CorpusRecord 62554

Long Beach School District BOE Meeting 01-14-2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Long Beach School District
Date
2025-01-15
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
24,805 words · about 138 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone welcome to tonight's meeting uh quick few quick comments so uh few things uh we have our Annie Middle School is presenting Annie coming up next week the 23rd and 24th at the middle school Auditorium if you guys want tickets it'll be a great show we also have Beauty and the Beast coming up the wrestling Community I think it's Wednesday uh it's a great opportunity to show where our gymnastics and our wrestling teams came up and they they give a great a great showing of sportsmanship camaraderie and uh all the successes that our teams put together speaking of successes we had the wrestling high school wrestling Eastern States champion this weekend and one of our Long Beach wrestlers Dan suaya won the state championship which is huge so i' like to give him

002a quick Round of Applause also on Monday on Martin Luther King day we will be uh included in the Martin Luther King Day parade uh with Center please your jacket on come walk for everything that represent it would be a great time and show school spirit is part of the community with that being said I'm going to pass on this to the superintendent the Showcase we have a great little uh Elementary literacy showcase as well as the first tredition of our draft uh proposals for the budget Capital plan thank you so much thank you mrto and just before we do our wonderful Elementary lit literacy showcase we have a very special person to thanks tonight and someone new to introduce um sadly for us but happy for her Lori Dolan our district clerk and also

003my secretary will be retiring at the end of this month um this is actually her last meeting and um we certainly want to thank her all of her hard work over the years she is one of the kindest most gracious people I have ever had the pleasure to work with um and while I would say she's Irreplaceable I'd also like to introduce her repl Susanna pret who is also an amazingly kind wonderful graceful person who has worked hard in our HR um office over the past few years moving into this new role so um I hope you'll join me in just saying big thank you L and welcome [Applause] to um thank you doc also Lori on behalf of the board I just like to reiterate it I know I've told you this every time

004I've seen you but it's bitter sweet that you're retiring but you deserve it and we're going to miss you and we're excited um for you and when everything goes on so congratulations again we'll miss you and we'll see you in town and without further Ado I'd like to introduce Miss Jenny Hoffman who's our literacy coordinator who is going to help some of our elementary students tell us about their reading and writing [Music] good evening everybody I'm going to ask all the students to come to the stage than big okay thank you we just had to get a little set up there um welcome everybody to the Long Beach Elementary student writing showcase and I'd like to start with a little quote that's on the screen here reading is like breathing in and writing is like

005breathing out it's one of my favorite quotes you can't have one without the other so tonight our focus is on writing um and in New York state we have three different text types that we teach to all students K12 so they are narrative writing which is um writing stories that are either real or imagined uh we have informational writing to teach others um about what you know and we have argument writing which is to really prove your s so you will see examples of all three um from all the grades tonight and there's no better way um to introduce writing than to just have students read their writing right so we're just going to have every student come up one by one um and share their wonderful work with you okay so first oh sorry

006I had another slide um another part of the standard just quickly before waiting very patiently um is practices of lifelong writers and Long Beach students um definitely practice all of these things almost every day they think read and speak and listen to support writing they write often and widely they write for multiple purposes including learning and for pleasure they persevere through challenging right tasks um they enrich personal language and background knowledge and vocabulary they experiment with language we analyze Mentor texts and try to become our own writers um and we strengthen writing by planning revising and editing and Publishing um so those are all the steps of the writing process and we like I said we um we work on writing every day in every grade okay so our first author is Ethan come on

007over here okay and Ethan you guys read the snowy day right and tell us what was Peter doing in the snowy day Peter on a snowy day snow angel and what were you doing on a snow day a no girl fight thank you very much good okay okay grace tell us what your um goal for the new year is to read and write and what are you doing in the picture there reading a book Thank you so [Applause] okay Daisy what was your goal for the new year F and what are you doing in the picture bing thank you so [Applause] much okay so before we move on to kindergarten you'll notice that pre writers they use a combination of drawing and dictating and oral expression um there's evidence that they're learning their letters the

008alphabet they're writing their name they're identifying the first word the sound in the word um they're differentiating between words and sentences and they do know some site words now we'll move on to kindergarten and Maria you're going to read yours right here is my walk walk here is the monkey B here is the playhouse thank you so and that was part of their show tell unit which you can see was down there um the kindergarteners practice writing um adding detail to their writing you'll see that they labeled objects in their drawings they wrote about the same topic over and over again um they use sounds they knew and inventive spelling and patterns they created settings and they picked topics that were important to them okay so Addy come on okay this is a howto unit

009which is informational writing ready how to draw a pig expert add what you need a pencil some paper cran box fancy weding pen [Music] Mar first you draw a circle for the head for the pig tip the circle is [Music] medium next you draw a smaller Circle for the nose with smaller circles in it to draw the smaller circles at the bottom of the then you draw two oals for the eyes tip put the oals in the top of the pck last you can if you want to you can do a design tip like mud [Music] thank [Applause] youby okay Paxton tell us how make my bed pillows sheets blankets bettered the bed first step is spread those sheets out to the four corners and then tuck them under the cushions make sure that you

010did all four cles second step is tuck the bed railing under the sheets and then pull them to the bottom cushion make sure that you cannot see the room then spread out the blanket out to all four corners make sure that you could not see the sheets last step is put the four pillows on the bed and split the into two and two and put them on the bed make sure that to face them up thank you and you start to notice some development in their writing as far as transition words right so you'll notice the first next then and last you'll see evidence of revision so the cross outs me has been reread and um and improved okay Jack how to play [Applause] Lacrosse Chapter One gear you need a helmet a masth and

011elbow pads and gloves and cleat and a stick not a wooden stick a lacrosse stick with a n and you're ready to go to your coach a mouth card is a thing that that protects your mouth chapter two positions the positions are Midfield and goalkeeper and attack and the opposite of attack is defense my favorites are Midfield and attack in Midfield you could take the face off and an attack you could score goals chapter three Dodges one of the most popular Dodges is a space Dodge you run up and bring the stick to to the side I love a spin Dodge you just spin around him it is so fun cuz you get to spin then you run up and and shoot super hard chapter four scoring you lift your stick a little back then

012and throw where you step that's where the ball goes shoot the ball as fast as you can chapter five cradling you keep the stick next to your ear and and move it back and forth and just run with it you make moves on the person and you seek a good heart shot on the goalkeeper thank you [Applause] ja as you can tell the writing is getting a little bit more um elaborated and longer so the rest of his piece is in the link in the corner so this will be posted if you want to know more about the cross um and also start noticing the different structures so information could be organized as chapters um students were T to use facts and details and examples that add it to it okay okay sha what is

013Han chapter one what is Han chapter two Lenora chapter three food chapter four presents chapter five glossery chapter one what is Hanah a long time ago there was a group called The macbes they need they needed L they thought the oil was going to last for one day but last for eight it was a miracle and they were so happy to wait theora chapter 2 manura we like the manura to remember the days long ago and there are eight days of Hanukkah but there are nine candles because of the shamash a shamash is a candle that lights the other candles chapter three food for food and hka we eat loas they're made out of potatoes they kind of taste like it too and there are Al and also you can dip it in applesauce foros

014and applesauce you do not have to but I think could taste chapter four presents your mom and dad watch you watch you and buy your presents only if you be good it kind of like Santa but with your hair they watch you every day until but if you be bad you do not get thank you sta okay we have Dana B By Dana marker a nonfiction book my introduction have you ever taken care of a pet maybe a if you love pets maybe a dog is the perfect pet for you read this book to find out how to take care of a dog supplies for a dog do you have supplies for a dog read this book to find out you will need a CER a leash a bowl a toy a treat food and

015a owner now you are ready to get a dog do you know how to b a dog read this this book to find out to bit a dog you need to the right soap you put the dog in the bag you squirt a little soap out then Rock gently on the dog next you rinse the dog and dry him and you have a clean dog do you have toys for your dog if you don't go to the to go to a dog store in one aisle there is toys go down that aisle and let your dog choose the toy and when he has it pay for it and your dog a toy do you know how to feat a dog if you don't know I will teach you go to a pet store for example

016you can go go to Petco or pet supplies go to go to the food aisle and find out what dog you have is your dog's mouth size medium small or big get the right food thank you so [Applause] much again the corner for the rest of her okay then you ready do you you have bad friends have you ever s about whatever you should let them go well I have I say that no matter what you should let go with bad friends and stop them from talking behind your back slowing you down or bailing on you one reason why you should let go of bad friends is that they slow you down once I was rushing to see something my friend kept trying to stop me and ask me questions by the time I got

017to the place that I was rushing to get to the thing I came for was finished and I could have made it my dad friend had saw me down friends slow you down because they want to bother you dead friends slow you down because they want you to miss stuff that's important to you dead friends slow you down because they want to keep you leading that is why you should let go of their friends with us down thank you again it's just a piece that persuasive you can see how the reasons and explanations are really trying to persuade us thank you Taylor Swift is the best singer ever because she's nice to her fans she's amazing at writing songs and most of all because she has the best content Ever One Reason Taylor Swift is

018the best singer ever is because she's nice to her fans for example whenever fans are hurt at Taylor's concert Taylor called security over to help the fan also one time at the a store the body guards at the concert were bothering a fan and Taylor told them to stop even though she was singing a song another example is if there is a child in the front row during 22 she will walk up to them give them a hug and the 22 hat thank you so much and you'll start to notice the fourth graders start with a thesis um and they pick a topic of their choice they State their reasons they elaborate um on each one with examples okay press me just because fast food tastes delicious it doesn't mean it is good for you

019fast food is bad because it is unhealthy it is not real food and most of all because it wasts too much some people might disagree with me because it tastes good and it is a quick stop for if you are in a rush but as you will see it does more harm than good one reason that fast food is bad is that it is unhealthy for example they put chemicals on on the food to make it stay out longer would you do that to your food I think not also they usually don't sell many greens vegetables such as sides of broccoli lettuce and green beans another example is that they add a lot of sugar on the food one day I was little and I got McDonald's and I got oatmeal when the oatmeal came

020there were rainbow raisins in the oatmeal I did not like it at all it was way too sweet and there was so much sugar in it I took one bite and it was way too sweet okay thank [Applause] you okay and uh James is gonna read us part of his narrative uh Jessy dreams and L SCS sun was Ring pure sunlight DW drops shimmered on the plants I heard the faint sound of trees wrestling the grass silky smooth beneath my feet the slight h of honeysuckle in the air I saw a shiny blue and black jet ski tied to the dock what's going on I thought in my head dad I yelled with a questioning voice what happened he yelled back inside the house whose jet ski is this that's ours he yelled with a

021cheery voice that that's ours yep my dad said as he came outside my jaw dropped I was with my family and my new dog in Carolina my dad had rented the J for us to use for the day my my smile was so big but it couldn't stop getting bigger the lake water was perfect for a jet ski no one was around and it was so smooth my dad secretly told me I could go first when nobody was looking okay James your turn this is going to be amazing I shouted wait what my brother and my sister Screech you heard with a spk on my face [Applause] so I hope that gave you a little bit of a taste of all the hard work that we do in our writing um across all the grade

022levels and again you heard a lot of informational and argument writing because that's what we've been focusing on um right before the break um but every single um grade starts with a narrative um and we really explore uh topics and and memories and things that they would like to write about um and they have a lot of choice um in those narratives so boys and girls why don't you come back out so we can give a big round of applause it really hard to [Applause] very I found my no already done [Applause] want to make a quick thank you before you go back to your parents um listening to your your your writing and how well you read everything it it brought back a memory of of a speech that I heard back um by

023an admiral in the Navy Admiral mcra he wrote it in 2014 at a College commencement and what he said there was that you have the ability to make change you have the ability to focus and part of that started by every day starting your day by making your bet putting an effort and focus on doing little things because if you can achieve little things you can achieve great things now today we heard and we saw how well you guys read and write and how much pride you put into it and I thank the staff and the parents for supporting that because in Long Beach reading and writing is the gate way for Learning and improving so keep doing what you're doing because in that speech by adal Craven he said if you can start by

024making your bed every morning you can do anything you want as long as you stick with it and you can change the world so tonight you guys showed us that your efforts in school is going to make a difference for everyone and you too can change the world so thank you so much for sharing that with us say one more thank you for bring up where's is he's here somewhere there you are can you do me a favor I want you to make me a copy of your story and I'm going to bring it home and I'm going to share it with my 21y old he doesn't know how to make his bed yet so I I'm very impressed that not only you know how to make a bed you so eloquently put it down

025on paper and and as Sam said if you can make your bed you can change [Applause] you're reading so you were the motivation Bud thank you um our next presentation just before we jump into that um I just want to say you guys were awesome awesome awesome and you're so great at speaking in front of all of these people there are a lot of adults who are scared to do that and you were so brave and confident and you T me a lot tonight about fast about how to bathe my dog I think I've been doing it all wrong about making read about so many things and So Beautiful Stories so thank you so much you did a great job now you could you are welcome to stay for the rest of the meeting but

026it's usually a little boring so if your parents want to take you home I think they owe you a special treat for everything that you did today okay congratulations thank [Applause] you give you a few thank you so much for those te so far thank you for the presentation [Music] so as everyone exits our next presentation by mrito is going to be over our proposed Capital PL it's going to be our first round draft going over conceptual Concepts what we want to utilize to include the district as a whole with long-term project that I C it on S deito thank you thank you give them one more minute so tonight we're just going to go through some basic concepts of what we'd like to see in our district a large scale Capital plan that we're

027proposing we've proposed it a few years U over the past few years we proposed a different Capital plan um for various reasons we put it on hold we waited uh we're hoping to move forward this year and we're going to go through some of the concepts um first is how does a proposed Bond project benefit the community so when you're doing a big Capital project something that exceeds what we would normally have in a given year as many of you know often times we have another ballot proposition where we use money from our capital reserve fund to do different types of projects and the the size of the project could range anywhere from let's say a million dollars to 11 million um but usually when you do a large scale project in order to afford

028it you want to spread out the payments over a number of years similar to when you buy a house you really can't afford to pay the whole amount up front and you get a mortgage so a bond is similar to a mortgage where you have an opportunity to do the work to pay the bills for the work but to repay all of that through some sort of a loan over about 15E period um so it actually allows things to remain stable in the tax levy without having any big or major increases and what we're proposing here is that we can do this and have no increase at all and maybe actually have a decrease um in what we have to pay out or the tax ly I'll talk a little bit about that later another

