001e um so we'll get our uh meeting started we'll start with the pledge to the flag please I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all well good evening everybody and especially to our students here thank you uh thank you for your patience and waiting for us uh the uh first item on our agenda is uh Communications from the public and press do I see anyone from either the media or from the public here I don't think so that would like to address the board seeing no one uh we'll move on to our next item and um it's labeled board correspondence but as is normally the case we don't have any board correspondence
002but we did um start what I hope is going to be something of a tradition last month uh by taking a little bit of time to um recognize some of the uh Allstar uh in last month's case students this month's case students uh we could also do programs uh St faculty uh any number of uh of different groups that have done something to distinguish themselves and to uh to give them some well-earned recognition um tonight um I'd like Mr Burke to kind of walk us through um some recognition for uh some of the students that have taken PL uh Taken part in uh area all state or uh even more uh petitions Mr Burke so in just a couple of moments we'll be handing out certificates to some of the finest musicians in what is
003truly the best music program I think in the North Country every once in a while Mr Oliver will introduce our Coral con or our concerts and say that uh he'll he'll mistakenly say it's one of the best and then he corrects himself and says it is the best and he's darn right it is the best and we have some of the best of that group here tonight um these students earned an opportunity to participate with the area all state which I learned is really quite the honor because they have to get judged by an outside independent evaluator and score high enough to make that competition and so again extraordinarily proud of these individuals there are 13 that are going to be recognized with a certificate and on behalf of the administration just to know how
004absolutely proud We Are of you and and what you do for our district and representing us so incredibly well it's not just Talent it's everything else that you bring to the table so very very well done and I'm happy to have you folks here tonight and I'd ask Mr hagget if he'd be willing to help sure hand out the certificates first we have [Applause] cor Adele [Applause] Corf Emma Coral Jordan corber [Applause] nichas Johnson Tres up also Nota all but also conference allate [Applause] can I say just one more sure so as as long as we're talking about music we have representatives of the music Ms music friends here and uh they are also to be congratulated so it's so interesting right and so impressive not only are they here to support concerts and and
005raise funds but they're here also to as we recognize our students so again what incredible support I think that's goes part and parcel for why our music program is so incredibly strong so thank you to our MS music friends as [Applause] well thank you Mr Burke and thanks to all of you for being here uh this is uh certainly a a pleasure to uh to recognize uh um individual and group achievements like this and um don't feel like you need to stick around however if you'd like to see democracy in action feel free to stick around uh moving on well see you later moving on in our agenda we'll move on to uh information and reports and uh we'll start with uh Isabelle with our student ex officio report the forest Department actually went at
006elementary schools today student council did to be to the bus drivers at the bus for all them thanks very much uh Isabelle and uh we'll move on now to the facilities committee report and trusty LeBlanc so the facilities Comm met at medicine on November 25th uh we had the regular crew and we had some guests called Terell Anna and Phil s from K and K we talked about Capal project with Phil we discussed the maximum cost allowance for school and we realized that the high school we're going to have a big challenge to decide what's going to make it because we have a lot of projects to go the pool the ASC the turf the girls locker room the roof the bathroom the kitchen the GU the gym entrance special and all that those are
007all competing priorities and we have a limited amount of money as we going expain later and we also will need to plan the five year have fiveyear plans for the rest of the school because we have a certain amount of money for for each School each year uh we talked about the hbac pro project but we didn't have an engineer so next meeting we should have a King and King engineer to talk more about our options we talk about leasing vehicles instead of owning the vehicle we have we have eight vehicle that we're looking at leasing for the future we spent some time talking about undering the tractors and dump because dump trailer because of the rust in the L country and we did not tour medison nothing was reported there was teachers night that
008evening so after a few hours we lifted the meeting we were supposed to meet last earlier this week but we didn't have enough materials so we're going to meet next month January 27th at 5 o' at the junior high I have a question um in terms of leasing vehicles are we talking about uh you know sort of the short-term future for that or is I guess my impression is that we basically own all of our vehicles outright or are we financing some of them no currently we we own all of our vehicles um one of the things that we're looking at is are we keeping our vehicles too long and what is that cost of of ownership so the um a number of schools bosis have switched over to a lease program through Enterprise and
009we've been exploring that so for example next year one of the things that we'd be looking at uh as pretty high priority needs would be two new Vans um as well as at least one new passenger vehicle um last year we purchased two traverses one was really supposed to be for um staff going to conferences they both been occupied by Transportation um so if we just talk about three new vehicles we're well over $100,000 and that still doesn't address some of our other needs with a plow truck that's starting to fall apart um another truck that we uh have replaced the transmission I think now three we're on the third Transmission in the past year um so basically what we're looking at is a lease program where it'd be around I think it's around a
010$70,000 cost for the first year and what we would be doing is we' be able to circulate those in and out um Enterprise actually watches the market so after a year or two years they're watching your mileage they'll make that recommendation that Now's the Time to get rid of the vehicle it has a high tradein value and that's when you would do that so you'd be making those moves pretty consistently um locally St Lawrence County I believe believe the village of MSA St Lawrence leis bosies and I believe there's at least one other school locally um within our region that are using Enterprise um to manage their fleets and to do this vehicle purchase um it looks like it's a good promising program but we we'll have much more detail for the board considering uh
011throughout the budget process okay thank you was King and King supposed to be at that meeting the way you worded it sounded like they were supposed suppos to be there and they weren't s was there but the engineer I thought he was going to be there but he wasn't yeah the engineer wasn't um I I wasn't under the impression that the engineer would be there and we ended up with HVAC questions okay and I'll talk probably a little more about that with the maximum cost allowance okay any other questions for Roar all right we'll move on now to the policy committee report and trustee Monroe okay uh before I go over our uh November policy committee meeting I just want to advise everyone if you haven't noticed yet uh we are a month behind in
