001um all in favor that is unanimous Bobby thank you will you please stand and join me with the Pledge of Allegiance okay um as we are returning to open session we already did roll call for those of you who weren't here earlier um so can I get a motion to approve our minutes from November 14th Natalia and Deb are there any discussion on those minutes seeing none all in favor that is unanimous thank you can I then get a motion to accept tonight's agenda Beth Dean any discussion on that all in favor thank you that's unanimous as well this enters our first public comment period but no one has signed up so we will move on to our board um reports section is there any um do we have any committee reports uh Dean uh
002so the property committee met on uh back on November 18th had a couple of quick items to discuss uh we did discuss the request of a memorial bench uh in memory of a a longtime District employee someone with 30 plus years experience excuse me 30 years uh of service and so uh we did approve that and then the other thing that we discussed was the installation of the uh Outfield fence at the softball field at the high school so was originally part of the um the Great Outdoors project it was originally budgeted to be approximately $35,000 for that it didn't get processed through when the work was being completed uh and through some work with vendors as well as John Tiner and his uh wonderful staff uh We've we've had that re-budget it down to
003approximately $15,000 in expenses and then we're going to take care of the labor piece of that ourselves so there will be a nice little savings to the district um won't be able to do it probably until uh after after the season I believe after this coming season because we wouldn't be able to get it done in time for the season so it'll be it'll be installed and and fully ready for softball of 2026 thanks Dean any questions for property okay any other yep go ahead I just the naming of the bench does that come to the board for voting on or is it done at the property level no I think it's just something that we discuss at the property level I don't believe that it's anything that comes in front of the board it's
004a donate yeah no expense I'm sorry I'm sorry I left that off there's no expense to the district it was a request uh of the family they're paying for it they just wanted to make sure that it was okay to do got it thank you any other reports John uh policy committee met and uh you'll see two items in the con Agenda One is a policy and one is a related regulation they both pertain to attendance and they are basically uh revisions specifying when parents will be informed about attendance issues um this it seems pretty straightforward and and I'll just add that I think our district is in a really good place with all the hard work we're doing on attendance which is so important and um you'll have a chance to look at this
005be between now and the next meeting and then it'll be included in the second reading at the next meeting when we'll vote on it thanks any questions on that for policy or John Tony uh finance and audit committee met as well uh two main topics um in the November meeting one was the internal audit and two was the third phase of the Legacy project um the Auditors from Questar are are internal auditors uh presented the financial risk assessment report and uh the cash receipts and banking internal audit and the fixed asset internal audit overall on the financial risk assessment report they um acknowledged that uh the the findings in the report were of minimal concern it's the best one I've seen in five years on the committee uh you know things like the extra classroom
006activity fund which always come up in the fund balance level which the board sets and is comfortable with and that sort of thing are the only things that came up um the uh cash receipts and banking internal audit has a um uh has a corrective action plan um uh associated with it that's in tonight's consent agenda it basically boiled down to uh the group finding a couple delays in time um uh depositing checks and uh it's one of these things that timing wise the issue had already been adj addressed back in the spring of this year when uh Bobby's Department got a remote deposit machine uh to address that and so now they can um deposit checks right from uh the office and so it was a it was a an issue that was already
007corrected but we have to submit a corrective action plan and that's in tonight's um uh tonight's agenda we moved on to a an update on the Legacy project to the the third phase um we are uh you know we are looking to recommend a project that has no new taxes tied to it um and we're uh also looking to contribute 7 and a. half million uh in a capital reserve contribution similar to what we did with the Great Outdoors project and Legacy 1 and two uh so the the funding for this uh project this phase of the project would come from reserves uh bonds and state aid um the last thing the committee uh discussed were the May 2025 propositions on the ballot um we're going in addition to the regular um and and sort
008of uh every year uh propositions regarding uh buses uh and the regular budget um we'll also have um uh a proposition to create a capital reserve this is for legacy 3 and uh the proposition for leg for the Legacy 3 funding um uh the authorization for uh the capital project itself will be on that uh that may 2025 um ballot and more to come in terms of workshops and and and all of that during um the next few months thanks Tony questions for finance committee all right this brings us to our students uh at at Lake a they held a PBIS assembly to recognize the 3B Award winners parents celebrated alongside students while they played Thanksgiving trivia with teachers versus students the first graders started the Peaceable Place program through the prevention Council students will
009learn about self-esteem coping skills and antibullying messaging the rain changed plans with our annual Turkey Trot so students enjoyed a Minute to Win It day instead um had Dorothy Nolan students got to redeem their Blue Streak bus during the first school wide Redemption at the end of November K Kids couldn't wait to win Raffles have lunch with their favorite folks around the building and find out what was in their mystery bags the annual Turkey Trot was a blast and it was great to see all of the families supporting the hard work of the students and the kids have been enthusiastically picking out books at our HSA book fair it is great to see the love of reading spread to others uh the the at Division Street dragons on stage did an amazing job with the
010drama club performance of jous last week the fourth and fifth grade students had their holiday chorus concert tonight and their um the classes look forward to the holiday singalong and parties next week at Caroline Street Spirit day assembly this week went really well the student council lead leads the assembly each month parent teacher conferences are going well and the Brookside museum has be has been coming to meet with the second grade students uh at Greenfield they just had their December be beest assembly on December 3rd we focused on the character trait kindness uh the fourth grade students are finishing up their too good for violence lessons from the prevention Council fifth grade begins their lessons on too good for drugs from the prevention Council and students in grades three through five are finishing up their
011family life lessons with guest educator Derek te from the center for the family at geyser Road math AIS teachers hosted family math night where families played math Bingo for fun prizes and then had time to play math centered games with each other fifth grade advisory Club hosted its second afternoon movie on our December 4th half day and are planning kids night out this Friday students will participate in many fun activities student council will host spirit week next week students and staff are super pumped and on Friday December 20th we will have our annual holiday sing along during our December Geyser get together uh at the high school um the high school partnered with Sunni ader onac for a direct admission event with um for the entire senior class Sunni Chancellor John King was able to
012join the school for the celebration event the unified program and best buddies participated in the po polar PL Plunge in Lake George NHS held a very successful blood drive collecting more than 90 pints of blood for those in need um it's concert season for the seroga ensembles come watch cor Orchestra chorus and band concerts in the next two weeks also on do on um Tuesday Dr Patton and principal s came into me and Casey's um student counsil class to uh discuss phone policy and like we had a lot of um ideas but the general consensus was that whatever the policy is consistency is key and at mavl Avenue student council is currently conducting a kindness closet clothing Drive the Winter concert season is in full effect the music teachers and students have done an amazing
013job preparing for the wi Winter concert season the conduct restorative instructional coaches Carrie Jackson and Nora Ketchum have been visiting Flex classrooms to describe their role as well as explain the importance of implementing restorative practices at Maple Avenue thank you very much Mike that brings us to you thank you Casey and Matt for your comprehensive report uh just want to start off by uh thanking everybody here at Dorthy Nolan Mrs jablonsky Miss eeman uh for hosting tonight's uh board meeting uh prior to the start of the business meeting uh the Board of Education had the opportunity to hear from our students here at Doran as well as our teachers and several of our parents uh who all uh represent our the Dorothy Nolan kindness crew uh and so they shared several examples of student L
014initiatives and teacher supportive initiatives uh parent involvement here at Dorthy Nolan uh everybody working together to create a welcoming and caring environment uh here at Doran elementary school so just want to thank our students uh for their tremendous amount of work uh and our teachers for your outstanding leadership uh so just a few uh recommendations uh Matt and Casey uh just touched on one uh that I know is of interest to the board uh and to parents and it's a Statewide conversation and that's on student cell phone use in schools uh and we have a committee at the high school who's been working uh over the fall months uh represented by uh teachers and support staff and administrators and students at the high school uh so last week uh they sent out a survey to
015all high school stakeholder groups uh so we had 1,1 14 students respond which is 55% of our student population uh 437 parents responded uh and 127 of our high school staff members which is about 30 53% of our staff responded uh and so an opportunity for the committee to gather feedback on our current student cell phone policy practices and procedures at the high school level uh that committee Now is working to review the survey results and and then the next uh phase would do uh be to hold focus groups uh with stakeholder groups in January uh with the committee uh prepared to make some recommendations uh for their findings to the Board of Education in February uh as you've been kind of following along with Governor Hogle at the state level uh she continues to
016gather feedback from stakeholders across the state uh and is expected to make some recommendations for school districts uh in the coming months so um again we're utilizing uh again our feedback from all of our stakeholders here locally uh for some recommendations and then obviously uh we'll be waiting for further guidance uh from the state uh if they're going to be um again recommending any uh uh changes to uh cell phone policies for school districts um last Monday uh had the opportunity to join several of my superintendent colleagues in our Bose's regions for our first uh Regional advocacy day down in Albany uh to meet with uh representatives from the governor's office from the Department of budget uh the assembly education committee uh again focusing uh our regional efforts uh on uh our advocacy efforts uh
017if you've been following along uh at the state level the Rockefeller Institute released a report last Monday afternoon uh for recommendations is how to improve the foundation Aid formula uh which obviously that formula is used AC across the state uh to distribute uh school aid to over 700 school districts in the state of New York uh so obviously Foundation Aid is critically important to all school districts uh especially uh the local SCH School District school districts in our area uh that at least half of our schools in this region are uh already fully funded uh utilizing the foundation Aid formula so the hold harmness uh stipulation is critically important uh but then again some of the recommendations uh for change in the Rockefeller Institute uh including just data points that for many years have been
018used in that uh formula uh that would include the actual cost of services to help support our students need um and then you know fixed costs that again remain open uh irregardless of decline in enrollment uh for school districts uh and again what we hope is there'll be a phase into any changes the for uh Foundation aid over many years uh to allow allow the districts um to make some uh again planned uh um uh allowable uh predictable uh changes as we as we move forward um so also we we talk about Workforce Development a lot uh and again uh working with State education department and our legislators on flexibility around teacher certification uh around the extended ability of retirees to be able to work in school district uh with around the uh the 211
