001your all right we'll call to order the regular meeting of the Board of Education of the Saratoga Springs City school district for Thursday January 23 2025 um Bobby could we have a roll call please sure trustee eka truste crackler here trusty Amory here trusty Braxton here trusty Bugan here trusty Colligan here trusty Copans here trusty lakia trusty yovic here student representative Juan student representative PRC thank you will you now join me in reciting the Pledge of Allegiance all right could I have a motion to approve the meeting minutes from January 9th Connie second Deb any discussion all in favor favor raise your hand motion's approved uh that's what do we have seven people 7even Z unanimous uh could I also get a a motion to accept this evening's agenda as presented Dean second Beth any
002discussion all in favor that's also 70 motion carries um this is the time when we normally have public comment I didn't see anyone signed up for public comment is there anyone who didn't realize they had to sign up and wishes to address the board all right moving on brings us to board committee reports uh does anyone have any I I don't think we met since the last meeting um no uh so we go right to uh Casey and Matt student representative reports at Division Street last week fifth graders from across the district visited the high school to practice with the corers students in grades 3 through five participated in a computer-based math simulation this week to practice for the state test that will take place in the spring The Bert team met to discuss and
003start planning for the evacuation relocation and reunification drill that will be happening in the spring at uh Greenfield Elementary the Greenfield HSA will have their annual Bingo night this Friday last week fifth grade students went to see the corers and K through five students are learning gymnastics and PE this month at Dorothy Nolan students in grades K through five are in the midst of taking their winter I ready assessments students in grades 3 through 5 were able to test drive the New York State computer-based Testing they will officially take later this spring it was a great opportunity to get some Kinks worked out ahead of time Olive the therapy dog at Dorothy Nolan visited with the first grade students solved riddles and named trusted adults they can talk to about their feelings uh at Maple
004students completed their I ready of math and reading diagnostic assessment they did an amazing job the Maple Avenue music musical Club proudly announces its production of Matilda featuring 73 talented M middle school students performances will run on January 31st February 1st 7th and 8th at the high school they welcomed the rising nth graders students and families last week and shared about academic programming distinction nominations for the next sshs induction this spring if you know of any graduates for recognition please send in your nomination by January 31st Saratoga Springs High School scho students showcase their talent and passion for poetry at the annual poetry out loud competition on January 9th congratulations to am uzo maniti and Anna Sandu who tied for first place and will advance to the regional competition a special recognition goes to Arisa
005galani the runner up for her outstanding performance thank you does anyone have any questions for Casey and Matt all right thanks very much you two uh brings us to administrative reports Mike take it away all right well good evening everyone um now that uh the governor has released her executive budget uh you'll hear later in the presentation just a a budget development update uh based on the information that we now have uh from the governor's office and so at the same time this kicks off um our legislative work um of working with our local elected officials on the legislative uh budget priorities uh for all school districts within our Bose's region uh so as I've mentioned in the past uh working with our boards of Education uh and superintendents and other advocacy groups uh who
006obviously are uh in support of public education and the incredible efforts of our teachers and administrators working with our students and families our local bosis uh has enacted uh the 2025 legislative and budget priorities for our bosis region and tomorrow morning uh we're going to be hosting a breakfast over at the Meer Center and we've invited all of the elected officials uh in our region uh to be able to participate uh hear from members of our advocacy team uh as well as our students and and faculty members and support staff uh who make up the school districts across our region uh so it's always it's a great event that we host each year uh a great partnership um with our elected officials and so on tonight's agenda uh there's a resolution for our Board of
007Education here in Saratoga Springs uh that will be joining the other 31 school boards across our region uh in adopting the legislative uh priorities that have been um established for this year uh and again just a quick review uh the first uh priority focus on school aid uh including uh the foundation Aid and and obviously supporting uh planning for districts to be able to ensure adequate funding uh and to fully fund the current LA education uh Foundation Aid formula for the current school year uh and again with many of the components that we've talked about in the past as it relates to some of the recommendations that have come from the Rockefeller Institute uh the second priority is continue to support school districts uh and teachers and and professional develop development opportunities and implementing the
008new uh regions Blue Ribbon Commission on the new graduation requirements from across the state uh and so again uh for that uh requires continued investment in programming uh opportunities for professional development um for increasing we've talked about in the past the Bose Aid to allow our students to continue to uh participate in CTE programs and what that funding looks like for reimbursement when it comes to CT teacher salaries um Workforce Development obviously is so critically important uh that school districts like most employers Across the Nation continue to face extreme Workforce challenges so whether it's our teachers bus drivers custodial staff food services staff administrators uh it's in increasingly difficult to fully staff all of our schools and so we want to Advocate obviously for uh requirements of professionals and certifications you know we've talked about
009folks move in from out of state with certifications and again how can the state be continue to be uh flexible and allowing um Educators to Dem demonstrate proficiency through experience as well as continuing to align our tier six retirement benefits more closely to those who are offered tier three and T tier four uh members allowing retirement at age 55 with 30 years of ser uh of of service to school districts and then finally um you know everything around zero emission buses uh that obviously we re recogniz the importance of being part of the process to help reduce emissions in New York State uh but we're working hard obviously to meet uh some challenging requirements uh to be able to complete the transition uh in the time that's been established by the state so again the
010funding streams are critically important uh getting clear guidance and and on financing uh evaluate how vendors are going to be able to keep up with the demand and adapting uh and adopting procedures and guidance for alternatives to help uh school districts uh as they kind of maneuver for through these transitions so uh so like I said our board will be adopting uh the resolution on on our agenda tonight uh and that information then will be signed and then submitted and then shared uh in in joint effort with the other school districts in our region and just one more recognition I want to thank Tony crackler uh on Wednesday morning uh we have an awesome opportunity each year to part participate in the leadership Saratoga program and these are professionals uh again from uh private business
011and industry across our region the program has been in place for many many years and uh both Tony and I participated on a leadership uh panel discussion uh all about school board roles and responsibilities and the work of school districts and superintendents and uh it's just great to have the opportunity to interact with Business Leaders uh throughout the community uh as they learn about leadership opportunities uh in all sectors including uh public education so but I appreciate the time that Tony spent uh in rep representing our Board of Education uh on that panel that's it anyone have any questions for Mike I have a quick one um I I was at two of those uh legislative breakfasts uh but one was online because it was still Coy times and um it was hard to know
012who what the all the the attendees were but in general did the did the legislators salute that do they do they either come themselves or send someone at least high level actually I think they're all coming in person this year so we usually have a great turnout great thanks anybody else all right that uh that brings us to our presentations who's starting first so first up is going to be our annual Staffing uh report as well as our our pre-budget uh Outlook again as I mentioned as the state does now release some additional information so I'm going to turn things over to Hillary Brewer our director of personnel development uh and then she'll be followed up uh with um uh Bobby and Joe GCO I'm G to turn my timer on because I really give
013people a hard time about 20 minutes all right welcome I'm Hillary Brewer director of personnel development this is Michael MTI he's our HR office coordinator um so he'll be be talking a little bit about recruiting and some of the challenges that you know we are experiencing but we are going to kick it off um and start with uh our mission our vision we strive to recruit engage and retain District staff members who will in turn Empower all Learners in an engaging collaborative environment to discover their personal Pathway to the Future um thank you I just want to tell you that my office is coming for first place at our annual Halloween party we've gotten second place two years in a row two years ago we were uh prices right and all those Graphics are thanks
014to Michael sorry uh I know John likes pictures myself Michael Becky Shane Christina duringa our HR uh generalists okay so our office does everything start to finish with employees from onboarding to offboarding everything they might need in the middle um following all the laws and rules of civil service which is for our non-instructional staff and then State education department um there's a lot of nuance to school district HR that we are responsible for um keeping track of tenure and uh teacher certification seniority all the things uh that go on in a school uh for our employees we are in charge of it including attendance which Becky Shane is uh our attendance specialist it takes a lot for almost 1,00 employees to manage their attendance especially if things come up um in people's lives so this
015is what our staffing look looks like overall uh we're at 1, 181.50 30 certified administrators 10 non-certified supervisors 562 certified staff and then 4795 non-certified and the slides will break that down we'll show you what that looks like so for our certificated staff this is everybody that holds a certificate through the New York State education department that is reported to the state um broken down by building your administrators general education and then instructional student support those would be your school sites counselors social workers attendance teacher um and then special education is obviously our special ed teachers but it also includes our speech teachers District OTS pts um and then we have a two chsas a behavioral support specialist and a CSE chair in the special ed realm this is our total certified staff history over
