CorpusRecord 62740

Manhasset Schools Board of Education Meeting 2-13-25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Manhasset School District
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Nassau County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
14,608 words · about 82 min
Collected
2026-06-09

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e all right good evening welcome to a regular meeting manhas School Board February 13th happy early Valentine's Day uh if we could please all rise for the pledge of allegiance alance to the flag the unit States of America stands Nation indivisible justice for all all right it's always great to start off the meetings with some recognition so I'll hand over you to gra to get started okay yes we're very excited uh to continue our partnership with cassa and uh we have some PSA winners I'm going to actually invite Connie Bruno to uh to tell us a little bit about the PSAs and uh talk to us about the program so first I'll start with a history of Casa if you don't know we've been operating in the in the community for over 24 years and

002our primary goal is to reduce substance use among Our Youth and enhanced mental health education is at the core of what we do and um when it comes to education in prevention the youth really are so important and youth messaging is tremendously important because youth they know the behavior they speak the language they can relate to the other children or kids um so about four years ago I approached Dr Coleman and Dr chowski about utilizing and leveraging the re sources in the broadcast journalism Suite along with the talent in those classes and that's how the competition was born so we felt that students were asked to produce a video in support of kasa's mission and the whole goal is to educate and change behavior and some of the topics are social media digital issues gambling

003underage gambling underage alcohol use and those are the topics that the students are given to create their PSA Kleen hi everyone um before we get started thank you so much to everyone for their support Administration the board this was such a wonderful project I'm so glad we continued it this year um the students did a phenomenal job with their projects it was so fun to watch them throughout their process and their personal growth and development as they became actors for the first time in front of a camera they wrote their original scripts they tried new things they took risks and that's really where the joy is so without further Ado this year there were eight outstanding contest submissions that were evaluated by a casa Board of judges in the following categories technical aspects of effective

004camera work editing skills and use of Lighting and Sound creativity of the message that reflects Insight imagination and ability to capture the attention of the attended audience incorporation of an effective tagline to impact the audience long after viewing social benefit and application of the psa's message to the target audience fact-based messaging from reliable sources and finally availability of followup information providing local Andor National advocacy Outreach contact opportunities and on that we have the opportunity to show you our first first place winner which is Project Healthy Minds uh is the video Jackson daily Lauren westall and Grace Panopoulos e e e the talent and the creat creativity is just amazing and on that I'll invite our first place winners up e and our second place winner for Rise br and repeat is Chloe p and finally

005our third place for don't struggle in silence we have Thomas Collard Mark madano stavos codus Dean Champa and Tony tan e e and again I'd like to thank the board Margo Verio Brenda McOwen and of course Kathleen Daly and this dry uh Dreer sorry and this is what stays at the school and it has the first place winners on it Hy just thank you uh on behalf of the district for all of the work that you do in supporting our students and supporting this really really important message uh Emser for you know your your first year with this program and to see what the kids are creating in uh in high school is really unbelievable so thank you so very much for your dedicated work for our kids thank you just on behalf of the

006board I just want to Echo Dr P's sentiments Connie what you do with Kasa and pretend continue to do with it is phenomenal so we really thank you so much for your effort in the community and Miss ster that that is that was remarkable I'm sorry we couldn't see the second and third place winners I'm sure they're they're just as good because that was Unreal watching that editing um the message the everything behind it it was it really was uh it really was great thank you for all of it and uh Mr daily making help everything start that's thank you for that doing that for the community so thank you everyone congratulations you are more than welcome to stay you know we we have tax cap calculations it could I see a future PSA award

007in the future if you were to you want to do some date on it enjoy with time with your family congratulations everyone e all right we'll go ahead and get started uh approval of minutes from the January 16th meeting all in favor all right and that will lead us right into the superintendent report okay thank you very much so good evening everyone um welcome to the last meeting before the February break uh I wanted to begin my report by thanking the sea for coordinating the annual guest who's coming to re event at Muny Park in Shelter Rock schools uh the students enjoyed meeting and being read to by our community members including nasso Police Department uh Sam the service dog was a big hit uh airline pilots doctors firefighters teachers business owners and many more

008uh the event was a great way for our community to spend some time with our students and we're grateful for the sea uh for sponsoring this event I also want to thank the Chinese American Association of North Hemstead for sponsoring our annual Lunar New Year celebration Shelter Rock and Muny Park students enjoyed traditional line dances fan dances and mass Change magic as well as a taii demonstration uh we thank the Chinese American Association for bringing this colorful and cultural celebration to our school community at the secondary school our brand new Manhasset High School robotics team combed com uh competed in its first ever Vex robotics competition the team made it to the quarterfinals which is a great accomplishment for their inaugural season and I want to congratulate their advisers Mr Carr and Mr Russo who

009worked with our students to design build and program the robots the team is looking forward to the next competition in March um our Unified sports club uh took uh took first place in the Cool School challenge at the town of North hemad Polar Plunge the staff students and parents raised $112,000 for the Special Olympics so I want to thank our club's advisers Miss slobin and Mr Fay for spearheading this effort for our students and finally in terms of uh congratulatory news our music department um is owed a a big thanks for taking our Secondary School band and Orchestra students to Disney World for the Epcot International Festival of the Arts beyond the fun and games which I hear were plentiful uh students also performed for thousands of spectators at the park so I want to

010thank Dr Owens for bringing this trip to Manhasset and for all the work that goes into pulling off a successful trip of this magnitude so uh let me now transition to some other important updates um Dr gerges and I met with representatives from the New York Power Authority and New York Transco to discuss the pro Propel energy project that will impact our area the Propel project is an underground electric transmission project that serves to address the Aging infrastructure and increased electrical Demand on Long Island by bolstering the electrical system reliability in the region uh the Propel Energy Group met with the district because the underground project will include a route on Northern Boulevard the company estimates that that construction will begin sometime in 2026 it'll take three to four years to complete the whole project

011um they're aware that they cannot shut down Northern Boulevard as it's a major throughway but they wanted us to know that the project may impact traffic around our schools and will certainly impact traffic around the community uh they're not certain of the exact date or the duration for the uh section of the project that will impact Manhasset uh but I did want to let the community know that the Propel Energy Group will be hosting a series of informational meetings for the community the first of which will be uh February 25th at the Hicksville Community Center at 6m they'll also be setting up an informational table at the Manassa Public Library to share information with Manhasset residents and Propel will do a direct mailing to the community uh to the community as well but they've asked

012us to uh they've asked us to share this information um so uh we have a one-page flyer and uh that they've given us as well as information um on their Community sessions which we'll pass along to the sca uh for uh for dissemination so moving on to our own construction uh the auditorium is moving along nicely uh contractors are beginning to frame out the ceiling they're planning to start the work on the roof over the stage over the April break the life skills classroom is substantially complete uh we were displeased with the way that the Cabinetry came out and we've asked the contractor to replace the cabinets and S and sink the loose furniture will be delivered next week all appliances have been received we're still working through the options to replace the Cabinetry but

013once we settle the cabinets will go into production they'll take about 12 weeks to complete uh students can begin to use the space shortly after the break as they can replace the cabinets and syn after hours we'll discuss this option with the teacher to determine if she wants to use the space now uh with the existing cabinets um or travel between the two spaces that she currently has uh and as I'm sure you've all seen the guard booth has been installed the arms will be installed over the summer and then the guard booth will be fully operational as a reminder the guard booth was not originally envisioned to include arms the arms were added as a result of our audit from Homeland Security and as such the guard knew the the guard booth also did

014not have a planned turnaround our architect is designing a turnaround option for our consideration and once we have a design and an estimate on the cost we'll share it with the board for authorization the fire alarm replacement project is also underway and should be completed by September uh this summer we have a number of projects that are scheduled to be complete at Shelter Rock we're doing the uh pavement and roadway uh replacement project uh the sidewalk replacement the bathroom reconstruction the classroom UV replacement the speech Suite reconstruction uh we may be able to begin this uh during the school year may not have to wait uh the Auditorium will be redone and the library um at Shelter Rock at the secondary school we have the exterior walls and column reconstruction this summer the bathroom reconstruction

015the classroom UV replacement the blackbox theater The Social Studies Office the tennis courts and the Dennis Street Access Road uh we're awaiting s approval for the site work and Auditorium project at Shelter Rock and for the masonry work the blackbox theater and the Dentistry project at the secondary school we anticipate receiving that approval on time everything else has been approved and on tonight's agenda is the award of bids for the shelter Rock and secondary school projects that have been approved by S the bids have been recommended uh by our architect they've gone through the normal bid process um and uh once we award the bids tonight uh we'll we'll be we'll be in a good position to begin this work over the summer that's my report for this evening thank you uh any questions I

016have one question in regards to the Propel project uh that's happening regardless because I know and speaking to uh some members at Northshore um H School District there seems to be a a large group opposed to this so I don't know if there have you heard anything they've shared to us that it's a New York state project uh New York state has awarded the bid Northern Boulevard is in New York state throughway so um they shared it to us as informational uh they indicated to us that it was moving on as planned um and that they'll hold a number of community meetings for uh for those that were interested they were alerting us uh as part of their um as part of their phasing project they have to alert uh school districts and Community groups