019waiver um many districts across the state uh again are are filling positions with retirees um again due to lack of certified um applicants um and again also reducing the requirement um for professionals who come with certification from other states or who are folks who are mid-career uh professional uh professionals to uh allow to demonstrate proficiency on previous requirements uh and tier six benefits right now the at the state level uh if we can closely more closely line with those offered with tier three and four I think again encourage more younger Educators who are entering the profession uh to allow them similar retirement benefits uh for those folks uh who've been in education a little bit longer um the last topic which will be a topic of our conversation tonight uh around Transportation uh the board
020is obviously very familiar and been following along with the state progress with the zero Mission bus uh transition and so obviously there's a lot of work to be done at the state level and the state's fully aware of the challenges that school districts are currently facing making that transition within the tight timeline uh that the state has laid out in law um so again working with vendors uh working with obviously an opportunity uh to fund uh the significant shift uh that would be required um and again even thinking about when you look at our actual runs which one of our runs would be more suitable for electric buses and which runs obviously you're going to be more of a challenge for school districts uh that are transporting students over um the number of miles that
021our buses would travel each day so uh a lot of feedback a lot of good support uh again initial conversations with folks the at the state level uh we have our uh in January a legislative breakfast uh that all school districts and board of educations are involved in we invite our local legislators to that breakfast uh Angie and I will both uh be attending uh and again throughout the spring um when the governor's budget uh is expected January 21st um again advocacy efforts again from all uh different groups involved in supporting public education uh it's just important for our voices uh to be heard as critical decisions are being made that are going to impact our local uh communities uh and then finally just uh just as a reminder we're excited I know our students
022staff uh families uh it doesn't happen very often uh but when the holiday falls on a Wednesday and New Year's Eve is on a Wednesday or New Year's Day is on a Wednesday uh we have a nice two- week break coming up um for the holiday recess uh so we've got uh a week and a day to go uh and then students staff uh will be off uh from Monday the 23rd um through um what's it January 6th uh is our is our first day back uh to school and classes resume uh so wish everybody a happy healthy holiday season and a happy New Year uh and enjoy this special time uh with your family and friends uh so we have two uh presentations tonight um so each year we have an opportunity to hear
023from our department heads uh and so tonight our transportation department will be providing their annual update uh to the board and to the community and just wanted for in some introductory remarks by before I turn it over to Jerry Kim and uh one of our guest presenters tonight um as the board knows and our community uh we continue to have conversations across the district uh about the ongoing challenges that our our our district faces uh when it comes to the bus driver shortage that is impacting school districts not only across the state U but across the country uh in our exportation department does just an outstanding job every single day uh helping overcome uh that challenge and and really working closely together uh and being as responsive as they can uh to the needs of
024our community uh but just to kind of put things in perspective for folks so you kind of realize and understand that that the challenges that our tresp department is in uh currently uh is that before the pandemic before covid uh historically we've had about 85 drivers uh on on on staff and over the last 5 years that number of 85 drivers is now reduced today uh to 69 total drivers in our school district uh so our transport Department as I mentioned works extremely hard to kind of Meet the busing needs of the district uh it's challenging there are unique qualities of Saratoga Springs that you'll learn in the next few minutes uh during the pre uh during the presentation uh that makes our transportation system uh even that much more challenging that many of our
025neighbors uh and so they do the best they can um but over the last two years uh we've heard from our parents we've heard from our teachers we've heard from our staff uh an increased frustration uh that when bus routes are cancelled and we're not able to offer late runs and fulfill the needs of athletic trips uh due to the lack of drivers uh that are available to cover all those runs so uh since the pandemic uh the district really has made a conserva effort uh to help with driver recruitment efforts uh our transportation department is out uh in the public as office and they as they can uh Hillary and her staff uh as well as more Manny our communication Specialists uh do the best they can to help promote uh driver opportunities at
026local and Regional job fairs uh we have we Host Drive bus events uh each fall uh they're out at engaging with the community promoting at school events last night uh we are at the high school concert and there was a table set up recruiting driver uh efforts uh at our at our high school so a lot of the school events uh and we also partnered with the local media uh to help attract new drivers to the district so we've done a lot of media push uh to help and encourage folks to consider uh working for the district uh and then back in September of 22 uh realizing that this was becoming a more of a problem uh the Board of Education supported uh creating an Mo MOA uh with our CCA that would help continue
027to encourage and promote D driver Recruitment and reten uh retention efforts uh outside of our existing contract uh that included some things that we really were hopeful that would help uh enhan driver recruitment so all District employees currently right now IR regardless whether you're csca ssta any administrator that if you recruit uh and um refer somebody to Transportation who completes uh the driver training program there's a $500 payment for any staff member uh who can recruit a new driver to the district uh We've increased the training differenti uh differential uh for all of our current drivers who act as trainers from $2 an hour to $4 an hour for their work uh We've increased the differential for all late runs so any of our after school runs Sports trips uh from again additional 2 hours
028to four hours an $4 an hour uh we've established a 20 $20 hour rate of pay for all new bus drivers when they're going through training uh that used to be minimum wage and now if you're training to be a bus driver you're paid now $20 an hour for that and then all of our substitute drivers uh when they come into the district uh there used to be a differential in pay now they're all paid uh the current entry level rate per our CSEA contract so again even with those efforts in place over the last two years and again trying to be as creative as we possibly can uh driver shortage continues to be a problem uh again that most school districts as you're talking to our neighbor districts uh are facing very similar challenges
029so with that said uh and now going into four years of the same challenge that we face on a daily basis uh we reached out to on the bus uh to come in and to help us to conduct a transportation study of our district uh Transportation operations and so tonight um uh Jerry Keenan our director and Kim Ross and then Paul overbaugh who's from on the bus uh would like to share uh their work over the last six months of what they've learned with interactions with our staff uh and again this is a starting point of conversation that we want to have with our parents we want to have with the community we want to have with the Board of Education about the situation that we're currently in and then working together uh to come
030up with some strategies moving forward forward uh that create a more sustainable solution uh for our school district uh so if the slides are ready I think I'm actually going to take the first two or three slides I don't know who has the clicker and then if uh the presenters want to come up so uh just to introduce you know Jerry Keenan our director uh Kim Ross on no check check good uh Jerry Keenan our director Kim Ross our assistant director and then I like I mentioned Paul overbaugh is with us uh from on on the bus so again I just want to start the presentation because really the scope of this work and the study was initiated by the school district uh that we invited uh Paul uh in his expertise and he talk
031a little bit about him himself and his background uh but the scope of work uh that was outlined by us as a school district when we invited them in so uh F the transportation services what we asked them to do uh was to evaluate our current transportation system So currently we operate and you'll see as we explain it we currently operate in a two-tier routing system and then we ask them to evaluate any possible future options that we should be considering using the limit ations that we have with existing Bell time so we can't change the length of our student or staff day uh but the starting and anying points of the school day is obviously uh the flexibility that we would have to have uh with options moving forward uh we asked them to
032kind of look at seeking routing efficiencies whether it be from our daily routes uh from our student home to school uh for our all of our special education program so you're going to see that we place a lot of students uh in District program programs where it's maybe not their their own home uh neighborhood elementary school but it could be another Elementary School within the district or could be uh students who are placed outside the district uh many of our students have the opportunity to participate in Bose's programs uh we have a lot of displaced students so those are homeless students who can live within 50 mile radius of the school district and the district has the responsibility to uh transport those students to and from school every day uh again you're familiar uh with
033our late runs after school where our students have the opportunity to stay with teachers for extra help um we have our project lift program at the elementary school where students can stay after school uh get additional support uh and that requires a late run uh home uh as well as all of our athletic trips field trips uh extracurricular activities that happen throughout the school year so within the scope uh we asked them to review all of our current practices Transportation procedures um processes uh board related policies anything that we do structurally right now it's set up that again uh can continue to make our system safer and more efficient overall uh with the goal ultimately is how can we help reduce our routes that would help support uh the driver shortage issues um try to
034help reduce travel time we don't want students on the buses any longer than they have already ready uh so again how can we help reduce travel time uh and then looking at our staffing analysis what our current levels of Staffing are within transportation and then opportunities for cross training uh again to improve efficiencies where there may be some redundancy uh and how we can kind of improve those things overall so uh as you can see there's a pretty wide scope of work and then over the last six months uh Paul and his Partners spent a lot of time interacting with our staff uh sitting side by side are dispatchers and routing Specialists and asking a lot of questions of Jerry and Kim uh so at this point I want to turn over to Jerry just
035to give a sense from his perspective of the current status where we stand right now uh in transportation here in Sara Springs good evening everybody um I know I don't know a few of the board members I haven't met you yet but welcome um so I'm Jerry I'm the director of Transportation um so this is kind of what my office staff looks like right now well my whole department but um Kim Kim Ross is my assistant director we have one secretary for the Department I have a head mechanic who oversees that then Kim and I uh work together um handling our dispatch routing bus drivers and bus assistants we also have a trainer and then we have part-time trainers that train between bus runs um hoping that we're going to get them all real busy
036real soon pray to God every day um so be I I want to get into a a little bit of the different things here in our planning um when I planned for the school year um you know we cover 112 square miles that's roughly almost double the size of some school districts with our same population um you know uh there will be a slide at the end that will show you those comparisons that we're the only District um of our size in the Capitol region that covers 112 square miles that's the challenge right there is just the amount of area we have to cover in a given day um taking into account that you know we have 6100 uh almost 6,200 total students with 5745 of them in District um planning for the year um
