001all right let's open our Saratoga Springs City School District board meeting for February 13 2025 can I please get a roll call trustey eka here truste crackler here truste amyy trustee Braxton here trusty bugman here truste Colligan here trusty Copans here trusty lakia here trusty yovic here here student representative Juan here student representative prosc here please stand and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance all right can I please get a motion to approve the minutes from January 23rd 2025 Connie and Natalia is there any discussion seeing none all in favor that is seven no eight zero we're missing one that's would be eight um can I get a motion to accept tonight's agenda Natalia John um any discussion all in favor again 8 Z thank you and this brings us to our first public
002comment period and we do have one person signed up um on behalf of the board thank you for being here we truly value your input from the community especially on a night like tonight and we appreciate your engagement um we ask speakers in the audience to conduct themselves in a civil and constructive manner modeling the same respectfulness we expect from our students in the district um the first public comment period is limited to 30 minutes then after that the board will conduct its business and have a second public comment period um the first two slots are held for students are there any students here who didn't sign up and wish to speak okay then our first person um and only person for the first um public comment period is Amy Frappier sorry if I mispronounced
003that graier okay I got fancy thank you so much and thank you for the opportunity to be here tonight it is not nice out there it's much nicer in here so this is the place to be um so um thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak to you this evening um I wanted to come and and talk to you um tonight because um I wanted to share some concerns that have been coming up in some discussions I've been having with a a group of a few dozen parents and um some of you might remember I was here about a year ago and we were talking about the the bathrooms and some concerns that we had and um the um the high school principal sa and um her team um did a really great
004job in addressing a lot of those concerns and we were really happy about that um it's been a little disappointing though for us um to find that um there have been some problems that are that we've been hearing from our kids about some of the bathroom issues in the high school again this year um so some of the things that we um have gotten in touch with uh principal s about were and I just wanted to give you an update about this were um involving things like um bathroom stalls with no locks on them so kids don't have privacy and um which had us concerned about um how we're dealing with um maintenance and repairs um there were some um concerns that the kids have brought about um some like cleanliness in the bathrooms and
005obviously you know with a school of almost 2,000 kids like it's complicated we we we really get that um but it's more that some of these things have been ongoing for longer periods of time so um we have reached out to principal sa and she's been I think really putting in um a fresh eye on that so I feel like that's going to move forward at the same time um the the parents um that have been concerned continually about um whether there's enough resources available to um you know if we're playing whacka all with some of these kinds of um maintenance Pro issues it may be partly because you know do we have enough resources to provide the kind of um Quality and you know safe healthy and dignified um environment that we want our
006kids to all be experiencing uh and so we have some concerns about whether there's enough resources there um and on at the same time um I'm sure you've been hearing from other folks uh some concerns about whether there's enough supervision um to kind of make sure that there's not going to be any kind of um uh you know vandalism or other kinds of you know things that can happen when there's not a close eye on things um the group of parents is also concerned on this theme of resources um with the the bus situation which continues to be a problem um we're all looking forward to break when um we're going to get all uh things will be pretty consistent but um I think as a group um as a group we feel like um
007this group has done a really good job over the years of kind of keeping our budget tight and can you wrap that up please yes I am um we spend less per child than a lot of the other school schools in our area and I know there there's a lot of complications to that but um with inflation uh really taking a bite out of what we can do with those dollars um we're starting to feel like uh we need to figure out a way to increase the resource pool for our schools so that the kids have what they need and so that the amazing staff and teachers uh also have what they need so um some of us are willing to give up our you know star whatever in order to make sure that the
008we invest properly in the future in the Next Generation thank you so thank you all right that closes our public comment period and we move on to board committee reports do we have any board committees wishing to report out John the policy committee met and you will see in the consent agenda several policies that are here before you for the first read I will uh note that there is one um pertaining to um bicycling to Maple Avenue which which would be of interest to a lot of folks in the public perhaps so that's something to look at I will also um say that at our last uh Board of Education business meeting there was um an issue that was raised about um offering uh ADM enrollment in our uh schools within our district to depending
009of employees who live outside the district and the board at that moment decided to send that to the policy committee for consideration and the policy committee uh reviewed our current policy there are a couple different ways that is uh viable um in our current policy and the policy committee decided that um the any expansion of that policy would be uh potentially uh un uh resource for employees that could be discussed in uh Union negotiations and determined that we had nothing else to uh work on at the moment so I'm just letting you know that for now we regard that as you know off the table until until somebody else raises it again or until it comes up in negotiations thank you for doing that appreciate it to the committee are there any questions for the
010committee okay um I see two hands did did you you raise your hand good all right whoever pick one uh business or finance committee met uh an audit committee on um February 3rd we um were informed that our internal Auditors would be on site uh this week and next week or I'm sorry no uh yeah this week and next week um and they'll be focusing on uh the area of federal Awards um last year it was cash receipts um and fixed assets this year uh their scope will be Federal Awards um we looked at the financing plan for the district for the current um December 2020 Legacy project and the anticipated um May 2025 Legacy project should it be approved um we reviewed information that we rely on when the um when we create a
011fin cial plan for the project um what factors are that produce the local share tax share responsibility um we look to keep the annual share local share generally identical from year to year and so we discussed how careful planning of the capital project um and strategic Assumption of debt can accomplish this um Bobby reviewed the um Office of the State Controllers controllers fiscal stress monitoring system score we are monitored each year and we report at this meeting each year on fiscal stress um they break it down into financial and environmental factors and um there are tiar of designation designation is a negative thing in this in this context there are three tiers of designation and we were not designated in any tier for either Financial or environmental so no designation uh it all reflects positively
012on the district um Bobby reviewed the uh preliminary tax cap calculation which we'll start talking about a ton in the coming months uh or weeks um when all the variables uh are entered are are Max allowable this year could be uh 4.72% we discussed why that felt in the in the current climate for um you know sort of Legacy project issues why that felt like it might be a little high and Bobby um discovered that uh there's some money in a Debt Service fund that is only allocatable to paying down um certain debt and if we allocate some of that our tax cap figure comes down and um it comes down uh into the 3.9 to 3.99 range which we felt was more uh acceptable but obviously this group will talk about that um more
013as we as we go on finally um Kudos stail in the uh business office she got positive pay um off the ground for the general ledger or general fund checking account which was um a big deal a lot of work it it basically is an electronic way of preventing fraudulent activity and and getting um checks into uh our bank account um more swiftly and and more with more security so kudos to uh Lucille for doing that that's all any questions for finance okay Dean thank you um so property committee hasn't met uh recently but uh I always touch base with John Tiner before the meetings just to ask if there's anything he'd like me to report out on and just recently they were notified um what we did discuss at property committee a few months
014ago was uh the district applying for a grant uh to receive uh funding to assist Geer Road with um an outdoor classroom and with that would be uh a concrete pad and then a structure that would go up that would support um not just an inclement weather but you know in the in the uh nicer months with the sun uh allowing students to be outside so uh we were just informed that we did uh receive that Grant totaling just under $119,000 uh and even more importantly uh John and his team will be working together this summer to uh do the work inhouse and put that structure together for the folks out at geyser so it's a good little win for the district and for uh certainly for Geyser thank you um any questions for property
015all right thanks that's pretty exciting um any other board reports nope okay that takes us to our students uh at Division Street on Monday the PTA hosted a breakfast for the dedicated bus drivers in celebration of love the bus month showing appreciation for all they do in addition students created thoughtful cards to express their gratitude project hosted a family fun night families and School staff were invited to play games with li students there were there was uh food and board games and at the end of the night each family was able to take a board game home with them students are very excited for Valentine's Day parties tomorrow at at Dorothy sorry at Dorothy Nolan students have been decorating cards to go along with some small tokens of appreciation for the bus drivers the HSA
