CorpusRecord 6235

2025-01-08 Abington Heights School District Board Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Abington Heights High School Media
Date
2025-01-09
Location
Lackawanna County, PA
Material
Transcript
Extent
5,779 words · about 33 min
Collected
2026-05-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001ladies and gentlemen welcome to the first meeting of 2025 for the amton high school board would everyone please rise and Pledge Your flag I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all it appears uh Dr schaer has many tasks tonight so we'll wait for him to sit down before we do R exactly exactly okay yeah Mr abdalah here Mr AAR here miss Henderson here miss hillbrand here miss carum here Mr Moran here Mr Robson here miss tney here Mr AER here perfect may I please have a motion to approve the agenda for the meeting of January 8th so moov second on the motion roll call please Mr AAR yes Miss Henderson yes Miss

002lebrand yes M Kum yes Mr Moran yes Mr Robson yes M tney yes Mr AER yes okay Mr abdalah yes that was intentional intentional okay um can we please have the superintendent's hat so on to your next role okay have a a a brief uh presentation today and it's really long on the lines of uh FYI uh um so the first one is not uh behind me on the board because it's just uh uh a couple of dates uh to remember um but we'll be announcing this and advertising this in the future um as as many of you know the Pennsylvania school code um is old predates the uh internet so we communicated School boards had to communicate in different ways and that is codified uh into law through statute so sometimes it it it

003does not make sense um however we still go through those processes and one of them is called an act 34 hearing which we're mandated to do uh for certain construction projects and the uh objective Behind Act 34 is to make sure that the public is aware um of everything uh that is occurring it would provide uh the opportunity for the uh board to hear feedback uh from uh the community and it's also uh a time where we uh set a uh threshold uh on construction uh that doesn't mean that the the the costs can't increase if it did you would go to another uh act 34 hearing so what that means for our purposes is that on February the the 5th the first board meeting in February uh all be uh putting a motion forward

004to ask the board to approve the advertising for a special meeting and at that time uh we will announce that we will be having an act 34 hearing on February the 27th so this is something that we need to make sure that um we have the opportunity uh as a board to hold space for because this is a special meeting this is an act 34 hearing um there will be uh specific criteria um that we will go through uh this will be facilitated uh by a solicitor um and then we'll have um folks here from the construction management uh company in kcba and we will essentially uh lay out the details that we already have numerous times uh about this project so this is not uh a surprise this is part of uh the the

005school code which obligated to do so I want to make sure I announce that in public so this isn't we're not trying to do something uh different I believe that we've been uh overly transparent as we should be throughout this whole process and Dr schaer is there like a particular threshold of amount on construction project or is it just no it's what we take is our because it's before a bid so it's uh our best estimates through the construction management and um our uh kcba so the next informational item that I I want to uh briefly go through uh as we turn the page on a new year in 2025 is this is really when we start our our budget process and um as as as many of you know and if if you are

006unaware often times School boards have to um approve our budget before we even know the state allocation despite the state having the same or the common wealth having the same deadline as we do I have yet to see us make it sometimes um we don't know what our allocation is well into the fall um that's certainly happened uh many times in my in my tenure this year was pretty quick and we found out in late August um nevertheless uh we have have to go through this process and uh in the beginning of this process what I always uh say in public is the board may take some votes in the very beginning of 2025 regarding the preliminary budget and they are not voting on a final budget that final budget vote comes in June okay

007so I just want to make sure um that everybody is uh aware of that so today what I want to talk about is our timeline that I'll be putting forth to the board um relative to the Act One referendum exception uh timeline and I'll and I'll talk a little bit about this but as I uh sat down to uh put together the preliminary budget with uh our our business manager Jim uh mirelly there were a couple key drivers uh that led to this timeline uh which I will discuss in the next uh Slide the timeline but I want to take this opportunity uh to talk about some of those key drivers that in in inform our uh decisions and our timelines I often talk about them as headwinds and Tailwinds uh every year we seem

008to have a bunch of headwinds and a bunch of Tailwinds and we do a a really good job at managing our budget throughout and coming in uh on the right side of that but it it it takes uh careful deliberate strategic management of your operational budget to do so and that happens kind of throughout the year but um these are kind of some of the the the the key players and and levers that we've seen throughout uh but uh special education enrollment uh has grown by 32% increasing from 450 students in 2019 to in uh 2023 it's certainly uh higher right now but what I'm doing is I'm pulling data from completed sources because the data to our state has a a lag so Jim we just submitted you know final reports in late November