017about the about the infrastructure project because it's the first major infrastructure project like this they've said in um in in quite a few years so there thought on um how like have we what would be the traffic implication because there are certain points during the school year like our off periods where the traffic coming off PL Dome there's a bottleneck um which sort which happened during the um midterm yeah we requested that they uh try to do this project over the summer um we don't know if they'll uh they said we weren't the first school district to make that request uh but we explained that we do have you know M Park School is right on Northern Boulevard um and our other two buildings are right off of Northern Boulevard so uh so we explained

018that traffic on a good day is bad and congested um between PL doome and Northern Boulevard so that was our request they made note of it um and we'll see they said they'll share with us the staging we also alerted them to the date of the sea fair to the date of the months par graduation um so that they could line around those events we'll see if they do and when do uh when will they start being the library information uh they did not give me a date yet for the uh for for the library informational sessions the only date that I have right now is the community session at the Hicksville Community Center February 25th at 6m there'll be another session in minola in March um and uh we can share the we can

019share that information we'll share that with the sea thank you any other questions uh missing our student delegate report you want to give a little insight into our visit when we went to the student sen sure so uh we had a wonderful meeting with the with the student Senate um Steve Mariana uh and I uh visited the student Senate along with uh Dr rer uh and the purpose of this the purpose of the conversation was really a school safety forum uh and the student Senate um members gave us some feedback on some of our safety initiatives they also spoke about uh some of the some of the safety enhancements that they would like to see uh in in the district one of the things that we spoke about was uh was that we are uh

020planning for a student swipe system for next year um the student swipe system would allow students essentially to tap into the school with their ID uh the ID station would be manned with uh by by a security Personnel or or or one of our supervisory AIDS uh and it allows to ensure that any individual that's entering our school is a student um and so that was well received we will also uh we're also planning for a swipe out system during lunch so that we can ensure that the kids that are swiping out we have records of their attendance in terms of who's in and out of the building uh there's also um we're also exploring the possibility of uh sending out alerts to parents when their students arrive late to school via the via the

021check-in um process or when they leave for lunch and return for lunch those are all things that are under consideration but that was one of the things that the student senate had asked we're working with Tower to secure funding for the uh for the swipe system and uh the tower found Foundation is is excited to partner with us on that initiative um so that was discussed we also discussed our cell phone uh we also discussed the cell phone policy in the building uh Dr rer has purchased uh cell phone caddies for every classroom in the secondary school um the the teachers have the right now have the discretion to use the caddies or to use some other mechanism uh to ensure that cell phones are not a distraction for students uh as you can imagine

022there was a lot of energy around that conversation um as uh as the students that are members of the student s tend to be uh Juniors and seniors and they were really advocating for uh for for a more flexible system for juniors and seniors uh and a and a and a different system for nth and 10th graders and 7eventh and eth seventh and eighth graders so uh Dr rer will continue the conversation going but as he said he's not going to stop a teacher from making good decisions in their classroom about how to handle cell phone use in their own uh in their own rooms so um it was a spirited uh discussion for sure uh that can imagine is a very impressive group of students who were very articulate um and and can certainly

023Advocate their uh their perspective and did so very well thank you yeah no I thought the student said it was very impressive and articulated very well you would have enjoyed the debate so I mean not being tongue and- cheek but uh it was a very healthy discussion and I was very impressed um with the Poise and the com commentary and they are well invested in the execution of the policy um as far as the points that they did make were relevant just from a maturity perspective so I think that Dr Roa should certainly holistically think through all of those aspects he also provided some good responses there were things that they didn't know from a state perspective that will come down the pike um so I think it was a very healthy discussion th% I

024think uh Dr Brer got a lot of good input back to go and work with the for shared decision- making so it was good it it was it was a positive that's something we should definitely try to keep every year is to have that interaction thought it was very nice to hear from all of them instead of just one representative uh any other questions about the reports okay so that'll take us to our first item we discussion you want to give it bring us a update I know you've been having uh Town Hall meetings you've had a couple different town hall meetings and where we are with the math and science uh programs yes absolutely so I'll give a little context I'm going to turn it over to Dr chowski to talk through our uh

025final recommendations so um so over the past month we've engaged in meaningful discussions with parents and teachers regarding our sixth grade double accelerated mathematics course and our seventh grade AP intensive science pathway the conversations have been held in the spirit of transparency to gather community and teacher input on how best to support our high achieving students one key takeaway is that the community strongly values the sixth grade double accelerated Math course additionally there's broad agreement with our recommendation to decouple the double accelerated Math course from the seventh grade AP intensive science Pathway to allow for greater flexibility in student placement based on the feedback we've gathered we are refining our recommendation as follows um we're going to recommend that we maintain the sixth grade double accelerated Math course as it's important to the community um

026we uh in order to do so uh we also recommend that we refine the entrance criteria to ensure the proper identification of students and again Dr chowski will go through the details of that in a moment um just by way of background the uh double accelerated sixth grade course is designed for students who have already mastered the sixth grade content identifying students who are prepared to skip sixth grade content is challenging and as you know no system is perfect uh selection for this process for this course must go beyond ability and potential to assess whether a student has the necessary foundational understanding of the curriculum to be skipped so we originally began this conversation for three reasons first uh this is the only Advanced course in The District in which students skip an entire year

027of curriculum our other Advanced courses are designed for students to study the grade level curriculum more deeply second we've uh as has been demonstrated by the changes we made to grade five in 2020 heterogeneous Elementary classrooms with structured enrichment benefit all students when we moved the double accelerated math class from fifth grade and put it into sixth grade and deepened the fifth grade curriculum for all students we saw our math scores increase by double digits as measured by both the New York state math assessment and the NWA assessment this was the only grade level to show this level of growth third because the course required students to skip a grade level of the curriculum we may be overidentifying students for double acceleration approximately 21% of our students are identified for double acceleration uh the comparator

028schools that do offer this program identify approximately 6 to 10% of their uh of their students for double acceleration Middle School teachers report that the curriculum gaps caused by skipping the sixth grade curriculum are problematic for some students while some students struggle with this type of acceleration as we discussed in our community meetings others Thrive 55% of students who were in double accelerated in sixth grade are achieving at the expected levels at the middle school suggesting that when students are properly identified the program is effective so our key conclusions are are really as follows a strong foundation in elementary math benefits all students whether they accelerate early or later and as a reminder we provide flexible entry points for students who are not initially selected for double acceleration in sixth grade to accelerate later in

029high school the double acceleration program is effective for students who are properly identified therefore we must refine the selection process to ensure we're identifying students who are truly ready and I'm going to turn this over now to Dr chowski to speak about how we can accomplish both goals how we can strength the foundation elementary math particularly in in sixth grade to benefit all students and refine our identification process to increase the likelihood of long-term success in the double accelerated Math course in sixth grade Dr chasi thank you Dr posi and many thanks to the community members teachers and administrators who have participated in this conversation we mean that sincerely our recommendation for the acceptance criteria for seven honors for science has not changed we are proposing to decouple the AP accelerated pathway from the double

030accelerated math any student who wishes to CH uh challenge themselves with the pathway is welcome to to participate in the process secondly um they will include we we will do so uh the criteria will include the average of trimesters 1 2 and three science assess ments and lab grades a secure local exam containing applied ma science skills and embedded mathematics necessary for success in the Earth and space seven honors um curriculum will be part of that exam as well we will no longer be using teacher recommendations or math grades to inform acceptance to the program our updated criteria for double accelerated grade six Math recommendation we will be expanding opportunities for participating in the double accelerated grade six Math through a secure examination in the spring any student who wishes to do so may sit

031for the exam the purpose of the exam is to demonstrate Mastery of the sixth grade curriculum skills critical thinking and application this local examination will be peer reviewed by the Association of math supervisors of Long Island we will no longer be using the coat our analysis of the Kat has revealed an insignificant correlation between Student Success and the exam and we will not be using it going forward however we do see the potential value in a nationally normed examination and the use of multiple measures during the remainder of the 2425 school year we will review other nationally normed assessments such as nwaa to determine the feasibility of replacing the coat in future years a determination as to the nationally normed assessment and a recommendation will be shared before the beginning of the 2526 school year

032teacher recommendations will no longer be part of the process but there's a part two of our our recommendation as well it's enhancing our elementary math instruction overall part one is creating a math Coach position similar to the literacy coaches to support grades five and six initially and then in future years to expand the support to lower grades two this coach will provide professional development to teachers to enhance differentiation and support as well as provide rot pushin modeling and support to enhance classroom instruction the person will create an additional we will also create an additional two 30 minute math enrichment periods during sixth grade Flex a model that has yielded strong positive data in grade five in addition curriculum writing will occur over the summer to support differentiation again we appreciate the community part participation and

033we continue to work with the math Specialists and teachers to support this possible update thank you so I want to thank you both you know for one diving into this this year Rebecca and uh and not only having a Direction but listening to the community and working on different Avenues pivoting and you I think it says a lot that this is a program that the Community Values so the math department is doing something right that there was a lot of passion uh about this program so I do appreciate you listening that aspect and looking at these different options uh I open it up to the board and anyone who' like to ask some questions thank you Dr chowski um a couple of questions to be clear for the science um selection process so whoever would

034like to take the exam will be permitted to take the exam yes in both cases for Math and for science if you would choose to challenge yourself you're welcome to sit for the exam okay for the grade point for cl for the lab um for the three trimesters is there a particular grade point average or number at this moment we're going to have to rework the rubric for this so I don't feel comfortable giving a number at this point but it will be criteria based it will not be a particular number like we're not going to say 25 is the cap for the number of students whoever qualifies we will accommodate that that was my next question actually that's very helpful because from a budget perspective so if we need potentially two sections because right