037when we did this you know we we landed at 71 Roots um when I only have 69 and I just got 69 drivers as of this week um so on February on December 10th I had a driver return that had he's on your agenda tonight he to be reinstated that put me at 69 um and then a new hire who just got licensed so I've been actually managing at 67 drivers starting my day four short every day um which means we pull that piece of the puzzle apart every single day and put that back together okay not only do we service the Saratoga um schools the maple lab the six elementaries but we have seven non-public schools 22 special needs schools and I have 79 displaced students that we have to figure out how to
038get into school every day um so when that planning starts taking place for me in the beginning of the year you know and I have to look at how am I going to manage this with the team that I have well that's actually that's when we start looking at outside contractors so my outside contractors right now are covering 13 schools for us um so I we use one contractor um it goes out for bid but it always gets one by Upstate um here in Saratoga Upstate is covering 13 we have seven contracts with Upstate they cover 13 schools for me um that's that those are schools that I can't get to these are my goal is to get back to where we can so I don't have to rely on them I also have another
039cont parent contract on the agenda tonight to be signed for another parent helping me get a displaced student to school every day so um couple of things that we didn't talk about is like where we travel those 50 miles that's a it's a all around us so I could be getting Glover Bill broad Alban Glenn's Falls Corinth it doesn't M I got Albany I you know I'm all over the place just trying to get these kids into school every day so these are some of the challenges that I'm facing um a lot of days and this changes in a heartbeat just so you know displaced kids can be living in one place today and we get a phone call from the liazon of M the mckin van vento liazon and we're now now they're living
040in Glenn's Falls when they were living in District and now I got to figure out how to get them here and I only have a certain amount of time to get those challenges figured out um and I when I say I I should say we because it's not just me it's a team I want to make sure I'm taking care of my team because we we are a great team that we all work together so um going back to my slides you know um we are traveling we're traveling all over the place so you'll see our buses in many different towns um this is just the area this is our district our 12 square miles okay so you know I could be in Middle grov um you know we could be picking up and one
041of the things that I did see in here that I do want to tell you is um you know balson Spa I got mckin vento Rock City falls on the bottom left over there that's out of District but I got kids there I got so it this we we actually travel a larger distance every single day than what this map reflects then within this map okay we have five flex zones for elementary schools which means you can live in a Division Street catchment Zone but you may go to I I don't have them in front of me I'm sorry but I'll just you know Caroline Street or you could go to Lake you know um so I may have sometimes up to three buses servicing the same neighborhood um because I could have um students
042in that neighborhood that are placed in three different elementary schools obviously we are we're we're a district that's trying to keep us um you know our class sizes at at an average but that posed a challenge now in these days when we're 15 16 drivers lower than where where we have been um so now the solution um I'm going to turn this over to Paul because this is a lot of the work Paul has done and Paul has worked really hard with our routing specialist and routing Clerk and our dispatcher so here uh this is Paul overal he's a former state director of pupil services for State Education Department and is now um with bosis on the bus thank you good evening ladies and gentlemen and thank you for allowing me to present uh the
043work that we've been doing uh first I do want to give accolades to your department because it is amazing what they accomplish on a daily basis 6,000 students is nothing to sneeze at 6,000 students plus those that have different needs that they are meeting on a daily basis and those needs are changing is something that is very commendable and I applaud them for that and I do know that as my history has started back in 1991 driving a school bus and then learning how to train people and becoming an spdi coming a 19a certified examiner filling the same role that Jerry has for seven years in Greenville Central School District down in Green County uh that's 120 square miles but nowhere near the population that you have here we had 1400 students you have like
044four times that amount so when you think about what they're doing on a daily basis it's amazing and they are not alone I've been all across the state from Long Island out to Buffalo and they're having the same concerns and the same issues I've seen people pulling their hair out trying to cover routes because they're so short um and it's amazing how you know sadly when things happen that you just have no more resources and you have to cancel a route and and ultimately the students suffer and and that's what we're trying to prevent by looking at everything that we have currently realizing the times are very important uh the high school arrives at 7:35 as well as the middle school that's on the first tier and then you have all your elementary schools arriving
045at 9:00 starting at 9:10 and then as they start at 9:10 they get out at 3 20 in the elementary they got out earlier in the first tier so the way that we have to figure you know how this impacts staff and how it impacts drivers and families and students is looking at the full needs that we have within the department and within the district So currently you have 63 drivers that have to be here sorry you have 63 drivers that have to be here uh early in the morning to meet meet those needs for high school and middle school that's a big group of people and if there was a way to take that big group of people and spread it out to meet all the needs that you have within all three tiers
046then I think those numbers of available staff at the end on the right side of the slide will increase so mically we focused on in District we focused on big buses the small buses are pretty much Set uh as static and they can change depending on the needs of the student or the needs of displaced students and things of that nature so with this you know we have to start looking at the afternoon and I and I think this is important for us to understand as a group is that the morning is not the problem it's the afternoon when we are confined by such a short time so basically we have to start in the afternoon and we have to say we're going to leave the high school at 210 if we leave the high
047school at 210 we cannot get back in some cases until 75 minutes later because we have to go up to Lake desolation and we know that from the high school up to there is about 20 minutes better and then they have to come 20 minutes back and you're not just going to drive up there and drop off one family you're going to try to use an efficient system to create as many people on that bus as possible there are 66 passengers for a reason but unfortunately because of the distance We cannot put 66 passengers on that bus and get them all home safely within the time restraints that we have so looking at that we work backwards and we try to figure out okay if you're going to do a a three- tier system and
048you're going to gone back an hour and that's what we did we we looked at a myriad of scenarios uh I think the first scenario we presented uh to the leadership here was to say well why don't we just moved the high school up till 7:15 and they're like well no we we really can't do that because the the community likes that 7:30 time and then we said okay well why don't we try and put the middle school first because they kind of are Standalone school from our study and they like well no because the high school has to interact with the bosies and other groups and and schools and also we have sports you know so we cannot interfere uh with that so that solution wasn't feasible then I said well maybe we need
049to look at the the flex zones and in looking at the flex zones um some of those young people have a long traveling distance because they're going to from you know up here all the way down to the other side of the district to a to a school where it's good for them academically and I think the best term that I've heard in relation to this is the driver shortage is basically a unprecedented consequence that the flick zones are causing it was good at the time and it still is good because students are in a smaller group size class size they're learning they're achieving they're doing well they're succeeding but now when you have this driver shortage how are we going to you know accommodate those needs as well so we look at the end
050of the day we start in the afternoon we work our way back through the each of the tiers and then from that dismissal time we work back to either the 6 and a half hours 6 hours and 10 minutes of of the educational day that's required by S and then we come up with a morning start time and looking at you know using staff and efficiently and and constant campaigns to attract more staff we we see that that this solution or this potential solution um recommendation if you will is what may be some something that could attract more drivers so the proposed solution is to no matter how we looked at it we had to move that High School unload arrive time up 15 minutes because you just need that much time in between the
051tiers and then saying well if we have a a afternoon schedule that's so tight what we try to do is look at all the routes and their length and with that we condensed that with Jerry's staff down to about a 45 to 50 minute run which means that we have to add more buses but if we're separating the tiers we could use some of those 5763 individuals to do those extra runs and with that um looking at Maple and Caroline in division they would start on the second tier and they would arrive the middle school with Maples Al arrive an hour later and their schedule would run one hour later than the high school and then Carolina division would be a separate time 8:40 to to 3:10 and then the last four schools would start
052an hour later because we need the time to get back and forth all around the district so when you look at the bell times we still are constrained by the length of day and then the staff times are the same but they're just adjusted a little on the start and the end but it's still nothing added or subtracted from their work day and most importantly what we have is that if we add seven buses to the current big bus fleet that gives us 32 so now instead of requiring 59 69 you know out of the 69 we're going to have 32 extra people to help out in that early shift should there be absenteeism or should there be an emergency of sorts in the after in the second tier we're going to increase the middle
053school buses by two increase Caroline by one and that one bus is basically going to just cover some of the flex zones for that school and then we're going to keep uh division at the same with seven buses and when we add all those up we have 16 drivers left now you say in the morning that really doesn't impact us but in the afternoon that's huge to have 16 bodies that can drive 16 buses that can provide late buses and after school trips and maybe even if you know the stars align and there's more people that come in the door that want to drive a school bus what's going to happen is that you're going to pull back some routes from the contractor and save some money because it is cheaper to run operations in
054District than it is to pay a contractor um and when we look at the the third tier those four elementary schools um they're basically the same amount of buses using 47 drivers having 22 drivers extra in the afternoon for those added trips and things of that nature and what's also interesting with this scenario is that if you have a person that wants to drive a school bus and they're not really fond of middle school or high school students they could come in and do a second tier elementary and a third tier elementary for the district so they might be attracted to this driving position because they're working with the little guys and that might be uh that actually that is a philosophy that some other districts in the area are using and they have acquired
055many drivers because of that feature so with that um we look at um the impact it is a 15minute earlier day for the high school um and it is a 45 minute later time for the Middle School the Carolina division Elementary Street Elementary Schools will start 20 minutes earlier while the Four elementary schools for tier three will start 40 minutes later if there was a way for us to do magic and to make that 40 minutes 30 we'd love to do it but we need more bodies to do that and we need you know more ability to maneuver around the district and maybe not go to every part but in what we have as the confines this is the best scenario that we found thus far so looking at the bell times we're still 19
056minutes earlier for the high school 40 minutes earlier 20 minutes for the Carolina division and four 40 minutes later for the others and then as we look at the faculty and staff they're going to report a little earlier and some are going to report a little later but at the end of the day you know we have an extra 26 people in the morning that are not on the road for the first tier we have an extra nine that are not on the road for the second tier and we have 47 drivers that we always have had for the third tier so with that looking at a comparison of all your neighboring districts in the Capitol region you'll see that the unbolded Saratoga is what you currently have 112 square miles two-tier system arriving at