009um and this is this is a a piece of data that's not uh shocking to me I think that uh there's there's different ways to take a look at data and they they tell a story and when I take a look at uh this it tells me that we are evolving in education uh we are evolving as we better understand uh the Myriad of of disabilities uh that are out there that uh many of our students um are faced with as a result of high quality research that we see uh in the United States we do a very good job there we're learning more and more about how to uh diagnose quickly or quicker than we did in the past we are uh learning better strategies as Educators uh to attend to the the various

010needs the the the depth and complexity that some of these disabilities present with within our classrooms and outside of our classrooms um and uh that's a good thing so unfortunately this does have uh an impact on our budget that way um and over the past six years uh our special education costs have have risen by 2.4 million so that's a a 30% increase as a result of of this uh the state provides us with two different subsidies one for special education one for regular education over that same period of time our subsidy from the state has gone up 133% while I am um you know hopeful and uh I appreciate that 133% increase there is some disproportionality that that we see there and that is just one of the uh challenges that we face and

011this is something that I advocate for and talk to our local legislators about how we we uh provide or calculate special education subsidy and you've heard us talk about this as a board and certainly me as a a superintendent about uh how this impacts us with uh cyber um so and for the board and anybody out out there listening um this this makes a a big difference for uh schools like inton Heights um that have to uh produce a Lon share of the revenue for Education um you know almost 70 cents out of every dollar comes from local sources to educate our children uh 29 cents from State funding and as you can see Federal funding only makes up 1.4 or One A Penny of that um so this again is it is nothing new

012we talk about this quite often that a majority of our uh funding for Education comes from uh local Revenue in addition our our health care costs have increased by 1.67 million over the past two years um 15% and 133% respectively uh some years prior to that we uh we did well and we didn't have to reimburse ourselves and I know that that sounds odd um but we are self-insured so we pay ourselves monthly um so you know we pay close to $600,000 a month for healthcare and in some cases when we do well we withhold a payment but that hasn't been um the case over the last two years we've been monitoring this we had uh held out hope that perhaps This was um an anomaly postco because we had not um ever experienced anything

013like Co but we do know uh anecdotally and through evidence that many people could not see their their doctors and health care providers during that time we obviously had some savings there and then we kind of regress back to the mean and then exceeded that by probably a standard deviation if you're into statistics um but we're at that point now where I spoke with Jim Marbell and said we now have to allocate more money into the operating budget uh to the tune of about $800,000 okay um because we are self- funded and we need to carry a balance and if we didn't make that adjustment within two years we would need to be we wouldn't have much choice but we'd have to join some type of Consortium we'd have to there would be a lot

014of things that would need to happen and so I I don't want to put the cart before the horse so that is a that was a key driver and of course uh Debt Service increases as we talk about construction as a result of this um we're putting together a uh preliminary budget um that will address this now this is a preliminary budget so we are we'd be voting on a preliminary budget but this is not the final budget the board uh has the authority to make any decision when it comes down uh to numbers when we come to a a a final uh budget but on January the the 10th we are going to advertise in a newspaper to give public notice of our intent to adopt the 2526 preliminary Budget on January the 22nd

015Jim will be there and we'll have the opportunity you'll be have the opportunity to ask questions we'll present the information um this deadline is 10 days prior to the budget adoption on January the 22nd that's actually 2025 I'm sorry about that error um we will uh put a motion to approve a preliminary budget which will include a tax increase above the the Act One index okay and then this is where the referendum exception comes in there's only a few instances and really only one that Abington Heights qualifies for to go above the Act One index and that has to do with special education and so we did qualify based on the data that I that I told you okay so our base our index is 4.7% with the exception it's about 5.2 Jimma have the

016exact number it's 5.2 um so that preliminary budget will have that 5.2 number there on January 23rd we will publish a notice in the newspaper of our intent to request approval from the Department of Education for a referendum exception so we have to then ask the Department of Education so as you can see nothing is a given here but you have to make sure um to protect yourselves it's my job to put protect you that way to look over those best interests and whatever the board decides the board decides but I I think I would be negligent if I did not uh look at that um so we'll publish that notice of our intent and then March 6th is a deadline to seek approval from the Department of Education for this exception uh requiring their

