001good evening everyone and welcome to the January 14th 2025 meeting of the Abington Board of school directors I note the attendance of all board members uh Mr Allen is joining us remotely today please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all the Abington Board of school directors has convened this evening's meeting at the administration building and the public is welcome this meeting is being broadcast live on the Abington School District YouTube channel this meeting is also being recorded and will be accessible on the district's website and cable channel no later than Friday January 17th 2025 to allow those members of the public who cannot participate to view
002the meeting at a later time comments from citizens will be conducted in person and by phone information regarding participating remotely in public comment will be displayed on the screen at the time of public comment the board thanks the public in advance for its coop cooperation this is a place where we hold dignity and high regard and everyone's voice is respected and welcomed in this space Dr fetcher do we have any additional announcements or agenda items none at this time are there any comments from my fellow board members Mr Allen nothing thank you Mrs Brown happy New Year everyone miss eisenhart good evening all Mr Muhammad happy New Year miss Spalding uh nothing at this time Miss Hartman happy New Year welcome back welcome everyone welcome everyone okay welcome back and happy New Year everyone Dr
003fetcher can you please proceed with our student council Representatives thank you Dr mauie uh first I would like Mary Carter from Abington High School to come forward or this information I'm not Mary car I still have something to say good evening Dr Maui Dr fetcher and the members of the school of board of school directors my name is brys Edmonds and I am the student council president of admington Senior High School we've kicked off the New Year in full swing with a Athletics clubs and other activities at the high school the chess team played at the Ben Franklin Chess Championship and Sophie AB Sophie abora 11th grade and Ching Chan 10th grade both won scholarships for outstanding performance Kenneth lawyer a current student enrolled in the protective services program at Eastern was selected as Eastern
004student of the month for January 2025 the athletic department is excited to announce that their excellence in athletics recognition for the month of December will go to Maya Johnson Maya has shown outstanding performance dedication and achievements on our girls basketball team on December 20th Maya became the all-time assist leader in the Abington girls basketball when she dissed out her 341st assist on Saturday January 4th at Central Bucks South High School the Abington tier leading team qualified for the PIAA state Championship competition in rting PA that will take place on January 30th and 31st congratulations to both the girls and boys indoor track teams they've already comp competed at Lehigh University and haford college with several students earning medals in both individual Buss and group relays the following advon Senior High School Scholars have been recognized
005by the Suburban one all league for their achievements on the golf team Maxwell Hayes all league First Team William Goldstein all League second team and Eli gy for all League second team Noah helier and mave Hong have been selected by the National Merit Scholarship Corporation as semi-finalists in the 2025 competition for merit scholarship Awards the Nationwide pool of semi-finalists representing less than 1% of us High School seniors includes the highest scoring entrance in each state this is yet another example of the senior high Scholars Rising above and beyond and displaying their academic prior within our school Tristan Bardo Jessica chako Jolene fry Mina Fuji Lucas hollenstein Elliot Kim Eugene Lim Arvin mefa Jeremy Moore miles Roland Gregory rodiny and Amy Wang represented the top 5% of a national group of approximately 1.6 million Scholars who
006entered the 2025 National Merit Scholarship program competition by taking the 2024 PSAT MS sqt these commended Scholars have demonstrated outstanding academic performance academic potential by their high performance in these programs and exceptional scores camsey akuta Tina Barnes Melvin kamang Siana KD Jeffrey kungl Samuel lard and Samuel Thompson wise I butchered your those names I'm sorry I'm doing my best or seven of among 5,000 students named as scholars in the 2025 National African-American recognition program these Scholars met or exceeded the rigorous academic and testing requirements established by the college board for entry into this prestigious prog program Vincent Foley Michaela hden Jeffrey kungle Caitlyn nunam Amy Wang and zo young are recognized in the inaugural first generation National recognition award program presented by the College Board eligible students qualify based on strong academic performance reflected by
007PSAT MN nmsqt or PSAT 10 scores within the top 10% of test takers for each award program in each state of a score of three or higher on two or more AP exams by the end of 10th grade Jonah Brown Walter Flores III Paula jarmal and Manuel zamb breno were four of approximately 5,000 Scholars named in the 2025 National Hispanic recognition program where Scholars met or exceeded the rigorous academic and testing requirements established by the college board for ENT entry into this prestigious program all all the students I've named above are representing the academic prowers aington Abington at the highest level can we please give them a round of [Applause] applause senior Olivia caps was recognized as the Suburban one League Univest athlete of the week she's a three-season athlete as an integral member of
008the soccer team swim team and lacrosse team she does this while we're still maintaining excellent grades and demonstrating the character of an outstanding student the following Scholars have advanced as finalists in the second phase of the student member of the board election and will be will be appearing on the election ballot suhan Kumar Selena woo and Eric Zayn all election information will be highlighted on our school TV show the bang show an advisory as you can see business business is in full swing as we enter a new year at the high school a new year comes with a whole set of new goals to achieve it is also a time of reflection to look back on the previous year and see what went well and what didn't either way we should all be going to
009the New Year trying to make some kind of change in our lives for the better for that is the only way we can truly measure our success year to year thank you and have a nice evening respectfully submitted Bryson Edmond thank you Bryson [Applause] a lot going on and we do look forward to honoring our Scholars at a future board meeting so you'll have the opportunity um to at that time have our scholars in front of us uh for you to be able to honor as well thank you brayon for that excellent report and congratulations to all our Scholars and our athletes uh I know that I'm particularly looking forward to seating our student representative so when the results of the election are ready I assume Dr fetcher will let us know I will let
010you know as soon as I know thank you at this time from Abington Middle School lilan Orin if you could please come forward good evening Dr Maui Dr fetcher and members of the board of school directors I'm Lil anoran and I on the Executive Board of student council for Abington Middle School the GSA had a holiday party at the end of December complete with a rainbow elephant gift exchange our take on the traditional white elephant members received gifts like homemade books stuffed animals and Christmas ornaments we are looking forward to our January meetings where we arranged some ways to make the school more more inclusive the seventh grade girls basketball team won first place in our league championship game the eighth grade girls basketball team won first place in the constellation bracket for the league
011congrat congratulations to all of the team members and coaches who participated this season we are proudly displaying the trophies in our Athletics display case on the first floor American Sign Language Club learned how to describe their families and participated in a spirited game of Family guest Who Art Club has started up for the new year there are three different project Focus rooms sculpture Ceramics and design the students are all very excited to get going on their projects new this year the design room will be creating signage for AMS and we can't wait to see student designs hanging up around the around the building the reading Olympics is in full swing reading books for the competition that will take place here at admington midddle school in April we have five teams that will compete with other
012schools in Montgomery County the school beautification club has some exciting ideas this year these ideas include updated pictures and creating morals to help AMS look even more beautiful the going green Club students enjoyed their annual movie meeting where they watch the original Dr sees The Lorax and head snacks after they had a Lorax trivia contest by the winners received prizes the AMS course carolled for a cause on December 19th and raised funds for every for the everware project showing their support for eighth grade choir member Amelia Fletcher a Amelia volunteers with the everwar project and provides toys and books for children whose parents are seeking assistance the AMS M4 and the ass hsm3 bands performed at the Philadelphia Flyers game on January 11th over 50 musicians walked rocked out for large crowds on The Concourse
013of walk of the Philadelphia hockey Center Philadelphia singer Lauren Hart who performs the anthems at all the home Flyers games was among one of the students was among was among was among was was one of the fans in the audience enjoying the great sounds of the Abington mod music fans character Cafe held their monthly meeting the Thursday before winter break we talked about what books we like to read over the break when we made crafts out of old recycled books Vibe and imagine we were once again join leaders at the senior high school for planning the a HS cultural Fair which will take place on February 28th 2025 Middle School leaders have been invited to the event by Dr wormly and we'll look forward to this experience thank you very much l lot going on
014there good job thank youan great job summarizing all that going on uh we appreciate your coming out um uh to our meeting and informing us Dr fetcher would you proceed with our board orientations this evening please uh yes uh Dr Maui uh first at this time I'd like uh Dr Stephanie violi assistant director of Elementary teaching and learning Miss Janine sack supervisor of literacy Dr Lindsay Morgan principal at rle Elementary School Miss Amita Abraham reading specialist at Overlook Elementary School and miss Amanda Wagner grade three teacher at rosin Elementary uh to present the recommended English language arts instructional materials adoption for the 2025 2026 school year good evening Dr Maui dror fetcher and members of the board of school directors this evening we will be sharing a recommendation for the adoption of new instructional materials
015for teaching English language arts in grades kindergarten through 5 as you aware the board of school directors must approve all instructional materials that will be used in classrooms as a requirement of Pennsylvania school code to prepare for this recommendation a superintendent Committee of stakeholders was tasked with review and evaluation of programs that would be effective for use in abington's Elementary classrooms we will share this Pro we will share the process that the committee underwent this evening our current program for English language arts is Journeys Journeys is being discontinued and will not be available for renewal in 2025 therefore the committee was charged with identifying materials and resources that would meet our District's needs the committee sought to ensure our selection would align with PA academic and cor standards for English language arts and the PA
016state literacy plan Additionally the committee sought to ensure that programs we reviewed were grounded in the science of reading research our committee considered numerous factors while evaluating potential programs including standards alignment current research of instructional practices and methodology and the diverse learning needs of our student population the committee also considered a plan for professional development and resources for parents and Guardians a diverse group of District stakeholders participated in the superintendence committee the committee had 53 members the superintendent committee completed its work between fall 2023 and fall 2024 committee members spent numerous hours dedicated to the review of appropriate programs and all K to5 teachers had the opportunity to look at the materials during a recent professional development day the recommendation for the K to 5 English language arts program is amplify core knowledge language arts