012our policy meeting minutes there's a clerical error on my end in getting the meeting minutes to Ashley in time and we wanted to make sure that board members had ample time to review the the meeting notes before the meeting and unfortunately last month that wasn't going to be able to happen so uh we're we're month behind right now we did meet this month also so those meeting minutes will be on the the uh January agenda and uh we'll see what we can do to get those caught up but uh as far as our meeting November 12th um we reviewed a number of policies in the 3,000 series um in one in the 7,000 uh the first one was 7131 and um we re we recommend resending the current policy and a need to discuss the
013creation of a new policy um that's for non-resident students uh Mr Burke had recommended that we also take a look at the Canton Central School District policy and see what they're doing and see if we can instead of Reinventing the look at their policy as a solution to uh to our policy as well uh in the 3000 Series uh the review only updates were for 3261 3262 uh solicitation of students um and then advertising so those were review no updates uh 3263 also review uh solicitations of personnel 3270 we we recommend resending uh as it's an exact duplication of 3280 in terms of the wording uh 3275 nominating recognition of community honores that was also reviewed no updates to that policy uh as well as 3280 that was the uh the duplicate policy that we
014recommend keeping uh 3310 uh we reviewed uh public access to records and we recommend one change that was just grammatical 3320 confidentiality of computerized information we reviewed this policy in and uh we have a few questions regarding access by employees of the district uh especially those in the IT department and there was some discussion about certain information and need to access it and need to access it with superintendent approval um if that's something um we might see fit um and then we also recommended adding a reference note to the existing um technology and it policy as well 3410 code of conduct on school property um we're we recommend replacing the current policy with the recommended irie1 updates uh which includes a section on privacy rights 3411 unlawful possession of a weapon on school grounds review
015only no updates to that policy 3421 Title 9 sex discrimination um again updated version with area updates and legal changes um and I have my notes here that page seven the first paragraph uh was the grammatical uh the word Target should be timely in that um that policy 3510 emergency closings review only no updates to that policy and 3520 extraordinary circumstances so we uh recommend resending that policy um as that policy was the basis of a covid forign policy um but also we we decided in the event of a need to uh to look at this policy we would pretty much already be uh adhering to regulation by some type of state of emergency action or whatever the case may be so no need for that policy recommend we sending that one um and then
016kind of the last discussion out of this November policy committee meeting was um uh discussions that we have uh engaged in before about our electronic device use policy policy 7316 um and we recommended having some further discussion about that and so some of the the the conversation that came out of that um electronic device uh policy discussion was that um we kind of need more information right we're kind of looking to see um what some of the issues are around it is it um you know our cell phones sometimes are they being used as Educational Tools in the classroom um by some teachers or are they becoming also distractions in between um School periods are students leaving the classroom to go to the bathroom uh a number of times during the day to be able
017to use their cell phones um and get away without getting caught um and then so a really good point that Mr Burke also brought up is that a lot of the cell phone related issues that he handles are from cell phone use outside of school so issues that stem from social media use or whatever the case may be it's and it's not during the school day hours it's more or less the major behavioral issues um that he has to deal with on the superintendent level um so those are some of the discussions we had and then um we kind of recommended taking a second look at the the policy we have in place which is we we feel is is pretty clear um about the use but um also talking about the handling observations um
018with phones within our schools so that's kind of where that conversation went and that is everything from the November policy committee meeting any uh questions for uh for Zach if not I have a comment and I I guess a request of the policy committee um during that uh November policy committee meeting Zach was there how much discussion was there of uh 3275 uh having to do with um nomination and recognition of community honores you recall I don't think there was much I really I don't I don't this policy has always bothered me uh I think we passed it in 2019 and I just I never liked the thresholds that were set um this is uh falls under the the naming of school facilities and it reads in rare circumstances where the honor honor contributions to
019the district have been at a level of sign significance that warrants greater recognition etc etc um there's a process by which a a facility can be named for that person a part of a facility a building um you know something of more significance than say a bench or a tree um and in part the uh requirements are a petition of a minimum of a th000 signatures and a minimum of a 100 letters of support I've always felt that that was just too high of a bar and I would like to request the policy committee take another look at that and see if that couldn't be modified I would think that 500 signatures and 50 letters of support would be sufficient and might be less daunting than doubling of that um we still have a 45-day
020comment period the uh the the board still has wide discretion uh for deciding whether the uh the naming should be done or not um I just think that that initial thousand signatures and 100 you know full-fledged letters of support is just a very very high bar um that that could potentially um get in the way of uh someone who might deserve to be honored by the naming of of a facility to just not let that happen I um I have a differing opinion on that and I look at I look at those thresholds as if it's that important to the public that that's the reason for that threshold to to impress upon us the importance of it that they've met that threshold I also I feel as though if you lower the threshold and I
021know you mentioned that we have the latitude you know but I think that threshold protects us from being the last decision maker on it in some regards because if it gets to that threshold we we should be more we we obviously most likely would support it the other thing about the the whole process and I was around when that was was being kicked around because I think it started in facilities before it got to policy MH and it was to limit that amount of change and that amount of um those sorts of things from being very easy it means it it means more but it because it it becomes difficult to keep track of all of the different things and the recognitions that people can get it becomes a burden on the district to maintain
