001e all right can I please get a motion to uh re-enter public session for Tony second Connie um all in favor thank you can we have quiet please all right please join me and standing with for the pledge all right can I please get a motion to approve our minutes from December 12 Natalia is first Beth are is there any discussion all right all in favor thank you that's unanimous can I please get a motion to accept this evening's agenda Connie and Tony any discussion all in favor thank you that's also unanimous all right before we start public comment um our superintendent would like to make a statement well good evening everyone uh hope everybody had a wonderful holiday break uh it's been great to have our students and staff back in school uh for
002the start of the new school year the New Year uh so before we started tonight's meeting I wanted to provide some follow-up information on feedback that the district has received from our annual transportation department presentation uh that was presented to the board in December uh in the review of our transportation efficiency study uh that was completed uh last summer uh into the fall uh so hopefully uh that this update and information is going to help alleviate any of the concerns uh that we've heard from parents and community members uh that have shared with us over the last several weeks uh the Board of Education and the district had contracted with on the bus transportation planning Service uh who's a service through the Franklin essic Hamilton bosies uh back in June of 2024 uh to conduct
003an efficiency study on our transportation department uh to help alleviate the challenges that we are currently facing uh again that many school districts across our state and Country have been facing for the last several years uh our school district here in Saratoga Springs like many of our neighbors uh are faced with challenges meeting the needs of our school Community uh due to a bus driver shortage uh that is impacting districts all across the country uh our entire transportation department staff from our drivers and our bus AIDS all of our routing Specialists our mechanics all of our trainers as well as our directors have been working extremely hard to overcome the challenges of the lack of drivers and we truly appreciate the daily tremendous efforts that that they put into serving District so just to give
004some perspective prior to the covid pandemic our school district uh employed about 85 bus drivers and over the last five years we've seen a significant decline in the number of drivers available to us so we currently have 67 drivers who are working for the school district uh and our district has been committed to driver recruitment efforts uh from our transportation staff thems our human resources department as well as our Communications and District leadership team have been working together to help promote driver opportunities at local and Regional job fairs uh we host test drive uh School Bus events here at school property uh our drivers are promoting bus driver opportunities at all school events and we have partnered with the local media to help attract new drivers to the district so uh the district is currently
005in contract negotiations with our local CSEA and our goal is to remain highly competitive in our ability to attract and to also retain staff in all areas so at our December 12th Board of Education meeting uh the Consultants from the on the bus transportation planning Service uh presenting findings and recommendations from the Transportation efficiency study uh to our Board of Education uh the recommendations uh that were shared during this presentation are not final decision being implemented by the district these are just findings and recommendations that were outlined that are a starting point for discussions and exploration of possible options for the district as we move forward the study itself was designed to help address the significant Transportation challenges that we Face including the bus driver shortage and the need to ensure reliable service for all
006students this review includ included in a a review of all of our existing B bus routes and student ridership our staffing levels and Driver availability the opportunities for improved efficiencies and exploring many alternative options that can best meet the needs of our students in school Community as was presented in the study uh the district is currently organized using a two- tier routing system with our high school and middle school in tier one and all six of our elementary schools on tier 2 this system was effective when the district had over 85 drivers available to us now with 67 drivers working there's significant stress on our system to meet the daily number of bus routes to and from school that need to be scheduled for our students needs the Consultants recommended that the district explore implementing
007a three-tier routing system that spreads out the number of bus rout routes over three arrival and dismissal times reducing the number of drivers that are required at each tier and better aligning to our current Staffing levels this would also allow the district to have our own drivers cover out of District runs that we currently contract out to private transport Transportation companies to cover these runs a three tier T transportation system is used by most large school districts in the capital region and across New York State uh we also provided a comparison of Local School District transportation systems uh that was provided in the TR in the presentation so routing and providing safe and efficient transportation for over 5,800 students to and from school on a daily basis is very complex and there are many many
008moving parts to meet the needs of our students programs and extracurricular opportunities we have heard feedback from parents who have expressed frustration when the regular school day bus routes have to be cancelled or when we are not able to offer late buses or cover athletic trips due to the lack of bus drivers it's our responsibility as a district to have a transportation system that is safe reliable sustainable and manageable for our transportation department to deliver we hope that the ongo ongoing driver Recruitment and Retention efforts can improve and we can return to having 85 drivers available that can support our current system if driver recruitment um opportunities do not improve then we'll need to cons uh continue to explore other options to meet our transportation needs so I've heard and I understand truly the concerns
009that have been that have been shared from our families and our parents who are already planning for child care and before and after school programming for this upcoming start of the school year in the fall of 2025 uh we all need additional time uh and the opportunity to gather feedback from all of our stakeholders to explore all possible options and scenarios that can help our current transportation system so at this time just so everybody is very clear there are going to be no changes that are going to be made to our current transportation system for the start of the new school year so again there is nothing decided nothing is going to change we're going to use the next several months to continue to gather feedback and that we ask that we continue for your
010partnership your patience and your support as we work together collaboratively to find a more sustainable and effective Solutions and to ensure safe and reliable transportation for every student so again we conducted the survey we want to explore as many options that are possible those recommendations were made to the district now it's up to us as our as the district leadership working with our transportation department Gathering feedback from our parents to find Solutions moving forward that's going to be in the best interest of all of you of our students of our programs of our teachers and staff but no decision has been made and there'll be no change for the start of the new school year for 2025 2026 thank you no all right thank you so much this brings us to our first public comment
011period on the behalf of the board I want to thank you sincerely for being here oh thank you um we truly inv value in your input and appreciate the community being here and engaged um our meetings are held in public so the board can conduct the business of the district visibly and maximize transparency and information sharing however they are not public public meetings with realtime dialogue and with attendees our board will provide these two public comment periods during which speakers May address us to share information and opinions that may inform our work and in the case that followup is necessary the appropriate District official will be in touch we ask speakers in the audience to conduct themselves in a civil and constructive manner modeling the same modeling the same respectfulness we expect from the students
012of our district we do not allow comments about specific individual employees students or trustees and ask that you be succinct and try not to repeat previous speakers to allow more opportunity uh people the opportunity to address us the first public comment period is limited to 30 minutes we have more than enough speakers to fill that so if you can be succinct we'll be able to hear from more of you um after the B the district I'm sorry after the board conducts its business we will have another open um public comment period for you to speak at if you wish to remain um this opens our first public comment period um the first three slots are allowed for are allotted for students do we have any students who signed up but didn't sign up in the
013student okay seeing none um you are allotted three minutes and before you address the board please clearly state your name uh first up we have Caitlyn getts good evening and thank you for letting us um address you all I did watch the board meeting my name is Caitlyn and I do have one child at Lake Avenue and I have a kindergartner that will beginning be beginning in the fall um I did just want to address the board and the administration with regard to the transportation proposal that was made at the last board meeting my family has been impacted by the ccil bus routes speak up of course yes my family has been impacted by the canceled bus routes on numerous occasions and I do know that it is a big problem for others I also
014understand the district and the transportation Department's predicament with the shortage of bus drivers however I do caution that any solution to this problem must be evaluated thoroughly and must be considered um must consider the impact on All Families my family um my concern is that with a schedule change the in the short term could solve one problem but it is likely to cause numerous other problems by its implementation ultimately creating more work and making life harder on both Educators and Families my husband and I both work in Albany and we commute and while we do have flexibility and are lucky enough to have that we do have to commute to the office regularly therefore we do rely heavily on our neighbors to help us get kids to and from school to do pickup to do
015drop off to do bus stop duty to make sure that our kids in the neighborhood are taken care of a lot of time in energy is spent amongst us and our neighbors to figure out a plan every single year and sometimes on a week toe basis to make sure that our kids in the neighborhood are covered one of the biggest concerns is that we need to have two working parents and most families do need to have two working parents a change to the schedule impacts that hugely by asking parents to adjust to a significantly different schedule no matter what it ends up being it really does ask the parents to work with their employers and It ultimately means that the district is relying on the flexibility of those employers as well to make any schedule
016change work so this is much bigger than us just working as families to make this work and there's a lot of families that do not have flexibility in order to make these scheduled changes also there are obviously significant Child Care concerns which you are all well aware of um and I'm not going to go into too much I mean you have all heard many of these things but um one of the other concerns that I do have is that I do live in a flex zone and in my neighborhood there are children that go to all three or go to three different elementary schools as we rely on neighbors if there is a separate start time an hour difference in the start time of elementary schools and we are relying on neighbors there are Lally
017going to be many situations where I may have to stay and get a child on the bus that is not my own and my neighbors might also have to do that and that is a major ask and favor that I may be lucky enough to have but it is a major ask and not a lot of other families might have that opportunity so just in general I I do ask that any wrap up please yes of course any change to the schedules um will impact the community in numerous ways and I implore the board and the administration to look in the real into the real life impacts of any proposal before moving forward thank you thank you next up is Aaron Larry hello a I'm aarin ly and I'm here again tonight to speak as
018the president of the Lake Avenue Elementary School PTA we've seen such a voracious Community response to the December efficiency study and that's because not only the decisions of the board of education but the decisions proposals and ideas of the district hold weight and have a tremendous impact on families without an actual mechanism to start discussions Lake Avenue PTA sent a me a survey to our members and program participants on January 3rd to be a better position to Advocate and express the concerns of our community by lunchtime Tuesday we had an estimated 26.2% response rate that number has since increased and we've seen responses come in from other schools in the district last night and this morning as of 6:30 we had 450 responses I can't speak to all of those but I can share some
019of the preliminary information about Lake based on our Tuesday data poll 78% of households expected an increased need for child care with any change in start time 88% of those families have no family or friends who would be able to assume those Child Care responsibilities for them and so 70% of our respondents expected to incur new new child care costs these were not minor a third of that 70% expected an additional monthly cost of about $400 or more based on the current YMCA rates that's about $4,000 per year but some could foresee an additional expense of ,000 a month or more because of multiple children in the household so $110,000 what about changes in costs when that demand skyrockets because we know we don't have have the capacity this doesn't yet address how people felt
