CorpusRecord 62553

Long Beach School District BOE Meeting 01-27-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Long Beach School District
Date
2025-01-28
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,185 words · about 52 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001welcome everyone thank you for coming out tonight nice cold cold weather made made the trip um before we start I just want to give a shout out to the wrestling high school wrestling program this weekend they were successful at the county they got the wild car spot and the upcoming weekend they're gonna be going to the state championship I also had the opportunity to sit right there and watch Annie um if anyone else will Annie this week the middle school performance you ra that's great um it was adorable it was well well first this the crew the parents everyone was just staring and watching how great these kids perform so great job with Annie with middle school so tonight we have a work session part of the work session is going to be uh presentation

002by the superintendent of schools regarding e school and also our budget foundations and a drafted the budget process and our bond um I have to ask that we please all maintain the quum today uh out of respect for others and for for being good role models for our kids uh please know no cheering no clapping and no booing regardless if you agree or disagree it's part about giving respect and time to other people uh you all have the opportunity to speak on tonight's agenda items um which are the work session items if you choose uh to maintain proper to Quorum and you have three minutes to come up and speak uh with that being said uh we're going to start uh the president uh continue with the president report so obviously everyone's here we're all

003expecting a vote of some type so tonight the board is going to be giving our um I guess our our not our opinions but we're going to bring resolution to the issue at East for the foreseeable future we're going to discuss our side superintendent's going to give a presentation um not everyone's going to agree with each other some people have their opinions which may differ from others but please give everyone respect and uh we'll get through this together we're a strong district and we'll give this presentation so um with that being said being the president I'm actually give my position on the situation so a year around probably a year plus already um we were dealt with a really challenging situation right Governor came in she said we're be cutting our foundation a and with

004that uh we were facing a budget crisis of a few million dollars um with no expectation of knowing if we' be able to maintain services and programs and how we're going to be able to maintain this great education we give our kids in the district without having some sacrifices so um that was the Nexus that drove this conversation right so this is the third time that um consolidation or use of buildings has come up in the last 20 years or so both times e School came up as a possible uh utilization for consolidation and and figur out a different plan for alternative plans um luckily the governor uh heard our voices you know obviously advocacy from constituents is important she heard our voices and she turned around and she didn't cut our uh Foundation Aid

005actually in this year we have about ballp Park $300,000 of available resources being given to us for foundation Aid which is helpful there's other money in the budget from the governor but we did not get our cut last year and we're not expecting our cut for next year so that was the Nexus that drove us to considering East repurposing East obviously there was a lot of talk closing of school a school um a lot of noise out there a lot of confusion right so what the district did is that we put together a presentation we started doing our diligence on this one of the more challenging aspects of this process was that the circumstances kept changing and there was many circumstances unknown so the superintendent is going to give an overview of what we went

006through um and the possibilities of us trying to make the most of what we have so so that was the dropping force was the funding um that was a major issue for me obviously I stood next to other parents I was getting phone calls conversations from all levels of government and um the board the administrative team was weighing our opportunities and our risks very very heavily so we engaged a committee advisory committee we were considering bringing in uh Consultants we had a demographic study done we were doing everything in our power even though the circumstances were changing to make the best decision on behalf of the entire community right we understand there issues that would be focused specifically for parents affecting and students in East in the other buildings parents with out children without children

007currently in school U people who don't have any kids in the school and they're struggling with paying their cost of living and maintaining obviously a nice quality of life um so that was one of the factors one of the other factors for me uh in this whole mix was proper utilization of the building getting the most out of it so I'm going to give my position on this uh my position is for as long as I'm here under the current circumstances for the foresee of the future so I do not want to see e School repurpose I do not want to I appreciate it um so I at the time right now under what we're dealing with I listen to the tremendous advocacy from the community um we represent your needs we have your best

008interests those who um were nice about um advocating I appreciate you those who had different approaches to try to you know motivate us to uh have a good solid decision so um those I understand those people had their opinions and their tactics as they chose but so my position and my formal position is to not repurpose e school um the other board members are going to be given their positions as well I feel like even though we're not doing a vote we owe it to you as the community so we can plan the up coming budget year focus on more positive things uh focus on making academic Excellence are are focused and uh also keeping the community as tightly as we can so I just want to thank all the parents all the staff the

009administrative team they went through every inch that they could they try to do as much diligence as they could provide as much information that they had um but before I finish I just want to give a shout out to a parent a Joan cap [Applause] appla Applause she didn't make any sympathetic cry for her so don't do that and I want to ask thank the entire board and the administrative team for helping me make my decision on this and I also want to thank miss an Conway because she's been my my uh scratching post I'm not sure the proper term but anytime I had concerns she brought back her her history of being on the other side of the table so with that I just say officially my position is to keep School as an

010elementary school and we're going to move forward with great opportunities thank you Mr if you is it working okay hi everybody um my feeling is this and we we I think you know that we struggle with making decisions um we listen to you we do try and be it transparent even though some of you don't think we are um but we do take it seriously and as far as I'm concerned right now I think it is way too difficult for the community and I do not think it serves the community at this time to close or recur with the school so I know you going hear that it's been a very difficult year for us as I know it's been a very difficult for all of you as well um especially these past few weeks

011have been extremely stressful and we really have been very Dent looking at all sides of what we could do to better our community and I really do just like Sam said Thank our administrative team and thank our staff for all of their support and guidance throughout these last few months just like Mr Pinto said this all started because of wony and what they did with the financial cuts and we're all concerned community members and as a parent and I know all of us our main concern are our kids our students they are the heart of our school district so 16 years ago I was on your side I was there wearing my sea of bread with all of my parents for my kids and we advocated for each school one of the things that I

