CorpusRecord 63662

Special Meeting: ESA Committee Meeting and Consideration of Resolutions | February 11, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Rochester City School District
Date
2025-02-12
Location
Monroe County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,676 words · about 76 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e hello Rochester Public Community teachers students and parents welcome to the equity and student achievement committee meeting board of the whole uh today is February 11th 2025 and I would like to call this meeting to order uh today there are no speakers in the on the speakers list and so um can I get a motion to review and accept the minutes from the December 10th 2024 equity and student achievement committee so move move by commissioner Elliott seconded by vice president LeBron any questions or comments LeBron vice president Malloy my apologies vice president Malloy any any questions all those in favor I any oppos uh next up can uh I get a motion to review and accept the minutes from the January 14th 2025 equity and student achievement committee can I get a motion so moved

002moved by vice president Malloy seconded by uh commissioner Elliott any questions all those in favor I any oppose okay okay I would like to also remind the public in the Rochester Community that they can access all of the documents and the presentations that will be given today through board docs rcsd um and we will begin shortly um by our chief of staff Lara Evans who will be presenting the academic plan Quarter Two here we go okay that's better we can go to the next slide good evening president Simmons vice president Malloy interim superintendent Dr Strickland fellow Commissioners and listening audience this evening I will provide Quarter Two updates regarding the academic plan as a reminder this plan is organized into five domains and it's connected to our long-term goals and outcomes including the Strategic plan

003each domain has a number of recommendations which is listed on the screen for a total of 47 recommendations next slide the reporting process Remains the Same from quarter one for each recommendation within the domain a relevant department will submit evidence for that recommendation they are then to confirm if the required actions were fully implemented during that quarter then the state monitor superintendent deputy and myself will review the plan and adjust as needed this includes any revisions or um retractions from it I also spend quality time with the state monitor afterwards to make sure that we are given our best effort in our submission the report is then submitted to him haime Alisa the final document is sent to the commissioner of education and the New York State Department of Education and the superintendent conducts a

004final review also want to say thank you to our fiscal monitor Mark poter Potter who also reviews the plan and provides feedback next slide the reporting question the reporting question for Quarter Two and I want to tell you the dates for Quarter Two um are from October 1st to December 31st is has the district fully implemented the actions during that quarter which is Quarter Two you can answer yes no no in progress which is if the district started and make significant progress this is also the case if it's a reoccurring recommendation or the due date is not in that quarter and also part no partial implementation if the district implemented timely at least 50% but less than 75% next slide for each domain I'm going to share areas of appropriate progress and areas of progress

005I will speak to a few of those areas the first domain is turnaround leadership for this quarter we had seven yeses one no in progress and one no partial implementation no partial implementation this is an approvement from last quarter where we had five yeses and no in progress the areas of appropriate progress the board is fully aware aware fully aware of the superintendent search the governance model which with the with the assistance from cgcs sharing boardly data with the Board of Education that happens at our ESA meetings like today or even um reports that are submitted the monitoring of percentage of students with five or more credits by the end of 9th grade which is also one of the board goals connected to the board goals the areas of progress is the East High transition

006back into the district monthly meetings are scheduled have been scheduled and members from both East and the righteous with members from both East and Rochester City School District there's a core team that governs excuse me governs the transition and the other teams that are guiding to work are organized by the tenants of the Dead SE also the monitor to progress of the monitoring of progress of imp mentation of academic goals Chiefs meet with principles monthly to review data and Mark per review data including marking period data excuse me next Slide the next domain is talent management this quarter we have five yeses one no in progress and one no partial implementation Leadership Academy for principles assistant principles and aspiring leaders a differentiated differentiated leadership development for our associate directors and special education is on the

007way is underway professional development on best teaching practice happen monthly at Network meetings as well as principal's meetings and for Recruitment and Retention of non- tenure staff human capital continues to utilize strategies to recruit and retain staff this includes the utilization of job fairs the areas in progress monthly a status completion reports they are provided to the independent monitor as well as executive cabinet School Chiefs utilize that data to help host principles accountable and to monitor progress next slide please instructional transformation is the next domain of course it's one of our it is the largest domain because that's what should lead our district instruction this quarter we had 11 yeses five no in progress and six no partial implementation this is an improvement from last quarter as well where we had nine yeses and 12

008no in progress and one no so I'm going just going to speak to some of the highlights for areas of appropriate progress tnl Department continues to update curriculum materials as it relates to the data wise um implementation the teacher learning Department continues to update I'm sorry professional development office of innovative office of innovation conduct conducted targeted workshops for school leaders on smart goals Creations success criteria and data analys analysis protocol Dr part 154 implementation to support this effort rcsd provides rent notifications and diligently track communication with families additionally a cross functional team from bilingual educational World Language in the office of student student equity and placement audited and refined the registration identification and placement process staff was also given professional development opportunities to enhance their understanding and implementation of these procedures the district continues to

009make progress related to the four areas of non-compliance the high school selection process the online application for families to participate in the lottery was revised to be become more student friendly the final revisions were complete before the lottery opened on December 7th 2024 the school selection application is was revised to easily allow families to know what buildings were offering for example with B so bilingual program as an example summer school planning the department of mtss which includes the office of expanded learning and then overseas summer programming has six priorities for summer learning learning and lastly the posting I ready data it is available online with directions for the community and families to access next slide areas not fully implemented extended school year program this is a recommendation that is not due so therefore that's why

010it's no in progress It's an ongoing recommendation that calls for by April to communicate with families in their native language about what programs will be offered January 15th was was the first meeting of the summer school learning design committee strategies to reduce chronic absenteeism the district continues to work on attendance um and to implement strategies designed to reduce chronic absenteeism the attendance liaison are responsible for keeping a log that outline strategies used within School the department also has a comprehensive website for schools offering streamlineed access to crucial resources fear of action the receivership problem practice has been enacted each school has four commitment areas to focus their lens to bring about student achievement corrective action plan which is known as the cap the districts continues to make progress on areas of non-compliance early literacy in

011numeracy the office of parent engagement has been actively leading the collaboration efforts to enhance early literacy and numeracy among Rochester City School District families in Quarter Two op partnered with the teaching and learning Department to design and distribute a parent survey aimed at understanding the specific needs of families and supporting their children learning at home this feedback provided valuable insights that information that gave information on development of that helped the development of an academic Family Center Workshop series and lastly the Implement implementation of Community Schools the executive director of family and Community engagement and the director of Community Schools developed a draft Community Schools expansion plan now next slide cultural shift is one of our smaller domains with three yeses and one no in progress highlights include we have our executive school-based planning steering committee

012we have a team to analyze enrollment and look at subgroup data with a focus on improving increasing enrollment and bringing students back especially from Charter the district had and school websites provide multilingual access in areas not fully implemented is that every is every is that every school having a PTO or a PTA next Slide the last domain is system resources and structures which have three yeses one no in progress and two no part partial implementation over a 4-year period students who were previously placed in out of Zone schools before Zone reconfiguration will phase out and the remaining students will be placed within the Zone with exceptions allowed only by board policy this quarter the office of special education focusing on ensuring that data pulled into the consent decree dashboard accurately represents the progress made by

013the district towards meeting the consent decree metrics weekly meetings were held with staff responsible for building the dashboard and the data from the dashboard was confirmed with hand calculations areas that are not fully implemented include UniFi unified Innovative and evidence-based strategies at each grade level span and professional learning commun communities implemented using research based models at every school that is all that is my presentation thank you thank you Chief Evans for the presentation I'm going to start off uh with with a CLE questions and uh this may be for anybody in the administration but I I'm wondering the process of adopting curriculum into the district um and my question specifically to to where usually is the curriculum coming from is this usually private uh businesses who who construct this curriculum or um what's the process

014of curriculum adoption here in the district Mrs Ramos so first and foremost the first thing we do is identify those areas that we are looking for instructional Court practices what is it that we're looking the curriculum to do so we have a rubric and then your process in rcsd is the net call for an RFP and an RFP calls for people that are interested in supporting us with this call to say these are instructional gaps this is what we need to do similar to the science of reading which is a supplement to our my viewer Mion Ela curriculum that was an RFP that said we're interested in Supple in supplementing our curriculum um these are the areas of Science and reading that we have to do and those rfps come in and then you have

015an instructional Council that looks part of that RFP at that composed of um staff and parents and then they pick out of that rubric and then it goes to the schools and we pilot it and right now we're piloting um High School Ela and we're piloting at different high schools and then we're Gathering all the material we talk to the students we talk to people involved and then we come back and a selection is done it's a long process we started the high school Ela process when I got here around October and we are in the process right now of gathering all the information with piloting we never want to pick something that is not relevant to the needs of what we need instructionally but to the alignment of our students so our students have

