001e e e can I begin Mr Brer thank you sir welcome to the January 22nd Work session limber Board of Education if we could all please rise for the pledge of the flag Mr pesi stes roll call all present we did just have a meeting with the Joint Council of ptas very productive meeting um always grateful to have that time with them to hear their insights and to share thoughts back and forth we have two presentations tonight Dr Bas will outline the program updates and sus man director of special services will discuss special education services but first I will turn over to Dr Lynch to discuss the fiscal Outlook thank you Mr billmont uh so welcome to the uh January 22nd Work session of the board of education so just to understand what the purpose
002of tonight is is on March the 3 Mr press will be presenting the 2526 budget but before we get to the point of talking about the dollars and cents this is the night that we talk about what we see as the programmatic out out come of next year what will be the priorities when it comes to curriculum and instruction and what things uh the budget will be supporting uh so uh the two things tonight Dr Bas will be talking about some uh uh changes to the to the academic program and Mrs Sabin will be talking about the Continuum of uh Education Services but before we get to that uh those of you who have been following these board meetings and really have been following the last four years of board meetings know that we've been
003talking about something called the fiscal cliff the reason we've been talking about a fiscal cliff is because when we came out of covid uh besides the federal money that was given to us uh state aid had reached astronomical proportions because they basically owed us a lot of money for the last 10 years and they made us whole for the last two years before last year so that was a huge influx of money and uh we did programmatic things with that money and what eventually happens and to take you back to the September 25th meeting Mr press presented an increase in costs in Social and emotional and Mental Health Services an increase in special education an increase in security and an increase in transportation so all of that remains true and we come to this point
004where now we have to talk about what the programmatic PRI priorities are for next year so I think the board Bo was very clear a few months ago that the programmatic priority is the implementation of the profile of the owl so this community had an an exhaustive process where we reached out and determined what was the most important things what do we want The lindbrook Graduate to know be able to do and be like and we heard on that screen what those things are this programmatic changes are going to reflect that there going to be the profile of the owl in action at the same time we know that at that same September 25th meeting Dr bcus had reported on the changes from the Blue Ribbon commission which were going to be changes in graduation
005requirements so our job is to kind of make the profile of the owl and that blue ribbon commission become one reality that is what we're going to do on the other hand you have also heard us talk about this impending fiscal cliff so to talk about some of the things that were I I can even say good news that came out of Albany yesterday so we were very we were very worried about how this Rockefeller report how the changes to Foundation Aid were going to be received uh so the governor's budget uh does include a significant increase in Foundation aid for this District that is because something that I had talked about and all of us had been talking to our legislators about came true the lwh hanging fruit coming out of the Rockefeller report
006something that could be relatively easy to implement was they were using poverty data from the year 2000 to fund this district for those of you that were here in the year 2000 you know that poverty in this district is not even close to where it was in the year 2000 so they adopted a new poverty metric that that actually kind of writes that ship and they're now using a three-year average of our actual economically disadvantaged children for the last three years surprise surprise that equals a million more dollars in Aid and that's the good news because that actually is is is kind of accounting for that uh there are some other things I wish they had addressed uh we thank them for whatever income we can get and that certainly goes a long way I
007have to say that gave us a sigh of when we saw some of those numbers and chances are if we keep uh pressing our legislators maybe even more money will be added to that uh Foundation aid but let's talk about some of the other things that they have not addressed that are really driving the costs of this District so I am proud to say for the last uh well 10 years but more specifically the last five years we have invested heavily in having lindbrook students educated in lindbrook schools we want all students to be educated in a lindbrook school and therefore we created programs that accommodate the least restrictive environment for those children so we now have established new small classes so that we do not need children to go to outside placements but that
008we can keep them home and we're very proud of those programs but at the same time those are very expensive programs because they involve a lot of adults in the the room because it's the right thing to do for children so what I wish would have been in the state aid formula is a better benefit to reward districts for doing the right things by children uh we ran some numbers yesterday and uh just to let you know where does state aid begin for those programs we must spend $70,000 of your money before the state even starts to Aid Us on kids that we're keeping in the district $70,000 is a lot of money on a particular kid so that we only get you know so let's say there's a teacher in the room a couple
009of AIDS in the room and a behaviorist in the aid in the room we divide that by the number of kids and each of those kids has to be worth more than $70,000 let's say they get to $80,000 we're only aided on that $10,000 that's got to change that is not a good way to reward districts for doing the right thing the exact counter argument is made when we looked and I'm not saying we're doing this this was an academic exercise gee if we sent them to a private placement if we put them on a bus and transported them to a private school what would our Aid amount be we then get aided on everything over and above 20 $3,000 does that seem backwards to you so a district that has invested and you'll look
010at the numbers that Mr press put on that screen back in September a district that invested in these programs doing and I will anyone who has seen me in those classrooms know I love these children to death those that are doing the right thing by these children are economically punished for keeping them home rather than for outsourcing those kids that's one thing we need to change and I think I could just see by people's faces that that kind of makes sense to you another thing that is not even anywhere present we will be the first to admit to you we use some of those excess funds to start a security Force none existed and now we have retired law enforcement guarding your children nowhere in the funding formula is that expense matched in an era
