CorpusRecord 63952

Board of Education Meeting 12/10/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Rondout Valley Central School District
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Ulster County, NY
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,925 words · about 72 min
Collected
2026-06-10

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e for e e it was a part oh I don't I understand so that's the only thing that's that's the only thing that's picking up the sound we're going to jack the [Music] volum what you doing [Music] so I'm going to go down there [Music] have still no they [Music] do [Music] trying to pull trying to p okay everyone I think we ready to started here I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for [Music] all recommended motion to approve the Revis December 10 2024 Board of Education meeting agenda as presented uh any discussion we do have a modification someone wants to make that that motion I'll make a motion to I'll make a

002motion to amend uh the the agenda to to move public comment prior to 72 to a second I'll second any discussion all in favor any oppos motion carries all right next agenda we have our Ganda Spotlight recognition from our junior high school and Miss Victoria saot from the junior high school will do a presentation good evening everybody hear me okay okay so for our Gander Spotlight to start we will hold on difficulties uh start with uh Heather Crowley and Jared free if you can come up uh to the podium I'm pleased to recognize Heather Crowley and Jared GRE for bringing the unified PE programed to our school this past year their Vision passion and dedication have created a space where all students regardless of ability can come together to learn grow and Thrive through physical

003activity unified PE embodies the values of inclusivity teamwork and empathy by fostering connections between students of diverse abilities this program not only enhances physical fitness but also builds lasting friendships and a stronger sense of community it has enriched our culture and exemplifies our commitment to creating an environment where every student feels Valu valued and included uh thank you Heather and Jared who is uh running a little late CU he's at a basketball game uh for your leadership and for going above and beyond to make this Vision a reality your hard work has set a powerful example of what it means to teach with heart Innovation and purpose I'm also pleased to announce that the Ronda Valley School District unified PE program received the Hudson Valley Region's unified grow in program award and we will be

004honored at an award Diner this Friday [Applause] so okay next up George Blanc can you please join me at I'm pleased to recognize George lanc our senior crisis counselor whose dedication has been a Cornerstone of support for not only our special education programs but for all the students in the Middle School Mr LeBlanc Works irly to provide compassionate guidance and support for our students his work extends far beyond far beyond crisis response it encompasses building trust in relationships fostering resilience and providing our students with access to the emotional and behavioral support they need to succeed he is a valuable member of our special education teams and our building level teams he provides valuable contributions and insights and we deeply appreciate the patience expertise and empathy that Mr W brings to this critical role his work

005exemplifies the core values of inclusivity equity and unwavering care that our school strives of SCH thank you George for your leadership dedication and the meaningful impact you make every day our school Community is stronger and more compassionate because of your efforts thank [Applause] you he was also a winner of the Thomas King the service award last year [Music] [Applause] and for our Gander student of the month uh Angelina lunstead who unfortunately could not be here tonight um but one of her teachers did nominate her and I'll you nominations uh Angelina is a kind compassionate and generous person who is always willing to jump in and help a friend or teacher in need without asking for anything in return she has helped to Bright in our hallways with her creative paintings and drawings in murals and

006collaborative art projects over the years one up there you can see uh she's the kind of student leader who quietly encourages and uplifts those around her without claiming the spotlight for herself uh We've witnessed her influence those around her to make good choices stand up to bullying and help her appears to feel a sense of belonging by making an effort to include quieter voices in the conversation so uh that is for Angelina in okay so at this point I'm going to do a um an update on how we're doing with our Northstar metric uh for the junior high that is maximum effort um and our overall goal this year was to reduce the amount of time students are missing instruction uh we feel that you know the more time the students are in school in

007the classroom uh getting the instruction they need um the better good results will have um and in looking at the amount of time students are missing instruction we're looking at three key pieces of data U we're looking at our smart pass data that is a new program we're using this year um to uh it's a digital Hall Pass Program and what's nice about that is we can see the amount of time students are missing class and put in uh interventions based on uh that time we're also looking at our tenance reports and our suspension rates um and monitoring that to see how we're doing with the goal our first objective um in trying to um improve the amount of times students are in class uh is starting with attendance um and this has been a

008goal that we have been uh working on for the past few years especially since Co um and we have um increased the amount of time students have been in school um throughout the years and we're hoping to continue improve that um but our um objective related to attendance is that um we will ensure that 100% of students identified as chronically absent um receive targeted interventions um the way we are doing that is through monitoring the attendance data at our monthly attendance meetings uh that is a team um of myself uh the counselors our school nurse and our social worker um our bi-weekly student review team meetings um in those meetings we have same people along with our crisis um our behavior um our behavior analyst our senior crisis counselor uh the school counselors school psychologist

009and we really come together and determine interventions uh for students based on um attendance uh social emotional concerns and then also creates uh we also collaborate with Community organizations um and we've been doing that for a number of years now the highlights so far this year uh we have been successful in um about over 10 instances of working with students to um have it so that we no longer have to provide those types of interventions so in a couple months uh we've already been pretty successful uh in um having those students um moved off of of our um of our review list and are able to then provide supports to to others uh for our next steps we're going to continue monitoring our data and provide individualized interventions um to continue to improve our attendance

010read our second objective uh this one's related to restorative practices and social emotional learning uh we want improve our school climate scores related to student to student relationships uh by 25% and we'll be looking at the U climate survey results U comparing them from last year to this coming year um some of what we are doing uh so far this year uh continuing proactive and restorage circles in the classrooms or um in the counseling offices uh we have um social emotional learning collaborative groups through some of our counselors our school psychologists and um um outside providers uh we do some conflict mediation as needed uh we have the stack anti-bullying curriculum that we um did do in the fall um in all of our classes and we also partnered with poster prevention Council uh they

011came in in the fall as well and did some work um uh the too good for drugs program was also touches on um student relationships um to highlight um we have something new this year um that we've been trying in our counseling Suite uh it is a clinic model in which if students um feel the need uh they can access a counselor or school psychologist social worker of at any point um during the day and that's been um uh been going very well with our counseling staff um students are able to access them get support they need and then we're able to give them back to class um in a time with fashion because what we really want is again for our students to be in the class as much as possible uh for our

012next steps we're going to monitor progress by surveying students uh to measure Improvement in school climate and address our strategies as needed so the plan for that is to do that in [Music] January and our third objective is related to high engagement in classroom activities um we are hoping to increase the percentage of students reporting that by 50% at the end of the year uh some of what we've been doing so far this year um is we've had professional development for our teachers um in Universal Design for Learning and writing Revolution um our instructional coaches have been instrumental in that and providing that professional development and then providing the individualized support to uh teachers um and departments we have an instructional support team that meets and looks at uh data for groups of students we

013have a number of interventions through AIS and some of our um highlights so far with the writing revolution in udl in the classroom um you'll see the slide up there is um uh writing Revolution speech therapy so they're using um writing Revolution strategies through speech uh we have u a class that is practicing writing complete sentences with correct punctuation by turning uh scrambled sentences into actual sentences um for reinforcing skills for lab conclusions uh we have sentence activities integrate because but so and short answer questions uh we have student simulation that we're doing uh online copy of class notes accessible for all students and a number of other um examples just a few of what we're doing in the class um for our next steps we'll continue providing the PDL um in udl and for

014writing Revolution uh we'll continue that with our um instructural coaches and we'll be pushing into uh the classrooms U working with our teachers and finally this is my my math equasion here so the theory is um you know improve attendance um having positive student relationships and increased engagement we'll have maximum results from all of our effort and just to highlight um from last year um 100% of our students passed the aler one regions last year um which was which was really great and we scored the best in the county for the 2024 8th grade New York State Science assessment um so we are hoping to continue that for this coming year and and continue uh making good stries so that's it thank you very [Applause] much thank you to S to all your staff and

015what you guys do each and every day uh more recognition coming up we want to recognize our uh full sports teams we had a really successful season this year uh with our fall Sports uh we're going to recognize at this time uh nette seon our field hockey coach she's going to come up here say a few words she was the state championship on [Applause] up I like um I just came I apologize for my appearance I just came from youth indoor so I am dressed to coach right now um yeah I will be super brief um this season was amazing um we came into this season having a lot of experience um successful experience the last three years in the postseason so um having gone to States in 2021 kind of gave the younger players

