CorpusRecord 63445

BOE Meeting January 16, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Red Hook CSD
Date
2025-01-17
Location
Dutchess County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,367 words · about 58 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001uh is this working working oh no nope no the problem is yeah get the mic there we go excellent and she can do audio video I'd like to um welcome everybody we can stand for the pledge welcome everybody I think if we have a emergency or a fire I think we're in very good hands tonight um I do need a vote to adjourn exec and enter the public hearing all in favor right so this is uh uh the public hearing uh regarding the tax exemption related to volunteer firefighters and uh uh ambulance First Responders um I'm Bruce is not here is there any errand do you want to speak to this so New York state allows school districts to approve a resolution which would um permit any volunteer firefighter volunteer ambulance worker to um get

002a a a real property tax exemption um which is up to 10% real property tax um so a couple criteria they have to be an active member of a volunteer firefighter Organization for at least two years um and this exemption also covers uh lifetime if they have served more than 20 years of active service then they get lifetime exemption a part of the resolution also that we added in here was that um should they be killed in active duty that their um spouse if they've had at least five years of active service their spouse would then be entitled to the exemption on the real property tax um or if they've served as at least 20 years then their un remarried spouse would be able to also have that exemption so in order to qualify they

003would have a letter from their organization attesting to the fact that they were an active member for at least two years then they would go to the assessor's office and apply Great Bear with me one second just yeah no that's good um uh does yeah and so sorry um um she's always keeping us in line uh any questions from the board no um we do have a uh public comment section so if there's anyone that would like to address the board regarding the exemption at least at least one of you please please yeah yeah and uh if you can just uh state your name so uh they can put it in the record I want to thank uh the board uh Red Hook Central School District for accepting the letter um this is going to

004be a huge tool for recruitment retainment um there is tremendous amount of dedicated volunteers uh that serve this community both ambulance as and as uh as firefighters um so again it's uh it will be a huge tool another tool in our box to bring in members um you know for the community that might not be here don't understand we do have a lot of new people that live in this community this is 100% volunteer organizations uh we do not get paid a dime people run their own personal vehicles their own fuel their own insurance um going to calls going to the firehouses so this this is just another way to show gratitude to all the time and effort that they put in in training so again thank you to everyone um I hope this passes

005and everything goes through there is a large group of members uh in both departments that have served this community for 20 30 40 uh 50 plus years that deserve this and it's getting harder and harder to pay taxes here so it'll be uh it'll be a big relief for most of them so thank you very much appreciate it thank you is there anyone else all right uh if not then we're going to adjourn the public hearing and mention the vote on this comes later in consent uh actually uh we're going to adjourn the public hearing I'll need a motion and a vote to do that and then we're going to go straight to consent agenda so that we'll vote we'll vote on the consent agendas which this item is a part um uh so uh

006do I have a motion to adjourn the public hearing motion second all in favor all right uh and so now we're GNA adjust our um order here and we're going to go to the consent agenda um do I have a motion second so um we we'll now be reviewing uh discussing and and voting on everything on the consent agenda this does include a donation from the a Enzo Foundation some field trips um um uh the tax exemption that we just discussed number of other things any questions or comments from any board members on anything here all in favor I post all good thank you for your service know I all right so now uh we're going to go back to uh the regular order of our meeting and that brings us to recognitions Dr warden

007so Tom Casada Tom you're here right yeah um and if we can also call up Chief Mike Lan from the red hug fire department to be also to be recognized I just gonna hate this so Mike was my student many many years ago we won't say how many and uh played on a few of my teams um so it's great to continue to work with Mike in this capacity so many of you don't know for for many years um we didn't have an athletic trainer so I would try to get um the volunteer fire departments to come work all of our football gam specifically uh and for many years we did that then it was it became ch challenging uh we had many years where we would contract out with Northern Duchess paramedics then Mike

008came on the SC I said Mike could could you maybe you know step back up and and help us out um see Mike all the time both companies come to the school when we have emergencies they're always there um for us and it's very important um we have at the school we have the um the mock accident everybody's seen those pictures if you haven't gotten to see what they do there it's it's amazing and put on presentations for our kids so it's comforting to know that they're there whenever we need them especially when we have these football events where by all means it's one of our you know most um highest causes of injuries so having the ambulance crew there in Jun conjunction with our athletic trainer and visiting other schools that have the athletic

009trainer there as well is a huge plus it makes everybody feel good we appreciate their knowledge we appreciate their help um and they transport kids for us quite a lot not just our kids if somebody from another district is hurt then you know they they step right up and take care of that so Mike's Been instrumental in in having that peace of mind for our programs and providing that safety for our kids so um we been planned on doing this a couple times and every time we do it Mike's always at a call so um we finally got him here tonight and hopefully there's not another call because there's a lot of people here as well but um I just wanted to you know thank the company um in front of the board and let

010them know that they do a lot of work behind the scenes Mike's quiet guy he loves coming to the school every time we got a fire drill that goes off you know Mike shows up right there and um you know because we've had a few this year we had pretty big one had a gym full of people and couldn't get the fire alarm to go off and there's Mike helping us out as always so um we appreciate all the work he does and all the work all the fire departments do locally um and it's great tonight that this was was part of the agenda so this this worked out really well so um I just want to thank Mike and the company and everything they do want to say anything Mike he does not want

011to say all right thank you Mr R are the students here are um see are Ben and Nora here I didn't see them so I think the students that we were going to recognize might have had a last minute conflict come up so maybe we can invite them again in the future but if Dr war and I could just speak briefly about their achievements um so tonight we're recognizing Ben pner and Nora Callahan Jurgens two of our incredible student musicians who recently not only attended our regional All State but actually were two redo students that went to the state level nisma All State Festival um absolutely an incredible accomplishment uh Norah is a soprano in our choir she's also involved with musicals um all sorts of drama club activities um she's also performed outside of

012Red Hook in Reinbeck as well so extremely talented Ben pner he plays the tuba and he actually went beyond the state level and he's playing in the northeastern Ensemble as well so for you know a relatively small school district uh we have two shining stars among many others in our music department but again we're we're so impressed with these two students and all their peers as you know we can all appreciate the time and dedication to become this level of musician the hours upon hours years after years of practice and passion um it's commendable we appreciate it and we just want to celebrate and recognize them so hopefully we can have them back in the future but in case their schedules don't allow because they are very very busy um at least we can give

