001e e e good evening everyone listening audience uh welcome to the equity and student achievement Committee of the whole uh today is Tuesday December 10th and we are going to um open our meeting at this time before we move into the agenda items I do want to uh make sure that I do go over the board goals that we have uh situated for this year 2023 to 2028 should I say and those board goals are are four comprehensive goals one being increase the percentage of students in grades 3 through eight who are proficient on the New York State Ela assessment from 16% in SE September 2023 to 40% in June of 2028 all students reading by third grade increase the percentage of students proficient on the third grade New York State Ela from 15% in
002September of 2023 to 50% in June of 20 28 the third goal increase the percentage of students in grades 3 through 8 who are proficient on the New York state math assessment from 14% in September 2023 to 40% by June of 2028 and lastly number four and certainly not least uh increase the number of students earning five or more credits in 9th grade from 70% in September 2023 to 90% by June of 2028 and those are our board goals available uh for your viewing on our website um moving forward in the agenda I do not see any speakers listed um for this evening and next I'd like to entertain a motion to review and accept the minutes from the November 12th 2024 Esa Committee of the whole so move move by commissioner Malloy second seconded
003by Santiago commissioner Santiago all in favor I I the vote has gone forward and the minutes are approved um I'm going to move into the agenda our folks are here patiently waiting I was with you all on the CPAC committee uh meeting last night before we go into that I do want to recognize along with uh president Elliott and superintendent Strickland if I just can take a moment and celebrate the black coat ceremony that we were able to attend um this past Saturday um School number nine Martin Luther King Jr School Number Nine and the boys Academy and they had their black coat ceremony thank you um and it was it was phenomenal and that the goals and the things that they work on with these these young men is um just something to be
004seen I encourage everyone to get involved support and uh and see what is happening with our children and identify those things that are working to lift our students and and make sure that we are supporting um I'm going to move into the agenda and so at this time I'm going to have uh we're going to have an presentation um the executive summary of outcomes on the consent decree and this will be presented by our chief of special education and diverse Learners chrisen Swan thank you thank you thank you commissioner Simmons and president Elliot good evening and Board of Education members um I'm actually going to introduce my colleagues who are here with me as well I think most of you may know Desiree Richmond who is our former Chief of special education but also is
005still serving as our consent decree coordinator but I'd also like to introduce to you tonight miss Stephanie nap who is our director or one of our directors of special education and this year uh we looked internally at our special education structure and each of the directors of special education took a key leadership role and Stephanie has been working very closely with our Frontline team and that's the team that creates all of the data around special education and also working with and and uh working on our consent decree so she jokingly had said that she's making her debut today because she's going to present some of the information or most of the information to you um but before she does that I do want to say say uh we have a lot to celebrate as we
006present to you tonight in regards to our consent decree and although we are standing in front of you presenting I just uh have to acknowledge that this is a team effort there are so many people who are working to improve instruction and opportunities for students with disabilities in the district and that um certainly is led by super intendent Strickland a commitment by Deputy superintendent Turner she and I work very closely together um our Chiefs have worked collaboratively with us this year to really enforce and continue to uh align practices in the buildings with the building administrators and certainly our teachers our teaching assistants and our par professionals so this is a collective effort uh we're proud of the growth that we're making and we also recognize that there's still areas um and opportunities for growth
007but uh without further Ado I'm going to invite Stephanie up who will walk you through the uh annual progress thank you Kristen and thank you for this opportunity to share the status of the consent decree according to the data that was collected in the 2023 24 school year this presentation is an opportunity for you to give us some feedack feedback before we are able to present this and publish this as part of our annual report so as was just discussed by commissioner Simmons our presentation truly does align with the Board of Education goals you'll see that threaded throughout some of the data that we present to you tonight so here is the history of our consent decree timeline again it started in the fall of 2024 when um a few families came before The Empire
008Justice Center concerned about the present the presentation and the growth that was presented to students with disabilities all the way to February of 2021 when the consent decree was approved by Judge David larer I'm proud to announce that we have a wonderful relationship with Empire Justice Center we're making some great gains in our collaborative work and you see that throughout our presentation I won't go through these line by line but this is a great overview of the goals and subg goals that are articulated in the consent decree you'll notice that there are 14 goals but a total of 21 measures that we are taking a look at annually to account for the consent decree measures we thought that this would be a very interesting graphic to show to you again when we break down the
00921 subg goals you'll notice that we have met 14 of them um we have not met five of the goals and we continue to monitor two I'll get into the details of what the continue to monitor the two are in subsequent SL slides so as Christ mentioned we have many celebrations we have met 14 of the benchmarks 16 of the 21 do not need to be reported on this year that's because we've made additional progress towards them we were within the 5% cap and then we've OB obtained partial disengagement for five of the 20- mon bench benchmarks this means that we have met those benchmarks for a number of consecutive years and so we don't have to report on them in the same frequency that we have for the others as we look at our
010areas of focus we still have seven of the 21 benchmarks that we have not yet achieved these are academic goals primarily and you'll notice that the whole district is working towards those those are proficiency and Ela and math and our graduation rates um our student performance rates really are reliant on many departments it's not just the spe the office of special education we all need to work in concert in order for us to meet those goals right now we're in the process of negotiating with the Empire Justice Center one of our goals in particular one of those goals has to do with mandatory professional development we believe that we've met those we have had the offerings put forth by our school district however when you look at our attendance records for superintendent conference days and
011other mandatory days you'll notice that sometimes we have low attendance on those days so again these are our areas of highlight you'll notice here that we've articulated the 14 goals that we've met um the star next to them show that those are the ones that are we imp partial disengagement so again those are the ones that we've met for at least two years and continue to make gains in those you'll notice here that we often will use beds day data as our total enrollment day data again beds day data is the f um in October in the first week and that allows for us to calculate this data um consistently as we measure from quarter to quarter these are the two that I mentioned that we are continuing to monitor um that we have not
012quite met them but we're within that 5% goal one of the things to note of this slide is that while we've made the 63.4% of our students with disabilities engaging in the general education curriculum for 80 80% of the day or longer um that is higher than what the New York state standard is so New York state in order for us to be highly efficient in this area is 58.7 so although the consent decree holds us to a higher standard we are meet meeting this metric when compared to New York State um measures the same thing goes for 4B um we have a rate of 17.7% of our students who are in the special ed or in the general education um less than 40% of the school day um again we want this number to
013be low and New York State holds us to a standard of 17.8 so again we do meet this metric when compared to New York state standards and then these are our areas of continued work so we have four goals that we continue to make gradual progress towards but yet have not met the Ben bench marks that are articulated in the consent decree um the percentage of students with disabilities with proficient Ela scores you'll note from the data that's been presented to you at as the Board of Education in the past that our scores are lower than what we would expect for a district this size um same thing goes with our proficient math levels our June graduation rate is an area that we continue to work on and then these two subsets of number of
014special education teachers not certified in New York state and then the racial disparity index of newly classified students who are African-American Or Hispanic versus those who are white so we've had an opportunity to take a look at some of the goals that we have for goals one and two and how we might be able to meet our uh Benchmark goals in the future as you know Rochester City School dist District continues to recruit and retain certified teachers or have great attempts to do so um we are engaging in evidence-based curriculums such as letters and I make it we have a continued partnership with the regional Partnership Center and as you know we are working on some literacy plans across some elementary schools that are articulated in this slide and then as always we continue to
015look at our accountability for buildings regarding their continuous Improvement regarding their academic and financial planning secondly according to um for us to meet the graduation rate we need to continue to have those early recovery grade recovery efforts and I know that there's a presentation later on today talking about those efforts we will continue to offer graduation op options for students that include opportunities for them to have Hands-On learning through CTE availability we will collaborate as we always have with the Department of teaching and learning and again we have expanded Partnerships with the regional Partnership Center in the areas of transition and behavior knowing that these areas contribute to our graduation rate we wanted to bring particular attention to this slide where in 2020 or 2023 we reported that we had 53.5 vacancies that were open
016on beds day for stud for teachers who are certified in New York state we want to point out to you that we continue to struggle in this area you'll know on this slide that we have 52.5 uncertified teachers as of beds Day this year we understand that in order for us to move this data we truly need to recruit and retain high quality teachers over a number of years again these certified teachers um we're working as Chris Dr Miller has told the board before we're working on these Innovative programming um for special education teachers we're looking at possible incentives for teachers and we're continuing our partner ships with local universities in order for us to identify people who currently work for the Rochester City School District who may be interested in going into the profession
017of teaching a racial disparity index continues to be an area of concern for the district we are um receiving a number of supports through the regional support center in order to address this including really honing in on our mtss processes and ensuring that those are strong in each of our buildings the use of Panorama has really changed um The District in many ways we're able to dive into Data more deeply um on an Moment by moment basis and we're able to then disaggregate that data to know which students are truly in need of additional supports we do need to do some additional work in our department to examine some of the reasons that students may be um identified as needing special education supports and making sure that we are putting supports in pract in process
018esport especially for our students um in the areas of elll classification area and taking a look at their attendance history again Panorama is allowing us to dig into that data a little bit more deeply than we have in years past the use of Panorama has really allowed the district to dig into this de detail um we're able to analyze data in one location it's very helpful for us as a csse to be able to disaggregate this data take a look at the areas of attendance behavior and cour work well before we make the decision that a student does need special education supports we also know that indicators um Research indicates that these early warning indicators also show us the students who may be at risk for not graduating high school so I often talk with
019our families about these collaborative efforts when I think about this I often describe it as being three legs of a stool in order for all of our students to be successful we truly need the school district the family and outside resources to all be working in concert with one another for students to meet their levels of success so in this slide we're really talking about how we work intimately with the office of um teaching and learning and ensuring That explicit education is happening in all of our classrooms whether you're talking about a student who is in a special education classroom or one who is in a general education classroom it's really critical that we collaborate with placement to ensure that our Continuum of services meets the needs of students in the district and that we
020make sure that we have those programs available to students for the upcoming school year we need to work intimately with human capital for recruiting and retaining those high quality teachers and Par professionals but also ensuring that our onboarding process is really indepth and allows people to really perform especially in our special classes um and live up to the expectations that students or we have for students to meet Benchmark we often think about our internal Partners things like CPAC and other organizations that really get parents in the door and collaborating with us and then our external Partners such as urmc autism up and Jordan Health so again I mentioned that this is an area that we're C currently in disagreement with the Empire Justice Center on regarding our disengagement criteria we know that we are offering
021over eight mandatory professional development um opportunities for csse and CPS um chair members and special education teachers however we continue to work on a platform that will allow us to track the mandatory PD and who is attending those so our consider ations or next actions of course we're continuing to maintain our performance on these goals we'll de develop and Implement a remedial action plan for the measures that did we did not meet we will um have assistance with all of our departments so again that deep collaboration to ensure that all of us are working to make sure that our students are exposed to and and engaging in curriculum that is at their grade level and we'll continue to monitor our data and the reporting that we are putting out to the state and uh forward
022facing to our community we really are looking for a consented Creek dashboard to be created this would really be helpful for us in so that we would be able to do a dipstick at any time to have this data available to us so again if we had to course correct in the middle of a semester we would be able to do so so we've already completed our annual report we've already set sent our report to the Empire Justice Center we've received some great feedback from them again I just want to highlight that this has truly been a collaborative effort with the Empire Justice Center and they're working on us working alongside of us to ensure that we are meeting these goals again the work that we're doing in special education benefits the whole District so
023again uh we have a common interest the Empire Justice Center and the district and they are understanding of that and helping us in any way to move this data forward um today we did our presentation to the board of education and our next step once we receive feedback from the um board of education is to publish and post our annual report and then have our finalized uh video that goes along with that are there any questions or comments thank you for your presentation thank you um before we open up the floor or the day is for questions or comments I do want to recognize that our parent representative for the esa committee is on our Microsoft teams that that would be Monica Graham and Monica if you do have questions I'll be looking for your
024hand if you have some and we also have vice president LeBron um on the teams as well and so again I'll be trying to check along with Charisma if you all have any um questions or comments that you'd like to present and at this time time I'm opening the day as for questions I'm going to start at the far end and I think I'm going to piggyback like this but I'm going to start with you commissioner Griffin um good evening thank you for your presentation don't have really much to say I do apologize I missed a meeting last night I couldn't get on for some reason but um I just wanted to uh applaud you all and what I've seen in the different schools in reference to meeting the needs of our children um I
025had the pleasure of visiting number four school number 19 school and um 45 school um and and and many others that in 16 school just to name a few that have the programs that you implemented in in the schools that are working and um with a small number of kids and and shout out to the all the peer professionals and and um in their field and how they really really um really really give a lot to these children um and and they play a big role they play a very big role in their position so I want to applaud them as well but I just I I my drive is to ensure that we have all of these in all the schools to to address the needs of our children with with many um altering