012loved about it was that it showed what a strong Community Long Beach is and that we all Stand Together we also did it very respectfully and even though we disagreed we respected other person's opinions but your advocacy has not fallen on De years once again once again you have brought up all the reasons why we should keep e school as an elementary school e school is a vital piece of our community and now that we have our state aid we can continue to make our district as successful as we have in the past the plan for E school had many questions not so many answers and it wasn't the plan that I could stand behind and I really want to thank the administrative team for trying their best to answer all of our questions so

013my resolution is that we should keep each school open and I would like to thank our advocacy for all of our parents and for our [Applause] kids even everybody thank you for coming out my opinion is different from my colleagues of thewood as I mentioned in past meetings to me it's an educational decision and the financial work Mr PTO said there was a lot of information out there he's actually there's also a lot of misinformation out here and I want to clarify some of that first I want to speak about class size looked over the class sizes at the respective K through grade four east class sizes run from 13 to 19 children in some of the classes there're two full-time teachers this model isn't sustainable let's talk about classroom size because we were charge

014with well you only going to increase classroom sizes other buildings if you move the kids there and that's not the case take a class of 18 kids they come in 9:00 in the morning they take off their coats take off their hats it's 18 once the Bell Rings the 18 kind of dwindles kid goes out to reading the kid goes out to math the kid might go out to Resource room kid might go out to speech kid might go out to B 18 becomes 153 so very very healthy classroom sizes very very healthy enrollment and I think we should be applauded for that for keeping classroom sizes respectable and as competitive as anywhere else in nashal County but once again the educational issue I don't think it's very healthy for a kid to be in

015a class with 13 or 14 kids I know I know especially when the 13 mik window I think students need a bigger reference group I think kids need maybe 60 or 70 kids in the building of other third and fourth graders not classes of 60 don't misquote me but other sections of third fourth and fifth grade so that there are more kids that serve as a reference group for our children in those schools it makes it easier for teachers to do grouping and to make plans and to keep curriculum on par among the various buildings so for me it is an educational issue and I'm not so sure that I'm on the wrong footing in this area as for finances we're 155 Million Dollar District I'm not so sure it's wise to pour money into

016a building that's 98 years old it's 1926 okay just turn so that to me is a concern in terms of practically speaking are we throwing good money after bad if I were asked about this I would be more apt to vote for a bond to build a new school than to spend money on a building that's 98 or as Mrs warw says 99 years old for me that's a financial decision as Financial Steward that's why I was elected to make those decisions I too applaud the parents I've had my disagreements with them I've been accused of being stbn and firm and we just choose to disagree most disagree respectively but I stand firm in my belief that East should be repurposed there was no effort on our part to sell it to bring anybody else

017in here but to use it as an n School institution our other elementary schools by the way most every child loves their Elementary School that love isn't solely East dependent I think when doubt West and Leo would say the same they all love their building and I think also as far as the education is concerned I think would be easier for our kids to make the transition to sixth grade if in fact you're a larger section I let you School fifth grade classes needless to say I'm in the minority here needless to say I haven't changed my opinion needless to say I do think it's a community decision in terms of being responsible to all the taxpayers and just not to and boy this was definitely the word of the week microcosm at East I

018do think that seniors young people that can't afford to buy here at taxes at business that are closed and that are shuttering that's on our watch and that concerns me I truly believe getting back to my original point I do not believe that the education of the children at East would have been compromised had they mooved to another Elementary School inconvenienced initially maybe but I'm willing to say the kids would come home quite enthusiastic about their new schools but that doesn't need discussion now because that's move point so I vote these should be repurposed that we have a fiscal responsibility and I vote that these should be repurposed because I believe it's in the best educational interest of the children and the community and best financial interest of the entire Community thank you um so

019I I had some stuff prepared to say um honestly I'm I'm a little bit at a loss for what to say I agree with my fellow board members that right now the community cannot bear repurposing e for any reason so my vote will be to keep the school [Applause] open that's said I I need to um set the record straight about a couple things because though I do appreciate parents like Joan who have gone out of her way to um really I think approach this with information and listen to sides and not be attacking what I have witnessed this community do to myself and some of the other fellow board members up here is is really disheartening and advocacy to me is not sharing misinformation it's not name calling it's not personal attack that is

020not advocacy and it does an incredible disservice and it made a whole lot of noise where they didn't have to be noise my position from day one was what is the plan moving forward and can we responsibly repurpose this school there were things I was looking for I didn't see that that's it that's the end of it but everybody making it more than it was really created such division in this town I I'm so incredibly disappointed so moving forward I want to be clear that my decision was not because I yielded to pressure or um you know I don't feel that I listen to the hardest or harshest voice voices or loudest I did what I think this community could bear and the advocacy that came appropriately was was welome and I do appreciate the

021administration putting together plans and giving us the opportunity to take the time that's what we did that's what the community ask us to do to take time and to think it through so ultimately the school is staying open um but I really I really hope and pray that we can rebuild some sort of culture and some sort of mutual respect and collaboration and I think that our schools our administrators our teachers and our children all of you deserve that more than anything else thank [Applause] you thank you everyone thank you for the crowd for maintaining pretty good decorum so uh we're going to be giving a presentation with some of the diligence and the steps that we went through in our consideration obviously uh majority the board felt that the benefits of consolidation did not

022did not outweigh the risks and the concerns that we're facing with so if some parents would like to stay with their kids you're more than welcome to stay if you think we need a pause to let people who are willing to or have other obligations or priorities we can take a two-minute pause uh for that so real quick we're going to take a quick pause of anyone needs a little bit of time and then we're going move on to the presentation so if you don't want to get up stay seated for the next two minutes otherwise more than welcome if you have other obligation [Applause] Mommy do you want to give your thoughts [Music] i r love all right everybody thank you so much uh you can wrap up your Cho more than welcome to