022some of it so there was reason those were some of the reasons we kicked around for why we hit those thresholds I don't remember Pat would have been here when that was going on I don't remember if what his what his um I'm sure he did a lot of research KN Pat I was there on the fac we discussed it a few time in the facilities comp I remember discussing yeah I'm sure Pat did resarch and found benchmarks at other places I would guess but I mean that's that's my perspective on it I can I understand your perspective but I if you look at it the other way if it's really important to them they will get through that it's not to Bar anyone or anything like that but that's that's what I remember from
023it back in its Inception so yeah well I mean it's I would still like to make a request that the policy Committee just bat that around and and and if if um you know if that's the way the the policy committee feels about it I can live with that but I just I would um i' I'd like to have another to to use the Kevin term another bite at that apple okay Paul so if I heard you correctly you're asking to uh for us to review uh a potential reduction in the number of signatures required supporting a plan yeah okay all right not and and you know there's there's nothing um since this is a review only policy there's nothing saying that we can't approve uh the action tonight and just take another look at
024it sure you know yep month or two down the road okay uh any other questions regarding the uh policy notes for November okay okay thanks very much Zach uh okay uh turning now to uh my report I've already said way too much but that's the way it is um under my report uh Ron and I uh had the uh pleasure of attending the winter Conference of the rural schools Association on December 4th and 5th in Saratoga Springs um I'm guessing maybe 300 or a little more folks in attendance there uh there were lots of board members superintendant uh building leaders other District Personnel um the conference was opened by the executive director of RSA Dave little um he is uh actually a a former School Board president uh he was he has been director of
025RSA for 10 years a former New York State assemblyman um if you've read uh any of his um writings you know during budget time last year was a he was very very active in writing and speaking uh about the uh the problems with the taking away of foundation Aid and that kind of thing um he's a just a a terrific uh writer speaker and advocate for Rural schools um sort of first up uh on the business end was um uh we had a a session that talked about key issues uh with the commissioner and three of her Deputy Commissioners uh they discussed among other things the highlights of the Rockefeller Institute report on Foundation Aid U that had just been released um they also touched on the blue ribbon Commission on graduation standards uh regionalization
026initiative and ways the Department's looking at uh easing School staff shortages um as always there were really not a lot of details but and there was not a lot in the way of interaction or question and answer uh with the uh the commissioner's panel um that's kind of what you get when when you go and listen to the commissioner um to me the most anticipated session was a more detailed presentation on the Rockefeller uh Institute study um that was given by the two primary authors um Robert Magna and Brian Backstrom and in the broadest sense what I took away from is that the report is just a report um any changes to be implemented are now in the hands of the state legislature and and there are lots of recommendations for changes in how Foundation
027Aid is determined that are interdependent on each other and there is a lot of concern that the state legislature will kind of cherry-pick parts of the report and say well okay we did something um and that what they do may or may not play very play well politically with with their constituencies um but um some of the recommendations that I felt like they made the most sense uh include uh increasing the unrestricted fund balance maximum to 10% I think that's something we could all uh get behind um making the state fully fund the transition to zero emission buses that's certainly a concern um the report also uh recommended increasing funding for more school-based Mental Health Services that seems to make some sense um and they also recommend reviewing the foundation Aid formula on a regular
028basis so that we don't end up back where we started um that was like the highlight of day one for me you have anything to add to that Ron anything that jumps out at you no I think you summed it up perfectly okay um the RSA conference differs from things like the the nisba convention or even the summer RSA conference that I attended in that there there really isn't any small group workshops to choose from and everyone is basically in one big room and we all take part in the same sessions um so day two was devoted to some subjects that might normally be part of a like a a smaller workshop at a at another uh event and uh the the one that I took the most away from was a presentation on something
029called facilitated intensive negotiation they call it that fin for short and it's a collective bargaining strategy something that I had never heard of um sort of the the the high points of it is you set aside three full days um outside of the school environment to negotiate a new agreement with your bargaining units with the help of a mediator a Public Employee Relations Board mediator um normally a mediator would come in after you've declared an impass and you can't go any further um but in this strategy the perb mediator is there from the very beginning um the district and the union agree ahead of time on uh the number of and the types of issues that are going to be uh uh bargained and um they you hammer out the contract in three days so
030um there's obviously a lot more to it than that but that's you know kind of the uh the essence of it and the panel that presented that was a lawyer from Ferrara and a a a school district super attendant and a nice it negotiator they had uh really great things to say about it they they had well prepared PowerPoint slides uh talked about how streamlined and cordial the process was I really found that very very interesting it's it's one of the the most interesting uh educational sessions that I've attended at any conference um and anything to to add to that Ron you you even told me that you've you've had a little bit of experience with that yeah from the opposite side of the table we did this when I was negotia teachers in sarak
031Lake um we took a whole day and we did not have a perb mediator it was just my team um and then also the uh the board's team and we hashed It Out by lunch we had a conceptual agreement we ate lunch came back and we had an Mo MOA by around 2:00 in the afternoon um you know we did a lot of these same things without knowing we were doing these same things um it kind of we agreed ahead of time that we wanted to give this a shot and uh it worked quite well um we tried a little bit of this at Canton um a couple of years ago where the teachers uh that were on the team were given release time for the day which creates a major problem um it you