016has partnered with Coach ran to offer Afterschool Mario Kart sessions in the gym and it's proved to be a great fundraiser and lots of fun for the kids the kindness crew formerly the no place for hate group has been pushing into each Home Room to share their message and hopes for our school during data days staff has been able to celebrate the growth students have made thus for thus far and plan for how to keep the momentum grow going in the second half of the year at Greenfield they had their bus driver breakfast on Wednesday on Friday um the 31st of January they the school had their PBIS celebration it was a winter carnival and students enjoyed both snow painting and sledding on Friday uh the 7th the HSA built or held a big little
017ball students brought a special person to the ball and danced to the music the second grade students stud had a bug Museum showcasing their research on bugs and the first grade students showed off their research on the animals at their writing celebration at Lake a all students are sledding this week this is very exciting as the sledding week has been cancelled for the last two years due to the lack of snow kids are excited to have PE classes full of snow filled fun the PTA hosted the annual Bingo night on Wednesday this week students and families had a great time at Maple Avenue the Maple Avenue musical production of Matilda came to an end last weekend a total of 73 students participated and there was a packed audience for each of the six shows The
018Faculty staff and students that participated in this year's musical did an amazing job at the high school the second semester has started midterms in January Regents went smoothly students completed course selections and they are now meeting with counselors to finalize requests for next year the High School drama club is presenting the Musical Legally Blonde starting Thursday March 6th and the NHS blood drive received 76 pints of blood thank you so much that brings us to you Mike great good evening everyone I hope you enjoyed your ice day today um so was a definitely a messy morning in Saratoga Springs uh so I want to Echo a few things from our students uh first of all congrat congratulations uh to all of our middle school students the entire cast and crew and the directors and so
019many of the parent volunteers uh who put a tremendous amount of time and effort each year into our musical performance of Matilda uh I was able to go on opening night and the weather that night wasn't great uh and we still had a packed house uh and they did six wonderful performances over two weekends uh so again just uh it's always impressive to our students performing on stage uh you would never know they were middle school students that were up there performing uh but I know they put a lot of time and and effort into rehearsals uh and the directors and the choreography it's always just a an incredible performance and uh just congratulations to everybody uh who put their hearts and souls into it uh we are coming up on our midwinter recess uh
020so tomorrow uh is our last day of class before the midwinter break uh that will run through next week uh so again uh hope everybody can get out enjoy the winter weather I think we've got some more snow coming in this weekend so uh if you like the snow uh it sounds like this week will be a good chance to get outside and to enjoy it um and also just uh tonight the Board of Education uh is scheduled to approve uh at least three key resolutions on tonight's agenda uh for legacy 2025 Capital project and just want to give some Kudos and recognition and thanks uh to our Legacy referendum referendum advisory committee uh this was over 40 members of our school Community uh staff and administrators and parents and business partners and community members
021uh that spent an entire year um really looking at all of our buildings the building condition survey uh visiting each of the sites um having the opportunity to continue um with the uh investment that our Comm Community has made in previous capital projects the work that we're doing on uh in all of our schools right now uh and we're excited about what Legacy 2025 uh will do for our districts moving into the future uh continuing to focus on our educational program uh improving accessibility as well as Safety and Security features in our schools uh as well as some of the energy efficiencies and maintenances uh and operations um again that our public comment speaker refer to is uh you know we have take great pride in our facilities and want to continue to be able
022to maintain uh and provide a productive learning environment for our students and staff uh so tonight uh the board will be approving the final resolutions that set the vote date uh and then there's going to be a lot of community engagement uh throughout the next several months leading up to uh the community vote on May 20th so uh anticipate hearing a lot more information with videos and newsletters and Public Presentation ations and opportunities for a lot of questions and feedback uh related to the Legacy 2025 Capital project uh you you will see there's our first board uh that just came out today uh and one of the the central pieces that we're super excited about uh is the renovation to the house of the AUD of the auditorium here at the high school um and
023so uh in continuing with some of the classro renovations uh and again some renovations to some existing athletic facilities and then again there's a tremendous amount of other work when it comes to just maintaining our infrastructure uh and making sure we have um safe access to all of our buildings so definitely more to come um but again the the the board of education has been engaged for the last several months and uh again tonight's a a really important night for for our district the last thing I want to um turn it over is uh last spring uh we had our stakeholders here at the high school uh where our teachers and administrators started having conversation last spring uh about opportunities to proactively address uh concerns that everyone had been having uh about student cell phone
024use uh here in school uh that was a concern that was also shared by the Board of Education last year uh and so the high school team kind of took it upon themsel uh in the fall uh and has engaged with all of our community stakeholders so we've had student participation teacher participation uh administrator support support uh engagement with our parents uh as well as community members uh so tonight we want to provide the opportunity for our cell phone student committee uh to share some of the feedback and some of the findings uh that they've heard uh over the last several months uh and they're going to share a little bit about uh Governor hokel has come out with some initial recommendations and some work that's ahead of us between now uh in the summertime
025uh in anticipation of the start of the new school year so I'm going to turn over to Kevin walper one of our assistant principles just for introductions uh and you'll hear from several of the folks that have been leading the charge here at the high school good evening everyone um I'm just going to introduce three pivotal people who worked on our committee um as Dr Patton said um Miss ragab Baron who's going to present first raised her hand during a faculty meeting and said we have to do something about these phones and we have to do it now and kudos to principal sa and the rest of the administrative team we're like let's do what everyone else do we'll start another committee so we started a committee and you're going to hear from two of
026our students um Sophie and um shuy who are exceptional ninth graders who Dove right into the work and spent a lot of time on this so um miss Mr rer Bron's going to start us off talking about our cell phone ad hoc committee which is that one great this is embarrassing because I also teach two tech classes and I just had to ask which button do I hit to move the slide forward so uh yes hi I am uh Bradley ragab Baron I'm an our teacher here at the high school um and it very true uh there it goes um back in May of 2024 um in the middle of a faculty meeting I stood up and declared I was losing my mind um slowly but surely because the the cell phones had really become
027a a ongoing uh issue particularly in um some of our more open format classes um teaching art that's we're in a studio setup and it just was becoming very distracting um so I I took it to admin um and of course we we started a committee we had our first meeting you can see October of 2024 our committee participants whoever can come at the the time of the meetings um have have been there or have offered support through helping us to come up with questions for like the survey or have come to me personally with things they would like brought to the committee um so it's been really open to everyone who has a stake uh in the school to to participating in this committee it was decided um very early on that we were
028going to need to at the very least have a survey and then possibly some focus groups afterwards from all stakeholders so as of December we did the stakeholder surveys which I'll talk about next on the on the next slide um and then in January of this year of 2025 we held our focus groups I will draw special attention to the staff focus group day which literally happened on it was rates you can see up on the screen and in our presentation here um we had of our participants of 251 staff members 127 of them took the survey as did 1,4 of the you know little over 1,800 students and uh 437 parents par responded to the survey all right and I don't expect you to read teeny tiny Graphics so I will give you kind
029of the what we took most away from our survey data um so what you can imagine is with such a variety of stakeholders there was a variety of opinions on what roles cell phone and Technology have to play um within our district within the school day um I I don't think there's anything particularly that will be surprising um about this um students for the most part in their responses felt they had absolutely no negative impact on their social mental physical cognitive or academic Health basically they they stated that in no way shape or form was it affecting them um and this was a fairly overwhelming response to that that was you know um you know 60 to 70% on some of the questions almost 80% % of our students were basically saying there are no
030problems the exception to this which we found most interesting was students did report that they do perceive from themselves sleep health issues due to phones um so we kind of we we took note of that and said okay now parents being asked the same Bank of survey questions about social mental physical cognitive academic sleep Health um had a different take if you will the majority of our parents reported that cell phones had some type from some to like all ranging to always as our as the responses they were given um having negative impact on their social mental and physical health most parents reported to us that they had no um perceived impact on cognitive or academic Health which we also found interesting because the number one thing teachers reported um overwhelmingly was that cell phones