035now I think that sort of as the program exists there was only capacity for one section at I think it was like 27 students so if there is a need we would have two sections yes we can do that we've already discussed the budget implications for that and how it would work with Mr oconnell okay thank you and then um question on the math um I'm not as familiar with the math supervisors of Long Island can you share a little bit more about would they be looking at it like three individuals from there is it one consultant sort of how would that work so um this is a local Professional Organization with the directors for most of the districts in the area um and within that group is just as you would submit to a

036journal is this this group of professionals will be reviewing this exam and then certifying that it matches up to demonstrate Mastery of the material in sixth grade so we felt that having an additional multiple sets of eyes it's not going to be just one person I don't know the exact number right now but we're looking like three to five um will be reviewing it would it be feasible to Think Through even having say like a sample student to try it to sort of gauge because that that would be sort of my because this is a a first time doing this right so or this exam I don't the F it's not a first time I mean they had a secure exam they've had that for the past few years the difference is is what we're

037doing is we are being respectful and asking other people to certify this and hopefully that will help with public confidence okay Al so that so that's helpful because that's the difference so it would be the current existing secure exam it would just be that exam not a completely new exam and that would be reviewed by the math supervisors of Long Island yes it would be I mean the exam is different every year but the concepts and standards and the applications are the same okay you you Dr chowski I have just more questions surrounding uh and if you could just fill this I know so much work goes behind the scenes and then we receive a delivery of information but it's important for us to understand your thought process and what you've already explored uh I'm

038trying to understand and if I understand clearly it's only a secure exam that will be used to age entry into the math but for science we're also looking at averages of labs and test and why wasn't the same criteria considered for the math so for math um at this point what we were looking at is trying to give more access to math for sixth grade so it we we thought that we could this was various people go back five steps so it wasn't just one person certainly it was a whole committee we can create an exam that captures the math and that's necessary for for this exam with also application and ALS um constructed responses with that we can do an exam that we we work with it um at this point there was some

039concern regarding um interpretation of grades and we wanted to make sure that this was as clean as possible within this and gave as much opportunity to students as possible as well you want to add to that sure you know the only thing that I would that I would add is that um one of the lessons we learned when we moved our uh selection process from fifth grade to sixth grade was when we had it in fifth grade they were using fourth grade math in classroom tests to determine whether or not uh students were as part of the criteria to gain to gain entry and uh what the teachers reported is they reported that it put a lot of undue stress on uh on kids on classroom exams in that uh they reported students crying um

040as a result of four test grades on single exams so we wanted to remove the um to remove any tie to classroom exams for mathematics uh we didn't have the same concern with science the only concern that we had heard regarding science was the coupling with math which is why we decided not to make um uh dramatic changes to the science process right uh right now in in this year uh to make changes to the math process right now decouple science see how the science process goes and then if we feel like we need to make a recommendation at a future point we can uh but we didn't want to tie to classroom exams because of because of the pressure that it puts on um on on students each time they take a math test

041in uh fifth grade thank you for that feedback um in my opinion I I would think that and I could understand like a test being so stressful um but it still is a result if you only have one option at one one test to take to get into a program um opposed to an indicator and using data from a full Year's worth where to tell a child it's okay you still have four more tests you still have this you still have that and it allows a child to have a bad day day um I also worry about one test um having an over um recommendation of children just because children could um study to pass one test um so that's my own opinion my other question and this is where I believe we had a

042hiccup this um year was that the national test I would imagine is incorporating curriculum that is being skipped and I understand an accelerated program is skipping content but is there a manner where we could teach something where we're offering highlights of information to avoid children being required to go get tutored in sections that are totally missed in school because we are a public school so we should be offering all of the curriculum that we are setting as standards for our children in order to get into public school programs um also with my previous comment I wasn't using that just to be clear as a recommendation in my opinion to um break apart the science program I I think it's it's a good model in uh in solitude in terms of using test scores and labs

043and in different um uh gauging points that are data driven to assess a student's entry point uh and then I just had some other questions about the program prior to 2020 and if I'm understanding I went through some slides of some old presentations um and correct me if I'm wrong and please explain if you do know why that was changed but um in the 16 and 18 presentations there was uh a coupling of of students that were offered enrichment into an enrichment program and those were students that fell below the cost for acceleration and then they those students only in the enrichment so um they were offered eight weeks of an after school program of support so that no one ever had that pressure I didn't get in it's you have eight weeks and you

044could try again and and we're never missing anybody that's within that cusp so um if you could just share with me why that the removal of that program and and why that wasn't implemented here um would you like me to start with the multiple measures or whatever works I know I just gave it's okay that that was good there was some really great questions thank you so much first of all the enrichment program still exists um we we have math we have science in fact it's just about ready to run um after school and that it's interest based so anyone who really would like to participate is welcome to do so um it's not just Math and Science but we also have uh they're writing graphic novels um there are there you know advanced math

045games which are really wonderful as well so the enrichment program Al though it's not competitive it's it's still there um in addition to things like mathletes and um other options that we have the math Olympiad um in terms of the multiple measures I agree with you uh and we've been looking at it we've been doing some a deep dive into correlations with the nwaa because it's a national and the kids are taking it anyway three times a year but we didn't want to change halfway through the year because it's really not fair is it and if we had to go back and we had to say to them um you know just kidding that at the beginning of the year maybe I didn't try or pay attention or give it the effort I needed um

046during those three Administrations maybe we wouldn't you know we just didn't think it was fair um to do that at this point which is why we're doing that work and maybe NWA isn't the answer because we've been looking through four cohorts of data and doing that correlation work very carefully um if it's not the answer we're going to find something that is for that multiple measure but three times a year is very different than every unit test putting that kind of pressure on somebody who's that young did I did I answer yes thank you for that background but just sorry just for clarification though and I really appreciate all the programs youve put together for enrichment but just so I could understand better the enrichment was specifically identifying students that were at the cusp didn't

047meet acceleration or offer targeted support to get them over that Benchmark in order to make it into acceleration so that this way if a child was told let's say passing was 90 you got an 89 87 886 here you we didn't forget about you you're still going to you you now qualify for this cohort to be getting this targeted after school support in order to get you over that Benchmark so um it's not to possibly remove any enrichment that we're offering across the board but just more targeted support for those children that fall right below the Benchmark so that we're not losing any students that can qualify into that acceleration at whatever juncture you think it's appropriate so one of the things that we had done at the time is we um we restructured the

048whole fifth grade model to add builtin enrichment uh twice a week um two 30 minute blocks and so that's what we propose that we do um that we do also for sixth grade because you're right Nadia um that it there are students that will be in the class who will benefit from a greater Challenge and one of the things that we'd heard from our community meetings is that um is that there are kids that that require greater challenge in all grades so our plan in terms of adding this math coach is to begin by focusing on grades five and six building enrichment meaningful enrichment opportunities for students and then to uh and then and then to spiral that down so that we eventually hit all we eventually hit all of the grades so so first

049solidify what we're doing or strengthen I should say what we're doing with grade five while expanding into grade six uh and then in future years go to grades three and four um and then so forth and so on yeah hi thank you Dr chowski so um just my my perspective I think this is a very good outcome um I think the reality is we are getting good uh math results in Manhasset and preserving this program makes sense so um thanks to all the parents thanks for having a thoughtful uh discussion thanks to uh the administration for for thinking this through and again and I said this to some of you who who came out to the information session I mean I as a parent I am living this real time so I have a seventh

050grader who is double accelerated I have a ninth grader who was not double accelerated once we got over the disappointment of her not being double accelerated she performed very well in her math classes um Miss tallarini sort of identified her and others as someone who should double up which she's doing this year and thriving and she is now on an accelerated path such that if she wants to go all the way in math she can and that is always open to all of our students whether that was this program or if if uh or the the prior program or the one that we're going to Institute here so I I just think that um we we have to remember that the the the my observation is that the administration is taking a lot of care

051to put your students in the right classes at the right time because some aren't accelerated in fourth fifth or sixth some G gain more Mo momentum as they go into the secondary school and and that's like okay so I but I I think we are achieving the right balance of maintaining a a top level accelerated program um but also watching all of our students enriching those who need more enrichment at this age and and I think it's it's sensible the identification program the how you identify as we've talked about Dr posi is always the hardest part and there's always going to be sort of inherent disappointment and inherent uh disagreement about how we do that but you know that's we we we could under identify we could over identify but the if there are if

052there are mistakes or people around the C you still have every opportunity to go all the way in math in manhas so I just want to remind people of that um because I think it's I think it's important to to remember so I'll leave it at that thank you thank you um I just have a quick question to pay you back off Mariana um when she talked about science how it won't be a cap on the amount of sections um how you're saying that anyone can take the math test so we're opening it up to every student um it's there is there a cap on how many can do the double accelerated math no uh we're not doing that either I mean it's going to be potentially we'll see we'll see how that goes you

