001e e e uh good evening um um this is the Rochester Board of Education work session on our budget my name is uh Cynthia Elliott president of the Rochester Board of Education uh the intent of this meeting really is for the board to have an opportunity to um to to to preview or to um engage in conversation around what the board believes the priorities uh should be and we also wanted to get ahead of this is because um we really want to make sure that we're doing this in advance um last year there was some uh last minute requests um and that um have the um board goals uh and we have the Strategic plan that would guide us uh but we certainly the Strategic plan that would guide us uh but we certainly want
002to um and we don't want to in any way Veer from those goals or uh the plan um and so the intent of this particular session is to have those kinds of um discussion and I'm sure that there may be things that may come up there may be uh people within the district or within the community that may have some concerns or some questions um and some input into this uh and we welcome that uh but we don't want it to be you know kind of last last minute kind of thing unless there's something that is happens within the community or happens within our world that we need to make adjustments with and so with that um and joining me let me just introduce my colleagues is commissioner Malloy commissioner Simmons vice president LeBron uh
003commissioner Patterson and uh commissioner Griffin who are joining us along with the superintendent and his staff and the state Monitor and so at this point I will turn it over to the superintendent superintendent de Mario oh I'm sorry yeah thank you so before we get started we do have one important um um meeting uh we have to go into executive session before we get started you can have all of that uh for when we come back um and so can I get a motion to go into executive session um moved by vice president LeBron seconded by commissioner Malloy all those in favor any oppos thank you so we'll go into executive session quickly and then we will come back out I believe so e e e so thank you we are we've returned from our
004executive session and we will continue with the budget work session and so at this time I will turn it over to Deputy Su s uh interim superintendent Demario Strickland uh interim superintendent yes thank you good evening uh president Elliott uh vice president LeBron board members in the Greater Rochester Community and colleagues that are watching uh first and foremost I wanted to start off with a statement for this evening um I want to thank you all for being here uh this week before our holiday break uh for this I want to say historic and transformative moment uh our District's first ever B Bo excuse me budget work session held this early in the season um as you may know this is not just another meeting it's an opportunity to build a foundation for unprecedented growth by
005activating dreams and unlocking potential for every student we serve the budget is more than a financial document it's a reflection of our values strategic priorities and communities aspirations while the superintendent provides input and guidance to align the budget with these priority it's the board's responsibility to pass a balanced budget that matches the vision of our strategic plan and the values of the Greater Rochester Community this process is more about it's more than numbers it's about designing Pathways to empower us our students support our Educators and uplift our entire District together through collaboration and Innovation we can balance fiscally uh we can balance fiscal resp responsibility with bold ambition transforming ideas into action and ensuring every decision reflects meaningful impact for those we serve let us move forward tonight with purpose and resolve by working together
006we can meet challenges with creativity transform possibilities into realities and shape a future of Excellence for our district thank you for your dedication your Insight and un and your unwavering commitment to this journey and we can begin so next slide so first and foremost I want to uh align our budget session with uh one of the action or excuse me one of the items in our strategic plan uh this aligns to goal number 5A uh which is to submit a balanced budget to the Board of Education uh goal 5B is actual general fund Revenue exceeds budget by no more than 1% an actual general fund expense is under budget by no more than 2% and that is in place to help us maintain uh a balanced budget uh from year to year next slide there
007are important ramifications in our financial plan that are actually attached to this process um F1 talks about contract examination F2 and three talks about Staffing ratios F5 three years of historical data F9 position management action form that's uh our way of adding or changing uh position titles uh in our uh people soft system f17 vacancy analysis F18 identification of Revenue and f24 through 28 is just uh recommendations on the budget development as a whole now really quick um in your executive summary you probably noticed you have a list of contracts um I will talk a little bit about that uh later in this uh presentation um we're talking about Staffing ratios so every collective bargaining well excuse me in our teacher collective bargaining agreement there are ratios between the number of staff and the amount
008of students that are in our schools and we want to make sure that we are being fiscally responsible by having those ratios accurately reflect what is in those agreements uh it's important to use three years of historical data and that we want to look at what our actuals are from one year to the next to determine what funds are actually needed to continue to meet uh our goals that we set forth for the community the position position management action form that's an area where I really want to take a deep dive look at and I've brought those things to you earlier and that what are the positions that we have in each department uh how are we bringing new positions to the Board of Education even if they are in the form of contingency just
009for greater transparency to you all and the public vacancy analysis uh we have vacancies we have uh vacancies in the form of there's no individuals in the position position there's vacancies in the form of there's individuals that are employed with us that are hitting uh lines uh with budgeted budgets attached um how do we do away with those positions that have been longstanding with no one actually in the position and someone actually taking on the responsibility of that uh of that uh task or of that position and how do we uh probably reimagine uh our vacancies in a different way in order to get them filled identification of Revenue that's something that happens extremely early and that we are looking for individ excuse me we're looking for the funds that come in from uh state