026conditions so uh shout out to you guys I I applaud you in your work I have no further qu no questions at all thank you commissioner Griffin I do have to Echo those sentiments as far as teachers assistance and as they do do a lot of work in these classrooms and uh we do want to acknowledge that um commissioner Malloy oh thank you uh thank you so much for your presentation very informative um great updates I'm actually really excited to hear of the potential for a dashboard on this I think that's just more public forward and uh in terms of accountability to the public that's that's great stuff um yeah just being able to track the professional development in general which which I know is a hassle to say the least um you know this
027is has the potential to have such a direct impact on our students and their their performance and then just being able to tie that in with the professional development that we're offering to um our teachers and also certification issues uh which is a concern as well I only have one question um and that is just on slide 10 I was curious uh about the schools uh that were listed there um how are the those specific schools chosen is it based on either receivership or CSI comprehensive support or Improvement status um or is it the percentage of students with disabilities at those those schools they are um identified based on their Essa on our Essa accountability so the 38 assessment data so those are uh buildings who have the opportunity to grow and uh improve and
028we get targeted support from the state education department through our regional Partners Center thank you so much and that's it thank you thank you commissioner Malloy commissioner Santiago commissioner Patterson oh I'm sorry I didn't you you were sitting back too far commissioner Patterson pop up on me thank you um first of all thanks you thank you for your presentation um that was very good um the only question I have um deals with uh certification I see it says there were let me see screen number 13 if I'm correct there were 52.5 uncertified teachers in classrooms on bed's day October 2nd 2024 um are we having a problem just locating certified teachers in this area of a special ed or you know could you explain that a little bit more for us absolutely I I would
029think that many of my colleagues across New York state would say that this is an area of concern um many people are leaving the profession of of Education in general but also in special education so I many many districts are are struggling in this area to recruit and retain certified special education teachers and Rochester city is is feeling that same hardship I think that the um the landscape after mic on I'm sorry to interrupt you is the mic on speak into the mic please I think it's just because I'm shorter um so I think that many of my colleagues across the state are seeing those same issues especially postco we're just not having many um youngsters go into the the field of education and then uh many of our Workforce is retiring okay thank you
030thank you okay that's safe to say it's similar to like what we're seeing in the skilled trades and and so how do we become Innovative and create an atmosphere where people will want to come to um this and I recognize it is happening across New York state but I'm here for the Rochester City School District so I want to know how we will try to continue to do that I know that efforts are truly being made um I did appreciate very much your the conversation with parents last night um and I do have some questions from that conversation that I will commit to the board log because I'm interested to understand some of these things as well we recognize that the best laid plans are only as good as their execution right and so um
031you know that that does bring me to some spaces um you mentioned placement this evening and let me make sure I'm talking into the mic or speaking into the mic um placement is a point of um concern for me um because when I think about a child and the the whole child we we recognize that special education is based on the assessment and the testing and I wouldn't even pretend to be an expert but I know there's some form of testing and and things that you need to go through a protocol that you must follow to ensure that child um is is assessed correctly right um but when they're placed in the schools I am hearing you know there may be some concerns around making sure it's the best fit do the special education actually
032physically look at the classrooms I know capacity must be crazy but do they look at the the actual classroom or the best fit for that child Beyond this the paper that has I diagnosed this child we do so uh we partner with placement part of our placement team we actually have an associate director of special education who works in placement and then our director of placement also has a special education background I think the concern and having heard some of the parents stories yesterday as well we've really improved on the placement process what where I think there there's an opportunity for growth commissioner Simmons is the transition so let's say a student um is in one particular building they a committee on Special Education meeting perhaps they need a more restrictive program and that program
033happens to be in another building we can place the student there and placement does place the student there but the buildings and the office of special education have to work together on a smooth transition and I think sometimes it's that transition that breaks down that we're really looking to improve upon thank you um I have two more questions um and that they're uh specific to the slide you presented I think one is slide number five and I may have missed something my I had to restart my computer so I was trying to look from here but on slide number five thank you Tom um you said 14 out of 21 benchmarks were achieved um did you list in this presentation the 14 um that we're working on because I saw some listed was it just
034some of the 14 or so that is on slide seven okay I was trying to make sure like did that tie those are the those are the 14 that were met correct okay so that's what I meant to say the 21 that the ones that were not met are those outlined here yes so the there are the two that we're very close to and we continue to monitor um and then we have the remaining five that are still outstanding okay perfect thank you you're welcome and then my last question was around um just the certified teacher piece and the Fidelity in the schools because again this was a great presentation the efforts that I believe special education is making um if it if it's done to Fidelity could can be something great but you were
035on the call that I was on last night yes and I think that um there are continued efforts between the office of human capital and our department to ensure that we have people who are not only certified but love the work that they're doing especially in those special classes okay and because I'm on the deis and this is a public conversation I'm going to exercise a little more transparency and and and just state that um you know some of the concerns and I can't validate the concerns but I'm sure they are legitimate I'm I'm confident of that but you know when students are sent home and what that looks like um I just want know that our children are are going to be whole and so I know you can only do so much from
036here but this the schools have to be on par and aligned with what you all are are looking to do completely agree and that's part of the collective effort around the consent decree um we certainly Own It commit to it the office of special education but we also recognize that this is District work and as I shared last night with our parents at CPAC what that looks like sometimes in terms of leadership is making sure that we're in front of principles and having these conversations and and yesterday the conversation um was a little bit about suspension and and students going home but making sure that we're providing professional learning around suspension and discipline but also having conversations and meeting with principles in their buildings and brainstorming what needs to be done to support children and
037their mental health and their behavioral health it's a collective effort and it's not just administrators like you mentioned it's PA professionals teaching assistants teachers uh we we will continue to struggle with those five remaining goals if we don't collectively problem solve and move move forward together and that's really Our intention thank you I appreciate that I'm going to get off my soap box cuz I walked into some schools and I see the attendance as well and so that the short staffing is not helping the situation at all I'm going to commissioner Santiago did I call on you also already please go ahead sir uh yeah thank you uh for the presentation uh I'll was say in some areas um even in in my family as I have sisters uh three little sisters that's in the
038district I have seen improvements in the special education department um and the IEP Department uh in which they've been working with my sister and she's been progressing and so I want to give you guys congratulations on that because it hasn't been the same in the past in comparison to now um but I do want to bring some attention to slide number nine um which of course is important and and you did put you know your plans moving forward regarding this these uh goals that haven't been able to be made um but I just want to make sure sure that one I congratulate you guys on the the things that that has has been uh progressed and improved um but also you know bring bring up the elephant in the room when it comes to our
039our proficiency and and reading um because all the other goals matter of course but these goals are some of our fundamental goals that we have to ensure that we are preparing these young people uh for when they leave the district and when they graduate and so I see a plan um but it's like you said there has to be a collaborative approach between everybody to ensure that this is getting done and I just want to ask and this might be a little bit specific um but when it comes to a lot of times when when IEPs are given uh to to students sometimes they may be taught uh behind grade level or taught at the grade level that they were at when they got the I IEP instead of being held to a standard to
040get to the grade level where they need to go to and so I'm wondering uh for for you guys what are some initiatives or some pushes you guys are putting in the department to Ure that we are teaching our young people not to stay in behind grade level but to get to the grade level that they need to get to I truly appreciate that question um commissioner Santiago I I think that what you will see as you go through our buildings is that you'll see many of our faces there we are ensuring that we are doing walkthroughs and having those difficult conversations with staff members about the rigor of their classes but not only the conversations what kind of um professional development do our teachers need in order to provide scaffolding for students we want
041to teach our students especially those with disabilities those compensatory skills that they need in the classroom in order to succeed that's explicit teaching and so again you will see many of us walking through and having those conversations but in order for you to have those critical conversations we need to build relationships with people so that they can hear us so again that is part of our our real effort this year is to be more visible in buildings not only us at the co level district office level but also our associate directors that's the expectation of those that we support yeah and and I'm glad to hear that you know you guys are are holding up those standards I think that that's not that's not just in the special education department but that's in our district
042all the way around you have uh uh some teachers who may not be doing what's needed for the child to be successful when it comes to their literacy and when it comes to uh what they as far as curriculum and and things of that sort and so I think that we have to start ensuring that we're holding a standard uh for for everybody to ensure that we're we're teaching these kids because if we're not passing these kids in Proficiency in ela and reading and math we're not succeeding these children we're continuously faing children generation after generation and so we have to be able to ensure that we're holding up a standard you know everybody gets paid everybody gets money but but what really matters is that these kids are are graduating from this District ready
043for the workforce ready to create their adulthood ready to create a life um and then I also want to say when it comes to suspensions um you know that that is of course something that that uh is part of our board goals um and I'm hoping to see certainly through special education that that we are giving the young people the services that they need um because because many times you may have uh certain individuals being suspended off of something that they just need a service for and so we have to find Solutions not suspensions in this district and so I'm hoping to see that and as Kristen um mentioned earlier tonight with the reorganization of our department we've been allowed to provide some of that data in real time to our Chiefs to our special
044education staff to our principles so that we can truly monitor those patterns and then create action items for schools that are having some particular issues thank you commissioner Santiago okay we're going to shake it up a little bit I see some hands on the zoom uh vice president LeBron if you don't mind I'm going to acquest to our parent representative for a moment and then I'll go to you uh so Monica if you um still have a question I'd love you to make comments or question now thank you can you all hear me okay yes awesome so no questions um just a comment for the Department I just want to say how I appreciate um how you all collaborate with CPAC un fortunately I missed last night's meeting I am um tending to a sick
045teenager um but I appreciate how your department shows up how you listen and how you provide followup for the parents so continue that collaboration and work with cek um commissioner you were there last night you saw we got some strong parents um and some parent leaders that are willing to assist with this change um so the the collaboration with this department is extremely important so thank you for the presentation and thank you for what you're doing thank you thank you awesome yes I definitely saw how the parents they they respond to you um because it appears that you care and I just feel like there's some progress that can certainly be made this is a huge undertaking vice president LeBron I actually have no questions or comments um I'm satisfied with the presentation and the
046progress that's being made obviously it's a very challenging area to make progress in so kudos to those putting in the effort and getting us where we're at from where the original consent decree started that's all thank you thank you vice president LeBron and at this time Comm uh Vice I'm sorry president Elliot thank you thank you um I too want to um congratulate you all on this work um this has been a uphill battle for us um and um I'm glad that it looks like we're moving in um the right direction I have a couple couple of questions that I want to ask about this process um how much longer are we under the consent decree is it that when we meet these goals that are listed on page uh four that we would uh
047have met the uh consent decree um requirements and um uh what's and what is in terms of the other goals that we have not met um when is it anticipated that we would have achieved those goals yes so we need to not only meet those goals but then maintain those goals for a number of years before we're able to get to that partial disengagement so we anticipate that um we will be working collaboratively with the Empire Justice Center for a bit of time um but I'm really excited about some of the traction that our team has with some of this work and we're we're poised to make that um that flip over to meeting those portions so that we can just progress monitor in the future but did you do you have anticipated goals for
048next year um for you know I just want to look at where we're moving in the next year y so the uh goals the five that we did not meet are the priority goals uh it's our plan that we'll continue to Monitor and work towards all of the goals that we did meet so the the hardest goals uh we believe that we're going to have to be really working collectively on are the proficiency levels in ela and math and and of course graduation now that is going to take some time and we know it's you know the Board of Education goals as well but what we're committed to and what we're doing differently is exactly what Stephanie just talked about so even today I had the opportunity to do a walk through with the superintendent
049and we saw a self-contained 1211 middle school classroom and it was really pleased to see that the students were not only had access to the General Ed literature and curriculum but were managing it were fully engaged and uh superintendent doesn't know this but I saw one of the students afterwards when we were leaving and I had an opportunity to speak with him and he was telling me how much he enjoyed that piece of literature perhaps a year or two ago we might have had adults who thought that our students wouldn't be able to read that book and so it's how do we make sure that our students have the curriculum and that we explicitly teaching it and giving them access and and knowing how to teach it to students who may inherently have a difficult
050time reading so it's when you have those High expect ations and that's what parents talked to us last night about we need our teachers to have high expectations of our children and those are the types of conversations that are going to move that needle we've got to believe that our children can do it and that it's our responsibility to figure out how to get them there so let me just be clear are are you saying that we uh we can anticipate achieving these goals next year I don't we're striving I mean we've got to move stud sooner rather than later I guess sooner than later sooner than later absolutely but but I I want us to understand where our starting point is we've got 3% of students with disabilities meeting proficiency we've got to radically