032know when we don't have a whole lot of Subs to take eight or 10 teachers out of the classroom is it's problematic um but uh there again it worked pretty well we needed uh a little more time I think it was maybe two or three meetings after that in the evening and we were able to iron out a deal um again no perb no uh no attorney um so it it can work I just uh was very very intrigued by it because I had never never heard of this particular method of bargaining um so I don't think anyone's saying that we're going to go this uh direction that would certainly be uh have to be something that would have to be agreed to but uh I was very intrigued um anything else uh you wanted
033to add Ron about just the the conference overall the only thing I would do is I would just recommend that if if you're available for the next RSA conference it was my first and quite honestly it was one of the most impressive conferences I've been to um I think Dave little put on just everything was very timely it was relevant to what we do it was just a phenomenal experience over you know really less than 48 hours um the venue was great um very inex expensive venue for us um and and the quality of the present presentations was just remarkable also the board conversations uh Paul and I sat with mostly a group from the Eerie bosies board Erie 2 and the conversation level was just out of this world we got I got probably
034more out of just the conversations with those board members than U than really even the rest of the conference because we're all on the same page it was really quite remarkable so you do have the time definitely go to an RSA at at RSA it was the uh Saratoga Springs Convention Center I think is what it's called yeah for the winter yes yep the winter conference is there yes there's two of them there's one in the summer that was in Lake Placid yep uh the uh RSA only started doing a no rsa's Summer Conference was in um oh I forget the name of the hotel the the fancy hotel outside or in in Cooper's town uh but frankly they've outgrown that that venue so uh that's why they um brought their show this past summer
035to Lake Placid at the convention center in Lake plassy okay the the last thing that I have have is um you you have on your agenda uh a link to some proposed norms for the board um I'm hoping for adoption of this list of norms that the board would agree to abide by to give ourselves guard rails for our governance role and um the desirability of having uh these sort of on the books uh came to light as I was working on our goal that we established a few months ago to revamp our onboarding process um nisba publishes a set of sample board Norms so this is something that is uh um that that other boards of education do and it seemed to me that having these written down would make a great discussion point
036for one of the sessions with our newly elected board candidates or newly elected board members as part of our onboarding process um to put in black and white what our standards of behavior are in meetings in interactions with Mr Burke and interactions with each other with the staff with the public Etc um the Norms I uh uh I sort of massaged them myself self and then sent them on to the policy committee because it was kind of in their realm I felt uh so they have been looked at by the policy committee and um so they're in my mind they're they're ready to go there were some uh small wording uh things that that we fixed uh as a result of the um uh pass through the policy committee um but if as we're looking
037at them tonight if you see something that is missing or some wording that you're not that wild about uh we can adopt them with some changes we can uh spend a little bit more time thinking about them there's there's a couple of ways that we can go here um but in addition to making the Norms part of the um onboarding discussion I would also propose that they be adopted each July at our reorganizational meeting so we're saying okay this is how we're going to interact with one another um and also incorporated into the Board of Education handbook so there's a a resolution on the agenda to adopt the board Norms later on that's my report any questions okay I guess we'll move on then to reports from Administration and Mr Burke the first item on
038my report is a conversation about regionalization and although not required I will be asking the board to um approve that we continue with the regionalization process there certainly have been a number of concerns expressed around the state of New York regarding this uh one of the first concerns was is this mandated um the board of regions voted unanimously to pass the regulation on an emergency basis and the first stipulation that they um addressed and stipulated to is that any any school district has the option of opting out of the regionalization process right from the get-go however to do so a board of education would have to authorize the superintendent to notify the um the department by January 15th in writing I'm asking again the board to continue to or to allow me to continue that
039process the second question is as a regionalization process is worked on and a regionalization plan is developed is a board required to adhere to the things that the that the regionalization uh Planning Group has worked on and has agreed upon that is not necessarily in statute that I can find however we can continue to get assurances from the Department that we will not be forced to do anything from the regionalization plan as we should always do if it's not necessarily in legislation we should keep paper documents of anything that indicates it um in the um New York State School boards Association on board today senior Deputy Commissioner for Ed for Education policy Jeff Madison reports and his quote is we will not approve a reg ization plan that does not have the sign off of
040the local districts that are participating I have other statements like that we also have statements from the FAQ that's online from the Department that indicate it's optional what we participate in at the end of this plan I think that this one from uh Deputy Commissioner Madison is is the guarantee that I need that we're not going to be forced into something even if 17 other districts agree to it um that this board would have the final authority to say yay or nay um and without that the the department will not approve the plan um but again I think it's important that and I am keeping a file of these so that if we do get to the end of the plan we can say we went into this in good faith we expect that the
041department and that the local regionalization effort would honor what has been put here so that if this District does not agree according you know through the board of education does not agree we will not be bound to those I think that's a critical aspect um so I I also think that going through the process I'm not sure what we will come up with that we don't already do or don't already offer as as a Services shared service through our bosies but until we go through the process I guess I won't know um so again I'm asking the board's consideration to allow that process to continue I would say I'm going I will be approaching it very precautionary um if there is if there are elements in the plan that would make sense for our students
042and for our community then I would certainly be in support of that and bringing that back to the board exactly and this will be a discussion item later on in the agenda um the second item is we do need to appoint um representatives to the New York Power Authority local government task force and uh trusty peretta has agreed to be one of those I would like to also continue that role Ro um we meet fairly regularly um to discuss um the the local agreement um and even though we would have two reps we only get one vote so it would obviously be you know what's in the board's best interest as represented by trusty Paretta any questions on that okay if Mr Lincoln could pull up the capital project financing overview I wanted I'd like
