something in the future with a facilitator because I still think who your all oppos count one two three four five sixs are you were in FA Sor okay so three in favor six oppos so now if that's the vote I know what I'm doing I'm going out to try to find find extra dates and bring them back and once I get those I'm hoping that whatever those dates are nine people well nine in my staff are going to make themselves at least one okay so at least I have that direction I'll work start work on that tomorrow with some of the people that I work for that wer know they just didn't do it all right so I have
190two last things one I'd like to thank an Marie for our little pad and po fits with rid Road on it thank you very much and if all goes to plan this would be the last time we meet in this room as it is format and the next time we gather rro as a body um you should see lots of changes instru dirty hopefully between coming out of the air up here and then I know this is going to be a little offbeat so if you lulg me for two minutes um my wife is my wife Jackie is a huge fan of The transy Bean Orchestra so during the holiday season you listen to uh CDs and things and then she went and found um a concert on one of the streaming services so we
191got we watching the concert so I looked up Trans Siberian orchestras we're listening to the music and I'm reading about it and um the drummer is Jeff plate now I don't know how many know anarie shaking her head so she knows this so um I had as a student a young man named Jeff PL in the 1980s so I go what the chances so I Google his name and sure enough pet high school graduate Jeff plate well known in the metal uh music genre and he's been the drummer for the trans cyberian Orchestra for 25 years and he work and his mother is out the place and she was a bus dispatcher for many years in the district okay Jeff has been yeah and Al They had two children Terry and Jeff and uh yeah
192over huh he goes all over he and he'll talk he'll talk to kids music program no problem all right one last announcement just so board goes you never fight Alone Michael Reynolds if you haven't seen of our students has at least moved forward in very positive T battle where they think it was n want to send out thoughts to the family I know Mom I think played softball for you as well um but wonderful family the kids have been very supportive he's having a hell of a bold in seing which is good uh and he's a senior here so we wish the best for his family we keep everybody prise but that's some great news for our student body Michael his family everybody thank you