010and local government as well as the federal government um and also any other grants and um items that help uh with the overall finances for the district and then finally the budget development it's just the process that we will undertake undertake uh for the next five months next slide wanted to look at the budget calendar Milestone so in October we already provided you with a a draft uh budget calendar um and in November at the uh I believe it was the finance meeting or the general body meeting we did provide you with the current budget forecast uh that that's where we just simply rolled over the funds uh with 4% increases in contracts and uh regular everyday expenses health care so on and so forth and uh projected what our possible Gap is in December
011um we have uh our Department of Finance has provided the budget documents to department managers and uh this Friday uh those budget documents and might I add it's not only operational budgets but we're also talking about Staffing in each department uh our DU to the finance office to begin constructing the budget in January our governor uh Kathy hoko provides uh or presents us with an executive budget uh we have we are proposing this year prior to budget presentations that uh commenced last year we would like our budget analyst our grant monitors and our department managers to actually have budget uh meetings together to determine if there's any overlap between what we have in title funds or excuse me through grants and in our general a fund budgets uh at the end of January uh I
012myself the state monitor uh members of my staff uh our fiscal consultant will sit through budget presentations each and every single day to review Staffing that must have Staffing justifications on what individuals do uh within our organization to determine if this is going to be a necessity and something that's going to help further improve student achievement as well as the operational budgets we will review those uh and by the end of the month it's with the hopes that we will have an initial draft book uh to present next slide in February we have to have a balanced budget completed because by March 1st we must turn in our um our budget to our state monitor as per the law uh uh under uh Financial excuse me under uh school districts that are under monitorship um
013in March already stated that uh we will provide you a copy of the budget book um and it will be available digit itally uh for the public um there will be a superintendent and state monitor presentation provided by myself and Mr Alisa uh talking about highlights around the budget and re uh bringing up this process again to talk about uh how we got into the journey where we are and then March at the end that's where you begin to submit your questions for Budget deliberations uh so that we are prepared doing in the April budget deliberation meetings uh with the answers to your questions around our budget we we've uh requested uh last year and and the hopes is that this continues this year that there is a budget presentation to city council which is
014ahead of schedule rather than after the fact to also Garner their thoughts around uh our budget finally in may we bring to you the budget for a board of education vote and then our hopes is that at the end of May we have a final budget book published and with that being said uh I would like my acting Chief uh Derek Blair to discuss the next two slides around the budget Gap thank good evening vice president LeBron president Elliott and viewing public uh as I presented before uh a couple of steps that need to happen when you're first determining um a budget is is figure out do we have enough money and what how we do that is first of all estimate our Revenue uh our revenue is estimated right now at about 918 million
015and our our budget expense is estimated at about 955 million so that leaves us with a $38 million budget Gap this is just estimated general fund budget and um you can you can actually move to the next slide please we presented in the documents a period 4 funds uh that kind of show you what we have budgeted for in each one of these sections General support instruction um transportation community service benefits these budgets need to be amended by at least 4% to cover our expenses next year and you can go to the next slide um but okay but basically um we need to come up with some savings at around $38 million thank you I'll leave I'll give it back to superintendent and just really quick the one of the documents that is available for
016the public that shows uh that there's three years of data that are in front of you and that's going to be very uh beneficial in helping us make uh some U you know great hopeful great decisions on getting to that Balan budget so you may ask um what are we going to do to address this Gap because we have to address the Gap I want to be very clear uh and it's been reiterated uh time and time again since the election we have no idea what next year's um forecast will look uh will look like and our state Monitor and our Board of Education president made it very clear that uh we need to leave fund balance alone and because of the state of where our country may be going that is something we need
017to definitely uh consider that needs to be at one of the top priorities however uh there are some things that we can do right off the bat we could look at our full-time equivalents so those are the employees throughout the district looking at central office looking at our school buildings looking uh at our facilities um and determining are those positions necessary uh meaning are they mandated does the commissioner state that you have to have this position for instance we can't go and say we're going to cut a principal you can't do that by law you must every school must have a principal however there are positions where they are not covered by the commissioner's regulations and other individuals can actually carry on those functions we have to look at our operational expenses uh so we
018need to start properly forecasting if you know that we have $50,000 in an in in an account and yet we've only spent 20,000 of those dollars we need to start practicing some fiscal responsibility and saying you know what I'm going to cut by 20,000 for the next year because I know that I don't need those expenses to um to be in my budget we're also needing to look at double budgeting that is the reason why I would like those meetings between the budget analysts between the department uh head and between the grant monitors to work together because at times we don't know that we've budgeted for something in our a funds as well as our title funds so in order to uh make sure we know what's accounted for in both funds it's good to
019have all those individuals meet and I want that meeting prior to actually coming to us for the budget presentations looking at the contracts in your executive summary uh you've seen there's a host of contracts many of those are mandated however some of those are not mandated and we have to just look at where we spending our resources are we getting the return on investment uh for the amount of funds that we are providing uh outside entities to help help us reach our strategic goals and um and it's many contracts um next looking at vacancies as I explained before we have current vacancies and that there are positions that are just there that have no one in them someone's actually doing that work this year is it necessary is this or can those responsibilities be rolled
