001e e e and good evening to our listening public uh today is January 23d 2025 and we are calling to order uh the meeting concerning uh Charter School this is a jese Community Charter School public hearing um and at this time I'm going to read some statements the education law subdivision 2857 and regulations of the commissioner of Education require the board to conduct a public hearing within 30 days of receipt of notice of an application for a new or revised Charter School the Board of Education of the Rochester city school district is conducting this public hearing regarding the revision of application for geny Community Charter School the purpose of this hearing is to gather Community input and to provide the New York State education department to provide two excuse me the board of the jese
002Community Charter School at the Rochester Museum and Science Center a charter school Education Corporation authorized by the Board of Regents seeks to merge with the board of Jesy Community Charter School Flor uh Flower City Campus a charter school Education Corporation authorized by the Sunni Board of Trustees such that when the merger is approved Jesy Community Charter School Flower City Campus would be the surviving Education Corporation under the amended name Jesy Community Charter Schools and authorized by the sun Sunni Board of Trustees beginning in the 2025 2026 school year a determination regarding this revision has not yet been made and is currently under review by the New York State education department this evening we we have two speakers that we would like to have uh come forward and when I call your name our first Speaker
003this evening will be Benjamin Clark speaking from the community Mr Clark you'll have three minutes to address the board thank you very much um well good evening president Simmons Commissioners members and guests my name is Benjamin Clark I am a parent of a genese Community Charter School student currently and also a recent recent graduate from genese Community Charter who now attends school of the arts I've been a lifelong resident of Rochester which is about 48 years of my 52 um and I have a lovely family and we all reside in the city of Rochester you know I want to thank you for the opportunity to speak regarding the merger of our two schools under one single chapter as you know our Flagship the genese Community Charter River Campus has been around for 20 years and
004has been dealing with 200 students on a yearly basis with the flowa city school that's going to grow to about 400 students keeping 400 students in Rochester that are all Rochester City residents as well as 400 families within the city proper is one of our major goals and one of my dreams is to see Rochester grow as individuals you know with both schools having the same mission to educate our youth through the Rochester's Rich history and focuses on Hands-On project learning my children have learned about the indigenous culture of the regional area how Rochester looked while covered in Shallow Seas how immigration occurred by going down to New York City on trips with individual classes to take a look at the tenement buildings down there learning about the Revolutionary War by going to Boston and
005taking different field studies and trips that really involve them and deeply ingrains them within the culture of America as well as Rochester and the things that came out of the city of Rochester students love the connections that they make through the rigorous teaching and learning through what we called learning Expeditions this merger would truly bring some Financial stability that we've been looking for and diversity as well by combining both schools and formalize the organizational structure that will allow the ideal management of both schools we hope will support this merger as it would be a better experience for the 400 students as well as the 400 families that reside in the city of Rochester and become students of other programs within the city of Rochester as well among many reasons for our merger one of the
006things that one of the biggest things that we're really looking at is financial stability more money can be put into students learning experiences in and out of classrooms the merger would result in better professional development model to train staff on Expeditionary Learning and curriculum the savings afforded by the merger could lead to Shared Specialized Staffing between schools create better opportunities for students that have learning needs special education develop English programs for the second Ed um for Learners that English is their second language thank you okay our next uh speaker this evening will be Colin or am I saying that correctly Mr or yes you got it thank you Mr or you'll have three minutes thank you good evening president Simmons board members and guests uh my name is Colin or I'm the proud parent of
007three genesy Community Charter students a fifth grader a third grader and a little kindergartener I'd like to speak on behalf of the school to ask you to consider this merger to ensure that more students have the opportunity to attend this great School in the future we as parents are concerned about the school's ability to provide the same quality of Expeditionary Learning for future Generations because of rising costs and harmful cuts to student per pupil funding from the state recently my son attended a field trip as Ben mentioned uh that field trip to New York City he went on this trip to learn about immigration at this critical time of division and misinformation my son's class was able to experience firsthand The Immigrant experience by going to Ells island with an immigrant's identity and backstory they
008learned how real people risk so much to pursue the American dream while this can be learned in a textbook or maybe on YouTube gccs believes that being placed in history leads to powerful lessons and Lasting Impressions that lead to first firsthand understanding then empathy if our schools were allowed to merge more resources would be available to ensure that all families including those in poverty can attend incredible trips like these these trips are expensive and our school has taken on more of the burden to make sure that all students could can attend a trip to New York or to Boston or uh to the leworth state park to see the genesy rivers Genesis and formation finally with the 1.5% percent percent cut in funding from this year from the state our school has had a reduced
009programming and Staffing our budget is currently strained as we try to maintain the quality of programming that have historically offered families with two budgets two bank accounts and two payrolls we lack the efficiency of a larger organization we need this merger to ensure that the student to teacher ratio remains low and students get the attention and support they deserve to thrive I also would Advocate on behalf of students with learning needs that they would be better served if our schools merged with a merger we could create a stronger continual support for these students gccs has served this community for 24 years I hope that by granting this merger they can continue to do this good work for many more years years to come thank you for your time and consideration thank you Mr or and
010I do not have any other speakers listed this evening so at this time this meeting is adjourned thank you e e e good evening everyone this is uh Thursday January 23rd 2025 and this is our Board of Education business meeting uh we're going to first call the or uh business meeting to order and I'd ask that um vice president Malloy uh present us with the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you the board expects District officials and the public to conduct themselves and speak in a respectful and courteous manner so as to model proper Civility and deor for students shouting personal insults vulgarity profanity attacks revealing
011information prohibited by law or any conduct that disrupts the flow of business is considered to be out of order the board May among any other steps available pursuant to law take the following actions during the meeting to maintain a fair and efficient meeting interrupt warn or terminate a participant statement when the statement exceeds a lot of time is personally directed abrasive obscene or irrelevant request any individual to leave the meeting when that individual whether in person or virtually does not observe the reasonable dequorum or the conduct interferes with the orderly progress of the meeting call For Recess or any adjournment to another time when the lack of public decorum so interferes with the orderly conduct of the meeting as to Warrant such action at this particular time I'm going to turn the mic over to
012our board clerk Miss W who is going to provide uh the Board of Education upcoming events thank you good evening president Simmons vice president Malloy Commissioners and Community for the month of February the board will open with a policy meeting on Tuesday February 4th beginning at 6 pm. on Wednesday February 5th at 5:00 p.m. the reception begins with a performance followed by an presentation of awards at 5:30 p.m. excuse me we will be celebrating our Black History Month and our Black History Month Scholars on Tuesday February 11th the board will convene for an Esa committee meeting followed by a special meeting for the consideration of resolutions and then we will conclude the month with the February 27th business meeting as a reminder to the community any individual wishing to speak to the board at any
013time may do so by contacting the board of education office by noon on the day of the meeting you may do so by phone at 585 262 8525 or via email at boardof education. rcsd.org as a reminder no unregistered speaker May address the board and no individual may speak on behalf of a registered speaker when registering to speak you must include your name telephone number home address affiliation and the topic on which you wish to speak individuals who do not reside in the city of Rochester do not have the privilege of speaking at meetings except if a exception is granted by the chair of the meeting and each registered speaker May address the board for up to three minutes and any speaker utilizing translation including American side language will be allowed to address the board
014for up to six minutes with three of those minutes being for your speaker and the remaining time for translation thank you thank you clerk W um am I looking at this uh properly I don't see any minutes attached no minutes to approve okay so we're going to move forward on our agenda and um go on our speakers portion this evening we have about four speakers that will be addressing the board this evening um are there speaker comments as well or just just in person speakers it looks like we have a couple virtually as well as a couple in person forgive me um so we're going to do that and just just to um level set when speakers are speaking to the board often times you'll notice that we're not responding and that is intentional we
015want to hear from you um and and just really absorb the information you're providing so our lack of response um is is in no form disrespect but we are allowing you to speak uh with um in full totality if that makes sense each speaker will have three minutes and I'm going to start with the first Speaker this evening which would be Maria Gonzalez hello I'm here today because uh as a community as a grandma and a mom I'm here to request the list of the person you have running from superintendent so we know as a community know who are we V voting and who are those those names okay it's not right for your guy just to choose whatever you want to choose okay we as the community as the people in the community we
016need to know before you you or your staff decide who they're going to vote for and who you guys decide for because the community have the right to understand and to vote to about the the people who you have on those list so as the Community member I want a list of those people who are running for superintendent if I got to get it from you or I can go higher thank you thank you Miss Gonzalez our next speaker will be virtually and that would be toyan Anderson okay she has not made it online just yet so we'll give her some time and move forward with our next speaker uh that would be Monica Graham thank good evening everyone can you hear me okay thumbs up can you all hear me okay oh perfect thank
017you president um good evening everyone my name is Monica Graham and I'm a parent leader as well as the current parent rep for the esa committee I have submitted a written statement for to the clerk for the board to review I will not be reading it in its entirety because if I did I'd go over the three minute allotment and I would like to respect everyone's time so I will read a portion of the statement now I understand that the board is considering dissolving the committee and as an RCS parent and Esa parent rep going on two years I'm opposed to the dissolution of this committee I have been fortunate enough to have two amazing amazing Commissioners lead this committee and I have learned so much from all of the people I've interacted with during
018my time at the esa committee I have been shown the utmost respect and consideration during the esa planning meetings as well as the monthly meetings led by President Simmons and now commissioner Santiago not only am I learning about required State education laws and decrees we have to follow I was also learning about different departments their functions and the amazing teams that keep them going I've been able to make suggestions ask questions and get answers directly from the people working in this District just as hard as me the relevant conversation and noteworthy inquiries that we have streamed to the public during the esa committee meetings will no longer happen if it's all dropped to a report the final decision to keep or dissolve the esa committee ultimately lies with this board I Echo the sentiments that
019have been shared in the public um hopefully will be shared during this meeting to keep this committee and um I feel that um strongly taking away this committee would be taking away an opportunity for parents to be at the table make suggestions ask questions and get answers directly from the people in this District who are doing the hard work my ask is that we keep this committee and continue to focus on the success and Equity of our students as the loving and devoted community that I know we all are thank you so much for listening thank you Miss Graham okay I'm going to circle back to the zoom has Miss Anderson been able to join the zoom and so we will move forward with an inperson um Community member uh Miss Lori Thomas good evening
020I'm here tonight for two reasons one to ask why I have yet to hear from the interim superintendent concerning the budget document I emailed to commissioner Patterson Patterson excuse me who told me he forward it to the interim superintendent secondly I want our parents and Community to know that according to the superintendent at the time the future for this district is another four years of failure not even meeting current New York State average scores by 2028 which are abysmal in themselves for the that reason I have applied for the position of superintendent of the Rochester City School District the community parents especially must know who has applied for this position and what the applicant's vision is for our children the community especially parents must know how closely the applicants come to meeting their requirements for
021superintendent we have the right to know who applied for position not just who was chosen from the list of applicants as well community members including parents should have the right to to interview the applicants not simply meet with the individual chosen by the board for too long our children have suffered at the hands of a district that has chosen a superintendent who is unable to meet the challenges of a failing system observing our children's gifts and talents to create success will replace the process of testing them to discover their disabilities leading to their failure as superintendent I will make sure parents are appreciated and respected for allowing us to educate their child teachers will no longer feel the pressure to comply with state standard practices and District control but we be but will be encouraged
022to explore their gifts and talents by sharing knowledge with students instead of giving students information and expecting them to regurgitate it onto a test because New York state has opened the process to a regionalised approach to education the opportunity exists for the initiation of a system of Education that will support all of the stakeholders stakeholders in the process while being beneficial to the tax payers who are tired of spending B billions on the miseducation of our children it has been proven that the montauri system of education is effective efficient and successful implementing this educational Concept in the rcsd must be done at all levels with the cart group beginning in the 2025 26 school year as students realize that the adults in their educational experience actually believe in their abilities when they are invited to
023explore their interest The Chronic absenteeism we we currently experience will Decline measurably and attendance will increase exponentially as parents realize that teachers believe in their children these stakeholders will be able to work together to discover and direct the natural abilities of the child leading to success it is up to the community espe especially parents to demand that they be made aware of who will be in charge of the system of Education that your children will be exposed to we can no longer be complacent leaving the decision to seven people as to who will lead our district and our children to success we must as a concerned Community make the choice ourselves thank you thank you Miss Thomas okay and we're going to go back up to the virtual and I it looks or appears that
024U Miss Anderson has joined us so our next speaker will be toyan Anderson okay thank you thank you so much and I apologize everyone CU I was in a room waiting I don't know what was happening so I apologize but um good evening and thank you everyone um I'm toyan Anderson and I am here this evening to speak on the esa committee and the need to have this committee to continue I am calling because I sat on this committee for about 45 years before the first pause of this commit committee and I would love to say this is the one committee I know it's also the committee that is not necessarily required but I'm going to say it is it is required and needed because this is the one committee that allows the parents and
025our community to know what's happening to be able to take the temperature to give input on what is happening in our schools what is happening with our children and I sat there as a parent representative and I had the honor of giving input perspective and ideas that were implemented received and welcomed from our CSP staff that was in the room because I firm beli that parents have to be true Partners in the process and not afterthought so we need to be at the table as decisions are being made because there's a prospective that parents brings that members of the board or the district sometimes cannot ask or Implement so our we're the ones with the live The Experience our kids are going through the process our voice needs to be heard I am asking this
026committee to please do not remove this committee because that that means to me that we we're removing the parents voice and I say that in the sense that the ability for parents in real time next to the boards elected officials that we ask to help support to make sure our district and Community is thriving removing us from being able to partner truly and give prospective as parents we need this committee to continue I was honored to serve on this committee I learned a lot and like I said it definitely helps make sure that our schools are operating at its Optimum to make sure our kids are getting what they need no it's not required by law but we should require it because we say we want to make sure children are doing well children come
027with parents and families and caregivers and our prospective is needed so please I'm asking you as a former Esa parent representative to continue to provide a space for parents to share partner and be able to give perspective on how our children future should look should be shaped and how success should look for us and our family thank you so much Miss Anderson thank you very much all have been um heard this evening and so that concludes our speakers portion of the agenda this evening thank you again we're going to move forward um and we're going to go into our advisory counsel reports uh we're going to start with Miss Hazel Roberts our student leadership Congress president hi guys you're so cute you're so cute good evening everyone the student leadership Congress held its in-person meeting
