CorpusRecord 621

School Board Action Meeting: December 10, 2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Lee County School Board
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Lee County, FL
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,381 words · about 92 min
Collected
2026-04-07

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone we're are we are ready to begin this evening's board meeting Sergeant arms has a front lobby been attended to yes thank you Chief we request that all electronic devices be turned off or put in silence mode also please refrain from using flash photography except during the special presentations portion of the meeting I am pleased to welcome the December 10th 20124 Schoolboard meeting the time is 6: p.m. and this meeting is hereby called to order prior to the start of tonight's meeting you have been enjoying the Music performed by students of Edison Park creative and expressive arts school Under the direction of Samantha O'Brien and Lisa James this group's performance consisted of students from the chors violin and ukulele and zbl this amazing group of young students were just featured during the Lee

002County School District sound of the Season annual holiday production we're going to ask them then to perform one more song thank you e e e w thank you Edison Park that was amazing perfect for this time of season if you'd like to hear more from the Edison Park musicians they will perform this Friday December 13th at 6:30 p.m. for their Winter concert Edison Park please as I said we'll now take a brief pause as we clear the performance area great job e power e e e we're going to restart in one moment please okay we're going to resume tonight's meeting we'd like to take this opportunity to remind the members of the public of the district's Mission which is ensure that each student achieves his or her highest potential and the district Vision to be

003a world-class school system this evening's agenda includes invocation presentations of colors and Pledge of Allegiance Allegiance acknowledgements recognition public comment consent action items which include one item under Board office two items under executive Services six items under academic Services nine items under Business Services three items under Human Resources two items under Information Systems one item under Legal Services 21 items under operations a recess for the Lee County School Board leas incorporation we will have tonight as well and four items under good of the order board members is there a motion to approve tonight's agenda Mr Ribble okay moved by Mr Ribble seconded by Miss Jordan please record your vote motion carries 70 as is the custom of the board Mr Ribble will introduce his guest for the invocation after this Mrs Langford Fleming will lead

004us in the presentation of colors and Pledge of Allegiance please stand for the invocation this evening I'm pleased to introduce Rick Jacobs the executive director at four kids of Southwest Florida a Forester Care Organization serving Lee CER Charlotte Glades and Henry counties for more than three decades he has dedicated his professional life to the nonprofit sector Rick has been married to his high school sweetheart Christine since 1993 they have seven children three biological four adopted from foster care and together they have fostered over 30 children in Southwest Florida the last 18 years Rick R's work experience combined with his personal foster care Journey has allowed him to lead the successful expansion of the four kids organization in Southwest Florida the four kids mission is simply to find a home for every child Mr Jacobs thank

005you join me in prayer if you would father we give thanks for this day that you have made I thank you for each of the board members each of the per people that are present here tonight that long to make our schools the best that they can be and to strive to reach incredible potential an old proverb says direct your children onto the right path and when they are older they will not leave it and so our teachers we pray would long to do that for our kids and then for those teachers we're reminded what your scripture says let us not get tired of doing what is right for after a while we will reap a harvest of blessing if we don't get distur get discouraged and give up and so God we're we're at

006that halfway point here of the school year and we get to think about this break and so we just lift our teachers to you and all the administration and pray that you would restore and refresh them the kids have just got done singing shabbat shalom which means peace and rest so I pray that you would give that peace and rest to our staff and also to all the leaders that pour into our kids we ask these things in the strong name of our Lord amen introducing the cadet who is presenting the national colors for our Pledge of Allegiance tonight is Lieutenant Colonel William heck senior Army instructor at East Lee County High School jrc Lieutenant Colonel hex served over years in the Army in numerous assignments both enlisted and as a commissioned Medical Service Corp

007officer he retired earlier this year as the executive officer for the 411th hospital Center in Jacksonville Florida this is Colonel hex's first year as a jotc instructor thank you presenting the national colors tonight is Cadet command sergeant major Allan Redfield from East Lee County High School he is currently the team captain for the Raiders Marksmanship and color guard teams and has a 3.6 grade point average earlier this year he enlisted into the Marine Corps to train as a combat engineer he is an outstanding example of what a Cadet represents please join me in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all please be seated next up

008on the agenda are acknowledgements the character word of the for October or for December sorry about that the is H kindness this month the school district Lee County proudly announces the following two winning designs kindness is a language with the which the deaf can hear and the blind can see by Mark Twain Hayden Johnson Senior at Fort Myers High School created the first design you see displayed on the screen and for the second design winner kindness demonstrating concern for the well-being of others IA abar a 12th grade student at stero High created the design scene on this screen so great good job now we're going to move on to recognitions board members please join me in the pit for recognitions okay good evening tonight we recognize the students from the 35th annual holiday greeting card

009celebration I would like to call Dr thomasi yay coordinator of fine and Performing Arts you please join me at the leum in 1990 the superintend of Lee County Schools Dr James Adams requested high school students artwork to highlight the district's holiday brochure we continue to highlight this tradition and showcase the artistic talents of our K12 art students each year we request artwork from elementary middle or high school students following a three-year rotational cycle this year's Entre Entre sorry entries I'm I'm hungry were some committed a bit differently than in the past years we expanded our program to all grade levels instead of the yearly cycle submitted entries were voted upon by The District staff and the winners are displayed in our lobby throughout the holiday season we will be honoring the top three vote Getters

010in each level elementary middle and high school the year's winners and Runners up will also have received Gallery space at the Sydney burn Davis Art Center which is downtown to Showcase their artwork throughout the month of December it is my privilege to introduce our students artistic winners as I call your name please come forward with your school representative Alan Park Adrien Valdez and I'm apologize up front just in case I miss say your name I apologize Hancock Creek Elementary Christy Yamaguchi Orangewood Elementary Joseph Hoy Rivera stheart it's bigger Challenger Middle Irani Gamboa Arena Arena hence Marsh Middle auriana Collins vet's Park Academy of the Arts Emma Mitchell Emma is unable to join us tonight from Cypress like high school oh I'm sorry forget what I just said back it up she's here Emma Mitchell unable

011to join us tonight from Cypress Lake High School Elena gourney School representative please come up to collect her award I Believe Miss RS is coming up riveral high school Sheila panel Doran congratulations also our next one is from their young parent education program Kayla RZ the artistic talent of these students and the dedication of their principles and our teachers are sincerely appreciated their efforts have brightened our holidays congratulations again together J good evening the school district of Lee County is proud to recognize Masha Dori she is a senior at Fort Meers high school and she's recognized for winning the Florida High School athletic associations class 3A girls cross country Championship the competition was held at appalache Regional Park in Tallahassee Florida on November 6 16 2024 this is where I go off script marshia ran

012for 18 minutes and five seconds five I ran track it was a Sprint there was no focus at all just had to listen for the bell and run as fast as you could I had friends that ran cross country and the focus it takes to run that race and the planning you have to stay near the pack do a good job then at the very end you're worried about everybody sprinting up behind or kicking I think is the word they using that's awesome to win a state championship is just unbelievable in that the school board and superintendent are pleased to recognize Masha and her coach Robert Robert Berkeley for their commitment determination and hard work that led to this outstanding accomplishment thank you goe shin good evening the lee district of Lee count the school

013district of Lee County is proud to announce that Amy Clark director of psychological and social work Services have been elected as the Florida Association of school psychologist president-elect Mrs Clark is a certified and licensed Florida school psychologist in her seventh year as director of psychological and social work services in the school district of Lee County her Focus has been to develop and grow the school's psychology department through professional supervision training and recruitment expanding school-based Mental Health Services and increasing compliant timely and appropriate evaluations since 2018 she has increased the number of school psychologists by 60% if yes fp's mission is to advocate for the mental health and educational development of Florida's children youth and families and to advance the professional development of school psychologists a top priority of this organization is addressing the critical shortage