016a great voice in the process yeah and I I guess that's that's why I was going to ask and I know that it is a a big need as far as curriculum for K all the way up actually prek all the way up to to to 12th grade um but I do Wonder for the the expenses and the money for some of the curriculum that we are spending for you know the the curriculum that's been created by whatever entity has been by um how effective would the process be if we allowed the teachers who's teaching our students and possibly even and like you said there's some student voice in the in the choice but even student voice in the the creation of some of this curriculum that could allow it to be more specific to

017the needs of Rochester and what's going and I mean this you know with all respect but I was in the high I was in school two years ago um and the curriculum that I took sucked you know know and that's just and I'm just being as real as I could possibly be um but I I say that and and how do we rethink the way that we are developing these curriculums I don't know if there's state law that blocks that but how do we add the people who understand what the students are attuned to in the classroom and the students who understand what they want to see or what engages them to create some of this curriculum so um great points right so there is something called relevance and that is one of the core

018standards um first and foremost you have to have an approved grade level curriculum that might be what you consider the boring curriculum but in the implementation and the adaptation of that curriculum becomes relevance and there's a process that we Ed to say once we are in this curriculum and learning it biology is a great example first year we're forming and storming with that content we're looking at the pieces that are just not connecting and we're adjust ing adding and that's what should be happening every year with curriculum right so one of the tnl responsibilities that you should be asking every year is how are you adapting and adjusting the curriculum so we continue to meet the needs of our students because every year that group of students has different needs we should not get away

019from rigor right you need great level curriculum you never supplant grade grade level curriculum you have a strategy that's part of that standard right that we're going to go to but the activities are the ones that scaffold us up to be able to get to that and so you've heard me a lot about priority standards what keeps a curriculum aligned and in tune to student needs when we're teaching the standards so that's our push to say this is the standard this is the curriculum how are you making this curriculum culturally rich and relevant so we hit the standard and that's been what we've been doing this entire year yeah okay well then that sounds good to me I I know that the curriculum piece is a very complicated and complex process but I I do

020believe that we're in a time where we can start looking at the ways that we are are currently doing things and how we can possibly make it more relevant to the students today because if the curriculum was perfect you know and the the district wouldn't be at a 50% absenteeism and so we have to think about how can we possibly find ways to to engage our students to the current place that they're in um and we could do better on that and so I'm just proposing ideas on how we get that so I think many times you know we talk about curriculum but delivery of instruction is huge huge I mean think about those teachers that engaged you they're using the same curriculum that you talked about right I mean those are the people that

021we remember because they made it relevant and that they still made it rigorous um so yeah I think those are the continuous questions that we welcome and that we ask you to continue to ask so that you do know the the work the directors are doing which means we want them in schools in those classrooms you know feeling and aching the pain that's going on thank you uh commiss I'm going to go down the line uh I'm G to start with vice president Mallo um no questions at this time thank you for your presentation I'm just looking forward to see how um these strategies actually translate to data numbers on the progress towards our academic goals thank you thank you com of President Simmons yes thank you um commissioner Santiago I love the conversation around

022curri ulum I remember a time when there was a bunch of competing curriculums and so that becomes an equity issue as well um and that sounds like a pedagogy um piece is is what we want to lean into um to what um Miss Ramos was stating I to be more specific around my question is I would lean into Slide Five and you may not have an answer right now Chief Evans and that's okay I noticed that um we were talking about um let me go to it the transition of East the area is in progress and we know that progress you know is incremental at times and it sounds from what I've heard that the transition of East has been going good when I hear the reports there's a lot of um Synergy and careful

023curation of how that's going to go I'm wondering how does that look uh when the recommendations come before us when do we as a board you know how does can can you answer that superintendent around when we start to actually adopt the recommendations that have come before us sure so um just for full transparency the only recommendations that you are actually going to be seeing would be memorandums of understanding uh that may happen between the staff and the district or excuse me the collective bargaining units and the district other than that most of those are inputs and those are those are decisions that myself and superintendent blocker would be making um she did um she did uh talked to me um just to get clarification and I I've explained that we've made a number of

024decisions already and those are what are actually under my purview and her purview for now uh as superintendent so those recommendations equal decisions yes gotcha can I also add I think the connection between superintendent blocker and Dr Strickland because they talk all the time and she is part of our executive cabinet it's like she's already being transition with us and keeping and and being a breasted as well because of the relationship that they have with each other because they talk all the time we discuss things as a district already not East versus rcsd no thank you very much and the clarity I think was in the recommendations because the recommendations equal the decisions that are within the inputs of the superintendent's purviews that gives me perfect clarity thank you for that and then my second

025question um was for slide eight and that was around um again areas not fully implemented and just wondering again at a very high level if there are themes or barriers um process or systems barriers that you all have identified that um are impeding on progress in these areas not that they're not progressing but obviously just you know is it related to all of them or anyone in just any of them like a very high level like hey these are some you processes that are impeding on progress so like early literacy you know I'm going to lean into that one or what have you but it could also be um implementation of the Community Schools model but just some high level ideas of of what's impeding on those sure so this is an example not necessarily

026that something is impeding on them but it takes time to actually accomplish them so for instance a few months ago you've already received a preliminary presentation on extended school year strategies to reduce chronic absenteeism would be something that I would say we have to ramp up how are we getting the community involved how are we getting the stakeholders involved and actually uh pinpointing strategies uh that will um be geared towards reducing The Chronic absenteeism I actually do have something that uh I want to put forth uh in the near future to actually engage the community as for theory of action uh currently in the district's budget presentations uh one of the things that I required is that they provided each department provid an if then statement [Music] um that that supports the work that they

027are supposed to do uh corrective action plan again those things won't be accomplished because they're just ongoing processes and I mean honestly I could speak to each of these and and Y and I also want to add about um strategies to reduce chronic absentees this is an ongoing conversation we have at cabinet we actually look at the data we compare it from like just taking out half days what happens when we don't have half dayss what does our attendance look like are is it trending that when a holiday is on a certain day and we don't have school Friday does that effect we're having those conversations weekly at cabinet as it relates to um absenteeism thank you so much commissioner Elliot um thank you uh just one question I have um how do we communicate

028uh to the community the definition of chronic absenteeism because um I think people would think that it's even more than 20 days but that it is you know probably they're out of school two or three months um is there a way in which we can um that the community and the definition of what chronic ABS ism is the same uh that we could communicate that um and the reasons why we are having um according to the state's definition Chron chronic absenteeism has been of things that go on in the home Deputy so no um that's a great question so I know that in uh previous uh presentations that I've done uh to the board we've announced uh what the definition of chronic absenteeism is we've also done a better job explaining what bands uh students

029may fall in based off of the based off of the number of days that the students are out um um and I know that that has been an improvement from last year the portion where I believe we need to do more work and we will do more work is around the root causes of Why students are not coming and starting to categorize what those different factors are we know unhoused students are on the rise we know students have medical conditions that you know keep them from being in school but I do know that uh the state has heard us and are making waves and trying to figure out a difference type of formula because the way we do business now after covid is so much different than how we did it before and U all

030we do is just continuously update them our schools have mtss uh problem solving teams problem solving teams are um the attendance portion is a part of the problem solving team and uh again it's just about putting the information out there but again the next step is engaging Community or excuse me finding the root causes engaging the community to help support those root causes and I think it's also important that we um inform stakeholders about it as well because I remember we had um a politician from one of the other municipalities that was being critical of us uh not understanding the definition of what chronic absenteeism is and the fact that we've got um you know families that you know take their kids to the doctors or you know they've got to go to work so

031they've got to have a child left at home to care for the children you know those kinds of of um extenuating circumstances that cause according to the state's definition chronic absenteeism so thank you great point I have no questions thank you for your presentation thank you um thank you for the presentation I have a couple of questions to actually um I'm not going to repeat because um president Simmons addressed those about the absente and the barriers um about the curriculum and reference to the curriculum uh and I don't know if it's more so a question or um what is a question and it's some reference to the split level classes are we doing that is do we have um um schools that are have split split level classes like fourth and fifth and how would

032that address how can you address the curriculum with split level classes and are we should we be doing the split level classes in the district can you answer that for me please I can um with certain specialized programming and special education they can group children based on um these pieces of of of need and you might come across classes with split level but remember how we talked about teaching a standard it's having that teacher understand what is it that we need to teach to and then picking the curriculum that best aligns to that with that grade level so is it difficult absolutely right because you have it but because when you're teaching the standard they're kind of all doing the same work they just might be using two different mediums to get to that work