028on January 8th 2025 with students from East High Edison Tech Wilson magnet early college and the School of the Arts in attendance we are also honored to welcome commissioner Santiago as a special guest speaker who shared insights on the legislative breakfast as mentioned at as mentioned at as as mentioned at the last board meeting the school climate and culture survey for students parents and staff is open until February 3rd a quick shout out to e upper and lower for currently having the highest number of students completing the survey to date to encourage participation I've sent Robo calls to families on Mondays in an email to the student population this survey is incredibly important as it helps us gather valuable data to improve our schools and highlight the great things happening across our district so I
029urge everyone to participate your feedback matters attention seniors parents and Guardians there are so many scholarship opportunities available for students for students pursuing higher education applications are open for scholarships from the Rochester Education Foundation and the Rochester area Community Foundation and addition additionally there are many other scholarships out there so apply for every opport opportunity you're eligible for this month I had the privilege of serving as a panelist for action for a better community's youth solutions for a better Rochester event it was an amazing it was an incredible experience while I had the chance to share my perspective I also learned so much from the other youth leaders whether it was their experiences or approaches it reinforce the sheer goals we all have for our community even if our methods differ I'm looking forward to
030many opportunities like this in the future the Congress also held a follow-up meeting this month on Martin Luther King Jr day this meeting allowed us to reconnect reflect and assess our progress we discussed the legislative breakfast again the school climate and culture survey and other ways to amplify student voice we also explored potential collaborations with additional youth organizations to enhance our impact in conclusion the student leadership Congress January meetings were productive and engaging the Congress asked insightful questions that help move our initiatives forward we are very excited to carry this momentum into the second half of the Year thank you for your time and stay warm thank you Miss Roberts okay so next we have our parent leadership advisory Council I don't see a report attached there so we're going to move on to our
031by bilingual education Council and we'll hear from Miss deth president Simmons at this time I do not see Miss garia in the room the um monthly becc report is posted to board docs okay thank you and there is no report for the special education parent advisory counsel noted either so at this time um the board May convene into executive session to discuss matters leading to the appointment promotion discipline suspension dismissal or removal of particular persons and pending or current litigation with general counsel I'd like to entertain a motion to move into executive session at this time so moved motion moved by vice president Malloy uh seconded by commissioner Griffin all in favor I we are going to exit into executive session at this time e e e and thank you for your patience welcome back
032we're going to reconvene our uh board meeting this evening we're going to move forward into our board reports portion of the agenda we're going to start with our ESA committee report commissioner Santiago hello Rochester the community uh the equity and student achievement committee met as a committee of the whole on Tuesday January 14th 20125 the sa committee met to receive the 2025 through 2026 summer and EXT ed school year plan as presented by expanded learning director Alysia Thomas and special director Melissa Pitman Commissioners engaged in thoughtful dialogue related to program outcomes costs and progress monitoring Tuesday February 11th 2025 at 6m will be the next Esa committee meeting thank you thank you commissioner Santiago and and at this time I would like to entertain a motion to accept the UN audited January well no actually
033we're going to hear from let me follow the script guys we're going to actually hear from um Mike mahany who is stepping in for someone tonight that's why I didn't have your name so thank you thank you for Dereck Blair so thank you Mr mahaney for joining us this evening and he will be providing our uh financial report all right good evening president Simmons vice president Malloy Commissioners and our community at home um if you will look um first at our cash flow on page seven uh we ended uh November with $257 million in cash if you don't mind sir I'm sorry to interrupt if you could just speak into the mic a little more so we can inject a little bit thank you uh we ended November with 200 $57 million in cash uh
034in December we had $17 million in receipts and transfers $87 million leave us in dispersements leaving with $277 million um on December 31st if you could go to page seven you'll see that um our cash flow tends to be the lowest of the year in December into January we get a large payment on January 31st for from New York State and you'll see the remaining of the Year our budget or excuse me our cash is um rather High compared to previous in the year our Revenue summaries on page nine our general fund Revenue has projections has largely stayed the same we have some minor changes from the adopted versus the current budget and we've received 2 $97 million so far about onethird of our revenues um again that's pretty typical most of our funding is
035from the state and they give us our funding generally in the second half of the year if you go back to page two um on page two you will see our um special aid changes uh we received uh Afghan Refugee Grant an increased amount from our adopted budget by about 2 million addition to that about 193,000 in rollover from 2024 we also received a grant award from Monro County um for an individual to help support um youth in Justice and transferring between our County Services and our school related to that youth and Justice on the bottom of the page you'll see our projected revenues and appropriate fund balance the change from the start of the year we increased our general fund Appropriations by $12.7 million and that is 1.4% our special Aid our grants we've
036increased by $7 million or 5 a. half% and our food service is unchanged if you go to page three um page three you'll see our Appropriations by function um currently our general fund available balance is 42 million or 44% special Aid is $64 million or 47% and our food service is just under 10 million or 36% on pages 15 through 23 you'll see all the budget transfers that we made in December these are budget transfers going in and out of accounts for several reasons um at the bottom of the page you'll see our Capital fund budget summary our cash Capital remaining available balance is $31.7 million and our bond funding is just under 10 million at $9.6 million if you go to the next page uh we had one large transfer in the capital fund
037and that was $157,000 and that was to fund the purchase of 500 radios in our security department our Charter School enrollment right now on uh January 1st was 8,266 kids if our enrollment Trend continues we will have roughly a positive variance compared to our budget of $7.9 million and that detail is listed on page 37 um if you could go to the following page our or Oracle is well underway as you know our EPM which is our budgeting system is live currently we are using that to budget next year's budget our HCM H Capital Management and Erp enterprise resource management systems are currently in system integration testing um we've been in system integration testing in December all of January and then I'll conclude probably in February before we move on to user acceptance testing and
038going live on 71 and that concludes my reports if you have any questions thank you um for the for this report Mr mahany did I say that right mahany yes yes okay thank you very much it I did have a question on on page 37 So based on this the projection that you're talking talking about it look so it looks like students are there's a trend of students returning to the district from Charter does that tend to fluctuate from yeah this is typical um at the beginning of the school year before students are even with us in the summer our enrollment tends to be far lower than what we have in September and Beyond then by bed's day typ typically is our Peak and we get students returning to us in the second semester okay
039thank you I just wanted to ask that really really quick but this is great financial I'm going to start to my far right and I'm going to open up for questions um at this time commissioner Griffin um yes uh thank you for your presentation can you tell me um I don't know if this is a question you can have have answer you have for me or something that has to be further research how do we put a cap on this it seems as though you know oracle is asking for money over and over again but we're not getting a results that we need in a fast time so how do we put a cap on this so we're not we cannot continually giving money Oracle to money to Oracle is there a cap on this
040at all our delivered contract is based on deliverables uh regardless of how much time and effort it takes them so that's based on us going live not necessarily on the people hours that they have to put in to get us to go live so one one more question how does this compar to like work day that's another process in Oracle so we have Oracle we have work pay so how does I mean that's something that is different from Oracle but how is it can does oracle work somewhat like work work pay too work day too I'm sorry yeah those are all large scale Enterprise systems um there's several vendors who are Global vendors like Oracle workday um the count implementing or uh workday as we speak um so it'd be a competitor to Oracle and
041they would deliver relatively similar functions yeah it just it's just baffling me kind of that all of the other city ordinance have used work work day and we go into Oracle when we could all be talking to each other on the same platform thank you okay thank you commissioner Griffin um commissioner Patterson yes thank you um I also there was I had two questions Oracle was one of them um and as far as our our fiduciary responsibility when it comes to funding and I don't know if I'm stepping outside my role as governance when I asked you know uh Madam president can we see that contract or superintendent can we see that contract for Oracle because we're investing multi-millions that's my understanding in Oracle and there's no end date no disrespect to you you know
042I'm just asking a question but I think we need to get a handle on Oracle I don't know enough about Oracle and for me to speak educatedly relative to it to you and the superintendent asking questions I have to have a little bit more knowledge relative to Oracle so if we can have maybe in a retreat or somewhere or somehow we can discuss Oracle a little bit more in depth because you know with this Gap we're talking about $38 million gap 37 whatever it is that you know we have a responsibility to get a handle on things that from my perspective it's kind of out of hand right now it's like Oracle just keeps going and going and going I understand the importance of it and how everything's supposed to meet and talk to one
043another I I get that but you know as a board member I'm more interested in the begin date and the end date you know was there a contract for a certain amount and how much have we gone over that amount at this point in time and as my colleague said is there an end date so those are some of the questions I have maybe we can have a conversation offline or in a retreat or something like that but I or an executive session but it needs to be a conversation you know that we have the answers to the to this question secondly when it comes to radios because of Technology you know you just said you invested in I don't know how much in new radios I couldn't see it up there but um because
044of the the Chang is so rapid in technology have we looked into leasing these radios like the sheriff's department does like the RPD does like the state police does have we looked into leasing them opposed to purchasing them because the advancement in technology and radio waves and all that other stuff that comes into place towers and you know what works better you know oec the office of emergency communications you know they all lease radios in a place of purchasing so I guess that's a question for you too yeah the radios we purchase are for individual sites so you will have a radio at you know a particular high school and and it'll be able to reach their athletic fields everywhere inside the premise they aren't radios that like a police department would be you know
045reaching you know Citywide or countywide um so these are individually you know 340 bucks something like that they're not a whole lot of money where you would necessarily be looking to do long-term leases on them but I I don't know to answer your question I don't know that we'd necessarily have looked into it but this is pretty typical for radios that we need to span the distance that we are yeah so again in cost-saving measure you know those are something someone should be doing looking into it and saying hey can we save here is it you know are we going to save in the long run because of advancement in technology and things like that so I want to become more I would hope this entire board will want to become more proactive relative to
046reactive that's all you know thank you commissioner Patterson um no no questions from commissioner Santiago at this time um I do want to just level set the conversation around Oracle just a bit because I do recognize that as Commissioners um I believe if if I'm not mistaken and we can always call that a question as far as um voting on Oracle we kind of initiated the contract by voting on it um and so we did get that contract going um and these are funds covered by they're covered by arpa Oracle covered by arpa funds am I correct okay so so everyone and voted yes and had received some information I do also want us to make sure we're looking at the updates and reports on how Oracle is moving forward right now um but I
047do think we can have some follow-up conversation uh vice president Malloy did you have anything uh thank you so much for your presentation and um it fantastic great information and glad to see things are are moving forward um but two others points just I'm sure it would be beneficial from any board members to understand Pro procurement and and how that works uh in the future thank you again all that information is available though um if we just ask for it other questions from the day at this time um yes commissioner LeBron yeah I just wanted to quickly um talk about Oracle as well and to your point the board voted on this we do get Oracle reports but this is not going to be unfortunately a cheap solution for the district because previous boards did
048not upgrade the systems and part of this system have this particular system rcsd being inefficient working on outdated um systems and that is part of the issue unfortunately and it impacts our finances it's impacted Accounting in the past it's impacted being able to process payroll in a much faster approach um and so I do look forward but I just would like the public to understand that as Commissioners we voted on this we got the information we get monthly and quarterly updates on Oracle uh we definitely get presentations from our chief of of Information Systems um and it but and lastly you know it's it's ex I'm just going to say I'm frustrated that we have Commissioners who get this information and then ask questions like they don't know what the hell's going on and it's
049extremely frustrating especially given the times of ignorance in this country that we're fighting um that our own board members who probably voted on this I'm going to pull up that resolution and see which one of the Commissioners voted on it um and then don't understand the impact of it and as someone who has worked in large systems both MCC and Rochester Regional Health when they merge with unity that we're dealing with that level of system integration and change and upgrades that is not something quick and easy and it will take us years even to get all of our staff on board all of our staff trained it is not a quick turnaround so I just want the public to also understand that when we're making this level of change yes it's going to cost us
050because we should have did it 20 years ago and we should have kept up with the times but also it is going to take time it is not something that is going to be quickly done um an oracle is cloud-based so hopefully in the future this District never has to live in ancient times with technology thank you thank you commissioner LeBron uh commissioner Elliot did you have any statements or question yes thank you so um going back to the cash on hand I see that as 277 million wasn't it last month 285 million um or what you know what was it last year seems like this is a decrease and I'd like to know why that is probably due to timing of our grants last year we were getting a lot of revenue from ARP
051no you spent something because you had 285 last last month I believe superintend you want to yeah I can if you can pull but I see on hand it's it's 277 million uh for this month commissioner Ellie can you direct them to the page you're looking at sir superintendent can also grab that in the beginning of the page are you on page seven or wherever you have where is this cash on hand 277 million I had my uh sheet on another uh I do see a 277 277 million on page one potentially I'm I'm not sure let me yeah let me go back let me let me deal okay thank you all right he had mentioned um you had mentioned 277 million but I also saw it on of the pages so um there's a
052decrease of that yeah um the dispersements were 87 million in the month leaving us with 277 remaining yeah it's on page one yeah so I guess my question is and maybe I'm don't understand it well but we had budgeted for um different items that we on dispersements so there was 287 million and then there is um 277 million so I what I'm thinking is if there were dispersements that that would be a wash um according to the budget and so I'm thinking you know unless there's you know some decrease in terms of uh investment rates or something to that effect that we still should have 285 million uh in our cash on hand unless I'm not understanding something is that 287 million you're speaking of our a Cas we had it so U Mr mahany
053she's talking about the very first page total dispersements 87 M 364,000 and she's asking um where was the subtraction where did that subtraction actually take place if you if you can't answer that then what we'll do is direct it to the question log and bring it to uh commissioner I guess what I'm saying is is that I don't want us spending that money if we don't have to I'm real concerned about that just because we have it on hand we don't know what's going to happen in the future and I want everybody to be cognizant of that that we are spending judiciously um because we don't know what's going to happen in the future and so you know this is not a pot where we can just you know spin now uh we have to
054be very judicious about um our resources so uh if you can check on that for me I'd appreciate it then the 87 million is made up of $54 million in accounts payable I didn't say 87 285 million at at one point I don't know if it was last month or the month before but we had on hand cash on hand around 285 you could you could research that um my point is Mr superintendent I just want us to be judicious in terms of how we spend money we don't have it we can't afford to just topend it recklessly that's my concern ab and then um and and then my next question is bed's day when you talked about the charter schools um because uh if they if they're the charter the beds day is the
055the determining factor of how uh money is uh uh received right and so they make sure that they have a high uh enrollment rate on beds day but then they're bringing them back to the district and so I just want to put that on record that um This truly is about money for those those it's not about uh that they really want to educate our kids but it's about the money that they can receive and so I just want us to be mindful of that and take and make sure that we're taking uh notice of that that on bed's day you know they make sure they have the students in but then afterwards they're sending them back to the city school district and that really is unfair but that's not for you it's just I'm