017Third Edition to 20 26 amplify CA has a pedagogical approach of explicit systematic found foundational skills instruction and a proven knowledge building sequence elements valued by our stakeholders include its level of rigor engaging in highin text and comprehensive approach to promising student achievement amplify ccla is designed to align with the science of reading principles providing systematic evidence-based instruction to support literacy development there are several key strengths across evaluations such as the reading League Ed reports and the international literacy Association that are of note the program has foundational skills Mastery as a component there's an abundant evidence of a systematic explicit instruction with a clear scope and sequence for phonics phonemic awareness influency the program is a knowledge Rich curriculum that prioritizes the development of content knowledge and comprehension and the program has explicit writing instruction
018that integrates writing tasks that build on knowledge gained from Reading lessons science of reading is the research-based understanding of reading velopment instruction and best practices and draws from education psychology Linguistics and Neuroscience the key findings from the science of reading research include instruction works best when components are integrated not isolated effective reading instruction is rooted in evidence and integrates to coding fluency vocabulary and comprehension teacher preparation and professional development are essential for improving literacy outcomes and teachers with a strong foundational knowledge improve students stent outcomes and Frameworks like the simple view of reading as depicted here on this slide help Educators focus on target areas where students need the most support proficient reading is the result of skill development in the areas of decoding and language comprehension the Third Edition of amplifi ccla introduces several
019notable updates that set it apart from previous editions one key enhancement is the inclusion of a skills component in third grade as a current third grade teacher I've observed that many students still face gaps in foundational skills this Edition will be instrumental in helping students transition from learning to read to reading to learn by strengthening their decoding and reading fluency giving students the skills needed to read grade level text other highlights that impress the committee include an increased focus on writing instruction based on the science of writing a richer representation of diverse perspectives and authentic T and the inclusion of poetry units for grades 2 through 5 amplify CA is designed to meet the needs of all Learners including those with varying reading levels and language skills cka places a strong emphasis on building foundational
020literacy skills for all students particularly in the early grades this Focus helps close achievement gaps by ensuring that students develop the critical skills they need in addition while students are learning to read the knowledge component allows students access to complex texts about a variety of topics such as Greek myths in grade two and the classification of animals in grade three the knowledge components the knowledge component levels the playing field for all students by building background knowledge of the world the knowledge component in amplifi ccla stands out for its intentional design for building relevant background knowledge in addition to our committee members elementary teachers were given the opportunity to explore the program and provide feedback teachers appreciated the knowledge building aspect of the program recognizing that our students come to us with varying backgrounds and experiences
021offering all students exposure to a wide range of topics will increase engagement and promote knowledge Equity the program's structured literacy approach with an emphasis on phonic instruction will be a critical building block for our students future reading success a group of us had the privilege of visiting a neighboring District during their first year of implementation teachers at the school shared that students were making significant gains in decoding comprehension and writing many of the key features of cka have already been mentioned however I would like to emphasize that the program has two instructional strands a skills strand that focuses on phical awareness phonics decoding and writing and a knowledge strand that supports students listening comprehension vocabulary and writing growth the program comes with resources for both teachers and families in digital and print formats in addition
022mclass will be a valuable tool to measure and monitor students literacy skills provide teachers with detailed information on students strengths and needs and also support teachers with suggestions for instructional practices to reinforce those skills in conclusion amplify cka is a research-backed structured literacy program promising positive shifts in our instructional practices and literacy success for our students thank you thank you very much uh we can answer any questions that you may have my fellow board members Mrs Brown yes uh thank you so much for the presentation I'm very excited about uh the potential adoption of this I have uh three two questions one I like the the learning to read uh leading to reading to learn I absolutely love that I wrote it down I'll probably use it in the future um but I will also
023say reading for enjoyment and I see that through the choice uh selection so I'm very happy that that's there U my question is how will we measure its success especially as it pertains to the uh achievement Gap my second question is the time allotted for reading per day does it match the suggestion of the uh program what they suggest and my third question you mentioned there's a digital and print format is that up to the teacher discretion I know we do a great job with planning together and teachers discussing best practices do we know if uh we're leaning more towards the digital um versus the print format so your first question yes ma'am um the uh assessment available through this program is is varied so there are lots of opportunities for our teachers to assign
024students formative assessment unit assessments mclass is Dibbles the eth Edition um so there's opportunity for us to do progress monitoring so through the vared assessment pieces our teachers will be able to track student progress and will be able to evaluate program effectiveness um obviously we set goals at the beginning of each each year our schools um and our teachers and um midyear review and year end review and we will do that with this program as well okay the second question was related to time allotment if it matches the suggestion yes um our uh daily minutes our daily instructional minutes at elementary do meet the recommended time for this program okay thank you and the final question about print digital at the Elementary grades we really do Focus um for the most part on using print
025resources um the digital U pieces of the program are uh avaluable for teachers for display purposes there's also some online programming that the students will be able to engage in typically we use the digital pieces for um opportunities for Center work and or independent work and during wi time but I would say um during the course uh pieces of U of A literacy block at elementary the students are engaged in print thank you so much anyone else yeah I'd like to say I appreciate the mental model aspect as a way for educators to be able to catch and possibly control childhood misconceptions related to experiences in general but particularly Academia thank you anyone else uh just a comment regarding the addition of the grade three foundational skills um that seems to be above and beyond
026what is offered at Journeys and also should uh help facilitate one of the key takeaways I heard which is strategies to support indiv individualized instruction um to help address our different tier levels of students that we have especially early in elementary so I'm excited to see how that goes with for the students that was a a really strong selling point for the Third Edition of this great anyone else um I appreciate the thoroughness of the process you all went through to select um a curriculum that's really going to help our students reading um I personally appreciate the emphasis on print resources especially for younger kids because it really helps with retention um and wanted to applaud you all for the um inclusion of poetry in the reading so well done any other questions okay thank
027you thank you so we proceed to our next orientation yes uh thank you Dr Mau I now ask Miss Laura Nama assistant director of secondary teaching and learning to review the proposed Academic Program changes for the 2025 26 school year mrama good evening Dr mallerie Dr fetcher and the board of school directors tonight I'm sharing proposed uh changes to the Addington senior high school program of studies for 2025 2026 um for this presentation I'm just going to include some brief background information and then I'll dive into details about those recommendations each year Abington School District updates our academic program of study um we propose additions modifications Andor deletions uh recent recommendations that you may remember are we created The College and Career Pathways we expanded our dual enrollment Partners over the last few years and
028we also developed um the foundational reading courses those are one of the more recent ones we did for 2025 26 Abington Middle School is proposing no changes to their program and the senior high school has 12 changes that I'll review so the first set of changes are in the business department we're recommending replacing our foundations of innovation 2 course which is currently required of all 10th grade students with a personal finance course this new course personal finance would be designed to meet new financial literacy requirements that are outlined in act 35 of 2023 so this is actually a state requirement um this recommendation would be accomplished through three adjustments to our program of studies the addition of personal finance the deletion of foundations of innovation two and then the modification of the title of foundations
029of innovation one to just simply foundations of Innovations um next in family and consumer science the high school is recommending three modifications and these modifications are just in the course title so the courses themselves are staying the same and the goal here is just to um um provide greater Clarity for our families during the course selection process so apparel one we are recommending become fashion and textiles that course does focus on choosing textiles and just introductory sewing apparel two would become apparel construction and fundamentals as they dive deeper into the construction of more complicated works and apparel 3 would become Fashion Design and Merchandising as they do at that point start to discuss more about the design industry the curriculum and the nature of the courses would remain the same the health and physical education
030department is also recommending a course change title our introduction to exercise science course we would like to rename body systems and applied Anatomy one and this modification is to better distinguish our program from programs that are offered at the eastern center for Arts and Technology they have an exercise program exercise science program there um also this class is very popular at Abington so we would recommend adding a second um body systems and applied Anatomy 2 to our catalog for um students particularly in their Junior and Senior year within mathematics programming um the high school is recommending adding a year-long financial algebra course as an elective offer oh sorry the this him moving distracted me sorry things are happening like I'm not doing that okay sorry um the um elective offerings for students who have completed
031Algebra 2 and so this course would extend students mathematical knowledge while allowing them to model and explore the real world of financial phenomena including interpreting and justifying reasoning to make data supported financial decisions and this course would be an alternative for students who um potentially do not want to take calculus but are looking for a higher level mathematics option the social studies department is recommending adding advanced placement African-American studies the senior high school has been exploring this course since College Board introduced it in 2022 the course focuses on African-American history culture and contributions encompassing topics like early African societies the transatlantic slave trade the civil rights movement and modern black cultural movements this course would complement not replace our current African-American history courses and expand students opportunities to explore our past in addition to that