016a real sense of what we needed to do to get back there um we came up short in 2022 and 23 and we were very very close in those years really successful and so the girls put a lot of time and effort in to a lot of time and effort in to get back to where we were and this season was pretty magical um we were really fortunate to have a really good side of the bracket where we were able to observe the teams that we were going to play um we had an outstanding Regional game winning 6-0 against C Valley um and the regional game was at Arlington and the state championship semifinal and the championship were at Arlington as well which was amazing to have it local we have a lot of incredible

017fans in support there and the team just played beautifully it was really like a a well oiled machine um just standing back and watching them play it was really really impressive and we as coaches were incredibly proud of everything that they accomplished this year um taking them to taking wh 2 to one final when they've won nine out of the last state 10 state championships is something to be really proud of so it was it was amazing I'm really proud to be a part of this program thank next is Jason Clint our uh boys golf coach [Applause] I'd like to thank first off the the parents of our athletes the Board of Ed our community the administrators um coach Panic our ad and his secretary um you need to grow because without those people we

018wouldn't have the success we're having I'd also like to thank our two assistant coaches um coach Michael Roach and we had an assistant coach who was actually a coach of other sports um Brody Maloney who donated this time because coach roach and his wife had a baby during the season so they had to leave midseason so before we got to the end of the season um I just wanted to acknowledge uh our team it's 13 guys big um and they do get to compete at scrimmages but on uh a game to a match to match basis our athletes have to compete for a spot as one of the top top six you're only allowed to play six golfers at a match um these golfers um have broken school records um Golf Course records and um

019I'm just going to acknowledge them by name because there only six at this time so Dominic J hokai Blue Stevie Schwarz um Domin palazolo Andrew Dingman and Hudson P Hudson couldn't be here [Applause] so this team is undefeated it's our first undefeated team in about 13 14 years um not only that but they won 2 five of their last 26 matches and they won mahals two years in a row now um additionally they have the team record over the last 20 years at the Apple Greens Golf Course of all High School fsy golf teams and there's there's they broke par which means the team scored a collective underpart for the course twice um this season we haven't had a team do that in well over a decade and no other team has done that since

020I've been a coach so I'd like to acknowledge those so to keep things moving I I'm going to present them with little plaques that we we put together for them that say R Valley varsity boys 20 24 undefeated mahals Champions so thank you very much chain our [Music] [Applause] Captain T Sports [Applause] Andrew D thank you very much Jason do any of give lessons better thank you Miss Simon in the field hockey team come back we want to get a little picture with you guys too so we also want to recognize you so Mr and your players please come on now [Applause] [Music] not [Applause] all right the next Paul sport team would like to recognize is cross country uh led by an [Applause] [Music] Bon hello everyone congrats to all the athletes here tonight

021swimming golf field hockey Andross country um we had quite a season uh this is I don't know maybe my 19th year coaching and every single year I have kids make states which is great um but none of them have ever been like this group standing behind me we're missing two um but they're tremendous athletes this was a boy first year each year it changes boys race first this year so I'm going to start with Owen right here so Owen schaer serini is a junior this is his first full year doing just cross country he was a dual sport soccer cross country athlete last year he's a track athlete and he is by far the fastest boy I've ever coached um he worked so hard this year he worked really hard he wanted to up his

022mileage he had a goal of not only making States but meddling at states which is top 20 in the state very hard to do just making States is a challenge last year he narly missed making States and he was a tremendous athlete last year as well so this year um he worked hard he had some really good results won some races medled in a lot of invites and at the end of the season at sectionals he was third overall and that was a qualification for the state meet in Queensbury so he was ranked 41st in the state going into into the meet only 20 medal you got 15 so that was a tremendous and if you run 5k run just over 16 minutes for 5K on a cross country course which is fast so now

023on to the girls te uh we have not had a girls team win sectionals and make States as a team since 2015 these girls were undefeated all season um in the regular season they won every single meet um invitationals are separate we went to some of the biggest invitationals in the east coast they they placed fourth in some of those invitationals um one in in um The Manhattan Invitational in Cross in uh Van courland Park is one of the biggest Cross Country meets and oldest Cross Country meets and they Place ninth in there and that meet every single one of them took a medal there Mr Incredible and then at mahals and sectionals we have to race against every other school so there's 17 schools at mahals they were second only getting meet by m

024c and next year we're going to meet them and then we went to seals were Class C this year um and we had to race against O'Neal who has won I don't know how many sectional titles they're a big Powerhouse and we beat them [Applause] solidly and Captain H who is right behind me one [Applause] [Music] sexuals and they they were ranked usually ninth most of the season in the state um I think they might have gotten as high as eighth um but they they went into the state meet ranked ninth and so you know we were hoping they would at least Place ninth they placed seventh which was great Parker Myers right over here dual sport athlete was the sportsmanship for Section n and so that's Florida this is Rowan Johnson that's her first

025year this is D Castro eth grader M gy this island Roth Mia tror Owen shaer serini and it's zenas first year as [Applause] well I couldn't do it without V Dr Who's the assistant coach also for track she's the assistant coach she helped early we had a volunteer coach Mike overly All Season who was Owen's training partner for the most part and uh coach Gina who's our modified coach who will soon be a varsity coach I hope and I'm getting old so he's gonna we're going to need him soon but I couldn't do it without everybody and Coach panic and Dina deg Gro are phenomenal so I want to thank them also and again congrats you guys [Applause] people [Applause] [Music] [Applause] and the last fall sport to recogniz our swim coach is Marian [Applause]

026H so as you can see we're a very small team we're a Powerhouse at one this young lady this young lady is dedicated committed works so hard at swimming at her Craft um just an amazing amazing season she's a senior this year so she has reached uh the Pinnacle she's had a great season started off getting to sectionals um she won the 50 free and the 100 free so she is the champion she was also selected the most valuable athlete at that particular Championship me I went back in the records and I took a look and she placed first in every event that she swam in a Duo meet so every time she swam she got first place which is huge so shees our first place from there she qualified and competed at the state

027level we went up to Roch or Webster New York at the Webster Aquatic Center and claraa plays seventh in the state in the 503 which is amazing and then got a second opportunity to stand on the podium she took eighth place in the [Applause] 100 um she has broken some school records she has broken four records this year alone in the 50 free the 100 free the 100 fly and the 200 I so that's huge and she will leave Rond out this year sadly um having and holding six out of the eight girls varsity swim records at Anga belly High School C so with that I want to congratulate CL on all her successes and she will be attending Sienna in the fall and she will be swimming for Sienna and I wish her all

028the luck in the world [Applause] thank thank you again congratulations to all of our sports teams our coaches for a tremendous season we'll hope to see you again here uh this time next year uh next on the agenda is the superintendent uh update and it's the capital project uh vote acceptance and the recommended motion is that the Board of Education accepts the December 3rd 2024 Capital project vote in the amount of 21 million4 54,4 59 with 525 yes votes compared to 203 no votes as [Music] presented please use the mic we so we did amend the agenda public com to to do now um so we will open the floor up for public comment as I typically say at the start of public comment we just ask that respectful don't use any identifying typ of

029information that would identify a student or a staff member um and keep in mind certain situations may also be identifying right you're uh talking about certain in in school or in classroom so on and so forth um we will allot three minutes um for each commenter um so with that oh sorry we have mics at either side i' ask you to uh step up to the mic the um we are live streaming so we do need you to speak into the mic in order for the community to hear your your response um so with that in mind if there's anyone who would like to make a public comment please step up to one of the mics thank you I'm short but not the short so I apologize um good evening my name is Carrie shei