033that concerns me because um kids live learn differently and and I I know it has to be challenging too for the teachers why is it that we're doing that is well it's it's it's it's really based on their individual education plan so sometimes in special education it's not about the grade level it kind of works sometimes as a no grade level but what are their needs and they try to B they try to group The Children based on needs it doesn't mean that they're not exposed to Great level material because have to be but remember in in these classes you also have extra staff and you see a lot when we visit we see a lot of individual groupings we see students with flexible grouping and they are today learning how to understand the the

034the the main theme based on the author's purpose right what is this the author trying to say and what is the main theme the the group of fourth graders might be working off of this material that's fourth grade and the group of fifth graders are working off this material that's fifth grade but guess what they're working to the same standard of understanding author's purpose so maybe that better understand so and then when they go to their groups they'll work with an adult on the fourth grade content level and then they'll work with the other adult on the fifth grade content level so you see a lot of explanation to the entire group about the standard that we're trying to get to and then you'll see them break off with their grade level materials if going

035back to what you said about the there there several teachers in the classroom so if we have several teachers in a classroom why not just give them a separate class well several supports so you might have one teacher with a teacher's aid or you might have one teacher with a pair of professional but there's one teacher in that class one teacher okay um another question is and I'm more than sure Chief Swan could do a much better job at this so please forgive me if I've not being very clear no no no it's fine I just it just concerns me um and you know actually who makes that decision does do the principles make the decision of the split level classes or is it something that um is recommended who actually decides what schools and

036what you know have the split level classes so we're going to go back again the kids are grouped by Need need Okay so we've got to remember sometimes you know you can have a kid that's reading at the sixth grade level and and and Ne and there's a kid at fourth grade that's reading at the sixth grade level we're always thinking of deficiency sometimes we're grouping based on strength of the students so that they're not delayed but and then one student might be at a fifth grade level with mathematics or another one needs curriculum of fourth grade so um it's not necessarily always about deficiency sometimes you look at these groupings also about being able to accelerate those kids okay thank you you're welcome and I think the last question for chief Evans who is

037part of the steering committee which which steering committee are you referring to um oh the executive School based steering committee yes uh the unions are involved myself the superintendent the deputy um who else is on a school base oh office of parent engagement um our parent group leaders there's a good number of lists I just didn't have it off the top of my head so that's who's part of the executive School based staring commes no Community engagement outside of no because it's it's for to work on our it's to support our school-based planning teams so to provide professional development if it's needed to help strengthen our um school-based planning teams and do we have like a layout of what the step what steps you guys are taking to address that area in the the St

038in the steering um committee yes so we have every every month in Deputy attorney can actually speak to this better than I can but every month the schools parently aison have to submit a report of parent groups school-based planning teams we call it the I call it the rainbow report they call it the Christmas tree report and then we work as a as a team to discuss ways that we can support schools to make sure they have all stakeholder voices at the schools for school-based planning team okay um commissioner uh Lebron no questions uh to our parent rep uh Monica Graham do you have any questions I just want to say thank you Chief Evans you're wel my apologies thank you good evening everyone apologies for my uh tardiness um so what I saw from

039the presentation no questions um you all have made great points so thank you so much for the presentation you're very welcome thank you commissioner thank you thank you um final question uh Chief Evans the PTO I saw that that's something that's not currently implemented yet uh and and it will be soon I'm just wondering where you guys it's a it's an area of progress so some schools may have a robust parent teacher organization and some schools are still in progress of trying to get uh you know more representation from parents okay thank you thank you Chief Evans and thank you for your report thank you guys for the work that you do um next up we're going to have our elementary Network updates uh which will include attendance suspensions and instructional priorities presented by school

040Chiefs Rhonda Moran and Brenda Tores Santana good evening president Simmons vice president Malloy commissioner Santiago commissioner Elliot commissioner Griffin commissioner LeBron commissioner Patterson super attendant Strickland State monitor alasas um and esteemed colleagues myself and as um was clearly stated Chief Moran will be presenting this evening so our vision for excellence includes instruction which you will see examples of today with the learning intentions and success criteria we make sure that We are following our vision for excellent instruction and everything that we do on a daily basis within the district with our structural Excellence preparing students for life we ground all of our work on the Strategic plan one a 1 b 1 C which heavily focuses on instruction as you can see we start with with the student we have the educator and the content with

041the task in the middle making sure that our core refers to the dynamic relationship that has to happen in the classroom between the students the educator and the content that is being learned and the assessment that must be there to make sure that the students learning intentions and success criterias are visible and this is Network 2 as we will be hearing from Network 2 in network 3 today these are the schools within Network 2 as you can see they are listed there looking at our attendance this year for Network 2 um last year as you can see in the blue highlighted it says 2324 Network average daily attendance was at 80% this year we are at 83% we know that there we talk about The Chronic absenteeism and what we're doing about it there's a

042lot of factors that play into that so at our schools all of them have the attendance team that meets regularly to make sure that they're um listening to concerns that are happening within their families and trying to attend to them there's also schoolwide celebrations that take place to ensure that the kids are celebrated so that they can see that being in school is important and the schools are using the tier um approach so you have your tier one tier two and tier three which is reflective also in how we look at our students academically tier one are those students that are always there so we're making sure that we're giving them shout outs and giving them the awards that they need because they are doing a good job in being there and we want them

043to be represented as well we don't only want to focus on tier two and tier three when there's interventions that need to be in place but we also want to celebrate those students that show up every day so um we also engage the parents in conversations through the attendance meeting to find out what are those crucial things and those areas that they are in need of or need support in to make sure that their students are showing up so one of the things that we're working on is writing within all of our schools so we're doing our cultural learning walks making sure that our learning environments are positive spaces making sure that there's Equity that the parent and the community are involved in all of our communication the the walks are intentional we want to

044make sure that we're observing the work that the students are doing in the classroom how the teachers are teaching so School focuses on our priority standards our two and R3 principal's learning walks when we do our Network meetings are looking intentionally to see what is happening within the writing pieces in our schools one way to do this is always to look for the bright spots what's happening well other things might be you want you're developing some wondering so that you can have conversations afterwards to make sure that number one that we're doing what we asked them to do so one of the things that we want to make sure that all schools are doing is using rubrics to score the students work providing a success criteria that they need to work on and then doing

045building wide celebrations to show the work that's happening in the buildings here you can see our suspension data and we all know that we're supposed to reduce by 10% we really don't want to suspend we need to have the students in front of an instructor so that they can learn and walk away with the learning success criterias within each every day that's why they need to be in in front of the teacher every day so with if you look at this chart you can clearly see from from 23 to 24 the numbers there of suspensions and we're looking for a 10% decrease and so right now we have our schools listed and so where we might have been at 1,18 last year right now we are currently at 266 so we're working on making sure

046that schools are constantly looking at this constantly having dialogue and conversation and making sure that this information is also shared with parents and getting ideas of what it is exactly that is needed to stop the trends of St of being absent and coming into school good evening so you'll see a lot of the similar a lot of similar themes with network 3 um and just taking a second to celebrate the leaders of network 3 and the hard work that they do every day Like Chief Santana Torres we've seen uh an improvement in attendance slightly under a percentage point in our average daily attendance and our chronics continue to be an opportunity of growth at 48.7% uh you already discussed the many things schools are doing to improve attendance it's just something that uh we're going

047to be relentless as we work on it suspension data for us uh we were at 6 58 suspensions at the end of last year currently we're resting at 167 our goal was a 10% reduction but you'll see it's significantly more than that in most of our schools teachers or principles are doing a great job we have more seasoned leaders um than when we started a few years ago stronger leadership teams stronger mtss plans and uh more consistent networks but we're we're excited to see that reduction of course we want to get to much less less than that even so Improvement strategies the strategies that Chief Santana torus Santana and I are working collaboratively on are focusing on priority standards you've heard Dr Ramos mention that learning intentions to success criteria we'll explain a little bit

048of what that is in the upcoming slide making sure that students work is posted and celebrated in every classroom across both networks and F tuning the quality of our lesson plans to ensure that they're focused on a standard they're differentiated and they prevent they present the rigor and relevance that commissioner Santiago was mentioning so a key Focus for us this year is looking at implementation the implementation science and what that means is what are the leaders doing to make sure things get executed in their building we took two items two small items one was success criteria and learning intentions and the other was making sure every single classroom has posted graded student work and we monitor the implementation for every school on these two items and a goal by the end of the year is