053know okay so it's you everyone gets a shot and if you hit it you hit it exactly and keeping along those same lines and thank you for your narrative Ted I I do want to Echo I think think the maintaining this sixth grade acceleration is is certainly in the right direction decoupling the science um the rubric the criteria is always the challenging part do we have a sense of that bright line right so if you have a larger number of students is it going to be an average would it make sense because I think to your point Dr posy if we're you know students are having anxiety over this one exam but yet you've had a a child who in fourth fifth and sixth they perform very well so would it be worth considering if

054not just their sixth grade grades fifth grade because I'm also understanding you've done enrichment now in this fifth grade cohort and they're performing very well so there is that sort of Equitable aspect there so should we be considering that trimester or perhaps two years of grades from a math perspective because then that would smooth over hopefully any you know I'll just be direct any concern in terms of teacher grading because now you're smoothing it over more than a year or two if that would be considered um versus this one year only one exam knowing that doing a little bit more due diligence you may add perhaps the nwea nwea something else so this year seems to be a particular outlier so maybe it would be worth considering the students grades over a longer period of

055time which is also a qu a quantitative measure versus a qualitative measure it's very good point the um and in fact in some of our conversations that we've had with uh with with with some community members we spoke about introducing multiple measures for this cohort uh in in uh 2425 the concern that we heard that really resonated with us was that um was that if you if you introduce that now and kids weren't prepared for it they didn't know that that was going to be one of the measures there was some concern that you know kids would have acted differently perhaps um so so that's the only that would be the only consideration is uh are we comfortable adding a measure that we didn't um that we didn't advertise was going to be part of

056the selection process for for now the secure exam has always been part of the selection process we're really removing um entrance criteria uh for this year we're removing the coat we're removing the teacher recommendation but we're maintaining the secure exam and then next year we hope to introduce probably the NWA maybe something else uh that would provide that would provide the second layer so you're right it's a one-year it's really a one-year issue so if I'm forgetting so we didn't include grades in the prior criteria no not since 2020 oh in Prior years we did but not in the last three not since we changed the program in 2020 when we moved it from fifth grade to sixth grade we changed the selection criteria and classroom grades were not uh were not included and the

057reason for that was based on the feedback from teachers about the pressure that it was putting on kids yeah and I certainly whoever the parent was I respect that feedback but if it was from one or two parents sort of had they not known I think looking at students grades over a full year or even if you needed to look at the prior year I think the difference here is you've enriched and I think you've shared really clearly with us that that enrichment for fifth grade they're doing very well so you would think that the performance and those grades from a overall perspective including those I just think it would make sense to potentially include grades that's another strong wrong quantifiable metric versus just a single exam and then not knowing what just in transparency

058I I think cut off I know we like to say bright line but in full transparency they will have to be a hard line whatever that's determined to make some decision making um need to be practical from that perspective for sure so you know the the um the only other consideration Mariana is that if we uh if we include other other grades which it's a decision point we could we could do that if that's um if that's what we feel is if that's what we feel is best as I said before no system is perfect every system is going to have flaws so um if we include other if we include other grades we're back to this rubric process we're back to how much do the classroom grades weigh how much is the secure how

059much does a secure exam count and then how much weight are you giving to both in order to in order to determine the selection criteria um in the conversations that we had with with some parents again uh you know the comment was well if the concern is that kids are skipping curriculum test test if they've if if they can skip the curriculum and uh you know so the secure exam uh the group felt and we agreed um made sense in terms of that it's not to say we couldn't create include another measure but if we do uh then we have to be be comfortable creating a rubric again with a cut off rather than relying on you know relying on um an entrance exam solely I want to thank everyone for your voices that makes

060a difference for all of us because without you guys like expressing your feelings and your thoughts it's important because otherwise nothing will get done um I want to thank the administration not the ch I and everybody for really looking at this and you know digging into it and making the right choices and doing it for the kids and I'm very happy to see that in the summer that we'll probably extend our subscription um reading for the math um program that we currently have that the kids can continue their education during the summer to keep them up here and thank you for that appreciate it uh as this is a discussion item uh it is open to the public for comment uh I know some of you have had opportunity to speak at other meetings as

061well as sent emails and you know the emails have been received by Administration the board uh and we thank you as everyone has said and to Echo that for your participation in this um it is a a team effort to get to the the finish line here uh but if there's any new information that someone would like to add that has not been said in the past or sitting on an email you have you can come up we just state your name any affiliation um and uh you have three minutes to uh in one question and a single question come on up good evening I'm s's Armstrong I have three students at uh Shelter Rock starting with a fourth grader a second grader and a kindergartner first I would I'd like to thank the board

062and the administration for agreeing to maintain the program that we value and want to keep for our students we applaud your decision and want to work with you to fine-tune it and enhance it and ask us for any support or assistance that you may require I understand that the 2425 year will be complicated as you will only have one uh measurement for assessment am I understanding correctly that in 2526 you intend on having more than one measurement so yes fantastic has the board considered a portfolio um Assessments in addition to just the um exam that will be monitored by the math supervisors of Long Island and by portfolio I mean perhaps a way to either either portfolio or a second assessment on that the school maintains or creates it just so we realize it's it's

063one question we for so she she's gonna answer that one in regards to the uh the portfolio you know it's not that's not a board decision on the portfolio that's Administration and that's the head of you know the curriculum looking at that aspect of it um that's not something that we decide as regards come to the recommendation from the administration for that got it do you have any other questions because we'll go through all if if you want to read read your questions then we'll respond uh I think um no I'm I'm I'm pretty relieved to hear that you're going to maintain the program and it's quite refreshing to hear that you have a plan in terms of uh narrowing down how you're going to uh assess who's going to uh join the program I

064do think having more than one measure is critical to assessments because we we can like uh previous members mentioned earlier lose some students so we have to give that some a bit more consideration as to how we will um have more than one measure because we clearly understand from the science that having more than one measure is ideal thank you so much for your comments once we uh finalize uh once we finalize the uh the selection criteria and process we're going to take all this information we're going to go back to our teachers we're going to go back to our team uh once we finalize it we'll send it we'll send out the information and a letter to the community so that uh so that's it's it's fully articulated but thank you for engaging with

065us in this conversation and once twice oh hi my name is Audrey yam I have um two kids in Mony Park so one's a fifth grader um so she is looking into this right now so quick question first question I have is um when are we going to have this exam I think you're saying that you're keeping the secure exam there's not going to be no coet right and then there's not going to be any teacher recommendation so um previously I think I reached out in back in September trying to understand this year's timeline I think I got a response saying that uh the coat is going to be administrated in March right now we're in February we're not going to administer the coat um we're not going to use the coat for this it's

066been proven to Be an Effective um as a as as an indicator based on our data analysis the secure exam we typically give in late May early June okay so again we'll communicate it um within the next few months okay and I think few weeks yeah you drawing a line right so what is the line like what what do people like New York State defines Mastery as 85% uh in terms of in terms of their exams so that's what we're looking at uh but we're still completing our data analysis okay so for this year 24 to 25 we looking at 85 to get into the program double accelerated yeah that's our M that's what New York State defines as Mastery okay thank you okay and I do want to thank everybody um for working so

067hard um on this matter um I do want to express like my comments I guess um I felt like the past couple weeks is a roller coaster ride for me to be honest like I heard about you know you guys had the meeting we saw um the presentation uh previously I've never looked into an elementary curriculum or ever attended a Boe meeting so that's my fault um but um I heard about it I got very shocked I didn't know what to you know I didn't know what to do um I you know I didn't know what to think I don't know where to look for information I don't understand your decision process I can't find a decision tree anywhere to me I was confused and I felt like a lot of the parents felt the

068same way hopefully um so felt like you know and within that very short period of time I felt like we were losing the program that we all treasured um and I felt like there the only way that I can do is to send an email to me I just felt like that wasn't enough um I went I attended both sea meetings I think you know I try to talk to you guys I felt a little bit better with that human engagement you know I see a real person you know I saw Ted and there and Mariana there I I felt a little bit better but I just felt like I don't know I I'm you know I'm a finance background so I like charts you know I like thr charts you know I like numbers

069I I love the statistics you know so I I wonder if there's anything the board you know the administration can do to make this decision-making process a little bit more transparent um more inclusive some more data um and engage more open community feedback mechanism into this whole process like coming into the meeting today right I was still like trying to figure out wait are they voting like is this set in stone how is this going to go forward I just don't know like so I had a lot of confusion so that's that's my you know that's my comment so thank you and uh and I'm glad that this is what got you engaged because there's always something that gets all of us in the community engaged and this was the the topic for you so

070on the uh School Board uh website it gives the list of topics and this was a topic that was going to be discussed uh we spoke about it last year that we wanted to dive into it so at our last meeting is when the initial presentation was going to be up so it wasn't a secret it wasn't hidden like it was up there uh that was the first presentation of it and it wasn't a presentation as this is what we're doing it was this is what the research because they spent the last you know 10 months diving into it research searching to come up with something uh I think they were very transparent into this was the thought process this is how it's evolved from 20 years ago of the gifted program to uh five

071years ago shifting to sixth grade and why the data showed all this it was a very uh transparent discussion in that uh and then what they at that point that we opened up community center community meetings to hear what the community had to say so there was an opportunity there to discuss it at the Schoolboard meeting and talk about it out loud uh and then we wanted to hear from the community so we opened up a midday one as well as an evening one that Schoolboard members attended to hear the community again making it transparent and open uh and all those presentations were put immediately on the website too so people could see it and here it's where if there was questions they could engage I know Dr chowski was on the phone talking to