031are a major distraction and disruption throughout the classroom day it is the thing that we are constantly um having to deal with instead of instructional time okay so that was kind of our our survey results okay um next up I'll have should we discuss our focus groups thanks hi um my name is shuy I'm a freshman here at the high school and I'll be talking about the focus groups so we planned and executed three different focus groups in order to hear from all the voices from the major stakeholders oh sorry about that wait no okay um so we asked the following five questions to each participant and they all gave their personal opinions about this what do you notice from the data what does the data tell you um what do you wonder about the
032data when should students have access to phones when should phones use not be permitted when should phones be stored and how do we assess whether policies are working and how to refine them uh sorry so I know you've all received a copy of these uh the presentation but here are some quotes that we were able to jot down and really really stood out to us as a student representative here that that was present at the focus groups um I noticed that from the staffs it was pretty unanimous um phones were interfering with learning and they were just detrimental to students overall in their education social and mental aspects of the life um as for the parents it was a bit more varried but they also all like agreed that it wasn't good for students both
033in and out of school um one thing I did notice was the third bullet up there how cell phones aren't really helpful in a um matter of emergency because while they're busy texting their parents their friends about what's going on they could have been listening to um teachers authorities and law enforcers about how to get to safety and stay um safe as for the students I wasn't there personally for the focus groups but I know from talking with some of my peers and friends that it will be hard to actually like ourselves our phone uses and be away for this for so long but you know it's pretty good for us and overall it's something that has to be done in order to get a better education um and I'll be turning this over to
034my friend Sophie Hi I'm Sophie um today I'll be discussing Governor hok's proposal for cell phones in our schools so the underline text is what we thought was the most important parts of her proposal so number two for me means that I will not be able to have access to my phone from 7:49 a.m. to 2:20 p.m. and number four means the school may have me store my phone and Apple watch in my locker away from class there will most likely be medical exceptions for those like my friend who have an insulin pump that is Monitor by her phone um the school will need to clearly communicate a way way for families to get in contact with their children during the day most likely using the phone at the students AP office so there are
035some steps we need to take before next school year so the first step will be for the law to be passed then the Board of Ed will need to create a policy by August 1st of this year once that happens then the school must Implement and communicate procedures and expectations to staff students parents Etc okay I'll pass this back to M Raa Baron all right so in conclusion short and sweet right okay there we go so um what we just want to conclude with is that yes this is this is coming we will be you know have to develop policy on it but um at the high school you know speaking from the high school perspective we are ready to act and develop a storage plan as needed um for each building and we we
036we are prepared to implement this Bell to Bell meaning 749 to 220 220 band as is best for our students so the work continues and we we look forward to kind of mocking in all right do we any questions that we can open up or hopefully any any I have a couple questions the first one is um how did you all get so awesome um but uh I'm a I'm a big fan of this agenda and I really appreciate all the good work and the presentation the data and I know there's tons of work behind what you've shared with us one question is um you know we never know what the state's going to do um and some of your language makes sounds like we're kind of um hooked to what the legislature achieves uh
037um and I I guess I'd like us to think about whether we want to whether that's necessary uh whether it's necessary for us to stay to to um follow a timeline that is somehow linked to what the state does to me this is the cheapest thing we can do to add a huge amount of value to our district in a relatively short period of time regardless of what the legislature does it would be really nice if there was guidance from experts at the state level it'd be really nice if there was funding but my personal view is we shouldn't wait on them if if I mean if they're on the same time frame and they want us to get it done by August great but if not I hope we'll consider a different path forward
038so I guess I only asked the one question what is your question any any other um I agree with everything John just said but did did you all in your research um ever want or or think that a policy should go beyond what the governor is talking about so our goal was not because obviously the high school doesn't dictate policy for the district um our goal was to see what the student staff and administrative experience was and parent of course um experience was with cell phones in the classroom and then to bring good data hopefully or the best that we could um you know one thing we talked about a lot in our groups was we realize what we're relying on is predominantly self-reported the the quality of that data is is what it is
039it is we can only rely on students and parents to self-report and and staff as well to self-report what they feel comfortable with and we were very cautious I would say of putting the cart before the horse we didn't want to be in the position of saying well the high school would like to do this for the whole District because as as you're well aware Maple already has a complete van of cell phones bellt Bell already that they have implemented um at their school and so there's a a variety of policies already in place and we were more exploring what we had currently at the high school um and I would like to say what the climate was from um parents and students and and faculty staff as well sorry I just to follow up
040was there any discussion on cell phone use in school approved extracurricular there was so one thing that came up particularly from our student focus group was consistency um and actually maybe I'm gonna redirect it to my to my student presenters to talk a little bit about some of that of the of the student experience with with thanks thanks sh um for the students so a lot of them actually likes having their phones with them it's for music when they're bored in class schedules tools and such but um like I said all of them believe that like deep down they don't really need their phones and that it could just be distracting them from actually having a good education and being able to focus in class uh so I that's at least from what I heard
041not sure about Sophie want to go yeah it was just from my my own Flex uh when uh because because principal s did a wonderful job making sure to go on to get as much student participation as we could during Flex time like directing the students please take out your laptops you've been sent this survey please take this survey and I have a freshman um flex and immediately the tittering I heard was no you can't answer it really because they're going to take the phones away which I which which I kind of felt like being like guys I can hear you you know so um I I found particularly from the frankness of the discussion from our student focus groups um one of the I'm going to go back to one other quote there that
042just like broke my heart um I had a student refer to the cell phone as the brick of sadness which I felt was very self-aware um students talking about one of our other pull group quotes that we didn't include in the slide was that one student feels compelled to scroll until they end on a high note so literally understanding that they have almost a compulsive need to use this and that they don't always feel in control of their own use which makes perfect sense the tech was designed to be um I mean even for adults I myself we did we did the embarrassing exercise at the end of our student focus group where we all look at our screen time if you've ever done this it'll mortify you um and uh and you know my
043our students were reporting for that focus group between 9 and 13 hours daily average usage um I was embarrassed enough to have to admit that I had spent an hour and 37 minutes on average online shopping so you know right it's like we we we all experienced that poll of tech I think it was it was very universally humanizing um many of our groups to realize we're experiencing many of the same things um even at varying age levels and experience any other questions yeah so I I have two questions was there any talk of there being value in teachers helping students to learn about good habits when they are in a situ like for example when students go to college or they go to work after high school if they go to college and they're
044in a lecture hall with 500 other students and there's one person lecturing that one person lecturing doesn't care if you're on YouTube nobody cares if you're wasting your your money or your parents money so was there any talk about how the high school could actually be an opportunity for teaching when it is and why it is appropriate was there also any best practices maybe are there teachers that maybe have a really good way of making the phones go away during instructional time sure so Holly Lewis who is a member of our of our our committee team is a health teacher um and I know that she does do a digital health component which is health is the required class that every student has to take here um I know also Mr Hill Bob Hill who's
045one of our health teachers does the same thing where they are talking about they do the screen time exercise they talk about appropriate usage do you feel compelled to use this how do you limit your usage um so I do know that through our health curriculum from what those teachers have reported to me that an educ ational component is happening um I think one thing that we were really surprised by and that some of the newer research coming out is just one thing that I'll I'll state it from the parent perspective we had Parents literally comparing their children to alcoholics with this that it seems to have gone beyond an ability to control themselves but that they are compelled there there seems to be a a ingrained compelling to do it so we are doing