049of course 100% currently we're sitting at about 61% and 57% another Focus that continues to be a focus and it's been a focus for two years is making sure our teachers know how to do develop high quality lesson plans and uh in in making sure their standard space Not Just program based but standards based and differentiated to meet the many needs in the classroom so here's an example of um the data around the implementation so we identified two things does every classroom teacher have learning intentions which is the standard and do does every kid know how their standard is going to be measured right now we're at 57% implementation we started this year at zero next the next piece is the the success criteria which really is how do we measure whether or not kids

050receive the information and um and we're coming along in in that direction too this has been a districtwide focus for both Elementary and high school if we do these two things well you'll see positive impact in student outcomes so here are some examples of things you'll see when you go visit classrooms you should see in every classroom these success criteria and learning intentions when you're talking to teachers and engaging with teachers please ask them about what these two things are they should be able to tell you the other piece that we looked at was making sure every student had writing posted that writing was happening every single day it was graded it was rigorous and uh we're at 61% implementation we visited every classroom in every school to collect this data and again if if

051this work is done student outcomes will be positively impacted we're hoping when you go into schools we know when you go into schools you'll see writing everywhere we're our goal is by the end of the year you're going to see it in front of every classroom and that's what we want we want schools that you walk into and you see AC academic rigor and an a culture of academics um so we're excited to see that when you when you visit our schools right now so what's next for our networks first is midyear evaluations right now we're meeting with every principal to make sure they have an evaluation of their performance they're presenting up to us their data performance um and how they are measuring up to the rubric that we used to evaluate them we

052meet with every principal for just over an hour um and we're in the midst of that this week we're going to go deeper with our learning intentions and success criteria and writing going into next year as it becomes a district goal and uh focus and lastly uh a small strategy that we're going to start implementing is the bump it up boards and these are just boards that help students understand what they need to do to get to the next level which is really helpful in those multi-age classrooms or or classrooms where kids are performing at different level our kids when are when kids are clear about their bar they rise to the bar so much easier so that's another strategy we're going to work on any questions for us thank you Chiefs I appreciate the

053presentation I do have two questions for you guys um I saw and in you guys' presentations uh suspensions were down uh which is great to see but I was one of the delegates for a legislation called Solutions not suspensions um and so I'm wondering from you guys' ends what are some practices that's being uh put into these schools as Solutions um in in exchange for the suspensions that we've seen through the years because I'm sure that there's still you know some some behavior issues uh that that may still be happening in the school so I'm wondering what are we doing to give those uh students the support that they need and what are the solutions that we're finding in the schools for our kids I I think that's an interesting question because it goes back

054to what you were saying earlier if we have high quality instruction and engaging cultures there's going to be less discipline challenges right so working on establishing positive cultures and strong instruction that's been our priority we do think that impacts suspensions uh uh other strategies that school every school is doing something different around how they're reducing suspensions AB relationships of course are it relationships with families are huge off offering Alternatives where a student doesn't have to be suspended when there's a discipline challenge they can sh they can use it as a learning opportunity to showcase some of the things that they're doing around the area that they were suspended in um restorative practices are in place as well and we have a lot of our elementary schools where the students are being trained in restorative practices

055and they run circles as well we were blessed this year to have a counselor put in every building and uh social workers and buildings too and using them as a front line so that when a kids a kid has a challenge in a classroom they're not sent to an office they're sent to support providers that's it's been a huge lift for us this year as well yeah and I and I'm hoping and I'm just putting this out there but I'm hoping to see that continued in our budget uh regarding around the the counselors and the social workers in every school because our schools do need it and with that being said I also want to say when we're speaking about chronic absenteeism and when we're speaking about some of the outcomes of our schools there

056are definitely disparities that our children are dealing with outside of school I mean I recently visited one of our schools uh elementary schools where there there are a lot of disparities in the neighborhood and so I'm wondering what are you guys doing what are principals doing what is the district doing to uh to continue and to promote Community Partnerships Community engagement on the individual School level not for every school in the district but the individual School level with connecting them with the churches that's in their neighborhood connecting them with the organizations that may be around there I'm just wondering what are we doing to do our best to engage Our Community Partners as much as possible as the issues our students are dealing with uh are larger than just what happens in the building this

057is a huge piece of what our attendance teams do it's the relationships with families the first they have to understand what's causing the attendance Challenge and then from that diagnosing the support that has to be provided to the family so whether it's uh doctors or whether it's um Community agency Partnerships clothing closets food any of those pieces uh it comes down to relationships the schools have to know our families and the challenges that they're working through and how we can best support them and and that's where you'll see Community join schools and moving forward and also I know you participated with school 33 when they had the mayor come out the children really love activities like that and so they know in order to be a part you have to come to school and so

058that's one way that we gain the attendance of the students in the schools thank you um I'm going to go up to our parent R Monica Graham do you have any questions or comments yes first of all thank you for the presentation that was amazing and I'm going to piggyback off what was just said regarding School visits and surprise visits so I'm part of the pillars of Hope program and my school is school 8 and um the children love when we come and we always try to bring a guest with us and do fun things so that is another incentive a to give them resources and um to to have them to want to come to school so I I agree wholeheartedly um that we should do as much as we can to get the

059community and the community programs in the school um in regards to the presentation I absolutely love that you all are celebrating the children that that show up um I know um we talk a lot about absenteeism and the children that aren't coming but sometimes our children face instrum instrumental obstacle obstacles excuse me um to even step through that door so to celebrate them and and just know that they're doing the work is great and I love the bump it up boards a clear um instruction this is what we have to do um is amazing and the the just the showing the work on the walls help build the morale for our children and the school climate as well so thank you so much and keep up the good work thank you uh thank you parent

060rep um and can I also just give a a shout out to our parent rep who has been on all the preview meetings have been at every Esa committee meeting that been that can we give it up for her Monica we love you we thank you we appreciate you uh for showing up uh commissioner LeBron do you have any questions yeah this is um more so a comment I just want to point out to I know that it's about knowing our families but you know in the last two weeks alone I've dealt with about 11 children from this district and the schools didn't even know they were homeless because what I'm finding is that families also don't always want to share their business with the school it's not that they may not even feel comfortable

061there's shame for them there's fear that CPS will get called right because there is no safe or stable place for them to go and I think that these are more complex issues that we can solve or even through question asking at this level um but I do want to you know continue to encourage that the state recognizes that we do have to look at Alternatives but I'll be honest I don't even know if we're going to have a Department of Education ation of half of these conversations are going to be relevant in another week or two and I think that's where we're at and the notion that we're just continuing to have conversations and I cannot stress the business as usual craziness that's happening right now because these are not those times and I can

062tell you that as a district that has the largest amount of refugee immigrant populations in the entire Monroe County because there are no programs like Ria and any other schools in Monroe County other than rcsd we're going to see even more students not coming to school because of fear of ice and that's just the reality and I don't think that no matter what a principal does right to get to know a family we're not going to convince them to come in because the reality is we have no real protections for those families so that's all I want to say on record for now thank you thank you thank you commissioner Griffin um yes thank you for your presentation I have a couple of uh questions of concern um I know that we have struggling children

063how many in percentage wise do you think that teachers offer the marking period recovery for our children so and would you kindie explain it to some people in audience that may not know what that is can I can I very quickly say that this is a presentation from our elementary school Chiefs uh the recovery is for high school um you is is that true correct okay I'm just making sure I just want to say cuz they may not be able to answer the question that you're asking right now cuz they're not over the high schools no that that's correct they're not able to answer that question this is for the elementary schools Focus uh next uh month I believe we have on schedule for the secondary individuals to come present and I'll be sure that

064your question is answered you can even get a head start by putting it in the question log and we'll make sure that you get that information thank you I was thank you very much I wasn't aware of that um so uh that's really what I wanted to my concern was um what with with with that being said though what what things do we have in place for those children we do have Marketplace recovery at the high school level but what things do we have in place for those children that are struggling um to to address their needs because we know at a certain level third grade you know we start to see the drop so with that being said we do have it at that we have it at that level so why not don't

065we have a program like that to address the needs of the children that that are younger so you know maybe that's something that we need to look into do you have any solutions for that we we we do it a little bit differently in elementary but you're absolutely right we need something for our kids that are are a little further behind right now we have something called mtss it's tiered instruction so we have instruction that all kids get tier one and students who are behind in a standard will get tier two or tier three where they'd have a double dose of instruction happen during the day so ours just happens during the day more often than not they'd have additional providers we have reading teachers intervention teachers that work with them to catch them up

066we have some after school program we have some tutoring that's happening uh so it varies school to school but we do have plans for every single student in every single school um to help them get to grade level standard okay so I guess my question would be that what point are we addressing that though because we I you know my concern is that sometimes we have a lot of kids that fall by the wayside and and and I know we have teacher shortages and you know things of that nature but how are we ensuring that we're addressing the children's needs at that prime time you know because we can lose a child because they feel like you know as the kids raising their hands answering the questions the other child is sitting there like uh