032our social science department would like to change a course title the advanced placement world history course um we would like it to actually be advanced placement world history modern um this is following a college board's lead the course was modified to focus specifically on modern history in 20120 and so this update would just again provide Clarity for families during the course selection process and better represent the curriculum being taught finally our last recommendation is within the science department the high school recomend recommends modifying advanced placement physics C into two courses the two courses would be advanced placement physics C mechanics and advanced placement physics the electricity and magnetism and the purpose for this modification is to better align the instructional minutes for the courses with the College Board recommendations and we believe that this will
033increase students opportunities to be successful in these courses um advanced placement physics C does have two advanced placement exams and it is recommended to be be taught as two separate courses by college board and with that I will take any questions you might have any questions from board members uh one comment the financial um the finance class I know that is a mandate but I am um very pleased to see that all students will have access this is something that all students will have access to yep in Pennsylvania so that is great um the africanamerican a history course um I know I asked this question before but I think it's worth asking again to make sure that that course does not start at a story of uh black people in chains that it incorporates the
034resistance the Rebellion um the Revolution and highlights the heroes and not just the um not just the hardships although that is part of the story and I believe I was able to receive a list of the courses that showed that we are looking at the African diaspora we're looking at uh countries in Africa the story is not starting from a place of chains correct thank you yes the course does start in Africa with the origins of Africa dysphoria did I say it right dip diaspora sorry diaspora um it moves through it does it does obviously discuss enslavement and moves through resistance and the practices of freedom and ends with debates in our current times thank you very much sorry about that that's okay I just had one one quick question of clarification you mentioned that
035the world history course title is being modified so that it's modern history just out of curiosity where does that start um the 1200s okay is considered modern right to present yeah I know historians have a very different sense of what the term modern means than um yes um I guess and that change it happened in 2020 and um the AP course is called that and we did not have that in our program of studies and we just wanted to make sure that that was aligned with college board but also clear to families that it is a studying modern history okay just a comment I'm I'm always very impressed with the course offerings that we have within our district um allowing students to really explore and Del into learning that they want to add to their
036repertoire um and uh thank you for some of these changes to be more descriptive and more deliberate so that families know what their children are choosing and getting into uh in advance thank you I do think that the the teachers and the faculty at the high school do a nice job of really trying to S work with you know students and families to find out what really they want to take and and explore and we've tried to add things over the years to meet those needs anyone else how will the selection of textbooks be handled so if courses are approved um there would be one or two courses here that well they will all need some type of instructional material and so what would happen next if they were approved is we would start uh
037committees to adopt um materials and then those would come before the board before the end of this school year so that we would have the summer to purchase and provide professional velopment thank you many of these courses um do have a there's a wealth of online materials and print materials that actually are free as well so there's a lot of resources particularly to support uh the financial literacy pieces and things like that and some of these are also being provided by the state um there are resources that they're providing for us to evaluate so thank you anyone else thank you okay thank you Dr fetcher our third and final orientation for this evening thank you Dr mauy at this time I'd like to invite Mr Phil Solomon regional manager at IC Mr Todd R CEO
038of rap strategies and Mr Peter Leatherman CEO of the mors Leatherman company to provide an update on Abington School District's future facilities planning okay well thank you for having us back Phil Solomon from IC have David shrer with me as well and Todd rap is online unfortunately he's not feeling so well so he didn't want to come here and coffin sneeze but he'll be presenting most of this in many ways this is the culmination of a two-year process and what we have tonight is quite a bit of information that we've called from uh surveys and scientific surveys and uh tools such as thought exchange so we are very excited to present this and hopefully you'll find it very informative and then obviously we'll be available for questions uh afterwards with that I was going to
039hand it over to Mr rap to start the the presentation thank you Phil thank you members of the uh of the board of school directors Dr fetcher and staff um I'm Todd rap from rap strategies you've heard from me before on the various issues uh during the planning process here Peter letherman sends his apologies just a reminder that the Morris weatherman company uh they're the ones who could conduct the fieldwork draw the sample are responsible for all data collection and data quality on this type of research work and then Peter and I work together to analyze the results of the survey Peter has been through the slide presentation carefully and he agrees 100% with the findings that we're providing here in the recommendation at the end um if we could move on to the next
040slide um just a reminder that this was really the last step of public input that the uh the the the board of school directors and the administration uh requested as part of your planning process trying to understand what investments you should be making your facilities this began back in November of 2023 and as you can tell from the diagram here we've taken a number of different steps over time adding certain information for the public to be able to increase their knowledge and get a fuller understanding of what the project is we had an earlier survey a scientific survey that was conducted in January of 2024 which was complemented by an online survey that was open for any member of the public to take we replicated that here in December of 2024 a different survey but
041once again we offered an online version of that for any Resident to be able to take um just to make sure that that no one feels like that they've been excluded from the process of providing input to the board ultimately all this information has come together in the assessments analysis that we've done the development of the options and ultimately now providing this information from your residents to help you with your decision next slide so the core of what you're going to see here is the scientific survey um the methodology of this was 500 adults and the adults reflect the demographics of the abon school district this is really the only type of research that we can do that we can tell you the demographically the sample represents demographically the 44,000 some adults who live in
042this District it is a telephone survey that was conducted in December you see there the the statistics on what percentage of the sample was cell phone only and you should look at the data as a margin of error of plus or minus 4.5 % as we compare the demographics of the earlier survey with this survey we saw only one distinction and that is that the sample was slightly less Democratic and slightly more Republican than the sample we saw in January 2024 if we all think about the November election that probably makes a little bit of sense forther for the sample here as you had a different performance level for the two parties in the 2024 election than we saw in 2022 for example the the original survey we did in January was focused on identifying
043the right strategies to study it was really a look at what people thought of their current schools and what are some of the challenges they were facing here we're really trying to Pi help you pick the right plan to submit to voters and so the questions were somewhat different Phil let's start walking through those questions one of the most striking things we found out was that 90% of your residents want a chance to make this decision we ask whether or not the district should propose a special 2025 referendum to let voters decide whether to make investments in the Middle School remember in the earlier survey we had already concluded that people believe the middle school and your your oldest schools which of course would be the Middle School need the most investment we asked this
044both early in the survey and later in the survey early in the survey 91% said that you should conduct a special referendum 17% believe that's strong ly only 6% Said No by the post test it was still 89% pardon me I'm going to take a sip of water here with 11% saying no Todd's struggling a bit with the cold from the airplane but uh but I'll tell you right now Phil there's no better place to have a station if you're sick than in Willow Grove so I so who are those 11% okay well 62% of them reported that they don't follow the School District activities that closely 75% didn't support any plan during any part of the survey 75% believe that the funding the school district is just fine you should be able to use
045that funding for the Middle School and 57% oppose nearly any tax increase for schools I really appreciate your patience next slide we asked about the perceptions of the quality of facilities we asked about the high school in part so we could have something to measure the Middle School results against and we asked whether you felt like it was Modern aging but functioning past its prime or should be replaced as you can see there's significantly different results for the Middle School than there are for the high school where the Middle School nearly half of the people responded that it's either past its prime or it needs replacing now who believes that it's aging but just functioning well it was largely people who are uninterested in the tax increase to improve schools it's people who don't believe
046new schools necessarily improve communities and it's people who are who are not predisposed to to vote for particularly any option by that I mean is that they were rather equally divided between the replacement or repair but those who also showed who said aging and they were divided it also important to point out that it was not based on how closely they followed the activities of the school district so was it necessarily people who lack knowledge of what's going on it's just a group of people who frankly have have different different opin about how to deal with the situation but if you go to the people who say that it's that the middle school is either passed its prime or needs to be replaced that that group of people pretty strongly fell towards the the option
047of replacing for them the question was no longer replace or repair they really believe you have to replace for them the question came down to one school versus two schools in terms of replacing the existing Middle School I hope that makes sense once you reach the conclusion the middle school has past its prime you are far more likely to say replace it and then what you're wrestling with is one or two schools next slide so you can remember from the first survey we did we talked a lot about environmental factors we didn't ask all the questions from the first survey but we did ask Three core questions which are about the confidence in the board and the Administration those questions are whether or not people trust you to do what's right for this children and
048staff of this District that during the last couple of years the school district has managed your budget effectively and efficiently and whether or not you do a good job of involving Community leaders parents and interested citizens in decisions about the school the first thing I want you to note is for all three of those you got remarkably positive results and in fact the results are extremely close to where you were back in January now I think we told you back then um Peter and I have worked in a lot of school districts together and I'm not sure we've ever seen this type of response in terms of school district decision making I'm glad we asked this a second time because you always worry that okay if you ask it only in one survey maybe you're