043to take just a few moments tonight to go through uh really kind of a basic outline of the financing aspect of the capital project on the second slide we uh have the basics of what a maximum cost allowance is and there are really two components of the maximum cost allowance the first part is the actual construction costs those are our hard cost and those are things that are really related to a building itself um so anything on the inside of the building the exterior of the building the roofs the windows the uh brick work those types of things that is generally the bigger portion of any one of these maximum cost allowances the incidental cost that includes the elements that are on the outside of the building site work so we might have to put
044in areas for uh contractors to park their trailers or to store um their bins and their materials it also includes things that would remain with the district such as parking lot side walks and athletic fields and it also includes our soft costs which are the engineering costs and the architectural fees the maximum cost allowance has a fiveyear look back window so every five years it gets reset and the money doesn't carry over and so as we'll take a look on the next slide or in a couple minutes I'm sorry um we'll talk about how that money and I don't want to say gets lost but it gets reset the 5year look back um with this one with our project we plan on bringing the referendum to the voters in May at the annual V budget
045vote if approved we will not be submitting um well basically design work will take place throughout the course of much of the 2025 26 school year we will submit then to s in the spring of 26 when we submit that sets the look back window so you go by years back from the spring of 26 and that's when they look at what have you already spent on your buildings by the spring of 26 we have almost a complete reset throughout the district for example at Jefferson Elementary our construction cost or our maximum cost allowance there is about $8.4 million our incidentals 1.6 almost 1.7 for a total maximum cost allowance at Jefferson of $10 million and these are based on um building units student units so it's based on your census your population over time
046um so when we go to Madison you'll notice a slightly different number the total maximum cost allowance at Madison is 11 Point almost 11.5 million at night Andale quite a bit higher at 12 point almost 12.2 million at the junior high 17. 2 million and as we've been talking about for quite some time now through facilities and at these meetings the Crux of the work really for this Capital project the focus is at the high school where our total combined maximum cost allowances right around $45 million what's important to note on the uh High School is our construction maximum cost is 36 million since our issue with the pipeline about a year ago I've talked with the board about the need to upgrade and replace our HVAC system here the initial estimate to replace the
047HVAC system completely and include air conditioning throughout this building was just over $37 million it at up our entire construction cost um maximum cost excuse me so we've been going back to the drawing board we've been working working with our architect and our engineer in fact we had a meeting earlier today and we have some preliminary numbers of scaling that back still getting the essential work done making sure that we have a reliable heat system and air conditioning in some of the major areas making sure that the air conditioning the auditorium the cafeteria the media center um that those are all upgraded and ready to go and also including air conditioning in the gymnasium and again the preliminary number right now looks to be about $19 million on that which we'll be sharing out discussing
048more with the facilities committee to get their feedback but I want people to understand why we can't just spend $50 million here at the high school on construction we have if we go above the maximum cost allowance it's no longer aable so we really want to make sure that we're maximizing every aable dollar from the state of New York and limiting the exposure to our local taxpayer which is the perfect segue into my last slide which is our building Aid currently our building Aid here at MSA is very high at about 97.4% please don't think that it means that for every dollar we spend we're going to get 97 cents back not everything and even the best laid out project is going to be aidable there will always be certain elements that we do in
049a capital project that are going to fully come back on the local taxpayer so when we look at 97 % in my mind I'm thinking I would be pleased if we can make that no less than 90% again we know things are not always going to be aidable but yet necessary this next number is going to be startling and I certainly don't want anyone to think that I would ever that we're looking at or the facilities committee is looking at spending every penny of our maximum cost allowance which is almost $87 million that's not what we're going to be doing but we are going to be looking at what are the necess Necessities what are the things that 7 years from now we wish we had have done and try to fix those things now
050while we have that money especially at the elementary schools and the junior high even though they just came off a capital some Capital Project work if we were to spend the $86 million or $87 million total maximum cost again if we had 97% Aid we'd get 84 million of that back leaving a local taxpayer share again around $3 million in our Reserve we have I believe and I should have written this down um is at $14 million on the cap 15 we have $15 million in our capital reserve so again the goal here will be to go to the taxpayers with a project that is 0% not extravagant I don't think any of the facilities commun is looking at anything that's extravagant but really what is necessary um um infrastructure Wise programmatic Wise that we
051can afford and that makes sense um the other part of this with bu buildings plus the cab plus Transportation managing construction at all of those buildings as Mr preder probably could attest to with just coming off from three it's a management nightmare we really want to make sure that what we do is something that we can control that between the facilities committee especially those that are here every day that we're able to be on the site watching what's going on talking with the construction managers and if we go too large it becomes problematic so again there's a real balancing act that the facilities committee is going to be working on over the next two months uh to get this project scoped where we need to be um it's exciting it's also I'd be pulling my
052hair out I won't be lying about that but uh it is it's also daunting because we're talking a large sum of money but we also have a a lot of work to do um with infrastructure especially here at the high school I do want to get a little excitement going um Isabelle and I have talked about some of the capital project and we've talked about the condition of our girls locker room that is at the high school that is a priority of the facilities committee um repairs to the pool what that looks like we're not sure but it'll certainly look better than having um duct tape holding tiles together we are going to be address addressing those issues um the HVAC system here in the high school has to be addressed we have to have