0577:30 7:40 arriving at 9:00 getting out in the afternoon at those times and then you have the proposal which is a three-tier system moving it up to a 720 um 820 840 and 940 and leaving at uh 310 210 and 410 so with that uh looking at some of those other districts no one else is in triple digits for square miles the highest is Shen which is 74 then you have South GL Falls at 65 everyone else is smaller and they're running three tier and their high school students are getting there or their first tier students are getting there earlier than the 720 in some cases so with that I'll entertain your [Music] questions yes uh thank you very much for your presentation I definitely think the comparison slide is very helpful I happen to
058work in one of these other districts where the students arrive at 7 a.m. um what is not clear and I'm I'm sorry to ask but did we enter Ain a four tier system ever in your workup no I did not entertain a four tier system okay some of the first drafts that we looked at had even those four Elementary Schools starting later if you were going to do a four tier system um I'm not really sure what time they would start for that fourth tier unless you move the first tier earlier MH so I'm I'm I'm looking at some of of these schedules and I'm trying to look at it through a parent lens and a teacher lens and a student lens but things like doctor's appointments and dentist appointments like those are things that
059get impacted but um particularly for the tier three um it's very hard to be a working family with that kind of schedule so it it's really not a you question but maybe it's more of a district question is there a way to like contract with the Y to have at each building like child care that starts at 8:00 a.m. to help our families um I don't know if if that's was a part of the discussion or not um I know it's not you but it's just something that definitely struck me nothing else really seemed like crazy um that was like a wo yeah it is late I will give you that and especially now with the shortest amount of daylight in the year um but the idea is that you know when you think about
060it you have high school kids that are coming in late and as a result of that it's pushing the elementary kids out late and unless you want to swap the two but you can't because those high school kids have other responsibilities other courses that they need to attend to bosies New Visions and things of that nature um and if you go to a four tier system you're still confined with the 112 square miles it's still going to take you 20 minutes up to Lake desolation and 20 minutes back and it's going to take you a while to get around to the flex zones for those schools ours so I want to just add um not just are the flex zones impacted um but I also have special needs Roots so I have special a lot
061of special needs kids in Greenfield that go to geyser um so my buses are running all over um you know I mean as for instance Maple you know Maple has a a quite a few special needs buses that have to cover the 112 miles and come in and drop those kids so um special needs plays a big factor into what we're able to do as well because they have to cover the 112 square miles on every tier depending on what program I'm sorry depending on what program is being offered at what school and where their placements are these buses are going going in and out in and out in and out a lot during the day Natalia did you have a question yeah I just wanted to respond to Connie what you said which um
062I guess I'll say more in a little bit but one thing is that so the YMCA is providing some some of that at some schools but as far as I can tell right now there is one slot per seven kids in elementary when you look at the YMCA Just across our district um and that might even be for all child care so like even if they were to like so right now Division Street doesn't have that care in the school it's still just not enough slots um and so I'll just say I have a lot of concerns about this as the parent of an elementary school student and also as um a public school worker but I guess um before I get into my concerns I'm just wondering will this plan actually allow for late
063buses um and I'm asking because if four elementary schools are going to move 40 minutes later and right now it's taking some elementary students an hour to get home on the bus I live right by the high school and there are students who are getting home an hour after they get on the bus um when would the late bus run be is that just covered by the fact that we would have more drivers and buses I'm also wondering about using buses during the day for field trips um because right now Elementary School students are getting dropped off later and high school's getting picked up earlier so is this going to allow for early and also sorry will this allow for um early bus runs for students to access beyond the bell both before and after
064school which also with the day getting shifted there's less time for that depending depending on which school we're at okay so one at a time I didn't get all three at once all right so basically what I'm wondering is does this solve our problem of I understand that this will take care of our canceled bus runs does it also allow for Equity across the district for students to be able to access different things like field trips like um after school programs and like before school programs yes I believe so because you're going to have you could have someone come in so right now you're running a late bus that's like 40 50 minutes after dismissal so if you get out at two o'clock and you have a 3:00 late bus at the high school or
065a 4:00 late bus at the middle school you know you're going to have people that are going to be able to juggle because they're going to come in early in the afternoon so say you have that that individual that just drives two Elementary runs they could come in early on certain days and drive a late bus and then go do their two Elementary runs um it's also possible that um you're going to have people that are available to do that project lift bus and I'm not sure if programming has lock that project lift in the afternoon or if the district's considered moving project lift to the morning I don't you know it all depends on what you want to do as a board and what is the best possible solution for the district um so
066yeah there's going to be extra drivers available for late buses one of the one of the suggestions that we had was to move Middle School first so that the middle school kids could ride the High School Bus and and and they would end up at the high school so they could get there for sports practices because there's some sports buses now uh that you currently have that Run Middle School students to the high school so with that you know that was a a possible solution to try and help resolve some of that but with these extra bodies that you're going to have in the afternoon then you should be able to accommodate those requests Connie does your question pertaining to this otherwise I want to go around first before we go to Second it is
067about one thing that Natalia mentioned and that's the kids being on the bus for like an hour would having all these extra drivers help to make help that not happen yes we are we are like for like for sure when we sat down with the routing specialist from the district we came up with a 45 to 50 minute length run compared to Now 60 to 75 so by making the routes shorter they have to be that shorter to get back in time for the next tier and you don't want buses pulling in while students are dismissed that's unsafe and we are totally against anything that's going to put children in Jeopardy so therefore when I created this model I was saying we need a little cushion here and there and we know that this city
068is not like any other so it does have times of the year when it does swell and populations do max out and congestion occurs so you know even though we're getting down to the nitty-gritty of the a minute here you know 90 seconds there that could be all delayed by a couple minutes by traffic or a major event that occurs at the track or something but with that um I believe that you're going to have have the availability to put this together properly and reduce ride time for students at the same time as giving Jerry extra staff and those staff that he has now will not have to fear of losing work or time because there's going to be so much more time that they're going to be able to uh do it would be
069great if he had full-time staff you know like a a permanent sub you know a full-time sub when I started driving a bus back in 91 the company I worked for paid their subs more than their regular drivers because they were so precious because they were committed to driving every route in the district at a whims notice they walk in the door can you drive 12 Route 12 can you drive Route 23 can you drive Route 14 and that sub was just going everywhere and knew all the routes all right we've got a queue here going so I've got Beth and then John and then Tony okay and Matt um first I'd like to say thank you for all of the information it's a little overwhelming um it seems like an impossible puzzle that you
070are trying to put together um knowing all the challenges that the transportation department has I want to thank all of you for everything that you you do every day to get our kids to school safely um because it sounds like you're really managing an unsustainable system and I'm sure that is incredible incredibly stressful it sounds stressful as you're describing it to us and so thank you for all that you do Under the current circumstances um I am concerned about the later start for those three elementary schools I just feel like as a working working families really all families um with kids Elementary age that's it's late it just feels very late and um having to we navigated that when our kids were in elementary schools it can be really challenging as a working parent to
071figure that out early Child Care um and I recognize that it sounds like you really thoroughly examined the different the nuances of this I am I guess I am a little unclear about what the issue was with starting Maple early in that first tier um and I know you've explained but if you don't mind just saying a little bit more about why that is not the option or a viable option so if you start Maple first as a as a standalone first tier uh then your high school is going to come in an hour later and that's going to impact the other programs that many of those students jump on a bus and get transported to a Bose's or they they go to different um work programs or things of that nature gotcha so this
072is like the ecca ptech bosies all those programs Hudson Valley uh we we travel we have multiple shuttle buses that they get off their bus at the high school they get off the we have multiple buses that they get off the bus at the high school and then we'll get on another bus to go to ACC we got two bus loads of students um that go to bosies on Henning Road um and then we have students at Hudson Valley so we are we're transporting and if we don't if we change that means I got to start picking those guys up at home to try to get them to bosis so that actually just creates more bus runs instead of less so I'm wondering it sounds like um with what you're proposing um it will reduce
073the need for those contracted Services would it be possible to address those students through through a third party or you know through an external the most of so of the 13 schools that I have trans that I'm I'm using to go out that seven contracts that we have those are all special needs students that are placements um all over the all over the capital region um Charlton uh uh Wildwood leam Wildwood Curry I mean those are some very long bus runs that go down so I would love to bring those back in but you know so I might be off topic from where you're going but I'm just saying that those are all unique situations of what I've what we have chosen to contract out out are those things that are harder for us to
074accomplish in District but yes my goal is to bring those back inhouse and our staff manage all of our runs I'm sorry if I don't know if I answered your question correctly but but but I think if you're if you're say suggesting we contract out for those high school kids bosies or other programs then it's going to you know expedite the expense because the average bus is going for about6 $800 a day you know so and if you're going to everywhere across the capital region it's definitely going to impact your budget thank you all right thanks John uh I want to Echo what Beth said appreciate your expertise and appreciate you all helping us roll up our sleeves on this really thorny issue and I know you wouldn't be uh bringing this to us if
075we weren't really jammed up um my first thought was how can we shrink our district uh Square footprint I'm just looking at a map and I don't see any other communities up there where there are high schools so I I guess I get that but can you just help me understand why this isn't a matter of supply and demand why I mean it seems like we need to pay people a lot more to want to do this why is that I mean we don't have endless money obviously but if we did why isn't that a solution actually it it's been a question that's been raised many times and what I tell people is that many people don't work for money they work for other reasons fulfillment of of making a difference in the life of