014of school psychologists in the State of Florida the school board and the superintendent congratulates Mrs on this esteemed achievement and sincerely thanks you for your continued dedication to the students and families of Lee County thank you thank you so much for you good evening the Sunco chapter of the National Academy of Television Arts and Sciences is a nonprofit Florida Corporation dedicated to Excellence and television they offer annual Regional Emmy awards called the Sunco Regional Emmy Awards to television markets in the entire State of Florida Alexandria Baton Rouge Lafayette Lake Charles in New Orleans Louisiana Mobile Alabama Thomasville Georgia and Puerto Rico the communications department has been recognized with two Emmy nominations in the education sector Adam Wright and Riley sper for Hurricane Ian a schools TV documentry and Riley sper new single hit teaching Beyond

015sound nominees and winners were awarded during the annual Regional Emmy Awards gala this past weekend we are pre we are proud to share that our team came back with the coveted Emmy statue for the hurricane Ian documentary congratulations Mr Wright and Miss scker thank you thank you that's a handful thank you so much good evening the Markham Awards honors excellence in marketing and Communications while recognizing the creativity hard work and generosity of the industry professionals Markham is administ by the Association of marketing and Communications professionals since in its Inception in 2004 Markham has involved into one of the largest and most respected creative competitions in the world for the 2024 school district of Lee County Communications Department was honored with two distinguished International Awards a platinum award in the Strategic Communications category for the sdlc

016Strategic Communications and engagement plan and a Gold Award in the Publications category for the sdlc impact report these accolades underscore the Department's commitment to Excellence in delivering strategic impactful communication initiatives the school board and the superintendent congrat congratulate director Irma Lancaster and the communications to team for their continued dedication and creativity and connecting with our stakeholders to tell the district's Story please come up and join us in the pit congrat ulations again no thank you than Dr yeah I figured that happen that was awesome we're going to move on now to item e which is public comment attorney de Bruno please address the item of public comment thank you and good evening School Board policy provides the opportunity at this point in the meeting to address the board concerning any matter on this meeting's agenda

017or any other matter relevant to the operation of the school district please complete a public comment card and put it in the basket provided if you need a public comment card they are provided by our staff the rules concerning public comment are posted in the back and will be made from the podium and the front center aisle please be advised that the board will not respond during public comment to remarks made by speakers the purpose of public comment is to provide feedback on District issues such as duties responsibilities decisions and the general operation of the district the school board is Viewpoint neutral during public comment we ask that Decor be kept in respect be shown which is what is expected when a government agency conducts official business therefore abusive language defined as swearing use of

018profanity or name calling is prohibited in addition clapping hissing booing or display of temper during public comment is prohibited speakers who fail to follow proper Decor in the chambers will be ruled out of order by the board chair or the board attorney any speaker continuing with such remarks will be required to relinquish the microphone per board policy 01691 and may be removed from the chambers by the Sergeant at Arms for board policy 01691 the time per speaker is 3 minutes if there are 20 2 minutes if there are 30 and 1 minute if there are 31 speakers and more the maximum time allotted for public comment is 1 hour 60 speakers you will find a countdown on the big screens in the front of the room once your time has elapsed the microphone will automatically

019shut off please state your name when you approach the microphone and I will call you five speakers at a time please follow staff's Direction when lining up Mr chairman there are 13 individuals that wish to address the board this evening the time for speaker is 3 minutes thank you attorney debris Bruno please ensure youve completed a public comment card to provide public comment the card is a public record identifying those who speak and providing content information of Staff or fault the cards are located with staff in the hallway is there anyone in the audience who wishes to speak that has not filled out a public comment card please raise your hand okay I am seeing none attorney de B Bruno please begin public comment thank you Mr chairman will the following individuals please line up

020Anthony call Jessica Lawrence Robert Lawrence Ali lock John C hello my name's Anthony call and of course I'm here again we've had a driver who was pulled off their bus and beaten on and I've numerously said about the safety of our school but I am actually here today to ask that our executive director be removed from his position because he is created an inner circle where only he decides what goes on there's positions made for people that do not not need to be there the word of the day up there was kindness the one person he made an assistant director now was an intern director and had a stack of complaints against her filed by not only people but employees that have quit retired because of this we're supposed to be excellent I'm proud to

021wear this uniform some of the kids that stood up here and sang I was our bus driver when they were little we need respect back here we're wondering how now we have six people that are making over $100,000 a year when there used to only be four what are we doing why are we throwing money away and US drivers and janitors and everything are fighting to get a pay raise and we can't understand this he's made decisions that have cost where they're having to move people to clean up the mistakes who is watching over this who is sanctioning him who is watching the decisions he's making it's making us look bad I'm asking please have somebody Overlook these decisions because when you got to pull a director from the Leonard compound to come over to

022the South compound for somebody who should have never been there in the first place to fix that mess and then make her a position as an assistant director are you going to give every one of the hardworking directors an assistant director no cuz we can't afford it but it's costing us money bad we have parents standing at our door going what are y'all doing I don't know I don't know what to tell them anymore I'm sorry I'm the one who has to say I'm sorry that your kids are late to school I'm sorry that our staff is working so hard to get your kids to school but I'm sorry and our staff is upset our supervisors they work tirelessly I know one West supervisor she's here from morning till evening I praise her every day

023but does anybody come and shake her hand and say you've done a wonderful job no she just keeps working and working and working so I would really appreciate if youall would look into it and please figure out what we're going to do with this District so that we can get these kids to school so they can actually learn thank you good evening my name is Jessica Lawrence I am an English teacher at Lee virtual school on August 29th the Executive Director of Human Resources sent an email communication with an opportunity for teachers to voluntarily transfer to a BSI school after speaking to my Administration considering all the details I accepted based of course on the terms outlined and confirmed in writing I was excited for the challenge of working with new students and collaborating with

024my new partner teacher when the turnaround supplement was finally added to our employee current compensation mid November we noticed that the supplement had been reduced by 15% I was met with hostility ridicule and condescension upon requesting support from Union president Kevin Dy I've been told via email from Miss Rivera and Dr ausi that quote unfortunately it was not specifically stated in the letter that all supplements that are available through the tal contract are prated from the time of year that a person begins working in a turnaround school I have to stop and ask with a letter that was sent on August 29 9th with a deadline from the state to have our names added as teachers of record by September 15th it is clear that District Personnel knew the amount would be reduced but unfortunately

025chose not to include that information I asking that you look at the incentives offered here in black and white and not allow the district to backpedal on what we Educators agreed to upon accepting these assignments I'm asking that the district not be allowed to bait and switch its teachers I am asking that we be paid in full as stated in the letter which spefic specifically asked us to help the district if we allow the district to act without principal namely asking teachers to take a job and lying by Omission about the pay it sets a precedent that teachers can enter into an agreement with the district only to have the terms of the agreement change after the fact we strive to hold our students accountable but the district can choose to act in a way

026that flies in the face of accountability we ask our students to hold themselves to high expectations and standards respect themselves and others and teachers are asking for the respect of honoring the agreement to be paid the full supplement amount the only amount disclosed to us thank you good evening my name is Robert Lawrence and my wife and I have been teachers in the school district of Lee County since 2012 through that time we've been continuously mistreated in regards to transparency and consideration regarding p payroll in compensation the most recent transgression that the district has undertaken to take money out of our pocket and thus food off of our table was the money that my wife described before me to you all regarding the written confirmation that she would receive all not a pro Reddit portion

027of the BSI stien and that now broken promise in my own time in the district I've received a half check without a warning that payroll counts days for employees on a 206 contract to start the school year I've had stiens thoughtlessly and inconsiderately added to Pat that increase the amount it was taxed I've had to wait months for payment of services rendered outside of my normal contract hours and terms I learned that our district helped that other districts helped teachers get less taxes taken out of the Civic seal of Excellence stien while we the teachers within Lee County covered that on our end to all of that I ask you kindly please stop messing with our money most of us entered this profession because we have a passion for teaching students but it is our