053um certainly some major upgrades to that um I was really excited talking with the engineers today and and I should probably wait for the facilities but again I'm just too excited about it because I thought we had a great meeting and one of the things we'd like to do is get away from the steam system the Steam Plant and that $19 million includes replacing the three steam boilers at the cab which are currently about 15 years old replacing those with three hot water boilers so we'd actually be able to transfer our system over to a hot water system um ideally the three three boilers there would be very similar or exact same models or same manufacturer as what we have at the other four buildings that we have that consistency um so again it was
054just very exciting to hear and see some of those things develop um again probably not air conditioning the entire facility here at the high school yet but it would be at least air condition ready for the next Capital project um so again I think we made great progress with our engineer um and my excitement was only overshadowed by uh Mr tessier's excitement because it's a very meat and potato type system um not a lot of Technology involved which means less future maintenance hopefully as well so so again it was a pretty exciting meeting today and again I'm looking forward to the next couple of months any questions about school financing on the capital project okay next item is we have a crossing guard agreement with the village of I'm sorry let me go back up
055school budget calendar I would like to call the board's attention to that that calendar and one kind of unusual item there is that in March I can find my calendar we are asking for a second special Board of Education meeting to approve the boards or to approve our District budget um the rationale for that is I did have it yes could I please sorry my computer's dead so on March 26th which is our regularly scheduled board meeting that's that two special Tuesday meeting where the board is required to vote on the Bose's budget and the Bose's board members the issue with that date is on Monday the 25th mallerie and I have to um certify our school property tax report card that's a statutory requirement in order to do that the board of education has
056to have approved and passed the budget for voter um approval if we don't have a special board meeting um on March 20th that would then indicate um that we would be approving a budget sometime in February frankly I need more time we need more time with the governor's numbers we need to see how the conversations are going between the three people in a room um in Albany where those discussions are leading what things are we hearing so we can modify our budget as needed it's really the gift of time that we're asking for by about three extra weeks um so again asking for that meeting on March 20th for the uh the right number yes y to to prepare that budget to have that budget uh approved any questions on the uh budget calendar good
057hard okay it's only Christmas time I'm already on the wrong month sorry it's April 20 April 28th is when we have to um certify April 29th is the Board of Ed meeting and asking thank you Paul for the April 14th meeting again gift of time sorry wrong months but still gift of time thank you so we be doing the the special board meeting on April 14th yes and then turning around and meeting again on the 29th because we have to vote on the Posies that's correct and that's also sandwiched in sandwiched in between there is spring break yes I think okay good thank you thanks for getting going through that with me um the next item is the crossing guard agreement we have six crossing guards the village of msen pays for three of those
058we've had an agreement for about a year now I think last year may have been the first year of that agreement where we subsid or we um reimburse the village for the other three that contract actually expired last June so the village is asking to update that and they're asking for approximately $1,300 more to cover the additional cost just the increase of their cost any questions on the crossing Garden contract okay Surplus items I'm asking that the board declare three Chromebooks Surplus at the last meeting the artist Association asked for a donation of Chromebooks we actually have a number of Chromebooks that are old that we leave on the Shelf as to just in case and just in case students need them at home for medical reasons or or for whatever purpose um we have
059a number of those they are near the end of life they're close to being Obsolete and we can certainly afford to give those and it would be in accordance with our district policy because the artist Association does benefit our students through their programs and that's as they indicated that's what they'd be using the the Chromebooks for we also have donations from the back the pack through the three elementary schools to tun to $270 each which would be allocated to the grade six field trip and that concludes my report okay thank you Mr Burke um we'll move on now to recommended actions and first up is uh all of the items that make up the consent agenda are there any consent agenda items that uh board members would like to have removed for individual action okay
060hearing no requests I would ask for a motion to approve the consent agenda we have a motion and a second uh All In uh all in favor any opposed consent agenda carries moving on to other items for Action uh first up is approval of the proposed board Norms second we have a motion and a second any uh comments or questions yes I have some sure okay so um some of the wording is not really my favorite and so I'm just going to address a couple of them that um this I don't know seemed weird um the last bullet in communication Norms communication says allow the president to speak on behalf of the board and the superintendent to speak on behalf of the district and I feel like you need to add something like the president
061of the board can speak on behalf of the board but for agreed to agenda items like if we've come to consensuses and we've um discussed something and we voted on it I have no problem with the board president presenting it as the whole board approves but the way that it's written it looks like the board president is speaking for the board no matter where they are what they're doing and it just doesn't seem like that just that struck me weird um and then um meeting Norms um the first bullet says adequately prepare for meetings ahead of time and arrive on time ready to do the work of the district I think it's a little strong I think um that we are all even though we're um elected officials we're not paid officials and we all
062have families and things that we do and um I think it should be a little softer I think maybe if it said to the best of your ability Endeavor to adequately prepare etc etc because stuff happens and you know there are lot of unforeseen things that can go on and and likewise in the second bullet where it says notify the cleric board president or committee chair in advance if you're not able to attend a meeting um I don't know how other people on the board feel about this but I am really struggling with the fact that um we have doubled the workload for all the board members now we're all on two committees instead of one committee and I'm finding it very hard to carve out time for meeting two different meetings plus the board