030and I'm a parent of an eighth grader in the junior high school um I've also been a classroom teacher for 27 years during my first year teaching can I [Music] this thank you I'm sorry I can't read and really that um okay as I was saying during my first year of teaching I experienced columbi in high school as a teacher since then there have been close to 600 school shootings in the United States the most recent one last week in California I understand probably more than most people the desire to keep Kids Safe in school in fact as a teacher I promise you I think about it every single day when I go to work the district's interest but I also recognize that the district's interest in hiring armed security is probably most likely one

031motivated by fear and based on opinion without data to support that decision if we take a motion out of this decision and we look at the data and there is a vast amount of data you'll find that school campuses that have guns on them that have officers that have guns that have security guards that have guns have done nothing to stop school shootings and school violence only honest conversations about the root cause of school violence and evidence-based interventions will begin to address violence in our school communities I think the presentation from the junior high school principal this afternoon this evening talked about some of those evidence-based Solutions we're on the right path hiring armed guards is the wrong direction um I said in my letter to the board oh I'm sorry hang on additionally I

032think this is important that that what I find most upsetting about this entire event is the lack of transparency around this decision it's just a lack of regard for the community and a lack of importance around the issue the fact that we're approving or you're approving a community contract tonight without Community input about something so important is really really deeply upsetting and more so troubling I said in my letter to the board that I sent y all last week that my as a child my life was forever changed fight gun violence it is something that my family and our community will never forget it is an experience that I don't want any of our children to have I don't want my child to have it I don't want your child and I don't want our

033classroom teachers to have it either I ask that you demand actually I'm demanding that you reevaluate the intentions to hire armed Private Security in our schools thank you but I do want to just say that they were entirely motivating this season and I am getting close to running 500 Miles because of that thank you I wanted to take a few minutes to thank our Administration and the board of ed for presenting the idea of adding an additional SRO to our district as well as armed security to the elementary schools I wanted to comment on this because I have a unique position I'm a member of this community I live in hon I am a teacher at for Hanson elementary school and I'm a parent of two Elementary School students that attend for Hanson Elementary School

034my husband made a public comment last month supporting this initiative so you know that he is a police officer in an urban area so you can imagine what our dinner table conversation sound like a cop and a teacher it's colorful at times anyway I honestly was surprised when I heard that people were against this initiative while I respect other opinions and perspectives that are different than mine it may me feel like perhaps individuals are misinformed I've heard a lot of concerns and push for more intervention and social emotional initiatives to promote community and peace in an effort to curve bullying social isolation and negative outlooks on school in general when I heard that I think I said out loud I'm not sure that our community is aware of all that we are doing in those

035areas our current SRO who I believed is absent at the moment was a constant presence in our school walking the hallways smiling playing basketball with kids high-fiving kids at arrival and dismissal do home visits with our social workers she even asks to come and read to our students pushing into our classrooms in any way that she could to show kids that officers are a part of our community and they are here to help us support us and protect us as presented by the company that we would potentially contract armed security officers could be the same for our kids as our sro's a lot of these people are retired police officers with Decades of all kinds of experiences the media doesn't like to show this but overall police officers do incredible work for our commun communities

036so get me started on all that our guidance counselors and social workers do for our kids everything from weekly whole group lessons to home visits when necessary constant contact with students and their families that are displaced information and resources on anything from free eye exams to dental care to Mental Health Resources and information you name it they do it they're also incredibly kind and individuals that students trust I'm so lucky that I'm a person that loves my job I love that it is hand hands on I get to meet all different kinds of people and kids I've served about 200 families over my 12E career I wouldn't trade it for anything sometimes I don't some sorry something that I don't love is that when we have to do a lock down drill and when I'm

037crowded in the farthest corner from the door with 15 third graders that I think about how long it would take for a shooter to get to us it would be really quick because our school was little I have to think about things like would I have enough time to run across the hall and grab my second grader to be with me I have to think about would my kindergartner that is all the way on the other side of the building be safe nobody should have to think about those things at their job while caring for kids statistically speaking school shootings are like the plane crash right not likely but possible sure why wouldn't we Embrace this gift of word of about is proposing this is a gift please vote yes thank you for your time

038[Applause] thank hi there I'm Caroline stano I came to the board meeting last month on this topic um I have two 8-year-olds who are second graders at marbletown elementary school I'm here tonight again to oppose the expansion of the student resource officer program specifically the the proposal to hire arm guards for the two elementary schools in the district I came to the board meeting last month to oppose this I also sent an email after that to this entire board with links to data and research looking at this issue over the last decade I did not receive a response but to go back to my points more specifically and I'm also going to take the mental health topic out of this because I do think the school is doing things to address mental health and I

039think it's becoming a distraction um to talk about that in the context of the armed security guards because there is data around this proposal that proves it doesn't make any sense if what we're trying to to do is increase safety in the schools to the contrary there is a lot of evidence and data and again I have shared links and I know others have as well that the presence of armed guards triple the death and injury rates in the event of a school shooting and can even make gun violence more likely at a school School shooters are often suicidal and the presence of an armed guard can be an incentive I respectfully request that this board engage the parent body and the public more meaningfully in this process before moving forward the idea that we'd

040be hiring a private security form without any specialization in school children is also outrageous this is an incredibly consequential decision for every children every child in this district and every family in this District every teacher in this district and the time should be taken to do the process right thank you very much [Applause] uh hi there I am a parent with a student in the district and uh at the elementary school and also a goling or Vander and making a preschooler hope hopefully um to be a gander um I'm a teacher myself outside of the district um I'm also a taxer and a voter uh and I was actually in an active Sher drill uh to day uh with my middle school students so I too am an educator I know those feelings and the

041anxiety that it causes um and it stays with you all day long when you have to be the face that your students are looking to um and what I want to say to that as an educator is we have to do our research and lean into it it's not political to do the research and when you start to look up whether or not armed guards make a school safer the first 10 entries you find are from private security companies who say why yes hire us and we'll make you safer I understand from my neighbors I understand from other parents that the idea of an armed guard makes them feel safer but the facts are that it does not make them safer the Journal of American Medicine has done an exhaustive research of school shootings from

042what was it 1980 uh to 2019 and across the board even schools that had armed security guards were not able to intervene in a meaningful way and we know the research has told us there's something called the weapon effect and the weapon effect escalates violence when there's a presence of a weapon it increases aggression we also know that whenever weapons are present there is room for error and even seasoned professionals police officers are capable of making Split Second mistakes we're talking about split-second mistakes around our children and police officers are trained for for one thing specifically they are not Educators they are not trained to be around children and one thing you can guarantee children are is unpredictable prior research also suggests that School shooters are actively suicidal and an armed guard is sometimes an

043invitation I also want to urge the board as I am an educator that teaches social studies to do a little homework because the first Google research results that I did for this company Atlas security that all of my neighbors are saying hey these are trained professionals that have years of experience when I looked them up the first reviews were incompetent unprofessional and not far beyond that weering at 14-year-old girls so I haven't done exhaustive research on this but I want to know that you have and if this is the company you're going with I want to know why and I want to know why you think this thank you I think you get the gist of what I'm trying to say I think the work that our counselors are doing is the good work that

044we need and I have very dare you for trying to make these decisions without consulting our parents our students your [Applause] constituents hello thank you for stepping her oh hi uh Jed Tucker um also a parent in the district I'm late to this whole conversation unfortunately but I think I understand why now um one I want to thank everybody who's spoken so far I've learned a lot from you all in the last couple minutes I came here tonight also to oppose the measure to introduce armed security into the elementary school um any any I don't know why we'd ever bring under any pretense bring guns into a school um whether that's by professionals who are trained and so forth but of course could make mistakes or anybody else so I'm I I did a little

045bit of research the last person took the wi out of my sales because it took me about 30 seconds of of looking online to find numerous stor of accidents of course they can happen I'm going to share these with the board anybody else who would like a Cofe I have them but of course it's very easy to find as as recently as last year in the Hudson Valley um unfortunately um a an SRO left a gun in a bathroom that was found by kids um this kind of thing can happen any time and importantly of course what IID like to say the only thing I can add and I'm completely sympathetic to the to the um woman who spoke on the other side um I absolutely would love to have SRO um in all the

