CorpusRecord 63663

Special Meeting: Policy Committee Meeting | February 4, 2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Rochester City School District
Date
2025-02-05
Location
Monroe County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
6,149 words · about 35 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening I am commissioner Griffin chair of the policy committee for the Rochester City School Board of Education it is now 6:17 p.m. on Tuesday February 4th 2025 this is the policy Committee of the whole and I want to apologize also to all that we ran we're running a little late I do apologize for that as well can I get a motion to approve the policy Cal meeting agenda second thank commissioner Patterson vice president mooy thank you any discussion all in favor I any oppos nay I did have a question but I wasn't recognized but I'm going to vote no because you said committee lists agenda is this for our last committee Mee this is the the minutes these are the minutes okay then I I vote y any opposed all in

002favor I motion carries we do not have any speakers this evening I understand that um there's there's a concern about the speakers and so what we're doing is we're reviewing the information noted by a policy to confirm all information noted is is uh in consensus across the board so I do respect Dr Mack that you did want to speak but we are reviewing that information I do respect you respect you coming here this evening okay we're going to move forward with the to approve uh the minutes from December 3rd 2024 I believe you've already done that commissioner so just for clarification uh Dr Matt based on the agenda topic for tonight um it doesn't align with what you what you want to talk about so recommendation is to contact our office through the Board of

003Education um email address and you can sign up either for our um February business meeting or the March business meeting or a meeting that the topic that you're trying to talk to will align but with committee meetings based on the by the board bylaws committee meetings your topic has to be on um the agenda and it's not for tonight if if you go to board do so if you go to rcsdk12.org booo you can look at all meeting agendas and you can see what agenda um items are on there when it comes to committee meetings but for business meetings you can talk about it's open if it's not on the agenda no it has to be on the agenda for the committee based on the board bylaws so if it's not on the agenda so

004tonight's based on tonight's meeting what you want to discuss is not on the agenda which is why I'm recommending you can sign up to speak at the next business meeting or whatever meeting aligns with what your topic is to time to speak Dr back what I will do is have the board clerk's office reach out to you to give you all of those specifics around how you can get uh the agenda available to you to ensure that your topic is in alignment with the agenda and we appreciate your your patience with us this evening thank you Charisma I'm going to turn the mic back over to the policy chair so that we can finish out this meeting thank Madam president Simmons um and we have the approve the Amendments for the December 3rd 2024 policy

005Cal meeting can I get a motion to approve the minutes from December 3rd 2024 policy c meeting commissioner Griffin I believe we we've done that well on according to the information says motion to approve the policy c meeting agenda these are minutes that'll be the motion at this time motion right motion motion all in favor any discussions any oppose motion carries and we need to review the nisal policy recommendations we did receive nisba policy recommendation updates last week um so we have the code of conduct committee and I will turn that over to Charisma um thank you so just really quickly as an update tomorrow is the last kodon committee meeting um and then the administration will review those recommendations there will there is a public hearing lated for March 11th for the community to

006give input on the code of conduct and then it will come out for the board's review um at the April 1st policy committee meeting thank you okay thank you Charisma um and then we're going to go into the unfinished business we have um policy 2300 and I need a motion to carry policy so no sorry Comm this is you all have to discuss the policy first before the motion the presentation it doesn't say that on here so that's why I'm I'm just going by what you have written here for me to to me to address so I do apologize to the listening public yeah am I good to go commissioner Griffin yeah go ahead go ahead okay all right so um for 2300 what you're about to see now is the so back so really

007quickly last year in February during the policy committee meeting um the board has asked for some sections to be paused on until you all started your governance model and so as you recall throughout the months for policy committee meetings that's what you all have been doing and so this is the last piece that was held up um this would this would be a new section leadership resonations and recalls and so just getting clarity as to if you all want to move forward with um this SE these sections being being recommended so the first part is um as you see on the screen this is the first uh section of it when you all last spoke um Commissioners had wanted to maybe change the language of the highlighted yellow do anyone have any feedback recommendations do