011when protecting children becomes the most important thing in the world to and we're doing it why is there not commensurate Aid to keep up with that I asked that question to the state and I would encourage you to ask that question to the state we are also proud of every dollar we have invested in the social emotional learning and the mental health of your children we have the best P per pupil ratio to social worker and psychologist and guidance counselor in Nassau County that is the right thing to do for your children we are not properly funded even a dime for any of that so you tell me where are the state of New York's priorities thank you very much for the extra million dollars I thank you very much for that million dollars I'm
012not never going to look a gift horse in the mouth but what is being failed to be understood at the at the level of Albany is we're not schools anymore we are full service student servicing and family servicing organizations nowhere are children able to be touched in a meaningful way better than in a school we have launched a northwell program and we now know the data that that is that is something that we've invested in and we don't know any names but we know that 60% we do not know about 60% of the cases that are being seen over at northwell because you're choosing not to put us into the loop and that's your family's business we don't want to know if that's a decision you're making again could we be more proud of that
013but these are the things that are driving the budget these are the things that are starting to just get a little tight in addition to that and it's just a fact that we're going to have the report when it comes time to to to the budget uh we have seen a historic increase in our transportation budget so what had happened is we have not had to run a bid for transportation since 2011 because there's a a a vory in the law that says as long as the incumbent transportation company is willing to do it at the cost of inflation go ahead and renew what we heard from our transportation provider is doing that for the last over 10 years had now put them in an economic state where they had to rebid the contract and
014when we rebid that contract we saw a 68% increase in our transportation costs that now has to hit this budget so that sounds like a lot of bad news um but there's some good news in it because while we are pursuing the profile of the owl and while we are going to do um some some changes to the curriculum what they they can actually coincide and do two things at once we have to continue to move forward because your children deserve that we will continue to move forward because your children deserve that I will be brutally honest and there's a lot of Administrators in this room right now we went back to them the last what idiot has administrative meetings at 3 o'l in the afternoon on a Friday could you imagine getting that phone
015call he wants to see all of you at 3:00 on Friday gee thanks Paul that's a great one why because we need them to take a hard look at their budgets to see you know and yes they're always good at saying okay yeah we can give this back but we needed them to make take really hard looks at say you know what how can we really tighten that belt so that we can continue to do the good things that I just talked about and I'm happy to say that they have been Stellar with giving some of those uh tightening the belt there may be other things that we will be presenting to tighten that belt the key is and I just love the way we just said it to the PTA we are going to
016be cutting away from the classroom and away from programs in as much as possible so that we can preserve the core of what this district has always been about so the good news is you have a really wonderful um uh administrative staff we have been talking to our teachers union and they have been very Cooperative in helping us brainstorm way to to make this a reality so cooperatively we're trying to bring that Gap and close that Gap I must be brutally honest on the 22nd of January right now it's not completely closed however Mr press you got a couple more weeks to work on this and we hope that by the time we will be presenting you a balanced budget on March the 5th but please recognize that there may be some things that you
017see that may be uncomfortable and not the way we've done things things but remember it's about preserving the great programs that we have if you have to see any of that stuff I hope that we don't have to you know we really do think that it can come off without much disruption uh and that is our that is our goal but that kind of uh I just wanted to set that uh uh expectation and kind of manage expectations um so we were just with PTA and I told them that we would have very explicit marching orders for what to speak to our legislators about I will be drafting everything I just said into a a message that you can all message out to our uh legislators I'm very happy to say that our assembly woman
018and our state senator have been in lindbrook schools and they have seen and uh and I Mrs aragona you you said it inside I will what what was the impression that you got from the from the legislators I think they got a great impression and I was saying inside when we met with PTA um I've been out of the elementary school for 5 years and the elementary school in that five years look so different in you know than when my kids went and I think she really I think they took everything in and I think they really appreciated it coming here and I I think it was effective I hope and then at least they'll have that picture in their head and then as I I tell them you know I may have a fire
019hose that gets pointed and it's it's you you know that's that's that's what you know Mr Belmont will talk about this all the time we get what we deserve for being at pathetic and so you know if we have to take to the you know and it may not be you know thank God you've given us reserves for the last 30 years you've given us some some buffer that we can use if we keep chipping away and chipping away let's hopefully move it so that over a multi-year process we can come out uh leaner meaner and and and concentrating on once again the profile of the owl what you told us you want from our our instructional program not to put too much pressure on Dr bcus but uh he's gonna now talk a little
020bit about the programmatic changes Dr question I have one quick question when do the final runs come out great question so uh we saw the executive budget run yesterday the final runs should come out on or about April 1st so they they are constitutionally obliged to pass a budget by April 1st they don't always do it yeah yeah I mean constitutionally obliged is uh kind of laughable because I don't remember the last time they came out on time with those numbers and there's no consequence to Albany if those numbers don't come out but we are obligated to put a budget in front of the community on May 1820 whatever it is this year and when we don't know how much we're getting from the state it's a shot in the dark and it's been a
021shot in the dark a number of times over the past few years and that's just another way we're behind the eightball and and to that point Thank you Mr Murray for bringing that up we traditionally limr has always been a adopt the budget on the at the March meeting that's what we've always done um when Dr Buck taught me how to be a business official like we adopt in March we're not adopting in March if we don't see something coming out of Albany I just think it would be hard a shot in the dark is is an excellent way to put it we'll be adopting at the April meeting just so we can again set expectations when it comes to I just feel like it could change I'm I'm being hopeful hopefully not naive but