046the education component I'll let principal SP s speak to though um the second question where you were asking about classroom practices and what we've already implemented so um just to piggyback on the first question there when we implemented our current procedures which is um no phones out during instructional time um even with some of our teachers that was a discussion point because there were teachers that did want to say I use my these phones for educational purposes we want to teach good habits we want to teach responsibility and that was a um a fairly long discussion with our department heads in a department head meeting um and in the end we talked about consistency being the way in which we could move forward with helping to teach our students when it is appropriate to have
047their phone so we did agree in the end that not during instructional time um would be the way in which we were going to move forward in our classroom procedures um but there there were many teachers that did want to utilize phones during instructional time and and did not want to um have a ban during instructional time um the second question can you repeat it again so I actually think that you I think that you um address both questions but I I just want to clarify there were in this focus group there were 15 staff members six students and 19 and those are where those quotes came from that's where those quotes came there were other conversations though Dr Patton and I had met with the student council um in December there was probably 15
048students in the room where we had a um a round table discussion um asking very similar questions to the focus groups with other students and I guess I mean by best practices for example I am a high school teacher and I do not have a problem with phones in my classroom because it's how I take attendance phone goes in the pocket every student's name has a a pocket yep and I don't even I look at the phones to take attendance and if their phone isn't there I don't start my lesson so I don't know if that is things like that are happening or being talked about because there are there is an opportunity to actually be successful and teach the kids how you can focus you can put it away and yes I can help
049you regulate that yes but but self-regulation is a really important thing to learn in high school and the governor is going to do what she's going to do she's going to let us have local control or not um and I I it is one concern I have where we're taking away the ability to help our kids self-regulate in a world where there are phones there's going to be phones even when they go home there's going to be phones but if they learn that when they're learning there are no phones and I as the adult in charge going to help do that there's value in that for sure yes and we do have many teachers that are engaging in those best practices um many different um tools that they're using we bought our teachers the this
050you know the shoe racks for a lack of better terms for students to put them in um unfortunately though that will not be um a possibility in the future because the the regulations I'm not sure if you've read read the proposed language these can be found online the state put out two doc documents um this is an overview summary you can find it right online that talks about the process that we should be engaging in and in determining some sort of school level policy um and some of the exemptions that would exist and then this is the legal language that specifically States uh Bell to Bell not being on an individual's person any and and it's any internet connected device so that would include tablets SmartWatches um and other items so um we are very
051proud of the work that our teachers have done in in engaging in those best practices this year um consistency is something that our students say is um important and that is probably one of the reasons why it continues to be um a topic of conversation amongst different faculty members great thank you very much great job [Applause] all right so we do have uh one uh formal presentation tonight uh from our district uh technology department uh so Dev alamad our assistant superintendent uh for information technology and operational Innovation as well as Lucas Manny our it support specialist uh and we have a I know a whole team of uh teachers and other Tech integrators here uh to talk a little bit about the focus tonight is is artificial intelligence uh and education so a little AI
052theme tonight so I'll turn it over to Dave uh good evening everyone so I asked Lucas to he's going to pass out before I get started in the presentation an AI cheat sheet I'm calling it it's an AI nomenclature sheet so some of the stuff yes it's not acronyms but it's still kind of some new new technology or new language so just to kind of you'll see part of the presentation I talks about kind of an introduction to AI so to move some of those slides along I thought I would provide this sheet so it gives a basic Definition of artificial intelligence you'll hear me talk about the ability of a computer or robot to perform tasks the AI we're talking about or focusing on what's called Genera generative AI which is really where you're
053creating something new whether it's a new document a new picture a new sound so and we'll hit that a little bit these AI tools or chat Bots is another word that's on there and Lucas will be talking about some of those tools that we've recommended our teachers try to use um connect to large language models like GPT 4 is a big one maybe you've heard of you probably have used a tool chat GPT but it connects to that large uh language model uh Gemini is one that Google has kind of changed and there's there's probably 10 or so out there there's quite a few so I won't get into a lot of details with those um machine learning is again another component of AI that talks about machines actually learn from data and it kind
054of improves their performance are they getting smarter no they're getting more information and they can respond from that information um we'll talk a little bit about prompt so that's on there number six in our nomenclature that's basically the questions that you ask Ai and they actually call it prompt engineering or it's it's really a skill and you'll see there's a couple of different uh attributes you really want to include in a prompt to make sure you're getting an accurate accurate response from an A tool um the natural language processing piece really goes back and ties to the large language models which is basically we we put a question in we want the answer back in common language that we can understand um the last three I'll kind of end with that there are challenges with
055any technology but with data privacy on the tools that we're going to be talking about tonight they have to be vetted they have to be Ed law 2D compliant so we want we want to make sure of that um some of the ethical challenges with AI and the biases with AI um all the AI tools that we talk about and we've done any kind of PD on it it's always about AI tools create draft draft information draft documents so with that we'll get started so just a quick introduction and again kind of went through some of this this is actually a quote created by a chatbot or co-pilot that Luke will talk a little bit about and again a type of technology that allows computers and machines to think and learn um if I kind
056of jump down in the definition the ab ability to analyze data recognize patterns is huge and it does it instantly in in seconds and again it's going through these large language model think of huge just piles and piles of data AI defined so some of the components in AI is the learning component is it getting smarter it's getting more information in there how does it do reasoning um what are the specific problems that AI can help us with what is the perception and again the thing that's changed so much is that language component now that AI can produce results that we can use we can create new documents we can create new pictures we can create u a whole bunch of things that again are useful to us now this is the definition and again
057the tools we're talking to tonight are generative AI so generative AI tools is said they create things and documents is is a big thing new text um images you can write a story and it will create an image based on the prompt that you put in um for computer coding a lot of our students are doing some computer coding but as and if you do you've seen coding bunch of tax right bunch of syntax I'm not great at it because I get like all these red errors but anyway so AI can help you to figure out like I'm missing a space I'm missing a quote um and again it can actually help us with new coding too so education with AI focusing on Ed the education component I'll start with what it is not it's
058not a replacement for teachers I have two great teachers standing next to me right here um these folks connect with our students students they help our students they teach our students and you're going to hear from them AI is just another tool and it just helps our students it provides feedback or it can give them um maybe they're struggling starting out with a concept or struggling with a concept maybe it can help them to get started so it's not going to solve all our problems I'm still in that column there on the right um one more thing that needs to take a lot of time for busy Educators you actually heard tonight that it's a tool that can help Educators I was a teacher for 10 years and I still remember creating things like essential
059questions and rubrics and assessments I did it on my own so you can actually now create a rubric anybody here create a rubric from scratch a lot of work so with AI you can put in criteria it will create you a rubric again it's a draft rubric you may not like some of it but I've just gained like a whole day so it's it's a great tool education with AI so again that personalized learning of the differentiation in seconds um text to speech language translation we're talk a little bit about World Language they actually dealing with AI a lot longer than we have I think it was 2006 I don't know if anyone knows corre my facts but that's when Google translate started and then was pretty bad in 2006 and it's gotten a lot
060better but it kind of changed how our world language teacher had had to teach AI literacy is how it works putting it all together on the knowledge skills and attitudes associated with how artificial intelligence works and again there's with AI literacy I can and again if you start to combine it with things like computer science it can really take our students um to the next level and a lot of programmers and even industry is using it and I I personally think it it's also a skill you kind of see it listed up there that employers are starting to use colleges are starting to use so I'm hoping down the road we can actually have almost like a course that we could teach our students like AI in our world talk about some of the basic
061fundamentals and how to use the tools appropriately and I'm going to hand things over to Luke and he's going to talk some about some of the AI tools so I'll just give an introduction the AI tools he's going to talk about we've been doing some PD with our our staff Luke myself where's Danielle Danielle has helped with that um our elementary and secondary Tech Teacher leaders have been helping with that like superintendent conference days talking about it in their PLT so those are the ones that have been helping us with some of the tools you're going to see thanks Dave so yeah Dave stole my thunder because that's what I was going to say um no it's all right so actually we all met um beginning of the school year uh planning for the professional