016the years so you can see this year we're down to 562 last year we're at 578 point4 but if some of you recall we had several positions last year in the Years prior that had been Grant funded positions that have now almost all fallen off uh so we are at 562 for certificated staff so non-certificated includes our clerical uh special education AIDS special education Tas we have just a few general education AIDS those are in our high school and middle school libraries for student supervision general education Tas those would be our building Tas at the elementary level and a few in the middle in the high school and then monitors and School nurses we also have um four School nurses out in the private and parochial and I should have mentioned that we have four
017special education teachers out and the private and parul as well that's they're under the district level and then these are the very specific positions the majority of them are at district office that support um the everyday workings of a school district facilities and operations John staff uh we are at 77 a half plus 17 hourly those are our grounds monitors we consider them hourly staff um so we kind of I put them off to the side but you see them here you see them when you enter the buildings you see them outside everywhere um but this is where John's staff is now Food Service staff you'll notice there's not a supervisor listed because Eric bush is actually a capital region Bose's employee but um he's here with us full time we have 12 Cooks amongst
018the eight kit Food Service helpers and then two folks that go back and forth um delivering food between various kitens and doing um pickups and things and then technology staff Dave staff um two supervisors nine it support techs that support the buildings um and then a telecom and electrical technician Ryan Warner does all things phones uh which one person for all the phones in the district if you think about it it's funny um and then one network and server technician and then our transportation staff a little cut off um but we're at a 100 now and you'll know we've been talking obviously about drivers we're at 69 drivers right now we would actually need 76 in order to fill all of our runs and in previous years we would have 76 plus we would have
019what we call unassigned drivers just permanent folks that showed up every day and then they could fill in as substitutes as people are out um so that is where we are at we might actually be down one now I think there might be one resignation on the board of a uh driver but Jerry is actively recruiting showing us all the folks that he's bringing in um so hopefully we'll have a few more joining us every board meeting we're down to two dispatchers and two in routing and then the bus maintenance and bus assistance um really just ride uh the majority of special education buses and this is what we look like year-over-year um I'm running out of space so I did have to take off a year from 17 18 um but you know we
020are as you know and when we sit in our budget meetings we look at every position as it comes up through attrition and we also are evaluating our staff um to see what we need what we may need to add what we may be able to do without and um we are down to 81.5 this year and that is you notice there was a difference of 16 non-instructional staff and then the rest made up on or excuse me instructional staff the rest made up on non-instructional staff a little bit of good news I I'd like to show this to you every year this is our um substitute fill rate so what you see at the top is the particular year in that month that was the number of substitutes that were required and then what
021was our actual fill rate so 1819 1920 we were always in the '90s there were years prior to that that Saratoga was in the hundreds um and as we know as we've gone through the last few years we were very much struggling but 2425 so far we are doing much better than we have in several years 85% fill rate 81 82 80 but I also just want to point out that the number of substitutes from month to month in each year that we've requested is less so is it that we're requesting less subs and we still have the same amount of Subs it's hard to know a Subs because they're perum they're not required to work we're bringing in Subs all the time but obviously it's whether they choose to work that day or not
022but it's encouraging to see and buildings are still making at work and hopefully we'll continue to see uh a positive pattern there so I'm going to just jump into our challenges I'll start at the end with the substitute pools that I just talked about but then also the turnover and the recruitment of non- instru instructional staff we talk about drivers this year we've struggled to keep teacher aids in our special education our self-contained classrooms we've been having a hard time we'll get five applicants we'll get one hired and then we've got to go back out and then we'll lose one over here so it's a constant balance of bringing in the non-instructional folks um if you're on our school email you know postings go out every single day with the postings and and we do
023get applicants but people are you know we don't have a huge pool of applicants for non-instructional and then um jumping over to last year when I presented to you we had several instructional positions that we were not able to fill this school year for 2024 25 we had a late resignation in technology which is the most difficult certification area to find I think there's two three colleges maybe two now in all of New York state that have that program for folks to get technology certified um so we had a a late resignation we went out we recruited two or three times um we ended up we have some flexibility in certain areas considered CT Career and Technical education where there are certificates um on the CTE side which is what you would find at a
024bosis so somebody that has industry EXP experience but not necessarily gone to a teacher prep program can get certified in various ways so we were able to fill that position just for this year we actually only filled it 08 um but we've made it work at the middle school but that individual is not going to stay on with us so that is the one position that technically was vacant um and again we're having conversations because it is so so difficult to find technology teachers so I'm going to turn over to Mike and just let him talk to you a little bit about what he sees out in the recruiting World um so in the recruiting World um what I see is a depth of um instructional candidates um so we'll get candidates who have 10
025years of experience um applying for the same positions that candidates who just graduated are applying for um so if I look at the numbers if I remember the numbers um last year with Elementary education we had over 200 candidates for seven positions and a lot of those candidates are coming from other schools with experience um and they're kind of challenging against the individuals without experience um which also goes with the recruiting of diverse candidates um those challenges go hand inand um the experience plus uh just overall exper no experience plus overall just timing um and in the timing of the recruiting Fair the recruiting fairs tend to happen during the day and candidates are in class uh student teaching during the day um so we don't often see those candidates in our recruiting fairs um
026another thing with the recruiting fear is the timing um tend to overlap so I know for a fact this year um Western New York teacher recruiting day is on the same day as um Mid Hudson recruiting day March 19th um so I got to figure out which one I'm going to but um that's just a challenge within the recruiting of teachers another recruiting challenge within the fairs is that um the teacher recruiting days are set up for the districts to interview candidates and offer them positions on the spot um because of how we interview in our policies we can't do that so I would talk to a candidate for an elementary position just explaining to them what the process is what the timeline would look like and then they would go two tables down to
027a skincity and be offered a job so it's it's weird or it's challenging for for us um and that's something that I don't know if we can fix um but it's something that I've brought up um to the um administrators of the teach including day fairs um to see if they could change something about that um but it's just me so I don't know if anybody else brought up that concern um and then the turnover of uh non-instructional staff um nurses teacher aids um those are harder positions to recruit for as well um I try to recruit for those as well during the um teacher fairs um cuz sometimes most the the the career Affairs are open to all so sometimes different um students come to my table and I explain to them about getting
028into education and through esy program or whatever the case may be to start at the district be a sub teaching assistant teacher Aid bus driver all the things um to at least get into Saratoga and then of course these are all the job fairs that I've been to um or we've been to the CCA job fair um College of St M of course is closed but I believe Sienna is doing a education specific job fair um in late March um also Rochester decided not to do their recruiting Fair this year um so that's something that we won't go to um and then another thing I reached out to Sunni Albany um because they are also having a like a nonprofit government education Fair um and I was kind of told not to come not just
029because they don't have as many candidates that I'm looking for in the education field um so I'm going to reach out to the school of education to see what their pool looks like and how could we um tap into their students and then just like Michael's saying when he sees a problem he brings it up um in terms of AD advocacy we at I am um the president-elect now of the New York State Association of school Personnel administrators so through that work I'm lucky enough to get to sit on different advocacy committees uh we actually meet with the New York State Ed Department of office of teaching which oversees certification quarterly and we meet with the commissioner annually um and that gives us the opportunity from the director of HR assistant soup of HR level
030to let them know here are our challenges and they've been receptive to a lot of them um the reciprocity that Mike spoke about in earlier years earlier Commissioners were not as receptive but Dr Roso was very receptive she actually had that experience coming in so potentially we could see some loosening of the requirements on reciprocity but they have been making some of the changes that we've asked for there's obviously a lot more to be done and then even when you get when someone is about to be certified or going for a second certification or applying for the professional it's just a very difficult process in general that folks don't understand um so we've been advocating for how they might be able to help lessen the burden on folks when they're getting their certificates um and
031same thing with changes Civil Service law is like no other um so we've been getting a few things at the state um that are starting to get a little movement so we're hoping that that side is going to be as um willing to work on things you know the majority of these Civil Service laws were enacted in 19 in the 50s and they just don't really apply anymore but it takes some time to get some movement there um and then just one thing you know Joe will speak about the governor's um budget and update but there was one piece that I pulled from there that I thought was um potentially important that we could utilize an advertise here um and that's that folks going to Community College are supposed to be able to go for