013them a shout out here tonight thank you and Miss Smith Miss cillo and I think Isaac is here too right um thank you I appreciate the uh appreciate being allowed to come and recognize this student tonight so it is my privilege tonight to recognize a very exceptional student from our Lambs Community his name is Isaac Shapiro at the recent New York State Council on leadership and Student Activities conference in Lake Placid Isaac our Lamb's student council president was recognized for this his remarkable leadership Isaac earned both the emerging student leader of designation and the Kelly Jeffers outstanding student leader award these accolades not only reflect his natural leadership abilities but they but also his dedication to our school community Isaac's achievements are the perfect example of our community our commitment to fostering leadership skills in

014our young people thank you for being a reflection of our school and of our radar profile Isaac we look forward to watching you continue your continued growth and positive impact on our school Community this year and Beyond congratulations no we're gonna have a have a for Isaac you want say all right and next uh please help me congratulate congratulate lamb student council adviser Lauren cerulo uh who also earned recognition this year at the state level student council conference winning the nla 2024 Kim goldor middle middle level adviser of the year so we really cleaned up at this Con at this conference there are two things we want uh two things that I want to let you know that are very special about this recognition the first is that this award originated um one of our

015retired teachers Kim golders um and she was actually there at the conference to present the award which was really special second this nomination for this award um was originated by student council members um from both from lambs and the high school uh who took the initiative this fall to nominate Lauren um and to go through the application recommendation process so that also makes it really special that it originated from students Lauren exemplifies educational excellence and dedication in her leadership she's involved in in everything in our school building and she truly has a pulse on the school Community this recognition not only reflects Lauren's outstanding contribution but also her profound impact um to our students Liv so thank you Lauren and congratulations I would like to just say something about Isaac um he uh the one

016war award that he won actually was a two-year application process that he went through with all these things that he had to submit and and things like that it's really a big deal to to get that and it takes a lot of time and dedication and he is a true go-getter he is there everywhere when we we need somebody to do something or take a leadership role he is uh well I'm sure he's going to do great things in the future hello hi I am Isaac and I'm the president of student council this year the reason we wanted to give Mrs R the best student council advisor of the year is because this is her third year student council adviser and she has been an immense help she's helped so many people with things like

017leadership applications and has generally made Student Council a more fun place I have no idea what student council would be like without her this year we wanted to do something special because of all the wonderful things she's done for us these activities brought student council to work as a team and we all know each other with the help of over 20 people we gave this honor sister Ru she has helped greatly with not just us but all the grades at Lambs as as advisers thank you to everyone who helped from rhhs and Lambs thank you for your attention and time have a good night thank you all right that brings us to our uh student Boe remarks uh Danielle hi sorry not in sorry um the student council is planning a Spring Carnival at the

018high school uh for a date tentatively as June 4th um the blood drive in the spring is starting to um become like in planning stages uh for sports both girls and boys basketball will play a game against Marboro tomorrow indoor track and Fields has a divisional meet this Saturday um the wrestling team won their meet against Liberty the other day and the boy swim team uh won their meet today against Valley Central or we'll play a meet we'll swim a meet against Valley Central today I don't know if they've won yet they did win okay and then the robotics team has a competition on Saturday um so for the senior class we're choosing our prom theme next week which is super exciting and then we're also ordering our senior class t-shirts um which Ava hubner

019designed um and we had a vote and it was great um Mentor Club we're having a unified spring s on um April 5th it's under the Under the Sea themed and it's at the high school it's from 5: to 8:00 p.m. um and pretty much just everybody is preparing for midterms next week um the 21st through the 24th so good luck on midterms thank you yeah all right thank you next that brings us to uh Dr Summers presentation I'll just do a a quick introduction to this too um as many of you know um digital literacy is really important to us um not only for our students future with their digital Footprints but also the importance of um using digal digital literacy as a tool in the workforce also in your personal life and something

020new that we've been working on the past couple years is the con of how artificial intelligence will be implemented in the school district and what that will look like Dr Summers is has done a lot of work in this area the past couple years so we're going to give you some highlights of what we've done so far and where we're headed thank you Dr Ward good evening thank you for coming for this um so first of all I'd like to thank this takes a team to to do this type of work and I'd like to thank the people who contributed to this um PowerPoint um Donna seelbach takes a lead role as a director of Technology the principles including Dr Boyd Mrs Smith and Mr R do a fabulous job at the school level to

021make sure that we when we were asked by the state education department that we implement it with Fidelity and I'd also like to let you know that the elementary Librarians really um help me out a lot Mrs Shoemaker and Mrs Quin Carl so thank you to all of them before I get started um next slide so what is artificial intelligence um it's we've had some form of artificial intelligence it's been around for a while it's algorithms analytics artificial intelligence has been used by K12 in higher education for years um now we have a new newish generative generative AI so we need to keep up as far as District policies and procedures are and we must speak to the intersection of the AI benefits and all the data privacy rules and regulations schools are required to

022abide by which we keep a very close um notice to and we are working right now towards an AI policy next slide so distinct use cases of AI Tools in schools and that is the verbiage that is used for tools so we have it under Umbrellas of institution teacher and students so there are different examples of the different tools we use it at an Institutional level to create newsletters presentation content um we also at a teacher Focus they can be used to create lesson plans generate differentiated instruction and also draft letters of recommendations student Focus that could be learning portals that personalize content based on student input and some assistance with writing assignments and translation of content students preferred language so it is a a good tool but we are examining all the ways that

023we should be using them in our instructional environment so AI tools used in bread hook are the following um and I'm not going to read all these slides to you so they Microsoft's co-pilot all these things have been vetted through our dep tech department except for chat GPT that is something that is used um certainly for letters of recommendations and and different things that we need at an institution level um kigos used a lot with a teacher Focus and also with a student focus at the high school only next steps for AI we need to um we have a committee form for the creation of an AI District policy to address the different stink use cases for AI we're going to continue to provide ongoing professional development to make sure that we Foster effective appropriate

024use of AIS to support instruction and then we will continue to vet requests for AI um products and making sure that we are complying with all the different regulations that we need to um Ed law 2D perpa Copa Hippa regulations um next slide good so before you go on Dr Summers if um just talk a little bit about I was able to see Mr Rod's um Roundtable discussions on AI oh that's what's coming coming sorry coming Dr W that's at the the end I'm doing foreshadowing so what is digital literacy um it certainly is the knowledge and the ability to use digital technology to create research communicate collaborate and share information we need to make sure that our students and staff understand digital citizenship which is really making sure that when you're using digital literacy