022it's an election coming and hopefully they'll send more money this way I'm not hopeful and and to play on further to what Dr Lynch was saying it's important to understand he only gave a few examples of the unfunded mandates that ALB has on us so when we invite legislators to walk around our schools and they go down the hallways they go oh I didn't know that oh that's interesting the difference is it's not just a question of going going back and asking for money the ruling party in Albany has their own agenda of legislative interests that they have so it's not enough to just say what we're not getting you have to go back and look at what the state budget contains and the programs that funding that many people find are not practical or
023useful and they cut away from what we're doing for our kids and the quickest example of it without belaboring this because I will and I do but I'll just give you one example you saw in the news today that one she made the decision she made the decision that schools should not allow phones in the classroom another example of not having local control what does Al know about what lindbrook is doing what hu's doing what rosin's doing what do they know what Buffalo is doing why are they making that decision and she's dedicated at this point 13 million ion to implementing a plan so that schools will keep phones out of the classroom think of where that $13 million could go when you're going to hear now what we're being cut from and things that
024we need programs for so just one example of it but you have to look at the state budget look at what they're spending money on and realize what they're not giv to the schools Dr bis thank you Mr Belmont so I'm I'm going to shift gears here to some more positive things thankfully so we're going to be talking about some changes that are happen happening first at the state level then we're going to work into what that means in lindbrook so that idea of the profile of the AL actually uh is something that's happening in Albany currently they're a little bit behind us they're working on something called the portrait of The Graduate so saying concept what do we think a student in New York state should look like upon graduation and they're talking about
025instead of uh course requirements and seat time they're talking more about standards and uh meeting stting proficiencies so what's happening up in Albany right now is they're debating a timeline there is a timeline up on the state department website if you go the uh commission at the state level was called the Blue Ribbon commission you can Google search this it's all readily available and their fax page is this chart this chart has some shocking things on there for people that uh haven't been keeping up in the news so what you're looking at because this is very different than anything we would ever say in lindbrook when we talk about the kids in the cohort of 2025 most of us in this room would think of our LM High School who is graduating this year when
026the state department talks about the cohort of 2025 they are talking about our current eighth graders why because they will be entering High School in the year 2025 so everything that's here is all based on State Department dates so so one of the uh first things you'll see here they are making changes they try to make the uh high school diploma more accessible to children so they are working in a progression to remove the Regent exam requirement so the cohort of 2024 it says up there will have to sit for the regent exams but they do not have to pass them anymore where are those kids now well based on what I just said they are our freshmen so our freshman have to at the moment according to what was published and this is all
027again at the moment and not voted upon by the board of regions but is published by the state department on its website that the freshmen will no longer have to pass regent exams just sit for them and they will graduate with something called a New York State high school diploma what that means you know the current sophomores Juniors and seniors they have different flavors of uh diplomas available from the state so there's a local diploma there's a Region's diploma there's a Region's diploma with Advanced distinction those will all be replaced by a New York State high school diploma the New York State high school diploma obviously for us will still say lick High School on it nobody has to worry you'll still get a limric high school diploma but there will be no distinctions between
028the diplomas what will be the distinctions is that there will be seals on the diplomas and depending on what kind of work you do outside of or in addition to your diploma work you will be able to earn these seals the assessments will be fully phased out from the uh requirements for graduation for that cohort in that starts High School in 2027 those are some of the highlights of what you're seeing here but you know what we are finding though is that the state is starting to uh open up what they're talking about for graduation so what does that mean for us we need to do the same thing you know look if the state's finally going to be flexible at something I think you know it's imperative that we do the same thing so
029if we look at our uh student over there with uh all the question marks over their head trying to figure out what to do with their life uh one of the things that the state has been talking about with the standards based approach is giving the kids options letting them take electives and letting them earn like I said before different types of seals and credentials in areas that they are interested in so all of the things that we're going to be talking about in a little bit we might be talking about things that have been in lindbrook for a very long time that may have been restrictive that didn't let kids have these type of choices and options we're going to be talking about trying to open up some more choices and options for our
030students so one of the uh first new offering types that we're talking about and again we can build different uh options into courses that exist or we can bring in new courses so new at L High School we're going to be introducing things called corera corsera is a company that's been very involved in the uh Collegiate and Beyond World giving people credentials that can allow them to get jobs elsewhere they also offer college courses through different universities such as the ones that are on the screen right now and uh what kids can earn you know when you take a course with corsera you can become a Google tech level one and then Google tech level two and such and what these things do are allowing kids to get jobs and when they come out of
031school they can come out with credentials that can earn them you know a promotion before they even start in certain companies which is a pretty cool opportunity these type of s courses also too just so people know are being offered at the University level you know they are also talking about micr credentialing and giving kids these Workforce ready uh additional certificates the other uh piece in here that we see is AP seminar AP seminar is the first of two AP Capstone courses anyone who has a high schooler may have been hearing about this uh early January uh there's been some literature passed around here so what were we looking to do here our first year we are getting our toe in the water this is going to be our pilot year we are offering this
032as an English elective what the uh seminar course and the subsequent AP research course that come as a partnership do if you take both of them you can get a AP Capstone diploma in order to earn that diploma you have to take four other region exams and the uh scores have sorry AP exams and uh you have to have a score of three or better on the capstones in an average of three or better on the other four uh assessments so what do we see with the seminar course they actually have it built around the acronym Quest so uh this is again a research-based course so they're talking about questioning and exploring understanding and analyzing evaluating multiple perspectives synthesizing ideas team transform and transmit so those are their Concepts what are we hearing this is