008you want to keep this section do you want to remove it um if you could provide Clarity around the language around in the manner they choose you can you can change it so this is coming from um this origin started from at the time then commissioner pow back in December 2023 and then it came back in February 2024 so if you want to change the language or remove it so in the manner they choose my interpretation of that is that you know that can be in writing that could be a verbal conversation and maybe that could just instead of the manner they choose explicitly stating the options that the person has so that it's it's a little more clear and concise around um you know that works I also if you want in the parentheses

009we can give examples if you want to do it that way to yeah examples are good a manner they choose these are the examples yes okay so you wanted writing you said verbal it could be a verbal conversation I think it should it needs to be followed up with writing though it needs to be in writing in writing at least yes so yeah interpret a dance maybe it's an email maybe it's a letter but it's got to be in writing any other people back with this are we going to move on in reference to the notes what does it mean commissioner's draft language for the sentence is that what we were that was a directive we had ourselves in previous meetings that we would draft some language around that yes yes okay and so the

010language we're talking about is the uh the language is highlighted yes okay so this is what it already had looked like I didn't receive any um language so again if you anyone have any additional input besides what president Simmons had recommended if not I can move on to the next slide what did what did the president recommend what did you recommend president um I'll speak Charisma I appreciate it thank you um so my recommendation commissioner Elliott was around um the language it says that the board president may also resign in the manner they choose so my thoughts were we should be more explicit around that so um they should it should be in writing it should be in writing yep so oh okay so but I guess the next sentence kind of contradicts well it

011sort of um agrees with that um do we need to have uh in the manner that they choose I'm trying to figure out however they must provide written notice to all B board members so it's special meeting it seems a little redundant what seem to me well I think it's a two-part I think it's a two and two and I I see what you're saying around the redundancy I think the in writing is the formal resignation from from that the role and then the written then the additional piece is now you need to also alert all board members in writing about the special meeting that that I've now Technic so you have the one piece that's a communication saying I've resigned from this role and then communicate to the full board that uh you need

012a special uh meeting or what have you so you're saying that in in place of the manner they choose to put it to resign in writing yes okay I think that it's probably need to word Smith that some if we're going to replace it with in writing and then the how they must provide not provide written notice to the boards maybe maybe that needs to be a little clearer yeah yeah okay okay okay so just for clarity so because I think I heard two different things I heard what you said president Simmons I'm sorry then we started saying that I said do we put iie so originally I was put and the board president may also resign in a matter they choose parenthesis I.E writing but you were trying to replace the matter they choose

013with the word writing so it's two parts but what I think um what commissioner Elliot suggested is just capture those notes and so it's okay to put the the examples in there right now and then um we can take some time do you need to have the explicit language right now this evening no if you all decide to forward this out to the um the business meeting you can come to that first reading with new language and then you guys can just be it there that's fine so I think that would work well but yes it does need to be if you're removing yourself in writing I can send an email or a letter whatever the cases but um then that additional conversation needs to happen collectively like you need to have that additional piece

014and so we can figure out how to make that more clear if you all bring that recommendation back okay is that okay y we're good say that that part is going to be in writing yes and then the other part is will be in writing too we just have the word Smith All right yes okay right moving on to the next slide so this is a option one and a option oh two so the first so language recommended due in the December 5th 2023 policy committee meeting is what's in um highlighted yellow um General Council combine both the bullets as option one during the February 6 meeting uh Commissioners seem to prefer the option two where the two bullets are separate so basically the question is which option if either is preferred anyone what is

015your question I I don't understand your question so there are two options on the screen um not both options you just need to pick between one of the two or neither um what I'm basically saying is that when you all last review this during the February 6 2024 meeting Commissioners seem to like the highlighted yellow which is option two option one is from general counsel so my question is which option is preferred if either um yeah I think oh go ahead uh for me personally I I agree with option one I wasn't on the board when it was proposed but um I agree with the first option I think it explains uh very clearly what the process and how the process should take place um and so I I agree with option one so I