032free if they're going for certain uh programs and they said teaching which would be a great great program where we could tap our AIDS our teaching assistance go do your ass Associates for free and we also have contract language where when they are doing job um specific coursework that they can get reimbursed so if it I I have several teaching assistants that have been reimbursed for their masters to become certified teachers but oftentimes what I see is a lot of folks don't even have an Associates yet so that's like a barrier um so potentially that could be something that we can use moving forward um and then I always just want to plug our baby schoolfront that has um in addition to board dos that has made our office so much more efficient but schoolfront
033is just such an efficient platform it's from recruiting straight through onboarding um we have a paper-free onboarding process for our staff which makes it so much easier they can do it from the comfort of their home um and then we're really using it to communicate with our staff um so there's an online portal that they can go into and name changes and address changes and we're starting to send out you know all the things that we would send to our employees that would used to have to be um filed into paper files it's all electronic and it goes into their um electronic personnel file and we're still um there's still more that we can do with it and we're still working on it but it is a great system and it's really what's allowed us
034to get Michael out of the office to do the recruiting so so thankful to have it questions for Mike and I comments or questions mattk thank you so much for that it sounds incredible I the question for I guess following up with Michael the the policy that prevents you from hiring immediately is that a a board policy that we can fix or is it it's our intern i turn it off it's our internal practice we have a hiring plan and we have steps along the way the the real Crux is you know a principal wants to be able to make sure that they're hiring the candidates they also want and I can't take eight principles or even you so it's just how we interview here we can't take them out on the spot so it's
035not our fault John thank you for the presentation I can't hear John as a sentence that is rarely said um I want to ask about if there's a process for communicating with people who leave our employment and um what is that process and uh do we have a do we have a hand other than sort of people aging out and retiring or involuntarily being asked to leave um um what do we learn from those processes and I know there's different categories yeah so twofold and that's I wish I had a system that could track just education systems are not set up very well to track when people are leaving and how long they were here it's I'm sure in the business world there's all sorts of analytics that we could get that we don't have
036here but we do have um a staff exit interview survey and we've automated that now so as an offboarding task once they've been board appointed to resign or retire it gets sent to them through uh schoolfront and it's a a digital form it's a Microsoft Office form and it comes to me um and so then I review them and it Al it's this a set um group of questions that everybody answers and then also offers them the ability like hey do you want to talk to Dr Brewer about that so if somebody wants to talk to me further then I see that and I can give them a call just kind of get some information so it's a lot of qualitative data you know we've looked at it um in our leadership meetings just to
037see what people are saying you know we get a lot of I'm retiring thank you so much and we do get some this wasn't for me and here's the reason why so you know we definitely look at it but to be able to solve every reason every person is leaving it's not an end all yeah John um based on what you learn from that and and this might be a question also for Mike does that information ever get channeled to our team that negotiates with the unions well yes because the team is Mike myself um Lisa Mike saying Bobby okay thank you I have a quick followup it it's kind of relates to to Matt's question um and it um comes out of Mike's comment your comment Mike about um the dynamic when you know
038we've got 200 teachers applying for a an elementary spot and um experience tending to rise to the top I I mean I don't bring this up because I I'm against experiencing experience rising to the top in in many metrics I mean it it naturally does right in a in a uh a job search um there's there's very little that that um you know can beat it uh in certain instances but I'm wondering we've talked about this uh in many different areas uh including at at this table and in um subcommittee meetings um but when we're trying to uh sort of further the grow your own type concept and when we're trying to uh I I would I would assume we're we're trying to play our part in um bucking the trend of the teachers in
039New York state Rising every year and you know to further the goal of getting younger teachers uh who might have a longer Horizon and and uh getting them in here is I guess is there any s or policy or contract um language that says you know experience has to has to win out in X number of cases or is is that just an organic organically they're presenting better because they're experienced and so especially in the elementary pool where we get all of those candidates this is I don't know why can't work this today is this working okay um this is where our hiring plan does help us because at the elementary level we have six principles and we have a process where we review those 200 applicants and you look at every resume and every
040we cover letter and we try to give as many people as we can a shot so we do the first round Zoom interview I want to say from those 200 in the first round last go around we saw 90 and then what we do is communicate with those other folks and typically the ones that are not getting an interview are because they didn't have any any experience at the elementary level haven't even done any subbing and there just wasn't anything on their resume that stood out versus you know this person told us in their cover letter that they loved education they've been student you know been going into classroom since this and they do all these things they have all these activities so it is a judgment call at times in the room when you're
041pulling people to interview and then other pools we get 10 applicants we interview every single one of them so and then in the interview process yes it does tend to shake out with experience but that's not to say always um you know we have hired some Elementary folks right out of school but it's less than Norm we typically get our elementary teachers that have a year two maybe three but we like to keep in touch with all the folks that applied because we'll say Hey listen we don't have a probationary spot for you right now but I might have a leave six weeks 12 weeks it turns into and that's how they get their foot in the door uh for a leave position and then to get that experience thank you John your last question
042well I want to comment on your question and then I'll have another question um at the nisba convention there were a couple really bright superintendents who have been doing doctoral work on Recruitment and Retention respectively and the re some of the research with recruitment says that one of the main priorities for for experienced teachers seeking employment is uh the step equivalency counting as many years as you have experience on your new contract and I just I just want to say that out loud I think that's really important uh in the analytical evidence um if I can ask one more question I will go ahead uh I think we've had this slow decline in our student body we've lost maybe about a thousand students over the last decade and I believe that our Workforce is declining
043but not at the same rate which means that um we're not losing teachers to attrition at the same rate that we're losing students and I think part of that is because of the complexity of special needs special ed mental health but I wonder if you can sort of clarify if you're able to on the spot the 30,000 foot view where is the place where we are sort of retaining or adding back lines relative to the loss in student body does that make sense yeah I mean I think over the years you know 10 years ago we didn't even have social workers so we have been adding positions like that and then you look across and see you know maybe we need more supports here we've added a school counselor we've needed more Behavior Specialists um
044while we're down teacher aids we've actually increased teaching assistance for more student support so it is more about the student support um I think you'll see now of course transportation is down but that's not because we want it to be down um but I think anecdotally it is we're adding student support thanks very [Applause] much good evening trustees oh I'm sorry Mike um so my name's Joe Greco director of budget and program integration Bobby es I know you know him um my doctorate is actually in teacher Recruitment and Retention not that you asking but figure I'd put it out there anyway um so for our pre-budget Outlook it's still somewhat early um so you know we'll kind of go through some of the things that we heard from the governor um some preliminary numbers get
045you kind of prepped for what you're going to be seeing as we move into the end of February March April we spending a lot of time together uh so you've seen this before so we kind of get a reference point we're here at the end of January uh we've been very busy November December January lead leading up to this so really now what we're starting to take a look at as you see coming up is our budget priorities establishing those um which we've been working in our leadership groups on and then of course the state aid figures which uh we have some numbers from the governor we're still waiting as the process continues over this next month but Bobby will be talking about that and then of course the budget workshops where we'll be talking
046at every board meeting and then in between those board meetings at those board workshops uh so we had talked about about this back in I believe October November just to kind of get a sense of how did does this budget process work uh we always usually start with our current budget and then what does it actually cost us to do the exact same thing we did this year next year so there's contractual obligations um if you remember from when we talked about this in October November about 76% of our budget is salary and benefits so we have a general sense of we know that the individuals that we have that are on contract we know about what those increases are going to be we have a general sense of what those benefits are going to
047be so we can start to kind of bring this into a closer picture as we get a little bit closer to these other pieces and then we start looking at budget priorities so at this point we start to look at positions that we have maybe there's some retirements that are open and then we start to look critically at each one of those positions say well is this something that we absolutely need to replace is this something that we might abolish that position and uh change it over to a different position depending on what our new needs are moving forward or is this a position that we might be able to do without uh giv our reduction in enrollment so as we start to shape up our budget priorities uh the next thing that we start
048to look at is revenue as this becomes a little bit more in Focus um and I think Tony you might have brought this up this graphic last time with well why is there only one of those blocks for state aid so I know we talk a lot about state aid and the importance of it but but in reality it makes up about 25% of our total revenue piter the other 75% is coming from our local tax levy um so we get squeezed on one end as far as how much state aid we receive and we get squeezed on the other end on how much we could Levy in taxes so we're kind of boxed in here but ultimately this is what really drives what our budget is how much money is coming in and then