072people as well as emailing um and regards to that and then the board members made themselves present at meetings as well so I think there was a lot of process to engage the community in this and to make it transparent uh this wasn't an overnight thing this was something that was worked on for the year and that was just ahead of it coming up as far as the presentation with it so uh I'm glad that this is great that you were able to you know engage and I'm glad you got to both meetings and came here and hopefully we see you at more uh to talk about it and um as we continue to go forward on this thank you Steve if I could just I so I think the other point I think I

073heard you say too is just are there ways that we could communicate with the community I think I'm also hearing that and there is an opportunity in terms of new new parents new students when they come in can we think about Rebecca are their opportuni to sort of share overall big picture about these programs sometimes I think it's more of just the awareness too I think that helps with new parents new students coming in particularly I like the idea of the new math instructor having them at an open house I think there's ways we could Bridge kind of that communication so from the process of this piece kind of I heard that but I also heard are there opportunities for us to bridge that communication mechanism with the community I go ahead Rebecca sorry I

074I'd also encourage um we do uh curriculum presentations at almost every U SCA meeting so we would encourage you and there those are usually recorded so if you are unavailable you know please Avail yourself of that thanks that was I was going to yeah we're on the same page yeah so yeah we changed all our curriculum presentations to go to the sca meetings so they have you have more direct back and forth because when we present here you know we we're Limited in the time of discussion the amount of questions so we moved all the curriculum presentations to SCA meetings so there could be more of a back and forth between parents and the heads of the department ments and the administration uh and then again those presentations are put online also so in a

075uh an effort to be more transparent have more uh access to parents we did that aspect at all so as well so that's something to take a look at the the sca when they send them out is when they're having the different department heads there and they discuss from elementary up through the uh the secondary school to kind of look at the path yeah I I did I did actually go back into your your meeting minutes and I did see like you started talking about this topic back in like November I think that was the first meeting that you're saying that this is going to be on the January 16 agenda like I guess like I'm not um in tuned with the specific wording and then did not think that this is coming along in

076the January understandable so yeah I I I do see that there is a sign I just don't didn't click it it didn't click I guess like I I guess I'll try to be more in tune with no and like and like Mariana said and we're always trying to find ways to be more accessible and communicate better of what the town hall means and things of that nature so our goal is to get more communication not less and have more access so we will continue to work on that as well from our end thank you so much right just wanted to add and I guess what we all said is thank you for your feedback that's very helpful for us hi I'm Jennifer Herber I'm a parent of a middle schooler and a daughter um in

077the uh Ms Park element so I have two comments about the decision- making a lot of it seems to uh rest on skipping sixth grade content and I just want to reiterate there's a way to not skip content if we um did more than just maintain this program we had an opportunity to improve it and we could have taken fifth grade and put fifth and sixth grade Jennifer is this in relation to the information that you shared the last meeting because we like like we said we're just looking for new information so if this is that do appreciate your input and value your input one of multiple points so if you'll just let me finish thanks minutes thank there's a if there's new information we'd appre maybe we consider expanding the program and not just

078maintaining it that was like the bare minimum so I would I still want to reiterate that there's an opportunity to actually improve the program you may choose not to do it but I would like everyone here to know that that is an opportunity that this whole idea of skipping is not necessary we could build it into the fifth grade program and advance in the fifth grade like we did before 2020 the comment about the children being stressed out in the fourth grade from all the tests that was due to a lack of flexibility and The Limited spots and I know we keep saying we have as many spots as students are qualified but it hasn't been true and maybe we're going to build it into the budget going forward but the fact of the matter

079is there has always been just one section in Elementary uh in each Elementary and so there were a limited number of spots and that and the lack of flexibility that that the Administration has put onto this since 2020 and I know the lack of flexibility came since then because I had a daughter who en enjoyed the flex exibility before that so I think that that's part of the stress I think it's induced by the whole process itself not necessarily that students can't be selected in the fourth grade the next point I want to make is about execution when it comes to like some of this bad data that we're referring to here saying that all with other schools only six to six to 10% of the student body is even in double accelerated mouth we

080have an exceptional absolutely exceptional student body here and um if we looked at Kat which is what we thought was a valid metric until about 10 minutes ago um n 50% of the kids here did over 90% nationally 90 percentile nationally on on math metrics like the the two math metrics of the Kat so we have an exceptional body and I don't think we should be treating it like well we should only pick the top six or 10% of the kids because that's what other schools do because we're not like other schools then my other comment is this and that is about Mrs Herbert we we asked for one comment or one question and this is you're on your you're on your third you're on your third comment now line is 85% children would end

081up in this program because based on our secure exams in the past only 17 kids would have hit the 85 we have a program of 56 kids so using that bright line this year for just one test would take a program that's currently 56 kids down to about 17 thank you Mrs harber good evening um my name is Char um I have two uh kids in the sh Rock uh one in sixth grade exactly in the double exer uh one is uh U kindergarten uh he's too busy figuring out which ball he likes more not math yet so I don't know I don't have a kids getting into the double O program in the near future in the next few years um but I do have some question is especially regarding if this is one

082entrance exam how the test content can be communicated with the parents I'm saying this because my daughter went through this program uh a year ago right so get getting to the um my understanding is for kette it was there is one test a year before so people get familiar with knowing where the kids are and then the next year take another one so when you get a results you're not surprised and you sort of no were making effort or not and so forth but for the next in fact in the previous program already there is another exam right after this uh cette right I I um I myself has heard of cases where the parents weren't aware what exactly is going to be in that program or in the test and then the kids didn't

083get in and they were surprised and kind of coming up with some kind of frustration and things like that right so um especially I assume this is regarding uh why uh trying to also test something about sixth grade math right so in that sense um it's more it's a question and also a comment that maybe some kind of communication needs to be done carefully um to make the parents who cares about this um to be aware of what's going to come up and potentially if the the kids get doesn't get in they're not surprised in some sense right I that's my question thank you so much for your for your question um the exam will the exam will Test sixth grad learning standards in mathematics so and uh when we draft our letter to the

084community we'll make sure that it includes that information and a link to what the standards are um but uh again just for just for clarity sake uh if students are not selected in sixth grade for the sixth grade double acceleration program there is a single acceleration opportunity in seventh grade and in seventh grade there's no cont cont that is skipped um so there's there there's no high stakes tests or anything like that to create uh for entrance into the seventh grade program so sixth grade will test the sixth grade learning standards and we'll include that in our communication appearance and then you can always follow up with the director of mathematics for more specific information thank you yeah um I just want to thank um everyone especially Dr passi Dr chowski and all the board

085um for hearing from the community um I myself participated in the in the town hall meeting and really um learned a lot through the process I really appreciate I can see everyone really cares about the Kids Care About Us um really appreciate thank you uh so we're going to uh move on to the presentation fund balance all right you are up I'll try not to sound like benstein something I said good evening thank you um this is one of the uh early and the Inception phases of the 2025 26 budget but also um as they would say budget season in general and this is the calculation of the tax levy limit which is in short how much money is the district allowed to raise under um a New York state law that was passed in

0862011 um over the prior year tax uh Levy now this is is an e-step calculation um which I'll um go through and hopefully explain um in uh in totality we start with our prior tax levy which was 9,748 822 that's what the voters approved in May of last year the second phase is what's known as the tax-based growth factor that is the number that was reported back in December new properties new constructions in the community that would add to the tax base so the first uh concept would be well does that include the Manhasset Crest not in totality that will be coming in future years once those rols catch up these are other new constructions within the Manhasset School District multipli together that's the adjusted tax base which is the first part of the calculation

087the next part I have to add is the pilots which are the payment in lie of taxes those are really two items that's Lipa and the Nassau County Housing Authority which is a very small portion Lipa is is over 90% of that of that number and for 25 uh for 24 25 our anticipated number was 1,610 567 now I have to take my exclusions which was really the bottom piece of last year's tax cap going through them one by one our debt service which is our bond and interest payments is 2,838 669 I deduct my building Aid which is a number that the state provides us I add back the district share of Bose's Capital expenditures to explain what that means Nassau Bose operat several buildings throughout the county each district has to pay a

088share of the capital expenses for their operation our number which is provided by bosis for 2425 was the $100,000 number and finally the energy performance contract which is also a debt service line uh uh just to note the $357,000 number that was the last year of the prior EPC so included in that calculation are my total exemptions which was just over 3 million subtracted from the the top number I have an adjusted tax levy that starts my 2025 26 calculation of 98 m655 455 now the next part is the allowable tax levy growth determined by the New York State Controller this is really your inflation Factor your CPI when the law was passed it stated that in that your allowable growth factor would be 2% or the rate of inflation whichever is less so this

089is measured on what's known from the Bureau of Labor Statistics the New York New Jersey CPI for December 31st 2024 the year ending the CPI was 3.3% so in this case it automatically defaults to 2% because that's the lower of the two numbers as we know 2024 continued the rate of high inflation it did go down slightly toward the end of the year but overall it was still higher than the 2% so we multiply that top number that I mentioned by the 2% to get to the next part of the calculation now I had mentioned earlier about the pilots I added it up there now I have to deduct next year's Pilots our estimate and I'll get into that in a little bit is 1, 643,000 $79 again the vast majority of it is Lipa