033not curriculum based this is research based so kids are EXP exploring interest areas and having an opportunity to dig deeper into something we are teaching this as a Humanities uh type of complement to what we're doing in the science research program at the moment I know that Mr sposi has shared with the high school that eventually you know this may become the U AP Humanities class and there might be an AP seminar for the science research kids as well we're not there yet but that was put out there as part of our possible future Vision so just to throw that out there this is a good start start uh other things that are happening well the state department is saying that everybody is graduating with the diploma based on meeting certain standards one of the
034things that was said though is you're not allowed to add other requirements to that diploma so if you meet these standards that means that courses like the writing lab don't belong in the high school I know this is something we've been discussing for a while and uh this will be a very good move to the middle school for our kids because it allows them to bolster their foundational skills before they see high school it's important that kids read and write well from the get-go going to high school how are we going to do this uh right now in 8th grade we have two classes that are married to each other so we have English and math that are both a period and a half we will reduce the math classes to one period and we
035will replace that math class with an English class that will bring in the writing lab so English would be a period and a half opposite science for a period and a half and the other benefit of this is that if we do it in the 8th grade we could have the same teacher teaching both which would add better continuity to the course itself the uh math the original reason we had put in the period and a half was that uh years ago the common Corp came in and there was a very Hefty curriculum that was jumped so when the state dropped it in there was about a year and a half to two years of curriculum that those eighth graders had missed we have long taken care of that so it is about time to
036make that move on the math and use it for a better purpose uh we do see that logo up there for the writing Revolution uh we have been partnering with the writing Revolution who does uh reading and writing across the curriculum we do think that is something that is going to help bolster not only our middle school program but across K through 12 we have teachers that are being trained currently on all different grade levels that are going to be implementing um Notions here and again this is that idea that literacy is pervasive and kids need to read and write all over um in every subject area other things that are going on you know back to what I said before we need to be flexible so that kids can take more electives and courses
037and pursue their passion areas so one of the things that's been going on in the high school we have something called a pay lab it's uh been a career exploration opportunity for students uh the students entering the paay lab were put in specific course sections to reach that laboratory uh you know that is a period on their schedule instead of having it as a standalone class we are going to work those opportunities into areas such as resource room and small classes where classes can visit and do some clearer exploration but it will not take an additional period out of a student's day which means that students will have more accessibility to electives uh other changes along the same lines any kid that's put in an inclusion class in lindbrook in the middle school and high
038school has had a learning lab attached in some way so at the middle school that's all of our inclusion classes and the high school that would have been the English and Social Studies classes and uh the learning lab technically was a general education service that was uh mandated for anybody in the ICT it was taught by a special educator with special education students and uh you know that wasn't necessarily the most inclusive environment so what we're going to do with the learning Labs we're going to replace them with Humanities and stem Labs you know so if kids need uh extra support in their subject areas they will still be able to get that they will be able to get that alongside their general education peers who also need similar supports so it will be uh
039delivered in a more inclusive environment and you only get what you need as opposed to everybody in inclusion having to sit for both sides of that lab and take a half period out of their schedule for humanities and stem they will take the humanities if they need Humanities they will take the stem if they need stem if they need both they can take both if they don't need either they can have an extra period again to take some of the electives and courses that they may have been excluded from in the past so in the Middle School many kids unfortunately when they have Support Services lose things like art and Tech and such that they may have really thrived in this will allow them to have those type of classes in the High School uh
040you will have the humanities labs and the Alor Labs will still be there for the kids that need Mass support and such so those will be opportunities again to give kids that need support support um the last part here uh if anybody has been coming to the board meetings for the last uh year or two we've been doing a lot of talking about reading and um my friend Scar's rope is up there which talks about the big ideas of reading and uh realistically when you get down to reading there's two concepts that you need to know how to take words off the page and to make meaning of them once you do so so uh we're going to be talking about reading in two different flavors called phonics and comprehension so phonics taking the words
041off the page comp branch and understanding them and uh what we're going to do here right now we have a lot of different programs going on throughout the day and depending on when your program is it may be more or less disruptive to what you can take elsewhere so we're going to streamline these secondary reading classes so that those that need phonics will be put in the same periods which again will open up some elective opportunities for them and they will learn you know how to read the words off of the page then that would happen in traditional reading settings the uh comprehension on the other hand like I said that's something you do all day long that's something it's built into your curriculum so uh for general education students that could be part of
042what's worked on in the humanities lab and for special education students that don't have other services again that would be a good place to work on comprehension if you're in a small class or a resource room we can work on comprehension in those environments and again not pull you out from something else and I think the biggest thing that we're talking about today is trying to give kids real opportunities to explore and access the great electives that we have currently and some of these great electives that I think we're going to be building over the next few years in response to what's happening both with our own portrait of the Al and the uh profile of the Al and the portrait of the graduate from the state so those are uh things that are coming