020into to someone else's position and then we have long-term vacancies those generally would be a lot easier to just make Cuts because these are vacancies that have been carried over from year after year after year and there's there could be some savings there and finally uh trups something we have not done in the past at least in the three years that I've been here are actually taking a look at had our classrooms full and where can we get our efficiencies so that we don't have to uh so that we don't over staff when we don't need to over staff our goal is to try to stay away from schools however trups generally do impact schools uh specifically as it goes with class size so you walk into a school you might see one student or
021two students on the books uh there may be four students on our student information system uh that may be in Period two but then period five you see that same class with 10 students how do we combine those so we can get efficiencies out of that and that generally has not been done I want I I don't want to say it hasn't been done holistically but uh as effectively each year um and that's where we are looking to address some of those savings and finally participatory budgeting so last year the uh the public had input on the design of the budget book um I truly value what the community thinks and what the community feels in terms of B budget priorities and making sure that they reflect the values of uh Greater Rochester and also
022the students that we serve in the Rochester City School District so I am proposing we have a meeting on Friday to meet with individuals uh from an agency that partici that helps us put together a um document of some sort sorry electronic document I can't find the words where we ask the public what it is that they um feel that we should add funds or where should our priorities lie um there's still some ideas being floated around um but nonetheless um I would say after the break and probably early January there will be some sort of press release to really talk about uh this to the public and really uh harness the inputs of all of our community members and the key benefits are increases transparency uh builds Community trusts and it ensures equity and
023resource allocation and I will even go forward or go forth with also saying we have some tough decisions to make and we need to enlist the support and help of the community to help make an own some of those decisions that we have to make and this is a vehicle uh to ensure that process so with that being said that is the end of the presentation uh I will go take a seat now this is uh very early in the process um as much as possible I will in try to make sure I can answer your question in the event that I cannot uh we will place those in the uh budget log and ensure that you get uh a response that is accurate and um acceptable thank you thank you I think what I'd
024like to start off with If the vice president doesn't mind is to for her to talk about since she's been a champion of participatory budget uh if uh the vice president could uh share with us exactly what participatory budget is for those in the room and also for those who are in our community vice president thank you president Elliott and um just so everyone's clear we use the tool balancing act that is the company that we have a contract with there are lots of other companies however Balancing Act um is also in the Syracuse school district and they were the first school district to roll out a actual participatory budgeting tool aimed at giving their parents their community members greater voice voice to how the budget gets spent um and so I'll give an example
025it could be that we are facing as you just heard $38 million in Cuts where should those cuts be and often times those those decisions are really happening with superintendent the administration to the board but the folks who are in the classroom and even families sometimes actually have a greater sometime greater ideas of how those cuts should look like right and so sometimes I find that often we do get it wrong right because we're sort of thinking this position and we don't know how critical that position is versus getting feedback from both the school community and families um and community members um so participatory budgeting allows us to uh forward facing put our budget out there and then also give options of decisions that we really have to make both as the administration and the
026board and gives the public an opportunity to weigh in um it'll allow us to not just make positive decisions but some negative ones too right if we have to close four schools we can put out these are the schools we're looking at here are the reasons why and help us select and give input as well from the community there might be things again that we have a blind spot to or we may not be able to see um and so the meeting on Friday is to discuss how far and deep we're going to go into it this year um we have been trying to roll out participatory budgeting for about 3 to four years now it started with other superintendents who were here and Dr jallow was the first one to the first state appointed
027monitor to help us sort of get going with that um and it's hard to do an Implement when we've had transition from both the superintendent and our CFO because it does require that stability from those departments to sort of help us champion this um but the goal is going to be to eventually have our entire budget up loaded into this participatory formatting and the public will then have a say in how we even vote on these things and then I do think in the long run it helps both the community have input and say and it takes away this we are making decisions without all of the information and input at all levels it sort of removes that for them and it to the Super the interim superintendent point it does create greater transparency because
028here are the we have here are the decisions we have to make and these are our options help us make these decisions and we'll end up landing and sort of supporting is my goal and hope that the board then takes that feedback and where folks sort of landed on these decisions and that's how we then decide right if 86% of our community doesn't want us to close a specific school and has voted for us to perhaps look at a different school we I think have an obligation to listen to our community members with the data and the data will be there because of the participatory budgeting tool um last year we rolled it out with as the superintendent mentioned with the budget book we took a number of budget books from other school districts to