023we have a superintendent giv the presentation if you don't mind happy to see a handful of happy smiling faces still in the room about the kids some parents but K once the once the Cs up we'll start with our presentation by the superintendent thank you so much thank you m Keno so my presentation will be super brief um I know that some people have reached out and asked for a summary of the process that we've gone through all year um we've been working on that summary for the past few weeks the board asked to hold it tonight so they would have the opportunity to make their decision um and so after tonight I'll be sending the presentation out to All Families you'll have an opportunity to go through it in detail and ask any questions

024you want I just want to go through the first two slides quickly tonight um the first one obviously we've kind of already talked through this we made the um the benefits of consolidation versus the concerns about consolidation as you were tonight the board has decided that um EOL remain open as an elementary school some of you saying well what does that mean so that means that it will remain open as school for the foreseeable future that in the fall will be go there meaning 23k and 2K we will new entrance um there in sections where they're smaller than in other grades that would had been our practice prior to last year um we will also be adding back into the bond proposal which we actually postpone now we W be able to do this year

025we needed to AR U finalize the specs for the bond by February we won't be able to do that it'll be next year but we are adding back in the $6 million of agback upgrades for the East Building the next 27 Pages or so I'm not going to go through tonight but it will be emails home to you and it'll be posted on the district website and again it's it's mostly a summary of information we've presented before there are some new things what would we have done as a transition plan people ask about that we just wanted to demonstrate that we have been thinking about that and working on it some of the work that the um advisory committee did and some of the budget um implications that we considered but again you can read

026that at your leisure we have a lot of kids here that have to get up early tomorrow so I hope hope through 27 pages I am going to email it to all families in the district so that everyone has a copy of it and for people who do not have children in the district school we will be posted on the school website by tomorrow and with that I'll turn it over for the second part of the presentation Mr deito we will talk about our basic budget foundations for this year 9 you all right this evening we're going to talk about the preliminary budgets and we're also going to review the governor state aid proposal so what you see here on the left are the descriptions of some broad categories starting with employee compensation um moving

027all of the employees over in the next schedule the 2526 schedule certain employees go further along this step and what we see here is an increase of about 2.23 % so those are the first things that we do when we prepare the budget is we move all the staff current staff and we move them into next year's salary schedule then you'll see there'll be a slide here about our process so I'm just going to go through this quickly equipment is the same because we haven't met with all of our stakeholders yet to determine if new equipment needs are necessary same with the vendor services but we did put a placeholder in there for bosis 2% so anything that's a Bose service at the bare minimum we believe it's going to increase by 2% but we

028know categories like transportation and some of the others will be higher than that we just don't have that information yet materials and supplies again we haven't had our meeting so that's why that is at at a the same level as the current year and then The Debt Service since we're moving into another year you see we we pay more principal and less of Interest with the the net savings is about $46,000 in the overall Debt Service because there serial Bond so the annual amounts differ slightly employee benefits are fortunate to see a little bit of a reduction because this past January our health insurance remained pretty much flat um it was able to offset some of the pension contribution increases so this preliminary budget which is basically our starting point you see here is an

029increase of about just shy $1.9 million or about 1.21% on the budget not the tax levy but the budget so that's the increase to the budget just right now just based on some basic up updates without really going to the whole process over the next couple of months so some of these bullets I covered already um but it's here just as a frame of reference uh we do anticipate some additional costs in the area of transportation we hear that the vendors are going to be increasing their pricing quite a bit we're going to try to renew as much as we can with those contractors who do some of our transportation we have a hybrid system where uh most of our buses uh excuse me most of our routes are done by our in-house bus driving

030but we do have a portion of our routes that are done through contractors um so we do anticipate some facilities increases as well some utility costs um we possibly will have some instructional program enhancements or cost increases again we still have to have those meetings um but some of these costs at least will be offset by some um retirements where those employee compensation savings will be achieved by some of the hiring uh senior staff members retiring with some of the new staff members who come in at a different salary rate uh taking those spots we think but all is said and done with some of these additions to some cost areas offset by savings through some requirements will probably be again about a maybe 1.5 or two million increase to the budget so just about

031where we are now when as the net position and then um you know we'll talk about what that means for the tax levy in the next few slides the next steps in the budget development process we have District staff meetings a few times a week with the various principles assistant principles directors all the different stakeholders in the district to get to present what they believe their needs will be next year we do expect to get some more specific cost projections from bosis regarding the transportation that they provide to the district as well as some of their Cooperative Services of which we participate um and again we have 1.4 million in our current contract budget so if it goes up by half and I know there are some some concerns that some of the transportation contractors

032will raise their prices by 50% then that can meet another $700,000 that we need to add to the budget so we are concerned about that and we need to see what happens over the next couple of months we'll have board meetings like this where we present some of what has been proposed by uh the administrative team for the board's consideration and for public comments what I have here is the executive budget estimate that came out last week and you see the different categories on the left first is foundation Aid that's what was mentioned earlier where the budget uh the governor proposes again this is only the governor's proposal we don't know what the final budget's going to be until around April 1st the governor has proposed a 2% increase in Foundation Aid that equates to

033about $390,000 the expense pay States you see they'll vary depending on how much we spend um so if we spend more on bosis we get more back in bosis Aid if we spend more on special education costs that are over a certain level certain thresholds we get some more Aid back if we have less building projects on the books then we get less building aid but we expect that building Aid category to increase because we're expect the state to process some of what we call our final course reports of some recent projects um that will give us some more building Aid just about the same level maybe a little bit higher than what we we have uh we've seen the current year about $3.1 million the instructional materials are are tied to enrollment since the