043down the pipeline questions from the board please um I have a question I think it was the second Slide the diploma requirements so the cohort 2024 is our current freshman that our current freshman correct they started school in 2024 so is is this happening this year like this June no well these are when these kids graduate so this has not been voted on by the state department yet but what the state is saying at the moment they propos to the Board of Regents who has to same way that you're a board of education and you ratify things they need the board of regions to ratify but if the board of regions ratifies their plan the current freshman when they graduate high school as long as they sat for the regions exams we can give them
044a diploma for passing all their coursework which is a big change and they traditionally in lindbrook you had basically two report cards going on the same time you had these are the assessment requirements and I met that I took an English exam and I passed it a math exam a science exam and two social studies exams as well as taking the course work and obtaining my credits if this goes through what will happen is it'll just be Credits based as long as you sat for the test you did not need to pass them anymore which is a big change so they'll take the test this year un knowing not knowing if this is going to going to matter or is this not going to matter correct got it when are they supposed to vote on
045this because they have a lot of dates of endgame but they doesn't seem like they've really shown us much of the roll out and it doesn't seem like it's realistically actually going to happen at this timeline yeah see and that's the problem right now it could happen in any timeline because they could make this change you know two years from now and still affect that freshman class what the state's uh agenda is there I I don't really know what the time on is I think we're all hopeful it's going to be sooner rather than later they have been saying it's going to be sooner rather than later but until Things become you know 100% solid it's hard to say exactly what they're doing this is their current model and there's a little disclaimer at the
046bottom of the page basically that says this has not been voted and ratified yet by the board of regions so we will say I do know that this stuff is something that's on their agenda it seems like every month what vote they're going to take at what point I don't know uh Dr Bas for cohorts 2728 cohorts 29 nothing is mentioned about region exams at all so do we have any indication of where the state's going with that do has has there been any chatter about that is this does this leave the door open for possibly eliminating regions exams well it doesn't sound like the regions exams will ever be eliminated that's what we're hearing so the region exams would be a pathway or a choice to demonstrate proficiency of standards and I think there
047are many students that would like to demonstrate Proficiency in that way so for many kids that might be their still their pathway but let's say that you have some students that sitting for an assessment where I have to memorize everything I did all year long and I have a learning disability where memorization is not necessarily my strong point but I understand the content and I can do a really great Capstone type project to demonstrate that I know this stuff that is something that could be another option and what they're talking about when they made all these changes they actually did put out in the documentation and I put that as my first bullet here that they were looking for ways for certain special education students who have not been able to access a diploma because
048they weren't necessarily the best test taker to be able to do things in a different way so that was one of the that was an impetus for why they did this but that doesn't mean the exams are going away and I'm going to throw out something else out there just so people understand uh what happens with the federal government's role in all of this so the federal government for years has been looking at math English and Science and if you notice what kind of tests we have in both the elementary and the middle schools it's those three subject areas so at the high school if other regions exams did fade those three areas you would assume would be because of federal statutes tested at some point whether or not again the tests count for anybody
049that's a different you know story um thank you for for this it's a lot to take in but you know I'm starting to think first of all we've talked about the diploma requirement changes and I think the flexibility for students is going to be a net positive eventually when we know what the state wants from us um but when we think about um Billy's comments about unfunded mandates and we listen to Dr Lynch talk about budget pressures that we're facing do we have any notion at this point of What kinds of budget pressures offering more Pathways to graduation are going to have on the district and how we might manage those that's a great question so as I indicated before we have outstanding elective programs some of those electives run very lean as far as
050children in seats and uh if we started to see where the funding does not keep up with that we would we could possibly be in a circumstance where we need to cut electives for budgetary reasons and or not offer as wide a a an offering because are you going to run a class for six which we currently can do um so you know again we're not necessarily looking at that in this current budget environment but you're asking longterm I think that's a reasonable thought Dr bcus if I may how are you handling the regions exams at present for instance if the region exams will no longer be required with this year's freshman if this passes those students are going to sit for whether it be a the living environment or the biology region or potentially
051the algebra or the geometry regents this year how are we handling those exams at a local level given that this is not yet law so right now the way that uh lindbrook has changed over the last few years the assessments benefit children in the sense that if you do well you can get it the point on your average if you don't do well it doesn't uh affect your grades anymore so right now we're actually in a good space with the way that assessments are being calculated towards grades you know again you do have to sit for the exams regardless so these kids would have to sit for these assessments the bigger question is going to be and this is back to what Mrs denino asked before they take the assessments now in June whether or
052not I make them retake the assessments because they have to pass I would hope that we have information from the state before that that happens because that's when Mrs Kelly gets very tricky no harm but it Do no harm only comes into play when you're worried about the overall average for the year for the course right it's if you're going to make a student sit to retake the exam because it is a diploma requirement you know that that's really my question what yes I I understand that question and I'm think we haven't answered before then because I can't imagine that we're the only ones thinking that way uh Dr bless one one other thing uh on the the slide where it says writing lab the Middle School uh the second bullet is uh the 1.5
053periods of math to the 1.5 periods of English I I i' just like to say as a math teacher believe it or not I I think this is a very strong move educationally because if you know what the New York State curriculum is like even if we're going away from the Region's EX if you know what the New York State curriculum is like for algebra geometry and in trig they're effectively reading comprehension exams which a math thrown in it and the the regions exams for social studies and the curriculum for social studies is very similar so I personally think as a math teacher especially once you get to the algebra 2 level I mean you there you you have to look far and wide to actually find arithmetic on that test it's all reading so