020about the changes in terms of their children's educations or teacher recruitment or richment opportunities or research about sleep and start times or observations and frustrations about inefficiencies inherent to flex zones that were shared in free text responses as these conversations continue I do hope that you please remember that schools do not exist in isolation and neither does a single School problem I know that every one here and working at the district does know that but this presentation certainly didn't suggest that if you want to have a conversation you have to have tools for people to provide feedback otherwise these ideas seem like a fate to compy that data can't stay internal it needs to be available to people to understand what is actually being discussed or it breeds distrust please ex re-examine how we are
021using Flex Zones because yes class sizes are down but so is the census so is the birth rate we can't attribute small class sizes to flex zones alone but it does seem like this busing crisis is at least partly attributable to flex zones that kids send kids from glenum past division Past Lake to Caroline I do want yeah before I take my seat I do want to suggest one more thing as an observer not a leader it does seem like this is uh looking at the numbers a good way to cut $1 million from capital expenditure for expected electric bus mandate and I do hope that you see the response here and see that the people here are better suited to help be partners with the district in lobbying the state or our local legislators
022in order to support our families and Community thankk you next up is Lee Grady hi my name is Leo Grady I I have two children at Division Street I am a ninth and 10th grade teacher Spanish teacher at Queensbury High School so I think my perspective and my experience 20 years Mike Patton actually hired me I still love it um is kind of from the really oh that's the first time I think I have ever heard that um my um I want to tell you what it's like teaching teenagers at 7:30 in the morning it's ugly although if you te first block it's good because they are basically still asleep we joke my colleagues and I joke it's not really funny but that first block we always like that first block is so good because
023they come in they they are they are one step up from from zombies and the second block you know there you see you see the real version of them um you know it would be funny again if we didn't know the negative physical emotional and academic effects that this chronic fatigue has on our adolescence um and I do think just for something to keep in mind for like when we decide like if if we do a new schedule to keep in mind pushing back for our adolescence would be would be life-changing um first block teaching would would you know they'd be a little rowdier but I'll take it I'll take it if it means that they're sleeping more and driving better and more awake um so again yeah I to Echo what everyone has said
024the the delaying the the Elementary start time who I really think would be affected would be women um the US Chamber of Commerce that's a thing there's a US Chamber of Commerce in 2021 said that 79% of women were cited they cited Family Care as the leading reason for exiting the workforce so I really think in addition to hardships it would be working women especially who would stay home with the kids but I do trust you guys I know you have worked through everything I I really know you have but um there's there's some complexity and I'm sure we can find a better solution then um a 7:30 start time for teenagers so thank you thank you next up is Aaron conin hello my name is Aaron Conlin I have two children at Lake Avenue
025and I am also here to say a few comments about the proposed schedule changes um I I've highlighted four things that I think will most affect my own Stu my own children um while agreeing with most of the other comments I'm sure that will be said um one at the elementary level I'm very concerned that in our family with two working parents how we would make a 10 o'clock start work um that's a common thing I'm sure you've heard um and then Mo looking ahead to the middle school years I'm concerned for the incoming sixth grade class if half of the class is used to starting school at 8:00 and half of that incoming class is shifting their school day by two hours like what that does for their academic performance and and achievement um
026when they're only half the class is making such a such a big jump and then looking ahead to the high school level I'm concerned that we're thinking of moving the high school day earlier when SC science is telling us that teenagers need more sleep and would benefit from a later start date a later start time um we know that sleep is a key component of mental health and we know how many teenagers are struggling with mental health difficulties right now so I think we should keep that in mind and then finally um just thinking about the long-term Vitality of the district as a whole we are a district with declining enrollment and I think we need to make ourselves um a welcoming place for new families and I don't think the scheduling plan does that
027a lot of families that live in Saratoga have a choice of where they live and I think we need to to say like we support families come to our district thank you very much thank you next up is Erica woic hi my name is Erica OIC I have um one uh first grader in Lake Avenue and I have an incoming uh first grader coming in uh in the fall um I want to Echo a lot of what was already said but also just add a couple more things one is um when I came into Lake AB with my first grader I think I had the most uh information that anyone could have about after care opportunities I knew people that were already in the Y program I knew about other options for that and even
028with all that information and all the dates in hand we didn't secure a spot at the YMCA Aftercare um I didn't find that out until um uh in the early year so January February and then at that point I still didn't know where my kid was going to go to school because we are in a flex zone Lake Caroline division and I just want to say that that period of trying to figure out what we were going to do between January and September when we started was extremely stressful for my family um we thought about all different options one being that if we ref Flex into division we would have to use the bus because it's farther enough um from us there and so um I just wanted to First make that point that there
029really is a lack of options for childcare in the outdoor hour hours and we're really stretching ourself thin as a family with two working parents in the current schedule how it is with one end kind of aligned with work start and one end not and if both of those were unaligned it would be really really difficult um the second point I want to make is that um the unintended consequences I mentioned that if we were flexed division we'd have to use a bus um if their start and end times changed more either pulling away from our workday ending on the back end or in the front end pulling away you know what I'm talking about um we would probably end up being busers and now we're not in order to cover child care right so
030by Shifting the hours in either direction you may end up creating way more need for utilizing the buses because we were scrambling to figure out how can we gab an hour here 30 minutes there so that I'm not paying um hundreds of dollars to various babysitters to try to scrap together care for my children so um I also want to say thank you to everybody who's involved in this in this process of trying to find a solution I will not pretend like I know all the constraints and all the pieces and I know it's a really challenging an important problem so I want to say um thank you to to those who are putting in the work thank you next up is Jill ran hi my name is Jill Regan I have a kid at
031Lake G and I have a kid at Maple AV um I have a little bit of a different perspective to share because I'm also a teacher at a Middle School South of the twins um and I just wanted to share with you that our district has gone to attend 10 to four schedule for elementary school and the consequences of that we have seen now because we're in year two of it so um educator to Educators we all know that the end of the day schedule for little kids our Primary students is specials read alouds it's not intense academic learning Because by the end of the day they're tired they're up at 6 it doesn't matter if they're school day starts at 10: or 7 they're up at 6 they're little um so one of the
032consequences we found is that we really don't have the time for instruction because those last two hours now are Deadtime we had kids falling asleep on the carpets you know that kind of thing um and then of course getting home at 5 o'clock when you're little and you have dinner and some kids have homework and you know we won't talk about family time or or sports or anything like that so just as a perspective from someone who's seen it happen now for a couple of years um and parents feel the same way Educators do down there the other piece is personal to me um I'm someone where my child care needs won't actually change because my daughter attends before and after school with the why the unintended consequence for her is that her drop off
033time will still be seven but she will have three hours before her school day starts um because we work down south both of us every day we have to go every day so she'll be at the Y her normal hours but those three hours in the morning like I can't imagine what her day will feel like by the time it's 1:00 so just another perspective to share I appreciate appreciate all the thought you've put in um in my district we have our HR department covering Transportation uh because we are so short so I really do understand the need for some sort of new strategy here so thank you for trying to think of it thank you very much next up is Rebecca Lynch Rebecca Lynch hi my name is Rebecca Lynch I have two children
034in our schools one at division one at Maple um I attended the last board meeting and while I Now understand that the schedule changes as presented at that meeting are off the table I did want to still address a few things um first I've heard it said repeatedly that what was presented at the last meeting was just a starting point for discussion and exploration of possible options however as an active and engaged parent in this District who regularly attends board meetings and reads District communication I ask that you be more mindful with how such things are presented in the future what I took away from that presentation both at the meeting and later from the language on the district website was that there was one single schedule that was going to be this solution and
035that there were no other potential ideas um or next steps it's hard as a parent to see something like that and not think that the district will be moving to implement it as is in the near future um second I had a lot of concerns with that proposal um those are moot now since the proposal as we've heard isn't going forward but I do ask that you consider the following things when working on any future proposal um we live in a child care desert as we've now heard people have trouble with child care um most families in our districts in our district are ones in which all adults in the home are working mine included um while schools not a daycare it's a major part of how we structure our days and that includes making
036sure that our children are in a safe space and taken care of so that we can go to work and provide for them uh a district problem also shouldn't be solved by placing an additional burden on families as the first step without considering other options I'm lucky that I can work from home half the time and I can care for my children before and after school when I do that and that I have the ability to pay for child care at the Y when I'm in the office but there are a lot of families that don't have that and aren't in that position um the district should look inward as the first step in solving a problem before making Chang changes that will cause major upheaval in the lives of our families um I regularly
037see decisions made without a clear and transparent review of Education research I recommend that the district partner with one of the colleges or universities in our area to have the ability to review evidence and research while making decisions such as this um lastly I've served on the district equity and inclusion committee since its Inception and I would suggest that the equity questions that were developed through there be asked and answered before any proposals move forward to the level that this most recent proposal reached and I thank you all for your time and service thank you next up is Jennifer lner hi everyone I'm Jennifer lefner I am not only a parent of two high schoolers in the district I'm also the chair of pediatrics at Saratoga Hospital what I say is my own opinions not
038that of the hospital but I wanted to give you some background for my comments I want to focus on the side effects of earlier school start times for the adolescence and high school students as many many of the people here are representing lake or Elementary School um as you all know and as was already commented early mornings are tough um during puberty a biological and hormonal shift in the sleep wake phase delay occurs such that there's a 2hour later sleep on onet and morning Awakening compared to middle and early childhood this is not something that can just be changed by force with earlier bed times these students need sleep that will eventually start at about 11 o'clock at night on average the health effects of early start times or earlier start times um and that
039is compared to what the Academy of Pediatrics has proposed since 2014 as a start time no earlier than 8:30 a.m. shorter sleep and chronic sleep loss leads to metabolic dysfunction which is typee 2 diabetes cardiovascular disease obesity increase in depressive symptoms poor attention suicidal ideation increased use of stimulants and increased visits to the nurse's office the academic effects poor academic performance specifically in the first period classes as we already heard and the endof year testing in those classes had lower scores one study even showed that a 1-hour delay in start time later resulted in a third percenti Point gain in math and reading test scores and those gains were even more elevated in the students at the lower part of the bell curve increased tardan tardiness and absenteeism which leads to lower graduation rates um