051change how we're instructing and getting curriculum in the hands of our children that's the that's the biggest hurdle really making sure that our children have access to the General Ed curriculum you you may have asked him this question before but let me just ask it again um I'm looking at uh slide six goals pertaining to student performance and the um no no that's not the one academic goals um will be difficult to achieve without the assistance of other departments what does that look like it looks like us the office of special education partnering with Dr Miller's office to make sure that we've got certified teachers in our classrooms it looks like extending not only having the teachers but professional learning so working with the office of professional learning and really asking ourselves What do teachers
052need to know and be able to do even before they come to you before tenure like one of the ideas that I've been thinking about is what professional learning Desiree and I have talked about this as well should all special education teachers uh participate in in the first three or four years of their tenure ship to make sure that they have the instructional background that they need to have in our classrooms it's working in partnership with the Chiefs so here are the instructional initiatives within the office of special education how do we align that with building administrators teachers and staff it's working collectively and cross functionally with every Department to achieve this okay so I heard you one of you mentioned about um you seem to be getting more support um and more of collaborative
053um Endeavors with the with Empire Justice talk a little bit more about that sure because before it used to be very you know autocratic dogmatic and so to hear that they are being more conciliatory is um very very positive right I I believe and I gave Desiree this compliment today that is one of Desiree Richmond's superpowers she's very skilled at bringing together people over hard situations and finding common ground and I think the reality is that Empire Justice sees a few things they see commitment not only from the office of special education but from the deputy superintendent the superintendent and yourselves as the Board of Education they see our intentions and quite honestly they see the growth so they're more inclined to be working with us in Partnership because they see the traction and and
054we're happy about that and we think that that is an accomplishment in itself yeah very good so a cple just a couple more questions this the last one president I leave page seven um 8A um the number of variances by commissioner approval due uh to lack of capacity what does that mean so if we uh go over the amount of students in a special education class so if we are talking about a self-contained 1211 class for example that means 12 students to one teacher in a uh teaching assistant if we have to put a 13th child in that classroom we need to seek approval through the State education department the office of special education can only seek approval for the whole District no more than two times in a year last year we had no
055variances this year we've sought approv approval once all right thank you since I can't ask any more questions well you can in the question I'm good all right thank you if I could say this though I'm really excited about um the work in um you know the the fact that we're moving forward um in this um Direction because it's been really challenging um over the years and there seems to be more clarity now than it has been in previous years so I want just to commend all of the work that you all have done thank you very much thank you so for that acknowledgement I appreciate that thank you president Elliot um State monitor has he's gone okay so because I wanted to get his thoughts on um consent agree but I also want to
056hear from you superintendent if you have anything uh thank you uh chairwoman Simmons uh first just wanted to acknowledge all that was said on this day as um definite Kudos and accolades to the office or Department of special education and all the progress that has been made it's it's something that I've follow followed uh since joining the organization never hearing about what a consent decree was but knowing that I had to help my fellow colleague Desiree Richmond uh really uh support and get these metrics under control so that we were making progress as a whole and um I just really appreciated one um appreciate her and and of course the work uh that uh director nap and and chief Swan continue to do um but also wanted to acknowledge the individuals that do work with
057our special education students each and every day as commissioner Griffin mentioned um they are to be commended in many ways and uh there's still a lot of progress that ought to be made and has to be made um when it comes to making sure that our students are getting access to grade level curriculum and and every service that the general education students get um that is going to be absolutely necessary really really really focusing on getting certificated teachers in front of our students that also means that we've we've had to unfortunately make some tough decisions where we said that you know our special education certified teachers cannot be in teacher on assignment positions um so you know that's one of the the backlashes as a result of you know putting individuals back into the classroom
058but it's a decision that we had to make for the class um for the the betterment of our students and and lastly you know just really want to talk about you know our suspensions yes making sure that our schools are doing right by our students making sure that uh if if we need to go that route um they are sent home with procedural safeguards and things of that nature and they're having manifestation reviews going to be absolutely necessarily necessary and critical but even before we get there are folks following the behavior intervention plans those things must be done uh they have a disability uh on paper on record we have to show our due diligence or guess what those students are going to return right back to the class and how do we Infuse the
059restorative practices within that to make sure that students are understanding where they um where they have gone wrong and how they are going to be welcomed back into the community and then finally above all we we have to improve um our student outcomes our student outcomes are most pressing when it comes to uh our special education students and our English language Learners um and the way we're going to do it are the classrooms that we visited today uh at Loretta Johnson it was fantastic to see students in grade uh seven I believe reading the same text as their general education peers and not having a struggle in the world and and they are able to really participate just like the folks down the hall and we need to make sure that that happens across the
060district they had some modifications but guess what they had the same thing in front of them that's it and if we continue to see that those outcomes will definitely get go up that's that's all thanks thank you thank you so much thank you for your presentation yet once again you get a CL you get a round of applause okay so we're going to move forward on the agenda um and I'm going to um ask for Jeffrey feni the director of attendance to join us at this time good evening everyone that's not Jeffrey by the way for our viewing audience this looks like Kelly Briggs I'm familiar with her good evening everyone I just wanted to introduce Joseph feni we call him Joe he is our new director of attendance he just started at the end
061of sep and he has been working very hard so again I just wanted to introduce him to everybody and I will yield the microphone to joei thank you hi everyone thank you um Board of Education superintendent Strickland Deputy superintendent Turner for having us here tonight um we're excited to show you some of the work that we've been doing um and here's a picture of our team so we're a part of the family and Community engagement Department along with the Departments of parent engagement youth engagement and Community Schools Kelly Briggs is our amazing executive director when I started my role in the beginning October one of the first things I did was to understand our strategic plan and what our goals are as a district reducing chronic absenteeism by 25% in 2028 drives our focus in
062decision-making in every everything that we're doing what we'll talk about today is driven towards meeting that goal so here the attendance Department's vision and Mission this is student focused and as you can see our mission is specifically aligned with our strategic plan and our goal of reducing chronic absenteeism so we recognize that school building based attendance teams are the backbone and key components of our efforts to reduce chronic absenteeism first and foremost this is what we need to be really good at doing we want to be able to provide resources guidance and framework which you'll hear more about as we move through this presentation we believe that our ability to support the different unique needs and systems of each School allow our framework to be flexible while still implementing best practices and having our attendance
063Specialists be as prepared as possible um to support these schools so seven of the members of our department work directly with school building based attendance teams we refer to these team members as attendance Specialists here are some of the ways they're supporting schools which we collaborated on to Define namely providing Community Resources supporting with home visits consultation for best practices for building attendance teams absence troubleshooting and searching for no show students as you see here data analysis is a part of this list part of our training has been with mtss coaches supporting our capacity in using our new Panorama database for in-depth review of individual students Power School interval data retrieval to look at recent history more more effectively and level two data for guiding Universal building-wide interventions so here are some important definitions that
064relate to our work in our presentation chronic absenteeism is missing 10% of school days severe chronic is 20% and average daily attendance is the percentage of students who attend on a given day so here are a few slides that will help you all get a macro level perspective on current attendance data on this slide you'll see average daily attendance for our last 5 years as we can see from the 2020 to 2021 school year to the 2021 22 school year average daily attendance dropped significantly in large part because of covid remote learning going away um ever since we've been on an upward trajectory average daily attendance in September was about 81% October 80.4% November 79.8% and in December we're now up to 80.1% um this pattern of a very slight drop off in average daily
065attendance over the first 3 months of school is consistent with how it's looked for the last four years although there's a slight drop there are highlights such as Francis Parker School 23 leading the district in Improvement during November in comparison from last year to this year their average daily attendance improved 3.9% this November in comparison to last November this one 10 so here's average daily attendance by grade level this is also consistent with prior years typically elementary schools hovering around 85 to 86% across the different grade levels and a gradual drop off in high school as the grades Advance as you can see here average daily attendance difference between genders is almost equal this slide shows average daily attendance by race this is another Baseline measurement lens to help us understand how we can best
066support improving attendance so as I talked about earlier upon starting in my new role in October we recognized is a team that we needed to make a clear initial focus on improving our capacity to support building attendance teams this required us to examine our department infrastructure and identify areas of strength and areas for growth so to work towards accomplishing this we've had daily hourlong department meetings during the 1: to 2 p.m window that's the one time we have all been available during the day during this time we were able to identify best practices for our build building- based attendance teams Define key roles and areas of expertise for our attendance Specialists identify a tiered intervention framework and provide a sample meeting template as a resource but not a mandate for schools that include short-term interval
067data to catch students before they fall into a severe chronic pattern some other areas for Focus for these meetings are the previously mentioned database trainings to support schools in data informed decision-making and establishing systems of documentation and supervision in order to improve our self-reflective practice and provide meaningful feedback to schools as you can see here we identified a best practice for determining essential members of a building attendance team here's our tiered intervention framework tier one in simple terms are building wide interventions such as celebrations of excellent and improved attendance tier two Targets students with individualized interventions tailored to their needs before they reach severe chronic absenteeism and tier three involves out of building supports namely Community Partners and agencies to support students and families that need a higher degree of support beyond what our buildings
068are able to provide directly so here's some school highlights at the elementary level you see examples of tier one interventions such as school 33 breakfast with the mayor for students with perfect attendance this occurred in October and in November their attendance was up 2% compared to November of 2023 School 54 had an ice cream social and recognition of students on the morning announcements again in in November 2024 that school showed an improvement by a percentage Point compared to November 2023 School four with the photo here of a meal for families of students with excellent attendance um they were able to have a 2% Improvement in November compared to last year in our middle schools one of our attendance Specialists here with us tonight Ken Davis is here with us he will be partnering with our
069five new middle schools in our Department of Youth engagement which is a part of our family and Community engagement team and our mtss team to develop and Implement programming to improve attendance an additional tier one intervention at the middle schools is Loretta Johnson holding an event to celebrate over 100 students with perfect attendance as an example of a tier 2 intervention is Edison doing an attendance challenge with home visits to 65 severe chronic absentee students by nine faculty pairs on a Friday to support them with re-engagement with school and offering Community Resources additionally part of our strategy is to look at ways that we can improve our recording of data here are some examples of data recording policy changes that have recently been implemented the Western New York regional information center which is our regional
070data warehouse that reports to the the New York Department of Education has approved rcsd adjusting exit dates for outof district transfers to the last day that they were physically in in our school rather than our prior policy of setting it is the day before they attended their new school additionally we have an approved registered never enrolled guideline that includes a new transfer into rcsd having a window of their first 10 first 10 school days from the date of their placement entry not being counted as absences until a student attends which provides relief to barriers such as not having transportation yet in place on the 11th day absences would be counted as if the student had you know the absence would be counted if the student still hasn't been attending we worked with our legal department
071and office of accountability to more clearly Define what would qualify as an out of District withdrawal this includes requiring an increased level of proof of permanent residency outside of Rochester and a safeguard of having our legal department review these cases to ensure we are withdrawing students appropriately additionally we have a new 8300 Home Room which allows no show students to be moved to a District central home room after the school year has been completed and a series of defined intervention attempts have occurred namely home visits phone calls and letters students in the 8300 Home Room will still have the students absences be accounted able in overall rcsd District data but no longer their individual School having absences accumulating for multiple years on their roster caring a no-show student that can't be withdrawn an additional area
072of high focus and effort for our department over the last two months has been improving our internal website which is a resource available to all rcsd district Personnel on Rock connect our website contains a comprehensive list of Community Resources such as mental health housing employment and food as well as additional resources for schools and parent Guardians additionally this website is serving as our attendance manual featuring a very thorough and comprehensive menu of all of our attendance processes and procedures that is much easier to navigate than a lengthy booklet additionally as a preview for our next presentation in 2025 we'll be able to transfer much of the information on our internal website that is pertinent to community members to an improved public website that will be mobile friendly which we'll use in social media and community
073outreach efforts so some additional future collaboration efforts we'll be working with the rock restorative Hub to collaborate with Community Partners such as the Center for Youth rise up Rochester Gandhi Institute and Pathways to peace to assist with supporting chronically absent students that schools identify would benefit benefit from Community Support as well as a community partner attendance challenge to incorporate them with schools on a planned Outreach day we're working with the mail room to get a list of return quarter one report cards sorted by school so we can present building attendance teams with this list of students and addresses to ensure schools can give contact update forms to these students which will also lead to many updated phone numbers and emergency contacts and thus leading to more consistent School connectedness with parent Guardians in the summer