028personal children my two are sitting here tonight that are paying the price of the school district's continued practice of finding loopholes making excuses and failing to uphold their promises surrounding payroll and compensation in a transparent and timely manner despite being a governmental career of service these are our careers our lives and the inconsiderate and often forgotten fact remains that when you withhold payment delay payment or impact how those funds are taxed that you take money away from a group that is already severely underpaid and struggling to give our families the lives that our peers and other business businesses with similar credentials are able to give theirs I simply ask what measures are in place to hold those individuals and departments accountable I've given up on talc being an instrument to keep the district accountable due

029to its poor leadership by Kevin Daly if you wonder why teachers leave why there is a shortage why our schools are in situations that they are regarding Staffing look no further than how you treat your employees and the situation that you put them in when asking them to do jobs without adequate payment and a transparent and timely manner our CH our children are here so my wife and I can set an example of standing up for yourself I hope that this board and the superintendant also set an example of doing the right thing and fulfill their promises I'm proud of my wife for sharing her story and support her in her quest to hold the district accountable to their word because this has gone on far too long I hope that with new leadership sitting

030in front of us this triggers the type of change the district dearly needs to allow our children to continue their academic careers within a district that is hemorrhaging quality teachers based on practices just like this thank you will the following individuals please line up Robert Daniels Jenny tardiff Paradiso devach bana Gary Price Alexander Grant good evening board members my name is Ali Lock And I am also a teacher at Lee virtual school I have been a teacher in this district for 13 years and I have Faithfully served my time here and been identified as a Highly Effective Teacher year after year I too received the email back in August to voluntarily switch and help out schools that were identified as BS high schools like Mrs Lawrence we had the conversation with our principal and our

031Administration and agreed to the terms that were laid out before us in the letter sent by the district when our supplement was finally added to us we saw that it was reduced by 15% it doesn't sound like a lot but when we make what we make every penny counts Dr Carlin I voted for you because I believe in you I believe in your platform and the administrators that I've worked for over the past 14 years also believe in you I am told that you are teacher first and that you will do everything you can for teachers in this District all I'm asking is that you honor that please we were told when we looked into this by Dr susette Rivera that she would escalate the request to honor the full amount of the $4,000 toour

032supplements but then later told by Dr iusi that unfortunately it was not communicated that would be pro-rated I'm asking you please to fix this error because it will not cost the district much to honor this as fewer than 30 teachers had to make this switch with a district that has over 200 current vacancies your strategic goal is stated to retain highly effective teachers and this is one way that you can do that by honoring what you said you were going to do for us thank you greetings Welcome to our new superintendent and board members I haven't seen before my name is John C I'm a proud parent of a child at 4 Myers Beach Elementary as well as a member of the ad hoc committee representative from our town I want to give you a

033quick update on where we are with the Ila there's been a glitch getting an Accura out operating cost number I'm not sure why however we collectively know what that number is because previous superintendent Dr Bernier presented a proposed budget for this year that our previous principle Dr Kohler con form she held to prior to retiring I went over the numbers with her it's a little over $1.1 million to be exact $1,134 183 we had 67 kids prior to Hurricane Milton we lost five on a temporary basis but feel confident they're coming back Upon Our return to the beach if I divide that 67 kids by our cening operating cost we've already met the terms of the Ila as our cost per student will already be lower than Pine Island if I divide it by the

03462 current students we currently have not counting them five we're only a couple hundred per student above them how did this happen so fast two reasons first is hard work and Sacrifice by your staff and teachers over a half million dollars was saved in our staffing we went from 25 to 30 staff down to 15 to 20 second is hard work by our community your demographer told us we wouldn't have more than 40 kids in our school by now we're up to 67 I could go in detail tell on the multiple ways we collectively have increased but don't think they're important for this message I was extremely disappointed to C Patria stood in front of you last month and cared so little about our school that she didn't take five minutes to verify our current

035numbers before labeling us her biggest regret FMB is nothing short of a partnered success story an amazing success story in the making I implore you in the strongest terms to keep having our back as we will achieve great things together for our child I want to thank you for hiring Kim praxes our new principal she will be the same rock star for us that Dr kler was and I want to tell you your teachers are amazing our current staff levels as well as the more diverse kids we are seeing at our Beach School makes their jobs very difficult but they are true Warriors for our kids and we really appreciate that lastly hurricane Milton hit October 9th that will be 9 weeks tomorrow our parents still have not been given a timeline for our return

036this is just too long it's unacceptable 9 weeks sending a Friday email that basically says we're are still waiting in this or that just isn't cutting it anymore it's hard for me to convey to you how much more difficult our family's lives are when we get busted off the island how much time our parents can't go to work because we're waiting thank you sir your time is up my name is Robert Daniels I have a new character word that I would like to recommend for next month reciprocity that is the basic idea that if I enter into an agreement with you and I do something for you I will get something in return from you later as agreed without having to fight for it having to argue for it you can call that the found

037found a of our social contract with each other the idea that if I live in my house and I don't bother your house you won't come and bother my house this is how everything in our society works and holds together as my co-workers have come down and talked about we have a problem with this idea currently in the district but it's not new as I have come here for the last two years and spoken about this problem has been in the compensation portion and in the student discipline portion of our work for going on about a decade now when I first came to the district 13 years ago as a teacher the Charter School Employees were all applying to fill every position we had they were chomping at the bit to get to the district

038was a goal getting to the district for me me raise of $5,000 back when that would translate into about 12 and a half now it was an incredible jump to come to the district the district had excellent student scores unfortunately they've dropped at about the same rate as teacher pay has as we adjust over time I'm the numbers guy I've come here before with the numbers I've taken from your annual reports sent to Tallahassee and hosted on the do doe website and have said hey our pay was down by 24% when I first started we've gotten a little better it's down by about 16% now I came forth and I said hey why is it that our pay as a portion of the total budget is down by about 9% for its portion of the

039budget with the thousands of millions again thousands of millions if it's 2.5 billion that's thousands of millions of dollars it is very discouraging to the teachers that the union when it is able to has come and press lawsuits to get a partial payment on an agreement of what was to be paid to hear that even what amounts to chump change for the district is not being paid out to employees directly without having to protest and Lodge complaint one of the few things we can fix directly with just throwing money at it in this District as I have said before is the teacher pay the support staff pay the bus driver pay your own Esau Department came here last year and said they could not hire new Personnel because the applicants were refusing to accept the

040job overpay time is up thank you good evening hi Bill how are you I'm Gary Price I've been a resident of Lee County for 46 years so I've seen the growth has happened in Lee County and most of it's good necessary the downside of that is the destruction and loss of any historical structure many historical structures we have Bita Springs has three basic historical structures and a few houses one of those is Ben Springs Elementary many of our residents including one of our Mayors went to school at Benita Springs Elementary I urge you to do what you can to preserve that structure or at least the portion of the structure that we all see from the street if there's no well there's no way I had the pleasure of being instrumental in the preparation of

041the untold stories of wgcu and the reason for that is because we don't have in-your-face history we don't have the structures like you have in New England we don't have the Forts and the and the structures like that but we do have some historical structures and they are important to the future of our community if you forget your past you're in a sad state so I urge you to do what you can to preserve the Bonita Springs Elementary School thank you will the following individuals please line up Robert Rio R sorry if I mispronounced your name you mispronounced my name and I need to talk it's is that okay I'm sorry I'm calling some individuals to line up for public comments if you could just please hold L Naro and Nigel fck the other individuals

042who are lined up please go ahead and continue on we just adding individuals to the line and Mr bana will be next after Miss tarda thank you my name is Jenny tardiff Paradiso and I am a parent of a child at Fort Meers Beach Elementary I'm an alumni at Beach Elementary a member of the PTO board and I'm also on the ad hoc committee last time I was up here I was convinced that it was the final time no offense to anyone involved but that was not a good time not for myself my friends my neighbors we spent entirely too long not knowing and too long fighting I'm here because I don't want to repeat of that for any of us I understand the floors that saturated the drywall needs to be changed out the