049we kind of build a balanced budget off of that once we get these numbers sharpened up then that's really when we start talking in March and in April of really getting into those budget modifications tightening our belt making sure we can come out with a balanced budget and then finally we have those late conversations about the use of fund balance and reserves uh to shore up that budget which then leads us to the proposed budget that we put out to our voters so the Governor State of the State so January 14th uh she gave her presentation and then after that uh this past Tuesday released the entire budget so we can kind of get a better sense of of what was related to that speech so just a couple highlights I wanted to talk about
050um the first one in there is the community eligibility program or C um also referred to as the universal free meals so this was a big charge for her uh this was fantastic news from our perspective um basically saying that all of our students regardless of income across the state would be eligible to receive breakfast and lunch at no charge uh so that's a tremendous piece in there um and if she's talking about it in her budget now that's pretty much a guarantee moving forward so we're super excited about that um the other piece in here increase funding for Early College Programs this one's a little bit of devil in the details while there is money that's allocated towards this it's not very clear on who is eligible or where this money is going to
051be directed to um so they're talking about Early College Programs uh Pathways for technology Early College so that the ptech but again I'm not sure if that's going to get directed towards individual bosies if it's going to schools so again more information to come on that for sure and then this last one which is uh pretty important for all of us here uh this is related to the cell phone or no distraction policy uh so according to her budget we would have to all districts by August would be adopting a policy that would be banning electronic devices that have capability of going out to the internet we would be banning these devices during the school day so the school day is a important distinction this is not Banning them during class time this is Banning
052during the school day which is Bell to Bell so when it's on campus that is considered the school day um so that means that we they would not have access to them in the cafeteria or study halls in the hallways um and the other piece in here it's the Banning and the storage or storage of see the panic over here they're like we're leaving doesn't matter um but the other piece in here is the secured storage of um so I know we've talked about in other schools have talked about the Yonder pouches or some other security um right in the budget itself it does uh recommend lockers or acknowledges that lockers are a sufficient way of storing uh electronic devices during the school day and we have ample supply of lockers here uh so this
053may not have a budgetary impact on us uh but certainly something that we're keeping a close eye on uh additionally with this schools are also required to not only have the policy and and secure the devices uh but schools are also required to report on the enforcement of this policy um and then on a yearly basis report out if there was disciplinary action based on these devices and uh provide also demographic information on those disciplinary action so again something like that might not be a financial impact but certainly a Time impact on our buildings things that are not mentioned and just because it's not mentioned doesn't mean it's not going to happen but I still am keeping an eye on this uh one of the first ones in here is pretty important is the extension
054of earnings limit for public sector retirees so right now I think the limit is $35,000 um that retirees would not be able to earn above that so after covid um they put basically this moratorium on that and allowed retirees to come out of retirement and then F hard to fill teaching positions and earn that salary without impacting their retirement right now that is set to sunset on June 30th and there's been no talk of reupping that so again it's something we want to just kind of keep an eye on that could have an impact on us for our recruitment efforts um pre kindergarten programs again nothing was mentioned here on changing allocations or per pupil allocations and then finally the EV bus mandate there was no change or modification to that timeline so as it
055stands it looks like that timeline is continuing unless we hear otherwise um just for as we push this big boulder up in icy Hill um the budget drivers obviously a state aid is one of our major ones and Bob's going to talk about that in a second but like I mentioned before 75 76% of of our expenditure is on benefits and salaries so health insurance ERS TRS contract negotiations those make up a huge portion of the actual expenses in our budget uh the other pieces in here again they're still budget drivers things that we want to keep an eye on increasing cost of bosies or Career and Technical education program special ed uh any of these mandates that come out that might be unfunded um and of course like I mentioned retirements breakage open positions
056any opportunity that we have to take a look at those positions critically and make sure that we're kind of getting the the the right people the right spots of the right times uh so we always look at each one of those openings uh whether or not it's something we need to move forward with so with that uh I know we want to concentrate a little bit on state aid um and what we heard from the governor so Bobby will talk about that all right um so right off the bat I will say we are starting this year's budget development process in a much different place um compared to where we started last year I know when uh Governor hok came out with her budget proposal last year um a lot of the discussion was uh
057the transition adjustment that basically was going to as most of you know step districts off of the foundation Aid amount that they were receiving to essentially kind of right size US based on um the loss of enrollment trends that districts have pretty much seen throughout the State um this one positive development was um really unlike that one um and you'll be able to see that here through looking at that Top Line of foundation Aid uh in 2425 of 2489 million and you'll notice as you work across to 2526 you're going to see 2539 so that right right off the bat is a positive development we see a 2% increase year-over year now you might wonder why do I see a local deduct for uh 41,7 69 and 2425 and then 173 278 in 2526 um
058if you remember back to the to the spring during our 2425 budget development cycle um I showed you what you'll see here is uh underneath the state aid run so this is actually our current year state aid run and that Top Line on that state aid run you see our um our foundation Aid amount do we have a laser pointer here well anyway you'll see 24.8 n on that that document there um and then you'll see the red box outlining a uh deduct for local share of Education um costs for certain students so essentially what happens is throughout any given school year if you have some um incarcerated youth or particular homeless students who are part of your student student population um they automatically take the cost of educating those students right off the the
059top of your foundation Aid that they provide you so last year going through the budget development cycle uh the aid run at that point in time showed a deduct for 2324 of 41769 so we thought it would be prudent to build in that current year deduct and assume it continues in this year 2425 so we did did that and we have a budgeted net Foundation Aid amount for the current year 2425 of 24, 857 so I track state aid and what we're projected to receive on a monthly basis so I was looking at this on the 22nd what was that yesterday and uh so I say well this year's state aid run is definitely higher than where we were um so I thought let's continue the same uh philosophy let's be prudent and plan for
060an identical deduct next year in 2526 because as we can see based on our current year State a run we have a takeback of $173,000 so unfortunately the local deduct as a result of that one line um does does increase by 131 uh, which is a negative for us um which essentially leaves us in a year-to-year situation of not seeing a 2% increase according to this proposal but rather a 1.47% year-over-year increase now if I track this and you know towards the end of the year in June that amount decreases a little bit in terms of the the local deduct then we'll reflect that in our plans for 25 26 to hopefully have a smaller deduct which would then increase our projected Foundation aid for 25 26 but I'm always a proponent of budgeting as
061close to actual um our Revenue side as possible so I always like to take into account any potential deduct that I know exists on any state aid run that we see and just some other Foundation aid changes um and I know most of us are now aware of the Rockefeller Institute recommendations um they did not touch on most of those recommendations but there were um a couple nuggets that kind of made its way into the governor's proposal so right off the bat like we've talked about there's a due minimum increase which I know last year I said the due minimum days are Beyond us well I I am giving up predicting on what the direction of the state is going to be from here on out um they are proposing to replace the census 2000
062poverty data with the small area income and poverty estimate data which is one of the recommendations from the Rockefeller study so that's a positive development we're not using uh 24 25 year old data at this point in time um they also proposed replacing the free and reduced price lunch data with economically disadvantaged data this is another positive because now with c and you know our district specifically having 100% Universal free meals it becomes very difficult to actually figure out who is actually eligible for free and reduced price launch based on those um income thresholds um because right now to be essentially just directly certified means that you receive um a public benefit in the form of snap or Medicaid and we know that is not reflective of all people who might be um experiencing economic
063hardship and then they also proposed modifying one of the four Foundation eight State sharing ratio tiers and increasing that maximum State sharing ratio from uh 91 to 93% so positive developments here um just right off the bat like I said compared to last year this is a much better starting place to kind of you know kick off budget development season so quickly just want to walk through this 2425 on the Le hand side totaling $ 36.9 million this represents our current year budgeted state aid so what we expected to receive when we developed the budget last year 2526 essentially represents what the governor produced on her state aid run like I talked about that Foundation Aid even though we know it's a due minimum increase of 2% we locally take into account that local deduct
064cost of educating certain students and that's why you see the 1.47% year-to-year increase um everything else is pretty straightforward and expected based on what we see on an annual basis I will call your attention to building a because this is something that we'll talk about tonight and then we will also be piggybacking and talking about in part of the capital project presentation so you'll notice a 1.3 mli million doll decrease uh to building Aid year-over-year I can tell you right off the bat I do not expect that to actually come to fruition what happens with the state and the way that they actually produce their building a figures they spit out numbers based on what they know is true today so basically what has been filed with State Ed and what's been approved and finished