062development day and um kind of broke up into the focus groups or groups uh we did an elementary group we did a middle school group and then Dave and I and a couple of other teachers broke out into kind of what we would do for staff and so we I'm going to show you a couple of tools that the teachers and and the group picked so again the one that's up on the screen right now is Microsoft co-pilot and again the nice part about it is we're already a Microsoft shop so part of the co-pilot that we have is kind of free to us and um one of the pieces I'm going to point out is it's protected as well it's really hard to see on the screen but up in the upper right corner
063where it says new chat there's a little Shield that shows and so the shield is actually letting everyone know that's using the program that it's actually the data is protected and what that kind of means like Dave said is some of the AI systems when you're interacting with it it's learning from you and what you're typing in uh with the co-pilot component none of the information goes back into the model if that makes sense so all of the data that you're interacting with the with the chatbot is staying with you and so when you close that session down the data is just gone um it's not going back into that large language model so again one of the things we always look for and Dave said is the data privacy and stuff like that so
064Dave and I met uh with some staff members and actually introduced co-pilot and actually walked the staff through um and again some of the prompts up there are pretty basic like you know setting up a meeting today and and again those prompts actually will then ask for more information like what's the meeting about what's the topic how long is the meeting and and it'll give you like the ability to write agendas and stuff like that so that was the first one um going to slide number two so another Tool uh this was the elementary I'm sorry this is the middle school and the high school decided to choose uh a tool called conmigo and again similar to co-pilot and similar to another one we're going to show you in a second um conmigo is actually
065part of um KH Academy that's where it kind of came from and Microsoft and others have put a lot of money into conmigo and so one of the nice Parts is for teachers especially is it's got prean prompts for you as you can see on the screen there's like you would click on an exit ticket and then when you select exit ticket what it's going to ask you is what do you what topic are you discussing and it'll give you an exit ticket idea or question and again there are tons of different promps there's uh IEP assistant which again when you're writing an IEP I'm assuming there's a ton of data inv D in writing that IEP so you would select that and then it's going to ask you for more information so that was
066secondary introduced that uh again during the PD sessions and then um at the elementary level they chose and kind of landed on Magic School and again similar platform where it's giving you a bunch of prean prompts in front of you uh and again one of the feedbacks or what I heard from uh the teachers that presented to their colleagues was about Midway through the screen there's report card comments and they said that was one of the best and most exciting uh prompts that they saw on the uh on the platform so again the day of the PD they were actually using it I think and getting um report card comments so the last tool actually lean and uh Mike actually use and so I'm just going to introduce it real quick and I'm not going
067to steal any of their Thunder um but again this this tool the last three tools I just showed were more staff using them and teachers using them as their own resources this tool actually is the teachers using it with students so that's what's kind of unique about this tool and again I will let them speak to it hi my name is Mike Catz uh I'm the English teacher in the spa program at the high school or an interdisciplinary Project based learning program I'm lean dolin and I'm a social studies teacher in the spa program and we teach ninth and tth grade um collaboratively with our students in the spa program so we have been using class companion as a writing tool which is uh what it is intended to be for students it's student facing
068as opposed to kind of like teacher facing so uh you know chat GPT is a is a reality in high school these days and students are using it and uh there are further sites that they can make it uh uh not recognizable as AI um so uh you know sort of kind of embracing the technology a little bit and kind of helping them with um responsible use I I felt was was something to maybe look into and then see how we can incorporate it into our own lessons in our classroom so part of class companion is uh U us inputting lessons um it looking at the resource materials and uh um looking at our rubrics and um then students actually do a little bit of writing and get some instantaneous feedback uh so it kind
069of not kind of it very much personalizes the feedback that students are getting in real time on demand in class and uh gives them really really great feedback and not answers um and Miss Donan is gonna show you in a second here uh the uh a Student Response here um and an example of a first attempt and then some feedback and a second attempt and the student put in and kind of the Improvement that that went in there yeah so um so in Spa we do both English and history so it's kind of a perfect place to try out a writing assignment with class companion so we've tried a couple different things um but this is really the largest assignment that we've done and this was just really from last week so it's it's fairly
070fresh um but this is an example of a student who's doing an enduring issues essay um this if you don't know is from the global 10 regions these are ninth graders so they're just kind of practicing at this point um and this is a formative assessment so this is something they didn't need to really stress out about we did it in class together and they could ask lots of questions um so it wasn't anything they were getting a final grade on that they needed to really worry about a lot um so for for this assignment we uploaded um the documents which is something you do for an enduring issues essay you put it in documents and then the students need to select three and write about a topic that connects them with an argumentative thesis
071and so they they had the rubric that was in there um the enduring issues rubric kind of matches what the region requirements are um so we used that the one that was in um in class companion and then the students were able to do a couple cool things they could submit for feedback based on the rubric and it would kind of give them a grade um based on the AI generated grade and that it would tell them very specific things that they could do better and they could also talk to ditto who's like the little chat bot in the corner and they can ask ditto questions like um I really need help putting together an introduction sentence I'm not really sure where to start and ditto will talk to them and get them to try
072to come up with stuff without giving them the answer and that's really the brilliant thing about class companion that we love is it doesn't give them the answers it just prompts them to think about what the answer might be so they still have to know the stuff themselves so this student um got this feedback when she first submitted the essay um and so this is some of the things it said they said right now you're going to get a three out of seven according to our rubric um and it was missing some things and so just like highlight a couple things that you see there um in the the third it wants it wants her to make U more of an argument and um discuss how it influenced modern political systems um so she's talking
073in particular if you know anything about history about Alexander the Great and she's trying to make a connection to Conquest So based on the feedback I saw because we can see all the things they change that she added a connection to Germany during World War III and trying to build an Empire which wasn't in her original draft and so she utilized the feedback and then she submitted again and it graded her again and it said you're looking good looks like you've got maybe a seven out of seven there so then she did actually a final one um she did three and then she submitted it in a final place so we have canvas for our final drafts um and so she submitted it to me and then I graded it so what was beautiful about
074this I can't in one this is all done in one class I can't and even with two of us with all our students 20 30 students we cannot give this level of attention to students in one one class block um and what I found was that by the time I graded these like at home when I have time to give them more feedback their level of um their essay level was higher than it would have been like I would have gotten the level one to grade at home had we not used Class companion and instead I'm grading now now three tries up it's so much better um than it originally was so I really think it's a valuable tool for the kids um I think they think it's kind of cool too honestly like I
075I think it's novel at least at this point where they think it's fun to to try it out um and I will I just wanted to add too um that I had one of the students who finished a little bit early and she said can I just see what chat GPT would say so I said actually yes let's see what that would look like just to compare so chat GPT gave her all the answers so it was great feedback but it was too much feedback and we and she agreed she's a great student who did a great job anyway um but we kind of agreed that chat GPT is like getting a perfect paper whereas this is telling you it's leading you rather than giving you the answers so this is really a cool tool
076that we're excited about using so I also want to add in addition to that the ditto companion you know the the chatbot that's in there uh it's like a controlled chatbot that gives them the the opportunity to work out like Hey how do I prompt AI you know as Dave was saying earlier is definitely going to be something that's going to they're going to encounter later in in the workforce it's going to be very important right and it is already so uh I don't know I just think incorporating it just makes so much sense and uh put a a couple more kind of teacher brains in the room sort of so just talking a little bit more about prompting and again keep this moving so that's just a definition for prompt and it's really think