046schools who don't have weapons it sounds like they do a terrific job and retired C without um we need much you can't have enough of that kind of thing um importantly I think just to uh just to say it's true that the the data on this is more on our side than theirs um but really this isn't really a topic like so many others where data really moves people um we could show you know of the 100,000 public schools in America um those that have arms securing them are not safer than the ones that do um we can talk about it at the end of time and do the research I'm afraid and I understand that this is at the same time very much a hot button issue like so many others people feel just

047strongly on one side of the other the only thing I'd like to add to that is to think to therefore to think about this just in terms of what's the kind of culture of school that we want to create um I like everybody else I have three kids this is the next one coming up the other two have been are in the district of course care very deeply about the safety of the schools U my kids in them every time I get another one of these alerts and calls I lose my mind um my kids actually have suffered quite a bit from the from the um the drills that we do at the schools another topic that I care a lot about um there are many many ways to ensure safety in schools short of

048introducing somebody with a weapon into them I'm not going to I you know them but but with this particular I'll say one last thing about this um because a lot of my work um for a long time has been working in the prison system and around people who have committed very heinous crimes um this particular kind of criminal activity or misbehavior is is very well known the causes of it are very well well known the perpetrators are typically from within the school um we know the the the profile and characteristics and the circumstances around which kids do this kind of thing um it's terrible it's infrequent it's terrible nonetheless um so there's what that what that suggests is that there are ways to intervene that have nothing to do with picking up arms it's about

049identifying kids who are in trouble the teachers do this very well it's about educating parents about gun safety and the list goes there's lots we can do I would love to be a part of any group or committee that might make an alternative proposal thank you very [Applause] much thank um hi I'm not an educator I'm just a parent uh but a parent of a junior in this high school and I found out about this issue through the newspaper um I'm not clear what problem is being solved here and given what we've heard about all the data that says that arm guards are not effective I would love to hear your data that refutes that and so far haven't heard anything yet um more people with guns seem to be a standard response when it

050comes to child safety but it's a thoroughly unfor response there are much better ways to do this and when it comes to something as contentious as this all decision should be made very publicly and I'm very disappointed that that hasn't happened so far there were lots of public comments in the and then I see a vote about this Alpha security thing on the agenda today I find that very strange um that's all I wanted to say thank [Applause] you hi I've spoken before um my name is Leah seel and I also was an educator a public educator for 10 years family of public Educators um and I don't have anything prepared I really wanted to speak from my heart because I really care about the school district um and I it's I've been sort of

051doing some self-reflection on why this issue is uh meaningful to me and I feel like my inherent trust in schools in public schools is so great I almost have to stop myself I mean I am completely with you I am here for for any kind of support I can give and when I you know put time to the side to write an email to the school board with some questions that are really meaningful to me like you know why why are we going to put armed guards in the schools or SRO however you want to call them I really mean that I really want to know what caused uh the decision to be made is it because there are school shootings is it because there's Strife in the school that isn't handled is it because

052there's some other source of violence I haven't gotten an answer to that question yet and I know a lot of people are wondering that so when I hear people talking about school shootings and so forth I actually don't know if that's the reason we have have armed guards I don't know what we're protecting against and I would love to know and I I think unfortunately this has made me feel really afraid um I wasn't feeling afraid before this I was feeling really confident sending my first grader to Marvel toown at the moment I feel scared I don't know if there have been threats I don't know what we're protecting ourselves against and I um I'm afraid now so I also don't know you know I worked with special needs kids for many years and I

053know that um it can be the case that for example a kid with severe autism if they see a gun can run out the gun and try to grab it all kinds of things can happen and those of us in education know that we have to be trained very carefully to handle any situation with a child I don't know if these these people will be I don't know what would happen in that situation um and it's it's not even that I have such a strong stance on this issue it's just that I would have appreciated um my concern as a parent being taken seriously um and my questions being answered with sincerity and and um thoroughness and I I say that partly because I know a lot of other issues are going to come into

054our view and I don't want the process to feel like this again because I have a lot of years to go and R out and I'm going to help every step of the way like you're never going to get rid of me and I just want to feel good about it so thank you [Applause] hi my name is Hannah sofka I'm a graduate of this school actually um I'm a professor of uh communication and New Media at Sunni orange I'm also the assistant chair of the Arts and communication Department um and uh so I'm coming of course at this as an educator I also worry about shootings and security and we have lock down drills um we're having actually a new um security PA system um right now being installed at our school um we're

055updating it okay and um as an assistant chair um I'm basically part of the administration of the college so I attend meetings where we talk about how we're going to use funding um you know uh decisions uh for an issue like this I can tell you right away that we would start by actually putting together a task force uh we would also um start by probably like right now actually we have an audit being done of our campus for a different issue we hired experts they came in they looked at our stuff they met with the people who were stakeholders who were affected by you know a decision like this uh and and we going to be told by experts what's the best course of action what's the best allocation of our resources um one

056of the first things when I found about out about this that I thought beside really having I I want to definitely Echo that feeling of not getting transparency here okay um was just like well wait how did you arrive at this decision um my proposal would be that you hire somebody who could do a security audit of all the campuses and figure out what's the best allocation it could be for examp example what's called School hardening so making it even more difficult to you know get into the building um it just came to my attention in the last week that um even though Japan doesn't have firearms as much as we do I mean basically they don't um at events at schools they check all the bags of everybody coming in you know that's just

057an example maybe we need metal detectors maybe we need staff that could look into the bags students which by the way deide Firearms I can already tell you contain Vapes contain drugs I mean why not have a look in those bags some districts have transparent backpack policies um so you know I would really suggest that you get um an auditor uh the other thing I am concerned about the actual company I didn't see of those reviews that I just heard about um my concern is that I actually teach communication to Future police officers um who are in our criminal justice department I'm not in that department but I'm teaching communication to those students and I can tell you that I'm aware from my colleagues in the criminal justice department that the training of officers in

058recent years and now has really evolved from the past um and you know with all respect to retired police they may not have training that's even up to date you know with with What's Done these days not to mention just how specific a school environment is um you know I'm really concerned about the training you know what are they getting um from what I could glean from your earlier meetings um I was aware that questions were asked about it and I really didn't think there was enough information about Alice training the other thing I just want to point out is that um guards have fled active shooter scenes the most uh well an example being at Parkland you're literally asking these people will you die for my child okay and not everybody's going to say

059yes as we've seen we've seen people not respond and we've certainly seen with all the best intentions officers not getting there on time they're in another part of the building Firearms just it happens so fast that it's not even funny okay uh so I think you should focus on not letting arms in and finding ways to you know do that best um and also ascertaining you know like I said ascertaining what's the best way of using these funds yeah I think that that kind of covers it and um and I really do suggest that you also I mean it sounds like there are quite a few Educators here there are people who have done a lot of research think of everyone who's come to this meeting as possible resources that could help you I'm very

060happy to help in any way um you know we all really just want what's good and we all want what's safe for our kids um so you're also dealing with a divisive issue so the more you can you know tap into the community which is going to make your jobs easier the less you know probably resistance you're going to get if you get an expert in too you know who's like hey here's the audit here's what they showed here's the data on our specific schools you know what we're dealing with here um you know it'll be less messy [Applause] thanks hi my name is Keen Camp I have a son at Marvel toown why has The Round Up Valley School Board refused to let the public vote on hiring arms secure private security this question

061has been met with silence and evasion despite my repeated attempts get a simple direct answer when I met with superintendent spadaro we cited sties as an example of a district that recently hired armed guards yet sties held a public vote to gauge Community opinion before making their decision if the s school board considered the issue important enough for a vote why doesn't round out Valley are we not entitled to the same respect and transparency a vote would ensure legitimacy and fostered Trust excluding the community from such a consequential dis decision is not only dismissive it is a violation of the Public's confidence after the last board meeting I asked again why the community was denied a voice board president scho maker responded that they did not consider this issue significant enough to justify public engagement