043remediation is done the report should be done we're all familiar with the ins and outs of post post storm procedures and how quickly or slowly these things can go please keep moving forward please keep the parents informed actually informed I want us to be able to continue hard on growing our stem water school program and continue to increase our enrollment and meet the goals that were laid out in the Ila that was formed we promised our children that they would be back on this Campus before the school year is over please help us make that happen sooner rather than later thank you good evening for the record my name is Derek bana and representing the Bonita Springs Historical Society dear Lee County school board members and staff I stand before you today not just as

044chairman of the Bonita Springs Historical Society but as the voice of thousands of residents who deeply value the heritage of our community we are here today to ask your support in preserving the historic sections of the Bonita Springs Elementary School this isn't just a building it's a part of our City's Soul a place that tells a story of where we've been and inspires us where we're going in a little over 2 months I la launched a petition to save the vital pieces of our history and the response has been overwhelming 1,116 Southwest Florida residents have signed this petition and over 11,364 individuals are actively following our efforts these numbers reflect a community that cares deeply the message is clear we want to see the historic sections of the Bonita Springs Elementary School restored and repurpose

045whether as part of the school's future fure or a place usted by the community to serve as a local Museum a Welcome Center or a cultural Hub this is an opportunity to create something extraordinary a place where education history and Community come together to inspire future Generations imagine students and families walking through Halls that tell the stories of Bonita Springs learning not just from textbooks but from the walls around them imagine a space that welcomes visitors and serves a vibrant Landmark celebrating our past while creating pride and belonging we understand the challenges of balancing budgets and priorities but preserving the historic core of B Springs Elementary is an investment not just in bricks and mortar but in the identity legacy and our community Spirit of Bita Springs I urge you to listen to the voices

046of the people the 1,116 petition ERS and 11,360 Advocates watching this moment last Saturday I had my first town hall there was several individuals from city council present there is now 15 active individuals like myself that are ready to go door too if we have to to stop the destruction of the of the historic ban Springs Elementary thank you good evening everybody Robert Ryu I work for the district in the maintenance department Dr Carlin congratulations and the rest of you I'm here today for just a couple reasons Anthony I worked with Anthony I first started driving a bus down here we moved here from Connecticut and he's totally right I've seen how they work I've never seen anything as bad as that is with the bus company sad to say I moved on I worked

047at maintenance department I'm here today because we just got a new contract ratified and I noticed that our wages our starting wages went down in turn to give us a raise now we had a study from green or whatever and we found out we were so far behind other districts we needed 22 point $7 million why do you take this not my wages but some of the guys I work with laborers 16 something an hour you brought them down 1590 something Carpenter 2204 now it's starting to away just 21.99 I don't understand that we can't get enough workers we keep going and going and going do this do that what are we supposed to do when I started working here as a bus driver there was almost 800 bus drivers we're down to like 530

048550 why are the kids late well we got two 300 I hear the district say we're only 100 short well to me if we had almost 800 now we're 500 something there's a problem because we went from 94,000 kids to over 100,000 kids now you guys can give yourselves $30,000 raises you can can do whatever but a bus driver gets $1,700 a year figure what give us a break Dr Carlin you said you would work for us please help us I love my job I really do I enjoyed I came here I worked on these walls I put them all back together Jeff and I he's retiring in February I do what my boss tells me I enjoy my job I've been a carpenter for 30 almost years but we need your help thank you

049good evening board members Dr Carlin good to see you up there finally my name is Nigel fullick and I'm here this evening representing the entire city council of Bita Springs and several thousand concerned citizens I'm also grateful that three of my fellow council members are here with me this evening in May I learned from a parent that a meeting was held at which parents were told the entire School building was to be demolished and a new modern school would replace it we applaud the attempt to provide long overdue upgrades to the facility but believe several important factors were overlooked in making making the decision this brick Schoolhouse was built in 1921 and our school is the only property in Benita Springs listed on the National Registry of historic places a state historic marker is displayed

050in front of the building and I was there in 2008 when Lee County Board chair Dr Jane cuckle good friend and mayor Ben Nelson cut the ribbon and placed the marker it remains a proud day in our City's history and is one of the few tangible reminders of our past we expressed Our concern to the school board staff after I confirmed the school meeting with Kathleen Morgan there were some informal conversations between City staff and your Schoolboard staff after Sam fiser called me at home in June our staff and myself were of the understanding that your staff was working on providing more information revisiting the decision and that we would then meet to address our concerns while we have not had any formal meetings with elected members of your board and our Council we were

051given to understand that we could address them in a public Workshop that being the case in good faith our Council took no further action and avoided addressing this through the media Fox News reported last Sunday the school board Representatives had stated that you were demolishing only a portion of the old schoolhouse but our city manager was informed in a letter on November 11th that your board would not meet with our city council and the decision to demolish the entire building remains intact I along with several building officials contractors and Engineers have concluded that the Deferred maintenance and lack of necessary repairs over the past four years have now rendered the school to a state where restoration is neither feasible nor pragmatic costing anywhere between $6 and $8 million we recognized and shared that to do

052so would not represent responsible use of tax dollars or be in the long-term interests of our children in conclusion I'm here this evening to ask that your new board recognize the district had a resp responsibility to maintain this historic building and now has an opportunity to work with us to preserve a limited portion of the structure by focusing on the south facade and incorporate only the original buildings footprint or for plan in the new construction we want to put past issues aside and work with you to the benefit of the children families and community that is Benita Springs in Lee County as a reminder Ben Springs represents only 8% of the Lee County population but we contribute over 11% of school tax RC your time is up thank you sir Alexander P Grant from Bonita

053Springs and I'm a member of the city's Bonita Springs historical board my resume is being sent to you I am have a bachelor's degree in both chemistry in history from University of Chapel Hill and a master's degree in soral science and I've had emology courses after that and anyway so I am a State Certified pest control operator and I own bugsaway Inc when I heard about the a problem with the school and I had received from the city manager and I read all 132 pages of the report on the Bonita Springs Elementary School I looked into the termite problem and from my observations in the photographs on a number of pages they are drywood termites which OB obviously must have occurred from flying insects in the vicinity that somehow got into the roof area of

054the N what it was the 1927 building now I know that the people at changa the developer there built on his own so first ball bought the property on which the school is and built the 1921 School in 1927 the there was a city of Bonita Springs before the depression and then we unincorporated and then we incorporated thanks to me I was chairman not of the City original City Charter for Bonita Springs anyway in 19 n what 1999 the national rail national historic preser Society the National Park Service made this a National Historic Site I had spoken with the city manager and thank you for your comments sir your time is up good evening chair School Board superintendent lunar 30-y year 38-year teacher tal member Jasper pstd service talkg I spoke with you Mr fiser

055and Mr psons last week and I was really disturbed about returning to only not returning but going to one meeting a month you're the fifth largest District in the state 32nd in USA you all are making about 50k now according to Mr persons's and the starting teacher salary is only 50,500 3 minutes for citizen input once a month you need you need to go back to two meetings a month my opinion you're falling forward the more money you're making the less you want to do the job I'm discouraged I was also not very happy about being intimidated by the security guards cuz I went over a few se you know you need to lighten up Mr fiser we talked about that even mayor Gunther gives you about 20 30 seconds and he's a pretty tough

056customer then the ccpd might come in not these big people here that came over to intimidate me I don't like intimidation at 20 years old I was at Fort Jackson Fort Gordon we've been now found out we were exposed to agent orange where were you all at 20 happily living your lives this is wrong I'm really discouraged so please don't intimidate me all right I just for the record all I had asked for was some prayer for Dr Charles Bell 30 years person here employee that's all the family wanted and I wanted to mention something about volunteering to be with kids well we won't go through that anymore you know I'm disturbed that these people have to beg you for supplements you know I don't know what's happened I'd like to know why C got

057990,000 from FEMA and I got zero what's going on here Dr Bernier I respect him but he's left baggage behind I really believe that I'm trying to get a hold of him in Jacksonville but he didn't return my calls something is wrong here you know I'm going to wish you Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year but I'm going to wish you health because with health you have everything all that money you ain't taking it with you ask Jimmy Buffett and anybody else and I'm not either I turned a your time is up Mr nvar I appreciate you thank you sir Mr chairman that concludes public comment thank you every everyone for those of you who can't see I've noticed superintendent Carlin staff has gone around to address many of the issues so they will