029have visuals because the tool allows you to create questions have visuals even videos to help explain what people are voting on um but we took visuals from other school districts and gave explanations and we ran f focus groups as well so we ask those focus groups members to not only participate in the tool itself but to give us feedback in those focus groups and that was led by our board clerk with lots of parent groups and gathered all that information to present back and that's how we sort of landed on the budget book format that we currently have now is it perfect let me just say no and this is going to be our first time rolling it out to a greater degree than we did last year and so I am conf confident that
030it will only get better as time goes on and so I say that to bear with us because again this will be the first time we're sort of looking to activate and turn it on into actual questions centered around monetary decisions um and then lastly and I'll say this um other school districts um are moving towards this model especially where you have school districts where community members don't get to vote and have a say and that's the biggest and that all has to do with laws around how taxes and Levy and all those things but nonetheless every other school district in the state of New York except the big five get to have a say in their actual budget and what decisions are made as parents except for the big five and so a lot
031of big fives are moving in towards this model Now Syracuse school district and their city council do it jointly and we're not there yet and I want to be clear but that should be the goal in the future future that we do look to city council and the school district and figure out how we give voice to the community together of how they want to see their streets and their schools work together Syracuse is there we're not but I will give kudos to the city who has their own participatory budgeting process and tool that they use to give in put on their budget um so baby steps but we're there I'm really excited that we're going to get to actually being able have used the tool in the budget it's been a long time coming
032for this board for this community and so is a really exciting time we have a lot of Community Partners who also support this and would lend us support in even running classes workshops and um helping parents right like the I know there are groups like citizens action the library there are groups who have offered to give us space give us laptops computers if we wanted to host these sessions we also don't have to be the only ones to host it the tool allows for other organizations to say you know what I'm going to take my parent group today and we're going to hold a participatory budgeting dinner and have laptops for people to give input and we can give them support so that they can use the tool um but we don't need to be
033there they don't even need our permission to do it and we encourage I want to encourage people now to do that um including Commissioners you all can say I'm going to host a budget evening at Javas right right you all can do that and bring laptops and tell and families can do that on their phone too so let me be clear that it's not that everyone needs to have a laptop or a tablet it's also mobile friendly so even if folks did not have access to tablets they can do the tool from home on their phone on a computer on a public computer a private computer it is a very easily accessible tool um and we'll make it accessible too as we move forward but that's all I have on part anticipatory budgeting and that
034piece I do have some questions but I'm going to stop now yeah I'm going to go to uh based on what uh vice president you said about Syracuse just want to have uh State monitor Alisa to comment about participatory budget and how it works in Syracuse question okay good evening thank you president Elliot for giving me the opportunity uh we began participatory budgeted in syracus around 2017 and it began first in the City School District then the city joined the district to use the format and what we did once we had an idea of what the budgeted was we went to the public with the areas of instruction facilities Support Services with the total amount of the budget that it was going to be during that year people had the opportunity to give us suggestions
035but if they thought that they wanted to increase instruction they needed to reduce in the other areas so they could not increase the budget they needed to work within the amount that was already presented to the public the idea is to balance the budget with the money that is already allocated then the city followed the same format and they began to do the same things with the city budget you know what how much money should go into operations how much money should go to parks and R how much money should go for uh snow removal all that so they were doing the same but it began first with the city school district using the the format all right thank you state monitor so we'll start with questions and I'll start with commissioner Malloy awesome thank
036you so much and thank you for your presentation uh this evening obviously well and thank you also to commissioner LeBron vice president LeBron for talking about participatory budgeting it's great to have a better understanding of how that what that looks like and I'm excited to see us um roll that out and implement it and get that feedback from our community members because we don't always U know everything as Commissioners and so I think every bit helps and I think that also is going to help us when we go to implement our governance model and and form those guard rails um which is really their statements of of what we value uh in the community and and that's wrapped in into our budgeting obviously um so I am concerned obviously about a 30 million projected Gap
037and I think that clearly indicates a lack of sustainability in the future and within a few years we could be in the same shape that we were when I first um came on to the board um I was elected in 2019 and the district had just um just cut many positions or over 200 positions I believe um so obviously I'm really concerned and want to make sure that we're moving in a direction that allows us to develop a sustainable model we're going to have to make some really difficult decisions um I for one want to make sure that we make those decisions um as far away from the classroom as possible um I I think we need to start looking at non-mandated Services we have to analyze those their effectiveness um and I and I
038want us also to think about what is going to most likely have a positive impact on our students academically speaking um and so I'll just say one other thing and then kind of stop there um you know we're supposed to be coming up with priorities uh this evening and I know obviously my priorities are around academic goals so far um literacy reading um safety both physical social emotional and then CTA CTE rather for our high school students um but we do we have to start thinking about um those making those difficult cuts and I'd prefer to see them as far away from the classroom as POS possible so thank you uh thank you commissioner Malloy commissioner Simmons thank you president Elliot um and thank you uh State monitor Alisa around this um breaking down the