025that you do it in appropriate safe ethical legal and positive way in online environments what it's not it's not a teacher certification area nor is it expected to become a class that a student takes it really is embedded in all of our work so New York State education dep department has set a standards for computer science and digital fluency learning standards and this is something that can be accessed through the New York State education department and it is a large document but it really outlines all the standards that are needed in each of the um grade levels so this is something that started in 2018 the state legislation passed a regulation that said that New York State education department had to what required them to draft standards the education department reached out to the field

026Educators uh people that work in the profession and they really spent time two years to reflect on what it should look like the standards the draft standards came out in 2020 and then um they continued to draft those they're under five Concepts impact of computing computation thinking networks and systems design cyber security and digital literacy this is the timeline so there was awareness building from December 2020 until June 2022 then roll out happened at the state level for capacity building which from July 22 July 2022 to August 20123 and then there was initial implementation last year and September of this year was full implementation we have done that we are always looking at the standards to make sure that we're not missing any and that is done um through our library systems through our classrooms

027and we certainly offer some courses specific to computer science so part of this process is the deployment of the onetoone devices our students have um Apple Computers they um during the school year of 202 2 2023 it was year one um devices were given out to grades 6 through 12 that was 950 MacBooks and so we use smart school bond act funds to make sure to purchase those MacBooks year two was one1 devices to all all of those students to make sure that we did not miss anyone and then year three this year which was new is one to one devices were given to all fit graders now those devices stay at school for the 6 through 12 they do take them home and are able to use them at home and um next slide

028okay so how do we do this millroad elementary students have access to Apple devices at the primary level the kindergarten classes attend sessions and the iPad lab with their teachers at um grades one and two have shared iPad iPad carts and at the intermediate level students have access to MacBook carts and grade five participates in the one toone program students are learning keyboarding and using typing.com wow okay um I have it here then also next one um the library programs next slide please um do use a common sense media program um students also explore lessons from unplugged projects to create chat Bots and simple video games to strengthen their understanding of AI literacy in the upper elementary and libraries also have mixed device cards courses at the secondary level again reminding you that all six

029through 12 students have Apple MacBooks and digital standard are embedded across the curriculum so the high school offers AP Computer Science design and drawing production Advanced video production and at the middle school all students take computer science which is a class professional development so that's one of the ways that we support our Educators in making sure they're current and compliant with the expectation of the standards from the state um so we do ongoing educational workshops we have done this for years the IT department has been very supportive of this we have our own teachers that um are very talented in the area of technology and offer professional developments within our uh after school but outside of their workday but to teachers so that these Workshops can be ongoing and now Dr Warden you attended Mr

030Rod's Round Table um it was amazing I when I first started teaching we we had very little content to draw from so um the lesson plans the assessments that you could find the rubrics are all right there just by typing in a few words and the teachers are getting an idea obviously you're still going to look through and see what works for your class but just the the amount of time it can cut down for planning and ideas I think is is great I also wanted to make it mention that one of the strands that um Dr Summers mentioned before and we're starting to look in into is cyber security is a huge Market out there um for students that graduate high school and college um in that area so that's something that we're trying

031to explore like how to offer that in the high school how do we have the area of expertise of our teachers to offer that because that is a large field that's happening right now all over um for our students so we're exploring that concept right now and that I did talk with Mr R they are um starting to develop a pathway for computer science and that would include cyber security um and also as some of you have the books in front of you do know that the kids are not just behind their computers um we know that this is a tool this is not going anywhere um so it does it does help you with your classes but there also is a reality that students aren't outside anymore and they're not playing and they're not

032they're not collaborating you know talking to each other as much as they have um in the past are using much more social media so the book talk and the community I think will help with the balance of all this that's going on um also in addition we have tons of time for re recess and almost all of our our schools too so that's really important to us so I want there is a balance also our counselors push in especially at the middle school and talk about digital footprint so whatever you put online is there forever and the impact that could have on you when you apply for colleges colleges do look at your social media um so getting students to understand that this is a great tool but there's also a lot of things that

033can go wrong um if you're not using your judgment as well so it's a balance for us to know that this is the future but also that there's a lot of things out there that students and families have to take precautions about I just wanted to say thank you for for talking about having that balance because when I see you know kindergarteners using iPads at school and and second graders needing to learn how to type on a keyboard it sort of does raise that question for me of like is that really necessary um what does it look like what are they doing and you know parents are trying to balance screen time at home and they're having also now screen time at school and just that balance that you're so if you you know when

034you pass the imagination station um coding for primary kids is picking stuff up and like physically moving they're not actually on computers for that it's patterns it's creating patterns pathways so um it's it's part of a bigger um so they're working on many more activities than just that there's like little pre-engineering classes there's coding I don't know what what else you want to the green screen right robotics in there so you know that is also part of this is that basis um typing came up as an issue because students type most of the time on their cell phones and they use their fingers so believe it or not like I don't I know how to type I couldn't tell you where any of the letters are but I took typing when I was in school

035so I think one of the things that we took for granted is that kids knew how to type which actually they don't they were just like plugging at the number so we wanted to go back and say that this is also a skill so that is more of like a program where the kids go on and it's more of like a rot program like fine a and then it's also um New York state test are done computer-based testing so they to know how to type and it's a great life skill typing um this isn't going away uh when people go out to the world of work college is part of the process so um thank you um you know as Dr Warden said it is we do offer very balanced program of having kids be

036actively engaged and also making sure they're current with Trends yeah so I have question on the uh AI side of this um um you know you reference uh Chad GPT um co-pilot uh I'd be interested uh are do we have any examples of how teachers are leveraging generative AI or um AI based avatars or any kind of uh educational media to complement uh what they're doing in the classroom I can't give you a specific example but I KH Academy has been going on forever that has always been part of it's just now it pulls up millions of videos um I could put in chat gbt right now tomorrow I'm going to teach a lesson on flowers pollination of flowers give me five videos that are appropriate for five yearolds who this is the first time

037they've ever heard the concept obviously you're going to go through each of the videos and say is this relevant is this appropriate I do know some teachers are using it for lesson planning but real careful look at what it has um that's why we continue with professional development no information no personal information can be put into any of these AI engines right um so but it is enhancing our instruction I don't think it's taking away from our instruction and it's used um with great thought yeah okay I me the reason I ask is I see tremendous opportunity for it to leverage and enhance education you can think about foreign language and avatars that are um you know for an ends to an AI that you can interact with um there's lots of apps you know