016I sort of I I like option two because it's less wordy or you know it needs to be it it's simpler at least to me it's simpler when it's broken down in into uh two pieces two parts uh than in option one it just seems to be in particular if people are going to be reading it um it can get this one can be a little wordy and it may lose something as people are reading it particular if our public is reading it it may lose something they may have to read it a few times before they can get it but I think the option two simplifies it more is what I'm thinking mam president GFF oh I'm sorry I'm sorry but she just she was just I think I um yeah I think she

017was lead chrisma was leading at this point yeah yeah not doe respectful and I understand goe all right for me personally um if uh General Council recommends option one that's more thorough for me personally Rec he recomend too it's it's option so option was back coun by General councel right option one which option one you said was General Counsel yeah yes I like I had to think what I just said as well I'm sorry so the non highlighted one so language recommended during a December 5th policy meeting um General Council combine both bullets and above bullet b as recommendation during the February 6th meeting Commissioners seem to prefer these two bullets versus the above bullet um B so you recommended option one charisma that's but I like I like option two it's just simpler are

018we are we um going to vote on that tonight Charisma is it or you just want to get a way in and how we feel I mean the the goal at least I hope is that you all can come to an agreement as to what language to move forward to the first reading um if you still want to play around with language of course you have three readings to do that or you can table it or you can decide not to go with neither so there's nothing to say you have to go with this language you can can decide not to because it's still in your rabbish rules of orders either way well I for me I would go with option two and then Madam president you wanted to say something as well yeah so

019so option two does is a little more U malleable to the pallet right however an option one it gives some um things like if this occurs at a meeting right it gives you specific ways to go about it um so I'm almost thinking option two can be the leading piece I don't know if this can be bulleted like because this thing about um this may occur through a motion to suspend the rules and to appoint a chair like this tells you how to do it um and so I think it would be helpful for the board to have that guidance um can it be presented like option two with this these pieces that are very specific um kind of outline of ABC where you know you can look at this is a howto can can

020that be separated out yeah I agree with that I think I would agree with that um pres Madam president um Simmons taking some of the the Lango out of option one and making the bullets that would we would cover our bases with that or if if um if the general counsel is um recommended it and to the president's point maybe it just can be separate the sentences can some of the sentences can be separated right and you may not need option to right that's what Madam president was saying yeah okay yeah so um I can work with general counsel to do that as well Justa because I just think it needs to be easier to read okay with the bulleted out as something or just sentences either either way is what I'm suggest so I

021work with general counsel to make it other additional bullets based on um option one so option one is what it sounds like you're all okay with long as it gets organized to be a little more cleaner to read okay all right all right next up so the next piece of this any open committee chair SE um whether by resonation or recall may be filled by election at the next meeting following the effective date of the resonation or immediately following a recall vote to serve for the remainder of the year so there's no notes based on the last two meetings we've discussed this topic there were no notes from that so the question is again if you all want this language to be added or not or have additional language I have I have something else

022and I don't know if it got addressed in the previous um slide but when we have um committee chairs that walk out does this address does any of this address the fact when a commissioner just leaves uh the chairmanship just leaves out are we addressing that um in in um in the policy and if it not perhaps we should should be or maybe something in the language addresses that and I'm just not sure but um I think we have to address that when people just AB abdicate uh their their role as chair um and you know what do we do as a board well I think can I add to that I think that we also need to and I think this is what this covers is that no one should be treated unjustly at

023a meeting so what happens when you treated unjustly is people will instead of being confrontational anything they leave so I think that this is what this this covers so I think if we put this information into into work then we don't have to worry about uh uh any committee person or a chairperson leaving the DI um but people need to be also be respectful of others and I think this covers that if in all due respect yeah I I will have to say that um when we are chairing here because this is an elected office right we all understand that and so when you are called to elected office you're expected to to explicitly execute the role and it can get difficult but when you are chairing there has to be an official ending of