034enrollment is declining that's why we're getting uh fewer dollars in those categories it's tied to the amount of students not necessarily the need of the students but just the number and that's why you see that going down um in terms of what's projected for next year something that is a little curious and I'm still waiting for an explanation back from State educ department is why they listed an increase in our upk a of about $652,000 because that 2. 170 number just try 2.2 is just about the level we expect to get in the current year and again it's only tied to the number of preas students that we have so if we have fewer students than what the state would allow for us then we don't get that same amount of money it's high the

035actual number of students but there really isn't an increase that we're going to see for next year because we're already at that level when we became a full day program last year um and then this is year two that's about the amount that we're getting from the state on upk and all of those expenses are actually in another fund in the special Aid fund they're not in the general fund so when we talk about supporting the $155 million budget it doesn't include that Revenue because all our prepaid costs in a different fund basically this is the text of what I just explained as I went through the chart and just some important calendar um we're in into January now through April is what we call budget development budget adoption is April 23rd which is when

036the board decides on what the final budget is and I know that what you'll hear over the next few months is just because the administration presents something to the board for their consideration doesn't mean that just because it's presented that's what going to be in that final budget and it's up to the board to decide what is included at budget adoption on April 23rd budget hearing is the time when anyone from the public can talk about what they like about the budget what they don't like about the budget even though it cannot be changed it's just an opportunity for the public to be heard on the budget and then May 20th is the budget vote and the trustee election that's all for this evening Dr gallager now questions and comments from the board so uh

037thank you Dr gallager Mr deito on your presentation um a lot of time and effort has been put into these presentations and uh the diligence that we went through so now that we're moving forward on on what's going on with these obviously we're going to be doing as you saw um improvements in the building hopefully if it goes with the bond proposal as well as shifting uh enrollment into the building uh to lower the burden on me schools U Mr deito thank you for the budget presentation uh a few questions that I had I actually had a basic question give me one second I'm just for the page so with just to clarify with the state aid right I know that we're trying to figure out why they presented it that way um the real

038change in our state aid Foundation Aid is an increase of three uh $390,000 is the change from this year's Foundation a to next year's Foundation a yes that's in the proposal yes is that still a concern though in the future is is trending from I guess higher ups still showing that there may be a shift in the whole formula yes I I wish I could say differently but it is still a concern I would say basically because of the Rockefeller Foundation what the governor commissioned in terms of study um although you know we do our demographics you know show us to be of of a certain level of need in different areas um I still believe that compared to other districts in the state that we're going to end up losing some money as you

039may know half of the districts right now are being identified as being at risk of losing money as there is a shift in this formula so I just think long term we're going to lose some money I can't say what that amount is going to be you know it all depends on how they change the formula what kind of factors they may include in terms of you know the different um population that is Ela to freeing launched and some other you know specific demographics of our district that may you know qualify for something that others around our neighbors may not but I just don't see it as a net increase for the district I see it long term as being some sort of a decrease from what we currently have even though the proposal doesn't

040fud a 2% for next year I think long is likely to be a decrease because we are in the category of half that you know the governor Dees as being overfunded okay great I guess that helps Focus you know now that we've created a lot of energy um in the community about the the importance of uh State funding let's not give up that fight obviously there are concerns again of state aid being cut it directly impacts the schools and it directly impacts the tax bur so just obviously the road is not over but if we can keep our momentum going down the road let's keep that nice group of uh advocacy going when it comes to supporting state aid thank you Mr dito and I also look forward to watching and working with your team

041because uh it's really amazing how you pull off uh balancing our budget Through The Years very much uh any other board members like to comment on the presentation presentations I apologize go ahead sir thank you Dr Galler and Mr for the presentation in news day this past week I believe it was last week five or six schools in Nassau and suff were identified the schools from physical stress I always hold my breath when that list comes out because when we were dealing with Sandy 10 years ago we were very vulnerable because we had such outstanding needs at that time because of all the destruction that was done in terms of funding so just a shout out to you and your office Mr too for keeping us on very very solvent grounds because uh we need

042it so thank you for the presentation I look forward to working in the next few months in terms of coming up with a responsible budget to this community for our kids thanks com yes thank you Mr Deo for your budget presentation you have always been wonderful with the numbers and showing how all of the money goes towards helping our students um I guess really my concern really is where you said how the government alany is really looking at our numbers and not our needs isn't it true like not just in our district but all across Long Island the needs for our students the needs our students have have increased even though in R isn't just down in Long Beach it's down in island so that is true and you know there are needs that our

043students have right now based on the way the world is but you know when you're faced with a situation where half of the district say well the level that they have still is insufficient based on the formula that exists now I I just don't foresee that we're going to be getting more that's all you know I think it's it's not that our students don't need things and they do um but it's it's all relative it's about comparing what our students need compared to all the other districts throughout New York State and there are some districts that even though we would like to have more don't even have half of what we have and I think that's what the Rockefeller Foundation was looking at is how to maybe change the formula to make it the factors

044be more relevant and I think there will be some changes but I just don't think overall what our net position is going to be let's say five to maybe 10 years is going to be more than what we have now I don't know if it's going to be the 9 million that we talked about you know it was 4 and a half 4 and A2 I don't know if it's going to be a $9 million reduction but I just don't know and I can't say with confidence that it's going to be the same level or even more we don't know what it's going to be after you know we really don't know but I just don't see it staying at this level or or or having more even though we do know that there are