038to do that and there's you know on down the line or even like personalizing it so if I'm say I'm going to teach about the American Revolution tomorrow and I have students who struggle with reading and then I have students who are more you could put your exactly what you're going to read with the class and say could you make this more accessible for students who have dyslexia could you make this um you know more advanced for students who already have prior knowledge for this so those as a former special education teacher is huge because those are things that you're modifying now you have that or students who don't speak English could you translate this for me really quickly um I think that's the the key to the amount of time that teachers take planning

039and I think also I mean you know AI is is changing so quickly and education with great respect doesn't change as quickly we know that right I think that it's all in the theme of how kids learn right so the fact that you can take you know a semester's worth of information and synthesize it in seconds is going to force teachers to think about lesson planning in a different methodology because kids are not going to have the patience to go Revolutionary War first you know five years you know it's a different speed with which there's access to information so it's going to help us shape you know like a different kind of teaching I mean I think most of us I'm going to age myself was either the encyclopedia your parents told you so now

040it's it's true so now and think about that's my lifetime so these students can go out and they can find out anything so now what you have to teach them is is this a reliable source who's F who gave this information where' this information come from so information is everywhere now so it's constantly in their on your social media your I mean it's all day long and what skill they need more than ever is who wrote this um what was their their point of view what's their purpose um and that's what the classes are more like you don't you can't learn every bit of content anymore I don't know do you guys want to talk about AI or anything not to put you on the spot yeah she's not asking you to confess that that's

041how you did your English assignment now like a part of um the process of turning in like our papers like our uh IAS or like essays that we do um we have to turn them in through turnit in.com which will give our teachers kind of like a percentage of like which one's of human written and AI written things it'll say like ai% so that's a huge part of like just our like that's how we turn things in um I think it's helpful like you can type in to like AI like give me sample IB style questions that ask me about genetics or something if I want to study for my like Bio exam I think that's like helpful right I feel like our teachers are teaching us how to use it in a way that

042is more productive rather than like plagiarism so like for math we use Microsoft co-pilot to like get sample questions um and stuff like that and it's also everything is turning digital now like our AP Calculus exam is going from completely paper to half online and half um looking that up online yeah there's 16 16 AP subjects that will have a fully digital exam and it's changing this year it's it's of just showing that everything is turning digitally and AI is unfortunately a big part of that but it can be used in more productive ways rather and and coming back to the professional development um because obviously you know uh teachers need you know support and um you know training to know how to you know optimize some of these tools and I know you spoke

043to it but now it's circling back to so we do we do ongoing professional development and some of our teachers have become very um very wise about AI so they're sharing their expertise I do know that when we go to conferences you know AI is always a piece of it so and uh bosis does offer some AI I think the internal work that um Mr Rody is doing with his Roundtable AI is important I know Jen malitzky at the middle school has done a lot with AI so it's building our capacity for professional development both in-house and sending people out for AI and you know the most important thing and this goes back to Dr daget is um and also Linda Jordan is that we need to teach students how to make very strong prompts

044because that's what part of this is about and then we need to teach students including teachers how to edit the information that comes out of it and how to know whether or not it is correct not all AI information is accurate and that has to be watched also so I think it's a thinking process that we're teaching our teachers and also they're teaching their students on how to approach this new tool um it's like when the first when the internet first came out or we rolled out computers or the calculator or the calculator yeah um so it's but ongoing professional development is key and we do have a lot of teachers um participate in it we've also had a lot of teachers participate in the book study so that balance again is so important yeah

045um and that's part of our role as Educators is to make sure we're continuous in our practice in our best instructional U methods for teaching yeah I think that that's a really good point I think one of the jobs we were looking at in the future is a prompt writer so you're interested in that um I mean if anybody's used it you know that you get better and better as you use it that the better your prompt is the better information you put in quicker the information is so thanks Dr yeah thank you all right we just that can I just say one thing oh yeah um I just just want to thank our firefighters for coming and um I know our meetings are really exciting but we respect your time so please you don't

046have to stay go to your families and or you could stay I mean there's a lot more exciting things happening thank you V and approve the exemption so you're good to go all right yeah yeah I thought they were interested go all right uh that does bring us to our first recognition of visitors CLE thank you thank you so uh we that brings us to our first recognition of visitors if there's anyone that would like to uh speak to the board again uh you have three minutes uh if you can state your name and about 15 seconds before your 3 minutes is up I'll give you a little polite wave um so I'll open it up if anyone would like to uh speak to the board and that uh that uh results is what I'm

047here to give a brief uh analysis of um the on the uh Dei cost benefit analysis I've got the top seven I have there are many others costs and benefits of Dei educational philosophy uh on the benefit side uh the number one benefit is increased educational performance whether increased or not increased uh number two is better racial uh sexual or uh other understandings of the community uh number three is better employee satisfaction number four is better parent satisfaction five is better student satisfaction six is better public satisfaction and better mental health of the students is number seven these are not in any particular order uh there could be other benefits unfortunately the uh Administration has not really helped in this process at all uh the cost side we have hard costs of the consultant fees

048that have occurred and other Associated costs we have soft costs or opportunity costs of going in a different direction or different philosophy and goals of Education number three we have a worsening or not or satisfaction of the Dei process with the public parent parents teachers students and other employees number four is increased legal costs number five is decreased or flat educational performance six is the lack of Financial Focus by the Board of Education and administrative leadership for example enrollment is down 18% 2019 to 2025 and costs per students are up 49% same period that means the cost per student has surged to current $3,914 per student this year increased homeschooling is number seven the top costs to look at are the hard cost the cost the opportunity costs The increased legal costs and the course

049results of the educational perform um unfortunately on the benefit side I cannot find any benefits whatsoever on the cost side the estimated cost is about $2 million per year and estimated to accelerate about 20% per year in conclusion we have I think three choices here we can ndi in the Red Hook School District immediately as an acknowledge costly failure in performance if not outright B we can do nothing we can we can um continue the Dei educational philosophy and continue to waste taxpayer dollars with no clear benefits this of course is the definition of insanity doing the same thing again and again and expecting different C which is what I would suggest and I offer to the board my Aid and also discussions in the future by want the board to seriously consider Community discussions