049getting a false positive there of some kind that's not true at all in fact 72% or almost three qus of people answered yes to each of these three in terms of their trust of the of the school board the and of those 85% would support a property tax increase to protect the current investment they've made in their schools and 93% want there to be a referend next slide now we also asked about whether or not people believe that new local funding is needed rather than asking us just one question we split it into two the first question was whether not Abington schools are a good investment then you'd support a property tax increase to protect that investment the the second is whether or not you think they're adequately funded 66% agreed that you are a
050good investment that they'd support a property tax increase to protect that investment we didn't say how much that increase was it's just their gut reaction to that 177% strongly agreed when we asked about adequate funding roughly half or 51% said no you're not adequately funded and when you take those two together 47% or roughly half are support for new local funding meaning that they don't think you're adequately funded and they would support a property tax increase to protect their current investment on top of that another 18% are open to a property tax increase even though they tend to believe you are adequately funded in other words there are the folks who would say show me what the plan is 96% of that group believe there should be a referendum next slide so we asked about
051of choosing between plans in several ways we began by simply asking about the overall strategy not talking about the cost not talking about the tax impact just how should we approach this should the middle school be replaced and if so should it be replaced with one or two schools 25% said no you should repair the current School 63% said you should replace out of that group more said that you should replace with one school then said you should replac with two schools although I'll acknowledge it was very close together when it came to the intensity those who believe that strongly 177% strongly believe you need replacement only 4% strongly believe in repair now again this is without knowing the cost the tax impact any of the questions like this it's just a gut reaction now
052your parents and this is on the right side 38% shows replace with one school 37% said replace with two schools that's 75% total of that group of 72% who was highly confident in the district decision making that I talked about two slides ago 39% said replaced with one school 37% said replaced with two schools of the group that thinks that more local funding is needed remember that 47% 44% said replaced with one school 43% said replace with two schools that's 87% who said replace it's important to look at the people who are confident in what the school district is doing already confident in board decisionmaking and who are natural stakeholders of the district to look at what they think because those are that's examples of people who are going to be listened to in the
053community by their friends and neighbors next slide so next we asked about three referenda referenda a we began and we in this case we began to talk about the actual cost of the tax imp back so referendum a is a renovation plan at $270 million or $51 a month referendum B is a new school on the current campus that's a $285 million or $54 a month and referendum C is two middle schools $450 million and8 and 86 a month I should point out to you that these aren't numbers that we pulled out of a hat uh the IC and Shader teams have worked very diligently to try to determine what the right numbers are for these and we think that this is that that these numbers would reflect what would be put on a referendum
054question if any of these options were chosen referendum a for renovate there was 54% support 42% opposition and you can see that I broke out the strong supporters in each of those also for referendum B the single new Middle School 60% support 36% opposition and for referendum C the two middle schools total support dropped to 41% and opposition of 56% if you look at that that's the impact of telling people the cost and and the taxes the tax increase every month once we did that for the new two middle schools an option that was relatively close to one middle school has begun to fall off again and the reason primary reason for that from everything we've looked at in the survey is simply the cost they're not willing to pay that extra $32 a month
055to have the two schools then we followed that up and we asked people what the best option was and what they felt the weakest option would be and this was really interesting to to us in terms of the best option the winner was referendum B followed by referendum C the two schools and referendum a the renovate but when we asked the weakest option very few people said referendum B far more people felt that one of the other two was the weakest option there's a call essing going on here around referendum B and the best way to explain this is to say that the people who support referendum c as their favorite plan won't reject referendum B just because it's only one school and the people who believe in renovation are at least open to the
056idea of having a new school particularly I would argue because the price is relatively close to the same and I think that what's in the circle there is important as anything for thinking about how to prioritize these plans the last thing I would point out here is that 23% said when we asked the best and the weakest option that they would support no plan now look at referendum B 36% opposition and 23% said no plan at all basically two out of every three opponents have decided right away I'm not voting for anything it doesn't matter at all and that's going to be true I mean frankly no matter what you put in the ballot that's just a reminder and and I'm not criticizing having that opinion everybody gets to make their own decision about how
057they want money invested in public facilities but it's just a reminder that roughly one out of every four voters simply do not want any tax increase whatsoever that would improve the schools and that makes up most of the opposition to referendum B next slide so then we we broke out those three groups again that we Tred to look at more closely the the column in green is just a reminder of the initial support for replacement either with one or two schools all of these groups would support referendum a and what you see here when it says 7116 that's the total support and then we break out the strong support they'd all support referendum a however they all support referendum B by a higher amount and particularly those first two groups more intense s and then
058referendum C while they do support them you will notice that the groups that are have the highest confidence your decision making it's barely a majority of 54% and your parents are only a 52% for supporting the two Middle School plan next slide we finally asked whether or not the district was planning carefully the first what said are you confident that the Abington School District considering the needs of students and staff as a develop a plan for these Investments this was asked after all the referendum options were provided 79% agreed that yes you're considering the needs of students and staff note that the intensity the strong support is a 13 to1 ratio we asked if you're con if you're confident that your the school district is looking to invest tax dollars carefully by finding the best
059funding plan for facilities Investments that was 73% with the same percentage saying strongly yes I will tell you that it's surprising to me that this result was within six percentage points of the other one we often see the the folks opinion on whether using tax dollars wisely drop off by much more double digits for example than we've seen here in Abington I am guessing a reason for that is because of the very extensive public input and information campaign that you've had to date to make sure people understand each step of the process now next slide this wasn't the only work we did we took the exact same or survey that we gave in on the telephone scientific survey and we put that online and invited every member of the public to take that survey the
060important thing here though is that this is a self- selected sample and every time we've done this as a firm where we've both had a telephone survey and then an online survey the online survey becomes dominated by school stakeholders that is it's not a representative population but what I like about doing this is that it gives a lot more depth to the information from school stakeholders especially parents now of the survey 2164 people started the survey which we opened a few days after the uh the scientific survey began and we closed it the morning of December 24th of the people who started the survey 37% did not complete it and of those two-thirds quit by question three they looked at the questions and they said nope I don't want to do this anymore they were
061just more Curious and by the time you hit question 27 which was really unwrapping the strategies over 85% of them quit the survey however 1361 people completed the survey and that's a great amount uh 44% are current parents on the uh telephone survey that's about 29% 31% are graduates of Abington School District or parents of grads that's relatively close to what we saw on the scientific survey and 24% don't have a direct connection and that's lower than we saw in the scientific survey next slide so I'm showing you a few highlights here of what this data showed and what you see here for those parents 44% of the sample the other connection to the school district of 31% and having no current uh connection when we asked whether we should go new or repair the
062current parents felt very strongly about going new the other two groups did not and then we asked the people who answered new should it be one middle school or two middle schools interestingly they began by saying having a minority agree in having one Middle School in all three groups but then when we asked the specific referendum questions that included the tax impact and the cost overall you can see some greatly different results in the case of parents they overwhelmingly gravitated to the one Middle School referendum option if those who have a different connection to the school district roughly half of them would support either the mo remodeling or the the the single middle school but support for the two Middle School op option really fell apart and for those who don't have a direct connection
063to the abant school district there was a slight preference for the one for the one Middle School referend then we went down and we listed all three of those again and said pick your favorite plan for two of the groups it was one Middle School for the third group it was no plan what was the least favorite across the board it was two middle schools and whether we should hold a referendum it was overwhelmingly support once again now I'll remind you again this is not a scientifically representative sample of the community it just reflects the opinions of these 1361 people but there's 1361 people who are interested enough in the school district to give you some data so it's important to look at this and compare it to what we saw in the scientific survey
064Phil next slide now we also did a thought exchange survey this was done earlier than either of the previous surveys I just reported on and the thought exchange the goal with this was to have people who either attended the open house or watched the open house online the presentation from it would then follow up by taking a questionnaire that that we included it's intended to be qualitative research more than quantitative I don't mind providing some quantitative data but the great thing about thought exchange is how it uses AI to analyze qualitative um answers to questions and and really you know that's where you get the things like the word clouds and the and the the tools like that that you could use but we did want to take a look at at least generally where
065we saw support coming in now not everybody watched the the full video of the presentation some people just went in and took the questionnaire separately themselves 61% of the respondents were parents once again far higher than the community as a whole 9% were staff 21% were the community of the people who responded to the survey nearly three quars agreed with replacing the Middle School 63% did agree that two middle schools would likely benefit students but the tax concerns LED them still to re to support the one Middle School option over the two middle schools once we showed them what the cost was and in this case what we did was we laid out several options and then we at and then we said now let us tell you about the cost and the tax impact