076a child the the the difference that one can make in society and if someone is going to be motivated by a salary increase it's only going to be temporary until they get falling back into that complacency again and really start that cycle all over again and as a matter of fact um I was working with a district out in the Rochester area and they said hey we're going to pay everybody $5 dollar more an hour if you bring in all these extra staff because we're so short drivers they they're like 22 drivers short every morning without people being absent uh in this in this district and we went out there and they said you know we had those people come in we gave them the money and they all left and now we're paying the
077current drivers more money and we have nothing to show for it uh so money is not always the answer uh I mean it helps don't get me wrong I I mean if somebody wants to give you more money then then by all means take it but but it's not going to be the end all Beall and really there needs to be a paradigm shift within our communities to want to do something for the good of our district yeah I I I that's helpful thank you um I'm stuck on the young people on the high schoolers actually the older people getting up early and we'll ask you to chime in if you think it's a good idea um can I I I understand there's lots of problems with the high schoolers shifting over to the third
078tier how is Nuna doing this I mean how are they what's the what's going on there does anybody know I I don't quite understand your question could you repeat it please well this unit has the high school drop off at 8:30 and they're the only one doing that they they have is that what it is Dave whispered uh 20 square miles maybe that so we have we have a perfect storm of population and square miles that's our thing thank you um Tony and then Matt um I I'll just uh a lot of what I uh am concerned about with this uh prop proposal as well as a lot of what I'm impressed about in terms of our transportation program um managing a really difficult situation have already been said so I'll try to skip a
079lot of that um wondering I guess maybe this is a question more a processed question for Mike I mean Mike you've rightly said that this is a this is a starting point right and we're not we're talking about September of next year we have nine months to you know Wrangle and figure out the best thing when will we and in what types of forums will we discuss this further I mean I don't think this is the last discussion but what's your what's your vision for when we'll get to discuss it again yeah I think it's an ongoing conversation you know again a lot of questions we we need that initial feedback from the board from the community we've been meeting with the bargain unit members we've been meeting with the transportation department you know just
080having access now to the report the data you know the challenges the unique characteristics of our school district this is an opportunity I think to educate everybody about the challenges that we face and now it's an opportunity to get the feedback from all the stakeholders to say this is one solution right there may be other Solutions out there that we haven't even explored yet you know so it's an opportunity I think from the the board uh again all of our stakeholders parents community members uh our staff to help us kind of work through this issue um again it's nice to have the Consultants the expertise of an outside perspective you know we kind of we do what we are used to doing and that's why we want to say hey you know what can we
081learn from neighboring school districts uh who face the same challenge but again um have a little bit more flexibility because their system is developed differently than ours right now so you know traditionally a two-tier system it worked when when we had 85 drivers it does not work with 69 drivers you know so the last four years have proved that so again recruitment efforts retention efforts negotiations obviously with CCA that we're currently in right now you know our primary goal obviously is to be able to recruit and retain the folks that we have um but we have to get either 69 back to 85 as a as a goal and we've been working on that so other strategies that community may have and again even just having these conversations for people to understand we are at
082a Tipping Point right now that either we have an increase of Staff or we have to change our system so it it's got to be one or the other and so I think Tony to your point it's we need to start engaging in those conversations I don't have I don't have answers you could see this is messy uh nobody likes uh change in in any way uh obviously we need to try to keep the primary focus what's what's best for our kids uh I think our parents have been extremely Cooperative the last four years but there is a growing frustration amongst our community that when we're cancelling bus routes regularly now and we're not meeting the needs of our program that we have to it's our responsibility to consider change I guess I guess what
083I what I'm trying to figure out is literally when are we going to talk about this again because if if I I want to otherwise I want to just whip off my list of things that I'm uh concerned about because I um I I don't know when I'm going to get to do it again but I mean is it are we going to be I think it's going to be I think it's going to be every month it's going to be an every month conversation until we're all on the same page of agreed upon as to what's our solution for September if there is you know it's like changes as needed right um gu so so again I think it's going to be based on the questions and the feedback as to where we're at
084as to what's going to dictate what our next appropriate steps will be okay so I guess just put me in the camp of being concerned about the uh earlier High School start time I think Studies have shown that that um you know we're we're already taxing kids too much in that area that age kid uh in in in terms of getting them to school that area that early um and also uh I just you know I think 9:50 a.m. is just a really really tough time to start an elementary school day when those those little ones the the older ones want to stay in bed the little ones are up at 6 o'clock and by 9:00 you're ready to pull your hair out if you're lucky enough to be able to be with them for
085those three hours and not have to have someone else um you know watch your kids so I'm concerned about those things I I do think that uh we should look at um you know I I agree that it's what with what you said Mike it's either you know add drivers and I I'll respectfully disagree I think more money is almost always the if we're not paying enough we ought to pay more um more money uh will will work better than platitudes about um you know getting getting butts in the seats I think and uh and finally I I do want to talk about or do want to introduce the notion or or the question I guess of Flex Zone I they they seem to be adding an extra level of complexity to this more complex
086three- tiered system um with school age population going down and the school age population affecting Elementary class counts earliest um should we have a discussion as to whether flex zones are a thing of the past are they needed to keep I don't know the answer I'm not saying eliminate Flex Zones and we'll we'll we'll be fine with uh the class size targets that we um we wanted to uh uh hit by introducing them but I'm saying it's a it's a probably a valid question given the population um numbers that we're seeing so I'll just throw that out there those three things out there and I I think I at least to kind of be able to respond to the flexone conversation because again many of the board members that are here today were not here
087in 2019 when the board directed The District to come up with a solution to to balance class sizes that when we had board meetings in the past the board meeting audien was were filled with parents and staff upset of inequities across our district when it came to Elementary class sides uh so we put a committee together in 2019 again pre pandemic back when we had 85 85 bus drivers knowing that and we we actually if you go back to those presentations we knew there was going to be impact on Transportation um again the transportation impact that we have today I think gets you know even more highlighted when you don't have as many drivers available to us as we did back then um Flex zes have solved our class siiz issue you know we have
088not have had more Equity across six elementary schools than we've ever had so no longer do you have parents and community members coming to to uh share concern about class size but the unintended consequence which was a known consequence was going to be the challenge he was going to put on Transportation so I guess it's the balance there is just being I think more mindful Dave does an incredible job working with our elementary principles working on their register's office to manage it it is very complex um but the other thing that the board in the past we used to hear a lot from was administrative transfers and we and we don't have administrative transfers anymore so we've solved problems and again it's created problems and so it's always that balance of ultimately where do you
089find The Sweet Spot and I think some of the recommendations uh in the report are hey we got to continue to evaluate Flex Zones I don't know if we're ready to blow them up yet because we're going to go right back to where we were before of inequity of class size across the district because we can't predict where famili are going to move into the district and a challenge with having six neighborhood elementary schools is you need some flexibility as when families come and go to manage enrollment in the past we couldn't we had no control over that and that's why you had some class sizes in certain buildings really high and other buildings really low now every class size across the district is the same uh but it's put it's put unended you know
090consequences on complexity and transportation all right we have two more in the queue and I don't know if anybody else wants to get back so Matt and then Natalia so uh first I'm gonna speak to my mic so I'm not IGN ignoring you all I just the mic is here um I just agree with all of my colleagues who are who are applauding the logic puzzle that you all are putting together every day it seems like a nightmare sat question and I'm glad I'm not doing it um I I I want to Echo what Tony said I do think there are real challenges to having the high school starting early uh or even earlier I see the know the Nuna schedule looks like the reasonable schedule on this in this pile to me and I
091guess so my question is is as we're looking at tiering this have we looked at potentially splitting the high school into those students who use the Bose CTE all the all the um programs that are are tied to this earlier start time as as a tier and the students who do not have those is a second tier rather than splitting up the tiers based on like location of elementary school and if not like could we look at that I mean you can look at anything to be honest um but we have not looked at that because we were looking at something that's going to impact the the larger good uh because you're still going to have the need for that large group of drivers to come in for that middle school and high school minus
092those that are going to other programs um so you're still going to need those bodies at that same time and I think one of the proposals that we brought forward to the leadership was uh just moving that big mass of drivers from the first tier to the second tier and Jerry very calmly said well I don't think that's really going to help me because I'm going to run into the same problem for the second tier when I'm not going to have enough drivers and then when you look at that in the afternoon that impacts all your late buses and your sports trips and things of that nature so I mean I think you can look at those options um if you wish um but we did not well okay so I guess I would suggest
093I would ask that we maybe look at different ways to split the high school middle school rather than just moving everyone earlier in the high school um and like and and sort of conversely moving the elementary schools later um you know I I do I I mean I understand that this isn't again really incredibly complex but sort of seeing the skuna up there functioning as a school district you know having sports teams and having uh being able to access presumably Pac in a smaller footprint obviously tells me that it's it's possible that the high school does but Matt you got to understand they run on a two-tier system with half the student population with 20 square miles I'm not saying it's not hard I'm just saying like it's clearly if you but if you want
0944,400 kids it's there's 4,400 kids in Missy unit it's not 20 square miles but not half the population right right Natalia Sor um I I do want to say I guess going back to you Mike I understand that we as like you as the district have until September but parents do not have until September for this and so going back to the before care issue which now has an additional 40 minutes added onto it which in my opinion makes a very very long day for kids as young as four in our kindergartens at the beginning of the year um I believe that the YMCA sign up for base is in February so we are talking about two months for parents who previously have not needed to use those kinds of services to sign up for