040and decrease Readiness to learn the safety effects of an earlier start time are increased risk-taking behaviors among adolescents increased athletic injuries among those student athletes and increased motor vehicle accident risk which is significantly higher among 16 to 18-year- Old driver drivers with earlier start times one study out of Wyoming noted that up to a 65% decreased rate of motor vehicle accidents in this population with later star Times by 30 minutes alone in the elementary school there's no biological pressure of sleep clock shift and it's easier for them to get to bed earlier and wake earlier there's been no real health effects of an earlier start time no change in sleep duration no consistent academic effects of an earlier start time the safety effects of a much later start time would be the youngest kids would
041be on a bus later and longer when it's darker during higher periods of traffic on potentially unsafe roads think about a kindergartener getting off the bus in Porter Corners at 5:30 p.m. can you please wrap up yes sorry um in terms of the community effects we have the YMCA based capacity people have talked about their dependence on the Y they are at capacity now they do not have capacity for more that it's just fact you could talk to scar Clark himself the timing of athletic practice and games if coaches are from the elementary of Middle School how would that be affected would there be buses for the high school sports if Elementary is pushed the road safety in the early mornings for our high school drivers would the city be able to plow and clear
042and salt on time to make it safe and find finally you know there are eight two states in the country who have already mandated start times no earlier than 8:30 with eight others considering it New York is one of them um I believe as a physician and quoting a superintendent from a large dist District outside of Denver it would be negligent to ignore the science around this change is hard we can't make all the factory the families happy at and there will be impacts on everyone there are certain percentage of students that are involved in athletics activities work but 100% of our students are involved in academics and that's what we need to focus on thank you thank you all right we have time for two more speakers um first Maddie zenetti and the last
043speaker will be Amber marzo hello I'm Maddie zetti and I'm also here to talk about the change in the school times but I do have a kindergartener at Lake Avenue but I thought just to come at it from a different perspective like Aaron said that the school is not isolated this a whole Community I also have two businesses in downtown Saratoga we do employ people who have kids in school we also do employ a lot of students from the high school if we work to have people needing to pick up their kids at 1 or 2:00 in the afternoon I honestly would not be able to hire those people because that would be the middle of the day they would have to leave their job if they couldn't come in until 10: or 11 because
044they were getting their kids on the bus and they didn't have the child care I could also not hire those people we wouldn't be able to staff our stores and there are a lot of businesses downtown who do rely on parents or on teachers who have after school time or weekends that we would not be able to rely on that part-time staff because they would have to be subsidizing the child care that they now have or they would not be able to get to their job in time to work even a 4-Hour shift that makes sense for a business owner so as much as I did come here planning on talking about it from the perspective of a parent who is up very early in the morning and if I could I'd get my kid
045out the door at like five in the morning but but I think that from a very different perspective is looking at how different parts of the community would also be affected because as a business and as an employer we would not be able to staff our stores or our offices because of the change in the schedules so thank you for considering a different view as well thank you thank you Amber marzo hello I my name is Amber marzo um I have a kindergartener at Division Street School um so I really wouldn't be greatly affected by this change but I just and I really this is very out of character for me to even stand in front of a microphone so I just really felt the need to say something because I I'm surprised that this
046idea has gotten this far and really it should have ended with the idea that the there are kindergarteners who I have who will be getting off the bus in the dark I mean I think Baseline safety this is a bad idea so I support your work I really want a good idea to come out of this I think so many things have been said that would be helpful such as like changing the start time in a different way to support high school kids um but anyway that's all I have to say so thank you for your time thank you all right you two were quick we have time for one more that's Sarah migga good evening my name is Sarah Miga um I want to thank you for your time in addressing this and I
047also want to take a second to commend all of our bus drivers and the amazing work that they do um we've had a really wonderful experience and I'm so grateful for that I have a first grader who is in Greenfield schools um and I disagree with this current plan um a lot of what's been said uh about getting home in the dark um living out in Greenfield and Middle Grove um it's very nerve-wracking to um some of the streets out there to be thinking about having them out on the on the roads at that time um I also don't have close neighbors who I could depend on I'm fortunate to have uh family who I can depend on a lot of the time but that's not a given um I'll also say that I would
048ask everyone to I'm I'm a working parent um from a working household and I have a great deal of flexibility and I feel very fortunate that that's the case um I would encourage us all to remember that even when you have the flexibility to be home to get someone on and off the bus that doesn't mean you're able to do your work at the same time I'm not actually working in that hour of time period even if I'm at home right juggling all those things so I guess I would just say as you move forward in um looking at different solutions to consider what the limits of flexibility are and what pushing Beyond them I think we've all grown very used to postco being like Oh we can be flexible or we all have the
049ability to do this which is not the case for everyone and the corrosive effects that happen when we push beyond the limits of that flexibility so thank you very much for your time thank you all right I'm sorry we couldn't get to everybody that stops our first comment period but we will start up with the list and then open it up to anybody else who wishes to speak in our second public comment period um this brings us to our board committee reports do we have any any board committee reports Dean thanks Angie uh so um I don't have a board committee report necessarily from facilities as John's going to give us a presentation this evening but um just because it's top of mine there is a district committee that I'm a part of which is
050the dirt committee the district Emergency Response Team and we had a great meeting today and I just wanted to give a quick overview on on what occurs there and kind of the great work that happens that committee is led by Dave ladu uh and and his team they're representatives from all district buildings and from the administrative offices as well as well as a few students and uh outside assistance from our First Responders law enforcement and uh fire and EMS today just to give folks with this great crowd in attendance uh a quick snapshot of what we did they facilitated um an approximately twoh hour uh interactive session where we went over reunification of what would occur in the event of a building needing to be evacuated right and when we say that typically our thoughts
051go to the worst of the worst but let's just understand that that could happen with a simple gas leak in proximity to a building where we have to evacuate the building and so we had five different teams that all were given different roles uh and uh we acted them out and and and Dave and Mike uh par participated and they were kind of uh um you know roles of parents and students and I just wanted to bring to the Forefront just the great work that kind of happens behind the scenes that a lot of people don't get an opportunity to see or hear from uh with respect to what we do here at the board and what happens kind of within the schools I love the idea that there's students that are involved in it
052which is fantastic it gives a great perspective from what they deal with on a daily basis and just knowing that there's commity Community resources that are involved in that as well um uh should give us you know a comforting feeling that uh that things are being done the right way we're always trying to get things done better so that in the event of an emergency or something else that might take place we're as well equipped as we can be so I just wanted to bring that up to the board because we haven't really ever talked about it in the past so thanks Dean Tony the finance committee met um the week after our our board meeting in in uh December uh we went through a number of items the first of which uh Bobby reviewed
053the Rockefeller Institute recommendations which came out in um December these are mostly relative to um State funding proposed changes uh two of them uh are a particular interest and concern to the business office um have budgetary impact uh if if uh they're they enacted they are the uh $500 minimum and safe harmless recommendation and the reserve funds recommendation I won't go through what each of those are I mean some of you have read this report um but if implemented those uh those two could have a significant impact on our district finances Bobby and his uh team will uh give us more in the uh coming budget discussions on both of those and the other uh Rock Feller uh recommendations but those were the two that that uh were of the most concern um we did
054uh we were informed that Questar bosis will be coming on three days in February uh to conduct their risk assessment work and the um 2425 internal audit piece which um is going to focus on federal Awards and school lunch operations uh we did a brief review of the seeker seeker details that uh are in the item on tonight's consent agenda that we're going to pull and and and take a a roll call vote on um we went over the fund balance and reserves plan which is also in tonight's uh consent agenda the yearly plan that that that was um uh a lot of that is the same from year to year the big difference this year the notable item is uh the potential establishment of a $10 million capital reserve um this is assuming um
055a a voter approval in May of this uh but we would fund it before uh June 30th of 20125 and just to let you know this is allocating existing funds in unrestricted fund balance to a capital reserve um uh to be used in Legacy 3 um uh execution it's not uh raising new funds that we don't already have so that was uh the fund balance and Reserve main piece and then the last two things where we reviewed some new benefits that we're going to be offering our employees through Uh current District Partners all of these benefits are no cost to the district and don't compete with um benefits currently offered by the the bargaining units um but there was an overview of that and then uh last we just want to um we were made
056aware of and I'd like to congratulate Joe Greco from our business office for um getting an article published uh about um decentralizing budget components to improve e efficacy uh which was published recently in a peer-reviewed uh international business officials Journal so and I think I sent the article to each of you um but I wanted to congratulate him on that and that's the end of my report thanks Tony any questions for finance thank you anything else no committees all right students here thank you at Dorothy Nolan the cafeteria got some finishing touches installed including some beautiful sound panels students jumped right back into the swing of things enjoying some of the before school enrichment opportunities and continuing their learning through the Beyond thebell program at Caroline Street midor assessments on I ready begin next week
057and on Tuesday January January 14th fifth graders across the district will be at the high school for an arts and education residency with the high school corers at Division Street students Contin continue to enjoy the many clubs offered and the Beyond thebell program is going well and next week students will be starting the year the middle of the year I ready Assessments in reading and math at geyser Road they're ready to jump into 2025 with the annual Snowball Dance on January 17th at Maple La the high school music program treated the Middle School to a holiday concert before the break school counselors will be working with uh eighth grade students over the next couple of months to assist them in selecting their ninth grade High School courses students will be completing their winter IR ready
058reading and math diagnostic assessments this month and the conduct restorative instructional coaches Carrie Jackson and Nora ketum visited all Maple Avenue uh students in their flexes to share the importance of restorative practices Community circles and how their positions will help support them at the high school school counselors held an assembly with all grade 10 students before the break to introduce them to the Bose's programs over 160 students expressed interest in the programs for next year and their Futures the music program treated the entire school to a holiday concert on the day before the break students in grades 9 through 11 start course advisement this week to request classes for next year and Saratoga High School will welcome Rising nth graders nth grade students next Tuesday January 14th for 8 to9 academic information night all right