063meeting it it just is starting it's getting to be a lot so maybe if it said something like make every effort to you know communicate with the superintendent or the district clerk or whatever if you can't be at something because sometimes things happen and I can't be there Trish I think um if you go up to before you get to those bullets I brought up we we talked about that in policy and I had some of the same concerns and the way we softened that was what was the word the original wording was the Board of Education agrees agrees to which means you will and so we changed it to aspires to is this is what we hop for so I we felt like that softened all of those things to make them amendable to
064us I don't know if you caught that just so you know that we is that in the introduction where is so it says board meeting Norms including committee meetings the Board of Education aspires to and that's for every one of them it says we aspire to this is our this is what we hope to do and so that sort of yeah we changed that word for all the all those things oh I see so it was it was previously agrees to which we thought that's what we thought was too harsh actually Kevin I think my original wording is was the board of Education will something either way it's very it was that's more like a must which that's one of the things that concerned me and we talked about that at committee as well we
065softened it all with the aspires to and I felt like that kind of I guess I feel like if you might not have caught it but if you know that that might that that's what we talked about and did that may help assade some of your concerns with some of the wording okay well it just feels like if we're adopting something and and two you know that doesn't address the one concern that I have about the board president will speak on behalf of the board because yeah I do agree with I just don't feel like I'm comfortable with that as long as we've agreed as consensus go back to the policy committee with the changes or I mean those if it be next meeting you if if you would prefer if the if the board
066would prefer to um table this item we can send that back to the policy committee and soften some of that language yeah motion to table it second okay we have a motion on the floor to table the approval of the board norms for um some softening of some language um any comments or questions all in favor any opposed okay thank you and thank you Trish for your your input on that um that that's exactly what we should be doing is looking at these things and and making changes as we see fit okay uh next is approval to continue the regionalization process so move do we have a second second we have a motion and a second are there any questions or comments so as long as we know that there's an out clause there an
067out that we document it's going to be okay I guess to explore as we as we stated previously I I would hope that the superintendent would represent the district and our taxing boundary and our students and the best interest of that boundary and interest and I I figure you will I worked with you before and I also would hope that we push the efforts of the regionalization process towards the Bosey sharing model as much as we possibly can I mean we I we could be open to there could be a benefit that we can't see and we don't know about so I don't want to close the door on that but I would hope that we would push the majority of it towards the bosis the existing bosis model of sharing for things that districts
068can't do for themselves afford to do for themselves so I would agree to it with those stipulations okay what I asked was um the superintendent of bosis is retiring and so that would be toward the end of when this regionalization is probably going to come to fruition it will probably be another superintendent who would be implementing it and for that reason I have concerns because I don't know what the politics of this new person will be I really trust Tom Burns and I I think he has great integrity but because I don't know who will be the next person um I for that reason I have a concern I have plenty of concerns um my main concern is that you can read in black and white the regulation in the New York state Register which
069now clearly gives uh districts an opportunity to to um elect not to participate in the regionalization plan discussion I would feel an awful lot better if the regulation said something to the same effect that on the on the back end when the regionalization plan is complete you have the option to not participate for whatever the reason may be um it's pretty clear in the frequently asked questions on the state Ed website it's pretty clear in the memo from Mr Madison from State Ed um that you know we've all had access to um it it points to that we have the opportunity to not Implement things that we don't agree with but it's not in the regulation and that that's that's my main uh cause for concern I I think there's there's an awful lot of
070good that can come from these conversations there was no reason to rush it along um this this is the kind of conversation that should be that should be happening over a several year period of time not you know uh several months uh so uh I'm I'm I'm still struggling with whether I'm I'm in a in agreement with going forward or not um I I guess it's going to be a a game time decision for me I've I've viewed this topic I've been fairly quiet on this topic because I just felt I haven't had enough information so I've really spent this time to read as much as I can and think and so I viewed this with a couple different lenses so the first lens I viewed it was as a as a state taxpayer I
071I applaud and appreciate the state's effort in maximizing their efficiency and use of our tax dollars 100% um through another lens as my respon as our responsibility as Ms Central School District board members to our students in our community right here behind us so what is this regionalization process going to look like and how does it affect us as a district and a community so I've looked at it through that lens and then the third lens I viewed it as is through my professional role in my community and Regional involvement and I find it conflicting that I've always been an advocate and I've said this for many years that um that we need to continue to work together as a region as a North Country if you've ever thought about if you've ever gone on
072vacation and you say where are you from it's often the North country or St Lawrence County or a pinpoint right but when we look at the things going on in our region we look at Economic Development projects we look at Business Development we look at local government when we're looking to grow and develop we do it on a community basis on a msin or a pot Stam or whatever your satellite towns are and so I thought about this and I said this is an opportunity for us with impressionable young youth um because this has been a general cycle a generational cycle of this everyone's trying to VI for their own best community within the nor country so I've really thought about this as an opportunity to say if we have the capability to maximize our
073services and help those around and it makes sense and we can entertain and continue that plan to see what it looks like I think that we're setting a really good example for the impressionable youth who are in front of us and saying we want to be the leaders in regionalization and working to expand that partnership and that advocacy for growing the North country because as a MSA community business owners here in different employers we don't employ just kids who graduate from MSA we employ kids who graduate from potam and who graduate from Norwood and braier and ogdenburg people come to MSA and still work right so if we can continue to help expand that Educational Services it comes back in its full capacity back into our own Community as well too so that's what I've