067you know I don't know the answer so we lose kids when they not when they feel they feel that they're less thereof because they don't have the Ed educational um the education that the that their their peers have so how we how do we know how are we dealing with that so I was going to start by saying that all the schools have data reviews and the data reviews are quarterly um the principes meet with all the classroom teachers and they go over the students data and then they put them into the tiers just like we were talking about mtss tier one tier two tier three and then depending on where the student falls then they decide what is the support they're going to provide to those students at that time you're asking a really

068great question a really great question we when you think about you hear a lot of people talk about standards and there's this grade level standard every kid needs to get to it's the obligation of the teacher to understand the steps that they have to take to get the kids to that standard so they'll set up small groups or they set up interventions to help kids get to that standard who aren't quite at that grade level standard it's part of what we do at elementary it's it's a it's a uh as common as breathing we do it all the time for every kid and my last question just would be based basically on the the level of um phics um I'm a big phonic person because I mean growing up it was Apple you know the

069Clapping you know the banana always clapping for for phonic and and really was it really stuck with me so I don't see a lot of kids doing that um what are we doing to put that back to put that back into our schools at that level because I think that is important for children to have that phonics so can you can you elaborate on that for me please yeah absolutely I I I call myself the queen of phonics too I I feel like it's so necessary in our schools and it was something that has been a challenge for our system for a long time we've re recently purchased CA which is a program that's just focused on Phonics it's being implemented in every one of our Elementary classrooms K1 two might might even shift to

070K3 so that we can ensure that when a kid enters school we figure out where they're falling in that Continuum of teaching phonics and where they fall off they can get instruction right away we have Diagnostics assessments reading teachers dedicated to it Dr pep and Harris is leading a strong agenda phonic agenda right now I think you'll be very pleased with where we're going okay thank you very much welcome commissioner Patterson I have no questions thank you commissioner Elliott thank you so I was at a school U getting back to the Reading part I was at a school on Friday and uh happy to see a lot of um the um writings from students on the walls and at this one particular school she was showing me where it wasn't that um the the teacher

071needs to have some more improvements so I was also glad to see that there was accountability um there as well so I'm really excited about um that happening in the schools and um just to also say that you know we're continuing to improve you know around attendance but also to um commissioner um LeBron's point with our current environment it may be a challenge and I don't know if there's some way in which we can extrapolate that particular issue and then still look at if we're making improvements on attendance so thank you very much uh chairperson santiano thank you uh president Simmons yes thank you um yeah so I'm hoping maybe the state will take a look at how they're doing I know they're already addressing how they're doing attendance but maybe there is something they

072can do for this period in time A Time such as this as they would say but I really don't have any questions I just wanted to um lift the the U presentation this evening I thoroughly enjoyed it thank you for showing high expectations through rubrics and and student focused work being displayed and and and it's feeding back it's looping and showing um that there is an expectation for our students and um their work as well so I just wanted to say kudos to that I was interested in the suspension suspensions rates I can't even say it um so I'll be keeping an eye on that because that's a drastic change is that comparison where it was over a th000 to now 200 is it like from the same period in time or yeah right now

073so that was at the end of the year okay so we're monitoring those numbers though to make sure we don't go nowhere near it right so we're still trending lower though either way thank you thank you yes commissioner Maloy thank you thank you so much for your presentation I we know the importance of tracking this type of information attendance absenteeism chronic absenteeism um so it's very very helpful and it's also good for us as Commissioners to be able to see some of the steps being taken to help improve those those student outcomes in our schools and I guess the only question I really have is the um teaching part this is fantastic I want to make sure that as Commissioners so that we can learn to discuss the data that's coming in other than I

074ready how can we expect to see maybe that incremental progress using all of this teaching methodology how will that be presented to us like as we go forward in our new governance model so that we can actually progress monitor um whether or not these are effective methodologies I hope I made sense yeah tot abely when you think about I I in my head is a thermometer it's just a test of the temperature of how our schools are doing right our our biggest bang for our book will come from our comma formative assessments which I know Dr Ramos and her team are looking to re are revamping right now as we speak that will tell us our kids attainment to a standard so that's the data once those are revamped that's the best data you're going

075to get into seeing our progress towards attaining standards and is that formative assessment um going to be standardized across all of our schools I know we have so many programs and unique offerings at all of our schools I'm so sorry to like if you so specific okay um we're going back to what I said when I first started in October we needed to teach us standards because with standard you know exactly where you're going it doesn't matter what vehicle you're using we know where we're going right and it doesn't matter which road you took 490 but we're with the destination so our com common formative assessments are not going to be um measuring content like they have in the past are going to measure the standard we've identified those strategies those were the priority standards

076that we've been working on with principles since December we are in our visits now saying show me how this looks the learning intentions success criteria line perfectly to that and we have already engaged um some of the I data to start to show us the stretch goals because the stretch goals are those that go to standard so um individually by school these Chiefs are looking at every one of those stretch goals we're seeing a lot of Greens in terms of starting to be able to see the Mark um it's it's um probably not as quick as we want but we know that it's starting to work um the the science of reading is working that's a little differently um we're asking every reading teacher to show impact of how students have grown under their Direction

077because this is what we expect them to do is to be able to help that tier one classroom teacher move forward and um Kim is doing a great job Kim Harris Pap is doing a great job of looking at that not in a um agory type of form you know but in a way to say tell me what you've done how is this helping our kids and how can we continue so I can tell you that um we're a tight group now there's nothing that we do without the other because we know that we need the Chiefs to be able to help us implement but the directors are also in those schools um helping principes and teachers at all times so it's starting to now kind of look like we're on the path let's just

078hope that that continues to go that way yeah and I just wanted to say thank you so much for taking the time to to answer that and um I know everything is in kind of the infancy stage so I know it takes time to to implement all of these strategies I can say that I've I've never seen something that looks so great before in this District so I'm really pleased and I'm looking forward to seeing the results and the impact um on our students learning thank you thank you uh thank you commissioner Elliot yeah I just wanted to go back I'm sorry to the um suspension data for Network 2 so if I'm looking correctly at this um the 10% reduction of that goal let's just look at school 30 3 for example so the

079goal was 274 but as of 23 there's only been eight suspensions am I reading that correctly you're looking at the suspensions right Network to data um suspension data this is where this is where you were at the end of the year page8 is what the superintendent just said so your question again so so for example School 33 where the goal uh 10% reduction would be 274 correct but I'm looking at what say for example grades K2 MH so am I understanding that right that there only eight suspensions yes but last year we had or or for the this particular am I reading that correctly yes and and that the gold though is 274 so we have have we drastically reduced the suspensions yes and is yes let me just let me just stop here and

080congratulate um let me just start off with superintendent um uh Demario uh Dr Strickland um because that is huge that that says that you have you all have done tremendous amount of work around suspensions and I go back to when I um started campaigning um 20 years ago where and this is high school data but there were 14,000 suspensions for the Middle School uh and primarily those were black black boys so I am just so excited that we're having that at 33 School we're talking about this point at least as of of February um 83 total yeah okay so that but that's still amazing yeah but I was just looking at the great yeah and so they're saying the superintendent is says 83 total but that's still uh absolutely amazing U that we have these

081kinds of reductions so I just want to give give the superintendent his staff um just tremendous uh congratulations for this work I know that this board has been talking about this for years and to see um these numbers come down and to see and I'm sure that there's been some alternate kinds of um opportunities for our kids to be involved in and not to just have them out of school because that's that also impacts attendance as well so I just wanted to really really highlight that because that's tremendously important and I don't expect that you know I know this and this is elementary school so I don't expect you know in June or or next month that it's going to be you know anywhere to reaching those uh that goal so again just congratulations that's

082huge work and I wanted to highlight that and honor you all for that thank you so so much thank you thank you Chiefs uh for your presentation uh thank you Deputy superintendent thank you thank you interim superintendent sorry thank you Deputy super attendant to our Chiefs to our principles to our teachers and most importantly to our students uh thank you guys for the work that you all are doing we do have reports uh from for the board that is currently on board docs there are three reports that are currently on board docs we have the attendance report the new course report and the receivership report um again to the public you can access all of these reports on board docs board dos rcsd or you can go to the Board website the district and you'll