066of each opt each option and we let them answer again and when they were identifying their important concerns in addition to educational needs they said safety and maintenance costs were identified as important concerns once again a self- selected sample but it's good it's just more data and it helps either reaffirm what we saw in a SC in a scientific survey and and hopefully provides a little bit more color next slide so just a reminder a few months ago we put this all together in four options several of these had multiple areas that we could have gone for example option one had an A and A B option three had an A and A B they basically broke down between a a a single Middle School building and a two middle school strategy and whether or
067not they would have impact on the elementary school level or potentially have to see some investment in the elementary schools at the same time as the middle school next slide and what we've learned from all these assessments is that first of all as I said the middle school was the highest priority we then identified the multiple options to consider the we went through a process of remodel one Middle School two middle schools with options within each we've learned that managing tax impact was important to Residents and what we concluded was we've got to find a plan that has the best long range value for students staff and residents now I'm sure everybody can say that that's what you're looking for but that's important because the best long range value is not necessarily the least expensive
068plan but it's rather how people believe their tax dollars being used best and as we've sought the input from the staff the parents and residents many times over these are the conclusions that we've drawn residents want a chance to vote building new is preferred because continued investment in the current middle school isn't that much cheaper and two Middle School seems too expensive even the best supporters pause at the tax impact of $86 a month so now we need to narrow this down to one plan and Dr fetcher said you guys you come forward and tell us what you think we should do so on the next slide you'll what our recommendations are building off of the six options that we tested we've taken one a and one B off the list in both cases the
069cost benefit it it was nearly the same cost to build one new school as continuing to invest in the current school if you continue to invest in the current School you still have an older school that's going to need more work over time we won't fully address the educational needs that are in that middle school and frankly a big issue was the disruption during construction there would be multiple classes of middle schoolers who would attend the middle school and have one two or even three years where they were going to school in a construction sect if we remodel the middle school and we asked a question on that in the survey and we found that it was a very high concern to Residents to try to avoid disrupting classroom education during construction when we looked
070at 3A and 3B 3A if you remember right was a middle school a new one on the current site and then one at Glenside welded we found that the site was probably not suitable for the needs of a new middle school and that was through informal conversations that we've had with other local officials in the area 3B would add have a new one um a different new school at Copper Beach but the what we found there was that and along with option number four which would create the graes five six and seven and eight plan that the educational benefit seem strong to people but the additional cost caused public support to Wade even for parents as importantly nearly everybody who supported option three or option four also would support option two finally and we didn't
071test this at all but we at least wanted to make sure that we made this comment for you that options three and four would result in additional ongoing operating cost if you have two middle schools instead of just one that puts puts pressure on your current general fund and let's face it what we're trying to do here is find a funding source that doesn't put pressure on your ongoing on your ongoing classroom needs bill so that's the that's the results of the research that we've done and uh we're here to answer any questions that you have about [Music] it so I know that was a lot of information we are happy to field questions unpack any additional information you may need I have David Trader with me as well if you have architectural questions or
072any process questions as well thank you for the uh presentation any questions or comments from the board I have a question to start um could you expand on time frames for the options I I'd like to hear specifically for option two um best estimate you have on uh when uh residents would expect the project to be completed and start to finish and then in comparison to some of the other options that have been on the table and explored sure option two so you always have a design and a municipal approval process so that's 12 to 18 months depending on how quickly uh you could get that done uh from there you have a construction process for the building is 30 to 36 months somewhere in that time frame depending on how the final Building looks
073and operates after that you still have a year roughly of the demolition of the existing building and then the relocation of the fields so if you remember where we're building or where the building would be built uh you would be relocating one of those athletic fields so that would need to be done in the other the year after that uh if you look at back into any of the renovation strategy you can add an additional year to year and a half to that just for the shuffling of students uh because we would have to have a significant amount modular classrooms so that we could create what's called swing space uh so you could operate or work on part of the building while those students are being educated in a modular classroom form okay so it's
074from what I'm hearing you say and I just want to be clear I've had a lot of residents ask me this recently the best estimate for time for replace with one Middle School is four to five years it sounds like based on the numbers and you're saying that that is the shortest amount of time in the options available that the other options presented would add an additional year to 18 months minimally to it that's correct could I just ask a follow-up clarification um so four to five years is start to finish design to field relocation and demolition correct so how long to occupancy of a new middle school so remember so it's about 12 to 18 months on the design right and 30 to 36 months in the construction so at the end of that
075you could occupy that building okay so then then you still have other work going on on site but the building would be occupied and necessarily the other building would be unoccupied that building would have to be demoed correct so okay sorry did that answer your question or I think so thank you I can build a graphic which would be probably helpful because I I know this is up a couple times and I believe I have one in one of the presentations but I I will send that to the board just for clarification thank you could could you remind all of us of the current status of the Middle School the cost of the Deferred maintenance that we've already identified as needing to occur um and the ramifications of not going to referendum and how that
076could impact the budget in the long term and I know that's might be answered by multiple individuals no worries I'll start with the first one so if you remember the very first thing we did over two years ago was just a condition assessment of the existing building that condition assessment showed about $26 Million worth of just maintenance deferred maintenance that was needed so regardless of what you do that investment will have to be made in the building over the next several years many of these systems are well beyond their useful life many are failing they are not failed but failure is inherently unpredictable so you have very large systems and money will need to be invested the tricky thing is if you wait to try to make a decision at that point you may have
077to invest money along the way meaning you'll if you did want to make a decision at some time in the future you would have kind of thrown good money after bad so you're at a point right now where you can you can make a clean decision and hopefully you know make the best decision for this community uh and and maybe avoid some of that um investment that you need to may need to make in the near future that that was the first part of your question but I'm sorry please remind me the second part um the long-term budget impact of not going to referendum and just paying for these items as they come along so you know you would then have to do all of this under your act one operating budget so you know
078I I'm not sure that you know I'm not in the best position to answer that but I don't believe that the district's finances are in a position to do that so to to invest that money you would certainly have to be taking from the educational program teaching learning those kind of programs to then shift resources into construction I think what you're what you're asking about the referendum is that allows you to have a A specialized portion outside of your act one that funds this program for the long period or for the long time so it would have a minimal impact on your your operating budget now the the only other options that would have would be the the two building options any of those two building options would have ongoing operational costs because there are
079will be some duplication of efforts uh you know nursing uh Food Service those kind of things uh you do get economies to scale in a single building so you'd have to consider that in any of the two building options um the the minimum estimate of that was about a million and a half per year of additional uh just Staffing costs and operational costs that go along with that not inclusive of the construction costs thank you thank you there was a part of Mr Muhammad's question that I I know there was a bunch of them um can you speak to the most pressing issues at the current Middle School that needs that would need to be addressed um I might I might phone a friend to David he did a lot the condition assessment um sure
080yeah I'm not quite sure which system to hone in on the uh the HVAC systems are are having challenges as you probably know uh and we continue to the building envelope is really one of our bigger challenges the the exterior window systems uh Roofing that goes along with that everything on the perimeter of the building so when you lump together the HVAC the building envelope and then of course lighting and electrical you're kind of down to the structure and so those are the kinds of things that we are looking at as things you'll have to deal with in the very near future so you're saying the cost to maintain those things over the years could conceivably cost the same amount that it would cost to actually build a new school it is very similar so
081the the the analysis that we did initially says $26 million just to replace all those systems and they are all in need of replacement there's very little that we can reuse within the building so if you look at the you know the renovate ad strategy uh there's you know almost every system needs to be replaced there's there's literally nothing to be reused except as David said the structure uh of the concrete and how would that cost compared to an a a replacement so the replacement value is$ 285 million so it's a you got a little bit of a you know there's a significant difference there now remember the the replacement option gives you more square footage than you have now your existing square footage is about 300,000 square feet the program that was done the
082program that the Educators would like to run require 345,000 Square ft so you are comparing a little bit of apples and oranges there um if you were to build out the program or build out the existing building to the program needs uh you're then a lot closer and I I will look this up and I believe it is 270 million compared to 285 million so you're getting you're getting a lot closer to the same cost I think it's about a difference of about $3 a month yes that is correct slide nine just wanted to add on those um elements that you mentioned uh you didn't mention um Ada accessible standards for the building um you also didn't mention um like a fire system or sprinkler system to protect our what is it 21 how many