045needs you know out there for our students do you foresee any any expected changes in when the governor pronounces the budget on April 1 I I I don't I don't know I don't want to say at this point yeah I mean I would think not just based on how politics goes like I would feel pretty good about the 2% the 390,000 but I couldn't say for sure but I I feel pretty good that we should be able to rely at least on that for next year thank you yeah um just thank you Mr deito thank you Dr gallager for your presentations um Mr deito I always find this to be the most complicated part of what we do and I really thank you for trying to simplify it a little bit so that I can

046understand it everybody else can understand so moving forward thanks so much right thank you very much to the board members on uh discussion on that so now we're opening up the questions and comments with the public on tonight's work session only we strongly strongly ask that you uh maintain the Quorum give respect to your neighbors uh not to clap or to to move regardless of your position um if you can just come on up give your give your opinions and uh we appreciate your input I just want to say um one of the one of the important things I did see was that uh many people did uh signed a petition a lot of them were from Long Beach um whether they signed it for whatever reason they signed it they still signed it and

047that type of organization um is always support of of of help and support Mission so good job on organizing a collaborative collaborative message and now you have the chance to say what you want in person so welcome hi my name is Indy W 15 Street I am a PR taxpayer homeowner alumni for two children out of the school district especially my two children Megan and Daniel ww who graduated proudly from East School I am proud that you s Pinto Miss cono Miss Pace Miss bsky for voting to keep our stable almost 100y old school being an elementary school I moved to this community 33 years ago I'm a taxpayer I'm an accountant there is not one of you on this board that could definitely tell me you have a business sense of understanding a budget

048and what I've gone through because I been on your budget advisory committee for many years I haven't been to a board meeting since my son graduated back in 2008 I used to come again with you miss Conway 20 years ago you threatened each School 10 years ago you threatened each school stop it this school needs to stay in our community you did it to Magnolia stop it for $684,000 you built something by a developer that came to you recently a a different developer who gave you a proposal as his proposal of an appraisal of $12.9 million well tell me when that property's to sale for 12 million n m 12.9 million i' buy it and keep it as a school I don't know who the developer was that came to you but your District did

049not do a proper study you didn't know the acces of what's goes on in our community and you talk about busing my kid was at Leo school when he first got here I wanted e School I got legal my son was on a bus for a year and a half yanked pulled to the ground I transferred him to East school because I wanted my kid to be in a neighborhood school like I grew up in Far OA I walked to school there was no big deal about it I met kids in the neighborhood the kids play together we have a beautiful field that the kids have nowhere to play sports nowhere to do baseball we stop this DRC Ryan you don't know your factors and you've been on this board way too long please retire

050because next year you're up and it's time to see you go like the rest of the board that left when I first came here 33 years ago please do our community a favor Dr de Mr DeVito thank you for your presentation thanks for speaking with me last week I thank news2 for coming out and I thank every one of you for coming in support of our community and keeping East school thank you [Applause] is it good okay um I had a whole speech because I had no idea how this is going to go um and it was about energy and I know that every single person that is in this room little louder little lower good oh chillian sorry 611 B I always forget something right um but I think that as opposed to the

051crushing anxiety that we all feel every time we've been together in this last year maybe now we could transfer this energy and create something very positive so I just wanted to thank the board for their time and their consideration in this matter whether we disagreed or not we've gone to this point and I'm proud of your ultimate decision I wanted to really thank the teachers because I don't know how you stood up and taught your classes the last year I have thought about you every day that's has been going on sorry and um and thank you Julian for organizing everything and for keeping your pool and for being a good representation to all the parents at East but thank you all we can move forward into better things thank you hello 728 Westchester Street I

052system and I am the nurseing school um I did see thankfully that we will be adding um in your presentation notes that two kindergarten classes and two prek classes so um but did you mention and can you please um adding a full-time social worker and a full-time psychologist next year if not okay because we are now operating on half time halim and it is not working for our children I am the nurse so they come to me first off most of the time um and I do see the breakdown of what's happening for our children's mental health and there's nowhere for them to go um when they're having a crisis so I just want that to be something that you really put into consideration if not now um definitely next year thank you thank you

053hi I'm Melissa Al M I live at 512 East day thank you I do not know you my children do not go to East but they did um I had a three minute and I went through my timer multiple times to make sure I didn't go over speech that I am not reading thank you thank you thank you thank you um property values social emotional well-being of our children matter um Dr Ryan I love you the class size it matters especially in this day and age when the social emotional well-being of our children even at the elementary school come in with a tremendous amount of needs classroom teachers we are no longer just classroom teachers I am an educator I am now a social worker myself I a psychologist I a GU counselor and with

054all the data that we need I have become a statistician we have enough means what we me is to keep class size as small as possible so thank you thank you thank you for thinking of the community and showing off the way that you have and thank you also again for doing whatever it is that you did I really appreciate it thank you thank [Applause] you uh BR Rogers 590 n Boulevard um I had a question the bud the third slide I saw the the vendor agreements L27 million are those collectively negotiated like what's like the length of those it seems a large item sure yeah so that's across all the different functions in the district so for example it could be if we need to bring in a contract nurse for a specific reason

055let's say there's a student that needs a nurse on the bus and we didn't anticipate that we'll bring in that and that's do a contract company or bosis are Cooperative services that again cross over all the different functions um it could be professional development so no they not negotiated it's not just one vendor it's a multitude of vendors a lot of them are special education vendors whether it's tuning or speech or things of that sort so there may be actually um about a 100 vendors at the minimum that we deal with On Any Given year they're typically annual contracts because the board you know usually you know wants to know what they're going to do and that's the reor so on J July one or so we have a reor meeting that's the time when