017approval and when I when we talk about an application there is a form that we fill out this is uh a very simple I'm not even going to call it an algorithm plus minus divide equals and you can tell sitting at a desk within five minutes if you if you qualify so if we did not qualify I would not be putting this in in in front of you um so that's that preliminary budget and then as you know the data will come in from January all the way till the end of May where we'll be making adjustments and then we'll talk about those adjustments and put it in front of the board in June for a final adoption and whatever it may be and it's just like anything else before you know I could I'm

018putting together a budget that is the maximum that will be a 5.7 and the board could say zero but I need to put that in here to account for anything that we may qualify for um that uh may protect us based on that information and during that whole time as we look at the information that comes in we'll re-evaluate the numbers so for instance I talked about uh headwinds and Tailwinds and for the last seven minutes I've been talking about a headwind a Tailwind for the last three years is our EIT has come in strong to earn income tax and by all the metrics that I've seen up to today it's coming in strong again probably a A plus 5.89% somewhere around 300,000 to the positive so that's a that's a tremendous um Tailwind but

019a a six number pales in comparison to a a 30% or 27% and as I talk with with uh Jim about this and I often times I I I I kick numbers around with him and some times it's in frustration and as we looked at this and and a lot of things too are out of our control and we advocate for different sources of funding I I told Jim that when I was a little kid I used to go play whiffle ball every single day in the backyard in the summer sometimes we'd have 15 neighbor kids out there playing and sometimes it was just like four of us so I would be on third base and I'd say all right there's a ghosty on First and a ghosty on second and you're just trying trying

020to keep track of all these goosies they're just like these people that you don't see I said Jim we just had to add 800,000 into healthc care that's like eight ghosties and I said plus six from Esser I've got a Newton Ransom school full of ghosties and I tell you that not to you know hey let let's kind of feel bad but to understand the challenges uh that the board has there's no decision that is easy everything it seems like is a tradeoff right and the worst case scenario is that we get into the business or we have to make sacred tradeoffs and we never want to have to tradeoff something sacred for another sacred that's just a matchup that I don't want to see in contrast to Penn State Notre Dame going any lines

021um so with that said and knowing that on January 22nd is when you'll have the detailed presentation um are there any are there any questions relative to the I I can't give you all the budget details but the process and the context did you say IND 4. 4.7 so the base index good question the base index in Pennsylvania is 4% then there is um for lack of a better term a poverty ratio that's the uh the term that everybody uses um ours gives us an additional 7 so then our index is 4.7 and then then we get a05 a half a percent on the exception it I think it comes out to almost a mill yeah yes yes I'm gonna let me work over with Jim have the number now I'm moving from like percentages

022to cash and yeah okay I I know the answer but I just I just want to make sure we confirm it for the public so we may put together a budget that had we will be putting together a budget that will in all probability have a tax increase correct perhaps as high as 5.2% correct but in reality this board doesn't have uh to approve that increase until June correct so everything we do until June is is simply budgeting and so on vote in June is what decides and at that point if the we have a budget that's 5 has a 5.7% increase the board says they're uncomfortable with that they can do that at that point in time correct they are not locked in nope the board could say we want 0% we want 4%

023we'll vot we just got to go higher right we just get into trade-offs but we'll have some of that data as as we get closer because again I'm giving you Health Care numbers and Jim and I have been tracking it since July and it's comur with what we saw the year before but maybe things turn around I don't know we but we still have plenty of data markers coming in on that I think I misspoke that vote isn't at the end of May it's the end of June correct we have to have it it's we usually have it in somewhere mid June in that area so if you could go back one page yep because I don't remember exactly what so you said uh healthcare costs increased by 1.67 million over the past two years

024is that combined I know you said it's 13 toal close to it's it's 870 in change each year each year yep so like when we talked about the budget a year ago was it roughly 800 lower than that like you know half of that lower good great question so for the most part we have budgeted a 3% increase yearly for healthcare approximately $250,000 and for a good bit of time that worked out well right and then we budgeted 3% and we went 800 close to 900 over and then we budgeted 3% again same thing happened and then and we stepped up the meetings with our Health Care Consultants uh we talked about more projections and we are arrived at the conclusion that the most prudent decision to make is to put another million in which