029reason why we do this is it's just for good planning um when you retire your debt so back in 2009 the Board of Education um had approved a bond uh went out to the community for Community boote back in May of 2009 and it was a 92 over $92 million bond that the community voted in favor of um we didn't borrow until 2011 the first part about $60 million then in 2013 we borrowed another $30 million that money that debt service is starting to what we say fall off meaning that the term is about to end so 5 million of our annual Debt Service our annual service for the past you know 15 or so years it's been about $8 million at the end of 2526 which is the next fiscal year it drops off

030it's already been repaid two years after that the remaining three million again it's an $8 million payment that we make every year that drops off that relates to the second part of the borrowing so it's good financial planning to have we say back fill it we borrow money so we can do some of these projects and then have that debt service either at the same level or a lower level so there's no tax impact so that's a little bit of the context in terms of how it benefits our community keeping our buildings shape allowing to not have a big impact on an annual basis in terms of an increase in the tax levy and how when you already have de service in the budget you can back fill it so that it just remains constant

031and we have the ability to keep our building in a good state of repair but also do some really exciting things so we're going to present to you some thoughts we have about about some of the really exciting projects that we hope to move forward with um and again this is our first introduction to this whole project at the high school and the middle school some things that we've been talking about to enhance our instructional program is we want to create space for carpentry a new carpentry CTE program for our robotics program for our Marine Science research for our Aquatics culture so we want to create some more space meaning we want to build out within the High School itself in areas where there's room um and I'm going to show you what that looks

032like in in a design ahead for some of these exciting programs that we know are growing that can really benefit our students whether it's through CTE through science research through that study through science research competition um that really capitalize on where we are which is a Barrier island with water all around us an alternative school we're looking for space that allows students who may not succeed in the conventional High School scenario or that environment and we want to carve out some space some new space um and build out on the high school there also have a Bloomberg like business lab Wellness room which is I'll explain a little bit more what that is a wrestling gym something that builds on to our existing gym that's dedicated for wrestlers and our wrestlers program but could also

033be used for other purposes for spaces that are premium at the high school and we really would like to have alternative space whether it's for test in for meetings for other types of physical education activities but primarily a space designed for our high school wrestling program we need to renovate our family and consumer science classroom at the high school we're looking to really change the whole feel of our cafeteria at the high school and have a new entrance way a new on the base side that that's really really showcases the high school with some additional space those are the program enhancements in terms of some repair repl of the building infrastructure we're looking at air handling units and air conditioning making sure that those are properly replaced um at the high school and to complement

034some more air conditioning where we still have a little bit more to go at the middle school redoing our locker rooms High School Middle School leard at the high school turf field has to be replace the high school we want to Turf the Courtyard at the middle school between the auditorium at the library and then basic repairs whether it's interior walls doors ceilings windows and some disability access throughout so what is some benefits of an expanded Tech space the ability to offer a full carpentry program that's would be CTE certified a designated area for robotics lab that includes a robotic testing area space that we really don't have right now a classroom as I said the Alternative Learning Center and then the full carpentry program will actually be a space where a wood shop would

035also house and that that creates available space for the new Marine Science Lab and a new dance room um what we're thinking about doing is putting a new Wellness Center where our current dance room is and you'll see what that looks like and in order to do that we're going to move the dance room down to some space on the ground here's a floor plan I know it's hard to see especially if you're way back in the back of the auditorium but you certainly get copies of this presentation online and you have a little bit more of a detail look at it but and basically this new uh gym facility would be extending to the east from the gym to where the basketball courts are we will relocate those basketball courts but it allows for

036this extension to the gym with some bathrooms as well here is our current dance room and you can see how great the view is it's very calming um and it will be a great place to convert it to something that looks like this so this is what we have as a wellness area where kids can really focus on their overall health and have different activities in there these are some ideas of what that space converting into something that looks like this great space but to improve it in this fashion the business lab what we said a bloom Bloomberg like lab excuse me would look like something like this this was a visit that we went to another District where they have this already so we have some ideas of how we may convert to an

037exist existing space to look like this the cafeteria here is a floor plan again this is more for review after the meeting but some renderings seal would look like this some wood floors um everything would be built off the center you see we' have some elevated dining space on the left countertop space along the window wall to the right um and that's what we have in store some Concepts that we have just introduced to everybody at the high school and the middle school at our elementary schools we to focus on playgrounds for the most part and ventilation and air conditioning also some doors ceilings walls we do need to handle some basic repairs of the Interiors so that's going to be hopefully included and we'll get into some more details the months to come another

038idea we had was have an inclusive playground which means that it goes beyond the accessibility standards where all people of all abilities can interact to set based on un design principles that guide the placement of all the different play structures the pathways the seating the equipment and it's a place where children families and caretakers can really play together regardless of their actual abilities and this is what something like that would look like and we hope to put uh one of these at least in one of our elementary schools and maybe very different versions of it at at maybe a second elementary school so that's some ideas about this inclusive playground concept that we are thinking about we also own the building of the public library and we need to do some repairs as the building

039infrastructure there we're not responsible for the actual Interiors but we are responsible with the building envelope so some things that we have in mind are the roof on the third floor the windows and the exterior doors so I mentioned to you about how the financing Works in terms of having no tax impact so if our current debt SE service in our budget take a look at the line by line is about 8 million if we have replacement de service that's less than that amount then that's how it becomes either no impact or perhaps even a reduction in tax levy so in summary uh we hope over the next several months talk about some of the details what we're going to do is as we present the budget we talk about the secondary budget or the

040elementary budget we'll talk about the related facilities that flesh this out in more detail with some cost figures with some descriptions about what this goal work is but it really hopefully will enhance our programs and Facilities take them up to a new level in terms of what our students can do and how they can use our facilities to support our educational and career opportunities to really engage our students with Cutting Edge programming that could be supported by the different facilities and just some ancillary benefits to our community is if our schools are performing at a very high level that could increase our property values and we hope to do all this in an environmental sustainability type of a way so that's the presentation for this evening I'm happy to take any questions or comments from

041the board and then of course from the public thank you very much Miss thank you thank you for that one of the I thinkal is very exciting can hear you that now okay um again that new inclusive playground proposal looks very exciting I just think that it it just includes so many people um and that's what we strive for here could you please explain to me I don't know if I'm the only one that doesn't understand what is a Bloomberg like business sure so I'm going to pull that picture up again um and uh Dr Galder or Bloomberg lab is a bit of a term of art um to rent a Bloomberg terminal is what dat Traders use and there are a couple of schools on island wealthier schools that actually do that um we

042kind of thought that was a little cost prohibitive and we can Vivic a lot of what that does but what and that was actually from be page what they did was set it up like a boomberg lab with a ticker and a stock trading floor and kind of a business type environment um and then use just some software that mimics day trading it's a much less expensive way to do it but our business program has really been growing over the past few years we have a great Virtual Enterprise program so we have students who are taking stock market courses now and again with you know relatively little Financial investment we thought this would be a great enhancement um for those kids who are interested in business which is a growing number of kids in our

043high school and and one more question the I know that the public had made it very clear that they were very interested in us having a wrestling gym and that's exciting as well what plans would we have for it when it's not wrestling season so you know the high school space is at a premium at the high school they are always looking for extra space um for different classes for different meetings for testing rooms you know often when we give any kind of test to our students that need a separate location it's difficult to find that at our high school um the high school team really feels pretty strongly that there'll be no problem using this you know during the offseason for wrestling and even during the wrestling season during the day um it gives

044us an auxiliary space for classes when we can't go outside so and I and I know that this was part of what was proposed to the community the B years ago and felt off because um you know they felt it wasn't the top priority at the time so again if it's something that we can do that enriches our program and we have a lot of Pride beach in our West program which I think is great I think it's something that we serve multiple purposes at the high school thanks so much anyone else also I meant to add currently our wrestlers practice frequently at the middle school because we don't have space at the high school so it would alleviate that problem as well I was going to say too um wrestling is almost like hockey

045where they're always wrestling it doesn't seem to have an end the students really love it when they're not wrestling um coaches always have them together so there's a wonderful camaraderie between our wrestlers um thank you Mr de for your for your presentation um I just have a question you mentioned you would move the basketball courts where would be have you thought about where they would be moved to on high school ground um I don't know mrin was gonna speak his folks and see you know where the best place for it was but we have a few different possibilities okay so they would still have a basketball okay um I want to thank you about the blomberg lab I remember at our last meeting we had those those wonderful students present their business plan and they

046created their own app for exercise so once you mentioned the Bloomberg lab I immediately went to them because you're right it seems that business is something that our students are showing a greater interest in and the more we can help them in high school with it with the better um I concur with M Fel about the disability accessibility I think that's a wonderful wonderful asset to our community um I why would we do more though more Turk though what what benefits did you see when you mentioned the Turk coures well I think what we've heard from the Middle School is that the area between the library do and the auditorium his play there gets very budy so half of it already is is a basketball court but the other half is not and they've been

047asking to do something so that it's it's more durable the surface and it doesn't just get so muddy when it rains or you know easily with holes and things like that just to make it safer and have a play area that the kids are going to play there they like to you know play sopore different things run around and we'll just hold up because it's hard to keep grass there because of the amount of traffic that's on that area and then it doesn't really hold up to the weather so between the weather and the amount of traffic they think that just having a Turf surface would be good for them okay but I guess since we're really just starting to discuss this we'll have a lot more time to discuss what best yeah y this

048is just um our first step thank you okay um just thank you Michael I just had a few questions of clarity um you mentioned good financial planning the $5 million is is falling off there's three million falling off in the next two years did I get that right right so not next year but the year after um that $5 million portion of the $8 million of debt service will not be there anymore because we would have paid off that first borrowing that we did in 2011 then two years later an additional 3 million drops off because then the borrowing we did in 2013 that gets fully repid so in terms of sound financial planning we already have a placeholder in the budget for that we do need some work in our buildings so to be

049able to Stage it in a way that we do the work we borrow we repay so that we keep that amount either level so there's no tax impact or lower where it would actually be reduction in the expenditure line is good planning because it keeps our facilities in a good state of repair and it doesn't add anything to the taxpayer right because we have a place in the budget there okay and just a point of clarification it would again be a 15year borrowing so PRI was 15 and then I'm assuming much like a mortgage rate there's an interest rate is that locked or flexible well you know I I i' have to check in terms of what the current legal framework is I know that when we borrowed back in 2011 2013 you know when

050we closed on those Bond issues we did have a certain rate but there was a vehicle for advanced repayment for some of the board members who were here there they may remember that when we got closer to the end of the repayment period we were allowed to prepay the principal and to do that at a lower interest rate so we saved actually uh several millions of dollars in the overall total repayment of those Bond issues by going back out getting a lower rate being able to prepay and the rest of the U the oute the actual Debt Service was lower so we talk about that 8 million it used to be actually higher like five seven years ago before we did some of the refinancing that's kind of the terminology most people are familiar with

051from a home orage in the bond world it's called advaned whatever I like this advaned pay um Advanced refunding excuse me um and it lowered it lowered our our annual payments okay y my last comment is just you know one of the Visions Dr gallager brought to this District was just growing our programs our CTE program so we've seen so much of that in the past few years and I love the idea of the carpentry CTE program um there's plenty of work for houses to be built H to be built I just think that is going to be a wonderful edition of right in here that's something that scks out to me thank you for answering my question thank you thank you Mr Deo I just have two questions one is is there a standard

052amount of time for district to go for bond for between bonds you mentioned in you a little talk that last time we off for Bond was 2009 approxim 15 years is that pretty much standard for or mitigating factors that kind of make that a I I think it's it's whatever the community is willing to support I know that from an administrative standpoint what I'm recommending now is to backfill to the existing Deb Service as it falls off so as you may recall 2009 was when the community approved the bond issue but we did far right away because we didn't need that money immediately so similarly um you know we're looking to borrow and to line up the borrowing and the repayment and all of that as The Debt Service falls off some districts you know

053there isn't a willingness to to do something like that but I know our community is always looking to reinvest and to make sure our buildings are in a good State before uh we did put up the 2009 vote I know think there was a bond issue or Bond vote for many many years greater than that 15year cycle so I I think that people would say it's good Financial Planning and good facilities planning to do it as every 15 years or so to make sure that you have some type of um plan to make sure that the facilities are kept properly and that there's a way to afford it and the way to afford it is if there's already a placeholder in the budget for a certain level doesn't need to be the exact level but

054there's already a placeholder there is to not have it be where okay then there's it drops and then like five or seven years later that you you insert it back in because then you have that kind of Spike that you don't want to have youd like to try to keep things low so I think that any facilities planner or a financial planner that deals with this type of thing would recommend that every 15 or so years that you go out for a new type of financing of facilities Improvement speaking about financing you've mentioned the lot of terms some beyond my comprehension the one that I didn't he address was the notion of State reimbursement so in fact if say it's $50 million toal project it might be would could we count on the state reimburse

055semester certain amount long as it's eligible correct so um we would be able to identify whatever this you know so I gave a range of different projects that we're considering for the most part most of them are eligible for building Aid and our building Aid ratio is is is quite high it's about 42 cents on the dollar that we get back from the state in building Aid uh so what happens is that then reduces the net cost to us in terms of what our debt service is so our debt service maybe like I said is about 8 million right now we get about you know maybe three and a half million of building Aid related to those projects so the difference is what the net cost is to the district what happens though is what's

056interesting is our building Aid that relates to this de service is also going to go because it's it's set up for a 15year payment in terms of the building a related to these projects thereabouts you know um so again if we spend a dollar and it's eligible most are not everything but most of these projects would be eligible for building a we get 42 back on that dollar from New York State um and if we don't do something we also will lose that back mil a building we don't have any de service to keep it going as best I recollect you were here just relatively new in 2009 yeah now that uh those Bond projects or will the bond pass we went at 2009 when will we completely finish with those projects well super strong

057Sandy complicated things as you may remember so um you know I know you'll remember this just a little anecdote is that we had just completed the Middle School library right and we were having a ribbon cutting and a whole big thing on the Tuesday of of that same week that superstorm Sandy so that delayed the actual completion of everything um but you know it took several years and then Super stor sanding we had to either redo we had just done or interrupted the uh timeline for the work so I couldn't really tell you at this point exactly when all that work ended because you know it kind got complicated with the over you know approximately $40 million of loss that we had to Super drug one of the other things that know tried in the

058last five six years is the notion of supply chain and how backlog they've been and how we've had to wait for certain things whether they might be textbooks or was but anyway I guess I'm getting ahead of myself thank you for the presentation there certainly a lot for us the community to J thank you for the work you put into it so far thank you Mr Deo thanks again for the presentation um obviously this is the first step for the public feedback uh to provide for us being on the capital Pro committee along with Miss Conway Mr gorilla M Mr Kramer Dr gager and yourself I know that we try to prioritize um enhancements and improvements to the district that would support safety and also support our program as well as giving opportunity for the