083kids do we have in that building um Dr feter almost 20 almost 2200 2200 students so those are two large elements um that you didn't mention in those Renovations um that I think the residents you know should be aware of as well well there's a significant thank you for bringing those points up and remember we also looked at things like the little theater and some of the functionality of different spaces throughout the facility we were just talking about systems at that point in time but truly accessibility throughout the facility um usability of that building the way that it's set up for today's educational structure and that sort of eases into from earlier presentations that middle of the road concept that Phil just talked about which is the demolition of some replacement of some to try
084to get some of those spaces up to up to par really and also just to clarify like should that happen and those needs need to be met which um I'm a speaking as a parent those are very important needs um that would have to happen while the students are occupying the building in this scenario so all these updates that you're mentioning right here would mean the students the staff the learning the curriculum how it's um being executed on a daily basis I mean long-term projects the public health standards um and safety concerns that we would have um as a result of uh Demolition and and Remodeling on a 19 is it 1964 year old building um and the products used then so those would all be considerations that would happen as we moved along that
085process as well yeah that's correct so yeah I mean you you've got you've got it nailed I mean any anytime we're going to try to fix something in this existing building it's occupied and all the systems are so large that it's not that you can't really just do them over a summer any one of the systems that David discussed any the Ada upgrades they're going to take more than a summer even HVAC even Roofing the building so massive that's more than a summer project so all of uh would need to take place during an occupied time frame in addition if you wait until something fails to address it there a lot of secondary Downstream issues with that so one you don't have a lot of options about upgrading a system you almost have to go
086with a like for like replacement because you're going to be in an emergency two when you do something in an emergency format it does cost more you've got to expedite materials and some materials are not even available in an expedited fashion today there's still supply chain issues stemming from the pandemic so many of these things would be very problematic to try to react to versus to plan for if that's what you're getting at because that's that's certainly an issue here especially with how obsolete many of the systems are right Fire Systems all of those things would also need to be upgraded there's almost nothing you could do in this building that would not trigger a CO a total code required upgrade in addition to that there are there are uh rules about how that works
087so uh any major replacement hbac or otherwise would then trigger all the other Ada uh compliance issues and code issues so though option two is slightly more expensive you have you eliminate the interruption to learning that's going to occur um where students and staff and the entire Community is going to be highly impacted by in a negative way um you have a little bit more cost but it's still not at the higher end of some of the options we saw before uh and so students and staff see this building come up move into the building and then they see the old building eventually come down that is exactly correct yep maybe one and that's probably uh the end result is critical obviously what you end up with as a district is critically important processes as
088well and so the point you've made is either you're going to have a new building standing on the site students will be going in an unaltered facility move into the new facility and then the old building comes down so they're not living through the construction in the buildings they will on the site everybody's going to have to bear with the site in the renovation option we have built in modular classrooms so you can move entire groups of students out into the modular classrooms and they'll continue to move around the building as parts of the building are renovated and finished so there is some disruption in the process while the students are going to school while the construction's occurring correct thank you anyone else yeah so if I'm sorry please please okay um so if our
089um if the public decides that we're not going to go with any of these options am I correct in saying that we will eventually end up spending the same amount of money correcting problems in a reactive fashion probably down the line and not have a new building to show for it is that correct that that's correct and you still have to apply the inflationary factors to that that 206 is today's dollars right okay so as you as you inflate them to the Future it's going to be more than that so yeah that that's the floor not the ceiling if you will okay um just a a few comments I believe most of my questions have been answered I just wanted to comment on the transparency of this process and how much information the public has
090access to and I want to thank you for the hard work that has gone into that including creating a calculator so each individual residents can look up their information and see what these how these choices impact them individually I think that that was huge I also wanted to highlight that the um surveys that were done two of two of them scientific and two of them just general anyone who wants to get feedback we similar in nature and it looks like the majority of our community members in Abington and rockage uh would like to proceed with option two I think it would behoove us as a board to be able to give um um feedback to Dr fetcher and his staff about what option we would like given uh input we would like to move forward
091with so that the next meeting they can present what that referendum would look like could could I ask one more question just before we do that um you could even ask more than one great thanks um I just want to get to it I I agree though um uh regarding I can't remember what slide it was but you said I think I just remember seeing the number 54 per month I believe that was option n thank you um can you explain for what value home value that is is and I'm assuming that's the average value for a Abington resident just clarify that um that is the median hubad value okay that's the same value that Mr leonetti uses as the the median so it's the middle I think it's typical for you to see that
092as a median taxpayer okay thanks I just wanted to know that for sure did you want to know what that house value was I'm sorry I just wanted to make sure your question actually yes thanks yeah I would I yeah we have what that correlates with too $387,400 okay any other questions just want to make comments um because I feel like there's been so many good questions um but to say thank you for the presentation and also thank you to everyone who answered surveys answered phone surveys went ahead and took the survey because this information is super valuable and important to us and making the decision on what to do going forward um so thank you everyone for your involvement I oh Brian sorry um I too I would like to make a a comment
093um I think all of my questions have been answered this has been extremely uh thorough and comprehensive um as Miss Brown had said about like feedback I I I do agree um with the direction I think that especially based off of the scientific data that um was presented tonight by Todd uh it's pretty clear of what the community wants when we factor in the dollars and cents and um I definitely could support um putting to referendum for the one referendum b or option two the the one new Middle School um I think that makes the the most sense and it's also uh backed up by the data of the community in terms of what we can afford okay anyone sorry no go ahead yeah um at the beginning of last year the residents shared that
094they had concerns about the Middle School um which was backed up by the the study of the building um the year prior uh and so we' seen that that that was a concern um the residents shared that they would like to see something be done about those issues and they threw out all sorts of ideas and we were all wrestling with those ideas and have been wrestling with those ideas for for about two years now um and you know here we are the resident said we would love to see two middle schools um but we don't have the tax tolerance for two middle schools um some people said we're okay with just renovating and expanding or just doing the maintenance um but we see that the cost is about the same as the one new
095school option um and the one new school option is less disruptive um and will yield benefits when it comes to the makeup of the school the the flexibility of the school being able to offer uh Innovative academic programming to Future generations of students in Abington and Rock Ledge and so I would totally support the one new Middle School option and hope to see that put forth uh in the next meeting Kathy um I walk around with my dog in the neighborhood and people now I know I'm on the school board so they stop and ask me questions a few of them says why do we need a new Middle School well last week I had the opportunity to take a tour of the middle school cuz I had never been in there besides a little
096theater yes I could clearly see we do need a new middle school and I was happy to have that uh tour that way I can intelligently speak to people who are I who don't think we need to to spend the money now I'm in that bracket with a senior I've lived in the township for 29 years my mortgage will be done next year so I'll have to pay the increase in full write a check not in in mortgage so somebody like myself we will feel the impact um a lot more than somebody having a $50 increase to their mortgage but um it's I I I mean it's just like it's it's it's a no-brainer it's just something that we really need to do for the community and for the aventon students so I you know
097I have to support it personally I did like the uh two School option but it's just too cost prohibitive so I would support the one okay anyone else have anything else to add um I'll go I um originally when we were given the options um as an educator I thought but the two School option was definitely the best one um as we work through the last year um through the process we realized for many reasons it's probably not feasible um financially the the options are just way more expensive and the operating cost would be too much um one of the things that we've talked a lot about is how to make one big Middle School um feel smaller on the inside um and I think that that something design wise that we would want to
098look at if we could do it so that it's not just one big school with three floors it's you know got smaller areas um for smaller groups of kids because I think all of us feel that 2200 kids in the middle schools a lot and you know exploring ways that we can make it feel a little bit smaller and more community- based as we move forward um if this is the option that you know we decide on um but I do want to thank everyone who took the time to respond to the surveys we really have taken all of that information into account um and we've spent countless hours with you know IC and thank you so much for all the information that you give us um and I feel pretty confident that after looking
099at the data that the one new Middle School feels like the best option for Abington right now um so anyone else I just wanted to add um the process has been interesting thus far in the time and energy and the layers of feedback that we've received throughout I guess you know over the last year um Additionally you know one of the biggest concerns that I saw with this was some of the public health um things that I brought up in my questions today and um it feels good to know that the residents are looking at options that are considering that um the safety of our students the safety of the staff um and long-term solutions for the best value of the community I I would be happy to support it and ultimately it going to
100referendum it really does make this a community-based decision it's not just about any one of us sitting here or any one of the 1300 people that took the non scientific survey or the 500 people that took the scientific survey or the handful of people that I talk to on a regular basis or the you know countless numbers of people that showed up at one of the open houses or that grab one of each you know us in the street or when we're on the bus stops waiting for our kids or just talking to your neighbors or friends it's an opportunity for all of us to collectively come together um and make the decision for what's best for the community so yes I um would support option two and i would support it going you know