050and as I suggested three and a half years ago to Dr Warden on Dei why we need it and what are the benefits and does it exceed the costs of the process thank you thank you hi folks my name is James canor I just actually happen to be here on a separate business tonight uh but we were talking about um how educators are implementing uh AI in the classroom and I thought that this would be a really good example so uh I'm a teacher here in the district I teach social studies and special education um one of my class sections I have 13 L students so English language Learners and I also have students with 504 plans and um and IEPs so it's a it's a very diverse group uh and they're really enjoyable to

051to teach and to work for um some of the ways that I've implemented AI in the classroom this year uh is being able to Target specific uh vocab words to support instruction and being able to level them for the students and to meet them where they're at uh a number of my students have uh come to the country very recently and they don't have primary education in their first language their home language uh and their English proficiency is also very low so being able to help support grade level education and meet students where they're at uh AI has been a really great resource I'm able to figure out where the students need instruction that's you know generally with the assistance of uh our enl teacher um and then Target specific vocabulary words and then use

052AI to create um accurate um vocabulary lists tailor definitions and I can align that with study guides and assessments and I can do that you know very quickly and consistently so I can continue to implement targeted instruction in the classroom instead of trying to um narrow texts or narrow lists the AI tools that we have available some are for free some provided by uh by the district really helped to Target education uh and really work with the students meet them where they're at so yeah that's great thank you you guys very much yeah if I may I really appreciate how much uh energy and attention you guys have all given to recognizing that we are at the very beginning of a new industrial or intellectual and academic Revolution AI is really changing the landscape of

053where we work play how things work um and your uh attention to that and implementing it in primary education is really important um you know typing skills are foundational I have two children one of them whoes in second grade here um and I'm counting on you guys I'm counting on us to be able to provide them with the basic tools they need how to type how to write prompts but also just basic reading skills and thinking and learning skills like it all it doesn't work AI doesn't work technology doesn't work if we don't support Reading Writing and play and teaching get how to use these skills so I appreciate the time and attention you guys have all given to to this topic thank Youk you yeah thanks for uh the effort you're putting into kind

054of creatively find and leverage technology to support um some of our students that you know need extra help uh anybody else all right uh that brings us to superintendent Communications Dr Bon I don't know if anybody was able to listen to Governor hok's State of the address but I wanted to address a couple of the topics or priorities that she outlined that have implications for education so we did note before and again thanks to the asanzo foundation for supporting our breakfast for all good night drive safe um Governor hokel has put in her budget um Universal School meals for all children so that's not only um breakfast but it's breakfast and lunch for every child in New York state she's also proposed modernizing the civil service system which is is huge for us um as

055you know that we have our certified employees but we also have our civil service employees throughout there and the system is Antiquated to say the best so looking at waving some of the fees um just an awareness campaign of how you can apply for a civil service job so that will be great for us because those are the areas that we need a lot of um support in she's also talking about a program to work with the Department of Labor that if um different businesses ire high school students that that they will be reimbursed 50% I think that's a great way to get students into the workforce she's also talking about increasing investments in early college high school programs she's also discussed um youth mental health with the Teen Mental Health First Aid Program which

056we started already and then weaving in um social emotional well-being to after school programs and as well as uh expanding broadband and cell phone service yes there are many people that don't still have that um she also talked about there's been a lot of discussion about cell phones it doesn't look like that she's given a direct um idea of what she's going to do but she calls it distraction free learning so I think she's going to be providing some standards for school districts to look at other areas of interest is expanding what we just talked about media literacy um talking about how to help teachers with guides on how to combat misinformation launching a public education campaign another area of Interest I thought for us is she's looking to provide additional funding for agriculture in

057the classroom programs that will enhance students understanding of agricultureal food systems and nutrition so I think having the um already having a future farmers and looking at a lot of the programs that we already have so that that was something I think we should just take note of so these are all her proposals so we'll see and I know we've already had many discussions around those areas um what's going on in the districts um at millroad as you know we transition to trimesters and that seems to be much more successful than having the four different quarters that gives um teachers times to get to know the students better we do have a great spelling B winner it's a fifth grader Mahi Jane she'll be coming to one of our next meetings but our fifth grader

058swept the bee um which is great um it's very tense those things um we continue to do our Shakespeare workshops I was able to see that this week there's a lot of energy in that room um moving on to Lambs lambs is also thinking about moving perhaps next year to a trimester as well because it gives teachers more time with students and not so focused on I got to get so many grades for a certain portion of time and as you could read her report there was some great activities um Bingo volleyball was going on um Martha Sher was again acknowledged she's it's it's still going um she's been recognized by the sun new Paul's alumni as well as representative Pat Ryan mentioned her name on the lore um the US State House of Representatives

059let's see oh I I think another thing that's really great is when we talk about real like real world connections um I think you were able to see that one of our teachers Justin Deming which will also have come he wrote a book called 50/50s it's a it's a literary project that he been working on and he put it out there to say if you buy this I will donate all the proceeds to um local families in need so they made $375 but we also want to congratulate him it is a huge thing to write a book so um and also our uh eighth graders also wrote a book that's um in the library at um Red Hook if you want to take a look at that and moving on to the high school we're

060starting core selections so it feels like we're always building for next year living in the following year um we're also working on an exterior mural we got the permission of the original person that painted the mural to move that's you have to do that so now we're going to look to with the support of Ali Roland and um the Education Foundation moving forward with that um when we talk a lot about Equity we also talk about the fact that we are growing our IB for all so every student is now in our English program so they all have the access and opportunity to be in there and we were able to be um recognized by IB as a school that is having a lot of success in this so I don't know if you got

061a chance to read that that they um would like to have more information about how we were able to make that successful so that's really great if we could be a model for other districts we're looking at a possible another new course next year called Innovative journalism and media content production we're looking at the ELA classes I know that English teachers came and they told you they were doing the English classes before the IB they're looking at making those full year instead of half year I think to get to know the students a little bit better all of our 11th graders will be taking the ELA regions in January that's something that we we move towards um let me see anything else oh just like I have have done before the Freshman Focus again will

062include that Teen Mental Health First Aid um that was recognized in the um Governor's proposals as well and let's see so as far as facilities are going um we have uh as you know we have a new HVAC C system at the high school so we have trainers coming in to help people learn the equipment because it's much more digitized than it ever was before and we have that Chiller which is a new type of technology for our staff to use so we have a lot of training going in there um the temperature Bild that also got passed so that was the bill that a a classroom can't get above a certain temperature that you have to move the classroom at the very last minute it was changed to like when practical basically if you