059thank you very much that brings us to administrative reports they always do a great job um so upcoming on January 24th uh each year our bosies host a regional Le legislative breakfast and this is an opportunity for Board of Education and District leaders from all across our region our Bose's is made up of 31 component school districts uh so we work very closely with all of our elected uh legislative leaders uh who represent us uh down in Albany uh so the governor will be coming out with her executive budget in the coming weeks and so over the next several months uh we welcome you to come back uh learn more about the budget development process uh in the school district uh and know that obviously we we work very closely uh in efficacy efforts uh
060in partnership with other uh school districts uh to help support funding for public schools uh throughout the state budget development process so uh the legislative breakfast that we do each year in January kind of kicks that off uh and we invite all the legislative leaders to come uh to bosis right here at Henning Road at the Meer Center uh we have students stud that participate in the presentation and then it's an opportunity for board presidents superintendent uh again to begin the conversation of advocacy uh and how we can best support the needs of our students and our programs and services and staff uh in public education throughout the state uh as the state finalizes their uh budget negotiations in the spring uh so more information to come uh and again uh throughout the next several
061months uh at each meeting will be talking about budget um preparations uh as well as uh next month uh the board will be hearing the final plans for our Capital project um proposition which will also be presented to the community uh in May uh at the same time of our annual budget vote so tonight we have uh two presentations uh each meeting we have an opportunity to hear from whether our principles or directors and uh tonight we we are going to hear from two of our outstanding leaders first up is Eric Bush who's our director of school lunch uh who's going to provide an overview of the operations related to our food services department uh and then after Eric's presentation uh we're have the opportunity to hear from John tener Mike Goodwin Dave Al hamdu
062uh about our overall facilities and operations uh plan for the year so uh we're going to turn over to Eric uh to kick it off with Food Services hi thank you uh I'm Eric push from the director of Food Services uh the first picture a little better okay um so first picture in the slide is from Dorothy Nolan uh right after the renovation we got new uh reusable trays there uh bright blue um I if you guys can see it but one of the students is still eating uh sorry I'll talk into it um she's got a nugget in her mouth in the back if you can see it which I left in because I thought it was one of the best pictures uh in the presentation uh next is a slide of our organizational
063chart uh I report directly to Bobby uh in the business office I fall under uh business um I work for Capitol region bosies uh we're part of the shared Food Service uh program uh in the black back you can see uh our support staff over at bosis uh Jeff Brad Su Frank Alysa Eisner is our registered dietitian uh and Chad me is our farm to school and purchasing uh bid agent uh under me is Megan Corney she was a cook at the high school she's moved up uh in a role of a culinary manager where she helps to oversee uh the 12 Cooks in the district and helps with Logistics of food around the district she also handles catering outside events uh anything that comes up call outs uh Karen Bowman is in my office
064she's our account uh senior account Clerk and then usually we have a uh twice a year we have a fall and spring uh Russell Sage intern uh dietitian that comes in um in each building we have a cook or two the high school has two Cooks uh Maple has two Cooks uh there's a cook at the um Cafe the new uh blue Street Cafe in the high school and uh my department has uh 45 Food Service helpers and three motor vehicle operators uh I did have the slide in before the Transportation uh presentation but I just wanted to highlight um our shared food service with Transportation uh we have 10 employees that we share with Transportation uh accounts for about 40 hours in labor uh that those bus drivers and AIDS in midday when they
065end their first shift and run um they come over and work for us for about three three and a half hours a day to serve run register uh help wherever and that's in multiple buildings uh we actually just picked up two more uh for Subs uh yesterday so that number goes up to 12 which is uh really great so it works for them uh we made it work for us um you know it's really hard to find that labor to come in for three hours a day three and a half hours a day just to run register uh for the lunch service and it's worked out really great um with the partnership with the transportation department uh next slide I wanted to just highlight uh the renovations it's it's crazy to think that within a
066year we've opened uh gone through and opened the high school renovation Dorothy Nolan renovation and then this past summer had uh Greenfield and division uh Renovations completed and open uh within the district next slide is a mural that just was installed uh to finish out the renovation at division uh turned out really nice it was a by a company um imaginate your space it's a hard signage uh with a little paint but um it's movable uh and it turned out really nice uh again I just want to highlight some of the uh options at the high school uh the picks here are added after the construction uh and it just to Showcase what we're able to do uh through the renovation process and all the different items that were added uh and we're able to
067Showcase and offer more offerings uh because of the renovation so I didn't think salad bars were going to come back after Co didn't think they were ever coming you know open self- serve items but uh they did in the student it's it's probably one of our hardest hit uh stations that and the vegetarian uh station was a surprise too at at how busy it is uh next slide is a good breakdown of our Blue Street Cafe that opened in the high school um we got a full year of data in on it uh so we average about 400 drinks a day that go out there are lattes and hot chocolates uh iced hot chocolates and iced lattes uh for the students so it's part of the reimbursable meals and for the one-year snapshot uh the
068blue Street Cafe increased uh reimbursable breakfasts at the high school uh over 27,000 breakfasts which is an insane number to hit in one year and increase uh in breakfasts alone so that um I know the staff and everyone is really proud of that uh that that number growth in one year is is pretty incredible uh it is a great partnership with the cares program uh we average about eight hours uh a week of care students that come in and work uh on register they work the machine see if I can get it this is a video of the student uh working it's kind of the future it's a smart Barista machine so it grinds the bean it grinds steams the milk uh adds flavoring in uh in about 30 seconds a cup uh which is
069pretty cool so you'll see them start going in they're in Starbucks uh Duncan uh it's kind of the future where before you know you're steaming by hand you're Brewing the espresso um okay sorry super loud um so it it's it's the future and the way companies are going um with these machines so students are in there learning they can get a job at Dunkin Donut Starbucks um we have about 20 coffee shops in Saratoga alone downtown which um is really great but it gives them the ability to to learn the machine learn drinks learn the register work in a space um so they can get a job right out of high school uh just to highlight uh it is we're going in our second year of C for free meals um between the building Renovations
070at the high school in Dorothy Nolan uh and CP we've seen an average of a 20% increase in meals uh I put in the reimbursement rates just to give um the board an idea of what we receive for C it's about 5050 from the state and fed go uh $247 breakfast $457 cents for lunch um so half comes from the federal government half of that comes from the state and again if there's any advocacy coming up every year that number um has to be renewed in the budget and shed up um or it would be detrimental to us and we might not be able to provide uh free meals every year if that's not voted on in the spring um the breakdown I just wanted to give a breakdown of the uh of our food
071cost which is uh been been the biggest battle since covid uh we spend close to $2 million on food uh this past year that's about 45% of my budget uh food cost has increased I pulled I pulled numbers uh from US Foods so per case uh per case average of what we're getting in every day has gone up $10 in the last two years um so that's a big chunk of our plate when you look at we're receiving $457 uh per reimbursable meal for lunch half of that is going to food cost it really doesn't leave a lot for piece of the plate that's labor piece that's equipment uh health insurance chemicals paper supplies that all goes in um so again uh when it goes back to any advocacy it's always great to you know
072push it's great Shore it up get us the number but also we we we are desperate for a DAT increase so uh the good news with the renovation and CP we're averaging about 4,000 reimbursable lunches per day across the district which is an amazing number um the picture there is also from Dorothy Nolan uh it was our biggest day in the district so far uh we served 4,200 Dino Nugget day which um which surprisingly it was the biggest day at the high school you would think it would you know you'd think it'd be uh just Elementary but high school kids love nuggets uh this was a little infograph just to show what a reimbursable meal is this was made by our uh Sienna uh intern just to help with the start of the high school
073uh year so it kind of gives a snapshot when they go to the register just what you need to grab for it to count as a reimbursable meal so it is counted free and you're not as a parent paying Alo cart prices uh for those meals uh the challenge with the high school is that it's a scattershot design so they can pick and choose what they want they can go and get chicken tenders the main meal slice of pizza but they can also hit the salad bar and mix and match uh all over so um just an educational piece for them next slide was just year year totals um we did over 6,300 uh lunches over 200,000 breakfasts last year uh I just gave a breakdown of we we purchased 11 tons of apples from
074Saratoga Apple uh we served over 400,000 New York apple slices in the bag that's that's probably our most popular fruit that goes out um we serve 35 uh tons of chicken and nine tons of baby carrots a lot of carrots uh next pick is from uh National milk day uh we partnered with King Derry which I have in the back a cooler so if everybody could grab a chocolate milk on the way out I also have uh honey honey crisp apples from Saratoga Apple available back there as well uh this was a great day we had 4,200 bottles of King uh King Dairy chocolate milk and white milk that was given out throughout the district uh Queenie came out to Division Street uh for some pictures with the students uh and it was a great
075partnership with a local uh milk producer uh we wanted to do a couple shoutouts uh for support throughout the district uh one is for uh Caroline and Erica from pupil Services they came up with an idea to do a pictograph uh menu so to help with uh special needs students uh to pick their meal for the day and it kind of snowball from there so our upk classes use it uh kindergarten asked for it so it kind of went out to to to a bunch of places and more more teachers uh and principles have been asking for it uh because it's a great learning tool so we wanted to say thank you uh next is a Greenfield they every every month the Greenfield art class changes out their um board in the hallway to update
076it uh with our menu uh they enjoy doing it and it looks really good also want to say uh thank you to Wendy and the maple La student council uh Wendy reached out for uh coffee sleeves from the blue Street Cafe uh for her students to give inspirational messages to uh the high school students and I was like oh that's that's cool I don't know are high school kids going to like that and then yes they toally really loved it which I was surprised they they're like we love the messages and it and it kind of took off so every month we we get a case over to Maple uh the students decorate it and um and and really really like the positive messages that come out of it uh just a look ahead for
077our department uh we have the lake a renovation coming up this summer uh the Caroline renovation as well uh we're looking to expand summer meals across the district uh it looks like there's positive with how the census data and the mapping tool worked we had some challenges last year of where we could operate uh throughout the district with the lunch truck um it it's been extremely popular um and we had a lot of feedback I'm involved with a collaborative group through the United Way in Albany we meet every month to go through the challenges that um every district is facing in the capital region uh with Summer meals and how we need to operate but um we've been getting more and more asks to uh provide meals over the summer uh from different camps different
078locations so we're we're very excited with with the new data that looks like it's coming out uh to be able to offer more sites throughout the district this summer uh we also one of the challenges with how much meals have increased with C somebody comment um with meals expanding and our numbers going up is sourcing local products a lot of times um we reach out and and Farms local producers just can't meet the amount of food that we're going through um for an order so uh we're looking to re-engage um locally within Saratoga it's hard when you talk about New York State you know there's a big push for New York State products local and it's hard to define local where we are you know if you talk New York state products is that stuff