101for the voters to finally to make the final decision so um I want to thank you guys for a great presentation for your hard work um up until now I know we have had a lot of questions throughout this process and you've been um very accommodating very forthcoming and answering those so I'm thankful to that for that um I also want to thank my fellow board members tonight for their thoughtful questions this is a group undertaking um many of us think of questions that the others don't and I feel like that was on really impressive display tonight um I would add a couple of thoughts to the points that others have made um for me I agree that the the solution that seems to rise to the top for many of the people who participate
102in the various surveys as the second one um and I'm happy to support that I was also um struck by how many people who participated in those surveys wanted an opportunity to vote to make a decision on this for the community for the students um and so I certainly want to add my thanks um to the people who participated in those surveys but um I I could not in good conscience having seen those survey results deny them the opportunity to weigh in through a referendum question um and I think I finally you know my kids started in this District right after um the big investment in the grade schools I think my daughter was in the second class to start at Highland um and and one of the reasons we moved to Abington because is
103because we saw it as a community that cared about education that was willing to make investments in facilities and curricula for students um there were school board members and residents who voted to support the building of those new grade schools um schools that benefited my kids and I cannot in good conscience denied deny students who have yet to come through our schools the same opportunity and so unless I'm mistaken Dr fetcher I believe the board is directing you to prepare a referendum question to be voted on the next meeting's agenda okay we'll do okay thank you thank you thank you gentlemen thank you okay we are now moving on to comments from citizens um before I do that I do want to point out that we will have three opportunities for public comment on the
104um on the possibility or on the referendum question and before the board votes to advance it if if that's their choice so I just want to put that out there um um comments from citizens are being conducted both in person and by phone the phone number to participate in public comments is 267 715 3717 and is being displayed on the screen at this time you'll be able to join the meeting by calling in on your mobile or landline phone if there's anyone present who would like to make a comment please use the microphone either to your left or to your right go ahead thank you first off I want to say uh Merry Christmas to everyone as we celebrated the birth of our Lord and savior and a Happy New Year and hope you all
105have a prosperous 2025 also I recognize a new leadership team I wasn't here in December I wish you well with that there are tough jobs you have to do so um first taxes are not Investments it's a great euphemism but you're always asking the poorest of us to pay for something and without considering the impact on their life as opposed to the impact on your budget so as far as elderly on a fixed income poor people parents struggling with their kids already in school I'd love to hear some options and discussions on that uh the second one is this is a $300 to $500 million tax increase that's what you're voting on you've completely misrepresented the referendum the referendum is required by state law when you want to increase our taxes Beyond whatever the limit
106is it is nothing to do with you giving us a choice to vote on a school plan you can write the referendum however you want you're required to propose a referendum in order to get people to agree to increase their taxes by more than what's legally required right so I think you misrepresented that and I don't know why unless you don't understand that um there was never one question asked on how does any of this improve education like why didn't we present a question that says we're going to spend $ hundred million of new taxpayers money how should we best spend this to increase or improve our kids education we're not ask that and that's because have any of you read the IC contract I'm asking an honest question I hope you have because I
107don't I have a question first we paid 75,000 then another 75,000 and then if you vote to go with a referendum then they get $115,000 more but in uh this next part here maybe you can confirm this for me on uh attachment B does IC get 10 to 12% of the total budget in other words a 20 to potentially $50 million contract if in fact this gets approved approved I'm asking that honestly because that's the motivation for IC to develop a propaganda campaign to convince people to voluntarily increase their taxes so here's what I propose you should have bought St Basil's we could have had a brand we had have a school in 40 acres of land for far less money and then explored options for five or 10 years as to how to move
108forward that would have saved Green Space and it would have given us a whole school but nobody thought of that even though we hired I yes opportunity missed okay next question when you did the tax calculator this is what I don't understand when we did the 2017 bond issue it was 25 years to pay off the bonds but when I looked at this Mr lionetti sent me the or told me the link today you put a 40-year wait on these bonds why is that thank you your time is up you're kidding please take a seat can I take some more time please take a seat I don't think there's anybody else here you won't give me any additional time please take a seat someone else is ready to speak there's plenty of time great hi
109uh Jen Pell from Glen side I wanted to thank um the gentleman for the presentation um and for all of the work that was done to um come up with this plan I um unfortunately was one of the 37% that started the survey but did not finish the survey um but luckily um I wanted the one school plan anyway so I'm I'm pretty happy about that um and I'm excited for what's coming in the future I think that this is a a really a great step forward for Abington to maintain our standards but also to grow and to um give the kids that are coming up in the future as much opportunities my kids had I've had my kids graduated from Abington so I am again one of those parents that I'm a parent but
110not a not of uh kids that are in the school now so I just want to thank you all for all the work um and I'm excited to see uh what happens next Take Care thank you for your voice uh Mr Green has anyone phoned in to be recognized for public comment uh we have no callers on the line okay Dr fetcher I think that um one of the uh comments that I would make in terms of the transparency of this process process um and the actual impact that was spoken about in in terms of coming to what is you know that of public opinion and also having this goto a vote of the entire Community truly speaks to what the community would like to see happen so every every taxpayer in Abington and Rock
111will have a voice in this and as much as we may make recommendations from the administration side um I will not have a vote and and I think that is important in it and let the community speak okay thank you uh with that I think we move on to item five oh you okay five minutes okay we're going to take a five minute recess everyone okay welcome back um so I just wanted to correct myself before the break I said we were moving on to agenda item five um that was handled at the beginning of the meeting and so we will move on to agenda item six approval of minutes Miss Frasier can you please read the recommendation to approve the December meeting minutes uh yes it is recommended that the board of school directors
112approves the minutes of the board reorganization meeting on December 2nd 2024 and the board meeting on December 10th second uh we have a second this is a voice vote all those in favor I I all those opposed the motion carries uh Miss Fraser can you please read the recommendation for approval of the Personnel agenda yes it is recommended that the board of school directors approves the changes in personnel as reflected in Personnel addendum numbers 7.1 and 7.1a and confidential addendum number 7.1 B second we have a second Dr fetcher thank you Dr mauy the personel agenda begins with the retirement of Mr Jay Blumenthal The Advocate School District tax collector for Abington Township who served the Abington School District for 19 years the Personal Agenda continues with the appointments of two administrative staff members including
113Miss Karen Sanchez who has been appointed to serve as the Abington School District tax collector by Abington Township and Mr William fry singer who has been appointed as the network administrator the Personnel addendum also includes a request for leave of absence of One Professional employee appointment of One Professional staff member as well as a change in status for professional employee Dr Patrick Watkins who has completed all requirements and earned his Doctorate from Newman University Dr Watkins uh has served the aboca school district for 22 years and currently serves as an elementary curriculum specialist at Rial Elementary School the Personnel addendum continues with compensation for IEP meetings and interpreter and translation services uh comments or questions from the board I just would like to say uh thank you for your uh Decades of service to uh
114Mr Blumenthal and congratulations to Karen Sanchez who will be coming in to um pick up those Reigns and continue with great work um and congratulations to the additional appointments as well indeed uh I'd particularly like to thank newly minted Dr or congratulate newly minted Dr Watkins um on earning his his Doctorate um it's great to see our staff pursuing additional training and education um congratulations to Miss Sanchez on her appointment and Mr Blumenthal on his retirement um and thanks to our staff for all the IEP meetings that they attend on behalf of our students um okay uh Mrs Flanigan this is a roll call vote Mr Allen hi Mrs Brown I miss eisenhart I Mr Muhammad I miss balding I miss Hartman I Miss Frasier I Miss Fey I Dr mie I the eyes have
115it and the motion passes Miss Fraser can you please read the recommendation for permits for use of buildings and grounds uh yes that the board it is recommended that the board of school directors approves the applications for permits for use of buildings and grounds as reflected in addendum number 81 second we have a second Dr fetcher thank you Dr Mai the permanent addendum continues to reflect typical requests for buildings and grounds and meetings and other school events and activities for this time of year are there questions or comments from the board just continue thank you to the uh staff who create spaces for students to do things that they enjoy really does make a difference anyone else nope I second that gratitude all right Miss uh Flanigan this is a roll call vote Mr Allen
116I Mrs Brown I missenard I Mr Muhammad I miss balding I miss Hartman I Miss Frasier I miss fezy I Dr Mau I the eyes have it the motion carries uh Miss Fraser can you please read the recommendation for permission to advertise for bids it is recommended that the board of school directors approves the permission to advertise for bids as reflected in addendum number 9.1 second Dr fetcher we have a second thank you Dr Maui uh this evening we have one request for permission to advertise and that's for middle school chair lift and the purpose of the lift is to facilitate movement from floor to floor for students who utilize wheelchair uh the elevator is original to the building and has increasingly required service which makes it unavailable for student use frequently uh the installation
117of this lift is is a matter of equity to ensure that all students have access to Middle School instructional program at all times okay questions or comments from my fellow board members I I do have a comment um and it's it's going to sound a little off at first but bear with me who would have thought that a chairlift would cost as much or more than a 30 passenger bus that we're going to um that we have the potential to approve in the next uh the next agenda item but is it worth it the answer is yes because we want to make sure that students have access and it's students who have learning differences is students who have physical uh challenges that get the short end when we don't make the hard decisions to invest
118in things like a school that would provide more than just the Ada Basics but actually provide access so this one item uh is an that I will vote Yes for is one of the reasons why it's so important to think about who um as I heard a Community member say who gets receives the most harm when we when we don't make decisions or when we do make decisions and in this case this is a prime example of how spending 250 to 300,000 more than a passenger bus is needed and without hesitation I say yes anyone else well said um anytime we have an opportunity to invest in curricula or changes to buildings that increase access for I for our students it is in my opinion money well spent uh Mrs Flanigan this is a roll