054truthfully I do think even though seems like with decreasing the math I think we're you know going through the back door and helping these kids do better with the higher curriculum not even higher algebra one has a ton of reading as well which is what they take in eth grade so uh Algebra 1 Algebra 2 curriculums whether it's a region exam or not are so heavily based in reading comprehension that I think this is going to help these students mathematically as well I agree with you and also too just to put it out there you know the science assessments I know we talked about region exams are fting in the yes I see that Mrs Kelly I know this is your area are being replaced next year for both the earth science and the living
055environment because of those changes people should anticipate more assessments that look like the grade five and the grade eight assessments which are very very very very difficult reading assessments they are no longer science tests they require you to break down scientific vocabulary and speak effectively about it so yes all the right moves here with all of our eighth graders taking those new science assessments will benefit them as well so it's not just on the math side yes the scientists in particular and again back to that writing Revolution idea we're all teachers of reading and writing within our own disciplines and I think that's something that you know again will be reinforced by some of those changes at Al yeah I mean just to jump on the point that Mr pesy made it's not just in
056the school level we're seeing at the college entrance level there's going to be a return of the standardized tests right a number of schools that did away with the SAT act are bringing it back if you look at how the SAT and ACT are administered even in for on the ACT even more so the the math and the science sections are heavily reading comprehension sections so the enforcing the Reading Writing element is really at that early age is really going to pay dividends throughout the high school level but also even at as you get towards the college level because there is more of a focus on the ability to read and write in every SE subject matter not just traditionally English sorry I'm gonna dovetail on that if I may um on the learning lab
057slide so where we talked about streamlining secondary reading I love that the writing lab is coming down because with writing fluency comes reading fluen very often but could you speak to the numbers that we're talking about when we talk about secondary reading middle school and high school you know do do we have ideas of how large these classes are or if they're pull out Services pushin Services is it okay so right now they're all pull out services and because we have the services so fragmented they are all different times a day and depending on who's receiving what course at you know a SN special time they may or be not be missing out on elective one of the uh great things about lindbrook high school is it's a small district and we all know each
058other pretty well one of the terrible things about lindbrook high school is it's a small district and a lot of things are offered as Singleton so if you have your class and you're The Unlucky One that has reading during the time where your uh favorite elective is being offered you do miss out so what it's going to allow is a lot of classes that may be offered uh one-on-one and such to be offered in a small group so that the kids are all in the same time period which means that we can work some of the electives around that time period as opposed to Well you ended up in this period that you ended up in that period and unfortunately Mr BR I had to pick a period to put the class in and that
059is something that happens and yes I apologize Mr Brash for calling you out there in the middle of the board me thank you Dr Bas thank you now I like to call upon Mrs Sabin to uh do her presentation on the Continuum of uh Education Services and just to clarify for the audience this is a budget work session so there are no questions from the audience the next board meeting on the 12th they'll take questions evening everyone Hi um I'm here to talk a little bit about the Continuum of special education Services here in lindbrook just before jumping into it um very briefly this is for special education students they are classified um and the continuous Services is under part 200 of the commissioner's regulation so um very different than electives and and choices and
060all of that so I just wanted to make a point of that before going into it so um in part 200 these are the the full Contin services so we always make an effort to have students seen in the least restrictive environment so that would be um potentially related Services speech occupational Physical Therapy sometimes counseling those are supports to the general education environment um resource room can be offered only in a group of up to five students so um that is for students who require that additional support consultant teacher direct is something not used very often um that's a pushin and very individualized service within the general education curriculum then um integrated co- teing there's a special education teacher a general education teacher um and we can't have more than 50% of the students classified
061within the total classroom um and that can't exceed a number of 12 students um here in lindbrook we have up to two hours so some students have a little less than two hours it could be up to two hours a day that a special education teacher would be pushing into an elementary ICT classroom um and on the secondary level it's more course course by course depending on student strengths and weaknesses special class settings um no general education students in there all special education students I'm going to walk us through all of the buildings and where we have different small special class sizes um but that is a not integrated at all um separate setting um for students who cannot be educated here in lindbrook and we heard we're very proud of the the programs that
062we offer in lindbrook um but where that can't be possible we have programs like bosis other public school districts and um state approved non-public schools for students who can't be included in a classroom setting due to their health or educational needs they could potentially be educated at home or in a hospital setting so that's the full Continuum I'm going to walk you through starting at the Kindergarten Center um so at the Kindergarten Center we do have the full Continuum new to lindbrook this year is that small class of 12 of a full day special class maximum number of students in that class is 12 um and Blended that's a term that we use here in lindbrook um that just means a foot in each door so they might be in an ICT setting for some
063portion of the day day and in a a special class setting for some portion of the day um used to be that we had two hours in each each door this was set forth but again these decisions are made by a committee um committee on special education looks at individual student needs um and they make a decision so the the number of hours that a student is in ICT or in Blended um can vary based on students individual needs again where they a strength we want them included in the least restrictive environment um and so this this Blended offers them that opportunity wherever possible um again this is the first year that we had a f Day program and those decisions are made based on um the cohorts of students that we have coming into