074we plan to conduct a ReachOut effort to students and families to increase enrollment in our school-based health centers and work with our nursing staff to reach out to families of pending vaccine non-compliant students to prevent extended absences from school and support with getting health care for families thank you for your presentation can I call you can I call you Joe or because Joe's fine fy's fine whatever works for you I want to call you your respected name so my name is not Jeffrey I'll call you it it does it say it says Jeffrey Feeny up here so it's it's not Jeffrey in any form it is not so someone gave me Jeffrey feny I'll find that person and I'll let them know your name is Jo oh it's all good don't worry about it okay
075but Mr joei I do appreciate your presentation thank thank you for the correction I'm going to open up the day for conversation um and I'm going to start I see commissioner Griffin has her hand going so I'm going to go ahead and give it to you thank you for your presentation um well needed um um information I have a question and I don't know if if I miss something but the 8300 room um can you please explain that a little bit more and can you explain how are you how are you addressing the homeless um in in this in this um the attendance you have in the presentation because I I might have missed that part but did you address the homelessness as far as part of the attendance because wouldn't they be a part
076of it or no is that included in here if the students if you can't contact the students based on the 8 8300 Home Room which slide was that 19 it's up for you right there okay thank you sorry yes so the 8300 room there's no show students will be added to a central Home Room schools will not be accountable for for absence data beginning in the following school year where do our children that do not have homes and we can't reach or can't connect to fall in line with this so the 8300 Home Room there's a series of interventions that are required we have business rules um three letters Home Three home visits phone calls and a variety of um intervention efforts need to have occurred so when a student is a no-show I think
077the point of this is historically that student has remained on a schools roster for years upon end that we have struggled finding you know CPS educ Ed educational neglect referral is also um a required component in order to place a student in the you know 8300 home room um but it's more of a like giving a fair picture of the school's data because if this I want to make sure this makes sense so a student that goes to 8300 is still factoring into our district accountability data but it's not necessarily fair to a school for a particular student that's a no-show to be carried on the roster of a school for four or five years because that's just really really impacting attendance data so by going to a centralized Home Room for our district you
078know that the district still is accountable but the schools have a more accurate perception of their data okay um so so we are responsible the district is responsible if I'm correct for a student up to a certain age correct so how are we addressing that that part of it because we are still responsible by law for that child how I think we need to figure out for me in my opinion how are we addressing the kids that are homeless and are we going to these different locations to see if the these kids even exist because we are still accountable for them am I not am I wrong or am I you're absolutely correct um commissioner Griffin okay I just want I'm just concerned yeah so I recognize that the attendance Department we have mckenny vento
079being the home students that are are facing homelessness we have students who um have come in from Puerto Rico and and sometimes they go home and a lot of times those students are not accounted for that they they leave and they um go back home and there's no updates to the school so the records will stay so East High School um number of years ago under like annibal solar I would say Rich you were there um and there were a lot of um students who went back to Puerto Rico there was no account for the fact these families were just making it happen and going where they needed to be to to continue their lives there was no uh account in the school so the students remained even though the babies were okay they remained
080on the roster of the school and then the school took a direct hit of attendance saying hey none of your kids are coming and so they're not saying that the kids are being thrown in the garbage can no to your point um but they are saying that they are still being accounted for so there it's not and and I don't want to speak for you because I need y'all to tell me if I'm on the right I I think not to interrupt you um um chair um commissioner Simmons well I think I don't want to I don't want to go in the weeds anyway in any way I think we're getting off the point of I'm specifically talking about kids that are in this District not talking about the kids going back to Puerto Rico
081or anything else we have kids that we can't account for that are homeless and they may show up somewhere in in the city of Rochester it happens I think that I'm having an issue with that part there I know that during Isis and all of that there's a lot of P people that were displaced during that time as well kids went back and all of that that was just an example I'm basically conceded about what we're responsible for and maybe this is something that is out of your realm at this time that's okay but if somebody could give us an answer to that I would I would really like an answer just so I see Deputy Turner she'll maybe make it a little more Layman's turn because there are there are students that was just
082an example it's not just students going back to Puerto Rico there's students here in Rochester but I want um Dr Turner to go ahead and yeah I that's a very legitimate concern uh commissioner Griffin and we have not only our attendance uh folks but we also have our staff in our families and transition program who actually are very well connected to the shelters to those uh there's a Consortium of providers who deal with families in transition that we're part of that table so that we're able to if there is a family or a scholar who is registered rcsd and have experienced homelessness uh we're able to for the for the most part identify where they are often times going to the to the shelters uh working with our partners so just like any other student
083we we are very much aware of that and keep uh as much in connection to those uh families in the various different locations whether they're doubling up or couch surfing uh with family members or friends or families okay and I think going forward forward if we can have that data included in this that would alleviate some of the questions because that is a concern so in in the future I would hope that hopefully we can have that have that information but thank you thank you commissioner Griffin and for the question log I do want to make sure I capture you properly as far as when you say that data what what specific data would you like to are you asking about he's he's he expressed that he's going to have that he has the information
084regarding the regarding the information that is already in the system of kids that are not how many St account accountable for so I want to make sure that we have that information at the regarding the kids that and homeless shelters or that that part of the homelessness in reference to our children we need to know that we need to know okay these kids may be homeless this is with their last Lo addresses and we it may be just a blanket number we need to know though that these are possible the homeless children because the children that were in were homeless because this is their last known address which was that shelter okay you know does that make sense it makes it makes some sense I think that there's an understanding of how how the information
085comes forward but I do want to make sure that we captured the question for your for your concern and then we continue the dialogue I think we can help you understand a little more commissioner Patterson thank you for your report you're welcome no questions I will take it you okay commissioner Patterson no questions you keep sitting back so I can't see you so I see you now okay thank you uh commissioner Santiago yeah um I'm just wondering what what are the and I I see there may possibly be a plan here but what are what are we doing to get the answers when it comes to the root cause of the problem of a child being chronically absent from the parent or not from the student but from the parent are we making an initiative
086to get in contact with the parent or the family of the child to see where where the problem may be that they may be missing school yeah just um our last presentation we talked about uh in talk contacting families and talking with our Scholars who are chronically absent there were five primary uh reasons or contributing factors to that and of course I'm going to have to remember them now uh one was um experiencing a health or Mental Health crisis uh yeah go ahead feel free to help me I got to go by memory um family crisis um homelessness and housing school safety social emotional needs like bullying and uh transportation and so I'm wondering what are we doing when we're getting those answers to support that family um so I think the schools know our
087students best you know in terms of these building based attendance teams like every every young person has their own individual story so the purpose of the framework that we're putting in place is to support our building attendance teams in order to address each student individually um the root cause of an absenteeism is variable by the student and it's really important that we know the student we know the situation we're doing home visits we're doing the appropriate level of effort to connect with the family and try and engage the student with school and build connectedness with the school but um you know it's it's caseby case basis and it's important that we dive in and do everything we can to support the individual student in their circumstances yeah and so and so I I hear that
088but I'm just wondering because when not get into the root cause and I think there has to be an urgency when we're looking at our our chronics absenteeism because just as much as this chronic absenteeism it connects to our proficiency it connects to every other thing that we're speaking about when it comes to this district and so we have to be able and we have to be able to look at the root causes that these students are missing school and figure out the services that we're we're providing to these children we can't forget that we're living and and many of our students are are living in in financial hardships um and in households of financial hardships and so in response to that we should be having services and we may not be able to do
089that in the district by itself but we also have to find ways to partner with our local community which I've heard from many community members and many Community organizations trying to partner with this district is that many times it becomes extremely hard to try to partner with this District but the truth is with this issue is not just going to be us alone to fix it because it's not just an absenteeism it's a housing issue it's a mental health issue like you said and so I'm just wondering how can we find ways not only to know the root cause but how to support and give services to these young people to fix the issue and I know that there's been uh you know a couple elected officials from other bodies of government who's made statements
090about The Chronic absenteeism but just as much as it's a district problem it's a Rochester's problem it's a Monro County problem it's a New York state problem and so it's not just it it's on the district to figure out what the problem is and to make sure that we're making the initiative to create a partnership but we need urgency behind that and we need collaboration because this is not just a Rochester City School District problem this is the city of Rochester Monroe County we got to figure this out together and so I'm hoping to see that happen and and whatever has to be done to make that happen it has to happen soon because we need to have urgency when it comes to Chronic absenteeism yeah just to underscore that a bit and to provide
091a little bit more detail so our health centers in our schools uh our mental health came out of that need which we heard from our community saying that our students uh need easier access to health to dental to mental health and we responded by working across with our partners our health providers to provide that either physically in the school or through tella health so that's that's another incident also in in our respective schools when we know that our Scholars are experiencing any kind of a need whether it's related to a family issue whether it's related to a community issue issue they are pulled in with consent because we can't make them two small groups provided by the uh social workers or counselors uh in their in their room we have mediation and restorative mediation to
092deal with some of the cyber bullying and the bullying that takes place so there's a lot going on I don't want to leave it to say that yes everyone looks different but students have access to a a facet of resources and a lot of them are taken advantage of it we work with Community Partners whether we have some of our uh folks here who sit at table with other Community Partners to figure out the housing situation right we work with Partners at times where we're able to provide a down what it's called down payment when you put a security deposit to help so there's a lot that we do above and beyond what typical school districts do so I just wanted to make sure you know that was also noted for the record yeah and
093and I want to say that I appreciate that and and when I was making my statement I wasn't saying that there's no initiative there I believe there's an initiative there but the numbers are showing that our district is around 50% in chronic absenteeism and so we we have to find ways to bring urgency behind this issue and we have our our our our services there um which can be Amplified and we need Partnerships from more than just the district to make stuff happen and so when people are out there speaking from other government bodies understand this is their responsibility just as much as it's a district responsibility thank you indeed it is thank you um commissioner Santiago president Elliott thank you so um thank you for the presentation I think part of um the missing
094part in The Narrative is and I'm looking on um page seven um and this is what the state requires and so um this is not that they are um absent a consecutive 10% of the time right uh or a consecutive 20% of the time and what we have not factored in there is that kids May out be out for Do's appointments um they may be out for absolutely legitimate reasons and all of that is included in this and so we have not factored out the fact that there are legitimate reasons parents who are making sure that their kids are healthy and whatever the other cases may be that they have to legitimately uh not have their children in school so I know commissioner Santiago one of the things that we talked about from the community
095intergovernmental Relations Committee is that advocating to to change the regulations on a state level so that's something that we have to do too because the state has not taken into consideration that there are legitimate reasons even when families may you know go away go to go back to to Puerto Rico as an example right that's not taken into um consideration that they may be learning somewhere else uh I'm not sure about that but we have to really look at what the definition of um Absa chronic absentee and severe severe chronic absenteeism because it it just doesn't take into account those parents that are legitimately doing work now the other piece about this is and there may be there may be families our students who have to work they've got to they've got to take care
096of the household right so those kinds of legitimate reasons for not being in in school uh is a part of this which it should not be now I'm also I also looked at the uh the um slide where attendance goes down look particularly in the high school level so we've got some work to do when it comes to our high school and how do we ensure that we've got the right programs that are going to be attracting and and have those students to remain um in schools but you know they get caught up in you know do I go to work uh or do I stay in school and and we've got to do a better job of um giving them the right information so that they can make the better decision long term as
097as well uh so I I just wanted to uh to share that that you know so that you've got you've got people out there who are talking and don't know what they're talking about so I just want and and that's on the record they don't know what they're they have not taken into consideration all of the legitimate reasons why uh our students may not be in school thank you commissioner thank you president Elliott um right and we recognize that there are a ton of variables that impact attendance but the reality is we have an attendance issue and that's why you're presenting which I do appreciate tonight um you know and there there are some students that stay home from school because they don't feel good or comfortable or safe should I say in the school
098community in which they reside and so we have to address that too um for sure um you know I'm thinking about this I heard you mention um educational neglect and and I you know I I recognize that emphatically does exist um and then I think about myself as a child right at ninth grade level I was a chronic runaway I barely came to school um I'm not sure which one of those three I subgroups I ended up in but I was one of them I know that and somehow I made it through um and so when we talk about and I know that it was not the standard of my parents that I'd be absent or running away from home but that's what I was doing at that particular time and so um you know
099I'm I'm I'm interested to hear more more about how that is determined if there are some parents out here that are fighting for their child to you know get in get in line and get in school and act like you got some sense and the child is kind of going Wayward at that time so that that is um a followup question I think I'll put that in the question log around um just just curiosity um but going back to the um slide that commissioner Griffin touched on what was that 90 83 8300 where the children I just want to throw um a general example out there and and ask for you to give me some guidance on my thought process now and I'm thinking through it as I talk so forgive me um so 8,300