074really thought about in kind of this regionalization process and how can we not only expand for our students but really as region because it does uh come back as an asset to us I said it's I appreciate your comments and I and I've thought a lot of the same things and and I've said this previously that the state the the intent of regionalization I I understand it and if it's going to do good things for students I appreciate it but I feel as though it I I agree with a lot of what Paul says this is where I'm sort of conflicted because a lot of me agrees with Paul's stance and I agree with the language and it scares me but I feel like if if you boil it down the the system that we
075operate in is you talked about the North country but we all have our taxing districts school districts within the North country I love that idea and I I agree we should all respect the North country and be proud to be from the North country but we were elected in the certain boundary that represents the massina taxation District so as a board member I feel we have to represent that to the best of our ability and wanting to participate in a broader discussion I feel like we should continue with the caveat that Mr Burke represents the best interest of every dollar that we've chosen the tax within our taxing district for the benefit of our students and the best way to do that at all times is through the bosis model it's already established it already
076exists and it's and it's a known quantity with no weird language you know exactly what you're getting when you get into it you can opt out of it we sign up for every service at Bose's we have the ability through bosis the Bose sharing model to advocate that boses create a program take away a program change a program and that's where I think we should leverage our efforts that's the best regionalization model to use we can't we can't change the fact that we this process was put in motion and I didn't like anything about how it was done but I see your side of it I see your side of it and the best way I could see going forward to protect that idea which I agree with to set a good example and Paul
077stance of I can't stand that language we can protect it through the way that Mr Burke approaches the convenings with the other superintendance seen is the biggest school in the North Country we will lead lead by example and hopefully the rest will follow and I think there's a lot of that there's a lot of the same concern shared by other boards there are other districts throughout the county who are need any kind of buoyancy they can get because of the transcript Gap across the county they can't help that we can't help that it's the world we're in it's the county we're in so I mean I just I wanted to consider those things as well we were elected within this boundary that's our only concern Statewide people are elected to a different boundary you know
078so if if you look at keep your focus there that's where I feel it should be and I I hope I articulated that correctly but you know we have a motion and a second to approve uh Mr Burks uh and and our District's uh involvement in the regionalization process are there any other questions concerns comments anyone else have anything to say I do have another thing to say so something that Trish's concern over the appointment of the district superintendent the impending retirement and subsequent appointment of the next district superintendent every District votes on board members in our case we have a board a Bose board member who happens to be the president of the Bose board I think all districts have a larger voice than what they realize with respect to the decisions that are
079made at Bose and you need to consider the Democratic process and understand all the different layers that exist Within the county and are we leveraging our voice are we being represented by those boards both these board members that's something that is really come to light with me I'm not saying they don't represent us or think about us but we don't always have conversations with them and I think that's that this get this sort of exposes that Gap and I would hope that hopefully some of them realize that or we all realize that maybe you go to a Bose board meeting and express your concerns that those are open meetings as well so those are other options because we have those voting Powers within the bosies as well so that's something to consider I don't know
080what the process is going to be for the appointment of the next district superintendent but it is a concern and it's something to think about this brings all that into a higher and more open light so I hope that these things these messages get out and that this this is these are very tough decisions we're putting into a POS we're put into a position don't commit or commit but if you commit you're in all the way and you don't know what you're getting into that's a very strange strange thing and anyone no who would ever sign that what would your lawyer tell you so I mean we didn't ask for it but that's what we've got so anyway sorry about that when's the next Bose's meeting uh January 6th maybe January 6th I think could
081be I'm just guessing I think it's on a Thursday though so yeah yeah so we we can find out just something to think about I mean that's good any other comments we have Motion in a second all in favor of continuing the regionalization process and we all have time to get out because we have until January 9th no January 15th 15th 15 to send a letter we we don't have a this is that's the last this is this is our this is our shot yep we can call a special meeting if any of the situations change or you have you know we can always do that so okay again I ask uh all all in favor of continuing the regionalization process planning all those opposed any any extensions okay okay moving on uh thank you
082for the discussion folks uh approval of the uh New York Power Authority local government task force Representatives so move second any comments or questions thank you Mr par for agreeing to have more fun with that group another meeting all in favor any opposed that carries approval of the 2025 26 how did we get ah 2026 2526 School Board school budget calendar so move second comments or questions all in favor opposed that carries approval of the crossing guard agreement second any comments or questions all in favor any opposed okay uh we have a resolution for a paid administrative leave so move I have a second okay we have a motion and a second any questions or comments hearing none all in favor any opposed and lastly approval of the Personnel action items from superintendent Burke and
083I recommend approval of the actions listed in items 1 through 68 on the Personnel so move second we have a motion and a second all in favor opposed that carries moving on uh any items for a new business uh this would be uh future agenda items we must still have a list from prior meetings to to get to right just as a reminder at the next meeting we plan on um having Mr Oliver here as well as a representative from Sunni Canton to talk about some of those programs that we're jointly working on so that should be a good evening sounds like an interesting presentation and discussion uh we have no public or press here we have a couple of Administrators thank you for hanging in there with us uh so uh I would um
084love toh call for a holiday adjournment so move second all in favor I'm sure everyone's against that have a happy holiday everybody we'll see you back in January did I think this