062let me be let me be clear deciding to place armed guards from a private security company with no clear oversight or specific training that pertains to children in our schools without input from students parents or staff is a decision of enormous significance to dismiss it as unimportant is both shocking and unacceptable the board and superintendent have failed in their duty to represent the people they serve this decision made behind closed doors undermines trust and credibility at every level leadership demands accountability and openness instead the board has chosen secrecy and disregard this was an opportunity to build trust in the community instead to have chosen to erod it entirely perhaps it's time for some new [Applause] leadership hi good evening my name is Kelly Stanley I'm really good at talking to kindergarteners but I'm not so

063good at talking adults excuse me if I get nervous um I doai Valley which does have arm security guards it actually has the armed security guards that you guys consider and from what I so nothing but positive I feel much safer I feel like the response time is a lot quicker if there's a deescalation that needs to happen it's not going to take the 15 minutes it takes to get across campus it's going to be immediate and they are very actively involved in um I guess everything with the children they greet them I I don't know what Vision everyone is taking on this but I can tell you from experience it when I school I do not see their guns out in the open I see them greeting them with positivity I see them supporting

064the classroom teachers I see them in the hallways giving them high thighs I see them a child that we just had was struggling to get to class A Behavior child someone self contained and the officer took her flashlight and played a game with him for him to get back to class those are the things that you're going to see you're see them out with their guns you're not going to see them threatening anybody and the um training that they have is knowledgeable and appropriate for the age group that you're looking for so as a taxpayer as children that are here and I came strictly for field talky I'm not going to be I'll be honest I think you're field Hoy and this really enticement and I'm not one to speak out in public and many

065of you know me but this spoke to me and I'm not stay up here and do a long speech but I live this every day and I can tell you with certainty that I feel much sa in my [Applause] [Music] school just wondering if you could have a little more time for a middle ground because there's so many people here we' got this side on this side I just wish we could say hey really like to meet all you people I'd like to know what we could do together it sounds like we've got good ideas from both sides so what I really really just like to ask a little more time a little more input I would prefer if you didn't make a decision tonight and you could just allow people to give more input

066you can consider what's out there my [Applause] I was ask um my name is Bianca Ferris I teach across the river at a high school um I feel very safe in my building and we do not have armed guards we have unarmed security with a school resource officer I go there we have one entrance we have double doors everybody has to come in with IVs and um I feel very safe there unarmed security guards and they form really great relationships with the students and security I understand the need for it but I don't see why they need to be armed wanted to share [Applause] that hi everyone I actually wasn't planning on speaking tonight either I came to hear about the great things that are going on at the junior high school but um I

067just want to reiterate that sounds to me when I'm hearing that tabling this vote for tonight might be a good idea um and I want to say that as an educator in this district for 20 years I have always felt safe I feel safe um I felt safe today without these guards I don't I don't I don't personally feel like um these additional guards are warranted both of my kids graduated from Ronda Valley I always felt that they were safe I've trusted our leadership to make good decis decisions in that respect so um I would love to sort of hear more about this issue and not have a vote tonight thank [Applause] you any other comments tonight hi my name is j gó I'm a parent of two girls in second grade and sixth grade

068um and I was reluctant to come to the mic because I initially planned to come to the board meeting to talk about separate issue but I don't want to make a left turn um I will talk about that issue but first I do want to um reinforce what the other parents said about uh needing more time that this feels like a fast track way to a really consequential consequential policy um to to bring guns into our schools doesn't feel like something that we should be finding out about in the newspaper and and realizing oh crap I need to come to this board meeting to say hold off on that while we all have a longer discussion um about the risk and reward scenario so I would definitely appreciate um holding off on that um since

069I got a babysitter I will make the comment that I came here to make um and not feel uh like it's a uh like it's a total left turn or um like it's bringing us into a different gear because this is obviously something that a lot of parents have voiced concerns about over the uh throughout the fall um I feel really strongly that we need a responsible cell phone policy in the school district um I want to acknowledge that a cell phone ban is not a rebuke on the students what I've seen is that the Ronda Valley kids have um a really supportive community that they're engaged in this is not about that it's about acknowledging that these devices are addictive that they have a negative impact on social and emotional development and that as

070the adults in the room we have a respons responsibility of keeping these intrusive devices from interfering with the school day I uh I spoke with an administrator on the Kingston School Board yesterday Kingston instituted a cell phone ban uh at the beginning of the school year and what I was told is that it was like a great exhale there was some resistance obviously that they overcame and it was like a great exhale because the students aren't anxiously awaiting the next opportunity to stay updated on their social media responsibilities on their apps and that the teachers only complain is that there are um too many papers to grade because more kids are handing in work because more kids are academically engaged so I want to see our students and teachers realize the same positive impacts from

071a responsible cell phone policy thanks a lot than you hi again I'm marus Sanchez I appreciate your engagement with me and others on this topic and just wanted to put into this space one aspect of the guards discussion that hasn't come up already tonight which is that some of us feel uncomfortable around guns and armed officers um that can be for many reasons it can be from a personal history it can also be because we're part of a targeted group my kids are kids of color I don't want to be wondering if they have light enough skin to pass onist you know I don't want to come here and talk about racism per se but this is a question that has to do with race there's no way to separate policing and race especially in

072an educational environment so while we may not be experiencing a flare up in that regard right now in our district it's really important to keep that lens on all the decisions that we make because we have kids of color here we have families who feel for whatever reason uncomfortable around law enforcement and they deserve to also be heard and may need to be sought out because it feels really uncomfortable to stand in front of you and say this um and to acknowledge that we might be one of those people who feels that way um so please take the time no matter the outcome here to listen to those voices in our community thank [Applause] hello as a student of rondout Valley I would like to make a statement saying if it wasn't for a project

073that I had to do today I would have no idea about these armed officers coming into our district at all I feel as a for a sibling for my siblings who would be directly impacted by these actions and choices I feel like we should have more chances to know about such actions being taken especially since we are physically involved with whatever we [Applause] choose any other comment tonight I think with that Dr Spar I will turn it over to you um while Dr Spar is getting set up he does have a presentation for us tonight I do want to just um reiterate and we did discuss this um as a board multiple times this year um I went actually went back to the agenda um and the the video recordings which are all located on

074YouTube but the first time we brought up security was on our August 20th meeting um where we approved the existing or or sorry the renewal of our existing SRO officer um and we did indeed have discussion during that approval on extension expansion of secur um we had further discussion well I couldn't make the September board meeting there was further discussion in October um when Dr spedo presented his goals and it was very clear in that um that presentation what the intent was um Dr spido will go through a little bit of of some of the reasoning and justification of why we're looking at expanding our security He he'll have that in his slides but I will say sitting on this board over the last several years I'm scared I really am this is not a

075kneer decision or reaction based on things that have happened recently we've had a longstanding history of threats that have happened to our school systems right this year it capped off with a pretty major incident in our high school um so as a board we haven't taken this lightly and by the way we're not taking anything that you all are bringing to us L either right we are hearing you I have read through every single email I promise you read through every single email you have sent I've also looked at every article that has been attached as I know several others here uh have as well so we are listening to you we have taken it into account I want to assure you of that Dr spedo will go through his presentation and then we will

076open it up for full board discussion where we can kind of debate this and and um discuss amongst ourselves um and and see where we land ultimately with uh moving ahead for this thank you thank you board chairman members of the board and good evening to the community and thank you for being here and I just must say it is a privilege and honor uh to serve as your superintendent of schools here in a great Community great people and of course Great Schools so thank you for being here I want to try to shed some light on the why uh that why the administration is recommending um extra security and first starts with our goals right our first goal uh in Ronda is safety we want to make sure students are safe staff members are

077St safe teacher safe everyone affiliate with school system that's our number one priority is safety and with that safety we want to implement a comprehensive safety plan and we want to add we're looking to add an additional SRO we've had an SRO for the last 10 years in our district um this this SRO has been affiliated with the school systems this SRO has built relationships with all of our four campuses and we just want to expand that resource that we have in place over the last 10 years uh we looking at adding two additional security guards we want security Personnel uh in each campus um you know we love to have an SRO in every building uh but you know the Manpower is limited uh at the sheriff's office so we feel like this hybrid