077of a prompt or like a command or request that tells the computer exactly what you wanted to do so and you'll see it there's a lot to it it's that skill of asking the right question so there's a couple infographics I had in the presentation and I'll spend more time on this one probably just go through the other ones pretty quickly so this was a nice infographic that we found that talked about the how to create a good prompt it's going to give you what you want so you look at context what are the specific details you want the AI tool to do that could be embedded in the prompt so be spe specific as you can the role who are you I'm a fourth grade teacher I'm a 12th grade teacher 10th grade teacher
078I'm an Ela teacher so that matters that's going to impact your response who is your audience well it's two fourth grade students it's two ninth grade students again that's going to change the response based on what your audience is um format I want it to be a paragraph I'm looking for it to be a song I want to be an email so those are all things and then task and tone I haven't got the humor part to work very well but you can say I want to be humorist but typically I want to be professional or information is is typically what I go with but that's kind of a nice info graphic in my opinion to help you with creating prompts here's a couple other ones and just real quick the one on the left
079talks about the five S's and again specific um set the scene simplify your language share the feedback and then the one on the right again just another infographic give clear Specific Instructions ask AI to adapt a personal task take on a role um small inputs and outputs number four provide reference material I'll just talk about that one briefly when we did it I don't know I think Dan was part of this as well we did an activity with some of the teachers we were looking at the computer science digital fluence learning standards and we were asking questions I didn't reference the New York State digital uh fluency learning standards so the we were doing it with co-pilot co-pilot actually created its own standards they were they were pretty good so when we started looking at
080them they like wow this is pretty good and then I think someone's like well look they're not the standards so they created new standards so that's why I'm saying you got to be careful with the feedback or the answers that you get it could be wrong in this particular case we didn't you we didn't really reference that we're looking we wanted to to match up or relate to the New York State learning standards this is just and I'm not sure if the link works or not for you folks but this is just a link that we provided to our teachers and again it goes into they call a prompt library and you can see some of those topics that Lucas was talking about whether it's assessments or rubrics and again it just gives our teachers
081ideas about how to prompt for those particular areas so it may give a couple sample prompts and there's like spaces where you can put in specific details uh content level grade level what are you looking for and I'm going to hand things back over so again I I kind of spoke to this um again where strategies kind of we we used this presentation when we did our PD so you know where we thought it could be used again classroom activities collaboration again Dave brought up the whole differentiated instruction which is super helpful uh obviously when you have probably 30 students and each one of them learns differently uh how you can give them different tasks and stuff like that so um and then this is another one that Dave found um uh Alexis Wiggins and
082so the concept is like as an example on line two assessment design so it gives you you know what what the concept or the example is and then over on the right it actually gives you sample prompts again so generate a 10 question quiz on fractions for fifth grades so again it's very specific it's exactly what you're looking for and then even it gives a multiple choice and short answer questions so again as specific as you can be is how you're going to get the best data out of the system so and again Dave's going to talk about ethics uh and so just just kind of enclosing no technology is perfect and with AI there definitely are challenges with it so when ai ai ai has been out for a while as I said but
083kind of Hit the schools maybe two years ago or so that's when we started getting emails and panic phone calls like you better block this Dave uh you know our kids are going to start using this for for inappropriate or cheating so I've lived that with different other Technologies so we you know we we listen we and some things we did block um we've already talked about misinformation um when we do our PDS we talk about everything created in AI needs to be deemed a draft because it doesn't always get it right maybe it doesn't understand what you're saying maybe that large learning model doesn't have the right information it's going to create something but it could be wrong um the biases of the creators again I don't know who who the these teams of
084people are that created some of these large language models what cultures are from what cultures they're not from um you know what what their backgrounds are so there's definitely again draft information the speed of implementation and change um it's hard I actually really enjoy this stuff so I've been reading about it all the time but it's the changing the the large language models are always getting better they're adding new features there's a zillion AI tools that are out there and then Equity as we roll this out we want to make sure that all of our staff anyone that wants to use the AI tools has access to it and then with our students any of our students that want to that we're going to roll it out to want to make sure all students would
085have access to it this is just one example and again I don't take credit for this this is from our world language department at the high school um as I said they've been dealing with Google Translate for many many years so this is kind of a term they've come up with is work on demand um so they were talking about using AI that a lot of their assignments they had the students right in front of them um create an essay create a story develop this right in front during class time and then again if they're using technology they could use something like a lock down browsers there's a way to make it secure so you can't use those AI tools they are looking for in the future to maybe use some of the stuff similar
086to what Lan and Mike showed you know tools that can help our students to improve their work but not do the work for them and that's kind of the end and again another infographic I guess I got too many of those up there but um evaluate verify edit revise and then the last one is you that was also something we talked about was you're responsible for what you you you put out so we had and some of our trainings I think someone said I'm just going to create an AI email and send it to you Mr L like that's great but it's from you so what it says is you are responsible for it because sometimes when it creates emails it doesn't make sense there's tone to it so you got to be careful with
087that so again still responsible draft draft draft got to make it your own got to take some time and go through it but it gives you a frame which I think is a huge part and it really helps our teachers with some of their work and that's it and questions for us questions Beth um thank you for um all of the information that you've presented to us and um I agree I think um AI is not going anywhere and as um an educational organization I think we do have a responsibility to our students um to to help them learn how to use it responsibly and carefully um so um I also think with that um comes a need for teachers you know to receive professional development and also understand the tools I think we're kind
088of at the start of AI there's an awful lot that um we know but there's an awful lot that is to come with this technology and so I I guess I'm I'm wondering do we what kind of professional development is available for our teachers and what kind of support is there in the classroom for teachers who you know I work in education as well so I hear like everybody's cheating some are but not everybody um so you know I just I wonder what kind of support there is for teachers with that so we've done PD at our superintendent conference days our secondary and Elementary technology teacher leaders we've done some AI training with them and they are support folks for the for buildings someone like L and Mike are good res resources for their colleagues
089um if we people that want like Lucas and I to come to a PLT and talk about it we do but there's there's a not a lot I wouldn't say but there's definitely a handful of all the different levels that can help our teachers with AI and we're starting out I totally agree with you I think that's where we're at yeah um thank you for this I especially loved getting to see like the the very specific use of it in the spa program I think that's really amazing um one of my concerns about AI is just the potential loss for human connection um and same thing with cell phone use right like there's a loss of human connection especially when we're all together in a community and so it's really um I guess cool to
090hear how you're using it and it's building on the connection it's not it doesn't sound like it's taking away from it um which is great um I guess I just wanted to bring up that I think that there's a really big ethical concern with AI which is the water consumption of it and so AI is a huge um energy suck and so I did um you know I think that a lot of times when I'm reading about this I'm reading about how if you have a conversation with chat GPT it's using about the equivalent of like a 500 Miller water bottle just to have that conversation with you because the machines that run it are so hot that they have to do an enormous amount of cooling um you know we're using something that I
091think is a lot safer um like I I've done the PD on Magic School and it's it's different than chat gbt like it's it is safer um but I did look up how much um water is being used by Microsoft and so since um since they really started with their generative AI in 2022 their water use has gone up by 34% and so I just think that um like I I want to be a person who Embraces technology and I love how our district does embrace technology but I do think that there are some really really big ethical concerns especially with just like a changing planet and I just I guess wanted to state that um while we're all here together talking about it because it is um a big problem that I think will
092become bigger thank you yes this through some of my research definitely have read that about and that's why typically your companies that can support these large language miles are Google Microsoft to your to your point takes a tremendous amount of resources so definitely something we need to watch oh sorry just wondering if there's a favorite um product that the staff likes or or is it really kind of varied I think what what Luke you want to speak I think what Luke talked about really were some of the favorites we tried to put some tools out but as you know there's a zillion tools and that was part of our strategy like we didn't want to have 16 different tools so we actually did kind of uh with the uh secondary and Elementary Tech Teacher leaders