056all those for the most part contracts are in place for the next year um so this is now getting ready in terms of anticipating what some of those costs will be for the vendors that we're going to use for the most part it's it's many vendors who we use year after year and we have to really figure out the cost going to stay the same or they going up but something like bis which is a large amount we spend about10 million with bis is the largest vendor so to speak with whom we deal with and it's not something that's independently negotiated but it's really something that the B board decide how they're going to increase their cost and then they pass that along to the different participating districts is there an opportunity to like negotiate

057a longer term for beneficial lot ofies do that you know typically what we try to do is have the opportunity to extend um because we are uh where there's an election every year in a different board um is is our our Cel no so so typically it's it's not advisable to do multi-year because the board could change right so that's why we do things on an annual basis with extensions and opportunities to extend um prices don't go up every year there are many years with our vendors that it stays the same you know especially during what happens in the world like for example after super storm sanding Co a lot of the contractors kept things level um but you know I can't say that's a guarantee but typical like with educational institutions like a public

058school district we don't have long-term contracts because the board changes on an annual basis and they really determine at the reor meeting who they want to engage with um and that's why we have to reor so so basically the board taking over that's that's why might be changes in no it's just in terms of changes in vendors so so a prior board is not supposed to obligate a future board to a multi-year contract because the board can change now maybe in state law that's why I was checking to see if our counsil is here I'm not sure if any of that which I just stated is actually in State education it's in practice I'm not sure about I know it's definitely the practice but it may also be memorialized well BOS I know you have

059no trouble speaking I just want to reiterate to the crowd the best way to use these mics is to bring your face right in front of his people different what do you mean s Perfect You're the perfect example thank you am I giv my name and address sure senin 57 Dolphin Street um I a two far question and I want to say thank you to everybody um really makes us all happy and we appreciate it especially as parents um and just to DRC Ryan I just want to relate one thing that CL just does matter especially for the kids that need that extra touch an extra Love sometimes one teacher to one one makes a difference so so class size is not always the bigger the better just keep that in mind and no you

060don't need to answer me I'm good um secondly I just wanted to know if in the future that East and I'm very happy and thank you will get a new playground um if that is something within the budget that can be done we've had some issues with the playground and since now we're adding two extra pre prek classes in the future if that can be something on the agenda yeah that was in the bond already but it certainly we'll be there again and I know that slide is broken and we can't fix it so we'll see about something the future or I don't know we have to it has to be replaced totally so we can look into what we can do the okay amazing and then the last question and again thank you everybody

061is I just wanted to know and I was trying to do some research as far as board member goes and I appreciate everybody I know it's a thankless job and I appreciate it um what is the standard as far as election like is there a statute to how long you can be on the board just like in presidial three there's no term limits like no term limits but um the rotation in the district is every three years you're up for re-election some years there's one person running some years there's two people running right but every year there is an opportunity for someone to run the school board and the election is the same time with the budget vote so you kind of do both at the same time right so unless somebody votes against votes

062with you but that person to stay on no we have to win at large you have to win a new at large election every time you do it it's an at large no like you stay on for four years and then no every threee terms something to thank you I just wanted to respond to you in terms of I never implied bigger was better my implication was that there is a Tipping Point in terms of how small some of the classes that East are and is a concern for me remember I never said bigger was better but there is a tipping to stud like idea everybody would who wouldn't teachers would parents would I made that point Thank you thank you evening Frank app today I think it was uh I think it was a

063very good decision um after speaking with uh my parents who actually resid in Rock Center had a similar tale where they moris Elementary was closed many years ago and we didn't have the for to see that there could be an increase in children and now they actually do face overow classroom so I do appreciate the decision to keep it open um being Beach is a very training City we do have a lot of renters you know the population of children I can assume could in a threeyear period increase quite a bit so the decision I think was a good one um also too I think you know coming from World of building and developers giving them an they they'll take all they can get and just by repurposing the school is one step closer to

064allowing a developer to get in a foothold of allowing money to come in here um you know once it's it's repurposed it's just another step towards it may be going into Administrative Building from there you know who knows where it would go got if the town ever got hold of that property you know what it would be developed into so I do appreciate the decision and I appreciate the work you guys do thank you hey um Matthew Meer 427 Market Street um my wife and I just bought two years ago there it was actually uh built in 1926 as well um the cost to tear down and rebuild was about five or six times the price don't know what engineering background you have but your numbers are way off you probably should as well it's

065ironic that the oldest person taes the only one we're not going to have thank you uh evening everybody my name gr Panini Long Beach the first time Mak back since 1970 I graduated out of the school I am old so anyway I I think it was a wise decision from the board to basically think of the children and the neighborhood instead of the money because the children and the people in this town come first no matter what and and I I would listen I would give another $500 to keep that school the year okay that's the way it is in Long Beach we take care of our own I live in the canals okay and I'm third generation w beach so I know a little bit what's going on and you know what but it

066should never be about money and it's not your fault it's not your fault it's the stat fault New York state has failed the taxpayer in the school taxes remember Lotto was created Created to take care of the tax payer with the schools they have failed they should be ashamed of themselves I hope you hear me state of New York okay because we shouldn't be we shouldn't have these decisions on money to keep our school or keep our kids or keep teachers okay what it's unamerican unamerican to do what they do to us and make this board try to make decisions but you did Choose Wisely thank you [Applause] I uh K C 361 East Broadway uh my question and concern is regarding the budget um the the Deb service compared to say the last five