100let's say a student goes to Edison Franklin Wilson where wherever right they go to a they go to school and um well they they're not going to school and they don't go to school to the point that they qualify if you will to be identified for 8,300 they go into that home room maybe they're homeless to commissioner Griffin's point or whatever the case and interventions have happened um we we we've gone to the house we found the house the address is no longer legit that was boarded up I've done those attendance blitz so I've seen that firsthand um all of these things happen outreaches happen once they go into 8300 do the out does the Outreach stop it continues okay we do not stop looking for the young people that would be placed in 8300
101Home Room the only purpose of that is for just for the giving a more fair depiction of what attendance is reflected in in a school okay and then my second question to that is now you find me whatever my circumstance was you you find me and I was originally a student of Edison High School before 8300 now you've identified where I'm at what's happening with me maybe it's within the school's perview maybe not do I uh when I return let's say you're able to help me out and I'm able to return do I go back to my home school which might have been Edison or Wilson or what have you or where where do I go am I displaced do I have to reapply how does that work so if you are 8300 Home Room
102like you're carried in that for the remainder of the school year if you're found then you're immediately reinstated in the school's roster immediately um and then when you come to school things progress as normal if you um were found after the school year ends and into the next school year you know you've been placed at that time after the school year ends into that centralized database for the remainder of that school year that absence data is accumulating for the school but the purpose of it is you know five six years of no show data you know so but if you are placed in the 8300 after the school year ends you will have to go to placement and reenroll but ideally you could get placed back in the same school Community if that's the right
103fit for you okay thank you for just giving me that understanding commissioner Malloy thank you so much um thanks so much for your presentation this is really enlightening um I particularly like all the strategies that your department is using and like the Western New York regional information center um out of District withdrawal policy looking at that um I'm very interested to see or to understand more the specific interventions that are taking place at some of our schools that are seeing Improvement in in those numbers um so at some point I know maybe we can put this on the question log if there's a way for us to get information uh about some of those strategies and what those look like specifically um one thing I'm really interested though in understanding more is how does our
104half day like superintendent conference days our half day attendance numbers impact our chronic absenteeism numbers um and you know they kind of two parts to this question because obviously there are we have some of our lowest attendance rates on those days and what does success look like for our schools where we're seeing uh Improvement in in those numbers um what are what are they specifically doing in those buildings to get more kids there is it a motivational tool School the other part of that question though is how motivated are families and students to send their kids to school on those half days if a good portion of our staff in any given building is calling and sick on those days and I know that's a difficult conversation I I just am interested in understanding more
105about the impact that those types of actions might have on students and families of this attitude of maybe it doesn't matter because they're not going to be there anyway um so that's just a concern that I have I'd like more information on that um how do we get kids to want to come to school on our half days superintendent can I could just say we've encouraged our principles to be Innovative on those days in particular really take the time to focus on the SE uh for students um and staff and in particular do something that's fun in the engaging to ensure that students are going to want to come to the school uh when we do have the half days uh I will say that um we're starting to have conversations about next year's calendar
106um we uh join up with the Monroe County uh the other districts in Monroe County to really decide uh you know what our calendar will look like and half days is definitely on the forefronts of our U Minds um in uh in the rcsd uh because we are seeing that there's some interesting numbers uh numbers that are well below average in terms of daily attendance you know where you know it could be half of the students come to school in those days and that certainly has an impact on chronic absenteeism if those students have missed uh well right now we've are over 60 days in if they've missed uh five days that sixth day would be that half day they are now chronically at so we are definitely really thinking about what are we going
107to do around uh the half days in general um with the thought that we also need time for professional development and professional learning of our staff and that's going to be very important so uh definitely uh going to um you know break down some data and really determine what's going to be our next step uh so that we don't contribute to our own issue um but rather help it and and try to do things that you know we need to do so that our staff also can get the the professional learning they need as well absolutely thank you so much thank you superintendent uh Strickland um is that a tiny hand I see okay I'm looking hard it is a hand that I see listen I've been looking for those hands uh vice president LeBron
108um if you still have a comment or question it is the mic is yours yes I do thank you um love all of the commentary tonight especially from um all of you all of you doing wonderful tonight so thank you for that it's been an enlightening conversation um I want to uplift though a few things um to the attendance department and team I know that there is a data sharing agreement with the county and DHS and so I just want to especially for listening audiences because sometimes we're putting stuff out there because we ourselves may not understand how things work or systems um and then that also creates further misinformation and we do have an elected official from Monroe County spreading misinformation right now and to commissioner Santiago's Point like there are things that other
109electics can do to address these issues because rcsd is not going to be able to fix all of these issues but I do want to uplift that any kid in a shelter is accounted for if there are kids in rcsd and even Charter kids they are accounted for I know I have EX quite a bit of families on the cas right now at at the center and they're not just at the shelters they're also placed at hotels right but anyone who's placed through Monroe we have a data sharing agreement attendance is also tied to the adult benefits it's sort of a layered issue and I just want to put that out there that it's not just cut and dry that we lost a kid in a sheler that's not going to happen what will happen
110though and it happened to me literally a few weeks ago is that there are families who are not going to shelters don't want to deal with the county and that system and are finding abandoned homes and cars to sleep in and those are the students that I think I have the most concerned about because in that regard they're not tied to a system any system that can track them um and so unless someone is doing Outreach and uncovers them and makes that connection they unfortunately will continue to be lost in this community until the county and the city step up in those efforts there there are initiatives at play but there absolutely needs to be more done um to commiss malloy's point I don't my kids ever for half days I'm fully aware that it
111does impact attendance but right now three kids right and two that have a bell time at 7:30 7:45 get out on a half day is like 10:30 I don't have anyone to go pick up these kids uh watch them for me if I don't just a babysitter here having another grandparent come to my house to watch them and that's just the reality and my daughter doesn't have those resources either um and so none of the kids are going on half days that's just the reality I even when I it was my three girls and I was a single mom you know on the bus on a half day there was just just no capacity for me to go to a job turn around in two hours on the bus come back and pick them up
112get them somewhere else like just doesn't make sense I personally would love for this District to just eliminate half days at this point and just extend those training days for time off because as a parent I would rather know upfront that in March for example we're going to have an extra week off because teachers are doing their training and I then need to ahead of time plan for child care versus trying to plan for these random half days throughout the year it's just really frustrating and then to the point of chronic absenteeism um you know this is a topic we've discussed over and over and over again but to the core the core issue is poverty and all the issues that come around it that is the majority of the issues surrounding attendance I do
113want to uplift though that there are a small minority group of families in this District who are not poor but have certain Privileges and pull their kids out not because they want their kids to miss education but because they want their children to have a different type of education around a topic and may take them to travel and I'll uplift that previous commissioner Ricardo Adams you know put that out there he took his daughters out for a week and took them across the country on a topic that they were already studying at ease so he can bring them directly to those locations so that they can ask questions and explore um and that's something I would have do for my own kid in the future too so I I just think that if we can
114at least get a breakdown of these things but I'm curious about our data sharing agreement um certainly more than welcome to have these conversations additional conversations um with the district around what that looks like because for me it should be going both ways I know we shared information with the county around attendance because again that is tied to the adults benefits and whether they're still going to be eligible for their full benefits that is directly tied but I'm wondering if we can turn around if we have a student that's missing and reach out to the county to say this student hasn't been to school what's the last known address that you have for them because often times the County's always tracking um again the placements for shelter no one can go to a shelter without
115the county doing the actual placement and I think it's a tough reality when people have never experienced that and then they are in a position where they suddenly become homeless and they need help and they don't realize how difficult it can be to be eligible for an emergency situation because it is complex and these are federal regulations and not local so I just am curious if we're data sharing both ways thank you thank you vice president LeBron and if we can just put that in the question log I heard it come up a few times around these these um opportunities and Partnerships data sharing agreements so if you capture that Charisma thank you very much and Mr feny we again appreciate your presentation once you do have that table um set up and what have
116you I'd also love to see um when where they're willing student and families that have been impacted by chronic absenteeism for the various reasons that are willing to speak out and speak up I'm sure they can tell you what might have helped them in hindsight you know that type of thing and it may be a great um conversation if they are not already happening um to give you all some insight as to what their Journeys may have been as well and I'm sure on some level they are right so thank you so very much um that concludes this presentation at this time we're going to um thank you hi Mr PA I wanted to add another question to the board loock if we could okay and can we include also um uh vice president LeBron
117hit on an area but I was recently just talking about this with someone but if we could add and try to figure out um the absenteeism around Thanksgiving time and Christmas on those days where people leave out of town because those days prior to Thanksgiving those two days a lot of kids don't go go to school and that also is affecting the attendance so those are things that we really need to look into and see how we can probably add those days somewhere else down the line and have that week off instead of taking those two days those two days kids do not come to school lot of the peers go out of town so if we could add that I would I would like that to be looked into as well thank you commissioner
118Griff did you you could uh superintendent I I just I just want um everyone up here to keep in mind and this is for the community also we only have a certain amount of days to work with um so I want to be conscious of I hear you I definitely understand that we want to make sure that we have uh students in schools um as much as possible but we only we have a 180 day requirement that students have to be in school and our teachers and staff have to be in school for 185 days and that's between generally Labor Day May and June and now with all the additional holidays that are being requested and things of that nature we're going to run out of days and and I just want us to be
119conscious of this but quickly I did want to uh get to commissioner Griffin you asked a question about the number of students that are unhoused right now for Rochester City School District alone almost around 852 students that is people on the books possibly so that it could actually be more than that um but when you're talking about the whole District Charter Schools unhoused could be more because that those are the people that report recognize it yes so just just keep that in mind I did want to answer your question since you brought that up can you add dropouts as well can you get information on dropouts for the board law on for the record can we have the Dropout information we're going to conclude at this time yeah just add that all right let's move
120forward um I think I saw someone approach the the uh mic and it is time for teaching and learning Updates this is going to be focused on quarterly data freshman passing five classes in quarter 1 this will be presented by uh Secondary School Chiefs Donna Lucy Linder who I believe is standing there thank you Miss Linder and Ed mcadre is he coming this evening to joining us no he's not okay no worries so miss um Lucy Linder the mic is yours thank you commissioner Simmons um good evening everyone again my name is Donna Lucy Linder and I always have to say this I am the proud uh chief of network one I always have to shout out my network I would like to acknowledge uh president Elliot and the rest of the board for this
121opportunity to share on how our schools are performing after the first marking period I would also like to acknowledge interim superintendent Strickland my rcsd colleagues and all the students we have the opportunity to serve here in the city of Rochester again unfortunately Chief mcadre could not join us this evening but his voice is reflected throughout this presentation tonight and I also have another one of my colleagues here uh Chief Torres as well so as I uh launch into the presentation um this presentation is regarding cohort 2024 uh our ninth graders so here this is what I call another opportunity to activate dreams and also to unlock the potential poal that is within our students so after reviewing um all of the board's goals for 2023 to 2028 this presentation will focus on goal 1D which
122is to increase the number of students earning five or more credits um in n9th grade from 70% in September 2023 to 90% by June 20128 so um I know say so a lot it's okay um and looking at the graduation requirements it is important that um parents and also students know what the New York State graduation requirements are so they are listed on slide number four so all students graduating from rcsd uh must earn four credits in ela social studies three science credits um three math credits A World Language credit and also art credit as well as physical education health and also have 3.5 credits of electives for a total credit accumulation of 22 credits now before I move on why is this important as a part of the non-negotiables of our interim superintendent uh
123uh Mr Strickland it was very important to him that all students be aware of how many credits they are accumulating um in each School building so that's part of the process that we undergo as we visit all of our secondary school buildings so what is our data telling us at this particular time after the first marking period so on slide six I'll give you a moment to take a look at it you'll see all the secondary schools listed on your left um to your right you'll see the percentage of students who are on track and in the third col column is the total number of ninth graders in those various schools so um School 58 world of inquiry if you look at that I believe that number is 69 students and so we have 75%
124of students who are currently on track after the first marking period and just choosing uh another random school probably one of mine but but it's okay um I'm going to choose soda it has 135 students um actually 199 students I can't see my own writing with an 84% pass rate uh at this particular time so these are the students who are on track after marking period one are there any questions regarding this chart okay um so the next slide shows the typical ninth grade schedule if you look at the left column you'll see uh period one and you'll see 202 uh 4 25 and that's um this school year obviously and this is a algebra one course which is a year round course you see the numbers a through D that means that that is
125a four cycle course students meet on a b c and d days if you look at that second line You'll see students who are enrolled in a regent biology course so you see a slight difference in a and a through D so those students actually have a lab on a and C days but a through D days they actually have the uh the lecture component of their course um if you go all the way down to period 9 um you'll see a math lab and also an English lab this is to support our numeracy and also our literacy goals for our district in terms of supporting students with additional intervention support this next slide right slide number eight is the data for cohort 2025 which is our current eighth graders um as a part of