090and a small part from the Nasa County housing Authority which brings me to my tax levy before the current year exclusions so those four lines that I had on the top now I have to update them for 2025 26 what what am I anticipating our debt service based on our bond payments our bond anticipation note and interest payments and in discussion with our fiscal advisers we estimated 3,223 750 our building Aid we did get that number uh in toward the end of January is 276 372 and just to you know just to establish that's based on building projects that have been submitted to the state so that we do receive the building Aid on prior work and construction that has been completed uh last week we got our Bose's Capital expenditures it's up about $4,000

091and you'll see a large increase in the energy performance contract because this is the first year of the new EPC that is in place so our interest and principal payment uh equate to $715,000 total uh exclusions to that number is just over $3.8 million which brings my final tax levy uh tax levy to 102 m853 1035 or a 3.11% increase year-over-year um if you use the starting number the first number on top of the page the 99 748 and subtracted from 102 you get the difference of 3,14 313 so in essence that is the maximum amount that the district would be able to Levy toward funding the budget in the 20125 26 school year what was it last year Sam it was 2. 68% 68 so we're picking up like and half a percent right

092and the vast majority I just want to mention is based on our debt service and our EPC uh exclusions that fuel or that that cause that increase in 268 to 311 I just have a I don't know if I could have a quick answer to it because I know it's probably more in depth but the EPC was supposed to save us money and can you explain on how it's appearing here in a large amount but it also has been on our budget and other increments prior to this year so the EPC is designed to save money both in in in energy costs uh throughout the district through different lighting uh boilers Etc um with respect to the number here that is the principal and interest payment amortised over 18 years um although we do pay

093it from the budget it is excluded from the tax cap so you're able to raise money through the cap and not um have it restricted as in hit against the cap as in you have to cut something else you have to consolidate something else in order to to pay for it I don't know if that it yes yes thank you so it's essentially Falls like furniture and fixtures and it'll just be chipping away at it the same way furniture and fixtures would be sitting on a a quick bck and it just chips away at what the total amount is every single year perent exactly exactly and um there's a schedule that's also produced as to the anticipated savings each year from the EPC as well you drawing power uh efficiencies not using as much energy

094throughout Etc all right me go to the other one first the other this the other presentation yeah yeah uh no the other one the big one there it is yep all right so the second uh presentation of the evening is the uh projected fund balance um for the 2425 uh school year uh as um as we are looking at it with an end date of January 31st 2025 so through the first seven months of the uh school year I apologize for the size of the uh the font on the screen there is a there is a lot uh in there but um I'd like to go over some of the main drivers what you see in front of you right now is the projected Rev and if you scroll all the way down to the

095bottom uh of the page you'll see that our projected Revenue uh amount over budget would be approximately $552,000 we're projecting that we'll have just over half a million dollars uh in overage um at the end of the school year so let's take a look at what makes that number um as mention mentioned before um there is a bit of a pilot increase the uh number that's been determined by Nassau County and Lipa uh the schedule has been Chang so it looks like we're getting an advance on that money so that money um we're looking to put that in deferred revenue which is the asterisk next to it but that is number that we would recognize as some sort of Revenue in 2425 uh the next big line which was a very big driver last year

096is interest and earnings um we're actually on track to match or possibly slightly exceed last year's number should rates continue or be within the same ballpark um as they are right now and we're anticipating an additional $234,000 uh there uh the other big areas uh of note state aid there is uh a dip of 273,000 um that is not because state aid has been withheld I just want to mention each year the state does prior year adjustments in one way or another based on Transportation Aid enrollment Etc this year we did have a deduct of $127,000 which is explained as to some of the estimates that they provided at the time were higher than what they should have been for the district and also expense based STS which is the actual usage with certain um

097with certain programs such as special ed that came in lower than what the state estimated we do have some additional state aid coming from our Intermediate Care Facility program which rounds out the revenue side for an approximate $552,000 um overage over budget for 2425 now going on to the next page is the expense side which going to go in depth as to the areas that brought us to this estimate so split um among approximately a dozen different codes are the areas of the expense side of the budget that would either produce fund balance or we would be short and the first one which is the largest uh section of the budget which is compensation salaries we're looking at an approximate fund balance of $430,000 uh for the 2020 uh 425 school year against a budget

098of just over 55.7 million the next area is equipment um our budget's 1.55 million and we're anticipating about 12,000 left over after some anticipated uh expenses that uh would be necessary for the district we're looking at a bit of a shortage in Transportation uh codes um due to routes and other uh trips from here till the end of the school year and our total contractual codes we looking at almost a break even out of an $8 million uh budget of 92 uh 70 in that regard um our special ed legal uh code which is one of the four legal codes that we maintain in the budget we're looking at actually an overage uh in terms of a surplus of $65,000 however uh similar to last year our contract therapy codes um for special education um

099is an area of vulnerability we're looking at just under $350,000 short and that is again based on required Services uh supply of providers out there and also cost that uh is associated with it on the flip side we did have some changes in uh tuition which is um allowing a surplus of just under $440,000 um for our public uh special ed tuition our private school tuition based on one placement is uh is causing a bit of a um shortage in that code as well and with respect to our bosis code it's almost a break even at uh at $23,000 rounding out the remaining um expense codes our supply codes um again on a budget of just under 1.6 million we're anticipating a $45,000 Surplus and interest expense that is a oneline item that's our tax

100anticipation note uh which is uh a borrowing that occurs uh in the late summer uh early fall uh when the budget was developed it was projected at one particular interest rate um the interest rate um was a little bit higher um so there is a bit of a shortage at $133,000 um our employee benefits code which I'll get into that we are anticipating a surplus of 500 uh just just over $500,000 particularly because our uh 2025 rates that came from N Ship uh were considerably lower than what was anticipated so that was a very big um a very positive surprise not just for Manhasset but throughout all districts that participate um also finally our interfund transfers those are our uh transfer to special Aid our spor special ed program our school lunch program and also

101our debt service um we actually do have a bit of a surplus um the estimate as to how much was needed um was higher than than what we went out for a borrowing so that does uh provide us with a little bit of fund balance there overall our expense side of the budget fund balance is 1,124 259 that's what we're anticipating for the 2425 school year and the bottom calculations if you add your revenues and expenses you get the 1.67 million um fund balance from rollover posos that's basically purchase orders last year that either were encumbered the services are not being rendered the supplies are not coming in and they would be liquidated adding to the fund balance and then finally the number that says dedicated to the 2425 tax levy that is when we

102said how much money are we going to use from the prior year budget to offset this year's budget that was the $840,000 number um if you recall that was $116,000 more than the prior year putting all of those numbers together how much fund balance are we anticipating for the year is 1,428 um to put that in terms of percentages that is approximately 0.9% so it is a very tight it is a very um it's a very uh thin budget um typically as our Auditors uh had said back in November um you do want to run fund balance between 2 to 4% so 9% is very much on the low side but this is again a preliminary estimate it could change um however there are some contingencies that are built in but also included in this

103estimate are items that we feel we do need um to pursue as you'll see in the footnotes there are some equipment purchases contractual repairs and uh legal fees that we uh estimate to be approximately $200,000 over budget also included in some of the footnotes are some of the items that are drivers within the expense side and the projections uh as well to go a little bit deeper into the area producing the most amount of fund balance which is the benefit codes and again I apologize for um the the size of the the slide in front of you I want to draw attention to a few particular uh codes the first is the Employee Retirement System what we budgeted versus what was actually expensed did produce uh a little over $200,000 in fund balance um the

104remaining codes again overage is based on estimates at at the time versus actual uh invoices and and bills that have come in and if you look at the very bottom toward the bottom you'll see that in our Active Health Insurance code we're anticipating a little over $300,000 in fund balance for our active employees and our for retirees um just under $142,000 in fund balance and I'll get into it into the uh the specifics um in a moment overall and I just want to make mention it does say 53,000 on the p on the previous slide that is because of rollovers and also monies that have been transferred out of benefit codes but if you're looking at straight expense versus Straight What was a approved by the budget you will see that again it is a

105very very small amount of money $570,000 over a nearly a $28 million uh budget so you're talking you know really only about 2 and a half% of that that's being produced in fund balance to put it in different terms and different percentages if you look at how much benefits have increased from 16 years ago since this was being tracked in 20091 the benefits line alone has increased nearly 94% back in 201910 benefits cost the district 13.4 million now in 2425 it's 28.2 million the increase in benefits as a percentage of the 20091 which is how much did benefits cost the district over the general fund back in 20 20091 was 16% and it's a lot more 28% 29% is really the number for the current year the increase in the budget from 20091 to now

106the budget has gone up $3.2 million and the percent increase in the 242 budget versus the 29 versus the 201910 budget which is how much was it then versus how much is it now that percentage is gone up over 37% so just to kind of put in perspective how much benefits do cost addition and how much are they in relation to the total general fund so I had mentioned a little bit earlier about our benefits code and if you look at the Active code you'll see that we budgeted and during budget season last year 372 uh active employees and you'll see what we estimated for the premium and at the time we said we think benefits the cost of the night ship plan is going to go up approximately 7% um we were shocked that

107the plan went up 79 cents which is unheard of um however the actual number of employees those electing to take coverage you'll see the comparison was 370 so it was nearly spoton however again that driver was really how much did we estimate for the second half of the year which came in much lower um versus um you know compared against really only a variance of two individuals going through the calculations the employee contributions how much they pay toward their insurance you'll see that this $32,000 number is how much we're projecting for just our active employees and again you're only talking about a staff mix staff variation of two people primarily driven by the fact that health insurance remained relatively flat for the 2025 calendar year now in 2024 25 when we look at our retirees