024the meeting or something of that nature so maybe there's some other discussion that needs to happen but you should not um I don't think that a chair can just you know get up and leave so they're you know I think that's something we have to to your point I think that we all have to you know to your point in reference to leaving but I also feel that as an elected official we need to be fair treated fairly and just it doesn't say that that we have to be abused in any fashion or any man manner or in humilated so I think there's a fine line but I think there's more discussion to be had on that so so so I do think that there needs to be some language in there I mean all

025of the you know sort of ancillary information is fine and good but if this were to happen we need to have some rules does the president take over is there another person that takes over it needs to be def we have that commissioner Elliott we have that language that um if something happens that the president can take that but let's um what part of the policy is it do you know right now yes so if you go under the president there it's not that explicit like if someone walks out this is will happen but the president is the um ex official member so like if for anything they can cheer any meeting um basically so that's there but don't get that explicit so I don't know that covers exactly what you're trying to say but

026you go to page um five of the actual policy the president section covers um basically that okay that may be sufficient but we just need to have we've had this to happen where people have just walked out regardless of the reason and we're left hanging and so it we have to continue the business of the of the people and we need to be explicit about you know who takes over that chair whatever committee it is who takes over in cases like that yeah I think if we need to further discuss say we can we can do that um another time I think we should move forward though cuz it is part it's already in in the verbiage in the policy so I just want to be clear so that's not lingering are we okay not

027adding or do you want to add it that way I know right now what I'm what I'm hearing is that we're we're okay because the language does exist okay but I'm also hearing there may be an appetite to revisit at some point to if we need to make it more explicit is I think it's going to come down to practice not policy the policy exists but the practice may not and so okay with she speaking I'm okay with it being the way it is if if everybody else is okay with it but I just want to make sure that that is covered all right thank you back to the question the the ne other question was based on what's currently um with this section the um any open committee chair this piece are our commissioner

028is okay with this being added any open committee chair seat whether by resonation recall may be filled by election at the next meeting following the effective date of the resignation or immediately filing a recall a recall vote to serve for the remainder of the year so do Commissioners want this section added or tweaked or not added at all can we try to can we try to have this a little bit more orderly can we start from to left to right so that we're not all over the place and jumping in I would appreciate it because it seems like we're we're not yeah doing it decent in order so we'll start with Isaiah commissioner um Santiago I'm sorry uh yeah I'm fine with this thing me and add it okay or being added I know this

029is a new uh so yeah I'm cool with this being added any other I guess easier question is any commissioner against this being added or want to tweak it no okay commissioner hold on we want to do this decent in the order um commissioner commissioner Malloy would you like to speak at this time no no she was does anyone else want to speak was the next one Comm please so I need to get back because this also brings up that piece uh about when when a chairperson walks out the room right so is there any consequences for when a a chairperson just abdicates their responsibility so I just want I'm just throwing that on the table and if it's somewhere we need to add some kind of language because there's got to be some accountability

030for a person to abdicate the chairmanship in a meeting so I just want to put that on the table if there's some some consequences and some form of accountability to that so thank you so I can speak to general counsel about that um the question you have uh commissioner Elliot I know commissioner Griffin no I'm I'm all set okay all right so with that being said I did it in reverse depending on what was going to happen with that section depending on this next section so um this already exists Committees of the Board of Education section 4 um so the sentence has highlighted yellow um or so the board may discuss the appointment of standing committee chairpersons each December with a view toward they being appointed during its annual organizational meeting once selected the committee