058be looked into so I also want to address we had members from the city government city council within Bonita Springs I saw vice mayor pone as well as we had the aforementioned council member fullick I don't know if I missed anyone else my apologies on that so I want to thank you for being such good partners with the school district in regards to historic building the board has spoken on that and student achievement needs to come first and that's why I'm so excited to partner all of us are excited to partner with the city of Bonita Springs to bring forward that $0 million brand new state-ofthe-art school and we really are truly looking forward to making sure that we partner and work on a way to give honor the historic building as part of that

059process whether that's with the city of Bon Springs as well historic so I want to appreciate you all for that and we look forward to continuing to hear feedback on that so regards to everyone else want to say we truly truly appreciate your feedback it is really important to us to hear that so thank you everyone and we're going to move on now to the next item on the agenda which would be consent agenda items so the documentation for Action items listed under consent is made available to board members seven business days prior to the board meeting we're expected to review all the materials and we have opportunity to speak with the superintendent with any questions we may have regarding the recommendations some of these items have also been working shop with the board in

060advance of appearing on the action agenda board members are there any agenda items you wish to pull for discussion Under The Unfinished and tabled items I will start with you miss juven Elli yes M consent operations 14 M14 which is approval to pursue the sale of 18 plus acres of sdlc property of 13401 Palamino Lane okay M14 has been noted thank you Miss juven Elli Mr Ribble none okay Miss Jordan none okay Mr persons I have none Miss Langford Fleming I have none Mrs chavano I have none and I have none so is there a motion to approve tonight's consent agenda's consent action items with the exception of item pulled M14 I make a motion to approve the agenda okay moved by Mr Ribble do we have a second second and by I'll second it

061second by Mr person so please record your vote motion carries 70 before we proceed on to the next agenda item superintendent Carlin please introduce any administrators and attendance we'll do chair fiser thank you very much for the privilege to announce our following administrators that have just been approved with the approval of this consent agenda so I'd like to introduce to you for the very first time darcia Burell who's our new assistant principal at Island Coast High School next up Jessica Rebus assistant principal Manatee Elementary very proud to announce Michelle Stanford as the proud principal of Pelican Elementary congratulations to David nulan who is being promoted to Chief safety security and Fleet operations Jess Jessica Dairy Berry who is the new assistant principal at a moner elementary and Kimberly English boxa principal of Fort Meers Beach

062Elementary we are very proud of all of you we know that you're going to do a phenomenal job at your schools and your sites and just thank you for joining our leadership team we're very proud of you thank than you Dr Carlin congratulations to everyone as I will always take off of Mr person's on this so please enjoy tonight and we look forward to seeing you all tomorrow in your new R thank you next up on the agenda will be item M14 whenever I'll take a pause to clear the room e e okay we're ready to resume the meeting whenever you're ready Dr Carlin please read your recommendation for item M14 thank you chair Fisher my recommendation is to approve the to approve the sale of 18 plus acres of school district of Lee County

063property located at 13401 palino Lane to American land Ventures for 12 million million $250,000 the estimated settlement costs to the district for broker fees legal fees and Title Insurance are $848,000 281 this designation indicates that the property is deemed unnecessary for educational purposes approval authorizes the superintendent to execute all documents thank you Dr Carlin is there a motion to adopt Dr Carlin's recommendation was there a First oh somebody I'll make the motion to approve motion to approve by Miss Ribble do we have a second okay Miss Jordan move by Miss Jordan second just want to confirm for the record thank you okay I will defer first off to miss juvell for any disc discussion thank you so for me I just I want really want to talk about this because I think we really need

064to think about selling land we're not purchasing land or and God's not making it and I know this is 18 Acres and it's not suitable for our prototype but are we really thinking outside the box could this have been an opportunity for attainable housing could this been an opportunity for a 7 750 seat school we know we need seats in the East Zone this is fairly close to the east Zone I just feel like we really since we have a new superintendent to have fresh eyes look at what is Surplus what we should be keeping what we should be selling and just to put it in perspective this is 18 acres for 1.2.2 million right 12 million and we just sold 69 Acres Three Oaks Parkway for 15 million so that's a big difference if

065if you start looking at that and the values and I'm telling you dirt is not cheap and I just am concerned I don't know that this is a bad deal good deal I'm not going to question that's not really what I'm my thought is really that we need to really be looking at our land and what we have I really didn't think we should have sold the 69 Acres even so I really would like to have the opportunity to have the superintendent and they're new and she's not had a chance to really look at at what we have listed to really look at what we have listed what we're going to sell what we really should sell I can I understand we have something like an acre and we have property on like upper Captiva

066that there's no school going to be on upper Captiva so I don't have a problem with selling those things and a lot here and there but 18 Acres that could be a site for 750,000 I mean 750 students I actually had a couple constituents that contacted me that are in the business and they said we shouldn't be selling land because we don't know where we're going to need a seed or two so that's why I pulled this item doesn't mean we won't sell it six months from now and I'm and I'm wrong but I think that superintendent should look at the look at our Surplus and really decide if this is what we should be doing at this time that's it thank you any other board member comments Miss Jordan thank you Miss janelli and

067I know that you've brought this piece of land has been brought up multiple times over the years and we always come to this conclusion of not selling it so I I feel the same way that when you're stating that land is it's just not there and yes I would love for our new superintendent to take a look at that and put her eyes on it and see what she feels Mr persons I mean 18 acres is maybe you could put a real small school on there but that's really not where we're probably going to be heading I don't think that would be cost effective you put a small school there you still got to get a s you know principal assistant principal the parking and everything else it's ends up being you know more expensive

068I now whether it's a good deal or not I'm not in real estate so I can't say that I'm trusting our planning department and everything that's looked into this that it is a good deal I'd rather see that money taken sold if we're not going to use it don't have any plans to use it this time there's nothing in our Capital plan to use it at this time and put toward something that we are going to use I mean it's just to hold on the land I agree it's not there but that area is built out if we don't need seats there right now I don't see where we will be needing seats so I'm more inclined to say I mean because it's been brought up before and it's just sitting there it's Surplus right

069now so unless the superintendent or someone has a defined use for it I think we could better use the money again it's sort of like do we want to keep it or do we need to keep it is it a want or a need and I'm just not sure at this time go to miss Langford Fleming then I'll come back to you Miss ganelli well first and foremost I want to thank Miss ganelli for bringing this topic up because so many times we'll go through a consent agenda and we'll just pass everything and I think that this is something that could later on somebody have questions about so I think it's great that we have a conversation about it especially for the public to see why we do what we do because I think that's

070part of the biggest problem we have had in the district in the past and I'm I'm taking a risk here as open at opening a can of worms but this is why two superintendents ago I brought up a conversation about why I feel it's important that we don't have necessarily just one commercial realtor that is looking out for the best interest in the district i' I brought it up in the past I know that our County uses multiple and and so to me this circles back to this particular I something like this we could be getting advice from more than one that's in the business none of us up here are commercial Realtors I know Miss ganelli is in the is in the real estate industry and so I have I can't speak on whether

071this is a good deal or a bad deal and I and I can't even speak on what we could put on this piece of property that could benefit the students of Lee County and what's best served is the taxpayers money so I guess I just I needed to state that for the record it was brought up I brought it up to years ago almost two years ago quite frankly and I think that's something that we need to converse about in the future instead of why we're relying on one group to maybe advise us on what we're doing with our real estate I'd love to hear what the superintendent has to say about this and I guess I'm open to tabling this if research needs to be done for the new superintendent but I'll go ahead