108we see a similar Trend we budgeted for 428 employees um to compare last year we budgeted for 46 employees 409 have uh have elected or are taken coverage um there there are differences you know based on people we anticipated to potentially retire we didn't have a lot um and also life changes as well similar Trend to Active Health Insurance um we did assume that the numbers were going to go up about three just under 4% but the changes were 0.53 10% and 0.9 so it was a very very small uh amount that it did go up as well in this case the Big Driver was we did budget 428 people 409 are on the insurance as of the last bill couple with that that it was not a big increase altogether and we're looking at

109just under $142,000 in a savings um in fund balance for the insurance code okay so this is a slide that we put up during the audit as to if these numbers are what they are right now how would it look in terms of how much money can we put in reserves at the end of the fiscal year starting with our proverbial 4% of $ 4,451 th000 we include our revenues over budget of 552 we include our expenses under budget of a million1 124 to get to the 1.67 million doll number take away the appropriated fund balance if that was to stay the same in developing the 2025 26 budget is the $840,000 number I would be left with approximately $680,000 to that we could put into reserves that is based I want to mention and

110this is a very very preliminary assumption that this is based on a budget that would increase approximately 3 and a half% the reason I say that is last year's budget went up 3.3% if we're to estimate that the budget Goes Up 3 and a half% so you're talking about a difference of $200,000 from 3.3 to 3.5% you'll see that our unassigned fund balance our 4% would be the $4.6 Million number which would allow for the $680,000 number that we could put into reserves and also be in compliance with the with the statute the next few sheets are just a a rehash of what was discussed during the audit presid presentation our numbers at June 30th for the last several years you'll see that at June 30th 2024 the general fund balance as a percent of

111budget was higher than in previous years it was 11% that was primarily due to a larger than anticipated Revenue um over budget for that year in the previous year it was 8% so our total fund bals are unreserved plus our reserved Monies uh combined together give us an 8% um over total and if you see actually in the 22 school year it was 7% so it has steadily increased the next slide is a description of our reserves um and fund balance um I do want to bring uh mention that in this one number three reserve for repairs uh included is the $170,000 that was prev previously approved out of the repair Reserve for the uh Middle School HVAC unit um this does have to be replenished at some point and the only way for that

112to occur is it does require voter approval so through the budget process the remaining pages are a description again of the reserves that the district maintains and fund balances and we going to bring up the final slide so the final slide to Standalone is really a broken it's a breakdown of the expense codes um a little bit further you see as we go down how much fund balance we do anticipate in each of uh the codes as mentioned before but most important is the 5year average um and how that is uh that that is trending so if you look at compensation the 5year average is 172,000 equipment is 102 transportation is 151 special at tuition is almost um exactly um as we anticipate for this year um contract therapist um it is a little bit

113uh higher in expense this year our special EDS uh fund balance is actually anticip anticipated to be a bit lower uh this year and see with uh our legal that is uh been that has been running uh in the red for for several years and that's where where you see the average uh start to dip our maintenance uh code is a little bit lower um with the 5year average supplies is a bit higher our tax anticipation note interest that's really a product of the last two years and interest rate fluctuations um employee benefits we did have um an increase last year in fund balance there that's why you see it closer to $700,000 and as you see for the remaining amounts they are relatively small in comparison so overall the 5-year average fund balance is

114a milliion 387 939 our anticipated expense side fund balance is $1,124 th000 so it is trending a bit lower year over-year so what does that mean um our fiveyear average is just under 2% and we are looking at just under 2% for the 20242 uh school year as you see the numbers the fiveyear average is 1.95% we're looking at 1.99% fund balance which is our percent remaining over over budget and that is relatively low that again that is a very very tight number um in comparison to what um has been discussed before from our external Auditors um with that that's all I have thank you Sam for that in-depth riveting presentation maybe more colors next time no thank you no Sam this is this is no small task I know this is the start of

115many presentations for the budget and thank you so much for you know taking it on in the detail of this and and everything um any questions from the board so I guess my first question is so so for this for this very preliminary 2526 we're we're saying this $840,000 number we're basically holding that flat that designated designation from the prior year tax levy effectively as of now as a starting point only subject to change but just rolling it over from year to year I mean do we want to try and get that down yes I mean like I mean so I would say should to the extent we have the room like that would be one thing I would try and dial down as you go yeah that was one of the things we talked

116about um s can you just turn your mic before second okay that was one of the things we talked about last year we increased the uh appropriate fund balance by about $168,000 we should be trying to shrink that so that we can put more money towards reserves we also do have to have to replenish the repair Reserve at $170,000 we are um contract therapists is also a major concern I mean $330,000 in the red uh we're running right now two years in a row uh we can plug it um preliminar we're looking to plug it a little bit higher uh next year uh but there that is still the biggest vulnerability I think that that that exist structurally within the budget and so so you're you're assuming that we will you have your 3.11 which

117is the maximum allowable right and taking taking all those revenues um if we have relief in other areas of expenses I mean is there a scenario where we we don't go to 3.11 I know that it's been brought up in the past but I'm not sure if it's been explored but with the contract therapist that's a line item that's continuing to grow we've heard all other school districts are scrambling to um seek the same therapist from the different centers it would be an area to explore to bring on and I understand we have contracts um but we if we had in-house related Services we would be able to save there even if we are paying for retirement in healthare especially when we know that it would be meeting different points aside from fiscal we would

118have services available for our students and we have the students iips and know and can gauge how many full-time staff we would even be able to start with uh and that would be an area to alleviate from our budget that's certainly something we can look into doing I will say that having tried to hire OTS and PTs in Prior districts it's not the easiest EST position to fill it you know depending on what contract we give them how many hours they can work and then finding people who are qualified and willing to do the work with our kids it's a challenge it's it's actually not as simple as I anticipated it being you know you figure you have your own folks and they can do all of the things you need them to do um

119but it was not easy to find Qualified people who are willing to do the work and really dig in with the kids and be able to give them a schedule on a contract through civil service with a salary that's amendable to the folks who are in those positions so as much as I would love to say yes let's do that and let's bring in all of our own people um I was trying to find one in my prior position and I could not fill it I a whole year of civil service it's not the only route we could go but a lot of people do go those civil Ser service route and then it's you have to go through the list and then ask for another list the Civil Service process is painful and not

120the easiest to navigate so it's certainly something we can look at we can run the numbers as to how many folks we would need what kind of a contract that would look like but just remember that a teacher has x amount of minutes they can do in a day right and they have then their lunch their prep Etc so we have to look at how many sessions we can get out of a contract therapist and what the cost of that would be versus how many sessions a contracted person of our own sorry our own person not an agency contract would be able to work and what the cost of their salary plus benefits would be and the salary would have to be high enough to entice the people in so if we're putting our salary

121at a nomin like at a kind of a base value um I think Mr Panza could say from his own professional experience you're going to need to pay people well to get appropriate physical therapist and occupational therapists in so it's just something to consider those are the challenges that I've run into trying to do that this is my own professional experience also it's what I do for a living and a lot of therapist um first of all uh I'm not familiar with them going through civil service so I know that speech pathologist otpt related services are hired outside of that scope for school districts as staff um can be that's a different we could certainly look into secondly most contract therapists seek to be working for a school district because in the centers that they

122work for they don't receive benefits so there is um a big interest for therapists to actually have a full schedule not have to commute between school districts so uh I strongly recommend that that is something that we do look into because we see this line item going up we have data sorry of our students iips to show how many sessions they do have certainly and they're on they're localized in one site so um it is and I understand civil service but the therapists don't have to go through there no it's true we don't have to do that Hi Sam thank you um I have a question regarding the the health insurance I believe it is the benefits that we pay all of that um the question I have is um the I I know you

123stated that it's um tabled like you know leveled off for this year in particular but there like is there like a correlation between the amount of employees that we currently have versus the amount of employees that we've had in the past that would that would affect the number what we're paying now being higher versus maybe in the past I understand benefits have increased in price but does anything with the amount of staff that we have versus just a question yep undoubtedly yes um any staff increases would cause the benefit shift uh to to go higher or lower either in in either direction um and part of it is also how many um change coverage throughout the year as well so let's say that there's a life event that they go from the individual plan to

124the family plan or vice versa that would also affect the um how much we would pay and how much they would also pay into it but um the short answer to your question is yes I should also mention with respect to health insurance that I think it was three years ago um another unprecedented move that the health insurance rates dropped um this is around the time when elective surgeries were not happening people didn't go to the doctor and that was reflected in in the following year the year after that the rates spiked so um it is a little bit surprising that they did level off for 25 but it remains to be seen for 26 Sam just a really quick question on the repairs maintenance miscellaneous contractual boies just looks like there's a between 23

12524 and 22 810 versus the 132 I'm just curious that line seems to was fluctuating a little bit any in I I would have to look into it but I think that was um likely due to um budget adjustments that were done for a particular purpose but I'll get back to you on that okay no problem thank you and last budget question I don't know it it might not be here but if I remember there is another school or private school that we will require to support funding for services is that going to impact the 25 budget I thought I remember reading somewhere that there is a school and we will have to account for yeah we have to um we will have to provide uh Health and Welfare Services to another to another District