079that comes from Long Island or finger lakes or where you so we really drilled down and said we're going to focus on just Saratoga County and what comes out and what we can buy uh right next door with our neighbors so um and then last is just um just a focus on increasing breakfast participation all the buildings you can see the numbers for lunch are so high breakfast we do have a good participation rate uh compared to other districts it's it's challenging um but we do want to focus and see what the barriers are and why and help increase breakfasts um across all all business buildings thanks any questions thanks Eric um it's always a pleasure to encounter you and not just because you bring treats and uh I guess our our friends in the
080public should know that whenever we we often have a workshop the board has a workshop and Eric's team caters it and it's amazing and so thank you for that too um I want to ask about morale among your people and how how would you know uh if morale was strong or not strong and um have you gotten a bump from all the infrastructure improvements I would say yes we've just had a little turnover over break with losing losing a couple staff um that we weren't expecting uh we have three open positions if anybody is interested um but uh morale seems high I think people are looking forward uh staff is looking forward to the negotiations that are going on um they're looking forward to the summer you know in a renovated space I my staff
081really loves that the students love what they're doing you know so it it kind of changes the dynamic when you're putting out you know you you're putting out good food but maybe the facility is 20 30 years at a date and it's just it looks rough you know and now in a new space they're they're excited and they're energized and anytime you know through the high school Dorothy Nolan uh division um Greenfield now it's this excitement of look how good it looks in here look how good the food looks like people are coming in so you you hear that a lot more uh in the building so that's exciting going through you know the whole process of renovation and and on that end hearing that from the employees so I would say on that end
082morale is definitely up I I have a regular focus group at home and uh the results are always very positive in recent recent years please thank your team for all the good work other questions from the board I I do want to thank you for the work you do with the care students I think that's amazing to utilize them in the cafe and give them like life skills that way um love the coffee sleeves and the positive messages that's such a unique um crossover from our two buildings that's great and thank you for the hint on advocating for the C will do thanks Bobby made sure I got that in there all right thank you so much thanks thank you just a shout out kudos to Eric the entire food services staff um you know
083you have the opportunity as parents you probably hear from your kids but you know for the incredible work that they do and the relationships that our staff creates with students as they go through the lunch line and uh to see some of the renovations kind of come to life now uh we have other school districts that are constantly requesting to come visit uh Saratoga and see all the great things that are that are happening here and uh through Eric and his team's leadership uh we really have uh kind of stood out when it comes to uh Food Services operations uh in our region so keep up the great work so now we want to turn over to our second presentations from our facilities and operations uh Department our director of facilities John Tiner and our
084assistant director uh Mike Goodwin and Dave alhamdu our assistant superintendent uh will be helping out thank you Mike I was going to introduce the team but you did it for me so thank you um it's only been 10 and a half months since we last presented uh we swapped with another group here and presented early this year and never in 25 minutes could we describe all the great things that have happened in facilities in 10 and a half months in 25 minutes so uh thank you for the opportunity we'll try to be succinct so this presentation every year is structured on the five primary goals that we have here in facilities and how they tie in with the district vision and then evidence of how we accomplish those goals so I'm going to talk about
085the first goal which is broaden the impact of facilities management on student achievement I'm going to show you examples of what we've done so obviously we've talked about the Legacy project um but I don't know if everybody understands the impact that it has on our department and the correlation that we have to have in the daily communication with our head custodians and our maintenance staff all the meetings that I have to attend whether it's project meetings or facilities llt it's an incredible undertaking and uh Bill's team and Pike and all the contractors do an incredible job but we have to communicate and we have to help them Implement and get into our buildings and coordinate all that work so in the last um so far to date it's been over I should I had the
086presentation in front of me $46 million worth of work construction that's taken place and we've had a big piece of that and helping to coordinate that um and it's a lot of work believe me can't reiterate that enough and but the results are incredible and it's been talked about in Eric's presentation and other presentations how it impacts our students and the community so this one's really really cool this is here at Maple and I can't take a lot of credit for this this was Mitch Schnider our athletic director John Goodson came to us in June of 2024 asking for our help to map out trails and to help them get this bike program off the ground here at at Maple and uh so we had to scramble we had to get you know property committee
087had convened for the year so you had to email everybody out get their input and approve these trails and um it's been amazing I have a video here but just seeing the kids out in the woods riding the riding the bikes and um all the I'll play the video so this is Mitch Snider here out with the kids black diamond what I do there so yeah so it's pretty awesome it's great that we're able to be a part of that we had to make sure the trails were safe that where the trails were mapped out was adequate and then we had to make some minor improvements to make sure they were safe so kudos to Maple Avenue and um it's been an awesome program so as you remember last year around this time we had
088some Community concern about the condition of our restrooms I just wanted to provide an update on that um since then we've done the lower G and upper G restrooms we put new partitions in painted the walls spruced up the rooms throughout the Legacy project every building is getting some new bathrooms so that's slowly kicking in and then we also uh redid the administration Wing female bathroom on the second floor so we continue to work on this we're also slowly going to convert to hand dryers to save on paper use more efficient less vandalism if you don't have paper to put down the toilets believe it or not so um so we're going to continue to work on that painting is huge obviously you know studies show a well-lit well painted environment for students increases student
089achievement so it's one of the cheapest ways just like in your home if you're selling your house so every year we take on projects painting this year we did more classrooms in the high school we painted the um tennis shed which really needed some attention and you can see the handrails up there and all the stairwells got painted I know if you remember a couple years ago we had a contractor come in and paint all the corridors on the second floor of the high school so it's made a big impact I'm going to turn it over to Mike good one to talk a little about about Safety and Security Systems thank you I'm Mike Goodwin assistant director facilities I've been with this place forever um basically I'm going to go over some of the enhanced
090School Safety and Security Systems and stuff we deal with you know each year first um we're doing another installation of a speed zone light up at Greenfield um this one was a little bit more extensive John had to go through do to uh get this one moving a little bit more we didn't quite get it in this year because of the uh the cold coming in we weren't able to to uh put the footings down in for the uh the northern uh speed zone light um the blue lights we uh did a little more signage where there a little bit more you could see those towards the entrances um basically we also installed baronet boxes which Dave was you know Dave and John have been working on that also trying to get them you know
091uh tweaked and tuned in right so they actually work they were installed at Dorothy Nolan in Greenfield um they've gone through testing on those and to get them working properly there's a lot of components to that and if they all have to work in sync I mean they're they're it's taking The Human Side out of things putting it into a uh a mechanical thing where it'll automatically call 911 so nobody has to say hey anybody call 911 this will actually do this for us radio communications we're always looking to improve our systems we're always buying radios batteries um we're going to go through and do it um some more training and also um looking at our inventory and assess the needs of what we need um generally we buy 10 to 15 new radios each
092year um lead testing and the drinking water um with new revisions this year it used to be 15 parts per billion now it's down to five parts per billion um we've installed a lot of the the um bottle filling stations which are actually lead filtering um units each one of them is like $1,500 um but we're putting in more of those um we're going to start we're mandated this year to start it's the end of the three-year cycle we have to uh test go through and do a retesting of all the um the potable water sources in the district and um then it will be on again another cycle three years on that we also have a meshify system which we work with nyser and uh Harford steam boiler this was a system they were
093wanting to test out and we've actually put sensors in different parts of different buildings to see if there's um it checks for temperature humidity um pipe changes in temperature um so we got basically little sensors out throughout the buildings different buildings and they actually come to our phones and they're always going off on our phones telling us if there's an issue with something but it's a it's a system that we're tweaking more which I think is added protection you know to help the district in case there is emergencies and stuff I turn it over to Dave thank you Mike so just briefly want to talk about some of the uh Capital project we call them Capital project or inhouse work that we do um facilities takes done a lot of things you see a lot
094of pictures tonight a lot of work that we do um so I'm just going to highlight three um one is an operation graduation classroom a Lake Avenue sensory room and you'll see that we redid the high school white gym floor um I don't know if Eric is still here but he showed how the renovations went for the cafeteria well some of you remember we actually had to use the white gym for the temporary cafeteria but it kind of did a some significant damage to the floor so we fixed all that facilities fixed all that so operation graduation so this is a new program for the high school it's a support program for our students um helping them to meet those graduation requirements so basically um we had to get create two new classrooms um one
095classroom was kind of already there but the picture on the top left is a storage closet as you can see um pretty heavyduty uh storage benches in there um and shelving all that had to be removed out uh we had to fix the ceilings floors they had to repaint stuff we had to add wireless network work um they had to we put whiteboard in across the existing chalkboard so again it came out really really nice you can see that in that picture on the right they also had um redid a storage room at Lake Avenue and created a sensory room so this room includes a small instructional area in case a student or a small group of students need a quiet place for instruction um it also has a smaller enclosed caling area that provides
096even more privacy decreased simulation and sensory items um students use this space throughout the day um sometimes it's part of their normal routine or if they just eat it but it came out really really well um it actually we have a wiring closet that I'm not sure they realized that when they first looked at it but we kind of came up with some creative ways to make sure the wiring closet was Secure and kind of covered so work together on that one and as I said this is the high school white white gym the floor and again um we had to move our cafeteria down there and it worked out pretty well having our cafeteria in the white gym temporarily but as I said it did a lot of damage to the floor so these
097folks had to we had contractors come in they had to sand it all the way down um they put in a new logo new paint work with our athletic department coaches I changed the design a little bit there uh put new finish on and it came out outstanding looks awesome so I think I'm hand stuff back to Mike basically we're going over uh ways we uh improve Department of morale through our team building and promotion of ownership and duties and responsibilities um there's different things that we do this is our eighth annual golf tournament John and I work on it I mean it's a constant you know show of love to our employees I mean it's great to have everybody get together it's um this last time we had 72 uh people participate in it
098um it's also a fun raising that we do for project lift um our department raised over $116,000 over the last eight years I mean we raise about $3,000 each year for it and we present it over to the Franklin Community Center to uh work with a project lift on it I'll let John say something about this picture so for many years truste Ellis was a strong supporter of getting new grounds equipment and new equipment um as was his former occupation of balson spa School District so I thought who better to take this over as our new sponsor than than trustee Culligan and um so every year we're going to highlight a new piece of equipment that he sponsors so um we're really excited about this thanks this is one of our uh recent pickup trucks