078approach uh would make sure we have a sec some form of security Personnel uh in each in every building uh we're creating Channels with Advance we're using technology and we're having content filtering and safety monitoring systems being implemented uh through our student issue Chromebooks through go Garden Beacon so we're going to we're going to look at and and monitor students on their Chromebooks to see you know uh what they're searching for and what they're going through on the devices that's going to be coming up too uh we also want to improve the physical security uh of all of our school buildings to prevent unauthorized access through our Capital Improvement projects and I just want to thank you for coming out and voting on that uh Capital project because one of the focuses on that project

079uh was security let's look at our neigh of school distry know we did did take a deep dive we did look at some data ourselves and wanted to see what other districts are doing with security with personnel and you see see school district one has three SRO and security attendance school district 2 has one SRO and unarmed guards School District 3 has four sro's and licensed security guards School District Four no SRO School District 5 one SRO and they're adding additional one right now Ronda we just have the one SRO for the four campuses school district 6 one SRO and Atlas uh armed guards in each school they voted on it school district 7 uh two sro's and two unarmed Atlas security guards the company we're looking to um go with and then School District

080a sro's at H school and unarmed security guards so the risks at Rond out why are we looking at this is law enforcement has advised us do you want plan for an event will happen but when it will happen so do not plan for an event that will happen but when it will happen that's we're trying to be proactive rather than reactive you know we concerning issues related to security and safety in recent years across our buildings what Mr SCM was talking about at our elementary school at Marble Town you know we have threats that led to Hiring Our SRO that happened you know 8 to 10 years ago and our in our Middle School you know chat rooms wereing threats for specific students to R out students threatening our students lives in a chat

081room and at the high school we we had a webon that was brought in you know a downside I think of it as the three the three ARS you know we are remote we are Rural and response time those three hours and that's why we're pursuing this uh because we are in a remote you know County we are we are Rural and the response time is is is very lengthy compared to a an urban setting and you know that response time has a has an impact on fire medical and and police being called uh if we need them in an emergency situation uh recent incident was when the SRO were unavailable due to handling another matter you know someone's threatening a staff we had a student elope um they were busy handling that that one

082SRO and the response time for the closest police unit was over 20 minutes so something happened at one of our schools we had no manpower to address anything that could take place why are we doing this we are looking to expand what we already have with our current SRO in place why won't you let us vote some data looking at our behavioral type reports so we're looking at um really major events that took place in the schools our Intermediate School and this data was compiled from 2022 until the present these are major event types that happened you can see the event type and the event count you know fighting with no inry we had 25 events physical altercation with minor injuries we had 33 events physical contact minor we had 23 events threats of violence

083we had four events over the last 3 years and possession of weapon at the Intermediate School we had one event that took place looking at our Junior High School from 2022 to presentent behavior report um we had conduct which endanger safety morals Health and Welfare weigh 106 of those events physical contact minor 18 events physical altercation with minor injury 16 events fighting Hands-On 12 fighting physical injury for fighting no injury 24 events disorderly for violent conduct we had nine of those events threats of school violence for possession of a weapon we had three and we also had a bomb threat over the last three years and then our high school from 2022 to present uh major event types conduct which endanger safety morals Health and Welfare we had 21 events physical contact minor 8 physical

084altercation with minor injury 16 fighting hands- on 17 physical injury 2 fighting no injury 10 disorderly for violent conduct 11 threat other than the bomb threat of f alarm five menacing intimidating and threatening behaviors we had three and then possession of a weapon we we had two events over the last three years infrastructure needs again we're very large school district covering about 150 uh square miles in Marble toown Rochester Rosendale and Waring the school district employs approximately 4 people approximately 1,700 ston hous in four facilities we've looked at this we've looked at our last Capital project had security infrastructure updates the high school we replace the P indoor Hardware with shelter and place Hardware the middle school high school in K Hanson we put in exterior lighting replacement at the middle school we replace door

085hardware with shelter andl Hardware at the do redesign the reception area and tax collection window the current capital project again the focus is security and what we're doing is we are upgrading the intrusion alarm system in all schools replacing the clock PA and lockdown system we're adding security film to all exterior windows and doors we're creating a secure entryway with access controll visitor waiting area both at at K Hansen and our Middle School we're replacing poorly functioning hallway smoke doors and we're replacing outdated and poorly functioning exit doors from poof security at Marble Town so it's a it's a it's a really a pronged attack here for school safety we're trying to um address it from a variety of ways to keep our students and staff safe every single day we again people alluded to

086um what our counselors are doing how all the mental health services we are provided to our students that's not going away that's we're we're continue sustaining these practices because it's working uh you know look at our our district rondal compared to the other districts you can see we have just as many psychologists School ologists um social workers we have nine school counselors uh two bcbas Behavior Specialists crisis counselors three students uh that are have it an individualized 9p or 23% of identified students and you see the staff we have even though we have less numbers less number of students we have more Mental Health Services than our surrounding counties and we're not cutting those back we're moving forward with that cuz we know we need these people our students need these people to be successful

087and that's going to still be a focus on our district on our school on our students moving forward again we we invested heavily in social emotional areas you saw the presentation tonight when Miss sa is really focusing on uh social emotional learning and restorative practices uh we want our teachers to stay focused on teaching uh social emotional aspects and not worried about Building Safety and Security we we want those Personnel to worry about the Safety and Security and we want our teachers to be focused on high quality teaching and Learning elementary schools are pushing into classrooms completing weekly lessons also align to American school counselor Association of students those things are still taking place we're we're not replacing what we have already uh embedded in our school climate and our school culture we are just

088expanding it and we're adding to it the question why so with and mental health Contin it's a basically a tiered approach there's tier one tier 2 and tier three interventions and again you can see all of all of the resources we have school counselors support support all these students with a comprehensive School counseling program that addresses the student needs you can see at Marvel toown K Hanson Intermediate School the Junior High um again miss saot talked about this right these things are happening she talked about the stack anti-bullying program we have going on the restorative practices uh I believe our high school has our first Wellness Wednesday tomorrow excited for that so we have things going on that again are addressing uh mental health and that's going to continue and then we have a lot

089of tier three interventions as well and those supports again are not going away again U people are wondering you know are you replacing Dei with all this extra security no Dei is still embedded in our in our district we we still have priorities uh each school you know has culture responsive and education Dei embedded goal U Marvel Town's uh DDI made the goal is to engage students you know we're going to continue creating a community of belonging and emphasizing cultur responsive practices uh we will create and carry out at these three schoolwide no place for hate events they're going to continue purchasing books for the class from the library to reflect all members of our school Community promoting in incl inclusivity uh review new and current curricula for more diversity within the unit of of

090study um third grade students who learn perform dances that they've already done if You' missed the vanover U performance amazing it was a packed house here a phenomenal job with our third graders in our in oure elementary schools uh the board approved uh a New York NYU contract um to um have training with them to do a school walk through to to see how much um Dei how much in inclusivity we have taking place within the school uh we're also looking at a spring cultur responsive sustaining uh education uh to promote that through a grant and we're looking at that getting receiving that Grant in the spring and we're hoping to roll out an SEO program across the district our Middle School still has a diversity club uh they meet every Thursday in the library

091our high school has a diversity club they're meeting on Wednesdays and like I said alluded to our first Wellness Wednesday is it's going to start tomorrow so big question is what about the training so I'm going to sh light on the training that um Atlas Services go through the security that they go through again it's based out of Goan it's local they're licensed and bonded guard company with a 32-year history of providing professional security officers they are currently serving right now in 15 school districts they comply with all of the appol safe School roles against violence and Education Act including background checks fingerprinting completion of a state mandated course providing services to students they must receive clearance from employment by the New York State education department prior to Services they have to show proof from