031chair shall shall serve for one year or until their successor is elected as outlin in section five herein so if you so if the board um amends this new section five that we just discussed in the previous section this will um reference back to that section is what it's saying is anyone against this language being added or want to tweak the language being added all right so student representative section five um so there's new legislation that's supposed to take effect July 1st um we although we already have a student rep there are some minor tweaks we have to due to um our board bylaws to align with that and so same similar I'm going take a section by section um so this is proposed language the Board of Education shall have an ex-official member who

032is an enrolled student in the Rochester City School District whose title shall be student rep representative any disagreement with that um I'm we can started this in for a second um I what do we have anything in here as far as a parent being a representative don't we have don't we have that I know there's we have it for the chair for the chairperson who's over chairing the committee but do we have one where we actually have an elected parent no we so as you just said the there's a committee a parent committee rep and a parent a student committee rep for the Committees but not for this this specifically is the new um legislation versus the um parent rep is not a current thing but you all can of course discuss that in the

033future or at this meeting right now this is specific to what the legislation is taking effect okay thank you yeah I know it's I know it's um the legislation that has addressed this but I was just concerned because I think a parent would be would be ideal to have on as as um in Li of of the um student too I think the both of them should be able to come and address and sit with us on the DI or you know sit here to to have their view their opinions or or communicate with us in reference to what they feel so that's just a suggestion something we could probably talk about at a later time but we don't can I um inject or so we we have historically had parent Representatives they're on our

034committees right now conveniently I think they meet with us via Zoom or whatsoever convenient for them but we've actually had parents that um during a committee meeting have joined us at the day in the past to um have you know facil help facilitate that meeting or represent their voice so that exists but in regard to this specific policy um I think I'm I want to just respond to say I'm okay with what is represented here on this um student policy which is what we're discussing yeah but no to to your point I do agree with what is written I was it was just a question or a statement that I made in reference to the per but thank you because I'm aware of the parent parent um committees as well thank you yes go ahead

035um um commissioner Elliott so I thought we have some kind of language in our bylaws regarding student Representatives we we do so what's happening now is that this is is cleaning it up to align with the legislation that's all so if you look at the this if you look at the attachment on bardocks with the actual policy you can kind of follow along what's being track change this PowerPoint is just to make things easier for you to kind of compare and contrast like what's already here what's not here based on what's the legislation um is says we're going to replace what what we have in here with this if there's anything already exists we would replace it if nothing exists like this current slide then the recommendation is to add it what would we do

036with the other what would we do with the other language that's in the bylaws so some is being recommended to be removed or amended um yeah so this current slide we don't actually spell out because again the ex officio is it's the title that is being put in the legislation and so we calling that this is what it is and also making sure that it's clear that they have to be an rcsd um student in our district all right thank you so no other commissioner is um if everyone is okay with this I'm move on to the next slide so I'm not going to read this whole thing but if you look to the left hand side this is what the current language is so to your point commissioner Elliot we do have some language

037like for this slide that exists and then to your um to your right is the proposed language and so part of the legislation is the board has um to create a process basically on how a student rep is selected and So currently the process the practice I should say has been um so so is your the president of so is your student rep um and we and and that we follow their bylaws and so just so you know any updates that you all make to your policy um what would happen is that I would work with s so their bylaws doesn't align to tweak it if need but um again we this is following the legislation that you all have to have a process as to how a ex official um member is selected is

038anyone opposed to this language so again left is what's currently in your bylaws right is what's being recommended with some tweaks to what was in the left side looks good to me all right I think silence as were good so this this um speaks also that they can be at committee meetings of the whole and other kinds of meetings as well that's what this language also includes correct because right now um the legislation says that they can be at any meeting that's not a closed meeting executive session whereas they're not they abided to the or meeting for example but they can't actually sit at the de currently and the bylaws um so that's why that's being recommended to change thank you all right I'm going move on to the next slide so I think I