059community to utilize our space because we know that the district has a lot of space and inside space that's often used by those outside of the school Community um some of the things that we're focusing on though we've had a lot of successes whether it's our robotics or with our trait carpentry or even our welding and we realized that we're growing outside of our means our successes are growing outside of our means and that's why we're focusing on bringing these types of freck and mortar um enhancements to support the operational budget we do every year to support the children and learning by you know putting in the right staff bring them teachers of training giving the day-to-day facility um and tools so now when we're doing this Capital project um we're actually giving the brick

060and mortar to help support that and I think it's important that we realize that because we need a safe environment we need to support instruction um we need to grow on our successes because you know we want to have regener on uh winning students in science and we're surrounded by water and we don't have a lot of capabilities to do Marine science uh we want to expend our welding to provide services whether it's on land or at Sea and make sure our kids are prepared After High School um to to have trads because not every kid's going to college a lot of them are now assuming jobs right out of high school and I sat yesterday with someone at the barber and he said hey you know I own a welding company and I actually

061hired a kid graduate from LOM high school with a welding certificate he went right into the workforce it was great for him so these types of opportunities um are really important to to this the community as a whole bring it back into the economy I think it's important that we pick up the fact that we're doing this now at this time because there's a lot of improvements and maintenance um needed and enhancements needed and now is a good time to do this because we're losing the debt service from the previous fond so essentially what we're looking to do is actually not have increased burden on the taxpayer but also provide the necessary upgrades and that's a good reason why we're doing it now because the truth is that if we can figure this out we

062can provide improvements to the community but also be financially responsible in the planning for because what we're doing now is planning for the future um it's not going to happen tomorrow but hopefully when we ask the public to approve these types of funds to support the community that they can see the forward vision of how it supports them the students and the community as a whole so thanks again for for the presentation and thank you for including us on the committee um it's it's great to see what we can do to help support the kids and and keep moving forward so thanks again thank you um um normally we have um our student organization give a little bit of a a speech on behalf of the the high school class but I is not here

063so we'll move on questions and comments on from the public on tonight's agenda only remember if you can tell us your name your please speak uninterrupted you can for 3 minutes and uh anything that's on tonight's agenda you're more than welcome to come on up and to and speak whoever goes up go first hello 445 East Olive Street um I didn't plan on speaking on this part of the agenda and I trying very hard to keep what we just saw which was a lot of things coming while they're while my community is facing the closure of school and my children being shifted into spaces that we will make at the three elementary schools um a lot of these things that you showed are not foundational to education a Wellness Center a coffee cafe aish CHS

064I think those are all nice to have and I think it is and I will address more on this after this but it is almost a slap in the face of this community and I appreciate that we are trying to build the infrastructure but we have I have stood here and ask you month over month year over year to fix our AG pack at our school and to see a what looks like a apartment the Sands Beach Club at the high school I hope you can understand how upsetting that is from a community standpoint when we're trying to argue for class sizes for our elementary schools for programs in our elementary schools so I hope that you this is the first version this continues to iterate but I hope you can understand where I'm coming

065from seeing things like this in a presentation thank Youk [Applause] moving on questions sorry 445 uh just questions around the expansion in this use of the bomb where was this last year when we stood here and we cried for where is the surprise that the bom was up shouldn't be so a year ago with a threat of losing $4 million whatever that that number was it was J now this is an expansion because we just oh B we're getting the money back we have the money but yet you're still bringing in parties to look at selling or not selling property it's it is like it's like telling my kids they have to go into the closet and live together so I can you know add things to my house because you know I want to

066have it's cool I'm not so you're being very irresponsible By ignoring what you're still doing as a board not giving any direction to the community or your staff or sorry the executive committee here or the sorry the executive team that's running this as to what the direction is it's all these things are great I would love them I would vote for them I would yes for the bom you're still trying to CR Kids into smaller schools please address that in your next session [Applause] thank hi my name is and than just hello my name is proud East Elementary East is more than just a school it's like a second home for me and so many other kids tonight I want to tell you why East Elementary is so important why we need to keep it

067open first I want to talk about how amazing of a place the school is to grow and learn the teachers work so hard to make learning fun and exciting for example this year when we were learning how to write mess to support our Reas with evidence our teacher asked us a questions he had to answer with evidence and we didn't realize that we were learning how to write mess while doing another reason is amazing is because our classroom makes us feel like a when we work together to do things like fun exciting projects last year in third grade got to work oning about we researched anals and so many different the last Way East is is a fabulous place to learn because the staff works so hard to send us on awesome field trips last

068year we went to go to United States which was so fun this year we've been to Aviation and tomorrow we go to rock we're AR so excited another reason is so important because it's like a giant family our our families and staff work together to come to make like the ballest or with coner and where everyone is excited for their and students the support this school provides us is for the kids oh it's so important it would break my heart to see closed down because I have so many wonderful memories that would never be replaced this is is not just a building a are able to grow and feel like once again my name isar proud thank you for [Applause] time in public uh if we can just make sure that we focus on at

069this time questions or comments on the agenda items only there'll be questions and comments later on any item if youd like but right now we're focusing on the two presentations hi 31 East Olive um I didn't plan on sharing either and I'm gonna run out of here to go pick my son up from wrestling practice um so as a parent who's in a fortunate enough situation as my son is graduating from echool technically I guess this isn't my problem anymore um as a neighborhood uh taxpayer considering echool being my neighborhood school it is still a problem for me so also in in the Dual situation that perhaps I live here long enough that I do care what you do with the middle school and the high school as my son will be attending both of

070those schools potentially as a wrestler and can benefit from all the things I'm just here to say how confused I am just back baffled and so confused again to reiterate what was said how can this be a year later knowing what we know now what's not being taken away from us that you could sit here and not address the obvious to us that what you could put towards keeping this school and what it matters to our children's education is just beyond me I mean I I know my statement today was going to be to you without real in that you were going to do this and insult us further what I was going to say was there is no trust for you and it's not just e School parents you have lost trust okay you

071have lost all Faith from us and this that just shows me that uh it's just been lost on you it's just been completely lost on you my discouragement um yeah so maybe I don't know maybe I'll send my I'll more money and send my son to uh Catholic High School because I'm just beyond beyond disgusted at this point so that's that's it for [Applause] me sorry before before you start um if we can I understand every people want to show support for speakers but historically you try not to clap or to Boo or to do any type of speing so you can go ahead and try to do that but it's not supportive to letting people speak so we appreciate everything you're saying we're not interrupting you you can just uh try to keep that

072in mind thank you thank [Music] you hold on my name is Mor Alvarado 61 three Monroe Boulevard I just have a question about the quickly um the criteria for going to B what's that like who gets to decide like whose ideas are the wellness room and the um I mean obviously not the repairs but the extras like the Bloomberg which I also agree would be fantastic because my kids will go to high school here but who gets to decide those and then who puts the dollar amount and then obviously it's the people who vote but so so we were at the first stage of the process so Central Administration would here introduce some ideas for the board and the public consideration then there's an opportunity like now to weigh in on what you like about

073it what you don't like about it or maybe something new that we haven't been present that hasn't been presented in the public forum like we right now you get to say hey I like this I don't like this so have you thought of that so that this is the opportunity right now to do that and then it's the board that will ultimately decide on the final scope the dollar value based on the cost figures that our architect and The Architects put together so for example if we're looking at expanding space for the robotics program of carpentry so put together some preliminary design he'll cost it out and he'll say this is what for this line item for this element of this over project was the cost the board will finally determine whether they want to

074go forward with the different line items that we propos that we hear the feedback on and then they sign off and they say okay this is what we're going forward to the voters and then it's on a ballot and then it's the community that actually has to say yes what they want to go forward all right so a general collaboration all those cool things the the other piece is the ideas are generated from our instructional sta okay that makes sense so my my recommendation like you said what you get it from would be um to use a bond to fix e school thank [Applause] you just want to comment on this Wellness room um it looks like it belongs in the breeze one the multi buildings just put up mean looks awesome I'd love to

075have I'd love to live there instead of my apartment I'm not entirely sure that that's exactly what we need in our schools especially when there are so many other factors I personally am a mom I'm also a taxpayer 20 something years I put a lot of money into this city I want what's best for my daughter but I also don't want to spend money that is unnecessary so I also think that this is a strange thing to present thank you I'm just wondering Juliana Louisiana Street so I think there's a lot of new people that don't actually know how the proper order is um at the back of the agenda or you can look online at the district site are the instructions so I know Mr Pino saying don't clap or don't speak needs to

076come on to microphone just general right I asked Mr dito on the bond proposal right so I'm trying to remember from past years and last year you did several proposals right before it was tabled that's correct okay so at the next meeting in two weeks will you have more specifics and break down so what we're going to do this year is we're going to run um the specifics of this bond proposal concurrently with the budget so for example um next week I don't think you know about like some Central administrative functions I'm not mistaken benefits and things of that sort maybe Transportation there's nothing there that has to do with that we're proposing in the box so we wouldn't really talk about it at the N Boe but let's say when we talk about the

077secondary program we start talking about what our proposed budget is for our secondary program we're going to talk about some of the structional enhancements that we're thinking about to support that program that we're proposing next year now again in terms of the timeline let's say we go out we put this out to vot it takes about a year year and a half to get approvals from New York State based to get on the drawings then we have to go go out to bid or use an existing contract that's out there to do the work for the most part we like to do the work in the summer so it doesn't interfere with the instructional program some things we can do during the school year so the actual work is probably not going to happen for

078let's say two to three years if we're lucky and it all goes well perhaps a little bit next summer so it's it's in the out years that we're talking about but in terms of introducing the detail for more discussion it's going to be over the next several months that we're going to be doing now later part of the agenda was elementary literacy okay that's not dedicated Public School educator with 19 years of experience I've always believed in the power of public education and remain committed to it however today I stand before you not just as a teacher but as a mother advocating for my second child who need the proper I this is the second time I've had to navigate this difficult and frustrating process to secure appropriate educational supports my child is legally entitled

079to receive my child is currently in first grade and struggle significantly with recognizing the letters of the alphabet and their sounds despite clear evidence from the first couple of weeks of school highlighting his need and for reading support we are now five months into the school year and I'm still fighting to have reading Services placed and included in his without Foundation skills reading skills my child canot access the broader curriculum putting him at a severe disadvantage academically and emotionally early intervention is critical and denying these Services only widens the gap between where he is and where he should be I made an effort to come speak to you tonight to bring to your attention that I've experienced several legal violations in this process over the past few weeks few months few months theate evaluations denial

080of priv evaluation C evaluation rates denial of reading Services denial of reading services for a child who doesn't need to know all this letters first grade we just witnessed kindergarten students reading I mean it was beautiful but now I need support for my child and that was just to name a few of the legal violations that have been occurring I provided consent for all necessary evaluations in September however two critical evaluations were delayed both January and February the Long Beach School District wanted my son to wait five months to get evaluated five months that is illegal and grossly unfair to my child due to these delays I requested the district cover the cost of a private valuation mind you I propos utilizing a provider that the Long Beach School District previously approved and funded and

081the provider confirmed availability for November evaluation despite no leg reason to do so my request was denied the one independent educational evaluation the district did approved was tapped at an unreasonably low rate legally the district must either pay the full cost of the evaluation or formally deny the request and initiate a due process hearing this failure to follow legal protocol further delayed and compromised my child's opportunity for a thorough And Timely assessment despite significant discrepancies between my child reading level and Grave expectations the district deemed it inappropriate to include breing services in his I PID this denial is unacceptable reading services are not optional they are essential for my child's academic success without targeted reading intervention my child will continue to fall further behind impacting his confidence motivation and long-term educational outcomes throughout this process

082I made numerous attempts to communicate with the district advocating persistently for my child's right to appropriate educational supports yet these efforts have been met with delays denials and lack of urgency I appreciate everything direct thank you so much this has directly contributed in my child receiving the services he desperately needs this is not just for procedural issues it is the profound disservice to my child and other students in similar situation the system is broken and the continuous fail to to uphold legal obligations has created significant barriers to my child's Learning and Development it is clear that the current system is failing to support our children meaningful and immediate change must happen to address these systematic failures timely evaluations appropriate services and adhere to educational lust are non-negotiable our children deserve better specifically immediate access to

083evidencebased reading interventions must be prioritized to address learning gaps before they've become insurmountable I hope this serves as a call to action for necessary improvements in our system thank you thank [Applause] you so this means nobody's going to respond I wouldn't think it's appropriate that we publicly disc your child specific needs in a public forum I think it's best that you communicate still with Dr Gallagher the administrative team handling it uh we heard what you said we appreciate your insights but for us to start debating about your child's specific needs in front of the public going be appropriate so thank you I am not asking you to discuss my child personal needs I'm asking you about I was told there are no reading services in this District to be placed on an IEP reading Services

084cannot be placed on the I page they can have AIS reading which has nothing to do with an i or they can have resource room and have some supports in there that is not reading Services yeah that's not act actually accurate but again I don't want to discuss it publicly I you don't want to discuss the district's failure to Supply Reading services to all the students because we're not failing this a secret so I don't you can't just say things like that and let we have to let them go we are not failing up here tonight we are teaching reading we're reading so you brightness but forget about the so one of the things that we we're trying not to do is have a debate right now if we can I think it's best serving

085for everybody follow that you follow the superintend thank you the last time I followed up with Dr Gallagher she said she agreed with me and would speak with the PPS department and that provider was still Deni thank you so much support thank you you just have to really speak into the bike even though it feels uncomfortable I'm so I don't understand I'm on volleyball deadline so I have to rush a bit but I mean just to reiterate a little bit that presentation was amazing I I've con seeed that line I have El school children but I know that they will be in middle school and they will be in high school and I want all the best and the good things for them but I'm hearing a lot of talk about priorities and I just

086don't see that in what was presented there I feel like we're living in a box but deciding to buy the yacht like I just don't really understand and as a as a mother as a business person as a person that runs a budget a home budget a financial budget I would ever say to myself well you know we can't fix the slide in the East playground for a year but I think we should put a Lou in high [Applause] school and I know that that was a little but I just really want everybody to be looking down the line and I I want to P that listen if we're closing the school and that's what all the things we get are then can we decide on all the things that need to happen beforehand like