067years are we trending up we trending down we stay about the same you know it's it's roughly 5.6% of the budget roughly so I would where we question well also I would like to say that uh in my mind the you know the debt is really attacks because at this point we're not getting any value for it because that you know we're carrying we're carrying that debt from you know previous obligations so uh I would like to see a tremendous effort to get to get that down as low as possible I'm happy to give you some shg on the de so the Deb relates the serial bonds that um the district used to pay for the last large scale Capital plan so in 2009 the community voted in favor of a 92.8 million bomb that

068was over two different years of borrowing um so it's really part of the repayment it's almost like a mortgage of the 92 million of B and twice not three times we were eligible for what's called Advanced refunding we were able to bring down the rate and save several million dollars of De service um and we did that we're not able to do that now because we only have one more year to repay off about five a little over five million of that and then two years later we repay the remaining three and a half million of debt service so we're at the very tal end of the repayment of that um and there are different conditions for repayment Advanced repayment and we did that so we did that twice not three times and we saved

069several millions of dollars by doing that so now that we're at the tail end there really not a chance to prepay any longer we just have to finish out again it's only like couple more years left but what I've been um advocating for and presenting since 2021 is to backfill that debt service and that's what we're talking about in terms of a large scale Capital plan going forward the scope of which we're going to be reviewing with the board and the community over the next several months is what to do for our next large scale Capital time thank great than Matthew Street been a long time since I've been to one of these meetings but I couldn't resist coming down the idea just the idea of selling these school was incredibly shortsighted I can't can't

070imagine the discussions that we had amongst all of you um this community does not need any more Condominiums especially in the canals we all know that would never lower our taxes so I think it was a shortsighted bad idea I'm glad to see that the majority of you have decided against it I would hope that it doesn't come up in a year from now or two years from now or 3 years from now um gentleman was talking about um Debt Service I'm curious as to how much is in the reserve fund these days and if any of that any excess of the reserve fund could be used to pay down the debt that we do have it's not about taxes I pay my taxes I don't complain I don't even look at my tax bill

071but what Ryan said is true you know we are topheavy with Administration I think of you would admit to that when I went to school there was one principal not three principles not four Deputy superintendance so I think we really need to re-evaluate what the commitment is to the commitment to education of our children was the commitment to business your business so I thank you for your time and again I congratulate all the young adults here for taking the time to come out tonight and support this uh move M against our children thank you just real quick I just want to give a quick clarification just so you know while we were we were going through our diligence in this entire process project process I apologize one of the things that was never on the

072table um was selling East so we all took a firm ground from Jump Streets we know we're going to be in a financial possible financial crisis uh we're looking for ways to uh distribute the classrooms within the district but at no time and it was a strong and firm consistent message even though part of the community did not hear it we were never on on up to selling East it was always going to be maintained for educational purposes so just clear that I know other people out there whatever the case maybe the building wasn't for sale the school wasn't for sale those types of issues we put away and that was we turned that off as a consideration of trying to do the best under the circumstances so but it was out there so I

073just wanted to make sure clarify that thank you Sam I would also just clarify that if if that was ever a consideration that would not be up to the Board of Education that would be up to a vote for the community that public reference that would that would never it was never on the table like Mr Pino said but even further than that even if it was or even if a future board if all of us are voted out and new board comes in and this comes up again it would again have to go to the community to just to be clear than thank you sorry but thank hi Rene orsman 84 K Street um I want to thank the board for their time and energy for this and I think the community put their

074time and energy on this um this was a really really devastating thing to have to hear my children don't go to East School they did not go to East School um I am a parent of children in middle school now and looking back I can't imagine that I had to tell my children in March of last year or whenever we were dealt that news that they were go their school was going to close um I moved here in 2006 and I actually taught at EAS school I was a TA with Mr mines if any of you remember regie [Applause] mes he was by far the best educator I've ever worked with um and I worked with really good ones um Donna was the kindergarten teacher at the time and there is a heart and soul

075of the school that I fell in love with it was one of my first teaching jobs right out of college and um this community is really strong this community has a lot of Art and um I've been part of the advisory committee I have been at the original meeting with Joanna and when Ryan were trying to just do anything that they could I've been on PTA we've been doing things to try to help this school even not as a parent of the school just a parent in the community and I'm really grateful that the board came to this decision I know it wasn't easy um we are celebrating this Friday we're doing a fundraiser and I know Mr pinto and Cas I texted you about it we're going to celebrate the fact that this families

076have gone through hell in back to keep the school open and we're going to have a really good time and we're going to celebrate the fact that the school is staying open and I'm going to show everybody this lovely flyer and we're going to have a really really good time I'm donating my time and my services to this fundraiser I'm going to host an amazing paint party and we're going to have so much fun to help celebrate the tireless work that these families have gone through and we're going to celebrate our children these kids have gone through way too much that children should even have to know about this is grownup stuff this should not be where our children are handling so thank you again and thank you to the community I'm really proud to

077be part of it thank you it War 63 Monroe Boulevard uh I also just want to say thank you for voting in my personal favor um whether it was on Factor feeling it uh benefits me personally I have a question for the board and the administration is there a I know we're going to bring on two sections so thank you that's exciting um for the next you know two years or uh what have you but is there like a resuscitation plan for the morale that is so down in the towns because we are divided and everyone does expect Easter clo but my plan is to focus on wonderful educational programs and things that we can do for our kids and put this conversation to rest okay so no not really I I'm just saying there's

078no plan is the point because everyone is now like again us and things were closing and it was said so much but is there a plan to make us more inviting more exciting I don't I don't think anyone on this board ever said it was closing I think what we were firmly saying the entire time is that we were going to take time we were going to consider it and not one person ever said other than doc Bryan that they had a position either way so as far as do you think Community loud and clear I have my opinions of what the community heard but I don't think they heard it from us as a board irr irrelevant from that I think the morale right now the focus needs to go back to just education