092an accredited Academy and be retired in good standing with all training in place known as the good guy Le document Supply included copy of the armed security guards and New York State security guard license and evidence of weapon registration with New York State they have successfully completed a certified weapons course they have also have supplemental training on suspicious packages response to active shooter incidents and enhance terrorism awareness and response they're experienced uh with children young adults they are pre-screened for assignment and are parents themselves atas security employees take the state mandated sexual harassment training CPI first aid in AED training They will receive inservice trading regularly on deescalation strategies conflict resolution and management of disruptive behavior they will participate in District training such as a behavior threat assessment that's going to help reduce bias help

093get them trained in that also diversity implicit bias training and armed security guards are expected to engage in additional training in collaboration with oler County Sheriff's Office in this February if if they are with us they're going to attend a 3-day training a 3day C pass training at a school safety conference where all the Sheriff's Office sro's go and attend so at Security Services again we currently have one SRO from the uler county sheriff's office this resources shared across our four buildings and has a visible presence in each school again the sheriff's office is short staffed and it is difficult right now to get sro's this leaves a gap in coverage across our for camp campes Atlas provides former law enforcement staff with the exact same level of training experience as our local sheriffs they

094can act as a first responder capable of providing preventative uh Security emergency medical service Courier Services Crisis Intervention supervisions of all hallways cafeteria playgrounds and be a trained Observer to relate information to law enforcement they can be beneficial to the district without limiting them to elementary schools uh they can be on the main campus for events outside the normal day they can help supervise extracurricular activities we have a rival basketball game we have a rival football game they can also help lend in hand with with extra security with regards to the perception of how students will see for security guards I think um the lady alluded to they're going to appear as another school official in the building they're going to build relationships with our students they're going to build relationships with our teachers they're

095going to be Affiliated uh as a school staff member uh again this will be greatly benefit the Ronda Valley Community situation for seconds counts and much like law enforcement they are here to protect and to serve children they come highly recommended from local school districts they in monel Valley Central sties and osis again there worked in 15 school districts there have been no shootings there's been no weapons no violence and no significant incidences under their services again Valley Central Saw a 47% decline in incidents and a 67% decline in incidents since providing security they provide us with the best outcomes by deterring potential threats they will help keep our staff and our students safe and again they're going to serve in a new a variety of roles uh besides protecting and serving they can help

096with traffic they can help with hallway recess and lunch supervision they help sec your entrances and exites they're going to monitor the cameras they help with firewatch they help with evacuation they're going to be CPR first aid trained they're going to help with patrolling and again they're lending a sense of security so from the administration's recommendation we are recommending to enhance our security services to add an additional SRO and to add two additional at security uh guards to our district thank you please answer the question why why you don't want to answer a question when we asked you what you were thinking we are so um uh don vantique um who's the former president um of the board and has a little bit more of the history um behind kind of the the need for

097the initial SRO and and other um items um Don would you would you mind speaking hi everyone so um so one of you should you're doing this I have absolutely no problem engaging in a conversation I would like the opportunity to say what I've written um I don't know if I have the so what I will say I don't know if I have the answers I also don't know if I have the answer you want to hear but what I will say right now tonight um is from my heart it's the truth as as much as I know the truth to be and I'm as transparent as I can be so for those of you who know me um uh you know me and you know I'll I'll say what I got to say and

098you may not like it but I respect I'm very respectful and I respect all of you and I respect what you have brought to the table both sides of of the discussion um I have been on the I'm just going to turn my phone on for a second because I wrote this up and I didn't want to forget things so um I've been on the school board this is my ninth year I have served as a vice president I've served as a president um I'm serving now as a board trustee um I this is one of the greatest things I've ever done I I feel compelled to let all of you know we have been through a lot of things that we have not shared um and it's safety driven um what we can share

099we do share um and some of the things and of course my phone's signing out um some of the conversations that we've had the issues that we've had have been very thought-provoking we've had tremendous conversation about it in um the boardroom with people at Stewarts in the morning with um Town Hall meetings with committee meetings um people call my house um we will have conversations and I have abs absolutely no problem having that conversation but with those conversations they've happened because we've had to vote on very strong topics that not everybody has liked when I first got onto the board we had first created um uh an SRO position we had um it was a couple of years that the SRO was in position and they were in position because there were significant threats that

100the police law enforcement deemed credible significant threats to our babies our little ganders um and if you know me I care so much about your kids um I care about them as much as I care about my own I don't ever want anything to happen to any of them so I was happy to see an SRO um implemented in the school and we also added a line item for a second SRO when we um were hiring them we had other situations that came up um we need we need security we we look at safety in a number of ways one we need to make sure our kids are safe um the threats in Marble Town we had to make sure our kids were safe we had to make sure our staff was safe you can't

101teach if you're scared you can't learn if you're scared we needed to make sure we were there and we did what we had to do to protect our our our staff our students next up was Co um and I was the president I became president a couple months after that was implemented and I have to be honest when I say this I spoke to the then Su sitting superintendent as president and I said we've got to do anything and everything we can to make sure that no one ends up having to say we're sorry about them getting covid in our school we implemented a ton of things and I know that's not what this this particular night is about but I wanted to let you know that safety is more than just the threats it's

102also your health it's the mental well-being as um a board member we approved a tremendous amount of staff for just um counseling for for mental health issues due to covid due to other things that were happening we have a very robust staff in that department that they do great work and I know a lot of you are staff members from other schools and I appreciate that but I do have to say I think our round out teachers and staff are some of the best so um I have to make sure as a board member that we're there for them so then what happened next um we got through Co everyone came back to school and a couple years ago as President we had some diversity uh questions come up we had um a homecoming where

103we had um crowned two kings and the public was divided as the president of the board I stood up and I promised all of the parents that we would keep the staff and the students safe and we would allow them to be them to be who they want to be and to be able to feel comfort able coming into school we continued on with all of our Mental Health Resources we continued on with making sure people felt comfortable and safe in school staff and students we then got more threats um we had bomb threats we had all kinds of threats and it it's not okay it's not okay to evacuate the school and have our kids scared it's not okay to evacuate the school and have parents calling me saying why couldn't you call me

104I could have come and gotten my baby I know but that's not we can't do that law enforcement has what has processed that we need to do we continue to get threats and then we start seeing weapons in school um we can't have weapons in school not by people who are not trained so we wanted to add the SRO to make sure that we are protecting our staff and our students and we wanted to do all of these things from a mental health perspective and to understand the history it's not an overnight thing that we talked about we have been talking about safety we have been talking about adding people I want to say for the entire time I've been on the board but very importantly the past two years um we have had meetings

105recently where we have talked about it to answer your question about why we're not letting people vote um it's not that it's not that we're not letting them vote when we first talked about and put the SRO in place that was all it was done before I came on board but from what I understand that was done with the public and with conversation I'll get confirmation on that but once so I I understand I understand that so if I could finish my statement please um I understand that there's a difference I also understand that we're going to have a conversation and you're going to hear that they've been through the same training and we're going to make sure that they're through the same training so let's have that conversation and then you and I can

106talk after the meeting if if you would like okay um so I wanted to bring you through the history I wanted you to know that your safety your children's safety the staff safety mental healthwise covid wise flu whatever that is a top priority the second top priority for us is curriculum so you'll hear more about that as well but um I just felt we need to tell you the history as I see it and as I know it um and I would still stand up and I I'll stand up anytime you want and say I'll protect the kids and for whatever it takes and talk to me don't take it out on the kids or the staff so um Chris that's that's what I wanted to say thank thanks Tom um so I think with

107that I know the board members have um several questions for Dr spedo so I I'd like to open it up for kind of board discussion debate and um please let us make this Lively I think it's important that we do have um you know open discussion be free to disagree with each other and and you know truly debate debate this issue and what through um things so that it looks like yes I just have a quick question I think for them to hear you you have to use a mic so I'm uh listening to everybody and hearing that if uh SRO were part of the elementary school instead of the uh Atlas security firm uh Paul what would that uh what would that entail and can we do that that is something we could discuss