095the again one slot for every seven kids in our elementary schools so I I do think that like having some sort of a concrete timeline is essential for the parents of our district and for the you know half of our district that's in the elementary schools um I'm going to say you know without that I just have a lot of concerns about elementary school starting that late I also don't really understand the Nisa unit schedule because are there kids only in elementary school for 5 and a half hours um that's what that shows um but that said I guess I've written down a lot of concerns and I'm only going to read some of them but I do want to State them because I do think they're important to think about um and one of
096them is that families including mine are struggling with the 910 start time already um it is hard to find a job that cover that allows for it I will say here that I did not work last fall because I could not find a job that allowed for that with my family um there's not enough care offered um for our community and it costs money so for families that have um you know students in public school to then be paying for a private support I mean that is a burden on families um I'm curious about how families are going to be able to manage with a 950 start time how will a person be able to have a job um there is some information about this out in the community and I've already gotten a text
097from a parent saying that they're going to need to ask for an administrative transfer because there's no way that they can manage to have two kids and to be able to go to their job in a different city um to me like the idea of moving the elementary school later it it makes me concerned that we as a board are going to come across is not really caring about whether adults in the home can work or not especially combined with a short Elementary day I mean I just Elementary School is not the same length as a work day and so there's already a lot of juggling that's happening so I'm curious about um if we have a plan for I guess this is not really a u question um but a a bigger question of
098just what happens when there's a shortage of childcare workers I'm glad that this is going to allow for more equity in terms of being able to access programs um I also want to say that other districts I understand that there's different pay scales throughout they also are working less hours and so a lot of our bus drivers um are retired and are then coming back to do this and I understand that part of that is just serving your community and especially serving the children of your community which is really commendable um but I'm curious if like are we concerned about an impact on our transportation staff and people who are currently happy with their job not continuing it um right now now there's a bus in my neighborhood that's dropping off kids at 410 and
099so I understand that this would potentially allow for shorter bus runs um but even if we say that that child's now getting into my neighborhood at 4:40 that is after the sunsets for three months out of the school year and so um in the past when we've talked about high school students and whether we could move the day later parents have brought up the concern of practi in in the dark um but here we're talking about children as young as four and five who are going to get dropped off after sunset in the months of November December and January I'm curious about how early dismissal would be handled in the case of a storm or how delays would be cancelled um how a teacher who works at the high school but who has a child
100at one of the Later Elementary Schools would manage the two-tier system right now there's an hour and 25 minute spread between drop off um and then a 1 hour spread between the pickup at the end of the day this is switching that to two hours and then well two hours and 20 minutes and then two hours so if we have a 2hour delay the third bus run hasn't even started yet so are you know I just have concerns about that same with the half days I'm curious about how coaching will work right now we have a lot of coaches at our at our high school that are coming from the elementary schools like they work there and that's what our um teacher contract allows for um so I'm curious about how that would work what
101would be the impact on Athletics um I'm curious about you know bus safety and visibility of small children if it's late if it's bigger children including some adults at our high school getting off the bus um in the dark that's I guess less scary to me than four and five-year-olds we're already dealing with Statewide drivers ignoring buses not stopping appropriately they're speeding by buses and the state has had to address that um and so I'm just curious like kindergarteners are very small um and so I'm worried about that um I'm also curious if there are any public elementary schools in the country that start at 950 or later when I tried to search for that on Google and I didn't do an extensive search everything that comes up first is about 2hour delays um I'm
102curious about you know students who are attending those four late elementary schools does that mean that their potential first meal of the day is at 9:40 in the morning so right now our schools are providing free breakfast and lunch to every student um and so you know for some children that is a second breakfast um that's what's happening in my household but for some children that's their first food of the day and it's at 9:40 in the morning I think that's late um at the school where I work there are children having their lunch at 10:15 so that is I just I worry about that and what about students who right now at some of our elementary schools are having lunch at 105 so I think we're that's going to there's going to be a
103big lift in terms of looking at the schedule um and finally I'll just say that um a lot of us are relying on neighbors like this is a community where we have to rely on Neighbors in order to you know get things done and I think that's the case in most communities um I I will say I think that the flex zones have complicated that with kids across the street from each other going to different schools but if we're now adding another element to it which is those school starting one hour apart from each other um I think that makes it a lot more difficult to work as a neighborhood and it will lead to parents having to rely on care that is paid for and outside of like the smaller community that their kids
104live in um and then actually one more which is that I'm I'm concerned about stuff that's after school and so right now there's you know kids taking Spanish classes and dance class and going to sports that are in the community rather than held through the schools and I just wonder what the impact is on those things and on like the business Community um people who are running like a dance studio that now children can you know half the children in our community now couldn't go to so I'm not expecting you to answer those questions right now rather I just wanted to say them um because I just I I feel so much concerned about this um and and in addition to that with the high school starting earlier what the research shows is that children
105in high school go to sleep at the same time regardless of what time they wake up there's like a 10 minute or 15 minute window and so even a 15minute move which I understand doesn't sound like a lot of time does mean like the research is that means 15 minutes less sleep for children and so then that's going to have an impact on the safety of their driving to school we know that when high school starts earlier there are more accidents and when it starts later there are fewer accidents it's going to have an impact on their testing on you know their ability to pay attention in class and stay awake on their ability to perform in sports Etc so um I guess I really really want to Echo what everyone else has said I
106have endless you know respect and I'm so grateful for our transportation department I really I guess am looking for something that's Concrete in terms of how we move forward because I have a lot of concern and I don't think I'm alone in that all right well last one John um thank you ditto I I share all these concerns but I I just want to um say that um if this is easy we would have already done it and um collectively we're going to have to roll up our sleeves and figure out something creative and we may need to think about a paradigm shift and hopefully by the time we get there we will alleviate a lot of those concerns but I I this is going to be a tough moment for for our community cuz
107we got to figure this out one way or the other thanks John it's a good first conversation um Dean go ahead just real quick I I know that someone and I can't remember who uh mentioned it in in some emails that we had earlier and it's something that I've thought about as well because in the district that I grew up in uh in in a different state but in a small city um we utilize public transportation and I'm just wondering ing if there are any districts you know in the capital region that utilize CDTA or other public transportation and how a half a dozen to 10 runs of something like that might assist us in a challenging time like this so if we have and there's rationale behind it let us know if we haven't
108then there's capacity to explore that I think it's worthwh doing um certainly not for our our our little guys and gals right we're not talking about putting the element kids on you know we're not talking about New York City and and major urban areas like that but where I grew up you know once you hit um I don't even think we did it we had junior high schools I don't even think we did it in junior high I think it was just high school once you got to high school um you rode city transportation and that's that's how you got the school so um just wondering lots to think about Albans concy they use it yeah all right um and they ride with the general public they don't just have their own buses so it's
109not like it's own route so you're going to put children on a bus that does not have the same requirements that a school bus driver has right so school bus drivers need to be fingerprinted need to be you know checked by the FBI need to be checked just make sure they're okay to work with children uh that's not always the case with your CDTA driver they're also 18 whereas New York State they have to be 21 to drive a school bus so there are some differences there but again it's it's what's going to work best for the community well thank you again for everything um in your presentation and especially to our transportation folks for being here and for everything you do every day we really appreciate you I just want to touch on a
110couple points that you guys made um Connie you spoke about the late buses we are doing late buses this year I have four buses I can tell you that the ridership out of the high school is generally under 15 per day on the two days that they get it my ridership at the middle school I could use another four I another four buses there I have um a pro well over hundred sometimes on those buses and some of those buses run for a while but we have introduced late buses back this year um it does pose its challenges but we were able to get that back out there um so I wanted to address that um John you mentioned you know we were we talked about money and we talked about recruiting efforts um my
111team is out everywhere everywhere Caboose Day chunk or treat doesn't matter where it is they're they're there okay we're recruiting I want to tell you about the couple challenges though our days start I'm out of my I'm out my door at 5:30 in the morning I'm getting home 5:30 6 7 o'clock at night okay and that's the same for my drivers the only difference between me and them is they get a few hours break in between in the day so trying to get somebody who wants to get up at four o'clock in the morning or 4:30 in the morning be to work before 6:00 am okay and then their day ends at five or six especially if they're project lift driver um that's a challenge in itself okay so the these these staff the staff
112that I have that are sitting here right now they come in they're there before 6:00 a.m. and they're not getting home to their families until uh 7 o'clock at night um that poses a big challenge right there when you're looking to recruit our what used to be a retirees job these days are now stretched out by all the programs we've introduced from 15 years ago or 20 years ago when I started um not to mention and I will tell you attracting younger crowds um the legalization of marijuana has posed a huge challenge for me we are federally do um examined we get we have random drug testing every two months in our building okay and we also drug test initially upon coming in so that has posed those that population is now not eligible to
113apply and those conversations end as soon as they ask me that question they are like okay thank you so we do it's it's not yes money will always help trust me money will always help but there's other challenges to this that that expand Beyond just being out there and waving green at them so I just wanted to point that where where I'm at so so thank you guys for all your time tonight thank you good just thank you to Jerry and to Kim all of our drivers mechanics uh and again just thank thank you uh to Paul and his partner Greg uh for again for just tremendous amount of time and effort uh they put into our efficiency study so uh definitely more to come we'll obviously continue the conversation throughout the spring all right