056just talking thank you thank you commissioner Elliott and so not only are they sending them back after bedday when they do send them back the data and maybe lack of uh performance gets counted with the district as well I'm going to give the mic to superintendent Strickland at this time um just um good evening again I I would like to say that you all are having great conversations around the financial report uh just quickly we are not allowed to pull out of the fund balance uh without a board resolution so to make that very 285 the numbers just the numbers just happen to be close and as Mr mahaney was going to say that 87 million uh actually has like all of our bills our payroll our you know just day-to-day operations which is why
057you see the de oh then I misspoke this cuz so the 287 285 milon still is a general correct thank you correct fun balance so um we also need our state monitor to get approval to yes for those transfers to just to be very clear then uh also wanted to let you know a little bit about the charter school payments so even if uh students are returned back to the district the district has set up payments to Charter Schools quarterly so that we do not lose out on uh ample amounts of money uh if in fact a student is returned to the district which does happen uh tends to happen after bed day all right thank you uh Mr superintendent thank you okay so we're GNA um going to stick to my left and then
058I'll end at my right and I'm going to go with um vice president Malloy at this time thank you and uh Dr Strickland just to piggyback on what you were saying about Charter Schools yes can it take or it's my understanding at least that to reconcile those funds it can take sometimes up to a year or longer to get those monies back uh very much so um that's why we have to be judicious and we went to a quarterly uh type system so that we it actually makes it easier to um collect those funds that uh may have been dispersed in the event that they came back closer to certain cut off dates so that is the the reconciliation process is AIT that's a part of part of the reconciliation process it also um has
059to do with uh the amount of special education services that have been provided uh as that is the district's responsibility at times sometimes English language Learners you know just various components that we're still responsible for uh we're also responsible for transportation as you know Food Service um uh various things that um go into proc challenges thank you okay thank you and so uh commissioner Patterson then we'll end with commissioner graph and if we can do like one question here a quick question for you and then commissioner Griffin and we'll move on to the next yes sir y so I never received the answer response relative to my question um you know with uh the request to to see the contract for Oracle no one supplied me with an answer relative to that uh Council really
060quick can you uh can you weigh in on uh what the what is the procedure around wanting to see a contract that has gone before the board but it's still I mean you know we have the information I mean we uh the district can provide that to the commissioner VI the question lock um uh fully executed uh contracts are are public record to the degree that they're not um conf certain confidential terms that we have to keep confidential certain proprietary information uh um uh of of an organization uh that would put them at a a competitive or legal disadvantage but um that we we can make that available to the commissioner so that would need to be redacted and it's some and the contract went forward based on our vote and support absolutely there there
061are authorizing resolutions for um for the contract and for any amendments uh to the contract um but that information can be provided to the to the commissioner so that will be a yes we can have access to the contract it's in the question log and put that in the question log for me a request has been entered GFF with you one question and we're we're done with this um thank you president Simmons um I understand first of all that the Oracle contract was approved and the money was coming that came out of ARA correct is that that correct okay so I guess the the question is um and and I think it's from me and my colleague to the left of me was basically when there's things when there's extra money that needs to be
062given where's that money coming from to Commissioners to commissioner uh uh Elliot's point we don't want to use money from the general fund balance so where's that money coming from it was a concern that we have we don't want to keep spending money and and so how we what are we doing with that money what where's that money coming from from Oracle when they're asking for more more dividends can that be answered so so the three large um transfers or the three large amounts that you the board voted on for Oracle were all under art funds those all came to the board of education to actually vote on those items the last one being right before I took office on July 1st you voted on uh Oracle resolution right uh on June something 2024 um
063if in in the event and and I will say that I've been extremely uh been extremely judicious with Oracle executive leadership team my team can all ATT test to being involved in that process bringing them to the table to understand where we are in the process and making sure things are moving along for a go live date of July 1st um so that we are not providing any additional funds to that um to them uh that definitely has happened in the event that more money would need to be used uh that is not for regular ongoing operating maintenance that would have to go to the board or that would have to come to board for your approval but at this time I do not intend on uh needing to do that okay so all the
064money that is used that we have for from Oracle from arpa are already used and as part of the the money that we're still giving them so we're not giving any money out of any type of General funds for additional funds needed for for Oracle is the concern so we're we're we're good there is that correct we are good there um after so then after we go live in July uh we will have to budget every year for just regular operating cause um which is what any uh type of system uh you would need to do that with any type of system just for ongoing maintenance um support um but some of some of their support is actually included within the contract so they don't just leave uh but again we have to Contin to
065budget some funds to add to sustain and and make sure we don't actually fall into this boat that we we're currently in which was being so Antiquated that it has taken an inal amount of time to get it off the ground okay thank you for the answer thank you I appreciate that thank you superintendent Strickland commissioner Griffin for your question and I encourage everyone to just take a look at some uh past Oracle resolutions that we all collectively passed I believe and it'll give you some um information and then also pay uh attention to the updates that come and I think they may be weekly if I'm not mistaken so that'll give us some updates and help us maintain a pulse on some of the concerns we have Mr mahaney I truly appreciate you your
066time and patience and thank you thank you oh we got to vote on this thank you but thank you for your um presentation this evening on the financial report at this time I'd like to entertain a motion to uh pass the financial report or accept this financial report second okay moved by vice president Malloy seconded by commissioner Santiago all in favor I I passes okay we're still in the report section we're going to we going to move forward okay at this particular time we're just going to join uh going to a brief president's report um and just sharing a brief Vision which is just for us to Prior continue to prioritize our students in every decision we make ensuring that our actions consistently serve in their best interest anywhere they Place their feet on this
067world stage they should Thrive and our responsibility is to create the conditions for them to do so so I'm currently navigating the onboarding process um I do want to state that I am committed to maintaining stability and evaluating our work as a board um in alignment with the student outcomes Focus governments model and the practices presented um in its best fit I'm energized uh by the opportunity to support and Lead this particular work an update for the community and the board as well of course we know that we are working in partnership with haa on our superintendent search um so far we have had some Community engagement sessions um on behalf by haa who's helped shape leadership profiles and used to assess candidates qualifications and again this was under the guidance of Dr Joseph at
068High the board will uh proceed with the next steps of the interview process and we will be sure to keep the community updated as we um proceed leadership meetings in collaboration with the administration we are re restructuring the weekly leadership meetings and additional information will be shared soon if Commissioners have any recommendations please feel free to reach out to me or board clerk when and we will take those into consideration to ensure that we have a a collective understanding and um agreement on how these leaders ship meetings can be shaped Community School visits uh the black coat ceremony for school number nine was attended I don't have a date in front of me and I'm not recalling it right now but it was a wonderful wonderful ceremony to watch our babies uh receive their black
069coats um also I did attend the Rochester Building Trades Council luncheon other meetings and events uh meeting with uh mayor Evans Rochester joint schools construction board a meeting with the state Monitor and fiscal consultant one-on-one with general counsel and a few other meetings and so as I shape and gain understanding of this particular role I will keep you all updated and of course I'm working very closely with superintendent Strickland at this time that concludes the okay we're going to move into our superintendent's report yes thank you great evening president Simmons vice president Malloy fellow Commissioners community staff families and most importantly our students I am excited to bring you a very important uh very important updates regarding our facilities modernization project and school configuration as well as my January report updates so we are beginning
070uh we are in the beginning phases of phase number three of our facilities modernization plan uh this includes uh School number nine which is our Martin Luther King Jr School Wilson commencement uh High School Edison East Padilla and finally our Douglas campus they are all included in our phase three of the facilities modernization plan um I'm bringing this report to you because additional swing space uh identified as critical has been identified as critical for project needs we are bound by uh different rules and expectations to get these projects done by a little after 2030 and it calls for uh some shifting in the um in the spaces of our students in this District um there's plans uh that have been developed to optimize resources while prioritizing Student Success so we want to be very clear
071uh Student Success is at the Forefront I want to remind uh you all and the public that our current operating capacity is 35,9 36 uh students um our current enrollment is 22,100 students uh that are in the Rochester City School District even uh and that's about 61% of uh operating uh capacity and that as as of two days ago even if we were pull even if we were able to pull all of our students back back from Charter we would still be not operating at capacity so I want to uh continue to uh bring those data to the forfront uh again 61% occupancy so as stated before there's additional uh facilities modernization plan swing space that are needed and there have been various con uh various uh options that were to be considered uh in
072this process um this swing space that we need uh which was identified by the plan the FMP plan in its uh originality was to have Jefferson uh high schools serve as swing space for schools that are being modernized um so in order to do that we needed to be be able to ensure that uh Jefferson had uh did not have or excuse me had available space uh for those schools that uh need to be modernized we had two different options uh because as you may know uh that Jefferson is occupied by uh the Andrew Langston Middle School as well as uh the Rochester International Academy program and uh we again as said stated before need that space for a swing space so that we can move another school into that space so that we are
073able to uh begin the construction we also could uh choose to close uh a school uh Northwest Middle School at the Douglas campus um would close at the end of the 2425 school year and the Andrew Langston Middle School would move to the Douglas campus um continuing to look at that footprint as uh I made mention a few uh slides ago we see that we're still currently over uh capacitated uh we have a lot of space and not enough students to fill in that space and that is u in particular in the Northwest Zone uh so I just want to be very clear on that uh next slide please so I am bringing a recommendation forward uh which would uh not be acted upon until the February board business meeting uh which would be to
074close the Northwest Middle School at the Douglas campus uh at the end of the 24 25 school year and we would be moving Andrew Langston which is currently at the Jefferson campus over to the Douglas campus where that will be its final home uh this summer of 2025 so that Jefferson can serve as swing space as it was originally intended to next slide we have various criteria uh that are that are in line uh that have caused us to uh come up with the need to continuously work on uh reducing the district's footprint uh our 2024 29 through 29 strategic plan goals uh really uh talk about improving student achievement and that also means putting high quality teachers in front of students um we we do have substitute teachers that are PDM which they are
075very great uh but you know we all know that uh we need uh folks that are identified as highly qualified in front of our students at all times uh this is good for long-term financial planning we have to maintain some stability in our finances as we have done uh for the past few years and uh it is my responsibility to ensure that that continues to happen uh I need to remind uh everyone on the day and the public that we do have an academic and a financial plan that really guides the work that I am supposed to lead uh each and every single day and uh these are the recommendations that are in the academic and financial plan that actually call for uh things that are could be U rivered as uh more drastic in
076nature which means closing schools next slide we also continue to look at the district capacity and the utilization uh so again we are still 61% enrolled only that means 39% of of our space is not being used and finally we have school accountability status Northwest junior high was the only Middle School that was not uh that did not really undergo any changes during reconfiguration it is a school that is of CSI status and looking at the data at Northwest Middle School or Northwest junior high on the northeast side of Rochester um we have seen some decreases in the English language art scores and there is a possibility of running into a receivership risk uh whereas Andrew Langston has just been opened uh the at the start of the 2425 school year uh they would simply
077be taking their beds code from the Jefferson campus and having their beds code now live at the Douglas campus here is how the new footprint would look uh for the start of the 2526 school year and the only two changes here would be uh that the Northwest Zone would only have one uh Middle School uh where students would attend and that's the third Good Marshall uh Middle School at the charlot campus and the second ch is just showing that East lower would no longer be a Citywide option but it is in fact a school in our most populous Zone which is the Northeast section of uh the city of Rochester as for student transitions really really wanted to take into account how does this impact our Scholars our our students um because they are uh
078the reason why we do this work um and how can we minimize the disruption uh as as much as possible so current Andrew Langston seventh graders uh they can finish their middle school years at the new Andrew Langston Middle School which would be at the Douglas campus or they can remain in their Zone and attend the thurg Good Marshall Middle School so we are giving those current seventh graders that will be eighth graders next school year the option as to which school they would like to attend secondly current Northwest seventh graders those are the students that are seventh graders at the Northwest Middle School will be remaining at the Douglas campus just as Andrew Langston Middle School students because that's where that's what uh that's the place that will holds the beds hold the beds
079code for Andrew Langston and then all incoming seventh graders which are our current sixth graders they are they have not been affected uh they are currently in their pre kindergarten through sixth grade schools if they are in the Northwest they would all simply uh be attending the uh thir Good Marshall Middle School or they would be attending uh a Citywide if they need to or if they uh are accepted or they choose to excuse me so the next steps it is extremely important for me to uh have a conversation with the Northwest Community um I definitely uh will be there uh my myself and my team uh to take copious notes to ensure that their voices are have been heard and after uh hearing all the various notes and thinking about the plan that has
080been put forth which is very important to gather uh both uh students and and family voices as well as staff voices um you will have a finalized plan uh brought to you on February 27th of this uh of next month which is at the board business meeting I am now going to quickly move into uh just a few remaining slides and then open it up to president Simmons and the rest of the Commissioners for questions uh just a reminder the school selection process uh for students who are going into grades kindergarten 7th and 9th grade next September uh this process is completely online um and the deadline is February 21st 2025 and families can access this information excuse me the school selection information at rcsdk12.org school selection I want to give a big shout out
081to Messiah Hampton James Monroe High School Jr for earning a spot in the exclusive Nike the next one's athlete Invitational talk about next level Talent Messiah Got His official invite at the Buffalo Bills game go bills and will be heading to New Orleans during the Super Bowl week in February and I would definitely chaperone that trip uh this is huge he will see behind the scenes actions from one of the biggest events in sports and show off his skills in a competition with 31 other top ath leetes from across the country Monroe is the Jewel of the city and we cannot wait to see Messiah make it shine even brighter all right I hope you will join us for a celebration with our students and families next month when we recognize Black History Month each
082year we recognize students for their exceptional academic accomplishments community service and Leadership this year's celebration will take place Wednesday February 5th at 5:30 p.m. right here in conference room 3 a3b at central office this is a wonderful opportunity to celebrate the rich cultural contributions that have shaped our society January is School Board recognition month and I want to thank all of our commissioners for all of the hard work you do on behalf of our students families and staff I am grateful for your partnership and appreciative of your collaboration on the important work we do throughout the course of the year I know that together we will make significant strides to continue to improve our district and with that being said uh that concludes my presentation I'm open to questions thank you superintendent strickler open to
083questions are there any questions at this time so Mr superintendent um in terms of OT in terms of um um Place uh enrollment and placement yes um and I heard you talk about the reconfiguration and that we have just 60% capacity yes um I'd like to see us to be able to do a some kind of plan about recruiting more students in our district and so that way we don't have to turn schools back to the city buildings back to the city and um I just think that we're having some great programs in great time to be in the Rochester City School District so if there is an opportunity not that just we open it up and we receive them but that we're being assertive about a plan to recruit them offering them uh some