079as a whole and bringing this community back together and part of that is everybody coming together and being happy and moving on and that's the responsibility of us that's responsibility of the parents that's responsibility of everyone in this room appreciate it we try not to do back and forth um in the meeting but I will say uh great first start is to go to the fundraiser Rene spoke of uh spread it out there ptas you you always do a tremendous job obviously P can collaborate and work on it sure I'll post that and probably the next best thing for us to do is full bear Sunday everyone just donate po be wear their uh buy your polar bear sweatshirts but wear your your school clothes on your way out that way everyone can show their

080pride so that's a good idea uh two other things when you guys miss and Dr Mr when you clarified just now that the building was never going to be sold clarifying helps so much in these meetings sometimes people get up here you know and say insane things that aren't true about IEPs and reading and all this stuff that literally is not true at all and stopping it right there and clarifying it huge so if we could do more of that that would be great and then the last thing um I agree with you know what Miss P said earlier too is like there was division however it was caused by one thing and it wasn't us so if we could do undoing that would be great thank you thank you so this is the only

081person you're allowed to give us a round of applause point for P Joanne tap 445 East solid Street thanks Sam thanks I I I really don't have much left to say I think you all have listened to me for a year answered my calls my emails my text Mr deito Miss bie Miss Conway Mr Pinto Dr Gallagher Miss pace even Dr Ryan I appreciate just kidding that a joke you guys have all listened to me you guys have all answered all of my questions every time I've asked uh I think I'm getting a lot of credit but I think there's a lot of families in group text and resources that I tapped into into this community that helped so much and to help clarifying this I'm not an education expert um I want to just

082come up here and say that I will help and commit to hoping repair this with our ptas I will make sure that this we come together and that everybody will be invited to our 100 Year East School bash next [Applause] year for everybody and I appreciate you guys so [Music] much hi Daniel for for Hudson streen uh I just want to say um thank you to um all of you for all the work that you've done in your consideration I also want to say I sent you an email earlier today and I didn't sign it and so um I'm sorry that was from me it was uh do magio 718 um but um I just you know if at some point you know maybe some of the concerns that are not directly affected by a

083school closing but maybe can be addressed like some of the concerns that nurse uh Heather had brought up as well were were uh in that email um and uh oh I did want to say that I know all of the schools are proud of themselves and they they have such a incredible uh that spirit Spirit and but I will say that I have spoken to I have a lot of friends that are are in the other schools and they have said what an incredible relationship that a a a special bond that are School seems to have the parents the way pickup is the fact that a lot of us are Walkers and there's something really special about e school and I I'm not just saying it because you know I'm part of it but it

084is recognized by a lot of the other parents and and community members and I I'm I'm I'm proud of that and and I'm I'm glad that we get to continue that so thank you [Applause] anyone else with that being said uh thank you very much for your comments from the public uh we are moving on to announcements from our Teachers Association I apologize sorry uh new and old Business board of education yes Dr Ryan go ahead that just wanted to welcome mrti here to her first go is know SAR the future meetings you will continue to see 200 people at the meeting so please make sure that you have the agendas and appropriate materials for them I just wanted to ask the superintendent of new business that the governor came out with this uh cell

085phone policy in terms of school and uh terms of her directive and money she's say she's going to thr it budget what implication that have for us if any so we already have a a effective cell phone band at both middle school and high school um I don't know the details of how she's going to distribute the 13 million it may be to purchase some of those magic cases or things of that nature um but I think our our middle school and high school team over the past two or three years have done a really good job of making students put their so points away and not have the not in the school day so it remains to be seen I think we all recognize the need disc our teenag and we'll see if there's

086F help us to do that no I just wanted to say Dr we we stated that PO gave cell phones last year didn't we two years ago and you've gotten very positive feedback from our staff already about it right it would be nice if we do get some money even though we already have thank you um I just have a brief comment um so this is my first time as a board of ed president obviously this is like baptism by school closing so we're pretty exciting um a lot of people send emails to the board and the district and I I'll take onus if you didn't get a response I apologize um I I tried to either figure out if some of these answers were able to be answered or if it was just for

087a person giving their opinion so if anyone feels slighted um especially had to I apologize for that publicly for not giving back to everybody and I'll do my better do better trying getting back but if if you don't get a good response like send the second email saying hey you missed out on something sometimes they get mixed in the weed so thank you for that okay any other qub comments new and old business with that being said thank you Karen come on up class Teachers Association I'll make a quick to um C lbca uh and I did want to thank all of you up there you did answer a lot of questions and I know school board and administration both was really willing to collaborate and discuss and if this was been a happen we

088were having a lot more so we truly appreciate you really thinking about this and taking the kids and teachers and parents into consideration and I really we think you made the best decision and and we are extremely happy for our children at East and families and teachers that work there thank you thank you uh administrative TPS okay uh Group C long beacha all right p all right oh we want to thank is that working again can you hear me now um but I understand exem success are stressful buty thank you also as her speaking on the ptas I know that when Co happened Megan Don brought the P together to do a lantern planing ceremony to sort of unite the district and maybe the PT can get together and do something similar to sort of

089unite our families so that's something we can discuss at the next round table meeting you can also do I forgot apologize the Harlem Wizards we used to have e school had a team right that was that was a fun fundraiser I got spped on on it was pretty embarrassing so just another creative idea P thank you uh student organizations okay it is only 8:21 we expecting to get out of here at 11: this is great um thank you everyone can I get a motion to ad during the meeting all in favor say hi thank you everyone thank you again have a great night EXC me sorry how are you how are you how you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.