063can't do it don't shut school but please try to do it so at the end of last year we made sure well the high school is going to be a lot better off this coming school year Lamb's got a lot of the standing AC's we tried you just can't have 100 degrees three days in a row um but we're trying to figure out how we can keep that the buildings as cool as possible and obviously we have our project going on I don't know when we'll start that here the air conditioning conditioning is likely going to be 20 26 27 okay um and I don't know if you want to talk talk a little um Erin about where we are with the capital project sure so we um are finish the design phase of the

064new gymnasium upgrade so we are on target to submit those plans for review in the beginning of March um we are going to use a third-party reviewer to try to expedite the process because um nce it is running at about 9 to 11 month review process whereas a thirdparty reviewer the maximum they should take is 16 weeks um so our hope is is to have that work done this summer in the high school gym it's better work to do over the summer it's less disruptive to the program um so that's that's our goal but it will all depend on when we get the plans back um from review that initial submission also includes renovating The Columns at lambs and it includes installing the lockdown buttons at all three buildings and just lastly I don't know

065you can talk about the realtor pass this around so um Dr Warden and I are going to host a realtor breakfast next week um January 22nd and the idea is to invite local Realtors just to come learn about our programs that we offer here um at Red Hook to highlight some of our successes and different programs that we may offer students um that set us apart from other school districts we'll also talk about the non-resident tuition program um and answer questions that they may have about that yeah so we're excited about it how many do we have joing right now we have about six but we think that they're bringing colleagues so we're anticipating more if you know people yeah yeah yeah that was one of the ideas when I attended the National Conference um

066that superintendant were doing in other parts of the country and I thought that's easy great um good way to advertise I know they're asked a lot of questions when they're showing houses and even if they can't move into the district what are the possibilities of yeah we'll let you know how it goes feel free to come if you want that's it all right uh Dr Summers so this is an update on teaching and learning across the district so I just like to highlight a few things um Kristen strathman and I attended a New York State education department roll out of the prek through grade three literacy instructional best practices and the K through3 literacy curriculum review guide as as per education law 818 districts must now attest that in September 2025 that a curriculum review

067that has been has been completed in prek through grade three ensuring instruction and interventions aligned with the commissioner's requirements we are in excellent shape almost all teachers in prek through grade five participated in a curriculum mapping um summer workshop well summer work last summer to integrate the big six skills in writing into our um Curriculum maps we have continued that process this year with plans for summer curriculum work this summer so we will be in excellent shape for that process a lot of school districts have not started that process it's a huge undertaking um and but we've always been reflective in what our work looks like um as far as updating it Dr Boyd and I will be participating in the regional professional development planning subcommittees that's through Duchess bosis we will support the sub

068Committee in literacy and numery and instructional design and assessment that will be ongoing starting in um next week and um that'll help support D the Bosey work to make sure that they're meeting the needs of school districts I continue to work with teams of Administrators and teachers during um the following meetings to make sure people are updated and that we're clearly communicating expectations but also sharing any issues or concerns that um teachers in the field or administrators need to discuss um so that happens during coherence technology curriculum Council Equity professional development and our a committee so we are busy in the district but I think think we're also enjoying it so excellent thank you thank you all right that brings us to uh the Boe review uh we can do a readout on committees maybe

069uh we can start with the uh Community Relations Committee do we we call it Community engagement Community engagement okay all right yeah yeah I was reading what was written but I thought it was Community engagement yeah yeah um who who from that committee would like to to read out uh so we um met and we worked on our um new Community Partnership team on the informational flyer um as well as the questionnaire um Jan helped us with that quite a bit so um thank you um we did set um some dates for the building tours this is for that group of community members that will come in it would be the same community members each time we're looking for around 12 um but uh we're looking at February uh 21st for Red Hook High School

070um March 21st for milroad elementary and then May 5th for Lyndon Avenue and all these will run um from 9 to 11 with the theory being that we would like some board members you know if you're check your availability um to be be able to go on these tours um with the administrators and with our community members and we the community members would attend each session they would go to all three and can you summarize the process for how we're going to select people how many we're going to select so so we're looking to select about 12 of them um we are working on the questions now and we would either go through those if we have more than that then it would probably go to a lottery system okay yeah okay I yeah we

071we'll send you once it gets tweaked we'll do that so we talked about that um we worked on that and then is the idea at the end of each of these tours uh the uh the representatives are you know from the community that do the tour will be able to offer feedback suggestions thoughts yes and so and then we would then share that out with the rest of the board but yes that would be and you know we're looking for something to do instead of a meet and greet and so this is um what we came up with so we would use you know collaborate with them with their input and then um and we talked about having a speaker at the end right so having the directors come to so I can't remember exactly

072who's coming on each each day but some the high school would have food service and transportation millroad then they would have technology and Athletics and then PPS and um I'm missing something up facilities so that you're able to hear from not only the the building but also what the director's point of view of the different things that are happening right and I I Envision questions throughout the whole tours um feedback and then a discussion at the end and it'll be the same people and it's very important that it's the timing I know is challenging for people but it's really important that school's in session they can see what's going on so they can see what's happening that's what I was going to say is that it's really about getting the community members back into the

073school buildings and the classrooms and getting to reconnect with what's happening because it's been a long time and with covid it's been even longer yeah so we're trying to kind of bridge that uh with the community again and a lot of these times when you do things like this you start to build Partnerships that you didn't know like oh I didn't know you did that in the community I didn't know you could support our students in that way and then do one of you want to speak to the AR the safe uh the school that we have the town coming next yeah um this is kind of in the parking lot for the committee is we're looking at kind of safe walkability in the village and in in the town for students um kind of

074looking at the surrounding streets and you know what could help to make it a safer uh commute for students walking biking whatever it might be um so we have reached out to to see if a representative from the town could attend the next meeting to look into you know what they've explored to that end um and see how we could you know support efforts um you know whether it's speed bumps more more sidewalks um you know whatever it could be I know in a number of areas over the years they have extended sidewalks we've all seen it I I kind of wonder if they have a longer term plan on where they may be extending sidewalks yeah it's Grant you know that this this particular program is is a grant there is a specific Grant

075that's called um safe roots to school per students yeah you had it right there and Ry backck actually received it and um they were able to expand their sidewalks um so it was just one of the things that we kind of were hoping to see if we could look into together maybe partnering with the town to see lead that it that's all you did I can make this into a paper airplane no it's uh it's it's great to see the new committee uh um uh uh with several great things so anyways good um uh policy yep um also I just wanted to comment on that too and just say about the community um the committee and all the work it definitely seems like the point of of creating that community and the board's presence to