126um so that'll be included in the budget I'm sorry to another religious school in the community that'll be included in the budget the cost of that will be offset because we will bill out uh the districts that uh of residents where the students where the students live okay so it's it'll be hopefully a an even yeah we have to ENC it it we don't get the money back in the same year typically so we have to encumber the money but yes eventually thank you do remember this um we did have several U maintenance and repair codes um that were not expensed in 23 24 which contributed to a large part of that 810 Sam thank you so much and next week or in two weeks we get the preliminary budget all right great all right

127moving right along going right to policy review and uh first reading of pole Watchers so pole watches I'm actually gonna recommend to the board I'm going to pass this to include it into 1050 I think there was a thought to have a separate if you don't mind passing these um to have a separate policy or guideline um but in fact we could include it into 1050 which we're already reviewing so I'd like to direct the board's attention because we'll cover 1050 and 1 sitting turn to sorry the pages aren't numbered but it would be section five and so I'll read it and then we will send it to Nicole to post but I have some suggestions for the board um adding information to provide Clarity and also an ability for the district clerk for pole

128Watchers so the role of a pole Watcher is to observe elections at the polling site on behalf of a particular candidate to the Board of Education pole Watchers should notify the district clerk um this is where it's either in writing or email no less than 72 hours I think other districts I think the example was mipa they actually had longer than 72 hours so we might want to leave that for consideration if we want to provide a longer window um to the uh 72 hours prior to the election candidate may not serve as pole Watchers pole Watchers shall sign in with the district clerk upon arrival at the polling site to help facilitate an orderly functioning of of polling sites candidates for the Board of Education should ensure the poll Watchers scheduling is such that

129no more than two poll Watchers per candidate are present at the polling site at any given time and poll Watchers may arrive 15 minutes before poll opening to observe the setup and polling preparations a pole Watcher may not electioneer be unobtrusive and interfere with the voting process in any manner any questions or concerns should be raised to the district clerk and I did uh omit the phone number which I have to add the phone number so my um policy recommendation to support um direction to pole Watchers is to include it in 10 oh sorry 10:05 I think I said 1050 before 1050 um to keep it together with the annual budget and vote for Schoolboard elections because that's where we have the information on electioneering and other details Y and then I just wanted to

130pause um and then we'll get to the ballads and this will come back because it'll be considered the first reading on this piece on this section for pole Watchers would that be correct so that you guys can and the information that you put here in the pole Watchers is this uh recommendations from the state recommendations from the legal is it based it's just it's it's a it's actually a combination um there was some information from mipa other surrounding like local I tried looking for similar kind of guidance I did look at State language New York City actually had a nice pamphlet but it they had it was a lot detailed more for election um what I would say more political versus this is more school Community oriented providing directional information we certainly can have legal

131take a look at it but it's pretty straightforward it's more of particularly for anyone new I'll just say for example myself I had no idea you could have a pole Watcher you know what did people do um so having the ability to read this and understand directionally would be helpful it seems very straightforward I think the shoot off legal just to make sure there's nothing we're missing but I it looks very straightforward I think and I think that's this is the right place to put it also to incorporate into this policy that makes sense yeah keep it together I I I don't know what others think but to have a separate Standalone um checklist or guideline versus keeping it within the policy would be helpful um the other this is um I remember if we

132said this is the second reading on the ballads so this has come up a couple of times and so at the last so this this one would be the second um absent so the recommendation is to have a general section that talks about ballads and the specific language that I had verbally mentioned last meeting but formally written here absentee ballots and absentee ballot application forms as well as other ballots required by state law will be made available for all district elections in accordance with the education law so what that affords us is if there are changes uh for example that are required by the state law uh we would abide by that um so this will so the two items um I will check in with Nicole and legal um does it behoove us for

133inwriting or email for requests I know that we're saying they should sign in for the pole Watchers and then I will add the District Clerk's contact information so that's something we can follow up with um I think we could combine those and and look to move it to a third and final reading next time like based on if you get those changes in legal takes a quick look at it and it's it's good instead of go since they ones in first ones in second we can just combine and go to third and final yeah I'd be okay with that and then aside from legal looking at it I think it's exact language from uh one of mpa's recommendations and prior to this appearing in our policy we had informal protocol and it's exactly follows what

134we've been doing within the district annually the next policy is I the two additions um one suggest question which I edited um Dina had asked for 10 working days so this was under employee notifications of disciplinary record request so the change from the last meeting was I think I had it as a placeholder for five and it was more practical to have 10 working days and then the other suggestion was to add um and this is where I did want to confirm the correct placement of the names and titles um direct any requests to Sam Sam service assistant superintendent for business operations and Dena magic magiko assistant superintendent from Human Resources so admittedly I don't remember if we said um add it within the text of employee notification of the 10 working days versus direct

135any requests to Sam because the way that the the wording and the state requirement is listed um that it's in some sense it's required by the public office so that when someone requests or or foils uh for a former employee it's it's a requirement to actually um notify or inform that individual so I don't think that they necessarily would have questions or notify per se but having a point of contact so that's actually a a point for discussion do we want to have um Dena and Sam's name there or what are what are the thoughts on that just titles I agree that yeah yeah agreed um so this would be are we should we vote on this one this would be I think this is the third and final on this one there's the third

136but I think the correct one has to be the the clean the clean one has to be okay without the names taken off and clean copy yeah okay like just that where it just has the title on it so we're voting on what's going to be okay okay we'll table it and we can vote on it next time with those changes and okay got it thank you all right 2526 graduation date we have an adoption here for the Cal we already adopted the calendar this is for the graduation date of June 20 202 6 at 5:00 p.m on the school calendar this is for next year school calendar all in favor great moving right along to board discussion and committee reports uh audit committee all right GIC Finance Mac we meet later also uh SCA

137it's been a lot of town hall meetings the last couple SCA Fair need volunteers it's very important director of the sca this year which is huge right but we do need for the hot dog stand and I believe another stand we need parent volunteers it's very very important young parents should get involved this is for the young children of Manhasset our Athletics is also helping out to that make sure that probably local teams will not have any sporting events as much as you know so they can come and enjoy and raise money for our district so please consider thank you and that's great and the passion that we had in regards to the passion that we had for double accelerated and everything else we need that kind of passion volunteering board and we need somebody

138to help with the journal as well so please really really put yourself out there we have parents that have been here for a while and they'll help you learn how to do it and teach you and and guide you so that this can continue on for the next These funds go directly to the students right everything goes back to the school and the kids power Foundation big dance yes yes as a reminder um it's actually coming up can't believe it um March 8th uh 7:30 Moonlight and Monte Carlo dinner dance and casino um hopefully I'll see many of you there I did want to just um put in a plug that they're champions for charity the results um was very successful um so they did um uh raise approximately $30,000 um they do continue as

139Dr posi mentioned would like to work with us to support the um badge swipe so we always appreciate um all the funds the tower and supports the community and so those are the two quick updates um and oh actually I I don't want to forget because um my youngest attended and it was very very successful the junior Tower uh bingo night it was so fun the room was packed um and that was a great night and so that was from the junior Tower um group uh that happened actually last week um the pace meeting we have our next meeting on March 4th so it's right after the break Kasa yes a couple of updates from Connie so there were some really good successful events in January January 22nd January 7th um I think the key

140is the screen agers under the influence you know a lot that Connie is doing and supporting under the the impact of our digital age and so I want to highlight upcoming events February 27th the author book discussion Dr Rich will lead an interactive book discussion on the mediatrice guide raising healthy smart kind kids in a screen saturated world as a follow-up to this event and so I would Echo the community and folks to lean into these conversations because I can say personally um the digital age is a benefit and also a curse in some ways to our um children particularly in the elementary um grades March 5th raising empowered athletes for parents with children in grades 8 to 12 March 11th Sullivan's message love loss hope purpose stories of life-changing moments and then on March

1412 25th uh Zoom with Jessica Ley educator and bestselling author of The Gift of failure so I do know that um there are emails that go out about these reminders and to sign up so I'd encourage everyone to take a take a look and register uh and at the EOC uh a lot of work going towards the summer program uh coordinating with adventures and learning and our our math and science departments uh as well as the EOC uh is working on Harlem Wizards uh coming again so they're taking that uh that on all right moving along uh resolution to approve the Personnel schedule everyone looked at that earlier all in favor of the Personnel schedule okay uh we have a a resolution to approve the uh mesp side letter in regards to sick Le contribution

142all in favor and if you take a look at consent agenda there uh we have some of our contracts that were're approving for the summer work that's on there uh fuel trips that are on there uh accessing uh grounds equipment uh reports treasure Financial uh any questions about consent agenda oh I just had one question on one of the consent items um maybe we can get some clarification I I see that there's a change order and there's a I believe a credit um I just wanted to get some insight which H I know it's says mty Park but um when was this work started and completed oh that was from 2022 that was from um project that started I believe in 1920 it was a steam pipe uh bursted in 2022 so this is paying

143the contract of that any other questions on the consent agenda right motion to approve consent agenda all in favor great uh upcoming items of interest uh we meet again on March 6 after the break to he the preliminary budget and uh we get into all budget hearings after that uh that'll be the only presentation for those uh for those nights uh we're open to public comment all right thank you uh motion

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.