072and hand it over through the chair to the super Dr Carly so first of all thank you for the conversation ation and I really do appreciate U Miss G vanelli bringing up the fact that you know I'm new to the seat and having that opportunity to take a look I did notice a couple of things and obviously being retired and having some opportunity to watch board meetings before I was elected gave me a little bit of perspective on what we're doing in terms of how we land here one of the things I noticed right off the bat was right before I got here we made a decision about the capital plan the costs were exorbitant you know cost of you inflation cost of materials all of that has skyrocketed and so I saw the board

073take deliberate action to actually reduce what we were doing with our Capital plan so that we could still move forward with some projects but there were unfortunately some projects that went by the wayside right and so we know we're in a high growth area we have 2,000 new students since May so that is that is definitely a concern to me because we need to make sure that we have a capital plan that is aggressively looking out for for you know being able to provide seats for students having said that and I also recognize Miss G ganelli for talking about attainable housing that is something that we've talked about as a community you know and that's a decision for us to make a conversation for us to have as we move forward do we want to

074be in that business you know there's a lot of reasons to do that we heard some teachers talk today about teachers leaving bus drivers leaving so you know it's getting difficult to be able to afford housing and so there is some some arguments certainly to be said for sitting at the table here's where I fall in this issue we have had some conversation offline with staff and they really are talking about the importance of you know looking closely at each of these properties and I also heard this in the community when I ran you all have a lot of surplus properties out there what are you doing and when you cry that you don't have enough money and capital what about all those properties the ones you know you're not going to build on the

075ones that are too small to really do anything in terms of substantively impacting your population in terms of serving your students so where I fall on this is I am comfortable with the sale of the property again I'm not a realtor so I you know it's hard for me to judge whether that's a good buy or a bad buy you know again I leave that to the experts but I will tell you that some of the things that Miss G gelli talked about tonight looking at attainable housing looking at our Surplus property and making decisions about what we're going to do with that property is on my radar so I would recommend that we proceed with the sale but we will keep those things in mind that the board has spoken about tonight thank you

076anything else Miss link for fing before before I go to miss juv vanelli no I just I found it to be very important that the public heard the superintendent's why behind the what thank you Miss janelli thank you thank you Dr Carlin for that so in just a rem little history for some of the newborn members as well this is the third contract for this piece of property two have fell apart before that so that it's a red flag that doesn't mean that this is even going to follow through with the sale as well we don't even get notified that when deals fall through like I found that out I think on the contract before this that the deal fell through like so that is one thing I would like to be updated on but

077I just think it's important to really think outside the box because I don't think we do that enough I think you know like using the Prototype it's not always perfect we're having to do something different for the Innovation school that's now not going to be called The Innovation school so I mean I think that looking at the plan and really dissecting what are we doing cuz we're kind of sometimes all over the place because we're not getting all the information or we get all the information but we're not given all the information the information sometimes there we don't always get it so I think it's I still am reluctant over it at this point in time because I think we should slow down a bit like I said the 69 Acres at in Three Oaks

078I don't think we should have sold that so I will probably vote no tonight but I respect the board and their outcome and I respect the superintendent sant's thought about all this but I'm just going to stay firm that sometimes I think you know God's not making any more dirt and I'm going to stick to that thank you any other comments before we move forward okay I just want to appreciate your Insight on that Miss juell thank you and you've brought some of these things up before I'm comfortable myself going forward with this but I agree with what you said and we really need to think outside the box and many of the issues you've talked about we've talked about as a board and I'm excited especially with our new superintendent the things that Canen

079happen now moving forward so we are going to was there anything else Dr okay is this going to be a roll call Vote Yes okay this going be a roll call vote so signify by saying I or nay we'll start off with you Mr janelli I'm a no thank you okay Mr Ribble i m Jordan I Mr persons I Mrs Lang for Fleming I Mrs chaviano I and I an I motion carries 61 thank you thank you next up on the agenda is Lee County Schoolboard leasing corporation we will now take a recess from luro school board Action meeting to attend to this matter the time is 7:30 p.m. as president of the Lee County Schoolboard lease incorporation I would like to call this meeting of the Lee County Schoolboard lease incorporation December 10th 20124

080to order the time is 7:30 p.m. on this evening's agenda includes public comment two secretary's recommendations good of the order and other business directors the president will entertain a motion to adopt the agenda for tonight miss Jordan I move to adopt the agenda as written okay we have a second a second okay this will be a roll call vote on this okay Mr juven Elli yes Mr Ribble yes M Jordan yes Mr psons yes M L for Fleming I Mrs chavano I and I am an i motion carries 70 attorney debris Bruno please address the item of public comment at this time members of the public have an opportunity to comment on the items outlined on the agenda for the leasing Corporation and Mr President there is nobody who has signed up at this time

081okay is there is there anyone in outside in the audience right now that is wishing to make any public comment on matter for the leasing Corporation okay seeing none moving on we'll now move on to the secretary's recommendations Dr Carlin please State your first recommendation thank you chair Fisher approval of the minutes of the last Lee County Schoolboard lease incorporation meeting held on April 23rd 2024 is there a motion to approve minutes Mr persons I make a motion to approve the minutes from April 23rd 2024 of the Lee County Schoolboard lease incorporation is there a second I'll second it thank you okay moved by Mr Pon second of Miss juvenile is there any discussion on these minutes okay seeing none we're going to go by roll call vote again Mrs juven Elli yes Mr Ribble

082i m Miss Jordan I Mr persons yes Mrs Langford Fleming I Mrs chavano I and I and I MO carries 70 we'll now move on to the next item on the agenda Dr Carlin please State your second recommendation thank you sir approval of the organizational resolution of the Lee County school board lease incorporation for the election of officers okay directors you've heard the secret secretary's recommendation to approve the organizational resolution of thee County school board lease Inc Corporation for the elction of officers I will now entertain a motion to approve Miss l Fleming I'll move to approve second I'll second moved by Miss lenford Fleming seconded by Miss juven Elli this will be again a roll call vote Mrs juven what is your vote Yes Mr Ribble i m Jordan I Mr persons i m

083lanord Fleming I this is chavano I and I and I motion carry 70 we'll now move on to go to the order other business please note that comments may only be made in Your Capacity as directors and officers of this Corporation there any comments from from you miss juven I do have a few well this just for the leasing coration I have nothing leasing I'm sorry thank you sorry just wanted to make sure Mr ribel I have none M Jordan I have none Mr psons I have none M lenford Fleming I have none Mrs chaviano I have none and I have none at this point having no other business come before this body and seeing no objection the meeting of the Lee County Schoolboard leasing Corporation is now adjourned the time is 7:34 p.m. I'll

084NE now reconvene the regular school board Action meeting of December 10th 24 the time is 7:34 p.m. we'll now move on to good the order and other business and I will now start with you Mrs juven II we have we approved a lot of things tonight but there was one thing that was that was particular that I wanted to talk about and I was trying to find it really fast it's the partnership with the with the state attorney H where did that go I just want if the community to know about it through the through the chair if the superintendent could just kind of talk a little bit about that real quick I was trying to find it and I don't know which one it is that Partnership of course it was like a big

085paragraph too so it's H6 under academic services and I threw the chair okay to speak about it thank you very much so this is an opportunity for us to partner with a wide variety of agencies State Attorney's Office the 20th judicial circuit the Children's Advocacy Center of Southwest Florida the Sheriff's Department Fort Meers PD Cape Coral PD Santa Bel PD and of course with us as a as a school board and really what we did tonight was we really to we helped to streamline collaborate and minimize the number of interviews involving juvenile victims of abuse neglect and including sexual abuse so this gives us an opportunity really to have more of you know ability to collaborate around these types of very serious issues that confront our children and making sure that we always preserve the

086you know the I don't know the ability to be able to talk with kids on a certain amount of times and not put them through additional trauma when they're involved in in various types of abuse so obviously you know very sad topic but very good news in terms of our ability to partner with our fellow folks in the community so thank you and so thank you for that because I think it's I think it's important I mean when some when when a victim has to tell their story so many times this eliminates that trauma have to relive that trauma and I think that I I'm excited to see how this is going to to you know unroll and but it at least it's supposed to help the victim where they don't have to tell their