076make a connection with the community it feels way more meaningful the type of things that coming forward I know it's in this early infancy but compared to my limited experience um this feels like so much more engaging uh and helpful for the board as well as for the community just anyway yeah yeah um for policy there is a lot um but I think how I'd like to summarize some of the work is that um there's a a lot being done around transportation in this last go around um some on facilities too but for the board to know um Mr lesie and U and Anthony from the Department of Transportation for the district um worked on the recommendations from what we get from Erie woses and our existing policy work and did a collaborative effort to

077match recommendation with current practice and spent time going through uh the policies that you'll see coming next time um but I just think that that's such a critical way to create policy is having the experts in the district um say so to what is actually going on uh and it creates a greater um liability net for the district which feels supportive of not only the work that they're doing but also our students and community in that same way feels really responsible so I'm happy to see that policy is uh evolving in a different way and that they're getting a lot more feedback directly from the different departments and people who are sitting and I know the stuff is hard to it's dense it's hard to look through it's probably why some of the things haven't

078been updated in a long time understandably other things are going on day today um and I know Scott's doing the same thing with the facilities things that you'll see upcoming uh anyway it makes it makes for someone who's working on the policy committee um rest assur that there's um direct input from the people who are doing the work and how it matches up to the recommendations that the district gets on how to write the policies in a given area thank you uh and that brings us to facilities Aaron I think you were going to read out sure so Erin kind of mentioned this really briefly um but the third party review information was submitted to the state for the gym renovation um State contracts were found so we don't have to go through the bid

079process um that's looking to okay okay we think okay um so we're hoping that that will be ready to go um this June and hopefully be finished up in the summer um and then summer 25 begin looking at the field design um for the soccer field construction to the West um it's looking like a summer 26 start possibly just being out of commission for a season and then the last topic of discussion was field one um so we talked about a couple options we could propose another Capital project um if we were to do that that would go to voters in May and then if approved we would be looking at you know a several year down the road finish um and I think we're thinking that's not that's not a great a great option

080we really need to fix the field now um so we're looking at resurfacing the grass utilizing the fund balance um with this fix that would allow us to start right away so in the spring um and if SED we would be in um in full use for the fall which won't affect any of the sports programs um and with that said if we are only looking to resurface just the grass field we could possibly bring up the track resurfacing um a new fence and possibly lights into a capital project a smaller Capital project yeah yeah so there the the idea would be um we would fix the field we would resid um the field inside the track um which is has pressing need to get fixed um and we would do that out of fund

081balance and then we would have a separate um Capital project that would require voter approval for fixing the fence the track and and and potentially lights if we want to do that so that's something we have to explore further and then present more information to the board so we talked about being at a Max of 500,000 but those numbers are not those are estimates yeah yeah so you know we we we toyed with you know do we bring this up to a capital project um but the problem being is that it just it will affect our programs we may not be able to use the fields and they wouldn't be finished for two plus years it would yeah it would it would take an extra year because we have to you know file with the

082state um the state has to approve yeah after after vote approval the state has to it then um you know then we've got to get the design work and then file and that's 12 months or we could use an outside you know review agency but it it it it delays it it delays it a year um at least so U what's the expected lifespan of that like the sing like two years three years no years well I think part of it depends on how well we take care care of it yeah so issues the safety of that field you know um part of this renovation would raise the drainage so we wouldn't have those big gullies so it would be more uniform we still have a crown because you have to have a crown on

083a grass field to get it to to drain um but it would address that major safety concern I have right now and right now as you've heard me say there's the grass that's on there is not good grass so this would fix that one question I would have about that is we had talked about the that it would be more beneficial to do the field the track at once and the fence because of just the construction work and so would this be this would be in separate things so the field would be resided and then and then the and then later the track can be resurfaced in the fence can be done and so does that not potentially cause harm to the field that's just been it's just more of a challenging workflow for them

084but they've assured us that they've done it before so yeah Tom said like if we were to do this immediate sing for the track because there are some areas right that have cracks or are immediately it's still usable we could just fix those now then do the capital project and then do the research the entire entirety of it that will not be hugely disruptive to the work we do and invest in the sing that makes sense and the lights like nothing would prohibit the next phase and then like a nicer fence and lighting not 100% sure but we're toying with these different ideas so with the the with the way the field is now will it impact uh your spring Sports no we would we would do it probably plan on doing it the end

085of May when the track season's done and um for the for this spring I'm trying to move as many lacrosse games off of the field as I can to um Bard College and uh de Stadium their new ter facility um partly because I have the concerns that I have so but this is this this hybrid approach of residing you know out of our fund balance allows us to uh get field one um uh resided and uh usable for the fall um CU that's pressing you know issue there uh and then the other items um aren't as pressing and we can get voter approval as a capital project and those items you know then would be covered two-thirds with state aid so we get the significant benefit there um it may take a year later um

086because we then have to get approval from the state they've got to review the plans uh but um the resid would be for the for the fall it's not you're not trying to get it done for this spring okay no the resid it would be done it would be done over it would be done starting like hopefully in May June through the summer so it would be ready for the fall and then the track and uh redoing the fence would be a capital project which then has you know there's there's a kind of an extra 12 month to have to go through the state but also we get two3 State funding to cover the cost of that so yeah so if the if it the field was resided even middle of June that gives me

087a solid 3 months and we're not talking about growth because you're going to resot it um generally in six weeks you could be back on it so this will give give us even more time there um you know to stay off and get that that good grass to grow and additionally in the in the football schedule I can request that hey the first three weeks we're not going to be home we're going to be on the road and so you know maybe we don't need it till the 1 of October so I'd be comfortable with that yeah it's also a repair it's not a rebuild so it goes quick it would not be a rebuild just repairing the surface of it to try to like Tom said level it those those side dips to level

088up so the timeline's shorter than it would be if it was a rebuild does it resolve in any way the drainage issues you said something about that so my concern is that the drainage being just such heavy drop offs you know um and speaking to a couple contractors they would come in and raise those so there are four literal drains in each corner of the field they would raise them up appropriately you know put put new gravel and probably tubing um skim all the grass off probably some some really good new top soil and that field is irrigated they'll have to work around that but they I'm sure that's not an issue and then lay brand new sod and we go from there it's not a new irrigation system that would be part of a