084of the um opportunities that we have in this District so absolutely uh that's uh that would be one of my number one missions is to ensure that we don't lose students and that we are able to gain uh one of the practices uh in my former District that I've been fortunate to be a part of is to replicate programs that are successful and that are in high demand and that's something that we need to do to order in order to open up more spaces for our students and to provide more access to high quality programs but most importantly we need to ensure that all of our programs and facilities are of high quality um and serve our parents and students uh well thank you thank you uh commissioner Griffin for me I guess my biggest
085problem is um the instability of the district when we knew prior to the reconfiguration that we were going to this was on the Forefront um uprooting our kids again and again in uring the instability is a big problem for me when we could have possibly made a difference prior to in the reconfiguration yes I agreed to the reconfiguration ation I did but I know better I do better and and knowing how how it has put um our children and our parents in such a big a big um disadvantage bothers me and here we go again so I have a big concern about this this project that you have presented here today in reference to the remodern isation and the reconfiguration of this District I have big concerns and i' and I've expressed them and I
086will continue to express them I think this needs to be Revisited I think that we other people need to be at the table um I don't know who put this together but I'm very frustrated for everyone involved outside that's outside listening because this is something that we cannot continue to do and uproot our kids and not showing them stability I I don't agree with this at all I do not agree with any step of this process thank you commissioner Griffin um did you want to respond um so I definitely understand commissioner uh ring your concerns uh that's probably you know at the Forefront of not wanting to move uh students you don't want a disrupt learning environments I just want to remind you I mean again the current operating capacity is 35,9 36 students if
087we were to bring all of our charter school students back we would be above 30 30,000 um and and it's all together because of the fact that those are all the students in the city of Rochester I just wanted to make mention however um space is needed to help continue to modernize our facilities throughout uh the district I mentioned School number nine Wilson Magnet High School uh East Edison uh the Douglas campus those are all being modernized so we need to make moves of those uh spaces uh so that we can use Jefferson as swing space and last but not least uh one of the things that my predecessor continuously said um is that you know the large reconfiguration that happened last year that was a a great step in the right direction however we
088need to be sure that we are going to uh continue to look at The District's footprint and uh that was that is what is consistently being done and according to our academic and financial plan okay I just want to I just want to finalize this with this what I'm saying to you I understand the kids need to be moved when I when I'm in a disagreement with so the public knows what I'm in disagreement with I'm in I'm for remodelation that's not what I'm saying so let's make that very clear but this if you ask me with our budget in the way it's been in the past it should have been done years ago so that's not my problem my problem is closing the school um and and then changing the name changing it to
089something that I feel like Frederick Douglas should stay Frederick Douglas cuz he's he's an upstanding person in this community so I don't think we should be changing having Andrew Lon go over there and stay at Frederick Douglas I don't think that should that should happen and I think I voiced that I don't think that should happen so I just want the public to know I'm not talking about the remodern and the movement of the schools I'm talking about any closure of a school and I'm talking about the renaming of the school and the and the fact that we did a reconfiguration that I feel again that was bad and and changing with all this room that we have all these square footage at Jefferson 270,000 ft 76,000 or 72,000 ft at at Douglas we're always
090these schools are Staples in our community and we need to make sure that we're that we're doing the right things and I don't feel Marshalls out there we could use Marshall as a swing school too that was in amercas before so for me for me what we've done in the past is affecting our children's future and that was one the remod the reconfiguration program from last year that's what I'm referring to let's make that clear all right thank you commissioner Griffin uh superintendent Strickland are are you all set yeah I'm a okay thank you so much are there any questions um uh commissioner Patterson and I'm just going to move my way back in this way yes thank you madam president um I just want to make sure that um you know we're all clear
091as a team right so I I do mention some things but I never mentioned things to cause an argument or a disagreement between us but you know I just do it for clarity so one thing I want to make sure what our priority is and if I'm wrong I hope someone on this board would tell me but um you know there's just some mention relative to uh where' I put it at now um well let me just get into it um oh uh increased student uh enrollment that's not our number one priority and that shouldn't be our number one priority to increase student enrollment our priority should be student outcomes and if I could just hear that you know more often that that's our priority because we can't again uh bring students back um when
092we're having problem with kids reading on grade level when we're having you know our kids aren't graduating on time or they aren't college or career ready so you know that's just something that I think we have to speak more of and I I would hope we would you know speak more of student outcomes being the priority and then everything else you know after that you know so I just want to put that out there thank you very much thank you commissioner Santiago yeah I just want to say um um that I know that you plan to start connecting with the community um but just to emphasize on making sure that you are talking to the parents and the students um really emphasizing on that of course the staff and and all that but but the
093parents and the students are the ones that get affected uh academically when it comes to to these kind of transitions um and part of me you know originally is is like you know there's enough transitions going on in this District but also knowing the historic uh connection to the facilities modernization plan um knowing that since this plan has been created for so many years that it's going to go into to it's going to be executed now and there's going to have to be Transitions and we got to make decisions that can mitigate as much instability as possible because the the reality is with with these facilities being modernized which needs to happen it also requires for us to move students around and so we can mitigate the instability as much as possible um and and
094make sure that we're supporting these children as they go into a new school as transitions are happening it's important but I have no strong standings on this until I you know parents and students are spoken to um as I do know the all the different aspects that's um that's applied in this this conversation superintendent Strickland y uh very very great points um both uh commissioner Patterson definitely um when you talk about student outcomes I'm I'm the number one fan and making sure that we do keep student outcomes at the Forefront uh it was just unfortunate for the sake of this presentation was just bringing in that as a caveat uh to um why we need to continue to reduce uh unfortunately so but definitely noted uh commissioner Santiago great points I I do want to
095let you know that last year uh I was able to almost attend every single uh student and family uh meeting of of a school that was being closed or moved or what have you and I'm even going to make uh a make an appearance with that staff uh as I do have a a deep connection with them I was a former School chief of that school and it would behoove me to get in front of them and and really gather their feedback and and provide my explanation as to what it is that uh caused these this decision to be brought forth by me and uh I can just assure you that that will definitely happen um The Hope is that guess what phase three is not the last phase we still want to continue to
096modernize our facilities and and with additional funding hopefully years down the line we'll be in phase four uh there's been other Big Five school districts that have been uh going through you know or been able to go through four phases uh so the goal would be that this is an ongoing process and unfortunately students would have to be uh disrupted by getting moved uh fortunately we do have two schools that are large enough where they don't have to move uh that being East and Edison they can stay in place while different portions of their school are actually being renovated and then the other schools that do have to move um uh Padia being one which they are the ones that are moving into Marshall uh because of the size of the student population and uh
097with Douglas and MLK number n one of our large elementary schools those are uh schools that have to move because they are getting intense gut type Rehabilitation done to their uh campuses uh so again we try as much as possible not to rupt our students is about our students first unfortunately um you have to you know go through the pain to get to the glory uh if you will thank you superintendent Strickland yeah I remember being at East High School with the Inception of the EPO and I think they were going under renovation then it was a gut and there was enough of the hallway where they were able to kind of break it off and then I've been at other schools and you have to consider special students safety so recognized students have to
098move for just for a point of clarity for me the Andrew Langston um School moving to the Douglas campus it would then if that were to occur if that were to move forward it would the name of the school would be Andrew Langston at Douglas C or yes absolutely that that campus is the namesake of Frederick Douglas um so it would simply be Andrew Langston Middle School at the Frederick Douglas campus uh so that is not going away um and again we're we're we're not closing the camp and actually they're at the tail end of the modernization uh so that school will emulate truly um you know inside and out and I'm not just talking about uh I'm talking about the physical um what Frederick Douglas stands for and um I'm excited about that Madam
099president I'm sorry okay I'm going to finish my questions and then I I'm going to move over here commissioner ell I did hear you ma'am I will um call on you in just a moment um I was going to ask you about um so uh I think the sentiments might have been expressed around the school closures we had the reconfiguration a lot of schools and there has been a lot of transition and change I do Echo commissioner Santiago's points around engaging families making you know seeing where they are as you've already stated I'm wondering if you have a pulse on I mean you know when does it stop type of thing right so do is this the fin yeah piece so I mean I I want to take you back to slide number three 61%
100of our spaces are taken up so that's 39% of our facilities are not at full strength or full usage it stops when student achievement or student outcomes increase it stops when enrollment increases and um it starts I mean that's that's in a sense what we have to do uh unfortunately so what you know in terms of last year so many schools were uh closed or moved at at one time these are things that should be consistently looked at and reassessed year after year and all of our large city district friends are also going through similar systems and they're actually looking at Rochester for what we've done and accomplished last year and how they can do it in their cities I will say though that until that 61% starts getting upwards to 85% or 90% so
101on and so forth um we w we will have to continue to look at efficiencies um yes because right now we have a budget that's paying for space that's not even needed so understood thank you um commissioner uh vice president Malloy there we go yes yeah thank you so much and first and foremost um you know a lot of this these things are the difficult decisions that in the coming years this board will have to make but for this particular decision yes I know I have a lot of reservations and concerns um but I want to say I understand operating capacity and how you know at 61% we can't continue down that road um it's not sustainable um and I understand the rationale behind everything and I understand our need for swing space as we
102go through the FMP updates um our declining enrollment all of that I get it I just I'm very disappoint pointed as we move in One Direction with our strategic plan our reconfiguration um I don't know that I thought that that was the end all necessarily but we had plans set and like so many things in our district now we're we're kind of switching those plans kind of along the way um and again I understand the rationale but I am really concerned for all of these students and all of those those families I'm disappointing I'm disappointed because it looks like we're moving in One Direction with the reconfiguration and it hasn't been fully implemented but now we're making these changes and I'm concerned about the impact on students and families especially when we look at our
103fourth goal um these are middle school students and our fourth goal is to increase the number of students earning five or more credits in nth grade from 70% up to 90% by June of 2028 my concern is on the academic impact that these transitions could potentially have and again I understand why we need to make tough decisions but I'm very concerned about this high-risk population Middle School is a horrible time for everyone huh myself included was awful um but students and families really need to feel like they are part of uh what's happening um and we've just gone in One Direction and I worry how the students and families are going to feel about having Gone In One Direction and now there's this big change for them thank you commissioner Malloy commissioner Elliot so this
104is where um a strategy for increasing enrollment comes into play if we've got 39% a v a vacancy rate of 39% it would seem to me as opposed to us being reactionary that we would be proactive and that we would go after uh students who are in some of these like our charter schools and bring those students back and so um I don't want us to just to be reactionary I want us to be assertive and aggressive and to go out and to recruit students for the Rochester City School District I think that we have an opportunity to be able to tell our story and I think if we told our story we don't tell our story well but that if we told our story I believe that we would have an opportunity to increase
105um student enrollment and we would not have to uh close the buildings um I I I I need to have some energy around Us increasing uh student enrollment that's got to be a a a priority um to reduce um uh just the vacancy rate um in this District uh and again I say we offer some wonderful programs and to mitigate all of the different changes and stuff all of the changes um in terms of um space uh seems to me the logical thing to do is to look at how can we enroll more students um in our schools we've got some great programs and so um I will say that I I want it to be a two-prong appro approach not that we're just closing school I understand the you know the cost of that
106but can we um mitigate that by increasing student enrollment and I don't hear uh and you know this is from you know all the other um you know previous superintendent about um enrollment I know that the um the birth rate is going down I understand that but we got charter schools that got 8,000 of our students that we can recruit from and so that's what I'm looking at that we become competitive and uh we bring those students back that way we can mitigate having to uh close schools but I also I would also say um that it it um the naming of schools that we have named these schools and now we're sort of reconfiguring these schools you know Andrew langst to at frederck Douglas it it can get it's long and it can get
107um cumbersome and so we've got to I believe figure out another way in which um to do that I mean if there's a Frederick Doug Douglas School there got to be a Frederick Douglas school if there is an Andrew Langster school there needs to be an Andrew Langster school so we we we got to do better at that uh Mr superintendent um because that can be it can be convoluted um and also convoluted for the community thank you okay and then there's a difference between a campus and then the school name too right okay before we move forward I do want to um move to the the zoom screen thank you and and that would be commissioner LeBron and then I would like to hear from the state monitor commissioner LeBron yeah I don't have
108any uh comments at this time I think it's going to require the superintendent to go out and speak to the school Community thanks yeah but before you get to the state monitor if I can just interject here you had mentioned about where there's a difference between the school and the campus what do you mean by that yeah so when there's when the schools are named the naming of a school is one thing and I believe that has to go through like a state protocol or what have you but the campus the name of the campus stays so when I mentioned the for example the uh Andrew Langston that's the name of a school they're going to go to the Douglas campus so but I hear your point about the re um right and I don't
109want to get I don't want my point to get missed by what you said wor because it's still convoluted and we're playing we can play games with that and that's not and that's what I don't want to have happen that we're playing games with these names I mean we have this board has uh and other boards have identified um these names and I just think that we need to be um uh what's the word I'm looking for um truthful then that's not the word about naming these schools and not to you know get caught up in this in this gaming um you know people have come to us and ask about you know these certain names and then when we have to close schools that that becomes problematic and and I want us to be
110I want us to be ethical authentic about this and that we can communicate this um to the public without trying to without the games that can be perceived yes absolutely okay so stay monitor did you want to weigh in thank you president Simmons for giving me the opportunity uh closing a building is never an easy thing to do and especially here in Rochester after uh the plan that was submitted last year by the superintendent that was approved by the board and at that time I recall that the superintendent said that you know it is only the beginning because I mean there's the opportunity to close more buildings it is something that uh talking to other Commissioners they have said that you know this should have been done many years back since we began to lose
111enrollment in the district since we begin to see uh uh the birth rate going down like uh commissioner Elliott said so it is necessary we talk about you know and it's one of the recommendation and the academic plan about a campaign to get kids back into the district which is important but it's also important that we focus on student outcomes if we see the graduation rate going up if we share about the academic programs that we have in the district at all Level Elementary Middle High School we should be able to attract some people back into the district people talk about reputation people talk about programs and the things that we need to do but if we work together if if we engage the community if we Engage The stakeholders we should be able to