025is your 800,000 plus your normal 3% to balance things out and a lot of those cost increases are prescription drugs special specialty drugs it it's the um same cast of characters that this is not an Abington Heights thing if you pick up the newspaper you know I I could not I'm not going to name some you know large Health Care Systems but I've certainly read about many Health Care Systems that and and I know many of you know uh that are facing the same thing school districts uh facing the same things and we just we looked at at you know all sorts of different ways to kind of contain it um and it just um that's um but that's a very that's a very volatile number compared to like budgeting the cost of paper right

026correct so like and that's a that's a huge increase over the last two years right and like huge we're hoping right that it doesn't continue but like you budgeted 800 like it could get worse it it given how till it's been recent yep it could we it it's and so like to put into context from a finance standpoint like when we all got together year ago and said hey we can raise this much in debt based on the budget and a lot of things in the budget will move but like that's a big move that's a lot of cash flow that's a sub if if you I shouldn't be doing like you know Ma Matchbox math here um but 800,000 is a hefty sum of Debt Service yeah it's probably if you said hey we're

027going to put this 800 towards Debt Service we're we're talking probably over 10 between 10 and 20 million in debt service and then you're just saying well we're going to not do that because we have to put it back into our operating and that number really also uh it relies on the experience so if we have a couple employees that have catastrophic illnesses that drives the cost right out site whereas if if that doesn't happen perhaps we have a quote good year and and I think a lot of that has to do with the age of our Workforce the older they are the more likely we to have higher yeah I you know we um that's why we have we have our our Health Care Consultants because we're not um only providing health care for

028our employees um well look we we uh we provide health care for what I think it it it breaks down to be call It 33 to 35% of our healthc care is our employees the remainder are the dependents and then the way our contract reads we do carry past right so these are these are uh opportunities for growth uh and Improvement um as we work with our uh you know our partners in the district uh our unions as we we we think about um how we might uh provide high quality Health Care in uh a more cost-efficient manner um this just happens to be a a really challenging battle and look I'm a I'm a Neo fight with Healthcare but I've tried to read about it it and I just get more confused as I

029read about it but I I I do know that we work with many different people uh with Healthcare enough to to to you know confuse everybody but but to Mr aar's point I mean 14% uh it could be way worse uh because just the cost of materials and labor over the last two years was well over 20 so not that it translates one to one but it it could be higher it could be higher sure and and we've had years where we've had over 14% increase in healthare um because we're self-insured we have a we have but we have a balance that we keep and there's always been a percentage that we've always kept towards that what do you do you have any understanding of yeah what is our what what do we have in

030that that account I I do um to my knowledge and I think we've addressed this before too there is no industry standard for what you should have in a balance with that said three years ago our balance was enough to pay for a Year's worth of claims which some may consider to be healthy but one thing I learned in statistics is that outliers are volatile and a couple of these outliers years and all of a sudden we're instead of 12 months we're now closer to six months so Jim and I ran the numbers and said if I did nothing if I advised the board to hold at 3% and did nothing at the end of 25 26 we would be in a spot where we may not be able to be self-insured because we would

031be at an area where I could not advise the board to continue because you another month could wipe you out you can't take that risk you can't take that risk is right so so by doing by making this adjustment up I'm pushing it out you know I'm saying okay this this is a significant you know we've been close to 900 at a loss but we've we had a before un healthy times $6.5 million um fund but when you're you're losing 2 million then you know you're in a spot where you got to make that adjustment those numbers so you said we were at six so it's currently sitting at 45 and the L this last year was 1.5 overs well it's well again these are my notes from uh from Jim's um fisal presentation but

032um my notes say that we were we are currently at four and a half and um our loss was 1.5 and he made a point to say we will need to replenish that fund um now what the numbers that I'm giving you I I don't want to get into the Weeds on it but we do get we do get some coupons back for prescription we have stop loss insurance stoploss insurance does not always kick in and so when we account even for that we're we've got losses so and I think as your as your balance goes down your stop loss insurance goes up because from their standpoint they have a higher risk even even in times where we did well the stop loss Insurance went up never seen it go go down so um and

033it gets harder and harder to to get there isn't isn't that much that isn't that competitive a market so it's with the mar yeah exactly it's the opposite of Market y Absolut yep so um It's a situation where you have to be conservative the good news is is that we're I'm bringing this up in January on purpose you know we've got you know six more months left we're going to there's a whole lot of information that has to come in this is why Jim if you put them in front of you would say well yeah you know I always have a difficult time putting together a preliminary budget I mean Governor Shapiro hasn't even put out his preliminary budget and then two minutes after he puts that out we hear from a different segment saying