083find these reports there um but these are public reports and also to our board members these reports are to us uh please don't forget the to complete the commissioner board meeting survey um and lastly can I get a motion to go into executive session second moved by commissioner Elliott seconded by President uh Simmons uh the board May recess an executive session to discuss matters leading to the appointment of specific individuals and to discuss matters of concern with the general counsel all those in favor I any oppos all right this meeting is now adjourned and going into not adjourning yet going into executive session I'm learning thank you e e e I welcome back to the esa Committee of the whole um I'm just going to ask for a motion to adjourn the meeting so moved

084motion by um vice president Malloy seconded by President Simmons all those in favor I any oppose Yesa meeting is adjourned am I jumping in right now okay so we're going to actually my voice is horse going into the special meeting um may I get a motion or entertain a motion to open our special meeting or do I even need that right now give me one second here I'm just trying to log into my computer okay thank you so we are now it's Tuesday February 11th it is 8:37 p.m. we are entering our special meeting to convene for consideration of resolutions we do not have speakers at this time uh going into our resolutions for consideration uh under action items on our board docks I'd like to um look uh at well I'm not even going

085to bundle these we'll do them contract substitute entertaining a motion um for contract substitute resolution resolution number 505 so moved you record that clerk when okay all in favor or any open for discussion on contract um substitute resolution 55 any discussion all in favor of 505 I I any opposed moving forward to act acting administrative appointment resolution 506 so moved excuse so entertaining a motion for resolution 506 by vice president Malloy seconded by commissioner Patterson open for discussion yes is that the is that an AP position I'm it is it is um yes I I don't I'm I'm just getting back to um to my desk I mean for my seat but um I have uh questions on is that for what school is that is that for East I'm uh General councel is that

086something we can discuss um openly on the day or is that the questions being posed for executive session yeah I think if it's just where the position is that's fine we're not talking about the person yes so it's at East Upper okay um I just have a question was that particular job posted for East High School I didn't see that particular AP job posted um and I that's that's big that's my big concern um sure sure good evening commissioner um East is handled a little bit differently because they have their own superintendent and they have their own um process that they go through but all um assistant principal positions are posted in December and we have open continuous recruitment so that when a position becomes available a pool of candidates can be um move to

087the school where stakeholders then consider the candidates but this is is an acting position and so East um had a process where they selected this candidate and there will be further process later yeah okay so I you you said something that is kind of striking you said that we have open you know revolving a hiring process uh for APS but in recently you have you have you have um posted the jobs for certain schools like for Franklin and and 58 and Andrew Langston so I just I'm just curious of why would you not pick from that pile of people we already have if we already have a rolling um process of of people that are in that pool why would you put that put those out there but those particular jobs out there or post

088those particular jobs for those schools if that is the case uh commissioner we do not post assistant principal positions by school it's just a continuous open principles might be different though yeah I mean this is for the AP and the and the As and the principal jobs you uh initially posted those positions for those jobs my question to you is what you said that we have we have a pool that we pick from so why didn't you just pick for the pool that previously for those jobs instead of instead of going through interview I'm gonna so superintendent would like to respond to that so East is still under the EPO that's why um superintendent blocker made her selection um uh this is an acting position acting positions are at the discretion of the superintendent she

089probably will likely run a process later in the in the in the months and uh that's that's all that there is to say okay thank you any other um discussion it uh discussion around 506 resolution 506 I'm denying I'm not I don't we haven't taken the vote yet but are there any further discussion on resolution 506 okay okay um I'm on 506 okay okay with no further discussion all in favor of resolution 506 I I any opposed nay okay moving forward um entertaining a motion for resolution 507 appointment to the professional educator area motion by commissioner Patterson I need a second two second it by commissioner Griffin open for discussion without any discussion all in favor of resolution 507 I I opposed resolution 507 carries entertaining a motion for resolution 58 a provisional appointment to

090the list of competitive Civil Service titles motion commissioner p P second second and commissioner Griffin open for discussion I would like to take a moment to uh just commend uh Elizabeth Estes um and congratulate her um as being provisionally appointed any further discussion items for 508 with no further discussion all in favor of resolution 508 I I any opposed resolution 508 carries permanent appointment to the listed classified Civil Service title resolution 509 entertaining a motion for resolution 509 so moved second okay moved by vice president Malloy seconded by commissioner Patterson 509 is open for discussion with no discussion all in favor of resolution 509 I I any opposed resolution 509 carries looking at uh resolution 510 entertaining a motion for resolution 510 so move moved by commissioner Elliott second seconded by commissioner Griffin resolution 510

091is open for discussion uh Madame President i' just like to take the opportunity to um just acknowledge and congratulate uh a number of people all of them um actually U but the folk that I know Tom quesa uh Joe baldino and W Moore I just want to say um much success to them and their next assignment and what they're doing um some may be I would imagine doing some Consulting with all of their expertise I I don't know that for sure but um Tom Case has been here a very long time he's been here even before my tenure on the board um also I believe W Moore and um and we were just talking about Joe baldino and so just wanted to congratulate them and thank them for their service here in the Rochester City

092School District and um you know wish them much success thank you madam president thank you so much commissioner Elliot and and I would like to Echo those sentiments I grew up on rosin street right adjacent to uh Mr Moore and so wonderful to see the work he did and and in his implementation of new generation of um I'm making up that what was it called leaders ship Academy for young men that's a different thing so um his work there and then Joseph baldino being at Wilson and so many different schools and um familiar names for sure and so thank you for your expressions and um any further discussion on resolution 510 with no further discussion um all in favor of resolution 510 any opposed resolution 510 carries resolution 511 entertaining a motion for resolution 511

093motion motion by commissioner Griffin second seconded by commissioner Patterson any discussion regarding 511 uh well in general yes I just want to know maybe this could be in the question log what's the percentage of employees who resign from the district so if that can be in the question log i' appreciate that capture thank thank you any other discussion around resolution 511 there no further discussion all those in favor of resolution 511 I any opposed resolution 511 carries entertaining a motion for resolution 512 motion motion by commissioner Patterson seconded by commissioner Griff any discussion regarding resolution 512 all in favor any opposed nay resolution 512 did were you able to capture that Okay resolution 512 carries okay we're going to move into our budget calendar at this time time will you be facilitating that clerkin sure

094um good evening everyone just so you all know on October 24th in one of the final Finance meetings you all approved the draft budget calendar at that time and as usual we do not have the city dates um they have now been provided and are highlighted and additionally um I just want to let you all know that this afternoon after this was posted um we received confirmation from the city on the budget vote date which will actually be June 77 and so added to the bottom of this calendar um so again these are dates just aligning to um your budget deliberations which will occur in August including your city budget hearing date um and your public uh excuse me your public hearing date uh also we made a shift to the superintendent's budget presentation it

095was originally scheduled to be provided in your Finance meeting as you know you Sunset that committee so that meeting will now occur in your excuse me that presentation will now occur in your business meeting so all changes are highlighted there thank you with the addition of June 17th being added to the calendar correct ma'am all righty thank you any questions from the fellow Commissioners around budget calendar no thank you for your presentation on that I just I do have one thing to say Madam president um I do know that we are doing these budget hearings prior to our vote on um on our budget but I would also like to say that we don't necessarily necessarily have to include whatever city council is asking us to include I think that we have to make that

096ultimate decision um they can share it with us but based on our own board goals and our strategic plan I think it's important that we recognize that we don't have to uh whatever they recommend that we don't have to include it in our budget uh particularly if it doesn't align with our goals and with our strategic plan so I just want to put that on the table and if you recall um I don't think they voted in favor our budget in the last three or so um um um budget so I don't feel that we need to feel um beholden if you will to necessarily um include what they may recommend into our budget just want to put that on the table thank you thank you and we do recognize that is a ceremonious uh

097vote to your point commissioner aliot for sure thank you for that um and so we're going to move over uh move into this we're moving into policy at this time right first we need a motion for the budget calendar and if you could just add on there the addition of the June 17th got you so do I make put that language in there so I would like to entertain a motion to adopt the budget calendar for 2025 with the addition of the date of June 17th for motion by commissioner Griffin second seconded by commissioner Patterson all in favor for the budget calendar I any opposed the budget calendar has been adopted okay and so at this point I'm going to turn the Mike back over again to clerk W uh who is going to do

098a presentation for our policies good evening Commissioners tonight I'll be discussing with you all your financial management policies part two two and part three hold on one moment um as a reminder the policy process is here um and is a robust process that includes both um outside excuse me Community voice um through your advisory groups as well as cabinet um and so for I'll just jump right into what is the significant changes for this set of policies um so as you can see here on the chart I'm sorry if you could Advance it another yep one more thank you sir um so this here lists the policies within the financial management section part two um as you see in the middle column we uh address significant changes uh and so we'll start with the non-resident