112move the agenda forward renovating buildings with students in the building is not easy being there done that it's not easy sometimes you have to split buildings into different locations in order to get the work done because if you're going to renovate a building with the students in there it's going to take longer to get the work done so it is a great proposal it is something that will save the money in the future for the district and that's one of the reason why the district has a monitor because uh there was some Financial constraints in the past so things that needs to be done and as a board not as a commissioner we need to work together to continue to support the students families and staff in the Rochester City School District thank you so
113very much com um I'm actually going to end with commissioner Malloy at this time and I was what I'm after we've um hear that a final question or comment I'm going to ask that all additional comments go into the question log of this this is very important very important it's it's a it's a idea that that I'd like to really put out there if you would okay I'll allow me please um 30 seconds but I'm going to do that after I go with commissioner Malloy sure thank you um so with this potential uh restructuring what are the associated cost savings with this proposal I think that that's something that we definitely need to know as Commissioners by making this type of disruption in our students and familes lives what what's the best so uh that's
114a fantastic question I I'm just going to be uh honest on this day as I did not want to lead necessarily with numbers per se um because these are our students our babies are they're human and I really understand the attachments that they have to their buildings and such I'm sorry um sorry um but we're talking about upwards to $1.3 million um and that's you know Staffing classrooms to contractual rates uh that's uh you know making sure again um reducing the footprints of our uncertificated teachers uh getting those students in front of certificated teachers um I don't want to make assumptions at this time however the Andrew Langston staff is smaller than the Northwest staff there's possibilities of uh some coexisting U just being honest there may be very little disruption because of the amount
115of perdum substitutes that we have in classrooms and those students are going to be afforded uh a high quality instructor uh I've been to both campuses I've seen those teachers in action and it can be an exciting time for actually like to bring them together actually uh to bring the amount of certificated teachers together so that each of those students have a high quality teacher in front of them uh so yes we're looking at upwards initially of 1.3 uh million but again there's no cost on our kids and and the stability and whatnot which is why I did not want to lead with that um but I am thinking about the future of this district and um what we need to do in order to get our facilities modernized so does that address in terms
116of that amount that you mentioned does that that addresses vacancies versus are Bonafide or actual vacancies I mean I would say both and uh so you know we we do have Bonafide vacancies and we have vacancies and the vacancies are the ones with non-certificated teachers in them and the Bonafide vacancies are no one's there we got to find a sub each day um I even pulled the numbers just to just to do a random check and both schools combined have 15 individuals that are vacant that are not there and this definitely will continue to help it's not just about the footprint but it's also about the reduction in the teaching force uh that we have to be extremely mindful of I'm not worried about any you know reduction in force uh as we have various
117vacancies that are both vacant and Bonafide uh through throughout the district so these individuals will be uh teaching uh somewhere hopefully it is the the they where they select um and you know we're just committed to making sure that everyone is just as comfortable as can be and that includes then like backfill vacancies with teachers on assignment um I mean backfill vacancies with teachers on assignment that's something that needs to be looked at holistically um and that's something that we're definitely already looking at in this budget cycle uh but uh regardless again so some of those schools have teachers on assignment and and we need to make decisions about placing those individuals in schools um but it's it's you know I'm just talking in general um there would be enough space and room to actually
118staff um many of those vacancies by um merging the schools in a sense I don't want to say that thank you vice president Malloy commissioner Patterson 30 seconds yes president 30 seconds for real um so has anyone ever thought of and again I was hoping to have dialogue we're not going to have that tonight but around smaller class sizes you know can we offer the parents who want to come back to this District something different can we have like a special school that has smaller class size to you know to deal with uh maybe our most disruptive kids can it be maybe a school for them that we pipe a lot of uh service that we pipe a lot of services into you know for them I'm just throwing ideas out there for you that's
119all thank you thank you commissioner Patterson that concludes the superintendent report unless you had a one last comment were we good okay so we're going to move over to superintendent blocker thank you for your patience we'll uh convene with your report at this time ma'am uh good evening president Simmons vice president Malloy Commissioners in the Rochester Community I am happy to share the East report tonight our first slide shows that our lower School Scholars uh went to Nazareth University they heard from the admissions officer about what Nas has to offer students as well as the admissions criteria then they participated in a scavenger hunt tour of the campus highlights included the galiso training center the map of study abroad where different Scholars have gone and opportunities and the tunnels that connect the buildings to avoid
120the cold Rochester winners we are thankful to the rcsd that student Support Services is able to provide these opportunities for our students at the middle school level so that by the time they become seniors colleges ingrained in them next we have Mrs Cotto's class um we talked about this briefly last time that they did their acts of kindness um they made 105 lunches and some hats scarves and gloves to give to the father Tracy Center the scholars also shared some socks and personal hygiene products they received enough donations to even have some snacks for themselves which as you can see them smiling here in this big Center picture uh it was a great reward for all of their hard work and their acts of kindness this next slide illustrates all our partners at East you
121have the Center for Youth College Prep Hillside iiro MCC Liberty Partnerships St to college Urban League and then it shows you the breakdown for each individual partner and so the uh inside big number is the number that represents the unique Scholars served so overall at East 888 Scholars this year have been served by our partners and then if you go into the different colored ones you can see how many students individuals went so for example if you looked at Hillside you'd know it's 120 individual students but you would know they made 974 interactions with the hillside staff so I just felt this was an important um slide to share what our agencies are doing for our kids and the number of students that are accessing them next is our uh urban clothing closet and our
122community food Pantry for November and December 129 clothing items were accessed by 59 different Scholars and a total of six uh 1,651 food items were accessed by 321 individuals and a total of 58 families on our next slide uh I just want to give a very special thank you to all of those that donated and volunteered to make our holiday basket distribution of reality we were able to distribute 124 baskets 89 families so a total of 346 individuals were served through that our e scholar artwork at Winton Road Library has changed we are now displaying our images from our photo 2 classes these are life prints where students brought in their own object to create a unique photograph then they edited and matted their prints we are proud the community gets to see the great
123work our Scholars are doing this is incredibly exciting this just happened last week um a huge shout out to Senor De Jesus and the incredible group of Spanish language arts Scholars each year we take our Scholars to take the klep exam which is the college level entrance program these exams allow kids to go into a university and have credits already under their belt when this group went last week they earned a total of 126 college credits based on their Spanish courses that they're taking so congratulations to all of them the next slide is the data snapshot that I provide each month if you go to the parts that are in yellow those are the only parts that have changed we've had 14 lower school outof school suspensions and 12 upper school outof school suspensions 50.5%
124are chronically absent lower and 51.9% at upper and the numbers are represented there if you go to our daily attendance lower school is 84.3% overall for the year and upper school is 80.6% then last I would just like to to also say my appreciation and thanks to our school board and happy National School Board recognition month thank you for what each of you do individually and collectively for the most precious members of the Rochester Community our children and our future thank you thank you so much uh superintendent blocker um are there any questions or comments regarding the report from superintendent blocker at this time yes uh Madam president so I just want to do a clap a round of applause for those students who got 126 college credits give them a shout out want to
125do that uh for them and then um I also uh wanted to um just thank uh folk about board recognition month but seem like we've been getting recognized a lot you know um so I just I thank um superintendant for uh acknowledging that but you know we don't really need that we come to do this work so um just wanted to share that thank you very much thank you any other questions comments okay vice president mooy just thank you so much for your presentation it's always such a pleasure to hear what's happening at East and all the great things that those students are doing and again kudos to those college credit um earning students thank you um and so we're going to at this time have a a joint presentation by both superintendent uh Strickland
126and superintendent Blocker on the East transition update yes good afternoon again uh Commissioners so just uh wanted to continue to uh remain steadfast and making sure that we transition East High School uh back into the district's portfolio and we do so with Grace and ease and integrity to ensure that the school can uh be sure to sustain uh practices and such uh as we continue to move move forward uh so both I and um um Miss blocker will be providing these updates and um we will entertain your questions after uh so first um you know we've talked a lot about uh the fact that we have to right size uh East as well um to ensure that um every school has different uh programs that will support all or various students in our district uh
127so with that being said it has been agreed upon um that the lower school will be adding uh special education classes and resource uh consultant teaching and uh two more restrictive uh environments uh for our 1211 self-contained students as well as our New York State alternative assessment students the upper school uh will uh also have uh resource and consultant teacher uh as well as one uh 1211 self-contained and they will begin uh the other part of our New York State alternative assessment program and it's is complementary to uh Edison just wanted to be uh very clear um this will be a phase in model um one of the things you don't want to do is you don't want to uh tip the boat uh too quickly uh so we have started the phas in at
128grade seven and grade nine and it will simply grow as we continue to uh go throughout our Years thank you um superintendent Strickland and I'd also like to say I appreciate the fact that you understand doing too much too quickly will tip the boat over um I've appreciated all of your support and the continuous meetings we've had to make sure we're on the same page about this moving forward I'm excited to share that our bilingual program at East lower school will begin it will be a transitional bilingual program so all of our Scholars that are coming from elementary schools no longer have their switch turned off they will be able to enroll in bilingual in 7th and eth and then transition up to the high school where we've had the bilingual program at 9 through
12912 for years in addition next year we will also expand our Spanish Heritage language offerings for our native language arts speakers so that all Scholars have an opportunity to be in the right setting to enable them to grow and flourish um I have approved uh the East curriculum usage uh for the 2025 206 school year um the Rochester city school district has invested millions of dollars into building this curriculum and it was extremely important that they are able to uh sustain uh some of those curricula um as we continue to move forward but later down the line I will explain uh what process we are going to undergo to ensure that uh the East curriculum is uh what is beneficial to both not only East uh high school students but all of the students in
130the Rochester City School District and superintendent Strickland just mentioned there is going to be an rcsd and East curriculum analysis there will be a curriculum review team that consists of four individuals from East and four from rcsd each of those teams will be content specific uh the purpose is to use a curriculum comparison framework to analyze the current East curriculum the current rcsd curriculum and determine the best approach for the 26 27 school year and on each month we will do one review so this month for February coming up we will start with social studies and then there is a plan for each one through the remainder of this school year and the start of next school [Music] year and as superintendent Strickland said uh we're going to analyze many elements uh how are each
131of those aligned with standards what's the content relevance in depth what are the responsive practices that are taking place where is differentiation and accessibility present what is the pedagogical approach is their student engagement what are the assessment and evaluation tools being used to determine if the scholars have learned what was expected what teacher supports are available from each curriculum uh where is flexibility and adaptability so teachers are not robots they have the opportunity to add their own flavor uh what are the cost and resource requirements to continue things we have and look at things the district has how can we align all curriculum with District goals and most importantly we end with the student outcomes our goal is not to Simply say one is better or different than the other is to compare and combine
132Frameworks and curriculums where possible so that every single rcsd scholar regardless of what school they're at has the same opportunity to thrive this wouldn't happen unless we had the support of superintendent Strickland and giving District people and US providing East people so that people start to understand the collaboration is what's critical as we move forward and any questions on those updates yes vice president mooy thank you thank you so much for the presentation all great information as we continue this trans uh transition um I do have a question just about enrollment at East in general um and the impact that this is going to have on enrollment so what is the total population right now at East 7 through 12 so we have 800 is the expectation at the high school 200 in each cohort
133and at the lower school it's 180 in the seventh and eth grade the goal starting next year is to add 50 new freshmen each year and grow up so we'll eventually have a thousand kids in the regular setting and then we will have another 100 plus kids in our Nisa and our self-contained set sets okay cuz I think you know when we look at the building capacities across our district and we go to potentially close other schools because of said capacity My worry is that East has historically been under capacity big time um if you look at the and I can't speak for the actual capacity of of the buildings there but isn't it close to like 2500 students or so it is but I would just want to caution we could go back to
1342500 students in one place I'm not saying that's the ideal go back to those same results we got at a 29% graduation rate so I think there's a balance there and I think adding some incrementally as we said 50 each year and being strategic to increase just the high school alone to 1100 students and then the lower school to approximately 4 500 we're really talking, 1600 students overall okay right so I agree there's more room but I also yeah absolutely the boat to sink completely because I'm looking to see maybe the positive impact that you know taking on an increased enrollment the impact that that will have districtwide on our other buildings and their enrollments because I know sometimes there's the perception that you know a lot of our students tend to end up in
135particular buildings in the district and if we can prevent that from happening and share absolutely not a burden because we love our students absolutely you know making it more equitable districtwide and and that's one of the reasons why we actually added the 1211 self-contained uh the the philosophy was a little different um in that we do know that students that are in self-contained classes have a lower chance of graduating uh however you know one of the things that I pushed the East staff on and uh uh superintendent blocker was in that meeting you're saying you're good so you should be able to really work to get those students up to par and get them over the finish line and graduate um but also uh again this is a growing model uh it would behoove us
136not to just say hey you're an 11th grader we're gonna we have 50 spots you can go to East rather than letting them bring them in at the ninth grade or those natural transition points and grow accordingly uh that will continue to set the school up for a long-term success well I want to say thank you so much just in terms especially of like diversification of this enrollment that seems very thoughtful and I love the fact that there's a a bilingual um increase and I mean just everything um from our sped students um I'm sorry I didn't see were there L students added to that as well they bilingual I mean they have more L students at the lower School uh than general education students well I don't even like explain it like that cuz
137L's can be and are General Ed as well so thank you so much absolutely thank you vice president Malloy any other questions or comments for um the transition conversation all right none seen uh that concludes that uh report thank you we're going to move into our consider consideration of resolutions at this time starting with the academic resolutions the academic resolutions are resolutions 462 through 477 I can um I would like to entertain a motion to potentially bundle these with of course we would have opportunity to bring out and have questions and discussion around them if the board is amable to bundling the resolutions 462 through 477 so moved second moved by vice president Malloy seconded by commissioner Patterson I'm looking at something and I apologize because I see an amendment to 285 do I need
138to do that first okay or do I need to you can do them all together um they're all academic resolutions so it would just be um for resolution 462 to 477 and an amendment to 285 okay so do I need need to withdraw that and do that again or we're good I think you should probably do it again okay thank you so the motion uh all in favor of that okay I motion carries and so at this point in time I'm going to open up for conversation around any um resolutions under the academic portion okay hold on one second so we have 462 I'm sorry did we just vote on the resolution um no I I we haven't voted yet right apologist pres I just a clarification do you just you just voted to bundle
139them right bundle them right and so now you you're just going to make a motion for all the resolutions right now so so the the bundling was authorized are you doing the bundling separate from the voting on The resolutions themselves was that your intent yeah my intent yes thank you for the question so my what I'm trying to do is bundle the uh make a motion entertain a motion to bundle the resolutions it sounds as if the board is in favor of doing so and at this time I want to open do I need to I would make another motion then for the resolutions themselves just for say super clear you're you're U making a motion for resolution 462 through that's the step I missed thank you for that right through four um 77 77