087okay the school's closing where are my kids going to school do I have a choice of where they're going to school umit where are the buses they're picking them up but I'm not going to be able to walk them anymore I only have one car how am I logistically going to do that how do I emotionally prepare my two children who barely want to leave me as it is uh to go to a completely different space which is going to happen anyway I mean you have to what do they say you have to prepare the child for the road not the road for the child I I don't want to baby them I want them to experience things I want to be able to tell them listen this change is coming but all these great

088things are going to happen and the taxpayers are going to spend less money and the schools are going to be better but honestly I looked through the numbers today and I didn't see an actual concrete plan as to where where is the benefits for us for the kids for the taxpayers what's happening to the building which just still all these questions and I wrote 10 speeches for today but instead I've just listened and this is what I've come up with so just I I really beseech you with all of MCU of my body to put us to an end our suffering we're just at a state of anxiety for months and months and months and personally like I barely can stand up right now I sick with worry of how this team is going to

089affect everyone not just my children but all the children in the district because if you integrate the schools you increase the ratio burn out the teachers and all the things that we love that are going on at this level might disappear so I just thank you for your time the rest of the meeting goes well [Music] thank hi helloo 63 I just want to say something and it's really as a general statement to everybody people can get mad they can say what they want but I been coming to the board of B for going on close to 9 years now and I understand when there's Hot Topic people come and get upset when everybody has a right to be you have a right to feel away from you but as we teach our children growing

090up there are rules to follow when we come to these Board of bed meetings we get three minutes when the timer goes off we should stop We Don't Clap we don't Boo and it doesn't matter how many time or doc Ryan or anybody out there saying please Don't Clap please don't food let's be respectful and try and follow the rules I just think if we want our children to follow the rules as adults we should set an example and follow them thank you thank you [Applause] [Music] people are confused the B proposal is suff from something else I was a little disappointed in the fact that it's very high school focus and I've sort of noticed the pattern over the last couple of years in our board meetings that everything seems to be [Music] school

091for that as well however I think we're getting stuck on the term wildness room and I think maybe Mis because I know Dr you and I discussed about having a room for kids with mental health issues because of recent things that have Happ Community especially the high school there are a lot of students struggling suicid so I you know been trying to fight on the elementary level from Services there are kids at high school that are things so we can't even begin to understand with our little ones and I think that Wellness room is actually a mental health and it was poorly worded so people are thinking that there's going to be a house offering facials at the high school but that's not what that room is point Thank you and just again this is

092a preliminary presentation we have talked about the need for wellness centers at our schools and we'd love at all of our schools but it has been a particular need at our high school over the past 10 years and it is a room where students can go to decompress to calm down to think to do the things that are healthy ways of strategies of coping stress but it's also potentially a room where our psychologists and our social workers can see students it's a room where we can run programs for students on health and wellness Oceanside has been operating a room like that for years bore America we've done our research it's really a beneficial thing if the pictures were too pretty they're just AI generated pictures of a Zen kind of a place where kids could

093sit and stay and I think with if you read anything about the state of mental health in our adolescence today I I think you really have to understand that that is a major component of a program enhancement at the high school it's not a spa and it's not part of the Long Beach to it's something that our kids desperately need and need it every well to be H uh CHR mcy 61 victim um before I uh speak of capital budget I just want to start by showing gratitude candidly to every single person that's in this room in less than 24 hours uh through connected text messages that shot across this community um you all showed up again and you've been showing up for a year and I'm just in awe of the persistence the passion

094the grit for our kids I feel really proud to get to raise my kids in this Village but exceptional people that cares this much about something um this is what a community is to me um I kind of I won't belabor this too much but I kind of agree with the tone dep presentation tonight um the idea of being asked to pay for Brick and water investments is a bit of a difficult message to hear to say the least um I can yeah uh so 12 months into this process I feel like what I have heard is that the governor has walked back the loss of funding we are not in danger of losing programs in fact they might expand we may yet see another savings uh from the bond proposals and there is no

095interest from renters willing to use more than a small portion of e school and there has been no plan of Revenue after cause shared with the community not only is there no urgency to act but we have not come close to meeting the established thresold by the board that any change should produce a significant benefit for the city to justify disrupting our schools Mr Pinto you want our kids to change the world and I want to change the world and do everybody in this room tonight I don't want to distrust my neighbors and I don't think that that is productive or healthy for this community but I think you all know that this loss would be devastating and the passion from this group should tell you that they are going to move Heaven and Earth

096to do what's best for this community and their children I don't think it's too late to work together to build something that can be amazing for everybody um and I would like to see that in our capital budget uh I have two questions based on what you know today do you truly believe that you have provided a better option for taxpayers and our community and are you willing to vote today to keep East School open in 2026 as work with the East family that is here to find a path forward together I'm willing to vote I'm voting as I did last year I have been changed I'm even more convinced I feel that e this whole issue is blocking us going forward in terms of budget in terms of taking care of the building I

097don't think that children's education is being compromised in the least in terms of the quality of Education fom size I think it's good for the community it's good for the taxpayer I said this a year ago I say it now and I'm hoping that we come to some closure on the E School matter before we pursue a bond before we talk about budget because the future be to Central that and if I'm voted down by my colleagues on the board I'll accept that but I refuse to keep stalling on this issue because it's sting us going forward so that's where I stand on this issue Where I Stood a year ago where I stand out so just so everyone knows we're not voting on the bond proposal the bond plan right tonight we're doing the

098introduction of what we have for concept for improving the district um DRC Ryan is is willing to give you know his opinion that he's continue to maintain uh throughout this whole process Dr Gallagher is going to give an update from our advisory committee of an update of our state of affairs and we're going to give a little more information towards the latter part of the meeting because that's the appropriate time to do it but right now we're still trying to work through the process give people the opportunity to speak on the bond proposal and we we'll address your questions for the most part we'll do our best to address them at the point that they are right now later on in the meeting but for now we're trying to give people the opportunity respect each

099other that they want to speak on the bond proposal give them that opportunity you guys can speak everyone here can speak on any Ty topic but not at this point of the meeting so if we can maintain that then it gives respect to the individuals who would like to speak on it or we can move on to the other business of the of the meeting but for right now obviously we're still speaking on the botom proposal and we're not going to Shi the meeting early to to handle this but I do appreciate your questions on it and we do have a lot of shared visions and a lot of things we're just trying to get through this part of the meeting right now okay no problem I thank [Applause] [Music] you good evening my name

100Judith Duran I live at 363 East Harrison my daughter goes to first grade at East I am a New York City educator for almost 20 years I teach High School to it so I completely agree with a lot of the things that you're saying about what adolescence need especially um because so many of our community students choose to go to private school or cath school because of the things that long agach high school doesn't offer with that being said I hope that you understand the public perception as a person of Long Beach that moved here in 2016 um I am a transplant as one would say so public perception of someone who has come here bought a home and chosen to raise her children here I have nothing po to say about this community this

101community in the past last year is being torn apart because of the lack of transparency on all of your parts you are breaking the trust between the community and the school and as a teacher who works in a building when that trust is broken nothing moves forward News 12 is banging down people's doors getting people to have statements so that the rest of Long Island is now showcasing Long Beach as a board and an Administration who doesn't have it together who is against their Community the state came out with an audit all of a sudden we have money all of a sudden we have this agenda and it is wonderful for high school students but there is zero transparency zero you will never move forward and I hope you are the only one you will

102never move forward without the trust of your community thank you Megan curly 466 H Boulevard EXC I wasn't planning on speaking so forgive me um so about the bond projects and the wellness uh thing I think some of us we do understand what it is or not that student um and I love the idea of students having to go I do have questions especially given high school students age how exactly that would be run who would have access when Etc I think that we do have to think of that liability um I was an program in my high school we had a Senor room so I do have firsthand knowledge of what might happen if you don't have oversight um I also think that our mental health um crisis is a Countrywide thing and I'm

103glad that we're making efforts to approach that I have to say how disappointed I have been as a parent in um what I have perceived in the past and now can absolutely say with certainty that this District cares very little for elementary age students I really I can't you know you'll say well they GRE up there whatever um this is formative I'm a former college professor and I want you to remember to take some lessons from colleges when they spent huge amounts of money making beautiful libraries with cafes and things and what was their main problem not getting kids to go there getting quality students and retention so all the bells and whistles are beautiful but as a taxpayer I would have to see exactly the need for it right the outcomes possible outcomes etc

104for any bond Capital project moving forward um and I do think it's in very poor taste and I know that some of you have complained on the board and admin that being too much or you know it's it's too much holding us back it's let's get over it you are so lucky to have constituents who care about their children you are so lucky to have this room full of people who are willing to stand up and talk and get yelled at and be raided like your children you are so lucky we care that's why you still have to deal with it that's all I to say thank you anyone else like to speak on tonight's agenda item only sir oh sorry Craig fer 67 Street you know I understand everybody's trying to do the best

105they can um I kind of equate this to almost like plastic surgery it's like okay it's it's great we all want to look good we want enhance a few things but what really matters is what's on the inside you know and um when my wife and I were first choosing school we immediately said all right Le Elementary you know going there it's gorgeous it's beautiful and you know like defin and she was like let's just go take a look at e you know um and we went to Leo and we're weling around and it's gorgeous it's like a college campus and I'm like oh this is beautiful but it had you know there was something missing there you know and I was just confused it felt a little bit cold I have friends who teach

106there they're lovely people I'm sure it's a lovely School I've friends whose kids go there it's lovely um but we went to East and I thought all right this place looks like a dump it's going to suck and I walked in the are and you want to talk about the most beautiful heart you'll ever find in this community in that school I mean the teachers I walked in and I was like whoa what's going on here every teacher knew every student's name they cared about them they LED them you know I saw my friends kids in there and I was like and oh yeah that's that's TJ yeah the grace is in the other room how do you know who are you you know talk to me I I need to meet this guy and

107um my my wife and I came out there we're just like Blown Away We like holy this is where our son has to go because my son would have gotten lost in the elementary he would have been unnumbered he would have been lost in a big classroom he's almost he's like very close to being on the Spectrum and he needed that special love and care that only he could give it and I swear to you I'm the soul my brother that school has made my son go from here to here and the parents and the kids they all love each other you got 15y olds playing with you know three year olds it's it's insane it's unbelievable in the playground I mean yeah but like everybody plays with each other doesn't matter what you look

108like how old you are everybody looks out for each other in this school and it's the same with the teachers they all know each other they all know each other's kids everybody can and I wish there was more East parents here but I know people have to work like have kids you know everybody's probably watching on zoom and wants to be here believe me they're here and and they're yeah but I mean it's this this school is not just a school it's a family it's a community and I know it might not be totally H topic um my time's up I'd like to thank the uh the Academy I know my up just quickly I it was because of the big pretty things that you guys are doing and I mean no disrespect I just

109want you to hear the heart of this school it's all heart and just when you sleep at night when you lay your head down alone tonight just think about your legacy do you want to be known as the person that destroyed a beautiful bleeding heart in community does does anyone else onight I have a couple questions my name fromn Street can't hear me I'll speak louder I can my voice one question theb onlyb model um not sure what you're asking what's another mod business models that we can up Bloomberg I don't know if you were hear when I answered that before we're not actually doing a moonberg lab that's a bit of a term of Art and we do have to say a terminal dat it was more of the idea of creating a business

110room or business rooms that has the ticker and the trading B it's not even an expensive kind of okay um no I just wanted to clarify because that's something that definitely comes up business programs right now we have Virtual Enterprise which presented at the last board meeting which is the simulated company and students trade with other simulated companies very cool program we've been running in for about five years um we have also grown our accounting program and our um stock market investing programs so we thought this would be a great way for them to kind of have a sense of what being on the trading for like for those classrooms but again it's not an expensive renovation it's not a that's why we're okay I just want to clar the community needs to know that

111it's not in that we may actually change it like business lab okay with that being said as a father of somebody that goes to this school I find it very difficult to hear that there's nothing being done to elementary schools with this Bond and I think that needs to be very clear to the community particular those on the other side of town yeah no but there are there are so as mrito said we're doing maintenance upgrades air conditioning ventilations and field enh it feels like in your head because other schools are not beinged and it just feels like it's a slap in the face again again this was supposed to just be an introductory over no I know that but I think there like a lot of people are saying there us to be [Music]

112thanks I have a question talk about a wellness center in high school so as parent are four grad and all parents who deal with kids and social media and everything is there any talk for elementary level because these kids need it as an elementary yeah there there is and you know again what we're looking at is what do now what can do in the future as someone mentioned supervision of these spaces is important right now we actually can do this at the high school can run programs in that room we have psychologists and social workers who can stamp it we have the plan to do it at the middle school as well kind of connected with the ISS room um because they're working on practices there you have to think a little bit more about

113what that looks like in elementary because elementary students don't have three periods they don't have the ability to drop in when they're upset so it may be at the elementary level that looks a little different maybe we provide some you know like psychist soci having more of that Imaging conversation work again but this is a capital plan there are certain things that you can include in that you can't include operational expens staff even Furniture is that really so we can still do them at level it has to look different and it is okay I know mindfulness and things like that were taking out of the equation so if this can be something very important it does have to start at the elementary level you know kids get to a high school level they already passed

114where they need to be some kids need it and and not all kids unfortunately go to a safe space once they leave school so if we can address that that help okay so I just want to make sure that it's going to be somewhere in okay thank you glad you brought that up because as educated I understand the importance of those spaces so we have been discussing them again this is just very the re the reason Wellness Center was put in into this because we repurposing space that was used for something else so now we have to do changes to that room that's the reason why I was in there um the mental health reason we called their Wellness Center is because you don't want to give it a stigma of a mental health room

115because then people aren't feel comfortable in that space so it's being looked at and we're going to be investing in every grade level secondary and primary uh primary and secondary to make sure the kids have supports but this is just utilizing this meeting because we're utilizing space that was for something else so there has to be a modification to the room so it's that's why we're doing the feedback in this meeting because we want to give people's inputs of things that could be important foress and if we don't start at the Young it's just going to escalate and as a parent my hardest job every day is to get off the social media you know and I'm thankful enough I live in the canal to go out and ride the bike old fashionly knock on

116the door and ask to play with kids that's my job that's my job so I feel like if we have those spes for kids can communicate and engage with each other that maybe that's that for step great thank you so much thank you and Daniel Street I'm not sure if I missed it but what was the bond amount that I know what composing we don't have an amount we're just talking ideas we're talking Concepts things we like to see in the upcoming Bond talking about why the timing is appropriate now just trying to give a context we spoke about it the last few years um saying that it would be great to start really thinking about this because the de service was going to be dropping off uh last year we had a number and