065and then basically they will just produce a number and spit out how much you're Due based on what you've already filed to be um complete with their office last year if you're looking at the 2425 um the budget proposal for building Aid was lower than that $3.1 million we talked about the same thing we knew that we we were anticipating filing final cost reports because of our ongoing Capital Project work so instead when we put the budget together we' revised the legislative proposal of building Aid upwards because the legislature doesn't know that we anticipate filing final cost reports by June of this year which will then increase our building Aid that we receive so we know that and that's why it's so important to hold the meetings and have the collaboration that we have because
066these things are very sensitive and you'll be able to see as I work through this how big of an impact this could be on an annual budget so just to kind of revisit where we are this year because it's important to know where we are currently um our actual state aid compared to our budget is is expected to be 36 .2 million instead of the 36.9 which really isn't the end of the world um last year at this time our difference was actually greater than that 724 th000 so this this is not the end of the world and it's okay what you'll see is if we're comparing this year's state aid of 36.2 million to the governor's run there's a little bit of a difference but again it's not the end of the world why
067because we know that building aid number reflected in the the governor's state aid proposal is understated we need to adjust that so if we're doing a building Aid reconciliation like I showed and so now call your attention to the Box on the lower right hand side that number that was in red representing the governor's executive run a building Aid was $1.8 Million we know that we're in the middle of our Legacy uh 2020 referendum right now project work we know we have to file final cost reports and are expected to file final cost reports by June 30th of this year when we do that that's going to generate an additional $2.5 million of building Aid that's not reflected in the governor's proposal and then if we're looking out based on our projections next year the
068work that we're doing through the 2526 school year we know that we also anticipate filing final cost reports by June 30th of 26 which will also generate building Aid in the form of a million a million dollar so our revised building a total will actually be 5.36 million and not the 1.8 million that the governor showed in her executive budget run so if we're comparing now our total state aid on a year-to-year basis you're not going to see a slight decrease you're going to see a 5.44% increase or just over a little over $2 million which again this is a very positive development compared to where we were last year so just year over-year in terms of comparing to our actuals to what the governor's run with our revised building aid number we're looking at
069an increase of roughly $2.7 million so just running down like we do every year our Reserve balances and our certain categories so first line is our capital Reserve that was approved in 2017 so this Reserve currently has um just a little over 3.8 million and essentially it was a balance of 3.5 million from the expected Reserve contributions that have been made over the years but we've also because of the positive interest rate environment have been able to earn additional interest on that so that's why we have 3.5 plus some interest earn representing $3.8 million we also anticipate um asking the voters to create a capital reserve for future projects um not the project that um is being proposed and talked about for May of this year um because in talking with our bond Council and
070Auditors um we would not actually be able to utilize any capital reserve that's created this may for that project so this capital reserve reflected under the 2425 column um would really be for future project projects Beyond um approved after July 1st of 2025 and then we have a retirement contribution Reserve um and that is essentially um for all of our Employee Retirement System um non-certificated people we have a retirement contribution subf fund Reserve which represents all of our certified people who are members of the teachers retirement system and those two reserves are specifically um there to be able to help pay down those liabilities due to the Retirement Systems on an annual basis um we have the employee benefit acred liability Reserve um the reserve for tax ciary which essentially represents all the um claims
071that we have out there that we could be on the hook for um and then workers comp Reserve this one and I've gone over this with the finance committee this is a slight change from the past in that this year we became members of Perma which is a Statewide um um workers comp uh organization and essentially they were able to do an Actuarial study to place a value on all claims prior to July 1st of 2024 so basically all claims that were on the books of when we were self-insured and that 1.79 million represents that the amount of the value for the all those claims of which we would be solely on the hook for so that's really reflective of what that workers compres Reserve is for the 1.79 and then we have a legally
072established repair Reserve but we have never taken action to actually fund that Reserve so at some point in the future I'm sure we're going to take a close look to figure out how much if anything do we need to just put in that repair Reserve to you know we know that the Legacy projects that we've had and been experiencing over the last few years they're they're timely they're drawn out and we might have needs that need to be addressed in more immediate fashion that would give us that ability if we had a a reserve funded in that nature and then an insurance Reserve essentially that's just there um just in case um so again last year we had a predicted amount of 19 uh m279 the estimate from the fund balance plan was uh 20.3
073so there was just a slight difference of about a million and a half and if our plans come to fruition and we have the approval of a capital reserve in May which we would be able to fund 6 million we'll have total Reserve balances of $28.6 million and just looking at the different categories of fund balance so school districts primarily have these four classifications of fund balance the one that we generally hear about is that unrestricted fund balance that's the one where were limited by section 1318 of real property tax law we cannot carry or should not carry is the recommendation more than 4% of your subsequent year budget in that line um what I can tell you is we're we're pretty high at June 30 of 24 but we're making very conscious and calculated
074plans to put money in areas where we know we're going to give it back to the taxpayer um and hopefully we'll be able to get that number to a more reasonable able level and really I'm targeting less than a 10% unrestricted fund balance so that's that's the ultimate goal the nice thing is you can see an increase from year to year from about 49.3 to 52.9 um so it does mean that our fund balances are increasing but we're utilizing that fund balance um you know this is one of those things where $4 million of that fund balance will be uh committed to a future Capital project that we're bringing up in May so this is just something that we talk about on an annual basis the board approves our fund balance and Reserve plan on
075an annual basis and it's something that we have to I know you already approved it but there's been some revisions based on the conversations we've been having as a result of our upcoming Legacy vote and so that those revisions will be reflected on the February 13th agenda so just kind of looking at our expenditures uh to fund equity ratio and you'll notice we're at 3.51 so basically this means for every three a half dollars spent we have $1 of fund equity and then we like to compare to peer groups so we list some other districts who are either similar in size or Geographic neighbors and you can see um we're we're in a positive environment compared to most of our peers and we obtain this information right from um open book New York so this
076is just a little history of our assigned fund balance and reserves um specifically this is the amount every year that we um appropriate towards the budget so pretty consistent I know last year we had the conversation of do we bite the bullet and make the decision to just make the difference the Gap go away and appropriate it through fund balance the decision was yet yes um you know retro in retrospect wasn't a bad decision because we're now you know looking at a positive um hopefully continuing to be positive budget development cycle so this is really just a summary slide to let you know where we've been um and what's happening this year and then just to really give a quick overview of the tax levy history you can see over seven years we've averaged just
077over 3% increase um and then each bar represents the total dollar value of our uh School tax levy for those specific years and finally we'll have a uh another school bus Bond proposition on the ballot um this one we would be acquiring 13 vehicles um eight 70 passenger buses um 2 64 passenger buses with a wheelchair lift um and then we're also uh anticipating a re iring two suburbans for facility use um the just some of the facility vehicles that we have are kind of getting in tired conditions we want to make sure that you know the folks that we have here they're working in safe and uh up to upto-date um Vehicles so we thought that that that was important and then also just an additional Suburban for student transport reasons um the total
078cost is anticipated to be a little over 2 million uh 60,000 at 2,65 and then when we're looking at our transportation Aid ratio um unfortunately it's decreased year to year so we're almost actually at the floor of where the transportation Aid ratio could be um which is basically 40% so essentially we would be able to receive 40% of that 2,65 th000 back through Transportation Aid which would leave an estimated local share of $1.2 million and then we receive Aid back on those Vehicles over a 5year period period so the annual local share cost would then be about $246,000 a year and finally just some open items um obviously the governor's come out with her run we have to go through the you know legislative budget process see what the assembly and the Senate do I'm
079sure they'll work through all of those things and then essentially produce a final state aid amount um still TBD on the property tax levy um just a couple variables that are still yet to be ironed out that we're looking at any bosei service requests are um you know still incoming and we're going to analyze those as they come in any staffing needs and projections is obviously going to be a big thing um program supports and reviews is also an essential item throughout this process and then as is curriculum uh renewal and as you'll hear in the next presentation Capital planning so just some important dates um most importantly being May 20th the budget and capital project vote um so any questions questions or comments for the gentleman Matt Matt uh what is a for our
080budget what is a 4% unrestricted fund balance I don't know off the top of my head I'm sorry that's okay sorry well we're at you were saying we were at like 20% it was around that yeah was pretty high any other questions or comments I have a quick question uh why why has our transportation Aid share decreased to around 40 what's what what what are the fat metrics that are involved in that there's there's the wealth measures that we've talked about over the course of time those are factored into the transportation Aid formula um it's just frustrating from my perspective because I know you know we're the big biggest District geographically around here and uh we we truly do receive the least amount of Transportation Aid uh compared to any other District around us and