140including the amendment to resolution 285 yes sir thank you okay so we've bundled and so now at this point I'd like to entertain a motion to uh for Resolutions 462 through 477 with an amendment to 285 so moved moved by vice president Malloy second second it by commissioner Patterson all in favor there any questions we're not voting we're just sorry I'm I'm yes so now I'm going to open the convers open the day is for conversation I didn't want I I just wanted to make something clear before we even voted we're not voting okay we're not voting yeah give me one second okay go ahead I'm sorry right so I move I've moved it for I kind of screwed that up a little bit but now we are going to open the day for discussion
141okay so if you um have a question uh between for Resolutions 477 I'm sorry 462 to 477 it's been a long day um now is the time to present your question okay um because I have quite a few I just wanted to give everyone a brief understanding on why they're within that bundled group that you have you can keep it as as concise as as much as possible because but I want you to understand the reason why that I feel we need to do something so I just want it's only going to take a second though okay as you're all aware our district is currently facing a budget Gap exceeding 39 million do in alignment with corporate industry standards is both prudent and necessary to ha on non-essential spending until this Gap is resolved continuing
142to spend without restraint will only deepen the deficit further reports from Dr Po and Mr haimy Alisa our monitor State monitor entitled Rochester City School District proposed academic and financial plan of 2024 through 2025 draft outlines critical recommendations for the board to follow in order to prevent further Financial acad mic decline adhering to these recommendations is essential to to demonstrating physical responsibility and secure the longterm stability of our district for this reason I am fir firmly requesting that all resolutions seeking to assess the general fund be paused until we resolve our budget deficit specic specifically concerning resolution resolutions to pause um because we only doing 466 through 477 I'm asking for resolution 466 6 468 462 464 and 465 to be paused until we can we can um fix our budget uh budget deficit or
143budget Gap thank you thank you commissioner Griffin were there other statements um yes okay um is it okay if I go to the go ahead commissioner Santi I'm GNA go to commissioner Santiago and then I'll go up to the um virtual okay um I just I'm G allow uh commissioner LeBron to answer that I'm sorry I'm allow her to do commissioner uh uh Lebron Yes again with misinformation to the public we have a 36 million gap we're always going to have a gap because we have contracts in our unions that say 3% so even if we did nothing next year we're going to have increases in our operating budget but this is not that budget so I just want to be clear that you have a commissioner alluding incorrect amounts to a budget Gap that
144exists for the 25 26 year which this board hasn't even voted on um and in addition since you want to bring up the S uh the state monitors recommendations that includes SCH closures which you just oppose that is part of us being fiscally responsible and aligning our footprint to our actual operational needs so I just want the public to be clear that we have a $36 million budget gap for the 2526 and that is solely based on our footprint right now if we do nothing um and so closing the school or a school or two will absolutely impact that deficit that that Gap I do not want to say it's a deficit because it's not a deficit um but that's all again misinformation to the public needs to start being addressed on this board because
145it's creating further misinformation BR bread out there to the community especially to parents who are listening in thinking and eating this up thinking that you're advocating for something that's false thank you thank you commissioner LeBron commissioner Santiago did you still have anything um any other comments questions on the information noted is from the general funds and the general funds is something that we talked talked about back about a month ago and as saying that we should not be assessing money from the general funds um because that could that could further put us in a different but um a um a worse Gap so I just want to make it clear that I'm not trying to give misinformation to the public if the money has not already been allocated and it hasn't already been used these
146particular contracts are new contracts they're not they're not pre-existing they're new the dates on them are new they're they're coming from 16 112 122 all these are new contracts that are just came up so what I'm saying to the general public is that when we have a gap we want don't want to spend more money and take out of what we have that is what I'm saying so I don't want I'm not trying to further confuse you guys nor do I not know what I'm talking about I do know what I'm talking about I do I that was passed you are confusing the public we are literally operating out of a budget pass thank you no no no we're going to we're going to maintain or order and the Quorum we are having discourse and
147we are U Commissioners are making points and so we're going to allow for that to happen and and we're going to keep it respectful as we are I agree um I'm going to take in and I do have a question that I would like to pose um because the points have been heard and they have been taken I want to give this superintendent did you have anything at this time just quickly in a nutshell when you actually see some of these academic resolutions pulling from General funds that's actually a good thing that we're using our actual funds to fund these student outcome versions of what it is that we're trying to do um it shouldn't just be title it should be like what our regular operating cost that are supporting us reaching those outcome goals
148so just wanted to let everyone know that please clarify for me uh commissioner Griffin I'm going to finish my question and then I will give you an opport so I have a question around uh resolutions 474 and U um let me just open it up really quickly my apologies and so these are um additional pay resolutions I'm looking at and I do see um I'm looking at the dates and I see an individual listed um should should that individual be on uh that is completely fine what we would do is replace uh any of the individuals on there with other individuals through a board transfer form which is usually an administrative task that would get done um you know just to make sure that we don't pay anyone that would not be actually working okay
149yeah I I don't have excuse me ma'am Miss okay so um commissioner Patterson one more and then commissioner Griffin one more and then we'll thank you pull it back in yeah that conversation that you guys just had I had no understanding of what you guys are talking about I'm sorry thank you um just for a point of clarity I was looking at resolutions 474 and 475 and um I was just um asking if if um the additional pays you know how that how that would work um but you mentioned an individual or something like that they should have if if we go further with that conversation we can pull that for executive session and I can provide some clarity on on what my exact um my actual question was understood thank you um so I
150would have to make a motion on that but before we do that I would like to open the days back up for one last comment or question from commissioner if if if the the financial or somebody's here that can clarify that that money is not coming out of monies that we are already looking at for the um the budget Gap I would I would like that I need a understanding to make sure that this money is not going to be it's not going to in excuse me excuse me so I need to make sure that we're not taking money out when we already have a gap that's what I want Clarity on and that's what we need to know as a Commissioners that is something very important to us because here again to to commissioner
151ell's point we don't want to spend money I need to speak to an expert in reference to that if they can let us know if we have to go in executive session because of it I'm down to do that but I need to know that this money from the general funds is not coming from what we have and it's not going to be added to our current budget Gap that's my concern okay want you to be very care commissioner um LeBron I'm going to go to you in one second I just want us to be very mindful um because we're interchangeably using budget um Gap and deficit and things of that nature so make sure we we just yeah I say deficit yes okay earlier you did so I just want to make sure we
152St consist with gap okay commissioner LeBron yeah um again to the listening audience and to to the public the board has a process to pass a budget if you look at our resolutions they're available publicly online it will tell you the budget line it'll tell you the goals that it's attached to and all of that pieces of information in terms of the budget line that it's being drawn from but just like any other organization that passes a budget and tries to stick to that budget this is where the funding is being allocated and draw from again the Gap that exists is not in the current Rochester City School District budget that the board voted on it is in next year's budget which we have not voted on We did an early assessment of where we're
153at that Gap by the way can also be reduced further by understanding what the state is going to be diving out to schools we don't have that information yet so I just want to be clear that when with these resolutions even though we pass a budget we are still required to go through a monthly process through these board business meetings to pass resolutions but that money has already been voted on and allocated to be spent in these pockets and these um areas if you will that's it I am so exhausted with misinformation and it drives me nuts when it's coming from Commissioners who have been there long enough thank you commissioner LeBron for those points of clarity and so that would also so those dates that we see um superintendent that seem to be new
154dates and things of that nature are things that are already voted on from what I'm understanding and things that um and this is is just the resolutions coming through to formalize that process correct these are funds that you you all have voted on uh when you passed the budget for this school year so now we're just allocating the funds uh that were budgeted for and spending them accordingly and then ask for the resolution uh process to help uh update uh commissioner Patterson uh just wanted you to know if uh any individual uh that may be on a resolution uh that is not needed for a service we have a internal board transfer form where I can simply replace the name of an individual and they would then be able to get uh paid for rendering
155their services to our students okay and then my last question commissioner s I'm going to go to you um right after I get done my last question is just anything like that's under Title One and this is just for my learning purposes those are typically submitted under Consolidated application and what have you um right uh yes we have to actually submit our Title One budget to our state monitor who approves it uh then it's approved by the state and they also contain um you know additional pay uh programs curricula so on and so forth um that we can purchase with with those funds perfect thank you very much commissioner Santiago uh yes I actually did have a question when it came to the after school in the secondary Saturday program um I was having conversations
156recently with with a couple of uh students and teachers and they talked about this program I'm just wondering are we keeping um the data as far as how beneficial this is towards I did have a question earlier and this was a question um but are we keeping track of of how uh the students are succeeding how it's uh impacting their literacy and their math absolutely uh great question commissioner Santiago believe it or not a few years ago uh commissioner Elliot um posed a question about uh making sure that we are getting outcomes out of uh these Saturday programs and Extended Learning opportunities of we've then uh began requiring attendance and Power School um ensuring uh you know looking at the amount of credits that are being accured looking at the amount of u marking period
157uh uh recovery efforts and online credit recovery efforts uh that are happening in these after school and Saturday programs and I even made mention that I do know that for instance this school is really popular I live uh close by to the school and it it's great to see the amount of students taking advantage of these additional opportunities to get across the Finish Line yeah and I I also want to add and this is a question and kind of a statement but for students who who get suspended from school um I I see that this may be a positive way to still keep them engaged in their academics um even through their suspension it's it's St statistically proven that suspensions are not beneficial to um a students progression uh academically and so if we are
158in those circumstances where a student does have to be suspended because of circumstances um that that has happened um that this is a program that they can go to where they're kind of in a different setting they can connect with the teacher that they connect with and uh learn in better ways and so I think that you know it's just a good idea to put out there thank you commissioner Santiago vice president Malloy thank you yeah so just for clarity again for the public um you know we did vote on this budget last year and all of these resolutions have come to us now but we've already approved um approved all of this and I will say this one thing I really love about how resolutions are coming before us this year in particular is
159the fact that all of the are aligned to those student focused outcomes and that didn't we didn't used to have that on our so you can look at any of these resolutions and you can see with each one what priority is is being addressed you can see the goal um and how the direct impact or intended impact of that type of programming um so I want to say kudos to admin just for having that there and if you read it carefully you can can really see how these align so that is a A plus this year so thank you for doing that and it um you know I know there's concern about extra pay resolutions this tells us why um for those funds that we already approved last year so okay thank you robust conversation
160um that I think concludes our conversation regarding our academic resolutions and so at this particular time I'd like to entertain a motion to um vote on that's already Mo okay so all in favor of of resolutions 462 through 477 and 285 i i i any opposed the motion carries we're going to move forward into uh the administrative support resolutions at this time and uh that would be resolutions 478 through 7177 am I looking at that right 99 and an amendment to 2324 all the amendment 717 2324 717 yes ma'am that's an amendment okay so moved so moved by vice president Malloy seconded by Pat Uh commissioner Patterson all in favor of bundling these resolutions I I so at this time um I'd like to open the floor no motion for motion to vote on resolutions
161478 I'm done tonight 478 uh through 499 including uh 2324 717 so moved second vice president Malloy moved Patterson uh commissioner Patterson second um question opening the floor for questions at this time I have a question commissioner Santiago yeah just wondering for um resolution 717 if you could just give like a quick update on what we're talking about here just to the public this is $8 million so so uh so you know that the overall FMP is 4 uh $ 75 or $85 million uh this uh resolution is uh being asked to be passed uh so that we can advance uh portions of that resolution uh that total in $8.4 million or a little over $8.4 million uh to actually begin the work that is needed uh to start the modernization process thank you thank
162you any other questions regarding these resolutions commiss uh vice president Malloy yeah just um regarding number 478 um and it's this is just sort of new terminology for me so um superintendant can you explain what this means exactly in as simple of terms as possible because when I initially saw this and saw like true up obviously this is not $40 million more than we budgeted or anything like that um can you just talk a little bit about true UPS or why is this transfer necessary because it seems like a significant amount so um when it when this resolution came in uh I too asked questions because I'm like I am not um spending this money um however what this is actually doing is rectifying accounts so at times in different budgets you tend to go
163over or under and and uh there's you have to move money so that lines are balanced as much as possible our finance team our budget director keeps up with that information and ensures that all lines are balanced appropriately and it's the excess of40 million that has been moved to ensure that we have balance no money has been pulled from anywhere this is all money within the current budget I just want to be very clear on that but this is just for continued uh fiscal transparen thank you and I have additional ones but I I can wait for other Commissioners to ask the first question okay were there any other questions at this time how many questions do you have just looks like uh two more okay I'll allow for for two more questions two yeah
164actually just one more because um the FMP one was was answered just now so okay yeah um so resolution number 483 um I'm just wondering was this increase cuz it's a pretty significant increase um are we seeing decreases in transportation costs elsewhere um or is this increase just because of an increase in the number of students requiring these Services um or the number of locations that we now need to serve with mckenny vinto I'm Miss I just mispronounced that um so it just seems like a significant increase from prior years and so I was wondering what the cause of that was so I am going to have I am going to have Deputy attner um speak to this uh resolution great thank you so much yes thank you for that um it is in response
165to the need both for mckenny vento uh student transportation and also special needs students um and again uh we put in there we did put it on bitnet and uh reive responses from three vendors and uh transpo came out on top and due to those increased number of students we needed to uh engage in a in a contract with them so oops had we originally budgeted then for that amount or where are those funds coming from all right so yeah the the Transportation uh budget is um often unpredictable so we look at the current number of students uh that we have uh how many vendors we need the specialized uh vendors like transport really does our mckenny vento and and small bus transportation needs and uh try to make those alignments if we uh happen
166to increase in mckenny vento which we can't predict and control right then we are able to use existing funds and reallocate them uh to and remember transportation is also reimbursable back to us uh so that's how we we work that out okay thank you so much thank you all in favor of uh resolutions 478 through 7117 I any opposed well let me just clear is it did you include 717 with 499 because if you did that means that you're you're saying that 500 5001 all through 717 is what we're voting on did I miss something yeah it's the 717 from 23 no no I understand that but looks like she said from from all of those through 717 and it's not what should have been said was9 and then and oh yeah that's what I
167had been doing and thank you for that um redirection I do appreciate that so let me restate that all in favor of resolutions 478 through 499 and 717 hi hi oos yes I discussion can I just discuss no discussion is happen we're we're now that's the N or I did you say I or nay um I just want I had a discussion about the one but the rest I can we you miss the discussion unfortunately so at this point is for the vote if you want to say I or nay on I want to say nay to all of them I want I want to I want on confirmation on one on one resolution we're voting this is not time for discussion president Madam president I'm just want confirmation on one yes I was trying