117then we decided to Shell the discussion we haven't come up with the total number yet this year we're still working on that and as we develop like I said over the next couple of months as we develop the ideas we'll put a cost figure and then we'll come up with the total but that hasn't been decided yet okay so the last time it was 8 million well it is is 8 million a year of debt service so what I can say what I've heard from the board so far is whatever kind of a bond issue we put up for a vote that would support a large Capital plans they do not want it to have any tax impact meaning that we at least have to be level to The Debt Service annually it's been about

1188 million years or lower where we actually can reduce taxes and still do some of the work that we're asking to do so that's the sort of broad Strokes framework that the board has said as we've discussed considering having a new big large scale Bond project was that they said they don't want any tax impact meaning it would not create any increase in taxes and what they're hoping is that it would actually allow for a decrease in the tax levy because the debt service that we pay on an annual basis would be lower than 8 million that we currently have so that's so far those are the only real marching orders that we've had in terms of broad outline from the board but we don't have a total yet okay so I I mean and

119I don't other than like my household budget personal but I don't how it seems almost backwards to me to to propose ideas without having like a general idea of how much you're working in it well as I said you know they said they don't want it to be any larger than the current debt service level of 8 million so we know what the ceiling is right we know what the ceiling is 8 million and that's The Debt Service the annual Debt Service that's that's how much we have to pay every year to repay the total amount so that's in the ceiling in terms of what the annual payment in our budget would be nothing more than the 8 million a year um Debt Service but in terms of coming up with it it helps to

120know like what the ceiling is because there so many different things that we can do in our district right so it's it's helpful to know that they just ceiling here and then how far or how close to that ceiling is Up For Debate so when we talk about the concepts you know whether we're talking about a Marine Science and Aquatic aculture lab or we're talking about a space for robotics or we're talking about you know doing something with a wrestling gym you know these are all ideas that we have up for debate to see okay what is important to the community to the board and how do we want to narrow it down because if we actually took all the great things that we'd like to do for our kids it would probably be higher

121than that but we know we don't want to do that so we have to narrow it down and we have to start making choices about what we to include um so we start to talk about priorities and ideas in terms of what we'd like to see then we start putting cost information down then it helps to refine this conversation and have it evolve further so like I said this every said this is the first step of introducing kind of what we're thinking about doing um for the future and again to get feedback from just as a point of reference I won't take any more of your time there certainly lot lot of your time when the original plan was approved 2009 when there was preparation for that when people administrators and general Administration made their

122wish list the wish list came over $200 million $350 million 3 hand we came up with this about 105 because kind of wanted to know just what the community could bear and we tried to prioritize as best we could so in terms of where we are now we are you know just listening to some of you U parents and community members you know in terms of what you're expressing concerning the bond some of those thoughts have been expressed by us there's no unanimity up here in terms of Wellness rooms or wrestling rooms or uh air conditioning or whatever it might might be T Fields those are things we have to kind of talk about so of Flesh up but to answer your question 2009 was over $300 million know C to 105 okay and when

123does that number get Nar down I just want to also remind everybody what I think Mr D said or somebody said this this is an AS irational plan this is this will go into effect in years to come this isn't today tomorrow this money isn't available and you know this is this is almost this is future planning this is Future Vision this throw everything out there at us we look at it you guys look at it you give us your feedback what we like what you don't like we are here to listen to your recommendations we make our recommendations and then a plan comes to play and the community votes on it we don't vote on it the community votes on it so I understand that everyone is very passionate about the East issue but

124I this issue is it's sort of separate and I understand how you all feel that maybe it's Lum together but it's a separate issue if that makes any sense and if it doesn't any anyone else from other public would like to speak on items from tonight's agenda yeah one more can't sorry she's apologize go ahead and at 6 East Street I'm I came down here because I saw I at Facebook and said that they want to cling school and they anyway every year since my passed away I grew up you know um my sister my parents had young children's store whatever ever since my dad passed away I been come down and uh they wanted to close School e school is a Jew it's a Jew my son is uh he's 39 he at stage

125but it's I don't know what we could have done live with my parents a year and a half and reasons but it was an absolute Jewel it is a jewel and it's very near dear to my heart I went there bil Chrystal went there my sister but you know like everybody want to and uh I I just can't see it go away just it's years [Music] old and um I just L my grandaughter six months ago and I just I wish my son would stay here you know would have gone to school at two Grands here you know in New Jersey and it's like how you go to cherill I mean one beach hello this one beacho everything and that's just my heart so [Music] I it's just thank you [Applause] m anyone else like

126to speak that hasn't um you can wait till the second part because move on there's one more well evening things hav [Music] changed my thoughts are one one and the need to get going on this is several of the speakers who spoke about how they believe there needs to be more information they believe that without information and involment that things will not work well they should it seems positive that you have money Accord to what you're saying Michael that you have the money but it's not in yet hatched what is important is that you bring the community together over next you wait months you made comment there might be more a year or two years and that not be very true but if you want to get community to support this you got to be

127involved when we do this exact same deal 9 years ago we really face the same challenges you're facing today one be school or one of the schools to make decisions on you can't be afraid to make that decision there needs to be a real discussion about curriculum and how the curriculum people you need to really address the issue of curriculum I would say that it would be a good idea for the board and the administra St to set aside a Saturday sometime in the spring the WEA a little better and bring everybody together in one of the schools or two of the schools and have a real discussion with the high school and the school middle school course and also like to say it's really wonderful that you going through this process it seems like

128demanding really right way to do it they have everybody on the same page going forward you're not on the same page it's going to be problems so thank you for your kindness to listen to me carefully I my name is Patrick G I live at 430 been there for a bun of years don't tell um but I I've been involved in the community in many ways I was a chief of lifeu for so years involved lot ofed projects along the way you need to get people to be involved and all you you A+ for being here L those thank you thanks [Applause] thank you Mr for all your years our community all the time volunteer all of your time thank you so much um with that being said uh moving on treasur support for November

1292024 approval ad minutes for executive session December 6 20124 in the executive session regular meeting of December 10th 2024 thank you can I seconds can I have any discussion Miss B yes Miss Conway yes DRC Ryan Miss p and I vote yes thank you uh moving on to the presentations by the superintendent thank you Mr Pino I'd ask the board to consider item one cicel motion is there a second second any discussion yes I just want to congratulate those people who names are on the docket for their years of service to thect District time they spent with the kids and for their contributions to their respective schools and to longes a community I particularly want to express my regret at seeing the name of Mr Myers the high school principal on this agenda he's been

130the high school principal post for 10 years and it was kind of like musical chairs finding a princial for that Building compared to time and his presence and his energy and his commitment to the district and to the kids should not go unnoticed saddens me that he's retiring he's retiring in good health and the requisite number of years so he'll receive a very generous pension from the state but I personally will miss him I just wanted to thank him for his contributions to the high school and through Long Beach Community thank anyone else um Yes actually I would like to thank all of our retirees for the years of dedication and I would also also like to Echo Dr Ryan's discussion about Mr Jeffrey he brought a wonderful atmosphere to our high school he was

131one of the best high school principls I think I've ever seen and I can't thank him enough for all that good that he's done for for our children and for how well he communicated with our parents he will be greatly missed but I wish him the best anyone else um part of keeping the disc discussion going I want to thank all retire he was one of my kid students she was an amazing educator everyone else on this list is great I would expect that Mr Myers would have been here tonight but I I would think he's literally doing high school work right now and I know that in his passion and dedication to the kids to the district one of the things he's always done is put the kids first and he sacrificed his personal

132benefit to help the kids and he's been a leader and a mentor for our kids and it's going to be big shoes to fill um sadly I know you know people retired it's part of a process where we we find new talent to help lead the building but I know that if he was here right now he' be getting a standing OB from everyone in the room but he's probably doing something for high school students appreciation because there's a few other events going on tonight uh so similar to the other board members the bitters uh I guess Bittersweet agenda item to to approve his retirement but I know that is in Goodwill and he's uh is just a great guy that was able to serve the district for so many years in such a strong

133and important position so with that Miss B how do you vote Conway yes DRC Ryan yes space yes and I vote yes thank you to all the Rees and all the Appo I'd ask the bo to consider item two non certificated Personnel Mo second any discussion B yes thank youan yes yes and I think we have a walk on resolution that we need to at this point for yes Fe resolved upon the recommendation of the superintendent of schools that the Board of Education hereby hereby appoints Susanna Fetti as District cler effective January 21st 2025 through June 30th 2025 motion 8 second any discussion I would just like to say um that M might be new in this decision but she's not new to the district and we're very happy to have her in this new

134job so welcome Miss Miss vot yes Conway yes Ry yes M PA yes I vote Yes welcome to the club i' like the to take 3 together um M did you want to say something about it three I did so the board has um written a letter concerning regionalization so proes there was a plan to regionalize with proes and we are going to opt out of it as a board because we feel that our stakeholders and ourselves would be able to make the best choices for our community it does not mean that we do not accept both's resources we still do this is just a way of us saying that we will be the ones with our stakeholders making the decisions for our community um after many webinars with thisa and with other neighboring districts

135okay pional letter and just before you read that Mr just to clarify it's not B it's the state requirement for us to participate in a rization process this in newspapers the state was not all that clear about what this is really going to mean so for now I think it's board feels that it's wise a letter going to assisant commissioner Frank of the Office of Education policy says Dear assistant commissioner Frank the L Board of Education understands the need for continued improvement in our education system School boards as locally elected representatives had Direct responsibility to the community they serve imperative are part of any discussion or decisions directly impact our district the lack of clarity around the proposal for re regionalization is a concern to us therefore W board of education is oping out the

136regionalization process as it currently stands thank you for attention on this matter sign to all members of the board I also want to thank Miss Conway I know she's a school teacher um she put a lot of effort and time into this and she really try to get as much U understanding of this whole process out and I just want to thank you for all her time that she she committed to helping for this decision thank you anyone comments on 3 through 3 through any other comments uh I want to make a comment I know that we're voting uh to approve of a deduct change order I just want to thank the business office and our our staff it's rare that we can actually have a lower cost change order on project so the diligence

137and the oversight of passive team is greatly appreciated and I just want to say thank you as well as for the exception of donation um we have a few donations from the Thomas eny Center of Center Point Church for a high school robotics donation from Zack bar of the rainbow research Corporation for high school Robotics and from Nat Alo as well for the high school robotics thank you for supporting the program these donations any other comments B how do you vote V yes Miss Conway yes bran yes P yes I vote yes thank you item nine is no action necessary it's a first reading of a new policy that is required by the state um regarding time out phal restraint items I would consider items 10 through 13 together and I would just like to

138point out that the amended policy on Public public comments at board meetings will shift our process to include having people fill out we're saying a card through the paper um to make public comment during board meetings with primary in for that and that'll begin in February was that people um rightfully objected to back with their because we brought a vide tap posted we're asking people to say their address that loud that will won be necessary you'll just give your name the address will be written on the card you can submit a card at any point during the meeting it's not designed to comments just really to so with that I B yesan PA yes I vote Yes um Board of Education any new or old business venting doc just uh I just wanted to uh

139wish you good luck Mrs Doan Mrs Williams you've been a very steady handed the district first office not easy to get us together in terms of coordinating meeting and scheduling and refreshments and coordinating these meetings and the video I personally will miss you and uh I wish you all good things on your new Venture so thank you very much my second point is two things were said three things were said during the closer discussion that sort of upset me the first was the inference or the statement was made that people up here don't care about children and I want to speak about my poor trustees here the sacrifice they've made in terms of meetings meetings and more meetings about a variety of issues through the district they paid tremendous sacrifices personal sacrifices in terms of

140professional and personal to undertake this responsibility for which there is no compensation other than the fact that they truly think they're helping this district and working to children so that statement was made it upset me and I wanted to publicly address it the second was yelling I don't remember anybody from here yelling at anybody at any of the speakers and that upset me as well and the third is just a point I'm going to make in summ summarizing my own position you people represent a very small segment of the community yes you're a school and yes you're a vibrant school and yes you're a passionate group but I when I was elected was elected by 35,000 people in this community from Point Lookout to East Atlantic Beach and they usted me to make the decisions

141that I thought were best for the entire community and I still believe that I think that's why they have me here I clearly do not agree with many of the constituents here but that's what we call democracy that's what we call free speech so I just wanted to say that because you're just a small micro when you say we're not listening to the community I listening to you as you may want me to be hearing you but I have a responsibility to listen to the 35,000 community members in this district and that's why I think I did thank you any other comments yes so I don't know if everyone remembers but a few months back we we don't know myday we've been talking a lot about the act the amount of accidents that are occurring

142on Greenway Road and Le Boulevard which is right by our high school now those accidents are occurring especially in the morning so I've been calling the fourth precinct DPW traffic department Long Beach Police Department everybody is willing to sit down and talk with me so finally thanks to l from myself and from some of our constituents many of our families have written letters I will be meeting with the fourth precinct on Thursday along with legislator meany a member from councilman Schneider's office and someone from the traffic department to discuss what we can do to help prevent the accidents or decrease the amount of accidents that are occurring on Greenway Road and Ne Boulevard so if any of you have any suggestions and you would like to let me know please you may email me or

143come speak with me after the meeting but this is a concern because we do want to help promote the safety of our students so we are looking at the signage of the streets and we are also looking at other ways to help protect all drivers thank you Miss Conway just to double up on that um thank you for spearing this on on behalf of the board obviously safety for our kids as they go to school Paramount to us um but just to clarify we don't have school involved accidents occurring that's not our major concern our major concern on this is individuals who are driving or commuting passing through the area where our kids are are are commuting to school on their bikes or walking so she's doing a great job now trying to try to

144create a safer environment for our kids to get to school so thank you so much for working on that well well thank you for clarifying it's not accidents that our students are having it's accidents that drivers are actually it's all kinds of drivers so thank you of the driver for any other comments thank you Mrs Conway for uh taking the time to address this issue and to meet with the local legislators to try to get some kind of positive response from them to protect our kids thank you thank you and I'll keep you all updated on what happens after Thursday's meeting oh Mr Deo will be also accompanying me that day so we can all discuss many different strategies that we can do so thank you Mr for taking that time okay any of the

145new world business from the board okay um so so the commit has been asking a lot about what's going on with with the issues um of of the elementary school in general um before you know people car characterize the board as saying you know we don't care about the kids um we don't we're Ed I just want to show support for the rest of the board doc doc was a school psychologist for many many years serving kids of all AG Elementary and he's dedicated himself to the board for many years I know that he had the best interest for all the kids and the community as a whole um it's not anyone's agenda to close something or take away from anyone uh we're we're literally grappling with trying to make it great uh the best