099tuition payment policy 6254 uh becc made a recommendation on this policy to clarify what the meaning of non-resident was um and so there was clarification to just add that this relates to being a city a non- city resident um there were no significant changes to policy 6256 or 6300 and then as we move into the auditing policies um with the advice and recommendation of the auditor general she has revamped and made a recommendation for these policies uh starting with 6600 it was reorganized just a simple fly a policy if you all remember that you had conversations around moving to as much plain language as possible um the policy was further aligned with the law and just really outlined the work of the audit committee then we have the internal auditor policy which is being recommended

100to be rescinded any key components of that policy have been included in the 6600 update same for um claims auditor policy that policy's language was simplified and reorganized um and there's really aligned to um to your current practices as it relates to that and then closing out for um part two of the policy excuse me of financial management policies was your independent auditor policy 6625 which is also being recommended to be rescinded it is found to be redundant with the law and the key components that were necessary were moved into policy 6600 any questions on the part two policies before I review part three okay question yes sir so uh and this is um the auditor general has looked over all this information and that's fine with her too right yes she was one she

101was considered the key expert on those policies as being the auditor and so many and most of those recommendations came from her okay thank you any other questions okay thank you so moving on to financial management policies in part three um there are just a few there and so for 6630 there were no significant changes that's excuse me the financial reports and resolution policy um your internal reports policy 6680 is being recommended to be rescinded this policy um existed before you all had board dos where many of these unrelated documents were um so they were not posted publicly before now they are available um and then for your purchase of food meals and refreshments 6835 which is a newer policy there are no um significant updates there are still just so you all are aware

102policies that are under review from this batch and were pulled because they needed further discussion that includes your purchasing policy your responsible bidder policy Contracting for Professional Services authorization for contracts and vendor relations so those policies will come forward to you at a later date and then just to review the deliverables related to the policies um that were just mentioned um as you all know you talked about the requirements that you have placed on Administration through many of your policies and so just looking to have a more thorough review of that portion as a part of the policy review process um and so as you see the non-resident tuition payment deliverable is legally required and that's why highlighted there um it states the Board of Education will establish tuition rates for non-resident students each year

103the administration will advance a resolution setting the non-resident tuition rates as soon as practicable after the Administration has been notified of those rates by the New York State Department of Education okay so reporting of Grants policy 6256 the current deliverable associated with that is that for the board to ensure better fiscal oversight direct the superint directs excuse me the super intendent to submit a written report to the board on a quarterly basis um and that will include all newly awarded grants in addition to superintendent order designate shall present to the finance committee in October for each school year for the purpose of discussing the overall use of grants in the prior year as well as grants being pursued or utilized in the current year so you all receive a quarterly report related to Grants via

104email and then um the grants director at this executive director Excuse Me Miss pakor typically comes into your October Finance meeting and provides a grants presentation annually in terms of deliverables for your financial reports and resolutions policy 6630 all of these deliverables are bundled into your monthly Finance uh report which you receive as a presentation from your CFO during your business meeting as we no longer um convene the finance committee so this list of um reports here which was also included in the other discussion related to board reports includes uh your cash flow your month monthly available funds report forecasting um Student Activities fund change order reports Grant reporting contract reports budget transfer reports and Charter School reporting this also goes on to State the superintendent shall provide other financial statements as requested by the

105board and then the final part part of the deliverable states that the Board of Education shall require the chief legal counsel to provide quarterly reports on any contracts for goods and services issued under $35,000 and that will include the vendor the length of the contract date it was signed amount of the contract a brief description of the services to be provided and verification that that contract was reviewed by the Department of Law and executed by the superintendent and you all currently receive that report via email there is no um presentation associated with that if there uh if is the will of the board these policies will be forwarded to the business meeting on February 27th for a first reading and continue to follow the policy adoption process as outlined in policy 2410 with final vote

106at the April buiness business meeting okay thank you clerk W um and for the purposes of this particular um agenda this evening I did ask that um these policies be moved to special meeting because there were questions around them at the last policy meeting and with that chair um the chairperson uh commissioner Griffin I'm going to ask that I uh work through these for the sake of time and in the special meeting absolutely go ahead for consideration and before I move forward with that um what I would like to be clear on clerk wi is um the policies we're looking at tonight our discussion points only correct that is correct M this is for discussion if you all agree you'll move it out to your business meeting where you have your readings right discussion and

107once we are done deliberating around a discussion this could can be forwarded to or out of policy meeting into the first reading where we will be able to kind of diss the policies as we go first second and third readings before the vote in April that is correct ma'am all right so with that said so I got to jump in on these real quick we got to read these Lord uh so I just gave you all a summary of what each of those policies was and ATT track change in board docs the full track change documents along with that presentation and a clean copy is available so and so when we go into the first readings um we can get a little more granular in in the actual out any question or what have you

108or would that be aable for this evening or we just I ideally if you all have points now that you'd like to discuss and have them updated or included in your first reading so that the policy is as complete as possible as it goes through the process that's ideal um however at each reading you have the opportunity to make changes have further discussion um and make decisions at that point okay so I'm I'm going to probably open up for a little bit of discussion to see if we can work through maybe some questions very brief questions um before I do do that I see vice president malloy's hand yeah when is the first reading then scheduled or when would that be what meeting yep if you forwarded out tonight it would be the February 27th

109board business meeting okay thank you each reading takes place at a at a business meeting until the April than you okay all right so with that said let's jump into policy 6254 H why is it not coming up for me there we go okay so um any discussion around 6254 we just bringing it out help me out you're making you're making a motion to forward it out and then starting a discussion then we can okay so first and foremost thank you uh counselor make I'd like to entertain a motion to forward policy 62 54 out of policy committee motion motion by commissioner Griffin second seconded by vice president Malloy open for discussion on policy 6254 excuse me discussion yes commissioner Patterson just a question um and it might be for councel the definition of a

110nonresident student would you clarify that for me please uh excuse me commissioner I believe that language was added to the policy that says non-resident is defined as a student who resides outside the city of Rochester um I mean a non-resident student is really someone who doesn't reside necessarily in the boundaries off the school district's um normal boundaries do we have those students that that are in the district from outside the C uh commissioner I couldn't confirm or deny that but that data might be available um elsewhere but I I couldn't tell you tonight whether that definitively exists at this time superintendent or president I I don't have that information but we can put it in the question log clerkin um I don't know if you were able to capture commissioner Patterson's question oh I'm sorry

111super yes we do have non-resident uh students and in particular where this actually bumps up is our summer school program a lot of our Suburban counterparts don't offer summer school so they choose to do it in Rochester thank you M thank you any other questions yeah out of curiosity um what is the tuition for what's the going rate like how is that determined that'll have to go in a question log I'm not sure about that yeah typically there's a rate that comes from the state um and that is adopted and the vote the board actually votes on that at a certain point um in the in the school year thank you so all in favor of policy of moving policy 6254 out of policy committee second um any opposed policy 6254 is being forwarded out

112of policy committee at this time like to entertain a motion to file uh forward policy 6256 out of policy committee moot motion by commissioner Patterson second seconded by commissioner Griffin policy 6256 is open for discussion any discussion on 6256 seeing as there is no discussion all in favor of forwarding policy 6256 out of policy committee I I any opposed policy 6256 is now forwarded out of policy committee entertaining a motion to forward policy 6300 out of out of policy committee motion motion motion by commissioner Patterson seconded by commissioner Griffin policy 6300 is open for discussion seeing there's no discussion all in favor of forwarding policy 6300 out of policy committee I any opposed motion carries entertaining a motion for policy 6600 out of policy committee motion motion by commissioner Patterson second seconded by commissioner Griffin

113policy 6600 is open for discussion I just have a a question what is the reasoning for the changes of the verbiage in uh 6600 there's a lot of information that has been crossed out can we can somebody explain why is it that we have so much information that's being removed from this uh policy and it was just amended on the 23rd was it was done back on December 23rd 2021 why is it that we're changing the verbiage can someone explain to me does anybody know why some of I can just speak to this if you don't mind briefly um some of it some of the lines you're saying is not deletions but reorganization um sometimes it's easier to look at the clean copy of the the document but again it was to simplify policies uh

114as well as to align it with updates to the law okay okay so these the these particular changes on here though were not governed by or mandated by anyone but the administration is that correct on the verbage chair these recommendations came from your general auditor okay so she's not here to to to to give more general information so I I guess we would have to refer to her for the other questions that I have in reference to it if she was the one that initially made these changes because I do have direct questions but you're probably not going to be able to answer it so I'll just have to I'll definitely send the questions into the board log so she can address them for me yeah you can put it and you can send it