089rebuild right yeah I think that's something to really that the board really has to think strongly about that you're taking $500,000 out out of a reserve the other option is you shut the field down and you do Capital project and you wait till you get that that's the position that we're in yeah you know I mean but you know it's something to really think about because you're not getting eight on that and that's a lot of money and a regular grass fields about what I mean to started over like what we're talking about yeah it's about with cost escalation it's about two and a half million and the Aid on that is 64% so so those are prices based off on the two fields that were just just passed those fields would be the same

090where you're you're going down x amount of feet and starting over did talk about was the fact that we're waiting for the um the village and the the sewer system so bringing up another project to voters when we're still waiting on another one you know could be problematic um so this I mean if we were to bring it up to the voters this could potentially be finished before the other field that the voters already passed well that's actually not quite accurate um uh the capital project that we had approved in May was uh to do two grass fields and we're moving forward on the soccer field the other one um in the back um because we don't want to take two of those fields out at the same time we will stagger that one um

091uh which of the fields we do in the back um you know may be impacted by whether or not the town does the sewer project and are they able to get that done in 2027 and you know do we connect to that um but that's not delaying our moving forward on um the the the grass fields that were approved uh in May that's not delaying the the town's sewer project is not delaying our starting that and then the the important thing about the town um Scott was great giving us uh what are those called schematic blueprints I forget words now this is my new thing um and the sewer project what what what they are projecting in terms of the placement will not impact any of our uh potential PL there's three fields in the

092back the one um uh if you were the one that's on the most to the east yeah um has uh that's where we have our leech field yeah um and uh it we wouldn't want to redo that field until we had an answer from the town as to whether or not we were going to connect into their sewer because if we connect into their sewer we don't need the leech field and we can just resurface it if we don't Connect into their sewer to redo that field we have to dig it up and also redo the leech field so it's it's it's a bigger build so um uh but there's two other fields back there and so what we would probably do is I think Tom suggested doing uh the middle one yeah if you

093if if we don't hook up with the town I think that's a that's a pretty significant project to do that field uh we'd be comfortable doing the field next to it ideally if we do hook up to the town that that field against the the furthest East I think provides the the best spot to you know to renovate in my op so we can move forward you know doing first the soccer field and then one of the fields in the back um and the only thing that uh impacts us is it relates to whether or not we do or don't um or the town does or doesn't do the sewer project that we could Connect into is just um the field in the back that's furthest to the east just to give you an idea

094timeline um so if we do put up anything for a capital project that legal language has to be adopted on March 20th in order to make the statutory guideline for a may vote so that would leave you one discussion on on the 20th of February um February 6 of the budget Workshop so February we have two but the six is the budget workshop and the 20th is a regular meeting we'll have a there'll be more information coming yeah any questions on this it's uh obviously still some work in process but yeah I I would just want to again discuss the the fund balance um in times of uncertainty but this is the this is the position that we're in um of trying to get a field three times because um you know I have some

095hesitancy to that but I also then everything would be off campus correct everything we would close it down and be off campus probably for like two years yeah if it ends up being hey we're gonna that that gets p in the other project that's probably a 2027 that's that's a long time that concerns me a little bit yeah yeah just for clarity the fund balance is are you talking about the reserve that not the not the capital reserve no said Reserve so right yeah the reserve would be a public vote we did talk about um as an option having a proposition where we could ask voters to allow us to um but we have to ask voters to um allow us to move pull money from the capital Reser what right but if we do

096that then we right but but if if we go the capital project route where we would pull the money out of the capital reserve fund um then we also have to go through the state filing process which delays it and if we're going to do that we may as well do a full rebuild because if we do a full rebuild we get 64% state aid coverage and that puts us back at um almost the same cost as yeah so so Tom if we were to do a you know Capital project full rebuild um what would our how would that affect our sports teams and how many like we would be on the road for how many seasons and where would we be I don't know is a tight timeline if if you had a May

0972025 May 2020 yeah five sorry uh approval could it be a build in summer of 2026 I mean that's I don't I mean it's possible have to you know talk to the architect it's usually a six-month design phase then we if we used a third-party reviewer that would expedited and then we'd have to go out to bid for everything so it's possible by the end of summer 2026 it would be very tight yeah so lots of disruptions with programs yeah so there's obviously uh you know a fair bit that's still being worked through and we'll have you know the next board meeting more information um the next time we have more uh sorry followup committee meetings but um just urgency or there there's you know there is um you know a tradeoff of um uh

098uh urgency of fixing field one versus you know a longer more significant consequences were discussed during those times yeah yeah um uh versus a more significant uh rebuild that would have state aid uh so uh anyways we wanted to provide a little bit of a readout so the board understands you know the different options and things that are being considered there's no decisions yet ultimately you know things will get refined and you know we'll come back with uh more conclusive information and data and cost estimates and then the board can discuss more thoroughly and ultimately we we will have to decide what which direction we want to go so those are the options questions all right well that's the three committees uh Boe member comments anybody have comments anything you wouldn't need to get off

099your chest that's appropriate for it's appropriate yeah um are you reading I cannot read it in Spanish but I would Slaughter it um so I was able to attend um the Red Hook uh PTSA meeting last night uh that is the parent teacher student Association um for our Middle School and High school um and so they are having their first fundraiser it is uh on Friday February 7th from 6: to 8 it coincides with uh Lamb's um dance activity night um at the uh Elmendorf fin so you're all invited they also have a new uh Facebook page if you just look up Red Hook PTSA um and they are putting out different uh events pieces of information um like uh updating it quite a bit so I would U encourage everyone to check that out

100and anyone in the community is invited to this fundraiser as well so hope to see yall there excellent anybody else anything no all right sorry I lost my agenda one second uh that brings us to policy review and approval we have two policies uh for second read do I have a motion any questions or comments on any of these not uh all in favor opposed okay uh we did Cover the consent agenda uh that brings us the Personnel agenda do I have a motion um uh any comments questions on any of these no all right all in favor I sorry opposed uh say something really quick um just want to congratulate um Kevin U one of our bus drivers he's been working here for 17 years on his retirement um thank thank you for your

101dedicated service and please enjoy your retirement also thank you to Donna for her service as a teacher Aid and we wish her well also in her retirement Larry Anthony we also wish him well in the retirement but he's coming right back so we will see him so congratulations to everyone who's retiring and go somewhere warm that's it excellent uh that brings us to Second recognition of visitors do we have uh anybody um no okay all right well that brings us to our uh item Q adjournment do have a motion second all in favor thanks e for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.