081even going through all the transportation analysis um that we've recently gone through um the lowest I've seen has been in the 60s so it it's a big disparity thanks Deb I'm sorry thanks yeah no that was impressive slightly overwhelming presentation but very helpful um I was curious about the policy Banning devices um and it sounded like any device that connects to the Internet so does that obviously it's aimed at cell phone and social media use um which sounds like a good idea but does it also ban like uh laptop devices so there are exceptions that are built into her budget that said if they the exceptions would be if the student needed that device for instructional reasons so it was okayed by a teacher um if there was uh an IEP for a student that
082needed for translation services or or other needs so there are exceptions that are built into it but I think the blanket is that if there devices whether it be SmartWatches phones anything that could get on the internet and be distracting to the educational process that is not okay by the teacher that would have to go in a locker great thanks John what's the chance that's absolutely going to happen do we know do we even know like she she's bringing to the she's bringing legislation right and then the the legislature has to act on it to move it forward is that fair I don't want to guess but I I think it's pretty high yep Beth as a followup to that do we think this might happen if it if it goes through for next year
083that's that's I think the date is August 1st okay W all right thank you gentlemen thank you [Applause] all right Joe so just for a just brief introduction uh to our uh next presentation uh as the board has uh been engaged obviously over the last several years uh in our current uh Legacy project uh over the last year and a half or so uh we've been engaged with our community uh Legacy referendum Advisory Group uh represented by over 40 stakeholders from across our community who presented to the board back in November uh with their recommend ations for legacy 2025 project so the last uh few months the board has been engaged in conversations with our Capital uh project team uh in reviewing the proposed scope as well as the timeline and the phasing of the
084project uh and so tonight we just we're going to quickly go through uh those again um and then obviously get into the conversations that Bobby had been referencing uh for the cost projections and then our long range financing plan plans uh so tonight's our last formal presentation to the board uh opportunity to answer any questions that the bo the board uh may have uh as it is for the preparation anticipation of what the board will be voting on at our next meeting which is February 13th uh and that's then to appr approve the formal resolution uh to move forward with the Legacy 2025 project and then again over the next 5 months uh it will be the responsibility of our district team working with uh our Architects and and the project team uh to get
085out into the community there'll be multiple presentations and opportunities for the community to learn more about the project uh which that Capital project proposition has been scheduled to be included in our May uh 20 vote so I'm going to turn over to the bill and Matt um and then again just to go over uh quickly this the scope and the timeline and then Bobby will get into uh our financing plan thanks Mike uh so really the presentation we're going to go through tonight is very similar uh with two changes from the one we did in December one we've changed the nomenclature and we'll we'll show you that as we go through the timeline we used to refer to it as Legacy 1 Legacy Phase 2 Legacy phase 3 we kind of changed that nomenclature because
086we thought it would be easier for the public really to follow instead of following all these different phases because we have sub phases with within each project so we're going to go really to a timeline reference so phase one was Great Outdoors that would be May 2018 current project would be December 2020 future project would be May 2025 so you'll see different references as we go through the proposals so we've taken the phases out and replaced them with dates that's one change the other change is obviously for Bobby and he's going to go through the financing other than that it's pretty much the same presentation so Pathways vision statement uh I think everyone knows what this is we went over it last time so we're going to go through here and here's kind of where
087we see our first nomenclature um we kicked this off in 2016 as far as the Legacy process and the Legacy projects so you know we've been at this eight years we have plenty more to go um but you'll see the first and the third step we referred to our May 2018 referendum approved by the voters moving forward the pathways vision statement then up to December 20 was really our next referendum committee for the vote in December of 2020 for our current project of roughly $130 million presentation um in October was from our May 2025 committee leading to our May 2025 vote so quick updates from from our current project the December 2020 here's a status slide of really where we are in the eight phases that is part of December 2020 you can see we're
088you know up through phase four with construction with that 60% complete everything before that's 100% complete uh we're working this summer in two different phases five and six and 7 we will be starting and we'll be bidding that in the fall starting construction in 26 and actually starting our last design phase this summer or this spring so it's been a quick ride since 202 um the past four years we've got a lot of work done um and the project is going along well again just another 50,000 foot level of where we are in the uh in the process design 75% complete we've got one phase left construction we're about halfway through and everything is uh on time so far couple slides of uh pictures from successful projects as we've gone through the phases I'm not
089going to go through each individual picture but these are pictures we went through in December uh these are the security vestibules in the Bus Loop down at Greenfield again some more classrooms and the furniture we've been buying for each one of our Renovations security vestibules kitchens roofs uh division was a very large roof project uh was completed last summer and some of the features here at the high school that the new cafeteria Fitness room uh that have been completed Transportation uh new bus wash and new bus lift and I'm going to hand it over to Matt he's going to go through the scope of work for May 2025 yeah sure so as you saw from December here's the diagram that we put together kind of uh prioritizing all the scope items and who we worked
090with between the building condition survey the lra committee um John tener's facilities group uh and the leadership team here at the district um we broke it up into three buckets of the scope from building improvements educational program and safety uh building improvements roof reconstruction basically tearing off uh roofs that have been uh no longer under warranty um to uh hva HVAC system Replacements um to make more energy efficient uh systems uh move in educational program classroom Renovations at the elementary school we'll be uh renovating six classrooms each and then middle school and high school we'll be doing renovations of 12 classrooms each full finishes HVAC ceilings and Floors uh that kind of thing and then uh throughout the the um Elementary School we'll be looking at Auditorium upgrades sound systems and AV Equipment systems um
091moving to the safety items we'd be looking at doing some ADA compliance where as I get into some of the other scope items upgrading some uh toilet rooms and stuff and then uh elevator refur refurbishments and uh a number of the buildings so moving to the high school quickly uh just kind to hit the key elements here for scope uh one of the major uh Renovations you'll see is the auditorium we'll be doing a full renovation on the auditorium uh we'll be looking at doing a softball field Improvement where we'll be doing a Turf infield and then uh we'll be resurfacing the track uh around the main football field um bringing that up um moving on um again just Auditorium this is the second floor of the high school um Auditorium Renovations and some of
092the other improvements shown um like I said we'll be doing roof improvements throughout all the buildings as we go through each floor plans are the highlighted areas uh the other highlighted areas are the mansard roofs at the high school that will'll be reconstructing um at the Middle School uh the main points here main Renovations we're looking to be doing uh noise reduction uh at the cafeterias uh trying to improve sound there and then uh one of the big ones are toilet room Renovations uh renovating a couple gang bathrooms in there doing a full gut Renovations there um moving to the second floor of maple AV uh looking at doing some removals and some Replacements of skylights throughout the building and again this is the biggest building that we'll be doing roof replacement um mve into
093Caroline Street uh some of the major besides renovating classrooms we'll be looking at uh some of the other classrooms that we have not touched upgrading the casework which is Cabinetry and base cabinets uh in those classrooms and then uh replacing HVAC systems in the main office and upgrading those um as you see here Caroline we got a few roofs left to do we're we're actually re renovating some of those uh this this summer in the uh phase four project moveing division very similar scope same building uh as uh Caroline we're looking at besid classroom Renovations looking at casework renovations to some of the classrooms that are not getting fully renovated and then also here we're looking at um HVAC uh at the main office area and um the uh Library area for rooftop Replacements again
094here we just finished a bunch of roofing at Division Street we just have the canopy roof left to finish up and then all those roofs would be replaced Dorothy Nolan um some of the main features here uh like I was saying Ada we'll be looking to upgrade and renovate the nurses suite and actually put in an ADA Bathroom in there so the whole nurses Suite would be getting renovated um and then we'll be looking at replacing exterior doors throughout the building again major roof renovation here at Dorothy Nolan at Geer Road we're looking at you know upgrading boilers and pumps in the boiler room and we're also looking here would be the other one will be renovating the nurses sweet upgrading the uh the nurse's bathroom to Ada accessibility the other one here too through
095guys are doing window Renovations throughout the whole building we're doing some roof replacement in this phase six project that'll happen not this summer but the following summer and then we also have some upgrading the roofs uh in this project at Green field we'll be uh upgrading uh some of the exhausts in the two-story Edition replacing some flooring um in the corridors uh the ramps that go to the two floor Edition um and we're also upgrading some of the casew work in some of the classrooms that they are not getting Renova and then here we've done some Roofing already in the phase two project and we'll be continuing doing some additional Roofing replacement here at Lake AB will be doing something similar to the high school will be renovating their Auditorium here we'll just be doing