064the district the needs of those students so again the committee looks at the needs of the students and says the students needs are greater than that of the students we traditionally were serving in a blended program um and so we were able to develop that full day special class in the Kindergarten Center great thing about the Kindergarten Center everyone is all in one place and we're able to offer that full Continuum so again where a student might have a strength and they can be included in a general education classroom or in an ICT setting they're not secluded in that small separate class um and again you know they get the support that they need there that's what we want to see happen we want to see them grow um so again starting at the Kindergarten
065Center our goal would be the next year they can go off um to their home Elementary School and be in a less restrictive environment if they've done well the committee meets again looks at individual needs of individual students um and we come together as a team and and um make sure that we have those programs offered Miss sa just for for parents who are listening and might not have a student in the specialed world can you just just explain that 1211 what that what those numbers actually mean sure I'm sorry that's okay maximum of 12 special education students no general education students in that special class setting um and the one is a special education teacher and the second one is an additional Aid in the classroom to provide additional um support and supervision um
066so now we see that number change a little bit when we're looking at the Maran Street Continuum because we do have a group of students whose needs are even greater than that full day class of 12 um those students are in a smaller class um maximum of eight special education students their their educational needs are much greater um their language skills they have a lot more support from our related Ser service Personnel in that class um and as you can see an additional Aid um sometimes and and we heard about um you know the the tour our local officials took that we have a lot of adults in some of these small classes because sometimes those students individual plans might warrant additional adult support beyond what is already available in that class um so the
067thing that I want to point out um at Maran Street uh traditionally we've been able to offer that Continuum the Blended program um has been in um in Maran street we have ICT there um and the students in the classes that I have listed here are in the upper grades so they're starting to age out and you'll see as I walk through the different buildings we have started um with cohorts so they start coming out of the kindergarten Center and go into an elementary school as a group so they may not go to their home school if they're in a class of eight um and it can't exceed eight so when Marian Street had a full group or wly had a full group we couldn't add the next year's kindergarteners to that group um we
068had to start a new cohort in another building and you'll see when I when I walk through those those other buildings um where those started but these students here at Maran Street are in the upper grades and starting to age out so these are are not younger students um and at Waverly Park again the full Continuum related Services resource room integrated C- teaching um when intergraded C- teing was offered here initially at at lindbrook it was offered in all buildings and in all grades but what we did see is that um each year we we see what the committee recommends um we just heard of of uh you can't enroll a class with just six students so um we had one year where there were zero ICT students recommended by the committee so that that
069wasn't necessarily run so again we're looking at we can't run a class for just one or two students um so when we're looking at Waverly Park we do anticipate a group of students coming into first grade next year requiring that ICT but we have grades in this building that do not have the ICT class at this time um and again the full day small special class of eight um is upper grades right now so fourth and fifth graders um who at some point they are they are going to be aging out um we do not have Blended at at Waverly we didn't have um enough students for the entire District to offer that in the same way that they had the integrated co- te so traditionally again that was offered at Maran Street we know
070those students are getting a little older and aging out and then I'm going to talk to you about where are younger cohorts are coming into at West End um this year we had a small class of eight begin so those are kindergarten youngsters so that's that's where um that Continuum is going to start up from the kindergarten level um and we anticipate next year that our current kindergarten 1211 class will be um at Westend so that's this is not something that we have here now it's something that we anticipate the committee recommending for a group of students um who will require continuation of that full day class of 12 um and that'll be at West End for next year we don't currently really have a blended program because we don't have the 12 um but
071that's something that will be offered going forward because we know again the students in the full day special class where they have um opportunities to be included in the co- te is what we traditionally called Blended so again individual decisions for individual students they may spend some time of their day in the integrated co- teing class and sometime of their day in the class maximum size of 12 students and then moving on to our middle schools um we have at North related Services resource room ICT um and our special class settings there as the kids are getting a little bit older that that smallest class profile the students who are in the eight have been moving up into a class that's now capped at 12 at the secondary it starts to look a little bit
072different um 12 students one teacher one Aid in that smallest class um and then we also have special class 15 um that is something that traditionally was at South um and now with uh this year's grade six we started that cohort here at North um again that offers the same opportunity for a blended type of program where students who have an area where they Excel can be participating in an integrated co- teing class um or where they need more support um they could be in that class that is being capped at 15 that in between 15 class is working on the same curriculum as our ICT students um just in a smaller setting with a special education teacher um providing more support and modifications um and again um at South we had traditionally had that
073class of 15 I list it here now because we still have students who are who have been there we're not having them transferred to North to participate in that program and as they age out um we're we're going to only be offering that at North for all of the students um we may only have a handful of students um enrolled in those small classes per grade um and again we want to make sure um it's a functional group so having just two or three kids in a small class learning together um doesn't feel like a classroom setting can I ask a question at the middle schools the 15 one and the 12 one are they integrated with the other students for specials and electives yes they have those opportunities throughout the day they're in cafeteria