115to me and I'll ensure it there forwarded to her thank you and and just to add a uh just a a process Point typically again policies are referred to again you've hear that that the term subject matter expresss within the district so if there's a policy that particularly affects a particular Department uh for example if there was a teaching and learning based policy it would not be before the board unless you know teaching and learning Department got an opportunity to review that and provide input uh if you have a a policy specific to audit audit committee the work of the committee that would not be before the board uh typically unless the the the auditor and her Department had a chance to review and provide input so you're usually seeing the collective input of of

116the um departments that are particularly affected or departments that do the work when these come to you with a recommend um uh changes thank you I just I guess my concern is that when we have a changes that are not actually uh mandated by the state or it didn't come in through this but it's the difference between the two you know when you're making so many changes I just think that we might miss something you know so and that's my concern and because you know we I am learning more about the different policies I I'm sometimes I get kind of skeptic of what change are made and why they're being made so that's why I'm asking the question but thank you for your information I appreciate it uh thank you commissioner Griffin and for my

117clarity I saw your hand commissioner Patterson for clarity again um we're we're voting to move these out of policy committee but when we go into readings if there are suggestions or language that we might uh want to see that that would be the time for those discussion points correct man and any questions you know could be forwarded now so that they be prepared for Preparation absolutely so is there any language that you well we'll we'll we'll keep going commissioner Patterson yeah just language again um and just for clarification purposes in line two says appoint the auditor general to oversee the work of the board's office of auditor general could you explain that to me I really have no you know I know Anessa to be the audit auditor general but is there something that I'm

118missing there um I again I I I don't want to speak for the a general but I will will offer like a brief opinion I think you can definitely put on a question log and she can offer additional information I think that's the office was established right by by the board Anissa is the board's employee there the board has U her as a as an employee so I think that's why she she um probably suggested the change and wrote it that way but I would put it on a question log and she could answer directly okay thank you thank you and for this particular policy I like one there's one some thing that's stood out to me that I actually liked and that was around a change in language I feel like I picked up

119on and that was from annual Financial records versus annual financial report because annual financial report is much broader and aerial view um whereas the annual Financial records my interpretation of that would be that we're getting a little more um concise and granular around the information um and so that that was interesting to me um I'll Reserve any other comments or questions for um the future because well I'll ask it now so that we are there it's on the second page and um it's like the strikeout of the employees of the district being prohibited from serving on this particular committee is um I do have a question around that so I just want to raise that uh we could probably put it on a hanger but there might be some clarity that I want to know

120about that as we um move forward is that fair yes ma'am okay um any other discussion points for policy 6600 um I do have one one one more thing to say um going forward with these um it would be probably appreciative for us to have an expert here with us to answer these questions in lie of um if if uh Anissa can't be here because that that's what we should have as a board um because we need questions answered and that's the best way for us to get them answered if an expert is present in my opinion if I could just add that Anessa was uh not asked to be here tonight because you all's process does not generally include the subject matter expert to come to the meeting so if you all are asking

121for that to happen for Anissa I can make that request and work with her to find a meeting that that can occur in um I'm also not if you're asking for the entire process to be shifted to always have a subject matter expert because that would be a a different conversation yeah I I mean I mean for our for us to know exactly what the what the Lango is and what it should be and to understand the Dynamics of the change I think for all of us it would be great for us to have an expert present when we're discussing these policies because you know we don't know everything but they do so it for me uh personally it would help to to to to know that the information being conveyed is by an expert

122okay I definitely respect opinion although I may have a difference of and and recognize that these policies do come before us for quite some time um even extension into a special meeting with a lot of opportunity to even connect with place things in the questioning log so I would encourage us to make sure we're leaning into those opportunities as well but your points are taken received um that is my opinion and so at this point I would like to entertain a motion to uh for policy 6600 to move forward out of the policy committee you have a motion you just need to vote thank God all right all in favor of policy 6600 I lost my flow I I any oppos entertaining a motion to forward policy 6610 out of policy committee motion motion a

123motion by commissioner Patterson second seconded by commissioner Griffin uh polic 6610 open for discussion no discussion around policy 6610 um I do have a I do want to say that I approve or not approved but um understood the recommendations being sent by 6610 um I do have um I do like to lean into language because one thing I saw is that it might give the how to although it is something that's absorbed within state law um having that how- to breakdown might be relevant so that is something I would like to explore as we continue to discuss this policy maybe in the readings um but um at this point I did not hear any discussion for policy 6610 so all in favor of policy 6610 nobody's in favor oh all in favor of moving let

124me finish thank you all in favor of mov moving policy 6610 for ing out of it out of the policy committee I I any opposed policy 6610 is um being forwarded out of the policy committee entertaining a motion for policy 6625 motion second motion commissioner Patterson second commissioner Griffin any discussion round 6625 yeah um can you uh explain why we're resending um 6625 where is it going what's happening with with this particular uh policy so the key components of that policy that were relevant were included into 6600 okay um it refers to other laws and everything with with this see my concern is that when you're dealing with policies there's a lot of different langual that goes with it and there's a lot of different references so if we don't know what applies to what

125I think it's still for the public this is not so much for us it's for the public as well and the community stakeholders to understand what we're what we're looking at they don't see this before we do so when that's why I say and an expert should be here for different questions and explain um to our listening public and and that's a big concern for me when you so why do we so we're resending it because it's part of policy 6 6000 you said so so commissioner if I can if I can just offer kind of like a a brief Insight so I think in the or the presentation overview presentation that clerkin did it stated that the the auditor generals were recommending recision of policies because they're now incorporated into policy 6600 this policy

126talks about the external auditor right and retention of an external auditor policy 6600 does have an entire uh section on the external auditor so again the board can can can can obviously look at both policies and make a determination whether you think that 6600 sufficiently captures what was in 6625 I think the point the audit journalist point is to have less policies and have more the relevant information combined into one policy and one place so I think I think the Commissioners can absolutely take a look and determine okay do I see enough transferred into this to be comfortable with it and and if you don't the board has an opportunity through the readings to to to offer to offer input on that that's helpful I appreciate that um Direction general counsel because again to my

127point made on the previous policy just now um so if we see language that talks more to the howto and things that we don't want to see lost we can suggest that during the readings and move it forward so we'll note that and if we have those suggestions um clerk when is that something we can do in between pendal uh or wait until the first reading probably is that Commissioners are are welcome and encouraged to send uh any corrections updates uh feedback prior to so that those can be included for the discussion so um perhaps not waiting until the next reading would be advantageous okay absolutely gives an opportunity to have pertinent answers and relevant answers to the questions because it's we it's not always able to anticipate every single question that might come up

128well I did subit answered questions but they never were answered so that's that's part of it too so some of the questions I'm asking never were answered and they were done on on J in January 31st for the record thank you for that and we'll double check on some things and so I'm going to ask that we all in favor am I doing it right 6 of forwarding policy 6625 out of the policy committee I I any opposed policy 6625 is now being forwarded out of the policy committee moving to policy 6680 forwarding uh entertaining a motion to forward policy 6680 out of policy committee motion second motion by commissioner Patterson seconded by commissioner Griffin 66 80 is now open for discussion I'm not going to be redundant see is uh see as there's no

129discussion regarding policy 6680 uh all in favor of policy 6680 any opposed policy 6680 carries out of the policy committee motion to inter uh entertaining a motion to forward policy 6620 out of the policy committee motion may I have a second second SEC seconded by commissioner Patterson um open for discussion seeing as there's no discussion all in favor of moving 6620 out of policy committee I I any opposed policy 6620 carries out of policy committee entertain aing a motion to forward policy 6630 out of the policy committee motion motion by commissioner Griffin second seconded by commissioner Patterson policy 6630 is open for discussion seeing as there's no discussion for policy 6630 all in favor of policy 6630 I I any oppos I policy 6630 is now being forwarded out of the policy committee entertaining a

130motion to uh forward policy 6835 out of the policy committee second motion by commissioner Patterson seconded by commissioner Griffin policy 6835 open for discussion seeing as there's no discussion policy all in favor of policy 6835 I I any opposed policy 6835 is now being carried out of or forwarded out of the policy committee we don't have any executive sessions do we the languages is there as a courtesy well thank God for that um we have now I'd like to entertain a motion to end or exit the policy Committee of the whole for this evening motion motion by commissioner Griffin special meeting ma'am we do have another one no this is the special meeting you said p oh the policy oh forgive me public I'm confusing you this is the special meeting so let me restate

131that entertaining a motion to exit the special meeting this evening motion motion by commissioner Griffin second seconded by commissioner Patterson all in favor of exiting exiting our special meeting motion I I I'm sorry any oppos good night good night for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.