099that we bought for Caroline Street we were're always trying to improve our uh Fleet and um I think we're doing a pretty good job John's doing a pretty good job at you know um budgeting for new vehicles which uh we're in desperate need of them I mean we've gotten rid of a few over ones that are pretty Rusty um we wind up auctioning them off this is our uh deck mower that we got for the uh high school we wind up taking the mower that that replaced and moving over to Maple Avenue which we needed it over there um and these things aren't cheap this this is our swasy um line painter for the athletic fields we went through a bunch of different Turf tank mini robot um and this was the best choice that
100we could find that actually had the most functionability that this unit you could actually it was comfortable using setting up and then if you actually had to paint lines you could actually use it just like a regular line painter grab a hold of it put it in manual and do it this thing is amazing to watch this thing once you set it up and just let it go and it just does Fields it's amazing the accuracy on this thing is is topnotch even compared to the other ones that we looked at I mean it was amazing yeah it's amazing to watch this thing go across the field you're think what's it doing what's it doing it has a program thing you'll go off and it paints an area then comes back around but it does
101it the most efficient way that is programmed too these are some of the professional developments we do a lot of these are also New York State mandated stuff you know like the uh water um plant operation certification the espesa certification that's all mandated by New York state that we have to fulfill keep our licenses up through the district I'll turn it back over to John thank you Mike so our last uh our last goal for our department is improving efficiency and our preventive maintenance and provot promoting creative thinking and we really really try to stick with that if a staff member comes up and says hey I got this idea we always listen sometimes we have to say no it's a little too far out there but uh we've had some folks and I've showed
102it in presentations throughout the years of some great ideas people have had so I'm going to talk about some struggles we've had here at the middle school with the well pumps that we had issues with um some a creative solution with our boilers and some of the Energy savings initiatives that we've been doing so at Maple Avenue we had um one well pump go down we we had to quickly switch over to the other one and then we found out after we had a vendor come in and replace the pump that there was a dead short underneath the concrete where you walked in this building tonight so yeah so imagine dealing with that snow was starting to fly um so we had multiple vendors here as you can see Mike and I were out digging
103um it was a lot of work we found a solution um we finally got it up in running res recently and so we're going to replace the other pump just to be safe so that they're the same age uh the new pumps are a lot more efficient and um they're also a lower horsepower the the original ones were oversized so it'll use less Energy new pumps a lot more efficient the end goal and we've tried this many times is to try to get Municipal Water here at Maple but there's a lot of players involved um you have to go through grants with multiple agencies and at this point we're still not able to do it but when you have well water in a building that has 1,300 students and 200 staff it's worrisome at times
104so hopefully down the road eventually we can get Municipal Water here so I've been dealing with these older boilers that we have since I came here 13 years ago and the controllers for these Airco boilers are proprietary you can only get them from one vendor when I started here they were $4,000 now they're $7,000 luckily in the Legacy project we're replacing boilers in a lot of the buildings but not until Legacy 3 will we be able to replace these remaining boilers so we did extensive research looked everywhere turned every stone over and finally recently found a vendor that an electronics repair vendor that actually can rebuild them so instead of spending $7,000 per controller which they're all failing it's under $1,000 and they have a 2-year warranty so that was a PO up there from
105a couple years ago it cost us $32,000 to have five of them installed and I just purchased one that's going in in a couple weeks for under $1,000 and we've been looking a long time so this was a great find Energy savings again we talk about the new boilers are extremely more efficient um I've looked at all the our energy data for both Natural Gas and Electric I see Trends going down unfortunately costs are projected to go up we just got a new report recently Bobby and I both saw it from nmic which is the energy Consortium that we belong to um but our usage is going down so not only not only electricity but with natural gas but we're also continue to install LED lights which is a huge saving in energy um whenever
106we have to replace lights in a building we convert it to led a lot lot of our parking lot lights which are huge energy users are converted to LED and then we've gotten a lot more aggressive with our setbacks for when we're on occupied mode and as you can see in that diagram it's a little hard to see that's just from 6:00 a.m. to 3:30 or 4 p.m. and then we go back to 65 degrees so that's saved a lot of energy as well and we've always had the setbacks but we're just getting more aggressive with them so again we're trying to save money wherever we can when budget constraints are difficult last year I reported on some of the challenges our department faced this is just an update um you know again Supply costs
107and Equipment have gone up significantly uh last year in the budget the 10% cuts that were made were restored that was a huge help to us unfortunately our trash uh contract went up $52,000 um when it was originally in the 80s so that's a significant increase that we didn't budget for so that's another challenge um and though a lot of our mechanical systems are past their recommended useful life we're continuing to replace Parts upgrade through the Legacy project when possible and uh just continue to do preventive maintenance our grounds and custodial equipment continues to age out as you can see we got that brand new beautiful mower the other mower is only four years old that we moved to Maple Avenue for a while we were transporting it back and fourth and that was very
108inefficient and a lot of wear and tear um and we we're doing a pretty good job filling positions we've been doing interviews almost every week the last month try to fill custodial positions one of the challenges been the cafeteria cleaner positions they're part-time they don't pay as much money and we had converted two of them in Prior budgets so we're trying to convert the last two positions over um I used money within my own budget and that's one of the proposals we have for this upcoming budget here's our org chart I know John always likes this um you know we have eight head custodians we have a maintenance supervisor a ground supervisor and a head grounds monitor um we have a ton of Subs that we have to use and some part-time staff we used
109to have 23 summer workers we've cut that down to 20 but we're lucky if we get 10 so that's always a challenge and they're so critically important especially with the capital project to help get our buildings cleaned and turned over in a short period of time that's it questions Natalia um first I have a comment about the like outside lighting which is that I had to drop my kid off at school one day during a fire drill and obviously didn't know there was a fire drill until I arrived but it was so obvious what was going on and what to do and I thought that was awesome um I have a question that I'm sorry I didn't submit in advance if you don't have an answer that's okay but I know that the state recently
110passed legislation about classroom temperatures so now there's that maximum temp of 88 degrees but also we have to take action at 82 degrees so first of all it sounds like those meshify sensors will make tracking that much easier um but second how like is there planning going on for that and um is that something that we are prepared for yeah at our Legacy LLC facilities committee we we talked about that in our last meeting there's obviously a lot more involved with that um there's only so many ways you can cool down a building um I think moving forward in capital projects we've already started to look at putting dual coil units in renovated classrooms so we have more air conditioned space obviously that's millions and millions of dollars worth of work to do throughout buildings
111throughout the district you know we started at Lake Avenue in Phase One of legacy and we cooled the whole thing third floor because that was the hottest area in the district but you're right it's a big Challenge and and I've talked with all my counterparts throughout the state and um you know there's going to be a lot of planning and and implementation with that and as well as our organization is lobbying to change a few things with that law and to make some things more specific and more attainable so we are working on that other questions Beth um thank you for the great presentation and more than a question I just have a comment it really comes through um in your presentation that you're very focused on the people in your area and the people
112that your team um and I just I wanted to recognize that because I think if you have a team that is feeling connected and respected and valued that um you're going to get good work um with that um as a byproduct so what you all do is really important obviously um it impacts everything that happens in the district and so I just wanted to say that really stood out um and I remember that from last year as well um and I just thank kudos to you all for um building that sort of um dynamic in your in your department so well done uh just a question uh sort of based on the recent article I forget what periodical it was in I think it might have been the Times Union but uh it was on
113the unexpected findings you know of of lead uh in in fixtures rather than in pipes that should have you know were placed after the the lead era did you guys find any of that um uh and is the effort to put in those water stations is that part of the solution to to sort of replace fixtures that might be um causing any uh elevated lead scores so I'm glad you brought that up back in 2016 when we first had to do the initial round of lead testing when we started to do remediation it's the first thing we figured out that when you replace a fixture a lot of times it's addressing the issue even sometimes Le a lot of times lead is supplied to the building at a higher level than the threshold and that
114was at 15 parts per billion now we're at five um but replacing fixtures with lead free fixtures has made a significant difference um and then again the other part of your question is you know um we've been budgeting for bottle filling stations since that time so every year I buy at least 10 sometimes 15 sometimes more bottle filling stations and during Co we shut down all the bubblers um and even when they wanted them back in service I was like No we're going to wait we're only going to turn on the bottle filling stations since then SD is clarified SED facilities planning that you can't just have a bottle Filling Station to count as an outlet you have to have X amount of outlets per 100 students 100 occupants so we've turned the bubblers on
115since but because they have those carbon filters they filter lead out they always come back non-detectable even though even though we have to test them so that is the goal to continue to buy more of those and Implement them and use less SNS we're putting signage up that says um non-drinking water nonpotable in most of the sinks in the district so that we don't have to test those thanks I I just I I love the and this is all part of that I love the contemporaneous relevance of your every year of your presentations I mean you guys you reference other presentations you you um you respond to year old Community things that you've Community concerns that you've remembered uh collaborating with students like The the girl you brought in from um from Greenfield about LED
116lights um I it just I think it shows that you're you're listening and um and it and putting some care and thought into these things I I I for one as a board member appreciate that so thanks thank you last comment I guess I just really want want to recognize and thank you for all the work that you do with all the ongoing Legacy project it's been going on since I've been on the board so it's been pretty much non-stop for your department and I just thank you for all the coordination and the extra work and care that you do to take care of some of those things we're trying to do so thank you so much for all the things you do to make that work yeah we talk about construction fatigue I'm retiring
117in 32 or 33 and that's when Legacy 3 ends so what about my my construction fatigue thank you I'm not thank you so much so thank uh thank you to John and Mike and Dave and it's obvious obviously to the board and the community and to our staff how much our facilities and operations team you know all the custodians all the facilities folks our grounds folks how much pride they take in their work and how impressive our facilities are uh I always say when we have an opportunity to host and we bring folks from other districts all the time they're amazed about how clean and how well-kept and how safe our our facilities uh look and so uh but that obviously comes with a lot of effort um so we continue to invest in facilities
118through our Capital Project work uh and that can only happen obviously with the folks and Facilities operations who kind of make it happen every day so um again want to thank um John and Mike for their leadership and the entire team for their tremendous efforts throughout the year and that's it for presentations all right this brings us to our consent agenda do we have any modifications Tony we do indeed um we are pulling um I3 for a roll call vote that's the previously mentioned uh Seeker resolution uh so I um I'm not sure which uh well let's I I'll read it I'm going to read part of it and as I discussed with board members earlier today I'm not going to read the whole thing we're supposed to read this um into the record and