146possible decision under the circumstances that were provided um Miss Pace raised her kids in the district she was a step up on many many years advocating for kid from elementary all the way up and and special as kids here as well retired school teacher we're we're we understand a lot of the the frustrations and challenges that everyone here is going through um we're not we're not trying to dismiss anyone we're not trying to do anything to hurt anyone we're we're literally trying to digest the information that's presented to us and try to make the best possible decision that we could to to service the community as a whole this Conway R your kids in the district as well um and she's currently an elementary school student teacher so there's no one here that has any

147uh negative influence or hopes to to diminish or minimize our school experience for any of our elementary students my kids are in elementary school right now if you think that you know speaking from the perspective of a parent if you think myself or anyone else here has the intention of trying to diminish or to to hurt the school environment to to reduce productivity and the efficiency of their education that's not the case you know we had a situation occur uh with with funding options that were going to be taken away while you know the foundation a situation this year has already been pulled back we don't have a clear picture of what's going on with the future of state and federal funding it's just that's the realistic World we're living in right now so we

148commissioned a group an advisory committee we worked and I'm telling you if you think decisions are being done and made we have been debating and having active discourse and in perspective I of how we can best make a decision on this matter but yesterday the advisor committee met with the superintendent she's going to give a brief update and then we're we're going to give an update afterwards so um as mrce has said and you know I work with these people now for almost 10 years um they are trying to make a good decision and some of that means making sure that we have all information off sorry they're trying to make a good decision and sometimes that means making sure that we have all the information we need we wanted to convene the advisory committee

149the board of advisory committee uh we did convene them yesterday we updated them on where we are um as you all know I'm aware that we in July the board asked us to investigate potential alternate uses for the building we've been trying to do that for a few months we we reached out to at that time I asked if we could U hire an outside consult to do it mostly because it's difficult for us to do it we met with two Consultants we didn't feel a very good fit for the process um we decided to reach out to some of our local trusted educational Partners to see if there was interest we reached out to three different groups the commission for the Blind naso bosis and The JCC commission for the blinds out naso bosis

150and JCC there may be some interest there's no proposal yet there's no decision yet um it's possible they may want to rent part of the building all of the building again n none of that has been decided yet by the same token we have heard from from all of you from certainly the East School staff and from ourselves and and and for us that we we need to make this decision soon the Board needs to make this decision soon so tonight in executive session they have directed us to prepare you know a presid presentation for the next meeting and my understanding is that the board would like to make the decision at the next meeting is that correct So the plan is now is is we're going to take all the information that was presented

151we've brought the stakeholders involved we've listened the input we've had as I said discussion debate and discourse internally as well um we're going to take the information that's presented to us now what's been projected for the future um for the engagement of of students and we're going to have the superintendent present that to us and we're not going to have a vote but when we come into public we're going to decide um what we're going to do we're going to still have open dialogue in the public setting we're going to discuss things um and then we're going to make a decision because the truth is is that the stress and the uncertainty has created a greater toll on focusing than than on what we would do to focus to improve education for elementary level students

152and obviously the district as a whole so that's the plan for now is for next meeting um we're going to give another presentation and we're going to bring it up for discussion and vote and hopefully that helps um in the whole situation with everyone here but we're we're doing what you're asking right now we're going to make a decision um and I think it's it's going to be a challenge um but when we do it we're going to do it with the best input output and perspective that we can and and uh we'll take it for next meeting so I I'll just add something to that I'm usually not this quiet at meetings and I'm I'm sitting here and I'm I'm just kind of absorbing everything um and I appreciate all what my fellow trustees

153have said about me and about each other and I think you get the message that all of us are here only to do what's right and what's good for the community as a whole um but a couple things I wanted to address and and I feel is important to put out there is that the comments of lack of transparency or not being open um I think if we actually go back and look at where we were and where we are there were a lot of requests that the community made and I think largely the board did follow those we formed a committee we um had open dialogues um we did the survey we sent the survey out again um we've listened to all different community members and this has really been a year a year

154and a half I've lost track of time and I think it is at this point getting to a point where is and so answers do have to be made so in one breath the community is saying we need an answer but what we're trying to say to you as a board and I'm sitting here saying we're still grappling with that answer we're not comfortable 100% with all of the information so you know you can sit here and and I feel you know DRC Ryan said I think we've tried to be as respectful um I don't know sometimes if if you guys you know have we were getting a lot of the bashing and the yelling at us but we really are trying to listen and be fair and so we would ask you or I

155would ask you to do the same and as a caveat to that I've shared this before my own children I went through this with E and I went through this with my daughter who was an e school student in a special ed class who was the only class that would grewed from that school and put into Toledo that year and I bought that F too so I have one some I've lost and that's kind of how it goes um so we're asking you guys to be patient give us some time a little more time so I know you guys want the answers but you're not going to get them tonight um and I'm just gonna apologize right now in advance the next meeting I have a business meeting that I will be out of town

156and I won't be here so I'm just letting you all know right now I probably won't be here and we'll work through that at another time right comments All Right Moving On questions and comments from the public on anyome sorry please minutes main cor for people even if you agree or disagree with what they say try to respect their time and give opportunity for everyone to speak thank you hi you again first I would like to say as far as Mr I'm just I'm very sad that he's retiring but I'm have to say he's wonderful for the six years I had and both my kids you're really couldn't have asked for a better principal and you do have big shoes that being said my friend Miss Dolan on the end right there I have worked

157with missan when she was in the music arset department I have worked with Miss Doan while she was a Dr Galler and while Mr Myers will be missed that right is they shoose to F but on the same note I know for years and I think you did a really good job in picking that so I would just like to say congratulations to you Miss Dolan I will miss our conversations and I will miss these meetings with you Mr Myers I know you're watching nothing but love that being said is there any way I know this is a very difficult issue I'm on the advisory committee I understand how difficult this is is there any that you could give us Community like a date I put you on pressure to give us a deadline as

158far as to when we the I know miss you won't be her next meeting because you have a prior engagement but is there any way possibly even like before we go to February bre or there is that time when you feel as a board that the decision regarding EOL will be made so so the next scheduled meeting is what the 28th no decision is going to be made prior to the 28th no I understand that but that's the kind of schedu night of the meeting right but I'm saying is are you guys giving yourself as a board are you giving yourself a deadline as far as when you guys going to together come up with an answer to this question or is it just 2 I'll just clarify even though I won't be here well

159I'll be able to give my input okay I know that like this that if we don't have everybody agreement or sorry I should say that the full board will give their their feedback okay all right thank you very much hi my name is I question I wanted to start with a Satan first we came here my son and myself during C and he was in Zoom school when it came time to go to school he wanted to go to lindel because I walk there three blocks and there enough space but now you have space for a whole other school I think that that's a little bit crazy and unfair especially the parents that have limited resources when it comes to getting their kids to school and picking them up so I think it's just very

160interesting that you make room at your convenience um and then to my second one is to say um pretty much what the lady in front of you just asked so if you decide on the 28th you're saying we'll have decision basically the next day like is there a legal time frame that you have to let us know that the school is closing so the decision is going to be made in public okay so that whatever whatever decision is formalized at that point it's going to be discussed public so January 28th we will know February 28th we're sorry I apologize January 28th we will know the if that that's I we're going to be voting on situation yet so [Music] that's Bradway I know there's a lot of passion behind me that's not what I'm here

161for I'm not East um I also have no sentimentality towards any building I actually P my daughter out of her elementary school last year and she a new one this year so that's not where I'm coming from I am on The Advisory Board um I I think that all decisions especially big ones need to be based on data and logic that's where I am um I've been on the board I've gone to every single meeting I've attended the focus group literally done every single School TS Etc I personally don't have the information myself to make this decision I'm wondering if our Guru here mrito has pulled together some actual money data points that you have that we don't if you told me and maybe even some of the other people in this room we our

162taxes will go down by 75% if he closes for at least the next two decades that would sway certain people certainly I'm a parent and a tax tax if you tell me my taxes are going to stay the same we're going to close this there's going to be bigger school you know bigger School classes etc etc that also would change my decision so has Mr deito to you guys with some sort of data that actually shows if KCC takes 30% of p and the district uses 70% of each what financially difference are we actually looking at will the repairs be still coming out of District budget and we're really not looking at much of the difference so that's my question is do you have more data than we do um so I would say the

163advisory committee has been surprised with actually in some ways more information then the board members that aren't part of it I'm on no I understand so that's why we're still working with the current numbers you know that the governor gave the State of Affairs speech yesterday she didn't give the funding sources for um for the school budgets for the upcoming year we are still thinking about how would we work with potential um yes we have that data and we can share that you'll save money the board has seen some of that last year we have to update whenever we would sa this year but yeah we have all that there there's updates it's still evolving there's updates but what we're literally in agreement with you if there's a value proposition that makes more sense and

164we're going to you know Steer towards that but we we we're still working with all the information so yeah so some sort of production models will be sent out yeah abely great thank [Music] you thank you sweetheart thank you so much [Music] she thank [Applause] you hello um I'm fges 175 East Street uh I wanted to speak to three issues um first being reason that we given for post closure of the school the entire reason as we know is that the propos post closure was because of threats of cuts Foundation we had confirmation that there will be no Cuts so we still don't understand why we're having continuing to have these conversations um the second thing I wanted to do is highlight the experience of other districts that have closed over the years close schools

165over the years I know people like to say that these School parents are emotional yes of course we are um but we've also done a lot of research on this and I'm not just speaking as one person one preschool parent also on the advisory committee um so I can say that these are conversations that we' had with District leaders in the in other districts with um superintendent with teachers so one was Northport we spoke to a district leader they closed two schools due to decreasing enrollment and to save costs that they wanted to sell the L to developers and the town went crazy um now there's a large Housing Development nearby and they predict that there will be lots of students and they're going to have to reopen at least one of those schools this

166is an information that I'm baking up this is coming from people in those districts um Baldwin they Clos schools and it was better for their Community because they really had more schools than they needed I know someone with two kids in elementary schools involved in right now and she said their classes are still tiny they have like 14 15 kits in each box um but that wouldn't be the case in Long Beach we would be hitting our cat in all in most of our classes West T said we spoke to a district leader they also close a school so of course just like with Mom if we were supposed to do that there would be larger class sizes the result has been the creation of an environment for failure these are this is from a

167district leader in that District particularly for children who have English as a second language they're being left behind and we all know that Long Beach has a large population of students where English is not spoken in their house um and we SP to a former superintendent in seur and they close a school due to declining enrollment both usth rented the building for a while and eventually pulled out and the building sat empty there was bondism there was lering it was very unpleasant for the community they eventually had to sell building to a ler that's all to say that it's been demonstrated that shutting the school down just because it's cost doesn't mean it's always the next option the final issue I wanted to address is the lack of planning as we've heard you know a

168lot of people have questions about that or at least a lack of clarity in communicating any definite PLS to the Long Beach Community not just to e School parents but to Long Beach Community we've been told that the pl make a decision by the end going to by the end of the month we just said it's January 28th so just putting that into perspective that gives us nine days so nine days to determine space for how to find how to determine to find space for 334 students in three schools most of already full CES nine days inside how to teachers and stop because there's no Cy for those without ten years 9 days to make a decision on a building that will affect the way that people their field their neighborhood and 9 days to

169make a responsible decision that will affect the community for years to come I it is 9 days that's that's all for me thank [Applause] you h my name is I live 175 Street I in grade at East Elementary I want to tell you some things about my school I want East to stay open because to comfortable it is a safe place to be created you don't have to worry if you emotion my best friends go to school with me school I love being able to walk to my school it's really nice to do one it's so far to do that at any other school being at makes me happy because things and I know if there's ever a problem you'll take care of us and fix the problem [Applause] well it's clear from question and

170everything information Community feels I'm wondering to the board members question any of you before before next next next meeting are there any critical pieces of dat that you have not seen you think are essential to make UC responsible I'm asking because it seems from deern so so I wouldn't specifically say you know how you defining critical there are definitely very very important pieces of this puzzle that we're trying to connect to make the decision um it's not a simple decision it's not a decision for today only it's a decision um for next year the year after including uh projections for the future uh risks for the future all those things are being considered um it it doesn't help that there is uncertainty with federal and state funding even though it's not as much of a

171risk as it was before but those risks are still there um obviously the of this whole process came out when we we lost Foundation if that was the basis for us to to stick up to maintain our funding from the state but since then you know opinions came out information came out considerations came out so we're we're still in the middle uh of taking our current situation and also comparing that to the Future situations for good and for bad to see how the decision is going to be factored so we we didn't make a decision yet so I'll say I've had arguments with te that I've had arguments with friends that I've made new friends that I've made new enemies on this whole process we're still working through it um but in an effort to

172try to to give certainty to some point on this process we're going to have to move forward uh with making a decision of how the building or buildings or other parts of the district are going to be uiz so um we're we're going to ask the administrative team you know truth is is that they also are part of the driving force in making sound decisions because they're executing a lot of the decisions we're going to work and look at all the details and the tangibles and even considerations that we may not have already thought of and then we're going to fact those together to try to make the best possible decision from next next meeting I can speak for me what is very important to me and where I sat from day one and I

173continue to sit to the same spot that I do not want to see if building so for me that has always been top priority is what is happening with the building and what plans we can put in place so that is effective for the entire District so I wouldn't say that there's specific pieces of data that are lacking it's putting kind of like what Mr Pinto said it's taking all the information that we have part of that was also the committee meeting again part of that is what you guys are saying to us tonight and putting that all together but I can say for for me personally my number one priority is I don't want to look at an overgrown building with grass growing and and empty an empty lot and um people have said

174selling the building I know there was a woman earlier completely off the table I hope that the community understand that so that to me is part my priority also like Miss Pace former New School parent I would never want to see that building empty and know what it would do to that neighborhood I know how much of the neighborhood relies upon the building as a school that is a big priority for me um but there are many many moving pieces still that just we still haven't been put together in the puzzle so we want to make sure that we're going to present to you clearest picture okay um I just wanted to say I you know I don't want to sound like I'm echoing the other members of the board very important to me and

175for this community to not have an empty building I think we share that that's one thing that is consistent throughout our discussions we have lots of things that we're putting together we're trying to hold on to information and not share it with you we just want to present it in a way that is logical and comes from a place of the importance that we feel for the community and that's where I stand with this um I I don't live far from echool I walk past there almost daily um I love seeing the kids in the playground it's just again it's very important to me that the building be used for something that is community-minded thank you hi 125 I had a whole thing written but I'm just gonna read my questions off I guess should