039scenario based budgeting that would take place because I think that's important to recognize we're working within a certain number and a lot of times folks are um they have things that they'd like to see happen without consideration of how that impacts other pieces so um I love that it is real time U mapping if you will and um similar to commissioner Malloy when we consider um positions that may need to be cut I'm thinking about obviously cut the fat right cut the fat the unneeded pieces but some fat is good for you and so when we are cutting the fat the unnecessary um weight that we may be carrying making sure we do it um with Precision because when you're looking at a piece of paper it's easy to say well these positions can absorb
040can be absorbed here um but not recognizing how it will impact or overwhelm um the workforce so just being really strategic and around how that happens but recognizing it does need to happen um I do have some um priorities as well I'm not going to go get into all of them but three that I want to just um mention off the top would be transportation is a concern for me um because it is impacting attendance on some levels uh very much so um of course you know literacy is a strong strong passion of mine um and then CTE because as far as our children persisting and being prepared for the workforce and so on we do need to make sure they're armed appropriately I like the direction we're going in but we have a long
041way to go thank you commissioner Simmons vice president LeBron oh my God all right um for me I'm not going to State any priorities um I've mentioned that I actually we've never taken our budget and aligned it with the Strategic plan and I kind of would like to leave it to the superintendent to present to us what that alignment looks like based on those priorities and our goals um but I do want to put on the board question log some questions because I do not think they can be answered tonight I'm okay with that um but on this handout that you just gave us it has that our 82% is the projected general fund Revenue from that we're receiving from the state of New York so I'm assuming that that means 18% is what we're
042depending on at the federal level um based on this handout right here first page second paragraph um and so this is for the board question log of I I still want to understand what percentage we're receiving of federal funds that's one two I am deeply concerned for what's to come in the next month this is not going to happen over years I want to be clear I have read project 2025 I encourage everyone to read project 2025 um and legally they're going to be able to do this I just have to put this out there that this is their legal Pathway to do these things and so if the Department of Education goes um and federal dollars goes because title $1 dollars are also going to be eliminated I just want to stress that we
043are a title one district and with great dependency and I don't know what that number means if I was to just go based on what I just got as a handout that said 82% is what we're receiving for revenues from the state that means 18% or about 209 million and that's just Federal and I'm not even clear if that includes title one and if you guys are counting title one under that so I would like those questions in the question log we need to and the city budget right because the city is also going to have cuts from federal but I know for us there's some really um scary things on the horizon I'll say that but the impact and I am with President Elliot you know in the past I know that we have
044saved money and we have worked very hard as a district to come out a of out of a deficit we had a deficit and to pay off our spinup loans because we were able to do that successfully last year however um the little bit of money that we do have it goes very fast if we know we're going to be taking hits from the federal government over the next four years and so I definitely want us to not just make Cuts but start looking at how we can save right and buffer ourselves to have the least amount of harmful impact coming from the feds to the state to us that's all thank you vice president I'll go down to commissioner Griffin do you have any questions can you hear me now um some of us
045have touched on it a little bit um with the when we look at the cuts that that could take place um for me I would think that we should stay as far as away from the schools as possible and teachers and more geared towards um central office and in in the leadership down in central office and put some and maybe take some of the folks that are here and move them in back into the schools to have a better understanding of what the school system looks like um and what what are some of the administration administrators and the staffs Staffing in the schools look like and what they're dealing with on a day-to-day basis I believe there's no overload here in the central office and um some people need to be moved around that is
046my opinion so I would ask that we if we with any cutting be done it should be done here and not in the school systems cuz we're already at a shortage for teachers um um I wanted to say a little bit about the transportation there is a big Transportation issue but I think that stems from a lot of from the reconfiguration I'll say that over and over again because if you take a school on the east side and move it to the West Side you are messing with transportation for parents when you also mess with times and times start times for schools you also mess with parents every parent does not start a school at the same time so when we start talk about Transportation issues we have to make make um make everyone aware
047of some of the leadership and administrative decision that are made are not conducive to our to our parents and maybe to teachers and to people that could drive the bus and get our children's to inform to and from school and my last statement or question or comment I will make it has to do with um and you may have answered this but the access um of the public to the B to the budget to the budget data can you say that again access to the to the public to the budget data and it may have been answered I'm not sure if it was answered but I would like to know how would how how are they going to have access to the budget and like I said I could have missed it and I apologize
048if it's redundant but if you could definitely answer those questions for me I would greatly appreciate yes absolutely no problem um so there's only one question if I'm not mistaken right well I would like input on on your thoughts in reference to in reference to moving away from the the the um the schools and and and basically looking at central office to reduce Staffing here because that definitely will will help us cutting cutting positions here then taking then move and taking them from the from the schools when we're already at a shortage for teachers for my understanding right absolutely uh great point if you have uh seen in the presentation uh I've placed uh mandated versus non-mandated staff um most of the mandated staff are in fact in schools most of the non-mandated staff are