168to get clarification on things we're dealing with before so I have an understanding of something so that's what I was doing to the listening public um um I want to I want to I think there's information in here about oh my God about the tenure everyone ex except the one so I'm just looking to see which one that was I do apologize to the listen in public is it a yay or nay though we're voting this is not discussion time um I had a problem with the I had a concern just a question about the tenure on the one resolution but I don't want it but I don't want to again I do not want to say nay to all of these when I have a question on one on one of these res iend
169part we voting what I would recommend commissioner Griffin is if you don't feel solid on the one that you have a question about you do have the right to say nay to it at this point but we we do need to move forward with a vote at this time so we're going to we're calling a vote for Resolutions 478 through 499 and 717 and if and uh if there's one that you'd like me to pull out you're not comfortable with it or you don't have full understanding and you want to vote nay you do have the option to do that that's what I that's all I was saying yeah what is that what resolution is it that the one with the tenure because I I don't know which number that is right now there's a
170lot of resolutions yeah just let me see hold on this is not I can we get clarity from our lawyer on Robert's rules because this is not how it works when we're at the voting stage there is not time for discussion we're voting this discussion was closed it's now time to vote and you cannot pull a resolution on an open um on an open uh motion Adrian can you give us that instruction yeah yes uh thank you very much um so I I think the the president Simmons uh summed up correctly the members are voting right now um I I get the president could entertain a um a question if or a ComEd if uh she she uh so chose but she um we not ENT you did you did rule that that the vote
171is occurring so my understanding is President Griffin is is just going to point out the one that she doesn't wantan to want to vote naon yeah it was the one with the so yeah we need you to give the resolution number so that we can vote yeah I'm trying to do that that's what I was trying to do I apologize but here again I was speaking with with Administration down yeah $499 okay um so is it 499 commissioner Griffin okay all right so we're going to entertain a motion for Resolutions 478 through well we've already have the motion we voted resolution on the floor they've passed and so did you want to how do we give a record for her no on $4.99 I me provide Clarity for a moment when you all bundle the
172resolutions you can still vote yay or nay to specific one so in this instance where you took the bundle and everyone said yay all commissioner Griffin we need to do is say I and then nay to whichever and name the number thank you didn't know which one she was saying nay thank you um to our folks who were able to identify the resolution we're going to move forward with the board of uh education legal audits resolution and this is concerning the legislative bre breakfast clerk when were you going to um touch on on that M okay yes uh this is just an amendment two staffers from another school who will be joining a gallery walk um will be also at the day and so they needed to be added in that that's what the amendment
173is for okay so um entertaining a motion for resolution 436 so moved moved by vice president Malloy second seconded by commissioner Santiago all in favor of resolution for 36 I I any opposed I the motion carries resolutions added after uh we've got a motion to entertain okay this is for the the 48 hour uh Rule and so this is resolutions 500 501 and um yes you all need a motion to wave the 48 hour requir M and then after that we take motions for the actual resolutions okay so entertaining the motion wave the 48 require 48 hour requirement for those resolutions motion motion by vice president Malloy second by anyone second seconded by commissioner Griffin all in favor I I I okay so the 48 hour rule has gone forward we're we're doing that and
174so a motion to entertaining a motion for Resolutions 502 5 500 500 to 502 it's written kind of weird for me tonight so entertaining a motion let me be clear excuse me entertaining a motion for Resolutions 500 through 502 at this time um so moved moved by vice president Malloy do second you remove meison um and open for discussion at this time yeah I I I disagree with uh the one I want the 152 I don't we're not voting so I don't want a conversation about it just when the voting comes I'll do it then sorry well no this is the time to conversate I'm open for discussion and so once we um have the discussion and we close the discussion we will go to vote and there will be no additional conversation so did
175you have us something for 502 yes um um I just I'm not in agreement with the uh one of the leadership's positions at uh Pia High School okay so um is there a way to section that out either you just yay or nay on that particular resolution and so at this time thank you for that uh commissioner Griffin any other comments or questions regarding uh resolutions 500 through 502 okay all right so uh all in favor of resolutions 500 through 502 I I any oppos a nay on 502 okay uh thank you the motion carries okay moving into the resource tab this is regarding uh the Medicaid Appliance uh compliance report that's just something folks can read and access online so we're not going to get into that but the information is available we um
176have had time as Commissioners to read and um familiarize oursel with this particular report it is available on board docs for our general public please forgive me I have a minut um and so now at this time we're going to move our agenda into unfinished business uh it looks like the uh legislative priorities are you going to touch on that sure so if Commissioners recall um Chief uh Ramos Lopez last meeting provided us with an update on what the administration is proposing after hearing feedback from the board around the legislative priorities this is a compilation of that um and so it is very similar as you know from last year's um with just some updates as it pertains to the specific um priorities which she spoke about in her presentation and so you all would
177vote on this legislative agenda um and then we'll move forward to our breakfast on February 8th thank you clerk one um yes commissioner aliot so I think I had mentioned a couple of things one had to do with I believe transportation um and um I think we also talked about discussing certification and there seems to be one other piece that I had offered and I don't see those here [Music] um so let me just put that out there and I you can come back to me okay sure and then uh were there any other conversation around the legislative priorities that have been presented yes um on the Career and Technical education where does cpps and seos and all of that fall into that um cpps is a very um is also something that the kids
178should be a part of would that be a part of uh a legislative priority as well because that is all in the same group when you're talking about Career and Technical education cpps is a part of that so why isn't that included in this uh that because CTE is encompasses all of those factors and so this is a aial view conversation around how we would like to see CTE U move forward but when you say CTE it is encompassing all the components of CTE they fall under that umbrella if you will CTE is the umbrella okay so in other words this the $3,900 per student would include the C do cpbs and all of that is that correct all of the CTE services being rendered so okay so c c includes those services that you're
179mentioning yes ma'am okay I I was not clear okay that's why I just wanted to clearity on that okay and a question by vice president Malloy yeah so I don't know to whom this question needs to go whether to our superintendent or to our our state monitor but obviously these are our proposed legislative priorities how do these align with Big Five school districts and the some of the priorities that they have put forward are they in line with what other big five schools are asking for um great question vice president Malloy I actually just came back from the commissioner's advisory Council uh where most of these items are actually uh have been talked about um some of it prek rising to the top Charter Schools up there um Transportation uh as well even though that
180didn't necessarily come out in the last meeting because I was one of the uh only representatives from the big five uh but we are very much in line with um most of the states and um I was actually making sure that we uh C that I captured it in my letter uh to you all uh so that if you wanted to add anything uh that we can all be uh uh you know their strength the numbers uh then I would recommend those items and they're mainly on here right yeah and thank you so much for for sending that letter out each week and um in terms of my own feelings on this I I like what we see here and I'd love to um have this be our final list well uh let me just
181uh Madam yes yes commissioner what's her name Simmons um it's I would like to include um um the transportation trans reimbursement for transportation we had had that on our agenda uh for um for a very long time and I think that we should look at including that back on um the agenda I think we also talked about so I mean it's this is presented but I don't know where the conversation um where the decisions were made and maybe I could talk to uh oh not no I wasn't in the decision making since the dissolve of cigr um so I don't know how that decision we had we had talked about and i' like to see it included back on uh the agenda for tuition Transportation uh reimbursement and we had also had some conversation around
182um I thought we had had some conversation around teacher certification um and um and I'm missing one more um so where where did this these decisions get made that this will this is the um legislative agenda that we're going to be voting on tonight can somebody provide probably would not support this without that provide clarity as to how this this this was formed and where decisions went and if there were other pieces brought forward um why they're not there who should I be who can answer for that if I could jump in for a second before Administration the process that we've been using for last couple years is that the board generally will have some start the conversation and talk about the high Lev things that you all would like to see from that the
183administration goes back and kind of um refines it in the details specific to the area so for instance if you said you wanted something on prek and you gave a little Direction on what it is and administration goes back looks at what it was that you recommended looks at what's happening looks at the district and then puts forward the recommendation for what the um agenda item should be which is what you are now all like receiving and what you heard from Chief um in the last presentation so based on the joint conversation that you all had around what you wanted to see happen and then back and forth with Administration again getting those details around what's happening across the state what might be some realistic expectations and then of course um taking in account the
184district's condition related to that and then so that's how we have been jointly working to create the legislative agenda I they would have to speak more to their process internally okay is anyone able from Administration able to to provide an understanding so let me just propose then that uh we reinstate as a legislative priority the transportation reimbursement um I'd like to have that restored to our list of priorities commissioner ellot if I could just ask for clarification um the the item you're talking about is the reimbursement by expanding the um allotted Zone eligibility so from 1.5 miles to a half a mile right right so that's what I'd like to um have restored to this agenda and I'm not sure what was the what was the rationale for not including that uh on our as
185a part of our priorities and and now and there is um you know there is evidence now that um the smaller Suburban districts are getting that reimbursement and I think that is important that we keep this on the agenda so that we can you know this may even be a discriminatory piece that the Suburban districts get it but the the the big five districts cannot get it and so um I so if they got it it's encouraging uh to me that we can look at that we may uh get it as well so I'd like to see it restored superintendent Strickland I'm sorry let me finish i' like to see it restored on here because I just think it's very important that we move and I think that there's a movement because as I said
186the suburban suburban districts that have been granted this funding so and granted the legislation so um thank you yeah thank you also commissioner I'm sorry superintendent strictly I'm going to invite um Chief maniso Lopez Ramos Ramos Lopez to the mic just to give clarification around transportation and then I just wanted to um add one of the priorities that I kind of left off that we were talking a lot about um at the state good evening Commissioners commissioner iiott to respond to your question regarding transportation we were looking at reducing the amount of priorities that we were listing specifically those that have been on the document for a number of years and have not yielded any positive results one of the issues specifically with transportation that we're facing right now is a severe challenge with drivers
187and so while I agree that we would want more funding and that we want that mile and a half restriction to be reduced and that we're on parody with our Suburban um counterpart districts at this time the shortage of drivers precludes us from looking at that as a priority simply because we may have the money but not necessarily the drivers to carry that out yeah so so um president um yes yeah so I disagree with that um I think that um yeah it may have been on a long time but I do think that we have to continue I think there is some traction with the fact that there are Suburban districts that have been approved this legislation has been approved and um I I guess I don't see the correlation between the fact that
188we don't have bus drivers and getting this legislation passed so that we can get that funding and we can make sure that there more kids on the bus I I'm I'm uh insisting that we include it because I again I think that there's an opportunity yeah it's been a long time and it's been in a long ter but I think that I don't want to forget it and and there are times when we do forget um our history that we want to fight uh for this so um I just want to make sure that we're um we're continuing with this and I want to make sure that it is before our legislators of so that they could continue to fight for this um and then I had talked about I thought we had talked about
189a um and I guess I would have wished that if there was going to be a reduction in this because of the the the the the items that I advocate for that there would have been a conversation with me about this because it's important to be that we we look at this but also you know we had talked about certification is a is is an area that um at least I had had a conversation about um and looking at how we can either have that uh removed or in some way modified uh so that there are more teachers uh of color a part of that um that we can recruit also student um teachers who may be from other states um so so that we can you know have a bigger pool around our teach
190teaching um population so um I guess I just wish there had been more conversation on that point uh commissioner Eliot it is my understanding that the State Department of Education is looking at the definitions and regulations for certification because that is specific with the New York State Department of Education we did not include that in the legislative priorities that are going to be discussed during the big five um days and all yeah all right but I I really want to I'm I'm somewhat in insisting that it goes on I don't know if I need to have a vote in the board says no we can say no but I just think it's that important and like I said if they have approved it already for the uh some of the Suburban schools um I just
191think we have more leverage to have it to move forward um if we continue to have that as a part of our um and one thing I'll say about our legislative priorities is that that a number of years ago the board had a listing of priorities and the administration had a listing of priorities I recall being the district clerk at the time when I pushed for those priorities to be unified and so that's very important for us to have a unified list it is brought to the board if there are items that the board wishes to have included that is certainly the prerogative of the board this is a joint list and and the administration would want to keep it that way okay so it sounds like maybe we want to put that on for
192some additional followup to get an appetite to see how we if we can socialize that um but we need on it tonight good point uh two things one I do see commissioner LeBron's hand so you know um yes so your legislative breakfast is on February 8th you do not technically have another a meeting to discuss this or to vote on it so if you all wish you we ain't doing a special meeting okay um commissioner um before I go to the zoom I I did see um commissioner Santiago and then I'll go up to the yeah I I don't have my hand up I'm sorry you guys I forgot to lower it so I just want to clarify that okay I just want to say I do agree with uh president Elliot uh for our
193students who are who who are 1.5 miles away from their school you know and for better transport transportation for them um I will also say that it does have to be passed tonight because the breakfast is coming up and so possibly we can make it in a way where it's passed with the addition of Transportation if four Commissioners agree yeah and I will say that um because I hear you um Marisol um Dr Ras Lopez I'm not doctor yet but thank you I'm call you I like to call doctors do I see it oh no but I I do say that although um we recognize there is a a shortage of drivers and so uh I understood that rationale um you know the thought is that at some point hopefully the drivers are back and
194that's still going to be a concern even when the shortage is no longer there and so even socializing that now if they if they can't move on it it's it's still being it's still putting being put out there to commissioner Elliot's point so um we may not get as much traction like you said but um letting them know that it's still an a strong interest and need for our families might be um a way to go and so with the understanding that it's on February 8th and we don't have no more time we need to uh uh how would we bring this in for potentially a vote for entertainment or how does that work can can I say something before you before you speak um I'm going to get that answer then I'm then I'll
195definitely goad yes so so I'm trying to understand what the board is doing is the board entertaining the amendment that um president that um commissioner Elliott put forward so or or is the board going to vote on it as as is so what I'm what what I'm asking you is um commission and then commissioner ell please uh correct me if I if I heard it wrong but from what I understand it sounds as if commissioner Elliott had uh something around the transportation that she articulated that she was hoping to have placed back on this agenda and I'm asking um if we are in favor of seeing this place on the agenda how would we move for just a motion to amend right so so we just put forward a motion to amend to add um
196you know what's being proposed by commissioner um Elliot um I you know I think if if commissioner would provide some some some general language the clerk could we have the language Lang exct language already it's been there we can just add it so so motion to amend to add the what the uh proposal put forward by Comm yep you vote on that okay so before I go into there it sounds like there's just a little more discussion um and so commissioner Griffin did you it was just saying that it was there before so I just I was just all for it that's all okay yeah and any any other pieces so at this time I'd like to I'm sorry uh superintendent I was just going to say a compromis is that it can still remain