039kind of just said this with the the annual or meeting um that's being recommended to be removed because again the legislation is saying all meetings and so that's the biggest change here just remove that first sentence can you talk a little bit about what um is meant around um the right to propose motions during the committee meetings is is is it I'm in agreement okay so um the right to propose motions during committee meetings and work sessions and then the other question is is that that does that not it doesn't mean that they can propose motions during uh the business meeting does it so doesn't we the same as a commissioner motion so let's say I say like hey I would would like classrooms to has more toys and I talk to commissioner Santiago and

040like hey and I can propose that the motion and he can then present it as a official motion um oh it would be and you're talking about the business meeting it would be or any meeting that that allows that to happen so it could be at like this meeting if that's something that makes sense then yes but yeah it's not like an official motion unless the actual commissioner makes that motion doesn't say that in here Charisma what makes a second they can't make I mean they can make the motion but it doesn't look like they can make the second you know right they can't the second and the the motion like they could propose it but then it would be on us to motion and second whatever they're proposing well yeah what what I understood

041Charisma to say is is that they bring it to um a commissioner for the motion so that's just one example another thing can be you all could have like motioned to like amend policy 2300 and it can also vote yeah I guess what I but they both don't really count in terms of like the what we need for Quorum not Quorum um the majority yeah so guess what I'm saying is what you're describing probably needs to also be included so that it's more clear yeah okay and again that's if you want that to happen like this is this part isn't required the the only thing that needs to be changed for this specific uh slide is the or's what was crossed out okay rest of this language is really up to you all to decide

042if you want to keep it tweak it but this is not a part that's necessarily required it just already within the bylaws all right thank you I will say I do think that it's important for there to be something you know inside of the policy just for whoever the student Representatives representative is so they can know you know and it's establish l in the bylaw as far as their responsibilities and what they can do in their role so do you want to tweak it or you want to just leave it as is no I the proposed language looks good to me so I'm supporting the proposed language I think it just needs to be tweaked a little bit um I I do think that we need that students should be able to propose things to

043us for um for their own rights cuz some things we can't see because they're in actually sitting in the seats and I think that they need to be able to do that but I I do think some of the verbiage may need to change a little bit now I'm not exactly sure how it should change I think that's something that maybe we should address but I do think their voice matters um and I think that it we just need to just tweak it a little bit can I um make a suggestion for both this bullet and then the one prior with the leadership recalls that you all mentioned um between now and the next business meeting um if you all can propose propose I'll send an email out if you can propose language for both

044of those and then I can update the um policy attachment so that when it comes to the business meeting you can review um both of those changes and then um you know motion to a minute to continue on in this readings okay so I will send out an email for that if I can make that suggestion yeah because I'm thinking what you used as an example with commission of Santiago as and I'm as I'm reading it again um this language may be okay but for the student representative they may need to know the process okay that's for our consideration y all right yep I will send out an email and we'll go from there all right so if besides the two things I know we you all need to kind of tweak the language with

045um if we're if everything else is okay next steps would be this would be forwarded to the next business meeting um it will follow the policy 2410 and vote at the April business meeting the most important part in this policy is that student rep I mean it's all important for the student rep piece um the addition because of the the July 1 you know things have to be in place so this is why it's being presented early enough that way we need to take a you know a little longer to tweak things you have that time but the goal is that by the April business meeting um it will be amended it will not affect our current president Roberts um at all just just so you know does not affect anything um with her it

046would just affect anything that happens for the upcoming year so it also allow so if needed to amend their bylaws so that they have time as they elect their new president motion I I didn't ask a motion um commissioner Griffin that sorry I I'm all set okay thank you now we're going to move for did you say something I'm sorry okay we just have to call for the motion for the motion oh I'm sorry you you I'm sorry I'm going on to the next one can I have a motion to move um 2300 forward yeah some any any discussion all in favor I I motion carries so now we're going to move forward to to um our um to our policy our Amendment sorry Amendment resolutions um for the following hold on one second am