034that's a joke it it should be you know the opposite of that and then we'll we will have to talk to other professionals and figure out oh well where should we put our marker in the preliminary are are we going to get an increase are you going to take money away yeah so but that's that's you're you're you most of you are used to this is how it this is how it goes and and and um I just want to be fully transparent about you know this wasn't an arbitrary type of decision it was informed by some information that I wanted to put in you early and then we'll keep on tracking it well I appreciate the information especially with the deadlines and the time frame because if we are going to go above the

035index we have to go through the the guidelines and the deadlines correct to be able to qualify for that so I appreciate the timeline okay okay thank you very much no problem uh our next item is uh time for public comment if there's someone in the public that would like to add the board um please come forward we'd like to ask you to identify yourself and where you live and keep your comments to roughly three minutes or so um so is there anyone that would like to speak to the board okay let's move then to the action and discussion items Dr schaer okay Mr aard ask that the board uh consider anot a motion a motion to approve uh the Personnel report as presented so moved second on the motion roll call please miss Henderson

036yes Miss hillbrand yes Miss Kum yes Mr Moran yes Mr Robson yes Miss Tierney yes Mr AER yes Mr abdalah yes Mr AAR yes motion carries I would like to note that uh Mrs Morrison our new Director of Human Resources is here and uh welcome we're excited to have you and I believe that you're gonna be starting January 22nd around yep close enough great all right okay Mr Aker ask that the board consider a motion to approve the 2324 Ida use of funds agreement with the neiu this is an annual agreement they're used as a pass through so moved second on a motion roll call please miss hillbrand yes Miss Kum yes Mr Moran yes Mr Robson yes Miss Tierney yes Mr AER yes Mr abdalah yes Mr AAR yes Miss Henderson yes motion carries

037n Mr aard asked the board consider a motion to approve the agreement with valdasta State University for student teaching field and clinical experience um I'll just take a moment uh here because this is this is somewhat new within the the last uh two years but um for probably those in education and and and most likely uh other fields uh that I'm unfamiliar with um it is becoming more and more difficult uh for teachers to find uh in-person programs certainly um there are advantages to programs that are online and as we um see more uh online programs occurring that means that we're going to have to have more articulation agreements from universities that we typically um may not uh have approved and and this is one of them so I just want to make sure everybody

038was aware of that so move second on the motion roll call please miss carum yes Mr Marine yes Mr Robson yes Miss Tierney yes Mr AER yes Mr abdala yes Mr AAR yes Miss Henderson yes Miss hillbrand yes motion carries n Mr AER um before I read this next motion I would probably be breaking Robert's rules that I'm totally unfamiliar with at this stage with asking Mr AAR to provide a little bit of an update from the facilities committee uh relative to a a construction management contract that we have I think don't they what's that I think the committee makes a motion yeah on the question I can make okay okay that's good then we'll do com all right then then in in that case Mr uh AER I would ask the board to consider

039a motion to approve a construction management uh contract with IC for the addition and renov renovation of the Abington Heights middle school so moved second on the motion all right sure so I'll make a few comments um the facilities committee did meet um last week right after New Year's uh to discuss the whole process again that we went through uh in our search for the construction manager and I'll start with the conclusion the committee unanimously unanimously voted to recommend putting IC on the agenda tonight for the full board uh to vote on so the process that we ran over the last couple of months uh led by Dr schaer and his administration um I think was an excellent one um Mr mirelly put out an RFP we got five responses the firms that responded to

040the RFP included um cha boil IC site logic and quandell um once the proposals came in Dr schaer shared them with selected members of his administration team including uh Mrs Snider the Middle School principal uh Mr parfrey our had of facilities as well as all the facilities committee members uh Miss hilderbrand had to recuse yourself she had a business relationship with one of the biders um Mr abdala and I were able to attend the finalist interviews in person where um after we did a ranking of the of the proposals it was pretty clear that uh we wanted to bring in three finalists and those included cha IC and site logic um all three firms came in and presented for about an hour all were excellent everybody on the committee once the interviews were over agreed

041that all three were qualified all three could definitely uh perform the work that was required it was great to have three qualified uh finalists um and after a good amount of deliberation and and discussion um we did Mr abdal and I and Dr schaer in particular um all agreed that IC was uh the number one choice um for a variety of reasons I was uh a little bit ignorant to what is a instructure manager do and so for the for the board I guess I'll just mention a couple of things so there there were and they all presented very similarly in terms of the process um the three main things that the construction manager is going to do for us in this project is is is first the preconstruction work they're going to get together