176I read them all and then have you answer okay first question which I guess you could answer first is I know in the Board of Ed meeting in the summer the survey was supposed to go out again but I didn't never see it go out again was it sent out again it was it was sent out twice first in the summer then get the call one of the things we wanted to ask the committee last night is they found value and even try it one more time um the consensus was that we probably have a pretty good sense of where the community fall on this the people who didn't fill out the survey are primarily people who don't have children in the district um and yeah it's still up on the website do you have

177numbers on how many responded the second time because I know the first time it was like only 800 or something right another two or three 200 okay that that's a really small number so that's that's kind of upsetting um the other thing I wanted to ask is I know well actually let me just read the list um I know that bosis in the summer we were told I think by Mr Deo that they were not interested in the building at what point did they shift did they decide that they were interested okay okay um and then another one that I have is as far as the savings that we would have from closing e school is there any way that you could explain like like solid figures of what we would be saving and from

178where and where that money would go um something that I thought of actually my friend was was saying it before this is like I could sell my house I could sell my car I could sell all of my possessions and I would have a lot of money but then I wouldn't have a house or a car or clothes and that's sort of what it feels like with East like why do we need this money which I guess leads me to my next question which I know Mr Pino you mentioned that there's uncertainty with funding you keep saying it but everything that I keep hearing from a state level is that we have the funding for this year so if you could just explain a little bit more what that uncertainty is um and then my

179last question is for someone who had leased the building is there any number on how long the lease would be for would it be one year would it be five years would it be 30 years and would the district be paying to fix up the building before the lease or would they would we be including it where it's like they don't have to pay rent but we're updating the building for them like what does that look like as far as our cost in renting out the building so um you are correct the first time we reached out disos was actually this process last year when we were facing the $8 million cut foundation made over two years and at first they said no the reason they said no is that most of their special education

180programs are not Regional in the sense that you don't have enough students to do like a Northshore Southshore when we reached out again I guess in the fall actually early fall after to the summer they um reconsidered because they're having trouble getting approval for segregated special education set St not ining that at all anymore so they need to find a place where they will be able to co- house a special education setting with some kind of a general program it doesn't have to be a big one one class and we were always different possibilities with that whether it be 3K with there's a shortage of specially 3K on island that's why we started our own here hes also operate those programs or even high school we currently run our medical assisting program which is a

181bis program out of the Nik building we could easily ship that so that was why there was a little more openness to the conversation um and and they realized that maybe it's District Department that way that might Beal um in terms of savings we people will give you the exact amount next next but it's a it's at least two to2 and5 million of savings per year because we would operate more efficiently so by that I mean and I know that there's talking about bigger classes if we remain that our our current class CH is 23 most of our classrooms and most buildings if we remained to 2020 22 and distributed there would be 233 students graduate after fifth grade who need to be relocated next year um we could easily absorb them in the other

182buildings there are several buildings we could put three additional sections at each of the other buildings and in that way not have to increase class sizes Beyond 20222 which we think is a good health full size for elementary it's not too big it's not tiny when you're talking about class 15 um which is what we have in some cases that that's tiny especially if kids are absent especially if you know there's two teachers in room this is true with their I we can't write programs that wal was mentioned before wal has deliberately small K1 classes but they go up to 20 21 22 and the old grade actually bigger than them we have all those we have the average class size cudney can show you that as um uncertainty of funding before you go on

183sorry but where does that two and a half million go like does it go to it could wellness centers like I want to know if if we're losing a school I want to know where that money is being relocated so our taxes if we zow with a higher tax they could go so that's milon but what is that per person like I I just I want people to see like is it $5 in everyone's pocket work that up a little bit but it's a little harder to do than you think because your tax value has everyone's home has a slightly different tax value so we can do like an average and we work those numbers up yeah because I think it would be really helpful to see that because if it's a significant amount I

184think people would be more okay with it but if it's like $5 a person then maybe not worth it so just to answer your question that was faced towards me um 13 funding so just because uh this year the governor changed her course on changing the foundation aid dispersements for us it it doesn't mean that future years the projections are to change they're actually still thinking that there's going to be a POS a significant possibility of reductions in state aid and also the state of the federal funding for schools can impact us as well so that's why we're not looking at this year as this one year head we're not planning on repurposing or creating a major disruption for one year of change but where who is saying that like is it where is that

185coming from that came from the Rockefeller Foundation study that the governor commissioned completed just December any formula any changing formula means a reduction in F I think the good news is it may be pushed back and Ted in over several years but we are facing almost 99% facing reductions in funding on the state level and with the federal level now changing in terms of focus of the Department of educ federal funding as well so if you ask me honestly if I think our Revenue over the next five or 10 years would be stable I would have to say no I don't think so we're designed to investment to the next um and then the last part the lease terms so again that's negotiated with the tenant I know that Northport just rented the two buildings

186that they have closed one they rented to variety preschool because again they're looking to expand their uh special education preschool services stuff account that was a 15E lease I think and there um it's like all inclusive the district is responsible for nothing pretty much they R to the other building to Western sou B only a portion of the building and it's a year year lease and there are different terms there like they're I think paying they're norp custodians but both pays for it so all of that has to be worked out when you negotiate with the tenant what terms but if let's say they pull out like let's say they're on a 5year lease and they don't renew what happens to East is that does it then get sold does it then sit empty because

187it seems like it was kind somewhat difficult to find a tenant it's it's uncorrect that's not correct let me just say we started with like a soft out we didn't want to hire a broker and go through that whole process we started with all right let's see what's out there with partners that we do would be partners um if we if they did not come through or if in five years we rent five years they don't need it anymore we would have the ability to go out finden again and I don't actually think be that hard to find I think that you know is a pretty vibrant there programs there are you know the bridgew building seems to be always full and that's kind of a general useful I think there would be many places

188that would be around here the benefit to keeping the building in the district honestly is if we did ever have a situation with the population back up again we would be able to look at you know reopen want or reconing and sorry one last thing as far as getting it up to speed to rent it out is there like a long time period that it would take to get it ready I can tell you thatas is very okay thank you I mean it's old building but maintain has an elevator and ramp in the back air conditioning in your so would it take a long time no I don't think thank you thank you Mor alado 613 Monroe Boulevard I have like six questions um more or less yes or no so we can go home

189um does the board and the admin have a clear concise plan for the closure of each School say plan a plan B plan C right nowor ask questions or you want well if you say yes to one I won't ask the other you know what I mean so no like is there a clear plan on paper right right now for E school's repurpose I feel like you've said no the whole night so so thank you um this one's important to me as the budget stands right now for this year and next is eSchool being open causing the cutting of other programs it's not a trick question I just want everyone listening to hear since echool is open are other things being cut I'm just saying it because it was mentioned on the call recently no

190I do not believe but I I have to Cave that we do not yet know what our state no I know I mean this the 2024 25 school year is anyone crying because East is open and they're losing something El no people were crying about something being cut nothing to do with it thank you um if the building remains open and repurposed for Bose lar JCC all the above oh you said you would give us a call SA I'm sorry seie and I wrote together so we have lot the same questions um if Miss pace you're not going to be here on the 28th how are we going to get what if we have a two to two vote you could absolutely anyit angry does the plan the board and admin have a clearcut on

191paper plan for where the students will go how many will go and how many staff and faculty will move to each building yes but it's based on giving parents choices and parents will have their first choice not first but first you never get first you all it'll be similar to how we do for P for prek starting of the year okay um so again like Ashley said in nine business days we expect to have this lots of people don't want a vacant building in nine days we're apparently going to know and have a promise in a lease that tenants would improve how many years it wouldn't be vacant for we won't have that so we won't know if it's going to be vacant or not in nine days it won't be vacant but I doubt

192that be can you promise it won't be vacant yes yes okay that's great um just to close like cost isn't only financial I know you know this but there's cost of effort there's cost of time and there's cost of emotion and we've all been through it and I know you have to but you ran for this seat and we did not and we are [Applause] over hi back hear 269 Neptune Boulevard um a lot of folks have been talking about data and database analysis I want to REM my thoughts analysis on the student population study done by and Associates um and of course offer help and decisions made this week are n Days by way of background I have an engineering degree in appli management statistics I started Myer in mro trading studies population growth

193investment decisions then spend time machine learning algorithms ass com terrorism and trafficking and SP time researching believe on qualifi to make this analysis population studies the board and hope you'll be receptive to my feedback the next two and a half minutes um I have two main takeaways from the reading the report first the math this is the mark um and second the subjective conclusions by the author come comes to at the end of the study false uh so the first point the author uses extremely basic forms of mathematical analysis it fails to meet any criteria for statistical significance lacking statistical significance for those that remember High School statistics class um means that you do not have the ability to draw objective conclusions from your data rather your analysis becomes subjective or simply your opinion on

194the math used to arrive at that subjective opinion there are a few things to call out most importantly there's least one simple arithmetic error in the districtwide this wide enrollment history table the auor did not do division properly and the organization failed to abely Pro read and qual control work the Au then goes on to mean said medium sking the study based on outlines not best practices in mathematical analysis they compare different durations of time periods also not best practice they fail to compare the trends and stud population Dynamics aging and Rejuvenation or other school districts as a mean comparison they do not inflation adjust the hous comparative they not use a Time weighted average or set another weight Rec population activity heavier than they did not do a survey of preschool numbers in the

195area to assess population growth from people moving District only looked at the birth rate and I'm sure there's others but I hope I at the point that the quality of the is low once again I reiterate that the author made on the second point the subjective opinion conclusion that quote there is no reason to believe the downward Trend will not continue referencing the school population is incorrect there are certainly reasons to believe that the trend will reverse first and most simply the kindergarten class SI increasing here here this trend continues obviously School popular second there's a likelihood that that increase in kindergarten class size will increase especially for as little skare program has experienced in approximately 20 seconds thank um experienced in approximately 42% increase in class size since 2018 and a approximately 75% increase

196since the end of Cl additionally zooming out from the student fater programs of Nursery School in kindergarten population decrease is projected to occur in later grades we do a linear regression analysis of the K to8 median growth rate you end up with a prediction of an increase of 31 students per year not necessarily a decrease now statistics can always be argued but the statement of there is no reason to believe the downward Trend will not continue is very obvious and false I really these two points of for math an incorrect objective conclusion about to tell you how to do job uh my expertise is in statistics while you're running School District however using this report as a means that concretely said that the student population is decreasing and will continue decreasing is intellectually dis honest

197you cannot do it with a straight face and we should be angry that we spent taxpayer money pay for this level of work I'm happy to work on the next iteration with you all over the next nine days en join any discussions I hope I have some had there thank you for listening and if you can ask one question I just love to hear your thoughts on this report and how it plays into do you have a of your analysis uh I can provide I just came the notes okay but lot thank [Applause] you Jessica Johnson 558 Lindell bouard um I am not an East parent um I'm a West parent I've been an educator for 20 years um a taxpayer and homeowner I'm here to show support for these parents but I wanted to

198address something that DRC Ryan said that I disagree with um you said that this is a small small part of the community or right represent a small part of the community microcosm the both of parents I know are not for this I know no parents East parents West parents Lindell parents Leo parents who think it's a good idea to close East and have all the other schools absorb those students those parents are not here because it's 10:00 and they're probably putting their kids to bed um and the East parents are most affected by this so they are willing to make that sacrifice come month after month these meetings um but to make that statement that it's a small section of the community I think is false um because there's a lot of parents and families

199in this community who are against this parents have spoken to me who are in support of this maybe we represent different parts of the community I didn't make that statement off the top of my head it was based on conversation right interaction with many members where are they I wouldn't dare tell you the Nam of the public session thank you um just to follow up on that I mean thank you for the response but I'm a parent who speaks to parents every day think I qualify to are I would encourage you if those parents are out there to tell them to send us an email because I mean we've receiv received many emails on both sides but if there's more thank you hi my name is Sophia vas I live at 360 East Park um

200I just have uh kind of a suggestion just in case you vote to closes um I hope you don't but um to ensure Equity across the district I urge you to consider a fair and transparent process should the school be specifically I recommend that the district require All Families to reapply to schools rather than limiting the application process to to those directly impacted by the closure of these while sibling placement should be prioritized to keep families together if more students apply to a particular school then it can accommodate possibly a lottery system should be implemented to determine the placement this approach would provide all families with an equal opportunity to access their preferred School rather than simply pleasing East School students in any school that has space for them I've heard I've often heard parents

201here at these board meetings say that children are resilient and will adapt if that is the case those same par should be willing to accept that their own children might also need to adapt if they do not get their first choice School under this new Equitable system closing a school impacts the entire Community not just the family's current World in East therefore it's critical that all parents across the district are informed and have an opportunity to prepare for the possibility of reapplying for schools so I just have a couple questions so my question for the board is is this a plan that could realistically be implemented if school if East school work to close and my last one is before the final decision is made in two weeks um would all the families across the

202district to be notified in advance that they may need to reapply for school placements and that there's no guarantee of receiving their first choice just if this is an option so we'll definitely take consideration but there's no way for us to say yes that right now but we'll take definely take it into consideration I appreciate the idea I mean it's just it seems more fair that it's not just the 270 students at least that should take on that respons possibility of having your school close and being you know shoved into other schools thank you s 65 car street thank you all for your time I've heard three or four times tonight that we don't want an empty building we want the building used for whatever resources could be used has been mentioned a few times

203so it sounds to me that some of these parents most of these parents and staff that's here sounds like your mind is made up and you're just making sure you all have all your DS in a row to make that final decision sounds to me that on February 28th that decision going to be made to school January sorry so it sounds to me that on January 28th that the decisions already been made that the vote is be made Clos second I heard in the presentation that they want put Turf between the library and the auditorium the middle school did I hear that correctly that's part of the presentation why why we put money in the budget to put T there proposing to close the school I have no problem with the wrestling gym I have

204no problem with the bonus Center scale down I have no problem with cafeteria Renovations that's high but if we're going to put money to put Turf over half of that area with the proposal of closing the school that to me did not make any sense well just to respond quickly it's not a very large sum of money I think it's about $35,000 to do that type of work U also it's a request that's been made by the Middle School administration based on the condition of the surface and grass can't grow it becomes dirt it becomes mud um and they feel that it really would improve the quality of life of the middle school student to have that in a different condition um that's basically so the administration at least came to tomorrow and said he

205why can't we take that $35,000 and put into East to start making improvements and Renovations keep the building open to keep our community together would that be put I think that when we start talking about the specifics um and just broad Strokes there is to to different things at the building at the school so it's not that when the current broad Str planed tonight doesn't include any funding um there is funding for thoughts about funding projects at these school so it's not an an invite understand that whatever the discussion is and whatever the decision may be about purposing e school um it's somewhat separate from what the district need to do to keep the building in in a a state of repair so there are items that we considering for each school about different things