049in fact in central office uh so we do know that we have to take a real tough look at the Staffing um all over you know what I mean but really uh within this building alone and not just saying that but as I said before we put it out there um we have to look at the non-mandated positions that um exist and um of course if in in the event and and we don't know what this is going to look like as of yet we haven't undergone that process around the justifications of staff and whatnot but of course we would like to hopefully open up opportunities for those individuals to go into mandated positions okay um so that was the one thing uh you're talking about start times uh I I I want to I
050I I really want to reiterate that Transportation it's not just a city of Rochester issue um it literally is the conversation that every superintendent every table I go to we are talking about the same thing and there are some items that made things easier uh in terms of transportation and that the the middle schools are zoned but we still have outliers where we've had to cross zone for special education programming uh maybe a a specific bilingual program uh we we still have to commit to providing those services to those students because they are mandated and then finally uh the budget book uh in its initial phase and its uh published phase um is available it's a public document um and everyone will get to see that um moreover the individuals if they wanted to look
051at last years they could go on to the website and it is still posted there I appreciate that I just want to make it clear though so some people may not understand when the terms mandated non-mandated because they can look at it in different lights so we need to make make sure we speak clearly in reference to what the public may not or may understand so we need to make sure we do that Absolut also I just want to say for me and for this district there there is an ongoing concern when I speak to parents as to the the changes that were made when we did the reconfiguration and closed one school on East Side to West Side that can that definitely had an impact on a lot of parents because now they're taking
052them from one side of town to the other side of town and then they have to work so when we make these changes we need to basically look look out the lens of a parent not just not this Administration and I think that's the big problem problem with our leadership is that we're not looking at we're looking at the glass half full and not full we're we're we're affecting people and parents in their homes in a way that you don't know you know and then you then you don't see it until the school year starts you see it school start when the school year starts then we have these problems with Transportation with the parents well I can't leave work and do this I can't leave work and do that you have to look at
053the glass full and not half full when it comes to our parents and our teachers we not doing that and I see it I see it all the time and that's why we have an effect on the attendance thank you commissioner um Griffin uh commissioner um Patterson thank you I'm going to be a little bit blunt this evening with the public and uh let them know speak for myself number one as a commissioner but number two to let you know that this problem it didn't have to occur I said a few years ago when the those uh federal funds state funds ARP and cers of funds we were using them for positions I said way back then that we're going to have a problem when those funds are gone retaining those positions and I said
054back then to the administration don't come to me I speak for myself not for the board but I am a part of the board and ask us to find ways now to retain those positions you should be coming to us and again that was a prior Administration PRI prior leadership but these things were noted way back then also uh when we talk about this $38 million deficit that we're going to be going into we talk about Transportation school choice and Zoning I spoke relative to that and said yeah we we would like each kid to have their choice of schools and things like that but you know you know it's just not going to work as far as funding you know we build these beautiful schools in these neighborhoods but we don't direct our kids
055you know to those schools we give choice of wherever they they want to go which costs the taxpayers a lot of money so yeah we have to make hard choices you know as board members but then again like we're doing here we're letting the public know why we're in a deficit the decisions that we've made as a board you know these decisions that we made that has affected our budget negatively impacted a budget so we have to look at ourselves as a board and say what could we have done better yes the superintendent and andum superintendent they present us with information but it's up to us as a board how we vote on those things and sometimes we have to make hard decisions and I don't think we made the decisions we should have made
056when it comes to this budget if we see ourselves now right back in a $38 million Bud uh deficit and I'm not even a math major and I said way back then I could see that there was going to be issues I talked about or spoke about electronic bus or electric buses that we should have we could have had those for free given to us through Senator jild Brand's contacts for free and moved forward into the future but some didn't see the future and something that we could have had that you know we're going into you know everything's becoming like EVS right electric vehicles and things like that less pollution we didn't see that we failed I spoke very directly people don't like that word but sometimes you have to be direct when you want
057to enact change and when we see individuals or the administration moving individuals from directors to executive directors that's an increase in number one pay number one but number two now you're filling another spot another position with another sixf fig job all these things I saw years ago when those funds were being utilized for positions and try to relate that information you know to uh you know the individuals on this board so again I'm not saying I'm perfect I'm just saying I had some ideas and that would have helped us so we wouldn't be in this position at this point in time thank you I'm not I'm not done yet thank you um Oracle Oracle how many millions of dollars are we spending on Oracle at this point in time we have to take a deep
058dive a deep look I would ask the administration you know I'm just a board member so I'm not going to be doing it but I would ask the administration take a deep dive into Oracle and look at the dollars that are being spent is it worth it could we have done something better or do we go forward I don't have the answer to that and so you know these again when we go to the the prior Administration we look at Union contracts and my parents were Union people so I don't have anything negative to say relative to the union people or unions but will I what I will say is that decisions were made on these contracts that didn't think about where we be today as far as the budget and a $38 million deficit