096seats and kind of finishes and and sprucing it up um and then we're doing univ ventilators which is the HVAC systems and all the classrooms will be upgrading second floor you know ventilators the highlighted area the auditorium renovation uh then on the third floor we'll be looking to do a full gut renovation of the library so we'll be upgrading the library on that and then here we're actually doing this this summer we're replacing the third story Roof then this following project we'll be looking at renovating the rest of the roofs and replacing them and then at the transportation building we'll be uh upgrading the boilers and then the fuel tanks um this and then finally we have a roofing replacement that we'll be doing at the transportation and I'll turn it back over to bill
097for phasing so this is the same schedule we looked at last time and I think one of the key things that we just want to point out for those listening um that aren't in the room you can see the red those are called Milestones you the red triangles of red diamonds that are here and this is what really Bobby's going to um expound on when he starts talking about finances but for each one of our buildings we maximize our Aid received from State education department on fiveyear intervals so if we do a project today five years later the State education department will replenish our maximum cost allowance for the amount we spend so it's critical and what really drove this entire project is by maximizing Aid drove the schedule of when we were going to
098build it and it really stems off the current project so if we did a project in 2023 it's going to happen again in 2028 so the schedule we set up in the current project really mimics what we're going to do in the future so without going we're not going through a line by line but that was what drove this and you'll see this in every one of the projects those red diamonds that says don't get it approved before this or you won't get your state a I'm going to turn over Bobby okay so um we came into this with some financial goals obviously uh first and foremost we want to continue to make the investments in our future um give the students you know the learning environment that we know uh they deserve and plus
099our faculty and staff members too we want up-to-date workplaces um and I think as most of you heard tonight uh the real changes and the impacts that those things can have on student learning um as Matt uh went through you can see the many items that were addressed through the building condition survey uh there were significant amounts of need across the district in terms of capital work so one of our uh additional goals was to address as many of those needs as possible while like Bill just mentioned maximizing our New York State Building Aid uh which is particular particularly difficult when um you're putting together a scope of a project this large because the timing of these um the undertaking the project work and most importantly the f fings with the State education department Drive
100most if not all of the funding that comes back to the district and what we're looking to also do is diligently manage our debt service and utilize Capital reserves and fund balance so that each year when we put together our tax levy calculation we have a very stable and predictable uh coming school year exemption which will then uh help to support our annual operating budget in the form of tax Revenue which as Joe mentioned in our previous presentation when we are um you know over 34s reliant on our local Levy it becomes significantly important to make sure that we can at least sustain the predictability of knowing that uh our revenues are continuing to be able to support our expenditure side of our budget and most importantly we were really hoping to accomplish all of
101these priorities uh with no additional taxes so how do we know that these could be accomplished with no additional taxes first and formost we have to take a look at uh where we are currently so what I'm going to show you um really is our current debt situation so basically this These Bars these gold bars represent the local share as we know it to be today so for all of the projects that have already been done complet deleted and filed uh with the State education department and using estimates and projections for the remaining phases of the existing December 2020 Legacy project this is what the local share situation looks like that local share is essentially the uh additional tax revenue that we have on an annual basis so you see as we go out uh
102it decreases and that in some years even kicks negative which would then uh be a decrease to our annual tax levy amount which would be significantly detrimental to our annual uh budget and operation so I put this line here because it's important it essentially represents what I perceive as our local share ceiling so what I'm looking to do is is make sure when we're looking at the phasing and all the estimates based on the timelines and the scope of work that we need to do I never want to see any line go above that red line line above the red line essentially means we have additional taxes if we can maintain at or below this red line we know that we're not going to have additional taxes so it's it's a pretty simple you know
103graph to look at um but it is significantly important to be able to have a handle on this and have a handle on the timing in which uh the building Aid is going to be flowing so this is probably a familiar slide but it's a very general slide um which we've put out to just help hopefully uh folks understand the highlevel uh you know breakdown of how we arrive at a local share so we have our total cost of construction um and then we'll we know we've been talking about our existing capital reserve that we intend to utilize for this project so we take off uh the revenue that would be received from that capital reserve and then we also intend to use $4 million from assigned fund balance um to also help lower that
104overall cost that we're going to have to finance uh through the issuance of of a bond and then we also know we get we get 70% back from building Aid so essentially in real simple terms that arri that gives us a local share a cost of the project but I'll go a little bit more into detail because it's it's far more complicated than that so as with any uh long range Capital planning project um there are important assumptions that we have to be aware of uh first and foremost is our state building Aid ratio so it's 70 A5 per. we also look at the amount of assumed um Aid ability of the project which is represented in line two so we're assuming that 95% of the work that we do we will be eligible to
105receive State Building Aid on which is positive because over you know 95% of this we're going to get 70% back from the state so we have a range of s approval dates in line four um line five certificate of substantial completion filing dates um line six final cost report submitt dates and really that's represented in um you know a a time period because we know all of these projects are not going to be completed and filed at the same time we know that there will be a project started and then phased out as bill went over in the timeline throughout um the course of those years um and then ending hopefully with final submission in June 2034 now when we file June 2034 that means that final project keeping in line with olve the repayment
106periods of 15 years we're going to be receiving building Aid on that project through 2049 15 years later I looked at this there's not many things I can say I will be retired so our first borrowing for this project we also assume at June 2026 with our first interest and principal payment due in June of 2027 we have assumed borrowing rates that essentially would be tacked on in the form of Interest and I know we've talked about a cost I want folks to remember the cost essentially is going to represent the principal amount due that we take out in the form of a bond so basically as with any financing it's assumed that there's interest also due on the principal amount that you're you're taking out and borrowing so there's also a probable period of
107usefulness in the bond resolution so just in New York state terms in general depending on what type of project work you have um ours in our case being a reconstruction project we will receive building aid over 15 years for those projects however state law does allow new reconstruction to be financed over a 30-year period so typically that's the maximum allowed in any bond issuance by state law so it's always you know one of those things that's just put there as a variable but the full intent is to line up the receipt of building Aid and our debt service to have those two to kind of married together um and as I go through this you'll you'll see and hear the number 23 years and you'll wonder why 23 years because we've talked about 15 years
108well it's 23 years because we have a project starting day one that is six years before the final phase of the entire project so it kind of gets just spread out a little bit more and like I had mentioned line 12 uh shows the amount of local funding that we're going to commit to this project which essentially decreases the amount that you have to finance through the issuance of a bond so we have like I mentioned $3.5 million that is sitting in a capital reserve it was actually that 3.8 million I showed last presentation it represents that Reserve amount plus a little bit of interest earned and then we intend to assign fund balance at the end of this June and then that will be transferred to the capital Fund in the summer to then
109help to offset any cost totaling $7.5 million um and this essentially just continues the same practice that we had with the Great Outdoors project we committed $7.5 million to The Great Outdoors through the use of fund balance for the December 2020 Legacy referendum we also committed $7.5 million of fund balance to that project so we're doing the same thing here in committing 7.5 million of fund balance to this project of May 2025 and then like I had mentioned there's an assumed uh amortization of State Building Aid so there's an interest rate that we would receive it's about 55% it would be repaid over 15 years because it's a reconstruction project and then essentially we would expect to receive a half of year in state aid in 2728 and how do we know that's because we
110would anticipate filing our first final cost report by June of 2028 which would essentially get us a half year of building Aid in 2728 school year so like with any financial plan um we have a budget for this project and just like with our annual school budget our expenditures have to equal our revenues so the proposed scope of work amount uh representing this project is m872 th000 so slightly above where the December 2020 Legacy project cost landed now I just went through how how we would anticipate paying for that $7.5 million through the use of fund balance and then the difference we would then have to finance or issue through a bond and that brings us again to the revenue side of m872 th000 so the these slides are going to be a little bit
111new just because because we've only been talking about cost in the form of principle but with any financing plan as IID mentioned there is an interest expense attached to this uh positive thing though we receive building Aid on our total debt service amount so we will we will receive building Aid on the principal and interest portions so on the left hand side what I show the total project scope cost um as you work across to the right you'll see 142. million and then we subtract out the intended use of capital reserves of 3.5 million and then like I mentioned the assigned fund balance of4 million for $7.5 million total and then that leaves us the amount that we intend to finance through the issuance of either short-term debt in notes or long-term debt in the