126my network I have uh uh middle schools as well as high schools so these are the students who are currently enrolled in Regent courses you'll see algebra biology earth science Spanish 1C Spanish 1p uh Spanish language art studio in art uh studio in art so you uh you see a total of 1,716 students with uh 78.1% of students who are actually passing after the first marking period I just want that to sit there for a moment because this slide can be a little confusing and if I go back to the top you'll see the total number of students enrolled across the district is 335 students and 273 students are passing with a pass rate after the first marking period of 81.4% the next slide please so how are we supporting these students we are taking
127intentional action steps we have uh Incorporated uh early monitoring systems to help support our our Learners um in terms of the graduation requirements are are distributed to all families and also students and they're also posted around the school uh counselors provide lessons to students about credit accumulation also about graduation requirements and they also have one-on-one goals meetings with students as well to let students know what the requirements are and if students need to make something up they also provide them with those opportunities as well uh in terms of interventions we have support strategies provided for all students who are not on on track we have those face-to-face conversations with students and also with families um we utilize a cohort tracker to track all of our students so that they can see where they are in
128terms of their courses and how many credits they are accumulating we are doing this in all secondary schools um the other goal all nth graders know the graduation requirements I've said that before and their earned credits and they should be able to tell you if any of you are to visit any of our schools um all staff in secondary schools share knowledge of graduation requirement ments with students school teams um the administrative teams monitor the cohort trackers and provide supports to ensure all ninth graders are on track to receive their ninth credits there are multiple layers of monitoring students progress via administrators counselors teachers and support staff such as uh Paras and anyone who's really in the school Community I've seen SSO step in and have conversations I've seen cafeteria workers have conversations I've seen
129custodians have conversation uh with students so it truly is a team effort School supports we at all secondary schools have marking period recovery options for our students and which they will have a certain period of time in which they can make up any work that they have lost either due to absence due to illness or any type of family uh challenges and or or struggles we also have online credit recovery options um for students as well in which they can also accumulate credits to make sure that they are staying on track towards graduation we have extended day programs which can happen after school and we're actually looking at some of our latest schools actually perhaps possibly having it uh before school starts if we can arrange busing and we also have Saturday options as well
130with the cohort tracking um those are uh those cohort track trackers are created at the beginning of the school year it says grade n but we also have them in Middle Schools as well during our recesses when um our students are still around and we have teachers in town we have recess Credit Recovery we also offer Summer Bridge programs to our students as well and so that we're not just focusing on students who are uh recovering credits we're also focusing on acceleration as well for students who are going above and beyond to make make sure that they remain challenged and engaged in their learn in their learning so at this particular time yes I'm brave are there any questions regarding the slides oh there's one last thing that I would like to mention before questions
131many thanks to our Visionary interim uh superintendent all of the school leaders that lead in our buildings every day to teachers support staff um clerical custodians and caregivers who wake up and work with their children every day uh as we all work together in support of our students so I just want to thank everyone for that and now questions thank you Miss Lucy Linder for your presentation at this particular time I'm going to open the day is for questions I'm trying to look at the uh teams or the zoom or what have you I don't think I see any tiny hands um I'm going to start at this end commissioner Malloy thank you Chief lender so much for your your present presentation great information looks like we're moving towards progress on on this important goal
132and uh looks like there's some great strategies being implemented so no questions at this time but thank you thank you um yes thank you for the presentation um we recognize the first it's so interesting when you work with students because the first markeing period they they come out everybody's ready and motivated and it's when you get into that third and fourth second they might do okay and then the third and fourth typically over the years when I've worked with students I noticed those are the areas that when they start to kind of get comfortable with the school year and um and so it these are um I would say encouraging percentages to see for the first marking period um I do have questions I think I might just go with the question log around schools
133um and how how students are placed I I just have a lot of questions around that but I don't think that's relevant to this presentation so I'm going to commit it to the question log I'm thinking through it as I talk so I'm going to move on and I'll come back to myself with an actual question I'm going to move on to president Elliott if you have a question at this time I'm moving down the line for you guys all right thank you so I have a question on I just want to be able to understand slide six what what are we looking at are we does this mean we're in a good position or tell me what I'm looking at cuz I'm not exactly sure slide six okay so slide number six has all
134of the secondary schools listed down the far left column okay and then if you look at the total number of ninth graders in the third column that's for each of the secondary schools and the percentage of students who are on track are in the far right column so if you're looking at World of inquiry school it has a total of 69 um n9th graders and 75% of those students almost 76% of those students are on track and in terms of passing their courses in the first marking perod yeah but when we look at the failing zero to2 classes is that is that not a bad thing or talk to me about what that that column actually means because that's going to I think help to inform uh moving forward and this is the first Market
135period right so I want to be able to understand and should and this I know that this is um you know first time that these ninth graders are receiving credits by and large and you know they're into a new kind of space but help me to understand this and help me to know that I can be encouraged U by what I'm seeing uh as we move forward into the succeeding marking periods okay thank you for that question so being encouraged because this information is being widely communicated to our students and we are given them the opportunity um to recover um some of the grades that or some of the projects that they may not have scored well on and if you look at the grand total of our percentages in the far right those are
136the percentages of students who are on track so overall in the district right now we have 60% of students who are on track after the first marking period and also be encouraged because we do have the after school and also Saturday program to also help support students in terms of passing these courses so that they can acrw or earn their credits is this the first thing I ask to miss uh Chief Torres sure yeah so to add to that question that you have so if you look at 58 School even though it says failing two classes 53 students right be encouraged because even though they're failing at this moment they can still earn the five credits that they need by the end of the year so that's why it's showing that that although 53 students
137are failing to classes yet by the end of the year they can still make it up those five credits so is there actually two classes or could it because it could be zero right you're saying failing to zero to two that they could be failing none or they could be failing one or more two okay but still get the five credits by the end of the year which is great and one of the things we're working at in elementary too is helping students also try to figure out a way like in algebra get how to start in middle school to get those credits that they need before they go to high school okay thank you I'm sorry I just would have loved to have seen maybe passing all which would put you at zero and
138then something that said failing one to two classes that might have made that a little more um distinct distinctive for me I rece that feedback and we we'll adjust accordingly thank you yes ma'am thank you so much all right we're going to move forward to um commissioner Santiago yeah I I'll just you know second with what they were saying because I I had to whisper in the superintendent ear over here like what's what do that first column mean and so um that would be good you know cuz some of us be ready like what's going on you know and so we don't want you know any red flags out there I think my my only comment is it's good to see a plan moving forward it's good to see the plan uh the programs that's
139available for the young people um that's currently in place um it looks like you guys are making an initiative to make sure that the young people know you know the requirements what they need to graduate um but I just want to also share you know just pushing and making sure every student knows about all of those programs with the online recovery the after school recovery um because sometimes we have the services people just don't know about them and so you know just pushing that out there and then I also very quickly if we can go to slide seven um is this this a the schedule for a ninth grader yes we had to add recess or something in there because as a college student I'm looking at that and I'm like man that's some time
140in there yeah all right so what can happen sometimes if students finish lunch early they can have recess right yes so that's the only thing but just in terms of trying to um support their literacy and numeracy skills has taken a priority because we need them to be able to pass those first sets or in some cases that that next round of regent exams yeah no and and it's important um but I was just looking at it I'm like that that's a full day but it's also good to see CTE included in the ninth grader schedule um and so just uh just UPS to you guys and and hope to see some good numbers by the end of the school year same keep working on it thank you thank you commissioner Santiago commissioner Patterson yes
141thank you again for your presentation um what do we do with the kids that for some reason even though you show it here that don't know where they are on track as far as credits what do we do with that seg that doesn't pay attention to this information because there's quite a few kids that you know when I speak to them and I ask them how many credits do you have and they can't answer so what do we do how do we get that information I think it's very important that each CH uh each uh student knows exactly you know where they are so even the ones that are failing you know they need to know how many credits do I have how many need how many do I need to make up you know
142to graduate and I I speak like I said I know I'm being repetitive right now but you know there's a few of them that you know especially my barber shop that don't even know that's a that's a great question so uh our students have one-on-one meetings with their counselors um and they set goals um in terms of where they are and where they would like to be do all of them know it 100% no but the information is available they do have these meetings we also have group meetings for our students our students also not uh receive progress reports in addition to report cards as well um at the end of the semester they would know their credit recovery but the early monitoring systems also inform students and families where where they are currently and
143what options are available to be able to uh recover a grade that they have lost as well thank you go ahead and I just want to um remind the board that the initiative that we have put in place is to support that effort that all students know where they are at right and so with the network teams the um Chiefs are going into the schools and having these conversations with the principles ensuring that that principles are making sure that counselors and even the principles themselves are having those delicate conversations with the students so that they know how many credits they have and what they and what's available for them to be able to get those credits C thank you okay um superintendent thank you uh just want to commissioner uh Patterson that was a great
144question um as was mentioned earlier that was one of my non-negotiables for all School leaders is that when we walk into schools and you would see me doing the same thing I start asking students how many credits do they have if you come up to a student and uh maybe you know it's a few of them and they don't know I definitely suggest you bring that to the principal um because that is something that was really uh expressed and continues to be reiterated each month at principal meetings that every student should know how many credits they have but also want to acknowledge that uh parents and some students and students in high schools actually have access to uh parent portal which is the power school um it's it's yeah through Power School so they should
145be able to actually look at the counselor dashboard that's on uh their parent portal and see how many credits they have but definitely bring that up to the school leader because that is an expectation for every single high school student and superintendent commissioner Griffin I'm coming for you or to you in just a moment I do want to just Echo that as far as ninth grade one best practice I happen to witness is I would say Edison High School um where the students I've gone a couple of years now for their uh kickoff and you would see all the graders come into the auditorium and there's a huge emphasis on the five I think they even have a mantra but it was five credits by the end of 9th grade and emphasizing that but they
146also additionally have the parent University embedded in their school and I've gone to some of those graduations where I've enjoyed watching parent um pilot cells I call them where they are able to really work and to understand what's needed for their child to be successful and those parents can also in turn um help educate other parents on what it looks like because because it can escape you it's just like go to school get your credits but what does that look like so I I have um appreciated those efforts commissioner Griffin the mic is yours thank you um I just wanted to add I for me when you're doing when you're doing the information in reference to the percentages it probably would have been a little bit easier with graphing for this but that's the only
147thing I want to say about the presentation outside of it was great information I just think it's would be a little bit easier to read and secondly you talked about um uh Credit Recovery is that also referred to Market period the market uh Market excuse me the market period recovery where the kid the child has like the 5we period has a time for them to increase their grade throughout that 5we period is that what you're referring to can you restate that I just want to make sure that I'm understand the market period recovery period that they have so they have a chance with with the teachers and and all that to re to improve their grade is that what referring to will you say Credit Recovery no so what happens is after a marking period
148there can be a time in which students still have work that they have not submitted and so they have a certain period of time to submit that work now in terms of credit recovery if a student has failed a course then they can actually go online through the Virtual Academy and take the course again on online to recoup that credit that they did not earn okay so those are two different things because I knew about the market period recovery but not the credit recovery thank you very they can also um have some credit recovery during recess as well for those marking periods and that's good information to know to the public because a lot of a lot of times you know parents because they're working they're not really knowledgeable understand that you know hey my
149God I didn't know you were failing um even I put myself in in a position where uh one of my sons had a 93 in in science and he was fine and then when I got to the school it was something totally different and I was kind of Blown Away and was not notified about it so and here I'm thinking everything is fine but the parent you know even and I felt the teacher had a responsibility to let me know because I how would I know that if if something was wrong so uh me as myself as a parent and and and my child as a student we we have to be we have to be present in some things and and for this for this I did not know anything about it I learned
150about it as a parent recently so I just want to put it out there that you know even myself I I'm learning and as parent as a parent myself I want people to take that initiative and help your children and understand the process because it is imperative that even me on this board know that process because even though I thought everything was fine you know then I come in something else and I do fought myself as a parent I fought my my child and I fought the teacher because I think that that should have been a common knowledge for them to come to me and say Hey listen your child is failing so but one wouldn't think that from a 5we peracute going to go to a 93 to to a lower grade so so
151I think that this is something that we really need to grab the bull by the horns and and ensure that our teach teachers are making the initiative and the parents and the child are taking responsibility to ensure that we can prevent failure at all costs so that we don't see scho students or the schools be hit by this so thank you very much thank you commissioner Griffin right and there's sensitivity around depending on the science like it can be you're doing great in the course but the lab credits aren't there and those like 1200 minutes so that'll that and so you're able to Rattle that off but the majority of our parents probably cannot and that's the communication that needs to Bridge and I think that's so powerful the efforts that you all are making