087story but you know one time to an adult and hopefully makes them feel more comfortable so like I said I'm this is a kind of an interesting partnership and I'm I'm excited about it because there's so many groups and that you're going to you know that that are involved in this partnership so I think it's exciting the other thing that I really wanted to talk about real quick was and this is through the chair if the superintendent would look into this the transportation department and the because we had some speakers come tonight and talk about stuff that I know that you're aware of because I've been we've been talking about it and I am concerned over the transportation and I I don't know how well it's not my role to make it better but to

088bring it to you and which I have but I mean when you have the employees come and the victims come that's cuz they feel like that's their mentality is a victim mentality and they don't see change and the change that they see isn't what should be changing then that sends up red flags so that's why I'm going to like have you really delve into this and really get to the bottom of things so we can so they can do their job and full comfortable that they can continue doing their job otherwise we're going to lose them to go do their job somewhere else and that's that's my concern because you can see the heart of this gentleman that comes and I know there's many behind him that are standing there asking for him to help

089and they're sending him as the as the advocate for that but and I know there's more because they're calling me too also this BSI stien I would like to get information on that and what if if in fact it's been reduced 15% and what happened because I am concerned on having when you have another you know teachers come and and complain about this and saying there's nothing they can do well they did speak up and I'm certainly listening up so I am going to make sure that them coming and speaking and and I love the fact that they said they brought their children to to show them for standing up for themselves and that this is what it looks like and there's nothing going to happen to them in fact I hope it's going to

090give 15% more so that's my plan so anyways I just wanted to acknowledge that and have you look into those two items and I just want to wish everyone a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year take the time when your vacation you have this vacation and enjoy every moment to relax because I know how hard everyone works at the district and I look forward to 2025 I think it's going to be a new year that'll give the sea legs to the superintendent maybe a little bit better opportunity for her to really get more information and get up to speed and I wish everybody at the table Merry Christmas and happy New Year and 2025 will be here before we know it so thank you thank you Mrs juven Mr Ribble all right I'm only

091going to take a minute I do heard this afternoon about my compliment to Scott rickenbacher and all he does with construction and I was very impressed with him I had a great meeting yesterday with student services found out what they're all about and how they're moving forward last week I attended the Florida School Board Association that was a cold several days of learning up there but we ran into some familiar faces here I want to congratulate Sam Fischer for being elected to the nominating committee for that board and we also I also want to thank our attorney depri Bruno who ran a excellent workshop on First Amendment rights and believe it or not my favorite topic civility so I thought you did a great job you were well received by all the folks that were

092there from the other 67 counties so that's all I have thank you Mr Ribble Miss Jordan thank you if I may Dr Carlin I also would like to have that if you would make sure you share that information regarding transportation I really feel that it is time for us to to figure this out because they continue to come and we want to make sure because we do need to keep them happy to do that and Absolut absolutely will do that thank you so much on that I really appreciate that and as well as the and I really believe that our word is our word and so when the family came up and spoke I just want to make sure that we are who we say we are and we do keep our word on that

093we'll look into that as well thank you and also I just wanted to put this out there I was going to pull the job descriptions however I did not after speaking today and speaking with Dr Carlin but again listening to all of our staff come up again and speaking about money I really want to make sure that we are really responsible and really making sure that we are doing everything we can for our employees who are very dedicated they're here all the time and I know Mr call he did have a lot of the kids from Edison Park that was his school at one time so I thank I thank him for always caring about the kids as well also tomorrow night I want to make sure that people do not forget that northp Myers

094Academy is presenting The Nutcracker it's a beautiful transition and you really want to go and watch this Northport Meers High School actually just performed elfl this past week they did a tremendous job and they also performed that they had over a thousand elementary kids came to the school to watch Elf my granddaughter was one of them so I listening to the story over and over again for days now but they always do an excellent job and you just cannot beat the performances that they do they are excellent we want to go and we want to make sure that we do support our students and our schools so please you know keep track of you know on the website they it's always there of what they're doing so please do that also there was I was

095able to attend a street a new Street honorary Street named after Pastor Edwards over off of Palm Avenue and in Fort Meyers who was U helped with u seg desegregation of our schools way back when and I just wanted to bring that up because there was a lot of people there and I think that it was a noteworthy of us to I was there and I felt we had Jared Edie there who was the historian of course and it was just a really a great day and I want to H say happy birthday to Mr Navaro because he did tell us it was his birthday he slid that in there so happy birthday you know to him and just want to wish everybody a Merry Christmas and hopefully everybody gets enough rest and comes back

096and we start the new year off together one team one dream thank you Miss Jordan next up Mr persons you could be a coffee bean I am a coffee bean I do want to say there's been so much going on since we had the new board brought on on on boarding the fsba many events welcoming events but the one thing that I really enjoyed since our last meeting was the grants they a did Awards even though I am disappointed they give out more money than when I was chair they get they gave out $100,000 in Grants to various schools and teachers and that was from the Lee County Foundation is amazing but the one that stuck to me and the one that I want to see our district get behind somehow find money for funding

097is Ty Elementary has an excellent program for teaching English to the parents who don't speak it they were awarded 5,000 to continue that program I think they got another Grant from somewhere else also so we need to really make that because it's such a problem when so many of our parents cannot speak English and cannot communicate to the district and we just need to somehow do everything we can to rectify that I know some churches are also working on that but it needs to be a total Community effort so anything we can do to get behind that I'll definitely support that's all thank you thank you thank you Mr persons Mrs Langford Fleming thank you and first of all before I get started on my list apologize I had to scoot out early from today's

098Workshop so I'll I'll try to be as brief as possible I just want to say thank you to the speakers that came this afternoon or this evening and address the board I used to say this to my students all the time if I don't know it's broken then I can't help you fix it so and that goes for our community members if we don't know there's something going on then we can't help you fix address the problem or fix the problem so thank you because Miss ganelli touched on the listen up speak up and I know that this board is also committed to following up as you could hear on this board tonight while we continue to push and ask those questions I did attend the fsba yes Miss depe Bruno knocked it out of

099the park thank you so much for Clarity on the first amendment I got a lot of positive comments after after that talk cuz I was really proud to say well she's our board attorney so I happen to know her personally but you know another part of the conference we were able to do breakout sessions and the one I chose to go to because I am a mom and I've just started I've started to see a pattern that's bothered me a little bit and School attendance is a huge concern it's a huge concern in the state a huge concern in the nation has gotten worse since covid I'm going to try to say this delicately it's not going to come out that way I am passed using covid as an excuse anymore we are Beyond Co

100and I know this District can come up with Solutions on how to get these kids back in the classrooms consistently it's directly correlated with student achievement and to get there on time whether they're bus riders or parent drop off or Guardians take them to school I mean our bus drivers are working around the clock Mr Call's here and he's probably got to get up in two hours so not just that but staying in school all day all 6 and 1 half hours that they're supposed to be there and I would like like to challenge our families at helping us keep those kids there because what's happening in first period is as as as important what's happening in 7th so that's just something that I've had a conversation with the super about and I wanted to

101bring that up on the board on the dis because I wanted you all to know I've been talking about it behind in our one-on ones thank you to St to Food Services today for providing the meal I know that was extra work on your part but I do agree with Miss Gianelli's final comments in the board Workshop I know we can do better and I and I I to I have complete faith that our food services are going to do better and meet that challenge I know part of it is financial financials part of it is communication part of it is what we can and cannot do but I know if these conversations start happening that we are going to come to Solutions yes Miss Jordan always say such a great job at bringing up

102all of our student events and not take anything away from our you know the events that happen that are outside of our schools but if I was going to take my family somewhere I would much rather take them to go watch violinist at the Edison Park you know their concert or a show at the barber B man performed by the North Fort Meers Academy arts and etc etc and that's that just that happens all year long I'm getting there chair Fisher we have endured another sticky year with another hurricane and the fact that we're here at the first after the first semester and the wheels are turning and the machine is running I just kudos to everyone on all the staff that made all that happen and I really truly hope that our staff and