119I'm going to read the main um pieces of it but then I'm going to leave about two-thirds that you've all taken a look at the enumerated pieces um uh I'm going to leave those unread in the interest of time but the uh Seeker resolution reads whereas the Board of Education of the city school District of Saratoga Springs is considering to undertake a project involving exterior site improvements and site work at various school buildings and sites along with various interior building Renovations and or reconstruction at the same various school buildings and sites and all Associated work related to such site and interior work all of which is more fully described on the attached Seeker rep project description dated December 2 2024 which is attached here to and made a part hereof all of which will occur
120on existing sites the project and whereas this is one sentence whereas the board wishes to fully comply with its obligations under the state the Seeker Act and the regulations there under with respect to the project and whereas some of the above School building sites are separately geographically with no are separated geographically with no environmental impacts between them for Seeker determination purposes with the only connection being that the entire project is subject to a single funding source and vote by the residents of the school district end of first sentence therefore the board will consider this as one single resolution to negate any perception of segmentation and whereas the board has carefully considered the nature and scope of the project received the considered advice of the project architect with respect to the potential for environmental impacts resulting
121from the project and whereas the board of education has reviewed the proposed action with respect to the type two criteria set forth in the Seeker regulations at six is a a long um uh I guess the the name of the act and has determined that the proposed action is a type two action pursuant to another section 61 7.5 etc etc of the Seeker regulations and whereas say upon reviewing of the foregoing the board makes the following determinations that's where I end those determinations are enumerated 1 through 4 and um you've all read them so uh resolved that a copy of this resolution shall be sent to um any involved or interested agencies including the Department of Environmental Conservation and the New York State Department of Education that being said I move that we uh take
122a roll call vote and approve that resolution I get a second Connie roll call truste AA yes truste crackler yes trusty Amory yes truste Braxton yes trusty bugman yes trusty Colligan yes trusty Copans trusty laki yes trusty white toich yes thank you so that being done I move that we approve the consent agenda items g h and I as Modified by what we just did uh with the roll call Action um yeah I that's what I move second Natalia you had a lot of work tonight Natalia second is there any discussion on any of these iies okay seeing none all in favor that is unanimous thank you so just a recognition on tonight's uh agenda uh the board just accepted um the resignations for the purposes of retirement of three of our teachers uh Jeffrey
123holstead our music teacher at the high school Carrie Rosner reading teacher at Dorothy Nolan and Colleen Waterhouse uh occupational therapist for the district all three um have submitted their plans for retirement the the end of the school year June 30th so just want to congratulate to all of our retirees and thank them for their many years of service to our students uh throughout their careers here in the district thanks Mike um all right this brings us to our second public comment period um all of my introduction stands I think you all here so um I will start with our list again um as it was and then open it up to others who would like to speak um first up is Casey Chau hi folks um I am a parent of two kids at Lake
124Avenue kids who have been Busters for their entirety of their Lake Avenue experience and many of the concerns I have with the proposed policy have already been really artfully represented so I just wanted to raise a couple of things that haven't been the first is that I'm sure my family is not an exception in that Mr Eric represents like a very Beloved Community member of my kids K5 experience and I want to implore the board if they haven't already to really um earnestly enlist our current bus drivers in the conversation about what this policy might be I worry that we might try to engineer a policy and create a problem for our current excellent bus drivers that undermines our ability to be able to retain them um I also wondered about this number this 85
125number that you've mentioned before Dr P and given that my understanding is the budget uh is only representing 75 bus driver lines so that discrepancy struck me as a concern and I wonder if we could get some clarity on it and then the last point I wanted to make is just folks have already I think done a nice job um highlighting the importance of or the concerns about bringing kids home at five o'clock in the dark um especially young kids I want to highlight too that for older Elementary age kids many of their extracurriculars begin at 5 o'clock um they're often you know 15 20 even 30 minutes away um so for me my kids home at like 3:58 on the bus every day and it is a wild turnaround to get them into the
126right clothing and with water bottles and with a snack and into the car and picking up the car pool to get to you know Gavin park or to Luther forest or whatever and I I worry that for the kids whose schools exit late we're going to be sort of disproportionately undermined in our ability to enlist our kids and meaningful extracurricular experiences that have been super important for us simultaneously hurting our local nonprofits like saratova shredders um in enrolling uh robust uh kid like you know rolling enrolling robustly from our K5 schools thanks thank you uh next up is Katie Rogue I hope I did that last name service is there a KD in the house Ro Rock RQ okay thank you um next up is Charles GLE good evening Charles got I have a first
127grader at Dorothy Nolan and a future kindergartener next year that will also be at Dorothy Nolan I appreciate that the alternatives are going to be more vetted I completely agree with everything that every parent uh said this evening including the teacher that had the the this schedule proposed south of the Twin Bridges and it was a complete failure as well as the pediatrician that spoke about the health effects that this will have on all the kids including my own my students or my kids would have a 10: a.m. start date at Dorothy Nolan again this is not healthy some kids actually depend on the school breakfast or they won't have breakfast so that should be considered it destroys the parents abilities to work kids won't have after school opportunities I have hockey at 5:00 pm
128soccer at 500 p.m dance at 4:20 baseball at 5:00 p.m. it decreases the ability of the students to learn and it's also going to discourage families to move to our community the big reason we moved here was because of this school district some families won't move here because they can't have their kids start school at 10: a.m. um what I heard this evening was way more comprehensive than the presentation we heard last month um the presentation said and this is a quote from the presentation that this is the solution so I'm happy that calmer Minds have prevailed and there will be more Alternatives but what I'd like to really touch on now is that we need more experts to assess those Alternatives it shouldn't be the experts that did that presentation because they only had
129one solution this board has a fiduciary duty to the families and the students in our community um so we should explore additional experts look for bus bus efficiencies in our current routing systems let's take a look at the flexible overlay zones I know multiple neighborhoods that have more three buses some for just one student in one single neighborhood that to me just doesn't make sense I'm not an expert on this uh but logic should prevail um and we also heard the facilities directors in Department today and what a great job they do at fostering a good working environment I know there are labor issues with paying bus drivers more and hopefully we can overcome that but maybe there can be a better working environment because working environments retain people and bus drivers um so a
13010: a.m. start date for my kids should be completely off the table it should not even be one of the Alternatives that are considered again this board has a fiduciary duty to find new Consultants do a more comprehensive study and I implore the board to include the teachers that we heard this evening the parents that we heard this evening including the pediatrician that we heard this evening none of that was considered in our current study um and that's a little bit irresponsible so thank you for your time and have a nice evening thank you Jill dolinski hi thank you very much um I am a parent of a incoming kindergartener a current first and fourth grader at Lake Avenue so for two years time I will have an elementary school student Middle School student and
131high school student in the district um I would like to speak to the presentation I watched the board meeting uh last month and I have spent some time looking at her slides and similar to our last speaker I am a little confused by some of the data or lack thereof so for one thing in looking at the distri comparison Slide the latest any other District dismisses any student is 3:30 p.m. I think 10:00 a.m. to be clear later than a 920 start is too late for any student in our district it is not conducive to our society's normal operating hours so to flip-flop all of this around having a two and a half hour Span in the morning and a two-hour Gap in the afternoon I would be surprised if that's the only solution that
132we have to this problem particularly because our district rollment is going down as others have said and we've been able to manage with a two-tier system for years previously in addition um I'd like to comment that when you look at the elementary schools that will be on the less desirable schedule whether that may be an early tier a mid tier a late tier you seem to have put the schools with special needs students where the schools that support special needs students in those tiers which may be logical because it's more bust ing needs but you're talking about taking families that already have more challenges finding proper care outside of school for their children and then putting them at a more disadvantage a more difficult time finding care whether they're dismissed early or late um so
133I find that really alarming as well and I'm not sure if that was considered finally I'll mention that while there are scheduling conflicts I am most concerned about the educational needs of my children and 10:00 a.m. or super early for high school super early for elementary super early for or super late either way it is not academically in their best interest and anyone who thinks that this is the proposal that's putting our students first I also question that thank you and I am referencing things I heard in the previous meeting thank you very much thank you Anna ventry hi I'm Anna ventry I have um two children in the district I am neighbors of two of the people on the board here um we live in an awesome awesome place and I think I second
134what many people have said in that schools are the heart of communities it's really really really important that people trust their school district and like feel connected to their community and I think that's something at saratogo we all really agree with um I'm also a teacher uh my teacher BR Albin I'm a m teacher I teach Middle School a lot of what the other teachers said really resonated with me um I think heing about this was somewhat disconcerting just given the lack of communication with the community we have so many smart people that live here and work here that care about this community um that I just I it it boggles my mind that this is our our only best solution um Mr Patton when you said earlier that you guarantee that this will not
135be a change that's made in the beginning of the year it stood out to me that you didn't say this is not a change that will happen at all next year um I can say as a parent we have to sign up for daycare in April or May um and that is for the entirety of the school year so I would love to hear from you that this is something that's not going to happen next school year or that it is going to happen next school year but I feel like it is grossly not okay to leave that open and Up For Debate mid year because that is just like a huge challenge to many many families um and then the last thing I want to say is I guess the first thing that came
136to mind when I read this was we're struggling to find bus drivers and so we're going to make a schedule that is less conducive to to them so I just would love to see some data on like who are these bus drivers that have stuck it out with our district and like that we rely on because I know Mr Mike makes a huge difference in my own children's life um and me knowing him and knowing that he's like a safe place for them is is really great to know um and so I guess with with these bus drivers that are here and have shown up year-over-year like have we pulled them do we know how this would affect them in their lives and their families um or is this only going to make the problem
137bigger and give us a larger Gap in our busing and so I would also encourage you to think about like schedules that would be more conducive to those people in our community across the board that we rely on for schools and school communities as you all know um really really really rely on all of those background people the janitors the um lunch staff the person that says hello in the morning in the office um the Tas the teachers the administration yeah it's great but like all these small behind the scenes people are really what makes the school the school so thank you so much for your time I appreciate you taking the time to think about the best solution thank you Christina Kim so I wasn't going to speak but um I think I can
138offer a perspective that might be helpful to the board um I was a single parent in the district that is no longer the case I'm in a much more privileged position now however I was impacted by base cuts and I guess it's even just a privilege to be at this meeting it means I have someone at home who can watch my children um and I think we need to consider the fact that a lot of the people who are going to be most impacted by this change who have the least resources also aren't represented here right now um and so I think that's just something we have to think about and that's really all I have to say so yeah thank you Claire Ingram Claire oh hi good evening my name is Claire Ingram I