119call vote Mr Allen hi Mrs Brown hi Miss eisenhart I Mr Muhammad I miss balding I miss Hartman I miss frer hi I miss FY I Dr mauy I the eyes have it the motion passes Miss Fraser can you please read the recommendation for awards of contracts yes it is recommended that the board of school directors approves the awards of contracts as reflected in addendum number 10.1 second we have a second Dr fetcher thank you Dr Maui uh this tonight for your consideration we have one award of contract and as Miss Brown mentioned it is for a one3 passenger student transportation bus questions or comments from my fellow board members no okay Mrs Flanigan this is a roll call vote Mr Allen I Mrs Brown I miss Hartman I mean I'm Sorry Miss eisenhart I
120Mr Muhammad I miss balding I miss Hartman I miss Fraser I Miss VY I Dr Maui I the eyes have it the motion passes Miss Fraser can you please read the recommendation for adoption of instructional materials yes it is recommended that the board of school directors in accordance with sections 508 and 803 of the Pennsylvania school code adopt new textbooks Andor instructional programs for the subjects courses and levels reflected in addendum number 11.1 second Dr fetcher we have a second thank you Dr maray uh this recommendation is for the instructional materials adoption which we discussed earlier in today's board orientation we can answer any additional questions that you may have questions or comments from board members yeah is there a um a yearly renewal fee after we pay the the original fees for the program
121will we have to pay yearly for materials and subscriptions Dr Viola can you go through the uh breakdown of terms of our [Music] agreement sure the company has agreed to a three-year payment plan for the purchase of these materials um the three-year payment plan allows for us to have six years worth of material okay great and then after that we'll have to purchase after six years we would have to renegotiate a price okay to re and typically typically these are up upfront and loaded as in the first year for majority of the cost and then the second year a smaller amount uh one of the things that it was important and and I asked our team to um go to this uh company to ask if we could split it up as much more as
122you know throughout the process and the reason for that is because of the way that it affects our um annual operating budget and so having this opportunity which they typically don't extend um was attractive to us because we can spread that out over three years and the impact on our operating budget is less in the first year and how often do we undertake curricula review what's the typical cycle we do typically tried to stay to a six-year cycle okay great so this would be up for review in any case at the end of six years yes perfect how does yearly cost for software versus textbooks compare off the top of my head um sorry that was just on the top of my head it's they they bundle the program together so um the price is
123really um adjusted based on the purchase of both I just wanted to add that you know each of the different textbooks that we adopt have different types of programs many of the Publishers today um anticipate that you will need actually both online and paper so it's very rare that you just have one or the other in today's market you they develop the programs that they're actually both that you will need so we'll never fully the vest ourselves of print materials or resources and the online is usually meant to augment and support sure thank [Music] you Mr Allen did you have any nothing okay um I one of the real treats for me was seeing teachers really excited about um integrating this curriculum into their instruction um so I'm I'm pleased with that Mrs Flanigan this
124is a roll call vote Mr Allen I Mrs Brown I miss eisenhart hi Mr Muhammad I miss balding I miss Hartman I Miss Fraser I miss FY I Dr mauy I uh the eyes have it the motion passes Miss Fraser can you please read the recommendations for the proposed Academic Program changes yes it is recommended that the board of school directors approves the academic program changes proposed for grades 6 to 9 to 12th excuse me as reflected in addendum number 12.1 and authorizes the publishing of the Abington middle school program of studies 2025 through 2026 for grades 6 through 8 and the Abington senior high school program of studies 2025 2026 for grades 9 through 12 as the official statements of the programs of study for grades 6 through 12 the board approves the courses
125listed with the understanding that scheduling of the courses is subject to sufficient enrollment and adequate budgetary provisions second we have a second Dr fetcher uh once again we um saw our presentation during the orientation and we can answer any questions that you may have any questions or comments from board members no okay all right Mrs Flanigan is another roll call though Mr Allen I Mrs Brown I Miss eisenhart I Mr Muhammad I miss balding I miss Hartman I Miss Frasier I miss FY I Dr Maui I the eyes have it the motion passes Miss Fraser can you please read the recommendation for the confidential student matter yes it is recommended that the board of school directors approves the confidential student matter as reflected in addendum number 13.1 second uh Dr fetcher we have a second
126okay the confidential student matter is in regard to an education service agreement keeping in mind the confidentiality of student matters I can answer questions that you may have questions okay Mrs Flanigan Please Mr Allen I Mrs Brown I Miss eisenhart I Mr Muhammad I miss balding I miss Hartman I Miss Frasier I miss FY I Dr mauy I the eyes have it the motion carries uh Dr fetcher are there any additional reports and recommendations by the administration and the superintendent uh yes Dr maie I provide the conference attendance and professional leaves and the capital Improvement projects report for your information okay any comments or [Music] questions no okay uh any other business that appropriately may be brought to the attention of the board of school directors okay with that we will move on to our
127final opportunity uh for comments from citizens comments are being conducted both in person and by phone the phone number to participate in public comments is 267 715 3717 and is being displayed on the screen at this time you will be able to join the meeting by calling in on your mobile or landline phone if there's anyone present who would like to make a comment please use the microphone either to your left or to your right you may go ahead okay thank you so uh I do not uh have confidence in the tax calculator that you've presented to people I think it is misleading so I'm going to ask why was the bond issue slated out to 40 years are you as the board really planning on taking 40 years to pay off this building an
128average commercial roof lasts 20 to 30 years and HVAC system lasts 20 to 30 years so if you're doing that to try and artificially make the tax increase look lower you should at least say that the second one is why five to 5 and a half percent and I'm just asking that because it doesn't seem to me like that's realistic there may be some reason but I'd love to have an explanation for it in the 2017 we gave bonds out at 5% in 2017 if we're giving them out now with the current situation there's a 30% higher CPI rate now the treasuries are what much higher than they were in 2017 the then we got ripped off in 2017 so if the same board making those same decisions like wait a minute in 2017 we
129should have gotten we shouldn't had to pay 5% or we're going to pay more than now I'd like to ask those questions I hope you all would consider it because you're telling people that they're going to pay taxes at a lower rate than I believe they're going to I still will stand by you're voting on a $1,000 increase for the people who live in Arsley per year on their taxes and now it looks like it's going to be 40 years instead of 25 the next question is can you explain to me I think I know would one of you please explain to me what does a wraparound Debt Service mean that's a highlight at the very top of the bond issue this stuff ought to be explained if you're telling people this is what it's
130going to cost if you're honest and you're confident you have no problem with people making decisions based on real information if you're trying to deceive them then then that's needs to be known too so the next thing is I'll go on real quick is um we had a 50 million special fund that was been spent by the board already two years ago we were told by the administration one minute that there was $118 million $461,000 pretty precise that was how much improvements were needed in the middle school at that time Junior High School whatever they're calling it at the time I don't remember we have a solid structure who was wrong was it the administration then or these inflated costs right now to make renovation look like it's more expensive than it would be um
131I'll leave that right there thank you all for your time but I do enjoy The Virtue signaling about spending $300,000 of other people's money it may be needed but uh I just think it's comical thank you for your voice hi um I just uh based on what he was just saying again this isn't you guys spending this money you guys are coming up with a plan presenting it to Abington residents and we are voting on whether to go ahead with it or not so it's not that you are spending this money or you are ass setting this number you are presenting the options it is being Chosen and then the voters get to vote on it and I again I'm excited about the possibilities for what the school district will have in the future um
132and then there was also a comment made about why didn't um the school district Buy St Basil's um and I'm not really sure of all the background on that but it seems to me that building on land the school district already owns is better than buying land from a public the private school or the dicese the other thing is the building at St basil from what I can tell probably fits a quarter of the students that we have in our middle school so not only would that be buying a a school that is about as old as the building we have now it would be having to then build a new building on that land we just bought and then hoping there's enough room for Fields I guess but once you build a building big
133enough for our students parking for the students and the and the staff and then trying to have some Fields I'm not really sure where the cost savings is there so I again I in favor of the plan of building on the land we already own and keeping all the kids on one campus to best utilize the fields the facilities the staff Etc so thank you again thank you for your voice um Mr Green has anyone phoned in to be recognized for public comment uh we have no callers on the line okay uh with that we will move on to closing comments of school directors at this time are there closing oh did I miss something I'm sorry I just wanted to uh respond to I apologize no that's all right um the the dollar amount
134of $118 million that was presented um and they were I'll just so the Public's aware the comment was made so I wanted to clarify thank you what was stated and where it was stated um so that was in theil the facilities assessment review in orientation on May 24th 2022 that's available on board do and then the facilities Forum presentation which was in June 29th 2022 and both of those presentations had the same dollar amount and the important thing to note about that uh dollar amount is it is for major systems and it is not a entire total renovation which would be starting at the $26 million budget and as well as uh costs um that have inflated over time so I just want to be clear about that in terms of why those numbers were
135given and what it actually stands for and and would mean uh and that would be um for just major systems in that building and not a renovation okay thank you for that clarification anything else okay okay with that we will move on to closing comments from school directors Mr Allen nothing thank you okay Mrs Brown thank you everyone have a great night Miss eisenhart Good night all Mr Muhammad good night Mrs or Miss falling I beg your pardon have a good evening everybody miss Hartman take care Miss Fraser just a little something from my notes a little homework assignment um I just like to share that an increase in property values will eventually offset the increase in our property taxes to pay for a new Middle School according to further research for every dollar spent
136on public schools home values can increase by $20 have a good evening Miss FY take good care of everyone thanks everyone for their time and attention and patience today have a good evening