042with our design firm kcba and really dig into the drawings that have been done so far and analyze them and make any based on experienced suggestions uh that they think should be considered as well as potentially cost savings if they think there's ways uh for us to save uh on design uh processes and then once that process is it'll be somewhat iterative is is complete uh the second stage is running the bidding process so they really manage the entire bidding process where we go out to hire our four Prime contractors the general contractor electrician h back and plumbing uh and then once that process is done they have a person who was one of the people that was uh at the finalist interview which is the actual on-site manager that sits at the site in

043a trailer every day from dawn to dusk basically throughout the whole construction process that works very closely with uh Mr Snider and our administration at the middle school on a daily basis to make sure that the project site is safe first and foremost and to make sure that the contractors are building what they're supposed to build um so that that whole process from start to finish um is is basically the the simple scope of services uh there's a lot of detail in the contract uh that's on the agenda tonight so um that's it if anybody has any questions on on the process that was run I'm happy to so Mr RAR not so much on the process but in looking at the the contract there's um I couldn't help but be reminded of our our

044pool project and um here's the good news that they have a daily PM there which is really good yeah that was really that was like my biggest concern yeah um and I know the the pricing is is such that there's a little bit in the beginning a little bit at the end and then there's a a chunk of about 820,000 or 113,000 in the middle the things that you talked about uh is that what the the the main deliverable is I mean I know there's working with the architect and daily PM work which is all good y but what's the what do we get for specific to the construction manager what do we get I mean I think that the bulk and Dr schaer can jump in too I think that the bulk of the

045cost of the construction manager is the fact that they're on site for two years it's it's really that person that's in the trailer every day running the process that's the bulk of the fee I don't I don't know the exact breakdown but that is actually the bulk of the fee uh and then the other processes which include the preconstruction interactions with kcba right uh and they the bidding process itself which is relatively quick but requires a lot of expertise expertise those are not as uh cost intensive so to speak not as time intensive as the actual so there's a lot of there are you know as Rod said yes for for two and a half years there will be uh a project manager but right right now I've already been sitting in meetings with them

046so we we meet bi-weekly with no less than eight Engineers project managers quants um usually three Architects and now with construction the construction management team coming in um what they'll do is they're looking at every design element what type of screws do you have what type of floor do you have and what we'll have access to is is is um you know a construction software package yep procort and we'll have um and we'll have that with us for life kind of um and we'll go or they are going through this pre-bid process where um for lack of a better term they're like checking the work of The Architects right they're taking a look at things seeing you know where we may save they're taking a look at the data that they have saying are these

047estimates on on time and then per like as we talk about um recent a recent suit that we settled um we are putting together bid documents that are very specific very explicit about what we want right which if you do that the right way then you can mitigate issues that we had uh 10 years ago right in addition we have built into uh the contract um a problem solving procedure right so not only is the construction manager there all the time but there will be Engineers there so if one of the trades people on the floor says you know what it shouldn't be done this way it needs to be done this way I know what the architect said on paper but this is what it looks like in the field there is a protocol

048that goes into place and there is a final decision maker in that and that's who you're hiring today is that construction management firm and then they will go through this pre-bidding process they'll put the the bidding documents out this will go to bid and in early June late may will'll be up here and IC will take over and we'll have a lot of people in the room and we'll open up envelopes and and and so it all um Begins the total of this is contract is around 898 242 I think there's one other thing as I think about it this isn't the construction isn't just one contract to a prime contractor state state law says we have we being Abington Heights has to execute a a RFP for electrical and RFP for mechanical and RFP

049for construction four different contracts four different contractors that we will have contract with so now imagine a situation where we're trying to build a middle school we have four different people on site at the same time doing the same thing and we have to make sure they work together and not only work together but well and get it all together so they're really there to protect us as much as anything too right but it's four different contracts go ahead mral and right correct me if I'm wrong all three fees were all yeah they were all very tight same thing all they're all similar and I you know I just like the curse saying this in under budget relative to what we budgeted prior to going to bed prior to you know realizing that we' run