114uh so we do have a second presentation uh tonight uh and so back last year uh the the community uh began to engage our district to engage with our community uh in our Legacy project uh so we had a legacy referendum advisory committee uh that was organized this time last year uh that had worked uh throughout the course of last school year and presented to the board in October uh so with us tonight is Bill MC Morty uh from Saratoga project management and Matt gasberry from Mosaic Architects uh and tonight we'd like to introduce to the board and to the community uh our plans for the next uh proposition of capital Project work uh that'll be presented to the community for their vote uh in May of 2025 uh so tonight we'd like to just
115focus on two areas uh and that's the scope of work that had been identified as priority items uh by the Legacy referendum advisory committee and some of the project timelines associated with this next phase of Legacy Project work so I'll turn it over to Bill and Matt thank you uh talk quick uh about our Pathways Vision I think we've seen this slide once or twice over the past few years so I'm not going to spend a lot of time on this slide uh this is kind of an important slide I'm not going to read obviously every line item but it has taken us from really the kickoff of Legacy in 2016 up until the current date 2016 to9 we spent a lot of time uh under uh educational planning actually took almost three years to
116get through that to really determine what we wanted to do in the Legacy project U many Community Summits staff Summits student Summits surveys enrollment studies all to get us to uh the point of really the second and third phases of Legacy so during that time during 200 uh between 16 and 19 two key things happened one was the uh pathway statement and the other was actually the passing of the first first phase of the Legacy project which we called the Great Outdoors project again we were still doing uh enrollment planning and educational planning but this pertained really to items outside the school buildings themselves and also in our parks in Gavin east side and Westside Rec The Next Step was actually the forming of our first Legacy referendum committee commonly known as El which led
117up to phase two of Legacy which was passed in December of 2020 actually scheduled for May but postponed due to covid and passed in 2020 and that's uh the second phase of Legacy which we're currently in right now that was $129 million next step would be in 2024 our second Legacy referendum committee which uh presentation was done in October to the board and this addresses this current referendum that we're talking about coming up in May of 25 so we are eight years in on the Legacy project and at the end you'll see it's probably another eight years more by the time we get to the end of uh Legacy 3 so just a quick update on our current project and where we stand with that so in Legacy Phase 2 there are really eight phases
118or eight parts of Legacy 2 we're currently in phase four phase one is completely done phase two and three are done constructionwise we're closing those out now phase three division was done last summer and we're headed to Caroline this summer so that'll be complete as of 25 in August and we'll be also at the middle school this summer we'll be complete that project this summer and we'll be headed to Lake Avenue to complete that elementary school this summer so we're running along pretty good and we've got a great Pace going um high school right now we in design development so we're about halfway through design and we're out for estimating right now and the next step would be the middle school so we're we're moving right along in our design and construction just a couple
119quick facts 75% probably more like 80 83% right now with design we got 70% contracts 51% Construction done and we're on time with all our submissions and all our schedules so we're run along into really good Pace couple good pictures successes we've done throughout the schools um classrooms in use uh new furniture new flexible ways to move uh kids around the classroom upper right would be the cafeteria here at doroth noan and on the lower right is uh our typical classroom that we're doing across the district pretty much the classroom uh performs the same no matter which building it's in a little bit of different dimensions in each school but BAS basically the same premise up at Greenfield uh probably the biggest Improvement is obviously uh the Bus drop off and solving that issue that
120we had out there uh security vestibules at each school that we go to and redo the main office here at Greenfield Division Street again classrooms we did uh nine classrooms this summer and then secure vests again kitchen renovations and pretty much the entire roofit division was done this summer High School uh cafeteria Upp our left huge improvement in our cafeteria Fitness room on the upper right uh Corridor outside the cafeteria lower left then obviously a pretty cool shot of uh the blue streaks logo seen from the parking lot at night transportation all those folks just left but uh put a new bus lift in and new bus wash so now we're going to move into the scope for legacy 3 I'm going to turn this over to Matt gasberry from Mosaic and he's going to
121run through the scope for this project thanks Bill so here's a diagram that we worked with to develop and prioritize the um the scope of the work that you guys going to see in the upcoming slides but we worked with uh the lra committee uh the leadership team with the district um John and his guys we worked with and um some of the other staff at each building uh going through each scope items there so the next slide we kind of broke it down into buckets where we had building building approved buckets educational program and safety um and I'll kind of go through some of these scope items now and then kind of just go through each building uh in a general scope but looking at you know building improvements we did roof reconstruction where
122we went through and did roof Ro scans knowing the what roofs need to be replaced uh in this next up upcoming project HVAC systems working with John tener and his guys of knowing what's um what maintenance needs to be up and what uh boilers and hbac Equipment need to be replaced um exterior window replacement we're doing a number of exterior uh window replacement um and the multiple buildings as you'll see when we go through the scope sides and then Paving and that Paving is uh replacement Paving where we're looking at doing uh multiple buildings where we're looking to do uh Paving replacement uh educational program classroom Renovations as you saw you walked around today and saw the Dorothy Nolan classroom Renovations so at all the uh elementary schools we'll be renovating six more classrooms at
123each building uh the middle school and high school will be renovating 12 classrooms um and then toilet room Renovations we'll be looking at doing toilet room Renovations at all the build builds doing multiple either uh fac uh faculty bathroom Renovations or gang toilet bathrooms which are multiple stalls um and then Auditorium up upgrades um all the elementary schools are looking at this current Legacy project are getting uh upgraded we're doing additional upgrading on the next Legacy project where we're doing AV Equipment and uh sound systems and stuff um and then safety we're looking at a multiple areas where we're doing Ada updating ADA compliance where uh several Nerf Suites we're updating and various other uh items of scope that were were improving the Ada access in the in buildings uh elevator refurbishments there's multiple buildings
124where we're upgrading the elevators uh there's multiple ones that keep breaking down with John and they have to do uh routine maintenance on them we're looking to upgrade those secur security film so we're looking to do security film on all the first floor exterior windows um to prevent Intruders and slow them down if they needed to break in that's also included we are not doing security film where we're replacing windows windows will actually have a laminated glass have the built-in film already um and then lastly doing a districtwide signage Improvement uh putting signage wave finding and all that kind of stuff in the buildings so jumping into the high school um some of the the major you know I'll just hit some of the big topic items for the high school uh one of the
125big items that we're renovating is we're going to be renovating the auditorium it'll be a full gut renovation um redoing seating finishes um and some of the ceilings and doing looking at Acoustics and those type of items there um one of the other items that we'll be looking at is doing a uh Varsity Softball field Improvement where we'll be doing an infield Turf uh replacement there and then um one of the other improvements at the high school would be the resurfacing the uh running track moving on to the next second floor just another example of uh scope items please jump in if you guys have any questions but uh you know the highlighted items you know is Auditorium renovation and window replacements um here here you can see at the high school we're doing uh
126some roof Replacements the highlighted areas are the roof replacements um we've did a lot of uh roof Replacements already in this current Legacy um and with the roof scans we did we have some additional Roofing that needs to be done the orange locations are the metal roofing that will be replacing at the mansard roofs uh around the building so at the middle school we'll be looking at just hitting some of the highlighted items you know we're going to be renovating um two of the gang bathrooms uh in there doing a Master Clock replacement um and then uh doing some security film around the first floor windows and then also um doing some noise reduction in the in the existing cafeterias um there's been complaints about being real noisy in there so everyone's seen the high
127school where the noise is really quieted down with some of the improvements that we did so those are some of the uh highlight scope items that we''ll be doing at the middle school moving at the the second floor of the middle school you know some of the other highlights here would just be uh Skylight Replacements or uh taking old skylights out that are currently leaking and causing uh water damage and issues that need to be fixed uh and then here as you can see Roofing at the middle school has not been touched since the 90s um so major of the roof major part of the roof will be replaced um at the middle school here now moving over to Caroline Street some of the Highlight items um we're looking at some of the classrooms that
128we are are not renovating in this with the full classroom renovation we'll be looking at replacing casework which is built-in cabinets um and some of the classrooms that we are not renovating and then when it comes time to renovate them in the future we not have to renovate those the case workk that's been done already um some of the other items is upgrading HVAC in the main office and um here we're actually looking at doing a full uh exterior window replacement throughout the building so you see here uh Roofing wise we have about you know a quarter of the roof left we are doing majority of the roof in this current Legacy that'll be done this summer um this is the remaining Roofing that needs to be replaced at Caroline Division Street Sim highlights to
129uh Caroline Street you know we'll be doing casework replacement built-in cabinets replacement in classrooms that we're not renovating and then uh we'll be uh doing HVAC upgrades in the library and the main office and then again exterior window replacement throughout here is similar to Caroline like Bill mentioned we did a majority of the roofs at division this past summer this is the remaining roof that need to be replaced in this upcoming Legacy moving to Dorothy Nolan um some of the highlighted items we'll be looking at uh renovating the nurse's Suite to make it Ada accessible for the toilet room and stuff and then also looking at doing uh exterior door replacement around the building at multiple locations um and then also looking at doing some pavement upgrading for the hard surface play area in the
130back by the playround as you can see here most of the roofing will be replaced in this upcoming Legacy we did do uh the current roofs that are not highlighted were done these past couple couple years and then these other highlighted ones will be done in this upcoming room Legacy uh geyser uh some of the scope items at geyser again we'll be doing similar to um um Dorothy Nolan would be upgrading the nurses Suite makeing ADA toilet room so that whole nurses Suite will be renovated um we're also upgrading boilers and and pumps in the mechanical room and then here we're also doing a exterior uh window replacement throughout the building and upgrading the windows uh again just the highlighted areas or just upgraded Windows around the second floor of the geyser I apologize this
131is uh typo here but the guys a roof will be looking at doing about 60% of the roofing will be replaced um in in the Legacy project so moving to Greenfield um some of the highlighted items we'll be doing similar to division Caroline we're looking at replacing casework in classrooms that are not getting renovated but you know upgrading some of those um we're looking at in the fourth and fifth Wing replacing uh mechanical units and exhaust fans to uh upgrade the ventilation there and then also looking at the ramps going to the first and second floor of the two-story Wing upgrading the flooring uh in those areas Roofing replacement we did do majority of the roofs in these last couple years of upgrading those these are main roofs that need to be be replaced um