074with their peers um we have a lot of after school clubs and alow buddies and a lot of opportunities for integration and then back to Waverly when you said there was no Blended does that mean that those students in that 812 are not ever integrated with their other peers they have opportunities for integration where the teachers are collaborating and doing activities together but they are um for the most part they're not learning their academic subjects together side by side so they do have pushin opportunities like for art or some possibly definitely for for specials um and again individual students so we've we've had you know the these students tend to by characteristic maybe excel at math they may go in and participate for a math lesson um at the beginning of a reading lesson sometimes
075there's a whole class lesson where there's a read out loud they might come in and join for activities like that so there's integration on those levels um but their instruction is happening predominantly in so that's why it didn't say Blended on that slide because it's there's no in between place right okay thank you um and I know it was already mention that I I just want to repeat again that traditionally um the ICT in the middle school and in the high school came with um a lab class that was an additional support and it was required so um we know we've had a a lot of requests from those students from the parents um for more opportunities for electives we know this particular population of students really require um you know H having a a
076better understanding of what those career opportunities are in the in the future and that's um a good opportunity to be an elective so um the committee meets if they need additional supports we we talk about how those needs can be met um but again in the high school that's that's the big change here um and otherwise Again full Continuum here where students have an opportunity by subject so again we're not calling it Blended because they may be in one type of class for Math and another type of class for English um it will depend on where their strengths and weaknesses lie can I ask you another question sorry um are these classes um at capacity and if not have we considered bringing in other children um students from other districts for tuition um not all
077of these classes are at capacity our our um our classes in the elementary schools are getting Fuller so when you're looking at a class that only has um a maximum of eight students and it's enrolled at six I I am sometimes concerned you know we'll have a student move in tomorrow over the summer and we may not have room for our own residents we have um in the past had students uh from other local districts participate in those classes when they were under enrolled so we had two classes enrolled at 4 we were able to welcome in um students from other districts we had the opportunity to collapse those two classes together um when a couple of students aged out and it didn't make sense to keep two classes open for non-residents so um so
078they're not with us right now um would it be fair to say and someone else Miss Burman or someone else might have to chime in also those small classes it's 812 classes I'm kind of doing a little math in my head but between salary and benefits they're easily a quarter of a million dollars a piece or more to run those class is that a fair statement um and it's additional related service person without even yeah without even talking about that absolutely um you know so you know you're talking a million dollars just for for that handful of students and we want to give that to them don't get me wrong but you know I think that's just something to point out is that these are high cost um needs that that we we're we're grappling
079with here now what would a student with that level of need typically cost to have to send out per student if there's a typical yeah I mean it it ranges when you put together all of the costs with Transportation related Services Etc I could use a ballpark of 80 90 100,000 it depends on on which placement they're in right um the thing I'm sorry so it's actually tremendous savings to have those programs here but right they're so expensive yeah I and I would imagine I can't speak to Transportation cost to bring them in the neighborhood versus elsewhere um would be reduced as well thank you but I also want to put the aid conversation on that one so that with each of those students at 80 to 100,000 back to my 70,000 number if not
080that we're doing this if we were to put them in outside District settings the aid is actually greater that we're getting back from the state and that just seems opposite to that's just un Constable um I I know because of the support we've received from the school board and from the community Community I don't have to say the value to all of our students of having these particular students as part of our school Community I I appreciate that so much um and the uh just the next piece to say to that is that um there are waiting lists at bosis um there you know when when we do have a situation where we need to look for placement because we really can't educate the students here um we have students who end up being on
081on home instruction for an interim placement we we don't ever want to see that happen but it's just important to know that there aren't necessarily options out there if if that were to be a decision and again I appreciate the support and and the knowledge um how much this Community Values these these particular students so thank you for that yeah no I didn't want to suggest that I thought we should look for other places I just wanted to like help the community understand how much one student with significant needs can cost and we have a complete moral ethical societal obligation to them that I believe in but it's not cheap yeah I mean I think that's highlight Mr Murray is highlighting a good point and I'm about as dollars and cents of a person as
082you can have but these are the kids that are most in need and I think keeping them wherever possible inh housee and meeting their needs locally where they're not sitting on a bus for 55 60 minutes to go to an outside placement where they're not constantly being moved around that's an area I'm not sure you could even put a price tag on right so yes it is cheaper to do it inhouse that's an added benefit but I think the real benefit is that we're providing the the needs of our most needy students but it really does highlight what what Dr Lynch is saying it is insane or unconscionable that the formula penalizes us for doing what's right in terms of we'd get more aid for sending these kids and putting them on a bus for
08355 minutes and having them at home while they wait for a Bose's placement to open up than we get for actually doing a better job I that's crazy to me I don't know what Albany is thinking none of us do yeah and just another thing that M Sab just said I just um the whole owl buddies program that has emerged uh in every one of our things so if you come and I encourage everyone to come to the mcer awards at the end of the year that SEPTA when you see how many kids get an award for working with children with special needs uh it is adding a level of compassion and Justice and just fun to every kid in this district and I don't and every kid that is involved in owl's buddies um
084it is just such an important aspect of their lives that I don't know what the price tag on that would be none um I had my son had participated in owl buddies at North and I think the general ed students actually get more out of it than the special ed students like they loved it so you guys are doing a great job thank you any other questions thank you m thank you need this back anything else from the board all right thank you for coming out our next meeting will be a regular board meeting on February 12th stay safe stay warm