152to ensure that does happen um between attendance what we're hearing in the networks this evening and um and so on uh you did mention after school and PM programs and things of that nature and I'm I'm I'm hoping that because I know not all schools are the same some PM programs may not be working in one school but they're they're working wonders at another and so I'm hoping that um the consideration of these these um programs as we look at what's going to what's going well what we need to move around that we look individually at the school communities where they're working or not working um be before anything is adjusted if that makes sense no it makes a lot of sense and communication to home is key because we need our students to stay
153they need that extra support and and if we're there we want them in the building with us so attendance needs to increase with those PR especially Saturday programming because I think if students are coming in with a with a fresh night of sleep and they can come in and they can get a lot in those few hours in the morning yeah and we also I mean and I and I'm going to get off my soap box but also there some of those School communities that are they're they're like models right they're not the traditional piece and and and it's just important that we try to follow things to Fidelity like I'm I go to I got to have some conversations but thank you for this presentation this evening I don't see any hands on the
154zoom I'm just keep calling it zoom and um again thank you Miss Lucy Linder and and um for your presentation this evening and thank you guys for serving our kids thank you and Miss Santana thank you so very much um so folks my computer is frozen um yes that completes the esa can I um oh I'm sorry that [Music] um you know what I have the discretion to do that and normally you you have to sign up to speak and and you sat here all evening it's 8 o' whatever you have to say is probably very important and so I'm going to extend this opportunity but what we will need to do is we're going to I make it short we're going to give you three minutes to share um respectfully please state your name
155into the mic and then you have three minutes to share your thoughts my name is Maria Gonzalez uh I came here to the meeting because I I have grandkids in school I'm Sorry Miss Miss gon I don't want to interrupt you we're gonna need because everyone can't hear you they're saying we need to hear you in the mic go ahead and restate your name and your your concern Maria Gonzalez uh I have grandkids in the in the city school district I even had my son when he started school here and he was a special ed okay I understand about special EDS about what's going on and I was willing and I came to talk in 2010 okay about what's going on with special ed I already explained to them about what's going on wrong about
156half a day of school uh talk to them about cutting off the half a day so the kids can be all day in school so they don't miss a day in school also I I mentioned why they have to call the smt when a p a child is absent why they have to wait till 3:00 to let the parent know that the child didn't go to school you know I mention it because a lot of people parents from the community they came to me and they tell me can you ask them why they call it 3:00 why the child is not in school so and some of those child they go to school but they go someplace else so you know I'm just letting you guys know what the community is talking to me about
157it's a parent they have Childs in the in the city school district so I just want everything better for those kids okay I even have a special child grandchild that you you cannot wait into there's a problem with that child to do a test from the you know Health practitioner if you see the teacher see a child that has problem please let the parent know as soon as possible what they see the way into the last minute when they're like almost the school end so I'm letting you know that we got to communicate you know better with the parents teacher with parents and parents with a teacher okay don't wait until the last year you know so you the child don't say they didn't pass grade because of this so and that's a Healy hand
158you know so yes thank you very much for your words Miss Gonzalez we have heard you we have you on um this meeting and so um we do appreciate it before you leave we're going to have someone connect with you so that you um they can give you the process to make sure that you're on the record or what have you but I'm I'm happy I was able to extend this opportunity for you to speak for have a blessed evening thank you this concludes the equity and student achievement Committee of the whole for the evening oh Monica Graham I forgot about you Monica come on I'm here I'm right here sis go ahead now I've been here all evening I know you ain't see my face but I've been here all evening so we can't
159see those tiny hands I just want to say thank you um to the Commissioners um to the presenters especially Miss Gonzalez thank you so much for showing up showing up for our community showing up for our parents showing up for our babies um I haven't said much because the conversations have been robust and you guys are on fire tonight I'm checking my notes and I'm like yep commissioner Santiago said this commissioner Simmons mentioned this commissioner Malloy missed this superintendent said this so I appreciate you all and I ask as a parent um as a community member that you continue with these robust conversations and um with these robust presentations in these informative presentations because we are watching we may not be able to show up or watch real time but the parents are watching and
160they need to know this um so I appreciate everyone that showed up tonight and Miss Gonzalez you did that so thank you so much thank you Miss Graham thank you so very much and so without further Ado we're going to close the equity and student achievement Committee of the whole this evening I do ask all Commissioners to take part in the U meeting survey um this will be followed by the special meeting um immediately following this uh I'm going to turn the mic over to president Elliott at this time oh yeah I enter well stay here all night okay entertaining a motion to close the meeting uh motion by commissioner Santiago second and by commissioner Malloy all in favor I this meeting is adjourned we will do the uh board um survey and then we'll
161go right into the uh uh special meeting oh I never LED in what sir get e e e uh good evening we are resuming for our special meeting uh which we are convening to uh consider uh resol uh resolutions for this evening um there are no speakers uh for this special meeting and so if my colleagues are okay with it uh we can just go and bundle and uh move them all at one time if everybody's in agreement with that all right so um so is there motion for Resolutions 368 through 376 still moved moved by commissioner Malloy second by commissioner Santiago any questions or comments related to resolutions 368 through 376 commissioner Santiago this is um a new commissioner question uh well new word commissioner question for provisional appointment what does what does that
162mean well at I'm sorry uh good evening thank you commissioner so a provisional appointment is essentially uh an appointment whereby someone is um tempor temporarily um in the the appointment until they're considered permanent okay and so it's it's an evaluation period of time before they achieve that permanency okay thank you any any other questions and comments related to resolutions 368 through 376 okay hold on one second I one second president Ellie I just want to make sure that is this the nisbit policy where we at right now I'm sorry under number three agenda item number three resolution consideration bunding you have opened the um special meeting agenda I thought I did hold on one second maybe I'm in the wrong thing cuz I want to make sure that no you're not you're in the right
163area no I'm not I was in the wrong one that's why I don't see what I'm looking for hold on one second I apologize I was in the wrong um meeting one second and we have resolution uh B and C uh resolutions 368 through 376 right and it's under uh the agenda item number three okay yes um for b and c I have questions that need to be addressed in a executive session okay so um I didn't hear what resolution number she's referring to 368 and yes 369 and what was the other one 370 vice president let me let me do uh Comm vice president 368 and 369 thank you president all right okay it's not 368 it's 369 and 370 oh well you said A and B so that's why I was I'm a
164little confused so let me let me back up it's 368 and 370 no 369 and 370 oh so B and C yes all right okay my apologies all right so we have a motion on the floor to uh for the um uh all the resolutions 368 through 376 can I get someone to do we want how do you do this Mr um councel um if the if the board wishes to get those in the um executive session before they U discuss before they make a decision you can just um just amend the bundle uh to exclude them so um do we have to draw the original motion um you can go ahead and withdraw it yeah draw the motion withdraw all right so uh we're going to for Resolutions 369 and 370 um we'll take
165those in executive session so um is there motions for Resolutions 368 and then 371 through 376 motion second commissioner Santiago second by commissioner Malloy all those in favor I any opposing thank you uh vice president president Elliott I'm sorry I just want to note that I will not be going into executive session for those resol Solutions but if we had voted tonight I would be in support of both of those thank you all right thank you um and so uh those pass and we will discuss resolutions 369 and 370 in executive session and then the next item on the agenda uh we did we vote on those we did vote right okay the next item on the agenda is the committee diet and this is where we are um reducing the number of um meetings
166that we have and so what you have before you and Rima did send this out is the calendar uh for those meetings and remember these are now work sessions is what we um are looking at so uh and we also have U Cindy Cindy um Eisner uh from the Council of great City Schools who's joined us um that if we have any questions or comments that she may be able to support us with this so um this is what you have before you is the calendar for um our work sessions and what uh we will be what the agenda will be for each one of those months so let me just open it up for any questions commissioner Malloy yeah so tonight's uh meeting is about a committee diet right committee diet calendar so I
167know that last week we voted on um a policy or I thought we had discussed a policy of maintaining three committees the audit committee the policy committee as well as I'm sorry the the esa committee as well um does this adhere to to that model here or is this is this a change that's what I have a question this is an addition too if I can just um go back um chair chair excuse me let me just let um chrisma weigh in so just for clarity uh last week's policy um review for 2300 is not included in this current committee structure if the board um so the the board is slated to vote on this committee um structure next week's business meeting and so what would happen is that if this becomes your new structure
168we would um have a resolution for you all to vote on an updated 2300 that would then remove all the Committees except audit um so that's what would happen but right now no it does not include um this committee structure so under this structure the only committee that would still exist is the audit committee no polic comments on that all of that will be done in these work sessions all of those discussions because remember that we eliminating um the Committees for the most part and having these work sessions the only required committee is audit right okay commissioner Patterson and so the other question I have is want to make sure we're going to have those discussions relative to moving from Committee of the whole yes so if you look in the excuse me if you
169look in the uh in the second and third well all the columns you will find you will see where um those particular committee functions will um will be discussed okay so like if you look at say in March there's claims audit um there is the uh draft budget there um if you look at I'm trying to look at uh quickly um with some of those items will be um discussed policies in July for example is what I'm seeing also in June I'm seeing policies so you know if you can just look through that you'll find that the committee functions what we were doing is going to be captured in this particular uh framework um anything else commissioner uh Patterson no thank you all right uh commissioner Santiago go yeah I just want to say I
170do not and I could be off but I don't remember having an agreement with removing policy and Esa in the upcoming 2025 year I thought the plan was to continue with Esa policy and audit in the 2025 year and with plans to sunset at some point but to have that discussion later and so I I can't I'm not in agreement with this because we didn't make that agreement as far I thought the three same committees that we were keeping for 2025 was policy Esa and other yeah it commissioner um Griffin I concur with uh commissioner Santiago this is not what we discussed I didn't even understand what was going on when I looked at it okay so let me just also say too that um these documents have been sent out and most of you
171all didn't take a look at these documents prior so you know we're having some discussion now that we have some discussion now that you know rahima sent these out and um now we're getting discussion but there should have been a review of this and that those discussions H before now so that's that's part of the issue too that we're now trying to get this out so I just remind my Commissioners that the staff sends this information us to out to us in plenty time um but you know we don't get they don't get the response that they need that you all have you know taken a look at this information so you know keep that in mind that we've got to do this work we should not be doing this kind of work at the
172day now this should have been done before we're pulling the car before the horse let me go to commissioner M yeah so I do all of my homework um yes so I always do my homework um and I did my homework on this by by reading this no no no but I think a lot of us did read this in advance but weren't quite clear at what we were looking at and how this compared to the conversation that we just had last week for policy 2300 at the policy meeting and so I think that was the confusion and that is a discussion that we should be discussing on the deis uh publicly because I mean we have questions um we're always revising our calendar and I think all of us at that not the retreat
173but the work session that we did with the council for the great City Schools there was an understanding that we were going to commit to a policy diet similar to what commissioner Santiago said but that the actual sunsetting of those uh committees was not going to be taking place until I think March of 2025 forgive me if I'm misunderstanding but I did read this in advance and it's the confusion about what we discussed last week versus this um I'm not opposed to you know sunsetting committees but this is just a little bit different that's why I have questions this evening thank you president Elliott can um commissioner um Charisma I'm sorry I just wanted to give some CL so back at the board work session um October 28th that you all are referencing yes you
174had some discussion about committee diets and Esa policy and um audit were the policies that most Commissioners wanted to see remain with Esa being sunsetted at some point and policy potentially being modified um what happened was that at the November 21st meeting as well as email rahima shared the documents as currently attached to this meeting um to get commissioner feedback and at that time no you know Commissioners did not have any input so then she followed with the email to receive input um and so with that being said because it wasn't really a temperature of which way to go it's being bought back tonight but the reason why um you're seeing this as a work session in a business meeting versus the policy committee the audit committee and the esa committee was basically all that
175had happened was all of um the committee uh work plans for this this year were basically collapsed into the months that you see so nothing was removed in term of in terms of like the committee's work um any Esa topics that would have taken place in January a policy topics were basically put onto that work session um just to kind of show Commissioners like what could happen if you all went to two meons a month versus having those other committees and so that's basically I just want to get clarity as to like why you're seeing this document versus um what was discussed um two months ago commissioner Simmons yes thank you president Elliot right and I I think I'm I'm pretty clear on that um and not having the conversation via email to avoid um
176what do you call it a quorum online or what have you but having this public conversation and I do appreciate understanding what it could look like um with these collapsed and what this would be the future state is what I'm understanding when I look at this document once all communities are Sunset the future state would be them working in the work sessions and one board session and this would be what it what it is right the the goal was hopefully you all this could be moving forward in January janary but answer the first question the first question I'm asking is this this is if we were to move forward with the ultimate goal the ultimate goal was we would be facing this right my second question so I just wanted you to do I I
177need the slow walk I call slow walk give me the slow walk and the second part of that is so so this is the future State and what I'm understanding now is that the future state has been accelerated we were going to move gradually toward it and there's and who made that decision to accelerate the future State through socializing this to us so is no necessary no decision made per se and like this is what the board is going to do this is just conversation to see if this could happen at more accelate rate in jary to it going quicker and doing remember now remember it was sent out so you understood but we can't talk about it online we got to talk publicly no but I guess what I was U what go ask