132at Greenfield so moving to Lake a um some of the the highlighted items here we're looking at uh upgrading or renovating the auditorium kind of keeping the architectural features just kind of replacing finishes uh replacing seating carpet um doing painting kind of cleaning up the space still keeping those the characteristics of the current Auditorium as um and then also look at um replacing unit ventilators which are the heating systems that are in the classrooms uh on the first floor and the second floor third floor was already done in this past Legacy again this second floor of Lake a um highlighted is the auditorium and then the other rooms are the the univ ventilators which is the heating system that would be upgraded in those classrooms and then finally the third floor is the uh Library
133renovation we're looking at doing a full gut renovation on the library uh at Lake a upgrading uh bookshelving finishes and everything carpet ceiling those upgrades um and then uh Lake a roof uh we'll be doing this this summer we're looking at upgrading replacing the third floor roof uh and then in this current Legacy we'll be looking at uh replacing the the rest of the roofing um for this and then moving to the last building the transportation building um some of the highlighted items here will be looking to replace the fuel tanks there um and upgrading [Music] boilers and uh doing districtwide signage here um and the remaining scope would just be doing some Roofing replacement here uh at this building kind of just running through anybody have questions on scope items before I turn it
134back over to Bill thank you so Matt touched on some of the scope items I mean obviously when you look at them online uh they'll be posted on the website you could go in very detail on exactly what line items are going through so anybody listening in the public you can definitely see in better detail as we go through so I'm going to talk a little bit about phase and how we get through this and what our plan is so uh obviously you're not going to be able to read those line items but I just want to go over in general we're talking about passing in May of 25 um and then really ending in Fall of 2033 so it's another extensive way to get through here it's uh one phase less than we currently
135have so it's seven phases again you know over multiple years but I think the the key thing here for phasing and also for financing and this really relates to uh getting to the goal of a no additional tax impact if you can see here you can see red line items here for each of the buildings that's our um SED maximum cost allowance Aid reset so in short terms that means SED will reset their aid to us every 5 years at after a project if we start a project before that 5-year timeline which we can they just won't give us enough the same amount of money as if we start after so the die has kind of been cast by the current phase 2 program and the phase three program will follow basically the same path
136every five years so if we started Dorothy and noan this year and it got approved 5 years from now we would be able to start another project so again for those of you who want to go into detail it'll be on the website and it'll lay out everything as we go through but that's really the driving force of how we laid this out was it was all based on maximizing our cost and Aid any questions on that I know it might be a little confusing but so that's just the next part so again this will be phases 9 through 15 current project is phases 1 through 8 there will be an overlap or we're planning an overlap phase 8 and phase 9 will overlap and we'll be bidding them almost at the same time and
137constructing them at the same time so we're we're not taking a break not scheduled to currently that can change if we choose to that's our choice but right now we're just keeping on keeping on so at the end of this if we started out in 16 we're ending in 33 it's quite an extensive program you know it's 17 years long should this pass all right what are our next steps so next steps uh here at the board on January 9th will uh pass our Seeker resolution this is a type two this is the most straightforward that it is and when you come to the State Environmental Quality review act we're doing pretty much everything inside the buildings the things we're doing outside we've already done our parking LS are already constructed we're just fixing them
138uh the change to softball field the fields already constructed we're just replacing with a Synthetic Turf so this is a type two straightforward it's onepage long done uh the attorneys will prepare that and we'll vote on that on the 9th the 23rd will basically shorter presentation tonight um on the scope and the phasing but we'll be rolling out the cost on that and then February 13th we will set the vote date for May 20th and then if that all goes smoothly we can go out and start talking to the public questions on that that's it for us questions con Connie hi so I have a question regarding like next steps um and really from learning from the committee process so were there any items that did show strong Community interest by way of actual votes
139maybe that will not be included in phase three but maybe in the future I can answer that um so there was obviously interest um for members of the community uh that have come to the board uh previously about a swimming pool in the district uh so we had uh a series of conversation exploring what a pool option would be for the school district um and again I think the Architects and and Bill were helpful in kind of uh explaining how a pool would be funded um you know uh by uh maximizing our building Aid and what would qualify as a building Aid unit um so as um the result of the prioritization vote for the pool uh that came out as a a a a third level priority um so it was not move forward
140as to be included as part of the recommendations but one of the outcomes that we discussed at elra was to create some kind of a subcommittee of continuing that interest of the stakeholders that had participated in the process expressing an interest in a pool and then partnering with other community agencies whether it be the city whether it be the county whether it be the YMCA as to um through some of the advocacy efforts that we've looked into about funding opportunities for the school district so this may not be the sole responsibility of the district to fund wholly a pool but if we could find Partners within um our local community or the county uh who' be interested in partnering with us um to explore those opportunities about a pool in the future so uh I
141think there was enough interest in the committee uh to continue the conversations uh it would just be outside the scope of this work that would be presented to the community in May um but again it may be opportunities for the future within the district yes so from what I was on the committee along with some other board members and the way the numbers work out and what we were told so board members could not vote um in that process and but the majority were ones and twos um the threes got the the way it worked out was that if you just look at numbers of ones numbers of twos numbers of Threes the threes won but there were more ones and twos then threes if that makes sense so there was definitely a strong showing
142and um should people that are interested wait to hear from you like how does that work well again I think we'd have to tap into the resources of the expertise of the folks in the room that had that interest in the pool and we we've heard from the folks come from the community is assembling that committee uh and again I don't know if necessarily the the district is going to take the lead in that I think where we'd want to reach out to community members who have that interest and then find out from our Community Partners I I've already started like having some conversations with the why you know to say hey what would be some interest what are some models that are out there not just in New York but across the country uh
143about pool use in communities obviously we've got a great partnership with Skidmore right now um we've utilized the pool at the Y in the past uh and an kind of as needed basis um and again is there enough interest and demand as much as we hear in the community for now a third uh indor Aquatics facility and what's the the potential uh to fund such a a project that can be sustainable over time thank you for addressing that yep other questions about tonight's presentation yep uh just a quick question Bill uh I don't know the answer to this with respect to the scope at the transportation facility are the fuel tanks above or below ground above okay no no follow-up question yeah yeah no they'll continue to be that way don't want to go under
144my followup to that was going to be that where that's where we would stumble in Seeker if we were digging no need any other questions thank you all right that brings us to our consent agenda um do we have any modifications we have three um under G3 uh new business item um there is a there was a a field trip that needs approval uh that was left off and that's a boys varsity ice hockey team uh field trip on December 20th uh so that would be new business item G3 um a Personnel item H9 um was left off and that's uh a reinstatement of a bus driver Jerry talked about that tonight so um uh effective actually a few days ago December 9th um there's a reinstatement of a bus driver and then the third
145one is unnumbered uh new business item um and it is a resolution which I will read the short wording of and we'll be voting on whether to uh resolve uh this it is hereby resolved that on the recommendation of the super superintendent of schools the resignation of Jonathan Warner effective December 13 2024 is hereby accepted and the agreement between Mr Warner and the school district dated December 3 2024 is hereby approved so given that I move that we approve consent agenda items g h and I as just modified can I get a second Beth is there any discussion all right seeing none all in favor all right that's unanimous thank you all right this brings us to our second public comment period do we have anyone wishing to address the board in the interest of
146time I'm going to give you my abbreviated public comment Spiel um please you have three minutes um do not address um a district employee or trustee by name positive or otherwise and can you get your timer yep thanks and please state your name before we begin go ahead hello my name is aarin lirry and I have come before this board before um and I'm sure I will many more times I am actually here tonight as president of the Lake Avenue PTA um on the consent agenda there was the formation of a club for a yearbook Club and this is something that we've been talking about a lot which is that Elementary School clubs are contractually disincentivized so for that club that was established today the teacher who takes that position will have to spend one
147year working for free and then the following year the people who worked free last year for example are making $441 for running an elementary school Club interestingly enough if you go to a tier 2 club which has to meet typically every other week instead of once a month to meet its requirements you actually lose money per hour your pay rate hourly pay rate is lower the problem with that is that because half of students in our district are elementary students and activities like sports are paid um at a heftier sum um we see a number of activities that are missing for elementary school students more so um this is a place that the district can actually address issues of equity the Rand Corporation found several years ago that families of means spend seven to eight
148times the amount of money on extracurriculars and out of school activities for their children and so if we are able to offer more activities to elementary students from K through five because as we are compensating teachers equally if they are not engaged in sports activities after school we might actually be able to see some of these changes that the district is pursuing in terms of addressing the opportunity Gap that said it sounds like there's many more issues facing elementary students and Lake families at in general I do want to say as we've been looking at this club thing Saratoga Springs City School District is a child care desert we have seen that um in the absence of clubs ptas are running before and after school programs and these programs actually effectively supplement YMCA programs because
149we can offer one hour extended day morning or afternoon if the school day starts at 10:00 um there is no way that we can provide an activity in the morning for 2 hours for an elementary school student so that Gap Child Care um an extended day disappears and if you have any question about how significant this is Lake Avenue opened our January registration one week ago well one eight days ago uh we have 102 people who have already paid for that service out of 383 children 102 families have engaged thank you thank you anybody else wishing to address the board all right thank you that brings us to agenda planning does anybody have agenda planning items tonight all right seeing no hands I will point out that we did pass our board goals officially tonight
150so those are now on the books um thank you for your work on those we did talk about in our retreats to use our board committee report out times to keep each other up to date on those um subcommittees we created so um I'll look forward to hearing those um as we go forward now um board comments Natalia um I wanted to say thank you to Hanniford helps and also to Doug and Ruthie Carol for their donations to our district other board comments all right thanks for sticking in there with a long night and um tough topics so um can I get a motion to adjourn Connie and Deb all in favor