047amendments to policy 5500 we just need to we need to get a motion for those for 5500 and 5600 so 5500 can we get a motion okay are we on amendment of resolution 314 I thought that's what she was I thought that's where she I was on there but then okay I my apologies to the public it's amendment to resolutions uh number 2024 to 2025 uh number 314 if Commissioners recall during the December 9th 19th 202 for business meeting the board approved resolutions uh number 2024 to 2025 437 committee diet which amended the board bylaws 2300 policy to Sunset the community intergovernmental relationship committee finance and resource allocation committee human capital committee effective January 1st 2025 this resolution impacted policies 6110 and 6150 which was recently amended by the board on October 24th 2024 as

048both policy have policy language that names the fin finance committee amend amended resolution number 2024-25 314 that amended policies 6110 6150 will all will allow these policies to be updated accordingly the resolutions in tonight's agenda are board dos as 4C outlines the changes both in the resolution and amendments um and I want to get a motion for Resolutions 2024 through 202 5 314 I mean 20 second any discussions all in favor all motion moves motion carries I'm sorry and now we're going to go to the new business sorry um we have amended to policy 5500 can I get a motion for that one hold on one second and just for clarity that is the student records and privacy and can we get a motion to to for that particular resolution I'm sorry any discussion yes

049um so um you know in light of if if I'm discussing the right one but in light of the whole ice um situation and as I read the policy um I saw that there were um certain people that were able to um access records um but I also uh saw on page um and it seems that this policy is uh protecting uh the students and the families rights for having people to access their records who don't have the authority to do that but then I'm also looking at on page three on the bullet two where it says or um well enforcement and also uh compliance purposes so how does that align how does our policy align with the fact that we may have some ice officials to come in and want to get records of

050our students of some of our students go ahead superintendent good evening everyone and good evening um Madam chair uh commissioner ot to answer your point this actually uh gets us more in line with a lot of the policies around protections for our English language Learners in particular or Refugee students or students that are seeking Asylum that's why if as you could see on page number two uh you have we have deleted and place of birth um that is something that should not be identified uh in student records and that actually protects our our students from uh being targeted in any way shape or form this entire policy is in line with furpa and and making sure that all their students right all the students rights are protected and what uh page number three is really

051um outlining is saying that we cannot disclose any records without consent um we have uh our legal department uh is very good at this and ensuring we have uh documentations or signed agreements with different organizations that would be education companies outside City of Rochester so on and so forth that all has to be recognized in moas and and um you know we just have to protect well let me just read you some Doc some information that I I got I just got today about ice operations in sensitive locations historically ice is has been restricted from conducting enforcement actions in schools religious institutions or and cour houses to allow individuals access to education Spirit spiritual support and legal services without fear of arrest however under the new directive ice agents are now authorized to make arrest

052at these locations though they still need to follow usual due process um principles so can you clarify that for me please yes okay thank you you're welcome um yes uh commissioner Elliot so uh they have to still follow the rules and expectations around um our protections of students we cannot disclose or give records to any individual um and that's without being accompany with a Warren or anything actually I don't even think that actually covers it to be honest you you we we cannot disclose records uh under any circumstances in particular without parent consent and and I don't even want to go down that road but they have to have an actual warrant in order to even get to a student and things of that nature and we're just we're following this entire situation closely but

053fura though is a federal absolutely regulation right correct so what's to say that you know with this Administration they may you know just resend that legislation and then we're open to it so that that's the uh Catch 22 uh around some of these administration's uh doings and their executive orders and um you know we just have to continue to follow and ensure that we are remaining in line if I may Madam chair absolutely yes so I I love this and I know we're going kind of a little off policy but I do want to recognize the efforts that have being made and I've talked to several groups um and I I like that we are in alignment and we know that this particular Administration does not follow rules but you are aligning the safety of