093and the Librarians went through and they tried some of the different tools and that's kind of where they the secondary kind of went with that K Migo component and the elementary liked magic school which we were fine with we like both of them but that was kind of what they focused on co-pilot is one that we focused on with everyone just because it's kind of when you go right into the Microsoft browser Edge it the tool is right there so we don't have to log in it's easy to use for all staff so that's probably been our been our Focus I'm sure these guys may have other ones and I I think as you use it you find a tool that you like again for us it's got to be data privacy at law 2D
094so that's where we pick these tools as well uh I'm trying to like push down my my concerns about this um I guess my my um my question like for the teachers really is what concerns do you have of our our students having access to AI both in and outside of the classroom and what sort of supports do you need or want to like overcome those concerns so all of the concerns they are definitely using it outside of the classroom and inside of the classroom right um in terms of resources there there are resources out there that you know like PL trism Checkers basically for AI but the you know there's always one step ahead so you can there resources that let you stifle the plagiarism checking AIS right um it's it's tough with writing
095I guess the On Demand work is like a pretty good solution and uh just I don't know like PD for teachers to to help us understand how to even recognize in the first place if there's something going on it's usually kind of obvious all of a sudden students are you know writing in complex sentences with uh beautiful vocabulary like wow where did this come from um than yeah I'll I'll just add I think it's just important to keep having conversations and talk about it and not ignore it because it's part of our world so we have to and maybe to give us uh room to maybe make mistakes or just be flexible um in trying to figure out what the right thing is to do through conversation and everybody's on the same page we all
096I think you know we want the best for our kids and we want them to be good Learners we don't want them to be cheating for sure um but we also want them to be Savvy consumers of information and ready to work in the world that we we have right now um so I I think we've had some really good conversations with our students too I mean they love to talk about it and I I think like bringing up the ethical stuff is great to do with kids they should have be having these conversations they're going to have to deal with them going on um and so that should be happening as well um [Applause] so just want to thank Lanna Mike uh for your support as early adapters and uh working to support our
097kids as they learn to utilize new technology uh and then to Dave and Lucas and to our entire Tech Team for all the the professional development the ongoing support uh that they provide to our teachers and our administrators and support staff uh throughout the district uh throughout the course of the school year so uh wonderful presentation and and thank you for everybody for enlightening us on all things Ai and that's it for presentations all right this brings us to our consent agenda I believe we have some roll call items which we will call out individually and um get motions for and give opportunity for a discussion if if needed so Tony what do we got yes indeed the the only modifications are those three roll calls uh Financial G1 Financial G2 and financial G3 um
098we should do those first right Bobby and then uh so I'll I'll quickly read the summary of what we're we're um having a roll call vote vote on then we have to do each one uh individually so Financial G1 um recommends that the Board of Education adopt the resolution specifying in detail the necessity for the construction of alterations and improvements to District buildings and or sites the resolution in its entirety is attached um and that's the Legacy 2025 Capital project document that you all got so can I get a we need a second and then get a chance to discuss this first right so can I get a second to that motion Natalia and then is there any discussion on this first one okay roll call vote trustee EMA yes truste crackler yes trustee Braxton
099yes trustee bugman yes trustee Colligan yes truste Copans yes trustee lakia yes trustee waoic yes all right uh Financial G2 is uh recommending that the Board of Education approval resolution of the enlarged City School District of the city of Saratoga Springs New York adopted February 13 2025 authorizing the Legacy 2025 Capital project consisting of the construction of alterations and improvements to District buildings Andor sites stating the estimated total cost thereof is not to exceed 142 million $872,000 appropriating set amount therefore including the expenditure of 3.5 million from the capital reserve fund established by voters of the district on May 16th 2017 and the expenditure of 4 million from The District's unassigned fund balance each of such expend expenditures are hereby approved and authorizing the issuance of not to exceed $135 m372 th000 in serial bonds
100of said District to finance the balance of said appropriation the resolution in its entirety is attached for each board member's awareness can I get a second for that one John is there any discussion on that one okay trusty a Mecca yes trusty crackler yes trusty Braxton yes trusty bugman yes trusty kollan yes trusty Copans yes trusty lakia yes trusty toic yes all right so uh Financial G3 the resolution in its entirety is attached for each board member's awareness recommend that the Board of Education approve a resolution of the enlarged City School District of the city of Saratoga Springs New York adopted February 13 2025 directing submission of two Bond propositions at the annual district meeting and election of the qualified voters of said School District um to be held May 20 2025 and prescribing the
101form of such Bond propositions to be inserted in the notice of such annual District meeting and election the resolution in its entirety is attached for each board members awareness can I get a second Beth any discussion on that one okay roll call truste AA yes trusty crackler yes truste Braxton yes yes trusty bugman yes trusty Colligan yes trusty Copans yes trusty lakia yes trusty yovic yes okay so that being finished I move that we approve consent agenda items e f and g as modified can I get a second John um any discussion all in favor okay that's 8 Z thank you thank you for all that reading that ends our business meeting and brings us to our second public comment period if there's anybody wishing to address the board seeing as everyone is very smart
102and went home before the storm um any agenda planning items yes uh I bringing back for the second reading um my proposal that the superintendent and this is I guess for our discussion and approval on this this meeting or is approval next meeting we just have a question okay so the proposal is that the superintendent present three possible ways to adjust or end the flex zones over the next six years uh with projected Effects by the end of the school year so June 2025 and I'm open for comments or amendments is there any discussion yes Matt I think you're asking for the administration to review the flex zone um practice and based on what they learn bring up several potential paths forward yeah yes I mean I the the district has been deal has been
103living with the flex districts for a while so I'm not sure that there's there's I don't know they need to like do additional review of it um but to think about ways it could be adjusted or or following the proposal from the Thea consultant ended over the course of the six years right so so to consider tradeoffs related to different paths forward correct and what are we being what is what are board members besides Matt being asked to do right now just give a majority that wants to ask the superintendent to do that okay before I weigh in on that I just I just wonder if Mike if you have any thoughts on this yeah if um the board members um correctly uh back in the 201819 school year um the board charged the superintendent
104uh with coming up with a system uh that we could balance our enrollment across six elementary schools because um prior to that several years of um board meetings um where uh community members from each of the elementary schools and it kind of rotated the year based on which class size was impacted the most uh and so uh uh in the fall of 2019 and I think trusty bergerman uh was I think the only current member um at the time that served on the actual committee on on the flexone committee so uh so we were charged uh in the spring of 18 to do the work in the fall of 19 uh so we assembled a committee uh probably over 30 stakeholders Community uh stakeholders parents and community members faculty staff Administration uh to develop the
105concept of attendance zones within the school district uh and again had all stakeholders involved um and included uh Transportation as part of the proposal and then in January of 2019 is when the Board of Education adopted the policy to go into effect I'm sorry fall of 19 January 2020 to go into effect fall of 20 and then Co hit um so that first year we it really was not implemented uh as intended so uh so we've really only had the flexone in place now then for the last three years um so we still continue to learn uh each year uh so this would be an opportunity for again based on the board's requests I would like to reconvene that group uh as many members who are still around and then invite new members uh again
106to look at what the original charge of the committee was and then use it as an opportunity to evaluate um progress and then what were some of the intended challenges we knew there was going to be some challenges uh with it uh we knew there would be huge benefits and there has been obviously a tremendous growth when it has come to um class size in in achieving some U uh equity in class siiz targets um but again it it Al say also created some um challenges that we could look to a group of of folks who would be interested in in in reviewing this as to what are some opportunities to make some improvement so that that's how I kind of see is bring that group act invite any other new members who would like
107to learn more about where this started in 2019 and where we can make uh improvements um or again if after that review if this decision or the movement is to getting away from FX zones um I just would be hesitant because I think we return right back to the problem of of where we started uh that was the original ask of the board um to help a address our class siiz issue okay I got Connie and then um natal so Mike I just want to I remember this because I what I remember was a lot of Caroline Street parents coming to a board meeting at one point complaining that they had they had large class sizes or they were cutting a teacher and so like basically when you trade you're trading one problem for another