059so yes um I want to work with my colleagues but I want to uh uh move forward um with a different way of teaching and learning again I also would not like to touch any schools um I don't know what's going to happen here but at this point in time I think the the schools you know should be left alone um if anything we need more psychologists and counselors and social workers you know uh with what we're dealing with in our communities um but we have to find ways uh working with my colleagues here and and the administrative staff uh to do better uh to cut this deficit and we're going to have to make some very hard and difficult choices thank you I got it yeah yeah so are you done commissioner Patterson yes
060ma'am all right so um some of my colleagues want to have some clarity some clarity so let me before I get to commissioner Santiago let me let's just put some some clarity to what has been said um first of all I want to say in terms of even with I know the appearance is is that you have in uh central office all of these high paying um employees um but the fact of the matter is if you look at the budget when it comes to the administrative line versus the line of teachers and others it far outweighs um the budget line for administrators not saying that you can't reduce that line but don't look at only cutting because you still will have a budget Gap if you only cut from central office so the fact
061of the matter is we will have to get into the schools we will have to make some decisions there so all you have do is look at the budget and you could count there's more there's there's more teachers and others versus administrators that line is much bigger and so you got to cut there so that's number one um number two is is that um a lot of the Gap that we have has to do with Legacy cost has to do with our Union costs where our unions are getting three and four% so that's what's also increased as well as health care costs that are increases so it's not a deficit we haven't gotten there yet we just have a gap that we're trying to determine where do we make uh those cuts with regard to
062Oracle Oracle while it is expensive over the long run it is going to be the most efficient system that we're having because right now our systems are inefficient uh payroll is one place HR is one place we want to try to put those all together so yes we are making an investment in the beginning so that in the long run it is going to save us money is going to be far more cost efficient so I just want to make sure that it is clear about exactly what we're doing it is a gap is being presented to us we have not made a decision about how we even going to close that Gap yet but we want to bring it to we want to talk about it now and we want to make sure the
063the the community is aware of it we do plan on closing the Gap uh with hope through efficiencies I'm hoping we don't have to spend any money from the fund balance um but when and let me just also say I've been here a long time and we are always presented ever since I've been here there's always been a presentation around a budget Gap not a budget deficit but a budget Gap so I want to uh make that clear so I'll go on to superintendent you want to also add here and uh just to further ad and thank you for that clarification um uh in the presentation I also talked about the governor's uh executive and legislative budget oh excuse me the Govern 's executive budget and also our legislative budget this is a budget Gap
064and it depends on what those actual numbers that are presented in January and voted on uh in her uh if if the legislator votes for her budget um it could change there's a possibility we could see nothing you know as as a gap um it's it's very likely but I want to reiterate if we were to carry over everything that we have today and start next year July 1 uh with all of those same things we have a $38 million gap so I just want to be clear but again that's why you were provided um and you know not going against anyone uh there's information for you uh so that you are aware you know that we are thinking about how we're going to close that Gap we are going to be very efficient and
065meticulous and what it is that we're doing when we make difficult decisions and we just want to ensure contined transparency in our process thank you thank you uh deput uh interim superintendent commissioner Santiago yeah I I was just wondering when it comes to this $38 million gap and this may have been covered already but but what exactly from what areas is this Gap coming from is it from from funds or grants that won't be coming back in uh in the 2025 year um just wondering what what the what is this Gap $38 million what is this Gap coming from so many uh many many districts uh they're all starting with gaps for the most part I just want to put that out there as well and most of the Gap already starts with increases in
066compensation for our employees and general um and generally they range between uh three and 4% so right off the bat as well as uh increases in health care um when you put all those things combined we're already 38 million in the whole last year we were in a similar predicament but not as much because of arpen cersa and that Gap was around 14 million if I'm not mistaken okay um thank you thank you for that and I will agree with majority of the board here on of course the the while we're looking at where the $38 million gap can be uh covered that we're looking at the positions and you gave the superintendent earlier about you know what what the plans are as far as attacking the Gap and so I'm hoping that we are
067looking at those things and I'm in full agreement with how you plan to uh to exercise um meeting the Gap and getting to $38 million um of course going to the positions that are unneeded which is uh something that you shared um and when it comes to this upcoming budget some of the things that that I support um and that I hope to see in this budget in agreement with commissioner um Malloy and commissioner Simmons uh of course CTE literacy uh for myself of course emotional support social emotion support uh the students extracurricular activities and services um I agree with commissioner Simmons on transportation and also in uh safety and security not specifically for that department but um looking at at ways that we can secure our our students and and provide security for our
068students in the schools um I think that we have to think out of the box and so I'm hoping uh that that we are able to do that um and provide uh funding behind us thinking outside the box when it comes to keeping our schools safe um I'll also say that this has been a conversation from this board for years when it comes to uh the school communities um and having the school location be in the community of of of the student or in the surrounding areas and I would say for the elementary and middle school level um you know I fully support that but I think once we get to the high school level uh things get a little bit different but $38 million gap here um and so I'm hoping to see how