178her about it what what rahima was was thinking is that you would review it you could Ju Just you know send it to her directly so uh um vice president yeah I do want to clarify that piece that when rahima sends it out we can send feedback to the board Clerk and the board clerk can collectively take all of our feedback and then share that out at the public meeting this is all you all said but she's sort of like that's the way to sort of have a conversation without having us breaking com you know um open meetings law um it's just to give the staff directly the feedback um so a couple of things I just want to clarify that nothing was voted on um and she sort of mentioned it to me too
179and I was like I don't remember voting on any changes just yet but one I've wholeheartedly support a policy diet um to I my if it was up to me by myself I would do it for January however for me I also have to think about our families and the calendar that we've already put out to them to then say hey suddenly we're having these conversations during the month of December when people are not really paying attention because it's the holiday for them as well um and then all of a sudden switch the calendar that has already been sent out and like our meetings are in the district's calendars too like we meet every Tuesday blah blah blah it's on our website I know the website can be quickly um change but it is such
180a big shift in the way that the board does things and even in our culture and our Norms from what this community is used to that I personally want to advocate for a date to Sunset within this school year that we start July 1 with a new calendar right and with less committees but that we also send out Communications to the community and to families in the district and even staff just informing them about these changes and why and that we are actually aligning ourselves for the first time in my history in this Comm in this board um into an actual governance model and not just people from the community who got elected and coming in with their own ideas and Views and have never governed so I I think that needs to also be
181explicitly stated and explicitly stated and particularly to our uh families and our staff in this District the the who what when why how and why and give that a timeline um and again we're still in the middle of a school year and I know it' be confusing because school starts in September and we don't end to like June but that is the school year and so when we put out a calendar with that timeline to make big sweeping changes within that school year I personally if it was just up to me and it was only going to be me impacted yes to January but it's not just about me and my family right it's thousands of families across this district and I would like to give them the opportunity to understand the who what where
182why how and what these changes mean and even looking at how families sign up to speak right right now in our current policy and community members can only sign up to the Committees that sort of align with the topics right if they're off topic they're not allowed to speak at a committee meeting they are allowed to come and speak at the general business meeting are we going to apply that to the Tuesday meetings because the other thing is that we're calling them work sessions but I just want to remind the public that whether we call it a committee meeting a work session or a board business meeting that they're business uh they're all board business meetings essentially but that they're all public open law meetings of the board period doesn't matter what we call it
183it's still a board meeting um but yeah those are my thoughts and that's where I'll where I'm at with it thank you thank you vice president commissioner Santiago yeah I'll just say um for for me personally I only support what the board agreed on during the work session which was to to keep audit to at some point to keep Esa until we Sunset that and to revise policy committee and so that's what we agreed on collectively and so my support continues behind that I don't know you know I know that this was may have been sent out um and I may have missed it myself personally but I don't think any decision should have been made even to the place of a draft without a collective decision like there was a collective decision on the
184sunsetting of certain policies and so um unless it's it's the what we agreed to collectively during that work session um I I I don't support it commissioner Patterson um you know for me personally um the the public expects us to make some changes um you know as a board and function the way other boards are operating be a big five or even the the smaller schools we can do this we can make change um and yeah change is uncomfortable um but it's the right thing to do there's no reason for us to have this many committee meetings um this has been said for a number of years um that um you know we need to move away from that so you know whether you know we cut back on a few or whether you know
185uh you know we we get rid of a few then um you know the Council of great City Schools um Dr Hart has made some great recommendations relative to you know what we should be doing here um as far as governance uh he has over 30 years experience you know in education so you know we're paying this individual this organization to come in and train us but we're not really we're like fighting you know uh some of the recommendations that you know his group is making um again you know it's uncomfortable I know it's uncomfortable um but we have to uh you know just decide to um change and then uh I forgot the slogan and maybe one of you can help me adult you are the Genesis so you're supposed to say I but
186I'm going to say you supposed to say to yourself I am the Genesis he but there's something else relative to um adult behaviors don't change oh student outcomes yeah until uh you know give it to me again let's say it adult uh student outcomes what adult student outcomes don't change until adult behavi there you go unless adult behaviors change on me I I I want to go to commissioner Griffin um thank you uh president Elliot I just want to say that I I firmly believe that we're all on the same page in reference to sa that we're not we're not saying it doesn't have to change we just want to make sure that the time frame is done correctly and what we agreed upon in the meeting uh several but two months ago or a
187month or so ago and and that the committee died is what we were saying so I don't think it was a confusion so I think that we're all in agreement that we need to change it but we don't want to push it on long like it was being pushed because it could interfere with the public so I think that was the consensus I don't think that we we were not in agreement of that at all thank you commissioner Griffin commissioner Simmons yes thank you president Ellie yes um not to personalize but yes commissioner Griffin that that's pretty much what I wanted to say that I think we have all explicitly expressed the Readiness and the need to change we we recognize that we want it and uh celebrate it actually it's necessary um but we
188just had a parent representative and no she does not speak for all parents but she is very um present in a lot of parent spaces and has a very strong gauge on parent voice again she's not the be all end all but I think Monica um you know I I'll leave it for her words when she got off the uh Esa meeting just now she just said I love the conversation the community is watching we we want to see these things continue I actually looked at commissioner Malloy and said we're about to Sunset a lot of these um but she was letting us know that she that she and a lot of parents she's encountering are appreciating these meetings and so I think doing our due diligence as commissioner Griffin would say we um do
189need to make sure we uh Sunset these in a responsible manner so that the community does not feel slighted or what have you they have a robust understanding of what is happening commissioner Malloy yeah thank you and kudos to props to everybody else and what they've said I agree with with all the sentiments that have been expressed um even by commissioner um Patterson um when I gave feedback on the calendar like I was looking at hypothetically like this is a great way that we can in the future structure this and that was the feedback that I provided um but I that again I didn't the feedback that I initially provided on this specific calendar that went out was I thought this was the end all type of calendar that we were working towards um based
190on the prior conversations and the work sessions that we had had I didn't know that that would actually be our calendar that we were making a decision about sunsetting right at that point but I would agree that we do need to make change and I support that change I do like that format of the calendar um as I shared and uh I I think that we should wait to start this though similar to what U vice president LeBron said for July 1 stting yeah so that's what I was going to um to ask uh I think that um to the vice president's point her recommendation of starting in July where where are folk on that and that we would continue with those other committees where do you all okay with that let me just go
191to commissioner uh Griffin first I agree okay commissioner Patterson I think we I should let me start I'm tired so excuse me I think we should stay the timeline that we've been given you know by the Council of great City Schools so whatever timeline he came up with I think we should remain there he's done that for a purpose and I don't think we should continue keep pushing things back just my thought yeah so we could check on what that timeline was yeah uh commissioner Santiago I I agree with what was originally set out with sunsetting Esa at some point uh revising policy and keeping onit and if I'm not mistaken I think Esa was going to be sunset prior to July even so I think some of these things were happening as we approached
192that July date but I would have to go back and look at the original agreement and do we have record of the original agreement like I love this document but do we have this based on our original agreement we do make sure that the board one last thing president the audit people keep mentioning audit up here but by law we have to keep audit audit is is the one committee that we have to keep so all right thank you uh commissioner Malo did you have any input no I just uh I I agree with what has already been expressed I'd like to wait until U let me just ask our state monitor if he has any input on this process this conversation thank you president Elliot this is a great conversations uh the idea for
193this to be on the agenda tonight is again is to get the board engage in this discussion uh there was some conversations before about some setting some committees immediately and some committees were going to be waiting until later on so again this is a great discussion and like commissioner Patterson said uh the council has been willing to work and support so let's continue to work with them and and move the agenda forward thank you st mon so I'm going to to go to um Cindy are you still on the call to see if you've got some input into this conversation uh Cindy El is from the Council of great City Schools hi everyone can you hear me okay we can yes okay um so I uh believe that I know it was Dr har who
194was with you when you went through the committee diet a couple of months ago um and I I have connected with him um on which committees the and and what you have been staying uh around the audit being you need to keep that by law um Esa being sunset uh not quite immediately in January but um soon uh and then the policy committee um I think that sounds accurate um um so I think a revision to uh this calendar in a way that you've been speaking to um with with the July uh it still it still is um moving the process along of implementing student outcomes focused governance um and honoring some of those uh comments and concerns that you've brought so um I don't have the exact date or agreement that you have around
195the sunet esa though um so that we need to look back at all right Cindy thank you very much appreciate the conversation commissioner Santiago yeah I just want want to very quickly say and I know that this you know this may be a little bit challenging to the current thought but with when it comes to our partnership with uh Dr Hart and their organization um I think there's a difference between working with them and just being yes men to everything that they have to say and so I hear that you know they give recommendations but we're the ones who are elected and we're the ones who represent the community that we represent and so there's a difference between working with them and being Yes Man and so every time I may challenge something it's not
196me trying to work against them it's me being the the person who was elected onto the Board of Education and understand the community that I represent because there's a difference between working with them and just being Yes Man and I I don't plan to be a Yes Man for anybody all right um last Charisma I just just want to get some clarity so I do understand the July 1st the July 2025 start date um and I understand policy modifying Esa Sunset and my question just for clarity because we have a January organization meeting um for cigr HC and finance um are are Commissioners get an agreement to get rid of those and okay I just want to be clear about that yes ma'am okay all right commission Malloy yeah I I wanted to agree with
197a lot of the sentiments uh expressed by uh commissioner Santiago um but yeah to be clear I don't think that this was the proposed calendar from the Council of great City Schools it was our understanding from the calendar they gave us at the work session that the earliest that we would see the committee diet take place and take effect was March 2025 that had been their recommendation so I don't think that this is just you know so I think the last point on this has to do with when do we uh are is the June 30 30th date the date that we Sunset the remaining committees or what's your recommendation commissioner Santiago I think is what we agreed to in the first place what we agreed to was that Esa will es Esa will progressively
198get to a sunset policy will be revised and AIT will stay that was the agreement originally it wasn't for every committee to be sunset Commission Griffin well it was for from my understanding for my recollection and I think you know before I even say anything let's get the information that was given to us at that meeting and let it give be given back to us so that we can so we can see it you know instead of making making accusations or assumptions I think that's the best way to do it because nobody's really 100% certain so I think for all of for for for myself I would rather have the information present it to me again to get the accurate dates because I was just trying to look for it on here and I can't
199even find it in my emails so if we could get that information I would greatly appreciate it all right thank you thank you we'll do that so any other conversation about the committee diet uh commissioner vice president you have okay yeah it is in our email I just want to put it out there like it was actually sent to us twice before the original conversation it's just a chart from the great uh Council um the so just have to say I'm actually I don't have any strong feelings about which committees get Sunset which don't because at the end of the day the work still has to get done it's just a matter of how the work gets done but again we're talking about a district at least for the last 24 years that I have
200been appearing in this District have had these committees with the exception of human resources that one was added during my time on this board um and a few others right who have changed in their names have change but it's also in our bylaws how parents and community members sign up to speak and I just want to remind folks that yes the community expects us to make changes however they also expect us to communicate those changes and having these discussions in an open board meeting is not going to cut it we're still going to have to do the heavy lift of communicating clearly and articulating to the community how they're going to be able to sign up to speak on certain topics um and so forth and if that requires any changes in our bylaws and
201whatever that's for us to figure out but that is the only concern I have is that again it's such a big shift in culturally procedurally how we have done things that we would be am missed on our to shame on us if we did not do our due diligence as the Board of Education to communicate this out to all of our fames and our staff and so forth that's all I don't have a preference on a timeline president Elliott if y'all want to vote for January y'all want to vote for July I just again remind folks that procedurally we've done it for so long a certain way that the public does not expect us to make changes without articulating what those changes are again the who what when why how communicated to them so that
202they have the understanding of how they get to come and speak and Advocate at these meetings thank you all right U thank you so if there's no other discussion um let's can I get a motion to go into executive session to discuss matters leading to the appointment or employment of a particular person to discuss matters made confidential pursuant uh to federal state law and to receive the advice of the general counsel is permitted by Section 105 of the open meetings law is there motion motion by commissioner Santiago is there second second by commissioner Malloy um all those in favor I I and so we will um adjourn from downstairs but thank you all for joining us let me just also uh yeah yeah um so let me just thank my colleagues for a robust discussion
203really do appreciate it appreciate everybody that was a part of this discussion so thank you very much and uh good night to the public thank you e e e back to the um uh the special uh meeting we have two resolutions to vote on after discussion so can I get a for Resolutions 269 and 270 369 to 370 369 and 37 hold up hold up hold up can I get a motion all right uh all those in favor any opposed okay all right no no no no I just 369 London is approved so you're voting in favor of resol all right and so you're against so so it's a it's 70 for 369 what happened okay sorry sorry okay all right but it's 61 for resolution 270 all right all right all right so we
204good yep all motion to motion to adjourn second all those in favor good night everybody who second the moot okay e