108so we have to if we're if if the thought of getting rid of the flex zones what we have to be prepared for are parents coming from specific schools complaining that they're losing teachers or their class sizes are too large so um I'm that's a really good idea I think to bring the original committee back because they have that history um to inform the future and you know maybe some tweaking is certainly necessary but um but thanks for looking into that that's a good strategy yeah I agree with doing that I guess my only thing would be I don't know that we need to set a specific number of proposals um so just a friendly Amendment um on that mat I also want to say that I think that a big difference between now and
1092018 2019 is just the number of students in our district it's down significantly um and so I'm wondering if um I guess that can be taken into account too I understand that the goal was to make class sizes more even across the district um but I also think that part of just smaller class sizes I was say my sons in the in the year that was the first year to really have them implemented um he's in third grade now and is in a tiny class which is awesome it's so great it's so great for his teacher I think that's really good but I think it's not I think the flex zones aren't the only Factor so I hope that we would look at you know all of the different factors that are going in but
110I really would like this looked at again um um and I know I'm a broken record on this but there are three elementary school buses that go through my neighborhood so I would love to you know taking into account the transportation issues that we're having maybe to say you know in 2018 2019 um we weren't in this situation that we're in now a lot has changed John um I appreciate I mean Connie rightly points out it's interesting how things are connected number of students in a classroom number of bus drivers uh uh administrative transfers start times all of this is connected and um I I like your plan and I I support your motion I like the idea of three scenarios I I I think it's a very good specific motion and so you know
111the the administration could say leave it the way it is get rid of it or here's two new options but the key is by getting multiple scenarios we're able to explore trade-offs together so I I'm very supportive Matt thank you yeah I was just going to answer Nat like I my I picked three because I I like the number three but I I really want multiple like I'd like more scenarios then keep it the way it is end it completely yes I support multiple scenarios yes Dean thank goodness you didn't go with my favorite number Matt because that's 11 so that would have been more challenging that'll you know I guess the only thing I would say uh two two things I think I'd be supportive of it as well Mike my only concern would
112be does Matt's request for end of the this school year make sense does timing allow for you to put that together especially the way you presented it with grabbing that that group that we had five years ago six years ago you know Gathering those folks back up again and then just to point out Matt to you that most likely even if that does occur the implementation of something like that doesn't occur until the following school year at that point in time because we're we're well down the road into Dave and attendance and all those folks kind of preparing and planning for transportation services and so on for next September so I think two things that I would point out one Mike is that timing okay and two just confirmation that most likely nothing would happen
113until 2627 it depends on how deep the discuss discussion goes and the recommendations for the types of tweaks or changes that are made it's just hard it's too hard to predict you know as to right now but again to I think John's point and your point there are a lot of moving Parts you know we we we're registering Stu new students to the district every week and so we're constantly looking at our enrollment uh so it's not just a beginning of the year even though when a new kindergarten class comes in that kind of sets the stage for building assignment but that enrollment process is on ongoing throughout the year so it would make sense to have a clean start of a new you know incoming class in order to implement any recommended changes um
114but again it it does have far-reaching you know um implications on any changes that that we make so we'll do the best we can to have some recommendations by the end of the year that's all I can say and again we'll have to gather the feedback for the committee and and and see what um what we can do for um any proposed scenarios and just to clarify I think CR crucially like unless the unless the recommendation is let's not change anything I I would anticipate that any roll out would not happen next year or the year like I think this is like a sixy year if it's going to be rolled out it would be rolled out over a six-year period to give parents time to adjust I mean this is not a I I
115do not expect the changes to happen soon but I would like the sort of planning to start so that we can get to that point at the end where we have the the best of all World busing situation well I think the turn around on the first one was pretty quick it was just a few months that the task force did this work and then it went into effect that following September so I think that is I right so I'm just saying but but final transportations okay but correct me if I'm wrong to kindergarten assignments and Transportation aren't finished until August right beginning of August so it's not done already for new for new incoming kindergartens but nonetheless so we're going to June 2025 is the aim I in listening to everybody is qualifying I
116have that we're asking Mike to reconvene that original Flex Zone committee adding some members as necessary review how the flex zones are working per the original charge look at how they might be improved or adjusted and provide at least of three scenarios okay and present to the board by June 2025 um understanding we may need to give some flexibility does that capture everybody's comments and asks okay so um are we all comfortable than asking Mike to to go forward with this okay thanks Mike and Dave in advance and thank you Matt um any other board agenda items yeah I have this I don't know if this is the appropriate time to ask this question so tell me if it isn't but um going back to one of your comments John when we were hearing about
117the cell phone work that was done and this question of is this something that we want to pursue and not wait for the state to provide guidelines or mandates um so I'm just wondering you know is this something that we should as a board talk about and make a decision um ahead of whatever mandate might be coming from the state and I guess I'm raising that as a like I'm not sure how to push that forward um but I do wonder what the process might be sure I think that would be agenda planning but maybe we can hear Do we have any guidelines from MBA or anybody coming to us yet okay just again what was uh written in the executive budget proposal it was an outline and then those conversations are going to happen
118across the state over the next several months and again at the end of the budget development process is when we would expect something to come from near York State School boards Association in the form of our our policy and then I think throughout the spring is having those conversations as information is being more solidified um and again now that the state is involved I I just it's it's great that our high school had started these conversations last year and have done a tremendous amount of work so I think some of the recommended uh processes and procedures we're already ahead of it uh other schools may be just waiting to see what was going to happen so I think a lot of the engagement uh that's taking place already just based on the initiative of the
119high school committee is going to put us in a good position to be ready to go um so I just don't know how at this point getting ahead Head of the State um it there's a pace to it that I think we're going to be in line and we'll be ready to go and when school boards has policies to be able to share as example policies and then there'll be some local decisions that we want to make as to how we want to implement communicate and just you know be ready to go for September in the spirit of what you said Beth it seems to me that we're in good shape we're moving forward forward and if at some point the state backs away from this entirely then I think this board may want to
120revisit whether we want to say no we're going forward without the state but it seems to me we can wait until that time to act does that a as somebody who's passionate about this issue that that it's okay with me and I wonder if it does with others it does yeah absolutely I just I want us I I think it's something that we we just need to continue to be talking about and be mindful thanks mat and I just want to clarify that'll be decided I mean by April 1 or whenever the the budget is passed right cor that's when we'll know like the state's going forward the state's not going forward any other comments about this one that's good so we'll keep it on our radar but not anything particular right now okay good
121good discussion any others all right do we have any board member comments Natalia um I just wanted to acknowledge we have a few donations in our agenda tonight one is from Karen Shanker gold for a digital piano um to Greenfield Elementary one is from Cantina um and one is from Joanne Clark um and so thank you for those donations I also just wanted to recognize the students that presented to us tonight it's um daunting to come I think those are both freshmen um and they were wonderful and I'm just thank you for doing that I think it means a lot more to hear about these things directly from students um alth I appreciate hearing from the teachers as well so uh this is probably the wrong place to say this but I'm GNA use my
122comment for it anyway um I'm very in favor of the capital project going forward um as a neighbor to the softball field I do have some uh concerns and hopes that as we move from a a natural surface there to artificial one that in our planning we we plan for not only the instulation of such a thing but the maintenance of it as well as the ultimate you know removal and disposal of whatever inorganic materials are in are putting on the ground in the soil uh so that we don't end up with a ground field in in in our softwall Sy great any other board member comments okay um at yes he was Voting I have a lot to read first we're not adjourning my friend at this time we will move into executive session
123and anticipate ad Journey directly after and will not take any action in public session um may I get a motion to enter executive session to discuss issues pertaining to negotiations pursu guarding a contract with our upk program John is first natal is second sorry I was looking over that way all in favor thank you