103employees shut their laptop for a little while I know you're not going to do it the entire two weeks because I was an educator and I know what that looks like but just for a little bit Embrace time with your family and friends and we get those two weeks off or or the staff does but I think it's important that we know there are some individuals that don't get those two weeks off and those are the special young the special gentlemen that are here in tonight in right here in our sro's and I appreciate you so much because I know that you're going to still be working to keep our fam safe through the Christmas season and I really really appreciate all that you do Merry Christmas and happy New Year thank you thank you

104Mrs Chavana yeah so I spoke earlier about you know a great week at fsba so we'll leave it at that there's a lot to learn so coffee being moment great job to Edison Park music Ensemble that was truly awesome to see our kids in action and as a mom whose daughter wanted to play violin and it's excited to do it I was like goodness this is it so very very cool very very proud like congratulations to these parents and supporting those efforts CU that's extra after school there's all these other things that go into that so thank you for championing that and I look forward to seeing what else these kids are going to come up with as we go on for the year of course as we enter the holiday season there is a

105lot going on for everyone and I really do hope everyone does truly disconnect because life's going to happen anyway right things are going to happen so take those moments with your family because you don't get those same moments twice you know take the time be grateful look around and just really recharge and fill your cup and be ready for the new year that's going to come cuz exciting things are going to happen I just look forward to serving you guys for next year so rest up be healthy be safe merry Christmas happy New Year thank you thank you okay I am up next when obviously most people have already spoken about stuff which is great so I appreciate that real quick fsba had a really good time up there really able to talk to a

106lot of different people from some different District and get some ideas I do find it amusing and now I know what Miss juven Elli and Miss Jordan Mr persons Miss lford Fleming we're no longer the new kids in the block so we know what that's like house there but great time up there thank you I I know they're going to be there will be a future meeting but I want to congratulate principal Burnside of dumbar high school for principal of the year assistant principal cook from North Fort Meers Academy the Arts and Miss Peggy Quinn of traler Middle School of school related employee year so that was we most of us were able to get around to that and that was that was a great moment outside of that oh thank you as well to

107principal Rino for as usual inviting us to Thanksgiving that's always a great time at a lam teal so outside of that I am excited for the new year it's as I said before pedal to the metal I want to wish everyone a happy Christmas happy Hanukkah and a Happy New Year so oh and attorney de Bri Bruno as everyone else said great job and like Miss lford Fleming said they're like who's that attorney so the work you put in we appreciate you so thank you now on to you m attorney to PR Bruno so the one thing I will say that in both sessions there were members of the audience who are asking some very thought-provoking questions they know who they are they some of them are on this day that's right now just saying

108but thank you very much Bor for for recognizing that I just want to wish everybody really good happy holiday season Happy New Year and merry Christmas happy Hanukkah this is the opportunity for us to just pause and really think about gratitude and being able to espouse our Humanity with each other we sent our legal quill and we were able to find a legal Avenue and a legal reason to be kind to each other especially during this season so we continue to ask that everybody do that and that's it thank you see you next year Madam superintendent thank you chair Fisher so I'll just Echo what everybody said about fads and the fsba conference this has now been I've had four days of new superintendent training so I think they are onboarding us well they kind

109of enticed us up there said no you're going to be with your board and then they whisked us away into training so it was kind of a kind of an interesting week but always just great to be with you and thank you so much for just everything you've done to welcome me on board this has been I I know Miss chavan and Mr Ribble Echo these sentiments but you know when you come into a new position and you know you're on the campaign Trail and you're elected and when you land together as a team I wouldn't choose any other team than this team to have my first superintendency experience so just thank you very much for that couple things just speaking of the conference just congratulations again to chair fiser on your recent appointment to

110the Florida palm Board of direct or Board of Trustees that's fantastic and also to the fsba nominating committee this past week so congratulations on that Miss lenford flemy I couldn't Echo your sentiments harder relative to the attendance student attendance and tonight we approved an amendment to the stronger connections Grant which has everything to do with everyday labs and support around our schools and their efforts relative to relative to interventions for student attendance so we're very excited about that I also had an opportunity need to get out to schools this week yay so that was exciting got to see The Nutcracker at North Fort Myers Academy what those children do over there and just seeing the principal involved the very professional set they have it is absolutely gorgeous and I hope you all get a chance

111to go tomorrow night I know I had a prayer commitment so I snuck over to the school the other day just a beautiful performance our little guys all the way up to our older students in sixth seventh and eighth grade there's a ballerina I'm not going to ruin it but she is absolutely amazing the talent is esque and I just can't wait if you get the opportunity please go see that so speaking of the first couple of weeks I'm very very proud to share with our community and our board has heard me talk about this numerous times we are so focused as a district on the five priorities that I ran on we talked on the campaign Trail and now I'm so happy because as a team we've talked about our priorities and getting laser

112are like focused on the work so things like making sure that we're ensuring safe schools for our staff and our children we had an incident a couple of weeks ago that you're going to hear about on the news if you haven't already relative to a situation at one of our elementary schools open gate caught the weapon that was going to be brought onto the campus and stopped it right there so we'll be talking with you about that but we just got noticed that was going to be on the news also things like increasing student achievement and I heard numerous teachers come up tonight and other team members and talk about how important student achievement is and that is our number number two priority right after Safety and Security and I'm going to share with you

113that our team is buckling down we are looking closely at ways to improve student achievement it starts with the teacher and it starts with high quality practices I heard a little talk today about budget and prioritizing our budget making sure that we are putting the dollars where they belong and I've heard comments about how are we going to preserve dollars and actually generate dollars so that we can put them towards salaries and things like that as the new superintendent in this school district I can tell you that I have an unwavering commitment to our staff I know people have said it I'm going to share with you how we're doing it I have given a work directive to our cabinet they will be coming back with their budgets in terms of cuts that will be

114made we will go line by line like I promised on the campaign Trail and we will will separate out the must does and the nice toos and when we talk about generating dollars for salaries that's one of my priorities is making sure that we're looking at those nice todos perhaps putting those aside and instead focusing on those high quality teachers and other team members that we have in the school district and making sure that they are making a livable wage so that is my commitment and that is the work we're going to go to work on as as a Cabinet we're going to model the way as the central office we're going to start the work and then I will share with you empowering the voices of parents very important talked on the campaign Trail

115about being a parent many of us our parents currently and we need to make sure that our parents are our partners so just thank you for indulging me allowing me to share some of my priorities with with our our public and now they are our district priorities so I'm very very proud of that work and can't wait to get started on it and then finally just want to wish everybody a very very Merry Christmas a happy holiday season and all the best in 2025 can't wait to get started get my skis under me and with our team I just also want to thank you for your commitment to this District to all of our teachers and our support team members and everybody out there including our students and families just have a great holiday disconnect

116all that good stuff we talked about tonight on the dis but please make sure that you take time for you regenerate take some time to relax and just enjoy your family time and we'll see everybody back here in January thank you superintendent Carlin next scheduled meetings of the board January 7 2025 there'll be a Schoolboard workshop with yes what go ahead M I apologize I just wanted to make sure we recognized our Communications today with the awards that they won but our HR department also had won some awards Dr Carin if you could I just want to make sure that oh sure yes thank you very much thank so much I appreciate that I would go home feeling bad no no worries at all thank you so much U Miss Jordan and let me find

117that just a moment here thank you for bringing that up so yes we did gosh and we are so lucky because we have so many different people if we if we recognized everybody that won an award we'll be here through next week but this is something very important so our chief of HR has also won an hro today Association award for excellence in the North America region and so thank you for bringing that up and congratulations to Angela now we're on to next scheduled meetings Tuesday January 7 2025 will be a Schoolboard workshop with public comment at 1 p.m followed by a Schoolboard Action meeting at 6:00 at this point having no other business to come before this body and seeing no objection this meeting is journ the time is 8:02 p.m. happy holidays everyone

118e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.