197on the legislative priorities as a a consideration for State education department even though those districts that are less than the one and a half miles they come up with the the the funding if I'm not mistaken for those students so we are just saying come down on the mileage however I want it to be very clear that we don't have the infrastructure right now or the capacity to actually um to pick up all of the students because of the bus driver shortage but I do recommend that well let's put the cart before the horse and right or the horse before the cart and make sure that the legislation is can be approved yeah work towards it so at this time for our babies um we'd like to entertain a motion to reinstate uh the language
198that um was previously on the legislative agenda agenda regarding Transportation yeah Transportation reimburse motion second okay moved by vice president Malloy seconded by commissioner Griffin all in favor I I I any opposed motion carries We'll add that back to the the agenda then I think we have to pass it as Amendment as amended now have pass it as amended yep I know what I'm talking about L here okay so we're going to go ahead and say a motion to say approve the legislative priorities as amended approve the legislative priorities as amended motion motion okay all in FA us all in favor did you catch catch the motion in the second rep um it was motioned by commissioner Santiago and seconded by vice president Malloy thank you thank you and the motion carried now let's not
199act brand new we know we all done fumbled up here before on these things especially late at night I'm tired okay so at this particular time we're going to go into the um second readings which is on the agenda at this time thank you madam president Simmons uh we have the finally proposed policy items are slated for second reading and that's policy 2120 .1 2160 2260 2280 2325 2440 2510 2521 2530 6500 9110 and 9260 uh I just have one uh Clarity uh one uh statement to make on 9110 9110 is the one that is referencing the uh affirmative action piece I'm requested from Madam president uh Simmons to to uh remove that particular one only because the verbiage has not been changed and we keep going through these readings and the information needs to
200State um it says affirmative action I just wanted to say directory of equity um if we put directory of equity in there that comfort that supports everyone so I'm asking for that to be removed and make that correction to director of equity and then we can move forward with the readings on that particular 9110 can we can we vote on it and if it doesn't pass then go from there isn't this been this been a policy that's been tabled a couple times so already I'm I'm call for order on the on the day for a moment so that I you know we don't get too lost in the discussion okay so you you're calling you would like to for 9110 you would like to do a director of equity right the verbiage is stating that
201they want to have that wanted to be want that to be governed under superintendent in a human capital what I'm saying is that we need someone in the director instead of having say affirmative action we should have someone in the directory of equity that would be a would be able to uh support those who would like to speak into relevance to anything that's happening in in in in the district with hene or actually be in compliance so we we want to make sure that we're in compliance with the EOC and everything else if we have person that's in directory of equity then that would govern everyone to secure that there's no there's no uh uh H what is that the word I want to use uh uh if somebody wants to come and speak to
202someone that they're not that they're not being what that black ball what is it retaliate against thank you so much uh Dr blocker retaliate against and so it's pertinent that we have someone in there to protect our people the staff in what so have you in the district and I think that would be the best way to do it all I'm asking you to do is to remove it from this second reading for now Madam president and we we could revisit it but just to remove it from now and then we can revisit it as a policy itself on another day that's all I'm asking okay thank you very much commissioner Santiago I just just for for food of thought because I feel like every time we this policy comes up you know this is
203something that's discussed but I know that this is something that the administration is done in the administration anyways but I'm also looking at our organizational meeting and on a yearly basis like we have the designation designate official newspaper or designate Ada coordinator and things like that and possibly to her thought of what she's proposing is having somebody you know who who's already because most of these people who are uh designated are already part of the district they're already uh uh employee just put on with another task and so I'm wondering with that even with her verbiage if something like that could happen and something in at our organizational meeting you know that that's currently done it doesn't create a new position but it puts the responsibility on somebody which is going to happen anyways but
204you know Ju Just to feed into what she you know what what my colleague is saying because it you know every time this is something that we we've talked about thank you commissioner Santiago superintendent strickman I was just just going to uh say uh after this was brought up um in the beginning um we we don't have an affirmative action officer uh however we begin looking internally in the office of human capital as uh for someone who could fulfill that that role uh to do that type of work and um you know that's there's a possibility that we can attach that work onto some individual uh without adding more positions to an already bloated uh type of budget yeah yes commissioner Elliot so let me just offer this as well I know that commissioner um
205Griffin wants to include this in we've got a new Administration who has just eliminated Dei in his um Administration and if we're getting any federal contracts we may get sued if we put that language in our policies if we've got Federal contracts and I don't know how much um the total amount of those Federal contracts are but we're talking about tital one funding and and some other Federal contracts we may want to be careful of putting any language around Dei because we may lose funding around that again to your point president Elliot I just want to say this you're absolutely right that is why I'm asking to table this because we need to get more information so we have the right verbiage to put in there that's all I'm saying we moving and we can
206go ahead and go the other ones uh for the second reading so we can go home yeah well we we are going to go home you you bet your bottom dollar we about to go home or at least to Executive session so what I will say however is um you know I do want to Echo uh this what was expressed because that the the the new Administration has also made comments around he wants to look at spaces that are being uh creative and how they're renaming so um I'm going to table this for now thank you um but this will be the absolute well first of all I don't even know if I have the authority as an individual to do that we're going to probably have to vote to do that um and if
207the if the board is amable it's going to require the board to be amable to tbling it um then we can do that but that will be the absolute in my um my Earnest of earnest thoughts time and and and then it'll be a final decision because we have discussed this and held this up um for quite a while so I would like to entertain a motion to one more time one more again she um she does it okay I'm sorry if you'd like to do it more no no no I just didn't know if I needed to do it cuz I did understand and it's okay because I forget this is the policy so please go ahead and and put your motion forward and then we will entertain it as a board and I
208don't know how that's going to go can I have a motion to table uh policy number 9110 so moved K until when when is it being Ted that's the rules you have to table it by a date what's the day to the next to the policy meeting I think this is the the third feary you got to lay the date down you have by law you have to put the date um clerk when the policy meeting is on February 4th thank you rahima okay you got to do it till February 4th and just just another just a point I guess clarification or question for the board so this is a second reading so this would have come before the board again another time for the third reading so is is the board saying this is
209going to be delayed and have another second reading is that the is that the intent okay okay let or is it being pulled out of the sent back to subcommittee completely yeah so this is my concern we kept going through the readings but the verbiage wasn't changing it just kept going through the readings so every when they they said we was going to bring bring it back and make the changes and the changes never came never were made and then it came back with the same verbage commission Griffin do you want to go back to a second reading or do you want this to go back to subcommittee I think it should go back to the subcommittee so we could we so we can make sure that we have the language correctly so we don't
210we're not we're not in particular of being sued by the language we that we have that we put in so I think it's better for us to make the make the appropriate changes based on what what's going to happen at the top but but I U commission um yes president Simmons I would this is just not the chairperson's decision is this is a committee of the whole and so it is what four of us would recommend um I I don't have you know either way in terms of U what to care whatever way it goes but I'm just saying it really depends on you know at least four people because it's a committee of the whole to help to make that decision but it's he's asking me personally the attorney asked me personally I'm sorry
211commissioner no I wasn't asking personally I'm asking for the will of the board just for the clarification so that so what's being expressed at this time um thank you um coun so so what's being expressed this time is even if we send it back to subcommittee or we hold it for second reading again um if it's not the appetite of the board it will you know potentially will still could get voted down up what sideways whatever it's going to happen that's what it will be and so it's this uh if we make a decision to do this this evening it's not going to guarantee that it's going to move forward as a as a vote or you know to do that let me just be clear on what what what I would what I would
212recommend to the board H is that I would recommend because these changes are happening at the top that we get the once it is moved from the top and it is proved then we would know exactly how to move forward on 9110 if we don't have the verbiage at the top and we remove something or we just take it away then we could be we could be we could be deed either way so I I would love to in my recommendation to see what happens at the top before we make a decision that is just my recommendation because we Cann not hold policies motion to take it to the subcommittee can can I can I one question Commissioners can I maybe I can offer some assistance um clerkin maybe can um uh help me here
213W would in terms of a process standpoint would um it pose issues if this came back for another second reading at the policy meeting in terms of the the timeline that um uh Charisma uh has in place for some of these um so I'm just pulling up policy 2410 because it's not just about the timeline that policy kind of calls out where readings happen and pushes things to the next business meeting specifically um so just give me one moment a second second reading can we we have to move on to a third right I guess the issue is is that if we had a p if we had to did it when when we first agreed to it to make the changes and then nobody agreed to it though that's the thing did at the
214one meeting Agree to Agree to change the verbiage and then it okay in any event in my recommendation I'm just asking for it to be tabled until the next meeting if if that's okay and hopefully by then we we uh uh the president will have made some decisions that's at the higher level can I can I quickly say I I just feel like there's kind of to what we're saying we're trying to go to there's going to be barely any other verbage that's going to to make a difference you know in comparison to what's currently being offered and so this has been this has been postponed for a long time and and we just got to go by the will of the board yeah I I'm I'm willing to eliminate the language particular in light
215of um what the current president is doing um and if we have Federal contracts I'm I'm interested in just eliminating the language now it to tell you the truth um because if we want to keep those uh federal dollars um you know we have to toally well I'll say this what I what I will say is um so he's he's got laws he's got the he's got he just signed into law of these the elimination he's not a rule follower we we do have a hand um from commissioner LeBron thank you I just want to point out um that I expressed about two months ago right after the election um and our superintendent our inm currently is doing the analysis but for us it's it's about $237 million um of Federal Aid that we currently
216get not including other grants that come from the federal um and to commissioner Elliot's Point yeah there was a bunch of new executive orders over about a 100 issued and people are going through them um and I also think that this is going to be the time that we have to make difficult decisions but we're going to have to make the right decision so that we minimize the impact both to our students and to our families um I don't think this is going to be the time to be bolster and try to push our way because we're not going to have the support we don't have the Congress we don't have the Senate we don't have the White House so I think we have to be actually very strategic and intelligent in these decisions um
217and that doesn't take away from the commitment always to have the most qualified and diverse Workforce um across this District that that doesn't take away or distract from that um but it is over $200 million that we would not be able to recoup or recover or be able to move forward as a district thank you thank you commissioner LeBron and so what was the title that you were thinking of I said dor I said director of equity but we could we could go back and just figure out what would be what would be sufficient if we can't use equity there's something that we could probably use all I'm saying is giving the time to next to the next meeting to to do that bring it back if we if we don't agree on it then
218we can just go ahead move at this particular time because I think and general counsel you can redirect me if I'm not correct um if we move forward with just uh because it doesn't seem like there's a supportive appe it of doing it there is a huge risk um this is an individual and I'm speaking about the president who um doesn't necessarily follow R follows rules and some of the things that he's enacting and implementing right now are contradicting some of our laws including the removal of the Constitution from people to be even seeing it like what are what are you doing there sir um so with that let me be careful right um if we just didn't do this tonight and for some strange reason he decides he you know that we're not coming
219after de Federal uh nothing's going to happen there is there an opportunity to bring this back under consideration um if if if it doesn't go away to the abyss right right so so I think the the board is going to see this again a third time right so I I think folks people can um the the Commissioners can change your minds um have further you know thoughts considerations and at the the third reading if there's there amendments and things like that people want to propose uh it could be done then um I would say the um the the the there's a focus on the title but it's it's really the work because and and and whoever this person is will have to report to the superintendent right and it says superintendent director of OC or
220design so whoever is doing that work will report to the superintendent so I I I think as the language as is is is all-encompassing um however the board will see it again for a third time and and if um Minds have been changed at that point an amendment can be appro be proposed right then and there or it could be um uh uh uh with withdrawn at that point or or you know postponed to to another time I think um you know really those are the two options so when's the third reading uh clerkin we'll be in a February business meeting on the 27th of February so yeah I I would um I would um caution you commissioner Griffin we don't want we should not have any language in their referencing either I AG with
221you there I I just said I just to make the ver that we did was not going to be sorry guys I I I agree with you commissioner uh Elliot what I'm saying is that I want to make sure that we use verbiage that is correct not that's incorrect but I don't believe the verbiage that's in there right now should be the persons that they have in control of of of this particular issue or concern should be the ones that people should be responding to or to go to for concerns in reference to anything related to the you know a personal issue the chief as a chief of human human capital I don't think that that should be the person that people go to okay you want to have that in there only because I
222don't well that's my concern that is the person that they go to Human Resources I'm sorry point of order please I got hold on we got it we got it let me so I'm going to give it to commissioner Elliott and the reason I say that is yeah all right because I'm just saying the reason I say that is because again to commissioner um uh Leon's Point we've got over 200 million that question so we may not want to have the language around a diversity it's not going I would want it to be what I don't want it to be is going to the chief of human capital I would want it to be someone outside of that's just my opinion I think it would we need somebody outside not somebody that's already inside that's
223my so it sounds like we have found a uh at least a way to move forward this evening um it it there's still some things that we probably have to work out but what we're going to do is move forward to the third re uh reading it sounds like that's what I'm feeling is the board appetite to do so so how would I move forward doing that asking to move part of the process anyway yeah it just goes to the third reading Y no there no motions on the reading voting we're not voting well none of that we're not voting and and we had a motion on the table to no did it was removed because it never moved forward I'm sorry Amy I'm sorry commissioner oh I did not was there a second for
224commissioner Griffin's motion no I believe it paused when I stopped to find the date and so she didn't complete the motion got whole a whole new motion from the beginning to the end because it interrupted so motion second we we have to State what's being motioned first policy blank to BL to the third reading a motion to a I mean the second reading to vote for thir second reading we're supposed to be doing the second reading so we could just all first of all let's do this all of the all of these readings were for the second reading is so can we have a motion to approve all the readings to the second reading commissioner Griffin there's no motion at the readings so you don't need a motion it will just automatically go to the
225third reading next month and then you all will take the vote oh so we don't even need a motion at all right thank you what we're being motioned in the first place so so so so what just can I interject one second there was a motion in order to potentially send it to to postpone this right so there was a motion introduced by commissioner Griffin the the readings don't need a motion it automatically goes to the next reading at the at the third reading there is a motion to adopt the policies formerly so we' be resending this uh so so commissioner Griffin I guess can either withdraw that motion or I withdraw it I withdraw it so motion is withdrawn we're all set all right uh okay so we're going on forward with the how
226now I don't even know what to say what we doing now moving forward you you you all set with the readings we're all set okay second readings are concluded all right and at this time we have the executive session right so uh the board May convene into executive session to discuss matters leading to the appointment promotion discipline suspension dismissal or removal par of particular persons in pending or current litigation with general counsel so move second by commissioner Elliot second by vice president Malloy all in favor we are going into executive session thank you e