112form of bonds and it's important to remember the balance that we're financing only represents the principal amount so that principal amount and naturally because of the filings of the projects that are are throughout this package um it would be spread over a 23-year period but each of the projects completed within this Legacy uh proposal would be aided from New York State at 15 years so the 135.5 million of principal also drives uh about $77 million of interest expense which then gives us a total debt service amount of 212 m738 th000 so what we do is we look at all right what's that total project cost represented through principal and interest we take out the 70 and a half% that we know will get through building Aid if we are on time with all of our
113projects and filings so we anticipate receiving just shy of $150 million back through building Aid leaving a projected local share of just over $63 million so this breaks down on an annual basis over this 23-year uh repayment to about $9.2 million average annual debt payment we will receive in the form of building aid about 6.5 million back so that line that I was talking about in the governor's run that I reconciled and adjusted that essentially would be the average we would expect over that period of time then leaving an average local share of $2.7 million and this is really just that broken down in a nice little p graph um so we have our our principal 135.5 plus our interest of 77.3 for a total debt cost of 22.7 but we'll will receive 70% and
114then the local share is essentially 30% I want to call your attention to the legend they're wrong the the notations down there the yellow is the local Shar as we know today um and that represents the current uh December 2020 Legacy referendum and all Project work that's been done in the past and then that local share I it's labeled Legacy 3 it is Legacy May 2025 so as I went over at the beginning this represents our local share and the fluctuations that we would see and you know the number of reasons this would be detrimental to our annual um school budget again the ceiling that I like to be able to see that we do not go over this represents all of the projects that we currently have and the estimates for the December 2020
115uh Legacy project plus all of the scope that we've just discussed so all of those costs that $ 2127 million of principal and interest that's represented now through that green line so you'll see you know in 2425 and 2526 the yellow and the green are identical well they're identical because they don't reflect any of the new May 2025 project where you start to see the May 2025 project is in that 2627 where we bring this project on instead of having a decrease into you know about the three and a half million range which would be significantly impacting the local tax levy we can we can keep it at the current level of where we expect it in 25 26 we continue that out which gives us the um stability and predictability for revenues and then
116come 2031 32 you can see we have another decrease from that red line where the green bar meets it to um the essentially the middle kind of right underneath 4 million what this tells me is that we might be able to address future Capital needs by bringing on an additional project um in 2031 32 and still do it without going over where our local share is today so when I'm looking at all of our project estimates um and all of the scope of work that we're able to accomplish with um you know the assumptions that we put together it's really a positive thing where it's not going above our red line it's not going above that local share ceiling so the takeaway here is there is no additional taxes as a result of the scope
117of work so in summary we were able to make investments in the future if this referendum is approved we're able to address significant amounts of capital needs we're maximizing through the use of critical timing and phasing uh the New York State Building Aid will receive we are diligently managing The Debt Service through the use of capital reserves and fund bals while trying to maintain a local uh stable uh tax share and we'll be able to accomplish this with no additional tax taxes above where we would expect the 2526 budget to be so just some next steps tonight obviously is the first time you're hearing the uh the scope with the financial details um but as we've communicated the next meeting on February 13th would be the day that uh the board sets the date for
118the vote and approves the project resolution which would authorize the scope of work for 142 $2.8 million uh you would also authorize the expense of the remaining amount of the 2017 capital reserve you would also authorize the use of $4 million of assigned fund balance to help pay for this project and you would also be approving the issuance of Serial bonds for $35.31 of a capital reserve uh for future projects now this would have a 10-year useful life and it would be specifically for projects that were approved after July 1st of 2025 so any future Capital needs this this Reserve would be uh intended to use at that point in time and then the total funding would be up to $10 million and we we would be able to um put $6 million in that
119right off the bat our original plan was to put 10 right off the bat and take four from it for this project in working with Bond counsil on the Auditors um statute actually prohibits that so we had to get a little bit creative in terms of just how to actually just appropriate it and reclassing it as an assigned fund balance and moving it next year really accomplishes that task so same end result it just looks a little bit different of how we get there and then like I mentioned in last Pres presentation most important thing is that budget and capital project referendum vote on May 20th of 2025 there any questions wow I'd be shocked if there wen't but maybe there aren't it's a lot to absorb anybody have any comments or questions Connie that
120was extremely thorough and that's why we have no questions yeah thank you very much folks for uh that presentation so again if if the board uh again now has all the information related to the L committee's uh recommendations uh and again appreciate their efforts throughout this process uh as well as now the proposed scope uh the timeline the phasing as well as the long range financing of the plan um you know we do have from now until February 13th uh to answer any final questions that the board may have uh and then we'll be working uh obviously with our legal council uh to make sure all the required resolutions will be on the agenda for February 13th and at that time we can talk about our Communications plan that we've been already building uh as
121to how we're going to be engaging uh all of our community and the stakeholders uh to raise awareness educate everybody again about the important vote that will take place uh related to this Capital project on on May 20th thank you all right we uh we now turn to the consent agenda for tonight um our consent agenda agenda is a commonly used vehicle provided for by our adopted rules of parliamentary procedure that allows a board to vote on a large number of items in a single motion these business items are associated with the everyday running of the schools and their inclusion in the agenda is the result of a great deal of Prior work and Care by the Professionals of the district there are from time to time items that by law cannot be included in
122a consent agenda we don't have those today uh and when this happens we pull those out and vote on them separately these items are known to trustees and the public several days ahead of the business meeting on which they are discussed uh or considered so that board members have the chance to ask questions of Discovery and do any advanced fact finding that is part of their due diligence process um John do we have any modifications to tonight's consent agenda we do not so I will offer a motion I move that we approve the consent agenda as uh listed in sections e f and g in there entirety without any changes do I have a second Beth any questions or comments all in favor uh consent agenda passes 70 Bobby and that brings us to the
123formal end of the meeting section with um public public comment first is there anyone who wishes to uh speak to the board in the second public comment period all right seeing no activity we'll move on to agenda planning are there any agenda planning items uh for this evening Matt uh so I want to propose as sort of the first the our first look at this uh I think uh there have been some uh challenges and questions about the flex zones uh and so I'd like to put on on the agenda at our next meeting uh that we asked the superintendent to uh come up with some alternative ways uh to keep the communities whole while also balancing class size and minimizing bus routes um the thinking and I I should emphasize this uh based on
124the Consultants uh uh plan as well is that any changes to flex zones would be implemented over a six-year period so not not anything immediate but I do think we may want to start looking at that process so that we can start that six-year look forward um so I I would ask that we ask the superintendent by the end of this year to present us with two or three Alternatives uh with relative positives and negatives uh that we can consider for over a long period uh potential change in Flex Zones again emphasizing the long period of the change and and so that uh consistent with our policy Matt's bringing that up so we have a time to think about it and we're not uh giving our consent or our non-consent to this in this meeting
125immediately we think about it there will be time for discussion and questions and back and forth uh at next meeting as well John can I just ask you to clarify what you mean by the end of this year school year uh yeah I me at the end of the school year yes any any questions for Matt or clarification requests or Beth um I like that idea I'm wondering if within that we can also or should we also consider our bus rots and transportation because I think that's what in part has prompted this yes that um just the way in which the flex zones impact our busing needs and so those just in my mind those two go together and I'm wondering if that was a thought you had as yeah I mean I think the
126the reason that this come came forward is because of the the the challenges we're having with the busing but all and then from that discussion that we've had the past couple of sessions the sort of uh in addition to the challenges them busing also the sort of challenges to the communities remaining whole when they're in a flex zone um so I'd like I think both of those things and any other potential that um uh un foreseeable um effects of the the changes in the flex zone so I guess come ready to discuss Flex Zones next time any other um agenda planning items all right that moves us into board member comments who's got them I have one Whimsical one real real uh I um I was noting that uh in the um I think when
127it was I think it was uh Joe who was talking about the governor hok's uh device you know Internet connected device um uh plan that um you know we have lockers uh you know in in abundance here they're completely unused um and so that may you know not necessitate an outlay of cash to to to store these things I want to come this is not this is only PR Locker right here students but I want to say that I am bring back the locker I think you know I mean for and my kids are going to say if if they ever saw this which they won't because they never watched these things but they this would be they' call this my Boomer moment but um man we need to bring back the lockers and you
128know the picture in the lockers and the socializing around the lockers this could be the way to do it come back to hearken our hearken back to our our days in the uh well for me in the 80s in high school but um anyway that's all I have to say anyone else all right so we do have to uh go into executive session um we um we are going to move into executive session to uh review tax or shiori cases uh could I get a motion to enter executive session for that reason John and second Dean any discussion all in favor all right motion carries