050into rock and we need more time but um yeah a couple other things that I'll mention um so on once we had decided that we were going to recommend IC we did go ahead and call references on IC um so all three of us called different ref references the the one reference that I'll bring up is I I talked to a a business manager at a very large school district um that has done a lot of projects Hazelton that has done a lot of projects with IC and their business manager as you can imagine it's a gigantic School District very polished experienced uh person that I was very happy he stayed on the phone with me for about 20 minutes um and you know he he had two big pieces of advice in in addition

051to recommending them very very highly couldn't couldn't speak you know more positively about IC um and I think this is this is relevant for our process he said that in his experience and he's he's been involved with other projects uh before sometimes a construction manager is brought in very very late in the process later than we're bringing them in when you're literally ready to go to bid and all they do is what they said is Bid and build right so they they manage the bids and they managed the build he he strongly recommended against just doing that he actually recommended and then we asked the the finalist this question and the and the gist that I that I got from everybody is that it's about 5050 when you hire the architect first or the construction

052manager first some people actually hire the construction management first but a lot of people hire the architect first he said whichever one you end up doing just make sure that you ask the construction manager to do two things one give you the their cost estimate because it they have more experience in cost estimating than the architecture firms was the comment that he made and it there theirs will be more analytical B and not as much estimates and he thinks in his experience it we and I'm not going to you know Hope's not a plan he said that oftentimes he has seen the construction manager come in with a lower estimate than what the Architects initially estimated so we can hope for that um but then the other thing he recommended strongly is have them really

053look you know work together right they're not meant to be adversarial but have them really take a close look at the designs and see if there are either ways that they can save you money through materials which is not as likely um or if they have different ideas that could save us funds and as we just heard Dr Schaefer go through like when we all got together a year ago and we thought we like we've been talking for years about how do we generate the cash flow to do these projects right and we're making a lot of difficult decisions to do that and we just found out out you know from Dr Schaefer that we're under a lot of pressure that we didn't know about a year ago that's eating up a chunk of that

054cash flow so as we think about we have a lot of projects we want to do after this project we've all talked about it at the other schools and uh so anything we can do within reason you know we still want to build a state-of-the-art excellent property at the middle school but within reason if we could somehow save money we should we should turn over those stones and they he said that they can absolutely help you do that he said IC is great at that so those are two things that I think and that and that was a comment he made whoever we work with right make sure that they they try to do that for you so that's all I have Mr yeah I just want to appreciate the uh due diligence that this

055committee did in researching and finding this um this um construction firm I think it's a a tribute to how hard and how strong we're all working to try to save as much as we can but get accomplished what we need to accomplish so I appreciate the work that you did in in getting in hiring this um this group thank you um I'd like to Echo that I think I'd like to thank the facilities committee Dr abdalah Mr AAR and his crew um you guys really did do a lot of work uh at doctor and um I think also i' like I'd like to thank the administration and the time they spent I know you had a lot of people involved and they asked a lot of questions that I think sometimes weren't weren't directly connected

056to what we're going to build but oftentimes how the process was going to happen I think it was very helpful so thank you very much for a thorough job okay with that I'd like a roll call please Mr Moran yes Mr Robson yes M Tierney yes Mr AER yes Mr ABD yes Mr AAR yes Miss Henderson yes Miss hillbrand yes and Miss carum yes motion carries 90 this time Mr aard ask the board consider a motion to approve the second reading of policy series 200 second on the motion roll call please Mr Robson yes Miss Tierney yes Mr AER yes Mr abdalah yes Mr AAR yes Miss Henderson yes Miss hilderbrand yes Miss Kum yes Mr Moran yes motion carries 90 Mr aard asked board consider a motion to approve the agreements between the Abington

057height school district and the Scranton school district for student 44A and 45a so moved second on the motion roll call please M Tierney yes Mr AER yes Mr abdala yes Mr AAR yes Miss Henderson yes Sil bran yes Miss Kum yes Mr Moran yes Mr Robson yes motion carries 90 okay next item is use of facilities report uh listed for November 2024 and then is there any unfinished business did you want board reports pardon did you want board reports you know I we don't have them today I should I didn't even know that but you got we got great never mind we're happy to listen if you'd like to no I'll wait till uh January 2 any new business Mrs old business um what is the date of our Retreat and when and where is

058it I was going to mention that again thank you as a matter of fact February 11th okay 9 until 4:30 Dr Abdullah is working hard to get us location and get it get got he's got it he knows people be at Glen Oak yes so get it on your calendars please any other New or Old business not I'd asked for a motion to adjourn so moved your ajour thank you very much hold on

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.