108Administration ly I mean our thought was was to have if if it was approved tonight to have the two SRO on the campuses one in the high school campus one in the Middle School campus there is more students here uh on campus and then the plan was was to have um the at security guards one at K Hanson and one at Marvel toown so it's for me to see um so I'm wondering if we can consider um a variation I I acknowledge that additional security is needed to stay in age there are issues we need to keep our kids safe what if we had our the security guards from atas but not [Applause] armed again it was advised to us that the training that the armed security guards go through through is a lot more

109intense it's it's a lot more uh rigorous and they're a lot more trained than an unarmed security guard but that's some research we have to do is some of their retired police officers that went through all that training you know did can they be unarmed in our schools as well but it's it's up to the client like the weapon can be concealed if you're if you're worried about them if you're worried about the weapon being exposed like the weapon weapon can I ask a followup question to that I'm sorry so if we were to approve the contract could the board make a decision later on about having armed security versus just security from the company like if we are tonight are we approving the contract as armed security or just Security in the RF in

110the RFP it's it's arm it's two arm securitys because it's a different role it's Ro different pay different training I think I guess my question is about discipline and the role that they have in deing kids like are they in charge of discipline how does that work that's good question though the administration is still in charge of discipline kind of like what the lady said alluded to a tribe Valley they're in their walk the Halls they're they're helping they're assisting um they're just another set of eyes and ears uh out there and if you know if they come you know they always intervene you always intervene in two things harm to self or harm to others so obviously they they intervene if the student safety was at risk but if there's a discipline issue you

111know we would direct them to let the administration handle a discipline issue well can we request Atlas hire uh vond community members as part yeah absolutely if if it is approved tonight you know we we will reach out to Atlas and make sure is there any retired police officers that are part of Atlas that live in the rondale community uh so they are familiar familiar with our community and the expectations that they have okay I'm going to go off topic just a little bit um first of all I don't know if you know my background um I've been in education for 42 years U I spent 20 of those in the State of Florida and I was in charge of Public Safety we built a 50 50 acre complex and we trained every public defender

112every police officer in the State of Florida who were nationally known when I took over that position I was very skeptical of having guns in my faulty and so I went to the lot of the training I learned so much that this isn't they just don't pull this out of a rabit out of a hat there is research and I want to talk about research for a minute now on that campus I have I have the UN I brings me to tears I've been on two campuses where there were shootings that campus where we trained every law enforcement individual in Florida my two daughters were on campus and I was coming back from Tampa I got the phone call there a shooter on campus now they left one campus the security armed got them off

113campus they went to another campus by the time they got to the second campus the armed guys shot them shot the tires out went in the ditch nobody was shot now I wonder why didn't they ever call me I've been charged to find out well there was nobody killed so why would that be a statistic it worked I have evidence Fort beer Florida you look it up now I come up here and I'm in charge of the police training at the Sunni aler probably never heard of this but there was an armed shooter on our campus there was an individual uh domestic violence and he ran through the campus with a long rifle and we have the training field set so all our our armed guys are are they have guns they stopped him in

114the field stopped it he ran back into his home mope now the first case the guy in Florida wasn't killed you know he ended up going to jail and going through mental health the second guy locked himself in into the trailer near the campus and after 3 days he killed himself but the point is nobody on our campus ever felt fear nobody ever felt like there was any time that they were in danger my children on that campus if you don't know it and they told me this many times I said well what if there's a shooting they go no it's when will there be a shooting and my short career I've witnessed two of those so as a member of this board one thing that I wanted to do do way back in the

115beginning this is my third year was security for our campuses we have it's a large campus so if something happen on this campus you're going to tell me if somebody flees here and goes to another campus there's no way they're going to stop them so anyway it's off the topic but I've lived it twice and I know the feeling of having your children safe because there's armed people there and they become part of the community and they're well known and they're loved any of [Music] youf can anyone read those out loud now I read the reviews but we've had recommendations from districts that they've been in again they've been in they've been in business for 32 years they're in 15 school districts and again ofy I didn't read that but some dated points for you

116there have been no shootings no weapon violence and no significant instances under their supervision I do apologize this is this is It's board time so we will proce discuss um any other comments I think you all have other questions points I know you said to go to the nispa um uh review of of this issue I did look at it um and they just had uh that the security private security be held at the same uh standards as as sro's in which we've uh brought that to the table so you stand stand I don't know so we we have we have reached out and and this is the last back and forth that we're going to do we we have got for the community here we have gotten feedback from sties who actually is using

117atlet right now and they are very they are very happy with the services I I need you to stop please you interrupting a public meeting I need you to stop this is unacceptable this is not and every here in the bo already make decision for us and we are very upset in community we pay taxes and we think that we can hire at somebody who can be addict to mental health this maybe it's issue with shooting and you are you want to have you push maybe it is your friends comp company local and you are happy to hire for from our taxes and I am against it so um Dr Dr SPO I have a question I and I I think you you might have said it and I know um but the security guards

118what kind of training will they have will they have the same as um oler County Sheriff's Department well I I have been very respectful to you and I told you that I would talk with you afterwards and but you're not letting me but you're not you're not me answer questions have I tried to answer part of it that I knew and I told you I would speak with you after I um why we're not bringing it to a vote on the budget we do have an SRO online item that was voted on in the budget in May for two sro's so and we do have um other items but my question out just okay I really really need I need a public please thank you and and we have students by the way in the

119audience please show them how to behave in a public meeting please show them how you behave in a public meeting thank you and just one thing I want to say so you let Mr McDon know it's great that he is mandated that these students here some of them left probably because they have to go home or whatever it is volunteer in our community go to local Town meetings and go to a board bed meeting and I you know what it's almost 9:00 guys so I give these kids a lot of credit and this is this is an interesting meeting and got to tell you my senior is here and I I don't go to these meetings I said you know what your teacher is mandating it I'm going to go too that's the least we

120can do is let the Board finish and speak thank you board I appreciate it because I'm not here I'm volunteering my time so please finish so please I I strongly so um my question is will the guards have the same training is the sheriff's department and um if there is any kind of um managing of which I know there is of the guards Dr SPO who will be managing that yeah sure so again they they they welcome that collaboration with the sheriff's office again they will be invited to that uh training the Sheriff's Office put on uh in February up in Saratoga the 3-day training again they comply with all of training with the stfe schools against violence and education um again their background checks fingerprinted they take State mandated courses uh that provide services

121the students they have to pass all background checks once we get that information from them then we send that information Nancy will send that information to the New York State Department of Education they have to um clear that background check and again they they participate in sexual harassment training they'll be particip they participate in deescalation training they are trained to work with students um what about conceal weapons like is the gun going to be on security guards um concealed or not is that something we can request absolutely again that that's up to us the clients so we we can request that the guns be uh concealed in you know not in a view of students I have another question I'm Sor um for our kids who are um Al some of our programs the special

122education programs um will are these guards be trained in how to um work directly with our students if that's the case in terms of behavior management and in terms of understanding that some of them cannot communicate verbally um will we be offering training in that area yeah so again with us being you know the being the supervisor up in the school district we can make them go to any training we want to like I alluded to in the presentation uh we want them to go through the BTA uh training we want them to go through how to they go through deescalation training and any any type of training we offer our teachers they are more than welcome and we can you know make them go to those trainings uh as well because they're they again

123we want them to be a staff member we want them infiltrated in our in our schools and our staff and we want them to be a part of the community any other board comment discuss I think with that I think we move on the agenda uh so on seven under agenda item three uh County olster Amendment agreement the recommend a motion that the Board of Education approve the amendment agreement between the roundout Valley Central school district and the county of oluler effective January 1 2025 as presented make motion any discussion all in favor I any oppose motion carries recommend a motion the rfpv approval for Atlas Security Services uh as presented I us any discussion all in favor any you opposed I'm opposed we are opposed opposed item number [Music] seven agenda items9 recommend a

124motion be resolved that the Board of Education approve the consent agenda items 1-9 as [Music] present all in favor OPP motion [Applause] are we all um recommending motion resolation approve theenda second any discussion know what it's fine you never this question I recommend a motion to adjourn the December 10th 2024 meeting any discussion all in favor any oppose cares you never explain

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.