054our students first and foremost and we recognize that they are coming anywhere someone um just mentioned the other day that um a car well I won't even go there right now I think this is not the proper forum for it but there is a great fear but I I'm I'm happy to see the efforts that have been going through our um communities to make sure that people have the information and I'm looking forward to seeing those efforts continue because there's still some questions um but that's all I wanted to to say because I think it's is an important conversation does anyone okay commissioner Patterson go ahead yeah I'm always um being proactive um so my advice would be to contact the DA's office and see exactly what we should do if a situation should present

055itself because federal law trumps state law trumps county law trumps city law um regulations and violations and things like that so it's a good idea really to reach out to your da and say hey if this happens this occurs you know what should we do how should we respond just uh just to respond to that very great point of course and that's where we were coming in line with we don't know what this Administration would do in general they you know one day it's something is is going to be in order and the next day it's rescinded um so it's it's created some sort of Hysteria among uh everyone uh every time the Attorney General provides updates updated guidance myself and my team tackle that guidance make sure that we're in line and we um

056are uh we will be in the process of updating our school leaders as they are the people that are on the front lines um as soon as the attorney uh General came out with the first uh information um I got on with our principles uh that like a few days later with our legal reminding them about the the rules and expectations that we have covered as a district and we would just continue to um move about in that way but great suggestion yeah definitely because you know again the attorney general you know is the um in New York state is the commanding officer but the federal government when they come in you know it's just good to have your da behind your back you know when you make these decisions you know thank you I

057I think that there's there's a lot of Fallout that may happen I think we you know we can go on and on about it we just have to you know roll with the punches as they come as they come along we need to address them ensure that our children going to be safe so I'm going to move forward I did have another question well hold on hold on one second I'll let I'll I'll let vice president Malloy end it so we can move forward yeah I just wanted to say that our our Administration has I appreciate how proactive on this sensitive topic we have a lot of worried families and students who are impacted by this but um thank you so much for all the community meetings that you have been attending as well as

058the principal's meeting and thank you for the dissemination of correct information uh to staff um and the reassurance that you have provided um students and families on this thank you and I just want to have a a motion oh this is I'm sorry this is new business I'm sorry and um then we have the policy 5600 basically that I'm sorry so president Simmons motion and BP Malloy um second but you all didn't take a a vote okay you okay you threw me off okay it was discussion and that's what we had discussion okay I'm apologize all in favor any oppos motion carries and then we have amendments uh to policy 5600 and this also deals with the student Privacy Law immigration enforcement um did anyone have any questions on that I just want to go

059with a motion for policy 5600 motion second any discussion yes so what does it mean with regard to third uh not allowing any third party access to a school site without permission okay I'm thinking that this has to it may it may um include ice in here well I guess it does when you think about it yes it does so you're we're saying in the policy that we're not going going to school staff must not allow but I mean what if they force themselves in and if what if you know they're arrest that are made because um staff School staff are not allowing them in how do we address that I'm going to go ahead and let um Dr Strickland superintendent U speak to that so uh that's that's on the minds of uh every

060school leader every day um what would uh School leaders have been instructed of a plan uh I don't want to come forth with that plan out loud um as we want to continue to protect uh our students at all costs but uh I will uh definitely uh take the time and opportunity to just quickly give you that verbage in a different form um and and I appreciate that um in consideration of recognizing that sometimes you have to be a little covert um around especially aggressive um situations like this the um I I I do appreciate that um the guidance is is is being given and and consideration of Staff who people can get hurt if we are not Mindful and so uh we we want to make sure that we put our staff and and

061families in a space of protection and good judgment so I do I love that that's happening do we have any other questions or discussion on this matter okay we're going to move forward all and so all in favor I any oppose motion carries and that will in a policy meeting um I ask everyone to fill out the survey um and I just want to add the board May recess to Executive session to discuss matters leading to the appointment of specific individuals EX that language that language is a courtesy that is typically on all of the meetings um just in case so if there's going to be one you'll be alerted but that's always that standard for it you're okay so I would like a motion to adjourn um the policy the policy meeting so moved

062second all in favor thank thank you hi been a germed

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.