069and and looking forward to see how you guys plan to meet that Gap um and of course if you guys can stay away from the students in the classroom as much as possible thank you commissioner Santiago one one more thing president uh for 2025 um I know what you know something that's always also at stake is um the funding for our our free school lunches for the students and so I think that that's something that should be um that should be analyzed as far as a plan uh because we don't want to be dropped with that and not have a plan forward on how we'll we'll provide lunches for the students the good thing is we're in Upstate New York where there's a lot of farms around and it would be great how we can
070to see how we can partner with those Farms to see I know also New York state is offering a grant and so I'm not sure the details if it's available to the big five districts yeah but there there's a a grant for the schools to use uh some of the resources from the farms and so I'm hoping to see how we can do that together to to still provide lunches for our students to provide good lunches with nutritional values um and and to find a way to to to ease this you know if it does come to the point where our funding for lunches uh is gone and it could be an opportunity truly it can be an opportunity for us to to better the lunches for our students and so I'm hoping to see
071that that's it commissioner Santiago all right okay uh so let me just thank my colleagues for their uh input I have just a couple of things and then I want to end with a with a statement and then if the superintendent has some other remarks he can make those remarks um but I want us to look thoroughly at the contracts uh we've got a number of cont contracts out there that we need to look at are they um uh in our best interest in our student best interest do they align with the board goals do they align with with the Strategic plan uh and I also know that when we look at graduation rates the the the groups that are um still needing to improve uh is elll and um sped and so if we
072can put funding um around those areas in order to uh I think our graduation rate would increase as a result of that uh but let me also End by saying this um because I want you all to be encouraged I don't care what we have going on in Washington I come from a people who went through slavery went through the middle passages had to come through being slavery had to go through Jim Crow I know that we as a people we make a way out of nowhere and so even if the federal funds were ended what I know from my people that we make a way when there is no way we all we select we elected a black president in a country that is totally racist and so if we can do that this
073is just a drop in the bucket of what we can do I'm also looking at the creativity that will come out of this don't know what the president the president-elect is going to do but I do know what my people have done over 400 years and this is no this is a piece of cake um to what they've gone through and I know that with hard work and creativity we can make sure that our children continue to exceed academically uh in this country we've been here before as a people I know it and so I want to again thank all my colleagues uh for their input uh Mr superintendent if you have some comments I also have something to say well why don't you say what you got to say first um I want to
074uh reply or respond to um commissioner patteron there's no need to reply because it's already been stated you've had your what you point of privilege point of privilege because it to do it um was there a comment directed at you commissioner uh something that uh was misquoted we'll say that so point of privilege I have the right I I I'm going to defer to unless my my apologies uh commissioner I didn't hear anything specifically kind of directed at you um or anything out of the rules of of protocol um and that's that's typically what a point of privilege is um is is used for um so but I think I heard the chair was going to allow you to to make your statement so I think you can make your statement thank you yeah so
075once again question is no EXC We're not gonna make statements I'm gonna let the super I'm gonna speak you cut me off if you want but I'm going to speak the main difference between a budget Gap and a budget deficit is that a budget Gap is projection of future imbalances while a budget deficit is a current year imbalance r i want to be clear we're not something that was said relative to commissioner you're speaking out of order now as well so so commissioner Patterson I I heard you make your statement now the cheer would like to give the the superintendent the the well I'm going to say what I have to say that that's when it came to Oracle I would like the public to know when it came to Oracle the Investments that we
076had went over theair over and Beyond the floor she gets to say as the chair who's speaking she's the budget with or commissioner pleas it doesn't commissioner please it doesn't it doesn't work like this and time implementation of the project increase cut the mic so we can get out of here I got kids to go home to all right okay thank you superintendent superintendent she's the president she can't Absol don't don't don't leave it alone come on leave it alone go ahead superintendent can read the bylaws fact you all prepared better and we would be in a much better position as well superintendent well I uh just wanted to say thank you all for your uh suggestions and thoughts um as it pertains to uh this season's budget process uh do know that um my
077my values my personal values and transparency and and openness and and making sure that um there's some inclusivity with the public and the overall Community is uh really at the Forefront here and we are going to uh have to take a deep look and make sure that we um make uh substantial uh decisions that are going to close this Gap um committed to staying away from the classroom as much as possible uh yet also thinking about overall efficiencies so I wanted to be very clear because we do have some efficiencies within our schools as well okay I just um I I want to put that out there um because some people may feel impacted but again I gave the example earlier around if a class English class has five kids in this one class and
078then in another class that same English class same level has 10 kids the efficiency would be to put those classes together and save the FTE um in some way shape or form but uh with that being said I have uh wrote or excuse me typed everything you all have uh provided and I will be sure that I work with uh my staff to provide you a balanced budget um that really reflects the goals of the Strategic plan and uh is acceptable to our state monitor as well as the commissioner of education so thank you all right thank for