206so I don't want you to think that they don't think that's be dedicated to the school because that's not the case I know ask one more question ask so we'll talk about purposing the building why are we going to ask our students our elementary students to leave the building just to be for other District doesn't make a whole L sense thank thank you um thank you for committing to send out model um can you please commit to send this out to the community with enough time for us to review it before the meeting I think that help us conversation a little bit better and ground exist I'd like to know if anybody research the cost to a tear down and reild the school that looks like aages acoss Island as you're thinking about alternative considerations

207and then three um you please confirm that I heard correctly that you're considering keeping um school open but renting a portion of the building um came to mind was the opportunity to pre School model I think that's very interesting and beneficial for all children that could be involved um that's there's a lot of around develop students to have model of children with special needs uh and it's very beneficial for for children with special needs I'm also a favor of inviting candidly like Community organizations if there's an opportunity to integrate that in the school to create a community schools model that's really fantastic I just want to make sure did I hear that correctly considering that as well tear down and rebuild no if we could that would be very helpful I think it would be

208interesting uh and umly the options yes thank you good evening I'll be brief uh a quick suggestion for the 28 is that you know you're going to have a full house here for the next location Mr Deo prepar the same information that started this whole mission perhaps maybe discuss the things that the committee had discussed over the summer replacement of what rooms are available and so forth and so on also I have a a real question about why you would set a vat for a day when you know that one of the board members will not be pres I think you owe it to the community have the meeting and let's let's put an end to this thing instead of kicking it down the road but then have a vote with five board members because

209I think you owe to the community that everybody knows how you voted on this I think that's the fairest thing you could possibly do because we don't want to hear what suggestions are or how you feel we want to know how you vote I think that's important to everybody so that in mind I would hope that you keep the vote on till February but have the discussion and Mr make one more presentation and give us all the facts just to refresh everybody's mind because I'm sure you're going to have a lot of people here that have never been involved in the whole process that want that might want that thank you that's a good point thank you your name and address please James link 16 may walk 445 East ol Street um I just want

210to comment that those AI pictures set me off and I understand the planning so I my first initial feedback I just would like to take back but I just also want to say that I have been here for all of the meetings I've been on The Advisory board meeting and I feel like I'm in the same exact spot that I was in January this like same year I know you're shaping your head Alexis but no you're not because the we sent out a survey to to people 900 people responded I asked what else can we do can we have focus groups can we survey those people from the community that we didn't capture in the survey to get their opinion besides being friends with Dr like can we get more information you're talking about a

211$2 million savings I looked at the Northport plan and Ashley had brought it up and a couple people have mentioned it the savings that they said was $7 million projected in the first year after closing those schools you saw right and then you can see that their taxes did not go down they have increased a year over year so much that their their Community is Raging it is a mess there and in their face Facebook group and it's the disaster and I know that Dr R said that this is a microcosm but it is not we are people we are children I involved in this community and I support om I support every single program in this entire Community to make a statement like that is is really upsetting and apping to the staff that

212are here the staff that give every day waking minute to bring kids into the E School stand outside hold them watch them cry help them when they lost their sibling I don't understand I've only seen you at e school at graduations I don't think you understand and concerts I would like for you to walk into that building and see the culture that they have built I work at a company and we pay millions of dollars to build a culture and a community that we have built at each school and that is priceless and I'm sorry I'm getting upset and I have a couple questions that I ask what the advis meeting how can you make a decision in nine business days when you don't understand or don't have a lease signed and you can't confirm

213that the building will be in use September 6 or whatever they start they said to you at the meeting that's right we won't have a Le sign we can't we won't have a Le sign till the spring and I think what we're hearing from people is we need a decision what we can guarantee is that in some way District would use part of the building or you know whatever part of the building for a district program we can guarantee right but Dr Geller we it has been a year and we have not seen a plan a transition plan a a lease plan a savings plan I think part of it so it's not to say we haven't been working on things behind the scenes but understand that we also get criticized people are protesting as

214boes is walking in because anything that we do isum to be a poor decision so sharing plans with the community you heard people tonight says decisions already made it hasn't we're trying to I would love to believe you I would love to believe you but I know the decision I know you've made that decision I can sent it on your faces Alexis even said and I maybe it was a switch you said there won't be a two to one vote I don't know what that means but like I can see it on your faces like I think you I what I meant and I was wrong I thought that I was able to AB like I was able to write something how how I would vote but I'm not I'm not able to do that

215I thought I was going to be able to vote if I'm not here so that's I hope that CL that does clarify and I know my time is up but like I have a million questions and I would love to sit down with you and ask them all and if you could show me the real savings backed up with research and data that it big sense to displace a part of our community that has been Central for 100 years and DRC Ryan I will email you long each City Facebook post where hundreds of people from the community not each school have commented not close a school it should be the last resort and it doesn't feel like we're at that stage in the budget and that's all I have to say thank you I my

216head and you said I feel like in the same place you're not because we have you are not you've done an amazing job you're an amazing Advocate and I admire you tremendously and I admire everybody that gets up at Steeps because you're passionate and that's awesome so you're all not the safe as we were a year ago because we've gotten information throughout that period of time as you have so that's why I was saying no we are not in the safe place because we've come very far but to to say that we have decision made already we simply don't and I don't know what else to say to you we've all said it um and you know now the pressure is on to make that decision but then we have other community members voicing their

217opinion that the vote shouldn't be made if I'm not here which is a valid point but that delays it again until February which is what we didn't want to do because I physically can't be here time so that's something will work out um but I appreciate you I appreciate your comments and they are they are and I think Alexis can speak from a point of endearment on this because when there was issues with the school in the past I wasn't around active back then but Alexis was active Annie was active but they were literally were were you and you know so they they used that as their Paradigm of the entire value composition that we're trying to figure out now it's all being considered so say that they they sympathize with you they they do

218because they were in a similar position exactly what you're and the passion that you have they had and they're taking that history and that passion into their decisions now as well so you got to keep that in mind too it's not like being pass they're they're taking that whole picture together so just keep that in mind help thank you and I I hate hating you guys and I hate coming up here and I don't like to sit I think it is unnecessary it is not necessary to close a school and we have funding we don't know I these uncertainties but like we don't know and I love West School be my first choice at these schools we don't know if a hering's going to hit next September and wipe it out where are those there's

219a lot of unknown we can't yes we can't make those assumptions and these T that we're we're going the last thing that we want to do is build a fragile model keep that in mind that's part of our consideration to build a fragile model for a shortterm gain or something we're considering that and that's not part of what we want to Envision in the whole process can I please be a part of can I meet with you can I look at it can I see what you're looking at maybe I'll call you I really want to see what you're looking at I want to be able to comat it just information of that back to school night in the fall in the playground had a wonderful evening and you'll find me at ballom dancing I

220and I appreciate when you say things like you're just a microcosm and you're small part of the community we're not we are the community so like that really is frustrating and like we're there were about 600 parents and 818 people voted for you so let's let's be real come on I like can't take it everybody else is so productive and so respective and you continue to just be this take this stance you're not even openminded not AG with you I'm Notre with you with Mr gra you haven't changed your mind either because I haven't [Music] seen yes I have a couple questions particularly to take you back what Mr said about one do we know of the are happen all right so with that being said when it comes to curriculum comes couple of the

221projects that you're moving forward with that curriculum will be changing so some of these projects seem a little I'm dealing with that now CTI this is a it's a great model it is it's important but the business model in that regard is why there are a few other options besides like when it comes to Ai and other curriculum that our young people will have to figure out in the next 10 15 years so thinking about that and thinking about maybe saving some other things in our community we can't keep ourselves in a box so to speak when it comes to this because we've been spending money on top of money fixing thec that we're not ready and I think that's very important to kind of allow the community to understand because this change will happen

222and yes there's going to be a lot of changes in the next four years when it comes to funding not only to our community but to New York State and I think we need to be very much transparent about that to everybody you know actually I've been working since the beginning of the week on a letter that I'm going to send to families outling the graduation retirment changes which we have been discussing for months and um we actually just wrote and got a grant to Pilot kigo for our middle school and high school students which is a great um AI tutor really for kids and we've been trying to wrestle with what is say for us as District sure you are as well how we teach our kids to use it ethically um it's going

223to affect every every single career maybe the knowledge industry more than any others and you know we we've been told to superintendent you people are going to be the enemies of your own success because you're going to be the last to adopt it so we are resing with all this and that's part of the reason we wanted to investing in space change is because we're GNA be able to customize again it's High School curriculum that's changing high school education we 25 years it's element what Mr G we have to prepare for curriculum and not spend bad money after bad money on things that don't work believe me that's my passion um I would much rather be talking about that this a lot of a lot of absolutely a lot of the changes that are coming

224through now from nework State actually mimic what we've been trying to project project in the profile of our graduates in general and those those don't actually start in high school even though that's when they're they're integrated they're we're trying to literally in the best of the New York State Frameworks which are now changing is increase success in life and the classroom models are going to transition and that's why we're trying to create that environment so like cyber security and all these other things that AI be taking over we get it and those are going to be fields that we're going to have to prepare our children to be successful in it we're definitely on the same page and pige holding ourselves by taking something away from young people won't help and we have to be

225careful like taking this physical space away making some other St small appreciate thank [Applause] else yeah Mr G give you as a former board president you have the privilege I wanted to say de at the end of discuss com out concern whe V decision whatever I know back when I was involved in the same identical situation it's not different and the final vote by the way that that decision was a 32 vote to keep the school as is 32 vote to keep to school as is but they were they were very worried about at that time the people that would to vote the three three and doc I know you were here for some of that discussion doc were here some of that discussion so you would remember that was a last effort to change

226the vote by making the E school um go through a a process I don't think it's okay there is um three to vote was really a tough vote for people was the three who got the decision to keep e School the way it was or the two people that thought that they should close the school down the last minute suggestion remember last suggest I offer was to go ahead and make the uh the school a u no them all to the complex whichever they seem to be very excited like complex wasn't very popular back then but popular now so what you put yourself into is a tough decision the bo you got people thinking you made your decision which I I haven't been there I don't think you have I think you really you're really

227facing a tough situation and I'll tell you you've got to get your act together the that's meeting that meeting on the 26 is it8 28 that that that meeting you you got to really be you're going to have a lot of people here and they're going to be expecting something to happen I I think it maybe that was a good decision to do that might be better to have the meeting on 28 and then have another meeting after what you do this again I don't think so so what I'm saying in summary is this I think the bo is looking at this issue home and husband wife they come out with aing and will CA some you votes one way or the other that's not why you're making your decision I hope that make a

228decision because it's education the right thing to do the community and you don't want to affect children all you still that you believe but you're not hurt children so you really have to you got a tough road so I say get get prepared between now and 28 be ready to make your presentation the thing that I think you missed out on a meeting somewhere in the middle where people thinking that I think the people that are here probably think that it's a am I right about that you don't think it's it's an open conversation I got it well that's what you guys got to address you with I will say this made before is that the decision is G have a tremendous Legacy what are we say no I was just going to say that

229unfortunately and I you know I respect I know I know that DRC Brian's position has been hard on some people here but at least he's confirm and he said the same thing all along and he has a strong opinion I think what's difficult for us as a board is any information we have presented to the echool families we are told we're wrong it's not correct the math is wrong we're not being transparent we've already made up our mind and it's you know it's ineffective so what's very frustrating for us as a board is that we're trying to share information but at every step of the way we are also met with resistance as well so I appreciate your comments and I agree with you we need to move forward quick right no difficult decision for

230school boys and this decision in front of usool and I know that one of the board members and IED back that ever noworder name but that ER she was one of supporters of the three I was on the Lu my last goal one I said to you before you got to be prepared if you're going to go with what you think right you got be prepared for all these subies and come decision thaty is what transition building all respect your time is up like everybody else thank you very much good luck everybody and people have been saying it tonight too we We Are One community and at times we understand you're taking out your frustrations at us you have to understand we're here to work together with you it's not a he said she says

231we all want the same thing we all want what's best for our kids and let's do it in True Long Beach Fashion let's work together let's work through our compromise andiz that use our democracy and we will come to a conclusion that will benefit our community oh so we want to I honestly I want to thank you guys for your patience it's 10:30 tonight I know how late it is and I know you call have a lot we to do more we all have to go to work but um right it just know we're all here together any other thank you we didn't want you to go Mrs do without a really big yeah thanks you're with us um any other questions or from seeing none moving on thank you so much Long Beach classroom

232Teachers [Music] Association okay Karen lcca first I'd like to congratulate all those on the agenda for retirement tonight thank you so much for all of your years of service to our district I would also like to welcome the new speakers being hired as well as MERS being appointed this evening we would also like to welcome our new members to the long F Association we are excited to announce that occupational and physical therapists are now members of our unit thank you Dr and theard for helping us this I'd also like to take a minute to thank Dr Galler for meeting last week to start discussions regarding the possible repurposing of peace and what that really means for our students back the in St um however I do feel it is necessary just to make sure as

233St here tonight that we really do consider everything before stud some of these questions are and concerns and many of these heard already but things that we just want to make sure of how many sections in how many students in each building how will the class sizes increase dramatically will they be similar will we lose staff at all regular Ed special ed special area will students receive those time in specials will they have all the same Services have we looked at Rooms make sure we could accommodate all this and I know some of this were hearing tonight so again have we checked to make sure that everything with air quality health and safety of each area isn't good standing before we move all our students into them have we coordinated with administrators to make sure

234all these plans work in each buildings do we have a plan for extra administrators will we have enough cafeteria time space to comate the large numbers in the buildings what will be the true savings be what will the cost be to keep it up how much will we save what programs can we add how will students benefit from closing and what specifically will we repurpose this score and I know this is a huge undertaking for you guys um as you may know our lvcta mission statement is to unify and TR the professional teaching staff for the purposes of approving the terms and conditions of teachers employment and to advance the quality of Education in the Long Beach Public Schools my main concern is that we're just not reducing the quity of education for our students

235or worsening the conditions that both staff and students replac them if the decision is made to repurpose the building I look forward to our continued discussions to address all of the concerns that have been raised tonight thank thank you uh grp B good evening Happ first of all congratulations to all the dist employees who are retiring especially Lor Dolan Barbara vas bab the middle school high school thank you for years of service thank you see nothing uh [Music] P Lori thank you for everything you do these meetings every two weeks are all set up by you all of our calls and helps every transition to a new president across the district you retrain you retach us you help us you guide us we are going to miss you and wish you the best of Lu

236thank you [Applause] thank you everyone motion to adjourn motion [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.