139have two children elake Avenue in kindergarten and in third grade um I'm going to try to not repeat things that have previously said been said but I Echo a lot of what has been said um so am going to try and keep it pointed to new new items like numerous other families I do have deep concerns with a previously proposed plan the seemingly limited input that led to them and the fact that this that it displaces a large portion of the burden with high cost and consequences onto the shoulders of families organizations and members of our community all of whom are also facing High new and unrelenting post-pandemic challenges like many other families both my husband and I work in Albany um we both work um and have to commute requiring us to leave home
140one and a half to two and a half hours before our kids' current School stay uh start time as an aside I just want to point out that we are not unique many many families in Saratoga Springs have dual income out of necessity in recent years Saratoga Springs has ranked third highest in all of New York state for greatest income disparity it's a necessity for dual working income families based on our home's location we are also ineligible for busing which is both a transportation and Child Care Resource that many families and more families may be unable to access and rely upon if the busing radius eligibility policy is changed so our family utilizes the YMCA's before and after school base program due to staffing issues a universal and chronic challenge we have been cut from
141base like many families in the past completely un upending Our Lives requiring to make significant changes to our work schedules at a moment's notice notice with tangible impacts on our perceived of professionalism and reliability by our colleagues and employers we're extremely fortunate to have family members in the area who also work however so we are not really able to rely upon them without them also facing those consequences with their employers flexibility has limits additional context to take into consideration since our family began using Bas Services just three years ago the cost for before and after for one child has increased by 49% and like many families we now have two kids in base our family has had to navigate the impact of challenges and District policy changes before our oldest was in the first class
142of students subject to flex zone enforcement while we needed as previously mentioned to sign up for school before and after child care services in April we did not learn about our school placement until the third week of August that is stress that is unnecessary to place upon families who are already stressed compounded stress and the strongest sense possible I want to urge the district to cons to ensure it is considering the Broad Ripple effect that potential policies will have for families including as mentioned those who cannot be here tonight because of the costs and the limited access to child care those who will be most likely most disproportionately impacted by such a change for the community from those who are providing child that upe to to employers I can I um I also want to
143ask how the district has has uh considered how schedule changes will impact teacher and bus driver satisfaction retention and recruitment thank you thank you that was the end of our sign up list but we are open to others who would like to speak if there is anybody left my name is Thomas Kemet I used to be a resident of the district I'm also an employee um I do Drive School Bus for the district um what I'm hearing mostly is that all of a sudden now we have an issue with school bus needs um for the three years that I've been employed with the district it's always been an issue even prior to Derry joining um so post pandemic it was an issue four years later now it's still an issue now it's an issue so
144what I'm going to say is this there's more to it than just a panel of people um this was dropped on Transportation not 20 minutes or several hours before being presented to the board the last meeting okay there was no reaction time there's no way to actually go over all the info even though you got to do it over the summer so therefore I asked the board that you table changing any board schedule for next year and we collaboratively work as a community parents teachers bus drivers all employees involved to come up with a more definite more stable solution rather than something thing out of bosis in Erie County that works for our district as opposed to somebody's experiences because everybody's experience is different but how this District works collaboratively together that's what makes your
145community that's what's going to make this better for everyone thank you thank you all right am I seeing no one no one else all right that closes our second public comment period thank you so much um that moves us into agenda planning does anyone have an agenda planning item for the um for the board Connie uh yes I would just like to request a review of policy 5152 which is our policy on admission of non-resident students um at the next policy meeting or whenever it fits into the policy agenda um I am aware based on what Dr Patton has said that we there is no scheduled change for next year there is still going to be a conversation because we don't know um if we're going to get enough bus drivers to solve this problem
146so this conversation will continue um and the reason why I would want this to be reviewed is because this policy actually or any change may impact our staff and um I would like to explore possible amendments to um supporting employee retention with um addressing their child care concerns um and just making sure that we can support the employees that we do have if they run into Child Care issues because of certain changes so um just a discussion in the policy committee that's all I'm asking for at this moment thoughts from the rest of the board go ahead I guess I'm I'm not sure what is the typical I I support the idea I'm just curious what is the typical review of policies is it um is is there a schedule for so typically actually Dr
147Pat well I I think John should answer this question because you're chair right yeah uh we work with school boards which is uh an entity in nisba and they have a cycle of sort of going through all of the policies and there are new things at the state level that's that uh prompt us necessarily to act and then nisba also comes up with stuff they think you all ought to work on this stuff and then our own administrators sometimes come up with stuff they think we ought to be working on and so we are sort of constantly going through all the thousands of policies we've sort of been through uh I think the full cycle during your time as superintendent um Mike would you want to add anything about best process here for something like
148this I just my only question is clarification as to the policy of admission of non-residency students how does that get impacted if it's related to Transportation conversation so there are some districts that actually have policy where in this particular policy they have uh Parts written in so that employees of the district can bring their children to the district that they work in um they would have to actually provide the transportation but it's more for this is really about a schedule change so even though it's not going to happen let's PR end right that there was an elementary school teacher who has children but their day is their life is so impacted where they may need to leave our district because the schedule is so out of whack with their home life if it would make
149it possible to retain them is this something that we want to look at does that make sense so it be a conversation about our residency status correct for employees of the district right okay in and it's it's really about retention of employees in the district who may be in a bind because they their schedule has now changed so yeah John The Next Step would be is there enough interest of the board to bring policy 5152 to the policy committee for conversation with any recommendations coming back to the board if there's going to be any modifications moving forward I just want to clarify so right now we do not have a policy about teachers who do not live in our district but who work in our district bringing their children to attend our schools is that
150correct that is correct okay so I support I support policy committee taking a look okay others I I just have a question and this is I mean I'm I support the look at this as well I do we does this board that during agenda planning need to weigh in by majority on on this or is this just a function of wouldn't couldn't this be a considered a function of the policy committee itself to to introduce uh policy review discussions I mean there the policy committee is not deciding on and then voting on policies themselves without board approval do they need our approval to take a look at policy X during their policy committee meetings when it's brought by a board member we like to have majority say yes it's worth going in the queue okay
151what if what if it's brought up in a oh I guess otherwise it's generally it's man it's brought up through the cycle then it's part of the cycle we don't need a majority if it's out of the blue then we generally do okay so far so far yep so far two uh trustees who don't sit on policy committee have encouraged policy committee to go to work on this thing but I also support it too all right sounds like we got we got majority thank you any other agenda planning items all right um board member comments thanks Angie just a quick comment uh to both of the presenters for this evening uh I would also like to say thanks to the community for coming out as always uh you know no matter what the issue is
152we kind of all here I speak for the nine of us that sit on the board appreciate our community's involvement in coming in and sharing your concerns um as far as the two presentations this evening they both hold a special place in my heart Eric's area because I like food and I like to eat uh and John's area because I live that life every day uh one of the things that I wanted to point out and I think Mike touched on it a little bit on the Food Services presentation I think one of the coolest things that have happened and Eric emphasized you know just that that feeling of being in that environment for his staff and for the students and the enjoyment of it and not only is the food better but the environment's
153better it's cleaner it's brighter it's more welcoming uh never in my life uh have I ever been involved in a district where outside organizations whether they be sports or or clubs are having their year-end celebrations and participations within the school district cafeteria and as being a a beneficiary of having that happen a couple of times with some some children in sports I can't tell you how amazing it has been and I see uh the conversation more and more amongst the booster clubs and the parents that are involved in sports and and clubs talking about we don't need to go to the restaurant we don't need to go to the club we don't need to go down the road and spend all this money we can support our district and spend much less having it there
154and the food that you and your staff have provided for those events has been second to none so not only the comment that John made an our benefit probably twice a year getting the the benefit of dinner but uh I speak on behalf of of a parent who has now had the ability to come into the cafeteria at the high school uh and and and um have that great uh benefit uh in those evenings I think it's absolutely awesome that that's happening and and most people probably aren't aware of that yet and then John uh I'd be remiss to not say uh that obviously being a facility director myself uh you know the challenges that you deal with on a regular basis and I will apologize to my committee members here I was texting a
155few times and although it has nothing to do with the Penn State game this evening I wish it did I don't know anything about it so don't say anything uh I was dealing with heating and air conditioning issues in multiple buildings uh you know John as you're where I I manage about 250,000 square feet of space from Lake George down to Albany and uh I'm dealing with one space that's 90 degrees right now I'm dealing with another one that's 60° there's snow there's ice there's Wells there's this there's that there's burnout wires underground stuff that people have no idea that you do and the hours and the amount of time and the preparation that goes into it is unconscionable for most people and I think that you and Mike and Dave uh and the rest
156of the employees of the district do an unbelievably phenomenal job uh and you all should be recognized for your efforts uh on a regular basis I mean ditto Dean um I wanted to thank the Albany City School District they made an enormous donation to our district um and I I just want to read what John wrote in the email to the board which is the value of the donation is staggering and may come with questions from the board Albany City School District donated almost $96,000 worth of cleaning products to our district which is really I'm sorry Sunni Albany no it says Albany City School District in the AL City school or Al Alban City School District yeah yeah yeah so thank you so much Albany that's amazing um I am also um I just wanted
157to I guess ask Dr Patton if you can just reiterate what you said in your opening statement because there was a concern during public comment um just to clarify you know what we're saying about the or what you're saying about the change for the schedule for next year so we are just starting this process we are going to be gathering all Staker stakeholder input we have one scenario that's been presented there are several other scenarios that have been discussed throughout this entire process so now we want to use this opportunity to engage all stakeholders in finding out a solution that's going to meet our best interest as a school Community nothing will happen for next school year we're going to be using all of this spring and all of next year to come up with
158a solution that everybody can buy into and support thank you so much any other board member comments all right seeing none may I get a motion to adjourn Connie and Deb everyone's hand went up all in favor I thank you